12-138 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION, Docket No.: FAA-2014-0807 

Complainant, FAA Case No. 2011S0190272 

vs. Judge: J.E. Sullivan 

PAZ AVIATION, INC., Location of Hearing: Miami, FL 

Respondent. 

------------------------~/ 

MOTION TO DISMISS 

Respondent, PAZ AVIATION, INC. ("Respondent"), by and through its 

undersigned counsel, moves for an Order Dismissing the above styled action and as 

grounds therefor states: 

l. The Administrator brought this action seeking a Civil Penalty against 

Respondent for alleged violations of certain Federal Aviation Regulations. 

2. In response to the Administrator's Complaint, Respondent filed an Answer 

which included an Affirmative Defenses of laches. 

3. On November 19,2014, this Comi entered its Order advising the parties 

that it was treating the Affirmative Defense of laches as a Motion to Dismiss and, on 

December23, 2014, issued an Order with a briefing schedule on the Motion to Dismiss. 

4. On January 23,2015, Respondent timely filed its Memorandum in support 

of the Motion to Dismiss on the grounds of laches. Pursuant to the court's briefing Order, 

the Administrator's Memorandum was due on February 13,2015. 

5. The Administrator failed to comply with this Court's Order as it has not 

timely filed its brief nor sought an extension oftime within which to do so. 

1'lcDONALD & i\IcDONALD. P. A,; P. 0. Bo.-..: 669122,1\Iiami, FL33166~9428 

TEL.: (305) 643~5313, FAX: (305) 643-4990; E-MAIL: dmm@Mcdom'lld<lttorncys.com 

8 ~:z: 9 ~OZ/6 ~n:o £ .JO ~ a6ed £6Z~·L9Z: (Z:OZ:) ~+ X!l..:l 
. WHI'J~Bl~OR.E:ResJ)oridet1f, PAZ AVIATION, tNC.,pfay$.timt the a~ove matter 

· bedisillisiiCdwithprej\idice and snehfunh~1: relief. as ihis coud deetris eqitii:abl~ bt: just . 

. :Re,spcctfully st1bmiited; 

McDONALb&lvtcbdNAtb · 

B~irt~.~~~~~~~tZ? 

. C.Eii'tl'F1CATE OF SERVICE . 

. l IIEREB ¥.certify ;hat the odgihal ahd oiie, b<ipy;)J:' the foregoillg was faxed ~~tel 

· ·. lllailedthis ~cjtl\ day (l{Fellrt~~~·y,.2015 to: 

· · I-ron. J.K St1ftivatt, AdminiStrative Law jitdge 

Office ofHeadJJg$, M~20 

US • .DejlarttM!lt ot Tnn'isj5ottatiQ.it 

· I2001\!ew.TerseyAvet1tle, S.K (Ell-310) 

. Washit\ji;toli, J)G :20590 

2\}2-366c694l ... 

202~366·753.6.. fax . . . 

Hetii'ittg becket Clerk · 

· FAA;.AGCc430, Suite2W1000 

Wilbur Wi.lght Bt!ildiiig .. 

. . .Boo Indep<;trdcnct;Avenue;. SW . Washltlgton;.J5C :20591 

2 02'267-1293 "' fax 

·- . \Xillllmil Vit1es, Att6Yiiey 

Fedei'al Avit!tlon Adhlinishatibtt 

-, Olfice ofthe n.¢gimml Counsel, AS0-7 

.. SouthernRegio11 · 

1701 ColiHlibinA,,ehue 

. College Prttk, GA 30337 

404 305-'5200 -tel. 

· · 404 305-'5223 "'fax 

Complaiitanl 's Counsel 

2 

(ofigiital+ ltopy) 

. _-. __ -t\tdJ6NA-t_i~ ~%-M"~:OhN_At_;Ji l~,.}~l:P,p. _ri?'X6691.2:2::--Nn~ill_i~:~F-~aJIG_6-:?'f2S· .. · TEL,: (J.05) 64J""5~ J.3.1.EAX:: (30~):64J-c4990;_ E~MAIL: .. dntm@M.cdonu!Oiitt~meys.eom 
Paz Avi<~ti.oJi, 1i1c,, 

c/o }ay Alleti,. President 

7455 W211° Coutt .. . ..• 

I-Iialcah,FL 330144:\01 

Re.wonde~~t . 

Mcbo:NACD & McDbNA.Lb, fA. Auot·i1~vs']oYRMpondd11t · P 0 Box 669122 · 

Miil!ni,. FL 3 3166·942& . (3(15)643-$3!3. 

{305)643"4990 '- fax ··. . 

dmm@McdoniildatfotJ\cys.coJll .•.. 

¥0~~4~o~;;;:,y~~;·. ~"4:'favid M .. McDoni!ld · ... ·. · ·· .... ··... ·. 

Fla. BarNo• 0844380 . 

l\ i\:DOi>fA Lth~:-i'i·lCDONALDi·p;-A;.f P,_ (J,J1o~- 61J912·~·-;:_i\ll_~_iili~· FL. J_-3:tGG~~J4'?.8 

. - TEL;:· (305) 643--53 tJ; FAX: (305) G43-•l990;_-E~MAIL:· \hllm@Mcdqna!dR!ttit1ieys.c·6il'i