7KH +RQRUDEOH .DUO 6 )RUHVWHU &K

IRU WKH (DVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI .HQWXFN\ VLWWL



5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




(1'< /:(//

	




	






1,9(56,7< 263,7$/6

20( $5( 	(59,&(6

	




	



 !"#$%
&'$(	$

!"$%"$%"&)'$"'*$!

-./0/12+ 3$'

"5+(6+5+$

)*'((&(' (64&

8!"63&(9'"

%'!)'$"'*$4
/ 












	  )&&'  9&$' 8	 9)	 ;		
	 , &(%'!" &$ '<=$%>'&? 2"& 2	 ; 8) ,'&5$&@&$+*?7!" 
)&&'9&$'	*$$  	*% " 8	 9)	 ; 		
	 , &( %' !"  &$   '<=$% >'&? 2"&9+*'& 48"&"( 2	 ;8),'&5$&@&$+*?7!" 







@ 9	 3 '"*+'$ 4+(5  & *"

 2 '&$'!! " &$&(7 A BC A DE &( )!&(&$ &$" 
&',"'$7'$ #"	",'* BC
&',"'$7D"C$%%'$ DE"'&+#="!'+"''&5!"# A F+'$ 5'&5$%$$%%'$ %(!' ($7%"&!'$%#% $%*"&+","$'#A5'&,' $'&!$%'"9="	$&("(*$BC9	DE/-
	G/

&( %'F 3'&'#+# '" 5 	$&("( *$ %','((G0
&',"'$7 $%('$"'*$*+"$F(&' !'$#$'&!"+##"7H+(5#&$&(5"&$! A F*"#$'&!"+##"7H+(5#&$&$%'+!A%$%" A A"!'& &($%"!"I#$!"#$%9	F,"$'#"J+'"#&$%('$"'*$*+"$!+&($%$ A A&$'(&!='"J+'"(=7$%9	"5+ $'&F(!'&'$'&!"!'& =*+%"*',(=$%",''$!&(%+" 7*#&$'&&*"  A "5+$%$
&',"'$7%&$$'!'('$=+"(&!%A'&55(!'$%&($%$$%('$"'*$*+"$$%"!"=+('$('*"$'&=7&$A"('&5%" 'J+'($((#5! A'&5H+"7,"('*$'&%"!,"&(#5 A  !+"$%" *&$&( $%$ $% ('$"'*$ *+"$ '#"" 7
 



"* +(( $% H+"7 !"# !'&"*"(?'&5"*$'**&$'$+$9		

$%('$"'*$ A  A &$  "!'&  ,"$'#"J+'"#&$(&'  ! 'J+'($( (#5  *+"$F"+ '&5$$%"*"(?

	


&37//--K A =5&

%#% $% *" &+" !"$% A FH=(+$'%#% $C("','&5$$'&$F%#" *,"'(?' (&+"'&5",'*$ &!*"$= '%(!"$%*"$'!'( =7 $% $'&$F $$C*# $L'&5M &+"'&5 &$ &",'*L%M",'(($$'&$

%& A  !'"$=5&# 

--K%"*',(N!"*%N0/!"*%
O'&!+'&,''$A"?A?(('$'& 7%"**# $'&5(#''&"A"?%+" 7*#&$'&BN"%*# $'&5 $% &*"7 (*+#+"$%"#"'! A *# $( &5"$%&$A%+" % "*',$'&$,''$

& 4+ 7  -- 
&',"'$7 *

 &!"%#% $%*"&+"=7%+" 7 7 $%$ $% &+" "(*+#&$$'&
&',"'$7#(",''$ "$ $ *#&$ !(('$'& %+" 77#&$%% '*7 ! "'#=+"'&5 % $% %#$+&(D,''$
0 







& ="+"7  -- 
&',"'$7 "(+*( $% ",''$

"$ !"#('* +"5'* ,''$$N/.&( !"'&!+'&,''$$N. +N. !"&7$'&$$%$A&A(#''&!"",'*=*&'("(!+ $'#%#% $%*"&+"=7$%%'$  A %($*# $#'&'#+#!$A&$7!',$'&$,''$"A?**"('&5$
&',"'$7'$"J+'"(!+ $'#%#% $%*"&+"$*# $#'&'#+#!$A&$7!',,''$"A?=*+C$% *$+  $'# &$ A'$% $'&$ (+"'&5 L/KM ,''$*# $'&5*'$((*+#&$$'&$", '&5$&(!"#L$%M,''$LM&(('*+'&5$% &!*"A'$%#('* &(% $%*""&& &($%$'&$LM&(!#'L 'MA+ ($5$%"A'$%*%(+ (#$'&5J+ !"$7B0E%+""A?D  4 $ 0  % %'$    "J+'"(  A  $"!"#&*  ",'* $ $&* A?" ,"7$&(7B!"A%'*%%A+ (=*#&$($"$!N"%+"E&($$$&("5+ "$!!#$'&5&('&",'*$"'&'&5B!"A%'*%%A*#&$($"$!NK" %+"E A%'*%  A  $$'!'( $? "I'#$ 7 !+"%+""#&$%

**"('&5$ A ('$
&',"'$7F$'#$!$%

$'# "J+'"( $ "!"# $A&$7!', ,''$ " A? B-%+"E%"5+ " 7A"?(&,"5!'I$7%+""A?$*# $%""J+'"(,''$'&* +('&5$&$!'!$&%+" *% A?$ *# $ "J+'"( (*+#&$$'& &($ %& *  $ $'&$ &( %7'*'&  (('$'& 7 A **$(&(&**'&, +&$"(!"(('$'& ,''$(+"'&5$%A?=+$A'("5+ ",''$"$!"+*%A"? A ('(&$"*',*#&$'&$"$!$'#&(% !!"&7%+"%A"?('&I*!!"$7%+"A?

&	$#="/-- A "'5&(!"#
&',"'$7

& *$=" /- --. % !' ( $%' A+'$ 5'&$
&',"'$7 5'&5,' $'&!$%,"$'#",''&'&$%9	&4+ 7//---
&',"'$7#,(!"+##"7H+(5#&$& A F9	* '#&$%5"+&($%$ A A"!'& # 7I#$!"#$%9	,"$'#

 




&("$%*'"*+#$&*$%"!"!H+"7*&!+'&!"#$%('$"'*$*&(&7"""A%"# 




% H+(5#&$ ! $% ('$"'*$ *

	 &(   	!"!+"$%""*(''&'&
/ 







*$'& " $ $% *+"$ '&*&'$&$ A'$% +=$&$' H+$'*D  (  ', 2 :     
  /0 ( . . B$% '" --0E B% ('&5 $%$H+(5F*##&$$H+"7(+"'&5J+ 27*$$"' A"%"# """EC2 '& 7+ $*%$%$$%"*('&5"&$$=('$+"=(=*+!&"""$%$"H+('*(&&D+$5/(6

/$1

5,*+7 (7 $/('(5$/

25$&7,&(

$1'

252&('85(G/..B/((--KE

&$%"*"(=!"+A"+&= $*&* +($%$$%

H+(5F"+ '&5"+ $('&+&!'""H+('*&'("'&5$%"+ '&5'&$%*&$I$!$%'&$"+*$'&A% !

- /( $ / A $%'&? $% "'? ! H+"7 *&!+'& A#'&'# 
&'$"'5'& '&$"+*$'&$%*+"$%'5% '5%$($%# 7"F (+$7 $ ? "*"( '& $% *&$I$ ! '$A' !+ & '&$"+*$'&   $%'&? $% *+"$F (*''& $5"+ $% $A '+ '? 7  "$( $% H+"7 $%$ $%"*"(?'&5 ,'(&* A $&$' 7 '5&'!'*&$ $ '$A' !+ &($"#'&$'& A'$%+$ +55$'&5$%$'$ *+ ("$+"&,"('*$!A' !+ &=(I* +', 7&!'&('&5$%$$%"*"(?'&5"*$'*A""*?  $%+5%$%*+"$ *+ ( %, #" * " 7 I '&( $% " $'&%'=$A& "*"(?'&5 &( A' !+ & $% '&$"+*$'&#'$'5$(#A%$$%"'?$%$$%H+"7A+ (#''&$""$$%*+"$F+=J+&$"+ '&5"* +('&5&7*&'("$'&!"*"(?'&5,'(&*&$%J+$'&!A' !+ &

3"," A &,""&$($%H+"7A'$%&7$%"7

$%A$%"*"(?'&5,'(&**+ (="=$',!$%!*$+ J+$'&$%$A"" 7$'+1'A%$%"
&',"'$7 A' !+ 7 ,' $( $% 9	F ,"$'# 7",''&!'&('$+& '? 7$%"!"$%$$%H+"7A+ (%, =& '&* '&( $ #? +*%  *&&*$'& =&$ $%('$"'*$ *+"$F "+ '&5   A F * '&5 "5+#&$ !*+(I* +', 7 & "+('&5 $% H+"7 $%$ '$ *+ ( A"( &(('$'& 7"!+&'(,"$'#'!'$ !+&(
&',"'$7F,' $'& ! $% 9	F "*"(?'&5 ",''& $ =A' !+ A%, "(7I '&($%''&'&*""*$$$#&$! A&(A'$ ! '? 7$#' ($%H+"7

 



",''&
&',"'$7"5+($%$$%J+ '!'*$'&&((+$'!"GK0=+$ A*#"!'& '&"$'*+ "&!GK0BE

& +5+$ - ---  A  

+##"7H+(5#&$	%"5+($%%"& !='=*+ %A='!"&* (+$'$!!#$'&&(=*+%&,"5"($$%

& ,#="/---$%('


&',"'$7%(&$'( A $%9	(&'(
&',"'$7F#$'&(5"&$( A F#$'& !" ('$"'*$*+"$I '&(CL
&',"5"(+#"5"( !$'#+( $'# $'#$ !"  ! $ &%&*#&$=7&%+" 7"$'!


	+/(.K.B)%'---$%$+& '?$% "7='"5+ !='"5+ $'&('(&$ A!A'$%(('$'& !"#!*#I '&($%$+& '?$%+ #+$%"'<( !"  "'("!'&*##''&=&+&(%'!$$C!!"$&(A"?+$+$LM !"I$"A"?D&$!"A"?%%

$..'& 7$%('$"'*$*+"$"!'& I#$!"#$%9*%"*$""&$+"!L%"MH=A%'$ F7#&$$%"&"$7*&$# $(=7$%9	"

& )*#="  ---  H+"

 A &%"9	(#5* '#%('$"'*$*+"$A"(( A 
 







2Q 'HFHPEHU   (OZHOO ILOHG D PRWLRQ IRU UHFRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI

WKH OLTXLGDWHG GDPDJHV LVVXH ZKLFK WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHQLHG E\ PDUJLQDOHQWU\ RUGHU RQ -DQXDU\  

$%#+&$!$%H+(5#&$!"#$%($!$%!' '&5!$%*# '&$$%"+5%$%($!&$"7!$%H+(5#&$D4$KK/B)$"("/KE&( A"((N0-..0.K'&$$"&7F!&(*$4$0B)$"("//E%('$"'*$*+"$('(&$%A,"A"( A  'J+'($((#5=*+'$!+&($%$$%%'$ %(C*$('&5(!'$%&(%("&= 5"+&($= ',$%$'$#$%(!7#&$D $ %# % $% *" &+" ('( &$ ,' $ $%9	4$.B)$"("/0--E,'&5" ,(

 A F !("  * '# +&(" $% 9	 $% ('$"'*$ *+"$('#'(A'$%+$"H+('* A F$$ A* '#+&("%'F3'&'#+#'"5	$&("(*$

& 4&+"7/
&',"'$7 !' (&$'*! 

A%'*%A% ('&=7&*&('&5$%('$"'*$*+"$F"+ '&5& $% #$'& !" "*&'("$'&   A  !' (  $'# 7&$'*!*" &="+"7/

		

	



&',"'$7"5+$%$$%('$"'*$*+"$""('&5"&$'&5

 A F#$'&!"+##"7H+(5#&$=*+ A A'( &  ! =' '& **"(&* A'$% /- GK0B=E	*'!'* 7
&',"'$7"5+$%$$%('$"'*$*+"$""('&*&* +('&5$%$$%&$+"! A FA"?A&$+&'J+&($%$ A A&$'(&!='=*+!$%(('$'& %+" 77% "*',( !"#$'&5'&",'*$"'&'&5&* (+$7&('&!+'&,''$$%$ $( &5"$%&$A%+"%'*+"$",'A(&,('$"'*$*+"$F 5"&$ ! +##"7 H+(5#&$  	$  
 

%
"-(KKKB$%'"---E&K/.
	KB/E	+##"7H+(5#&$'""& 7A%&$%"'&('+$$#$"' J+$'&!!*$&(&

 



,"$'#1($'$!' +A' !+  $% #='5++ %"'&5 %,*&!+($%H+"7$A%*&'("'&'&5A' !+ &


&"$'*+ "$%*+"$F"+ '&5*

=7 $% H+"7  & '&$"+*$'& $%
&',"'$7F!' +"$?$'#"

($"#'&'&5A' !+ &$%'&'&*""*$ $%+5%$%9	($ ="'&5  "',$ *$'& !" "*# 7"F "*"(?'&5 "**""="$ & # 7F * '#A' !+ 7'& !' '&5$ *#&$%(&")$  
" 
 
B) 3'*% -.E B!'&('&5 A' ",''& A%" *#&7  C*#&$'&$'#D"&(!"A%+""A?AC+*$'= =+( %"'&DE  " I#  $?&A'&5 7+&("""$('$# +55$$H+"7$%$$%# 7"'$!' +"$7,"$'#!"#" '#'&$,'(&*$%$#'5%$ $"=7&!'$# 7
!$%'#" '? 7$%$$%# 7"A$%$'$*$','$',' $($%9	('"5"(!$%$ "'?%

 0K  	+ /-0  (!&(&$F "*$'* ! ?&A'&5 $'#"*"(A%'*%5"$ 7+&("A"?(=7$%'" "&& '$%,' $'&!$%*$A"

*&* +(%A,"$%$&7

A%"# (" + !'$%$CL&M"""'&$%(#''&"& """ " (!*$ '& &7 "+ '&5('$+"='&5H+(5#&$""("+
. 







+-/(/B$%'"--EB'&$"& *'$$'&#'$$(E


&'$' 7A*&* +($%$$%('$"'*$*+"$('(&$""'&

"!+'&5$5', A F"('&$"+*$'&&$%'+!A' !+ &
&("/-
	G/B=E & # 7#7="'&5"',$*$'&5'&$&# 7"!"+&'(,"$'#" #'&'#+# A5  %' ",''& ( &$ +$%"'<# 7+'$!",' $'&!$%9	F"*"(?'&5"J+'"#&$+$%"'$7$&!"*$%*$F"*"(?'&5",''&',$(I* +', 7'&$%	*"$"7!9=" /- 
	 G / B+$%"'<'&5 $% 	*"$"7 $ '&'$'$'&H+&*$'&"*('&5$"$"'&&7,' $'&!/-
	G /K '&* +('&5 /- 
	 G /KBEBKE A%'*% #? '$+& A!+  !" & # 7" $ !'  $ *# 7 A'$% $%"*"(?'&5"J+'"#&$*&$'&('&/-
	G/B*EE:,/(. B$%'"E&K/0
	-B--.EB&$'&5$%$	*"$"7%I* +', +$%"'$7 $ ="'&5 +'$ +&(" G /E   A $%"!" A &$ &$'$ ( $ (#5 !" 
&',"'$7F,' $'&!$%9	F"*"(?'&5"J+'"#&$"*+!*$'&A=(  7+&
&',"'$7F!' +"$7,"$'#*&J+&*%*+ (=&!'$!"#$%$%"7" $$+$! '#'$$'&& 7'!$%H+"7 !+&($%$
&',"'$7F!' +"$7,"$'#AA' !+ 
&*&$"$ A F"('&$"+*$'&A+ ( A$%H+"7$!'&(A' !+ ,' $'&!$%9	'!'$*&* +(($%$
&',"'$7"*?  7 ('"5"(( '$ $$+$"7 (+$7 $ ? "*"(A%$%""&$$%H+"7 = ',($%%'$ A"*? $'$(+$7$7,"$'#%''&'&**+"$$$#&$!$% '*=  A&('$I* +'&A""

+"'&J+'"7(&$&($%"%A," #+$

*&'(" A%$%" $% *+"$ #''&$"+*$( $% H+"7 A%&(+"'&5  A F * '&5 "5+#&$ '$ "+ ( $%$ *+& F"5+#&$*&*"&'&5$%"*"(?'&5,'(&*AC&$& #&$ ! "*? & " A' !+ &D  4 $ / $%+5%A$%'&?$%$$%*+"$F"+ '&5A*""*$'&!"'$"J+'" A $",$%$
&',"'$7F!' +"$7

 



"$7'&$'$ ($H+(5#&$,9 2 KB*E  O'A'&5   !*$%"!"#'&$% '5%$#$!,"*+"$$%&($"#'&A%$%"$%$%$"&= H+"7*+ (!'&(

( $ KK B*'$'&5 % " .

0K
	K0K.B

%9	",'($%$# 7

A"? #" $%& !"$7 %+" " ,"$'# *#&$'& $  "$&% ! $'# $%'" "5+ " 72"&# 7('&C=&!'(%A,""I#$(!"#$%/- 
	 G /BEBE  % #",'&5$%$&# 7$'!'9	 &( I#$'& +&(" *&$"+(5'&$$%# 7"//0(-B$%'"E&$//B/EB*'$'&5	!..-/B-EE

% 9	F '# #&$'&5 "

$&("(!"($"#'&'&5A%$%"I#$'&"!'& %""$$$*##& 7?&A&$%C # 7A%"C*#&$(!='$"$!&$ $%&N!="( (5'&5"$%"!*' '$'% "5+ $'&   *"$  C%# 7CA%"*#&$("$!$ $N/K"A?I"$%"!*' '$'D/-GK0

8*+$%"'&('+$$%

N/K"A?I* +('&5="( $%C%"$$$D '$
&',""!'& # 7I#$!"$$
&',"'$7#+$",6BE$%
. 







*&'$(!$%"!"#&*!A"?C"J+'"'&5?&A (5!&(,&*($7'&!' (!*'&*" "&'&5D:B/E$%$%"CA"?"J+'"L(M$%*&'$&$I"*'!('*"$'&&(H+(5#&$D:&(BE$%$%A'(C&1$"$!$ $N/K"A?I* +',!="( (5'&5"$%"!*' '$'D/-GK0KBEB#%'(((E A (&$('+$$%!'"$$A"&5!$%'$$	%('+$& 7A%$%"%A'(&!='(!'&(=7$%9	"5+ $'&

%9	"5+ $'&$!"$%$%! A'&55+'( '&!"

($"#'&'&5A%$%""$'*+ "*#&$'& &J+ '!'!='""&5#&$6

9'$$ "&('!!'*+ $7 "''&($"#'&'&5 A%$%" "$'*+ "# 7#&$""&5#&$'&, ,7#&$&!='	+*%""&5#&$"*%"*$"'<(=7$%7#&$!&5"(+#!"'&5 H="5"( !$%$'#"J+'"(!"'$*# $'&%7#&$'&&"#= '*A"?7#&$A'$%$%'#"$&$('$'&*$'&$%$5&" 7?'&5!7#&$'#(!"$%?'&(!H=A%'*%'+&'J+"$%"$%&!""'!H=A%'*%""$(&'&(!'&'$&+#="!$'#&(!"A%'*%7#&$&&'(&$'* =''#(,"&(,"5'&27#&$=(&$%&+#="!%+"" (7 A"?( &( &$ & $% **# '%#&$ ! 5',&'&5 $?"&$*&'("(7#&$&!='

/-GK0B=E A *&*($%$%"H=AC+&'J+D A'$%'& $% #&'&5 ! $% "5+ $'&  	%*&$&( %A," $%$ 
&',"'$7F *#&$'&  &A%'*%*#='&!7#&$&(%+" 7*#&$'&(&$J+ '!7!='=*+'$$'*#&$'&$ $'&"$$C$%&+#="!%+""(7A"?(&(&$&$%**# '%#&$ !  5',& '&5  $?D  /- GK0B=E

 



!$%"&'$# 7&($%" *&('$'& &( "*$'*#'&$'&&(% "",+*$'#

"$00/$$%*&* +'&*+& =H*$($$%C"*"(?$%A' !+ ,' $'&D"$K

"&$ 7 +&($""( =7 $%

$$#$( $ "&$ %" $%"7 (+"'&5* '&5"5+#&$%' '+  '&$'!!F *+&  !*"*"(?'&5"*$'*!$""*$?(J+$$'#"*"(*J+$'&6  CA $% !*$ $%$ $%"*"(&($%$A?&A$%$$%"('* " '&*# $ ( 7+"*?  ('"5"( ! $% (!&("*"(+&("$%'"9="	$&)!&*+& =H*$(&($%=H*$'& A F$$"&7%A$% #''&5 $'# "*"( &( !#'&$'&$%'' "*? ('"5"('$ #"	",'*!$%"*"(D  4 $ /  % ('$(!&*+& F=H*$'&&($"+ ( $%$ $%$ ' &$ &  #A' !+ &D4$/

 A  =H*$ $ $% "+ '&5 

*&$&($%$$%H+"7%+ (%,
&',"'$7F "*"(?'&5 "A' !+ &",'A$%('$"'*$H+"7CA% $($"#'&A%$$%H+"7!" ,&$*&'("$'&!"$%H+"7$"*%'$(*''&& 7'!$%'&$"+*$'&,'A(#' ('&5""H+('*' D!
 







"*? '&!' '&5$#'&$'&"J+'"($'#"*"(!"'$# 7%"('&$""5$"7?(6

)'(2 '&$'!!",=7"&("&*!$%,'(&*$%$$%(!&(&$
&',"'$7'$ #"*$(A' !+ 7"A'$%"*? ('"5"(!$%"J+'"#&$!$%'"9="	$&("(LM*$=7!' '&5$*# 7A'$%$% A & "*"( ?'&5 !" %+" A"?( " !"7#&$!,"$'#7Q

2 F 2"( 4+"7 
&$"+*$'& $ 0  $ $% *  !$%,'(&* (!& *+&  =H*$( $ $% "('&$"+*$'& & $% 5"+&( $%$ '$ "#'$$( $% H+"7 $($"#'& "*? & =( +& 
&',"'$7F !' +" $?"*"(A%$%""&$'$!+&($%$
&',"'$7*$(A' !+ 7 '& !' '&5 $ 7 ,"$'#  )!& *+& I '&( $%$ C& *& &,''&  '$+$'& A%" &# 7" #7 #'&$'& %((7 "*"( =+$ &,"$% *#&$$%'"# 7!","$'#%+"'&I*!0D"$

%' $% "*"( *&$'& & I &$'& !$% *+"$F

"+ '&5 & $%' '+ $% *+"$ "&$ 7 ($"#'&( $%$ A F "J+$( '&$"+*$'& A '#""  
&$( $%*+"$ 5, $% ! A'&5 '&$"+*$'& & $% '+ !A' !+ &6

L
M!7+!'&($%$$%(!&(&$'$%"?&A"*$(A'$%"*? ('"5"(!"A%$%"'$*&(+*$A"%'='$(=7$% '"9=" 	$&("( *$$%&$%$'# !"#I$&(=*?&$%"7"

& # 7" *$ A' !+ 7 '! '$ ?&A " %A(

"*? ('"5"(!"$%#$$"!A%$%"'$*&(+*$A "%'='$( =7 $% '" 9=" 	$&("( *$  &# 7"*$A'$%"*? ('"5"(A%&'$*$"!' $*$A'$%*&*'++&*&*"&!"$%*&J+&*

P+"'&$"+*$($%$$%'"9="	$&("(*$

"J+'"&# 7"$#??&("","*"(

 



7KH UHJXODWLRQV SURYLGH

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́ )RU H[HDFK ZHHN LQ ZKLFK DQ\ ZRUN LV SH ZKLFK LV PDGH VXEMHFW WR GHSHUPLWWHG XQGHU SDUDJUDSK D RI WKL

 &)5  

 5"  % (!'&'$'& ! 

GK0B=E$$$%$+*%""&=7 7#&$ !"  *# $( $?"J+'"( !" '$ *# $'&D   &5+5 +55$ $%$  *#*&'("(  ! =' ""&5*#&&$$%$$' *#&$'&A"?(%''*&$"$(A'$%$A%'*% I '*'$ 7 ",'( $%$ C='($% "7'&$'&*&'$7#&$D/-GK0.B

!" (('$'&  !"# ! *#&"5+ $'&+55$$%$$%)"$"#'$%7="'(*#&$'&*%%!*$$%$&'#' "",''
 







7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW VXJJHVWHG WKDW LWV UXOLQJ ZDV DOVR VXSSRUWHG E\

HYLGHQFH VKRZLQJ WKDW WKH SHUYLVLW IHH VFKHGXOH XVHG E\ 8QLYHUVLW\ ZDV3DFWXDOO\ EDVHG RQ WKH QXPEHU RI KRXUV ZRUNHG DQG QRW RQ WKH

DFFRPSOLVKPHQW RI D VLQJOH JLYHQ WDVN DV UHTXLUHG E\  &)5  ́ (OZHOO  ) 6XSS G DW  ,Q SDUWLFXODU WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWUHOLHG XSRQ D 8QLYHUVLW\ GRFXPHQW ZKLFK VHW IRUWK WKH PHWKRG E\ ZKLFKWKH EDVLF SHUYLVLW IHH ZDV FDOFXODWHG 7KLV GRFXPHQW VKRZHG WKDW

SD\PHQW IRU KRPH YLVLWV ZDV EDVHG RQ WKH KRXUO\ UDWH RI PXOWLSOLHG E\ WKLUW\ QLQH KRXUV RI ZRUN DQG WKHQ GLYLGLQJ WKHJURVV KRXUO\ ZDJH E\  WKH DYHUDJH SURGXFWLYLW\ QXPEHU SHUZHHN 7KH UHPDLQLQJ KRXU ZDV IRU PHHWLQJV SDLG RQ DQ KRXUO\EDVLV

,G %DVHG XSRQ WKLV GRFXPHQW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRQFOXGHG WKDW >W@KH

GHIHQGDQW GLG QRW SD\ (OZHOO DQ DJUHHG VXP UHJDUGOHVV RI WKH WLPH VSHQWRQ D SDUWLFXODU WDVN EXW XVHG WLPH HVWLPDWHV IRU D IODW SD\PHQW DPRXQW ZLWKDQ HQKDQFHPHQW E\ DQ KRXUO\ UDWH LI D YLVLW WRRN ORQJHU WKDQ WZR KRXUV ́,G ,Q HVVHQFH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DJUHHG ZLWK (OZHOO¶V FRQWHQWLRQ WKDW WKHIODW SHUYLVLW IHH ZDV UHDOO\ D SUR[\ IRU KRXUO\ FRPSHQVDWLRQ

:KLOH ZH DUH LQFOLQHG WR DJUHH WKDW D SODLQWLII FRXOG PDLQWDLQ DQ

)/6$ FODLP XSRQ HYLGHQFH WKDW WKH HPSOR\HU¶V XVH RI D IHH EDVHGFRPSHQVDWLRQ SODQ ZDV QRWKLQJ PRUH WKDQ D SUR[\ IRU DQ KRXUO\ ZDJH ZH

"5+ $'& +55$ $%"!" $%$ %7="'( *#&$'& & A%'*% *#='& =$% ! =( &( %+" 7*#&$'&"I* +((!"#$%(!'&'$'&!!='""&5#&$%'*&* +'&'*&'$&$A'$%$%5&" "+  $%$ I#$'& $ $% 9	 " &""A 7 *&$"+(5'&$$%# 7"/$&/0($-

8*+ $% +&('+$( !*$ %A $%$  A F

*#&$'&""&5#&$A=($ $'&"$&$%&+#="!%+"%A"?(A*&* +($%$$%('$"'*$*+"$*""*$ 7A"((+##"7H+(5#&$$$% '&$'!!$
&',"'$7F* '#$%$%A&I#$"!'&  $%+5% A A'(&$"'*$!='!"#$!%""J+'"(H=(+$''&* +('&5#$!%"$'&$,''$%A '(&&%+" 7='!"#(+$''&* +('&5'&!+'&,''$$%$ $( &5"$%&$A%+"&* (+$7'&",'*$"'&'&5&("J+'"($!!#$'&5A%, "(7I '&(+*%%7="'( &(&$J+ '!7!='""&5#&$

 



!"H+(5#&$'&$"$$%	+ '&$'!! *&&$ "*," =$% "H+(5#&$ '&$"$ +&(" $% !$!$/0
	$/($/K:+!/%B$%'"E&K
	-
 !""!"#$%

 A  "5+$%$$%('$"'*

 A $% H+"7 $ *&'(" "*"(?'&5'&'$($"#'&$'&9	,' $'&A"A' !+ !'"#'$  A  $ "*," & (,"$'#%' $%9	&"#  '#'$$'& !"*$'&$ "*,"I$&($% '#'$$'&"'($$%,' $'& A A' !+   /- 
	+"$%I '&($%$9	# 7"'$%"?&A"%A(#$$"!A%$%"'$*&(+*$A%&+ '".&""


,'(&*"&$($$"' ",

$ ? "*"( ! $% $'# A# 7 '& ""'&5 *%#&5#&$(+$'&(*# $'&&( "A"?  
&',"'$7 +(#'$$((+"'&5*"I#'&$'&# 7"%$$+$"7(+$7$#$%$'#A"?(=7# 7=+$$%$$%%'$ F*$','$7""$$%# 7$"*"($'#&$
&',"'$7!!"(&I &$'&

 A F "( H+"7 '&$"+*

'&$""5$"7A%'*%A+ (%, $%"7"$$+$! '#'$$'&'!'$
0 







:H QRWH WKDW WKLV FRQFOXVLRQ LV QRW LQFRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH MXU\¶V

YHUGLFW WKDW 8QLYHUVLW\¶V YLRODWLRQV RI WKH )/6$ ZHUH QRW ZLOOIXO 6HH

'HS¶W RI /DERU Y &LW\ RI 6DSXOSD  )G   Q WK &LU VHH DOVR 5HLFK Y 1HZVSDSHUV RI 1HZ (QJ ,QF  )G  VW &LU  DIILUPLQJ GLVWULFW FRXUW¶V ILQGLQJ WKDW RYHUWLPH

YLRODWLRQV ZHUH QRW ZLOOIXO ZKHUH FRXUW DOVR DZDUGHG OLTXLGDWHGGDPDJHV $OWKRXJK D MXU\ YHUGLFW ILQGLQJ WKDW WKH HPSOR\HU DFWHGZLOOIXOO\ IRUHFORVHV WKH SRVVLELOLW\ RI ILQGLQJ WKDW WKH HPSOR\HU DFWHG LQJRRG IDLWK 3DOR *URXS )RVWHU +RPH  )G DW  WKH UHYHUVH LV QRW

QHFHVVDULO\ WUXH )RU H[DPSOH PHUH QHJOLJHQFH E\ WKH HPSOR\HU LV QRWVXIILFLHQW WR SHUPLW D ILQGLQJ RI ZLOOIXOQHVV 0F/DXJKOLQ Y 5LFKODQG

6KRH &R  86    1HYHUWKHOHVV DQ HPSOR\HU ZKRDFWHG QHJOLJHQWO\ 2 EXW QRW ZLOOIXOO\ 2 LQ YLRODWLQJ WKH )/6$ ZRXOG QRWEH DEOH WR VDWLVI\ WKH REMHFWLYH VWDQGDUG RI UHDVRQDEOHQHVV UHTXLUHG WR

GHPRQVWUDWH JRRG IDLWK 6HH &LW\ RI 6DSXOSD  )G DW  QRWLQJ WKDW

JRRG IDLWK LV REMHFWLYH VWDQGDUG

$V D JHQHUDO PDWWHU D SODLQWLII¶V OLTXLGDWHG GDPDJHV HTXDO WKH

GHWHUPLQHG DPRXQW RI XQSDLG RYHUWLPH FRPSHQVDWLRQ  86&  E

3","4+"'F$$'#&7(("(& 7A%$%"%#

% $%*"&+"'&5"J+'"*+"!"!'& $+(7&('&, , $% I"*' ! ('*"$'&  % "&5 ! $%"!'& I#$'&$$"&$$'+'&$%'&$&$*$%'&5'&4+"'F$$'#&7*&*"&($%%'$ F5"+&(!" = ','&5$%$   & A%'*% *#='&( ! &( %+" 7*#&$'& A "" 7 *&'("(  ! ='*#&$'& &!"$%+"!$%9	%"!"$%'$$'#&7",'(&'$&*'&(#&$"$'&5$%%'$ F5(!'$%$$%*&$" J+$'&"&$(%"


& +# A ($"#'& $%$ 
&',"'$7 % !!"( &

,'(&*$%$A+ ($'!7'$=+"(&!",'&5'$*$('&5( !'$% A%& ($'&5$%7#&$ *%# *% &5(%"$%"!"","$%('$"'*$*+"$F(*''&&$

$A"( A  'J+'($((#5&("#&($%*$$% ('$"'*$ *+"$ !"  ($"#'&$'& ! $% #+&$ !""'$ 'J+'($( (#5   '   

/3/ #&-0//(-/-.B$%'"--E

2+"+&$$$%'(*''&A,*$$%('$"'*$*+"$FA"(

 



WKLQN WKLV ZRXOG EH D TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW WR HYLGHQFH FLWHG E\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRXPDWHULDO IDFW DV WR ZKHWKHU 8QLYHUVLW\FDOFXODWHG IRU WKH SXUSRVH RI FRPSHQVZRUNHG 7KH IDFW WKDW GLIIHUHQW IHHV ZHNLQGV RI KRPH YLVLWV KRZHYHU PLJKW VXSIDFWRUV RWKHU WKDQ WKH QXPEHU RI KRXUV ZWKH SHUYLVLW IHH 7KHUHIRUH WKH HYLGHQFZDV UHDOO\ D SUR[\ IRU KRXUO\ FRPSHQVDVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW WR WKH SODLQWLII LQ WKLV FKDYH EHHQ VXIILFLHQW WR RYHUFRPH WKH GH

MXGJPHQW E\ VKRZLQJ D PDWHULDO IDFW TXHVFRPSHQVDWLRQ DUUDQJHPHQW ZDV DFWXDOO\ 

&$""7$
&',"'$7F"$'


&, "
4 '" /E ( &$ #&($  A F9	* '#
&,)$$%$%#% $%*"&+"$$A"'(& !=' !I#$ "!'&  A% A" G K0B=E ! $% 9	 "5+ ,)$& "'#"' 7(("&+"F$'&$,''$A"+&'J+H=A%'*%""$(&'&(!'&'A%'*%7#&$&&'(&$'* =5'&D/-GK0B=E:$-3","=*+$%,)$ A" '(   7 &  !&+#="!%+"&$&*%!'(&&%+" 7='!"&7& ('(&$(("$%*&$" 'A%$%"&# 7A%''(=' #7 = *&'("(  "!!"#$%,"$'#",''&!$%(*''&'&,)$(&$*&$" 8*+
&',"'$7('(&$*#& A '&$&I#$"!'&('$"'*$*+"$"" 7A"((+#
/ 







' ##(&

&*"  A "5+$%$$%('$"'*$*+"$=+(

'$ ('*"$'& =7 &$ A"('&5 %" 'J+'($( (#5	*$'&/B=E!$%9	",'($%$CLM&7# 7"A%,' $$%",''&!*$'&/"*$'&/!$%'$'$ % = '= $$%# 7"# 7!!*$('&$%#+&$!$%'"+&'(#'&'#+#A5"$%'"+&'(,"$'# *#&$'&  $% * #7 = &( '& &(('$'& J+ #+&$ 'J+'($((#5D/-
	G/B=EB--.E9'J+'($((#5+&("$%9	CR"*#&$'&&$& $7"+&'%#&$FD%&
" %" 00 /( / // B$% '" -E BJ+$'&55'"%
%
	K/K.B-0/EE:!$!$5*2/0
	-B-0KEBC
$*&$'$+$&5"'& "*5&'$'&$%$!' +"$7$%$$+$"7#'&'#+#&$'##7=($"'#&$ $#'&$&&*!$%#'&'#+#$&("(! ','&5&*"7!"% $%!!'*'&*7&(5&" A ='&5!A"?"&($$%!"! A!*##"*$%$(+= 7#&$#+$=#('&$%,&$!( 7'&"("$'&+""$"$'&!$%A"?" $ $%$ #'&'#+# $&("( ! A ='&5DB'&$"& J+$$'&#'$$(EE

('$"'*$*+"$%A,"%$%('*"$'&&$$A"(

 'J+'($((#5$",' '&5 '&$'!!'!C$%# 7"%A$$%$'!*$'&!$%*+"$$%$$%*$"#''&5','&5"'$+*%*$'&A'&5(!'$%&($%$%%("&= 5"+&(!"= ','&5$%$%'*$"#''&A&$,' $'&!$%'"9="	$&("(*$!-.D/-
	G/B--.E: 
,.(0.00B$%'"---E%'=+"(&&$%# 7" ' +=$&$'  &( "J+'" C"! $%$ L$%# 7"FM!' +"$=7$%$$+$A1"'&5(!'$%&("('*$(+&+*%"&= 5"+&($%$'$A+ (=+&!'"$'#+&L'$M#"$%&*#&$"7,"('*$D%&
"00/($//B'&$"& J+$$'&#'$$(EB#%'(((EC
&$%=&*!+*%"!L%A,"M ('$"'*$ *+"$ % & A" " ('*"$'& $ "(+* &

 



-XULV GLG WHVWLI\ WKDW VKH ZDV QRW D

DFWLRQV E\ WKH 'HSDUWPHQW RI /DERU DJDLSULRU 'HSDUWPHQW RI /DERU HQIRUFHPHQW DVXIILFLHQW WR HVWDEOLVK WKH HPSOR\HU¶V JRRIRU EHOLHYLQJ WKDW LWV DFWLRQV ZHUH FRPSOL# 7"F '=' '$7 !" $% J+'A5D#:
"

--0KB$%'"---EBCR $%+",'A('$"'*$*+"$F(*''&=+ ! ('*"$'& $%$ ('*"*&'$&$ 7A'$%$%$"&5"+#!," ! (+= '&5FD BJ+$'&5 "

K/(/-B

*&* +($%$$%('$"'*$*+

&$A"('&5 A  'J+'($((##$'$ =+"(& ! ",'&5$%$'$A%&'$'&$'$+$('$*#&$'&+=#'$$(=7$%%'$ $$= $$'#&7!	+&4+"'$%%(#'&'$"$"4+"'$$'!'($%$'&'& $$"$%$ A " '(+*&* +('&5 $%$ %# *" &+"=*+ C&+" " "!'& '&(','(+ &($%7" 7&$%'"4$-4+"'%A,"A&$$%$'#'$*#&$'& &A$%$ A A"?( !"$%%'$*+ (&$"$$%$'$A" 7'&5'$*"$('$%7="'(",''$!%" % 
&',"'$7 +55$( $%I"$' " '&'& ! &7 $%?&A (5!$%9	"5+ $'&$%)"$#&$!9="
&!*$&$A"!$%%'$ ,""J+)"$#&$ ! 9=" *&*"&'&5""&5#&$