UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION

OFFICE OF ELEMENTARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION

Dear Colleague:

On December 10, 2015, the President signed into law the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), which 

reauthorizes the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA). The reauthorized law, 

which we will refer to in this document as the ESSA, prioritizes excellence and equity for our students 

and supports great educators. Your work provides a strong foundation to help ensure that every child 

graduates from high school ready for college and careers. The ESSA reinforces your efforts, and the 

U.S. Department of Education (ED) looks forward to supporting you during the upcoming transition and 

throughout ESSA implementation. 

To facilitate an orderly transition to the programs authorized by the ESSA, we are conducting a careful

review of the work in which you and your State are currently engaged. In the coming months, ED will 

provide ongoing guidance to support schools, districts, and States in the transition to the ESSA. This 

letter begins this process and provides guidance regarding certain activities for which we know you are 

working toward imminent deadlines and that are affected by this reauthorization. In particular, this 

letter covers ED’s expectations regarding: Title I assessment peer review; annual measurable objectives 

(AMOs) and annual measurable achievement objectives (AMAOs) for school years 2014–2015 and 

2015–2016; conditions and other related requirements under ESEA flexibility; priority and focus school 

lists; and educator evaluation and support systems under ESEA flexibility. 

Title I Assessment Peer Review

The reauthorized law maintains the requirement that each State administer high-quality annual

assessments in at least reading/language arts, mathematics, and science that meet nationally recognized 

professional and technical standards. As described in ED’s letter to you on September 25, 2015, a highquality State assessment system that is aligned to State-determined content standards is essential to 

providing information that States, districts, principals, and teachers can use to identify the academic 

needs of students, target resources and supports toward students who need them most, evaluate school 

and program effectiveness, and close achievement gaps among students. A high-quality assessment 

system also provides useful information to parents about their child’s advancement against and 

achievement of grade-level standards. 

We are reviewing the ESSA to better understand the impact of any changes to the requirements for State 

assessment systems but, because the essential requirements are unchanged, ED’s peer review of State 

assessment systems will continue so that each State receives feedback from external experts on the 

assessments it is currently administering. However, the schedule will be slightly altered; ED is 

cancelling the January 2016 peer review window and adjusting the March and May 2016 windows to 

April and June 2016. More information will be provided in the coming weeks. 

December 18, 2015

400 MARYLAND AVE., SW, WASHINGTON, DC 20202

http://www.ed.gov/

The Department of Education’s mission is to promote student achievement and preparation for global competitiveness by 

fostering educational excellence and ensuring equal access.

Archive Information:

This guidance has been formally rescinded by the Department and 

remains available on the web for historical purposes only.
Page 2

AMOs and AMAOs

In accordance with a February 27, 2015, letter from the Director of ED’s Office of State Support, many 

States that implemented new assessments in the 2014–2015 school year are preparing to submit new

AMOs for ED’s review and approval in January 2016. However, the ESSA requires States to “establish 

ambitious State-designed long-term goals...for all students and separately for each subgroup of 

students” instead of AMOs. ED wants to support State efforts to prepare for this transition; therefore, in 

accordance with ED’s authority to ensure an orderly transition to the ESSA, ED will not require States

to submit AMOs (for school years 2014–2015 or 2015–2016) in January 2016 for ED’s review and 

approval, nor will ED require States to report performance against AMOs for the 2014–2015 or 2015–

2016 school years. Additionally, ED will not require States to hold districts accountable for their 

performance against AMAOs 1, 2, and 3 under Title III of the ESEA for the 2014–2015 or 2015–2016

school years.

Please note, however, that all States and districts must continue to publish report cards, including report 

cards for the 2014–2015 school year (if those report cards have not yet been published), for the 2015–

2016 school year, and beyond. Report cards must continue to include information that shows how a 

district’s student achievement on the State assessments compares to students and subgroups of students 

in the State as a whole. At the school level, the district must include information that shows how a 

school’s student achievement on the State assessments compares to students and subgroups of students 

in the district and in the State as a whole. However, consistent with ED’s authority to ensure an orderly 

transition to the ESSA, report cards need not include the information required under ESEA section 

1111(h)(1)(C)(ii). 

General ESEA Flexibility Update

Under ESSA section 4(c)(1), waivers granted through ESEA flexibility remain effective through 

August 1, 2016. Given this timeframe, ED expects each State that is currently approved to implement 

ESEA flexibility to continue to meet all ESEA flexibility principles during the 2015–2016 school year. 

However, because ESEA flexibility terminates on August 1, 2016, ED will not seek or review requests 

to extend ESEA flexibility from a State with an ESEA flexibility request approved only through the 

2015–2016 school year. In addition, ED will no longer review or approve requests for ESEA flexibility, 

as announced by ED on September 23, 2011, from a State that does not yet have an approved flexibility

request. ED will continue to make decisions on a case-by-case basis but, generally speaking, will 

prioritize monitoring and enforcement on principles that are included in both the ESEA and ESSA.

Follow-Up Actions Required Under ESEA Flexibility Renewal

During the ESEA flexibility renewal process, ED renewed some States subject to certain follow-up 

actions and conditions as described in our renewal letter. Many of the follow-up actions, including those 

required to resolve a condition, required a State to take certain actions during, or by the end of, the 

2015–2016 school year. Because ESEA flexibility terminates on August 1, 2016, a State will no longer

be required to submit follow-up responses to ED related to areas of ESEA flexibility that are not 

required under both the ESEA and ESSA. Instead, ED will continue to provide technical assistance, 

feedback, and support to States and districts in these key areas so they can continue to build on the 

strong foundations they have constructed and facilitate a smooth transition.
Page 3

For follow-up actions related to areas that are required under both the ESEA and ESSA, a State must 

submit required follow-up responses as specified in its ESEA flexibility renewal approval letter. In 

particular, a State is required to provide information for follow-up actions under Principle 1 of ESEA 

flexibility, including follow-up actions related to consultation with stakeholders, college- and careerready standards, and high-quality assessments, and under Principle 2 related to reporting requirements.

In the coming days, a member of my staff will contact each State’s ESEA flexibility contact to clarify 

whether any follow-up actions that were required as part of the State’s ESEA flexibility renewal must be 

carried out.

All Other Amendments to ESEA Flexibility Requests

Through August 1, 2016, a State may continue to request amendments affecting activities required under 

the ESSA; ED will review these amendments and make a determination on their approval. If a State 

wishes to amend Principle 1 or any of the reporting components of Principle 2 of its approved ESEA 

flexibility request, it must submit an amendment for ED’s review. 

On areas no longer required under both the ESEA and ESSA, ED will continue to provide technical 

assistance, including feedback and support, but will not formally process amendment requests or 

decisions on their approval. If you have questions about whether a particular change requires an 

amendment, please reach out to your program officer in ED’s Office of State Support.

Priority and Focus School Lists

Under ESEA flexibility, many States were required to submit updated priority and focus school lists in 

January 2016. In order to facilitate an orderly transition to ESSA during the 2015–2016 school year, all 

States implementing ESEA flexibility may now select either of the following options with regard to 

these lists:

Option A: Do not exit schools and maintain current identification. A State may “freeze” its

current lists of priority and focus schools as of December 10, 2015 (the date of enactment of the 

ESSA). These schools would continue to implement their approved interventions through the 

2015–2016 and 2016–2017 school years. The State would not be able to exit schools from the 

current lists until after the 2016–2017 school year. 

Option B: Exit schools and identify new priority and focus schools. A State may exit priority 

and focus schools that meet the State’s approved exit criteria and identify new priority (at least 5 

percent of Title I schools) and focus (at least 10 percent of Title I schools) schools based on more 

recent data. Newly identified schools, as well as those that remain on these lists because they did 

not meet the State’s exit criteria, would implement their approved interventions through the 

2016–2017 school year. A State selecting this option must provide updated lists of priority and 

focus schools to ED by Monday, March 1, 2016; please note that this deadline supersedes prior 

assurances and communications requiring some States to submit these lists in January 2016.

Each State implementing ESEA flexibility should inform ED of which of the above options it has 

selected through an e-mail to its State e-mail address, OSS.[STATE]@ed.gov, submitted on or before 

Friday, January 29, 2016. 
Page 4

Supporting Educator Effectiveness

To help ensure that all educators have the necessary tools to be maximally effective, every State 

implementing ESEA flexibility is engaged in the challenging and critical work of designing, building, 

and operationalizing educator evaluation and support systems. We believe that this hard work and 

leadership should be recognized and encouraged. As noted, the law provides for ESEA flexibility, 

including those principles related to educator evaluation and support systems, to continue to be 

implemented through August 1, 2016. Given that educator evaluation and support systems are not 

required under the ESSA, ED will continue to provide technical assistance, including feedback and 

support, but will not formally process amendment requests related to these systems, and will prioritize 

monitoring and enforcement on principles that are included in both the ESEA and ESSA.

I understand that you may have additional questions about how to proceed, including specific questions 

about which portions of the guidance provided above applies to schools and districts in your State. You 

can find the latest information at www.ed.gov/essa and can ask questions by e-mailing us at 

essa.questions@ed.gov or through your contact in our Office of State Support. Please also know that 

ED is working to provide you with comprehensive guidance on the transition, as well as guidance on the 

requirements of the programs authorized under the ESSA. We will work with stakeholders to 

understand the issues on which guidance would be most helpful; in the meantime, I hope this letter

answers some of your most urgent questions. 

Please note that a Request for Information (RFI) that seeks advice and recommendations regarding 

regulations under Title I of the ESEA as reauthorized by the ESSA is available today for public 

inspection at https://www.federalregister.gov/public-inspection. A link to that document will be

available at www.ed.gov/essa when it is published in the Federal Register.

Thank you for your ongoing commitment to improving educational outcomes for all students. I look 

forward to our continued partnership as we move ahead with this critical work. 

Sincerely,

/s/

Ann Whalen

Delegated the Authority to Perform the Functions 

and Duties of Assistant Secretary for 

Elementary and Secondary Education

cc: State Title I Directors

State Assessment Directors

State ESEA Flexibility Leads