D fW hirat–asngtonHuman Health CriteriaReview DocumentsSection1– Freshwatercriteriacomparisonbychemical(NTR,Governor’sProposal,and2otherscenarios)Revised8/8/2014Section2– Marinewatercriteriacomparisonbychemical(NTR,Governor’sProposal,and2otherscenarios)Section3– CalculationsandfactorsusedtoderiveproposedfreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaforeachchemicalSection4– CalculationsandfactorsusedtoderiveproposedmarinewaterHumanHealthCriteriaforeachchemicalSection5– ComparisonsummaryofcurrentNationalToxicsRule(NTR)criteriaandthecriteriaderivedfromtheGovernor’sproposalThis page purposely left blankComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐FRESHWATER†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→2 L/day 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-51,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane0.17 0.14 1.4 0.17NoChange1,1,2-Trichloroethane0.60 0.50 5.0 0.60NoChange1,1-Dichloroethylene0.0571,3421,3420.057NoChange1,2,4-TrichlorobenzeneNC 36 36 36‐‐1,2-Dichlorobenzene2,700614 614 6144.41,2-Dichloroethane0.38 0.40 4.0 0.38NoChange1,2-DichloropropaneNC0.44 4.4 4.4‐‐1,2-Diphenylhydrazine0.040 0.016 0.16 0.040NoChange1,2-Trans-DichloroethyleneNC 703 703 703‐‐1,3-Dichlorobenzene40091 91 914.41,3-Dichloropropene1010.3 10.3 10NoChange1,4-Dichlorobenzene40091 91 914.42,3,7,8-TCDD (Dioxin)0.0000000130.000000064 0.000000064 0.000000013NoChange2,4,6-Trichlorophenol2.1 0.26 2.6 2.1NoChange2,4-Dichlorophenol9326 26 263.52,4-DimethylphenolNC87 87 87‐‐2,4-Dinitrophenol7071 71 70NoChange2,4-Dinitrotoluene0.11 0.10 0.97 0.11NoChange2-ChloronaphthaleneNC 171 171 171‐‐2-ChlorophenolNC 16 16 16‐‐2-Methyl-4,6-Dinitrophenol131111111.33,3'-Dichlorobenzidine0.040 0.0031 0.031 0.0311.34,4'-DDD0.00083 0.000036 0.00036 0.000362.34,4'-DDE0.00059 0.000025 0.00025 0.000252.44,4'-DDT0.00059 0.000025 0.00025 0.000252.4AcenaphtheneNC 108 108 108‐‐Acrolein3201.01.01.0317Acrylonitrile0.059 0.020 0.20 0.059NoChangeAldrin0.00013 0.0000057 0.000057 0.0000572.3Lowest of NTR orScenario 3FRESHWATERScenario 2 Scenario 3Governor'sProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Section1Revised8/8/14ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐FRESHWATER†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→2 L/day 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-5Lowest of NTR orScenario 3FRESHWATERScenario 2 Scenario 3Governor'sProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*alpha-BHC0.0039 0.00051 0.0051 0.0039NoChangealpha-Endosulfan0.93 9.7 9.7 0.93NoChangeAnthracene9,6003,3103,3103,3102.9Antimony14151514NoChangeArsenic0.018 0.0047 0.04710**‐‐Asbestos7,000,000 fibers/L**7,000,000 fibers/L**7,000,000 fibers/L**7,000,000 fibers/L**NoChangeBenzene1.2 1.8 18 1.2NoChangeBenzidine0.00012 0.000020 0.00020 0.00012NoChangeBenzo(a)Anthracene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangeBenzo(a)Pyrene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangeBenzo(b)Fluoranthene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangeBenzo(k)Fluoranthene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangebeta-BHC0.014 0.0018 0.018 0.014NoChangebeta-Endosulfan0.93 9.7 9.7 0.93NoChangeBis(2-Chloroethyl)Ether0.031 0.023 0.23 0.031NoChangeBis(2-Chloroisopropyl) Ether1,4001,3161,3161,3161.1Bis(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate1.8 0.23 2.3 1.8NoChangeBromoform4.3 3.8 38 4.3NoChangeButylbenzyl PhthalateNC 215 215 215‐‐Carbon Tetrachloride0.25 0.12 1.2 0.25NoChangeChlordane0.00057 0.000093 0.00093 0.00057NoChangeChlorobenzene6804214214211.6Chlorodibromomethane0.41 0.36 3.6 0.41NoChangeChloroform5.7301 301 5.7NoChangeChrysene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangeCopperNC 1,300** 1,300** 1,300**‐‐Cyanide700736736700NoChangeDibenzo (a,h) Anthracene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangeDichlorobromomethane0.27 0.49 4.9 0.27NoChangeSection1Revised8/8/14ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐FRESHWATER†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→2 L/day 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-5Lowest of NTR orScenario 3FRESHWATERScenario 2 Scenario 3Governor'sProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Dieldrin0.00014 0.0000061 0.000061 0.0000612.3Diethyl Phthalate23,0004,3324,3324,3325.3Dimethyl Phthalate313,00096,38696,38696,3863.2Di-n-Butyl Phthalate2,7004554554555.9Endosulfan Sulfate0.93 9.7 9.7 0.93NoChangeEndrin0.76 0.034 0.034 0.03422Endrin Aldehyde0.76 0.034 0.034 0.03422Ethylbenzene3,1009349349343.3Fluoranthene30016161619Fluorene1,3004414414412.9gamma-BHC (Lindane)0.0190.97 0.97 0.019NoChangeHeptachlor0.00021 0.0000091 0.000091 0.0000912.3Heptachlor Epoxide0.00010 0.0000045 0.000045 0.0000452.2Hexachlorobenzene0.00075 0.000033 0.00033 0.000332.3Hexachlorobutadiene0.44 0.41 4.1 0.44NoChangeHexachloro-cyclopentadiene2401741741741.4Hexachloroethane1.9 0.33 3.3 1.9NoChangeIndeno (1,2,3-cd) Pyrene0.0028 0.0015 0.015 0.0028NoChangeIsophorone8.4 30 304 8.4NoChangeMethyl Bromide484242421.1Methylene Chloride4.7 4.9 49 4.7NoChangeNickel6101561561563.9Nitrobenzene171616161.1N-Nitrosodimethylamine0.00069 0.00078 0.0078 0.00069NoChangeN-Nitrosodi-n-PropylamineNC0.0052 0.052 0.052‐‐N-Nitrosodiphenylamine5.0 0.63 6.3 5.0NoChangePentachlorophenol0.28 0.17 1.7 0.28NoChangePhenol21,00010,69010,69010,6902.0Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs)0.00017 0.0000073 0.0000730.00017***NoChangeSection1Revised8/8/14ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐FRESHWATER†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→2 L/day 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-5Lowest of NTR orScenario 3FRESHWATERScenario 2 Scenario 3Governor'sProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Pyrene9603313313312.9SeleniumNC 141141141‐‐Tetrachloroethylene0.80 0.27 2.7 0.80NoChangeThallium1.7 0.24 0.24 0.247.0Toluene6,8004,1324,1324,1321.6Toxaphene0.00073 0.000032 0.00032 0.000322.3Trichloroethylene2.7 1.6 16 2.7NoChangeVinyl Chloride2.0 0.026 0.26 0.267.7ZincNC 2,3472,3472,347‐‐GENERALNOTES:FOOTNOTES:**BasedonDrinkingWaterMCL***PCBscalculatedusinga4x10‐5risklevel,resultinginacriterionof0.00029ug/L;sinceitishigherthanNTR,theNTRisusedintheGovernor'sProposal.†Criteriaarebasedonconsumptionofwater&organismsRedFontindicatesCarcinogen*TheGovernor'sproposalresultsinanequalorlowercriterionforeachchemical.Thenumberrepresentstheratioofreduction.Allcriteriavaluesareexpressedasug/LunlessnotedotherwiseCriterionisLowerComparedtoNTRCriterionisHigherComparedtoNTRCriterionisforNewChemicalCriterionremainingthesamearenotshadedNC=nocriterionSection1Revised8/8/14ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐MarineWater†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→000Fish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-51,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane110.464.64.62.41,1,2-Trichloroethane421.818182.41,1-Dichloroethylene3.24,0824,0823.2NoChange1,2,4-TrichlorobenzeneNC 404040‐‐1,2-Dichlorobenzene17,000740740740231,2-Dichloroethane994.242422.41,2-DichloropropaneNC1.71717‐‐1,2-Diphenylhydrazine0.540.0230.230.232.41,2-Trans-DichloroethyleneNC 5,7875,7875,787‐‐1,3-Dichlorobenzene2,600110110110241,3-Dichloropropene1,700727272241,4-Dichlorobenzene2,600110110110242,3,7,8-TCDD (Dioxin)0.0000000140.0000000640.0000000640.000000014NoChange2,4,6-Trichlorophenol6.50.282.82.82.32,4-Dichlorophenol790343434232,4-DimethylphenolNC 979797‐‐2,4-Dinitrophenol14,000610610610232,4-Dinitrotoluene9.10.393.93.92.42-ChloronaphthaleneNC 181181181‐‐2-ChlorophenolNC 171717‐‐2-Methyl-4,6-Dinitrophenol765323232243,3'-Dichlorobenzidine0.0770.00330.0330.0332.44,4'-DDD0.000840.0000360.000360.000362.44,4'-DDE0.000590.0000250.000250.000252.44,4'-DDT0.000590.0000250.000250.000252.4AcenaphtheneNC 113113113‐‐Acrolein7801.11.11.1734Acrylonitrile0.660.0280.280.282.3Aldrin0.000140.00000580.0000580.0000582.4MARINEScenario 2 Scenario 3 Governor's ProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Lowest of NTR orScenario 3Section2Revised8/8/2014ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐MarineWater†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→000Fish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-5MARINEScenario 2 Scenario 3 Governor's ProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Lowest of NTR orScenario 3alpha-BHC0.0130.000560.00560.00562.3alpha-Endosulfan2.010102.0NoChangeAnthracene110,0004,5714,5714,57124Antimony4,30018318318324Arsenic0.140.00590.05910**‐‐AsbestosNC NC NC NC‐‐Benzene715.959591.2Benzidine0.000540.0000230.000230.000232.4Benzo(a)Anthracene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5Benzo(a)Pyrene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5Benzo(b)Fluoranthene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5Benzo(k)Fluoranthene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5beta-BHC0.0460.00200.0200.0202.4beta-Endosulfan2.010102.0NoChangeBis(2-Chloroethyl)Ether1.40.0600.600.602.3Bis(2-Chloroisopropyl) Ether170,0007,4037,4037,40323Bis(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate5.90.252.52.52.3Bromoform360151541542.3Butylbenzyl PhthalateNC 221221221‐‐Carbon Tetrachloride4.40.191.91.92.3Chlordane0.000590.0000930.000930.00059NoChangeChlorobenzene21,00088888888824Chlorodibromomethane341.515152.3Chloroform4701,2191,219470NoChangeChrysene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5CopperNC NC NC NC‐‐Cyanide220,0009,1439,1439,14324Dibenzo (a,h) Anthracene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5Dichlorobromomethane222.020201.1Section2Revised8/8/2014ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐MarineWater†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→000Fish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-5MARINEScenario 2 Scenario 3 Governor's ProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Lowest of NTR orScenario 3Dieldrin0.000140.00000610.0000610.0000612.3Diethyl Phthalate120,0005,0105,0105,01024Dimethyl Phthalate2,900,000126,984126,984126,98423Di-n-Butyl Phthalate12,00051451451423Endosulfan Sulfate2.010102.0NoChangeEndrin0.810.0350.0350.03523Endrin Aldehyde0.810.0350.0350.03523Ethylbenzene29,0001,2191,2191,21924Fluoranthene37016161623Fluorene14,00061061061023gamma-BHC (Lindane)0.0631.11.10.063NoChangeHeptachlor0.000210.00000910.0000910.0000912.3Heptachlor Epoxide0.000110.00000450.0000450.0000452.5Hexachlorobenzene0.000770.0000330.000330.000332.3Hexachlorobutadiene502.121212.4Hexachloro-cyclopentadiene17,00063263263227Hexachloroethane8.90.383.83.82.4Indeno (1,2,3-cd) Pyrene0.0310.00210.0210.0211.5Isophorone6001101,099600NoChangeMethyl Bromide4,00017117117123Methylene Chloride1,600686776772.4Nickel4,60019519519524Nitrobenzene1,90079797924N-Nitrosodimethylamine8.10.343.43.42.3N-Nitrosodi-n-PropylamineNC0.0580.580.58‐‐N-Nitrosodiphenylamine160.696.96.92.3Pentachlorophenol8.20.353.53.52.4Phenol4,600,00097,95997,95997,95947Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs)0.000170.00000730.0000730.00017***NoChangeSection2Revised8/8/2014ComparisonofHumanHealthCriteria‐MarineWater†Scenario 1(NTR)Body Weight (BW)→70 kg 80 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI)→000Fish Consumption Rate (FCR)→6.5 g/day175 g/day175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)→1 x 10-61 x 10-61 x 10-5MARINEScenario 2 Scenario 3 Governor's ProposalBywhatfactoristhecriteriareducedfromcurrentNTRtotheGovernor'sproposal?*Lowest of NTR orScenario 3Pyrene11,00045745745724SeleniumNC 476476476‐‐Tetrachloroethylene8.90.383.83.82.4Thallium6.30.270.270.2724Toluene200,0008,5458,5458,54523Toxaphene0.000750.0000320.000320.000322.4Trichloroethylene813.434342.4Vinyl Chloride5250.282.82.8188ZincNC 2,9182,9182,918‐‐GENERALNOTES:Marinecriteriaalsoapplytothosefreshwatersthatarenotdesignatedas"DomesticWaterSupplyUse"‐drinkingwaterintakeiszeroFOOTNOTES:Allcriteriavaluesareexpressedasug/LunlessnotedotherwiseRedFontindicatesCarcinogenCriterionisLowerComparedtoNTRCriterionisHigherComparedtoNTRCriterionisforNewChemicalCriterionremainingthesamearenotshadedNC=nocriterion**BasedonDrinkingWaterMCL***PCBscalculatedusinga4x10‐5risklevel,resultinginacriterionof0.00029ug/L;sinceitishigherthanNTR,theNTRisusedintheGovernor'sProposal.*TheGovernor'sproposalresultsinanequalorlowercriterionforeachchemical.Thenumberrepresentstheratioofreduction.†CriteriaarebasedonconsumptionoforganismsonlySection2Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDFRESHWATERHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-550.2 0.2NR NR0.17Current (NTR)4.50.057 0.057NR 0.0040.60Current (NTR)5.60.6cNR NA 0.050.057 Current (NTR)114NR NR NA 0.0136 Gov's Proposal55.6NR NR 0.09 0.09614 Gov's Proposal1.20.091 0.091NRNR0.38Current (NTR)4.1NA0.067cNRNR4.4Gov's Proposal24.90.8 0.8NRNR0.040Current (NTR)1.58NR NR NA 0.02703 Gov's Proposal55.6NR NR0.0134c0.0134c91 Gov's Proposal1.9 NA0.10.0003d0.0003d10 Current (NTR)55.6 NR NR0.0134c0.0134c91 Gov's Proposal5,000156,000cNR NA 0.0000000007 0.000000013 Current (NTR)1500.011 0.011NR NR2.1Current (NTR)40.7 NR NR 0.003 0.003 26 Gov's Proposal93.8 NR NR NA 0.02 87 Gov's Proposal1.5 NR NR 0.002 0.002 70 Current (NTR)3.80.311c0.311cNR 0.0020.11Current (NTR)ProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaGov's ProposalScenarios Used to DeriveFreshwater Human HealthCriteriaCurrent(NTR)CHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSGovernor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Current(NTR)Gov'sProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)BioconcentrationFactor(BCF)a1,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane1,1,2-Trichloroethane1,1-Dichloroethylene1,2-Dichloroethane1,2-Dichlorobenzene1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene2,4-Dichlorophenol2,4-Dinitrotoluene2,4-Dinitrophenol1,3-Dichloropropene1,3-Dichlorobenzene1,2-Trans-Dichloroethylene1,2-Diphenylhydrazine1,2-Dichloropropane2,4-Dimethylphenol2,4,6-Trichlorophenol2,3,7,8-TCDD (Dioxin)1,4-DichlorobenzeneSection3Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDFRESHWATERHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5ProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaGov's ProposalScenarios Used to DeriveFreshwater Human HealthCriteriaCurrent(NTR)CHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSGovernor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Current(NTR)Gov'sProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)BioconcentrationFactor(BCF)a202NR NR NA 0.08171 Gov's Proposal134NR NR NA 0.00516 Gov's Proposal5.5NR NR0.0004c0.0004c11 Gov's Proposal3120.45 0.45NR NR0.031Gov's Proposal53,6000.24 0.24NR NR0.00036Gov's Proposal53,6000.34 0.34NR NR0.00025Gov's Proposal53,6000.34 0.34NR 0.00050.00025Gov's Proposal242 NR NR NA 0.06 108 Gov's Proposal215 NR NR0.0156e0.00051.0 Gov's Proposal300.54 0.54NRNR0.059Current (NTR)4,67017 17NR 0.000030.000057Gov's Proposal1306.3 6.3NR NR0.0039Current (NTR)270 NR NR0.00005c0.006c0.93 Current (NTR)30 NR NR 0.3 0.3 3,310 Gov's Proposal1 NR NR 0.0004 0.0004 14 Current (NTR)441.75c1.75cNR 0.000310*Drinking WaterMCLNA NR NR NR NR7,000,000fibers/L*Drinking WaterMCL5.20.03e0.015fNRNR1.2Current (NTR)AntimonyAnthraceneAcenaphthene4,4'-DDTBenzeneAsbestosArsenic3,3'-Dichlorobenzidine2-Methyl-4,6-Dinitrophenol2-Chloronaphthalene2-ChlorophenolAcrolein4,4'-DDDalpha-Endosulfanalpha-BHCAldrinAcrylonitrile4,4'-DDESection3Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDFRESHWATERHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5ProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaGov's ProposalScenarios Used to DeriveFreshwater Human HealthCriteriaCurrent(NTR)CHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSGovernor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Current(NTR)Gov'sProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)BioconcentrationFactor(BCF)a87.5230 230NR 0.0030.00012Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.0028Current (NTR)3012e7.3NR NR0.0028Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.0028Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.0028Current (NTR)1301.8 1.8NRNR0.014Current (NTR)270NR NR0.00005c0.006c0.93 Current (NTR)6.91.1 1.1NR NR0.031Current (NTR)2.47 NR NR 0.04 0.04 1,316 Gov's Proposal1300.014 0.014NR NR1.8Current (NTR)3.750.0079 0.0079NR NR4.3Current (NTR)414 NR NR NA 0.2 215 Gov's Proposal18.750.13d0.13dNR0.0007e0.25Current (NTR)14,1001.3c0.35cNR0.0005c0.00057Current (NTR)10.3 NR NR 0.02 0.02 421 Gov's Proposal3.750.084 0.084NR 0.020.41Current (NTR)3.750.0061cNR NA 0.015.7 Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.0028Current (NTR)ChryseneChloroformChlorodibromomethaneBis(2-Ethylhexyl) PhthalateChlorobenzeneBromoformBenzo(b)FluorantheneBenzo(a)AnthraceneBenzidineBenzo(a)PyreneBis(2-Chloroisopropyl) Etherbeta-Endosulfanbeta-BHCBenzo(k)FluorantheneBis(2-Chloroethyl)EtherChlordaneCarbon TetrachlorideButylbenzyl PhthalateSection3Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDFRESHWATERHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5ProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaGov's ProposalScenarios Used to DeriveFreshwater Human HealthCriteriaCurrent(NTR)CHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSGovernor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Current(NTR)Gov'sProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)BioconcentrationFactor(BCF)aNANR NR NRNR1,300*Drinking WaterMCL1 NR NR0.02d0.02d700 Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.0028Current (NTR)3.750.13e0.062NR NR0.27Current (NTR)4,67016 16NR 0.000050.000061Gov's Proposal73 NR NR 0.8 0.8 4,332 Gov's Proposal36 NR NR10c10c96,386 Gov's Proposal89 NR NR 0.1 0.1 455 Gov's Proposal270 NR NR0.00005c0.006c0.93 Current (NTR)3,970 NR NR 0.0003 0.0003 0.034 Gov's Proposal3,970 NR NR0.0003c0.0003c0.034 Gov's Proposal37.5 NR NR 0.1 0.1 934 Gov's Proposal1,150 NR NR 0.04 0.04 16 Gov's Proposal30 NR NR 0.04 0.04 441 Gov's Proposal1301.3cNR NA 0.0003 0.019 Current (NTR)11,2004.5 4.5NR 0.00050.000091Gov's Proposal11,2009.1 9.1NR 0.0000130.000045Gov's Proposal8,6901.6 1.6NR 0.00080.00033Gov's ProposalDieldrinDichlorobromomethaneDibenzo (a,h) AnthraceneCyanideCoppergamma-BHC (Lindane)Heptachlor EpoxideHexachlorobenzeneHeptachlorEndosulfan SulfateDi-n-Butyl PhthalateDimethyl PhthalateDiethyl PhthalateFluoreneFluorantheneEthylbenzeneEndrin AldehydeEndrinSection3Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDFRESHWATERHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5ProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaGov's ProposalScenarios Used to DeriveFreshwater Human HealthCriteriaCurrent(NTR)CHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSGovernor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Current(NTR)Gov'sProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)BioconcentrationFactor(BCF)a2.780.078 0.078NR NR0.44Current (NTR)4.34 NR NR0.007e0.006174 Gov's Proposal86.90.014d0.014dNR0.001e1.9Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.0028Current (NTR)4.380.0041e0.00095NR 0.28.4Current (NTR)3.75 NR NR 0.0014 0.0014 42 Gov's Proposal0.90.0075d0.0075dNRNR4.7Current (NTR)47NR NR0.02c0.02c156 Gov's Proposal2.89 NR NR0.0005d0.0005d16 Gov's Proposal0.02651 51NR NR0.00069Current (NTR)1.13 NA7NR NR0.052Gov's Proposal1360.0049 0.0049NR NR5.0Current (NTR)110.12d0.12dNR0.03e0.28Current (NTR)1.4 NR NR0.6e0.310,690 Gov's Proposal31,2002g2gNRNR0.00017**Current (NTR)30NR NR 0.03 0.03331 Gov's Proposal4.8NR NR NA 0.005141 Gov's Proposal30.60.04d0.04dNRNR0.80Current (NTR)TetrachloroethyleneSeleniumPyrenePolychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs)PhenolPentachlorophenolN-NitrosodiphenylamineMethyl BromideIsophoroneIndeno (1,2,3-cd) PyreneN-Nitrosodi-n-PropylamineN-NitrosodimethylamineNitrobenzeneNickelMethylene ChlorideHexachlorobutadieneHexachloro-cyclopentadieneHexachloroethaneSection3Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDFRESHWATERHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 2 L/day 2 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR)6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5ProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedFreshwaterHumanHealthCriteriaGov's ProposalScenarios Used to DeriveFreshwater Human HealthCriteriaCurrent(NTR)CHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSGovernor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Current(NTR)Gov'sProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)BioconcentrationFactor(BCF)a116NR NR0.00007c0.00007c0.24 Gov's Proposal10.7 NR NR0.2d0.2d4,132 Gov's Proposal13,1001.1 1.1NR NR0.00032Gov's Proposal10.60.013d0.013dNRNR2.7Current (NTR)1.170.0174e1.4gNR 0.0030.26Gov's Proposal47 NR NR NA 0.3 2,347 Gov's ProposalZincVinyl ChlorideTrichloroethyleneToxapheneTolueneThalliumcNotassessedundertheIRISprogram,orInformationreviewedbutvaluenotestimateddDiffersfromIRISvalue.Ecologyusednon‐IRIStoxicityCSFsorRfDstocalculatepreliminarycriteriaforthischemical.ThesevaluesarebasedontoxicityfactorsusedbyEPAinpastcriteriadevelopment,andcanbefoundinEPA2002(USEPA,2002.U.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency.NationalRecommendedWaterQualityCriteria:2002HumanHealthCriteriaCalculationMatrix.EPA‐822‐R‐02‐012.November2002).UseofthesefactorsispreliminaryandformaldraftcriteriamightbebasedoncurrentIRISvalues.eDiffersfromcurrentIRISvaluefLowestvalueamongrangeinIRISgHighestvalueamongrangeinIRIS*BasedonDrinkingWaterMCL**PCBscalculatedusinga4x10‐5risklevel,resultinginacriterionof0.00029ug/L;sinceitishigherthanNTR,theNTRisusedintheGovernor'sProposal.GENERALNOTES:RedFontindicatesCarcinogenNR=NotReportedNA=NotApplicableMCL=MaximumContaminantLevelFOOTNOTES:aBCFswerederivedintheoriginalcriteriadevelopmentdocumentsforeachchemicalandcanbefoundinEPA2002(USEPA,2002.U.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency.NationalRecommendedWaterQualityCriteria:2002HumanHealthCriteriaCalculationMatrix.EPA‐822‐R‐02‐012.November2002).bCurrentIRISvaluesunlessnotedotherwiseSection3Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDMARINEHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 0 L/day 0 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR) 6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-550.2 0.2NR NR4.6Gov's Proposal4.50.057 0.057NR 0.00418Gov's Proposal5.60.6cNR NA 0.053.2 Current (NTR)114NR NR NA 0.0140 Gov's Proposal55.6NR NR 0.09 0.09740 Gov's Proposal1.20.091 0.091NRNR42Gov's Proposal4.1NA0.067cNRNR17Gov's Proposal24.90.8 0.8NRNR0.23Gov's Proposal1.58NR NR NA 0.025,787 Gov's Proposal55.6NR NR0.0134c0.0134c110 Gov's Proposal1.9 NA0.10.0003d0.0003d72 Gov's Proposal55.6 NR NR0.0134c0.0134c110 Gov's Proposal5,000156,000cNR NA 0.0000000007 0.000000014 Current (NTR)1500.011 0.011NR NR2.8Gov's Proposal40.7 NR NR 0.003 0.003 34 Gov's Proposal93.8 NR NR NA 0.02 97 Gov's Proposal1.5 NR NR 0.002 0.002 610 Gov's Proposal3.80.311c0.311cNR 0.0023.9Gov's ProposalVARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSCHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteriaBioconcentrationFactor(BCF)a1,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane1,1,2-Trichloroethane1,1-Dichloroethylene1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene1,2-DichlorobenzeneScenarios Used to DeriveMarine Human Health CriteriaCurrent(NTR)Governor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov'sProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov's Proposal1,3-Dichloropropene1,4-Dichlorobenzene2,3,7,8-TCDD (Dioxin)2,4,6-Trichlorophenol2,4-Dichlorophenol1,2-Dichloroethane1,2-Dichloropropane1,2-Diphenylhydrazine1,2-Trans-Dichloroethylene1,3-Dichlorobenzene2,4-Dimethylphenol2,4-Dinitrophenol2,4-DinitrotolueneOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)Section4Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDMARINEHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 0 L/day 0 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR) 6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5VARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSCHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteriaBioconcentrationFactor(BCF)aScenarios Used to DeriveMarine Human Health CriteriaCurrent(NTR)Governor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov'sProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov's ProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)202NR NR NA 0.08181 Gov's Proposal134NR NR NA 0.00517 Gov's Proposal5.5NR NR0.0004c0.0004c32 Gov's Proposal3120.45 0.45NR NR0.033Gov's Proposal53,6000.24 0.24NR NR0.00036Gov's Proposal53,6000.34 0.34NR NR0.00025Gov's Proposal53,6000.34 0.34NR 0.00050.00025Gov's Proposal242 NR NR NA 0.06 113 Gov's Proposal215 NR NR0.0156e0.00051.1 Gov's Proposal300.54 0.54NRNR0.28Gov's Proposal4,6701717NR 0.000030.000058Gov's Proposal1306.3 6.3NRNR0.0056Gov's Proposal270NR NR0.00005c0.006c2.0 Current (NTR)30 NR NR 0.3 0.3 4,571 Gov's Proposal1 NR NR 0.0004 0.0004 183 Gov's Proposal441.75c1.75cNR 0.000310*Drinking WaterMCLNANR NR NRNRNCNC5.20.03e0.015fNRNR59Gov's Proposal2-Methyl-4,6-Dinitrophenol3,3'-Dichlorobenzidine4,4'-DDD4,4'-DDE4,4'-DDT2-Chloronaphthalene2-Chlorophenolalpha-EndosulfanAnthraceneAntimonyArsenicAsbestosAcenaphtheneAcroleinAcrylonitrileAldrinalpha-BHCBenzeneSection4Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDMARINEHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 0 L/day 0 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR) 6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5VARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSCHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteriaBioconcentrationFactor(BCF)aScenarios Used to DeriveMarine Human Health CriteriaCurrent(NTR)Governor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov'sProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov's ProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)87.5230 230NR 0.0030.00023Gov's Proposal3012c7.3cNRNR0.021Gov's Proposal3012e7.3NR NR0.021Gov's Proposal3012c7.3cNRNR0.021Gov's Proposal3012c7.3cNRNR0.021Gov's Proposal1301.8 1.8NRNR0.020Gov's Proposal270NR NR0.00005c0.006c2.0 Current (NTR)6.91.1 1.1NR NR0.60Gov's Proposal2.47 NR NR 0.04 0.04 7,403 Gov's Proposal1300.014 0.014NR NR2.5Gov's Proposal3.750.0079 0.0079NR NR154Gov's Proposal414 NR NR NA 0.2 221 Gov's Proposal18.750.13d0.13dNR0.0007e1.9Gov's Proposal14,1001.3c0.35cNR0.0005c0.00059Current (NTR)10.3 NR NR 0.02 0.02 888 Gov's Proposal3.750.084 0.084NR 0.0215Gov's Proposal3.750.0061cNR NA 0.01470 Current (NTR)3012c7.3cNRNR0.021Gov's ProposalBenzo(k)Fluoranthenebeta-BHCbeta-EndosulfanBis(2-Chloroethyl)EtherBis(2-Chloroisopropyl) EtherBenzidineBenzo(a)AnthraceneBenzo(a)PyreneBenzo(b)FluorantheneChlorobenzeneChlorodibromomethaneChloroformChryseneBis(2-Ethylhexyl) PhthalateBromoformButylbenzyl PhthalateCarbon TetrachlorideChlordaneSection4Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDMARINEHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 0 L/day 0 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR) 6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5VARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSCHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteriaBioconcentrationFactor(BCF)aScenarios Used to DeriveMarine Human Health CriteriaCurrent(NTR)Governor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov'sProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov's ProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)NANR NR NRNRNCNC1 NR NR0.02d0.02d9,143 Gov's Proposal3012c7.3cNRNR0.021Gov's Proposal3.750.13e0.062NR NR20Gov's Proposal4,67016 16NR 0.000050.000061Gov's Proposal73 NR NR 0.8 0.8 5,010 Gov's Proposal36 NR NR10c10c126,984 Gov's Proposal89 NR NR 0.1 0.1 514 Gov's Proposal270 NR NR0.00005c0.006c2.0 Current (NTR)3,970 NR NR 0.0003 0.0003 0.035 Gov's Proposal3,970 NR NR0.0003c0.0003c0.035 Gov's Proposal37.5 NR NR 0.1 0.1 1,219 Gov's Proposal1,150 NR NR 0.04 0.04 16 Gov's Proposal30 NR NR 0.04 0.04 610 Gov's Proposal1301.3cNR NA 0.0003 0.063 Current (NTR)11,2004.5 4.5NR 0.00050.000091Gov's Proposal11,2009.1 9.1NR 0.0000130.000045Gov's Proposal8,6901.6 1.6NR 0.00080.00033Gov's ProposalCopperDimethyl PhthalateDi-n-Butyl PhthalateEndosulfan SulfateEndrinEndrin AldehydeCyanideDibenzo (a,h) AnthraceneDichlorobromomethaneDieldrinDiethyl PhthalateHexachlorobenzeneEthylbenzeneFluorantheneFluorenegamma-BHC (Lindane)HeptachlorHeptachlor EpoxideSection4Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDMARINEHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 0 L/day 0 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR) 6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5VARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSCHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteriaBioconcentrationFactor(BCF)aScenarios Used to DeriveMarine Human Health CriteriaCurrent(NTR)Governor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov'sProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov's ProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)2.780.078 0.078NR NR21Gov's Proposal4.34 NR NR0.007e0.006632 Gov's Proposal86.90.014d0.014dNR0.001e3.8Gov's Proposal3012c7.3cNRNR0.021Gov's Proposal4.380.0041e0.00095NR 0.2600Current (NTR)3.75 NR NR 0.0014 0.0014 171 Gov's Proposal0.90.0075d0.0075dNRNR677Gov's Proposal47NR NR0.02c0.02c195 Gov's Proposal2.89 NR NR0.0005d0.0005d79 Gov's Proposal0.02651 51NR NR3.4Gov's Proposal1.13 NA7NR NR0.58Gov's Proposal1360.0049 0.0049NR NR6.9Gov's Proposal110.12d0.12dNR0.03e3.5Gov's Proposal1.4 NR NR0.6e0.397,959 Gov's Proposal31,2002g2gNRNR0.00017**Current (NTR)30NR NR 0.03 0.03457 Gov's Proposal4.8NR NR NA 0.005476 Gov's Proposal30.60.04d0.04dNRNR3.8Gov's ProposalHexachlorobutadieneHexachloro-cyclopentadieneHexachloroethanePhenolPolychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs)PyreneSeleniumTetrachloroethyleneNitrobenzeneN-NitrosodimethylamineN-Nitrosodi-n-PropylamineN-NitrosodiphenylaminePentachlorophenolIndeno (1,2,3-cd) PyreneIsophoroneMethyl BromideMethylene ChlorideNickelSection4Revised8/8/2014FACTORSUSEDTODERIVEPROPOSEDMARINEHUMANHEALTHCRITERIAFORWASHINGTONSTATEBody Weight (BW) 70 kg 80 kgDrinking Water Intake (DI) 0 L/day 0 L/dayFish Consumption Rate (FCR) 6.5 g/day 175 g/dayCancer Risk Level (RL)1 x 10-61 x 10-5VARIABLESNOTSPECIFICTOCHEMICALSCHEMICAL‐SPECIFICVARIABLESProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteria(ug/L)Basis forProposedMarineHumanHealthCriteriaBioconcentrationFactor(BCF)aScenarios Used to DeriveMarine Human Health CriteriaCurrent(NTR)Governor'sProposalCurrent (NTR)andGov's ProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov'sProposalCurrent(NTR)Gov's ProposalOral Cancer Slope Factor(CSF)b(mg/kg-day)-1Oral Reference Dose(RfD)b(mg/kg-day)116NR NR0.00007c0.00007c0.27 Gov's Proposal10.7 NR NR0.2d0.2d8,545 Gov's Proposal13,1001.1 1.1NR NR0.00032Gov's Proposal10.60.013d0.013dNRNR34Gov's Proposal1.170.0174e1.4gNR 0.0032.8Gov's Proposal47 NR NR NA 0.3 2,918 Gov's ProposalZincThalliumTolueneToxapheneTrichloroethyleneVinyl ChlorideeDiffersfromcurrentIRISvaluefLowestvalueamongrangeinIRISgHighestvalueamongrangeinIRIS*BasedonDrinkingWaterMCL**PCBscalculatedusinga4x10‐5risklevel,resultinginacriterionof0.00029ug/L;sinceitishigherthanNTR,theNTRisusedintheGovernor'sProposal.GENERALNOTES:RedFontindicatesCarcinogenaBCFswerederivedintheoriginalcriteriadevelopmentdocumentsforeachchemicalandcanbefoundinEPA2002(USEPA,2002.U.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency.NationalRecommendedWaterQualityCriteria:2002HumanHealthCriteriaCalculationMatrix.EPA‐822‐R‐02‐012.November2002).dDiffersfromIRISvalue.Ecologyusednon‐IRIStoxicityCSFsorRfDstocalculatepreliminarycriteriaforthischemical.ThesevaluesarebasedontoxicityfactorsusedbyEPAinpastcriteriadevelopment,andcanbefoundinEPA2002(USEPA,2002.U.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency.NationalRecommendedWaterQualityCriteria:2002HumanHealthCriteriaCalculationMatrix.EPA‐822‐R‐02‐012.November2002).UseofthesefactorsispreliminaryandformaldraftcriteriamightbebasedoncurrentIRISvalues.NR=NotReportedNA=NotApplicableNC=NoCriterionMCL=MaximumContaminantLevelFOOTNOTES:bCurrentIRISvaluesunlessnotedotherwisecNotassessedundertheIRISprogram,orInformationreviewedbutvaluenotestimatedSection4Revised8/8/2014

# FRESH Count MARINE Count

Carcinogens 1

‐ 2X More Protective 1 Carcinogens 1

‐ 2X More Protective 9

3,3'-Dichlorobenzidine Benzene

Benzo(a)Anthracene



# Carcinogens 2

‐ 5X More Protective 9 Benzo(a)Pyrene

4,4'-DDD Benzo(b)Fluoranthene

4,4'-DDE Benzo(k)Fluoranthene

4,4'-DDT Chrysene

Aldrin Dibenzo (a,h) Anthracene

Dieldrin Dichlorobromomethane

Heptachlor Indeno (1,2,3-cd) Pyrene

Heptachlor Epoxide

Hexachlorobenzene 

# Carcinogens 2

‐ 5X More Protective 33

Toxaphene 1,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane

1,1,2-Trichloroethane



# Carcinogens 5

‐ 10X More Protective 1 1,2-Dichloroethane

Vinyl Chloride 1,2-Diphenylhydrazine

2,4,6-Trichlorophenol



# Carcinogens Remaining the same 36 2,4-Dinitrotoluene

1,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane 3,3'-Dichlorobenzidine

1,1,2-Trichloroethane 4,4'-DDD

1,2-Dichloroethane 4,4'-DDE

1,2-Diphenylhydrazine 4,4'-DDT

2,4,6-Trichlorophenol Acrylonitrile

2,4-Dinitrotoluene Aldrin

Acrylonitrile alpha-BHC

alpha-BHC Benzidine

Asbestos beta-BHC

Benzene Bis(2-Chloroethyl)Ether

Benzidine Bis(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate

Benzo(a)Anthracene Bromoform

Benzo(a)Pyrene Carbon Tetrachloride

Benzo(b)Fluoranthene Chlorodibromomethane

Benzo(k)Fluoranthene Dieldrin

beta-BHC Heptachlor

Bis(2-Chloroethyl)Ether Heptachlor Epoxide

Bis(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate Hexachlorobenzene

Bromoform Hexachlorobutadiene

Carbon Tetrachloride Hexachloroethane

Chlordane Methylene Chloride

Chlorodibromomethane N-Nitrosodimethylamine

Chrysene N-Nitrosodiphenylamine 

# Compared to the Current (NTR) Criteria, what does each chemical do under the

Governor's Proposal?

Section 5 Revised 8/7/2014

# Dibenzo (a,h) Anthracene Pentachlorophenol

Dichlorobromomethane Tetrachloroethylene

Hexachlorobutadiene Toxaphene

Hexachloroethane Trichloroethylene

Indeno (1,2,3-cd) Pyrene

Isophorone 

# Carcinogens >10X More Protective 1

Methylene Chloride Vinyl Chloride

N-Nitrosodimethylamine

N-Nitrosodiphenylamine 

# Carcinogens Remaining the same 3

Pentachlorophenol Chlordane

Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs) Isophorone

Tetrachloroethylene Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs)

Trichloroethylene



# Carcinogens Less Protective 1

Carcinogens Less Protective 1 Arsenic

Arsenic



# New Carcinogens 2

New Carcinogens 2 1,2-Dichloropropane

1,2-Dichloropropane N-Nitrosodi-n-Propylamine

N-Nitrosodi-n-Propylamine



# Non

‐ Carcinogens >10X More Protective 29

Non

‐ Carcinogens 1

‐ 2X More Protective 8 1,2-Dichlorobenzene

2-Methyl-4,6-Dinitrophenol 1,3-Dichlorobenzene

Bis(2-Chloroisopropyl) Ether 1,3-Dichloropropene

Chlorobenzene 1,4-Dichlorobenzene

Hexachloro-cyclopentadiene 2,4-Dichlorophenol

Methyl Bromide 2,4-Dinitrophenol

Nitrobenzene 2-Methyl-4,6-Dinitrophenol

Phenol Acrolein

Toluene Anthracene

Antimony



# Non

‐ Carcinogens 2

‐ 5X More Protective 10 Bis(2-Chloroisopropyl) Ether

1,2-Dichlorobenzene Chlorobenzene

1,3-Dichlorobenzene Cyanide

1,4-Dichlorobenzene Diethyl Phthalate

2,4-Dichlorophenol Dimethyl Phthalate

Anthracene Di-n-Butyl Phthalate

Dimethyl Phthalate Endrin

Ethylbenzene Endrin Aldehyde

Fluorene Ethylbenzene

Nickel Fluoranthene

Pyrene Fluorene

Hexachloro-cyclopentadiene



# Non

‐ Carcinogens 5

‐ 10X More Protective 3 Methyl Bromide

Diethyl Phthalate Nickel

Di-n-Butyl Phthalate Nitrobenzene



# Section 5 Revised 8/7/2014

# Thallium Phenol

Pyrene



# Non

‐ Carcinogens >10X More Protective 4 Thallium

Acrolein Toluene

Endrin

Endrin Aldehyde 

# Non

‐ Carcinogens Remaining the same 7

Fluoranthene 1,1-Dichloroethylene

2,3,7,8-TCDD (Dioxin)



# Non

‐ Carcinogens Remaining the same 11 alpha-Endosulfan

1,1-Dichloroethylene Chloroform

1,3-Dichloropropene beta-Endosulfan

2,3,7,8-TCDD (Dioxin) Endosulfan Sulfate

2,4-Dinitrophenol gamma-BHC (Lindane)

alpha-Endosulfan

Antimony 

# New Non

‐ Carcinogens 9

beta-Endosulfan 1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene

Chloroform 1,2-Trans-Dichloroethylene

Cyanide 2,4-Dimethylphenol

Endosulfan Sulfate 2-Chloronaphthalene

gamma-BHC (Lindane) 2-Chlorophenol

Acenaphthene



# New Non

‐ Carcinogens 10 Butylbenzyl Phthalate

1,2,4-Trichlorobenzene Selenium

1,2-Trans-Dichloroethylene Zinc

2,4-Dimethylphenol

2-Chloronaphthalene 

# Total Carcinogens = 49

2-Chlorophenol 

# Total Non-Carcinogens = 45

Acenaphthene 

# TOTAL CHEMICALS = 94

Butylbenzyl Phthalate

Copper

Selenium

Zinc



# Total Carcinogens = 50



# Total Non-Carcinogens = 46



# TOTAL CHEMICALS = 96

Section 5 Revised 8/7/2014