PM2.5 SIP

Appendix J

Attainment Demonstration

J-1: Annual Standard Attainment Test

J-2: 24-Hour Standard Attainment Test

J-3: Impact Tables
{This page left blank for printing purposes}
1

Appendix J: ATTAINMENT DEMONSTRATION

Calculation of combined impacts and design values are provided in this section. Model input/output and post-processing files have been given in 

Appendix G (or on the accompanying DVD).

J-1: Annual Standard Attainment Test

The annual standard attainment tests for Liberty and Clairton are given in this section. Calculations are based on the steps listed in the attainment 

test methodology section, taken from EPA Modeling Guidance. Below is a key to terms used in the subsequent charts for the attainment tests. 

[Note: Substitute Clairton (CL) FRM for Liberty (LB) FRM for the Clairton tests.]

TERMS

LB_FRMw Liberty FRM weighted average concentration (baseline)

LB_FRMc Liberty FRM concentration, concurrent with speciation samples

LB_FRMf Liberty FRM future projected concentration

Blank Passive blank mass (constant)

Non-Blank Sum of all species but passive blank

OCMmb Organic Carbon Mass by mass balance (FRM minus other species)

OC Organic Carbon (measured)

OCfloor Organic Carbon floor (OC*1.4*0.7)

EC Elemental Carbon (measured)

TotalC Elemental + Organic Carbon (modeled or calculated)

SO4 Sulfate (modeled or measured)

NO3r Retained Nitrate, calculated by EPA using PIT temp and relative humidity

NO3 Nitrate (modeled or measured)

NH4r

Retained (or Indirect) Ammonium, calculated from DON, sulfate, and retained 

nitrate

PBWcalc Particle Bound Water, calculated by polynomial fitted to AIM

DON Degree of Neutralization

Crustal(alt) Crustal Component, calculated from Si, Ti, Ca, and Fe (not Al)

OPP Other Primary PM2.5 (analogous to alternative crustal and A25 from CMAQ)

A25 Primary Unspeciated PM2.5 from CMAQ (analogous to crustal or OPP)
2

Liberty Annual Test – Baseline FRM Values

FRM Quarterly Avgs Quarterly Avgs (3-Year) Weighted Quarterly Avgs

Year Qtr Avg 3-Year Period Qtr Avg Qtr Avg

2000 1Q 20.278 2000-2002 1Q 19.289 1Q 18.278

2000 2Q 21.865 2000-2002 2Q 23.172 2Q 22.097

2000 3Q 20.838 2000-2002 3Q 23.875 3Q 24.426

2000 4Q 20.681 2000-2002 4Q 19.348 4Q 19.192

Year Qtr Avg 3-Year Period Qtr Avg

2001 1Q 19.448 2001-2003 1Q 18.234

2001 2Q 25.600 2001-2003 2Q 22.374

2001 3Q 25.621 2001-2003 3Q 24.588

2001 4Q 21.539 2001-2003 4Q 19.543

Year Qtr Avg 3-Year Period Qtr Avg

2002 1Q 18.141 2002-2004 1Q 17.311

2002 2Q 22.051 2002-2004 2Q 20.746

2002 3Q 25.166 2002-2004 3Q 24.815

2002 4Q 15.825 2002-2004 4Q 18.683

Year Qtr Avg

2003 1Q 17.112

2003 2Q 19.470

2003 3Q 22.977

2003 4Q 21.266

Year Qtr Avg

2004 1Q 16.680

2004 2Q 20.716

2004 3Q 26.301

2004 4Q 18.959
3

Liberty Annual Test – SANDWICH Species Reconstruction

YEAR QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC

2003 4Q 23.0500 3.4310 4.5790 0.4490 0.5510 0.3661 8.0690

2004 1Q 11.8769 0.9600 3.2069 1.2638 0.3931 0.3283 3.1262

2004 2Q 21.0500 2.9277 6.0354 0.0000 0.6315 0.3578 5.7354

2004 3Q 21.6417 2.6967 6.0742 0.0000 0.5482 0.3061 5.6300

2004 4Q 20.6500 2.6758 4.4708 0.5592 0.6600 0.3715 6.5750

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC OCfloor NH4r

1Q 11.8769 0.9600 3.2069 1.2638 0.3931 0.3283 3.1262 3.0636 1.4194

2Q 21.0500 2.9277 6.0354 0.0000 0.6315 0.3578 5.7354 5.6207 2.1597

3Q 21.6417 2.6967 6.0742 0.0000 0.5482 0.3061 5.6300 5.5174 1.8592

4Q 21.8500 3.0534 4.5249 0.5041 0.6055 0.3688 7.3220 7.1756 1.8150

PBW Calculation SO4 NO3r NH4r

 - Calculated from SO4, NO3r, and NH4r 3.2069 1.2638 1.4194

 - NH4r calculated from DON, SO4, NO3r 6.0354 0.0000 2.1597

 - DON > 0.225, low acidity equation 6.0742 0.0000 1.8592

4.5249 0.5041 1.8150

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum PBWcalc

0.5445 0.2146 0.2410 -20574.6078 -130.0236 20704.8009 0.1696 0.9988

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 2.6185

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.2957

0.6612 0.0737 0.2652 -23247.8924 -180.1287 23428.3020 0.2809 1.9228

Methodology:

 - Use measured SO4 and EC

 - Use retained nitrate (calculated)

 - Use calculated indirect NH4 (retained) method for baseline and future

 - Use crustal (alt) for other particulate PM2.5 (OPP)

 - Use calculated particle bound water for baseline and future

 - Degrees of Neutralization (DON) constant from base to future
4

Liberty Annual Test – Relative Compositions

Quarterly Averages

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc Blank

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc

1Q 11.8769 0.5000 11.3769 3.1349 0.9600 3.2069 1.2638 0.3931 1.4194 0.9988

2Q 21.0500 0.5000 20.5500 6.1771 2.9277 6.0354 0.0000 0.6315 2.1597 2.6185

3Q 21.6417 0.5000 21.1417 7.6678 2.6967 6.0742 0.0000 0.5482 1.8592 2.2957

4Q 21.8500 0.5000 21.3500 8.9243 3.0534 4.5249 0.5041 0.6055 1.8150 1.9228

Relative Compositions (fractions of Non-Blank)

FRACT QTR

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc

1Q 1.0000 0.2755 0.0844 0.2819 0.1111 0.0346 0.1248 0.0878

2Q 1.0000 0.3006 0.1425 0.2937 0.0000 0.0307 0.1051 0.1274

3Q 1.0000 0.3627 0.1276 0.2873 0.0000 0.0259 0.0879 0.1086

4Q 1.0000 0.4180 0.1430 0.2119 0.0236 0.0284 0.0850 0.0901

Weighted Quarterly Composition 

WEIGHT QTR LB_FRMw Blank

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 18.2778 0.5000 17.7778 4.898616 1.5001 5.0112 1.9749 0.6142 2.2179 1.5608 0.3283

2Q 22.0970 0.5000 21.5970 6.491846 3.0769 6.3429 0.0000 0.6637 2.2698 2.7519 0.3578

3Q 24.4259 0.5000 23.9259 8.677582 3.0518 6.8741 0.0000 0.6204 2.1040 2.5980 0.3061

4Q 19.1917 0.5000 18.6917 7.813162 2.6732 3.9615 0.4413 0.5301 1.5890 1.6834 0.3688
5

Liberty Annual Test – Quarterly Compositions, Combined Modeled Carbons

Baseline Quarterly Compositions

Baseline (2002) QTR LB_FRMw Blank

NonBlank OCMmb EC TotalC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc DON

Avg 1Q 18.2778 0.5000 17.7778 4.8986 1.5001 6.3987 5.0112 1.9749 0.6142 2.2179 1.5608 0.3283

Avg 2Q 22.0970 0.5000 21.5970 6.4918 3.0769 9.5687 6.3429 0.0000 0.6637 2.2698 2.7519 0.3578

Avg 3Q 24.4259 0.5000 23.9259 8.6776 3.0518 11.7294 6.8741 0.0000 0.6204 2.1040 2.5980 0.3061

Avg 4Q 19.1917 0.5000 18.6917 7.8132 2.6732 10.4864 3.9615 0.4413 0.5301 1.5890 1.6834 0.3688

AVG 20.9981

Modeled Total Carbon (CMAQ - modeled CMAQ equivalent + modeled Liberty nearby)

Baseline 

(2002) QTR CMAQ

CMAQ

Equiv

Liberty 

Nearby TotalC

Avg 1Q 5.1254 1.4167 10.5117 14.2205

Avg 2Q 3.6771 1.8561 9.3809 11.2019

Avg 3Q 4.4407 2.3062 9.8994 12.0339

Avg 4Q 5.0019 1.6817 7.7244 11.0445

Future 

Projected

(2014) QTR CMAQ

CMAQ

Equiv

Liberty 

Nearby TotalC

Avg 1Q 4.6131 1.6111 5.9295 8.9314

Avg 2Q 3.3040 2.0500 5.2880 6.5421

Avg 3Q 3.9889 2.4700 5.5947 7.1136

Avg 4Q 4.5940 1.7786 4.6393 7.4547
6

Liberty Annual Test – RRFs

CMAQ Modeled Species, with ACHD Adjusted Carbon

Baseline (2002) QTR TotalC SO4 NO3 A25

Avg 1Q 14.2205 2.5160 4.1174 2.9545

Avg 2Q 11.2019 6.1574 1.5524 1.8452

Avg 3Q 12.0339 9.6876 0.9486 2.0878

Avg 4Q 11.0445 3.3985 5.5314 2.9253

Future Projected

(2014) QTR TotalC SO4 NO3 A25

Avg 1Q 8.9314 2.1181 3.9782 3.1346

Avg 2Q 6.5421 3.6307 1.3358 2.0315

Avg 3Q 7.1136 5.4068 0.7892 2.3275

Avg 4Q 7.4547 2.7258 5.0980 3.1525

RRFs (Future Projected divided by Baseline)

RRF QTR TotalC SO4 NO3 A25

Ratio 1Q 0.6281 0.8418 0.9662 1.0609

Ratio 2Q 0.5840 0.5897 0.8604 1.1010

Ratio 3Q 0.5911 0.5581 0.8319 1.1148

Ratio 4Q 0.6750 0.8021 0.9216 1.0777
7

Liberty Annual Test – Future Projected and Design Values

Future Projected Compositions

Future Projected

(2014) QTR LB_FRMf Blank

NonBlank PBWcalc NH4r TotalC SO4 NO3r OPP DON

Avg 1Q 14.5383 0.5000 14.0383 1.3027 1.9384 4.0188 4.2186 1.9081 0.6517 0.3283

Avg 2Q 13.5201 0.5000 13.0201 1.6227 1.3384 5.5883 3.7401 0.0000 0.7307 0.3578

Avg 3Q 14.5860 0.5000 14.0860 1.4500 1.1743 6.9336 3.8365 0.0000 0.6916 0.3061

Avg 4Q 14.3708 0.5000 13.8708 1.3477 1.2898 7.0779 3.1774 0.4067 0.5713 0.3688

AVG 14.2538

PBW Calculation SO4 NO3r NH4r

 - Calculated from SO4, NO3r, and NH4r 4.2186 1.9081 1.9384

 - NH4r calculated from DON, SO4, NO3r 3.7401 0.0000 1.3384

 - DON > 0.225, low acidity equation 3.8365 0.0000 1.1743

3.1774 0.4067 1.2898

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5231 0.2366 0.2403 -20513.8060 -119.9254 20633.8929 0.1615 1.3027

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 1.6227

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 1.4500

0.6519 0.0835 0.2646 -23188.0772 -176.1440 23364.4977 0.2765 1.3477

Design Values

Case Year Value

Baseline 2002 21.0

Future Projected 2014 14.3
8

Clairton Annual Test – Baseline FRM Values

FRM Quarterly Avgs Quarterly Avgs (3-Year) Weighted Quarterly Avgs

Year Qtr Avg 3-Year Period Qtr Avg Qtr Avg

2000 1Q 20.278 2000-2002 1Q 19.289 1Q 18.278

2000 2Q 21.865 2000-2002 2Q 23.172 2Q 22.097

2000 3Q 20.838 2000-2002 3Q 23.875 3Q 24.426

2000 4Q 20.681 2000-2002 4Q 19.348 4Q 19.192

Year Qtr Avg 3-Year Period Qtr Avg

2001 1Q 19.448 2001-2003 1Q 18.234

2001 2Q 25.600 2001-2003 2Q 22.374

2001 3Q 25.621 2001-2003 3Q 24.588

2001 4Q 21.539 2001-2003 4Q 19.543

Year Qtr Avg 3-Year Period Qtr Avg

2002 1Q 18.141 2002-2004 1Q 17.311

2002 2Q 22.051 2002-2004 2Q 20.746

2002 3Q 25.166 2002-2004 3Q 24.815

2002 4Q 15.825 2002-2004 4Q 18.683

Year Qtr Avg

2003 1Q 17.112

2003 2Q 19.470

2003 3Q 22.977

2003 4Q 21.266

Year Qtr Avg

2004 1Q 16.680

2004 2Q 20.716

2004 3Q 26.301

2004 4Q 18.959
9

Clairton Annual Test – SANDWICH Species Reconstruction

YEAR QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC

2003 4Q 23.0500 3.4310 4.5790 0.4490 0.5510 0.3661 8.0690

2004 1Q 11.8769 0.9600 3.2069 1.2638 0.3931 0.3283 3.1262

2004 2Q 21.0500 2.9277 6.0354 0.0000 0.6315 0.3578 5.7354

2004 3Q 21.6417 2.6967 6.0742 0.0000 0.5482 0.3061 5.6300

2004 4Q 20.6500 2.6758 4.4708 0.5592 0.6600 0.3715 6.5750

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC OCfloor NH4r

1Q 11.8769 0.9600 3.2069 1.2638 0.3931 0.3283 3.1262 3.0636 1.4194

2Q 21.0500 2.9277 6.0354 0.0000 0.6315 0.3578 5.7354 5.6207 2.1597

3Q 21.6417 2.6967 6.0742 0.0000 0.5482 0.3061 5.6300 5.5174 1.8592

4Q 21.8500 3.0534 4.5249 0.5041 0.6055 0.3688 7.3220 7.1756 1.8150

PBW Calculation SO4 NO3r NH4r

 - Calculated from SO4, NO3r, and NH4r 3.2069 1.2638 1.4194

 - NH4r calculated from DON, SO4, NO3r 6.0354 0.0000 2.1597

 - DON > 0.225, low acidity equation 6.0742 0.0000 1.8592

4.5249 0.5041 1.8150

S Term

N 

Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum PBWcalc

0.5445 0.2146 0.2410 -20574.6078 -130.0236 20704.8009 0.1696 0.9988

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 2.6185

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.2957

0.6612 0.0737 0.2652 -23247.8924 -180.1287 23428.3020 0.2809 1.9228

Methodology:

 - Assume Liberty species compositions are representative of Clairton (but at smaller concentrations)

 - Use measured SO4 and EC

 - Use retained nitrate (calculated)

 - Use calculated indirect NH4 (retained) method for baseline and future

 - Use crustal (alt) for other particulate PM2.5 (OPP)

 - Use calculated particle bound water for baseline and future

 - Degrees of Neutralization (DON) constant from base to future
10

Clairton Annual Test – Relative Compositions

Quarterly Averages (Liberty FRM used to generate compositions)

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc Blank Non-Blank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc

1Q 11.8769 0.5000 11.3769 3.1349 0.9600 3.2069 1.2638 0.3931 1.4194 0.9988

2Q 21.0500 0.5000 20.5500 6.1771 2.9277 6.0354 0.0000 0.6315 2.1597 2.6185

3Q 21.6417 0.5000 21.1417 7.6678 2.6967 6.0742 0.0000 0.5482 1.8592 2.2957

4Q 21.8500 0.5000 21.3500 8.9243 3.0534 4.5249 0.5041 0.6055 1.8150 1.9228

Relative Compositions (fractions of Non-Blank)

FRACT QTR Non-Blank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc

1Q 1.0000 0.2755 0.0844 0.2819 0.1111 0.0346 0.1248 0.0878

2Q 1.0000 0.3006 0.1425 0.2937 0.0000 0.0307 0.1051 0.1274

3Q 1.0000 0.3627 0.1276 0.2873 0.0000 0.0259 0.0879 0.1086

4Q 1.0000 0.4180 0.1430 0.2119 0.0236 0.0284 0.0850 0.0901

Weighted Quarterly Compositions (Clairton weighted FRM with species fractions from Liberty)

WEIGHT QTR CL_FRMw Blank Non-Blank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 13.9271 0.5000 13.4271 3.6998 1.1330 3.7848 1.4916 0.4639 1.6751 1.1788 0.3283

2Q 17.3044 0.5000 16.8044 5.0513 2.3941 4.9353 0.0000 0.5164 1.7661 2.1413 0.3578

3Q 20.9413 0.5000 20.4413 7.4138 2.6073 5.8730 0.0000 0.5300 1.7976 2.2196 0.3061

4Q 14.7063 0.5000 14.2063 5.9382 2.0317 3.0109 0.3354 0.4029 1.2077 1.2794 0.3688
11

Clairton Annual Test – Quarterly Compositions, Combined Modeled Carbons

Baseline Quarterly Compositions

Baseline (2002) QTR CL_FRMw Blank

NonBlank OCMmb EC TotalC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc DON

Avg 1Q 13.9271 0.5000 13.4271 3.6998 1.1330 4.8328 3.7848 1.4916 0.4639 1.6751 1.1788 0.3283

Avg 2Q 17.3044 0.5000 16.8044 5.0513 2.3941 7.4453 4.9353 0.0000 0.5164 1.7661 2.1413 0.3578

Avg 3Q 20.9413 0.5000 20.4413 7.4138 2.6073 10.0211 5.8730 0.0000 0.5300 1.7976 2.2196 0.3061

Avg 4Q 14.7063 0.5000 14.2063 5.9382 2.0317 7.9700 3.0109 0.3354 0.4029 1.2077 1.2794 0.3688

AVG 16.7198

Modeled Total Carbon (CMAQ - modeled CMAQ equivalent + modeled Clairton nearby)

Baseline 

(2002) QTR CMAQ

CMAQ

Equiv

Clairton 

Nearby TotalC

Avg 1Q 5.1254 1.4167 2.0177 5.7265

Avg 2Q 3.6771 1.8561 4.0775 5.8985

Avg 3Q 4.4407 2.3062 7.7318 9.8663

Avg 4Q 5.0019 1.6817 3.9413 7.2615

Future 

Projected

(2014) QTR CMAQ

CMAQ

Equiv

Clairton 

Nearby TotalC

Avg 1Q 4.6131 1.6111 1.5923 4.5943

Avg 2Q 3.3040 2.0500 2.7064 3.9605

Avg 3Q 3.9889 2.4700 4.4092 5.9281

Avg 4Q 4.5940 1.7786 2.4705 5.2859
12

Clairton Annual Test – RRFs

CMAQ Modeled Species, with ACHD Adjusted Carbon

Baseline 

(2002) QTR TotalC SO4 NO3 A25

Avg 1Q 5.7265 2.5160 4.1174 2.9545

Avg 2Q 5.8985 6.1574 1.5524 1.8452

Avg 3Q 9.8663 9.6876 0.9486 2.0878

Avg 4Q 7.2615 3.3985 5.5314 2.9253

Future 

Projected

(2014) QTR TotalC SO4 NO3 A25

Avg 1Q 4.5943 2.1181 3.9782 3.1346

Avg 2Q 3.9605 3.6307 1.3358 2.0315

Avg 3Q 5.9281 5.4068 0.7892 2.3275

Avg 4Q 5.2859 2.7258 5.0980 3.1525

RRFs (Future Projected divided by Baseline)

RRF QTR TotalC SO4 NO3 A25

Ratio 1Q 0.8023 0.8418 0.9662 1.0609

Ratio 2Q 0.6714 0.5897 0.8604 1.1010

Ratio 3Q 0.6008 0.5581 0.8319 1.1148

Ratio 4Q 0.7279 0.8021 0.9216 1.0777
13

Clairton Annual Test – Future Projected and Design Values

Future Projected Compositions

Future Projected

(2014) QTR CL_FRMf Blank

NonBlank PBWcalc NH4r TotalC SO4 NO3r OPP DON

Avg 1Q 11.9447 0.5000 11.4447 0.9839 1.4640 3.8773 3.1862 1.4412 0.4922 0.3283

Avg 2Q 11.2818 0.5000 10.7818 1.2626 1.0414 4.9991 2.9101 0.0000 0.5686 0.3578

Avg 3Q 12.6319 0.5000 12.1319 1.2388 1.0033 6.0211 3.2778 0.0000 0.5909 0.3061

Avg 4Q 11.4645 0.5000 10.9645 1.0243 0.9803 5.8017 2.4149 0.3091 0.4342 0.3688

AVG 11.8307

PBW Calculation SO4 NO3r NH4r

 - Calculated from SO4, NO3r, and NH4r 3.1862 1.4412 1.4640

 - NH4r calculated from DON, SO4, NO3r 2.9101 0.0000 1.0414

 - DON > 0.225, low acidity equation 3.2778 0.0000 1.0033

2.4149 0.3091 0.9803

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5231 0.2366 0.2403 -20513.8060 -119.9254 20633.8929 0.1615 0.9839

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 1.2626

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 1.2388

0.6519 0.0835 0.2646 -23188.0772 -176.1440 23364.4977 0.2765 1.0243

Design Values

Case Year Value

Baseline 2002 16.7

Future Projected 2014 11.8
14

J-2: 24-Hour Standard Attainment Test

The 24-hour attainment tests for Liberty and Clairton are given in this section. Calculations are based on the steps listed in the attainment test 

methodology section, taken from EPA Modeling Guidance. Species reconstruction calculations are similar to the steps used for the annual test. 

However, the analysis is based on modeled and observed high days rather than averages. Below is a key to terms used in the subsequent charts 

for the attainment tests. [Note: Substitute Clairton (CL) FRM for Liberty (LB) FRM for the Clairton tests.]

TERMS

LB_FRMh Liberty FRM baseline high day concentration

LB_FRMc Liberty FRM concentration, concurrent with speciation samples

LB_FRMf Liberty FRM future projected concentration

Blank Passive blank mass (constant)

Non-Blank Sum of all species but passive blank

OCMmb Organic Carbon Mass by mass balance (FRM minus other species)

OC Organic Carbon (measured)

OCfloor Organic Carbon floor (OC*1.4*0.7)

EC Elemental Carbon (measured)

TotalC Elemental + Organic Carbon (modeled or calculated)

SO4 Sulfate (modeled or measured)

NO3r Retained Nitrate, calculated by EPA using PIT temp and relative humidity

NO3 Nitrate (modeled or measured)

NH4r

Retained (or Indirect) Ammonium, calculated from DON, sulfate, and retained 

nitrate

PBWcalc Particle Bound Water, calculated by polynomial fitted to AIM

DON Degree of Neutralization

Crustal(alt) Crustal Component, calculated from Si, Ti, Ca, and Fe (not Al)

OPP Other Primary PM2.5 (analogous to alternative crustal and A25 from CMAQ)

A25 Primary Unspeciated PM2.5 from CMAQ (analogous to OPP)
15

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Baseline Observed (FRM) High Days

Methodology:

 - Identify official 98th percentile value for each year

 - Identify highest day in each quarter equal to or below yearly 98th-percentile

FRM High Days

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

98th-Percentile 64.2 63.9 59.9 66.6 68.5

High Days 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

1Q 46.7 61.9 50.8 60.4 64.2

2Q 64.2 63.9 58.2 66.6 59.6

3Q 48.6 56.4 59.9 60.8 64.2

4Q 60.3 57.5 56.8 64.8 68.5
16

Liberty 24-Hour Test – SANDWICH Species Reconstruction for High Days

Methodology:

 - Identify highest 25% (top 3 days for 1-in-6 monitor) of speciation days, by concurrent FRM value

 - Calculate quarterly averages of high day species

YEAR QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC

2003 4Q 45.5333 7.4367 6.3400 0.6433 1.0333 0.3750 16.8333

2004 1Q 23.7667 3.0633 5.5200 1.7867 0.7400 0.3750 6.2733

2004 2Q 48.8000 7.4633 14.0533 0.0000 1.0367 0.3750 14.1233

2004 3Q 42.6333 6.1533 10.1200 0.0000 0.7300 0.3300 11.5633

2004 4Q 40.6333 7.1033 7.3867 0.0000 1.0000 0.3750 14.3733

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC OCfloor NH4r

1Q 23.7667 3.0633 5.5200 1.7867 0.7400 0.3750 6.2733 6.1479 2.5881

2Q 48.8000 7.4633 14.0533 0.0000 1.0367 0.3750 14.1233 13.8409 5.2700

3Q 42.6333 6.1533 10.1200 0.0000 0.7300 0.3300 11.5633 11.3321 3.3396

4Q 43.0833 7.2700 6.8633 0.3217 1.0167 0.3750 15.6033 15.2913 2.6670

PBW Calculation SO4 NO3r NH4r

 - Calculated from SO4, NO3r, and NH4r 5.5200 1.7867 2.5881

 - NH4r calculated from DON, SO4, NO3r 14.0533 0.0000 5.2700

 - DON > 0.225, low acidity equation 10.1200 0.0000 3.3396

6.8633 0.3217 2.6670

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum PBWcalc

0.5579 0.1806 0.2616 -22883.8778 -134.1956 23018.2516 0.1781 1.7627

0.7273 0.0000 0.2727 -24075.3421 -206.5969 24282.2458 0.3068 5.9290

0.7519 0.0000 0.2481 -21279.4654 -224.6079 21504.3893 0.3160 4.2532

0.6966 0.0326 0.2707 -23858.5521 -194.3152 24053.1608 0.2934 2.8910
17

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Quarterly Compositions for High Days

Methodology:

 - Use measured SO4 and EC

 - Use retained nitrate (calculated)

 - Use calculated indirect NH4 (retained) method for baseline and future

 - Use crustal (alt) for other particulate PM2.5 (OPP)

 - Use calculated particle bound water for baseline and future

 - Degrees of Neutralization (DON) constant from base to future

 - Apply quarterly relative compositions to each quarterly high day in 5-year period

Quarterly Averages

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc Blank

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 23.7667 0.5000 23.2667 7.8059 3.0633 5.5200 1.7867 0.7400 2.5881 1.7627 0.375

2Q 48.8000 0.5000 48.3000 14.5477 7.4633 14.0533 0.0000 1.0367 5.2700 5.9290 0.375

3Q 42.6333 0.5000 42.1333 17.5372 6.1533 10.1200 0.0000 0.7300 3.3396 4.2532 0.330

4Q 43.0833 0.5000 42.5833 21.5537 7.2700 6.8633 0.3217 1.0167 2.6670 2.8910 0.375

Relative Compositions (fractions of Non-Blank)

FRACT QTR

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc

1Q 1.0000 0.3355 0.1317 0.2372 0.0768 0.0318 0.1112 0.0758

2Q 1.0000 0.3012 0.1545 0.2910 0.0000 0.0215 0.1091 0.1228

3Q 1.0000 0.4162 0.1460 0.2402 0.0000 0.0173 0.0793 0.1009

4Q 1.0000 0.5062 0.1707 0.1612 0.0076 0.0239 0.0626 0.0679
18

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Baseline High Day Compositions

Baseline High Day Compositions

2000 QTR LB_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 46.7 0.5 46.2 10.9609 3.5477 1.4694 21.5827 15.4999 6.0828 5.1392 3.5001 0.375

2Q 64.2 0.5 63.7 18.5341 0.0000 1.3672 29.0290 19.1860 9.8429 6.9503 7.8194 0.375

3Q 48.6 0.5 48.1 11.5531 0.0000 0.8334 27.0454 20.0207 7.0247 3.8125 4.8555 0.330

4Q 60.3 0.5 59.8 9.6382 0.4517 1.4277 40.4772 30.2679 10.2093 3.7453 4.0598 0.375

2001 QTR LB_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 61.9 0.5 61.4 14.5671 4.7150 1.9528 28.6835 20.5994 8.0840 6.8300 4.6516 0.375

2Q 63.9 0.5 63.4 18.4468 0.0000 1.3608 28.8923 19.0957 9.7966 6.9176 7.7826 0.375

3Q 56.4 0.5 55.9 13.4266 0.0000 0.9685 31.4312 23.2673 8.1639 4.4308 5.6429 0.330

4Q 57.5 0.5 57.0 9.1869 0.4306 1.3609 38.5820 28.8507 9.7313 3.5700 3.8697 0.375

2002 QTR LB_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 50.8 0.5 50.3 11.9336 3.8626 1.5998 23.4980 16.8754 6.6226 5.5953 3.8107 0.375

2Q 58.2 0.5 57.7 16.7884 0.0000 1.2384 26.2947 17.3789 8.9158 6.2956 7.0829 0.375

3Q 59.9 0.5 59.4 14.2673 0.0000 1.0292 33.3992 24.7241 8.6750 4.7082 5.9962 0.330

4Q 56.8 0.5 56.3 9.0741 0.4253 1.3441 38.1082 28.4964 9.6118 3.5261 3.8222 0.375

2003 QTR LB_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 60.4 0.5 59.9 14.2112 4.5998 1.9051 27.9827 20.0962 7.8865 6.6631 4.5380 0.375

2Q 66.6 0.5 66.1 19.2324 0.0000 1.4187 30.1227 19.9089 10.2138 7.2122 8.1140 0.375

3Q 60.8 0.5 60.3 14.4834 0.0000 1.0448 33.9052 25.0987 8.8065 4.7795 6.0871 0.330

4Q 64.8 0.5 64.3 10.3635 0.4857 1.5351 43.5232 32.5456 10.9776 4.0272 4.3653 0.375

2004 QTR LB_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 64.2 0.5 63.7 15.1128 4.8916 2.0260 29.7579 21.3711 8.3869 7.0858 4.8259 0.375

2Q 59.6 0.5 59.1 17.1957 0.0000 1.2685 26.9327 17.8005 9.1322 6.4484 7.2548 0.375

3Q 64.2 0.5 63.7 15.3001 0.0000 1.1037 35.8169 26.5139 9.3030 5.0490 6.4303 0.330

4Q 68.5 0.5 68.0 10.9598 0.5137 1.6235 46.0276 34.4184 11.6092 4.2589 4.6165 0.375
19

Liberty 24-Hour Test – RRFs

Methodology:

 - Apply modeled RRFs to modeled high day compositions for each quarter in 5 year period

 - Use same SANDWICH species reconstruction for future as used in baseline (indirect NH4, calculated PBW)

Modeled High Day Species

 (Total Carbon = CMAQ - modeled CMAQ equivalent + modeled Liberty nearby)

Baseline 

(2002) QTR SO4 NO3 A25 TOTALC

Avg 1Q 3.2066 4.8787 4.0141 28.9438

Avg 2Q 11.0324 1.3792 2.4018 24.5974

Avg 3Q 15.3512 1.2590 2.7443 25.4487

Avg 4Q 5.5906 7.7099 3.8504 24.9323

Future 

(2014) QTR SO4 NO3 A25 TOTALC

Avg 1Q 2.6960 5.5175 4.5303 15.7763

Avg 2Q 5.4634 2.2522 2.8623 12.4108

Avg 3Q 8.0339 1.4256 3.0960 13.3174

Avg 4Q 3.6355 8.7097 4.4953 13.9551

RRFs (Future Projected divided by Baseline)

RRF QTR SO4 NO3 A25 TOTALC

Ratio 1Q 0.8408 1.1309 1.1286 0.5451

Ratio 2Q 0.4952 1.6330 1.1917 0.5046

Ratio 3Q 0.5233 1.1323 1.1282 0.5233

Ratio 4Q 0.6503 1.1297 1.1675 0.5597
20

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2000)

Future Projected High Day Compositions -

2000

2000 QTR LB_FRMf Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 34.2 0.5 33.7 9.2155 4.0122 1.6584 11.7639 4.1891 2.8515 0.3283

2Q 33.2 0.5 32.7 9.1783 0.0000 1.6293 14.6469 3.2844 3.9821 0.3578

3Q 25.8 0.5 25.3 6.0462 0.0000 0.9402 14.1530 1.8506 2.2851 0.3061

4Q 36.7 0.5 36.2 6.2676 0.5103 1.6669 22.6559 2.4595 2.6705 0.3688

PBW Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

9.2155 4.0122 4.1891

9.1783 0.0000 3.2844

6.0462 0.0000 1.8506

6.2676 0.5103 2.4595

S Term N Term

A 

Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5291 0.2304 0.2405 -20530.9922 -122.7818 20653.9378 0.1637 2.8515

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 3.9821

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.2851

0.6785 0.0552 0.2663 -23360.4076 -187.5453 23548.2420 0.2891 2.6705
21

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2001)

Future Projected High Day Compositions2001

2001 QTR LB_FRMf Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 45.3 0.5 44.8 12.2474 5.3323 2.2040 15.6343 5.5673 3.7897 0.3283

2Q 33.1 0.5 32.6 9.1351 0.0000 1.6217 14.5779 3.2690 3.9634 0.3578

3Q 29.9 0.5 29.4 7.0267 0.0000 1.0926 16.4481 2.1507 2.6556 0.3061

4Q 35.0 0.5 34.5 5.9741 0.4864 1.5888 21.5951 2.3443 2.5454 0.3688

PBW Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

12.2474 5.3323 5.5673

9.1351 0.0000 3.2690

7.0267 0.0000 2.1507

5.9741 0.4864 2.3443

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5291 0.2304 0.2405 -20530.9922 -122.7818 20653.9378 0.1637 3.7897

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 3.9634

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.6556

0.6785 0.0552 0.2663 -23360.4076 -187.5453 23548.2420 0.2891 2.5454
22

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2002)

Future Projected High Day Compositions2002

2002 QTR LB_FRMf Blank Non-Blank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 37.2 0.5 36.7 10.0333 4.3683 1.8055 12.8079 4.5608 3.1046 0.3283

2Q 30.1 0.5 29.6 8.3138 0.0000 1.4759 13.2672 2.9751 3.6070 0.3578

3Q 31.7 0.5 31.2 7.4666 0.0000 1.1611 17.4779 2.2854 2.8219 0.3061

4Q 34.6 0.5 34.1 5.9008 0.4804 1.5693 21.3299 2.3155 2.5142 0.3688

PBW Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

10.0333 4.3683 4.5608

8.3138 0.0000 2.9751

7.4666 0.0000 2.2854

5.9008 0.4804 2.3155

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5291 0.2304 0.2405 -20530.9922 -122.7818 20653.9378 0.1637 3.1046

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 3.6070

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.8219

0.6785 0.0552 0.2663 -23360.4076 -187.5453 23548.2420 0.2891 2.5142
23

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2003)

Future Projected High Day Compositions2003

2003 QTR LB_FRMf Blank Non-Blank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 44.2 0.5 43.7 11.9482 5.2020 2.1501 15.2524 5.4313 3.6971 0.3283

2Q 34.5 0.5 34.0 9.5242 0.0000 1.6907 15.1987 3.4082 4.1322 0.3578

3Q 32.2 0.5 31.7 7.5798 0.0000 1.1786 17.7427 2.3200 2.8647 0.3061

4Q 39.5 0.5 39.0 6.7392 0.5487 1.7923 24.3608 2.6446 2.8714 0.3688

PBW Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

11.9482 5.2020 5.4313

9.5242 0.0000 3.4082

7.5798 0.0000 2.3200

6.7392 0.5487 2.6446

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5291 0.2304 0.2405 -20530.9922 -122.7818 20653.9378 0.1637 3.6971

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 4.1322

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.8647

0.6785 0.0552 0.2663 -23360.4076 -187.5453 23548.2420 0.2891 2.8714
24

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2004)

Future Projected High Day Compositions -

2004

2004 QTR LB_FRMf Blank Non-Blank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 47.0 0.5 46.5 12.7062 5.5320 2.2865 16.2200 5.7758 3.9317 0.3283

2Q 30.9 0.5 30.4 8.5155 0.0000 1.5117 13.5892 3.0473 3.6946 0.3578

3Q 34.0 0.5 33.5 8.0071 0.0000 1.2451 18.7431 2.4509 3.0262 0.3061

4Q 41.7 0.5 41.2 7.1270 0.5803 1.8954 25.7626 2.7967 3.0366 0.3688

PBW Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

12.7062 5.5320 5.7758

8.5155 0.0000 3.0473

8.0071 0.0000 2.4509

7.1270 0.5803 2.7967

S Term N Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5291 0.2304 0.2405 -20530.9922 -122.7818 20653.9378 0.1637 3.9317

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 3.6946

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 3.0262

0.6785 0.0552 0.2663 -23360.4076 -187.5453 23548.2420 0.2891 3.0366
25

Liberty 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Days and Weighted Design Value

Future Projected FRM High Days

High Days 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

1Q 34.2 45.3 37.2 44.2 47.0

2Q 33.2 33.1 30.1 34.5 30.9

3Q 25.8 29.9 31.7 32.2 34.0

4Q 36.7 35.0 34.6 39.5 41.7

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

98th-Percentile 36.7 45.3 37.2 44.2 47.0

3-Year Design Values

3-Year Period Avg

2000-2002 39.7

2001-2003 42.2

2002-2004 42.8

Future Projected Weighted Average

5-Year Period Avg

2000-2004 42
26

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Baseline Observed (FRM) High Days

Methodology:

 - Identify official 98th percentile value for each year

 - Identify highest day in each quarter equal to or below yearly 98th-percentile

FRM High Days

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

98th-Percentile 44.5 50.4 58.8 39.8

High Days 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

1Q 22.9 20.2 24.1 16.7

2Q 44.5 50.4 58.8 26.3

3Q 36.5 39.8 37.0 39.8

4Q 31.5 35.0 21.1 26.4
27

Clairton 24-Hour Test – SANDWICH Species Reconstruction for High Days

Methodology:

 - Identify highest 25% (top 3 days for 1-in-6 monitor) of speciation days, by concurrent FRM value

 - Calculate quarterly averages of high day species

YEAR QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC

2003 4Q 45.5333 7.4367 6.3400 0.6433 1.0333 0.3750 16.8333

2004 1Q 23.7667 3.0633 5.5200 1.7867 0.7400 0.3750 6.2733

2004 2Q 48.8000 7.4633 14.0533 0.0000 1.0367 0.3750 14.1233

2004 3Q 42.6333 6.1533 10.1200 0.0000 0.7300 0.3300 11.5633

2004 4Q 40.6333 7.1033 7.3867 0.0000 1.0000 0.3750 14.3733

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc EC SO4 NO3r Crustal(alt) DON OC OCfloor NH4r

1Q 23.7667 3.0633 5.5200 1.7867 0.7400 0.3750 6.2733 6.1479 2.5881

2Q 48.8000 7.4633 14.0533 0.0000 1.0367 0.3750 14.1233 13.8409 5.2700

3Q 42.6333 6.1533 10.1200 0.0000 0.7300 0.3300 11.5633 11.3321 3.3396

4Q 43.0833 7.2700 6.8633 0.3217 1.0167 0.3750 15.6033 15.2913 2.6670

PBW Calculation SO4 NO3r NH4r

 - Calculated from SO4, NO3r, and NH4r 5.5200 1.7867 2.5881

 - NH4r calculated from DON, SO4, NO3r 14.0533 0.0000 5.2700

 - DON > 0.225, low acidity equation 10.1200 0.0000 3.3396

6.8633 0.3217 2.6670

S Term

N 

Term A Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum PBWcalc

0.5579 0.1806 0.2616 -22883.8778 -134.1956 23018.2516 0.1781 1.7627

0.7273 0.0000 0.2727 -24075.3421 -206.5969 24282.2458 0.3068 5.9290

0.7519 0.0000 0.2481 -21279.4654 -224.6079 21504.3893 0.3160 4.2532

0.6966 0.0326 0.2707 -23858.5521 -194.3152 24053.1608 0.2934 2.8910
28

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Quarterly Compositions for High Days

Methodology:

 - Assume Liberty species compositions are representative of Clairton (but at smaller concentrations)

 - Use measured SO4 and EC

 - Use retained nitrate (calculated)

 - Use calculated indirect NH4 (retained) method for baseline and future

 - Use crustal (alt) for other particulate PM2.5 (OPP)

 - Use calculated particle bound water for baseline and future

 - Degrees of Neutralization (DON) constant from base to future

 - Apply quarterly relative compositions to each quarterly high day in 5-year period

Quarterly Averages (Liberty FRM used to generate compositions)

AVGs QTR LB_FRMc Blank

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 23.7667 0.5000 23.2667 7.8059 3.0633 5.5200 1.7867 0.7400 2.5881 1.7627 0.375

2Q 48.8000 0.5000 48.3000 14.5477 7.4633 14.0533 0.0000 1.0367 5.2700 5.9290 0.375

3Q 42.6333 0.5000 42.1333 17.5372 6.1533 10.1200 0.0000 0.7300 3.3396 4.2532 0.330

4Q 43.0833 0.5000 42.5833 21.5537 7.2700 6.8633 0.3217 1.0167 2.6670 2.8910 0.375

Relative Compositions (fractions of Non-Blank)

FRACT QTR

NonBlank OCMmb EC SO4 NO3r OPP NH4r PBWcalc

1Q 1.0000 0.3355 0.1317 0.2372 0.0768 0.0318 0.1112 0.0758

2Q 1.0000 0.3012 0.1545 0.2910 0.0000 0.0215 0.1091 0.1228

3Q 1.0000 0.4162 0.1460 0.2402 0.0000 0.0173 0.0793 0.1009

4Q 1.0000 0.5062 0.1707 0.1612 0.0076 0.0239 0.0626 0.0679
29

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Baseline High Day Compositions

Baseline High Day Compositions (Clairton weighted FRM with species fractions from Liberty)

2001 QTR CL_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 22.9 0.5 22.4 5.3144 1.7201 0.7124 10.4643 7.5151 2.9492 2.4917 1.6970 0.3750

2Q 44.5 0.5 44.0 12.8022 0.0000 0.9444 20.0514 13.2525 6.7989 4.8008 5.4012 0.3750

3Q 36.5 0.5 36.0 8.6468 0.0000 0.6237 20.2419 14.9843 5.2576 2.8535 3.6341 0.3300

4Q 31.5 0.5 31.0 4.9964 0.2342 0.7401 20.9832 15.6907 5.2924 1.9416 2.1046 0.3750

2002 QTR CL_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 20.2 0.5 19.7 4.6738 1.5128 0.6266 9.2030 6.6093 2.5937 2.1914 1.4925 0.3750

2Q 50.4 0.5 49.9 14.5189 0.0000 1.0710 22.7401 15.0296 7.7106 5.4446 6.1254 0.3750

3Q 39.8 0.5 39.3 9.4395 0.0000 0.6809 22.0974 16.3579 5.7395 3.1150 3.9672 0.3300

4Q 35.0 0.5 34.5 5.5605 0.2606 0.8237 23.3523 17.4623 5.8900 2.1608 2.3422 0.3750

2003 QTR CL_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 24.1 0.5 23.6 5.5991 1.8123 0.7506 11.0249 7.9177 3.1072 2.6252 1.7879 0.3750

2Q 58.8 0.5 58.3 16.9629 0.0000 1.2513 26.5681 17.5596 9.0085 6.3611 7.1565 0.3750

3Q 37.0 0.5 36.5 8.7669 0.0000 0.6324 20.5231 15.1924 5.3306 2.8931 3.6845 0.3300

4Q 21.1 0.5 20.6 3.3202 0.1556 0.4918 13.9437 10.4267 3.5169 1.2902 1.3985 0.3750

2004 QTR CL_FRMh Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC OCMmb EC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 16.7 0.5 16.2 3.8434 1.2440 0.5152 7.5679 5.4350 2.1329 1.8021 1.2273 0.3750

2Q 26.3 0.5 25.8 7.5067 0.0000 0.5537 11.7574 7.7708 3.9866 2.8150 3.1670 0.3750

3Q 39.8 0.5 39.3 9.4395 0.0000 0.6809 22.0974 16.3579 5.7395 3.1150 3.9672 0.3300

4Q 26.4 0.5 25.9 4.1744 0.1956 0.6184 17.5311 13.1094 4.4218 1.6221 1.7583 0.3750
30

Clairton 24-Hour Test – RRFs

Methodology:

 - Apply modeled RRFs to modeled high day compositions for each quarter in 5 year period

 - Use same SANDWICH species reconstruction for future as used in baseline (indirect NH4, calculated PBW)

Modeled High Day Species

 (Total Carbon = CMAQ - modeled CMAQ equivalent + modeled Clairton nearby)

Baseline 

(2002) QTR SO4 NO3 A25 TOTALC

Avg 1Q 3.3923 6.9342 4.2275 8.7011

Avg 2Q 11.1759 2.1162 2.5364 10.9683

Avg 3Q 14.3607 1.7461 2.7087 18.7943

Avg 4Q 5.4649 9.1134 4.2483 12.8309

Future 

(2014) QTR SO4 NO3 A25 TOTALC

Avg 1Q 2.7198 7.0642 4.5243 6.5736

Avg 2Q 5.8094 2.2107 2.9508 6.0933

Avg 3Q 8.1005 1.6617 3.1000 9.6738

Avg 4Q 3.1847 9.9989 4.6728 8.0735

RRFs (Future Projected divided by Baseline)

RRF QTR SO4 NO3 A25 TOTALC

Ratio 1Q 0.8018 1.0187 1.0702 0.7555

Ratio 2Q 0.5198 1.0447 1.1634 0.5555

Ratio 3Q 0.5641 0.9517 1.1445 0.5147

Ratio 4Q 0.5828 1.0972 1.0999 0.6292
31

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2001)

Future Projected High Day Compositions -

2001

2001 QTR CL_FRMf Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 18.4 0.5 17.9 4.2609 1.7524 0.7624 7.9057 1.9071 1.3231 0.3283

2Q 24.7 0.5 24.2 6.6548 0.0000 1.0987 11.1393 2.3814 2.8873 0.3578

3Q 19.8 0.5 19.3 4.8774 0.0000 0.7139 10.4189 1.4929 1.8434 0.3061

4Q 20.1 0.5 19.6 2.9117 0.2569 0.8141 13.2030 1.1483 1.2400 0.3688

PBW 

Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

4.2609 1.7524 1.9071

6.6548 0.0000 2.3814

4.8774 0.0000 1.4929

2.9117 0.2569 1.1483

S Term

N 

Term

A 

Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5380 0.2212 0.2408 -20556.1609 -126.9622 20683.2901 0.1671 1.3231

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 2.8873

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 1.8434

0.6745 0.0595 0.2660 -23334.2825 -185.8331 23520.4028 0.2872 1.2400
32

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2002)

Future Projected High Day Compositions -

2002

2002 QTR CL_FRMf Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 16.3 0.5 15.8 3.7473 1.5411 0.6705 6.9528 1.6772 1.1637 0.3283

2Q 27.9 0.5 27.4 7.5472 0.0000 1.2460 12.6330 2.7007 3.2744 0.3578

3Q 21.6 0.5 21.1 5.3245 0.0000 0.7793 11.3740 1.6298 2.0123 0.3061

4Q 22.3 0.5 21.8 3.2404 0.2859 0.9060 14.6937 1.2780 1.3799 0.3688

PBW 

Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

3.7473 1.5411 1.6772

7.5472 0.0000 2.7007

5.3245 0.0000 1.6298

3.2404 0.2859 1.2780

S Term

N 

Term

A 

Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5380 0.2212 0.2408 -20556.1609 -126.9622 20683.2901 0.1671 1.1637

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 3.2744

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.0123

0.6745 0.0595 0.2660 -23334.2825 -185.8331 23520.4028 0.2872 1.3799
33

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2003)

Future Projected High Day Compositions -

2003

2003 QTR CL_FRMf Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 19.4 0.5 18.9 4.4891 1.8462 0.8033 8.3292 2.0092 1.3940 0.3283

2Q 32.5 0.5 32.0 8.8176 0.0000 1.4557 14.7596 3.1554 3.8256 0.3578

3Q 20.1 0.5 19.6 4.9452 0.0000 0.7238 10.5636 1.5136 1.8690 0.3061

4Q 13.5 0.5 13.0 1.9349 0.1707 0.5410 8.7736 0.7631 0.8240 0.3688

PBW 

Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

4.4891 1.8462 2.0092

8.8176 0.0000 3.1554

4.9452 0.0000 1.5136

1.9349 0.1707 0.7631

S Term

N 

Term

A 

Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5380 0.2212 0.2408 -20556.1609 -126.9622 20683.2901 0.1671 1.3940

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 3.8256

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 1.8690

0.6745 0.0595 0.2660 -23334.2825 -185.8331 23520.4028 0.2872 0.8240
34

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Day Compositions (2004)

Future Projected High Day Compositions -

2004

2004 QTR CL_FRMf Blank

NonBlank SO4 NO3r OPP TotalC NH4r PBWcalc DON

1Q 13.5 0.5 13.0 3.0815 1.2673 0.5514 5.7175 1.3792 0.9569 0.3283

2Q 14.7 0.5 14.2 3.9021 0.0000 0.6442 6.5317 1.3964 1.6930 0.3578

3Q 21.6 0.5 21.1 5.3245 0.0000 0.7793 11.3740 1.6298 2.0123 0.3061

4Q 16.9 0.5 16.4 2.4327 0.2147 0.6801 11.0309 0.9594 1.0360 0.3688

PBW 

Calc SO4 NO3r NH4r

3.0815 1.2673 1.3792

3.9021 0.0000 1.3964

5.3245 0.0000 1.6298

2.4327 0.2147 0.9594

S Term

N 

Term

A 

Term Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Sum Total

0.5380 0.2212 0.2408 -20556.1609 -126.9622 20683.2901 0.1671 0.9569

0.7365 0.0000 0.2635 -23027.7738 -213.2158 23241.3091 0.3195 1.6930

0.7656 0.0000 0.2344 -19730.9031 -235.0839 19966.2763 0.2894 2.0123

0.6745 0.0595 0.2660 -23334.2825 -185.8331 23520.4028 0.2872 1.0360
35

Clairton 24-Hour Test – Future Projected High Days and Weighted Design Value

Future Projected FRM High Days

High Days 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

1Q 18.4 16.3 19.4 13.5

2Q 24.7 27.9 32.5 14.7

3Q 19.8 21.6 20.1 21.6

4Q 20.1 22.3 13.5 16.9

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

98th-Percentile 24.7 27.9 32.5 21.6

3-Year Design Values

3-Year Period Avg

2000-2002 26.3

2001-2003 28.4

2002-2004 27.3

Future Projected Weighted Average

5-Year Period Avg

2000-2004 27
36

J-3: Impact Tables

Impacts by source or source group for the modeled receptor grids are shown in the tables below. 

These tables are given to display annual and 24-hour maximum impacts from individual 

sources/groups for comparative purposes. They do not reflect the exact quarterly and daily 

averaging that were used in the attainment tests given above. Impacts from the equivalent and 

nearby grids were combined on a concurrent basis for use in the attainment tests.

Note: Annual average impacts from different source groups can be summed cumulatively. 24-

hour impacts cannot be summed in the same way due to the possibility that maximums for 

individual source groups can occur on different days.

Near-Field (20 km Domain) Source Group Impacts, CMAQ-Equivalent Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

20 km Background Sources 0.042 0.047 0.4967 0.5507

Allegheny Energy Mitchell Plant* 0.031 0.078 0.3355 0.7945

Clairton Slag 0.006 0.007 0.1118 0.1236

CP Industries 0.007 0.010 0.0964 0.1295

Dura-Bond Industries 0.040 0.062 0.6698 1.0975

Eastman Chemical/Sanyo 0.017 0.022 0.2620 0.3448

GM (Motors Liquidation Company) 0.006 0.006 0.0782 0.0785

Guardian 0.010 0.013 0.1319 0.1712

Kelly Run Sanitation 0.010 0.011 0.1442 0.1565

Kinder Morgan/Marsh Asphalt 0.020 0.024 0.3095 0.3654

Koppers 0.031 0.042 0.4990 0.6652

Liberty Pultrusion <0.001 <0.001 0.0033 0.0041

Mid-Continent Coal & Coke Co. 0.026 0.028 0.4014 0.4293

Nash (Gardner Denver Nash) <0.001 <0.001 0.0030 0.0035

PreCoat 0.002 0.002 0.0219 0.0249

RRI Energy Elrama Plant 0.037 0.066 0.3814 0.8059

UPMC McKeesport 0.001 0.001 0.0165 0.0202

US Steel Clairton Batteries 0.200 0.203 2.9571 2.9988

US Steel Clairton Quenches 0.051 0.052 0.6344 0.6433

US Steel Clairton Combustion 

Stacks 0.038 0.039 0.4996 0.5066

US Steel Clairton PEC Baghouses 0.051 0.051 0.6193 0.6268

US Steel Clairton Boilers 0.022 0.016 0.3005 0.2120

US Steel Clairton Fugitives 

(Ambient) 0.165 0.174 2.4362 2.5828

US Steel Edgar Thomson 0.366 0.273 5.8904 4.3659

US Steel Irvin 0.109 0.104 1.5343 1.4875

* Allegheny Energy Mitchell Plant lies just outside the 20 km domain and was modeled as part of 

the 150 km domain. It is included here for comparison to other nearby sources.
37

Distant (150 km Domain) Source Group Impacts, CMAQ-Equivalent Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Allegheny Valley (Allegheny Co.) 0.028 0.031 0.375 0.402

Armstrong County 0.002 0.002 0.025 0.028

Beaver County 0.009 0.010 0.154 0.175

Butler County 0.008 0.008 0.175 0.178

EGUs 0.070 0.212 0.590 0.961

Fayette County 0.006 0.007 0.097 0.122

Greene County 0.013 0.013 0.090 0.093

Lawrence County 0.012 0.016 0.235 0.276

Ohio Background 0.016 0.016 0.194 0.189

Ohio Valley (Allegheny Co.) 0.013 0.015 0.178 0.208

Urban Pittsburgh (Allegheny Co.) 0.027 0.029 0.361 0.427

Washington County 0.036 0.036 0.333 0.374

Westmoreland County 0.034 0.035 0.286 0.316

Western Suburban (Allegheny 

Co.) 0.009 0.010 0.095 0.111

West Virginia Panhandle 0.247 0.212 3.037 2.480
38

US Steel Clairton Works Source Group Impacts - Liberty Nearby Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Batteries 1-3 0.089 0.089 1.728 1.728

Batteries 7-9 0.089 --- 1.601 ---

Batteries 13-15 0.099 0.099 1.637 1.637

Batteries 19-20 0.087 0.085 1.610 1.557

B Battery 0.007 0.006 0.356 0.298

C Battery --- 0.021 --- 0.845

Quench 1 1.410 1.207 19.550 16.764

Quench 3 1.400 --- 20.010 ---

Quench 5 1.450 0.111 18.875 1.679

Quench 7 0.582 0.110 6.894 1.543

Quench B 0.848 0.848 12.897 12.897

Quench C --- 0.076 --- 1.513

Combustion Stack 1 0.016 0.016 0.241 0.241

Combustion Stack 2 0.024 0.024 0.369 0.369

Combustion Stack 3 0.017 0.017 0.231 0.231

Combustion Stack 7 0.013 --- 0.187 ---

Combustion Stack 8 0.012 --- 0.182 ---

Combustion Stack 9 0.013 --- 0.169 ---

Combustion Stack 13 0.015 0.015 0.155 0.155

Combustion Stack 14 0.015 0.015 0.155 0.155

Combustion Stack 15 0.017 0.017 0.157 0.157

Combustion Stack 19 0.020 0.011 0.195 0.105

Combustion Stack 20 0.018 0.018 0.175 0.175

Combustion Stack B 0.013 0.007 0.179 0.096

Combustion Stack C --- 0.010 --- 0.108

PEC Baghouse 1-3 0.022 0.022 0.281 0.281

PEC Baghouse 7-9 0.024 --- 0.309 ---

PEC Baghouse 13-15 0.047 0.047 0.485 0.485

PEC Baghouse 19-20 0.053 0.053 0.574 0.574

PEC Baghouse B 0.159 0.099 1.708 1.061

PEC Baghouse C --- 0.029 --- 0.399

Boilers 0.199 0.199 2.001 2.001

Material Handling 0.149 0.126 1.223 1.090

Industrial Roads 0.012 0.012 0.140 0.140

Mobile Sources 0.325 0.184 3.632 2.056

Coke/Coal Transfer 0.047 0.060 0.435 0.560

Miscellaneous 0.015 0.015 0.180 0.180
39

US Steel Clairton Works Source Group Impacts - Clairton Nearby Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Batteries 1-3 0.048 0.048 0.941 0.941

Batteries 7-9 0.043 --- 0.877 ---

Batteries 13-15 0.043 0.043 1.023 1.023

Batteries 19-20 0.046 0.044 1.228 1.188

B Battery 0.004 0.004 0.221 0.185

C Battery --- 0.013 --- 0.624

Quench 1 0.744 0.638 17.261 14.801

Quench 3 0.714 --- 16.359 ---

Quench 5 0.439 0.015 9.424 0.606

Quench 7 0.139 0.014 4.031 0.540

Quench B 0.115 0.115 4.188 4.188

Quench C --- 0.014 --- 0.487

Combustion Stack 1 0.006 0.006 0.151 0.151

Combustion Stack 2 0.009 0.009 0.222 0.222

Combustion Stack 3 0.005 0.005 0.129 0.129

Combustion Stack 7 0.005 --- 0.125 ---

Combustion Stack 8 0.005 --- 0.119 ---

Combustion Stack 9 0.004 --- 0.090 ---

Combustion Stack 13 0.002 0.002 0.065 0.065

Combustion Stack 14 0.002 0.002 0.065 0.065

Combustion Stack 15 0.002 0.002 0.058 0.058

Combustion Stack 19 0.003 0.002 0.093 0.050

Combustion Stack 20 0.003 0.003 0.082 0.082

Combustion Stack B 0.004 0.002 0.137 0.073

Combustion Stack C --- 0.003 --- 0.071

PEC Baghouse 1-3 0.008 0.008 0.207 0.207

PEC Baghouse 7-9 0.008 --- 0.215 ---

PEC Baghouse 13-15 0.017 0.017 0.456 0.456

PEC Baghouse 19-20 0.017 0.017 0.446 0.446

PEC Baghouse B 0.032 0.020 0.713 0.443

PEC Baghouse C --- 0.010 --- 0.219

Boilers 0.017 0.017 0.630 0.630

Material Handling 0.021 0.015 0.692 0.591

Industrial Roads 0.007 0.007 0.260 0.260

Mobile Sources 0.065 0.037 2.690 1.523

Coke/Coal Transfer 0.069 0.080 1.361 1.705

Miscellaneous 0.004 0.004 0.075 0.075
40

Other Near-Field Source Group Impacts, Liberty Nearby Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

20 km Background Sources 0.020 0.022 0.239 0.266

AKJ Industries 0.001 0.001 0.008 0.008

Allegheny Energy Mitchell Plant* 0.045 0.042 0.364 0.473

Clairton Slag 0.016 0.016 0.247 0.255

CP Industries 0.016 0.022 0.179 0.240

Dura-Bond Industries 0.048 0.073 0.935 1.540

Eastman Chemical/Sanyo 0.024 0.032 0.244 0.322

ELG Metals 0.010 0.010 0.217 0.217

GM (Motors Liquidation Company) 0.004 0.004 0.044 0.045

Guardian 0.014 0.019 0.204 0.266

Jefferson Regional Med. Ctr. <0.001 <0.001 0.009 0.009

Kelly Run Sanitation 0.011 0.012 0.247 0.267

Kinder Morgan/Marsh Asphalt 0.011 0.001 0.170 0.023

Koppers 0.132 0.174 1.133 1.504

Liberty Pultrusion 0.000 0.000 0.004 0.005

Mid-Continent Coal & Coke Co. 0.040 0.043 0.365 0.389

Mon Valley Transportation Ctr. 0.219 0.219 1.347 1.347

Nash (Gardner Denver Nash) 0.027 0.027 0.270 0.270

Penn Coil 0.001 0.001 0.006 0.006

PreCoat 0.002 0.002 0.032 0.037

RRI Energy Elrama Plant 0.137 0.111 2.096 1.464

UPMC McKeesport 0.001 0.001 0.018 0.022

US Steel Edgar Thomson 0.209 0.201 4.108 3.978

US Steel Irvin 0.104 0.099 1.937 1.846

* Allegheny Energy Mitchell Plant lies just outside the 20 km domain and was modeled as part of 

the 150 km domain. It is included here for comparison to other nearby sources.
41

Other Near-Field Source Group Impacts, Clairton Nearby Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

20 km Background Sources 0.010 0.011 0.164 0.180

AKJ Industries <0.001 <0.001 0.003 0.003

Allegheny Energy Mitchell Plant* 0.074 0.058 0.595 0.451

Clairton Slag 0.061 0.063 0.713 0.736

CP Industries 0.002 0.003 0.046 0.061

Dura-Bond Industries 0.008 0.013 0.133 0.220

Eastman Chemical/Sanyo 0.073 0.096 0.773 1.013

ELG Metals 0.001 0.001 0.017 0.017

GM (Motors Liquidation Company) 0.001 0.001 0.022 0.022

Guardian 0.029 0.038 0.277 0.360

Jefferson Regional Med. Ctr. <0.001 <0.001 0.008 0.008

Kelly Run Sanitation 0.018 0.019 0.212 0.229

Kinder Morgan/Marsh Asphalt 0.004 0.001 0.087 0.010

Koppers 0.029 0.039 0.702 0.934

Liberty Pultrusion <0.001 <0.001 0.002 0.002

Mid-Continent Coal & Coke Co. 0.042 0.045 1.235 1.319

Mon Valley Transportation Ctr. 0.014 0.014 0.258 0.258

Nash (Gardner Denver Nash) 0.083 0.083 0.651 0.651

Penn Coil <0.001 <0.001 0.004 0.004

PreCoat 0.001 0.001 0.008 0.008

RRI Energy Elrama Plant 0.233 0.178 2.062 1.540

UPMC McKeesport <0.001 <0.001 0.005 0.006

US Steel Edgar Thomson 0.135 0.130 3.310 3.164

US Steel Irvin 0.039 0.037 0.690 0.658

* Allegheny Energy Mitchell Plant lies just outside the 20 km domain and was modeled as part of 

the 150 km domain. It is included here for comparison to other nearby sources.
42

Distant Source Group Impacts, Liberty Nearby Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Allegheny Valley (Allegheny Co.) 0.025 0.026 0.358 0.373

Armstrong County 0.002 0.002 0.024 0.028

Beaver County 0.008 0.009 0.147 0.165

Butler County 0.007 0.008 0.172 0.176

EGUs (2002 Added Condensibles)* 0.464 --- 3.044 ---

EGUs 0.073 0.382 0.597 1.268

Fayette County 0.007 0.008 0.104 0.130

Greene County 0.013 0.013 0.092 0.097

Lawrence County 0.011 0.015 0.225 0.262

Ohio Background 0.015 0.015 0.209 0.203

Ohio Valley (Allegheny Co.) 0.011 0.013 0.129 0.155

Urban Pittsburgh (Allegheny Co.) 0.020 0.022 0.312 0.386

Washington County 0.046 0.046 0.461 0.575

Western Suburban (Allegheny Co.) 0.007 0.005 0.083 0.055

Westmoreland County 0.041 0.039 0.282 0.335

West Virginia Panhandle 0.232 0.200 2.191 1.788

* The added baseline (2002) EGU condensibles were modeled as a separate source to examine 

the impacts from these emissions. Any corrections made to the future case EGUs are included 

as part of the EGUs source group.
43

Distant Source Group Impacts, Clairton Nearby Receptor Averages

Source Group

Baseline

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future 

Annual 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Baseline

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Future

24-Hour 

Maximum 

Impacts 

(μg/m3)

Allegheny Valley (Allegheny Co.) 0.021 0.022 0.325 0.340

Armstrong County 0.001 0.001 0.023 0.026

Beaver County 0.008 0.009 0.142 0.156

Butler County 0.006 0.007 0.154 0.163

EGUs (2002 Added Condensibles)* 0.425 --- 3.220 ---

EGUs 0.077 0.359 1.192 1.262

Fayette County 0.007 0.008 0.106 0.134

Greene County 0.015 0.014 0.106 0.100

Lawrence County 0.011 0.014 0.208 0.241

Ohio Background 0.015 0.014 0.203 0.198

Ohio Valley (Allegheny Co.) 0.009 0.011 0.138 0.160

Urban Pittsburgh (Allegheny Co.) 0.015 0.017 0.263 0.299

Washington County 0.055 0.051 0.524 0.463

Western Suburban (Allegheny Co.) 0.007 0.005 0.111 0.078

Westmoreland County 0.046 0.039 0.310 0.275

West Virginia Panhandle 0.233 0.201 2.468 2.022

* The added baseline (2002) EGU condensibles were modeled as a separate source to examine 

the impacts from these emissions. Any corrections made to the future case EGUs are included 

as part of the EGUs source group.