UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTE C TION AGENCY WASHI N GTO N , D . C . 20 4 60

OFFICE OF AIR -"NO RADIATI O N 

### MEM ORA N D UM Subject: From: To: Summary of S t ake hold er Meetin gs Car i ssa Cy ran D ocket s E P A -HQ-OAR-20 1 3 -060 2. E P A -HQ-OAR- 2 0 1 3 -0603. a nd EPA-HQO A R- 20 1 3 - 0495 T hi s m e morandum s umm a ri zes m ee t ing s wi th s t ake h o ld e r s during the week of A pril 13 . 2015. Ap ril 1 2. Administrator McCarthy met w i th r ep r ese ntati ves f r om th e Na ti o n a l Rural E lectric Coo p e rati ve Assoc i ation. O n Apr il 13 , Associate Assista nt Ad mini st rator f o r C lim ate and Se ni or Co un se l fo r Ai r and R ad iation Joseph Go t Tma n met w ith repr esen t a ti ves from Nat ural R esource D e fense Council. S i g n-in s heet attached. On Ap ril 14. Assoc iat e A s s i s tant A dmini s trat o r for Cl imat e and Senior Co un se l for A ir and R ad iation J oseph Go f fman m et w ith repre se ntati ve s from N uclear Energy I n s titute and Edison E le c tric Institute. S i g n-in s h eet attached. On A pril 14. Actin g Ass i sta nt Adminis tr ator for A ir a nd Radiatio n Jan e t M cCa b e a nd Ass ociat e A ss i s tant Admin i s tr a t o r fo r C l imate a nd Se ni or Co un se l f o r A ir and R adia ti o n J oseph Goffman m et w ith r ep r ese nt at i ves fro m Duk e Ener gy. S i gn- in s heet attached. On Ap ril 15 . Associate Ass i s t ant Ad mini s trat o r for C limat e and Seni o r Co un se l for A ir and Radiation Jo se ph Goffman met w ith repre se ntati ves fr o m seve r al T exas e l ec tri c coope rati ves . including Eas t T exa s E l ec tri c Cooperative . Sam R ayb urn G&T , o rth eas t Texas E lectric Coope r ative, U p s hur-Rur a l E l ec tric Cooperative, W ood County E l ectric Coo p e r ative, a nd Sam ll ous t o n E lectric Coo p e r a tive. S i g n-in sheet attached. On A pril 15, Ac t i n g Ass i s t ant A dmini s tr a tor J a n e t M cCa b e a nd A ss oc i ate Ass i s tant Ad mini s t r ator for C lim a t e a nd Se ni or Co un se l to r A ir a nd Radiati on J osep h GotTman participated in a me e tin g w ith s t a t e of fi c i a l s orga ni ze d b y the Georgetown C li m a t e Ce nter. S i g nin s h ee t attached . O n April 15 , Act in g A s sis t ant A dmini s trator tor Ai r and R ad iation J a n et McCabe a nd Associate Ass i s t a nt Administrator for C limate and Se ni o r Co un se l fo r A ir a n d Radi a ti o n J osep h Goff m a n
Internet Address (URL) • http //w ww epa gov R ec y c led / R ec y c labl e ·

**Pr~nted** w1th Vege t able Oil Based Inks on 100 Postconsumer Process Chtonne Free Recycled Papermet with representatives from Entergy Corporation. Sign-in sheet and presentation from the meeting are attached. On April 15, Act in g Assistant Administrator fo r Air and R adiation Janet Mc Ca be and Associate Ass i sta nt Ad mini strator l or Climate and Senior Co un se l for Air and Radiati o n J oseph Goffman met w ith representatives from Wisconsin utilities. includin g WPPl Energy. We E n ergies, Integrys Busine ss Support. Madison Gas and E l ectric. All iant Energy a nd Excel Energy. O n Ap ril 16 . Associa t e Assista nt Admi ni strator for Climate and Se ni or Counsel f or Air and Radiation Joseph Goffman met with representatives from FirstEner gy. Sign-in shee t attached. On April 17, Associate Ass i s tant Administrator l or C limate and Senior Co un se l for Air and Radiation J oseph Goffman met w ith representativ es from The Earth Partn e r s. S i g n-in s h eet attached.

### Date: Ap ril13 , 2015 

### Meeting: lli(d) Discussion Meeting Rule(s) Discus s ed: 

# G P 

# P Written Materials? Y 

# e@ Name Or ga nization Phon e N umber



# - ) t+v \ \) D J N 

# '1i'-y" (l) 

# f. t)c '14 

# z :z-'8'1 . 

## -z- Yln



# ~~ tv(l.}J(_
I 

# t- •'1-- 5 (

**~** 

# (, 'J.) l,



# o~~~ **MtJ r**  **\'J~9e-** -. Jk ) ?.. -



### ?.~1

**·** 

## ;)!f 

# J/

**~6 .:(_**  **/) 1**  

# / t\J 9. 6}c, d l l- . 7 2 7 - '-{6 )'1



# Jk

**fli&~** 

# r;C A- I 

### 2 tJL 

# J'l( 

# 7}'- CY



# 4lA **~lffi lfktA/I**  

# f l I I 

### 7CJ 2- 

# 5""&y

**~** I 

# f/ i/ 7/w . (A( **~** 

### ;< 

## '< I r v ( 

# 1 I 

# -+ I 

# I I 

# ---+-- =-=!- I I

### Date: Apri l 14 , 2015 Meeting: N ucl ear E nergy a nd 111(d) Discus s ion Rule(s) Discussed: 

### Written Materials? 

# Y & Name Organizat i on 

# ! Phon e N urn b e r



# 0r~ **V'Vz£1~ ~8Jtn~**  

# tJJ{nMC 

# w'L
. {?tl. 

## '?oL-1



# £~ LlJ olu



# A ,( rl tStv ,



# n~ **J ~~**  **1u-e 202-SO~-)**  **[V** 

# S C

**tL e**  

## S + t i 111 -0(' 

### EPP... cJo c;.. 

### 3 

### L!-



## ~ 

# q I 

# "'i · l



# f?~ **J.** 

# Jla rve'-/ pfA- :Lo4--?7's 

## - 1' 

## Yz9



# ~ e t f 11 "/ 

# JJ 

# \. / f ,

**I~'-'"'** 

# c fO/) 

# 802 )c ·· 

# -vc '' I


# Ul!W~ E"PA-

**2~** L



## .?~Y **~** '3/'C/



# L~v 

# (//) I l 

# I I I , _ 

# I 

# I

### Date :



# Th **fS~** 1 

# !Tp W I f, :l OJS 

# Lt f- 

# tf 

# 3.'yrn Meeting: 

# 'J) G t.lt L 

# t:Yi tX. trJ Rule(s) Discussed:



### ~ 

# P 

# P Written Materials? 

### Y 

# e@ Name Organization
I ( 

## r( 1\ 

### (( 

# ,, I( I ( I ( 

### Phone Number 

# 7 °Y - . ] 

# 6 2- J)fj/
2_02- /( (( r t 

### r( ( ( 

### '( ( ( 

### !( I( 

### I( (( f(

### Date: April 15 , 2015 Meeting: Co-Ops Follow Up Meeting Rule(s) Discussed: 

# c rP Written Materials?

## Yes**~** Name Organ i zation Phone N urn ber 

# 7 o 7 · -

### DAt.,

# IJJulne~**,** 

# ftr w._**~J** i-O)} 

## uj;

# ~~**!Yl** Meeting:

# ~ fo 'viJVl 

# Ctcmd0

# €.1**~.-t.uu** Pl eiJ\11 

# L:J VY/eelyy Rule(s)Discussed:

# Lc~**'o on** **c'-~** C'N'.( \ 

# L\t.\>J\**we._r** Written Materials?

### Y~ Name Organization Phone N urn ber 

# 3VNV\J{;J**~** 

# N VvJ '/ e -.k_**(.SI~)** 2- 5 C, 

# -J' 1p6 

# :sl/ J

'c. JJ 

# sV\ · '1

/ir ;J t <-./ '( 

### v- (__ 

# s**I~** '- / 0 

### Z -

### .C**l(** 

## 4

# ~ viu-

# A-r~AJ**Ueh' ~**  

# 2JJz_ - fo(o f - 

# ee . r:rtp v 

# u v

# ~ .19-£-.TJt . A 

## f2v OJL--p/f I 

# thtc {);;.!)- t:JFfJuf!,;_ rr rJ:;A.u71 l]y;._)\1

### 3os-&9.J..:.~~:/(:-

# ~ l.A) - ( \ f',\ 1YbN \ 

# ( Lf 0 

# I ) 'L U - 7_ 

# i 

# 1 / 'IJ&.v · l 

# d**-r"~** 'f"f0 

# tu**~** ' 

# VV\ it-JIVe.**~D** 

# k oSl-**t-s-:;-z~s-2-**

## z~v**l"** c\, 1 1 1 

## qov- £t{J!J. .2 0 2 - .)C.,""\ .- o<-., I \

# -o~~WaM._**~B** -:2- 6 

### "2. 

# '3 tf3 <fl <.(<{)

### j

### f(**;r((/~ '7** **6~/1--** 2o2-
- "3 o/ -:? 

### -1'12 "J

# C~-t.

# O~**~:~K** Ceo"'i-e 

# \o._,V) 20 ":) -**'(~f) ~**  

# J 

# 1 ;lo 

### " 

# L ,**~6~ L;V\** **c~** 

# G fO t C-.f 

## -\6 .._;)V) 

### L- oL_-

### u~**\-** 

# (;**~L\** 

# g**:fu\, ~5-C~~**  u 

# Bf' I 

# o L -**'-t~** 

# - t1\**~**

# tc**t~** 

# I-t**GLb.u** J 

# ' &If- ( TI R; 

# 9rrff fVwt/) 

# & rr- '-/ t/

## ( I - _) j\ --1- 

### tL 30YJYYI 

### Date: 

# W e.oL;rPJ 

# J 

# a:J , AfteL -

**~** 1 

### 0 .) CVL 

### 1 

### r Meeting: 

# - 6-!t{k. 

# ;J.j Rule(s) Discussed: 

# G p 

# p Written Materials@No 

### Name Organization Phone Number 

# C

f7



# ~I~ 

# 0 IJJtJ1:!



# lc~v **&1-l.& ::c,~,**  GJ(a 

# 0o I (.,

**~** 

# R 17 

# 3S3 (c )



# ·~, 

# ( I

**~[A** IAA. () oJ (._ J 

### I I 

### )_{)J - ( 

## · s

**~** 

## - 

# 11 f ((

**~ {~**  **(!~ ~~ftc**  

# f?e1 A Jfp,·,-



# ~<ev 

# hit- :Zo·:z_ 

## -·'Jt':S fcp-1 

# --s- 6 

## c (;..,; ' 'If""'"'"\



## ~~ ').<VI{1'"' 

### f-1c t'



### ~ 

## bt.' 

# 6{/1-

# ·- "' :::l 

# al



# > ...... 

# ·- 

# - ·- ...... :::::) V) 

# ' 

# >

bll

**~** 

### QJ 

# ...... c: 

# wEntergy

• Has supported

an economy-wide price on carbon (cap-and-trade

or tax)

since 2000

• Was the first investor-owned utility to adopt

a voluntary

cap on carbon emissions,

now stated

as 20 % below 2000 levels through 2020

• Significant emissions reductions between 2000 and 2005 due to this commitment (19.6% reduction in the Utility from 2000-2005; 40% in the company as a whole); reductions have continued

over the years at a

slower

pace

• Singled out by Administrator McCarty during the announcement of the

111(d) proposed rule as one of three leaders in taking early action

• Only U.S. electric utility in its sector named to the Dow Jones Sustainability

Inde x World Index in 2014 **~**Entergy Utility achieved these reductions by:

• $3.2 billion in Fleet Transformation since 2007 (less efficient gas to higher efficiency gas)

3,875 MW CCGT while retiring legacy gas

Gas fleet heat rate improved by 10% from '13 to '14, resu ltin g in:

• $345 million in an nual fuel savings,

• 3.7 million metric tons COiyr avoided

• 455 MWs of nuclear uprates since 2001 maintaining and expanding nuclear production saves SO million metric tons C0

2 /yr

• $304 million in Combined Heat and Power Reduced fuel usage and avoided line losses resulting in 925,000 metric tons COiyr

avoided

• $14.7 million in Environmental Initiatives Funding

61 intern al efficiency measures for 5.3 million metric tons/yr avoidedEntergy Utility reduced C0 2 intensity by 37%*
over past decade (includes nuclear)

2000 So u rces of Ge n e r at i on

I 0°0 •

Coal I

• Gas/0 1 1 (Legacy and

Peaking unrts) cca:n oa-f'
• llklclear 0 **~dro** & Wfld I

- - - - - -. 2014 Sources of Generation

I 0%

I 46 % **~. 18**  **~o** 1 8% • Coal • Gas/Ool (l egacy and

Peaking unrts)

• CCGT4 0 ()-if'S
• llklclear o **~dro &**  Wind • 2000 93 , 5 8 1 GWh owned gen e r a tion

- 1,089 lb C0

2 /MWh

- 50

. 9 mill i on tons C0

2

• 2014
- 86

, 66 8 GWh own e d

g en e r a tion

- 701 lb C0

2 /MWh

- 30

. 4 million ton s C0

2

* 20 % o f thi s t o tal o ccurr e d 2 000

- 2005

.Recent Entergy Emission Rates (Utility Only)

• Results for 2013 (lbs CO/MWh)

• All Entergy-owned assets in the State: -Arkansas = 1029

- Louisiana

- - 813

- Mississippi

= 473 -Texas = 1365

• Entergy Corporate-wide total for 2013

= 590 6**~** 4 Out of 5 States Would Have to Achieve Most of Their 2030 Goals by 2020

Q **~** .,.,. **I)~** HI !""\. 35 % v NO 67% so 67 % NE 54% KS 53% I 62 % TX 72 % OK

AR Percentage of 2030 goals that would have

to be achieved by 2020 >75° / o 50o/o to 7 4°/o <50o/o lEIEntergyGeneration(GasandCoalUnits)ModeledAtOrNear0%Generationin2020(EPAIPM),ByState•AR-85%•LA-48%•MS-68%•TX-100%•EntergyUtilityfleettotal-68%•SeeEntergycomments,p.13andn.16.8Renewables•Muchlessrealisticresourcethantheruleprojects•Asanexample,ArkansasandLouisianacombinedhaveabout1%oftheavailablewindylandofthatregion'sbenchmarkState,Kansas.•NRELestimatesofpotentialwindresourcewith30%ormorecapacityfactor:-Kansas-over950,000MW-Arkansas-approximately9000MW-Louisiana-approximately410MW9Energy Efficiency

• EPA's estimates of available

energy efficiency gains, and their
costs, are extremely optimistic.

• " While EPA's estimates

may be achievable theoretically , the

cost for this level of EE/DSM would be cost prohibitive. The experience garnered from Texas and Arkansas indicates that

the "low hanging fruit" of efficiency

measures have already

been captured. Additional EE/DSM "harvests"

are expected

to come at a much higher cost. For each additional KWh
saved, the costs per KWh for these savings

are increasing." Entergy comments at 41. 10

# - ....... 

## QJ

**~** V') 

# ro

**~** 

# ...--.... QJ 

# c 

# E 0 

# ·- 0 

# ·- +.J 

# E V') 

# ::l 

# u 00 • 

# Vl 

# >N !.... +.J 

## 4- 

# ·- Q) 

# ·- 0 +.J 

# E ::l +.J 

# ::l

**~** 

# 0 ::l 

# 0 

# +-' 0 0

Vl 4- 

# 0 

# ::J 0 0
.... 

# u ?12. 0 0 Lf) 

## !.... 

# I"-- 

# N ::J

**>~** 

# 0 QJ QJ • +.J +.J 

## QJ 

# ro ro 

# E 

# E E 

# ·- 0 

# ·- X 

# u

X 

# 0 0 

# c

**~** 

# ·-

**~** 

# c.. I 

# c.. c.. $ 

# c.. ro 0 

# <X: ..._...- 

# •

### Date: April16, 2015 Meeting: F irstEnergy /C PP Follow Up Meeting Ru l e(s) Discussed: II 1 

# c tA 

# J Written Materials?

# Yes**~** Name O r gan i zat i on 

# /f1;;cTV 

# /V:: 

# I/ ;(rs/ f;((etUU 

# 2t'A ljoftL 

# /lrL**ftaln~. ~-VtA::.** 



# 0 I c tr 

# tv r (; 

### v-- I 

# u ! Vt:::S 

# £/!y fVA/11.5

# &-_:?6~;/cj' 1// 

# ?tiMA f A/1.-{ {{!Lj

# ~ 

# GPb 'i 

# f LA 

### rJ,

# ~~/ 

# r1 /

## ~Pt:J 

# -**I~**

### ~t: 

# (cJUMCt11 { :::- p f ;J 

# c J 

### Phone N umb er 

# f Jo-) ('(- .)Yt(d 

## ;J.od- 

## cf.Jr-**?o~o**



### )-c 

## l- 

# 5 3]-).('2 

## rl- ?51) 

# -761- 

# 4437


# - I

### Date: April17, 2015 Meeting: Bioma ss Co - Fir in g in t h e C l ean Power Plan Ru l e(s) Discussed: 

# t,pp Written Materials? Yes @ Nam e



# So---{' **~~~** 

# tTY\ 

# J V) 

# JY\ c 

# G



# ~ hY\ '- / l



# ~11vL C-vrvtvWl



# ~ 

# I 

# f<e, " d 

# Htt

**(v~'>** E 

# 11se

**~t-<** I vH1 

### I



# 6~(( **ltv~** rt 

# S "



# -- Or ga ni za ti o n



## C?~



# ~_;fo~ **~~;**

# CPA1?(/J8>A 

# & 

# f-ll I P h o n e N umb e r 

## I 

## t5L- 

## $Y3 r

**~** 

### r 'f (;:)



## ;)O~ 

# l!r1

**~13L**
**?**

%\_ 3V3- 

# 9 ') 3.! 2C>2 

### 7 

# rs qyzc; I (). 0 7-



### s~~ **~l'l \**  zL)L



## ~~r- 

# rrc6sI 

# I I



# - 

# I

-

·-