EXHIBIT 1

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 1 of 33
Rulings on Outstanding Exhibits from Parties' 1st and 2nd Priority Exhibits Lists 

Priority List Trial Exhibit No. Date Category Description Objections Rulings

D1 D-Gen-0187 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re 

Combat Arms Earplugs, dated 8/25/2004

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, G7 See Order, ECF No. 118 (Estes); 141 

(Hacker); 124 (Keefer)

D1 D-Gen-0272 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Email from D. Ohlin to E. Berger, K. 

Gates, et al., re: Information on Combat 

Arms earplugs, dated 03/23/2005, with 

attachments.

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, G7 See Order, ECF No. 118 (Estes); 141 

(Hacker); 124 (Keefer)

D1 D-Gen-1175 General Government 

Documents

Email from D. Ohlin to D. Ohlin re Letter 

for Combat Arms earplug, dated 

4/9/1999

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, G7 See Order, ECF No. 118 (Estes); 141 

(Hacker); 124 (Keefer)

D1 D-Gen-1663 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re 

Combat Arms Earplugs, dated 

8/25/2004. Attachment: Mime.822

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, G7 See Order, ECF No. 118 (Estes); 141 

(Hacker); 124 (Keefer)

D1 D-Gen-1924 General Government 

Documents

Combat Arms "Ultrafit" Earplugs, Prior 

Project-On Going

FRE 602; FRE 802 Hearsay SUSTAINED

P2 P-GEN-00021 3/15/2011 Email attaching Moldex Filter Technical 

Drawing and Patent No. 6,068,079

Prejudicial, confusing, waste of 

time (FRE 403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); ; 3M MIL #06: Previous 

Litigation/CID Report

OVERRULED 

P2 P-GEN-00022 5/2/2006 U.S. Patent No. 7,036,157 B1 Prejudicial, confusing, waste of 

time (FRE 403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); ; 3M MIL #06: Previous 

Litigation/CID Report

WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021

P2 P-GEN-00196 11/17/1992 Importance of EARCAL Log 20 and 

Incremental Impact on its Liability is 

Small

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 601, 

611(a), 602); Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Relevance (FRE 401/402); Rule of 

Completeness; Incomplete 

Document or Unfairness

OVERRULED 

P2 P-GEN-00199 4/7/1993 DoJ Fine to Cabot EARCAL Lab Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay w/in 

Hearsay (FRE 805); ; 3M MIL #08: 

Fine on Cabot Safety Corporation

Sustained for substantive purposes; 

depending on D's position, could become 

necessary for impeachment. 

P2 P-GEN-01312 11/18/2008 3M Budget re Key Projects w Outside 

Technology Partners and Suppliers

Prejudicial, confusing, waste of 

time (FRE 403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); ; 3M MIL #07: 3M’s 

Financial Condition

WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021

P2 P-GEN-01693 2/16/2011 Thread re CAE Patents and Securing 

German Military Sales

Prejudicial, confusing, waste of 

time (FRE 403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); ; 3M MIL #14: 3M’s 

Alleged Monolopy

OVERRULED 

P2 P-GEN-01714 3/19/2011 Thread re Ohlin After Action Report on 

Joint Defense Veterans Audiology 

Conference

Prejudicial, confusing, waste of 

time (FRE 403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); Rule of Completeness; 

Incomplete Document or 

Unfairness

OVERRULED 

Page 1 of 4

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 2 of 33
Rulings on Outstanding Exhibits from Parties' 1st and 2nd Priority Exhibits Lists 

Priority List Trial Exhibit No. Date Category Description Objections Rulings

P2 P-GEN-02495 5/1/2017 Pistol, TC 23.35 Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance (FRE 

401/402);

WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021

D2 D-Gen-0116 12/31/2011 General Government 

Documents

Report: U.S. AbilityOne Commission, 

Annual Report 2011

FRE 802; FRE 803(18) To be used on cross only

D2 D-Gen-0783 8/23/2016 General Government 

Documents

Infantry Platoon and Squad, Army 

Techniques Publication No. 3-21.8, U.S. 

Department of the Army (April 2016).

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0826 2/22/2007 General Government 

Documents

Tank Platoon, FM 3-20.15, Headquarters 

Department of the Army, dated 

2/22/2007

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0832 12/13/2012 General Government 

Documents

Tank Platoon December 2012, ATP 3-20-

15 (FM 3-20.15), Headquarters, 

Department of the Army, dated 

12/13/2012

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0834 4/30/2014 General Government 

Documents

Unit Field Sanitation Teams, April 2014, 

ATP 4-25.12, Headquarters Department 

of the Army, dated 4/30/2014

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0835 5/6/2015 General Government 

Documents

Field Hygiene and Sanitation, May 2015 , 

TC 4-02.3, Headquarters Department of 

the Army, dated 5/6/2015

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0838 General Government 

Documents

XM1158 7.62-mm Cartridge, FY19 Army 

Programs

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0840 General Government 

Documents

Chapter 89, Cleaning Instructions - M1A1 

AIM SA Abrams Tank, ADF Force 

Extraction Cleaning Manual

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0852 Oct-07 General Government 

Documents

Bose Product Improved Combat Vehicle 

Crewman (PICVC) Active Noise 

Reduction Headset Use and 

Maintenance Manual, US Army Training 

Manual 2007

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0884 05/00/2003 General Government 

Documents

Report: Military Transformation: Army’s 

Evaluation of Stryker and M-113A3 

Infantry Carrier Vehicles Provided 

Sufficient Data for Statutorily Mandated 

Comparison, U.S. General Accounting 

Office, Report to Congressional 

Committees GAO-03-671, dated 

05/00/2003.

FRE 802; FRE 803(18) EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0943 06/00/1989 General Government 

Documents

Research Report: M1 Tank Gunnery: A 

Detailed Analysis of Conditions, 

Behaviors, and Processes, G. Meade, 

dated June 1989

FRE 802; FRE 803(18) EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

Page 2 of 4

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 3 of 33
Rulings on Outstanding Exhibits from Parties' 1st and 2nd Priority Exhibits Lists 

Priority List Trial Exhibit No. Date Category Description Objections Rulings

D2 D-Gen-0950 09/00/2008 General Government 

Documents

MRAP Vehicles Handbook No. 08-30, 

Tactics, Techniques and Procedures, 

Center for Army Lessons Learned (CALL), 

September 08

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0956 General Government 

Documents

Audio Testing Software User Guide, Navy 

DOEHRS HC

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 To be used on cross only, unless Defendants 

can establish that Navy guide is same as 

Army guide.

D2 D-Gen-0998 4/10/2013 General Government 

Documents

L. Sweeney, et al, Exposure Evaluation 

for Benzene, Lead and Noise in Vehicle 

and Equipment Repair Shops, April 2013

FRE 802; FRE 803(18) EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-0999 05/00/1995 General Government 

Documents

T. Swingle, US Army Rotary-Wing 

Emergency Egress Study, dated May 

1995

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-1007 7/1/1982 General Government 

Documents

Vaughan, et al, M1 Abrams Tank 

Procedures Guide, July 1982

FRE 802; FRE 803(18); MIL G2, G12 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 3/25/2021; may use 

as demonstrative.

D2 D-Gen-1791 7/13/2010 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: On-Site Assessment Report, 

NVLAP, 3M EARCAL Acoustical Lab 

Testing, dated 07/13/2010

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1792 7/27/2012 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: On-Site Assessment Report, 

NVLAP, 3M EARCAL Acoustical Lab 

Testing, dated 07/27/2012

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1793 6/29/2016 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: On-Site Assessment Report, 

NVLAP, 3M Indianapolis Acoustical 

Laboratories Testing, dated 06/29/2016

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1821 10/20/2006 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

NVLAP ON-SITE ASSESSMENT SUMMARY 

by E-A-RCAL Acoustical Laboratory, Jeff 

Schmitt dated 10/2/2006

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1829 8/25/2004 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Combat Arms filters Part #018-1000; 

Material - Dupont Delrin 900P Black 

(Measurement Samples 1-3), dated 

08/25/2004

FRE 901 Incomplete designation To be used for cross only

D2 D-Gen-1838 11/1/2006 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: NVLAP Lab Signature Sheet re 

EARCAL Acoustical Laboratory, dated 

10/31 thru 11/1/2006

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1850 10/20/2004 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: NVLAP, Signature Sheet for 

Aearo Co., EARCAL Acoustical Lab 

Testing, dated 10/20/2004

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1851 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: NVLAP General Operations 

Checklist Testing for Aearo Co., EARCAL 

Acoustical lab

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

Page 3 of 4

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 4 of 33
Rulings on Outstanding Exhibits from Parties' 1st and 2nd Priority Exhibits Lists 

Priority List Trial Exhibit No. Date Category Description Objections Rulings

D2 D-Gen-1853 6/13/2001 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: EARCAL Acoustical Laboratory, 

NVLAP Signature Sheet, dated 

06/13/2001

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1854 7/23/2003 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

Report: NVLAP Signature Sheet re Aearo 

Company E-A-RCAL Acoustical Lab, dated 

07/23/2003

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

D2 D-Gen-1910 6/17/2008 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

Documents

NVLAP Signature Sheet re E-A-RCal 

Acoustical Laboratory, signed by Richard 

Peppin, dated 06/17/2008 & 06/18/2008

FRE 401/402; NVLAP report is 

hearsay

See Order, ECF No. 126 (Estes); 147 

(Hacker); 130 (Keefer)

P1 P-GEN-00128 3M Thread re CAEv2 Not 

to Be Sold with Current 

Labelling

3M/Aearo/Cabot documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste of 

time (FRE 403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); ; 3M MIL #16: 3M’s 

Discontinuation/Lack of Recall

Parties to confer and make redactions in 

accordance with the Court’s MIL ruling.

Page 4 of 4

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 5 of 33
Defendants' 3rd Priority Exhibits List

Trial Exhibit No. Category Document Date Description Stipulation to Authenticity/ 

Business Record Exception Objections Ruling on Objections

D-Gen-0013 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 8/6/1999 Aearo Company Quality Control, 

Specification, Filter for Nonlinear Plug, 018-

1000 Filter, dated 08/06/1999

FRE 401, FRE 402; FRE 802 OVERRULED

D-Gen-0044 General Government 

Documents

12/00/2012 M. Binseel, K. Cave et al., ARL Testing_A 

Comparison of the Single-sided (Gen II) and 

Double-sided (Gen I) Combat Arms Earplugs 

(CAE): Acoustic Properties, Human 

Performance, and User Acceptance, Army 

Research Laboratory (2012)

FRE 802; FRE 803(18) OVERRULED

D-Gen-0083 Scientific literature 4/21/2016 Hearing Protection Device Data, dated 

04/21/2016

FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403; 

FRE 802

OVERRULED

D-Gen-0110 Scientific literature 00/00/2010 Product Information sheets: Surefire EP7 

Sonic Defenders Ultra: Two Levels of 

Protection Against Two Types of Noise (ANSI 

S12.42-2010)

FRE 401, FRE 402, FRE 403 WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

D-Gen-0184 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 7/14/1999 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re Letter for 

Combat Arms earplug, dated 7/14/1999

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, 

G7

OVERRULED

D-Gen-0193 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 2/8/2007 Email from T. Sidor to B. Myers re Aearo/EAR 

Contact Information, dated 2/8/2007

FRE 802 OVERRULED

D-Gen-0222 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 6/23/2005 Fiche D'Auto Controle: Suivi De Production, 

Battenfield horizontale, dated 06/23/2005

Foundation; FRE 402; Vague Expert only; not to be 

shown to jury

D-Gen-0223 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 6/2/2005 Fiche D'Auto Controle: Suivi De Production, 

Battenfield horizontale, Filtre Acoustique, 

dated 06/02/2005

Foundation; FRE 402; Vague Expert only; not to be 

shown to jury

D-Gen-0267 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 12/11/2006 Email from L. Connors to R. Zielinski re 

Questions on Combat Arms Packaging re 

NSN6515-01-466-2710, dated 12/11/2006

Foundation; FRE 403; FRE 

802; MIL G3; MIL G4; MIL G5

OVERRULED

D-Gen-0273 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 4/16/2002 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re Combat 

Arms Earplug, dated 4/16/2002

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, 

G7

OVERRULED. See P-GEN00481.

Page 1 of 5

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 6 of 33
Defendants' 3rd Priority Exhibits List

Trial Exhibit No. Category Document Date Description Stipulation to Authenticity/ 

Business Record Exception Objections Ruling on Objections

D-Gen-0275 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 6/27/2005 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re Hearing 

Enhancement and Protection Field Trial - Your 

Participation, dated 4/18/2002

Foundation; FRE 402; FRE 

403; FRE 802; FRE 805

SUSTAINED

D-Gen-0286 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 8/25/2004 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re Combat 

Arm Earplugs, dated 8/25/2004

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, 

G7

SUSTAINED in part, per 

ECF No. 118 (Estes); 141 

(Hacker); 124 (Keefer). 

Otherwise OVERRULED

D-Gen-0293 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 6/29/1999 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re Purchase 

of Combat Arms Earplugs, dated 6/29/1999

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, 

G7

OVERRULED

D-Gen-0389 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 1/15/2000 Letter from P. Hamery to Elliott Berger re test 

results for Impulse noise, dated 1/5/2000

FRE 802 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1101 General Government 

Documents

3/15/2007 Contract File Contents List re Solicitation 

#SP0200-06-R-4202, dated 03/15/2007

Compound; FRE 802; 

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3

OVERRULED

D-Gen-1110 General Government 

Documents

Presentation: Attenuation Measurements of 

Passive Linear and Nonlinear Hearing 

Protectors for Impulse Noise, W. Murphy, C. 

Kardous, undated.

FRE 402; FRE 602; FRE 802 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1363 Scientific literature 6/24/2016 Report: Performance Assessment of the 3M 

Combat Arms Generation 4.0 Tactical Military 

Shooter's Ear Plug, H. Gallagher, N. 

Abouzahra, et al., Air Force Research 

Laboratory, AFRL-RH-WP-TR-2016-0092, 

dated 06/24/2016.

FRE 802; FRE 803(18) OVERRULED

D-Gen-1407 General Government 

Documents

4/9/1999 Email from D. Ohlin to D. Ohlin re Letter for 

Combat Arms earplug, dated 4/9/1999

Hearsay (FRE 802); MIL G3, 

G7

SUSTAINED in part, per 

ECF No. 118 (Estes); 141 

(Hacker); 124 (Keefer). 

Otherwise OVERRULED

Page 2 of 5

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 7 of 33
Defendants' 3rd Priority Exhibits List

Trial Exhibit No. Category Document Date Description Stipulation to Authenticity/ 

Business Record Exception Objections Ruling on Objections

D-Gen-1795 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 11/30/2004 Email from E. Berger to B. Myers, R. Knauer re 

with Ohlin on Wed at 10am, attaching Earplug 

Card and Combat Arms Feedback document, 

dated 11/30/2004

MIL G3; MIL G5; MIL G7; 

Soldier's comments are 

hearsay

OVERRULED

D-Gen-1796 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 1/30/1998 Memorandum from E. Berger to B. Myers re 

January Monthly Report / Hearing Technical 

Marketing, dated 01/30/1998

FRE 401/402 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1808 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 5/18/1999 Email from D. Ohlin to M. Fischer re Slides; 

attaching Earplug power point presentation, 

dated 05/18/1999

MIL G3 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1832 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 12/24/1997 Aearo Memorandum from E. Berger to B. 

Myers re December Monthly Report / Hearing 

Technical Marketing, dated 12/24/1997

FRE 401/402 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1833 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 10/31/1997 Aearo Memorandum from E. Berger to B. 

Myers re December Monthly Report / Hearing 

Technical Marketing

FRE 401/402 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1845 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 12/21/2006 Delivery Order for Commercial Items issued 

by Defense Supply Center Philadelphia, signed 

by T. Sidor, dated 12/21/2006

MIL G3 (inspection) OVERRULED

D-Gen-1856 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents Report: E-A-R UltraFit Combat Arms Earplug 

Marketing Overview

FRE 802, Foundation OVERRULED

D-Gen-1861 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 8/17/2005 Email from B. Myers to M. Salon re combat 

arms, dated 08/17/2005

FRE 802, Foundation, MIL G7 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1864 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 6/11/1999 Email from B. Myers to D. Ohlin re Letter for 

Combat Arms earplug, dated 06/11/1999

FRE 403; FRE 802 Hearsay; 

MIL G5; MIL G7

OVERRULED

D-Gen-1865 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 4/19/1999 Email from B. Myers to D. Ohlin re Letter for 

Combat Arms earplug, dated 04/19/1999

FRE 403; FRE 802 Hearsay; 

MIL G5; MIL G7

OVERRULED

Page 3 of 5

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 8 of 33
Defendants' 3rd Priority Exhibits List

Trial Exhibit No. Category Document Date Description Stipulation to Authenticity/ 

Business Record Exception Objections Ruling on Objections

D-Gen-1869 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 2/9/2000 Email from R. Bosanko to B. Myers re Combat 

Arms Earplugs, dated 02/09/2000

FRE 802, Foundation, MIL G7 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1871 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 11/22/1999 Email from E. Berger to B. Myers re your 

responses please, dated 11/22/1999

Daubert, FRE 802, 

Foundation

OVERRULED

D-Gen-1872 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 8/2/1999 Email from E. Spahn to B. Myers re Combat 

Arms Earplug, dated 08/02/1999

FRE 802, Foundation OVERRULED

D-Gen-1879 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 2/13/2003 Email from B. Myers to J. Komada re My 

Current Draft of the Spec Sheet on the 

Combat Arms Ear, dated 02/13/2003

FRE 802, Foundation, MIL G7 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1880 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 4/16/2004 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers, B. Bascom re 

Combat Arms Earplug, dated 04/16/2004

FRE 403; FRE 802 Hearsay; 

MIL G5; MIL G7

OVERRULED

D-Gen-1881 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 8/25/2004 Email from M. Cimino to D. Ohama re Combat 

Arms Earplugs, dated 08/25/2004

FRE 802, Foundation, MIL G7 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1896 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 7/2/2004 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re 

Observations, dated 7/2/2004

FRE 403; FRE 802 Hearsay; 

MIL G5; MIL G7

SUSTAINED

D-Gen-1897 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 2/25/2000 Email from B. Myers to B. Myers re ECN for 

Combat Arms earplug, with attachments: 

ecncombatarms.doc; ATTACH.BIN, dated 

2/25/2000

FRE 802, Foundation, MIL 

G3, G4, G7

OVERRULED

D-Gen-1903 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 12/13/2005 Email from K. Spahn to M. Santoro re 

Instruction Sheet, with attachment, dated 

12/13/2005

FRE 602; FRE 802; FRE403 OVERRULED

D-Gen-1917 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 9/20/2001 Email from D. Ohlin to B. Myers re Combat 

Arms Earplugs, dated 09/20/2001

FRE 401, FRE 403; FRE 802 

Hearsay; MIL G5; MIL G7

SUSTAINED as to 

asserting the truth of 

what is in the document; 

otherwise OVERRULED.

D-Gen-1919 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 2/7/2000 Email from R. Bosanko to B. Myers re Combat 

Arms Earplugs, dated 2/7/2000

FRE 401; FRE 403 OVERRULED

Page 4 of 5

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 9 of 33
Defendants' 3rd Priority Exhibits List

Trial Exhibit No. Category Document Date Description Stipulation to Authenticity/ 

Business Record Exception Objections Ruling on Objections

D-Gen-1922 3M/Aearo/Cabot Documents 4/16/2007 Memorandum from E. Berger to J. Hamer, R. 

Knauer, et al., re Conversation with Mary 

Binseel and Kara Cave of US Army Research 

Lab, dated 4/16/2007

FRE 602; FRE 802 Hearsay SUSTAINED

D-Keefer-0226 Case Specific Documents \ 

Government Medical 

Records (VA and DOD)

10/6/2010 Medical Record: Martin ACH, Fort Benning, 

GA, Readiness Processing Center re L. Keefer, 

dated 10/06/2010

Stipulated Authentic, Subject to 

the Business Record Exception FRE 

803(6) per Keefer Dkt. 26

MIL C2, MIL C8, FRE 402 OVERRULED

D-Keefer-0228 Case Specific Documents \ 

Government Medical 

Records (VA and DOD)

10/2/2009 Medical Record: Emergency Medical 

Treatment, Theater Facility, Theater Clinic re 

L. Keefer, dated 10/02/2009

Stipulated Authentic, Subject to 

the Business Record Exception FRE 

803(6) per Keefer Dkt. 26

MIL C2, FRE 402 Redact as discussed at 

Conference on 

3/25/2021

D-Keefer-0297 Case Specific Documents \ 

VA Disability Applications, 

Exams, and Determinations

9/11/2015 Medical Record: Lewis Keefer Progress Notes 

re VA C&P Exam Sleep Apnea and Headaches 

dated 9/11/2015

Stipulated Authentic, Subject to 

the Business Record Exception FRE 

803(6) per Keefer Dkt. 26

MIL C1, MIL C2, MIL C3 Redact as discussed at 

Conference on 

3/25/2021

Page 5 of 5

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 10 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-00096 9/26/2006 Ohlin Army Email re CAEv2 

Case and Instructions 

Feedback

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00098 4/26/2007 215516 HPDA Report 

Screenshot

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00104 Berger-MDL-30(b)(6)-

0026 | Todor-MDL30(b)(1)-007

6/10/2009 Thread re Berger" Intense 

Pressure" to "Match 

Attenuation Values"

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 

601, 611(a), 602); Prejudicial, 

confusing, waste of time (FRE 

403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); ; 3M MIL #08: Fine 

on Cabot Safety Corporation

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00161 6/1/1981 Berger (1981) Details of Real 

World Hearing Protector 

Performance as Measured in 

the Laboratory

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00205 Berger-MDL-30(b)(6)-

0044

6/24/1994 Gardner, Falco (1994) 

Critique of the UltraFit 

Earplug

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 

601, 611(a), 602); Hearsay 

(FRE 802);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00221 Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-034 4/1/1996 Marc Doty Research 

Notebook No. H1026 

(excerpt)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 

601, 611(a), 602); Hearsay 

(FRE 802)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00231 Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-002 12/1/1996 Marc Doty Performance 

Review - 1996

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 

601, 611(a), 602); Hearsay 

(FRE 802); Relevance (FRE 

401/402);

SUSTAINED; Impeachment 

only

P-GEN-00241 3/30/1997 EARCAL Attenuation Test 

Report: Test ID 143003, 

UltraFlex

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00242 Berger-MDL-2nd 

30(b)(6)-017 | DotyMDL-30(b)(6)-036

3/30/1997 EARCAL Attenuation Test 

Report 143003

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

Page 1 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 11 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-00245 Berger-MDL-2nd 

30(b)(6)-018 | DotyMDL-30(b)(6)-037

4/24/1997 EARCAL Attenuation Test 

Report 143002

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00256 Berger-MDL-2nd 

30(b)(6)-005 | DotyMDL-30(b)(6)-014 | 

Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-015

9/10/1997 Marc Dotty Research 

Notebook No. 7304

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Rule of 

Completeness; Incomplete 

Document or Unfairness

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00265 Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-003 12/1/1997 Marc Doty Performance 

Review - 1997

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

SUSTAINED; Impeachment 

only

P-GEN-00280 Berger-MDL-30(b)(6)-

0014 | Falco-MDL30(b)(1)-0057 | 

Merkley-MDL-Touhy0005 | Gates-MDLTouhy-0011 | BergerMDL-2nd 30(b)(6)-008 

| Price-MDL-Touhy-002 

| Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-

023

4/9/1998 DoD Hearing Conservation 

Mtg Agenda with GarintherISL Notes

General Government 

Documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805);

WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

P-GEN-00297 Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-018 1/26/1999 CAEv1 Technical Drawing 

2055-0 

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Rule of 

Completeness; Incomplete 

Document or Unfairness; 3M 

MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00310 Berger-MDL-30(b)(1)-

D11 | Merkley-MDLTouhy-0006 | GatesMDL-Touhy-0013

4/9/1999 Aearo-Military Thread re 

CAE Purchase and Design 

Change

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00325 Gates-MDL-Touhy-0015 6/30/1999 Kalb, Garinther, Golden, 

Price (1999) ARL-HRED HPD 

Assessments in 

Reverberating Environments

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805); 

Unidentified Highlighting or 

Handwriting

WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

Page 2 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 12 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-00326 Kieper-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0059 | Klun-MDL30(b)(1)-0026 | 

Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0021

7/1/1999 June Monthly EARCal Lab 

Memo

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #22: 

Method B Testing and Test 

Panels

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00335 Klun-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0006 | Klun-MDL30(b)(1)-0022

7/30/1999 Klun Email re CAE Review 

Meeting Agenda

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Email 

Missing Attachments in 

Produced Version

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00343 Todor-MDL-30(b)(1)-

013

8/9/1999 SPO 227 without signed 

approvals

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00360 Berger-MDL-30(b)(6)-

0009

11/22/1999 Email re ISL to Test CAEv2 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay w/in Hearsay (FRE 

805);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00389 1/25/2000 213015 CAEv2 Closed End 

Subject Data 

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00408 5/1/2000 Earlog 18: Can Hearing Aids 

Provide

Hearing Protection?

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00409 5/1/2000 Earlog 19: Tips for Fitting 

Hearing Protectors

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00419 6/1/2000 Ohlin-Fatz Publication re 

Army-Improved CAEv2

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 

601, 611(a), 602); Hearsay 

(FRE 802);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00442 3/1/2001 Berger-Casali Thread re Test 

Study and EAR's "No" Vote 

on Canadian Standard 

Adopting ANSI S12.6-1997 

Method B

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805); 

Relevance (FRE 401/402);

SUSTAINED for any other 

purpose other than 

impeachment.

P-GEN-00447 5/24/2001 Individual Subject Data 

(Slightly-Modified UltraFit 

Plug - 213025)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Rule of Completeness; 

Incomplete Document or 

Unfairness

WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

Page 3 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 13 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-00459 Knauer-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0018 | Zielinski-MDL30(b)(1)-0023

8/1/2001 EARCal July Monthly Report 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Relevance (FRE 401/402); ; 

3M MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00463 8/30/2001 DuPont Engineering 

Polymers - General Design 

Principles

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Competency & Lacks 

foundation/Speculative (FRE 

601, 611(a), 602); Prejudicial, 

confusing, waste of time (FRE 

403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402);

SUSTAINED

P-GEN-00464 Berger-MDL-30(b)(6)-

0045 | Battler-MDL30(b)(1)-011

9/10/2001 Ohlin to Myers and Berger re 

Army Hospital James Wax 

CAEv2 Report Email

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

P-GEN-00501 Klun-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0038 | Zielinski-MDL30(b)(1)-0026

2/27/2003 Request for Deviation for 

Increasing Spec Range of TJR 

ARC Boxes (Attachment)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00531 9/30/2003 EARCal September Monthly 

Report (Cimino Apprised of 

Marketing Claim Problems)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #22: 

Method B Testing and Test 

Panels

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00589 6/18/2004 215024 CAEv4 Closed end 

Test Report

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00604 Childress-MDL-30(b)(6)-

035

8/25/2004 Request for Deviation 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00623 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0034 | Todor-MDL30(b)(1)-023

10/11/2004 Request for Deviation re 

Increasing TJR ARC 

Calibration Box Upper 

Threshold

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

Page 4 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 14 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-00630 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0035

11/2/2004 EARCal October Monthly 

Report

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00636 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0040

11/22/2004 Zielinski TJR Visit Summary 

re CAE ARC Boxes

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00642 Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-044 12/1/2004 Marc Doty Performance 

Review - 2004

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

SUSTAINED for any other 

purpose other than 

impeachment.

P-GEN-00654 Moses-MDL-0024 | 

Kieper-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0008 | Merkley-MDLTouhy-0025

1/1/2005 Aearo CAEv1 and CAEv2 

Brochure (BW)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #15: 

Fitting and Instruction 

Requirements to Plaintiffs

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00670 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0048

2/14/2005 Martinez's CAE ARC Box 

Calibration Values at TJR

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00713 Childress-MDL-30(b)(6)-

045

4/21/2005 Aearo Direct Materials 

Shipping Request

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

Page 5 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 15 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-00718 5/2/2005 April Monthly EarCal Lab 

Memo

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #18: 

Aearo’s Start/Stop of nonCAEv2 Tests; 3M MIL #22: 

Method B Testing and Test 

Panels; 3M MIL #23: Product 

Specific Testing

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00740 6/8/2005 CAE Attenuation Test Report 

(215505 - 215508)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #23: 

Product Specific Testing

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00817 10/4/2005 EAR ARC Plug Blister Pack 

Insert

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00872 11/30/2005 Myers to Klun re Proposed 

Army Agreement re CAEv3 

Development But Keep IP

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay w/in Hearsay (FRE 

805); Prejudicial, confusing, 

waste of time (FRE 403); 

Relevance (FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00956 Falco-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0053

3/7/2006 Falco to Berger, et. al re 

Comments to Development 

of the CAE Memo (Parent)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-00987 5/3/2006 April Monthly EarCal Lab 

Memo

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #22: 

Method B Testing and Test 

Panels

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01002 Myers-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0049

6/2/2006 Method B Master Testing 

Spreadsheet

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #22: 

Method B Testing and Test 

Panels

OVERRULED

Page 6 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 16 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-01017 7/5/2006 June Monthly EarCal Lab 

Memo

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #22: 

Method B Testing and Test 

Panels

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01043 10/10/2006 Email with attachments of 

"Military Landscape" for 

sales potential of 3M hearing 

protection related products 

in 2006

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01047 11/1/2006 Browning Duo Blister Pack 

Card (Colored)

Hearsay (FRE 802); WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

P-GEN-01049 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0061

11/6/2006 Documents re CAEv2 SKU 

CAE 370-ALPHA

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); ; 3M MIL 

#26: Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01087 Childress-MDL-30(b)(6)-

003

1/15/2007 Tool Approval Form 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

DEFER TO TRIAL

P-GEN-01129 Berger-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0041

5/7/2007 April Monthly EarCal Lab 

Memo

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01136 5/15/2007 EARCAL CAEv3 Attenuation 

Test Report (Closed - 

215015)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01138 5/15/2007 CAEv2 testing see NRRs 20.8 

closed and octave band 

results. Also fitting 

instructions for testing. E-ARCAL attenuation test 5-15-

2007 record created date 

1/10/99 modified 12/10/07

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

Page 7 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 17 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-01142 Klun-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0050

5/16/2007 Alphapointe Meeting Notes 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay w/in Hearsay (FRE 

805); Prejudicial, confusing, 

waste of time (FRE 403); 

Relevance (FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01146 6/1/2007 May Monthly EarCal Lab 

Memo

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01206 Falco-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0030

12/11/2007 Falco to Berger re Testing 

Closed and Open Ends of 

Low Profile CAE Prototypes

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01272 8/1/2008 EARCal July Monthly Report 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Relevance (FRE 401/402); OVERRULED

P-GEN-01277 8/20/2008 Combat Arms Plug and + 

Com Tac II Muff Test ID 

268124

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01295 9/30/2008 CAEv2 Sales from 2004 to 

2008

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #07: 

3M’s Financial Condition

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01314 11/18/2008 Management meeting for 

military operations briefing

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01324 12/10/2008 Management meeting for 

military operations briefing

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01475 10/21/2009 Email from Moses to Cimino 

re New Dynamics 

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

Page 8 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 18 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-01493 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0055

12/4/2009 Kieper Emails re ATM's Use 

of Outdated Documents

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Email Missing Attachments in 

Produced Version; 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

P-GEN-01521 Doty-MDL-30(b)(6)-052 1/23/2010 Ely Email re Sale of CAEs to 

French Military

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01600 8/16/2010 Michael & Associates 

testing, including CAE 

testing. Sponsored by 

Moldex

DOCUMENT UNDER REVIEW, 

PRODUCED ON FEBRUARY 22, 

2021

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-GEN-01655 12/9/2010 Berger PPT on NRR and Fit 

Test Numbers Best Practice 

Recommendations. Includes 

a slide of Labeled vs. Field 

Values with a big 

discrepancy. discusses issues 

with NRR

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01803 Moses-M2-5626 9/2/2011 Moses Email to Morris re 

Potential 3M Patent 

Enforcement

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01856 Berger-MDL-30(b)(6)-

0016

1/24/2012 Berger and Levinson to ISL re 

ISL Patents for Potential IP 

Enforcement

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #06: 

Previous Litigation/CID 

Report

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-GEN-01907 4/13/2012 Evaluation of the Surefire 

EP4 Sonic Defenders Plug EA-R 12-03/HP by Berger & 

Kieper

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #23: 

Product Specific Testing

OVERRULED

P-GEN-01945 5/31/2012 CAE Sales History - 1999-

2009

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); OVERRULED

P-GEN-01966 6/20/2012 ISL Slideshow Hamery 

3M_MDL000096722

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Relevance (FRE 401/402); EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

Page 9 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 19 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-02013 Madison-MDL-30(b)(1)-

011 | Madison-MDL30(b)(1)-0011

10/11/2012 Hearing Protection Solutions - 

HPDs and HCPs PPT

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Email Missing 

Attachments in Produced 

Version

DEFER; parties to meet and 

confer on missing 

attachments.

P-GEN-02106 5/13/2013 EARCAL CAEv4 Attenuation 

Test Report (Open - 215023, 

Closed - 215024)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02219 Gavin-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0010 | Fallon-MDL30(b)(1)-011

4/11/2014 Gavin re CAE Sales 

Observations

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #07: 

3M’s Financial Condition; 3M 

MIL #14: 3M’s Alleged 

Monolopy

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02221 Gavin-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0011

4/11/2014 CAE Sales Review Discussion 

Guide

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Privileged 

Material (FRE 501/502); ; 3M 

MIL #07: 3M’s Financial 

Condition; 3M MIL #14: 3M’s 

Alleged Monolopy

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02236 Moses-MDL-0031 5/5/2014 Thread re Moses thinks 

Posters are effective

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02238 Merkley-MDL-Touhy00215/7/2014 Jones Email attaching 

Importance of Hearing to the 

War Fighter (Merkley Slide 

Deck)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); ; 3M MIL 

#20: Rise in Hearing Loss in 

2000s

SUSTAINED

Page 10 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 20 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-02292 11/20/2014 Fallon to Berger et al. re 

adding proper labeling, 

including EPA label to 

comms products

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #15: 

Fitting and Instruction 

Requirements to Plaintiffs; 

3M MIL #19: CAEv2’s 

Contractual Compliance

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02305 1/10/2015 Earlog 20: The Naked Truth 

About NRRs

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Subject to 

3M MIL #22: Method B 

Testing and Test Panels

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02418 1/28/2016 Email re removing CAEv2 

from New Dynamics product 

brochure

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Email Missing Attachments in 

Produced Version; 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #16: 3M’s 

Discontinuation/Lack of 

Recall

SUSTAINED regarding dualended info; otherwise 

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02436 6/2/2016 Email from Ravi Thomas to 

Hamer and Berger re ARC 

testing

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02438 Childress-MDL-30(b)(6)-

048

6/6/2016 Charlie Myers re theory 

behind ARC testing

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

Page 11 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 21 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-02448 6/20/2016 Kaczorowski re CAE issues 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

SUSTAINED in case in chief; 

may be used only for 

impeachment and rebuttal

P-GEN-02578 Zielinski-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0017

5/9/2019 Team Verification 

Instructions for the CAE and 

Revolver

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Translation or Technical 

issue; Unidentified 

Highlighting or Handwriting

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02625 EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-GEN-02645 Moses-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0021

12/6/2019 CAEv2 Cuts from Various 

Brochures Moses 21

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Rule of 

Completeness; Incomplete 

Document or Unfairness

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02657 Kieper-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0034

12/19/2019 Flashdrive Containing HPDA 

Database

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

DEFER TO TRIAL

P-GEN-02674 3/6/2020 Compilation file from ATM 

with emails from ATM 

employees

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Hearsay 

w/in Hearsay (FRE 805); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Improper 

Compilation; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02725 2009.10.21 Tuten 18_E-mail(s), 

3M_MDL000054363 -

3M_MDL000054368

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

Page 12 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 22 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-02756 2016.06.10 Email from Thomas to 

Myers, Shaver, & Berger RE: 

ARC calibration procedure

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02813 EARLog 16 - A New Hearing 

Protection Attenuation 

Standard (Berger)

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Relevance (FRE 401/402) OVERRULED

P-GEN-02824 Letter from Richard E. 

Knauer

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02909 1998 Quality Manual 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #19: 

CAEv2’s Contractual 

Compliance; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-02962 McNamara-MDL30(b)(1)-0002CV/Resume of Timothy K. 

McNamara

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); SUSTAINED as to resume; 

otherwise overruled.

P-GEN-03079 10/23/2001 CDC Email to 3M re Impulse 

Peak Level Preliminary 

Testing w ISL ATF

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

P-GEN-03090 Berger-MDL-30(b)(1)-

0003

07/25/1997 ISL Email to Berger re CAE 

Prototypes and Potential 

Problems with Prototype 

Designs

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-03094 09/18/2001 Berger to NIOSH re ISO 9001 

compliance

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

3M MIL #22: Method B 

Testing and Test Panels; 3M 

MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

Page 13 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 23 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-GEN-03098 07/15/1999 Combat Arms Plug meeting 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-03099 Childress-MDL-30(b)(6)-

018

06/10/2016 Combat Arms Assembly SOP 

227

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #19: 

CAEv2’s Contractual 

Compliance; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-03111 Todor-MDL-30(b)(1)-

011

08/03/1999 AEARO Company Memo 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #26: 

Manufacturing Quality 

Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-03134 Berger-MDL-2nd 

30(b)(6)-007

12/26/2007 Study and Production of 

Nonlinear Perforated 

Earplugs

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Hearsay (FRE 802); 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-GEN-03154 6/10/2016 P1671-Combat Arms 

Assembly SOP 227

3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

OVERRULED

P-GEN-03183 1/5/2009 FLUKE 45 SOP 3M/Aearo/Cabot 

documents

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #26: Manufacturing 

Quality Control/Arc Box

WITHDRAWN 3/25/21

P-HACKER-12083 7/23/1998 Enlistment Audiogram from 

Hearing Loss and Tinnitus 

Disability Questionnaire

Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Rule of Completeness; 

Incomplete Document or 

Unfairness

OVERRULED

Page 14 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 24 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12123 3/17/2011 Audiogram Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12130 4/7/2014 Evans ACH Outpatient 

Appointment 

Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #01: 

Judge Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

SUSTAINED as to any 

information related to 

tobacco use, per Order, ECF 

No. 1695.

P-HACKER-12135 9/24/2014 Armed Forces Medical Exam 

Periodic Health Assessment

Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #01: 

Judge Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

SUSTAINED as to any 

information related to 

tobacco use, per Order, ECF 

No. 1695.

P-HACKER-12145 2/10/2016 EBH-West Bragg Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #01: 

Judge Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

Meet & confer

P-HACKER-12152 7/17/2017 Hearing Conservation Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #01: 

Judge Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12153 7/17/2017 Audiogram Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402);

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12157 4/13/2018 Hearing Conservation Hacker CS documents Privacy Redaction Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); ; 3M MIL #01: 

Judge Jones Order re Expert 

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

Page 15 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 25 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12178 Photo Hacker in Uniform Hacker CS Documents NO OBJECTION

P-HACKER-12200 4/28/2004 Examiner's Summary Hacker CS Documents Rule of Completeness; 

Incomplete Document or 

Unfairness; Prejudicial, 

confusing, waste of time (FRE 

403); Relevance (FRE 

401/402); Subject to 3M MIL 

#01: Judge Jones Order re 

Expert Testimony (Hacker)

SUSTAINED

P-HACKER-12201 5/16/2006 Blanchfield ACH - Ashau 

Valley Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12204 8/28/2007 Blanchfield ACH, Carentan 

Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12205 9/21/2007 Report of Medical Exam Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12210 8/31/2009 Blanchfield ACH - Carentan 

Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12211 10/5/2009 NMC Portsmouth Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12212 11/25/2009 NMC Portsmouth, Primary 

Care Cl

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12214 1/13/2010 Evans ACH - SRC Site - Work 

Assessment

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

OVERRULED

P-HACKER-12215 1/14/2010 Evans ACH - Deployment 

Health Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403)

OVERRULED

Page 16 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 26 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12216 1/22/2010 Evans ACH - Wellness Center Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12218 3/16/2011 Evans ACH - Social Work 

Care Management Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

OVERRULED; relevant to 

emotional distress claims.

P-HACKER-12219 3/25/2011 Evans ACH, SRC Site Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12220 3/31/2011 Evans ACH - Substance 

Abuse Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

SUSTAINED as to altercation, 

per Order, ECF No. 1716. 

Otherwise OVERRULED.

P-HACKER-12221 6/1/2011 Evans ACH - Internal 

Medicine Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

SUSTAINED

P-HACKER-12222 8/3/2011 Evans ACH - Nutrition Care Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

SUSTAINED

P-HACKER-12223 8/4/2011 Evans ACH - Nutrition Care Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

SUSTAINED

P-HACKER-12224 10/31/2011 Evans ACH - SRC Site Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

SUSTAINED

P-HACKER-12225 9/5/2012 Evans ACH Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12226 11/27/2012 Evans ACH Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

Page 17 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 27 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12227 12/19/2012 Evans ACH Urology Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12228 1/25/2013 Evans ACH Urology Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12230 6/12/2013 Evans ACH Urology Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12236 5/14/2014 Evans ACH, Orthopedics 

Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12237 5/19/2014 Evans ACH, Embedded 

Behavioral Health

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Translation or 

Technical issue

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12240 11/1/2014 Evans ACH - ER Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12243 11/3/2014 Evans ECH - Embedded 

Behavioral Health

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12244 11/3/2014 Evans ECH - Embedded 

Behavioral Health

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12245 11/5/2014 Evans ECH - Embedded 

Behavioral Health

Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402) Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12251 11/9/2015 Theater Facility, Theater 

Clinic

Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402) Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12254 5/4/2016 AMC Womack - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

Page 18 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 28 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12255 5/5/2016 AMC Womack - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12256 6/7/2016 AMC Womack - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12257 6/8/2016 AMC Womack - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12258 1/4/2017 Robinson Clinic - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12259 1/4/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12260 1/11/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg - 

Physical Therapy

Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12261 1/23/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg - 

Physical Therapy

Hacker CS Documents Relevance (FRE 401/402); 

Subject to 3M MIL #01: Judge 

Jones Order re Expert 

Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

Page 19 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 29 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12262 2/2/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg - 

Physical Therapy

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12263 2/6/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg - 

Physical Therapy

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12264 2/13/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg - 

Physical Therapy

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12267 4/3/2017 Joel Clinic - Bragg Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12268 7/26/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12269 8/11/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

Page 20 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 30 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12270 8/23/2017 AMC Womack - Bragg - 

Emergency Room

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12272 8/31/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12273 10/3/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12274 10/19/2017 Bragg Battalion Aid Station - 

Camp Mackall

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN 

3/25/21

P-HACKER-12275 10/24/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

Page 21 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 31 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12276 11/17/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12277 12/8/2017 EBH - East Bragg Clinic Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12279 4/13/2018 Joel Clinic - Bragg - 

Optometry

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12280 5/9/2018 AMC Womack - Bragg - Epi & 

Disease Control

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

P-HACKER-12281 5/11/2018 Joel Clinic - Bragg - 

Optometry

Hacker CS Documents Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Testimony (Hacker)

Parties to confer

Page 22 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 32 of 33
Plaintiffs' 3rd List of Priority Exhibits

EHK Exhibit No. DEPOSITION EX No. Date Document Name Document Category Sealed/ Redaction FRE Objection RULING ON OBJECTIONS

P-HACKER-12291 4/21/2020 JB San Antonio Military 

Treatment Facility - 

Comprehensive Information 

Report

Hacker CS Documents Improper Compilation; 

Prejudicial, confusing, waste 

of time (FRE 403); Relevance 

(FRE 401/402); Subject to 3M 

MIL #01: Judge Jones Order 

re Expert Test

Parties to confer

Page 23 of 23

Case 7:20-cv-00137-MCR-GRJ Document 127-1 Filed 03/26/21 Page 33 of 33