# o ,>-v;Mi/-ulUl' l
U S , DepeNtmen t o f 120 0 Ne wJerseyAvenue , S E ThmsportOtlo n

_Washington , D C 2059 0 Of f ic e O

f th e SecfBtar y o f Transportatio n

Apri l 27 , 201 0

Th e Honorabl e Willia mByrn e Mayo r o f th e City o f

Morgantow n 38 9 Spruc e Stree t Morgantown , Wes t

Virgini a2650 5

Dear Mayo r Byrne : I woul dlik e t o update yo u o nth e essentia l ai r servic e situatio na

t Beckley , Clarksburg/Fairmont , Morgantown , an dParkersburg , Wes t Virginia , an dgiv e yo u an opportunity t o submi t

any comment s if

yo u wish

. I n anticipatio nof th e en do f

Colga n Air' s curren t

contrac t o n Jul y 31 , 2010 , th e Departmen t issue dOrde r

2010-2-16 , Marc h12 , 2010 , t o solici t proposal s fro mal l intereste dai r carrier s t o provid e servic e at al l four communities , includin g yours
. I nrespons e t o tha t order , w e receive dproposal s fro mthre e carriers : Colga n Air , Inc

. d/b/ aUnite dExpres s (Colgan) , Gulfstream Internationa l Airline s (Gulfstream) , an dCharte r Ai r Transport

. W e hav e directe deac hcarrie r t o serv e it s proposal(s ) o n you ; i n addition , copies of th e proposal s ma y b e accesse donlin e throug hth e Department' s Docket s Managemen t Syste mat : http://www.regulations.gov/b y enterin g "DOT-OST-1997-276 1 (Beckley) , DOT-OST-2005-2073 4 (Parkersburg) , DOT-OST-2005-2073 5 (Morgantown) , o r DOT

OST-2005-2073 6 (Clarksburg/Fairmont ) i n th e "Ente r Keywor do r

ID " field , but

w e hav e summarize dth e proposal s i n th e attachmen t provided

. M y purpos e i n writin g t o yo u at thi s tim e i s t o reques t

£in y final conmient s yo u migh t hav e o n th e carriers ' servic e an dsubsid y proposal s befor e w e submi t a recommendatio n o n th e carrier-selectio nissu e t o th e Assistan t Secretary for

Aviatio nan d Internationa l Affairs

. Pleas e not e that

th e averag e passenge r

fare s show ni n eac hproposa l d o no t necessaril y reflec t

th e average loca l fare Morgantow npassenger s woul dactuall y pay , but , rather , reflec t

aprorate dportio n of

th e tota l ticke t

price , e.g. , th e Morgantown

Washington , D.C

. portio n o f aMorgantown-Washington , D.C.-Sa nFrancisc o ticke t tha t th e subsidize dcarrie r

woul drealize

. Also , th e fare show ni s ne t of certai ncharge s suc h a s Federa l transportatio n security fees , excis e o r ticke t taxes , an dPassenge r

Facilit yCharges

. O f course , carrier s hav e th e discretio nt o charg e fare s the y deemappropriate , an dth e passenge r

fare s presente dinthei r

proposal s hav e bee ndevelope dfor subsid y rat e computatio npurpose s only

. Yo u shoul dals o not e tha t th e schedule s that

th e caiTier s hav e submitte dar e illustrativ e only , an dthat the y ma y mak e schedul e change s t o reflec t changin g conditions , e.g. , t o bette r

mee t shiftin g connectin g ban k time s a t th e hub

. Th e Departmen t expect s subsidize dai r

carrier s t o maintai nwell-time dan dwell-space dflight s i norde r t o ensur e full compensation

. W e reques t

that yo u revie w eac hproposa l an dservic e optio nan dsubmi t an y comment s yo u ma y hav e befor e w e submi t arecommendatio nt o th e Assistan t Secretary

. W e as k that yo u submi t

an y comment s yo u ma y hav e a s soo na s possible , but i nan y cas e n o late r tha n Ma y 19 , 2010

. W e wil l carefull y conside r you r comment s befor e w e submi t arecommendatio n t o th e Assistan t Secretar y fo r

adecision

. W e appreciat e tha t ther e ar e significan t

issue s for

yo u t o consider , s o if

yo u hav e an y question s o r i f yo u fin dthat

yo u nee dadditional tim e t o draf t you r comments , pleas e le t

u s know

. Pleas e sen dyou r

comment s t o m e at

th e followin g e-mai l address : EAS@dot.go v o r b y fa x t o 202-366-7638

. I

f yo u hav e an y questions , pleas e fee l fre e t o contac t Kevi n Schlemme r

o f m y staf f a t kevin.schlemmer@dot.go v o r 202-366-3176

. Similar letter s hav e bee n sen t

t o th e civi c official s o f

th e othe r thre e EA S communitie s a

t issu e here

. Sincerely , 

# ^ll.l^l/c A Denni s J

. DeVan y Chief , Essentia l Ai r

Servic e Division , X-5 3 Offic e o f Aviatio nAnalysi sAttachmen t

Hu b ( # o f flight s Subsid yamoun t Communit v Beckle y

Parl<ersburg / r\/lariett a

Clarl<sburg / Fairmon t Carrie r

Colga n CAT * CAT * CAT * CAT * CAT * CAT * CAT * Gulfstrean n Gulfstrea m
Colga n CAT * CAT * CAT * CAT * CAT * Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m
Colga n CAT * CAT * CAT * Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m oe rweek )

IA D (24 ) CLT(24)/IAD(12 ) IA D (24 ) CL T(24 ) CLT(24 ) CL T(24 ) IA D (24 ) CL T(24 ) CL E (24 ) PI T(24 )

IA D (24 ) CLT(24)/IAD(12 ) IA D (24 ) CL T(24 ) CL T(24 ) IA D (24 ) CLE (48 ) CLE (36 ) PI T(48 ) PI T(36 )

IA D (36 ) IAD(24)/CLT(12 ) IA D (24 ) CL T(24 ) CLE(48 ) PI T(48 ) CL E (36 ) PI T(36 ) Aircraf t

Saa b 34 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 J3 2 J3 2 B-190 0 B-190 0

Saa b 34 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 B-190 0

Saa b 34 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 pe rcommunit y

$2,313,45 7 $2,330,86 6 $1,821,23 9 $1,555,80 3 $1,931,96 4 $2,198,85 0 $1,893,86 3 $1,724,16 1 $2,399,38 9 $2,322,42 2
$2,598,97 5 $2,330,86 6 $1,821,23 9 $1,555,80 3 $1,931,96 4 $2,287,94 4 $2,642,23 7 $2,112,39 0 $2,573,45 4 $2,040,00 4
$1,488,21 9 $1,548,57 0 $1,815,27 2 $2,446,25 0 $1,547,24 2 $1,373,47 8 $2,265,02 4 $1,832,89 7 Cpmbine d wit h n/ a Parkersbur g Parkersbur g Parkersbur g Parkersbur g n/ a n/ a n/ a n/ a n/ a

n/ a Beckle y Beckle y Beckle y Beckle y n/ a n/ a n/ a n/ a n/ a
Morgantow n Morgantow n n/ a n/ a Morgantow n Morgantow n n/ a n/ a Note s

aircraf t base d a t PK B aircraf t base d a t BKW

aircraf t base d a t PK B aircraf t base d a t BKW

Morgantow n Colga n

CAT * CAT * CAT * Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m Gulfstrea m IA D (36 )

IAD(24)/CLT(12 ) IA D (24 ) CLT(24 ) CL E (48 ) PI T(48 ) CLE (36 ) PI T(36 ) Saa b 34 0

EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 EMB-12 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 B-190 0 $1,488,21 9

$1,548,57 0 $1,689,07 7 $3,203,42 4 $1,547,24 2 $1,373,47 8 $2,030,28 1 $1,421,06 5 Clarksbur g

Clarksbur g n/ a n/ a Clarksbur g Clarksbur g n/ a n/ a

CAT=Charte rAi rTranspor t CLT=Charlotte ; IAD=Washington-Dulles ; PIT=PJttsburg h

CA Tpropose s 1 single-sto p o rnonsto p roun d tri p t o Myrtl e Beac h pe rwee k tha t woul d beunsubsidize d