Archeological Overview and Assessment for

Wilson's Creek National Battlefield,

Greene and Christian Counties, Missouri

National Park Service - Midwest Archeological Center
$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋2YHUYLHZ ̋DQG ̋$VVHVVPHQW ̋IRU

:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÒ

*UHHQH ̋DQG ̋&KULVWLDQ ̋&RXQWLHVÒ ̋0LVVRXUL

%\

'RXJODV ̋'Ô ̋6FRWW

0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU

7HFKQLFDO ̋5HSRUW ̋1RÔ ̋ÁÁ

8QLWHG ̋6WDWHV ̋'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋,QWHULRU

1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFH

0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU

/LQFROQÒ ̋1HEUDVND

ÎÌÌÌ
7KLV ̋UHSRUW ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋UHYLHZHG ̋DJDLQVW ̋WKH ̋FULWHULD ̋FRQWDLQHG ̋LQ ̋ÈÍ&)5 ̋3DUW ̋ÊÒ ̋6XESDUW ̋$Ò

6HFWLRQ ̋ÊÔÏÂ ̋ıDÙ ̋ıÏÙ ̋DQGÒ ̋XSRQ ̋UHFRPPHQGDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋)LHOG ̋$UHD ̋2IILFH

DQG ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋FODVVLILHG ̋DV

$YDLODEOH

0DNLQJ ̋WKH ̋UHSRUW ̋DYDLODEOH ̋PHHWV ̋WKH ̋FULWHULD ̋RI ̋ÈÍ&)5 ̋3DUW ̋ÊÒ ̋6XESDUW ̋$Ò ̋6HFWLRQ ̋ÊÔÏÂ ̋ıDÙ ̋ıÏÙÔ
L

$EVWUDFW

7KLV ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋RYHUYLHZ ̋DQG ̋DVVHVVPHQW ̋ IRU ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋GHVFULEHV ̋WKH

PXOWLSOH ̋ HSLVRGHV ̋ RI ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ LQYHVWLJDWLRQ ̋ WKDW ̋ KDYH ̋ RFFXUUHG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN ̋ VLQFH ̋ WKH ̋ Ï‰ÁÌVÔ ̋ 7KH

UHSRUW ̋GLVFXVVHV ̋WKH ̋ËÌ ̋UHFRUGHG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋DQG ̋WKHLU ̋UHODWLRQ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋RYHU ̋ÂÒÌÌÌ ̋\HDUV

RI ̋GRFXPHQWHG ̋KXPDQ ̋XVH ̋DQG ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋ODQGVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋DVVHVVPHQW ̋GLVFXVVHV ̋ZKDW ̋LV ̋NQRZQ

DERXW ̋WKH ̋SDUN©V ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFHVÒ ̋EXW ̋PDNHV ̋SDUWLFXODU ̋QRWH ̋WKDW ̋WKH ̋PDLQ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFH

RI ̋ WKH ̋ SDUNÒ ̋ WKH ̋ SK\VLFDO ̋ HYLGHQFH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ ÏÂÁÏ ̋ %DWWOH ̋ RI ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHNÒ ̋ LV ̋ QRW ̋ IXOO\ ̋ UHFRUGHGÒ

GRFXPHQWHGÒ ̋RU ̋VWXGLHGÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋RYHUYLHZ ̋DQG ̋DVVHVVPHQW ̋FRQFOXGHV ̋ZLWK ̋D ̋VHULHV ̋RI ̋UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV ̋IRU

IXWXUH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ LQYHVWLJDWLRQVÒ ̋ LQFOXGLQJ ̋ D ̋ SDUNZLGH ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ DQG ̋ D

PHWDOðGHWHFWLQJ ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHILHOG ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÔ
LL

$FNQRZOHGJPHQWV

7KH ̋GHYHORSPHQW ̋RI ̋WKLV ̋RYHUYLHZ ̋DQG ̋DVVHVVPHQW ̋ZDV ̋VLJQLILFDQWO\ ̋DVVLVWHG ̋E\ ̋D ̋QXPEHU ̋RI ̋SHRSOHÔ

, ̋ZRXOG ̋OLNH ̋WR ̋WKDQN ̋WKH ̋ VWDII ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋ IRU ̋WKHLU ̋DVVLVWDQFH ̋DQG ̋FRXUWHV\

GXULQJ ̋P\ ̋YLVLWV ̋WR ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋DQG ̋ IRU ̋DQVZHULQJ ̋P\ ̋PDQ\ ̋TXHVWLRQVÔ ̋ ̋ ,Q ̋SDUWLFXODU ̋ , ̋ZRXOG ̋OLNH ̋WR ̋WKDQN

&RQQLH ̋ 6ODXJKWHUÒ ̋ *DU\ ̋ 6XOOLYDQÒ ̋ 6DP ̋ 0DUWLQVHQÒ ̋ -RKQ ̋ 6XWWRQÒ ̋ DQG ̋ -HII ̋ 3DWULFN ̋ IRU ̋ WKHLU ̋ KHOS ̋ DQG

JUDFLRXVQHVVÒ ̋DQG ̋IRU ̋WKHLU ̋FRPPHQWV ̋RQ ̋HDUOLHU ̋UHSRUW ̋GUDIWVÔ

0\ ̋VLQFHUH ̋WKDQNV ̋DUH ̋DOVR ̋H[WHQGHG ̋WR ̋RXU ̋SHUSHWXDO ̋YROXQWHHUÒ ̋'LFN ̋+DUPRQÒ ̋IRU ̋KLV ̋DEOH ̋DVVLVWDQFH

DQG ̋DGYLFH ̋GXULQJ ̋RQH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋YLVLWVÔ ̋ ̋'UÔ ̋7KRPDV ̋6ZHHQH\ ̋DQG ̋.DUHQ ̋6ZHHQH\ ̋NLQGO\ ̋DOORZHG ̋XV

DFFHVV ̋WR ̋WKH ̋*HQHUDO ̋6ZHHQH\ ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋0XVHXP ̋WKH\ ̋ RZQ ̋ DQG ̋ RSHUDWH ̋MXVW ̋ RXWVLGH ̋WKH ̋ SDUNÔ ̋ ̋7KHLU

H[WHQVLYH ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋DQG ̋7UDQVð0LVVLVVLSSL ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋FROOHFWLRQ ̋ZDV ̋QRW ̋RQO\ ̋LPSUHVVLYH ̋WR ̋YLHZÒ

EXW ̋LQYDOXDEOH ̋WR ̋WKH ̋GHYHORSPHQW ̋RI ̋WKLV ̋ZRUNÔ

7KRPDV ̋ 7KLHVVHQ ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ &HQWHU ̋ SURYLGHG ̋ DGYLFH ̋ DQG ̋ DFWHG ̋ DV ̋ D ̋ VRXQGLQJ

ERDUG ̋RQ ̋PDQ\ ̋RFFDVLRQVÔ ̋ ̋$V ̋DOZD\VÒ ̋WKDQNV ̋7RPÔ ̋ ̋6KHUGD ̋:LOOLDPV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋5HJLRQDO ̋2IILFH

DQG ̋ VHYHUDO ̋ RWKHU ̋ UHYLHZHUV ̋ SURYLGHG ̋ XVHIXO ̋ FRPPHQWV ̋ RQ ̋ WKH ̋ GUDIW ̋ UHSRUW ̋ IRU ̋ ZKLFK ̋ , ̋ DP ̋ JUDWHIXOÔ

&DUURO ̋ 0R[KDP ̋ DQG ̋ .HQ ̋ *REEHU ̋ LQVXUHG ̋ WKLV ̋ GRFXPHQW ̋ PHW ̋ WKH ̋ XVXDO ̋ KLJK ̋ VWDQGDUGV ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 5HSRUW

3URGXFWLRQ ̋7HDPÔ
LLL

7DEOH ̋RI ̋&RQWHQWV

$EVWUDFW ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔL

$FNQRZOHGJPHQWVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔLL

/LVW ̋RI ̋7DEOHV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔLY

/LVW ̋RI ̋)LJXUHV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔLY

,QWURGXFWLRQÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏ

(QYLURQPHQWÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍ

5HJLRQDO ̋&XOWXUH ̋+LVWRU\ ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔË

3UHYLRXV ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋,QYHVWLJDWLRQVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔ‰

([SHFWHG ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFHVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÍ

3K\VLRJUDSKLF ̋&RQVLGHUDWLRQVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÍ

:DWHU ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÍ

9DOOH\ ̋%RWWRPV ̋DQG ̋6WUHDP ̋7HUUDFHVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÍ

5LGJHWRSVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÍ

3UHKLVWRULF ̋6LWH ̋DQG ̋)HDWXUH ̋7\SHVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÈ

7DVNð6SHFLILF ̋7\SHV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÈ

+DELWDWLRQ ̋6LWHV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÈ

6LWH ̋'HQVLW\ ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÈ

6LWH ̋$JHVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏË

3UHKLVWRULF ̋6LWHVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏË

+LVWRULFð$JH ̋6LWHV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏË

3RWHQWLDO ̋7KUHDWV ̋WR ̋WKH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFHV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÊ

'HYHORSPHQW ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÊ

9HJHWDWLYH ̋0DQLSXODWLRQÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÊ

9DQGDOLVPÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏÊ

0DQDJHPHQW ̋5HFRPPHQGDWLRQV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏ‰

&XOWXUDO ̋6LWHV ̋,QYHQWRU\ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏ‰

3DUNZLGH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋,QYHQWRU\ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÏ‰

6SHFLILF ̋1HHGV ̋IRU ̋)XWXUH ̋3DUNZLGH ̋,QYHVWLJDWLRQV ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÎÌ

&RQFOXVLRQVÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÎÏ

5HIHUHQFHV ̋&LWHG ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÎÍ
LY

7DEOHV

ÏÔ /LVW ̋RI ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋UHFRUGHG ̋RU ̋NQRZQ ̋DW ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÎ‰

)LJXUHV

ÏÔ /RFDWLRQ ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍÏ

ÎÔ 7KH ̋ 5D\ ̋ +RXVH ̋ SOD\HG ̋ D ̋ SURPLQHQW ̋ UROH ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ EDWWOH ̋ DQG ̋ ZDV ̋ WKH ̋ VLWH ̋ RI ̋ WKH

&RQIHGHUDWH ̋ILHOG ̋KRVSLWDO ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍÎ

ÍÔ 7KH ̋5D\ ̋&RUQILHOG ̋VDZ ̋&RQIHGHUDWH ̋ILUH ̋ZLWKHU ̋D ̋8QLRQ ̋DGYDQFH ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍÎ

ÈÔ %ORRG\ ̋+LOO ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋ VFHQH ̋RI ̋ VRPH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋PRVW ̋LQWHQVH ̋ ILJKWLQJ ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋$XJXVW ̋ ÏÌÒ

ÏÂÁÏÒ ̋EDWWOHÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍÍ

ËÔ *HQHUDO ̋6LJHO©V ̋DWWDFN ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋&RQIHGHUDWH ̋UHDU ̋ZDV ̋KDOWHG ̋QHDU ̋WKLV ̋ORFDWLRQ ÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍÍ

ÁÔ .QRZQ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋DW ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍÈ

ÊÔ 'DUUHOO ̋7URJGRQ©V ̋UHOLF ̋ILQGV ̋DURXQG ̋%ORRG\ ̋+LOOÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÔÍË
Ï

,QWURGXFWLRQ

7KH ̋ UROOLQJ ̋ KLOOV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ 2]DUN ̋ XSODQGV ̋ DORQJ ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHN ̋ ZHUH ̋WKH ̋ VFHQH ̋ RI ̋ RQH ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ HDUOLHVW

DUPHG ̋FODVKHV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋$PHULFDQ ̋&LYLO ̋:DUÔ ̋ ̋2Q ̋$XJXVW ̋ ÏÌÒ ̋ ÏÂÁÏÒ ̋8QLRQ ̋WURRSV ̋ XQGHU ̋WKH ̋ FRPPDQG ̋ RI

*HQHUDO ̋ 1DWKDQLHO ̋ /\RQ ̋ ZHUH ̋ GHIHDWHG ̋ LQ ̋ D ̋ KDUGðIRXJKW ̋ EDWWOH ̋ ZLWK ̋ &RQIHGHUDWH ̋ IRUFHV ̋ OHG ̋ E\ ̋ 0DMRU

*HQHUDO ̋ 6WHUOLQJ ̋ 3ULFH ̋ DQG ̋ *HQHUDO ̋%HQ ̋0F&XOORFK ̋ ı%HDUVV ̋ Ï‰ÁÌÙÔ ̋  ̋ /\RQ ̋ ZDV ̋WKH ̋ ILUVW ̋ 8QLRQ ̋ JHQHUDO

RIILFHU ̋NLOOHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ZDUÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋ZDV ̋VLJQLILFDQW ̋EHFDXVH ̋LW ̋KHOSHG ̋WR ̋GHWHUPLQH ̋ZKHWKHU ̋WKH ̋1RUWK

RU ̋6RXWK ̋ZRXOG ̋JDLQ ̋FRQWURO ̋RI ̋WKH ̋VWDWH ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÔ

:LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ ı)LJXUH ̋ ÏÙ ̋ LV ̋ ORFDWHG ̋ LQ ̋ VRXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋ DERXW ̋ ÏÂÌ ̋ PLOHV

VRXWKHDVW ̋RI ̋.DQVDV ̋&LW\Ô ̋ ̋7KH ̋EDWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ORFDWHG ̋LQ ̋*UHHQH ̋DQG ̋&KULVWLDQ ̋FRXQWLHVÒ ̋LQFOXGHV ̋WKH ̋ÏÒÊËÎð

DFUH ̋ VLWH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ EDWWOHÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ EDWWOH ̋ ZDV ̋ FRPPHPRUDWHG ̋ ZKHQ ̋ &RQJUHVV ̋ SDVVHG ̋ D ̋ MRLQW ̋ UHVROXWLRQ ̋ RQ

'HFHPEHU ̋ÎÈÒ ̋ÏÂÁÏ‚ ̋DQG ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋ZDV ̋RQO\ ̋RQH ̋RI ̋VL[ ̋EDWWOHV ̋WR ̋UHFHLYH ̋WKLV ̋GLVWLQFWLRQ ̋GXULQJ ̋WKH

ZDUÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SDUN ̋ZDV ̋FUHDWHG ̋E\ ̋3XEOLF ̋/DZ ̋ÂÁðÈÍÈ ̋RQ ̋$SULO ̋ÎÎÒ ̋Ï‰ÁÌÒ ̋DQG ̋UHQDPHG ̋D ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG

RQ ̋'HFHPEHU ̋ÏÁÒ ̋Ï‰ÊÌ ̋ı+D]HOZRRG ̋Ï‰‰‰ÙÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋EDWWOH ̋LV ̋WKH ̋SULPDU\ ̋LQWHUSUHWDWLYH ̋HPSKDVLV ̋RI

WKH ̋ SDUNÔ ̋  ̋ +RZHYHUÒ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ DOVR ̋ FRQWDLQV ̋ D ̋ ZHDOWK ̋ RI ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ LQIRUð

PDWLRQÔ

:LWKLQ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ DQG ̋ &KULVWLDQ ̋ &RXQWLHVÒ ̋ 0LVVRXULÒ ̋ WKHUH ̋ DUH ̋ ÏÒË‰Í ̋ ıÊÂÂ ̋ DQG ̋ ÂÌËÒ ̋ UHVSHFWLYHO\Ù

UHFRUGHG ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ DV ̋ RI ̋ WKLV ̋ ZULWLQJÒ ̋ DQG ̋ ËÌ ̋ RI ̋ WKRVH ̋ VLWHV ̋ DUH ̋ IRXQG ̋ RQ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN

1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÔ ̋  ̋ 6LQFH ̋ WKH ̋ 6WDWH ̋ +LVWRULF ̋ 3UHVHUYDWLRQ ̋ 2IILFHÒ ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ 'HSDUWPHQW ̋ RI ̋ 1DWXUDO

5HVRXUFHVÒ ̋ LQ ̋ -HIIHUVRQ ̋ &LW\ ̋ EHJDQ ̋ NHHSLQJ ̋ UHFRUGVÒ ̋ WKHUH ̋ KDYH ̋ EHHQ ̋ ÏÎÍ ̋ UHSRUWV ̋ RI ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO

LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ILOHG ̋IRU ̋*UHHQH ̋&RXQW\ ̋DQG ̋È‰ ̋IRU ̋&KULVWLDQ ̋&RXQW\Ô ̋ ̋6HYHQWHHQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ÏÊÎ ̋UHSRUWV ̋UHODWH

GLUHFWO\ ̋WR ̋ZRUN ̋GRQH ̋RQ ̋SDUN ̋ODQGVÔ

:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋LV ̋OLVWHG ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋5HJLVWHU ̋RI ̋+LVWRULF ̋3ODFHVÔ ̋ ̋6SHFLILF

VLWHV ̋DQG ̋IHDWXUHV ̋UHODWHG ̋WR ̋WKH ̋ÏÂÁÏ ̋EDWWOH ̋DUH ̋DOVR ̋OLVWHG ̋DQG ̋LQFOXGH„ ̋5D\ ̋+RXVH ̋ı)LJXUH ̋ÎÙÒ ̋5D\ ̋6SULQJ

+RXVHÒ ̋5D\ ̋&RUQILHOG ̋ı)LJXUH ̋ÍÙÒ ̋*LEVRQ©V ̋0LOOÒ ̋(GZDUGV ̋&DELQÒ ̋6KDUS ̋+RXVHÒ ̋6KDUS©V ̋&RUQILHOGÒ ̋6KRUW

)DUPVWHDGÒ ̋7Ô%Ô ̋0DQOH\ ̋+RXVHÒ ̋&Ô%Ô ̋0DQOH\ ̋+RXVHÒ ̋*ZLQQ ̋+RXVHÒ ̋0DQOH\ ̋&HPHWHU\Ò ̋(GJDU ̋&HPHWHU\Ò

/\RQ ̋0DUNHUÒ ̋%ORRG\ ̋+LOO ̋ı)LJXUH ̋ÈÙÒ ̋WKH ̋6LQNKROHÒ ̋:LUH ̋5RDGÒ ̋DQG ̋6LJHO©V ̋DUWLOOHU\ ̋SRVLWLRQ ̋ı)LJXUH ̋ËÙÔ

2EMHFWV ̋LQFOXGHG ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋5HJLVWHU ̋OLVWLQJ ̋LQFOXGH ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋UHODWHG ̋WR ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋WKDW ̋UHVLGH ̋LQ ̋WKH

SDUN ̋FROOHFWLRQÔ

7KHUH ̋DUH ̋ËÌ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋UHFRUGHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ ̋ ̋-XVW ̋RYHU ̋RQHðKDOI ̋KDYH ̋D ̋FRPSRQHQW ̋WKDW ̋LV

SUHKLVWRULF ̋LQ ̋DJHÔ ̋ ̋7ZHQW\ðILYH ̋VLWHV ̋GHULYH ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋KLVWRULF ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ODQGÒ ̋DQG ̋PRVW ̋RI ̋WKRVH

ZHUH ̋RFFXSLHG ̋DW ̋WKH ̋WLPH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋%DWWOH ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋EDWWOHILHOG ̋LWVHOI ̋KDV ̋QRW ̋EHHQ

UHFRUGHG ̋DV ̋DQ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHÔ ̋ ̋1RQH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋UHFRUGHG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋DUH ̋LQGLYLGXDOO\ ̋OLVWHG ̋RQ ̋WKH

1DWLRQDO ̋5HJLVWHUÒ ̋QRU ̋KDYH ̋WKH\ ̋EHHQ ̋IRUPDOO\ ̋HYDOXDWHG ̋ ̋IRU ̋HOLJLELOLW\ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋5HJLVWHUÔ
Î
Í

(QYLURQPHQW

:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋LV ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋HDVW ̋DQG ̋ZHVW ̋VLGHV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHN ̋YDOOH\ ̋>QRWD

EHQH„ ̋ ̋:KHQ ̋ UHIHUULQJ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋RU ̋ EDWWOHILHOGÒ ̋WKH ̋ SUHIHUUHG ̋ IRUP ̋LV ̋WKH ̋ SRVVHVVLYH•:LOVRQ©V‚ ̋ZKHQ

UHIHUULQJ ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ FUHHNÒ ̋ WKH ̋ RIILFLDOO\ ̋ UHFRJQL]HG ̋ IRUP ̋ LV ̋ :LOVRQV@Ô ̋  ̋ 7KLV ̋ UHJLRQ ̋ LV ̋ FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋ E\ ̋ D

JHQHUDOO\ ̋ UROOLQJ ̋WRSRJUDSK\ ̋ZLWK ̋ VWHHS ̋ VORSHV ̋DVVRFLDWHG ̋ZLWK ̋ZDWHUZD\VÔ ̋ ̋3K\VLRJUDSKLFDOO\Ò ̋:LOVRQV

&UHHN ̋LV ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋3ODWHDXÒ ̋DQ ̋XQGXODWLQJ ̋WR ̋UROOLQJ ̋SODLQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ZHVWHUQ ̋2]DUNVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋6SULQJILHOG

3ODWHDX ̋LV ̋ERXQGHG ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋QRUWK ̋DQG ̋HDVW ̋E\ ̋WKH ̋0LVVRXUL ̋DQG ̋0LVVLVVLSSL ̋5LYHU ̋YDOOH\V ̋DQG ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋VRXWK

E\ ̋ WKH ̋ HGJH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ $UNDQVDV ̋ 5LYHU ̋ YDOOH\Ô ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ 3ODWHDX ̋ H[WHQGV ̋ ZHVW ̋ LQWR ̋ QRUWKHDVW ̋ 2NODKRPDÔ ̋  ̋ 7KLV

UHJLRQ ̋KDV ̋OHVV ̋UHOLHI ̋DQG ̋VWUHDP ̋GLVVHFWLRQ ̋WKDQ ̋PRVW ̋RWKHU ̋UHJLRQV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋2]DUNV ̋ı6DXHU ̋Ï‰ÎÌ„ÁÁÙÔ ̋ ̋7KH

ZHVWHUQ ̋ 2]DUNV ̋ DUH ̋ FRQVLGHUHG ̋ ı0F0LOODQ ̋ Ï‰ÊÁ„ÎÏÙ ̋ WR ̋ EH ̋ RQ ̋ WKH ̋ 3UDLULH ̋ 3HQLQVXOD ̋ ERUGHUÒ ̋ DQ ̋ DUHD ̋ RI

HFRORJLFDO ̋LPSRUWDQFH ̋LQ ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋VHWWOHPHQW ̋DQG ̋VXEVLVWHQFH ̋SDWWHUQVÔ

%HGURFN ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋3ODWHDX ̋LV ̋FRPSRVHG ̋ RI ̋ VHGLPHQWDU\ ̋ URFNÒ ̋PDLQO\ ̋OLPHVWRQHÒ ̋ GRORPLWHÒ

VDQGVWRQHÒ ̋DQG ̋VKDOHÔ ̋ ̋9HU\ ̋FKHUW\ ̋OLPHVWRQH ̋LV ̋DEXQGDQW ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋:LOVRQV&UHHN ̋GUDLQDJH ̋ı+XJKHV ̋Ï‰ÂÎ„ÎÙÔ

7KH ̋PRVW ̋LPSRUWDQW ̋PLQHUDO ̋UHVRXUFH ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋DUHD ̋ı+XJKHV ̋Ï‰ÂÎ„ÍÙ ̋LV ̋WKH ̋%XUOLQJWRQ§.HRNXN ̋ IRUPDWLRQÔ

,W ̋LV ̋ D ̋ SDUW ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋ VWUDWD ̋ RI ̋ SUHGRPLQDWHO\ ̋ FKHUW\ ̋ OLPHVWRQH ̋ DQG ̋ LV ̋ EHWZHHQ ̋ WKH ̋ 3HQQV\Oð

YDQLDQ ̋DQG ̋2UGRYLFLDQ ̋VWUDWDÔ ̋ ̋6LQNKROHV ̋DQG ̋FDYHV ̋DUH ̋FRPPRQ ̋LQ ̋WKLV ̋IRUPDWLRQÔ

7KH ̋PDLQ ̋GUDLQDJH ̋V\VWHP ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋LV ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHN ̋DQG ̋LWV ̋WULEXWDU\Ò ̋6NHJJV ̋%UDQFKÔ ̋ ̋$W ̋QRUPDO

IORZÒ ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHN ̋LV ̋DSSUR[LPDWHO\ ̋ÍÌ ̋WR ̋ÍË ̋IHHW ̋ZLGH ̋DQG ̋ILYH ̋WR ̋VL[ ̋IHHW ̋GHHSÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋PLOH ̋VRXWK ̋RI ̋WKH

SDUNÒ ̋ WKH ̋ FUHHN ̋ IORZV ̋ LQWR ̋ WKH ̋ -DPHV ̋ 5LYHUÔ ̋  ̋ *URXQG ̋ ZDWHU ̋ FRQVLVWV ̋ RI ̋ SULPDU\ ̋ DTXLIHUV ̋ LQ ̋ OLPHVWRQHÒ

GRORPLWHÒ ̋DQG ̋VDQGVWRQH ̋IRUPDWLRQV ̋ı1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFH ̋Ï‰ÊÁ„ÏÏðÏÌ ̋§ ̋ÏÏðÏÎÙÔ

$QQXDO ̋ SUHFLSLWDWLRQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋DUHD ̋DYHUDJHV ̋ RYHU ̋ ÈÎ ̋LQFKHVÒ ̋ZLWK ̋ ÈÏ ̋LQFKHV ̋ RFFXUULQJ ̋ DV

UDLQ ̋DQG ̋RYHU ̋RQH ̋LQFK ̋DV ̋VQRZÔ ̋ ̋8VXDOO\ ̋ÁÌ ̋SHUFHQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SUHFLSLWDWLRQ ̋IDOOV ̋EHWZHHQ ̋WKH ̋EHJLQQLQJ ̋RI

$SULO ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ HQG ̋ RI ̋ 6HSWHPEHU ̋ ı+XJKHV ̋ Ï‰ÂÎÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ FOLPDWH ̋ RI ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ LV ̋ PLGðFRQWLQHQWDOÒ ̋ ZLWK

WHPSHUDWXUH ̋ IOXFWXDWLRQV ̋ RI ̋ ÈÌ ̋ GHJUHHV ̋LQ ̋ZLQWHU ̋ DQG ̋ ËÈ ̋ GHJUHHV ̋LQ ̋ VXPPHU ̋ ı&KDSPDQ ̋ Ï‰ÊË„ÏÎÙÔ ̋ ̋ 7KH

DYHUDJH ̋DQQXDO ̋WHPSHUDWXUH ̋LV ̋ËÁ ̋GHJUHHVÔ

7KLV ̋UHJLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋2]DUNV ̋LV ̋DW ̋WKH ̋ZHVWHUQ ̋OLPLWV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋HDVWHUQ ̋KDUGZRRG ̋IRUHVW ̋DQG ̋LV ̋WUDQVLWLRQDO

LQWR ̋WKH ̋ZHVWZDUG ̋VDYDQQD ̋DQG ̋SUDLULH ̋ODQGVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SUHGRPLQDWH ̋IRUHVW ̋WD[RQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋LV ̋RDNÒ ̋RFFXUULQJ

LQ ̋ VHYHUDO ̋ VSHFLHV ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋EODFNÒ ̋KLFNRU\Ò ̋EODFN ̋MDFNÒ ̋SRVWÒ ̋ZKLWHÒ ̋ VFDUOHWÒ ̋DQG ̋ QRUWKHUQ ̋ UHG ̋ RDNÔ ̋ ̋7KH

IRUHVW ̋LV ̋FODVVLILHG ̋DV ̋SDUW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋RDN§KLFNRU\ ̋FOLPD[ ̋YHJHWDWLRQ ̋ı1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFH ̋Ï‰ÊÁ„ÏÏðÏÙÔ

7KH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋3ODWHDX ̋FRQVLVWV ̋RI ̋DW ̋OHDVW ̋WKUHH ̋SULPDU\ ̋HQYLURQPHQWDO ̋]RQHV ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋IORRGSODLQÒ

RSHQ ̋ZRRGODQGVÒ ̋DQG ̋WDOO ̋JUDVV ̋SUDLULHV ̋ı6WH\HUPDUN ̋Ï‰Ë‰ÙÔ ̋ ̋9HJHWDWLRQ ̋LV ̋YDULDEOH ̋LQ ̋WKLV ̋DUHDÒ ̋GHSHQGLQJ

WR ̋ D ̋ JUHDW ̋ H[WHQW ̋ RQ ̋ VORSH ̋ DQG ̋ VRLO ̋ W\SH ̋ ı8Ô6Ô ̋ 'HSDUWPHQW ̋ RI ̋ $JULFXOWXUH ̋ Ï‰Ê‰ÙÔ ̋  ̋ 6SULQJILHOGÒ ̋ RQ ̋ WKH

DYHUDJHÒ ̋KDV ̋D ̋JURZLQJ ̋VHDVRQ ̋RI ̋Ï‰‰ ̋GD\VÒ ̋SURYLGLQJ ̋DGHTXDWH ̋WLPH ̋IRU ̋PRVW ̋UHJLRQDO ̋DJULFXOWXUDO ̋FURSV

ı1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFH ̋Ï‰ÊÁ„ÏÏð‰ÙÔ ̋ ̋0RVW ̋DUHDV ̋WKDW ̋DUH ̋QRW ̋ZRRGHG ̋RU ̋LQ ̋FURSV ̋KDYH ̋D ̋FRYHU ̋RI ̋JUDVVHV

DQG ̋OHJXPHV ̋DQG ̋DUH ̋XVHG ̋DV ̋JUD]LQJ ̋ODQG ̋ı+XJKHV ̋Ï‰ÂÎ„ÍÙÔ

%HDUVV ̋ ıÏ‰ÊÂÙ ̋ DQG ̋ *UHPDXG ̋ ıÏ‰ÂÁÙ ̋ KDYH ̋ ERWK ̋ VWXGLHG ̋ WKH ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ UHFRUGV ̋ UHODWLQJ ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ SDVW

YHJHWDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHILHOGÔ ̋ ̋8VLQJ ̋ILUVWKDQG ̋DFFRXQWV ̋RI ̋EDWWOH ̋SDUWLFLSDQWVÒ ̋UHVLGHQWVÒ ̋DQG ̋HDUO\ ̋*HQHUDO

/DQG ̋2IILFH ̋VXUYH\ ̋UHFRUGVÒ ̋WKH\ ̋UHFRQVWUXFWHG ̋WKH ̋YHJHWDWLYH ̋SDWWHUQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋DW ̋WKH ̋WLPH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHÔ

,Q ̋ ÏÂÁÏ ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN ̋ ZDV ̋ D ̋ PL[ ̋ RI ̋ SUDLULH ̋ JUDVVHV ̋ LQ ̋ VDYDQQDKðOLNH ̋ VLWXDWLRQVÒ ̋ ZRRGODQG ̋ DUHDVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ IDUP

ILHOGVÔ ̋ ̋:LWK ̋WKH ̋H[FHSWLRQ ̋RI ̋ IDUP ̋ ILHOGVÒ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋KDV ̋SUREDEO\ ̋KDG ̋D ̋ VLPLODU ̋HQYLURQPHQW ̋ IRU ̋DW ̋OHDVW

ËÒÌÌÌ ̋\HDUVÒ ̋ZLWK ̋PLQRU ̋FKDQJHV ̋LQ ̋GHQVLW\ ̋RI ̋YHJHWDWLRQ ̋UHJLPHV ̋WKDW ̋FRðYDULHG ̋ZLWK ̋FOLPDWLF ̋VKLIWVÔ

,Q ̋WKH ̋ SDVWÒ ̋WKH ̋ SUDLULH ̋ DQG ̋ RSHQ ̋ZRRGODQGV ̋ZHUH ̋WKH ̋ KRPH ̋ RI ̋ODUJH ̋ DQLPDOV ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋ ELVRQÒ ̋ HONÒ

ZROIÒ ̋ DQG ̋ EODFN ̋ EHDUÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ ZRRGHG ̋ DUHDV ̋ FRQWDLQHG ̋ ZKLWHðWDLOHG ̋ GHHUÒ ̋ IR[Ò ̋ VTXLUUHOÒ ̋ FRWWRQWDLO ̋ UDEELWÒ
È

VNXQNÒ ̋RSRVVXPÒ ̋DQG ̋ZRRGFKXFN ̋ı6FKZDUW] ̋DQG ̋6FKZDUW] ̋Ï‰ÂÏ„ÂÙÔ ̋ ̋:KLWHðWDLOHG ̋GHHU ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋VWDSOH ̋PHDW

LWHP ̋ IRU ̋ PDQ\ ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ LQKDELWDQWV ̋ LQ ̋ WKLV ̋ UHJLRQ ̋ ı3DUPDOHH ̋ Ï‰ÁË„ÎÈÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ IORRG ̋ SODLQV ̋ VXSSRUWHG

EHDYHUÒ ̋PLQNÒ ̋PXVNUDWÒ ̋DQG ̋RWWHU ̋ ı6DXHU ̋Ï‰ÎÌ„Ë‰ÙÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋DUHD ̋LV ̋QRW ̋ RQ ̋DQ\ ̋PDMRU ̋ IO\ZD\‚ ̋ VR ̋WKHUH ̋LV ̋D

OLPLWHG ̋DEXQGDQFH ̋RI ̋ZDWHUIRZO ̋VXFK ̋DV ̋GXFNV ̋DQG ̋JHHVHÔ ̋ ̋9DULRXV ̋VRQJELUGV ̋DQG ̋ODUJH ̋KDZNV ̋LQKDELW ̋WKH

SDUNÔ ̋  ̋ /RFDO ̋ ILVK ̋ LQFOXGH ̋ FDWILVKÒ ̋ FDUSÒ ̋ EXIIDORÒ ̋ EDVVÒ ̋ VXQILVKÒ ̋ DQG ̋ VXFNHU ̋ ı3IOLHJHU ̋ Ï‰ÊËÙÔ ̋  ̋ +RZHYHUÒ

SUHVHQWðGD\ ̋SROOXWLRQ ̋KDV ̋JUHDWO\ ̋DOWHUHG ̋WKH ̋QDWXUDO ̋KDELWDWV ̋DQG ̋GHQVLWLHV ̋RI ̋ILVKÒ ̋UHSWLOHÒ ̋DQG ̋DPSKLELDQ

SRSXODWLRQVÔ
Ë

5HJLRQDO ̋&XOWXUH ̋+LVWRU\

$ ̋EULHI ̋RYHUYLHZ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋UHJLRQDO ̋FXOWXUH ̋KLVWRU\ ̋RI ̋VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋ZLOO ̋EH ̋SURYLGHG ̋LQ ̋RUGHU

WR ̋ SODFH ̋ WKH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ LQ ̋ D ̋ VSDWLDO ̋ DQG ̋ WHPSRUDO

SHUVSHFWLYHÔ ̋  ̋ )RU ̋ GHWDLOHG ̋ GHVFULSWLRQV ̋ RI ̋ WKLV ̋ DUHD ̋ VHH ̋ &KDSPDQ ̋ ıÏ‰ÊËÒ ̋ Ï‰ÂÌÙÒ ̋ 'RXWKLW ̋ ıÏ‰ÂÏÙÒ ̋ DQG

2©%ULHQ ̋ DQG ̋:RRG ̋ ıÏ‰‰ÂÙÔ ̋  ̋ (VVHQWLDOO\Ò ̋WKH ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ KXPDQ ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ ODQGV ̋ LQ ̋ DQG ̋ DURXQG

:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋EHJLQV ̋DURXQG ̋ÂÒÌÌÌ ̋WR ̋‰ÒÌÌÌ ̋\HDUV ̋DJR ̋ı)ODQGHUV ̋HW ̋DOÔ ̋Ï‰ÂÏ‚ ̋5D\ ̋HW

DOÔ ̋ Ï‰ÂÈÙÔ ̋ ̋1DWLYH ̋$PHULFDQV ̋FRQWLQXHG ̋WR ̋ XVH ̋WKH ̋ODQGV ̋ XQWLO ̋WKH ̋ EHJLQQLQJ ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ QLQHWHHQWK ̋ FHQWXU\Ò

ZKHQ ̋ (XURDPHULFDQ ̋ VHWWOHUV ̋ EHFDPH ̋ WKH ̋ SUHGRPLQDQW ̋ ODQG ̋ XVHUVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ FXOWXUDO ̋ VHTXHQFH ̋ LV

GLYLGHG ̋ LQWR ̋ IRXU ̋ JHQHUDO ̋ SHULRGVÒ ̋ 3DOHRLQGLDQÒ ̋ $UFKDLFÒ ̋ :RRGODQGÒ ̋ DQG ̋ 0LVVLVVLSLDQÒ ̋ ZLWK ̋ VHYHUDO

WHPSRUDO ̋VXEGLYLVLRQV ̋ZLWKLQ ̋HDFK ̋WKDW ̋FRUUHVSRQG ̋WR ̋FKDQJHV ̋LQ ̋OLIHZD\VÔ

7KH ̋HDUOLHVW ̋KXPDQ ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋LQ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋LV ̋DWWULEXWHG ̋WR ̋3DOHRLQGLDQV ̋DQG ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋GHVFULEHG ̋LQ

GHWDLO ̋ HOVHZKHUH ̋ ı5HDJDQ ̋ HW ̋ DOÔ ̋ Ï‰ÊÂ‚ ̋ &KDSPDQ ̋ Ï‰ÊËÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ 3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋ SHULRG ̋ ZDV ̋ IURP ̋ ÏÈÒÌÌÌ ̋ WR

ÏÌÒÌÌÌ ̋ \HDUV ̋ DJR ̋ ı&KDSPDQ ̋ Ï‰ÊËÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ SHRSOH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋ SHULRG ̋ IROORZHG ̋ D ̋ KXQWLQJðSDWWHUQ

OLIHVW\OH ̋ WKDW ̋ ZDV ̋ GHSHQGHQW ̋ RQ ̋ QRZðH[WLQFW ̋ ODUJH ̋ PDPPDOV ̋ DV ̋ D ̋ SULPDU\ ̋ IRRG ̋ VRXUFHÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ PDWHULDO

FXOWXUH ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ SHULRG ̋LV ̋FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋ E\ ̋D ̋ YDULHW\ ̋ RI ̋ODQFHRODWH ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQW ̋ IRUPVÔ ̋ ̋ )UHTXHQWO\ ̋WKH

SRLQWV ̋DUH ̋LQ ̋DVVRFLDWLRQ ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋ UHPDLQV ̋ RI ̋H[WLQFW ̋ ELJ ̋ JDPH ̋DQLPDOVÔ ̋ ̋)RU ̋H[DPSOHÒ ̋ODQFHRODWH ̋ VSHDU

SRLQWV ̋KDYH ̋EHHQ ̋ IRXQG ̋LQ ̋DVVRFLDWLRQ ̋ZLWK ̋PDVWRGRQ ̋ UHPDLQV ̋DW ̋.LPPVZLFNÒ ̋ QHDU ̋6WÔ ̋/RXLVÒ ̋0LVVRXUL

ı*UDKDP ̋HW ̋DOÔ ̋Ï‰ÂÏÙÔ ̋ ̋ ,Q ̋WKH ̋VWXG\ ̋DUHD ̋RI ̋VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋SRLQWV ̋DUH ̋ UDUHÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH

IHZ ̋VLWHV ̋NQRZQ ̋WHQG ̋WR ̋RFFXU ̋RQ ̋XSODQGV ̋RU ̋RQ ̋KLJK ̋WHUUDFHVÔ ̋ ̋&RROH\ ̋DQG ̋)XOOHU ̋ ıÏ‰ÊË„ËÈÙ ̋ UHSRUWHG ̋D

3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋&ORYLV ̋SRLQW ̋IURP ̋*UHHQH ̋&RXQW\Ò ̋EXW ̋QR ̋HYLGHQFH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋SHULRG ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋IRXQG

ZLWKLQ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋WR ̋GDWHÔ

7KH ̋WUDQVLWLRQ ̋ IURP ̋WKH ̋ 3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋ $UFKDLF ̋ SHULRG ̋ SUREDEO\ ̋ FRLQFLGHG ̋ ZLWK ̋WKH ̋ FKDQJH ̋ LQ

HQYLURQPHQWDO ̋DQG ̋FOLPDWLF ̋FRQGLWLRQV ̋WR ̋FRQGLWLRQV ̋WKDW ̋DUH ̋PRUH ̋VLPLODU ̋WR ̋WKRVH ̋WKDW ̋H[LVW ̋WRGD\Ô ̋ ̋7KH

FXOWXUH ̋FRPSOH[ ̋DVVRFLDWHG ̋ZLWK ̋WKLV ̋WUDQVLWLRQDO ̋SHULRG ̋LV ̋WKH ̋'DOWRQ ̋FRPSOH[ ̋ ıÏÌÒÌÌÌð‰ÒÌÌÌ ̋\HDUV ̋DJR

>%3@ÙÔ ̋ ̋,W ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋LGHQWLILHG ̋WKURXJKRXW ̋D ̋JUHDW ̋GHDO ̋RI ̋WKH ̋VRXWKHDVW ̋ı*RRG\HDU ̋Ï‰ÂÎ‚ ̋&RROH\ ̋DQG ̋)XOOHU

Ï‰ÊË„ÁÌ‚ ̋ 3ULFH ̋ DQG ̋ .UDNNHU ̋ Ï‰ÊËÙÔ ̋  ̋ ,W ̋ LV ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ WKDW ̋ WKH ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ OLIHVW\OH ̋ ZDV ̋ VLPSO\ ̋ DQ ̋ DGDSWDWLRQ ̋ WR

ZDUPHU ̋DQG ̋GULHU ̋FOLPDWLF ̋FRQGLWLRQVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SHRSOH ̋ZHUH ̋SUREDEO\ ̋RUJDQL]HG ̋LQWR ̋ VPDOO ̋H[WHQGHGðIDPLO\

EDQGV ̋WKDW ̋GHSHQGHG ̋RQ ̋KXQWLQJ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJ ̋IRU ̋WKHLU ̋OLYHOLKRRGÔ

$UWLIDFWV ̋ DWWULEXWHG ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ FRPSOH[ ̋ KDYH ̋ EHHQ ̋ IRXQG ̋ DW ̋ VRPH ̋ ORFDWLRQV ̋ ZLWKLQ ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN

ERXQGDULHV ̋ı%UD\ ̋Ï‰ÁÊDÒ ̋Ï‰ÊË‚ ̋+HOP ̋Ï‰ÂÌ‚ ̋/\QRWW ̋Ï‰ÂÎ‚ ̋/\QRWW ̋HW ̋DOÔ ̋Ï‰ÂÎÙÔ ̋ ̋&RQVLGHUDEOH ̋WHVWLQJ ̋LQ ̋WKH

7DEOH ̋ 5RFN ̋ /DNH ̋ DUHD ̋ KDV ̋ SURYLGHG ̋ GDWD ̋ UHJDUGLQJ ̋ WKH ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ LQ ̋ VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋ 0LVVRXUL

ı&KDSPDQ ̋Ï‰ÊËÙ ̋DQG ̋DW ̋-RKQ ̋3DXO ̋&DYH ̋ı5D\ ̋Ï‰‰ËÒ ̋Ï‰‰ÊÙÒ ̋DOWKRXJK ̋PRVW ̋UHSRUWHG ̋VLWHV ̋DOVR ̋FRQWDLQ ̋DQ

(DUO\ ̋$UFKDLF ̋FRPSRQHQWÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋'DOWRQ ̋FRPSOH[ ̋LV ̋FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋E\ ̋ODQFHRODWH ̋RU ̋SHQWDJRQDO ̋SURMHFWLOH

SRLQWV ̋ZLWK ̋EDVDO ̋JULQGLQJ ̋DQG ̋WKLQQLQJÒ ̋ZKLFK ̋ZHUH ̋DSSDUHQWO\ ̋XVHG ̋IRU ̋KXQWLQJÔ ̋ ̋*UDYHUVÒ ̋EXULQVÒ ̋GULOOVÒ

DQG ̋DG]HV ̋DUH ̋DOVR ̋ IRXQG ̋WKDW ̋ VXJJHVW ̋ZRRGZRUNLQJÔ ̋ ̋%RQH ̋QHHGOHVÒ ̋DZOVÒ ̋ VQXEðHQG ̋ VFUDSHUVÒ ̋DQG ̋ IODNH

NQLYHV ̋ LQGLFDWH ̋ WKDW ̋ DQLPDOV ̋ ZHUH ̋ SURFHVVHG ̋ IRU ̋ PHDW ̋ DQG ̋ OHDWKHUÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ VHWWOHPHQW ̋ V\VWHP ̋ LV

FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋E\ ̋D ̋ORZ ̋QXPEHU ̋RI ̋VLWHV ̋LQ ̋WKLV ̋UHJLRQÒ ̋ZKLFK ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋D ̋UHVXOW ̋RI ̋ORZ ̋SRSXODWLRQ ̋GHQVLW\Ô

+RZHYHUÒ ̋WKH ̋SRVVLELOLW\ ̋WKDW ̋VRPH ̋VLWH ̋ORFDOHV ̋ZHUH ̋VXEMHFW ̋WR ̋HURVLRQDO ̋GHVWUXFWLRQ ̋RU ̋DUH ̋GHHSO\ ̋EXULHG

PDNHV ̋SRSXODWLRQ ̋HVWLPDWHV ̋VXVSHFW ̋ı'RXWKLW ̋Ï‰ÂÏ„ËÏÙÔ

7KH ̋QH[W ̋VXEVWDJH ̋LV ̋WKH ̋(DUO\ ̋$UFKDLF ̋ı‰ÌÌÌðÊÌÌÌ ̋%3ÙÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋OLIHVW\OH ̋FRQWLQXHG ̋WR ̋EH ̋IRFXVHG ̋RQ

KXQWLQJ ̋ DQG ̋ JDWKHULQJÔ ̋  ̋ 6PDOO ̋ H[WHQGHGðIDPLO\ ̋ EDQGV ̋ ZHUH ̋ SUREDEO\ ̋ WKH ̋ JURXSV ̋ URDPLQJ ̋ WKH ̋ DUHD ̋ RI

VRXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋ DQG ̋WKH ̋ 2]DUNVÔ ̋  ̋5HFHQW ̋ H[FDYDWLRQV ̋ DW ̋ -RKQ ̋ 3DXO ̋ &DYH ̋ LQ ̋ &KULVWLDQ ̋ &RXQW\ ̋ ı5D\

Ï‰‰ËÒ ̋ Ï‰‰ÊÙ ̋LQGLFDWH ̋WKDW ̋ WKH ̋ FXOWXUDO ̋ FRQWLQXXP ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ 2]DUNV ̋ LV ̋ PDUNHG ̋ E\ ̋ VPDOO ̋ EDQGV ̋ IROORZLQJ ̋ D

KXQWLQJ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJ ̋OLIHVW\OHÒ ̋EXW ̋DOVR ̋DGDSWLQJ ̋WR ̋QHZ ̋WHFKQRORJLHV ̋DQG ̋WR ̋FKDQJHV ̋LQ ̋FOLPDWH ̋WKURXJK

WLPHÔ
Á

7KH ̋(DUO\ ̋$UFKDLF ̋ DUWLIDFW ̋ DVVHPEODJH ̋LQFOXGHV ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ 6HUUDWHG ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQWV ̋ DV ̋ ZHOO ̋ DV ̋ RWKHU

FKLSSHGðVWRQH ̋ SURMHFWLOHV ̋LGHQWLILHG ̋DV ̋5LFH ̋/REHGÒ ̋5LFH ̋&RQWUDFWLQJðVWHPPHGÒ ̋5LFH ̋/DQFHRODWHÒ ̋$JDWH

%DVLQ ̋/DQFHRODWHÒ ̋DQG ̋*UDKDP ̋&DYH ̋1RWFKHGÔ ̋ ̋2WKHU ̋LGHQWLILHG ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋ VXUYLYLQJ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO

UHFRUG ̋LQFOXGH ̋ VQXEðHQG ̋ DQG ̋ IODNH ̋ VFUDSHUVÒ ̋ RYRLG ̋ VFUDSHUVÒ ̋ VWHPPHG ̋ VFUDSHUVÒ ̋ FKRSSHUVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ DG]HV ̋ RI

GLIIHUHQW ̋IRUPVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋HQWLUH ̋DVVHPEODJH ̋LV ̋FDOOHG ̋WKH ̋5LFH ̋FRPSOH[Ò ̋DQG ̋LV ̋QDPHG ̋IRU ̋WKH ̋5LFH ̋5RFNVKHOWHU

VLWH ̋ZKHUH ̋LW ̋ZDV ̋ILUVW ̋IRXQGÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋5LFH ̋FRPSOH[ ̋(DUO\ ̋$UFKDLF ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋'DOWRQ ̋FRPSOH[ ̋RYHUODS ̋LQ ̋WLPH

DQG ̋VSDFHÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH\ ̋DSSDUHQWO\ ̋FRðH[LVWHG ̋IRU ̋VRPH ̋WLPHÔ ̋ ̋,W ̋LV ̋DVVXPHG ̋WKH ̋5LFH ̋FRPSOH[ ̋DQG ̋UHODWHG ̋WRRO

DVVHPEODJHV ̋ JUDGXDOO\ ̋ UHSODFHG ̋ WKH ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ DVVHPEODJHÒ ̋ SUREDEO\ ̋ UHIOHFWLQJ ̋ WKH ̋ IDFW ̋ WKDW ̋ WKH ̋ 1DWLYH

$PHULFDQV ̋ ZHUH ̋ EHJLQQLQJ ̋ WR ̋ H[SORLW ̋ D ̋ ZLGHU ̋ UDQJH ̋ RI ̋ HFR]RQHV ̋ DQG ̋ IORUDO ̋ DQG ̋ IDXQDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ WKDQ

WKRVH ̋XVHG ̋E\ ̋WKH ̋'DOWRQðFRPSOH[ ̋SHRSOHÔ

7KH ̋ 0LGGOH ̋ $UFKDLF ̋ VXEVWDJH ̋ ıÊÌÌÌ§ËÌÌÌ ̋ %3Ù ̋ LV ̋ OHVV ̋ ZHOO ̋ XQGHUVWRRGÒ ̋ EXW ̋ LW ̋ LV ̋ UHSUHVHQWHG ̋ E\

VWHPPHG ̋SRLQWVÒ ̋VXFK ̋DV ̋-DNLH ̋DQG ̋7DEOH ̋5RFN ̋6WHPPHGÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV ̋JURRYHG ̋D[HV ̋DQG ̋FHOWVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋WLPH

SHULRG ̋LV ̋FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋E\ ̋D ̋FOLPDWLF ̋VKLIW ̋WR ̋VRPHZKDW ̋GULHU ̋FRQGLWLRQV ̋DORQJ ̋WKH ̋IRUHVWÓSUDLULH ̋HFRWRQH ̋LQ

VRXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋(YHQ ̋WKRXJK ̋WKH ̋,QGLDQV ̋FRQWLQXHG ̋WKH ̋KXQWLQJ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJ ̋OLIHVW\OHÒ ̋DUFKHRORJLVWV

JHQHUDOO\ ̋ LQWHUSUHW ̋ WKH ̋ 0LGGOH ̋ $UFKDLF ̋ DUWLIDFWV ̋ DV ̋ UHSUHVHQWLQJ ̋ DGDSWDWLRQV ̋ WR ̋ D ̋ OHVV ̋ IDYRUDEOH

HQYLURQPHQW ̋WKDQ ̋ VHHQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋HDUOLHU ̋ SHULRGVÔ ̋ ̋5RGJHUV ̋6KHOWHU ̋LQ ̋ZHVWðFHQWUDO ̋0LVVRXUL ̋LV ̋DQ ̋H[FHOOHQW

VRXUFH ̋RI ̋VHWWOHPHQW ̋DQG ̋VXEVLVWHQFH ̋GDWD ̋IURP ̋WKLV ̋SKDVH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋$UFKDLF ̋ı0F0LOODQ ̋Ï‰ÊÁÙÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋FXOWXUDO

DGDSWDWLRQ ̋XWLOL]HG SODQWV ̋DQG ̋DQLPDOV ̋IURP ̋ZRRGODQGVÒ ̋SUDLULHÒ ̋DQG ̋ZHWODQG ̋HFR]RQHVÔ ̋ ̋'LYHUVLW\Ò ̋UDWKHU

WKDQ ̋VSHFLDOL]DWLRQÒ ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋GRPLQDQW ̋HFRQRPLF ̋H[SORLWDWLRQ ̋WKHPH ̋ı&KDSPDQ ̋Ï‰ÊË„ÏË‰ÙÔ

,Q ̋WKH ̋2]DUNV ̋WKH ̋/DWH ̋$UFKDLF ̋ıËÌÌÌ§ÍÌÌÌ ̋%3Ù ̋LV ̋FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋E\ ̋D ̋JURXQGðVWRQH ̋WRRO ̋LQGXVWU\ ̋DQG

D ̋ FKDQJH ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ VW\OH ̋ DQG ̋ PDWHULDO ̋ XVHG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ PDNLQJ ̋ RI ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQWV ̋ ı&Ô ̋ 3ULFH ̋ Ï‰Ê‰ÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ WRRO

DVVHPEODJH ̋LV ̋ FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋ E\ ̋ YDULRXV ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQWV ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋ 6WRQH ̋ 6TXDUHðVWHPPHGÒ ̋ 7DEOH ̋5RFN

6WHPPHGÒ ̋DQG ̋$IWRQ ̋&RUQHUðQRWFKHG ̋YDULHWLHVÔ ̋ ̋2WKHU ̋WRRO ̋W\SHV ̋DUH ̋WULDQJXODUðOLNH ̋ELIDFHVÒ ̋FKLSSHGðVWRQH

D[HVÒ ̋ GULOOVÒ ̋ IODNH ̋ WRROVÒ ̋ IODNH ̋ NQLYHVÒ ̋ IODNH ̋ VFUDSHUVÒ ̋ KDPPHUVWRQHVÒ ̋ KDQGVWRQHVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ DQYLOVWRQHVÔ

5HSUHVHQWDWLYH ̋VLWHV ̋DUH ̋QXPHURXV ̋DQG ̋H[WHQVLYHÔ ̋ ̋$GDSWDWLRQ ̋WR ̋VSHFLILF ̋DQG ̋D ̋ZLGHU ̋UDQJH ̋RI ̋HFRORJLFDO

]RQHV ̋ DQG ̋LQFUHDVHG ̋ HQYLURQPHQWDO ̋ H[SORLWDWLRQ ̋ DUH ̋ DSSDUHQW ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ GLYHUVLILHG ̋ VWRQH ̋ WRRO ̋ DVVHPEODJHV

UHFRYHUHG ̋ IURP ̋ VLWHV ̋ LQ ̋ VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ ı+HOP ̋ HW ̋ DOÔ ̋ Ï‰ÂÌ„ÎÊÙÔ ̋  ̋ 5HFHQW ̋ DQDO\VLV ̋ VXJJHVWV ̋ WKDW

KRUWLFXOWXUH ̋ RI ̋ VTXDVK ̋ DQG ̋ JRXUGV ̋ IRVWHUHG ̋ H[WHQVLYH ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ ı.LQJ ̋ Ï‰ÂÌ‚ ̋ -HQQLQJV ̋ Ï‰ÊÈÙ ̋ LQ ̋ WKH

ZHVWHUQ ̋2]DUNV ̋IRU ̋PXFK ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ODVW ̋ÈÒÌÌÌ ̋\HDUV ̋ ı.LQJ ̋Ï‰ÂÌ„ÎÎËÙÔ ̋ ̋/DWH ̋$UFKDLF ̋JURXSV ̋ZHUH ̋SUREDEO\

VWLOO ̋ RUJDQL]HG ̋ LQWR ̋ EDQGV ̋ WKDW ̋ IROORZHG ̋ D ̋ VHDVRQDO ̋ URXQGÒ ̋ EXW ̋ WKHUH ̋ DUH ̋ VXJJHVWLRQV ̋ WKDW ̋ WKH ̋ VRFLDO

RUJDQL]DWLRQ ̋ZDV ̋EHFRPLQJ ̋PRUH ̋FRPSOH[Ô

7KH ̋ :RRGODQG ̋ VWDJH ̋ ıÍÌÌÌ§ÏÏÌÌ ̋ %3Ù ̋ LV ̋ JHQHUDOO\ ̋ FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋ E\ ̋ WKH ̋ HDUOLHVW ̋ DSSHDUDQFH ̋ RI

SRWWHU\ ̋ DQG ̋ ERZV ̋ DQG ̋ DUURZVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ LV ̋ WHUPHG ̋ E\ ̋ &KDSPDQ ̋ ıÏ‰ÂÌÙ ̋ WKH ̋ 3UDLULH§)RUHVW ̋ 3RWWHU ̋ WUDGLWLRQÔ

+RZHYHUÒ ̋'RXWKLW ̋ ıÏ‰ÂÏÙ ̋GHVFULEHV ̋:RRGODQG ̋FHUDPLF ̋ VLWHV ̋DV ̋SDUW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋(DUO\ ̋ -DPHV ̋5LYHU ̋FRPSOH[Ô

$FFRUGLQJ ̋WR ̋'RXWKLW ̋ıÏ‰ÂÏ„Ë‰ÙÒ ̋WKH ̋PDMRU ̋FKDQJH ̋IURP ̋$UFKDLF ̋WR ̋:RRGODQG ̋WLPHV ̋LV ̋RI ̋D ̋WHFKQRORJLFDO

QDWXUH ̋ıHÔJÔÒ ̋FHUDPLF ̋W\SHVÙ ̋DQG ̋QRW ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋IRUP ̋RI ̋VHWWOHPHQW ̋DQGÓRU ̋VXEVLVWHQFH ̋SUDFWLFHVÔ

(DUO\ ̋ DQG ̋ 0LGGOH ̋ :RRGODQG ̋ VLWHV ̋ DUH ̋ VFDUFH ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋ DUHD ̋ RI ̋ 0LVVRXULÒ ̋ DQG ̋ /DWH

:RRGODQG ̋VLWHV ̋DUH ̋RQO\ ̋VOLJKWO\ ̋PRUH ̋QXPHURXVÔ ̋ ̋&KDQJHV ̋WKURXJKRXW ̋WKH ̋:RRGODQG ̋SHULRG ̋KDYH ̋QHYHU

EHHQ ̋IXOO\ ̋GHILQHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋2]DUNV ̋ı'RXWKLW ̋Ï‰ÂÏ„ËÁÙÔ ̋ ̋9HKLN ̋ıÏ‰ÊÂÙ ̋VXJJHVWV ̋WKLV ̋LV

GXH ̋LQ ̋SDUW ̋WR ̋D ̋VXEVLVWHQFH ̋EDVH ̋RI ̋KXQWLQJ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJÒ ̋UDWKHU ̋WKDQ ̋WKDW ̋RI ̋ODUJHðVFDOH ̋KRUWLFXOWXUH ̋RQ

WKH ̋QDUURZ ̋IORRGSODLQV ̋DQG ̋VKDOORZ ̋VRLOVÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋DUHD ̋RI ̋WKH ̋2]DUNV ̋GLG ̋QRW ̋KDYH ̋WKH ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋WR ̋VXSSRUW

SRSXODWLRQ ̋LQFUHDVHV ̋DQG ̋DQ ̋DJULFXOWXUDO ̋HFRQRP\ ̋ı5RSHU ̋Ï‰Ê‰ÙÒ ̋EXW ̋HYHQ ̋ZLWK ̋LWV ̋ORZHU ̋FDUU\LQJ ̋FDSDFLW\

LW ̋PDLQWDLQHG ̋D ̋VWDEOH ̋KXQWLQJ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJ ̋OLIHVW\OH ̋WKDW ̋XWLOL]HG ̋RQO\ ̋VXFK ̋WUDSSLQJV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋:RRGODQG

SHULRG ̋DV ̋FHUDPLFV ̋DQG ̋ERZV ̋DQG ̋DUURZV ̋WR ̋PDNH ̋OLIH ̋EHWWHUÔ

,Q ̋WKH ̋2]DUNVÒ ̋WKH ̋:RRGODQG ̋DQG ̋+RSHZHOOLDQ ̋SHULRGV ̋DUH ̋FDOOHG ̋WKH ̋-DPHV ̋5LYHU ̋&HUDPLF ̋FRPSOH[Ô

7KH ̋GLDJQRVWLF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋LQFOXGH ̋SRWWHU\ ̋WKDW ̋LV ̋JULWð ̋RU ̋FOD\ðWHPSHUHG ̋DQG ̋KDV ̋D ̋ERG\ ̋WKDW ̋LV ̋HLWKHU ̋VPRRWK

RU ̋FRUGðPDUNHGÔ ̋ ̋2WKHU ̋ KDOOPDUNV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋HUD ̋ DUH ̋ODUJH ̋ VWHPPHG ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQWVÓNQLYHV ̋WKDW ̋ KDYH ̋ EHHQ
Ê

W\SHG ̋DV ̋*DU\ ̋DQG ̋/DQJWU\ ̋DQG ̋VPDOOHU ̋WULDQJXODU ̋DUURZ ̋SRLQWV ̋VXFK ̋DV ̋WKH ̋6FDOORUQ ̋W\SHÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV ̋IXOOð

JURRYHG ̋D[HV ̋DQG ̋FHOWVÔ

7KH ̋ILQDO ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋VWDJH ̋LV ̋WHUPHG ̋0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋ıÏÏÌÌðÍÌÌ ̋%3ÙÔ ̋ ̋,W ̋LV ̋UHSUHVHQWHG ̋E\ ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋WKDW

LQFOXGH ̋ VKHOOðWHPSHUHG ̋ FHUDPLFVÒ ̋ 6FDOORUQ ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQWVÒ ̋ VLGHðQRWFKHGÒ ̋ WULDQJXODUÒ ̋ DQG ̋ RYDWH ̋ DUURZ

SRLQWVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ PLOOLQJ ̋ VWRQHVÔ ̋  ̋ 6LWHV ̋ DUH ̋ RIWHQ ̋ DJULFXOWXUDO ̋ YLOODJHVÒ ̋ FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋ E\ ̋ FLYLFðFHUHPRQLDO

FHQWHUVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋FXOWXUH ̋KDG ̋D ̋FRPSOH[ ̋VRFLRðSROLWLFDO ̋RUJDQL]DWLRQ ̋ı&KDSPDQ ̋Ï‰ÂÌÙÔ

7KH ̋ HDUO\ ̋ 0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋ LQ ̋ VRXWKZHVW ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ KDV ̋ EHHQ ̋ WHUPHG ̋ WKH ̋ /DWH ̋ -DPHV ̋ 5LYHU ̋ &HUDPLF

FRPSOH[ ̋E\ ̋'RXWKLW ̋ ıÏ‰ÂÏÙ ̋DQG ̋LV ̋GHILQHG ̋DV ̋WKH ̋YLOODJHðIDUPHU ̋WUDGLWLRQÔ ̋ ̋(YLGHQFH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LGGOH ̋DQG

/DWH ̋ 0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋ SHULRG ̋ LQ ̋ VRXWKZHVWHUQ ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ LV ̋ VSDUVHÔ ̋  ̋ $V ̋ ZLWK ̋ WKH ̋ :RRGODQG ̋ SHULRGÒ

0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋ PDQLIHVWDWLRQV ̋ DUH ̋ SRRUO\ ̋ XQGHUVWRRG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ VRXWKZHVW ̋ UHJLRQ ̋ RI ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ ̋  ̋ +RZHYHUÒ

DYDLODEOH ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋GRHV ̋QRW ̋VXJJHVW ̋DQ ̋H[WHQVLYH ̋FKDQJH ̋LQ ̋VHWWOHPHQW ̋DQG ̋VXEVLVWHQFH ̋SUDFWLFHV ̋IURP

WKH ̋ HDUOLHU ̋ SHULRGVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KLV ̋ YLHZ ̋ LV ̋ JHQHUDOO\ ̋ VXSSRUWHG ̋ DQG ̋ HPSKDVL]HG ̋ E\ ̋ %HQQ ̋ DQG ̋ 5D\ ̋ ıÏ‰‰ÁÙÒ ̋ ZKR

DUJXH ̋WKDW ̋WKH ̋:RRGODQG ̋WR ̋0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋FXOWXUH ̋WUDGLWLRQ ̋HYROXWLRQ ̋ZDV ̋PXFK ̋PRUH ̋D ̋FRQWLQXDWLRQ ̋RI

WKH ̋KXQWLQJ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJ ̋OLIHVW\OH ̋WKDQ ̋DQ ̋DGRSWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋FRPSOH[ ̋FXOWXUDO ̋WUDSSLQJV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋KLHUDUFKLFDO

0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋FXOWXUH ̋WUDGLWLRQÔ

7KH ̋WUDQVLWLRQ ̋IURP ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋WR ̋KLVWRULF ̋LV ̋JHQHUDOO\ ̋FRQVLGHUHG ̋WR ̋RFFXU ̋DW ̋WKH ̋WLPH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋HDUOLHVW

FRQWDFW ̋E\ ̋(XURSHDQVÔ ̋ ̋,Q ̋ZHVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋WKH ̋HDUO\ ̋KLVWRULF ̋SHULRG ̋LV ̋FRQVLGHUHG ̋DV ̋WKH ̋HDUO\ ̋ÏÊÌÌVÔ ̋ ̋,Q

WKLV ̋HDUO\ ̋KLVWRULF ̋SHULRGÒ ̋WKH ̋2VDJH ̋DQG ̋0LVVRXUL ̋ZHUH ̋WKH ̋SULPDU\ ̋RFFXSDQWV ̋RI ̋ZHVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋DQG

WKH ̋ 2VDJH ̋ UHVLVWHG ̋ WKH ̋ SUHVVXUH ̋ FDXVHG ̋ E\ ̋ WKH ̋ ZHVWZDUGðH[SDQGLQJ ̋ (XURSHDQVÔ ̋  ̋ 7R ̋ SURWHFW ̋ (XURSHDQ

HQGHDYRUVÒ ̋LQ ̋ÏÊÂ‰ ̋WKH ̋6SDQLVK ̋PRYHG ̋WKH ̋'HODZDUH ̋DQG ̋6KDZQHH ̋LQWR ̋0LVVRXUL ̋WR ̋FRQIURQW ̋WKH ̋2VDJHÔ

7KH ̋2VDJH ̋HYHQWXDOO\ ̋PRYHG ̋ZHVW ̋RQWR ̋WKH ̋3ODLQVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋'HODZDUH ̋DQG ̋6KDZQHH ̋ZHUH ̋JLYHQ ̋UHVHUYDWLRQV

LQ ̋VRXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋+RZHYHUÒ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋HDUO\ ̋ÏÂÌÌV ̋WKH\ ̋WRR ̋ZHUH ̋PRYHG ̋IXUWKHU ̋ZHVW ̋ı&KDSPDQ ̋Ï‰Ë‰ÙÔ

7KH ̋ HDUOLHVW ̋ ZKLWH ̋ VHWWOHUV ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ VRXWKZHVW ̋ DUHD ̋ RI ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ DUH ̋ EHOLHYHG ̋ WR ̋ KDYH ̋ FRPH ̋ IURP

.HQWXFN\Ò ̋7HQQHVVHHÒ ̋DQG ̋1RUWK ̋DQG ̋6RXWK ̋&DUROLQD ̋GXULQJ ̋WKH ̋HDUO\ ̋WR ̋PLGðÏÂÌÌV ̋ ı6WÔ ̋/RXLV„ ̋:HVWHUQ

+LVWRULFDO ̋ &RPSDQ\ ̋ ÏÂÂÍ„ÏÎË§ÏÍÌÙÔ ̋  ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RXQW\ ̋ ZDV ̋ RUJDQL]HG ̋ LQ ̋ ÏÂÍÍÒ ̋ ZLWK ̋ WKH ̋ WRZQ ̋ RI

6SULQJILHOG ̋LQFRUSRUDWHG ̋LQ ̋ÏÂÍÂ ̋ı5D\ ̋Ï‰‰‰ÙÔ

%\ ̋ÏÂÁÌÒ ̋WKH ̋SRSXODWLRQ ̋RI ̋VRXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋ZDV ̋D ̋PL[WXUH ̋RI ̋LPPLJUDQWV ̋IURP ̋ERWK ̋WKH ̋VRXWK ̋DQG

WKH ̋QRUWKÔ ̋ ̋+RZHYHUÒ ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋SLWWHG ̋QHLJKERU ̋DJDLQVW ̋QHLJKERU ̋DQG ̋UHODWLYH ̋DJDLQVW ̋UHODWLYH ̋WKURXJKð

RXW ̋WKH ̋VWDWHÔ ̋ ̋2Q ̋$XJXVW ̋ÏÌÒ ̋ÏÂÁÏÒ ̋WKH ̋PRVW ̋VLJQLILFDQW ̋EDWWOH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ZDU ̋LQ ̋ZHVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋WRRN ̋SODFHÒ

WKH ̋%DWWOH ̋DW ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÔ ̋ ̋,WV ̋VLJQLILFDQFH ̋OLHV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋IDFWV ̋WKDW ̋LW ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋VHFRQG ̋PDMRU ̋EDWWOH ̋RI ̋WKH

&LYLO ̋:DUÒ ̋WKDW ̋LW ̋ZDV ̋VHFRQG ̋ODUJHVW ̋DVVHPEO\ ̋RI ̋8QLRQ ̋VROGLHUV ̋WR ̋HYHU ̋ILJKW ̋D ̋SLWFKHG ̋EDWWOH ̋XS ̋WR ̋WKDW

GDWHÒ ̋DQG ̋WKDWÒ ̋ODUJHO\ ̋DV ̋D ̋UHVXOW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHÒ ̋0LVVRXULDQV ̋KDG ̋WR ̋PDNH ̋D ̋GHFLVLRQ ̋ZKHWKHU ̋WKH\ ̋ZRXOG

VWD\ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋8QLRQ ̋RU ̋VHFHGHÔ ̋ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋GLG ̋QRW ̋VHFHGHÒ ̋DOWKRXJK ̋WKH ̋VWDWH ̋ZDV ̋WRUQ ̋DSDUW ̋LQ ̋ELWWHU ̋ILJKWLQJ

IRU ̋WKH ̋UHPDLQGHU ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ZDUÔ ̋ ̋%HDUVV ̋ıÏ‰ÁÌÙ ̋DQG ̋3LVWRQ ̋DQG ̋+DWFKHU ̋ıÎÌÌÌÙ ̋KDYH ̋GHVFULEHG ̋WKLV ̋EDWWOH ̋LQ

GHSWKÔ

%ULHIO\Ò ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋SLWWHG ̋D ̋8QLRQ ̋DUP\ ̋FRPPDQGHG ̋E\ ̋%ULJDGLHU ̋*HQHUDO ̋1DWKDQLHO ̋/\RQ ̋DJDLQVW ̋D

&RQIHGHUDWH ̋DUP\ ̋FRPPDQGHG ̋ E\ ̋0DMRU ̋*HQHUDO ̋6WHUOLQJ ̋3ULFHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋8QLRQ ̋WURRSV ̋ZHUH ̋ FRPSRVHG ̋ RI

WURRSV ̋IURP ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋ ,RZDÒ ̋DQG ̋.DQVDVÒ ̋DQG ̋VHYHUDO ̋ UHJXODU ̋DUP\ ̋XQLWV ̋DQG ̋WKUHH ̋EDWWHULHV ̋RI ̋DUWLOOHU\Ô

7KH ̋&RQIHGHUDWH ̋IRUFHV ̋ZHUH ̋FRPSRVHG ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋*XDUG ̋DQG ̋D ̋ODUJH ̋FRQWLQJHQW ̋RI ̋$UNDQVDV

DQG ̋/RXLVLDQD ̋XQLWV ̋XQGHU ̋*HQHUDOV ̋%HQ ̋0F&XOORFK ̋DQG ̋1Ô ̋%DUW ̋3HDUFHÔ

7KH ̋&RQIHGHUDWHV ̋ZHUH ̋FDPSHG ̋VRXWKZHVW ̋RI ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋RQ ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHNÔ ̋7KH ̋FRPPDQGHUV ̋ZHUH

SODQQLQJ ̋WR ̋HQJDJH ̋/\RQ©V ̋FRPPDQG ̋LQ ̋EDWWOHÒ ̋GHIHDW ̋KLPÒ ̋DQG ̋JDLQ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋IRU ̋WKH ̋&RQIHGHUDF\Ô ̋ ̋/\RQ

DQG ̋ KLV ̋8QLRQ ̋FRPPDQG ̋ KDG ̋D ̋ GLIIHUHQW ̋LGHDÒ ̋DQG ̋ RQ ̋$XJXVW ̋ ÏÌÒ ̋ ÏÂÁÏÒ ̋ KH ̋OHG ̋D ̋ VXUSULVH ̋DWWDFN ̋ RQ ̋WKH

HQHP\ ̋FDPSÔ ̋ ̋'HVSLWH ̋LQIHULRU ̋QXPEHUVÒ ̋/\RQ ̋GLYLGHG ̋KLV ̋FRPPDQGÔ ̋ ̋+H ̋VHQW ̋&RORQHO ̋)UDQ] ̋6LJHO ̋RQ ̋D

VZLQJ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋VRXWKÒ ̋WR ̋ IODQN ̋WKH ̋&RQIHGHUDWH ̋ ULJKWÒ ̋DQG ̋/\RQ ̋DWWDFNHG ̋WKH ̋QRUWK ̋HQG ̋RI ̋WKH ̋&RQIHGHUDWH

FDPS ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋PDLQ ̋ERG\ ̋RI ̋KLV ̋WURRSVÔ
Â

/\RQ©V ̋HDUO\ ̋PRUQLQJ ̋DWWDFN ̋VXUSULVHG ̋WKH ̋HQFDPSHG ̋&RQIHGHUDWHVÔ ̋ ̋+LV ̋DWWDFN ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋QRUWK ̋GURYH

RII ̋WKH ̋&RQIHGHUDWH ̋ JXDUGÒ ̋DQG ̋ KH ̋ZDV ̋DEOH ̋WR ̋ RFFXS\ ̋WKH ̋ FUHVW ̋ RI ̋ D ̋ ULGJH ̋WKDW ̋ODWHU ̋ EHFDPH ̋ NQRZQ ̋ DV

%ORRG\ ̋+LOOÔ ̋ ̋/\RQ©V ̋ DGYDQFH ̋ZDV ̋ FKHFNHG ̋ E\ ̋WKH ̋ 3XODVNL ̋ $UNDQVDV ̋ $UWLOOHU\ ̋%DWWHU\Ò ̋ ZKLFK ̋ JDYH ̋WKH

&RQIHGHUDWHV ̋FULWLFDO ̋WLPH ̋WR ̋UHIRUP ̋DQG ̋RUJDQL]H ̋D ̋EDWWOH ̋OLQHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋EDWWOH ̋UDJHG ̋IRU ̋RYHU ̋ILYH ̋KRXUVÔ ̋ ̋2QH

RI ̋WKH ̋PRUH ̋VLJQLILFDQW ̋HOHPHQWV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ILJKW ̋ZDV ̋D ̋)HGHUDO ̋DWWDFN ̋WKURXJK ̋-RKQ ̋5D\©V ̋FRUQILHOGÒ ̋QHDU ̋WKH

5D\ ̋+RXVHÔ ̋ ̋&RQIHGHUDWH ̋ILUH ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋HGJH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ILHOG ̋KDOWHG ̋DQG ̋WXUQHG ̋WKH ̋8QLRQ ̋DGYDQFH ̋LQ ̋WKDW ̋DUHDÔ

7KH ̋ VRXWKHUQ ̋DWWDFN ̋ E\ ̋ 6LJHO ̋ZDV ̋LQLWLDOO\ ̋ VXFFHVVIXOÒ ̋ EXW ̋ORVW ̋PRPHQWXP ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ ILHOGV ̋ RI ̋ 6KDUS©V

IDUP ̋DV ̋LW ̋FDPH ̋XQGHU ̋DUWLOOHU\ ̋ILUHÔ ̋ ̋6LJHO©V ̋DWWDFN ̋FROODSVHG ̋DQG ̋KLV ̋PHQ ̋ZHUH ̋URXWHGÔ ̋ ̋2Q ̋%ORRG\ ̋+LOOÒ

/\RQ ̋ ZDV ̋ ZRXQGHG ̋ WZLFH ̋ DQG ̋ WKHQ ̋ NLOOHG ̋ OHDGLQJ ̋ D ̋ FRXQWHUFKDUJHÔ ̋  ̋ 0DMRU ̋ 6DPXHO ̋ 6WXUJLV ̋ DVVXPHG

FRPPDQG ̋RI ̋WKH ̋8QLRQ ̋WURRSVÒ ̋EXW ̋ZLWK ̋DPPXQLWLRQ ̋ UXQQLQJ ̋ORZÒ ̋RUGHUHG ̋D ̋ZLWKGUDZDO ̋WR ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

7KH ̋ 8QLRQ ̋ ORVW ̋ WKH ̋ EDWWOH ̋ DQG ̋ VXIIHUHG ̋ RYHU ̋ ÏÒÍÌÌ ̋ FDVXDOWLHVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ &RQIHGHUDWH ̋ YLFWRU\ ̋ DOVR ̋ VDZ

VLJQLILFDQW ̋ORVVHV ̋RI ̋RYHU ̋ÏÒÎÌÌ ̋PHQÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋EDWWOH ̋ZDV ̋D ̋8QLRQ ̋ORVVÒ ̋EXW ̋LW ̋JDOYDQL]HG ̋VXSSRUW ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋VWDWH

DQG ̋DW ̋KLJKHU ̋OHYHOV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋8Ô6Ô ̋JRYHUQPHQW ̋IRU ̋NHHSLQJ ̋0LVVRXUL ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋8QLRQÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋%DWWOH ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V

&UHHN ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋EHJLQQLQJ ̋RI ̋D ̋SURWUDFWHGÒ ̋ELWWHUÒ ̋DQG ̋EORRG\ ̋IRXU ̋\HDUV ̋RI ̋FLYLO ̋ZDU ̋LQ ̋0LVVRXULÔ

)ROORZLQJ ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DUÒ ̋VRXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋VHWWOHG ̋LQWR ̋D ̋UXUDO ̋DJUDULDQ ̋PRGH ̋FRQVLVWLQJ ̋RI ̋VPDOO

IDUPVWHDGV ̋ZLWK ̋KRPHV ̋VFDWWHUHG ̋SUHGRPLQDWHO\ ̋DORQJ ̋WKH ̋GUDLQDJH ̋V\VWHPVÔ ̋ ̋6WUXFWXUHV ̋ZHUH ̋XVXDOO\ ̋ORJ

RU ̋SODQN ̋DQG ̋EXLOW ̋E\ ̋WKH ̋RZQHUV ̋RU ̋ORFDO ̋FUDIWVPHQÔ ̋ ̋%\ ̋ÏÂÊÌÒ ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋JURZWK ̋RI ̋UDLOURDGV ̋DQG ̋VDZPLOOVÒ

PLOOHG ̋ OXPEHU ̋ EHFDPH ̋ UHDGLO\ ̋ DYDLODEOH ̋ DQG ̋ IUDPH ̋ KRXVHV ̋ ZLWK ̋ FODSERDUG ̋ VLGLQJ ̋ EHFDPH ̋ WKH ̋ QRUP

IRU ̋WKH ̋UHJLRQ ̋ı5DIHUW\ ̋Ï‰ÊÌ„ÎÎÍ§ÍÌÌÙÔ ̋ ̋$ERXW ̋WKH ̋EHJLQQLQJ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋WZHQWLHWK ̋FHQWXU\ ̋DQG ̋FRðRFFXUULQJ

ZLWK ̋ WKH ̋ GHYHORSPHQW ̋ RI ̋ D ̋ EHWWHU ̋ URDG ̋ QHWZRUNÒ ̋ WKH ̋ UXUDO ̋ VHWWOHPHQW ̋ V\VWHP ̋ VKLIWHG ̋ WR ̋ KRPHV ̋ VLWXDWHG

DORQJ ̋WKH ̋URDGZD\VÔ ̋ ̋:LWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋WKHUH ̋DUH ̋DERXW ̋ÎË ̋UHFRUGHG ̋KLVWRULF ̋VLWHVÒ ̋PRVWO\ ̋VPDOO ̋IDUPVWHDGV

WKDW ̋FRUUHVSRQG ̋WR ̋WKH ̋UXUDO ̋DJUDULDQ ̋WKHPHÔ ̋ ̋:LWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋LV ̋DOVR ̋WKH ̋WRZQVLWH ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋WKDW

EHJDQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ODWH ̋QLQHWHHQWK ̋FHQWXU\ ̋DQG ̋EHFDPH ̋GHIXQFW ̋VKRUWO\ ̋DIWHU ̋:RUOG ̋:DU ̋,Ô
‰

3UHYLRXV ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋,QYHVWLJDWLRQV

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋DW ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋EHJDQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋Ï‰ÁÌV ̋DQG ̋KDYH ̋FRQWLQXHG ̋VSRUDGLFDOO\

VLQFHÔ ̋ ̋$OO ̋RI ̋WKH ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ZHUH ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋LQ ̋UHVSRQVH ̋WR ̋VSHFLILF ̋PDQDJHPHQW ̋LVVXHV ̋RU ̋LQ ̋VXSSRUW

RI ̋DFKLHYLQJ ̋FRPSOLDQFH ̋ZLWK ̋6HFWLRQ ̋ÏÌÁ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋+LVWRULF ̋3UHVHUYDWLRQ ̋$FWÒ ̋DV ̋DPHQGHGÔ ̋ ̋7KH

YDULRXV ̋ SURMHFWV ̋ WKDW ̋ LGHQWLILHG ̋ WKH ̋ ËÌ ̋ NQRZQ ̋ VLWHV ̋ DUH ̋ EULHIO\ ̋ GLVFXVVHG ̋ EHORZÒ ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ VLWH ̋ OLVWLQJ ̋ LV

VXPPDUL]HG ̋LQ ̋7DEOH ̋ÏÔ ̋ ̋)LJXUH ̋Á ̋ VKRZV ̋WKH ̋GLVWULEXWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKHVH ̋ NQRZQ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH

SDUNÔ

7KH ̋ILUVW ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VWXG\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋ZDV ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋LQ ̋Ï‰ÁÁ ̋DQG ̋IRFXVHG ̋RQ ̋WKH

SRUWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN ̋ LQ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RXQW\ ̋ ı%UD\ ̋ Ï‰ÁÊDÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ ILHOGZRUN ̋ LQFOXGHG ̋ VXUYH\ ̋ DQG ̋ H[FDYDWLRQÒ

SULPDULO\ ̋ RQ ̋ IHDWXUHV ̋ UHODWLQJ ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ $XJXVW ̋ ÏÌÒ ̋ ÏÂÁÏÒ ̋ EDWWOHÔ ̋  ̋ ,QYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ RQ ̋ %ORRG\ ̋ +LOO ̋ ZHUH

GHVLJQHG ̋WR ̋ORFDWH ̋DQG ̋HYDOXDWH ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋DQG ̋IHDWXUHV ̋SHUWDLQLQJ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋PHWDO ̋GHWHFWRU ̋ZDV ̋XVHG

LQ ̋DQ ̋DWWHPSW ̋WR ̋ORFDWH ̋HYLGHQFH ̋RI ̋DUWLOOHU\ ̋SODFHPHQWVÔ ̋ ̋2QO\ ̋WKUHH ̋LWHPV ̋RI ̋GHILQLWH ̋EDWWOH ̋RULJLQ ̋ZHUH

UHFRYHUHG ̋ GXH ̋WR ̋ SUHYLRXV ̋ VXUYH\V ̋ E\ ̋ FROOHFWRUV ̋ DQG ̋ GHQVH ̋ YHJHWDWLRQ ̋  ̋WKDW ̋ PDGH ̋WKH ̋ XVH ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ PHWDO

GHWHFWRU ̋GLIILFXOWÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋8QLRQ ̋EXULDO ̋VLWHÒ ̋WKH ̋VLQNKROH ̋ıÎÍ*5ÁÈÌÙ ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋ZHVW ̋VLGH ̋RI ̋%ORRG\ ̋+LOO ̋ıZKHUH

ÍÈ ̋8QLRQ ̋VROGLHUV ̋KDG ̋EHHQ ̋EXULHG ̋DQG ̋ODWHUÒ ̋LQ ̋ÏÂÁÊÒ ̋H[KXPHG ̋ IRU ̋ UHEXULDO ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋1DWLRQDO

&HPHWHU\ÙÒ ̋ZDV ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋DQG ̋UHVWRUHGÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋IHZ ̋KXPDQ ̋VNHOHWDO ̋HOHPHQWVÒ ̋EXOOHWVÒ ̋DQG ̋D ̋IHZ ̋EXWWRQV ̋ZHUH

UHFRYHUHG ̋GXULQJ ̋WKH ̋UHVWRUDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋VLQNKROHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SUREDEOH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋*ZLQQ ̋KRXVH ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÍËÙ

ZDV ̋DOVR ̋ORFDWHGÔ ̋ ̋6XUIDFH ̋VXUYH\ ̋ UHVXOWHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋DQG ̋VXEVHTXHQW ̋H[FDYDWLRQV ̋DW ̋WKH ̋(Ô%Ô ̋6KRUW

IDUPVWHDG ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÎÂÙÒ ̋*LEVRQ©V ̋KRXVH ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÍÌÙÒ ̋*LEVRQ©V ̋0LOO ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÍÎÙÒ ̋DQG ̋WZR ̋GDPV ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÎÊÒ

ÎÍÏÙÔ ̋ ̋)LYH ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋ VLWHV ̋ZHUH ̋ORFDWHG ̋DQG ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋ZLWKLQ ̋ ILYH ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ VLWHV„ ̋WKH ̋*ZLQQ ̋ VLWH

ıÎÍ*5ÎËÍÙÒ ̋ WKH ̋ *LEVRQ ̋ +RXVH ̋ VLWH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎËÏÙÒ ̋ WKH ̋ *LEVRQ ̋ 0LOO ̋ VLWH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎËÎÙÒ ̋ WKH ̋ (Ô%Ô ̋ 6KRUW ̋ VLWH

ıÎÍ*5ÎÈ‰ÙÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋6KRUW ̋6SULQJ ̋VLWH ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎËÌÙÔ

$GGLWLRQDO ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ZHUH ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ QRUWKHUQ ̋ SRUWLRQ ̋ RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN

1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋LQ ̋Ï‰ÁÊ ̋ı%UD\ ̋Ï‰ÁÊEÙÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋VWXG\ ̋ZDV ̋D ̋FRQWLQXDWLRQ ̋RI ̋SUHYLRXV ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋DQG

LQFOXGHG ̋ IXUWKHU ̋ UHVHDUFK ̋ DW ̋ WKH ̋ *LEVRQ ̋ KRXVH ̋ DQG ̋ *LEVRQ©V ̋ 0LOOÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ *LEVRQ ̋ KRXVH ̋ URRW ̋ FHOODU ̋ ZDV

H[FDYDWHG ̋DQG ̋GHILQHGÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋FUHHNðEHG ̋DW ̋WKH ̋*LEVRQ©V ̋0LOO ̋VLWH ̋ZDV ̋H[FDYDWHGÒ ̋DQG ̋PLOOVWRQHV ̋DQG ̋RWKHU

WRROV ̋DQG ̋HTXLSPHQW ̋SDUWV ̋DVVRFLDWHG ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋PLOO ̋ZHUH ̋UHFRYHUHGÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋RULJLQDO ̋URXWH ̋RI ̋D ̋VKRUW ̋VHFWLRQ

RI ̋WKH ̋WHOHJUDSK ̋ URDG ̋ ZDV ̋ORFDWHGÒ ̋ DV ̋ ZDV ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ (GZDUGV ̋ FDELQ ̋ VLWHÔ ̋  ̋ ([FDYDWLRQV ̋ RI ̋ WKH

SUHKLVWRULF ̋ 6KRUW ̋ 6SULQJ ̋ VLWH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎËÌÙ ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ +HDGUDFH ̋ &URVVLQJ ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎËÁÙ ̋ ZHUH ̋ ODUJHO\

XQSURGXFWLYHÔ ̋  ̋ +RZHYHUÒ ̋ WKH ̋ Ï‰ÁÊ ̋ LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ DW ̋ WKH ̋ 6KRUW ̋ 6SULQJ ̋ VLWH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎËÌÙ ̋ ZHUH ̋ VLJQLILFDQW

EHFDXVH ̋WKH\ ̋UHSUHVHQW ̋WKH ̋ILUVW ̋H[FDYDWLRQ ̋RI ̋D ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋VLWH ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH ̋ERXQGDULHV ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN

1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÔ

7KH ̋QH[W ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ZHUH ̋LQ ̋Ï‰ÊÈ ̋ZKHQ ̋%UD\ ̋ıÏ‰ÊËÙ ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋DGGLWLRQDO ̋VXUYH\

DQG ̋ WHVWLQJÒ ̋ IRFXVLQJ ̋ RQ ̋ WKH ̋ VRXWKHUQ ̋ KDOI ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ SDUNÒ ̋ SDUWLFXODUO\ ̋ WKH ̋ DUHD ̋ ZLWKLQ ̋ &KULVWLDQ ̋ &RXQW\Ô

+LVWRULF ̋VLWHV ̋H[DPLQHG ̋DW ̋WKLV ̋WLPH ̋LQFOXGHG ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋KRXVH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎÍÍÙÒ ̋WKH ̋6KDUS ̋KRXVHıÎÍ&1ÊÁÙÒ ̋WKH

7Ô%Ô ̋0DQOH\ ̋KRXVH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎÍÂÙÒ ̋WKH ̋&Ô%Ô ̋0DQOH\ ̋KRXVH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎËËÙÒ ̋WKH ̋0DQOH\ ̋&HPHWHU\ ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎÍ‰ÙÒ

WKH ̋WRZQ ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÈÍÙÒ ̋DQG ̋D ̋ZHOO ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎÈÌÙ ̋XVHG ̋DV ̋D ̋EXULDO ̋VLWH ̋RI ̋VROGLHUV ̋IROORZLQJ

WKH ̋ EDWWOHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋ZRUN ̋ZDV ̋ SULPDULO\ ̋ VXUIDFH ̋ VXUYH\Ò ̋ ZLWK ̋WKH ̋ H[FHSWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ H[FDYDWLRQ ̋ DW ̋WKH ̋ VXJJHVWHG

ORFDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ -RVHSK ̋6KDUS ̋ IDUPÔ ̋ ̋%UD\ ̋ZDV ̋ XQDEOH ̋WR ̋ GHILQLWLYHO\ ̋ UHORFDWH ̋WKH ̋ VWUXFWXUHÔ ̋ ̋7KHUH ̋ZDV

HYLGHQFHÒ ̋KRZHYHUÒ ̋RI ̋D ̋ODWHUÒ ̋WXUQðRIðWKHðFHQWXU\ ̋VWUXFWXUHÒ ̋WKH ̋6WHHOH ̋IDUPÒ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋LQYHVWLJDWHG ̋DUHDÔ ̋ ̋7KH

Ï‰ÊÈ§Ï‰ÊË ̋VWXG\ ̋RI ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋VLWHV ̋ZDV ̋OLPLWHG ̋WR ̋VXUIDFH ̋VXUYH\Ô ̋ ̋6XEVXUIDFH ̋WHVWLQJ ̋ZDV ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋DW

RQO\ ̋ RQH ̋ VLWH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎÈÂÙ ̋ DQG ̋ ZDV ̋ OLPLWHG ̋ WR ̋ D ̋ VLQJOH ̋ WHVW ̋ SLWÔ ̋  ̋ %UD\©V ̋ ZRUN ̋ ZDV ̋ XQGHUWDNHQ ̋ XQGHU

DXWKRULW\ ̋ RI ̋ D ̋ FRQWUDFW ̋ ıÏÈðÏÌðÌÎÍÎðÏÎÌ‰Ù ̋ IRU ̋ Ï‰ÁÁ ̋ DQG ̋ Ï‰ÁÊ ̋ DQG ̋ E\ ̋ SXUFKDVH ̋ RUGHU ̋ IRU ̋ Ï‰ÊÈ§Ï‰ÊË

ı3;ÁÏÏËðÈðÌÏÈÏÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ GLVSRVLWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ %UD\©V ̋ SURMHFW ̋ QRWHVÒ ̋ UHFRUGVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ SKRWRJUDSKV ̋ LV ̋ QRW ̋ NQRZQ‚

KRZHYHUÒ ̋FRSLHV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋UHSRUWV ̋DUH ̋RQ ̋ILOH ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋DQG ̋DW ̋0:$&Ô ̋ ̋7KH ̋DUWLIDFW ̋FROOHFWLRQV ̋IURP ̋%UD\©V

ZRUN ̋ DUH ̋ FXUUHQWO\ ̋ KRXVHG ̋ DW ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU ̋ ı0:$&Ù ̋ DV ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋ ı:,&5Ù

$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÍÎÏ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÈÎÂÔ
ÏÌ

,Q ̋Ï‰ÊÂÒ ̋&UDLJ ̋&HOODU ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU ̋ı&HOODU ̋Ï‰ÊÂÙ ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋D ̋EULHI ̋VXUYH\

RI ̋WKH ̋DUHD ̋WR ̋EH ̋DIIHFWHG ̋E\ ̋WKH ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋YLVLWRU ̋FHQWHUÔ ̋ ̋ ,QYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋LQFOXGHG ̋D ̋ZDONðRYHU

VXUYH\ ̋WKDW ̋LQYROYHG ̋OLPLWHG ̋ VKRYHO ̋WHVWLQJÔ ̋ ̋1R ̋ FXOWXUDO ̋PDWHULDOV ̋ZHUH ̋ORFDWHGÔ ̋ ̋&HOODU ̋ DOVR ̋ UHORFDWHG

VHYHUDO ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SUHYLRXVO\ ̋UHFRUGHG ̋KLVWRULF ̋DQG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋IHDWXUHV ̋EXW ̋ZDV ̋XQDEOH ̋WR ̋UHORFDWH ̋D ̋SRUWLRQ

RI ̋WKH ̋ROG ̋:LUH ̋5RDG ̋QHDU ̋WKH ̋WZHQWLHWKðFHQWXU\ ̋TXDUU\Ô ̋ ̋2QO\ ̋D ̋WULS ̋UHSRUW ̋ZDV ̋ILOHG ̋IRU ̋WKLV ̋SURMHFWÔ

&RQVWUXFWLRQ ̋PRQLWRULQJ ̋GXULQJ ̋VHZHU ̋OLQH ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋DW ̋D ̋QHDUE\ ̋VLWH ̋ıÎÍ*5ÎËÌ ̋ð ̋WKH ̋6KRUW ̋6SULQJ

VLWHÙ ̋ ZDV ̋ FRQGXFWHG ̋ E\ ̋ &DURO\Q ̋ +HOP ̋ RI ̋ 6RXWKZHVW ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ 6WDWH ̋ 8QLYHUVLW\ ̋ ı+HOP ̋ Ï‰ÂÌÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH

FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋UHYHDOHG ̋DQRWKHU ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋VLWH ̋ıÎÍ*5ÈÍÏÙ ̋QRW ̋SUHYLRXVO\ ̋NQRZQÒ ̋EXW ̋PRVW ̋RI ̋WKLV ̋VLWH ̋ZDV

GDPDJHG ̋ RU ̋ GHVWUR\HG ̋ E\ ̋ WKH ̋ FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋ DFWLYLW\Ô ̋  ̋ 5HFRYHUHG ̋ ZHUH ̋ (DUO\Ò ̋0LGGOHÒ ̋ DQG ̋ /DWH ̋ $UFKDLF

OLWKLF ̋PDWHULDOV ̋DQG ̋KLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋ ı/\QRWW ̋ Ï‰ÂÎÙÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋ZRUN ̋ZDV ̋ XQGHUWDNHQ ̋ E\ ̋6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL

6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋XQGHU ̋DXWKRULW\ ̋RI ̋SXUFKDVH ̋RUGHU ̋3;ÁÏÏËðÌðÌÏÈ%Ô ̋ ̋7KH ̋SURMHFW ̋UHFRUGV ̋DQG ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋DUH

KRXVHG ̋DW ̋0:$& ̋DV ̋:,&5 ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÊÁ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÈÁÔ

,QYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ LQ ̋ Ï‰ÂÏ ̋ DQG ̋ Ï‰ÂÎ ̋ ZHUH ̋ DLPHG ̋ DW ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ DQG ̋ HYDOXDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO

UHVRXUFHV ̋DORQJ ̋WKH ̋URXWH ̋RI ̋D ̋SURSRVHG ̋7RXU ̋5RDGÔ ̋ ̋3KDVH ̋, ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VXUYH\ ̋IRU ̋WKH ̋SURSRVHG ̋7RXU

5RDG ̋ ı$OWHUQDWLYH ̋$Ù ̋ZDV ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋ E\ ̋ -HIIUH\ ̋5LFKQHU ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU ̋LQ ̋ Ï‰ÂÏ

ı/\QRWW ̋HW ̋DOÔ ̋ Ï‰ÂÎ„ÎÎ§ÎÈÙÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋ UHFRQQDLVVDQFH ̋ VXUYH\Ò ̋WRJHWKHU ̋ZLWK ̋ V\VWHPDWLF ̋ VKRYHO ̋WHVWVÒ ̋ORFDWHG

ILYH ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋DORQJ ̋WKH ̋VRXWKHUQ ̋H[WHQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋URDGZD\Ô ̋ ̋5LFKQHU ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋VKRYHO

WHVWLQJ ̋ DW ̋ ÎÌðP ̋ LQWHUYDOV ̋ EHWZHHQ ̋ WKH ̋ UDLOURDG ̋ JUDGH ̋ DQG ̋ :LOVRQV ̋ &UHHNÔ ̋  ̋ +H ̋ UHORFDWHG ̋ VLWH ̋ ÎÍ&1Ê‰

ı0LGGOHÓ/DWH ̋$UFKDLF ̋OLWKLF ̋VLWHÙ ̋DQG ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋DQ ̋DGGLWLRQDO ̋ÎË ̋VKRYHO ̋WHVWV ̋WR ̋GHWHUPLQH ̋WKH ̋H[WHQW ̋RI

WKH ̋VLWHÔ ̋ ̋5LFKQHU ̋DOVR ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋D ̋KLVWRULF ̋ VLWH ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋QRUWK ̋ VLGH ̋RI ̋ÎÍ&1Ê‰ ̋DQG ̋ UHORFDWHG ̋ VLWH ̋ÎÍ&1ÂÏ

ıD ̋VPDOO ̋XSODQG ̋OLWKLF ̋VFDWWHUÙÒ ̋DQGÒ ̋LQ ̋DGGLWLRQÒ ̋KH ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋D ̋OLPLWHG ̋VXUYH\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋WRZQVLWH ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V

&UHHN ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎÈÍÙ ̋ZLWK ̋D ̋ VLQJOH ̋OLQH ̋RI ̋ VKRYHO ̋WHVWVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋ VKRYHO ̋WHVWV ̋ UHYHDOHG ̋WKH ̋SUHVHQFH ̋RI ̋KLVWRULF

DUWLIDFWV ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋RI ̋IRUPHU ̋VWUXFWXUHVÔ

,Q ̋ Ï‰ÂÎÒ ̋ SHUVRQQHO ̋ IURP ̋ WKH ̋ 0LGZHVW ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ &HQWHU ̋ UHWXUQHG ̋ WR ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHNÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH\

FRQGXFWHG ̋ VXEVXUIDFH ̋WHVWLQJ ̋ RI ̋ VLWHV ̋ORFDWHG ̋ DORQJ ̋ 7RXU ̋5RDG ̋ $OWHUQDWLYH ̋ $ ̋ ı/\QRWW ̋ HW ̋ DOÔ ̋ Ï‰ÂÎÙ ̋ DQG

LQLWLDWHG ̋VXUYH\ ̋DQG ̋VLWH ̋WHVWLQJ ̋RI ̋RWKHU ̋DOWHUQDWLYHVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋PDLQ ̋REMHFWLYH ̋RI ̋WKLV ̋VWXG\ ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋FROOHFWLRQ

RI ̋ GDWD ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ VLJQLILFDQFH ̋ RI ̋ LQGLYLGXDO ̋ VLWHVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ WHDP ̋ ORFDWHG ̋ DQG ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋ VLWH

ÎÍ&1ÊÌÌ ̋ ıD ̋ VPDOO ̋OLWKLF ̋ VFDWWHUÙÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH\ ̋ H[FDYDWHG ̋ IRXU ̋WHVW ̋ SLWV ̋ DW ̋WKH ̋ 6WHHOH ̋ IDUP ̋ ı7KH ̋ 6WHHOH ̋ IDPLO\

ZHUH ̋ODWHU ̋ RFFXSDQWV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ 6KDUS ̋ IDUPVWHDG ̋ >ÎÍ&1ÊÁ@ÙÒ ̋ UHFRYHULQJ ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ DUWLIDFWV ̋ ıNLWFKHQðUHODWHGÙ‚

DQG ̋WKH\ ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋WZR ̋WHVW ̋SLWV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋DUHD ̋RI ̋VLWH ̋ÎÍ&1ÂÏÒ ̋UHFRYHULQJ ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋ıOLWKLF ̋GHEULV

DQG ̋(DUO\ ̋$UFKDLF ̋SURMHFWLOH ̋SRLQWVÙÔ ̋ ̋$OVR ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋ZHUH ̋ILYH ̋WHVW ̋SLWV ̋DW ̋VLWH ̋ÎÍ&1Ê‰ ̋ZKHUH ̋SUHKLVWRULF

FKLSSHGðVWRQH ̋GHEULVÒ ̋VWRQH ̋WRROVÒ ̋DQG ̋WKUHH ̋0LGGOH ̋WR ̋/DWH ̋$UFKDLF ̋GDUW ̋SRLQWV ̋ZHUH ̋ UHFRYHUHGÔ ̋ ̋ ,W ̋ZDV

UHFRPPHQGHG ̋WKDW ̋$OWHUQDWLYH ̋& ̋ZRXOG ̋KDYH ̋WKH ̋OHDVW ̋LPSDFW ̋XSRQ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋DW ̋:LOVRQ©V

&UHHN ̋ DQG ̋ ZRXOG ̋WKHUHIRUH ̋ PRVW ̋OLNHO\ ̋ EH ̋WKH ̋OHDVW ̋ H[SHQVLYH ̋ ZLWK ̋ UHJDUG ̋WR ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ PLWLJDWLRQÔ

3URMHFW ̋UHFRUGV ̋DUH ̋KRXVHG ̋DW ̋0:$& ̋DV ̋:,&5 ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÊÂ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÏÊÍÔ

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋VXUYH\ ̋DQG ̋HYDOXDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋3KDVH ̋ ,, ̋ ıQRUWKHUQÙ ̋VHFWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SURSRVHG ̋7RXU ̋5RDG

ZHUH ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋LQ ̋2FWREHU ̋Ï‰ÂÍ ̋E\ ̋SHUVRQQHO ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU ̋XQGHU ̋WKH ̋GLUHFWLRQ

RI ̋ 6XVDQ ̋ 0RQNÔ ̋  ̋ 7KLV ̋ SURMHFW ̋ ORFDWHG ̋ ÏÌ ̋ DUHDV ̋ RI ̋ DUWLIDFW ̋ FRQFHQWUDWLRQ ̋ DORQJ ̋ WKH ̋ URXWH„ ̋ IRXU ̋ ZHUH

DVVLJQHG ̋0LVVRXUL ̋VWDWH ̋VLWH ̋QXPEHUVÒ ̋ZLWK ̋WZR ̋RWKHUV ̋EHLQJ ̋SUHYLRXVO\ ̋NQRZQ ̋VLWHVÔ ̋ ̋$OO ̋FRQFHQWUDWLRQV

ZHUH ̋IXUWKHU ̋VKRYHO ̋WHVWHGÔ ̋ ̋7HVW ̋XQLWV ̋PHDVXULQJ ̋Ï ̋[ ̋Ï ̋P ̋ZHUH ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋DW ̋IRXU ̋VLWHV ̋WR ̋GHWHUPLQH ̋VLWH

GHSWKÒ ̋FRQWHQWÒ ̋DQG ̋DUWLIDFW ̋GHQVLW\ ̋ı0RQN ̋Ï‰ÂËDÙÔ ̋ ̋6LWHV ̋ZKLFK ̋DSSHDUHG ̋VLJQLILFDQW ̋ZHUH ̋VFKHGXOHG ̋IRU

DGGLWLRQDO ̋H[FDYDWLRQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋VSULQJ ̋RI ̋Ï‰ÂÈÔ ̋ ̋0RQN ̋UHFRYHUHG ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋WKDW ̋LQFOXGHG ̋PDWHULDOV

IURP ̋$UFKDLF ̋WR ̋0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋WLPH ̋ KRUL]RQVÔ ̋ ̋6KH ̋DOVR ̋ UHFRYHUHG ̋ KLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋WKDW ̋ZHUH ̋ SULPDULO\

WZHQWLHWKðFHQWXU\ ̋ IDUP ̋ DQG ̋ DUFKLWHFWXUDO ̋ LWHPV‚ ̋ KRZHYHUÒ ̋ RQH ̋ EOXH ̋ VSRQJHZDUH§GHFRUDWHG ̋ FHUDPLF

IUDJPHQW ̋LQGLFDWHG ̋ DQ ̋ HDUO\ð ̋WR ̋ PLGðQLQHWHHQWKðFHQWXU\ ̋ RFFXSDWLRQÔ ̋  ̋ $V ̋ D ̋ UHVXOW ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ ILQGVÒ ̋ WKH ̋ 7RXU

5RDG ̋ZDV ̋PRYHG ̋DSSUR[LPDWHO\ ̋ÍÌ ̋IHHW ̋QRUWK ̋RI ̋WKH ̋RULJLQDO ̋SURSRVHG ̋URDGÔ

0RQN ̋ ıÏ‰‰ÌÙ ̋ H[FDYDWHG ̋ HLJKW ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ WKDW ̋ ZHUH ̋ IRXQG ̋ DORQJ ̋ WKH ̋ SURSRVHG ̋ 7RXU ̋ 5RDG

ULJKWðRIðZD\ ̋DV ̋SDUW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋PLWLJDWLRQÔ ̋ ̋6L[ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋HLJKW ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋VLWHV ̋ıÎÍ&1ÊÌÎÒ ̋ÎÍ*5ÎÈËÒ
ÏÏ

ÎÍ*5ÁÎ‰Ò ̋ÎÍ*5ÁÍÌÒ ̋ÎÍ*5ÁÍÏÒ ̋DQG ̋ÎÍ*5ÁÍÎÙ ̋DUH ̋SUHKLVWRULFÒ ̋DQG ̋WZR ̋ıÎÍ&1ÊÁ ̋DQG ̋ÎÍ&1ÂÏÙ ̋DUH ̋WKH

UHSXWHG ̋ ORFDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ QLQHWHHQWKðFHQWXU\ ̋ 6KDUS ̋ IDUP‚ ̋ KRZHYHUÒ ̋ QR ̋ HYLGHQFH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 6KDUS ̋ IDUP ̋ ZDV

ORFDWHGÔ ̋ ̋%RWK ̋VLWHV ̋ıÎÍ&1ÊÁ ̋DQG ̋ÎÍ&1ÂÏÙ ̋FRQWDLQHG ̋KLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋SRLQWLQJ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋6WHHOH ̋IDPLO\Ò ̋ZLWK

VLWH ̋ ÎÍ&1ÂÏ ̋ FRQWDLQLQJ ̋ D ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ OLWKLF ̋ FRQFHQWUDWLRQ ̋ DV ̋ ZHOOÔ ̋  ̋ 3URMHFW ̋ UHFRUGV ̋ DQG ̋ DUWLIDFWV ̋ DUH

KRXVHG ̋DW ̋0:$& ̋XQGHU ̋:,&5 ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÂÏ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÌÈÔ

,Q ̋Ï‰ÂÎ ̋DQG ̋Ï‰ÂÍÒ ̋WZR ̋SHULRGV ̋RI ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋WRRN ̋SODFH ̋DW ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋KRXVHÔ ̋ ̋&RQVWUXFWLRQðUHODWHG

DFWLYLWLHV ̋QHFHVVLWDWHG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ZRUNÒ ̋ERWK ̋LQVLGH ̋DQG ̋RXWVLGH ̋WKH ̋KRXVHÒ ̋DQG ̋0DUN ̋/\QRWW ̋H[FDYDWHG

WHVW ̋XQLWV ̋DW ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋+RXVH ̋SULRU ̋WR ̋SUHVHUYDWLRQ ̋DQG ̋VWDELOL]DWLRQ ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋ı+HQVOH\ ̋Ï‰ÂÎÙÔ ̋ ̋(YLGHQFH

ZDV ̋ IRXQG ̋ RQ ̋WKH ̋ EXLOGLQJ©V ̋ZDOOV ̋WKDW ̋ D ̋ ILUHSODFH ̋ FRXOG ̋ KDYH ̋ EHHQ ̋ORFDWHG ̋ RQ ̋WKH ̋ ZHVW ̋ ZDOOÔ ̋  ̋ )XUWKHU

FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋PLWLJDWLRQ ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ZRUN ̋ EHJDQ ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋0DUFK ̋ Ï‰ÂÍ ̋ SURMHFWÒ ̋ XQGHU ̋WKH ̋ GLUHFWLRQ ̋ RI

6XVDQ ̋0RQN ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÔ ̋ ̋:RUN ̋IRFXVHG ̋RQ ̋WHVWLQJ ̋DORQJ ̋WKH ̋RXWHU ̋IRXQGDWLRQ

RI ̋WKH ̋KRXVHÒ ̋ZKLFK ̋ZDV ̋WKH ̋LQLWLDO ̋PDQDJHPHQW ̋FRQFHUQ ̋ı0RQN ̋Ï‰ÂÍÒ ̋Ï‰ÂËEÙÔ

7KH ̋ VHFRQG ̋ SURMHFWÒ ̋ LQ ̋ 1RYHPEHU ̋ Ï‰ÂÍ ̋ XQGHU ̋ WKH ̋ GLUHFWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ -DFN ̋ 5D\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 0LGZHVW

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ &HQWHUÒ ̋ IRFXVHG ̋ RQ ̋ WHVWLQJ ̋ LQVLGH ̋ WKH ̋ KRXVHÒ ̋ XQGHU ̋ IORRUERDUGVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ ILUHSODFH

EHWZHHQ ̋5RRPV ̋Í ̋DQG ̋ÈÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋0:$& ̋WHDP ̋DOVR ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋D ̋ZDONðRYHU ̋VXUYH\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SORZHG ̋ILHOGV ̋DORQJ

WKH ̋ VLGH ̋DQG ̋LQ ̋EDFN ̋RI ̋WKH ̋KRXVH ̋DQG ̋ IRXQG ̋KLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFW ̋FRQFHQWUDWLRQV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ VRXWK ̋ ILHOG ̋DUHD ̋WKDW

PD\ ̋FRUUHVSRQG ̋ZLWK ̋SRVVLEOH ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋RI ̋RXWEXLOGLQJVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋KLVWRULF ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋WKDW ̋ZHUH ̋UHFRYHUHG ̋VSDQ ̋D

WLPH ̋SHULRG ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋PLGðQLQHWHHQWK ̋FHQWXU\ ̋XQWLO ̋WKH ̋SUHVHQW ̋GD\Ô ̋ ̋3UHKLVWRULF ̋OLWKLF ̋PDWHULDOV ̋ZHUH ̋IRXQG

VFDWWHUHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ILHOG ̋WR ̋WKH ̋VRXWK ̋DQG ̋HDVW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋KRXVHÔ

-DFN ̋+Ô ̋5D\ ̋DQG ̋&KULVWRSKHU ̋+Ô ̋6FKRHQ ̋FDUULHG ̋RXW ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋H[FDYDWLRQV ̋LQVLGH ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋+RXVH

WR ̋IDFLOLWDWH ̋WKH ̋VWDELOL]DWLRQ ̋DQG ̋UHVWRUDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋KRXVH ̋IRU ̋LWV ̋XVH ̋DV ̋DQ ̋LQWHUSUHWDWLYH ̋IDFLOLW\ ̋LQ ̋Ï‰ÂÍ

ı6XGGHUWK ̋Ï‰‰ÎÙÔ ̋ ̋7KH\ ̋PDSSHG ̋DQG ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋DUHDV ̋LQ ̋5RRPV ̋Í ̋DQG ̋È ̋WKDW ̋ZHUH ̋WR ̋EH ̋GLVWXUEHG ̋E\ ̋WKH

UHVWRUDWLRQ ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQÔ ̋ ̋ -DFN ̋5D\ ̋DOVR ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋DORQJ ̋WKH ̋ZHVW ̋DQG ̋ QRUWK ̋ZDOOV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋FHOODU ̋ORFDWHG

EHQHDWK ̋ 5RRPV ̋ Ï ̋ DQG ̋ Î ̋ DQG ̋ GLVFRYHUHG ̋ WKH ̋ RULJLQDO ̋ ¶VRXWK ̋ HQWUDQFHß ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ FHOODU ̋ GLVFXVVHG ̋ LQ ̋ RUDO

KLVWRULHVÔ ̋ ̋+LVWRULF ̋KRXVHKROG ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋ZHUH ̋UHFRYHUHGÔ ̋ ̋3URMHFW ̋UHFRUGV ̋DQG ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋IRU ̋WKHVH ̋SURMHFWV ̋DUH

KRXVHG ̋DW ̋0:$& ̋XQGHU ̋:,&5 ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RVÔ ̋ÎÊÊÒ ̋ÎÊ‰Ò ̋DQG ̋ÎÂÎ‚ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RVÔ ̋‰ÊÒ ̋ÏÊËÒ

DQG ̋ÎÎÏÒ ̋UHVSHFWLYHO\Ô

,Q ̋Ï‰ÂÂÒ ̋'DYLG ̋$XVWLQ ̋DQG ̋:LOOLDP ̋0DUWLQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LVVRXUL ̋+LJKZD\ ̋DQG ̋7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ ̋'HSDUWPHQW

FRQGXFWHG ̋ D ̋ FXOWXUDO ̋ UHVRXUFH ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 5RXWH ̋ == ̋ URDG ̋ XQGHU ̋ DXWKRULW\ ̋ RI ̋ DQ ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO

5HVRXUFHV ̋3URWHFWLRQ ̋$FW ̋SHUPLWÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋SRUWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋URDG ̋SDVVHV ̋WKURXJK ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋PDLQWHQDQFH ̋DUHDÔ

$XVWLQ ̋DQG ̋0DUWLQ ̋ıÏ‰ÂÂÙ ̋UHFRUGHG ̋DQG ̋WHVWHG ̋VLWH ̋ÎÍ*1ÁÂÌÒ ̋D ̋KLVWRULF ̋KRPHVWHDG ̋ZLWK ̋VRPH ̋SUHKLVWRULF

OLWKLF ̋PDWHULDO ̋DOVR ̋SUHVHQWÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋VLWH ̋LV ̋NQRZQ ̋DV ̋WKH ̋6KRUWÓ0F.HHO ̋IDUPÔ ̋ ̋7KH\ ̋UHFRUGHG ̋D ̋OLJKW ̋VFDWWHU

RI ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ WUDVK ̋ LQ ̋ WKHLU ̋ VKRYHO ̋ WHVWV ̋ DQG ̋ ORFDWHG ̋ D ̋ FRQFUHWHðOLQHG ̋ FLVWHUQÔ ̋  ̋ $XVWLQ ̋ DQG ̋ 0DUWLQ ̋ ıÏ‰ÂÂ„

ÎÏ§ÎÂÙ ̋ZHUH ̋DEOH ̋WR ̋ GHWHUPLQH ̋WKDW ̋ EXLOGLQJV ̋ UHODWHG ̋WR ̋WKH ̋ VLWH ̋ZHUH ̋ VWDQGLQJ ̋ZKHQ ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUN

6HUYLFH ̋WRRN ̋RZQHUVKLS ̋RI ̋WKH ̋ODQG ̋LQ ̋Ï‰ÁÌÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋VWUXFWXUHV ̋ZHUH ̋UD]HG ̋DW ̋WKDW ̋WLPH ̋DQG ̋GXULQJ ̋VXEVHTXHQW

GHYHORSPHQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋PDLQWHQDQFH ̋IDFLOLW\Ô

1HDU ̋WKH ̋VRXWKHUQ ̋HGJH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋6KRUWÓ0F.HHO ̋VLWH ̋WKH\ ̋DOVR ̋ORFDWHG ̋D ̋VPDOO ̋SURMHFWLOH ̋SRLQW ̋IUDJPHQW

LQ ̋D ̋VKRYHO ̋WHVWÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SURMHFWLOH ̋SRLQWÒ ̋DOWKRXJK ̋EURNHQÒ ̋DSSHDUV ̋WR ̋EH ̋D ̋/DWH ̋:RRGODQG ̋RU ̋/DWH ̋3UHKLVWRULF

W\SHÔ ̋  ̋ 1R ̋ RWKHU ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ PDWHULDOV ̋ ZHUH ̋ IRXQG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ RWKHU ̋ VKRYHO ̋ WHVWVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ SURMHFW ̋ UHFRUGV ̋ DQG

DUWLIDFWV ̋DUH ̋SUHVXPDEO\ ̋KRXVHG ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋0LVVRXUL ̋+LJKZD\ ̋DQG ̋7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ ̋'HSDUWPHQWÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SURMHFW

LV ̋UHFRUGHG ̋DV ̋:,&5 ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÂÍ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÊ‰Ô

1R ̋IXUWKHU ̋ZRUN ̋ZDV ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋XQWLO ̋LW ̋ZDV ̋YLVLWHG ̋E\ ̋0DUN ̋/\QRWWÒ ̋ZKR ̋H[DPLQHG ̋WKH

H[SRVHG ̋ FHOODUV ̋ DW ̋ WKH ̋ *LEVRQ ̋ +RXVH ̋ ı/\QRWW ̋ Ï‰‰ÍÙÒ ̋ ZKLFK ̋ KDG ̋ EHHQ ̋ H[FDYDWHG ̋ E\ ̋ WKH ̋ 8QLYHUVLW\ ̋ RI

0LVVRXUL ̋LQ ̋Ï‰ÁÁ ̋EXW ̋ZHUH ̋QHYHU ̋EDFNILOOHGÔ ̋ ̋+H ̋IRXQG ̋WKDW ̋WKH ̋VWRQH ̋ZDOOV ̋ZHUH ̋FROODSVLQJ ̋DQG ̋VDSOLQJV

ZHUH ̋JURZLQJ ̋XS ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋FHOODU ̋IORRUÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋KROHV ̋ZHUH ̋EDFNILOOHG ̋ZLWK ̋FOHDQ ̋ILOO ̋PDWHULDOÔ
ÏÎ

9HUJLO ̋1REOH ̋VXUYH\HG ̋WKH ̋ÎÌÌð[ðÏÌÌðIW ̋DUHD ̋SURSRVHG ̋ IRU ̋WKH ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋RI ̋D ̋QHZ ̋VHSWLF ̋ IDFLOLW\

ı1REOH ̋Ï‰‰ÈÙÔ ̋ ̋6KRYHO ̋WHVWV ̋DW ̋ÏËðP ̋LQWHUYDOV ̋DORQJ ̋WKUHH ̋WUDQVHFWV ̋\LHOGHG ̋FKHUW ̋IODNHVÔ ̋ ̋7KHVH ̋ILQGLQJV

ZHUH ̋ FRQVLVWHQW ̋ ZLWK ̋ WKH ̋ ILQGLQJV ̋ RI ̋ H[FDYDWLRQV ̋ GRQH ̋ LQ ̋ Ï‰ÂÈ ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ VDPH ̋ JHQHUDO ̋ DUHDÔ ̋  ̋ 1REOH

GLVFRYHUHG ̋ WKDW ̋ WKH ̋ HDVWHUQ ̋ HGJH ̋ RI ̋ VLWH ̋ ÎÍ*5ÎÈË ̋ RYHUODSSHG ̋ WKH ̋ SUHIHUUHG ̋ FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋ ORFDWLRQÔ ̋  ̋ +H

UHFRPPHQGHG ̋VWULSSLQJ ̋WKH ̋SORZ ̋]RQH ̋SULRU ̋WR ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋WR ̋GHWHUPLQH ̋LI ̋ IHDWXUHV ̋ZHUH ̋SUHVHQWÔ ̋ ̋7KH

IROORZLQJ ̋ \HDU ̋ ı1REOH ̋ Ï‰‰ËÙÒ ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ UHODWHG ̋ WR ̋ D ̋ SURSRVHG ̋ GHYHORSPHQW ̋ RI ̋ D

ZDVWHZDWHU ̋ WUHDWPHQW ̋ SODQW ̋ ZHUH ̋ XQGHUWDNHQÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ SORZ ̋ ]RQH ̋ ZDV ̋ VWULSSHG ̋ RI ̋ RYHUEXUGHQ ̋ ZLWK ̋ KHDY\

PDFKLQHU\ ̋LQ ̋RUGHU ̋WR ̋ ILQG ̋XQGLVWXUEHG ̋FXOWXUDO ̋ IHDWXUHVÔ ̋ ̋6RPH ̋FKLSSHGðVWRQH ̋ IODNHV ̋ZHUH ̋VHHQ ̋EXW ̋QRW

FROOHFWHGÒ ̋DQG ̋QR ̋VRLO ̋DQRPDOLHV ̋UHVXOWLQJ ̋IURP ̋FXOWXUDO ̋DFWLYLW\ ̋ZHUH ̋ORFDWHGÔ ̋ ̋3URMHFW ̋UHFRUGV ̋DUH ̋KRXVHG

DW ̋0:$& ̋XQGHU ̋:,&5 ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ÍÍÁ ̋DQG ̋0:$& ̋$FFHVVLRQ ̋1RÔ ̋ËÂÊÔ

7KH ̋ODWHVW ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQ ̋ZDV ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋E\ ̋'DYLG ̋+D\HVÒ ̋IURP ̋%XIIDOR ̋1DWLRQDO ̋5LYHUÒ

LQ ̋WKH ̋\DUG ̋RI ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋+RXVH ̋ı+D\HV ̋Ï‰‰‰ÙÔ ̋ ̋'XULQJ ̋WKH ̋VSULQJ ̋RI ̋Ï‰‰‰Ò ̋D ̋UHOLF ̋FROOHFWRU ̋ZDV ̋FDXJKW ̋PHWDO

GHWHFWLQJ ̋DW ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋+RXVHÔ ̋ ̋+D\HV ̋DVVLVWHG ̋WKH ̋HQVXLQJ ̋ODZ ̋HQIRUFHPHQW ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQ ̋E\ ̋GRFXPHQWLQJ

WKH ̋ GDPDJH ̋WR ̋WKH ̋ VLWHÔ ̋  ̋ +H ̋ FRQGXFWHG ̋OLPLWHG ̋WHVW ̋ H[FDYDWLRQV ̋WR ̋ GHWHUPLQH ̋WKH ̋ PDQQHU ̋ DQG ̋ H[WHQW ̋ RI

GDPDJH ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ VXEVXUIDFH ̋ UHVRXUFHVÔ ̋  ̋ +H ̋ UHFRYHUHG ̋ D ̋ YDULHW\ ̋ RI ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ PHWDOÒ ̋ JODVVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ FHUDPLF

PDWHULDOVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ DOVR ̋LGHQWLILHG ̋ DQ ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ IHDWXUHÔ ̋  ̋ 3URMHFW ̋ UHFRUGV ̋ KDYH ̋ QRW ̋ EHHQ ̋ FDWDORJHG ̋ DV ̋ RI

6HSWHPEHU ̋Ï‰‰‰Ô

'XULQJ ̋Ï‰‰‰Ò ̋KXPDQ ̋VNHOHWDO ̋HOHPHQWV ̋ORFDWHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN©V ̋FROOHFWLRQVÒ ̋DQG ̋SUHVXPDEO\ ̋IRXQG ̋LQ ̋RU

DURXQG ̋ WKH ̋ EXULDO ̋ VLQNKROH ̋ ıÎÍ*5ÎÍÈÙ ̋ RQ ̋ %ORRG\ ̋ +LOOÒ ̋ ZHUH ̋ DQDO\]HG ̋ ı:LOOH\ ̋ HW ̋ DOÔ ̋ Ï‰‰‰Ù ̋ DQG

GRFXPHQWHGÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋DQDO\VLV ̋GHWHUPLQHG ̋WKDW ̋SDUWV ̋RI ̋DW ̋OHDVW ̋VL[ ̋LQGLYLGXDOV ̋DUH ̋SUHVHQWÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋LQGLYLGXDOV

UHSUHVHQWHG ̋ DSSHDU ̋ IRU ̋WKH ̋PRVW ̋ SDUW ̋WR ̋ EH ̋ \RXQJ ̋ PDOHVÒ ̋ DQG ̋WKHUH ̋LV ̋ VRPH ̋ HYLGHQFH ̋ RI ̋WUDXPD ̋ RQ ̋WKH

ERQHV ̋WKDW ̋LV ̋FRQVLVWHQW ̋ZLWK ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋RU ̋QLQHWHHQWKðFHQWXU\ ̋W\SH ̋ZRXQGVÔ

,Q ̋DGGLWLRQ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋IRUPDO ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQVÒ ̋UHOLF ̋FROOHFWRUV ̋ZHUH ̋DFWLYH ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHILHOG

SULRU ̋WR ̋LWV ̋HQWHULQJ ̋WKH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6\VWHPÔ ̋ ̋$OWKRXJK ̋WKH ̋QXPEHU ̋RI ̋FROOHFWRUV ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋H[WHQW ̋RI ̋WKHLU

FROOHFWLRQV ̋DUH ̋XQNQRZQÒ ̋WKHUH ̋DUH ̋WZR ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋EDWWOHILHOG ̋FROOHFWLRQV ̋ SUHVHUYHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋*HQHUDO

6ZHHQH\ ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋0XVHXP ̋RZQHG ̋DQG ̋RSHUDWHG ̋E\ ̋'UÔ ̋7KRPDV ̋DQG ̋.DUHQ ̋6ZHHQH\Ô ̋ ̋7KH ̋FROOHFWLRQV

ZHUH ̋PDGH ̋E\ ̋WKH ̋ODWH ̋)OHHW ̋.HUU ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋ODWH ̋'DUUHOO ̋7URJGRQÒ ̋ERWK ̋ORFDO ̋FROOHFWRUV ̋DQG ̋UHVLGHQWVÔ

%RWK ̋ FROOHFWLRQV ̋ DUH ̋ODUJHO\ ̋ XQSURYHQLHQFHGÒ ̋ EXW ̋ FRQVLVW ̋ RI ̋ KXQGUHGV ̋ RI ̋LWHPVÔ ̋  ̋ $PRQJ ̋WKH ̋ UHOLFV

REVHUYHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋FROOHFWLRQV ̋DW ̋WKH ̋*HQHUDO ̋6ZHHQH\ ̋0XVHXP ̋DUH ̋YDULRXV ̋FDOLEHUV ̋RI ̋OHDG ̋EDOOV ̋DQG ̋EXOOHWV

ıÔÍÌÒ ̋ÔËÈÒ ̋ÔËÂÒ ̋DQG ̋ÔÁ‰ ̋FDOLEHUVÙÒ ̋ IUDJPHQWV ̋RI ̋ÁðOE ̋DQG ̋ ÏÎðOE ̋FDQQRQ ̋ VKHOO ̋DQG ̋FDVH ̋ VKRWÒ ̋FDQLVWHU ̋ EDOOVÒ

VROLG ̋VKRWÒ ̋DQG ̋EODFNVPLWKðPDGH ̋EDU ̋VKRWÔ ̋ ̋$OVR ̋SUHVHQW ̋DUH ̋PXVNHW ̋WDNHðGRZQ ̋WRROVÒ ̋VRPH ̋W\SH ̋RI ̋FKHFN

FKDLQÒ ̋D ̋SRW ̋KDQJHU ̋IRU ̋D ̋FDPSILUHÒ ̋D ̋0RGHO ̋ÏÂÏÁ ̋ED\RQHWÒ ̋DQG ̋D ̋PXVNHW ̋ORFNSODWHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋SDUN ̋FROOHFWLRQV

FRQWDLQ ̋PDQ\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋VDPH ̋W\SH ̋EXOOHWVÒ ̋FDQQRQEDOO ̋IUDJPHQWVÒ ̋EDU ̋VKRWÒ ̋SHUVRQDO ̋LWHPVÒ ̋DQG ̋DFFRXWUHPHQW

IUDJPHQWVÔ

7KH ̋WZR ̋UHOLF ̋FROOHFWLRQV ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋FROOHFWLRQ ̋KDYH ̋OLWWOH ̋SURYHQLHQFH ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋DVVRFLDWHG ̋ZLWK

WKHPÔ ̋ ̋+RZHYHUÒ ̋'DUUHOO ̋7URJGRQ ̋ GLG ̋PDNH ̋D ̋ URXJK ̋ VNHWFK ̋PDS ̋ RI ̋ VRPH ̋ RI ̋ KLV ̋ ILQGV ̋ ı)LJXUH ̋ ÊÙÔ ̋ ̋7KH

PDSÒ ̋ GUDZQ ̋LQ ̋ EDOOSRLQW ̋ SHQ ̋ RQ ̋ D ̋ODUJH ̋ VFUDS ̋ RI ̋ 1DXJDK\GHÒ ̋LV ̋ SDUW ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ *HQHUDO ̋ 6ZHHQH\ ̋0XVHXP

FROOHFWLRQ ̋DQG ̋ZDV ̋PDGH ̋DYDLODEOH ̋IRU ̋VWXG\ ̋WKURXJK ̋WKH ̋NLQGQHVV ̋RI ̋'UÔ ̋7KRPDV ̋6ZHHQH\Ô ̋ ̋7KH ̋DUWLIDFW

ILQG ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋VNHWFKHG ̋E\ ̋7URGJRQ ̋LQFOXGH ̋EXOOHWVÒ ̋FDQQRQ ̋VKHOO ̋IUDJPHQWVÒ ̋DQG ̋FDQLVWHU ̋EDOOVÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV

D ̋ IHZ ̋HTXLSPHQW ̋LWHPVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋PDS ̋LV ̋ QRW ̋ SUHFLVH ̋ EXW ̋ GRHV ̋ JLYH ̋ D ̋ JHQHUDO ̋LGHD ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ DUWLIDFW ̋W\SHV ̋ DQG

GLVWULEXWLRQ ̋ZHVW ̋RI ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHN ̋DQG ̋QRUWK ̋RI ̋6NHJJV ̋%UDQFK ̋WR ̋DERXW ̋WKH ̋*LEVRQ©V ̋0LOO ̋VLWHÔ
ÏÍ

([SHFWHG ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFHV

$V ̋ZDV ̋LQGLFDWHG ̋SUHYLRXVO\Ò ̋D ̋ VHDUFK ̋RI ̋WKH ̋0LVVRXUL ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWH ̋ ILOHV ̋ SURGXFHG ̋ UHFRUGV ̋ RI

ÏÒË‰Í ̋NQRZQ ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋DQG ̋KLVWRULF ̋VLWHV ̋LQ ̋*UHHQH ̋DQG ̋&KULVWLDQ ̋&RXQWLHV ̋FRPELQHGÔ ̋ ̋:LWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN

WKHUH ̋ DUH ̋ ËÌ ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHVÒ ̋ DERXW ̋ HYHQO\ ̋ GLYLGHG ̋ EHWZHHQ ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ DQG ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ VLWHVÔ

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋EHJDQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋PLGðÏ‰ÁÌV ̋DQG ̋KDYH ̋FRQWLQXHG ̋ VSRUDGLFDOO\ ̋ VLQFH

WKHQÔ ̋ ̋1HDUO\ ̋DOO ̋WKH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ZRUN ̋KDV ̋IRFXVHG ̋RQ ̋ORFDWLQJ ̋DQG ̋LGHQWLI\LQJ ̋KRXVHV ̋DQG ̋IHDWXUHV ̋WKDW

H[LVWHG ̋DW ̋WKH ̋WLPH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋RU ̋LQ ̋UHVSRQVH ̋WR ̋SDUN ̋GHYHORSPHQW ̋QHHGV ̋ıHÔJÔÒ ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋7RXU

5RDGÙÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋ ËÌ ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ SURYLGH ̋ VRPH ̋LGHD ̋ RI ̋ZKHUH ̋ RWKHU ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV

PLJKW ̋ EH ̋ IRXQG‚ ̋ KRZHYHUÒ ̋ WKH ̋ UHFRUGLQJ ̋ HIIRUWV ̋ WR ̋ GDWH ̋ DUH ̋ QRW ̋ WKH ̋ UHVXOW ̋ RI ̋ D ̋ V\VWHPDWLF ̋ SDUNZLGH

LQYHQWRU\Ò ̋EXW ̋KDYH ̋LQVWHDG ̋EHHQ ̋PDQDJHPHQWðGULYHQ ̋DFWLRQVÔ ̋ ̋7KXV ̋WKH ̋VLWH ̋GLVWULEXWLRQ ̋GDWD ̋LV ̋VRPHZKDW

VNHZHGÒ ̋DQG ̋PD\ ̋QRW ̋UHIOHFW ̋WKH ̋HQWLUH ̋UDQJH ̋RI ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋SUHVHQW ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋ERXQGDU\Ô

,W ̋LV ̋WKHUHIRUH ̋QHFHVVDU\ ̋WR ̋SURMHFW ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋GDWD ̋DYDLODEOH ̋DQG ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋ODUJHU ̋ERG\ ̋RI ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋3ODWHDX

DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋ WR ̋ SUHGLFW ̋ WKH ̋ W\SHV ̋ RI ̋ FXOWXUDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ WKDW ̋ PD\ ̋ EH ̋ H[SHFWHG ̋ WR ̋ RFFXU ̋ DW

:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÔ

3K\VLRJUDSKLF ̋&RQVLGHUDWLRQV

7KH ̋ GLVWULEXWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ EDVLF ̋ QDWXUDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ DFURVV ̋ WKH ̋ 2]DUN ̋ 3ODWHDX ̋ LV ̋ D ̋ PRVDLF ̋ DQG ̋ WKHUHIRUH

XQHYHQÒ ̋ DQG ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ UHIOHFWV ̋ WKDW ̋ GLYHUVLW\ ̋ LQ ̋ PLFURFRVPÔ ̋  ̋ ,W ̋ LV ̋ H[SHFWHG ̋ WKDW ̋ WKH ̋ HYLGHQFH ̋ RI

SUHKLVWRULF ̋DQG ̋KLVWRULF ̋KXPDQ ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋DQG ̋XVH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋ZLOO ̋EH ̋ VLPLODUO\ ̋FRQFHQWUDWHG ̋LQ ̋FHUWDLQ

ORFDOHV ̋DQG ̋DEVHQW ̋LQ ̋RWKHUVÔ

:DWHU

:DWHU ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋LQ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋DUH ̋6NHJJV ̋%UDQFKÒ ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHNÒ ̋DQG ̋VHYHUDO ̋VSULQJVÔ ̋ ̋0RVW ̋RI

WKH ̋ZDWHU ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋DUH ̋FRQFHQWUDWHG ̋DW ̋WKH ̋ERWWRPV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋YDOOH\VÒ ̋DQG ̋LW ̋LV ̋QHDU ̋WKHVH ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋WKDW ̋WKH

PDMRULW\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋KDELWDWLRQ ̋VLWHV ̋VKRXOG ̋EH ̋H[SHFWHGÔ

9DOOH\ ̋%RWWRPV ̋DQG ̋6WUHDP ̋7HUUDFHV

3UHKLVWRULF ̋KDELWDWLRQ ̋ VLWHV ̋DQG ̋FDPSVLWHV ̋DUH ̋ IRXQG ̋ RQ ̋ VWUHDP ̋WHUUDFHV ̋WKURXJKRXW ̋WKH ̋2]DUNV ̋DQG

WKH ̋ 6SULQJILHOG ̋ 3ODWHDXÒ ̋ DQG ̋ KXPDQ ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ VLWHV ̋ VKRXOG ̋ OLNHZLVH ̋ EH ̋ H[SHFWHG ̋ WR ̋ RFFXU ̋ RQ ̋ WHUUDFH

UHPQDQWV ̋DORQJ ̋:LOVRQV ̋&UHHNÔ ̋ ̋7R ̋ GDWHÒ ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ VLWHV ̋DSSHDU ̋WR ̋ EH ̋HSKHPHUDO

FDPSVLWHV ̋RU ̋OLPLWHGðXVH ̋VLWHVÔ ̋ ̋+RZHYHUÒ ̋WKH ̋YDOOH\ ̋ERWWRPV ̋DQG ̋ORZHU ̋VWUHDP ̋WHUUDFHV ̋KDYH ̋JRRG ̋VRLOV

WKDW ̋FRXOG ̋KDYH ̋VXSSRUWHG ̋OLPLWHG ̋KRUWLFXOWXUH ̋DQG ̋SRVVLEO\ ̋VPDOOð ̋WR ̋PHGLXPðVL]HG ̋KDELWDWLRQ ̋VLWHVÔ ̋ ̋6XFK

KDELWDWLRQ ̋ VLWHV ̋ ZRXOG ̋ W\SLFDOO\ ̋ EH ̋ LQGLFDWHG ̋ E\ ̋ D ̋ UHODWLYHO\ ̋ GLYHUVH ̋ DUUD\ ̋ RI ̋ DUWLIDFW ̋ W\SHVÒ ̋ LQFOXGLQJ

FKLSSHGð ̋DQG ̋JURXQGðVWRQH ̋WRROVÒ ̋HYLGHQFH ̋ RI ̋ ERWK ̋WRRO ̋PDQXIDFWXUH ̋DQG ̋PDLQWHQDQFHÒ ̋ IHDWXUHV ̋ VXFK ̋DV

KHDUWKV ̋DQG ̋WUDVK ̋PLGGHQVÒ ̋DQG ̋SHUKDSV ̋WKH ̋UHPDLQV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋DFWXDO ̋KDELWDWLRQ ̋VWUXFWXUHV ̋WKHPVHOYHVÔ ̋ ̋7KH

ODWWHU ̋ PLJKW ̋ EH ̋LQGLFDWHG ̋ E\ ̋ VFDWWHUV ̋ RI ̋ FKDUFRDOÒ ̋ SDWWHUQV ̋ RI ̋ SRVW ̋ PROGVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ SHUKDSV ̋ E\ ̋ IUDJPHQWV ̋ RI

GDXE ̋RU ̋EXUQHG ̋FOD\Ô

*DPH ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋YDOOH\ ̋ERWWRPV ̋ZRXOG ̋KDYH ̋LQFOXGHG ̋WKRVH ̋VSHFLHV ̋WKDW ̋W\SLFDOO\ ̋UHTXLUH ̋VXFK

FRYHUÒ ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋GHHUÒ ̋ UDEELWVÒ ̋ IR[Ò ̋ VTXLUUHOÒ ̋DQG ̋D ̋YDULHW\ ̋RI ̋ELUGVÔ ̋ ̋)LVK ̋ZHUH ̋SUREDEO\ ̋WDNHQ ̋ IURP ̋WKH

VWUHDPV ̋GXULQJ ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋WLPHVÔ

5LGJHWRSV

7KH ̋ ULGJHWRSV ̋ DQG ̋ VORSHV ̋ DVVRFLDWHG ̋ ZLWK ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ DUH ̋ HDVLO\ ̋ DFFHVVLEOH ̋ IURP ̋ WKH ̋ YDOOH\

ERWWRPVÔ ̋  ̋ 0DQ\ ̋ KDYH ̋ H[FHOOHQW ̋ YLHZVKHGV ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ DUHDÒ ̋ DQG ̋ FRXOG ̋ ZHOO ̋ KDYH ̋ SURYLGHG ̋ ORFDWLRQV ̋ IRU
ÏÈ

ZDWFKLQJ ̋ IRU ̋ JDPHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋ URFN\ ̋ VRLOV ̋ IRXQG ̋ RQ ̋WKH ̋ ULGJHV ̋ SUREDEO\ ̋ H[FOXGH ̋PRVW ̋ RI ̋WKLV ̋ SK\VLRJUDSKLF

W\SH ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋SRWHQWLDO ̋IRU ̋DJULFXOWXUDO ̋GHYHORSPHQWÔ

3UHKLVWRULF ̋6LWH ̋DQG ̋)HDWXUH ̋7\SHV

*LYHQ ̋ZKDW ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋LGHQWLILHG ̋DQG ̋LQYHVWLJDWHG ̋HOVHZKHUH ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋3ODWHDXÒ ̋WKH ̋IROORZLQJ

SUHKLVWRULF ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWH ̋W\SHV ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋H[SHFWHG ̋WR ̋RFFXU ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ

7DVNð6SHFLILF ̋6LWHV

7KHVH ̋ W\SHV ̋ RI ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ ZLOO ̋ UHIOHFW ̋ VKRUWðWHUP ̋ HSLVRGHV ̋ RI ̋ XVH ̋ UHODWHG ̋ WR ̋ VSHFLILF

DFWLYLWLHVÒ ̋DQG ̋ZLOO ̋LQFOXGH ̋NLOO ̋VLWHVÒ ̋ZKHUH ̋JDPH ̋ZDV ̋WDNHQ ̋RU ̋KXQWHGÒ ̋DQG ̋JDWKHULQJ ̋VLWHVÒ ̋ZKHUH ̋VSHFLILF

SODQW ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋ZHUH ̋REWDLQHG ̋DQG ̋SHUKDSV ̋SURFHVVHGÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋RI ̋WDVNðVSHFLILF ̋VLWHV ̋DUH ̋GLIILFXOW ̋WR

SUHGLFWÒ ̋DOWKRXJK ̋WKH ̋FXUUHQWO\ ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋ VLWHV ̋ VXJJHVW ̋WKDW ̋PRVW ̋ZLOO ̋ EH ̋ IRXQG ̋ RQ ̋WHUUDFHV ̋ RU ̋ ULGJHWRSVÔ

7KH ̋WHUUDFH ̋VLWHV ̋DSSHDU ̋WR ̋EH ̋DVVRFLDWHG ̋ZLWK ̋JRRG ̋DFFHVV ̋WR ̋ZDWHUÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH\ ̋DUH ̋ IUHTXHQWO\ ̋DVVRFLDWHG

ZLWK ̋KLVWRULFðSHULRG ̋VLWHVÒ ̋VXJJHVWLQJ ̋WKDW ̋ZKDW ̋ZDV ̋RQFH ̋D ̋JRRG ̋FDPSLQJ ̋RU ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋VLWH ̋UHWDLQHG ̋WKH

VDPH ̋DSSHDO ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋PRUH ̋ UHFHQW ̋SDVW ̋DV ̋ZHOOÔ ̋ ̋7KHVH ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋FDPSVLWHV ̋ IUHTXHQWO\ ̋FRQWDLQ ̋RQO\ ̋YHU\

VPDOO ̋ TXDQWLWLHV ̋ RI ̋ SUHVHUYHG ̋ DUWLIDFWXDO ̋ PDWHULDOÔ ̋  ̋:KHQ ̋ LGHQWLILHGÒ ̋ KRZHYHUÒ ̋ WKH\ ̋ KHOS ̋ WR ̋ PRUH ̋ IXOO\

GRFXPHQW ̋WKH ̋WRWDO ̋UDQJH ̋RI ̋KXPDQ ̋DFWLYLW\Ô

+DELWDWLRQ ̋6LWHV

7KHVH ̋ VLWH ̋ W\SHV ̋ ZLOO ̋ RFFXU ̋ ERWK ̋ DV ̋ VLQJOH ̋ FRPSRQHQWVÒ ̋ UHIOHFWLQJ ̋ RQHðWLPH ̋ RFFXSDWLRQVÒ ̋ RU ̋ DV

PXOWLSOH ̋FRPSRQHQWVÒ ̋UHIOHFWLQJ ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋WKDW ̋ZHUH ̋SHULRGLFDOO\ ̋ UHRFFXSLHGÒ ̋SHUKDSV ̋RYHU ̋WKH ̋FRXUVH ̋RI

VHYHUDO ̋ WKRXVDQG ̋ \HDUVÔ ̋  ̋ +DELWDWLRQ ̋ VLWHV ̋ DUH ̋ XVXDOO\ ̋ FKDUDFWHUL]HG ̋ E\ ̋ D ̋ ZLGHU ̋ UDQJH ̋ RI ̋ DUWLIDFW ̋ W\SHVÒ

PLGGHQ ̋RU ̋WUDVK ̋GHSRVLWVÒ ̋DQG ̋IHDWXUHV ̋WKDW ̋WRJHWKHU ̋UHIOHFW ̋D ̋PRUH ̋VXEVWDQWLDO ̋UDQJH ̋RI ̋KXPDQ ̋DFWLYLWLHVÔ

/DUJHð ̋DQG ̋ VPDOOðGLPHQVLRQ ̋OLWKLF ̋ GHELWDJHÒ ̋FRPSOHWH ̋DQG ̋ IUDJPHQWDU\ ̋ ILQLVKHG ̋ FKLSSHGðVWRQH ̋ DUWLIDFWVÒ

DQG ̋JHQHUDO ̋WUDVK ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋DQLPDO ̋ERQHÒ ̋EURNHQ ̋FHUDPLFVÒ ̋DQG ̋FKDUFRDO ̋DUH ̋DOO ̋WR ̋EH ̋H[SHFWHGÔ ̋ ̋+HDUWK

IHDWXUHVÒ ̋EXUQHG ̋URFN ̋FRPSOH[HVÒ ̋DQG ̋SRVW ̋PROG ̋SDWWHUQV ̋LQGLFDWLQJ ̋KRXVH ̋VWUXFWXUH ̋UHPDLQV ̋PD\ ̋DOVR ̋EH

SUHVHQW ̋ DW ̋ KDELWDWLRQ ̋ VLWHVÔ ̋  ̋ 6RPH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ ILQLVKHG ̋ DUWLIDFWVÒ ̋ SDUWLFXODUO\ ̋ SURMHFWLOH ̋ SRLQWVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ FKDUFRDO

IURP ̋VWUXFWXUHV ̋DQG ̋KHDUWK ̋IHDWXUHV ̋ZLOO ̋HQDEOH ̋VRPH ̋RI ̋WKHVH ̋RFFXSDWLRQV ̋WR ̋EH ̋SODFHG ̋LQ ̋WLPHÔ ̋ ̋7R ̋GDWHÒ

QRQH ̋RI ̋WKHVH ̋VLWH ̋W\SHV ̋KDYH ̋EHHQ ̋FRQILUPHG ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋ERXQGDULHVÔ

7KH ̋SRVVLELOLW\ ̋RI ̋PXOWLSOHðFRPSRQHQW ̋KDELWDWLRQ ̋VLWHV ̋H[LVWVÒ ̋DQG ̋WKHVH ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋IRXQG ̋LQ ̋DUHDV ̋ZKHUH

FULWLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋VXFK ̋DV ̋ZDWHU ̋ZHUH ̋SUHGLFWDEO\ ̋DYDLODEOHÒ ̋WKH ̋FULWLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋HVVHQWLDOO\ ̋GULYLQJ ̋WKH

UHSHDWHG ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ VDPH ̋ ORFDOHÔ ̋  ̋ +DELWDWLRQ ̋ VLWHV ̋ PD\ ̋ WKXV ̋ EH ̋ H[SHFWHG ̋ RQ ̋ ZHOOðGHYHORSHG

WHUUDFHV ̋ DW ̋ VWUHDPVLGH ̋ORFDOHVÒ ̋ EXW ̋WKH\ ̋PD\ ̋ DOVR ̋ RFFXU ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ YLFLQLW\ ̋ RI ̋ VSULQJVÔ ̋  ̋&HUWDLQO\Ò ̋WKHUH ̋ DUH

PXOWLFRPSRQHQW ̋VLWHVÒ ̋SUHKLVWRULF ̋FDPSV ̋ZLWK ̋KLVWRULF ̋IXQFWLRQV ̋RYHUOD\LQJ ̋WKH ̋HDUOLHU ̋RFFXSDWLRQÒ ̋SUHVHQW

LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ ̋ ̋5HSHDWHG ̋RFFXSDWLRQV ̋DW ̋PXOWLSOHðFRPSRQHQW ̋KDELWDWLRQ ̋VLWHV ̋ZLOO ̋EH ̋ UHIOHFWHG ̋LQ ̋LQFUHDVHG

TXDQWLWLHV ̋RI ̋GHEULV ̋IURP ̋GD\ðWRðGD\ ̋DFWLYLWLHVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋UHSHDWHG ̋RFFXSDWLRQV ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋GLUHFWO\ ̋VXSHULPSRVHG

DWRS ̋RQH ̋DQRWKHUÒ ̋RU ̋WKH\ ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋LQGLFDWHG ̋E\ ̋KRUL]RQWDO ̋VWUDWLJUDSK\ ̋RI ̋IHDWXUHV ̋DQG ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋WKDW ̋RQO\

PLQLPDOO\ ̋RYHUODSÔ

6LWH ̋'HQVLW\

,W ̋ LV ̋ GLIILFXOW ̋ WR ̋ DFFXUDWHO\ ̋ HVWLPDWH ̋ WKH ̋ GHQVLW\ ̋ RI ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ DW ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ LQ ̋ WKH

DEVHQFH ̋ RI ̋ DQ\ ̋ V\VWHPDWLF ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ HIIRUWV ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ SDUNÔ ̋  ̋ +RZHYHUÒ ̋ LW ̋ VHHPV ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ WKDW ̋ SUHKLVWRULF

KDELWDWLRQ ̋ VLWH ̋ GHQVLW\ ̋ ZLOO ̋ EH ̋ WKH ̋ JUHDWHVW ̋ DORQJ ̋ :LOVRQV ̋ &UHHN ̋ DQG ̋ QHDU ̋ VSULQJ ̋ ORFDOHVÔ ̋  ̋ )RU ̋ WKRVH

:RRGODQGðSHULRG ̋ JURXSV ̋ SUDFWLFLQJ ̋ UXGLPHQWDU\ ̋ KRUWLFXOWXUHÒ ̋ DUDEOH ̋ODQG ̋ ZRXOG ̋ KDYH ̋ EHHQ ̋ FRQILQHG ̋WR

WKH ̋YDOOH\ ̋ERWWRPVÔ
ÏË

7KH ̋GHQVLW\ ̋RI ̋ULGJHWRS ̋VLWHV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋ZLOO ̋SUREDEO\ ̋EH ̋OHVV ̋WKDQ ̋WKDW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋VWUHDPVLGH ̋VLWHVÒ ̋DQG

WKHLU ̋ SK\VLFDO ̋ GLPHQVLRQV ̋ ZLOO ̋ SUREDEO\ ̋ DOVR ̋ EH ̋ VPDOOHUÔ ̋  ̋ ,I ̋ ULGJHWRS ̋ VLWHV ̋ UHIOHFW ̋ OLPLWHG ̋ DFWLYLW\

IXQFWLRQVÒ ̋WKHQ ̋WKH\ ̋ ZLOO ̋OLNHO\ ̋ KDYH ̋ D ̋OLPLWHG ̋ DUWLIDFWXDO ̋ GLYHUVLW\ ̋LQ ̋ UHJDUG ̋ WR ̋ OLWKLF ̋ VRXUFHV ̋ DQG ̋ WRRO

W\SHVÔ

+LVWRULF ̋(XURDPHULFDQ ̋VLWHV ̋DQG ̋IHDWXUHV ̋ZLOO ̋EH ̋IRXQG ̋LQ ̋HVVHQWLDOO\ ̋DOO ̋DUHDV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ ̋ ̋*LEVRQ©V

0LOO ̋IHDWXUHV ̋D ̋FRPSOH[ ̋PLOOUDFHÒ ̋DQG ̋RWKHU ̋ZDWHU ̋FRQWURO ̋GHYLFHV ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋IRXQG ̋HOVHZKHUH ̋RQ ̋:LOVRQ©V

&UHHNÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋QXPEHU ̋RI ̋KRPHVWHDGVÓIDUPVWHDGV ̋DUH ̋NQRZQ ̋WR ̋H[LVW ̋RQ ̋SDUN ̋ODQGVÒ ̋DQG ̋WKHVH ̋VLWHV ̋ZLOO ̋FRQWDLQ

D ̋YDULHW\ ̋RI ̋VWUXFWXUHV ̋LQFOXGLQJ ̋IDUPKRXVHVÒ ̋URRW ̋FHOODUVÒ ̋VPDOO ̋EDUQV ̋RU ̋OLYHVWRFN ̋VKHGVÒ ̋DQG ̋FRUQ ̋FULEVÒ

WRJHWKHU ̋ ZLWK ̋ SULYLHVÒ ̋ FLVWHUQVÒ ̋ FRUUDOVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ DVVRFLDWHG ̋ WUDVK ̋ GHSRVLWVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ :LUH ̋ 5RDG ̋ LV ̋ YLVLEOH ̋ LQ ̋ D

QXPEHU ̋RI ̋SODFHVÒ ̋DQG ̋RWKHU ̋ROG ̋URDGV ̋DUH ̋OLNHO\ ̋WR ̋EH ̋SUHVHQW ̋DV ̋ZHOOÔ

7KH ̋SULPDU\ ̋UHDVRQ ̋IRU ̋WKH ̋H[LVWHQFH ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋LV ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋EDWWOH

WKDW ̋ZDV ̋ IRXJKW ̋WKHUHÔ ̋ ̋+RZHYHUÒ ̋WKLV ̋LV ̋WKH ̋OHDVW ̋ZHOO ̋GRFXPHQWHG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋FRPSRQHQW ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH

SDUN ̋ERXQGDULHVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋5D\ ̋+RXVHÒ ̋DV ̋D ̋IHDWXUH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHÒ ̋LV ̋SDUWLDOO\ ̋VWXGLHG‚ ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋8QLRQ ̋EXULDO ̋VLWH

RI ̋WKH ̋6LQNKROH ̋ZDV ̋H[FDYDWHG ̋DQG ̋UHVWRUHG ̋WR ̋LWV ̋ÏÂÁÏ ̋DSSHDUDQFHÔ ̋ ̋0DQ\ ̋UHOLFV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋KDYH ̋EHHQ

IRXQG ̋ E\ ̋ FROOHFWRUV ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN ̋ VWDIIÒ ̋ EXW ̋ YHU\ ̋ OLWWOH ̋ RI ̋ WKDW ̋ LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋ LV ̋ ZHOO ̋ SURYHQLHQFHG ̋ RU

GRFXPHQWHGÔ

6LWH ̋$JHV

,W ̋LV ̋OLNHO\ ̋WKDW ̋ DUWLIDFWV ̋ GLDJQRVWLF ̋ RI ̋ DOO ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ PDMRU ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋WLPH ̋ SHULRGV ̋ ZLOO ̋ HYHQWXDOO\ ̋ EH

LGHQWLILHG ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÒ ̋IRU ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋IURP ̋DGMDFHQW ̋DUHDV ̋VXJJHVWV ̋WKDW ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOG ̋3ODWHDX ̋KDV

VHHQ ̋LQWHUPLWWHQW ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋IRU WHQ ̋PLOOHQQLDÔ ̋ ̋+RZHYHUÒ ̋WKH ̋OLPLWHG ̋ODQGIRUPV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋DUH ̋QRW ̋OLNHO\

WR ̋FRQWDLQ ̋HYLGHQFH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋FRPSOHWH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHFRUGÔ

3UHKLVWRULF ̋6LWHV

7KH ̋3DOHRLQGLDQ ̋RFFXSDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋DUHD ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÒ ̋IURP ̋FLUFD ̋ÏÎÒÌÌÌ§ÂÌÌÌ ̋\HDUV ̋%3Ò ̋ZLOO

PRVW ̋OLNHO\ ̋EH ̋LQGLVWLQFWÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋LV ̋LQ ̋SDUW ̋GXH ̋WR ̋WKH ̋ VPDOO ̋QXPEHUV ̋RI ̋KXPDQV ̋XWLOL]LQJ ̋WKH ̋DUHD ̋DW ̋WKDW

WLPHÔ

$UFKDLFðSHULRG ̋RFFXSDWLRQVÒ ̋SDUWLFXODUO\ ̋WKRVH ̋GDWLQJ ̋WR ̋WKH ̋0LGGOH ̋$UFKDLFÒ ̋DUH ̋NQRZQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÒ

DOEHLW ̋ DV ̋ LVRODWHG ̋ ILQGV ̋ DQG ̋ OLPLWHG ̋ RFFXSDWLRQ ̋ FDPSVLWHVÔ ̋  ̋ ,W ̋ LV ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ WKDW ̋ $UFKDLFðDJH ̋ VLWHV ̋ DUH ̋ ZHOO

GLVWULEXWHG ̋ DORQJ ̋ WKH ̋ GUDLQDJHV ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ SDUNÒ ̋ EXW ̋ WKH\ ̋ PD\ ̋ EH ̋ REVFXUHG ̋ E\ ̋ ODWHU ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ RU ̋ KLVWRULF

RFFXSDWLRQVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KHVH ̋ VLWHV ̋ DUH ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ WR ̋ EH ̋ GLIILFXOW ̋ WR ̋ ILQG ̋ DQG ̋ LQWHUSUHWÒ ̋ EDVHG ̋ RQ ̋ WKH ̋ RFFXUUHQFH ̋ DQG

GLVWULEXWLRQ ̋RI ̋$UFKDLFðDJH ̋VLWHV ̋WKDW ̋KDYH ̋SUHYLRXVO\ ̋EHHQ ̋IRXQGÔ

3RVWð$UFKDLF ̋ RFFXSDWLRQV ̋ GDWLQJ ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋:RRGODQG ̋ SHULRG ̋ DUH ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ WR ̋ EH ̋ ZHOO ̋ UHSUHVHQWHG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH

SDUNÒ ̋ DV ̋ LW ̋ LV ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ WKDW ̋ WKLV ̋ WLPH ̋ SHULRG ̋ VDZ ̋ LQFUHDVHG ̋ SRSXODWLRQ ̋ QXPEHUVÔ ̋  ̋ *HQHUDO ̋ SRVWð$UFKDLF

FOLPDWLF ̋VWDELOLW\ ̋KDV ̋SUREDEO\ ̋DOVR ̋FRQWULEXWHG ̋WR ̋SUHVHUYDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKHVH ̋ODWHU ̋FXOWXUDO ̋GHSRVLWVÔ

+LVWRULFð$JH ̋6LWHV

+LVWRULF ̋ IDUPLQJ ̋ VLWHVÒ ̋ D ̋ PLOOLQJ ̋ VLWHÒ ̋ FHPHWHULHVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ D ̋ WRZQVLWH ̋ DUH ̋ UHFRUGHGÔ ̋  ̋ 2WKHUÒ ̋ PRUH

HSKHPHUDO ̋KRPHVWHDG ̋RU ̋IDUPLQJ ̋VLWHV ̋DUH ̋OLNHO\ ̋WR ̋EH ̋SUHVHQWÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV ̋XQUHFRUGHG ̋DQG ̋XQGRFXPHQWHG

IHDWXUHV ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ NQRZQ ̋ VLWHVÔ ̋  ̋ ([WHQVLYH ̋ HYLGHQFH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ EDWWOH ̋ LV ̋ OLNHO\ ̋ SUHVHQW ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ IRUP ̋ RI ̋ EXOOHWVÒ

DFFRXWUHPHQWVÒ ̋DQG ̋D ̋YDULHW\ ̋RI ̋RWKHU ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋RYHU ̋YLUWXDOO\ ̋WKH ̋HQWLUH ̋SDUN ̋ODQGVÔ
ÏÁ
ÏÊ

3RWHQWLDO ̋7KUHDWV ̋WR ̋WKH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFHV

:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋ H[LVWV ̋WR ̋ SUHVHUYHÒ ̋ SURWHFWÒ ̋ DQG ̋LQWHUSUHW ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋ EDWWOH

WKDW ̋ RFFXUUHG ̋WKHUH ̋LQ ̋ ÏÂÁÏÔ ̋  ̋ *LYHQ ̋ WKH ̋ VSLULW ̋ RI ̋ SUHVHUYDWLRQ ̋ LQKHUHQW ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN ̋ PDQGDWHÒ ̋ WKUHDWV ̋ WR

DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ DUH ̋ QRW ̋ QXPHURXVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KHUH ̋ DUH ̋ HVVHQWLDOO\ ̋ WZR ̋ EURDG ̋ PDQDJHPHQW ̋ DFWLRQV ̋ WKDW

FRXOG ̋ DIIHFW ̋ WKH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV„ ̋ GHYHORSPHQW ̋ RI ̋ URDGVÒ ̋ WUDLOVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ YLVLWRU ̋ IDFLOLWLHV‚ ̋ DQG

YHJHWDWLYH ̋ PDQLSXODWLRQÔ ̋  ̋ ,Q ̋ DGGLWLRQ ̋ DQRWKHU ̋ VLJQLILFDQW ̋ WKUHDW ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ LV ̋ WKH

LOOHJDO ̋FODQGHVWLQH ̋UHOLFðFROOHFWLQJ ̋DFWLYLWLHV ̋WKDW ̋DSSHDU ̋WR ̋EH ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋LQFUHDVH ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ

'HYHORSPHQW

7KH ̋SDUN ̋*HQHUDO ̋0DQDJHPHQW ̋3ODQ ̋WKDW ̋LV ̋FXUUHQWO\ ̋XQGHUJRLQJ ̋UHYLVLRQ ̋PD\ ̋FDOO ̋IRU ̋FKDQJLQJ ̋WKH

SRZHU ̋OLQH ̋FRUULGRUV ̋RU ̋XQGHUJURXQGLQJ ̋VRPH ̋SRZHU ̋OLQHVÒ ̋IRU ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋RU ̋DOWHUDWLRQ ̋RI ̋SDUNLQJ ̋ORWVÒ

RU ̋ IRU ̋WKH ̋GHYHORSPHQW ̋RI ̋QHZ ̋YLVLWRU ̋WUDLOVÔ ̋ ̋(DFK ̋RI ̋WKHVH ̋SRWHQWLDOO\ ̋JURXQGðGLVWXUELQJ ̋DFWLYLWLHV ̋ZLOO

UHTXLUH ̋GHWDLOHG ̋FRRUGLQDWLRQ ̋WR ̋HQVXUH ̋WKDW ̋XQUHFRUGHG ̋FXOWXUDO ̋IHDWXUHV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋DUHD ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋LGHQWLILHG ̋DQG

HYDOXDWHG ̋DKHDG ̋RI ̋FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋DQG ̋WKDW ̋UHFRUGHG ̋VLWHV ̋DUH ̋DYRLGHG ̋RU ̋DGHTXDWHO\ ̋PLWLJDWHGÔ

9HJHWDWLYH ̋0DQLSXODWLRQ

2QH ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN©V ̋ FXUUHQW ̋ JRDOV ̋ LV ̋ WR ̋ UHVWRUH ̋ VHOHFWHG ̋ DUHDV ̋ WR ̋ WKHLU ̋ ÏÂÁÏ ̋ DSSHDUDQFHÒ ̋ RU ̋ DW ̋ OHDVW

HVWDEOLVK ̋D ̋YHJHWDWLRQ ̋SDWWHUQ ̋LQ ̋WKRVH ̋DUHDV ̋WKDW ̋LV ̋FRQVLVWHQW ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋HDUO\ ̋ÏÂÁÌVÔ ̋ ̋7KLV ̋JRDO ̋ UHTXLUHV

H[SDQGLQJ ̋ WKH ̋ FXUUHQW ̋ SUHVFULEHG ̋ ILUH ̋ SURJUDP ̋ DQG ̋ PHFKDQLFDO ̋ PDQLSXODWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ VRPH ̋ YHJHWDWLRQ ̋ DQG

WUHHVÔ ̋  ̋ $ ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ /DQGVFDSH ̋ 6WXG\ ̋ ZDV ̋ EHJXQ ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ IDOO ̋ RI ̋ Ï‰‰‰Ò ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ UHVXOW ̋ PD\ ̋ UHFRPPHQG

PRGLILFDWLRQV ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ FXUUHQW ̋ YHJHWDWLRQ ̋ PDQDJHPHQW ̋ SODQÔ ̋  ̋ 5HJDUGOHVVÒ ̋ WKH ̋ YHJHWDWLRQ ̋ PDQLSXODWLRQ

WHFKQLTXHV ̋DUH ̋QRW ̋OLNHO\ ̋WR ̋FKDQJH ̋VLJQLILFDQWO\Ô

0RZLQJ ̋LV ̋XQOLNHO\ ̋WR ̋DIIHFW ̋VXEVXUIDFH ̋UHVRXUFHVÒ ̋EXW ̋DWWHQWLRQ ̋VKRXOG ̋EH ̋SDLG ̋WR ̋DQ\ ̋DERYHðJURXQG

HOHPHQWV ̋LQ ̋RUGHU ̋WR ̋SURWHFW ̋WKHPÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV ̋WR ̋WKH ̋SRWHQWLDO ̋IRU ̋FDXVLQJ ̋LQFUHDVHG ̋HURVLRQ ̋RQ ̋VRPH ̋VLWHVÔ

3ORZLQJ ̋ WR ̋ HOLPLQDWH ̋ FHUWDLQ ̋ YHJHWDWLRQ ̋ RU ̋ WR ̋ UHVWRUH ̋ 5D\©V ̋ &RUQILHOG ̋ KDV ̋ WKH ̋ SRWHQWLDO ̋ IRU ̋ GLVWXUELQJ

DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ IHDWXUHVÒ ̋ VLWHVÒ ̋ DQG ̋ LQ ̋ SDUWLFXODUÒ ̋ DUWLIDFWV ̋ UHODWHG ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ EDWWOH ̋ LWVHOIÔ ̋  ̋ $Q\ ̋ PHFKDQLFDO

JURXQGðGLVWXUELQJ ̋ HIIRUWV ̋ VKRXOG ̋ EH ̋ UHYLHZHG ̋ IRU ̋ FRPSOLDQFH ̋ ZLWK ̋ 6HFWLRQ ̋ ÏÌÁ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ +LVWRULF

3UHVHUYDWLRQ ̋$FWÒ ̋DV ̋DPHQGHGÔ

$ ̋FRQVLGHUDEOH ̋DPRXQW ̋RI ̋UHFHQW ̋UHVHDUFKÒ ̋SULPDULO\ ̋LQ ̋PRXQWDLQRXV ̋WHUUDLQÒ ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋RQ

WKH ̋HIIHFW ̋RI ̋EXUQLQJ ̋RQ ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋ı(LQLQJHU ̋Ï‰‰Ì‚ ̋&RQQRU ̋DQG ̋&DQQRQ ̋Ï‰‰ÏÙÔ ̋ ̋6D\OHU ̋HW ̋DOÔ

ıÏ‰Â‰Ù ̋KDYH ̋DGGUHVVHG ̋WKH ̋HIIHFWV ̋RI ̋ILUH ̋RQ ̋VLWHV ̋DQG ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋LQ ̋PRUH ̋RSHQ ̋SUDLULH ̋WHUUDLQÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋JHQHUDO

FRQFOXVLRQ ̋LV ̋WKDW ̋IDVWðPRYLQJ ̋ILUHV ̋ZLWK ̋IODPH ̋KHLJKWV ̋XQGHU ̋ÏÌ ̋IHHW ̋DQG ̋ZKLFK ̋SURGXFH ̋OLJKW ̋JURXQG ̋FKDU

KDYH ̋ D ̋ ORZ ̋ SRWHQWLDO ̋ WR ̋ LPSDFW ̋ VXUIDFH ̋ OLWKLF ̋ PDWHULDOVÔ ̋  ̋ ,Q ̋ DQ\ ̋ FDVHÒ ̋ WKHVH ̋ ILUHV ̋ KDYH ̋ D ̋ YHU\ ̋ ORZ

SUREDELOLW\ ̋RI ̋LPSDFWLQJ ̋DUWLIDFWV ̋DQG ̋ IHDWXUHV ̋WKDW ̋DUH ̋EXULHG ̋GHHSHU ̋WKDW ̋WZR ̋LQFKHV ̋EHORZ ̋WKH ̋ JURXQG

VXUIDFHÔ

9DQGDOLVP

7KH ̋ UHFHQWO\ ̋LQYHVWLJDWHG ̋ FDVH ̋ RI ̋ UHOLF ̋ FROOHFWLQJ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋ SDUNÒ ̋ DV ̋ ZHOO ̋ DV ̋ UHSRUWV ̋ RI ̋ RWKHU ̋ SRVVLEOH

FODQGHVWLQH ̋ GLJJLQJÒ ̋ VXJJHVWV ̋ WKDW ̋ YDQGDOLVP ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN©V ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ LV ̋ LQFUHDVLQJÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH

WKUHDWV ̋DUH ̋UHDOÒ ̋DQG ̋DFWXDO ̋LOOHJDO ̋GLJJLQJ ̋DQG ̋FROOHFWLQJ ̋DUH ̋OLNHO\ ̋WR ̋LQFUHDVH ̋DV ̋GHYHORSPHQW ̋RXWVLGH ̋WKH

SDUN ̋ERXQGDULHV ̋HOLPLQDWHV ̋RU ̋ UHGXFHV ̋WUDGLWLRQDO ̋ UHOLFðFROOHFWLQJ ̋ VLWHV ̋ IRU ̋ORFDO ̋FROOHFWRUVÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋SDUNZLGH

DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋ZLOO ̋EH ̋SDUWLFXODUO\ ̋XVHIXO ̋WR ̋ODZ ̋HQIRUFHPHQWÒ ̋DV ̋LW ̋ZLOO ̋HVWDEOLVK ̋DQG ̋GRFXPHQW
ÏÂ

FXUUHQW ̋VLWH ̋FRQGLWLRQÔ ̋ ̋7KDW ̋EDVHOLQH ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋FDQ ̋WKHQ ̋EH ̋XVHG ̋WR ̋GHWHUPLQH ̋WKH ̋H[WHQW ̋RI ̋GDPDJH ̋WR ̋D

VLWH ̋LI ̋LOOHJDO ̋DFWLYLWLHV ̋GR ̋RFFXU ̋WKHUHÔ ̋ ̋:LWK ̋WKH ̋EDVHOLQH ̋VLWH ̋FRQGLWLRQ ̋LQIRUPDWLRQÒ ̋GDPDJH ̋DVVHVVPHQWV

DUH ̋PDGH ̋HDVLHU ̋DQG ̋PRUH ̋ DFFXUDWHÒ ̋WKXV ̋PDNLQJ ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFH ̋ 3URWHFWLRQ ̋$FW ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQV

PRUH ̋FRPSOHWH ̋DQG ̋KRSHIXOO\ ̋HDVLHU ̋WR ̋SURVHFXWHÔ
Ï‰

0DQDJHPHQW ̋5HFRPPHQGDWLRQV

7KH ̋UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV ̋IRU ̋PDQDJHPHQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋DUH ̋UHODWLYHO\

VWUDLJKWIRUZDUGÔ ̋  ̋ (YHU\ ̋ UHDVRQDEOH ̋ HIIRUW ̋ VKRXOG ̋ EH ̋ PDGH ̋ WR ̋ FRPSOHWH ̋ DQ ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN©V

SUHKLVWRULF ̋DQG ̋KLVWRULF ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHFRUGÔ

&XOWXUDO ̋6LWHV ̋,QYHQWRU\

7KH ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋&XOWXUDO ̋ 6LWHV ̋ ,QYHQWRU\ ̋ KDV ̋ EHHQ ̋ EHJXQ ̋ DW ̋0:$& ̋ DQG

ZLOO ̋ EH ̋ FRPSOHWHG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ QHDU ̋ IXWXUHÔ ̋  ̋ 7KLV ̋ GRFXPHQW ̋ ZLOO ̋ SURYLGH ̋ IXUWKHU ̋ UHIHUHQFH ̋ IRU ̋ UHOHYDQW

DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋OLWHUDWXUH ̋ IRU ̋WKH ̋DUHDÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋&XOWXUDO ̋6LWHV ̋ ,QYHQWRU\ ̋ZLOO ̋OLVW ̋WKH ̋ IRUPDOO\ ̋ UHFRUGHG ̋ VLWHVÒ

DQG ̋ ZLOO ̋ LGHQWLI\ ̋ RQ ̋ 8Ô6Ô*Ô6Ô ̋ EDVH ̋ PDSV ̋ ERWK ̋ WKHLU ̋ ORFDWLRQV ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ SK\VLFDO ̋ OLPLWV ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ YDULRXV

LQGLYLGXDO ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHQWRULHV ̋WKDW ̋KDYH ̋WDNHQ ̋SODFHÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋&XOWXUDO ̋6LWHV ̋,QYHQWRU\

ZLOO ̋EH ̋PDLQWDLQHG ̋DQG ̋SHULRGLFDOO\ ̋XSGDWHG ̋E\ ̋&HQWHU ̋VWDII ̋DV ̋QHZ ̋SURMHFWV ̋DUH ̋FRQGXFWHG ̋RU ̋D ̋SDUNZLGH

LQYHQWRU\ ̋ FDQ ̋ EH ̋ FRPSOHWHGÔ ̋  ̋ 2QH ̋ DVSHFW ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ 6LWHV ̋ ,QYHQWRU\ ̋ LV ̋ WKH ̋ GHYHORSPHQW ̋ RI ̋ DQ

DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ OD\HU ̋ IRU ̋ WKH ̋ SDUN©V ̋ *HRJUDSKLFDO ̋ ,QIRUPDWLRQ ̋ 6\VWHP ̋ GDWDEDVHÔ ̋  ̋ 7KLV ̋ HOHPHQW ̋ ZDV

FRPSOHWHG ̋DV ̋SDUW ̋RI ̋WKLV ̋2YHUYLHZ ̋DQG ̋$VVHVVPHQW ̋HIIRUWÔ

3DUN ̋ VWDII ̋ VKRXOG ̋ EHFRPH ̋ IDPLOLDU ̋ ZLWK ̋ WKLV ̋ 2YHUYLHZ ̋ DQG ̋ $VVHVVPHQW ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ 6LWHV

,QYHQWRU\ ̋ DQG ̋ LQWHJUDWH ̋ WKHP ̋ LQWR ̋ WKHLU ̋ FXOWXUDO ̋ UHVRXUFH ̋ FRPSOLDQFH ̋ SURFHVVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH\ ̋ VKRXOG ̋ URXWLQHO\

FRQVXOW ̋ WKHP ̋ DV ̋ EDVLF ̋ FRPSRQHQWV ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 6HFWLRQ ̋ ÏÌÁ ̋ SURFHVV ̋ SULRU ̋ WR ̋ DQ\ ̋ XQGHUWDNLQJ ̋ WKDW ̋ LV ̋ QRW ̋ D

SURJUDPPDWLF ̋ H[FOXVLRQ ̋ DV ̋ VSHFLILHG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ Ï‰‰Ë ̋ 6HUYLFHZLGH ̋ 3URJUDPPDWLF ̋ $JUHHPHQW ̋ ZLWK ̋ WKH

$GYLVRU\ ̋&RXQFLO ̋ RQ ̋ +LVWRULF ̋ 3UHVHUYDWLRQ ̋ DQG ̋WKH ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋&RQIHUHQFH ̋ RI ̋ 6WDWH ̋ +LVWRULF ̋ 3UHVHUYDWLRQ

2IILFHUV ̋DQG ̋LQ ̋'LUHFWRU©V ̋2UGHU ̋1XPEHU ̋ÎÂ„ ̋&XOWXUDO ̋5HVRXUFH ̋0DQDJHPHQW ̋*XLGHOLQH ̋ ı1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN

6HUYLFH ̋Ï‰‰ÊÙÔ ̋6WDII ̋VKRXOG ̋DOVR ̋XQGHUVWDQG ̋WKDW ̋WKH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋FRQWDLQHG ̋LQ

WKH ̋&XOWXUDO ̋6LWHV ̋ ,QYHQWRU\ ̋LV ̋QRW ̋ IRU ̋SXEOLF ̋GLVWULEXWLRQÒ ̋DQG ̋KDV ̋EHHQ ̋H[HPSWHG ̋ IURP ̋WKH ̋)UHHGRP ̋RI

,QIRUPDWLRQ ̋$FWÔ

3DUNZLGH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋,QYHQWRU\

7KH ̋0LGZHVW ̋5HJLRQ ̋ 6\VWHPZLGH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ ,QYHQWRU\ ̋ 3URJUDP ̋ 3ODQ ̋ ı0LGZHVW ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO

&HQWHU ̋Ï‰‰‰Ù ̋LGHQWLILHV ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋DV ̋D ̋SDUN ̋QHHGLQJ ̋D ̋SDUNZLGH ̋LQYHQWRU\Ô ̋ ̋7KH ̋SDUNZLGH ̋LQYHQWRU\

VHUYHV ̋WR ̋PHHW ̋D ̋QXPEHU ̋RI ̋*RYHUQPHQW ̋3HUIRUPDQFH ̋DQG ̋5HRUJDQL]DWLRQ ̋$FW ̋ UHTXLUHPHQWVÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV

WR ̋ DFKLHYH ̋ FRPSOLDQFH ̋ ZLWK ̋ 6HFWLRQ ̋ ÏÏÌ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ +LVWRULF ̋ 3UHVHUYDWLRQ ̋ $FWÒ ̋ DV ̋ DPHQGHGÔ ̋  ̋ $

V\VWHPDWLFÒ ̋SDUNZLGH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋ZLOO ̋SURYLGH ̋GHWDLOHG ̋EDVHOLQH ̋GDWD ̋ UHJDUGLQJ ̋WKH ̋W\SHV ̋ RI

VLWHV ̋WKDW ̋DUH ̋DFWXDOO\ ̋SUHVHQW ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ ̋ ̋7KHVH ̋GDWD ̋ZRXOG ̋LQFOXGH ̋VSHFLILF ̋VLWH ̋ORFDWLRQVÒ ̋LGHQWLI\ ̋WKH

SUHKLVWRULF ̋ DQG ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ FXOWXUHV ̋ DQG ̋ DFWLYLWLHV ̋ WKDW ̋ DUH ̋ UHSUHVHQWHG ̋ DQG ̋ WKH ̋ DJHV ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ RFFXSDWLRQVÒ

SURYLGH ̋D ̋FXUUHQW ̋ VLWH ̋FRQGLWLRQ ̋DVVHVVPHQWÒ ̋DQG ̋ZRXOG ̋FXPXODWLYHO\ ̋GRFXPHQW ̋WKH ̋ UHODWLYH ̋ QXPEHUV ̋ RI

HDFK ̋W\SH ̋RI ̋VLWHÔ ̋ ̋$ ̋PDMRU ̋IRFXV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋LQYHQWRU\Ò ̋SHU ̋WKH ̋SDUNðGHILQHG ̋QHHGVÒ ̋ZRXOG ̋EH ̋DQ ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋DQG

PHWDO ̋GHWHFWRU ̋VXUYH\ ̋WR ̋ORFDWH ̋KLVWRULF ̋URDG ̋QHWZRUNVÒ ̋PLOLWDU\ ̋FDPSVÒ ̋DUWLOOHU\ ̋SRVLWLRQVÒ ̋WURRS ̋SRVLWLRQVÒ

DQG ̋VROGLHU ̋EXULDO ̋VLWHVÒ ̋DQG ̋WR ̋GHWHUPLQH ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋5D\ ̋+RXVH ̋VXSSRUW ̋VWUXFWXUHVÒ ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋RI

WKH ̋6KDUS ̋KRXVHÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋*ZLQQ ̋KRXVHÒ ̋DV ̋ZHOO ̋DV ̋WKH ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋RI ̋RWKHU ̋IHDWXUHV ̋DVVRFLð

DWHG ̋ZLWK ̋WKH ̋ÏÂÁÏ ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋EDWWOHÔ
ÎÌ

6SHFLILF ̋1HHGV ̋IRU ̋)XWXUH ̋3DUNZLGH ̋,QYHVWLJDWLRQV

x 3UHSDUH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWH ̋IRUPV ̋IRU ̋WKH ̋%DWWOHILHOG ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋:LUH ̋5RDGÔ

x 'HYHORS ̋D ̋GHWDLOHG ̋DVVHVVPHQW ̋DQG ̋LGHQWLILFDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ SDUN ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋FROOHFWLRQV ̋DV

EDVHOLQH ̋GDWD ̋ UHSUHVHQWLQJ ̋WKH ̋SK\VLFDO ̋HYLGHQFH ̋RI ̋ZHDSRQV ̋DQG ̋HTXLSPHQW ̋DFWXDOO\ ̋XVHG ̋LQ ̋WKH

EDWWOHÔ

x 'HYHORS ̋D ̋GHWDLOHG ̋DVVHVVPHQW ̋DQG ̋LGHQWLILFDWLRQ ̋RI ̋*HQHUDO ̋6ZHHQH\ ̋0XVHXPÒ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN§

UHODWHG ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ FROOHFWLRQV ̋ WR ̋ GHYHORS ̋ DGGLWLRQDO ̋ EDVHOLQH ̋ GDWD ̋ VHW ̋ RQ ̋ ZHDSRQV ̋ DQG

HTXLSPHQW ̋DFWXDOO\ ̋XVHG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋EDWWOHÔ

x 'HYHORS ̋D ̋*,6ðEDVHG ̋PDS ̋RI ̋&LYLO ̋:DU§UHODWHG ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ILQGV ̋ıXWLOL]H ̋'DUUHOO ̋7URJGRQ ̋PDS

LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋*HQHUDO ̋6ZHHQH\ ̋0XVHXPÙ ̋DV ̋EDVHOLQH ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋IRU ̋IXWXUH ̋LQYHVWLJDWLRQVÔ

x 'HYHORS ̋D ̋*,6 ̋PDS ̋OD\HU ̋RI ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋ VROGLHU ̋EXULDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ZLWKLQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋EDVHG ̋RQ ̋6SULQJILHOG

1DWLRQDO ̋&HPHWHU\ ̋GLVLQWHUPHQW ̋UHFRUGV ̋DV ̋D ̋JXLGH ̋WR ̋IXWXUH ̋UHVHDUFK ̋RQ ̋ILQDO ̋WURRS ̋GLVSRVLWLRQÔ

x ,GHQWLI\ ̋ ODQG ̋ RZQHUVKLS ̋ WUDFWV ̋ WKURXJK ̋ WLPH ̋ DQG ̋ GHYHORS ̋ D ̋ *,6 ̋ PDS ̋ OD\HU ̋ WR ̋ DVVLVW ̋ LQ ̋ ORFDWLQJ

SRWHQWLDO ̋KLVWRULFðDJH ̋EXLOGLQJV ̋DQG ̋IHDWXUHVÔ

x 'HYHORS ̋ *,6 ̋ EDVH ̋ PDS ̋ RI ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ DQG ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ VLWHV ̋ DQG ̋ IHDWXUHV ̋ XVLQJ ̋ D

SKRWRJUDPPHWULFDOO\ ̋SURGXFHG ̋PDS ̋DV ̋WKH ̋EDVLVÔ

x 'HYHORS ̋D ̋SDUNZLGH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋ UHVHDUFK ̋ GHVLJQ ̋WR ̋ JXLGH ̋ IXWXUH ̋ SDUN ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋DQG

1DWLRQDO ̋5HJLVWHU ̋HYDOXDWLRQVÔ

x &RQGXFW ̋ SDUNZLGH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ WR ̋ ORFDWH ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ DQG ̋ KLVWRULF ̋ UHVRXUFHVÔ ̋  ̋ 7KH

SDUNZLGH ̋ LQYHQWRU\ ̋ VKRXOG ̋ XVH ̋ VKRYHO ̋ WHVWLQJ ̋ WR ̋ ORFDWH ̋ DQG ̋ HYDOXDWH ̋ SUHKLVWRULF ̋ UHVRXUFHVÒ ̋ DQG

PHWDO ̋GHWHFWLQJ ̋WR ̋LGHQWLI\ ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋FRPSRQHQWVÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋UHVXOW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SDUNZLGH ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋ZLOO ̋EH ̋D

UHSRUW ̋ DQG ̋ D ̋ *,6 ̋ EDVH ̋ PDS ̋ WKDW ̋ LQFOXGHV ̋ WKH ̋ LGHQWLILFDWLRQ ̋ DQG ̋ HYDOXDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ DOO ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO

UHVRXUFHV ̋IRU ̋WKH ̋IROORZLQJ ̋SXUSRVHV„

ÏÔ 'HYHORS ̋ D ̋ PRUH ̋ DFFXUDWH ̋ LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ ÏÂÁÏ ̋ EDWWOH ̋ XVLQJ ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ GDWD ̋ DQG

SK\VLFDO ̋HYLGHQFH ̋WR ̋FRQWUDVW ̋DQG ̋FRPSDUH ̋DJDLQVW ̋WKH ̋GRFXPHQWDU\ ̋UHFRUGÔ

ÎÔ 'HILQH ̋WKH ̋IXOO ̋UDQJH ̋RI ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFHV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ

ÍÔ &RPSOHWH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋5HJLVWHU ̋UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV ̋IRU ̋VLJQLILFDQW ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋UHVRXUFHVÔ

ÈÔ ,GHQWLI\ ̋ VLWHV ̋ RU ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ ORFDWLRQV ̋ WKDW ̋ DUH ̋ LPSRUWDQW ̋ RU ̋ VHQVLWLYH ̋ DQG ̋ VKRXOG ̋ EH

DYRLGHG ̋E\ ̋JURXQGðGLVWXUELQJ ̋PDQDJHPHQW ̋DFWLRQVÔ

ËÔ ,GHQWLI\ ̋ DUHDV ̋ FRQWDLQLQJ ̋ QR ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ UHVRXUFHV ̋ WKDW ̋ FDQ ̋ EH ̋ H[FOXGHG ̋ IURP ̋ IXWXUH

FXOWXUDO ̋FRPSOLDQFH ̋LVVXHVÔ

ÁÔ (VWDEOLVK ̋ D ̋ EDVHOLQH ̋ DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋ FRQGLWLRQ ̋ DVVHVVPHQW ̋ WR ̋ PHHW ̋ *35$ ̋ JRDOV ̋ ıÏDÂ ̋ DQG

ÏEÎ$Ù ̋IRU ̋VLWH ̋FRQGLWLRQ ̋DQG ̋PDQDJHPHQWÔ

ÊÔ (VWDEOLVK ̋EDVHOLQH ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWH ̋FRQGLWLRQV ̋WKDW ̋ZLOO ̋DLG ̋ODZ ̋HQIRUFHPHQW ̋LQ ̋DVVHVVLQJ

GDPDJH ̋VKRXOG ̋XQDXWKRUL]HG ̋PHWDO ̋GHWHFWLQJÒ ̋FROOHFWLQJÒ ̋RU ̋GLJJLQJ ̋RFFXU ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋SDUNÔ
ÎÏ

&RQFOXVLRQV

&ROOHFWLQJ ̋DQG ̋DQDO\]LQJ ̋WKH ̋DERYH ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋LV ̋HVVHQWLDO ̋WR ̋WKH ̋ GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋LQGLYLGXDO ̋ VLWH

VLJQLILFDQFH ̋ DW ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÔ ̋ ̋ .QRZOHGJH ̋ RI ̋ VLWH ̋ VLJQLILFDQFH ̋LV ̋LQ ̋WXUQ ̋ FULWLFDO ̋WR ̋ PDNLQJ ̋LQIRUPHG

PDQDJHPHQW ̋ GHFLVLRQV ̋ ZKHQ ̋ HYHQ ̋ VPDOOðVFDOH ̋ FRQVWUXFWLRQ ̋ DQGÓRU ̋ GHYHORSPHQW ̋ DFWLYLWLHV ̋ PXVW ̋ EH

XQGHUWDNHQ ̋ WR ̋ SURYLGH ̋ YLVLWRU ̋ VHUYLFHV ̋ VXFK ̋ DV ̋ QHZ ̋ WUDLOVÒ ̋ HQKDQFH ̋ WKH ̋ YLHZVKHG ̋ WKURXJK ̋ YHJHWDWLYH

PDQLSXODWLRQÒ ̋DQG ̋RWKHU ̋DFWLYLWLHVÔ ̋ ̋*LYHQ ̋WKH ̋H[WHQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋DQG ̋NQRZQ ̋ IHDWXUHVÒ ̋ VXFK ̋DV ̋WKH ̋5D\

+RXVHÒ ̋RYHU ̋WKH ̋HQWLUH ̋ODQGVFDSH ̋FRPSULVLQJ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÒ ̋DOPRVW ̋DQ\ ̋JURXQGðGLVWXUEDQFH ̋DFWLYLW\ ̋DW

DQ\ ̋ORFDWLRQ ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋SDUN ̋ZLOO ̋WHFKQLFDOO\ ̋FRQVWLWXWH ̋DQ ̋XQGHUWDNLQJÒ ̋DQG ̋SDUN ̋VWDII ̋VKRXOG ̋URXWLQHO\ ̋HQJDJH

WKH ̋ 6HFWLRQ ̋ ÏÌÁ ̋ FRPSOLDQFH ̋ SURFHVV ̋ LQ ̋ RUGHU ̋ WR ̋ VHHN ̋ FRQFXUUHQFH ̋ IURP ̋ WKH ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ 6WDWH ̋ +LVWRULF

3UHVHUYDWLRQ ̋2IILFHUÔ

0DQ\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ YLVLWRUV ̋ IURP ̋ WKH ̋ LPPHGLDWH ̋ DUHD ̋ DUH ̋ LQWHUHVWHG ̋ LQ ̋ DUFKHRORJ\Ô ̋  ̋ 2QH ̋ RXWFRPH ̋ RI ̋ D

SDUNZLGH ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋ZRXOG ̋EH ̋D ̋PRUH ̋FRPSOHWH ̋XQGHUVWDQGLQJ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋SUHKLVWRU\ ̋DQG ̋KLVWRU\ ̋RI ̋ODQG ̋XVH ̋LQ

WKH ̋ SDUN ̋ WKURXJK ̋ WLPHÔ ̋  ̋ 7KDW ̋ KLVWRU\ ̋ FRXOG ̋ EH ̋ WROG ̋ LQ ̋ D ̋ YDULHW\ ̋ RI ̋ PHDQV ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ YLVLWLQJ ̋ SXEOLFÔ ̋  ̋ %\

IRFXVLQJ ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋HIIRUWV ̋RQ ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋%DWWOH ̋RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÒ ̋QHZ ̋LQIRUPDWLRQ ̋RQ ̋ORFDWLRQV ̋RI

FDPSVLWHVÒ ̋EDWWOH ̋OLQHVÒ ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋PRYHPHQW ̋RI ̋WURRSV ̋GXULQJ ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋PD\ ̋EH ̋IRUWKFRPLQJÔ ̋ ̋7KH ̋DUWLIDFWV

UHVXOWLQJ ̋IURP ̋WKH ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋PD\ ̋YHU\ ̋ZHOO ̋DLG ̋LQ ̋SUHVHQWLQJ ̋D ̋PRUH ̋FRPSOHWH ̋SLFWXUH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋EDWWOH ̋WR ̋WKH

YLVLWRU ̋E\ ̋SUHVHQWLQJ ̋WKH ̋SK\VLFDO ̋HYLGHQFH ̋WR ̋WKHPÔ ̋ ̋,Q ̋WXUQ ̋WKH ̋GDWD ̋JHQHUDWHG ̋E\ ̋WKH ̋LQYHQWRU\ ̋FDQ ̋EH

XVHG ̋ E\ ̋ SDUN ̋ LQWHUSUHWHUV ̋ WR ̋ HQKDQFH ̋ WKH ̋ VLWH ̋ LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ ̋ WKURXJK ̋ D ̋ QXPEHU ̋ RI ̋ GLIIHUHQW ̋ PHWKRGV

ıHÔJÔÒ ̋H[KLELWVÒ ̋SHUVRQDO ̋SUHVHQWDWLRQVÒ ̋EURFKXUHVÒ ̋DQG ̋SXEOLFDWLRQVÙÔ
ÎÎ
ÎÍ

5HIHUHQFHV ̋&LWHG

$XVWLQÒ ̋'DYLGÒ ̋DQG ̋:LOOLDP ̋0DUWLQ

Ï‰ÂÂ 3KDVH ̋ , ̋&XOWXUDO ̋5HVRXUFH ̋6XUYH\Ò ̋5RXWH ̋==Ò ̋*UHHQH ̋&RXQW\Ò ̋ -RE ̋1RÔ ̋ ÂÌ ̋==ðÍÊ‰Ô ̋ ̋0LVVRXUL

+LJKZD\ ̋DQG ̋7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ ̋'HSDUWPHQWÒ ̋-HIIHUVRQ ̋&LW\Ô

%HDUVVÒ ̋(GZLQ ̋&Ô

Ï‰ÁÌ 7KH ̋ %DWWOH ̋ RI ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHNÔ ̋  ̋ 8QLWHG ̋ 6WDWHV ̋ 'HSDUWPHQW ̋ RI ̋ ,QWHULRUÒ ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUN ̋ 6HUYLFHÒ

:DVKLQJWRQÒ ̋'Ô&Ô

Ï‰ÊÂ +LVWRULFDO ̋ %DVH ̋ DQG ̋ *URXQG ̋ &RYHU ̋ 0DSÒ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ DQG

&KULVWLDQ ̋&RXQWLHVÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋'HQYHU ̋6HUYLFH ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋'HQYHUÔ

%HQQÒ ̋'DYLG ̋:ÔÒ ̋DQG ̋-DFN ̋+Ô ̋5D\

Ï‰‰Á 7KH ̋3URVSHFW ̋6SULQJ ̋ 6LWH ̋ DQG ̋WKH ̋ 3UREOHP ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋/DWH ̋:RRGODQGÓ0LVVLVVLSSLDQ ̋7UDQVLWLRQ ̋LQ

WKH ̋:HVWHUQ ̋2]DUNVÔ ̋ ̋0LGFRQWLQHQWDO ̋-RXUQDO ̋RI ̋$UFKDHRORJ\ ̋ÎÏıÏÙ„È‰§ÊÂÔ

%UD\Ò ̋5REHUW ̋7Ô

Ï‰ÁÊD $Q ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ DQG ̋ ([FDYDWLRQV ̋ DW ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUNÒ

0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋0DQXVFULSW ̋RQ ̋ILOHÒ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

Ï‰ÁÊE :LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋5HYLVLWHG„ ̋$Q ̋$FFRXQW ̋RI ̋WKH ̋Ï‰ÁÊ ̋([FDYDWLRQVÔ ̋ ̋0DQXVFULSW ̋RQ ̋ILOHÒ ̋1DWLRQDO

3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

Ï‰ÊË ,QYHQWRU\ ̋DQG ̋(YDOXDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFHVÒ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÒ

0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋0DQXVFULSW ̋RQ ̋ILOHÒ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

&HOODUÒ ̋&UDLJ

Ï‰ÊÂ 7ULS ̋ UHSRUWÒ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÔ ̋  ̋ 2Q ̋ ILOHÒ ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUN ̋ 6HUYLFHÒ ̋ 0LGZHVW

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

&KDSPDQÒ ̋&DUO ̋+Ô

Ï‰Ë‰ 7KH ̋ 2ULJLQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 2VDJH ̋ ,QGLDQ ̋ 7ULEH„ ̋ $Q ̋ (WKQRJUDSKLFDOÒ ̋ +LVWRULFDO ̋ DQG ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO

6WXG\Ô ̋ ̋3KÔ'Ô ̋GLVVHUWDWLRQÒ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LFKLJDQÒ ̋$QQ ̋$UERUÔ

Ï‰ÊË 7KH ̋$UFKHRORJ\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋,Ô ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXUL ̋3UHVVÒ ̋&ROXPELDÔ

Ï‰ÂÌ 7KH ̋$UFKHRORJ\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋,,Ô ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXUL ̋3UHVVÒ ̋&ROXPELDÔ

&RROH\Ò ̋5REHUW ̋(ÔÒ ̋DQG ̋0Ô ̋)XOOHU

Ï‰ÊË $Q ̋$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋DQG ̋+LVWRULFDO ̋6XUYH\ ̋ RI ̋$UHDV ̋WR ̋ EH ̋$IIHFWHG ̋ E\ ̋WKH ̋&RQVWUXFWLRQ ̋ RI ̋WKH

-DPHV ̋ 5LYHU ̋ ,QWHUFHSWRU ̋ 6HZHU ̋ LQ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RXQW\Ò ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVHDUFKÒ

6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

&RQQRUÒ ̋0HOLVVD ̋$ÔÒ ̋DQG ̋.HQQHWK ̋3Ô ̋&DQQRQ

Ï‰‰Ï )RUHVW ̋)LUHV ̋DV ̋D ̋6LWH ̋)RUPDWLRQ ̋3URFHVV ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋5RFN\ ̋0RXQWDLQV ̋RI ̋1RUWKZHVWHUQ ̋:\RPLQJÔ

$UFKDHRORJ\ ̋LQ ̋0RQWDQD ̋ÍÎıÎÙ„Ï§ÏÈÔ
ÎÈ

'RXWKLWÒ ̋0DU\ ̋/HH

Ï‰ÂÏ )LQDO ̋ 5HSRUW ̋ RQ ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ ,QYHVWLJDWLRQV ̋ RI ̋ 6LWHV ̋ DORQJ ̋ WKH ̋ -DPHV ̋ 5LYHU ̋ ,QWHUFHSWRU

6HZHUÒ ̋ &LW\ ̋ RI ̋ 6SULQJILHOGÒ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RXQW\Ò ̋ 0LVVRXUL„ ̋ Ï‰Ê‰Ô ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVHDUFKÒ

6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

(LQLQJHUÒ ̋6XVDQ ̋)Ô

Ï‰‰Ì /RQJ ̋0HVD ̋ )LUH ̋ Ï‰Â‰„ ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ DQG ̋ 3RVWð)LUH ̋ $VVHVVPHQWÔ ̋  ̋0DQXVFULSW ̋ RQ ̋ ILOHÒ

0HVD ̋9HUGH ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUNÒ ̋&RORUDGRÔ

)ODQGHUVÒ ̋5REHUWÒ ̋6X]DQQH ̋+DUULVÒ ̋DQG ̋'DYLG ̋4XLFN

Ï‰ÂÏ $ ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ 5HVRXUFHV ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 3URSRVHG ̋ 8QLYHUVLW\ ̋ 3OD]D ̋ 3URMHFW ̋ &LW\ ̋ RI ̋ 6SULQJILHOGÒ

*UHHQH ̋&RXQW\Ò ̋0LVVRXUL„ ̋Ï‰ÂÏÒ ̋3URMHFW ̋&$5ðÈÈÏÔ ̋ ̋Î ̋YROXPHVÔ ̋ ̋&HQWHU ̋IRU ̋$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋5HVHDUFKÒ

6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

*RRG\HDUÒ ̋$OEHUW ̋&Ô

Ï‰ÂÎ 7KH ̋ &KURQRORJLFDO ̋ 3RVLWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 'DOWRQ ̋ +RUL]RQ ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ 6RXWKZHVWHUQ ̋ 8QLWHG ̋ 6WDWHVÔ

$PHULFDQ ̋$QWLTXLW\ ̋ÈÊıÎÙ„ÍÂÎ§Í‰ËÔ

*UDKDPÒ ̋5Ô:ÔÒ ̋&Ô9Ô ̋+D\QHVÒ ̋'Ô ̋/Ô ̋-RKQVRQÒ ̋DQG ̋0Ô ̋.D\

Ï‰ÂÏ .LPPVZLFN„ ̋$ ̋&ORYLVð0DVWRGRQ ̋$VVRFLDWLRQ ̋LQ ̋(DVWHUQ ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋6FLHQFH ̋ÎÏÍ„ÏÏÏË§ÏÏÏÊÔ

*UHPDXGÒ ̋*UHJ

Ï‰ÂÁ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ $ ̋ 3ODQ ̋ IRU ̋ WKH ̋ 5HVWRUDWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ +LVWRULF ̋ 9HJHWDWLRQÔ

0LVVRXUL ̋'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋&RQVHUYDWLRQÒ ̋-HIIHUVRQ ̋&LW\Ò ̋0LVVRXULÔ

+D\HVÒ ̋'DYLG ̋'L[RQ

Ï‰‰‰ $VVHVVPHQW ̋ RI ̋ 'DPDJH ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVRXUFHV ̋ DW ̋ WKH ̋ 5D\ ̋ +RXVHÒ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN

1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋5HSXEOLFÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋%XIIDOR ̋1DWLRQDO ̋5LYHUÒ ̋+DUULVRQÒ ̋$UNDQVDVÔ

+D]HOZRRGÒ ̋/DXUD

Ï‰‰‰ /HJLVODWLYH ̋+LVWRU\ ̋ RI ̋WKH ̋ Ï‰ÁÌ ̋ (QDEOLQJ ̋ $FW ̋ RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ DQG ̋WKH

$PHQGLQJ ̋$FW ̋RI ̋Ï‰ÊÌÔ ̋ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋5HSXEOLFÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ

+HOPÒ ̋&DURO\Q

Ï‰ÂÌ &RQVWUXFWLRQ ̋0RQLWRULQJ ̋RI ̋$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋6LWH ̋ÎÍ*5ÎËÌÒ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOG

3DUNÒ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RXQW\Ò ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVHDUFKÒ ̋ 6RXWKZHVW ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ 6WDWH

8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

+HOPÒ ̋&ÔÒ ̋%Ô-Ô ̋7XUQHUÒ ̋'Ô5Ô ̋4XLFNÒ ̋DQG ̋%Ô ̋3XUULQJWRQ

Ï‰ÂÌ $Q ̋ ,QWHQVLYH ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ 5HVRXUFHV ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ RI ̋ 6LOYHU ̋ 6SULQJV ̋ 3DUN ̋ LQ ̋ 6SULQJILHOGÒ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RÔÒ

0LVVRXUL„ ̋ Ï‰ÂÌÔ ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVHDUFKÒ ̋ 6RXWKZHVW ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ 6WDWH ̋ 8QLYHUVLW\Ò

6SULQJILHOGÔ

+HQVOH\Ò ̋7RP

Ï‰ÂÎ 7ULS ̋ 5HSRUWÒ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ 1RYHPEHU ̋ Â§‰Ô ̋  ̋ 2Q ̋ ILOHÒ ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUN

6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

+XJKHVÒ ̋+DUROG

Ï‰ÂÎ 6RLO ̋6XUYH\ ̋RI ̋*UHHQH ̋DQG ̋/DZUHQFH ̋&RXQWLHVÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋8Ô6Ô ̋'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋$JULFXOWXUHÒ ̋6RLO

&RQVHUYDWLRQ ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋-HIIHUVRQ ̋&LW\Ò ̋0LVVRXULÔ

-HQQLQJVÒ ̋-HVVH ̋'Ô

Ï‰ÊÈ 3UHKLVWRU\ ̋RI ̋1RUWK ̋$PHULFDÔ ̋ ̋ÎQG ̋HGLWLRQÔ ̋ ̋0F*UDZð+LOOÒ ̋1HZ ̋<RUNÔ
ÎË

.LQJÒ ̋)UDQFHV ̋%Ô

Ï‰ÂÌ 3ODQW ̋5HPDLQV ̋IURP ̋3KLOOLSV ̋6SULQJÒ ̋D ̋0XOWLFRPSRQHQW ̋6LWH ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋:HVWHUQ ̋2]DUN ̋+LJKODQG ̋RI

0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋3ODLQV ̋$QWKURSRORJLVW ̋ÎËıÂ‰Ù„ÎÏÊ§ÎÎÊÔ

/\QRWWÒ ̋0DUN ̋-Ô

Ï‰ÂÎ ÎÍ*5ÎËÌ„ ̋ $Q ̋ (DUO\ð0LGGOH ̋ $UFKDLF ̋ 6LWH ̋ DW ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÔ ̋  ̋ 0LVVRXUL

$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋6RFLHW\ ̋1HZVOHWWHUÒ ̋1XPEHU ̋ÍËÊ ̋DQG ̋ÍËÂÔ

Ï‰‰Í 7ULS ̋ 5HSRUWÒ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ )HEUXDU\ ̋ ÏÏ§ÏÍÒ ̋ Ï‰‰ÍÔ ̋  ̋ 2Q ̋ ILOHÒ ̋ 1DWLRQDO

3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

/\QRWWÒ ̋0DUNÒ ̋6Ô0Ô ̋0RQNÒ ̋-Ô-Ô ̋5LFKQHUÒ ̋DQG ̋7Ô5Ô ̋&KHYDQFH

Ï‰ÂÎ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ DQG ̋ 7HVWLQJ ̋ DW ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ 7RXU ̋ 5RDG ̋ $OWHUð

QDWLYHV ̋$Ò ̋%Ò ̋DQG ̋&Ô ̋ ̋5HSRUW ̋RQ ̋ILOHÒ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

0F0LOODQÒ ̋5Ô ̋%UXFH

Ï‰ÊÁ 7KH ̋ '\QDPLFV ̋ RI ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ DQG ̋ (QYLURQPHQWDO ̋ &KDQJH ̋ DW ̋ 5RGJHUV ̋ 6KHOWHUÒ ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ ̋  ̋ ,Q

3UHKLVWRULF ̋ 0DQ ̋ DQG ̋ +LV ̋ (QYLURQPHQWVÒ ̋ HGLWHG ̋ E\ ̋ :Ô5Ô ̋ :RRG ̋ DQG ̋ 5Ô%Ô ̋ 0F0LOODQÒ ̋ SSÔ ̋ ÎÏÏ§ÎÍÈÔ

$FDGHPLF ̋3UHVVÒ ̋1HZ ̋<RUNÔ

0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHU

Ï‰‰‰ 0LGZHVW ̋5HJLRQÒ ̋6\VWHPZLGH ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋,QYHQWRU\ ̋3URJUDP ̋3ODQÔ ̋ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO

&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

0RQNÒ ̋6XVDQ ̋0Ô

Ï‰ÂÍ $ ̋3UHOLPLQDU\ ̋5HSRUW ̋RQ ̋6XUYH\ ̋5HFRQQDLVVDQFH ̋DQG ̋(YDOXDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋3KDVH ̋,, ̋6HFWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH

3URSRVHG ̋ 7RXU ̋ 5RDG ̋ 5LJKWðRIð:D\ ̋ DW ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÔ ̋  ̋ 0DQXVFULSW ̋ RQ ̋ ILOHÒ

1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

Ï‰ÂËD $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ DQG ̋ 7HVWLQJ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ 3URSRVHG ̋ 7RXU ̋ 5RDGÒ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO

%DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋2FFDVLRQDO ̋6WXGLHV ̋LQ ̋$QWKURSRORJ\ ̋1RÔ ̋ÏÏÔ ̋ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

Ï‰ÂËE $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ 7HVWLQJ ̋ DW ̋ WKH ̋ 5D\ ̋ +RXVH„ ̋  ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ

2FFDVLRQDO ̋6WXGLHV ̋LQ ̋$QWKURSRORJ\ ̋1RÔ ̋ÏÌÔ ̋ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ

/LQFROQÔ

Ï‰‰Ì $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋([FDYDWLRQV ̋DW ̋(LJKW ̋6LWHV ̋LQ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÔ ̋ ̋0LFURILFKH

RQ ̋ILOHÒ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFH

Ï‰ÊÁ 'UDIW ̋ (QYLURQPHQWDO ̋ 6WDWHPHQWÒ ̋ 0DVWHU ̋ 3ODQ ̋ :LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ

1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋5HJLRQÒ ̋/LQFROQÒ ̋1HEUDVNDÔ

Ï‰‰Ê 'LUHFWRU©V ̋2UGHU ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÂÒ ̋&XOWXUDO ̋5HVRXUFH ̋0DQDJHPHQW ̋*XLGHOLQHVÒ ̋5HOHDVH ̋1RÔ ̋ËÔ ̋ ̋1DWLRQDO

3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋:DVKLQJWRQÒ ̋'Ô&Ô

1REOHÒ ̋9HUJLO

Ï‰‰È 7ULS ̋ 5HSRUWÒ ̋ 1RYHPEHU ̋ Î‰§'HFHPEHU ̋ ÎÒ ̋ Ï‰‰ÈÔ ̋  ̋ 2Q ̋ ILOHÒ ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUN ̋ 6HUYLFHÒ ̋ 0LGZHVW

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

Ï‰‰Ë 7ULS ̋5HSRUWÒ ̋6HSWHPEHU ̋ÏÍ§ÏËÒ ̋Ï‰‰Ë ̋ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHNÔ ̋ ̋2Q ̋ILOHÒ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ
ÎÁ

2©%ULHQÒ ̋0LFKDHO ̋-ÔÒ ̋DQG ̋:Ô ̋5D\PRQG ̋:RRG

Ï‰‰Â 7KH ̋3UHKLVWRU\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXUL ̋3UHVVÒ ̋&ROXPELDÔ

3DUPDOHHÒ ̋3DXO ̋:Ô

Ï‰ÁË 7KH ̋ )RRG ̋ (FRQRP\ ̋ RI ̋ $UFKDLF ̋ DQG ̋ :RRGODQG ̋ 3HRSOHV ̋ DW ̋ 7LFN ̋ &UHHN ̋ &DYH ̋ 6LWHÒ ̋ 0LVVRXULÔ

7KH ̋0LVVRXUL ̋$UFKHRORJLVW ̋ÎÊ„Ï§ÍÈÔ

3IOLHJHUÒ ̋:LOOLDP ̋/Ô

Ï‰ÊË 7KH ̋)LVKHV ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋&RQVHUYDWLRQÒ ̋-HIIHUVRQ ̋&LW\Ò ̋0LVVRXULÔ

3LVWRQÒ ̋:LOOLDP ̋*DUUHWWÒ ̋DQG ̋5LFKDUG ̋:Ô ̋+DWFKHU ̋,,,

ÎÌÌÌ :LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN„ ̋7KH ̋6HFRQG ̋%DWWOH ̋RI ̋WKH ̋&LYLO ̋:DU ̋DQG ̋WKH ̋0HQ ̋:KR ̋)RXJKW ̋,WÔ ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI

1RUWK ̋&DUROLQD ̋3UHVVÒ ̋&KDSHO ̋+LOOÒ ̋1RUWK ̋&DUROLQDÔ

3ULFHÒ ̋&\QWKLD ̋5Ô

Ï‰Ê‰ $Q ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDOÒ ̋ +LVWRULFDOÒ ̋ DQG ̋ $UFKLWHFWXUDO ̋ /LWHUDWXUH ̋ 5HYLHZ ̋ IRU ̋ D ̋ 3RUWLRQ ̋ RI ̋ 0DUN

7ZDLQ ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ )RUHVW ̋ DQG ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ 5HVRXUFHV ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ RI ̋ ÂË ̋ 'ULOO ̋ 6LWHV ̋ LQ ̋ 0DUN ̋ 7ZDLQ ̋ 1DWLRQDO

)RUHVWÒ ̋ &RQGXFWHG ̋ IRU ̋ $VDUFRÒ ̋ 0LVVRXUL„ ̋ Ï‰Ê‰Ô ̋  ̋ 3URMHFW ̋ 5HSRUW ̋ ÎÎÍÔ ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO

5HVHDUFKÒ ̋6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

3ULFHÒ ̋-DPHV ̋(ÔÒ ̋DQG ̋-Ô-Ô ̋.UDNNHU

Ï‰ÊË 'DOWRQ ̋2FFXSDWLRQ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋2]DUN ̋%RUGHUÔ ̋ ̋0XVHXP ̋%ULHIV ̋1RÔ ̋ÎÌÔ ̋ ̋0XVHXP ̋RI ̋$QWKURSRORJ\Ò

8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋&ROXPELDÔ

5DIIHUW\Ò ̋0LOWRQ ̋'DOH

Ï‰ÊÌ 3HUVLVWHQFH ̋9HUVXV ̋&KDQJH ̋LQ ̋/DQG ̋8VH ̋DQG ̋/DQGVFDSH ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋6SULQJILHOGÒ ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋9LFLQLW\ ̋RI

WKH ̋2]DUNVÔ ̋ ̋3KÔ'Ô ̋GLVVHUWDWLRQÒ ̋'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋*HRJUDSK\Ò ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋1HEUDVNDð/LQFROQÔ

5D\Ò ̋-DFN ̋+Ô

Ï‰‰Ë $Q ̋$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋,QYHVWLJDWLRQ ̋DW ̋-RKQ ̋3DXO ̋&DYH ̋ ıÎÍ&1ÊËÂÙ ̋LQ ̋1RUWKHUQ ̋&KULVWLDQ ̋&RXQW\Ò

0LVVRXULÒ ̋3URMHFW ̋&$5ð‰ÊÊÔ ̋ ̋&HQWHU ̋IRU ̋$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋5HVHDUFKÒ ̋6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUð

VLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

Ï‰‰Ê $GGLWLRQDO ̋([FDYDWLRQV ̋DW ̋-RKQ ̋3DXO ̋&DYH ̋ıÎÍ&1ÊËÂÙ ̋LQ ̋1RUWKHUQ ̋&KULVWLDQ ̋&RXQW\Ò ̋0LVVRXULÒ

3URMHFW ̋ &$5ðÏÌÎÎÔ ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVHDUFKÒ ̋ 6RXWKZHVW ̋ 0LVVRXUL ̋ 6WDWH ̋ 8QLYHUVLW\Ò

6SULQJILHOGÔ

Ï‰‰‰ $Q ̋ ,QWHQVLYH ̋&XOWXUDO ̋5HVRXUFHV ̋6XUYH\ ̋ IRU ̋3URSRVHG ̋ ,PSURYHPHQWV ̋ RI ̋5HSXEOLF ̋:DVWHZDWHU

)DFLOLWLHVÒ ̋ *UHHQH ̋ &RXQW\Ò ̋ 0LVVRXULÒ ̋ 3URMHFW ̋ &$5ðÏÌÂÊÔ ̋  ̋ &HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋ $UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋ 5HVHDUFKÒ

6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

5D\Ò ̋-DFN ̋+ÔÒ ̋%HWW\ ̋-DQH ̋7XUQHUÒ ̋DQG ̋'DYLG ̋:Ô ̋%HQQ

Ï‰ÂÈ $Q ̋ ,QWHQVLYH ̋ &XOWXUDO ̋ 5HVRXUFHV ̋ 6XUYH\ ̋ RI ̋ WKH ̋ %DWWOHILHOG ̋ 6XEXUEDQ ̋ 'HYHORSPHQW ̋ =RQHÒ

*UHHQH ̋&RXQW\Ò ̋0LVVRXUL„ ̋Ï‰ÂÈÒ ̋3URMHFW ̋&$5ðËÂÎÔ ̋ ̋&HQWHU ̋ IRU ̋$UFKDHRORJLFDO ̋5HVHDUFKÒ ̋6RXWKZHVW

0LVVRXUL ̋6WDWH ̋8QLYHUVLW\Ò ̋6SULQJILHOGÔ

5HDJDQÒ ̋0Ô-ÔÒ ̋5Ô0Ô ̋5RZOHWWÒ ̋:Ô ̋'RUWÒ ̋-UÔÒ ̋9Ô0Ô ̋%U\DQWÒ ̋-UÔÒ ̋DQG ̋&Ô-Ô ̋-RKDQQVHQ

Ï‰ÊÂ )ODNH ̋7RROV ̋6WUDWLILHG ̋%HORZ ̋3DOHRð,QGLDQ ̋$UWLIDFWVÔ ̋ ̋6FLHQFH ̋ÎÌÌ„ÏÎÊÎ§ÏÎÊËÔ

5RSHUÒ ̋'RQQD ̋&Ô

Ï‰Ê‰ 7KH ̋:RRGODQG ̋ 3HULRG ̋ LQ ̋ WKH ̋ 2]DUNV„ ̋  ̋ 7KH ̋ &RQFHSWÒ ̋ LWV ̋ +LVWRU\Ò ̋ DQG ̋ LWV ̋ 3ODFH ̋ LQ ̋ 3UHKLVWRU\Ô

3DSHU ̋SUHVHQWHG ̋DW ̋WKH ̋ÍÊWK ̋ ̋3ODLQV ̋&RQIHUHQFHÒ ̋1RYHPEHU ̋Ï‰Ê‰Ò ̋.DQVDV ̋&LW\Ò ̋0LVVRXULÔ
ÎÊ

6DXHUÒ ̋&DUO ̋2Ô

Ï‰ÎÌ *HRJUDSK\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋2]DUN ̋+LJKODQG ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋&KLFDJR ̋3UHVVÒ ̋&KLFDJRÔ

6D\OHUÒ ̋5RGQH\ ̋'ÔÒ ̋5REHUW ̋:Ô ̋6HDEORRPÒ ̋DQG ̋6WDQOH\ ̋$Ô ̋$KOHU

Ï‰Â‰ ,PSDFWV ̋RI ̋3UHVFULEHG ̋%XUQLQJ ̋RQ ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋DQG ̋%LRORJLFDO ̋5HVRXUFHV ̋RI ̋WKH ̋.QLIH ̋5LYHU

,QGLDQ ̋9LOODJHV ̋1+6Ô ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋1RUWK ̋'DNRWDÒ ̋*UDQG ̋)RUNVÔ

6FKZDUW]Ò ̋&Ô:ÔÒ ̋DQG ̋(Ô5Ô ̋6FKZDUW]

Ï‰ÂÏ 7KH ̋:LOG ̋0DPPDOV ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋5HYLVHG ̋HGLWLRQÔ ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXUL ̋3UHVV ̋DQG ̋0LVVRXUL

'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋&RQVHUYDWLRQÒ ̋&ROXPELDÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ

6WH\HUPDUNÒ ̋-Ô$Ô

Ï‰Ë‰ 9HJHWDWLRQDO ̋+LVWRU\ ̋RI ̋WKH ̋2]DUN ̋)RUHVWÔ ̋ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXUL ̋6WXGLHV ̋1RÔ ̋ÍÏÔ

6WÔ ̋/RXLV„ ̋:HVWHUQ ̋+LVWRULFDO ̋&RPSDQ\

ÏÂÂÍ +LVWRU\ ̋RI ̋*UHHQH ̋&RXQW\Ô ̋ ̋1L[RQð-RQHV ̋3ULQWLQJ ̋&RPSDQ\Ò ̋6WÔ ̋/RXLVÔ

6XGGHUWKÒ ̋:Ô ̋(Ô

Ï‰‰Î 7KH ̋ Ï‰ÂÍ ̋ $UFKHRORJLFDO ̋ ([FDYDWLRQV ̋ DW ̋WKH ̋ 5D\ ̋ +RXVHÒ ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋ %DWWOHILHOGÒ

0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋7HFKQLFDO ̋5HSRUW ̋1RÔ ̋ÏËÔ ̋ ̋1DWLRQDO ̋3DUN ̋6HUYLFHÒ ̋0LGZHVW ̋$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ

8Ô6Ô ̋'HSDUWPHQW ̋RI ̋$JULFXOWXUH

Ï‰Ê‰ 6RLO ̋6XUYH\ ̋RI ̋*UHHQH ̋DQG ̋/DZUHQFH ̋&RXQWLHVÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋-HIIHUVRQ ̋&LW\Ò ̋0LVVRXULÔ

9HKLNÒ ̋5DLQ

Ï‰ÊÂ $Q ̋$QDO\VLV ̋RI ̋&XOWXUDO ̋9DULDELOLW\ ̋GXULQJ ̋WKH ̋/DWH ̋:RRGODQG ̋3HULRG ̋LQ ̋WKH ̋2]DUN ̋+LJKODQG ̋RI

6RXWKZHVW ̋0LVVRXULÔ ̋ ̋3KÔ'Ô ̋GLVVHUWDWLRQÒ ̋8QLYHUVLW\ ̋RI ̋0LVVRXULÒ ̋&ROXPELDÒ ̋0LVVRXULÔ

:LOOH\Ò ̋3ÔÒ ̋3DXOHWWH ̋/HDFKÒ ̋DQG ̋'HDQQD ̋*ULPVWHDG

Ï‰‰‰ $QDO\VLV ̋ RI ̋ +XPDQ ̋ %RQHV ̋ $WWULEXWHG ̋ WR ̋ WKH ̋ &LYLO ̋:DU ̋ %DWWOH ̋ RI ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋ &UHHN„ ̋ 7KH ̋ .HUUð

*OLGZHOO ̋ DQG ̋ 0DQLRQ©V ̋ $XFWLRQ ̋ &ROOHFWLRQVÔ ̋  ̋ 5HSRUW ̋ RQ ̋ ILOHÒ ̋ 1DWLRQDO ̋ 3DUN ̋ 6HUYLFHÒ ̋ 0LGZHVW

$UFKHRORJLFDO ̋&HQWHUÒ ̋/LQFROQÔ
ÎÂ
Î‰

7DEOH ̋ÏÔ ̋ ̋/LVW ̋RI ̋DUFKHRORJLFDO ̋VLWHV ̋UHFRUGHG ̋RU ̋NQRZQ ̋DW ̋:LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋1DWLRQDO ̋%DWWOHILHOGÔ

6LWH ̋1RÔ 6LWH ̋1DPH 7LPH ̋3HULRG 6LWH ̋7\SH

ÎÍ&1ÊÁ 6KDUS ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ&1ÊÊ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ&1ÊÂ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ&1Ê‰ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ&1ÂÌ 3UHKLVWRULF 5RFNVKHOWHUÓOLWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ&1ÂÏ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ&1ÊÌÌ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ&1ÊÌÎ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎÎÊ *LEVRQ ̋0LOO ̋'DP ̋Ï +LVWRULF 'DP

ÎÍ*5ÎÎÂ 6KRUW ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÌ *LEVRQ ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÏ *LEVRQ ̋0LOO ̋'DP ̋Î +LVWRULF 'DP

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÎ *LEVRQ ̋0LOO +LVWRULF 0LOO

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÍ 5D\ ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÈ 6LQNKROH +LVWRULF &LYLO ̋:DU ̋EXULDO ̋ORFDOH

ÎÍ*5ÎÍË *ZLQQ ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÁ :LQQ ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÊ (GZDUGV ̋&DELQ +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍÂ 0DQOH\ ̋&DELQ +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎÍ‰ 0DQOH\ ̋&HPHWHU\ +LVWRULF &HPHWHU\

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÌ %XULDO ̋:HOO +LVWRULF &LYLO ̋:DU ̋EXULDO ̋ORFDOH

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÏ +LVWRULF 5RFN ̋DUW ̋ORFDOH

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÎ /\RQ ̋0HPRULDO +LVWRULF *HQHUDO ̋/\RQ ̋PHPRULDO ̋PDUNHU

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÍ :LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋7RZQ +LVWRULF 7RZQVLWH

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÈ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU
ÍÌ

7DEOH ̋ÏÔ ̋ ̋&RQFOXGHGÔ

6LWH ̋1RÔ 6LWH ̋1DPH 7LPH ̋3HULRG 6LWH ̋7\SH

ÎÍ*5ÎÈË 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÁ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÊ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎÈÂ 3UHKLVWRULF 5RFNVKHOWHUÓOLWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎÈ‰ 6KRUW ̋6LWH 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎËÌ 6KRUW ̋6SULQJ ̋6LWH 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU ̋DQG ̋PLGGHQ

ÎÍ*5ÎËÏ *LEVRQ ̋+RXVH ̋6LWH 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎËÎ *LEVRQ ̋0LOO ̋6LWH 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎËÍ *XLQQ ̋+RXVH ̋6LWH 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎËÈ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÎËË 0DQOH\ ̋+RXVH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÎËÁ *LEVRQ ̋0LOO ̋+HDGUDFH +LVWRULF 0LOO ̋FRPSOH[

ÎÍ*5ÈÍÏ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHUÓ0LGð/DWH ̋$UFKDLF

ÎÍ*5ÁÎ‰ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÁÍÌ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHUÓ/DWH ̋$UFKDLF

ÎÍ*5ÁÍÏ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÁÍÎ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÁÍÁ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÁÍÊ 0DQOH\ ̋0LOO ̋'DP +LVWRULF 'DP ̋FLUFD ̋Ï‰ÍÂ

ÎÍ*5ÁÍÂ 3UHKLVWRULF /LWKLF ̋VFDWWHU

ÎÍ*5ÁÍ‰ 0DQOH\ ̋4XDUU\ +LVWRULF 5RFN ̋TXDUU\

ÎÍ*5ÁÈÌ 6LQNKROHÓ1DWXUDO ̋7UDS 3UHKLVWRULF 1DWXDO ̋VLQNKROH ̋ZLWK ̋IDXQD

ÎÍ*5ÁÂÌ 6KRUWÓ0F.HHO ̋6LWH +LVWRULF )DUP ̋KRXVHÓFRPSOH[

1RW ̋DVVLJQHG :LUH ̋5RDG +LVWRULF +LVWRULF ̋URDG ̋DQG ̋WHOHJUDSK ̋OLQH

1RW ̋DVVLJQHG :LOVRQ©V ̋&UHHN ̋%DWWOHILHOG +LVWRULF &LYLO ̋:DU ̋EDWWOH ̋VLWH
31

Figure 1. Location of Wilsons Creek National Battlefield.
32

Figure 2. The Ray House played a prominent role in the battle and was the site of the

Confederate field hospital.

Figure 3. The Ray Cornfield saw Confederate fire wither a Union advance.
33

Figure 4. Bloody Hill was the scene of some of the most intense fighting of the August

10, 1861, battle.

Figure 5. General Sigels attack on the Confederate rear was halted near this location.
34

Figure 6. Known archeological sites at Wilsons Creek National Battlefield.
35

Figure 7. Darrell Trogdons relic finds around Bloody Hill.
36