Author: Abt Associates Inc. 

Anna Wall

File Updated: 8/4/2010 by Jeff Petrusa (RTI) and Kate Cardamone (EPA)

Purpose:

Data Source: See individual worksheets. 

This worksheet contains: 

Worksheet Description

Wage Rates Hourly labor rates for common personnel likely to be impacted by the rule.

Labor Burden- Option 1 Estimates of the time needed to complete the reporting requirements of Option 1.

Labor Burden- Option 2 Estimates of the time needed to complete the reporting requirements of Option 2.

Labor Burden_Assumptions

Analysis of the number of corporate owners in the Electric Utilities sector estimated to meet MRR 

reporting requirements and of the number of NAICS codes reported to TRI in all sectors.

Labor Burden_>1 Corp. Parent Incremental time needed to complete requirements of recording multiple corporate parents.

Industry Size Number of facilities likely to be affected, by sector.

Analysis- Option 1 Calculations of the total labor burden and cost of complying with the reporting requirements 

under Option 1. 

Analysis- Option 2 Calculations of the total labor burden and cost of complying with the reporting requirements 

under Option 2. 

Summary by Data ElementOp. 1

Summary of estimates of total cost and total labor burden by the Option 1 proposed data 

elements: Ultimate Parent Company Name, Address, and Type of Facility Ownership, Facility 

NAICS Code(s), and Cogeneration.

Summary by Data ElementOp. 2

Summary of estimates of total cost and total labor burden by the Option 2 proposed data 

elements: Ultimate Parent Company Name, Address, and Type of Facility Ownership, Percent and 

Rank of Ownership, Facility NAICS Code(s), and Cogeneration.

Summary by Cost & Labor 

Burden- Op. 1 Summary of estimates for Option 1 proposed data elements by total cost and total labor burden.

Summary by Cost & Labor 

Burden- Op. 2 Summary of estimates for Option 2 proposed data elements by total cost and total labor burden.

Summary for All Sectors Summary of estimates of total cost and total labor burden for all U.S. sectors analyzed. 

Note about Jan 15th update:

the only update to the analysis in the file dated 1.15.10 is the change in the distribution of more 

than one owner. Please note that the change in this ownership table carries through the entire 

analysis by shifting the proportion of facilities with one owner (as shown in the Industry Size tab 

of the worksheet)

Note about Jan 29th update:

This file dated 1.29.10 is a corrected version of the 1.15.10 file. Corrections made to Labor 

Burden Assumptions tabel adjustments to change in the distribution of more than one owner. 

Please note that the change in this ownership table carries through the entire analysis by shifting 

the proportion of facilities with one owner (as shown in the Industry Size tab of the worksheet)

Note about July 21st update:

Added facilties covered under subparts T, FF, II, TT (683 facilities). All facilities assumed to have 

one corporate parent company. Only updated burden and costs under option 2, as this is the 

option EPA has decided to use in the Final Rule.

This workbook contains estimates of the total labor burden and total cost of reporting additional data 

elements for common GHG-emitting sectors

Economic Analysis of Reporting Proposed Facility Identification and Corporate Ownership Data 

Elements for the Mandatory GHG Reporting Rule under 2 Options

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 1 of 28

ReadMe

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Personnel Type Hourly Wage Rate

 electricity manager $88.79

 refinery manager $101.31

 industrial manager $71.03

 lawyer $101.00

Blended Average Management and 

Legal Wage Rate $90.53

Personnel Type Hourly Wage Rate

 electricity engineer/technician $60.84

 refinery engineer/technician $63.89

 industrial engineer/technician $55.20

Average Technical Wage Rate $59.98

Percent of reporting completed by 

Management and Legal Personnel 0.80%

Percent of reporting completed by 

Technical Personnel 99.20%

Blended Wage Rate $60.22

Blended wage rate reflects the proportion of time expected for proposed 

activities for both labor categories. Estimates on the breakdown of personnel 

type burden are approximated from TRI data element specific estimates 

generated as part of the engineering reporting burden analysis: TRI Reporting 

Burden Estimates, Memo from Hilary Eustace, David Cooper, Susan Day to 

Paul Borst, TRIPD,OIAA, OEI, USEPA, July 16, 2004

Management

Average Loaded Hourly Wage Rates by Labor Category

Technical 

Source: U.S. EPA, 2009. Regulatory Impact Analysis for the Mandatory Reporting of 

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Final Rule (GHG Reporting). September.

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 2 of 28

Wage Rates

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Activity (Facilities with 1 Owner) First Year Burden 

(minutes)

Subsequent Year Burden 

(minutes)

3/5/2010 Update to Option 2 Burden; 3/8/2010 added back again on 

20 20 (change value to Zero to turn option back on).

Identify and record parent company address 20 10 0

Total 40 30

Activity First Year Burden 

(minutes)

Subsequent Year Burden 

(minutes)

Identify and record primary NAICS code 10 2.5

Identify and record 2 additional applicable NAICS 20 5

Determine and record cogeneration 10 2.5

Total 40 10

Source: Communication with Shana Harbor and Kate Cardemon, EPA

 "Realistic Burden Estimates for Corporate Identifier and NAICS code" ; revised by Abt Associates. 

Average Reporting Labor Burden Associated with Option 2: Reporting Data 

Elements, by Activity for 1 Ultimate U.S. Corporate Parent

 Labor Burden Associated with Reporting 1 Ultimate U.S. Parent Company and Address

Reporting Labor Burden Associated with NAICS Code(s) and Cogeneration

Identify and record parent company name

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 3 of 28

Labor Burden- Option 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Number of Owners Number of Plants

Percent of Total 

Plants

Percent of Plants 

with more than 1 

Owner

1 1280 86.96%

2 121 8.22% 63.02%

3 29 1.97% 15.10%

4 15 1.02% 7.81%

5 8 0.54% 4.17%

6 7 0.48% 3.65%

7 2 0.14% 1.04%

8 3 0.20% 1.56%

9 1 0.07% 0.52%

10 0 0.00% 0.00%

11 0 0.00% 0.00%

12 2 0.14% 1.04%

13 1 0.07% 0.52%

14 1 0.07% 0.52%

15 0 0.00% 0.00%

16 2 0.14% 1.04%

1.3 3.1

1 3

Source: Energy Information Administration, Annual Electric Generator Report 2007. 

Number of NAICS 

Codes Reported Number of TRI IDs Percent of TRI IDs 

1 18,663 86.04%

2 2,155 9.93%

3 634 2.92%

4 158 0.73%

5 45 0.21%

6 35 0.16%

8 1 0.00%

12 1 0.00%

1.2

98.9%

Number of NAICS 

Codes Reported Number of TRI IDs Percent of TRI IDs 

1 47,187 93.07%

2 2,542 5.01%

3 705 1.39%

4 178 0.35%

5 48 0.09%

6 36 0.07%

8 1 0.00%

12 1 0.00%

1.1

99.5%

Source: TRI Program, Public Data Release. http://www.epa.gov/TRI/tridata/index.htm#pdr

Distribution of Number of NAICS Codes Reported by TRI Facilities 

in RY2008

*Operating or standby plants which are expected to meet MRR requirements (i.e., meet Acid Rain Program 

requirements - 1) burn fossil fuels and 2) have at least one generator unit with a nameplate capacity greater than 

25 megawatts).

Assumptions Underlying Labor Burden Estimates Associated with Option 2: 

Reporting Data Elements, by Activity, for more than 1 Corporate Parent

Average number of owners

Percent of TRI IDs reporting 3 or fewer NAICS codes

Average number of NAICS codes

Distribution of Electric Utility Generator Plants* by Number of Corporate Owners

Average number of owners (rounded)

Distribution of Number of NAICS Codes Reported by TRI Facilities 

in Any Year 

Average number of NAICS codes

Percent of TRI IDs reporting 3 or fewer NAICS codes

Assumptions Underlying Labor Burden Estimates Associated with Options 1 and 2: 

Reporting Facility NAICS code(s)

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 4 of 28

Labor Burden_Assumptions

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Activity First Year Burden 

(minutes)

Subsequent Year Burden 

(minutes)

Identify and record parent company name 10 10

Identify and record parent company address 10 10

Total 20 20

Activity First Year Burden 

(minutes)

Subsequent Year Burden 

(minutes)

Determine and record percent ownership 5 5

Total 5 5

Source: Conversations with Kate Cardamone and Shana Harbour, U.S. EPA

Incremental Labor Burden Associated with Reporting More than 1 Ultimate U.S. Parent 

Company, Address, and Status : Electric Utility Industry

One-time Labor Burden Associated with Reporting More than 1 Ultimate U.S. Parent Company, 

Address, and Status : Electric Utility Industry

Average Incremental Reporting Labor Burden Associated with Option 2: 

Reporting Data Elements, by Activity, for more than 1 Corporate Parent 

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 5 of 28

Labor Burden_>1 Corp. Parent

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry Number of 

Facilities

Estimated 

Percent with 

Single Owner

Estimated 

Percent with 

Multiple Owners 80.92

Stationary Combustion 3,000 100% 0% 799

Landfills 2,551 100% 0%

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,502 100% 0% $40.15 85.31 40.7706236

Electricity Generation 1,108 87% 13% 99% 1%

Pulp and Paper 425 100% 0%

Vehicle Manufacturers 0 100% 0% 3/8/2010 Mobile sources were removed from analysis

Petroleum Product Suppliers 315 100% 0%

GHG Suppliers 167 100% 0%

Petroleum Refineries 150 100% 0%

Iron and Steel 121 100% 0%

Manure 0 100% 0%

Cement 107 100% 0%

Lime 89 100% 0%

Petrochemical 80 100% 0%

Glass 55 100% 0%

Nitric Acid 45 100% 0%

Hydrogen 41 100% 0%

Ammonia 23 100% 0%

Phosphoric Acid 14 100% 0%

Aluminum 14 100% 0%

CO2 Suppliers 13 100% 0%

Lead 13 100% 0%

Ferroalloy 9 100% 0%

Titanium oxide 8 100% 0%

Zinc 5 100% 0%

Soda Ash 5 100% 0%

Adipic Acid 4 100% 0%

HCFC-22 3 100% 0%

Silicon Carbide 1 100% 0%

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 683 100% 0% 7/21/2010 - Add facilities that report under recently finalized subparts (see 75 FR 39736; July 12, 2010)

Total 10,551

Source: U.S. EPA. “Final Mandatory Greenhouse Gas Reporting Rule: Overview.” Powerpoint 

Presentation. October 5, 2009

Number of Facilities Likely to be Required to Report GHG Emissions, by Industry

Energy Information Administration. Annual Electric Generators Report 2007, Form 860 

data. http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/page/eia860.html

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 6 of 28

Industry Size

DRAFT 

9/8/2010
20 1 1

Industry First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 120,000 90,000 0 0 120,000 90,000 2,000.00 1,500.00 $120,438.35 $90,328.76

Landfills 102,040 76,530 0 0 102,040 76,530 1,700.67 1,275.50 $102,412.74 $76,809.56

Natural Gas Suppliers 60,080 45,060 0 0 60,080 45,060 1,001.33 751.00 $60,299.47 $45,224.60

Electricity Generation 38,539 28,904 12,284 10,839 50,823 39,743 847.06 662.39 $51,009.13 $39,888.66

Pulp and Paper 17,000 12,750 0 0 17,000 12,750 283.33 212.50 $17,062.10 $12,796.57

Vehicle Manufacturers 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 12,600 9,450 0 0 12,600 9,450 210.00 157.50 $12,646.03 $9,484.52

GHG Suppliers 6,680 5,010 0 0 6,680 5,010 111.33 83.50 $6,704.40 $5,028.30

Petroleum Refineries 6,000 4,500 0 0 6,000 4,500 100.00 75.00 $6,021.92 $4,516.44

Iron and Steel 4,840 3,630 0 0 4,840 3,630 80.67 60.50 $4,857.68 $3,643.26

Manure 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 4,280 3,210 0 0 4,280 3,210 71.33 53.50 $4,295.63 $3,221.73

Lime 3,560 2,670 0 0 3,560 2,670 59.33 44.50 $3,573.00 $2,679.75

Petrochemical 3,200 2,400 0 0 3,200 2,400 53.33 40.00 $3,211.69 $2,408.77

Glass 2,200 1,650 0 0 2,200 1,650 36.67 27.50 $2,208.04 $1,656.03

Nitric Acid 1,800 1,350 0 0 1,800 1,350 30.00 22.50 $1,806.58 $1,354.93

Hydrogen 1,640 1,230 0 0 1,640 1,230 27.33 20.50 $1,645.99 $1,234.49

Ammonia 920 690 0 0 920 690 15.33 11.50 $923.36 $692.52

Phosphoric Acid 560 420 0 0 560 420 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

Aluminum 560 420 0 0 560 420 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

CO2 Suppliers 520 390 0 0 520 390 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Lead 520 390 0 0 520 390 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Ferroalloy 360 270 0 0 360 270 6.00 4.50 $361.32 $270.99

Titanium oxide 320 240 0 0 320 240 5.33 4.00 $321.17 $240.88

Zinc 200 150 0 0 200 150 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Soda Ash 200 150 0 0 200 150 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Adipic Acid 160 120 0 0 160 120 2.67 2.00 $160.58 $120.44

HCFC-22 120 90 0 0 120 90 2.00 1.50 $120.44 $90.33

Silicon Carbide 40 30 0 0 40 30 0.67 0.50 $40.15 $30.11

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 27,320 20,490 0 0 27,320 20,490 455.33 341.50 $27,419.80 $20,564.85

Total 416,259 312,194 12,284 10,839 428,543 323,033 7,142.39 5,383.89 $430,108.90 $324,213.48

Analysis of Total Labor Burden and Total Cost Associated with Option 2: Reporting Parent Company Name(s), Address(es), Percent Ownership, Facility 

NAICS Code, and Cogeneration

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Parent Company Name, Address, and Percent Ownership

Labor Burden (minutes): 

 1 corporate parent Total Labor Burden (minutes) Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Cost Labor Burden (minutes):  >1 corporate parent

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 7 of 28

Analysis- Option 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 120,000 30,000 2,000.00 500.00 $120,438.35 $30,109.59

Landfills 102,040 25,510 1,700.67 425.17 $102,412.74 $25,603.19

Natural Gas Suppliers 60,080 15,020 1,001.33 250.33 $60,299.47 $15,074.87

Electricity Generation 44,320 11,080 738.67 184.67 $44,481.90 $11,120.47

Pulp and Paper 17,000 4,250 283.33 70.83 $17,062.10 $4,265.52

Vehicle Manufacturers 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 12,600 3,150 210.00 52.50 $12,646.03 $3,161.51

GHG Suppliers 6,680 1,670 111.33 27.83 $6,704.40 $1,676.10

Petroleum Refineries 6,000 1,500 100.00 25.00 $6,021.92 $1,505.48

Iron and Steel 4,840 1,210 80.67 20.17 $4,857.68 $1,214.42

Manure 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 4,280 1,070 71.33 17.83 $4,295.63 $1,073.91

Lime 3,560 890 59.33 14.83 $3,573.00 $893.25

Petrochemical 3,200 800 53.33 13.33 $3,211.69 $802.92

Glass 2,200 550 36.67 9.17 $2,208.04 $552.01

Nitric Acid 1,800 450 30.00 7.50 $1,806.58 $451.64

Hydrogen 1,640 410 27.33 6.83 $1,645.99 $411.50

Ammonia 920 230 15.33 3.83 $923.36 $230.84

Phosphoric Acid 560 140 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

Aluminum 560 140 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

CO2 Suppliers 520 130 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Lead 520 130 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Ferroalloy 360 90 6.00 1.50 $361.32 $90.33

Titanium oxide 320 80 5.33 1.33 $321.17 $80.29

Zinc 200 50 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Soda Ash 200 50 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Adipic Acid 160 40 2.67 0.67 $160.58 $40.15

HCFC-22 120 30 2.00 0.50 $120.44 $30.11

Silicon Carbide 40 10 0.67 0.17 $40.15 $10.04

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 27,320 6,830 455.33 113.83 $27,419.80 $6,854.95

Total 422,040 105,510 7,034.00 1,758.50 $423,581.66 $105,895.42

Total Labor Burden (minutes) Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Cost

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Facility NAICS Code(s) and Facility Cogeneration

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 8 of 28

Analysis- Option 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 240,000.00 120,000.00 4,000.00 2,000.00 $240,876.69 $120,438.35

Landfills 204,080.00 102,040.00 3,401.33 1,700.67 $204,825.48 $102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers 120,160.00 60,080.00 2,002.67 1,001.33 $120,598.93 $60,299.47

Electricity Generation 95,143.48 50,823.48 1,585.72 847.06 $95,491.03 $51,009.13

Pulp and Paper 34,000.00 17,000.00 566.67 283.33 $34,124.20 $17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 25,200.00 12,600.00 420.00 210.00 $25,292.05 $12,646.03

GHG Suppliers 13,360.00 6,680.00 222.67 111.33 $13,408.80 $6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries 12,000.00 6,000.00 200.00 100.00 $12,043.83 $6,021.92

Iron and Steel 9,680.00 4,840.00 161.33 80.67 $9,715.36 $4,857.68

Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 8,560.00 4,280.00 142.67 71.33 $8,591.27 $4,295.63

Lime 7,120.00 3,560.00 118.67 59.33 $7,146.01 $3,573.00

Petrochemical 6,400.00 3,200.00 106.67 53.33 $6,423.38 $3,211.69

Glass 4,400.00 2,200.00 73.33 36.67 $4,416.07 $2,208.04

Nitric Acid 3,600.00 1,800.00 60.00 30.00 $3,613.15 $1,806.58

Hydrogen 3,280.00 1,640.00 54.67 27.33 $3,291.98 $1,645.99

Ammonia 1,840.00 920.00 30.67 15.33 $1,846.72 $923.36

Phosphoric Acid 1,120.00 560.00 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum 1,120.00 560.00 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

CO2 Suppliers 1,040.00 520.00 17.33 8.67 $1,043.80 $521.90

Lead 1,040.00 520.00 17.33 8.67 $1,043.80 $521.90

Ferroalloy 720.00 360.00 12.00 6.00 $722.63 $361.32

Titanium oxide 640.00 320.00 10.67 5.33 $642.34 $321.17

Zinc 400.00 200.00 6.67 3.33 $401.46 $200.73

Soda Ash 400.00 200.00 6.67 3.33 $401.46 $200.73

Adipic Acid 320.00 160.00 5.33 2.67 $321.17 $160.58

HCFC-22 240.00 120.00 4.00 2.00 $240.88 $120.44

Silicon Carbide 80.00 40.00 1.33 0.67 $80.29 $40.15

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 54,640.00 27,320.00 910.67 455.33 $54,839.59 $27,419.80

Total 850,583 428,543 14,176.39 7,142.39 $853,690.56 $430,108.90

Total Labor Burden (minutes) Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Cost

Total Labor Burden and Total Cost Associated with Reporting All Proposed Data Elements

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 9 of 28

Analysis- Option 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 1,500.00 $120,438.35 $90,328.76

Landfills 1,700.67 1,275.50 $102,412.74 $76,809.56

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 751.00 $60,299.47 $45,224.60

Electricity Generation 847.06 662.39 $51,009.13 $39,888.66

Pulp and Paper 283.33 212.50 $17,062.10 $12,796.57

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 157.50 $12,646.03 $9,484.52

GHG Suppliers 111.33 83.50 $6,704.40 $5,028.30

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 75.00 $6,021.92 $4,516.44

Iron and Steel 80.67 60.50 $4,857.68 $3,643.26

Manure 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 71.33 53.50 $4,295.63 $3,221.73

Lime 59.33 44.50 $3,573.00 $2,679.75

Petrochemical 53.33 40.00 $3,211.69 $2,408.77

Glass 36.67 27.50 $2,208.04 $1,656.03

Nitric Acid 30.00 22.50 $1,806.58 $1,354.93

Hydrogen 27.33 20.50 $1,645.99 $1,234.49

Ammonia 15.33 11.50 $923.36 $692.52

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

Aluminum 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Lead 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Ferroalloy 6.00 4.50 $361.32 $270.99

Titanium oxide 5.33 4.00 $321.17 $240.88

Zinc 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Soda Ash 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Adipic Acid 2.67 2.00 $160.58 $120.44

HCFC-22 2.00 1.50 $120.44 $90.33

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.50 $40.15 $30.11

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 455.33 341.50 $27,419.80 $20,564.85

Total 7,142.39 5,383.89 $430,108.90 $324,213.48

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Ultimate Parent Company 

Name(s), Address(es), and Percent of Ownership

Industry

Total Burden (hours) Total Cost

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 10 of 28

Summary by Data Element- Op. 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 500.00 $120,438.35 $30,109.59

Landfills 1,700.67 425.17 $102,412.74 $25,603.19

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 250.33 $60,299.47 $15,074.87

Electricity Generation 738.67 184.67 $44,481.90 $11,120.47

Pulp and Paper 283.33 70.83 $17,062.10 $4,265.52

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 52.50 $12,646.03 $3,161.51

GHG Suppliers 111.33 27.83 $6,704.40 $1,676.10

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 25.00 $6,021.92 $1,505.48

Iron and Steel 80.67 20.17 $4,857.68 $1,214.42

Manure 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 71.33 17.83 $4,295.63 $1,073.91

Lime 59.33 14.83 $3,573.00 $893.25

Petrochemical 53.33 13.33 $3,211.69 $802.92

Glass 36.67 9.17 $2,208.04 $552.01

Nitric Acid 30.00 7.50 $1,806.58 $451.64

Hydrogen 27.33 6.83 $1,645.99 $411.50

Ammonia 15.33 3.83 $923.36 $230.84

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

Aluminum 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Lead 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Ferroalloy 6.00 1.50 $361.32 $90.33

Titanium oxide 5.33 1.33 $321.17 $80.29

Zinc 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Soda Ash 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Adipic Acid 2.67 0.67 $160.58 $40.15

HCFC-22 2.00 0.50 $120.44 $30.11

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.17 $40.15 $10.04

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 455.33 113.83 $27,419.80 $6,854.95

Total 7,034.00 1,758.50 $423,581.66 $105,895.42

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration

Industry

Total Burden (hours) Total Cost

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 11 of 28

Summary by Data Element- Op. 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 4,000.00 2,000.00 $240,876.69 $120,438.35

Landfills 3,401.33 1,700.67 $204,825.48 $102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers 2,002.67 1,001.33 $120,598.93 $60,299.47

Electricity Generation 1,585.72 847.06 $95,491.03 $51,009.13

Pulp and Paper 566.67 283.33 $34,124.20 $17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 420.00 210.00 $25,292.05 $12,646.03

GHG Suppliers 222.67 111.33 $13,408.80 $6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries 200.00 100.00 $12,043.83 $6,021.92

Iron and Steel 161.33 80.67 $9,715.36 $4,857.68

Manure 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 142.67 71.33 $8,591.27 $4,295.63

Lime 118.67 59.33 $7,146.01 $3,573.00

Petrochemical 106.67 53.33 $6,423.38 $3,211.69

Glass 73.33 36.67 $4,416.07 $2,208.04

Nitric Acid 60.00 30.00 $3,613.15 $1,806.58

Hydrogen 54.67 27.33 $3,291.98 $1,645.99

Ammonia 30.67 15.33 $1,846.72 $923.36

Phosphoric Acid 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

CO2 Suppliers 17.33 8.67 $1,043.80 $521.90

Lead 17.33 8.67 $1,043.80 $521.90

Ferroalloy 12.00 6.00 $722.63 $361.32

Titanium oxide 10.67 5.33 $642.34 $321.17

Zinc 6.67 3.33 $401.46 $200.73

Soda Ash 6.67 3.33 $401.46 $200.73

Adipic Acid 5.33 2.67 $321.17 $160.58

HCFC-22 4.00 2.00 $240.88 $120.44

Silicon Carbide 1.33 0.67 $80.29 $40.15

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 910.67 455.33 $54,839.59 $27,419.80

Total 14,176.39 7,142.39 $853,690.56 $430,108.90

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting All Proposed Data Elements

Industry

Total Burden (hours) Total Cost

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 12 of 28

Summary by Data Element- Op. 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Estimated Total Labor Burden Associated with Proposed Data Elements, by Year and by Sector

First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 1,500.00 2,000.00 500.00 4,000.00 2,000.00

Landfills 1,700.67 1,275.50 1,700.67 425.17 3,401.33 1,700.67

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 751.00 1,001.33 250.33 2,002.67 1,001.33

Electricity Generation 847.06 662.39 738.67 184.67 1,585.72 847.06

Pulp and Paper 283.33 212.50 283.33 70.83 566.67 283.33

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 157.50 210.00 52.50 420.00 210.00

GHG Suppliers 111.33 83.50 111.33 27.83 222.67 111.33

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 75.00 100.00 25.00 200.00 100.00

Iron and Steel 80.67 60.50 80.67 20.17 161.33 80.67

Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Cement 71.33 53.50 71.33 17.83 142.67 71.33

Lime 59.33 44.50 59.33 14.83 118.67 59.33

Petrochemical 53.33 40.00 53.33 13.33 106.67 53.33

Glass 36.67 27.50 36.67 9.17 73.33 36.67

Nitric Acid 30.00 22.50 30.00 7.50 60.00 30.00

Hydrogen 27.33 20.50 27.33 6.83 54.67 27.33

Ammonia 15.33 11.50 15.33 3.83 30.67 15.33

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 7.00 9.33 2.33 18.67 9.33

Aluminum 9.33 7.00 9.33 2.33 18.67 9.33

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 6.50 8.67 2.17 17.33 8.67

Lead 8.67 6.50 8.67 2.17 17.33 8.67

Ferroalloy 6.00 4.50 6.00 1.50 12.00 6.00

Titanium oxide 5.33 4.00 5.33 1.33 10.67 5.33

Zinc 3.33 2.50 3.33 0.83 6.67 3.33

Soda Ash 3.33 2.50 3.33 0.83 6.67 3.33

Adipic Acid 2.67 2.00 2.67 0.67 5.33 2.67

HCFC-22 2.00 1.50 2.00 0.50 4.00 2.00

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.50 0.67 0.17 1.33 0.67

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 455.33 341.50 455.33 113.83 910.67 455.33

Total 7,142.39 5,383.89 7,034.00 1,758.50 14,176.39 7,142.39

Ultimate Parent Company 

Name, Address, and Percent 

Ownership

Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration All Data Elements

Industry

Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Labor Burden (hours)

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 13 of 28

Summary By Cost & Burden- Op. 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Estimated Total Cost Associated with Proposed Data Elements, by Year and by Sector

First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion $120,438.35 $90,328.76 $120,438.35 $30,109.59 $240,876.69 $120,438.35

Landfills $102,412.74 $76,809.56 $102,412.74 $25,603.19 $204,825.48 $102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers $60,299.47 $45,224.60 $60,299.47 $15,074.87 $120,598.93 $60,299.47

Electricity Generation $51,009.13 $39,888.66 $44,481.90 $11,120.47 $95,491.03 $51,009.13

Pulp and Paper $17,062.10 $12,796.57 $17,062.10 $4,265.52 $34,124.20 $17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers $12,646.03 $9,484.52 $12,646.03 $3,161.51 $25,292.05 $12,646.03

GHG Suppliers $6,704.40 $5,028.30 $6,704.40 $1,676.10 $13,408.80 $6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries $6,021.92 $4,516.44 $6,021.92 $1,505.48 $12,043.83 $6,021.92

Iron and Steel $4,857.68 $3,643.26 $4,857.68 $1,214.42 $9,715.36 $4,857.68

Manure $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement $4,295.63 $3,221.73 $4,295.63 $1,073.91 $8,591.27 $4,295.63

Lime $3,573.00 $2,679.75 $3,573.00 $893.25 $7,146.01 $3,573.00

Petrochemical $3,211.69 $2,408.77 $3,211.69 $802.92 $6,423.38 $3,211.69

Glass $2,208.04 $1,656.03 $2,208.04 $552.01 $4,416.07 $2,208.04

Nitric Acid $1,806.58 $1,354.93 $1,806.58 $451.64 $3,613.15 $1,806.58

Hydrogen $1,645.99 $1,234.49 $1,645.99 $411.50 $3,291.98 $1,645.99

Ammonia $923.36 $692.52 $923.36 $230.84 $1,846.72 $923.36

Phosphoric Acid $562.05 $421.53 $562.05 $140.51 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum $562.05 $421.53 $562.05 $140.51 $1,124.09 $562.05

CO2 Suppliers $521.90 $391.42 $521.90 $130.47 $1,043.80 $521.90

Lead $521.90 $391.42 $521.90 $130.47 $1,043.80 $521.90

Ferroalloy $361.32 $270.99 $361.32 $90.33 $722.63 $361.32

Titanium oxide $321.17 $240.88 $321.17 $80.29 $642.34 $321.17

Zinc $200.73 $150.55 $200.73 $50.18 $401.46 $200.73

Soda Ash $200.73 $150.55 $200.73 $50.18 $401.46 $200.73

Adipic Acid $160.58 $120.44 $160.58 $40.15 $321.17 $160.58

HCFC-22 $120.44 $90.33 $120.44 $30.11 $240.88 $120.44

Silicon Carbide $40.15 $30.11 $40.15 $10.04 $80.29 $40.15

Subparts T, FF, II, TT $27,419.80 $20,564.85 $27,419.80 $6,854.95 $54,839.59 $27,419.80

Total $430,108.90 $324,213.48 $423,581.66 $105,895.42 $853,690.56 $430,108.90

Industry

Total Cost Total Cost Total Cost

Ultimate Parent Company 

Name, Address, and Percent 

Ownership

Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration All Data Elements

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 14 of 28

Summary By Cost & Burden- Op. 2

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Option 1: Summary of Total Labor Burden and Total Cost Associated with Proposed Data Elements for First and Subsequent Years 

Ultimate Parent Company Name, 

Address, Type of Ownership, and 

Percent Ownership

6,579 $396,162

$37.55

NAICS Code(s) and Cogeneration 6,579 $396,162 $37.55

All Data Elements 13,157 $792,324 $75.09

Ultimate Parent Company Name, 

Address, Type of Ownership, and 

Percent Ownership

4,934 $297,121

$28.16

NAICS Code(s) and Cogeneration 1,645 $99,040 $9.39

All Data Elements 6,579 $396,162 $37.55

EIA Table 4-3

Option 2: Summary of Total Labor Burden and Total Cost Associated with Proposed Data Elements for First and Subsequent Years 

Total Labor 

Burden (hours) Total Cost Cost per Facility

U.S. Parent Company Name, Address, 

and Percent Ownership 7,142 $430,109 $40.76

NAICS Code(s) and Cogeneration 7,034 $423,582 $40.15

All Data Elements 14,176 $853,691 $80.91

U.S. Parent Company Name, Address, 

and Percent Ownership 5,384 $324,213 $30.73

NAICS Code(s) and Cogeneration 1,759 $105,895 $10.04

All Data Elements 7,142 $430,109 $40.76

First Reporting Year

Subsequent Reporting Years

Cost per 

Facility

First Reporting Year

Subsequent Reporting Years

Total Labor 

Burden (hours) Total Cost

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 15 of 28

Summary for All Sectors DRAFT

9/8/2010
NOTE: Option 1 was proposed but not finalized. See Option 2 for estimates relevant to final rule.

Activity First Year Burden 

(minutes)

Subsequent Year Burden 

(minutes)

Identify and record parent company name 10 10

Identify and record parent company address 10 10

Determine and record type of company ownership 20 10

Total 40 30

Activity First Year Burden 

(minutes)

Subsequent Year Burden 

(minutes)

Identify and record primary NAICS code 10 2.5

Identify and record 2 additional applicable NAICS 

codes 20 5

Identify and record cogeneration 10 2.5

Total 40 10

Source: Communication with Shana Harbor and Kate Cardemon, EPA

 "Realistic Burden Estimates for Corporate Identifier and NAICS code" ; revised by Abt Associates. 

 Labor Burden Associated with Reporting 1 Ultimate U.S. Parent Company, Address, 

and Type of Ownership

Reporting Labor Burden Associated with Primary NAICS Code and Cogeneration

Average Reporting Labor Burden Associated with Option 1: Reporting Data 

Elements, by Activity for 1 Ultimate U.S. Corporate Parent

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 16 of 28

Labor Burden- Option 1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
NOTE: Option 1 was proposed but not finalized. See Option 2 for estimates relevant to final rule.

Industry First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 120,000 90,000 2,000.00 1,500.00 $120,438.35 $90,328.76

Landfills 102,040 76,530 1,700.67 1,275.50 $102,412.74 $76,809.56

Natural Gas Suppliers 60,080 45,060 1,001.33 751.00 $60,299.47 $45,224.60

Electricity Generation 44,320 33,240 738.67 554.00 $44,481.90 $33,361.42

Pulp and Paper 17,000 12,750 283.33 212.50 $17,062.10 $12,796.57

Vehicle Manufacturers 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 12,600 9,450 210.00 157.50 $12,646.03 $9,484.52

GHG Suppliers 6,680 5,010 111.33 83.50 $6,704.40 $5,028.30

Petroleum Refineries 6,000 4,500 100.00 75.00 $6,021.92 $4,516.44

Iron and Steel 4,840 3,630 80.67 60.50 $4,857.68 $3,643.26

Manure 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 4,280 3,210 71.33 53.50 $4,295.63 $3,221.73

Lime 3,560 2,670 59.33 44.50 $3,573.00 $2,679.75

Petrochemical 3,200 2,400 53.33 40.00 $3,211.69 $2,408.77

Glass 2,200 1,650 36.67 27.50 $2,208.04 $1,656.03

Nitric Acid 1,800 1,350 30.00 22.50 $1,806.58 $1,354.93

Hydrogen 1,640 1,230 27.33 20.50 $1,645.99 $1,234.49

Ammonia 920 690 15.33 11.50 $923.36 $692.52

Phosphoric Acid 560 420 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

Aluminum 560 420 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

CO2 Suppliers 520 390 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Lead 520 390 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Ferroalloy 360 270 6.00 4.50 $361.32 $270.99

Titanium oxide 320 240 5.33 4.00 $321.17 $240.88

Zinc 200 150 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Soda Ash 200 150 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Adipic Acid 160 120 2.67 2.00 $160.58 $120.44

HCFC-22 120 90 2.00 1.50 $120.44 $90.33

Silicon Carbide 40 30 0.67 0.50 $40.15 $30.11

Total 394,720 296,040 6,578.67 4,934.00 $396,161.87 $297,121.40

Analysis of Total Labor Burden and Total Cost Associated with Option 1: Reporting Parent Company 

Name, Address, Type of Ownership, Facility NAICS Code, and Cogeneration

Total Labor Burden (hours)

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Parent Company Name, Address, Type of 

Ownership, and Percent Ownership

Total Labor Burden 

(minutes) Total Cost

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 17 of 28

Analysis- Option 1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 120,000 30,000 2,000.00 500.00 $120,438.35 $30,109.59

Landfills 102,040 25,510 1,700.67 425.17 $102,412.74 $25,603.19

Natural Gas Suppliers 60,080 15,020 1,001.33 250.33 $60,299.47 $15,074.87

Electricity Generation 44,320 11,080 738.67 184.67 $44,481.90 $11,120.47

Pulp and Paper 17,000 4,250 283.33 70.83 $17,062.10 $4,265.52

Vehicle Manufacturers 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 12,600 3,150 210.00 52.50 $12,646.03 $3,161.51

GHG Suppliers 6,680 1,670 111.33 27.83 $6,704.40 $1,676.10

Petroleum Refineries 6,000 1,500 100.00 25.00 $6,021.92 $1,505.48

Iron and Steel 4,840 1,210 80.67 20.17 $4,857.68 $1,214.42

Manure 0 0 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 4,280 1,070 71.33 17.83 $4,295.63 $1,073.91

Lime 3,560 890 59.33 14.83 $3,573.00 $893.25

Petrochemical 3,200 800 53.33 13.33 $3,211.69 $802.92

Glass 2,200 550 36.67 9.17 $2,208.04 $552.01

Nitric Acid 1,800 450 30.00 7.50 $1,806.58 $451.64

Hydrogen 1,640 410 27.33 6.83 $1,645.99 $411.50

Ammonia 920 230 15.33 3.83 $923.36 $230.84

Phosphoric Acid 560 140 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

Aluminum 560 140 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

CO2 Suppliers 520 130 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Lead 520 130 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Ferroalloy 360 90 6.00 1.50 $361.32 $90.33

Titanium oxide 320 80 5.33 1.33 $321.17 $80.29

Zinc 200 50 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Soda Ash 200 50 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Adipic Acid 160 40 2.67 0.67 $160.58 $40.15

HCFC-22 120 30 2.00 0.50 $120.44 $30.11

Silicon Carbide 40 10 0.67 0.17 $40.15 $10.04

Total 394,720 98,680 6,578.67 1,644.67 $396,161.87 $99,040.47

Total Labor Burden (hours)

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Facility NAICS Code and Facility Cogeneration

Total Labor Burden (minutes) Total Cost

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 18 of 28

Analysis- Option 1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 240,000.00 120,000.00 4,000.00 2,000.00 $240,876.69 $120,438.35

Landfills 204,080.00 102,040.00 3,401.33 1,700.67 $204,825.48 $102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers 120,160.00 60,080.00 2,002.67 1,001.33 $120,598.93 $60,299.47

Electricity Generation 88,640.00 44,320.00 1,477.33 738.67 $88,963.79 $44,481.90

Pulp and Paper 34,000.00 17,000.00 566.67 283.33 $34,124.20 $17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 25,200.00 12,600.00 420.00 210.00 $25,292.05 $12,646.03

GHG Suppliers 13,360.00 6,680.00 222.67 111.33 $13,408.80 $6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries 12,000.00 6,000.00 200.00 100.00 $12,043.83 $6,021.92

Iron and Steel 9,680.00 4,840.00 161.33 80.67 $9,715.36 $4,857.68

Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 8,560.00 4,280.00 142.67 71.33 $8,591.27 $4,295.63

Lime 7,120.00 3,560.00 118.67 59.33 $7,146.01 $3,573.00

Petrochemical 6,400.00 3,200.00 106.67 53.33 $6,423.38 $3,211.69

Glass 4,400.00 2,200.00 73.33 36.67 $4,416.07 $2,208.04

Nitric Acid 3,600.00 1,800.00 60.00 30.00 $3,613.15 $1,806.58

Hydrogen 3,280.00 1,640.00 54.67 27.33 $3,291.98 $1,645.99

Ammonia 1,840.00 920.00 30.67 15.33 $1,846.72 $923.36

Phosphoric Acid 1,120.00 560.00 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum 1,120.00 560.00 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

CO2 Suppliers 1,040.00 520.00 17.33 8.67 $1,043.80 $521.90

Lead 1,040.00 520.00 17.33 8.67 $1,043.80 $521.90

Ferroalloy 720.00 360.00 12.00 6.00 $722.63 $361.32

Titanium oxide 640.00 320.00 10.67 5.33 $642.34 $321.17

Zinc 400.00 200.00 6.67 3.33 $401.46 $200.73

Soda Ash 400.00 200.00 6.67 3.33 $401.46 $200.73

Adipic Acid 320.00 160.00 5.33 2.67 $321.17 $160.58

HCFC-22 240.00 120.00 4.00 2.00 $240.88 $120.44

Silicon Carbide 80.00 40.00 1.33 0.667 $80.29 $40.15

Total 789,440 394,720 13,157.33 6,578.67 $792,323.74 $396,161.87

Total Labor Burden (minutes) Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Cost

Total Labor Burden and Total Cost Associated with Reporting All Proposed Data Elements: 

Option 1

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 19 of 28

Analysis- Option 1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 1,500.00 $120,438.35 $90,328.76

Landfills 1,700.67 1,275.50 $102,412.74 $76,809.56

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 751.00 $60,299.47 $45,224.60

Electricity Generation 738.67 554.00 $44,481.90 $33,361.42

Pulp and Paper 283.33 212.50 $17,062.10 $12,796.57

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 157.50 $12,646.03 $9,484.52

GHG Suppliers 111.33 83.50 $6,704.40 $5,028.30

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 75.00 $6,021.92 $4,516.44

Iron and Steel 80.67 60.50 $4,857.68 $3,643.26

Manure 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 71.33 53.50 $4,295.63 $3,221.73

Lime 59.33 44.50 $3,573.00 $2,679.75

Petrochemical 53.33 40.00 $3,211.69 $2,408.77

Glass 36.67 27.50 $2,208.04 $1,656.03

Nitric Acid 30.00 22.50 $1,806.58 $1,354.93

Hydrogen 27.33 20.50 $1,645.99 $1,234.49

Ammonia 15.33 11.50 $923.36 $692.52

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

Aluminum 9.33 7.00 $562.05 $421.53

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Lead 8.67 6.50 $521.90 $391.42

Ferroalloy 6.00 4.50 $361.32 $270.99

Titanium oxide 5.33 4.00 $321.17 $240.88

Zinc 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Soda Ash 3.33 2.50 $200.73 $150.55

Adipic Acid 2.67 2.00 $160.58 $120.44

HCFC-22 2.00 1.50 $120.44 $90.33

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.50 $40.15 $30.11

Total 6,578.67 4,934.00 $396,161.87 $297,121.40

NOTE: Option 1 was proposed but not finalized. See Option 2 for estimates relevant to final rule.

First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 500.00 $120,438.35 $30,109.59

Landfills 1,700.67 425.17 $102,412.74 $25,603.19

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 250.33 $60,299.47 $15,074.87

Electricity Generation 738.67 184.67 $44,481.90 $11,120.47

Pulp and Paper 283.33 70.83 $17,062.10 $4,265.52

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 52.50 $12,646.03 $3,161.51

GHG Suppliers 111.33 27.83 $6,704.40 $1,676.10

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 25.00 $6,021.92 $1,505.48

Iron and Steel 80.67 20.17 $4,857.68 $1,214.42

Manure 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement 71.33 17.83 $4,295.63 $1,073.91

Lime 59.33 14.83 $3,573.00 $893.25

Petrochemical 53.33 13.33 $3,211.69 $802.92

Glass 36.67 9.17 $2,208.04 $552.01

Nitric Acid 30.00 7.50 $1,806.58 $451.64

Hydrogen 27.33 6.83 $1,645.99 $411.50

Ammonia 15.33 3.83 $923.36 $230.84

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

Aluminum 9.33 2.33 $562.05 $140.51

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Lead 8.67 2.17 $521.90 $130.47

Ferroalloy 6.00 1.50 $361.32 $90.33

Titanium oxide 5.33 1.33 $321.17 $80.29

Zinc 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Soda Ash 3.33 0.83 $200.73 $50.18

Adipic Acid 2.67 0.67 $160.58 $40.15

HCFC-22 2.00 0.50 $120.44 $30.11

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.17 $40.15 $10.04

Total 6,578.67 1,644.67 $396,161.87 $99,040.47

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration

Industry

Total Burden (hours) Total Cost

Total Burden (hours) Total Cost

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting Ultimate Parent Company 

Name(s), Address(es), Type of Ownership, and Percent of Ownership

Industry

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 20 of 28

Summary by Data Element- Op. 1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 4,000.00 2,000.00 240,876.69 120,438.35

Landfills 3,401.33 1,700.67 204,825.48 102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers 2,002.67 1,001.33 120,598.93 60,299.47

Electricity Generation 1,477.33 738.67 88,963.79 44,481.90

Pulp and Paper 566.67 283.33 34,124.20 17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 420.00 210.00 25,292.05 12,646.03

GHG Suppliers 222.67 111.33 13,408.80 6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries 200.00 100.00 12,043.83 6,021.92

Iron and Steel 161.33 80.67 9,715.36 4,857.68

Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Cement 142.67 71.33 8,591.27 4,295.63

Lime 118.67 59.33 7,146.01 3,573.00

Petrochemical 106.67 53.33 6,423.38 3,211.69

Glass 73.33 36.67 4,416.07 2,208.04

Nitric Acid 60.00 30.00 3,613.15 1,806.58

Hydrogen 54.67 27.33 3,291.98 1,645.99

Ammonia 30.67 15.33 1,846.72 923.36

Phosphoric Acid 18.67 9.33 1,124.09 562.05

Aluminum 18.67 9.33 1,124.09 562.05

CO2 Suppliers 17.33 8.67 1,043.80 521.90

Lead 17.33 8.67 1,043.80 521.90

Ferroalloy 12.00 6.00 722.63 361.32

Titanium oxide 10.67 5.33 642.34 321.17

Zinc 6.67 3.33 401.46 200.73

Soda Ash 6.67 3.33 401.46 200.73

Adipic Acid 5.33 2.67 321.17 160.58

HCFC-22 4.00 2.00 240.88 120.44

Silicon Carbide 1.33 0.67 80.29 40.15

Total 14,176.39 7,142.39 $853,690.56 $430,108.90

Industry

Total Burden (hours) Total Cost

Labor Burden and Cost Associated with Reporting All Proposed Data 

Elements

Abt Associates Inc. 

Page 21 of 28

Summary by Data Element- Op. 1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
NOTE: Option 1 was proposed but not finalized. See Option 2 for estimates relevant to final rule.

First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 1,500.00 2,000.00 500.00 4,000.00 2,000.00

Landfills 1,700.67 1,275.50 1,700.67 425.17 3,401.33 1,700.67

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 751.00 1,001.33 250.33 2,002.67 1,001.33

Electricity Generation 738.67 554.00 738.67 184.67 1,477.33 738.67

Pulp and Paper 283.33 212.50 283.33 70.83 566.67 283.33

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 157.50 210.00 52.50 420.00 210.00

GHG Suppliers 111.33 83.50 111.33 27.83 222.67 111.33

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 75.00 100.00 25.00 200.00 100.00

Iron and Steel 80.67 60.50 80.67 20.17 161.33 80.67

Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Cement 71.33 53.50 71.33 17.83 142.67 71.33

Lime 59.33 44.50 59.33 14.83 118.67 59.33

Petrochemical 53.33 40.00 53.33 13.33 106.67 53.33

Glass 36.67 27.50 36.67 9.17 73.33 36.67

Nitric Acid 30.00 22.50 30.00 7.50 60.00 30.00

Hydrogen 27.33 20.50 27.33 6.83 54.67 27.33

Ammonia 15.33 11.50 15.33 3.83 30.67 15.33

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 7.00 9.33 2.33 18.67 9.33

Aluminum 9.33 7.00 9.33 2.33 18.67 9.33

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 6.50 8.67 2.17 17.33 8.67

Lead 8.67 6.50 8.67 2.17 17.33 8.67

Ferroalloy 6.00 4.50 6.00 1.50 12.00 6.00

Titanium oxide 5.33 4.00 5.33 1.33 10.67 5.33

Zinc 3.33 2.50 3.33 0.83 6.67 3.33

Soda Ash 3.33 2.50 3.33 0.83 6.67 3.33

Adipic Acid 2.67 2.00 2.67 0.67 5.33 2.67

HCFC-22 2.00 1.50 2.00 0.50 4.00 2.00

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.50 0.67 0.17 1.33 0.67

Total 6,578.67 4,934.00 6,578.67 1,644.67 13,157.33 6,578.67

Estimated Total Labor Burden Associated with Proposed Data Elements, by Year and by Sector: 

Option 1

Total Labor Burden (hours)

Ultimate Parent Company 

Name, Address, and Type of 

Ownership

Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration All Data Elements

Industry

Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Labor Burden (hours)

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 22 of 28

Summary By Cost & Burden-Op. 1 

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion $120,438.35 $90,328.76 $120,438.35 $30,109.59 $240,876.69 $120,438.35

Landfills $102,412.74 $76,809.56 $102,412.74 $25,603.19 $204,825.48 $102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers $60,299.47 $45,224.60 $60,299.47 $15,074.87 $120,598.93 $60,299.47

Electricity Generation $44,481.90 $33,361.42 $44,481.90 $11,120.47 $88,963.79 $44,481.90

Pulp and Paper $17,062.10 $12,796.57 $17,062.10 $4,265.52 $34,124.20 $17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers $12,646.03 $9,484.52 $12,646.03 $3,161.51 $25,292.05 $12,646.03

GHG Suppliers $6,704.40 $5,028.30 $6,704.40 $1,676.10 $13,408.80 $6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries $6,021.92 $4,516.44 $6,021.92 $1,505.48 $12,043.83 $6,021.92

Iron and Steel $4,857.68 $3,643.26 $4,857.68 $1,214.42 $9,715.36 $4,857.68

Manure $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement $4,295.63 $3,221.73 $4,295.63 $1,073.91 $8,591.27 $4,295.63

Lime $3,573.00 $2,679.75 $3,573.00 $893.25 $7,146.01 $3,573.00

Petrochemical $3,211.69 $2,408.77 $3,211.69 $802.92 $6,423.38 $3,211.69

Glass $2,208.04 $1,656.03 $2,208.04 $552.01 $4,416.07 $2,208.04

Nitric Acid $1,806.58 $1,354.93 $1,806.58 $451.64 $3,613.15 $1,806.58

Hydrogen $1,645.99 $1,234.49 $1,645.99 $411.50 $3,291.98 $1,645.99

Ammonia $923.36 $692.52 $923.36 $230.84 $1,846.72 $923.36

Phosphoric Acid $562.05 $421.53 $562.05 $140.51 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum $562.05 $421.53 $562.05 $140.51 $1,124.09 $562.05

CO2 Suppliers $521.90 $391.42 $521.90 $130.47 $1,043.80 $521.90

Lead $521.90 $391.42 $521.90 $130.47 $1,043.80 $521.90

Ferroalloy $361.32 $270.99 $361.32 $90.33 $722.63 $361.32

Titanium oxide $321.17 $240.88 $321.17 $80.29 $642.34 $321.17

Zinc $200.73 $150.55 $200.73 $50.18 $401.46 $200.73

Soda Ash $200.73 $150.55 $200.73 $50.18 $401.46 $200.73

Adipic Acid $160.58 $120.44 $160.58 $40.15 $321.17 $160.58

HCFC-22 $120.44 $90.33 $120.44 $30.11 $240.88 $120.44

Silicon Carbide $40.15 $30.11 $40.15 $10.04 $80.29 $40.15

Total $396,161.87 $297,121.40 $396,161.87 $99,040.47 $792,323.74 $396,161.87

Industry

Total Cost Total Cost Total Cost

Ultimate Parent Company 

Name, Address, and Type of 

Ownership

Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration All Data Elements

Estimated Total Cost Associated with Proposed Data Elements, by Year and by Sector: Option 1

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 23 of 28

Summary By Cost & Burden-Op. 1 

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry Industry EST/FIRM Ratio Scaling Factor

Stationary Combustion General Stationary Fuel Combustion Sources1.25 0.88

Electricity Generation Electricity Generation 6.39 4.46

Adipic Acid Adipic Acid Production 1.36 0.95

Aluminum Aluminum Production 1.24 0.86

Ammonia Ammonia Manufacturing 1.19 0.83

Cement Cement Production 2.38 1.66

Ferroalloy Ferroalloy Production 1.00 0.70

Glass Glass Production 1.27 0.89

HCFC-22 HCFC-22 Production and HFC-23 Destruction 6.58 4.59

Hydrogen Hydrogen Production 6.58 4.59

Iron and Steel Iron and Steel Production 1.17 0.82

Lead Lead Production 1.15 0.80

Lime Lime Production 2.05 1.43

Nitric Acid Nitric Acid Production 1.19 0.83

Petrochemical Petrochemical Production 1.42 0.99

Petroleum Refineries Petroleum Refineries 1.54 1.08

Phosphoric Acid Phosphoric Acid Production 1.43 1.00

Pulp and Paper Pulp and Paper Manufacturing 1.98 1.38

Silicon Carbide Silicon Carbide Production 1.15 0.80

Soda Ash Soda Ash Manufacturing 1.48 1.03

Titanium oxide Titanium Dioxide Production 1.57 1.09

Zinc Zinc Production 1.15 0.80

Landfills Municipal Solid Waste Landfills 1.67 1.16

Electricity Generation Suppliers of Coal Based Liquids Fuels 1.12 0.78

Petroleum Product Suppliers Suppliers of Petroleum Products 1.54 1.08 Statistic Scaling Factor Stats

Natural Gas Suppliers Suppliers of Natural Gas and NGLs 4.49 3.14 Median 1.00

GHG Suppliers Suppliers of Industrial GHGs 6.58 4.59 Average 1.65

CO2 Suppliers Suppliers of Carbon Dioxide (CO2) 6.58 4.59 Min 0.00

Vehicle Manufacturers Mobile Sources 0.00 0.00 Max 4.59

Industry Specific Scaling Factor To Adjust Reporting Burden Estimate

Source: Statistics of U.S. Businesses (SUSB) 2006. U.S. All Industries

This sheet provides the detailed data obtained from 

SUSB dataset and shows the uderlying calculations 

used to develop the scaling factors used in the 

sensitivity anlaysis of Option 1. Note that Mobile 

Sources and Manure have been removed from the 

analysis.
GHG Industry NAICS NAICS DescriptionFirms Establishments EST/Firm RatioScalling Factor Weights for Industry with Multi NAICS

Facilities operating boilers, process heaters, incinerators, turbines, and internal combustion engines:

211 Extractors of crude petroleum and natural gas. 6606 7803 1.18 0.82 3% 0.85 1.21

321 Manufacturers of lumber and wood products. 14757 16735 1.13 0.79 6% 0.88 1.26

322 Pulp and paper mills. 3269 5139 1.57 1.10 2% 0.64 0.91

325 Chemical manufacturers. 9608 13247 1.38 0.96 5% 0.73 1.04

324 Petroleum refineries, and manufacturers of coal products. 1166 2448 2.10 1.46 1% 0.48 0.68

316 Manufacturers of rubber and miscellaneous plastic products. 1353 1398 1.03 0.72 1% 0.97 1.39

326 11456 14592 1.27 0.89 5% 0.79 1.13

339 29925 31239 1.04 0.73 11% 0.96 1.37

331 Steel works, blast furnaces. 4310 5285 1.23 0.86 2% 0.82 1.17

332 Electroplating, plating, polishing, anodizing, and coloring. 54969 59064 1.07 0.75 21% 0.93 1.33

336 Manufacturers of motor vehicle parts and accessories. 10552 12707 1.20 0.84 5% 0.83 1.19

221 Electric, gas, and sanitary services.6554 17174 2.62 1.83 6% 0.38 0.55

622 Health services. 4060 6843 1.69 1.18 2% 0.59 0.85

611 Educational services. 73793 82647 1.12 0.78 30% 0.89 1.28

Electricity Generation 221112 Fossil-fuel fired electric generating units, including units owned by 201 1285 6.39 Federal and municipal governments and units located in Indian Country 4.46 0.16 . 0.22

Adipic Acid Production 325199 Adipic acid manufacturing facilities.497 677 1.36 0.95 0.73 1.05

Aluminum Production 331312 Primary Aluminum production facilities. 46 57 1.24 0.86 0.81 1.16

Ammonia Manufacturing 325311 Anhydrous and aqueous ammonia manufacturing facilities. 122 145 1.19 0.83 0.84 1.21

Cement Production 327310 Portland Cement manufacturing plants. 121 288 2.38 1.66 0.42 0.60

Ferroalloy Production 331112 Ferroalloys manufacturing facilities. 22 22 1.00 0.70 1.00 1.43

327211 Flat glass manufacturing facilities. 56 83 1.48 1.03 13% 0.67 0.97

327213 Glass container manufacturing facilities. 32 72 2.25 1.57 11% 0.44 0.64

327212 Other pressed and blown glass and glassware manufacturing facilities. 457 499 1.09 0.76 76% 0.92 1.31

HCFC-22 Production and HFC-23 

Destruction

325120 Chlorodifluoromethane manufacturing facilities.

83 546 6.58 4.59 0.15 0.22

Hydrogen Production 325120 Hydrogen manufacturing facilities. 83 546 6.58 4.59 0.15 0.22

Iron and Steel Production 331111 Integrated iron and steel mills, steel companies, sinter plants, blast furnaces, basic oxy 686 805 1.17 0.82gen process furnace shops. 0.85 1.22

331419 Primary lead smelting and refining facilities. 139 166 1.19 0.83 43% 0.84 1.20

331492 Secondary lead smelting and refining facilities. 195 217 1.11 0.78 57% 0.90 1.29

Lime Production 327410 Calcium oxide, calcium hydroxide, dolomitic hy 39 drates manufacturing facilities. 80 2.05 1.43 0.49 0.70

Nitric Acid Production 325311 Nitric acid manufacturing facilities.122 145 1.19 0.83 0.84 1.21

32511 Ethylene dichloride manufacturing facilities. 35 53 1.51 1.06 7% 0.66 0.95

325199 Acrylonitrile, ethylene oxide, methanol manufacturing facilities. 497 677 1.36 0.95 84% 0.73 1.05

325110 Ethylene manufacturing facilities. 35 53 1.51 1.06 7% 0.66 0.95

325182 Carbon black manufacturing facilities.10 26 2.60 1.81 3% 0.38 0.55

Petroleum Refineries 324110 Petroleum refineries. 228 352 1.54 1.08 0.65 0.93

Phosphoric Acid Production 325312 Phosphoric acid manufacturing facilities. 30 43 1.43 1.00 0.70 1.00

322110 Pulp mills. 31 44 1.42 0.99 8% 0.70 1.01

322121 Paper mills. 179 325 1.82 1.27 57% 0.55 0.79

322130 Paperboard mills. 87 205 2.36 1.64 36% 0.42 0.61

Silicon Carbide Production 327910 Silicon carbide abrasives manufacturing facilities. 300 344 1.15 0.80 0.87 1.25

325181 Alkalies and chlorine manufacturing facilities. 30 46 1.53 1.07 71% 0.65 0.93

212391 Soda ash, natural, mining and/or beneficiation. 14 19 1.36 0.95 29% 0.74 1.06

Titanium Dioxide Production 325188 Titanium dioxide manufacturing facilities. 390 612 1.57 1.09 0.64 0.91

331419 Primary zinc refining facilities. 139 166 1.19 0.83 43% 0.84 1.20

331492 Zinc dust reclaiming facilities, recovering from scrap and/or alloy 195 217 1.11 ing purchased metals. 0.78 57% 0.90 1.29

562212 Solid waste landfills. 842 1467 1.74 1.22 67% 0.57 0.82

221320 Sewage treatment facilities. 478 726 1.52 1.06 33% 0.66 0.94

Suppliers of Coal Based Liquids Fuels 211111 Coal liquefaction at mine sites. 6498 7276 1.12 0.78 0.89 1.28

Suppliers of Petroleum Products 324110 Petroleum refineries. 228 352 1.54 1.08 0.65 0.93

221210 Natural gas distribution facilities. 526 2458 4.67 3.26 82% 0.21 0.31

211112 Natural gas liquid extraction facilities. 144 527 3.66 2.55 18% 0.27 0.39

Suppliers of Industrial GHGs 325120 Industrial gas manufacturing facilities.83 546 6.58 4.59 0.15 0.22

Suppliers of Carbon Dioxide (CO2) 325120 Industrial gas manufacturing facilities.83 546 6.58 4.59 0.15 0.22

333618 Heavy-duty, non-road, aircraft, locomotive, and marine diesel engine manufacturing. 271 322

336120 Heavy-duty vehicle manufacturing facilities. 77 95

336312 Small non-road, and marine spark-ignition engine manufacturing facilities. 810 876

336999 Personal watercraft manufacturing facilities. 456 465

336991 Motorcycle manufacturing facilities.466 474

Median 1.43 1.00 0.70 1.00

Average 2.05 1.43 0.65 0.94

MAX 6.58 4.59 1.00 1.43

MIN 1.00 0.70 0.15 0.22

SUSB Data

Zinc Production

Mobile Sources

Soda Ash Manufacturing

Suppliers of Natural Gas and NGLs 

General Stationary Fuel Combustion 

Sources

Glass Production

Pulp and Paper Manufacturing

Petrochemical Production

Lead Production

Municipal Solid Waste Landfills
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Industry Scaling 

Factor

1st yr 

burden 

(hrs)

Subsequent 

yr burden 

(hrs)

1st yr 

burden ($)

Subsequent 

yr burden 

($)

Stationary Combustion 2,000.00 1,500.00 2,000.00 500.00 4,000.00 2,000.00 Stationary Combustion 0.88 3,501.14 1,750.57 $210,835.72 $105,417.86

Landfills 1,700.67 1,275.50 1,700.67 425.17 3,401.33 1,700.67 Landfills 1.16 3,958.93 1,979.46 $238,403.40 $119,201.70

Natural Gas Suppliers 1,001.33 751.00 1,001.33 250.33 2,002.67 1,001.33 Natural Gas Suppliers 3.14 6,279.21 3,139.61 $378,128.93 $189,064.47

Electricity Generation 738.67 554.00 738.67 184.67 1,477.33 738.67 Electricity Generation 4.46 6,589.29 3,294.64 $396,801.36 $198,400.68

Pulp and Paper 283.33 212.50 283.33 70.83 566.67 283.33 Pulp and Paper 1.38 782.14 391.07 $47,100.08 $23,550.04

Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Vehicle Manufacturers 0.00 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00 3/8/2010 Mobile sources omited from the analysis

Petroleum Product Suppliers 210.00 157.50 210.00 52.50 420.00 210.00 Petroleum Product Suppliers 1.08 452.39 226.19 $27,242.36 $13,621.18

GHG Suppliers 111.33 83.50 111.33 27.83 222.67 111.33 GHG Suppliers 4.59 1,021.93 510.97 $61,539.98 $30,769.99

Petroleum Refineries 100.00 75.00 100.00 25.00 200.00 100.00 Petroleum Refineries 1.08 215.42 107.71 $12,972.55 $6,486.28

Iron and Steel 80.67 60.50 80.67 20.17 161.33 80.67 Iron and Steel 0.82 132.08 66.04 $7,953.96 $3,976.98

Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Manure 0.00 0.00 0.00 $0.00 $0.00 Manure omited from the Analysis

Cement 71.33 53.50 71.33 17.83 142.67 71.33 Cement 1.66 236.91 118.45 $14,266.49 $7,133.25

Lime 59.33 44.50 59.33 14.83 118.67 59.33 Lime 1.43 169.83 84.91 $10,226.85 $5,113.42

Petrochemical 53.33 40.00 53.33 13.33 106.67 53.33 Petrochemical 0.99 105.81 52.91 $6,372.08 $3,186.04

Glass 36.67 27.50 36.67 9.17 73.33 36.67 Glass 0.89 64.92 32.46 $3,909.54 $1,954.77

Nitric Acid 30.00 22.50 30.00 7.50 60.00 30.00 Nitric Acid0.83 49.75 24.88 $2,996.04 $1,498.02

Hydrogen 27.33 20.50 27.33 6.83 54.67 27.33 Hydrogen4.59 250.89 125.45 $15,108.62 $7,554.31

Ammonia 15.33 11.50 15.33 3.83 30.67 15.33 Ammonia0.83 25.43 12.71 $1,531.31 $765.65

Phosphoric Acid 9.33 7.00 9.33 2.33 18.67 9.33 Phosphoric Acid 1.00 18.67 9.33 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum 9.33 7.00 9.33 2.33 18.67 9.33 Aluminum0.86 16.14 8.07 $971.79 $485.89

CO2 Suppliers 8.67 6.50 8.67 2.17 17.33 8.67 CO2 Suppliers 4.59 79.55 39.78 $4,790.54 $2,395.27

Lead 8.67 6.50 8.67 2.17 17.33 8.67 Lead 0.80 13.88 6.94 $836.09 $418.05

Ferroalloy 6.00 4.50 6.00 1.50 12.00 6.00 Ferroalloy0.70 8.37 4.19 $504.16 $252.08

Titanium oxide 5.33 4.00 5.33 1.33 10.67 5.33 Titanium oxide 1.09 11.68 5.84 $703.24 $351.62

Zinc 3.33 2.50 3.33 0.83 6.67 3.33 Zinc 0.80 5.34 2.67 $321.57 $160.79

Soda Ash 3.33 2.50 3.33 0.83 6.67 3.33 Soda Ash1.03 6.89 3.45 $415.04 $207.52

Adipic Acid 2.67 2.00 2.67 0.67 5.33 2.67 Adipic Acid0.95 5.07 2.53 $305.22 $152.61

HCFC-22 2.00 1.50 2.00 0.50 4.00 2.00 HCFC-22 4.59 18.36 9.18 $1,105.51 $552.75

Silicon Carbide 0.67 0.50 0.67 0.17 1.33 0.67 Silicon Carbide 0.80 1.07 0.53 $64.23 $32.12

Total 6,578.67 4,934.00 6,578.67 1,644.67 13,157.33 6,578.67 Total 24,021 12,011 $1,446,531 $723,265

Sensitivity Analysis: Adjusted Estimates of burden 

and Cost under Option1.

Total Labor Burden (hours) Total Labor Burden 

(hours) Total Labor Burden (hours)

Estimated Total Labor Burden Associated with Proposed Data Elements, by Year and by Sector: 

Option 1

Ultimate Parent Company 

Name, Address, and Type of 

Ownership

Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration All Data Elements

Industry

This sheet applies the scaling factors developed on the 

Industry Weights sheet to burden estimates for Option 1 . 

The resulting higher costs are reported in the table below. 

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 26 of 28

RTI Sensitivity Analysis Opt.1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
First Year Subsequent 

Years First Year Subsequent Years First Year Subsequent Years

Stationary Combustion $120,438.35 $90,328.76 $120,438.35 $30,109.59 $240,876.69 $120,438.35

Landfills $102,412.74 $76,809.56 $102,412.74 $25,603.19 $204,825.48 $102,412.74

Natural Gas Suppliers $60,299.47 $45,224.60 $60,299.47 $15,074.87 $120,598.93 $60,299.47

Electricity Generation $44,481.90 $33,361.42 $44,481.90 $11,120.47 $88,963.79 $44,481.90

Pulp and Paper $17,062.10 $12,796.57 $17,062.10 $4,265.52 $34,124.20 $17,062.10

Vehicle Manufacturers $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Petroleum Product Suppliers$12,646.03 $9,484.52 $12,646.03 $3,161.51 $25,292.05 $12,646.03

GHG Suppliers $6,704.40 $5,028.30 $6,704.40 $1,676.10 $13,408.80 $6,704.40

Petroleum Refineries $6,021.92 $4,516.44 $6,021.92 $1,505.48 $12,043.83 $6,021.92

Iron and Steel $4,857.68 $3,643.26 $4,857.68 $1,214.42 $9,715.36 $4,857.68

Manure $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Cement $4,295.63 $3,221.73 $4,295.63 $1,073.91 $8,591.27 $4,295.63

Lime $3,573.00 $2,679.75 $3,573.00 $893.25 $7,146.01 $3,573.00

Petrochemical $3,211.69 $2,408.77 $3,211.69 $802.92 $6,423.38 $3,211.69

Glass $2,208.04 $1,656.03 $2,208.04 $552.01 $4,416.07 $2,208.04

Nitric Acid $1,806.58 $1,354.93 $1,806.58 $451.64 $3,613.15 $1,806.58

Hydrogen $1,645.99 $1,234.49 $1,645.99 $411.50 $3,291.98 $1,645.99

Ammonia $923.36 $692.52 $923.36 $230.84 $1,846.72 $923.36

Phosphoric Acid $562.05 $421.53 $562.05 $140.51 $1,124.09 $562.05

Aluminum $562.05 $421.53 $562.05 $140.51 $1,124.09 $562.05

CO2 Suppliers $521.90 $391.42 $521.90 $130.47 $1,043.80 $521.90

Lead $521.90 $391.42 $521.90 $130.47 $1,043.80 $521.90

Ferroalloy $361.32 $270.99 $361.32 $90.33 $722.63 $361.32

Titanium oxide $321.17 $240.88 $321.17 $80.29 $642.34 $321.17

Zinc $200.73 $150.55 $200.73 $50.18 $401.46 $200.73

Soda Ash $200.73 $150.55 $200.73 $50.18 $401.46 $200.73

Adipic Acid $160.58 $120.44 $160.58 $40.15 $321.17 $160.58

HCFC-22 $120.44 $90.33 $120.44 $30.11 $240.88 $120.44

Silicon Carbide $40.15 $30.11 $40.15 $10.04 $80.29 $40.15

Total $396,161.87 $297,121.40 $396,161.87 $99,040.47 $792,323.74 $396,161.87

Industry

Total Cost Total Cost Total Cost

Estimated Total Cost Associated with Proposed Data Elements, by Year and by Sector: Option 1

Ultimate Parent Company 

Name, Address, and Type of 

Ownership

Primary NAICS Code and 

Cogeneration All Data Elements

Abt Associates Inc.

Page 27 of 28

RTI Sensitivity Analysis Opt.1

DRAFT

9/8/2010
Industry

Number of 

Facilities

Estimated 

Percent with 

Single Owner

Estimated 

Percent with 

Multiple 

# with 

single

# multi 

owner

Stationary Combustion 3000 100% 0% 3000 0

Landfills 2551 100% 0% 2551 0

Natural Gas Suppliers 1502 100% 0% 1502 0

Electricity Generation 1108 87% 13% 963.48 144.52

Pulp and Paper 425 100% 0% 425 0

Vehicle Manufacturers 0 100% 0% 0 0

Petroleum Product Suppliers 315 100% 0% 315 0

GHG Suppliers 167 100% 0% 167 0

Petroleum Refineries 150 100% 0% 150 0

Iron and Steel 121 100% 0% 121 0

Manure 0 100% 0% 0 0

Cement 107 100% 0% 107 0

Lime 89 100% 0% 89 0

Petrochemical 80 100% 0% 80 0

Glass 55 100% 0% 55 0

Nitric Acid 45 100% 0% 45 0

Hydrogen 41 100% 0% 41 0

Ammonia 23 100% 0% 23 0

Phosphoric Acid 14 100% 0% 14 0

Aluminum 14 100% 0% 14 0

CO2 Suppliers 13 100% 0% 13 0

Lead 13 100% 0% 13 0

Ferroalloy 9 100% 0% 9 0

Titanium oxide 8 100% 0% 8 0

Zinc 5 100% 0% 5 0

Soda Ash 5 100% 0% 5 0

Adipic Acid 4 100% 0% 4 0

HCFC-22 3 100% 0% 3 0

Silicon Carbide 1 100% 0% 1 0

Subparts T, FF, II, TT 683 100% 0% 683 0

Total 10551 10406.48 144.52

Facilities

Percentage of 

total 

reporters

Facilities with single 

owner 99%

Facilities with multiple 

owners 1%

Reporting Cost per Facility ($2006/facility)

single owner multi-owner weighted average

US Parent Company 

Name, Address, % 

ownership

First Year $40.15 $85.31 $40.77

Subsequent Years $30.11 $75.28 $30.73

Primary NAICS and 

Cogen

First year $40.15 $40.15 $40.15

Subsequent Years $10.04 $10.04 $10.04

Total

First Year $80.91 853702.28

Subsequent Years $40.77 430114.8