P i 

OAR Box 1802 

Prepped by Charmelle Mathews 

Document Number: 

46) IV-E-41 

Docket Number: 

A-90-37 

Printed 11/4/200811:57:59 AM Sheet 46 of 117 
P.2 

E/-c -4-1 

FOR NSR REFORM RULEMAKING DOCKET 

SUMMARY OF PAL INDUSTRY GROUP STAKEHOLDER MEETING - JAN. 12,2000 

The meeting was held Jan. 12,2000 at the Ariel Rios Building in Washington, D.C. The 

attendance sign-up sheet is attached. 

The meeting with Bob Pereiasepe was requested by a PAL industry group with 

representatives from Daimler Chrysler, DuPont, Eli Lilly, Merck, and Intel. The industies were 

represented by Pat Raher. The group gave an overview of their suggested PAL approach 

contained in their submittal to EPA dated December 1,1999. Their approach includes options 

for setting PAL levels using both actual and achievable allowable emissions. The group urged 

EPA to adopt both options to provide industry with increased flexibility and more certainty 

regarding major NSR applicability. The group also summarized their favorable experiences with 

several existing PAL at their facilities. The EPA response was that we would consider their 

proposal and views as we finalize the PAL rules. 
P.3 

\rt\tfl TVVC S4cxkc^Lde^ 

MAaJka i a — 

.i!.iJo'v"p*Vi^*-

\3^}\i6U^ 

:

uh %fk&. 

O.Todd //nc/ t 

ji hite- 6A&? 5 

j! , p 

J! B^^'fc ^ M L 

HO, 8 r<^ m7i vy 

r_.j

 o vv*3 $ € i T~? 

Mike. 5«fco<Jl 

afft/dAc 

P4y^(ye^C%^^66r/K. 

?b<. Dpj/yiL^CM^VSLl^ 

Merc )\ 

lc.L\ Ll UUJ #•*) CoV-fflrNyj 

. Mkf 

.6af^o«Hf- U^f-yiSf 

aPA 

^>i\ 

So? : .^ 3 - J? 9H 

^n-zi(p-Cy^n 

2o>- £??- H£H 

9-1 ?-.£*# ^S*>?-. 

9/? 5V/-0&7 3 . 

z 
P.4 

A^o-31 

E7-5-4-1 

FOR NSR REFORM RULEMAKING DOCKET 

SUMMARY OF PAL INDUSTRY GROUP STAKEHOLDER MEETING - JAN. 12,2000 

The meeting was held Jan. 12,2000 at the Ariel Rios Building in Washington, D.C. 

attendance sign-up sheet is attached. 

The 

The meeting with Bob Pereiasepe was requested by a PAL industry group with 

representatives from Daimler Chrysler, DuPont, Eli Lilly, Merck, and Intel. The industies were 

represented by Pat Raher. The group gave an overview of their suggested PAL approach 

contained in their submittal to EPA dated December 1,1999. Their approach includes options 

for setting PAL levels using both actual and achievable allowable emissions. The group urged 

EPA to adopt both options to provide industry with increased flexibility and more certainty 

regarding major NSR applicability. The group also summarized their favorable experiences with 

several existing PAL at their facilities. The EPA response was that we would consider their 

proposal and views as we finalize the PAL rules. 
P.5 

(lyll<Ji /IVl C Sfeu^Wdaxi .•••' 

i' 

S M&SLc£y,a_. Hflfoierr. 

i;Jo'v"X^yJ,ra~ 

i-J^aue-L/zut tjywfcif. 

;3^pVbbMl5 

ilh. flfk& V" 

...jj; YW'.. 3f^vf. 

!'' Tod d //W c 

. |ftifcr 6*8*5 . .. . 

Be^Mi e YyyiA-y-

.A0OK titoftf 

oB^I L^th^t* 

•SO 6 

\:\_JyO(tyd S €l^T"7_ 

;.; Mike . Seaoell 

.L ~^oeo ^ ^o-s-^" 

•:.: /tnn.R.M^ncuJ^. 

i-UoJ^o^. 

_C«(L4MW73&AI 

- '£fft/6te 

&!Klo((Cy 

ItymetiCftt &£.&•/*_ 

£o< Dflwi^C^YSCztf-

'/jOq/4/iJ * //ri/tkoto Zip 

C>yyL '°^ l (~rJ>*«7p/f7'y. 

/Vl e re A 

feacx 

(=;Ll Ll UU| faoa Co^-fAN^j 

Uhl 

C&jbonHi- (Ja,f(o^f 

f^wL. b"~U UL-L ^ ^ ^ ° : 

• QRq /eJ^/o^CSj ^ 

^ 

£^>0-

efA 

i

7

^ 

^ A 

JiJQ^JL_ 

<

>#-sy/*t/979 

pl'StoH'ZTl^ 

<?</8~S?6-SbS~f 

~lC?bS\tq1*\kU 

Zte-J?37-S'{y-byZ-

.3*ZL- 7?f-«^?3 

.90 3 : ,.<V.3 - 39 ?H 

To* ^3-1 ^ 

3r7^Tfe--o3?i 

#<?;>: 6<?6.iZ?f 

Oca- £??- 3-^Y 

^r* - ^^4-^^/ 0 

W-SVr'-^Str : 

-2-cO. - jf £ y^/^yys? 

?y?-w/-vtoa 

9/7 <Tc//-^^73 . 

^ ^ -r^^r ^ 

Zat-^kw-ife&y 

a