?H // %GSd) +4*,4& .4A47 .:A0= >300?

IVS ?H // QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb O\R bVS W\T]`[ObW]\ Q]\bOW\SR VS`SW\ \SWbVS` `S^ZOQS \]` ac^^ZS[S\b bVS TWZW\U O\R aS`dWQS ]T ^ZSORW\Ua ]` ]bVS` ^O^S`a Oa `S_cW`SR Pg ZOe' SfQS^b Oa

^`]dWRSR Pg Z]QOZ `cZSa ]T Q]c`b) IVWa T]`[' O^^`]dSR Pg bVS ?cRWQWOZ 8]\TS`S\QS ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa W\ HS^bS[PS` ,42/' Wa `S_cW`SR T]` bVS caS ]T bVS 8ZS`Y ]T 8]c`b T]` bVS

^c`^]aS ]T W\WbWObW\U bVS QWdWZ R]QYSb aVSSb) (SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON NEXT PAGE OF THIS FORM.)

4& #E$ ;7,49?411> /0109/,9?>

#F$ 8]c\bg ]T GSaWRS\QS ]T ;W`ab AWabSR EZOW\bWTT 8]c\bg ]T GSaWRS\QS ]T ;W`ab AWabSR 9STS\RO\b

(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES) (IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES ONLY)

CDI:5 >C A6C9 8DC9:BC6I>DC 86H:H' JH: I=: AD86I>DC D;

I=: IG68I D; A6C9 >CKDAK:9)

#G$ 6bb]`\Sga (Firm Name, Address, and Telephone Number) 6bb]`\Sga (If Known)

44& -,>4> :1 5@=4>/4.?4:9(Place an “X” in One Box Only) 444& .4?4D09>34; :1 ;=49.4;,7 ;,=?40> (Place an “X” in One Box for Plaintiff

(For Diversity Cases Only) and One Box for Defendant) 

" , J)H) <]dS`\[S\b " . ;SRS`OZ FcSabW]\ ;?1 /01 ;?1 /01

EZOW\bWTT (U.S. Government Not a Party) 8WbWhS\ ]T IVWa HbObS " , " , >\Q]`^]`ObSR or E`W\QW^OZ EZOQS " / " /

]T 7caW\Saa >\ IVWa HbObS

" - J)H) <]dS`\[S\b " / 9WdS`aWbg 8WbWhS\ ]T 6\]bVS` HbObS " - " - >\Q]`^]`ObSR and E`W\QW^OZ EZOQS " 0 " 0

9STS\RO\b (Indicate Citizenship of Parties in Item III) ]T 7caW\Saa >\ 6\]bVS` HbObS

8WbWhS\ ]` HcPXSQb ]T O " . " . ;]`SWU\ CObW]\ " 1 " 1

;]`SWU\ 8]c\b`g

4A& 9,?@=0 :1 >@4? (Place an “X” in One Box Only) 8ZWQY VS`S T]`5 CObc`S ]T HcWb 8]RS 9SaQ`W^bW]\a)

.:9?=,.? ?:=?> 1:=104?@=0';09,7?C -,96=@;?.C :?30= >?,?@?0>

" ,,+ >\ac`O\QS ;0=>:9,7 495@=C ;0=>:9,7 495@=C " 1-0 9`cU GSZObSR HSWhc`S " /-- 6^^SOZ -3 JH8 ,03 " .20 ;OZaS 8ZOW[a 6Qb

" ,-+ BO`W\S " .,+ 6W`^ZO\S " .10 ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g ( ]T E`]^S`bg -, JH8 33, " /-. LWbVR`OeOZ " .21 FcW IO[ %., JH8

" ,.+ BWZZS` 6Qb " .,0 6W`^ZO\S E`]RcQb E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg " 14+ DbVS` -3 JH8 ,02 .2-4%O&&

" ,/+ CSU]bWOPZS >\ab`c[S\b AWOPWZWbg " .12 =SOZbV 8O`S* " /++ HbObS GSO^^]`bW]\[S\b

" ,0+ GSQ]dS`g ]T DdS`^Og[S\b " .-+ 6aaOcZb' AWPSZ $ EVO`[OQScbWQOZ ;=:;0=?C =423?> " /,+ 6\bWb`cab

$ :\T]`QS[S\b ]T ?cRU[S\b HZO\RS` ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g " 3-+ 8]^g`WUVba " /.+ 7O\Ya O\R 7O\YW\U

" ,0, BSRWQO`S 6Qb " ..+ ;SRS`OZ :[^Z]gS`ak E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg " 3.+ EObS\b " /0+ 8][[S`QS

" ,0- GSQ]dS`g ]T 9STOcZbSR AWOPWZWbg " .13 6aPSab]a ES`a]\OZ " 3.0 EObS\b ( 6PP`SdWObSR " /1+ 9S^]`bObW]\

HbcRS\b A]O\a " ./+ BO`W\S >\Xc`g E`]RcQb CSe 9`cU 6^^ZWQObW]\ " /2+ GOQYSbSS` >\TZcS\QSR O\R

%:fQZcRSa KSbS`O\a& " ./0 BO`W\S E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg " 3/+ I`ORS[O`Y 8]``c^b D`UO\WhObW]\a

" ,0. GSQ]dS`g ]T DdS`^Og[S\b AWOPWZWbg ;0=>:9,7 ;=:;0=?C 7,-:= >:.4,7 >0.@=4?C " /3+ 8]\ac[S` 8`SRWb

]T KSbS`O\ka 7S\STWba " .0+ B]b]` KSVWQZS " .2+ DbVS` ;`OcR " 2,+ ;OW` AOP]` HbO\RO`Ra " 31, =>6 %,.40TT& %,0 JH8 ,13, ]` ,14-&

" ,1+ Hb]QYV]ZRS`ak HcWba " .00 B]b]` KSVWQZS " .2, I`cbV W\ AS\RW\U 6Qb " 31- 7ZOQY Ac\U %4-.& " /30 ISZS^V]\S 8]\ac[S`

" ,4+ DbVS` 8]\b`OQb E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg " .3+ DbVS` ES`a]\OZ " 2-+ AOP]`*BO\OUS[S\b " 31. 9>L8*9>LL %/+0%U&& E`]bSQbW]\ 6Qb

" ,40 8]\b`OQb E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg " .1+ DbVS` ES`a]\OZ E`]^S`bg 9O[OUS GSZObW]\a " 31/ HH>9 IWbZS MK> " /4+ 8OPZS*HOb IK

" ,41 ;`O\QVWaS >\Xc`g " .30 E`]^S`bg 9O[OUS " 2/+ GOWZeOg AOP]` 6Qb " 310 GH> %/+0%U&& " 30+ HSQc`WbWSa*8][[]RWbWSa*

" .1- ES`a]\OZ >\Xc`g ( E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg " 20, ;O[WZg O\R BSRWQOZ :fQVO\US

BSRWQOZ BOZ^`OQbWQS ASOdS 6Qb " 34+ DbVS` HbObcb]`g 6QbW]\a

=0,7 ;=:;0=?C .4A47 =423?> ;=4>:90= ;0?4?4:9> " 24+ DbVS` AOP]` AWbWUObW]\ 10/0=,7 ?,B >@4?> " 34, 6U`WQcZbc`OZ 6Qba

" -,+ AO\R 8]\RS[\ObW]\ " //+ DbVS` 8WdWZ GWUVba 3EFIEW .SVTYW* " 24, :[^Z]gSS GSbW`S[S\b " 32+ IOfSa %J)H) EZOW\bWTT " 34. :\dW`]\[S\bOZ BObbS`a

" --+ ;]`SQZ]ac`S " //, K]bW\U " /1. 6ZWS\ 9SbOW\SS >\Q][S HSQc`Wbg 6Qb ]` 9STS\RO\b& " 340 ;`SSR][ ]T >\T]`[ObW]\

" -.+ GS\b ASOaS $ :XSQb[S\b " //- :[^Z]g[S\b " 0,+ B]bW]\a b] KOQObS " 32, >GHjIVW`R EO`bg 6Qb

" -/+ I]`ba b] AO\R " //. =]caW\U* HS\bS\QS -1 JH8 21+4 " 341 6`PWb`ObW]\

" -/0 I]`b E`]RcQb AWOPWZWbg 6QQ][[]RObW]\a " 0.+ <S\S`OZ " 344 6R[W\Wab`ObWdS E`]QSRc`S

" -4+ 6ZZ DbVS` GSOZ E`]^S`bg " //0 6[S`) e*9WaOPWZWbWSa ( " 0.0 9SObV ES\OZbg 48842=,?4:9 6Qb*GSdWSe ]` 6^^SOZ ]T

:[^Z]g[S\b :XLIV* " /1- CObc`OZWhObW]\ 6^^ZWQObW]\ 6US\Qg 9SQWaW]\

" //1 6[S`) e*9WaOPWZWbWSa ( " 0/+ BO\RO[ca $ DbVS` " /10 DbVS` >[[WU`ObW]\ " 40+ 8]\abWbcbW]\OZWbg ]T

DbVS` " 00+ 8WdWZ GWUVba 6QbW]\a HbObS HbObcbSa

" //3 :RcQObW]\ " 000 E`Wa]\ 8]\RWbW]\

" 01+ 8WdWZ 9SbOW\SS (

8]\RWbW]\a ]T

8]\TW\S[S\b

A& :=4249 (Place an “X” in One Box Only)

" , D`WUW\OZ

E`]QSSRW\U

" - GS[]dSR T`][

HbObS 8]c`b

" . GS[O\RSR T`][

6^^SZZObS 8]c`b

" / GSW\abObSR ]`

GS]^S\SR

" 0 I`O\aTS``SR T`][

6\]bVS` 9Wab`WQb

(specify)

" 1 BcZbWRWab`WQb

AWbWUObW]\ (

I`O\aTS`

" 3 BcZbWRWab`WQb

AWbWUObW]\ (

9W`SQb ;WZS

A4& .,@>0 :1 ,.?4:9

8WbS bVS J)H) 8WdWZ HbObcbS c\RS` eVWQV g]c O`S TWZW\U (Do not cite jurisdictional statutes unless diversity)5

7`WST RSaQ`W^bW]\ ]T QOcaS5

A44& =0<@0>?0/ 49

.:8;7,49?*

" 8=:8@ >; I=>H >H 6 .7,>> ,.?4:9

JC9:G GJA: -.' ;)G)8d)E)

/08,9/ " 8=:8@ N:H ]\Zg WT RS[O\RSR W\ Q][^ZOW\b5

5@=C /08,9/* " NSa "C]

A444& =07,?0/ .,>0#>$

41 ,9C (See instructions):

?J9<: 9D8@:I CJB7:G

96I: H><C6IJG: D; 6IIDGC:N D; G:8DG9

1:= :114.0 @>0 :97C

G:8:>EI # 6BDJCI 6EEAN>C< >;E ?J9<: B6<) ?J9<:

Deseret Ranches of North Florida, LLC The St. Joe Company, Inc.

Salt Lake County, Utah

John A. Tucker, Foley & Lardner

One Independent Drive, Suite 1300

Jacksonville, FL 32202

28 USC 1332 and 2201

Declaratory Judgment Action to interpret restriction covenants related to real property

05/19/2020

Case 5:20-cv-00149-TKW-MJF Document 2 Filed 05/19/20 Page 1 of 2
?H // GSdS`aS %GSd) +4*,4&

49>?=@.?4:9> 1:= ,??:=90C> .:8;70?492 .4A47 .:A0= >300? 1:=8 5> ((

6cbV]`Wbg ;]` 8WdWZ 8]dS` HVSSb

IVS ?H // QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb O\R bVS W\T]`[ObW]\ Q]\bOW\SR VS`SW\ \SWbVS` `S^ZOQSa \]` ac^^ZS[S\ba bVS TWZW\Ua O\R aS`dWQS ]T ^ZSORW\U ]` ]bVS` ^O^S`a Oa

`S_cW`SR Pg ZOe' SfQS^b Oa ^`]dWRSR Pg Z]QOZ `cZSa ]T Q]c`b) IVWa T]`[' O^^`]dSR Pg bVS ?cRWQWOZ 8]\TS`S\QS ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa W\ HS^bS[PS` ,42/' Wa

`S_cW`SR T]` bVS caS ]T bVS 8ZS`Y ]T 8]c`b T]` bVS ^c`^]aS ]T W\WbWObW\U bVS QWdWZ R]QYSb aVSSb) 8]\aS_cS\bZg' O QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb Wa acP[WbbSR b] bVS 8ZS`Y ]T

8]c`b T]` SOQV QWdWZ Q][^ZOW\b TWZSR) IVS Obb]`\Sg TWZW\U O QOaS aV]cZR Q][^ZSbS bVS T]`[ Oa T]ZZ]ea5

4&#E$ ;PEMRXMJJW%/IJIRHERXW& :\bS` \O[Sa %ZOab' TW`ab' [WRRZS W\WbWOZ& ]T ^ZOW\bWTT O\R RSTS\RO\b) >T bVS ^ZOW\bWTT ]` RSTS\RO\b Wa O U]dS`\[S\b OUS\Qg' caS

]\Zg bVS TcZZ \O[S ]` abO\RO`R OPP`SdWObW]\a) >T bVS ^ZOW\bWTT ]` RSTS\RO\b Wa O\ ]TTWQWOZ eWbVW\ O U]dS`\[S\b OUS\Qg' WRS\bWTg TW`ab bVS OUS\Qg O\R

bVS\ bVS ]TTWQWOZ' UWdW\U P]bV \O[S O\R bWbZS)

#F$ .SYRX[ SJ =IWMHIRGI& ;]` SOQV QWdWZ QOaS TWZSR' SfQS^b J)H) ^ZOW\bWTT QOaSa' S\bS` bVS \O[S ]T bVS Q]c\bg eVS`S bVS TW`ab ZWabSR ^ZOW\bWTT `SaWRSa Ob bVS

bW[S ]T TWZW\U) >\ J)H) ^ZOW\bWTT QOaSa' S\bS` bVS \O[S ]T bVS Q]c\bg W\ eVWQV bVS TW`ab ZWabSR RSTS\RO\b `SaWRSa Ob bVS bW[S ]T TWZW\U) %CDI:5 >\ ZO\R

Q]\RS[\ObW]\ QOaSa' bVS Q]c\bg ]T `SaWRS\QS ]T bVS "RSTS\RO\b" Wa bVS Z]QObW]\ ]T bVS b`OQb ]T ZO\R W\d]ZdSR)&

#G$ ,XXSVRI[W& :\bS` bVS TW`[ \O[S' ORR`Saa' bSZS^V]\S \c[PS`' O\R Obb]`\Sg ]T `SQ]`R) >T bVS`S O`S aSdS`OZ Obb]`\Sga' ZWab bVS[ ]\ O\ ObbOQV[S\b' \]bW\U

W\ bVWa aSQbW]\ "%aSS ObbOQV[S\b&")

44& 5YVMWHMGXMSR& IVS POaWa ]T Xc`WaRWQbW]\ Wa aSb T]`bV c\RS` GcZS 3%O&' ;)G)8d)E)' eVWQV `S_cW`Sa bVOb Xc`WaRWQbW]\a PS aV]e\ W\ ^ZSORW\Ua) EZOQS O\ "M"

W\ ]\S ]T bVS P]fSa) >T bVS`S Wa []`S bVO\ ]\S POaWa ]T Xc`WaRWQbW]\' ^`SQSRS\QS Wa UWdS\ W\ bVS ]`RS` aV]e\ PSZ]e)

J\WbSR HbObSa ^ZOW\bWTT) %,& ?c`WaRWQbW]\ POaSR ]\ -3 J)H)8) ,./0 O\R ,./3) HcWba Pg OUS\QWSa O\R ]TTWQS`a ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa O`S W\QZcRSR VS`S)

J\WbSR HbObSa RSTS\RO\b) %-& LVS\ bVS ^ZOW\bWTT Wa acW\U bVS J\WbSR HbObSa' Wba ]TTWQS`a ]` OUS\QWSa' ^ZOQS O\ "M" W\ bVWa P]f)

;SRS`OZ _cSabW]\) %.& IVWa `STS`a b] acWba c\RS` -3 J)H)8) ,..,' eVS`S Xc`WaRWQbW]\ O`WaSa c\RS` bVS 8]\abWbcbW]\ ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa' O\ O[S\R[S\b

b] bVS 8]\abWbcbW]\' O\ OQb ]T 8]\U`Saa ]` O b`SObg ]T bVS J\WbSR HbObSa) >\ QOaSa eVS`S bVS J)H) Wa O ^O`bg' bVS J)H) ^ZOW\bWTT ]` RSTS\RO\b Q]RS bOYSa

^`SQSRS\QS' O\R P]f , ]` - aV]cZR PS [O`YSR)

9WdS`aWbg ]T QWbWhS\aVW^) %/& IVWa `STS`a b] acWba c\RS` -3 J)H)8) ,..-' eVS`S ^O`bWSa O`S QWbWhS\a ]T RWTTS`S\b abObSa) LVS\ 7]f / Wa QVSQYSR' bVS

QWbWhS\aVW^ ]T bVS RWTTS`S\b ^O`bWSa [cab PS QVSQYSR& %HSS HSQbW]\ >>> PSZ]e+ 9:?0* JIHIVEP UYIWXMSR EGXMSRW XEOI TVIGIHIRGI SZIV HMZIVWMX[

GEWIW&&

444& =IWMHIRGI #GMXM\IRWLMT$ SJ ;VMRGMTEP ;EVXMIW& IVWa aSQbW]\ ]T bVS ?H // Wa b] PS Q][^ZSbSR WT RWdS`aWbg ]T QWbWhS\aVW^ eOa W\RWQObSR OP]dS) BO`Y bVWa

aSQbW]\ T]` SOQV ^`W\QW^OZ ^O`bg)

4A& 9EXYVI SJ >YMX& EZOQS O\ "M" W\ bVS O^^`]^`WObS P]f) >T bVS`S O`S [cZbW^ZS \Obc`S ]T acWb Q]RSa Oaa]QWObSR eWbV bVS QOaS' ^WQY bVS \Obc`S ]T acWb Q]RS

bVOb Wa []ab O^^ZWQOPZS) 8ZWQY VS`S T]`5 CObc`S ]T HcWb 8]RS 9SaQ`W^bW]\a)

A& :VMKMR& EZOQS O\ "M" W\ ]\S ]T bVS aSdS\ P]fSa)

D`WUW\OZ E`]QSSRW\Ua) %,& 8OaSa eVWQV ]`WUW\ObS W\ bVS J\WbSR HbObSa RWab`WQb Q]c`ba)

GS[]dSR T`][ HbObS 8]c`b) %-& E`]QSSRW\Ua W\WbWObSR W\ abObS Q]c`ba [Og PS `S[]dSR b] bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`ba c\RS` IWbZS -3 J)H)8)' HSQbW]\ ,//,)

GS[O\RSR T`][ 6^^SZZObS 8]c`b) %.& 8VSQY bVWa P]f T]` QOaSa `S[O\RSR b] bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`b T]` Tc`bVS` OQbW]\) JaS bVS RObS ]T `S[O\R Oa bVS TWZW\U

RObS)

GSW\abObSR ]` GS]^S\SR) %/& 8VSQY bVWa P]f T]` QOaSa `SW\abObSR ]` `S]^S\SR W\ bVS RWab`WQb Q]c`b) JaS bVS `S]^S\W\U RObS Oa bVS TWZW\U RObS)

I`O\aTS``SR T`][ 6\]bVS` 9Wab`WQb) %0& ;]` QOaSa b`O\aTS``SR c\RS` IWbZS -3 J)H)8) HSQbW]\ ,/+/%O&) 9] \]b caS bVWa T]` eWbVW\ RWab`WQb b`O\aTS`a ]`

[cZbWRWab`WQb ZWbWUObW]\ b`O\aTS`a)

BcZbWRWab`WQb AWbWUObW]\ i I`O\aTS`) %1& 8VSQY bVWa P]f eVS\ O [cZbWRWab`WQb QOaS Wa b`O\aTS``SR W\b] bVS RWab`WQb c\RS` OcbV]`Wbg ]T IWbZS -3 J)H)8)

HSQbW]\ ,/+2)

BcZbWRWab`WQb AWbWUObW]\ i 9W`SQb ;WZS) %3& 8VSQY bVWa P]f eVS\ O [cZbWRWab`WQb QOaS Wa TWZSR W\ bVS aO[S RWab`WQb Oa bVS BOabS` B9A R]QYSb)

;70,>0 9:?0 ?3,? ?30=0 4> 9:? ,9 :=4249 .:/0 )& D`WUW\ 8]RS 2 eOa caSR T]` VWab]`WQOZ `SQ]`Ra O\R Wa \] Z]\US` `SZSdO\b RcS b]

QVO\USa W\ abObcS)

A4& .EYWI SJ ,GXMSR& GS^]`b bVS QWdWZ abObcbS RW`SQbZg `SZObSR b] bVS QOcaS ]T OQbW]\ O\R UWdS O P`WST RSaQ`W^bW]\ ]T bVS QOcaS) /S RSX GMXI NYVMWHMGXMSREP

WXEXYXIW YRPIWW HMZIVWMX[& :fO[^ZS5 J)H) 8WdWZ HbObcbS5 /2 JH8 00. 7`WST 9SaQ`W^bW]\5 J\OcbV]`WhSR `SQS^bW]\ ]T QOPZS aS`dWQS

A44& =IUYIWXIH MR .SQTPEMRX& 8ZOaa 6QbW]\) EZOQS O\ "M" W\ bVWa P]f WT g]c O`S TWZW\U O QZOaa OQbW]\ c\RS` GcZS -.' ;)G)8d)E)

9S[O\R) >\ bVWa a^OQS S\bS` bVS OQbcOZ R]ZZO` O[]c\b PSW\U RS[O\RSR ]` W\RWQObS ]bVS` RS[O\R' acQV Oa O ^`SZW[W\O`g W\Xc\QbW]\)

?c`g 9S[O\R) 8VSQY bVS O^^`]^`WObS P]f b] W\RWQObS eVSbVS` ]` \]b O Xc`g Wa PSW\U RS[O\RSR)

A444& =IPEXIH .EWIW& IVWa aSQbW]\ ]T bVS ?H // Wa caSR b] `STS`S\QS `SZObSR ^S\RW\U QOaSa' WT O\g) >T bVS`S O`S `SZObSR ^S\RW\U QOaSa' W\aS`b bVS R]QYSb

\c[PS`a O\R bVS Q]``Sa^]\RW\U XcRUS \O[Sa T]` acQV QOaSa)

/EXI ERH ,XXSVRI[ >MKREXYVI& 9ObS O\R aWU\ bVS QWdWZ Q]dS` aVSSb)

Case 5:20-cv-00149-TKW-MJF Document 2 Filed 05/19/20 Page 2 of 2