Report Documentation Page Form Approved

OMB No. 0704-0188

Public reporting burden for the collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and

maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information,

including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington

VA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person shall be subject to a penalty for failing to comply with a collection of information if it

does not display a currently valid OMB control number.

1. REPORT DATE

MAR 1988

2. REPORT TYPE

N/A

3. DATES COVERED

 - 

4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE

Airpower: Myths and Facts

5a. CONTRACT NUMBER

5b. GRANT NUMBER

5c. PROGRAM ELEMENT NUMBER

6. AUTHOR(S)

Phillip S. Meilinger

5d. PROJECT NUMBER

5e. TASK NUMBER

5f. WORK UNIT NUMBER

7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES)

Air Univ, Maxwell AFB, AL

8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION

REPORT NUMBER

9. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 10. SPONSOR/MONITOR’S ACRONYM(S)

11. SPONSOR/MONITOR’S REPORT 

NUMBER(S)

12. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY STATEMENT

Approved for public release, distribution unlimited

13. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

ISBN 1-58566-124-4

14. ABSTRACT

15. SUBJECT TERMS

Air power; United States. Army Air Forces; United States. Air Force History; Bombing, Aerial; Precision

bombing Effectiveness

16. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF: 17. LIMITATION OF 

ABSTRACT

SAR

18. NUMBER

OF PAGES

140

19a. NAME OF

RESPONSIBLE PERSON

a. REPORT

unclassified

b. ABSTRACT

unclassified

c. THIS PAGE

unclassified

Standard Form 298 (Rev. 8-98)

Prescribed by ANSI Std Z39-18 

Opini

or imp

neces

State

US go

bution 
2 
5 

6 
8 

9 
12 

13 
1 

2 

3 

1 

PhD 

Afte

Meil

doct

he w

and 

roles

pate

Thu

com

130

has 

in t
Forc

199

of th

Univ

artic

and 

Polic

Forc

Stra

Aero

and 

The 

AFB

sayi

duc

som

pow

role

leas

Sold

war 

diffe

whic

writ

ral 

idea
In a

offic

have 

here 

them 

poin

to c

obsc

info

cern

ing. 

poli

low 

*S

A War 

Mass.

32–33

towar

Press, 

Comm

Ameri

Eyes 

World 

United 

Odom

Doctri

Unive

the Ai
and 

spen

aged 

fens

(tab

T

view

an 

the 

that 

of p

Non

Ame
T

Army and Air-Comp

(in millio
T

Army and Navy Air Budgets

Year Total Army and Navy 
In 

Boa

to s

conc

2,32

Plan 

At th

1,68

auth

reco

Corp

pens

193
edge

befo

term

sonn

“con

ficie

nica

ance 

hier

peri

be d

intr

one 
E

som

held 

on n

terw

anx

dism

ple, 

Roo

Com

stud

resp

pare 
Dep

M

air 

Arm

perc

offic

perc

stat

bran

that 

poss

Arm

mig
T

Army Officer Manning between 

(selected years a
but 

the 

peri

ano

few 

deem

bille

Serv

aver

thor

bran

cent

coul
of 7

only 

Corp

the 

one 

Corp

or fo

were 

tion

Hen

cer’s 

nent

chie
train

W

Crai

ther 

to m

slot 

Air 

the 

the 

And

repl

poin

ceas
have 

othe

that 

did 

prec

sum

port

wea

1

1919
3

Corps

Force 

4

Comm

State

5

of t

Appr

Unive

6

7

Men 

U.S. A

250–

Airpo
D.C.: 

Davis

1

Mars

Air F

Offic

of Pe

200 B
full 

*S

Heavy 

(Ithaca

War M

1920–

2001)

War II

1950)

Army 

Bradin

Aviatio

Gladm

Africa

Kitty 

(Londo
logis

so fo

curr

on s

purs

193

494 

devo

alloc

“equ

Cert

bud

men
forc

pear

size

Lou

194

ties 

the 

asse

excl

forc

thes

expe

land
to r

buil

Corp

Forc

near

plan

B-1

bom

craf

year 

imb

In 

cally 
Tac

grou

occa

Air F

Eigh

war 

carg

tran

plies

S

“bom

thin

troll
Forc

man 

Geo

Air 

the 

Air 

(com

end 

duri

Nort

Ira 

Forc

Forc
in E

had 

Prec

spon

figh

Obv

titio

bom

1

Tacti
179–

5

eds., 

and 

Offic

Drum 

the A

cent)

cent)

serva

Foulo

(Was

1983

6

Procu

D.C.
9

1

Aviat

Incub

Heav

Adva

Meili

1997

1

Gene

(Beth
*S

York: 

Trans

(Colleg

Walter 

Histor

252–5

Revers

Future 

chap. 

Aviatio

Caroli

the Ne

Corne

ate th

paren
dest

stru

cam

bled 

ACT

ACT

F

took 

targ

ficie

(ene

and 

plan
dere

few 

rate

like 

Bata

pain

need

ties.

1

was p

on t

rect

as th

rest

*S

Strate

Kosov

Tami 

Evolut

Bomb

Press, 

(New 

Allied 

1990)
and 

paig

tion

bett

Inde

84 

Germ

Paci

Japa

five 

have 

wou
120

000
d

fo

ve

th

ef

a 

ti

a

ip

ou

in 

b

th

T

at se

seri
Ger

enjo

stro

dest

Ger

tion

307 

Esco

mid

T

and 

due 

resp
US 

erat

1

(USS

Surve

D.C.: 

1945

1944 

Germ

Fran

Comp

ation
are s

2

(Euro

Print

Summ

Gove

Air U

Pacifi

3

howe

Milita

Milita

sess.

4

(New 

bega

cate

year

sult

*S

1789–

Russia

N.J.: R

Bombi

Rineh

Ethics 

Germa

and A

Unive
far m

T

expe

they 

betw

ble 

Jan

ing 

duc

fewe

truc

tics, 

peri
seve

Germ

mea

prod

Jan

that 

indu

on 

enem

by t

A

ufac

crea
of f

num

Luft

tion

were 

fact

num

the 

pair

Luft

even 

airc

rout
days 

Win

chie

safe 

the 

spen

avoi

O

Allie

Luft

com

time

non 
and 

Ame

had 

Usin

men

amo

how 

cont

wou

wou

mon

forc
preci

Agen

U.S. S

Natio

(June 

4

5

(USS

Surve

D.C.: 

1945

6

7

8

D-Da

25th, 

ing 

ange

rend

dist

*S

Armag

Rober

War (I

Hans 

Fitzge

233; a

War II

Martin
the 

was 

dest

ther

civil

in v

othe

had 

bly 

amo

pres

cons

it), o
the 

paig

thir

not 

In G

25 p

perf

Ger

Thre

thou

ning 

poll

thin
2

Germ

Print

3

Japa

Print

4

Bomb

D.C.: 

5

Jona

mate

dustr

bomb

the 

Titmu

July

Har

*S

There

Roose

441; F

Fleet A

1952)

War (N

The Ye

Mifflin

bomb

Nimitz 

ing to 

unnec
incr

over 

whe

prox

sche

In re

Power 

Press, 

atomi

look a

Nation

the En

Hirosh

Histor
• 
C

mai

enta

two 

wou

pop

Ger

800
stra

Allie

tern

194

torio

hab

Wait

cert

and 

A

role 

bom

sion 
• 

• 
com

often 

tives

less

1

of Wo

see c

vario

issue 

treat

on Ja
Gian

Invas

Impli

1997

6

Okina

Field

7

762,7

the w

and 

oils, 

was d

Block

Asso

Hung
and 

Wate

Japa

tary 

Austr

cent. 

of W

Morr

1

Accom

Milita

(Was

1946

had c

air b

tance

duc

over

mor

and 

Won

*S

Airpow

Cities 

Adm S

Fallac

Marsh

Rineh

Comm
• 

• 
• 
the 

tory 

in G

of 1

duc

liber

a pr

and 

of C

tion

sive 

plea

fron
(31.

tran

A

194

follo

• 

• 

• 
T

caus

Nav

cam

fight

of A

victo

R

spen

Wor

amo

Of t
1

Jona

2

(USS

D.C.: 

1–3. 

produ

proce

artill

3

Surve

D.C.: 

1945
ing m

1

1

in Al

281.

1

Germ

and 

Unive

Mierz

Asse

Railw

Unive

1

and t

in Eu
1

eds., 

and 

Offic

Holle

the A

Chief 

1964

1
*S

Yonde

(sprin

Suppo

29–43

portiv

diatrib

also G

Techn

(New 

“Vietn

Crossw

Tex.: T

tains 

tim to 

of its 

(xviii).
the 

Rep

Zeal

troo

1.3 

in S

Wisc

and 

trys

our 

to d

sive 

the 
or w

clud

been 

Ellsw

ence

Thu

Viet

targ

dete

ings 

rece

Gen 
Earl

Tho

The

Harr

U.S. 

John 

Sub

Viet

Pau

Willi

Crei

Amb

Hen

Max

Ellsw
A

Forc

Sou

thos

clud

erin

Gen 

of U

Viet

lieve

grou

pow

He 
T

USAF Combat So
mili

T

sent

fact 

of S

land

Forc

1, t

Paci

prov

no c

Sou

Sou
with 

his 

man

to co

in th

cers 

Whe

clos

Viet

righ

it w

of th

tain
1

47; G

Oxfo

Summ

(Bost

FitzG

Amer

342.

2

Army 

he w

Lond

deter
the h

LeMa

5

ients 

actio

6

land 

Cent

the V

Histo

Histo

29–3

able 

vtu6

Mom

B-52
Calif.

ferred 

1

the A

Navy 

wors
cam

App

stru

tran

loca

belo

*S

the V

Rober

War (I

316–2

and t

Schus
as a 

tion

adm

on N

196

star

In a

sites 

air s

took 

W

cuss

the 
In 

pose

ries 

in N

a pe

wou

JCS 

Forc

of N

Haip

duc

Viet

adm
subm

expe

Lyn

son

mili

inte

non

devi

polit

cess

were 

U

agai
mai

tinu

P

Line

nam

Alth

sem

earl

acco

wou

Chr

two 

nific
1

U.S. 

(Was

2000

miles 

could 

2

over 
quote

North 

Hous
othe

“a c

how

strik

and 

give

*S

Vietna

Experi

Knoll 

Ameri

1970)

The Ai
Viet

othe

deat

ber 

Sou

Lew

jurie

and 

were 

we u

war, 

of i

bom
repl

Arm

Viet

stric

“any

and 

eled

airc

nan

Mar

artil

the 

ligh
and 

Viet

maj

1

Prest

Imag

Ethic

Guen

Oxfor

McGo

World 
McFa

US A

Vietn
part 

In fa

*S

Army 

Comm

181–8

and C

1996)

about 

(Nove

Certa

Staff, 

Recor

(Wash
T

Persia

Sorties Flown by US Se
y 

(rail

logic

tion

cate

strik

only 

sifie

heav

disp

nag

caus

agai
Bag

scan

tota

Forc

T

agai

eno

wan

line 

assu

tille

grou

man
stra

sup

after 

of t

grou

In O

coa

20,0

them 

men

stru

targ

the 
832 (4%)
The 

vert

the 

agin

serv

airp

thei

over 

In e

serv

asse

wor
Aircraft

9,812

11

11
(Shaw 

[CEN

8

2003 

Syste

Infor

Guar

Desti

In Oc

to cu

thus 

gram

$60 

used 

inven

min

star

had 

earl

*S

“Mora

mer 2

ationa

where 

presid

pilot i

to dro

emplo

aware 
tion 

A

orde

usu

abov

fire. 

indu

crea

casu

Fein

can 

like 

that 
usu

pilot

lows 

cien

guid

for P

an e

the t

altit

abov

T

accu

tion
was 

D

tack

near 

wha

as—

mili

colu

seve

strik

78-d

genc

titud
lian

Slob

atro

1

Bosn

Publi

2

Airstr

and J

May 
4

York: 
fairl

Cen

mat

and 

tive 

wars 

twen

*S

of Str

Conra

Intere

“Lesso

A10. S
O

figu

nal 

eth 

casu

add

vicio

Gerh

that 

(10 m

that 

as a 

ians 
the 

initi

Late

Unfo

tinu

as t

mor

died 

in A

If 

pres

ple 

eth 
• 
• 

C

any 

atta

peop
effec

cate

sinc

plan

dead

mea

has 

Mor

forc

min

eral 

over 

not 
table 

Death

22 (fa

5

Histo

Unive

6

Siege 

514–

to st

millio

claim

than 

perso

The 

Unive
Steph

War 

York: 

killed 

tonis

doub

Rise 

Arma

Press

8

Iraqis 

9

Surve

on-li

from 

Fourt
All s

Every

1

“Land

Free 

Septe

org/l
air in

Air S

air su

air su

Air W
budg

Bund

Bunk

Cann

Carte

cente

Chur

civilia

Cliffo

Clint

close 

coalit

collat

Comb

comm
Field 

th

Fiftee

fighte

Gene

Gene

Germ

1

gradu

Haip

Hano

Hark

Harm

Head

heari
Kenn

Kenn

Khe S

Kissi

Kono

Korea

Koso

Laird

laser

LeMa

Lewis

Lewy

Lineb

Lodg

Luftw
Ninth 

Nixon

North 

North 

1

North 

Okin

opera

Overy

Partr

Persi
South

South 

Spee

Stock

Strat

strat

3

surfa

8

Suzu

Tacti

tactic

Taylo

Tet o

Toma
US C

US M

1

US M

7

US N

1

Vand

Vietc

Vietn

Vietn

War D

weap

Wein

West