T hi s di s pos i t i on i s notappr opr i at e f orpubl i c at i on and i s notpr e c e de nt * e xc e pta s pr ovi de d by9th C i r . R
. 36- 3. NOT F OR P UB L I CAT I ON UN I TE D STATE S C OU RT OF APPE ALS FOR T HE NI NTH CI RC UI T

DA R R E N T HO MAS ; J E S US AV I L A; ERN ESTO A V I LA ; TRA CY BA TTS; A A R O N B R E IT IG A M ; A N T O N IO C AB AL L E R O; R UB E N C AL DE R ON i ndi vi dua l l yand a s G uar di an A d L i t e m f or C h ri st i n a an dD av i dC al d ero n , m i n o rs; C AR OL INA C AL DE R ON ; L IND A C AL DE R ON ; J OR GE C AL DE R ON ; D E M E T R IO C A R IL L O ; E L Z IE C OL E MAN; DO L OR E S DA L T ON , G uar di an a d L i t e m f

oram i norR on Da l t o n ; MAR R I AN NE E NG L I S H, i ni di vi dua l l yand a s par e ntand he i rof L aw re nce J oh nson ; D ec ea se d; S E R G IO G A LIN D O ; RA U L G O N ZA LES; M A RCELO G O N ZA LEZ; RI CH A RD HE RNA ND E Z ; J E F F R E Y H OL L I MAN; S O C O R R O H U E R T A , G uardi an ad l i t em for m i no r F ernand ezM art i nez; E R IC J O N E S ; S A N D R A L E O N A R D , he i rof Wi l l i am L e o n ar d ; d e c e a s e d ; C AN DI L E O N A R D , he i rof

W i l l i am L e onar d; d e c e a s e d ; YI DE F ON Z A L OR E NZ AN A; A L F R E D O M A Y A , i ni di vi du al l y andas Gu ar d i ana dl i t e m f

o rI r e n e May a ; R AU L M A Y A , i nd i vi du aland as G uardi an ad l i t e m f o rR au lMay aJr , am i n o r ; C AR L OS MAYA ; MAR GU E R I T A MAY A; N o. 09- 55297 D
. C
. N o . 2 : 9 0 -cv -0 5 2 1 7 -T JH
ME MOR AN DU M * 

# FI LED
APR08 2 010 M OLLY C. DW Y ER, CLERK U

. S. C O U R T OF APPE ALS- 2-

R UB E N MAY A; L UP E MAYA ; N A T A L IE M E L E N D R E Z , G uardi an ad l i t em for am i no r J es si e M el endrez; GEORGE M ENDI BL ES ; ES TE LL A M O N T O Y A , i nd i vi du al l y andas G uardi an ad l i t em for R ebec caM on t oya am i no r & C ry s t a lT r e vi no & M oni que T r e vi no; R AP HA E L OC HO A; J OS E OR T E GA ; D E L IA O S IT A ; P A T S Y P E R E Z G uardi an atl i t em for A do lph o A l ej ade am i no r & B r i anAl e

j a d e am i n o r ; R I T A P R E C I AD O, G uar di an a d l i t e m f

orS a l va dorP r e c i a do a mi n o r ; TE RE SA RODRI GU EZ , i nd i vi du al l y andas G uardi an ad l i t em A l i ce O re

j ela m i no r M ar i a O re

j ela m i no r; SE RGI O SAN CHEZ ; J OSE S AN CHEZ ; ALFR EDO SAN CHEZ ; CHARLE S S C O T T ; M IC H A E L S T E R L IN G ; K E V IN M ARSHALL; W I LL I AM SC OTT; AL VIN WAS HINT ON ; DA NN Y W I L L I A M S ; JU L I A P O L K A dm i ni s tr at or f o rEs t at e o f

Ll o y dPo l k ; ES TE LA SANCHEZ; ALFONSO SAN CHEZ ; F R A N C I S C O T O V A R , i ndi vi dua l l yand as gu ar di an ad l i t em for m i no rs F ranci sc o T ov arJr , Y es eni a T ov ar , M ar ce l a T ov ar , Ja i m e T ov ar , Je sus T ov arand H erm an To v ar ; EL SA TOVA R; M ARTA VELE Z, P l ai n t i ffs,

and F R E DD I E F UI AV A, P la in tif

f

- I n te rv e n o r - A p p e llan t,- 3-

v. L O S A N G E L E S C O U N T Y , ap ub lic en ti ty; L O S A N G E L E S S H E R IF F ’S DE P AR T ME NT , ap ub l i c e n t i ty ; C I T Y O F L Y N W O O D , a pub l i c e nt i ty & a m un i cipal c o rp o r at i o n ; SH ERM A N BLO CK in d iv idu a llyan da s S h e r if f o f th e C o u n ty o f Lo s A n g e l e s ; RO BERT ED M O N D S, i ndi vi dua l l yand a s U nde r s he r i f f of the Co u n tyo f

Lo s A n g e l e s ; J ERRY H A RPER, i ndi vi dua l l yand a s A s s i s t antS he r i f f of the Co u n tyo f

Lo s A n g e l e s ; RI CH A RD F O R E M A N , i ndi vi dua l l yand a s A s s i s t ant S h eri ff o f th e C o u n ty o f L o s A n g el es; B E R T J. C U E V A , i nd i vi du al l y andas C o m m an d e ro f

th e L o s A n g e le s C o u n ty S h e r i f f’ s L yn wo o dS t at i o n ; P AU L AR C HA MB AU L T , # 2 1 3 6 6 9 ; AN T HO NY CAM PB EL L, # 0 1 3 4 0 5 ; JAM ES CO RRI G A N , # 2 1 3 6 7 1 ; RO BERT D E L G A D IL L O , # 2 3 0 2 3 7 ; M IC H A E L J. GA RC I A, # 2 0 7 1 3 6 ; KELL Y MC MI C HA E L , # 2 6 0 3 0 9 ; DO UG L AS G I L L I E S #244674; J
. L E S L I E , #223389; JASON M AN N, # 1 9 6 1 7 5 ; GU Y M ATO #188894; J O H N M O S S O T T I , #232692; E D W A R D M
. N O R D S K O G #241276; MI C HA E L P I P P IN, # 1 1 6 2 1 2 ; DA N RA I M O , # 2 0 7 2 2 0 ; TH O M A S RO SA S, #111632; J
. S H E E H Y , #207157; E L I Z A B E T H N M I S M I T H #222075; G R E G O R Y T H O M P S O N , #196144; T H O M A S Z A M P I E L L O , # 1 2 8 w h o is sued i nd i vi du al l y andi n h i s off i ci al c ap a c i ty ; JUA N A L VA R AD O; U N KN O W N A N D E R S O N , S gt#160080;- 4-

CHARLE S B ARTON; TI M OTHY E. BEN SO N , # 2 4 6 3 8 0 ; G A RY B L A C K W E L L ; S T E V E B L A I R#236778; R O B E R T B L U M E , #273451; U N KN O W N B R A N D E N B U R G #209523; C
. B R AN T L E Y, L t
. ; T I MOT HY B R OA D; K A TH ERIN E BRO W N
- V O Y ER, # 2 5 8 4 8 9 ; T. BRO W N ELL; RI CH A RD C A L Z A D A ; S C O T T C A R T E R#150582; R I C HA R D L
. C AS T R O, L t
. ; J OH N CHAPM AN , # 2 2 0 8 3 7 ; JAV I ERCL I FT ; J OH N N I M CORINA , # 2 1 3 4 3 5 ; DA NI EL CO O PER; D A N I ELLE CO RM I ER; U N KN O W N C O S T L E I G H , #173151; F R U S T IN O D E L V A L L E ; U N KN O WN DE VINE , S g t ; R OB E R T DI L L AR D; C R AI G D I T S C H; S T E P HE N D OWNE Y, # 2 1 9 1 3 7 ; R AY MOND E S QU E R R A, # 1 3 7 4 5 1 ; LANCE F RALI CK; RONA LD E
. G I L B E R T , # 2 0 7 1 3 1 ; U N KN O WN GI R ON , # 0 3 3 1 4 4 ; NE I L S GI T T I S ARN, #2 36 61 6; T IM O T H Y G L O V E R ; C U R T IS G O LD EN ; FRA N K N M I G O N ZA LES; KE VIN G ORAN , # 2 2 2 0 2 1 ; R AY MOND GO T T C ap t a i n ; R UB E N G R AC I A, # 2 1 3 4 5 9 ; AL B E R T GR OT E F E ND , # 0 3 4 6 5 7 ; J OS E P H N MI GU Z MAN; A LLEN H A RRI S; TO M M Y H A RRI S, S g t
. ; T
. J
. HA R VE Y, # 0 3 8 5 3 5 ; A. H E R R E R A , L t
. ; U N KN O WN H O LBRO O K , # 2 0 9 6 1 9 ; J O SEPH H O LM ES, # 0 4 1 8 8 5 ; ERI C H U BN ER, #37190; D A L E H U F F M A N #265013; KE VIN J
. KI F F , # 2 3 5 1 5 1 ; L OY L UN A, # 2 0 1 6 6 3 ; A LLY N LA W REN CE M ARTIN, # 2 2 3 3 7 4 ; SC OTT L EE MC C OR MI C K, # 2 4 8 0 4 3 ; AB E L A.- 5-

M ORENO, # 1 9 5 9 1 2 ; JACK N EI HO USE; U N KN O W N N E L S O N , #220245; U N KN O W N N U N E Z , #067434; R O D O L F O O ’ D E L L ; U N KN O WN O’ HA R A # 1 8 3 1 1 9 ; R I C HA R D O R OS C O, # 0 6 8 7 3 4 ; JA M ES PA CIN A ; A N D RE P IN E S E T T , # 2 6 0 1 7 1 ; U N KN O WN RADELE FF , Lt
. ; JACK RAM I RE Z #211246; R
. A
. R E E D , #236792; M I CH A EL N M I REY N O LD S; UN KN OW N RI FKIN, # 2 0 7 1 9 5 ; ALLE N NM I RI PL EY; M ARTIN ROD RI GU EZ ; W I LL I AM ROM AN , # 0 7 7 6 6 8 ; T. RUNN ING ; M I CHAEL S ALVA TORE , # 0 4 4 8 5 2 ; M I CH A EL SCH N EI D ER, # 2 4 4 0 9 2 ; LARRY SHU LT Z; SAM UEL S I L V A ; M. S P A R K S , L t
. ; B R I A N N MI STEIN W A N D , # 2 1 8 5 2 4 ; JA CK TARASI UK # 2 4 4 9 1 2 ; GERALD R I C H A R D T H O M P S O N , #238853; GREG THURM AN ; PATR I CK VA LDEZ ; MI C HA E L VO GE , # 1 8 6 7 6 1 ; B YR ON W A IN I E #222015; K
. W A L L , #238868; TODD LAW RE NCE W ALLACE , #248150; J O H N A
. W E S T , #248032; JA ME S WH I T T E N ; MI C H A E L N MI W IL B E R ; R O B E R T W IN D R IM ; C H R IS JA M E S Y O U N G , #248084, e a c h of w hom i s s ued i nd i vi du al l y i n h i s or heroffi ci al c apa c i tya s an a ge ntore m pl oy e e of the C o u n ty o f L o s A n g el es, D efen d an t s - A p p el l ees.

A pp ea lfr om the U ni t ed S t at es D i stri ctC ou rtT he pane lunani m ous l yc onc lude s thi s c a s e i s s ui t abl e f orde c i s i on ** w ith o u t o r a l ar g u m e n t. See F ed. R
. A pp . P
. 34 (a )( 2).

- 6- f o rth e C e n tr a l D is tr ic t o f C a lif o rn ia T e rryJ
. H att e r , D i s tr i c tJudge , P r e s i di ng A r gue d and S ubm i tt e d A pr i l6, 2010 ** P a s a d e n a , C a lif

o rn ia B efo re: F E RN A N D E Z , S IL V E R M A N an dG R A B E R , C i rcu i tJu d g es. I n te rv e n o r - A p p e llan t F r e d d ie F u iav a ’s p e titio nf o rh ab e a s c o rp u s is c u rr e n tly pend i ng i n st at e c ou rt
. T he st at e c ou rtpart i al l y grant ed F ui ava’ s m ot i on un der C a lif o rn iaP e n a l C o d e § 1 0 5 4 .9 to tak e a d d itio n a l d is c o v e ryins up p o rt o f h is pet i t i on . F ui ava then m ov ed t o i nt ervene i n thi s c l osed ca se i n the C entra lD i stri ct of C al i forni a s ee ki ng m od i fi cat i on of any prot ec t i ve order coveri ng the di sc ov ery ge ne r at e d dur i ng the l i f e of thi s c a s e . A f

t e rthe di s tr i c tc ourtde ni e d hi s m ot i on
w i thouts t at i ng ar e a s on f ori t s de ni a l , apane lof

thi s c i r c ui tr e m ande d t o gi ve the di s tr i c tc ourtan opportuni tyt o s t at e the r e a s ons f ori t s rul i ng. See T

ho m as v. Co u n t yo f L. A. , N o. 06- 56228, 275 F e d. A ppx. 664 ( 9th C i r . 2008) ( c i t i ng Fol t z v . State Farm Mut
. A uto. I ns . Co. , 3 3 1 F .3 d1 1 2 2 ( 9 th C ir . 2 0 0 3 ) )
. O n rem and, the di stri ctcourtagai n d eni ed the m ot i on t o i nt ervene,
c onc ludi ng thatF ui avaha d notart i c ul at e d how a c c e s s t o the e vi de nc e he s ought

w ou l d b e r el evantt o h i s c ol l at er all i t i gat i on . T he di stri ctcourtfurther c on clud ed- 7-

thatthe re l i ance i nt er es tof the C ou nty i n m ai nt ai ni ng the prot ec t i ve order

o u twe i g h e dth e p o l i c yo f av o i d i n g dup l i c at i v e d i s c o v e ry . F u i av aap p e a l e dan dwe
now va c at e the di s tr i c tc ourt ’ s or de rbe c aus e the m ot i on t o i nt e rve ne t o m odi f ythe p r o te c tiv e o r d e ris m o o t. I n r e s pons e t o the pane l ’ s i nqui r i e s , ne i the rpartyha s i de nt i f i e d apr ot e c t i ve
or de rthatc ove r s the di s c ove ryi n thi s c a s e . F ui ava ’ s m ot i on t o i nt e rve ne s e e ki ng
m o d if ic atio no f

ap r o te c tiv e o r d e ris th e r e f o r e m o o t. N o p r o te c tiv e o r d e rp r e v e n ts F u iav af r o m o b ta in in g th e d is c o v e ryh e s e e k s . T h e d is tr ic t c o u rt’s o r d e rd e n y in g F u iav a ’s r e n e w e dm o tio nto in te rv e n e to
m o d if yth e p r o te c tiv e o r d e ris V A C A T E D an dth e c a s e is R E M A N D E D w ith d ir e c tio n s to d is m is s th e m o tio na s m o o t.