09/09/201 1 14:2 4 FA X 202493514 2 

### FA A r OM S @]001/00 5

5 7 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 $ 1 7 l e l y :?r i 2 1 2 2 2 3 I d 7. b 7 6 

## n 2 9 3 0 .". 1 3 2 3 1 3 4 3 b 3f . i 1 J d 3 9 4 0 ^ 1 •^ 2 < 3 4 4 -l.S -16 -1 7 -1 8 4 9 b O 5 1 5 2 JEFFRE Y M . }L\K>F. R FA AOFFIC EOFRiXGIONA LCOUNSE L 160 1 LrK D AVENU ESOUTHWES T R£NTON , WASHrNG l O N9S05 7 •1BLHPH^^^^: : (425)227-216 1 FACSIMILE ; (425 ) 227-100 7 

## OFFARTMEN TO F I'lANSPORTATIO M ••'C'CKETOPhRATiON S ZOi i Si ? - np 3 : qc ; UMTE D STATE S O FAMERIC A DEPARTMEN TO FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D. C

FA ACas e No . 20 ] 1NM07002 1 DM S No . F/\A-2011-048 4 I nth e Matte r

of : Cornerston e Aviation , Inc . F.A ACas e No . 2011MM07002 2 DM S No . F.AA-2011-048 1 F.A ACas e Ko . 2011NM07004 2 DMSNo . FAA-20I1-048 9 Judg e Richar dC . Goodwi n COMPLAINANT^ S INITIALDISCQVKRYREOUES' I To : Re^-pondcnt I nacc-ordanc c v-it

h14C.f_R . § 13.22 0 an dth e Federa l Rule s o f Civi l Procedure , pleas e respon dt o tli e followin g Inrerrogatorics , Rcquesrt s for Productio no f

Documents , an dReques t fo r Admissions , separatel y an dfuU

y unde r oai hb y Augus t

2^ , 2011 . Thes e discover y request s are intende dt o discove r informatio nand/o r

document s no t

onl y withi n you r persona l knowledg e o r

obtainabl e b y you , bu t

als o mfonnatio ninth e possessio no f o r obtainabl e b y you r

attorneys , invesrigaiors , reprcsentaTrves , employees , agents , o r anyon e actin g o n you r behal f o r o nthei r behalf. ihes e discover y request s ar c continuin g i nnatur e an dan y informatio nwhic hma y b e discL>veredb y yo u subsequen t

to th e servic e an dfilin g o f you r ans^ver s mus t

b e brough t

t o th e attentio no f

th e agenc y attorne y throug hsupplementa l answer s u'he ni t become s availabl e t o you , a t areasonabl e tim e prio r

t o th t hearin g inthi s matter . I f ther e ar e an y additions , delerion. s o r change s j nth e answer s o r

infortnatio aprovide dat an y tim e prio r

t o hearin g Ihc Responden. 1 i s specificall y requeste dt o s o immediatel y infom i th e agenc y attorney . I f suc b informatio ni s no t furnishcd i th e agenc y attorne y a t

th e tim e o f

th e beariD g wil l mov e t o exclud e fru mciidenc e suc h informatio nrequeste dan dno t furnished . Complainani; : IiiiUi l Discover y Rcqiic u Comcraon c AviuLioi v Inc . - 20 1 l>fMfJ7U021 , 20llNMn?O022 , iO I1NM070O4 2 Pag e 1 o f

6 VRL : (425 > 221-1]Or , TAX : (425 ) ;::7-l00 7

g' d 

### i^SlZ'SS^lO Q uoiiiErt v©uoisjaujO Q 

### d9L:c O i l eode s09/09/201 1 14:2 4 FA X 202493514 2 FA A- QM S ©002/00 5 SepO S 1 1 02.16 p Cornsrston g Availio n 801-355-275 4 p. 4

FA ACorrespondenc e Complainant' s tn'rtia l Discover yReques t Cornerston e Aviatio n

Bernar d Connell y- FV^ AFSD O 102 0 N . Flye rWa y Sal t Lak e City , LTT8431 6 

### (301)257-505 4 Willia m Hughe s - FAA 102 0 N . Flye rWa y Sal t Lak e City , U T8411 6 (SOI ) 257-504 5 Georg e Davi d Cawthr a - FAA - FSD O Manage r 102 0 N . Flye rWa y Sal t Lak e City . LI T8411 6 (SOI ) 257-S04 6

Pag e 4 o f409/09/201 1 1 4 2 4 FA X 202493514 2 FA A^ DM S 0003/00 5 SepO S 1 1 02:l5 p Cornerston Q Avaitio n 801-355-275 4 p. 3

FAACorrespondenc e Complairwn fs Initia l Discover yReques t Cornerston e Aviatio n ATTACHMEN T Camero n Howell-CFI l fo rMichae l Stan n IZS l Nort h MurdotV ; Drw e Plensan t Grove , U T8405 2 («01 ) 523-285 8 Kri s Kh e - CFI I fo rHale yWilso n 879 1 Sout h Terr a Poin t Wa y Wes t Jordan , U TS408 8 (801 ) B54-4d2 1 Michae l Stan n - studen t o fCamero n Howel t 211 5 S . Richar d St . Sal t Lak e Cilv,UTS411 5 (801 ) 244-140 4 Fion a Silcox-Assistan t chie finstructo rfo rCS Aa t SLCC campu s 

### 25 0 W . 390 0 So . Sal t Lak e atY,UT&410 7 

### (801 ) 949-319 4 Bria n Vandenve l - Chie finstructo rfo rCS A 101 5 N . 101 0 W . f'leas^sn t Grove , U T8406 2 (801 ) 836-711 2 Richar d Marshal l -forme rchie finstructo rfo rCS A- Privat e Pilo t Certjfkatjo n progra m 7SB ^ Sout h Gran t Stree t Midvale , U T8404 7 (801 ) 671-330 2 To m Kuhlma n —retire d FAA , curren t Designate d Pilo t Examine rfDPE ) 

### 950 8 Sout hKilmui r

Circl e \ So . Jordan , UT8409 5 

### (801)633-638 6 \ Jac k Garzell a - Compute rSoftwar e specialis t 187 1 Longbranc h Driv e Draper , UT8402 O (801)523-824 3 Pag e 3 o fa09/09/201 1 14.2 4 FA X 2024935U 2 FA A^ OM S @]004/00 5 Se p 0 8 1 1 02:15 p Cornerston e Avaltio n 601-355-275 4 p. 2

FAACorrespondenc e Coniplainanr' s initia l Discover yflequest Cornerston e Aviatio n S . Adrrii t - sh e onl yqualifie s t o receiv e partia l credi t urvde rhe rpar t 6 1 tramin^VKhtc h acnount a t o 25 % o fth e cours e requiremfint*; . V > sh e COLII H onl ycoun t 7. S hour s tov^ard s he rinstrumen t groun d instruction . Durin g th e cours e o finstrumen t trainin g he rinstructo rlogge d 18. 8 hour s o f briefin g tim e wit h he ro n a one-on-on e basis . Tha t equate s t o 26. 3 hour s ou t o fth e require d 3 0 hours . S . Admi t 7 . Admit - the yuse d t o h e 14 1 bu t a t th e tim e o fWilson' s trainin g the ywer e Par t 61 . 8 . Admi t 9 . Admi t 10 . Admi t 11 . Admi t 12 . Admi t 13 . Admi t 14 . Admi t 15 . Admi t 16 . Admi t 37 . N o - Whe n CS

Addministratio n <jiscovere d tJ^a t Camero n H&well , his instructor , an d Michae l Stan n bega n th e fligh t trainin g prio rt o hi s passin g hi s privat e pilo t certificatio n chec k ride , CSA repai d Mr . Stan n fo rhi s trainin g u p unti l tha t pain t (severa l thousan d dollars ) an d tol d hi m tha t w e coul d no t coun t an yo ftha t trainin g an d woul d re-star t hi s instrumen t program . CSAself dtsciose d tha t Informatio n t o iVi e fSD O i n SLC . CSAtol d hi s CF l t o begi n a ne wtrainin g recor d an d destro yth e ol d recor d a s i t coul d no t b e used . Additionally , student s hav e acces s t o onlin e schedulin g progra m t o schedul e flights . Michae l Stan n schedule d ahea d t o star t instrumen t trainin g

Pac e 2 o f409/09/201 1 14.2 5 FA X 202493514 2 FA A- Of.lS [2005/00 5 Se p 081 1 02:15 p Cornerston e Avaitio n 30 1 -355-275 4 p . 1

FA ACorrespon d fi n r e ("omplainant s Initia l Discover yReques t Cornerston e Aviatio n LNTERROGATORIE S Sinc e complaint s ar e consalidate d int o on e letter , th e response s hav e als o bee n consolidated . Pleas e refe rt o initia l lette rt o CS Afo rdetail s o fite m numbers . L IMomes , Addresse s an d Telephon e Number s (se e attachment ) 2 . Al l correspondenc e fro m FAAi s i n th e possessio n o f3usa n Horstman , Includin g al l copie s o f document s sen t t o he rb yJeffre yHarper . 3 . Names , Addresse s an d Telephon e Number s o fperson s who m CS Aintend s t o hav e testif ya s a factua l o rexper t wrtnes s i n CSA' s defens e a t th e hearin g o fthi s rnatter . (se e attachment ) 4 . Th e documenb > CSAarriicipatbi . offtntri ^ Ini o evidt;nc e ^ L th e he^iin g o r(hi s matte rar e th e sam e CS Aoffere d t o th e FAAFSDO , al l o fwhic h wer e sen t t o Jeffre yHarper , Th e matter s concernin g SLC C record s wril l b e addresse d b yeithe rSusa n Horstma n o rFion a Silcox . 5 . Al l exper t witnesse s ar e involve d i n fligh t trainin g i n on e aspec t o rarwther , eithe ra s instructors , chec k pilots , assistan t o rchie finstructor s o rFAAD P examiners , (se e attachment ) 6 . Al l exper t witnesse s ar e involve d i n flight trainin g i n or e aspec t o ranother , erthe ra s instructors , chec k pilots , assistan t o rchie finstructor s o rFAAD P examiners . Th e subjec t matte ri s m yFA A Par t 14 1 TCO . On e witnes s i s a compute rsoftwar e specialis t designin g ou rne wprogram . 7 . Pleas e clariT y:hi s r^iques t a s 1 d o no t kno wwli o Mr . Michdelb yii . 8 . Sinc e thi s ha s t>ee n ongoin g fo rsevera l month s f t i s impossibl e t o recal l exac t date s o f conversation s an d wit h who m I hav e discusse d th e matter s allege d i n th e Complain L I t i s mos t likel ylimite d t o person s affiliate d wit h th e fligh t sci^oo l a s the yhav e receive d instructio n s o th e occurrence s wil l no t happe n again . 9 . CSA' s Par t 14 1 TCO.an d trainin g document s REQUEST S FO R PRODUCTTO N l - ^ Th e FA

Aalread yha s copie s o fth e document s —d o yo u nee d m e t o mak e addititHia l copie s o fth e material s yo u sen t T O me ? Th e softwar e designe ro fne wfligh t schoo l trainin g progra m ha s compute rprotulyp e ready . TJtfs wil l hav e t o b e show n i n perso n t o FAA . REQUE&TFO R ADMISSION S 1 . Admi t 2 , Admi t - di d a t th e time ; wit h FA Aconsen t hav e no wchange d metho d o frecor d keepin g 3 - Admi t 4 . Admi t - Sh e wa s a transfe rstuden t fro m Uta h Valle yUniversit ywher e sh e complete d he r privat e pilo t groun d schoo l course . Pag e 1 o f4