p. 1



# OAR Box 1828
Prepped byOllie Stewart



## Document

Number: 

# 148 ) ll-K-(B)-14 7
Docket Number: 

# A-83-2 7

Printed 11/12/200811:12:53 AM Sheet 148of 325P. 2



## ENERG YAND ENVIRONMENTA L ANALYSIS , INC . 165 5 NORT

HPOR T MYE RDRIV EARLINGTON, VIRGINI A 2220 9 703/528-100 0



### Augus t 6 , 198 4 

# A-83-2 7

II-K-CB)-14 7

Mr . Rober t Shor t Economi c Analysi s Branc h U.S . Environmenta l Protectio nAgenc y Mai l Drop-1 2 Researc hTriangl e Park , N C 2771 1 Subject : EP

A Contrac t No . 68-02-3564 , Wor kAssignmen t #1 9 Dea r Robert : Attache dar e summary table s whic hcompar e nationa l result s fro m som e o f th e fift hroun

dS0 2 

### NSP S IFCA

M runs . Thes e table s wer e re queste db

y Fre dPorte r a t ou r meetin go nAugus t 3 , 1984 . Th e enclose d table s includ e result s fro m the Bas e Cas e an

dOptio nCase s 1 an

d2 fo r th e highe r oi l an

dga s prices . Th e enclose dtable s includ e result s from the Bas e Cas e andOptio nCase s 1 , 8 an d1 0 fo r the Referenc e Cas e fue l prices . Sincerely ,

Tim Hoga n(j TH/c e Enclosure s
cc : Dr . A . Weh e

MANAGEMENT / ECONOMIC S /

ENGINEERINGTABL E 2 . PROJECTE DNATIONALIMPACT S OF ALTERNATIVE SO , NSP S FORINDUSTRIA

LFOSSI LFUEL-FIRE DBOILER S (Referenc e cas e fue l prices ) P. 3

Regulatory alternativ e
Baselin e

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8 Unit s

1 0 shor t ton s millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l
1 0 shor t ton s millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l 

### so 2



### so ?

1 0 shor t ton s S0 2 millio n$ 198 2 ga s IO 3 Bt uresi d coa l
3 1 0 shor t ton s millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l
1 0 shor t ton s millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l
1 0 shor t ton s millio n%

198 2 ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l
3 1 0 shor t ton s millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l

1 0 shor t ton s millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l 3 1 0 shor t ton s millio n$

198 2 ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l 

### so 2

S0 2



### so 2



### so 2

S0 ?

S0 ? 100-15 0

104. 8 900. 9 2 6 9 9 4
104. 8 900. 9 26 99 4
68. 1 906. 5 28 100 1

68. 1 906. 5 2 8 100 1
27. 9 - 926.2 5 6 7 0 3
27. 9 926. 2 5 6 7 0 3

27. 9 926.2 5 6 70 3

27. 9 926.2 5 6 70 3
19. 4 941. 1 7 1 5 7 1 Boile r siz e (MMBtu/hr )

150-20 0 200-25 0

81. 6 728. 5 2 4 86 1
81. 6 728. 5 2 4 8 6 1
58. 9 732. 7 2 5 86 0

23. 9 749. 3 5 0 60 1
23. 9 749. 3 50 6 0 1
23. 9 749. 3 50 60 1

23. 9 749. 3 5 0 60 1

21. 2 759. 4 5 4 5 7 0
21. 2 759. 4 5 4 5 7 0 .52. 1

445. 3 1 5 4 6 6
13. 7 455. 6 33 34 0
13. 7 455. 6 3 3 34 0

13. 7 455. 6 3 3 3 4 0
13. 7 455. 6 3 3 34 0
13. 7 455. 6 3 3 3 4 0

12. 5 458. 7 34 3 3 0

12. 5 458.7 3 4 3 3 0
12. 5 458.7 34 3 3 0 >25 0

40. 9 1.274. 6 87 92 1 3
40. 4 1.274. 7 87 92 1 3
40. 4 1.274. 7 87 92 1 3

40. 4 1.274. 7 8 7 92 1 3
40. 4 1,274. 4 87 9 2 1 3
19. 9 1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 2 6

19. 9 1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 2 6

19. 9 1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 26
19. 9 1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 2 6TABL E 2
. PROJECTE D NATIONA L IMPACT S OF ALTERNATIVE S0 9 NSP S FO RINDUSTRIA

L FOSSI L FUEL-FIRE D BOILER S * (Referenc e cas e fue l prices )

Regulatory alternativ e Unit s 100-15 0 Boile r siz e (MMBtu/hr ) 150-20 0 200-25 0 >25 0

Baselin e 1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 104. 8 900. 9 2 6 9 9 4 81. 6

728. 5 2 4 8 6 1 52. 1

445. 3 

### 1 5 4 6 

### 6
13. 7 455. 6 

### 3 3 3 4 

### 0
13. 7 455. 6 

### 3 3 3 4 

### 0 40. 9

1,274. 6 

### 8 7 9 2 1 3
40. 4 1,274. 7 

### 8 7 9 2 1 3
40. 4 1,274. 7 

### 8 7 9 2 1 3 1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 104. 8 900. 9 2 6 9 9 4 81. 6

728. 5 2 4 8 6 1
1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 3 Bt u resi d

coa l 68. 1 906. 5 2 8 10 0 1 58. 9

732. 7 2 5 8 6 0TABL E 2
. PROJECTE D NATIONA L IMPACT S O F ALTERNATIVE S0 9 NSP S FO RINDUSTRIA

L FOSSI L FUEL-FIRE D BOILER S c (Referenc e cas e fue l prices )

(Continued )

Regulatory alternativ e Unit s 100-15 0 Boile r siz e (MMBtu/hr ) 150-20 0 200-25 0 >25 0

1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 68. 1 906. 5 2 8 10 0 1 23. 9

749. 3 5 0 6 0 1 13. 7

455. 6 

### 3 3 3 4 

### 0

13. 7 455. 6 

### 3 3 3 4 

### 0
13. 7 455. 6 

### 3 3 3 4 

### 0 40. 4

1,274. 7 

### 8 7 9 2 1 3

40. 4 1,274. 4 

### 8 7 9 2 1 3
19. 9 1,309. 3 

### 10 7 5 9 2 6 1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 27. 9 926. 2 5 6 7 0 3 23. 9

749. 3 5 0 6 0 1
1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 27. 9 926. 2 5 6 7 0 3 23. 9

749. 3 5 0 6 0 1TABL E 2
. PROJECTE D NATIONA L IMPACT S O F ALTERNATIVE SO ? NSP S FO RINDUSTRIA

L FOSSI L FUEL-FIRE D BOILER S L (Referenc e cas e fue l prices )

(Continued )

Regulatory alternativ e Unit s 100-15 0 Boile r siz e (MMBtu/hr ) 150-20 0 200-25 0 >25 0

1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 27. 9 926. 2 5 6 7 0 3 23. 9

749. 3 5 0 6 0 1 12. 5

458. 7 3 4 3 3 0 19. 9

1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 2 6

1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l
. 27. 9 926. 2 5 6 7 0 3 21. 2

759. 4 5 4 5 7 0 12. 5

458. 7 3 4 3 3 0 19. 9

1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 2 6

1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 19. 4 941. 1 7 1 5 7 1 21. 2

759. 4 5 4 5 7 0 12. 5

458. 7 3 4 3 3 0 19. 9

1,309. 3 10 7 5 9 2 6TABL E 3 . PROJECTE DNATIONA LIMPACT S OF ALTERNATIVE SO , NSP S FO RINDUSTRIA

LFOSSI LFUEL-FIREDBOILER S c (Highe r oi l an

dga s prices ) P. 7

Regulatory alternative Unit s 100-15 0 Boile r siz e (MMBtu/hr ) 150-20 0 200-25 0 >25 0
Baseline 1 0 shor t ton s S0 2 million$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bturesi d

coa l 74. 0

1.008. 0 8 2 7 4 0 107. 8

837. 6 4 1

' 0 7 0 85. 5

493. 1 1 9 0 4 8 58. 6

1.386. 3 6 5 0 12 6

1 0 shor t tons S0 2 million$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l 11. 2

1.008. 7 10 5 0 2 3 25. 2

843. 7 5 6 0 5 5 20. 1

504. 4 2 4 0 4 3 58. 6

1.386. 5 6 5 0 12 6
1 0 shor t ton s S0 2 million$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bturesi d

coa l 11. 2

1,008. 7 10 5 0 23 " 25. 2

843. 7 5 6 0 5 5 20. 1

504. 4 2 4 0 4 3 29. 5

1.411. 1 9 0 0 10 1

1 0 shor t ton s S0 2 million$ 198 2

ga s 1 0 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l 11. 2

1,008. 7 10 5 0 2 3 25. 2

843. 7 5 6 0 5 5 5. 2

500. 4 5 0 0 1 7 29. 5

1,411. 1 9 0 0 10 1

IO 3 shor t ton s S0 2 million$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt uresi d

coa l 11. 2

1,008. 7 10 5 0 2 3 7. 1

832. 1 8 8 0 2 3 5. 2

500. 4 5 0 0 1 7 29. 5

1,411. 1 9 0 0 10 1
1 0 shor t ton s S0 2 million$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bturesi d

coa l 3. 8

1,010. 6 11 7 0 1 2 7. 1

832. 1 8 8 0 2 3 5. 2

500. 4 5 0 0 1 7 29. 5

1,411. 1 9 0 0 10 1Regulatory

alternativ e

Baselin e



### 1

2 TABL E 3
. PROJECTE D NATIONA L IMPACT S O F ALTERNATIVE SO , FO RINDUSTRIA

L FOSSI L FUEL-FIRE D BOILER S L (Highe r oi l an

d ga s prices )

Unit s

10 3 shor t ton s S0 2 millio n$ 198 2



### ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l
3 1 0 shor t ton s SO

p millio n$ 198 2



### ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 3 1 0 shor t ton s S0 2 millio n$ 198 2



### ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 100-15 0

74. 0 1,008. 0 

### 8 2 

### 7 4 0

11. 2 1,008. 7 

### 10 5 

### 0 2 3
11. 2 1,008. 7 

### 10 5 

### 0 2 3 Boile r siz e

150-20 0

107. 8 837. 6 

### 4 1 

### 0 7 0

25. 2 843. 7 

### 5 6 

### 0 5 5
25. 2 843. 7 

### 5 6 

### 0 5 5 NSP S

(MMBtu/hr ) 200-25 0

85. 5 493. 1 

### 1 9 

### 0 4 8

20. 1 504. 4 

### 2 4 

### 0 4 3
20. 1 504. 4 

### 2 4 

### 0 4 3 >25 0

58. 6 1,386. 3 

### 6 5 

### 0 12 6

58. 6 1,386. 5 

### 6 5 

### 0 12 6
29. 5 1,411. 1 

### 9 0 

### 0 10 1 •TABL E 3
. PROJECTE D NATIONA L IMPACT S O F ALTERNATIVE SO

- NSP S FO RINDUSTRIA

L FOSSI L FUEL-FIRE D BOILER S 6 (Highe r oi l an

d ga s prices ) (Continued )

Regulatory alternativ e Unit s 100-15 0 Boile r siz e (MMBtu/hr ) 150-20 0 200-25 0 >25 0

1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l 11. 2 1,008. 7 

### 10 5 

### 0 2 3

11. 2 1,008. 7 

### 10 5 

### 0 2 3 

### 3. 8 1,010. 6 

### 11 7 

### 0 1 2 25. 2

843. 7 

### 5 6 

### 0 5 5


### 7. 1 832. 1 

### 8 8 

### 0 2 3


### 7. 1 832. 1 

### 8 8 

### 0 2 3 

### 5. 2

500. 4 

### 5 0 

### 0 1 7


### 5. 2 500. 4 

### 5 0 

### 0 1 7


### 5. 2 500. 4 

### 5 0 

### 0 1 7 29. 5

1,411. 1 

### 9 0 

### 0 10 1

29. 5 1,411. 1 

### 9 0 

### 0 101
29. 5 1,411. 1 

### 9 0 

### 0 10 1 1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l
1 0 shor t ton s SO , millio n$ 198 2

ga s IO 1 2 Bt u resi d

coa l