Consumers Energy
EPA ICR Response 

### JHCampbell Coal Shipment Analysis

2009

ORIS
Code Shipment ID Sample ID Amount
Received units Sulfur % %Ash HHV units Mercury units

1710A D171-3 9833.81 tons dry 11.93 6.71 12,386 btu/lb 0.10 ppm Eastern Coal

1710A D224-7 9739.00 tons dry 10.48 7.53 12,601 btu/lb 0.09 ppm Bull Creek WV Boone 01
1710A D395-1 11920.65 tons dry 13.89 4.96 12,396 btu/lb 0.09 ppm Elk Run / Sylvester WV Boone
1710A D173-7 9316.64 tons dry 11.20 6.80 12,362 btu/lb 0.11 ppm Liberty I WV Boone
1710 B D230-10 9943.44 tons dry 8.56 6.38 12,964 btu/lb 0.07 ppm Wells WV Boone
1710 C D236-3 10158.32 tons dry 11.72 6.42 12,596 btu/lb 0.12 ppm Brooks Run WV Brax ton 03
1710 D D175-6 10392.63 tons dry 14.17 5.79 12,316 btu/lb 0.07 ppm Toms Fork (Samples) WV Kanawha 06
1710 D D245-7 10074.75 tons dry 15.25 6.67 11,919 btu/lb 0.08 ppm Fork Creek WV Lincoln 14

1710 D D176-7 9892.36 tons dry 9.22 7.02 12,818 btu/lb 0.06 ppm Pardee/Elk Lick WV Logan 07
1710 E D178-3 10019.32 tons dry 11.62 7.08 12,455 btu/lb 0.11 ppm Mountain Laurel Complex WV Logan
1710 E D179-7 10381.55 tons dry 10.47 6.90 12,547 btu/lb 0.07 ppm Snap Creek / Phillips WV Logan
1710 E D180-1 10365.08 tons dry 11.88 4.75 12,845 btu/lb 0.05 ppm West Cazy/Ashley Kay WV Logan
1710 F D303-7 10829.69 tons dry 9.31 7.56 12,946 btu/lb 0.11 ppm Birch River/Evergreen WV Nicholas 08

1710 F D184-7 11063.39 tons dry 7.99 6.84 13,206 btu/lb 0.11 ppm Bluegrass KY Perry 09
1710 F D186-7 9248.58 tons dry 10.77 8.92 12,316 btu/lb 0.08 ppm Charlene KY Perry

1710 F D304-7 10938.61 tons dry 12.08 5.81 12,715 btu/lb 0.06 ppm Scotts Branch KY Pike 10
1710 F D182-7 10828.42 tons dry 11.71 7.20 12,243 btu/lb 0.06 ppm Myra KY Pike

1710 F D183-1 11134.74 tons dry 10.12 3.85 13,223 btu/lb 0.07 ppm Goals WV Raleigh 11
1710 G D189-14 9684.60 tons dry 10.51 7.79 12,233 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710 G D187-3 10560.85 tons dry 11.08 6.31 12,705 btu/lb 0.12 ppm Western Coal

1710 G D190-7 10093.32 tons dry 13.96 4.52 12,517 btu/lb 0.06 ppm Absaloka MT Big Horn 02
1710 G D191-7 11269.96 tons dry 10.79 7.52 12,546 btu/lb 0.10 ppm Spring Creek MT Big Horn

1710 H D192-3 11326.52 tons dry 11.94 6.74 12,475 btu/lb 0.13 ppm Black Thunder North WY Campbell 04
1710 H D196-1 9928.50 tons dry 13.36 7.60 12,312 btu/lb 0.07 ppm North Antelope / Rochelle (NARM) WY Campbell
1710 H D194-7 9936.67 tons dry 11.72 5.67 12,503 btu/lb 0.05 ppm Jacobs Ranch WY Campbell
1710 H D195-6 10060.44 tons dry 12.41 5.29 12,700 btu/lb 0.05 ppm Antelope WY Converse 05
1710 H D193-1 10258.34 tons dry 11.29 3.11 13,209 btu/lb 0.06 ppm Antelope/Spring Creek WY /MT Converse/Big Horn 13
1710 I D197-3 10552.42 tons dry 11.68 6.46 12,538 btu/lb 0.10 ppm Jacobs Ranch/Spring Creek WY /MT Campbell/Big Horn 12
1710 I D198-14 10327.54 tons dry 11.24 6.50 12,333 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710 I D001-7 10913.88 tons dry 13.74 5.49 12,447 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710 J D002-3 11388.62 tons dry 12.08 6.46 12,583 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710 J D267-1 11166.81 tons dry 13.53 6.61 12,214 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710 J D003-11 9614.41 tons dry 13.37 6.40 12,409 btu/lb 0.12 ppm 1710 J D004-7 11136.83 tons dry 13.69 5.22 12,493 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710 K D269-3 11154.83 tons dry 11.77 6.93 12,547 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC001-4 11533.55 tons dry 5.16 28.85 8,876 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC001-4 11617.98 tons dry 5.55 28.62 8,869 btu/lb 0.80 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC002-4 11346.69 tons dry 5.88 29.51 8,738 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC002-4 11569.61 tons dry 5.78 28.66 8,820 btu/lb 0.16 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC003-4 11518.83 tons dry 5.76 28.88 8,848 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC003-4 11497.36 tons dry 6.35 29.18 8,726 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC004-4 11657.03 tons dry 5.41 28.14 8,907 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC004-4 11486.97 tons dry 6.51 29.28 8,688 btu/lb 0.12 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC005-4 11587.01 tons dry 5.35 28.78 8,870 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC008-4 11297.32 tons dry 6.11 28.61 8,823 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC009-4 11613.68 tons dry 5.18 28.11 8,963 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC010-4 11547.87 tons dry 5.37 28.37 8,936 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC005-4 11399.20 tons dry 5.92 28.59 8,852 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC006-4 11456.04 tons dry 6.56 28.48 8,805 btu/lb 0.20 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC011-4 11190.77 tons dry 5.13 29.84 8,783 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC012-4 11517.79 tons dry 5.45 28.29 8,924 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC013-4 11341.78 tons dry 5.12 28.76 8,937 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC014-4 11560.64 tons dry 5.02 28.56 8,917 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AM BTMCXC015-4 11518.49 tons dry 5.77 28.65 8,868 btu/lb 0.15 ppm 1710AM WTMCXC007-4 11264.29 tons dry 5.19 29.80 8,801 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC001-4 11441.01 tons dry 4.97 29.18 8,760 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC002-4 11356.00 tons dry 4.33 29.70 8,729 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC003-4 11472.25 tons dry 4.43 29.31 8,829 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC004-4 11285.14 tons dry 4.47 30.04 8,686 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC005-4 10158.52 tons dry 4.67 29.53 8,786 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC006-4 11303.30 tons dry 4.61 30.31 8,721 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC007-4 11280.09 tons dry 4.47 29.92 8,717 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AM NAMCXC008-4 11156.40 tons dry 4.84 29.84 8,679 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC016-4 11356.39 tons dry 4.97 28.95 8,895 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC008-4 11343.37 tons dry 4.74 29.46 8,865 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC009-4 11386.84 tons dry 8.29 28.10 8,576 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC017-4 11530.57 tons dry 4.62 28.84 8,933 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC011-4 11448.95 tons dry 5.46 28.63 8,934 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC018-4 11349.52 tons dry 5.10 28.09 8,943 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC019-4 10788.23 tons dry 4.63 28.83 8,936 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC012-4 11564.43 tons dry 5.28 28.73 8,865 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC013-4 11811.68 tons dry 4.83 29.07 8,935 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC014-4 11453.64 tons dry 4.76 29.53 8,867 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC015-4 11444.10 tons dry 5.14 28.83 8,939 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC020-4 10845.11 tons dry 5.09 28.63 8,951 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC021-4 11577.07 tons dry 5.12 28.58 8,934 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC016-4 11481.38 tons dry 4.74 29.34 8,885 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC022-4 11539.42 tons dry 4.91 28.96 8,922 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC023-4 11562.69 tons dry 4.94 28.78 8,950 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN WTMCXC017-4 11477.12 tons dry 4.65 29.22 8,916 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC024-4 11569.72 tons dry 5.59 28.57 8,916 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AN BTMCXC025-4 11487.78 tons dry 5.15 28.94 8,850 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC009-4 11299.07 tons dry 4.57 30.01 8,654 btu/lb 0.01 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC010-4 11370.71 tons dry 4.44 29.98 8,711 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC011-4 11329.79 tons dry 5.15 30.04 8,615 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC012-4 11722.05 tons dry 4.81 29.42 8,758 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC013-4 11378.89 tons dry 4.78 29.99 8,691 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC014-4 11409.14 tons dry 4.83 29.78 8,688 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC015-4 11372.58 tons dry 4.49 29.84 8,693 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC016-4 11341.19 tons dry 4.24 29.96 8,733 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC017-4 11418.73 tons dry 4.36 29.28 8,828 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AN NAMCXC018-4 11426.76 tons dry 5.15 29.23 8,703 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC026-4 11556.27 tons dry 5.28 28.97 8,842 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC027-4 11377.60 tons dry 6.27 28.90 8,742 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC028-4 11387.48 tons dry 5.53 28.90 8,827 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC029-4 11526.04 tons dry 5.06 28.39 8,938 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC030-4 11639.93 tons dry 6.52 28.46 8,750 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC031-4 11637.96 tons dry 5.31 28.17 8,989 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AO WTMCXC018-4 11440.33 tons dry 4.74 29.27 8,887 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC032-4 10968.22 tons dry 5.13 28.65 8,860 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC033-4 11554.28 tons dry 5.47 28.82 8,950 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC034-4 11591.22 tons dry 5.28 28.69 8,873 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC035-4 11588.02 tons dry 5.68 28.16 8,878 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC036-4 11487.10 tons dry 4.83 28.93 8,948 btu/lb 0.12 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC037-4 11576.43 tons dry 4.74 28.72 8,939 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC038-4 11486.42 tons dry 5.43 28.96 8,871 btu/lb 0.13 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC039-4 11594.52 tons dry 5.16 28.77 8,883 btu/lb 0.09 ppm Sample ID Suffix Code

EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0234-DRAFT-2428.xls Page 1 of 4 3/23/10Consumers Energy
EPA ICR Response 

### JHCampbell Coal Shipment Analysis

2009

ORIS
Code Shipment ID Sample ID Amount
Received units Sulfur % %Ash HHV units Mercury units Sample ID Suffix Code

1710AO BTMCXC040-4 11593.85 tons dry 6.46 28.51 8,757 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC041-4 11532.52 tons dry 5.58 28.59 8,875 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC042-4 11601.48 tons dry 5.02 28.55 8,968 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC912-4 11631.49 tons dry 5.78 28.46 8,864 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AO BTMCXC043-4 11504.88 tons dry 5.71 28.71 8,840 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AO NAMCXC019-4 11410.96 tons dry 4.77 29.35 8,781 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AO NAMCXC020-4 11332.91 tons dry 4.54 30.18 8,681 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AO NAMCXC021-4 11407.23 tons dry 5.00 29.68 8,655 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AO NAMCXC022-4 11262.66 tons dry 4.55 30.47 8,655 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AO NAMCXC023-4 11418.51 tons dry 4.61 29.35 8,785 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AO NAMCXC024-4 10936.20 tons dry 4.25 30.11 8,736 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC044-4 11481.46 tons dry 5.88 28.85 8,794 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC045-4 11524.90 tons dry 5.26 28.82 8,849 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC046-4 11570.48 tons dry 5.35 28.72 8,917 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC047-4 11539.40 tons dry 5.05 28.74 8,950 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC048-4 11598.68 tons dry 5.26 28.64 8,902 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC049-4 11502.40 tons dry 5.49 29.03 8,863 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC050-4 11472.66 tons dry 5.11 29.06 8,870 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AP WTMCXC019-4 11499.15 tons dry 5.09 29.46 8,857 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP WTMCXC020-4 11518.40 tons dry 5.45 29.29 8,811 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC051-4 11586.73 tons dry 5.29 28.53 8,883 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AP WTMCXC021-4 11666.58 tons dry 4.82 28.56 8,975 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP WTMCXC022-4 11642.79 tons dry 5.61 28.68 8,889 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC052-4 11435.74 tons dry 5.29 28.97 8,868 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AP WTMCXC023-4 11448.02 tons dry 6.42 29.47 8,649 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AP WTMCXC024-4 11423.73 tons dry 4.87 29.40 8,886 btu/lb 0.14 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC053-4 11487.81 tons dry 4.47 29.10 8,892 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC054-4 11401.31 tons dry 4.86 29.35 8,840 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC055-4 11506.95 tons dry 4.56 29.15 8,904 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC056-4 11586.20 tons dry 4.89 28.81 8,912 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AP BTMCXC057-4 11542.90 tons dry 4.57 28.95 8,938 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP NAMCXC025-4 11428.87 tons dry 5.09 29.69 8,707 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AP NAMCXC026-4 11417.53 tons dry 4.67 29.53 8,773 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AP NAMCXC027-4 11489.04 tons dry 5.04 29.28 8,753 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AP NAMCXC028-4 11342.58 tons dry 4.75 30.26 8,655 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AP NAMCXC029-4 11377.24 tons dry 5.07 29.93 8,649 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AQ WTMCXC025-4 11480.77 tons dry 5.73 29.58 8,720 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ WTMCXC026-4 11375.55 tons dry 5.16 29.84 8,793 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC058-4 11568.40 tons dry 5.84 28.67 8,862 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC059-4 11489.65 tons dry 6.95 27.93 8,797 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC060-4 11629.38 tons dry 5.68 28.61 8,851 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC061-4 11613.26 tons dry 5.14 28.42 8,978 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC062-4 11710.14 tons dry 5.31 27.93 8,984 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AQ WTMCXC028-4 11493.91 tons dry 6.32 29.00 8,786 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC063-4 11600.86 tons dry 4.87 28.59 8,929 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC064-4 11585.43 tons dry 6.21 28.50 8,835 btu/lb 0.12 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC065-4 11659.49 tons dry 5.99 28.11 8,848 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC066-4 11488.93 tons dry 5.40 28.61 8,881 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC068-4 11681.98 tons dry 5.18 28.17 8,962 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ WTMCXC906-4 11587.62 tons dry 4.90 28.83 8,995 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AQ WTMCXC029-4 11597.79 tons dry 6.47 28.48 8,739 btu/lb 0.13 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC069-4 11559.18 tons dry 4.59 28.67 8,976 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC070-4 11587.87 tons dry 4.78 28.52 8,973 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AQ BTMCXC071-4 11559.66 tons dry 5.30 28.72 8,828 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AQ WTMCXC030-4 11629.11 tons dry 5.36 28.62 8,912 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AQ NAMCXC907-4 11281.79 tons dry 4.78 29.85 8,697 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AQ NAMCXC030-4 11433.14 tons dry 5.66 29.70 8,605 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AQ NAMCXC031-4 11447.40 tons dry 4.92 29.51 8,733 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AQ NAMCXC032-4 11401.87 tons dry 5.29 29.75 8,638 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AQ NAMCXC033-4 11517.65 tons dry 4.67 28.88 8,813 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC034-4 11447.65 tons dry 4.99 29.57 8,728 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AR WTMCXC031-4 11457.45 tons dry 5.56 29.34 8,774 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AR WTMCXC032-4 11557.39 tons dry 5.53 28.79 8,849 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC072-4 11554.88 tons dry 5.77 28.71 8,748 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC073-4 11595.03 tons dry 5.29 28.10 8,873 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC074-4 11527.42 tons dry 5.58 28.99 8,785 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AR WTMCXC033-4 11332.36 tons dry 4.59 29.62 8,876 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC076-4 11461.24 tons dry 5.69 29.35 8,771 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AR WTMCXC035-4 11492.45 tons dry 4.82 29.13 8,857 btu/lb 0.14 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC077-4 11588.13 tons dry 6.06 28.68 8,796 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC078-4 11441.15 tons dry 5.91 29.28 8,784 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC079-4 11532.88 tons dry 5.22 29.04 8,872 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AR WTMCXC037-4 11577.42 tons dry 5.39 28.37 8,940 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC080-4 11607.01 tons dry 5.07 28.97 8,920 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC081-4 11545.24 tons dry 5.14 28.81 8,870 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC082-4 11497.10 tons dry 5.21 29.11 8,878 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC083-4 11590.30 tons dry 4.24 28.57 9,013 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AR BTMCXC084-4 11503.05 tons dry 4.91 28.87 8,867 btu/lb 0.14 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC035-4 11599.59 tons dry 4.61 28.98 8,834 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC036-4 11460.54 tons dry 5.05 29.37 8,710 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC037-4 11319.33 tons dry 4.67 30.12 8,643 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC038-4 11368.62 tons dry 4.28 29.69 8,759 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC039-4 11443.38 tons dry 4.67 29.55 8,825 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC040-4 11428.40 tons dry 5.11 29.44 8,633 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC041-4 11391.48 tons dry 4.94 29.69 8,729 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC042-4 10154.66 tons dry 4.92 29.43 8,772 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AR NAMCXC043-4 11239.26 tons dry 5.31 29.40 8,665 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS ATMCXC001-5 11581.65 tons dry 5.75 28.12 8,793 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS ATMCXC002-5 11550.11 tons dry 5.35 28.34 8,846 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC085-4 11538.43 tons dry 5.27 28.83 8,866 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC086-4 11538.36 tons dry 4.82 28.96 8,901 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC087-4 11579.25 tons dry 5.83 28.46 8,795 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC088-4 11507.63 tons dry 5.28 28.95 8,868 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC038-4 11561.48 tons dry 5.56 28.68 8,866 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC089-4 11547.34 tons dry 5.11 28.66 8,877 btu/lb 0.12 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC090-4 11636.54 tons dry 6.06 28.32 8,848 btu/lb 0.13 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC039-4 11511.59 tons dry 5.95 29.12 8,747 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC040-4 11492.48 tons dry 6.17 29.07 8,744 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC091-4 11660.45 tons dry 6.57 28.07 8,818 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC092-4 11595.26 tons dry 4.81 28.48 8,937 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC041-4 11540.33 tons dry 5.34 28.92 8,900 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC042-4 11513.82 tons dry 5.30 29.21 8,885 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC093-4 11690.78 tons dry 5.92 28.00 8,852 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC043-4 11490.11 tons dry 5.88 29.05 8,763 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC094-4 11604.15 tons dry 5.94 28.32 8,850 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AS BTMCXC095-4 11537.98 tons dry 5.19 28.84 8,829 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC044-4 11515.23 tons dry 5.02 29.08 8,908 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC045-4 11530.11 tons dry 5.23 29.08 8,831 btu/lb 0.09 ppm

EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0234-DRAFT-2428.xls Page 2 of 4 3/23/10Consumers Energy
EPA ICR Response 

### JHCampbell Coal Shipment Analysis

2009

ORIS
Code Shipment ID Sample ID Amount
Received units Sulfur % %Ash HHV units Mercury units Sample ID Suffix Code

1710AS BTMCXC916-4 11540.22 tons dry 5.68 28.92 8,786 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AS WTMCXC046-4 11570.96 tons dry 4.72 28.63 8,983 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AS NAMCXC044-4 11479.70 tons dry 4.68 29.20 8,786 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS NAMCXC045-4 11453.68 tons dry 4.75 29.69 8,749 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AS NAMCXC047-4 11533.46 tons dry 4.89 29.43 8,739 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AS NAMCXC048-4 11561.34 tons dry 4.95 28.81 8,826 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AS NAMCXC049-4 11529.93 tons dry 4.78 28.97 8,817 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AS NAMCXC050-4 11490.34 tons dry 4.64 29.30 8,775 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AT ATMCXC003-5 11639.90 tons dry 6.46 28.05 8,716 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT ATMCXC004-5 11639.26 tons dry 5.31 27.95 8,909 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT ATMCXC005-5 11624.99 tons dry 4.75 27.75 9,004 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT ATMCXC006-5 11709.60 tons dry 5.52 27.28 8,933 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT ATMCXC007-5 11588.14 tons dry 4.90 27.59 9,025 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT BTMCXC096-4 11617.77 tons dry 5.65 28.43 8,863 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT BTMCXC097-4 11580.56 tons dry 5.10 28.72 8,857 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC047-4 11414.29 tons dry 4.62 29.76 8,895 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AT BTMCXC098-4 11587.52 tons dry 5.22 28.60 8,918 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC048-4 11377.12 tons dry 4.81 29.89 8,847 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC049-4 11477.01 tons dry 5.00 29.22 8,859 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AT BTMCXC099-4 11644.24 tons dry 5.39 28.34 8,927 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC050-4 11605.33 tons dry 6.48 28.64 8,753 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC051-4 11613.74 tons dry 5.70 28.59 8,912 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC052-4 11552.73 tons dry 5.49 28.74 8,890 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC053-4 11517.76 tons dry 5.07 28.95 8,899 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC054-4 11486.48 tons dry 5.36 28.81 8,897 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC055-4 11516.86 tons dry 4.77 29.14 8,898 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC056-4 11533.81 tons dry 4.77 29.03 8,947 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC057-4 11486.58 tons dry 5.11 29.19 8,852 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AT WTMCXC058-4 11453.18 tons dry 4.73 29.62 8,872 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AT NAMCXC051-4 11495.12 tons dry 4.63 29.13 8,830 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AT NAMCXC052-4 11402.46 tons dry 4.94 29.42 8,732 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT NAMCXC053-4 11463.83 tons dry 4.66 29.35 8,804 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT NAMCXC054-4 11428.49 tons dry 4.91 29.21 8,742 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AT NAMCXC055-4 11383.91 tons dry 4.63 30.01 8,657 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AU ATMCXC008-5 10684.67 tons dry 5.20 27.44 8,971 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU ATMCXC009-5 11691.09 tons dry 4.96 27.48 8,985 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU ATMCXC010-5 11684.41 tons dry 4.90 27.48 8,998 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU ATMCXC011-5 11637.67 tons dry 5.76 28.07 8,836 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC059-4 11515.62 tons dry 5.20 28.51 8,939 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC060-4 11576.64 tons dry 5.43 28.73 8,918 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC061-4 11638.41 tons dry 5.00 28.33 8,989 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AU BTMCXC100-4 11584.95 tons dry 5.63 28.50 8,851 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AU BTMCXC101-4 11585.49 tons dry 5.94 28.51 8,896 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC906-4 11588.57 tons dry 5.56 28.74 8,880 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC062-4 11569.84 tons dry 4.91 28.65 8,912 btu/lb 0.13 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC063-4 11576.21 tons dry 5.72 29.23 8,799 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU BTMCXC102-4 11535.25 tons dry 6.18 28.97 8,742 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU WTMCXC064-4 11619.86 tons dry 5.58 29.15 8,812 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU BTMCXC103-4 11560.27 tons dry 5.32 28.82 8,927 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC056-4 11504.55 tons dry 4.71 29.23 8,794 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC057-4 11387.52 tons dry 4.95 29.98 8,663 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC058-4 11451.72 tons dry 5.21 29.46 8,729 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC059-4 11401.72 tons dry 5.12 29.63 8,624 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC915-4 11383.23 tons dry 5.03 29.24 8,760 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC060-4 11417.62 tons dry 4.99 29.88 8,622 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AU NAMCXC061-4 11482.74 tons dry 4.88 29.24 8,779 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC104-4 11561.91 tons dry 5.65 28.79 8,863 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AV WTMCXC065-4 11472.41 tons dry 4.81 29.53 8,907 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC105-4 11438.31 tons dry 4.90 29.34 8,844 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC106-4 11499.18 tons dry 6.13 28.98 8,765 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC107-4 11452.02 tons dry 5.41 29.31 8,847 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC108-4 11578.60 tons dry 5.84 28.63 8,860 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC109-4 11603.28 tons dry 5.57 28.49 8,885 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AV WTMCXC066-4 11136.17 tons dry 5.44 29.68 8,777 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC110-4 11526.85 tons dry 5.07 28.40 8,864 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV WTMCXC067-4 11438.74 tons dry 5.05 29.58 8,837 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC112-4 11501.33 tons dry 7.00 28.50 8,709 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC113-4 11546.28 tons dry 4.61 28.72 8,944 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC114-4 11649.54 tons dry 5.27 28.25 8,913 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AV WTMCXC068-4 11488.62 tons dry 6.58 29.16 8,667 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC115-4 11526.55 tons dry 5.53 28.89 8,850 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC116-4 11550.37 tons dry 5.16 29.05 8,877 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC117-4 11649.97 tons dry 5.58 28.28 8,912 btu/lb 0.08 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC118-4 11615.44 tons dry 5.26 28.50 8,887 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV WTMCXC069-4 11520.91 tons dry 5.08 28.59 8,933 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC119-4 11489.52 tons dry 5.21 28.99 8,868 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC120-4 11478.75 tons dry 5.02 28.93 8,859 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AV BTMCXC121-4 11478.23 tons dry 5.54 29.06 8,853 btu/lb 0.13 ppm 1710AV NAMCXC062-4 11407.12 tons dry 5.18 29.61 8,748 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV NAMCXC063-4 11427.93 tons dry 4.66 29.28 8,814 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV NAMCXC064-4 11551.61 tons dry 4.80 28.68 8,821 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AV NAMCXC065-4 11325.41 tons dry 4.63 29.52 8,770 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AV NAMCXC066-4 11460.63 tons dry 5.20 29.07 8,731 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW ATMCXC013-5 11738.99 tons dry 5.56 27.30 8,976 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1710AW ATMCXC014-5 11718.64 tons dry 5.34 27.28 8,998 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1710AW ATMCXC015-5 11642.70 tons dry 5.39 27.76 8,912 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1710AW ATMCXC016-5 11617.07 tons dry 6.11 27.95 8,755 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC123-4 11575.31 tons dry 5.75 28.58 8,850 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC126-4 11640.41 tons dry 5.09 28.45 8,931 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC127-4 11635.27 tons dry 4.95 28.14 8,985 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AW WTMCXC070-4 11469.64 tons dry 5.54 29.41 8,838 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW WTMCXC071-4 11427.66 tons dry 4.36 29.72 8,909 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC128-4 11730.65 tons dry 5.03 28.44 8,946 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC129-4 11658.01 tons dry 4.90 27.97 9,015 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW WTMCXC072-4 11492.19 tons dry 4.61 28.75 8,982 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC130-4 11598.33 tons dry 5.08 28.50 8,953 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC131-4 11535.18 tons dry 5.51 28.40 8,881 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW BTMCXC132-4 11559.73 tons dry 5.58 28.93 8,853 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC070-4 11537.10 tons dry 4.61 29.29 8,804 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC071-4 11499.05 tons dry 4.68 29.11 8,822 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC072-4 11514.15 tons dry 5.03 28.77 8,797 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC073-4 11482.37 tons dry 5.03 29.21 8,712 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC074-4 11480.05 tons dry 5.07 29.35 8,730 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC075-4 11242.34 tons dry 4.29 29.56 8,813 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC076-4 11349.83 tons dry 4.71 29.84 8,624 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AW NAMCXC077-4 11330.24 tons dry 4.51 29.96 8,706 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX ATMCXC017-5 11607.74 tons dry 6.00 28.00 8,824 btu/lb 0.04 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC133-4 11522.50 tons dry 5.92 28.89 8,814 btu/lb 0.08 ppm

EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0234-DRAFT-2428.xls Page 3 of 4 3/23/10Consumers Energy
EPA ICR Response 

### JHCampbell Coal Shipment Analysis

2009

ORIS
Code Shipment ID Sample ID Amount
Received units Sulfur % %Ash HHV units Mercury units Sample ID Suffix Code

1710AX WTMCXC073-4 11203.28 tons dry 4.47 29.45 8,990 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX WTMCXC074-4 11503.01 tons dry 4.51 29.10 8,987 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC134-4 11635.73 tons dry 5.45 28.32 8,944 btu/lb 0.10 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC135-4 11588.22 tons dry 5.79 28.73 8,863 btu/lb 0.09 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC136-4 10945.52 tons dry 5.52 28.68 8,889 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX WTMCXC075-4 11377.01 tons dry 4.66 29.69 8,848 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC137-4 11490.33 tons dry 5.28 28.67 8,859 btu/lb 0.11 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC138-4 11486.46 tons dry 5.78 28.74 8,849 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX BTMCXC139-4 11526.01 tons dry 5.53 28.76 8,890 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX WTMCXC076-4 11320.59 tons dry 5.22 29.43 8,825 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC078-4 11224.11 tons dry 4.91 29.78 8,680 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC079-4 11169.23 tons dry 4.83 29.54 8,792 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC080-4 11418.49 tons dry 5.02 29.45 8,747 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC919-4 11065.27 tons dry 4.80 29.45 8,755 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC918-4 11184.24 tons dry 5.47 30.46 8,526 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC081-4 11307.30 tons dry 4.59 29.56 8,710 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC083-4 11068.78 tons dry 5.11 29.94 8,573 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC084-4 11297.31 tons dry 4.91 28.92 8,812 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC085-4 11461.70 tons dry 4.76 29.50 8,749 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC086-4 11461.04 tons dry 4.91 29.24 8,710 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC087-4 11357.44 tons dry 4.90 30.06 8,661 btu/lb 0.05 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC088-4 11328.48 tons dry 4.95 29.29 8,748 btu/lb 0.07 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC089-4 7363.65 tons dry 4.63 29.23 8,771 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC090-4 11320.92 tons dry 5.55 29.45 8,640 btu/lb 0.06 ppm 1710AX NAMCXC091-4 11273.82 tons dry 4.43 29.80 8,698 btu/lb 0.06 ppm

EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0234-DRAFT-2428.xls Page 4 of 4 3/23/10