TSD VisibilityTables for AZ RH FIP for Three Facilities, July 2012

created on 2012-07-02; updated 07-15

Includes mid- and late June modeling runs:

 Cholla Ctrl2_R2; Coronado Base_R_S, ctrl1_rs, and ctrl2_rs, Ctrl5_R_S, and ctrl6_rs

This is updated relative to NPR tables; has some minor cost corrections for Apache SNCR and SCR,

 and uses 22nd high instead of 23rd high for Coronado base_q, ctrl1_rs, ctrl2_rs, ctrl5_rs, ctrl6_rs

 to be consistent with all the other results. Also includes some late results for Bosque del Apache area.

98th percentile delta deciviews, all 2001-2003 days together, visibility method 8b

No rounding of intermediate dv or $

Table size (cols X rows) This spreadsheet links to:

5 x 17 AEPCO Apache aep_az_unit2-3_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots2.xls

4 x 21 APS Cholla cho_az_unit2-4_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls

6 x 25 SRP Coronado srp_az_unit1-2_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls

more SRP CoronadoCoronado_modrev3_n822_visx.xlsx

$/yr, millions EGU BART Costs_Apache_Cholla_Coronado_FINAL2.xlsx

Ndays > 0.5, 1.0: AZRHFIP_TSD_Apache_visx.xlsx (&c for Cholla & Coronado)

AEPCO Apache

Base Improvements

UNC name Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

Pre-LNB NOx u.2 Post-LNB 2, LNB 3 Post-LNB 2, SNCR

Pre-LNB 2, 

SCR+H2SO4

Apache Units 2 and 3: EPA's Visibility Improvement from NOx Controls

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r ctrl3s

Class I Area Baseline impact (dv) Improvement from 

LNB (dv)

Improvement from 

SNCR (dv)

Improvement from 

SCR (dv)

Chiricahua NM 3.41 0.44 0.82 1.51

Chiricahua WA 3.46 0.53 1.00 1.59

Galiuro WA 2.22 0.39 0.65 1.10

Gila WA 0.63 0.14 0.22 0.37

Mazatzal WA 0.28 0.05 0.09 0.14

Mount Baldy WA 0.28 0.07 0.11 0.18

Saguaro NP 2.49 0.38 0.66 1.16

Sierra Ancha WA 0.29 0.06 0.10 0.14

Superstition WA 0.61 0.10 0.19 0.31

Cumulative dv 13.67 2.14 3.83 6.51

# areas >= 0.5 6 1 4 4

Number of days >= 0.5 dv 128 10 23 42

Number of days >= 1.0 dv 75 12 25 40

$/max dv, millions $4.8 $6.0 $8.2

$/cumulative dv, millions $1.2 $1.6 $2.0

Max 3.46 0.53 1.00 1.59

Max area Chiricahua WA Chiricahua WA Chiricahua WA Chiricahua WA

$/yr, millions $2.6 $6.0 $13.0

$2,550,391 $5,971,695 $13,034,430
APS Cholla

Base Improvements

UNC name Rev Base Ctrl1_R Ctrl2_R2

PostLNB SO2cor

Post-LNB SNCR 

SO2c

Post-LNB SCR 

SO2c

Cholla Units 2, 3, and 4: EPA's Visibility Improvement From NOx Controls

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r2

Class I Area Baseline impact (dv) Improvement from 

SNCR (dv)

Improvement from 

SCR (dv)

Capitol Reef NP 1.46 0.27 0.76

Galiuro WA 0.45 0.05 0.14

Gila WA 0.70 0.09 0.22

Grand Canyon NP 2.22 0.37 1.06

Mazatzal WA 1.19 0.16 0.43

Mesa Verde NP 1.34 0.26 0.70

Mount Baldy WA 1.21 0.27 0.52

Petrified Forest NP 4.53 0.47 1.34

Pine Mountain WA 0.85 0.12 0.31

Saguaro NP 0.30 0.02 0.05

Sierra Ancha WA 1.36 0.20 0.51

Superstition WA 1.27 0.17 0.51

Sycamore Canyon WA 1.42 0.27 0.68

Cumulative dv 18.30 2.71 7.21

# areas >= 0.5 11 0 8

Number of days >= 0.5 dv 252 7 21

Number of days >= 1.0 dv 213 8 29

$/max dv, millions $17.8 $20.8

$/cumulative dv, millions $3.1 $3.8

Max 4.53 0.47 1.34

Max area Petrified Forest NP Petrified Forest NP Petrified Forest NP

$/yr, millions $8.4 $27.7

$/yr $8,436,046 $27,736,569

SRP Coronado

Base Improvements

UNC name base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs

LNB; 

SCR.08w/H2SO4 SNCR; SCR.08 SCR.05; SCR.08 SCR.05 w/H2SO4

Coronado Units 1 and 2: EPA's Visibility Improvement From NOx Controls

base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs

Class I Area Baseline impact (dv) Improvement from 

SNCR on unit 1 (dv)

Improvement from 

SCR .05 on unit 1 

(dv)

Improvement from 

SCR .05 on both (dv)

Bosque del Apache * 0.47 0.08 0.20 0.23

Bandelier NM 0.37 0.07 0.18 0.20

Chiricahua NM 0.20 0.03 0.07 0.08

Chiricahua WA 0.21 0.03 0.07 0.09

Galiuro WA 0.20 0.02 0.08 0.09
Gila WA 1.23 0.22 0.59 0.66

Grand Canyon NP 0.24 0.03 0.09 0.11

Mazatzal WA 0.20 0.01 0.06 0.07

Mesa Verde NP 0.40 0.07 0.19 0.20

Mount Baldy WA 0.87 0.16 0.42 0.44

Petrified Forest NP 1.22 0.17 0.47 0.56

Pine Mountain WA 0.14 0.02 0.04 0.05

Saguaro NP 0.12 0.01 0.03 0.04

San Pedro Parks WA 0.54 0.11 0.28 0.30

Sierra Ancha WA 0.24 0.03 0.06 0.07

Superstition WA 0.21 0.02 0.06 0.06

Sycamore Canyon WA 0.16 0.01 0.05 0.06

Cumulative dv 6.54 1.02 2.74 3.07

# areas >= 0.5 4 0 1 2

Number of days >= 0.5 dv 28 6 16 18

Number of days >= 1.0 dv 10 2 8 8

$/max dv, millions $17.7 $16.3 $15.0

$/cumulative dv, millions $3.9 $3.5 $3.2

* Bosque del Apache is NOT included in cumulate totals above: simulations were not part of EPA decision-making for NPRM

Max 1.23 0.22 0.59 0.66

Max area Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA

$/yr, millions $3.9 $9.6 $9.9

$/yr $3,923,430 $9,634,654 $9,907,100

Bosque del Apache inadvertently omitted

Costs *including* that for unit 2 SCR 0.08 llb/MMBtu

Cumulative dv 6.54 1.02 2.74 3.07

# areas >= 0.5 4 0 1 2

$/max dv, millions $59.8 $32.2 $29.2

$/cumulative dv, millions $13.1 $6.9 $6.3

Max 1.23 0.22 0.59 0.66

Max area Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA

$/yr, millions $13.3 $19.0 $19.3

$/yr $13,284,134 $18,995,358 $19,267,804
finalwithplots2.xls

finalwithplots.xls

finalwithplots.xls

o_FINAL2.xlsx

 Cholla & Coronado)

Impacts

Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

links to aep_az_unit2-3_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots2.xls

vm8b, All Years p98 ddv

Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

3.409 2.973 2.591 1.898

3.464 2.932 2.466 1.871

2.219 1.826 1.569 1.120

0.629 0.493 0.413 0.255

0.277 0.229 0.190 0.137

0.282 0.217 0.170 0.100

2.493 2.117 1.836 1.331

0.287 0.229 0.188 0.147

0.612 0.512 0.419 0.300

<--- links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Apache_visx.xlsx

Costs

EGU BART Costs_Apache_Cholla_Coronado_FINAL2.xlsx

unit LNB SNCR SCR

2 $1,269,566 $2,829,359 $6,407,583

3 $1,280,825 $3,142,336 $6,626,847
Impacts

Rev Base Ctrl1_R Ctrl2_R2

links to cho_az_unit2-4_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls

vm8b, All Years p98 ddv

Rev Base CTRL1_R ctrl2_r2

1.460 1.191 0.698

0.446 0.400 0.309

0.701 0.614 0.484

2.224 1.850 1.163

1.192 1.031 0.763

1.338 1.083 0.634

1.214 0.949 0.698

4.528 4.055 3.192

0.845 0.725 0.537

0.299 0.278 0.248

1.360 1.165 0.853

1.266 1.099 0.761

1.424 1.151 0.745

<--- links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Cholla_visx.xlsx

Costs, Total Cost/year

EGU BART Costs_Apache_Cholla_Coronado_FINAL2.xlsx

unit SNCR SCR

2 $2,544,307 $8,113,266

3 $2,607,329 $8,842,201

4 $3,284,409 $10,781,102

ctrl6_rs

SCR -90% 

w/H2SO4 links to srp_az_unit1-2_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls, and to coronado_sjbmod.xlsx

vm8b, All Years p98 ddv

ctrl6_rs

Improvement from 

SCR -90% on both 

(dv) base_q Base Base_R Ctrl1-R Ctrl-2 Ctrl-5

0.25 0.725

0.22 0.562 0.480 0.365 0.293 0.184 0.160

0.09 0.292 0.248 0.191 0.161 0.125 0.115

0.09 0.307 0.264 0.201 0.172 0.120 0.112

0.09 0.274 0.254 0.193 0.171 0.108 0.102
0.73 1.829 1.546 1.201 0.978 0.605 0.531

0.12 0.351 0.301 0.233 0.200 0.144 0.128

0.08 0.274 0.230 0.197 0.181 0.130 0.121

0.23 0.595 0.503 0.390 0.319 0.203 0.180

0.50 1.280 1.076 0.849 0.688 0.444 0.389

0.63 1.707 1.420 1.168 0.998 0.695 0.631

0.06 0.193 0.168 0.139 0.126 0.098 0.092

0.04 0.160 0.143 0.112 0.098 0.079 0.073

0.34 0.825 0.693 0.526 0.421 0.252 0.221

0.08 0.343 0.295 0.236 0.203 0.167 0.161

0.07 0.274 0.235 0.202 0.182 0.146 0.134

0.07 0.221 0.195 0.159 0.149 0.102 0.099

3.43 9.49 8.05 6.36 5.34 3.60 3.25

2 4

20 <--- links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Coronado_visx.xlsx

10

$13.5

$2.9

n-making for NPRM

0.73 max 1.829 1.546 1.201 0.998 0.695 0.631

Gila WA

$9.9 ?

$9,907,100 ?

Costs

EGU BART Costs_Apache_Cholla_Coronado_FINAL2.xlsx

unit SNCR SCR.05/.08 SCR.05

1 $3,923,430 $9,634,654 $9,634,654

2 $9,360,704 $9,360,704 $9,633,149

2 to 0.08 $0 $0 $272,445

s, and to coronado_sjbmod.xlsx

benefits relative to Base_R

base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs Ctrl_1_R Ctrl-2 Ctrl-5

0.466 0.382 0.268 0.232 0.212

0.372 0.303 0.188 0.172 0.151 0.072 0.181 0.205

0.197 0.164 0.131 0.119 0.108 0.030 0.066 0.076

0.206 0.176 0.135 0.120 0.112 0.029 0.081 0.089

0.198 0.176 0.117 0.109 0.104 0.022 0.085 0.091
1.226 1.004 0.636 0.566 0.493 0.223 0.596 0.670

0.238 0.204 0.145 0.130 0.12 0.033 0.089 0.105

0.199 0.188 0.142 0.133 0.124 0.016 0.067 0.076

0.402 0.331 0.211 0.198 0.173 0.071 0.187 0.210

0.871 0.709 0.456 0.430 0.376 0.161 0.405 0.460

1.217 1.049 0.744 0.662 0.587 0.170 0.473 0.537

0.144 0.129 0.102 0.097 0.088 0.013 0.041 0.047

0.116 0.102 0.084 0.076 0.072 0.014 0.033 0.039

0.535 0.430 0.259 0.231 0.198 0.105 0.274 0.305

0.243 0.213 0.182 0.175 0.167 0.033 0.069 0.075

0.211 0.191 0.156 0.149 0.141 0.020 0.056 0.068

0.164 0.153 0.110 0.100 0.094 0.010 0.057 0.060

6.54 5.52 3.80 3.47 3.11 1.02 2.76 3.11

4 0 1 2

17.5938547 16.1655272 14.7867158

3.83897222 3.49081674 3.18249264

1.226 1.049 0.744 0.662 0.587 0.223 0.596 0.670 Max

Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Max area

$3.9 $9.6 $9.9 $/yr, millions

$3,923,430 $9,634,654 $9,907,100 $/yr


Max area

$/yr, millions
TSD Visibility Tables for AZ RH FIP for Three Facilities, July 2012

Includes mid- and late June modeling runs:

 Cholla Ctrl2_R2; Coronado Base_R_S, ctrl1_rs, and ctrl2_rs, Ctrl5_R_S, and ctrl6_rs

This is updated relative to NPR tables; has some minor cost corrections for Apache SNCR and SCR,

 and uses 22nd high instead of 23rd high for Coronado base_q, ctrl1_rs, ctrl2_rs, ctrl5_rs, ctrl6_rs

 to be consistent with all the other results.

Number of days per year over 0.5 dv, visibility method 8b

Table size (cols X rows) This spreadsheet links to:

5 x 12 AEPCO Apache AZRHFIP_TSD_Apache_visx.xlsx

4 x 16 APS Cholla AZRHFIP_TSD_Cholla_visx.xlsx

6 x 20 SRP CoronadoAZRHFIP_TSD_Coronado_visx.xlsx

more SRP Coronado Coronado_modrev3_visx.xlsx

bosq SRP Coronado Coronado_bosq_n822_visx.xlsx

AEPCO Apache

Base Improvements

UNC name Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

Pre-LNB 

NOx u.2

Post-LNB 2, 

LNB 3 

Post-LNB 2, 

SNCR

Pre-LNB 2, 

SCR+H2SO

Apache Units 2 and 3: EPA's Visibility Improvement Days From NOx Controls

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r ctrl3s

Class I Area Baseline 

impact (days)

Improvement 

from LNB 

(days)

Improvement 

from SNCR 

(days)

Improvement 

from SCR 

(days)

Chiricahua NM 128 10 21 42

Chiricahua WA 116 8 23 39

Galiuro WA 46 7 10 20

Gila WA 12 5 8 11

Mazatzal WA 3 2 3 3

Mount Baldy WA 2 1 1 2

Saguaro NP 80 6 13 19

Sierra Ancha WA 2 1 1 2

Superstition WA 9 2 5 8

Cumulative #days >= 0.5 398 41 85 146

Max 127.67 9.67 22.67 42.00

Max areaChiricahua NMChiricahua NMChiricahua WAChiricahua NM
APS Cholla

Base Improvements

UNC name Rev Base Ctrl1_R Ctrl2_R2

PostLNB 

SO2cor

Post-LNB 

SNCR 

SO2c

Post-LNB 

SCR SO2c

Cholla Units 2, 3, and 4: EPA's Visibility Improvement Days From NOx Controls

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r2

Class I Area Baseline 

impact (days)

Improvement 

from SNCR 

(days)

Improvement 

from SCR 

(days)

Capitol Reef NP 19 1 8

Galiuro WA 5 1 3

Gila WA 17 4 10

Grand Canyon NP 28 3 9

Mazatzal WA 35 5 16

Mesa Verde NP 33 7 21

Mount Baldy WA 29 4 14

Petrified Forest NP 252 6 20

Pine Mountain WA 19 4 11

Saguaro NP 4 2 3

Sierra Ancha WA 41 5 16

Superstition WA 26 3 10

Sycamore Canyon WA 24 5 12

Cumulative #days >= 0.5 530 50 152

Max 252.00 7.33 21.00

Max areaPetrified Forest NP Mesa Verde NPMesa Verde NP

SRP Coronado

Base Improvements

UNC name base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs

LNB; 

SCR.08w/H

2SO4

SNCR; 

SCR.08

SCR.05; 

SCR.08

SCR.05 

w/H2SO4

Coronado Units 1 and 2: EPA's Visibility Improvement Days From NOx Controls

base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs

Class I Area Baseline 

impact (days)

Improvement 

from SNCR 

on unit 1 

(days)

Improvement 

from SCR 

.05 on unit 1 

(days)

Improvement 

from SCR 

.05 on both 

(days)

Improvement 

from SCR -

90% on both 

(days)

Bosque del Apache * 6 1 5 5 6
Bandelier NM 3 2 3 3 3

Chiricahua NM 1 1 1 1 1

Chiricahua WA 2 1 2 2 2

Galiuro WA 2 1 1 2 2

Gila WA 27 6 16 18 20

Grand Canyon NP 3 1 2 2 3

Mazatzal WA 1 1 1 1 1

Mesa Verde NP 6 1 5 6 6

Mount Baldy WA 17 2 12 13 15

Petrified Forest NP 28 4 13 15 18

Pine Mountain WA 0 0 0 0 0

Saguaro NP 1 0 0 1 1

San Pedro Parks WA 8 4 8 8 8

Sierra Ancha WA 2 1 1 2 2

Superstition WA 0 0 0 0 0

Sycamore Canyon WA 0 0 0 0 0

Cumulative #days >= 0.5 100 24 67 74 80

Max 27.67 6.33 16.00 18.33 max

Max areaPetrified Forest NPGila WA Gila WA Gila WA

ctrl1-rs, ctrl2_rs, and crtrl-5_rs are relative to Base_RS (UNC "Rev. Base, SO4 Sensitivity")

All scenarios have unit 2 SCR 0.08; unit 2 costs include only incremental relative to that

Bosque del Apache inadvertently omitted
Impacts

Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Apache_visx.xlsx

vm8b, average # days/year in 2001-2003

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r ctrl3_s

128 118 107 86

116 108 94 77

46 39 36 26

12 7 3 1

3 1 0 0

2 1 0 0

80 75 68 61

2 1 1 0

9 7 5 1
Impacts

Rev Base Ctrl1_R Ctrl2_R2

links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Cholla_visx.xlsx

vm8b, average # days/year in 2001-2003

base_R ctrl1_r ctrl2_r2

19 17 11

5 4 2

17 13 6

28 25 19

35 30 19

33 26 12

29 24 15

252 246 232

19 15 8

4 2 1

41 36 25

26 23 16

24 20 12

links to Coronado_modrev3_n822_visx.xlsx, to AZRHFIP_TSD_Coronado_visx.xlsx, and to Coronado_bosq_n822_visx.xlsx (& 

vm8b, average # days/year in 2001-2003

base_q Base Base_R Ctrl1-R Ctrl-2 Ctrl-5 base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs

11.7 6.0 5.0 1.3
9 2 1 0 0 0 3 2 0

3 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

3 1 1 0 0 0 2 1 0

3 1 1 0 0 0 2 1 0

36 11 8 6 3 3 27 20 11

5 1 1 1 0 0 3 2 0

2 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0

10 2 2 1 0 0 6 5 1

25 7 6 4 2 1 17 15 5

39 11 9 8 4 3 28 23 14

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

1 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0

15 4 3 1 0 0 8 4 0

4 1 1 0 0 0 2 1 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

159.00 44.00 32.33 23.33 9.00 7.00 100.00 75.67 33.33

10 13

38.667 11.000 8.667 7.667 4.000 3.333 27.667 23.333 14.333

ronado_bosq_n822_visx.xlsx (& formerly to UNC_NDays_over_threshold.xls)

benefits relative to Base_R

ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs Ctrl_1_R Ctrl-2 Ctrl-5

0.7 0.0
0 0 1 1 1

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 1 1

0 0 0 1 1

8 7 2 5 6

0 0 0 1 1

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 1 2 2

5 3 1 4 5

12 10 1 5 5

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 1 3 3

0 0 0 1 1

0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0

26.33 19.67 9.00 23.33 25.33

6 10 10

0 0 0

0 0 0

12.333 9.667 2.000 5.333 5.667 Max

Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Max area

$0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $/yr, millions

$0 $0 $0 $/yr
TSD Visibility Tables for AZ RH FIP for Three Facilities, July 2012 (this one not used in body of TSD

created on 2012-07-02; updated 07-17

This sheet is identical to ddv_p98th, except it uses EPA costs (w/o property tax and insurance) for $/dv

Includes mid- and late June modeling runs:

 Cholla Ctrl2_R2; Coronado Base_R_S, ctrl1_rs, and ctrl2_rs, Ctrl5_R_S, and ctrl6_rs

This is updated relative to NPR tables; has some minor cost corrections for Apache SNCR and SCR,

 and uses 22nd high instead of 23rd high for Coronado base_q, ctrl1_rs, ctrl2_rs, ctrl5_rs, ctrl6_rs

 to be consistent with all the other results. Also includes some late results for Bosque del Apache area.

98th percentile delta deciviews, all 2001-2003 days together, visibility method 8b

No rounding of intermediate dv or $

Table size (cols X rows) This spreadsheet links to:

5 x 17 AEPCO Apache aep_az_unit2-3_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots2.xls

4 x 21 APS Cholla cho_az_unit2-4_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls

6 x 25 SRP Coronado srp_az_unit1-2_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls

more SRP CoronadoCoronado_modrev3_n822_visx.xlsx

$/yr, millions (EPA's TSD)

Ndays > 0.5, 1.0: AZRHFIP_TSD_Apache_visx.xlsx (&c for Cholla & Coronado)

AEPCO Apache

Base Improvements

UNC name Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

Pre-LNB NOx u.2 Post-LNB 2, LNB 3 Post-LNB 2, SNCR

Pre-LNB 2, 

SCR+H2SO4

Apache Units 2 and 3: EPA's Visibility Improvement from NOx Controls (using EPA cost)

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r ctrl3s

Class I Area Baseline impact (dv) Improvement from 

LNB (dv)

Improvement from 

SNCR (dv)

Improvement from 

SCR (dv)

Chiricahua NM 3.41 0.44 0.82 1.51

Chiricahua WA 3.46 0.53 1.00 1.59

Galiuro WA 2.22 0.39 0.65 1.10

Gila WA 0.63 0.14 0.22 0.37

Mazatzal WA 0.28 0.05 0.09 0.14

Mount Baldy WA 0.28 0.07 0.11 0.18

Saguaro NP 2.49 0.38 0.66 1.16

Sierra Ancha WA 0.29 0.06 0.10 0.14

Superstition WA 0.61 0.10 0.19 0.31

Cumulative dv 13.67 2.14 3.83 6.51

# areas >= 0.5 6 1 4 4

Number of days >= 0.5 dv 128 0 0 0

Number of days >= 1.0 dv 0 0 0 0

$/max dv, millions $4.3 $5.6 $7.5

$/cumulative dv, millions $1.1 $1.5 $1.8

Max 3.46 0.53 1.00 1.59

Max area Chiricahua WA Chiricahua WA Chiricahua WA Chiricahua WA

$/yr, millions $2.3 $5.6 $12.0

$2,295,498 $5,621,452 $11,972,377
APS Cholla

Base Improvements

UNC name Rev Base Ctrl1_R Ctrl2_R2

PostLNB SO2cor

Post-LNB SNCR 

SO2c

Post-LNB SCR 

SO2c

Cholla Units 2, 3, and 4: EPA's Visibility Improvement From NOx Controls (using EPA cost)

base ctrl1_r ctrl2_r2

Class I Area Baseline impact (dv) Improvement from 

SNCR (dv)

Improvement from 

SCR (dv)

Capitol Reef NP 1.46 0.27 0.76

Galiuro WA 0.45 0.05 0.14

Gila WA 0.70 0.09 0.22

Grand Canyon NP 2.22 0.37 1.06

Mazatzal WA 1.19 0.16 0.43

Mesa Verde NP 1.34 0.26 0.70

Mount Baldy WA 1.21 0.27 0.52

Petrified Forest NP 4.53 0.47 1.34

Pine Mountain WA 0.85 0.12 0.31

Saguaro NP 0.30 0.02 0.05

Sierra Ancha WA 1.36 0.20 0.51

Superstition WA 1.27 0.17 0.51

Sycamore Canyon WA 1.42 0.27 0.68

Cumulative dv 18.30 2.71 7.21

# areas >= 0.5 11 0 8

Number of days >= 0.5 dv 252 0 0

Number of days >= 1.0 dv 0 0 0

$/max dv, millions $17.3 $19.1

$/cumulative dv, millions $3.0 $3.5

Max 4.53 0.47 1.34

Max area Petrified Forest NP Petrified Forest NP Petrified Forest NP

$/yr, millions $8.2 $25.5

$/yr $8,201,572 $25,482,955

SRP Coronado

Base Improvements

UNC name base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs

LNB; 

SCR.08w/H2SO4 SNCR; SCR.08 SCR.05; SCR.08 SCR.05 w/H2SO4

Coronado Units 1 and 2: EPA's Visibility Improvement From NOx Controls (using EPA cost)

base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs

Class I Area Baseline impact (dv) Improvement from 

SNCR on unit 1 (dv)

Improvement from 

SCR .05 on unit 1 

(dv)

Improvement from 

SCR .05 on both (dv)

Bosque del Apache * 0.47 0.08 0.20 0.23

Bandelier NM 0.37 0.07 0.18 0.20

Chiricahua NM 0.20 0.03 0.07 0.08

Chiricahua WA 0.21 0.03 0.07 0.09

Galiuro WA 0.20 0.02 0.08 0.09
Gila WA 1.23 0.22 0.59 0.66

Grand Canyon NP 0.24 0.03 0.09 0.11

Mazatzal WA 0.20 0.01 0.06 0.07

Mesa Verde NP 0.40 0.07 0.19 0.20

Mount Baldy WA 0.87 0.16 0.42 0.44

Petrified Forest NP 1.22 0.17 0.47 0.56

Pine Mountain WA 0.14 0.02 0.04 0.05

Saguaro NP 0.12 0.01 0.03 0.04

San Pedro Parks WA 0.54 0.11 0.28 0.30

Sierra Ancha WA 0.24 0.03 0.06 0.07

Superstition WA 0.21 0.02 0.06 0.06

Sycamore Canyon WA 0.16 0.01 0.05 0.06

Cumulative dv 6.54 1.02 2.74 3.07

# areas >= 0.5 4 0 1 2

Number of days >= 0.5 dv 28 6 16 18

Number of days >= 1.0 dv 10 2 8 8

$/max dv, millions $17.2 $15.8 $14.5

$/cumulative dv, millions $3.8 $3.4 $3.1

* Bosque del Apache is NOT included in cumulate totals above: simulations were not part of EPA decision-making for NPRM

Max 1.23 0.22 0.59 0.66

Max area Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA

$/yr, millions $3.8 $9.3 $9.6

$/yr $3,825,556 $9,315,313 $9,586,793

Bosque del Apache inadvertently omitted

Costs *including* that for unit 2 SCR 0.08 llb/MMBtu

Cumulative dv 6.54 1.02 2.74 3.07

# areas >= 0.5 4 0 1 2

$/max dv, millions $56.5 $30.6 $27.7

$/cumulative dv, millions $12.3 $6.6 $6.0

Max 1.23 0.22 0.59 0.66

Max area Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA

$/yr, millions $12.5 $18.0 $18.3

$/yr $12,547,192 $18,036,949 $18,308,429
 used in body of TSD)

ance) for $/dv

finalwithplots2.xls

finalwithplots.xls

finalwithplots.xls

 Cholla & Coronado)

Impacts

Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

links to aep_az_unit2-3_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots2.xls

vm8b, All Years p98 ddv

Base Ctrl1-R Ctrl2-R Ctrl3-S

3.409 2.973 2.591 1.898

3.464 2.932 2.466 1.871

2.219 1.826 1.569 1.120

0.629 0.493 0.413 0.255

0.277 0.229 0.190 0.137

0.282 0.217 0.170 0.100

2.493 2.117 1.836 1.331

0.287 0.229 0.188 0.147

0.612 0.512 0.419 0.300

<--- links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Apache_visx.xlsx

Costs

From EPA's TSD

unit LNB SNCR SCR

2 $1,142,120 $2,652,841 $5,869,299

3 $1,153,378 $2,968,611 $6,103,078
Impacts

Rev Base Ctrl1_R Ctrl2_R2

links to cho_az_unit2-4_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls

vm8b, All Years p98 ddv

Rev Base CTRL1_R ctrl2_r2

1.460 1.191 0.698

0.446 0.400 0.309

0.701 0.614 0.484

2.224 1.850 1.163

1.192 1.031 0.763

1.338 1.083 0.634

1.214 0.949 0.698

4.528 4.055 3.192

0.845 0.725 0.537

0.299 0.278 0.248

1.360 1.165 0.853

1.266 1.099 0.761

1.424 1.151 0.745

<--- links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Cholla_visx.xlsx

Costs, Total Cost/year

From EPA's TSD

unit SNCR SCR

2 $2,482,318 $7,475,028

3 $2,533,432 $8,113,131

4 $3,185,822 $9,894,796

ctrl6_rs

SCR -90% 

w/H2SO4 links to srp_az_unit1-2_dollarperdv_analysis_finalwithplots.xls, and to coronado_sjbmod.xlsx

vm8b, All Years p98 ddv

ctrl6_rs

Improvement from 

SCR -90% on both 

(dv) base_q Base Base_R Ctrl1-R Ctrl-2 Ctrl-5

0.25 0.725

0.22 0.562 0.480 0.365 0.293 0.184 0.160

0.09 0.292 0.248 0.191 0.161 0.125 0.115

0.09 0.307 0.264 0.201 0.172 0.120 0.112

0.09 0.274 0.254 0.193 0.171 0.108 0.102
0.73 1.829 1.546 1.201 0.978 0.605 0.531

0.12 0.351 0.301 0.233 0.200 0.144 0.128

0.08 0.274 0.230 0.197 0.181 0.130 0.121

0.23 0.595 0.503 0.390 0.319 0.203 0.180

0.50 1.280 1.076 0.849 0.688 0.444 0.389

0.63 1.707 1.420 1.168 0.998 0.695 0.631

0.06 0.193 0.168 0.139 0.126 0.098 0.092

0.04 0.160 0.143 0.112 0.098 0.079 0.073

0.34 0.825 0.693 0.526 0.421 0.252 0.221

0.08 0.343 0.295 0.236 0.203 0.167 0.161

0.07 0.274 0.235 0.202 0.182 0.146 0.134

0.07 0.221 0.195 0.159 0.149 0.102 0.099

3.43 9.49 8.05 6.36 5.34 3.60 3.25

2 4

20 <--- links to AZRHFIP_TSD_Coronado_visx.xlsx

10

$13.1

$2.8

n-making for NPRM

0.73 max 1.829 1.546 1.201 0.998 0.695 0.631

Gila WA

$9.6 ?

$9,586,793 ?

Costs

From EPA's TSD

unit SNCR SCR.05/.08 SCR.05

1 $3,825,556 $9,315,313 $9,315,313

2 $8,721,636 $8,721,636 $8,993,116

2 to 0.08 $0 $0 $271,480

s, and to coronado_sjbmod.xlsx

benefits relative to Base_R

base_rs ctrl1_rs ctrl2_rs ctrl5_rs ctrl6_rs Ctrl_1_R Ctrl-2 Ctrl-5

0.466 0.382 0.268 0.232 0.212

0.372 0.303 0.188 0.172 0.151 0.072 0.181 0.205

0.197 0.164 0.131 0.119 0.108 0.030 0.066 0.076

0.206 0.176 0.135 0.120 0.112 0.029 0.081 0.089

0.198 0.176 0.117 0.109 0.104 0.022 0.085 0.091
1.226 1.004 0.636 0.566 0.493 0.223 0.596 0.670

0.238 0.204 0.145 0.130 0.12 0.033 0.089 0.105

0.199 0.188 0.142 0.133 0.124 0.016 0.067 0.076

0.402 0.331 0.211 0.198 0.173 0.071 0.187 0.210

0.871 0.709 0.456 0.430 0.376 0.161 0.405 0.460

1.217 1.049 0.744 0.662 0.587 0.170 0.473 0.537

0.144 0.129 0.102 0.097 0.088 0.013 0.041 0.047

0.116 0.102 0.084 0.076 0.072 0.014 0.033 0.039

0.535 0.430 0.259 0.231 0.198 0.105 0.274 0.305

0.243 0.213 0.182 0.175 0.167 0.033 0.069 0.075

0.211 0.191 0.156 0.149 0.141 0.020 0.056 0.068

0.164 0.153 0.110 0.100 0.094 0.010 0.057 0.060

6.54 5.52 3.80 3.47 3.11 1.02 2.76 3.11

4 0 1 2

17.1549596 15.6297198 14.3086463

3.74320548 3.37511341 3.07959942

1.226 1.049 0.744 0.662 0.587 0.223 0.596 0.670 Max

Gila WA Gila WA Gila WA Max area

$3.8 $9.3 $9.6 $/yr, millions

$3,825,556 $9,315,313 $9,586,793 $/yr


Max area

$/yr, millions