July 2015

NASA/TM2015-218781/Volume II/Part 3

NESC-RP-12-00783

 

Empirical Model Development for Predicting 

Shock Response on Composite Materials 

Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Appendices

Steven J. Gentz/NESC

Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia

David O. Ordway, David S. Parsons, Craig M. Garrison, C. Steven Rodgers, and Brian W. Collins

Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Alabama
NASA STI Program . . . in Profile

Since its founding, NASA has been dedicated to the 

advancement of aeronautics and space science. The 

NASA scientific and technical information (STI) 

program plays a key part in helping NASA maintain 

this important role.

The NASA STI program operates under the 

auspices of the Agency Chief Information Officer. 

It collects, organizes, provides for archiving, and 

disseminates NASA’s STI. The NASA STI 

program provides access to the NTRS Registered 

and its public interface, the NASA Technical 

Reports Server, thus providing one of the largest 

collections of aeronautical and space science STI in 

the world. Results are published in both non-NASA 

channels and by NASA in the NASA STI Report 

Series, which includes the following report types:

 TECHNICAL PUBLICATION. Reports of 

completed research or a major significant phase 

of research that present the results of NASA 

Programs and include extensive data or 

theoretical analysis. Includes compilations of 

significant scientific and technical data and 

information deemed to be of continuing 

reference value. NASA counter-part of peerreviewed formal professional papers but has 

less stringent limitations on manuscript length 

and extent of graphic presentations.

 TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM. Scientific 

and technical findings that are preliminary or of 

specialized interest, e.g., quick release reports, 

working papers, and bibliographies that contain 

minimal annotation. Does not contain extensive 

analysis.

 CONTRACTOR REPORT. Scientific and 

technical findings by NASA-sponsored 

contractors and grantees.

 CONFERENCE PUBLICATION. 

Collected papers from scientific and 

technical conferences, symposia, seminars, 

or other meetings sponsored or 

co-sponsored by NASA.

 SPECIAL PUBLICATION. Scientific, 

technical, or historical information from 

NASA programs, projects, and missions, 

often concerned with subjects having 

substantial public interest.

 TECHNICAL TRANSLATION. 

English-language translations of foreign 

scientific and technical material pertinent to 

NASA’s mission.

Specialized services also include organizing 

and publishing research results, distributing 

specialized research announcements and feeds, 

providing information desk and personal search 

support, and enabling data exchange services.

For more information about the NASA STI 

program, see the following:

 Access the NASA STI program home page 

at http://www.sti.nasa.gov

 E-mail your question to help@sti.nasa.gov

 Phone the NASA STI Information Desk at 

757-864-9658

 Write to:

 NASA STI Information Desk

 Mail Stop 148

 NASA Langley Research Center

 Hampton, VA 23681-2199
National Aeronautics and 

Space Administration

Langley Research Center 

Hampton, Virginia 23681-2199

July 2015

NASA/TM2015-218781/Volume II/Part 3

NESC-RP-12-00783

 

Empirical Model Development for Predicting 

Shock Response on Composite Materials 

Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Appendices

Steven J. Gentz/NESC

Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia

David O. Ordway, David S. Parsons, Craig M. Garrison, C. Steven Rodgers, and Brian W. Collins

Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, Alabama
Available from:

NASA STI Program / Mail Stop 148

NASA Langley Research Center

Hampton, VA 23681-2199

Fax: 757-864-6500

Acknowledgments

The team would like to acknowledge the following for providing their expertise:

Dr. Curt Larsen/Johnson Space Center (JSC), of the NESC, for championing the 

Pyroshock Characterization of Composites task.

Mr. Ken Johnson/MSFC for his tireless support statistically analyzing the postprocessed acceleration data.

Mr. Lee Allen/MSFC for supporting Ken Johnson in statistically analyzing the 

post-processed data

Ms. Barbara Breithaupt/MSFC for post-processing the pseudo-velocity data.

Mr. Justin Jackson/MSFC for providing his expertise in composite test panel 

fabrication.

The use of trademarks or names of manufacturers in the report is for accurate reporting and does not 

constitute an official endorsement, either expressed or implied, of such products or manufacturers by the 

National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

1 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on Composite 

Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Volume II: Appendices

Part 3

April 16, 2015
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

2 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Table of Contents

Technical Assessment Report Volume 2; Part 3

Appendix B. Pyroshock Test Reports (concluded)..................................................................3

B5. Group IV (MAF Panel Tests) .............................................................................................3

Appendix C. Pyroshock Data Summary ..............................................................................386
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

3 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Appendix B. Pyroshock Test Reports (concluded)

B5. Group IV (MAF Panel Tests)

The test report documenting the test results for the Group panel tests with and without MAF 

bonded to the panel are documented in the attachment below.
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

4 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

5 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

6 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

7 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

8 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

9 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

10 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

11 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

12 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

13 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

14 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

15 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

16 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

17 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

18 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

19 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

20 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

21 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

22 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

23 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

24 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

25 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

26 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

27 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

28 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

29 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

30 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

31 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

32 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

33 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

34 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

35 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

36 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

37 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

38 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

39 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

40 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

41 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

42 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

43 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

44 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

45 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

46 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

47 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

48 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

49 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

50 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

51 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

52 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

53 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

54 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

55 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

56 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

57 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

58 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

59 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

60 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

61 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

62 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

63 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

64 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

65 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

66 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

67 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

68 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

69 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

70 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

71 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

72 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

73 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

74 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

75 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

76 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

77 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

78 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

79 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

80 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

81 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

82 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

83 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

84 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

85 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

86 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

87 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

88 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

89 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

90 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

91 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

92 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

93 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

94 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

95 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

96 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

97 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

98 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

99 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

100 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

101 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

102 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

103 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

104 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

105 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

106 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

107 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

108 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

109 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

110 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

111 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

112 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

113 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

114 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

115 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

116 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

117 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

118 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

119 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

120 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

121 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

122 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

123 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

124 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

125 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

126 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

127 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

128 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

129 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

130 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

131 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

132 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

133 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

134 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

135 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

136 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

137 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

138 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

139 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

140 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

141 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

142 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

143 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

144 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

145 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

146 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

147 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

148 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

149 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

150 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

151 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

152 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

153 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

154 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

155 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

156 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

157 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

158 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

159 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

160 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

161 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

162 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

163 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

164 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

165 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

166 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

167 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

168 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

169 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

170 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

171 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

172 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

173 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

174 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

175 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

176 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

177 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

178 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

179 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

180 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

181 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

182 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

183 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

184 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

185 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

186 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

187 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

188 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

189 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

190 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

191 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

192 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

193 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

194 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

195 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

196 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

197 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

198 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

199 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

200 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

201 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

202 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

203 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

204 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

205 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

206 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

207 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

208 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

209 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

210 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

211 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

212 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

213 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

214 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

215 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

216 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

217 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

218 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

219 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

220 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

221 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

222 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

223 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

224 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

225 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

226 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

227 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

228 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

229 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

230 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

231 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

232 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

233 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

234 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

235 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

236 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

237 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

238 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

239 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

240 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

241 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

242 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

243 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

244 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

245 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

246 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

247 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

248 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

249 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

250 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

251 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

252 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

253 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

254 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

255 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

256 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

257 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

258 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

259 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

260 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

261 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

262 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

263 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

264 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

265 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

266 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

267 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

268 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

269 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

270 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

271 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

272 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

273 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

274 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

275 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

276 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

277 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

278 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

279 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

280 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

281 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

282 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

283 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

284 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

285 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

286 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

287 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

288 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

289 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

290 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

291 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

292 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

293 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

294 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

295 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

296 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

297 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

298 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

299 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

300 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

301 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

302 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

303 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

304 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

305 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

306 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

307 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

308 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

309 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

310 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

311 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

312 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

313 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

314 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

315 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

316 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

317 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

318 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

319 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

320 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

321 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

322 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

323 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

324 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

325 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

326 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

327 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

328 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

329 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

330 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

331 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

332 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

333 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

334 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

335 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

336 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

337 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

338 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

339 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

340 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

341 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

342 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

343 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

344 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

345 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

346 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

347 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

348 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

349 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

350 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

351 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

352 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

353 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

354 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

355 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

356 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

357 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

358 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

359 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

360 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

361 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

362 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

363 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

364 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

365 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

366 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

367 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

368 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

369 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

370 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

371 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

372 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

373 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

374 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

375 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

376 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

377 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

378 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

379 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

380 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

381 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

382 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

383 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

384 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

385 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

386 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Appendix C. Pyroshock Data Summary

A summary of the testing performed for this task assessment is provided in Figure C1, which 

includes the test configurations, test dates, and the post-test processed data results.

Date By Revision

12/30/2014 K Johnson Corrected Group III run dates.

Added column Type - Thick to data tabs.

1/13/2015 K Johnson Added model tabs (worksheets for individual model reports).

Delivered final database rev with corrections and rearrangements of 

several columns.
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

387 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Database describing individual Panel and Test information.

No of tests 

previously 

performed 

on this 

panel

=1 if LSC 

Plate = 

"Aluminum"

=1 if LSC plate 

was severed in 

test

= 1 if Damped

=1 if LSC is 

spliced from two 

or more pieces

= Y if any 

debonded accels 

are present in 

Test

=1 if backer plate 

was used; =0 if 

no backer plate; 

blank if no data

Date panel 

manufacture

d

Test 

No

Grou

p

Goal Panel 

No

Material Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

LSC 

Core 

Load

Panel 

Thickness

Ply Type LSC Plate Type - Thick Aluminum 

LSC Plate

Sever Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced LSC Debonded 

Accels

Orientation 0 

Degre

e

Plate 

Torque

Accel 

Torque

Accel 

Washer

Backer Plate Mfg Date Accel 

Config

Notes File Name Do not 

remove this 

column

P1 0 Pathfinder P1 5052 Aluminum 8/10/2012 0 1 0 0.187 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum Aluminum - 0.187 1 1 0 0 Aluminum 1

P2 0 Pathfinder P1 5052 Aluminum 8/16/2012 1 2 2 0.187 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum Aluminum - 0.187 1 1 0 0 Aluminum 1

P3 0 Pathfinder P3 Composite, IM7/R913 9/10/2012 0 1 0 0.2 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

1

P4 0 Pathfinder P4 Composite, IM7/R913 11/30/2012 0 1 0 0.2 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0 All plies 0°; 38 ply 0 0

P5 0 Pathfinder P5 Composite, IM7/R913 12/5/2012 0 1 0 0.2 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0 All plies 90°; 38 ply 0

1 1 Monolithic 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 1/23/2013 0 1 0 0.2 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0 0-Deg; 18 ply 0 5 5 3 5 0 1 11/28/2012 1 b NEST1-01_1048 0

2 1 Monolithic 2 Composite, IM7/TC350 1/29/2013 0 1 0 0.2 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 1 11/28/2012 1 b NEST1-02_1048 1

2 R 1 Monolithic 2 Composite, IM7/TC350 12/16/2013 1 2 2 0.2 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply

1 11/28/2012 NESr1-04_Time1048 1

3 1 Monolithic 3 Composite, IM7/TC350 2/8/2013 0 1 0 0.3 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0 Y

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 1 12/13/2012 1 b

A number of debonded 

accels

NEST1-03_1048 1

4 1 Monolithic 4 Composite, IM7/TC350 2/5/2013 0 2 2 0.3 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 1 12/17/2012 1 b NEST1-04_1048 1

4 R 1 Monolithic 4 Composite, IM7/TC350 12/12/2013 1 2 2 0.3 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply

1 12/17/2012 NESr1-02_1048 1

5 1 Monolithic 5 Composite, IM7/TC350 2/22/2013 0 2 2 0.2 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 1 12/20/2012 1 b NEST1-05_1048 1

6 1 Monolithic 6 Composite, IM7/TC350 5/8/2013 0 2 2 0.2 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0 0-Deg; 18 ply 0 5 5 3 5 0 0 1 b NEST1-06 0

7 1 Monolithic 7 Composite, IM7/TC350 5/9/2013 0 2 2 0.2 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 0 2 NEST1-07 1

8 1 Monolithic 8 Composite, IM7/TC350 5/16/2013 0 1 0 0.3 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 0 3 NEST1-08 1

9 1 Monolithic 9 Composite, IM7/TC350 5/17/2013 0 2 2 0.3 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 0 2 NEST1-09 1

9 R 1 Monolithic 9 Composite, IM7/TC350 1/23/2014 1 2 2 0.3 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply

1 NESTr1-09_1048 1

1 0 1 Monolithic 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 5/29/2013 0 1 0 0.2 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 1 0 0 Y

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply

1 5 5 3 5 0 0 3

A number of debonded 

accels

NEST1-10 1

10R 1 Monolithic 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 1/16/2014 1 1 0 0.2 Tape Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.2 1 0 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply

1 NESr1-10_1048 1

1 1 2 Sandwich 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 5/31/2013 0 1 0 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 0 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 2 0 2 5 1 0 2 NEST2-11_1048 1

1 2 2 Sandwich 1 4 Composite, IM7/TC350 6/28/2013 0 2 2 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 2 0 2 5 1 NEST2-12_1048 1

1 3 2 Sandwich 1 3 Composite, IM7/TC350 7/16/2013 0 1 0 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST2-13_1048 1

1 4 2 Sandwich 1 2 Composite, IM7/TC350 7/17/2013 0 2 2 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 0 3 NEST2-14_1048 1

1 5 2 Sandwich 1 6 Composite, IM7/TC350 7/18/2013 0 2 2 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST2-15_1048 1

1 6 2 Sandwich 1 8 Composite, IM7/TC350 7/23/2013 0 2 2 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST2-16_1048 1

1 7 2 Sandwich 1 5 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/9/2013 0 1 0 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST2-17_1048 1

1 8 2 Sandwich 1 7 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/19/2013 0 1 0 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST2-18_1048 1

1 9 3 Sever Plate 1 9 Composite, IM7/TC350 10/31/2013 0 1 0 1 Fabric Al Honey Fabric Composite Al Honey - 1 0 0 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST3-19_1048 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

388 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

2 0 3 Sever Plate 2 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 11/19/2013 0 2 2 1 Fabric Rohacell Fabric Composite Rohacell - 1 0 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST3-20_Time1048 1

2 1 3 Sever Plate 2 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 12/4/2013 0 2 2 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST3-21_1048 1

2 2 3 Sever Plate 2 2 Composite, IM7/TC350 11/25/2013 0 1 0 1 Fabric Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 0 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST3-22_Time1048 1

2 3 3 Sever Plate 2 3 Composite, IM7/TC350 4/18/2014 0 1 0 1 Fabric Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 0 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1

Note on this test: Prior to 

conducting the last 10 gpf test 

a modification to the standoff 

shims is going to be 

introduced to increase the 

shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to 

ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the 

standoff shim.

1

2 4 3 Sever Plate 2 4 Composite, IM7/TC350 4/22/2014 0 2 2 1 Fabric Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1

2 5 3 Sever Plate 2 5 Composite, IM7/TC350 6/10/2014 0 2 2 1 Fabric Al Honey Fabric Composite Al Honey - 1 0 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1

2 6 3 Sever Plate 2 6 Composite, IM7/TC350 12/18/2013 0 2 2 1 Tape Rohacell Tape Composite Rohacell - 1 0 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 NEST3-26_Time1048 1

2 7 3 Sever Plate 2 7 Composite, IM7/TC350 6/11/2014 0 1 0 1 Fabric Rohacell Fabric Composite Rohacell - 1 0 0 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1

2 8 3 Sever Plate 2 8 Composite, IM7/TC350 1/24/2014 0 1 0 1 Tape Al Honey Tape Composite Al Honey - 1 0 0 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1

Some delamination of the 32 

quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC 

panel.

NEST3-28_1048 1

A01 4 Acoustic Foam 8 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/25/2014 1 2 2 0.3 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 0 0

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply

1 1

A02 4 Acoustic Foam 8 Composite, IM7/TC350 9/5/2014 2 2 2 0.3 Fabric Monolithic Aluminum Monolithic - 0.3 1 1 1 1

+45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply

1 Spliced LSC 1

A03 4 Acoustic Foam P1 5052 Aluminum 8/27/2014 2 2 2 0.187 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum Aluminum - 0.187 1 1 0 1 Aluminum 1 Spliced LSC

A04 4 Acoustic Foam P1 5052 Aluminum 9/2/2014 3 2 2 0.187 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum Aluminum - 0.187 1 1 1 1 Aluminum 1 Spliced LSC

A05 4 Acoustic Foam 1 7 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/20/2014 1 2 2 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1

A06 4 Acoustic Foam 1 7 Composite, IM7/TC350 9/3/2014 2 2 2 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 1 1

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 Spliced LSC 1

A07 4 Acoustic Foam 1 8 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/26/2014 1 2 2 1 Tape Rohacell Aluminum Rohacell - 1 1 1 1 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1

A08 4 Acoustic Foam 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/26/2014 1 2 2 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 0 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1

A09 4 Acoustic Foam 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 9/4/2014 2 2 2 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 1 1

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 Spliced LSC 1

A10 4 Acoustic Foam 1 2 Composite, IM7/TC350 8/21/2014 1 2 2 1 Tape Al Honey Aluminum Al Honey - 1 1 1 1 0

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

389 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Data SRS Prelim Params

282

This column 

repeats Test 

N o

= 1 if more than 

one Freq Break 

Point

Max (First 

Slope; 

Second 

Slope)

If one slope First 

Slope; if two 

slopes Second 

Slope

= Max SRS 

Accel

Number of 

Slopes/ 

Plateaus

=1 if Max 

SRS Freq = 

10000

=Plateau 

Max

inch H z H z H z dB/Oct dB/Oct dB/Oct dB/Oct g g g count H z g in/s in/s

c Test No Panel No Group Goal Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Aluminum LSC 

Plate

Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accels

0 Degree Material Orientation Plate 

Torque

Accel 

Torque

Accel 

Washer

Mfg Date Accel 

Config

Notes Backer 

Plate

Test Output 

Name

Station First 

Frequency 

Break Point

Second 

Frequency Break 

Point

Frequency Break 

Point Max

Freq Break 

Censor

First 

Slope

Second 

Slope

Slope Max Last Slope First 

Plateau

Second 

Plateau

Plateau Max No Plateaus Max SRS 

Freq

Max SRS 

Freq 

Censor

Max SRS 

Accel

Max PV 

Freq

Max PV 

Velocity

1 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 #VALUE! 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 1-2 1 3569 3569 0 8.8 8.8 8.8 17525 17525 1 10000 1 17525 1479 171

2 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 #VALUE! 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 3-4 2 1829 1829 0 10.5 10.5 10.5 11295 11295 1 8414 0 11295 1622 178

3 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 5-6 3 2235 2235 0 9.9 9.9 9.9 12561 12561 1 9886 0 12561 1479 165

4 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 7-8 4 3956 3956 0 7.2 7.2 7.2 10377 10377 1 10000 1 10377 1549 178

5 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 9-10 5 2948 2948 0 7.9 7.9 7.9 11293 11293 1 6237 0 11293 3311 155

6 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 11-12 6 282 1972 1972 1 17.2 18.4 18.4 18.4 923 13285 13285 2 6607 0 13285 1738 226

7 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 1-2 1 2205 2205 0 9.5 9.5 9.5 15170 15170 1 3981 0 15170 3802 234

8 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 3-4 2 3837 3837 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 14814 14814 1 8222 0 14814 3715 173

9 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 5-6 3 2247 2247 0 9.2 9.2 9.2 13014 13014 1 8222 0 13014 871 191

10 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 7-8 4 4232 4232 0 7.5 7.5 7.5 15470 15470 1 6310 0 15470 4074 161

11 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 9-10 5 2923 2923 0 8 8 8 14643 14643 1 6383 0 14643 4266 179

12 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 11-12 6 278 4148 4148 1 17.5 7.6 17.5 7.6 1351 18641 18641 2 10000 1 18641 3802 276

13 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913 ((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply P3 Ch. 1-2 1 1265 1265 0 11.4 11.4 11.4 9605 9605 1 10000 1 9605 1096 212

14 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913 ((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply P3 Ch. 3-4 2 2802 2802 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 15179 15179 1 7244 0 15179 245 175

15 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913 ((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply P3 Ch. 5-6 3 238 2145 2145 1 14.9 10.7 14.9 10.7 738 8231 8231 2 10000 1 8231 1318 163

16 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913 ((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply P3 Ch. 7-8 4 216 1570 1570 1 23.7 15.4 23.7 15.4 1148 8496 8496 2 10000 1 8496 1202 233

17 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913 ((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply P3 Ch. 9-10 5 210 1695 1695 1 16.5 13.4 16.5 13.4 486 11554 11554 2 10000 1 11554 1445 175

18 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913 ((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° 

(2X); 90° (2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply P3 Ch. 11-12 6 374 1651 1651 1 15.9 23.5 23.5 23.5 1816 8579 8579 2 6918 0 8579 1380 168

19 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 1-2 1 2869 2869 0 6 6 6 13601 13601 1 10000 1 13601 398 300

20 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 3-4 2 940 940 0 13.1 13.1 13.1 10268 10268 1 10000 1 10268 490 271

21 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 5-6 3 773 3474 3474 1 9.8 18 18 18 5137 10480 10480 2 10000 1 10480 447 281

22 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 7-8 4 791 3350 3350 1 7.5 12.1 12.1 12.1 4016 7299 7299 2 3508 0 7299 479 273

23 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 9-10 5 358 3368 3368 1 16.6 17.7 17.7 17.7 5245 7107 7107 2 3467 0 7107 550 423

24 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 11-12 6 356 3191 3191 1 15.2 25.7 25.7 25.7 4602 6856 6856 2 3508 0 6856 550 441

25 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 1-2 1 1676 1676 0 10.1 10.1 10.1 12478 12478 1 5370 0 12478 1622 309

26 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 3-4 2 2252 2252 0 9 9 9 15120 15120 1 6607 0 15120 1995 265

27 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 5-6 3 1641 1641 0 9.1 9.1 9.1 8685 8685 1 7674 0 8685 1585 315

28 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 7-8 4 1574 1574 0 9.2 9.2 9.2 8786 8786 1 1884 0 8786 1862 288

29 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 9-10 5 376 1278 1278 1 12.7 16.7 16.7 16.7 1175 10497 10497 2 1660 0 10497 1622 393

30 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 11-12 6 700 2593 2593 1 13.4 17.9 17.9 17.9 4099 9672 9672 2 5957 0 9672 794 273

31 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 1 Ch. 1-2 1 2644 2644 0 6.6 6.6 6.6 13982 13982 1 10000 1 13982 447 332

32 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 1 Ch. 3-4 2 2587 2587 0 5.8 5.8 5.8 12754 12754 1 8222 0 12754 513 318

33 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 1 Ch. 5-6 3 2519 2519 0 5.9 5.9 5.9 11777 11777 1 3428 0 11777 661 313

34 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 1 Ch. 7-8 4 1952 1952 0 6.2 6.2 6.2 10551 10551 1 6026 0 10551 617 341

35 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 1 Ch. 9-10 5 1989 1989 0 6.3 6.3 6.3 11626 11626 1 3273 0 11626 575 342

36 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 1 Ch. 11-12 6 377 1980 1980 1 16.6 19.2 19.2 19.2 3684 12599 12599 2 5248 0 12599 468 390

43 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 2 Ch. 1-2 1 1994 1994 0 9.6 9.6 9.6 14368 14368 1 10000 1 14368 871 255

44 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 2 Ch. 3-4 2 2440 2440 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 11514 11514 1 5248 0 11514 3467 194

45 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 2 Ch. 5-6 3 2051 2051 0 10.2 10.2 10.2 12570 12570 1 5888 0 12570 1380 241

46 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 2 Ch. 7-8 4 2492 2492 0 7.9 7.9 7.9 11525 11525 1 3758 0 11525 1413 238

47 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 2 Ch. 9-10 5 3307 3307 0 7 7 7 12773 12773 1 3802 0 12773 1514 207

48 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 55 35 0 11/28/2012 1b 1 2 Ch. 11-12 6 308 1876 1876 1 16.8 20.6 20.6 20.6 1190 12181 12181 2 4624 0 12181 1549 223

61 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 12/17/2012 1b 1 4 Ch. 1-2 1 2594 2594 0 7.8 7.8 7.8 11005 11005 1 10000 1 11005 1413 175

62 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 12/17/2012 1b 1 4 Ch. 3-4 2 1406 1406 0 9.5 9.5 9.5 8270 8270 1 5495 0 8270 1288 220

63 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 12/17/2012 1b 1 4 Ch. 5-6 3 2022 2022 0 9.4 9.4 9.4 8448 8448 1 8414 0 8448 1738 222

64 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 12/17/2012 1b 1 4 Ch. 7-8 4 337 2239 2239 1 12.8 12.1 12.8 12.1 986 9696 9696 2 9120 0 9696 1549 182

65 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 12/17/2012 1b 1 4 Ch. 9-10 5 266 3655 3655 1 16.1 6.9 16.1 6.9 655 9607 9607 2 5689 0 9607 2188 171

66 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 12/17/2012 1b 1 4 Ch. 11-12 6 3039 3039 0 7 7 7 9069 9069 1 6166 0 9069 447 135

49 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 12/13/2012 1b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 1-2 1 1756 1756 0 9.5 9.5 9.5 11499 11499 1 10000 1 11499 1698 213

50 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 12/13/2012 1b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 3-4 2 1899 1899 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 8646 8646 1 10000 1 8646 1445 258
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

390 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

51 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 12/13/2012 1b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 5-6 3 1832 1832 0 8.5 8.5 8.5 9003 9003 1 7161 0 9003 1698 284

52 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 12/13/2012 1b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 7-8 4 340 1466 1466 1 14 14.2 14.2 14.2 1401 8228 8228 2 1799 0 8228 1318 297

53 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 12/13/2012 1b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 9-10 5 349 1643 1643 1 13.5 11 13.5 11 1138 7945 7945 2 9120 0 7945 1585 274

54 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 12/13/2012 1b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 11-12 6 555 2487 2487 1 12.8 16.3 16.3 16.3 2709 9363 9363 2 6918 0 9363 692 219

67 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 12/20/2012 1b 1 5 Ch. 1-2 1 2631 2631 0 7.4 7.4 7.4 13539 13539 1 9120 0 13539 741 246

68 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 12/20/2012 1b 1 5 Ch. 3-4 2 3351 3351 0 7.1 7.1 7.1 16746 16746 1 8610 0 16746 3311 303

69 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 12/20/2012 1b 1 5 Ch. 5-6 3 3209 3209 0 7.7 7.7 7.7 16265 16265 1 9016 0 16265 2692 269

70 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 12/20/2012 1b 1 5 Ch. 7-8 4 2767 2767 0 8.1 8.1 8.1 13872 13872 1 5957 0 13872 2818 264

71 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 12/20/2012 1b 1 5 Ch. 9-10 5 3087 3087 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 15586 15586 1 5888 0 15586 2630 276

72 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 12/20/2012 1b 1 5 Ch. 11-12 6 457 2952 2952 1 14.7 12.6 14.7 12.6 2586 17671 17671 2 5248 0 17671 2754 293

73 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 1b 0 6 Ch. 1-2 1 2560 2560 0 7.2 7.2 7.2 18254 18254 1 9661 0 18254 1230 375

74 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 1b 0 6 Ch. 3-4 2 2016 2016 0 8.1 8.1 8.1 15930 15930 1 9226 0 15930 955 376

75 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 1b 0 6 Ch. 5-6 3 1372 1372 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 11264 11264 1 8222 0 11264 1072 364

76 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 1b 0 6 Ch. 7-8 4 1696 1696 0 6.5 6.5 6.5 10721 10721 1 3388 0 10721 891 368

77 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 1b 0 6 Ch. 9-10 5 1885 1885 0 5.9 5.9 5.9 13675 13675 1 2455 0 13675 1072 447

78 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 55 35 0 1b 0 6 Ch. 11-12 6 311 2031 2031 1 19.4 17.5 19.4 17.5 3413 13618 13618 2 2265 0 13618 2138 382

79 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply 55 35 0 2 0 7 Ch. 1-2 1 2500 2500 0 7.4 7.4 7.4 20354 20354 1 8710 0 20354 871 380

80 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply 55 35 0 2 0 7 Ch. 3-4 2 1825 1825 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 15695 15695 1 7586 0 15695 871 344

81 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply 55 35 0 2 0 7 Ch. 5-6 3 1089 1089 0 8.8 8.8 8.8 11437 11437 1 9772 0 11437 1023 381

82 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply 55 35 0 2 0 7 Ch. 7-8 4 1651 1651 0 8 8 8 10996 10996 1 8810 0 10996 1413 373

83 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply 55 35 0 2 0 7 Ch. 9-10 5 2354 2354 0 6.1 6.1 6.1 13602 13602 1 4898 0 13602 490 385

84 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 

ply 55 35 0 2 0 7 Ch. 11-12 6 302 2303 2303 1 16.4 12.7 16.4 12.7 2943 16139 16139 2 8318 0 16139 339 482

85 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 3 0 8 Ch. 1-2 1 2759 2759 0 10 10 10 15759 15759 1 10000 1 15759 1660 171

86 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 3 0 8 Ch. 3-4 2 1495 1495 0 10.6 10.6 10.6 14657 14657 1 10000 1 14657 1445 233

87 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 3 0 8 Ch. 5-6 3 1476 1476 0 14.3 14.3 14.3 11130 11130 1 10000 1 11130 1820 270

88 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 3 0 8 Ch. 7-8 4 2056 2056 0 9.3 9.3 9.3 9468 9468 1 4732 0 9468 2089 256

89 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 3 0 8 Ch. 9-10 5 2142 2142 0 10 10 10 10158 10158 1 7079 0 10158 1950 263

90 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 55 35 0 3 0 8 Ch. 11-12 6 2208 2208 0 9.6 9.6 9.6 10309 10309 1 6918 0 10309 1995 218

97 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 2 0 9 Ch. 1-2 1 1707 1707 0 9.6 9.6 9.6 9877 9877 1 10000 1 9877 1514 226

98 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 2 0 9 Ch. 3-4 2 1252 1252 0 10.6 10.6 10.6 9279 9279 1 6839 0 9279 1660 306

99 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 2 0 9 Ch. 5-6 3 945 945 0 14.5 14.5 14.5 10512 10512 1 1995 0 10512 1698 346

100 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 2 0 9 Ch. 7-8 4 1874 1874 0 8.5 8.5 8.5 10884 10884 1 9661 0 10884 1820 336

101 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 2 0 9 Ch. 9-10 5 1917 1917 0 8.9 8.9 8.9 9542 9542 1 7413 0 9542 1549 276

102 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 55 35 0 2 0 9 Ch. 11-12 6 653 2495 2495 1 12.3 19.9 19.9 19.9 2648 13631 13631 2 6761 0 13631 741 218

109 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 10 Ch. 1-2 1 3060 3060 0 8.7 8.7 8.7 22897 22897 1 10000 1 22897 1096 274

110 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 10 Ch. 3-4 2 2288 2288 0 9 9 9 18794 18794 1 8414 0 18794 1096 283

111 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 10 Ch. 5-6 3 2644 2644 0 8.3 8.3 8.3 18405 18405 1 10000 1 18405 1122 306

112 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 10 Ch. 7-8 4 1613 1613 0 10.8 10.8 10.8 12351 12351 1 3846 0 12351 1259 311

113 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 10 Ch. 9-10 5 2007 2007 0 8.5 8.5 8.5 11920 11920 1 4571 0 11920 1096 281

114 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 55 35 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 10 Ch. 11-12 6 516 2395 2395 1 14.4 13.6 14.4 13.6 2430 14080 14080 2 4416 0 14080 2399 300

115 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 2 0 11 Ch. 1-2 1 2458 2458 0 10 10 10 17035 17035 1 10000 1 17035 2570 139
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

391 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

116 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 2 0 11 Ch. 3-4 2 2587 2587 0 7.7 7.7 7.7 11602 11602 1 9333 0 11602 479 173

117 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 2 0 11 Ch. 5-6 3 295 2061 2061 1 14.9 15.3 15.3 15.3 1067 10434 10434 2 9120 0 10434 295 209

118 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 2 0 11 Ch. 7-8 4 326 3128 3128 1 13.8 8.4 13.8 8.4 1021 8908 8908 2 3758 0 8908 309 190

119 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 2 0 11 Ch. 9-10 5 307 3210 3210 1 15.9 7 15.9 7 1461 8097 8097 2 3508 0 8097 457 191

120 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 2 0 11 Ch. 11-12 6 219 1778 1778 1 20.4 20.1 20.4 20.1 700 8439 8439 2 4955 0 8439 224 187

121 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 12 Ch. 1-2 1 2957 2957 0 7.8 7.8 7.8 14557 14557 1 10000 1 14557 1862 262

122 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 12 Ch. 3-4 2 311 1719 1719 1 13.9 10.9 13.9 10.9 1219 9624 9624 2 5129 0 9624 1698 306

123 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 12 Ch. 5-6 3 245 1701 1701 1 17.7 10.6 17.7 10.6 1423 8259 8259 2 4786 0 8259 245 346

124 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 12 Ch. 7-8 4 278 1930 1930 1 19.5 10.7 19.5 10.7 1964 6863 6863 2 1995 0 6863 263 358

125 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 12 Ch. 9-10 5 287 1940 1940 1 13.7 10 13.7 10 1051 8240 8240 2 1972 0 8240 1950 257

126 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 20 25 1 12 Ch. 11-12 6 214 1533 1533 1 20.4 15.2 20.4 15.2 624 7624 7624 2 1778 0 7624 1660 271

127 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 13 Ch. 1-2 1 4158 4158 0 7.6 7.6 7.6 11810 11810 1 10000 1 11810 4467 145

128 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 13 Ch. 3-4 2 360 2016 2016 1 17.2 12 17.2 12 1389 7534 7534 2 10000 1 7534 1905 190

129 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 13 Ch. 5-6 3 307 2103 2103 1 18.9 12.7 18.9 12.7 1479 6283 6283 2 10000 1 6283 240 169

130 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 13 Ch. 7-8 4 296 2369 2369 1 19.7 8.3 19.7 8.3 1283 4464 4464 2 4121 0 4464 257 185

131 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 13 Ch. 9-10 5 348 1910 1910 1 14.3 9.9 14.3 9.9 1000 5078 5078 2 1950 0 5078 1905 162

132 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 13 Ch. 11-12 6 230 1636 1636 1 21.2 13.9 21.2 13.9 397 5637 5637 2 1841 0 5637 1778 192

133 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 3 0 14 Ch. 1-2 1 2923 2923 0 6.5 6.5 6.5 13588 13588 1 7328 0 13588 933 260

134 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 3 0 14 Ch. 3-4 2 1198 1198 0 10.9 10.9 10.9 11460 11460 1 5129 0 11460 955 250

135 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 3 0 14 Ch. 5-6 3 308 2714 2714 1 16.3 9.3 16.3 9.3 1781 13169 13169 2 4842 0 13169 275 255

136 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 3 0 14 Ch. 7-8 4 340 2281 2281 1 13.1 10.2 13.1 10.2 1285 8454 8454 2 3846 0 8454 316 209

137 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 3 0 14 Ch. 9-10 5 249 2145 2145 1 17.5 10.6 17.5 10.6 1499 9768 9768 2 3467 0 9768 479 191

138 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 3 0 14 Ch. 11-12 6 211 1799 1799 1 21.6 16.8 21.6 16.8 1575 11453 11453 2 4786 0 11453 214 444

139 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 15 Ch. 1-2 1 3771 3771 0 6.2 6.2 6.2 16318 16318 1 7943 0 16318 933 253

140 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 15 Ch. 3-4 2 2650 2650 0 6.7 6.7 6.7 11694 11694 1 4121 0 11694 955 241

141 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 15 Ch. 5-6 3 296 2145 2145 1 17 9.8 17 9.8 1540 10038 10038 2 4315 0 10038 275 234

142 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 15 Ch. 7-8 4 385 2577 2577 1 14.3 8.5 14.3 8.5 1567 8181 8181 2 3802 0 8181 324 190

143 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 15 Ch. 9-10 5 263 2494 2494 1 17.5 8.4 17.5 8.4 1375 8493 8493 2 3350 0 8493 2188 184

144 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 15 Ch. 11-12 6 208 1735 1735 1 21.1 15.7 21.1 15.7 1362 9479 9479 2 1995 0 9479 214 388

145 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 16 Ch. 1-2 1 2026 2026 0 9.7 9.7 9.7 14050 14050 1 10000 1 14050 1778 271

146 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 16 Ch. 3-4 2 312 1690 1690 1 12.9 12.1 12.9 12.1 1427 10589 10589 2 1928 0 10589 1862 341

147 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 16 Ch. 5-6 3 277 1704 1704 1 17.7 13.2 17.7 13.2 1996 9001 9001 2 1995 0 9001 245 340

148 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 16 Ch. 7-8 4 278 1858 1858 1 19.3 11.2 19.3 11.2 1875 7201 7201 2 1972 0 7201 263 350

149 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 16 Ch. 9-10 5 298 1911 1911 1 12.7 11.8 12.7 11.8 1205 9232 9232 2 1950 0 9232 1905 292

150 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 16 Ch. 11-12 6 225 1593 1593 1 19.9 15.6 19.9 15.6 655 9354 9354 2 1841 0 9354 1698 322

151 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 17 Ch. 1-2 1 3152 3152 0 8.6 8.6 8.6 14466 14466 1 10000 1 14466 1738 181

152 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 17 Ch. 3-4 2 1653 1653 0 9.2 9.2 9.2 11093 11093 1 4266 0 11093 380 194

153 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 17 Ch. 5-6 3 336 2324 2324 1 18.1 13.6 18.1 13.6 2197 8921 8921 2 4121 0 8921 288 255

154 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 17 Ch. 7-8 4 362 3379 3379 1 15.9 8.7 15.9 8.7 1705 9639 9639 2 3846 0 9639 316 221

155 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 17 Ch. 9-10 5 263 2809 2809 1 20.3 9.2 20.3 9.2 1255 9565 9565 2 4677 0 9565 2188 183

156 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 17 Ch. 11-12 6 214 1934 1934 1 23.4 15.6 23.4 15.6 991 8747 8747 2 4467 0 8747 219 270
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

392 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

157 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 18 Ch. 1-2 1 2447 2447 0 9.7 9.7 9.7 10395 10395 1 5070 0 10395 1778 169

158 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 18 Ch. 3-4 2 471 2331 2331 1 14 10.1 14 10.1 1331 6624 6624 2 8035 0 6624 2042 143

159 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 18 Ch. 5-6 3 292 2282 2282 1 20.4 11.8 20.4 11.8 1201 5766 5766 2 7762 0 5766 251 145

160 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 18 Ch. 7-8 4 292 2169 2169 1 19.3 11.2 19.3 11.2 990 4782 4782 2 5070 0 4782 257 148

161 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 18 Ch. 9-10 5 405 1924 1924 1 15.3 15.8 15.8 15.8 1169 5308 5308 2 1995 0 5308 1950 165

162 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 18 Ch. 11-12 6 224 1701 1701 1 18.1 13.3 18.1 13.3 315 4303 4303 2 1972 0 4303 1698 136

163 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 19 Ch. 1-2 1 607 3281 3281 1 13.4 20.9 20.9 20.9 2621 10742 10742 2 7079 0 10742 646 236

164 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 19 Ch. 3-4 2 715 3250 3250 1 10.5 19.7 19.7 19.7 2112 8435 8435 2 10000 1 8435 562 149

165 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 19 Ch. 5-6 3 631 3408 3408 1 14 18.7 18.7 18.7 1926 7950 7950 2 10000 1 7950 525 146

166 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 19 Ch. 7-8 4 641 3440 3440 1 8.6 10 10 10 1321 7160 7160 2 3548 0 7160 3388 126

167 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 19 Ch. 9-10 5 551 3184 3184 1 10.9 22.6 22.6 22.6 1523 6428 6428 2 3802 0 6428 537 157

168 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 19 Ch. 11-12 6 420 3606 3606 1 13.6 8.1 13.6 8.1 691 6138 6138 2 4074 0 6138 2951 97

169 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 20 Ch. 1-2 1 576 6320 6320 1 14.6 8.9 14.6 8.9 3202 32442 32442 2 9772 0 32442 562 275

170 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 20 Ch. 3-4 2 489 3656 3656 1 10.1 11.3 11.3 11.3 2247 17874 17874 2 8511 0 17874 468 284

171 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 20 Ch. 5-6 3 571 3286 3286 1 10.7 13.6 13.6 13.6 1555 14719 14719 2 9016 0 14719 2818 210

172 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 20 Ch. 7-8 4 549 2920 2920 1 11.9 13.8 13.8 13.8 1794 8905 8905 2 8414 0 8905 537 194

173 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 20 Ch. 9-10 5 472 2640 2640 1 12.5 21.5 21.5 21.5 2576 7233 7233 2 7943 0 7233 468 322

174 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 20 Ch. 11-12 6 266 1597 1597 1 20.5 19.5 20.5 19.5 772 6167 6167 2 3715 0 6167 219 107

181 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 22 Ch. 1-2 1 331 1998 1998 1 17.2 17.1 17.2 17.1 513 10707 10707 2 10000 1 10707 2042 261

182 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 22 Ch. 3-4 2 392 2253 2253 1 14.8 15 15 15 830 8661 8661 2 10000 1 8661 2042 193

183 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 22 Ch. 5-6 3 308 2093 2093 1 18.9 17 18.9 17 776 6811 6811 2 10000 1 6811 1995 170

184 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 22 Ch. 7-8 4 313 1844 1844 1 16.9 19.6 19.6 19.6 626 5007 5007 2 2188 0 5007 1905 146

185 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 22 Ch. 9-10 5 443 1865 1865 1 12.6 21.4 21.4 21.4 756 4924 4924 2 1972 0 4924 1905 155

186 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 22 Ch. 11-12 6 253 1956 1956 1 21 16.2 21 16.2 447 5014 5014 2 2089 0 5014 2042 148

175 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 21 Ch. 1-2 1 2878 2878 0 8.8 8.8 8.8 15533 15533 1 10000 1 15533 1738 233

176 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 21 Ch. 3-4 2 1761 1761 0 9.2 9.2 9.2 10938 10938 1 9886 0 10938 1995 226

177 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 21 Ch. 5-6 3 361 2225 2225 1 17.4 13.7 17.4 13.7 2236 10912 10912 2 4315 0 10912 288 219

178 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 21 Ch. 7-8 4 346 2234 2234 1 14.3 11.5 14.3 11.5 1105 7992 7992 2 3846 0 7992 1738 172

179 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 21 Ch. 9-10 5 481 2393 2393 1 10.4 10.8 10.8 10.8 1471 8322 8322 2 3589 0 8322 2188 198

180 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 21 Ch. 11-12 6 222 1948 1948 1 22.5 15.2 22.5 15.2 842 10013 10013 2 2344 0 10013 1995 285

55 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 12/17/2012 4R Ch. 1-2 1 3141 3141 0 7.2 7.2 7.2 12188 12188 1 6531 0 12188 977 186

56 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 12/17/2012 4R Ch. 3-4 2 2708 2708 0 7.9 7.9 7.9 12597 12597 1 9661 0 12597 1202 216

57 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 12/17/2012 4R Ch. 5-6 3 1576 1576 0 11.6 11.6 11.6 12111 12111 1 6683 0 12111 1698 219

58 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 12/17/2012 4R Ch. 7-8 4 2768 2768 0 8.9 8.9 8.9 11301 11301 1 6026 0 11301 1514 178

59 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 12/17/2012 4R Ch. 9-10 5 2623 2623 0 7.3 7.3 7.3 11004 11004 1 6237 0 11004 1318 223

60 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 12/17/2012 4R Ch. 11-12 6 246 2685 2685 1 19.8 11.3 19.8 11.3 637 15187 15187 2 6095 0 15187 2188 176

37 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 11/28/2012 2R Ch. 1-2 1 680 3355 3355 1 10.8 28.3 28.3 28.3 5837 14498 14498 2 9886 0 14498 692 311

38 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 11/28/2012 2R Ch. 3-4 2 2284 2284 0 8.9 8.9 8.9 15403 15403 1 5433 0 15403 891 268

39 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 11/28/2012 2R Ch. 5-6 3 1912 1912 0 9.5 9.5 9.5 13801 13801 1 5623 0 13801 955 305

40 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 11/28/2012 2R Ch. 7-8 4 1229 3203 3203 1 6.9 17 17 17 5701 14176 14176 2 3467 0 14176 1096 290

41 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 11/28/2012 2R Ch. 9-10 5 266 3568 3568 1 15.6 5.8 15.6 5.8 1842 14959 14959 2 3548 0 14959 245 320
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

393 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

42 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

18 ply 11/28/2012 2R Ch. 11-12 6 303 2231 2231 1 17.1 15.7 17.1 15.7 1949 15046 15046 2 4786 0 15046 275 249

205 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 26 Ch. 1-2 1 311 3300 3300 1 20.5 12.8 20.5 12.8 1663 7476 7476 2 6310 0 7476 229 145

206 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 26 Ch. 3-4 2 445 2872 2872 1 11.6 8.2 11.6 8.2 1256 6938 6938 2 3631 0 6938 468 150

207 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 26 Ch. 5-6 3 336 3511 3511 1 15.4 6.4 15.4 6.4 1377 6832 6832 2 4624 0 6832 437 190

208 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 26 Ch. 7-8 4 536 2982 2982 1 10.1 7.9 10.1 7.9 1508 5689 5689 2 3715 0 5689 589 143

209 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 26 Ch. 9-10 5 400 3109 3109 1 12 5.8 12 5.8 1103 4816 4816 2 3589 0 4816 490 136

210 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 26 Ch. 11-12 6 265 1846 1846 1 21.3 14.5 21.3 14.5 855 5860 5860 2 4315 0 5860 1778 125

103 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 10R Ch. 1-2 1 843 843 0 15.4 15.4 15.4 9328 9328 1 4416 0 9328 457 234

104 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 10R Ch. 3-4 2 744 744 0 15.7 15.7 15.7 9291 9291 1 10000 1 9291 468 345

105 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 10R Ch. 5-6 3 1016 1016 0 13.7 13.7 13.7 12158 12158 1 9772 0 12158 479 279

106 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 10R Ch. 7-8 4 1712 1712 0 8.6 8.6 8.6 9621 9621 1 4266 0 9621 1288 301

107 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 10R Ch. 9-10 5 682 682 0 16.1 16.1 16.1 10153 10153 1 5129 0 10153 575 258

108 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

38 ply 10R Ch. 11-12 6 803 803 0 20.1 20.1 20.1 16717 16717 1 4677 0 16717 562 343

91 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 9R Ch. 1-2 1 2143 2143 0 7.1 7.1 7.1 10921 10921 1 10000 1 10921 1514 216

92 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 9R Ch. 3-4 2 2080 2080 0 8.8 8.8 8.8 15926 15926 1 9886 0 15926 1413 226

93 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 9R Ch. 5-6 3 1241 1241 0 11.9 11.9 11.9 13369 13369 1 9661 0 13369 1585 245

94 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 9R Ch. 7-8 4 2114 2114 0 8.3 8.3 8.3 10124 10124 1 6166 0 10124 1288 245

95 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 9R Ch. 9-10 5 1111 1111 0 12.3 12.3 12.3 12541 12541 1 5957 0 12541 1514 193

96 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

54 ply 9R Ch. 11-12 6 1055 1055 0 13.6 13.6 13.6 13214 13214 1 6761 0 13214 891 195

271 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape 

ply LSC panel. 28 Ch. 1-2 1 857 3806 3806 1 14.5 9.9 14.5 9.9 3428 10071 10071 2 5495 0 10071 977 160

272 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape 

ply LSC panel. 28 Ch. 3-4 2 328 2852 2852 1 19.1 11.8 19.1 11.8 2258 10130 10130 2 4315 0 10130 3388 160

273 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape 

ply LSC panel. 28 Ch. 5-6 3 313 3394 3394 1 21.6 9.7 21.6 9.7 1978 9601 9601 2 4571 0 9601 525 147

274 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape 

ply LSC panel. 28 Ch. 7-8 4 681 2712 2712 1 10.8 10.1 10.8 10.1 1738 7848 7848 2 4842 0 7848 2344 141

275 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape 

ply LSC panel. 28 Ch. 9-10 5 299 2848 2848 1 17.2 7.9 17.2 7.9 1157 6619 6619 2 3350 0 6619 2344 135

276 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape 

ply LSC panel. 28 Ch. 11-12 6 285 2241 2241 1 19 13.2 19 13.2 606 8164 8164 2 4842 0 8164 2138 141

187 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf 

test a modification to the standoff shims is going to 

be introduced to increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 

mils to ensure the legs of the LSC are firmly seated 

on the standoff shim.

23 Ch. 1-2 1 451 3876 3876 1 14.4 10.8 14.4 10.8 776 13582 13582 2 4266 0 13582 4169 197

188 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf 

test a modification to the standoff shims is going to 

be introduced to increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 

mils to ensure the legs of the LSC are firmly seated 

on the standoff shim.

23 Ch. 3-4 2 416 2854 2854 1 8.6 15.9 15.9 15.9 626 11327 11327 2 10000 1 11327 3890 156

189 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf 

test a modification to the standoff shims is going to 

be introduced to increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 

mils to ensure the legs of the LSC are firmly seated 

on the standoff shim.

23 Ch. 5-6 3 339 2969 2969 1 14 13.6 14 13.6 862 8538 8538 2 10000 1 8538 3162 139

190 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf 

test a modification to the standoff shims is going to 

be introduced to increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 

mils to ensure the legs of the LSC are firmly seated 

on the standoff shim.

23 Ch. 7-8 4 361 3376 3376 1 12 10.1 12 10.1 803 8628 8628 2 10000 1 8628 324 125

191 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf 

test a modification to the standoff shims is going to 

be introduced to increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 

mils to ensure the legs of the LSC are firmly seated 

on the standoff shim.

23 Ch. 9-10 5 276 3700 3700 1 19.1 10.1 19.1 10.1 986 7586 7586 2 4074 0 7586 4074 114
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

394 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

192 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf 

test a modification to the standoff shims is going to 

be introduced to increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 

mils to ensure the legs of the LSC are firmly seated 

on the standoff shim.

23 Ch. 11-12 6 291 2555 2555 1 14.9 15.1 15.1 15.1 660 9024 9024 2 4169 0 9024 2042 145

193 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 24 Ch. 1-2 1 2449 2449 0 7.4 7.4 7.4 10702 10702 1 9226 0 10702 1175 225

194 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 24 Ch. 3-4 2 1318 1318 0 11.2 11.2 11.2 10450 10450 1 3936 0 10450 1698 259

195 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 24 Ch. 5-6 3 339 2007 2007 1 16.2 10.9 16.2 10.9 1566 8200 8200 2 3236 0 8200 339 281

196 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 24 Ch. 7-8 4 338 2005 2005 1 13.6 12 13.6 12 1531 7486 7486 2 3802 0 7486 339 276

197 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 24 Ch. 9-10 5 304 2205 2205 1 16.2 10.4 16.2 10.4 1565 8366 8366 2 2239 0 8366 2188 232

198 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 24 Ch. 11-12 6 225 1588 1588 1 17 18.7 18.7 18.7 1131 7389 7389 2 2065 0 7389 229 301

199 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 25 Ch. 1-2 1 505 3370 3370 1 16.8 10.8 16.8 10.8 1801 6571 6571 2 7674 0 6571 955 95

200 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 25 Ch. 3-4 2 261 2108 2108 1 22.9 10 22.9 10 1208 4937 4937 2 7674 0 4937 513 142

201 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 25 Ch. 5-6 3 328 3100 3100 1 19 6.4 19 6.4 1201 4457 4457 2 6310 0 4457 324 211

202 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 25 Ch. 7-8 4 281 2810 2810 1 19.5 7.4 19.5 7.4 1038 3925 3925 2 9333 0 3925 331 165

203 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 25 Ch. 9-10 5 247 2249 2249 1 23.4 8.6 23.4 8.6 1037 3365 3365 2 3162 0 3365 513 122

204 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 25 Ch. 11-12 6 294 1761 1761 1 17.4 17.5 17.5 17.5 672 4136 4136 2 9772 0 4136 309 126

277 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 0 27 Ch. 1-2 1 3991 3991 0 6.7 6.7 6.7 13604 13604 1 10000 1 13604 2138 181

278 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 0 27 Ch. 3-4 2 322 1764 1764 1 14.2 11.4 14.2 11.4 556 7871 7871 2 4365 0 7871 1622 177

279 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 0 27 Ch. 5-6 3 293 1324 1324 1 17.4 15.2 17.4 15.2 464 7293 7293 2 4624 0 7293 2089 182

280 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 0 27 Ch. 7-8 4 302 908 908 1 11.2 24.5 24.5 24.5 511 6432 6432 2 4315 0 6432 1023 143

281 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 0 27 Ch. 9-10 5 498 1186 1186 1 14.2 18.8 18.8 18.8 1354 4675 4675 2 4074 0 4675 1202 152

282 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric 

Composite 0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both faces 0 27 Ch. 11-12 6 292 1278 1278 1 17.5 21.2 21.2 21.2 384 5309 5309 2 2089 0 5309 1995 160

235 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A05 Ch. 1-2 1 5423 5423 0 6.5 6.5 6.5 28490 28490 1 10000 1 28490 1230 286

236 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A05 Ch. 3-4 2 249 2095 2095 1 16.9 12.7 16.9 12.7 1630 19259 19259 2 10000 1 19259 1230 278

237 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A05 Ch. 5-6 3 304 2208 2208 1 16.1 11 16.1 11 1726 14063 14063 2 10000 1 14063 1445 256

238 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A05 Ch. 7-8 4 349 1906 1906 1 11.5 14.1 14.1 14.1 1123 11892 11892 2 9661 0 11892 1479 235

239 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A05 Ch. 9-10 5 272 1673 1673 1 15.9 14.8 15.9 14.8 1581 10860 10860 2 3631 0 10860 1259 252

240 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A05 Ch. 11-12 6 208 1418 1418 1 19.9 22.2 22.2 22.2 1669 9224 9224 2 2265 0 9224 214 476

265 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A10 Ch. 1-2 1 3244 3244 0 5.8 5.8 5.8 15731 15731 1 8414 0 15731 295 324

266 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A10 Ch. 3-4 2 2816 2816 0 7.8 7.8 7.8 17244 17244 1 8128 0 17244 1820 256

267 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A10 Ch. 5-6 3 1898 1898 0 7.9 7.9 7.9 12947 12947 1 8511 0 12947 562 286

268 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A10 Ch. 7-8 4 2490 2490 0 8.1 8.1 8.1 12470 12470 1 8511 0 12470 2089 239

269 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A10 Ch. 9-10 5 1827 1827 0 9.4 9.4 9.4 12688 12688 1 8222 0 12688 1349 225

270 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A10 Ch. 11-12 6 913 2106 2106 1 9.2 21 21 21 2647 10113 10113 2 6607 0 10113 2138 275

211 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 1-2 1 1823 1823 0 8.8 8.8 8.8 8801 8801 1 1905 0 8801 1778 291

212 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 3-4 2 412 1837 1837 1 15.4 12.4 15.4 12.4 2437 12045 12045 2 1995 0 12045 1905 380

213 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 5-6 3 306 1816 1816 1 20.3 14.1 20.3 14.1 2320 9947 9947 2 2065 0 9947 1995 300

214 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 7-8 4 302 1931 1931 1 18.9 11.9 18.9 11.9 1907 7338 7338 2 2042 0 7338 257 258

215 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 9-10 5 273 1910 1910 1 18.3 10.5 18.3 10.5 1256 8401 8401 2 1972 0 8401 1950 262
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

395 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

216 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 11-12 6 214 1621 1621 1 20.1 14.9 20.1 14.9 488 8715 8715 2 1950 0 8715 1660 291

247 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A07 Ch. 1-2 1 771 771 0 13.6 13.6 13.6 12017 12017 1 8128 0 12017 398 311

248 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A07 Ch. 3-4 2 2786 2786 0 6.3 6.3 6.3 12631 12631 1 8610 0 12631 692 260

249 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A07 Ch. 5-6 3 319 1418 1418 1 14.8 11.5 14.8 11.5 2125 12103 12103 2 7943 0 12103 832 276

250 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A07 Ch. 7-8 4 197 1713 1713 1 16.3 7.6 16.3 7.6 912 9114 9114 2 8810 0 9114 912 281

251 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A07 Ch. 9-10 5 162 1341 1341 1 17.5 11.5 17.5 11.5 627 9785 9785 2 10000 1 9785 813 284

252 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A07 Ch. 11-12 6 260 1494 1494 1 16.3 20.9 20.9 20.9 1315 10422 10422 2 3467 0 10422 1660 327

253 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A08 Ch. 1-2 1 314 1670 1670 1 17.5 10.8 17.5 10.8 1829 12610 12610 2 8511 0 12610 1660 302

254 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A08 Ch. 3-4 2 491 1387 1387 1 11 10.5 11 10.5 2510 8942 8942 2 1758 0 8942 1349 342

255 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A08 Ch. 5-6 3 582 1518 1518 1 13.1 10.4 13.1 10.4 3181 7914 7914 2 4467 0 7914 1479 302

256 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A08 Ch. 7-8 4 516 1498 1498 1 17.1 8.6 17.1 8.6 4023 6133 6133 2 1950 0 6133 457 368

257 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A08 Ch. 9-10 5 404 945 945 1 15.8 20.3 20.3 20.3 2061 7057 7057 2 1820 0 7057 407 297

258 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 A08 Ch. 11-12 6 404 1084 1084 1 12.7 15.1 15.1 15.1 1946 7789 7789 2 1841 0 7789 1479 283

223 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 1-2 1 2064 2064 0 6.5 6.5 6.5 9408 9408 1 5559 0 9408 224 237

224 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 3-4 2 2320 2320 0 7.5 7.5 7.5 10782 10782 1 8810 0 10782 1479 253

225 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 5-6 3 1962 1962 0 9.6 9.6 9.6 9279 9279 1 5370 0 9279 1738 261

226 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 7-8 4 2055 2055 0 8.4 8.4 8.4 8970 8970 1 5495 0 8970 1549 237

227 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 9-10 5 303 1132 1132 1 10.2 17.2 17.2 17.2 909 9392 9392 2 6310 0 9392 1349 255

228 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 11-12 6 312 1944 1944 1 15 13.4 15 13.4 1082 12381 12381 2 6607 0 12381 1023 167

229 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 1-2 1 411 1789 1789 1 16 13.7 16 13.7 2141 12017 12017 2 9772 0 12017 1862 297

230 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 3-4 2 493 1550 1550 1 14.6 14 14.6 14 2674 10233 10233 2 1905 0 10233 1820 336

231 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 5-6 3 538 1716 1716 1 13.8 10.3 13.8 10.3 2504 8206 8206 2 1972 0 8206 1778 269

232 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 7-8 4 498 1611 1611 1 15.9 12.6 15.9 12.6 2030 6336 6336 2 1950 0 6336 501 236

233 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 9-10 5 428 1888 1888 1 16.4 8.9 16.4 8.9 2388 5420 5420 2 1950 0 5420 724 197

234 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 11-12 6 638 1562 1562 1 12.8 11 12.8 11 2625 5809 5809 2 1799 0 5809 631 247

241 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 1-2 1 518 518 0 14.7 14.7 14.7 9028 9028 1 10000 1 9028 347 389

242 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 3-4 2 414 414 0 18.5 18.5 18.5 10150 10150 1 5623 0 10150 398 327

243 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 5-6 3 1376 1376 0 6.7 6.7 6.7 9472 9472 1 6918 0 9472 245 348

244 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 7-8 4 1611 1611 0 6.9 6.9 6.9 10677 10677 1 2917 0 10677 295 369

245 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 9-10 5 227 1250 1250 1 16 14.5 16 14.5 2165 11652 11652 2 6457 0 11652 214 445

246 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 11-12 6 243 1525 1525 1 19.1 19 19.1 19 2444 10981 10981 2 1928 0 10981 229 403

259 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 1-2 1 795 795 0 15.2 15.2 15.2 18346 18346 1 10000 1 18346 977 302

260 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 3-4 2 435 1702 1702 1 13.5 8.4 13.5 8.4 2464 10158 10158 2 10000 1 10158 427 346

261 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 5-6 3 445 1343 1343 1 13 9.1 13 9.1 2772 6601 6601 2 4027 0 6601 537 311

262 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 7-8 4 442 1487 1487 1 16.3 9.7 16.3 9.7 2215 6162 6162 2 3673 0 6162 457 292

263 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 9-10 5 451 1473 1473 1 12.2 13 13 13 2017 6596 6596 2 3548 0 6596 501 244

264 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 

ply both faces 0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 11-12 6 363 1349 1349 1 15.6 22.3 22.3 22.3 2088 6488 6488 2 9886 0 6488 355 321

217 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 1-2 1 206 1938 1938 1 19 9.3 19 9.3 529 9217 9217 2 4217 0 9217 1122 198

218 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 3-4 2 125 1032 1032 1 17.8 14.2 17.8 14.2 121 8904 8904 2 3936 0 8904 661 263

219 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 5-6 3 214 1000 1000 1 18 15.3 18 15.3 498 7978 7978 2 3890 0 7978 724 231

220 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 7-8 4 334 1580 1580 1 13.9 11.1 13.9 11.1 899 7338 7338 2 3631 0 7338 724 140

221 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 9-10 5 246 1411 1411 1 20.2 10.9 20.2 10.9 871 5774 5774 2 4266 0 5774 234 156

222 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 

27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 11-12 6 197 1069 1069 1 16.4 14.6 16.4 14.6 351 5433 5433 2 3126 0 5433 759 158
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

396 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Shock Response Spectrum Envelope Plot Points

c Test No Panel 

N o

Group Goal Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thicknes

s

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Aluminum 

LSC Plate

Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accels

0 Degree Material Orientation Plate 

Torque

Accel 

Torque

Accel 

Washer

Mfg Date Accel 

Config

Notes Backer 

Plate

Test Output 

Name

Station F 1 F 2 F 3 F 4 F 5 SRS1 SRS2 SRS3 SRS4 SRS5 F3 prime F4 prime SRS3 

prime

SRS4 

prime

No of 

Notches

1 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 1 0 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 1-2 1 100 3569 10000 9 5 17525 17525 3569 3569 17525 17525 1

2 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 2 1 0.187 1 0 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1829 10000 7 1 11295 11295 1829 1829 11295 11295 1

3 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 3 3 0.187 1 0 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 5-6 3 100 2235 10000 7 7 12561 12561 2235 2235 12561 12561 1

4 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 4 5 0.187 1 0 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 7-8 4 100 3956 10000 128 10377 10377 3956 3956 10377 10377 1

5 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 5 7 0.187 1 0 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 9-10 5 100 2948 10000 133 11293 11293 2948 2948 11293 11293 1

6 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 6 9 0.187 1 0 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P1 Ch. 11-12 6 100 282 826 1972 10000 4 8 923 923 13285 13285 826 1972 923 13285 3

7 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2205 10000 113 15170 15170 2205 2205 15170 15170 1

8 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 2 1 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 3-4 2 100 3837 10000 151 14814 14814 3837 3837 14814 14814 1

9 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 3 3 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 5-6 3 100 2247 10000 114 13014 13014 2247 2247 13014 13014 1

1 0 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 4 5 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 7-8 4 100 4232 10000 142 15470 15470 4232 4232 15470 15470 1

1 1 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 5 7 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 9-10 5 100 2923 10000 164 14643 14643 2923 2923 14643 14643 1

1 2 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 6 9 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum P2 Ch. 11-12 6 100 278 523 4148 10000 7 0 1351 1351 18641 18641 523 4148 1351 18641 3

1 3 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° (2X); 90° 

(2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

P3 Ch. 1-2 1 100 1265 10000 8 0 9605 9605 1265 1265 9605 9605 1

1 4 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 2 1 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° (2X); 90° 

(2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

P3 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2802 10000 226 15179 15179 2802 2802 15179 15179 1

1 5 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 3 3 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° (2X); 90° 

(2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

P3 Ch. 5-6 3 100 238 554 2145 10000 8 5 738 738 8231 8231 554 2145 738 8231 3

1 6 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 4 5 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° (2X); 90° 

(2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

P3 Ch. 7-8 4 100 216 717 1570 10000 5 6 1148 1148 8496 8496 717 1570 1148 8496 3

1 7 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 5 7 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° (2X); 90° 

(2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

P3 Ch. 9-10 5 100 210 410 1695 10000 6 3 486 486 11554 11554 410 1695 486 11554 3

1 8 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 6 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/R913

((+45°/-45° (2X); 0° (2x); +45°/-45° (2X); 90° 

(2x)) (X 3.2); 38 ply

P3 Ch. 11-12 6 100 374 1110 1651 10000 5 6 1816 1816 8579 8579 1110 1651 1816 8579 3

1 9 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2869 10000 489 13601 13601 2869 2869 13601 13601 1

2 0 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 2 1 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 3-4 2 100 940 10000 7 9 10268 10268 940 940 10268 10268 1

2 1 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 3 3 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 5-6 3 100 773 2736 3474 10000 183 5137 5137 10480 10480 2736 3474 5137 10480 3

2 2 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 4 5 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 7-8 4 100 791 2486 3350 10000 304 4016 4016 7299 7299 2486 3350 4016 7299 3

2 3 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 5 7 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 9-10 5 100 358 3038 3368 10000 157 5245 5245 7107 7107 3038 3368 5245 7107 3

2 4 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 6 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 0°; 38 ply P4 Ch. 11-12 6 100 356 2907 3191 10000 186 4602 4602 6856 6856 2907 3191 4602 6856 3

2 5 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 1-2 1 100 1676 10000 113 12478 12478 1676 1676 12478 12478 1

2 6 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 2 1 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2252 10000 146 15120 15120 2252 2252 15120 15120 1

2 7 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 3 3 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1641 10000 126 8685 8685 1641 1641 8685 8685 1

2 8 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 4 5 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1574 10000 133 8786 8786 1574 1574 8786 8786 1

2 9 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 5 7 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 9-10 5 100 376 582 1278 10000 7 2 1175 1175 10497 10497 582 1278 1175 10497 3

3 0 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 6 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/R913 All plies 90°; 38 ply P5 Ch. 11-12 6 100 700 1942 2593 10000 5 4 4099 4099 9672 9672 1942 2593 4099 9672 3

3 1 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 1 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2644 10000 388 13982 13982 2644 2644 13982 13982 1

3 2 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 2 1 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 1 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2587 10000 552 12754 12754 2587 2587 12754 12754 1

3 3 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 3 3 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 1 Ch. 5-6 3 100 2519 10000 493 11777 11777 2519 2519 11777 11777 1

3 4 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 4 5 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 1 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1952 10000 501 10551 10551 1952 1952 10551 10551 1

3 5 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 5 7 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 1 Ch. 9-10 5 100 1989 10000 516 11626 11626 1989 1989 11626 11626 1

3 6 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 6 9 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 1 Ch. 11-12 6 100 377 1346 1980 10000 9 4 3684 3684 12599 12599 1346 1980 3684 12599 3

4 3 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 2 Ch. 1-2 1 100 1994 10000 122 14368 14368 1994 1994 14368 14368 1

4 4 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 2 1 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 2 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2440 10000 203 11514 11514 2440 2440 11514 11514 1

4 5 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 3 3 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 2 Ch. 5-6 3 100 2051 10000 7 6 12570 12570 2051 2051 12570 12570 1

4 6 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 4 5 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 2 Ch. 7-8 4 100 2492 10000 173 11525 11525 2492 2492 11525 11525 1

4 7 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 5 7 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 2 Ch. 9-10 5 100 3307 10000 214 12773 12773 3307 3307 12773 12773 1

4 8 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 6 9 0.2 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 11/28/2012 1 b 1 2 Ch. 11-12 6 100 308 951 1876 10000 5 2 1190 1190 12181 12181 951 1876 1190 12181 3

6 1 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/17/2012 1 b 1 4 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2594 10000 161 11005 11005 2594 2594 11005 11005 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

397 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

6 2 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 2 1 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/17/2012 1 b 1 4 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1406 10000 126 8270 8270 1406 1406 8270 8270 1

6 3 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 3 3 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/17/2012 1 b 1 4 Ch. 5-6 3 100 2022 10000 7 8 8448 8448 2022 2022 8448 8448 1

6 4 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 4 5 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/17/2012 1 b 1 4 Ch. 7-8 4 100 337 720 2239 10000 7 5 986 986 9696 9696 720 2239 986 9696 3

6 5 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 5 7 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/17/2012 1 b 1 4 Ch. 9-10 5 100 266 345 3655 10000 4 8 655 655 9607 9607 345 3655 655 9607 3

6 6 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 6 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/17/2012 1 b 1 4 Ch. 11-12 6 100 3039 10000 175 9069 9069 3039 3039 9069 9069 1

4 9 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/13/2012 1 b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 1-2 1 100 1756 10000 123 11499 11499 1756 1756 11499 11499 1

5 0 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 2 1 0.3 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/13/2012 1 b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1899 10000 210 8646 8646 1899 1899 8646 8646 1

5 1 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 3 3 0.3 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/13/2012 1 b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1832 10000 149 9003 9003 1832 1832 9003 9003 1

5 2 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 4 5 0.3 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/13/2012 1 b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 7-8 4 100 340 693 1466 10000 8 1 1401 1401 8228 8228 693 1466 1401 8228 3

5 3 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 5 7 0.3 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/13/2012 1 b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 9-10 5 100 349 565 1643 10000 6 9 1138 1138 7945 7945 565 1643 1138 7945 3

5 4 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 6 9 0.3 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/13/2012 1 b A number of debonded accels 1 3 Ch. 11-12 6 100 555 1571 2487 10000 7 0 2709 2709 9363 9363 1571 2487 2709 9363 3

6 7 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/20/2012 1 b 1 5 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2631 10000 244 13539 13539 2631 2631 13539 13539 1

6 8 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 2 1 0.2 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/20/2012 1 b 1 5 Ch. 3-4 2 100 3351 10000 264 16746 16746 3351 3351 16746 16746 1

6 9 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 3 3 0.2 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/20/2012 1 b 1 5 Ch. 5-6 3 100 3209 10000 190 16265 16265 3209 3209 16265 16265 1

7 0 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 4 5 0.2 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/20/2012 1 b 1 5 Ch. 7-8 4 100 2767 10000 155 13872 13872 2767 2767 13872 13872 1

7 1 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 5 7 0.2 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/20/2012 1 b 1 5 Ch. 9-10 5 100 3087 10000 205 15586 15586 3087 3087 15586 15586 1

7 2 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 6 9 0.2 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 12/20/2012 1 b 1 5 Ch. 11-12 6 100 457 1177 2952 10000 6 4 2586 2586 17671 17671 1177 2952 2586 17671 3

7 3 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 1 b 0 6 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2560 10000 376 18254 18254 2560 2560 18254 18254 1

7 4 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 2 1 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 1 b 0 6 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2016 10000 282 15930 15930 2016 2016 15930 15930 1

7 5 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 3 3 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 1 b 0 6 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1372 10000 417 11264 11264 1372 1372 11264 11264 1

7 6 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 4 5 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 1 b 0 6 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1696 10000 510 10721 10721 1696 1696 10721 10721 1

7 7 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 5 7 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 1 b 0 6 Ch. 9-10 5 100 1885 10000 752 13675 13675 1885 1885 13675 13675 1

7 8 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 6 9 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 Composite, IM7/TC350 0-Deg; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 1 b 0 6 Ch. 11-12 6 100 311 1263 2031 10000 8 8 3413 3413 13618 13618 1263 2031 3413 13618 3

7 9 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 7 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2500 10000 384 20354 20354 2500 2500 20354 20354 1

8 0 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 2 1 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 7 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1825 10000 399 15695 15695 1825 1825 15695 15695 1

8 1 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 3 3 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 7 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1089 10000 352 11437 11437 1089 1089 11437 11437 1

8 2 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 4 5 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 7 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1651 10000 261 10996 10996 1651 1651 10996 10996 1

8 3 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 5 7 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 7 Ch. 9-10 5 100 2354 10000 563 13602 13602 2354 2354 13602 13602 1

8 4 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 6 9 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90°; 18 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 7 Ch. 11-12 6 100 302 1027 2303 10000 145 2943 2943 16139 16139 1027 2303 2943 16139 3

8 5 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 0 8 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2759 10000 6 4 15759 15759 2759 2759 15759 15759 1

8 6 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 2 1 0.3 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 0 8 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1495 10000 123 14657 14657 1495 1495 14657 14657 1

8 7 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 3 3 0.3 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 0 8 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1476 10000 1 9 11130 11130 1476 1476 11130 11130 1

8 8 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 4 5 0.3 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 0 8 Ch. 7-8 4 100 2056 10000 8 7 9468 9468 2056 2056 9468 9468 1

8 9 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 5 7 0.3 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 0 8 Ch. 9-10 5 100 2142 10000 6 2 10158 10158 2142 2142 10158 10158 1

9 0 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 6 9 0.3 1 0 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 0 8 Ch. 11-12 6 100 2208 10000 7 3 10309 10309 2208 2208 10309 10309 1

9 7 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 9 Ch. 1-2 1 100 1707 10000 108 9877 9877 1707 1707 9877 9877 1

9 8 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 2 1 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 9 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1252 10000 109 9279 9279 1252 1252 9279 9279 1

9 9 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 3 3 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 9 Ch. 5-6 3 100 945 10000 4 7 10512 10512 945 945 10512 10512 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

398 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

100 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 4 5 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 9 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1874 10000 170 10884 10884 1874 1874 10884 10884 1

101 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 5 7 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 9 Ch. 9-10 5 100 1917 10000 123 9542 9542 1917 1917 9542 9542 1

102 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 6 9 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 5 5 3 5 0 2 0 9 Ch. 11-12 6 100 653 1520 2495 10000 5 8 2648 2648 13631 13631 1520 2495 2648 13631 3

109 1 0 1 0 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 1 0 Ch. 1-2 1 100 3060 10000 166 22897 22897 3060 3060 22897 22897 1

110 1 0 1 0 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 2 1 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 1 0 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2288 10000 176 18794 18794 2288 2288 18794 18794 1

111 1 0 1 0 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 3 3 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 1 0 Ch. 5-6 3 100 2644 10000 197 18405 18405 2644 2644 18405 18405 1

112 1 0 1 0 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 4 5 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 1 0 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1613 10000 8 3 12351 12351 1613 1613 12351 12351 1

113 1 0 1 0 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 5 7 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 1 0 Ch. 9-10 5 100 2007 10000 171 11920 11920 2007 2007 11920 11920 1

114 1 0 1 0 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 6 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 5 5 3 5 0 3 A number of debonded accels 0 1 0 Ch. 11-12 6 100 516 1103 2395 10000 4 7 2430 2430 14080 14080 1103 2395 2430 14080 3

115 1 1 1 1 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 9 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 2 0 1 1 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2458 10000 8 6 17035 17035 2458 2458 17035 17035 1

116 1 1 1 1 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 2 1 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 2 0 1 1 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2587 10000 184 11602 11602 2587 2587 11602 11602 1

117 1 1 1 1 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 3 3 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 2 0 1 1 Ch. 5-6 3 100 295 840 2061 10000 7 3 1067 1067 10434 10434 840 2061 1067 10434 3

118 1 1 1 1 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 4 5 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 2 0 1 1 Ch. 7-8 4 100 326 658 3128 10000 6 9 1021 1021 8908 8908 658 3128 1021 8908 3

119 1 1 1 1 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 5 7 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 2 0 1 1 Ch. 9-10 5 100 307 737 3210 10000 7 5 1461 1461 8097 8097 737 3210 1461 8097 3

120 1 1 1 1 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 6 9 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 2 0 1 1 Ch. 11-12 6 100 219 845 1778 10000 4 9 700 700 8439 8439 845 1778 700 8439 3

121 1 2 1 4 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 1 2 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2957 10000 185 14557 14557 2957 2957 14557 14557 1

122 1 2 1 4 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 1 2 Ch. 3-4 2 100 311 550 1719 10000 8 9 1219 1219 9624 9624 550 1719 1219 9624 3

123 1 2 1 4 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 1 2 Ch. 5-6 3 100 245 628 1701 10000 102 1423 1423 8259 8259 628 1701 1423 8259 3

124 1 2 1 4 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 1 2 Ch. 7-8 4 100 278 957 1930 10000 7 2 1964 1964 6863 6863 957 1930 1964 6863 3

125 1 2 1 4 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 1 2 Ch. 9-10 5 100 287 564 1940 10000 9 5 1051 1051 8240 8240 564 1940 1051 8240 3

126 1 2 1 4 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 2 5 1 1 2 Ch. 11-12 6 100 214 567 1533 10000 4 7 624 624 7624 7624 567 1533 624 7624 3

127 1 3 1 3 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 9 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 3 Ch. 1-2 1 100 4158 10000 109 11810 11810 4158 4158 11810 11810 1

128 1 3 1 3 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 2 1 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 3 Ch. 3-4 2 100 360 864 2016 10000 3 6 1389 1389 7534 7534 864 2016 1389 7534 3

129 1 3 1 3 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 3 3 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 3 Ch. 5-6 3 100 307 1057 2103 10000 4 3 1479 1479 6283 6283 1057 2103 1479 6283 3

130 1 3 1 3 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 4 5 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 3 Ch. 7-8 4 100 296 955 2369 10000 3 6 1283 1283 4464 4464 955 2369 1283 4464 3

131 1 3 1 3 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 5 7 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 3 Ch. 9-10 5 100 348 713 1910 10000 5 2 1000 1000 5078 5078 713 1910 1000 5078 3

132 1 3 1 3 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 6 9 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 3 Ch. 11-12 6 100 230 520 1636 10000 2 1 397 397 5637 5637 520 1636 397 5637 3

133 1 4 1 2 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

3 0 1 4 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2923 10000 359 13588 13588 2923 2923 13588 13588 1

134 1 4 1 2 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

3 0 1 4 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1198 10000 130 11460 11460 1198 1198 11460 11460 1

135 1 4 1 2 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

3 0 1 4 Ch. 5-6 3 100 308 740 2714 10000 8 4 1781 1781 13169 13169 740 2714 1781 13169 3

136 1 4 1 2 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

3 0 1 4 Ch. 7-8 4 100 340 752 2281 10000 9 1 1285 1285 8454 8454 752 2281 1285 8454 3

137 1 4 1 2 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

3 0 1 4 Ch. 9-10 5 100 249 742 2145 10000 105 1499 1499 9768 9768 742 2145 1499 9768 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

399 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

138 1 4 1 2 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

3 0 1 4 Ch. 11-12 6 100 211 883 1799 10000 109 1575 1575 11453 11453 883 1799 1575 11453 3

139 1 5 1 6 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 5 Ch. 1-2 1 100 3771 10000 387 16318 16318 3771 3771 16318 16318 1

140 1 5 1 6 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 5 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2650 10000 308 11694 11694 2650 2650 11694 11694 1

141 1 5 1 6 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 5 Ch. 5-6 3 100 296 681 2145 10000 7 2 1540 1540 10038 10038 681 2145 1540 10038 3

142 1 5 1 6 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 5 Ch. 7-8 4 100 385 800 2577 10000 6 3 1567 1567 8181 8181 800 2577 1567 8181 3

143 1 5 1 6 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 5 Ch. 9-10 5 100 263 673 2494 10000 8 4 1375 1375 8493 8493 673 2494 1375 8493 3

144 1 5 1 6 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 5 Ch. 11-12 6 100 208 825 1735 10000 104 1362 1362 9479 9479 825 1735 1362 9479 3

145 1 6 1 8 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 6 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2026 10000 110 14050 14050 2026 2026 14050 14050 1

146 1 6 1 8 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 6 Ch. 3-4 2 100 312 625 1690 10000 123 1427 1427 10589 10589 625 1690 1427 10589 3

147 1 6 1 8 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 6 Ch. 5-6 3 100 277 856 1704 10000 100 1996 1996 9001 9001 856 1704 1996 9001 3

148 1 6 1 8 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 6 Ch. 7-8 4 100 278 904 1858 10000 7 1 1875 1875 7201 7201 904 1858 1875 7201 3

149 1 6 1 8 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 6 Ch. 9-10 5 100 298 675 1911 10000 120 1205 1205 9232 9232 675 1911 1205 9232 3

150 1 6 1 8 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 6 Ch. 11-12 6 100 225 571 1593 10000 4 5 655 655 9354 9354 571 1593 655 9354 3

151 1 7 1 5 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 9 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 7 Ch. 1-2 1 100 3152 10000 107 14466 14466 3152 3152 14466 14466 1

152 1 7 1 5 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 2 1 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 7 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1653 10000 156 11093 11093 1653 1653 11093 11093 1

153 1 7 1 5 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 3 3 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 7 Ch. 5-6 3 100 336 1251 2324 10000 5 8 2197 2197 8921 8921 1251 2324 2197 8921 3

154 1 7 1 5 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 4 5 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 7 Ch. 7-8 4 100 362 1019 3379 10000 5 7 1705 1705 9639 9639 1019 3379 1705 9639 3

155 1 7 1 5 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 5 7 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 7 Ch. 9-10 5 100 263 743 2809 10000 4 8 1255 1255 9565 9565 743 2809 1255 9565 3

156 1 7 1 5 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 6 9 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 7 Ch. 11-12 6 100 214 836 1934 10000 5 2 991 991 8747 8747 836 1934 991 8747 3

157 1 8 1 7 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 9 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 8 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2447 10000 5 9 10395 10395 2447 2447 10395 10395 1

158 1 8 1 7 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 2 1 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 8 Ch. 3-4 2 100 471 894 2331 10000 3 6 1331 1331 6624 6624 894 2331 1331 6624 3

159 1 8 1 7 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 3 3 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 8 Ch. 5-6 3 100 292 1022 2282 10000 3 2 1201 1201 5766 5766 1022 2282 1201 5766 3

160 1 8 1 7 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 4 5 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 8 Ch. 7-8 4 100 292 931 2169 10000 3 2 990 990 4782 4782 931 2169 990 4782 3

161 1 8 1 7 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 5 7 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 8 Ch. 9-10 5 100 405 1079 1924 10000 3 3 1169 1169 5308 5308 1079 1924 1169 5308 3

162 1 8 1 7 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 6 9 1 1 0 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 1 8 Ch. 11-12 6 100 224 523 1701 10000 2 8 315 315 4303 4303 523 1701 315 4303 3

163 1 9 1 9 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 9 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 9 Ch. 1-2 1 100 607 2186 3281 10000 4 7 2621 2621 10742 10742 2186 3281 2621 10742 3

164 1 9 1 9 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 2 1 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 9 Ch. 3-4 2 100 715 2131 3250 10000 6 8 2112 2112 8435 8435 2131 3250 2112 8435 3

165 1 9 1 9 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 3 3 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 9 Ch. 5-6 3 100 631 2160 3408 10000 2 7 1926 1926 7950 7950 2160 3408 1926 7950 3

166 1 9 1 9 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 4 5 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 9 Ch. 7-8 4 100 641 1249 3440 10000 9 4 1321 1321 7160 7160 1249 3440 1321 7160 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

400 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

167 1 9 1 9 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 5 7 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 9 Ch. 9-10 5 100 551 2168 3184 10000 6 8 1523 1523 6428 6428 2168 3184 1523 6428 3

168 1 9 1 9 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 6 9 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

1 9 Ch. 11-12 6 100 420 713 3606 10000 2 7 691 691 6138 6138 713 3606 691 6138 3

169 2 0 2 0 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 Ch. 1-2 1 100 576 1312 6320 10000 4 6 3202 3202 32442 32442 1312 6320 3202 32442 3

170 2 0 2 0 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 Ch. 3-4 2 100 489 1210 3656 10000 155 2247 2247 17874 17874 1210 3656 2247 17874 3

171 2 0 2 0 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 Ch. 5-6 3 100 571 1211 3286 10000 6 9 1555 1555 14719 14719 1211 3286 1555 14719 3

172 2 0 2 0 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 Ch. 7-8 4 100 549 1448 2920 10000 6 2 1794 1794 8905 8905 1448 2920 1794 8905 3

173 2 0 2 0 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 Ch. 9-10 5 100 472 1978 2640 10000 102 2576 2576 7233 7233 1978 2640 2576 7233 3

174 2 0 2 0 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 0 Ch. 11-12 6 100 266 842 1597 10000 2 7 772 772 6167 6167 842 1597 772 6167 3

181 2 2 2 2 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 9 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 2 Ch. 1-2 1 100 331 687 1998 10000 1 7 513 513 10707 10707 687 1998 513 10707 3

182 2 2 2 2 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 2 1 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 2 Ch. 3-4 2 100 392 877 2253 10000 2 9 830 830 8661 8661 877 2253 830 8661 3

183 2 2 2 2 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 3 3 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 2 Ch. 5-6 3 100 308 972 2093 10000 2 3 776 776 6811 6811 972 2093 776 6811 3

184 2 2 2 2 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 4 5 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 2 Ch. 7-8 4 100 313 973 1844 10000 2 6 626 626 5007 5007 973 1844 626 5007 3

185 2 2 2 2 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 5 7 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 2 Ch. 9-10 5 100 443 1102 1865 10000 3 4 756 756 4924 4924 1102 1865 756 4924 3

186 2 2 2 2 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 6 9 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 2 Ch. 11-12 6 100 253 795 1956 10000 1 8 447 447 5014 5014 795 1956 447 5014 3

175 2 1 2 1 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 1 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2878 10000 112 15533 15533 2878 2878 15533 15533 1

176 2 1 2 1 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 1 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1761 10000 134 10938 10938 1761 1761 10938 10938 1

177 2 1 2 1 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 1 Ch. 5-6 3 100 361 1107 2225 10000 5 5 2236 2236 10912 10912 1107 2225 2236 10912 3

178 2 1 2 1 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 1 Ch. 7-8 4 100 346 794 2234 10000 5 8 1105 1105 7992 7992 794 2234 1105 7992 3

179 2 1 2 1 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 1 Ch. 9-10 5 100 481 910 2393 10000 9 7 1471 1471 8322 8322 910 2393 1471 8322 3

180 2 1 2 1 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 1 Ch. 11-12 6 100 222 733 1948 10000 4 3 842 842 10013 10013 733 1948 842 10013 3

5 5 4 R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 12/17/2012 4 r Ch. 1-2 1 100 3141 10000 202 12188 12188 3141 3141 12188 12188 1

5 6 4 R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 2 1 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 12/17/2012 4 r Ch. 3-4 2 100 2708 10000 171 12597 12597 2708 2708 12597 12597 1

5 7 4 R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 3 3 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 12/17/2012 4 r Ch. 5-6 3 100 1576 10000 5 9 12111 12111 1576 1576 12111 12111 1

5 8 4 R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 4 5 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 12/17/2012 4 r Ch. 7-8 4 100 2768 10000 8 5 11301 11301 2768 2768 11301 11301 1

5 9 4 R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 5 7 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 12/17/2012 4 r Ch. 9-10 5 100 2623 10000 213 11004 11004 2623 2623 11004 11004 1

6 0 4 R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 6 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 12/17/2012 4 r Ch. 11-12 6 100 246 497 2685 10000 3 3 637 637 15187 15187 497 2685 637 15187 3

3 7 2 R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 11/28/2012 2 r Ch. 1-2 1 100 680 2764 3355 10000 185 5837 5837 14498 14498 2764 3355 5837 14498 3

3 8 2 R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 2 1 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 11/28/2012 2 r Ch. 3-4 2 100 2284 10000 153 15403 15403 2284 2284 15403 15403 1

3 9 2 R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 3 3 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 11/28/2012 2 r Ch. 5-6 3 100 1912 10000 129 13801 13801 1912 1912 13801 13801 1

4 0 2 R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 4 5 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 11/28/2012 2 r Ch. 7-8 4 100 1229 2321 3203 10000 328 5701 5701 14176 14176 2321 3203 5701 14176 3

4 1 2 R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 5 7 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 11/28/2012 2 r Ch. 9-10 5 100 266 399 3568 10000 146 1842 1842 14959 14959 399 3568 1842 14959 3

4 2 2 R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 6 9 0.2 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 18 ply 11/28/2012 2 r Ch. 11-12 6 100 303 1019 2231 10000 8 4 1949 1949 15046 15046 1019 2231 1949 15046 3

205 2 6 2 6 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 6 Ch. 1-2 1 100 311 1625 3300 10000 3 5 1663 1663 7476 7476 1625 3300 1663 7476 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

401 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

206 2 6 2 6 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 6 Ch. 3-4 2 100 445 819 2872 10000 7 0 1256 1256 6938 6938 819 2872 1256 6938 3

207 2 6 2 6 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 6 Ch. 5-6 3 100 336 785 3511 10000 6 2 1377 1377 6832 6832 785 3511 1377 6832 3

208 2 6 2 6 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 6 Ch. 7-8 4 100 536 1088 2982 10000 9 0 1508 1508 5689 5689 1088 2982 1508 5689 3

209 2 6 2 6 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 6 Ch. 9-10 5 100 400 670 3109 10000 6 9 1103 1103 4816 4816 670 3109 1103 4816 3

210 2 6 2 6 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 6 Ch. 11-12 6 100 265 832 1846 10000 2 7 855 855 5860 5860 832 1846 855 5860 3

103 10R 1 0 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 10r Ch. 1-2 1 100 843 10000 4 0 9328 9328 843 843 9328 9328 1

104 10R 1 0 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 2 1 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 10r Ch. 3-4 2 100 744 10000 5 0 9291 9291 744 744 9291 9291 1

105 10R 1 0 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 3 3 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 10r Ch. 5-6 3 100 1016 10000 6 3 12158 12158 1016 1016 12158 12158 1

106 10R 1 0 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 4 5 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 10r Ch. 7-8 4 100 1712 10000 164 9621 9621 1712 1712 9621 9621 1

107 10R 1 0 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 5 7 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 10r Ch. 9-10 5 100 682 10000 5 9 10153 10153 682 682 10153 10153 1

108 10R 1 0 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 6 9 0.2 1 0 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 38 ply 10r Ch. 11-12 6 100 803 10000 1 6 16717 16717 803 803 16717 16717 1

9 1 9 R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 9 r Ch. 1-2 1 100 2143 10000 297 10921 10921 2143 2143 10921 10921 1

9 2 9 R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 2 1 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 9 r Ch. 3-4 2 100 2080 10000 185 15926 15926 2080 2080 15926 15926 1

9 3 9 R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 3 3 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 9 r Ch. 5-6 3 100 1241 10000 9 4 13369 13369 1241 1241 13369 13369 1

9 4 9 R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 4 5 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 9 r Ch. 7-8 4 100 2114 10000 152 10124 10124 2114 2114 10124 10124 1

9 5 9 R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 5 7 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 9 r Ch. 9-10 5 100 1111 10000 9 2 12541 12541 1111 1111 12541 12541 1

9 6 9 R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 6 9 0.3 2 2 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 54 ply 9 r Ch. 11-12 6 100 1055 10000 6 5 13214 13214 1055 1055 13214 13214 1

277 2 8 2 8 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 9 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC panel. 2 8 Ch. 1-2 1 100 857 1971 3806 10000 1 9 3428 3428 10071 10071 1971 3806 3428 10071 3

278 2 8 2 8 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 2 1 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC panel. 2 8 Ch. 3-4 2 100 328 1328 2852 10000 5 2 2258 2258 10130 10130 1328 2852 2258 10130 3

279 2 8 2 8 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 3 3 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC panel. 2 8 Ch. 5-6 3 100 313 1278 3394 10000 3 3 1978 1978 9601 9601 1278 3394 1978 9601 3

280 2 8 2 8 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 4 5 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC panel. 2 8 Ch. 7-8 4 100 681 1105 2712 10000 5 5 1738 1738 7848 7848 1105 2712 1738 7848 3

281 2 8 2 8 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 5 7 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC panel. 2 8 Ch. 9-10 5 100 299 755 2848 10000 5 1 1157 1157 6619 6619 755 2848 1157 6619 3

282 2 8 2 8 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 6 9 1 1 0 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Tape 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Some delamination of the 32 quasi-isotropic tape ply LSC panel. 2 8 Ch. 11-12 6 100 285 684 2241 10000 2 2 606 606 8164 8164 684 2241 606 8164 3

187 2 3 2 3 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 9 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf test a 

modification to the standoff shims is going to be introduced to 

increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the standoff shim.

2 3 Ch. 1-2 1 100 451 780 3876 10000 2 1 776 776 13582 13582 780 3876 776 13582 3

188 2 3 2 3 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 2 1 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf test a 

modification to the standoff shims is going to be introduced to 

increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the standoff shim.

2 3 Ch. 3-4 2 100 416 952 2854 10000 8 1 626 626 11327 11327 952 2854 626 11327 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

402 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

189 2 3 2 3 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 3 3 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf test a 

modification to the standoff shims is going to be introduced to 

increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the standoff shim.

2 3 Ch. 5-6 3 100 339 1073 2969 10000 5 0 862 862 8538 8538 1073 2969 862 8538 3

190 2 3 2 3 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 4 5 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf test a 

modification to the standoff shims is going to be introduced to 

increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the standoff shim.

2 3 Ch. 7-8 4 100 361 818 3376 10000 6 2 803 803 8628 8628 818 3376 803 8628 3

191 2 3 2 3 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 5 7 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf test a 

modification to the standoff shims is going to be introduced to 

increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the standoff shim.

2 3 Ch. 9-10 5 100 276 1103 3700 10000 3 9 986 986 7586 7586 1103 3700 986 7586 3

192 2 3 2 3 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 6 9 1 1 0 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

Note on this test: Prior to conducting the last 10 gpf test a 

modification to the standoff shims is going to be introduced to 

increase the shelf width by 5 to 8 mils to ensure the legs of the LSC 

are firmly seated on the standoff shim.

2 3 Ch. 11-12 6 100 291 901 2555 10000 4 7 660 660 9024 9024 901 2555 660 9024 3

193 2 4 2 4 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 9 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 4 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2449 10000 206 10702 10702 2449 2449 10702 10702 1

194 2 4 2 4 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 2 1 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 4 Ch. 3-4 2 100 1318 10000 8 5 10450 10450 1318 1318 10450 10450 1

195 2 4 2 4 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 3 3 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 4 Ch. 5-6 3 100 339 807 2007 10000 5 9 1566 1566 8200 8200 807 2007 1566 8200 3

196 2 4 2 4 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 4 5 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 4 Ch. 7-8 4 100 338 904 2005 10000 9 8 1531 1531 7486 7486 904 2005 1531 7486 3

197 2 4 2 4 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 5 7 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 4 Ch. 9-10 5 100 304 832 2205 10000 7 8 1565 1565 8366 8366 832 2205 1565 8366 3

198 2 4 2 4 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 6 9 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 4 Ch. 11-12 6 100 225 868 1588 10000 115 1131 1131 7389 7389 868 1588 1131 7389 3

199 2 5 2 5 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 9 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 5 Ch. 1-2 1 100 505 1639 3370 10000 2 0 1801 1801 6571 6571 1639 3370 1801 6571 3

200 2 5 2 5 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 2 1 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 5 Ch. 3-4 2 100 261 905 2108 10000 3 1 1208 1208 4937 4937 905 2108 1208 4937 3

201 2 5 2 5 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 3 3 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 5 Ch. 5-6 3 100 328 898 3100 10000 2 8 1201 1201 4457 4457 898 3100 1201 4457 3

202 2 5 2 5 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 4 5 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 5 Ch. 7-8 4 100 281 947 2810 10000 3 7 1038 1038 3925 3925 947 2810 1038 3925 3

203 2 5 2 5 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 5 7 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 5 Ch. 9-10 5 100 247 986 2249 10000 3 1 1037 1037 3365 3365 986 2249 1037 3365 3

204 2 5 2 5 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 6 9 1 2 2 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

2 5 Ch. 11-12 6 100 294 944 1761 10000 3 0 672 672 4136 4136 944 1761 672 4136 3

271 2 7 2 7 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 9 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 7 Ch. 1-2 1 100 3991 0 0 10000 220 13604 0 0 13604 3991 3991 13604 13604 3

272 2 7 2 7 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 2 1 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 7 Ch. 3-4 2 100 322 433 1764 10000 3 5 556 556 7871 7871 433 1764 556 7871 3

273 2 7 2 7 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 3 3 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 7 Ch. 5-6 3 100 293 444 1324 10000 2 1 464 464 7293 7293 444 1324 464 7293 3

274 2 7 2 7 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 4 5 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 7 Ch. 7-8 4 100 302 487 908 10000 6 6 511 511 6432 6432 487 908 511 6432 3

275 2 7 2 7 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 5 7 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 7 Ch. 9-10 5 100 498 798 1186 10000 3 1 1354 1354 4675 4675 798 1186 1354 4675 3

276 2 7 2 7 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 6 9 1 1 0 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1

Fabric 

Composite

0 0 0 0 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 2 7 Ch. 11-12 6 100 292 605 1278 10000 1 7 384 384 5309 5309 605 1278 384 5309 3

235 A05 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A05 Ch. 1-2 1 100 5423 10000 383 28490 28490 5423 5423 28490 28490 1

236 A05 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A05 Ch. 3-4 2 100 249 650 2095 10000 125 1630 1630 19259 19259 650 2095 1630 19259 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

403 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

237 A05 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A05 Ch. 5-6 3 100 304 704 2208 10000 8 8 1726 1726 14063 14063 704 2208 1726 14063 3

238 A05 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A05 Ch. 7-8 4 100 349 694 1906 10000 102 1123 1123 11892 11892 694 1906 1123 11892 3

239 A05 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A05 Ch. 9-10 5 100 272 764 1673 10000 113 1581 1581 10860 10860 764 1673 1581 10860 3

240 A05 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A05 Ch. 11-12 6 100 208 891 1418 10000 147 1669 1669 9224 9224 891 1418 1669 9224 3

265 A10 1 2 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A10 Ch. 1-2 1 100 3244 10000 538 15731 15731 3244 3244 15731 15731 1

266 A10 1 2 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A10 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2816 10000 227 17244 17244 2816 2816 17244 17244 1

267 A10 1 2 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A10 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1898 10000 271 12947 12947 1898 1898 12947 12947 1

268 A10 1 2 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A10 Ch. 7-8 4 100 2490 10000 168 12470 12470 2490 2490 12470 12470 1

269 A10 1 2 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A10 Ch. 9-10 5 100 1827 10000 133 12688 12688 1827 1827 12688 12688 1

270 A10 1 2 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A10 Ch. 11-12 6 100 913 1433 2106 10000 9 1 2647 2647 10113 10113 1433 2106 2647 10113 3

211 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 1-2 1 100 1823 10000 124 8801 8801 1823 1823 8801 8801 1

212 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 2 1 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 3-4 2 100 412 846 1837 10000 6 5 2437 2437 12045 12045 846 1837 2437 12045 3

213 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 3 3 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 5-6 3 100 306 973 1816 10000 5 4 2320 2320 9947 9947 973 1816 2320 9947 3

214 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 4 5 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 7-8 4 100 302 975 1931 10000 5 9 1907 1907 7338 7338 975 1931 1907 7338 3

215 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 5 7 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 9-10 5 100 273 645 1910 10000 5 9 1256 1256 8401 8401 645 1910 1256 8401 3

216 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 6 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 A01 Ch. 11-12 6 100 214 505 1621 10000 3 9 488 488 8715 8715 505 1621 488 8715 3

247 A07 1 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A07 Ch. 1-2 1 100 771 10000 118 12017 12017 771 771 12017 12017 1

248 A07 1 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A07 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2786 10000 392 12631 12631 2786 2786 12631 12631 1

249 A07 1 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A07 Ch. 5-6 3 100 319 571 1418 10000 122 2125 2125 12103 12103 571 1418 2125 12103 3

250 A07 1 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A07 Ch. 7-8 4 100 197 274 1713 10000 144 912 912 9114 9114 274 1713 912 9114 3

251 A07 1 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A07 Ch. 9-10 5 100 162 316 1341 10000 153 627 627 9785 9785 316 1341 627 9785 3

252 A07 1 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A07 Ch. 11-12 6 100 260 822 1494 10000 9 9 1315 1315 10422 10422 822 1494 1315 10422 3

253 A08 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A08 Ch. 1-2 1 100 314 571 1670 10000 6 6 1829 1829 12610 12610 571 1670 1829 12610 3

254 A08 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A08 Ch. 3-4 2 100 491 670 1387 10000 137 2510 2510 8942 8942 670 1387 2510 8942 3

255 A08 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A08 Ch. 5-6 3 100 582 896 1518 10000 6 9 3181 3181 7914 7914 896 1518 3181 7914 3

256 A08 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A08 Ch. 7-8 4 100 516 1115 1498 10000 3 8 4023 4023 6133 6133 1115 1498 4023 6133 3

257 A08 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A08 Ch. 9-10 5 100 404 656 945 10000 5 2 2061 2061 7057 7057 656 945 2061 7057 3

258 A08 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 A08 Ch. 11-12 6 100 404 623 1084 10000 103 1946 1946 7789 7789 623 1084 1946 7789 3

223 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 1-2 1 100 2064 10000 366 9408 9408 2064 2064 9408 9408 1

224 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 2 1 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 3-4 2 100 2320 10000 216 10782 10782 2320 2320 10782 10782 1

225 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 3 3 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1962 10000 8 0 9279 9279 1962 1962 9279 9279 1

226 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 4 5 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 7-8 4 100 2055 10000 135 8970 8970 2055 2055 8970 8970 1

227 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 5 7 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 9-10 5 100 303 500 1132 10000 140 909 909 9392 9392 500 1132 909 9392 3

228 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 6 9 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A03 Ch. 11-12 6 100 312 652 1944 10000 6 3 1082 1082 12381 12381 652 1944 1082 12381 3

229 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 1-2 1 100 411 838 1789 10000 5 0 2141 2141 12017 12017 838 1789 2141 12017 3

230 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 2 1 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 3-4 2 100 493 870 1550 10000 5 6 2674 2674 10233 10233 870 1550 2674 10233 3

231 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 3 3 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 5-6 3 100 538 858 1716 10000 5 3 2504 2504 8206 8206 858 1716 2504 8206 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

404 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

232 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 4 5 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 7-8 4 100 498 937 1611 10000 2 9 2030 2030 6336 6336 937 1611 2030 6336 3

233 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 5 7 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 9-10 5 100 428 1082 1888 10000 4 5 2388 2388 5420 5420 1082 1888 2388 5420 3

234 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 6 9 0.187 2 2 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5052 Aluminum Aluminum 0 Spliced LSC A04 Ch. 11-12 6 100 638 1010 1562 10000 5 1 2625 2625 5809 5809 1010 1562 2625 5809 3

241 A06 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 1-2 1 100 518 10000 161 9028 9028 518 518 9028 9028 1

242 A06 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 3-4 2 100 414 10000 130 10150 10150 414 414 10150 10150 1

243 A06 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 5-6 3 100 1376 10000 514 9472 9472 1376 1376 9472 9472 1

244 A06 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 7-8 4 100 1611 10000 448 10677 10677 1611 1611 10677 10677 1

245 A06 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 9-10 5 100 227 623 1250 10000 247 2165 2165 11652 11652 623 1250 2165 11652 3

246 A06 1 7 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A06 Ch. 11-12 6 100 243 947 1525 10000 147 2444 2444 10981 10981 947 1525 2444 10981 3

259 A09 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 1-2 1 100 795 10000 9 8 18346 18346 795 795 18346 18346 1

260 A09 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 2 1 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 3-4 2 100 435 618 1702 10000 9 0 2464 2464 10158 10158 618 1702 2464 10158 3

261 A09 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 3 3 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 5-6 3 100 445 758 1343 10000 111 2772 2772 6601 6601 758 1343 2772 6601 3

262 A09 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 4 5 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 7-8 4 100 442 790 1487 10000 3 9 2215 2215 6162 6162 790 1487 2215 6162 3

263 A09 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 5 7 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 9-10 5 100 451 851 1473 10000 9 5 2017 2017 6596 6596 851 1473 2017 6596 3

264 A09 1 1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 6 9 1 2 2 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350

90°/+45°/-45°/0°/0°/ -45°/+45°/90°; 8 ply both 

faces

0 Spliced LSC A09 Ch. 11-12 6 100 363 994 1349 10000 7 4 2088 2088 6488 6488 994 1349 2088 6488 3

217 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 1-2 1 100 206 304 1938 10000 5 4 529 529 9217 9217 304 1938 529 9217 3

218 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 2 1 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 3-4 2 100 125 166 1032 10000 6 2 121 121 8904 8904 166 1032 121 8904 3

219 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 3 3 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 5-6 3 100 214 337 1000 10000 5 1 498 498 7978 7978 337 1000 498 7978 3

220 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 4 5 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 7-8 4 100 334 504 1580 10000 5 5 899 899 7338 7338 504 1580 899 7338 3

221 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 5 7 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 9-10 5 100 246 497 1411 10000 4 2 871 871 5774 5774 497 1411 871 5774 3

222 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 6 9 0.3 2 2 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 Composite, IM7/TC350 +45°/-45°; 0° (2x); +45°/-45°; 90° (2x); 27 ply 0 Spliced LSC A02 Ch. 11-12 6 100 197 346 1069 10000 5 5 351 351 5433 5433 346 1069 351 5433 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

405 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Data Other Prelim Params

564 Maximum observation number (no. of observations) =|Time Min G|

time time time time H z g^2*s/Hz

c Test No Panel No Group Goal Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance from 

LSC

Sensor Vert 

Posn T-B

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Aluminum LSC 

Plate

Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accels

0 Degree Test Output Name Channel Time Min G Abs Time 

Min G

Time Max 

G

Temporal 

Energy

Max ESD Freq Max ESD 

Displace

1 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 9 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 1 1 -6160 6160 4647 1.50E+09 3463 7.69

2 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 9 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 2 2 -5163 5163 6149 1.43E+09 1610 7.97

3 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 21 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 3 3 -3205 3205 3238 1.29E+09 1756 7.6

4 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 21 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 4 4 -5198 5198 4911 1.58E+09 1756 11.95

5 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 33 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 5 5 -3617 3617 4237 1.52E+09 1463 6.97

6 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 33 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 6 6 -3551 3551 3220 1.39E+09 3220 7.26

7 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 45 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 7 7 -4786 4786 4627 1.63E+09 3024 7.02

8 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 45 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 8 8 -3371 3371 3665 1.16E+09 11073 5.16

9 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 57 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 9 9 -3357 3357 4135 1.34E+09 3220 5.93

10 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 57 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 10 10 -3593 3593 3871 1.39E+09 1756 6.71

11 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 69 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 11 11 -5155 5155 3420 1.52E+09 1756 9.94

12 P1 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/10/2012 0 69 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P1 NEST01 - Ch 12 12 -3681 3681 3916 1.32E+09 1463 6.39

13 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5380 5380 5003 2.10E+09 3707 15.68

14 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 2 2 -7321 7321 4875 1.86E+09 927 7.09

15 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4333 4333 4481 1.97E+09 6293 8.49

16 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 4 4 -6015 6015 5915 2.18E+09 3902 9.15

17 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 5 5 -5349 5349 4326 2.09E+09 6293 11.67

18 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 6 6 -5449 5449 4368 2.17E+09 3659 12.15

19 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 7 7 -5048 5048 5549 2.36E+09 4390 17.14

20 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 8 8 -4840 4840 5055 2.30E+09 4390 14.33

21 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 9 9 -5584 5584 4959 2.18E+09 4195 14.1

22 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 10 10 -4480 4480 5295 2.02E+09 4390 9.77

23 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 11 11 -5429 5429 5476 2.33E+09 3902 15.62

24 P2 P1 0 Pathfinder 8/16/2012 1 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P2 NEST02_1048 - Ch 12 12 -6723 6723 6643 2.62E+09 5951 14.45

25 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 1 1 -3945 3945 2668 7.17E+08 1317 7.39

26 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 2 2 -3642 3642 2369 5.61E+08 1073 6.07

27 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 3 3 -3097 3097 3934 7.40E+08 2634 4.88

28 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 4 4 -3420 3420 4563 8.90E+08 3073 5.07

29 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 5 5 -2869 2869 3522 7.32E+08 2927 6.1

30 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 6 6 -2422 2422 1998 5.67E+08 1805 6.18

31 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 7 7 -2973 2973 2403 7.79E+08 1268 20.83

32 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 8 8 -3230 3230 2341 6.28E+08 1268 10.12

33 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 9 9 -2277 2277 2210 5.07E+08 1073 3.58

34 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 10 10 -2312 2312 2760 6.14E+08 1415 7.46

35 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 11 11 -2335 2335 2262 4.31E+08 1317 3.07

36 P3 P3 0 Pathfinder 9/10/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 P3 NEST03 1048 - Ch 12 12 -2569 2569 2213 4.75E+08 1268 5.18

37 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 1 1 -4077 4077 4735 8.62E+08 537 14.83

38 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6068 6068 5025 1.07E+09 1415 9.93

39 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 3 3 -2222 2222 3080 5.85E+08 537 11.24

40 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 4 4 -14 14 1 1.56E+04 8049 0

41 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2061 2061 2203 6.60E+08 537 10.08

42 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2976 2976 2352 6.86E+08 537 10.27

43 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 7 7 -1636 1636 1988 5.62E+08 537 7.46

44 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 8 8 -1568 1568 1840 4.90E+08 537 9.5

45 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 9 9 -1570 1570 1205 5.63E+08 1220 10.8

46 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1513 1513 1501 4.81E+08 537 25.89

47 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1417 1417 1556 6.00E+08 537 33.79

48 P4 P4 0 Pathfinder 11/30/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P4 NEST04_1048 - Ch 12 12 -1376 1376 1490 3.22E+08 537 11.31

49 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 1 1 -3837 3837 4136 7.58E+08 1561 7.43

50 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 2 2 -4546 4546 3998 9.80E+08 1610 12.88

51 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3578 3578 2765 7.85E+08 2000 11.87

52 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3808 3808 4088 9.98E+08 2000 14.21

53 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3698 3698 1898 7.43E+08 2000 16.37

54 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3012 3012 2320 9.07E+08 1610 17.36

55 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2545 2545 2000 8.14E+08 1805 15.26

56 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2684 2684 2369 8.07E+08 1805 14.58

57 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2567 2567 3028 7.12E+08 927 12.75

58 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2458 2458 2916 8.89E+08 1610 19.83

59 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2926 2926 2377 5.78E+08 780 12.15

60 P5 P5 0 Pathfinder 12/5/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 P5 NEST05_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2489 2489 2678 6.23E+08 780 10.54

61 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5189 5189 5405 1.47E+09 1073 20.61

62 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5378 5378 4227 1.22E+09 1073 19.65

63 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4560 4560 3825 1.28E+09 634 11.8

64 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3650 3650 4483 1.17E+09 634 11.08

65 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3454 3454 2540 1.04E+09 3317 21.46

66 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3120 3120 3560 1.02E+09 1073 16.74

67 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2637 2637 3224 1.23E+09 1220 13.58
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

406 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

68 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3742 3742 3611 9.75E+08 1659 12.33

69 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3473 3473 2662 1.16E+09 3317 20.17

70 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 10 10 -3005 3005 2301 8.42E+08 1073 17.09

71 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3330 3330 3290 1.03E+09 1854 13.71

72 1 1 1 Monolithic 1/23/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1 NEST1-01_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2579 2579 2202 7.83E+08 732 12.64

73 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 1 1 -4662 4662 4632 1.12E+09 3366 9.2

74 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6908 6908 4174 9.27E+08 1073 8.97

75 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3369 3369 4553 1.02E+09 3366 12.69

76 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4208 4208 4179 8.83E+08 1756 7.08

77 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3547 3547 3451 1.28E+09 2927 12.79

78 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3038 3038 3379 8.15E+08 3366 8.73

79 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3377 3377 2815 9.13E+08 1366 8.7

80 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2697 2697 2643 8.01E+08 1756 8.58

81 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3376 3376 2932 8.46E+08 3805 13.37

82 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2547 2547 3022 7.03E+08 3805 7.93

83 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2851 2851 3076 6.37E+08 1951 7.27

84 2 2 1 Monolithic 1/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2 NEST1-02_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2805 2805 2002 6.28E+08 3805 6.44

109 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 1 1 -4228 4228 3964 9.19E+08 3659 6.14

110 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5341 5341 3780 7.53E+08 537 3.58

111 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3269 3269 4114 7.79E+08 3659 6.75

112 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3269 3269 3971 7.04E+08 1463 4.81

113 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3166 3166 2727 6.93E+08 1756 6.43

114 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3356 3356 2580 5.70E+08 1171 3.53

115 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2400 2400 3335 6.15E+08 1512 6.67

116 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2850 2850 1887 4.41E+08 1171 5.29

117 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2567 2567 2591 5.20E+08 1366 4.16

118 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2068 2068 2521 4.32E+08 1317 4.82

119 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2123 2123 2652 4.01E+08 2195 2.65

120 4 4 1 Monolithic 2/5/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4 NEST1-04_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2657 2657 1737 3.86E+08 439 2.71

97 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5650 5650 4787 1.02E+09 1805 7.18

98 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5609 5609 4274 8.90E+08 2195 5.35

99 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4086 4086 3692 8.30E+08 1951 8.69

100 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3267 3267 4763 7.22E+08 1659 6.29

101 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3259 3259 2849 7.84E+08 1220 12.7

102 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 6 6 -4771 4771 2214 6.33E+08 1171 5.33

103 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2284 2284 3825 7.76E+08 1805 10.19

104 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2311 2311 2725 5.00E+08 1756 7.3

105 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2734 2734 3218 6.32E+08 1659 9.92

106 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2833 2833 2876 5.78E+08 1463 9.46

107 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2439 2439 2471 5.19E+08 732 8.21

108 3 3 1 Monolithic 2/8/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 3 NEST1-03_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2638 2638 2276 4.37E+08 732 5.47

133 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 1 1 -4943 4943 4621 1.38E+09 5756 8.65

134 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6495 6495 5551 1.07E+09 1122 19.6

135 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3593 3593 4888 1.71E+09 3268 19.18

136 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 4 4 -6056 6056 5040 1.36E+09 2780 6.83

137 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 5 5 -4966 4966 4063 1.82E+09 2585 16

138 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 6 6 -5534 5534 4091 1.34E+09 2780 12.34

139 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 7 7 -4211 4211 4428 1.46E+09 2585 16.74

140 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3615 3615 3625 1.58E+09 2585 17.01

141 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 9 9 -4198 4198 3944 1.44E+09 2585 13.27

142 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2816 2816 3789 1.18E+09 2585 17.03

143 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3298 3298 4745 1.35E+09 2634 13.28

144 5 5 1 Monolithic 2/22/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5 NEST1-05_1048 - Ch 12 12 -3706 3706 3978 1.14E+09 2341 15.26

145 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 1 1 -7215 7215 3877 1.95E+09 1073 29.29

146 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 2 2 -6960 6960 4214 1.92E+09 1073 43.64

147 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 3 3 -5202 5202 3735 1.59E+09 976 32.95

148 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 4 4 -3761 3761 4133 1.54E+09 976 36.2

149 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 5 5 -2991 2991 3783 1.77E+09 1073 31.12

150 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 6 6 -3667 3667 3823 1.44E+09 1073 37.71

151 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 7 7 -3507 3507 3402 1.74E+09 1220 34.7

152 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 8 8 -2790 2790 3312 1.46E+09 829 26.66

153 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 9 9 -3269 3269 3169 1.73E+09 1073 42.83

154 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 10 10 -3579 3579 3179 1.42E+09 1073 33.46

155 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 11 11 -3276 3276 4184 1.34E+09 2244 20.7

156 6 6 1 Monolithic 5/8/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6 NEST1-06 - Ch 12 12 -2746 2746 4337 1.28E+09 2293 21.22

157 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 1 1 -6799 6799 4764 1.76E+09 1073 21.16

158 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 2 2 -7559 7559 5690 1.77E+09 1073 24.38

159 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 3 3 -5258 5258 7438 2.06E+09 878 22.98

160 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 4 4 -3526 3526 4830 1.37E+09 878 17.49

161 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 5 5 -3262 3262 5551 1.80E+09 1415 21.67

162 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 6 6 -4083 4083 4513 1.62E+09 976 14.82

163 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 7 7 -3183 3183 4229 1.44E+09 1073 22.54

164 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 8 8 -3333 3333 3509 1.46E+09 1073 21.16

165 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 9 9 -3988 3988 3917 1.49E+09 537 17.26

166 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 10 10 -2792 2792 3522 1.33E+09 1415 20.36

167 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 11 11 -4540 4540 4428 1.32E+09 390 14.02

168 7 7 1 Monolithic 5/9/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7 NEST1-07 - Ch 12 12 -2467 2467 2755 1.11E+09 390 15.17

169 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 1 1 -6655 6655 5504 1.07E+09 1854 7.57

170 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 2 2 -5372 5372 3973 7.60E+08 1854 4.74

171 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 3 3 -4004 4004 3262 9.18E+08 1854 8.81

172 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 4 4 -6717 6717 4605 8.92E+08 2000 6.45
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

407 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

173 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 5 5 -4715 4715 3848 9.34E+08 2000 16.68

174 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 6 6 -2585 2585 3122 6.68E+08 1366 7.18

175 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 7 7 -4005 4005 2986 8.46E+08 2049 15.32

176 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 8 8 -2336 2336 2432 5.51E+08 2000 6.69

177 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 9 9 -3004 3004 2654 7.58E+08 1951 8.74

178 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 10 10 -2769 2769 2607 5.38E+08 2244 5.33

179 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 11 11 -2439 2439 2945 5.57E+08 780 4.98

180 8 8 1 Monolithic 5/16/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8 NEST1-08 - Ch 12 12 -2207 2207 2637 5.48E+08 2293 6.7

181 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 1 1 -4135 4135 4899 1.06E+09 2049 11.28

182 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 2 2 -5255 5255 6319 1.09E+09 1805 10.59

183 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 3 3 -3755 3755 3839 1.08E+09 2000 15.25

184 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 4 4 -4634 4634 3800 1.02E+09 2000 17.25

185 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 5 5 -3949 3949 3904 1.23E+09 1902 21.81

186 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 6 6 -4916 4916 2705 8.87E+08 1805 12.52

187 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 7 7 -4617 4617 3754 1.12E+09 1805 19.08

188 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 8 8 -2902 2902 3283 8.75E+08 1805 15.92

189 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 9 9 -3205 3205 3578 7.88E+08 1854 10.22

190 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 10 10 -2821 2821 2867 7.98E+08 1366 8.74

191 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 11 11 -3414 3414 3282 8.28E+08 732 11.4

192 9 9 1 Monolithic 5/17/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9 NEST1-09 - Ch 12 12 -2240 2240 2688 6.98E+08 732 9.66

205 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 1 1 -8246 8246 5837 1.68E+09 4000 18.03

206 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 2 2 -8688 8688 6179 1.70E+09 1415 22.91

207 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 3 3 -4494 4494 5174 1.47E+09 1024 24.86

208 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 4 4 -6865 6865 6394 1.65E+09 1122 10.15

209 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 5 5 -4817 4817 3485 1.39E+09 1122 22.47

210 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 6 6 -4848 4848 5793 1.55E+09 1122 15.11

211 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 7 7 -3574 3574 3571 1.31E+09 1268 26.28

212 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 8 8 -4584 4584 3935 1.35E+09 1268 23

213 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 9 9 -3869 3869 3872 1.29E+09 2488 11.59

214 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 10 10 -3239 3239 3339 1.04E+09 1024 13.81

215 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 11 11 -3463 3463 3617 1.02E+09 2293 11.5

216 10 10 1 Monolithic 5/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 Y 1 10 NEST1-10 - Ch 12 12 -4004 4004 3858 1.02E+09 2439 9.26

229 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 1 1 -6463 6463 5676 1.05E+09 5024 7.18

230 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 2 2 -4751 4751 5260 7.95E+08 3610 4.32

231 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 3 3 -5014 5014 3809 9.18E+08 3561 6.03

232 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3518 3518 4376 7.20E+08 3610 4.95

233 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3441 3441 4431 7.10E+08 3805 8.58

234 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3063 3063 3595 6.90E+08 3805 7.65

235 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3790 3790 3071 6.39E+08 3805 8.8

236 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3237 3237 2583 5.83E+08 3805 6.89

237 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3684 3684 2612 5.78E+08 3610 5.04

238 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2686 2686 2173 5.55E+08 439 4.28

239 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2444 2444 3117 5.60E+08 4976 4.62

240 11 11 2 Sandwich 5/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11 NEST2-11_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2198 2198 2091 4.86E+08 1463 5.52

241 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 1 1 -6886 6886 3504 7.46E+08 1220 9.81

242 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6553 6553 3979 8.50E+08 2000 10.09

243 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3868 3868 5466 7.38E+08 1854 10.21

244 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 4 4 -2930 2930 5129 6.06E+08 1951 11.09

245 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2611 2611 4255 5.14E+08 244 9.03

246 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2369 2369 4971 5.05E+08 244 9.91

247 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2390 2390 2391 3.90E+08 244 8.35

248 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2219 2219 2191 3.75E+08 1951 8.66

249 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3148 3148 1879 3.91E+08 1951 9.26

250 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2654 2654 1520 2.47E+08 1854 4.3

251 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2410 2410 2094 3.61E+08 1756 6.53

252 12 14 2 Sandwich 6/28/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12 NEST2-12_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2066 2066 2165 2.93E+08 1854 4.47

253 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 1 1 -2727 2727 3160 3.27E+08 585 3.2

254 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 2 2 -3696 3696 2993 4.23E+08 2049 3.11

255 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 3 3 -2275 2275 3798 3.33E+08 1902 4.11

256 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 4 4 -2856 2856 4428 2.82E+08 1951 3.99

257 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 5 5 -1592 1592 2255 2.23E+08 1951 4.52

258 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 6 6 -1475 1475 3482 2.07E+08 1951 2.71

259 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2086 2086 1501 1.68E+08 1854 1.88

260 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2091 2091 1510 1.61E+08 1951 3.58

261 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2057 2057 1110 1.62E+08 1951 4.01

262 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2142 2142 834 1.42E+08 390 2.83

263 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1499 1499 1789 2.02E+08 1756 4.03

264 13 13 2 Sandwich 7/16/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 13 NEST2-13_1048 - Ch 12 12 -1527 1527 1390 1.74E+08 1854 2.79

265 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5086 5086 4686 8.86E+08 976 13.81

266 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5088 5088 6030 1.02E+09 976 13.37

267 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3421 3421 4696 8.57E+08 976 13.91

268 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 4 4 -5016 5016 6555 9.42E+08 976 10.48

269 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2826 2826 4722 8.25E+08 4683 12.22

270 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2349 2349 5272 7.12E+08 976 6.39

271 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3067 3067 2613 6.51E+08 4829 8.61
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

408 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

272 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3051 3051 3407 5.20E+08 3561 8.02

273 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3112 3112 2240 6.34E+08 3317 6.53

274 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2848 2848 2377 6.45E+08 3561 11.34

275 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2947 2947 2710 7.47E+08 1854 11.04

276 14 12 2 Sandwich 7/17/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 14 NEST2-14_1048 - Ch 12 12 -3251 3251 2674 6.32E+08 195 9.42

277 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5884 5884 5737 9.32E+08 976 11.97

278 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6295 6295 6119 1.18E+09 976 10.8

279 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4473 4473 4455 8.25E+08 976 10.45

280 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 4 4 -2945 2945 6336 7.78E+08 976 8.72

281 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3628 3628 4176 7.63E+08 3756 7.03

282 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2638 2638 4998 6.50E+08 976 5.38

283 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3137 3137 2752 5.44E+08 1805 4.65

284 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2591 2591 3323 5.79E+08 3561 10.76

285 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3123 3123 2512 5.64E+08 3268 7.46

286 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2933 2933 2511 5.55E+08 3512 6.08

287 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3248 3248 4272 7.48E+08 1805 16.31

288 15 16 2 Sandwich 7/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 15 NEST2-15_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2948 2948 1592 4.83E+08 195 8.07

289 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 1 1 -6597 6597 3145 8.42E+08 2000 12.48

290 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6612 6612 3876 8.72E+08 2000 11.66

291 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4633 4633 5288 8.92E+08 2000 13.84

292 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3795 3795 5517 7.71E+08 2000 12.6

293 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2877 2877 4288 6.38E+08 1902 16.38

294 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2181 2181 4615 5.91E+08 1951 10.43

295 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2787 2787 2284 4.67E+08 1951 8.6

296 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2721 2721 1973 4.54E+08 1902 9.64

297 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3310 3310 1919 4.78E+08 1854 9.99

298 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2881 2881 1600 3.68E+08 1854 10.51

299 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2449 2449 2950 5.03E+08 1659 9.72

300 16 18 2 Sandwich 7/23/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 16 NEST2-16_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2482 2482 2348 4.72E+08 1854 10.2

301 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 1 1 -3837 3837 4881 6.80E+08 976 5.65

302 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5129 5129 5774 8.05E+08 976 6.16

303 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3421 3421 4361 7.28E+08 3805 10.57

304 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3491 3491 5692 6.87E+08 3805 11.07

305 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2497 2497 4348 6.08E+08 3805 10.84

306 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2242 2242 4535 6.36E+08 3805 14.71

307 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2650 2650 3031 5.13E+08 3805 10.21

308 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3122 3122 2546 4.77E+08 3805 8.15

309 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2689 2689 2603 5.24E+08 3805 6.13

310 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2355 2355 1747 4.29E+08 3561 5.32

311 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3084 3084 3852 5.84E+08 1854 9.76

312 17 15 2 Sandwich 8/9/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 17 NEST2-17_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2974 2974 2100 4.35E+08 1268 4.44

313 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 1 1 -3173 3173 3579 4.04E+08 1951 2.52

314 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 2 2 -3608 3608 2994 3.93E+08 2049 3.04

315 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3049 3049 3029 2.44E+08 1902 2.72

316 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3171 3171 3146 2.59E+08 1951 5.53

317 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 5 5 -1932 1932 2374 1.93E+08 1951 5.93

318 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 6 6 -1666 1666 3245 1.99E+08 244 1.92

319 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 7 7 -1866 1866 1700 1.50E+08 1463 2.17

320 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 8 8 -1467 1467 1418 1.60E+08 1951 3.71

321 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 9 9 -1866 1866 1357 1.73E+08 1902 5.08

322 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1545 1545 736 1.09E+08 1902 2.36

323 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1537 1537 1284 1.29E+08 1902 2.49

324 18 17 2 Sandwich 8/19/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 18 NEST2-18_1048 - Ch 12 12 -1281 1281 1141 1.33E+08 1902 4.55

325 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 1 1 -2987 2987 2929 4.01E+08 537 5.79

326 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 2 2 -3387 3387 3137 5.84E+08 3659 5.15

327 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 3 3 -1860 1860 2443 3.56E+08 537 4.03

328 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3056 3056 3373 4.04E+08 537 4.15

329 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2370 2370 2243 3.16E+08 3415 3.96

330 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 6 6 -1961 1961 2729 2.82E+08 3415 3.52

331 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 7 7 -1380 1380 1520 2.41E+08 3756 2.46

332 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 8 8 -1996 1996 2700 2.93E+08 3463 4.06

333 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 9 9 -1701 1701 1823 2.28E+08 537 4.7

334 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1906 1906 1627 2.60E+08 537 4.03

335 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1570 1570 1464 1.97E+08 4829 1.16

336 19 19 3 Sever Plate 10/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 19 NEST3-19_1048 - Ch 12 12 -1732 1732 1237 1.93E+08 4049 1.74

337 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -6746 6746 8903 1.33E+09 439 10.34

338 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -7679 7679 9611 1.28E+09 439 7.5

339 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -5374 5374 3898 6.14E+08 488 6.9

340 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -4579 4579 5506 7.78E+08 488 8.23

341 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -5214 5214 2153 4.69E+08 2878 5.99

342 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -5167 5167 2602 3.98E+08 2537 4.15

343 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -3131 3131 1955 3.92E+08 2780 5.13

344 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -3006 3006 2002 2.76E+08 488 2.93

345 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2658 2658 2773 3.92E+08 439 11.31

346 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1920 1920 1815 3.05E+08 439 11.29
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

409 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

347 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -1530 1530 2238 1.77E+08 3512 1.73

348 20 20 3 Sever Plate 11/19/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 20 NEST3-20_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1130 1130 1574 1.31E+08 1024 1.59

361 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -4099 4099 3964 5.39E+08 2098 5.49

362 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -3129 3129 2759 2.90E+08 1902 2.96

363 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -2076 2076 2538 3.05E+08 2195 4.86

364 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -2885 2885 2715 2.80E+08 2195 3.43

365 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -2023 2023 2061 2.01E+08 2195 4.48

366 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -1532 1532 1844 1.81E+08 2244 2.59

367 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -1236 1236 1653 1.45E+08 1854 4.19

368 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -1121 1121 1450 1.39E+08 1854 3.01

369 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -1178 1178 1212 1.15E+08 1854 3.82

370 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1276 1276 1309 1.19E+08 1854 4.55

371 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -1136 1136 885 8.67E+07 1854 1.91

372 22 22 3 Sever Plate 11/25/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 22 NEST3-22_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1169 1169 1028 1.04E+08 1854 1.99

349 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5422 5422 3126 6.96E+08 1854 7.99

350 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5769 5769 3761 9.00E+08 2439 9.33

351 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3707 3707 4245 8.05E+08 2439 11.5

352 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4652 4652 4735 7.61E+08 2049 10.73

353 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3055 3055 4654 6.67E+08 3756 11.75

354 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2222 2222 4658 5.73E+08 3756 12.23

355 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3345 3345 3202 5.55E+08 3756 10.15

356 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3133 3133 2877 4.81E+08 3756 9.07

357 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3670 3670 2480 4.78E+08 2049 7.78

358 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 10 10 -3159 3159 2023 5.08E+08 2049 6.85

359 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3238 3238 3460 6.30E+08 1854 15.35

360 21 21 3 Sever Plate 12/4/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 21 NEST3-21_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2970 2970 2717 4.04E+08 1805 4.96

121 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -7668 7668 5406 1.26E+09 1220 6.52

122 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -4887 4887 3899 8.75E+08 1366 7.73

123 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -4298 4298 4754 8.42E+08 1073 11.27

124 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -5202 5202 4945 8.93E+08 1073 6.57

125 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -4053 4053 4156 9.07E+08 1073 11.99

126 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -3142 3142 2364 5.93E+08 1073 7.06

127 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2928 2928 3373 7.07E+08 2146 6.42

128 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -2599 2599 2124 4.88E+08 1220 8.88

129 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2607 2607 3329 7.52E+08 2146 8.88

130 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1996 1996 2579 4.70E+08 1366 5.85

131 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -2961 2961 3971 6.21E+08 6146 7.03

132 4R 4 1 Monolithic 12/12/2013 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4R NESr1-04_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -3081 3081 2211 4.38E+08 2195 3.54

85 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5489 5489 4484 1.58E+09 1073 21.08

86 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 2 2 -4654 4654 4574 1.24E+09 927 23.97

87 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4120 4120 4468 1.51E+09 1171 19.35

88 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3954 3954 4588 1.18E+09 1756 13.47

89 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3700 3700 3780 1.52E+09 927 30.77

90 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3549 3549 3997 1.26E+09 927 22.26

91 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3478 3478 3637 1.41E+09 3171 21.34

92 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3203 3203 3728 1.13E+09 3610 11.14

93 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3554 3554 3851 1.37E+09 2927 17.39

94 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2503 2503 4468 1.14E+09 2927 13.44

95 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3783 3783 3646 9.22E+08 5366 6.41

96 2R 2 1 Monolithic 12/16/2013 1 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2R NESr1-02_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2536 2536 2169 6.90E+08 1610 11.3

409 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -2642 2642 3324 2.10E+08 585 1.81

410 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -1810 1810 3619 2.05E+08 585 2.54

411 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -1203 1203 2871 1.61E+08 488 2.46

412 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -1595 1595 3058 2.27E+08 488 2.49

413 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -2024 2024 2296 1.76E+08 634 2.22

414 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -2139 2139 2354 2.12E+08 439 3.24

415 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2272 2272 1723 1.82E+08 634 3.95

416 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -2492 2492 1218 1.59E+08 634 2.46

417 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2134 2134 1256 1.61E+08 488 2.05

418 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1681 1681 1275 1.31E+08 488 2.27

419 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -1660 1660 1676 1.44E+08 1463 1.89

420 26 26 3 Sever Plate 12/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 26 NEST3-26_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1404 1404 1435 1.09E+08 1902 1.29

217 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 1 1 -4947 4947 6354 9.50E+08 1122 10.84

218 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5027 5027 5308 9.81E+08 1122 17.6

219 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4901 4901 3667 1.20E+09 488 13.7

220 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4255 4255 3672 8.59E+08 537 10.01

221 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3319 3319 2484 9.89E+08 1122 19.83

222 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3718 3718 3075 8.56E+08 1122 12.28

223 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3326 3326 2819 8.33E+08 878 11.27

224 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3260 3260 2751 7.91E+08 976 12.04

225 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3080 3080 3320 7.47E+08 1122 7.25

226 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2604 2604 3242 7.31E+08 1122 16.29

227 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3821 3821 3818 8.73E+08 5171 8.47

228 10R 10 1 Monolithic 1/16/2014 1 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10R NESTr1-10_1048 - Ch 12 12 -3107 3107 2284 6.58E+08 537 15.64

193 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 1 1 -6681 6681 6966 1.36E+09 1756 12.68

194 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 2 2 -4445 4445 5701 9.22E+08 1951 8.6

195 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4896 4896 6589 1.02E+09 1171 12.44

196 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3521 3521 3957 8.98E+08 1951 8.83

197 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 5 5 -4107 4107 4216 9.12E+08 1951 11.25
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

410 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

198 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 6 6 -4106 4106 3312 7.00E+08 1171 10.44

199 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3243 3243 3085 8.64E+08 1171 9.22

200 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3134 3134 3353 6.89E+08 1756 8.61

201 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3136 3136 4757 8.12E+08 1317 5.59

202 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2291 2291 2296 4.79E+08 1366 7.92

203 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2812 2812 2803 6.32E+08 976 5.64

204 9R 9 1 Monolithic 1/23/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9R NESTr1-09_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2735 2735 2347 4.56E+08 878 4.71

553 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 1 1 -3298 3298 5055 5.33E+08 976 8.39

557 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 2 2 -2883 2883 4536 4.74E+08 2439 7.84

558 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4094 4094 3978 5.04E+08 2439 8.37

559 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 1/0/1900 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3421 3421 3674 3.99E+08 976 5

560 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 1/0/1900 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 5 5 -4355 4355 2953 4.46E+08 3366 5.05

561 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 1/0/1900 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2839 2839 1513 3.26E+08 3317 5.04

562 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 1/0/1900 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2919 2919 2236 3.63E+08 3561 6.63

563 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 1/0/1900 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2360 2360 2034 2.57E+08 2976 3.73

564 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 1/0/1900 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 9 9 -1601 1601 2670 2.97E+08 3268 7.97

554 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1636 1636 2276 2.83E+08 3561 4.23

555 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2259 2259 2529 2.53E+08 4976 1.88

556 28 28 3 Sever Plate 1/24/2014 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 0 1 28 NEST3-28_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2348 2348 2210 2.81E+08 4098 3.8

373 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -5017 5017 4630 6.69E+08 4293 5.5

374 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -6056 6056 3562 5.89E+08 2829 3.7

375 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -3179 3179 4541 4.81E+08 4341 2.38

376 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -2533 2533 3924 4.72E+08 4000 4.39

377 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -2982 2982 3384 4.57E+08 3024 3.61

378 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -2798 2798 3078 3.62E+08 4146 2.14

379 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2613 2613 3486 4.08E+08 3805 6.06

380 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -2113 2113 2280 3.22E+08 2829 3.27

381 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2564 2564 2028 3.09E+08 3805 3.12

382 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -2296 2296 2977 3.97E+08 3951 3.68

383 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -2778 2778 2079 3.64E+08 2146 5.16

384 23 23 3 Sever Plate 4/18/2014 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 23 NEST3-23_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -2802 2802 1898 3.81E+08 4634 3.28

385 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -3214 3214 2993 6.34E+08 1171 10.04

386 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -6845 6845 3548 7.97E+08 1171 8.57

387 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -3959 3959 3805 7.17E+08 1171 9.92

388 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -3112 3112 3420 6.58E+08 1171 9.62

389 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -2578 2578 3579 5.73E+08 3415 6.28

390 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -2696 2696 3469 5.88E+08 1171 6.7

391 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2513 2513 3666 5.55E+08 341 9.39

392 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -2085 2085 3325 4.49E+08 341 9.32

393 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2768 2768 3323 4.98E+08 2098 7.91

394 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -2032 2032 2321 4.33E+08 2098 8.55

395 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -2211 2211 2482 4.04E+08 1902 6.16

396 24 24 3 Sever Plate 4/22/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 24 NEST3-24_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -2952 2952 3371 4.23E+08 1463 5.3

397 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -2283 2283 2154 2.30E+08 1171 2.53

398 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -1676 1676 2357 2.22E+08 1171 2.58

399 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -1631 1631 2580 2.59E+08 2244 3.36

400 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -1486 1486 1931 2.17E+08 3317 2.47

401 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -1345 1345 1997 2.24E+08 341 2.93

402 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -1423 1423 2007 2.05E+08 341 2.9

403 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2586 2586 1525 1.72E+08 341 2.69

404 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -1861 1861 1358 1.72E+08 3220 2.95

405 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -1419 1419 1234 1.54E+08 488 2.46

406 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1189 1189 1171 1.64E+08 2244 2.92

407 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -1351 1351 1370 1.72E+08 1902 1.95

408 25 25 3 Sever Plate 6/10/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 25 NEST3-25_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1422 1422 1495 1.46E+08 293 1.74

541 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -4430 4430 4082 5.11E+08 2195 4.3

545 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -4223 4223 3677 4.80E+08 634 2.83

546 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -2523 2523 3519 3.94E+08 2000 3.97

547 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -2359 2359 1968 2.79E+08 1220 2.41

548 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -3335 3335 2592 3.18E+08 2244 3.44

549 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -1873 1873 2442 1.99E+08 683 3.56

550 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2182 2182 1972 2.20E+08 683 4.34

551 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -1476 1476 1302 1.43E+08 683 2.53

552 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -1474 1474 1272 1.84E+08 1220 2.71

542 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1778 1778 1306 1.60E+08 1854 1.94

543 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -1784 1784 1608 1.56E+08 1073 2.62

544 27 27 3 Sever Plate 6/11/2014 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 27 NEST3-27_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1953 1953 1443 1.89E+08 1854 2.9

481 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -8779 8779 7265 1.45E+09 976 15.79

482 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -10529 10529 6415 1.50E+09 976 16.44

483 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -5423 5423 6436 1.23E+09 1512 16.62

484 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4780 4780 8189 1.35E+09 976 12.98

485 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3575 3575 6735 1.04E+09 3805 13

486 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3368 3368 5283 9.02E+08 3805 10.58

487 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3760 3760 3550 8.93E+08 1512 13.13

488 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2996 2996 3452 7.66E+08 1512 14.58

489 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -4044 4044 3479 8.38E+08 3561 12.51

490 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -3619 3619 2564 8.79E+08 1512 12.11
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

411 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

491 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2724 2724 3735 8.90E+08 195 12.24

492 A05 17 4 Acoustic Foam 8/20/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A05 NEST05-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2828 2828 2566 8.48E+08 195 12.05

433 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -7487 7487 4522 1.26E+09 780 7.98

434 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -7280 7280 5163 1.03E+09 537 6.38

435 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -6210 6210 4261 1.05E+09 780 9.41

436 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4581 4581 4729 9.22E+08 1756 6.98

437 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -4159 4159 3009 9.56E+08 1951 12.4

438 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -3135 3135 4721 7.53E+08 585 9.05

439 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3846 3846 2457 7.48E+08 1463 6.41

440 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2639 2639 2683 5.66E+08 2000 7.43

441 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2806 2806 2404 6.98E+08 2098 5.33

442 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -2623 2623 2533 5.97E+08 1317 7.55

443 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -2591 2591 2063 5.22E+08 2195 10.06

444 A10 12 4 Acoustic Foam 8/21/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A10 NEST10-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2476 2476 2741 5.98E+08 2195 11.77

421 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -3636 3636 2689 6.71E+08 2000 14.36

422 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -3829 3829 3375 6.07E+08 2049 9.22

423 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -4292 4292 3904 8.29E+08 2049 17.02

424 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -4054 4054 4127 5.69E+08 1951 11.95

425 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -3150 3150 3532 6.52E+08 1951 21.71

426 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -2257 2257 3151 4.38E+08 1951 6.24

427 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2545 2545 2418 4.23E+08 1951 10.52

428 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -2251 2251 2337 3.81E+08 1951 13.63

429 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2497 2497 1780 3.63E+08 1951 12.85

430 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -2314 2314 1666 3.10E+08 1902 8.16

431 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -2260 2260 2150 3.93E+08 1707 9.52

432 A01 8 4 Acoustic Foam 8/25/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A01 NEST01-G4_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -2022 2022 2066 3.87E+08 1902 9.73

505 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5961 5961 4014 1.29E+09 927 13.41

506 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -6894 6894 4842 1.73E+09 927 8.52

507 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -7264 7264 5042 1.73E+09 1024 11.49

508 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3611 3611 3727 1.28E+09 1171 12.85

509 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -4042 4042 3265 1.20E+09 829 14.99

510 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -4088 4088 4342 1.64E+09 829 29.18

511 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -3683 3683 3974 1.25E+09 927 13.78

512 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -3402 3402 3493 1.32E+09 927 20.19

513 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -3018 3018 3197 1.01E+09 829 13.08

514 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -4250 4250 5543 1.70E+09 829 18.45

515 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -3530 3530 4736 1.23E+09 1317 8.57

516 A07 18 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 A07 NEST07-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -3890 3890 3132 1.18E+09 1415 13.51

517 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -3600 3600 3330 8.86E+08 829 15.7

518 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -4699 4699 3039 7.36E+08 1220 11.61

519 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4118 4118 3421 8.09E+08 1659 16.75

520 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3125 3125 3163 6.55E+08 829 11.46

521 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -3536 3536 2745 6.19E+08 829 10.42

522 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2684 2684 2753 5.58E+08 829 15.66

523 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -1635 1635 1865 5.25E+08 439 23.14

524 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2381 2381 1536 4.28E+08 439 22.74

525 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -1881 1881 2360 4.55E+08 829 14.06

526 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1592 1592 1739 3.54E+08 537 7.7

527 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1660 1660 2017 4.09E+08 829 11.86

528 A08 11 4 Acoustic Foam 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 A08 NEST08-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -1860 1860 2070 4.84E+08 1854 10.39

457 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -4998 4998 2418 9.11E+08 1415 17.04

458 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -6685 6685 4698 9.37E+08 1220 5.63

459 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -3077 3077 4493 1.06E+09 1073 12.54

460 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -3033 3033 3841 8.55E+08 1073 9.12

461 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -3713 3713 3234 9.12E+08 1073 14.19

462 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -2919 2919 2505 5.77E+08 1415 10.28

463 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2775 2775 2590 6.97E+08 1463 8.66

464 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -2360 2360 2622 5.57E+08 5171 6.57

465 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -2728 2728 2563 6.23E+08 1415 8.75

466 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1944 1944 2080 4.73E+08 1512 5.42

467 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -2606 2606 3567 5.05E+08 6732 2.6

468 A03 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 8/27/2014 2 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 A03 NEST03-G4_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1532 1532 1583 4.21E+08 3463 3.81

469 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -3420 3420 4613 5.77E+08 2000 8.48

470 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -3706 3706 4035 6.85E+08 1951 8.46

471 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3757 3757 3197 6.56E+08 1902 10.31

472 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -3922 3922 3231 6.11E+08 634 8.21

473 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2960 2960 2598 4.76E+08 1951 7.34

474 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2574 2574 1913 4.69E+08 1902 7.46

475 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -1985 1985 1900 3.12E+08 1902 7.71

476 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -2113 2113 1763 2.97E+08 537 6.84

477 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -1462 1462 1300 2.61E+08 1902 4.17

478 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1360 1360 1376 2.26E+08 1902 6.11

479 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1135 1135 1473 2.33E+08 1171 4.5

480 A04 P1 4 Acoustic Foam 9/2/2014 3 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A04 NEST04-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -1238 1238 1860 3.11E+08 1805 7.1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

412 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

493 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -7159 7159 6109 2.45E+09 927 17.78

494 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -3887 3887 5178 1.87E+09 341 19.74

495 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -4031 4031 4334 2.15E+09 1024 19.81

496 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4156 4156 5574 2.47E+09 2195 18.52

497 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -6442 6442 6108 2.51E+09 1415 29.51

498 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -5289 5289 4719 2.20E+09 829 29.09

499 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -5161 5161 5804 2.33E+09 927 16.89

500 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -6008 6008 6249 2.97E+09 1902 21.91

501 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -4392 4392 5517 2.68E+09 1317 14.54

502 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -4134 4134 4617 2.34E+09 732 19.77

503 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -4308 4308 4536 1.88E+09 1902 21.61

504 A06 17 4 Acoustic Foam 9/3/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A06 NEST06-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -6155 6155 5958 2.65E+09 1902 16.72

529 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 1 1 -5186 5186 4761 9.44E+08 976 22.74

530 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 2 2 -5980 5980 3560 8.35E+08 976 22.51

531 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 3 3 -3817 3817 4198 7.63E+08 976 21.34

532 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 4 4 -4562 4562 4280 8.13E+08 976 19.81

533 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 5 5 -2682 2682 2826 5.54E+08 976 13.09

534 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 6 6 -2590 2590 3681 5.45E+08 976 13.62

535 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 7 7 -2261 2261 2569 3.79E+08 390 5.68

536 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 8 8 -1925 1925 2688 4.03E+08 976 5.51

537 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 9 9 -2268 2268 1771 3.24E+08 488 11.32

538 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 10 10 -1909 1909 2316 3.64E+08 488 13.09

539 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 11 11 -1963 1963 2432 4.12E+08 341 12.6

540 A09 11 4 Acoustic Foam 9/4/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A09 NEST09-G4_1048 - Ch 12 12 -2011 2011 1693 3.72E+08 341 11.33

445 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 1 1 -3884 3884 2397 4.55E+08 1220 6.88

446 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 2 2 -4328 4328 2360 4.46E+08 1220 4.35

447 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 3 3 -3099 3099 2999 4.65E+08 1220 6.46

448 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 4 4 -3064 3064 2251 4.61E+08 1220 5.14

449 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 5 5 -2090 2090 2588 3.31E+08 780 5.42

450 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 6 6 -2238 2238 2620 4.06E+08 732 7.03

451 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 7 7 -2653 2653 2106 3.11E+08 3122 4.57

452 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 8 8 -1952 1952 1940 2.62E+08 3512 2.92

453 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 9 9 -1656 1656 1321 2.19E+08 4098 1.72

454 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 10 10 -1470 1470 1253 1.91E+08 3512 2.71

455 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 11 11 -1399 1399 1383 2.21E+08 780 3.3

456 A02 8 4 Acoustic Foam 9/5/2014 2 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 A02 NEST02-G4_Time1048 - Ch 12 12 -1341 1341 1108 1.90E+08 2098 3.39
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

413 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Freq Break Max

c Frequency Break 

Point Max

Pred Formula 

Frequency Break 

Point Max

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - 

Thick

LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced LSC Sever Debonded 

Accel

0-Degree

Variable Maximum Frequency Break Point 1 3569 2857.49 711.51 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Transformation log(Frequency Break Point Max) 2 1829 2402.73 -573.73 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Table SRS Preliminary Parameters 3 2235 2401.60 -166.60 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Model File 150108 1436 Max FB Dist3, TypeThick, Dist x Damp split-plot.jrp 4 3956 2558.07 1397.93 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Excluded Values Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 2948 2602.99 345.01 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Reason for Exclusions 6 1972 2268.39 -296.39 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

7 2205 2857.49 -652.49 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Model Baseline analysis Exp( 8 3837 2402.73 1434.27 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

7.47667461668358 + 0.256726082283925 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 9 2247 2401.60 -154.60 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 10 4232 2558.07 1673.93 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, -0.071171881273597, 11 2923 2602.99 320.01 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3, -0.132292944311272, 12 4148 2268.39 1879.61 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Al Honey - 1, 0.0876199515198583, 13 1265 2199.69 -934.69 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.0130949295614228, 14 2802 1895.69 906.31 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.128939803626434, 15 2145 1942.01 202.99 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

. 16 1570 2120.06 -550.06 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

) + Match( :Acoustic Damped, 17 1695 2211.03 -516.03 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

0, 0.208717894264659, 18 1651 1974.82 -323.82 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

1, -0.208717894264659, 19 2869 2199.69 669.31 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

. 20 940 1895.69 -955.69 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * Match( :Acoustic Damped, 21 3474 1942.01 1531.99 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

0, -0.102207869493011, 22 3350 2120.06 1229.94 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

1, 0.102207869493011, 23 3368 2211.03 1156.97 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

. 24 3191 1974.82 1216.18 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

) + ((((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (:Distance from LSC - 39)) / 30) * 25 1676 2199.69 -523.69 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

0.0279313603300628 + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 26 2252 1895.69 356.31 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 27 1641 1942.01 -301.01 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.0761703094306936, 28 1574 2120.06 -546.06 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Monolithic - 0.3, 0.0659903940637854, 29 1278 2211.03 -933.03 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Al Honey - 1, -0.0510118941049901, 30 2593 1974.82 618.18 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Rohacell - 1, -0.105802245822947, 31 2644 2199.69 444.31 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0146534364334584, 32 2587 1895.69 691.31 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

. 33 2519 1942.01 576.99 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

) + ((((((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (:Distance from LSC - 39)) / 30) * ( 34 1952 2120.06 -168.06 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

:Distance from LSC - 39)) / 30) * -0.284608051208915 35 1989 2211.03 -222.03 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

) 36 1980 1974.82 5.18 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

43 1994 2199.69 -205.69 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

44 2440 1895.69 544.31 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

45 2051 1942.01 108.99 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

46 2492 2120.06 371.94 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

414 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Table of Estimates

Average of Pred Formula Frequency Break Point Max Distance from LSC

47 3307 2211.03 1095.97 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Type - Thick Type Panel Thickness Acoustic Damped 9 21 33 45 57 69

48 1876 1974.82 -98.82 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Al Honey - 1 Al Honey 1 0 2927.9 2398.1 2334.9 2422.5 2401.1 2038.2 61 2594 2090.44 503.56 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Al Honey - 1 Al Honey 1 1 1572.1 1397.4 1476.4 1662.4 1788.1 1647.2 62 1406 1794.22 -388.22 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 Homogeneous 0.187 0 2857.5 2402.7 2401.6 2558.1 2603.0 2268.4 63 2022 1830.59 191.41 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 Homogeneous 0.187 1 1534.3 1400.1 1518.6 1755.4 1938.4 1833.2 64 2239 1990.30 248.70 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 Monolithic 0.2 0 2199.7 1895.7 1942.0 2120.1 2211.0 1974.8 65 3655 2067.27 1587.73 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 Monolithic 0.3 0 2090.4 1794.2 1830.6 1990.3 2067.3 1838.9 66 3039 1838.92 1200.08 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 Monolithic 0.3 1 1122.5 1045.5 1157.6 1365.8 1539.5 1486.1 49 1756 2090.44 -334.44 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

Rohacell - 1 Rohacell 1 0 2796.5 2240.8 2134.4 2166.5 2100.9 1744.7 50 1899 1794.22 104.78 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

Rohacell - 1 Rohacell 1 1 1501.6 1305.7 1349.7 1486.7 1564.5 1410.0 51 1832 1830.59 1.41 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

52 1466 1990.30 -524.30 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

53 1643 2067.27 -424.27 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

54 2487 1838.92 648.08 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

67 2631 2199.69 431.31 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

68 3351 1895.69 1455.31 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

69 3209 1942.01 1266.99 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Aluminum 10 

gpf Undamped, 

10"

70 2767 2120.06 646.94 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

2790.5 71 3087 2211.03 875.97 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Al Honey - 1 Al Honey 1 0 105% 86% 84% 87% 86% 73% 72 2952 1974.82 977.18 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Al Honey - 1 Al Honey 1 1 56% 50% 53% 60% 64% 59% 73 2560 2199.69 360.31 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Aluminum - 0.187 Homogeneous 0.187 0 102% 86% 86% 92% 93% 81% 74 2016 1895.69 120.31 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Aluminum - 0.187 Homogeneous 0.187 1 55% 50% 54% 63% 69% 66% 75 1372 1942.01 -570.01 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Monolithic - 0.2 Monolithic 0.2 0 79% 68% 70% 76% 79% 71% 76 1696 2120.06 -424.06 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Monolithic - 0.3 Monolithic 0.3 0 75% 64% 66% 71% 74% 66% 77 1885 2211.03 -326.03 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Monolithic - 0.3 Monolithic 0.3 1 40% 37% 41% 49% 55% 53% 78 2031 1974.82 56.18 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

Rohacell - 1 Rohacell 1 0 100% 80% 76% 78% 75% 63% 79 2500 2199.69 300.31 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Rohacell - 1 Rohacell 1 1 54% 47% 48% 53% 56% 51% 80 1825 1895.69 -70.69 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

81 1089 1942.01 -853.01 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

82 1651 2120.06 -469.06 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

83 2354 2211.03 142.97 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

84 2303 1974.82 328.18 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

85 2759 2090.44 668.56 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

86 1495 1794.22 -299.22 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

87 1476 1830.59 -354.59 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

88 2056 1990.30 65.70 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% UpperPct of TotalStd Dev 89 2142 2067.27 74.73 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Panel No 0.1097201 0.007672 0.0156711 -0.023043 0.038387 6.1% 0.08759 0.01 90 2208 1838.92 369.08 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Test No 0.6872973 0.0480584 0.0183314 0.0121296 0.083987 38.2% 0.219222 97 1707 2090.44 -383.44 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Residual 0.0699238 0.0067129 0.0584288 0.085199 55.6% 0.264431 98 1252 1794.22 -542.22 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Total 0.1256542 0.016574 0.0985842 0.165699 100.0% 0.354477 99 945 1830.59 -885.59 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

100 1874 1990.30 -116.30 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

101 1917 2067.27 -150.27 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

102 2495 1838.92 656.08 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

109 3060 2199.69 860.31 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

Alternate Model Simple T/B fixed var Exp( 110 2288 1895.69 392.31 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

150129 1458 Max FB Dist3, Damp split-plot.jrp 7.4764533806607 + 0.176312424977772 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 111 2644 1942.01 701.99 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

Match( :Acoustic Damped, "0", 0.193963571811882, "1", -0.193963571811882, . ) + 112 1613 2120.06 -507.06 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 113 2007 2211.03 -204.03 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

0.0279313603300806) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC 114 2395 1974.82 420.18 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

 - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * -0.284608051208917)) 115 2458 2927.91 -469.91 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

) 116 2587 2398.12 188.88 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

117 2061 2334.86 -273.86 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

118 3128 2422.50 705.50 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

119 3210 2401.13 808.87 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

120 1778 2038.24 -260.24 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

121 2957 2796.49 160.51 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

122 1719 2240.82 -521.82 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

123 1701 2134.42 -433.42 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

124 1930 2166.53 -236.53 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

125 1940 2100.87 -160.87 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

126 1533 1744.70 -211.70 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

127 4158 2796.49 1361.51 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

128 2016 2240.82 -224.82 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

129 2103 2134.42 -31.42 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

130 2369 2166.53 202.47 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

131 1910 2100.87 -190.87 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

132 1636 1744.70 -108.70 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

415 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

133 2923 2927.91 -4.91 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

134 1198 2398.12 -1200.12 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

135 2714 2334.86 379.14 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

136 2281 2422.50 -141.50 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

137 2145 2401.13 -256.13 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

138 1799 2038.24 -239.24 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

139 3771 2927.91 843.09 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

140 2650 2398.12 251.88 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

141 2145 2334.86 -189.86 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

142 2577 2422.50 154.50 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

143 2494 2401.13 92.87 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

144 1735 2038.24 -303.24 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

145 2026 2796.49 -770.49 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

146 1690 2240.82 -550.82 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

147 1704 2134.42 -430.42 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

148 1858 2166.53 -308.53 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

149 1911 2100.87 -189.87 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

150 1593 1744.70 -151.70 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

151 3152 2927.91 224.09 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

152 1653 2398.12 -745.12 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

153 2324 2334.86 -10.86 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

154 3379 2422.50 956.50 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

155 2809 2401.13 407.87 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

156 1934 2038.24 -104.24 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

157 2447 2796.49 -349.49 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

158 2331 2240.82 90.18 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

159 2282 2134.42 147.58 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

160 2169 2166.53 2.47 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

161 1924 2100.87 -176.87 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

162 1701 1744.70 -43.70 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

163 3281 2927.91 353.09 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

164 3250 2398.12 851.88 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

165 3408 2334.86 1073.14 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

166 3440 2422.50 1017.50 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

167 3184 2401.13 782.87 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

168 3606 2038.24 1567.76 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

169 6320 2796.49 3523.51 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

170 3656 2240.82 1415.18 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

171 3286 2134.42 1151.58 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

172 2920 2166.53 753.47 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

173 2640 2100.87 539.13 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

174 1597 1744.70 -147.70 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

181 1998 2796.49 -798.49 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

182 2253 2240.82 12.18 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

183 2093 2134.42 -41.42 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

184 1844 2166.53 -322.53 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

185 1865 2100.87 -235.87 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

186 1956 1744.70 211.30 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

175 2878 2927.91 -49.91 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

176 1761 2398.12 -637.12 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

177 2225 2334.86 -109.86 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

178 2234 2422.50 -188.50 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

179 2393 2401.13 -8.13 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

180 1948 2038.24 -90.24 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

55 3141 2090.44 1050.56 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

56 2708 1794.22 913.78 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

57 1576 1830.59 -254.59 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

58 2768 1990.30 777.70 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

59 2623 2067.27 555.73 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

60 2685 1838.92 846.08 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

37 3355 2199.69 1155.31 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

38 2284 1895.69 388.31 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

39 1912 1942.01 -30.01 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

40 3203 2120.06 1082.94 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

41 3568 2211.03 1356.97 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

42 2231 1974.82 256.18 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

205 3300 2796.49 503.51 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

206 2872 2240.82 631.18 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

207 3511 2134.42 1376.58 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

208 2982 2166.53 815.47 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

209 3109 2100.87 1008.13 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

210 1846 1744.70 101.30 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

103 843 2199.69 -1356.69 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

104 744 1895.69 -1151.69 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

105 1016 1942.01 -926.01 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

106 1712 2120.06 -408.06 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

107 682 2211.03 -1529.03 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

108 803 1974.82 -1171.82 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

91 2143 2090.44 52.56 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

92 2080 1794.22 285.78 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

93 1241 1830.59 -589.59 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

94 2114 1990.30 123.70 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

95 1111 2067.27 -956.27 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

96 1055 1838.92 -783.92 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

416 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

187 3876 2927.91 948.09 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

188 2854 2398.12 455.88 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

189 2969 2334.86 634.14 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

190 3376 2422.50 953.50 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

191 3700 2401.13 1298.87 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

192 2555 2038.24 516.76 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

193 2449 2927.91 -478.91 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

194 1318 2398.12 -1080.12 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

195 2007 2334.86 -327.86 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

196 2005 2422.50 -417.50 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

197 2205 2401.13 -196.13 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

198 1588 2038.24 -450.24 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

199 3370 2927.91 442.09 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

200 2108 2398.12 -290.12 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

201 3100 2334.86 765.14 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

202 2810 2422.50 387.50 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

203 2249 2401.13 -152.13 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

204 1761 2038.24 -277.24 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

235 5423 2796.49 2626.51 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

236 2095 2240.82 -145.82 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

237 2208 2134.42 73.58 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

238 1906 2166.53 -260.53 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

239 1673 2100.87 -427.87 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

240 1418 1744.70 -326.70 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

265 3244 1572.14 1671.86 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

266 2816 1397.38 1418.62 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

267 1898 1476.44 421.56 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

268 2490 1662.37 827.63 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

269 1827 1788.10 38.90 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

270 2106 1647.18 458.82 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

211 1823 2090.44 -267.44 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

212 1837 1794.22 42.78 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

213 1816 1830.59 -14.59 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

214 1931 1990.30 -59.30 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

215 1910 2067.27 -157.27 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

216 1621 1838.92 -217.92 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

247 771 1501.57 -730.57 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

248 2786 1305.72 1480.28 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

249 1418 1349.69 68.31 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

250 1713 1486.72 226.28 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

251 1341 1564.50 -223.50 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

252 1494 1409.96 84.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

253 1670 2927.91 -1257.91 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

254 1387 2398.12 -1011.12 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

255 1518 2334.86 -816.86 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

256 1498 2422.50 -924.50 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

257 945 2401.13 -1456.13 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

258 1084 2038.24 -954.24 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

223 2064 2857.49 -793.49 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

224 2320 2402.73 -82.73 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

225 1962 2401.60 -439.60 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

226 2055 2558.07 -503.07 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

227 1132 2602.99 -1470.99 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

228 1944 2268.39 -324.39 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

229 1789 1534.33 254.67 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

230 1550 1400.07 149.93 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

231 1716 1518.64 197.36 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

232 1611 1755.40 -144.40 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

233 1888 1938.42 -50.42 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

234 1562 1833.18 -271.18 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

241 518 1501.57 -983.57 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

242 414 1305.72 -891.72 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

243 1376 1349.69 26.31 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

244 1611 1486.72 124.28 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

245 1250 1564.50 -314.50 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

246 1525 1409.96 115.04 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

259 795 1572.14 -777.14 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

260 1702 1397.38 304.62 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

261 1343 1476.44 -133.44 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

262 1487 1662.37 -175.37 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

263 1473 1788.10 -315.10 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

264 1349 1647.18 -298.18 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

217 1938 1122.46 815.54 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

218 1032 1045.49 -13.49 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

219 1000 1157.56 -157.56 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

220 1580 1365.79 214.21 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

221 1411 1539.48 -128.48 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

222 1069 1486.10 -417.10 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

417 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Last Slope

c Last Slope Pred Formula 

Last Slope

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - 

Thick

LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced LSC Sever Debonded 

Accel

0-Degree

Variable Last Slope Tests 45 1 8.8 8.86 -0.06 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Transformation log(Last Slope) Panels 30 2 10.5 9.99 0.51 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Table SRS Preliminary Parameters 3 9.9 9.78 0.12 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Model File 150108 1747 Last Slope Dist3, Dist x Sever split-plot.jrp 4 7.2 9.53 -2.33 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Excluded Values Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 7.9 10.58 -2.68 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Reason for Exclusions 6 18.4 15.32 3.08 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

7 9.5 8.86 0.64 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Model Baseline analysis Exp( 8 7.6 9.99 -2.39 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

2.39316377208557 + -0.185201911061676 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 9 9.2 9.78 -0.58 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Match( :Sever, "0", 0.133271932004697, "1", -0.133271932004697, . ) + (( 10 7.5 9.53 -2.03 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * Match( :Sever, 11 8 10.58 -2.58 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

0, -0.106188564068464, 12 7.6 15.32 -7.72 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

1, 0.106188564068464, 13 11.4 8.86 2.54 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

. 14 7.6 9.99 -2.39 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 15 10.7 9.78 0.92 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

0.195326659484799) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 16 15.4 9.53 5.87 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 0.352644069684689)) 17 13.4 10.58 2.82 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

) 18 23.5 15.32 8.18 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

19 6 8.86 -2.86 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

20 13.1 9.99 3.11 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

21 18 9.78 8.22 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

22 12.1 9.53 2.57 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

23 17.7 10.58 7.12 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

24 25.7 15.32 10.38 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

25 10.1 8.86 1.24 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

26 9 9.99 -0.99 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

27 9.1 9.78 -0.68 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

28 9.2 9.53 -0.33 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

29 16.7 10.58 6.12 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

30 17.9 15.32 2.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

31 6.6 8.86 -2.26 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

32 5.8 9.99 -4.19 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

33 5.9 9.78 -3.88 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

34 6.2 9.53 -3.33 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

35 6.3 10.58 -4.28 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

36 19.2 15.32 3.88 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

43 9.6 8.86 0.74 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

44 7.6 9.99 -2.39 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

45 10.2 9.78 0.42 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

46 7.9 9.53 -1.63 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Table of Estimates Average of Pred Formula Last Slope Distance from LSC 47 7 10.58 -3.58 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Sever 9 21 33 45 57 69 10 48 20.6 15.32 5.28 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

1 8.9 10.0 9.8 9.5 10.6 15.3 9.0 61 7.8 8.86 -1.06 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

0 14.3 14.8 13.3 11.9 12.2 16.2 62 9.5 9.99 -0.49 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

63 9.4 9.78 -0.38 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Severed 98% 111% 108% 106% 117% 170% 64 12.1 9.53 2.57 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Unsevered 158% 164% 148% 132% 135% 179% 65 6.9 10.58 -3.68 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

66 7 15.32 -8.32 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

49 9.5 8.86 0.64 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

50 7.6 9.99 -2.39 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

51 8.5 9.78 -1.28 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

52 14.2 9.53 4.67 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

53 11 10.58 0.42 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

54 16.3 15.32 0.98 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

67 7.4 8.86 -1.46 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

68 7.1 9.99 -2.89 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

69 7.7 9.78 -2.08 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

70 8.1 9.53 -1.43 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

71 7.6 10.58 -2.98 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

72 12.6 15.32 -2.72 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

73 7.2 8.86 -1.66 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

74 8.1 9.99 -1.89 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

75 7.6 9.78 -2.18 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

76 6.5 9.53 -3.03 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

77 5.9 10.58 -4.68 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

78 17.5 15.32 2.18 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0

79 7.4 8.86 -1.46 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

80 7.6 9.99 -2.39 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

81 8.8 9.78 -0.98 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

82 8 9.53 -1.53 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

83 6.1 10.58 -4.48 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

84 12.7 15.32 -2.62 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

85 10 8.86 1.14 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

86 10.6 9.99 0.61 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

87 14.3 9.78 4.52 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

418 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Variance Components 88 9.3 9.53 -0.23 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% Upper Pct of TotalStd Dev Random Effect Variance Component Component's Percent Share of Total Variance Standard Deviation of Effect's 

Component (transformed units) 89 10 10.58 -0.58 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Panel No 0.1097201 0.007672 0.015671 -0.023043 0.038387 6.1% 0.087589954 0.01 Panel-to-Panel 0.007672 6.1% 0.0875900 90 9.6 15.32 -5.72 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Test No 0.6872973 0.048058 0.018331 0.01213 0.083987 38.2% 0.219222262 Test-to-Test 0.0480584 38.2% 0.2192223 97 9.6 8.86 0.74 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Residual 0.069924 0.006713 0.058429 0.085199 55.6% 0.264431087 Within-Test 0.0699238 55.6% 0.2644311 98 10.6 9.99 0.61 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

Total 0.125654 0.016574 0.098584 0.165699 100.0% 0.354477362 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.1256542 100.0% 0.3544774 99 14.5 9.78 4.72 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

100 8.5 9.53 -1.03 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

101 8.9 10.58 -1.68 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

102 19.9 15.32 4.58 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

109 8.7 8.86 -0.16 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

110 9 9.99 -0.99 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

111 8.3 9.78 -1.48 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

112 10.8 9.53 1.27 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

113 8.5 10.58 -2.08 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

114 13.6 15.32 -1.72 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1

115 10 14.30 -4.30 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

116 7.7 14.81 -7.11 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

117 15.3 13.33 1.97 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

118 8.4 11.93 -3.53 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

119 7 12.16 -5.16 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

120 20.1 16.17 3.93 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

121 7.8 8.86 -1.06 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

122 10.9 9.99 0.91 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

123 10.6 9.78 0.82 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

124 10.7 9.53 1.17 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

125 10 10.58 -0.58 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

126 15.2 15.32 -0.12 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

127 7.6 8.86 -1.26 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

128 12 9.99 2.01 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

129 12.7 9.78 2.92 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

130 8.3 9.53 -1.23 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

131 9.9 10.58 -0.68 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

132 13.9 15.32 -1.42 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

133 6.5 8.86 -2.36 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

134 10.9 9.99 0.91 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

135 9.3 9.78 -0.48 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

136 10.2 9.53 0.67 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

137 10.6 10.58 0.02 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

138 16.8 15.32 1.48 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

139 6.2 8.86 -2.66 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

140 6.7 9.99 -3.29 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

141 9.8 9.78 0.02 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

142 8.5 9.53 -1.03 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

143 8.4 10.58 -2.18 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

144 15.7 15.32 0.38 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

145 9.7 8.86 0.84 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

146 12.1 9.99 2.11 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

147 13.2 9.78 3.42 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

148 11.2 9.53 1.67 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

149 11.8 10.58 1.22 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

150 15.6 15.32 0.28 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

151 8.6 8.86 -0.26 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

152 9.2 9.99 -0.79 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

153 13.6 9.78 3.82 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

154 8.7 9.53 -0.83 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

155 9.2 10.58 -1.38 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

156 15.6 15.32 0.28 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

157 9.7 8.86 0.84 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

158 10.1 9.99 0.11 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

159 11.8 9.78 2.02 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

160 11.2 9.53 1.67 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

161 15.8 10.58 5.22 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

162 13.3 15.32 -2.02 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

163 20.9 14.30 6.60 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

164 19.7 14.81 4.89 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

165 18.7 13.33 5.37 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

166 10 11.93 -1.93 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

167 22.6 12.16 10.44 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

168 8.1 16.17 -8.07 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1

169 8.9 8.86 0.04 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

170 11.3 9.99 1.31 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

171 13.6 9.78 3.82 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

172 13.8 9.53 4.27 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

173 21.5 10.58 10.92 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

174 19.5 15.32 4.18 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

181 17.1 14.30 2.80 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

182 15 14.81 0.19 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

183 17 13.33 3.67 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

184 19.6 11.93 7.67 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

185 21.4 12.16 9.24 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

186 16.2 16.17 0.03 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

175 8.8 8.86 -0.06 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

176 9.2 9.99 -0.79 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

177 13.7 9.78 3.92 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

178 11.5 9.53 1.97 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

179 10.8 10.58 0.22 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

180 15.2 15.32 -0.12 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

55 7.2 8.86 -1.66 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

56 7.9 9.99 -2.09 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

419 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

57 11.6 9.78 1.82 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

58 8.9 9.53 -0.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

59 7.3 10.58 -3.28 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

60 11.3 15.32 -4.02 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

37 28.3 8.86 19.44 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

38 8.9 9.99 -1.09 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

39 9.5 9.78 -0.28 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

40 17 9.53 7.47 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

41 5.8 10.58 -4.78 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

42 15.7 15.32 0.38 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1

205 12.8 8.86 3.94 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

206 8.2 9.99 -1.79 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

207 6.4 9.78 -3.38 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

208 7.9 9.53 -1.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

209 5.8 10.58 -4.78 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

210 14.5 15.32 -0.82 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1

103 15.4 14.30 1.10 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

104 15.7 14.81 0.89 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

105 13.7 13.33 0.37 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

106 8.6 11.93 -3.33 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

107 16.1 12.16 3.94 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

108 20.1 16.17 3.93 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1

91 7.1 8.86 -1.76 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

92 8.8 9.99 -1.19 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

93 11.9 9.78 2.12 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

94 8.3 9.53 -1.23 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

95 12.3 10.58 1.72 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

96 13.6 15.32 -1.72 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

187 10.8 14.30 -3.50 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

188 15.9 14.81 1.09 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

189 13.6 13.33 0.27 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

190 10.1 11.93 -1.83 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

191 10.1 12.16 -2.06 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

192 15.1 16.17 -1.07 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1

193 7.4 8.86 -1.46 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

194 11.2 9.99 1.21 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

195 10.9 9.78 1.12 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

196 12 9.53 2.47 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

197 10.4 10.58 -0.18 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

198 18.7 15.32 3.38 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

199 10.8 8.86 1.94 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

200 10 9.99 0.01 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

201 6.4 9.78 -3.38 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

202 7.4 9.53 -2.13 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

203 8.6 10.58 -1.98 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

204 17.5 15.32 2.18 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1

235 6.5 8.86 -2.36 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

236 12.7 9.99 2.71 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

237 11 9.78 1.22 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

238 14.1 9.53 4.57 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

239 14.8 10.58 4.22 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

240 22.2 15.32 6.88 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

265 5.8 8.86 -3.06 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

266 7.8 9.99 -2.19 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

267 7.9 9.78 -1.88 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

268 8.1 9.53 -1.43 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

269 9.4 10.58 -1.18 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

270 21 15.32 5.68 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

211 8.8 8.86 -0.06 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

212 12.4 9.99 2.41 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

213 14.1 9.78 4.32 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

214 11.9 9.53 2.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

215 10.5 10.58 -0.08 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

216 14.9 15.32 -0.42 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1

247 13.6 8.86 4.74 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

248 6.3 9.99 -3.69 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

249 11.5 9.78 1.72 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

250 7.6 9.53 -1.93 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

251 11.5 10.58 0.92 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

252 20.9 15.32 5.58 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1

253 10.8 8.86 1.94 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

254 10.5 9.99 0.51 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

255 10.4 9.78 0.62 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

256 8.6 9.53 -0.93 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

257 20.3 10.58 9.72 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

258 15.1 15.32 -0.22 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1

223 6.5 8.86 -2.36 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

224 7.5 9.99 -2.49 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

420 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

225 9.6 9.78 -0.18 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

226 8.4 9.53 -1.13 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

227 17.2 10.58 6.62 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

228 13.4 15.32 -1.92 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1

229 13.7 8.86 4.84 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

230 14 9.99 4.01 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

231 10.3 9.78 0.52 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

232 12.6 9.53 3.07 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

233 8.9 10.58 -1.68 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

234 11 15.32 -4.32 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

241 14.7 8.86 5.84 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

242 18.5 9.99 8.51 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

243 6.7 9.78 -3.08 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

244 6.9 9.53 -2.63 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

245 14.5 10.58 3.92 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

246 19 15.32 3.68 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

259 15.2 8.86 6.34 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

260 8.4 9.99 -1.59 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

261 9.1 9.78 -0.68 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

262 9.7 9.53 0.17 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

263 13 10.58 2.42 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

264 22.3 15.32 6.98 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1

217 9.3 8.86 0.44 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

218 14.2 9.99 4.21 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

219 15.3 9.78 5.52 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

220 11.1 9.53 1.57 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

221 10.9 10.58 0.32 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1

222 14.6 15.32 -0.72 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

421 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Max SRS Accel

c Max SRS 

Accel

Predicted Max 

SRS Accel

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - 

Thick

LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accel

0-Degree Aluminum LSC 

Plate

Variable Maximum SRS Acceleration Panels 30 1 17525 12626.38 4898.62 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(Max SRS Accel) Tests 45 2 11295 10582.45 712.55 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table SRS Preliminary Parameters 3 12561 9415.30 3145.70 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model File 150102 1652 All Data Max Plat - Max SRS Accel without Panel effect split-plot.jrp 4 10377 8892.48 1484.52 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Excluded Values Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 11293 8915.64 2377.36 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Reason for Exclusions 6 13285 9489.05 3795.95 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Row Labels 7 15170 13573.69 1596.31 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model Analysis without Panel random effect Exp( 6111.288661 8 14814 11674.44 3139.56 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

9.12264279357447 + -0.175906636393387 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 6273.074061 9 13014 10658.96 2355.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 6819.19555 10 15470 10330.81 5139.19 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.239841649170964, 6820.133545 11 14643 10629.06 4013.94 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3, -0.0259617976444534, 6835.476928 12 18641 11609.03 7031.97 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.114859502597656, 7237.927027 13 9605 14680.19 -5075.19 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.158934902223547, 7476.629249 14 15179 12448.42 2730.58 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.059914553294692, 7478.641002 15 8231 11205.67 -2974.67 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

. 7906.750199 16 8496 10707.84 -2211.84 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) + 0.0684974241978297 * ((:LSC Core Load - 16) / 6) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39 7941.09363 17 11554 10861.93 692.07 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) / 30) * Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 8129.716778 18 8579 11696.42 -3117.42 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.0946234438399386, 8155.226836 19 13601 14680.19 -1079.19 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.3, 0.0857940847197687, 8194.041037 20 10268 12448.42 -2180.42 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.0900791110938465, 8282.651386 21 10480 11205.67 -725.67 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.155745103509068, 8343.83921 22 7299 10707.84 -3408.84 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0654066860432069, 8408.638756 23 7107 10861.93 -3754.93 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

. 8605.332912 24 6856 11696.42 -4840.42 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:LSC Core Load - 16) / 6) * 8887.536961 25 12478 14680.19 -2202.19 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

0.0323247729199656) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC 8892.480736 26 15120 12448.42 2671.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

 - 39) / 30) * 0.186658985688534) 8915.64006 27 8685 11205.67 -2520.67 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) 8951.147975 28 8786 10707.84 -1921.84 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9232.445739 29 10497 10861.93 -364.93 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9415.299267 30 9672 11696.42 -2024.42 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9489.053832 31 13982 14680.19 -698.19 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9519.401173 32 12754 12448.42 305.58 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9593.520497 33 11777 11205.67 571.33 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9708.854758 34 10551 10707.84 -156.84 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9742.006049 35 11626 10861.93 764.07 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9754.35776 36 12599 11696.42 902.58 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

9874.421322 43 14368 14680.19 -312.19 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

10330.81128 44 11514 12448.42 -934.42 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

10582.44729 45 12570 11205.67 1364.33 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

10583.46675 46 11525 10707.84 817.16 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table of Estimates Average of Predicted Max SRS Accel Distance from LSC 10629.05852 47 12773 10861.93 1911.07 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Type - Thick LSC Core Load 9 21 33 45 57 69 10658.96036 48 12181 11696.42 484.58 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 10 12385.2 9754.4 8155.2 7237.9 6819.2 6820.1 10707.84345 61 11005 12205.30 -1200.30 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 22 13314.4 10760.9 9232.4 8408.6 8129.7 8343.8 10710.70225 62 8270 10583.47 -2313.47 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 10 12626.4 10582.4 9415.3 8892.5 8915.6 9489.1 10760.90066 63 8448 9742.01 -1294.01 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 22 13573.7 11674.4 10659.0 10330.8 10629.1 11609.0 10861.93196 64 9696 9519.40 176.60 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 10 14680.2 12448.4 11205.7 10707.8 10861.9 11696.4 10873.12717 65 9607 9874.42 -267.42 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 22 15781.6 13733.0 12685.8 12439.8 12949.4 14309.6 11205.66767 66 9069 10873.13 -1804.13 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 10 11353.5 9593.5 8605.3 8194.0 8282.7 8887.5 11353.48339 49 11499 11353.48 145.52 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 22 12205.3 10583.5 9742.0 9519.4 9874.4 10873.1 11609.03066 50 8646 9593.52 -947.52 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Rohacell - 1 10 12655.5 9708.9 7906.8 6835.5 6273.1 6111.3 11674.43996 51 9003 8605.33 397.67 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Rohacell - 1 22 13605.0 10710.7 8951.1 7941.1 7478.6 7476.6 11696.41939 52 8228 8194.04 33.96 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

10" Aluminum 10 gpf 12205.29539 53 7945 8282.65 -337.65 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

12413.58 12385.17378 54 9363 8887.54 475.46 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Al Honey - 1 10 100% 79% 66% 58% 55% 55% 12439.80315 67 13539 15781.59 -2242.59 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 22 107% 87% 74% 68% 65% 67% 12448.42058 68 16746 13732.96 3013.04 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 10 102% 85% 76% 72% 72% 76% 12626.38097 69 16265 12685.82 3579.18 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 22 109% 94% 86% 83% 86% 94% 12655.4846 70 13872 12439.80 1432.20 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 10 118% 100% 90% 86% 88% 94% 12685.81743 71 15586 12949.39 2636.61 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 22 127% 111% 102% 100% 104% 115% 12949.39114 72 17671 14309.55 3361.45 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 10 91% 77% 69% 66% 67% 72% 13314.38988 73 18254 15781.59 2472.41 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.3 22 98% 85% 78% 77% 80% 88% 13573.694 74 15930 13732.96 2197.04 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Rohacell - 1 10 102% 78% 64% 55% 51% 49% 13604.98118 75 11264 12685.82 -1421.82 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Rohacell - 1 22 110% 86% 72% 64% 60% 60% 13732.96126 76 10721 12439.80 -1718.80 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

14309.55011 77 13675 12949.39 725.61 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

14680.18596 78 13618 14309.55 -691.55 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

15781.58878 79 20354 15781.59 4572.41 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

(blank) 80 15695 13732.96 1962.04 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Grand Total 81 11437 12685.82 -1248.82 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

82 10996 12439.80 -1443.80 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

83 13602 12949.39 652.61 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

84 16139 14309.55 1829.45 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

85 15759 11353.48 4405.52 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

86 14657 9593.52 5063.48 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

87 11130 8605.33 2524.67 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

422 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Variance Components 88 9468 8194.04 1273.96 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% Upper Pct of 

Total Std Dev Random Effect Variance Component Component's Percent Share of Total Variance

Standard Deviation of Effect's 

Component (transformed units) 89 10158 8282.65 1875.35 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Panel No 0.01 Panel-to-Panel 90 10309 8887.54 1421.46 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Test No 2.150112 0.0573286 0.0139952 0.0298986 0.0847587 6825.5% 0.2394339 Test-to-Test 0.0573286 68.3% 0.2394339 97 9877 12205.30 -2328.30 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Residual 0.0266631 0.0025539 0.0222886 0.0324722 3174.5% 0.1632884 Within-Test 0.0266631 31.7% 0.1632884 98 9279 10583.47 -1304.47 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Total 0.0839917 0.0141497 0.0619319 0.1204256 10000.0% 0.2898132 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.0839917 100.0% 0.2898132 99 10512 9742.01 769.99 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

100 10884 9519.40 1364.60 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

101 9542 9874.42 -332.42 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

102 13631 10873.13 2757.87 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

109 22897 14680.19 8216.81 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Alternative Model Model including Panel random effect Exp( 110 18794 12448.42 6345.58 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Model does not converge 9.12610467618132 + -0.175906636393387 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 111 18405 11205.67 7199.33 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 112 12351 10707.84 1643.16 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.253322876785093, 113 11920 10861.93 1058.07 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3, -0.0585021378695135, 114 14080 11696.42 2383.58 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.117723733085097, 115 17035 12385.17 4649.83 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.12708844064221, 116 11602 9754.36 1847.64 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0499914348117271, 117 10434 8155.23 2278.77 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

. 118 8908 7237.93 1670.07 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

) + 0.0814198959674507 * ((:LSC Core Load - 16) / 6) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39 119 8097 6819.20 1277.80 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

) / 30) * Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 120 8439 6820.13 1618.87 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.0946234438399386, 121 14557 13604.98 952.02 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3, 0.0857940847197687, 122 9624 10710.70 -1086.70 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.0900791110938465, 123 8259 8951.15 -692.15 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.155745103509068, 124 6863 7941.09 -1078.09 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0654066860432069, 125 8240 7478.64 761.36 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

. 126 7624 7476.63 147.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:LSC Core Load - 16) / 6) * 127 11810 12655.48 -845.48 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.0323247729199656) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC 128 7534 9708.85 -2174.85 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

 - 39) / 30) * 0.186658985669625) 129 6283 7906.75 -1623.75 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) 130 4464 6835.48 -2371.48 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

131 5078 6273.07 -1195.07 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

132 5637 6111.29 -474.29 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

133 13588 13314.39 273.61 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

134 11460 10760.90 699.10 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

135 13169 9232.45 3936.55 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

136 8454 8408.64 45.36 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

137 9768 8129.72 1638.28 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

138 11453 8343.84 3109.16 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

139 16318 13314.39 3003.61 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

140 11694 10760.90 933.10 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

141 10038 9232.45 805.55 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

142 8181 8408.64 -227.64 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

143 8493 8129.72 363.28 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

144 9479 8343.84 1135.16 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

145 14050 13604.98 445.02 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

146 10589 10710.70 -121.70 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

147 9001 8951.15 49.85 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

148 7201 7941.09 -740.09 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

149 9232 7478.64 1753.36 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

150 9354 7476.63 1877.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

151 14466 12385.17 2080.83 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

152 11093 9754.36 1338.64 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

153 8921 8155.23 765.77 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

154 9639 7237.93 2401.07 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

155 9565 6819.20 2745.80 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

156 8747 6820.13 1926.87 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

157 10395 12655.48 -2260.48 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

158 6624 9708.85 -3084.85 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

159 5766 7906.75 -2140.75 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

160 4782 6835.48 -2053.48 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

161 5308 6273.07 -965.07 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

162 4303 6111.29 -1808.29 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

163 10742 12385.17 -1643.17 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

164 8435 9754.36 -1319.36 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

165 7950 8155.23 -205.23 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

166 7160 7237.93 -77.93 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

167 6428 6819.20 -391.20 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

168 6138 6820.13 -682.13 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

169 32442 13604.98 18837.02 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

170 17874 10710.70 7163.30 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

171 14719 8951.15 5767.85 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

172 8905 7941.09 963.91 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

173 7233 7478.64 -245.64 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

174 6167 7476.63 -1309.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

181 10707 12655.48 -1948.48 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

423 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

182 8661 9708.85 -1047.85 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

183 6811 7906.75 -1095.75 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

184 5007 6835.48 -1828.48 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

185 4924 6273.07 -1349.07 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

186 5014 6111.29 -1097.29 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

175 15533 13314.39 2218.61 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

176 10938 10760.90 177.10 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

177 10912 9232.45 1679.55 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

178 7992 8408.64 -416.64 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

179 8322 8129.72 192.28 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

180 10013 8343.84 1669.16 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

55 12188 12205.30 -17.30 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

56 12597 10583.47 2013.53 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

57 12111 9742.01 2368.99 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

58 11301 9519.40 1781.60 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

59 11004 9874.42 1129.58 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

60 15187 10873.13 4313.87 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

37 14498 15781.59 -1283.59 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

38 15403 13732.96 1670.04 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

39 13801 12685.82 1115.18 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

40 14176 12439.80 1736.20 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

41 14959 12949.39 2009.61 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

42 15046 14309.55 736.45 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

205 7476 13604.98 -6128.98 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

206 6938 10710.70 -3772.70 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

207 6832 8951.15 -2119.15 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

208 5689 7941.09 -2252.09 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

209 4816 7478.64 -2662.64 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

210 5860 7476.63 -1616.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

103 9328 14680.19 -5352.19 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

104 9291 12448.42 -3157.42 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

105 12158 11205.67 952.33 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

106 9621 10707.84 -1086.84 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

107 10153 10861.93 -708.93 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

108 16717 11696.42 5020.58 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

91 10921 12205.30 -1284.30 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

92 15926 10583.47 5342.53 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

93 13369 9742.01 3626.99 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

94 10124 9519.40 604.60 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

95 12541 9874.42 2666.58 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

96 13214 10873.13 2340.87 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

187 13582 12385.17 1196.83 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

188 11327 9754.36 1572.64 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

189 8538 8155.23 382.77 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

190 8628 7237.93 1390.07 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

191 7586 6819.20 766.80 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

192 9024 6820.13 2203.87 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

193 10702 13314.39 -2612.39 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

194 10450 10760.90 -310.90 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

195 8200 9232.45 -1032.45 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

196 7486 8408.64 -922.64 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

197 8366 8129.72 236.28 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

198 7389 8343.84 -954.84 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

199 6571 13314.39 -6743.39 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

200 4937 10760.90 -5823.90 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

201 4457 9232.45 -4775.45 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

202 3925 8408.64 -4483.64 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

203 3365 8129.72 -4764.72 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

204 4136 8343.84 -4207.84 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

235 28490 13604.98 14885.02 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

236 19259 10710.70 8548.30 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

237 14063 8951.15 5111.85 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

238 11892 7941.09 3950.91 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

239 10860 7478.64 3381.36 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

240 9224 7476.63 1747.37 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

265 15731 13314.39 2416.61 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

266 17244 10760.90 6483.10 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

267 12947 9232.45 3714.55 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

268 12470 8408.64 4061.36 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

269 12688 8129.72 4558.28 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

270 10113 8343.84 1769.16 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

211 8801 12205.30 -3404.30 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

212 12045 10583.47 1461.53 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

213 9947 9742.01 204.99 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

214 7338 9519.40 -2181.40 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

215 8401 9874.42 -1473.42 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

424 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

216 8715 10873.13 -2158.13 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

247 12017 13604.98 -1587.98 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

248 12631 10710.70 1920.30 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

249 12103 8951.15 3151.85 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

250 9114 7941.09 1172.91 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

251 9785 7478.64 2306.36 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

252 10422 7476.63 2945.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

253 12610 13314.39 -704.39 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

254 8942 10760.90 -1818.90 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

255 7914 9232.45 -1318.45 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

256 6133 8408.64 -2275.64 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

257 7057 8129.72 -1072.72 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

258 7789 8343.84 -554.84 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

223 9408 13573.69 -4165.69 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

224 10782 11674.44 -892.44 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

225 9279 10658.96 -1379.96 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

226 8970 10330.81 -1360.81 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

227 9392 10629.06 -1237.06 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

228 12381 11609.03 771.97 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

229 12017 13573.69 -1556.69 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

230 10233 11674.44 -1441.44 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

231 8206 10658.96 -2452.96 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

232 6336 10330.81 -3994.81 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

233 5420 10629.06 -5209.06 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

234 5809 11609.03 -5800.03 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

241 9028 13604.98 -4576.98 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

242 10150 10710.70 -560.70 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

243 9472 8951.15 520.85 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

244 10677 7941.09 2735.91 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

245 11652 7478.64 4173.36 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

246 10981 7476.63 3504.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

259 18346 13314.39 5031.61 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

260 10158 10760.90 -602.90 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

261 6601 9232.45 -2631.45 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

262 6162 8408.64 -2246.64 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

263 6596 8129.72 -1533.72 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

264 6488 8343.84 -1855.84 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

217 9217 12205.30 -2988.30 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

218 8904 10583.47 -1679.47 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

219 7978 9742.01 -1764.01 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

220 7338 9519.40 -2181.40 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

221 5774 9874.42 -4100.42 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

222 5433 10873.13 -5440.13 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

425 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Max PV Velocity

c Max PV 

Velocity

Pred Formula Max 

PV Velocity 2

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - 

Thick

LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accel

0-Degree Aluminum LSC 

Plate

Variable Maximum SRS Acceleration Panels 30 1 171 254.63 -83.63 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(Max SRS Accel) Tests 45 2 178 254.63 -76.63 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table SRS Preliminary Parameters 3 165 254.63 -89.63 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model File 141230 1722 Max PV Vel intercept only uninteresting factor data disincluded.jrp 4 178 254.63 -76.63 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Excluded Values Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 155 254.63 -99.63 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Reason for Exclusions 6 226 254.63 -28.63 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

7 234 254.63 -20.63 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model Intercept-only model Exp(5.53979681316261 ) 8 173 254.63 -81.63 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

9 191 254.63 -63.63 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

10 161 254.63 -93.63 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

11 179 254.63 -75.63 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

12 276 254.63 21.37 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

13 212 254.63 -42.63 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

14 175 254.63 -79.63 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

15 163 254.63 -91.63 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

16 233 254.63 -21.63 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

17 175 254.63 -79.63 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

18 168 254.63 -86.63 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

19 300 254.63 45.37 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

20 271 254.63 16.37 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

21 281 254.63 26.37 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

22 273 254.63 18.37 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

23 423 254.63 168.37 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

24 441 254.63 186.37 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

25 309 254.63 54.37 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

26 265 254.63 10.37 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

27 315 254.63 60.37 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

28 288 254.63 33.37 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

29 393 254.63 138.37 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

30 273 254.63 18.37 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

31 332 254.63 77.37 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

32 318 254.63 63.37 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

33 313 254.63 58.37 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

34 341 254.63 86.37 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

35 342 254.63 87.37 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

36 390 254.63 135.37 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

43 255 254.63 0.37 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

44 194 254.63 -60.63 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

45 241 254.63 -13.63 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

46 238 254.63 -16.63 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table of Estimates Average of Pred Formula Max PV Velocity 2 Distance from LSC 47 207 254.63 -47.63 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Type - Thick LSC Core Load 9 21 33 45 57 69 48 223 254.63 -31.63 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 10 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 61 175 254.63 -79.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 22 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 62 220 254.63 -34.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 10 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 63 222 254.63 -32.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 22 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 64 182 254.63 -72.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 10 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 65 171 254.63 -83.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 22 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 66 135 254.63 -119.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 10 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 49 213 254.63 -41.63 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 22 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 50 258 254.63 3.37 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Rohacell - 1 10 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 51 284 254.63 29.37 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Rohacell - 1 22 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 254.6 52 297 254.63 42.37 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

53 274 254.63 19.37 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

54 219 254.63 -35.63 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

67 246 254.63 -8.63 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

68 303 254.63 48.37 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

69 269 254.63 14.37 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

70 264 254.63 9.37 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

71 276 254.63 21.37 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

72 293 254.63 38.37 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

73 375 254.63 120.37 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

74 376 254.63 121.37 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

75 364 254.63 109.37 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

76 368 254.63 113.37 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

77 447 254.63 192.37 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

78 382 254.63 127.37 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

79 380 254.63 125.37 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

80 344 254.63 89.37 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

81 381 254.63 126.37 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

82 373 254.63 118.37 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

83 385 254.63 130.37 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

84 482 254.63 227.37 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

85 171 254.63 -83.63 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

86 233 254.63 -21.63 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

87 270 254.63 15.37 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

426 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Variance Components 88 256 254.63 1.37 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% 

Lower

95% 

Upper Pct of Total Std Dev Random Effect Variance Component Component's Percent Share of Total Variance

Standard Deviation of Effect's 

Component (transformed units) 89 263 254.63 8.37 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Panel No 0.4987936 0.0120609 0.01974 -0.0266 0.05075 1554.1% 0.10982213 0.01 Panel-to-Panel 0.0120609 15.5% 0.1098221 90 218 254.63 -36.63 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Test No 1.7106575 0.0413641 0.0208 0.0006 0.08212 5330.1% 0.20338166 Test-to-Test 0.0413641 53.3% 0.2033817 97 226 254.63 -28.63 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Residual 0.0241802 0.00275 0.01959 0.03061 3115.8% 0.15549984 Within-Test 0.0241802 31.2% 0.1554998 98 306 254.63 51.37 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Total 0.0776053 0.01519 0.05471 0.11869 10000.0% 0.27857728 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.0776053 100.0% 0.2785773 99 346 254.63 91.37 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

100 336 254.63 81.37 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

101 276 254.63 21.37 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

102 218 254.63 -36.63 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

109 274 254.63 19.37 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

Alternative Model Model including potentially significant terms 110 283 254.63 28.37 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

141230 1654 Max PV Vel TT Dist x Plate Dist x Sever Dist x Damp.jrp 111 306 254.63 51.37 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

112 311 254.63 56.37 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

113 281 254.63 26.37 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

114 300 254.63 45.37 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

115 139 254.63 -115.63 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

116 173 254.63 -81.63 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

117 209 254.63 -45.63 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

118 190 254.63 -64.63 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

119 191 254.63 -63.63 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

120 187 254.63 -67.63 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

121 262 254.63 7.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

122 306 254.63 51.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

123 346 254.63 91.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

124 358 254.63 103.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

125 257 254.63 2.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

126 271 254.63 16.37 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

127 145 254.63 -109.63 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

128 190 254.63 -64.63 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

129 169 254.63 -85.63 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

130 185 254.63 -69.63 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

131 162 254.63 -92.63 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

132 192 254.63 -62.63 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

133 260 254.63 5.37 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

134 250 254.63 -4.63 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

135 255 254.63 0.37 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

136 209 254.63 -45.63 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

137 191 254.63 -63.63 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

138 444 254.63 189.37 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

139 253 254.63 -1.63 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

140 241 254.63 -13.63 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

141 234 254.63 -20.63 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

142 190 254.63 -64.63 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

143 184 254.63 -70.63 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

144 388 254.63 133.37 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

145 271 254.63 16.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

146 341 254.63 86.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

147 340 254.63 85.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

148 350 254.63 95.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

149 292 254.63 37.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

150 322 254.63 67.37 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

151 181 254.63 -73.63 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

152 194 254.63 -60.63 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

153 255 254.63 0.37 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

154 221 254.63 -33.63 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

155 183 254.63 -71.63 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

156 270 254.63 15.37 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

157 169 254.63 -85.63 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

158 143 254.63 -111.63 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

159 145 254.63 -109.63 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

160 148 254.63 -106.63 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

161 165 254.63 -89.63 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

162 136 254.63 -118.63 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

163 236 254.63 -18.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

164 149 254.63 -105.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

165 146 254.63 -108.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

166 126 254.63 -128.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

167 157 254.63 -97.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

168 97 254.63 -157.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

169 275 254.63 20.37 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

170 284 254.63 29.37 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

171 210 254.63 -44.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

172 194 254.63 -60.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

427 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

173 322 254.63 67.37 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

174 107 254.63 -147.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

181 261 254.63 6.37 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

182 193 254.63 -61.63 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

183 170 254.63 -84.63 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

184 146 254.63 -108.63 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

185 155 254.63 -99.63 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

186 148 254.63 -106.63 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

175 233 254.63 -21.63 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

176 226 254.63 -28.63 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

177 219 254.63 -35.63 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

178 172 254.63 -82.63 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

179 198 254.63 -56.63 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

180 285 254.63 30.37 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

55 186 254.63 -68.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

56 216 254.63 -38.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

57 219 254.63 -35.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

58 178 254.63 -76.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

59 223 254.63 -31.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

60 176 254.63 -78.63 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

37 311 254.63 56.37 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

38 268 254.63 13.37 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

39 305 254.63 50.37 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

40 290 254.63 35.37 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

41 320 254.63 65.37 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

42 249 254.63 -5.63 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

205 145 254.63 -109.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

206 150 254.63 -104.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

207 190 254.63 -64.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

208 143 254.63 -111.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

209 136 254.63 -118.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

210 125 254.63 -129.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

103 234 254.63 -20.63 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

104 345 254.63 90.37 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

105 279 254.63 24.37 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

106 301 254.63 46.37 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

107 258 254.63 3.37 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

108 343 254.63 88.37 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

91 216 254.63 -38.63 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

92 226 254.63 -28.63 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

93 245 254.63 -9.63 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

94 245 254.63 -9.63 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

95 193 254.63 -61.63 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

96 195 254.63 -59.63 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

187 197 254.63 -57.63 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

188 156 254.63 -98.63 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

189 139 254.63 -115.63 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

190 125 254.63 -129.63 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

191 114 254.63 -140.63 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

192 145 254.63 -109.63 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

193 225 254.63 -29.63 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

194 259 254.63 4.37 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

195 281 254.63 26.37 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

196 276 254.63 21.37 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

197 232 254.63 -22.63 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

198 301 254.63 46.37 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

199 95 254.63 -159.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

200 142 254.63 -112.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

201 211 254.63 -43.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

202 165 254.63 -89.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

203 122 254.63 -132.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

204 126 254.63 -128.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

235 286 254.63 31.37 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

236 278 254.63 23.37 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

237 256 254.63 1.37 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

238 235 254.63 -19.63 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

239 252 254.63 -2.63 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

240 476 254.63 221.37 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

265 324 254.63 69.37 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

266 256 254.63 1.37 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

267 286 254.63 31.37 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

268 239 254.63 -15.63 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

269 225 254.63 -29.63 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

270 275 254.63 20.37 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

211 291 254.63 36.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

212 380 254.63 125.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

213 300 254.63 45.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

214 258 254.63 3.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

215 262 254.63 7.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

216 291 254.63 36.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

247 311 254.63 56.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

248 260 254.63 5.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

249 276 254.63 21.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

250 281 254.63 26.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

251 284 254.63 29.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

428 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

252 327 254.63 72.37 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

253 302 254.63 47.37 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

254 342 254.63 87.37 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

255 302 254.63 47.37 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

256 368 254.63 113.37 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

257 297 254.63 42.37 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

258 283 254.63 28.37 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

223 237 254.63 -17.63 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

224 253 254.63 -1.63 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

225 261 254.63 6.37 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

226 237 254.63 -17.63 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

227 255 254.63 0.37 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

228 167 254.63 -87.63 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

229 297 254.63 42.37 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

230 336 254.63 81.37 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

231 269 254.63 14.37 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

232 236 254.63 -18.63 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

233 197 254.63 -57.63 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

234 247 254.63 -7.63 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum HomogeneousAluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

241 389 254.63 134.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

242 327 254.63 72.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

243 348 254.63 93.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

244 369 254.63 114.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

245 445 254.63 190.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

246 403 254.63 148.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

259 302 254.63 47.37 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

260 346 254.63 91.37 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

261 311 254.63 56.37 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

262 292 254.63 37.37 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

263 244 254.63 -10.63 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

264 321 254.63 66.37 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

217 198 254.63 -56.63 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

218 263 254.63 8.37 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

219 231 254.63 -23.63 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

220 140 254.63 -114.63 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

221 156 254.63 -98.63 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

222 158 254.63 -96.63 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

429 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

F4 Prime

c F4 prime Pred Formula 

F4 prime

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded Accel 0-Degree Aluminum LSC 

Plate

Variable F4prime Panels 30 1 3569 2456.87 1112.13 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(F4 prime) Tests 45 2 1829 2071.77 -242.77 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table SRS Plot Points 3 2235 2076.73 158.27 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model File 150115 1218 F4prime Dist3, Damp split-plot.jrp 4 3956 2218.35 1737.65 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Excluded Values Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 2948 2263.76 684.24 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Reason for Exclusions (Test 10R may be a wild point) 6 1972 1978.42 -6.42 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

7 2205 2456.87 -251.87 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model Baseline Exp( 8 3837 2071.77 1765.23 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

7.47645338066068 + 0.176312424977771 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 9 2247 2076.73 170.27 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Match( :Acoustic Damped, "0", 0.193963571811918, "1", -0.193963571811918, . ) + 10 4232 2218.35 2013.65 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 11 2923 2263.76 659.24 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.0279313603300892) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC 12 4148 1978.42 2169.58 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

 - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * -0.284608051208915)) 13 1265 2456.87 -1191.87 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) 14 2802 2071.77 730.23 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

15 2145 2076.73 68.27 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

16 1570 2218.35 -648.35 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

17 1695 2263.76 -568.76 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

18 1651 1978.42 -327.42 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

19 2869 2456.87 412.13 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

20 940 2071.77 -1131.77 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

21 3474 2076.73 1397.27 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

22 3350 2218.35 1131.65 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

23 3368 2263.76 1104.24 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

24 3191 1978.42 1212.58 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

25 1676 2456.87 -780.87 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

26 2252 2071.77 180.23 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

27 1641 2076.73 -435.73 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

28 1574 2218.35 -644.35 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

29 1278 2263.76 -985.76 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

30 2593 1978.42 614.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

31 2644 2456.87 187.13 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

32 2587 2071.77 515.23 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

33 2519 2076.73 442.27 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

34 1952 2218.35 -266.35 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

35 1989 2263.76 -274.76 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

36 1980 1978.42 1.58 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

43 1994 2456.87 -462.87 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

44 2440 2071.77 368.23 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

45 2051 2076.73 -25.73 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

46 2492 2218.35 273.65 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table of Estimates Average of Pred Formula F4 prime Distance from LSC 47 3307 2263.76 1043.24 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Acoustic Damped 9 21 33 45 57 69 48 1876 1978.42 -102.42 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0 2456.9 2071.8 2076.7 2218.4 2263.8 1978.4 61 2594 2456.87 137.13 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

1 1666.9 1405.6 1409.0 1505.1 1535.9 1342.3 62 1406 2071.77 -665.77 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

63 2022 2076.73 -54.73 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

64 2239 2218.35 20.65 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

65 3655 2263.76 1391.24 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

66 3039 1978.42 1060.58 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

49 1756 2456.87 -700.87 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

50 1899 2071.77 -172.77 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

51 1832 2076.73 -244.73 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

52 1466 2218.35 -752.35 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

53 1643 2263.76 -620.76 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

54 2487 1978.42 508.58 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

67 2631 2456.87 174.13 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

68 3351 2071.77 1279.23 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

69 3209 2076.73 1132.27 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

70 2767 2218.35 548.65 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

71 3087 2263.76 823.24 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

72 2952 1978.42 973.58 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

73 2560 2456.87 103.13 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

74 2016 2071.77 -55.77 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

75 1372 2076.73 -704.73 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

76 1696 2218.35 -522.35 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

77 1885 2263.76 -378.76 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

78 2031 1978.42 52.58 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

79 2500 2456.87 43.13 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

80 1825 2071.77 -246.77 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

81 1089 2076.73 -987.73 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

82 1651 2218.35 -567.35 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

83 2354 2263.76 90.24 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

84 2303 1978.42 324.58 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

85 2759 2456.87 302.13 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

86 1495 2071.77 -576.77 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

87 1476 2076.73 -600.73 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

430 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

180 2231 1978.42 252.58 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

55 3300 2456.87 843.13 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

56 2872 2071.77 800.23 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

57 3511 2076.73 1434.27 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

58 2982 2218.35 763.65 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

59 3109 2263.76 845.24 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

60 1846 1978.42 -132.42 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

37 843 2456.87 -1613.87 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

38 744 2071.77 -1327.77 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

39 1016 2076.73 -1060.73 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

40 1712 2218.35 -506.35 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

41 682 2263.76 -1581.76 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

42 803 1978.42 -1175.42 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

205 2143 2456.87 -313.87 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

206 2080 2071.77 8.23 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

207 1241 2076.73 -835.73 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

208 2114 2218.35 -104.35 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

209 1111 2263.76 -1152.76 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

210 1055 1978.42 -923.42 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

103 3876 2456.87 1419.13 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

104 2854 2071.77 782.23 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

105 2969 2076.73 892.27 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

106 3376 2218.35 1157.65 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

107 3700 2263.76 1436.24 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

108 2555 1978.42 576.58 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

91 2449 2456.87 -7.87 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

92 1318 2071.77 -753.77 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

93 2007 2076.73 -69.73 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

94 2005 2218.35 -213.35 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

95 2205 2263.76 -58.76 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

96 1588 1978.42 -390.42 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

187 3370 2456.87 913.13 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

188 2108 2071.77 36.23 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

189 3100 2076.73 1023.27 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

190 2810 2218.35 591.65 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

191 2249 2263.76 -14.76 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

192 1761 1978.42 -217.42 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

193 3771 2456.87 1314.13 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

194 2650 2071.77 578.23 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

195 2145 2076.73 68.27 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

196 2577 2218.35 358.65 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

197 2494 2263.76 230.24 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

198 1735 1978.42 -243.42 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

199 2447 2456.87 -9.87 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

200 2331 2071.77 259.23 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

201 2282 2076.73 205.27 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

202 2169 2218.35 -49.35 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

203 1924 2263.76 -339.76 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

204 1701 1978.42 -277.42 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

235 5423 2456.87 2966.13 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

236 2095 2071.77 23.23 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

237 2208 2076.73 131.27 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

238 1906 2218.35 -312.35 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

239 1673 2263.76 -590.76 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

240 1418 1978.42 -560.42 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

265 3244 1666.89 1577.11 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

266 2816 1405.62 1410.38 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

267 1898 1408.98 489.02 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

268 2490 1505.07 984.93 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

269 1827 1535.88 291.12 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

270 2106 1342.28 763.72 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

211 1823 2456.87 -633.87 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

212 1837 2071.77 -234.77 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

213 1816 2076.73 -260.73 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

214 1931 2218.35 -287.35 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

215 1910 2263.76 -353.76 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

216 1621 1978.42 -357.42 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

247 771 1666.89 -895.89 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

248 2786 1405.62 1380.38 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

249 1418 1408.98 9.02 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

250 1713 1505.07 207.93 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

251 1341 1535.88 -194.88 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

252 1494 1342.28 151.72 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

253 1670 2456.87 -786.87 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

254 1387 2071.77 -684.77 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

255 1518 2076.73 -558.73 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

256 1498 2218.35 -720.35 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

257 945 2263.76 -1318.76 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

258 1084 1978.42 -894.42 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

431 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

223 2064 2456.87 -392.87 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

224 2320 2071.77 248.23 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

225 1962 2076.73 -114.73 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

226 2055 2218.35 -163.35 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

227 1132 2263.76 -1131.76 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

228 1944 1978.42 -34.42 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

229 1789 1666.89 122.11 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

230 1550 1405.62 144.38 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

231 1716 1408.98 307.02 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

232 1611 1505.07 105.93 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

233 1888 1535.88 352.12 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

234 1562 1342.28 219.72 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

241 518 1666.89 -1148.89 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

242 414 1405.62 -991.62 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

243 1376 1408.98 -32.98 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

244 1611 1505.07 105.93 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

245 1250 1535.88 -285.88 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

246 1525 1342.28 182.72 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

259 795 1666.89 -871.89 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

260 1702 1405.62 296.38 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

261 1343 1408.98 -65.98 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

262 1487 1505.07 -18.07 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

263 1473 1535.88 -62.88 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

264 1349 1342.28 6.72 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

217 1938 1666.89 271.11 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

218 1032 1405.62 -373.62 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

219 1000 1408.98 -408.98 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

220 1580 1505.07 74.93 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

221 1411 1535.88 -124.88 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

222 1069 1342.28 -273.28 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

432 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

SRS 1

c SRS1 Pred Formula 

SRS1 2

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accel

0-Degree Aluminum 

LSC Plate

Variable SRS1 Panels 30 1 95 118.78 -23.78 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(SRS1) Tests 45 2 71 96.44 -25.44 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table SRS Plot Points 3 77 93.62 -16.62 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model File 150115 1627 SRS1 Dist3, Dist2 x TT split-plot.jrp 4 128 94.74 33.26 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Excluded Values Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 133 87.14 45.86 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Reason for Exclusions 6 48 63.53 -15.53 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

7 113 118.78 -5.78 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Model Baseline Exp( 8 151 96.44 54.56 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

4.58252882781051 + -0.00155145073510171 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + 9 114 93.62 20.38 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 10 142 94.74 47.26 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.331779574313124, 11 164 87.14 76.86 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.236470368298261, 12 70 63.53 6.47 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187, -0.0339738031050941, 13 80 185.49 -105.49 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.772626838077598, 14 226 194.65 31.35 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3, -0.170403092361119, 15 85 210.29 -125.29 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

. 16 56 203.91 -147.91 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * - 17 63 154.75 -91.75 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.111656869712595) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 18 56 80.14 -24.14 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * -0.356921848771425)) + (( 19 489 185.49 303.51 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 20 79 194.65 -115.65 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.0071549630796822, 21 183 210.29 -27.29 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Rohacell - 1, 0.0439527963276101, 22 304 203.91 100.09 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0455795776598272, 23 157 154.75 2.25 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.2, -0.0611256521870972, 24 186 80.14 105.86 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.3, -0.0212517587206578, 25 113 185.49 -72.49 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

. 26 146 194.65 -48.65 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 27 126 210.29 -84.29 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 28 133 203.91 -70.91 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Al Honey - 1, 0.280819406496983, 29 72 154.75 -82.75 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.132152767507317, 30 54 80.14 -26.14 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0274709498380225, 31 388 185.49 202.51 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.2, -0.440111881502178, 32 552 194.65 357.35 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.3, 0.263974292674489, 33 493 210.29 282.71 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

. 34 501 203.91 297.09 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) ) 35 516 154.75 361.25 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) 36 94 80.14 13.86 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

43 122 185.49 -63.49 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

44 203 194.65 8.35 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

45 76 210.29 -134.29 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

46 173 203.91 -30.91 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Table of Estimates Average of Pred Formula SRS1 2 Distance from LSC 47 214 154.75 59.25 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Type - Thick 9 21 33 45 57 69 48 52 80.14 -28.14 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 116.0 88.8 83.8 83.1 75.5 56.1 61 161 140.35 20.65 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 118.8 96.4 93.6 94.7 87.1 63.5 62 126 95.37 30.63 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 179.5 184.3 197.6 191.8 146.9 78.1 63 78 83.57 -5.57 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 130.6 91.0 81.0 80.1 76.6 62.0 64 75 82.34 -7.34 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Rohacell - 1 101.7 79.9 76.5 76.6 69.9 51.2 65 48 79.53 -31.53 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

66 175 65.67 109.33 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

49 123 140.35 -17.35 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

50 210 95.37 114.63 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

51 149 83.57 65.43 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

52 81 82.34 -1.34 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

53 69 79.53 -10.53 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

54 70 65.67 4.33 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

67 244 185.49 58.51 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

68 264 194.65 69.35 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

69 190 210.29 -20.29 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

70 155 203.91 -48.91 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

71 205 154.75 50.25 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

72 64 80.14 -16.14 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

73 376 185.49 190.51 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

74 282 194.65 87.35 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

75 417 210.29 206.71 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

76 510 203.91 306.09 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

77 752 154.75 597.25 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

78 88 80.14 7.86 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

79 384 185.49 198.51 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

80 399 194.65 204.35 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

81 352 210.29 141.71 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

82 261 203.91 57.09 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

83 563 154.75 408.25 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

84 145 80.14 64.86 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

85 64 140.35 -76.35 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

86 123 95.37 27.63 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

87 19 83.57 -64.57 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

433 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Variance Components 88 87 82.34 4.66 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Var Ratio

Var 

Compo

nent

Std 

Error

95% 

Lower

95% 

Upper Pct of Total Std Dev Random Effect

Variance Component Component's Percent Share of 

Total Variance

Standard Deviation of Effect's 

Component (transformed units) 89 62 79.53 -17.53 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.5986449 0.1171 0.0979 -0.075 0.309 2335.2% 0.34 0.01 Panel-to-Panel 0.1170589 23.4% 0.3421387 90 73 65.67 7.33 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.9648861 0.1887 0.0779 0.0359 0.3414 3763.9% 0.43 Test-to-Test 0.1886735 37.6% 0.4343656 97 108 140.35 -32.35 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.1955 0.0189 0.1632 0.2386 3900.9% 0.44 Within-Test 0.1955397 39.0% 0.4421987 98 109 95.37 13.63 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.5013 0.0845 0.3695 0.719 10000.0% 0.71 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.5012721 100.0% 0.7080057 99 47 83.57 -36.57 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

100 170 82.34 87.66 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

101 123 79.53 43.47 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

102 58 65.67 -7.67 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

109 166 185.49 -19.49 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

110 176 194.65 -18.65 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

111 197 210.29 -13.29 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

112 83 203.91 -120.91 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

113 171 154.75 16.25 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

114 47 80.14 -33.14 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

115 86 119.77 -33.77 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

116 184 80.96 103.04 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

117 73 70.96 2.04 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

118 69 70.31 -1.31 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

119 75 68.67 6.33 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

120 49 57.64 -8.64 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

121 185 82.83 102.17 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

122 89 74.44 14.56 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

123 102 76.00 26.00 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

124 72 76.86 -4.86 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

125 95 67.13 27.87 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

126 47 44.16 2.84 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

127 109 82.83 26.17 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

128 36 74.44 -38.44 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

129 43 76.00 -33.00 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

130 36 76.86 -40.86 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

131 52 67.13 -15.13 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

132 21 44.16 -23.16 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

133 359 119.77 239.23 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

134 130 80.96 49.04 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

135 84 70.96 13.04 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

136 91 70.31 20.69 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

137 105 68.67 36.33 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

138 109 57.64 51.36 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

139 110 82.83 27.17 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

140 123 74.44 48.56 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

141 100 76.00 24.00 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

142 71 76.86 -5.86 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

143 120 67.13 52.87 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

144 45 44.16 0.84 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

145 107 119.77 -12.77 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

146 156 80.96 75.04 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

147 58 70.96 -12.96 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

148 57 70.31 -13.31 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

149 48 68.67 -20.67 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

150 52 57.64 -5.64 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

151 47 119.77 -72.77 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

152 68 80.96 -12.96 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

153 27 70.96 -43.96 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

154 94 70.31 23.69 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

155 68 68.67 -0.67 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

156 27 57.64 -30.64 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

157 46 82.83 -36.83 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

158 155 74.44 80.56 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

159 69 76.00 -7.00 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

160 62 76.86 -14.86 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

161 102 67.13 34.87 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

162 27 44.16 -17.16 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

163 17 82.83 -65.83 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

164 29 74.44 -45.44 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

165 23 76.00 -53.00 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

166 26 76.86 -50.86 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

167 34 67.13 -33.13 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

168 18 44.16 -26.16 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

169 112 119.77 -7.77 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

170 134 80.96 53.04 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

171 55 70.96 -15.96 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

172 58 70.31 -12.31 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

173 97 68.67 28.33 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

174 43 57.64 -14.64 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

181 202 140.35 61.65 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

182 171 95.37 75.63 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

183 59 83.57 -24.57 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

434 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

184 85 82.34 2.66 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

185 213 79.53 133.47 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

186 33 65.67 -32.67 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

175 185 185.49 -0.49 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

176 153 194.65 -41.65 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

177 129 210.29 -81.29 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

178 328 203.91 124.09 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

179 146 154.75 -8.75 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

180 84 80.14 3.86 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

55 35 82.83 -47.83 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

56 70 74.44 -4.44 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

57 62 76.00 -14.00 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

58 90 76.86 13.14 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

59 69 67.13 1.87 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

60 27 44.16 -17.16 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

37 40 185.49 -145.49 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

38 50 194.65 -144.65 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

39 63 210.29 -147.29 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

40 164 203.91 -39.91 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

41 59 154.75 -95.75 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

42 16 80.14 -64.14 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

205 297 140.35 156.65 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

206 185 95.37 89.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

207 94 83.57 10.43 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

208 152 82.34 69.66 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

209 92 79.53 12.47 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

210 65 65.67 -0.67 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

103 21 119.77 -98.77 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

104 81 80.96 0.04 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

105 50 70.96 -20.96 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

106 62 70.31 -8.31 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

107 39 68.67 -29.67 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

108 47 57.64 -10.64 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

91 206 119.77 86.23 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

92 85 80.96 4.04 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

93 59 70.96 -11.96 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

94 98 70.31 27.69 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

95 78 68.67 9.33 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

96 115 57.64 57.36 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

187 20 119.77 -99.77 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

188 31 80.96 -49.96 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

189 28 70.96 -42.96 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

190 37 70.31 -33.31 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

191 31 68.67 -37.67 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

192 30 57.64 -27.64 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

193 387 119.77 267.23 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

194 308 80.96 227.04 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

195 72 70.96 1.04 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

196 63 70.31 -7.31 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

197 84 68.67 15.33 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

198 104 57.64 46.36 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

199 59 82.83 -23.83 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

200 36 74.44 -38.44 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

201 32 76.00 -44.00 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

202 32 76.86 -44.86 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

203 33 67.13 -34.13 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

204 28 44.16 -16.16 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

235 383 82.83 300.17 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

236 125 74.44 50.56 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

237 88 76.00 12.00 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

238 102 76.86 25.14 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

239 113 67.13 45.87 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

240 147 44.16 102.84 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

265 538 119.77 418.23 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

266 227 80.96 146.04 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

267 271 70.96 200.04 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

268 168 70.31 97.69 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

269 133 68.67 64.33 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

270 91 57.64 33.36 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

211 124 140.35 -16.35 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

212 65 95.37 -30.37 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

213 54 83.57 -29.57 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

214 59 82.34 -23.34 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

215 59 79.53 -20.53 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

216 39 65.67 -26.67 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

247 118 82.83 35.17 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

248 392 74.44 317.56 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

249 122 76.00 46.00 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

250 144 76.86 67.14 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

251 153 67.13 85.87 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

252 99 44.16 54.84 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

253 66 119.77 -53.77 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

254 137 80.96 56.04 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

255 69 70.96 -1.96 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

256 38 70.31 -32.31 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

257 52 68.67 -16.67 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

258 103 57.64 45.36 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

223 366 118.78 247.22 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

224 216 96.44 119.56 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

435 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

225 80 93.62 -13.62 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

226 135 94.74 40.26 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

227 140 87.14 52.86 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

228 63 63.53 -0.53 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

229 50 118.78 -68.78 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

230 56 96.44 -40.44 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

231 53 93.62 -40.62 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

232 29 94.74 -65.74 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

233 45 87.14 -42.14 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

234 51 63.53 -12.53 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

241 161 82.83 78.17 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

242 130 74.44 55.56 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

243 514 76.00 438.00 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

244 448 76.86 371.14 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

245 247 67.13 179.87 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

246 147 44.16 102.84 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

259 98 119.77 -21.77 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

260 90 80.96 9.04 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

261 111 70.96 40.04 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

262 39 70.31 -31.31 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

263 95 68.67 26.33 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

264 74 57.64 16.36 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

217 54 140.35 -86.35 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

218 62 95.37 -33.37 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

219 51 83.57 -32.57 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

220 55 82.34 -27.34 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

221 42 79.53 -37.53 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

222 55 65.67 -10.67 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

436 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

SRS 4 Prime

c SRS4 

prime

Pred Formula 

SRS4 prime

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of 

Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever Debonded 

Accel

0-Degree Aluminum 

LSC Plate

SRS4prime Panels 30 1 17525 13330.40 4194.60 P 1 P 1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 0.187 10 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

log(SRS4prime) Tests 45 2 11295 11391.31 -96.31 P 1 P 1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 0.187 10 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

SRS Plot Points 3 12561 10333.43 2227.57 P 1 P 1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 0.187 10 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

150116 1312 SRS4prime Dist2 Dist x TT.jrp 4 10377 9950.77 426.23 P 1 P 1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 0.187 10 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 5 11293 10172.07 1120.93 P 1 P 1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 0.187 10 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

6 13285 11038.31 2246.69 P 1 P 1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 0.187 10 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

7 15170 13330.40 1839.60 P 2 P 1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Baseline Exp( 8 14814 11391.31 3422.69 P 2 P 1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

9.14798243845737 + -0.166463884546463 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + (( 9 13014 10333.43 2680.57 P 2 P 1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 10 15470 9950.77 5519.23 P 2 P 1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

0.186658985688572) + Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 11 14643 10172.07 4470.93 P 2 P 1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.201913000399105, 12 18641 11038.31 7602.69 P 2 P 1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3, -0.0258841493632474, 13 9605 15163.61 -5558.61 P 3 P 3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.110345882637344, 14 15179 12979.83 2199.17 P 3 P 3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.134506588908993, 15 8231 11794.42 -3563.42 P 3 P 3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0688236205104796, 16 8496 11376.92 -2880.92 P 3 P 3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

. 17 11554 11649.67 -95.67 P 3 P 3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

) + ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * Match( :Name( "Type - Thick" ), 18 8579 12663.20 -4084.20 P 3 P 3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2, 0.0763648448330247, 19 13601 15163.61 -1562.61 P 4 P 4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Monolithic - 0.3, 0.0925137193328283, 20 10268 12979.83 -2711.83 P 4 P 4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Al Honey - 1, -0.0887469386341148, 21 10480 11794.42 -1314.42 P 4 P 4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Rohacell - 1, -0.152257946188005, 22 7299 11376.92 -4077.92 P 4 P 4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

Aluminum - 0.187, 0.0721263206562666, 23 7107 11649.67 -4542.67 P 4 P 4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

. 24 6856 12663.20 -5807.20 P 4 P 4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) 25 12478 15163.61 -2685.61 P 5 P 5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

) 26 15120 12979.83 2140.17 P 5 P 5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

27 8685 11794.42 -3109.42 P 5 P 5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

28 8786 11376.92 -2590.92 P 5 P 5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

29 10497 11649.67 -1152.67 P 5 P 5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

30 9672 12663.20 -2991.20 P 5 P 5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

31 13982 15163.61 -1181.61 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

32 12754 12979.83 -225.83 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

33 11777 11794.42 -17.42 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

34 10551 11376.92 -825.92 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

35 11626 11649.67 -23.67 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

36 12599 12663.20 -64.20 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

43 14368 15163.61 -795.61 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

44 11514 12979.83 -1465.83 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

45 12570 11794.42 775.58 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

46 11525 11376.92 148.08 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Average of Pred Formula SRS4 prime Distance from LSC 47 12773 11649.67 1123.33 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Type - Thick 9 21 33 45 57 69 48 12181 12663.20 -482.20 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Al Honey - 1 13393.0 10732.2 9134.9 8259.0 7931.9 8092.1 61 11005 11881.14 -876.14 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Aluminum - 0.187 13330.4 11391.3 10333.4 9950.8 10172.1 11038.3 62 8270 10235.99 -1965.99 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.2 14975.0 12753.3 11533.2 11074.9 11292.5 12226.2 63 8448 9361.44 -913.44 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Monolithic - 0.3 12248.7 10317.3 9238.6 8793.8 8897.1 9567.4 64 9696 9088.59 607.41 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Rohacell - 1 13162.4 10525.7 8948.0 8086.9 7770.5 7939.0 65 9607 9366.79 240.21 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

66 9069 10247.69 -1178.69 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

49 11499 11881.14 -382.14 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

50 8646 10235.99 -1589.99 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

51 9003 9361.44 -358.44 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

52 8228 9088.59 -860.59 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

53 7945 9366.79 -1421.79 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

54 9363 10247.69 -884.69 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

67 13539 15163.61 -1624.61 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

68 16746 12979.83 3766.17 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

69 16265 11794.42 4470.58 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

70 13872 11376.92 2495.08 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

71 15586 11649.67 3936.33 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

72 17671 12663.20 5007.80 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

73 18254 15163.61 3090.39 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

74 15930 12979.83 2950.17 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

75 11264 11794.42 -530.42 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

76 10721 11376.92 -655.92 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

77 13675 11649.67 2025.33 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

78 13618 12663.20 954.80 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 0 1

79 20354 15163.61 5190.39 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

80 15695 12979.83 2715.17 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

437 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

81 11437 11794.42 -357.42 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

82 10996 11376.92 -380.92 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

83 13602 11649.67 1952.33 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

84 16139 12663.20 3475.80 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

85 15759 11881.14 3877.86 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

86 14657 10235.99 4421.01 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

87 11130 9361.44 1768.56 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Variance Components 88 9468 9088.59 379.41 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Random Effect Var Ratio

Var 

Compon

ent

Std Error 95% 

Lower

95% 

Upper

Pct of Total Std Dev

Random Effect

Variance 

Component

Component's Percent 

Share of Total Variance

Standard Deviation of 

Effect's Component 

(transformed units)

89 10158 9366.79 791.21 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminu

m

0 0 1 1 1

Panel No -0.492224 -0.01332 0.021515 -0.05548 0.02885 0.0% #NUM! 0 Panel-to-Panel -0.01332 0.0% 0 90 10309 10247.69 61.31 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Test No 2.6577824 0.071899 0.027232 0.01852 0.12527 7266.1% 0.26814008 Test-to-Test 0.07190 72.7% 0.26814 97 9877 11881.14 -2004.14 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Residual 0.027052 0.002585 0.02262 0.03293 2733.9% 0.16447583 Within-Test 0.02705 27.3% 0.16448 98 9279 10235.99 -956.99 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

Total 0.098951 0.027314 0.06149 0.1852 10000.0% 0.31456541 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.09895 100.0% 0.31457 99 10512 9361.44 1150.56 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

100 10884 9088.59 1795.41 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

101 9542 9366.79 175.21 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

102 13631 10247.69 3383.31 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

109 22897 15163.61 7733.39 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

110 18794 12979.83 5814.17 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

111 18405 11794.42 6610.58 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

112 12351 11376.92 974.08 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

113 11920 11649.67 270.33 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

114 14080 12663.20 1416.80 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 Y 1 1

115 17035 13088.72 3946.28 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

116 11602 10487.72 1114.28 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

117 10434 8920.84 1513.16 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

118 8908 8055.10 852.90 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

119 8097 7721.06 375.94 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

120 8439 7856.41 582.59 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

121 14557 13614.04 942.96 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

122 9624 10635.00 -1011.00 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

123 8259 8819.20 -560.20 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

124 6863 7763.57 -900.57 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

125 8240 7254.96 985.04 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

126 7624 7196.95 427.05 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

127 11810 13614.04 -1804.04 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

128 7534 10635.00 -3101.00 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

129 6283 8819.20 -2536.20 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

130 4464 7763.57 -3299.57 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

131 5078 7254.96 -2176.96 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

132 5637 7196.95 -1559.95 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

133 13588 13088.72 499.28 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

134 11460 10487.72 972.28 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

135 13169 8920.84 4248.16 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

136 8454 8055.10 398.90 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

137 9768 7721.06 2046.94 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

138 11453 7856.41 3596.59 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

139 14050 13614.04 435.96 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

140 10589 10635.00 -46.00 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

141 9001 8819.20 181.80 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

142 7201 7763.57 -562.57 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

143 9232 7254.96 1977.04 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

144 9354 7196.95 2157.05 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

145 14466 13088.72 1377.28 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

146 11093 10487.72 605.28 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

147 8921 8920.84 0.16 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

148 9639 8055.10 1583.90 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

149 9565 7721.06 1843.94 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

150 8747 7856.41 890.59 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

151 10742 13088.72 -2346.72 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

152 8435 10487.72 -2052.72 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

153 7950 8920.84 -970.84 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

154 7160 8055.10 -895.10 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

155 6428 7721.06 -1293.06 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

156 6138 7856.41 -1718.41 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

157 32442 13614.04 18827.96 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

158 17874 10635.00 7239.00 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

159 14719 8819.20 5899.80 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

160 8905 7763.57 1141.43 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

161 7233 7254.96 -21.96 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

162 6167 7196.95 -1029.95 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

163 10707 13614.04 -2907.04 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

164 8661 10635.00 -1974.00 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

165 6811 8819.20 -2008.20 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

438 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

166 5007 7763.57 -2756.57 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

167 4924 7254.96 -2330.96 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

168 5014 7196.95 -2182.95 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 0

169 15533 13088.72 2444.28 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

170 10938 10487.72 450.28 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

171 10912 8920.84 1991.16 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

172 7992 8055.10 -63.10 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

173 8322 7721.06 600.94 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

174 10013 7856.41 2156.59 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

181 12188 11881.14 306.86 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

182 12597 10235.99 2361.01 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

183 12111 9361.44 2749.56 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

184 11301 9088.59 2212.41 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

185 11004 9366.79 1637.21 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

186 15187 10247.69 4939.31 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

175 14498 15163.61 -665.61 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

176 15403 12979.83 2423.17 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

177 13801 11794.42 2006.58 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

178 14176 11376.92 2799.08 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

179 14959 11649.67 3309.33 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

180 15046 12663.20 2382.80 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

55 7476 13614.04 -6138.04 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

56 6938 10635.00 -3697.00 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

57 6832 8819.20 -1987.20 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

58 5689 7763.57 -2074.57 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

59 4816 7254.96 -2438.96 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

60 5860 7196.95 -1336.95 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

37 9328 15163.61 -5835.61 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

38 9291 12979.83 -3688.83 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

39 12158 11794.42 363.58 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

40 9621 11376.92 -1755.92 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

41 10153 11649.67 -1496.67 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

42 16717 12663.20 4053.80 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

205 10921 11881.14 -960.14 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

206 15926 10235.99 5690.01 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

207 13369 9361.44 4007.56 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

208 10124 9088.59 1035.41 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

209 12541 9366.79 3174.21 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

210 13214 10247.69 2966.31 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 1 1 0

103 13582 13088.72 493.28 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

104 11327 10487.72 839.28 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

105 8538 8920.84 -382.84 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

106 8628 8055.10 572.90 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

107 7586 7721.06 -135.06 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

108 9024 7856.41 1167.59 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

91 10702 13088.72 -2386.72 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

92 10450 10487.72 -37.72 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

93 8200 8920.84 -720.84 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

94 7486 8055.10 -569.10 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

95 8366 7721.06 644.94 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

96 7389 7856.41 -467.41 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

187 6571 13088.72 -6517.72 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

188 4937 10487.72 -5550.72 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

189 4457 8920.84 -4463.84 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

190 3925 8055.10 -4130.10 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

191 3365 7721.06 -4356.06 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

192 4136 7856.41 -3720.41 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 0 1 1

193 16318 13088.72 3229.28 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

194 11694 10487.72 1206.28 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

195 10038 8920.84 1117.16 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

196 8181 8055.10 125.90 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

197 8493 7721.06 771.94 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

198 9479 7856.41 1622.59 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

199 10395 13614.04 -3219.04 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

200 6624 10635.00 -4011.00 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

439 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

201 5766 8819.20 -3053.20 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

202 4782 7763.57 -2981.57 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

203 5308 7254.96 -1946.96 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

204 4303 7196.95 -2893.95 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 1 1 0

235 28490 13614.04 14875.96 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

236 19259 10635.00 8624.00 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

237 14063 8819.20 5243.80 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

238 11892 7763.57 4128.43 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

239 10860 7254.96 3605.04 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

240 9224 7196.95 2027.05 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

265 15731 13088.72 2642.28 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

266 17244 10487.72 6756.28 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

267 12947 8920.84 4026.16 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

268 12470 8055.10 4414.90 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

269 12688 7721.06 4966.94 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

270 10113 7856.41 2256.59 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

211 8801 11881.14 -3080.14 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

212 12045 10235.99 1809.01 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

213 9947 9361.44 585.56 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

214 7338 9088.59 -1750.59 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

215 8401 9366.79 -965.79 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

216 8715 10247.69 -1532.69 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

247 12017 13614.04 -1597.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

248 12631 10635.00 1996.00 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

249 12103 8819.20 3283.80 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

250 9114 7763.57 1350.43 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

251 9785 7254.96 2530.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

252 10422 7196.95 3225.05 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1

253 12610 13088.72 -478.72 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

254 8942 10487.72 -1545.72 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

255 7914 8920.84 -1006.84 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

256 6133 8055.10 -1922.10 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

257 7057 7721.06 -664.06 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

258 7789 7856.41 -67.41 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 0 0 1 1 1

223 9408 13330.40 -3922.40 A03 P 1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

224 10782 11391.31 -609.31 A03 P 1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

225 9279 10333.43 -1054.43 A03 P 1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

226 8970 9950.77 -980.77 A03 P 1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

227 9392 10172.07 -780.07 A03 P 1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

228 12381 11038.31 1342.69 A03 P 1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 0 1 1 1 1

229 12017 13330.40 -1313.40 A04 P 1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

230 10233 11391.31 -1158.31 A04 P 1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

231 8206 10333.43 -2127.43 A04 P 1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

232 6336 9950.77 -3614.77 A04 P 1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

233 5420 10172.07 -4752.07 A04 P 1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

234 5809 11038.31 -5229.31 A04 P 1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 0.187 22 AluminumHomogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

241 9028 13614.04 -4586.04 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

242 10150 10635.00 -485.00 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

243 9472 8819.20 652.80 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

244 10677 7763.57 2913.43 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

245 11652 7254.96 4397.04 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

246 10981 7196.95 3784.05 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

259 18346 13088.72 5257.28 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

260 10158 10487.72 -329.72 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

261 6601 8920.84 -2319.84 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

262 6162 8055.10 -1893.10 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

263 6596 7721.06 -1125.06 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

264 6488 7856.41 -1368.41 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

217 9217 11881.14 -2664.14 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

218 8904 10235.99 -1331.99 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

219 7978 9361.44 -1383.44 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

220 7338 9088.59 -1750.59 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

221 5774 9366.79 -3592.79 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1

222 5433 10247.69 -4814.69 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

440 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Max ESD Disp

Row Labels

Count of Pred 

MaxESDDisp 

Dist2 Dist x CL 

noTB Plate

c Max ESD 

Displace

Pred MaxESDDisp 

Dist2 Dist x CL noTB 

Plate

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Sensor Vert 

Posn T-B

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Aluminum 

LSC Plate

Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever 0 Degree Channel

Variable Maximum ESD Displacement 2.12 2 1 7.69 7.41 0.28 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(MaxESDDisp) 2.42 2 2 7.97 7.41 0.56 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

Table Other Preliminary Parameters 2.46 2 3 7.6 7.96 -0.36 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

Model File 150127 1600 MaxESDDisp Dist2 Dist x CL noTB Plate.jrp 2.62 2 4 11.95 7.96 3.99 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

Excluded Values Test P4 Channel 4: Clear low outlier; excluded by analyst without SME approval 2.65 2 5 6.97 8.12 -1.15 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 2.70 2 6 7.26 8.12 -0.86 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

2.74 6 7 7.02 7.88 -0.86 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

Model Simple T/B random var Exp( 3.27 6 8 5.16 7.88 -2.72 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

1.88508105265126 + -0.00428823884622233 * :Distance from LSC + 3.70 6 9 5.93 7.26 -1.33 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

Match( :LSC Core Load 10 -0.181783869892254 22 0.181783869892254 . ) + ( 3.94 6 10 6.71 7.26 -0.55 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

:Distance from LSC - 39.0223048327138) * Match( :LSC Core Load 3.97 6 11 9.94 6.36 3.58 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

10 0.00174623217523917 4.06 6 12 6.39 6.36 0.03 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

22 -0.00174623217523917 6.36 32 13 15.68 11.83 3.85 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

. 7.26 32 14 7.09 11.83 -4.74 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

) + (:Distance from LSC - 39.0223048327138) * ((:Distance from LSC - 7.41 32 15 8.49 12.19 -3.70 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

39.0223048327138) * -0.000177622933837467) + 7.88 32 16 9.15 12.19 -3.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

Match( :Aluminum LSC Plate 0 -0.550041910060047 1 0.550041910060047 . ) 7.96 32 17 11.67 11.93 -0.26 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

) 8.12 32 18 12.15 11.93 0.22 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

8.24 50 19 17.14 11.10 6.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

9.81 50 20 14.33 11.10 3.23 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

11.10 50 21 14.1 9.81 4.29 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

11.83 50 22 9.77 9.81 -0.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

11.93 50 23 15.62 8.24 7.38 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

12.19 50 24 14.45 8.24 6.21 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

Grand Total 540 25 7.39 7.41 -0.02 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

26 6.07 7.41 -1.34 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

27 4.88 7.96 -3.08 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

Table of Estimates Average of Pred MaxESDDisp Dist2 Dist x CL noTB Plate Distance from LSC 28 5.07 7.96 -2.89 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

LSC Core Load Aluminum LSC Plate LSC Plate 9 21 33 45 57 69 29 6.1 8.12 -2.02 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

10 0 Fabric Composite 2.465 2.649 2.704 2.623 2.418 2.117 30 6.18 8.12 -1.94 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

10 1 Aluminum 7.405 7.958 8.124 7.881 7.264 6.361 31 20.83 7.88 12.95 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

22 0 Fabric Composite 3.938 4.057 3.972 3.695 3.266 2.743 32 10.12 7.88 2.24 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

22 0 Tape Composite 3.938 4.057 3.972 3.695 3.266 2.743 33 3.58 7.26 -3.68 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

22 1 Aluminum 11.830 12.190 11.935 11.102 9.813 8.240 34 7.46 7.26 0.20 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

35 3.07 6.36 -3.29 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

Count of Pred MaxESDDisp Dist2 Dist x CL noTB Plate Distance from LSC 36 5.18 6.36 -1.18 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

LSC Core Load Aluminum LSC Plate LSC Plate 9 21 33 45 57 69 37 14.83 7.41 7.42 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

10 0 Fabric Composite 2 2 2 2 2 2 38 9.93 7.41 2.52 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

10 1 Aluminum 32 32 32 32 32 32 39 11.24 7.96 3.28 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

22 0 Fabric Composite 4 4 4 4 4 4 Value omitted 40 0 7.96 -7.96 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

22 0 Tape Composite 2 2 2 2 2 2 41 10.08 8.12 1.96 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

22 1 Aluminum 50 50 50 50 50 50 42 10.27 8.12 2.15 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

43 7.46 7.88 -0.42 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

44 9.5 7.88 1.62 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

45 10.8 7.26 3.54 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

46 25.89 7.26 18.63 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

47 33.79 6.36 27.43 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

48 11.31 6.36 4.95 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

49 7.43 7.41 0.02 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

50 12.88 7.41 5.47 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

51 11.87 7.96 3.91 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

52 14.21 7.96 6.25 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

53 16.37 8.12 8.25 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

54 17.36 8.12 9.24 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

55 15.26 7.88 7.38 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

56 14.58 7.88 6.70 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

57 12.75 7.26 5.49 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

58 19.83 7.26 12.57 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

59 12.15 6.36 5.79 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

60 10.54 6.36 4.18 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

61 20.61 7.41 13.20 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

62 19.65 7.41 12.24 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

63 11.8 7.96 3.84 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

441 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% 

Lower

95% 

Upper Pct of Total Std Dev 64 11.08 7.96 3.12 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

Sensor Vert Posn T-B 0.0514975 0.0049875 0.0075628 -0.009835 0.01981 1.5% 0.070622 65 21.46 8.12 13.34 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

Test No[LSC Core Load,Aluminum LSC Plate,Panel No] 2.0174722 0.1953922 0.1011601 -0.002878 0.393662 58.2% 0.442032 66 16.74 8.12 8.62 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

Panel No 0.3987081 0.0386149 0.1074366 -0.171957 0.249187 11.5% 0.196507 67 13.58 7.88 5.70 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

Residual 0.09685 0.0061938 0.085771 0.110236 28.8% 0.311207 68 12.33 7.88 4.45 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

Total 0.3358446 0.0560643 0.248271 0.479813 100.0% 0.579521 69 20.17 7.26 12.91 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

0.1018375 30.3% 0.31912 70 17.09 7.26 9.83 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

71 13.71 6.36 7.35 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

72 12.64 6.36 6.28 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

Alternate Model Simple T/B fixed var Exp( 73 9.2 7.41 1.79 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

1.88510332632982 + -0.00428770641895911 * :Distance from LSC + 74 8.97 7.41 1.56 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

Match( :Name( "Sensor Vert Posn T-B" ) 75 12.69 7.96 4.73 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

B -0.0517092529959019 76 7.08 7.96 -0.88 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

T 0.0517092529959019 77 12.79 8.12 4.67 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

. 78 8.73 8.12 0.61 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

) + Match( :LSC Core Load 10 -0.181779168472158 22 0.181779168472158 . ) + 79 8.7 7.88 0.82 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

(:Distance from LSC - 39.0223048327138) * Match( :LSC Core Load 80 8.58 7.88 0.70 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

10 0.00174676530378358 81 13.37 7.26 6.11 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

22 -0.00174676530378358 82 7.93 7.26 0.67 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

. 83 7.27 6.36 0.91 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

) + (:Distance from LSC - 39.0223048327138) * (:Distance from LSC - 84 6.44 6.36 0.08 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

39.0223048327138) * -0.000177638654225502 + Match( :Aluminum LSC Plate 109 6.14 11.83 -5.69 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

0 -0.54999674812178 110 3.58 11.83 -8.25 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

1 0.54999674812178 111 6.75 12.19 -5.44 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

. 112 4.81 12.19 -7.38 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

) 113 6.43 11.93 -5.50 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

) 114 3.53 11.93 -8.40 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

115 6.67 11.10 -4.43 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

116 5.29 11.10 -5.81 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

117 4.16 9.81 -5.65 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

118 4.82 9.81 -4.99 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

119 2.65 8.24 -5.59 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

120 2.71 8.24 -5.53 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

97 7.18 7.41 -0.23 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

98 5.35 7.41 -2.06 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

99 8.69 7.96 0.73 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

100 6.29 7.96 -1.67 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

101 12.7 8.12 4.58 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

102 5.33 8.12 -2.79 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

103 10.19 7.88 2.31 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

104 7.3 7.88 -0.58 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

105 9.92 7.26 2.66 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

106 9.46 7.26 2.20 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

107 8.21 6.36 1.85 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

108 5.47 6.36 -0.89 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

133 8.65 11.83 -3.18 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

134 19.6 11.83 7.77 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

135 19.18 12.19 6.99 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

136 6.83 12.19 -5.36 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

137 16 11.93 4.07 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

138 12.34 11.93 0.41 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

139 16.74 11.10 5.64 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

140 17.01 11.10 5.91 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

141 13.27 9.81 3.46 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

142 17.03 9.81 7.22 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

143 13.28 8.24 5.04 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

144 15.26 8.24 7.02 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

145 29.29 11.83 17.46 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

146 43.64 11.83 31.81 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

147 32.95 12.19 20.76 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

148 36.2 12.19 24.01 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

149 31.12 11.93 19.19 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

150 37.71 11.93 25.78 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

151 34.7 11.10 23.60 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

152 26.66 11.10 15.56 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

153 42.83 9.81 33.02 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

154 33.46 9.81 23.65 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

155 20.7 8.24 12.46 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

156 21.22 8.24 12.98 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

157 21.16 11.83 9.33 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

158 24.38 11.83 12.55 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

159 22.98 12.19 10.79 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

160 17.49 12.19 5.30 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

161 21.67 11.93 9.74 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

162 14.82 11.93 2.89 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

163 22.54 11.10 11.44 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

164 21.16 11.10 10.06 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

165 17.26 9.81 7.45 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

166 20.36 9.81 10.55 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

167 14.02 8.24 5.78 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

168 15.17 8.24 6.93 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

169 7.57 7.41 0.16 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

170 4.74 7.41 -2.67 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

171 8.81 7.96 0.85 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

172 6.45 7.96 -1.51 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

442 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

173 16.68 8.12 8.56 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

174 7.18 8.12 -0.94 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

175 15.32 7.88 7.44 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

176 6.69 7.88 -1.19 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

177 8.74 7.26 1.48 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

178 5.33 7.26 -1.93 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

179 4.98 6.36 -1.38 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

180 6.7 6.36 0.34 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

181 11.28 11.83 -0.55 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

182 10.59 11.83 -1.24 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

183 15.25 12.19 3.06 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

184 17.25 12.19 5.06 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

185 21.81 11.93 9.88 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

186 12.52 11.93 0.59 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

187 19.08 11.10 7.98 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

188 15.92 11.10 4.82 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

189 10.22 9.81 0.41 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

190 8.74 9.81 -1.07 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

191 11.4 8.24 3.16 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

192 9.66 8.24 1.42 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

205 18.03 7.41 10.62 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

206 22.91 7.41 15.50 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

207 24.86 7.96 16.90 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

208 10.15 7.96 2.19 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

209 22.47 8.12 14.35 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

210 15.11 8.12 6.99 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

211 26.28 7.88 18.40 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

212 23 7.88 15.12 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

213 11.59 7.26 4.33 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

214 13.81 7.26 6.55 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

215 11.5 6.36 5.14 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

216 9.26 6.36 2.90 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

229 7.18 7.41 -0.23 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

230 4.32 7.41 -3.09 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

231 6.03 7.96 -1.93 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

232 4.95 7.96 -3.01 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

233 8.58 8.12 0.46 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

234 7.65 8.12 -0.47 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

235 8.8 7.88 0.92 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

236 6.89 7.88 -0.99 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

237 5.04 7.26 -2.22 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

238 4.28 7.26 -2.98 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

239 4.62 6.36 -1.74 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

240 5.52 6.36 -0.84 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

241 9.81 11.83 -2.02 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

242 10.09 11.83 -1.74 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

243 10.21 12.19 -1.98 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

244 11.09 12.19 -1.10 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

245 9.03 11.93 -2.90 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

246 9.91 11.93 -2.02 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

247 8.35 11.10 -2.75 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

248 8.66 11.10 -2.44 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

249 9.26 9.81 -0.55 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

250 4.3 9.81 -5.51 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

251 6.53 8.24 -1.71 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

252 4.47 8.24 -3.77 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

253 3.2 7.41 -4.21 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

254 3.11 7.41 -4.30 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

255 4.11 7.96 -3.85 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

256 3.99 7.96 -3.97 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

257 4.52 8.12 -3.60 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

258 2.71 8.12 -5.41 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

259 1.88 7.88 -6.00 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

260 3.58 7.88 -4.30 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

261 4.01 7.26 -3.25 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

262 2.83 7.26 -4.43 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

263 4.03 6.36 -2.33 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

264 2.79 6.36 -3.57 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

265 13.81 11.83 1.98 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

266 13.37 11.83 1.54 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

267 13.91 12.19 1.72 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

268 10.48 12.19 -1.71 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

269 12.22 11.93 0.29 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

270 6.39 11.93 -5.54 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

271 8.61 11.10 -2.49 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

272 8.02 11.10 -3.08 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

273 6.53 9.81 -3.28 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

274 11.34 9.81 1.53 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

275 11.04 8.24 2.80 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

276 9.42 8.24 1.18 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

443 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

277 11.97 11.83 0.14 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

278 10.8 11.83 -1.03 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

279 10.45 12.19 -1.74 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

280 8.72 12.19 -3.47 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

281 7.03 11.93 -4.90 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

282 5.38 11.93 -6.55 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

283 4.65 11.10 -6.45 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

284 10.76 11.10 -0.34 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

285 7.46 9.81 -2.35 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

286 6.08 9.81 -3.73 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

287 16.31 8.24 8.07 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

288 8.07 8.24 -0.17 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

289 12.48 11.83 0.65 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

290 11.66 11.83 -0.17 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

291 13.84 12.19 1.65 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

292 12.6 12.19 0.41 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

293 16.38 11.93 4.45 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

294 10.43 11.93 -1.50 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

295 8.6 11.10 -2.50 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

296 9.64 11.10 -1.46 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

297 9.99 9.81 0.18 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

298 10.51 9.81 0.70 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

299 9.72 8.24 1.48 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

300 10.2 8.24 1.96 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

301 5.65 7.41 -1.76 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

302 6.16 7.41 -1.25 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

303 10.57 7.96 2.61 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

304 11.07 7.96 3.11 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

305 10.84 8.12 2.72 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

306 14.71 8.12 6.59 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

307 10.21 7.88 2.33 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

308 8.15 7.88 0.27 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

309 6.13 7.26 -1.13 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

310 5.32 7.26 -1.94 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

311 9.76 6.36 3.40 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

312 4.44 6.36 -1.92 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

313 2.52 7.41 -4.89 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

314 3.04 7.41 -4.37 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

315 2.72 7.96 -5.24 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

316 5.53 7.96 -2.43 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

317 5.93 8.12 -2.19 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

318 1.92 8.12 -6.20 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

319 2.17 7.88 -5.71 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

320 3.71 7.88 -4.17 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

321 5.08 7.26 -2.18 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

322 2.36 7.26 -4.90 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

323 2.49 6.36 -3.87 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

324 4.55 6.36 -1.81 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

325 5.79 2.46 3.33 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 1

326 5.15 2.46 2.69 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 2

327 4.03 2.65 1.38 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 3

328 4.15 2.65 1.50 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 4

329 3.96 2.70 1.26 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 5

330 3.52 2.70 0.82 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 6

331 2.46 2.62 -0.16 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 7

332 4.06 2.62 1.44 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 8

333 4.7 2.42 2.28 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 9

334 4.03 2.42 1.61 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 10

335 1.16 2.12 -0.96 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 11

336 1.74 2.12 -0.38 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 12

337 10.34 3.94 6.40 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

338 7.5 3.94 3.56 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

339 6.9 4.06 2.84 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

340 8.23 4.06 4.17 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

341 5.99 3.97 2.02 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

342 4.15 3.97 0.18 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

343 5.13 3.70 1.43 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

344 2.93 3.70 -0.77 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

345 11.31 3.27 8.04 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

346 11.29 3.27 8.02 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

347 1.73 2.74 -1.01 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

348 1.59 2.74 -1.15 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

361 5.49 7.41 -1.92 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

362 2.96 7.41 -4.45 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

363 4.86 7.96 -3.10 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

364 3.43 7.96 -4.53 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

365 4.48 8.12 -3.64 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

366 2.59 8.12 -5.53 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

367 4.19 7.88 -3.69 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

368 3.01 7.88 -4.87 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

369 3.82 7.26 -3.44 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

370 4.55 7.26 -2.71 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

371 1.91 6.36 -4.45 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

372 1.99 6.36 -4.37 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

349 7.99 11.83 -3.84 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

350 9.33 11.83 -2.50 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

444 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

351 11.5 12.19 -0.69 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

352 10.73 12.19 -1.46 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

353 11.75 11.93 -0.18 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

354 12.23 11.93 0.30 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

355 10.15 11.10 -0.95 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

356 9.07 11.10 -2.03 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

357 7.78 9.81 -2.03 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

358 6.85 9.81 -2.96 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

359 15.35 8.24 7.11 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

360 4.96 8.24 -3.28 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

121 6.52 11.83 -5.31 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

122 7.73 11.83 -4.10 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

123 11.27 12.19 -0.92 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

124 6.57 12.19 -5.62 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

125 11.99 11.93 0.06 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

126 7.06 11.93 -4.87 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

127 6.42 11.10 -4.68 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

128 8.88 11.10 -2.22 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

129 8.88 9.81 -0.93 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

130 5.85 9.81 -3.96 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

131 7.03 8.24 -1.21 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

132 3.54 8.24 -4.70 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

85 21.08 11.83 9.25 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

86 23.97 11.83 12.14 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

87 19.35 12.19 7.16 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

88 13.47 12.19 1.28 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

89 30.77 11.93 18.84 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

90 22.26 11.93 10.33 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

91 21.34 11.10 10.24 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

92 11.14 11.10 0.04 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

93 17.39 9.81 7.58 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

94 13.44 9.81 3.63 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

95 6.41 8.24 -1.83 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

96 11.3 8.24 3.06 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

409 1.81 3.94 -2.13 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

410 2.54 3.94 -1.40 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

411 2.46 4.06 -1.60 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

412 2.49 4.06 -1.57 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

413 2.22 3.97 -1.75 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

414 3.24 3.97 -0.73 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

415 3.95 3.70 0.25 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

416 2.46 3.70 -1.24 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

417 2.05 3.27 -1.22 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

418 2.27 3.27 -1.00 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

419 1.89 2.74 -0.85 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

420 1.29 2.74 -1.45 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

217 10.84 7.41 3.43 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

218 17.6 7.41 10.19 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

219 13.7 7.96 5.74 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

220 10.01 7.96 2.05 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

221 19.83 8.12 11.71 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

222 12.28 8.12 4.16 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

223 11.27 7.88 3.39 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

224 12.04 7.88 4.16 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

225 7.25 7.26 -0.01 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

226 16.29 7.26 9.03 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

227 8.47 6.36 2.11 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

228 15.64 6.36 9.28 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

193 12.68 11.83 0.85 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

194 8.6 11.83 -3.23 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

195 12.44 12.19 0.25 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

196 8.83 12.19 -3.36 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

197 11.25 11.93 -0.68 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

198 10.44 11.93 -1.49 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

199 9.22 11.10 -1.88 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

200 8.61 11.10 -2.49 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

201 5.59 9.81 -4.22 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

202 7.92 9.81 -1.89 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

203 5.64 8.24 -2.60 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

204 4.71 8.24 -3.53 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

373 5.5 7.41 -1.91 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

374 3.7 7.41 -3.71 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

375 2.38 7.96 -5.58 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

376 4.39 7.96 -3.57 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

377 3.61 8.12 -4.51 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

378 2.14 8.12 -5.98 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

379 6.06 7.88 -1.82 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

380 3.27 7.88 -4.61 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

381 3.12 7.26 -4.14 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

382 3.68 7.26 -3.58 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

383 5.16 6.36 -1.20 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

384 3.28 6.36 -3.08 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

385 10.04 11.83 -1.79 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

386 8.57 11.83 -3.26 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

445 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

387 9.92 12.19 -2.27 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

388 9.62 12.19 -2.57 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

389 6.28 11.93 -5.65 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

390 6.7 11.93 -5.23 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

391 9.39 11.10 -1.71 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

392 9.32 11.10 -1.78 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

393 7.91 9.81 -1.90 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

394 8.55 9.81 -1.26 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

395 6.16 8.24 -2.08 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

396 5.3 8.24 -2.94 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

397 2.53 3.94 -1.41 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

398 2.58 3.94 -1.36 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

399 3.36 4.06 -0.70 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

400 2.47 4.06 -1.59 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

401 2.93 3.97 -1.04 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

402 2.9 3.97 -1.07 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

403 2.69 3.70 -1.01 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

404 2.95 3.70 -0.75 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

405 2.46 3.27 -0.81 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

406 2.92 3.27 -0.35 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

407 1.95 2.74 -0.79 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

408 1.74 2.74 -1.00 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

481 15.79 11.83 3.96 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

482 16.44 11.83 4.61 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

483 16.62 12.19 4.43 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

484 12.98 12.19 0.79 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

485 13 11.93 1.07 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

486 10.58 11.93 -1.35 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

487 13.13 11.10 2.03 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

488 14.58 11.10 3.48 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

489 12.51 9.81 2.70 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

490 12.11 9.81 2.30 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

491 12.24 8.24 4.00 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

492 12.05 8.24 3.81 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

433 7.98 11.83 -3.85 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 1

434 6.38 11.83 -5.45 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 2

435 9.41 12.19 -2.78 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 3

436 6.98 12.19 -5.21 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 4

437 12.4 11.93 0.47 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 5

438 9.05 11.93 -2.88 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 6

439 6.41 11.10 -4.69 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 7

440 7.43 11.10 -3.67 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 8

441 5.33 9.81 -4.48 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 9

442 7.55 9.81 -2.26 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 10

443 10.06 8.24 1.82 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 11

444 11.77 8.24 3.53 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 12

421 14.36 11.83 2.53 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

422 9.22 11.83 -2.61 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

423 17.02 12.19 4.83 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

424 11.95 12.19 -0.24 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

425 21.71 11.93 9.78 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

426 6.24 11.93 -5.69 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

427 10.52 11.10 -0.58 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

428 13.63 11.10 2.53 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

429 12.85 9.81 3.04 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

430 8.16 9.81 -1.65 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

431 9.52 8.24 1.28 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

432 9.73 8.24 1.49 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

505 13.41 11.83 1.58 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 1

506 8.52 11.83 -3.31 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 2

507 11.49 12.19 -0.70 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 3

508 12.85 12.19 0.66 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 4

509 14.99 11.93 3.06 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 5

510 29.18 11.93 17.25 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 6

511 13.78 11.10 2.68 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 7

512 20.19 11.10 9.09 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 8

513 13.08 9.81 3.27 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 9

514 18.45 9.81 8.64 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 10

515 8.57 8.24 0.33 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 11

516 13.51 8.24 5.27 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 12

517 15.7 11.83 3.87 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

518 11.61 11.83 -0.22 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

519 16.75 12.19 4.56 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

520 11.46 12.19 -0.73 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

521 10.42 11.93 -1.51 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

522 15.66 11.93 3.73 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

446 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

523 23.14 11.10 12.04 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

524 22.74 11.10 11.64 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

525 14.06 9.81 4.25 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

526 7.7 9.81 -2.11 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

527 11.86 8.24 3.62 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

528 10.39 8.24 2.15 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

457 17.04 11.83 5.21 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 1

458 5.63 11.83 -6.20 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 2

459 12.54 12.19 0.35 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 3

460 9.12 12.19 -3.07 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 4

461 14.19 11.93 2.26 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5

462 10.28 11.93 -1.65 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 6

463 8.66 11.10 -2.44 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 7

464 6.57 11.10 -4.53 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 8

465 8.75 9.81 -1.06 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 9

466 5.42 9.81 -4.39 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 10

467 2.6 8.24 -5.64 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 11

468 3.81 8.24 -4.43 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 12

469 8.48 11.83 -3.35 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

470 8.46 11.83 -3.37 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

471 10.31 12.19 -1.88 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

472 8.21 12.19 -3.98 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

473 7.34 11.93 -4.59 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

474 7.46 11.93 -4.47 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

475 7.71 11.10 -3.39 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

476 6.84 11.10 -4.26 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

477 4.17 9.81 -5.64 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

478 6.11 9.81 -3.70 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

479 4.5 8.24 -3.74 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

480 7.1 8.24 -1.14 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

493 17.78 11.83 5.95 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

494 19.74 11.83 7.91 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

495 19.81 12.19 7.62 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

496 18.52 12.19 6.33 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

497 29.51 11.93 17.58 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

498 29.09 11.93 17.16 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

499 16.89 11.10 5.79 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

500 21.91 11.10 10.81 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

501 14.54 9.81 4.73 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

502 19.77 9.81 9.96 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

503 21.61 8.24 13.37 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

504 16.72 8.24 8.48 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

529 22.74 11.83 10.91 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

530 22.51 11.83 10.68 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

531 21.34 12.19 9.15 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

532 19.81 12.19 7.62 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

533 13.09 11.93 1.16 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

534 13.62 11.93 1.69 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

535 5.68 11.10 -5.42 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

536 5.51 11.10 -5.59 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

537 11.32 9.81 1.51 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

538 13.09 9.81 3.28 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

539 12.6 8.24 4.36 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

540 11.33 8.24 3.09 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

445 6.88 11.83 -4.95 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

446 4.35 11.83 -7.48 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

447 6.46 12.19 -5.73 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

448 5.14 12.19 -7.05 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

449 5.42 11.93 -6.51 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

450 7.03 11.93 -4.90 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

451 4.57 11.10 -6.53 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

452 2.92 11.10 -8.18 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

453 1.72 9.81 -8.09 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

454 2.71 9.81 -7.10 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

455 3.3 8.24 -4.94 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

456 3.39 8.24 -4.85 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

447 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Time Min G

Row Labels

Count of Pred 

MaxESDDisp 

Dist2 Dist x CL 

noTB Plate

c Time Min G Pred Formula 

Time Min G

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Sensor Vert 

Posn T-B

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Aluminum LSC 

Plate

Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever 0 Degree Channel

Variable Time of Minimum G 2.12 2 1 -6160 -5184.96 -975.04 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(abs(Time Min G)) 2.42 2 2 -5163 -5184.96 21.96 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

Table Other Preliminary Parameters 2.46 2 3 -3205 -3980.74 775.74 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

Model File 150120 1759 Abs Time Min G Dist2, Plate split-plot.jrp 2.62 2 4 -5198 -3980.74 -1217.26 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

Excluded Values Test P4 Channel 4: Clear low outlier; excluded by analyst without SME approval 2.65 2 5 -3617 -3255.07 -361.93 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 2.70 2 6 -3551 -3255.07 -295.93 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

2.74 6 7 -4786 -2834.88 -1951.12 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

Model -Exp( 3.27 6 8 -3371 -2834.88 -536.12 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

7.79677993066145 + -0.345537869774988 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + (( 3.70 6 9 -3357 -2629.58 -727.42 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 3.94 6 10 -3593 -2629.58 -963.42 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

0.196999372504149) + Match( :Aluminum LSC Plate, 3.97 6 11 -5155 -2597.86 -2557.14 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

0, -0.214201144626985, 4.06 6 12 -3681 -2597.86 -1083.14 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

1, 0.214201144626985, 6.36 32 13 -5380 -5184.96 -195.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

. 7.26 32 14 -7321 -5184.96 -2136.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

) 7.41 32 15 -4333 -3980.74 -352.26 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

) 7.88 32 16 -6015 -3980.74 -2034.26 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

7.96 32 17 -5349 -3255.07 -2093.93 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

8.12 32 18 -5449 -3255.07 -2193.93 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

8.24 50 19 -5048 -2834.88 -2213.12 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

9.81 50 20 -4840 -2834.88 -2005.12 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

11.10 50 21 -5584 -2629.58 -2954.42 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

11.83 50 22 -4480 -2629.58 -1850.42 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

11.93 50 23 -5429 -2597.86 -2831.14 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

12.19 50 24 -6723 -2597.86 -4125.14 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

Grand Total 540 25 -3945 -5184.96 1239.96 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

26 -3642 -5184.96 1542.96 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

27 -3097 -3980.74 883.74 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

Table of Estimates Average of Pred Formula Time Min G Distance from LSC 28 -3420 -3980.74 560.74 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

Aluminum LSC Plate 9 21 33 45 57 69 29 -2869 -3255.07 386.07 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

0 -3378.3 -2593.6 -2120.8 -1847.1 -1713.3 -1692.6 30 -2422 -3255.07 833.07 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

1 -5185.0 -3980.7 -3255.1 -2834.9 -2629.6 -2597.9 31 -2973 -2834.88 -138.12 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

32 -3230 -2834.88 -395.12 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

33 -2277 -2629.58 352.58 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

34 -2312 -2629.58 317.58 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

35 -2335 -2597.86 262.86 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

36 -2569 -2597.86 28.86 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

37 -4077 -5184.96 1107.96 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

38 -6068 -5184.96 -883.04 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

39 -2222 -3980.74 1758.74 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

Value omitted 40 -14 -3980.74 3966.74 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

41 -2061 -3255.07 1194.07 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

42 -2976 -3255.07 279.07 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

43 -1636 -2834.88 1198.88 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

44 -1568 -2834.88 1266.88 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

45 -1570 -2629.58 1059.58 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

46 -1513 -2629.58 1116.58 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

47 -1417 -2597.86 1180.86 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

48 -1376 -2597.86 1221.86 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

49 -3837 -5184.96 1347.96 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

50 -4546 -5184.96 638.96 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

51 -3578 -3980.74 402.74 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

52 -3808 -3980.74 172.74 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

53 -3698 -3255.07 -442.93 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

54 -3012 -3255.07 243.07 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

55 -2545 -2834.88 289.88 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

56 -2684 -2834.88 150.88 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

57 -2567 -2629.58 62.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

58 -2458 -2629.58 171.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

59 -2926 -2597.86 -328.14 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

60 -2489 -2597.86 108.86 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

61 -5189 -5184.96 -4.04 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

62 -5378 -5184.96 -193.04 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

Variance Components 63 -4560 -3980.74 -579.26 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var 

Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% Upper Pct of Total Std Dev

Random Effect

Variance Component

Component's 

Percent Share of 

Total Variance

Standard 

Deviation of 

Effect's 

Component 

(transformed 

units)

64 -3650 -3980.74 330.74 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

Panel No 1.8497921 0.0775164 0.020978 0.0364003 0.1186325 6491.0% 0.278417672 Panel-to-Panel 0.0775164 64.9% 0.2784177 65 -3454 -3255.07 -198.93 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

Test No -0.366942 -0.015377 0.0095668 -0.034128 0.0033737 0.0% #NUM! Test-to-Test -0.015377 0.0% 0.0000000 66 -3120 -3255.07 135.07 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

Residual 0.0419055 0.0026718 0.0371249 0.0476779 3509.0% 0.204708329 Within-Test 0.0419055 35.1% 0.2047083 67 -2637 -2834.88 197.88 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

Total 0.1194219 0.021119 0.0868387 0.1746209 10000.0% 0.345574739 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.1194219 100.0% 0.3455747 68 -3742 -2834.88 -907.12 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

69 -3473 -2629.58 -843.42 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

70 -3005 -2629.58 -375.42 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

71 -3330 -2597.86 -732.14 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

72 -2579 -2597.86 18.86 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

Alternate Model 73 -4662 -5184.96 522.96 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

448 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

74 -6908 -5184.96 -1723.04 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

75 -3369 -3980.74 611.74 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

76 -4208 -3980.74 -227.26 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

77 -3547 -3255.07 -291.93 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

78 -3038 -3255.07 217.07 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

79 -3377 -2834.88 -542.12 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

80 -2697 -2834.88 137.88 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

81 -3376 -2629.58 -746.42 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

82 -2547 -2629.58 82.58 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

83 -2851 -2597.86 -253.14 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

84 -2805 -2597.86 -207.14 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

109 -4228 -5184.96 956.96 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

110 -5341 -5184.96 -156.04 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

111 -3269 -3980.74 711.74 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

112 -3269 -3980.74 711.74 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

113 -3166 -3255.07 89.07 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

114 -3356 -3255.07 -100.93 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

115 -2400 -2834.88 434.88 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

116 -2850 -2834.88 -15.12 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

117 -2567 -2629.58 62.58 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

118 -2068 -2629.58 561.58 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

119 -2123 -2597.86 474.86 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

120 -2657 -2597.86 -59.14 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

97 -5650 -5184.96 -465.04 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

98 -5609 -5184.96 -424.04 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

99 -4086 -3980.74 -105.26 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

100 -3267 -3980.74 713.74 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

101 -3259 -3255.07 -3.93 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

102 -4771 -3255.07 -1515.93 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

103 -2284 -2834.88 550.88 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

104 -2311 -2834.88 523.88 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

105 -2734 -2629.58 -104.42 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

106 -2833 -2629.58 -203.42 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

107 -2439 -2597.86 158.86 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

108 -2638 -2597.86 -40.14 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

133 -4943 -5184.96 241.96 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

134 -6495 -5184.96 -1310.04 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

135 -3593 -3980.74 387.74 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

136 -6056 -3980.74 -2075.26 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

137 -4966 -3255.07 -1710.93 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

138 -5534 -3255.07 -2278.93 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

139 -4211 -2834.88 -1376.12 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

140 -3615 -2834.88 -780.12 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

141 -4198 -2629.58 -1568.42 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

142 -2816 -2629.58 -186.42 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

143 -3298 -2597.86 -700.14 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

144 -3706 -2597.86 -1108.14 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

145 -7215 -5184.96 -2030.04 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

146 -6960 -5184.96 -1775.04 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

147 -5202 -3980.74 -1221.26 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

148 -3761 -3980.74 219.74 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

149 -2991 -3255.07 264.07 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

150 -3667 -3255.07 -411.93 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

151 -3507 -2834.88 -672.12 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

152 -2790 -2834.88 44.88 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

153 -3269 -2629.58 -639.42 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

154 -3579 -2629.58 -949.42 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

155 -3276 -2597.86 -678.14 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

156 -2746 -2597.86 -148.14 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

157 -6799 -5184.96 -1614.04 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

158 -7559 -5184.96 -2374.04 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

159 -5258 -3980.74 -1277.26 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

160 -3526 -3980.74 454.74 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

161 -3262 -3255.07 -6.93 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

162 -4083 -3255.07 -827.93 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

163 -3183 -2834.88 -348.12 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

164 -3333 -2834.88 -498.12 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

165 -3988 -2629.58 -1358.42 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

166 -2792 -2629.58 -162.42 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

167 -4540 -2597.86 -1942.14 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

168 -2467 -2597.86 130.86 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

169 -6655 -5184.96 -1470.04 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

170 -5372 -5184.96 -187.04 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

171 -4004 -3980.74 -23.26 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

172 -6717 -3980.74 -2736.26 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

173 -4715 -3255.07 -1459.93 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

174 -2585 -3255.07 670.07 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

175 -4005 -2834.88 -1170.12 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

176 -2336 -2834.88 498.88 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

449 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

177 -3004 -2629.58 -374.42 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

178 -2769 -2629.58 -139.42 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

179 -2439 -2597.86 158.86 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

180 -2207 -2597.86 390.86 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

181 -4135 -5184.96 1049.96 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

182 -5255 -5184.96 -70.04 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

183 -3755 -3980.74 225.74 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

184 -4634 -3980.74 -653.26 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

185 -3949 -3255.07 -693.93 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

186 -4916 -3255.07 -1660.93 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

187 -4617 -2834.88 -1782.12 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

188 -2902 -2834.88 -67.12 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

189 -3205 -2629.58 -575.42 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

190 -2821 -2629.58 -191.42 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

191 -3414 -2597.86 -816.14 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

192 -2240 -2597.86 357.86 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

205 -8246 -5184.96 -3061.04 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

206 -8688 -5184.96 -3503.04 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

207 -4494 -3980.74 -513.26 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

208 -6865 -3980.74 -2884.26 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

209 -4817 -3255.07 -1561.93 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

210 -4848 -3255.07 -1592.93 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

211 -3574 -2834.88 -739.12 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

212 -4584 -2834.88 -1749.12 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

213 -3869 -2629.58 -1239.42 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

214 -3239 -2629.58 -609.42 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

215 -3463 -2597.86 -865.14 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

216 -4004 -2597.86 -1406.14 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

229 -6463 -5184.96 -1278.04 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

230 -4751 -5184.96 433.96 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

231 -5014 -3980.74 -1033.26 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

232 -3518 -3980.74 462.74 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

233 -3441 -3255.07 -185.93 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

234 -3063 -3255.07 192.07 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

235 -3790 -2834.88 -955.12 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

236 -3237 -2834.88 -402.12 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

237 -3684 -2629.58 -1054.42 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

238 -2686 -2629.58 -56.42 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

239 -2444 -2597.86 153.86 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

240 -2198 -2597.86 399.86 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

241 -6886 -5184.96 -1701.04 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

242 -6553 -5184.96 -1368.04 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

243 -3868 -3980.74 112.74 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

244 -2930 -3980.74 1050.74 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

245 -2611 -3255.07 644.07 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

246 -2369 -3255.07 886.07 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

247 -2390 -2834.88 444.88 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

248 -2219 -2834.88 615.88 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

249 -3148 -2629.58 -518.42 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

250 -2654 -2629.58 -24.42 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

251 -2410 -2597.86 187.86 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

252 -2066 -2597.86 531.86 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

253 -2727 -5184.96 2457.96 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

254 -3696 -5184.96 1488.96 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

255 -2275 -3980.74 1705.74 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

256 -2856 -3980.74 1124.74 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

257 -1592 -3255.07 1663.07 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

258 -1475 -3255.07 1780.07 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

259 -2086 -2834.88 748.88 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

260 -2091 -2834.88 743.88 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

261 -2057 -2629.58 572.58 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

262 -2142 -2629.58 487.58 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

263 -1499 -2597.86 1098.86 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

264 -1527 -2597.86 1070.86 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

265 -5086 -5184.96 98.96 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

266 -5088 -5184.96 96.96 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

267 -3421 -3980.74 559.74 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

268 -5016 -3980.74 -1035.26 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

269 -2826 -3255.07 429.07 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

270 -2349 -3255.07 906.07 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

271 -3067 -2834.88 -232.12 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

272 -3051 -2834.88 -216.12 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

273 -3112 -2629.58 -482.42 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

274 -2848 -2629.58 -218.42 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

275 -2947 -2597.86 -349.14 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

276 -3251 -2597.86 -653.14 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

277 -5884 -5184.96 -699.04 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

278 -6295 -5184.96 -1110.04 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

279 -4473 -3980.74 -492.26 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

280 -2945 -3980.74 1035.74 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

281 -3628 -3255.07 -372.93 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

282 -2638 -3255.07 617.07 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

283 -3137 -2834.88 -302.12 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

284 -2591 -2834.88 243.88 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

285 -3123 -2629.58 -493.42 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

286 -2933 -2629.58 -303.42 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

287 -3248 -2597.86 -650.14 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

450 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

288 -2948 -2597.86 -350.14 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

289 -6597 -5184.96 -1412.04 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

290 -6612 -5184.96 -1427.04 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

291 -4633 -3980.74 -652.26 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

292 -3795 -3980.74 185.74 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

293 -2877 -3255.07 378.07 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

294 -2181 -3255.07 1074.07 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

295 -2787 -2834.88 47.88 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

296 -2721 -2834.88 113.88 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

297 -3310 -2629.58 -680.42 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

298 -2881 -2629.58 -251.42 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

299 -2449 -2597.86 148.86 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

300 -2482 -2597.86 115.86 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

301 -3837 -5184.96 1347.96 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

302 -5129 -5184.96 55.96 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

303 -3421 -3980.74 559.74 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

304 -3491 -3980.74 489.74 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

305 -2497 -3255.07 758.07 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

306 -2242 -3255.07 1013.07 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

307 -2650 -2834.88 184.88 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

308 -3122 -2834.88 -287.12 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

309 -2689 -2629.58 -59.42 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

310 -2355 -2629.58 274.58 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

311 -3084 -2597.86 -486.14 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

312 -2974 -2597.86 -376.14 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

313 -3173 -5184.96 2011.96 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

314 -3608 -5184.96 1576.96 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

315 -3049 -3980.74 931.74 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

316 -3171 -3980.74 809.74 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

317 -1932 -3255.07 1323.07 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

318 -1666 -3255.07 1589.07 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

319 -1866 -2834.88 968.88 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

320 -1467 -2834.88 1367.88 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

321 -1866 -2629.58 763.58 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

322 -1545 -2629.58 1084.58 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

323 -1537 -2597.86 1060.86 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

324 -1281 -2597.86 1316.86 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

325 -2987 -3378.26 391.26 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 1

326 -3387 -3378.26 -8.74 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 2

327 -1860 -2593.65 733.65 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 3

328 -3056 -2593.65 -462.35 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 4

329 -2370 -2120.84 -249.16 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 5

330 -1961 -2120.84 159.84 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 6

331 -1380 -1847.06 467.06 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 7

332 -1996 -1847.06 -148.94 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 8

333 -1701 -1713.30 12.30 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 9

334 -1906 -1713.30 -192.70 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 10

335 -1570 -1692.63 122.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 11

336 -1732 -1692.63 -39.37 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 12

337 -6746 -3378.26 -3367.74 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

338 -7679 -3378.26 -4300.74 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

339 -5374 -2593.65 -2780.35 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

340 -4579 -2593.65 -1985.35 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

341 -5214 -2120.84 -3093.16 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

342 -5167 -2120.84 -3046.16 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

343 -3131 -1847.06 -1283.94 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

344 -3006 -1847.06 -1158.94 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

345 -2658 -1713.30 -944.70 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

346 -1920 -1713.30 -206.70 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

347 -1530 -1692.63 162.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

348 -1130 -1692.63 562.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

361 -4099 -5184.96 1085.96 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

362 -3129 -5184.96 2055.96 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

363 -2076 -3980.74 1904.74 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

364 -2885 -3980.74 1095.74 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

365 -2023 -3255.07 1232.07 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

366 -1532 -3255.07 1723.07 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

367 -1236 -2834.88 1598.88 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

368 -1121 -2834.88 1713.88 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

369 -1178 -2629.58 1451.58 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

370 -1276 -2629.58 1353.58 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

371 -1136 -2597.86 1461.86 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

372 -1169 -2597.86 1428.86 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

349 -5422 -5184.96 -237.04 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

350 -5769 -5184.96 -584.04 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

351 -3707 -3980.74 273.74 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

352 -4652 -3980.74 -671.26 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

353 -3055 -3255.07 200.07 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

354 -2222 -3255.07 1033.07 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

355 -3345 -2834.88 -510.12 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

356 -3133 -2834.88 -298.12 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

357 -3670 -2629.58 -1040.42 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

358 -3159 -2629.58 -529.42 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

359 -3238 -2597.86 -640.14 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

360 -2970 -2597.86 -372.14 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

121 -7668 -5184.96 -2483.04 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

122 -4887 -5184.96 297.96 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

123 -4298 -3980.74 -317.26 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

124 -5202 -3980.74 -1221.26 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

125 -4053 -3255.07 -797.93 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

451 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

126 -3142 -3255.07 113.07 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

127 -2928 -2834.88 -93.12 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

128 -2599 -2834.88 235.88 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

129 -2607 -2629.58 22.58 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

130 -1996 -2629.58 633.58 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

131 -2961 -2597.86 -363.14 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

132 -3081 -2597.86 -483.14 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

85 -5489 -5184.96 -304.04 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

86 -4654 -5184.96 530.96 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

87 -4120 -3980.74 -139.26 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

88 -3954 -3980.74 26.74 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

89 -3700 -3255.07 -444.93 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

90 -3549 -3255.07 -293.93 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

91 -3478 -2834.88 -643.12 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

92 -3203 -2834.88 -368.12 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

93 -3554 -2629.58 -924.42 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

94 -2503 -2629.58 126.58 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

95 -3783 -2597.86 -1185.14 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

96 -2536 -2597.86 61.86 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

409 -2642 -3378.26 736.26 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

410 -1810 -3378.26 1568.26 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

411 -1203 -2593.65 1390.65 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

412 -1595 -2593.65 998.65 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

413 -2024 -2120.84 96.84 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

414 -2139 -2120.84 -18.16 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

415 -2272 -1847.06 -424.94 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

416 -2492 -1847.06 -644.94 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

417 -2134 -1713.30 -420.70 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

418 -1681 -1713.30 32.30 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

419 -1660 -1692.63 32.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

420 -1404 -1692.63 288.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

217 -4947 -5184.96 237.96 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

218 -5027 -5184.96 157.96 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

219 -4901 -3980.74 -920.26 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

220 -4255 -3980.74 -274.26 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

221 -3319 -3255.07 -63.93 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

222 -3718 -3255.07 -462.93 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

223 -3326 -2834.88 -491.12 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

224 -3260 -2834.88 -425.12 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

225 -3080 -2629.58 -450.42 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

226 -2604 -2629.58 25.58 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

227 -3821 -2597.86 -1223.14 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

228 -3107 -2597.86 -509.14 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

193 -6681 -5184.96 -1496.04 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

194 -4445 -5184.96 739.96 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

195 -4896 -3980.74 -915.26 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

196 -3521 -3980.74 459.74 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

197 -4107 -3255.07 -851.93 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

198 -4106 -3255.07 -850.93 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

199 -3243 -2834.88 -408.12 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

200 -3134 -2834.88 -299.12 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

201 -3136 -2629.58 -506.42 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

202 -2291 -2629.58 338.58 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

203 -2812 -2597.86 -214.14 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

204 -2735 -2597.86 -137.14 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

373 -5017 -5184.96 167.96 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

374 -6056 -5184.96 -871.04 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

375 -3179 -3980.74 801.74 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

376 -2533 -3980.74 1447.74 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

377 -2982 -3255.07 273.07 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

378 -2798 -3255.07 457.07 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

379 -2613 -2834.88 221.88 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

380 -2113 -2834.88 721.88 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

381 -2564 -2629.58 65.58 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

382 -2296 -2629.58 333.58 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

383 -2778 -2597.86 -180.14 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

384 -2802 -2597.86 -204.14 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

385 -3214 -5184.96 1970.96 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

386 -6845 -5184.96 -1660.04 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

387 -3959 -3980.74 21.74 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

388 -3112 -3980.74 868.74 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

389 -2578 -3255.07 677.07 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

390 -2696 -3255.07 559.07 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

391 -2513 -2834.88 321.88 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

392 -2085 -2834.88 749.88 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

393 -2768 -2629.58 -138.42 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

394 -2032 -2629.58 597.58 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

395 -2211 -2597.86 386.86 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

396 -2952 -2597.86 -354.14 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

397 -2283 -3378.26 1095.26 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

398 -1676 -3378.26 1702.26 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

452 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

399 -1631 -2593.65 962.65 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

400 -1486 -2593.65 1107.65 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

401 -1345 -2120.84 775.84 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

402 -1423 -2120.84 697.84 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

403 -2586 -1847.06 -738.94 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

404 -1861 -1847.06 -13.94 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

405 -1419 -1713.30 294.30 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

406 -1189 -1713.30 524.30 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

407 -1351 -1692.63 341.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

408 -1422 -1692.63 270.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

481 -8779 -5184.96 -3594.04 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

482 -10529 -5184.96 -5344.04 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

483 -5423 -3980.74 -1442.26 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

484 -4780 -3980.74 -799.26 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

485 -3575 -3255.07 -319.93 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

486 -3368 -3255.07 -112.93 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

487 -3760 -2834.88 -925.12 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

488 -2996 -2834.88 -161.12 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

489 -4044 -2629.58 -1414.42 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

490 -3619 -2629.58 -989.42 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

491 -2724 -2597.86 -126.14 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

492 -2828 -2597.86 -230.14 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

433 -7487 -5184.96 -2302.04 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 1

434 -7280 -5184.96 -2095.04 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 2

435 -6210 -3980.74 -2229.26 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 3

436 -4581 -3980.74 -600.26 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 4

437 -4159 -3255.07 -903.93 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 5

438 -3135 -3255.07 120.07 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 6

439 -3846 -2834.88 -1011.12 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 7

440 -2639 -2834.88 195.88 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 8

441 -2806 -2629.58 -176.42 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 9

442 -2623 -2629.58 6.58 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 10

443 -2591 -2597.86 6.86 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 11

444 -2476 -2597.86 121.86 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 12

421 -3636 -5184.96 1548.96 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

422 -3829 -5184.96 1355.96 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

423 -4292 -3980.74 -311.26 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

424 -4054 -3980.74 -73.26 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

425 -3150 -3255.07 105.07 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

426 -2257 -3255.07 998.07 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

427 -2545 -2834.88 289.88 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

428 -2251 -2834.88 583.88 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

429 -2497 -2629.58 132.58 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

430 -2314 -2629.58 315.58 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

431 -2260 -2597.86 337.86 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

432 -2022 -2597.86 575.86 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

505 -5961 -5184.96 -776.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 1

506 -6894 -5184.96 -1709.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 2

507 -7264 -3980.74 -3283.26 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 3

508 -3611 -3980.74 369.74 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 4

509 -4042 -3255.07 -786.93 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 5

510 -4088 -3255.07 -832.93 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 6

511 -3683 -2834.88 -848.12 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 7

512 -3402 -2834.88 -567.12 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 8

513 -3018 -2629.58 -388.42 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 9

514 -4250 -2629.58 -1620.42 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 10

515 -3530 -2597.86 -932.14 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 11

516 -3890 -2597.86 -1292.14 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 12

517 -3600 -5184.96 1584.96 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

518 -4699 -5184.96 485.96 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

519 -4118 -3980.74 -137.26 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

520 -3125 -3980.74 855.74 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

521 -3536 -3255.07 -280.93 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

522 -2684 -3255.07 571.07 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

523 -1635 -2834.88 1199.88 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

524 -2381 -2834.88 453.88 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

525 -1881 -2629.58 748.58 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

526 -1592 -2629.58 1037.58 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

527 -1660 -2597.86 937.86 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

528 -1860 -2597.86 737.86 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

457 -4998 -5184.96 186.96 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 1

458 -6685 -5184.96 -1500.04 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 2

459 -3077 -3980.74 903.74 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 3

460 -3033 -3980.74 947.74 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 4

461 -3713 -3255.07 -457.93 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5

462 -2919 -3255.07 336.07 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 6

463 -2775 -2834.88 59.88 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 7

464 -2360 -2834.88 474.88 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 8

465 -2728 -2629.58 -98.42 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 9

466 -1944 -2629.58 685.58 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 10

467 -2606 -2597.86 -8.14 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 11

468 -1532 -2597.86 1065.86 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 12

469 -3420 -5184.96 1764.96 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

470 -3706 -5184.96 1478.96 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

471 -3757 -3980.74 223.74 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

472 -3922 -3980.74 58.74 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

473 -2960 -3255.07 295.07 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

474 -2574 -3255.07 681.07 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

475 -1985 -2834.88 849.88 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

453 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

476 -2113 -2834.88 721.88 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

477 -1462 -2629.58 1167.58 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

478 -1360 -2629.58 1269.58 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

479 -1135 -2597.86 1462.86 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

480 -1238 -2597.86 1359.86 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

493 -7159 -5184.96 -1974.04 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

494 -3887 -5184.96 1297.96 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

495 -4031 -3980.74 -50.26 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

496 -4156 -3980.74 -175.26 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

497 -6442 -3255.07 -3186.93 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

498 -5289 -3255.07 -2033.93 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

499 -5161 -2834.88 -2326.12 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

500 -6008 -2834.88 -3173.12 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

501 -4392 -2629.58 -1762.42 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

502 -4134 -2629.58 -1504.42 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

503 -4308 -2597.86 -1710.14 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

504 -6155 -2597.86 -3557.14 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

529 -5186 -5184.96 -1.04 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

530 -5980 -5184.96 -795.04 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

531 -3817 -3980.74 163.74 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

532 -4562 -3980.74 -581.26 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

533 -2682 -3255.07 573.07 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

534 -2590 -3255.07 665.07 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

535 -2261 -2834.88 573.88 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

536 -1925 -2834.88 909.88 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

537 -2268 -2629.58 361.58 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

538 -1909 -2629.58 720.58 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

539 -1963 -2597.86 634.86 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

540 -2011 -2597.86 586.86 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

445 -3884 -5184.96 1300.96 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

446 -4328 -5184.96 856.96 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

447 -3099 -3980.74 881.74 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

448 -3064 -3980.74 916.74 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

449 -2090 -3255.07 1165.07 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

450 -2238 -3255.07 1017.07 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

451 -2653 -2834.88 181.88 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

452 -1952 -2834.88 882.88 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

453 -1656 -2629.58 973.58 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

454 -1470 -2629.58 1159.58 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

455 -1399 -2597.86 1198.86 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

456 -1341 -2597.86 1256.86 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

454 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Max PV Freq

Row Labels

Count of Pred 

MaxESDDisp Dist2 

Dist x CL noTB 

Plate

c Time Min G Pred Formula 

Time Min G

Difference Test No Panel No Group Test Date No of Prev 

Tests on 

Panel

Distance 

from LSC

Sensor Vert 

Posn T-B

Panel Thickness LSC Core 

Load

Ply Type Type - Thick LSC Plate Aluminum 

LSC Plate

Acoustic 

Damped

Spliced 

LSC

Sever 0 Degree Channel

Variable Time of Minimum G 2.12 2 1 -6160 -5184.96 -975.04 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

Transformation log(abs(Time Min G)) 2.42 2 2 -5163 -5184.96 21.96 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 9 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

Table Other Preliminary Parameters 2.46 2 3 -3205 -3980.74 775.74 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

Model File 150120 1759 Abs Time Min G Dist2, Plate split-plot.jrp 2.62 2 4 -5198 -3980.74 -1217.26 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 21 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

Excluded Values Test P4 Channel 4: Clear low outlier; excluded by analyst without SME approval 2.65 2 5 -3617 -3255.07 -361.93 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

Tests 27, 28 not used in model creation; used as confirmation points. 2.70 2 6 -3551 -3255.07 -295.93 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 33 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

2.74 6 7 -4786 -2834.88 -1951.12 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

Model -Exp( 3.27 6 8 -3371 -2834.88 -536.12 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 45 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

7.79677993066145 + -0.345537869774988 * ((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) + (( 3.70 6 9 -3357 -2629.58 -727.42 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * (((:Distance from LSC - 39) / 30) * 3.94 6 10 -3593 -2629.58 -963.42 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 57 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

0.196999372504149) + Match( :Aluminum LSC Plate, 3.97 6 11 -5155 -2597.86 -2557.14 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 T 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

0, -0.214201144626985, 4.06 6 12 -3681 -2597.86 -1083.14 P1 P1 0 8/10/2012 0 69 B 0.187 10 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

1, 0.214201144626985, 6.36 32 13 -5380 -5184.96 -195.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

. 7.26 32 14 -7321 -5184.96 -2136.04 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

) 7.41 32 15 -4333 -3980.74 -352.26 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

) 7.88 32 16 -6015 -3980.74 -2034.26 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

7.96 32 17 -5349 -3255.07 -2093.93 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

8.12 32 18 -5449 -3255.07 -2193.93 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

8.24 50 19 -5048 -2834.88 -2213.12 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

9.81 50 20 -4840 -2834.88 -2005.12 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

11.10 50 21 -5584 -2629.58 -2954.42 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

11.83 50 22 -4480 -2629.58 -1850.42 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

11.93 50 23 -5429 -2597.86 -2831.14 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

12.19 50 24 -6723 -2597.86 -4125.14 P2 P1 0 8/16/2012 1 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

Grand Total 540 25 -3945 -5184.96 1239.96 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

26 -3642 -5184.96 1542.96 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

27 -3097 -3980.74 883.74 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

Table of Estimates Average of Pred Formula Time Min G Distance from LSC 28 -3420 -3980.74 560.74 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

Aluminum LSC Plate 9 21 33 45 57 69 29 -2869 -3255.07 386.07 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

0 -3378.3 -2593.6 -2120.8 -1847.1 -1713.3 -1692.6 30 -2422 -3255.07 833.07 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

1 -5185.0 -3980.7 -3255.1 -2834.9 -2629.6 -2597.9 31 -2973 -2834.88 -138.12 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

32 -3230 -2834.88 -395.12 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

33 -2277 -2629.58 352.58 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

34 -2312 -2629.58 317.58 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

35 -2335 -2597.86 262.86 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

36 -2569 -2597.86 28.86 P3 P3 0 9/10/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

37 -4077 -5184.96 1107.96 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

38 -6068 -5184.96 -883.04 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

39 -2222 -3980.74 1758.74 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

Value omitted 40 -14 -3980.74 3966.74 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

41 -2061 -3255.07 1194.07 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

42 -2976 -3255.07 279.07 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

43 -1636 -2834.88 1198.88 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

44 -1568 -2834.88 1266.88 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

45 -1570 -2629.58 1059.58 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

46 -1513 -2629.58 1116.58 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

47 -1417 -2597.86 1180.86 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

48 -1376 -2597.86 1221.86 P4 P4 0 11/30/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

49 -3837 -5184.96 1347.96 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

50 -4546 -5184.96 638.96 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

51 -3578 -3980.74 402.74 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

52 -3808 -3980.74 172.74 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

53 -3698 -3255.07 -442.93 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

54 -3012 -3255.07 243.07 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

55 -2545 -2834.88 289.88 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

56 -2684 -2834.88 150.88 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

57 -2567 -2629.58 62.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

58 -2458 -2629.58 171.58 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

59 -2926 -2597.86 -328.14 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

60 -2489 -2597.86 108.86 P5 P5 0 12/5/2012 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

61 -5189 -5184.96 -4.04 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

62 -5378 -5184.96 -193.04 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

Variance Components 63 -4560 -3980.74 -579.26 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

Variance Components Random Effect Var Ratio Var 

Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% Upper Pct of Total Std Dev

Random Effect

Variance Component

Component's 

Percent Share of 

Total Variance

Standard 

Deviation of 

Effect's 

Component 

(transformed 

units)

64 -3650 -3980.74 330.74 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

Panel No 1.8497921 0.0775164 0.020978 0.0364003 0.1186325 6491.0% 0.278417672 Panel-to-Panel 0.0775164 64.9% 0.2784177 65 -3454 -3255.07 -198.93 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

Test No -0.366942 -0.015377 0.0095668 -0.034128 0.0033737 0.0% #NUM! Test-to-Test -0.015377 0.0% 0.0000000 66 -3120 -3255.07 135.07 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

Residual 0.0419055 0.0026718 0.0371249 0.0476779 3509.0% 0.204708329 Within-Test 0.0419055 35.1% 0.2047083 67 -2637 -2834.88 197.88 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

Total 0.1194219 0.021119 0.0868387 0.1746209 10000.0% 0.345574739 Total Variability Not Explained by Model 0.1194219 100.0% 0.3455747 68 -3742 -2834.88 -907.12 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

69 -3473 -2629.58 -843.42 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

70 -3005 -2629.58 -375.42 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

71 -3330 -2597.86 -732.14 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

72 -2579 -2597.86 18.86 1 1 1 1/23/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

Alternate Model 73 -4662 -5184.96 522.96 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

455 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

74 -6908 -5184.96 -1723.04 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

75 -3369 -3980.74 611.74 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

76 -4208 -3980.74 -227.26 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

77 -3547 -3255.07 -291.93 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

78 -3038 -3255.07 217.07 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

79 -3377 -2834.88 -542.12 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

80 -2697 -2834.88 137.88 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

81 -3376 -2629.58 -746.42 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

82 -2547 -2629.58 82.58 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

83 -2851 -2597.86 -253.14 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

84 -2805 -2597.86 -207.14 2 2 1 1/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

109 -4228 -5184.96 956.96 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

110 -5341 -5184.96 -156.04 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

111 -3269 -3980.74 711.74 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

112 -3269 -3980.74 711.74 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

113 -3166 -3255.07 89.07 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

114 -3356 -3255.07 -100.93 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

115 -2400 -2834.88 434.88 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

116 -2850 -2834.88 -15.12 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

117 -2567 -2629.58 62.58 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

118 -2068 -2629.58 561.58 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

119 -2123 -2597.86 474.86 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

120 -2657 -2597.86 -59.14 4 4 1 2/5/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

97 -5650 -5184.96 -465.04 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

98 -5609 -5184.96 -424.04 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

99 -4086 -3980.74 -105.26 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

100 -3267 -3980.74 713.74 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

101 -3259 -3255.07 -3.93 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

102 -4771 -3255.07 -1515.93 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

103 -2284 -2834.88 550.88 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

104 -2311 -2834.88 523.88 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

105 -2734 -2629.58 -104.42 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

106 -2833 -2629.58 -203.42 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

107 -2439 -2597.86 158.86 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

108 -2638 -2597.86 -40.14 3 3 1 2/8/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

133 -4943 -5184.96 241.96 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

134 -6495 -5184.96 -1310.04 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

135 -3593 -3980.74 387.74 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

136 -6056 -3980.74 -2075.26 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

137 -4966 -3255.07 -1710.93 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

138 -5534 -3255.07 -2278.93 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

139 -4211 -2834.88 -1376.12 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

140 -3615 -2834.88 -780.12 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

141 -4198 -2629.58 -1568.42 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

142 -2816 -2629.58 -186.42 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

143 -3298 -2597.86 -700.14 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

144 -3706 -2597.86 -1108.14 5 5 1 2/22/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

145 -7215 -5184.96 -2030.04 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 1

146 -6960 -5184.96 -1775.04 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 2

147 -5202 -3980.74 -1221.26 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 3

148 -3761 -3980.74 219.74 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 4

149 -2991 -3255.07 264.07 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 5

150 -3667 -3255.07 -411.93 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 6

151 -3507 -2834.88 -672.12 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 7

152 -2790 -2834.88 44.88 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 8

153 -3269 -2629.58 -639.42 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 9

154 -3579 -2629.58 -949.42 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 10

155 -3276 -2597.86 -678.14 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 11

156 -2746 -2597.86 -148.14 6 6 1 5/8/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 0 12

157 -6799 -5184.96 -1614.04 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

158 -7559 -5184.96 -2374.04 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

159 -5258 -3980.74 -1277.26 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

160 -3526 -3980.74 454.74 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

161 -3262 -3255.07 -6.93 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

162 -4083 -3255.07 -827.93 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

163 -3183 -2834.88 -348.12 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

164 -3333 -2834.88 -498.12 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

165 -3988 -2629.58 -1358.42 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

166 -2792 -2629.58 -162.42 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

167 -4540 -2597.86 -1942.14 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

168 -2467 -2597.86 130.86 7 7 1 5/9/2013 0 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

169 -6655 -5184.96 -1470.04 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

170 -5372 -5184.96 -187.04 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 9 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

171 -4004 -3980.74 -23.26 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

172 -6717 -3980.74 -2736.26 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 21 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

173 -4715 -3255.07 -1459.93 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

174 -2585 -3255.07 670.07 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 33 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

175 -4005 -2834.88 -1170.12 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

176 -2336 -2834.88 498.88 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 45 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

177 -3004 -2629.58 -374.42 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

178 -2769 -2629.58 -139.42 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 57 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

179 -2439 -2597.86 158.86 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 T 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

180 -2207 -2597.86 390.86 8 8 1 5/16/2013 0 69 B 0.3 10 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

181 -4135 -5184.96 1049.96 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

182 -5255 -5184.96 -70.04 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

456 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

183 -3755 -3980.74 225.74 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

184 -4634 -3980.74 -653.26 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

185 -3949 -3255.07 -693.93 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

186 -4916 -3255.07 -1660.93 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

187 -4617 -2834.88 -1782.12 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

188 -2902 -2834.88 -67.12 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

189 -3205 -2629.58 -575.42 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

190 -2821 -2629.58 -191.42 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

191 -3414 -2597.86 -816.14 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

192 -2240 -2597.86 357.86 9 9 1 5/17/2013 0 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

205 -8246 -5184.96 -3061.04 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

206 -8688 -5184.96 -3503.04 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

207 -4494 -3980.74 -513.26 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

208 -6865 -3980.74 -2884.26 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

209 -4817 -3255.07 -1561.93 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

210 -4848 -3255.07 -1592.93 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

211 -3574 -2834.88 -739.12 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

212 -4584 -2834.88 -1749.12 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

213 -3869 -2629.58 -1239.42 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

214 -3239 -2629.58 -609.42 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

215 -3463 -2597.86 -865.14 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

216 -4004 -2597.86 -1406.14 10 10 1 5/29/2013 0 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

229 -6463 -5184.96 -1278.04 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

230 -4751 -5184.96 433.96 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

231 -5014 -3980.74 -1033.26 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

232 -3518 -3980.74 462.74 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

233 -3441 -3255.07 -185.93 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

234 -3063 -3255.07 192.07 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

235 -3790 -2834.88 -955.12 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

236 -3237 -2834.88 -402.12 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

237 -3684 -2629.58 -1054.42 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

238 -2686 -2629.58 -56.42 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

239 -2444 -2597.86 153.86 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

240 -2198 -2597.86 399.86 11 11 2 5/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

241 -6886 -5184.96 -1701.04 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

242 -6553 -5184.96 -1368.04 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

243 -3868 -3980.74 112.74 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

244 -2930 -3980.74 1050.74 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

245 -2611 -3255.07 644.07 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

246 -2369 -3255.07 886.07 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

247 -2390 -2834.88 444.88 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

248 -2219 -2834.88 615.88 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

249 -3148 -2629.58 -518.42 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

250 -2654 -2629.58 -24.42 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

251 -2410 -2597.86 187.86 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

252 -2066 -2597.86 531.86 12 14 2 6/28/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

253 -2727 -5184.96 2457.96 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

254 -3696 -5184.96 1488.96 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

255 -2275 -3980.74 1705.74 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

256 -2856 -3980.74 1124.74 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

257 -1592 -3255.07 1663.07 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

258 -1475 -3255.07 1780.07 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

259 -2086 -2834.88 748.88 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

260 -2091 -2834.88 743.88 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

261 -2057 -2629.58 572.58 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

262 -2142 -2629.58 487.58 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

263 -1499 -2597.86 1098.86 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

264 -1527 -2597.86 1070.86 13 13 2 7/16/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

265 -5086 -5184.96 98.96 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

266 -5088 -5184.96 96.96 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

267 -3421 -3980.74 559.74 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

268 -5016 -3980.74 -1035.26 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

269 -2826 -3255.07 429.07 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

270 -2349 -3255.07 906.07 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

271 -3067 -2834.88 -232.12 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

272 -3051 -2834.88 -216.12 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

273 -3112 -2629.58 -482.42 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

274 -2848 -2629.58 -218.42 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

275 -2947 -2597.86 -349.14 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

276 -3251 -2597.86 -653.14 14 12 2 7/17/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

277 -5884 -5184.96 -699.04 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

278 -6295 -5184.96 -1110.04 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

279 -4473 -3980.74 -492.26 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

280 -2945 -3980.74 1035.74 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

281 -3628 -3255.07 -372.93 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

282 -2638 -3255.07 617.07 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

283 -3137 -2834.88 -302.12 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

284 -2591 -2834.88 243.88 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

285 -3123 -2629.58 -493.42 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

286 -2933 -2629.58 -303.42 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

287 -3248 -2597.86 -650.14 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

288 -2948 -2597.86 -350.14 15 16 2 7/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

289 -6597 -5184.96 -1412.04 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

290 -6612 -5184.96 -1427.04 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

291 -4633 -3980.74 -652.26 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

457 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

292 -3795 -3980.74 185.74 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

293 -2877 -3255.07 378.07 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

294 -2181 -3255.07 1074.07 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

295 -2787 -2834.88 47.88 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

296 -2721 -2834.88 113.88 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

297 -3310 -2629.58 -680.42 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

298 -2881 -2629.58 -251.42 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

299 -2449 -2597.86 148.86 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

300 -2482 -2597.86 115.86 16 18 2 7/23/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

301 -3837 -5184.96 1347.96 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

302 -5129 -5184.96 55.96 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

303 -3421 -3980.74 559.74 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

304 -3491 -3980.74 489.74 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

305 -2497 -3255.07 758.07 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

306 -2242 -3255.07 1013.07 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

307 -2650 -2834.88 184.88 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

308 -3122 -2834.88 -287.12 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

309 -2689 -2629.58 -59.42 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

310 -2355 -2629.58 274.58 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

311 -3084 -2597.86 -486.14 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

312 -2974 -2597.86 -376.14 17 15 2 8/9/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

313 -3173 -5184.96 2011.96 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

314 -3608 -5184.96 1576.96 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

315 -3049 -3980.74 931.74 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

316 -3171 -3980.74 809.74 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

317 -1932 -3255.07 1323.07 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

318 -1666 -3255.07 1589.07 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

319 -1866 -2834.88 968.88 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

320 -1467 -2834.88 1367.88 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

321 -1866 -2629.58 763.58 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

322 -1545 -2629.58 1084.58 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

323 -1537 -2597.86 1060.86 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

324 -1281 -2597.86 1316.86 18 17 2 8/19/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

325 -2987 -3378.26 391.26 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 1

326 -3387 -3378.26 -8.74 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 2

327 -1860 -2593.65 733.65 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 3

328 -3056 -2593.65 -462.35 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 4

329 -2370 -2120.84 -249.16 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 5

330 -1961 -2120.84 159.84 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 6

331 -1380 -1847.06 467.06 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 7

332 -1996 -1847.06 -148.94 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 8

333 -1701 -1713.30 12.30 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 9

334 -1906 -1713.30 -192.70 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 10

335 -1570 -1692.63 122.63 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 11

336 -1732 -1692.63 -39.37 19 19 3 10/31/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 0 1 12

337 -6746 -3378.26 -3367.74 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

338 -7679 -3378.26 -4300.74 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

339 -5374 -2593.65 -2780.35 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

340 -4579 -2593.65 -1985.35 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

341 -5214 -2120.84 -3093.16 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

342 -5167 -2120.84 -3046.16 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

343 -3131 -1847.06 -1283.94 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

344 -3006 -1847.06 -1158.94 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

345 -2658 -1713.30 -944.70 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

346 -1920 -1713.30 -206.70 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

347 -1530 -1692.63 162.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

348 -1130 -1692.63 562.63 20 20 3 11/19/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

361 -4099 -5184.96 1085.96 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

362 -3129 -5184.96 2055.96 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

363 -2076 -3980.74 1904.74 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

364 -2885 -3980.74 1095.74 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

365 -2023 -3255.07 1232.07 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

366 -1532 -3255.07 1723.07 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

367 -1236 -2834.88 1598.88 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

368 -1121 -2834.88 1713.88 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

369 -1178 -2629.58 1451.58 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

370 -1276 -2629.58 1353.58 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

371 -1136 -2597.86 1461.86 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

372 -1169 -2597.86 1428.86 22 22 3 11/25/2013 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

349 -5422 -5184.96 -237.04 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

350 -5769 -5184.96 -584.04 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

351 -3707 -3980.74 273.74 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

352 -4652 -3980.74 -671.26 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

353 -3055 -3255.07 200.07 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

354 -2222 -3255.07 1033.07 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

355 -3345 -2834.88 -510.12 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

356 -3133 -2834.88 -298.12 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

357 -3670 -2629.58 -1040.42 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

358 -3159 -2629.58 -529.42 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

359 -3238 -2597.86 -640.14 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

360 -2970 -2597.86 -372.14 21 21 3 12/4/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

121 -7668 -5184.96 -2483.04 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

122 -4887 -5184.96 297.96 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

458 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

123 -4298 -3980.74 -317.26 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

124 -5202 -3980.74 -1221.26 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

125 -4053 -3255.07 -797.93 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

126 -3142 -3255.07 113.07 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

127 -2928 -2834.88 -93.12 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

128 -2599 -2834.88 235.88 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

129 -2607 -2629.58 22.58 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

130 -1996 -2629.58 633.58 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

131 -2961 -2597.86 -363.14 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

132 -3081 -2597.86 -483.14 4R 4 1 12/12/2013 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

85 -5489 -5184.96 -304.04 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

86 -4654 -5184.96 530.96 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 9 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

87 -4120 -3980.74 -139.26 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

88 -3954 -3980.74 26.74 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 21 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

89 -3700 -3255.07 -444.93 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

90 -3549 -3255.07 -293.93 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 33 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

91 -3478 -2834.88 -643.12 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

92 -3203 -2834.88 -368.12 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 45 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

93 -3554 -2629.58 -924.42 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

94 -2503 -2629.58 126.58 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 57 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

95 -3783 -2597.86 -1185.14 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 T 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

96 -2536 -2597.86 61.86 2R 2 1 12/16/2013 1 69 B 0.2 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

409 -2642 -3378.26 736.26 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

410 -1810 -3378.26 1568.26 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

411 -1203 -2593.65 1390.65 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

412 -1595 -2593.65 998.65 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

413 -2024 -2120.84 96.84 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

414 -2139 -2120.84 -18.16 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

415 -2272 -1847.06 -424.94 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7

416 -2492 -1847.06 -644.94 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

417 -2134 -1713.30 -420.70 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

418 -1681 -1713.30 32.30 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

419 -1660 -1692.63 32.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

420 -1404 -1692.63 288.63 26 26 3 12/18/2013 0 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Tape Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

217 -4947 -5184.96 237.96 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

218 -5027 -5184.96 157.96 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 9 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

219 -4901 -3980.74 -920.26 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

220 -4255 -3980.74 -274.26 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 21 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

221 -3319 -3255.07 -63.93 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

222 -3718 -3255.07 -462.93 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 33 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

223 -3326 -2834.88 -491.12 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

224 -3260 -2834.88 -425.12 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 45 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

225 -3080 -2629.58 -450.42 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

226 -2604 -2629.58 25.58 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 57 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

227 -3821 -2597.86 -1223.14 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 T 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

228 -3107 -2597.86 -509.14 10R 10 1 1/16/2014 1 69 B 0.2 10 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.2 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

193 -6681 -5184.96 -1496.04 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

194 -4445 -5184.96 739.96 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

195 -4896 -3980.74 -915.26 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

196 -3521 -3980.74 459.74 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

197 -4107 -3255.07 -851.93 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

198 -4106 -3255.07 -850.93 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

199 -3243 -2834.88 -408.12 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

200 -3134 -2834.88 -299.12 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

201 -3136 -2629.58 -506.42 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

202 -2291 -2629.58 338.58 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

203 -2812 -2597.86 -214.14 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

204 -2735 -2597.86 -137.14 9R 9 1 1/23/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Tape Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

373 -5017 -5184.96 167.96 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 1

374 -6056 -5184.96 -871.04 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 9 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 2

375 -3179 -3980.74 801.74 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 3

376 -2533 -3980.74 1447.74 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 21 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 4

377 -2982 -3255.07 273.07 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 5

378 -2798 -3255.07 457.07 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 33 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 6

379 -2613 -2834.88 221.88 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 7

380 -2113 -2834.88 721.88 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 45 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 8

381 -2564 -2629.58 65.58 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 9

382 -2296 -2629.58 333.58 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 57 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 10

383 -2778 -2597.86 -180.14 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 T 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 11

384 -2802 -2597.86 -204.14 23 23 3 4/18/2014 0 69 B 1 10 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 0 1 12

385 -3214 -5184.96 1970.96 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

386 -6845 -5184.96 -1660.04 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

387 -3959 -3980.74 21.74 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

388 -3112 -3980.74 868.74 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

389 -2578 -3255.07 677.07 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

390 -2696 -3255.07 559.07 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

391 -2513 -2834.88 321.88 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

392 -2085 -2834.88 749.88 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

393 -2768 -2629.58 -138.42 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

394 -2032 -2629.58 597.58 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

395 -2211 -2597.86 386.86 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

396 -2952 -2597.86 -354.14 24 24 3 4/22/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

397 -2283 -3378.26 1095.26 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 1

398 -1676 -3378.26 1702.26 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 9 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 2

399 -1631 -2593.65 962.65 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 3

400 -1486 -2593.65 1107.65 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 21 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 4

401 -1345 -2120.84 775.84 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 5

402 -1423 -2120.84 697.84 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 33 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 6

403 -2586 -1847.06 -738.94 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 7
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

459 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

404 -1861 -1847.06 -13.94 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 45 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 8

405 -1419 -1713.30 294.30 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 9

406 -1189 -1713.30 524.30 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 57 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 10

407 -1351 -1692.63 341.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 T 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 11

408 -1422 -1692.63 270.63 25 25 3 6/10/2014 0 69 B 1 22 Fabric Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Fabric Composite 0 0 0 1 1 12

481 -8779 -5184.96 -3594.04 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

482 -10529 -5184.96 -5344.04 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

483 -5423 -3980.74 -1442.26 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

484 -4780 -3980.74 -799.26 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

485 -3575 -3255.07 -319.93 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

486 -3368 -3255.07 -112.93 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

487 -3760 -2834.88 -925.12 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

488 -2996 -2834.88 -161.12 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

489 -4044 -2629.58 -1414.42 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

490 -3619 -2629.58 -989.42 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

491 -2724 -2597.86 -126.14 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

492 -2828 -2597.86 -230.14 A05 17 4 8/20/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

433 -7487 -5184.96 -2302.04 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 1

434 -7280 -5184.96 -2095.04 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 2

435 -6210 -3980.74 -2229.26 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 3

436 -4581 -3980.74 -600.26 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 4

437 -4159 -3255.07 -903.93 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 5

438 -3135 -3255.07 120.07 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 6

439 -3846 -2834.88 -1011.12 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 7

440 -2639 -2834.88 195.88 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 8

441 -2806 -2629.58 -176.42 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 9

442 -2623 -2629.58 6.58 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 10

443 -2591 -2597.86 6.86 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 11

444 -2476 -2597.86 121.86 A10 12 4 8/21/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 12

421 -3636 -5184.96 1548.96 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

422 -3829 -5184.96 1355.96 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

423 -4292 -3980.74 -311.26 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

424 -4054 -3980.74 -73.26 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

425 -3150 -3255.07 105.07 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

426 -2257 -3255.07 998.07 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

427 -2545 -2834.88 289.88 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

428 -2251 -2834.88 583.88 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

429 -2497 -2629.58 132.58 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

430 -2314 -2629.58 315.58 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

431 -2260 -2597.86 337.86 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

432 -2022 -2597.86 575.86 A01 8 4 8/25/2014 1 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

505 -5961 -5184.96 -776.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 1

506 -6894 -5184.96 -1709.04 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 2

507 -7264 -3980.74 -3283.26 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 3

508 -3611 -3980.74 369.74 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 4

509 -4042 -3255.07 -786.93 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 5

510 -4088 -3255.07 -832.93 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 6

511 -3683 -2834.88 -848.12 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 7

512 -3402 -2834.88 -567.12 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 8

513 -3018 -2629.58 -388.42 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 9

514 -4250 -2629.58 -1620.42 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 10

515 -3530 -2597.86 -932.14 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 11

516 -3890 -2597.86 -1292.14 A07 18 4 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 0 1 1 12

517 -3600 -5184.96 1584.96 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 1

518 -4699 -5184.96 485.96 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 2

519 -4118 -3980.74 -137.26 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 3

520 -3125 -3980.74 855.74 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 4

521 -3536 -3255.07 -280.93 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 5

522 -2684 -3255.07 571.07 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 6

523 -1635 -2834.88 1199.88 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 7

524 -2381 -2834.88 453.88 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 8

525 -1881 -2629.58 748.58 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 9

526 -1592 -2629.58 1037.58 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 10

527 -1660 -2597.86 937.86 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 11

528 -1860 -2597.86 737.86 A08 11 4 8/26/2014 1 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 0 0 1 1 12

457 -4998 -5184.96 186.96 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 1

458 -6685 -5184.96 -1500.04 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 2

459 -3077 -3980.74 903.74 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 3

460 -3033 -3980.74 947.74 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 4

461 -3713 -3255.07 -457.93 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 5

462 -2919 -3255.07 336.07 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 6

463 -2775 -2834.88 59.88 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 7

464 -2360 -2834.88 474.88 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 8

465 -2728 -2629.58 -98.42 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 9

466 -1944 -2629.58 685.58 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 10

467 -2606 -2597.86 -8.14 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 11

468 -1532 -2597.86 1065.86 A03 P1 4 8/27/2014 2 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 0 1 1 1 12

469 -3420 -5184.96 1764.96 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

460 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

470 -3706 -5184.96 1478.96 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 9 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

471 -3757 -3980.74 223.74 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

472 -3922 -3980.74 58.74 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 21 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

473 -2960 -3255.07 295.07 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

474 -2574 -3255.07 681.07 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 33 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

475 -1985 -2834.88 849.88 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

476 -2113 -2834.88 721.88 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 45 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

477 -1462 -2629.58 1167.58 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

478 -1360 -2629.58 1269.58 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 57 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

479 -1135 -2597.86 1462.86 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 T 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

480 -1238 -2597.86 1359.86 A04 P1 4 9/2/2014 3 69 B 0.187 22 Aluminum Homogeneous Aluminum - 0.187 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

493 -7159 -5184.96 -1974.04 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

494 -3887 -5184.96 1297.96 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

495 -4031 -3980.74 -50.26 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

496 -4156 -3980.74 -175.26 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

497 -6442 -3255.07 -3186.93 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

498 -5289 -3255.07 -2033.93 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

499 -5161 -2834.88 -2326.12 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

500 -6008 -2834.88 -3173.12 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

501 -4392 -2629.58 -1762.42 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

502 -4134 -2629.58 -1504.42 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

503 -4308 -2597.86 -1710.14 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

504 -6155 -2597.86 -3557.14 A06 17 4 9/3/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Rohacell Rohacell - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

529 -5186 -5184.96 -1.04 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

530 -5980 -5184.96 -795.04 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 9 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

531 -3817 -3980.74 163.74 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

532 -4562 -3980.74 -581.26 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 21 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

533 -2682 -3255.07 573.07 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

534 -2590 -3255.07 665.07 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 33 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

535 -2261 -2834.88 573.88 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

536 -1925 -2834.88 909.88 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 45 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

537 -2268 -2629.58 361.58 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

538 -1909 -2629.58 720.58 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 57 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

539 -1963 -2597.86 634.86 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 T 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

540 -2011 -2597.86 586.86 A09 11 4 9/4/2014 2 69 B 1 22 Tape Al Honey Al Honey - 1 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12

445 -3884 -5184.96 1300.96 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 1

446 -4328 -5184.96 856.96 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 9 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 2

447 -3099 -3980.74 881.74 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 3

448 -3064 -3980.74 916.74 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 21 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 4

449 -2090 -3255.07 1165.07 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 5

450 -2238 -3255.07 1017.07 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 33 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 6

451 -2653 -2834.88 181.88 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 7

452 -1952 -2834.88 882.88 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 45 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 8

453 -1656 -2629.58 973.58 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 9

454 -1470 -2629.58 1159.58 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 57 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 10

455 -1399 -2597.86 1198.86 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 T 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 11

456 -1341 -2597.86 1256.86 A02 8 4 9/5/2014 2 69 B 0.3 22 Fabric Monolithic Monolithic - 0.3 Aluminum 1 1 1 1 1 12
NASA Engineering and Safety Center 

Technical Assessment Report 

Document #:

NESC-RP12-00783

Version:

1.0

Title:

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Page #:

461 of 461

NESC Request No.: TI-12-00783

Variance Components Worksheet

Figure C1. Summary of Results – Test Configuration and Associated Data

Transformed variable. Table for charts

Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% Upper Pct of Total Column1 CORRECT ROW NAMES HERE Random Effect

Variance 

Component

Variance 

Component 

Standard Deviation

Percent of 

Total

Panel No[Panel Thickness] 0.3986457 0.0386089 0.1074376 -0.171965 0.2491827 11.669 Panel No[Panel Thickness] Panel-to-Panel 0.0386 0.1965 12%

Test No[Panel No] 2.017498 0.1953949 0.1011628 -0.002881 0.3936704 59.058 Test No[Panel No] Test-to-Test 0.1954 0.4420 59%

Residual 0.0968501 0.0061939 0.0857708 0.1102358 29.273 Residual Within-Test 0.0969 0.3112 29%

Total 0.3308539 0.0555536 0.244184 0.4737575 100 Total Total 0.3309 0.5752 100%

Random Effect Var Ratio Var Component Std Error 95% Lower 95% Upper Pct of Total

Panel No 0.3986457 0.0386089 0.1074376 -0.171965 0.2491827 11.669

Test No[LSC Core Load,Aluminum LSC Plate,Panel No] 2.017498 0.1953949 0.1011628 -0.002881 0.3936704 59.058

Residual 0.0968501 0.0061939 0.0857708 0.1102358 29.273

Total 0.3308539 0.0555536 0.244184 0.4737575 100

Analysis Variables

Test 

No.[Panel 

No]& 

Random

Panel No[Panel Thickness]& 

Random

Distance 

from LSC

Panel 

Thickness

LSC Core 

Load Ply

Panel 

Thickness*L

SC Core 

Load

Panel 

Thickness*P

ly

Panel 

Thickness*D

istance from 

LSC

LSC Core 

Load*Ply

LSC Core 

Load*Distan

ce from LSC

Ply*Distance 

from LSC

Distance 

from LSC * 

Distance 

from LSC

Sensor Vert 

Posn T-B

Fit Model(

0.0201 0.0258508 0.0057508 0.286109453 Cause( :Freq Break Censor ),

0.02043 0.01583 -0.0046 -0.22515908 Y( :First Frequency Break Point ),

Effects(

:Test No[:Panel No] & Random,

:Panel No[:Panel Thickness, :Ply] & Random,

:Distance from LSC,

:Panel Thickness,

:LSC Core Load,

:Ply,

:Distance from LSC * :Panel Thickness,

:Distance from LSC * :LSC Core Load,

:Distance from LSC * :Ply,

:Panel Thickness * :LSC Core Load,

:Panel Thickness * :Ply,

:LSC Core Load * :Ply

) ,

Keep dialog open( 1 ),

Personality( "Standard Least Squares" ),

Emphasis( Effect Leverage ),

Method( REML )

) ;

Level Least Sq Mean What Std Error Lower 95% Upper 95%

[2]2 2029.1904 Test 200.33077 1338.4982 2719.8827

[2]2R 2011.9683 Test 201.18087 1270.4195 2753.5171

[3]3 2007.1819 Test 199.73648 1320.7738 2693.5899

[4]4 1987.4149 Test 201.50704 1251.0639 2723.766

[4]4R 2052.1476 Test 199.51699 1407.0857 2697.2095

[5]5 2037.4932 Test 199.33959 1370.6639 2704.3225

[7]7 2011.1243 Test 199.46104 1338.247 2684.0016

[8]8 2019.2974 Test 199.36046 1363.1422 2675.4525

[8]A1 2006.6984 Test 203.01733 1112.718 2900.6789

[9]9 1999.1126 Test 199.68961 1354.0976 2644.1275

[9]9R 2019.7064 Test 200.75317 1332.4648 2706.948

[10]10 2020.6784 Test 199.33959 1353.8491 2687.5077

[Fabric,0.2]2 2105.8767 Panel 177.75969 1670.3671 2541.3862

[Fabric,0.2]7 1659.121 Panel 209.29856 1096.9284 2221.3137

[Fabric,0.3]4 2051.854 Panel 177.98082 1626.6798 2477.0282

[Fabric,0.3]8 1592.6835 Panel 204.36962 1090.1478 2095.2192

[Tape,0.2]5 2880.4835 Panel 213.15237 2323.0191 3437.9479

[Tape,0.2]10 2311.3835 Panel 213.15237 1753.9191 2868.8479

[Tape,0.3]3 1854.5904 Panel 255.38973 1302.4228 2406.758

[Tape,0.3]9 1678.6832 Panel 174.38324 1260.8844 2096.482

(Calculated using transformed response variable)
REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE Form Approved

OMB No. 0704-0188

2. REPORT TYPE 

Technical Memorandum

 4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE

Empirical Model Development for Predicting Shock Response on 

Composite Materials Subjected to Pyroshock Loading

Appendices

5a. CONTRACT NUMBER

 6. AUTHOR(S)

Gentz, Steven J.; Ordway, David O.; Parsons, David S.; Garrison, Craig 

M.; 

Rodgers, C. Steven; Collins, Brian W.

 7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES)

NASA Langley Research Center

Hampton, VA 23681-2199

 9. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES)

National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Washington, DC 20546-0001

 8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION

 REPORT NUMBER

L-20593 NESC-RP-12-00783

10. SPONSOR/MONITOR'S ACRONYM(S)

NASA

13. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

12. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY STATEMENT

Unclassified - Unlimited

Subject Category 24 Composite Materials

Availability: NASA STI Program (757) 864-9658

19a. NAME OF RESPONSIBLE PERSON

STI Help Desk (email: help@sti.nasa.gov)

14. ABSTRACT

The NASA Engineering and Safety Center (NESC) received a request to develop an analysis model based on both frequency 

response and wave propagation analyses for predicting shock response spectrum (SRS) on composite materials subjected to 

pyroshock loading. The model would account for near-field environment (~9 inches from the source) dominated by direct 

wave propagation, mid-field environment (~2 feet from the source) characterized by wave propagation and structural 

resonances, and far-field environment dominated by lower frequency bending waves in the structure. This document contains 

appendices to the Volume I report.

15. SUBJECT TERMS

NASA Engineering and Safety Center; Shock response spectrum; Pyroshock loading; Model development

18. NUMBER

 OF 

 PAGES

466

19b. TELEPHONE NUMBER (Include area code)

(443) 757-5802

a. REPORT

U

c. THIS PAGE

U

b. ABSTRACT

U

17. LIMITATION OF 

 ABSTRACT

UU

Prescribed by ANSI Std. Z39.18

Standard Form 298 (Rev. 8-98)

3. DATES COVERED (From - To)

April 2012 - April 2015

5b. GRANT NUMBER

5c. PROGRAM ELEMENT NUMBER

5d. PROJECT NUMBER

5e. TASK NUMBER

5f. WORK UNIT NUMBER

869021.05.05.09.13

11. SPONSOR/MONITOR'S REPORT

 NUMBER(S)

NASA/TM-2015-218781/Volume II/Part 3

16. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF:

The public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, 

gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this 

collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Department of Defense, Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and 

Reports (0704-0188), 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person 

shall be subject to any penalty for failing to comply with a collection of information if it does not display a currently valid OMB control number.

PLEASE DO NOT RETURN YOUR FORM TO THE ABOVE ADDRESS.

1. REPORT DATE (DD-MM-YYYY)

01- 07 - 2015