# !!!!2 ProtectionAgency April29,2016JohnR .Kasich,Governor MaryTaylor,Lt.Governor CraigW.Butler,Director 

# GeorgeCzerniak,Director Attention:BilalQazzaz AirandRadiationDivision 

# U

.S.EPA,RegionV 77WestJacksonBoulevard Chicago,Illinois60604 RE:2015SLAMSDataCertification DearMr.Czerniak:CERTIFIEDMAIL

AtthistimewearecertifyingOhio'sambientmonitoringdata.Pleasefindenclosedour SLAMSReports(AMP-450NCforPMcandAMP-600)forcalendaryear2015asrequiredin40 CFR,Part58,Section58.15.Theambientconcentrationandthequalityassurancedatafor thesesiteshavebeencompletelysubmittedtotheAQSdatabase. Icertifythatthedatainthereportareaccuratetothebestofourknowledgetakinginto considerationthequalityassurancefindingsandonlytotheextentoftheactivitiesperformed byOhioEPA. Therewerenoincidentsofairpollutionthatreachedorexceededlevelsasspecifiedby Section51.151whichcouldcausesignificantharmtothehealthofpersons. Sincerely, RobertHodanbosi Chief,DivisionofAirPollutionControl Enclosure50WestTownStreet•Suite700•P.O.Box1049•Columbus,OH43216-1049 epa.ohio.gov•(614)644-3020•(614)644-3184 (fax)UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTI O N AGEN C Y User ID: GYE CERTIFICATION EVALUATION AN D CONCURRENCE Report Request ID: 1441543 Report Code: AMP600 GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS Tribal Code State County Sit:e Parameter POC City AQCR UAR 39 PR O TOCOL SELECTIONS Parameter Classification Parameter Method CRITERIA SELECTED OPTIONS Option Type MERGE PDF FILES AGENCY ROLE DATE CRITERIA Start Date End Date 2015 2015 Duration Option Value YES CERTIFYING Selection Criteria Page 1
C BSA CSA

EPA Region Apr. 29, 2016Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report Summary Apr. 29, 2016 Certification Year: 2015 Certifying Agency (CA): National Park Service (0745) Pollutants in Report: Parameter Name Sulfur dioxide PQAOs in Report: PQAO Name National Park Service Summary of 'N' flags for all pollutants: Parameter PQAO Code AQS Site-10 0745 0745 0745 42401 42401 42401 39-121-8001 39-121-8001 39-121-8001 Code 42401 1 Monitors Evaluated Monitors Recommended for Monitors NOT Recommended Concurrence by AQS for Concurrence by AQS 0

1 PQAO Code TSA Date 0745 AQS Cert. Agency Recommended Recommended POC Flag Flag Reason for AQS Recommendation N N N Annual Summary completeness
< 70%. Annual Performance Evaluation Audit Missing or 1 Level. SignatureofMonitoringOrganizationRepresentative: **~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~**
**~~ ~~~~~~~~**  Pa g e 1 o f 4Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report Summary Apr. 29, 2016 Certification Year: 2015 Certifying Agency (CA): Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Pollutants in Report
: Parameter Name Carbon monoxide Lead (TSP) LC Lead PM10 LC FRM/FEM N i trogen diox

i de (N02) Ozone PM10 Total 0-10um STP PM2

. 5 - Local Conditions Sulfur dioxide PQAOs in Report
: PQAO Name URSCorp

,TX Shell Engineering & Assoc., MO Central Ohio PQAO North East Ohio PQAO South West Ohio PQAO Summary of 'N' flags for all pollutants: Code 42101 14129 85129 42602 44201 81102 88101 42401 AQS Monitors Evaluated 14 24 2 7 48 50 74 34 Monitors Recommended for Concurrence by AQS 14 23 2 6 47 50 70 32 PQAO Code 1299 TSA Date 1373 1453 09/21/15 1454 1455 Cert. Agency Monitors NOT Recommended for Concurrence by AQS 0 0 1 1 0 4 2 Parameter Recommended Recommended PQAO Code AQS Site-ID POC ----

- 1453 88101 1453 42602 1453 42401 1454 88101 1454 88101 1455 44201 1455 88101 1455 42401 1455 14129 1455 44201 39-003-0009 39-049-0037 39-013-3002 39-1 03-0004 39-035-0060 39-027-1002 39-061-0006 39-061-0040 39-091-0006 39-027-1 002 2 1 2 3 4 1 1 Flag Flag N
N N
N N
N N
N N
N N
N N
N N
N N
N N
N Page 2 of 4 Reason for AQS Recommendation Flow Rate Audit completeness< 65% . Annual Performance Evaluation Audit Missing or 1 Level. Annual Performance Evaluation Audit Missing or 1 Level. Flow Rate Audit Bias > 6% . PQAO-Level Collocation criteria not met. Annual Performance Evaluation Audit Missing or 1 Level. Flow Rate Audit completeness
< 65% . Annual Summary completeness
< 70%. Flow Rate Audit completeness
< 65% . 1 - Point QC Completeness
< 65% .Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report Summary Apr. 29, 2016 Signature of Monitoring Organizat

i on Representative

: **~~** Page 3 of 4Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report Summary Apr. 29, 2016 Certification Year: 2015 Certifying Agency (CA): USEPA- Clean Air Markets Division (1344) Pollutants in Report

: Monitors Monitors Recommended for Monitors NOT Recommended Parameter Name Code Evaluated Concurrence by AQS for Concurrence by AQS Ozone 44201 3

3

0 PQAOs in Report: PQAO Name PQAO Code TSA Date USEPA -Clean Air Markets Division 1344 Summary of 'N' flags for all pollutants: AQS rt. Agency Parameter Recommended Reco ed PQAO Code AQS Site-10 POC Flag Flag Signature of Monitoring Organization Representative: **------------------ ~-=-** **------** Page 4 of 4Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants 2015 Name Approval Date National Park Service (07 45) Sulfur dioxide National Park Service (07 45) 06/06/2007 NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met POC Monitor ID Type 21-8 001 1 EPA Routine Data Mean Min Certifying Year 2015 Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Count Count Comp
. Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) . ---------- --·- -·. · ··-· . ._.,... __·-.-.

... PQAO Name Central Ohio PQAO (1453) PP Approval Date NPAPAudit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Routine Data QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc . ite ID Type Count Count Comp. 9-0 1 3-0006 1 SLAMS 0 .152 0 .000 0.700 0 0 99 9-049-0005
1 SLAMS 0 .29 1 0.000 2 .200 0 0 99 9-049-0038
1 SLAMS 0 .162 0 .000 2 .200 0 0 98 PQAO Name North East Ohio PQAO (1454) **~pp** Approval Date NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias 2

2 .43955 Routine Data AQS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Site ID Type Count Count Comp. **~9-Q35-0051**
1 SLAMS 0.300

- 0 .10 0 6 .300 0 0 94
y One Point Quality Check Precision Bias Complete Criteria Met y One Point Quality Check Precision Bias Complete 0 .73 +1 .38 100 1 .54 -3.2 5 100 3 .26 +/ - 2 .78 100 Criteria Met y One Point Quality Check Precision Bias Complete 3 .46 +5 .62 96 - Annual PE NPAP Bias Complete Bias Annual PE NPAP Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level Criteria 5 .83 100

y I 1 .15 100

y 0 .14 100

y

I Annual PE NPAP Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level Criteria 4 .07 100 3.12 y -

- QAPP Appr. y y y QAPF Appr. y Concur. Flag Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Flag Flag Concur Concur

. Flag Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Flag Flag Concur y y s y y

s y y s Concur. Flag Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Flag Flag Concur y y sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Y ear 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) **-- ~-** **~** -----

- -·-- ·····- ··--··-- ·-.-. u- r- ... PQAO Name North East Ohio PQAO (1454) PAPP Approval Date Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur

. Flag !AQs POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPI' Aqs Rec CARec Epa **~ite**10 Type Count Count Comp
. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur **9- 5-0060** 1 S LAMS 0 .271 0 .000 2 .237 0 0 93
3 .24 +/-2
.53 100 3 .21 100 y y y

y s ., **9- 035-0073** 1 S LAM S 0 .23 1 0 .00 0 1 .1 2 5 0 0 93 4 .98 +/-3
.82 96
- 3 .92 100

' y y y

I y s **·~**

l **9-08 5-** **0006**1 S LAM S 0 .33 9 0 .000
1 .800 0 0 99

1 .68 +/-1
.63 100
- 2 .40 100

.. y y y

y s II

l **151-0020**1 SLAMS 0 .345 0 .000 3 .500 0 0 98
3 .79 +5 .45 85 4 .00 100

y r y y

y s L **15 3-** **002 0** 1 SLA M S 0 .1 20 - 0 .1 00 1 .3 0 0 0 0 99 4 .88 +/ - 3 .57 88 2 .57 100

y
r y y

y s I **9- 53-** **0025**1 S LAMS

I

' 0 .1 2 0 0 .000 2 .600 0 0 95 3.27 +/-2
.63 83
- 5 .50 100
1 .7 6 y
' y y y s - -'

- **~** PQAO Name South West Ohio PQAO (1455) APP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 1

4 .75880
y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa ite 10 Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur S LAM S 0 .2 6 1 0 .072
1 .216 0 0 89
5 .86 +/-5
.09 88
1 .48 100 y y

y y s SLAMS 0. 3 6 5 0 .0 7 1 2.5 7 5 0 0 99
5 .90 +/ - 5 .15 96
- 3 .26 100 y y y

y s SLAMS 0 .3 5 1 0 .000
1 .700 0 0 99 4 .49 +/-4
.36 100 0 .52 100 4 .76 y y y

y s S LAM S 0 .15 9 0 .010
1 .3 10 0 0 94
8 .30 +/-6
.56 92
- 4 .13 100 y y y

y sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Year 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) -

-- --
-- **----** \.rr-, PQAO Name Central Ohio PQAO (1453) QAPP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summa!)£: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met y Routine Data One Point Quality Check AnnuaiPE NPAP Concur. Flag !A OS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

. Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CARec Epa **~iteiD** Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur p 9-013 - 0006 1 SLAMS
7 .0 0. 0 48 .0

0 95 2 .21 +/-1
. 83 100 3 .01 100

y y y y s **049-00 7** 1 S LAMS

, 10 .2 0 .0 54 .0

0 94
5 .35 - 5 .23 100

0
y I y N N s L p 9-049 - 00 3 8 1 SLAMS 12 .3 0.0 58 .0

0 95 4 .24 + /-4 .81 100
- 2 . 92 100- y y

y
; y s .

' -
-

- ----- PQAO Name North East Ohio PQAO (1454) PP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa ite ID Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur 9-035 - 0060 1 SLAMS 12 . 9 0 .0 58 .0

0 93
3 .84 +/-3
.33 100
- 14 .52 100 y y y y

s 9-035-0073
1 SLAMS
9 .4 0 .0 5 9 .0

0 86 6 . 10 +/-5
.82 85 6 .07 100 y y y y

s -
-- PQAO Name South West Ohio PQAO (1455) QAPP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summa!)£: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

. Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa iteiD Type Count Count Comp
. Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur 9-061-0040
1 SLAMS 11 .0
1 .0 65.0

0 94
3 . 34 +/-2
. 68 100
- 6 . 64 100

y y y

y s 9-061-0048
1 SLAMS 21.6

1 .0 85 .0

0 93 4 . 52 +/-3
. 63 100
- 5 . 62 100

y y y y

s -
--Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Year 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter Ozone (44201} **{~~ m**  PQAO Name Central Ohio PQAO (1453) PP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summa.!Y:_ Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 3 5.53954

y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur

. Flag QS POC Monitor I Mean Min Max Exceed

.Outlier Perc .Precision B ia s Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF' Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa ite 10 Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur 9-003-0009
1 S LAMS 0 .048 0 .02 5 O.o76 0 0 95 -
1 .94 +/-1
.58 100
- 0 .01 - 100

y y y

y s •

I SLA MS 0 .047 0.021 0 .0 78 0 0 96

1 .87 +/-1
.56 100
- 0 .13 100 y y y

y y s ...

**~** 9 - 049-0029 1 SLAMS 0 .05 1 0.019 0 .082 0 0 95

1 .27 +/ - 1 .02 100
1 .76 100 :::;:: y y y

y s !
f SLAMS 0 .04 7 0 .01 3 0.073 0 0 95

1 .97 +/-1
.81 100 0 .40 100

y y y y s 9- 04 9- 008 1 1 SLA M S 0.046 O.Q15 0.082 0 0 95 0 .82 +1-0
.70 100
- 0 .28 100 5 .54 y. y y

y s S LAMS 0.048 0 .018 0.078 0 0 96 6 .59 +/-6
.09 100 0 .1 2 100

y ' y y

y s SLAMS 0 .048 0 .02 2 0.085 0 0 94

1 .87 + / - 1 .58 100 2 .79 100 J) y y y y

s 9-089-0005
1 SLAMS 0 .049 0 .022 0 .076 0 0 95
3 .04 -2 .76 100 0 .80 100 .i: y ' y y

y s ..,

i 9-095 - 0024 1 SLAMS 0.046 0 .015 0.072 0 0 94
3 .37 -2 .50 80 • 5 .19 100

y y y y s c 9 - 095-0027 1 SLAMS 0 .046 0 .02 2 0 .084 0 0 99

1 .01 +1-0
.88 87 0 .78 100
1 .9 7 y.. y y y s 9 - 095-0034 1 SLAMS 0 .047 0.022 0 .076 0 0 92 0 .79 +/-0
.85 87 2 .02 100 y y

y y s 9-097-0007
1 SLAMS 0 .0 4 9 0 .020 0 .077 0 0 95 1.41 +/-1.1 5 100

1 .05 100 y y y

y s SLAMS 0.048 O.Q16 0 .083 0 0 95
3 .58 +/-2.95 100

1 .77 100 6 .37 y y y y s SLAMS 0 .047 0.022 0.071 0 0 95

1 .33 +/-1
.14 100
1 .46 100 y y

y y s PQAO Name North East Ohio PQAO (1454) APP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summa!Y

: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 5

6 .14353

y Routine Data One Point Quality Check AnnuaiPE NPAP Concur. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

.Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF' Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa ite ID Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur 9-007 - 1001 1 SLAMS 0 .050 0 .024 0.092 0 0 94

1 .61 +2 .25 100 4 .51 100 y y

y y s 9 - 035-0034 1 SLAMS 0 .046 0 .019 0.075 0 0 96 2 .10 +/ - 1 .54 93 1.47 100 6 .14 y y y y

s 9-0 3 5 - 0060 1 SLAMS 0 .044 0 .006 0 .077 0 0 93 0 .90 +/ - 1 .13 100 0 .32 100 y y

y y s -
-
-Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Year 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) ------- **--~ ·-** 
.·--. PQAO Name QAPP Approval Date Routine Data One Point Quality Check AnnuaiPE NPAP Concur

. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa ite ID Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur 9-035-0064
1 SLAMS 0 .046 0 .017 0.085 0 0 98

1 .83 +/-1
.46 100
- 0 .53 100 y y y

y s 9 - 035-5002 1 SLAMS 0.048 0 .020 0.080 0 0 99 1.83 +/-1.44 100 4 .98 100;;.! ·! y y y

y s 9-055 - 0004 1 S LAMS 0 .052 0 .025 0.086 0 0 100 2 .80 +/-2
.25 100
- 1 .00 100

I y y y y

s **~**

I 9-085-0003
1 SLAMS 0 .051 0 .025 0 .084 0 0 98

1 .79 +/-1
.41 100

1 .14 100

y
I y y

y s ...

; S LAMS 0 .049 0.024 0 .081 0 0 99 0 .79 +/-0
.67 100 2 .02 100 y y y

y s S LAMS 0 .046 0 .020 0.070 0 0 95
3 .75 +/-3
.54 100 1.61 100 5 .68 y

' y y y s ! S LAMS 0 .049 0.015 0.076 0 0 93

1 .55 +/-1
.2 1 87 10 .57 100 4 .26 y j y y y

s S LAMS 0 .048 0 .021 0 .073 0 0 99

1 .94 +/-1
.64 100 0 .90 100 8. 19 y I y y y s S LAMS 0 .04 3 0.019 0 .071 0 0 95 1.38 +/-1
.14 100 2 .25 100

y

l y y

y s '

[ SLAMS 0 .050 0.00 2 0.082 0 0 98 2 .87 +/ -2 .31 100 2 .18 100 y y y

' y s t SLAMS 0 .048 0.021 0 .077 0 0 98 1.27 +/-1.08 87
- 0 .05 100 6.9 7 y , y y y

s SLAMS 0 .049 0 .01 7 0 .078 0 0 98 0 .90 +/-0
.70 93
1 .35 100

y !I y y y s SLAMS 0 .044 0 .014 0.073 0 0 99
3 .11 +/-2
.43 100
- 0 .02 100 I' y. y y y

s ' SLAMS 0 .050 0.023 0.079 0 0 93

1 .44 +/ - 1 .13 100

1 .62 100 y y y y

s SLAMS 0 .044 0 .008 0.074 0 0 93 2 .37 +/-1
.72 87 2 .14 100 y y y y

s PQAO Name South West Ohio PQAO (1455) QAPP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summarv: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 4

2 .67352
y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag AQS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Site ID Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur p 9-017-0004
1 SLAMS
0 .051 0 .017 0.085 0 0 95
3 .58 +/ - 2 .98 100 4 .04 100

y y y y

s

IP 9-017-0018
1 SLAMS
0 .052 0 .018 0.082 0 0 100 2 .16 +/-2.29 100
- 5 .41 100

y y y y s p 9-023-0001
1 SLAMS
0 .050 0.020 0.086 0 0 100

I 1 .97 +/-1
.47 87 0 .49 100 y y y y

s ' p9 - 023 - 0003 1 SLAMS
0 .048 0.019 0 .086 0 0 100 0 .60 -2 .19 87
- 0.67 100 y y

y y s p 9-025-0022
1 SLAMS
0 .050 0 .019 0 .087 100

I 3 .53 +/-3
.02 100 100 4 .66 y y y y

s 0 0

- 1 .85 -

--Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Year 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) - **---- ~-** ----·
·- \. ·--.

... PQAO Name South West Ohio PQAO (1455) PP Approval Date Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur

. Flag

I POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur S LAM S 0 .048 0 .0 1 7 0.082 0 0 96

0 y y
N
I N s l"J

**~**

! S LAMS 0 .049 0 .018 0 .086 0 0 100
2 .15 +/-2
.01 80 0 .33 100

y J y y

y s I

'. •

' S LAMS 0 .052 0.017 0 .090 0 0 98 2 .47 +/-2.49 100 3 .89 100

y 1 y y

y s S LAMS 0 .052 0 .017 0 .09 2 0 0 100
3 .71 +/-3
.54 100 4 .29
1 00 2 .10 y ) y y

y s ' SLA M S 0.0 4 9 0 .0 05 0 .08 8 0 0 99

1 .59 +/ - 1 .74 100 0 .14 100

y y y y

s S LAMS 0 .048 0 .016 0 .0 73 0 0 95

1 .67 +/ -1 .49 87 3 .75 100

y
' y y

y s S LA MS 0 .048 O.Q1 5 0 .081 0 0 95

1 .84 +1 .98 87 2 .27 100 0.89 y y y y s S LAM S 0 .04 9 0.0 1 9 0 .08 3 0 0 100
2 .30 - 2 .07 87
- 2 .86 100

y \ y y

y s S LAMS 0 .049 0 .0 1 7 0 .079 0 0 100

I 1.34 +/-1
.42 80 0 .37 100

I y
i y y

y s S LAM S 0 .048 0 .009 0 .077 0 0 100 0.89 +1.40 87 2 .12 100

y

I y y y s '

I

I ' SLAM S 0. 051 0 .017 0 .089 0 0 100 2.80 -3 .62
1 00
1 .59 100 3 .25 y

I y y

I y s ---

-

-Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Year 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) --··- ·-·-
···-- ·- ·-.

- PQAO Name Central Oh
i o PQAO (1453) APP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summa!Y: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Me t 2

1 .50871
y Routine Data One Po
i nt Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

.Outlier Perc .Precision Bias Complete B ias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CARec Epa ite ID Type Count Count Comp.

Crit e ria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur 9-003-0009 1 SLAMS
0 .3 0 .0 30 .0
0 96 4.41 +/ - 3 .55 100
- 1 .01 100 y y y y

s ..

I

j 9-013 - 0006 1 S LAMS 0 .3 0 .0 21 .0
0 96 3 .70 + / -2 .89 10 0 - 4 .97 100

l y y y

y s ; 9-013-3002 2 SLAMS

1 .5 0 .0 4 9 .0
0 96 4 .46 +6 .05 100 L 0 'I y

' y N. N s I

. ubm

i tt er Comm en t Site rep
l aced by site 3 9- 013-0006 before audit wa s done

f 9 - 049-0034 1 SLAMS
0 .1 0 .0 17.0

0 95 2 .46 +/ -2 .22 100
- 2 .20 10 0 2 .01 y y y y

s 9 - 081 - 0017 1 S LAMS

1 .2 0 .0 40 .0
0 96 4 .27 +/-3

.46 100
- 0 .85 10 0 1 .00 y ; y y y

s 9-095-0008 2 SLAMS 0.9 0.0 30.0

0 75 12.86 +/- 7 .58 100 2 .82 100

y I y y y s SLAMS
0 .8 0 .0 52 .0
0 94 4 .03 +/-3

.26 100
- 3 .03 100- y y

y y s ' 9 - 115-0004 1 SLAMS 1.9 0 .0 164
.0
0 96 4 .10 +/-3

.39 100 • 4 .26 100

y f y y y s -

- j PQAO Name PAPP Approval Date North East Ohio PQAO (1454) NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 3

6 .68150
y Routine Data One Point Quality Check AnnuaiPE NPAP Con c ur. Flag AQS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complet e Bias Complete B i as PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Site ID Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Con c ur 39-007
- 100 1 1 SLAMS

1 .6 0 .0 58 .0
0 96 3 .05 + 4 .05 100 5 .88 100 y y y y

s 39-029-0019
1 SLAMS

1 .0 0 .0 29 .0
0 95 2 .66 +/ - 2 .06 100 3 .75 100 y y y y

s 39·035 -0038 2 SLAMS
2 .9 0.0 75 .0
0 97 3 .29 -3 .75 100 0 .26 100 3 .45 y y y y s 39-035-0045
1 SLAMS 0.8 0 .0 51 .0
0 98 5 .26 +/·5

.63 96 • 4 .17 100 y y

y y s 39-035-0060
1 SLAMS 2.3 0 .0 92.0

0 94

1 .50 +/·1

.70 100
- 1 .06 100

y y y y s 39-035
- 0060 2 SLAMS 2.5
- 0 .1 86.7

0 94

1 .85 +1-1.45 100
- 2 .14 100

y y y

I y s 9-035-0065
1 SLAMS

1 .3 0.0 92.0

0 88 4 .82 +/-3

.61 100

1 .32 100 y y

y y s 9-085 - 0003 1 SLAMS

1 .8 - 1 .0 50 .0
0 99

1 .90 +/-1

.88 100 2 .23 100

y y y y s -Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Cert

i fying Yea r 2015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) PQAO Name North East Ohio PQAO (1454) PP Approval Date Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur

. Flag POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

. Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Type Count Count Comp
. Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur SLAM S 3

. 1 -
1 . 0 198.0

0 99

1 . 20 +/-0

. 91 100 4 . 64 100 6 . 68 y y y

y s SLAMS
0 . 9
- 2 . 0 49 . 0
0 94
! 1 . 60 +/ - 1 . 26 69 0 . 39 100

y I y y y

s SLAM S 0 .7 0 .0 46 . 0
0 95 2 . 67 +/-2

. 03 92 3 . 53 100

y

I y y y

s j

I S LAM S 0 . 9 - 1 . 0 39.0

0 95 2 . 56 +/-2

. 18 83 2 . 90 100 7.19 y y y y

s -

-
-
- PQAO Name Shell Engineering & Assoc

. , MO (1373) APP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc. Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPP Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Type Count Count Comp. Criteria Appr. Flag Flag Concur INDUSTRi
2 . 8

1 . 0 101

. 0
0 95 0 . 93 +/-1

. 05 96 - 3
.11 100 y y y

y s AL iNDUSTRI

1 .3 0 . 0 44 . 0
0 95 3 . 08 +/-2

. 15 100
- 2 . 90 100
, y y y y

s AL PQAO Name PAPP Approval Date South West Ohio PQAO (1455) NPAP Audit Summary: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 2

2 . 90292
y Routine Data One Point Quality Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. Flag !AQs POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa **~iteiD** Type Count Count Comp
. Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur **9-001 0001** 1 SLAMS

1 . 0 0 . 0 20 . 0
0 93 4 .12 +/ - 3 . 10 96
- 2 . 66 100

y y y y

s

I **9-QH-0019**
1
i NDUSTRI 1.2
- 2 . 0 102
. 0
0 94 2 . 35 +/-1

. 93 100
- 5 . 49 100

y y y y s AL **9-Q17 0020** 1 INDUSTRI AL

1 .4 0 . 0 81 . 0
0 99 2 . 65 +/ - 2 . 20 100 0.47 100

y y y y

sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Po ll utants Certifying Year
2 015 Certifying Agency Code Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) - -- ·--------- --··- ·-·-

···-- \ ·-·- .,

l l"'l"'- / PQAO Name South West Ohio PQAO (1455) QAPP Approval Date Routine Data One Point Quality Check AQS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

.Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete **~iteiD** Type Count Count Comp. 39-017 - 0021 1 iN DUSTRi

1 .7 -
1 .0 44.0

0 99
5 .02 +/ -4 .62 1 0 0 AL 39 - 02 3 -0003 1 S LAMS 0. 4 0 .0 21 .0

0 100
3 .73 + /-3 .12 100 39-061-00 10 2 SLAMS

1 .3 - 1 .0 67 .0

0 99
I 1 .43 +/-1
.73 100 39 - 061 - 0040 1 S LAMS

1 .6
- 0 .2 45 .9

0 68
3 .56 +/ - 3 .02 77 3 9 - 08 7 -0012 1 SLAM S 0 .4 0 .0 25 .0

0 95
7 .2 4 +/-4
.34 96 39 - 135 - 1 001 1 SLAMS
0 .6
- 0 .1 115
.2
0 95 3 ..22 +/-2
.26 88 p 9-145-0013
1 S LAMS
0 .8 - 1 .0 28 .0

0 94

I 3 .53 +/-2
.75 88 - PQAO Name URSCorp

,TX (1299) PP Approval Date 02/27/2013 NPAP Audit Summa!Y: Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met y Routine Data One Point Quality Check QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed. Outlier Perc .Pr eci sion B i as Complet e it e ID Type Count Count Comp
. 9 - 145-0020 1 iNDUSTRI

1 .5 0 .2 29.4

0 99

1 .79 +8 .63 73 AL I N DUSTRi 2 .4 1

.5 29.8

0 99

1 .99 + 3 .08 69 AL 2015 Certifying Year Certifying Agency Code Parameter USEPA- Clean Air Markets Division (1344) i PQAO Name APP Approval Date NPAP Audit Summa!Y

: Ozone {44201) loom USEPA
- Clean Air Markets Division (13 44) 10/02/2011 Number of Passed Audits NPAP Bias Criteria Met 16

2 .51448
y Routine Data

On e Point Qua

l ity Check Annual PE NPAP Concur. F l ag Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Criteria Appr
. Flag Flag Concur - 3 .79 100

y y y

y s 0 .86 100

y.. y y y s ' - 8 .56 100 3.78 y
: y y y

s 0 .65 100

y
' y N i N s - 9 .95
1 00 2.0 3 y y

y

I y s I - 7 .67 100

y .. y y y s - 8 .59 100 r y i· y y 1 y s 1 -·- -
- Annual PE NPAP Concur

. Flag B ias Complete B i as PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Rec Epa Criter

i a Appr
. Flag Flag Concur 1 .84 100 y y

y y s 0 .02 100 y y

y y s Annual PE NPAP Concur

. FlagData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Gaseous Pollutants Certifying Y e ar 2015 C e rt i fyi ng A ge n c y Co d e USEPA- Clean Air Markets Division
( 1344 ) -----------

-- --··- . ·-- .... PQ A O Name USEPA- Clean Air Markets Division (1344) QAPP Approval Date 10/02/2011 Routine Data One Point Quality Chec k Annual PE NPAP Concur

. Flag QS POC Monitor Mean Min Max Exceed

.Outlier Perc . Precision Bias Complete Bias Complete Bias PQAO Level QAPF Aqs Rec CA Re c Epa iteiD T ype Count Count Comp
. Criteria Appr . Flag Flag Concur 1 EPA 0 .04 8 0 .01 1 0 .0 79 0 0 86

1 .87 - 2 .99
1 00
- 1 .66 100

y y y y s I

**~** 1 E P A 0 .0 4 8 0 .01 6 0 .0 7 9 0 0 93

1 .90 +/ - 1 .69 100
- 0 .14 10 0 5 .54 y y y

y s ' 1 EPA 0 .0 4 9 0 .0 1 2 0 .0 86 0 0 94

1 .04 -1 .22 100
- 0 .8 3
1 0 0

y 1 y y y

s -

-
-
-Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifyi n g Y ear
: 2015 Certif y i ng Ag ency : Ohio EPA Central Office
( 1256 ) P arameter

: PM10 Total 0 - 10um STP (81102) CONTINUOUS PQAO N ame: North East Ohio PQAO (1454) **uality**Assurance Project P l an Approval Date : Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Verif

i cation Flow Rate Audit **Col~ ce**  Flag Monitor Exceed

.Outlier % % % QAPP AQS RecCA Rec EPA AQS Site 10 POC **~Mean**Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete Bias Complete **~** Flag Flag Concur 3 9 -03 5 - 00 6 0 3 S L A M S 31 .4 9

.0 4 2 0 .0 0 99 +/-1

.00 100 -0 .7 3 100 y y y
s -

- Parameter

: PM10 Total 0 - 10um STP ( 81102) CONTINUOUS PQAO Name: South West Ohio PQAO (1455) p ual it y Assurance Project Plan Approva

l Da t e : Mon

i tors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Veri fi cation Flow Rate Aud

i t **Col~en ce**  Flag Monitor Exceed

.Outlier % % % QAPP AQS RecCA Rec EPA AQS Site 10 POC **~Mean**Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete Bias Complete **~**Flag Flag Concur 39-061-0040
9 S LAMS 21.55
- 1. 0 122
.0 0 97 -3 .94 100 -2 .27 100 y y
y s Parameter

: PM10 Total 0 - 10um STP (81102) CONTINUOUS

I PQAO Name
: URSCorp

,TX ( 1299)

! **uality**Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: 02/27/2013 Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Verification Flow Rate Audit **Col~enc**
**e** Flag Monitor Exceed

.Outlier % % % QAPP AQS Rec CA Rec EPA AQS Site 10 POC **~Mean**Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete Bias Complete **~** Flag Flag Concur 3 9 - 14 5 - 0020 1 INDU S TRI 12 .44

.0 3 2 1 .0 0 99 +/-1.18 100 -1 .87 100 y y
y s AL 3 9-145-00 2 1 1 INDUSTRI 15 .57

.0 325

.0 0 98 -0 .79 100 -1.24 100 y y y s AL 39-14 5- 0022 1 INDUSTRI 13 .66

.0 2 08 .0 0 99 +/ - 1 .14 100 -3 .40 100 y y
y s ALData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifyi ng Y e a r :2015 C ert ifyin g Agency

: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Par am eter : PM10 Total 0-10um STP (81102) INTERMITTENT PQAO Name
: Central Ohio PQAO (1453) **uality**Assurance Project Plan Approval Date : Collocation Summary #Sites #Sites % CV Criteria # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? 4 1 3 100 5 . 86 6 .42 y M oni t ors Summaries Rout

i ne Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation Concurrence Flag Monitor Exceed

. Outlier % % AQS Site 10 POC **~**Mean Min Max Count **Count~C~o~m~p~le~t~e~**
**L: ia** **== le** **====== ====~====** **i_ ~~** **-- ~~====**  39- 01 3 -0006 1 SLAMS 2 2 . 00 3 . 0 39 . 0 0 3 9 - 013-0006 2 3 9 - 049-0024 3 9-049-0024
2 39 - 081-0001 39-081-001 7 39-081-0017
2 SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS 19 . 79 3 . 0 24 . 62 7 . 0 23 . 96 6 . 0 21.42 4 . 0 22 . 10 4 . 0 21.67 4 . 0 3 7 . 0 0 55 . 0 0 52 . 0 0 45.0 0 44 . 0 0 43 . 0 0 0 93 0 80 0 91 0 91 0 100 0 100 0 100 -2 . 48 100 ' -3 . 07 100 " +0.60 100 -0.95 100 -0.86 100 +1 . 37 100 +2.86 100 7 . 05 100 3.78 100 y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y s s s s s s sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) **arameter**

**:**PM10 Total 0-10um STP (81102) INTERMITTENT QAO Name: North East Ohio PQAO (1454) uality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: 1 Collocation Summary :

# Sites # Sites # Sites Reg Collocated 13 2 5 !Monitors Summaries

% cv Collocated Est CV UB 100 6.90 7 . 45 Routine Data (ug/m3) Criteria Met? y Flow Rate Audit Collocation Concurrence Flag AQS Site ID POC 39-029-0020 39-029-0022 39-029-0022
2 39-035-0038 39-035 - 0038 4 39-035-0038
6 39-035-0038
7 39-035-0038
8 39-035-0045 39-035-0045
2 39-035-0060
1 39-035-0065 39-035-1002 39-085-1001 39-085-1001
2 39-093-3002 39-099-0005 39-099-0006 Monitor Exceed. Outlier % I % **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete **.::B::ia::s :__:** **C::o::m~p=le::te :.L** **.::C:::V :.___:** **=::~====:::~..:==: .:::~** **-= ~==** **::J** SLAMS 19 . 62 3 .0 54 .0 0 SLAMS 17 .16 5 .0 34 .0 0 SLAMS 16 .02 4 .0 33 .0 0 SLAMS 23 .24 3 .0 56 .0 0 SLAMS 25 . 56 7.0 60 .0 0 SLAMS 31 .76 6.0 90.0 0 SLAMS 23 . 96 6 .0 51 .0 0 SLAMS 28 .71 6.0 59 .0 0 SLAMS 23.45 4 .0 44 .0 0 SLAMS 23.40 5.0 43.0 0 SLAMS 41 . 93 10.0 119
.0 0 SLAMS 37 . 28 5 .0 83.0 0 SLAMS 15 . 67 5 .0 35 .0 0 SLAMS 17.16 3 .0 35 .0 0 SLAMS 17.37 2 .0 36.0 0 SLAMS 10 . 07 3.0 35 .0 0 SLAMS 15 .72 3.0 32 .0 0 SLAMS 19 . 20 3.0 57 .0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 100 95 96 100 100 100 100 0 100 0 100 0 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 95 96 100 95 95 98 96 98 -0.68 100 +1 . 09 100 +0 .72 100 +1 . 94 100 +2 .14 100 +0 . 45 100 +3 .7 0 100 +0 . 96 100 +3.05 100 +2 .03 100 +3 . 94 100 +1 . 38 100 +3 .63 100 -1 . 79 100 -1.63 100 +3 .58 100 -2 .88 100 -1 . 80 100 6 . 89 100 5.94 100 4 .24 100 9 .58 100 y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) j Parameter: PM10 Total 0-10um STP (81102) INTERMITTENT PQAO Name: North East Ohio PQAO (1454) Fuality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary # Sites # Sites % CV Criteria # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? 13 2 5 100 6 . 90 7 . 45 y Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation Concurrence Flag Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % AQS Site 10 POC J:iE.! Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV 39-099-0006
2 SLAMS 18 .68 2.0 56 .0 0 0

I 98 -3 .87 100

y y y y s 39-155-0005

1 SLAMS 16 . 65 1 .0 43.0 0 0 i 80 -2.61 100 26 .72 100 y y y

y s I

I 39-155-0005
2 SLAMS 14.71 1 .0 31.0 0 0 84

I -7.47 100 y y y

y s 39-155-0006

1 SLAMS 12 . 75

.0 34 .0 0 0 93
I -3 . 65 100 y y y y

sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter: PM 10 Total 0-1 Oum STP (811 02) INTERMITTENT PQAO Name: South West Ohio PQAO (1455) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary # Sites # Sites # Sites Reg Collocated 12 2 4 Monitors Summaries

% cv Collocated Est CV UB 100 4 .11 4 .41 Routine Data (ug/m3) Criteria Met? y Flow Rate Audit Monitor Exceed.Outlier % % Collocation Concurrence Flag AQS Site ID POC 39-017-0003 39-017-0015 39-017-0019 **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete **L-=: B::ia::s:.__::C::o=::m::p::l::e::te** **:L: C::V** **:::__::: ::::::::** **:::.: :::=::::::::::::c:::** **::L _::~** **---= ~~=:::::J**  39-017-0020

1 39-057-0005 39-061-0014 39-061-0040
4 39-061-0040
5 39-061-5001 39-061-5001
2 39-087-0012

1 39-113-7001 39-113-7001
2 39-145 - 0013 39-145-0013
2 39-145-0019 SLAMS 20 .07 8 .0 45 .0 0 SLAMS 23 .38 7 .0 46 .0 0 INDUSTRI 20 .23 4.0 42.0 0 AL INDUSTRI 38.46 10 .0 97 .0 0 AL SLAMS 13.42 4.0 42 .0 0 SLAMS 23.63 9 .0 51.0 0 SLAMS 16 . 49 3 .0 44 .0 0 SLAMS 17 .00 3 .0 46 .0 0 SLAMS 20 .08 8 .0 43 .0 0 SLAMS 19 .65 8 .0 44 .0 0 SLAMS 17.45 8 .0 41 .0 0 SLAMS 18.69 5.0 49 .0 0 SLAMS 18.85 5 .0 50 .0 0 SLAMS 16.56 8 .0 42 .0 0 SLAMS 16 .72 7 .0 40 .0 0 SLAMS 16 . 37 7 .0 32.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 96 96 100 98 95 100 97 96 100 100 100 98 98 98 100 95 +0.41 100 +0 . 19 100 -1 .21 100 -0 .12 100 -0 . 79 100 -0 .17 100 -1 .27 100 -0 . 32 100 -0 .47 100 -0 . 97 100 +0 . 80 70 -2 . 40 100 -0 .85 100 +5 . 94 70 +2 . 80 70 +3 . 32 100 4 . 37 100 4 .80 100 4.98 100 4 .21 100 y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency

: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter: PM2

. 5- Local Conditions (88101) PQAO Name: Central Ohio PQAO (1453) uality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites % cv Criteria # #Audited #PEP #PEP % Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 118 2 1

0 0 r--"N
4 3 8

9 100 +0 . 16 y . 120 1 1

1 100 8 . 88 12.06 y 142 3 1 2 100 9 .24 10 . 28 y 145 8 1 3 100 5 . 16 5 . 61 y Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEPConcurrence Flag Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS Rec CA Rec EPA AQS Site ID POC Method **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit. Met Crit. MeJ rumr:. Flag Flag Concur 39-003-0009

1 142 SLAMS 9.63
1 .7 26 .7 0 90 : +1 .12 100 9 . 34 100 y y y y
y s 39-009-0003

1 142 SLAMS 7 . 35 1.9 18 . 6 0 93
j -2.02 100 12 . 05 100 y y y y
y s 39 - 009-0003 2 142 SLAMS 7 .27 2.4 19 . 9 0 83 -1 .72 100

y y y y
y s 39-013-0006

1 145 SLAMS 8 .72 1.5 23 . 9 0 98

' -1 .42 100

y y y y
y s 39-049-0024

1 145/ SLAMS 9 . 93 2.1 24 .2 0 90 -2 . 05 100

y y y y
y s 118 39-049-0039

1 120/ SLAMS 10 . 35 2 .1 30 .7 0 95

' t•' '- 1.18 100 8 . 25 100 y y y y y
s 145 39-049
- 0039 2 145/ SLAMS 11.02 3 . 3 28.4
0 93 -0 . 80 100

y y y y
y s 120 39-049-0081

1 118/ SLAMS 9.81
1 .7 24 . 9 0 100

1 -1.45 100

y y y y
y s 145 39-081-0017

1 145 SLAMS 10 .74 1 . 9 37.5
0 90 -2 . 63 100 7 . 53 100 y y y y y s 39-081-0017
2 145 SLAMS 11 . 20 2.4 24
.1 0 83

- 1 . 07 100

y y y y
y s 39-081-0021

1 142 SLAMS 9 . 15 1 . 8 26.7
0 100 -1.32 100

y y y y
y s 39-081-0021
4 142 SLAMS 10 . 66 3 .1 36 . 0 0 100 -0 .12 100 y y
y y y s 39-095-0024

1 145 SLAMS 10 . 15 2 . 0 40 . 3 0 97 -1.42 100 2 . 35 100 y y y y y
s 39-095-0024
2 145 SLAMS 10.68 2 . 8 23.2
0 95 -1 . 33 100

y y y y
y s -Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter

: PM2

. 5- Local Conditions (88101) PQAO Name: Central Ohio PQAO (1453) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites % cv Criteria
# #Audited #PEP #PEP % Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 118 2 1

0 0 I
N 4 3 8 9 100 +0 .16 y - 120 1 1 1 100 8 . 88 12 . 06 y 142 3 1 2

I 100 9 .24 10.28 y ' 145 8 1 3 100 5 .16 5 .61 y Monitors Summar

i es Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEPConcurrence Flag Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS Rec CA Rec EPA AQS Site 10 POC Method **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit. Met Crit. Met **~**Flag Flag Concur 39-095-0026

1 145 SLAMS 9 . 59 2 .3 37 .0 0 98

'-1 . 33 100

y y y y
y s 39-095-0028

1 1 45 SLAMS 9 . 96 2 .6 38.4
0 99
- 1 . 10 100

y y y y
y s 39-003-0009
2 142 SLAMS 9.80 1 .7 26.5
0 78 +0 .42 - 50

y y y N I N s -Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter

: PM2.5- Local Conditions (88101) PQAO Name: North East Ohio PQAO (1454) uality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites % cv Criteria
# #Audited #PEP #PEP % Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 120 3 1 2 100 6 . 60 7 . 28 y 4 4

8 7 87.5 -6 . 20 y 142 5 1 2

,, 100 4 . 40 4 . 82 y 145 9 1 2

I 100 3 . 93 4 .24 y 179 1 1

0 L9 __.!:!__. - Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEP Concurrence Flag

! Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS RecCA Rec EPA AQS Site ID POC Method **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit Met Crit. Me **~**Flag Flag Concur 39-035-0034

1 145 SLAMS 9 .17 1 . 5 25 .2 0

; 98 -2 . 20 100

y y y y y s 39-035-0038

1 145 SLAMS 11 .77 2 . 9 38 . 5 0 92 +1 . 10 100 3 . 80 100 y y y y
y s 39-035-0038
2 145 SLAMS 11 . 76 2.8 39 . 3 0 100 -3 . 35 100

y y y y y
s 39-035-0045

1 145/ SLAMS 10.95 2.4 28 . 3 0 95 -3 . 43 100

y y y y
y s 120 39-035
- 0065 1 145 SLAMS 13 . 34 2 .2 36 . 5 0 98 -2 . 04 100

y y y y
y s 39-035-1002

1 145 SLAMS 9 . 05 1 .7 24.8
0 96 -0 . 91 100

y y y y
y s 39 - 085-0007
1 120 SLAMS 8 . 13 1.6 21 . 5 0 97 +0 . 40 100 8 . 19 100 y y y y
y s 39-085-0007
2 120 SLAMS 8.47 1.5 20.9
0 95 -0.36 100 y y y y
y s 39 - 093-3002
1 120 SLAMS 8 . 31 1 . 5 27 .4 0 96 +1 . 36 100 6 . 75 100 y y y y
y s 39-093-3002
2 120 SLAMS 8 . 67 2 .2 29 . 9 0 93 -0 . 68 100 y y y y
y s 39-099-0005

1 142 SLAMS 10.84 1.9 32.4
0 95 i. +1.47 100 5 . 85 100 y y y y
y s 39-099-0005
2 142 SLAMS 11 . 02 1.8 32.0
0 100

I -1 . 20 100

y y y y
y s 39-099-0014

1 142 SLAMS 10 . 51 1 .4 34 . 8 0 100 +0
. 85 100

y y y y
y s 39-099-0014
4 142 SLAMS 9 . 66 2 . 6 24 . 0 0 100 +1 . 03 100

y y y y y s 39-103-0004

1 145 SLAMS 7.57 1.4 22.6
0 95 -0.07 100

y y y y
y s -------

----

-Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter C e rtif y i ng Ye ar : 2015 C erti fyin g Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) P arameter

: PM2

. 5 - Local Conditions (881 01) PQAO Name
: North East Ohio PQAO (1454) Quality Assurance P r oject Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites % cv Criteria # #Audited #PEP #PEP % Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 1 2 0 3 1

2 100 6.60 7 . 28 y 4 4

8 7 87 .5
- 6 . 20 y I 14 2 5 1

2

I 100 4 . 40 4 .82 y I 14 5 9 1

2

I 100 3 . 9 3 4 .24 y 1 7 9 1 1 0 i 0

N **~** M o nit o rs S um ma ries

: Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEPConcurrence Flag

i I Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS RecCA Rec EPA

i AQS Site 10 POCMethod **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit. Me Crit. Me **~** Flag Flag Concur 39 - 133-0002
1 145 SLAMS 8 . 93 1 .6 22 . 9 0 95 -1 .24 100 y y y y y

s 39-151 - 00 1 7 1 14 2 SLAMS 11.43 2.3 32 .2 0 99

I +2 .11 100 4 . 09 100 y I y y y
y s 39-151-0017
2 142 SLAMS 12 . 39 3 .3 33 .2 0 100 -1 . 39 100

y y y y
y s 39-151-0020

1 142 SLAMS 10.45 2.4 38 .2 0 97 +1 . 15 100

y y y y
y s 3 9- 1 53-0017
1 145 SLAMS 10 .22 1 .8 35 .1 0 93 -2.47 100 4 . 82 100 y y y y
y s 39- 1 53-0017 2 145 SLAMS 10.91 1. 9 35.7
0 86 -2 . 58 100

y y y y
y s 39- 1 53-0017 3 1 7 0 SPM 13 . 87 -7 .6 196
.1 0 97 -2 .10 100

y y y y
y s 39 - 153 - 0023 1 145 SLAMS 9 . 93 1 . 9 47 .0 0 84 -1 .41 100

y y y y
y s 39-155-0005

1 142 SLAMS 11 . 79 5 .3 27 .5 0 78 +/-0.00 100

y y y y
y s 39 - 1 55-0005 4 142 SLAMS 9 . 65 2 . 9 20 .6 0 78 -0 .12 100

y y y y
y s 39-035-0060

1 179 SLAMS 11 . 28 2 .6 26 .1 0 76 -1 .77 100

I N l y y N N s 3 9-103-0004
3 170 SPM 11 . 63 - 8.0 55.6
0 94
l +10
.30 , 100

y y y N l N s **~--- -----** 

---Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter: PM2.5- Local Cond

i tions (88101) PQAO Name
: South West Ohio PQAO (1455) uality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites % cv Criteria # #Audited #PEP #PEP
% Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 118 2 1 1 100 5 . 57 6 .41 y 4 3 8 8
100

- 4 . 80 y 120 1 1 1 l 100 4 . 05 4 . 63 y
. 142 11 2 2 100 5 . 01 5 . 52 y 145 3 1 1 I 100 5 . 01 5.74 y Monitors Summaries

i Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEPConcurrence Flag

I Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS RecCA Rec EPA
. AQS Site ID POCMethod b:l!! Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit. Me Crit. Me **~** Flag Flag Concur 39-017-0003

1 142 SLAMS 9 . 67 3 .7 20 .7 0 100 -2 . 67 100

y y y y
y s 39-017-0003
4 142 SLAMS 11 . 01 2 . 0 23.4
0 100 -2 . 56 100

y y y y
y s 39-017-0016

1 142 SLAMS 8.54 2 . 9 22.6
0 100 -2 . 54 100

y y y y y

s 39-017-0016
4 142 SLAMS 10.41 2 . 3 30 . 8 0 100 -2 . 16 100

y y y y
y s 39-017-0019

1 142 INDUSTRI
9 . 50 2.7 21 .2 0 100 -1 . 64 100

y y y y y s AL 39-017-0019
4 142 INDUSTRI 10 . 95 2 .2 26 . 6 0 100 -1 . 91 100 y y y y y

s AL 39-017-0020

1 142 INDUSTRI 11.06 4 . 3 22 .4 0 100 -0 . 36 100

y y y y
y s AL 39-017-0020
4 142 INDUSTRI 12 . 52 3 . 0 27 . 8 0 100 -2.16 100

y y y y
y s AL 39-017-0022

1 142 SPM 12 . 08 3.9 31.8
0

I 96 -0 . 45 100

y y y y
y s 39-023-0005

1 142 SLAMS 8 . 31 2 . 5 21 . 6 0 100

.-1 .71 100

y y y y
y s 39-023-0005
4 142 SLAMS 9 . 69 1 . 9 26 . 8 0 100 -1 . 02 100

y y y y
y s 39-057
- 0005 1 142 SLAMS 8.33 2.2 17 .7 0 100 -3 . 04 100 7 . 26 100 y y y y y
s 39-057-0005
2 142 SLAMS 8.48 2 . 0 17 . 3 0 100 -1 . 68 100

y y y y
y s 39-05 7-0005 4 142 SLAMS 8 .22 2 .2 20 . 9 0 100 -2 . 68 100

y y y y
y s -Data Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year:2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter: PM2.5- Local Conditions (88101) PQAO Name: South West Ohio PQAO (1455) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites % cv Criteria
# #Audited #PEP #PEP % Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 118 2 1 1 100 5 . 57 6.41 y 4 3 8 8
100 -4 . 80 y 120 1 1

1 100 4 . 05 4.63 y 142 11 2 2

'100 5 . 01 5 . 52 y 145 3 1 1

' 100 5.01 5 . 74 y Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEPConcurrence Flag Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS Rec CA Rec EPA AQS Site ID POC Method **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit. Me Crit . Me **~**Flag Flag Concur

, i 39-061-0006

1 142 SLAMS 9 . 31 2 . 2 25 . 8 0 97 -0 . 82 100 y y y y

y s 39-061-001 0 1 142 SLAMS 9 . 45 2 . 2 21 . 4 0 100 +0 . 27 100

y

I y y y

y s 39-061-001 0 4 142 SLAMS 8 . 92 2 .7 21 . 8 0 100 -0 . 45 100

y y y y y

s 39-061-0014

1 120 SLAMS 10 . 68 2 . 1 26 . 6 0 95 -0 . 66 100 4 . 63 100 y y y y
y s 39-061
- 0014 2 120 SLAMS 11 . 27 3 . 5 25 . 0 0 98

I -0 . 89 100

I y y y y y s 39 - 061-0040
1 142 SLAMS 9.24 2 . 1 24.6
0 98 -1 . 21 100 4.07 100

Iy y y y
y s 3 9-061-0040
4 142 SLAMS 9 . 44 2 . 2 22.0
0 96 -0 . 53 100

I y y y y
y s 39-061-0042

1 142 SLAMS 9 . 73 2.9 25.0
0 100 -0 . 82 100

y y y y
y s 39-061-0042
4 142 SLAMS 10.47 2 . 3 27.0
0 100 -0 . 27 100

y y y y y s 39-087-0012

1 118/ SLAMS 7 . 28 1.8 17 . 9 0 97 -2 . 48 100

y y y y
y s 145 39-113-0038

1 145 SLAMS 9 . 46 1 . 9 21
. 1 0 95 -2 . 02 100 5 . 74 100 y y y y
y s 39-113-0038
2 145 SLAMS 10 . 35 2 . 3 33 . 4 0 100 -2.25 100

y y y y
y s 39-135-1001

1 145 SLAMS 8 . 32 1.6 19 . 8 0 93 -1 . 79 100 y y
y y y
s 39-145-0013

1 118 SLAMS 8 . 53 1 . 7 31
. 5 0 97 -1 . 50 100 6.41 100 y y y y
y s **~-145-0013**
2 118 SLAMS 8 . 77 1 . 8 20.8
0 91

' -1 . 92 100

y y y y
y sData Evaluation and Concurrence Report for Particulate Matter Certifying Year

: 2015 Certifying Agency: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Parameter: PM2.5- Local Conditions (88101) PQAO Name: South West Ohio PQAO (1455) uality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary
PEP Summary #Sites #Sites
% cv Criteria # #Audited #PEP #PEP % Criteria Method # Sites Reg Collocated Collocated Est CV UB Met? Methods Methods Required Submitted Complete Bias Met? 118 2 1 1 100 5 . 57 6 .41 y 4 3 8 8 100 -4 .80 y 120 1 1
1 100 4 . 05 4 . 63 y 142 11 2 2 100 5 .01 5 . 52 y 145 3 1

1 100 5 .01 5 .74 y Monitors Summaries Routine Data (ug/m3) Flow Rate Audit Collocation PEPConcurrence Flag Monitor Exceed. Outlier % % % PQAO PQAO QAPP AQS RecCA Rec EPA AQS Site 10 POC Method **~**Mean Min Max Count Count Complete Bias Complete CV Complete Crit. Met Crit. Met **~** Flag Flag Concur 39-061-0006
4 142 SPM 8.60 2.7 19 .2 0 100 +I- ro:.

y y y N N s ------

-

---------

----

-Data Concurrence and Evaluation Report for Lead Certification Year 2015 Certifying Agency Name: lead (TSP) lC (14129) Ohio EPA Ce nt ra l Office (1256) PQAO Name
: Cen tra l Ohio PQAO (1 453 ) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date : Collocation Summary

: Number of Number of Number Colloc Sites Actual of Sites Required Colloc Sites 5

2 Analysis Audit Summary

: Number Percent Percent Collocated 100 cv Est 5 . 81 Number Required Submitted Complete Bias Criteria Met 24
2 4 92 +/-4

. 58 y Monitors Recommended for Certification CVUB 7 .42

Criteria Met y

PEP Summary Number of Number of Number of Methods PEP Audits Methods Audited Required 0 Mon

i tor Exceed

. Outlier I Routine Data (ug/m"3) Percent Percent Percent PQAO I Flow Rate Audit I Collocation PQAO I PEP AQS Site-ID PO C Type **~ ~** **~ ~** Count 39-049 -00 39 39-051-0001 SLAMS SLAMS 39-05 1-0 001 2 SLAMS 39-101-0003
1 SLAMS 39 - 101-0004 39 - 1 67-0008
S PM SLAMS 39 - 167 - 0008 2 SLAMS
0 . 007 0 . 002 0 . 019 0 0 . 040 0 . 003 0 . 316 0 0.034 0 . 003 0 . 196 0 . 022 0.002 0 . 067 0.010 0 . 002 0 . 044 0 . 003 0 . 002 0.012 0 . 003 0 . 002 0 . 010
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Comp. **~** Comp. **~** Comp
. **~** 100 -2 . 15 100 98 -1 . 50 100 91 100 100 98 98 +2 . 06 -3 . 55 -2 . 78 +2 . 90 +5.40 100 70 70 1 00 100 7 .42 100 100 y y y y y y y

**~** y y y y y y y Number of Audits Percent Criteria Met Submitted Complete Bias Analysis Crit. Met I lead y y y y y y y 0
0

y I Certification QAPP AQS CA Rec EPA Appr
. **~**Valu e Concur y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y s s s s s s sData Concurrence and Evaluation Report for Lead Certification Year 2015 Certifying Agency Name
: O h io EPA C entral Offi ce ( 1 2 56 ) Lead (TSP) LC (14129) PQAO Name
: North East Oh
i o PQA O ( 1454 ) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary

: Number of Number of Number Colloc Sites Actual of Sites Required Colloc Sites 8 Analysis Audit Summary: Number Percent 3 Percent Collocated 100 cv Est 3 . 43 Number Required Submitted Complete Bias Criteria Met 24 24 92 +1-4
. 58 y Monitors Recommended for Certification CVUB 4 .74

Criteria Met y

PEP Summary Number of Number of Number of Methods PEP Audits Methods Audited Required 0
2 Exceed. Outlier Monitor AQS Site·ID P O C Type I Routine Data (uglm"3) ---- **~ ~** Max Count Count

I Flow Rate Audit I Collocation Percent Percent Percent PQAO Comp. **~** Comp
. CV UB Comp. Crit. Met I **p~e; ~**  3 9 - 029 - 0019 3 9 - 0 2 9-0020 3 9 -0 2 9-002 2 39-029-0022
2 39·035-0038
1 39 - 035-0042
1 39-035-0042
2 39 - 035-0049 39 - 035-0049 2 39-035-0060 39 - 035-0061 3 9-035-0072 SLAMS S LAMS SLAMS S LAMS SLAMS SLAMS S LAMS SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS SLAMS
0 . 010 0 . 008 0.008 0 . 008 0 . 009 0 . 009 0 . 009 0 . 014 0.013 0 . 015 0 . 018 0 . 009 0 . 002 0 . 0 02 0 . 00 2 0.002 0 . 002 0 . 002 0.00 2 0 . 003 0.003 0 . 003 0 . 003 0 . 00 2 0 . 0 2 5 0 . 09 0 0 . 0 2 0 0 . 020 0 . 031 0 . 034 0 . 024 0 . 049 0 . 052 0 . 060 0 . 098 0 . 051 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 98 +0 .24 100 1 00 -2 . 33 1 00 98 +1 . 87 100 98
- 0 .51 100 95 100 95 98 91 96 98 98 +2 . 57 +3.15 - 2 . 0 7 +0 . 10 +4 .27 +3 . 35 +2 . 09 +1 .41 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 18 . 51 5.64

y y 100 y 100 100 y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y Number of Audits Percent Criteria Met Submitted Complete Bias I Lead Analysis **~** y y y y y y y y y y y y 0 0

y I Certification QAPP AQS CA Rec EPA Appr
. **~Value C~**  y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y y s s s s s s s s s s s sData Concurrence and Evaluation Report for Lead Certification Year 20 1 5 Certifying Agency Name: Ohio EPA Cent ral Office (1256) Lead (TSP) LC (14129) PQAO Name
: Sou th West Ohio PQAO (1455) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date: Collocation Summary

: Number of Number of Number Colloc Sites Actual of Sites Required Colloc Sites 2 Analy sis Audit Summary

:

2 Percent Collocated 100 cv Est CVUB Criteria Met y

PEP Summary Number of Number of Number of Methods PEP Audits Methods Audited Required 0 Number Required Number Percent Submitted Complete Bias Criteria Met 24 24 92 +/-4

. 58 Monitors Recommended for Certification Monitor Exceed

. Outlier I Routine Data (ug/m"3) AQS Site-ID ----- **~** Type **~ ~** **~**Count Count 39-017
- 0015 SLAMS 39-017-0015
2 SLAMS 39-113-700 1 1 SLAMS 39 -1 13 - 7001 2 SLAMS Monitor• Rot Raca..endad

0 . 004 0 . 002 0 . 011 0 0 . 004 0 . 002 0 . 007 0 . 004 0 . 002 0 . 017 0 . 004 0 . 002 0.017 for Certification

0 0 0 Monitor Exceed. Outlier I Routine Data (ug/m"3) AQS Slte-ID POC Type Mean **~ ~** **~**Count 39-09 1 -0006 SLAMS
0 . 003 0 . 002 0 . 005 0 y 0 0 0 0 0
I Flow Rate Audit I Collocation Percent Percent Percent PQAO Comp
. **~** Comp. **~** Comp
. **~** 96 +1 . 20 100 96 y 100 83 76 Percent Comp. +1 . 16 -4 . 27 -5 . 09 100 100 100 Percent Bias Comp
. I Flow Rate Audit --- ------ 100 +I100 y y y Percent PQAO I Collocation **~** Comp. Crit. Met y I PEP PQAO **~** y y y y PQAO Crit. Met I PEP y Number of Audits Subm

i tted 0 I Lead Analysis **~** y y y y Analysis Crit . Met I Lead y Percent Complete Bias 0 Criteria Met y I Certification QAPP AQS CA Rec EPA Appr
. Rec . V **~ C~**  y y y y y y y y y y y y s s s s I Certification QAPP AQS CA Rec EPA Appr
. **~~Concur** y N N sData Concurrence and Evaluation Report for Lead Certification Year 2015 Certifying Agency Name: Ohio EPA Central Office (1256) Lead PM10 LC FRMIFEM (85129) PQAO Name
: South West O h io PQAO (1455) Quality Assurance Project Plan Approval Date : Collocation Summary

: Number of Number of
PEP Summary Number of Number of Number Colloc Sites Actual of Sites Required Colloc Sites Percent Collocated cv Est CVUB Criteria Met 0
0 100 Analysis Audit Summary

: Number Percent Number Required Submitted Complete Bias Criteria Met 24 66 100 +/-3

. 03 Monitors Recommended for Certification Monitor Exceed. Outlier y Percent Comp. Percent Bias Comp
. I

Routine Data (ug/m"3) AQS Site-10 POC Type **~ ~** **~**Count Count

I Flow Rate Audit --- ------ 39 - 061 - 0040 SLAMS
0 . 003 0 . 000 0 . 020 0 39-061
- 0040 2 SLAMS
0 . 003 0 . 000 0 . 022 0 0 0 97 96 -1 . 27 100 -0 .32 100 Number of Methods PEP Audits Methods Audited Required 0 I Collocation Percent PQAO CVUB Comp
. **~** 100

I **Po';.~ ~**  Number of Audits Submitted I Lead Analysis Crit . Met --- y y 0 Percent Complete Bias 0 Criteria Met I Certification QAPP AQS CA Rec EPA Appr. **~Value C~**  y y y y y y s sUNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY User ID: GYE

Q U ICKLOOK AL L PARAMETERS Report Request ID: 1441535 Report Code: AMP450NC GEOGRAP HI C SELECTIONS Tribal Code State county Site Parameter POC City AQCR UAR CBSA 39 PROTOCOL SELECTIONS Parameter Classification ALL Parameter Method 86101 Duration

CSA EPA Regi on SORT OR DER
I 1 Opt i on Type Option Value

1 Order Column SELECTED OPTIONS MERGE PDF FILES
YES

1 STATE_CODE EVEN T S PR OCESSING EXCLUDE REGIONALLY CONCURRED EVEN T S

2 3 4 5 6 7 AGE N CY ROLE PQAO DATE CRITERIA Start Date End Date 2015 2015 Selection Criteria Page 1 COUNTY_CO D E SITE_ID PARAMETER_CODE POC DATES EDT ID APPLICABLE STANDARDS Standard Description Apr. 29, 2016UNITEDSTATESENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONAGENCYAIRQUALITYSYSTEMQUICKLOOKALLPARAMETERSEXCEPTIONALDATATYPES!EDTDESCRIPTIONI0NOEVENTS1EVENTSEXCLUDED2EVENTSINCLUDED5EVENTSWITHCONCURRENCEEXCLUDEDApr.29,2016UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AIR QUALITY SYSTEM QUICKLOOK ALL PARAMETERS

Apr. 29, 2016 p 0 c

11 1st Max 2nd Max 3rd Max 4th Max Arith. Cert& **t<~** D ura tion Eval **~** Parameter Unit PQAO Year Meth Obs Value Va l ue Value Value Mean Site ID: 39-035-0060 City: Cleveland 86101 PM10-2.5

- Local Conditions Site ID: 39-061 -0040 City: Cincinnati 86101 PM10-2.5

- Local Conditions 86101 PM10-2.5

- Local Co ndi tions County: Cuyahoga Micrograms/cubic meter 1 (LC) 1454 County: Hamilton 2015 176 Micrograms

/ cubic meter 1 1455 2015 173 (LC) Micrograms/cubic meter 2 1455 2015
1 73 (LC) Site ID: 39-121-8001 City: N ot in a city County: Noble 86101 PM10 - 2.5 - Local Conditions Site ID: 39 -135-10 01 City: New Paris 86101 PM10-2.5

- Local Conditions Micrograms/cubic meter 5 (LC) 0745 County: Preble Micrograms/cubic meter 1 (LC) 1455 2015 805 2015 176 Address: E. 14TH & ORANGE 92 75.8 57.3 53.7 49.3 Address: 250 WM. HOWARD TAFT 117 25.1 23.7 20.4 19.3 56 27.3 18
.5
1 7.5 16.0 Address: ST JOHNS ROAD QUAKER CITY 58 23.9 12.1 11.3 10 .6 Address: 6940 OXF ORD GETTYSBURG RD . 106 21.7

1 6.4 13.2 12.1 Note: The * indicates that the mean do es not satisfy summary c riteri a .
Page 2 of 5

19. 75* 24 HOUR 7 .86 24 HOUR 7.99 24 HO UR 5.81*24 HOUR 4. 74* 24 H OUR

0 0 0 0 0PARAMETER 86101 86101 86101 **~1ETHOD** CODE 173 176 805 Note: The * indicates that the mean does not satisfy summary criter ia. UNITED STATES **ENVIRONt~ENTAL**PROTECTION AGENCY AIR QUALITY SYSTEM QUICKLOOK ALL PARAMETERS METHODS USED IN THIS REPORT COLLECTION METHOD ANALYSIS METH OD BGI Inc Model PQ200 PM10-2.5 Sampler Pair Paired Gravimetric Dif feren ce Ther m o Scientific Partisol-Plus Model 2025 Se· Paired Gravimetric IMPROVE IMPROVE Page 3 of 5
Apr. 29, 2016UNITEDSTATESENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONAGENCYAIRQUALITYSYSTEMQUICKLOOKALLPARAMETERSPQAOSUSEDINTHISREPORTIPQAO'"'"c'DEEC'''T'ONI074514541455Note:The*indicatesthatthemeandoesnotsatisfysummarycriteria.NationalParkServiceNorthEastOhioPQAOSouthWestOhioPQAOPage4of5Apr.29,2016UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AIR QUALITY SYSTEM QUICKLOOK ALL PARAMETERS CERTIFICATION EVALUATION AND CONCURRENCE FLAG MEANINGS FLAG MEANING M N s u X y The monitoring organization has revised data from this monitor since the most recent certification letter received from the state. The certifying agency has submitted the certification letter and required summary reports, but the certifying agency and/or EPA has determined that issues regarding the quality of the ambient concentration data cannot be resolved due to data completeness, the lack of performed quality assu rance checks or the results of uncertainty statistics shown in the AMP255 report or the certification and qual ity assurance report. The cert ifying age ncy has submitted the certification letter and required summary reports. A value of "S" conveys no Regional assessment regarding data quality per se . This flag will remain until the Region provides an "N" or "Y" concurrence flag
. uncertified. The certifying agency did not submit a requi re d certification letter and summary reports for this monitor even though the due date has passed, or the state's certification letter specifically did not apply the certification to this monitor. Certification is not required by 40 CFR 58 . 15 and no conditions apply to be the basis for assigning another flag value The certifying agency has submitted
a certification letter, and EPA has no unresolved reservations about data quality (after reviewing

t he letter, the attached summary reports, the amount of quality assurance da ta submitted to AQS, t he quality statistics, an d the highest reported concentrati
o ns) . Note: The • indicates that the mean does not satisfy summary criteria.

Page 5 of 5
Apr. 29, 2016