p. 1



# OAR Box 1787 Prepped by Ollie Stewart



### Document

Number: 

# 52 ) ll-C-1 0
Docket Number: 

# A-90-3 7

Printed 11/4/200810:22:19 AM

Sheet 52 of 147P. 2

\j.-_W-.j il:jJA M JfKUM tt' Affb/^ W i uyiyiyb4lbbu y f'UUJ/UU J 

### A-30-3" " 7 •\\rCL- \0

UNITE D STATE S ENVIRONMENTA L PROTECTIO

NAGENC Y WASHINGTON , D.C . 2046 0

OFFIC E O F AI R AM D RADIATION

MEMORANDUM REDUC E O R ELIMINAT E PQELOTIO NTODAY ! May20 , 3 9-9.1
SUBJECT : Transmitta l o f an Agenda for th e May21 , 199 3 "P 2

Partnershi p Feasibility " Mp.c=-.ting , an d M yWorking Definitio n o f Pollution Preventio n FROM :
TO ; Loui e R . Palay , Nationa l Ai r Complianc e ^oy.ULio n

Preventio n (P2 ) Coordinato r *._> ' /(-j'••/'/>,, Addressee s < BACKGROUND : O n May5 , 1993 , man yo f yo u joine d m e i n whic hcontinue d ou r discussion- ? abou t th e fc a a eerio e o f P 2 partnership s (EPA/State/indus t group ) fo r th e primarypurpoc c o f deraonstrat i ••approac hft o cpinpllanc e wit n ai r po l i iit-.lo n r e superio r t o "ond-of-pipc " approaches
. D u rin g possibilit yo f Usin g a recen t 3 MCompan y(-T 2 NSR ) permi t a s a starting poin t for industr y implemen t enforceabl e P2-baead permit s wa s ra i t wa o agree d tha t ther e wa s a need fo r al l i ofctal n an d revie wtho 3Mpermit , an d t o mee t matte r further
. Friday , May ' 21st , fro m8:3 0 selecte d a s th e bes t choic e fo r thi s meeting
. a conferenc e cal l oibilit yo f foriuin

g ry/communit yactio n n g tha t a P 2 gulationc ) wa a tha t discussio n the based , flexibl e t o develop an

d ised
. A t tha t time ntoroeto d partie s t o t o discus s thi s a mED T t o Noo n wa s
*+* * Not e tha t I have scheduled the meeting t o star t 3 0 -minute a earlie r than som

e o f you heard before , an d I hav e moved-u p th e tim

e whe n th

p telephon e conferenc e line s at e available , i n orde r t o accommodat e addition;-- ! n*---pnrat a presentations
. *** * LOCATION . PURPOSE , an d MEETIN

GAGENDA : Location ; Classroom"D" , on th e secon d floo r o f ou r building a t 280 0 Crysta l Drive , Crysta l city , VA . Determin e whethe r the D MCompan

ypermi t provide s a suitabl e an

d appropriat e basi s fo r developing P2

- baee d "flexible " permits
. Suc hpermit s (includin g NSR , Titl e II I an

d Titl e V ) .ir

e on e o f tht * decirec J output s o f -suc

hpartnerships
.P. 3 ub-^u-y J11:JJA MMU

Mtn. m/bbii < 

### r uyiyiao-iioou b ruu^/uu j r^

Meetin g Agenda ; 8:30-8:4 5 8:45-9:3 0 EP

A welcom e an

d openin g remark s Vide o o n semiconducto r manufacturin g process , Intel' s majo r emiosio n pointa , an d P 2 opportunitie s Texa s Instruments * summaryo f it s manufacturing process , majo r emissio n points , an d P 2 opportunitie s SSC D summaryo f th e 3 MCompanypermi t Dupon t Corporatio n summaryo f it s manufacturing process , majo r emissio n points , an d P 2 opportunitie s Merc k Corporatio n summaryo f it s manufacturing process , majo r emissio n points , an d P 2 opportunitie s Discussio n comparing th e 3 Moperatin g an d permi t condition s wit hth e potentia l partners ' operating an d permi t condition s Decision s - (1 ) ar e th e 3 Mcondition s sufficientl ycomparabl e t o thos e o f th e industria l partners ? (2 ) Doe s th e 3 Mpermi t provid e a n appropriat e basi s fo r developin g P2-base d permit s fo r th e partnerships ? (3 ) Wha t ar e the nex t step s an d tentativ e schedule ? Fo r thos e o f yo u wh o can no t atten d th e meetin g i n person , I hav e arrange dt o hav e telephon e conferenc e line s available , fro m 9:3 0 t o Noo n (only)
. Th e call-i n numbe r i s (202 ) 260-4290
. I f yo u hav e an

ydifficult yconnecting o r being heard , pleas e see k assistanc e from

EPA' s teleconferencing staf f b ycallin g (202 ) 260-2001
. MY WORKINGDEFINITIONO F P2 : P 2 mean s Whateve r actio n on e takes , ofte n i n a continuou s o r iterativ e manner , to : eliminat e o r reduc e th e formatio n o f pollutio n o r wast e a t th e sourc e o r in th e process ; o r th e protectio n o f a natura l resourc e b yconservation
. P 2 doe s no t includ e recycling , excep t whe n i t i s don e "i n process" , e.g. , continuousl yan

d on-site
. Pollutio n preventio n i s th e strongl y preferre d firs t choic e whic hon e shoul d mak e whe n selectin g a n appropriat e emissio n reductio n approach
. Onl yafte r al l opportunitie s fo r P 2 hav e bee n exhausted , shoul d on e choos e a n 9:30-9:4 5

9:45-10:0 0 10:00-10:1 5

10:15-10:3 0

10:30-11:3 0

ll:30-Noo nP. 4



### alternat e optionwhichi s lowe r in th e hierarchy , namely : recycling , i f P 2 i s no t sufficien t o r feasible ; prope r controls , i f P 2 an

drecycling are no t sufficien t o r feasible ; and prope r (safe ) disposal , i f P2 , recycling , an d control s ar e no t sufficien t o r feasible
. Furthermore , an yactio n whic hresult s i n o r cause s a negativ e impac t upo n anothe r medi a i s no t P2
. Som e example s o f P 2 include : improving combustio n efficiency , pre-cleanin g coa l t o remov e sulfu r befor e combustion , us e o f lo wNo xburners , reducing leakag e fromvalve s and piping , reducin g th e flo wo f ai r ove r a volatil e toxi c chemical , an d replacin g o r reducin g a toxi c chemica l use d i n a process . Addressee s Potentia l Agenc yand IndustryT 2 Partners : Intel , Ji mJewet t Texa s Instruments , Jane t Ondrice k Dupont , John Deg e Merck , Bruc e Wallingto n (% D . Bowers ) Kir t COX , AQMD , OAQP S Jac k Edwardson , ESD , OAQP S Gregor yFoote , OG C ,/Mik e Trutna , OAQP S Willia mTyndall , OPA R Gi l Wood , TSD , OAQP S SSC D (L
. Paley , L . Lay , C . Poffenberger , J . Engert , P . Reinermann , C . Mixon , D . Lyons ) AE D (J
. Berman , K . schapiro ) Davi d Kling , PPD , OPPT S Lyn n Vendinello , P 2 Staf f offic e
cc : J . Rasnic , SSC D R . Biondi , SSC D S . Hoover , SSC D M . Miller , SSC D

MTG521PE.RMT , 5/20/9 3