8B

- i APPENDIX 8 B. LI FE

- CYCLE COST AND PAYBA CK PERIO D RESULTS

TABLE OF CO NTENTS

8B.1 DISTRIBUTION OF LIFE

- CYCLE COST RESULTS

................................ .......... 8B

- 1 8B.1.1 Representative Unit 1, NEMA Design B, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

.......................... 8B

- 1 8B.1.2 Representative Unit 2, Design B, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .... 8B

- 4 8B.1.3 Representative Unit 3, Design B, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .... 8B

- 6 8B.1.4 Representative Unit 4, Design C, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ ...... 8B

- 9 8B.1.5 Representative Unit 5, Design C, 50 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .. 8B

- 10 8B.1.6 Representative Unit 6, Fire Pump, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ ... 8B

- 12 8B.1.7 Representative Unit 7, Fire Pump, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ . 8B

- 14 8B.1.8 Representative Unit 8, Fire Pump, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ . 8B

- 16 8B.2 DISTRIBUTION OF PAYB ACK PERIOD RESULTS

................................ ....... 8B

- 18 8B.2.1 Representative Unit 1, Design B, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .... 8B

- 18 8B.2.2 Representative Unit 2, Design B, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .. 8B

- 20 8B.2.3 Representative Unit 3, Design B, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .. 8B

- 23 8B.2.4 Representative Unit 4, Design C, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .... 8B

- 25 8B.2.5 Representative Unit 5, Design C, 50 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ .. 8B

- 27 8B.2.6 Representative Unit 7, Fire Pump, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ . 8B

- 28 8B.2.7 Representative Unit 8, Fire Pump, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

................................ . 8B

- 30

TABLE OF FIGURES

Figure 8B.1.1 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 1 Figure 8B.1.2 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 2 Figu re 8B.1.3 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 2 Figure 8B.1.4 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 3 Figure 8B.1.5 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savin gs for CSL 5

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 3 Figure 8B.1.6 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 4 Figure 8B.1.7 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 4 Figure 8B.1.8 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 5 Figure 8B.1.9 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 58B

- ii Figure 8B.1.10 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 5

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 6 Figure 8B.1.11 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 6 Figure 8B.1.12 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 7 Figure 8B.1.13 Representative Unit 3: Distri bution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 7 Figure 8B.1.14 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings fo r CSL 4

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 8 Figure 8B.1.15 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 5

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 8 Figure 8B.1.16 Representative Unit 4: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 9 Figure 8B.1.17 Representative Unit 4: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 8B

- 9 Figure 8B.1.18 Representative Unit 4: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 10 Figure 8B.1.19 Representative Unit 5: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 10 Figure 8B.1.20 Representative Unit 5: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 11 Figu re 8B.1.21 Representative Unit 5: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 11 Figure 8B.1.22 Representative Unit 6: Di stribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 12 Figure 8B.1.23 Representative Unit 6: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Saving s for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 12 Figure 8B.1.24 Representative Unit 6: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 13 Figure 8B.1.25 Representative Unit 6: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 13 Figure 8B.1.26 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 14 Figure 8B.1.27 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 14 Figure 8B.1.28 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 15 Figu re 8B.1.29 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 15 Figure 8B.1.30 Representative Unit 8: Di stribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 16 Figure 8B.1.31 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Saving s for CSL 2

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 16 Figure 8B.1.32 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 178B

- iii Figure 8B.1.33 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 8B

- 17 Figure 8B.2.1 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 18 Figure 8B.2.2 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 18 Figure 8B.2.3 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 19 Figure 8B.2.4 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

.......... 8B

- 19 Figure 8B.2.5 Representative Unit 1: Distribution of Payba ck Periods for CSL 5

.......... 8B

- 20 Figure 8B.2.6 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 20 Figure 8B.2.7 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 21 Figure 8B.2.8 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 21 Figure 8B.2.9 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

.......... 8B

- 22 Figure 8B.2.10 Representative Unit 2: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 5

.......... 8B

- 22 Figure 8B.2.11 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 23 Figure 8B.2.12 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 23 Figure 8B.2.13 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 24 Figure 8B.2.14 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

.......... 8B

- 24 Figure 8B.2.15 Representative Unit 3: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 5

.......... 8B

- 25 Figure 8B.2.16 Representative Unit 4: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 25 Figure 8B.2.17 Representative Unit 4: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 26 Figure 8B.2.18 Representative Unit 4: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 26 Figure 8B.2.19 Representative Unit 5: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 27 Figure 8B.2.20 Representative Unit 5: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 27 Figure 8B.2.21 Representative Unit 5: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 28 Figure 8B.2.22 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 28 Figure 8B.2.23 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 29 Figure 8B.2.24 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 29 Figure 8B.2.25 Representative Unit 7: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

.......... 8B

- 30 Figure 8B.2.26 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

.......... 8B

- 30 Figure 8B.2.27 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

.......... 8B

- 31 Figure 8B.2.28 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

.......... 8B

- 31 Figure 8B.2.29 Representative Unit 8: Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

.......... 8B

- 328B

- 1 APPENDIX 8B. LI FE

- CYCLE COST AND PAYBA CK PERIO D RESULTS

8B.1 DISTRIBUTION OF LIFE

- CYCLE COST RESULTS
The distributions presented in this section each correspond to example runs of 10,000 Monte Carlo samples. As a result, their means may not correspond exactly with the mean values presented in the life

- cycle cost ( LCC ) section, which were generated by a di fferent Monte Carlo

run.

8B.1.1 Representative Unit 1, NEMA Design B, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.1 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 18B

- 2 Figure 8B.1.2 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

Figure 8B.1.3 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 38B

- 3 Figure 8B.1.4 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

Figure 8B.1.5 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 58B

- 4 8B.1.2 Representative Unit 2, Design B, 30 hp, 4 P oles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.6 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

Figure 8B.1.7 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 28B

- 5 Figure 8B.1.8 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

Figure 8B.1.9 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 48B

- 6 Figure 8B.1.10 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 5

8B.1.3 Representative Unit 3, Design B, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.11 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 18B

- 7 Figure 8B.1.12 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

Figure 8B.1.13 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 38B

- 8 Figure 8B.1.14 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 4

Figure 8B.1.15 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 58B

- 9 8B.1.4 Representative Unit 4, Design C, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.16 Representative Unit 4 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

Figure 8B.1.17 Representative Unit 4 : Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 28B

- 10 Figure 8B.1.18 Representative Unit 4 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

8B.1.5 Representative Unit 5, Design C, 50 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.19 Representative Unit 5 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 18B

- 11 Figure 8B.1.20 Representative Unit 5 : Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 2

Figure 8B.1.21 Representative Unit 5 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 38B

- 12 8B.1.6 Representative Unit 6, Fire Pump, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.22 Representative Unit 6 : Distribution of L ife

- Cyc le Cost Savings for CSL 1

Figure 8B.1.23 Representative Unit 6 : Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 28B

- 13 Figure 8B.1.24 Representative Unit 6 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

Figure 8B.1.25 Representative Unit 6 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 48B

- 14 8B.1.7 Re presentative Unit 7, Fire Pump, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.26 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

Figure 8B.1.27 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 28B

- 15 Figure 8B.1.28 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

Figure 8B.1.29 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 48B

- 16 8B.1.8 Representative Unit 8, Fire Pump, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.1.30 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 1

Figure 8B.1.31 Representa tive Unit 8 : Distribution of Life

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 28B

- 17 Figure 8B.1.32 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 3

Figure 8B.1.33 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of L ife

- Cycle Cost Savings for CSL 48B

- 18 8B.2 DISTRIBUTION OF PAYBACK PERIOD RESUL TS

8B.2.1 R epresentative Unit 1, Design B, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.1 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

Figure 8B.2.2 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 28B

- 19 Figure 8B.2.3 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

Figure 8B.2.4 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 48B

- 20 Figure 8B.2.5 Representative Unit 1 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 5

8B.2.2 Representative Unit 2, Design B, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.6 Representative U nit 2 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 18B

- 21 Figure 8B.2.7 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

Figure 8B.2.8 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 38B

- 22 Figure 8B.2.9 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

Figure 8B.2.10 Representative Unit 2 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 58B

- 23 8B.2.3 Representative Unit 3, Design B, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.11 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

Figure 8B.2.12 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 28B

- 24 Figure 8B.2.13 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

Figure 8B.2.14 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 48B

- 25 Figure 8B.2.15 Representative Unit 3 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 5

8B.2.4 Representative Unit 4 , Design C, 5 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.16 Representative Unit 4 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 18B

- 26 Figure 8B.2.17 Representative Unit 4 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

Figure 8B.2.18 Representative Unit 4 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 38B

- 27 8B.2.5 Representative Unit 5, Design C, 50 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.19 Representative Unit 5 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 1

Figure 8B.2.20 Representative Unit 5 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 28B

- 28 Figure 8B.2.21 Representative Unit 5 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 3

8B.2.6 Representative Unit 7, Fire Pump, 30 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.22 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 18B

- 29 Figure 8B.2.23 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CS L 2

Figure 8B.2.24 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 38B

- 30 Figure 8B.2.25 Representative Unit 7 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4

8B.2.7 Representative Unit 8, Fire Pump, 75 hp, 4 Poles, Enclosed

Figure 8B.2.26 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 18B

- 31 Figure 8B.2.27 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 2

Figure 8B.2.28 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 38B

- 32 Figure 8B.2.29 Representative Unit 8 : Distribution of Payback Periods for CSL 4