Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Author: Tetra Tech and Abt Associates

Date Created: 5/7/2013

Date Modified: 5/16/2014

Purpose:

Contains technology costs for new units options and provides number of new units used for ICR/admin costs 

assignment. Uses information from New Unit & Repowering Costs5-6-13forAbt.xlsx received from TetraTech on 

5/7/13. 

File Contents:

Worksheet Contents

2013 Options Contains costs factors for estimating new unit capacity values.

2013 Costs Develops total new units technology costs by option.

2013 Summary Tables Contains summary tables with the number of new units as well as new units capacity and costs by option.

EPA New Unit Costs Contains unit closed-cycle cooling costs for new units based on generating capacity by capacity type. Also 

includes new units costs used in IPM analysis.

Notes Provides information on the new units option costs contained in this file.

Input Files:

External data used in calculations/analysis:

None

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 1
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Version 5-6-13 

Revised 4-22-13 version on 5-6-13 to exlude stand alone units from high energy efficiency definition (Option C) and changed 

Revised on 4-22-13 to include Summary of Number of Units Table - no other revisions made to 4-8-13 version

Revision of 12-10/11-12 new unit cost analysis using revised baseline compliance assumptions (90% for adjacent; 75% for rep

Created by Tetra Tech 4-8-13

Revision of 12-10/11-12 new unit cost analysis using revised baseline compliance assumptions (90% for adjacent; 75% for rep

EPA has selected Option C ( Turbine and condenser is newly built or replaced, Excluding high efficiency systems) as the final o

Uses same data and calculation approach used to derive New Unit Option Costs sent to EPA on 12-10-12

Note that Option IDs have evolved and tables in the "2013 options" tab use the original Tetra Tech letter IDs

Key to Evolving Option IDS

EPA Final Option (EPA December 

Briefing)

Option A - All standalone greenfield 

and repowered VI iv. New units defined as any repowering

Option B - Turbine and condenser is 

newly built or replaced III

 iii. New units defined as building a turbine and condenser 

(not including all other upgrades) with no exemptions

Option C - Turbine and condenser is 

newly built or replaced, Excluding 

high efficiency systems II

 ii. New units defined as building a turbine and condenser 

(not including all other upgrades) with some or all of the 

exemptions for “efficiency” listed below.

Option D - Only standalone greenfield 

(proposal) I

 i. New units defined as standalone greenfield construction 

only (As presented at proposal)

EPA 12-6-12 Options

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 1
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

tion (Option C) and changed stand alone capital costs from $0 to same as repowered units

-8-13 version

90% for adjacent; 75% for repowered).

90% for adjacent; 75% for repowered).

ciency systems) as the final option

ch letter IDs

EPA Initial 

Option ID

NA - New

Option A All new units 1

Option B 

Excludes combined cycle 

and cogenand repowered 2

Option D

Stand alone greenfield 

construction only 3

Option C 

Excludes combined cycle, 

cogen and repowered NA - New

BPJ 4

EPA 11-27- Option IDs 

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 2
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

 from $0 to same as repowered units

Original Tt ID

Option F - EM requirements for all adjacent and all types of 

repowering

Option A - EM requirements for all adjacent new units and 

repowered new units

Option D - EM Requirements for all adjacent new units and 

repowered new units with an exclusion for high efficiency 

generation systems

Option B - EM requirements for adjacent new units only

Option E - EM requirements for lower efficiency adjacent 

units only

Option C - Site-specific EM for all adjacent new units and 

repowered new units

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 3
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Assumed CUR 80.0%

Assumed Power Costs $/MWH $45

New Unit Costs for Repowering and New Added Units

Costs in 2009 dollars

Costs and Generating Output Reduction Equation Units

GPM/MW

Capital Cost - Repowering (CC) CC = MWS x Constant Dollars

Capital Cost - New Unit with New Intake (CC) CC = MWS x Constant Dollars

Fixed O&M Cost (OMF) OMF = MWS x Constant Dollars

Variable O&M - Chemicals (OMC) OMC= MWS x Constant Dollars

Variable O&M - Pump & Fan Power (OMV) OMV= MWS x Constant MW

Energy Penalty -Heat Rate (EP) Non-nuclear EP=MWS x Constant MW

Energy Penalty -Heat Rate (EP) Nuclear EP=MWS x Constant MW

New Unit Costs for Repowering and New Added Units

Adjusted to 2011 using ENR CCI = 8938.3 (January 2011)

Costs and Generating Output Reduction Equation Units

GPM/MW

Capital Cost - Repowering (CC) CC = MWS x Constant Dollars

Capital Cost - New Unit with New Intake (CC) CC = MWS x Constant Dollars

Fixed O&M Cost (OMF) OMF = MWS x Constant Dollars

Variable O&M - Chemicals (OMC) OMC= MWS x Constant Dollars

Variable O&M - Pump & Fan Power (OMV) OMV= MWS x Constant MW

Energy Penalty -Heat Rate (EP) Non-nuclear EP=MWS x Constant MW

Energy Penalty -Heat Rate (EP) Nuclear EP=MWS x Constant MW

New Unit Costs for IPM - Abt

Adjusted to 2011 using ENR CCI = 8938.3 (January 2011)

Costs and Generating Output Reduction Equation Units

Adj Factors

Capital Cost - New Unit with New Intake (CC) CC = MWS x Constant Dollars/MW

Fixed O&M Cost (OMF) OMF = MWS x Constant Dollars/MW

Variable O&M - Chemicals (OMC) OMC= MWS x Constant Dollars/MWh

Variable O&M - Pump & Fan Power (OMV) OMV= MWS x Constant MWh 

Variable O&M - Pump & Fan Power (OMV) OMV= MWS x Constant Dollars

Variable O&M - Pump & Fan Power (OMV) OMV= MWS x Constant %

Variable O&M - Pump & Fan Power (OMV) OMV= MWS x Constant Dollars/MWh

Tech Capacity (MW) MW

ICR/Admin Capacity (MW) MW

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 1
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Coal (42% 

Efficient)

Combined 

Cycle ( 57% 

Efficient)

Nuclear 

(33.5% 

Efficient)

390 200 680

$60,060 $30,800 $104,720

$60,060 $30,800 $104,720

$366 $188 $639

$151 $77 $262

0.0077 0.0040 0.0134

0 0 0

0 0 0

Coal (42% 

Efficient)

Combined 

Cycle ( 57% 

Efficient)

Nuclear 

(33.5% 

Efficient)

390 200 680

$63,842 $32,739 $111,314

$63,842 $32,739 $111,314

$389 $200 $679

$160 $82 $279

0.0077 0.0040 0.0134

0 0 0

0 0 0

Coal (42% 

Efficient)

Combined 

Cycle ( 57% 

Efficient)

3.00% 3.00%

$1,915.25 $982.18

$11.68 $5.99

$0.000685 $0.000351

1.6204 0.8310

$72.92 $37.39

0.0231% 0.0119%

$1.35 $1.35

8.85 97.92

88.50 979.20

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 2
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Option F - EM requirements for all adjacent new units and repowered new units 

(any repowering)

Option A - EM requirements for all adjacent new units and repowered new units 

(replace turbine & condenser only)

Option D - EM Requirements for all adjacent new units and repowered new units 

with an exclusion for high efficiency generation systems

Option B - EM requirements for adjacent new units only (Proposal)

Option E - EM requirements for lower efficiency adjacent units only

Option C - Site-specific EM for all adjacent new units and repowered new units

Option - Tetra Tech ID

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 1
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 2
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Coal & Biomass

Combined Cycle

Total

1 Repowering where both the steam turbine and condenser are replaced

Summary of Estimated Annual New Unit Generating Capacity by Category EPA 

Coal & Biomass

Combined Cycle

Total

1 Repowering including modified/overhauled steam turbine and condenser 

Stand 

Alone

Repowe

red 

Option IV - All stand alone greenfield new 

units and all types of repowered new 

units 1

Option A - All standalone greenfield and 

repowered 276 1,757

Option III - All new units where turbine 

and condenser is newly built or replaced 

Option B - Turbine and condenser is newly 

built or replaced 93 724

Option II - All new units where turbine 

and condenser is newly built or replaced 

excluding high efficiency systems

Option C - Turbine and condenser is newly 

built or replaced, Excluding high efficiency 

systems

93 0

 Option I - all stand alone greenfield new 

units only 

Option D -Only standalone greenfield 

(proposal) 0 0

8 0

0 0

1

 Option IV does not include costs for nuclear uprates which may would could potentially increase the cost estimate consider

Total Including Phase 

MW

Fuel Type

295

3,264

3,559

New Capacity

Total Including Phase 

New Capacity

MW

3,264

Fuel Type

3,559

Summary of Estimated Annual New Unit Generating Capacity by Category EPA 

Baseline Noncompliant 

Option Description EPA Final Options Capacity (MW)

295

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 3
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Values in table are added annually

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 4
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Repowered 

Existing 1 Total

Stand Alone

Repower

ed 1

Total Stand 

Alone

Repowered 

1

Total

MW MW MW MW MW MW MW MW

364 659 80 373 453 8 93 101

2065 5,329 147 2898 3,044 15 0 15

2,430 5,989 227 3,271 3,497 23 93 116

ondenser are replaced 6

ng Capacity by Category EPA Final Option A

Repowered 

Existing 1 Total

Stand Alone

Repower

ed 1 Total Stand Alone

Repowered 

1 Total

MW MW MW MW MW MW MW MW

1093 1,388 80 1102 1,182 8 276 284

6196 9,460 147 7028 7,175 15 1,757 1,772

7,289 10,848 227 8,130 8,357 23 2,033 2,055

m turbine and condenser 14

Stand 

Alone

Repower

ed Total

$7,400,000 $0 $7,400,000 0.5 2.9 3.4 1,282 $6,000

$2,980,000 $0 $2,980,000 0.2 1.2 1.4 462 $6,000

$675,000 $0 $675,000 0.16 0.0 0.2 68 $10,000

$96,000 $0 $96,000 0.0 0.0 0.0 7 $13,000

$49,000 $0 $49,000 0.0 0.0 0.0 3 $17,000

$0 $35,000 $35,000 0 0.0 0.0 0 NA 

se the cost estimate considerably 

Existing Facilities Non-compliant Only

Total Including Phase I Existing Facility New Units Only Existing Facilities Non-compliant Only

Total Including Phase I Existing Facility New Units Only

New Unit Option Costs and Impacts

ng Capacity by Category EPA Final Option C

Estimated Number of New 

Unit Projects Requiring CCRS Flow 

Reduction 

(MGD)

Annualized 

Cost per MGD 

Reduction

Total 

Annualized 

Cost

Total 

Annualized 

ECS

Total 

Annualized 

Capital and 

O&M

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 5
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 6
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Current1

MW

MW Coal & Biomass 295

3,573 Combined Cycle 3,264

1,491 Total 3,559

5,064 1

 Includes 100 MW added to new coal

2

 Assumes distribution of 15% coal & biomass and 85% combined cycle

ICR/Admin

MW Number Units

3,573 Coal & Biomass 2.0

1,491 Combined Cycle 12.0

5,064 Total 13.9

* Used conservative assumption that any new unit or repowering that replaces turbine & co

0.13275

0.2448

Total Including 

Phase I New 

Capacity Used 

at Proposal

Total Including 

Phase I New 

Capacity Used 

at Proposal

Estimated Annual New and Repowered Capacity

Fuel Type

New Capacity

Fuel Type

Option A

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 7
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 8
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Proposal

Current @ 

0.22% Current @ 0.5%

MW MW MW MW MW

3,573 160 364 659 659

1,491 909 2,065 5,329 5,329

5,064 1,069 2,430 5,989

0.50%

Non-Compliant ICR/Admin* Non-Compliant ICR/Admin* Non-Compliant ICR/Admin*

Number Units Number Units Number Units Number Units Number Units Number Units

0.5 0.8 0.2 0.8 0.17 0.8

3.0 5.1 1.2 5.1 0.02 5.1

3.4 5.83 1.4 6 0.2 6

ng that replaces turbine & condenser may be subject to admin activities until deemed compliant

0.013275 10.00%

0.02448 10.00%

and Repowered Capacity

New Capacity Repowered 2

Summary of Number of Unit

Option A Option B Option C Option D

Total Current @ 

0.5

Total Including 

Phase I 

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 9
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 10
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Non-Compliant 

Number Units

0.01

0.02

0.04

Option D

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 11
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Input Values

Annual New Capacity Proposal Current

MW 24 yr

Coal 3,573 295 7080

Combined Cycle 1,491 3,264 78336

Total 5,064 3,559

1.42

MW

Existing Generating Capacity 485,943

Tubine & CondRepower Any

Percent Existing Capacity Repowered Annually 0.50% 1.5%

Percent Repowered as Coal 0.08% 0.23%

Percent Repowered as Combined Cycle 0.43% 1.28%

Assumed CUR 80.0%

Assumed Power Costs $/MWH 45 Also in January 2011 dollars

Annualization Factor 0.051

Average Project Size (MW) 600

Flow Reduction 94.9%

Makeup Volume 5.1%

Baseline Flow /MW (gpm/MW) 600

New Unit Once Through Flow Coal 390

New Unit Once Through Flow

Combined 

Cycle 200

New Unit Once Through Flow Nuclear 680

ICR Costs

ECS $490,000

Activity Cost

Parallel in 

EFR? Frequency

Start-up 2800

No (keep all 

costs) once

Permit application (122.21r2 and r3) 7600 Yes

Source waterbody flow (125.86b3) 4500

No (keep all 

costs) once

Source water biological baseline (122.21r4) 15500 Yes

Track 1 flow reduction 5300

No (keep all 

costs)

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 1
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Track 1 velocity 8000

No (keep all 

costs)

Track 1 design and construction 5700

No (keep all 

costs)

Remote inspection equipment 59000 No* once

$49,400 plus 

$59,000 for 

equipment

EPA Option B (Tt A) - EM requirements for all adjacent new units and repowered new units

Total Capacity 

including 

Phase 1

Category 

Capacity

Noncompliant 

Capacity

MW MW MW

New Adjacent Unit Coal 266 80 8.0

New Adjacent Unit Combined Cycle 490 147 15

Repowered New Capacity Coal 30 9 2

Repowered New Capacity Combined Cycle 2774 832 208

existing capacity Repowered as Coal 364 364 91

existing capacity Repowered as Combined Cycle 2065 2065 516

Total 5989 3497 840

Rep Coal 394 373 93

Rep CC 4840 2898 724

EPA Option D (Tt B) - EM requirements for adjacent new units only

Total Capacity 

including 

Phase 1

Category 

Capacity

Noncompliant 

Capacity

MW MW MW

New Adjacent Unit Coal 266 80 8.0

New Adjacent Unit Combined Cycle 490 147 15

Repowered New Capacity Coal 0 0 0

Repowered New Capacity Combined Cycle 0 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Coal 0 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Combined Cycle 0 0 0

Total 755 227 23

Rep Coal 0 0 0

Rep CC 0 0 0

EPA Option BPJ (Tt C) - Site-specific EM for all adjacent new units and repowered new units

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 2
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Option not Included in EPA Briefing

Category 

Capacity

Noncompliant 

Capacity

MW MW

New Adjacent Unit Coal 0 0.0

New Adjacent Unit Combined Cycle 0 0

Repowered New Capacity Coal 0 0

Repowered New Capacity Combined Cycle 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Coal 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Combined Cycle 0 0

Total

New 0 0

Repowered 0 0

EPA Option C (Tt D) - EM Requirements for all adjacent new units and repowered new units with an exclusion for high effic

Seleted Option

Category 

Capacity

Noncompliant 

Capacity

MW MW

New Adjacent Unit Coal 80 8.0

New Adjacent Unit Combined Cycle 147 15

Repowered New Capacity Coal 9 2

Repowered New Capacity Combined Cycle 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Coal 364 91

existing capacity Repowered as Combined Cycle 0 0

Total 600 116

Rep Coal 0 373 93

Rep CC 0 0 0

EPA Option (Tt E) - EM Requirements for all adjacent new units with an exclusion for high efficiency generation systems

Option not Included in EPA Briefing

Category 

Capacity

Noncompliant 

Capacity

MW MW

New Adjacent Unit Coal 80 8.0

New Adjacent Unit Combined Cycle 0 0

Repowered New Capacity Coal 0 0

Repowered New Capacity Combined Cycle 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Coal 0 0

existing capacity Repowered as Combined Cycle 0 0

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 3
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Total

New 80 8

Repowered 0 0

EPA Option A (Tt F)- EM requirements for all stand alone greenfield new units and all types of repowered new units 

Total Capacity 

including 

Phase 1

Category 

Capacity

Noncompliant 

Capacity

MW MW MW

New Adjacent Unit Coal 266 80 8.0

New Adjacent Unit Combined Cycle 490 147 15

Repowered New Capacity Coal 30 9 2

Repowered New Capacity Combined Cycle 2774 832 208

existing capacity Repowered as Coal 1093 1093 273

existing capacity Repowered as Combined Cycle 6196 6196 1549

Total 10848 8357 2055

Rep Coal 1123 1102 276

Rep CC 8970 7028 1757

8130

23 year

Plant Type Capacity 

(MW) Annual Ave (MW

Biomass 4,475 195

Coal Steam 0 0

Combined Cycle 75,077 3,264

Combustion Turbine 5,505 239

Fossil Waste 0 0

Fuel Cell 0 0

Geothermal 900 39

Hydro 0 0

Landfill Gas 3,163 138

Municipal Solid Waste 0 0

Non-Fossil Waste 0 0

Nuclear 0 0

O/G Steam 0 0

Pumped Storage 0 0

Solar 233 10

Tires 0 0

Wind 24,851 1,080

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 4
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Total 114,204 4,965

Grouped

Nuclear 0 0

Coal 0 0

Renewables/Other 33622.00 1462.00

Natural Gas 80,582 3,503

biomass & Coal 4,475 195

Steam total 3,459

Existing Capacity from Abt Email 11-22-12

Plant Type Excl. BL CCRS Incl. BL 

CCRS

Coal Steam 190,869 278,293

Combined Cycle 31,369 33,426

Gas 40,698 42,914

Nuclear 61,788 88,532 Total Phase 1 & repowered & New @ 0

Oil 20,408 20,570 Total repowered & New @ 0

Other Steam 549 766 Total Phase 1 & repowered & New @ 

Total 345,682 464,501 Total repowered & New @ 

Total Phase 1 & repowered & New @ 

Coal Steam 199,345 289,534 Total repowered & New @ 

Combined Cycle 35,123 37,510

Gas 43,445 46,540

Nuclear 61,937 88,680

Oil 22,370 22,553

Other Steam 898 1,127

Total 363,118 485,943

New 4-8-13

Exhibit IX-3.—Annual and 24-year total capacity at existing facilities requiring costs for closed-cycle

Stand-alone Repowered Total 

MW MW MW

Fossil Fuel 8 93 101

Combined Cycle 15 0 14.688

Total 23 93 116

Old

Exhibit IX-3.—Annual and 24-year total capacity at existing facilities requiring costs for closed-cycle

Fuel type

Annual only

Total Capacity

Capacity (MW)

Steam Capacity

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 5
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Stand-alone Repowered Total 

MW MW MW

Fossil Fuel 40 187 226

Combined Cycle 73 1,449 1,522

Total 113 1,635 1,749

Fuel type

Annual only

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 6
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Added by Abt

pound_to_ton 0.0005

0.22% 0.50% heat_rate_coal 8,500 BTU/KWh 

8% 160 364 heat_rate_ngcc 6,800 BTU/KWh 

92% 909 2065 co2_coeff_coal 210.2 pounds CO2 per million B

co2_coeff_natgas 117.0 pounds CO2 per million B

Based on the gpm/MW values used in converting $/GPM to $/M

HHV LHV

NGCC 6,800 6,100

Abt Coal 8,500 8,200

0.22% 0.50%

Abt Mix EIA 25 yr Additions mix Use

8% 16% 15%

92% 84% 85% 5.67

o in January 2011 dollars Economic Factors 

Discount rate, % 3.0%

Assumed life, yrs 30

Amortization factor0.051

Use

2800

4500

5300

Repowered Total MW @

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 7
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

8000

5700

Use Annualized

26300 30,000 Set equal to $0 for now

B B B B B B B

Capital Cost 

(CC) 

Fixed O&M 

Cost (OMF)

Variable O&M - 

Chemicals 

(OMC)

Variable 

O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power 

(OMV)

Variable O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power (OMV)

Total O&M 

Adjusted for 

CUR

Annualized 

Capital

Dollars Dollars Dollars MW Dollars Dollars Dollars

$508,499 $3,102 $1,275 0.1 $24,200 $23,481 $25,943

$480,876 $2,933 $1,205 0.1 $22,885 $22,205 $24,534

$141,250 $862 $354 0.0 $6,722 $6,523 $7,206

$6,812,403 $41,555 $17,075 0.8 $324,203 $314,578 $347,564

$5,816,895 $35,483 $14,580 0.7 $276,827 $268,608 $296,774

$16,903,797 $103,112 $42,369 2.0 $804,454 $780,570 $862,419

$30,663,720 $187,046 $76,858 3.7 $1,459,290 $1,415,965 $1,564,440

5958145 36344 14934 1 283549 275131 303980

23716200 144667 59445 3 1128657 1095148 1209983

D D D D D D D

Capital Cost 

(CC) 

Fixed O&M 

Cost (OMF)

Variable O&M - 

Chemicals 

(OMC)

Variable 

O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power 

(OMV)

Variable O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power (OMV)

Total O&M 

Adjusted for 

CUR

Annualized 

Capital

Dollars Dollars Dollars MW Dollars Dollars Dollars

$508,499 $3,102 $1,275 0.1 $24,200 $23,481 $25,943

$480,876 $2,933 $1,205 0.1 $22,885 $22,205 $24,534

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$989,375 $6,035 $2,480 0.1 $47,084 $45,687 $50,477

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 8
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Capital Cost 

(CC) 

Fixed O&M 

Cost (OMF)

Variable O&M - 

Chemicals 

(OMC)

Variable 

O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power 

(OMV)

Variable O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power (OMV)

Total O&M 

Adjusted for 

CUR

Annualized 

Capital

Dollars Dollars Dollars MW Dollars Dollars Dollars

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

C C C C C C C

Capital Cost 

(CC) 

Fixed O&M 

Cost (OMF)

Variable O&M - 

Chemicals 

(OMC)

Variable 

O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power 

(OMV)

Variable O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power (OMV)

Total O&M 

Adjusted for 

CUR

Annualized 

Capital

Dollars Dollars Dollars MW Dollars Dollars Dollars

$508,499 $3,102 $1,275 0.1 $24,200 $23,481 $25,943

$480,876 $2,933 $1,205 0.1 $22,885 $22,205 $24,534

$141,250 $862 $354 0.0 $6,722 $6,523 $7,206

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$5,816,895 $35,483 $14,580 0.7 $276,827 $268,608 $296,774

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$6,947,520 $42,379 $17,414 0.8 $330,633 $320,817 $354,457

5958145 36344 14934 1 283549 275131 303980

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

igh efficiency generation systems

Capital Cost 

(CC) 

Fixed O&M 

Cost (OMF)

Variable O&M - 

Chemicals 

(OMC)

Variable 

O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power 

(OMV)

Variable O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power (OMV)

Total O&M 

Adjusted for 

CUR

Annualized 

Capital

Dollars Dollars Dollars MW Dollars Dollars Dollars

$508,499 $3,000 $1,000 0.1 $24,000 $23,000 $25,943

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 0.0 $0 $0 $0

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 9
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

$508,499 $3,000 $1,000 0.1 $24,000 $23,000 $25,943

A A A A A A A

Capital Cost 

(CC) 

Fixed O&M 

Cost (OMF)

Variable O&M - 

Chemicals 

(OMC)

Variable 

O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power 

(OMV)

Variable O&M - Pump 

& Fan Power (OMV)

Total O&M 

Adjusted for 

CUR

Annualized 

Capital

Dollars Dollars Dollars MW Dollars Dollars Dollars

$508,499 $3,102 $1,275 0.1 $24,200 $23,481 $25,943

$480,876 $2,933 $1,205 0.1 $22,885 $22,205 $24,534

$141,250 $862 $354 0.0 $6,722 $6,523 $7,206

$6,812,403 $41,555 $17,075 0.8 $324,203 $314,578 $347,564

$17,450,685 $106,448 $43,740 2.1 $830,480 $805,824 $890,321

$50,711,391 $309,335 $127,108 6.1 $2,413,362 $2,341,711 $2,587,258

$76,105,103 $464,235 $190,757 9.2 $3,621,852 $3,514,322 $3,882,826

17591934 107309 44094 2 837202 812347 897527

57523794 350891 144183 7 2737565 2656289 2934821

Annual Energy Outlook 2011

Add coal plant Distribution Excluding Renewables

195 Natural Gas 60% 81%

100 Coal 11% 15%

3264 Renewables 25%

239 Nuclear 3% 4%

0 http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/archive/aeo11/MT_naturalgas.cfm from:

0

39

0 GW % of Total GW % of Total

138 2010-2015 1.12 2% 12.41 19%

0 2016-2020 5.20 27% 2.30 12%

0 2021-2025 0.00 0% 2.71 8%

0 2026-2030 0.00 0% 3.61 7%

0 2031-2035 0.00 0% 4.48 8%

0 Total Additions 6.32 3% 25.51 11%

10 New Capacity* 0% 0%

0 *Distribution of new capacity from Abt

1080 Distribution coal v NG 16%

Figure 78. Electricity generation capacity add

Nuclear Coal

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 10
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

5,065

0 0% 0%

100 0% 2%

1462.00 29% 29%

3,503 71% 69%

295 4% 6%

November 25, 2012 Arcle :"The demise of coal-fired power plants"

States that between now and 2016 companies plan to close down 30 gigawatts of coal capacit

4 yr 1 yr Assumed CUR Operating Increase

MW MW MW

Rate of Coal Closure 30,000 7,500 0.4 3,000

tal Phase 1 & repowered & New @ 0.22% 4,628 0.8 3,702 702

Total repowered & New @ 0.22% 2,137 0.8 1,709

otal Phase 1 & repowered & New @ 0.5% 5,989 0.8 4,791 1,791

Total repowered & New @ 0.5% 3,497 0.8 2,798

otal Phase 1 & repowered & New @ 1.0% 8,418 0.8 6,735 3,735

Total repowered & New @ 1.0% 5,927 0.8 4,742

Stand-alone Repowered Total 

MW MW MW

192 2232 2424

352.512 0 353

544.512 2232 2777

24-year total only

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 11
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Stand-alone Repowered Total 

MW MW MW

956 4,480 5,435 23.9

1,763 34,771 36,533 24.15068493

2,718 39,251 41,969 24.05309735

24-year total only

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 12
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

ounds CO2 per million Btu

ounds CO2 per million Btu

onverting $/GPM to $/MW of 390 (coal) and 200 (NGCC). Because EIA uses HHV for most of their data reporting and we use CO2 coefficie

Eff HHV Eff LHV

50% 56%

40% 42%

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 13
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

B B B B B B B B

Total 

Annualized

Number 

Facilities 

Req. 

CCRS

Number Facilities 

Req. ECS

Annualized 

ECS Costs

CCRS 

Annual ICR

ECS Costs - 

NonAnnuali

zed

Total 

Annual 

Cost

NonCompliant 

Baseline 

Flow

Dollars gpm

$49,424 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $49,424 2,485

$46,739 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $46,739 2,350

$13,729 0 $13,729 690

$662,142 0 $662,142 33,293

$565,382 0.2 0 $0 $0 $0 $565,382 43,735

$1,642,989 1.2 0 $0 $0 $0 $1,642,989 247,831

$2,980,000 1.4 0.0 $0 $0 $0 $2,980,000 330,384

579111 0 0 0 0 0 579111 44425

2305131 1 0 0 0 0 2305131 281124

$0

D D D D D D D D

Total 

Annualized

Number 

Facilities 

Req. 

CCRS

Number Facilities 

Req. ECS

Annualized 

ECS Costs

CCRS 

Annual ICR

ECS Costs - 

NonAnnuali

zed

Total 

Annual 

Cost

NonCompliant 

Baseline 

Flow

Dollars gpm

$49,424 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $49,424 2,485

$46,739 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $46,739 2,350

$0 0 $0 0

$0 0 $0 0

$0 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0

$0 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0

$96,000 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $0 $96,000 4,835

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

$0

BPJ

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 14
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Total 

Annualized

Number 

Facilities 

Req. 

CCRS

Number Facilities 

Req. ECS

Annualized 

ECS Costs

CCRS 

Annual ICR

ECS Costs - 

NonAnnuali

zed

Total 

Annual 

Cost

NonCompliant 

Baseline 

Flow

Dollars gpm

$0 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $6,500 $0 0

$0 0.0 0.0 $1,000 $0 $12,000 $1,000 0

$0 0 $0 0

$0 0 $0 0

$0 0.0 0.2 $4,000 $0 $76,200 $4,000 0

$0 0.0 1.2 $30,000 $0 $591,600 $30,000 0

$0 0.0 1.4 $35,000 $0 $686,300 $35,000 0

New 0.0 Reduction

Repowered 0.0 Red Vol

$591,600

C C C C C C C C

Total 

Annualized

Number 

Facilities 

Req. 

CCRS

Number Facilities 

Req. ECS

Annualized 

ECS Costs

CCRS 

Annual ICR

ECS Costs - 

NonAnnuali

zed

Total 

Annual 

Cost

NonCompliant 

Baseline 

Flow

Dollars gpm

$49,424 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $49,424 2,485

$46,739 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $0 $46,739 2,350

$13,729 0 $13,729 690

$0 0 $0 0

$565,382 0.2 0 $0 $0 $0 $565,382 43,735

$0 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $0 $0 0

$675,000 0.2 0.0 $0 $0 $0 $675,000 49,260

579111 0 0 0 0 0 579111 44425

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

$0

Red Vol

Total 

Annualized

Number 

Facilities 

Req. 

CCRS

Number Facilities 

Req. ECS

Annualized 

ECS Costs

CCRS 

Annual ICR

Total 

Annual 

Cost

NonCompliant 

Baseline 

Flow

Dollars gpm

$48,943 0.0 0 $0 $0 $48,943 2,485

$0 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $0 0

$0 $0 0

$0 $0 0

$0 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $0 0

$0 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $0 0

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 15
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

$49,000 0.0 0.0 $0 $0 $49,000 2,485

New 0.0 Reduction

Repowered 0.0 Red Vol

$0

A A A A A A A A

Total 

Annualized

Number 

Facilities 

Req. 

CCRS

Number Facilities 

Req. ECS

Annualized 

ECS Costs

CCRS 

Annual ICR

ECS Costs - 

NonAnnuali

zed

Total 

Annual 

Cost

NonCompliant 

Baseline 

Flow

Dollars gpm

$49,424 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $49,424 2,485

$46,739 0.0 0 $0 $0 $0 $46,739 2,350

$13,729 0 $13,729 690

$662,142 0 $662,142 33,293

$1,696,145 0.5 0 $0 $0 $0 $1,696,145 131,205

$4,928,968 2.9 0 $0 $0 $0 $4,928,968 743,493

$7,400,000 3.4 0 $0 $0 $0 $7,400,000 913,516

1709874 0 0 0 0 0 1709874 131895

5591110 3 0 0 0 0 5591110 776786

$0

GW % of Total GW % of Total GW MW/yr

30.17 47% 20.00 31% 63.71 12,741

4.76 25% 6.73 35% 19.00 3,800

10.56 31% 21.26 62% 34.53 6,905

6.73 13% 40.77 80% 51.12 10,224

4.27 8% 46.29 84% 55.03 11,006

56.49 25% 135.06 60% 223.38 8,935

29% 71%

84%

neration capacity additions by fuel type, 2010-2035 (gigawatts)

Renewables/Other Natural Gas Total

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 16
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

gawatts of coal capacity

Increase % of total

0.6%

0.2%

0.4%

0.8%

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 17
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 18
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

and we use CO2 coefficients reported by EIA, we used HHV heat rates.

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 19
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

B B B B B B B B

NonCompliant 

Final Flow

Flow 

Reduction 

(gpm)

Variable 

O&M - 

Chemical

s (OMC)

Variable 

O&M - 

Pump & 

Fan Power 

(OMV) En Pen En Pen Total CO2 Total CO2

gpm gpm Dollars Dollars KWh (MBtu) (short tons) (metric tons)

158 2,300 $1,020 $19,360 430,214 3,657 384 349

150 2,200 $964 $18,308 406,843 2,767 162 147

44 600 $283 $5,378 119,504 1,016 107 97

2,122 31,200 $13,660 $259,363 5,763,611 39,193 2,293 2,080

1,812 41,900 $11,664 $221,461 4,921,365 41,832 4,397 3,989

5,266 242,600 $33,895 $643,563 14,301,402 97,250 5,689 5,161

9,553 321,000 $61,487 $1,167,432 25,942,939 176,412 10,320 9,362

1856 42500 11947 226839 5040869 42847 4503 4085

7389 273800 47556 902926 20065013 136442 7982 7241

$47,556 $902,926

D D D D D D D D

NonCompliant 

Final Flow

Flow 

Reduction 

(gpm)

Variable 

O&M - 

Chemical

s (OMC)

Variable 

O&M - 

Pump & 

Fan Power 

(OMV) En Pen En Pen Total CO2 Total CO2

gpm gpm Dollars Dollars KWh (MBtu) (short tons) (metric tons)

158 2,300 $1,020 $19,360 430,214 3,657 384 349

150 2,200 $964 $18,308 406,843 2,767 162 147

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

308 5,000 $1,984 $37,668 837,057 5,692 333 302

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

$0 $0

BPJ BPJ BPJ BPJ BPJ BPJ

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 20
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

NonCompliant 

Final Flow

Flow 

Reduction 

(gpm)

Variable 

O&M - 

Chemical

s (OMC)

Variable 

O&M - 

Pump & 

Fan Power 

(OMV) En Pen En Pen Total CO2 Total CO2

gpm gpm Dollars Dollars KWh (MBtu) (short tons) (metric tons)

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

0%

0

$0 $0

C C C C C C C C

NonCompliant 

Final Flow

Flow 

Reduction 

(gpm)

Variable 

O&M - 

Chemical

s (OMC)

Variable 

O&M - 

Pump & 

Fan Power 

(OMV) En Pen En Pen Total CO2 Total CO2

gpm gpm Dollars Dollars KWh (MBtu) (short tons) (metric tons)

158 2,300 $1,020 $19,360 430,214 3,657 384 349

150 2,200 $964 $18,308 406,843 2,767 162 147

44 600 $283 $5,378 119,504 1,016 107 97

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

1,812 41,900 $11,664 $221,461 4,921,365 41,832 4,397 3,989

0 0 $0 $0 0 0 0 0

2,165 47,000 $13,931 $264,507 5,877,926 39,970 2,338 2,121

1856 42500 11947 226839 5040869 42847 4503 4085

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

$0 $0

#REF!

NonCompliant 

Final Flow

Flow 

Reduction 

(gpm)

gpm gpm

158 2,300

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 21
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

158 2,000

94%

2,327

$0 $0

A A A A A A A A

NonCompliant 

Final Flow

Flow 

Reduction 

(gpm)

Variable 

O&M - 

Chemical

s (OMC)

Variable 

O&M - 

Pump & 

Fan Power 

(OMV) En Pen En Pen Total CO2 Total CO2

gpm gpm Dollars Dollars KWh (MBtu) (short tons) (metric tons)

158 2,300 $1,020 $19,360 430,214 3,657 384 349

150 2,200 $964 $18,308 406,843 2,767 162 147

44 600 $283 $5,378 119,504 1,016 107 97

2,122 31,200 $13,660 $259,363 5,763,611 39,193 2,293 2,080

5,437 125,800 $34,992 $664,384 14,764,094 125,495 13,190 11,966

15,799 727,700 $101,686 $1,930,689 42,904,205 291,749 17,067 15,483

23,711 890,000 $152,606 $2,897,481 64,388,471 437,842 25,614 23,237

5481 126400 35275 669762 14883598 126511 13296 12062

17922 758900 115346 2190052 48667816 330941 19360 17563

$115,346 $2,190,052

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 22
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 23
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 24
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 25
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

En Pen (%)

mgd

0.8% 3 Coal 0.128015095 $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

0.4% 3 NGCC 65648.76657 $32,739.35 $199.71 $65.65

0.8% 1 Coal $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

0.4% 45 NGCC $32,739.35 $199.71 $65.65

0.8% 60 Coal $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

0.4% 349 NGCC $32,739.35 $199.71 $65.65

0.4% 462 Total

0 $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

0 $32,739.35 $199.71 $65.65

En Pen (%)

0.8% 3 Coal $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

0.4% 3 NGCC $32,739.35 $199.71 $65.65

#DIV/0! 0 Coal

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

#DIV/0! 0 Coal

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

0.5% 7 Total

#DIV/0!

#DIV/0!

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 26
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

En Pen (%)

#DIV/0! 0 Coal

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

#DIV/0! 0 Coal

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

#DIV/0! 0 Coal

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

#DIV/0! 0 Total

En Pen (%)

0.8% 3 Coal $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

0.4% 3 NGCC $32,739.35 $199.71 $65.65

0.8% 1 Coal $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

0.8% 60 Coal $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

#DIV/0! 0 NGCC

0.7% 68 Total

0 $63,841.72 $389.43 $128.02

#DIV/0!

3

0

0

0

0

0

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 27
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

3

En Pen (%)

Capital 

Cost

Fixed 

O&M

Variable 

O&M 

(chemicals)

mgd

0.8% 3 Coal New Coal $63,842 $389 $128

0.4% 3 NGCC New NGCC $32,739 $200 $66

0.8% 1 Coal Repowered Coal $63,842 $389 $128

0.4% 45 NGCC Repowered NGCC $32,739 $200 $66

0.8% 181 Coal $63,842 $389 $128

0.4% 1048 NGCC $32,739 $200 $66

0.4% 1282 Total

0 $63,842 $389 $128

0 $32,739 $200 $66

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 28
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 29
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 30
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 31
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

$2,430.59 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246.46

$2,430.59 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246.46

$2,430.59 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246.46

$2,430.59 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246.46

$2,430.59 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246.46

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 32
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

$2,430.59 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246.46

$2,430.59

$2,430.59

$2,430.59

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 33
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Variable 

O&M 

(auxiliary 

energy 

requirement)

$2,431 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246

$2,431 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246

$2,431 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246

$2,431 1.95 1.95 1.95 1.95

$1,246

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 34
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Costs See Costs Table Figure 8-15 (Flow-based) 8-16 in TDD

Costs are estimated for new added units

Costs are estimated for Increase for existing units (repowering) whi

Cost are estimated for repowered existing capacity estimated at 2% 

295 27.00%

Asumed % not Phase I 30% 295 4.50%

Assumed Baseline Non-compliance Adjacent Unit 10%

Assumed Baseline Non-compliance Repowering 25%

Median Plant size 600

% Not 

Phase I

% Adjacent vs 

Repowered

% Noncompliant 

in Baseline

New adjacent unit coal capacity 30% 90% 10%

New adjacent unit combined cycle capacity 30% 15% 10%

New adjacent unit nuclear capacity 30% 100% 0%

Repowered new coal capacity 30% 10% 25%

Repowered new combined cycle capacity 30% 85% 25%

Repowered new nuclear capacity 0% 0% 25%

Repowered existing coal capacity - - -

Repowered combined cycle capacity - - -

Repowered nuclear capacity - - -

Indicates revised data & links for baseline compliance 4-5-13 

Cost Component

New Capacity

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 1
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

 (Flow-based) 8-16 in TDD

w added units

ease for existing units (repowering) which includes net capital costs and O&M

wered existing capacity estimated at 2% of existing capacity & flow

79.65

13.275

% of Total New 

Capacity that is 

Non-compliant

% of Total 

Existing 

Capacity that is 

Repowered

% Noncompliant in 

Baseline

% of Total 

Existing Capacity 

that is 

Repowered and 

Non-compliant

% of Total 

Existing Capacity 

that is 

Repowered

% Non-compliant 

in Baseline

2.7% - - - - -

0.5% - - - - -

0.0% - - - - -

0.8% - - - - -

6.4% - - - - -

0.0% - - - - -

- 0.075% 25% 0.019% 0.225% 25%

- 0.425% 25% 0.106% 1.275% 25%

- 0% 25% 0% 0% 25%

Existing Capacity Repowered (Replace Turbine & 

Condenser) Existing Capacity Repowered -Liberal Definition

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 2
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

% of Total 

Existing Capacity 

that is 

Repowered and 

Non-compliant

Option F 

(EPA 

Final A)

Option A 

(EPA Final 

B)

- New adjacent unit coal capacity 2.7% 2.7%

- New adjacent unit combined cycle capacity 0.5% 0.5%

- New adjacent unit nuclear capacity 0.0% 0.0%

- Repowered new coal capacity 0.8% 0.8%

- Repowered new combined cycle capacity 6.4% 6.4%

- Repowered new nuclear capacity 0.0% 0.0%

0.056% Repowered existing coal capacity -

0.319% Repowered combined cycle capacity -

0% Repowered nuclear capacity -

Option F 

(EPA 

Final A)

Option A 

(EPA Final 

B)

New adjacent unit coal capacity 0.0% 0.0%

New adjacent unit combined cycle capacity 0.0% 0.0%

New adjacent unit nuclear capacity 0.0% 0.0%

Repowered new coal capacity 0.0% 0.0%

Repowered new combined cycle capacity 0.0% 0.0%

Repowered new nuclear capacity 0.0% 0.0%

Repowered existing coal capacity -

Repowered combined cycle capacity -

Repowered nuclear capacity -

Estimated capacity is used to estimate number of facilities that must conduct an ECS

Cost Component Capacity Estimating Factors Applicable to 

owered -Liberal Definition

Cost Component

Cost Component Capacity Estimating Factors Applicable to Site-sp

Cost Component

% of Total New Capacity that is No

% of Total New Capacity that is No

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 3
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Option B 

(EPA Final 

D) BPJ

Option D 

(EPA Final 

C) Option E

Option F 

(EPA Final 

A)

Option A 

(EPA Final B)

Option B 

(EPA Final 

D) BPJ

2.7% 0% 2.7% 2.7% - - -

0.5% 0% 0.5% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0% 0.8% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

- - 0.056% 0.019% 0% 0%

- - 0.319% 0.106% 0% 0%

- - 0% 0% 0% 0%

Option B 

(EPA Final 

D) BPJ

Option D 

(EPA Final 

C) Option E

Option F 

(EPA Final 

A)

Option A 

(EPA Final B)

Option B 

(EPA Final 

D) BPJ

0.0% 2.7% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0.5% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0.8% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 6.4% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

0.0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% - - -

- - 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.019%

- - 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.106%

- - 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0%

at must conduct an ECS

 Estimating Factors Applicable to EM Requirements for Each New Unit Compliance Option

ating Factors Applicable to Site-specific ECS Requirements for Each New Unit Compliance Option

% of Total New Capacity that is Non-compliant % of Total Existing Capacity that is Repowered and Non-compliant

% of Total New Capacity that is Non-compliant % of Total Existing Capacity that is Repowered and Non-compliant

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 4
Record for the Final Section 316(b) Existing Facilities Rule

Option D 

(EPA Final C) Option E

-

-

-

-

-

-

0.019% 0%

0% 0%

0% 0%

Option D 

(EPA Final C) Option E

-

-

-

-

-

-

0.0% 0.0%

0.0% 0.0%

0.0% 0.0%

s Repowered and Non-compliant

s Repowered and Non-compliant

EPA-HQ-OW-2008-0667-DRAFT-3486 5