BEFORE THE 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

Joint Application of 

DELTA AIR LINES, INC.; 

VIRGIN BLUE INTERNATIONAL AIRLINES 

PTY LTD d/b/a V AUSTRALIA; 

VIRGIN BLUE AIRLINES PTY LTD; 

PACIFIC BLUE AIRLINES (AUST) PTY LTD 

and 

PACIFIC BLUE AIRLINES (NZ) LTD 

Under 49 U.S.C. §§ 41308 and 41309 for 

Approval of and Antitrust Immunity for 

Alliance Agreements 

Docket DOT-OST-2009-0155 

MOTION FOR CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT 

UNDER 14 C.F.R§ 302.12 

January 15, 2010 
Communications with respect to this document should be sent to: 

Merren McArthur 

General Counsel, Corporate and Government 

Affairs 

Dayna Hall 

Legal Counsel 

The Virgin Blue Group 

P.O. Box 1034 

Spring Hill QLD 4004 

Australia 

+617 3333 6801 

merren. mcarthur&yirginblue. com, au 

dayna. hall@)virqinblue. com, au 

Anita Mosner 

Sophy Chen 

Holland & Knight 

2099 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Suite 100 

Washington DC 20006 

(202)419-2604 

anita. mosner@>hklaw. com 

soph y. chen(d).hklaw. com 

Andrea Fischer Newman 

Senior Vice President, Government 

Affairs 

Alexander Van der Bellen, 

Managing Director, Government Affairs 

and Associate General Counsel 

Jeff Morgan 

Director, International and Regulatory 

Affairs 

DELTA AIR LINES, INC. 

1212 New York Avenue, N.W. 

Washington, DC 20005 

(202)842-4184 

sascha. vanderbellen@)delta. com 

for. VIRGIN BLUE AIRLINES PTY LTD, 

VIRGIN BLUE INTERNATIONAL AIRLINES 

PTY LTD d/b/a V AUSTRALIA, 

PACIFIC BLUE AIRLINES (NZ) LTD, and 

PACIFIC BLUE AIRLINES (AUST) PTY LTD 
BEFORE THE 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

Joint Application of 

DELTA AIR LINES, INC.; 

VIRGIN BLUE INTERNATIONAL AIRLINES 

PTY LTD d/b/a V AUSTRALIA; 

VIRGIN BLUE AIRLINES PTY LTD; 

PACIFIC BLUE AIRLINES (AUST) PTY LTD 

and 

PACIFIC BLUE AIRLINES (NZ) LTD 

Under 49 U.S.C. §§ 41308 and 41309 for 

Approval of and Antitrust Immunity for 

Alliance Agreements 

Docket DOT-OST-2009-0155 

MOTION FOR CONFIDENTIAL TREATMENT 

UNDER 14 C.F.R§ 302.12 

V Australia, Virgin Blue, the Pacific Blue carriers and Delta (together, "Joint 

Applicants") have filed today in this Docket a joint response to the Department's Order 

Requesting Additional Information. Order 2009-11-20 (Dec. 1, 2009). The Joint 

Applicants seek confidential treatment of (i) the confidential portions of their response, 

(ii) the materials described on the attached indices of confidential documents, and 

(iii) the confidential data on compact disc that will be provided under separate cover. 

These materials contain confidential, proprietary and commercially sensitive 

information protected from public disclosure by the Department's Notice concerning 

access to documents in this proceeding. Notice (July 16, 2009). Pursuant to that 

Notice, the Joint Applicants request that the Department withhold from public disclosure 

the materials described above, which the Joint Applicants have filed under seal with this 

Motion. 
Motion for Confidential Treatment 

Page 2 

Respectfully submitted, 

Anita M. Mosner 

for Virgin Blue International Airlines Pty 

Ltd d/b/aV Australia; 

Virgin Blue Airlines Pty. Ltd; 

Pacific Blue Airlines (Aust) Pty Ltd and 

Pacific Blue Airlines (NZ) Ltd 

Alexander Van der Bellen 

for Delta Air Lines, Inc. 

A» 

#9106676 v2 
Index of Delta Air Lines Confidential Documents 

Bates 

Range 

DL000554-DL000577 

DL000578-DL000671 

DL000672-DL000677 

DL000678-DL000682 

DL000683-DL000684 

DL000685 

DL000686-DL000706 

DL000707-DL000756 

DL000757-DL000758 

DL000759-DL000763 

DL000764-DL000769 

DL000770-DL000775 

DL000776-DL000779 

DL000780-DL000796 

DL000797-DL000800 

DL000801-DL000802 

DL000803-DL000804 

DL000805-DL000807 

DL000808-DL000810 

DL000811-DL000812 

DL000813-DL000814 

DL000815-DL000817 

Date 

November 2009 

July 25, 2009 

October 19, 2009 

not dated 

not dated 

not dated 

not dated 

not dated 

September 14, 2009 

May 14, 2009 

May 14, 2009 

May 15, 2009 

April 7, 2009 

November 2008 

June 26, 2009 

July 18, 2009 

July 24, 2009 

August 9, 2009 

August 21, 2009 

August 28, 2009 

August 31, 2009 

September 4, 2009 

Description 

Virgin BlueA/ Australia Overview 

DL/DJ-VA Bilateral Codeshare 

DeltaA/irgin Blue Group 

Policies and Procedures Comparison Document 

V Australia/Delta Technology Project Charter 

Sell & Report Code Share Development 

LAX schedule data 

Procedure for exchanging SSIM files 

Technology implementation timeline 

LAX-SYD traffic composition data 

PNRs by type of connectivity in LAX 

Email from Pappas, Charlie W to Buckalew, Edward 

re V Australia sales and network benefits 

Email from Guenthner, Andrew to Mathias Friess; 

Pappas, Charlie W; & Curcio, Matteo X re VA & 

DL/NW SPA Expansion 

Email from Guenthner, Andrew to Pappas, Charlie W 

& Curcio, Matteo X re VA & DL/NW SPA Expansion 

Email from Guenthner, Andrew to Pappas, Charlie W 

& Curcio, Matteo X re VA & DL/NW SPA Expansion 

Email from Pappas, Charlie W to Mathias Friess re 

DL - VA/DJ updates 

PPT re Summer 2009 Pacific Network Plan 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Production 

Category 

CQ7 

CQ2 

CQ7 

DP2 

CQ7 

CQ7 

DP2 

CQ2 

CQ1 

CQ2 

CQ2 

CQ2 

CQ2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

Page 1 of 2 
Bates 

Range 

DL000818-DL000821 

DL000822 

DL000823-L000826 

DL000827-DL000829 

Date 

September 13, 2009 

September 18, 2009 

October 18, 2009 

November 20, 2009 

Description 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Weekly Status Report 

Production 

Category 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

Note: Pursuant to the pre-filing meeting and agreement with the Department, production of "transpacific" documents is 

limited to documents pertinent to Australia and the South Pacific region. 

Category Key: IDP - Initial Document Request 

DP - Document Request 

CQ No. - Clarification Question 

Page 2 of 2 
Delta Air Lines Privilege Log 

List of Privileged Documents 

Bates 

Range 

DL000830-

DL000832 

DL000833-

DL000838 

DL000839-

DL000840 

DL000841 

DL000842 

DL000843-

DL000846 

Date 

April 20, 2009 

May 8, 2009 

June 19, 2009 

June 19,2009 

June 23, 2009 

June 15,2009 

Author 

Van der Bellen, Alexander* 

Merren McArthur*+ 

Van der Bellen, Alexander*+ 

Van der Bellen, Alexander* 

Coblin, James*+ 

Van der Bellen, Alexander** 

Recipient 

Curcio, Matteo X; Guenthner, Andrew; 

Pappas, Charlie W; Renner, Andreas; 

Coblin, James*; Morgan, Jeff; (Flotteron, 

Michael) 

Pappas, Charlie W+; Van der Bellen, 

Alexander**; Curcio, Matteo X+; Coblin, 

James*+; (Mathias Friess; Dayna Hall*; 

Phil Squires) 

Renner, Andreas+; Curcio, Matteo X+; 

Coblin, James*+; Pappas, Charlie W+; 

McClain, Scott*+; (Newman, Andrea*; 

Morgan, Jeff; Newman, Dennis; Johnson, 

Cameron 

Hauenstein, Glen W; Cortelyou, Robert J; 

Newman, Dennis; Renner, Andreas; 

Johnson, Cameron; Dube, Vinay; 

Pappas, Charlie W; Curcio, Matteo X; 

Spann, Bobby; Coblin, James*; (Smith, 

Cynthia W; Kelley, Laura A; PindroMartin, 

Mary; Fowler, Nekia T; McClain, Scott*; 

Morgan, Jeff) 

Van der Bellen, Alexander*+; (Curcio, 

Matteo X; Pappas, Charlie W; Morgan, 

Jeff) 

Pappas, Charlie W+; Curcio, Matteo X+; 

Renner, Andreas+; Coblin, James*+ 

(Morgan, Jeff; Newman, Andrea*; 

Barnett, Sametta; Veith, Sally) 

Privilege Description 

DL-Virgin Blue ATI application 

outline 

Agenda for legal/regulatory 

meeting; Virgin Blue 

comments on draft 

Cooperation/Coordination/ JV 

documents 

Legal advice re Delta Sydney 

frequency reduction 

announcement. 

ATI application document 

production instructions 

Discussion and legal advice re 

JV and Codeshare 

Agreement terms 

Discussion of DOT ATI meeting 

and outline 

Privilege 

Claim 

AC.WP 

AC, WP 

AC 

AC, WP 

AC 

AC 

Initial Document Request (IDP)/ 

Document Request (DP)/ 

Clarification Question (CQ) No. 

IDP2, IDP6 

IDP2 

IDP4 

IDP2 

IDP2 

IDP2, IDP6 

Page 1 of 3 
Delta Air Lines Privilege Log 

Bates 

Range 

DL000847-

DL000852 

DL000853-

DL000856 

DL000857 

DL000858 

DL000859 

DL000860-

DL000862 

DL000863-

DL000868 

DL000869 

Date 

June 18, 2009 

June 22, 2009 

August 24, 

2009 

September 22, 

2009 

October 10, 

2009 

October 13, 

2009 

October 12, 

2009 

9/25/2009 

Author 

Pappas, Charlie W+ 

Van der Bellen, Alexander** 

Van der Bellen, Alexander** 

Van der Bellen, Alexander** 

Van der Bellen, Alexander* 

Van der Bellen, Alexander** 

Luke Woodward*; Alastair 

Corrigall 

Renner, Andreas* 

Recipient 

Coblin, James**; Curcio, Matteo X* 

Guenthner, Andrew*; McClain, Scott**; 

Pappas, Charlie W+; (Morgan, Jeff; 

Curcio, Matteo X) 

Guenthner, Andrew*; Curcio, Matteo X; 

Pappas, Charlie W; Renner, Andreas; 

(Newman, Andrea*; Morgan, Jeff) 

Pappas, Charlie*; Curcio, Matteo X+; 

Renner, Andreas*; (Morgan, Jeff) 

Newman, Andrea*; Hirst, Ben*; 

Hauenstein, Glen W.; Dube, Vinay; 

Curcio, Matteo X; Renner, Andreas; 

Morgan, Jeff; Coblin, James*; McClain, 

Scott*; Bunce, Gary* 

Pappas, Charlie*; Curcio, Matteo X; 

Renner, Andreas*; Morgan, Jeff* 

Merren McArthur*; 

Sascha Van der Bellen*; (Dayna Hall*; 

Jeff Morgan; Anita Mosner*) 

Morgan, Jeff*; Van der Bellen, 

Alexander**; (Pappas, Charlie; Curcio, 

Matteo X) 

Privilege Description 

Discussion and legal advice re 

Codeshare Agreement terms 

Legal advice and discussion re: 

segregation of DLA/A 

coordination from other ATI 

partners 

Discussion of affidavits in DL/ 

Virgin Blue docket 

Discussion of information request 

from the ACCC 

Discussion of ACCC meeting 

Discussion of ACCC meeting and 

follow up questions 

Memorandum discussing ACCC 

meeting 

Discussion of Sydney traffic 

composition for ACCC 

Privilege 

Claim 

AC 

AC 

AC 

AC 

AC 

AC 

AC, WP 

AC, WP 

Initial Document Request (IDP)/ 

Document Request (DP)/ 

Clarification Question (CQ) No. 

IDP2 

IDP2 

CQ2 

CQ3, CQ5 

CQ1, CQ4, CQ5 

CQ2, CQ7 

CQ1.CQ2, CQ5, CQ7 

DP2 

Page 2 of 3 
Delta Air Lines Privilege Log 

Bates 

Range 

DL000870-

DL000872 

DL000873-

DL000879 

DL000880-

DL000881 

DL000882-

DL000883 

Date 

9/28/2009 

10/1/2009 

11/16/2009 

11/6/2009 

Author 

Spann, Bobby+ 

Van der Bellen, Alexander* 

Gounaris, loannis+ 

Van der Bellen, Alexander** 

Recipient 

Harris, Roger+; Renner, Andreas+; Long, 

Steve+; (Van der Bellen, Alexander*; 

Pappas, Charlie; Curcio, Matteo X; 

Morgan, Jeff) 

Renner, Andreas; Pappas, Charlie; 

Curcio, Matteo X; Johnson, Cameron; 

Spann, Bobby; Morgan, Jeff 

Van der Bellen, Alexander**; Morgan, 

Jeff+; Guenthner, Andrew*; Pappas, 

Charlie*; Renner, Andreas* 

Dube, Vinay*; Newman, Andrea**; Hirst, 

Ben**; Hauenstein, Glen W+; Curcio, 

Matteo X+; Renner, Andreas*; Pappas, 

Charlie*; Morgan, Jeff* 

Privilege Description 

Discussion of cost 

savings/synergies for ACCC filing 

Discussion of ACCC questions 

and draft responses 

Discussion of Alaska SYD traffic 

statistics for ACCC 

Discussion of ACCC draft 

determination 

Privilege 

Claim 

AC, WP 

AC, WP 

AC, WP 

AC 

Initial Document Request (IDP)/ 

Document Request (DP)/ 

Clarification Question (CQ) No. 

CQ1 

CQ2, CQ5 

CQ2 

CQ7 

Page 3 of 3 
Virgin Blue Privilege Log 

Bates 

Range 

VB0897 

VB0898-

VB0900 

VB0901-

VB0902 

VB0903-

VB0904 

VB0713 

Description 

Email regarding 

Delta Alliance 

document from 

Gilbert & Tobin 

Draft Presentation 

Email to be sent 

from Brett G to 

Richard Branson 

in preparation for 

conference call w/ 

Delta 

"Virgin Blue 

Comments on 

Delta Draft 

Documents" 

Virgin Blue 

August 2009 CEO 

Board Report 

Date 

May 4, 

2009 

Undated 

March 8, 

2009 

May 8, 

2009 

Undated 

Author 

Ivan Colhoun 

Ivan Colhoun 

Merren 

McArthur 

Merren 

McArthur 

Merren 

McArthur (by 

her PA) 

Recipient 

Merren McArthur, Brett 

Godfrey, Mathias Friess, 

Tony Wheelens, David 

Lloyd, Scott Swift, 

Dayna Hall 

Merren McArthur, Brett 

Godfrey, Mathias Friess, 

Tony Wheelens, David 

Lloyd, Scott Swift, 

Dayna Hall 

Brett Godfrey 

Charlie Pappas, 

Alexander Van der 

Bellen, Matteo Curcio, 

Jams Colbin 

Cc: Mathias Friess, 

Dayna Hall, Phil Squires 

Board of Directors 

Privilege Description 

Internal discussion of legal advice received 

from Australian counsel 

Information provided to counsel for 

purposes of seeking legal advice; contains 

references to restricted government data 

Advice of counsel for purposes of preparing 

for alliance negotiations 

Advice of counsel 

Redaction reflects advice of counsel for 

purposes of applying for antitrust immunity1 

Type of 

Privilege 

AC, WP 

AC 

AC 

AC, WP 

AC 

DOT 

Reference 

IDP2, IDP4, 

IDP6 

IDP4, DP2 

IDP2, IDP4, 

IDP5, IDP6 

IDP2 

IDP8, DP2 

#8996890 v2 

Redactions made within the document production for purposes of privilege are in black. 
INDEX OF DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY 

THE VIRGIN BLUE GROUP 

Bates 

Numbers 

VB0634-

VB0636 

VB0637 

VB0638-

VB0644 

VB0645-

VB0674 

VB0675-

VB0677 

VB0678-

VB0705 

VB0706-

VB0710 

VB0711-

VB0734 

Description 

Email: "Monday 11th May - US Mtg" 

"Agenda: V Australia - Delta Meeting, 

May 11, 2009" 

"Virgin Blue Holdings Limited Board 

Minutes of Meeting Held on Thursday, 

July 2, 2009" 

Virgin Blue June 2009 CEO Board 

Report 

"Virgin Blue Holdings Limited Board 

Minutes of Meeting Held on 

Wednesday, July 29, 2009" 

Virgin Blue July 2009 CEO Board 

Report 

"Virgin Blue Holdings Limited Board 

Minutes of Meeting Held on 

Wednesday, August 26, 2009" 

Virgin Blue August 2009 CEO Board 

Report 

Author 

Matteo Curcio 

Matteo Curcio 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Recipient 

Phil Squires 

Cc: Merren McArthur, Joanne McDonald, 

Mathias Friess, Charlie Pappas, Andreas 

Renner, Alexander Van der Bellen 

Phil Squires 

Cc: Merren McArthur, Joanne McDonald, 

Mathias Friess, Charlie Pappas, Andreas 

Renner, Alexander Van der Bellen 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Date 

May 9, 2009 

May 9, 2009 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

DOT 

Reference1 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2, CQ5 

DP2 

DP2, CQ5 

Initial Document Request (IDP), Document Request (DP), Clarification Question (CQ) No. 
INDEX OF DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY 

THE VIRGIN BLUE GROUP 

Bates 

Numbers 

VB0735-

VB0741 

VB0742-

VB0776 

VB0777-

VB0806 

VB0807-

VB0832 

VB0833-

VB0839 

VB0840 

VB0841 

VB0842-

VB0843 

Description 

"Virgin Blue Holdings Limited Board 

Minutes of Meeting Held on 

Wednesday, September 30, 2009" 

Virgin Blue September 2009 CEO 

Board Report 

Virgin Blue October 2009 CEO Board 

Report 

Virgin Blue November 2009 CEO 

Board Report 

Virgin Blue December 2009 CEO 

Board Report 

Email: "Delta V Australia Program 

Timelines" 

"Delta - V Australia Program 

Timelines" 

Email: "Minutes: DL/VA/DJ Schedule 

Distribution Conf Call" 

Author 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Board Secretary 

Richard Carter 

Richard Carter 

Nathalie Montano 

Recipient 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Board of Directors 

Don Curtis, Richard Silcox, Richard Healey 

Cc: Caria Vandenheuval, Phil Squires, Mathias 

Friess 

Don Curtis, Richard Silcox, Richard Healey 

Cc: Caria Vandenheuval, Phil Squires, Mathias 

Friess 

Don Curtis, Derek Adair, Aliene Jones, 

Guangzhen Xing, Seynabou Niang, Armand 

Zakarian, Richard Carter, Mathias Friess, 

David Chudleigh, Caria Vandenheuval, JeanChristophe Bachet, Phil Squires 

Cc: Janis Ritter, Jill Gannaway, Richard Silcox 

Date 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

Undated 

11/16/2009 

11/16/2009 

11/17/2009 

DOT 

Reference1 

DP2 

DP2, CQ5 

DP2 

DP2, CQ5 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 
INDEX OF DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY 

THE VIRGIN BLUE GROUP 

Bates 

Numbers 

VB0844 

VB0845-

VB0847 

VB0848 

VB0849-

VB0850 

VB0851 

Description 

Email: VA7DL Schedules 

" VA7DL Schedules" 

Email: "VA7DL" 

Email: DJ Wetlease for Codeshare 

with DL 

"DJ Wetlease - DCS Issues 

Summary" 

Author 

Don Curtis 

Don Curtis 

Phil Squires 

Nandor Locher 

Nandor Locher 

Recipient 

Phil Squires, Mathias Friess, Carla 

Vandenheuval, Richard Carter 

Cc: Nathalie Montano, loannis Gounaris, Jim 

Healey 

Phil Squires, Mathias Friess, Carla 

Vandenheuval, Richard Carter 

Cc: Nathalie Montano, loannis Gounaris, Jim 

Healey 

Don Curtis, Nathalie Montano, Jim Healey, 

David Chudleigh, Daniel Graham, Richard 

Carter, Sandra Weston, Richard Silcox, Carla 

Vandenheuval, Tom Alberts, Megan Pausey 

Cc: Mathias Friess, Charlie Pappas, JeanChristophe Bachet, Matthew Yarrow 

David Hanlon, Wayne Bradford, Robert 

D'Alessio, Martin Giddens, Anthony Jackson, 

Phil Squires, Phil Warth, Neil Hanson, Andrew 

Mason, Jo Scougall, Richard Carter, Hugo 

Ritchie, Ayse Blackley 

Cc: Lisa Daniel, Kay Wallis, Natalie Katz, Mark 

Donataccio, Simon Twedle 

David Hanlon, Wayne Bradford, Robert 

D'Alessio, Martin Giddens, Anthony Jackson, 

Phil Squires, Phil Warth, Neil Hanson, Andrew 

Mason, Jo Scougall, Richard Carter, Hugo 

Ritchie, Ayse Blackley 

Cc: Lisa Daniel, Kay Wallis, Natalie Katz, Mark 

Donataccio, Simon Twedle 

Date 

11/18/2009 

11/18/2009 

11/19/2009 

10/27/2009 

10/27/2009 

DOT 

Reference1 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 
INDEX OF DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY 

THE VIRGIN BLUE GROUP 

Bates 

Numbers 

VB0852-

VB0854 

VB0855-

VB0856 

VB0857-

VB0858 

VB0859-

VB0861 

VB0862-

VB0863 

VB0864-

VB0896 

Description 

Email: "VA/DL Conference Call 

Results" 

Email: "DL/VA Code Share 

Implementation - Added Test Links" 

Email: "VA/ DL / DJ Codeshare Effort" 

Email: "VA/ DL / DJ Codeshare Effort" 

Email: "Delta Update - Privileged and 

Confidential" 

"SYD-LAX Airfare comparisons" 

Author 

Jim Healey 

Jim Healey 

Richard Silcox 

Phil Squires 

Phil Squires 

Ivan Calhoun 

Recipient 

Janis Ritter, Jill Gannaway, Richard Silcox, 

Dwayne Crook, Rick Ballard, Daniel Graham, 

Suzanne Risby, Carta Vandenheuval, Don 

Curtis, Nathalie Montano, Brian Rodkey 

Cc: Jean-Christophe Bachet, Sandra Weston, 

Phil Squires, Earl Anderson, Megan Pausey, 

Richard Carter 

Dwayne Crook, Janis Ritter, Jill Gannaway, 

Richard Silcox, Rick Ballard, Daniel Graham,, 

Suzanne Risby, Carla Vandenheuval, Don 

Curtis, Nathalie Montano, Brian Rodkey, 

Jean-Christophe Bachet, Sandra Weston, Phil 

Squires, Earl Anderson, Megan Pausey, 

Richard Carter, Derek Adair, Allene Jones 

Jill Gannaway, Janis Ritter, Jim Healey, Don 

Curtis, Nathalie Montano, Phil Squires, Carta 

Vandenheuval, Richard Carter 

Mathias Friess, Andrew Mason, Tom Alberts, 

Richard Carter, Carla Vandenheuval, Dayna 

Hall, Merren McArthur, Jean-Christophe 

Bachet 

Mathias Friess, Gordon Young, Richard 

Carter, Carla Vandenheuval 

Cc: Tony Wheelens, Merren McArthur, Dayna 

Hall 

Merren McArthur 

Date 

11/05/2009 

11/12/2009 

11/11/2009 

11/11/2009 

08/6/2009 

May-2009 

DOT 

Reference1 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

DP2 

IDP3, IDP4, 

DP2, CQ5 

# 8668046 v9 
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

 A copy of the foregoing Document has been served this 15th day of January, 2010, 

upon the following persons via email: 

Marshall S. Sinick 

Counsel for Alaska Airlines 

msinick@ssd.com 

Carl B. Nelson Jr. 

Associate General Counsel 

American Airlines Inc. 

carl.nelson@aa.com 

John L. Richardson 

Counsel for Amerijet International 

jrichardson@johnlrichardson.com 

Angeline Bird 

Sandra Lunsford 

Federal Express Corporation 

anbird@fedex.com 

sllunsford@fedex.com 

Mark Atwood 

Counsel for Kalitta Air 

matwood@sherblackwell.com 

Thomas V. Lydon 

Kelli Bryan 

Evergreen International Airlines, Inc. 

tom.lydon@evergreen.com 

charters@evergreenairlines.com 

Russell E. Pommer 

Associate General Counsel & Director of 

Regulatory Affairs 

Atlas Air, Inc. 

rpommer@atlasair.com 

Kevin P. Montgomery 

Polar Air Cargo, Inc. 

kevin.montgomery@polaraircargo.com 

Lawrence D. Wasko 

ldwasko@starpower.net 

Counsel for Arrow Air, Inc. 

Stephen Lachter 

lachter@starpower.net 

Counsel for ASTAR Air Cargo, Inc. 

Howard Kass 

Benjamin T. Slocum 

US Airways 

howard_kass@usairways.com 

benjamin.slocum@usairways.com 

David L. Vaughan 

Danielle Fisher 

Counsel for United Parcel Service 

dvaughan@kellydrye.com 

dfisher@kelleydrye.com 

Hershel Kamen 

Dan Weiss 

Continental Airlines 

hkamen@coair.com 

dan.weiss@coair.com 

Jeffrey A. Manley 

Julie Oettinger 

United Airlines 

jeffrey.manley@united.com 

julie.oettinger@united.com 

Mark McMillin 

Assistant General Counsel 

World Airways Inc. 

mcmillin@woa.com 

Malcolm Benge 

mlbenge@zsrlaw.com 

Counsel for World Airways Inc. 

Jonathan B. Hill 

jhill@dlalaw.com 

Counsel for Hawaiian Airlines, Inc 
John Byerly 

Deputy Assistant Secretary for Transportation Affairs 

U.S. Department of State 

byerlyjr@state.gov 

John Allen 

Federal Aviation Administration 

john.allen@faa.gov 

Todd Homan 

Peter Irvine 

U.S. Department of Transportation 

todd.homan@dot.gov 

peter.irvine@dot.gov 

Jill Ptacek 

U.S. Department of Justice 

Jill.Ptacek@usdoj.gov 

Alexander Van der Bellen 

Delta Air Lines, Inc. 

sascha.vanderbellen@delta.com 

Anita M. Mosner 

Sophy Chen 

Counsel for Virgin Blue International Airlines Pty Ltd d/b/a V Australia; 

Virgin Blue Airlines Pty. Ltd; 

Pacific Blue Airlines (Aust) Pty Ltd and 

Pacific Blue Airlines (NZ) Ltd