UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

QUICKLOOK CRITERIA PARAMETERS

Oct. 13, 2011 Report Request ID: 919382 Report Code: AMP450

Selection Criteria Page 1 User ID: GYE

State County City

Site Parameter POC AQCR UAR CBSA CSA EPA

Region Method Duration Begin Date End Date

39

54

54 081

009

029 GEOGRAPHIC SELECTIONS

PROTOCOL SELECTIONS

Parameter

Classification Parameter Method Duration

QUICK LOOK 88101

SELECTED OPTIONS

EVENTS PROCESSING

MERGE PDF FILES

WORKFILE DELIMITER Option Type Option Value

EXCLUDE REGIONALLY CONCURRED EVENTS

YES

, SORT ORDER

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 Order Column

PARAMETER_CODE

STATE_CODE

COUNTY_CODE

SITE_ID

POC

DATES

EDT_ID

GLOBAL DATES

2008 Start Date End Date

2010 Tribal

Code

APPLICABLE STANDARDS

Standard Description

PM25 24-hour 2006

PM25 Annual 2006Oct. 13, 2011

Note: The * indicates that the mean does

not satisfy summary criteria. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450)



### Page 1 of 6 EXCEPTIONAL DATA TYPES

EDT DESCRIPTION

0

1

2

5 NO EVENTS

EVENTS EXCLUDED

EVENTS INCLUDED

EVENTS WITH CONCURRENCE EXCLUDEDOct. 13, 2011

Note: The * indicates that the mean does

not satisfy summary criteria. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450)



### Page 2 of 6 PM2.5 - Local Conditions (88101) Ohio Micrograms/cubic meter (LC) (105)

SITE ID P

O

C PQAO CITY COUNTY ADDRESS YEAR METH #OBS 4TH

MAX CERT EDT

39-081-0017

39-081-0017

39-081-0017

39-081-1001

39-081-1001

39-081-1001

39-081-1001

39-081-1001

39-081-1001 1

1

1

1

1

1

2

2

2 0809

0809

0809

0809

0809

0809

0809

0809

0809 Steubenville

Steubenville

Steubenville

Mingo

Junction

Mingo

Junction

Mingo

Junction

Mingo

Junction

Mingo

Junction

Mingo

Junction Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson

Jefferson 618 LOGAN ST.

618 LOGAN ST.

618 LOGAN ST.

501

COMMERICAL

501

COMMERICAL

501

COMMERICAL

501

COMMERICAL

501

COMMERICAL

501

COMMERICAL 2008

2009

2010

2008

2009

2010

2008

2009

2010 120

120

120

120

120

120

120

120

120 45.6

38.6

35.3

39.5

23.5

25.9

38.2

23.1

28.2 Y

Y

Y 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0 24-HOUR

98TH

PERCENTILE

VALUE

35.2

24.7

29.8

35.0

23.3

25.1

38.2

22.5

26.3 106

112

108

57

58

55

48

52

52 1ST

MAX 2ND

MAX 3RD

MAX

36.4

25.1

33.3

35.0

23.3

25.1

33.5

22.5

26.3 35.2

24.7

29.8

30.9

22.9

23.3

26.6

22.4

25.2 34.8

24.0

29.1

27.7

22.5

22.5

26.1

21.1

23.6 14.28*

12.11

12.68

14.05

11.22

12.64

13.57*

10.69*

13.01* WTD

ARITH

MEANOct. 13, 2011

Note: The * indicates that the mean does

not satisfy summary criteria. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450)



### Page 3 of 6 PM2.5 - Local Conditions (88101) West Virginia Micrograms/cubic meter (LC) (105)

SITE ID P

O

C PQAO CITY COUNTY ADDRESS YEAR METH #OBS 4TH

MAX CERT EDT

54-009-0005

54-009-0005

54-009-0005

54-009-0011

54-009-0011

54-009-0011

54-009-0011

54-009-0011

54-009-0011

54-029-1004 1

1

1

1

1

1

2

2

2

1 1150

1150

1150

1150

1150

1150

1150

1150

1150

1150 Follansbee

Follansbee

Follansbee

Weirton

Weirton

Weirton

Weirton

Weirton

Weirton

Weirton Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Brooke

Hancock FOLLANSBEE -

MAHAN LANE

FOLLANSBEE -

MAHAN LANE

FOLLANSBEE -

MAHAN LANE

WEIRTON -

MARLAND

HEIGHTS

ELEMENTARY

WEIRTON -

MARLAND

HEIGHTS

ELEMENTARY

WEIRTON -

MARLAND

HEIGHTS

ELEMENTARY

WEIRTON -

MARLAND

HEIGHTS

ELEMENTARY

WEIRTON -

MARLAND

HEIGHTS

ELEMENTARY

WEIRTON -

MARLAND

HEIGHTS

ELEMENTARY

WEIRTON - OAK

ST AND OWINGS

ST (BETWEEN 2008

2009

2010

2008

2009

2010

2008

2009

2010

2008 145

145

145

145

145

145

145

145

145

145 39.8

38.3

32.6

37.4

48.6

38.0

38.4

48.4

37.6

39.4 Y

Y

Y

Y 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0 24-HOUR

98TH

PERCENTILE

VALUE

38.9

23.2

29.8

34.9

26.3

31.6

38.4

48.4

37.6

35.8 117

122

122

121

118

122

29

32

29

119 1ST

MAX 2ND

MAX 3RD

MAX

39.5

24.4

32.0

35.9

29.3

36.3

37.5

25.7

30.0

37.3 38.9

23.2

29.8

34.9

26.3

31.6

34.7

25.0

29.2

35.8 35.6

23.1

29.7

34.5

24.7

30.8

31.4

19.2

21.5

30.9 14.68

12.15

14.14

13.79

11.88

13.48

15.48

11.86

14.37

13.33 WTD

ARITH

MEANOct. 13, 2011

Note: The * indicates that the mean does

not satisfy summary criteria. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450)



### Page 4 of 6 PM2.5 - Local Conditions (88101) West Virginia Micrograms/cubic meter (LC) (105)

SITE ID P

O

C PQAO CITY COUNTY ADDRESS YEAR METH #OBS 4TH

MAX CERT EDT

54-029-1004

54-029-1004 1

1 1150

1150 Weirton

Weirton Hancock

Hancock DEAD ENDS)

WEIRTON - OAK

ST AND OWINGS

ST (BETWEEN

DEAD ENDS)

WEIRTON - OAK

ST AND OWINGS

ST (BETWEEN

DEAD ENDS) 2009

2010 145

145 29.6

34.4 0

0 24-HOUR

98TH

PERCENTILE

VALUE

25.2

31.2 122

122 1ST

MAX 2ND

MAX 3RD

MAX

28.7

33.1 25.2

31.2 22.9

30.7 11.25

12.58 WTD

ARITH

MEANOct. 13, 2011

Note: The * indicates that the mean does

not satisfy summary criteria. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450)



### Page 5 of 6 88101

88101 120

145 Andersen RAAS2.5-300 PM2.5 SEQ w/WINS

R & P Model 2025 PM-2.5 Sequential Air Sampler GRAVIMETRIC

Gravimetric PARAMETER METHOD

CODE COLLECTION METHOD ANALYSIS METHOD METHODS USED IN THIS REPORTOct. 13, 2011

Note: The * indicates that the mean does

not satisfy summary criteria. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

AIR QUALITY SYSTEM

QUICK LOOK REPORT (AMP450)



### Page 6 of 6 PQAOS USED IN THIS REPORT

PQAO AGENCY DESCRIPTION

0809

1150 Ohio EPA, Southeast District Office

West Virginia Air Pollution Control Commission

### Environmental

Protection Agency

John R. Kasich, Governor

Mary Taylor, Lt. Governor

Scott 

### J. Nally, Director



## CERTIFIED MAIL

March 10, 2011

Cheryl L. Newton, Director

Air and Radiation Division

U.S.EPA, Region V

77 West Jackson Boulevard

Chicago, Illinois 60604

RE: 2010 SLAMS PM,_, and Ozone Data Certification

Dear Ms. Newton:

Please find enclosed our SLAMS Report (AMP-450, AMP-450NC and AMP255) for calendar year 2010 as required in 40 CFR, Part 58, Section

58.15. The ambient concentration and the quality assurance data

have been completely submitted to the AQS database.

The remaining criteria pollutant data will be certified within the

month of April.

I certify that the Ozone and PM,_, data in the report are accurate to

the best of our knowledge taking into consideration the quality

assurance findings and only to the extent of the activities

performed by Ohio EPA.

There were no incidents of air pollution that reached or exceeded

levels as specified by Section 51.151 which could cause significant

harm to the health of persons.

Sincerely,

Robert Hodanbosi

Chief, Division of Air Pollution Control

Enclosure

50 West Town Street,**Su~e** 700

P.O. Box 1049

Columbus, OH 43216·1049 614\644 3020

614\644 3184 (fax)

www.epa.ohio.gov

## 1 

# OHIO

2005 Base Year PM2.5 SIP Inventory

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

Lazarus Government Center

50 West Town Street, Suite 700

Columbus Ohio 43215

Prepared by Ohio EPA

Division of Air Pollution Control

Emissions Inventory Unit

February 2008

## 2 

# Table of Contents

Section Page

Introduc tion ................................................................................................. 3

1.0 Point Sources ............................................................................................. 4

2.0 Area S ources .............................................................................................. 8

3.0 Non Road Sources........................................................................15

4.0 On Road Sources.......

.................. .................. ................ ................ .............17

5.0 MAR Sources..............................................................................43

Table

2-1 Categories included in the 2005 area source Inventory.............................8

2-2 Emission Factors used for Wood Bu rners included in area sources............11

3-1 NMIM NCD Tables for Specific Years and States ........................................... 

## 16

4-1 Federal Functional Class Categories............................................................ 

## 23

4-2 DVMT Summary by County



## .................................................................. . 24

4-3 Speed by Federal Functional Class ............................................................. 

## 28

4-4 Link Group Codes & Associated BPR Curves

.......................................... 

## 29

4-5 Mobile6 Inputs.................................................................................31

4-6 LADCO Data Output............................................. .............39

4-7 County Summary Table of MPOs by County......................................... .40

5-1 Number of operations and LTOs for 2005.............................................. 45

5-2 EDMS Aircraft Emissions ..................................................................50

5-3 Fleet Emission Fa ctor Categories ........................................................51

5-4 Pollutant by County (Sample) ............................................................. 54

. Figure

1............................... ......... Speed Comparison Graphs.....................................27

## 3 

# 2005 Base Year PM2.5 SIP Inventory for Ohio

Introduction

The State of Ohio has a nu mber of counties with air quality data showing nonattainment for the following PM 2



## . 5 

## standard:

• 

## Annual Standard = 15.0 ug/m3

The Clean Air Act Amendments (CAA A) requires all states to revise and submit State

Implementation Plans (SIP) for areas which are classified as non-atta inment of the 1997

Fine Particle (PM 2



## . 5 

## ) National Ambient Air Quality St andards (NAAQS). The Federal

Register ( Vol. 72, No. 79/ Wednesday, April 25, 2007) provides the emissions inventory

rules and regulations for the PM 2



## . 5 

## Clean Air Fine Particle implementation rule. An

electronic version of the document can be found at http://www.epa.gov/fedrgstr/EPAAIR/2007/April/Day-25/a6347.pdf.



## As part of the designation of non-attainment areas for PM 2



## . 5 

## standards, a new

attainment demonstration SIP will be necessary. A key el ement in the overall SIP

planning process is the need for an updated emissions inventory. This document

presents the 2005 Base Year Pa rticulate SIP Emissions Inv entory for Ohio as required

by the CAAA. It includes emissions for poi nt, area, on-road mobi le and non-road mobile

for the State of Ohio.

This technical report document s the procedures and the me thodologies that were used

in the development of daily emissions for all counties in Ohio. This report describes the

following:

1. Identification of st ationary and mobile sources included in the

inventory;

2. Sources of data, and data collecti on methods used in the development

of the inventory;

3. Methods and procedures used to estimate emissions; and

4. Assumptions considered in t he development of the emissions

inventories.

The intent of this report is to descri be how the inventory was prepared, and what

information was considered in the inventory development.

This document is comprised of 5 sections , one section for each inventory type. The

biogenic inventory is not being discussed in this document because Ohio EPA did not

participate in the generation of this inventory. Lake Michigan Air Directors Consortium

(LADCO) ran EPA’s BEIS model in the Em ission Modeling System (EMS) to generate

Summer Weekday emissions for VOC and NOx.

## 4 

# SECTION 1

POINT SOURCES

Emissions and source specific data for point sources are collected for the 2005 baseyear SIP inventory by the Ohio Envir onmental Protection Agency (Ohio EPA.) The

primary source of data for point sources is facility reported STARShip files. STARShip

is a software package developed by Ohio EPA, Division of Ai r Pollution Control (DAPC),

to assist the regulated community in prepar ing and submitting a variety of electronic

permit applications and reports to the DAPC . These data are reported by the Title V

facilities annually as part of the emission s fee/inventory process conducted by Ohio

EPA and include emissions, process rates, oper ating schedules, emissions control data

and other relevant information.

The STARShip files are electr onically transferred to the DAPC and stored into the

Division’s Oracle database, STARS. The f iles are reviewed by the local air agencies

and Ohio EPA district and central office staff. After review, the data are imported into

Excel and linked with an Access® database to further process the information into the

federally approved National Em ission Inventory (NEI) database format in version 3.0.

The files are quality assured ag ain using the United States Environmental Protection

Agency’s (U.S.EPA) QA/QC so ftware for format and content. The data is finally

submitted to LADCO for emissions processi ng through the Emissions Modeling System.

The State provided inv entory for Electric Generating Un its (EGU) is replaced with the

Federal EGU inventory. T he EGU inventory is compiled by U.S. EPA’s Acid Rain

Program. It is based on facility report ed emissions as meas ured by continuous

emissions monitors. In conclusion, the final point source inventory is a hybrid of the

federal EGU inventory and the state provided non-EGU units.

A major distinction typically made in emissi ons inventories is t hat between point and

area sources. In this invent ory, point sources are sources for which individual records

are maintained for that source. Such records are maintained for all Ohio Title V facilities

(706 facilities statewide). The area source inventory accounts for facilities from nonTitle V facilities and calculates emissions information using surrogate emissions factors

based on energy usage, population, employment records, or other reliable data. A

more detailed discussion of t he area source inventory is pr ovided in Section 2. The

point source inventory descr ibed herein is considered to be the most current and

accurate source of emissions data available for 2005.

1.1 Point Source Process Emissions

Ohio EPA defines point source process emissions as those which occur at an

identifiable Title V stationary stack or vent. Point source emissions not emitted from

discrete stacks or vents are termed fugitive emissions and are discussed in Section 1.2.

## 5 1.1.1 Source Identificati on and Data Collection

The sources to be included in the 2005 base year inventory are identified using the Title

V STARS database. Facility production and emissions data are included in this

database. This information is fac ility-reported actual 2005 emissions.

1.1.2 Non-reactive VOC Emissions Adjustments

This section is primarily appl icable for VOC pollutants. S ources are required to identify

emissions of photochemically non-reactive Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC.) Based

upon this information, those emissions have been specifically excl uded from the 2005

base line inventory in accordance with U.S. EPA’s “Recommended Policy on the

Control of Volatile Organic Co mpounds.” A complete list of the compounds that U.S.

EPA has identified as being photochemically non -reactive, and therefore not included in

the inventory, are listed below:

• Methane

• Ethane

• Methylene chloride

• Methyl chloroform

• Trichlorofluoromethane (CFC-11)

• Dichlorodifluoromethane (CFC-12)

• Chlorodifluoromethane (CFC-22)

• Trifluoromethane (HFC-23)

• Chlorofluoromethance (HCFC-31)

• Difluoromethane (HFC-32)

• Decafluoropentane (HFC-43-10mee)

• Ethylfluoride (HFC-161)

• Trichlorotrifluoroethane (CFC-113)

• Dichlorotetrafluoroethane (CFC-114)

• Chloropentafluoroethane (CFC-115)

• 2,2-Dichloro-1,1,1-trifluoroethane (HCFC-123)

• 1,1,2-Trifluoroethane (HCFC-123a)

• 2-Chloro-1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane (HCFC-124)

• Pentafluoroethane (HFC-125)

• 1,1,2,2,-Tetrafluoroethane (HFC-134)

• 1,1,1,2-Tetrafluoroethane (HFC-134a)

• 1,1-Dichloro-1-fluoroethane (HCFC-141b)

• 1-Chloro-1,1,-difluoroethane (HCFC-142b)

• 1,1,1-Trifluoroethane (HFC-143a)

• Fluoroethane (HCFC-151a)

• 1,1-Difluoroethane (HFC-152a)

• Pentafluoropropane (HFC-225ca)

• Pentafluoropropane (HFC-225cb)

• Hexafluoropropane (HFC-236ea)

• Hexafluoropropane (HFC-236fa)

• Pentafluoropropane (HFC-245ca)

• Pentafluoropropane (HFC-245ea)

• Pentafluoropropane (HFC-245eb)

## 6 • Pentafluoropropane (HFC-245fa)

• Pentafluorobutane (HFC-365mfc)

• Parachlorobenzotrifluoride (PCBTF)

• Methoxybutane

• Nonaflourobutane

• Heptafluoropropane ((CF 3 

### ) 2 

### CFCF 2 

### OCH 3 

### )

• Heptafluoropropane ((CF 3 

### )CFCF 2 

### OC 2 

### H 5 

### )

• Perchloroethylene

• Cyclic, branched or linear completely methylated siloxanes

• Methyl acetate

• Volatile methyl siloxanes

• Acetone



## 1.1.3 Emissions Esti mation Methodologies

Since source reported actual annual emi ssions are used in the 2005 base year

inventory, no estimation methods are necessary . The reports are provided to LADCO in

National Emissions Inventory Input Format (NIF) 3.0 format. LADCO imported and

processed the NIF files in EMS and applied temporal and spat ial profiles to the annual

emissions to calculate weekday emissions rate s. The final point source inventory is

split into two separate reports, the Electric Generating Units (EGU) which is the U.S.

EPA inventory for electric generating units a nd the non-EGU which is the state inventory

minus the EGU units.

1.2 Point Source Fugitive Emissions

Another type of emissions data which is r equired to be filed from point sources is

fugitive emissions. Before 1990, fugitive emissions were categorized as area sources

due to the lack of detailed information availa ble for fugitive sources. However, since

these emissions are now el ectronically reported in t he State’s ORACLE database,

STARS, these emissions can be classified as point sources.

1.3 References

Getting Started: Emissions In ventory Methods for PM2.5 U.S. Environmental Protection

Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, September, 1999.

Emissions Inventory Guidance for Implem entation of Ozone and Particulate Matter

National Ambient Air Qaulity Standards (N AAQS) and Regional Haze Regulations

, Office of Air Quality Planning & Standards Research, Triangle Park, NC. November

2005.

Compilation of Air Pollution Emission Factors, Fourth Ed ition and Supplements, AP-42

. U.S. Environmental Protecti on Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, September 1985.

## 7 Preparing 2002 Regional PM2.5 Emissions QAQPS PM Inventory Conference Inventory

Conference San Diego, 2003.

Documentation for the 2002 Electric Generating Unit Nati onal Emissions Inventory

(NEI) . Eastern research group, Inc., 1600 Peri meter Park Drive, Morrisville, NC 27560

and E.H. Pechan and Associates, Inc., 5528–B Hempstead Way

## 8 

# SECTION 2

AREA SOURCES

Area sources are sources which are typically small, indivi dual, numerous, and have not

been inventoried as specific point, mobile, or biogenic sources. For inventory purposes,

they are grouped with other like sources into categories that allow emissions to be

calculated collectively usi ng one methodology. Since area sources are traditionally

defined at the county level, most methods are designed to estimate area source

emissions at the county level.

Ohio EPA has either used published Emission Inventory Improvement Program (EIIP) 6



## methodologies or selected other methodologies which are shared by other states. The

decision of which methodology to use was lar gely based on Ohio’s data availability.

Data which was not available on a county-lev el is estimated by assigning a percentage

of the state’s total activity to each county based on the state’s popul ation or employment

information. If Ohio county specific activity data is available throu gh Ohio EPA or other

State Agencies, that data is us ed rather than allocating acti vity by percentage. Table 2-1

lists the sources which emit PM 2.5 

## , NO

x 

## and SO 2 

## along with the respective EFs used to

calculate each pollutant.

Table 2-1 Categories in the 2005 PM 2



## . 5 

## SIP Area Source inventory

Area Source NO

x 

## PM 2.5 

## SO 2 

## Section

Commercial Natural

Gas Combustion 94 lb/MMSCF 7.6 lb/MMSCF 0.6 lb/MMSCF 2.1

Industrial Distillate Oil

Combustion 20 lb/E3gal fuel 0.25 lb/E3gal fuel 42.6 lb/E3gal fuel 2.2

Industrial Residual Oil

Combustion 55 lb/E3gal fuel 4.67 lb/E3gal fuel 157 lb/E3gal fuel 2.2

Industrial Natural Gas

Combustion 94 lb/MMSCF 7.6 lb/MMSCF 0.6 lb/MMSCF 2.2

Residential Coal

Combustion 9.1 Lb/Ton Coal 3.8 Lb/Ton Coal 31 Lb/Ton Coal 2.3

Residential Distillate

Oil Combustion 18 lb/E3gal fuel 0.83 lb/E3gal fuel 42.6 lb/E3gal fuel 2.3

Residential Natural

Gas Combustion 94 lb/MMSCF 7.6 lb/MMSCF 0.6 lb/MMSCF 2.3

Residential LPG

Combustion 13 lb/E3gal fuel 0.17 lb/E3gal fuel 0.1 lb/E3gal fuel 2.3

Human Cremation 1.01E+01 lb/Ton

cremated 0.0637 lb/Ton

cremated NA 2.4

Structure Fires 1.4 Lb/Ton

burned 10.8 Lb/Ton

burned NA 2.5

Outdoor Wood Boilers 2.8 Lb/Ton 2.76E+1 Lb/Ton 4 E-1 Lb/Ton 2.6

## 9 Residential Wood

Combustion

Non-Certified

Non-Catalytic

Catalytic 2.80E+00 lb/Ton

2.80E+00 lb/Ton

2.00E+00 lb/Ton 3.06E+01 lb/Ton

1.96E+01 lb/Ton

2.04E+01 lb/Ton 4.00E-01 lb/Ton

4.00E-01 lb/Ton

4.00E-01 lb/Ton 2.3

2.1 

## Commercial Natural Gas Combustion (SCC 2103006000)

The 2005 total state-level commercial sector energy consumption is obtained from the

Energy Information Administration (EIA)’s State Energy Data System (SEDS), and

apportioned per county based on population 4 

## . Emissions factors are given in table 2-1.

The area source emissions are calculated ba sed on an adjusted value by subtracting

the emissions due to point sources.

2.2 Industrial Fuel Combustion

Industrial Distillate Oil Combustion (SCC 2102004000)

Ohio’s fuel consumption is apportioned per county based on the county’s population 4



## . The area source NO X 

## emissions are calculated and adjusted by subtracting the

emissions due to point source s. A heating value of 140 MMBTU/1000 Gal is used and

84,408 thousand gallons are consumed in 2005. [MMBTU stand for Million British

Thermal Units]. Emissions fact ors are given in table 2-1.

SO 2 

## emissions were calculated us ing EF 42.6 Lb/1000 Gal. PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions

are calculated using 1Lb/1000 Ga l and 0.25 Lb/1000 Gal respecti vely. All Factors are

obtained from AP-42 19



## Industrial Residual Oil Combustion (SCC 2102005000)

Ohio’s fuel consumption is apportioned per county based on the county’s population 4



## . The area source NO X 

## emissions are calculated and adjusted by subtracting the

emissions due to point sour ces. 54,652 thousand gallons 14 

## are consumed in 2005 and

a heating value of 140 MMBTU/1000 Gal is used. The SO 2 

## emissions are calculated

using EF 157 Lb/1000 Gal. PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions are calculated using 7.17 Lb/1000

Gal and 4.67 Lb/1000 Gal respectively. All factors are obtained from AP-42 19



## Industrial Natural Gas Combustion (S CC 2102006000)

Ohio’s fuel consumption is apportioned per county based on the county’s population 4



## . The area source NO X 

## emissions are calculated and adjusted by subtracting the

emissions due to point sources. 293,857 MMCF 14 

## are consumed in 2005. The SO 2

## 10 emissions are calculated usi ng EF 0.6 Lb/MMBTU. The PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions are calculated using 7.6 Lb/MMBTU. All factors were obtained from AP-42 19



## 2.3 Residential Fuel Combustion

Residential Coal Combustion (SCC 2104001000)

Ohio’s household consumption of coal is apportioned per county based on county

population 4 

## . NO X 

## emissions are calculated using EF of 9.1 of coal. The SO 2 

## emissions

are calculated using EF 31Lb/1000 Gal. The PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions are calculated

using 6.2Lb/Ton and 3.8 Lb/Ton respectively . All factors were obtained from AP-42 19



## Residential Distillate Oil Combustion (SCC 2104004000)

Ohio’s household consumption of distillate oil is apportioned per county based on

county population 4 

## . NO X 

## emissions are calculated us ing EF of 18 lb/1000 gallons

distillate fuel respectively. A heating value of 140 MMBTU/1000 Gal is used. The SO 2 

## emissions are calculated using EF 42.6 Lb/1000 Gal. The PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions

are calculated using 1.08Lb/1000 Gal and 0.83 Lb/1000 Gal respec tively. All factors are

obtained from AP-42 19



## Residential Liquid Petroleu m Gas Combustion (LPG)

(SCC 2104007000)

Ohio’s household consumption of LPG is apportioned per county based on county

population 4 

## . NO X 

## emissions are calculated using EF of 13 lb/1000 gallons LPG. The

SO 2 

## emissions are calculated usi ng EF 0.1 Lb/1000 Gal. The PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions

are calculated using 0.17Lb/1000 Gal. All factors are obtained from AP-42 19



## Residential Natural Gas Combustion (SCC 2104006010)

Ohio’s household consumption of LPG is apportioned per county based on county

population 4 

## . NO X 

## emissions are calculated using EF of 94 lb/MMSCF. MMSCF stands

for Million Standard Cubic Feet. This source also emits SO 2 

## emissions which are

calculated using EF 0.6 Lb/MMBTU. The PM 10 

## and PM 2.5 

## emissions are calculated

using 7.6Lb/MMBTU. All fact ors are obtained from AP-42 19



## Residential Wood Combustion

NO X 

## emissions from this area source are ca lculated for seven types of residential

heating units that utilize wood for fuel. They are listed below with the appropriate SCC:

Fireplaces without inserts 2104008001

Fireplaces with inserts cataly tic (non-U.S. EPA cert) 2104008002

Fireplaces with inserts non -catalytic 2104008003

Fireplaces with inserts catalytic (U.S. EPA cert) 2104008004

Wood stoves – Conventional 2104008010

Woodstoves – Catalytic 2104008030

Wood stoves – Non catalytic 2104008050

## 11 The number of Ohio homes with fireplaces ar e adjusted for those t hat burn wood. The

following assumptions are applie d to those adjusted homes:

92 percent of wood combust ed in non-certified units

5.7 percent of wood combusted in non-catalytic units

2.3 percent of wood combusted in catalytic units

A state consumption value is applied which is apportioned to each county based on its

population 4 

## . Table 2-2 shows the EF used for each of the seven types of indoor wood

burners which make-up this category:

Table 2-2 Emission Factors Used for Wood Burners

SCC 2104008002 210400 8003 2104008004

SCC 2104008010 210400 8050 2104008030

SCC 2104008001

RAPIDS Code Non-Certified N on-Catalytic Catalytic Units

SO 2 

## 4.00E-01 4.00E-01 4.00E-01 Lb/ton

NO X 

## 2.80E+00 2.80E+00 2.00E+00 Lb/ton

PM 2.5 

## 3.06E+01 1.96E+01 2.04E+01 Lb/ton

To avoid double counting of wood consumption for fuel, this category is adjusted by

subtracting the wood consumption from OWB to allow this category to account only for

indoor wood burning emissions.

Residential Wood combustion also emits SO 2 

## which is calculated using EF 0.4 Lb/Ton

EF. The PM 2.5 

## emissions are calculated using EF as shown in table 2-2. All factors are

obtained from AP-42 19



## 2.4 Human Cremation (SCC 2810060200)

Not all Ohio counties possess a crematory so only those counties with crematories are

used to calculate the number of cremations and their resulting NOx emissions. The

2005 cremation data is obtained fr om the Ohio Department of Health, Vital Statistics 17



## . It is estimated that 3% of deaths occur outsi de the State of Ohio with no available data

to account for their disposition at the time this area source is being calculated.

Therefore, those deaths are not accounted for in this category.

The methodology does not offer an EF for NOx for this category nor is NOx required to

be calculated for this area source. Ohio f eels that it is a combustion source and NOx

needs to be included in the inventory al ong with the other com bustion sources.

Through its Permits-to-Install for human crem ation, Ohio has se lected a NOx EF of

10.13lb/ton cremated to calculate emi ssions from this area source.

## 12 This source also emits PM, PM 10 

## , and PM 2.5 

## emissions which are calculated using EF

0.1 Lb/Ton, 0.071Lb/Ton and, 0.0637 Lb/Ton respec tively. All factors are obtained from

AP-42 19



## 2.5 Structur e Fires (SCC 2810030000)

The Structure Fires category includes resid ential and commercial fires resulting from

unintentional actions. Intentional fires, fo rest and wildfires, agricultural, and vehicle

burning are not included in this area source

. The State Fire Marshall Office, Fire

Prevention Bureau 15 

## provided data on the number of st ructure fires per county in 2005.

This area source is consider ed a combustion source for NO X 

## emissions which are

calculated using EF 1.4 lb/ton burned. The residential and commercial structures fires

for each county are tabul ated and a fuel load ing of 1.15 Ton/fire is applied. This source

also emits PM, PM 10 

## , and PM 2.5 

## emissions which are calculat ed using EF 10.8 Lb/Ton.

This factor was obtained from AP-42 19



## 2.6 Outdoor W ood Boilers (SCC 2104008070)

Outdoor Wood Boilers (OWB), are also known as outdoor water stoves and outdoor

wood furnaces, are used as outdoor residenti al heaters. These boilers have wood

burning fireboxes surrounded by a water reserv oir vented by a chimney stack. The

combustion of the wood in t he firebox heats the water in the surrounding reservoir and

the heated water is pumped to the residence. OWB units can also supply residential

hot water. The water capacit y ranges from 60 gallons to 764 gallons. The operational

design creates long periods where the fire smolders and creosote is formed 13



## .

When the water circulating through the furn ace reaches an upper set point, the air

supply to the fire is cut-off, cooling the fire so the water will not overheat. The furnace

operates in this "idle" mode until the water te mperature hits a lower set point and the air

supply is re-established. The OWB may be in idle mode far longer than in operating

mode. This type of operating causes very poor combustion and heavy foul smoke. Most

of the smoke emitted is fi ne condensed organic material t hat does not burn under cool,

oxygen starved conditions. In addition, many owners burn green wood full of moisture

which also causes poor combustion 12



## . The smoke created from these outdoor wood

burning units can contain severa l pollutants that are harmful to breathe, including fine

particle pollution such as PM 2.5 11 

## in addition to NOx (research assisted by Deborah

Lucas, DAPC intern, 2007)

This new area source category has many unknowns and variables associated with it

and Ohio does not possess accurate OWB uni t sales data available to calculate

emissions on the county level. Therefore, several assu mptions are made in agreement

with the Great Lake States in order to formulate a homogeneous inventory for the

region.

## 13 The assumptions are as follows:

• 100% of wood combusted in non-certified units.

• OWB units to be 90% in rural counties and 10% in urban counties

• 11.68 cords of wood consumption per unit per year (includes heating efficiency of

30-40%)

• 5 months heating season = 3650 hours (24/7)

• PM 2.5 

## emissions factor (g/kg wood) =13.82 (Average of indoor and outdoor) or

27.64 lb/ton of wood

The agreed upon methodology requi res that total number of OWB sold in Ohio be

apportioned to each county based on rural or urban designation while observing the 9:1

ratio in area sales. The guesstimated factor s (see above) are applied to calculate the

emissions from this outdoor wood burner. Total emissions obtained from this category

are subtracted from the Residential Wood Co mbustion category to allow for accurate

emissions from the indoor wood burning units.

2.7 References

1. Documentation For the 2002 Non-Point S ource National Emission Inventory For

CAPS and HAPS . U.S. Environmental Protecti on Agency. Emissions Factor and

inventory Group. E.H Pe chan and Associates, Inc. January 2004.

2. United States Census Bureau. Population Division.

http://eire.census.gov/popest/data/c ounties/tables/CO-EST 2002/CO-EST2002-01-

39.php (Accessed 2003)

3. United States Census Bureau. County Business Patterns.

http://censtats.census.gov/cbpnaic/cbpnaic.shtml

(Accessed 2003)

4. Ohio Department of Development, Office of Strategic Research. Population Projects

by Age and Sex: 2005-2030. http://www.odod.ohio.gov /research/files/p200.htm

(Accessed August 2006)

5. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 1999 Base Year Non-point Source National

Emission Inventory for Hazardous Air Pollutants, Research Triangle Park, NC.

September 28, 2001.

6 . Environmental Protection Agency ( EPA). STAPPA-ALAP CO-EPA Emission

Inventory Improvement Progr am (EIIP). Volume III - Area Sources Preferred and

Alternative Methods. November 1996.

7. Documentation for the Dr aft 1999 National Emissions In ventory (Version 3.0) for

Criteria Air Pollutants and Amm onia. Area Sources. E. H. Pechan & Associates, Inc.

March 3, 2003

## 14 8. U.S. Environmental Pr otection Agency, STAPPA-ALAPC O-EPA Emission Inventory

Improvement Program (EIIP), Volume III - Area Sources Preferred and Alternative

Methods, Chapter 8. September 1997.

9. Spreadsheet formulation provided by “Buzz” David Asse lmeier, Air Quality Planning

Section, Inventory Group, Springfield, Illinois.

10. Environmental Protection Agen cy (EPA). STAPPA-ALAPCO-EPA Emission

Inventory Improvement Progr am (EIIP). Volume III - Area Sources Preferred and

Alternative Methods. May 1997.

11. (Environmental Chemistr y.com) viewed on Feb 8th, 2007.

[http://environmentalchemistry.com/yogi /environmental/200602out doorwoodfurnaces.ht

ml ]

12. (Washington State, Department of Ecology) viewed on Feb 8th, 2007

[http://www.ecy.wa.gov/progr ams/air/AOP_Permits/Boiler /Outdoor_Boilers_home.html]

13. U.S. Environmental Protection Agen cy. Reducing Pollution from Outdoor WoodFired Hydronic Heaters. Fact Sheet

http://www.epa.gov/owhh/ pdfs/fact_sheet_1_29_07.pdf (Accessed 1/2007)

14. Industrial Sector E nergy Price and Expenditure Estimates, 1970-2001, Ohio.

Energy Information Administration. U. S. Department of Energy.

http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/st ates/sep_prices/ind/pr_ind_oh.html

http://www.eia.doe.gov/em eu/aer/pdf/pages/sec1_27.pdf (Accessed 2003)

15. State Fire Marshal Office. Fire Prevention Bureau, Columbus, Ohio.

http://www.com.state.oh. us/odoc/sfm/firecont.htm (Accessed 2003)

16. Documentation for the Draft 1999 National Emissions In ventory (Version 3.0) For

Criteria Air Pollutants and Amm onia. Area Sources. E. H. Pechan & Associates, Inc.

March 3, 2003

17. Ohio Department of Health, Vital Statistics

18. Environmental Protection Agency. STAPPA-ALAPCO-EPA Em ission Inventory

Improvement Program (EIIP). Volume X – Emissions Projections. December 1999.

http://www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/eiip/techreport/volume10/x01.pdf

(Accessed 2/2007)

19. Environmental Protection Agency. AP-42. http://www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/ap42/

## 15 

# SECTION 3

NON-ROAD SOURCES

The non-road inventory is gener ated regionally by running U. S. EPA’s Nati onal Mobile

Inventory Model (NMIM) model. The Wi sconsin Department of Natural Resources

undertook the responsibility of customizing the NMIM input files and submitting the

output file in NIF format to LADCO and U.S. EPA. LADCO process ed the NMIM files in

their emissions model and generat ed daily emissions rates. Grant Heatherington from

the Wisconsin Department of Natural Reso urces provided the following descriptions...

The National Mobile Inventory Model (NMIM) developed by USEPA was used to

estimate emissions for all other non-road m obile categories. NMIM consolidates nonroad mobile emissions and on-road emissions modeling into a singl e modeling system.

Only the non-road emissions modeling portion of NMIM was used in the development of

this emission’s inventory. NMIM uses the USEPA’s NONROAD model to calculate nonroad mobile emissions. The basic NONROAD algorithm for calculating emissions uses

base year equipment populati ons, average load factors, available engine powers,

activity hours and emission factors. Before NMIM was run, modifications and additions

were made to the NM IM input data.

a. Added emission factors for diesel ta mpers/rammers provided by E.H.

Pechan & Associates, Inc. Diesel tampers/rammers are a type of

construction equipment.

b. Revised PM 2.5 

## ratios in SCC table to correctly calculate PM 2



## . 5 

## diesel

emissions. This error was introduc ed with NMIM2005 and didn’t exist in

NMIM2004.

c. Revised gasoline parameter s using updates provi ded by the states and

E.H. Pechan & Associates, Inc. Ga soline parameters include Reid Vapor

Pressure (RVP), oxygenate c ontent and sulfur content.

The NMIM NEI NIF files are on the LADCO ftp site at:

ftp://ftp.airtoxics.org/in v2005/nonroad/NMIM /Base_L_ph2/2005/



# Revised NMIM2005 Input Data

Emission Factor Data

All States: Pechan revised the brake specific fuel consumption (BSFC) emission factor data to

include diesel tampers/rammers (2270002006). The revised NMIM file is saved as

revBSFC.EMF.

## 16 Population Data

For 26000.pop, replaced default file supplied with NMIM2005 with 26000_rev_NMIM05.pop that

contains revised construction data missing from 26000.pop external file provided with

NMIM2005. This Michigan construction data should have been added with the other LADCO

states modified construction data but was overlooked.



## SCC Data

The default SCC table of NCD20060201 is replaced by a version that contains corrections to the

PM25fac field that earlier NCDs contained (i.e. changed from 0.92 to 0.97 for diesel non-road

equipment) in NONROAD2004.



## Fuel Data

LADCO States: Pechan revised four tables (countyyear, countyyearmonth, datasource and

gasoline) in the National County Database (NCD) used by NMIM to incorporate new fuel data.

AIR revised gasoline characteristics per instructions from the states. Also, gasoline

characteristic revisions for 2005 provided by states were incorporated. Additional revisions

were incorporated into 2002 data for non-road Stage 2 controls. Depending on the year being

modeled, different versions of the revised tables are used. Also, the countynrfile, countyyear

and datasource tables were revised to reference the new activity, allocation, growth, population

and seasonality files described above. NCD tables with names ending in “def” are default

versions of the table. See table below for the appropriate versions of the tables for the selected

years.

Non-LADCO States: The countynrfile, countyyear and datasource tables were revised to

reference the new activity, allocation and seasonality files described above. See table below for

the appropriate versions of the tables for the selected years.



## Table 3-1 NMIM National County Database Tables for Specific Years and States

States

Years

1999 (WI only) 2002, 05, 07, 08, 09, 12 and 18

LADCO states countynrfile_NMIM05_rev,

countyyear_NMIM05_rev,

countyyearmonth_NMIM05_w

_05_12_18_rev,

datasource_NMIM05_rev,

gasoline_NMIM05_def

SCC_NCD20060201_rev

(used when NCD20060201 is

used) countynrfile_NMIM05_rev,

countyyear_NMIM05_rev ,

countyyearmonth_NMIM05_w_05_12_18_rev,

datasource_NMIM05_rev,

gasoline_NMIM05_w_05_12_18_rev

SCC_NCD20060201_rev (used when

NCD20060201 is used)

## 17 

# SECTION 4

ON-ROAD SOURCES

A mobile source of air pollution is a self-p ropelled or portable emi tter of air pollutants,

and mobile source emissions are those genera ted by the engines or motors that power

such sources. Most mobile sources, exce pt jet or turboprop ai rcraft, are powered by

internal combustion (IC) piston engines, and nearly all use liquid fuels.

Gaseous fuels, such as compressed natur al gas (CNG) or li quefied petroleum gas

(LPG), had only a very small fraction of the motor fuel market in Ohio in 2005. Solid

fuels have not been used by mobile sources in significant amounts since railroads

retired their coal-powered steam locomotives in the 1950s.

4.1 Categories of Mobile Sources

For inventory and planning pur poses, mobile sources ar e divided into two major

categories.

1. On-highway mobile sources (usually referred to as on-road ), e.g., motor

vehicles such as cars, vans, trucks, buses and motorcycles used for

transportation of goods and pa ssengers on roads and streets

2. Off-highway (usually referred to as non-road ) mobile sources including:

• Modes of powered transportation that do not use roads, such as aircraft,

trains, ships and boats, and motor vehicles used off-road.

• Self-propelled or portable motoriz ed machines or equipment not used for

transportation, ranging from constructi on equipment and farm tractors to

lawnmowers and hand-held power weed choppers.

Mobile Sources: All on-road mobile source s are self-propelled.

Non-road Mobile Sources: Some non-road mobile source s (e.g., farm tractors), are

self-propelled, but many non-road sources ar e not. A gasoline-powe red chain saw is a

familiar example of a non-self-pr opelled non-road mobile source.

Stationary Sources: Not all movable or portable emi ssion sources are mobile sources,

however. A small truck-portable cement or hot-mix asphalt plant, for example, may be

set up near a construction or road-building site . Such plants are classified as stationary

sources, not mobile sources for two reasons: (1) they may operate for weeks or months

at a single location, and (2) the trucks that move the plants do not supply power for

them.

## 18 NOTE: Not all Internal Combustion engines (IC) or turbine engines are mobile sources.

Fixed IC engines, such as those that pow er pipeline compressors or standby generators

in electricity plants and elsewhere, are al so classified as stationary sources.

4.1.1 Categories and Componen ts of Mobile Source Emissions

There are three categories of mobile source emissions:

• Exhaust or tailpipe emissions , which result from the combustion of fuel in the

source’s engine

• Evaporative emissions , which result from evaporation of fuel from the engine or

its fuel system

• Refueling emissions

Exhaust Emissions: Are the result of fuel combustion and occu r only when the engine

is running.

Evaporative emissions: Are Volatile Organic Compou nd (VOC) based only and are

continuously emitted from an engine’s fuel syst em, whether the engine is running or not.

Gasoline is a very volatile fuel, so total VOC emissions from gasoline powered vehicles

have a large evaporative component. Diesel and je t fuels are of very low volatility, so

evaporative emissions from diesel and turbi ne engines are a much smaller part of their

total VOC emissions. Evaporative emission s for CNG or LPG powered vehicles are

negligible because their fuel tanks and systems are of necessity, sealed.

Evaporative and exhaust VOC emissions can be calculated separately for most mobile

source categories. Evaporative emissions do not include VOC emissions that occur

during refueling.

Refueling Emissions: These emissions are the third category of mobile source

emissions. Refueling emissi ons are entirely VOC. Alth ough they result from the

evaporation of fuel, they ar e distinct from, and not dire ctly related to, evaporative

emissions as defined above.

Refueling emissions have two subcomponents:

• Displacement emissions . These occur when new fuel is transferred into a partly

filled tank--be it a service station stor age tank, a portable fuel container (gas

can), or a vehicle or engine’s fuel tank; displacing the air in the tank and forcing

that vapor-rich air out the inlet pipe or other vent. There are two stages of

displacement emissions:

o “ Stage I ” emissions occur when the underground storage tanks at a

service station are being refilled;

## 19 o “ Stage II ” emissions occur when a motor vehicle (or gas can) is being

refueled.

NOTE: These emissions are covered in , “Area Sources,” section 3.6.

• Spill emissions . These occur when drops of fuel drip or splash on the ground

during or after refueling and evaporate away.

4.2 Ohio On-Road Mobile Source Inventory

The inventory of on-road mobile source emissions was developed in conjunction with

the Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT), Lake Michigan Air Director’s

Consortium (LADCO), Unit ed States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), and

the Ohio EPA (OEPA). Estimates of the amounts of NOx and VO C are reported by

county in tons per day. Emissions are repor ted for a typical ozone season weekday in

the summer of 2005.

4.2.1 Emission Inventories Developed with MOBILE6 Model

MOBILE6 Overview:

MOBILE6 is a computer program that es timates hydrocarbon (HC), carbon monoxide

(CO), oxides of nitrogen (NO

x 

## ), exhaust particulate matter (which consists of several

components), tire wear particula te matter, brake wear particu late matter, sulfur dioxide

(SO 2 

## ), ammonia (NH 3 

## ), six hazardous air pollutant (HAP), and carbon dioxide (CO 2 

## )

emission factors for gasoline-f ueled and diesel highway moto r vehicles, and for certain

specialized vehicles such as natural-gas-fuel ed or electric vehicles that may replace

them. The program uses the calculation procedures presented in technical reports

posted on EPA's MOBILE6 Web page http ://www.epa.gov/otaq/models.htm.

MOBILE6 emission factor estimates depend on various conditions, such as ambient

temperatures, travel speeds, operating modes, fuel volatility, and mileage accrual rates.

Many of the variables affe cting vehicle emissions can be specified by the user.

MOBILE6 will estimate emission factors fo r any calendar year between 1952 and 2050,

inclusive. Vehicles from the 25 most re cent model years are considered to be in

operation in each calendar year.

4.2.2 MOBILE6 Defaults:

MOBILE6 includes default values for a wide range of conditions that affect emissions.

These defaults are designed to represent “ national average” input data values. Users

who desire a more precise estimate of local emissions can substitute information that

more specifically reflects local conditions. Use of local input data will be particularly

common when the local emission inventor y is to be constructed from separate

## 20 estimates of roadways, geographic areas, or ti mes of day, in which fleet or traffic

conditions vary considerably.

A list of MOBILE6 input parameters is provi ded below. Most of these inputs are optional

because the model will supply default values unless alternate data are provided.

4.2.3 MOBILE6 Input Parameters

• Calendar year

• Month (January, July)

• Hourly Temperature

• Altitude (high, low)

• Weekend/weekday

• Fuel characteristics (Reid va por pressure, sulfur content,

oxygenate content, etc.)

• Humidity and solar load

• Registration (age) distribution by vehicle class

• Annual mileage accumulation by vehicle class

• Diesel sales fractions by vehicle class and model year

• Average speed distribution by hour and roadway

• Distribution of vehicle miles traveled by roadway type

• Engine starts per day by vehi cle class and distribution by hour

• Engine start soak time distribution by hour

• Trip end distribution by hour

• Average trip length distribution

• Hot soak duration

• Distribution of vehicle miles traveled by vehicle class

• Full, partial, and multiple diurnal distribution by hour

• Inspection and maintenance ( I/M) program description

• Anti-tampering inspection program description

• Stage II refueling emissions inspection program description

• Natural gas vehicle fractions

• HC species output

• Particle size cutoff

• Emissions factors for PM and HAP

• 

## Output format specific ations and selections

4.2.4 MOBILE6 References

The following publications prov ide much of the guidance fo r the preparation of the onhighway inventory.

EPA-450/4-81-026d (Revised), now EPA/450-R-92-009, Procedures for Emission

Inventory Preparation , Volume IV: Mobile Sources , December 1992. Hereafter,

“Procedures Vol. IV”. The 1992 vers ion is still the definitive document on

## 21 inventories. If a previous edition is referr ed to, the fact will be not ed as, for example,

“the 1989 Procedures Vol. IV” or “Volume IV, 1989 edition”.

EPA420-R-03-010, User’s Guide to MOBILE6.1 and MOBILE6.2: Mobile Source

Emission Factor Model

, August 2003. This is the User’s Guide for the official

MOBILE6.2.03 on-highway mobile source em ission factor model and will usually be

referred to as the M6.2 (or simply M6) User’s Guide (UG). The M6 model in its

various versions was developed and publis hed by Assessment & Modeling Division

(AMD) of the National Vehicle & Fuels Em issions Laboratory (NVFEL) in Ann Arbor,

Michigan. The NVFEL is part of USE PA Office of Transportation & Air Quality

(OTAQ), formerly the Office of Mobile Sources (OMS).

Technical Guidance on the Use of MOBILE6 for Emission Inventory

Preparation , August 2004. Hereafter, the M6 “Technical Guidance [Document]” or

“TGD”. The TGD is the pr imary source of guidance on M6 inputs and an invaluable

adjunct to the M6 User’s Guide.

USEPA document “Frequently Asked Questions on MOBILE6” , 16 January

2002. Hereafter, [M6] “FAQ”. This document was published along with the M6

TGD.

USEPA memo, “Policy Guidance on the Use of MOBILE6 for SIP Development

and Transportation Conformity” , dated 18 January 2002, from John Seitz,

Director of OAQPS, and Mar go Oge, Director of OTAQ, to Regional Air Division

Directors.

4.3 Ohio’s Alternate Data for MOBILE6

Alternative data is state-specif ic data that is used in the M obile6 runs. Using local data

is preferred to using the default data in Mobi le6. Efforts are made to collect as much

local data as possible.

4.3.1 Vehicle Registra tion Distribution by Age

Overview:

The vehicle age distribution determines the fr action of vehicles operating within each

emissions control requirement standard and the deterioration of the emission control

technology.

Emission rates vary widely between new and older vehicles. Thus, even small changes

in fleet age, particularly for older vehicles , may result in large changes in emission

totals.

## 22 The MOBILE6 model requires esti mates of a distribution of r egistered vehicles by age

and vehicle category for current and future years. MOBILE6 default values were

developed using national level vehicle registration data by age and class for July 1,

1996. EPA developed a methodology to convert t he July 1, 1996 registration profile into

a general registration distribut ion by age and by vehicle ca tegory for some 6 composite

(gasoline and diesel) vehicle types plus motorcycles. To project future changes, EPA

evaluated general sales growth and vehicle scrappage trends for the total light-duty

vehicle in-use fleet and the total heavy-dut y vehicle in-use fleet, and made minor

adjustments, where possible, to reflect some of the differences between vehicle

categories.

Description: The MOBILE6 model requires estima tes of a distribution of registered

vehicles by age and vehicle category for curr ent and future years. OEPA chose to use

local vehicle registration data provided by the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV)

which was sent to the Lake Michigan Air Dir ectors Consortium (LADCO) to develop

these inputs. LADCO then contracted with a subcontractor to breakout the age

distribution data from the Vehicle Identification Num bers (VIN).

Note: It was learned during the course of this inventory that there were some

discrepancies in the age distribution data. But it was too large of a project to reevaluate

the data prior to this invent ory. This will be corrected in the next inventory (2008).

Method Applicability: This approach is most applic able in areas where there are

significant differences in the local vehicle fleet age distribution rela tive to the national

average.

Data Sources and Procedures: This approach involves using local vehicle registration

data. This is typically available at the county level, but may also be applied using

statewide data from the stat e motor vehicle registration office. The fleet age should be

representative of the vehicle fleet over the small urban or rural area under question.

Advantages:

• Uses locally specific registration data, which is likely more representative of the

local area than t he national default.

• Requires minimal additional resources, par ticularly if data is readily available at

the county or local level fr om the State departm ent of motor vehicle registration.

• Recommended by EPA and generally is encouraged as a preferred approach

over the national default approach.

## 23 4.3.2 Daily Vehicle Miles Traveled (DVMT)

Overview:

In coordination with Ohio Metropolitan Pl anning Organizations (MPOs), the Ohio

Department of Transportation (ODOT) provi ded Daily Vehicle Miles Traveled (DVMT)

data and travel demand model (TDM) data. TDM data will be covered in another

section. Because TDM results are used by t he state and MPOs to fo recast traffic for a

variety of reasons, undergo rigorous calibrati on and validation checks, and are sensitive

to roadway capacity/travel time improvement s, the TDMs are considered the best tool

for emissions forecasting. Therefore, the DVMT data discussed in this section is not

used directly for all areas of Ohio. In countie s where it is not used directly it is used for

making rough emissions estimates where model s do not exist or where time prohibits

the use of TDMs. DVMT is a simple mechan ism to measure how much traffic is flowing

along a roadway during an average 24 hour peri od. This simple formula multiplies

Average Annual Daily Traffic (AADT) by the length of the roadway. For example; if a

roadway is 2 miles in length and the AADT is 4000 vehicles per day the DVMT would be

computed by multiplying 2* 4,000 =8,000 or 8,000 DVMT.

County-By-County DVMT is computed usin g the State of Ohio, Department of

Transportation’s Roadway Information F iles and the annual Highway Performance

Monitoring System (HPMS) Summary Reports . DVMT’s are computed for all of the

Federal Functional Class (FC) categories within each of Ohio’s 88 counties.

The AADT and Roadway length information prov ides a very accurate estimate of

statewide total DVMT for The State Highway S ystem (Interstate, US and State Routes).

County total DVMT are consistent and cons idered a good source of county level DVMT

for countywide emissions estimates. For roadways that are not part of the State

Highway System, various representative count s were used, such as: railroad crossing

counts, HPMS Sample Section Counts, etc. All traffic count data that was not collected

during the current year has had statewide growth factors applied to account for

systematic growth.

Given the previously mentioned methodologies, the DVMT data is more accurate on

roads functionally classified as collector or above.

Table 4-1 Federal Func tional Class Categories:

01 - Rural Interstate

02 - Rural Principal Arterial

06 - Rural Minor Arterial

07 - Rural Major Collector

08 - Rural Minor Collector

09 - Rural Local 11 - Urban Interstate

12 - Urban Freeway & Expressway

14 - Urban Principal Arterial

16 - Urban Minor Arterial

17 - Urban Collector

19 - Urban Local

## 24 Table 4-2 DVMT County Summary:

For PDF web based tables of 2005 DVMT by county see:

http://www.dot.state.oh.us /techservsite/availpro/Road_%20Infor/KDVMT/vmt2005.pdf

Disclaimer by ODOT:

The above PDF web based tables contain the State of Ohio's adjusted county DVMT's

and road mileage for the years 1990 - 2005. Please be aware that the numbers are

estimates only. The factoring process used annual, estimated, and statewide ADT

(Average Daily Traffic) growth factors, deriv ed from the output of a limited number of

traffic counting stations around the state. Although the growth factors are available by

functional class, they are more reliable for major roads such as interstates or

expressways, which are relatively well-sampl ed, than for local roads or collectors. The

numbers also do no allow for periodic, large- scale functional reclassification actions

## 25 which reassign selected roads or road segm ents from one functional class to another.

The Ohio Department of Transportation t herefore does not warr ant the accuracy,

completeness, or reliability of these estimates for your research. We also do not

assume responsibility for any incorrectness that may occur.

4.3.3 VMT From Travel Demand Models (TDM)

Overview:

Travel demand forecast modeling is perform ed by the Ohio Metropolitan Planning

Organizations (MPOs) and ODOT for a multit ude of purposes including the preparation

of regional emissions estimate s. The ODOT Office of Te chnical Services’ Modeling &

Forecasting Section recommends that Ohio ’s TDMs and ODOT’s conformity analysis

methods be used to establish the roadway mob ile source portion of Ohio’s SIP budget

to assure consistent methods are used for transportation conformity analysis and

budgets. Therefore, ODOT provided both MPO regional TDM runs and statewide TDM

runs with associated data to OEPA and LADC O. The ODOT provided model run data

for years 2002, 2005, 2009, 2012, and 2018.

Data provided included loaded networks in both CSV format and GIS shape files, trip

end summaries, zone boundary GIS shape files, intra-zonal trip VMT estimates, and

VMT summaries for each of the loaded networ ks. Additional post processing data was

provided including but not lim ited to metadata describing the loaded networks, Hourly

distribution by functional cla ss, speed profiles, day of week / weekend / monthly car and

truck traffic profiles, 2009 & 2018 VMT RPO data sets, state wide VMT growth rates for

local traffic, and a 2005 VMT summary comparison spreadsheet. It should be noted

that among other things, the loaded TDM Netw orks contain distance and daily volumes

from which VMT is computed.

Network volumes are post processed to esti mate VMT by hour of day. The hourly

volumes and capacity, posted speed limi t, and type of roadway for each roadway

segment are then used to estimate aver age hourly speeds needed for MOBILE6 based

emissions estimates. Modelin g by segment by hour of day in this way makes emissions

estimates more sensitive to the effects of roadway improvements. This allows

transportation planners to evaluate the relati ve emissions affect of improvements to

individual roadways as well as packages of improvements and the entire set of planned

roadway improvement projec ts air quality impacts of construction programs.

## 26 4.3.4 Speed Di stribution Profiles

Overview:

ODOT provided speed distribution profiles to LADCO. A couple of different sets of

speed distribution profiles were provided to OEPA and LADCO for their use, a table of

space mean speeds by functional class for use with DVMTs and link group speed

curves for post processing travel demand model traffic forecasts. Both sets of speed

profiles are based on the same speed study c onducted by ODOT. The speed study is

documented in “Statewide Travel Time Study, May 2001 by Greg Giaimo, Ohio

Department of Transportation ”. When OEPA asked for s peeds for use with MOBILE6

for development of CERR, ODOT provided a set of speeds based on that statewide

travel time study. Those speeds are doc umented in a technical memorandum titled

“Estimation of Average Speed by Functional Class for MOBILE6 Runs ” dated

5/27/2004. Readers should refer to those docum ents for the details. Here the contents

of the technical memo, Estimated Average Speed by Functional Class, are summarized.

Space Mean Speeds by Functional Class for U se with County Level DVMT, HPMS:

The memo states that the s peeds which the Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT)

had been using prior to that date, 2004, fo r air quality analysis estimates based on

County DVMT summaries, were developed by a former ODOT employee for addressing

the one (1) hour standards conformity ru les established due to 1990 emissions

exceedances. No documentation was found in ODOT’s files on the origin of these

average speed values or how they were esti mated. In addition, EPA has requirements

for using latest planning assumptions for ai r quality conformity analyses. Therefore,

ODOT believed that it was in the state’s best interest to use the mo st recent available

data to provide a new set of estimated av erage speeds consistent with those used for

urban area travel demand models which were under development at that time. The

memo contains comparisons of 2002 speed dat a obtained from traf fic count equipment,

automatic traffic recorders (ATRs) which co llect data continuously throughout the year.

It also contains comparisons of the new speeds with those used to address the one

hour standard Gebhart’s. The graphs shown in figure 1, taken from the memo, illustrate

the comparisons. The first graph compares time mean speeds from the ATRs with

space mean speeds from ODOTs travel time study done in 2001and with the speeds

used for addressing the one hour standard.

## 27 Figure 1 - Speed Comparison Graphs

Speeds Comparison

0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0 70.0 80.0

FC01 FC 0

6

F C0 8

F C1 1 FC1 4 FC1 7



## Functional ClassSpeed Average Speed

1990 Analysis

Speeds

2001 Speed Study



# Speeds Comparison

0 20 40 60 80 100

FC 0

1 FC 06

F C08

F C11 FC14 FC 1

7

R

AMPS



## Functional ClassSpeed 

## Average Speed

Min. Avg Speed

Max. Avg. Speed

Gebhardt's Speeds

Spd Study Est

Speeds

Spd Study Greg Est



## The following caution statem ent was taken from the Estimation of Average Speed by

Functional Class memo.

CAUTION 

# : It should be noted that speeds on facilities falling in any one of the federal

functional classifications vary greatly bet ween roadways, between hour of the day, and

day of the week. So these provide only very rough estimates of speed and should be

used with caution. In addition, it is expec ted that these average statewide speeds are

higher than the average speeds in t he non-attainment areas because the non-

## 28 attainment counties tend to be more popul ated and more congested. The document

“Highway Vehicle Speed Es timation Procedures For Use in Emission Inventories”,

September 1991 by Earl Ruiter of Cambridge Systematics Inc. is referenced by EPA’s

documented procedures for emission inventor y preparation. This document suggests

post processing travel demand model traffic assignment results to estimate average

speeds.

Final space mean speeds that ODOT provi ded are summarized in the Table 1 below:

Table 4-3 Speed by Federal Functional Class

Functional Class 1990 Analysis 2001 Speed Study

Speeds Speeds

FC01 57.3 64.0

FC02 45.3 53.0

FC06 39.9 53.0

FC07 35.1 43.1

FC08 30.5 43.1

FC09 28.0 43.1

FC11 46.3 61.6

FC12 43.3 61.6

FC14 18.9 29.3

FC16 19.6 29.3

FC17 19.6 29.2

FC19 19.6 23.8

It was decided by mutual agreement among individuals within the ODOT Office of

Technical Services that these new s pace mean speed based average speed estimates

were reproducible and defensib le since they are well docu mented and should therefore

be the speeds used with HPMS** VMT if any year 2002 emissions budget work is done

using only the county level VMT summaries discussed in section 5.3.2 Daily Vehicle

Miles Traveled (DVMT).

** Note that HPMS VMT is a statewide VMT estimate and the county level DVMT

summaries are consistent with the HPMS VMT so the county level DVMT summaries

are loosely referred to as HPMS VMTs even though in fact they are not.

4.3.5 Link Group Speed Curves:

The ODOT Modeling & Forecasting Section recommends that Ohio’s travel demand

forecasting models and ODOT’s conformity anal ysis methods be used to establish the

roadway mobile source portion of Ohio’s SIP budget for reasons already mentioned in

5.3.2 and to assure consistent methods are used for transportation conformity

demonstration analyses and budget s. Therefore, ODOT pr ovided travel demand model

runs and the speed curves by link group that ODOT uses for the speed estimates within

## 29 the post processing of travel demand model runs for estimating regional emissions.

Table 2 shows these link group curves.

Table 4-4 Link Group Cod es & Associated BPR Curves

Link

Group Facility

Type Free Flow

Speed Areatype a b

1 Freeway 75 Any 0.39 6.3

2 Freeway 70 Any 0.32 7.0

3 Freeway 65 Any 0.25 9.0

4 Freeway 60 Any 0.18 8.5

5 Freeway 55 Any 0.10 10.0

6 Multi-Lane 60 Rural 0.09 6.0

7 Multi-Lane 55 Rural 0.08 6.0

8 Multi-Lane 50 Rural 0.07 6.0

9 Multi-Lane 45 Rural 0.07 6.0

10 2 Lane Any Rural 0.34 4.0

10 Urban

Street 50 Suburban 0.34 4.0

11 Urban

Street 50 Urban 0.74 5.0

12 Urban

Street 50 CBD 1.16 6.0

13 Urban

Street 40 Suburban 0.38 5.0

14 Urban

Street 40 Urban 0.70 5.0

15 Urban

Street 40 CBD 1.00 5.0

16 Urban

Street 35 Suburban 0.96 5.0

17 Urban

Street 35 Urban 1.00 5.0

18 Urban

Street 35 CBD 1.40 5.0

19 Urban

Street 30 Suburban 1.11 5.0

20 Urban

Street 30 Urban 1.20 5.0

21 Urban

Street 30 CBD 1.50 5.0

Note: a and b are the BPR curv e parameters for the equation

T = T 0 

## {1 + a * (V/C)^b]

## 30 More complete details about emissions mode ling process employed by ODOT may be

found in ODOT documentations. The docum ent titled “Congestion Management & Air

Quality Analysis (CMAQ) Program Docu mentation” dated December 2005 may be

obtained from the ODOT web site at www.dot.state.oh.us/urban/data/cmaq.doc

(Microsoft Word document)

4.4 Mobile6 Inputs:

The following table contains the inputs s upplied to LADCO to process our mobile

inventory.

4.4.1 Ohio’s 2005 MOBILE6 Inputs

The following tables are the result of a joint meeting between Ohio EPA, ODOT, and

MPOs from around the state. At that meeting Mobile6 inputs were discussed and

efforts were made to verify the sources of data inputs for Moble6. Dialogue has

continued between the parties.

For historical reference:

>>> Dave Moore <Dave.Moore1@dot.s tate.oh.us> 4/10/2006 2:13 PM >>>

All,

An air quality coordination meeting has been scheduled for April 27, 2006 at 10:00 AM at ODOT Central

Office conference room GA. The primary purpose of this meeting is to discuss development of 2002

mobile source inventories for use in developi ng the Ohio 2007 8-Hour Ozone SIP Attainment

Demonstrations. See meeting agen da below. OEPA is working to ward a June 15, 2006 schedule for

submitting the 2002 invent ories to US EPA.

A key component of the meeting will be to review a nd confirm the MOBILE6.2 i nput parameters, by Ohio

a/q area, for use in developing the 2002 mobile inve ntories. See draft templa te below. The Ohio MPO

travel demand models will be used to generate t he 2002 VMT inputs to MOBILE. Thanks, DM

DM

## 31 IMPORTANT NOTICE: The following tables are not to be used for inventory purposes

as the data is subject to change. For the cu rrent input table, contact Ohio EPA, Division

of Air Pollution Control.

Table 4-5 Mobile Inputs



# Cleveland-Akron 2005 Ozone M6.2 Inputs

Includes the following counties:

Ashtabula, Cuyahoga, Geauga, Lake, Lorain, Medina, Portage, Summit



## State Programs

Input

Stage II Refueling 93/3/86/86

Anti-tampering Programs 96/78/50/22222/21111111/1/12/098./12111112

I/M Programs Yes

Exclude Ashtabula County - No I/M program

Program 1 2004 2050 2 T/O OBD I/M

Model Years 1 1996 2050

Vehicles 1 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 1 30.0

Compliance 1 98.0

Waiver Rates 1 1.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 1 25

Grace Period 1 4

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 2 2004 2050 2 T/O EVAP OBD & GC

Model Years 2 1996 2050

Vehicles 2 22222 11111111 1

Stringency

Compliance 2 98.0

Waiver Rates 2 1.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 2 25

Grace Period 2 4

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 3 2001 2003 2 T/O ASM 2525 PHASE-IN

## 32 Model Years 3 1996 2003

Vehicles 3 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 3 30.0

Compliance 3 98.0

Waiver Rates 3 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 3 25

Grace Period 3 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 4 2001 2050 2 T/O ASM 2525 PHASE-IN

Model Years 4 1975 1995

Vehicles 4 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 4 30.0

Compliance 4 98.0

Waiver Rates 4 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 4 25

Grace Period 4 4

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 5 1998 2000 2 T/O LOADED/IDLE

Model Years 5 1975 2000

Vehicles 5 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 5 30.0

Compliance 5 98.0

Waiver Rates 5 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 5 25

Grace Period 5 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 6 1996 1997 2 T/O IM240

Model Years 6 1975 1997

Vehicles 6 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 6 30.0

Compliance 6 98.0

Waiver Rates 6 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints 6 CUTPOINT.D

Exemption Age 6 25

Grace Period 6 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

## 33 Program 7 1996 2050 2 T/O GC

Model Years 7 1975 1995

Vehicles 7 22222 21111111 1

Stringency

Compliance 7 98.0

Waiver Rates 7 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 7 25

Grace Period 7 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file



## Fuel Commands

Fuel Program 1

Oxygenated Fuels 0.00 0.42 0.00 0.036 2

Fuel RVP 9



## Alternative Emission Regulati ons and Control Measures

Rebuild Effects 0.1



## External Conditions Commands

Calendar Year 2005

Evaluation Month 7

Min/Max Temperature National Climatic Data Center



## Vehicle Fleet Characteristic Commands

Registration Distribution Variable

## 34 

# Cincinnati-Dayton-Springfield 2005 Ozone M6.2 Inputs

Includes the following counties:

Ohio : Butler, Clark, Clermont, Clinton, Greene, Hamilton, Miami, Montgomery,

Warren

Indiana : Lawrenceburg Twp., Dearborn County

Kentucky : Boone, Campbell and Kenton counties



## State Programs

Input

Note: Indiana and Kentucky inputs may not coincide with Ohio inputs

Stage II Refueling 93/3/86/86

Anti-tampering Programs 96/78/05/22222/21111111/1/12/098./12111112

I/M Programs Yes

Excludes Clinton Co. and Miami Co., OH, Dearborn County, IN - No I/M program

Note: I/M inputs for Kentucky counties are not included

Program 1 2004 2050 2 T/O OBD I/M

Model Years 1 1996 2050

Vehicles 1 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 1 30.0

Compliance 1 98.0

Waiver Rates 1 1.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 1 25

Grace Period 1 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 2 2004 2050 2 T/O EVAP OBD & GC

Model Years 2 1996 2050

Vehicles 2 22222 11111111 1

Stringency

Compliance 2 98.0

Waiver Rates 2 1.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 2 25

Grace Period 2 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 3 2001 2003 2 T/O ASM 2525 PHASE-IN

Model Years 3 1996 2003

Vehicles 3 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 3 30.0

Compliance 3 98.0

## 35 Waiver Rates 3 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 3 25

Grace Period 3 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 4 2001 2050 2 T/O ASM 2525 PHASE-IN

Model Years 4 1975 1995

Vehicles 4 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 4 30.0

Compliance 4 98.0

Waiver Rates 4 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 4 25

Grace Period 4 4

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 5 1998 2000 2 T/O LOADED/IDLE

Model Years 5 1975 2000

Vehicles 5 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 5 30.0

Compliance 5 98.0

Waiver Rates 5 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 5 25

Grace Period 5 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 6 1996 1997 2 T/O IM240

Model Years 6 1975 1997

Vehicles 6 22222 21111111 1

Stringency 6 30.0

Compliance 6 98.0

Waiver Rates 6 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints 6 CUTPOINT.D

Exemption Age 6 25

Grace Period 6 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file

Program 7 1996 2050 2 T/O GC

Model Years 7 1975 1995

Vehicles 7 22222 21111111 1

## 36 Stringency

Compliance 7 98.0

Waiver Rates 7 3.0 1.0

Cutpoints

Exemption Age 7 25

Grace Period 7 2

NO TTC Credits

Effectiveness

DESC file



## Fuel Commands

Fuel Program 1

Oxygenated Fuels 0.00 0.42 0.00 0.036 2

Fuel RVP 9



## Alternative Emission Regulati ons and Control Measures

Rebuild Effects 0.1



## External Conditions Commands

Calendar Year 2005

Evaluation Month 7

Min/Max Temperature National Climatic Data Center



## Vehicle Fleet Characteristic Commands

Registration Distribution Variable

## 37 

# Other Areas ( excluding NOACA/AMATS 

# and OKI/MVRPC 

# ) Ozone M6.2

Inputs

Includes the following counties:

Ohio : Belmont, Columbiana, Delaware, Fairfield, Franklin, Jefferson, Knox, Licking,

Lucas,Madison, Mahoning, Pickaway, Trumball, Wood



## Fuel Commands

Input

Fuel Program 1

Oxygenated Fuels 0.00 0.42 0.00 0.036 2

Fuel RVP 9



## Alternative Emission Regulati ons and Control Measures

Rebuild Effects 0.1 (0.30 for 2018)



## External Conditions Commands

Calendar Year All

Evaluation Month 7

Min/Max Temperature National Climatic Data Center



## Vehicle Fleet Characteristic Commands

Registration

Distribution Variable



## 4.5 Ohio’s Mobile Emission Data Processed by LADCO (Lake Michigan Air

Director’s Consortium):

2005 TDM and Mobile6 input data were provided to LADCO for processing. The data

was processed by LADCO with T3 to prepare it as an input into the ConCEPT model.

T3 and ConCEPT are described as follows.

## 38 4.5.1 T3--Development of Link-Level Mobile Source Emission Inventories:

Highly resolved emission inventories for on- road mobile sources are needed for air

quality modeling to develop the necessary technical support for new State

Implementation Plans (SIPs) fo r regional haze, fine particles , and ozone. Emissions for

on-road motor vehicles are estimated using vehi cle miles traveled, tr ip starts and ends,

speed, and other activity data developed by State Agencies and Metropolitan Planning

Organizations (MPOs) using transportati on demand models (TDMs), and emission

factors from EPA's MOBILE6 model. To s upport this modeling in the upper Midwest,

ENVIRON, working with LADCO, State DOTs, and local MPOs, has developed a

software tool (the TDM Transformation Tool, or "T3") that takes TDM output from

approximately twenty transportation networ ks using a variety of models, applies

appropriate data transformations , and outputs link- and county-le vel activity data in a

uniform format for input to the CONCEPT emissions processing model (a new

emissions processing model also developed wit h funding from LADCO). In a parallel

effort, analyses of extensive automatic tra ffic recorder (ATR) dat a collected by State

DOTs were conducted to develop temporal profiles (hour of day , day of week, and

month of year) of vehicle counts and vehicl e mix by roadway type for developing the

detailed on-road emissi on inventories.

T3 provides a conduit from the projections of traffic demand model ers regarding vehicle

types, road networks, and vehicle activity to the activity data required by emissions

modelers. The primary goals of T3 are to provide an easy mechanism for incorporating

TDM model outputs in as "raw" a format as possible, while simult aneously providing a

great degree of flexibility in representing t he TDM projections in terms acceptable to

most air quality models. These goal s have been achieved through the use of a

dimensional transformation approach, w here the dimensions of the various

transformations are user-defined - hence the name of the tool.

By Stella Shepard, Alison K. Pollack, John Haasbeek, ENVIRON International

Corporation, 101 Rowland Way, Su ite 220, Novato, CA. 94945

& Mark Janssen, Lake Michigan Air Directors Consortium (LADCO ), 2250 E. Devon

Avenue # 250, Des Plaines, IL 60018, janssen@ladco.org

4.5.2 ConCEPT--Consolidated Community Emissions Processing Tool an OpenSource Tool for the Emi ssions Modeling Community:

The new CONCEPT (CONsolidated Communi ty Emissions Processing Tool)

Emissions Processor is now available for use by the emissions modeling community.

Developed as joint project between Alpine Geophysics, LLC and ENVIRON Corporation,

with Midwest RPO and joint RPO funding, the CONCEPT model combines the best

attributes of current emissions modeling syste ms into an open source model highlighting

the following features:

• Open Source. Writt en primarily in PostgreSQL, th e software required for running

## 39 CONCEPT is in the public dom ain. The model itself is GNU Public License (GPL)

compliant and users are encouraged to make additions and enhancements to the

modeling system.

• Transparent. The database structur e of the model makes the system easy to

understand, and the modeling codes themselv es are extremely well documented to

encourage user participation in the customizing the system for specific modeling

requirements.

• Quality Control. The CONCEPT model structure an d implementation allows for

multiple levels of QA analysis during every step of the emissions calculation process.

Using the database structures, an emissions modeler can easily trace a process or

facility and review the calculat ion procedures and assumptions for any emissions value.

The CONCEPT model includes modules for the major emissions source

categories: area source, point source, on-ro ad motor vehicles, non-road motor vehicles

and biogenic emissions, as well as a num ber of supporting modules, including spatial

allocation factor development, speciation pr ofile development, growth and control for

point and area sources, and CEM point sour ce emissions handling. The emissions

modeling community has alr eady begun development of addi tional CONCEPT support

modules including CEM preproce ssing software, graphical QA tools, and an interface to

the traffic demand models for on-road mo tor vehicle emissions estimation.

By Cyndi Loomis, James G. Wilkinson, Alpine Geophysics, LLC, & John Haasbeek,

Alison Pollack, ENVIRON Corporation. & Mark Janssen, Lake Michigan Air Directors

Consortium (LADCO), 2250 E. Devon Av enue # 250, Des Plaines, IL 60018,

janssen@ladco.org

4.5.3 LADCO Ohio Data Outputs for 2005:

The following LADCO outputs and documents can be found at:

www.ladco.org/tech/e mis/net05/index.html

Table 4-6 LADCO Data Output

Sta

te Network T3

Descripti

on DOC M6

Inpu

ts VM

T vs

HP

MS

Exc

el Average

Day

VMT

(this

should

match

conformi

ty

inventory

) Co

unt

y

Em

issi

on

s

Re

por

t All

Pollut

ants

After

Speci

ation Dropped

VMT M6

Run

Summ

ary Pollut

ant

T otals

(Short

) Raw

Summ

ary (pol,ve

h,

etype) Hourly

Tempo

ral

Summ

ary Hourly

Veh

Mix

Summ

ary Hourly

Speed

Summ

ary (with

volum

e/

capaci

ty)

OH AKRON AKRON OH OH AKRON 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

## 40 OH CANTON CANTON OH OH CANTON 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH CINCI CINCI OH OH CINCI 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH CLEVE CLEVE OH OH CLEVE 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH COLUMB

US COLUMB

US OH OH COLUMB

US 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH SPRING

FLD SPRING

FLD OH OH SPRING

FLD 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH TOLEDO TOLEDO OH OH TOLEDO 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH YNGSTO

WN YNGSTO

WN OH OH YNGSTO

WN 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

OH STATEW

D STATEW

D OH OH STATEW

D 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1



## Additional Documents on LADCO Web Page:

“Comparison to EPA's Default Model NMIM”

“How we Build the 2005 Vmt/Networks”

“Spreadsheet/Graphics on Vehicle Mix”

“Background on the T3 Tool “

4.6 MPO Contact Table

Table 4-7 County Summary Ta ble of MPOs by County

FIPS County Model Network MPO Contact Person

39001 Adams Statewide

39003 Allen Statewide Lima Allen County Regional

Planning Commission Tom Mazur

39005 Ashland Statewide

39007 Ashtabula Statewide

39009 Athens Statewide

39011 Auglaize Statewide

39013 Belmont Statewide Bel-O-Mar Regional Council

and Interstate Planning

Commission Rakesh Sharma

39015 Brown Statewide

39017 Butler Cincinnat/Dayton Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana

Regional Council of

Governments Andy Reser

39019 Carroll Statewide

39021 Champaign Statewide

39023 Clark Springfield Coordinating Committee of

the Clark County-Springfield Eric Ottoson

## 41 Transportation Study

39025 Clermont Cincinnat/Dayton Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana

Regional Council of

Governments Andy Reser

39027 Clinton Statewide

39029 Columbiana Statewide

39031 Coshocton Statewide

39033 Crawford Statewide

39035 Cuyahoga Cleveland Northeast Ohio Areawide

Coordinating Agency Bill Davis

39037 Darke Statewide

39039 Defiance Statewide

39041 Delaware Columbus Mid-Ohio Regional Planning

Commission Nick Gill

39043 Erie Statewide

39045 Fairfield Statewide

39047 Fayette Statewide

39049 Franklin Columbus Mid-Ohio Regional Planning

Commission Nick Gill

39051 Fulton Statewide

39053 Gallia Statewide

39055 Geauga Cleveland Northeast Ohio Areawide

Coordinating Agency Bill Davis

39057 Greene Cincinnat/Dayton Miami Valley Regional

Planning Commission Ana Ramirez

39059 Guernsey Statewide

39061 Hamilton Cincinnat/Dayton Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana

Regional Council of

Governments Andy Reser

39063 Hancock Statewide

39065 Hardin Statewide

39067 Harrison Statewide

39069 Henry Statewide

39071 Highland Statewide

39073 Hocking Statewide

39075 Holmes Statewide

39077 Huron Statewide

39079 Jackson Statewide

39081 Jefferson Statewide Brooke-Hancock-Jefferson

Transportation Study Policy

Committee Mike Proprocki

39083 Knox Statewide

39085 Lake Cleveland Northeast Ohio Areawide

Coordinating Agency Bill Davis

39087 Lawrence Statewide KYOVA Interstate Planning

Commission

39089 Licking Columbus Licking County Area

Transportation Study Matthew Hill

39091 Logan Statewide

39093 Lorain Cleveland Northeast Ohio Areawide Bill Davis

## 42 Coordinating Agency

39095 Lucas Toledo Toledo Metropolitan Area

Council of Governments Sujatha Mohanakrishnan

39097 Madison Statewide

39099 Mahoning Youngstown Eastgate Regional Council

of Governments R.P. Samulka

39101 Marion Statewide

39103 Medina Cleveland Northeast Ohio Areawide

Coordinating Agency Bill Davis

39105 Meigs Statewide

39107 Mercer Statewide

39109 Miami Cincinnat/Dayton Miami Valley Regional

Planning Commission Ana Ramirez

39111 Monroe Statewide

39113 Montgomery Cincinnat/Dayton Miami Valley Regional

Planning Commission Ana Ramirez

39115 Morgan Statewide

39117 Morrow Statewide

39119 Muskingum Statewide

39121 Noble Statewide

39123 Ottawa Statewide

39125 Paulding Statewide

39127 Perry Statewide

39129 Pickaway Statewide

39131 Pike Statewide

39133 Portage Akron Akron Metropolitan Area

Transportation Study Jason Segedy

39135 Preble Statewide

39137 Putnam Statewide

39139 Richland Statewide Richland County Regional

Planning Commission John Adams

39141 Ross Statewide

39143 Sandusky Statewide

39145 Scioto Statewide

39147 Seneca Statewide

39149 Shelby Statewide

39151 Stark Canton Stark County Regional

Planning Commission Dan Slicker

39153 Summit Akron Akron Metropolitan Area

Transportation Study Jason Segedy

39155 Trumbull Youngstown (partial

county model

coverage) Eastgate Regional Council

of Governments R.P. Samulka

39157 Tuscarawas Statewide

39159 Union Statewide

39161 Van Wert Statewide

39163 Vinton Statewide

39165 Warren Cincinnat/Dayton Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana

Regional Council of

Governments Andy Reser, OKI

+

## 43 + Miami Valley Regional

Planning Commission Ana Ramirez, MVRPC

39167 Washington Statewide Wood-Washington-Wirt

Interstate Planning

Commission

39169 Wayne Statewide

39171 Williams Statewide

39173 Wood Toledo Toledo Metropolitan Area

Council of Governments Sujatha Mohanakrishnan

39175 Wyandot Statewide



## NOTE: Complete MPO information can be found at,

www.dot.state.oh.us/urban/mpomap.htm and at

www.dot.state.oh.us/urban/mpolist.htm#Cleveland

.



# SECTION 5

MARINE, AIRCRAFT and RAIL (MAR) SOURCES

MAR sources are non-road sour ces which are significant enoug h in terms of emissions

to be considered separately from the rest of the non-road sources. The MAR inventory

consists of commercial marines, aircraft and locomotive sources. The marine and

locomotive inventory is generated by Environ 1 

## under contract with LADCO and the

aircraft inventory is generated by Ohio EPA.

5.1 Marine Vessel Sources

The approach to commercial marine emi ssion estimates needed to be flexible because

the activity data was available in many fo rmats. Emission esti mates were determined

either by multiplying engine power, load factor, hours per ye ar of operation, or on the

basis of the number of gall ons of fuel consumed.

Emissions were determined for ten subclasses of vessel types: Deep draft vessels

(DDV) at port, DDV mid-late, push boats (rivers /lakes), tugs, ferries, other special

(excursion) vessels, support vessels, dredges, commercial fishing, and military vessels

(Coast Guard). These were linked to various Ohio lakes and rivers.

Because of the large variety of methodologie s employed, inventory tables for the ten

subcategories are detailed in the comp lete inventory prepared and published by

ENVIRON Internati onal Corporation: LADCO 2005 COMMERCIAL MARINE

EMISSIONS , by Christian E. Li ndhjem, March, 2007.

Emission totals produced by ENVIRON were provided to LADCO to submit to EPA for

Ohio’s State Implementation Plan (SIP).

## 44 5.2 Rail Sources

The primary activity unit used to determine em issions is gallons of fuel consumed.

Emission rates were derived from EPA doc uments provided as support documentation

for the 1997 locomotive emission standards (EPA, 1997). Gallons of fuel consumed

were based on rail activity.

Rail activity was broken down into four Source Category Codes (SCC). Class I, linehaul rail: Large interstate railroad companies like Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern.

Class I,II, III, switching rail: Yard operations. Class II, III line haul: Regional and local

railroads. And Passenger rail: AMTRAK.

Class I, line-haul represents 84.3% of fuel used and the larges t emission’s category.

The complete emission’s inventory was prepared and published by ENVIRON

International Corporation: LADCO 2005 LOCOMOTIVE EMISSIONS , by Christian E.

Lindhjem, February, 2007.

Emission totals produced by ENVIRON were provided to LADCO to submit to EPA for

Ohio’s State Implementation Plan (SIP).

EPA. 1997: "Locomotive Emission Standards." Regulatory Support Document, United States

Environmental Protection Agency, O ffice of Mobile Sources, April. And EPA 1997, Emission Factors for

Locomotives," Environmental Protecti on Agency, EPA420-F-97-051, December.



## 5.3 Aircraft Sources

INTRODUCTION:

The aircraft emission’s inventory is derived by taking the number of Landings and

Take Offs (LTOs) per year and multiplying by an emission fact or. In the Ohio inventory

when specific aircraft models and engine type emission factors are known they were

used. For the rest of the inventory the emission factors came from USEPA’s fleet

average emissions data. Those results are t hen compiled as tons per year per pollutant

by county. The following de scribes the components, met hodology, and concludes with

a description of an Access based aircraft emission calculator.

COMPONENTS:

I. Ohio Airports:

A list of both towered and non-towered airpor ts in Ohio is obtained from the Ohio

Department of Transportation. See: www.dot.state.oh.us/aviation/ In conversation

with ODOT two individuals stated that the 16 4 airports listed covered over 90% of the

airports in Ohio. See Table 1.

## 45 II. Number of Operations/LTOs by Airport/County:

The ODOT list contained the number of operations a year per airport. An

operation is either a landing or a take-off. A Landing and Take Off (LTO) is required for

FAA EDMS calculations. LTOs were deriv ed simply by dividing the number of

operations by two. These were totaled by county.

Table 5-1 Number of operations and LTOs for 2005

County Airport Name ID Total Operations 

### LTOs/Year

Adams Alexander Salamon AMT 5210 

### 2605

Allen Allen County AOH 32500 

### 16250

Ashland Ashland County 3G4 49240 

### 24620

Ashtabula Ashtabula County HZY 16886 

### 8443

Ashtabula Germack 7D9 840 

### 420

Athens Ohio University UNI 51600 

### 25800

Auglaize Neil Armstrong AXV 29456 

### 14728

Belmont Barnesville-Bradfield 6G5 10150 

### 5075

Belmont Alderman 2P7 6150 

### 3075

Brown Brown County GEO 5157 

### 2578.5

Butler Butler County Regional HAO 61687 

### 30843.5

Butler Hook Field Municipal MWO 40050 

### 20025

Butler Miami University OXD 16708 

### 8354

Carroll Carroll County -Tolson TSO 34950 

### 17475

Carroll Parsons 5D6 2674 

### 1337

Champaign Grimes Field I74 23480 

### 11740

Champaign Weller 38I 300 

### 150

Clark Springfield-Beckley Municipal SGH 64033 

### 32016.5

Clark Mad River I54 15350 

### 7675

Clermont Clermont County I69 35741 

### 17870.5

Clinton Airborne Airpark ILN 52000 

### 26000

Clinton Clinton Field I66 29360 

### 14680

Clinton Hollister Field 2B6 161 

### 80.5

Columbiana Columbiana County Ø2G 31146 

### 15573

Columbiana Koons 8G8 2546 

### 1273

Coshocton Richard Downing I4Ø 19550 

### 9775

Coshocton Tri-City 8ØG 8085 

### 4042.5

Crawford Port Bucyrus 17G 24871 

### 12435.5

Crawford Galion Municipal GQQ 5216 

### 2608

Cuyahoga Burke Lakefront BKL 97100 

### 48550

Cuyahoga Cleveland-Hopkins International CLE 234356 

### 117178

Cuyahoga Cuyahoga County CGF 79774 

### 39887

Darke Darke County VES 9238 

### 4619

Defiance Defiance Memorial DFI 9130 

### 4565

Delaware Delaware Municipal DLZ 39300 

### 19650

Delaware Packer 5E9 3181 

### 1590.5

Erie Hinde 88D 1350 

### 675

Erie Kelleys Island 89D 25495 

### 12747.5

Erie Griffing-Sandusky SKY 112100 

### 56050

## 46 Erie Wakeman I64 17324 

### 8662

Fairfield Miller's Farm 7B4 360 

### 180

Fairfield Fairfield County LHQ 43066 

### 21533

Fayette Fayette County I23 29405 

### 14702.5

Franklin Ohio Stat e University OSU 134459 

### 67229.5

Franklin Port Columbus International CMH 218438 

### 109219

Franklin Rickenbacker International LCK 96200 

### 48100

Franklin Bolton Field TZR 69149 

### 34574.5

Franklin Columbus Southwest Ø4I 11833 

### 5916.5

Franklin Darby Dan 6I6 11260 

### 5630

Fulton Fulton County USE 21123 

### 10561.5

Gallia Gallia-Meigs Regional GAS 12200 

### 6100

Geauga Gates 7D8 4200 

### 2100

Geauga Geauga County 7G8 5350 

### 2675

Greene Greene County - Lewis A. Jackson I19 37400 

### 18700

Greene Bloom 14I 100 

### 50

Guernsey Cambridge Municipal CDI 6040 

### 3020

Hamilton Lunken LUK 129430 

### 64715

Hamilton Blue Ash ISZ 35000 

### 17500

Hamilton Cincinnati West I67 30197 

### 15098.5

Hancock Bluffton 5G7 71980 

### 35990

Hancock Findlay FDY 19800 

### 9900

Hancock Priebe 7D5 3850 

### 1925

Hardin Ada ØD7 331 

### 165.5

Hardin Hardin County I95 6562 

### 3281

Hardin Elliott's Landing O74 1560 

### 780

Harrison Harrison County 8G6 11900 

### 5950

Henry Henry County 7W5 15637 

### 7818.5

Highland Highland County HOC 18325 

### 9162.5

Holmes Holmes County 1ØG 21400 

### 10700

Huron Huron County 5A1 10100 

### 5050

Huron Willard 8G1 2715 

### 1357.5

Jackson James A. Rhodes I43 6053 

### 3026.5

Jefferson Jefferson County Airpark 2G2 15969 

### 7984.5

Jefferson Eddie Dew Memorial 1G8 3540 

### 1770

Knox Knox County 4I3 20150 

### 10075

Knox Wynkoop 6G4 4691 

### 2345.5

Lake Concord Airpark 2G1 4510 

### 2255

Lake Willoughby Lost Nation Municipal LNN 45085 

### 22542.5

Lawrence Lawrence County Airpark HTW 41910 

### 20955

Licking Newark-Heath VTA 12457 

### 6228.5

Logan Bellefontaine Regional EDJ 8325 

### 4162.5

Lorain Columbia 4G8 5150 

### 2575

Lorain Elyria 1G1 14300 

### 7150

Lorain Lagrange 92D 1155 

### 577.5

Lorain Lorain County Regional LPR 62000 

### 31000

Lorain Reader-Botsford Airfield 67D 18700 

### 9350

Lucas Toledo Express TOL 94600 

### 47300

## 47 Madison Madison County UYF 41410 

### 20705

Mahoning Salem Airpark 38D 16920 

### 8460

Mahoning Tri-City 3G6 10555 

### 5277.5

Mahoning Elser Metro 4G4 49232 

### 24616

Mahoning Lansdowne Ø4G 750 

### 375

Marion Marion Municipal MNN 42650 

### 21325

Medina Medina Municipal 1G5 79685 

### 39842.5

Medina Wadsworth Municipal 3G3 41025 

### 20512.5

Medina Weltzien Skypark 15G 79130 

### 39565

Mercer Lakefield CQA 16212 

### 8106

Miami Hartzell Field I17 10200 

### 5100

Miami Troy Skypark 37I 4264 

### 2132

Miami Waco Field 1WF 0 

### 0

Monroe Monroe County 4G5 3324 

### 1662

Montgomery Brookville Air-Park I62 29359 

### 14679.5

Montgomery James M. Cox Dayton Intl DAY 134524 

### 67262

Montgomery Dayton Wright Brothers MGY 89045 

### 44522.5

Montgomery Moraine Airpark I73 12938 

### 6469

Montgomery Dahio Trotwood I44 1853 

### 926.5

Montgomery Phillipsburg 3I7 68000 

### 34000

Morgan Morgan County I71 5725 

### 2862.5

Morrow Morrow County 4I9 19108 

### 9554

Muskingum Zanesville Municipal ZZV 33312 

### 16656

Muskingum Parr 42I 16150 

### 8075

Noble Noble County - Mike Brienza Field I1Ø 5950 

### 2975

Ottawa Middle Bass-East Point 3W9 1300 

### 650

Ottawa Middle Bass Island 3T7 6500 

### 3250

Ottawa North Bass Island 3X5 1000 

### 500

Ottawa Carl R. Keller Field PCW 20890 

### 10445

Ottawa Put-In-Bay 3W2 15140 

### 7570

Paulding Paulding 2H8 2100 

### 1050

Perry Crooksville I84 400 

### 200

Perry Perry County I86 4550 

### 2275

Pickaway Pickaway County CYO 35450 

### 17725

Pickaway Clarks Dream Strip Ø3I 2770 

### 1385

Pike Pike County EOP 2012 

### 1006

Portage Freedom Air Field 7D6 1623 

### 811.5

Portage Farview 86D 3353 

### 1676.5

Portage Mills 7E3 1050 

### 525

Portage Portage County 29G 9621 

### 4810.5

Putnam Ruhe's R47 13250 

### 6625

Putnam Putnam County OWX 11910 

### 5955

Putnam Ohio Dusting Co. 6C2 2995 

### 1497.5

Richland Mansfield Lahm Regional MFD 57518 

### 28759

Richland Shelby Community 12G 2012 

### 1006

Ross Ross County RZT 50150 

### 25075

Sandusky Fremont 14G 37450 

### 18725

Sandusky Sandusky County Regional S24 6148 

### 3074

## 48 Scioto Greater Portsmouth Regional PMH 45830 

### 22915

Seneca Bandit Field 5D9 140 

### 70

Seneca Fostoria Metropolitan FZI 7900 

### 3950

Seneca Weiker 82D 320 

### 160

Seneca Seneca County 16G 60165 

### 30082.5

Shelby Sidney Municipal I12 20500 

### 10250

Stark Barber 2D1 13750 

### 6875

Stark Miller Airport 4G3 8000 

### 4000

Stark Beach City 2D7 6112 

### 3056

Summit Akron Fulton International AKR 26000 

### 13000

Summit Akron-Canton Regional CAK 120441 

### 60220.5

Summit Mayfield 1D4 450 

### 225

Summit Kent State University 1G3 72500 

### 36250

Trumbull Braceville 41N 425 

### 212.5

Trumbull Warren 62D 14738 

### 7369

Trumbull Youngstown-W arren Regional YNG 98298 

### 49149

Tuscarawas Harry Clever Field PHD 54880 

### 27440

Union Union County MRT 31886 

### 15943

Van Wert Van Wert County VNW 20516 

### 10258

Vinton Vinton County 22I 5225 

### 2612.5

Warren Warren County I68 24951 

### 12475.5

Warren Red Stewart Airfield 4ØI 16800 

### 8400

Wayne Wayne County BJJ 96520 

### 48260

Williams Williams County ØG6 10010 

### 5005

Wood Wood County 1GØ 27405 

### 13702.5

Wood Bordner 3D8 2200 

### 1100

Wood Deshler Municipal 6D7 2000 

### 1000

Wood Metcalf TDZ 90700 

### 45350

Wyandot Wyandot County 56D 7410 

### 3705



## III. Aircraft Models and Number of LTO/yr:

Specific aircraft models by airport (generally t he larger airports) is obtained from “Table

7” provided by the United States Departm ent of Transportation, Office of Airline

Information. This provided the number of LTO’s for each aircraft model per year per

airport.

Table 2. Sample from “Table 7.” This is the all community total of aircraft models for

the Akron/Canton area. “All Service” departure s were used as the number of LTOs per

year for that model. Listed in the original table are airc raft model by airport and number

of services/LTOs.

## 49 **TOTAL DEPARTURES PERFORMD**

**Aircraft Scheduled Non-Sched All**

**Model Service Service Service**

A-318 1 1

A319 384 384

BOEING 717-200 3850 3850

BOEING 727-100 1 1

BOEING 727-200 5 5

BOEING 737-100/200 74 74

BOEING 737-200C 3 3 6

BOEING 737-300 2 2

BOEING 737-700/LR 212 212

BOEING 737-800 5 5

BOEING 757-200 4 4

BOEING 767-300/ER 4 4

CANADAIR RJ-100/ER 542 3 545

CANADAIR RJ-700 2881 2881

CONVAIR CV-580 3 3

DASSAULT FALCON 7 7

DHC8-100 DASH 8 2 2

DOUGLAS DC-9-15F 13 13

DOUGLAS DC-9-30 6 6

EMBRAER-145 144 144

RJ-200ER/RJ-440 5519 5519

SAAB-FAIRCHD 340/B 1804 1804

ALL TYPES 15342 130 15472

IV. Emission Factors:

Where there was specific aircraft model data the emission factors were derived

using the FAA’s Emission Dispersion Modeling System (EDMS). EDMS is a combined

emissions and dispersion model for assessing ai r quality at civilian airports and military

air bases. The model was developed by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) in

cooperation with the Unit ed States Air Force (USAF). The model is used to produce an

inventory of emissions generated by source s on and around the airport or air base, and

to calculate pollutant concentrations in these environments.

## 50 Table 5-2 EDMS Aircraft Emissions

Emissions provided by Michigan Department of Environmental Quality. (The few

aircraft in Ohio not included in the table had emissions derived by EDMS 5.0 in-house.)

EDMS Aircraft Emissions/LTO by Aircraft Type

EDMS 4.5 Emissions Inventory Report of 2005 Aircraft Inventory Emissions Factors

Year 2005 Lbs Emitted Per LTO

Aircraft Type CO NOx HC VOC SO2 PM2.5 PM10

A- 318 19.8 18.7 4.0 4.4 1.5 0.0 0.0

A-300-600/R/CF/RCF 27.1 56.4 2.0 2.2 4.0 0.2 0.2

A-300B/C/F-100/200 30.2 52.5 3.5 3.7 3.3 0.2 0.2

A-310-200C/F 32.6 52.5 7.3 7.9 3.3 0.2 0.2

A-319 19.8 18.7 4.0 4.4 1.5 0.0 0.0

A320-100/200 13.7 19.8 1.3 1.3 1.8 0.2 0.2

A-321 16.8 36.8 3.1 3.3 2.2 0.0 0.0

A-330-200 29.8 61.5 0.4 0.4 4.4 0.2 0.2

AVROLINER RJ85 24.7 9.5 2.9 3.3 1.3 0.2 0.2

BAE-146-300 24.7 9.0 3.1 3.3 1.3 0.2 0.2

BEECH 1900 A/B/C 11.0 1.1 3.3 3.5 0.2 0.0 0.0

BEECH KINGAIR C90 1.8 0.9 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0

717-200 11.7 23.4 0.0 0.0 1.5 0.0 0.0

727-100 21.4 23.1 4.6 5.1 2.9 0.4 0.4

727-100C/QC 44.5 19.8 4.6 5.1 2.4 1.1 1.1

727-200 19.6 27.3 2.9 3.1 3.3 1.1 1.1

737-100/200 14.1 16.1 2.2 2.4 2.0 0.7 0.7

737-200C 13.9 17.4 6.8 7.5 2.0 0.9 0.9

737-300 28.7 15.9 1.8 2.0 1.8 0.0 0.0

737-400 26.5 18.5 1.5 1.5 1.8 0.0 0.0

737-500 24.7 21.2 1.3 1.3 2.0 0.0 0.0

737-700/LR 17.6 20.1 2.0 2.0 1.8 0.4 0.4

737-800 15.7 27.1 1.5 1.8 2.0 0.7 0.7

737-900 15.7 27.1 1.5 1.8 2.0 0.7 0.7

747-100 252.6 108.5 106.7 116.8 7.1 0.4 0.4

747-200/300 60.6 104.7 7.1 7.7 6.8 0.7 0.7

747-400 67.0 105.6 5.7 6.4 7.3 0.7 0.7

757-200 24.7 35.7 2.0 2.2 2.6 0.4 0.4

757-300 27.1 33.1 0.4 0.4 3.1 0.2 0.2

767-200/ER 32.6 52.5 7.3 7.9 3.3 0.2 0.2

767-300/ER 32.0 62.2 2.6 2.9 4.0 0.4 0.4

777 32.8 85.1 5.1 5.7 4.4 0.4 0.4

CANADAIR RJ100/ER 16.3 4.9 1.5 1.8 0.7 0.0 0.0

CANADAIR RJ-700 12.6 9.3 0.0 0.0 1.1 0.0 0.0

CESSNA 208 1.1 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0

CONVAIR CV-580 36.2 0.9 8.8 9.5 0.7 0.0 0.0

DASSAULT FALCON 13.7 2.6 2.4 2.6 0.2 0.0 0.0

DHC8-100 DASH 8 5.1 3.1 0.0 0.0 0.4 0.0 0.0

DORNIER 328 JET 1.3 6.6 11.9 12.6 0.7 0.0 0.0

DOUGLAS DC-10-10 102.5 76.7 38.6 42.1 4.2 0.0 0.0

DOUGLAS DC-10-30 45.4 78.7 5.3 5.7 5.1 0.4 0.4

## 51 DOUGLAS DC-10-40 131.8 81.8 30.2 33.1 6.0 0.7 0.7

DOUGLAS DC-8-63 263.5 25.6 219.1 239.9 4.2 5.1 5.1

DOUGLAS DC-8-71 53.6 34.6 3.1 3.3 3.7 0.0 0.0

DOUGLAS DC-8-73 53.6 34.6 3.1 3.3 3.7 0.0 0.0

DOUGLAS DC-9-10 14.1 14.6 3.7 4.0 1.8 0.2 0.2

DOUGLAS DC-9-15F 14.1 14.6 3.7 4.0 1.8 0.2 0.2

DOUGLAS DC-9-30 14.1 14.6 3.7 4.0 1.8 0.2 0.2

DOUGLAS DC-9-40 39.7 16.5 10.8 11.9 2.0 1.3 1.3

DOUGLAS DC-9-50 12.6 20.1 1.8 1.8 2.2 0.9 0.9

EMBRAER-135 12.8 5.5 1.1 1.3 0.7 0.0 0.0

EMBRAER-140 13.7 6.0 1.3 1.3 0.7 0.0 0.0

EMBRAER-145 6.4 6.8 1.1 1.1 0.7 0.0 0.0

EMBRAER-170 9.0 9.7 0.0 0.0 1.1 0.0 0.0

F28-4000/6000 76.7 10.4 77.2 84.4 1.5 0.0 0.0

JETSTREAM 41 4.6 2.0 0.4 0.7 0.2 0.0 0.0

L-101101/100/200 33.3 112.0 6.2 6.8 5.7 1.3 1.3

LEAR-25 75.2 0.7 7.9 8.4 0.2 0.0 0.0

LOCKHEED L100-30 48.7 9.9 19.6 21.4 1.8 0.0 0.0

MD-11 47.8 93.3 4.0 4.4 6.0 0.7 0.7

MD-80, 1, 2, 3, 7, 8 16.3 20.3 0.0 0.0 2.2 0.2 0.2

MD-90 12.1 23.8 0.2 0.2 2.0 0.2 0.2

RJ-200ER/RJ-440 16.3 4.9 1.5 1.8 0.7 0.0 0.0

SAAB-FAIRCHD 340/B 4.2 1.5 1.5 1.5 0.2 0.0 0.0



## NOTE: Where specific aircraft model data was not available fleet emissions were used.

EPA default fleet average emissi on factors were taken from “Documentation for Aircraft,

Commercial Marine Vessel, ,Locomotive, and Other Non-road Components of the

National Emissions Inventory. 2005, s ee Appendix A, Aircraft Emission Estimation

Methodology.” Specific model LTOs were subtracted from county LTO totals to

eliminate double counting those LTOs.

Table 5-3 Fleet Emissi on Factor Categories

Fleet emission factors were br oken down into three categories. Itinerant General, Local

General, and Military.

Table 5-3a Fleet Average Emission Factor s for Itinerant General Aircraft.

(Taken from : Table A-5)

Pollutant Emission Factors (lbs/LTO)

HC 1.234

NOx 0.158

CO 28.13

SOx 0.015

PM10 0.60333

Note: Air taxi HC emissions * VOC/HC ( 0.9914) conversion factor = air taxi VOC estimate

## 52 Table 5-3b Fleet Average Emission Factor s for Local General Aircraft.

(Taken From: Table A-11)

Pollutant Emission Factors (lbs/LTO)

HC 0.394

NOx 0.065

CO 12.014

SOx 0.01

PM10 0.2367

Note: GA HC emissions * VOC/HC( 0.9708) conversion factor = GA VOC estimate

Table 5-3c Fleet Average Emission Fa ctors for Military Aircraft.

(Taken from: Table A-17)

Pollutant Emission Factors (lbs/LTO

HC 1.234

NOx 0.158

CO 28.13

SOx 0.015

PM10 0.60333

Note: Military HC emissions * VOC/HC( 1.1046) conversion factor = Military VOC estimate

METHODOLOGY

Introduction

The following information was considered in the development of emission estimates:

1. Commercial scheduled and non-scheduled ai rcraft air carrier activity and

commercial air freight activity by aircraft model types,

2. General aviation and air taxi annual loca l and itinerant operations for year 2005,

3. Military annual local and iti nerant operations for year 2005.

Due to the need to have aircraft operations in formation expressed as landing/take off

(LTO) cycles, the following assumptions were made:

1. For commercial aircraft and commercial ai r freight activity, t he number of annual

aircraft annual LTO cycles was assu med to be equal to the number of

## 53 departures. The daily LTO cycle frequency was then obtained by dividing the

yearly LTO cycles by 365.

2. For general aircraft annual local and iti nerant airport operations, each respective

operations total was divided by 2 to obt ain the corresponding year local and

itinerant LTO cycles. The expected daily local and itinerant LTO cycles then

were obtained by dividing these annual totals by 365.

3. For military annual local and itinerant operat ions, each respective operations total

was divided by 2 to obtain the correspondi ng year local and itinerant LTO cycles.

The expected military daily local and iti nerant LTO cycles then were obtained by

dividing these annual totals by 365.

Airport LTO cycles were further categoriz ed into commercial aircraft by plane and

engine type, general aviation itinerant aircraft of unknown aircraft type, general aviation

local aircraft of unknown aircraft type, and military aircraft. This was necessary in order

to utilize the U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Av iation Administration EDMS

Emissions and Dispersion Modeling System . Commercial and air freight aircraft

emission factors per LTO cycle were det ermined using EDMS for each commercial

aircraft type models where possible were used at each towered airport. Default

commercial aircraft engine type, and Enviro nmental Protection Agency (EPA) default

time in mode values for takeoff, approach, and landing roll times were used in the

EDMS model simulations.

For those aircraft types that could not be determined using the EDMS emissions model,

aircraft emission factors based upon EPA alter native fleet average procedures were

then used to estimate their emissions. These included general aviation and air taxi

itinerant aircraft of unknown aircraft type, general aviation local aircraft of unknown

aircraft type, and military aircraft. Conversion from total hydrocarbons to volatile organic

compounds was performed and based upon the EPA guidance

.



## APPROACH

1. A list of more than 90% of the airports was obtained fr om the Ohio Department of

Transportation. These were classed by airport, county, aircraft flight classification, and

the total number of op erations per year.

2. The number of oper ations (a landing or a take off) were then divided by two giving

the number of LTOs per year per airport. These airports were combined by county for

the total number of LTOs per year, per county.

3. In dialog with ODOT it was determined that the following Ohio flight groups of aircraft

be combined to match the three categorie s used by the USEPA in calculating

emissions.

## 54 Itinerant (General, air carrier, commuter, ai r taxi, general aviation itinerant)

Local (General aviation local)

Military (Military)

4. LTOs for specific models of aircraft per airport were ta ken from the FAA Table 7.

See Table 2 above. These were then combined to gi ve the number of LTOs per aircraft

model per county. Specific model LTOs were subtracted from county totals to avoid

double counting those LTOs.

5. Emission factors were det ermined from the FAA’s EDMS pr ogram for specific aircraft

model and engine type. See IV. Emission factors above. The aircraft emission table

provided by Michigan has the emission factors for most of the aircraft fl own in Ohio. .

Where specific aircraft model data was not available USEPA average fleet emissions

were used.

6. Emission factors times LTOs by count y yielded tons per y ear per county.

Table 5-4 Pollutant by County (Sample)

County POLLUTANT ACTIVITY(LTOS/YEAR) ACTIVITY(LTOS/DAY) EMISSIONS(TON/YEAR)

ADAMS CO 2605 7.136986 24.552325

ADAMS HC 2605 7.136986 0.977285

ADAMS NOX 2605 7.136986 0.136045

ADAMS PM10-PRI 2605 7.136986 0.513114825

ADAMS PM25-PRI 2605 7.136986 0

ADAMS SOX 2605 7.136986 0.0157875

ADAMS VOC 2605 7.136986 0.96314234

ALLEN CO 16250 44.52055 147.945065

ALLEN HC 16250 44.52055 5.841097

ALLEN NOX 16250 44.52055 0.827189

ALLEN PM10-PRI 16250 44.52055 3.081191265

ALLEN PM25-PRI 16250 44.52055 0

ALLEN SOX 16250 44.52055 0.0984575

ALLEN VOC 16250 44.52055 5.769568254

ASHLAND CO 24620 67.45205 173.67794

ASHLAND HC 24620 67.45205 6.19414

ASHLAND NOX 24620 67.45205 0.94895

ASHLAND PM10-PRI 24620 67.45205 3.532515

ASHLAND PM25-PRI 24620 67.45205 0

ASHLAND SOX 24620 67.45205 0.1311

ASHLAND VOC 24620 67.45205 6.07175247

ASHTABULA CO 8863 24.28219 78.115087

ASHTABULA HC 8863 24.28219 3.042551

ASHTABULA NOX 8863 24.28219 0.431593

## 55 ASHTABULA PM10-PRI 8863 24.28219 1.623493455

ASHTABULA PM25-PRI 8863 24.28219 0

ASHTABULA SOX 8863 24.28219 0.0520325

ASHTABULA VOC 8863 24.28219 2.99420213

ATHENS CO 25800 70.68493 196.874985

ATHENS HC 25800 70.68493 7.267183

ATHENS NOX 25800 70.68493 1.081521

ATHENS PM10-PRI 25800 70.68493 4.037266335

ATHENS PM25-PRI 25800 70.68493 0

ATHENS SOX 25800 70.68493 0.1420925

ATHENS VOC 25800 70.68493 7.128180006



## 7. Emissions were then summed by pollut ants in each county by SCC aircraft category

type so data could be provided to LADCO in the EPA prescribed NEI – NIF format.

DATA ERROR

The first aircraft emission inventory submitt ed to LADCO in April, 2007 contained an

error. The inventory submitted in May, 2007 has the error corrected. The error was the

result of a carry-over func tion in Access that picked up the number of operations as

instead of LTOs....which made the in ventory exactly twice as lar ge as what it really was.

ACCESS CALCULATOR

Introduction:

Our database programmer set up Access applic ation to calculate Ohio’s aircraft

emission inventory, and export those results to Excel. His utility allows for easy

modification of the aircraft data to match futu re data scenarios. Ou tput to Excel also

allows for additional data manipulation and importation.

## 56 Interface:

Through this interface the following sets of data can be edited/updated: Airport activity,

emission factors, specific airport emissi ons, state/county FIPS, detailed aircraft

information, airport informati on, and aircraft SCCs. Once the final emissions have been

calculated and summed, then the data can be expo rt via the export function on the Main

Menu

.

# Technical Memorandum

Northeast Ohio (AMATS, NOACA, Ashtabula)

1997 Annual NAAQS PM Fine Attainment SIP Inventory

Mobile Source Emissions (PM 2.5 and NOx)

May 2011

By AMATS, NOACA and ODOT

In Coordination with the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

# Table of Contents

1. Overview ............................................................................................................... 1

2. Urban Travel Dema nd Models ............................................................................. 5

3. Emission Factor Generation ................................................................................. 5

4. Post Proce ssing ................................................................................................... 22

5. Multiple MPO Coordi nation Issu es .................................................................... 24

Appendix A Interagency Consulta tion Documentation

Appendix B Post Processing Default Distributions

### 1 

# 1. Overview

This memorandum is intended to document the USEPA MOVES based mobile source air quality

analyses performed by the Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) for the Akron

Metropolitan Area Trans portation Study (AMATS) and Ashtabul a Township areas, and by the

Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency fo r the counties of Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain and

Medina in its area. These analyses were conduc ted in support of Ohio EPA’s intent to submit a

redesignation package State Implementation Plan (SIP) submittal for the 1997 Annual PM 2.5 

## NAAQS.

The designated northeast Ohio nonattai nment areas for the 1997 Annual PM 2.5 

## NAAQS includes

the counties of Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain, Medina , Portage, and Summit; and Ashtabula Township

in Ashtabula County. USEPA has recently proposed to redesignate these c ounties to attainment

based on several years of monitoring data ( 76 FR 28393). Despite the potential change in

attainment status, Ohio EPA must still contin ue its efforts to assemble the necessary

redesignation submittals.

The inventories include count y based, annual totals of PM 2.5 

## and Oxides of Nitrogen (NO X 

## ) for

the base year 2005, the attainment year 2008, th e interim year 2015, and the maintenance period

horizon year 2022.

Latest Planning Assumptions

These annual PM 2.5 

## inventory runs meet the latest planning assumption requirement. As

discussed in Section 2 of this report, the travel forecast modeling processes used to develop

vehicle miles of travel (VMT) for the AMATS a nd NOACA areas is calibrated using the latest

population and land use data available and are vali dated using corresponding traffic count data.

Currently, the travel demand mode ls are validated to year 2005.

U.S. EPA’s most recent emissions software, M OVES, is used for all mobile source emission

analyses with MOVES inputs and output need s being established at various interagency

consultation meetings and e-mails between November 2010 and May 2011 (See Appendix A ).

It was also established that annual emission estimates would be based on a single-season

approach. Since travel demand models produce average daily conditions, the daily emissions

estimates are multiplied by 365 days to produce annua l emissions estimates expressed in tons per

year.

Finally, the regional emissions analys is includes emissions for Direct PM 2.5 

## (exhaust, brake, and

tire wear), and Oxid es of Nitrogen (NO X 

## ).Sulfur Dioxide (SO 2 

## ), Volatile Organic Compounds

(VOCs) and Ammonia (NH 3 

## ) are considered insignificant at this time. SO 2 

## emissions are shown

to support the assertion that they are insignificant.2On Road Mobile Source Emissions Inventory SummaryTables 1 to 4 present a summary of emissions by county as well as the entire nonattainment area for NOX, PM2.5 and SO2forcalendar years 2005, 2008, 2015, and 2022. They also include annual VMT totals. The remainder of this document focuses on theassumptions behind the analyses.Table 1 – Northeast Ohio On-Road Mobile Source Emissions2005 BaseCOUNTY NOX(tons/year) PM2.5(tons/year) SO2(tons/year) Annual VMTAshtabula Twp. 294.66 11.50 5.07 79,693,005Cuyahoga 36,506.02 1,247.92 845.65 10,605,503,693Lake 8,067.92 282.95 176.88 2,112,119,403Lorain 9,181.08 319.21 199.86 2,468,649,943Medina 9,280.85 319.21 207.56 2,100,347,788Portage 5,707.22 187.71 96.74 1,761,085,222Summit 17,377.28 611.78 319.72 5,505,977,908TOTAL86,415.032,980.28 1,851.48 24,633,376,9623Table 2 – Northeast Ohio On-Road Mobile Source Emissions2008 AttainmentCOUNTY NOX(tons/year) PM2.5(tons/year) SO2(tons/year) Annual VMTAshtabula Twp. 232.83 10.04 1.57 80,604,775Cuyahoga 28,227.20 1,040.28 253.16 10,644,066,125Lake 6,425 241.78 51.94 2,154,120,865Lorain 7,354.77 274.43 60.17 2,519,904,703Medina 7,603.83 317.43 57.65 2,228,836,730Portage 4,630.98 160.90 30.52 1,811,101,624Summit 13,609.82 511.43 100.66 5,635,781,676TOTAL 68,084.64 2,556.29 555.66 25,074,416,498Table 3 – Northeast Ohio On-Road Mobile Source Emissions2015 InterimCOUNTY NOX(tons/year) PM2.5(tons/year) SO2(tons/year) Annual VMTAshtabula Twp. 107.68 5.37 0.66 82,946,980Cuyahoga 12,371.38 430.01 76.36 10,586,598,518Lake 2,840.39 122.02 15.91 2,178,585,720Lorain 3,456.51 143.34 18.51 2,550,296,428Medina 3,306.35 152.50 17.63 2,308,164,735Portage 2,264.50 87.54 13.23 1,935,234,601Summit 6,170.32 251.70 42.76 5,992,078,124TOTAL 30,517.14 1,192.47 185.06 25,633,905,1064Table 4 – Northeast Ohio On-Road Mobile Source Emissions2022 MaintenanceCOUNTY NOX(tons/year) PM2.5(tons/year) SO2(tons/year) Annual VMTAshtabula Twp. 54.49 3.03 0.62 85,561,840Cuyahoga 6,065.83 320.94 68.07 10,685,893,665Lake 1,417.15 69.42 14.45 2,250,259,310Lorain 1,723.02 81.69 16.83 2,632,524,905Medina 1,677.58 78.48 16.83 2,489,638,720Portage 1,014.35 49.45 7.40 2,036,373,863Summit 3,059.45 162.98 39.57 6,246,851,092TOTAL 15,011.86 765.99 163.77 26,427,103,395

### 5 

# 2. Urban Travel Demand Models

NOACA maintains a PC-based regional travel demand forecasting model on the Citilabs CUBE

platform for use in its urban transportation planning process. This model employs the traditional

four step modeling process to project existing a nd future traffic volumes and travel patterns on

the regional transportation networ ks. The four step process cons ists of trip generation, trip

distribution, mode split, and route assignment. Out put from the model is link-by-link directional

volumes for four time periods: AM peak, Midday, PM peak, and Night and is added together to

create 24-hour traffic volumes for the existing or future regional transportation networks.

The Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) holds the transportation model for the AMATS

area. AMATS prepares and submits networks for its planning area to ODOT. ODOT prepares

networks for Ashtabula County. ODOT's modeling is also run on a PC-based CUBE platform.

These models are uniquely suited to perform emission analyses. The modeling process identifies

growth in vehicle miles of travel and changes in regional travel patter ns resulting from the

projects that are proposed in these areas’ transportation plans and programs.

Detailed information about NOACA’s travel demand forecast model can be found here:

http://www.noaca.org/traveldemandmemo.pdf

Landuse and Socio-economic Data

The areas’ socio-economic model variables reflect the current and expected future regional land

uses as best known to staff.

Socio-economic variables were developed fo r all areas based on 2000 Census data and 2030

county-level Ohio Department of Development population projections. Minor adjustments to

2005 data have been made in an effort to have this data correspond to 2005 estimates released by

the US Census Bureau.

Until new 2010 Census based projections are developed by the Ohio Department of

Development (ODOD), the current data represen ts the best available for this effort.



# 3. Emission Factor Generation

Base and Attainment Years

Using MOVES, emission factor files were ge nerated for base year-2005, attainment year-2008,

interim year 2015, and maintenance year 2022. A ssumptions for these runs include an I/M

program in all but Ashtabula Township. Progr ams and corresponding MOVES parameters were

developed in consultation with OEPA.

### 6 

## Technical Details

Table 7 summarizes the settings used in th e MOVES run specification file and the MOVES

County-Data Manager. All inputs for the region’s analyses are included in the CD provides to

Ohio EPA as part of this document submittal. Fu rther information about specific inputs that are

not using default values is also discussed below.

Table 7 – MOVES Inputs

RunSpec Parameter Settings

MOVES Version 2010/08/26

Scale County

MOVES Modeling Technique Emission Factor Method

Rates per Distance

Rates per Vehicle

Time Span Time Aggregation: Hour

1 Month representing average annual temperatures

All hours of day selected

16 speed bins

Weekdays only

Geographic Bounds Cuyahoga, Lake, Lo rain, Medina, Portage and Summit

Counties; Ashtabula Township

Vehicles/Equipment All related source ty pes, gasoline and diesel; CNG-Transit

Buses for base year-2005 and attainment year-2008

Road Type All road types including off-network

Pollutants and Processes NO

x 

## , All PM 2.5 

## categories, SO 2 

## , Total Energy Consumption

Strategies Alternative Vehicle Fuels and Technologies for interim year

2015, and maintenance year 2022 to offset impact of CNG

General Output Units = grams, joules and miles

Output Emissions Time = hour, Location =county, on-road emission rates by road

type and source use type.

Advance Performance None

County Data Manager Sources

Source Type Population Combinatio n of local and default data

Local BMV Vehicle Registration Total

Local BMV population for motorcycle (11), moped (11), bus

(41, 42,43), mobile home ( 54), house vehicle (54)

MOVES default fractions for the rest (21,31,32,51,52,53,61,62)

Future year growth rate based on TFM’s household growth rates.

Vehicle Type VMT Travel Demand Forecast Model’s daily VMT

EPA annual VMT converter

### 7 

## Hourly VMT fractions - ODOT Hourly Percentage

I/M Program I/M program info rmation supplied by Ohio EPA

Fuel Formulation Default

Fuel Supply Default

Metereology Data Local data obtained fr om NOAA National Climatic Data Center.

Data will consist of monthly high and low temperatures and

daily relative humidity for 2005.

Ramp Fraction Travel Demand Forecast Model

Road Type Distribution ODOT’s 2005 DVMT by FC

Age Distribution Local data ODOT from 2009 moto r vehicle registration

The same age distribution will be used for all analysis years

Average Speed Distribution Default as a place holder

Zone Activity Default with necessary modification as prescribed in MOVES

userguide.

### 8 

## Temperature and Relative Humidity

Temperatures used for the single season approach are representative of 12 months in 2005 based

on NOAA data from the National Climate Data Center website. The month of April was used as

the representative month. Data for Cleveland Ho pkins International Airport (CLE) was used for

NOACA’s area. Data for Akron-Canton Airpor t (CAK) was used for AMATS and Ashtabula

Twp. Areas. To get the correct fomat for MOVE S, the data was entered into a spreadsheet

provided by EPA which was designe d to convert Mobile6 data to MOVES. The average annual

hourly temperature and relative humidity distribution profile for Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain, and

Medina Counties can be seen in Table 8a. Ta ble 8b portrays the data for Portage and Summit

Counties; and Ashtabula Twp.

Table 8a – Temperature and Relative Humi dity Data for NOACA portion of area

Hour Average Temperature Average

Relative Humidity

1 42.1033 68

2 40.9717 73

3 40.0825 75

4 39.4358 76

5 38.9508 76

6 38.3850 77

7 37.9000 70

8 38.3042 68

9 40.7292 63

10 44.6092 58

11 48.5700 58

12 51.9650 56

13 54.9558 53

14 56.5725 54

15 57.1383 52

16 57.3000 52

17 56.8958 52

18 55.7642 52

19 53.8242 53

20 51.3183 56

21 48.8125 57

22 46.6300 61

23 45.0942 64

24 43.5583 66

### 9 

## Table 8b – Temperature and Relative Humi dity Data for AMATS portion of area

Hour Average Temperature Average

Relative Humidity

1 44.9033 

### 76

2 43.7717 

### 78

3 42.8825 

### 79

4 42.2358 

### 81

5 41.7508 

### 82

6 41.1850 

### 83

7 40.7000 

### 82

8 41.1042 

### 79

9 43.5292 

### 74

10 47.4092 

### 71

11 51.3700 

### 68

12 54.7650 

### 63

13 57.7558 

### 61

14 59.3725 

### 58

15 59.9383 

### 56

16 60.1000 

### 55

17 59.6958 

### 57

18 58.5642 

### 60

19 56.6242 

### 65

20 54.1183 

### 69

21 51.6125 

### 71

22 49.4300 

### 73

23 47.8942 

### 74

24 46.3583 

### 75

### 10 

## Ramp Fraction

Ramp fractions were derived using the base ye ar travel demand model VHT fractions. Ramp

fractions can be seen in Table 9. Base year fractions were ke pt the same for future years.

Table 9 – Ramp Fractions

County roadTypeID roadDesc rampFraction

Cuyahoga 2 Rural Restricted Access 0

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.116

Lake 2 Rural Restricted Access 0.092

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.092

Lorain 2 Rural Restricted Access 0.107

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.107

Medina 2 Rural Restricted Access 0.058

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.058

Portage 2 Rural Restricted Access 0.014

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.184

Summit 2 Rural Restricted Access 0.005

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.091

Ashtabula 2 Rural Restricted Access 0

4 Urban Restricted Access 0.18411Source Type PopulationSource type population is based on a combination of local and MOVES default data. Localdata was obtained from ODPS Bureau ofMotor Vehicles Motor Vehicle Registrationsby county and vehicle type data for the base year 2005 and intermediate year 2008. TheMOVES default source type population datawas obtained from the national level MOVES inventory runs for each county.OBMV’s vehicle registration data was usedas a control total for all source type population and a sub totalfor Intercity Bus (41),Transit Bus (42), and School Bus (43). The same data was also used to assign source type population of Motorcycle (11) and MotorHome (54). For the rest of source types 21, 31, 32, 51, 52, 53, 61 and62, the fraction of each source type from the MOVES defaultdata was used and adjusted to match up the control total for source type population.Future year source type growth rate is based ontravel demand model’s annual household growthrate from year 2005 to year 2022 for corresponding analysis years. Table 10 showssource type population for the analyzed counties in 2005.Table 10 – Source Type Population for year 2005sourceTypeID sourceTypeName CuyahogaLake Lorain Medina Portage SummitAshtabulaTwp11 Motorcycle24,754 7,960 10,241 6,585 7,158 17,354 59321 Passenger Car579,339 121,433 150,152 89,819 84,140 277,131 7,50631 Passenger Truck362,540 76,735 95,416 58,943 60,169 190,713 5,40432 Light Commercial Truck121,119 25,636 31,877 19,692 2,413 7,648 21741 Intercity Bus289 61 29 16 33 139 1042 Transit Bus742 37 17 9 17 74 543 School Bus2,003 422 198 108 198 849 6251 Refuse truck314 73 92 73 64 154 652 Single Unit Short-haul Truck17,464 4,049 5,122 4,059 2,651 6,355 24653 Single Unit Long-haul Truck1,770 410 519 411 338 812 3254 Motor Home5,121 780 1,354 901 2,537 4,821 2961 Comb Short-haul Truck3,758 1,043 1,083 1,336 1,283 2,293 11862 Comb Long-haul Truck3,870 1,075 1,116 1,376 1,476 2,637 136

### 12 

## I/M Program

I/M program information was supplied by Ohio EPA. The I/M program was applied to all

analysis years for every geogra phy with the exception of Ashtabula Township. The I/M program

MOVES inputs reflect:

1) ASM 2525 Final Cutpoints, for model years up to 1995

2) Two-mode, 2500 RPM/Idle Test , for model years 1996 & newer

OBD II in Ohio is not an exhaust emission test and is not considered, since the pollutants under

current consideration are only SO2, NO X 

## and PM 2.5 

## . The compliance rate and failure rates are

obtained from Ohio EPA and compliance factor s are calculated. These are applied for all

counties under consideration and for all model years.

Vehicle Age Distribution

Vehicle age distribution informa tion was derived using ODPS vehi cle registration data (2009).

The data was given to OEPA who supplied a VIN decoder that allowed ODOT to create

correctly formatted MOVES inputs. A different age distribution file is used for each county.

Table 11 provides a sample distribution for Cuya hoga County. The distributions for other areas

can be found in the electronic input submittals. The same age distributions were used for all

analysis years.

### 13 

## Table 11 – Vehicle Age Distribution for

Cuyahoga County

yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 11 30 0.106925

2005 11 29 0.018783

2005 11 28 0.026115

2005 11 27 0.014845

2005 11 26 0.011632

2005 11 25 0.01317

2005 11 24 0.014596

2005 11 23 0.00998

2005 11 22 0.007536

2005 11 21 0.009369

2005 11 20 0.009074

2005 11 19 0.008758

2005 11 18 0.010636

2005 11 17 0.013827

2005 11 16 0.017312

2005 11 15 0.021

2005 11 14 0.02272

2005 11 13 0.021951

2005 11 12 0.02582

2005 11 11 0.03761

2005 11 10 0.044965

2005 11 9 0.05413

2005 11 8 0.060081

2005 11 7 0.075515

2005 11 6 0.063725

2005 11 5 0.066418

2005 11 4 0.076963

2005 11 3 0.068658

2005 11 2 0.044852

2005 11 1 0.021362

2005 11 0 0.001675

2005 21 30 0.031927

2005 21 29 0.001002

2005 21 28 0.001082

2005 21 27 0.001608

2005 21 26 0.002483

2005 21 25 0.003053

2005 21 24 0.003691

2005 21 23 0.005082

2005 21 22 0.006714

2005 21 21 0.010246 yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 21 20 0.013223

2005 21 19 0.017294

2005 21 18 0.023152

2005 21 17 0.028475

2005 21 16 0.034352

2005 21 15 0.044328

2005 21 14 0.040195

2005 21 13 0.048119

2005 21 12 0.050547

2005 21 11 0.056333

2005 21 10 0.057401

2005 21 9 0.054497

2005 21 8 0.058427

2005 21 7 0.059745

2005 21 6 0.059884

2005 21 5 0.060329

2005 21 4 0.058016

2005 21 3 0.060513

2005 21 2 0.05262

2005 21 1 0.04119

2005 21 0 0.014472

2005 31 30 0.002999

2005 31 29 0.000209

2005 31 28 0.000285

2005 31 27 0.000524

2005 31 26 0.000797

2005 31 25 0.001189

2005 31 24 0.001723

2005 31 23 0.002477

2005 31 22 0.003177

2005 31 21 0.00491

2005 31 20 0.006233

2005 31 19 0.008686

2005 31 18 0.011764

2005 31 17 0.02159

2005 31 16 0.026281

2005 31 15 0.03281

2005 31 14 0.031973

2005 31 13 0.036449

2005 31 12 0.043884

2005 31 11 0.049373

2005 31 10 0.053384

2005 31 9 0.052496

2005 31 8 0.068594

### 14 

## yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 31 7 0.073487

2005 31 6 0.079743

2005 31 5 0.092016

2005 31 4 0.082702

2005 31 3 0.07979

2005 31 2 0.07549

2005 31 1 0.04345

2005 31 0 0.011516

2005 32 30 0.006296

2005 32 29 0.000508

2005 32 28 0.000914

2005 32 27 0.001219

2005 32 26 0.002844

2005 32 25 0.002945

2005 32 24 0.002945

2005 32 23 0.004367

2005 32 22 0.005078

2005 32 21 0.008531

2005 32 20 0.010358

2005 32 19 0.009851

2005 32 18 0.014522

2005 32 17 0.024576

2005 32 16 0.03727

2005 32 15 0.054737

2005 32 14 0.036458

2005 32 13 0.043668

2005 32 12 0.041637

2005 32 11 0.048746

2005 32 10 0.055753

2005 32 9 0.040317

2005 32 8 0.038997

2005 32 7 0.03788

2005 32 6 0.029349

2005 32 5 0.029958

2005 32 4 0.086016

2005 32 3 0.091398

2005 32 2 0.13923

2005 32 1 0.063166

2005 32 0 0.030466

2005 41 30 0.002855

2005 41 29 0.001428

2005 41 28 0.001428

2005 41 27 0.001428

2005 41 26 0.000714 yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 41 25 0.00571

2005 41 24 0

2005 41 23 0.003569

2005 41 22 0.009279

2005 41 21 0.003569

2005 41 20 0.007852

2005 41 19 0.010707

2005 41 18 0.017131

2005 41 17 0.009993

2005 41 16 0.009279

2005 41 15 0.0207

2005 41 14 0.019986

2005 41 13 0.0207

2005 41 12 0.024982

2005 41 11 0.042827

2005 41 10 0.071378

2005 41 9 0.06424

2005 41 8 0.059957

2005 41 7 0.097787

2005 41 6 0.114918

2005 41 5 0.063526

2005 41 4 0.114918

2005 41 3 0.086367

2005 41 2 0.044254

2005 41 1 0.068522

2005 41 0 0

2005 42 30 0.010638

2005 42 29 0

2005 42 28 0

2005 42 27 0

2005 42 26 0.005319

2005 42 25 0

2005 42 24 0

2005 42 23 0

2005 42 22 0

2005 42 21 0.005319

2005 42 20 0

2005 42 19 0

2005 42 18 0

2005 42 17 0

2005 42 16 0.021277

2005 42 15 0.005319

2005 42 14 0.010638

2005 42 13 0.005319

### 15 

## yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 42 12 0.047872

2005 42 11 0.079787

2005 42 10 0.026596

2005 42 9 0.058511

2005 42 8 0.079787

2005 42 7 0.079787

2005 42 6 0.079787

2005 42 5 0.074468

2005 42 4 0.170213

2005 42 3 0.074468

2005 42 2 0.12766

2005 42 1 0.037234

2005 42 0 0

2005 43 30 0.000585

2005 43 29 0

2005 43 28 0

2005 43 27 0.001171

2005 43 26 0.001171

2005 43 25 0.005855

2005 43 24 0.002342

2005 43 23 0.007611

2005 43 22 0.008197

2005 43 21 0.005855

2005 43 20 0.008197

2005 43 19 0.014052

2005 43 18 0.007611

2005 43 17 0.009368

2005 43 16 0.009953

2005 43 15 0.011124

2005 43 14 0.010539

2005 43 13 0.044496

2005 43 12 0.050937

2005 43 11 0.088993

2005 43 10 0.104801

2005 43 9 0.067916

2005 43 8 0.100703

2005 43 7 0.058548

2005 43 6 0.050351

2005 43 5 0.052693

2005 43 4 0.052693

2005 43 3 0.0726

2005 43 2 0.049766

2005 43 1 0.059719

2005 43 0 0.042155 yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 51 30 0.014851

2005 51 29 0.002475

2005 51 28 0

2005 51 27 0

2005 51 26 0

2005 51 25 0.002475

2005 51 24 0.00495

2005 51 23 0.012376

2005 51 22 0

2005 51 21 0.00495

2005 51 20 0.00495

2005 51 19 0.00495

2005 51 18 0.007426

2005 51 17 0.012376

2005 51 16 0.024752

2005 51 15 0.066832

2005 51 14 0.044554

2005 51 13 0.027228

2005 51 12 0.044554

2005 51 11 0.027228

2005 51 10 0.044554

2005 51 9 0.044554

2005 51 8 0.059406

2005 51 7 0.09901

2005 51 6 0.032178

2005 51 5 0.071782

2005 51 4 0.128713

2005 51 3 0.071782

2005 51 2 0.094059

2005 51 1 0.04703

2005 51 0 0

2005 52 30 0.014851

2005 52 29 0.002475

2005 52 28 0

2005 52 27 0

2005 52 26 0

2005 52 25 0.002475

2005 52 24 0.00495

2005 52 23 0.012376

2005 52 22 0

2005 52 21 0.00495

2005 52 20 0.00495

2005 52 19 0.00495

2005 52 18 0.007426

### 16 

## yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 52 17 0.012376

2005 52 16 0.024752

2005 52 15 0.066832

2005 52 14 0.044554

2005 52 13 0.027228

2005 52 12 0.044554

2005 52 11 0.027228

2005 52 10 0.044554

2005 52 9 0.044554

2005 52 8 0.059406

2005 52 7 0.09901

2005 52 6 0.032178

2005 52 5 0.071782

2005 52 4 0.128713

2005 52 3 0.071782

2005 52 2 0.094059

2005 52 1 0.04703

2005 52 0 0

2005 53 30 0.096774

2005 53 29 0

2005 53 28 0

2005 53 27 0

2005 53 26 0.064516

2005 53 25 0.032258

2005 53 24 0.032258

2005 53 23 0.032258

2005 53 22 0.064516

2005 53 21 0.032258

2005 53 20 0.064516

2005 53 19 0.032258

2005 53 18 0

2005 53 17 0.032258

2005 53 16 0.064516

2005 53 15 0.032258

2005 53 14 0.193548

2005 53 13 0.096774

2005 53 12 0.064516

2005 53 11 0

2005 53 10 0

2005 53 9 0

2005 53 8 0

2005 53 7 0

2005 53 6 0.032258

2005 53 5 0 yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 53 4 0

2005 53 3 0

2005 53 2 0

2005 53 1 0

2005 53 0 0.032258

2005 54 30 0.155541

2005 54 29 0.007973

2005 54 28 0.012568

2005 54 27 0.014595

2005 54 26 0.023378

2005 54 25 0.021622

2005 54 24 0.02473

2005 54 23 0.024865

2005 54 22 0.026486

2005 54 21 0.028514

2005 54 20 0.023649

2005 54 19 0.017838

2005 54 18 0.023514

2005 54 17 0.027568

2005 54 16 0.032432

2005 54 15 0.037838

2005 54 14 0.032973

2005 54 13 0.034054

2005 54 12 0.036351

2005 54 11 0.045

2005 54 10 0.045811

2005 54 9 0.032297

2005 54 8 0.034595

2005 54 7 0.037027

2005 54 6 0.038378

2005 54 5 0.039054

2005 54 4 0.039595

2005 54 3 0.034595

2005 54 2 0.028784

2005 54 1 0.014865

2005 54 0 0.003514

2005 61 30 0.026394

2005 61 29 0.001795

2005 61 28 0.001969

2005 61 27 0.0027

2005 61 26 0.004162

2005 61 25 0.005771

2005 61 24 0.007714

2005 61 23 0.007951

### 17 

## yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 61 22 0.01355

2005 61 21 0.017698

2005 61 20 0.017692

2005 61 19 0.018667

2005 61 18 0.023951

2005 61 17 0.030517

2005 61 16 0.044041

2005 61 15 0.043611

2005 61 14 0.038558

2005 61 13 0.047786

2005 61 12 0.044426

2005 61 11 0.056475

2005 61 10 0.062624

2005 61 9 0.052544

2005 61 8 0.054525

2005 61 7 0.065875

2005 61 6 0.064946

2005 61 5 0.065997

2005 61 4 0.06129

2005 61 3 0.052723

2005 61 2 0.042316

2005 61 1 0.018436

2005 61 0 0.003296

2005 62 30 0.001821

2005 62 29 0

2005 62 28 0

2005 62 27 0.00091

2005 62 26 0.000759

2005 62 25 0.002731

2005 62 24 0.001517

2005 62 23 0.001972

2005 62 22 0.00349

2005 62 21 0.005159

2005 62 20 0.0044

2005 62 19 0.003945

2005 62 18 0.007131

2005 62 17 0.016083

2005 62 16 0.021393

2005 62 15 0.028827

2005 62 14 0.034593

2005 62 13 0.025338

2005 62 12 0.059172

2005 62 11 0.080413

2005 62 10 0.107419 yearid sourcetypeid ageid ageFraction

2005 62 9 0.075861

2005 62 8 0.04582

2005 62 7 0.047944

2005 62 6 0.099833

2005 62 5 0.090882

2005 62 4 0.057047

2005 62 3 0.112729

2005 62 2 0.017145

2005 62 1 0.038993

2005 62 0 0.006676

### 18 

## Road Type Distribution

Road type distribution is base d on the ODOT’s 2005 daily vehicle miles of travel (DVMT) by

functional classification (FC). Th ese inputs vary by county. A sa mple road type distribution

input for Cuyahoga County can be seen in Ta ble 12. Cuyahoga County does not contain rural

road types 2 and 3. The distributions for othe r areas can be found in the electronic input

submittals.

Table 12 – Road Type Distribution for Cuyahoga County

sourceTypeID roadTypeID roadTypeVMTFraction

11 1 0

11 2 0

11 3 0

11 4 0.4761

11 5 0.5239

21 1 0

21 2 0

21 3 0

21 4 0.4761

21 5 0.5239

31 1 0

31 2 0

31 3 0

31 4 0.4761

31 5 0.5239

32 1 0

32 2 0

32 3 0

32 4 0.4761

32 5 0.5239

41 1 0

41 2 0

41 3 0

41 4 0.4761

41 5 0.5239

42 1 0

42 2 0

42 3 0

42 4 0.4761

42 5 0.5239

43 1 0

43 2 0

### 19 

## sourceTypeID roadTypeID roadTypeVMTFraction

43 3 0

43 4 0.4761

43 5 0.5239

51 1 0

51 2 0

51 3 0

51 4 0.4761

51 5 0.5239

52 1 0

52 2 0

52 3 0

52 4 0.4761

52 5 0.5239

53 1 0

53 2 0

53 3 0

53 4 0.4761

53 5 0.5239

54 1 0

54 2 0

54 3 0

54 4 0.4761

54 5 0.5239

61 1 0

61 2 0

61 3 0

61 4 0.4761

61 5 0.5239

62 1 0

62 2 0

62 3 0

62 4 0.4761

62 5 0.5239

Vehicle Type VMT and VMT Fractions

VMT by MOVES vehicle types is subdivided into f our sections namely HPMS base year VMT,

monthly VMT fractions, daily VMT fractions and hourly VMT fractions. For NOACA’s

counties, HPMS base year VMT was derived by using the converter tool, US EPA’s AADVMT

Calculator_HPMS.xls. The converter take s average annual daily VMT (AADVMT) and

generates MOVES input data based on default factors. AADVMT is computed by using total

daily VMT obtained from travel demand mode l and fractioning it with the MOVES default

distance travelled by each source type to come up vehicle type VMTs. The same method was

### 20 

## used to generate for other analysis years. ODOT uses weigh in motion (WIM) data to develop

inputs for the counties it models. The inputs for each geographic area can be seen in the supplied

input files. Sample HPMS base year VMT for 2005 is provided in Table 13.

Table 13 – Yearly HPMS VMT for 2005

HPMS

VType ID Cuyahoga Lake Lorain Medina Portage Summit Ashtabula

TWP

10 32,922,024 6,679,430 7,643,257 6, 670,080 7,077,843 22,229,559 320,426

20 5,535,142,837 1,090,354,599 1,260,262,447 989,168,530 1,262,277 ,469 3,964,466,531 57,145,446

30 3,276,696,376 651,498,431 757,091,949 613,540,515 389,472,936 1,223,227,424 17,632,101

40 13,744,581 3,270,549 3,993,067 4, 965,027 3,980,932 12,503,013 180,224

50 206,032,254 44,685,476 52,797,748 54,841, 123 29,429,299 92,429,337 1,332,314

60 316,106,345 81,519,583 79,496,762 128,111, 534 69,870,561 219,444,226 3,163,159

### 21 

## Output Emission Factors

Table 14 shows the first record in a MOVES sample output (rate per distance) emission file for

year 2005. For any given month, day of week, hour of the day, pollutant, and process; the rate

per distance varies by road type, and speed bin. Rates per distan ce emissions are applied to link

and intrazonal VMT.

Table 14 – Sample Emission File (Rate per Distance) for year 2005

Heading

: MOVESScenarioI

D MOVESRunI

D yearID monthID dayID hourID

Record: Cuyahoga 1 2005 4 5 24

Heading

: linkID pollutantID processID sourceTypeI

D SCC fuelTypeID

Record: 990180516 117 10 0 0

Heading

: modelYearID roadTypeID avgSpeedBinI

D temperature relHumidit

y ratePerDistanc

e

Record: 0 5 16 43.5583 66 0.000879331



## Table 15 shows the first record in a MOVES sample output (rate pe r vehicle) emission file for

year 2005. The rate per vehicle varies for any co mbinations of month, da y of week, hour of the

day, pollutant, and process. Rates per vehicle em issions are applied to the vehicle souce type

population.

Table 15 – Sample Emission File (Rate per Vehicle) for year 2005

Heading: MOVESScenarioID MOVESRunID yearID monthID dayID

Record: Cuyahoga 1 2005 4 5

Heading: hourID zoneID pollutantID processID sourceTypeID

Record: 24 990180 115 90 0

Heading: SCC fuelTypeID modelYearID temperature ratePerVehicle

Record: 0 0 43.5583 0.0000446782



## All output files are available in the electronic submittal.

### 22 

# 4. Post Processing

Total emissions were computed with the aid of several custom programs by ODOT. The process

uses data on daily and directiona l traffic distributions as well as more up to date volume/delay

functions from the 2000 Highway Capacity Manual (HCM). This process, described below and

illustrated in Figure 4, also uses rewritten code able to handle the newer model network formats

and MOVES generated em ission factors.

The first step in the the process involves r unning ODOT postcms.exe to calculate hourly link

volumes based on the percentage of the daily vo lume (travel demand mode l output) determined

by a link’s facility and area type. Link speeds fro m the travel demand model are not used in the

analysis. The speeds are estimated as a post-pr ocess to the model based on HCM methods using

a link’s volume-to-capacity ratio and link group code. The daily to hourly volume conversion

percentages and speed tables can be seen in Appendix B.

The second step (mmoves.exe) uses a combin ation of the MOVES emission factors and the

hourly link volumes that are out put of the postcms.exe progra m. The hourly volumes are

multiplied by the MOVES emission factor fo r the corresponding hour of day, speed bin, and

roadtype to calculate emissions for every network link for each hour. The final link on road

vehicle emissions for the area is the su m of all individual link-hour emissions.

The third step, (mvehicle.exe), calculates vehicl e-based emissions for each source type for each

hour of the day. The vehicle source type is base d on a combination of local and default data.

The final vehicle emissions for each county are th e sum of all individual hourly emissions for all

vehicle types.

Intrazonal trips do not get loaded onto the networ k, so the fourth step in the process requires a

separate method to account for those trips that us e local roads to travel within a zone. The

mintra.exe program uses intrazonal trips to es timate VMT using the area in square miles and

intrazonal trips of each zone . The zone is assumed circular and th e radius of the circle is used as

the average trip length for these intrazonal trips. Intrazonal emissions are then calculated by

combining MOVES generated emissions with estim ated intrazonal VMT. The emission rates are

the same as those used to calculated link based emissions.

The final step is to summarize link, vehicle, a nd intrazonal emissions for each county, pollutant,

and analyzed year, and to multiply annual aver age daily emissions by 365 to produce an annual

estimate. Summary emissions for each pollutant , county, and scenario year in northeast Ohio

were previously displayed in tables 1-4.23Figure 4 – Emission Calculation ProcessMOVESTFMODOTCMAQNOACAAQODOTMMOVESODOTMVEHICLEODOTMINTRAEmission FactorRate/DistanceEmission FactorRate/Vehicle24HR NETSpeedCalculatorLNKGRPCMAQ NETCMAQ ReportHOURLY.CSVIntrazonal Trips24HRVehicle Trips4 PeriodsVehicle TripMatrices4 PeriodsAssigned NETVHTVMT4 CongestedSPEEDEMISSIONOUTPUTTon/dayTAZ Area (Sq.mi)2. ODOT’s CMAQ POST-PROCESSOR3. INTRASOZNAL TRIP CALCULATION4. ODOT’s MOVESPOST-PROCESSOR1. NOACA AQPOST-PROCESSORRamp FractionsAverageSpeed DistributionRoad TypeVMT fractionsVehicle TypeAnnual VMTsFuel supply &formulationI/M ProgramAge DistributionMeteorologyZone ActivitySource TypePopulationFINALEMISSIONTon/Year

### 24 

# 5. Multiple MPO Coordination Issues

AMATS, NOACA, ODOT, and OEPA have a long hi story of working together in air quality

issues. All parties have have had an opportunity to review and approve this summary document.

# Appendix A

Interagency Consultation Documentation

### ‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message

‐‐‐‐‐

From: Carolina Prado [mailto:Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us]

Sent: Thursday, October 21, 2010 9:00 AM

To: Jividen, Phyllis; Nino.Brunello@dot.state.oh.us ; Bill Davis

Cc: Jennifer Hunter

Subject: Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain area PM2.5 redesignation effort

Nino, Bill and Phyllis

,

Ohio EPA is starting to work on PM2.5 redesignations in all Ohio's

nonattainment areas, and Jennifer Hunter and I would like to have a small

conference call with you and start discussion on the mobile emission

modeling portion of the redesignation effort in the Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain

area.

Since historically, NOACA has modeled a portion of the area and ODOT and

AMATS another, it would be useful to agree and be consistent among what's

modeled and the assumptions used, as well as to have a sense of timing and

other inputs needed.

We would like to schedule a conference call on Monday October, 25 at 10:00

AM.

We will be calling you so please verify the following information:

Nino: (614) 752

‐ 5742

Bill: (216) 241

‐ 2414, Ext. 251

Phyllis: (330) 375

‐ 2436

Please let us know if this time/day will work for you ASAP so we can make

changes accordingly. The other available day we have is Friday October 29.

Thanks,

Carolina M. Prado

State Implementation Plan (SIP) Development Ohio EPA, Division of Air

Pollution Control 614

‐ 644

‐ 2310 Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us



# ***************************** ************************** ************************

‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message

‐‐‐‐‐

From: Carolina Prado [mailto:Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us]

Sent: Friday, October 29, 2010 11:05 AM

To: PJividen@akronohio.gov ; Leigh.Oesterling@dot.gov ;

Nino.Brunello@dot.state.oh.us ; Patricia Morris; Jennifer Hunter; B Davis

Subject: Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain area PM2.5 redesignation effort

Interagency Consultancy Group,

### On Monday, November 15, 2010 from 10:30 AM to 12:30PM, we will have an

Interagency Consultation Group call to agree on parameters and timing for

the PM2.5 redesignation for the Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain area PM2.5

nonattainment area. The Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain area includes the counties

of Ashtabula (partial), Lake, Cuyahoga, Lorain, Medina, Summit and

Portage. For the purpose of redesignations and maintenance plans we have

to include emissions/projections for all these areas.

As you all know we have to use MOVES to model our mobile emission for

PM2.5, NOx, and SO2, and to fulfill our redesignation/maintenance plan,

the following years will need mobile inventories

‐ 2005 base nonattainment

year, 2008 attainment year, 2015 interim (BUDGET) year and 2022

maintenance (BUDGET) year. During this call we would like to agree and be

consistent among what's modeled and the assumptions used, as well as to

have a sense of timing and other inputs needed.

Please call 614

‐ 387

‐ 7405

If you think I am forgetting somebody, please forward this email.

Thanks,

Carolina M. Prado

State Implementation Plan (SIP) Development Ohio EPA, Division of Air

Pollution Control 614

‐ 644

‐ 2310



# ***************************** ************************** ************************

‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message

‐‐‐‐‐

From: Carolina Prado [mailto:Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us]

Sent: Monday, December 20, 2010 12:43 PM

To: PJividen@akronohio.gov; Leigh.Oesterling@dot.gov; Dave Moore;

Nino.Brunello@dot.state.oh.us; PatriciaMorris; B Davis

Cc: Jennifer Hunter

Subject: RE: NEXT: Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain area PM2.5 redesignation effort

You are right.

This is our schedule:

1. ODOT is expected to submit all post

‐ processor information to NOACA (for

the 4 counties in its jurisdiction, Lake, Cuyahoga, Lorain and Medina) by

January 10, 2011.

2. ODOT and NOACA will submit the final mobile emission numbers (for Lake,

Cuyahoga, Lorain and Medina, Portage, Summit and Ashtabula

‐ partial

counties) to the rest of the IAC group by the end of January 2011

3. ODOT and NOACA will submit to IAC group in a document the final mobile

emission number for review and comment. February 1, 2011.

### 4. IAC group call on Feb 7, 2011, discuss final mobile emission numbers

for the 7 county area, make changes if needed, and propose budgets for

2015 and 2022.

Thanks

>>> B Davis <BDavis@mpo.noaca.org> 12/20/2010 12:35 PM >>>

I believe ODOT's deadline for providing NOACA with the post

‐ processor was

January 10th?

Bill Davis

NOACA

(216)

‐ 241

‐ 2414, Ext. 251



# ***************************** ************************** ************************

‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message

‐‐‐‐‐

From: Carolina Prado [mailto:Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us]

Sent: Monday, December 20, 2010 12:13 PM

To: PJividen@akronohio.gov; Leigh.Oesterling@dot.gov; Dave Moore;

Nino.Brunello@dot.state.oh.us; Patricia Morris; B Davis

Cc: Jennifer Hunter

Subject: NEXT: Cleveland

‐ Akron

‐ Lorain area PM2.5 redesignation effort

Thanks for all your input on today's call.

Our next call will be on February 7, 2011 from 11:00AM to 12:30PM EST.

Please call 614

‐ 387

‐ 7405

During the call we will discuss the final mobile emission numbers for the

7 county area, make changes if needed, and propose budgets for 2015 and

2022.

As discussed during today's call, ODOT is expected to submit all post

‐

processor information to NOACA (for the 4 counties in its jurisdiction,

Lake, Cuyahoga, Lorain and Medina) by January 1, 2011.

ODOT and NOACA will submit the final mobile emission numbers (for Lake,

Cuyahoga, Lorain and Medina, Portage, Summit and Ashtabula

‐ partial

counties) to the rest of the IAC group by the end of January 2011 so that

by the Feb 7, 2011 meeting, we all had time to review the numbers.

Thanks,

Carolina M. Prado

State Implementation Plan (SIP) Development

Ohio EPA, Division of Air Pollution Control



## 614-644-2310



# ***************************** ************************** ************************

### ‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message

‐‐‐‐‐

From: Carolina Prado [mailto:Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us]

Sent: Wednesday, May 11, 2011 12:42 PM

To: Nino.Brunello@dot.state.oh.us; Chandra Parasa; NGILL@morpc.org; B

Davis; E Kang; Ana Ramirez

Cc: Jennifer Hunter

Subject: Clarification: Mobile emission estimate

Importance: High

** High Priority **

Hi everybody,

Thanks for reworking the post

‐ processor information and thanks for

committing to a fast turn around. We really appreciate all your effort!

I just want to clarify a couple of issues so we don't waste more time.

For all our redesignation documents we are stating that "...Mobile

source emissions were calculated from MOVES2010

‐ produced emission

factors. Only PM2.5 and NOx necessitate emissions inventory analysis. As

documented in Ohio EPA’s attainment demonstration SIP, Ohio EPA in

consultation with U.S. EPA determined mobile sources are insignificant

contributors for SO2. Consistent with Ohio EPA’s attainment

demonstration, Ohio EPA continues to consider mobile source SO2 to be an

insignificant contributor to fine particles for this nonattainment

area...."

However we still need to show SO2 emission estimations per county, so

that USEPA can agree with us that SO2 is indeed insignificant.

So we will need SO2 mobile emission as well (not only PM2.5 and NOx),

just like what you did previously for Dayton and Columbus, for example.

We also need the Annual VMT.

We should have something like this for every county:

Hamilton County, Ohio Emissions Estimations for On

‐ Road Mobile Sources

2005200820152021PM2.5 (tpy)1,222.0201,080.540826.00571.48NOx

(tpy)31,127.0927,020.9315,925.199,530.16SO2

(tpy)88.8598.3094.43100.82Annual

VMT7,241,536,8127,421,012,5947,630,239,6507,811,745,310

Please let us know if you have any question!

Thanks!!

Carolina

Carolina M. Prado

State Implementation Plan (SIP) Development

Ohio EPA, Division of Air Pollution Control

614

‐ 644

‐ 2310

Carolina.Prado@epa.state.oh.us

# Appendix B

Post Processing Default DistributionsHOUR 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 2021 22 23PCTADTURB FWY 0.9 0.6 0.5 0.6 0.9 2.2 5.2 7.3 6.4 5.2 4.9 5.1 5.3 5.5 6.1 7.2 8.0 7.9 5.8 4.2 3.42.9 2.2 1.5URB ART 0.7 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.6 1.5 3.5 5.7 5.5 5.1 5.3 6.2 6.5 6.4 6.8 7.6 8.2 8.1 6.2 4.8 4.03.0 1.9 1.3RUR FWY 1.4 1.1 0.9 1.0 1.3 2.2 3.7 5.2 5.4 5.4 5.6 5.6 5.7 6.0 6.5 7.1 7.5 7.0 5.6 4.5 3.83.2 2.5 2.0RUR ART 0.8 0.5 0.4 0.5 1.0 2.4 4.8 6.2 5.5 5.3 5.5 5.8 6.0 6.0 6.7 7.6 8.1 7.7 5.6 4.2 3.52.8 1.9 1.3PCTADT TRKURB FWY 2.1 1.9 1.8 2.0 2.4 3.0 3.9 4.6 5.3 6.0 6.3 6.4 6.4 6.4 6.3 5.8 5.2 4.6 4.1 3.7 3.43.1 2.8 2.4URB ART 1.1 0.9 1.0 1.2 1.6 2.3 3.9 5.9 6.9 6.7 7.1 7.6 7.4 7.2 7.4 7.2 6.0 5.0 3.7 2.8 2.31.9 1.5 1.3RUR FWY 2.6 2.2 2.1 2.3 2.6 3.1 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.1 5.6 5.8 5.8 5.8 5.8 5.6 5.3 4.9 4.6 4.3 4.03.8 3.5 3.1RUR ART 1.5 1.3 1.4 1.6 2.2 3.0 4.2 5.3 6.1 6.7 7.0 7.1 7.0 6.9 6.8 6.3 5.5 4.6 3.8 3.1 2.62.3 2.1 1.7PCTDIRURB FWY 38 40 40 46 56 64 70 70 68 62 58 52 52 52 50 46 38 38 46 52 4642 42 40URB ART 44 46 44 48 54 62 66 68 64 56 54 52 50 50 50 46 40 38 46 52 4846 46 46RUR FWY 44 46 48 54 60 68 68 64 58 54 52 50 50 52 52 48 42 40 44 48 4844 46 44RUR ART 40 42 44 48 58 66 72 68 60 56 54 50 50 50 50 46 40 38 46 50 4644 44 44LOS E VC 0 0.625 1.25 1.875 2.5 3.125 3.75 4.375 5 5.625 6.25 6.875 7.5 8.125 8.75 9.375 10 10.625 11.25 11.875 12.513.125 13.75 14.375SPEEDVCcurve1 75 75 75 75 75 75 74.9 74.8 74.6 74.2 73.5 72.3 70.5 67.8 64.2 59.5 54 47.7 41.2 34.9 28.923.7 19.2 15.5curve2 70 70 70 70 70 70 70 69.9 69.8 69.6 69.2 68.4 67.1 65.1 62.2 58.2 53 47 40.5 33.9 27.722.2 17.6 13.8curve3 65 65 65 65 65 65 65 65 65 64.9 64.8 64.4 63.8 62.6 60.5 57 52 45.4 37.8 29.9 22.716.7 12.1 8.6curve4 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 59.9 59.8 59.6 59.1 58.2 56.7 54.3 50.8 46.1 40.3 33.8 27.321.3 16.2 12.2curve5 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 54.9 54.7 54.3 53.6 52.3 50 46.5 41.5 35.3 28.521.9 16.1 11.5curve6 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 60 59.9 59.8 59.7 59.4 59.1 58.5 57.7 56.5 55 53.1 50.7 47.9 44.741.1 37.3 33.4curve7 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 55 54.9 54.9 54.7 54.5 54.2 53.8 53.1 52.2 50.9 49.3 47.3 44.9 42.139 35.7 32.2curve8 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 50 49.9 49.9 49.8 49.6 49.4 49 48.5 47.7 46.7 45.4 43.8 41.8 39.536.8 33.9 30.9curve9 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 45 44.9 44.8 44.7 44.4 44.1 43.6 43 42.1 40.9 39.4 37.6 35.533.1 30.5 27.8curve10 50 50 50 50 49.9 49.8 49.7 49.4 49 48.4 47.5 46.5 45.1 43.5 41.7 39.6 37.3 34.9 32.4 29.8 27.324.9 22.6 20.4curve11 50 50 50 50 50 49.9 49.7 49.4 48.9 48 46.7 44.9 42.5 39.6 36.2 32.6 28.7 25 21.4 18.2 15.312.9 10.8 9curve12 50 50 50 50 50 49.9 49.8 49.6 49.1 48.2 46.8 44.5 41.4 37.5 32.9 28 23.1 18.7 14.9 11.8 9.27.2 5.7 4.5curve13 40 40 40 40 40 40 39.9 39.8 39.5 39.2 38.6 37.8 36.7 35.3 33.5 31.4 29 26.4 23.7 21.1 18.516.1 13.9 12curve14 40 40 40 40 40 39.9 39.8 39.6 39.1 38.5 37.5 36.1 34.3 32.1 29.4 26.5 23.5 20.5 17.7 15.1 12.810.7 9 7.6curve15 40 40 40 40 40 39.9 39.7 39.4 38.8 37.9 36.5 34.7 32.3 29.5 26.4 23.2 20 17 14.3 11.9 9.98.2 6.8 5.6curve16 35 35 35 35 35 34.9 34.8 34.5 34 33.2 32.1 30.5 28.5 26.1 23.5 20.6 17.9 15.2 12.8 10.7 8.97.4 6.1 5.1curve17 35 35 35 35 35 34.9 34.7 34.4 33.9 33.1 32 30.3 28.3 25.8 23.1 20.3 17.5 14.9 12.5 10.4 8.67.2 5.9 4.9curve18 35 35 35 35 35 34.9 34.6 34.2 33.5 32.4 30.9 28.8 26.3 23.4 20.4 17.4 14.6 12.1 9.9 8.1 6.65.4 4.4 3.6curve19 30 30 30 30 30 29.9 29.8 29.5 29 28.2 27.1 25.6 23.7 21.5 19.1 16.6 14.2 12 10 8.3 6.85.6 4.6 3.8curve20 30 30 30 30 30 29.9 29.7 29.4 28.9 28.1 26.9 25.3 23.4 21.1 18.6 16.1 13.6 11.4 9.5 7.8 6.45.3 4.3 3.6curve21 30 30 30 30 30 29.9 29.7 29.3 28.7 27.7 26.2 24.4 22.1 19.6 17 14.4 12 9.9 8.1 6.6 5.44.4 3.6 2.9VC RATIO TO LOS CONVERSION (VALUE SHOWN IS LOWER LIMIT FOR THAT LOS)(URBAN ROADS USE SPEED BREAKS BELOW FOR LOS DETERMINATION)(ALL USE THE BASE VC'S TO DETERMINE EXCEEDANCE)BASE RUR2 FWYA 0.00 0.00 0.00B 0.30 0.00 0.25C 0.50 0.10 0.40D 0.70 0.30 0.60E 0.90 0.50 0.80F 1.00 1.00 1.00F+ 1.10 1.10 1.10F++ 1.30 1.30 1.30SPEED VC RATIO BREAKS FOR URBAN STREETS (HIGHEST SPEED FOR GIVEN LOS & FF SPEED)FFS B C D E F>47 42. 34. 27. 21. 16.>37 35. 28. 22. 17. 13.>32 30. 24. 18. 14. 10.<33 25. 19. 13. 9. 7.LEVEL OF SERVICE THRESHOLD BY AREANUM LOS DEFINITION1 F CINCINNATI,CLEVELAND,COLUMBUS CENTRAL MPO COUNTIES (CUY,FRA,HAM)2 E OTHER TMA MPOS (AKRON,CANTON,DAYTON,TOLEDO,YOUNGSTOWN + NON-CENTRAL COUNTIES FROM 1)3 E OTHER MPOS & PARTS OF AREAS 1 & 2 OUTSIDE URBANIZED AREA4 E RURAL NON MPO COUNTIESPEAK SPREADING MODEL INFO (SET MAX ITERATIONS TO 0 TO DISABLE PEAK SPREADING)MAX VC RATIO FWY: 1.30MAX VC RATIO ART: 1.30MAX ITERATIONS : 1000TRUCK PCE: 2.00AQ SEASON FACTOR: 1.00MODEL CLASS PARAMETERS (MAX 4 CLASSES, HOURS 0-23 W/ NO OVERLAP IN CLASS, ALLOCATE ENTIRE CLASS AS TRUCK(1) OR NOT(0))CLS TRK 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0CLS BEG 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0CLS END 23 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0CLS NUM 1 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0

### 1



## Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM2.5, and Regional Haze:

Final Technical Support Document ( Supplement ), September 12, 2008

The purpose of this paper is to summarize a new modeling analysis performed by the Lake

Michigan Air Dir ectors Consorti um (LADCO) to address the effect of the recent court decision

vacat ing EPA’s Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). This new modeling is intended to supplem ent

the LADCO Technical Support Document (“ Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM2.5,

and Regional Haze: Final Technical Support Document”, April 25, 2008) , which summarizes the

air quality analyses conducted by LADCO and its contractors to support the development of

State Implementation Plans for ozone, PM2.5, and regional haze in the States of Illinoi s, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin

.

Compared to the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1), the new modeling shows similar

results for ozone, but much more nonattainment for PM2.5 and higher visibility levels for

regional haze. Specifically, the new modeling shows:

Ozone : Attainment of the 0.08 ppm standard by 2009 everywhere in the region, except

Holland, MI , and n onattainment of the 0.075 ppm standard through at least 2018.

PM2.5 : Widespread nonattainment of annual (15 ug/m 3 

### ) and daily (35 ug/m 3 

### ) standards.

Haze : Higher visibility levels on the 20% worst visibility days in 2018 in Class I areas in

the eastern U.S., resulting in most areas being above the glide path.

Background : On July 11, 2008, the U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit v acated EPA’s CAIR

rule (cite). The reductions in NOx and SO2 emissions associated with this rule were a key part

of the LADCO States’ attainment demonstrations for ozone and PM2.5 and the reasonable

progress determinations for regional haze . LADCO’s prev ious modeling (Round 5.1) relied on

EGU emission projections from EPA’s IPM3.0 analysis, which assumed implementation of

Phases I and II of CAIR. For this new modeling, alternative EGU emission projections were

developed , which did not rely on CAIR (or IP M).

Model Set

- Up : The new modeling was performed consistent with LADCO’s previous modeling

(Round 5.1):

Model Version: CAMx v4.50beta_deposition

Future Years: 2009, 2012, 2018

Runs: (a) Ozone : Summer 2005 meteorology with 12 km grids

(b) PM2.5 an d haze : F ull year 2005 meteorology with 36 km grids



### Emission Scenarios: The new modeling assumed the same set of “on the books” controls as

in LADCO’s previous modeling (Round 5.1) for all sectors, except EGUs. In light of the CAIR

decision, three new E GU scenarios were prepared:

### 2

Scenario A: 2007 CEM

- based emissions w ere projected for all states in the modeling domain

based on EIA growth rates by state (NERC region) and fuel type. The assumed growth rates for

the Midwest States were: MAIN (IL, IA, MO, WI): 8.8% (2007

- 2018); ECAR (IN, KY, MI, OH):

13.5% (2007

- 2018); and MAPP (MN): 15.1% (2007

- 2018). No control w as applied. The annual

emissions w ere temporalized based on profiles derived from 2004

- 2006 CEM data. (Note, these

are the same temporal prof iles used in R ound 5.1 .)

Scenario B. Scenario A emissions for the LADCO States and select neighboring states (e.g.,

MN, IA, MO, KY, TN, and WV) w ere adjusted by applying legally enforceable controls (i.e.,

emission reductions required by a Consent Decree , state rule, or permit). Only those legally

enforceable controls identified (and justified) by the States w ere applied. The States also

supplied the appropriate control factors. A table summarizing the Scenario B con trols is provided

in Appendix I.

Sc enario C. For the years 2009 and 2012, Scenario A emissions for all states w ere adjusted by

applying all planned SO2 and NOx controls based on the July 10 CAMD list (i.e., 9 0 % reduction

for scrubbers, 9 5 % reduction for SCRs). Because the July 10 CAMD list only includes controls

generally out to 2011, additional SO2 and NOx controls for the year 2018 w ere assumed for all

BART

- eligible EGUs in the five LADCO State plus MN, IA, MO, KY, TN, and MO list (i.e., 9 0 %

reduction for scrubbers, 9 5 % reduction for SCRs )

. 1 

### A ll Scenario B controls we re included in

Scenario C. A table summarizing the Scenario C controls is provided in Appendix II.



### Table 1 and Figure 1 provide a summary of the 5

- state regional NOx and SO2 emissions for

each scenario and future year. (No te, the CAIR emissions included here are based on EPA’s

IPM3.0 modeling.) Several comments on the emissions should be noted:

Summer NOx

• There is ll ittle difference between the three alternative scenarios and CAIR . T his

suggests that summer ozone concen trations for the alternative scenarios are

likely to be similar to those predicted with CAIR (i.e., Round 5.1).

Annual NOx:

• There is a s ignificant change in emissions between scenarios , mostly during the

non

- summer months.

• Scenario B reflects application of NOx controls in several states (e.g., IL,OH, WI).

• Because there are relatively few SCRs (in the LADCO States) on the CAMD list,

Scenario C results in only a small emissions decrease compared to Scenario B

.

• Assumed BART controls result in a significant em issions decrease.

Annual SO2

• There is a s ignificant change in emissions between scenarios

.

• Scenario B reflects application of SO2 controls in several states (e.g., I L,OH, WI).

• Because there are several FGD s (in the LADCO States) on the CAMD list,

Scenario C results in a large emissions decrease compared to Scenario B

.

• Assumed BART controls result in a significant emissions decrease (i.e., even

lower emissions than t he IPM

- estimated CAIR emissions).

1 

### A subsequent analysis was conducted with the following inventory changes: (a) 95% reduction for

scrubbers, 90% redcuction for SCRs (consistent with EPA’s default assumptions for IPM), and (b)

revisions provided for a few plants in Indiana and Minnesota. The changes resulted in a relatively small

difference in the regioinal NOx and SO2 emissions (e.g., about a 2% NOx increase and about a 1

- 2%

decrease in SO2). To assess the impact of the chan ges, PM2.5 modleing was conducted with the new

Scenario B and Scenario C emissions for 2012. The modeling showed little change in the predicted

PM2.5 concentrations.

### 3 

### Figure 1. Regional NOx and SO2 Emissions

Summe r NO x Emi ss ions

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000

2005 2007 200

9A 200 9B 200 9C

200 9 C AIR 201 2A 201 2B 201 2C

201 2 C AIR 201 8A 201 8B 201 8C

201 8BART

201 8 C AIR



### Annu al NO x Emi ss ions

0 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 1,000,000

2005 2007 200

9A 200 9B 200 9C

200 9 C AIR 201 2A 201 2B 201 2C

201 2 C AIR 201 8A 201 8B 201 8C

201 8BART

201 8 C AIR



### Annu al SO2 Emi ss ions

0 500,000 1,000,000 1,500,000 2,000,000 2,500,000 3,000,000

2005 2007 200

9A 200 9B 200 9C

200 9 C AIR 201 2A 201 2B 201 2C

201 2 C AIR 201 8A 201 8B 201 8C

201 8BART

201 8 C AIR

### 4 

### Table 1. Regional NOx and SO2 Emissions



# Summer NOx Emissions (TPD)

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C 2010

CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C 2012

CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C 2018 C

BART 2018

CAIR

IL 305 305 311 311 311 275 340 236 236 266 333 227 227 219 224

I N 393 393 376 376 374 384 393 393 390 368 410 386 383 292 264

MI 393 393 350 350 350 242 366 366 366 229 377 377 377 260 243

OH 408 408 395 355 335 285 423 351 351 290 431 366 366 230 290

WI 413 413 167 160 160 238 184 170 170 177 183 168 168 168 17 7

1,912 1,912 1,599 1,552 1,530 1,424 1,706 1,516 1,513 1,330 1,734 1,524 1,521 1,169 1,198



# Annual NOx Emissions (TPY)

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C 2010

CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C 2012

CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C 2018 C

BART 2018

CAIR

IL 126,786 121,006 124,917 124,917 124,917 83,224 137,438 81,989 81,989 82,248 135,983 79,771 79,771 63,590 69,958

IN 214,727 203,493 203,776 203,776 201,947 133,188 212,790 212,790 210,877 125,541 221,950 212,805 210,81 0 177,027 90,415

MI 120,332 112,484 112,478 112,478 112,478 83,117 117,621 117,621 117,621 77,897 122,447 122,447 122,447 89,444 79,543

OH 255,554 240,351 240,016 173,071 164,911 94,346 251,065 172,514 172,514 97,679 261,644 179,737 179,737 125,762 95, 678

WI 71,414 54,582 56,540 54,065 54,065 53,032 62,266 57,759 57,759 56,480 61,812 56,952 56,952 56,952 56,158

788,812 731,917 737,727 668,307 658,317 446,908 781,179 642,673 640,760 439,845 803,837 651,712 649,717 512,774 391,752



# Annual SO2 Emissions (TPY)

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C 2010

CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C 2012

CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C 2018 C

BART 2018

CAIR

IL 326,598 273,467 281,028 281,028 281,028 295,516 309,209 196,238 194,746 267,1 10 305,364 106,638 105,152 82,351 275,716

IN 866,964 722,301 721,252 721,252 619,486 374,335 754,323 754,323 558,567 379,144 786,551 764,065 559,945 426,695 359,915

MI 350,694 343,487 343,140 343,140 315,326 227,296 358,879 358,879 301,062 233,204 373, 964 373,964 313,677 178,680 242,853

OH 1,100,510 960,820 959,466 959,466 693,438 427,145 1,003,633 897,099 572,807 370,532 1,045,945 819,770 481,623 333,740 315,560

WI 181,426 137,562 142,007 142,007 133,738 139,181 156,659 144,818 133,592 139,203 155, 818 144,027 132,849 77,214 127,073

2,826,192 2,437,638 2,446,892 2,446,892 2,043,017 1,463,473 2,582,703 2,351,356 1,760,775 1,389,192 2,667,641 2,208,463 1,593,245 1,098,679 1,321,116

### 5



### Modeling Results: Several tables summarizing the modeling result s are provided:

Table 2

- future year ozone and PM2.5 concentrations for key monitors in the

LADCO region

Table 3

- number of monitoring sites greater than the National Ambient Air Quality

Standards (NNAQS)

Table 4

–

visibility levels fo r Class I areas in the eastern U.S.

Note, given that Scenario B and BART controls were only applied in an 11

- state Midwest

region, the validity of the results for other Class I areas in the eastern U.S. may be

questionable. The Scenario C controls, on the other hand, cover all states and are, thus,

likely valid in other Class I areas.

Spatial plots of the future year ozone and PM2.5 concentrations are provided in Figures 2

– 4.

Based on these results, the following key findings should be noted:

Ozone

• There is little change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1 with CAIR)

• The modeling shows a ttainment of the 0.08 ppm (85 ppb) standard by 2009,

except Holland. (Note, Holland does meet this standard by 2012.)

• The modeling shows nonattainm ent of the 0.075 ppm (75 ppb) standard through

2018.

PM2.5

- Annual

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• The modeling shows extensive non atta inment of the annual standard.

PM2.5

- Daily

• There is a signif icant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• Th e modeling shows extensive nonattainment of the daily standard.

Haze

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• T he modeling shows higher vis ibility levels in 2018 for the 20% worst visibility

days (average about 0.5 deciviews for the northern Class I areas ). The resulting

visibility levels in the northern Class I areas (except Voyageurs) a re above t he

glide path.2005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Site Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen.C-BART

Lake Michigan Area

Chiwaukee 550590019 84.7 82.2 82.2 82.0 82.3 81.1 80.8 80.6 80.9 77.2 77.2 77.0 76.0 76.2

Racine 551010017 80.3 77.8 77.8 77.5 77.5 76.6 76.2 76.1 76.1 72.9 72.3 72.1 71.1 71.2

Milwaukee-Bayside 550890085 82.7 79.9 79.9 79.7 79.8 78.5 78.0 78.0 78.0 74.3 73.6 73.4 72.4 72.7

Harrington Beach 550890009 83.3 80.1 80.1 79.9 80.1 78.6 78.1 78.0 78.3 73.9 73.2 73.1 72.2 72.5

Manitowoc 550710007 85.0 80.8 80.8 80.7 80.8 79.0 78.5 78.4 78.6 73.9 73.2 73.1 72.0 72.5

Sheboygan 551170006 88.0 84.1 84.0 83.9 84.0 82.2 81.7 81.5 81.8 76.9 76.0 75.9 74.8 75.4

Kewaunee 550610002 82.7 78.2 78.2 78.0 78.1 76.4 75.9 75.7 75.9 71.3 70.7 70.5 69.4 69.9

Door County 550290004 88.7 84.1 84.1 83.9 83.9 82.0 81.4 81.3 81.5 76.5 75.6 75.5 74.2 74.7

Hammond 180892008 77.7 76.2 76.2 76.0 75.4 75.6 75.3 75.2 74.6 73.2 72.7 72.6 71.7 71.6

Whiting 180890030 79.3 77.8 77.8 77.7 77.0 77.2 76.9 76.8 76.2 74.8 74.3 74.2 73.2 73.1

Michigan City 180910005 77.0 74.5 74.5 74.3 73.9 73.3 72.9 72.8 72.5 69.7 69.2 69.1 68.1 68.1

Ogden Dunes 181270020 78.3 76.3 76.3 76.2 75.6 75.5 75.1 75.0 74.5 72.9 72.3 72.1 71.2 70.8

Holland 260050003 90.0 85.7 85.7 85.5 85.3 83.5 83.1 82.9 82.8 78.2 77.5 77.3 76.0 76.1

Jenison 261390005 82.0 76.8 76.8 76.7 76.0 75.1 74.6 74.5 74.5 70.2 69.6 69.5 67.9 68.7

Muskegon 261210039 85.0 80.6 80.6 80.5 80.5 78.6 78.2 78.1 78.0 73.5 72.8 72.8 71.5 71.9

Indianapolis Area

Noblesville 189571001 82.7 78.3 78.3 78.1 78.1 76.1 75.9 75.7 75.6 70.2 69.9 69.8 68.9 68.7

Fortville 180590003 78.0 74.1 74.1 73.9 73.9 71.9 71.8 71.7 71.4 66.7 66.5 66.3 65.4 65.1

Fort B. Harrison 180970050 78.7 75.4 75.3 75.2 75.1 73.8 73.6 73.6 73.2 70.6 70.3 70.2 69.3 69.1

Detroit Area

New Haven 260990009 86.0 82.4 82.3 82.1 81.4 81.4 81.2 81.1 80.2 78.1 77.8 77.7 76.5 76.1

Warren 260991003 84.0 82.4 82.3 82.2 81.3 82.1 81.8 81.7 80.7 79.7 79.4 79.3 78.0 77.6

Port Huron 261470005 82.7 78.2 78.2 78.1 77.5 76.5 76.3 76.2 75.5 72.6 72.5 72.3 70.9 70.9

Cleveland Area

Ashtabula 390071001 89.0 84.2 84.1 83.9 83.4 82.0 81.8 81.6 81.0 76.8 76.5 76.4 74.8 75.1

Geauga 390550004 79.3 75.8 75.8 75.6 74.7 74.0 73.8 73.7 72.7 69.5 69.2 69.1 67.6 67.3

Eastlake 390850003 86.3 83.1 83.1 82.9 81.9 81.8 81.6 81.5 80.5 78.2 78.0 77.8 76.5 76.2

Akron 391530020 83.7 79.1 79.1 79.0 78.1 76.9 76.7 76.6 75.6 70.9 70.6 70.4 68.7 68.7

Cincinnati Area

Wilmington 390271002 82.3 77.3 77.4 77.1 77.5 75.3 75.2 74.8 74.9 70.1 69.9 69.5 67.1 68.3

Sycamore 390610006 84.7 81.5 81.4 81.1 81.9 80.4 80.2 79.8 80.3 76.4 76.0 75.7 73.5 74.6

Lebanon 391650007 87.7 82.8 82.8 82.4 83.0 80.8 80.7 80.3 80.7 75.4 75.1 74.8 72.6 74.2

Columbus Area

London 390970007 79.7 75.0 75.0 74.8 75.0 73.0 72.8 72.7 72.6 68.1 67.8 67.6 65.9 66.3

New Albany 390490029 86.3 82.1 82.1 81.9 81.8 80.2 80.0 79.9 79.6 74.7 74.3 74.2 73.3 73.0

Franklin 290490028 80.3 76.7 76.6 76.5 75.9 75.1 74.9 74.8 74.1 70.5 70.2 70.1 70.2 69.0

St. Louis Area

W. Alton (MO) 291831002 86.3 81.1 81.2 81.1 81.0 80.0 79.9 79.9 78.6 76.9 76.8 76.7 74.2 74.9

Orchard (MO) 291831004 87.0 82.1 82.1 82.0 82.0 80.9 80.8 80.7 80.0 77.7 77.6 77.4 75.2 76.2

Sunset Hills (MO) 291890004 82.3 79.2 79.2 79.1 78.7 78.3 78.1 78.1 77.1 75.3 75.2 75.1 73.0 73.9

Arnold (MO) 290990012 82.3 77.8 77.8 77.7 77.2 76.7 76.6 76.5 75.6 73.6 73.4 73.4 71.3 72.0

Margaretta (MO) 295100086 83.0 79.8 79.8 79.7 79.3 78.8 78.7 78.6 77.9 75.7 75.6 75.5 73.7 74.4

Maryland Heights (MO) 291890014 87.3 85.4 85.4 85.3 84.0 84.3 84.1 84.0 81.7 81.1 80.9 80.8 78.4 78.1 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR 

# Table 2a. Ozone Modeling Results

2009 2012 20182005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Site Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen.C-BART

Illinois

Chicago - Washington HS 170310022 15.2 14.9 14.8 14.5 14.1 14.8 14.7 14.2 14.0 15.0 14.6 14.2 13.7 13.9

Chicago - Mayfair 170310052 15.8 15.1 15.1 14.8 14.4 15.1 14.9 14.5 14.2 15.1 14.7 14.3 13.7 13.9

Chicago - Springfield 170310057 15.0 14.6 14.6 14.3 13.9 14.6 14.4 14.0 13.8 14.8 14.4 14.0 13.4 13.7

Chicago - Lawndale 170310076 14.9 14.5 14.5 14.2 13.8 14.5 14.3 13.9 13.7 14.7 14.3 13.9 13.3 13.6

Blue Island 170312001 14.8 14.4 14.4 14.0 13.7 14.4 14.2 13.8 13.6 14.5 14.1 13.7 13.2 13.4

Summit 170313301 15.2 14.9 14.9 14.6 14.2 14.9 14.7 14.3 14.0 15.0 14.6 14.3 13.7 13.9

Cicero 170316005 15.5 15.1 15.1 14.8 14.4 15.1 14.9 14.5 14.3 15.2 14.9 14.4 13.9 14.2

Granite City 171191007 16.7 16.3 16.2 15.9 15.1 16.1 16.0 15.3 14.9 15.9 15.6 14.9 14.2 14.3

E. St. Louis 171630010 15.6 15.2 15.2 14.8 14.1 15.0 14.9 14.3 13.9 14.9 14.6 14.0 13.3 13.4

Indiana

Jeffersonville 180190005 16.4 15.8 15.7 14.8 13.8 15.8 15.6 14.5 13.7 16.0 15.5 14.3 13.7 13.4

Jasper 180372001 15.2 14.3 14.2 13.4 12.4 14.2 14.0 13.0 12.2 14.3 13.9 12.8 12.1 11.8

Gary 180890031 15.6 13.9 13.9 13.5 13.0 13.8 13.6 13.1 12.8 13.7 13.4 12.9 12.3 12.4

Indy-Washington Park 180970078 15.3 14.4 14.4 13.6 12.8 14.3 14.2 13.2 12.6 14.3 13.9 12.9 12.2 12.0

Indy-W 18th Street 180970081 16.0 15.1 15.1 14.3 15.0 14.9 13.9 15.0 14.6 13.5 12.8

Indy- Michigan Street 180970083 15.9 15.0 15.0 14.2 13.4 14.9 14.8 13.8 13.1 14.9 14.5 13.5 12.8 12.6

Michigan

Allen Park 261630001 14.5 11.0 14.0 13.5 13.0 14.0 13.8 13.2 12.8 13.9 13.6 13.0 12.4 12.4

Southwest HS 261630015 15.9 15.3 15.3 14.8 14.2 15.2 15.0 14.4 13.9 15.1 14.8 14.1 13.5 13.5

Linwood 261630016 14.6 14.1 14.1 13.6 13.1 14.0 13.9 13.3 12.8 13.9 13.6 13.0 12.5 12.5

Dearborn 261630033 17.5 17.0 17.0 16.4 15.8 16.9 16.7 16.0 15.5 16.8 16.4 15.7 15.1 15.1

Wyandotte 261630036 14.7 14.2 14.1 13.6 13.1 14.1 13.9 13.3 12.8 14.0 13.7 13.0 12.4 12.5

Ohio

Middletown - Bonita 390170003 16.2 15.3 15.2 14.3 13.5 15.2 15.0 13.9 13.2 15.2 14.8 13.7 13.0 12.8

Fairfield 390170016 15.8 15.1 15.0 14.1 13.1 15.1 14.9 13.7 12.9 15.2 14.7 13.5 12.8 12.5

Cleveland-28th Street 390350027 15.4 14.9 14.9 14.3 13.5 14.7 14.5 13.9 13.2 14.6 14.2 13.5 12.8 12.7

Cleveland-St. Tikhon 390350038 17.4 16.7 16.7 16.0 15.2 16.5 16.3 15.6 14.8 16.3 16.0 15.2 14.4 14.3

Cleveland-Broadway 390350045 16.5 15.9 15.8 15.2 14.4 15.6 15.5 14.8 14.0 15.5 15.1 14.4 13.6 13.5

Cleveland-GT Craig 390350060 17.1 16.5 16.4 15.8 15.0 16.3 16.1 15.4 14.6 16.1 15.7 15.0 14.2 14.1

Newburg Hts - Harvard Ave 390350065 16.0 15.4 15.3 14.7 14.0 15.2 15.0 14.3 13.6 15.1 14.7 14.0 13.2 13.1

Columbus - Fairgrounds 390490024 15.3 14.6 14.5 13.7 12.9 14.4 14.1 13.2 12.6 14.2 13.8 12.8 12.2 12.0

Columbus - Ann Street 390490025 15.1 14.4 14.3 13.5 12.7 14.2 13.9 13.1 12.4 14.1 13.6 12.6 12.0 11.9

Cincinnati - Seymour 390610014 17.3 16.6 16.5 15.5 14.5 16.5 16.3 15.1 14.3 16.6 16.2 14.9 14.2 13.8

Cincinnati - Taft Ave 390610040 15.5 14.8 14.7 13.8 12.8 14.8 14.6 13.4 12.6 14.9 14.5 13.2 12.5 12.2

Cincinnati - 8th Ave 390610042 16.9 12.0 16.1 15.0 14.0 16.1 15.9 14.7 13.8 16.2 15.7 14.4 13.7 13.4

Sharonville 390610043 15.6 14.9 14.8 13.9 12.9 14.9 14.7 13.5 12.7 14.9 14.5 13.3 12.6 12.3

Norwood 390617001 16.2 15.5 15.4 14.4 13.4 15.4 15.2 14.0 13.2 15.5 15.1 13.8 13.1 12.8

St. Bernard 390618001 17.6 16.8 16.7 15.7 14.7 16.7 16.5 15.3 14.4 16.8 16.4 15.1 14.3 14.0

Steubenville 390810016 15.8 14.5 14.4 13.5 12.8 14.3 14.2 13.1 12.5 14.8 14.5 13.3 12.9 12.7

Mingo Junction 390811001 16.5 15.2 15.2 14.3 13.5 15.0 14.9 13.8 13.2 15.6 15.2 14.0 13.6 13.4

Ironton 390870010 15.2 14.8 14.6 13.6 12.8 14.6 14.4 13.2 12.5 14.8 14.1 12.8 12.4 12.3

Dayton 391130032 15.5 14.9 14.8 14.0 13.2 14.8 14.6 13.6 12.9 14.8 14.3 13.3 12.6 12.4

New Boston 391450013 14.7 12.0 14.0 13.0 12.1 14.1 13.8 12.5 11.9 14.2 13.6 12.2 11.7 11.6

Canton - Dueber 391510017 16.3 15.7 15.6 14.8 14.0 15.5 15.3 14.4 13.6 15.4 14.9 14.0 13.3 13.3

Canton - Market 391510020 14.6 11.0 14.1 13.3 12.6 13.9 13.7 12.9 12.3 13.9 13.5 12.6 12.0 11.9

Akron - Brittain 391530017 15.1 14.6 14.5 13.8 13.0 14.4 14.2 13.4 12.7 14.3 13.8 13.0 12.3 12.3

Akron - W. Exchange 391530023 14.3 13.7 13.7 13.0 12.3 13.6 13.3 12.6 12.0 13.4 13.0 12.2 11.6 11.5 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

2009 2018 2012 

# Table 2b. PM 2.5 

# Modeling Results (Annual)2005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Key Site County Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. C - BART

Illinois

Chicago - Washington HS Cook 170310022 36.6 36 36 36 36 36 36 37 36 37 36 37 37 35

Chicago - Mayfair Cook 170310052 40.3 37 37 37 36 37 36 37 36 38 37 37 37 36

Chicago - Springfield Cook 170310057 37.4 34 34 33 32 35 34 33 32 36 34 33 33 31

Chicago - Lawndale Cook 170310076 38.1 35 35 35 35 36 35 36 35 36 35 36 36 34

McCook Cook 170311016 43.0 39 39 39 39 40 39 40 39 40 40 41 40 38

Blue Island Cook 170312001 37.7 35 35 35 34 36 35 36 34 36 35 36 36 33

Schiller Park Cook 170313103 41.6 40 40 40 39 40 40 40 39 41 40 40 39 39

Summit Cook 170313301 40.2 38 38 39 38 39 38 39 38 39 38 39 39 37

Maywood Cook 170316005 39.2 38 38 38 38 38 38 39 38 39 38 39 39 37

Granite City Madison 171191007 39.2 36 36 35 33 36 35 34 33 36 35 35 33 32

E. St. Louis St. Clair 171630010 33.7 31 31 30 28 31 30 29 28 31 30 30 29 28

Indiana

Jeffersonville Clark 180190005 38.4 35 33 31 29 35 34 32 31 37 35 34 33 31

Jasper Dubois 180372001 36.2 32 32 30 28 32 32 30 29 33 31 31 30 28

Gary - IITRI Lake 180890022 39.0 35 35 35 34 35 34 35 34 36 36 36 35 35

Gary - Burr School Lake 180890026 39.0 34 34 34 33 34 34 35 34 34 34 34 34 32

Gary Lake 180890031 35.2 29 28 26 24 28 28 24 24 29 28 27 27 27

Indy-West Street Marion 180970043 38.0 34 34 33 33 35 35 34 33 36 35 34 34 33

Indy-English Avenue Marion 180970066 38.0 34 34 32 32 35 34 33 32 35 34 33 33 32

Indy-Washington Park Marion 180970078 36.6 33 33 32 31 33 33 32 31 34 33 32 32 32

Indy-W 18th Street Marion 180970081 38.3 33 33 31 31 33 33 32 31 34 33 32 32 31

Indy- Michigan Street Marion 180970083 36.0 32 32 29 28 32 31 29 28 32 31 29 29 29

Michigan

Luna Pier Monroe 261150005 38.9 34 34 32 32 34 34 32 32 34 33 32 31 31

Oak Park Oakland 261250001 39.9 38 38 37 36 38 37 37 36 38 37 37 36 35

Port Huron St. Clair 261470005 39.6 36 35 35 34 35 35 35 34 35 35 34 33 33

Ypsilanti Washtenaw 261610008 39.5 37 37 36 35 37 36 36 35 37 36 36 35 34

Allen Park Wayne 261630001 38.6 36 36 36 35 36 35 35 34 36 35 35 34 33

Southwest HS Wayne 261630015 40.1 36 36 36 35 36 35 35 35 36 35 35 34 33

Linwood Wayne 261630016 43.0 40 40 40 39 40 40 40 39 40 39 39 39 38

E 7 Mile Wayne 261630019 41.0 39 39 39 38 39 39 39 38 39 38 38 38 37

Dearborn Wayne 261630033 43.9 41 41 41 40 41 41 41 40 41 40 40 40 39

Wyandotte Wayne 261630036 37.2 36 36 36 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 34

Newberry Wayne 261630038 42.7 39 39 39 38 39 38 38 37 39 38 38 37 36

FIA Wayne 261630039 39.7 35 34 34 33 35 34 34 33 35 34 33 33 31

Ohio

Middleton Butler 390170003 39.3 33 32 29 28 33 33 29 28 34 32 29 28 27

Fairfield Butler 390170016 37.1 32 31 29 27 31 30 28 28 32 30 29 28 27

Butler 390170017 40.8 33 32 30 29 33 33 30 29 33 32 30 29 28

Cleveland-28th Street Cuyahoga 390350027 36.9 34 34 33 32 34 33 33 32 34 33 33 31 31

Cleveland-St. Tikhon Cuyahoga 390350038 44.2 40 40 37 36 40 39 36 35 40 38 36 35 34

Cleveland-Broadway Cuyahoga 390350045 38.8 35 35 33 31 35 34 32 30 35 34 31 29 29

Cleveland-GT Craig Cuyahoga 390350060 42.1 39 39 38 37 39 38 38 37 39 38 37 36 35

Newburg Hts - Harvard Ave Cuyahoga 390350065 38.9 35 35 33 31 35 34 32 30 36 35 32 31 30

Columbus - Fairgrounds Franklin 390490024 38.5 34 34 33 33 34 33 32 32 34 34 33 32 31

Columbus - Ann Street Franklin 390490025 38.5 34 33 31 31 33 33 31 31 34 33 31 31 30

Cincinnait Hamilton 390610006 40.6 33 33 30 27 33 32 29 28 34 32 29 28 27 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

2009 2012 2018 

# Table 2c. PM 2.5 

# Modeling Results (Daily)2005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Key Site County Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. C - BART Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

2009 2012 2018 

# Table 2c. PM 2.5 

# Modeling Results (Daily)

Cincinnati - Seymour Hamilton 390610014 38.4 33 33 28 26 33 32 27 25 33 31 29 25 24

Cincinnati - Taft Ave Hamilton 390610040 36.7 31 30 26 24 31 30 26 24 32 29 26 24 23

Cincinnati - 8th Ave Hamilton 390610042 37.3 32 32 30 28 32 31 29 28 33 31 29 28 27

Sharonville Hamilton 390610043 36.0 32 31 30 28 32 31 29 28 32 31 29 28 27

Norwood Hamilton 390617001 38.8 34 33 32 30 33 33 31 30 34 33 31 30 29

St. Bernard Hamilton 390618001 40.6 35 35 32 30 35 34 31 30 35 33 32 31 29

Steubenville Jefferson 390810016 40.7 36 35 32 29 35 34 30 28 37 35 31 29 28

Mingo Junction Jefferson 390811001 42.0 37 37 33 30 37 36 32 30 38 36 32 30 30

Dayton Montgomery 391130032 37.8 34 33 31 30 33 33 31 30 34 33 31 31 30

Canton - Dueber Stark 391510017 38.6 33 32 30 28 33 31 30 28 33 30 29 28 27

Akron - Brittain Summit 391530017 38.1 33 33 31 30 33 32 31 30 33 32 30 29 29

Wisconsin

Green Bay - Est High Brown 550090005 37.1 35 34 35 35 34 35 35 34 33 33 33 32 32

Madison Dane 550250047 36.4 33 33 32 32 33 32 32 31 32 31 30 29 29

Milwaukee-Health Center Milwaukee 550790010 38.7 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 34 35 34 34 34 33

Milwaukee-SER Hdqs Milwaukee 550790026 37.4 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 33

Milwaukee-Virginia FS Milwaukee 550790043 39.9 37 37 37 36 37 36 37 36 36 36 37 36 36

Milwaukee- Fire Dept Hdqs Milwaukee 550790099 37.8 34 34 33 33 34 33 33 32 34 33 33 33 32

Waukesha Waukesha 551330027 35.5 32 32 32 31 32 32 32 31 32 31 31 30 29

### 10 

### Table 3. Mo deling Res ults: Number of Sites > NAAQS

Ozone (85 ppb) Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 0 0 0 0

---- 0

IN 0 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 3 1 1 1

---- 1

OH 4 0 0 0

---- 0

WI 2 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 9 1 1 1 1

2012

IL 0 0 0 0

---- 0

IN 0 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 3 0 0 0

---- 0

OH 4 0 0 0

---- 0

WI 2 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 9 0 0 0 0

2018

IL 0 0 0 0 0 0

IN 0 0 0 0 0 0

MI 3 0 0 0 0 0

OH 4 0 0 0 0 0

WI 2 0 0 0 0 0

Total 9 0 0 0 0 0

O zone (75 ppb) Round 5 without CAIR Round5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 12 6 6 6

---- 4

IN 26 10 9 8

---- 5

MI 21 12 12 12

---- 12

OH 45 27 25 24

---- 21

WI 12 10 10 10

---- 10

Total 116 65 62 60

---- 52

20 12

IL 12 3 3 3

---- 1

IN 26 5 4 4

---- 3

MI 21 9 8 8

---- 6

OH 45 18 14 12

---- 11

WI 12 10 9 9

---- 9

Total 116 45 38 36 30

2018

IL 12 0 0 0 0 0

IN 26 0 0 0 0 0

MI 21 3 3 3 3 3

OH 45 3 3 2 1 1

WI 12 3 2 1 1 1

Total 116 9 8 6 5 5

### 11

PM2.5

- Annual Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 7 4 4 1

---- 1

IN 6 2 2 0

---- 0

MI 2 2 2 1

---- 1

OH 26 1 3 12 5

---- 1

WI 0 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 41 21 20 7 3

2012

IL 7 3 1 1

---- 0

IN 6 1 1 0

---- 0

MI 2 2 1 1

---- 1

OH 26 12 9 4

---- 0

WI 0 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 41 18 12 6 1

2018

IL 7 3 1 0 0 0

IN 6 1 1 0 0 0

MI 2 2 1 1 1 1

OH 26 13 8 2 0 0

WI 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 41 19 11 3 1 1

PM2.5

- Daily

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 16 7 7 6

---- 6

IN 13 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 14 10 9 9

---- 5

OH 31 4 3 2

---- 2

WI 8 1 1 1

---- 1

Total 82 2 2 20 18

---- 14

2012

IL 16 9 6 8

---- 6

IN 13 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 14 8 6 6

---- 5

OH 31 3 3 2

---- 1

WI 8 1 1 1

---- 1

Total 82 21 16 1 7 13

2018

IL 16 10 6 8 8 5

IN 13 4 1 1 0 0

MI 14 8 6 6 5 4

OH 31 5 3 2 1 0

WI 8 1 1 1 1 1

Total 82 2 8 17 18 1 5 10

### 12 

### Ta ble 4 . Mo deling Results: Future Year Visibility Levels

Worst 20% 2018

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

Site Baseline

(2000

- 2004) 2018 URP Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

BART

BOWA1 19.86 17.94 19.09 18.87 18.54 18.02 17.94

VOYA2 19.48 17.75 18.60 18.44 18.17 17.77 17.63

SENE1 24.38 21.64 24.02 23.58 23.03 22.38 22.59

ISLE1 21.59 19.43 21.05 20.86 20.62 20.22 20.09

ISLE9 21.59 19.43 20.83 20.58 20.38 19.84 19.84

HEGL1 26.75 23.13 26.24 25.83 24.87 24.23 24.22

MI NG1 28.15 24.27 27.51 26.98 25.81 24.93 24.74

CACR1 26.36 22.91 25.32 24.80 23.57 22.97 22.44

UPBU1 26.27 22.82 25.31 24.79 23.50 22.79 22.59

MACA1 31.37 26.64 30.11 29.08 27.06 26.24 26.10

DOSO1 29.05 24.69 27.88 26.96 24.36 23.74 23.00

SHEN1 29 .31 25.12 28.38 27.65 25.24 24.69 23.92

JARI1 29.12 24.91 28.06 27.21 25.00 24.48 24.06

BRIG1 29.01 25.05 28.10 28.07 26.57 26.25 25.21

LYBR1 24.45 21.48 24.06 23.86 22.58 22.30 21.14

ACAD1 22.89 20.45 22.88 22.76 22.31 22.16 21.49

Best 20% 2018

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

Site Baseline

(2000

- 2004) 2018 Max Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

BART

BOWA1 6.42 6.42 6.20 6.17 6.16 6.12 6.14

VOYA2 7.09 7.09 6.87 6.83 6.81 6.78 6.75

SENE1 7.14 7.14 7.80 7.78 7. 81 7.77 7.71

ISLE1 6.75 6.75 6.77 6.76 6.72 6.67 6.60

ISLE9 6.75 6.75 6.63 6.61 6.58 6.53 6.52

HEGL1 12.84 12.84 12.17 12.20 12.07 11.63 11.66

MING1 14.46 14.46 13.78 13.77 13.70 13.37 13.28

CACR1 11.24 11.24 10.94 10.99 10.97 10.78 10. 52

UPBU1 11.71 11.71 11.18 11.23 11.18 10.96 10.73

MACA1 16.51 16.51 16.32 16.21 15.76 15.34 15.25

DOSO1 12.28 12.28 12.02 11.84 11.27 11.03 11.00

SHEN1 10.93 10.93 10.98 10.91 10.25 10.16 9.91

JARI1 14.21 14.21 14.19 13.98 13.42 13.21 13.14

BRI G1 14.33 14.33 14.32 14.46 14.22 14.17 13.92

LYBR1 6.37 6.37 6.39 6.38 6.31 6.28 6.14

ACAD1 8.78 8.78 8.97 8.96 8.90 8.89 8.82

### 13 

### Figure 2. Ozone Modeling Results

2009 Round 5

–

S cen

. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2012 Round 5

–

Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2018 Round 5

–

Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

### 14 

### Figure 3. PM2.5 Annual Modeling Results

2009 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– S cen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2012 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2018 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

### 15 

### Figure 4 . PM2.5 Daily Modeling Results

2009 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2012 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2018 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

# Appendix I

Scenario B (Legally Enforceable) ControlsNOx

– 2009

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1b_2009 Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2009

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.8147 0.8416 0.8416 0.00 0.00 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.0515 3.1522 3.1522 0.00 0.00 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.9419 7.1708 7.1708 0.00 0.00 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.1310 2.2013 2.2013 0.00 0.00 lnb LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.1244 12.5243 12.5243

cyid 12.1244 12.5243 12.5243

stid 12.9392 13.3659 13.3659

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrlde s

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.9860 6.9756 2.3252 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NO X 3.6327 3.6273 1.2091 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.0133 5.0058 1.6686 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.8493 7.8376 2.6125 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.4814 23.4464 7.8155

cyi d 23.4814 23.4464 7.8155

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control E F Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.0017 0.0017 0.0001 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.8167 5.8080 0.2904 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.9017 7.8899 0.3945 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.8775 7.8657 0.3933 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.8586 3.8528 0.1926 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- f cid 25.4561 25.4182 1.2709

cyid 25.4561 25.4182 1.2709

stid 48.9375 48.8646 9.0864

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future YearSTID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.7972 2.8 895 1.6470 0.00 0.43 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.9073 3.0032 1.7118 0.00 0.43 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.3270 2.4038 1.2740 0.00 0.47 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 1010020 2 NOX 2.3427 2.4199 1.2826 0.00 0.47 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10.3742 10.7164 5.9154

cyid 10.3742 10.7164 5.9154

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & L Alliant Energy

- Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S1 1 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.6197 1.6731 1.0038 0.00 0.40 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S11 B24 01 10100203 NOX 4.1072 4.2426 3. 4789 0.00 0.18 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.6804 5.8677 4.9876 0.00 0.15 SCR SCR added by LADCO

- --- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 11.4072 11.7834 9.4703

cyid 11.4072 11.7834 9.4703

stid 21.7814 22.4997 15.3857

======== ======== ==========

83.6581 84.7302 37.8380NOx

- 2012

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for N OX r6s1b_2012 Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2012

STID=17 CYID=33 fcid=0338 01AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc poli d Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 33 033801AAA 0005 0005 01 10100202 NOX 1.642 1.871 0.9357 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 33 033801AAA 0006 0006 01 10100202 NOX 2.116 2.413 1.2063 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 3.758 4.284 2.1420

cyid 3.758 4.284 2.1420

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.815 0.929 0.9288 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMER EN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.735 7.678 7.6780 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01 10100501 NOX 5.936 5.378 5.3781 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.671 13.056 13.0561

cyid 12.671 13.056 13.0561

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctr ltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 02 10100401 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=137 fcid=137805AAA name=AMEREN ENE RGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons /Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 137 137805AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 5.356 6.106 6.1058 0.00 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.052 3.479 3.4789 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.942 7.914 7.9141 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 14

3805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.131 2.429 2.4294 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- - ------- ---------- fcid 12.124 13.822 13.8224

cyid 12.124 13.822 13.8224STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 NOX 6.527 7.441 0.0074 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 NOX 2.646 3.017 0.0030 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 9.173 10.458 0.0105

cyid 9.173 10.458 0.0 105

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10 100203 NOX 22.429 25.570 1.2785 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 NOX 38.993 44.454 2.2227 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 61.422 7 0.024 3.5012

cyid 61.422 70.024 3.5012

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809AAO 0032 0033 02 10100604 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year F uture Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 NOX 5.731 6.534 3.9203 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 02 10100223 NOX 8.598 9.802 0.0098 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 NOX 10.974 12.511 0.01 25 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

-- -- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.303 28.847 3.9426

cyid 25.303 28.847 3.9426

stid 130.622 147.527 43.5096

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 NOX 13.661 14.142 2.8284 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU00 3 002 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fci d 13.661 14.142 2.8284

cyid 13.661 14.142 2.8284

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes27 1 09 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 NOX 2.079 2.152 1.2911 0.00 0.400 SNCR SCR added by LADCO

---- ---- ---- -------- ---------- stid 15.739 16.294 4.1195

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid T ons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.986 7.296 2.4319 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.633 3.794 1.2646 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P 1 10100202 NOX 5.013 5.235 1.7452 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.849 8.197 2.7324 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.481 24.522 8.1740

cyid 23.481 24.522 8.1740

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid s tkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 NOX 20.852 21.776 1.0888 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.002 0.002 0.0001 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.817 6.074 0.3037 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 068400

0000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.902 8.252 0.4126 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0. 000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.877 8.227 0.4113 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 1010 0202 NOX 3.859 4.030 0.2015 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0. 950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.456 26. 584 1.3292

cyid 25.456 26.584 1.3292

stid 69.789 72.882 10.5920

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CR EEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 NOX 4.755 5.421 3.0898 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 NOX 3.277 3.736 2.2045 0.00 0.410 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 NOX 3.333 3.800 2.8499 0.00 0.250 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 NOX 3.384 3.857 2.9316 0.00 0.240 SC R SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 14.749 16.814 11. 0757

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATIONBase Yr Grown Controll ed Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 0 1 10100202 NOX 2.797 3.189 1.8177 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.907 3.314 1.8893 0.0 0 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.327 2.653 1.4061 0.00 0.470 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.343 2.671 1.4155 0.00 0.470 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10.374 11.827 6.5285

cyid 25.123 28.641 17.6042

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & L Alliant Energy

- Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrl type ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S11 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.620 1.846 1.1079 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S11 B24 0 1 10100203 NOX 4.107 4.682 3.8395 0.00 0.180 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.680 6.476 5.5045 0.0 0 0.150 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 11 .407 13.005 10.4519

cyid 11.407 13.005 10.4519

stid 36.530 41.646 28.0562

======== ======== ==========

252.681 278.349 86.2773NOx 20 18

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1b_2018 Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2018

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AIN name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 01 10100226 NOX 2.283 2. 592 1.5550 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 02 10100601 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 01 10100226 NOX 3.991 4.531 2.7184 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 02 1010 0601 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 6.274 7.122 4.2734

cyid 6.274 7. 122 4.2734

STID=17 CYID=33 fcid=033801AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Co ntrolled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 33 033801AAA 0005 0005 01 10100202 NOX 1.642 1.863 0.9317 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 33 033801AAA 0006 0006 01 10100202 NOX 2.116 2.402 1.2012 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 3.758 4.266 2.1329

cyid 3.758 4.266 2.1329

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.815 0.925 0.924 9 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Ba se Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.735 7.645 7.6453 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01 10100501 NOX 5.936 3.984 3.9838 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.671 11.629 11.6291

cyid 12.671 11.629 11.6291

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 02 10100401 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=137 fcid=137805AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Ye ar Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 137 137805AAA 0003 0003 01 10100 202 NOX 5.356 6.080 6.0798 0.00 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCOSTID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.052 3.464 3.4641 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.942 7.880 7.8804 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.131 2.419 2.4191 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.124 13.764 13.7636

cyid 12.124 13.764 13.7636

STID=17 CYID= 167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 NOX 6.527 7.410 0.0074 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 NOX 2.646 3.004 0.0030 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 9.173 10.414 0.0104

cyid 9.173 10.414 0.0104

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Contro l EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10100203 NOX 22.429 25.462 1.2731 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 179 179801 AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 NOX 38.993 44.265 2.2132 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- ----- --- ---------- fcid 61.422 69.726 3.4863

cyid 61.422 69.726 3.4863

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809AAO 0032 0033 02 10100604 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 NOX 5.731 6.506 3.9036 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0 011 0016 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 02 10100223 NOX 8.598 9.760 0.0098 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 NOX 10.974 12.458 0.0125 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.303 28.724 3.9258

cyid 25.303 28.724 3.9258

stid 136.896 152.649 46.2263STID=18 CYID=147 fcid=00020 name=INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER

- ROCKPORT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

18 147 00020 1 001 01 10100222 NOX 23.226 25.291 1.2646 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

18 147 00020 1 001 02 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

cyid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

stid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 NOX 13.661 15.733 3.1466 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 13.661 15.733 3.1466

cyid 13.661 15.733 3.1466

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 109 271090

0011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 NOX 2.079 2.394 1.4363 0.00 0.400 SNCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- ----- --- ---------- stid 15.739 18.127 4.5830

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day To ns/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.986 7.607 2.5358 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LAD CO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.633 3.956 1.3186 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.013 5.459 1.8197 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.849 8.547 2.8491 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.481 25.570 8.5232

cyid 23.481 25.570 8.5232

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 NOX 20.852 22.706 1.1353 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year F uture Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.002 0.002 0.0001 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.817 6.334 0.3167 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.902 8.604 0.4302 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.00 00 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.877 8.578 0.4289 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.859 4.202 0.2101 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.456 27.720 1.38 60

cyid 25.456 27.720 1.3860

st id 69.789 75.996 11.0445

STID=54 CYID=39 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- KANAWHA RIVER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 39 0006 012 001 99 10100202 NOX 4.829 5.258 2.6291 0.00 0.500 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

54 39 0006 012 002 99 10100202 NOX 4.921 5.359 2.6794 0.00 0.500 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

cyid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

stid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10 100202 NOX 4.755 5.398 3.0766 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 NOX 3.277 3.720 2.1951 0.00 0.410 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 NOX 3.333 3.784 2.8378 0.00 0.250 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 NOX 3.384 3.841 2.9191 0.00 0.240 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 14.749 16.743 11.0285

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALL EY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.797 3.175 1.4289 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.907 3.300 1.4852 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.327 2.642 1.1887 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.343 2.659 1.1967 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10.374 11.777 5.2 995

cyid 25.123 28.519 16.3281

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & L Alliant Energy

- Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S11 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.620 1.839 1.103 2 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO55 117 460033090 S11 B24 01 10100203 NOX 4.107 4.662 3.8232 0.00 0.180 SCR SCR added by LADCO

5 5 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.680 6.448 5.4811 0.00 0.150 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 11.407 12.949 10.4074

cyid 11.407 12.949 10.4074

stid 36.530 41.469 26.735 5

======== ======== ==========

291.931 324.149 95.1624SO2

– 2009

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for SO2 r6s1b_2009 1

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2009

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58

- 07

- 001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO.

- LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Cont rol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

19 115 58

- 07

- 001 117487 147281 99 10100222 SO2 33.664 34.774 3.4774 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fc

id=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 42.166 42.103 4.2103 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 SO2 55.385 55.303 5.5303 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

cyid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

stid 9 7.551 97.406 9.7406

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP

- Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 271410

0004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 SO2 16.765 16.987 3.6401 0.3 0.85 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 SO2 22.549 22. 848 4.8959 0.3 0.85 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

cyid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

stid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid= 0005 name=OHIO POWER

- MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 17.775 17.748 1.7748 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 5.689 5.680 0.5680 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.463 23.428 2.3428

cyid 23.463 23.428 2.3428

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 SO2 11.196 11.179 1.1179 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid= 0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- JOHN E AMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 79.635 79.516 7.9516 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 SO2 139.377 139.169 13.9169 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 219.012 218.685 21.8685

cyid 219.012 218.685 21.8685

stid 253.671 253.293 25.3293

======== ======== ==========

424.200 425.307 47.0832SO2

– 2012

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for SO2 r6s1b_2012 1

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2012

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AMI name=MIDWEST GENERATION L LC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day To ns/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AMI 0007 0010 01 10100226 SO2 16.13 18.39 1.839 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

ST ID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0018 0033 01 10100226 SO2 24.14 27.52 2.752 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0021 0036 01 10100226 SO2 19.23 21.92 2.192 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 09719

0AAC 0016 0031 01 10100203 SO2 4.59 5.24 0.005 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 47.96 54.68 4.950

cyid 47.96 54.68 4.950

STID=17 CYID=125 fcid=125804AAB name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 125 125804AAB 0019 0023 01 10100202 SO2 22.34 25.47 3.821 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=127 fcid=127855AAC name=ELECTRIC ENERGY INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/D ay Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0001 01 10100222 SO2 11.83 13.48 13.482 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0002 01 10100222 SO2 11.48 13.09 13.085 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0003 01 10100222 SO2 10.25 11.68 11.680 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0004 01 10100222 SO2 12.04 13.73 13.731 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0006 01 10100222 SO2 12.68 14.46 14.456 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 58.27 66.43 66.435

cyid 58.27 66.43 66.435

STID=17 CYID=135 fcid=135803AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING C O

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Ton s/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 32.99 37.61 3.761 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0003 01 10100203 SO2 72.92 83.13 8.313 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 105.91 120.74 12.074

cyid 105.91 120.74 12.074STID=17 CYID=157 fcid=157851AAA name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 157 157851AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 25.14 28.66 4.299 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0002 00 02 01 10100203 SO2 25.79 29.41 4.411 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0013 0013 01 10100202 SO2 27.79 31.68 4.752 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.72 89.75 13.462

cyid 78.72 89.75 13.462

STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 SO2 4 4.20 50.39 0.050 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 SO2 16.40 18.70 0.019 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 60.61 69.10 0.06 9

cyid 60.61 69.10 0.069

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid p rid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10100203 SO2 25.35 28.90 2.890 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 SO2 41.57 47.39 4.739 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 66.91 76.29 7.629

cyid 66.91 76.29 7.629

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Ton s/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 SO2 15.33 17.48 0.017 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 101 00501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 15.33 17.48 0.017

cyid 15.33 17.48 0.017

stid 472.19 538.32 110.295

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58

- 07

- 001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO.

- LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYI D fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

19 115 58

- 07

- 001 117487 147281 99 10100222 SO2 33.66 38.38 3.838 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 42.17 44.03 4.403 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 SO2 55.39 57.84 5.784 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 97.55 101.87 10.187

cyid 97.55 101.87 10.187

stid 97.55 101.87 10.187

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=27 06100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 SO2 33.99 35.19 15.081 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 33.99 35.19 15.081

cyid 33.99 35.19 15.081

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Pu blic Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid T ons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 SO2 7.86 8.13 1.220 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER S crubber added by LADCO

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP

- Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID f

cid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 SO2 16.76 17.36 3.719 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 SO2 22.55 23.34 5.002 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 39.31 40.70 8.721

cyid 39.31 40.70 8.721

stid 81.16 84.02 25.023

STID=39 CYID=13 fcid=0607130015 name=R. E. BURGER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Cont rol EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 13 0607130015 R6 B011 B011P1 10100202 SO2 29.83 31.15 3.115 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 13 0607130015 R7 B012 B012P1 10100202 SO2 34.77 36.31 3.631 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 64.60 67.46 6.746

cyid 64.60 67.46 6.746

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 SO2 316.00 330.00 33.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- stid 380.60 397.46 39.746

STID=47 CYID=1 fcid=0009 name=TVA BULL RUN FOSSIL PLANTBase Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Da y Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 1 0009 S

- 1 001 99 10100212 SO2 130.81 133.01 13.301 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubbe r added by LADCO

STID=47 CYID=73 fcid=0007 name=TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stk id dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 73 0007 S

- 1A 001 99 10100212 SO2 20.15 20.49 2.0 49 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 1B 002 99 10100212 SO2 20.25 20.59 2.059 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2A 003 99 10100212 SO2 19.62 19.95 1.995 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2B 004 99 10100212 SO2 18.93 19.25 1.925 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.95 80.28 8.028

cyid 78.95 80.2 8 8.028

STID=47 CYID=85 fcid=0011 name=TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Contr olled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 85 0011 S1

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 17.06 17.35 1.735 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 04 004 99 10100212 SO2 19.85 20.18 2.018 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 05 005 99 10100212 SO2 24.11 24.52 2.452 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 61.02 62.04 6.204

cyid 61.02 62.04 6.204

STID=47 CYID=145 fcid=0013 name =TVA KINGSTON FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Ton s/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 145 0013 S

- 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 12.68 12.89 1.289 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scr ubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 002 99 10100202 SO2 14.00 14.24 1.424 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 003 9 9 10100202 SO2 13.80 14.04 1.404 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 004 99 10100202 SO2 12.24 12.44 1.244 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 005 99 10100202 SO2 19.57 19.90 1.990 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 006 99 10100202 SO2 18.92 19.24 1.924 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 007 99 10100202 SO2 21.30 21.66 2.166 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 008 99 10100202 SO2 18.54 18.85 1.885 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBE R Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 009 99 10100202 SO2 20.72 21.07 2.107 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 151.77 154.33 15.433

cyid 151.77 154.33 15.433

STID=47 CYID=165 fcid=0025 name=TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Cont rol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 165 0025 S

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 13.91 14.14 1.414 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 00

25 S

- 01 002 99 10100212 SO2 14.87 15.12 1.512 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 003 99 10100212 SO2 16.33 16.60 1.660 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 004 99 10100212 SO2 20.39 20.73 2.073 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Sc rubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ----------fcid 65.49 66.59 6.659

cyid 65.49 66.59 6.659

stid 488.04 496.25 49.625

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER

- MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 17.77 18.56 1.856 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 5.69 5.94 0.594 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- --- ----- ---------- fcid 23.46 24.50 2.450

cyid 23.46 24.50 2.450

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 SO2 11.20 11.69 1.169 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- JOHN E A MOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 79.63 83.16 8.316 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LA DCO

54 79 0006 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 100.33 104.78 10.478 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 SO2 139.38 145.55 14.555 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 319.35 333.50 33.350

cyid 319.35 3 33.50 33.350

stid 354.00 369.69 36.969

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 SO2 12.75 14.5 4 3.490 0.0 0.760 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 SO2 8.68 9.89 2.473 0.0 0.750 SCRUBBER Scrubber add ed by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 SO2 10.97 12.51 2.876 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 SO2 11.28 12.86 2.958 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 43.68 49.80 11.797

cyid 43.6 8 49.80 11.797

stid 43.68 49.80 11.797

======== ======== ==========

1950.90 2075.80 287.480SO2

– 2018

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for SO2 r6s1b_2018 1

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2018

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AIN name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 01 10100226 SO2 10.92 12.39 1.239 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 01 10100226 SO2 17.69 20.08 2.008 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 28.61 32.48 3.248

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AMI name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AMI 0007 0010 01 10100226 SO2 16.13 18.31 1.831 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- cyid 44.74 50.79 5.079

STID=17 CYID =79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 SO2 36.35 41.27 4.127 0.0 0. 900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01 10100501 SO2 28.99 19.46 1.946 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 65.34 60.72 6.072

cyid 65.34 60.72 6.072

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATIO N LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0018 0033 01 10100226 SO2 24.14 27.40 2.740 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0021 0036 01 10100226 SO2 19.23 21.83 2.183 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 01 10100203 SO2 4.59 5.22 0.005 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 47.96 54.45 4.928

cyid 47.96 54.4 5 4.928

STID=17 CYID=125 fcid=125804AAB name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 125 125804AAB 0019 0023 01 10100202 SO2 22.34 25.36 3.805 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=127 fcid=127855AAC name=ELECTRIC ENERGY INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes17 127 127855AAC 0002 0003 01 10100222 SO2 10.25 11.63 11.630 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0004 01 10100222 SO2 12.04 13.67 13.673 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0001 01 10100222 SO2 11.83 13.42 1.342 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0002 01 10100222 SO2 11.48 13.03 1.303 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 1 27855AAC 0003 0005 01 10100222 SO2 11.72 13.31 1.331 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0006 01 10100222 SO2 12.68 14.39 1.439 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 70.00 79.46 30.719

cyid 70.00 79.46 30.719

STID=17 CYID=135 fcid=135803AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Bas e Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 32.99 37.45 3.745 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0003 01 10100203 SO2 72.92 82.77 8.277 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10 5.91 120.22 12.022

cyid 105.91 120.22 12.022

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 SO2 15.28 17.34 1.734 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=157 fcid=157851AAA name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown C ontrolled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 157 157851AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 25.14 28.54 4.281 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0002 0002 01 10100203 SO2 25.79 29.28 4.3 92 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0013 0013 01 10100202 SO2 27.79 31.54 4.732 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.72 89.36 13.404

cyid 78.72 89.36 13.404

STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=16712 0AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc poli d Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 SO2 44.20 50.18 0.050 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOW N Scrubber added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 SO2 16.40 18.62 0.019 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 60.61 68.80 0.069

cyid 60.61 68.80 0.069

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Co ntrol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10100203 SO2 25.35 28.77 2.877 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 SO2 41.57 47.19 4.719 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- ------- - -------- ----------fcid 66.91 75.96 7.596

cyid 66.91 75.96 7.596

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809AAO 0006 0009 01 10100203 SO2 15.89 18.04 1.804 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197809AAO 0016 0031 01 1 0100202 SO2 27.43 31.13 3.113 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197809AAO 0017 0033 01 10100202 SO2 23.13 26.26 2.626 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 66.45 75.44 7.544

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0009 0014 02 10100222 SO2 11.64 13.21 1.321 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 SO2 25.67 29.14 2.914 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 SO2 15.33 17.40 0.017 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 101005 01 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 52.64 59.75 4.252

cyid 119.09 135.19 11.796

stid 696.90 777.66 97.225

STID=18 CYID=147 fcid=00020 name=INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER

- ROCKPORT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

18 147 00020 1 001 01 10100222 SO2 66.42 72.32 7.232 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

18 147 00020 1 001 02 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 66.42 72.32 7.232

cyid 66.42 72.32 7.232

stid 66.42 72.32 7.232

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58

- 07

- 001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO.

- LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

19 115 58

- 07

- 001 117487 147281 99 10100222 SO2 33.66 38.22 3.822 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=127 fcid =2112700003 name=KENTUCKY POWER CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc poli d Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

21 127 2112700003 2 002 99 10100202 SO2 104.52 113.82 11.382 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBE R Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 42.17 45.92 4.592 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 SO2 55.39 60.31 6.031 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 97.55 106.23 10.623

cyid 97.55 106.23 10.623

stid 202.07 220.04 22.004

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Cont rol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 SO2 33.99 39.15 16.778 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 61 27

06100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 33.99 39.15 16.778

cyid 33.99 39.15 16.778

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF c trltype ctrldes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 SO2 7.86 9.05 1.357 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP

- Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid To ns/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 SO2 16.76 19.31 4.138 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Sc rubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 SO2 22.55 25.97 5.565 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 39.31 45.28 9.703

cyid 39.31 45.28 9.703

stid 81.16 93.48 27.838

STID=39 CYID=13 fcid=0607130015 name=R. E. BURGER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 13 0607130015 R6 B011 B011P1 10100202 SO2 29.83 32.48 3.248 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 13 0607130015 R7 B012 B012P1 10100202 SO2 34.77 37. 86 3.786 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 64.60 70.34 7.034

cyid 64.60 70.34 7.034

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Futur e Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 SO2 316.00 344.11 34.411 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 SO2 65.07 70.85 7.085 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 SO2 94.58 103.00 10.300 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBE R Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B00 4 B004P1 10100203 SO2 81.64 88.90 8.890 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R5 B005 B005P1 10100203 SO2 97.22 105.87 10.587 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

3 9 167 0684000000 R5 B005 B005P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 SO 2 113.96 124.10 12.410 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 452.48 492.72 49.272

cyid 452.48 492.72 49.272

stid 833.08 907.16 90.716

STID=47 CYID=1 fcid=0009 name=TVA BULL RUN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 1 0009 S

- 1 001 99 10100212 SO2 130.81 136.82 13.682 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=47 CY ID=73 fcid=0007 name=TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 73 0007 S

- 1A 001 99 10100212 SO2 20.15 21.07 2.107 0.0 0.90 0 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 1B 002 99 10100212 SO2 20.25 21.18 2.118 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2A 003 99 10100212 SO2 19.62 20.52 2.052 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2B 004 99 10100212 SO2 18.93 19.8 0 1.980 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.95 82.57 8.257

cyid 78.95 82.57 8.257

STID=47 CYID=85 fcid=0011 name=TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Futur e Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 85 0011 S1

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 17.06 17.84 1.784 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 04 004 99 10100212 SO2 19.85 20.76 2.076 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 05 005 99 10100212 SO2 24.11 25.22 2.522 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 61.02 63.82 6.382

cyid 61.02 63.82 6.382

STID=47 CYID=145 fcid=0013 name=TVA KINGSTON FOSSIL PLAN T

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Ton s/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 145 0013 S

- 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 12.68 13.26 1.326 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 002 99 10100202 SO2 14.00 14.65 1.465 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO47 145 0013 S

- 1 003 99 10100202 SO2 13.80 14.44 1.444 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 004 99 10100202 SO2 12.24 12.80 1.280 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 005 99 10100202 SO2 19.57 20.47 2.047 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 006 99 10100202 SO2 18.92 19.79 1.979 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 007 99 10100202 SO2 21.30 22.28 2.228 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 008 99 10100202 SO2 18.54 19.39 1.939 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LA DCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 009 99 10100202 SO2 20.72 21.68 2.168 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 151.77 158.75 15.875

cyid 151.77 158.75 15.875

STID=47 CYID=165 fcid=0025 name=TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 165 0025 S

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 13.91 14.54 1.454 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 01 002 99 10100212 SO2 14.87 15.56 1.556 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 003 99 10100212 SO2 16.33 17.08 1.708 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 004 99 10100212 SO2 20.39 21.32 2.132 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

--- - -------- -------- ---------- fcid 65.49 68.50 6.850

cyid 65.49 68.50 6.850

stid 488.04 510.46 51.046

STID=54 CYID=39 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- KANAWHA RIVER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 39 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 19.45 21.18 10.591 0.0 0.500 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 39 0006 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 20.94 22.80 11.399 0.0 0.500 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- --- ------- fcid 40.39 43.98 21.990

cyid 40.39 43.98 21.990

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER

- MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 17.77 19.36 1.936 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 5.69 6.19 0.619 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.46 25.55 2.555

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0006 name=OHIO POWER

- KAMMER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0006 013 001 99 10100203 SO2 47.06 51.25 5.125 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0006 013 002 99 10100203 SO2 47.66 51.90 5.190 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0006 013 003 99 10100203 SO2 41.94 45.67 4.567 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO---- -------- -------- ----------

fcid 136.67 148.82 14.882

cyid 160.13 174.37 17.437

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0001 name=APPALACHIAN POWER CO.

- PHILIP SPORN PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID C YID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0001 014 001 99 10100202 SO2 18.6 5 20.31 2.031 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 002 99 10100202 SO2 15.87 17.28 1.728 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 003 99 10100202 SO2 21.46 23.36 2.336 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 004 99 10100202 SO2 20.53 22.36 2.236 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 005 005 99 10100202 SO2 46.82 50.98 5.098 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 123.33 134.30 13.430

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 SO2 11.20 12.19 1.219 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- --- ----- -------- ---------- cyid 134.53 146.49 14.649

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid=0006 name=APPALACH IAN POWER

- JOHN E AMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 79.63 86.72 8.672 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 100.33 109.26 10.926 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 SO2 139.38 151.77 15.177 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 319.35 347.75 34.775

cyid 319.35 347.75 34.775

stid 654.39 712.59 88.851

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 SO2 12.75 14.48 3.475 0.0 0.760 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 SO2 8.68 9.85 2.462 0.0 0.750 SCR UBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 SO2 10.97 12.45 2.864 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 SO2 11.28 12.81 2.945 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ------ ---- fcid 43.68 49.59 11.746

cyid 43.68 49.59 11.746

stid 43.68 49.59 11.746

======== ======== ==========

3099.41 3 381.52 400.481

# Appendix II

Scenario C Controls (CAMD List)

### 1 

## NOx Controls (SCRs , 2007

– 2013) )

Plant Name UniqueID_Final State Name County Capacity

MW On Line

Year SCR

Online

Year

Chesterfield 3797_B_4 Virginia Chesterfield 166 1960 2013

Chesterfield 3797_B_5 Virginia Chesterfield 310 1964 2012

Scherer 6257_B_3 Georgia Monroe 875 1987 2011

Chesterfield 3797_B_6 Virginia Chesterfield 658 1969 2011

Sandow No 4 6648_B_4 Texas Milam 545 1981 2011

Beech Hollow Power Project 82704_B_1 Pennsylvania Washington 272 2011 2011

Longview Power 82702_B_1 West Virginia Monongalia 695 201 1 2011

Cliffside 2721_B_6 North Carolina Cleveland 800 2011 2011

AES Westover 2526_B_11 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_12 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_13 New York Broome 84 1951 2010

Iatan 2 6065_B_2 Missouri Plat te 850 2010 2010

Southwest 6195_B_2 Missouri Greene 300 2010 2010

Trimble Station (LGE) 6071_B_2 Kentucky Trimble 732 2010 2010

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_2 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2010 2010

Clay Boswell 1893_B_3 Minnesota Itasca 350 1973 2009

Asheville 2706_B_2 North Carolina Buncombe 184 1971 2009

Conesville 2840_B_4 Ohio Coshocton 780 1973 2009

Marshall 2727_B_3 North Carolina Catawba 657 1969 2009

St Johns River Power Park 207_B_1 Florida Duval 626 1987 2009

Ghent 1356_B_2 Kentucky Car roll 469 1977 2009

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_1 Maryland Prince George's 341 1964 2009

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_2 Maryland Prince George's 342 1965 2009

San Juan 2451_B_2 New Mexico San Juan 320 1973 2009

Big Bend 645_B_BB01 Florida Hillsborough 411 1970 200 9

Big Bend 645_B_BB02 Florida Hillsborough 391 1973 2009

Big Bend 645_B_BB03 Florida Hillsborough 414 1976 2009

Nebraska City Unit 2 6096_B_2 Nebraska Otoe 663 2009 2009

Cross 130_B_4 South Carolina Berkeley 652 2009 2009

Springerville 8223_B_4 Arizon a Apache 400 2009 2009

Sandow 5 82010_B_5 Texas Milam 600 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_1 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_2 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

TS Power Plant 82013_B_1 Nevada Eureka 200 2009 2009

Plum Point Energy 82014_B_1 Ar kansas Mississippi 665 2009 2009

Comanche 470_B_3 Colorado Pueblo 750 2009 2009

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_1 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2009 2009

Two Elk Generating Station 55360_B_1 Wyoming Campbell 300 2009 2009

J K Spruce 7097_B_BLR2 Texas Bex ar 750 2009 2009

Dallman 963_B_34 Illinois Sangamon 200 2009 2009

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_4 New York Yates 27 1950 2008

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_5 New York Yates 27 1950 2008

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_6 New York Yates 106 1953 2008

Charles R Lowman 56 _B_2 Alabama Washington 238 1979 2008

Charles R Lowman 56_B_3 Alabama Washington 238 1980 2008

Barry 3_B_5 Alabama Mobile 750 1971 2008

St Johns River Power Park 207_B_2 Florida Duval 626 1988 2008

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_2 Maryland Charles 620 1971 2008

### 2

Bailly 995_B_7 Indiana Porter 160 1962 2008

San Juan 2451_B_1 New Mexico San Juan 322 1976 2008

San Juan 2451_B_3 New Mexico San Juan 495 1979 2008

Weston 4078_B_4 Wisconsin Marathon 519 2008 2008

AES Deepwater 10670_B_AAB001 Texas Harri s 140 1986 2007

La Cygne 1241_B_1 Kansas Linn 724 1973 2007

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_1 Maryland Charles 624 1970 2007

PSEG Hudson Generating Station 2403_B_2 New Jersey Hudson 583 1967 2007

San Juan 2451_B_4 New Mexico San Juan 506 1982 2007

Big Bend 645_B_BB04 Florida Hillsborough 457 1985 2007

Cross 130_B_3 South Carolina Berkeley 620 2007 2007

Wygen II 55479_B_4 Wyoming Campbell 90 2007 2007

Council Bluffs 1082_B_4 Iowa Pottawattamie 790 2007 2007



## SO2 Controls (FGDs, 2007

– 2012)

Plan t Name UniqueID_Final State Name County Capacity

MW On Line

Year Scrubber

Online

Year

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_1 Alabama Jefferson 684 1978 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_2 Alabama Jefferson 687 1985 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_3 Alabama Jefferson 687 1989 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_4 Alabama Jefferson 688 1991 2011

Cape Fear 2708_B_5 North Carolina Chatham 143 1956 2011

Baldwin Energy Complex 889_B_1 Illinois Randolph 624 1970 2011

Baldwin Energy Complex 889_B_2 Illinois Randolph 629 1973 2011

Baldwin Energy Complex 889_B_3 Illinois Randolph 629 1975 2011

Scherer 6257_B_3 Georgia Monroe 875 1987 2011

Milton R Young 2823_B_B1 North Dakota Oliver 250 1970 2011

W H Sammis 2866_B_6 Ohio Jefferson 630 1969 2011

W H Sammis 2866_B_7 Ohio Jefferson 630 1971 2011

PSEG Hudson Generating Station 2403_B_2 New Jersey Hudson 583 1967 2011

John Sevier 3405_B_1 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1955 2011

John Sevier 3405_B_2 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1955 2011

John Sevier 3405_B_3 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1956 2011

John S evier 3405_B_4 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1957 2011

Beech Hollow Power Project 82704_B_1 Pennsylvania Washington 272 2011 2011

Longview Power 82702_B_1 West Virginia Monongalia 695 2011 2011

Cliffside 2721_B_6 North Carolina Cleveland 800 2011 2011

AES Gree nidge LLC 2527_B_4 New York Yates 27 1950 2010

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_5 New York Yates 27 1950 2010

Barry 3_B_5 Alabama Mobile 750 1971 2010

E C Gaston 26_B_5 Alabama Shelby 861 1974 2010

Warrick 6705_B_4 Indiana Warrick 300 1970 2010

Coffeen 861_B_ 01 Illinois Montgomery 340 1965 2010

Coffeen 861_B_02 Illinois Montgomery 560 1972 2010

Cardinal 2828_B_3 Ohio Jefferson 630 1977 2010

Brandon Shores 602_B_1 Maryland Anne Arundel 643 1984 2010

Brandon Shores 602_B_2 Maryland Anne Arundel 643 1991 2010

Monroe 1733_B_4 Michigan Monroe 775 1974 2010

Cliffside 2721_B_5 North Carolina Cleveland 550 1972 2010

Crystal River 628_B_4 Florida Citrus 720 1982 2010

Bowen 703_B_1BLR Georgia Bartow 713 1971 2010

### 3

Crist 641_B_6 Florida Escambia 302 1970 2010

Cri st 641_B_7 Florida Escambia 477 1973 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_1 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_2 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_3 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_4 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 201 0

Clifty Creek 983_B_5 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_6 Indiana Jefferson 217 1956 2010

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_1 Maryland Prince George's 341 1964 2010

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_2 Maryland Prince George's 342 1965 2010

Dickerson 1572_ B_1 Maryland Montgomery 182 1959 2010

Dickerson 1572_B_2 Maryland Montgomery 182 1960 2010

Dickerson 1572_B_3 Maryland Montgomery 182 1962 2010

R E Burger 2864_B_7 Ohio Belmont 156 1955 2010

R E Burger 2864_B_8 Ohio Belmont 156 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2 876_B_1 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_2 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_3 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_4 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_5 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Cheswick 8226_B_1 Pennsylvani a Allegheny 580 1970 2010

PSEG Mercer Generating Station 2408_B_1 New Jersey Mercer 315 1960 2010

PSEG Mercer Generating Station 2408_B_2 New Jersey Mercer 310 1961 2010

Silver Lake 2008_B_4 Minnesota Olmsted 61 1969 2010

Kingston 3407_B_1 Tennessee Ro ane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_2 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_3 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_4 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_5 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kingston 3407_B_6 Tennessee Roane 177 195 5 2010

Kingston 3407_B_7 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kingston 3407_B_8 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kingston 3407_B_9 Tennessee Roane 178 1955 2010

Sioux 2107_B_1 Missouri St. Charles 497 1967 2010

Sioux 2107_B_2 Missouri St. Charles 497 1968 2010

Chesterfield 3797_B_5 Virginia Chesterfield 310 1964 2010

Yorktown 3809_B_1 Virginia York 159 1957 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_11 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_12 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_13 New York Broome 84 1 951 2010

Iatan 2 6065_B_2 Missouri Platte 850 2010 2010

Southwest 6195_B_2 Missouri Greene 300 2010 2010

Trimble Station (LGE) 6071_B_2 Kentucky Trimble 732 2010 2010

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_2 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2010 2010

Cholla 113_B _3 Arizona Navajo 271 1980 2009

Mayo 6250_B_1A North Carolina Person 362 1983 2009

Mayo 6250_B_1B North Carolina Person 362 1983 2009

Conesville 2840_B_4 Ohio Coshocton 780 1973 2009

G G Allen 2718_B_1 North Carolina Gaston 162 1957 2009

G G Allen 271 8_B_2 North Carolina Gaston 162 1957 2009

G G Allen 2718_B_3 North Carolina Gaston 260 1959 2009

### 4

G G Allen 2718_B_4 North Carolina Gaston 275 1960 2009

G G Allen 2718_B_5 North Carolina Gaston 265 1961 2009

H L Spurlock 6041_B_1 Kentucky Mason 315 1977 2009

Crystal River 628_B_5 Florida Citrus 717 1984 2009

Deerhaven Generating Station 663_B_B2 Florida Alachua 228 1981 2009

Bowen 703_B_2BLR Georgia Bartow 718 1972 2009

Wansley 6052_B_2 Georgia Heard 892 1978 2009

E W Brown 1355_B_1 Kentucky Mercer 94 1957 2009

E W Brown 1355_B_2 Kentucky Mercer 160 1963 2009

E W Brown 1355_B_3 Kentucky Mercer 422 1971 2009

Ghent 1356_B_2 Kentucky Carroll 469 1977 2009

Fayette Power Project 6179_B_1 Texas Fayette 598 1979 2009

Fayette Power Project 6179_B_2 Texa s Fayette 598 1980 2009

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_1 Maryland Charles 624 1970 2009

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_2 Maryland Charles 620 1971 2009

PPL Brunner Island 3140_B_1 Pennsylvania York 321 1961 2009

PPL Brunner Island 3140_B_2 Penn sylvania York 378 1965 2009

Keystone 3136_B_1 Pennsylvania Armstrong 850 1967 2009

Keystone 3136_B_2 Pennsylvania Armstrong 850 1968 2009

Bull Run 3396_B_1 Tennessee Anderson 881 1967 2009

Bay Shore 2878_B_4 Ohio Lucas 215 1968 2009

Hatfields Ferry Po wer Station 3179_B_1 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1969 2009

Hatfields Ferry Power Station 3179_B_2 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1970 2009

Hatfields Ferry Power Station 3179_B_3 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1971 2009

Nebraska City Unit 2 6096_B_2 Nebraska Otoe 663 2009 2009

Cross 130_B_4 South Carolina Berkeley 652 2009 2009

Springerville 8223_B_4 Arizona Apache 400 2009 2009

Sandow 5 82010_B_5 Texas Milam 600 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_1 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_2 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2 009

TS Power Plant 82013_B_1 Nevada Eureka 200 2009 2009

Plum Point Energy 82014_B_1 Arkansas Mississippi 665 2009 2009

Comanche 470_B_3 Colorado Pueblo 750 2009 2009

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_1 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2009 2009

Two Elk Gene rating Station 55360_B_1 Wyoming Campbell 300 2009 2009

J K Spruce 7097_B_BLR2 Texas Bexar 750 2009 2009

Dallman 963_B_34 Illinois Sangamon 200 2009 2009

Charles R Lowman 56_B_1 Alabama Washington 86 1969 2008

John E Amos 3935_B_1 West Virginia Putnam 800 1971 2008

John E Amos 3935_B_2 West Virginia Putnam 800 1972 2008

Cholla 113_B_4 Arizona Navajo 380 1981 2008

Roxboro 2712_B_1 North Carolina Person 369 1966 2008

Roxboro 2712_B_3A North Carolina Person 341 1973 2008

Roxboro 2712_B_3B North Caroli na Person 341 1973 2008

Miami Fort 2832_B_7 Ohio Hamilton 500 1975 2008

Miami Fort 2832_B_8 Ohio Hamilton 500 1978 2008

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_2A Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_2B Virginia Port smouth 19 1988 2008

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_2C Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

J M Stuart 2850_B_1 Ohio Adams 585 1971 2008

J M Stuart 2850_B_2 Ohio Adams 597 1970 2008

### 5

J M Stuart 2850_B_3 Ohio Adams 597 1972 2008

J M Stuart 2850_B_4 Ohio Adams 597 1974 2008

Monroe 1733_B_3 Michigan Monroe 795 1973 2008

Belews Creek 8042_B_1 North Carolina Stokes 1,115 1974 2008

Belews Creek 8042_B_2 North Carolina Stokes 1,115 1975 2008

Bowen 703_B_3BLR Georgia Bartow 902 1974 2008

Bowen 703_B_4B LR Georgia Bartow 929 1975 2008

Hammond 708_B_1 Georgia Floyd 112 1954 2008

Hammond 708_B_2 Georgia Floyd 112 1954 2008

Hammond 708_B_3 Georgia Floyd 112 1955 2008

Hammond 708_B_4 Georgia Floyd 510 1970 2008

Wansley 6052_B_1 Georgia Heard 891 1976 200 8

Harding Street 990_B_70 Indiana Marion 435 1973 2008

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_1A Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2008

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_1B Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2008

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_1C Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 198 7 2008

Ghent 1356_B_4 Kentucky Carroll 478 1984 2008

Council Bluffs 1082_B_3 Iowa Pottawattamie 690 1978 2008

PPL Brunner Island 3140_B_3 Pennsylvania York 749 1969 2008

PPL Montour 3149_B_1 Pennsylvania Montour 774 1972 2008

PPL Montour 3149_B_2 Penn sylvania Montour 766 1973 2008

Comanche 470_B_1 Colorado Pueblo 366 1973 2008

Comanche 470_B_2 Colorado Pueblo 370 1975 2008

Cayuga 1001_B_2 Indiana VermilIon 473 1972 2008

Winyah 6249_B_1 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1975 2008

Winyah 6249_B_2 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1977 2008

Winyah 6249_B_3 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1980 2008

Chesterfield 3797_B_6 Virginia Chesterfield 658 1969 2008

Brayton Point 1619_B_1 Massachusetts Bristo 243 1963 2008

Brayton Point 1619_B_2 Massachusetts Bristo 24 4 1964 2008

Weston 4078_B_4 Wisconsin Marathon 519 2008 2008

Gorgas 8_B_10 Alabama Walker 690 1972 2007

Gorgas 8_B_8 Alabama Walker 165 1956 2007

Gorgas 8_B_9 Alabama Walker 175 1958 2007

John E Amos 3935_B_3 West Virginia Putnam 1,300 1973 2007

Moun taineer 6264_B_1 West Virginia Mason 1,300 1980 2007

Cardinal 2828_B_1 Ohio Jefferson 600 1967 2007

Cardinal 2828_B_2 Ohio Jefferson 600 1967 2007

Roxboro 2712_B_2 North Carolina Person 639 1968 2007

Roxboro 2712_B_4A North Carolina Person 343 1980 200 7

Roxboro 2712_B_4B North Carolina Person 343 1980 2007

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_1A Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_1B Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_1C V irginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Killen Station 6031_B_2 Ohio Adams 615 1982 2007

Marshall 2727_B_2 North Carolina Catawba 378 1966 2007

Marshall 2727_B_3 North Carolina Catawba 657 1969 2007

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_2A Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 198 7 2007

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_2B Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2007

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_2C Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2007

Ghent 1356_B_3 Kentucky Carroll 478 1981 2007

### 6

Louisa 6664_B_101 Iowa Louisa 700 1983 2007

Allen S King 1915_ B_1 Minnesota Washington 571 1968 2007

Mitchell 3948_B_1 West Virginia Marshall 800 1971 2007

Gibson 6113_B_1 Indiana Gibson 630 1975 2007

Gibson 6113_B_2 Indiana Gibson 628 1975 2007

Winyah 6249_B_4 South Carolina Georgetown 270 1981 2007

Pleasant Pr airie 6170_B_2 Wisconsin Kenosha 617 1985 2007

Cross 130_B_3 South Carolina Berkeley 620 2007 2007

Wygen II 55479_B_4 Wyoming Campbell 90 2007 2007

Council Bluffs 1082_B_4 Iowa Pottawattamie 790 2007 2007



## Assumed BART Facilities and Units

State County Fac ID Facilit y Name Unit ID

MI Bay B2840 CE

- KARN/WEADOCK EU00036

MI Bay B2840 CE

- KARN/WEADOCK EU00037

MI Eaton B4001 LAN. BW&L ERICKSON EU00007

MI Houghton B6553 UP POWER CO / PORTAGE EU00008

MI Huron B2815 DTE

- HARBOR BEACH EU00009

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RG00023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RG00023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RG00023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Moores Park RG00021

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00029

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00030

MI Marq uette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00031

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00032

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00033

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00062

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00068

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00063

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00064

MI Ottawa B2835 CE

– CAMPBELL EU00062

MI Ottawa B2835 CE

– CAMPBELL EU00061

MI Saint Clair B2796 DTE

- ST. CLAIR / BELLE RIVER EU00111

MI Saint Clair B6145 DTE

– GREENWOOD EU00009

MI Wayne B2132 WYANDOTTE EU00036

MI Wayne B2185 DET ROIT PLD, MISTERSKY EU00014

MI Wayne B2811 DTE

– TRENTON EU00035

OH Lake 0243160009 CEI., EASTLAKE PLANT B005

OH 0247030013 Orion Power Midwest B012

OH 0285010188 Dept of Public Utilities, City of Orrville B001

OH 0285010188 Dept of Public Utilities, City of Orrville B004

OH 0448020006 Toledo Edison Co., Bay Shore B003

OH 0448020006 Toledo Edison Co., Bay Shor e B004

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B003

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B004

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Pl ant B007

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B001

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B002

### 7

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B003

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B004

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B008

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power P l ant B009

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B009

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W. H. SAMMIS PLANT B011

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W. H. SAMMIS PLANT B012

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W. H. SAMMIS PLANT B013

OH 0684000000 Muskingum River Power Plant B006

OH Ada ms 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B001

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B002

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B003

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B004

OH 070100 0060 DP&L, Killen Station B001

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B002

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B008

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B009

OH 1413100008 CG&E W. C. BECKJORD B005

OH 1413100008 CG&E W. C. BECKJORD B006

OH 1431350093 CG&E MIAMI FORT STATION B015

IL Peoria 856 Ameren

– Edwards 2

IL Sangamon 963 CWLP

– Dallman 31

IL Sangamon 963 CWLP

– Dallman 32

IL Christian 876 Dominion

– Kincaid 1

IL Christian 87 6 Dominion

– Kincaid 2

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant En ergy

- Columbia Generating B20

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant En ergy

- Columbia Generating B21

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant En ergy

- Columbia Generating B22

WI GRANT 122014530 Alliant Energy, Nelso n Dewey B22 (unit 2)

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Energies

- Oak Creek Station B26 (Unit 6)

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Energies

- Oak Creek Station B27 (Unit 7)

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Energies

- Oak Creek Station B28

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Energies

- Valley Station B21

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Energies

- Valley Station B23

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Energies

- Valley Station B24

WI BRO WN 405031990 WI Public Service Corp

- JP Pulliam B27 (unit 8)

WI SHEBOYGAN 460033090 WP & L Allian t Energy

– Edgewater B24

W I BUFFALO 606034110 Dairyland Power Coop Alma Station

(J.P. Madgett boilers) B25 (+B26)

WI BUFFALO 606034110 Dairyland Power Coop Alma Station B27

WI VERNON 663020930 Dairyland Power Coop Genoa Station B20

WI VERNON 663020930 Dairyland Power Coop Genoa Station B25

IN Porter 995 Bailly 7

IN Porter 995 Bailly 8

IN Vermillion 1001 Cayuga 1

IN Vermillion 1001 Cayuga 2

IN Montgomery 1024 Crawfordsville 6

IN Warrick 1012 Culley 2

### 8

IN Warrick 1012 Culley 3

IN Gibson 6113 Gibson 1

IN Gibson 6113 Gi bson 2

IN Cass 1032 Logansport 6

IN Sullivan 6213 Merom 1

IN Sullivan 6213 Merom 2

IN LaPorte 997 Michigan City 12

IN Lake 996 Mitchell 11

IN Pike 994 Petersburg 1

IN Pike 994 Petersburg 2

IN Pike 994 Petersburg 3

IN Pike 1043 Ratts 1

IN Pike 104 3 Ratts 2

IN Wayne 7335 RPL 2

IN Jasper 6085 Schahfer 14

IN Jasper 6085 Schahfer 15

IN Lake 981 Stateline 4

IN Marion 990 Stout 70

IN Dearborn 988 Tanners Creek 4

IN Vigo 1010 Wabash River 6

IN Warrick 6705 Warrick 4

IA 07

- 02

- 005 Cedar Fal ls Utilities Unit #7 (EU10.1A)

IA 88

- 01

- 004 Central Iowa Power Cooperative

(CIPCO)

– Summit Lake Station Comb Turbines (EU

1 /1G , EU2 /2 G)

IA 70

- 08

- 003 Central Iowa Power Cooperative

(CIPCO)

– Fair Station Unit # 2 (EU 2 &

EU 2G)

IA 85

- 01

- 006 City of Am es

- Steam Electric Plant Boiler #7 (EU 2)

IA 29

- 01

- 013 Interstate Power & Light

- Burlington Main Plant Boiler.

IA 03

- 03

- 001 Interstate Power & Light

- Lansing Boiler #4. Sixteen

units in total.

IA 23

- 01

- 014 Interstate Power & Light

- ML Kapp Boiler #2. Six units

in total.

IA 57

- 01

- 042 Interstate Power & Light

- Prairie Creek Boiler #4. Fourteen

units in total.

IA 78

- 01

- 026 MidAmerican Energy Co

- Council Bluffs Boiler #3 (EU003)

IA 97

- 04

- 010 MidAmerican Energy Co

- Neal North Boilers #1

- 3

(EU0 01

- EU003)

IA 97

- 04

- 011 MidAmerican Energy Co

- Neal South Boiler #4 (EU003)

IA 70

- 01

- 011 Muscatine Power and Water Boiler #8

IA 63

- 02

- 005 Pella Municipal Power Plant Boilers #6

- 8

MN 2709900001 Austin Utilities NE Power Station EU001

MN 27 13700027 Hibbing Public Utilities EU003

MN 2703100001 MN Power, Taconite Harbor EU003

MN 2706100004 MN Power, Boswell Energy Center EU003

MN 2701500010 New Ulm Public Utilities EU003

- Boiler 4

MN 2711100002 Otter Tail Power Hoot Lake EU003

MN 27 10900011 Rochester Public Utilities, Silver Lake EU003

MN 2710900011 Rochester Public Utilities, Silver Lake EU004

MN 2713700028 Virginia Public Utilities EU003

- Boiler 9

MN 2714100004 Xcel Energy, Sherco EU001, EU002

MN 2716300005 Xcel Energy, Allen S King EU001

- Boiler 1

### 9

MN 2705300015 Xcel Energy, Riverside EU003

- Boiler 8

MO 290710003 Ameren

- Labadie B1, B2, B3, B4

MO 291830001 Ameren

- Sioux B1, B2

MO 290990016 Ameren

- Rush Island B1, B2

MO 290950031 Auila

- Sibley B3

- 5C

MO 291430004 Assoc. Electric

- New Madrid B1(EP

- 01), B2

(EP

- 02)

MO 290770039 City Utilities Springfield

- Southwest B1 (E09)

MO 290770005 City Utilities Springfield

- James River EO7, EO8

MO 290970001 Empire Distric Electric

- Asbury B7

MO 29083 0001 KC Power and Light

- Montrose EP08

MO 290210004 Aqula

- Lake Road EP06

MO 291750001 Assoc. Electric

- Thomas Hill EP01, EP02

MO 290950021 Trigen

- Kansas City B1A

MO 290190002 City of Columbia Municipal Power Plant EP02

MO 291950010 Marshall Munipal Utilities EP05

MO 290950050 Independence Power & Light

- Blue Valley B3 (EP05)

WV 3943 Fort Martin

WV 6004 Pleasants

WV 3948 Mitchell

WV 3935 Amos

WV 6264 Mountaineer

WV 3944 Harrison

TN 3396 TVA Bull Run

TN 3399 TVA Cumberland

KY 1363 Cane Run

KY 1364 Mill Creek

KY 6041 Spurlock

KY 1384 John Sherman Cooper

KY 1353 Big Sandy

KY 1356 Ghent

KY 1355 Brown

KY 1374 Owensboro Municipal

KY 1372 Henderson Municipal

KY 1378 Paradise

KY 1361 Coleman

KY 1382 Reid/Henderson 2

KY 6639 Green

### 1



## Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM2.5, and Regional Haze:

Final Technical Support Document ( Supplement ), September 12, 2008

The purpose of this paper is to summarize a new modeling analysis performed by the Lake

Michigan Air Dir ectors Consorti um (LADCO) to address the effect of the recent court decision

vacat ing EPA’s Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). This new modeling is intended to supplem ent

the LADCO Technical Support Document (“ Regional Air Quality Analyses for Ozone, PM2.5,

and Regional Haze: Final Technical Support Document”, April 25, 2008) , which summarizes the

air quality analyses conducted by LADCO and its contractors to support the development of

State Implementation Plans for ozone, PM2.5, and regional haze in the States of Illinoi s, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin

.

Compared to the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1), the new modeling shows similar

results for ozone, but much more nonattainment for PM2.5 and higher visibility levels for

regional haze. Specifically, the new modeling shows:

Ozone : Attainment of the 0.08 ppm standard by 2009 everywhere in the region, except

Holland, MI , and n onattainment of the 0.075 ppm standard through at least 2018.

PM2.5 : Widespread nonattainment of annual (15 ug/m 3 

### ) and daily (35 ug/m 3 

### ) standards.

Haze : Higher visibility levels on the 20% worst visibility days in 2018 in Class I areas in

the eastern U.S., resulting in most areas being above the glide path.

Background : On July 11, 2008, the U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit v acated EPA’s CAIR

rule (cite). The reductions in NOx and SO2 emissions associated with this rule were a key part

of the LADCO States’ attainment demonstrations for ozone and PM2.5 and the reasonable

progress determinations for regional haze . LADCO’s prev ious modeling (Round 5.1) relied on

EGU emission projections from EPA’s IPM3.0 analysis, which assumed implementation of

Phases I and II of CAIR. For this new modeling, alternative EGU emission projections were

developed , which did not rely on CAIR (or IP M).

Model Set

- Up : The new modeling was performed consistent with LADCO’s previous modeling

(Round 5.1):

Model Version: CAMx v4.50beta_deposition

Future Years: 2009, 2012, 2018

Runs: (a) Ozone : Summer 2005 meteorology with 12 km grids

(b) PM2.5 an d haze : F ull year 2005 meteorology with 36 km grids



### Emission Scenarios: The new modeling assumed the same set of “on the books” controls as

in LADCO’s previous modeling (Round 5.1) for all sectors, except EGUs. In light of the CAIR

decision, three new E GU scenarios were prepared:

### 2

Scenario A: 2007 CEM

- based emissions w ere projected for all states in the modeling domain

based on EIA growth rates by state (NERC region) and fuel type. The assumed growth rates for

the Midwest States were: MAIN (IL, IA, MO, WI): 8.8% (2007

- 2018); ECAR (IN, KY, MI, OH):

13.5% (2007

- 2018); and MAPP (MN): 15.1% (2007

- 2018). No control w as applied. The annual

emissions w ere temporalized based on profiles derived from 2004

- 2006 CEM data. (Note, these

are the same temporal prof iles used in R ound 5.1 .)

Scenario B. Scenario A emissions for the LADCO States and select neighboring states (e.g.,

MN, IA, MO, KY, TN, and WV) w ere adjusted by applying legally enforceable controls (i.e.,

emission reductions required by a Consent Decree , state rule, or permit). Only those legally

enforceable controls identified (and justified) by the States w ere applied. The States also

supplied the appropriate control factors. A table summarizing the Scenario B con trols is provided

in Appendix I.

Sc enario C. For the years 2009 and 2012, Scenario A emissions for all states w ere adjusted by

applying all planned SO2 and NOx controls based on the July 10 CAMD list (i.e., 9 0 % reduction

for scrubbers, 9 5 % reduction for SCRs). Because the July 10 CAMD list only includes controls

generally out to 2011, additional SO2 and NOx controls for the year 2018 w ere assumed for all

BART

- eligible EGUs in the five LADCO State plus MN, IA, MO, KY, TN, and MO list (i.e., 9 0 %

reduction for scrubbers, 9 5 % reduction for SCRs )

. 1 

### A ll Scenario B controls we re included in

Scenario C. A table summarizing the Scenario C controls is provided in Appendix II.



### Table 1 and Figure 1 provide a summary of the 5

- state regional NOx and SO2 emissions for

each scenario and future year. (No te, the CAIR emissions included here are based on EPA’s

IPM3.0 modeling.) Several comments on the emissions should be noted:

Summer NOx

• There is ll ittle difference between the three alternative scenarios and CAIR . T his

suggests that summer ozone concen trations for the alternative scenarios are

likely to be similar to those predicted with CAIR (i.e., Round 5.1).

Annual NOx:

• There is a s ignificant change in emissions between scenarios , mostly during the

non

- summer months.

• Scenario B reflects application of NOx controls in several states (e.g., IL,OH, WI).

• Because there are relatively few SCRs (in the LADCO States) on the CAMD list,

Scenario C results in only a small emissions decrease compared to Scenario B

.

• Assumed BART controls result in a significant em issions decrease.

Annual SO2

• There is a s ignificant change in emissions between scenarios

.

• Scenario B reflects application of SO2 controls in several states (e.g., I L,OH, WI).

• Because there are several FGD s (in the LADCO States) on the CAMD list,

Scenario C results in a large emissions decrease compared to Scenario B

.

• Assumed BART controls result in a significant emissions decrease (i.e., even

lower emissions than t he IPM

- estimated CAIR emissions).

1 

### A subsequent analysis was conducted with the following inventory changes: (a) 95% reduction for

scrubbers, 90% redcuction for SCRs (consistent with EPA’s default assumptions for IPM), and (b)

revisions provided for a few plants in Indiana and Minnesota. The changes resulted in a relatively small

difference in the regioinal NOx and SO2 emissions (e.g., about a 2% NOx increase and about a 1

- 2%

decrease in SO2). To assess the impact of the chan ges, PM2.5 modleing was conducted with the new

Scenario B and Scenario C emissions for 2012. The modeling showed little change in the predicted

PM2.5 concentrations.

### 3 

### Figure 1. Regional NOx and SO2 Emissions

Summe r NO x Emi ss ions

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000

2005 2007 200

9A 200 9B 200 9C

200 9 C AIR 201 2A 201 2B 201 2C

201 2 C AIR 201 8A 201 8B 201 8C

201 8BART

201 8 C AIR



### Annu al NO x Emi ss ions

0 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 1,000,000

2005 2007 200

9A 200 9B 200 9C

200 9 C AIR 201 2A 201 2B 201 2C

201 2 C AIR 201 8A 201 8B 201 8C

201 8BART

201 8 C AIR



### Annu al SO2 Emi ss ions

0 500,000 1,000,000 1,500,000 2,000,000 2,500,000 3,000,000

2005 2007 200

9A 200 9B 200 9C

200 9 C AIR 201 2A 201 2B 201 2C

201 2 C AIR 201 8A 201 8B 201 8C

201 8BART

201 8 C AIR

### 4 

### Table 1. Regional NOx and SO2 Emissions



# Summer NOx Emissions (TPD)

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C 2010

CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C 2012

CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C 2018 C

BART 2018

CAIR

IL 305 305 311 311 311 275 340 236 236 266 333 227 227 219 224

I N 393 393 376 376 374 384 393 393 390 368 410 386 383 292 264

MI 393 393 350 350 350 242 366 366 366 229 377 377 377 260 243

OH 408 408 395 355 335 285 423 351 351 290 431 366 366 230 290

WI 413 413 167 160 160 238 184 170 170 177 183 168 168 168 17 7

1,912 1,912 1,599 1,552 1,530 1,424 1,706 1,516 1,513 1,330 1,734 1,524 1,521 1,169 1,198



# Annual NOx Emissions (TPY)

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C 2010

CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C 2012

CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C 2018 C

BART 2018

CAIR

IL 126,786 121,006 124,917 124,917 124,917 83,224 137,438 81,989 81,989 82,248 135,983 79,771 79,771 63,590 69,958

IN 214,727 203,493 203,776 203,776 201,947 133,188 212,790 212,790 210,877 125,541 221,950 212,805 210,81 0 177,027 90,415

MI 120,332 112,484 112,478 112,478 112,478 83,117 117,621 117,621 117,621 77,897 122,447 122,447 122,447 89,444 79,543

OH 255,554 240,351 240,016 173,071 164,911 94,346 251,065 172,514 172,514 97,679 261,644 179,737 179,737 125,762 95, 678

WI 71,414 54,582 56,540 54,065 54,065 53,032 62,266 57,759 57,759 56,480 61,812 56,952 56,952 56,952 56,158

788,812 731,917 737,727 668,307 658,317 446,908 781,179 642,673 640,760 439,845 803,837 651,712 649,717 512,774 391,752



# Annual SO2 Emissions (TPY)

2005 2007 2009 A 2009 B 2009 C 2010

CAIR 2012 A 2012 B 2012 C 2012

CAIR 2018 A 2018 B 2018 C 2018 C

BART 2018

CAIR

IL 326,598 273,467 281,028 281,028 281,028 295,516 309,209 196,238 194,746 267,1 10 305,364 106,638 105,152 82,351 275,716

IN 866,964 722,301 721,252 721,252 619,486 374,335 754,323 754,323 558,567 379,144 786,551 764,065 559,945 426,695 359,915

MI 350,694 343,487 343,140 343,140 315,326 227,296 358,879 358,879 301,062 233,204 373, 964 373,964 313,677 178,680 242,853

OH 1,100,510 960,820 959,466 959,466 693,438 427,145 1,003,633 897,099 572,807 370,532 1,045,945 819,770 481,623 333,740 315,560

WI 181,426 137,562 142,007 142,007 133,738 139,181 156,659 144,818 133,592 139,203 155, 818 144,027 132,849 77,214 127,073

2,826,192 2,437,638 2,446,892 2,446,892 2,043,017 1,463,473 2,582,703 2,351,356 1,760,775 1,389,192 2,667,641 2,208,463 1,593,245 1,098,679 1,321,116

### 5



### Modeling Results: Several tables summarizing the modeling result s are provided:

Table 2

- future year ozone and PM2.5 concentrations for key monitors in the

LADCO region

Table 3

- number of monitoring sites greater than the National Ambient Air Quality

Standards (NNAQS)

Table 4

–

visibility levels fo r Class I areas in the eastern U.S.

Note, given that Scenario B and BART controls were only applied in an 11

- state Midwest

region, the validity of the results for other Class I areas in the eastern U.S. may be

questionable. The Scenario C controls, on the other hand, cover all states and are, thus,

likely valid in other Class I areas.

Spatial plots of the future year ozone and PM2.5 concentrations are provided in Figures 2

– 4.

Based on these results, the following key findings should be noted:

Ozone

• There is little change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1 with CAIR)

• The modeling shows a ttainment of the 0.08 ppm (85 ppb) standard by 2009,

except Holland. (Note, Holland does meet this standard by 2012.)

• The modeling shows nonattainm ent of the 0.075 ppm (75 ppb) standard through

2018.

PM2.5

- Annual

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• The modeling shows extensive non atta inment of the annual standard.

PM2.5

- Daily

• There is a signif icant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• Th e modeling shows extensive nonattainment of the daily standard.

Haze

• There is a significant change from the previous LADCO modeling (Round 5.1

with CAIR)

• T he modeling shows higher vis ibility levels in 2018 for the 20% worst visibility

days (average about 0.5 deciviews for the northern Class I areas ). The resulting

visibility levels in the northern Class I areas (except Voyageurs) a re above t he

glide path.2005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Site Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen.C-BART

Lake Michigan Area

Chiwaukee 550590019 84.7 82.2 82.2 82.0 82.3 81.1 80.8 80.6 80.9 77.2 77.2 77.0 76.0 76.2

Racine 551010017 80.3 77.8 77.8 77.5 77.5 76.6 76.2 76.1 76.1 72.9 72.3 72.1 71.1 71.2

Milwaukee-Bayside 550890085 82.7 79.9 79.9 79.7 79.8 78.5 78.0 78.0 78.0 74.3 73.6 73.4 72.4 72.7

Harrington Beach 550890009 83.3 80.1 80.1 79.9 80.1 78.6 78.1 78.0 78.3 73.9 73.2 73.1 72.2 72.5

Manitowoc 550710007 85.0 80.8 80.8 80.7 80.8 79.0 78.5 78.4 78.6 73.9 73.2 73.1 72.0 72.5

Sheboygan 551170006 88.0 84.1 84.0 83.9 84.0 82.2 81.7 81.5 81.8 76.9 76.0 75.9 74.8 75.4

Kewaunee 550610002 82.7 78.2 78.2 78.0 78.1 76.4 75.9 75.7 75.9 71.3 70.7 70.5 69.4 69.9

Door County 550290004 88.7 84.1 84.1 83.9 83.9 82.0 81.4 81.3 81.5 76.5 75.6 75.5 74.2 74.7

Hammond 180892008 77.7 76.2 76.2 76.0 75.4 75.6 75.3 75.2 74.6 73.2 72.7 72.6 71.7 71.6

Whiting 180890030 79.3 77.8 77.8 77.7 77.0 77.2 76.9 76.8 76.2 74.8 74.3 74.2 73.2 73.1

Michigan City 180910005 77.0 74.5 74.5 74.3 73.9 73.3 72.9 72.8 72.5 69.7 69.2 69.1 68.1 68.1

Ogden Dunes 181270020 78.3 76.3 76.3 76.2 75.6 75.5 75.1 75.0 74.5 72.9 72.3 72.1 71.2 70.8

Holland 260050003 90.0 85.7 85.7 85.5 85.3 83.5 83.1 82.9 82.8 78.2 77.5 77.3 76.0 76.1

Jenison 261390005 82.0 76.8 76.8 76.7 76.0 75.1 74.6 74.5 74.5 70.2 69.6 69.5 67.9 68.7

Muskegon 261210039 85.0 80.6 80.6 80.5 80.5 78.6 78.2 78.1 78.0 73.5 72.8 72.8 71.5 71.9

Indianapolis Area

Noblesville 189571001 82.7 78.3 78.3 78.1 78.1 76.1 75.9 75.7 75.6 70.2 69.9 69.8 68.9 68.7

Fortville 180590003 78.0 74.1 74.1 73.9 73.9 71.9 71.8 71.7 71.4 66.7 66.5 66.3 65.4 65.1

Fort B. Harrison 180970050 78.7 75.4 75.3 75.2 75.1 73.8 73.6 73.6 73.2 70.6 70.3 70.2 69.3 69.1

Detroit Area

New Haven 260990009 86.0 82.4 82.3 82.1 81.4 81.4 81.2 81.1 80.2 78.1 77.8 77.7 76.5 76.1

Warren 260991003 84.0 82.4 82.3 82.2 81.3 82.1 81.8 81.7 80.7 79.7 79.4 79.3 78.0 77.6

Port Huron 261470005 82.7 78.2 78.2 78.1 77.5 76.5 76.3 76.2 75.5 72.6 72.5 72.3 70.9 70.9

Cleveland Area

Ashtabula 390071001 89.0 84.2 84.1 83.9 83.4 82.0 81.8 81.6 81.0 76.8 76.5 76.4 74.8 75.1

Geauga 390550004 79.3 75.8 75.8 75.6 74.7 74.0 73.8 73.7 72.7 69.5 69.2 69.1 67.6 67.3

Eastlake 390850003 86.3 83.1 83.1 82.9 81.9 81.8 81.6 81.5 80.5 78.2 78.0 77.8 76.5 76.2

Akron 391530020 83.7 79.1 79.1 79.0 78.1 76.9 76.7 76.6 75.6 70.9 70.6 70.4 68.7 68.7

Cincinnati Area

Wilmington 390271002 82.3 77.3 77.4 77.1 77.5 75.3 75.2 74.8 74.9 70.1 69.9 69.5 67.1 68.3

Sycamore 390610006 84.7 81.5 81.4 81.1 81.9 80.4 80.2 79.8 80.3 76.4 76.0 75.7 73.5 74.6

Lebanon 391650007 87.7 82.8 82.8 82.4 83.0 80.8 80.7 80.3 80.7 75.4 75.1 74.8 72.6 74.2

Columbus Area

London 390970007 79.7 75.0 75.0 74.8 75.0 73.0 72.8 72.7 72.6 68.1 67.8 67.6 65.9 66.3

New Albany 390490029 86.3 82.1 82.1 81.9 81.8 80.2 80.0 79.9 79.6 74.7 74.3 74.2 73.3 73.0

Franklin 290490028 80.3 76.7 76.6 76.5 75.9 75.1 74.9 74.8 74.1 70.5 70.2 70.1 70.2 69.0

St. Louis Area

W. Alton (MO) 291831002 86.3 81.1 81.2 81.1 81.0 80.0 79.9 79.9 78.6 76.9 76.8 76.7 74.2 74.9

Orchard (MO) 291831004 87.0 82.1 82.1 82.0 82.0 80.9 80.8 80.7 80.0 77.7 77.6 77.4 75.2 76.2

Sunset Hills (MO) 291890004 82.3 79.2 79.2 79.1 78.7 78.3 78.1 78.1 77.1 75.3 75.2 75.1 73.0 73.9

Arnold (MO) 290990012 82.3 77.8 77.8 77.7 77.2 76.7 76.6 76.5 75.6 73.6 73.4 73.4 71.3 72.0

Margaretta (MO) 295100086 83.0 79.8 79.8 79.7 79.3 78.8 78.7 78.6 77.9 75.7 75.6 75.5 73.7 74.4

Maryland Heights (MO) 291890014 87.3 85.4 85.4 85.3 84.0 84.3 84.1 84.0 81.7 81.1 80.9 80.8 78.4 78.1 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR 

# Table 2a. Ozone Modeling Results

2009 2012 20182005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Site Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen.C-BART

Illinois

Chicago - Washington HS 170310022 15.2 14.9 14.8 14.5 14.1 14.8 14.7 14.2 14.0 15.0 14.6 14.2 13.7 13.9

Chicago - Mayfair 170310052 15.8 15.1 15.1 14.8 14.4 15.1 14.9 14.5 14.2 15.1 14.7 14.3 13.7 13.9

Chicago - Springfield 170310057 15.0 14.6 14.6 14.3 13.9 14.6 14.4 14.0 13.8 14.8 14.4 14.0 13.4 13.7

Chicago - Lawndale 170310076 14.9 14.5 14.5 14.2 13.8 14.5 14.3 13.9 13.7 14.7 14.3 13.9 13.3 13.6

Blue Island 170312001 14.8 14.4 14.4 14.0 13.7 14.4 14.2 13.8 13.6 14.5 14.1 13.7 13.2 13.4

Summit 170313301 15.2 14.9 14.9 14.6 14.2 14.9 14.7 14.3 14.0 15.0 14.6 14.3 13.7 13.9

Cicero 170316005 15.5 15.1 15.1 14.8 14.4 15.1 14.9 14.5 14.3 15.2 14.9 14.4 13.9 14.2

Granite City 171191007 16.7 16.3 16.2 15.9 15.1 16.1 16.0 15.3 14.9 15.9 15.6 14.9 14.2 14.3

E. St. Louis 171630010 15.6 15.2 15.2 14.8 14.1 15.0 14.9 14.3 13.9 14.9 14.6 14.0 13.3 13.4

Indiana

Jeffersonville 180190005 16.4 15.8 15.7 14.8 13.8 15.8 15.6 14.5 13.7 16.0 15.5 14.3 13.7 13.4

Jasper 180372001 15.2 14.3 14.2 13.4 12.4 14.2 14.0 13.0 12.2 14.3 13.9 12.8 12.1 11.8

Gary 180890031 15.6 13.9 13.9 13.5 13.0 13.8 13.6 13.1 12.8 13.7 13.4 12.9 12.3 12.4

Indy-Washington Park 180970078 15.3 14.4 14.4 13.6 12.8 14.3 14.2 13.2 12.6 14.3 13.9 12.9 12.2 12.0

Indy-W 18th Street 180970081 16.0 15.1 15.1 14.3 15.0 14.9 13.9 15.0 14.6 13.5 12.8

Indy- Michigan Street 180970083 15.9 15.0 15.0 14.2 13.4 14.9 14.8 13.8 13.1 14.9 14.5 13.5 12.8 12.6

Michigan

Allen Park 261630001 14.5 11.0 14.0 13.5 13.0 14.0 13.8 13.2 12.8 13.9 13.6 13.0 12.4 12.4

Southwest HS 261630015 15.9 15.3 15.3 14.8 14.2 15.2 15.0 14.4 13.9 15.1 14.8 14.1 13.5 13.5

Linwood 261630016 14.6 14.1 14.1 13.6 13.1 14.0 13.9 13.3 12.8 13.9 13.6 13.0 12.5 12.5

Dearborn 261630033 17.5 17.0 17.0 16.4 15.8 16.9 16.7 16.0 15.5 16.8 16.4 15.7 15.1 15.1

Wyandotte 261630036 14.7 14.2 14.1 13.6 13.1 14.1 13.9 13.3 12.8 14.0 13.7 13.0 12.4 12.5

Ohio

Middletown - Bonita 390170003 16.2 15.3 15.2 14.3 13.5 15.2 15.0 13.9 13.2 15.2 14.8 13.7 13.0 12.8

Fairfield 390170016 15.8 15.1 15.0 14.1 13.1 15.1 14.9 13.7 12.9 15.2 14.7 13.5 12.8 12.5

Cleveland-28th Street 390350027 15.4 14.9 14.9 14.3 13.5 14.7 14.5 13.9 13.2 14.6 14.2 13.5 12.8 12.7

Cleveland-St. Tikhon 390350038 17.4 16.7 16.7 16.0 15.2 16.5 16.3 15.6 14.8 16.3 16.0 15.2 14.4 14.3

Cleveland-Broadway 390350045 16.5 15.9 15.8 15.2 14.4 15.6 15.5 14.8 14.0 15.5 15.1 14.4 13.6 13.5

Cleveland-GT Craig 390350060 17.1 16.5 16.4 15.8 15.0 16.3 16.1 15.4 14.6 16.1 15.7 15.0 14.2 14.1

Newburg Hts - Harvard Ave 390350065 16.0 15.4 15.3 14.7 14.0 15.2 15.0 14.3 13.6 15.1 14.7 14.0 13.2 13.1

Columbus - Fairgrounds 390490024 15.3 14.6 14.5 13.7 12.9 14.4 14.1 13.2 12.6 14.2 13.8 12.8 12.2 12.0

Columbus - Ann Street 390490025 15.1 14.4 14.3 13.5 12.7 14.2 13.9 13.1 12.4 14.1 13.6 12.6 12.0 11.9

Cincinnati - Seymour 390610014 17.3 16.6 16.5 15.5 14.5 16.5 16.3 15.1 14.3 16.6 16.2 14.9 14.2 13.8

Cincinnati - Taft Ave 390610040 15.5 14.8 14.7 13.8 12.8 14.8 14.6 13.4 12.6 14.9 14.5 13.2 12.5 12.2

Cincinnati - 8th Ave 390610042 16.9 12.0 16.1 15.0 14.0 16.1 15.9 14.7 13.8 16.2 15.7 14.4 13.7 13.4

Sharonville 390610043 15.6 14.9 14.8 13.9 12.9 14.9 14.7 13.5 12.7 14.9 14.5 13.3 12.6 12.3

Norwood 390617001 16.2 15.5 15.4 14.4 13.4 15.4 15.2 14.0 13.2 15.5 15.1 13.8 13.1 12.8

St. Bernard 390618001 17.6 16.8 16.7 15.7 14.7 16.7 16.5 15.3 14.4 16.8 16.4 15.1 14.3 14.0

Steubenville 390810016 15.8 14.5 14.4 13.5 12.8 14.3 14.2 13.1 12.5 14.8 14.5 13.3 12.9 12.7

Mingo Junction 390811001 16.5 15.2 15.2 14.3 13.5 15.0 14.9 13.8 13.2 15.6 15.2 14.0 13.6 13.4

Ironton 390870010 15.2 14.8 14.6 13.6 12.8 14.6 14.4 13.2 12.5 14.8 14.1 12.8 12.4 12.3

Dayton 391130032 15.5 14.9 14.8 14.0 13.2 14.8 14.6 13.6 12.9 14.8 14.3 13.3 12.6 12.4

New Boston 391450013 14.7 12.0 14.0 13.0 12.1 14.1 13.8 12.5 11.9 14.2 13.6 12.2 11.7 11.6

Canton - Dueber 391510017 16.3 15.7 15.6 14.8 14.0 15.5 15.3 14.4 13.6 15.4 14.9 14.0 13.3 13.3

Canton - Market 391510020 14.6 11.0 14.1 13.3 12.6 13.9 13.7 12.9 12.3 13.9 13.5 12.6 12.0 11.9

Akron - Brittain 391530017 15.1 14.6 14.5 13.8 13.0 14.4 14.2 13.4 12.7 14.3 13.8 13.0 12.3 12.3

Akron - W. Exchange 391530023 14.3 13.7 13.7 13.0 12.3 13.6 13.3 12.6 12.0 13.4 13.0 12.2 11.6 11.5 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

2009 2018 2012 

# Table 2b. PM 2.5 

# Modeling Results (Annual)2005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Key Site County Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. C - BART

Illinois

Chicago - Washington HS Cook 170310022 36.6 36 36 36 36 36 36 37 36 37 36 37 37 35

Chicago - Mayfair Cook 170310052 40.3 37 37 37 36 37 36 37 36 38 37 37 37 36

Chicago - Springfield Cook 170310057 37.4 34 34 33 32 35 34 33 32 36 34 33 33 31

Chicago - Lawndale Cook 170310076 38.1 35 35 35 35 36 35 36 35 36 35 36 36 34

McCook Cook 170311016 43.0 39 39 39 39 40 39 40 39 40 40 41 40 38

Blue Island Cook 170312001 37.7 35 35 35 34 36 35 36 34 36 35 36 36 33

Schiller Park Cook 170313103 41.6 40 40 40 39 40 40 40 39 41 40 40 39 39

Summit Cook 170313301 40.2 38 38 39 38 39 38 39 38 39 38 39 39 37

Maywood Cook 170316005 39.2 38 38 38 38 38 38 39 38 39 38 39 39 37

Granite City Madison 171191007 39.2 36 36 35 33 36 35 34 33 36 35 35 33 32

E. St. Louis St. Clair 171630010 33.7 31 31 30 28 31 30 29 28 31 30 30 29 28

Indiana

Jeffersonville Clark 180190005 38.4 35 33 31 29 35 34 32 31 37 35 34 33 31

Jasper Dubois 180372001 36.2 32 32 30 28 32 32 30 29 33 31 31 30 28

Gary - IITRI Lake 180890022 39.0 35 35 35 34 35 34 35 34 36 36 36 35 35

Gary - Burr School Lake 180890026 39.0 34 34 34 33 34 34 35 34 34 34 34 34 32

Gary Lake 180890031 35.2 29 28 26 24 28 28 24 24 29 28 27 27 27

Indy-West Street Marion 180970043 38.0 34 34 33 33 35 35 34 33 36 35 34 34 33

Indy-English Avenue Marion 180970066 38.0 34 34 32 32 35 34 33 32 35 34 33 33 32

Indy-Washington Park Marion 180970078 36.6 33 33 32 31 33 33 32 31 34 33 32 32 32

Indy-W 18th Street Marion 180970081 38.3 33 33 31 31 33 33 32 31 34 33 32 32 31

Indy- Michigan Street Marion 180970083 36.0 32 32 29 28 32 31 29 28 32 31 29 29 29

Michigan

Luna Pier Monroe 261150005 38.9 34 34 32 32 34 34 32 32 34 33 32 31 31

Oak Park Oakland 261250001 39.9 38 38 37 36 38 37 37 36 38 37 37 36 35

Port Huron St. Clair 261470005 39.6 36 35 35 34 35 35 35 34 35 35 34 33 33

Ypsilanti Washtenaw 261610008 39.5 37 37 36 35 37 36 36 35 37 36 36 35 34

Allen Park Wayne 261630001 38.6 36 36 36 35 36 35 35 34 36 35 35 34 33

Southwest HS Wayne 261630015 40.1 36 36 36 35 36 35 35 35 36 35 35 34 33

Linwood Wayne 261630016 43.0 40 40 40 39 40 40 40 39 40 39 39 39 38

E 7 Mile Wayne 261630019 41.0 39 39 39 38 39 39 39 38 39 38 38 38 37

Dearborn Wayne 261630033 43.9 41 41 41 40 41 41 41 40 41 40 40 40 39

Wyandotte Wayne 261630036 37.2 36 36 36 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 34

Newberry Wayne 261630038 42.7 39 39 39 38 39 38 38 37 39 38 38 37 36

FIA Wayne 261630039 39.7 35 34 34 33 35 34 34 33 35 34 33 33 31

Ohio

Middleton Butler 390170003 39.3 33 32 29 28 33 33 29 28 34 32 29 28 27

Fairfield Butler 390170016 37.1 32 31 29 27 31 30 28 28 32 30 29 28 27

Butler 390170017 40.8 33 32 30 29 33 33 30 29 33 32 30 29 28

Cleveland-28th Street Cuyahoga 390350027 36.9 34 34 33 32 34 33 33 32 34 33 33 31 31

Cleveland-St. Tikhon Cuyahoga 390350038 44.2 40 40 37 36 40 39 36 35 40 38 36 35 34

Cleveland-Broadway Cuyahoga 390350045 38.8 35 35 33 31 35 34 32 30 35 34 31 29 29

Cleveland-GT Craig Cuyahoga 390350060 42.1 39 39 38 37 39 38 38 37 39 38 37 36 35

Newburg Hts - Harvard Ave Cuyahoga 390350065 38.9 35 35 33 31 35 34 32 30 36 35 32 31 30

Columbus - Fairgrounds Franklin 390490024 38.5 34 34 33 33 34 33 32 32 34 34 33 32 31

Columbus - Ann Street Franklin 390490025 38.5 34 33 31 31 33 33 31 31 34 33 31 31 30

Cincinnait Hamilton 390610006 40.6 33 33 30 27 33 32 29 28 34 32 29 28 27 Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

2009 2012 2018 

# Table 2c. PM 2.5 

# Modeling Results (Daily)2005

Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR Round 5

with CAIR

Key Site County Site ID Base Year Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. A Scen. B Scen.C Scen. C - BART Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 without CAIR

2009 2012 2018 

# Table 2c. PM 2.5 

# Modeling Results (Daily)

Cincinnati - Seymour Hamilton 390610014 38.4 33 33 28 26 33 32 27 25 33 31 29 25 24

Cincinnati - Taft Ave Hamilton 390610040 36.7 31 30 26 24 31 30 26 24 32 29 26 24 23

Cincinnati - 8th Ave Hamilton 390610042 37.3 32 32 30 28 32 31 29 28 33 31 29 28 27

Sharonville Hamilton 390610043 36.0 32 31 30 28 32 31 29 28 32 31 29 28 27

Norwood Hamilton 390617001 38.8 34 33 32 30 33 33 31 30 34 33 31 30 29

St. Bernard Hamilton 390618001 40.6 35 35 32 30 35 34 31 30 35 33 32 31 29

Steubenville Jefferson 390810016 40.7 36 35 32 29 35 34 30 28 37 35 31 29 28

Mingo Junction Jefferson 390811001 42.0 37 37 33 30 37 36 32 30 38 36 32 30 30

Dayton Montgomery 391130032 37.8 34 33 31 30 33 33 31 30 34 33 31 31 30

Canton - Dueber Stark 391510017 38.6 33 32 30 28 33 31 30 28 33 30 29 28 27

Akron - Brittain Summit 391530017 38.1 33 33 31 30 33 32 31 30 33 32 30 29 29

Wisconsin

Green Bay - Est High Brown 550090005 37.1 35 34 35 35 34 35 35 34 33 33 33 32 32

Madison Dane 550250047 36.4 33 33 32 32 33 32 32 31 32 31 30 29 29

Milwaukee-Health Center Milwaukee 550790010 38.7 35 35 35 35 35 35 35 34 35 34 34 34 33

Milwaukee-SER Hdqs Milwaukee 550790026 37.4 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 33

Milwaukee-Virginia FS Milwaukee 550790043 39.9 37 37 37 36 37 36 37 36 36 36 37 36 36

Milwaukee- Fire Dept Hdqs Milwaukee 550790099 37.8 34 34 33 33 34 33 33 32 34 33 33 33 32

Waukesha Waukesha 551330027 35.5 32 32 32 31 32 32 32 31 32 31 31 30 29

### 10 

### Table 3. Mo deling Res ults: Number of Sites > NAAQS

Ozone (85 ppb) Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 0 0 0 0

---- 0

IN 0 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 3 1 1 1

---- 1

OH 4 0 0 0

---- 0

WI 2 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 9 1 1 1 1

2012

IL 0 0 0 0

---- 0

IN 0 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 3 0 0 0

---- 0

OH 4 0 0 0

---- 0

WI 2 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 9 0 0 0 0

2018

IL 0 0 0 0 0 0

IN 0 0 0 0 0 0

MI 3 0 0 0 0 0

OH 4 0 0 0 0 0

WI 2 0 0 0 0 0

Total 9 0 0 0 0 0

O zone (75 ppb) Round 5 without CAIR Round5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 12 6 6 6

---- 4

IN 26 10 9 8

---- 5

MI 21 12 12 12

---- 12

OH 45 27 25 24

---- 21

WI 12 10 10 10

---- 10

Total 116 65 62 60

---- 52

20 12

IL 12 3 3 3

---- 1

IN 26 5 4 4

---- 3

MI 21 9 8 8

---- 6

OH 45 18 14 12

---- 11

WI 12 10 9 9

---- 9

Total 116 45 38 36 30

2018

IL 12 0 0 0 0 0

IN 26 0 0 0 0 0

MI 21 3 3 3 3 3

OH 45 3 3 2 1 1

WI 12 3 2 1 1 1

Total 116 9 8 6 5 5

### 11

PM2.5

- Annual Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 7 4 4 1

---- 1

IN 6 2 2 0

---- 0

MI 2 2 2 1

---- 1

OH 26 1 3 12 5

---- 1

WI 0 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 41 21 20 7 3

2012

IL 7 3 1 1

---- 0

IN 6 1 1 0

---- 0

MI 2 2 1 1

---- 1

OH 26 12 9 4

---- 0

WI 0 0 0 0

---- 0

Total 41 18 12 6 1

2018

IL 7 3 1 0 0 0

IN 6 1 1 0 0 0

MI 2 2 1 1 1 1

OH 26 13 8 2 0 0

WI 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 41 19 11 3 1 1

PM2.5

- Daily

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

2009 Baseyear Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

- BART

IL 16 7 7 6

---- 6

IN 13 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 14 10 9 9

---- 5

OH 31 4 3 2

---- 2

WI 8 1 1 1

---- 1

Total 82 2 2 20 18

---- 14

2012

IL 16 9 6 8

---- 6

IN 13 0 0 0

---- 0

MI 14 8 6 6

---- 5

OH 31 3 3 2

---- 1

WI 8 1 1 1

---- 1

Total 82 21 16 1 7 13

2018

IL 16 10 6 8 8 5

IN 13 4 1 1 0 0

MI 14 8 6 6 5 4

OH 31 5 3 2 1 0

WI 8 1 1 1 1 1

Total 82 2 8 17 18 1 5 10

### 12 

### Ta ble 4 . Mo deling Results: Future Year Visibility Levels

Worst 20% 2018

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

Site Baseline

(2000

- 2004) 2018 URP Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

BART

BOWA1 19.86 17.94 19.09 18.87 18.54 18.02 17.94

VOYA2 19.48 17.75 18.60 18.44 18.17 17.77 17.63

SENE1 24.38 21.64 24.02 23.58 23.03 22.38 22.59

ISLE1 21.59 19.43 21.05 20.86 20.62 20.22 20.09

ISLE9 21.59 19.43 20.83 20.58 20.38 19.84 19.84

HEGL1 26.75 23.13 26.24 25.83 24.87 24.23 24.22

MI NG1 28.15 24.27 27.51 26.98 25.81 24.93 24.74

CACR1 26.36 22.91 25.32 24.80 23.57 22.97 22.44

UPBU1 26.27 22.82 25.31 24.79 23.50 22.79 22.59

MACA1 31.37 26.64 30.11 29.08 27.06 26.24 26.10

DOSO1 29.05 24.69 27.88 26.96 24.36 23.74 23.00

SHEN1 29 .31 25.12 28.38 27.65 25.24 24.69 23.92

JARI1 29.12 24.91 28.06 27.21 25.00 24.48 24.06

BRIG1 29.01 25.05 28.10 28.07 26.57 26.25 25.21

LYBR1 24.45 21.48 24.06 23.86 22.58 22.30 21.14

ACAD1 22.89 20.45 22.88 22.76 22.31 22.16 21.49

Best 20% 2018

Round 5 without CAIR Round 5 w/ CAIR

Site Baseline

(2000

- 2004) 2018 Max Scen. A Scen. B Scen. C Scen. C

BART

BOWA1 6.42 6.42 6.20 6.17 6.16 6.12 6.14

VOYA2 7.09 7.09 6.87 6.83 6.81 6.78 6.75

SENE1 7.14 7.14 7.80 7.78 7. 81 7.77 7.71

ISLE1 6.75 6.75 6.77 6.76 6.72 6.67 6.60

ISLE9 6.75 6.75 6.63 6.61 6.58 6.53 6.52

HEGL1 12.84 12.84 12.17 12.20 12.07 11.63 11.66

MING1 14.46 14.46 13.78 13.77 13.70 13.37 13.28

CACR1 11.24 11.24 10.94 10.99 10.97 10.78 10. 52

UPBU1 11.71 11.71 11.18 11.23 11.18 10.96 10.73

MACA1 16.51 16.51 16.32 16.21 15.76 15.34 15.25

DOSO1 12.28 12.28 12.02 11.84 11.27 11.03 11.00

SHEN1 10.93 10.93 10.98 10.91 10.25 10.16 9.91

JARI1 14.21 14.21 14.19 13.98 13.42 13.21 13.14

BRI G1 14.33 14.33 14.32 14.46 14.22 14.17 13.92

LYBR1 6.37 6.37 6.39 6.38 6.31 6.28 6.14

ACAD1 8.78 8.78 8.97 8.96 8.90 8.89 8.82

### 13 

### Figure 2. Ozone Modeling Results

2009 Round 5

–

S cen

. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2012 Round 5

–

Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2018 Round 5

–

Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

### 14 

### Figure 3. PM2.5 Annual Modeling Results

2009 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– S cen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2012 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2018 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

### 15 

### Figure 4 . PM2.5 Daily Modeling Results

2009 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2012 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

2018 Round 5

– Scen. A Round 5

– Scen. B Round 5

– Scen. C Round 5

- CAIR

# Appendix I

Scenario B (Legally Enforceable) ControlsNOx

– 2009

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1b_2009 Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2009

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.8147 0.8416 0.8416 0.00 0.00 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.0515 3.1522 3.1522 0.00 0.00 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.9419 7.1708 7.1708 0.00 0.00 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.1310 2.2013 2.2013 0.00 0.00 lnb LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.1244 12.5243 12.5243

cyid 12.1244 12.5243 12.5243

stid 12.9392 13.3659 13.3659

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrlde s

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.9860 6.9756 2.3252 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NO X 3.6327 3.6273 1.2091 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.0133 5.0058 1.6686 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.8493 7.8376 2.6125 0.85 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.4814 23.4464 7.8155

cyi d 23.4814 23.4464 7.8155

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control E F Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.0017 0.0017 0.0001 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.8167 5.8080 0.2904 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.9017 7.8899 0.3945 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.8775 7.8657 0.3933 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.8586 3.8528 0.1926 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00 0.95 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- f cid 25.4561 25.4182 1.2709

cyid 25.4561 25.4182 1.2709

stid 48.9375 48.8646 9.0864

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future YearSTID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.7972 2.8 895 1.6470 0.00 0.43 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.9073 3.0032 1.7118 0.00 0.43 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.3270 2.4038 1.2740 0.00 0.47 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 1010020 2 NOX 2.3427 2.4199 1.2826 0.00 0.47 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10.3742 10.7164 5.9154

cyid 10.3742 10.7164 5.9154

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & L Alliant Energy

- Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S1 1 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.6197 1.6731 1.0038 0.00 0.40 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S11 B24 01 10100203 NOX 4.1072 4.2426 3. 4789 0.00 0.18 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.6804 5.8677 4.9876 0.00 0.15 SCR SCR added by LADCO

- --- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 11.4072 11.7834 9.4703

cyid 11.4072 11.7834 9.4703

stid 21.7814 22.4997 15.3857

======== ======== ==========

83.6581 84.7302 37.8380NOx

- 2012

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for N OX r6s1b_2012 Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2012

STID=17 CYID=33 fcid=0338 01AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc poli d Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 33 033801AAA 0005 0005 01 10100202 NOX 1.642 1.871 0.9357 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 33 033801AAA 0006 0006 01 10100202 NOX 2.116 2.413 1.2063 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 3.758 4.284 2.1420

cyid 3.758 4.284 2.1420

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.815 0.929 0.9288 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMER EN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.735 7.678 7.6780 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01 10100501 NOX 5.936 5.378 5.3781 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.671 13.056 13.0561

cyid 12.671 13.056 13.0561

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctr ltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 02 10100401 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=137 fcid=137805AAA name=AMEREN ENE RGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons /Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 137 137805AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 5.356 6.106 6.1058 0.00 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.052 3.479 3.4789 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.942 7.914 7.9141 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 14

3805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.131 2.429 2.4294 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- - ------- ---------- fcid 12.124 13.822 13.8224

cyid 12.124 13.822 13.8224STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 NOX 6.527 7.441 0.0074 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 NOX 2.646 3.017 0.0030 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 9.173 10.458 0.0105

cyid 9.173 10.458 0.0 105

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10 100203 NOX 22.429 25.570 1.2785 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 NOX 38.993 44.454 2.2227 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 61.422 7 0.024 3.5012

cyid 61.422 70.024 3.5012

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809AAO 0032 0033 02 10100604 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year F uture Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 NOX 5.731 6.534 3.9203 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 02 10100223 NOX 8.598 9.802 0.0098 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 NOX 10.974 12.511 0.01 25 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

-- -- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.303 28.847 3.9426

cyid 25.303 28.847 3.9426

stid 130.622 147.527 43.5096

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 NOX 13.661 14.142 2.8284 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU00 3 002 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fci d 13.661 14.142 2.8284

cyid 13.661 14.142 2.8284

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes27 1 09 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 NOX 2.079 2.152 1.2911 0.00 0.400 SNCR SCR added by LADCO

---- ---- ---- -------- ---------- stid 15.739 16.294 4.1195

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid T ons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.986 7.296 2.4319 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.633 3.794 1.2646 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P 1 10100202 NOX 5.013 5.235 1.7452 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.849 8.197 2.7324 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.481 24.522 8.1740

cyid 23.481 24.522 8.1740

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid s tkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 NOX 20.852 21.776 1.0888 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.002 0.002 0.0001 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.817 6.074 0.3037 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 068400

0000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.902 8.252 0.4126 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0. 000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.877 8.227 0.4113 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 1010 0202 NOX 3.859 4.030 0.2015 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0. 950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.456 26. 584 1.3292

cyid 25.456 26.584 1.3292

stid 69.789 72.882 10.5920

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CR EEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 NOX 4.755 5.421 3.0898 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 NOX 3.277 3.736 2.2045 0.00 0.410 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 NOX 3.333 3.800 2.8499 0.00 0.250 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 NOX 3.384 3.857 2.9316 0.00 0.240 SC R SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 14.749 16.814 11. 0757

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALLEY STATIONBase Yr Grown Controll ed Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 0 1 10100202 NOX 2.797 3.189 1.8177 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.907 3.314 1.8893 0.0 0 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.327 2.653 1.4061 0.00 0.470 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.343 2.671 1.4155 0.00 0.470 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10.374 11.827 6.5285

cyid 25.123 28.641 17.6042

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & L Alliant Energy

- Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrl type ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S11 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.620 1.846 1.1079 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S11 B24 0 1 10100203 NOX 4.107 4.682 3.8395 0.00 0.180 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.680 6.476 5.5045 0.0 0 0.150 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 11 .407 13.005 10.4519

cyid 11.407 13.005 10.4519

stid 36.530 41.646 28.0562

======== ======== ==========

252.681 278.349 86.2773NOx 20 18

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for NOX r6s1b_2018 Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2018

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AIN name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 01 10100226 NOX 2.283 2. 592 1.5550 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 02 10100601 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 01 10100226 NOX 3.991 4.531 2.7184 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 02 1010 0601 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 6.274 7.122 4.2734

cyid 6.274 7. 122 4.2734

STID=17 CYID=33 fcid=033801AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Co ntrolled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 33 033801AAA 0005 0005 01 10100202 NOX 1.642 1.863 0.9317 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 33 033801AAA 0006 0006 01 10100202 NOX 2.116 2.402 1.2012 0.00 0.500 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 3.758 4.266 2.1329

cyid 3.758 4.266 2.1329

STID=17 CYID=57 fcid=057801AAA name=AES DUCK CREEK

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 57 057801AAA 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 0.815 0.925 0.924 9 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Ba se Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.735 7.645 7.6453 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01 10100501 NOX 5.936 3.984 3.9838 0.00 0.000 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.671 11.629 11.6291

cyid 12.671 11.629 11.6291

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 02 10100401 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=137 fcid=137805AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Ye ar Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 137 137805AAA 0003 0003 01 10100 202 NOX 5.356 6.080 6.0798 0.00 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCOSTID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0001 01 10100202 NOX 3.052 3.464 3.4641 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0001 0003 01 10100202 NOX 6.942 7.880 7.8804 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 NOX 2.131 2.419 2.4191 0.00 0.000 lnb LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 12.124 13.764 13.7636

cyid 12.124 13.764 13.7636

STID=17 CYID= 167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 NOX 6.527 7.410 0.0074 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 NOX 2.646 3.004 0.0030 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SHUTDOWN added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 9.173 10.414 0.0104

cyid 9.173 10.414 0.0104

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Contro l EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10100203 NOX 22.429 25.462 1.2731 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 179 179801 AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 NOX 38.993 44.265 2.2132 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- ----- --- ---------- fcid 61.422 69.726 3.4863

cyid 61.422 69.726 3.4863

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809AAO 0032 0033 02 10100604 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 NOX 5.731 6.506 3.9036 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0 011 0016 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 02 10100223 NOX 8.598 9.760 0.0098 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 NOX 10.974 12.458 0.0125 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.999 SHUTDOWN SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.303 28.724 3.9258

cyid 25.303 28.724 3.9258

stid 136.896 152.649 46.2263STID=18 CYID=147 fcid=00020 name=INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER

- ROCKPORT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

18 147 00020 1 001 01 10100222 NOX 23.226 25.291 1.2646 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

18 147 00020 1 001 02 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

cyid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

stid 23.226 25.291 1.2646

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 NOX 13.661 15.733 3.1466 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.800 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 13.661 15.733 3.1466

cyid 13.661 15.733 3.1466

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 109 271090

0011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 NOX 2.079 2.394 1.4363 0.00 0.400 SNCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- ----- --- ---------- stid 15.739 18.127 4.5830

STID=39 CYID=1 fcid=0701000007 name="DP&L, J.M. STUART GENERATING STATION"

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day To ns/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 1 0701000007 R1 B001 B001P1 10100202 NOX 6.986 7.607 2.5358 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LAD CO

39 1 0701000007 R2 B002 B002P1 10100202 NOX 3.633 3.956 1.3186 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R3 B003 B003P1 10100202 NOX 5.013 5.459 1.8197 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 1 0701000007 R4 B004 B004P1 10100202 NOX 7.849 8.547 2.8491 0.85 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.481 25.570 8.5232

cyid 23.481 25.570 8.5232

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 NOX 20.852 22.706 1.1353 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year F uture Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 167 0684000000 R1 B001 B001P1 10200501 NOX 0.002 0.002 0.0001 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 NOX 5.817 6.334 0.3167 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 NOX 7.902 8.604 0.4302 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.00 00 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100203 NOX 7.877 8.578 0.4289 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 NOX 3.859 4.202 0.2101 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 NOX 0.000 0.000 0.0000 0.00 0.950 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 25.456 27.720 1.38 60

cyid 25.456 27.720 1.3860

st id 69.789 75.996 11.0445

STID=54 CYID=39 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- KANAWHA RIVER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 39 0006 012 001 99 10100202 NOX 4.829 5.258 2.6291 0.00 0.500 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

54 39 0006 012 002 99 10100202 NOX 4.921 5.359 2.6794 0.00 0.500 SCR Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

cyid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

stid 9.750 10.617 5.3085

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10 100202 NOX 4.755 5.398 3.0766 0.00 0.430 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 NOX 3.277 3.720 2.1951 0.00 0.410 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 NOX 3.333 3.784 2.8378 0.00 0.250 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 NOX 3.384 3.841 2.9191 0.00 0.240 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 14.749 16.743 11.0285

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007800 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER VALL EY STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007800 S11 B21 01 10100202 NOX 2.797 3.175 1.4289 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S11 B22 01 10100202 NOX 2.907 3.300 1.4852 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B23 01 10100202 NOX 2.327 2.642 1.1887 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

55 79 241007800 S12 B24 01 10100202 NOX 2.343 2.659 1.1967 0.00 0.550 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10.374 11.777 5.2 995

cyid 25.123 28.519 16.3281

STID=55 CYID=117 fcid=460033090 name=WP & L Alliant Energy

- Edgewater Gen Station

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 117 460033090 S11 B23 01 10100203 NOX 1.620 1.839 1.103 2 0.00 0.400 SCR SCR added by LADCO55 117 460033090 S11 B24 01 10100203 NOX 4.107 4.662 3.8232 0.00 0.180 SCR SCR added by LADCO

5 5 117 460033090 S12 B25 01 10100221 NOX 5.680 6.448 5.4811 0.00 0.150 SCR SCR added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 11.407 12.949 10.4074

cyid 11.407 12.949 10.4074

stid 36.530 41.469 26.735 5

======== ======== ==========

291.931 324.149 95.1624SO2

– 2009

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for SO2 r6s1b_2009 1

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2009

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58

- 07

- 001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO.

- LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Cont rol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

19 115 58

- 07

- 001 117487 147281 99 10100222 SO2 33.664 34.774 3.4774 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fc

id=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 42.166 42.103 4.2103 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 SO2 55.385 55.303 5.5303 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

cyid 97.551 97.406 9.7406

stid 9 7.551 97.406 9.7406

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP

- Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 271410

0004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 SO2 16.765 16.987 3.6401 0.3 0.85 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 SO2 22.549 22. 848 4.8959 0.3 0.85 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

cyid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

stid 39.314 39.834 8.5360

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid= 0005 name=OHIO POWER

- MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 17.775 17.748 1.7748 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 5.689 5.680 0.5680 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.463 23.428 2.3428

cyid 23.463 23.428 2.3428

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 SO2 11.196 11.179 1.1179 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid= 0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- JOHN E AMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 79.635 79.516 7.9516 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 SO2 139.377 139.169 13.9169 0.0 0.90 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 219.012 218.685 21.8685

cyid 219.012 218.685 21.8685

stid 253.671 253.293 25.3293

======== ======== ==========

424.200 425.307 47.0832SO2

– 2012

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for SO2 r6s1b_2012 1

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2012

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AMI name=MIDWEST GENERATION L LC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day To ns/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AMI 0007 0010 01 10100226 SO2 16.13 18.39 1.839 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

ST ID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0018 0033 01 10100226 SO2 24.14 27.52 2.752 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0021 0036 01 10100226 SO2 19.23 21.92 2.192 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 09719

0AAC 0016 0031 01 10100203 SO2 4.59 5.24 0.005 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 47.96 54.68 4.950

cyid 47.96 54.68 4.950

STID=17 CYID=125 fcid=125804AAB name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 125 125804AAB 0019 0023 01 10100202 SO2 22.34 25.47 3.821 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=127 fcid=127855AAC name=ELECTRIC ENERGY INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/D ay Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0001 01 10100222 SO2 11.83 13.48 13.482 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0002 01 10100222 SO2 11.48 13.09 13.085 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0003 01 10100222 SO2 10.25 11.68 11.680 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0004 01 10100222 SO2 12.04 13.73 13.731 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0006 01 10100222 SO2 12.68 14.46 14.456 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 58.27 66.43 66.435

cyid 58.27 66.43 66.435

STID=17 CYID=135 fcid=135803AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING C O

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Ton s/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 32.99 37.61 3.761 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0003 01 10100203 SO2 72.92 83.13 8.313 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 105.91 120.74 12.074

cyid 105.91 120.74 12.074STID=17 CYID=157 fcid=157851AAA name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 157 157851AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 25.14 28.66 4.299 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0002 00 02 01 10100203 SO2 25.79 29.41 4.411 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0013 0013 01 10100202 SO2 27.79 31.68 4.752 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.72 89.75 13.462

cyid 78.72 89.75 13.462

STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=167120AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 SO2 4 4.20 50.39 0.050 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 SO2 16.40 18.70 0.019 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 60.61 69.10 0.06 9

cyid 60.61 69.10 0.069

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid p rid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10100203 SO2 25.35 28.90 2.890 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 SO2 41.57 47.39 4.739 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 66.91 76.29 7.629

cyid 66.91 76.29 7.629

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Ton s/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 SO2 15.33 17.48 0.017 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 101 00501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 15.33 17.48 0.017

cyid 15.33 17.48 0.017

stid 472.19 538.32 110.295

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58

- 07

- 001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO.

- LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYI D fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

19 115 58

- 07

- 001 117487 147281 99 10100222 SO2 33.66 38.38 3.838 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 42.17 44.03 4.403 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 SO2 55.39 57.84 5.784 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 97.55 101.87 10.187

cyid 97.55 101.87 10.187

stid 97.55 101.87 10.187

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=27 06100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 SO2 33.99 35.19 15.081 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 33.99 35.19 15.081

cyid 33.99 35.19 15.081

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Pu blic Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid T ons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 SO2 7.86 8.13 1.220 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER S crubber added by LADCO

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP

- Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID f

cid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 SO2 16.76 17.36 3.719 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 SO2 22.55 23.34 5.002 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 39.31 40.70 8.721

cyid 39.31 40.70 8.721

stid 81.16 84.02 25.023

STID=39 CYID=13 fcid=0607130015 name=R. E. BURGER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Cont rol EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 13 0607130015 R6 B011 B011P1 10100202 SO2 29.83 31.15 3.115 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 13 0607130015 R7 B012 B012P1 10100202 SO2 34.77 36.31 3.631 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 64.60 67.46 6.746

cyid 64.60 67.46 6.746

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 SO2 316.00 330.00 33.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- stid 380.60 397.46 39.746

STID=47 CYID=1 fcid=0009 name=TVA BULL RUN FOSSIL PLANTBase Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Da y Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 1 0009 S

- 1 001 99 10100212 SO2 130.81 133.01 13.301 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubbe r added by LADCO

STID=47 CYID=73 fcid=0007 name=TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stk id dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 73 0007 S

- 1A 001 99 10100212 SO2 20.15 20.49 2.0 49 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 1B 002 99 10100212 SO2 20.25 20.59 2.059 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2A 003 99 10100212 SO2 19.62 19.95 1.995 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2B 004 99 10100212 SO2 18.93 19.25 1.925 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.95 80.28 8.028

cyid 78.95 80.2 8 8.028

STID=47 CYID=85 fcid=0011 name=TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Contr olled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 85 0011 S1

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 17.06 17.35 1.735 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 04 004 99 10100212 SO2 19.85 20.18 2.018 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 05 005 99 10100212 SO2 24.11 24.52 2.452 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 61.02 62.04 6.204

cyid 61.02 62.04 6.204

STID=47 CYID=145 fcid=0013 name =TVA KINGSTON FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Ton s/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 145 0013 S

- 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 12.68 12.89 1.289 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scr ubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 002 99 10100202 SO2 14.00 14.24 1.424 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 003 9 9 10100202 SO2 13.80 14.04 1.404 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 004 99 10100202 SO2 12.24 12.44 1.244 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 005 99 10100202 SO2 19.57 19.90 1.990 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 006 99 10100202 SO2 18.92 19.24 1.924 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 007 99 10100202 SO2 21.30 21.66 2.166 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 008 99 10100202 SO2 18.54 18.85 1.885 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBE R Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 009 99 10100202 SO2 20.72 21.07 2.107 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 151.77 154.33 15.433

cyid 151.77 154.33 15.433

STID=47 CYID=165 fcid=0025 name=TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Cont rol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 165 0025 S

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 13.91 14.14 1.414 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 00

25 S

- 01 002 99 10100212 SO2 14.87 15.12 1.512 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 003 99 10100212 SO2 16.33 16.60 1.660 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 004 99 10100212 SO2 20.39 20.73 2.073 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Sc rubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ----------fcid 65.49 66.59 6.659

cyid 65.49 66.59 6.659

stid 488.04 496.25 49.625

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER

- MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 17.77 18.56 1.856 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 5.69 5.94 0.594 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- --- ----- ---------- fcid 23.46 24.50 2.450

cyid 23.46 24.50 2.450

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 SO2 11.20 11.69 1.169 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- JOHN E A MOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 79.63 83.16 8.316 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LA DCO

54 79 0006 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 100.33 104.78 10.478 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 SO2 139.38 145.55 14.555 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 319.35 333.50 33.350

cyid 319.35 3 33.50 33.350

stid 354.00 369.69 36.969

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 SO2 12.75 14.5 4 3.490 0.0 0.760 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 SO2 8.68 9.89 2.473 0.0 0.750 SCRUBBER Scrubber add ed by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 SO2 10.97 12.51 2.876 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 SO2 11.28 12.86 2.958 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 43.68 49.80 11.797

cyid 43.6 8 49.80 11.797

stid 43.68 49.80 11.797

======== ======== ==========

1950.90 2075.80 287.480SO2

– 2018

Point Source Grown and Controlled Emissions by facility for SO2 r6s1b_2018 1

Base Year = 2002

Future Year = 2018

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AIN name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AIN 0010 0013 01 10100226 SO2 10.92 12.39 1.239 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 31 031600AIN 0012 0016 01 10100226 SO2 17.69 20.08 2.008 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 28.61 32.48 3.248

STID=17 CYID=31 fcid=031600AMI name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 31 031600AMI 0007 0010 01 10100226 SO2 16.13 18.31 1.831 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- cyid 44.74 50.79 5.079

STID=17 CYID =79 fcid=079808AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 79 079808AAA 0003 0003 01 10100202 SO2 36.35 41.27 4.127 0.0 0. 900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 79 079808AAA 0012 0013 01 10100501 SO2 28.99 19.46 1.946 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 65.34 60.72 6.072

cyid 65.34 60.72 6.072

STID=17 CYID=97 fcid=097190AAC name=MIDWEST GENERATIO N LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 97 097190AAC 0018 0033 01 10100226 SO2 24.14 27.40 2.740 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0021 0036 01 10100226 SO2 19.23 21.83 2.183 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 97 097190AAC 0016 0031 01 10100203 SO2 4.59 5.22 0.005 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 47.96 54.45 4.928

cyid 47.96 54.4 5 4.928

STID=17 CYID=125 fcid=125804AAB name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 125 125804AAB 0019 0023 01 10100202 SO2 22.34 25.36 3.805 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=127 fcid=127855AAC name=ELECTRIC ENERGY INC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes17 127 127855AAC 0002 0003 01 10100222 SO2 10.25 11.63 11.630 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0002 0004 01 10100222 SO2 12.04 13.67 13.673 0.0 0.000 LNB LNB added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0001 01 10100222 SO2 11.83 13.42 1.342 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0001 0002 01 10100222 SO2 11.48 13.03 1.303 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 1 27855AAC 0003 0005 01 10100222 SO2 11.72 13.31 1.331 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 127 127855AAC 0003 0006 01 10100222 SO2 12.68 14.39 1.439 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 70.00 79.46 30.719

cyid 70.00 79.46 30.719

STID=17 CYID=135 fcid=135803AAA name=AMEREN ENERGY GENERATING CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Bas e Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 32.99 37.45 3.745 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 135 135803AAA 0001 0003 01 10100203 SO2 72.92 82.77 8.277 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 10 5.91 120.22 12.022

cyid 105.91 120.22 12.022

STID=17 CYID=143 fcid=143805AAG name=AES ED EDWARDS STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 143 143805AAG 0002 0004 01 10100202 SO2 15.28 17.34 1.734 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=17 CYID=157 fcid=157851AAA name=DYNEGY MIDWEST GENERATION INC

Base Yr Grown C ontrolled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 157 157851AAA 0001 0001 01 10100203 SO2 25.14 28.54 4.281 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0002 0002 01 10100203 SO2 25.79 29.28 4.3 92 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 157 157851AAA 0013 0013 01 10100202 SO2 27.79 31.54 4.732 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.72 89.36 13.404

cyid 78.72 89.36 13.404

STID=17 CYID=167 fcid=16712 0AAO name=CITY WATER LIGHT & POWER

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc poli d Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0012 01 10100203 SO2 44.20 50.18 0.050 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOW N Scrubber added by LADCO

17 167 167120AAO 0010 0013 01 10100203 SO2 16.40 18.62 0.019 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 60.61 68.80 0.069

cyid 60.61 68.80 0.069

STID=17 CYID=179 fcid=179801AAA name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Co ntrol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0029 01 10100203 SO2 25.35 28.77 2.877 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 179 179801AAA 0018 0031 01 10100203 SO2 41.57 47.19 4.719 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- ------- - -------- ----------fcid 66.91 75.96 7.596

cyid 66.91 75.96 7.596

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197809AAO name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197809AAO 0006 0009 01 10100203 SO2 15.89 18.04 1.804 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197809AAO 0016 0031 01 1 0100202 SO2 27.43 31.13 3.113 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197809AAO 0017 0033 01 10100202 SO2 23.13 26.26 2.626 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 66.45 75.44 7.544

STID=17 CYID=197 fcid=197810AAK name=MIDWEST GENERATION LLC

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

17 197 197810AAK 0009 0014 02 10100222 SO2 11.64 13.21 1.321 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0011 0016 02 10100222 SO2 25.67 29.14 2.914 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0013 0010 03 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 02 10100223 SO2 15.33 17.40 0.017 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

17 197 197810AAK 0007 0012 03 101005 01 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.999 SHUTDOWN Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 52.64 59.75 4.252

cyid 119.09 135.19 11.796

stid 696.90 777.66 97.225

STID=18 CYID=147 fcid=00020 name=INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER

- ROCKPORT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

18 147 00020 1 001 01 10100222 SO2 66.42 72.32 7.232 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

18 147 00020 1 001 02 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 66.42 72.32 7.232

cyid 66.42 72.32 7.232

stid 66.42 72.32 7.232

STID=19 CYID=115 fcid=58

- 07

- 001 name=MIDAMERICAN ENERGY CO.

- LOUISA STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

19 115 58

- 07

- 001 117487 147281 99 10100222 SO2 33.66 38.22 3.822 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=127 fcid =2112700003 name=KENTUCKY POWER CO

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc poli d Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

21 127 2112700003 2 002 99 10100202 SO2 104.52 113.82 11.382 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBE R Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=21 CYID=161 fcid=2116100009 name=EAST KY POWER COOP

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes21 161 2116100009 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 42.17 45.92 4.592 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

21 161 2116100009 2 002 99 10100212 SO2 55.39 60.31 6.031 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 97.55 106.23 10.623

cyid 97.55 106.23 10.623

stid 202.07 220.04 22.004

STID=27 CYID=61 fcid=2706100004 name=Minnesota Power Inc

- Boswell Energy Ctr

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Cont rol EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 61 2706100004 SV003 EU003 001 10100226 SO2 33.99 39.15 16.778 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

27 61 27

06100004 SV003 EU003 002 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.3 0.700 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 33.99 39.15 16.778

cyid 33.99 39.15 16.778

STID=27 CYID=109 fcid=2710900011 name=Rochester Public Utilities

- Silver Lake

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF c trltype ctrldes

27 109 2710900011 SV003 EU004 001 10100202 SO2 7.86 9.05 1.357 0.0 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=27 CYID=141 fcid=2714100004 name=NSP

- Sherburne Generating Plant

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid To ns/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU001 001 10100222 SO2 16.76 19.31 4.138 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Sc rubber added by LADCO

27 141 2714100004 SV001 EU002 001 10100222 SO2 22.55 25.97 5.565 0.3 0.850 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 39.31 45.28 9.703

cyid 39.31 45.28 9.703

stid 81.16 93.48 27.838

STID=39 CYID=13 fcid=0607130015 name=R. E. BURGER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 13 0607130015 R6 B011 B011P1 10100202 SO2 29.83 32.48 3.248 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 13 0607130015 R7 B012 B012P1 10100202 SO2 34.77 37. 86 3.786 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 64.60 70.34 7.034

cyid 64.60 70.34 7.034

STID=39 CYID=31 fcid=0616000000 name=CONESVILLE POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Futur e Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

39 31 0616000000 R4 B004 B004P1 10100212 SO2 316.00 344.11 34.411 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=39 CYID=167 fcid=0684000000 name=MUSKINGUM RIVER POWER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P1 10100201 SO2 65.07 70.85 7.085 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R2 B002 B002P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P1 10100201 SO2 94.58 103.00 10.300 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBE R Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R3 B003 B003P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B00 4 B004P1 10100203 SO2 81.64 88.90 8.890 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R4 B004 B004P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R5 B005 B005P1 10100203 SO2 97.22 105.87 10.587 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

3 9 167 0684000000 R5 B005 B005P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P1 10100202 SO 2 113.96 124.10 12.410 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

39 167 0684000000 R6 B006 B006P2 10100501 SO2 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 452.48 492.72 49.272

cyid 452.48 492.72 49.272

stid 833.08 907.16 90.716

STID=47 CYID=1 fcid=0009 name=TVA BULL RUN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 1 0009 S

- 1 001 99 10100212 SO2 130.81 136.82 13.682 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

STID=47 CY ID=73 fcid=0007 name=TVA JOHN SEVIER FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 73 0007 S

- 1A 001 99 10100212 SO2 20.15 21.07 2.107 0.0 0.90 0 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 1B 002 99 10100212 SO2 20.25 21.18 2.118 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2A 003 99 10100212 SO2 19.62 20.52 2.052 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 73 0007 S

- 2B 004 99 10100212 SO2 18.93 19.8 0 1.980 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 78.95 82.57 8.257

cyid 78.95 82.57 8.257

STID=47 CYID=85 fcid=0011 name=TVA JOHNSONVILLE FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Futur e Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 85 0011 S1

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 17.06 17.84 1.784 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 04 004 99 10100212 SO2 19.85 20.76 2.076 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 85 0011 S1

- 05 005 99 10100212 SO2 24.11 25.22 2.522 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 61.02 63.82 6.382

cyid 61.02 63.82 6.382

STID=47 CYID=145 fcid=0013 name=TVA KINGSTON FOSSIL PLAN T

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Ton s/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 145 0013 S

- 1 001 99 10100202 SO2 12.68 13.26 1.326 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 002 99 10100202 SO2 14.00 14.65 1.465 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO47 145 0013 S

- 1 003 99 10100202 SO2 13.80 14.44 1.444 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 004 99 10100202 SO2 12.24 12.80 1.280 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 1 005 99 10100202 SO2 19.57 20.47 2.047 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 006 99 10100202 SO2 18.92 19.79 1.979 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 007 99 10100202 SO2 21.30 22.28 2.228 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 008 99 10100202 SO2 18.54 19.39 1.939 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LA DCO

47 145 0013 S

- 2 009 99 10100202 SO2 20.72 21.68 2.168 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 151.77 158.75 15.875

cyid 151.77 158.75 15.875

STID=47 CYID=165 fcid=0025 name=TVA GALLATIN FOSSIL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

47 165 0025 S

- 01 001 99 10100212 SO2 13.91 14.54 1.454 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 01 002 99 10100212 SO2 14.87 15.56 1.556 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 003 99 10100212 SO2 16.33 17.08 1.708 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

47 165 0025 S

- 02 004 99 10100212 SO2 20.39 21.32 2.132 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

--- - -------- -------- ---------- fcid 65.49 68.50 6.850

cyid 65.49 68.50 6.850

stid 488.04 510.46 51.046

STID=54 CYID=39 fcid=0006 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- KANAWHA RIVER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 39 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 19.45 21.18 10.591 0.0 0.500 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 39 0006 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 20.94 22.80 11.399 0.0 0.500 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- --- ------- fcid 40.39 43.98 21.990

cyid 40.39 43.98 21.990

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0005 name=OHIO POWER

- MITCHELL PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0005 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 17.77 19.36 1.936 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0005 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 5.69 6.19 0.619 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 23.46 25.55 2.555

STID=54 CYID=51 fcid=0006 name=OHIO POWER

- KAMMER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 51 0006 013 001 99 10100203 SO2 47.06 51.25 5.125 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0006 013 002 99 10100203 SO2 47.66 51.90 5.190 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 51 0006 013 003 99 10100203 SO2 41.94 45.67 4.567 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO---- -------- -------- ----------

fcid 136.67 148.82 14.882

cyid 160.13 174.37 17.437

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0001 name=APPALACHIAN POWER CO.

- PHILIP SPORN PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID C YID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0001 014 001 99 10100202 SO2 18.6 5 20.31 2.031 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 002 99 10100202 SO2 15.87 17.28 1.728 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 003 99 10100202 SO2 21.46 23.36 2.336 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 014 004 99 10100202 SO2 20.53 22.36 2.236 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 53 0001 005 005 99 10100202 SO2 46.82 50.98 5.098 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 123.33 134.30 13.430

STID=54 CYID=53 fcid=0009 name=APPALACHIAN POWER

- MOUNTAINEER PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 53 0009 001 001 99 10100202 SO2 11.20 12.19 1.219 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- --- ----- -------- ---------- cyid 134.53 146.49 14.649

STID=54 CYID=79 fcid=0006 name=APPALACH IAN POWER

- JOHN E AMOS PLANT

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

54 79 0006 012 001 99 10100202 SO2 79.63 86.72 8.672 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 012 002 99 10100202 SO2 100.33 109.26 10.926 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

54 79 0006 003 003 99 10100202 SO2 139.38 151.77 15.177 0.0 0.900 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ---------- fcid 319.35 347.75 34.775

cyid 319.35 347.75 34.775

stid 654.39 712.59 88.851

STID=55 CYID=79 fcid=241007690 name=WIS ELECTRIC POWER OAK CREEK STATION

Base Yr Grown Controlled Base Year Future Year

STID CYID fcid stkid dvid prid scc polid Tons/Day Tons/Day Tons/Day Control EF Control EF ctrltype ctrldes

55 79 241007690 S13 B25 01 10100202 SO2 12.75 14.48 3.475 0.0 0.760 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S13 B26 01 10100202 SO2 8.68 9.85 2.462 0.0 0.750 SCR UBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B27 01 10100212 SO2 10.97 12.45 2.864 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

55 79 241007690 S14 B28 01 10100212 SO2 11.28 12.81 2.945 0.0 0.770 SCRUBBER Scrubber added by LADCO

---- -------- -------- ------ ---- fcid 43.68 49.59 11.746

cyid 43.68 49.59 11.746

stid 43.68 49.59 11.746

======== ======== ==========

3099.41 3 381.52 400.481

# Appendix II

Scenario C Controls (CAMD List)

### 1 

## NOx Controls (SCRs , 2007

– 2013) )

Plant Name UniqueID_Final State Name County Capacity

MW On Line

Year SCR

Online

Year

Chesterfield 3797_B_4 Virginia Chesterfield 166 1960 2013

Chesterfield 3797_B_5 Virginia Chesterfield 310 1964 2012

Scherer 6257_B_3 Georgia Monroe 875 1987 2011

Chesterfield 3797_B_6 Virginia Chesterfield 658 1969 2011

Sandow No 4 6648_B_4 Texas Milam 545 1981 2011

Beech Hollow Power Project 82704_B_1 Pennsylvania Washington 272 2011 2011

Longview Power 82702_B_1 West Virginia Monongalia 695 201 1 2011

Cliffside 2721_B_6 North Carolina Cleveland 800 2011 2011

AES Westover 2526_B_11 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_12 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_13 New York Broome 84 1951 2010

Iatan 2 6065_B_2 Missouri Plat te 850 2010 2010

Southwest 6195_B_2 Missouri Greene 300 2010 2010

Trimble Station (LGE) 6071_B_2 Kentucky Trimble 732 2010 2010

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_2 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2010 2010

Clay Boswell 1893_B_3 Minnesota Itasca 350 1973 2009

Asheville 2706_B_2 North Carolina Buncombe 184 1971 2009

Conesville 2840_B_4 Ohio Coshocton 780 1973 2009

Marshall 2727_B_3 North Carolina Catawba 657 1969 2009

St Johns River Power Park 207_B_1 Florida Duval 626 1987 2009

Ghent 1356_B_2 Kentucky Car roll 469 1977 2009

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_1 Maryland Prince George's 341 1964 2009

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_2 Maryland Prince George's 342 1965 2009

San Juan 2451_B_2 New Mexico San Juan 320 1973 2009

Big Bend 645_B_BB01 Florida Hillsborough 411 1970 200 9

Big Bend 645_B_BB02 Florida Hillsborough 391 1973 2009

Big Bend 645_B_BB03 Florida Hillsborough 414 1976 2009

Nebraska City Unit 2 6096_B_2 Nebraska Otoe 663 2009 2009

Cross 130_B_4 South Carolina Berkeley 652 2009 2009

Springerville 8223_B_4 Arizon a Apache 400 2009 2009

Sandow 5 82010_B_5 Texas Milam 600 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_1 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_2 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

TS Power Plant 82013_B_1 Nevada Eureka 200 2009 2009

Plum Point Energy 82014_B_1 Ar kansas Mississippi 665 2009 2009

Comanche 470_B_3 Colorado Pueblo 750 2009 2009

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_1 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2009 2009

Two Elk Generating Station 55360_B_1 Wyoming Campbell 300 2009 2009

J K Spruce 7097_B_BLR2 Texas Bex ar 750 2009 2009

Dallman 963_B_34 Illinois Sangamon 200 2009 2009

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_4 New York Yates 27 1950 2008

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_5 New York Yates 27 1950 2008

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_6 New York Yates 106 1953 2008

Charles R Lowman 56 _B_2 Alabama Washington 238 1979 2008

Charles R Lowman 56_B_3 Alabama Washington 238 1980 2008

Barry 3_B_5 Alabama Mobile 750 1971 2008

St Johns River Power Park 207_B_2 Florida Duval 626 1988 2008

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_2 Maryland Charles 620 1971 2008

### 2

Bailly 995_B_7 Indiana Porter 160 1962 2008

San Juan 2451_B_1 New Mexico San Juan 322 1976 2008

San Juan 2451_B_3 New Mexico San Juan 495 1979 2008

Weston 4078_B_4 Wisconsin Marathon 519 2008 2008

AES Deepwater 10670_B_AAB001 Texas Harri s 140 1986 2007

La Cygne 1241_B_1 Kansas Linn 724 1973 2007

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_1 Maryland Charles 624 1970 2007

PSEG Hudson Generating Station 2403_B_2 New Jersey Hudson 583 1967 2007

San Juan 2451_B_4 New Mexico San Juan 506 1982 2007

Big Bend 645_B_BB04 Florida Hillsborough 457 1985 2007

Cross 130_B_3 South Carolina Berkeley 620 2007 2007

Wygen II 55479_B_4 Wyoming Campbell 90 2007 2007

Council Bluffs 1082_B_4 Iowa Pottawattamie 790 2007 2007



## SO2 Controls (FGDs, 2007

– 2012)

Plan t Name UniqueID_Final State Name County Capacity

MW On Line

Year Scrubber

Online

Year

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_1 Alabama Jefferson 684 1978 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_2 Alabama Jefferson 687 1985 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_3 Alabama Jefferson 687 1989 2011

James H Miller Jr 6002_B_4 Alabama Jefferson 688 1991 2011

Cape Fear 2708_B_5 North Carolina Chatham 143 1956 2011

Baldwin Energy Complex 889_B_1 Illinois Randolph 624 1970 2011

Baldwin Energy Complex 889_B_2 Illinois Randolph 629 1973 2011

Baldwin Energy Complex 889_B_3 Illinois Randolph 629 1975 2011

Scherer 6257_B_3 Georgia Monroe 875 1987 2011

Milton R Young 2823_B_B1 North Dakota Oliver 250 1970 2011

W H Sammis 2866_B_6 Ohio Jefferson 630 1969 2011

W H Sammis 2866_B_7 Ohio Jefferson 630 1971 2011

PSEG Hudson Generating Station 2403_B_2 New Jersey Hudson 583 1967 2011

John Sevier 3405_B_1 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1955 2011

John Sevier 3405_B_2 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1955 2011

John Sevier 3405_B_3 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1956 2011

John S evier 3405_B_4 Tennessee Hawkins 176 1957 2011

Beech Hollow Power Project 82704_B_1 Pennsylvania Washington 272 2011 2011

Longview Power 82702_B_1 West Virginia Monongalia 695 2011 2011

Cliffside 2721_B_6 North Carolina Cleveland 800 2011 2011

AES Gree nidge LLC 2527_B_4 New York Yates 27 1950 2010

AES Greenidge LLC 2527_B_5 New York Yates 27 1950 2010

Barry 3_B_5 Alabama Mobile 750 1971 2010

E C Gaston 26_B_5 Alabama Shelby 861 1974 2010

Warrick 6705_B_4 Indiana Warrick 300 1970 2010

Coffeen 861_B_ 01 Illinois Montgomery 340 1965 2010

Coffeen 861_B_02 Illinois Montgomery 560 1972 2010

Cardinal 2828_B_3 Ohio Jefferson 630 1977 2010

Brandon Shores 602_B_1 Maryland Anne Arundel 643 1984 2010

Brandon Shores 602_B_2 Maryland Anne Arundel 643 1991 2010

Monroe 1733_B_4 Michigan Monroe 775 1974 2010

Cliffside 2721_B_5 North Carolina Cleveland 550 1972 2010

Crystal River 628_B_4 Florida Citrus 720 1982 2010

Bowen 703_B_1BLR Georgia Bartow 713 1971 2010

### 3

Crist 641_B_6 Florida Escambia 302 1970 2010

Cri st 641_B_7 Florida Escambia 477 1973 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_1 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_2 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_3 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_4 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 201 0

Clifty Creek 983_B_5 Indiana Jefferson 217 1955 2010

Clifty Creek 983_B_6 Indiana Jefferson 217 1956 2010

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_1 Maryland Prince George's 341 1964 2010

Chalk Point LLC 1571_B_2 Maryland Prince George's 342 1965 2010

Dickerson 1572_ B_1 Maryland Montgomery 182 1959 2010

Dickerson 1572_B_2 Maryland Montgomery 182 1960 2010

Dickerson 1572_B_3 Maryland Montgomery 182 1962 2010

R E Burger 2864_B_7 Ohio Belmont 156 1955 2010

R E Burger 2864_B_8 Ohio Belmont 156 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2 876_B_1 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_2 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_3 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_4 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Kyger Creek 2876_B_5 Ohio Gallia 217 1955 2010

Cheswick 8226_B_1 Pennsylvani a Allegheny 580 1970 2010

PSEG Mercer Generating Station 2408_B_1 New Jersey Mercer 315 1960 2010

PSEG Mercer Generating Station 2408_B_2 New Jersey Mercer 310 1961 2010

Silver Lake 2008_B_4 Minnesota Olmsted 61 1969 2010

Kingston 3407_B_1 Tennessee Ro ane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_2 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_3 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_4 Tennessee Roane 135 1954 2010

Kingston 3407_B_5 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kingston 3407_B_6 Tennessee Roane 177 195 5 2010

Kingston 3407_B_7 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kingston 3407_B_8 Tennessee Roane 177 1955 2010

Kingston 3407_B_9 Tennessee Roane 178 1955 2010

Sioux 2107_B_1 Missouri St. Charles 497 1967 2010

Sioux 2107_B_2 Missouri St. Charles 497 1968 2010

Chesterfield 3797_B_5 Virginia Chesterfield 310 1964 2010

Yorktown 3809_B_1 Virginia York 159 1957 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_11 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_12 New York Broome 22 1943 2010

AES Westover 2526_B_13 New York Broome 84 1 951 2010

Iatan 2 6065_B_2 Missouri Platte 850 2010 2010

Southwest 6195_B_2 Missouri Greene 300 2010 2010

Trimble Station (LGE) 6071_B_2 Kentucky Trimble 732 2010 2010

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_2 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2010 2010

Cholla 113_B _3 Arizona Navajo 271 1980 2009

Mayo 6250_B_1A North Carolina Person 362 1983 2009

Mayo 6250_B_1B North Carolina Person 362 1983 2009

Conesville 2840_B_4 Ohio Coshocton 780 1973 2009

G G Allen 2718_B_1 North Carolina Gaston 162 1957 2009

G G Allen 271 8_B_2 North Carolina Gaston 162 1957 2009

G G Allen 2718_B_3 North Carolina Gaston 260 1959 2009

### 4

G G Allen 2718_B_4 North Carolina Gaston 275 1960 2009

G G Allen 2718_B_5 North Carolina Gaston 265 1961 2009

H L Spurlock 6041_B_1 Kentucky Mason 315 1977 2009

Crystal River 628_B_5 Florida Citrus 717 1984 2009

Deerhaven Generating Station 663_B_B2 Florida Alachua 228 1981 2009

Bowen 703_B_2BLR Georgia Bartow 718 1972 2009

Wansley 6052_B_2 Georgia Heard 892 1978 2009

E W Brown 1355_B_1 Kentucky Mercer 94 1957 2009

E W Brown 1355_B_2 Kentucky Mercer 160 1963 2009

E W Brown 1355_B_3 Kentucky Mercer 422 1971 2009

Ghent 1356_B_2 Kentucky Carroll 469 1977 2009

Fayette Power Project 6179_B_1 Texas Fayette 598 1979 2009

Fayette Power Project 6179_B_2 Texa s Fayette 598 1980 2009

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_1 Maryland Charles 624 1970 2009

Morgantown Generating Plant 1573_B_2 Maryland Charles 620 1971 2009

PPL Brunner Island 3140_B_1 Pennsylvania York 321 1961 2009

PPL Brunner Island 3140_B_2 Penn sylvania York 378 1965 2009

Keystone 3136_B_1 Pennsylvania Armstrong 850 1967 2009

Keystone 3136_B_2 Pennsylvania Armstrong 850 1968 2009

Bull Run 3396_B_1 Tennessee Anderson 881 1967 2009

Bay Shore 2878_B_4 Ohio Lucas 215 1968 2009

Hatfields Ferry Po wer Station 3179_B_1 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1969 2009

Hatfields Ferry Power Station 3179_B_2 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1970 2009

Hatfields Ferry Power Station 3179_B_3 Pennsylvania Greene 530 1971 2009

Nebraska City Unit 2 6096_B_2 Nebraska Otoe 663 2009 2009

Cross 130_B_4 South Carolina Berkeley 652 2009 2009

Springerville 8223_B_4 Arizona Apache 400 2009 2009

Sandow 5 82010_B_5 Texas Milam 600 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_1 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2009

Oak Grove 82011_B_2 Texas Robertson 800 2009 2 009

TS Power Plant 82013_B_1 Nevada Eureka 200 2009 2009

Plum Point Energy 82014_B_1 Arkansas Mississippi 665 2009 2009

Comanche 470_B_3 Colorado Pueblo 750 2009 2009

Elm Road Generating Station 56068_B_1 Wisconsin Milwaukee 615 2009 2009

Two Elk Gene rating Station 55360_B_1 Wyoming Campbell 300 2009 2009

J K Spruce 7097_B_BLR2 Texas Bexar 750 2009 2009

Dallman 963_B_34 Illinois Sangamon 200 2009 2009

Charles R Lowman 56_B_1 Alabama Washington 86 1969 2008

John E Amos 3935_B_1 West Virginia Putnam 800 1971 2008

John E Amos 3935_B_2 West Virginia Putnam 800 1972 2008

Cholla 113_B_4 Arizona Navajo 380 1981 2008

Roxboro 2712_B_1 North Carolina Person 369 1966 2008

Roxboro 2712_B_3A North Carolina Person 341 1973 2008

Roxboro 2712_B_3B North Caroli na Person 341 1973 2008

Miami Fort 2832_B_7 Ohio Hamilton 500 1975 2008

Miami Fort 2832_B_8 Ohio Hamilton 500 1978 2008

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_2A Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_2B Virginia Port smouth 19 1988 2008

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_2C Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2008

J M Stuart 2850_B_1 Ohio Adams 585 1971 2008

J M Stuart 2850_B_2 Ohio Adams 597 1970 2008

### 5

J M Stuart 2850_B_3 Ohio Adams 597 1972 2008

J M Stuart 2850_B_4 Ohio Adams 597 1974 2008

Monroe 1733_B_3 Michigan Monroe 795 1973 2008

Belews Creek 8042_B_1 North Carolina Stokes 1,115 1974 2008

Belews Creek 8042_B_2 North Carolina Stokes 1,115 1975 2008

Bowen 703_B_3BLR Georgia Bartow 902 1974 2008

Bowen 703_B_4B LR Georgia Bartow 929 1975 2008

Hammond 708_B_1 Georgia Floyd 112 1954 2008

Hammond 708_B_2 Georgia Floyd 112 1954 2008

Hammond 708_B_3 Georgia Floyd 112 1955 2008

Hammond 708_B_4 Georgia Floyd 510 1970 2008

Wansley 6052_B_1 Georgia Heard 891 1976 200 8

Harding Street 990_B_70 Indiana Marion 435 1973 2008

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_1A Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2008

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_1B Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2008

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_1C Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 198 7 2008

Ghent 1356_B_4 Kentucky Carroll 478 1984 2008

Council Bluffs 1082_B_3 Iowa Pottawattamie 690 1978 2008

PPL Brunner Island 3140_B_3 Pennsylvania York 749 1969 2008

PPL Montour 3149_B_1 Pennsylvania Montour 774 1972 2008

PPL Montour 3149_B_2 Penn sylvania Montour 766 1973 2008

Comanche 470_B_1 Colorado Pueblo 366 1973 2008

Comanche 470_B_2 Colorado Pueblo 370 1975 2008

Cayuga 1001_B_2 Indiana VermilIon 473 1972 2008

Winyah 6249_B_1 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1975 2008

Winyah 6249_B_2 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1977 2008

Winyah 6249_B_3 South Carolina Georgetown 295 1980 2008

Chesterfield 3797_B_6 Virginia Chesterfield 658 1969 2008

Brayton Point 1619_B_1 Massachusetts Bristo 243 1963 2008

Brayton Point 1619_B_2 Massachusetts Bristo 24 4 1964 2008

Weston 4078_B_4 Wisconsin Marathon 519 2008 2008

Gorgas 8_B_10 Alabama Walker 690 1972 2007

Gorgas 8_B_8 Alabama Walker 165 1956 2007

Gorgas 8_B_9 Alabama Walker 175 1958 2007

John E Amos 3935_B_3 West Virginia Putnam 1,300 1973 2007

Moun taineer 6264_B_1 West Virginia Mason 1,300 1980 2007

Cardinal 2828_B_1 Ohio Jefferson 600 1967 2007

Cardinal 2828_B_2 Ohio Jefferson 600 1967 2007

Roxboro 2712_B_2 North Carolina Person 639 1968 2007

Roxboro 2712_B_4A North Carolina Person 343 1980 200 7

Roxboro 2712_B_4B North Carolina Person 343 1980 2007

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_1A Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_1B Virginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Cogentrix Virginia Leasing Corp 10071_B_1C V irginia Portsmouth 19 1988 2007

Killen Station 6031_B_2 Ohio Adams 615 1982 2007

Marshall 2727_B_2 North Carolina Catawba 378 1966 2007

Marshall 2727_B_3 North Carolina Catawba 657 1969 2007

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_2A Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 198 7 2007

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_2B Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2007

Cogentrix Hopewell 10377_B_2C Virginia Hopewell (city) 18 1987 2007

Ghent 1356_B_3 Kentucky Carroll 478 1981 2007

### 6

Louisa 6664_B_101 Iowa Louisa 700 1983 2007

Allen S King 1915_ B_1 Minnesota Washington 571 1968 2007

Mitchell 3948_B_1 West Virginia Marshall 800 1971 2007

Gibson 6113_B_1 Indiana Gibson 630 1975 2007

Gibson 6113_B_2 Indiana Gibson 628 1975 2007

Winyah 6249_B_4 South Carolina Georgetown 270 1981 2007

Pleasant Pr airie 6170_B_2 Wisconsin Kenosha 617 1985 2007

Cross 130_B_3 South Carolina Berkeley 620 2007 2007

Wygen II 55479_B_4 Wyoming Campbell 90 2007 2007

Council Bluffs 1082_B_4 Iowa Pottawattamie 790 2007 2007



## Assumed BART Facilities and Units

State County Fac ID Facilit y Name Unit ID

MI Bay B2840 CE

- KARN/WEADOCK EU00036

MI Bay B2840 CE

- KARN/WEADOCK EU00037

MI Eaton B4001 LAN. BW&L ERICKSON EU00007

MI Houghton B6553 UP POWER CO / PORTAGE EU00008

MI Huron B2815 DTE

- HARBOR BEACH EU00009

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RG00023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RG00023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Eckert RG00023

MI Ingham B2647 LAN. BW&L Moores Park RG00021

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00029

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00030

MI Marq uette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00031

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00032

MI Marquette B4261 WE

- ENERGIES EU00033

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00062

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00068

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00063

MI Monroe B2816 DTE

- MONROE EU00064

MI Ottawa B2835 CE

– CAMPBELL EU00062

MI Ottawa B2835 CE

– CAMPBELL EU00061

MI Saint Clair B2796 DTE

- ST. CLAIR / BELLE RIVER EU00111

MI Saint Clair B6145 DTE

– GREENWOOD EU00009

MI Wayne B2132 WYANDOTTE EU00036

MI Wayne B2185 DET ROIT PLD, MISTERSKY EU00014

MI Wayne B2811 DTE

– TRENTON EU00035

OH Lake 0243160009 CEI., EASTLAKE PLANT B005

OH 0247030013 Orion Power Midwest B012

OH 0285010188 Dept of Public Utilities, City of Orrville B001

OH 0285010188 Dept of Public Utilities, City of Orrville B004

OH 0448020006 Toledo Edison Co., Bay Shore B003

OH 0448020006 Toledo Edison Co., Bay Shor e B004

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B003

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Plant B004

OH 0616000000 Conesville Power Pl ant B007

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B001

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B002

### 7

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B003

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B004

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Pl ant B008

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power P l ant B009

OH 0641050002 Cardinal Power Plant B009

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W. H. SAMMIS PLANT B011

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W. H. SAMMIS PLANT B012

OH Jefferson 0641160017 W. H. SAMMIS PLANT B013

OH 0684000000 Muskingum River Power Plant B006

OH Ada ms 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B001

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B002

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B003

OH Adams 0701000007 DP&L, J.M. Stuart Generating Station B004

OH 070100 0060 DP&L, Killen Station B001

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B002

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B008

OH 1409040243 City of Hamilton Dept of Public Utilities B009

OH 1413100008 CG&E W. C. BECKJORD B005

OH 1413100008 CG&E W. C. BECKJORD B006

OH 1431350093 CG&E MIAMI FORT STATION B015

IL Peoria 856 Ameren

– Edwards 2

IL Sangamon 963 CWLP

– Dallman 31

IL Sangamon 963 CWLP

– Dallman 32

IL Christian 876 Dominion

– Kincaid 1

IL Christian 87 6 Dominion

– Kincaid 2

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant En ergy

- Columbia Generating B20

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant En ergy

- Columbia Generating B21

WI COLUMBIA 111003090 Alliant En ergy

- Columbia Generating B22

WI GRANT 122014530 Alliant Energy, Nelso n Dewey B22 (unit 2)

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Energies

- Oak Creek Station B26 (Unit 6)

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Energies

- Oak Creek Station B27 (Unit 7)

WI MILWAUKEE 241007690 We Energies

- Oak Creek Station B28

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Energies

- Valley Station B21

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Energies

- Valley Station B23

WI MILWAUKEE 241007800 We Energies

- Valley Station B24

WI BRO WN 405031990 WI Public Service Corp

- JP Pulliam B27 (unit 8)

WI SHEBOYGAN 460033090 WP & L Allian t Energy

– Edgewater B24

W I BUFFALO 606034110 Dairyland Power Coop Alma Station

(J.P. Madgett boilers) B25 (+B26)

WI BUFFALO 606034110 Dairyland Power Coop Alma Station B27

WI VERNON 663020930 Dairyland Power Coop Genoa Station B20

WI VERNON 663020930 Dairyland Power Coop Genoa Station B25

IN Porter 995 Bailly 7

IN Porter 995 Bailly 8

IN Vermillion 1001 Cayuga 1

IN Vermillion 1001 Cayuga 2

IN Montgomery 1024 Crawfordsville 6

IN Warrick 1012 Culley 2

### 8

IN Warrick 1012 Culley 3

IN Gibson 6113 Gibson 1

IN Gibson 6113 Gi bson 2

IN Cass 1032 Logansport 6

IN Sullivan 6213 Merom 1

IN Sullivan 6213 Merom 2

IN LaPorte 997 Michigan City 12

IN Lake 996 Mitchell 11

IN Pike 994 Petersburg 1

IN Pike 994 Petersburg 2

IN Pike 994 Petersburg 3

IN Pike 1043 Ratts 1

IN Pike 104 3 Ratts 2

IN Wayne 7335 RPL 2

IN Jasper 6085 Schahfer 14

IN Jasper 6085 Schahfer 15

IN Lake 981 Stateline 4

IN Marion 990 Stout 70

IN Dearborn 988 Tanners Creek 4

IN Vigo 1010 Wabash River 6

IN Warrick 6705 Warrick 4

IA 07

- 02

- 005 Cedar Fal ls Utilities Unit #7 (EU10.1A)

IA 88

- 01

- 004 Central Iowa Power Cooperative

(CIPCO)

– Summit Lake Station Comb Turbines (EU

1 /1G , EU2 /2 G)

IA 70

- 08

- 003 Central Iowa Power Cooperative

(CIPCO)

– Fair Station Unit # 2 (EU 2 &

EU 2G)

IA 85

- 01

- 006 City of Am es

- Steam Electric Plant Boiler #7 (EU 2)

IA 29

- 01

- 013 Interstate Power & Light

- Burlington Main Plant Boiler.

IA 03

- 03

- 001 Interstate Power & Light

- Lansing Boiler #4. Sixteen

units in total.

IA 23

- 01

- 014 Interstate Power & Light

- ML Kapp Boiler #2. Six units

in total.

IA 57

- 01

- 042 Interstate Power & Light

- Prairie Creek Boiler #4. Fourteen

units in total.

IA 78

- 01

- 026 MidAmerican Energy Co

- Council Bluffs Boiler #3 (EU003)

IA 97

- 04

- 010 MidAmerican Energy Co

- Neal North Boilers #1

- 3

(EU0 01

- EU003)

IA 97

- 04

- 011 MidAmerican Energy Co

- Neal South Boiler #4 (EU003)

IA 70

- 01

- 011 Muscatine Power and Water Boiler #8

IA 63

- 02

- 005 Pella Municipal Power Plant Boilers #6

- 8

MN 2709900001 Austin Utilities NE Power Station EU001

MN 27 13700027 Hibbing Public Utilities EU003

MN 2703100001 MN Power, Taconite Harbor EU003

MN 2706100004 MN Power, Boswell Energy Center EU003

MN 2701500010 New Ulm Public Utilities EU003

- Boiler 4

MN 2711100002 Otter Tail Power Hoot Lake EU003

MN 27 10900011 Rochester Public Utilities, Silver Lake EU003

MN 2710900011 Rochester Public Utilities, Silver Lake EU004

MN 2713700028 Virginia Public Utilities EU003

- Boiler 9

MN 2714100004 Xcel Energy, Sherco EU001, EU002

MN 2716300005 Xcel Energy, Allen S King EU001

- Boiler 1

### 9

MN 2705300015 Xcel Energy, Riverside EU003

- Boiler 8

MO 290710003 Ameren

- Labadie B1, B2, B3, B4

MO 291830001 Ameren

- Sioux B1, B2

MO 290990016 Ameren

- Rush Island B1, B2

MO 290950031 Auila

- Sibley B3

- 5C

MO 291430004 Assoc. Electric

- New Madrid B1(EP

- 01), B2

(EP

- 02)

MO 290770039 City Utilities Springfield

- Southwest B1 (E09)

MO 290770005 City Utilities Springfield

- James River EO7, EO8

MO 290970001 Empire Distric Electric

- Asbury B7

MO 29083 0001 KC Power and Light

- Montrose EP08

MO 290210004 Aqula

- Lake Road EP06

MO 291750001 Assoc. Electric

- Thomas Hill EP01, EP02

MO 290950021 Trigen

- Kansas City B1A

MO 290190002 City of Columbia Municipal Power Plant EP02

MO 291950010 Marshall Munipal Utilities EP05

MO 290950050 Independence Power & Light

- Blue Valley B3 (EP05)

WV 3943 Fort Martin

WV 6004 Pleasants

WV 3948 Mitchell

WV 3935 Amos

WV 6264 Mountaineer

WV 3944 Harrison

TN 3396 TVA Bull Run

TN 3399 TVA Cumberland

KY 1363 Cane Run

KY 1364 Mill Creek

KY 6041 Spurlock

KY 1384 John Sherman Cooper

KY 1353 Big Sandy

KY 1356 Ghent

KY 1355 Brown

KY 1374 Owensboro Municipal

KY 1372 Henderson Municipal

KY 1378 Paradise

KY 1361 Coleman

KY 1382 Reid/Henderson 2

KY 6639 Green

## Public Notice

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

Redesignation and Maintenance Plan for the

Cleveland-Akron-Lorain, OH 24-Hour PM 2.5 

## Nonattainment Area

Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain, Medina, Portage and Summit Counties

Notice is hereby given that the Director of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency,

(Ohio EPA) is requesting that the United States Environment al Protection Agency (U.S.

EPA) revise the current air quality designation for the Cleveland-Akron-Lorain

nonattainment area, including Cuyahoga, Lak e, Lorain, Medina, Portage and Summit

counties to attainment with respect to the 2006 24-hour PM 2.5 

## national ambient air

quality standard (NAAQS). Fine particle pollution or PM 2.5 

## is a mixture of microscopic

solids and liquid droplets suspended in air that is 2.5 micrometers in diameter and

smaller – 1/30 th 

## the diameter of a human hair. PM 2.5 

## can be emitted directly or formed

secondarily in the atmosphere. Air qualit y monitoring data collected between 2008 and

2010 in the region demonstrate a ttainment of the NAAQS and t here is evidence that the

improved air quality is due to permanent, enfor ceable emission reductions. In addition,

existing requirements are sufficient to maintain the 2006 24-hour PM 2.5 

## standard in this

area at least ten years into the future.

Computer models show that existing stat e and federal emission reduction requirements

are sufficient to attain and maintain the NAAQS in the Cleveland-Akron-Lorain area.

Therefore, Ohio EPA proposes to utilize ex isting emission inventory information and

projections of future emissions as the dem onstration of the ability to maintain the

NAAQS in the Cleveland-Akron- Lorain area in the future.

The Cleveland-Akron-Lorain ar ea is currently designated as nonattainment for the 2006

24-hour PM 2.5 

## standard. As part of an acceptabl e maintenance plan, Ohio EPA is

required to develop a contingency plan to prov ide for additional emission reductions if a

violation of the NAAQS is monitored afte r the area has been redes ignated. The plan

which Ohio EPA is proposing to USEPA as part of this redesignation contains

reductions which will help alleviate the ambi ent problem until a re vised SIP can be

developed.

The State of Ohio proposes to:

1. Request the U.S. EPA redesignate the Cleveland- Akron-Lorain area to

attainment with respect to the 2006 24-hour PM 2.5 

## NAAQS and revise the

maintenance plan. This request will document that existing enforceable control

measures are responsible for the obs erved improvement in air quality.

2. Designate existing controls as sufficient to maintain the NAAQS into the future.

3. Commit to the proposed contingency plan.

## These actions must be noticed to allo w public comment and to satisfy USEPA

requirements for public involvement in SIP re lated activities. This notice addresses Ohio

EPA’s reliance on the emission projections as evidence of attainment and maintenance

and the commitment to instit ute contingency measures if ambient exceedances or

violations trigger the contingency plan r equirements. Written comments will be received

on or before May 21, 2012at the following address:

E-mail: Erica.Fetty@epa.state.oh.us

Mailing address: Erica Fetty

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, DAPC

Lazarus Government Center

P.O. Box 1049

Columbus, Ohio 43216-1049

Pursuant to Section 119.03 of the Ohio Revised Code, a public hearing on this

redesignation request will be c onducted as follows May 21, 2012 at 2:30 PM, at the

Ohio EPA Northeast District Offices, 2110 East Aurora Road, Twinsburg, Ohio 44087.

All interested persons are entitled to att end or be represented at the hearings and give

written or oral comments on these changes. All oral comments presented at the

hearing, and all written statements submitted at the hearing or to the above address by

the close of business on May 21, 2012 will be considered by Ohio EPA prior to final

action on this redesignation. Written stat ements submitted after May 21, 2012 may be

considered as time and circumstances permit, but will not be part of the official record of

the hearing.

This redesignation and maintenance request is available on Ohio EPA DAPC’s Web

page for electronic downloading at: http://www.epa.ohio.gov/dapc/SIP/annual.aspx

. Questions regarding accessing the web site should be directed to Arunee Niamlarb at

614-728-1342; other questions or comments about this document should be directed to

either Erica Fetty, (614)-644-2310, Erica.Fetty@epa.state.oh.us or Jennifer Dines at

(614) 644-3696, Jennifer.Dines@epa.state.oh.us or mailed to Erica Fetty or Jennifer

Dines at the above address.

# SHUMAKER.

Shwnake.t; 

## Loop & 

### Kendrick, UP

G!ERJ A BUDZYNSKI



### 419.321.1332

cbudzynski@sJk.law.com 1000 Jackson Street

Toledo, Ohio 43604-5573 419.241.9000

419.241.6894 fax

www.slk-law.com



## May21, 2012

Erica Fetty

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, DAPC

Lazarus 

## Government Center

P.O. Box 1049

Columbus, Ohio 43216-1049 VIA EMAIL AND U.S. REGULAR MAIL

Re: Redesignation and Maintenance Plan for the Ohio Portion of the ClevelandAkron- Lorain 24- Hour PM

2 

### .s 

## Nonattainment Area



## Otr File Na 043591



## Dear 

## Ms. Fetty:

In April, 2012, Ohio EPA provided public notice of its intention to request that U.S. EPA

redesignate the Cleveland-Akron-Lorain 24-hour PM 2

_ 5 

## nonattainment area as "attainment." The

following comments regarding this action are submitted on behalf of the OhioUtilityGroupandits

member companies (the "Utilities").' Based on a review of the draft request for redesignation

("Ohio Request")/ the Utilities support Ohio EPA's redesignation request to attainment for the

Geveland-Akron-Lorain 24-hour PMz 5 

## National Ambient 

## Air Quality Standards ("NAAQS").

First, data from Ohio's monitors demonstrate that the Cleveland-Akron-Lorain area is

attaining the 2006 24-hour PM

25 

## NAAQS. 

## This is based on quality assured air quality monitoring

data for 2008-2010. 

## It is notable that the downward trend in PM

25 

## in the ambient air coincides with

the installation and operation of flue gas desulfurization pollution controls on many electrical

generating units ("EGUs"). In fact, the Ohio Request identifies emission controls on EGUs as one

factor leading to this trend.'

1 

## The member companies include: Buckeye Power, Inc., The Dayton Power and Light Company,

Duke Energy Ohio, First Energy, Ohio Power Company (a unit of AEP), and Ohio Valley Electric

Cozporation.

2 

## Ohio EPA, Draft: Redesignation Request and Maintenance Plan for the Cleveland-Akron-Lorain

24-Hour PM

25 

## Nonattainment Area, Cuyahoga, 

## Lake, Lorain, Medina, Portage, and Summit, Ohio

(April2012),

.·

. . . available at http:/ 

## I www.epa.ohio.gov/ portals/ 27 /SIP/ Attain!PM2 5 24hr/ Cleveland PM25 24-

hr redesig DRAFT.pdf, last visited May 16, 2012. Hereinafter "Ohio Request."

3 

## Id. at 13.

CHARLOTTE 

## I COLUMBUS 

## I SARASOTA 

## I TAMPA 

## I TOLEDO

## Erica Fetty

May21, 2012

Page 2

Second, Ohio EPA has demonstrated that the improvement in 

## air quality is due to

permanent and enforceable emissions reductions. 

## This air quality improvement is attributable to the

implementation of the Oean 

## Air Interstate Ru1e ("CAIR'') and NOx SIP Call Ru1es! These ru1es

have a direct impact on the Utilities, requiring the Utilities to install controls to reduce PM:,.
5 

## and its

precursor pollutants.' U.S. EPA has determined that the regu1ations developed in response to both

of these ru1es are permanent and enforceable because both cap the total emissions allotted in each

covered state and both impose strict compliance deadlines. In addition, since U.S. EPA's 

## initial

designations were made federally enforceable, "federal consent decrees required the reductions of 

# so2 and NOX emissions from utility sources." 

# 6

Third, Ohio EPA 

## has addressed their obligation to reduce regionally transported pollutants.

Ohio EPA has an approved CAIR program that requires EGUs to reduce emissions that impact

downwind states. 

## While the federal CAIR ru1es were vacated and later remanded to U.S. EPA, the

CAIR ru1es remain in effect at 

## this time. In 2011, U.S. EPA finalized a replacement (voss-State 

## Air

Pollution Ru1e or "CSAPR'') to CAIR However, CSAPR 

## was challenged in the United States

District Court, District of Columbia. During the appeals process, the Court stayed CSAPR in

December 2011. In issuing the stay, CAIR 

## was reinstated by the D. 

## C. Circuit and remains in effect.

Thus, Ohio EPA's reliance on CAIR is appropriate until the final regu1ations replace CAIR

Fourth, Ohio EPA has developed a Plan that indicates that these reductions 

## will be

maintained. These reductions 

## will be maintained due to the implementation of CAIR, which

ensures that the current and future emissions of NOx> directly emitted PM:,. 5 , 

## and S0 2 

## for the area

remain at or below attainment year emission levels.'

Finally, because of the implementation of ru1es such as the NOx SIP Call and CAIR, Ohio

EPA 

## has incorporated into the Utilities' permits additional controls, monitoring, recordkeeping, and

reporting requirements. These controls have resu1ted in a downward trend in 

## air pollutants and have

been a contributing factor to why monitors in the Oeveland-Akron-Lorain are now measuring

attainment.



## The Utilities appreciate the opportunity to comment on 

## the Ohio Request. Based on the

information provided, the Utilities support Ohio EPA's request for redesignation. 

## If you have any

questions regarding these comments, please contact me.

CAB\bd

4 

## !d. at 4-5.

5 

## Ohio Request at 40.

6 

## !d.

7 

## !d. at 26-36.

SLK_TOL # 195194lvl

# Verytru1yyo~urs,

# ~·a. 

# ,

Cheri 

## A Budzyns

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 1

1 OHIO ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

PUBLIC HEARING

2

3

4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -:

:

5 In re: :

:

6 Ohio EPA Requests :

Recognition of Improved Air :

7 Quality in Northeast Ohio :

:

8 :

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -:

9

10

11 Transcript of proceedings before the Ohio

12 Environmental Protection Agency, taken at 2110 East

13 Aurora Road, Twinsburg, Ohio 44087,on Monday,

14 May 21, 2012, commencing at 2:30 p.m.

15

16

17

18 APPEARANCES:

19 Mary McCarron, Ohio EPA Public Interest Center

Erica Fetty, Ohio EPA

20

21

- - -

22

23

24

25

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 2

1 PROCEEDINGS

2 MS. McCARRON: We'll open up the

3 hearing.

4 My name is Mary McCarron. I am public

5 information officer for Ohio Environmental

6 Protection Agency. I will be presiding over

7 today's public hearing.

8 Thank you for taking the time to attend

9 this hearing before the Ohio EPA. The purpose

10 of the hearing today is to obtain comments

11 from any interested person regarding Ohio

12 EPA's proposed action.

13 The State of Ohio plans to ask U.S. EPA

14 to officially recognize that air quality in

15 the Cleveland-Lorain-Akron area meets the 2006

16 Federal Fine Particulate Standard.

17 Air quality data from 2008-2010 show

18 that the Cleveland-Lorain-Akron area is

19 meeting the 2006 24-hour National Fine

20 Particulate Matter Standard. When asking for

21 redesignation, states are required to

22 demonstrate that the metropolitan area will be

23 able to maintain compliance with the Fine

24 Particulate Standard for 10 years. Current

25 national, state and local air pollution

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 3

1 controls to limit particulate emissions will

2 enable the area to maintain the air quality,

3 including: Lower emissions from coal-burning

4 power plants, additional controls on

5 diesel-powered vehicles and enforcement

6 efforts.

7 The proposed redesignation request

8 affects Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain, Medina,

9 Portage and Summit Counties.

10 Comments can be submitted until the

11 close of business today, May 21. You may

12 email comments to Erika.fetty@epa.ohio.gov.

13 All interested persons are entitled to

14 attend or be represented, and to present oral

15 and/or written comments concerning the

16 proposed action. All written and oral

17 comments received as part of the official

18 record will be considered by the Director of

19 Ohio EPA before a final decision is made.

20 Written statements submitted after the

21 comment period closes may be considered as

22 time and circumstances permit, but will not be

23 part of the official record of the hearing.

24 If you wish to present oral testimony

25 at this hearing today and have not already

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 4

1 signed the registration sheet, please do so at

2 this time. The sheet is available at the

3 registration table. Persons will be called in

4 the order in which they have registered.

5 There is no cross-examination of

6 speakers or of representatives of Ohio EPA in

7 public hearings such as this. Ohio EPA

8 hearings provide citizens the opportunity to

9 submit comments on the official record.

10 Therefore, we will not be able to answer

11 questions during the hearing. However, Ohio

12 EPA staff may ask clarifying questions of the

13 person testifying to ensure the record is as

14 complete and accurate as possible.

15 I will now read the names of those who

16 have registered at this hearing and will give

17 each person an opportunity to testify.

18 Terry Tucker, would you like to --

19 MR. TUCKER: I do have some

20 questions. Do I ask them now?

21 MS. McCARRON: If you want to put

22 them into the record, you can put them in

23 now. Then if we go off the record, after

24 everybody had a chance, we might be able to

25 answer them. I can't guarantee we can answer

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 5

1 them. State your name and spell it for the

2 Court Reporter.

3 MR. TUCKER: My name is T-E-R-R-Y,

4 T-U-C-K-E-R, Wadsworth, Ohio. My question is

5 who is asking for the redesignation. I

6 believe it's Ohio EPA.

7 Secondly, I understand that there were

8 a number of monitors for monitoring

9 particulate that were not operating;

10 therefore, is the request for the

11 redesignation valid, since some of the

12 monitors were not operating.

13 We're still failing to meet the current

14 standard. So I'm wondering -- that is a third

15 question -- why we're asking for redesignation

16 when we're not meeting the current standard.

17 Those are my three questions. I don't know

18 how this works. I've never been to one of

19 these before. I came to attend and ask the

20 questions, see how it works.

21 MS. McCARRON: Thank you very much

22 for attending.

23 We will move on to George Homa. Would

24 you like to make any testimony?

25 MR. HOMA: The question I have is

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 6

1 maybe also related to particulates. Who is

2 interested or takes comments on airline fuel

3 dumping?

4 I came here about -- back in the era

5 when DC-10's were losing their engines because

6 of Chinese bolts, asking the same question. I

7 was out in my yard one day, I thought my

8 neighbor had a severe diesel spill someplace

9 from a truck. There was stuff on the plants

10 and trees, grass. I could breathe it, choke

11 on it. I'm sure it was from airline fuel

12 being dumped. No one here, or at Cleveland

13 Hopkins, or the FAA seemed to be interested in

14 hearing me.

15 MS. McCARRON: The proper authority

16 to reply to that would be either U.S. EPA or

17 the FAA.

18 MR. HOMA: FAA, zero response.

19 MS. McCARRON: I would check at the

20 Federal EPA then. Ohio EPA doesn't regulate

21 that.

22 MR. HOMA: It is Ohio

23 environment.

24 MS. McCARRON: It is in the air,

25 across state lines, air traffic. We don't

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 7

1 regulate that.

2 MR. TUCKER: Like interstate

3 commerce.

4 MR. TUCKER: Can I put a no-fly zone

5 straight up above my residence?

6 MS. McCARRON: If you want, we can

7 discuss this off the record, since it is not

8 pertaining to the particulate matter standard

9 directly. I'll talk with you after we are

10 done with the hearing.

11 MR. HOMA: Check out no-fly

12 zones also.

13 MS. McCARRON: Burt Mechenbier.

14 MR. MECHENBIER: Pass.

15 MS. McCARRON: I appreciate the

16 testimony. We'll go off the record until 3:00

17 p.m.

18 (Recess taken.)

19 MS. McCARRON: Back on the record.

20 At this time there is nobody else to provide

21 testimony. I will remind you written comments

22 can be submitted until 5:00 p.m. today.

23 Thanks for attending. The time is now

24 3:00 p.m. this hearing is adjourned.

25 (Hearing adjourned at 3:00 p.m.)

# (216) 696-2272 FINCUN-MANCINI -- THE COURT REPORTERS Page 8

1 State of Ohio, )

) SS:

2 County of Cuyahoga. )

3

4 C E R T I F I C A T E

5 This certifies that the foregoing is a true

6 and correct transcript of the proceedings had

7 before the State of Ohio, Environmental

8 Protection Agency, in Twinsburg, Ohio on

9 Monday, May 21, 2012, commencing at

10 2:30 p.m.

11

12 In Re:

13 Ohio EPA Requests Recognition of Improved Air

Quality in Northeast Ohio

14

15

16

17

18

__________________________ 19 COURT REPORTER

20 FINCUN-MANCINI COURT REPORTERS

1801 East Ninth Street

21 Suite 1720

Cleveland, Ohio 44114

22 (216) 696-2272

(216) 696-2275 FAX

23

24

25