UNITED STATES D]STRICT COURT

FOR THE

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINIOS

UNITED STATES OF

AMERICA

V

CHARLES ESTELL

' NIo . 12 c-a-k\t,

(

(

(

MOTION FOR APPOTNTMENT OF COUNSEL

Now, comes, petitioner, proceeding pro-se, asking the court

to grant counsel for the following reasons :

1. Charles Estell was qonvicted of bank robbery and gun

charges by a jury in federal court

2. During the sentencj-ng phase of his proceedings Mr.

Estel-l was enhanced under the career offender statue pursaunt,

to 4bL.1 and 2k2. (c)

3. Since the Supreme Cou::t decisions in Session v dimaya 139

s.ct l2o4 12L2, ]-223 2001ed 2d 549; .fohnson v us 135 s.ct 2551,

192 Ied 2d 569; us v Davis 139 s.ct 23]-9 204 1ed 2d 757. The

supreme court have concluded that the residual clause that s

used to determine whet.her or not a charge can meet t.he

el-ements thats needed to trigger a career offender

FILED 4/1/2020

THOMAS G. BRUTON CLERK, U.S. DISTRICT COURT

PJ

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 1 of 7 PageID #:2509
enhancemenE, is unconstituEional. The court herd in each

case that thq imposition of crimnal punishment cannot be made

to depend on a judges estimation of the d.egree of risk posed

bt a crime imagined "ordinary case" .

4 Due to the courts interpretation of what constitutes a

crime of violence , now MR.Estel1 doesnt belleve that his case

fit,s the career offender requirements , and should. be

resentenced t

IN CLOSING

Mr. Este11 is askin the court to appoint counsel so hi_s

arg,uement can be addressed

DArE; Jlt,l,

RESPECTFUI-,LY SUBMITTED

btuz-tilS--

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 2 of 7 PageID #:2510
"zo

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 3 of 7 PageID #:2511
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF

v.

IN TI{E CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK

ILLINOIS 2l-001

74

OB

IR NUMBER 0918314 ID NUMBER 030938470

(s) enurerated below

SenEeDce CIaBs

$os 65 '1

CHARI,ES ESTEI,T,

DefeEda$t

The

rs hereby

CounE

003

ORDER OF COMMITIJIENT AND lErylENCE TO

i#riiois prpanttqmrr oE coRR'BcTroNs

= = = 

:i= = ===== ==:===== 

:== = = === 

: :=== ==

aJrove named defendant h'awrng been adjudged guiLty of ttre off

seatenced to the ifti"ois Department of Corrections aE foLLo

Offense SEatutory Clcatsroa

: F-s/Ir'3lar VEEICUTaR HI''IACKrArG

and sald EeDtence gf'aff nn coDsurruts wrtslr coun! (s)

sng wrth) (conBecutrve to)

and saad sefltsence sha1I

and gard senEence tntt'illl'*rreat wrcl) (Jt_*tt" t'o) tshe Eente'ce rmpoaed on

and sald' aelEence =*t'I G--*renE srth) (IlI"""t" Eo) tshe aenLe'ce rntposed on

and saad serEeace =*"ilG*og6ng 

wrtsb) ("I*"ot"" co) Ebe sentence amE'oged on

On Counts 

-- 

defendant having been convicted of a class of

a class x offendet ;;;;;""t To 730 ar'cs s/s-s-3 (c) (8) 

'

On CorrnL .- defendant is sentenced to arr exte[ded term pursuant

the EenEence lmPoaed oa

MO9

).los

r MOS

c MOS

is sentenced' as

?30 lr,cs 515-8-2'

time actuallY served

anct Ehat Ebe sheraff

the DePartnent Eake

IT IS FIIRTEER ORDERm TIIAT COUIITIS !'2'4'5 tvIS NOTLE PROS' 2 YEARS

.ITIsFURTI{ERoRDEREDtshattheclerkprovrdetheshelaffofcookcouatywaEhacopyofthls

EakeEhed'ef,eEda[canEocustsodydd.d'eI1verlram./hertoEbelllanorEDepartnerrtofcorrectronsaad

}r1m/t}ertlrEocusEodyudcotr'faEebam'/herrEamaalrerprovldedby].awutll.EheaboveseEceEcelsf

DATED

CERTIFIED

rNP2 04/26110

BY

DEPUTY CLERK

L2 L2 ,7

ccc Nl05

OOBBT

L2 CR 416

26 2Al0 KI

flssmiateJudge Luciano Panici. 1B 3 0

JUDGE PANICT

frlleit

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 4 of 7 PageID #:2512
M/ O4gg3 DP5 09.ls.A0 06/04/12 CArIr0000

rLF'BITPOO

HDR/2LO1DP5OU 04993

I{TN/WENTZ

THE FOIJIJO!{ING RECORD PERTAINS TO FBI/349506RA5

srD/cA29 6.9054 e

RESTRICTED - DO NOT USE FOR EMPLOYMENT, LTCE]SSING, PI,ACEMENT OR

CERTIFTCATION PURPOSES

**************************.******.*****************,t**!&******.*************

DO NOT CO],I,ECT DNA. SAMPLE NOT VERIFIED BY FINGERPRIMT RECETVED BY THE

CAL-DNA DATA BANK- FOR INFO (510) 620-3300 OR pC296..pC296@DO,f.CA.cOV

'****************************Jr*******************************************

*,I PAIM PRINT ON FIT,E AT DOJ FOR ADDITIONAIJ INFORMATTON PIEASE E-MATIJ

PALI{. PRI}IT@DO.] . CA. GOV ** TII MUIJTIPTE SOURCE RECORD,

cr.r /A29690548

DOB/L9740'tt7 SEX/r"1 RAC/BLACK HcI/6a2 wcT/18s EyE/BhO HAr/BLK pOB/rL

NAII4/ O 01 ESTELI,, CHARLES

to,IulFBI -349506RA5

.*.* * *

200810L4 CASOSAN DIEGO

81"78871A

DOB.:19740?L7

0 0r. : 113 60 (A) HS - SELL/FURNTSH/ETC MARTWANA/IIASH

002:i-1359 HS-POSSES$ .MARIJUANA FOR SALE 2OO8L2iO CASCSAN DIEGO CENTRAIJ

cD2t612L

00 1 : 1 136 0 (A) HS : SEIrL/FURNISH/ETC MARIJUANA/HASI{

DTSPO:-DISMISSED

20090109 cAscsAN DIEGO ' scD27672L

OO1:1.i359 I{S-POSSESS MARIOUA}IA FOR SAtE

'IDTSPO: CONVICTED

. CONV STATUS:MISDEiMEANOR

SEN: STAYED

* * * *-* **.r^* * * * * * * * * * ** * * :l * * * *.* * ** * * *.** * * * *. * * *, * * * * *** ** ***

WANTS NOT CHECKED - PLEASE CHECK NCIC WAITTS

****************************Jr*****************.*********

END OF RECORD

0 0402 t2 cR 4t6

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 5 of 7 PageID #:2513
SUPERIOR COURT OF GALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO

CENTML DIVISION, CENTRAL COURTHOUSE, 1.IOO UNION ST., SAN DIEGO, CA 92101

EAST COUNTY DIVISION, 250 E. MAIN ST., EL CAJON, CA 92020

NORTH COUNTY DIVISION, 325 S. MELROSE DR., VISTA, CA 92081

SOUTH COUNTY DIVISION. 5OO 3RD AVE., CHULA VISTA, CA 91910 Hn,*',,n,t,n,:."D

AUG 0I 20t9

BYI N. Salazar, DePutY

PLAINTIFF

PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

DEFENDANT

Charles Estell

SUPERIOR COURT CASE NUMBER

sco216721

M|NUTES, RESPONSE, AND ORDER ON

pETtTtoN FOR RESENTENCTNG (HS 11361.8)

DISTRICT ATTORNEY NUMBER

ACJ499

TO BE FILLED OUT BY THE COURT ONLY:

Defendant has filed a petition for resentencing/reduction and alleges pursuant to H&S Code $ 11361.8.

Defendant tr nas completed his/her sentence and petitions to have the felony count(s) designated as a misdemeanor(s).

TO BE FILLED OUT BY THE PROSECUTING AGENCY ONLY:

The Diskict Attomey responds:

X fne District Attorney agrees that the foltowing counts are eligible for resentencing/reduction:

LJ Defendant is not entitled to the relief requested,

HS 11359

Reason: ! No counts eligible under H&S Code $ 11361.8,

L-.J Defendant has at least one prior conviction for an offense under Pen. Code $ 667(e)(2)(C)(iv) or for an offense

requiring registration pursuant to Pen. Code g 290(c).

E A hearing should be held to determine E whether defendant poses an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety I other:

x

n

Defendant has completed his/her sentence and is entitled to have the felony conviction(s) designated as a misdemeano(s).

Defendant is still serving his/her sentence and is entitled to resentencing.

Date:Au9 5, 2Ot9

COURT ORDER

The Petition is denied.

LORNAA[I(S}TE

o,,", ff-8{1 Judge of the Sffierior Court

CLERK'S CERTIFICATE

The foregoing document, consisting of

tr copy on file in this office.

_pages, is a full, true, and correct copy of the Ioriginal

Clerk of the Superior Court

by Deputy

SoSC CRM-278 - THC (Now I 1/16)

Date:

MINUTES, RESPONSE AND ORDER ON H&S Code S 11361.8,

PETITION FOR RESENTENCING (HS 1136r.8)

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 6 of 7 PageID #:2514
.. l.xvill 

I l'lu 

rJ

<_)

q1daH

"ao3o

-C,I

(_, iltoA

(JG

ol

.n%

n, b

eg4

,a

a- f

a)

<)

d^ k {@(

JI

-d 

r!

- 

-I

: 

s

- 

-ul

:i

#Ir

-t

-

-E4 4

= 4 I. 4 E

-a-

-- 

r'l

-H4

c6

Ln

$rt a

CJ

.oY-<,

c$CVoo

-,

a-a

CJJ

=qqc?=G

hJ c

lJ) ad%kI v

cf)

fi

r(.rJ J+5+

s/

Case: 1:12-cr-00416 Document #: 185 Filed: 04/01/20 Page 7 of 7 PageID #:2515