p.1 

OAR Box 1828 

Prepped by Ollie Stewart 

Document Number: 

148) ll-K-(B)-147 

Docket Number: 

A-83-27 

Printed 11/12/2008 11:12:53 AM Sheet 148 of 325 
P.2 

ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS, INC. 

1655 NORTH PORT MYER DRIVE ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 22209 703/528-1000 

August 6, 1984 

A-83-27 

II-K-CB)-147 

Mr. Robert Short 

Economic Analysis Branch 

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 

Mail Drop-12 

Research Triangle Park, NC 27711 

Subject: EPA Contract No. 68-02-3564, Work Assignment #19 

Dear Robert: 

Attached are summary tables which compare national results from 

some of the fifth round S02 NSPS IFCAM runs. These tables were requested by Fred Porter at our meeting on August 3, 1984. The enclosed 

tables include results from the Base Case and Option Cases 1 and 2 for 

the higher oil and gas prices. The enclosed tables include results from 

the Base Case and Option Cases 1, 8 and 10 for the Reference Case fuel 

prices. 

Sincerely, 

Tim Hogan (j 

TH/ce 

Enclosures 

cc: Dr. A. Wehe 

MANAGEMENT / ECONOMICS / ENGINEERING 
TABLE 2. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE SO, NSPS 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS 

(Reference case fuel prices) 

P.3 

Regulatory 

alternative 

Baseline 

1 

2 

3 

4 

5 

6 

7 

8 

Units 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

so2 

so? 

10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO3 Btu resid 

coal 

3 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

10 short tons 

million % 1982 

gas 

IO1 2 Btu resid 

coal 

3 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

3 

10 short tons 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

so2 

S02 

so2 

so2 

S0? 

S0? 

100-150 

104.8 

900.9 

26 

99 

4 

104.8 

900.9 

26 

99 

4 

68.1 

906.5 

28 

100 

1 

68.1 

906.5 

28 

100 

1 

27.9 -

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

19.4 

941.1 

71 

57 

1 

Boiler size (MMBtu/hr) 

150-200 200-250 

81.6 

728.5 

24 

86 

1 

81.6 

728.5 

24 

86 

1 

58.9 

732.7 

25 

86 

0 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

21.2 

759.4 

54 

57 

0 

21.2 

759.4 

54 

57 

0 

.52.1 

445.3 

15 

46 

6 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

12.5 

458.7 

34 

33 

0 

12.5 

458.7 

34 

33 

0 

12.5 

458.7 

34 

33 

0 

>250 

40.9 

1.274.6 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1.274.7 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1.274.7 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1.274.7 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1,274.4 

87 

92 

13 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 
TABLE 2. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE S09 NSPS 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS * 

(Reference case fuel prices) 

Regulatory 

alternative Units 100-150 

Boiler size (MMBtu/hr) 

150-200 200-250 >250 

Baseline 10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

104.8 

900.9 

26 

99 

4 

81.6 

728.5 

24 

86 

1 

52.1 

445.3 

15 

46 

6 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

40.9 

1,274.6 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1,274.7 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1,274.7 

87 

92 

13 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

104.8 

900.9 

26 

99 

4 

81.6 

728.5 

24 

86 

1 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO3 Btu resid 

coal 

68.1 

906.5 

28 

100 

1 

58.9 

732.7 

25 

86 

0 
TABLE 2. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE S09 NSPS 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS

 c 

(Reference case fuel prices) 

(Continued) 

Regulatory 

alternative Units 100-150 

Boiler size (MMBtu/hr) 

150-200 200-250 >250 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

68.1 

906.5 

28 

100 

1 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

13.7 

455.6 

33 

34 

0 

40.4 

1,274.7 

87 

92 

13 

40.4 

1,274.4 

87 

92 

13 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 
TABLE 2. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE SO? NSPS 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS

 L 

(Reference case fuel prices) 

(Continued) 

Regulatory 

alternative Units 100-150 

Boiler size (MMBtu/hr) 

150-200 200-250 >250 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

23.9 

749.3 

50 

60 

1 

12.5 

458.7 

34 

33 

0 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal . 

27.9 

926.2 

56 

70 

3 

21.2 

759.4 

54 

57 

0 

12.5 

458.7 

34 

33 

0 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

19.4 

941.1 

71 

57 

1 

21.2 

759.4 

54 

57 

0 

12.5 

458.7 

34 

33 

0 

19.9 

1,309.3 

107 

59 

26 
TABLE 3. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE SO, NSPS 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS

 c 

(Higher oil and gas prices) 

P.7 

Regulatory 

alternative Units 100-150 

Boiler size (MMBtu/hr) 

150-200 200-250 >250 

Baseline 10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

74.0 

1.008.0 

82 

7 

40 

107.8 

837.6 

41 

' 0 

70 

85.5 

493.1 

19 

0 

48 

58.6 

1.386.3 

65 

0 

126 

10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

11.2 

1.008.7 

105 

0 

23 

25.2 

843.7 

56 

0 

55 

20.1 

504.4 

24 

0 

43 

58.6 

1.386.5 

65 

0 

126 

10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23" 

25.2 

843.7 

56 

0 

55 

20.1 

504.4 

24 

0 

43 

29.5 

1.411.1 

90 

0 

101 

10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

1 01 2 Btu resid 

coal 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23 

25.2 

843.7 

56 

0 

55 

5.2 

500.4 

50 

0 

17 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 

IO3 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23 

7.1 

832.1 

88 

0 

23 

5.2 

500.4 

50 

0 

17 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 

10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

3.8 

1,010.6 

117 

0 

12 

7.1 

832.1 

88 

0 

23 

5.2 

500.4 

50 

0 

17 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 
Regulatory 

alternative 

Baseline 

1 

2 

TABLE 3. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE SO, 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS

 L 

(Higher oil and gas prices) 

Units 

103 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

3 

10 short tons SOp 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

3 

10 short tons S02 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

100-150 

74.0 

1,008.0 

82 

7 

40 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23 

Boiler size 

150-200 

107.8 

837.6 

41 

0 

70 

25.2 

843.7 

56 

0 

55 

25.2 

843.7 

56 

0 

55 

NSPS 

(MMBtu/hr) 

200-250 

85.5 

493.1 

19 

0 

48 

20.1 

504.4 

24 

0 

43 

20.1 

504.4 

24 

0 

43 

>250 

58.6 

1,386.3 

65 

0 

126 

58.6 

1,386.5 

65 

0 

126 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 

• 
TABLE 3. PROJECTED NATIONAL IMPACTS OF ALTERNATIVE SO- NSPS 

FOR INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILERS

 6 

(Higher oil and gas prices) 

(Continued) 

Regulatory 

alternative Units 100-150 

Boiler size (MMBtu/hr) 

150-200 200-250 >250 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23 

11.2 

1,008.7 

105 

0 

23 

3.8 

1,010.6 

117 

0 

12 

25.2 

843.7 

56 

0 

55 

7.1 

832.1 

88 

0 

23 

7.1 

832.1 

88 

0 

23 

5.2 

500.4 

50 

0 

17 

5.2 

500.4 

50 

0 

17 

5.2 

500.4 

50 

0 

17 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 

29.5 

1,411.1 

90 

0 

101 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal 

10 short tons SO, 

million $ 1982 

gas 

IO12 Btu resid 

coal