3,Eo =74p c, UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTEC'I'ION AGENCY REGION IX 75 Hawthorne Street San Francisco, CA 94105-3901 September 17, 2007



### Mr. Tom Cackette Acting Executive Officer California Air Resources Board 100 1

### I Street Sacramento, CA 95812
OnAugust 24,2007, CARB submitted revisionsto the California State Implementation Plan (SIP). We havereviewed materials submitted with the following rules and foundthat they fulfill the completeness criteria in 40 CFR Part 51, Appendix 

### V.

Printed on Recycled Paper

"-.PA - "-"- APCDIAQMD Antelope Valley El Dorado County Imperial County Imperial County Imperial County Imperial County Imperial County Imperial County Kern County Kern County Kern County Monterey Bay Unified Monterey Bay Unified MontereyBay Unified MontereyBay Unified Monterey Bay Unified SanDiego County SanJoaquin Valley San Joaquin Valley Rule # 1158 527 101 201 202 207.1 2 17 420 404.1 431 431 101 201 415 4 18 1002 11 4 104 4401 Rule Title Storage,Handling, And Transport ofPetroleum Coke (Rescinded) Federal Major Modifications Definitions Permits Required Exemptions - Federal Major Modification Large Confined Animal Facilities Permits Required Beef Feedlots Particulate Matter Concentration Propellant Combustion and Rocket Testing (1/24/07) Propellant Combustionand Rocket Testing (318107) Definitions SourcesNot RequiringPermits Circumventions Transfer of Gasoline into Stationary Storage Containers Transfer ofGasoline into Vehicle Fuel Tanks ExemptionsfromRule 10Permit Requirements Reduction ofAnimal Matter Reduction of Animal Matter

### This addresses allrevisions in this submittal.

### In the coming months we will review the complete revisions for action pursuant to Clean Air Act section 110(k). SanJoaquinValley San JoaquinValley San Joaquin Valley SanJoaquinValley San JoaquinValley San Joaquin Valley SanJoaquinValley SanJoaquinValley San JoaquinValley San Joaquin Valley San JoaquinValley


### Questions regarding our completeness review shouldbe directedto Cynthia 

### G. Allen at (415) 947-4120. Sincerely, 4402 4404 4453 4454 4565 4625 4641 4672 4711 4712 4713



### Director, Air Division Crude Oil Production Sumps Heavy Oil Test Station-Kern County RefineryVacuum Producing Devicesor Systems RefineryProcess Unit Turnaround Biosolids,Animal Manure, and Poultry Litter Operations Wastewater Separators Cutback, SlowCure, and Emulsified Asphalt, Paving and Maintenance Operations Petroleum Solvent Dry Cleaning Operations Refinery Vacuum Producing Devices or Systems RefineryProcess Unit Turnaround Heavy Oil Test Station -Kern County



### cc: Mr. EldonHeaston Executive Director Antelope Valley AQMD Mojave Desert AQMD Ms. Marcel1McTaggart,APCO 

### El Dorado County APCD 

### Mr. Stephen Birdsall, APCO Imperial CountyAPCD Mr. David 

### L. Jones, APCD Kern CountyAPCD Mr. Doug QuetinAPCO Monterey Bay Unified APCD3 

### Ms. Rosa Abreu, Acting APCO SanDiego CountyAPCD 

### Mr. Seyed Sadredin,APCO SanJoaquin ValleyAPCD 

### Mr. Jorge 

### L. Fernandez, Chief Program Evaluation Branch, CARB

### EPI,Region9 

### SIP COMPLETENESSCHECKLIST To evaluate compliancewith 40 CFR 51, Appendix V



### RULE# Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer lust 24, 2007 slope Valley AQMD Itember

### 6, 2007 ;.Allen Au! An1 Sey C.C Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not ApplicableTo Rule 0 

### = Material Missing



### ADMINISTRATIVE MA1 

# 7 I I I I I I 

### Rescission 

# I (a) Submittal letterfrc m Governorldesignee 

## 1x1 

# 1 

# I I 1158
(b) Evidenceof adopton 

### X c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt 

### X (dl)Copy of actual rult !/plan 

### X (d2) Rule changes indi :ated by underline/cross-out 

### X e) Proof that action rlet procedural requirements 

### X (f) Copy of public not ce 

### X (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice 

### X 

### L agency response 

### NIA TECHNICAL SUPPOR17 I I I I I I 

# I (a) Regulated pollutar~ts identified 

# I (b) Affectedsources l;attainment status identified 

# I X 

# I c) Rulelplan emissio~ ls irr~pact (d) Attainment, PSD2 c other required demonstration 

### NIA NIA e) Modelingsupport 3s appropriate (f) Reliance on contir uous err~ission reductions


### ( OVERALL COMPLET ENESS ICl 

# 1 1 1 NIA NIA (g) Evidenceof limits & other needed requirements (i) Justificationfor de~iation from EPA policy



### Notes: 

### NIA NIA - -

### EPA Region 9 

### SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliancewith 40 CFR 51, AppendixV Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not ApplicableTo Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 El Dorado CountyAQMD September 

### 6, 2007 C.G. Allen


### RULE# 527 

### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (perAppendix V, Section 2.1)

(a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee (b) Evidence of adoption (c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out

(h) Public comments & agency response 

### X X 

### X X X (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice


### TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per AppendixV, Section2.2) I 1 I I I I 

# I (a) Regulated pollutants identified 

### X X X



### ( (b) Affected sources 

### & attainment status identified 

# I X 

## [ 

# 1 1 I -

(c) Rulelplan emissions impact (d) Attainment, PSD & other required demonstration 

### NIA NIA (e) Modelingsupport as appropriate (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions - - 

### NIA NIA (g) Evidence of limits 

### & other needed requirements --


### X (i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy



### Notes: I I 

### NIA OVERALL COMPLETENESS C

### EPA Region 9 

### SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To eval~~ate compliancewith 40 CFR 51, Appendix

### V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not ApplicableTo Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 Imperial CountyAPCD September 

### 6, 2007 C.G. Allen



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix 

### V. Section 2.1

### 1 207.1



### RULE # (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee (b) Evidence of adoption

-- -- - - - - - - - b2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out 

# I x 

# I X 

# 1 X 

# I X 

# 1 101

- (c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt (dl) Copy of actual rulelplan 

### X X



# I (h) Public comments 

### & agency response 

# I A 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I 201



### X X (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice
(a) Regl~lated pollutants identified 

### NIA NIA NIA 202


### X X

- - - - -- 

# I (b) Affected sources 

### & attainment status identified 

# ( x 

# 11 X 

# I X 

# 1 X X
X X X X X X X X X
X X X

(c) Rulelplan emissions impact (d) Attainment, PSD 

### & other required demonstration 

### X X

(e) Modeling support as appropriate (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions 

# I (i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# I NIA 

# ( NIA 

# I NIA 

# ( NIA X X X

NIA NIA

I 

### X X X

NIA NIA



### Notes: NIA NIA
(g) Evidenceof limits 

### & other needed requirements


### OVERALL COMPLETENESS NIA NIA NIA NIA

C NIA NIA NIA NIA NIA - 

### NIA NIA NIA 7 - -- 

### NIA

C NIA
C C

### EPA Region 9 

### SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliance with 40 CFR 51, Appendix V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 Imperial County APCD September 

### 6, 2007 C.G. Allen


### RULE#

---- - 

# / (b) Evidence of adoption 

### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix V, Section 2.1

### ) 420 (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee

(d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out 

# I X 

# I X 21 7

(c) StateIDistrict legal authorityto adopt (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan 

### X X
X X (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice



### TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix V, Section 2.2) I I I I I I 

### X X

(g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice 

### (h) Public corr~ments 

### & agency response 

# I (a) Regulated pollutants identified 

## IxIxl 

# I I X X X NIA

(c) Rulelplan emissions impact 

# I X 

# I X X X X NIA

(b) Affected sources & attainment status identified 

# I (d) Attainment, PSD 

### & other required demonstration 

# I NIA 

# I A 

# ( I



### X

(f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions 

# I A 

# / A 

# I
I I I I (e) Modeling support as appropriate 

### X

(i) Justification for deviationfrom EPA policy 

# I A 

# I A 

# ( ~ - -



### NIA (g) Evidenceof limits 

### & other needed requirements 

# I X X



### Notes: NIA

I I I 1 - -



### C OVERALL COMPLETENESS C

### EPA Region 

### 9 SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate corr~pliance with 40 CFR 51, Appendix V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 Kern County APCD September 7, 2007 C.G. Allen



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix V, Section 2.1) I I I I I I



### RULE# 431 404.1 (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee (b) Evidence of adoption 431

(c) StateIDistrict legal authorityto adopt (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan 

### X X

I I I I


# I (h) Public comments 

### & agency response 

### X X (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice 

### X X

X (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out

~ - - 

# I (b) Affected sources 

### & attainment status identified 

# r hr 

# 7 T X X X X
X X X
TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix V, Section 2.2) 

### X X X

(a) Regulated pollutants identified 

### X X X X

(c) Rulelplan emissions impact (d) Attainment, PSD 

### & other required demonstration (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions 

# I X 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I
I I I I 

# I X X X

X

(e) Modeling support as appropriate 

### NIA NIA

(i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I X

NIA (g) Evidence of limits 

### & other needed requirements 

# 1 NIA 

# I X X
NIA NIA



### X



### Notes: X NIA NIA

I I I I 

### OVERALL COMPLETENESS NIA

C C C

### EPA Region 9 

### SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliance with 40 CFR 51, Appendix 

### V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 Monterey Bay Unified APCD September 7, 2007 C.G. Allen


# I (b) Evidence of adoption 

## ~xIxbo4I 418 

### RULE 

### # ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix 

### V, Section 2.1

### ) 

# I (c) StateIDistrict legal authorityto adopt 

## IxIxIxIxI 101


### X (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee

I I I I 201


### X
(dl)Copy of actual rulelplan (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice 415

(g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice (h) Public comments & agency response 

### X

X X X X

TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix 

### V, Section 2.2) 

### X

X NIA (a) Regulated pollutants identified (b) Affected sources & attainment status identified (c) Rulelplan emissions impact 

### X X X X

(d) Attainment, PSD & other required demonstration 

# I (g) Evidence of limits & other needed requirements 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I X

# ( X

# I X NIA


### X X X (e) Modeling support as appropriate (f) Relianceon continuous emission reductions 

## [ (i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I X X X X

NIA 

### X X X X X NIA


### X X X
NIA NIA



### Notes: NIA

OVERALL COMPLE'TENESS 

### X NIA
NIA



### X X
NIA NIA I



### X X X NIA

C - - 

### NIA NIA NIA NIA NIA

C C C

### EPA Region 9 

### SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliance with 40 CFR 51, Appendix 

### V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix 

### V, Section 2.1

### ) I I I I I I August 24, 2007 Monterey Bay Unified APCD September 7, 2007 C.G. Allen


# I (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee

(b) Evidence of adoption (c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt 

# I (f) Copy of public notice 

# IXI X X (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements 

### X X X (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice (h) Public comments 

### & agency response 

### X NIA TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix 

### V, Section 2.2)

(a) Regulated pollutants identified (b) Affected sources & attainment status identified (c) Rulelplanemissions impact (d) Attainment, PSD 

### & other required demonstration 

### X X X NIA (e) Modeling support as appropriate (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions (i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# 1 NIA 

# I NIA NIA (g) Evidence of limits 

### & other needed requirements 

### X



### Notes:

OVERALL COMPLETENESS C

### EPA Region 9 SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliance with 40 CFR 51, Appendix 

### V
Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (~er A~~endix 

### V. Section 2.1) 

### RULE # 

### August 24, 2007 San Diego County APCD September 7, 2007 C.G. Allen
11 

# I (c) StatelDistrict legal authority to adopt Key: 

### C 

### = Complete I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing

(a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee (b) Evidence of adoption X X
(d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out 

### 10 I I I I 

### (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan 

# I (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements 

# I X 

# I X
(f) Copy of public notice (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice X X (h) Public comments & agency response X 

### TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix V, Section 2.2) 

# I (d) Attainment, PSD & other required demonstration 

# I FI

(a) Regulated pollutants identified (b) Affected sources & attainment status identified (c) Rulelplan emissions impact 

### NIA X 

### NIA
(f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions 

# 1 NIA 

# I
I I I I 

### (e) Modeling support as appropriate (g) 

### Evidence of limits & 

### other needed requirements 

# I NIA I I I 

### NIA
(i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# I NIA



### Notes:

OVERALL COMPLETENESS C

### EPA Region

### 9 SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliancewith 40 CFR 51, Appendix V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 San JoaquinValley AQMD September 7, 2007 C.G. Allen



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix V, Section 2.1) I I I I I I 

# I (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee 

## lxlxlxlxl

RULE# 

### ( (b) Evidenceof adoption 

## IxIxIxIxl 4402 4404 4104 4401

(c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt (dl) Copy of actual rulelplan

I(g) Certificationthathearingfulfilledpublicnotice 

# I X

# I X

# I X

# I X

# I

(e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice 

# 1 (h) Public comments 

### & agency response 

# I NIA 

# I X

# ( NIA 

# I NIA 

# I X X
X X X X

TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix V, Section2.2) 

### X X

(a) Regulated pollutants identified 

### X (b) Affected sources 

### & attainment status identified 

### X (c) Rulelplan emissions impact (d) Attainment, PSD & other required demonstration (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions 

# 1 NIA 

# 1 NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA I I I I 

### X X

(e) Modeling support as appropriate 

### ( (g) Evidenceof limits 

### & other needed requirements 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# 1 X X
X X

X 

## --- X NIA NIA 

### X X

X X X

NIA NIA NIA

(i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy



### Notes: - 

### NIA

OVERALL COMPLETENESS NIA NIA

NIA NIA NIA

-



### NIA

C NIA

NIA

C NIA NIA C C

### EPA Region 

### 9 SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliancewith 40 CFR 51, Appendix V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer San Joaquin Valley AQMD Septerr~ber 10, 2007 C.G. Allen



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (perAppendix V, Section 2.1) I I I I I I



### RULE# 

# 1 (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee 

## lxlxlxlxl 

# I (b) Evidenceof adoption 

### bIxIXx1 4453 4565 4454

(c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out 4641

(e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice


### TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix V, Section 2.2) I I I I I 

### X X 0

(h) Public comments 

### & agency response 

### X X X X X 0



### NIA (a) Regulated pollutants identified (b) Affected sol~rces 

### & attainment status identified



# I (i) Justificationfor deviation from EPA policy 

# I NIA 

# ( NIA 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I X X X

(c) Rulelplan emissions impact (d) Attainment, PSD 

### & other required demonstration (e) Modeling support as appropriate (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions (g) Evidenceof limits 

### & other needed requirements 

### X X NIA

NIA


### X X

Notes: 

### X 

# 1 X 0 

### X X X

NIA NIA NIA NIA NIA
OVERALL COMPLETENESS 

### X X X X
X X NIA

NIA NIA NIA NIA NIA
C 

### X X X X X NIA NIA



### X X
C NIA NIA NIA NIA NIA
C C

### EPA Region 

### 9 SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKI-IST To evaluate compliance with 40 CFR 51, Appendix V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 0 

### = Material Missirrg Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 San Joaquin Valley AQMD September 10, 2007 C.G. Allen


### RULE# ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per Appendix V, Section 2.1) 

# I (c) StateIDistrict legal authority to adopt 

## lxlXl 

# I I 4625
(b) Evidence of adoption 4672


### X (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee


# I (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out 

# 1 0 

# 1 0 

# 1 1 1 X X (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan 

# 1 (e) Proof that acGn metprocedural requirements 

# I x 

# I x 

# I I I X
X X
(f) Copy of public notice (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice


### TECHNICAL SUPPORT (per Appendix V, Section 2.2) I I I 1 I I

(h) Public comments 

### & agency response 

### ( (a) Regulated pollutants identified 

## lxlxl 

# I I X X



# I (b) Affected sources & attainment status identified 

# 1 X

# 1 X

### ( 

# I 1 X X NIA 

# I (c) Rulelplan emissions impact 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I I I NIA

(d) Attainment, PSD & other required demonstration (e) Modeling support as appropriate 

# I (i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

# I I I

(f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions (g) Evidenceof limits & other needed requirements 

### NIA NIA



### Notes: NIA NIA NIA NIA
OVERALL COMPLETENESS NIA NIA
C C

### EPA Region 

### 9 SIP COMPLETENESS CHECKLIST To evaluate compliancewith 40 CFR 51, Appendix V Key: 

### C 

### = Complete 

### I 

### = Incomplete 

### NIA 

### = Not Applicable To Rule 

### 0 

### = Material Missing Submittal Date District Name Date Reviewed EPA Reviewer August 24, 2007 San Joaquin Valley AQMD September 10, 2007 C.G. Allen



### ADMINISTRATIVE MATERIALS (per AppendixV, Section 2.1

### ) I I I I I I



### RULE # 

# I (a) Submittal letter from Governorldesignee 

## Ixlxlxl 

# I 

# I (b) Evidence of adoption 4711



# I (d2) Rule changes indicated by underlinelcross-out 

# I 0 

# I 0 

# I 0 

# ( 4712

(c) StateIDistrict legal authorityto adopt (dl)Copy of actual rulelplan 4713

X X (e) Proof that action met procedural requirements (f) Copy of public notice



### TECHNICAL SUPPORT herA~~endix V. Section 2.2) (g) Certification that hearing fulfilled public notice (h) Public comments 

### & agency response (a) Regulated pollutants identified 

## IxIxIxl X X
X X X X

X 

### NIA


# I (c) RuWplan emissions impact 

# I NIA 

# I NIA 

## ( NIA 

# I X X

(b) Affected sources 

### & attainment status identified X X X 

### NIA

X

# I X

# I X X 

### NIA

I I I I (d) Attainment, PSD 

### & other required demonstration 

# I NIA 

# I NIA


### ( (i) Justification for deviation from EPA policy 

# 1 NIA 

# I NIA 

# 1 NIA 

# 1 I NIA (e) Modeling support as appropriate (f) Reliance on continuous emission reductions (g) Evidence of limits 

### & other needed requirements I I I I



### Notes: NIA NIA NIA
OVERALL COMPLETENESS NIA NIA NIA
C NIA NIA NIA
C C