08/19/201 0 15:3 5 FA X 2024335U 2 FA A ^ DM S 0001/01 0

UNITE D STATE S O F AMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N , - - - - - - > , _ _ . OFFIC E O F HEARING S ^ -- v.^-^^

^ WASHINGTON , D,C . - ' " * ^ 201 0

*************** * i * i «r>1nr«»*****»***^H-**-)r«******* - I n th e Matte ro f JN L MARBL E & * FA A Docke t No. : CP10WP000 7 GRANITE , INC . *

Respondent . * FA A Region : Western-Pacifi c Judge : Honorabl e Richar d C . Goodwi n DM S No . FAA-2010^54 1 * +



### MOTIO N T O COMPE L DISCOVER Y RESPONSE S AN D MOTIO N T O DEE M A S A N ADMISSIO N O F TRUT H EAC H STATEMEN T I N COMPLAINANT' S REQUEST S FO RADMISSIO N To ; Th e Honorable Richar

dC . Goodwi

n an dt o Responden

t herein : Complainant , b

y an dthrough counsel , pursuan t to §§13.21 8 an

d13.22 0 o f th e Rule s of Practic e in FA

A Civi l Penalt y Actions , [1 4 C.F.R . § 13.21 8 an d§13.220 ] files thi s Motio n t o Compe l Answer s t o Complainant' s Firs t

Discover y Reques t an dMotion t o Dee ma s a n Admissio

n of Trutl i Eac h Statemen

t i n Complainant' s Request s fo r Admission . Thi s motion i s base do n the fac t tha t n o response s t

o Complainant' s Firs t Discover y Reques t have bee n filed b y Respondent . O n Jul y 8 , 2010 , Complainan

t serve dit s Firs t Reques t fo r Discover y seeking informatio n regarding th e identit

y o f witnesses , testimony , documents an dothe r evidenc e08/19/201 0 15.3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A ^ DM S @002/01 0

t o b e presente dby Responden t a t th e hearin g i n th e withi n case . ( A tru e cop y o f sai d discover y reques t i s attache dheret o a s exhibi t "A." ) (Se e Decl . o f

Jef f Kamberg) . Complainant' s first

discovery reques t

als o containe dth e followin g reques t fo r admissions : 1 . Admi t

that o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , you wer e atickete dpassenge r o n Northwes t

Airline s Fligh t

2 2 fromHonolulu , Hawai i t o Sa n Francisco , California , 2 . Admi t

that o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , yo u knowingl y offere dchecke d baggag e o n th e flight

mentione di n Interrogatory 1 . 3 . Admi t

that o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , you r

checke dbaggag e fo

r th e fligh t mentione di n Interrogatory 1 containe don e quar t acetone . 4 . Admi t

tha t o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , you r

checke dbaggag e fo

r th e fligh t mentione di n Xnterrogaioiy 1 containe drw o 3 0 gra mtube s o f

hardene r paste . Respondent' s response s t o Complainant' s discovery wer e du e o n Augus t 9 , 2010 . T o date . Responden t

ha s faile dt o provid e response s t o th e propounde ddiscovery , no r ha s h e requeste da

n extensio n o f

tim e in whic h t o fil e aresponse . Withou t response s t o th e propounde ddiscovery , Complainan t wil l b e hampere di n it s ability t o prepar e fo

r ahearing , whic h accordin g t o th e Procedural Order serve do n Jun e 28 , 2010 , wil l b e se t anytim e afler

Septembe r

1 , 2010 . Complainan t

request s th e Administrativ e La

w Judg e issu e a

n Orde r compellin g Responden t

t o provid e separat e an d complet e answer s l o eac h o f th e discovery request s propounde db y Complainant . Complainan t

fiirther request s tha

t th e Administrativ e Law Judg e deema s a n admissio n o f

th e truth eac h statemen t containe di n th e reques t for admissions , o n basi s tha t Responden t

faile dt o respon dt o Complainant' s request s for admissio n witlii n 3 0 days . [ 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.22 1 (I)(l ) whic h state s " A parly' s failure t o respon dl o areques t for admission , in writin g andsigne db y th e attorne y o r th e party , no t

late r than 3 0 day s afte

r08/19/201 0 15:3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A + DM S @!003/01 0

servic e o f th e request , i s deeme da

n admissio n o f

th e trut h o f th e statemen t

o r statement s containe di n th e reques t

fo r admission." ] Respectfijll y submitted . Naomi Tsud a Regiona l Qoimsc l

: Augus t 13,201 0cftf t + DM S 01004/01 0 08/19/201 0 15:3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A UH i

DECLARATIO N O F JEF F KAMBER G I , Jef f Kamberg , declare a s follows ; Al l matter s slate dherei n are withi n m y ow n personal knowledge , an di f calle da s avviijiess , I could , andwoul dcompetentl y testif y thereto , excep t

fo r thos e matter s state dupo n informatio n an dbelief , an da s t o thos e matters , I believ e ihe mt o b e true : 1 . I a

malegal technicia n in th e Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counsel , Federa l Aviatio n Admini.?tration , Westem-Pacifi c Region . 2 . O n Jul y 8 , 2010 , I serve dth e original Complainant' s Firs t Se t o f Discovery to Responden t

to ; JN L Marbl e & Granite , ATTN : Joe l Huerta . 642 9 Southfron t Road , Uni t

D, Livermore , C A 9455 1 vi aUniie dState s Mail , postag e prepaid . 3 . T o date , I hav e no t receive dth e Complainant' s Firs t Se t o f Discovery to Responden t bac k a s returne dmail . I declar e unde r

penalt y o f

perjur y unde r th e law s o f

th e Unite dState s o f

Americ atha t

th e foregoin g i s tru e an dcorrect . Signe dthi s 13" " day o f

August , 201 008/19/201 0 15:3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FAA ^ DM S 0005/01 0

UNITE D STATE S O F AMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

**M*««i'm«»*«itm*»«A*****«**tit f **»***» « * I n th e Matte ro f JN L MARBL E & * FA A Docke t No. : CP10WP000 7 GRANITE , INC . *

Respondent . * FA A Region : Western-Pacifi c Judge : Honorabl e Richar d C . Goodwi n DM S No . FAA-2010-054 1 * * COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T SE T O F DISCOVER Y T O RESPONDEN T To : Responden t

actin g in/»ro/?er : Complainant , b y an dthroug h counsel , pursuan t t o Sectio n 13,22 0 o f

th e Rule s o f Practic e i n FA A Civi l Penalt y Actions , request s th e Responden t pleas e respon dt o th e followin g Discovery Request s separatel y an dfiilly unde r oath , withi n thirty (30 ) day s o f th e dat e o f

service . Thes e discovery request s ar c intende dt o b e continuin g i n natur e an d any informatio n whic h may b e discovere db y yo u subsequen t to th e servic e an dfilin g o f you r answer s mus t

b e brough t

t o th e attentio n o f

th e Complainant' s attorne y throug h supplemental answer s whe n i t become s availabl e t o you , an di n areasonabl e tim e prio r t o th e hearin g i n thi s matter . I f ther e are any additions , deletion s o r change s i n th e answer s o r informatio n provide dat an y tim e prio r

t o hearing , th e Responden t i s specificall y requeste dto s o immediatel y infor mComplainant' s attorney . I f suc h informatio n i s notOS/13/201 0 15:3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A - DM S iOOG/01 0

furnished , a

t th e tim e o f

th e hearing , th e attorne y fo r Complainan t

may mov e t o exclud e fromevidenc e suc h informatio n requeste dan dno t fiimished . If , i n respondin g to , o r

failin g t o respon dt o thes e request s fo r discovery yox

i invok e o r rel y upo n an

y privileg e o f

an y kind , stat e specificall y th e natur e o f th e privilege , th e basi s upo n whic h yo u invoke , rel y upo n or clai mit , includin g an

y statutor y o r decisiona l reference , an didentif y al l document s o r

othe r information , includin g contact s an dcommunication s whic h yo u believ e t o b e embrace db y th e privileg e invoked . INTERROGATORIES ; 1 . Identif

y b y name , addres s an dtelephon e numbe r al l person s wh o hav e persona l knowledg e o f

th e incident s allege di n th e complain t an dyou r

affirmativ e defense s allege di n you r

answer . 2 . Identif

y b y title , date , author , presen t custodian , andcontent , al l document s obtaine db y yo u o r i n you r possessio n relatin g t o th e assertion s i n th e complain t andyou r answer , includin g all affinnativ e defenses . 3 . Identif

y b y name , addres s an dtelephon e number , al l person s who myo u inten dt o hav e testif

y a s afactua

l witnes s i n you r

defens e at

th e hearing i n thi s matter , an d provid e adetaile dsummar y o f eac h person' s anticipate dtestimony . 4 . Identif

y b y name , addres s an dtelephon e number , al l person s who myo u inten dt o hav e testif

y a s a n exper t witnes s i n you r

defens e at

th e hearin g i n thi s matter , an dprovid e adetaile dsununary o f eac h expert' s anticipate dtestimony . 5 . Identif

y b y title , date , author , presen t custodian , andcontent , whic h document s yo u anticipat e offerin g int o evidenc e a t th e hearin g i n thi s matter , an dthroug h whic h witnes s o r

witnesses . 6 . Wit h respec t to eac h exper

t witnes s identifie di n respons e t o Interrogator y No . 4 , above , specif

y thei r are ao f expertise , i f

any , an dprovid e asynopsi s o f thei r credentials , background , trainin g an dexperience .08/19/201 0 15:3 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A ^ DM S @007/01 0

7 . If you r response s t o an

y o f th e belo w Request s for

Admission s ar e anythin g other tha n a n unqualifie d"admit, " provid e al l fact s t o suppor t you r denials . REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTIO N O F DOCUMENTS : 1 . Provid e acop y o f al l writte n statements/affidavits/declaration s o f individual s identifie di n respons e t o interrogatory numbe r 1 , o n th e previou s page . 2 . Provid e acop y o f all document s identifie di n interrogatory numbe r 2 , on th e previou s page . 3 . Provid e acop y o f al l document s i n suppor t o f any an dal l o f

you r affinnativ e defense s ple di n you r answer . 4 . Provid e acop y o f th e curren t

curriculu mvita e for

eac h an devery expert you inten dt o hav e testif

y in you r defens e a t th e hearing i n thi s matter , 5 . Provid e acop y o f any an dal l recorde dstatement s o f an y witnesse s havin g persona l knowledg e o f

th e incident s allege di n th e complain t an dyou r

affirmativ e defense s allege di n you r answe r includin g bu t

no t limite dt o tap e recording s an d transcription s o f

th e tap e recordings

6 . Provid e an y an da U document s you r

expert s wil l b e relyin g upo n t o testif y i n you r defens e at

th e hearin g o n thi s matter . 7 . I f any o f you r response s t o th e belo w liste dRequest s fo r Admission s ar e anythin g othe r

tha n a n unequivocal "admit, " pleas e provid e acop y o f al l document s t o suppor t you r responses . 8 . Provid e acop y o f

an y andal l reports , notes , charts , diagrams , flight plot s o r othe r writte n documentatio n prepare db y you r expert(s ) whic h wil l b e testifyin g i n you r defens e a t th e hearin g o n thi s matter .c i i ^ DM S 21008/01 0 08/19/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 202493514 2 !•« «

REQUES T FO RADMISSIONS : 1 . Admi t

tha t o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , yo u were atickete dpassenge r o n Northwes t

Airline s Flight

2 2 fromHonolulu , Hawai i t o Sa n Francisco , California . 2 . Admi t

tha t o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , yo u knowingl y offere dchecke d baggag e o n th e fligh

t mentione din Interrogatory 1 . 3 . Admi t

tha t o n or abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , you r

checke dbaggag e fo

r th e flight mentione di n Interrogator y I containe don e quar

t acetone . 4 . Admi t

that o n o r abou t Jun e 11 , 2008 , you r

checke dbaggag e for

th e fligh t mentione di n hiterrogatory 1 containe dtw o 3 0 gramtube s o f hardene r paste . Respectfull y submitted , Naom i Tsud a Regiona l Counse l

By :

Dated: l Ju)^8.201 008/19/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 202493514 2 FA A • > DM S g|009/01 0

CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E I hereb y certif

y tha t o n thi s dat e I hav e place di n th e Unite dState s mail , postag e prepaid , th e execute dorigina l o f th e COMPLAINANT' S FIRS T DISCOl/ER Y REQUES T T O RESPONDENT , addresse da s follows : JN L Marbl e & Granite Atm : Joe l Huert a 642 9 Southfront

Road , Uni t

D Livermore , CA 9455 1

Dated : J<^

L « « 20^ ^

Jef f Kamberg ^ Lega l Technicia n Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counsel t Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Western-Pacifi c Regio n Hawthorne , Cahfomi a08/19/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 202493514 2 FA A ^ DMS 0010/01 0

CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E I hereb y certif

y tha i o n thi s dat e 1 hav e faxe dan dplace din th e Unite dState s mail , po.stag e prepaid , th e execute doriginal o f th e MOTIO N T O COMPE L DISCOVER Y RESPONSE S AN D MOTIO N T O DEE M A S AN ADMISSIO N O F TRUT H EAC H STATEMEN T I N COMPLAINANT' S REQUEST S FO RADMISSION , addresse da s follows : Th e Honorabl e RichardC . Goodwi n Administrativ e Law Judg e Offic e o f Hearings , M-2 0 U.S . Departmen t

o f Transportatio n 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S.E . Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , Roo mE12-32 0 Washingto n D C 2059 0 Facsimile : (202)366-753 6 Federal Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Washingto n D C 205 9 J Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Building

- Suite 2W100 0 Facsimile : (202 ) 493-514 2 I further certifie dthat

o n thi s dat e I hav e place di n th e Unite dState s mail , postag e prepaid , certifie dmail , retur n receip t requested , acop y o f

th e abov e addresse dto : JN L Marbl e an dGranite , Inc. , ATTN : Joe l Huert a 642 9 Southfront

Road , Uni t

D Livermor e C A 9455 1 

### D,,,^ ^ AU

G1 3 201 0 JeffKambCTg Legal Technicia n Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse l Federal Aviatio n Administratio n Westem-Pacifi c Regio n Hawthorne , Californi a