Boiler No. 3 Boiler No. 4 

% Sulfur Annual Costs % Sulfur Annual Costs 

1.0 $0.68 million 0.5 $9.2 million 

0.7 $0.80 million 0.3 $18.3 million 

0.5 $3.2 million -- -- 

0.3 $5.7 million -- -- 
% Sulfur 

Average Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/ton SO2 

Removed) 

Incremental 

Cost 

Incremental 

Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/ton SO2 

Removed) 

1 $2,189 -- -- 

0.7 $1,234 $0.12 million $354

0.5 $3,700 $2.44 million $10,808

0.3 $5,156 $2.44 million $10,808

% Sulfur 

Average Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/ton SO2 

Removed) 

Incremental 

Cost 

Incremental 

Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/ton SO2 

Removed) 

0.5 $27,952 -- -- 

0.3 $15,835 $9.1 5 million $1 1,046 
TABLE 3-7

VISIBILITY IMPACT RANKINGS AT PSD CLASS I AREAS

FPL ENERGY WYMAN UNIT NO. 3

Fuel Sulfur Content 1.6% 1.0% 0.7% 0.5%

Acadia National Park 3.36 2.37 1.93 1.58

Great Gulf Widerness Area 1.23 0.87 0.70 0.58

Lye Brook Wilderness Area 0.49 0.38 0.25 0.20

Moosehorn Wilderness Area 1.46 0.99 0.77 0.61

Presidential Range-Dry River Wilderness Area 1.76 1.54 1.07 0.90

Roosevelt Carnpobello International Park 1.43 0.97 0.75 0.60

Cumulative Impacts 9.73 7.12 5.47 4.47

TABLE 3-8

VISIBILITY IMPACT RANKINGS AT PSD CLASS I AREAS

FPL ENERGY WYMAN UNIT NO. 4

Fuel Sulfur Content 0.7% 0.5%

Acadia National Park 3.14 2.73

Great Gulf Widerness Area 1.55 1.31

Lye Brook Wilderness Area 0.74 0.60

Moosehorn Wilderness Area 1.70 1.41

Presidential Range-Dry River Wilderness Area 1.95 1.70

Roosevelt Carnpobello International Park 1.56 1.29

Cumulative Impacts 10.64 9.04
0.3%

1.21

0.47

0.14

0.46

0.73

0.44

3.45

0.3%

2.30

1.06

0.44

1.09

1.38

0.99

7.26
TABLE 5-2 

SO2 CONTROL TECHNOLOGY FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS -BOILER NOS. 3 AND 4 

Technically 

Estimated Feasible and 

SO2 Abatement Method Efficiency Demonstrated? 

Low-sulfur (0.05, 0.0015%) No. 2 Fuel Oil 98% Yes 

Reduced sulfur (l%, 0.7%, 0.5%) No. 6 Fuel Oil 30-50% Yes 

Wet Scrubbers >90% Yes 

Dry Scrubbers 60-95% No 
Rank Based on Rank Based on 

Control Project 

Efficiency Suitability 

1 2

4 1

2 3

3 4
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 4 1,035,313 524,077 666,785 56,017 323,562 140,505

Unit 

2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

Unit 4 10,027,949 4,943,088 6,382,955 577,749 3,2 12,458 1,559,476

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 4 66,853 32,954 42,553 3,852 21,416 10,397

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 20.90% 17.40% 21.70% 1.50% 6.60% 3.30%

Unit 4 18.20% 9.00% 11.60% 1.00% 5.80% 2.80%

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,149.1 1,383.0 1,499.8 74.9 452.5 255.1

Unit 4 3,226.7 1,569.6 1,992.1 170.6 1,050.2 574.8

 EPA Clean Air Market Acid Rain database. 

Based on annual heat input and assuming 150,000 Btu/gallon. 'Based on annual heat input and maximum heat input rate

Capacitv Factor

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 -2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input

SO2 Emissions

Annual Fuel Usage
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

779,695 595,431 361,401 189,790 232,034

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

7,485,519 5,663,022 3,480,352 1,895,104 2,385,967

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

49,903 37,753 23,202 12,634 15,906

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

19.10% 19.60% 11.60% 4.10% 4.90%

13.60% 10.30% 6.30% 3.40% 4.30%

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,266.1 1,441.4 787.4 263.7 353.8

2,398.2 1,780.9 1,081.4 610.4 812.5

ut and maximum heat input rates of 1,190 MMBtu/hr and 6,290 MMBtu/hr for Boiler Nos. 3 and 4, respectively. 

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 

 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 

2-Year Average Fuel Usage

2-Year Average Capacity Factor 
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 2003 (MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

2 %S #6 @ $11.63 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 25,285,365 $ 21,116,952 $ 25,130,453 $ 1,812,361 $ 8,013,407 $ 3,979,600 

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 20.90% 17.40% 21.70% 1.50% 6.60% 3.30%

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 2,276 1,900 2,366 163 721 358

Capacitv Factor

Annual Fuel Usage

Calculated SO2 Emissions

Annual Fuel Cost for

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 - 2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

2-Year Average 

Fuel Cost for 2 %S #6 @ $11.63 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 23,201,164 $ 23,705,208 $ 14,052,913 $ 4,912,884 $ 5,996,509 

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

19.10% 19.60% 11.60% 4.10% 4.90%

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

2,088 2,133 1,265 442 540

2-Year Average Capacity Factor 

2-Year Average Fuel Usage

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 2003 (MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

1.6 %S #6 @ /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - 

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 20.90% 17.40% 21.70% 1.50% 6.60% 3.30%

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,820 1,520 1,893 130 577 286

Cumulative Visibility Impact 

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

Annual Fuel Cost for

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 - 2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input

Capacitv Factor

Annual Fuel Usage

Calculated SO2 Emissions
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

2-Year Average 

Fuel Cost for 1.6 %S #6 @ $0.00 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - 

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

19.10% 19.60% 11.60% 4.10% 4.90%

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,670 1,707 1,012 354 432

Cumulative Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 

2-Year Average Capacity Factor 

2-Year Average Fuel Usage

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 2003 (MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

1 %S #6 @ $11.97 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 26,024,576 $ 21,734,300 $ 25,865,135 $ 1,865,345 $ 8,247,677 $ 4,095,942 

1 %S #6 @ $11.97 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 739,211 $ 617,349 $ 734,682 $ 52,984 $ 234,270 $ 116,343 

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,138 950 1,183 82 361 179

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,138 950 1,183 82 361 179

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 650 650 621 650 650 650

Greatest Visibility Impact (d

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

Greatest Visibility Improvemen

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 0.99 0.99 0.99 0.99 0.99 0.99

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 746,678 623,584 742,103 53,519 236,636 117,518

Calculated SO2 Emissions

Annual Fuel Cost for

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 -2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input

Increased Annual Fuel Cost for

Calculated SO2 Emissions Reductions

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

Annual Fuel Usage
Cumulative Visibility Impact 

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

Cumulative Visibility Improveme

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 2.61 2.61 2.61 2.61 2.61 2.61

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 283,223 236,532 281,487 20,300 89,759 44,576

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

2-Year Average 

Fuel Cost for 1 %S #6 @ $11.97 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 23,879,444 $ 24,398,224 $ 14,463,746 $ 5,056,511 $ 6,171,816 

Increased 2-Year 

Average Fuel Cost 1 %S #6 @ $11.97 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 678,280 $ 693,016 $ 410,833 $ 143,627 $ 175,306 

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,044 1,067 632 221 270

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,044 1,067 632 221 270

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

650 650 650 650 650

Greatest Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

Greatest Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

0.99 0.99 0.99 0.99 0.99

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

685,131 700,016 414,983 145,078 177,077

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 

2-Year Average Fuel Usage

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions Reductions

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
Cumulative Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

umulative Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

2.61 2.61 2.61 2.61 2.61

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

259,877 265,523 157,407 55,029 67,167

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 4 1,035,313 524,077 666,785 56,017 323,562 140,505

Unit 2003 (MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

Unit 4 10,027,949 4,943,088 6,382,955 577,749 3,212,458 1,559,476

0.7 %S #6 @ $12.03 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 26,155,025 $ 21,843,244 $ 25,994,785 $ 1,874,695 $ 8,289,019 $ 4,116,474 

Unit 4 $ 120,636,226 $ 59,465,349 $ 76,786,949 $ 6,950,320 $ 38,645,870 $ 18,760,496 

0.7 %S #6 @ $12.03 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 869,660 $ 726,292 $ 864,332 $ 62,334 $ 275,612 $ 136,874 

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 4 66,853 32,954 42,553 3,852 21,416 10,397

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 20.90% 17.40% 21.70% 1.50% 6.60% 3.30%

Unit 4 18.20% 9.00% 11.60% 1.00% 5.80% 2.80%

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 796 665 828 57 252 125

Unit 4 3,674 1,811 2,338 212 1,177 571

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,479 1,235 1,538 106 469 233

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 588 588 562 588 588 588

Greatest Visibility Impact (d

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 -2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input

Increased Annual Fuel Cost for

Calculated SO2 Emissions Reductions

Annual Fuel Cost for

Capacitv Factor

Annual Fuel Usage

Calculated SO2 Emissions

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)
Unit 3 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

Greatest Visibility Improvemen

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 1.43 1.43 1.43 1.43 1.43 1.43

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 608,154 507,897 604,428 43,590 192,735 95,716

Cumulative Visibility Impact 

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

Cumulative Visibility Improveme

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 4.26 4.26 4.26 4.26 4.26 4.26

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 204,146 170,491 202,895 14,632 64,698 32,130

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

779,695 595,431 361,401 189,790 232,034

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

7,485,519 5,663,022 3,480,352 1,895,104 2,385,967

2-Year Average 

Fuel Cost for 0.7 %S #6 @ $12.03 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 23,999,140 $ 24,520,520 $ 14,536,246 $ 5,081,857 $ 6,202,752 

 $ 90,050,794 $ 68,126,155 $ 41,868,635 $ 22,798,101 $ 28,703,183 

Increased 2-Year 

Average Fuel Cost 0.7 %S #6 @ $12.03 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 797,976 $ 815,312 $ 483,333 $ 168,973 $ 206,243 

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

49,903 37,753 23,202 12,634 15,906

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

19.10% 19.60% 11.60% 4.10% 4.90%

13.60% 10.30% 6.30% 3.40% 4.30%

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

731 747 443 155 189

2,742 2,075 1,275 694 874

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,357 1,387 822 287 351

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

588 588 588 588 588

Greatest Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 

2-Year Average Capacity Factor 

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions Reductions

2-Year Average Fuel Usage

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)
3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

Greatest Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

1.43 1.43 1.43 1.43 1.43

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

558,025 570,149 337,995 118,163 144,226

Cumulative Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

umulative Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

4.26 4.26 4.26 4.26 4.26

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

187,318 191,388 113,458 39,665 48,414

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 4 1,035,313 524,077 666,785 56,017 323,562 140,505

Unit 2003 (MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

Unit 4 10,027,949 4,943,088 6,382,955 577,749 3,212,458 1,559,476

0.5 %S #6 @ $13.25 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 28,807,488 $ 24,058,436 $ 28,630,998 $ 2,064,814 $ 9,129,634 $ 4,533,938 

Unit 4 $ 132,870,324 $ 65,495,916 $ 84,574,154 $ 7,655,174 $ 42,565,069 $ 20,663,057 

0.5 %S #6 @ $13.25 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 3,522,123 $ 2,941,484 $ 3,500,545 $ 252,453 $ 1,116,227 $ 554,338 

Unit 4 $ 12,234,098 $ 6,030,567 $ 7,787,205 $ 704,854 $ 3,919,199 $ 1,902,561 

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 4 66,853 32,954 42,553 3,852 21,416 10,397

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 569 475 592 41 180 90

Unit 4 2,624 1,293 1,670 151 841 408

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,707 1,425 1,775 122 541 269

Unit 4 1,050 517 668 60 336 163

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 2,064 2,064 1,972 2,063 2,063 2,064

Unit 4 11,656 11,656 11,656 11,655 11,656 11,655

Greatest Visibility Impact (d

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

Unit 4 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14

Annual Fuel Usage

Calculated SO2 Emissions

Annual Fuel Cost for

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 -2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input

Increased Annual Fuel Cost for

Calculated SO2 Emissions Reductions

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)
Greatest Visibility Improvemen

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 1.78 1.78 1.78 1.78 1.78 1.78

Unit 4 0.41 0.41 0.41 0.41 0.41 0.41

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,978,721 1,652,519 1,966,598 141,827 627,094 311,426

Unit 4 29,839,263 14,708,701 18,993,183 1,719,156 9,559,021 4,640,392

Cumulative Visibility Impact 

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

Unit 4 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64

Cumulative Visibility Improveme

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26

Unit 4 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 669,605 559,218 665,503 47,995 212,210 105,387

Unit 4 7,646,311 3,769,105 4,867,003 440,534 2,449,499 1,189,100

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

779,695 595,431 361,401 189,790 232,034

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

7,485,519 5,663,022 3,480,352 1,895,104 2,385,967

2-Year Average 

Fuel Cost for 0.5 %S #6 @ $13.25 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 26,432,968 $ 27,007,223 $ 16,010,412 $ 5,597,224 $ 6,831,793 

 $ 99,183,127 $ 75,035,042 $ 46,114,664 $ 25,110,128 $ 31,614,063 

Increased 2-Year 

Average Fuel Cost 0.5 %S #6 @ $13.25 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 3,231,804 $ 3,302,015 $ 1,957,499 $ 684,340 $ 835,283 

 $ 9,132,333 $ 6,908,887 $ 4,246,029 $ 2,312,027 $ 2,910,880 

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

49,903 37,753 23,202 12,634 15,906

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

522 533 316 111 135

1,959 1,482 911 496 624

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,566 1,600 949 332 405

783 593 364 198 250

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

2,064 2,064 2,064 2,064 2,064

11,656 11,656 11,656 11,656 11,656

Greatest Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions Reductions

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)

2-Year Average Fuel Usage
Greatest Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

1.78 1.78 1.78 1.78 1.78

0.41 0.41 0.41 0.41 0.41

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,815,620 1,855,065 1,099,719 384,461 469,260

22,273,983 16,850,944 10,356,169 5,639,090 7,099,707

Cumulative Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64

umulative Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26 5.26

1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

614,411 627,760 372,148 130,103 158,799

5,707,708 4,318,054 2,653,768 1,445,017 1,819,300

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
Unit 2003 (MWh) 2004 (MWh) 2005 (M\Vh) 2006 (MWh) 2007 (MWh) 2008 (MWh) 

Unit 3 218,284 186,518 230,208 13,149 66,469 29,796

Unit 4 1,035,313 524,077 666,785 56,017 323,562 140,505

Unit 2003 (MMBtu) 

2004 

(MMBtu) 2005 (MMBtu) 2006 (MMBtu) 

2007 

(MMBtu) 

2008 

(MMBtu) 

Unit 3 2,174,150 1,815,731 2,160,830 155,835 689,029 342,184

Unit 4 10,027,949 4,943,088 6,382,955 577,749 3,212,458 1,559,476

0.3 %S #6 @ $14.97 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 32,547,026 $ 27,181,493 $ 32,347,625 $ 2,332,850 $ 10,314,764 $ 5,122,494 

Unit 4 $ 150,118,397 $ 73,998,027 $ 95,552,836 $ 8,648,903 $ 48,090,496 $ 23,345,356 

0.3 %S #6 @ $14.97 /mmBtu

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 $ 7,261,661 $ 6,064,542 $ 7,217,172 $ 520,489 $ 2,301,357 $ 1,142,895 

Unit 4 $ 29,482,170 $ 14,532,679 $ 18,765,888 $ 1,698,582 $ 9,444,627 $ 4,584,859 

Unit 

 2003 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2004 (10^3 

gal/yr) 

2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

Unit 3 14,494 12,105 15,072 1,039 4,594 2,281

Unit 4 66,853 32,954 42,553 3,852 21,416 10,397

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 341 285 355 24 108 54

Unit 4 1,574 776 1,002 91 504 245

Unit 2003 (TPY) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,934 1,615 2,011 139 613 304

Unit 4 2,099 1,035 1,336 121 672 326

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 3,754 3,754 3,588 3,754 3,754 3,755

Unit 4 14,045 14,045 14,045 14,043 14,045 14,044

Greatest Visibility Impact (d

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

Unit 4 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14

Increased Annual Fuel Cost for

Calculated SO2 Emissions Reductions

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)

Annual Fuel Usage

Calculated SO2 Emissions

Annual Fuel Cost for

TABLE 5-3 FPL ENERGY WYMAN STATION ACTUAL FUEL USAGE. 2003 -2008 

Gross Generation

 Annual Heat Input
Greatest Visibility Improvemen

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 2.15 2.15 2.15 2.15 2.15 2.15

Unit 4 0.84 0.84 0.84 0.84 0.84 0.84

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 3,377,517 2,820,717 3,356,824 242,088 1,070,399 531,579

Unit 4 35,097,822 17,300,808 22,340,343 2,022,122 11,243,603 5,458,166

Cumulative Visibility Impact 

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

Unit 4 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64

Cumulative Visibility Improveme

Unit 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Unit 3 6.28 6.28 6.28 6.28 6.28 6.28

Unit 4 3.38 3.38 3.38 3.38 3.38 3.38

Unit 2003 ($/ton) 2004 (TPY) 2005 (TPY) 2006 (TPY) 2007 (TPY) 2008 (TPY) 

Unit 3 1,156,315 965,691 1,149,231 82,880 366,458 181,990

Unit 4 8,722,536 4,299,609 5,552,038 502,539 2,794,268 1,356,467

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

Calculated SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
2003-2004 (MWh) 2004-2005 (MWh) 2005-2006 (MWH) 2006-2007 (MWh) 2007-2008 (MWh) 

202,401 208,363 121,679 39,809 48,133

779,695 595,431 361,401 189,790 232,034

2003-2003 

(MMBtu) 

2004-2005 

(blMBtu) 

2005-2006 

(MMBtu)

 2006-2007 

(MMBtu) 

2007-2008 

(MMBtu) 

1,994,941 2,038,281 1,208,333 422,432 515,607

7,485,519 5,663,022 3,480,352 1,895,104 2,385,967

2-Year Average 

Fuel Cost for 0.3 %S #6 @ $14.97 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 29,864,267 $ 30,513,067 $ 18,088,745 $ 6,323,807 $ 7,718,637 

 $ 112,058,219 $ 84,775,439 $ 52,100,869 $ 28,369,707 $ 35,717,926 

Increased 2-Year 

Average Fuel Cost 0.3 %S #6 @ $14.97 /mmBtu

2003 - 2004 2004 - 2005 2005 - 2006 2006 - 2007 2007 - 2008

 $ 6,663,103 $ 6,807,859 $ 4,035,832 $ 1,410,923 $ 1,722,127 

 $ 22,007,426 $ 16,649,285 $ 10,232,235 $ 5,571,606 $ 7,014,743 

2003-2004 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2004-2005 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2005-2006 (10^3 

gal/yr)

 2006-2007 (10^3 

gal/yr)

2007-2008 (10^3 

gal/yr)

13,300 13,589 8,056 2,816 3,437

49,903 37,753 23,202 12,634 15,906

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

313 320 190 66 81

1,175 889 546 298 375

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,775 1,813 1,075 376 459

1,567 1,185 729 397 499

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

3,754 3,754 3,754 3,754 3,755

14,045 14,045 14,045 14,045 14,045

Greatest Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36 3.36

3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14 3.14

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions Reductions

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton)

2-Year Average Fuel Usage

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Emissions 

 2-Year Average Generation 

 2-Year Average Heat Input 
Greatest Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

2.15 2.15 2.15 2.15 2.15

0.84 0.84 0.84 0.84 0.84

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

3,099,118 3,166,446 1,877,131 656,243 800,989

26,199,317 19,820,577 12,181,232 6,632,864 8,350,885

Cumulative Visibility Impact (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73 9.73

10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64 10.64

umulative Visibility Improvement (dv)

2003-2004 2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008

6.28 6.28 6.28 6.28 6.28

3.38 3.38 3.38 3.38 3.38

2003-2004 (TPY) 2004-2005 (TPY) 2005-2006 (TPY) 2006-2007 (TPY) 2007-2008 (TPY) 

1,061,004 1,084,054 642,648 224,669 274,224

6,511,073 4,925,824 3,027,288 1,648,404 2,075,368

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)

 Calculated 2-Year Average SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv)
Wyman #3 (2007 - 2008)

Fuel Sulfur (%) 1 0.7 0.5

Increased Annual Fuel Cost $ 175,306 $ 206,243 $ 835,283

SO2 Emission Reductions (tpy) 270 351 405

SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton) $ 650 $ 588 $ 2,064

Greatest Visibility Improvement (dv) 0.99 1.43 1.78

Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv) $ 177,077 $ 144,226 $ 469,260

Cumulative Visibility Improvement (dv) 2.61 4.26 5.26

Cumulative Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv) $ 67,167 $ 48,414 $ 158,799

Wyman #4 (2007 - 2008)

Fuel Sulfur (%) 0.5

Increased Annual Fuel Cost $ 2,910,880

SO2 Emission Reductions (tpy) 250

SO2 Reductions Cost-Effectiveness ($/ton) $ 11,656

Greatest Visibility Improvement (dv) 0.41

Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv) $ 7,099,707

Cumulative Visibility Improvement (dv) 1.60

Cumulative Cost-Effectiveness ($/dv) $ 1,819,300
0.3

$ 1,722,127

459

$ 3,755

2.15

$ 800,989

6.28

$ 274,224

0.3

$ 7,014,743

499

$ 14,045

0.84

$ 8,350,885

3.38

$ 2,075,368
% Sulfur 

Ranked 

Visibility

Impact 

Visibility Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/deciview) 

Incremental 

Visibility

Improvement 

 Incremental 

Visibility Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/deciview) 

1 I st $0.69 million -- -- 

8th $1.95 million -- -- 

0.7 I st $0.56 million 0.44 dv $0.27 million 

8th $1.67 million 0.13 dv $0.92 million 

0.5 I st $1.82 million 0.35 dv $6.97 million 

8th $5.41 million 0.12 dv $20.3 million 

0.3 I st $2.64 million 0.37 dv $6.59 million 

8th $8.12 million 0.10 dv $24.4 million 

% Sulfur 

Ranked 

Visibility

Impact 

Visibility Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/deciview) 

Incremental 

Visibility

Improvement 

 Incremental 

Visibility Cost 

Effectiveness 

($/deciview) 

0.5 I st $22.3 million -- -- 

8th $39.8 million -- -- 

0.3 I st $19.5 million 0.53 dv $17.3 million 

8th $35.2 million 0.29 dv $3 1.6 million