NAT I INST OF STAND & TECH IU

A1110M MlSft33

NIST

PUBLICATIONS

Nisr United States Department of Commerce

Technology Administration

National Institute of Standards and Technology

NIST Technical Note 1365

Sub-Doppler Frequency Measurements

on OCS at 87 THz (3.4 /jm)

with the CO Overtone Laser:

Considerations and Details

A. Dax

J.S. Wells

L. Hollberg

A.G. Maki

W. Urban

NIST Technical Note 1365

Sub-Doppler Frequency Measurements

on OCS at 87 THz (3.4 /jm)

with the CO Overtone Laser:

Considerations and Details

A. Dax*

J.S. Wells

L. Hollberg

A.G. Maki

W. Urban*

Time and Frequency Division

Physics Laboratory

National Institute of Standards and Technology

325 Broadway

Boulder, CO 80303-3328

*lnstitut fur Angewandte Physik

der Universitat Bonn

Bonn, D-53115 Germany

July 1994

r rATES o*

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, Ronald H. Brown, Secretary

TECHNOLOGY ADMINISTRATION, Mary L. Good, Under Secretary for Technology

NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF STANDARDS AND TECHNOLOGY, Arati Prabhakar, Director

National Institute of Standards and Technology Technical Note

Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol., Tech. Note 1365, 32 pages (July 1994)

CODEN:NTNOEF

U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE

WASHINGTON: 1994

For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402-9325

CONTENTS

page

1. INTRODUCTION : 2

2. THE NIST OVERTONE LASER 3

2.1 Sub-Doppler Experiments with the CO Overtone Laser 3

3. SATURATED-ABSORPTION CONSIDERATIONS 4

3.1 A Novel Linear Diode 4

3.2 Polarization Considerations 6

3.3 Experimental Results 8

4. OPTICAL HETERODYNE POLARIZATION SPECTROSCOPY 10

4.1 Analysis of OHPS Technique 10

4.2 Details of OHPS Experiment 12

4.2.1 The Two Stage Analyzer 12

4.2.2 The Compound X/4 Plate 14

4.3 Elimination of Spurious Signals 15

4.4 Suitable Dispersion Signals 15

5. THE C02 LASER SYNTHESIZER 17

5.1 Improvements in NIST C02 Lasers 17

5.2 Synthesizer-CO Overtone Laser Beatnote 17

6. RESULTING HETERODYNE FREQUENCY MEASUREMENTS 18

7. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 20

8. REFERENCES 21

in

Sub-Doppler Frequency Measurements on OCS at 87 THz

(3.4 jum) with the CO Overtone Laser: Considerations and Details

A. Daxf, J.S. Wells, L. Hollberg, and A.G. Maki$

Time and Frequency Division

National Institute of Standards and Technology

Boulder, Colorado 80303

and

W. Urban

Institut fur Angewandte Physik

der Universitat Bonn

Bonn, D-53115 Germany

We have investigated two techniques for making sub-Doppler frequency measurements

with the CO overtone laser. We studied three OCS transitions whose frequencies overlap either

directly with CO Av = 2 overtone transition frequencies or with the overtone lines after they

have been shifted by an acousto-optic modulator. We have investigated both conventional

saturated-absorption and an optical heterodyne polarization. While we eventually used the latter technique for our measurements, it is too cumbersome to use as a conventional laser stabilization

tool. Saturation absorption is considerably simpler and has potential for a more accurate

measurement, if some technical problems are overcome. This becomes more important in the

light of a potential use of the CO Av=2 P26 (9) transition in a new frequency chain. This

transition was used for the OCS P(27) 10°l-00°0 measurement. Polarization spectroscopic

techniques with optical heterodyne detection were used to observe the features and then to provide the discriminant for locking the overtone laser to the OCS transitions. A C02 laser

synthesizer was used for the frequency measurement basis. The new frequencies (uncertainties

in parentheses) resulting from the measurements are for the OCS 10°l-00°0 P(27), 87 117

278.492(50) MHz; OCS ll'l-OFO R(14), 87 222 001.143(70) MHz; and for the OC^S 10°1-

00°0 P(9), 87 010 586.671(75) MHz.

tguest researcher from ^permanent address:

Institut fur Angewandte Physik 15012 24th Ave. SE

der Universitat Bonn Mill Creek, WA 98012

Bonn, D-53115 Germany

Key words:

absolute frequency, measurements, carbonyl sulfide, frequency calibration standards, optical

polarization spectroscopy, saturated absorption spectroscopy, sub-Doppler frequency

measurements
1. INTRODUCTION

Since 1979, we have been involved in a major effort to provide frequency/wavenumber

calibration standards based on heterodyne frequency measurements [1,2]. Our heterodyne

frequency measurement activity came to a temporary halt when we reached the 61.76 THz (2060

cm"1 ) region, the upper limit of our Av = 1 CO laser [3]. Some measurements at slightly higher

frequencies were possible based on a doubling of the C02 laser [4]. It was the development of

the CO overtone laser [5] that made further progress possible. The most recent status [6] (over

330 transitions in the 2.6 to 4.1 fim region) suggests the potential usefulness of this laser. A

long standing NIST-IAP collaboration resurfaced in Bonn, where the overtone laser served as

a transfer oscillator in some tunable diode laser (TDL) based heterodyne measurements.

Frequencies were measured of OCS transitions in the 1 l

le l-01 le and 1 llf l-01 lf bands at 87

THz (3.4 /xm) [7]. With the exception of some measurements on CO [8] and N2 [9], our

measurements between 1979 and 1990 were all Doppler-limited. In a separate effort, Fayt et al.

[10] have made sub-Doppler measurements on those OCS transitions that are near the 9 /xm C02

laser transitions.

The Doppler-limited frequency measurements culminated in the publication of a

calibration atlas [2] which spans much of the region from 486 to 3120 cm"1 plus another small

region from 4071 to 4352 cm"1. The atlas has a spectral map and facing table format and will

be updated from time to time in the form of a computer diskette for the facing tables as new and

improved frequency values become available [2,11]. Since a deliberate effort was made to keep

the atlas at a manageable length, about three quarters of the possible frequency entries were not

included. The diskette in NIST Standard Reference Database 39 includes these omitted values.

In an effort to further improve the calibration frequencies, both NIST and the IAP in the

University of Bonn, Germany have started to make sub-Doppler frequency measurements on OCS. Our measurements were at 3.4 /tm, those of our colleagues in Bonn were near 5 /xm [12].

In this technote we describe the first NIST OCS experiments and the new frequency calibration

tables appear elsewhere [13].
2. THE NIST OVERTONE LASER

The dc-gas-discharge-excited, CO-overtone laser was developed by W. Urban and coworkers at the Institut fur Angewandte Physik (IAP) der Universitat Bonn [5] and the current

description of status and recent improvements is available in Ref [6]. Basically, this liquidnitrogen-cooled flowing-gas CO laser operates on Av = 2 transitions. It operates over the 2.6

/xm to 4. 1 urn region where some 330 lines have been made to lase. In our NIST laboratory we

have constructed a CO overtone laser similar to the laser developed in Bonn [5]. Our 1.87 m

long laser has a 450 line/mm grating and a 10 m radius-of-curvature output coupler. The LN2

-

cooled gain section is about 1.09 m long, with a bore ID of 12 mm. The operating partial

pressures of the He, N2 , air, and CO are essentially the same as the Bonn papers indicate [5,6].

(We can attest to the wisdom of using an aluminum gas cylinder for storing the CO to avoid

problems [6] arising from Fe(CO)5 in older iron cylinders.) Our pressures were measured at

the gas outlet of the laser under operating conditions (77 K, 4 ma discharge current). The

partial pressures of the gases were: for helium, 844 Pa (6.35 Torr); nitrogen, 80 Pa (0.6 Torr);

air, 6 Pa (0.05 Torr); and carbon monoxide, 53 Pa (0.4 Torr). The pumping speed of the

effluent through the vacuum pump was about 1 £/min at ambient temperatures and altitude.

The Bonn versions of the laser have the output power taken from the zeroth order of the

grating. While our grating mount has a capability for such coupling, we chose to take the output

from a dielectric-coated ZnSe coupler. This compensated coupler (the second surface of the

coupler is curved) minimizes the spreading of the output beam. In an effort to minimize the

laser linewidth, we have inserted convection barriers to enclose the regions between the

resonator optical elements and the Brewster windows of the gain tube. We have also inserted

a surge reservoir between the mixing valves and the gas inlet to the laser tube to reduce the

effect of pressure fluctuations from the flow meters. For the lines used here, we have obtained

single mode laser powers of 80 to 100 mW. The measured linewidth is about 100 kHz, and the

measured polarization quality (I hor/I vca) was 2000.

2.1 Sub-Doppler Experiments with the CO Overtone Laser

Our experiment was designed to take advantage of the CO overtone laser to make some

heterodyne frequency measurements with sub-Doppler techniques (and polarization sensitive

devices) [14-47] on OCS transitions that overlap or nearly overlap a CO laser transition. '!
different experimental approaches were investigated to see which was best for making subDoppler measurements on the OCS transitions. The first involved saturated-absorption

techniques [14-18,20,22,23], and the second used polarization-selective optical-heterodyne

techniques [24,28-37,40,43-47]. The first technique is potentially the more accurate for

frequency measurements [15-18] (provided that the transition moment of the molecule is

sufficiently large) and is also much simpler to use. However, because of the weak transition

moment involved and some technical problems in obtaining a clean modulation signal for thirdderivative detection [28,29] this technique was shelved for the time being. The second

technique produced a much better signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), but was considerably more

cumbersome. We discuss details of both experiments showing their advantages and limitations.

3. SATURATED-ABSORPTION CONSIDERATIONS

The goal of optical heterodyne frequency measurements on calibration gases is to find

precise line center positions. Despite the convenience and promising features which are afforded

by an intracavity absorption cell [14], we have chosen an extracavity absorption cell. The

extracavity operation promises better frequency accuracy of the molecular line to be measured

by controllable pump/probe intensities and negligible gas lens effects [15,16].

3.1 A Novel Linear Diode

In order to stabilize a laser to a highly reproducible saturation feature, it is desirable to

obtain a discriminant with both a high (SNR) and a small linewidth. The factor limiting the

linewidth in a saturated-absorption experiment is often the residual Doppler width [17]. This

arises from a small angle (which is usually introduced to prevent optical feedback to the laser)

between the probe beam and the counterpropagating pump beam in the low pressure absorption

cell. The common trick to prevent optical feedback and still have collinear beams is to insert

an optical diode [18]. We present the features of the optical diode we used; it is a novel,

simple, and broadband device. A comparison is made between our linear diode and the most

commonly used diode in the mid-infrared, a linear polarizer in front of a X/4 retarder plate

[15,18] which we call a circular diode.

The principal setup of our saturated-absorption experiment is shown in Fig. 1. A threemirror wavelength-independent polarization rotator rotates the horizontal polarization of the
incident laser beam to a 45° position [19]. After passing the polarizer, the single laser beam

is split into two beams with equal intensities and high quality polarizations. One is parallel to

and the other is perpendicular to the horizontal plane. As long as both beams have equal

intensities and the beam paths are nearly equal in length, one tends to observe symmetric line

shapes [20]. After one round trip, the ordinary beam enters the polarizer where the

extraordinary beam has left it before. But now the ordinary beam stays ordinary (fixed by its

polarization) and passes straight through the polarizer, where it can be focused on a detector.

Mirror

Beam Stop

€55B Mirror

Variable Oc) Rochon

polarization v!V Polarizer

rotator Detector

Figure. 1. Elements of setup for saturated absorption spectroscopy using a linear diode.

Conversely, the extraordinary beam separates in the opposite direction and can be focused to a

second detector or beam stop.

Our polarizer was of a Rochon type made of MgF2 [21]. We used the astigmatism-free

ordinary beam for probing and the extra-ordinary beam for pumping. During the round trip,

the plane of incidence at each optical component remains the same for both beams and their

polarizations stay parallel and perpendicular to this plane. Therefore, no ellipticity which would

considerably decrease the diode's quality can build up at reflective optical components.

An optical diode which used two birefringent crystals for linear polarizations has been

demonstrated [22]; we have shown that a single crystal is sufficient. It is instructive to consider

the difference in the expected saturated absorption signal strength between that produced with

a linear diode and that from a circular diode.
3.2 Polarization Considerations

The molecular absorption cross section depends on the polarization of the applied laser

beam [23,24]. This can be understood quantum mechanically by a different overlap of the mdependent wave functions related to a molecular transition expressed by the relevant ClebschGordon coefficients [23]. Classically, this effect is attributable to the fact that a light field

rotating in the same sense as the spinning molecule undergoes a pronounced interaction [25].

Thus, the saturation of a molecular transition depends on the polarization of the laser beam, the

rotational quantum number J, AJ, and the magnetic quantum number m. The absorption coefficient aP for the probe beam in the limit of weak saturation is

generally given [25] by

aP = ct - fiplp - PSIS , (1)

where

aQ = linear absorption coefficient,

fl P = self saturation coefficient for the probe beam,

PS = cross saturation coefficient,

IP = probe beam intensity,

Is = pump beam intensity.

0ps describes the interaction between the pump and probe beam transferred by the nonlinear

optical medium. It is responsible for a Lamb dip on the Doppler profile given by the linear

absorption coefficient or . The polarization dependence has already been extracted from 6PS by Dabkiewicz and

Hansch et al. [26,27]. They have taken advantage of the Wigner-Eckart theorem and have

summed the Clebsch-Gordon coefficients over the magnetic quantum numbers. They obtained

four relevant factors fty , fjr , f| r , and ftr describing the polarization dependent interaction of

the counterpropagating pump and probe beams. Here J is the lower state and J' the upper state

rotational number of the corresponding molecular transition. £+ stands for two circularly

polarized beams spinning in the same direction, f for two circularly polarized beams spinning

oppositely, f"" for two parallel linearly polarized, and £

l for two perpendicular linearly polarized

beams.
Their calculation is restricted to the following limitations:

1. Weak saturation,

2. Natural linewidth < < doppler width,

3. Spontaneous emission is neglected,

4. No multiple optical pumping, and

5. No coherence effects (already included in 2).

To get appropriate information about the signal strength by using different optical diodes, we

need to know whether the above cited f

are comparable and which f values correspond to which

experimental setup.

The comparability of the factors f is discussed in References [23] and [24], which show

that we have to refer all f's to one saturation intensity. In Ref. [24] this is the saturation

intensity for the case where two counterpropagating beams are polarized linearly and are parallel

to each other. That has already been accomplished in the same way by Dabkiewicz and Hansen

[26]. So we obtain, for example, for large J values (J > 4) the scaling law: f*:^":^

1 '? scal e

as 3/2:1/4:3/4:1 for R and P transitions and as 2/3:2/3:1/3:1 for Q transitions.

The second problem concerns only the circularly polarized case. For convenience the

circularly polarized beam passing the circular diode is normally retroreflected somewhere behind

or inside the gas sample cell (see for example Ref. [15]). Therefore, we have for that case the

situation depicted in Fig. 2. A a

+ polarized beam is going to the right and a o~ polarized beam

to the left. Since both have the same spinning direction, f" is the appropriate parameter here.

Spin

Figure 2. The two counterpropagating a

+ and a beams are spinning in the same direction.
So the saturated absorption signal (in the limit of small saturation and 7>4) is two times larger

when we use a circular diode with a retroreflector behind than when we use our linear diode.

If necessary, we can recover the factor of two by summing up the two detector signals

mentioned above. A linear diode based on the Faraday effect [18] would lead to a 2/3 times

smaller signal for R and P transitions compared to using a circular diode and a 3/2 times larger

signal for Q transitions.

3.3 Experimental Results

We set up a slightly more complex experiment than Fig. 1 suggests; the primary difference

was that we attenuated the power down to about 1 mW in each beam. Figure 3 shows a

recorded Lamb dip employing this setup. The laser was frequency modulated by applying a 1.2

kHz sine wave to a single piezoelectric transducer (PZT) on the laser mirror mount. The Lamb

dip was obtained by detecting at 3/(3.6 kHz) [28,29] and scanning the laser frequency over the

absorption profile. The gas pressure in the 1.5 m long absorption cell was 0.27 Pa and the laser

power approximately 1 mW for each beam. The SNR was 14 and the linewidth of this P(27)

10°l-00°0 transition was less than 200 kHz.

Figure 3. The third derivative saturated absorption signal of the OCS P(27) line at 3.4 /xm. The

linewidth is less than 200 kHz.

Despite this promising result, which can be improved by using more laser power in the

cell, we rejected this technique for two technical reasons. The first is a problem with the PZT

which had nonlinearities and a slight tilt with increasing voltage. The nonlinearity often caused

the Lamb dip to appear asymmetric. The second reason for rejecting this technique was that the

X
liquid-nitrogen-cooled CO overtone laser shows randomly distributed intensity spikes after

a few hours of operation (Fig. 4).

]^AY--^*ywJUJ^

Figure 4. Randomly distributed intensity spiking of the CO overtone laser after a few hours

of operation. The detection system and experimental parameters are the same as for Fig. 3.

Obviously, this limits the accuracy of stabilizing a laser to a reference line. The reason

for this spiking is attributable to frozen C02 particles falling down the laser tube wall and

crossing the laser beam. C02 is built up from dissociation products of CO in the gas

discharge exiting the laser active medium. This can be a problem for this laser (and for the

Av = 1 CO laser running on high vibrational quantum numbers) since a relatively high

amount of CO (up to 8 percent) is necessary to run these lasers [6,30].

Our quasi-wavelength-independent setup has been adopted by our colleagues in Bonn

[12,31] for calibration gas measurements at 5 jum. They had much higher (about 1000 time

higher) spectral line intensities for most of their measured OCS and CO transitions and no

spiking problem due to the low amount of CO in their 5 jum CO laser. Alternatively, they

employ a Cardanic-compensated PZT and mirror mount similar to Ref. [32] originally

designed for the Bonn C02 lasers [33,34] and a still higher modulation frequency using a

two-stage PZT [35,36].
4. OPTICAL HETERODYNE POLARIZATION SPECTROSCOPY

The polarization spectroscopy method. was invented by Wieman and Hansch in 1976 [37].

Since then, this versatile method has been used not only for several laser spectroscopic

measurements, but also for laser stabilization [38-47]. The principle of operation is that a strong

pump beam introduces an anisotropy in a sample; that is, the sample becomes dichroic and

birefringent if the pump frequency is near a molecular resonance. A weak probe beam at the

same frequency will suffer a change in its polarization if it interacts with the same molecules as

the pump beam. With an appropriate selection method, we can observe these changes in

polarization at low power. The possible variations concerning the polarization of the pump and

probe and the offset angle of the analyzer from a predetermined orientation produce different

signal shapes and intensities for molecular Q, R, and P transitions [37-42].

After the problems with the saturated absorption technique, we selected the optical

heterodyne polarization spectroscopy (OHPS) technique [24,37,43]. Its physical principle is

extensively explained in Ref. [44].

4.1 Analysis of OHPS Technique

The main advantage of the OHPS technique is that a weak signal can be considerably

enhanced by heterodyning the signal wave (amplitude Es) with a much stronger local oscillator

wave (amplitude E ), as long as E (which can also contribute noise) is selected appropriately.

To use this technique, we apply intensity modulation to the pump beam and detect the

modulation transfer to the probe beam. The result is a low noise dispersion shaped signal which

depends on the molecular transition. This sub-Doppler signal is appropriate for the stabilization

(a line-center-lock to a molecular transition) of a laser. An absolute frequency measurement of

the stabilized-laser radiation can then permit the molecule to be used for calibration. The J

dependence of the signal is calculated in Refs. [24], [37], [40], and [43].

Since both birefringence and dichroism can contribute to the signal here, the most difficult

problem is to obtain a line shape that is symmetric about the true line center [37,45,46]. The

local oscillator wave E can be obtained most conveniently from the probe beam itself by slightly

uncrossing the analyzer with respect to the polarizer by an angle 4>. An improper choice of <f> may be accompanied by asymmetries in the dispersion signal.

It is of interest to consider the SNR for this type of experiment in the infrared region.

10
Workers in the visible region use the approximation SNR ~ lh/%, where £ is the extinction

ratio of the analyzer. The detector noise, however sets a finite limit. In the visible (500 nm),

the detector noise may be 10"5 that of the detectors in the 3 /*m region [49], and we may assume

that Dt < < yP , where yP is the laser noise and P is the laser output power. In this case,

the detector noise may be neglected. The detector noise may not be neglected in the 3 /xm

region.

Let A0 be the azimuth angle change of the probe beam's polarization vector due to the

birefringence of the medium. As shown in the section following Eq. (3), A0 is proportional to

AnkoL, where An is the refractive index change, Icq is the wavevector, and L is an effective path

length. We detect changes in the azimuthal angle which produce a signal, S = 2P <I>,A#, where

$! is the offset angle of the analyzer. We consider for now a single-stage analyzer. The laser

power reaching the detector is P (^i

2 + £)> where P £ represents the leakage through the

analyzer.

The laser noise is this term multiplied by y, and since the detector and laser noise are

uncorrected, the total noise is given by N = {[yP ($ 2 + £)]

2 + A

2 }*- To find the maximum

value for the SNR (limited by the laser power [48]), we look for an extremum with respect to

the variable $,. With the optimum value for <!>, we obtain

SNR^ = Const [/y(7A)F\ for yP& < < Dt

. (2)

A good extinction ratio of the analyzer is essential. In the visible spectral region extinction ratio

values of 10"7 are often cited [37,47]. Our Rochon type analyzer had a specified extinction ratio

of | = 10~5 [21]. Practically, it is not that good because of the optical beam path through the

crystal (the crystal is often tilted to avoid feedback to the laser).

By using a two-stage analyzer we could improve the extinction ratio considerably. By using

the Jones formalism [50], we have calculated the contributions to the detector response 7^ and

achieved, by using linear approximations

7det = Ce'*^ E

2 {^^2 -^e2 -^2 6

2 + €

2 -ek Abt + 4> 1 2 + <t> l k Ab-€AKk L+4> l Ank L

+ Vi [k

2 AnLAbr +

k

2 AicLAb^

+ V,[{kQAnL)2 + {kQAbf)

2 + {AKk{JL)2 + {kQAb)2 ]} (3)

11
where Cis a proportionality constant, k is the susceptibility (k = k+ + k_), k = 2ir/\, X is the

wavelength of the probe beam, and L is the estimated overlap length of the crossed beams within

the cell. The symbols £, and £ 2 represent the extinction ratios for the first and second analyzer,

e is the ellipticity of the polarization after the polarizer, and Ak = k+ - k_ and An = n+

- n_

are the susceptibility change and refractive index change of the anisotropic medium in the

circular basis. Ak describes the dichroism having a Lorentzian lineshape, An describes the

birefringence and has a dispersion lineshape, <£, is the deviation from the crossing angle of the

first analyzer, and Abr = b* - b~ (the real part) and Ab{ = b\ - b~{ (the imaginary part) describe

the anisotropy of the cell windows under vacuum stress [24,28,43].

Since both extinction ratios have similar values between 10

-4 and 10"5

, the term % x %2 is

negligible. The same is usually true for all terms containing e

2

, since we have found

experimentally that e < 10"3

. The signal term can be expressed as 4> x EQ{EoAnk<£), showing the

heterodyning of the signal amplitude E Ank(jL and the local oscillator amplitude 4> y E [44]. The

terms A/c, (A/c)

2

, and (An)2 may lead to asymmetry of the signal, and the remaining terms are

responsible for the background.

4.2 Details of (he OHPS Experiment

The overtone laser is the starting point of the experiment in the block diagram in Fig. 5. The output of the overtone laser is directed by several mirrors to a wedged, uncoated ZnSe beam

splitter where the transmitted portion is used for the saturating beam. The beam reflected from

the front surface is used for the linear probe beam, and the beam reflected from the back surface

is directed via an acousto-optic modulator to the IR frequency synthesizer. When a frequency

overlap did not exist between the CO and OCS transitions, the beam from the overtone laser

traversed the AOM first (for a shift to the required frequency) and then onto the three functional

paths.

4.2.1 The Two Stage Analyzer

As indicated in Fig. 5, the probe beam's polarization was rotated by 7r/2 by the five-mirror

variable rotator and was then focused by mirror 1 onto a reflecting wedged germanium plate

polarizer [33,51]. The beam is recollimated by mirror 2. This increases the polarization purity

of the beam from 2000:1 at the laser output to greater than 650 000:1. A four-mirror

polarization-conserving half-wave plate [33,52] returns the polarization back to horizontal. The

12
E Q.

to o

CD m

E

C3

8

fc

00

U

o

<L) C

r-- <N

<—c

o

c

e

a

3

E/i s

o

c

3

8*

ex

o.o

Qi 3

E

2

CO

13

c

• o~-

«-» o

c3

a

3
probe beam traverses the OCS cell at a small angle with respect to the cell axis and is focused

by mirror 3 onto a second reflecting wedged germanium plate polarizer which acts as the first

stage of the analyzer. Only the component polarized perpendicular to the plane of incidence is

reflected by this L unit along on the detection path. The local oscillator wave is generated by

tilting the base of this device to the offset angle $,. A similar one stage analyzer can also be

found in Refs. [38] and [48]. These collinear signal and local oscillator beams are focused on

the Rochon analyzer by mirror 4 and mirror 5 focuses them on the detector.

4.2.2 The Compound X/4 Plate

Before considering the path of the pump beam, we point out that instead of the usual X/4

plate, we have used a two-component scheme to achieve circular polarization. Our twocomponent scheme has two advantages. First, and most important, it is possible to have control

over the polarization quality (similar to using a Babinet-Soleil compensator). Additionally, the

device is purely reflective and consequently is nearly wavelength independent.

The path (shown in Fig. 5) of the saturating beam through our two-component device starts where it emerges from the ZnSe beam splitter. The beam then has its polarization rotated by

a three-mirror variable polarization rotator to some arbitrary value, say $ (the difference

between a three-mirror rotator and a five-mirror rotator is that the latter conserves the

polarization quality much better [33]). The beam is focused by mirror 6 on a titanium plate,

which affords an adjustable angle of incidence relative to the incoming beam. The physics

involved in the phase shift on reflection from the titanium plate is described in [33] and is

simply the physics of Fresnel reflection by a metal surface [53]. A measured polarization

quality of 99.5 percent was achieved for the saturation beam by iterative adjustment of the angles

$ and 0. It is essential to have a good circular polarization quality here, otherwise the pump

wave can be considered to be composed of a circular and a linear part where dichroism can be

accompanied with this linear pump wave. According to Ref. [38] such a dichroism changes the

azimuthal angle of the probe beam's linear polarization. The resulting absorption-shaped

contribution to the signal would increase, making the dispersion-shaped signal asymmetric

relative to the baseline and relative to the baseline intersection point. The saturation beam

traversed the cell at a small angle with the cell axis. The crossing angle between the two beams

was estimated to be about 1 mrad.

14
4.3 Elimination of Spurious Signals

The experiments required a major rearrangement of our laboratory. The area available

for the saturation scheme was rather small (1 m x 2.5 m) and a considerably larger number of

folding mirrors was used than Fig. 5 would suggest. This led to some complications, since even

a minuscule reflection from the perimeter of the beam could somehow find its way back to the

sensitive detection system. Determining sufficient clearances for the beam was a tedious

procedure. The problem of interfering noise by backscattered pump light and the leaking probe

light at the detector has already been pointed out in Ref. [37]. The recommended solutions are

to use a spatial filter [24,37], an intermodulation technique [46], or a phase modulation of the

pump beam [43], or to shift the frequency between the pump and probe beam [47].

By greatly increasing the gain of the detector amplifier we found two ways to reduce the

background signal and a third procedure to reduce the background interference noise more than

2 orders of magnitude. Besides spatial shielding in front of the detector, we cleaned all mirrors

and made them meticulously free of dust before each measurement. In addition, almost the

whole optical path was flushed with dry nitrogen gas. This was very effective, since

interference noise is attributable to random fluctuations of the refractive index caused by air

turbulence in the probe and pump beam path. This flushing removed CH4 and water which are

atmospheric absorbers at 3.4 jum [54].

4.4 Suitable Dispersion Signals

When the elimination of the spurious signals was completed, suitable stabilization signals were observed. We measured the frequency of three OCS transitions which had accidental

overlaps with the CO overtone laser or its AOM shifted sidebands. Some of the data from the

experiment on the P(27)A line of OCS at 3.4 /xm are shown in the next two figures. Figure 6

shows the nearly symmetric dispersion signal which was used to lock the CO overtone laser. The common procedure for achieving a symmetric signal is to squeeze the cell windows in order

to reduce the term ^A/cLA^/2 (see Eq. (3)). This is the main contribution to the asymmetry of

the signal if e < < koAbr We investigated an alternative method which was to rotate the second analyzer (Rochon

crystal) of our two stage system relative to the first analyzer. Offset angles of <^ < 5

° were enough to achieve symmetric signals. Since the polarization of the probe beam after the first

15
Frequency

Figure 6. Dispersion signal of saturated P(27) OCS transition. The center frequency is 87 117 278.492(50) MHz and the peak to peak linewidth is about 700 kHz. The width

of the scan shown here is about 45 MHz.

analyzer is elliptical, this technique is reminiscent of the method employed by Delsard and

Keller [39]. They used a linear pump beam and a circular probe beam and found that it was

possible to change the signal continuously from an absorption shape to a dispersion shape simply

by rotating their analyzer 45°.

16
Our quantitative description does not demonstrate that we can symmetrize the signal

without changing the real zero crossing of the Lamb dip. To do this would require the inclusion

of a valid model which describes the cell windows under stress. However, not only do the

dispersion signals appear symmetric, but also another measurement using a different technique

produced a result which agreed to within 20 kHz with our result for the same 5.3 /*m OCS

transition [12,13,55].

5. THE C02 LASER SYNTHESIZER

We refer again to Fig. 5; the third beam from our wedged ZnSe beamsplitter was focused

by mirror 8 on the acousto-optic modulator (AOM), and the shifted beam was recollimated and

sent to the input of the infrared frequency synthesizer. The frequency synthesizer consists of

two C02 laser frequency standards, a microwave oscillator, a MIM diode, and a spectrum

analyzer along with a marker oscillator. (See Ref. [2], pp. 17-21, or Refs. [3], [4], or [7].)

5.1 Improvements in NIST C02 Lasers

The C02 lasers in our synthesizer were previously used in less accurate measurements and

are still stabilized with a first derivative lock. In order to upgrade the lasers and achieve higher

accuracies, we have started our improvements by converting stabilization to an external cell

(pressure 5.3 Pa (40 mTorr) C02). The output of each C02 laser was directed towards its own

85 percent reflecting ZnSe beam splitter and the reflected portions were directed to an external

cell and retroflected at a small angle to avoid feedback to the laser. The transmitted portions were combined on a 50 percent beam splitter and directed to the MIM diode, which was also

irradiated with the CO overtone laser power. Each laser was retrofitted with a new ribbed bore

design gain tube to discriminate against off-axis modes. One C02 laser had invar support rods,

the second one is currently being modified to include them. New locking-electronics and new

PZTs will complete the improvement program.

5.2 Synchronizer-CO Overtone Laser Beatnote

Figure 7 shows the time-averaged beatnote between the locked CO overtone laser (after

passing through the AOM) and a reference synthesized from a combination of C02 -stabilized

laser standards. Aside from the frequency determination, which is the primary goal, two

features are significant. The first is that the linewidth of the laser is about 100 kHz, which is

17
i« s

3 £

3 A

.t£ »- — a

a

<

-0.5 MHz +0.5 MHz

Frequency

Fig. 7. Spectrum analyzer display of time-averaged (100 scans) beatnote between the CO

overtone laser which was locked to the P(27) line and a reference from the infrared frequency

synthesizer. The center frequency is 1171.900 MHz, the video bandwidth is 30 kHz, and the

sweep time is 62.56 ms.

considerably less than the 700 kHz saturation feature. The relative phase and amplitudes of

modulation of the reference lasers were adjusted to minimize the beatnote linewidth; hence the

linewidth here is an upper limit on that of the CO laser. The second feature (not discernible here) is that the SNR of the beatnote was generally

between 25 and 30 dB, and hence suitable for stabilizing the overtone laser to the synthesized

reference. This makes it an ideal reference for use in a heterodyne measurement to measure the

linewidth of TDLs and to use in frequency offset control in an alternate scheme with a line

narrowed TDL [56],

6. RESULTING HETERODYNE FREQUENCY MEASUREMENTS

Dispersion signals similar to that in Fig. 6 were obtained for two other transitions.

Parameters for these measurements were pressures of about 1.3 Pa (10 mTorr) with an estimated

overlap pathlength L of about 1 m in a 1.5 m long absorption cell. The measurements were all

18
made with the same sample of gas at room temperature. No isotopically enriched samples (^S

for example) were used in the measurements. Table I gives the three sub-Doppler frequency

measurements made through the use of this polarization spectroscopic technique. This technique

is limited to the measurement of transitions that happen to be within the limited tuning range of

the CO laser lines or within the range of the side-band produced by the acousto-optic modulator.

The uncertainties in the measurements come from two sources. One is the uncertainty in

locating the line center. Our estimate of this uncertainty comes from two sources. One is one

half of the peak-to-peak frequency separation divided by the signal to noise ratio. The other part

is one half of the peak-to-peak frequency separation divided by the signal to asymmetry ratio,

where we define the asymmetry ratio as the difference between the midpoint of a line connecting

the peaks and the extrapolation of the off axis baseline through the zero crossing of the

discriminant. The second part of the uncertainty comes from possible deviations from locking

the C02 lasers to the desired frequency. This can arise from less than optimal setting of the

grating, DC offsets in the servo signal, and drifts in the offset that occur after initially zeroing

out such errors. Based on some locking studies, we think this could be as high as 10 kHz for

Table I. The measured transition frequencies for carbonyl sulfide.

CO OCS Transition Obs. Freq. b C02 Freq. Stds. c Beat Freq.

Trans. 3 (MHz) (MHz)

P26(9) P(27) 10°l-00°0 87 117 278.496±0.050 2x/?(8)I+/?(12)I -1261.908

P26(8) R(\4) ll lf l-01 lf 87 222 001.143+0.070 2xP(28)I + P(32)II -1056.507d

P26(10) P(9)e 10°l-00°0 87 010 586.667+0.075 2x/?(28)I+P(24)I -412.438

a For the CO laser designation the subscript indicates the lower state vibrational quantum

number and the number in parentheses is J". b The OCS observed frequency is given by the sum of the C02 laser frequencies and the beat

frequency.

c For the C02 laser designation the I indicates the 10 /xm band and the II indicates the

9 um band.

a For the measurement of the R(\4) line of the 1 l lf

l — 01 "0 band a microwave frequency of

10 999.988 MHz was added to the C02 laser frequencies.

e This transition is for 16 ,2 C

34 S; the other two are for 16 12 C

32 S.

19
each harmonic required for synthesis. The standard deviation of each measurement set was

less than the estimated uncertainties, since some possible systematic errors are included in

the estimated uncertainties.

The C02 laser frequencies used to calculate the measured OCS frequency values

in Table I were taken from a recent reanalysis of the C02 laser frequencies [57] and, for the

lines used for this work, only differ from the frequencies given by Bradley et al. [58] by a

few kilohertz.

These new OCS frequencies were added to our 5700-entry data bank and fitted

(each data point is weighted as the square of the reciprocal of the uncertainty) to determine

new molecular constants. These constants were then used to predict new frequency

calibration tables with smaller uncertainties than had existed previously. These tables appear

in Ref. [13].

7. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This work was supported in part by the NASA Office of Upper Atmospheric

Research. A. Dax was funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and the

Graduiertenkolleg "Wechselwirkung in Molekiilen" in Bonn, Germany. The Institut fur

Angewandte Physik of the University of Bonn provided a large quantity of optics for this

experiment. We thank B. Nelles and his co-workers from Carl Zeiss for polishing the

titanium mirror and Koch from the Deutsche Titan GmbH Diisseldorf for making the

substrate available to us. We also thank L. Zink of CIRES for valuable suggestions

regarding this manuscript.

20
8. REFERENCES

1. Wells, J.S.; Petersen, F.R.; Maki, A.G.; Heterodyne frequency measurements

with a tunable diode laser-C02 laser spectrometer: spectroscopic reference

frequencies in the 9.5 /xm band of carbonyl sulfide, Appl. Opt. 18: 3567-3573

(Nov 1979).

2. Maki, A.G.; Wells, J.S.; Wavenumber calibration tables from heterodyne

frequency measurements, Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol. Special Publication 821,

1991.

3. Wells, J.S.; Schneider, M.; Maki, A.G.; Heterodyne frequency measurements of

OCS near 61.76 THz (2060 cm 1 ), J. Mol. Spectrosc. HO: 170-176 (Mar 1990).

4. Maki, A.G.; Wells, J.S.; Jennings, D.A.; Heterodyne frequency measurements

of CO and OCS beyond 2100 cm 1

, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 144: 224-229 (Nov 1990).

5. Gromoll-Bohle, M.; Bohle, W.; Urban, W.; Broadband CO laser emission on

overtone transition Av=2, Opt. Comm. 69: 409-413 (Jan 1989).

6. Bachem, E.; Dax, A.; Weidenfeller, A.; Schneider, M.; Urban, W.; Recent

progress with the CO-overtone Av=2 laser, Appl. Phys.B 57: 185-191 (Dec

1993).

7. Dax, A.; Miirtz, M.; Wells, J.S.; Schneider, M.; Bachem, E.; Urban W.; Maki,

A.G.; Extension of heterodyne frequency measurements on OCS to 87 THz

(2900 cm 1 ), J. Mol. Spectrosc. 156: 98-103 (Nov 1992).

8. Pollock, C.R.; Petersen, F.R.; Jennings, D.A.; Wells, J.S.; Maki, A.G.;

Absolute frequency measurements of the 2-0 band of CO at 2.3 ^m; calibration

standard frequencies from color center laser spectroscopy, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 99:

357-368 (June 1983).

9. Pollock, C.R.; Petersen, F.R.; Jennings, D.A.; Wells, J.S.; Maki, A.G.;

Absolute frequency measurements of the 00°2-00°0, 20°l-00°0, and 12°l-00°0

bands of N2 by heterodyne spectroscopy, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 107 : 62-71 (Sept

1984).

10. Fayt, A.; LaHaye, J.G.; Lemaire, J.; Herlemont, F.; Bantegnie, J.G.; Waveguide

and diode laser heterodyne measurements with C02 laser and assignment of the

cw FIR laser emission of OCS, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 140: 252-258 (Apr 1990).

11. Maki, A.G.; Wells, J.S.; New frequency calibration tables from heterodyne

frequency measurements, Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol. J. Res. 97: 409-470 (JulAug 1992), and Natl. Inst. Stand. Technol. Reference Database #39, Wavelength

calibration tables (1992).

21
12. George, T.; Wappelhorst, M.H.; Saupe, S.; Mtirtz, M.; Urban, W.; SubDoppler heterodyne frequency measurements on carbonyl sulfide transitions

between 56 and 62 THz, J. Mol. Spectrosc. (accepted).

13. Dax, A.; Wells, J.S.; Hollberg, L.; Maki, A.G.; Urban, W.; Sub-Doppler

frequency measurements on OCS at 87 THz (3.4 /xm) with the CO overtone laser,

J. Mol. Spectrosc. (accepted).

14. Chebotayev, V.P.; Supernarrow saturated absorption resonances, Physics Reports

119 : 75-116 (Mar 1985).

15. Clairon, A.; Acef, O.; Chardonnet, C; Borde, C.J.; State of the art for high

accuracy frequency standards in the 28 THz range using saturated absorption resonances of Os04 and C02 , A. de Marchi (ed.) Frequency Standards and

Metrology, 212-221, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1989).

16. Ghosh Roy, D.N.; Bertinetto, F.; Rebaglia, B.I.; Cresto, P.C.; Effects of iodine

saturation dispersion on the 127I

2 stabilized He-Ne laser, J. Appl. Phys. 54;, 531-

534 (Feb 1983).

17. Hirano, I.; Saturated absorption spectra on the Cs-D2 line, J. Quant. Spectrosc.

Radiat. Transf. 42: 359-373 (Nov 1989).

18. Levenson, M.D.; Introduction to Nonlinear Spectroscopy, Academic Press (1982).

19. Greniger, Charles E.; Reflective device for polarization rotation, Appl. Opt. 27:

774-776 (Feb 1988).

20. Hall, J.L.; Borde, C.J.; Shift and broadening of saturated absorption resonances due to curvature of the laser wave fronts, Appl. Phys. Let. 29: 788-790 (Dec

1976).

21. Bernhard Halle Nachf. GmbH & Co. Data sheet, Berlin Germany, (1991).

22. Couillaud, B.; in Progress in Atomic Spectroscopy in Beyer, Kleinpoppen, eds.,

Part C, Plenum Press (1984).

23. Sargent III, M.; Polarized field saturation spectroscopy, Phys. Rev. A 14- 524-

527 (July 1976).

24. Teets, R.E.; Kowalski, F.V.; Hill, W.T.; Carlson, N.; Hansen, T.W.; Laser

polarization spectroscopy, Proc. Soc. Photo-Opt Instrum. Engrs. 113 : 80-87 (Aug

1977).

22
25. Meystre, P.; Sargent III, M.; Elements of quantum optics, Springer-Verlag,

Berlin (1990).

26. Dabkiewicz, Ph.; Hansch, T.W.; Polarization intermodulated excitation

(POLINEX) of the Cul 578.2 nm transition, Opt. Comm. 38: 351-356 (Sept

1981).

27. Hansch, T.W.; Lyons, D.R.; Schawlow, A.L.; Siegel, A.; Wang, Z-Y.; Yan,

G — Y.; Polarization intermodulated excitation (POLINEX) spectroscopy of

helium and neon, Opt. Comm. 37: 87-91 (April 1981).

28. Demtroder, W.; Laser spectroscopy, 494-499 Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1982).

29. Bayer-Helms, F.; Helmcke, J.; Modulation broadening of spectral profiles, PTBBericht Me-17, Braunschweig, Germany (1977).

30. Little, C.E.; The interaction of stimulated emission and gain medium in the CO

laser, Ph. D. Thesis, Macquarie University, Sydney Australia (1987).

31. George, T.; Saupe, S.; Wappelhorst, M.H.; Urban, W.; The CO fundamental

band laser as a secondary frequency standard at 5 ^m, submitted to Applied

Phys.B (1994).

32. Tuma, W.; van der Hoeven, C.J.; Parallel movement piezoelectric transducer,

Rev. Sci. Instrum. 47: 765-766 (June 1976).

33. Dax, A.; Prazisionsspektroskopie im Mittlern infraroten Spektralbereich, I Photoakustischer Nachweis von Methan, II Heterodynmessungen an OCS bei 87

THz, III Subdopplermethoden zur Ermittlung von Eichgaslinien, Ph. D. thesis,

Inst. f. Angew. Physik, Univ of Bonn, Germany (1992).

34. Biischer, S.; Resonante Absorptionszellen fiir die Infrarotlaser-photoakustische

Spektroscopie von Gasen, Diploma thesis, Inst. f. Angew. Physik, Univ. of Bonn,

Germany (1991).

35. Muller, K.; Aufbau und Erprobung einer astigmatimuskomponensierten Whitzelle

mit piezo unterstutzer Etaloneliminierung, Diploma thesis, Inst. f. Angew.

Physik, Univ. of Bonn, Germany (1993).

36. George, T.; Der CO-Fundamentalbanden Laser als sekundarer Frequenzstandard:

hochauflosende Sattigungsspektroskopie und Heterodynfrequenzmessung an CO

und OCS zwischen 1900 und 2100 cnv

1 , Ph. D. thesis, Inst. f. Angew. Physik,

Univ. of Bonn, Germany (1993).

23
37. Wieman, C; Hansch, T.W.; Doppler-free laser polarization spectroscopy, Phys.

Rev. Let. 36: 1170-1173 (May 1976).

38. Stert, V.; Fischer, R.; Doppler-free polarization spectroscopy using linear

polarized light, Appl. Physics JJ: 151-154 (Oct 1978).

39. Delsart, C; Keller, J.C.; in Laser Spectroscopy III, Hall, J.L.; Carlsten, J.L.,

eds., Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1977).

40. Saikan, S.; Angular momentum dependence of laser-induced birefringence and

dichroism in atomic resonance lines, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 68(9): 1184-1187 (Sept

1978).

41. Goddon, D.; Groh, A.; Hanses, H.J.; Schneider, M.; Urban, W.; Heterodyne

frequency measurements of the 1-0 band of HF at 2.7 /im, J. Mol. Spectrosc.

147 : 392-397 (June 1991).

42. Groh, A.; Goddon, D.; Schneider, M.; Zimmermann, W.; Urban, W.; SubDoppler heterodyne frequency measurements on the C02 10°11-00°01 vibrational

band: new reference lines near 3714 cm"1

, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 146 : 161-168 (Mar

1991).

43. Raab, M.; Honing, G.; Demtroder, W.; Vidal, C.R.; High resolution laser

spectroscopy of Cs2 .II. Doppler free polarization spectroscopy on the C'lL^X1 !*

system, J. Chem. Phys. 76(9): 4370-4386 (May 1982).

44. Levenson, M.D.; Eesley, G.L.; Polarization selective optical heterodyne detection

for dramatically improved sensitivity in laser spectroscopy, Appl. Phys. 19: 1-17

(April 1979).

45. Wieman, C.; Hansch, T.W.; Precision measurement of the IS Lamb shift and the

1S-2S isotope shift of hydrogen and deuterium, Phys. Rev. A 22: 192-205 (July

1980).

46. Belfrage, Ch.; Grafstrom, P.; Kroll, S.; Svanberg, S.; Doppler-free laser

spectroscopy measurements on a Ne discharge for determination of 22 Ne-20Ne

isotope shifts, Physica Scripta 27: 367-370 (May 1983).

47. Raab, M.; Weber, A.; Amplitude-modulated heterodyne polarization

spectroscopy, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B. 2(9): 1476-1479 (Sept 1985).

48. Bohle, W.; Konzepte der Absorptionsspketroskopie mit Polarisationseffekten,

Internal report Inst. f. Angew. Physik, Univ. of Bonn, Germany (1989).

24
49. Keyes, R.J; ed., Optical and infrared detectors in "Topics in Applied Physics" 19:

Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1977).

50. Azzam, R.M.A.; Ellipsometry and Polarized Light, North Holland Publ.,

Amsterdam (1977).

51. Murty, M.V.R.K.; Shukla, R.P.; Extinction of light in Brewster polarizers: a shadow phenomenon, Appl. Opt. 22: 1094-1098 (Apr 1983).

52. Chraplyvy, A.R.; Polarization flipper for infrared laser beams, Appl. Opt. 15:

2022-2023 (Sept 1976).

53. Born, M.; Principles of Optics, 6th ed., Pergamon Press, Oxford (1987).

54. Wolfe, W.L.; Zissis, G.J., eds.; The Infrared Handbook, Office of Naval

Research, Washington DC (1978).

55. Wells, J.S.; Dax, A.; Hollberg, L.; Maki, A.G.; Sub-Doppler frequency

measurements on OCS near 1689 and 1885 cm" 1

, J. Mol. Spectrosc. (to be

submitted).

56. Miirtz, M.; Schaefer, M.; Schneider, M.; Wells, J.S.; Urban, W.; Schiessl, U.;

Tacke, M.; Stabilization of 3.3 and 5.1 jum lead-salt diode lasers by optical

feedback, Optics Commun. 94: 551-556 (Dec 1992).

57. Maki, A.G.; Chou, C.C.; Evenson, K.M.; Zink, L.; Shy, J. T.; Improved

molecular constants and frequencies for the C02 laser from new high-7 regular

and hot-band frequency measurements, J. Mol. Spectrosc. (accepted).

58. Bradley, L.C.; Soohoo, K.L.; Freed, C; Absolute frequencies of lasing

transitions on nine C02 isotopic species, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. OE-22 : 234-

267 (Feb 1986).

*U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1994-573-013/00038

25

NISTTechnical Publications

Periodical

Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology—Reports NIST research

and development in those disciplines of the physical and engineering sciences in which the Institute is active. These include physics, chemistry, engineering, mathematics, and computer sciences. Papers cover a broad range of subjects, with major emphasis on measurement methodology and the basic

technology underlying standardization. Also included from time to time are survey articles on topics

closely related to the Institute's technical and scientific programs. Issued six times a year.

Nonperiodicals

Monographs—Major contributions to the technical literature on various subjects related to the Institute's scientific and technical activities. Handbooks—Recommended codes of engineering and industrial practice (including safety codes)

developed in cooperation with interested industries, professional organizations, and regulatory bodies.

Special Publications— Include proceedings of conferences sponsored by NIST, NIST annual reports, and

other special publications appropriate to this grouping such as wall charts, pocket cards, and

bibliographies.

Applied Mathematics Series—Mathematical tables, manuals, and studies of special interest to physicists,

engineers, chemists, biologists, mathematicians, computer programmers, and others engaged in scientific and technical work.

National Standard Reference Data Series—Provides quantitative data on the physical and chemical

properties of materials, compiled from the world's literature and critically evaluated. Developed under a worldwide program coordinated by NIST under the authority of the National Standard Data Act (Public

Law 90-396). NOTE: The Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data (JPCRD) is published bi- monthly for NIST by the American Chemical Society (ACS) and the American Institute of Physics (AIP).

Subscriptions, reprints, and supplements are available from ACS, 1155 Sixteenth St., NW, Washington,

DC 20056.

Building Science Series—Disseminates technical information developed at the Institute on building

materials, components, systems, and whole structures. The series presents research results, test methods, and performance criteria related to the structural and environmental functions and the durability

and safety characteristics of building elements and systems.

Technical Notes—Studies or reports which are complete in themselves but restrictive in their treatment of a subject. Analogous to monographs but not so comprehensive in scope or definitive in treatment of

the subject area. Often serve as a vehicle for final reports of work performed at NIST under the sponsorship of other government agencies.

Voluntary Product Standards—Developed under procedures published by the Department of Commerce

in Part 10, Title 15, of the Code of Federal Regulations. The standards establish nationally recognized

requirements for products, and provide all concerned interests with a basis for common understanding of

the characteristics of the products. NIST administers this program in support of the efforts of private

sector standardizing organizations.

Consumer Information Series— Practical information, based on NIST research and experience, covering

areas of interest to the consumer. Easily understandable language and illustrations provide useful background knowledge for shopping in today's technological marketplace.

Order the above NIST publications from: Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office,

Washington, DC 20402.

Order the following NIST publications—FIPS and NISTIRs—from the National Technical Information

Service, Springfield, VA 22161.

Federal Information Processing Standards Publications (FIPS PUB)—Publications in this series collectively constitute the Federal Information Processing Standards Register. The Register serves as [lie- official source of information in the Federal Government regarding standards issued by NIST pursuant to the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949 as amended. Public Law 89-306 (79 Stat. 1127), and as implemented by Executive Order 11717 (38 FR 12315, dated May 11. 1973) and Part 6 of

Title 15 CFR (Code of Federal Regulations).

NIST Interagency Reports (NISTIR)— A special series of interim or final reports on work performed bj

NIST for outside sponsors (both government and non-government). In general, initial distribution is handled by the sponsor; public distribution is by the National Technical Information Service. Springfield,

VA 22161, in paper copy or microfiche form.
U.S. Department of Commerce

National Institute of Standards and Technology

325 Broadway

Boulder, Colorado 80303-3328

Official Business

Penalty for Private Use, $300