General Service Fluorescent Lamp and Incandescent Reflector Lamp March 10-11, 2008 

Energy Conservation Standard ANOPR Public Meeting 

Incandescent Reflector Lamps 

ANOPR Public Meeting 

Rulemaking Overview 

Energy Conservation Standards for 

General Service Fluorescent Lamps and 

Building Technologies Program 

Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy 

U.S. Department of Energy 

March 10-11, 2008 

http://www.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/residential/incandescent_lamps_anopr.html 

Overview 

Purpose of the Public Meeting 

 To present methodologies and characterize results for analyses to 

date 

 To discuss specific issues related to each analysis 

 To seek input from attendees on methodologies, assumptions and 

data sources 

 To describe upcoming analyses and next steps 

2 
General Service Fluorescent Lamp and Incandescent Reflector Lamp March 10-11, 2008 

Energy Conservation Standard ANOPR Public Meeting 

Overview 

The Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) directs DOE to consider 

seven factors when setting energy conservation standards 

Factor Analysis 

1. Economic impact on consumers Life-cycle cost analysis 

and manufacturers Manufacturer impact analysis 

2. Lifetime operating cost savings Life-cycle cost analysis 

3. Total projected energy savings National impact analysis 

4. Impact on utility or performance Screening Analysis 

Engineering analysis 

5. Impact of any lessening of Manufacturer impact analysis 

competition 

6. Need for national energy National impact analysis 

conservation 

7. Other factors the Secretary Environmental assessment 

considers relevant Utility impact analysis 

Employment impact analysis 

3 

Overview 

Steps in the Standards Rulemaking: ANOPR 

Framework 

Document ANOPR NOPR Final 

Rule 

Effective 

Date 

Market & 

Technology 

Assessment Engineering Product Price 

Screening Analysis Determination 

Analysis Life-Cycle 

Cost and 

Payback 

Period Analyses 

Energy Use National 

Characterization Impact 

Analysis 

Shipments 

Analysis 

4 
General Service Fluorescent Lamp and Incandescent Reflector Lamp March 10-11, 2008 

Energy Conservation Standard ANOPR Public Meeting 

Overview 

Steps in the Standards Rulemaking: NOPR 

Framework 

Document ANOPR NOPR Final 

Rule 

Effective 

Date 

Impact Impact Impact Subgroup Impact

Manufacturer 

Analysis 

Utility 

Analysis 

Trial 

Standard 

Levels 

Revise 

ANOPR 

Analyses 

Environmental 

Assessment 

Regulatory 

Analysis 

Employment 

Analysis 

LCC 

Analysis 

Issues for Public Comment 

 Expansion of Scope for General Service Fluorescent Lamps (Issue #1)

 Product Classes (Issue #3)

 Standards for Color Rendering Index

 Selection of Efficacious Lamp Substitutes and Candidate Standard Levels

 Scaling to Product Classes Not Analyzed (Issue #4)

 Approaches for Establishing End-user prices

 Operating Hours (Issue #6)

 General Service Fluorescent Lamp Energy Consumption (Issue #7)

 Life-Cycle Cost Calculation (Issue #8)

 Installation Costs (Issue #9)

 Base-Case and Standards-Case Market Share Matrices (Issue #10)

 Shipment Forecasts (Issue #11)

 Base-Case and Standards-Case Forecasted Efficiencies (Issue #12)

 NES and NPV Calculation Inputs

 Trial Standard Levels (Issue #13)

5 

Overview 

6 
General Service Fluorescent Lamp and Incandescent Reflector Lamp March 10-11, 2008 

Energy Conservation Standard ANOPR Public Meeting 

Overview 

Comments from Participants 

 Participants are invited to provide summary comments or 

statements 

 Participants are invited to raise additional issues for discussion 

today 

 ANOPR comment period open through April 12, 2008 

7