Attachment N 

2009 Emission Inventory 

Best & Final Changes 
Best and Final Changes (as of Dec. 17, 2007)

Point Source SectorRequest ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

ALNov. 14

EGUNonEGU

From Christal Thompson: "Ed, None of the changes we made to the 2018 inventory should be reflected in the 2009. All of these changes will take place after 2009. Let me know if you have any questions. Thanks, Christal"

None required 

FLNov. 9

EGU For 2018, MACTEC removed scrubbers from Lansing Smith 

(ORIS=643) units 1 & 2. IPM Did not have scrubbers in 2009, so no changes are needed 

None required 

FLNov. 9

EGU IPM did not assign scrubbers in 2009, but scrubbers are currently 

being installed. From Tom Rogers: "It will be close, they are constructing the scrubbers as we speak. I would include the scrubbers for 2009."

12033-0330045 Gulf Power Crist Changed 2009 EM emissions:  Unit 4 SO2 from 3038.0 to 303.8 tpy Unit 5 SO2 from 3160.9 to 316.1 tpy Unit 6 SO2 from 12421.1 to 1232.1 tp Unit 7 SO2 from 18599.4 to 1859.9 tpAdded SO2 record to CE table with 90Changed stack temp to 169 per VISTA

FLNov. 9

EGU IPM forecast no operation (or emissions) for Northside (ORIS=667) 

units 1A and 2A. For 2018, FLDEP estimated emissions using the 2002 base and growth factors for Northside units 1A and 2A. Tom Rogers indicated the same approach should be used for 2009. 

2009 emissions were interpolated betwB&F emissions to get 2009 B&F emissUnit 1A SO2 2002=5,089.7 tpy 2018=2009=5,466.1 Unit 1A NOx 2002=871.6 tpy 2018=Unit 2A SO2 2002=2,420.6 tpy 2018=2009=2,599.6 Unit 2A NOx 2002=424.1 tpy 2018=
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

FLAug 31andNov 9

NonEGU From Tom Rogers: " BART – One unit needs to be changed (Georgia 

Pacific (1070005), unit 15). "From Tom Rogers: "Change also needs to be made in 2009"

121071070005 Georgia Pacific Unit 15Changed 2018 EM file as follows: NOx from 508.68 to 71.1 tpy CO from 54.11 to 459 tpy SO2 from 3950.9 to 2 tpy PM10-PRI from 59.53 to 0 tpy PM25-PRI from 41.81 to 0 tpyChanged 2018 EP file as follows: SCC from 10200401 to 10200601 (RChanged 2018 ER file as follows: Stack height from 237 to 156.5 ft Stack temperature from 445 to 450 Exit velocity from 60 to 45.6 Flow rate from 3858 to 2901
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

FLAug 31

EGU From Tom Rogers re:2018: " Corrections to Point Sources – These 

changes are primarily associated with changes to the state’s oil-fired utility boilers. Where the IPM 2018 solution has either shut-down or converted all these units to natural gas only, the department has reason to believe that these units may continue to operate using oil. A total of 12 facilities, comprising 24 oil-fired units are being modified." From Tom Rogers re:2009: "Assuming these sources were converted in IPM prior to 2009, I would use the 2002 data for all the units."Assume the following Oil-fired units will continue to burn oil: 0090006 Cape Canaveral Units 1 and 2 0090196 Indian River Units 1, 2, and 3 0110036 Port Everglades Units 1, 2, 3, and 4 0250003 Turkey Point Units 1 and 2 0550018 TECO Phillips Station Units 1 and 2 0810010 Manatee Units 1 and 2 0850001 Martin Units 1 and 2 0990042 Riviera Units 3 and 4 1010017 Anclote Units 1 and 2 1050004 C.D. McIntosh Unit 1 1210003 Suwanneee Rive Unit 3 0310045-B Northside Unit 3

Made Changes to 2009 EM file as direTotal 2002 Typical Emissions from the SO2 132,298 tpy NOx 46,698 tpy VOC 784 tpy CO 35,068 tpy PM10-PRI 11,251 tpy PM25-PRI 8,960 tpyBased G2 2009 Emissions from these  SO2 < 1 tpy NOx 176 tpy VOC 4 tpy CO 55 tpy PM10-PRI 5 tpy PM25-PRI 5 tpyBest and Final 2009 Emissions from th SO2 132,298 tpy NOx 46,698 tpy VOC 784 tpy CO 35,068 tpy PM10-PRI 11,251 tpy PM25-PRI 8,960 tpyAdded necessary records to CE, PE, ERan QA Checker to verify complete se

GADec. 16

EGU From Jim Boylan: " Georgia would like to make updates to the SO2 

emissions at Plant Bowen (Units 3-4), Plant Hammond (Units 1-4), and Plant Wansley (Unit 1) to reflect 95% scrubber control efficiency instead of 90%. Please see attached spreadsheet for details. "

Changed 2009 EM table as follows:Bowen (01500011) Unit SG03 SO2 from 4938.37 to 246 Unit SG04 SO2 from 5086.19 to 253Hammond (11500003) Unit SG01 SO2 from 517.2 to 258.6  Unit SG02 SO2 from 519.9 to 259.9  Unit SG03 SO2 from 514.6 to 257.3  Unit SG04 SO2 from 2164.0 to 1082Wansley (14900001) Unit SG01 SO2 from 3780.60 to 189Changed CE table to show 95% SO2 e
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

KYNov 7

EGU Per a consent decree and for BART, for East Kentucky Power 

Cooperative (EKPC) Spurlock Station (21-161-00009) Units 1 and 2 add WFGD SO2 controls for 2009

Changed 2009 EM emissions:  Unit 1 SO2 from 12,861.9 to 1,286.19  Unit 2 SO2 from 19,494.4 to 1,949.44 Added SO2 record to CE table with 90Changed stack temp to 169 per VISTA

KYNov 7

EGU For 2009 emissions, add omitted pre-2009 SCR NO2 control for Duke 

Energy East Bend (21-015-00029). The SCR control came online in 2002 and was reflected in Duke Energy East Bend Unit 2 2002 emissions provided to VISTAS

No changes to 2009 EM emissions sinreflected in the emission rate. Added NOx record to CE table with 76

KYNov 7

EGU For 2009 emissions, change the NO2 control efficiency for East 

Kentucky Power (EKPC) Cooper (21-199-00005) Unit 2 to reflect Low NOx Burner control and not a SCR

Changed 2009 EM emissions:  Unit 2 NOx from 500.1 to 2406.5 tpyChanged NOx record in CE table fo 90efficiency

KYNov 7

EGU For 2009 emissions, change the SO2 and NO2 control efficiency for 

AEP Big Sandy (21-127-00003) Unit 1 to reflect no SO2 scrubber control, and Overfire Air NO2 control instead of a SCR NO2 control

Changed 2009 EM emissions:  Unit 1 SO2 from 1,177.4 to 11,774 tpy Unit 1 NOx from 588.7 to 3,924.3 tpyChanged SO2 record in CE table from Changed NOx record in CE table from Changed stack temp from 169 to 314 with no scrubber) 

MSAug 30

EGU From Elliot Bickerstaff re:2018: "Attached is a spreadsheet with 

Mississippi's revisions for the best and final run. There are two worksheets. The first has some EGUs that were shut down by IPM and need to be added back in for 2018. We are using the 2002 emissions data. "2801100031 Entergy Delta Plant2804900112 Entergy Rex Brown Plant2814900027 Entergy Baxter Wilson Plant2815100048 Entergy Gerald Andrus PlantSame changes needed for 2009

Made Changes to 2009 EM file as direTotal 2002 Typical Emissions from the SO2 67 tpy NOx 11,267 tpy VOC 161 tpy CO 2,068 tpy PM10-PRI 230 tpy PM25-PRI 224 tpyAdded necessary records to CE, PE, ERan QA Checker to verify complete se

NC No Changes Requested None required 
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

SCAug 31

EGU From Carla Bedenbaugh: "I am sending this e-mail to give some 

additional information regarding SC's desire to have fuel oil burning units put back into our 2018 VISTAS inventory. It seems the IPM has predicted fuel oil would not be combusted in SC in 2018, but we do not believe that to be the case at this time. I have compared our current VISTAS 2002 inventory to the current 2018 to try and identify the fuel burning processes that were excluded in the 2018 inventory. I have attached an EXCEL file that lists the units from 2002 that I have identified. "

Added 99 oil-fired units from 2002 inveinventory:Total emission added in 2009 from thefollows: SO2 688 tpy NOx 526 tpy VOC 10 tpy CO 69 tpy PM10-PRI 53 tpy PM25-PRI 37 tpy

SCAug 31

nonEGU From Carla Bedenbaugh: "We have identified several Large Facilities 

that are in the VISTAS’ current 2009 and 2018 inventories, but have permanently closed. Please make sure these sources are removed, or their emissions zeroed out, in the 2009 and 2018 inventories. Below are the closed facilities " Avondale Mills Horse Creek 0080-0098 Avondale Mills Stevens 0080-0001 Avondale Mills Swint 0080-0005 Avondale Mills Warren 0080-0039 Avondale Mills Gregg 0080-0061 CMC Joist: Cayce 1560-0116 Delta Mills: Delta 1680-0008  Efco Corp 0300-0025 Fuji Photo Film: M Plant 1240-0050 Guardian Fiberglass (formerly Trigen Biopower) 1240-0060 Korn Industries Sumter Cabinet 2140-0009 Sea-Hunt Boat 1560-0117 Springs Global: Katherine Plant 0640-0035 Springs Global: Elliott 0640-0036 Takata Restraint Systems 0660-0033 Vytech 0200-0050

Changed 2009 EM emissions to 0 for eTotal emission reductions in 2009 from are as follows: SO2 1,141 tpy NOx 703 tpy VOC 1,263 tpy CO 554 tpy PM10-PRI 412 tpy PM25-PRI 343 tpy
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

SCDec 18

EGU From Carla Bedenbaugh: "I spoke to the engineer and Cross Unit #4 

is planned to be running by the end of 2008 and should be included in the 2009 inventory. The new Florence County units should not be in the 2009 inventory. "

Add these emissions for new Cross Un SO2 3,834.8 tpy NOx 1,278.2 tpy VOC 54.56 tpy CO 454.67 tpy PM10-PRI 595.84 tpy PM25-PRI 470.37 tpy NH3 27.28 tpy

TNSept 4

nonEGU From Julie Aslinger: "The following companies have shut down. 

(These changes would apply to both the 2009 and 2018 inventories.) "47011-0004 – all sources (Cleveland Chair Company)47011-0012 – all sources (Allied Signal, Inc.)47053-0143 – all sources (A. O. Smith Corporation)47059-0008 – all sources (Five Rivers Manufacturing)47059-0116 – all sources (Greeneville Casting, Inc.)47065-3500 – all sources (Velsicol Chemical – Hamilton County)47107-0142 – all sources (Advanced Spa Designs)

Changed 2009 EM emissions to 0 for eTotal emission reductions in 2009 from follows: SO2 7 tpy NOx 67 tpy VOC 523 tpy CO 81 tpy PM10-PRI 193 tpy PM25-PRI 167 tpy

TNSept 4

nonEGU From Julie Aslinger: "The following individual sources have shut down. 

(These changes would apply to both the 2009 and 2018 inventories.) "47009-0130-002 (APAC – TN, Inc.-Harrison Construction – Asphalt plant)47009-0130-003 (APAC – TN, Inc.-Harrison Construction – Asphalt crusher)47139-0004-001 (Intertrade - Number 6 acid plant)

Changed 2009 EM emissions to 0 for eTotal emission reductions in 2009 from follows: SO2 2,145 tpy NOx 47 tpy VOC 33 tpy CO 43 tpy PM10-PRI 10 tpy PM25-PRI 6 tpy

TNSept 4

nonEGU From Julie Aslinger: "A portion of the following source has shut down - 

47163-0003-020101 (Eastman, B-83-1 Stoker Boilers). This source previously consisted of 14 boilers (Boilers 11-24). Boilers 11-17 have been removed from service. A quick calculation of heat input capacity has determined that boilers 11-17 made up 26.64% of the total heat input capacity of the source. Emissions from this source should be reduced by 26.64%. (This reduction should also apply to 2009 emissions.) "

Changes 2009 EM emissions as follow CO from 808.28 to 592.95 tpy NOx from 933.6 to 864.9 tpy PM10 from 32.5 to 23.8 tpy PM25 from 32.5 to 23.8 tpy SO2 from 1583.7 to 1161.8 tpy VOC from 2.0 to 1.47 tpy
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

VANov. 2

EGUnonEGU

From Doris McLeod: "These are SO2 only because the big NOx reductions at EGU’s were already submitted in a much previous inventory version, and I don’t have any good estimation data on cobenefits for PM reduction due to additional SO2 control. "Affected Facilities:CNTY FAC_ID FACILITY023 00003 ROANOKE CEMENT COMPANY031 00156 DOMINION - ALTAVISTA POWER STATION093 00006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER COMPANY095 00022 OWENS-BROCKWAY GLASS CONTAINER099 ORIS54304 SEI BIRCHWOOD POWER FACILITY101 00001 STONE CONTAINER CORP (D/B/A SMURFIT-STON117 ORIS52007 MECKLENBURG COGENERATION FACILITY143 00100 OWENS-BROCKWAY GLASS CONTAINER INC670 00055 JAMES RIVER COGENERATION COMPANY670 00058 HOPEWELL COGENERATION LTD PARTNERSHIP740 ORIS10071 COGENTRIX PORTSMOUTH730 00001 SOUTHSIDE VIRGINIA TRAINING CENTER550 00026 DOMINION - CHESAPEAKE670 ORIS10771 LG&E WESTMORELAND HOPEWELL

Made changes to SO2 emissions as diaccount for permit limits and changes t2009 SO2 emissions from the units idespreadsheet changed as follows as a rchanges:SO2 from these units reduced from 64Made appropriate changes to CE tablescrubbers are or are not planned

WVNov. 9

EGU From Laura Crowder: Pleasants Units 1 and 2 had SO2 emissions 

reduced to account for the facility's inclusion of previously bypassed 15% effluent stream to the scrubber and the control efficiency and emissions will reflect a change from 79.9% to 95% control. Apply this change to 2009 also

Changed 2009 EM emissions:  Unit 1 SO2 from 5,758.97 to 1,432.58  Unit 2 SO2 from 5,605.08 to 1,394.30 Changed SO2 record in CE table to 95
Request ID Sector Nature of Request MACTEC Action 

WVSept 5 Oct. 5 andDec 14

NonEGU From Bob Betterton: "Weirton Steel (54-029-00001) and Wheeling 

Pittsburgh Steel (54-009-00002): Two sources in our Weirton PM2.5 nonattainment area, Weirton Steel (ISG Weirton) and Wheeling Pittsburgh Steel, have undergone significant, permanent process changes since 2002. WV DEP staff have consulted among ourselves as well as with facility staff and determined that calendar year 2004 emissions represent a better basis for future year emissions estimates. Therefore, we have compiled PM precursor emissions data from the 2004 inventory for these sources to use as a surrogate to apply VISTAS most current growth factors. The first two attachments contain projected emissions for 2009 and 2018 in NIF format. These are formatted as NIF EM (emissions) records. " 

Made Changes to 2009 EM file as direWV supplied PM10-FIL and PM25-FILAugmentation routine to generated PMPM10-PRI and PM25-PRI records; Addnecessary records to CE, PE, EP, EU, Ran QA Checker to verify complete sewidows/orphans2009 Emissions from Wheeling-Pitt cha SO2 from 1,006 to 518630 tpy NOx from 486 to 417 tpy VOC from 257 to 201 tpy CO from 259 to 153 tpy PM10-PRI from 249 to 164 tpy PM25-PRI from 232 to 137 tpy NH3 from 142 to 1157 tpy2009 Emissions from ISG Wierton cha SO2 from 935 to 1,119 tpy NOx from 1,159 to 1,184 tpy VOC from 835 to 97 tpy CO from 8,564 to 2,479 tpy PM10-PRI from 6,622 to 430 tpy PM25-PRI from 5,840 to 413 tpy NH3 from 0 to 0 tpy
Best and Final Changes (as of Dec. 18, 2007)

Point Source SectorBEST AND FINAL 2009 INVENTORY (Dec. 18, 2007)STATE_NAME SO2 NOx VOC CO PM10-PRI PM25-PRI 

Alabama 479,297.45 151,714.01 49,116.84 195,355.78 32,389.21 23,150.62 Florida 354,481.95 179,660.41 39,612.01 158,733.03 60,128.40 48,808.85 Georgia 462,666.47 148,849.68 36,430.09 171,148.11 40,993.63 29,889.69 Kentucky 308,086.83 135,020.40 49,154.07 137,836.71 23,636.93 15,965.57 Mississippi 102,209.87 103,673.94 38,311.01 64,864.93 24,425.99 14,194.93 North Carolina 284,822.53 101,289.48 62,879.47 68,685.94 36,062.72 26,406.42 South Carolina 176,314.59 88,035.24 35,126.64 71,577.19 33,000.42 25,596.28 Tennessee 323,514.15 123,925.87 74,463.57 126,539.56 50,229.12 40,487.04 Virginia 232,815.90 115,358.49 44,513.53 80,860.98 18,651.70 14,153.14 West Virginia 324,621.77 124,313.75 14,377.33 105,347.65 16,470.08 10,186.97 

3,048,831.51 1,271,841.27 443,984.56 1,180,949.88 335,988.20 248,839.51 

BASE G 2009 INVENTORY (July 2007)STATE_NAME SO2 NOx VOC CO PM10-PRI PM25-PRI Alabama 479,297.45 151,714.01 49,116.84 195,355.78 32,389.21 23,150.62 Florida 251,565.06 132,185.18 38,789.06 122,965.05 48,878.99 39,855.83 Georgia 471,435.90 148,849.68 36,430.09 171,148.11 40,993.63 29,889.69 Kentucky 326,610.90 129,778.40 49,154.07 137,836.71 23,636.93 15,965.57 Mississippi 102,142.89 92,408.67 38,151.27 62,798.82 24,201.97 13,976.14 North Carolina 284,822.53 101,289.48 62,879.47 68,685.94 36,062.72 26,406.42 South Carolina 172,932.84 86,934.29 36,325.03 71,608.33 32,764.33 25,431.73 Tennessee 326,088.42 124,288.62 75,020.25 126,878.89 50,441.66 40,668.20 Virginia 255,671.93 113,593.24 44,503.72 80,855.00 18,556.16 14,055.83 West Virginia 333,462.53 124,358.41 15,171.10 111,537.99 22,746.75 15,709.19 

3,004,030.45 1,205,399.98 445,540.90 1,149,670.62 330,672.35 245,109.22 

Difference between Best and Final compared to Base GSTATE_NAME SO2 NOx VOC CO PM10-PRI PM25-PRI Alabama 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Florida 102,916.89 47,475.23 822.95 35,767.98 11,249.41 8,953.02 Georgia -8,769.43 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Kentucky -18,524.07 5,242.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Mississippi 66.98 11,265.27 159.74 2,066.11 224.02 218.79 North Carolina 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 South Carolina 3,381.75 1,100.95 -1,198.39 -31.14 236.09 164.55 Tennessee -2,574.27 -362.75 -556.68 -339.33 -212.54 -181.16 Virginia -22,856.03 1,765.25 9.81 5.98 95.54 97.31 West Virginia -8,840.76 -44.66 -793.77 -6,190.34 -6,276.67 -5,522.22 

44,801.06 66,441.29 -1,556.34 31,279.26 5,315.85 3,730.29 

Negative number indicates Best&Final emissions decreased from BaseGPositive number indicates Best&Final emissions increased from Base G