|  | Wetlands                                        Recent Additions | Contact Us |                                                                                 Print Version                                                                                 Search:                                                                                 EPA Home> Water> Wetlands, Oceans and Watersheds                    > Wetlands                    > Wetlands Fact Sheet > What About Takings?                    Laws, Regulations,          Guidance, and          Scientific DocumentsState, Tribal, and          Local InitiativesLandownersWater Quality and          401 CertificationMonitoring and          AssessmentWetlands and          WatershedsRestorationEducationIn Your Area
 
        What About Takings? The Issue: When does a government action      affecting private property amount to a "taking," and what are      the takings implications of wetland regulation?The Fifth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America
No person shall...be deprived of...property without due process of law,        nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.
Legal Background
The concept of takings comes from the Fifth Amendment (see box below),        which prohibits the taking of private property by the government for a        public use without payment of just compensation. This fact sheet briefly        explores the issue of takings as it relates to wetlands regulation.

The Supreme Court and lower courts have established a body of law used        to determine when government actions affecting use of private property        amount to a "taking" of the property by the government. When        private property is "taken" by the government, the property        owner must be fairly compensated.

Initially, the courts recognized takings claims based on government actions        that resulted in a physical seizure or occupation of private property.        The courts subsequently ruled that, in certain limited circumstances,        govern ment regulation affecting private property also may amount to a        taking.

In reviewing these "regulatory" takings cases, the courts generally        apply a balancing test; they examine the character of the government's        action and its effect on the property's economic value. Government        actions for the purpose of protecting public health and safety, including        many types of actions for environmental protection, generally will not        constitute takings. The courts also look at the extent to which the government's        action interferes with the reasonable, investment-backed expectations        of the property owner.

In Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council (1992), the U.S. Supreme Court        ruled that a State regulation that deprives a property owner of all economically        beneficial use of that property can be a taking. The court further clarified,        however, that a regulation is not a taking if it is consistent with "restrictions        that background principles of the State's law of property and nuisance        already placed upon ownership." As an example of "background        principles," the court referred to the right of government to prevent        flooding of others' property.

Dolan v. City of Tigard (1994), a more recent Supreme Court takings case,        involved a requirement by the City of Tigard in Oregon that, to prevent        flooding and traffic congestion, a business owner seeking to expand substantially        onto property adjacent to a floodplain create a public greenway and bike        path from private land. The Supreme Court ruled that the City’s        requirement would be a taking if the City did not show that there was        a Areasonable relationship@ between the creation of the greenway and bike        path and the impact of the development. As compared to the facts in Dolan,        the Clean Water Act Section 404 program generally does not require property        owners to provide public access across or along their property.
Current Status
The presence of wetlands does not mean that a property owner cannot undertake        any activity on the property. In fact, wetlands regulation under Section        404 does not necessarily even result in restricting the use of a site.        Many activities are either not regulated at all, explicitly exempted from        regulation, or authorized under general permits.

Moreover, in situations where individual permits are required, the Federal        agencies can work with permit applicants to design projects that meet        the requirements of the law and protect the environment and public safety,        while accomplishing the legitimate individual objectives and protecting        the property rights of the applicant. Overall, more than 95% of all projects        receive Section 404 authorization.

 

About the Wetlands Program | Helpline | Publications | Espanol
 
EPA Home                                 | Privacy                                 and Security Notice |                                 Contact Us

 

  |
|--|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|