ECONOMIC ANALYSIS SUMMARY

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Boiler Design: Babcock & Wilcox Gas/Oil

LNB LNB w/ FGR LNB w/SNCR RO

w/Ro

Case 1 2 3 4 5 NOx Emission Control System None LNB LNB w/ FGR LNB w/SNCR ROFA w

TOTAL INSTALLED CAPITAL COST ($) 0 600,000 920,000 2,523,750 5,250Including Other Owner Costs ($) 0 1,050,000 1,610,000 4,416,563 9,189FIRST YEAR O&M COST ($)

Operating Labor ($) 0 11,300 16,950 22,600 22,Maintenance Material ($) 0 22,600 33,900 45,200 45,Maintenance Labor ($) 0 11,300 16,950 22,600 22,Administrative Labor ($) 0 0 0 0 TOTAL FIXED O&M COST 0 45,200 67,800 90,400 90,Reagent Cost 0 0 0 278,097 296SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost 0 0 0 0 Electric Power Cost 0 0 252,419 25,242 277Makeup Water Cost 0 0 0 0 TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST 0 0 252,419 303,339 574TOTAL FIRST YEAR O&M COST 0 45,200 320,219 393,739 664

FIRST YEAR DEBT SERVICE ($) 0 111,359 170,750 468,403 974TOTAL FIRST YEAR COST ($) 0 156,559 490,970 862,142 1,639

Power Consumption (MW) 0.0 0.0 1.1 0.1 1Annual Power Usage (Million kW-Hr/Yr) 0.0 0.0 5.0 0.5 5

CONTROL COST ($/Ton Removed)

NOx Removal Rate (%) 0.0% 45.4% 53.2% 59.1% 63NOx Removed (Tons/Yr) 0 642 752 834 89First Year Average Control Cost ($/Ton NOx Rem.) 0 244 653 1,033 1,8Incremental Control Cost ($/Ton NOx Removed) 0 244 3,036 4,493 14,

2-1 3-2 4-3 5

For the other owner costs a factor of 1.75 was used for everything except the SCR to represent balance of plant cost, electrical costs, AFUDC etc.For the SCR a factor of 1.25 was used because the material cost of $250/kW from the CH2M HILL database already included the balance of plant and a few other costs

Parameter Current Operation NOx Control

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 1 of 5 
INPUT CALCULATIONS 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Boiler Design: Babcock & Wilcox Gas/Oil

LNB LNB w/ FGR LNB w/SNCR ROFA 

w/Rotamix LNB w/SCR

Case 1 2 3 4 5 6

NOx Emission Control System None LNB LNB w/ FGR LNB w/SNCR ROFA w/Rotamix LNB w/SCR

Unit Design and Coal Characteristics

Type of Unit PC PC PC PC PC PC

Net Power Output (kW) 113,000 113,000 113,000 113,000 113,000 113,000

Net Plant Heat Rate (Btu/kW-Hr) 10,910 10,910 10,910 10,910 10,910 10,910

Boiler Fuel No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil

Fuel Heating Value (Btu/Lb) 19,300 19,300 19,300 19,300 19,300 19,300

Fuel Sulfur Content (wt.%) 0.637% 0.637% 0.637% 0.637% 0.637% 0.637%

Fuel Ash Content (wt.%) 0.038% 0.038% 0.038% 0.038% 0.038% 0.038%

Boiler Heat Input, each (MMBtu/Hr) 1,233 1,233 1,233 1,233 1,233 1,233

Fuel Flow Rate (Lb/Hr) 63,877 63,877 63,877 63,877 63,877 63,877

 (Ton/Yr) 142,689 142,689 142,689 142,689 142,689 142,689

 (MMBtu/Yr) 5,507,791 5,507,791 5,507,791 5,507,791 5,507,791 5,507,791

Emissions

Uncontrolled NOx (Lb/Hr) 632 632 632 632 632 632

 (Lb/MMBtu) 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51

 (Lb Moles/Hr) 21.07 21.07 21.07 21.07 21.07 21.07

 (Tons/Yr) 1,413 1,413 1,413 1,413 1,413 1,413

NOx Removal Rate (%) 0.0% 45.4% 53.2% 59.1% 63.0% 86.4%

 (Lb/Hr) 0 287 337 374 398 546

 (Lb Moles/Hr) 0.00 9.57 11.22 12.45 13.27 18.20

 (Ton/Yr) 0 642 752 834 890 1,220

NOx Emission Rate (Lb/Hr) 632 345 296 259 234 86

 (Lb/MMBtu) 0.51 0.28 0.24 0.21 0.19 0.07

 (Ton/Yr) 1,413 771 661 578 523 193

General Plant Data

Annual Operation (Hours/Year) 4,468 4,468 4,468 4,468 4,468 4,468

Annual On-Site Power Plant Capacity Factor 51% 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51 0.51

Economic Factors

Interest Rate (%) 8.55% 8.55% 8.55% 8.55% 8.55% 8.55%

Discount Rate (%) 9.00% 9.00% 9.00% 9.00% 9.00% 9.00%

Plant Economic Life (Years) 20 20 20 20 20 20

Installed Capital Costs (including owner costs)

NOx Emission Control System ($2007) 0 1,050,000 1,610,000 4,416,563 9,189,145 35,781,250

Total Emission Control Systems ($2007) 0 1,050,000 1,610,000 4,416,563 9,189,145 35,781,250

NOx Emission Control System ($/kW) 0 9 14 39 81 317

Total Emission Control Systems ($/kW) 0 9 14 39 81 317

Total Fixed Operating & Maintenance Costs

Operating Labor ($) 0 11,300 16,950 22,600 22,600 28,250

Maintenance Material ($) 0 22,600 33,900 45,200 45,200 56,500

Maintenance Labor ($) 0 11,300 16,950 22,600 22,600 28,250

Administrative Labor ($) 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total Fixed O&M Cost ($) 0 45,200 67,800 90,400 90,400 113,000

Annual Fixed O&M Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00%

Reagent Cost None None None Urea Urea Anhydrous NH3

Unit Cost ($/Ton) 0.00 0.00 370.00 370.00 370.00 400.00

 ($/Lb) 0.000 0.000 0.185 0.185 0.185 0.200

Molar Stoichiometry 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.45 0.45 1.00

Reagent Purity (Wt.%) 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Reagent Usage (Lb/Hr) 0 0 0 336 359 310

First Year Reagent Cost ($) 0 0 0 278,097 296,453 276,989

Annual Reagent Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00%

SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Replacement Cost SCR Catalyst

Annual SCR Catalyst (m3) / No. FF Bags 0 0 0 0 0 57

SCR Catalyst ($/m3) / Bag Cost ($/ea.) 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000

First Year SCR Catalyst / Bag Replace. Cost ($) 0 0 0 0 0 169,500

Annual SCR Catalyst / Bag Cost Esc. Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00%

Auxiliary Power Cost

Auxiliary Power Requirement (% of Plant Output) 0.00% 0.00% 1.00% 0.10% 1.10% 0.50%

 (MW) 0.00 0.00 1.13 0.11 1.24 0.57

Unit Cost ($2007/MW-Hr) 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00

First Year Auxiliary Power Cost ($) 0 0 252,419 25,242 277,661 126,210

Annual Power Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00% 2.00%

Economic factors as per Sierra Pacific 2008 Planning Guidelines

Parameter Comments Current 

Operation

NOx Control

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 2 of 5 10/2/2008 7:39 AM
Interest Rate

Plant Life

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Current Operation

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 - - - - - - - 

 

2 2015 - - - - - - - 

 

3 2016 - - - - - - - 

 

4 2017 - - - - - - - 

 

5 2018 - - - - - - - 

 

6 2019 - - - - - - - 

 

7 2020 - - - - - - - 

 

8 2021 - - - - - - - 

 

9 2022 - - - - - - - 

 

10 2023 - - - - - - - 

 

11 2024 - - - - - - - 

 

12 2025 - - - - - - - 

 

13 2026 - - - - - - - 

 

14 2027 - - - - - - - 

 

15 2028 - - - - - - - 

 

16 2029 - - - - - - - 

 

17 2030 - - - - - - - 

 

18 2031 - - - - - - - 

 

19 2032 - - - - - - - 

 

20 2033 - - - - - - - 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 LNB

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 45,200 - - - - - 111,359 

 

2 2015 46,104 - - - - - 111,359 

 

3 2016 47,026 - - - - - 111,359 

 

4 2017 47,967 - - - - - 111,359 

 

5 2018 48,926 - - - - - 111,359 

 

6 2019 49,904 - - - - - 111,359 

 

7 2020 50,903 - - - - - 111,359 

 

8 2021 51,921 - - - - - 111,359 

 

9 2022 52,959 - - - - - 111,359 

 

10 2023 54,018 - - - - - 111,359 

 

11 2024 55,099 - - - - - 111,359 

 

12 2025 56,201 - - - - - 111,359 

 

13 2026 57,325 - - - - - 111,359 

 

14 2027 58,471 - - - - - 111,359 

 

15 2028 59,640 - - - - - 111,359 

 

16 2029 60,833 - - - - - 111,359 

 

17 2030 62,050 - - - - - 111,359 

 

18 2031 63,291 - - - - - 111,359 

 

19 2032 64,557 - - - - - 111,359 

 

20 2033 65,848 - - - - - 111,359 

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 3 of 5 
Fort Churchill Unit 2 LNB w/ FGR

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 67,800 - - 252,419 - 252,419 170,750 

 

2 2015 69,156 - - 257,468 - 257,468 170,750 

 

3 2016 70,539 - - 262,617 - 262,617 170,750 

 

4 2017 71,950 - - 267,869 - 267,869 170,750 

 

5 2018 73,389 - - 273,227 - 273,227 170,750 

 

6 2019 74,857 - - 278,691 - 278,691 170,750 

 

7 2020 76,354 - - 284,265 - 284,265 170,750 

 

8 2021 77,881 - - 289,951 - 289,951 170,750 

 

9 2022 79,439 - - 295,750 - 295,750 170,750 

 

10 2023 81,027 - - 301,665 - 301,665 170,750 

 

11 2024 82,648 - - 307,698 - 307,698 170,750 

 

12 2025 84,301 - - 313,852 - 313,852 170,750 

 

13 2026 85,987 - - 320,129 - 320,129 170,750 

 

14 2027 87,707 - - 326,531 - 326,531 170,750 

 

15 2028 89,461 - - 333,062 - 333,062 170,750 

 

16 2029 91,250 - - 339,723 - 339,723 170,750 

 

17 2030 93,075 - - 346,518 - 346,518 170,750 

 

18 2031 94,936 - - 353,448 - 353,448 170,750 

 

19 2032 96,835 - - 360,517 - 360,517 170,750 

 

20 2033 98,772 - - 367,727 - 367,727 170,750 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 LNB w/SNCR

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 90,400 278,097 - 25,242 - 303,339 468,403 

 

2 2015 92,208 283,659 - 25,747 - 309,406 468,403 

 

3 2016 94,052 289,332 - 26,262 - 315,594 468,403 

 

4 2017 95,933 295,119 - 26,787 - 321,905 468,403 

 

5 2018 97,852 301,021 - 27,323 - 328,344 468,403 

 

6 2019 99,809 307,041 - 27,869 - 334,910 468,403 

 

7 2020 101,805 313,182 - 28,427 - 341,609 468,403 

 

8 2021 103,841 319,446 - 28,995 - 348,441 468,403 

 

9 2022 105,918 325,835 - 29,575 - 355,410 468,403 

 

10 2023 108,036 332,351 - 30,166 - 362,518 468,403 

 

11 2024 110,197 338,998 - 30,770 - 369,768 468,403 

 

12 2025 112,401 345,778 - 31,385 - 377,164 468,403 

 

13 2026 114,649 352,694 - 32,013 - 384,707 468,403 

 

14 2027 116,942 359,748 - 32,653 - 392,401 468,403 

 

15 2028 119,281 366,943 - 33,306 - 400,249 468,403 

 

16 2029 121,666 374,282 - 33,972 - 408,254 468,403 

 

17 2030 124,100 381,767 - 34,652 - 416,419 468,403 1

 

18 2031 126,582 389,403 - 35,345 - 424,747 468,403 1

 

19 2032 129,113 397,191 - 36,052 - 433,242 468,403 1

 

20 2033 131,696 405,135 - 36,773 - 441,907 468,403 1

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 4 of 5 
Fort Churchill Unit 2 ROFA w/Rotamix

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 90,400 296,453 - 277,661 - 574,114 974,564 1

 

2 2015 92,208 302,382 - 283,215 - 585,597 974,564 1

 

3 2016 94,052 308,430 - 288,879 - 597,309 974,564 1

 

4 2017 95,933 314,598 - 294,656 - 609,255 974,564 1

 

5 2018 97,852 320,890 - 300,550 - 621,440 974,564 1

 

6 2019 99,809 327,308 - 306,561 - 633,869 974,564 1

 

7 2020 101,805 333,854 - 312,692 - 646,546 974,564 1

 

8 2021 103,841 340,531 - 318,946 - 659,477 974,564 1

 

9 2022 105,918 347,342 - 325,325 - 672,666 974,564 1

 

10 2023 108,036 354,289 - 331,831 - 686,120 974,564 1

 

11 2024 110,197 361,375 - 338,468 - 699,842 974,564 1

 

12 2025 112,401 368,602 - 345,237 - 713,839 974,564 1

 

13 2026 114,649 375,974 - 352,142 - 728,116 974,564 1

 

14 2027 116,942 383,494 - 359,185 - 742,678 974,564 1

 

15 2028 119,281 391,163 - 366,368 - 757,532 974,564 1

 

16 2029 121,666 398,987 - 373,696 - 772,682 974,564 1

 

17 2030 124,100 406,966 - 381,170 - 788,136 974,564 1

 

18 2031 126,582 415,106 - 388,793 - 803,899 974,564 1

 

19 2032 129,113 423,408 - 396,569 - 819,977 974,564 1

 

20 2033 131,696 431,876 - 404,500 - 836,376 974,564 1

Fort Churchill Unit 2 LNB w/SCR

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 113,000 276,989 169,500 126,210 - 572,698 3,794,816 4

 

2 2015 115,260 282,528 172,890 128,734 - 584,152 3,794,816 4

 

3 2016 117,565 288,179 176,348 131,309 - 595,835 3,794,816 4

 

4 2017 119,917 293,942 179,875 133,935 - 607,752 3,794,816 4

 

5 2018 122,315 299,821 183,472 136,613 - 619,907 3,794,816 4

 

6 2019 124,761 305,818 187,142 139,346 - 632,305 3,794,816 4

 

7 2020 127,256 311,934 190,885 142,133 - 644,951 3,794,816 4

 

8 2021 129,801 318,173 194,702 144,975 - 657,850 3,794,816 4

 

9 2022 132,398 324,536 198,596 147,875 - 671,007 3,794,816 4

 

10 2023 135,045 331,027 202,568 150,832 - 684,427 3,794,816 4

 

11 2024 137,746 337,648 206,620 153,849 - 698,116 3,794,816 4

 

12 2025 140,501 344,400 210,752 156,926 - 712,078 3,794,816 4

 

13 2026 143,311 351,288 214,967 160,064 - 726,320 3,794,816 4

 

14 2027 146,178 358,314 219,266 163,266 - 740,846 3,794,816 4

 

15 2028 149,101 365,481 223,652 166,531 - 755,663 3,794,816 4

 

16 2029 152,083 372,790 228,125 169,862 - 770,776 3,794,816 4

 

17 2030 155,125 380,246 232,687 173,259 - 786,192 3,794,816 4

 

18 2031 158,227 387,851 237,341 176,724 - 801,916 3,794,816 4

 

19 2032 161,392 395,608 242,088 180,259 - 817,954 3,794,816 4

 

20 2033 164,620 403,520 246,929 183,864 - 834,313 3,794,816 4

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 5 of 5 
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS SUMMARY

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Boiler Design:

SO2 Control

SDA

Case 1 7SO2 Emission Control System None SDA

TOTAL INSTALLED CAPITAL COST ($) 0 22,000,000Including Other Owner Costs ($) 0 ---FIRST YEAR O&M COST ($)

Operating Labor ($) 0 56,500Maintenance Material ($) 0 113,000Maintenance Labor ($) 0 56,500Administrative Labor ($) 0 0TOTAL FIXED O&M COST

0 226,000

Reagent Cost 0 177,197SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost 0 0Electric Power Cost 0 89,352Makeup Water Cost 0 25,112TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST

0 291,662

TOTAL FIRST YEAR O&M COST 0 517,662

FIRST YEAR DEBT SERVICE ($) 0 2,333,232TOTAL FIRST YEAR COST ($) 0 2,850,894

Power Consumption (MW) 0.0 0.4

Annual Power Usage (Million kW-Hr/Yr) 0.0 1.8

CONTROL COST ($/Ton Removed)

SO2 Removal Rate (%) 23.5% 84.8%SO2 Removed (Tons/Yr)

0 1,540

First Year Average Control Cost ($/Ton SO2 Rem.)

0 1,852

Incremental Control Cost ($/Ton SO2 Removed) Base 1,852

7-1

Parameter Current Operation

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 1 of 3 
INPUT CALCULATIONS 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Boiler Design:

SO2 Control

SDA

Case 1 7

SO2 Emission Control System None SDA

Unit Design and Coal Characteristics

Type of Unit PC PC

Net Power Output (kW) 113,000 113,000

Net Plant Heat Rate (Btu/kW-Hr) 10,910 10,910

Boiler Fuel No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil

Fuel Heating Value (Btu/Lb) 19,300 19,300

Fuel Sulfur Content (wt.%) 0.637% 0.637%

Fuel Ash Content (wt.%) 0.038% 0.038%

Boiler Heat Input, each (MMBtu/Hr) 1,233 1,233

Fuel Flow Rate (Lb/Hr) 63,877 63,877

 (Ton/Yr) 142,689 142,689

 (MMBtu/Yr) 5,507,791 5,507,791

Emissions

Uncontrolled SO2 (Lb/Hr) 813 813

 (Lb/MMBtu) 0.659 0.659

 (Lb Moles/Hr) 12.68 12.68

 (Tons/Yr) 1,815 1,815

SO2 Removal Rate (%) 23.5% 84.8%

 (Lb/Hr) 191 689

 (Ton/Yr) 427 1,540

SO2 Emission Rate (Lb/Hr) 621 123

 (Lb/MMBtu) 0.504 0.10

 (Ton/Yr) 1,388 275

General Plant Data

Annual Operation (Hours/Year) 4,468 4,468

Annual On-Site Power Plant Capacity Factor 51% 0.51

Economic Factors

Interest Rate (%) 8.55% 8.55%

Discount Rate (%) 9.00% 9.00%

Plant Economic Life (Years) 20 20

Installed Capital Costs (including owner costs)

SO2 Emission Control System ($2007) 0 22,000,000

Total Emission Control Systems ($2007) 0 22,000,000

SO2 Emission Control System ($/kW) 0 195

Total Emission Control Systems ($/kW) 0 195

Total Fixed Operating & Maintenance Costs

Operating Labor ($) 0 56,500

Maintenance Material ($) 0 113,000

Maintenance Labor ($) 0 56,500

Administrative Labor ($) 0 0

Total Fixed O&M Cost ($) 0 226,000

Annual Fixed O&M Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Reagent Cost None LIme

Unit Cost ($/Ton) 0.00 91.25

 ($/Lb) 0.000 0.046

Molar Stoichiometry 0.00 1.10

Reagent Purity (Wt.%) 100% 90%

Reagent Usage (Lb/Hr) 0 869

First Year Reagent Cost ($) 0 177,197

Annual Reagent Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Replacement Cost

Annual SCR Catalyst (m3) / No. FF Bags 0 0

SCR Catalyst ($/m3) / Bag Cost ($/ea.) 3,000 3,000

First Year SCR Catalyst / Bag Replace. Cost ($) 0 0

Annual SCR Catalyst / Bag Cost Esc. Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Auxiliary Power Cost

Auxiliary Power Requirement (% of Plant Output) 0.00% 0.35%

 (MW) 0.00 0.40

Unit Cost ($2007/MW-Hr) 50.00 50.00

First Year Auxiliary Power Cost ($) 0 89,352

Annual Power Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Water Cost

Makeup Water Usage (Gpm) 0 77

Unit Price ($/1000 Gallons) 1.22 1.22

First Year Water Cost ($) 0 25,112

Annual Water Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Economic factors as per Sierra Pacific 2008 Planning Guidelines

Parameter Current 

Operation

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 2 of 3 10/2/2008 8:08 AM
Interest Rate

Plant Life

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Current Operation

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL A

COS

0 20131 2014 - - - - - - - 

 

2 2015 - - - - - - - 

 

3 2016 - - - - - - - 

 

4 2017 - - - - - - - 

 

5 2018 - - - - - - - 

 

6 2019 - - - - - - - 

 

7 2020 - - - - - - - 

 

8 2021 - - - - - - - 

 

9 2022 - - - - - - - 

 

10 2023 - - - - - - - 

 

11 2024 - - - - - - - 

 

12 2025 - - - - - - - 

 

13 2026 - - - - - - - 

 

14 2027 - - - - - - - 

 

15 2028 - - - - - - - 

 

16 2029 - - - - - - - 

 

17 2030 - - - - - - - 

 

18 2031 - - - - - - - 

 

19 2032 - - - - - - - 

 

20 2033 - - - - - - - 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 SDA

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL A

COS

0 20131 2014 226,000 177,197 - 89,352 25,112 291,662 2,333,232 2,8

 

2 2015 230,520 180,741 - 91,139 25,614 297,495 2,333,232 2,8

 

3 2016 235,130 184,356 - 92,962 26,127 303,445 2,333,232 2,8

 

4 2017 239,833 188,043 - 94,821 26,649 309,514 2,333,232 2,8

 

5 2018 244,630 191,804 - 96,717 27,182 315,704 2,333,232 2,8

 

6 2019 249,522 195,640 - 98,652 27,726 322,018 2,333,232 2,9

 

7 2020 254,513 199,553 - 100,625 28,280 328,458 2,333,232 2,9

 

8 2021 259,603 203,544 - 102,637 28,846 335,027 2,333,232 2,9

 

9 2022 264,795 207,615 - 104,690 29,423 341,728 2,333,232 2,9

 

10 2023 270,091 211,767 - 106,784 30,011 348,563 2,333,232 2,9

 

11 2024 275,493 216,003 - 108,920 30,612 355,534 2,333,232 2,9

 

12 2025 281,003 220,323 - 111,098 31,224 362,644 2,333,232 2,9

 

13 2026 286,623 224,729 - 113,320 31,848 369,897 2,333,232 2,9

 

14 2027 292,355 229,224 - 115,586 32,485 377,295 2,333,232 3,0

 

15 2028 298,202 233,808 - 117,898 33,135 384,841 2,333,232 3,0

 

16 2029 304,166 238,484 - 120,256 33,798 392,538 2,333,232 3,0

 

17 2030 310,250 243,254 - 122,661 34,474 400,389 2,333,232 3,0

 

18 2031 316,455 248,119 - 125,114 35,163 408,397 2,333,232 3,0

 

19 2032 322,784 253,082 - 127,617 35,866 416,564 2,333,232 3,0

 

20 2033 329,239 258,143 - 130,169 36,584 424,896 2,333,232 3,0

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 3 of 3 
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS SUMMARY

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Boiler Design:

PM Control

Fabric Filter

Case 1 8

PM Emission Control System None Fabric Filter

TOTAL INSTALLED CAPITAL COST ($) 0 22,000,000Including Other Owner Costs ($) 0 ---FIRST YEAR O&M COST ($)

Operating Labor ($) 0 45,200Maintenance Material ($) 0 90,400Maintenance Labor ($) 0 45,200Administrative Labor ($) 0 0TOTAL FIXED O&M COST

0 180,800

Reagent Cost 0 0SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost 0 62,400Electric Power Cost 0 89,352Makeup Water Cost 0 0TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST

0 151,752

TOTAL FIRST YEAR O&M COST 0 332,552

FIRST YEAR DEBT SERVICE ($) 0 2,333,232TOTAL FIRST YEAR COST ($) 0 2,665,784

Power Consumption (MW) 0.0 0.4

Annual Power Usage (Million kW-Hr/Yr) 0.0 1.8

CONTROL COST ($/Ton Removed)

PM Removal Rate (%) 0.00% 52.98%PM Removed (Tons/Yr)

0 47

First Year Average Control Cost ($/Ton PM Rem.)

0 57,278

Incremental Control Cost ($/Ton PM Removed) Base 57,278

8-1

Parameter Current Operation

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 1 of 4 
INPUT CALCULATIONS 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Boiler Design:

PM Control

Fabric Filter

Case 1 8

PM Emission Control System None Fabric Filter

Unit Design and Coal Characteristics

Type of Unit PC PC

Net Power Output (kW) 113,000 113,000

Net Plant Heat Rate (Btu/kW-Hr) 10,910 10,910

Boiler Fuel No. 6 Fuel Oil No. 6 Fuel Oil

Fuel Heating Value (Btu/Lb) 19,300 19,300

Fuel Sulfur Content (wt.%) 0.637% 0.637%

Fuel Ash Content (wt.%) 0.038% 0.038%

Boiler Heat Input, each (MMBtu/Hr) 1,233 1,233

Fuel Flow Rate (Lb/Hr) 63,877 63,877

 (Ton/Yr) 142,689 142,689

 (MMBtu/Yr) 5,507,791 5,507,791

Emissions

Uncontrolled Fly Ash (Lb/Hr) 31 39

 (Lb/MMBtu) 0.03 0.032

 (Lb Moles/Hr) 1.0 1.3

 (Tons/Yr) 70 88

Fly Ash Removal Rate (%) 0.00% 52.98%

 (Lb/Hr) -8 21

 (Ton/Yr) -18 47

Fly Ash Emission Rate (Lb/Hr) 39 18

 (Lb/MMBtu) 0.032 0.015

 (Ton/Yr) 88 41

General Plant Data

Annual Operation (Hours/Year) 4,468 4,468

Annual On-Site Power Plant Capacity Factor 51% 0.51

Economic Factors

Interest Rate (%) 8.55% 8.55%

Discount Rate (%) 9.00% 9.00%

Plant Economic Life (Years) 20 20

Installed Capital Costs (including owner costs)

NOx Emission Control System ($2007) 0 0

SO2 Emission Control System ($2007) 0 0

PM Emission Control System ($2007) 0 22,000,000

Total Emission Control Systems ($2007) 0 22,000,000

NOx Emission Control System ($/kW) 0 0

SO2 Emission Control System ($/kW) 0 0

PM Emission Control System ($/kW) 0 195

Total Emission Control Systems ($/kW) 0 195

Total Fixed Operating & Maintenance Costs

Operating Labor ($) 0 45,200

Maintenance Material ($) 0 90,400

Maintenance Labor ($) 0 45,200

Administrative Labor ($) 0 0

Total Fixed O&M Cost ($) 0 180,800

Annual Fixed O&M Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Reagent Cost None None

Unit Cost ($/Ton) 0.00 0.00

 ($/Lb) 0.000 0.000

Molar Stoichiometry 0.00 0.00

Reagent Purity (Wt.%) 100% 100%

Reagent Usage (Lb/Hr) 0 0

First Year Reagent Cost ($) 0 0

Annual Reagent Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Replacement Cost Bags

Annual SCR Catalyst (m3) / No. FF Bags 0 600

SCR Catalyst ($/m3) / Bag Cost ($/ea.) 3,000 104

First Year SCR Catalyst / Bag Replace. Cost ($) 0 62,400

Annual SCR Catalyst / Bag Cost Esc. Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Auxiliary Power Cost

Auxiliary Power Requirement (% of Plant Output) 0.00% 0.35%

 (MW) 0.00 0.40

Unit Cost ($2007/MW-Hr) 50.00 50.00

First Year Auxiliary Power Cost ($) 0 89,352

Annual Power Cost Escalation Rate (%) 2.00% 2.00%

Economic factors as per Sierra Pacific 2008 Planning Guidelines

Parameter Current 

Operation

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 2 of 4 10/2/2008 8:04 AM
Interest Rate

Plant Life

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Current Operation

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 - - - - - - - 

 

2 2015 - - - - - - - 

 

3 2016 - - - - - - - 

 

4 2017 - - - - - - - 

 

5 2018 - - - - - - - 

 

6 2019 - - - - - - - 

 

7 2020 - - - - - - - 

 

8 2021 - - - - - - - 

 

9 2022 - - - - - - - 

 

10 2023 - - - - - - - 

 

11 2024 - - - - - - - 

 

12 2025 - - - - - - - 

 

13 2026 - - - - - - - 

 

14 2027 - - - - - - - 

 

15 2028 - - - - - - - 

 

16 2029 - - - - - - - 

 

17 2030 - - - - - - - 

 

18 2031 - - - - - - - 

 

19 2032 - - - - - - - 

 

20 2033 - - - - - - - 

Fort Churchill Unit 2 Fabric Filter

Year Date TOTAL FIXED O&M COST Reagent Cost SCR Catalyst / FF Bag Cost Electric Power Cost Makeup Water Cost TOTAL VARIABLE O&M COST DEBT SERVICE TOTAL 

CO

0 20131 2014 180,800 - 62,400 89,352 - 151,752 2,333,232 2

 

2 2015 184,416 - 63,648 91,139 - 154,787 2,333,232 2

 

3 2016 188,104 - 64,921 92,962 - 157,883 2,333,232 2

 

4 2017 191,866 - 66,219 94,821 - 161,040 2,333,232 2

 

5 2018 195,704 - 67,544 96,717 - 164,261 2,333,232 2

 

6 2019 199,618 - 68,895 98,652 - 167,546 2,333,232 2

 

7 2020 203,610 - 70,273 100,625 - 170,897 2,333,232 2

 

8 2021 207,682 - 71,678 102,637 - 174,315 2,333,232 2

 

9 2022 211,836 - 73,112 104,690 - 177,802 2,333,232 2

 

10 2023 216,073 - 74,574 106,784 - 181,358 2,333,232 2

 

11 2024 220,394 - 76,065 108,920 - 184,985 2,333,232 2

 

12 2025 224,802 - 77,587 111,098 - 188,685 2,333,232 2

 

13 2026 229,298 - 79,138 113,320 - 192,458 2,333,232 2

 

14 2027 233,884 - 80,721 115,586 - 196,307 2,333,232 2

 

15 2028 238,562 - 82,335 117,898 - 200,234 2,333,232 2

 

16 2029 243,333 - 83,982 120,256 - 204,238 2,333,232 2

 

17 2030 248,200 - 85,662 122,661 - 208,323 2,333,232 2

 

18 2031 253,164 - 87,375 125,114 - 212,489 2,333,232 2

 

19 2032 258,227 - 89,123 127,617 - 216,739 2,333,232 2

 

20 2033 263,391 - 90,905 130,169 - 221,074 2,333,232 2

SP/NP Tracy Fort Churchill BART Economic Analysis Model 3 of 4