INDEX TO DOCKET EPA-R09-OAR-2012- 0021

Approval, Disapproval and Promulgation of Air Quality Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze 

State and Federal Implementation Plans

INDEX 

NO.

CATEGORY / DOCUMENT TITLE DOCUMENT 

DATE

REGS.GOV

DOCUMENT ID

A. EPA Guidance Documents, Policies and Rulemakings

A.1. Proposed Rule - Visibility Protection for Federal Class I

Areas, 45 FR 34762

1980-05-22

A.2. Final Rule - Visibility Protection for Federal Class I Areas, 

45 FR 80084

1980-12-02

A.3. Proposed Rule - Regional Haze Regulations, 62 FR 

41138.pdf

1997-07-31 

A.4. IWAQM Phase 2 Summary Report And Recommendations 

For Modeling Long Range Transport Impacts

1998-12

A.5. Final Rule - Regional Haze Regulations, 64 FR 35714 1999-07-01 

A.6. Proposed BART Guidelines, 66 FR 38108 2001-06-20

A.7. Guidance for Estimating Natural Visibility Conditions under 

the Regional Haze Rule

2003-09

A.8. Guidance for Tracking Progress under the Regional Haze 

Rule

2003-09

A.9. Re-proposed BART Guidelines 2004-05-04

A.10. BART Guidelines Error Correction Memo 2005-06-24

A.11. Final Rule - Regional Haze Regulations and Guidelines for 

BART Determinations

2005-07-06

A.12. Memo from Joseph W. Paise regarding Regional Haze

Regulations and Guidelines for BART

2006-07-19 

A.13. Guidance - 110(a)(2)(D) SIPs for the 8-hour Ozone and 

PM2.5 NAAQS

2006-08-15 

A.14. Additional Regional Haze Questions (Guidance) 2006-09-27

A.15. Final Rule - Revision to Regional Haze Regulations, 71 FR 

60612

2006-10-13 

A.16. Guidance for Setting Reasonable Progress Goals Under the 

Regional Haze Program

2007-06-01

A.17. Finding of Failure To Submit SIPs Required by the 1999 

Regional Haze Rule, 74 FR 2392

2009-01-15 

A.18. Proposed Consent Decree, Clean Air Act Citizen Suit, 76 FR 

75544

2011-12-02 

A.19. Visibility Monitoring Guidance 1999-06-01

A.20. 2002 Base Year Emission Inventory SIP Planning 2002-11-18

A.21. Emissions Inventory Guidance for Implementation of Ozone 

and Particulate Matter NAAQS and Regional Haze 

Regulations

2005-08-01

A.22. Final Guidance for EPA Rulewriters: Regulatory Flexibility

Act

2006-11

A.23. Performance Test Calculation Guidelines 1990-06-06 

A.24. Revision to the Guideline on Air Quality Models, 70 FR 

68218

2005-11-09 
A.25. Methods for Measurement of Filterable PM10 and PM2.5 

and Measurement of Condensable PM Emissions From 

Stationary Sources, 75 FR 80118

2010-12-21

A.26. National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants 

From Coal and Oil-Fired Electric Utility Steam Generating 

Units and Standards of Performance for Fossil-Fuel-Fired 

Electric Utility, Industrial-Commercial-Institutional, and 

Small Industrial-Commercial-Institutional Steam Generating 

Units (MATS Rule), 77 FR 9304

2012-02-16 

A.27. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Nevada, 76 FR 36450

2011-06-22

A.28. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

New York, 77 FR 24794

2012-04-25

A.29. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

California, 76 FR 13944

2011-03-15

A.30. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Rhode Island, 77 FR 11798

2012-02-28

A.31. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Delaware, 76 FR 27973

2011-05-13

A.32. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Nebraska, 77 FR 12770

2012-03-02

A.33. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Colorado, 77 FR 18052

2012-03-26

A.34. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Oklahoma, 76 FR 16168

2011-12-28

A.35. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Vermont, 77 FR 11914

2012-02-28

A.36. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Wisconsin, 77 FR 11928

2012-02-28

A.37. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Kansas, 76 FR 52604

2011-08-23

A.38. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Arkansas, 76 FR 64186

2011-10-17

A.39. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Maryland, 77 FR 11827

2012-02-28

A.40. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

North Dakota, 76 FR 58570

2011-09-11

A.41. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Illinois, 77 FR 3966

2012-01-26

A.42. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

South Dakota 76 FR 76646

2011-12-08

A.43. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for 

California, 76 FR 34608

2011-06-14

A.44. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for 

Delaware, 76 FR 42557

2011-07-19

A.45. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for Kansas, 

76 FR 80754

2011-12-27

A.46. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for New 2012-01-03
Jersey, 77 FR 19

A.47. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for District 

of Columbia, 77 FR 5191 

2012-02-02

A.48. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for 

Arkansas, 77 FR 14603

2012-03-12

A.49. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for Nevada, 

77 FR 17334

2012-03-26

A.50. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for South 

Dakota, 77 FR 24845

2012-04-26

A.51. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for 

Nebraska, 77 FR 40149

2012-07-06

A.52. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for New 

York, 77 FR 51915

2012-08-28

A.53. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Proposed Rule for 

Virginia 77 FR 3691

2012-01-25

A.54. Regional Haze Implementation Plans, Final Rule for Hawaii, 

77 FR 61478

2012-10-09

A.55. Interim Guidance on Considering Environmental Justice 

During the Development of an Action

2010-07

B. State Plans, Rules, Support Documents, and 

Correspondence (letters and emails)

B.1. Arizona Regional Haze SIP (with appendices) 2011-01

B.2. AEPCO Apache 1 BART Analysis 2007-12

B.3. AEPCO Apache 2 BART Analysis 2007-12

B.4. AEPCO Apache 3 BART Analysis 2007-12

B.5. AEPCO Apache additional BART response 2009-07-08

B.6. APS Cholla 2 BART Analysis 2008-01

B.7. APS Cholla 3 BART Analysis 2008-01

B.8. APS Cholla 4 BART Analysis 2008-01

B.9. Additional APS Cholla BART response 2009-06-18

B.10. SRP Coronado 1 and 2 BART Analysis 2008-02

B.11. SRP Coronado additional BART response 2009-06-25

B.12. Summary of WRAP RMC BART Modeling for Arizona

Draft#5 

2007-05-25

B.13. WRAP Stationary Sources Joint Forum - Identification of 

BART-Eligible Sources in the WRAP Region

2005-04-04

B.14. WRAP Stationary Sources Joint Forum – Appendix H 2006-09-21

B.15. WRAP RMC BART Exemption Screening Modeling 

Protocol

2006-09-15

B.16. Original Arizona Section 309 SIP 2003-12-23

B.17. Arizona Section 309 SIP Revision 2004-12

B.18. Direct Final Approval of ADEQ Open Burning Rules, 71 FR 

28270

2006-05-14

B.19. Arizona Regional Haze Submittal Letter 2008-12-24

C. EPA Communications with Facilities 
C.1. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Andrew (AEPCO) 2011-11-17

C.2. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Bevier (SRP) 2011-11-17

C.3. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Bittel (APCC) 2011-11-17

C.4. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Mollenhauer

(Catalyst Paper)

2011-11-17

C.5. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Reilly (APS) 2011-11-17

C.6. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Spell (APS) 2011-11-17

C.7. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Verville (Lhoist 

North America)

2011-11-17

C.8. Letter from Colleen McKaughan (EPA) to Yockey (TEP) 2011-11-17

C.9. Letter from Eric Massey (ADEQ) to Deborah Jordan (EPA) 2011-11-21

C.10. Letter from Arizona Public Service Company (APS) 2011-12-12

C.11. Letter from Sue Kidd (APS) to Francisco Donez (EPA) 2012-02-14

C.12. Letter from Kelly Barr (SRP) to Francisco Donez (EPA) 2012-02-02

C.13. [Reserved]

C.14. Summary of EPA meeting with utility companies 2011-12-21

C.15. EPA follow-up to 12/21/2011 utilities meeting 2011-12-29

C.16. Letter from Kelly Barr (SRP) to Deborah Jordan (EPA) 2012-06-29

C.17. Letter from Michelle Freeark (AEPCO) to Deborah Jordan 

(EPA)

2012-06-26

C.18. 2012-08-06 Jordan to Freeark-AEPCO request for 

information and responses – 7 files

2012-08-06 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0019

C.19. Barr SRP to Webb – 3 files 2012-07-20 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0029

C.20. Kidd APS to Blumenfeld – 2 files 2012-07-20 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0030

C.21. EPA clarification request to AEPCO – 2 files 2012-09 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0031

C.22. Jordan-Barr SRP Exchange 09-14-2012 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0032

C.23. Freeark to McKaughan 2012-09-06 2012-09-06

C.24. Freeark-McKaughan emails re CBI + SNCR 2012-10 2012-10

C.25. Info request to SRP 2012-07-27 – 4 files 2012-07

C.26. APS SCR cost information 2012-10-15 – 7 files 2012-10

C.27. McKaughn-Kidd emails re Cholla Unit 1 – 5 files 2012-10

D. EPA Correspondence (other letters and emails) 

D-01 AZ Delegation Letter to Lisa Jackson re FIP Comment 

Period and Hearings – also contains 10 response letters dated 

2012-07-26

2012-07-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0018

D-02 Emissions conf call memo 2012-08-03 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0018
D-03 Daryl Seymore_City of Show Low Letter to Lisa Jackson - 2 

files

2012-07-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0020

D-04 JR Despain Navajo Cty to Blumenfeld- 2 files 2012-07-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0021

D-05 Willis-Snowflake to Jackson- 2 files 2012-07-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0022

D-06 Henry Darwin ADEQ Letter to Thomas Webb 07-20-2012 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0023

D-07 Robin Boyd City of Winslow Letter to Lisa Jackson- 2 files 2012-07-20 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0024

D-08 Jeffers Cattle Co to Jackson- 2 files 2012-07-21 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0025

D-09 McAnally-Phoenix Chamber to Jackson- 2 files 2012-07-23 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0026

D-10 Swarthout-NPC to Jackson- 2 files 2012-07-23 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0027

D-11 Apache Cty to Blumenfeld- 2 files 2012-07-24 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0028

E. EPA Contractor Documents

E.1. UNC Task 5 Report (AZ-BART-Modeling-Protocol)

(Earlier versions of the modeling protocol were received by 

EPA on March 14, 2012 and June 29, 2012. However, only

certain portions of this protocol were relied upon by EPA in 

the proposed rule signed July 2, 2012. The July 16, 2012 

version of the modeling protocol, which included in the 

docket, incorporates only the material relied upon by EPA for 

the July 2, 2012 proposal.) 

2012-07-16 

E.2. UNC Task 8 Report (Apache-Cholla-Coronado BART 

Analysis Report)_final

(An earlier version of the Task 8 Report was received by

EPA on June 28, 2012. However, only certain portions of this 

report were relied upon by EPA in the proposed rule signed 

July 2, 2012. The July 16, 2012 version of the report, which 

included in the docket, incorporates only the material relied 

upon by EPA for the July 2, 2012 proposal.) 

2012-07-16 

E.3. Jim Staudt CV
F. EPA Final Products 

F.1. FCPP Technical Support Document 2010-10-06 

F.2. Supplemental Cost Analysis 2012-11

F.3. Tangentially-fired coal unit SCR retrofit 2012-11

F.4. Cholla 2001-03 NOx Emission Data (daily) 2012-11

F.5. Cholla 2010-12Q3 NOx Emission Data (monthly) 2012-11

F.6. Coronado 2 2011-12Q3 NOx Emission Data (daily) 2012-11

F.7. CAMD Emission Data 2001-11 (daily) 2012-11

G. Additional Documents Considered for Proposed 

Rulemaking

G.1. Consent Decree Between U.S. and SRP (final as entered) 2008-12-19

G.2. Coronado Title V Permit (final) 2011-12-16

G.3. TSD for Coronado Title V Permit final) 2011-12-16

G.4. Technical Literature: Ultra-Low NOx Control 2007-01-01

G.5. Erickson, Lisauskas, Licata - What’s New in SCRs 2006-05-16

G.6. Lani - Nitrogen Oxides Emission Control Options for CoalFired EGUs AWMA2009-05

G.7. AEP Apache Title V TSD 2007-05-24

G.8. AEP Apache Title V Permit 2007-07-09

G.9. Final Title V Permit for Cholla 2012-05-31

G.10. Final Title V TSD for Cholla 2012-05-31

G.11. Cichanowicz - Implementation Schedule for SCR and FGD 2010-10-01

G.12. AZ Corp Commission - Annual Report -

Arizona_Electric_Power_Cooperative_Inc

2012-05-14

G.13. ECR memo - Impact of Ammonia in Fly Ash 2010-08-31

G.14. EPRI H2SO4 report 2010-04

G.15. Modeling Files

(Due to the format of some modeling files, they are not 

available from the electronic docket. These files are available 

upon request. See the TSD for more information.)

G.16. NGS Revised BART Report 2009-01

H. Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and Technical Support 

Document 

H.1. Technical Support Document 2012-07

H.2. Index to Docket EPA-R09-OAR-2012- 0021

Approval, Disapproval and Promulgation of Air Quality

Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze State and 

Federal Implementation Plans

2012-07

H.3. Approval, Disapproval and Promulgation of Air Quality

Implementation Plans; Arizona; Regional Haze State and 

Federal Implementation Plans (Pre-publication version)

2012-07-02

H.4. Notice of Additional Public Hearings and Extension of 

Comment Period, 77 FR 45326

2012-07-31

I. Public Comments Received on Proposed Rule and Public 
Hearing Transcripts 

I-01 7-31-2012 Public Hearing, Phoenix AZ 2012-07-31

I-02 8-14-2012 Public Hearing-Holbrook AZ 2012-08-14

I-03 Comments received September 17, 2012, from United States 

Department of the Interior, National Parks Service, Denver 

CO, from Susan Johnson, DPS, to Thomas Webb, EPA.

2012-09-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0064

I-04 Comments 2012-09-18 Edison Electric Institute (EEI) 2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0061

I-05 Comments from 2012-09-07 Representative Paul Gosar's 

Public Meeting

2012-09-07 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0062

I-06 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 - Thomas Armstrong 2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0035

I-07 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 - Robert Carreira 2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0036

I-08 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 – Jonathan Gardner, 

IBEW

2012-08-30 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0037

I-09 Comment on FR Doc # 2012- 18545 - Anonymous 2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0040

I-10 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Ralph Score 2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0038

I-11 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Laila Amerman 2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0039

I-12 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Robert E. Quick, 

Arizona Mining Association

2012-09-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0041

I-13 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Robert E. Quick, 

Arizona Mining Association – with attachments

2012-09-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0042

I-14 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - CREDO Action mass 

campaign: 1,955 letters

2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0043

I-15 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Micheal G. Dunn, 

PacifiCorp

2012-09-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0044

I-16 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Christopher Lish 2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0045

I-17 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Anonymous 2012-09-26 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0046
I-18 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - T. Ted Cromwell, 

National Rural Electric Cooperative Association

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0047

I-19 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Kelly J. Barr, Salt 

River Project (SRP) 1 of 2 – cover letter and comments

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0048

I-20 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Kelly J. Barr, Salt 

River Project (SRP) 2 of 2 – attachments

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0049

I-21 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Mike E. Bowen, New 

Mexico Mining Association

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0050

I-22 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Kevin Rogers, Arizona 

Farm Bureau

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0051

I-23 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Susan Kidd, Arizona 

Public Service (APS)

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0052

I-24 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Earthjustice on behalf 

of NPCA et al.

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0053

I-25 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Mark Ourada, 

American Coalition for Clean Coal Electricity

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0054

I-26 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Edwin D. Hill, 

International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0055

I-27 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 – Henry Darwin, 

Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ)

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0056

I-28 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Henry Darwin, Arizona 

Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) – duplicate

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0057

I-29 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Arizona Utilities 

Group

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0058

I-30 [Not used]

I-31 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-18520 - Office of 

Congressman Jeff Flake

EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0013

I-32 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 – James Arndt 2012-08-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0014

I-33 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 – Sid Abma 2012-07-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0015

I-34 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 – William Tracey 2012-07-27 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-
0021-0016

I-35 Comment on FR Doc # 2012-17659 – Ed Rogers 2012-08-02 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0017

I-36 COMMENT letter from EarthJustice to Janet McCabe, June 

29, 2012 

2012-06-29 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0064

I-37 COMMENT: Email from OConnor to Webb, September 5, 

2012 and Donez Email to OConnor, September 7, 2012.

2012-09-05 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0065

I-38 COMMENT: AZ White Mtns Mass Comment Campaign, 

August 2012

2012-08 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0066

I-39 COMMENT: James Arndt, 8-17-2012 2012-08-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0067

I-40 COMMENT via email from Sid Abma to Margo Perez 

Sullivan July 11, 2012.

2012-07-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0068

I-41 COMMENT via email William Tracey to Margot Perez 

Sullivan, July 27, 2012.

2012-07-27 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0069

I-42 COMMENT via email Ed Rogers referring to Cholla power 

plant and visibility in Winslow, Arizona and other areas sent 

first to Rory Mays, 8-02-2012, then directed to the correct 

person, Tom Webb.

2012-08-02 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0070

I-43 COMMENT via email Therese North to Tom Webb, 8-02-

2012.

2012-08-02 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0071

I-44 COMMENT via email from Richard Low to Jared 

Blumenfeld, 8-11-2012

2012-08-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0072

I-45 COMMENT via email from Karin and Carole Sitts to 

Thomas Webb, 8-13-2012.

2012-08-13 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0073

I-46 COMMENT via email from Melinda Conrad to Thomas 

Webb, 8-14-2012.

2012-08-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0074

I-47 COMMENT letter from Rep. Jeff Flake to Colleen 

McKaughan, 8-14-2012.

2012-08-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0075

I-48 COMMENT via email from Randy Murph to Thomas Webb, 

8-14-2012.

2012-08-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0076

I-49 COMMENT via email from David Shumway to Thomas 

Webb, 8-14-2012.

2012-08-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0077

I-50 COMMENT via email from Karlee DeWitt to Thomas Webb, 2012-08-15 EPA-R09-
8-15-2012. OAR-2012-

0021-0078

I-51 COMMENT from public hearing: David M. Newlin EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0079

I-52 COMMENT from public hearing: Elizabeth Speck, Benson 

AZ

EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0080

I-53 COMMENT via email 8-16-2012: Daniel Sawvel, Cochise 

County AZ

2012-08-16 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0081

I-54 COMMENT via email 8-16-2012: Jamie Stanford to Thomas 

Webb, 8-16-12.

2012-08-16 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0082

I-55 COMMENT via email 8-17-2012: David Santeford. 2012-08-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0083

I-56 COMMENT via email 8-19-2012: Gary Truschke to Thomas 

Webb.

2012-08-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0084

I-57 COMMENT via email 8-20-2012: Gary Maurer, CEO, 

Prescott Chamber of Commerce to Thomas Webb.

2012-08-20 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0085

I-58 COMMENT via email from Emily Regis to Tom Webb 

August 20, 2012.

2012-08-20 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0086

I-59 COMMENT via email from Don Berry to Jared Blumenfeld, 

August 29, 2012.

2012-08-29 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0087

I-60 COMMENT via email from Nathan Hatch to Tom Webb, 

August 29, 2012.

2012-08-29 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0088

I-61 COMMENT via email from Jonathan Gardner to Tom Webb, 

August 30, 2012.

2012-08-30 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0089

I-62 COMMENT via email from Tim Miller to Tom Webb, 

September 4, 2012.

2012-09-04 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0090

I-63 COMMENT via email from Leigh A. Verley to Tom Webb, 

September 10, 2012.

2012-09-10 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0091

I-64 COMMENT via email from Monica Balderrama to Tom 

Webb, September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0092

I-65 COMMENT via email from Janice Bernal to Tom Webb, 

September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0093

I-66 COMMENT via email from Gail A. Casto to Tom Webb, 2012-09-11 EPA-R09-
September 11, 2012. OAR-2012-

0021-0094

I-67 COMMENT via email from Bikrham Chaudhary to Tom 

Webb, September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0095

I-68 COMMENT via email from Kevin Gin to Tom Webb, 

September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0096

I-69 COMMENT via email from Samantha Gooman to Tom 

Webb, September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0097

I-70 COMMENT via email from James L. Jones to Tom Webb, 

September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0098

I-70 COMMENT via email from Chris Maakestad to Tom Webb, 

September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0099

I-71 COMMENT via email from John Shaver to Tom Webb, 

September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0100

I-72 COMMENT via email from Cathie Thompson to Tom Webb, 

September 11, 2012.

2012-09-11 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0101

I-73 COMMENT via email from Danny Brown to Tom Webb, 

September 12, 2012.

2012-09-12 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0102

I-74 COMMENT via email from Lori Fonzi to Tom Webb, 

September 12, 2012.

2012-09-12 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0103

I-75 COMMENT via email from Russell McLeod to Tom Webb, 

September 12, 2012.

2012-09-12 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0104

I-76 COMMENT via email from Jamie R. Stanford to Tom Webb, 

September 12, 2012.

2012-09-12 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0105

I-77 COMMENT via email from Tammy Gehris to Tom Webb, 

September 13, 2012.

2012-09-13 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0106

I-78 COMMENT via email from Kirk Gray to Tom Webb, 

September 13, 2012.

2012-09-13 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0107

I-79 COMMENT via email from Pat Middlebrook to Tom Webb, 

September 13, 2012.

2012-09-13 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0108

I-80 COMMENT via email from Pat David Michael Paul to Tom 

Webb, September 13, 2012.

2012-09-13 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0109

I-81 COMMENT via email from Kenneth R Cool III to Tom 2012-09-13 EPA-R09-
Webb, September 13, 2012. OAR-2012-

0021-0110

I-82 COMMENT via email from Stuart D. Kershner, PhD to Tom 

Webb, September 14, 2012.

2012-09-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0111

I-83 COMMENT via email from Mark Woods to Tom Webb, 

September 14, 2012.

2012-09-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0112

I-84 COMMENT via email from Caron Johnson to Tom Webb, 

September 15, 2012.

2012-09-15 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0113

I-85 COMMENT via email from Leslie E Thompson to Tom 

Webb, September 16, 2012.

2012-09-16 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0114

I-86 COMMENT via email from Robyn Daughenbaugh to Tom 

Webb, September 17, 2012.

2012-09-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0115

I-87 COMMENT via email from Glen Manygoats to Tom Webb, 

September 17, 2012.

2012-09-17 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0116

I-88 COMMENT via email from Kevin Barnes to Tom Webb, 

September 18, 2012.

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0117

I-89 COMMENT via email from Chris Barton to Tom Webb, 

September 18, 2012.

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0118

I-90 COMMENT via email from Lori Fonzi to Tom Webb, 

September 18, 2012.

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0119

I-91 COMMENT via email from Geoff Oldfather to Tom Webb, 

September 18, 2012.

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0120

I-92 COMMENT via email from Vincent Yazzie to Tom Webb, 

September 18, 2012.

2012-09-18 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0121

I-93 COMMENT via email from Stephen B. Estitty to Tom 

Webb, October 3, 2012.

2012-10-03 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0122

I-94 COMMENT via email from Maureen Creegan to Tom Webb, 

August 24, 2012.

2012-08-24 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0123

I-95 COMMENT via email from Gretchen Conger to Tom Webb, 

August 29, 2012.

2012-08-29 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0124

I-96 COMMENT via email from Barbara Stockwell to Tom 

Webb, September 14, 2012.

2012-09-14 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0125

I-97 COMMENT via email from Michelle Freeark (AEPCO) to 2012-09-18 EPA-R09-
Tom Webb, September 18, 2012. OAR-2012-

0021-0126

I-98 COMMENT via hardcopy from Dilleen_Kodish_Smith 

(Earthjustice) Letter to Janet McCabe dated June 29, 2012.

2012-07-29 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0127

I-99 COMMENT via hardcopy from Lavonda Begay to Jared 

Blumenfeld July 19, 2012.

2012-07-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0128

I-100 COMMENT via hardcopy from Karl Guzzo to Jared 

Blumenfeld July 19, 2012.

2012-07-19 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0129

I-101 COMMENT via hardcopy from Ed Pahl to Jared Blumenfeld 

July 23, 2012.

2012-07-23 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0130

I-102 COMMENT via hardcopy from Gary Pierce to Jared 

Blumenfeld July 23, 2012.

2012-07-23 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0131

I-103 COMMENT Public Hearing transcript, Benson AZ, August 

15, 2012.

2012-08-15 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0167

I-104 Comment via hardcopy from AZ Rock Products Assoc to 

Jackson 

I-105 Comment via hardcopy from Benson Unified Sch. Distr #9

[Reserved]

J. Additional Documents Considered for Final Rulemaking

J-01 Coal Availability Study—Standing Rock Area, San Juan 

Basin Northwest New Mexico by Gretchen K. Hoffman and 

Glen E. Jones, Open-file Report 540, July, 2011.

2011-07 EPA-R09-

OAR-2012-

0021-0063

J-02 Letter re Potential Force Majeure -- SRP Consent 

Decree_(41554364)_(2)

2012-08-09

J-03 Pierce_Air Response_July 26 2012 2012-07-26

J-04 2012-06-26 Kelly J Barr Esq Salt River Letter to Deborah 

Jordan

2012-06-26

J-05 2012-06-29 Michelle R Freeark Arizona's G & T 

Cooperatives Letter to Deborah Jordan

2012-06-29

J-06 Barr_Air Response_July 26 2012 2012-07-26

J-07 Burns_Air Response_July 26 2012 2012-07-26

J-08 Burns_Air Response_July 26 2012 2012-07-26

J-09 Burns_Air Response_July 26 2012 2012-07-26

J-10 Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. 7401 et seq. 2011

J-11 Congressional Review Act (5 U.S.C 801 et seq.) 2011

J-12 Executive Order 12866: Regulatory Planning and Review (58 

FR 51735)

1993-10-04

J-13 Executive Order 12898: Federal Actions To Address 

Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and LowIncome Populations (59 FR 7629)

1994-02-16

J-14 Executive Order 13045: Protection of Children From 1997-04-23
Environmental Health Risks and Safety Risks (62 FR 19885)

J-15 Executive Order 13132: Federalism (64 FR 43255) 1999-08-10

J-16 Executive Order 13175: Consultation and Coordination With 

Indian Tribal Governments (65 FR 67249)

2000-11-09

J-17 Executive Order 13211: Actions Concerning Regulations 

That Significantly Affect Energy Supply, Distribution, or Use 

(66 FR 28355)

2001-05-22

J-18 Executive Order 13563: Improving Regulation and 

Regulatory Review (76 FR 3821)

2011-01-21

J-19 National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act (15 

USC 3701 et seq.)

2011

J-20 Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.) 2011

J-21 Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) 2011

J-22 Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (2 U.S.C. 501 et seq.) 2011

J-23 AEPCO Apache Generating Station BART Determination 

Economic Impacts 11_07_2012

J-24 Apache Station Incremental Cost Assessment Report and 

spreadsheet – 2 files

2012-11-12

J-25 Haldor-Topsoe SCR Experience List 10-09 2009-10

J-26 Hitachi SCR experience list

J-27 Ted Kurtides, Lessons Learned from SCR Reactor Retrofit

J-28 Institute of Clean Air Companies, SCR White Paper, May

2009

2009-05

J-29 Design and Operation of Coal-fired TURBO furnaces for 

NOx control 1978-11

1978-11

J-30 An Overview of Riley Stoker’s Burner Development Efforts 

for NOx Control 1983-04

1983-04

J-31 Low NOx Combustion System Solutions for Wall Fired,TFired, and Turbo Fired Boilers 2006-082006-08

J-32 readme_modeling_files_NFR1

J-33 2006FinalDryBottomPC_FGD_FFpmSpeciationProfile_Chol

la-Unit2-filtPM

J-34 BRODE_CA

J-35 Cholla_mrg23_visx_table

J-36 Cholla_NFR_remodeling

J-37 Coronado_base_p_visx

J-38 FLAG_2010

J-39 modeling_docket_list

J-40 Arizona BART Eligibility TSD (Supporting Documentation 

on Emissions Unit Bart Eligibility Analysis)

2006

J-41 Memorandum from Jeffrey Cole (RTI International) to Bill 

Maxwell (EPA) regarding NESHAP MACT Floor Analysis 

for Coal- and Oil-fired Electric Utility Steam Generating 

Units for Final Rule” 

2011-12-16

J-42 EPA, Transport Rule Engineering Feasibility Response to 

Comments, Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0491-4529, 

2011-07-06

J-43 Arizona Department of Transportation, Approved Materials 

Source List, Fly Ash, Natural Pozzolan, and Lime, Revised 

2012-07-10
J-44 In re: Upper Blackstone Water Pollution Abatement District, 

Order Denying Review In Part and Remanding In Part,

NPDES Appeal Nos.08-11 to 08-18 & 09-06

2010-05-

28

J-45 EPA’s Technical Information Document 09, “Methods 201 

and 201A in Presence of Water Droplets” 

1991-09-09

J-46 CEMS Cost Calculation 2012-11

J-47 Timeline of all tribal consultations on BART.docx 2012-07-02

J-48 History of Arizona State Implementation Plan (SIP) 

Submittals Under the Regional Haze Rule

2012-11-14

J-49 American Corn Growers Ass'n v. EPA, 291 F.3d 1 2002

J-50 Center for Energy and Economic Development v. EPA, 398 

F.3d 653 

2005

J-51 Central Arizona Water Conservation Dist. v. EPA, 990 F.2d 

1531 

1993

J-52 Hall v. EPA, 273 F.3d 1146 2001

J-53 Luminant Generation Co., L.L.C. v. E.PA, 675 F.3d 917 2012

J-54 Montana Sulphur & Chemical Co. v. EPA, 666 F.3d 1174 2012

J-55 Texas v. EPA, 690 F.3d 670 2012

J-56 Train v. NRDC, 421 U.S. 60 1975

J-57 Union Elec. Co. v. EPA, 427 U.S. 246 1976

J-58 Utility Air Regulatory Group v. EPA, 471 F.3d 1333 2006

J-59 EME Homer City Generation v. EPA, 696 F.3d 7 2012

J-60 NPCA v. EPA, Complaint (D.D.C. Case 1:11-cv-01548) 2011-08-29 

J-61 NPCA v. EPA, Consent Decree (D.D.C. Case 1:11-cv01548) Dkt # 212012-03-30

J-62 NPCA v. EPA, D.D.C. Memorandum Opinion and Order 

(D.D.C. Case 1:11-cv-01548) Dkt # 35

2012-05-25

J-63 NPCA v. EPA, Docket (D.D.C. Case 1:11-cv-01548) 2012

K. Notice of Final Rulemaking and Response to Comments

K.1. Notice of Final Rulemaking 2012-11-15

K.2. Final Index to Docket EPA-R09-OAR-2012- 0021 2012-11-15