### Worksheet **Description**

A1E Options Presents tables summarizing reductions in age-one equivalent (A1E) losses under regulatory options by

region. Includes values for existing units and new units. Total IM&E Presents tables summarizing reductions in forgone fishery yield and biom ass production forgone. Includes values for existing units and new units. IM&E Distribution Presents tables summarizing reductions in A1E losses under regulatory

options and the percentage of losses with monetized use value. Includes values for existing units and new units. Imp Nonuse Val Presents table for the break-even analysis. Household Counts Presents state-level household data used for the break-even analysis. Total Benefits Summary Presents table summarizing monetized benefits for existing and new units by

benefits category

and regulatory

option. National SP Presents tables summarizing benefits estimates based on the 316(b) stated preference (SP) survey . Note that benefits based on the SP survey

are not included in EPA's cost-benefit comparison for the final rule and options considered. **National Benefits Summary Tables for BA .xls**  Author: Abt Associates Inc. Created: 05/02/14 Purpose: To summarize monetized benefits for existing units and new units under the final rule and options considered. Many of the tables are presented in Chapter 13 of the Benefits Analysis for the final rule.**Region IM**  **E IM&E** 

California 0.7 <0.01 0.7 North Atlantic 0.4 <0.01 0.4 Mid-Atlantic 29.6 0.93 30.5 South Atlantic 11.6 <0.01 11.6 Gulf of Mexico 38.7 0.08 38.8 Great Lakes 184.0 0.02 184.0 Inland 347.7 0.39 348.1 **Total 612.8**  **1.41 614.2** 

**Region IM**  **E IM&E**  California 0.7 <0.01 0.7 North Atlantic 0.4 0.51 0.9 Mid-Atlantic 31.6 1.40 33.0 South Atlantic 12.4 0.48 12.9 Gulf of Mexico 40.2 0.08 40.3 Great Lakes 202.5 0.06 202.6 Inland 359.6 2.00 361.6 **Total 647.5**  **4.53 652.0** 

**Region IM**  **E IM&E**  California 0.8 30.8 31.5 North Atlantic 0.6 43.8 44.4 Mid-Atlantic 36.1 515.8 551.9 South Atlantic 17.0 8.6 25.6 Gulf of Mexico 48.2 55.2 103.4 Great Lakes 230.8 17.7 248.5 Inland 414.7 217.4 632.2 **Total 748.2**  **889.3 1,637.5** 

**Region IM**  **E IM&E**  California 1.1 50.4 51.5 North Atlantic 0.6 57.2 57.9 Mid-Atlantic 39.1 591.9 631.0 South Atlantic 17.1 9.2 26.4 Gulf of Mexico 53.5 93.5 147.0 

### Proposal Option 4 (millions of A**1E)**

**Final Rule (millions of A 1E)** 

**Proposal Option 2 (millions of A 1E)** 

**Baseline (millions of A 1E)**  Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent; IM = impingement mortality; E = entrainment; IM&E = impingement mortality and entrainment Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent; IM = impingement mortality; E = entrainment; IM&E = impingement mortality and entrainment Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent; IM = impingement mortality; E = entrainment; IM&E = impingement mortality and entrainment Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this reportGreat Lakes 236.7 24.6 261.3

Inland 476.0 279.9 756.0 **Total 824.2**  **1,106.7 1,931.0** 

**Regulatory Option IM**  **E IM&E**  Final Rule-Existing Units 647.5 4.5 652.0 Final Rule-New Units 0.4 1.9 2.3 Final Rule-Existing and New Untis 647.9 6.5 654.3

**Regulatory Option IM**  **E IM&E**  Option A 74.5 353.3 427.8 Option B 26.8 127.3 154.2 Option C 4.0 18.7 22.7 Final Rule - New Units 0.4 1.9 2.3 

### Final Rule (New Units + Existing Units) (millions of A**1E)**

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent; IM = impingement mortality; E = entrainment; IM&E = impingement mortality and entrainment Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report


### New Units (millions of A**1E)**

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent; IM = impingement mortality; E = entrainment; IM&E = impingement mortality and entrainment Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent; IM = impingement mortality; E = entrainment; IM&E = impingement mortality and entrainment Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report

### Existing Units

**Regulatory Option Millions of A1E**  **Foregone Fishery Yield (m** **illion lbs) a**  **Biom ass Production Forgone**  **(m illion lbs)**  Proposal Option 4 614.2 12.6 130.3 Final Rule-Existing Units 652.0 13.4 138.9 Proposal Option 2 1,637.5 51.1 494.2 Baseline 1,931.0 69.8 626.6



### New Units

**Regulatory Option Millions of A1E**  **Foregone Fishery Yield (m** **illion lbs) a**  **Biom ass Production Forgone**  **(m illion lbs)**  Option A 427.8 18.4 160.0 Option B 154.2 6.6 57.7 Option C 22.7 1.0 8.5 Final Rule-New Units 2.3 0.1 0.9



### Existing and New Units

**Regulatory Option Millions of A1E**  **Foregone Fishery Yield (m** **illion lbs) a**  **Biom ass Production Forgone**  **(m illion lbs)**  Final Rule-Existing Units 652.0 13.4 138.9 Final Rule-New Units 2.3 0.1 0.9 Final Rule-Existing and New Units 654.3 13.5 139.8 Notes: A1E = age-one equivalents

a The reductions in foregone fishery yield presented here are equal to increases in commercial and recreational harvest. Refer to Chapter 3 for additional detail regarding the calculation of foregone fishery yield and biomass production forgone. Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalents

a The reductions in foregone fishery yield presented here are equal to increases in commercial and recreational harvest. Refer to Chapter 3 for additional detail regarding the calculation of foregone fishery yield and biomass production forgone. Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalents

a The reductions in foregone fishery yield presented here are equal to increases in commercial and recreational harvest. Refer to Chapter 3 for additional detail regarding the calculation of foregone fishery yield and biomass production forgone. Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this reportProposal Option 4 614.2 528.2 85.9 16.1 2.6%

Final Rule - Existing Units 652.0 560.8 91.2 17.1 2.6% Proposal Option 2 1,637.5 1,258.7 378.8 44.7 2.7% Baseline 1,931.0 1,459.7 471.3 54.0 2.8%

Option A 427.8 303.9 123.9 12.3 2.9% Option B 154.2 109.5 44.6 4.4 2.9% Option C 22.7 16.1 6.6 0.7 2.9% Final Rule - New Units 2.3 1.7 0.7 0.1 2.9%

Final Rule-Existing Units 652.0 560.8 91.2 17.1 2.6% Final Rule-New Units 2.3 1.7 0.7 0.1 2.9% Final Rule-Existing and New Units 654.3 562.5 91.9 17.2 2.9% 

### New Units

**Existing and New Units Existing Units** 

**Regulatory Option**

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent

a "Percent of fish with monetized use value" is equal to "commercial and recreational harvest (millions of fish harvested)" divided by "all species (millions of A1E)." Source: U.S. EPA Analysis for this report **All Species (m** **illions of A1E)**  **Forage Species**

**(m illions of**  **A1E) Com** **me rcial and** 

**Recreational Species**  **(m illions of A1E)**  **Com me** **rcial and**

**Recreational Harvest**  **(m illions of fish**  **harvested) Percent of Fish** 

**with Monetized Use Value**  **a**

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent

a "Percent of fish with monetized use value" is equal to "commercial and recreational harvest (millions of fish harvested)" divided by "all species (millions of A1E)." Source: U.S. EPA Analysis for this report **Regulatory Option All Species**  **(m illions of**  **A1E) Forage Species** 

**(m illions of**  **A1E) Com** **me rcial and** 

**Recreational Species**  **(m illions of A1E)**  **Com me** **rcial and**

**Recreational Harvest**  **(m illions of fish**  **harvested) Percent of Fish** 

**with Monetized Use Value**  **a**

Notes: A1E = age-one equivalent

a "Percent of fish with monetized use value" is equal to "commercial and recreational harvest (millions of fish harvested)" divided by "all species (millions of A1E)." Source: U.S. EPA Analysis for this report **Regulatory Option All Species**  **(m illions of**  **A1E) Forage Species** 

**(m illions of**  **A1E) Com** **me rcial and** 

**Recreational Species**  **(m illions of A1E)**  **Com me** **rcial and**

**Recreational Harvest**  **(m illions of fish**  **harvested) Percent of Fish** 

**with Monetized Use Value**  **a Regulatory Option**  **a Use Benefits**  **of IM&E Reductions**  **(2011$, mi** **llions) a**  **Annual**

**Social Cost (2011$,**  **mi llions)**  **b Annual Nonuse** 

**Benefits Necessary to Break Even (2011$)** **c Num** **ber of**

**Households in States with Regulated**  **Facilities (m illions)**  **d Annual Break** 

**Even Nonuse WTP per**  **Household (2011$)**  **e**

Proposal Option 4 $19.6 $251.8 $232.2 114.9 $2.02 Final Rule - Existing and New Units $14.5 $274.9 $260.4 114.9 $2.27

Proposal Option 2 $0.0 $3,643.2 $3,643.2 114.9 $31.72

Proposal Option 4 $14.5 $272.1 $257.6 114.9 $2.24

Final Rule - Existing and New Units $0.0 $297.3 $297.3 114.9 $2.59

Proposal Option 2 $0.0 $3,583.0 $3,583.0 114.9 $31.19

aBenefits are discounted using a 3% or 7% discount rate, respectively. Use benefits include estimated commercial fishing benefits, recreational fishing benefits, and use benefits for T&E species.
bThe total social cost of the final rule includes facility compliance costs and administrative costs.

cAnnualized compliance costs minus annualized use benefits.
d I ncludes households in states with at least one surveyed facility. Household counts are based on Census 2010 (U.S. Census Bureau 2010).

eDollars per household per year that, when added to use benefits, would yield a total annualized benefit (use plus nonuse) equal to the annualized costs. Source: U.S. EPA analysis for this report; U.S. Census Bureau, 2010 

### Implicit Nonuse Value—Break-Even A**nalysis, 3 Percent and 7 Percent Discount Rates**

**3% Discount Rate** 

**7% Discount Rate** 

### State **Households Include (1=yes, 0=no)**  **Households to Include**

Alabam a 1,883,791 1 1,883,791 Alaska 258,058 1 258,058 Arizona 2,380,990 1 2,380,990 Arkansas 1,147,084 1 1,147,084 California 12,577,498 1 12,577,498 Colorado 1,972,868 1 1,972,868 Connecticut 1,371,087 1 1,371,087 Delaware 342,297 1 342,297 District of Columbia 266,707 0 0 Florida 7,420,802 1 7,420,802 Georgia 3,585,584 1 3,585,584 Hawaii 455,338 1 455,338 Idaho 579,408 0 0 Illinois 4,836,972 1 4,836,972 Indiana 2,502,154 1 2,502,154 Iowa 1,221,576 1 1,221,576 Kansas 1,112,096 1 1,112,096 Kentucky 1,719,965 1 1,719,965 Louisiana 1,728,360 1 1,728,360 Maine 557,219 1 557,219 Maryland 2,156,411 1 2,156,411 Massachusetts 2,547,075 1 2,547,075 Michigan 3,872,508 1 3,872,508 Minnesota 2,087,227 1 2,087,227 Mississippi 1,115,768 1 1,115,768 Missouri 2,375,611 1 2,375,611 Montana 409,607 1 409,607 Nebraska 721,130 1 721,130 Nevada 1,006,250 0 0 New Ham pshire 518,973 1 518,973 New Jersey 3,214,360 1 3,214,360 New Mexico 791,395 1 791,395 New York 7,317,755 1 7,317,755 North Carolina 3,745,155 1 3,745,155 North Dakota 281,192 1 281,192 Ohio 4,603,435 1 4,603,435 Oklahoma 1,460,450 1 1,460,450 Oregon 1,518,938 1 1,518,938 Pennsylvania 5,018,904 1 5,018,904 Rhode Island 413,600 1 413,600 South Carolina 1,801,181 1 1,801,181 South Dakota 322,282 1 322,282 Tennessee 2,493,552 1 2,493,552 Texas 8,922,933 1 8,922,933 Utah 877,692 1 877,692 Vermont 256,442 1 256,442 Virginia 3,056,058 1 3,056,058 Washington 2,620,076 1 2,620,076 West Virginia 763,831 1 763,831 Wi sconsin 2,279,768 1 2,279,768 Wyom ing 226,879 1 226,879 Puerto Rico 1,376,531 0 0 Total 118,092,823 114,863,927

### Existing Units

**5 th**  **Mean 95**  **th 5**  **th Mean**  **95 th** 

Proposal Option 4 $829.1 $1,363.1 $1,898.8 $642.6 $1,056.8 $1,472.2 Final Rule - Existing Units $880.5 $1,448.8 $2,019.0 $682.5 $1,123.2 $1,565.3 Proposal Option 2 $2,159.9 $3,430.7 $4,823.7 $1,442.4 $2,294.5 $3,226.1



### New Units

**5 th**  **Mean 95**  **th 5**  **th Mean**  **95 th**  Option A $381.8 $596.7 $842.7 $270.7 $423.1 $597.5 Option B $137.6 $215.0 $303.7 $97.6 $152.5 $215.3 Option C $20.3 $31.6 $44.7 $14.4 $22.4 $31.7 File Rule - New Units $2.1 $3.3 $4.6 $1.5 $2.3 $3.3


### Existing and New**Units**

**5 th**  **Mean 95**  **th 5**  **th Mean**  **95 th**  Final Rule - Existing Units $880.5 $1,448.8 $2,019.0 $682.5 $1,123.2 $1,565.3 Final Rule - New Units $2.1 $3.3 $4.6 $1.5 $2.3 $3.3 Final Rule - Existing and New Units $882.6 $1,452.1 $2,023.6 $683.9 $1,125.5 $1,568.6 **3 % Discount Rate Regulatory Option**  **3 % Discount Rate 7 % Discount Rate** 

**7 % Discount Rate**

Scenario: U.S. EPA analysis for this report **Regulatory Option 3 % Discount Rate**  **7 % Discount Rate**

Scenario: U.S. EPA analysis for this report

**Regulatory Option**