2 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 1 of 20
,1 : Verizon LTE 10:18 PM @4y 27% 0• 

< Fear-y the Neri 

scary and uncomfortable but it's the 

right thing to do and you won't be 

alone. God is ALWAYS with us. 

12:03 PM 

Sabrina Torres 

For people looking to help and don't 

know how, or don't have the means to 

donate here is a link to a video that 

you can stream for free and just let 

the ads play! This raises money that 

is donated to protesters and people 

helping the cause across the nation 

Sabrina Torres 

ii Youtube 

STREAM TO DONATE: how to help with 

no monev or leavina vour house. 

Q Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 001 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 2 of 20
,, Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ <1 27% L} 

< 

• 

• 

Garret CSU 

Do we know which protesters it is 

donating to? Seems like some 

protesters we should support, others 

not so much 

Sabrina Torres 

It donates to Black Lives Matter. 

There's also of list of petitions and 

resources in the description of the 

video for people who want to be 

active allies and become more 

educated on the issue . 

Garret CSU 

Gotcha ty 

Drew Redmond 

Brooklyn Bail Fund 

Minnesota Freedom Fund 

Atlanta Action Network 

Columbus Freedom Fund 

Louisville Communily Ball Fund 

Chicago Bond 

Black Visions Collective 

Richmond Community Bail Fund 

The Ball Pro1ect Inc 

NW Com Bail Fund 

Ph1ladelph1a Bail Fund 

The Korchh1nsk1-Paquet Family Gofundme 

George Floyd's Family Gofundme 

BlackL1vesMatter.com 

Reclaim lhe Block 

ACLU 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 002 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 3 of 20
,1 : Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@-v 27% 0• 

< 

• 

Just to clarify, this is everything that 

the add revenue will go towards 

3:09 PM 

Jack Denton 

The various funds on that list are fine • 

causes as far as I know, but everyone 

should be aware that 

BlacklivesMatter.com, Reclaim the 

Block, and the ACLU all advocate for 

things that are explicitly antiCatholic. 

Laura Escher 

what do they advocate for? 

Lola Martin 

I'm just curious, but can you specify 

these "things" @Jack Denton 

Laura Escher 

I actually don't know LOL : · • 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 003 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 4 of 20
,, 11 Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ 4V 27% ~ ) 

< 

Laura Escher 

I actually don't know LOL 

Laura Escher 

cuz I've heard the same thing but 

don't actually know 

Jack Denton 

BlacklivesMatter.com fosters "a • , 

queer affirming network" and 

defends transgenderism. 

The ACLU defends laws protecting 

abortion facilities and sued states 

that restrict access to abortion. 

Reclaim the Block claims less police 

will make our communities safer and 

advocates for cutting PDs' budgets. 

This is a little less explicit, but I think 

it's contrary to the Church's teaching 

on the common good. 

Laura Escher 

Ah yes I just read the \!9 

BlacklivesMatter.com creed so I got 

u now 

Laura Escher 

Thanks! 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 004 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 5 of 20
,11 i Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

© ~27% 0 • 

< 

4:02 PM 

Sabrina Torres 

It's not a religious issue though, it's a 

human rights issue. Everyone of 

God's creations has the right to live 

peacefully 

Peter Maisenbacher 

Including the unborn, which last I 

checked are the most vulnerable of 

us. 

Laura Powers 

1J facebook .com 

Security Check Required 

Drew Redmond 

• 

That's such a powerful video @Laura 9 1 

Powers 

4:31 PM 

Silvia Meyer 

I know I never speak in this chat but 

I've decided that I cannot stay silent 

on this topic. I wholeheartedly agree 

that this is not a religious issue. It is a 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 005 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 6 of 20
,11\ Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

< Fear-y the Neri 

4:31 PM 

Silvia Meyer 

I know I never speak in this chat but 

I've decided that I cannot stay silent 

on this topic. I wholeheartedly agree 

that this is not a religious issue. It is a 

human rights issue. As Catholics we 

are called to love one another as we 

are Gods beloved creation. No one is 

more loved or more important or 

more worthy than anyone. As a firm 

supporter of the pro-life movement, I 

stand behind defending the sanctity 

of human life. However we tend to 

focus on only protecting human life in 

the womb. Which yes, is extremely 

important. But how are we going to 

advocate the defense of the unborn if 

we're not going to stand for our 

brothers and sisters here on earth? 

How are going to march in DC to 

defend life and stay silent in times 

like these? Innocent men and women 

and children are dying and this is 

what we should focus on. 

Silvia Mey~ ------------

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 006 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 7 of 20
,Iii Verizon LTE 10!18 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ </ 27% 0 • 

< 

Tue, 4:51 PM 

JR Ryan 

No one has said anything about 

George Floyd and others, probably b/ 

c it's summer, or maybe b/c a lot of 

the upperclassman have left, or 

maybe b/c this topic seems political 

(and maybe it is), or maybe b/c this 

group is highly concentrated with 

white people, myself included, and 

may not think about these things as 

much. BUT we are the Body of Christ, 

His church, made up of all people of 

all races and tongues and we have 

this shared experience called life, 

which involves suffering, carrying a 

cross. So whatever you think about 

what's going on regarding this 

situation in our country, I ask that you 

pray. Pray for black people who feel 

they are not valued or that they are 

treated as less in this country, pray 

that they may know Christ's love. And 

pray that we, as Catholics, may share 

Christ's love with EVERYONE we meet 

because Christ dwells in each of us. 

Q Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 007 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 8 of 20
,di Verizon LTE 10:18 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ '19 27% 0 1 

< 

• 

Emma MacPhee 

Amen 

Gina Passarella 

Amen 

JR Ryan 

Yes, there is more that could be 

mentioned about protests and riots 

and hate but I'd rather focus on what 

we can do and that is to pray and to 

love. 

If you do get the opportunity or feel it 

is helpful, speak up. We do call 

ourselves pro life and I think this is an 

opportunity to stand up for life. 

"Open your mouth for the mute, 

For the rights of all who are left 

desolate, 

Open your mouth, judge righteously, 

maintain the rights of the poor and 

needy." Proverbs 31 :8-9 

Lola Martin 

Thank you for speaking up @JR Ryan 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 008 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 9 of 20
,Ill Verizon LTE 10:18 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ .cJ 27% ~ } 

< 

Shannon Flaharty 

1\1\this!!! thank you @JR Ryan 

Ashley Douglas 

Amen!!! 

Tue, 5:14 PM 

Jae Williams 

Amen! 

Tue, 10:28 PM 

Gabe CSU 

- Very well said, JR! Thanks for 

bringing it up here. I'm sure 

everyone's aware by now of what's 

going on to some extent. I typically 

only speak about CSU/FSU stuff in 

here but I think this is worth bringing 

up. This isn't a political issue. It's a 

cultural issue. It's a human rights 

issue. And even though we might not 

be directly affected we should still 

care and act. 

Prayer is powerful. Prayer is 

underrated in today's culture. But 

there's a big difference betwe·en 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 009 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 10 of 20
,1 i 1 Verizon LTE 10:18 PM 

< Fear-y the Neri 

Prayer is powerful. Prayer is 

underrated in today's culture. But 

there's a big difference between 

awareness and activism. Activism 

comes in many different ways. We 

have more power than we realize. Use 

it wisely. I'm learning on the go so 

don't feel like this is something you 

should already know. My parents 

never taught me how to fight for 

change. They did teach me that 

ignorance is the root of most evils. 

Gabe CSU 

Ever since I got here I saw how this 

beautiful group of souls cared to 

make their community better, starting 

with helping one another grow closer 

to Christ and helping the less 

fortunate. A coach used to tell me if I 

ran and I didn't hurt then maybe I 

wasn't trying. If you're not angry 

about what's going on then maybe 

you're not listening. I'm sure you've 

seen online the many ways you can 

help fight police brutality, systemic 

racism, and oppression by now. It's 

scary_and unf omfortable but it's the ___ _ 

G:) Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 010 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 11 of 20
•••/ Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ ~ 21%(C} 

< 

Silvia Meyer 

I do not condone violent protests nor 

do I support any further killing. 

Violence and hatred will only breed 

more violence and hatred. But what is 

happening in today's society is a 

direct violation of human dignity. 

We're all quick to say that God is 

love. So let's put that into action. 

Love one another. Educate yourselves 

on how to help one another. We can 

all support this movement in our own 

special way. Some us may feel more 

comfortable going to go protest 

physically. Some might be more 

comfortable sharing articles and 

ways to help and helping to educate 

others. Others might have to have 

these uncomfortable conversations 

with our friends and families. Others 

may be called to pray. However you 

chose to show your support, one 

thing is very clear: you cannot stay 

silent. Silence equates impassivity. 

Silence will only allow for evil to 

continue to penetrate our society. 

@ Send Message ... 

---:::-

+ 

Exhibit 2, Page O 11 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 12 of 20
,111 Verizon LTE 10:19 PM @ "i 27%0 • 

< 

• 

• 

Fear-y the Neri 

continue to penetrate our soc1e1y. 

Silvia Meyer 

Our God is not a passive god. We 

should not be a passive people. Stay 

safe. Love each other. Support each 

other. These are tough times we live 

in. Be the good we want to see in this 

world. 

Gina Passarella 

Couldn't have put it better myself, 

Silvia 

Drew Redmond 

Very well said! @Silvia Meyer 

Lola Martin 

thanks for re-focusing everything 

@Silvia Meyer, well said . 

Garret CSU 

What's the difference between a socalled "religious" issue and a "human 

rights" issue? t•m not sure "human 

rights" have any valid rational 

grounding outside of a religious 

context 

Jack Denton 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 012 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 13 of 20
,,;; Verizon LTE 10:19 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

© "'v 27% 0 • 

< 

• 

Jack Denton 

I don't mean to anger anyone - I know • 1 , 

this is a very emotional topic. 

However, it is important to know what 

you're supporting when you're 

Catholic. If I stay silent while my 

brothers and sisters may be 

supporting an organization that 

promotes grave evils, I have sinned 

through my silence. I love you all, and 

I want us all to be aware of the truth. 

As far as it's a religious issue or not, 

there isn't an aspect of our lives that 

isn't religious, because God wants 

our whole lives and everything we do 

to be oriented around him!<3 

Lola Martin 

you guys i love you all but i'd hate to 

see this group chat turn into a 

political debate, like it kind of already 

is. i didn't join this group chat to be 

involved in political things, i joined it 

so we can walk with Christ together. 

so let's focus on the core issue here 

which is racism. it doesn't mean we 

are or aren't supporting other things, 

j)ut we have to keeQ our eyes wide 

Q Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 013 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 14 of 20
,1 li Verizon LTE 10:20 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@iy 27% 0 · 

< 

• 

Olivia Stephenson 

You only open minds with 

conversation, so that's also important 

too:) 

Garret CSU 

Speaking of heated debate, the 

theology club is discussing the 

proper Christian perspective of 

gender roles this Friday at noon via 

Zoom, if anyone wants to join hmu 

Sabrina Torres has left the group. 

4:46 PM 

Silvia Meyer 

I agree that this chat shouldn't be 

used for political debate but these 

are issues we cannot ignore. I was 

born in a country that is subjected to 

tyranny and severe oppression. I 

know what it's like to go out and 

protest day after day and see no 

results. I know what it's like to be 

ruled by a government that doesn't 

care whether you live or die. I know 

what it's like to have no electricity, no 

---,., .:.tor ,:,ort r.LJO t'\IAIA 1"1_ 110.1 ,r u,ho lo_ 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page O 14 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 15 of 20
o1 i! Verizon LTE 10:20 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ ~27% 0 · 

< 

Silvia Meyer 

I agree that this chat shouldn't be 

used for political debate but these 

are issues we cannot ignore. I was 

born in a country that is subjected to 

tyranny and severe oppression. I 

know what it's like to go out and 

protest day after day and see no 

results. I know what it's like to be 

ruled by a government that doesn't 

care whether you live or die. I know 

what it's like to have no electricity, no 

water and no power in your whole 

country simple because the 

gover·nment felt like it. I know what 

it's like to be shot at and gassed and 

imprisoned and tortured and killed for 

something that you believe in. 

Thankfully I was given the 

opportunity to come to this country 

and be able to have a voice. We are 

all privileged to be able to even have 

a community like this. All I'm saying is 

do not let that privilege go to waste. 

We have a voice. Use it. The 

conversations are tough but we are 

blessed to be able to have them. 

@ Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 015 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 16 of 20
•• , l Verizon LTE 10:20 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

@ "v 27% 0 · 

< 

Peter Meisenbacher 

Ron Burgundy - That Escalated Quickly 

Peter Maisenbacher 

I stop checking this chat for like 20 

minutes 

Gavin Cummins 

@ Send Message .. . 

• 

+ 

Exhibit 2, Page 016 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 17 of 20
,1 ;' Verizon LTE 10:20 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

©"'v27% 0 · 

< 

Silvia Meyer 

And like I said, we don't all have to go 

out and protest. If you don't feel 

comfortable donating to certain 

organizations that's totally up to you. 

But the one thing we can all agree on 

is that this country needs prayers. 

Pray for the protesters. Pray for law 

enforcement officers. Pray for our 

leaders. Pray for justice. 

Matt Ayers 

, Hey everyone I hope you're all doing 

well. Lately I've been dealing with a 

lot of conflict with the current 

situation of George Floyd. But there's 

also a lot of questions and serious 

concerns that I have. If anyone's 

available, I'd love to talk. 

5:23 PM 

Drew Redmond 

I'm always here if anyone needs to 

talk @Matt Ayers 

Matt Ayers 

Thanks @Drew Redmond I just had 

a good talk with Michael Campanella 

Q Send Message ... 

I. 

+ 

Exhibit 2, Page O 1 7 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 18 of 20
e1 li Verizon LTE 10:20 PM 

< Fear-y the Neri 

Matt Ayers 

· Thanks @Drew Redmond I just had 

a good talk with Michael Campanella 

about this. And I'm not here to start 

with the black lives matter or all lives 

matter or left vs. right. I guess my 

only conflict right now is where/how 

to see God. Because while we have 

free will, God also has divine 

intervention and lately it seems like 

prayers haven't been working. But 

while Michael cleared most of the 

confusion up, there's always internal 

conflict to some extent. If you or 

anyone else has any further advice, 

I'm willing to listen. 

7:33 PM 

Miguel Vassallo 

·=-

On a side note, 7 am yoga tomorrow ~ ,, 

on landis for anyone who wants to 

join 

8:51 PM 

Jac1k

1 DFe~tond 'f k • I He o nen s, 1 you now me, you 

know I proudly serve as President of 

--~ he studen Senate. nfortunate.Lv Lt __ _ 

Q Send Message ... + 

Exhibit 2, Page 018 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 19 of 20
.111 Verizon LTE 

< 

Jack Denton 

10:20 PM 

Fear-y the Neri 

8:51 PM 

Hello Friends, if you know me, you • Jr-; 

• 

know I proudly serve as President of 

the Student Senate. Unfortunately, it 

appears someone took a screenshot 

of my messages earlier and sent 

them to a senator. The Senate is 

currently taking a vote to remove me 

from office due to these messages 

claiming they don't feel comfortable 

that I serve in the position while being 

Catholic. I ask for your prayers at this 

time. 

9:11 PM 

Steven Rega 

Disgraceful. Praying for you 

Jacob May 

That's awful, seems like their trying 

to trash the first amendment. Praying. 

Peter Meisenbacher 

~ Hey, everyone. In light of recent 

events in this groupchat I'm afraid I'm 

going to have to be leaving. I've only 

Jieen ere_iQ(.._a_~IJOJUime_but I've 

@ Send Message ... 

8 

+ 

Exhibit 2, Page O 19 

Case 4:20-cv-00425-AW-MAF Document 1-2 Filed 08/31/20 Page 20 of 20