Worksheet Description

Undiscounted Time 

Profiles

Summarizes the undiscounted time profiles of monetized benefits 

for the final rule and options considered. Includes profiles for 

individual benefit categories and totals. Benefits are in millions of 

2011$.

Discounted Time 

Profiles

Summarizes the discounted time profiles of total monetized 

benefits for the final rule and options considered. Benefits are in 

millions of 2011$, discounted using rates of 3 and 7 percent.

Discounting Summary Tables for BA.xls

Author: Abt Associates Inc.

Created: 05/12/14

Purpose: To summarize the time profiles of both undiscounted and discounted 

monetized benefits under the final rule and options considered.
Year

Proposal Option 

4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2

Proposal Option 

4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2

2013 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2014 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2015 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2016 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2017 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2018 $0.010 $0.010 $0.001 $0.076 $0.287 $0.002

2019 $0.032 $0.034 $0.003 $0.111 $0.330 $0.002

2020 $0.118 $0.123 $0.011 $0.219 $0.781 $1.226

2021 $0.227 $0.237 $0.043 $0.266 $0.981 $4.763

2022 $0.347 $0.362 $0.089 $0.424 $1.367 $27.977

2023 $0.442 $0.460 $0.274 $0.424 $1.367 $28.606

2024 $0.543 $0.565 $0.400 $0.424 $1.367 $54.082

2025 $0.568 $0.591 $0.580 $0.424 $1.367 $63.689

2026 $0.579 $0.602 $0.702 $0.424 $1.367 $79.819

2027 $0.586 $0.609 $0.843 $0.424 $1.367 $79.819

2028 $0.586 $0.609 $0.920 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2029 $0.586 $0.609 $0.977 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2030 $0.586 $0.609 $1.014 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2031 $0.586 $0.609 $1.062 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2032 $0.586 $0.609 $1.128 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2033 $0.586 $0.609 $1.141 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2034 $0.586 $0.609 $1.148 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2035 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2036 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2037 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2038 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2039 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2040 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2041 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2042 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2043 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2044 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2045 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2046 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2047 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2048 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2049 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2050 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2051 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2052 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2053 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2054 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2055 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2056 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2057 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2058 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2059 $0.586 $0.609 $1.153 $0.424 $1.367 $80.145

2060 $0.527 $0.548 $1.038 $0.352 $1.135 $66.520

2061 $0.469 $0.487 $0.922 $0.284 $0.916 $53.697

2062 $0.117 $0.122 $0.231 $0.212 $0.684 $40.072

T&E (in millions) Nonuse Benefit Transfer (in millions)
2063 $0.059 $0.061 $0.115 $0.140 $0.451 $26.448

2064 $0.029 $0.030 $0.058 $0.072 $0.232 $13.625
Proposal Option 

4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2

Proposal Option 

4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.008 $0.009 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.025 $0.027 $0.001 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.096 $0.103 $0.008 $0.736 $0.790 $0.042

$0.177 $0.190 $0.212 $2.008 $2.150 $1.858

$0.352 $0.376 $0.506 $8.186 $8.770 $4.535

$0.530 $0.564 $1.793 $13.513 $14.443 $16.887

$1.027 $1.084 $2.527 $21.920 $23.415 $24.470

$1.253 $1.324 $2.979 $24.650 $26.350 $33.814

$1.318 $1.393 $3.563 $25.676 $27.446 $42.597

$1.368 $1.445 $4.114 $26.361 $28.180 $50.910

$1.379 $1.457 $5.064 $26.434 $28.258 $56.750

$1.379 $1.457 $5.947 $26.434 $28.258 $64.266

$1.379 $1.457 $6.210 $26.434 $28.258 $66.963

$1.379 $1.457 $6.723 $26.434 $28.258 $71.649

$1.379 $1.457 $6.844 $26.434 $28.258 $74.265

$1.379 $1.457 $6.877 $26.434 $28.258 $74.845

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.279

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.379 $1.457 $6.910 $26.434 $28.258 $75.406

$1.241 $1.312 $6.219 $23.790 $25.433 $67.866

$1.104 $1.166 $5.528 $21.147 $22.607 $60.325

$0.276 $0.291 $1.382 $5.287 $5.652 $15.081

Commercial Fishing Benefits (in millions) Recreational Fishing Benefits (in millions)
$0.138 $0.146 $0.691 $2.643 $2.826 $7.541

$0.069 $0.073 $0.346 $1.322 $1.413 $3.770
Total (excluding 

SCC) (in millions)

Proposal Option 

4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2 New Units SCC Final Rule New Units 

Proposal Option 

4

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.004 $0.000

$8.644 $8.644 $0.000 $0.000 $0.009 $8.644

$8.877 $8.877 $0.000 $0.000 $0.015 $8.877

$9.111 $9.111 $0.000 -$0.013 $0.021 $9.111

-$1.853 -$1.853 $137.902 -$0.026 $0.028 -$1.759

-$1.946 -$1.946 $144.797 -$0.041 $0.035 -$1.777

-$1.992 -$1.992 $148.245 -$0.055 $0.042 -$0.824

-$1.992 -$1.992 -$1,273.070 -$0.069 $0.048 $0.686

-$2.038 -$2.038 -$1,304.271 -$0.085 $0.055 $7.271

$44.021 $44.021 -$1,497.929 -$0.102 $0.062 $58.931

$45.000 $45.000 -$1,537.891 -$0.119 $0.069 $68.915

$45.978 $45.978 -$1,571.852 -$0.136 $0.076 $72.873

$46.956 $46.956 -$2,636.784 -$0.155 $0.082 $74.954

$47.934 $47.934 -$2,691.622 -$0.174 $0.089 $76.674

$48.913 $48.913 -$2,746.482 -$0.193 $0.096 $77.736

$49.891 $49.891 -$2,801.387 -$0.214 $0.103 $78.714

$50.869 $50.869 -$2,856.319 -$0.235 $0.109 $79.692

$50.869 $50.869 -$2,106.269 -$0.251 $0.116 $79.692

$51.847 $51.847 -$2,146.745 -$0.273 $0.123 $80.671

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,187.190 -$0.296 $0.130 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,227.684 -$0.319 $0.136 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,268.161 -$0.343 $0.143 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,308.592 -$0.367 $0.150 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,348.851 -$0.393 $0.157 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,389.138 -$0.418 $0.164 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,429.267 -$0.445 $0.170 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,469.384 -$0.472 $0.177 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,509.866 -$0.500 $0.184 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,550.348 -$0.528 $0.191 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,590.829 -$0.557 $0.197 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,631.311 -$0.587 $0.204 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,671.793 -$0.617 $0.211 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,712.275 -$0.648 $0.218 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,752.756 -$0.680 $0.225 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,793.238 -$0.712 $0.231 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,833.720 -$0.745 $0.238 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,874.201 -$0.778 $0.245 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,915.272 -$0.813 $0.252 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,956.929 -$0.848 $0.258 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$2,999.182 -$0.884 $0.265 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$3,042.038 -$0.921 $0.272 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$3,085.507 -$0.958 $0.279 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$3,129.597 -$0.997 $0.286 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$3,174.316 -$1.036 $0.292 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$3,219.675 -$1.077 $0.299 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 -$3,265.682 -$1.118 $0.306 $28.823

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.263 $25.911

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.221 $23.003

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.116 $5.892

Social Cost of Carbon (SCC)
$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.072 $2.980

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.037 $1.492
Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2 New Units

Final Rule - 

Existing and 

New Units

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.004 $0.004

$8.644 $0.000 $0.009 $8.652

$8.877 $0.000 $0.015 $8.892

$9.111 $0.000 $0.009 $9.120

-$1.547 $137.906 $0.002 -$1.544

-$1.555 $144.804 -$0.006 -$1.560

-$0.195 $149.531 -$0.014 -$0.209

$1.566 -$1,266.195 -$0.021 $1.545

$8.836 -$1,271.165 -$0.030 $8.806

$60.856 -$1,450.370 -$0.040 $60.816

$71.431 -$1,456.412 -$0.050 $71.381

$75.609 -$1,470.789 -$0.061 $75.549

$77.765 -$2,510.104 -$0.072 $77.693

$79.535 -$2,555.936 -$0.085 $79.451

$80.605 -$2,603.604 -$0.098 $80.507

$81.583 -$2,650.052 -$0.111 $81.472

$82.561 -$2,701.988 -$0.125 $82.436

$82.561 -$1,946.689 -$0.135 $82.426

$83.540 -$1,984.363 -$0.150 $83.389

$31.692 -$2,024.182 -$0.166 $31.526

$31.692 -$2,064.202 -$0.183 $31.510

$31.692 -$2,104.547 -$0.200 $31.493

$31.692 -$2,144.978 -$0.217 $31.475

$31.692 -$2,185.237 -$0.236 $31.456

$31.692 -$2,225.524 -$0.255 $31.437

$31.692 -$2,265.653 -$0.274 $31.418

$31.692 -$2,305.770 -$0.295 $31.398

$31.692 -$2,346.252 -$0.316 $31.377

$31.692 -$2,386.734 -$0.337 $31.355

$31.692 -$2,427.215 -$0.360 $31.333

$31.692 -$2,467.697 -$0.382 $31.310

$31.692 -$2,508.179 -$0.406 $31.286

$31.692 -$2,548.661 -$0.430 $31.262

$31.692 -$2,589.142 -$0.455 $31.237

$31.692 -$2,629.624 -$0.480 $31.212

$31.692 -$2,670.106 -$0.507 $31.186

$31.692 -$2,710.587 -$0.533 $31.159

$31.692 -$2,751.658 -$0.561 $31.131

$31.692 -$2,793.315 -$0.589 $31.103

$31.692 -$2,835.568 -$0.618 $31.074

$31.692 -$2,878.424 -$0.648 $31.044

$31.692 -$2,921.893 -$0.679 $31.013

$31.692 -$2,965.983 -$0.711 $30.981

$31.692 -$3,010.702 -$0.744 $30.948

$31.692 -$3,056.061 -$0.778 $30.914

$31.692 -$3,102.068 -$0.812 $30.880

$28.427 $141.642 $0.263 $28.690

$25.176 $120.472 $0.221 $25.397

$6.749 $56.766 $0.116 $6.864

Undiscounted Totals (in millions)
$3.484 $34.795 $0.072 $3.556

$1.749 $17.798 $0.037 $1.786
Proposal Option 

4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal Option 

2

2012 -1 1.030 1.070 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2013 0 1.000 1.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2014 1 0.971 0.935 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

2015 2 0.943 0.873 $8.147 $8.147 $0.000

2016 3 0.915 0.816 $8.124 $8.124 $0.000

2017 4 0.888 0.763 $8.095 $8.095 $0.000

2018 5 0.863 0.713 -$1.517 -$1.334 $118.959

2019 6 0.837 0.666 -$1.488 -$1.302 $121.271

2020 7 0.813 0.623 -$0.670 -$0.158 $121.582

2021 8 0.789 0.582 $0.542 $1.236 -$999.546

2022 9 0.766 0.544 $5.572 $6.772 -$974.242

2023 10 0.744 0.508 $43.850 $45.283 -$1,079.211

2024 11 0.722 0.475 $49.786 $51.603 -$1,052.143

2025 12 0.701 0.444 $51.111 $53.031 -$1,031.582

2026 13 0.681 0.415 $51.040 $52.955 -$1,709.258

2027 14 0.661 0.388 $50.690 $52.582 -$1,689.775

2028 15 0.642 0.362 $49.896 $51.737 -$1,671.154

2029 16 0.623 0.339 $49.052 $50.840 -$1,651.425

2030 17 0.605 0.317 $48.215 $49.951 -$1,634.747

2031 18 0.587 0.296 $46.811 $48.496 -$1,143.475

2032 19 0.570 0.277 $46.005 $47.642 -$1,131.655

2033 20 0.554 0.258 $15.959 $17.547 -$1,120.741

2034 21 0.538 0.242 $15.494 $17.036 -$1,109.610

2035 22 0.522 0.226 $15.043 $16.540 -$1,098.347

2036 23 0.507 0.211 $14.604 $16.058 -$1,086.843

2037 24 0.492 0.197 $14.179 $15.591 -$1,074.992

2038 25 0.478 0.184 $13.766 $15.136 -$1,062.923

2039 26 0.464 0.172 $13.365 $14.696 -$1,050.571

2040 27 0.450 0.161 $12.976 $14.268 -$1,038.033

2041 28 0.437 0.150 $12.598 $13.852 -$1,025.492

2042 29 0.424 0.141 $12.231 $13.449 -$1,012.802

2043 30 0.412 0.131 $11.875 $13.057 -$999.981

2044 31 0.400 0.123 $11.529 $12.677 -$987.047

2045 32 0.388 0.115 $11.193 $12.307 -$974.019

2046 33 0.377 0.107 $10.867 $11.949 -$960.912

2047 34 0.366 0.100 $10.551 $11.601 -$947.742

2048 35 0.355 0.094 $10.243 $11.263 -$934.525

2049 36 0.345 0.088 $9.945 $10.935 -$921.273

2050 37 0.335 0.082 $9.655 $10.616 -$908.001

2051 38 0.325 0.076 $9.374 $10.307 -$894.911

2052 39 0.316 0.071 $9.101 $10.007 -$881.999

2053 40 0.307 0.067 $8.836 $9.715 -$869.263

2054 41 0.298 0.062 $8.579 $9.433 -$856.700

2055 42 0.289 0.058 $8.329 $9.158 -$844.308

2056 43 0.281 0.055 $8.086 $8.891 -$832.085

2057 44 0.272 0.051 $7.851 $8.632 -$820.030

2058 45 0.264 0.048 $7.622 $8.381 -$808.141

2059 46 0.257 0.044 $7.400 $8.137 -$796.414

2060 47 0.249 0.042 $6.459 $7.086 $35.306

2061 48 0.242 0.039 $5.567 $6.093 $29.154

2062 49 0.235 0.036 $1.384 $1.586 $13.337

2063 50 0.228 0.034 $0.680 $0.795 $7.937

Using 3% Discount Rate (in millions)

Year period df 3% df 7%
2064 51 0.221 0.032 $0.330 $0.387 $3.942

2065 52 0.215 0.030 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

NPV $828.931 $880.882 -$41,234.429

ann factor $0.037 $0.037 $0.037

annualized $31.012 $32.955 -$1,542.641
New Units

Final Rule - 

Existing and New

Proposal 

Option 4

Final Rule - 

Existing Units

Proposal 

Option 2 New Units

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

$0.004 $0.004 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.004

$0.008 $8.156 $7.550 $7.550 $0.000 $0.008

$0.014 $8.138 $7.246 $7.246 $0.000 $0.012

$0.008 $8.103 $6.951 $6.951 $0.000 $0.007

$0.002 -$1.332 -$1.254 -$1.103 $98.325 $0.002

-$0.005 -$1.307 -$1.184 -$1.036 $96.489 -$0.004

-$0.011 -$0.170 -$0.513 -$0.121 $93.120 -$0.009

-$0.017 $1.219 $0.399 $0.911 -$736.937 -$0.012

-$0.023 $6.749 $3.955 $4.806 -$691.429 -$0.016

-$0.029 $45.253 $29.958 $30.936 -$737.294 -$0.020

-$0.036 $51.567 $32.741 $33.936 -$691.931 -$0.024

-$0.043 $52.988 $32.356 $33.571 -$653.048 -$0.027

-$0.049 $52.905 $31.103 $32.270 -$1,041.604 -$0.030

-$0.056 $52.526 $29.735 $30.845 -$991.236 -$0.033

-$0.063 $51.675 $28.175 $29.215 -$943.666 -$0.035

-$0.069 $50.771 $26.663 $27.635 -$897.664 -$0.038

-$0.076 $49.875 $25.229 $26.137 -$855.380 -$0.040

-$0.079 $48.417 $23.578 $24.427 -$575.955 -$0.040

-$0.086 $47.556 $22.306 $23.099 -$548.693 -$0.042

-$0.092 $17.455 $7.448 $8.190 -$523.087 -$0.043

-$0.098 $16.938 $6.961 $7.654 -$498.532 -$0.044

-$0.104 $16.436 $6.506 $7.153 -$475.024 -$0.045

-$0.110 $15.948 $6.080 $6.685 -$452.477 -$0.046

-$0.116 $15.475 $5.682 $6.248 -$430.812 -$0.046

-$0.122 $15.015 $5.311 $5.839 -$410.051 -$0.047

-$0.127 $14.568 $4.963 $5.457 -$390.135 -$0.047

-$0.133 $14.135 $4.639 $5.100 -$371.068 -$0.047

-$0.138 $13.714 $4.335 $4.767 -$352.881 -$0.047

-$0.143 $13.305 $4.051 $4.455 -$335.486 -$0.047

-$0.148 $12.909 $3.786 $4.163 -$318.856 -$0.047

-$0.153 $12.524 $3.539 $3.891 -$302.967 -$0.047

-$0.158 $12.150 $3.307 $3.636 -$287.791 -$0.047

-$0.162 $11.787 $3.091 $3.399 -$273.305 -$0.046

-$0.167 $11.434 $2.889 $3.176 -$259.482 -$0.046

-$0.171 $11.092 $2.700 $2.968 -$246.298 -$0.045

-$0.175 $10.760 $2.523 $2.774 -$233.729 -$0.044

-$0.179 $10.438 $2.358 $2.593 -$221.750 -$0.044

-$0.182 $10.125 $2.204 $2.423 -$210.383 -$0.043

-$0.186 $9.821 $2.060 $2.265 -$199.596 -$0.042

-$0.190 $9.526 $1.925 $2.116 -$189.360 -$0.041

-$0.193 $9.240 $1.799 $1.978 -$179.647 -$0.040

-$0.196 $8.961 $1.681 $1.849 -$170.430 -$0.040

-$0.200 $8.692 $1.571 $1.728 -$161.684 -$0.039

-$0.203 $8.429 $1.468 $1.615 -$153.385 -$0.038

-$0.206 $8.175 $1.372 $1.509 -$145.510 -$0.037

-$0.209 $7.928 $1.283 $1.410 -$138.038 -$0.036

$0.065 $7.151 $1.078 $1.182 $5.891 $0.011

$0.054 $6.146 $0.894 $0.979 $4.682 $0.009

$0.027 $1.613 $0.214 $0.245 $2.062 $0.004

$0.016 $0.811 $0.101 $0.118 $1.181 $0.002

scount Rate (in millions) Using 7% Discount Rate (in millions)
$0.008 $0.395 $0.047 $0.055 $0.565 $0.001

$0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000 $0.000

-$4.694 $876.188 $402.860 $424.898 -$16,994.287 -$1.492

$0.037 $0.037 $0.068 $0.068 $0.068 $0.068

-$0.176 $32.779 $27.219 $28.708 -$1,148.205 -$0.101
Final Rule - Existing 

and New

$0.000

$0.000

$0.004

$7.557

$7.259

$6.957

-$1.101

-$1.040

-$0.130

$0.899

$4.790

$30.916

$33.913

$33.544

$32.240

$30.812

$29.180

$27.597

$26.097

$24.387

$23.058

$8.147

$7.610

$7.108

$6.640

$6.202

$5.792

$5.410

$5.053

$4.719

$4.407

$4.116

$3.844

$3.590

$3.352

$3.131

$2.923

$2.730

$2.549

$2.380

$2.222

$2.075

$1.937

$1.809

$1.689

$1.577

$1.472

$1.374

$1.193

$0.987

$0.249

$0.121
$0.057

$0.000

$423.406

$0.068

$28.607