### Ap**pendix XI A ttachment 3**  **Control Measure Benefit Summary for New** **Jersey**

**Post 2002 Updated through 10/23/2012** 

**State or Fed**  **Control Measure Effectiv**  **e Start Date of**  **Benefits Pollutant** **Sector Turn**  **Over (1)**  **Benefits Reference/Notes (3)**  **New Jersey Admin. Code**  **(NJAC) EPA** 

**Approval Date** 

**PM2.5 NOx**  **SO2 VOC (2)**  

### SIP M**easures**

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decree

(PSE&G Hudson) 2000- 2007 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 416 5,850 18,895 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decree

(PSE&G Mercer) 2000- 2007 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 56 11,678 2,463 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decrees

(PSE&G Hudson) 2007- 2011 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 2,015 2,606 3,350 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decree

(PSE&G Mercer) 2007- 2011 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 953 953 13,761 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

New Jersey EGU - BL England

ACO/Acid Rain Program 2000- 2009 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 0 3,920 13,919 Actual Emission Statements/ Not in PM2.5 NAA County NA NA

New Jersey EGU Rule (other than

consent decrees and ACOs)) 2013 PM2.5, SO2, NOx Point 2.16 tpd 788 tpy 7 tpd

2,571 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 4.2, 10.2, 19.4 8/3/2010

New Jersey NOx

Budget Program (SIP Call) 1999 NOx Point 3860 t/ozone

season Rule Proposal 7/20/98, Amended 8/21/00/Overlap with consent decrees and ACO NJAC 7:27-

27.31 5/22/2001

New Jersey NOx

Budget Program (SIP Call) 2003 NOx Point 9140 t/ozone

season Rule Proposal 7/20/98, Amended 8/21/00/Overlap with consent decrees and ACO NJAC 7:27-

27.31 5/22/2001

FederalAcid Rain 1995 SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ NA NA

FederalAcid Rain 2000 SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ Some NOx overlap with Nox Budget Program NA NA **Estimated Benefits tpy ,**  **unless otherwise noted (3)**



### 1

### 2

### 3New

Jersey High Electric Demand

Day (HEDD) Program 2009 SO2, NOx Point 19.8t/HE DD Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.29 8/3/2010

New Jersey High Electric Demand

Day (HEDD) Program 2015 SO2, NOx Point 63.7t/HE DD Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.29 8/3/2010

New Jersey ICI, SCT, SRE 2005

(Point Sources) 2007 NOx Point 6.8 tpd Rule Proposal - 9/20/04 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 7/31/2007

New Jersey ICI, SCT, SRE 2005

(Area Sources) 2010 NOx Area 658 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NJAC 7:27-

19.7 7/31/2007

New Jersey ICI Boilers 2009 2009 NOx Point 1.7 tpd 408 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey ICI Boilers 2009 2010 NOx Point 2.2 tpd 740 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey ICI Boilers 2009 2011 NOx Point 2.9 tpd 970 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 8/3/2010

FederalRICE MACT (Point) 2014 PM2.5, NOx Point 1 74 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NA NA

FederalRICE MACT (Area) 2014 PM2.5, NOx Area 9 In ICI 2005 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NA NA

Federal and NJRefinery Consent

Decrees (Sunoco, Valero, and ConocoPhillips) 2000- 2007 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Point 566 2,612 5,458 3,105 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJRefinery Consent

Decrees (Sunoco, Valero, and ConocoPhillips) 2007- 2011 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Point 19 1,575 1,232 302 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

New Jersey Case by Case NOx

(FSELs/AELs) 2009 NOx Point TBD NJAC 7:27- 19.13 8/3/2010

FederalResidential Woodstove

NSPS 1988 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Area x 263 26 5 PM2.5 Redesignation (3)/ Benefits 2007- 2025 NA NA

New Jersey Asphalt Production

Plants Rule 2009 NOx Point 0.21 tpd 43 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.9 8/3/2010

New Jersey Asphalt Production

Plants Rule 2010 NOx Point 0.42 tpd 86 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.9 8/3/2010

New Jersey Asphalt Production

Plants Rule 2011 NOx Point 0.64 tpd 132 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.9 8/3/2010

New Jersey Glass Manufacturing 2012 NOx Point 3.2 tpd 1,170 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.10 8/3/2010



### 4

### 5

### 6New

Jersey Municipal Waste

Combustors (Incinerators) 2009 NOx Point 0.3 tpd 67 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.13 8/3/2010

New Jersey Municipal Waste

Combustors (Incinerators) 2010 NOx Point 100 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.13 8/3/2010

New Jersey Sewage and Sludge

Incinerators 2009 NOx Point NQ NQ NQ NQ Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.28 8/3/2010

New Jersey Low Sulfur Distillate

and Residual Fuel Strategies (Point) 2014- 2016 SO2,

NOx Point 281 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NJAC 7:27-9 1/3/2012

New Jersey Low Sulfur Distillate

and Residual Fuel Strategies (Area) 2014- 2016 SO2,

NOx Area 3,183 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NJAC 7:27-

27.9 1/3/2012

FederalUSEPA MACT

Standards including Industrial Boiler/Process Heater MACT 2009 VOC Point and Area 1.3 tpd 2.7 tpd Ozone SIP(8) NA NA

New Jersey I/M Program for

Gasoline Vehicles 1974 VOC, NOx, COOnroad Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NJAC 7:27-15 Various

FederalNational Low Emission

Vehicle Program (NLEV) 1999 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

New Jersey New Jersey Low

Emission Vehicle (LEV) Program 2009 PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC, Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NJAC 7:27-292/13/2008

FederalTier 1 Vehicle Program 1994 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

FederalTier 2 Vehicle

Program/Low Sulfur Fuels 2004 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

FederalHeavy-Duty Highway

Rule - Vehicle Standards and Diesel Fuel Sulfur Control 2007 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA



### 7

### 8

### 9FederalHeavy-Duty Highway

Rule - Vehicle Standards and Diesel Fuel Sulfur Control 2010 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

Federal and NJ**Total Onroad Control**

**Measure Benefits in Model 2002-2009**  **2002- 2009**  NOx,

VOC Onroad x **977 81,242**  **2,922 49,597**  2002 Modeling Inventory/Statewide/Incl udes growth (6) NA NA

Federal and NJ**Total Onroad Control**

**Measure Benefits Model 2007-2025**  **2007- 2025**  NOx,

VOC Onroad x **3,236 94,092**  **84 NQ**  PM2.5 Redesignation/ PM2.5 NAA counties only/ Includes growth

(6) NA NA

FederalHeavy Duty Diesel

Vehicle (HDDV) Defeat Device Settlement 1998 NOx Onroad NQ NA NA

New Jersey Vehicle I/M Program

Revisions 2010 VOC, NOx, COOnroad 6.1 tpd 2,226 tpy NOx+ VOC Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 Portion of estimated benefits in Total Onroad Benefits in Model NJAC 7:27-159/16/2011

New Jersey Diesel Smoke (I/M

Cutpoint) Rule Amendments 2010 PM2.5, NOx Onroad 0.06 tpd 22 tpy 0.17 tpd

62 tpy 0.59 tpd

215 tpyRule Proposal - 6/16/08NJAC 7:27-14 TBD

New Jersey Diesel Smoke (I/M

Cutpoint) Rule Amendments 2011 PM2.5, NOx Onroad 0.05 tpd 18 tpy 0.14 tpd

51 tpy 0.55tpd

201 tpyRule Proposal - 6/16/08NJAC 7:27-14 TBD

New Jersey Vehicle Idling Rule

Amendments 2011 PM2.5, NOx Onroad 200 6 tpd PM2.5 from Rule Proposal - 9/18/06 NOx from Ozone SIP(8) NJAC 7:27- 14.1, 14.3 4/14/2009

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 1 Tier 2, Category 3 Tier 1 2004 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 2 Tier 2 2007 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 3 Tier 2 2011 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 3 Tier 3 2016 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA



### 10

### 11

### 12FederalLarge Industrial SparkIgnition Engines over 19 kW(>50 hp) Tier 1 2004 NOx, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLarge Industrial SparkIgnition Engines over 19 kW(>50 hp) Tier 2 2007 NOx, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLocomotive Engines

and Marine Compression-Ignition Engines Less Than 30 Liters per Cylinder Tier 2 2006 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLocomotive Engines

and Marine Compression-Ignition Engines Less Than 30 Liters per Cylinder Tier 3 2009 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLocomotive Engines

and Marine Compression-Ignition Engines Less Than 30 Liters per Cylinder Tier 4 2014 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalNew Nonroad Engine

Standards: Gasoline boats and personal watercraft, outboard engines 1998 VOC, NOx, PM2.5 Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalNew Nonroad Engine

Standards: Gasoline boats and personal watercraft inboard engines 2010 VOC, NOx, PM2.5 Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalNonroad Diesel

Engines:
≥50 hp All engine sizes
≤50 hp 1996- 2014 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA



### 13

### 14

### 15FederalPhase 2 Standards for

New Nonroad SparkIgnition Nonhandheld Engines at or below 19 kW(lawn and garden) 1997- 2012 NOx, VOC, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalPhase 2 Standards for

Small Spark-Ignition Handheld Engines at or below 19 kW(lawn and garden) 1997- 2010 NOx, VOC, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalRecreational Vehicles

(includes snowmobiles, off-highwaymotorcycles, and allterrain vehicles) 2006- 2012 NOx, CO,

VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

Federal**Total Control**

**Measure Benefits in Nonroad model 2002-**  **2009 2002-**  **2009** PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Nonroad x **884 10,776**  **12,178 20,999**  2002 Modeling Inventory/Benefits include growth (6) NA NA

Federal**Total Control**

**Measure Benefits in Nonroad Model 2007-**  **2025 2007-**  **2025** PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Nonroad x **2,053 27,059**  **13,099 NQ**  PM2.5 Redesignation (3)/ PM2.5 counties only NA NA



### Not in Maintenance Plan But Supports SIP New JerseyMercury Rule 2006- 2012 NQ NQ NQ NQ NJAC 7:27-27 NA

FederalMercury and Air Toxics

Standards (MATS) Coal- and oil-fired EGUs 2016 PM2.5, SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

New Jersey Diesel Retrofit

Program 2008- 2015 PM2.5 Onroad,

Nonroad 150 Rule Proposal - 8/6/07 N.J.A.C 7:27- 32 NA

New Jersey New Jersey Clean

Construction Program 2014 PM2.5 Nonroad NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA



### 16

### 17

### 18New

Jersey EGU - BL England

ACO 2013 PM2.5, SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ Not in PM2.5 NAA County NA NA

Federal and NJRefinery Consent

Decree (Hess) 2015 PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC Point NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

New Jersey Stage I and Stage II

(Gasoline Transfer Operations) 2003 VOC Area 14.5 tpd Rule Proposal - 8/5/02 NJAC 7:27- 16.3 7/2/2004

New Jersey Architectural Coatings

2005 2005 VOC Area 25 tpd Rule Proposal - 7/21/03NJAC 7:27-23########

New Jersey Consumer Products

2005 2005 VOC Area 11 tpd Rule Proposal - 9/15/03NJAC 7:27-241/25/2006

New Jersey Consumer Products

2009 Amendments 2009 VOC Area 1.2 tpd Rule Proposal - 11/5/07NJAC 7:27-247/22/2010

New Jersey Mobile Equipment

Repair and Refinishing 2005 VOC Area 9.0 tpd 3,285 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/5/02 NJAC 7:27- 16.12 7/2/2004

New Jersey Portable Fuel

Containers 2005 2005- 2015 VOC Area x 13 tpd 2007 Inventory NJAC 7:27-247/22/2010

New Jersey Portable Fuel

Containers 2009 Amendments 2009- 2019 VOC Area x 12 tpd 2007 Inventory NJAC 7:27-247/22/2010

New Jersey Adhesives and

Sealants 2009 VOC Area 6.9 tpd Rule Proposal - 11/5/07NJAC 7:27-267/22/2010

New Jersey Solvent Cleaning 2005 VOC Area 4.0 tpd 1,460 tpyRule Proposal - 8/5/02 NJAC 7:27- 16.6 7/2/2004

New Jersey Asphalt Paving 2009 VOC Area 3.6 tpd 420 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.19 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2010 VOC Point and Area 2.25 tpd 464 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2011 VOC Point and Area 0.48 tpd 637 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2013 VOC Point and Area 0.95 tpd 984 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2016 VOC Point and Area 1.58 tpd 1,504 tpyRule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010



### 19

### 20

### 21New

Jersey Petroluem Storage 2019 VOC Point and Area 1.4 tpd 2,024 tpyRule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey CTG: Flexible

Packaging Printing Materials 2010 2009 VOC Point and Area 35.3 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey CTG: Offset

Lithographic and Letterpress Printing Materials 2010 2009 VOC Point and Area 157 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey CTG: Flat Wood

Paneling Coatings 2010 VOC Point and Area 0 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey Case by Case VOC

(FSELs/AELs) 2009 VOC Point TBD NJAC 7:27- 16.17 8/3/2010

New Jersey Nonattainment New

Source Review (NNSR) Ongoing PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC Point and Area NQ NQ NQ NQ NJAC 7:27-8 NA

New Jersey Prevention of

Significant Deterioration (PSD) Ongoing PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC Point and Area NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

New Jersey Energy Master Plan OngoingVarious All NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

FederalEnergy Conservation

Standards for New FedComm and MultiFamily High-Rise ResBuildings and New LowRise Res Buildings 2012 SO2, NOx Area NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

**Legend/Notes:** NQ = Not Quantified NA = Not Applicable
TBD = To Be Determined EGU - Electric Generating Unit ICI = Industrial, Commercial and Institutional Boilers SCT = Stationary Combustion Turbines SRE = Stationary Reciprocating Engines IM = Inspection and Maintenance RICE = Reciprocating Internal Combustion Engines



### 22

### 23

### 24MACT = Maximum Achievable Control Technology

CTG = Control Technology Guideline 1. Turnover means measure has cumulative benefits each year until complete fleet or equipment turnover 2. Although the USEPA does not consider VOC as a PM2.5 precursor for SIP and conformity purposes, NJ anticipates PM2.5 benefit from the implementation of these measures. 3. Estimated benefits from the PM2.5 Attainment and Redesignation SIPs are in PM2.5 nonattianment counties only. Actual benefits are statewide Actual benefits are higher due to statewide control measures 4. NJDEP SIP Revision for the Attainment and Maintenance of the Fine Particulate Matter (PM2.5) NAAQS: PM2.5 Attainment Demonstration, Final, dated March 26, 2009 5. See Total Onroad Control Measure Benefits in Model 6. On-road estimated benefits are actually higher, total estimated benefit does not exclude growth in emissions 7. See Total Nonroad Control Measure Benefits in Model 8. NJDEP SIP Revision for the Attainment and Maintenance of the Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standard: 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration, Final, dated October 29, 2007



### 25

### 26

### 27

### Ap**pendix XI A ttachment 3**  **Control Measure Benefit Summary for New** **Jersey**

**Post 2002 Updated through 10/23/2012** 

**State or Fed**  **Control Measure Effectiv**  **e Start Date of**  **Benefits Pollutant** **Sector Turn**  **Over (1)**  **Benefits Reference/Notes (3)**  **New Jersey Admin. Code**  **(NJAC) EPA** 

**Approval Date** 

**PM2.5 NOx**  **SO2 VOC (2)**  

### SIP M**easures** New Jersey I/M Program for

Gasoline Vehicles 1974 VOC, NOx, COOnroad Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NJAC 7:27-15 Various

FederalResidential Woodstove

NSPS 1988 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Area x 263 26 5 PM2.5 Redesignation (3)/ Benefits 2007- 2025 NA NA

FederalTier 1 Vehicle Program 1994 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

FederalAcid Rain 1995 SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ NA NA

FederalNonroad Diesel

Engines:
≥50 hp All engine sizes
≤50 hp 1996- 2014 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalPhase 2 Standards for

Small Spark-Ignition Handheld Engines at or below 19 kW(lawn and garden) 1997- 2010 NOx, VOC, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalPhase 2 Standards for

New Nonroad SparkIgnition Nonhandheld Engines at or below 19 kW(lawn and garden) 1997- 2012 NOx, VOC, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA **Estimated Benefits tpy ,**  **unless otherwise noted (3)**



### 1

### 2

### 3FederalNew Nonroad Engine

Standards: Gasoline boats and personal watercraft, outboard engines 1998 VOC, NOx, PM2.5 Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalHeavy Duty Diesel

Vehicle (HDDV) Defeat Device Settlement 1998 NOx Onroad NQ NA NA

New Jersey NOx

Budget Program (SIP Call) 1999 NOx Point 3860 t/ozone

season Rule Proposal 7/20/98, Amended 8/21/00/Overlap with consent decrees and ACO NJAC 7:27-

27.31 5/22/2001

FederalNational Low Emission

Vehicle Program (NLEV) 1999 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

FederalAcid Rain 2000 SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ Some NOx overlap with Nox Budget Program NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decree

(PSE&G Hudson) 2000- 2007 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 416 5,850 18,895 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decree

(PSE&G Mercer) 2000- 2007 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 56 11,678 2,463 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJRefinery Consent

Decrees (Sunoco, Valero, and ConocoPhillips) 2000- 2007 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Point 566 2,612 5,458 3,105 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

New Jersey EGU - BL England

ACO/Acid Rain Program 2000- 2009 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 0 3,920 13,919 Actual Emission Statements/ Not in PM2.5 NAA County NA NA

Federal and NJ**Total Onroad Control**

**Measure Benefits in Model 2002-2009**  **2002- 2009**  NOx,

VOC Onroad x **977 81,242**  **2,922 49,597**  2002 Modeling Inventory/Statewide/Incl udes growth (6) NA NA

Federal**Total Control**

**Measure Benefits in Nonroad model 2002-**  **2009 2002-**  **2009** PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Nonroad x **884 10,776**  **12,178 20,999**  2002 Modeling Inventory/Benefits include growth (6) NA NA



### 4

### 5

### 6New

Jersey NOx

Budget Program (SIP Call) 2003 NOx Point 9140 t/ozone

season Rule Proposal 7/20/98, Amended 8/21/00/Overlap with consent decrees and ACO NJAC 7:27-

27.31 5/22/2001

FederalTier 2 Vehicle

Program/Low Sulfur Fuels 2004 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 1 Tier 2, Category 3 Tier 1 2004 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLarge Industrial SparkIgnition Engines over 19 kW(>50 hp) Tier 1 2004 NOx, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLocomotive Engines

and Marine Compression-Ignition Engines Less Than 30 Liters per Cylinder Tier 2 2006 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalRecreational Vehicles

(includes snowmobiles, off-highwaymotorcycles, and allterrain vehicles) 2006- 2012 NOx, CO,

VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decrees

(PSE&G Hudson) 2007- 2011 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 2,015 2,606 3,350 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJEGU Consent Decree

(PSE&G Mercer) 2007- 2011 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx Point 953 953 13,761 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJRefinery Consent

Decrees (Sunoco, Valero, and ConocoPhillips) 2007- 2011 PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Point 19 1,575 1,232 302 Actual Emission Statements (2003 start for PM2.5) NA NA

Federal and NJ**Total Onroad Control**

**Measure Benefits Model 2007-2025**  **2007- 2025**  NOx,

VOC Onroad x **3,236 94,092**  **84 NQ**  PM2.5 Redesignation/ PM2.5 NAA counties only/ Includes growth

(6) NA NA



### 7

### 8

### 9Federal**Total Control**

**Measure Benefits in Nonroad Model 2007-**  **2025 2007-**  **2025** PM2.5,

SO2, NOx, VOC Nonroad x **2,053 27,059**  **13,099 NQ**  PM2.5 Redesignation (3)/ PM2.5 counties only NA NA

New Jersey ICI, SCT, SRE 2005

(Point Sources) 2007 NOx Point 6.8 tpd Rule Proposal - 9/20/04 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 7/31/2007

FederalHeavy-Duty Highway

Rule - Vehicle Standards and Diesel Fuel Sulfur Control 2007 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 2 Tier 2 2007 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

FederalLarge Industrial SparkIgnition Engines over 19 kW(>50 hp) Tier 2 2007 NOx, CONonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

New Jersey High Electric Demand

Day (HEDD) Program 2009 SO2, NOx Point 19.8t/HE DD Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.29 8/3/2010

New Jersey ICI Boilers 2009 2009 NOx Point 1.7 tpd 408 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey Case by Case NOx

(FSELs/AELs) 2009 NOx Point TBD NJAC 7:27- 19.13 8/3/2010

New Jersey Asphalt Production

Plants Rule 2009 NOx Point 0.21 tpd 43 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.9 8/3/2010

New Jersey Municipal Waste

Combustors (Incinerators) 2009 NOx Point 0.3 tpd 67 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.13 8/3/2010

New Jersey Sewage and Sludge

Incinerators 2009 NOx Point NQ NQ NQ NQ Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.28 8/3/2010

FederalUSEPA MACT

Standards including Industrial Boiler/Process Heater MACT 2009 VOC Point and Area 1.3 tpd 2.7 tpd Ozone SIP(8) NA NA

New Jersey New Jersey Low

Emission Vehicle (LEV) Program 2009 PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC, Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NJAC 7:27-292/13/2008



### 10

### 11

### 12FederalLocomotive Engines

and Marine Compression-Ignition Engines Less Than 30 Liters per Cylinder Tier 3 2009 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

New Jersey ICI, SCT, SRE 2005

(Area Sources) 2010 NOx Area 658 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NJAC 7:27-

19.7 7/31/2007

New Jersey ICI Boilers 2009 2010 NOx Point 2.2 tpd 740 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey Asphalt Production

Plants Rule 2010 NOx Point 0.42 tpd 86 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.9 8/3/2010

FederalHeavy-Duty Highway

Rule - Vehicle Standards and Diesel Fuel Sulfur Control 2010 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Onroad x Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 Note 5 NA NA

New Jersey Vehicle I/M Program

Revisions 2010 VOC, NOx, COOnroad 6.1 tpd 2,226 tpy NOx+ VOC Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 Portion of estimated benefits in Total Onroad Benefits in Model NJAC 7:27-159/16/2011

New Jersey Diesel Smoke (I/M

Cutpoint) Rule Amendments 2010 PM2.5, NOx Onroad 0.06 tpd 22 tpy 0.17 tpd

62 tpy 0.59 tpd

215 tpyRule Proposal - 6/16/08NJAC 7:27-14 TBD

FederalNew Nonroad Engine

Standards: Gasoline boats and personal watercraft inboard engines 2010 VOC, NOx, PM2.5 Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

New Jersey ICI Boilers 2009 2011 NOx Point 2.9 tpd 970 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey Asphalt Production

Plants Rule 2011 NOx Point 0.64 tpd 132 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.9 8/3/2010

New Jersey Diesel Smoke (I/M

Cutpoint) Rule Amendments 2011 PM2.5, NOx Onroad 0.05 tpd 18 tpy 0.14 tpd

51 tpy 0.55tpd

201 tpyRule Proposal - 6/16/08NJAC 7:27-14 TBD

New Jersey Vehicle Idling Rule

Amendments 2011 PM2.5, NOx Onroad 200 6 tpd PM2.5 from Rule Proposal - 9/18/06 NOx from Ozone SIP(8) NJAC 7:27- 14.1, 14.3 4/14/2009

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 3 Tier 2 2011 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA



### 13

### 14

### 15New

Jersey Glass Manufacturing 2012 NOx Point 3.2 tpd 1,170 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.10 8/3/2010

New Jersey EGU Rule (other than

consent decrees and ACOs)) 2013 PM2.5, SO2, NOx Point 2.16 tpd 788 tpy 7 tpd

2,571 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 4.2, 10.2, 19.4 8/3/2010

FederalRICE MACT (Point) 2014 PM2.5, NOx Point 1 74 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NA NA

FederalRICE MACT (Area) 2014 PM2.5, NOx Area 9 In ICI 2005 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NA NA

FederalLocomotive Engines

and Marine Compression-Ignition Engines Less Than 30 Liters per Cylinder Tier 4 2014 PM2.5, NOx, CO, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

New Jersey High Electric Demand

Day (HEDD) Program 2015 SO2, NOx Point 63.7t/HE DD Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.29 8/3/2010

FederalDiesel Marine Engines

over 37 kWCategory 3 Tier 3 2016 NOx, VOC Nonroad x Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 Note 7 NA NA

New Jersey Municipal Waste

Combustors (Incinerators) 2010 NOx Point 100 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 19.13 8/3/2010

New Jersey Low Sulfur Distillate

and Residual Fuel Strategies (Point) 2014- 2016 SO2,

NOx Point 281 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NJAC 7:27-9 1/3/2012

New Jersey Low Sulfur Distillate

and Residual Fuel Strategies (Area) 2014- 2016 SO2,

NOx Area 3,183 PM2.5 Redesignation (3) NJAC 7:27-

27.9 1/3/2012



### Not in Maintenance Plan But Supports SIP

New Jersey Stage I and Stage II

(Gasoline Transfer Operations) 2003 VOC Area 14.5 tpd Rule Proposal - 8/5/02 NJAC 7:27- 16.3 7/2/2004

New Jersey Architectural Coatings

2005 2005 VOC Area 25 tpd Rule Proposal - 7/21/03NJAC 7:27-23########

New Jersey Consumer Products

2005 2005 VOC Area 11 tpd Rule Proposal - 9/15/03NJAC 7:27-241/25/2006

New Jersey Mobile Equipment

Repair and Refinishing 2005 VOC Area 9.0 tpd 3,285 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/5/02 NJAC 7:27- 16.12 7/2/2004



### 16

### 17

### 18New

Jersey Solvent Cleaning 2005 VOC Area 4.0 tpd 1,460 tpyRule Proposal - 8/5/02 NJAC 7:27- 16.6 7/2/2004

New Jersey Portable Fuel

Containers 2005 2005- 2015 VOC Area x 13 tpd 2007 Inventory NJAC 7:27-247/22/2010


### New JerseyMercury Rule 2006- 2012 NQ NQ NQ NQ NJAC 7:27-27 NA

New Jersey Diesel Retrofit

Program 2008- 2015 PM2.5 Onroad,

Nonroad 150 Rule Proposal - 8/6/07 N.J.A.C 7:27- 32 NA

New Jersey Portable Fuel

Containers 2009 Amendments 2009- 2019 VOC Area x 12 tpd 2007 Inventory NJAC 7:27-247/22/2010

New Jersey Consumer Products

2009 Amendments 2009 VOC Area 1.2 tpd Rule Proposal - 11/5/07NJAC 7:27-247/22/2010

New Jersey Adhesives and

Sealants 2009 VOC Area 6.9 tpd Rule Proposal - 11/5/07NJAC 7:27-267/22/2010

New Jersey Asphalt Paving 2009 VOC Area 3.6 tpd 420 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.19 8/3/2010

New Jersey CTG: Flexible

Packaging Printing Materials 2010 2009 VOC Point and Area 35.3 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey CTG: Offset

Lithographic and Letterpress Printing Materials 2010 2009 VOC Point and Area 157 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey Case by Case VOC

(FSELs/AELs) 2009 VOC Point TBD NJAC 7:27- 16.17 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2010 VOC Point and Area 2.25 tpd 464 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey CTG: Flat Wood

Paneling Coatings 2010 VOC Point and Area 0 Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.7 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2011 VOC Point and Area 0.48 tpd 637 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

FederalEnergy Conservation

Standards for New FedComm and MultiFamily High-Rise ResBuildings and New LowRise Res Buildings 2012 SO2, NOx Area NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA



### 19

### 20

### 21New

Jersey EGU - BL England

ACO 2013 PM2.5, SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ Not in PM2.5 NAA County NA NA

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2013 VOC Point and Area 0.95 tpd 984 tpy Rule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey New Jersey Clean

Construction Program 2014 PM2.5 Nonroad NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

Federal and NJRefinery Consent

Decree (Hess) 2015 PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC Point NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

FederalMercury and Air Toxics

Standards (MATS) Coal- and oil-fired EGUs 2016 PM2.5, SO2, NOx Point NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2016 VOC Point and Area 1.58 tpd 1,504 tpyRule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey Petroluem Storage 2019 VOC Point and Area 1.4 tpd 2,024 tpyRule Proposal - 8/4/08 NJAC 7:27- 16.2 8/3/2010

New Jersey Nonattainment New

Source Review (NNSR) Ongoing PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC Point and Area NQ NQ NQ NQ NJAC 7:27-8 NA

New Jersey Prevention of

Significant Deterioration (PSD) Ongoing PM2.5, SO2, NOx, VOC Point and Area NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

New Jersey Energy Master Plan OngoingVarious All NQ NQ NQ NQ NA NA

**Legend/Notes:** NQ = Not Quantified NA = Not Applicable
TBD = To Be Determined EGU - Electric Generating Unit ICI = Industrial, Commercial and Institutional Boilers SCT = Stationary Combustion Turbines SRE = Stationary Reciprocating Engines



### 22

### 23

### 24IM = Inspection and Maintenance

RICE = Reciprocating Internal Combustion Engines MACT = Maximum Achievable Control Technology CTG = Control Technology Guideline 1. Turnover means measure has cumulative benefits each year until complete fleet or equipment turnover 2. Although the USEPA does not consider VOC as a PM2.5 precursor for SIP and conformity purposes, NJ anticipates PM2.5 benefit from the implementation of these measures. 3. Estimated benefits from the PM2.5 Attainment and Redesignation SIPs are in PM2.5 nonattianment counties only. Actual benefits are statewide Actual benefits are higher due to statewide control measures 4. NJDEP SIP Revision for the Attainment and Maintenance of the Fine Particulate Matter (PM2.5) NAAQS: PM2.5 Attainment Demonstration, Final, dated March 26, 2009 5. See Total Onroad Control Measure Benefits in Model 6. On-road estimated benefits are actually higher, total estimated benefit does not exclude growth in emissions 7. See Total Nonroad Control Measure Benefits in Model 8. NJDEP SIP Revision for the Attainment and Maintenance of the Ozone National Ambient Air Quality Standard: 8-Hour Ozone Attainment Demonstration, Final, dated October 29, 2007



### 25

### 26

### 27