# From: Keith Barnett/RTP/USEPA/US

To: Cortney_Higgins@omb.eop.gov

Cc: Charlotte Bertrand/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Amy Lamson/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Ron

Evans/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Walton.Tom@epamail.epa.gov

, Steven |

|Silverman/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Torres.Elineth@epamail.epa.gov

, "Michael Laney" < mnl@rti.org >, Susan Fairchild/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA

Date: 07/14/2010 02:59 PM

Subject: Cost spreadsheet

Dear Courtney:

I got clearance from OPEI to send you the Portland Cement cost spreadsheets and

some of the economics tables. This is what I plan to discuss on Friday.

(See attached file: Portlandcementtables.docx)(See attached file: costs for OMB

‐

7

‐ 1

‐ 10.xls)

We already talked about emissions levels

‐ are there other items you want to talk

about?

Keith W. Barnett

USEPA/OAQPS/SPPD/MMG

Mail Code D243

‐ 02

Research Triangle Park, NC 27711

919

‐ 541

‐ 5605

barnett.keith@epa.gov

# Table 3-5. National-Level Market Impacts: 2005

Changes from Baseline

Baseline Absolute Percent

Market Price ($/metric ton) $83.70 $4.40 5.3%

Market Output (million metric tons) 126

− 6

− 4.7%

Domestic production 93

− 10

− 10.8%

Imports 33 3 10.0%



# Table 3-6. Regional Compliance Costs and Market Price Changes ($/metric ton of

cement): 2005

Incremental Compliance Costs

($/metric ton of estimated

cement production)

Baseline

Price Market Price Change

Market Mean Minimum Maximum Absolute Percent

Atlanta $3.60 $1.10 $5.90 $81.30 $2.60 3.2%

Baltimore/Philadelphia $6.20 $1.20 $10.00 $81.20 $5.70 7.0%

Birmingham $3.60 $1.10 $4.80 $82.60 $3.70 4.5%

Chicago $6.80 $0.90 $10.10 $65.90 $4.40 6.7%

Cincinnati $8.10 $4.00 $14.10 $84.10 $10.00 11.9%

Dallas $5.60 $3.50 $8.50 $74.70 $4.90 6.6%

Denver $3.00 $1.00 $8.10 $88.70 $5.30 6.0%

Detroit $6.50 $4.00 $10.30 $92.80 $6.30 6.8%

Florida $3.40 $1.20 $5.50 $90.70 $3.30 3.6%

Kansas City $8.60 $3.80 $13.80 $86.10 $7.80 9.1%

Los Angeles $6.00 $3.20 $13.10 $77.30 $4.10 5.3%

Minneapolis $6.30 $4.50 $8.80 $92.20 $8.20 8.9%

New York/Boston $2.50 $1.00 $4.50 $89.00 $1.60 1.8%

Phoenix $1.90 $1.00 $6.00 $82.10 $3.20 3.9%

Pittsburgh $7.60 $6.90 $8.00 $88.00 $5.30 6.0%

St. Louis $4.80 $3.80 $5.60 $83.70 $5.20 6.2%

Salt Lake City $5.90 $1.60 $9.90 $91.40 $9.70 10.6%

San Antonio $4.00 $0.80 $7.70 $82.30 $3.20 3.9%

# San Francisco $3.10 $1.00 $5.00 $96.90 $3.20 3.3%

Seattle $1.20 $1.00 $1.40 $88.00 $0.60 0.7%

Grand Total $5.20 $0.80 $14.10 $83.70 $4.40 5.3%



# Table 3-7. Summary of Region al Market Impacts: 2005

Regional Markets

With Imports Without Imports All Markets

Change in Market Price

Absolute ($/metric ton)

Mean $4.70 $5.90 $4.40

Median $4.30 $5.20 $4.60

Minimum $0.60 $3.20 $0.60

Maximum $9.70 $10.00 $10.00

Percentage of baseline price

Mean 5.5% 7.0% 5.3%

Median 5.7% 6.1% 6.0%

Minimum 0.6% 3.9% 0.6%

Maximum 10.6% 11.9% 11.9%

Change in Domestic Production

Absolute (thousand metric tons)

Mean

− 562

− 257

− 298

Median

− 457

− 251

− 303

Minimum

− 59

− 144

− 20

Maximum

− 1,519

− 380

− 679

Percentage of baseline production

Mean

− 12.3%

− 6.2%

− 11.1%

Median

− 11.0%

− 5.4%

− 10.4%

Minimum

− 5.6%

− 3.4%

− 3.4%

Maximum

− 35.1%

− 10.4%

− 35.1%

# Table 3-8. Distribution of Industry Impacts: 2005

Changes in Total Operating Profit:

Plants with Loss Plants with Gain All Plants

Number 59 44 103

Cement Capacity (million metric tons)

Total 55,145 39,070 94,214

Average per plant 935 888 915

Compliance Costs

Total (thousand) $299,102 $70,908 $370,010

Average ($/metric cemen t) $5.42 $1.81 $3.93

Capacity Utilization (percent)

Baseline 99.4% 97.9% 98.7%

With regulation 80.0% 99.5% 88.1%

Change in total operating profits (million)

− $383 $144

− $239

Change in Employees (thousand)

− 1.6 0.1

− 1.5



# Table 3-9. Cement Plants with Sign ificant Utilization Changes: 2005

Total

Number 15

Cement Capacity (thousand metric tons)

Total 8,969

Average per plant 598

Compliance Costs

Total (thousand) $70,369

Average ($/metric ton) $7.85

Capacity Utilization (%)

Baseline 98.4%

With regulation 54.8%

Change in Operating Profit (million)

− $135

Change in Employees (thousand)

− 0.6

# Table 3-10. Job Losses/Gains Associated with the Final Rule

Method 1,000 Jobs

Partial equilibrium model

− 1.5

(demand effect only)

Literature-based estimate (net effect [A + B + C below]) 0.3

(

− 0.6 to +1.3)

A. Literature-based estimate: Demand effect − 0.8

(

− 1.6 to +0.1)

B. Literature-based estimate: Cost effect 0.5

(+0.2 to +0.9)

C. Literature-based estimate: Factor shift effect 0.6

(+0 to +1.1)



# Table 4-1. Small Entity Analysis

Owner Entity

Type Annual

Sales ($10 6 

# ) Employees Plants Kilns Clinker

Capacity (10 3



# metric tons

per year) Cost-toSales

Ratio

Salt River

Materials Group a 

# Tribal

government $184 b 

# NA 1 1 1,477 0.6%

Monarch Cement

Company Business $154 600 1 2 787 2.8%

Continental

Cement

Company, LLC Business $93 c 

# <750 1 1 1,164 4.5%

Snyder Associate

Companies Business $29 350 1 2 286 7.4%

a 

# Enterprise is owned by Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community.

b 

# EPA estimate. Estimate uses revenue data for four of the six enterprises owned by Salt River Pima-Maricopa

Indian Community.

c 

# EPA estimate. Estimate uses cement pro duction levels and average market prices.IncurredCapitalCosts1,203,724wetACINone25,113,5983,081,533000568,67628,195,131GA201822324PreheaterACINoneACINone021051500004247202105150KilnsControlsNecessaryforComplianceUnit*CPro200linkerduction8 (t/yr)KilnTypeHgHClOrg HAPPMWet scrubberTCIACI TCIRTO/scrubberTCILimeinjection TCI PM TCIAll CEMSFirst Costs blankTotal TCI w/omonitor costs($) blankAL101964,522PreheaterACINoneACINone02,469,177000 424,7202,469,177AL2011,656,774PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone30,419,4074,241,341000 568,67634,660,748AL3011,547,645PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone29,200,8583,961,971000 568,67633,162,830AL401789,255PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone19,494,9972,020,493000 568,67621,515,489AL501990,978PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone22,347,6142,536,903000 568,67624,884,518ARNEW1700,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone18,140,5991,792,000000 568,67619,932,599AZ101132,300DryACINoneACINone0338,688000 568,676338,688AZ102132,300DryACINoneACINone0338,688000 424,720338,688AZ103132,300DryACINoneACINone0338,688000 568,676338,688AZ1041,068,140PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,375,9692,734,438000 568,67626,110,406AZ2041,176,166PrecalcinerACINoneACINone03,010,985000 424,7203,010,985CA1011,176,166DryACIwetscrubberACINone24,767,0343,010,985000 568,67627,778,020CA1021,176,166DryACIwetscrubberACINone24,767,0343,010,985000 568,67627,778,020CA11082,004,002PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone34,098,2185,130,245000 568,67639,228,463CA2011,515,678PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone28,837,4583,880,136000 568,67632,717,594CA3011,203,724PrecalcinPrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone25,113,5983,081,533000 568,67628,195,131CA3021,916,919PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone33,201,3014,907,314000 568,67638,108,615CA4011,601,658PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone29,808,1294,100,245000 568,67633,908,375CA501652,568PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone17,392,7551,670,575000 568,67619,063,330CA6011,056,014PrecalcinerACIandWSwetscrubberACINone23,216,3882,703,396000 568,67625,919,785CA7011,700,866PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone30,902,5924,354,218000 568,67635,256,810CA8011,138,688PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone24,290,4492,915,040000 568,67627,205,489CA901928,146PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone21,486,3482,376,054000 568,67623,862,402CO101522,496PrecalcinerACINoneACINone01,337,589000 424,7201,337,589CO2011,699,764PrecalcinerwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 25,367,8650 973,636 568,67626,341,501CONEW11,000,000PrecalcinerACINoneACINone02,560,000000 568,6762,560,000FL101693,354PreheaterACINoneACINone01,774,986000 424,7201,774,986FL102687,842PreheaterACINoneACINone01,760,876000 424,7201,760,876FL201789,255PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone19,494,9972,020,493000 568,67621,515,489FL301666,898PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone17,620,9201,707,260000 568,67619,328,180FL302896,179PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone21,039,2222,294,218000 568,67623,333,441FL4011,092,391PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,692,9722,796,520000 568,67626,489,492FL501881,849PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone20,836,7192,257,534000 568,67623,094,253FL6011,897,078PrecalcinerACINoneACINone04,856,519000 424,7204,856,519FLNEW11,100,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,791,8612,816,000000 568,67626,607,861FLNEW2750,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone18,907,3021,920,000000 568,67620,827,302GA201822324,PreheaterACINoneACINone021051500004247202105150, ,,, ,IA101601,862DryACIwetscrubberACINone16,568,7961,540,767000 568,67618,109,562IA102385,809DryACIwetscrubberACINone12,688,672987,671000 568,67613,676,343IA2011,074,754PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,462,7072,751,369000 568,67626,214,076IA301*805,790PrecalcinerwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubberNone00 32,897,83700 568,67632,897,8372,300,524NoneACINone05,889,341000568,6765,889,341NM101238099PreheaterACINoneACINone0609534000424720609534ID101126,766WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags6,507,199324,52000 416,244 568,6767,247,963ID102159,835WetACIwetscrubberACINone7,478,184409,178000 568,6767,887,362IL101625,011DryACIwetscrubberACImembranebags16,948,2631,600,02700 1,084,125 568,67619,632,415IL201175,267PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone7,903,394448,685000 568,6768,352,079IL202175,267PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone7,903,394448,685000 568,6768,352,079IL203175,267PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone7,903,394448,685000 568,6768,352,079IL204175,267DryACIwetscrubberACINone7,903,394448,685000 568,6768,352,079IL302984,364PrecalcinerACINoneACINone02,519,972000 424,7202,519,972IL401469,585DryACIwetscrubberACImembranebags14,276,4791,202,13700 913,220 568,67616,391,836IL402648,159DryACIwetscrubberACINone17,322,1481,659,287000 568,67618,981,435IN301328,489DryACIwetscrubberACImembranebags11,521,396840,93100 736,986 568,67613,099,314IN302684,535DryACIwetscrubberACImembranebags17,899,0641,752,41000 1,144,945 568,67620,796,419IN401276,680PreheaterACIwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags0708,301 17,322,9220 664,866 568,67618,696,089IN402276,680PreheaterACIwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags0708,301 17,322,9220 664,866 568,67618,696,089IN403302,033PreheaterACIwetscrubberACImembranebags10,955,336773,20500 700,777 568,67612,429,318KS401432,106PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone13,581,4771,106,191000 568,67614,687,668KS402339,512PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone11,751,838869,150000 568,67612,620,988KY1011,550,952PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone29,238,2793,970,437000 568,67633,208,717MD101169,756WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags7,753,321434,57500 495,955 568,6768,683,851MD102169,756WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags7,753,321434,57500 495,955 568,6768,683,851MD2012,300,524PrecalcinPrecalcinererACINoneACINone05,889,341000 568,6765,889,341MD301564,383DryACIwetscrubberACINone15,941,7991,444,821000 568,67617,386,621ME101713,195PrecalcinerACINoneACINone01,825,780000 424,7201,825,780MI1011,360,252PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone27,024,9223,482,246000 568,67630,507,168MI201461,868WetwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 23,558,3750 904,187 568,67624,462,561MI202453,050WetwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 23,287,4540 893,788 568,67624,181,242MI301368,172DryACIwetscrubberACINone12,337,388942,520000 568,67613,279,909MI302368,172DryACIwetscrubberACINone12,337,388942,520000 568,67613,279,909MI303370,377DryACIwetscrubberACINone12,381,661948,164000 568,67613,329,825MI304641,545DryACIwetscrubberACINone17,215,8771,642,356000 568,67618,858,232MI305658,080DryACIwetscrubberACINone17,480,7461,684,684000 568,67619,165,430MO201670,205DryACIwetscrubberACINone17,673,2941,715,726000 568,67619,389,019MO202670,205DryACIwetscrubberACINone17,673,2941,715,726000 568,67619,389,019MO3021,056,014PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,216,3882,703,396000 568,67625,919,785MO5011,018,536PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone22,718,4422,607,451000 568,67625,325,893MONEW14,400,000PrecalcinerACIlimeinjection ACINone011,264,0000 426,1130 568,67611,690,113MONEW21,000,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone22,469,4682,560,000000 568,67625,029,468MT101329,591WetACINoneACImembranebags0843,75300 738,469 424,7201,582,222MT201308,647WetACINoneACImembranebags0790,13700 709,945 424,7201,500,081NE101351,637PreheaterACIwetscrubberACImembranebags12,001,893900,19200 767,722 568,67613,669,807NE102607,374PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACImembranebags16,659,6671,554,87600 1,065,665 568,67619,280,208NM101238099,PreheaterACINoneACINone0609534000424720609534,,,NM102238,099PreheaterACINoneACINone0609,534000 424,720609,534NV101249,122DryACINoneACINone0637,753000 424,720637,753NV102249,122PreheaterACINoneACINone0637,753000 424,720637,753NVNEW1500,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone14,824,3211,280,000000 568,67616,104,321261,248WetwetACI10,042,096668,79400642,360568,67611,353,250TX202320773WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags113582438211780072655056867612905970NY101645,954PreheaterACINoneACINone01,653,643000 424,7201,653,643NY201933,658WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags21,562,8122,390,16400 1,379,303 568,67625,332,279NY202932,555WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags21,547,5342,387,34200 1,378,326 568,67625,313,201NY301630,522WetACINoneACINone01,614,136000 424,7201,614,136OH101728,628PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone18,582,1611,865,287000 568,67620,447,449OK101209,439DrywetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 14,657,8100 562,577 568,67615,220,386OK102209,439DrywetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 14,657,8100 562,577 568,67615,220,386OK103308,647DrywetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 18,497,4440 709,945 568,67619,207,389OK201277,782WetACIlimeinjection ACImembranebags0711,1230 81,222 666,454 568,6761,458,799OK202288,806WetACIlimeinjection ACImembranebags0739,3420 83,141 682,198 568,6761,504,681OK301340,614DryACIwetscrubberACINone11,774,716871,972000 568,67612,646,688OK302319,670DryACIwetscrubberACINone11,334,808818,356000 568,67612,153,163OR101985,466PrecalcinerACIandWSwetscrubberACINone22,272,9562,522,794000 424,72024,795,750PA101145,505WetACIwetscrubberACINone7,068,377372,493000 568,6767,440,870PA102145,505WetACIwetscrubberACINone7,068,377372,493000 568,6767,440,870PA201262,350PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone10,067,497671,616000 568,67610,739,114PA202580,918PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone16,220,4061,487,150000 568,67617,707,556PA301274,476DryACIwetscrubberACINone10,344,154702,657000 568,67611,046,811PA302261,248DryACIwetscrubberACINone10,042,096668,794000 568,67610,710,890PA303264,555DryACIwetscrubberACINone10,118,173677,260000 568,67610,795,433PA401261,248WetACIwetscrubberACImembrmembraneanebags10,042,096668,79400 642,360 568,67611,353,250PA402405,651WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags13,076,2751,038,46500 836,447 568,67614,951,187PA5011,410,958PreheaterACIwetscrubberACImembranebags27,624,9393,612,05400 1,767,077 568,67633,004,071PA701461,868PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone14,135,2591,182,383000 568,67615,317,642PA702311,954PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone11,169,847798,602000 568,67611,968,449PA801587,532PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone16,330,9591,504,082000 568,67617,835,040PA802587,532PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone16,330,9591,504,082000 568,67617,835,040PA901123,458WetACIwetscrubberACINone6,404,782316,052000 568,6766,720,834PR101652,568PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone17,392,7501,670,574000 568,67619,063,324PR201970,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone22,062,5572,483,200000 568,67624,545,757SC2011,078,060PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,505,9962,759,835000 568,67626,265,831SD101154,324WetACINoneACINone0395,068000 424,720395,068SD102154,324WetACINoneACINone0395,068000 424,720395,068SD103660,284PrecalcinerACINoneACINone01,690,328000 424,7201,690,328TN101899,486PrecalcinerACINoneACINone02,302,684000 424,7202,302,684TN201756,186PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone19,000,7101,935,835000 568,67620,936,545TX1001859,803PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACImembranebags20,522,5872,201,09500 1,312,763 568,67624,036,446TX101977,750PrecalcinerACIlimeinjection ACINone02,503,0400 172,8180 568,6762,675,859TX12011,264,351PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone25,865,0553,236,739000 568,67629,101,794TX1301111,333WetACIwetscrubberACINone6,019,593285,012000 568,6766,304,606TX201320,773WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags11,358,243821,17800 726,550 568,67612,905,970TX202320773,WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags11358243, ,8211780072655056867612905970,,,, ,TX203320,773WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags11,358,243821,17800 726,550 568,67612,905,970TX301159,835PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone7,478,184409,178000 568,6767,887,362TX302159,835PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone7,478,184409,178000 568,6767,887,362TX303180,779PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone8,051,590462,794000 568,6768,514,385wetACINone24,767,0341,689,600000568,67626,456,634TX402608,476PrecalcinerACINoneACINone01,557,698000 568,6761,557,698TX5011,074,754PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone23,462,7072,751,369000 568,67626,214,076TX5021,237,896PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone25,538,9603,169,013000 568,67628,707,973TX601241,406DryACINoneACINone0618,000000 424,720618,000TX602272,271PreheaterACINoneACINone0697,013000 424,720697,013TX701*1,087,981PrecalcinerwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 39,391,9250 1,511,889 568,67640,903,814TX702*1,133,176PrecalcinerwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 40,365,7270 1,549,264 568,67641,914,992TX905*2,164,939PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone35,715,7895,542,245000 568,67641,258,033UT101918,225PrecalcinerACINoneACINone02,350,657000 424,7202,350,657UT201784,846PrecalcinerwetscrubberwetscrubberRTOandscrubbermembranebags00 32,382,0930 1,242,847 568,67633,624,939VA1011,247,816PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone25,661,5693,194,410000 568,67628,855,979WA101744,060PrecalcinerACINoneACINone01,904,794000 424,7201,904,794WA201419,981WetACINoneACImembranebags01,075,15000 854,053 424,7201,929,203WV101229,281WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags9,285,672586,95900 593,974 568,67610,466,605WV102229,281WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags9,285,672586,95900 593,974 568,67610,466,605WV103346,126WetACIwetscrubberACImembranebags11,888,666886,08200 760,479 568,67613,535,228WVNEW1700,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone18,140,5991,792,000000 568,67619,932,599WY101189,598DryACIwetscrubberACINone8,284,998485,370000 568,6768,770,368WY102442,027PreheaterACIwetscrubberACINone12,553,8321,131,589000 568,67613,685,421ALNEW11,300,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone22,347,6143,328,000000 568,67625,675,614AZNEW1660,000PrecalcinPrecalcinererACIwetscrubberACINone24,767,0341,689,600000 568,67626,456,634AZNEW21,900,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone24,767,0344,864,000000 568,67629,631,034AZNEW31,100,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone24,767,0342,816,000000 568,67627,583,034GANEW1900,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone19,981,0662,304,000000 568,67622,285,066ILNEW11,826,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone17,322,1484,674,560000 568,67621,996,708INNEW11,224,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone10,955,3363,133,440000 568,67614,088,776NCNEW12,300,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone11,098,6505,888,000000 568,67616,986,650PANEW1379,000PrecalcinerACIwetscrubberACINone6,404,782970,240000 568,6767,375,0221,952,321,627285,502,703 299,710,183 763,294 33,157,505 87,526,0682,571,455,311*Shadedunitsareareasources.3,557,8941,095,389000198,1174,653,2830748315000154820748315IncurredAnnualizedCostsWetscrubberTACACI TACRTO/scrubber TACLimeinjectionTACPM TACAll CEMSAnnualCostsblankTotal TACw/o monitorcosts($)0877,715000154,820877,7154,328,3061,507,664000198,1175,835,9704,154,0091,408,357000198,1175,562,3662,751,092718,222000198,1173,469,3143,174,964901,790000198,1174,076,7542,492,445637,000000198,1173,129,4450120,393000154,820120,3930120,393000154,820120,3930120,393000154,820120,3933,268,230972,007000198,1174,240,23701,070,311000154,8201,070,3113,485,2981,070,311000198,1174,555,6093,485,2981,070,311000198,1174,555,6094,834,9771,823,642000198,1176,658,6194,086,9821,379,267000198,1175,466,2493,557,8941,095,389000198,1174,653,2834,707,4061,744,397000198,1176,451,8034,224,9491,457,509000198,1175,682,4582,462,003593,837000198,1173,055,8403,288,465960,973000198,1174,249,4384,380,5371,547,788000198,1175,928,3253,440,9851,036,206000198,1174,477,1913,042,855844,613000198,1173,887,4680475,471000154,820475,471005,048,9570207,100198,1175,256,0570910,000000198,117910,0000630,952000154,820630,9520625,936000154,820625,9362,756,320718,222000198,1173,474,5422,502,925606,877000198,1173,109,8022,974,937815,523000198,1173,790,4603,350,711994,075000198,1174,344,7872,946,267802,483000198,1173,748,74901,726,341000154,8201,726,3413,364,7161,001,000000198,1174,365,7162,673,129682,500000198,1173,355,6290748315,000154820,748315,2,128,421547,694000198,1172,676,1151,656,171351,086000198,1172,007,2573,286,955978,026000198,1174,264,981006,585,83200198,1176,585,83202,093,477000198,1172,093,4770216670000154820216670917,836115,35700132,190198,1171,165,3831,054,737145,450000198,1171,200,1872,255,350568,76000221,949198,1173,046,0591,077,896159,493000198,1171,237,3901,077,896159,493000198,1171,237,3901,077,896159,493000198,1171,237,3901,077,098159,493000198,1171,236,5920895,771000154,820895,7711,912,234427,32200198,980198,1172,538,5362,303,060589,825000198,1172,892,8851,511,425298,92500175,296198,1171,985,6452,287,329622,92700230,122198,1173,140,3780251,7793,207,2210165,603198,1173,624,6030251,7793,207,2210165,603198,1173,624,6031,524,599274,85000170,429198,1171,969,8791,905,162393,216000198,1172,298,3791,649,425308,956000198,1171,958,3804,152,9401,411,366000198,1175,564,3061,045,808154,47800142,903198,1171,343,1891,045,808154,47800142,903198,1171,343,18902,093,477000198,1172,093,4772,093,139513,589000198,1172,606,7280649,008000154,820649,0083,553,4751,237,829000198,1174,791,304004,199,8900197,766198,1174,397,656004,148,1680196,369198,1174,344,5371,669,412335,036000198,1172,004,4491,669,412335,036000198,1172,004,4491,675,231337,043000198,1172,012,2732,304,646583,806000198,1172,888,4522,338,805598,853000198,1172,937,6582,469,054609,887000198,1173,078,9412,469,054609,887000198,1173,078,9413,207,585960,973000198,1174,168,5583,139,756926,867000198,1174,066,62304,004,00003,009,9950198,1177,013,9953,105,827910,000000198,1174,015,8270299,92800175,495154,820475,4230280,86900171,662154,820452,5301,616,988319,99000179,426198,1172,116,4042,334,896552,71000219,468198,1173,107,0740216670,000154820,216670,0216,670000154,820216,6700226,701000154,820226,7010226,701000154,820226,7012,094,479455,000000198,1172,549,4791,339,224237,73500162,579198,1171,739,53815072002919030017389319811719729970587,819000154,820587,8192,603,396849,62800261,619198,1173,714,6432,601,759848,62500261,487198,1173,711,8720573,775000154,820573,7752,488,647663,051000198,1173,151,699002,479,4040151,856198,1172,631,260002,479,4040151,856198,1172,631,260003,157,9440171,662198,1173,329,6060252,7820788,633165,817198,1171,207,2320262,8130817,404167,933198,1171,248,1491,319,830309,959000198,1171,629,7891,278,770290,900000198,1171,569,6703,162,679896,774000154,8204,059,453954,101132,410000198,1171,086,511954,101132,410000198,1171,086,5111,402,125238,739000198,1171,640,8632,276,016528,635000198,1172,804,6521,364,119249,773000198,1171,613,8921,326,104237,735000198,1171,563,8391,335,687240,745000198,1171,576,4321,339,224237,73500162,579198,1171,739,5381,724,326369,14200188,663198,1172,282,1303,798,2451,283,97200313,733198,1175,395,9501,962,001420,300000198,1172,382,3021,554,167283,878000198,1171,838,0452,262,934534,654000198,1172,797,5882,262,934534,654000198,1172,797,588867,031112,347000198,117979,3782,470,377593,837000198,1173,064,2143,119,831882,700000198,1174,002,5313,301,916981,035000198,1174,282,9510140,434000154,820140,4340140,434000154,820140,4340600,859000154,820600,8590818,532000154,820818,5322,670,698688,129000198,1173,358,8262,876,876782,42100252,676198,1173,911,9730889,7530423,2890198,1171,313,0413,621,7131,150,559000198,1174,772,272816,290101,313000198,117917,6031,507,200291,90300173,893198,1171,972,9971507200, ,291903,00173893,198117,1972997, ,1,507,200291,90300173,893198,1171,972,9971,043,997145,450000198,1171,189,4471,043,997145,450000198,1171,189,4471,123,430164,509000198,1171,287,9393,427,432600,600000198,1174,028,0320553,713000198,117553,7133,286,955978,026000198,1174,264,9813,576,2891,126,485000198,1174,702,7740219,680000154,820219,6800247,767000154,820247,767008,094,8880279,437198,1178,374,326008,326,1280284,460198,1178,610,5884,991,5971,970,095000198,1176,961,6920835,585000154,820835,585006,501,6520243,280198,1176,744,9323,603,7011,135,513000198,1174,739,2140677,095000154,820677,0950382,18200191,029154,820573,2111,245,096208,64500156,076198,1171,609,8171,245,096208,64500156,076198,1171,609,8171,579,141314,97400178,453198,1172,072,5692,486,649637,000000198,1173,123,6491,165,578172,534000198,1171,338,1121,769,873402,244000198,1172,172,1183,208,1691,183,000000198,1174,391,1693,427,432600,600000198,1174,028,0323,496,2221,729,000000198,1175,225,2223,457,0631,001,000000198,1174,458,0632,748,162819,000000198,1173,567,1622,146,3411,661,660000198,1173,808,0011,556,0591,113,840000198,1172,669,8991,731,9232,093,000000198,1173,824,923832,161344,890000198,1171,177,05130,597,920440,744,891NEI228772,004,002.1109621886ACI681211289wet11000001220611096ACIandWS12020ACI161206620wetscrubberUnitNEI IDClinkerProduction2008 (t/yr)Kiln TypeBaseHg(lbline/yr)*Baseline Hg(lb/MM tonclinker)Hg CoHntrol (OrAP)gHEmisReduafterHACon(lbgsionctionOrgPtrol/yr)AnnualbaselineOrg HAPemissions(tpy) Org HAP ControlOrg HAPEmissionReductionwithControls(tpy)HClBaselineemissionfactor(ppmvd@7% O2)Baseline HClEmissions(tpy)HCl Control(Org HAP)AL101NEIAL321964,522Preheater107.02110.96ACI96 41 ACI33 0.00 5.00 NoneAL201NEIAL80261,656,774Precalciner186.69112.68ACI and WS183 80 ACI64 12.06 93.33 wet scrubberAL301NEIAL11700041,547,645Precalciner316.80204.70ACI and WS310 66 ACI53 12.06 87.18 wet scrubberAL401NEIALT$4449789,255Preheater31.6640.11ACI and WS31 34 ACI27 15.12 55.73 wet scrubberAL501NEIAL1150002990,978Precalciner109.96110.96ACI and WS108 42 ACI34 7.61 35.22 wet scrubberARNEW1700,000Precalciner77.67110.96ACI and WS76 20 ACI16 12.06 39.4 wet scrubberAZ101NEI18621132,300Dry14.72111.28ACI136 ACI5 12.06 5.00 NoneAZ102NEI18621132,300Dry14.72111.28ACI136 ACI5 12.06 5.00 NoneAZ103NEI18621132,300Dry14.72111.28ACI136 ACI5 12.06 5.00 NoneAZ104NEI186211,068,140Precalciner120.94113.22ACI and WS119 46 ACI36 12.06 60.17 wet scrubberAZ204NEIAZ02504211,176,166Precalciner130.51110.96ACI117 50 ACI40 0.00 5.00 NoneCA101NEI227431,176,166Dry427.17363.19ACI and WS419 50 ACI40 12.06 66.25 wet scrubberCA102NEI227431,176,166Dry427.17363.19ACI and WS419 50 ACI40 12.06 66.25 wet scrubberCA1108NEI228772,004,002PrecalcinerPrecalciner222.37110.96anACIWSd218 86 ACI68 12.06 112.89 wet scrubbe.06.scrubberCA201NEI200461,515,678Precalciner104.0568.65ACI and WS102 65 ACI52 55.37 391.92 wet scrubberCA301NEI229001,203,724Precalciner133.57110.96ACI and WS131 51 ACI41 12.06 67.81 wet scrubberCA302NEI229001,916,919Precalciner212.70110.96ACI and WS208 82 ACI65 12.06 107.98 wet scrubberCA401NEI248591,601,658Precalciner177.72110.96ACI and WS174 68 ACI55 12.06 90.22 wet scrubberCA501NEI25375652,568Precalciner68.83105.47ACI and WS67 18 ACI14 14.87 45.32 wet scrubberCA601NEICA15051221,056,014Precalciner1,785.261,690.57ACI and WS1,750 45 ACI36 2.56 12.62 wet scrubberCA701NEI228381,700,866Precalciner188.73110.96ACI and WS185 73 ACI58 12.06 95.81 wet scrubberCA801NEI201301,138,688Precalciner126.35110.96ACI and WS124 49 ACI39 12.06 64.14 wet scrubberCA901NEI2CA151186928,146Precalciner102.99110.96ACI and WS101 40 ACI32 12.06 52.28 wet scrubberCO101NEI446522,496Precalciner114.75219.62ACI103 22 ACI18 0.00 5.00 NoneCO201NEI8861,699,764Precalciner24.6614.51wet scrubber20 153 RTO and scrubber150 1.10 8.73 wet scrubberCONEW11,000,000Precalciner110.96110.96ACI100 20 ACI16 12.06 56.3 NoneFL101NEIFLR053001693,354Preheater136.74197.22ACI123 30 ACI24 0.00 5.00 NoneFL102NEIFLR053001687,842Preheater147.45214.37ACI133 29 ACI23 0.00 5.00 NoneFL201NEIFLR001008789,255Precalciner87.58110.96ACI and WS86 34 ACI27 12.06 44.46 wet scrubberFL301NEI26327666,898Preheater74.00110.96ACI and WS73 28 ACI23 12.06 37.57 wet scrubberFL302NEI26327896,179Precalciner99.44110.96ACI and WS97 38 ACI31 12.06 50.48 wet scrubberFL401NEI262771,092,391Precalciner121.21110.96ACI and WS119 47 ACI37 12.06 61.53 wet scrubberFL501NEIFL12100465881,849Precalciner97.85110.96ACI and WS96 10 ACI8 12.06 49.68 wet scrubberFL601NEIFL08600201,897,078Precalciner210.50110.96ACI189 49 ACI39 0.00 5.00 NoneFLNEW11100000, ,Precalciner12206.11096.ACIandWS12020ACI161206620wetscrubber..FLNEW2750,000Precalciner83.22110.96ACI and WS82 20 ACI16 12.06 42.2 wet scrubberGA201NEIGA1530003822,324Preheater91.25110.96ACI82 35 ACI28 0.00 5.00 NoneIA101NEIIA0330060601,862Dry112.34186.65ACI and WS110 13 ACI10 12.06 33.90 wet scrubberIA102NEIIA0330060385,809Dry77.98202.11ACI and WS765 ACI4 12.06 21.73 wet scrubberNEI33444Wet4.7327.8657ACI612.069.56wet3516371440ACIandWS1415ACI1224704056wetscrubberIA201NEI122381,074,754Precalciner130.72121.63ACI and WS128 46 ACI37 12.06 60.54 wet scrubberIA301*NEIIA0330035805,790Precalciner85.90106.60wet scrubber69 81 RTO and scrubber80 12.06 45.39 wet scrubberID101NEIID0050004126,766Wet3.1124.53ACI and WS35 ACI4 12.06 7.14 wet scrubberID102NEIID0050004159,835Wet3.5622.27ACI and WS37 ACI5 12.06 9.00 wet scrubberIL101NEI51435625,011Dry50.7281.15ACI and WS503 ACI2 12.06 35.21 wet scrubberIL201NEI51527175,267Preheater19.45110.96ACI and WS197 ACI6 12.06 9.87 wet scrubberIL202NEI51527175,267Preheater19.45110.96ACI and WS197 ACI6 12.06 9.87 wet scrubberIL203NEI51527175,267Preheater19.45110.96ACI and WS197 ACI6 12.06 9.87 wet scrubberIL204NEI51527175,267Dry19.45110.96ACI and WS197 ACI6 12.06 9.87 wet scrubberIL302NEI51352984,364Precalciner109.23110.96ACI98 42 ACI34 8.61 5.00 NoneIL401NEI52351469,585Dry5.5111.73ACI and WS5 20 ACI16 12.06 26.45 wet scrubberIL402NEI52351648,159Dry63.5498.04ACI and WS62 28 ACI22 12.06 36.51 wet scrubberIN301NEI31319328,489Dry30.6893.39ACI and WS30 14 ACI11 12.06 18.50 wet scrubberIN302NEI31319684,535Dry63.9493.40ACI and WS63 29 ACI23 12.06 38.56 wet scrubberIN401NEI32033276,680Preheater29.01104.85ACI and WS28 27 RTO and scrubber27 12.06 15.59 wet scrubberIN402NEI32033276,680Preheater31.20112.76ACI and WS31 27 RTO and scrubber27 12.06 15.59 wet scrubberIN403NEI32033302,033Preheater35.98119.11ACI and WS35 13 ACI10 12.06 17.01 wet scrubberKS401NEI12739432,106Precalciner47.95110.96ACI and WS47 18 ACI15 12.06 24.34 wet scrubberKS402NEI12739339,512Precalciner37.67110.96ACI and WS37 14 ACI12 12.06 19.12 wet scrubberKY101NEIKYR00601,550,952Precalciner172.10110.96ACI and WS169 66 ACI53 12.06 87.37 wet scrubberMD101NEI33444169,756169,756Wet4.7327.86ACI anWSd57 ACI6 12.06 9.56 wet scrubbescrubberMD102NEI33444169,756Wet5.4632.17ACI and WS57 ACI6 12.06 9.56 wet scrubberMD201NEI333942,300,524Precalciner420.19182.65None0 20 ACI16 12.06 129.59 NoneMD301NEI33699564,383Dry62.62110.96ACI and WS61 24 ACI19 12.06 31.79 wet scrubberME101NEIME0130002713,195Precalciner79.14110.96ACI71 30 ACI24 0.00 5.00 NoneMI101NEIMIB15591,360,252Precalciner150.94110.96ACI and WS148 58 ACI46 12.06 76.62 wet scrubberMI201NEIMIB1743461,868Wet78.77170.55wet scrubber63 694 RTO and scrubber680 12.06 26.02 wet scrubberMI202NEIMIB1743453,050Wet78.20172.62wet scrubber63 681 RTO and scrubber667 12.06 25.52 wet scrubberMI301NEI12018368,172Dry31.6585.96ACI and WS31 16 ACI13 30.78 52.92 wet scrubberMI302NEI12018368,172Dry32.7688.99ACI and WS32 16 ACI13 30.78 52.92 wet scrubberMI303NEI12018370,377Dry33.7591.14ACI and WS33 16 ACI13 30.78 53.24 wet scrubberMI304NEI12018641,545Dry67.54105.28ACI and WS66 27 ACI22 30.78 92.22 wet scrubberMI305NEI12018658,080Dry69.12105.03ACI and WS68 28 ACI22 30.78 94.59 wet scrubberMO201NEIMO0990002670,205Dry74.37110.96ACI and WS73 29 ACI23 12.06 37.75 wet scrubberMO202NEIMO0990002670,205Dry74.37110.96ACI and WS73 29 ACI23 12.06 37.75 wet scrubberMO302NEI345201,056,014Precalciner117.18110.96ACI and WS115 45 ACI36 12.06 59.49 wet scrubberMO501NEI343261,018,536Precalciner59.2558.17ACI and WS58 43 ACI35 12.06 57.37 wet scrubberMONEW14,400,000Precalciner488.23110.96ACI439 20 ACI16 1.55 31.8 lime injectionMONEW21,000,000Precalciner110.96110.96ACI and WS109 20 ACI16 12.06 56.3 wet scrubberMT101NEIMT0430001329,591Wet8.2925.14None0 0.27 ACI0 0.00 5.00 NoneMT201NEIMT0310005308,647Wet34.39111.43ACI314 ACI3 0.00 5.00 NoneNE101NEI572351,637Preheater14.3740.88ACIandWS1415ACI1224704056wetscrubber..NE102NEI572607,374Precalciner34.8557.38ACI and WS34 26 ACI21 24.70 70.06 wet scrubberNM101NEINMT$12442238,099Preheater26.42110.96ACI24 10 ACI8 0.00 5.00 NoneNM102NEINMT$12442238,099Preheater26.42110.96ACI24 10 ACI8 0.00 5.00 NoneNV101NEI2NV410803249,122Dry27.64110.96ACI25 11 ACI9 0.00 5.00 NoneNEI4674453.77205.825311ACI912.0614.72wet111333Wet1211096ACIandWS125ACI41206wetscrubberNV102NEI2NV410803249,122Preheater27.64110.96ACI25 11 ACI9 0.00 5.00 NoneNVNEW1500,000Precalciner55.48110.96ACI and WS54 20 ACI16 12.06 28.2 wet scrubberNY101NEINYT$1163645,954Preheater87.92136.11ACI79 28 ACI22 0.00 5.00 NoneNY201NEI34931933,658Wet72.7177.87ACI and WS71 47 ACI38 26.23 114.37 wet scrubberNY202NEI34931932,555Wet69.3274.33ACI and WS68 47 ACI38 12.06 52.53 wet scrubberNY301NEINY4192600630,522Wet69.96110.96ACI63 27 ACI22 9.11 5.00 NoneOH101NEIOHT$6526728,628Preheater107.17147.08ACI and WS105 31 ACI25 12.06 41.04 wet scrubberOK101NEI12976209,439Dry29.83142.41wet scrubber24 73 RTO and scrubber71 17.03 16.66 wet scrubberOK102NEI12976209,439Dry26.21125.15wet scrubber21 63 RTO and scrubber61 17.03 16.66 wet scrubberOK103NEI12976308,647Dry34.21110.84wet scrubber27 77 RTO and scrubber76 15.07 21.72 wet scrubberOK201NEIOK1826277,782Wet22.8282.16ACI21 12 ACI9 1.42 1.84 lime injectionOK202NEIOK1826288,806Wet42.18146.04ACI38 12 ACI10 1.42 1.92 lime injectionOK301NEIOK4013107340,614Dry10.9332.09ACI and WS11 15 ACI12 12.06 19.19 wet scrubberOK302NEIOK4013107319,670Dry10.4432.66ACI and WS10 14 ACI11 12.06 18.01 wet scrubberOR101NEI40539985,466Precalciner3,219.893,267.38ACI and WS3,155 61 ACI49 0.00 5.00 wet scrubberPA101NEIPA01993-1145,505Wet16.15110.96ACI and WS166 ACI5 12.06 8.20 wet scrubberPA102NEIPA01993-1145,505Wet16.15110.96ACI and WS166 ACI5 12.06 8.20 wet scrubberPA201NEIPA94-2626262,350Preheater29.11110.96ACI and WS29 11 ACI9 12.06 14.78 wet scrubberPA202NEIPA94-2626580,918Precalciner64.46110.96ACI and WS63 25 ACI20 12.06 32.72 wet scrubberPA301NEI46744274,476Dry53.86196.24ACI and WS53 12 ACI9 12.06 15.46 wet scrubberPA302NEI46744261,248261,248Dry53.77205.82anACIWSd53 11 ACI9 12.06 14.72 wet scrubbescrubberPA303NEI46744264,555Dry54.61206.42ACI and WS54 11 ACI9 12.06 14.90 wet scrubberPA401NEIPAT$1626261,248Wet47.51181.84ACI and WS47 11 ACI9 12.06 14.72 wet scrubberPA402NEIPAT$1626405,651Wet98.85243.67ACI and WS97 17 ACI14 12.06 22.85 wet scrubberPA501NEI72551,410,958Preheater168.70119.56ACI and WS165 60 ACI48 12.06 79.48 wet scrubberPA701NEIPA58-1290461,868Preheater36.0177.97ACI and WS358 ACI6 12.06 26.02 wet scrubberPA702NEIPA58-1290311,954Preheater23.9876.86ACI and WS237 ACI5 12.06 17.57 wet scrubberPA801NEI2PA110039587,532Preheater40.4868.90ACI and WS403 ACI2 12.06 33.10 wet scrubberPA802NEI2PA110039587,532Preheater40.4868.90ACI and WS402 ACI2 12.06 33.10 wet scrubberPA901NEIPA23-0797123,458Wet8.2666.95ACI and WS8 0.43 ACI0.34 12.06 6.95 wet scrubberPR101652,568Preheater72.41110.96ACI and WS71 28 ACI22 12.06 36.76 wet scrubberPR201970,000Precalciner107.63110.96ACI and WS105 41 ACI33 12.06 54.64 wet scrubberSC201NEISC03512441,078,060Precalciner207.33192.31ACI and WS203 46 ACI37 14.30 71.99 wet scrubberSD101NEISDT$8989154,324Wet17.12110.96ACI157 ACI5 0.00 5.00 NoneSD102NEISDT$8989154,324Wet17.12110.96ACI157 ACI5 0.00 5.00 NoneSD103NEISDT$8989660,284Precalciner73.27110.96ACI66 28 ACI23 0.00 5.00 NoneTN101NEITN0653070899,486Precalciner99.81110.96ACI90 38 ACI31 0.00 5.00 NoneTN201NEITN0930008756,186Precalciner230.60304.95ACI and WS226 32 ACI26 12.06 42.60 wet scrubberTX1001NEI13290859,803Precalciner62.6972.91ACI and WS61 37 ACI29 12.06 48.43 wet scrubberTX101NEITXRBG0259977,750Precalciner108.49110.96ACI98 42 ACI33 0.46 2.10 lime injectionTX1201NEITXT$119241,264,351Precalciner140.29110.96ACI and WS137 54 ACI43 12.06 71.22 wet scrubberTX1301NEITX309123F111,333Wet12.35110.96ACIandWS125ACI412066 2wetscrubber..7TX201NEI7376320,773Wet33.63104.86ACI and WS33 14 ACI11 12.06 18.07 wet scrubberTX202NEI7376320,773Wet31.8499.25ACI and WS31 14 ACI11 12.06 18.07 wet scrubberTX203NEI7376320,773Wet32.22100.43ACI and WS329 ACI7 12.06 18.07 wet scrubberTX301NEITXT$11980159,835Preheater16.65104.15ACI and WS167 ACI5 12.06 9.00 wet scrubber42.05110.964119ACI1512.0624.90wetTX302NEITXT$11980159,835Preheater11.4871.81ACI and WS117 ACI5 12.06 9.00 wet scrubberTX303NEITXT$11980180,779Preheater18.53102.50ACI and WS18 11 ACI9 12.06 10.18 wet scrubberTX402NEITXT$11872608,476Precalciner67.52110.96ACI61 26 ACI21 0.34 0.97 NoneTX501NEIT$FNP14081,074,754Precalciner119.26110.96ACI and WS117 46 ACI37 12.06 60.54 wet scrubberTX502NEIT$FNP14081,237,896Precalciner137.36110.96ACI and WS135 53 ACI42 12.06 69.73 wet scrubberTX601NEITXT$12011241,406Dry26.79110.96ACI24 10 ACI8 0.00 5.00 NoneTX602NEITXT$12011272,271Preheater30.21110.96ACI27 12 ACI9 0.00 5.00 NoneTX701*NEITX139099J1,087,981Precalciner19.5717.99wet scrubber16 112 RTO and scrubber110 12.06 61.29 wet scrubberTX702*NEITX139099J1,133,176Precalciner41.4236.55wet scrubber33 142 RTO and scrubber139 44.00 232.84 wet scrubberTX905*NEI132582,164,939Precalciner300.09138.61ACI and WS294 25 ACI20 12.06 121.95 wet scrubberUT101NEIUT10303918,225Precalciner197.08214.63ACI177 26 ACI21 0.00 5.00 NoneUT201NEI42038784,846Precalciner116.98149.05wet scrubber94 82 RTO and scrubber80 5.15 18.88 wet scrubberVA101NEIVA25531,247,816Precalciner138.46110.96ACI and WS136 32 ACI26 12.06 70.29 wet scrubberWA101 NEIWA+B70331133744,060Precalciner57.9277.84ACI52 21 ACI17 0.00 5.00 NoneWA201NEIWA0331404419,981Wet65.40155.73ACI59 18 ACI14 0.00 5.00 NoneWV101NEIWV0030006229,281Wet17.2975.42ACI and WS17 10 ACI8 12.06 12.92 wet scrubberWV102NEIWV0030006229,281Wet19.9887.15ACI and WS20 10 ACI8 12.06 12.92 wet scrubberWV103NEIWV0030006346,126Wet16.8248.61ACI and WS16 15 ACI12 12.06 19.50 wet scrubberWVNEW1700,000Precalciner77.67110.96ACI and WS76 20 ACI16 12.06 39.4 wet scrubberWY101NEI338189,598Dry21.04110.96ACI and WS218 ACI6 12.06 10.68 wet scrubberWY102379,000379,000PrecalcinerPrecalciner42.05110.96anACIWSd41 19 ACI15 12.06 24.90 wet scrubbescrubberALNEW1NEIAL1150002990,978Precalciner109.96110.96ACI and WS108 20 ACI16 12.06 73.2 wet scrubberAZNEW1NEIAZ02504211,176,166Precalciner130.51110.96ACI and WS128 20 ACI16 12.06 37.2 wet scrubberAZNEW2NEIAZ02504211,176,166Precalciner130.51110.96ACI and WS128 20 ACI16 12.06 107.0 wet scrubberAZNEW3NEIAZ02504211,176,166Precalciner130.51110.96ACI and WS128 20 ACI16 12.06 62.0 wet scrubberGANEW1NEIGA1530003822,324Preheater91.25110.96ACI and WS89 20 ACI16 12.06 50.7 wet scrubberILNEW1NEI52351648,159Dry63.5498.04ACI and WS62 20 ACI16 12.06 102.9 wet scrubberINNEW1NEI32033302,033Preheater35.98119.11ACI and WS35 20 ACI16 12.06 68.9 wet scrubberNCNEW1NEIMT0310005308,647Wet34.39111.43ACI and WS34 20 ACI16 12.06 129.6 wet scrubberPANEW1NEIPA23-0797123,458Wet8.2666.95ACI and WS8 20 ACI16 12.06 21.3 wet scrubber18,184.9117,073 5,9955,1946,20694%87%112770131None03313146190None0248235HClEmissionReductionafter OrgHAPControl(ton/yr)PM 10BaselineEmissionrate (lb/tonclinker)Totalfilterable PM(tpy)PM Control withOrg HAP controlPM EmissionReductionwith Org HAPControl (tpy)BaselineSO2emissions(tpy)SO2reductionswith OrgHAP Control(tpy)0.000.0312.80None0294093.230.1191.03None0757187.090.0646.90None0706655.670.0934.64None024122935.180.20100.71None0454239.390.29100.71None01,0299780.000.000.07None056300.000.000.11None056300.000.8053.01None0563060.110.1789.73None06946600.000.018.07None0765066.190.000.08None047645366.190.000.07None0476453112.770.01.318None0331314391.530.0861.58None025023867.740.34202.92None0199189107.870.34323.14None031630090.130.34270.00None026425145.270.1446.53None010810212.610.013.04None017416695.710.0538.43None028126764.080.015.33None018817852.230.1046.00None01531450.000.51133.03None08408.720.1081.31membrane bags732722580.000.1681.31None016000.000.0412.94None0700.000.0518.82None07044.410.0312.05None017816937.530.1445.86None07650.430.1045.86None020219261.470.028.55None024623349.630.0312.26None01981880.000.015.75None042706190.0 0.15 7.5None024823542.210.025.75None01691600.000.26107.01None01,122033.870.1339.25None02,7172,58121.710.1019.19None01,7411,6549.550.3328.28membrane636604405259membranebags58103498260.480.1051.20None061858745.350.013.23None04634407.130.052.90membrane bags244428.990.010.70None0565335.171.05327.98membrane bags3251,8381,7469.866.51570.83None05064809.860.3429.55None05064809.860.3429.55None05064809.860.3429.55None05154900.000.1259.79None02,746026.430.025.36membrane bags31,3811,31236.470.0515.07None01,9061,81018.490.69113.65membrane bags1121,4831,40938.520.42142.94membrane bags1403,0902,93515.570.75104.06membrane bags10332130515.570.6995.19membrane bags9432130517.000.75113.29membrane bags11235133324.320.1226.68None027025719.110.3050.10None021220287.280.19151.18None01471409.550.3328.28membrane bags276366049.550.3327.82membrane bags276366040.000.34386.83None03,612031.760.2879.35None02,0631,9600.000.34120.23None0107076.550.19128.75None03,5573,37925.990.1534.84membrane bags334,1573,94925.500.3476.37membrane bags744,0773,87452.870.3360.58None097792952.870.2138.49None097792953.190.1425.39None098393492.120.0723.86None01,7031,61894.500.0620.89None01,7471,66037.720.91304.28None050648137.720.34112.98None050648159.430.34178.02None01,1511,09457.320.016.66None01,1101,05523.890.006.66None04,7963,35756.270.016.66None01,0901,0360.000.84137.69membrane bags13611500.000.4061.80membrane bags6010804052.0 3.459.28membranebags581034,98269.990.34102.39membrane bags993803610.000.089.56None0800.000.1214.83None0800.000.3442.00None0188014.700.1316.91None01,1791,12010815None04354130.000.3442.00None06028.140.3484.29None01231160.000.2891.56None0970114.250.75350.20membrane bags3465,5935,31352.480.0313.36membrane bags95,5865,3070.000.48150.23None03,777041.000.48176.64None01,8361,74416.640.1818.57membrane bags182,6022,47216.640.1516.15membrane bags152,6022,47221.700.1015.09membrane bags143,8353,6431.380.011.78membrane bags01,1968371.440.011.75membrane bags01,24387019.170.3560.39None04,2324,02117.990.3860.82None03,9723,7735.000.0630.58None064618.190.032.17None05695408.190.2216.14None056954014.760.79103.11None030528932.690.2572.32None033431715.450.1216.91None01,2391,17714.700.1316.91None01,1791,12014.890.1215.29None01,1941,13414.700.98127.96membrane bags1271,02197022.830.4591.39membrane bags891,5851,50679.400.18126.20membrane bags1191,6391,55725.990.011.73None053651017.550.010.98None036234433.060.2162.47None068264833.060.2162.71None06826486.950.105.88None048245836.720.025.88None07654.590.015.88None021820771.920.1898.00None05124860.000.6348.97None032700.001.91147.24None032700.000.013.68None010600.000.0210.15None0427042.551.73654.03None035934148.380.1876.33membrane bags724944701.580.0943.36None056239471.150.17108.15None07276916 2.71 9.4108.15None043541318.050.68108.95membrane bags1071,2531,19118.050.67108.11membrane bags1071,2531,19118.050.67106.79membrane bags1051,2531,1918.990.2519.59None018617624.870.3474.51None02542418.990.2318.44None018617610.170.2220.09None02101990.000.026.85None0350060.480.22116.79None061858769.660.19116.79None07126760.000.3440.69None01,09000.000.3445.90None0316061.230.22122.29membrane bags117626594232.610.1583.64membrane bags78652619121.830.0891.65None01,2451,1830.000.34154.79None060018.860.0415.51membrane bags12514870.220.29179.26None05935630.000.0831.14None019700.000.0714.96membrane bags13798012.900.055.82membrane bags585981612.901.11127.82membrane bags12785981619.480.024.25membrane bags31,2961,23139.390.014.25None01,0991,04410.670.3431.96None01019624.870.3474.51None025424173.160.34219.15None0595637.140.34111.26None0429408106.920.34320.29None01,2351,17361.900.34185.43None071567950.650.34151.72None01,2291,167102.760.34307.82None05,3685,10068.880.34206.33None01,4221,351129.430.34387.72None080576521.330.3463.8893916None01,4811,4075,85812,9452,957151,916124,01214,01994.41%23%82%)($)($)($)UnitNEIID(t/yr)Kiln Typeclinker)SO2 (ton)clinker (%)TCI ($)TCI ($)TAC ($)TAC ($)($)Cost ($)Cost ($)Cost ($)Costs ($)NewkilnssubjecttoNSPSAZNEW3Cal Portland Rillito, AZPosponedAZNEW2Cemex Seligman,AZ2012CEMSCostCapital ($) Annual ($)GANEW1Houston AmerPerry, GA2012SO2143,135 42,326INNEW1Lehigh Mitchell,IN2012NOx140,951 41,809NCNEW1TitanAmerica Castle Hayne, NC2012Flow meter 35,780 13,864ILNEW1Lafarge Gain Chain, IL2013ALNEW1National CemeRagland,AL2013Cost to meet 1.33 lb SO2/ton clinker*UnitNEI IDClinkeProducn 200tyr)( /rtio8Kiln)TypeBaselineSO2(lb/tonclinker)BaseSO2 (lineton)rmlbc( )Removaefficiencequiredeet 1.3SO2/tlinker (%)lyto3on)LInjeTCimectionI ($)WetScrubbTCI ($)er)LInjeTAimectionC ($)WetScrubberTAC ($)SO2 CEMSFirst Cost($)FlowCEMS FirstCost ($)SO2 CEMSAnnualCost ($)FlowCEMSAnnualCost ($)TotalAnnualCosts ($)($)($)($)ALNEW11,300,000Precalciner0.0958.50-13780000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW21,900,000Precalciner1.30 1,235.00-20000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW31,100,000Precalciner1.30715.00-20000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190GANEW1900,000Precalciner0.95427.50-400000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190ILNEW11,826,000Precalciner5.58 5,094.54760000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190INNEW11,224,000Precalciner1.15703.80-160000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190NCNEW12,300,000Precalciner1.15 1,322.50-160000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190393,330Cost to meet 0.4 lb SO2/ton clinker*UnitNEIIDClinkeProducn 200(t/yr)rtio8Kiln TypeBaselineSO2(lb/tonclinker)BaseSO2 (ton)linermclinker (%)Removaefficiencequiredeet 0.4SO2/tolytolbnLInjeTCI ($)imectionWetScrubbTCI ($)erLInjeTAC ($)imectionWetScrubberTAC ($)SO2 CEMSFirst Cost($)FlowCEMS FirstCost ($)SO2 CEMSAnnualCost ($)FlowCEMSAnnualCost ($)TotalAnnualCosts ($)ALNEW11,300,000Precalciner0.0958.50-3440000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW21,900,000Precalciner1.30 1,235.00690000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW31,100,000Precalciner1.30715.00690000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW31.71500850000,13535,78042,32613,86456,190GANEW1900,000Precalciner0.95427.50580000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190ILNEW11,826,000Precalciner5.58 5,094.54930000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190INNEW11,224,000Precalciner1.15703.80650000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190NCNEW12,300,000Precalciner1.15 1,322.50650000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190393,330Cost to meet 0.2 lb SO2/ton clinker*UnitNEI IDClinkeProducn 200(t/yr)rtio8KilnTypeBaselineSO2(lb/tonclinker)BaseSO2 (lineton)rmcRemovaefficiencequiredeet 0.2SO2/tolinker (%lytolbn)LInjeTCimectionI ($)WetScrubbTCI ($er)LInjeTAimectionC ($)WetScrubberTAC ($)SO2 CEMSFirst Cost($)FlowCEMS FirstCost ($)SO2 CEMSAnnualCost ($)FlowCEMSAnnualCost ($)TotalAnnualCosts ($)ALNEW11,300,000Precalciner0.0958.50-1220000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW21,900,000Precalciner1.30 1,235.00850000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190AZNEW31,100,1,100,000000Precalciner1.30715.00850000 1,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,19043GANEW1900,000Precalciner0.95427.50790000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190ILNEW11,826,000Precalciner5.58 5,094.54960000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190INNEW11,224,000Precalciner1.15703.80830000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190NCNEW12,300,000Precalciner1.15 1,322.50830000143,135 35,780 42,326 13,864 56,190393,330*Wet scrubbers are required for HCl control under the NESHAP; there are no additional control costs under the NSPS.)($)($)($)($)($/)UnitNEIID(t/yr)Kiln Typeclinker)NOX (ton)clinker (%)($)($)($)($)($)Cost ($)Cost ($)($)Cost ($)($/ton)NewkilnssubjecttoNSPSAZNEW3CalPortland Rillito, AZPosponedAZNEW2Cemex Seligman, AZ2012CEMSCostCapital ($) Annual ($)GANEW1Houston AmerPerry, GA2012SO2143,135 42,326INNEW1Lehigh Mitchell, IN2012NOx140,951 41,809NCNEW1Titan America Castle Hayne, NC2012Flow meter 35,780 13,864ILNEW1Lafarge Gain Chain, IL2013ALNEW1National CemeRagland, AL2013Cost to meet 1.95 lb NOX/ton clinkerUnitNEI IDClinkProdun 20ty( /erctio08r) Kyiln TypeBaseNO(lb/clinklineXtoner)BNaselineOX (ton)Remeffirequmeelb NOclinkovalciencyired tot 1.95X/toner (%)SNCR($)TCI SCR TCI($)SNCR($)TAC)SCR TAC($)NOX CEMSFirst Cost($)FlowCEMS FirstCost ($)NOX CEMSAnnualCost ($)FlowCEMSAnnual($)TotalAnnualCost ($)CE($/ton)($)($)($)ALNEW11,300,000Precalciner2.501,625.00222,288,0000 663,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 718,673AZNEW21,900,000Precalciner2.502,375.00223,344,0000 969,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,024,673AZNEW31,100,000Precalciner2.501,375.00221,936,0000 561,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 616,673GANEW1900,000Precalciner2.501,125.00221,584,0000 459,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 514,673ILNEW11,826,000Precalciner2.502,282.50223,213,7600 931,2600 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 986,933INNEW11,224,000Precalciner2.501,530.00222,154,2400 624,2400 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 679,913NCNEW12,300,000Precalciner2.502,875.00224,048,0000 1,173,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,228,67313,187.5018,568,0000 5,380,50005,770,211 438Cost to meet 1.5 lb NOX/ton clinkerUnitNEIIDClinkProdun 20(t/yr)erctio08Kiln TypeBaseNO(lb/clinker)lineXtonBNOX (ton)aselineRemeffirequmeeNOclinker (%)ovalciencyired tot 1.5 lbX/tonSNCR($)TCI SCR TCI($)SNCR($)TACSCR TAC($)NOX CEMSFirst Cost($)FlowCEMS FirstCost ($)NOX CEMSAnnualCost ($)FlowCEMSAnnual($)TotalAnnualCost ($)CE($/ton)ALNEW11,300,000Precalciner2.501,625.00402,288,0000 1,313,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,368,673AZNEW21,900,000Precalciner2.502,375.00403,344,0000 1,919,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,974,673AZNEW31,100,000Precalciner2.501,375.00401,936,0000 1,111,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,166,673rAZNEW3501,.8005,027,02,750,000140,95135,78041,80913,8642,805,673GANEW1900,000Precalciner2.501,125.00401,584,0000 909,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 964,673ILNEW11,826,000Precalciner2.502,282.50403,213,7600 1,844,2600 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,899,933INNEW11,224,000Precalciner2.501,530.00402,154,2400 1,236,2400 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 1,291,913NCNEW12,300,000Precalciner2.502,875.00404,048,0000 2,323,0000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 2,378,67313,187.5018,568,0000 10,655,5000 986,657 250,460 292,663 97,048 11,045,211 838Cost to meet 0.5 lb NOX/ton clinkerUnitNEI IDClinkProdun 20(t/yerctio08r) Kiln TypeBaseNO(lb/clinklineXtoner)BNaselineOX (ton)RemeffirequmeeNOclinkovalciencyired tot 0.5 lbX/toner (%)SNCR($)TCI SCR TCI($)SNCR($TAC)SCR TAC($)NOX CEMSFirst Cost($)FlowCEMS FirstCost ($)NOX CEMSAnnualCost ($)FlowCEMSAnnual($)TotalAnnualCost ($)CE($/ton)ALNEW11,300,000Precalciner2.501,625.008005,941,0000 3,250,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 3,305,673AZNEW21,900,000Precalciner2.502,375.008008,683,0000 4,750,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 4,805,673AZNEW31,1001,100,000,000Precalcinerecalcine2.501,375.008005,027,0000 2,750,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 2,805,673GANEW1900,000Precalciner2.501,125.008004,113,0000 2,250,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 2,305,673ILNEW11,826,000Precalciner2.502,282.508008,344,8200 4,565,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 4,620,673INNEW11,224,000Precalciner2.501,530.008005,593,6800 3,060,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 3,115,673NCNEW12,300,000Precalciner2.502,875.00800 10,511,0000 5,750,000 140,951 35,780 41,809 13,864 5,805,67313,187.5048,213,500026,375,000 986,657 250,460 292,663 97,048 26,764,711 2,030