IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES 

FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF ALABAMA 

NORTHERN DIVISION 

WILLIE MCNAIR, ) 

 ) 

Plaintiff/Counter-Defendant, ) 

) 

v. ) Case No. 2:06-cv-695-WKW 

 ) 

RICHARD ALLEN, et al., ) 

) 

Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs. ) 

___________________________________ 

 ) 

JAMES CALLAHAN, ) 

 ) 

Plaintiff/Counter-Defendant, ) 

 ) 

v. ) Case No. 2:06-cv-919-WKW 

 ) 

RICHARD ALLEN, et al., ) 

) 

Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs. ) 

JOINT DEPOSITION DESIGNATION LIST WITH OBJECTIONS

 James Callahan and Willie McNair (the “Plaintiffs”) and Richard Allen, et al. (the 

“Defendants”) hereby submit the following fact witness deposition designations, with objections. 

The parties reserve the right at trial to use only selected portions of a witness’ deposition 

designation, to call a witness live instead of by deposition designation, or to not use at all a 

deposition designation for a particular witness. The parties also reserve the right to use, or object 

to the use of, any portion of expert deposition testimony. 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 1 of 12
2 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Grantt 

Culliver 

Page 07 Line 14 through 

Page 07 Line 16 

Page 08 Line 17 through 

Page 09 Line 10 

Page 12 Line 23 through 

Page 13 Line 07 

Page 13 Line 13 through 

Page 14 Line 02 

Page 14 Line 05 through 

Page 16 Line 18 

Page 17 Line 01 through 

Page 17 Line 06 

Page 18 Line 20 through 

Page 22 Line 04 

Page 23 Line 10 through 

Page 26 Line 18 

Page 35 Line 06 through 

Page 37 Line 04 

Page 37 Line 12 through 

Page 38 Line 07 

Page 38 Line 20 through 

Page 39 Line 02 

Page 39 Line 08 through 

Page 43 Line 22 

Page 44 Line 22 through 

Page 45 Line 05 

Page 46 Line 09 through 

Page 61 Line 12 

Page 61 Line 23 through 

No objections. Entire 

Deposition 

Entire transcript is 

hearsay as to 

Defendants, not 

subject to any 

exception.* 

FRE 801, 802 

The deposition is 

inadmissible under 

Federal Rule of 

Civil Procedure 32. 

* In all hearsay 

objections, not subject 

to any exceptions.

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 2 of 12
3 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 65 Line 03 

Page 65 Line 08 through 

Page 66 Line 03 

Page 66 Line 23 through 

Page 68 Line 15 

Page 69 Line 12 through 

Page 69 Line 19 

Page 70 Line 14 through 

Page 71 Line 08 

Page 71 Line 18 through 

Page 74 Line 23 

Page 75 Line 07 through 

Page 75 Line 09 

Page 75 Line 24 through 

Page 76 Line 20 

Page 79 Line 23 through 

Page 80 Line 06 

Page 80 Line 12 through 

Page 81 Line 05 

Page 81 Line 13 through 

Page 83 Line 05 

Page 84 Line 14 through 

Page 86 Line 23 

Page 87 Line 14 through 

Page 88 Line 06 

Page 89 Line 17 through 

Page 89 Line 22 

Page 90 Line 14 through 

Page 91 Line 04 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 3 of 12
4 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 91 Line 23 through 

Page 92 Line 21 

Page 93 Line 09 through 

Page 94 Line 17 

Page 96 Line 09 through 

Page 98 Line 04 

Page 101 Line 25 through 

Page 104 Line 04 

Page 105 Line 11 through 

Page 106 Line 03 

Page 106 Line 06 through 

Page 106 Line 16 

Page 107 Line 05 through 

Page 107 Line 19 

Page 108 Line 04 through 

Page 108 Line 19 

EMT-1 Page 06 Line 14 through 

Page 06 Line 16 

Page 07 Line 20 through 

Page 08 Line 14 

Page 09 Line 04 through 

Page 09 Line 11 

Page 10 Line 11 through 

Page 10 Line 22 

Page 11 Line 12 through 

Page 12 Line 04 

Page 13 Line 05 through 

Page 13 Line 22 

Page 14 Line 14 through 

No objections. Entire 

deposition. 

Entire transcript is 

hearsay as to 

Defendants. 

FRE 801, 802 

The deposition is 

inadmissible under 

Federal Rule of 

Civil Procedure 32. 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 4 of 12
5 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 14 Line 20 

Page 14 Line 24 through 

Page 17 Line 05 

Page 19 Line 03 through 

Page 20 Line 20 

Page 21 Line 02 through 

Page 21 Line 18 

Page 21 Line 21 through 

Page 21 Line 25 

Page 22 Line 14 through 

Page 23 Line 07 

Page 24 Line 17 through 

Page 25 Line 18 

Page 25 Line 24 through 

Page 26 Line 20 

Page 27 Line 04 through 

Page 27 Line 21 

Page 28 Line 07 through 

Page 29 Line 02 

Page 29 Line 19 through 

Page 30 Line 08 

Page 30 Line 12 through 

Page 31 Line 19 

Page 32 Line 04 through 

Page 38 Line 08 

Page 39 Line 03 through 

Page 39 Line 06 

Page 39 Line 14 through 

Page 40 Line 15 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 5 of 12
6 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 40 Line 19 through 

Page 41 Line 08 

Page 46 Line 10 through 

Page 46 Line 24 

EMT-2 Page 06 Line 01 through 

Page 06 Line 16 

Page 08 Line 04 through 

Page 08 Line 15 

Page 09 Line 14 through 

Page 09 Line 18 

Page 10 Line 16 through 

Page 15 Line 22 

Page 19 Line 16 through 

Page 22 Line 04 

Page 22 Line 10 through 

Page 24 Line 04 

No objections. Entire 

deposition. 

Entire transcript is 

hearsay as to 

Defendants. 

FRE 801, 802 

The deposition is 

inadmissible under 

Federal Rule of 

Civil Procedure 32. 

DOC-1 Page 06 Line 15 through 

Page 06 Line 17 

Page 07 Line 20 through 

Page 08 Line 05 

Page 08 Line 17 through 

Page 09 Line 08 

Page 09 Line 09 through 

Page 10 Line 01 

Page 10 Line 20 through 

Page 11 Line 09 

Page 11 Line 13 through 

Page 11 Line 17 

Page 13 Line 04 through 

No objections. Entire 

deposition. 

No objections, 

except as to: 

39:19-40:02 

41:14-41:21 

42:06-42:11 

Leading. 

FRE 611(c). 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 6 of 12
7 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 14 Line 23 

Page 15 Line 12 through 

Page 24 Line 01 

Page 24 Line 20 through 

Page 26 Line 10 

Page 26 Line 21 through 

Page 29 Line 21 

Page 31 Line 03 through 

Page 31 Line 16 

Page 31 Line 24 through 

Page 33 Line 04 

Page 33 Line 20 through 

Page 34 Line 16 

Page 35 Line 04 through 

Page 35 Line 07 

Page 35 Line 12 through 

Page 36 Line 22 

DOC-2 Page 06 Line 15 through 

Page 06 Line 17 

Page 07 Line 16 through 

Page 07 Line 19 

Page 07 Line 24 through 

Page 08 Line 02 

Page 08 Line 12 through 

Page 08 Line 15 

Page 10 Line 08 through 

Page 12 Line 13 

Page 12 Line 19 through 

Page 12 Line 22 

No objections. Entire 

deposition. 

No objections. 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 7 of 12
8 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 13 Line 08 through 

Page 17 Line 03 

Page 17 Line 10 through 

Page 20 Line 09 

Page 20 Line 18 through 

Page 26 Line 23 

Page 27 Line 13 through 

Page 27 Line 19 

Page 28 Line 15 through 

Page 28 Line 21 

Page 29 Line 14 through 

Page 30 Line 03 

Page 31 Line 04 through 

Page 31 Line 21 

Page 32 Line 06 through 

Page 32 Line 21 

Page 34 Line 23 through 

Page 35 Line 21 

Page 35 Line 25 through 

Page 36 Line 13 

Page 36 Line 19 through 

Page 37 Line 23 

Page 38 Line 14 through 

Page 39 Line 06 

Page 43 Line 12 through 

Page 44 Line 14 

Page 44 Line 22 through 

Page 45 Line 25 

Page 46 Line 23 through 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 8 of 12
9 

Deponent Plaintiffs’ Designations Defendants’ 

Objections to 

Plaintiffs’ 

Designations 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Plaintiffs’ 

Objections to 

Defendants’ 

Designations 

Page 47 Line 11 

RN Page 06 Line 15 through 

Page 06 Line 17 

Page 08 Line 16 through 

Page 09 Line 06 

Page 09 Line 23 through 

Page 12 Line 15 

Page 13 Line 05 through 

Page 13 Line 07 

Page 13 Line 13 through 

Page 14 Line 03 

Page 15 Line 10 through 

Page 15 Line 14 

Page 15 Line 18 through 

Page 16 Line 10 

Page 17 Line 01 through 

Page 17 Line 06 

Page 17 Line 11 through 

Page 17 Line 19 

Page 19 Line 01 through 

Page 20 Line 03 

Page 20 Line 24 through 

Page 23 Line 06 

Page 23 Line 13 through 

Page 23 Line 16 

Page 23 Line 22 through 

Page 23 Line 25 

Page 27 Line 21 through 

Page 28 Line 07 

No objections. Entire 

deposition. 

No objections, 

except as to: 

27:21-28:01 

Vague and 

ambiguous. 

FRE 611(a). 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 9 of 12
10 

 Defendants do not object to entering into the record any portion of deposition testimony 

designated by the Plaintiffs. However, in Defendants’ view, each of the deposition transcripts of 

Warden Culliver, EMT-1, EMT-2 and RN should be submitted in their entirety. If the 

depositions are not submitted in their entirety, then, in addition to the portions designated by the 

Plaintiffs, Defendants counter-designate: 

Deponent Defendants’ Counter-Designations Plaintiffs’ Objections 

Grant Culliver p. 9:11 to 12:22 

p. 26:19 to 27:24 

p. 29:14-20 

p. 30:21 to 32:18 

p. 43:23 to 44:21 

p. 45:6-13 

p. 66:4-22 

p. 68:16 to 69:11 

p. 69:20 to 70:13 

p. 83:6 to 84:13 

p. 86:24 to 87:13 

p. 88:11 to 89:16 

p. 89:23 to 90:13 

p. 91:5-15 

p. 101:5-24 

p. 104:5-9 

p. 105:17-24 

Objections set forth above. No 

further objections. 

EMT-1 p. 8:14 to 9:2 

p. 10:25 to 11:11 

p. 12:5-10 

p. 13:9-13 

p. 14:4-13 

p. 14:24 to 15:8 

p. 23:8 to 24:6 

p. 27:1-3 

p. 27:22 to 28:6 

p. 33:2 to 35:1 

p. 38:9 to 39:6 

p. 42:3 to 49:6 

Objections set forth above. No 

further objections. 

EMT-2 p. 8:16 to 9:7 

p. 9:19 to 10:15 

p. 11:25 to 12:9 

p. 14:6-11 

p. 14:23 to 15:8 

p. 16:15 to 17:9 

Objections set forth above. No 

further objections. 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 10 of 12
11 

Deponent Defendants’ Counter-Designations Plaintiffs’ Objections 

p. 17:22 to 19:16 

p. 22:5-9 

p. 24:17 to 25:12 

p. 26:11 to 27:3 

Date: September 24, 2007 

/s/ Vincent R. FitzPatrick, Jr.

VINCENT R. FITZPATRICK, JR. 

HEATHER K. MCDEVITT 

STEPHANIE COHEN 

Bar Numbers (SDNY): 

VF2907; HM9973; SM7006 

Counsel for Plaintiff Willie McNair 

White & Case LLP 

1155 Avenue of the Americas 

New York, NY 10036 

Telephone (212) 819-8200 

vfitzpatrick@whitecase.com

hmcdevitt@whitecase.com

stephcohen@whitecase.com

 - and - 

RANDALL S. SUSSKIND (SUS002) 

CATHLEEN I. PRICE (PRI056) 

Counsel for Plaintiffs Willie McNair 

and James Callahan 

Equal Justice Initiative of Alabama 

122 Commerce Street 

Montgomery, AL 36104 

Telephone: (334) 269-1803 

Facsimile: (334) 269-1806 

rsusskind@eji.org

cprice@eji.org

/s/ James W. Davis

TROY KING (KIN047) 

ATTORNEY GENERAL 

James W. Davis (DAV103) 

Assistant Attorney General 

J. Clayton Crenshaw (CRE007) 

Assistant Attorney General 

(334) 242-7300 

(334) 353-8440 Fax 

ccrenshaw@ago.state.al.us

jimdavis@ago.state.al.us

OF COUNSEL: 

Office of the Attorney General 

11 South Union Street 

Montgomery, AL 36130 

Facsimile: (212) 354-8113 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 11 of 12
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

 I certify that on September 24, 2007, a copy of the foregoing was filed electronically with 

the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system which will send notification of such filing to 

the following: J. Clayton Crenshaw, James W. Davis, Corey Maze and Jasper Roberts. 

 /s/ Stephanie Cohen 

STEPHANIE COHEN 

Bar Number (SDNY): SM7006 

Counsel for Plaintiff Willie McNair 

White & Case LLP 

1155 Avenue of the Americas 

New York, NY 10036 

Telephone: (212) 819-8200 

Facsimile: (212) 354-8113 

stephcohen@whitecase.com 

Case 2:06-cv-00695-WKW-CSC Document 116 Filed 09/24/2007 Page 12 of 12