From:       Keith Barnett/RTP/USEPA/US                                                       

To:      Cortney_Higgins@omb.eop.gov                                                      

Cc:          Charlotte Bertrand/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Amy Lamson/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Ron

Evans/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA, Walton.Tom@epamail.epa.gov, Steven         |

|Silverman/DC/USEPA/US@EPA, Torres.Elineth@epamail.epa.gov,

"Michael Laney" <mnl@rti.org>, Susan Fairchild/RTP/USEPA/US@EPA               

Date:  07/14/2010 02:59 PM                                                                   

Subject:   Cost spreadsheet                                                                  

Dear Courtney:

I got clearance from OPEI to send you the Portland Cement cost spreadsheets and

some of the economics tables.  This is what I plan to discuss on Friday.

(See attached file: Portlandcementtables.docx)(See attached file: costs for OMB‐

7‐1‐10.xls)

We already talked about emissions levels ‐ are there other items you want to talk

about?

Keith W. Barnett

USEPA/OAQPS/SPPD/MMG

Mail Code D243‐02

Research Triangle Park, NC  27711

919‐541‐5605

barnett.keith@epa.gov
Table 3-5. National-Level Market Impacts: 2005 

Changes from Baseline 

Baseline Absolute Percent 

Market Price ($/metric ton) $83.70 $4.40 5.3% 

Market Output (million metric tons) 126 −6 −4.7% 

Domestic production 93 −10 −10.8% 

Imports 33 3 10.0% 

Table 3-6. Regional Compliance Costs and Market Price Changes ($/metric ton of 

cement): 2005 

Incremental Compliance Costs 

($/metric ton of estimated 

cement production) Baseline 

Price

Market Price Change 

Market Mean Minimum Maximum Absolute Percent 

Atlanta $3.60 $1.10 $5.90 $81.30 $2.60 3.2% 

Baltimore/Philadelphia $6.20 $1.20 $10.00 $81.20 $5.70 7.0% 

Birmingham $3.60 $1.10 $4.80 $82.60 $3.70 4.5% 

Chicago $6.80 $0.90 $10.10 $65.90 $4.40 6.7% 

Cincinnati $8.10 $4.00 $14.10 $84.10 $10.00 11.9% 

Dallas $5.60 $3.50 $8.50 $74.70 $4.90 6.6% 

Denver $3.00 $1.00 $8.10 $88.70 $5.30 6.0% 

Detroit $6.50 $4.00 $10.30 $92.80 $6.30 6.8% 

Florida $3.40 $1.20 $5.50 $90.70 $3.30 3.6% 

Kansas City $8.60 $3.80 $13.80 $86.10 $7.80 9.1% 

Los Angeles $6.00 $3.20 $13.10 $77.30 $4.10 5.3% 

Minneapolis $6.30 $4.50 $8.80 $92.20 $8.20 8.9% 

New York/Boston $2.50 $1.00 $4.50 $89.00 $1.60 1.8% 

Phoenix $1.90 $1.00 $6.00 $82.10 $3.20 3.9% 

Pittsburgh $7.60 $6.90 $8.00 $88.00 $5.30 6.0% 

St. Louis $4.80 $3.80 $5.60 $83.70 $5.20 6.2% 

Salt Lake City $5.90 $1.60 $9.90 $91.40 $9.70 10.6% 

San Antonio $4.00 $0.80 $7.70 $82.30 $3.20 3.9% 
San Francisco $3.10 $1.00 $5.00 $96.90 $3.20 3.3% 

Seattle $1.20 $1.00 $1.40 $88.00 $0.60 0.7% 

Grand Total $5.20 $0.80 $14.10 $83.70 $4.40 5.3% 

Table 3-7. Summary of Regional Market Impacts: 2005 

Regional Markets 

With Imports Without Imports All Markets 

Change in Market Price 

Absolute ($/metric ton) 

Mean $4.70 $5.90 $4.40 

Median $4.30 $5.20 $4.60 

Minimum $0.60 $3.20 $0.60 

Maximum $9.70 $10.00 $10.00 

Percentage of baseline price 

Mean 5.5% 7.0% 5.3% 

Median 5.7% 6.1% 6.0% 

Minimum 0.6% 3.9% 0.6% 

Maximum 10.6% 11.9% 11.9% 

Change in Domestic Production 

Absolute (thousand metric tons) 

Mean −562 −257 −298 

Median −457 −251 −303 

Minimum −59 −144 −20 

Maximum −1,519 −380 −679 

Percentage of baseline production 

Mean −12.3% −6.2% −11.1% 

Median −11.0% −5.4% −10.4% 

Minimum −5.6% −3.4% −3.4% 

Maximum −35.1% −10.4% −35.1% 
Table 3-8. Distribution of Industry Impacts: 2005 

Changes in Total Operating Profit: 

Plants with Loss Plants with Gain All Plants 

Number 59 44 103 

Cement Capacity (million metric tons) 

Total 55,145 39,070 94,214 

Average per plant 935 888 915 

Compliance Costs 

Total (thousand) $299,102 $70,908 $370,010 

Average ($/metric cement) $5.42 $1.81 $3.93 

Capacity Utilization (percent) 

Baseline 99.4% 97.9% 98.7% 

With regulation 80.0% 99.5% 88.1% 

Change in total operating profits (million) −$383 $144 −$239 

Change in Employees (thousand) −1.6 0.1 −1.5 

Table 3-9. Cement Plants with Significant Utilization Changes: 2005 

Total 

Number 15 

Cement Capacity (thousand metric tons) 

Total 8,969 

Average per plant 598 

Compliance Costs 

Total (thousand) $70,369 

Average ($/metric ton) $7.85 

Capacity Utilization (%) 

Baseline 98.4% 

With regulation 54.8% 

Change in Operating Profit (million) −$135 

Change in Employees (thousand) −0.6 
Table 3-10. Job Losses/Gains Associated with the Final Rule 

Method 1,000 Jobs 

Partial equilibrium model −1.5 

(demand effect only) 

Literature-based estimate (net effect [A + B + C below]) 0.3

(−0.6 to +1.3) 

A. Literature-based estimate: Demand effect −0.8

(−1.6 to +0.1) 

B. Literature-based estimate: Cost effect 0.5

(+0.2 to +0.9) 

C. Literature-based estimate: Factor shift effect 0.6

(+0 to +1.1) 

Table 4-1. Small Entity Analysis 

Owner 

Entity 

Type 

Annual 

Sales ($106) Employees Plants Kilns 

Clinker 

Capacity (103

metric tons 

per year) 

Cost-toSales 

Ratio 

Salt River 

Materials Groupa

Tribal 

government 

$184b NA 1 1 1,477 0.6% 

Monarch Cement 

Company 

Business $154 600 1 2 787 2.8% 

Continental 

Cement 

Company, LLC 

Business $93c <750 1 1 1,164 4.5% 

Snyder Associate 

Companies 

Business $29 350 1 2 286 7.4% 

a

 Enterprise is owned by Salt River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community. 

b

 EPA estimate. Estimate uses revenue data for four of the six enterprises owned by Salt River Pima-Maricopa 

Indian Community. 

c

 EPA estimate. Estimate uses cement production levels and average market prices. 
1,203,724 wet ACI None 25,113,598 3,081,533 

GA201 822 324 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 2 105 150 

Kilns Controls Necessary for Compliance

Unit*

C

Pro

200

linker 

duction 

8 (t/yr) Kiln Type Hg HCl Org HAP PM

Wet scrubber

TCI ACI TCI

RT

AL101 964,522 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 2,469,177 

AL201 1,656,774 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 30,419,407 4,241,341 

AL301 1,547,645 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 29,200,858 3,961,971 AL401 789,255 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 19,494,997 2,020,493 AL501 990,978 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 22,347,614 2,536,903 

ARNEW1 700,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 18,140,599 1,792,000 

AZ101 132,300 Dry ACI None ACI None 0 338,688 

AZ102 132,300 Dry ACI None ACI None 0 338,688 

AZ103 132,300 Dry ACI None ACI None 0 338,688 

AZ104 1,068,140 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,375,969 2,734,438 

AZ204 1,176,166 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 3,010,985 

CA101 1,176,166 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 24,767,034 3,010,985 

CA102 1,176,166 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 24,767,034 3,010,985 

CA1108 2,004,002 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 34,098,218 5,130,245 

CA201 1,515,678 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 28,837,458 3,880,136 

CA301 1,203,724 Precalcin Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 25,113,598 3,081,533 CA302 1,916,919 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 33,201,301 4,907,314 

CA401 1,601,658 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 29,808,129 4,100,245 CA501 652,568 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,392,755 1,670,575 CA601 1,056,014 Precalciner ACI and WS wet scrubber ACI None 23,216,388 2,703,396 CA701 1,700,866 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 30,902,592 4,354,218 CA801 1,138,688 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 24,290,449 2,915,040 CA901 928,146 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 21,486,348 2,376,054 

CO101 522,496 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 1,337,589 

CO201 1,699,764 Precalciner wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 

CONEW1 1,000,000 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 2,560,000 

FL101 693,354 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 1,774,986 FL102 687,842 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 1,760,876 FL201 789,255 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 19,494,997 2,020,493 

FL301 666,898 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,620,920 1,707,260 FL302 896,179 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 21,039,222 2,294,218 FL401 1,092,391 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,692,972 2,796,520 FL501 881,849 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 20,836,719 2,257,534 FL601 1,897,078 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 4,856,519 

FLNEW1 1,100,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,791,861 2,816,000 

FLNEW2 750,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 18,907,302 1,920,000 

GA201 822,324 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 2, , 105 150 

IA101 601,862 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 16,568,796 1,540,767 

IA102 385,809 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 12,688,672 987,671 

IA201 1,074,754 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,462,707 2,751,369 

IA301 * 805,790 Precalciner wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber None 0 0 
2,300,524 None ACI None 0 5,889,341 

NM101 238 099 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 609 534 

ID101 126,766 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 6,507,199 324,520 

ID102 159,835 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,478,184 409,178 

IL101 625,011 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 16,948,263 1,600,027 

IL201 175,267 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,903,394 448,685 

IL202 175,267 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,903,394 448,685 IL203 175,267 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,903,394 448,685 IL204 175,267 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,903,394 448,685 IL302 984,364 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 2,519,972 

IL401 469,585 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 14,276,479 1,202,137 

IL402 648,159 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,322,148 1,659,287 

IN301 328,489 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 11,521,396 840,931 

IN302 684,535 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 17,899,064 1,752,410 

IN401 276,680 Preheater ACI wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 708,301 

IN402 276,680 Preheater ACI wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 708,301 IN403 302,033 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 10,955,336 773,205 

KS401 432,106 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 13,581,477 1,106,191 

KS402 339,512 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 11,751,838 869,150 

KY101 1,550,952 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 29,238,279 3,970,437 

MD101 169,756 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 7,753,321 434,575 

MD102 169,756 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 7,753,321 434,575 

MD201 2,300,524 Precalciner Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 5,889,341 

MD301 564,383 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 15,941,799 1,444,821 

ME101 713,195 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 1,825,780 

MI101 1,360,252 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 27,024,922 3,482,246 

MI201 461,868 Wet wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 

MI202 453,050 Wet wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 MI301 368,172 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 12,337,388 942,520 

MI302 368,172 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 12,337,388 942,520 MI303 370,377 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 12,381,661 948,164 MI304 641,545 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,215,877 1,642,356 MI305 658,080 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,480,746 1,684,684 

MO201 670,205 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,673,294 1,715,726 MO202 670,205 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,673,294 1,715,726 MO302 1,056,014 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,216,388 2,703,396 MO501 1,018,536 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 22,718,442 2,607,451 

MONEW1 4,400,000 Precalciner ACI lime injection ACI None 0 11,264,000 

MONEW2 1,000,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 22,469,468 2,560,000 

MT101 329,591 Wet ACI None ACI membrane bags 0 843,753 

MT201 308,647 Wet ACI None ACI membrane bags 0 790,137 

NE101 351,637 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 12,001,893 900,192 

NE102 607,374 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 16,659,667 1,554,876 

NM101 238,099 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 609,534 NM102 238,099 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 609,534 

NV101 249,122 Dry ACI None ACI None 0 637,753 

NV102 249,122 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 637,753 

NVNEW1 500,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 14,824,321 1,280,000 
261,248 Wet wet ACI 10,042,096 668,794 

TX202 320 773 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 11 358 243 821 178 

NY101 645,954 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 1,653,643 

NY201 933,658 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 21,562,812 2,390,164 

NY202 932,555 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 21,547,534 2,387,342 NY301 630,522 Wet ACI None ACI None 0 1,614,136 

OH101 728,628 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 18,582,161 1,865,287 

OK101 209,439 Dry wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 

OK102 209,439 Dry wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 OK103 308,647 Dry wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 OK201 277,782 Wet ACI lime injection ACI membrane bags 0 711,123 

OK202 288,806 Wet ACI lime injection ACI membrane bags 0 739,342 

OK301 340,614 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 11,774,716 871,972 

OK302 319,670 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 11,334,808 818,356 

OR101 985,466 Precalciner ACI and WS wet scrubber ACI None 22,272,956 2,522,794 

PA101 145,505 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,068,377 372,493 

PA102 145,505 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,068,377 372,493 PA201 262,350 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 10,067,497 671,616 

PA202 580,918 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 16,220,406 1,487,150 

PA301 274,476 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 10,344,154 702,657 

PA302 261,248 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 10,042,096 668,794 PA303 264,555 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 10,118,173 677,260 

PA401 261,248 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane membrane bags 10,042,096 668,794 

PA402 405,651 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 13,076,275 1,038,465 

PA501 1,410,958 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 27,624,939 3,612,054 

PA701 461,868 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 14,135,259 1,182,383 

PA702 311,954 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 11,169,847 798,602 

PA801 587,532 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 16,330,959 1,504,082 

PA802 587,532 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 16,330,959 1,504,082 PA901 123,458 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI None 6,404,782 316,052 

PR101 652,568 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,392,750 1,670,574 

PR201 970,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 22,062,557 2,483,200 SC201 1,078,060 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,505,996 2,759,835 SD101 154,324 Wet ACI None ACI None 0 395,068 SD102 154,324 Wet ACI None ACI None 0 395,068 SD103 660,284 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 1,690,328 

TN101 899,486 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 2,302,684 TN201 756,186 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 19,000,710 1,935,835 

TX1001 859,803 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 20,522,587 2,201,095 

TX101 977,750 Precalciner ACI lime injection ACI None 0 2,503,040 

TX1201 1,264,351 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 25,865,055 3,236,739 

TX1301 111,333 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI None 6,019,593 285,012 

TX201 320,773 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 11,358,243 821,178 

TX202 320,773 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 11, , 358 243 821,178 TX203 320,773 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 11,358,243 821,178 

TX301 159,835 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,478,184 409,178 

TX302 159,835 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 7,478,184 409,178 TX303 180,779 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 8,051,590 462,794 
wet ACI None 24,767,034 1,689,600 

TX402 608,476 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 1,557,698 

TX501 1,074,754 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 23,462,707 2,751,369 

TX502 1,237,896 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 25,538,960 3,169,013 TX601 241,406 Dry ACI None ACI None 0 618,000 

TX602 272,271 Preheater ACI None ACI None 0 697,013 

TX701 * 1,087,981 Precalciner wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 

TX702 * 1,133,176 Precalciner wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 TX905 * 2,164,939 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 35,715,789 5,542,245 

UT101 918,225 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 2,350,657 

UT201 784,846 Precalciner wet scrubber wet scrubber RTO and scrubber membrane bags 0 0 

VA101 1,247,816 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 25,661,569 3,194,410 

WA101 744,060 Precalciner ACI None ACI None 0 1,904,794 

WA201 419,981 Wet ACI None ACI membrane bags 0 1,075,150 WV101 229,281 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 9,285,672 586,959 

WV102 229,281 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 9,285,672 586,959 WV103 346,126 Wet ACI wet scrubber ACI membrane bags 11,888,666 886,082 

WVNEW1 700,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 18,140,599 1,792,000 

WY101 189,598 Dry ACI wet scrubber ACI None 8,284,998 485,370 

WY102 442,027 Preheater ACI wet scrubber ACI None 12,553,832 1,131,589 

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 22,347,614 3,328,000 

AZNEW1 660,000 Precalciner Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 24,767,034 1,689,600 

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 24,767,034 4,864,000 AZNEW3 1,100,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 24,767,034 2,816,000 

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 19,981,066 2,304,000 

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 17,322,148 4,674,560 

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 10,955,336 3,133,440 

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 11,098,650 5,888,000 

PANEW1 379,000 Precalciner ACI wet scrubber ACI None 6,404,782 970,240 

1,952,321,627 285,502,703 

*Shaded units are area sources.
3,557,894 1,095,389 0 0 0 198,117 4,653,283

0 748 315 0 0 0 154 820 748 315

Incurred Annualized Costs

Wet 

scrubber 

TAC ACI TAC

RTO/scrubb

er TAC

Lime 

injection 

TAC PM TAC

All CEMS 

Annual 

Costs blank

Total TAC 

w/o monitor 

costs($)

0 877,715 0 0 0 154,820 877,715

4,328,306 1,507,664 0 0 0 198,117 5,835,970

4,154,009 1,408,357 0 0 0 198,117 5,562,366

2,751,092 718,222 0 0 0 198,117 3,469,3143,174,964 901,790 0 0 0 198,117 4,076,7542,492,445 637,000 0 0 0 198,117 3,129,445

0 120,393 0 0 0 154,820 120,393

0 120,393 0 0 0 154,820 120,393

0 120,393 0 0 0 154,820 120,393

3,268,230 972,007 0 0 0 198,117 4,240,237

0 1,070,311 0 0 0 154,820 1,070,311

3,485,298 1,070,311 0 0 0 198,117 4,555,609

3,485,298 1,070,311 0 0 0 198,117 4,555,609

4,834,977 1,823,642 0 0 0 198,117 6,658,619

4,086,982 1,379,267 0 0 0 198,117 5,466,249

3,557,894 1,095,389 0 0 0 198,117 4,653,283

4,707,406 1,744,397 0 0 0 198,117 6,451,803

4,224,949 1,457,509 0 0 0 198,117 5,682,458

2,462,003 593,837 0 0 0 198,117 3,055,840

3,288,465 960,973 0 0 0 198,117 4,249,438

4,380,537 1,547,788 0 0 0 198,117 5,928,325

3,440,985 1,036,206 0 0 0 198,117 4,477,191

3,042,855 844,613 0 0 0 198,117 3,887,468

0 475,471 0 0 0 154,820 475,471

0 0 5,048,957 0 207,100 198,117 5,256,0570 910,000 0 0 0 198,117 910,0000 630,952 0 0 0 154,820 630,9520 625,936 0 0 0 154,820 625,936

2,756,320 718,222 0 0 0 198,117 3,474,542

2,502,925 606,877 0 0 0 198,117 3,109,802

2,974,937 815,523 0 0 0 198,117 3,790,460

3,350,711 994,075 0 0 0 198,117 4,344,787

2,946,267 802,483 0 0 0 198,117 3,748,749

0 1,726,341 0 0 0 154,820 1,726,341

3,364,716 1,001,000 0 0 0 198,117 4,365,716

2,673,129 682,500 0 0 0 198,117 3,355,629

0 748,315 0 0 0 154,820 748,315

2,128,421 547,694 0 0 0 198,117 2,676,115

1,656,171 351,086 0 0 0 198,117 2,007,257

3,286,955 978,026 0 0 0 198,117 4,264,981

0 0 6,585,832 0 0 198,117 6,585,832
0 2,093,477 0 0 0 198,117 2,093,477

0 216 670 0 0 0 154 820 216 670

917,836 115,357 0 0 132,190 198,117 1,165,383

1,054,737 145,450 0 0 0 198,117 1,200,1872,255,350 568,760 0 0 221,949 198,117 3,046,059

1,077,896 159,493 0 0 0 198,117 1,237,3901,077,896 159,493 0 0 0 198,117 1,237,3901,077,896 159,493 0 0 0 198,117 1,237,3901,077,098 159,493 0 0 0 198,117 1,236,592

0 895,771 0 0 0 154,820 895,771

1,912,234 427,322 0 0 198,980 198,117 2,538,536

2,303,060 589,825 0 0 0 198,117 2,892,8851,511,425 298,925 0 0 175,296 198,117 1,985,645

2,287,329 622,927 0 0 230,122 198,117 3,140,378

0 251,779 3,207,221 0 165,603 198,117 3,624,603

0 251,779 3,207,221 0 165,603 198,117 3,624,603

1,524,599 274,850 0 0 170,429 198,117 1,969,879

1,905,162 393,216 0 0 0 198,117 2,298,3791,649,425 308,956 0 0 0 198,117 1,958,3804,152,940 1,411,366 0 0 0 198,117 5,564,306

1,045,808 154,478 0 0 142,903 198,117 1,343,189

1,045,808 154,478 0 0 142,903 198,117 1,343,189

0 2,093,477 0 0 0 198,117 2,093,477

2,093,139 513,589 0 0 0 198,117 2,606,728

0 649,008 0 0 0 154,820 649,008

3,553,475 1,237,829 0 0 0 198,117 4,791,304

0 0 4,199,890 0 197,766 198,117 4,397,656

0 0 4,148,168 0 196,369 198,117 4,344,537

1,669,412 335,036 0 0 0 198,117 2,004,4491,669,412 335,036 0 0 0 198,117 2,004,4491,675,231 337,043 0 0 0 198,117 2,012,2732,304,646 583,806 0 0 0 198,117 2,888,4522,338,805 598,853 0 0 0 198,117 2,937,6582,469,054 609,887 0 0 0 198,117 3,078,9412,469,054 609,887 0 0 0 198,117 3,078,9413,207,585 960,973 0 0 0 198,117 4,168,5583,139,756 926,867 0 0 0 198,117 4,066,623

0 4,004,000 0 3,009,995 0 198,117 7,013,995

3,105,827 910,000 0 0 0 198,117 4,015,827

0 299,928 0 0 175,495 154,820 475,423

0 280,869 0 0 171,662 154,820 452,530

1,616,988 319,990 0 0 179,426 198,117 2,116,404

2,334,896 552,710 0 0 219,468 198,117 3,107,074

0 216,670 0 0 0 154,820 216,6700 216,670 0 0 0 154,820 216,6700 226,701 0 0 0 154,820 226,7010 226,701 0 0 0 154,820 226,701

2,094,479 455,000 0 0 0 198,117 2,549,479
1,339,224 237,735 0 0 162,579 198,117 1,739,538

1 507 200 291 903 0 0 173 893 198 117 1 972 997

0 587,819 0 0 0 154,820 587,819

2,603,396 849,628 0 0 261,619 198,117 3,714,643

2,601,759 848,625 0 0 261,487 198,117 3,711,872

0 573,775 0 0 0 154,820 573,775

2,488,647 663,051 0 0 0 198,117 3,151,699

0 0 2,479,404 0 151,856 198,117 2,631,260

0 0 2,479,404 0 151,856 198,117 2,631,2600 0 3,157,944 0 171,662 198,117 3,329,6060 252,782 0 788,633 165,817 198,117 1,207,232

0 262,813 0 817,404 167,933 198,117 1,248,149

1,319,830 309,959 0 0 0 198,117 1,629,7891,278,770 290,900 0 0 0 198,117 1,569,6703,162,679 896,774 0 0 0 154,820 4,059,453

954,101 132,410 0 0 0 198,117 1,086,511

954,101 132,410 0 0 0 198,117 1,086,511

1,402,125 238,739 0 0 0 198,117 1,640,8632,276,016 528,635 0 0 0 198,117 2,804,6521,364,119 249,773 0 0 0 198,117 1,613,8921,326,104 237,735 0 0 0 198,117 1,563,8391,335,687 240,745 0 0 0 198,117 1,576,432

1,339,224 237,735 0 0 162,579 198,117 1,739,538

1,724,326 369,142 0 0 188,663 198,117 2,282,130

3,798,245 1,283,972 0 0 313,733 198,117 5,395,9501,962,001 420,300 0 0 0 198,117 2,382,3021,554,167 283,878 0 0 0 198,117 1,838,0452,262,934 534,654 0 0 0 198,117 2,797,5882,262,934 534,654 0 0 0 198,117 2,797,588

867,031 112,347 0 0 0 198,117 979,378

2,470,377 593,837 0 0 0 198,117 3,064,2143,119,831 882,700 0 0 0 198,117 4,002,5313,301,916 981,035 0 0 0 198,117 4,282,951

0 140,434 0 0 0 154,820 140,434

0 140,434 0 0 0 154,820 140,4340 600,859 0 0 0 154,820 600,8590 818,532 0 0 0 154,820 818,532

2,670,698 688,129 0 0 0 198,117 3,358,8262,876,876 782,421 0 0 252,676 198,117 3,911,973

0 889,753 0 423,289 0 198,117 1,313,041

3,621,713 1,150,559 0 0 0 198,117 4,772,272

816,290 101,313 0 0 0 198,117 917,603

1,507,200 291,903 0 0 173,893 198,117 1,972,997

1, , 507 200 291,903 0 0 173,893 198,117 1, , 972 9971,507,200 291,903 0 0 173,893 198,117 1,972,997

1,043,997 145,450 0 0 0 198,117 1,189,447

1,043,997 145,450 0 0 0 198,117 1,189,447

1,123,430 164,509 0 0 0 198,117 1,287,939
3,427,432 600,600 0 0 0 198,117 4,028,032

0 553,713 0 0 0 198,117 553,713

3,286,955 978,026 0 0 0 198,117 4,264,9813,576,289 1,126,485 0 0 0 198,117 4,702,774

0 219,680 0 0 0 154,820 219,6800 247,767 0 0 0 154,820 247,7670 0 8,094,888 0 279,437 198,117 8,374,326

0 0 8,326,128 0 284,460 198,117 8,610,588

4,991,597 1,970,095 0 0 0 198,117 6,961,692

0 835,585 0 0 0 154,820 835,585

0 0 6,501,652 0 243,280 198,117 6,744,932

3,603,701 1,135,513 0 0 0 198,117 4,739,214

0 677,095 0 0 0 154,820 677,095

0 382,182 0 0 191,029 154,820 573,211

1,245,096 208,645 0 0 156,076 198,117 1,609,817

1,245,096 208,645 0 0 156,076 198,117 1,609,817

1,579,141 314,974 0 0 178,453 198,117 2,072,569

2,486,649 637,000 0 0 0 198,117 3,123,6491,165,578 172,534 0 0 0 198,117 1,338,1121,769,873 402,244 0 0 0 198,117 2,172,1183,208,169 1,183,000 0 0 0 198,117 4,391,169

3,427,432 600,600 0 0 0 198,117 4,028,0323,496,222 1,729,000 0 0 0 198,117 5,225,222

3,457,063 1,001,000 0 0 0 198,117 4,458,063

2,748,162 819,000 0 0 0 198,117 3,567,1622,146,341 1,661,660 0 0 0 198,117 3,808,001

1,556,059 1,113,840 0 0 0 198,117 2,669,899

1,731,923 2,093,000 0 0 0 198,117 3,824,923

832,161 344,890 0 0 0 198,117 1,177,051

30,597,920 440,744,891
NEI22877 2,004,002 . 110 96 218 

1 100 000 122 06 110 96 ACI and WS 120 

Unit NEI ID

Clinker 

Production 

2008 (t/yr) Kiln Type

Base

Hg(lb

line 

/yr)*

Baseline Hg 

(lb/MM ton 

clinker)

Hg Co

H

ntrol (Or

AP)

g 

H

Emis

Redu

after

HA

Con

(lb

g 

sion 

ction 

 Org 

P 

trol 

/yr)

A

ba

O

em

AL101 NEIAL321 964,522 Preheater 107.02 110.96 ACI 96 

AL201 NEIAL8026 1,656,774 Precalciner 186.69 112.68 ACI and WS 183 

AL301 NEIAL1170004 1,547,645 Precalciner 316.80 204.70 ACI and WS 310 AL401 NEIALT$4449 789,255 Preheater 31.66 40.11 ACI and WS 31 

AL501 NEIAL1150002 990,978 Precalciner 109.96 110.96 ACI and WS 108 

ARNEW1 700,000 Precalciner 77.67 110.96 ACI and WS 76 

AZ101 NEI18621 132,300 Dry 14.72 111.28 ACI 13 

AZ102 NEI18621 132,300 Dry 14.72 111.28 ACI 13 AZ103 NEI18621 132,300 Dry 14.72 111.28 ACI 13 AZ104 NEI18621 1,068,140 Precalciner 120.94 113.22 ACI and WS 119 

AZ204 NEIAZ0250421 1,176,166 Precalciner 130.51 110.96 ACI 117 CA101 NEI22743 1,176,166 Dry 427.17 363.19 ACI and WS 419 CA102 NEI22743 1,176,166 Dry 427.17 363.19 ACI and WS 419 

CA1108 NEI22877 2,004,002 Precalciner Precalciner 222.37 110.96 ACI and WS 218 

CA201 NEI20046 1,515,678 Precalciner 104.05 68.65 ACI and WS 102 

CA301 NEI22900 1,203,724 Precalciner 133.57 110.96 ACI and WS 131 CA302 NEI22900 1,916,919 Precalciner 212.70 110.96 ACI and WS 208 CA401 NEI24859 1,601,658 Precalciner 177.72 110.96 ACI and WS 174 CA501 NEI25375 652,568 Precalciner 68.83 105.47 ACI and WS 67 

CA601 NEICA1505122 1,056,014 Precalciner 1,785.26 1,690.57 ACI and WS 1,750 

CA701 NEI22838 1,700,866 Precalciner 188.73 110.96 ACI and WS 185 CA801 NEI20130 1,138,688 Precalciner 126.35 110.96 ACI and WS 124 CA901 NEI2CA151186 928,146 Precalciner 102.99 110.96 ACI and WS 101 

CO101 NEI446 522,496 Precalciner 114.75 219.62 ACI 103 CO201 NEI886 1,699,764 Precalciner 24.66 14.51 wet scrubber 20 

CONEW1 1,000,000 Precalciner 110.96 110.96 ACI 100 

FL101 NEIFLR053001 693,354 Preheater 136.74 197.22 ACI 123 FL102 NEIFLR053001 687,842 Preheater 147.45 214.37 ACI 133 FL201 NEIFLR001008 789,255 Precalciner 87.58 110.96 ACI and WS 86 

FL301 NEI26327 666,898 Preheater 74.00 110.96 ACI and WS 73 FL302 NEI26327 896,179 Precalciner 99.44 110.96 ACI and WS 97 FL401 NEI26277 1,092,391 Precalciner 121.21 110.96 ACI and WS 119 

FL501 NEIFL12100465 881,849 Precalciner 97.85 110.96 ACI and WS 96 

FL601 NEIFL0860020 1,897,078 Precalciner 210.50 110.96 ACI 189 

FLNEW1 1, , 100 000 Precalciner 122.06 110.96 ACI and WS 120 FLNEW2 750,000 Precalciner 83.22 110.96 ACI and WS 82 

GA201 NEIGA1530003 822,324 Preheater 91.25 110.96 ACI 82 

IA101 NEIIA0330060 601,862 Dry 112.34 186.65 ACI and WS 110 

IA102 NEIIA0330060 385,809 Dry 77.98 202.11 ACI and WS 76 
NEI33444 Wet 4.73 27.86 5 

351 637 14 40 ACI and WS 14 

IA201 NEI12238 1,074,754 Precalciner 130.72 121.63 ACI and WS 128 

IA301 * NEIIA0330035 805,790 Precalciner 85.90 106.60 wet scrubber 69 

ID101 NEIID0050004 126,766 Wet 3.11 24.53 ACI and WS 3 

ID102 NEIID0050004 159,835 Wet 3.56 22.27 ACI and WS 3 

IL101 NEI51435 625,011 Dry 50.72 81.15 ACI and WS 50 IL201 NEI51527 175,267 Preheater 19.45 110.96 ACI and WS 19 IL202 NEI51527 175,267 Preheater 19.45 110.96 ACI and WS 19 IL203 NEI51527 175,267 Preheater 19.45 110.96 ACI and WS 19 IL204 NEI51527 175,267 Dry 19.45 110.96 ACI and WS 19 IL302 NEI51352 984,364 Precalciner 109.23 110.96 ACI 98 

IL401 NEI52351 469,585 Dry 5.51 11.73 ACI and WS 5 

IL402 NEI52351 648,159 Dry 63.54 98.04 ACI and WS 62 

IN301 NEI31319 328,489 Dry 30.68 93.39 ACI and WS 30 IN302 NEI31319 684,535 Dry 63.94 93.40 ACI and WS 63 IN401 NEI32033 276,680 Preheater 29.01 104.85 ACI and WS 28 

IN402 NEI32033 276,680 Preheater 31.20 112.76 ACI and WS 31 IN403 NEI32033 302,033 Preheater 35.98 119.11 ACI and WS 35 

KS401 NEI12739 432,106 Precalciner 47.95 110.96 ACI and WS 47 KS402 NEI12739 339,512 Precalciner 37.67 110.96 ACI and WS 37 

KY101 NEIKYR0060 1,550,952 Precalciner 172.10 110.96 ACI and WS 169 

MD101 NEI33444 169,756 169,756 Wet 4.73 27.86 ACI and WS 5 

MD102 NEI33444 169,756 Wet 5.46 32.17 ACI and WS 5 

MD201 NEI33394 2,300,524 Precalciner 420.19 182.65 None 0 

MD301 NEI33699 564,383 Dry 62.62 110.96 ACI and WS 61 

ME101 NEIME0130002 713,195 Precalciner 79.14 110.96 ACI 71 

MI101 NEIMIB1559 1,360,252 Precalciner 150.94 110.96 ACI and WS 148 

MI201 NEIMIB1743 461,868 Wet 78.77 170.55 wet scrubber 63 

MI202 NEIMIB1743 453,050 Wet 78.20 172.62 wet scrubber 63 

MI301 NEI12018 368,172 Dry 31.65 85.96 ACI and WS 31 

MI302 NEI12018 368,172 Dry 32.76 88.99 ACI and WS 32 MI303 NEI12018 370,377 Dry 33.75 91.14 ACI and WS 33 MI304 NEI12018 641,545 Dry 67.54 105.28 ACI and WS 66 MI305 NEI12018 658,080 Dry 69.12 105.03 ACI and WS 68 

MO201 NEIMO0990002 670,205 Dry 74.37 110.96 ACI and WS 73 MO202 NEIMO0990002 670,205 Dry 74.37 110.96 ACI and WS 73 MO302 NEI34520 1,056,014 Precalciner 117.18 110.96 ACI and WS 115 

MO501 NEI34326 1,018,536 Precalciner 59.25 58.17 ACI and WS 58 

MONEW1 4,400,000 Precalciner 488.23 110.96 ACI 439 

MONEW2 1,000,000 Precalciner 110.96 110.96 ACI and WS 109 

MT101 NEIMT0430001 329,591 Wet 8.29 25.14 None 0 

MT201 NEIMT0310005 308,647 Wet 34.39 111.43 ACI 31 

NE101 NEI572 351,637 Preheater 14.37 40.88 ACI and WS 14 NE102 NEI572 607,374 Precalciner 34.85 57.38 ACI and WS 34 

NM101 NEINMT$12442 238,099 Preheater 26.42 110.96 ACI 24 

NM102 NEINMT$12442 238,099 Preheater 26.42 110.96 ACI 24 

NV101 NEI2NV410803 249,122 Dry 27.64 110.96 ACI 25 
NEI46744 53.77 205.82 53 

111 333 Wet 12 110 96 ACI and WS 12 

NV102 NEI2NV410803 249,122 Preheater 27.64 110.96 ACI 25 

NVNEW1 500,000 Precalciner 55.48 110.96 ACI and WS 54 

NY101 NEINYT$1163 645,954 Preheater 87.92 136.11 ACI 79 NY201 NEI34931 933,658 Wet 72.71 77.87 ACI and WS 71 

NY202 NEI34931 932,555 Wet 69.32 74.33 ACI and WS 68 

NY301 NEINY4192600 630,522 Wet 69.96 110.96 ACI 63 

OH101 NEIOHT$6526 728,628 Preheater 107.17 147.08 ACI and WS 105 

OK101 NEI12976 209,439 Dry 29.83 142.41 wet scrubber 24 

OK102 NEI12976 209,439 Dry 26.21 125.15 wet scrubber 21 OK103 NEI12976 308,647 Dry 34.21 110.84 wet scrubber 27 OK201 NEIOK1826 277,782 Wet 22.82 82.16 ACI 21 

OK202 NEIOK1826 288,806 Wet 42.18 146.04 ACI 38 

OK301 NEIOK4013107 340,614 Dry 10.93 32.09 ACI and WS 11 

OK302 NEIOK4013107 319,670 Dry 10.44 32.66 ACI and WS 10 

OR101 NEI40539 985,466 Precalciner 3,219.89 3,267.38 ACI and WS 3,155 

PA101 NEIPA01993-1 145,505 Wet 16.15 110.96 ACI and WS 16 

PA102 NEIPA01993-1 145,505 Wet 16.15 110.96 ACI and WS 16 

PA201 NEIPA94-2626 262,350 Preheater 29.11 110.96 ACI and WS 29 

PA202 NEIPA94-2626 580,918 Precalciner 64.46 110.96 ACI and WS 63 

PA301 NEI46744 274,476 Dry 53.86 196.24 ACI and WS 53 

PA302 NEI46744 261,248 261,248 Dry 53.77 205.82 ACI and WS 53 

PA303 NEI46744 264,555 Dry 54.61 206.42 ACI and WS 54 

PA401 NEIPAT$1626 261,248 Wet 47.51 181.84 ACI and WS 47 

PA402 NEIPAT$1626 405,651 Wet 98.85 243.67 ACI and WS 97 

PA501 NEI7255 1,410,958 Preheater 168.70 119.56 ACI and WS 165 

PA701 NEIPA58-1290 461,868 Preheater 36.01 77.97 ACI and WS 35 

PA702 NEIPA58-1290 311,954 Preheater 23.98 76.86 ACI and WS 23 PA801 NEI2PA110039 587,532 Preheater 40.48 68.90 ACI and WS 40 PA802 NEI2PA110039 587,532 Preheater 40.48 68.90 ACI and WS 40 PA901 NEIPA23-0797 123,458 Wet 8.26 66.95 ACI and WS 8 

PR101 652,568 Preheater 72.41 110.96 ACI and WS 71 

PR201 970,000 Precalciner 107.63 110.96 ACI and WS 105 

SC201 NEISC0351244 1,078,060 Precalciner 207.33 192.31 ACI and WS 203 

SD101 NEISDT$8989 154,324 Wet 17.12 110.96 ACI 15 

SD102 NEISDT$8989 154,324 Wet 17.12 110.96 ACI 15 

SD103 NEISDT$8989 660,284 Precalciner 73.27 110.96 ACI 66 

TN101 NEITN0653070 899,486 Precalciner 99.81 110.96 ACI 90 TN201 NEITN0930008 756,186 Precalciner 230.60 304.95 ACI and WS 226 

TX1001 NEI13290 859,803 Precalciner 62.69 72.91 ACI and WS 61 

TX101 NEITXRBG0259 977,750 Precalciner 108.49 110.96 ACI 98 

TX1201 NEITXT$11924 1,264,351 Precalciner 140.29 110.96 ACI and WS 137 

TX1301 NEITX309123F 111,333 Wet 12.35 110.96 ACI and WS 12 

TX201 NEI7376 320,773 Wet 33.63 104.86 ACI and WS 33 

TX202 NEI7376 320,773 Wet 31.84 99.25 ACI and WS 31 

TX203 NEI7376 320,773 Wet 32.22 100.43 ACI and WS 32 

TX301 NEITXT$11980 159,835 Preheater 16.65 104.15 ACI and WS 16 
42.05 110.96 41 

TX302 NEITXT$11980 159,835 Preheater 11.48 71.81 ACI and WS 11 

TX303 NEITXT$11980 180,779 Preheater 18.53 102.50 ACI and WS 18 

TX402 NEITXT$11872 608,476 Precalciner 67.52 110.96 ACI 61 

TX501 NEIT$FNP1408 1,074,754 Precalciner 119.26 110.96 ACI and WS 117 

TX502 NEIT$FNP1408 1,237,896 Precalciner 137.36 110.96 ACI and WS 135 TX601 NEITXT$12011 241,406 Dry 26.79 110.96 ACI 24 

TX602 NEITXT$12011 272,271 Preheater 30.21 110.96 ACI 27 

TX701 * NEITX139099J 1,087,981 Precalciner 19.57 17.99 wet scrubber 16 

TX702 * NEITX139099J 1,133,176 Precalciner 41.42 36.55 wet scrubber 33 TX905 * NEI13258 2,164,939 Precalciner 300.09 138.61 ACI and WS 294 

UT101 NEIUT10303 918,225 Precalciner 197.08 214.63 ACI 177 UT201 NEI42038 784,846 Precalciner 116.98 149.05 wet scrubber 94 

VA101 NEIVA2553 1,247,816 Precalciner 138.46 110.96 ACI and WS 136 

WA101 NEIWA+B70331133 744,060 Precalciner 57.92 77.84 ACI 52 

WA201 NEIWA0331404 419,981 Wet 65.40 155.73 ACI 59 

WV101 NEIWV0030006 229,281 Wet 17.29 75.42 ACI and WS 17 

WV102 NEIWV0030006 229,281 Wet 19.98 87.15 ACI and WS 20 

WV103 NEIWV0030006 346,126 Wet 16.82 48.61 ACI and WS 16 

WVNEW1 700,000 Precalciner 77.67 110.96 ACI and WS 76 

WY101 NEI338 189,598 Dry 21.04 110.96 ACI and WS 21 

WY102 379,000 379,000 Precalciner Precalciner 42.05 110.96 ACI and WS 41 

ALNEW1 NEIAL1150002 990,978 Precalciner 109.96 110.96 ACI and WS 108 

AZNEW1 NEIAZ0250421 1,176,166 Precalciner 130.51 110.96 ACI and WS 128 AZNEW2 NEIAZ0250421 1,176,166 Precalciner 130.51 110.96 ACI and WS 128 AZNEW3 NEIAZ0250421 1,176,166 Precalciner 130.51 110.96 ACI and WS 128 

GANEW1 NEIGA1530003 822,324 Preheater 91.25 110.96 ACI and WS 89 

ILNEW1 NEI52351 648,159 Dry 63.54 98.04 ACI and WS 62 

INNEW1 NEI32033 302,033 Preheater 35.98 119.11 ACI and WS 35 

NCNEW1 NEIMT0310005 308,647 Wet 34.39 111.43 ACI and WS 34 

PANEW1 NEIPA23-0797 123,458 Wet 8.26 66.95 ACI and WS 8 

18,184.91 17,073 

94% 
112 77 01 31 None 0 331 314

61 90 None 0 248 235

HCl 

Emission 

Reduction 

after Org 

HAP 

Control 

(ton/yr)

PM 10 

Baseline 

Emission 

rate (lb/ton 

clinker)

Total filterable PM (tpy)

PM Control with 

Org HAP control

PM Emission 

Reduction 

with Org HAP 

Control (tpy)

Baseline 

SO2 

emissions 

(tpy)

SO2 

reductions 

with Org 

HAP Control 

(tpy)

0.00 0.03 12.80 None 0 294 0

93.23 0.11 91.03 None 0 75 71

87.09 0.06 46.90 None 0 70 66

55.67 0.09 34.64 None 0 241 22935.18 0.20 100.71 None 0 45 4239.39 0.29 100.71 None 0 1,029 978

0.00 0.00 0.07 None 0 563 0

0.00 0.00 0.11 None 0 563 0

0.00 0.80 53.01 None 0 563 0

60.11 0.17 89.73 None 0 694 660

0.00 0.01 8.07 None 0 765 0

66.19 0.00 0.08 None 0 476 45366.19 0.00 0.07 None 0 476 453

112.77 0.01 8.31 None 0 331 314

391.53 0.08 61.58 None 0 250 238

67.74 0.34 202.92 None 0 199 189

107.87 0.34 323.14 None 0 316 300

90.13 0.34 270.00 None 0 264 251

45.27 0.14 46.53 None 0 108 102

12.61 0.01 3.04 None 0 174 16695.71 0.05 38.43 None 0 281 267

64.08 0.01 5.33 None 0 188 17852.23 0.10 46.00 None 0 153 145

0.00 0.51 133.03 None 0 84 0

8.72 0.10 81.31 membrane bags 73 272 258

0.00 0.16 81.31 None 0 160 0

0.00 0.04 12.94 None 0 7 0

0.00 0.05 18.82 None 0 7 0

44.41 0.03 12.05 None 0 178 169

37.53 0.14 45.86 None 0 7 6

50.43 0.10 45.86 None 0 202 192

61.47 0.02 8.55 None 0 246 23349.63 0.03 12.26 None 0 198 188

0.00 0.01 5.75 None 0 427 0

61.90 0 0.1 5 7.5 None 0 248 23542.21 0.02 5.75 None 0 169 160

0.00 0.26 107.01 None 0 1,122 0

33.87 0.13 39.25 None 0 2,717 2,581

21.71 0.10 19.19 None 0 1,741 1,654
9.55 0.33 28.28 membrane 636 604

40 52 59 membrane bags 58 1 034 98260.48 0.10 51.20 None 0 618 58745.35 0.01 3.23 None 0 463 440

7.13 0.05 2.90 membrane bags 2 44 42

8.99 0.01 0.70 None 0 56 53

35.17 1.05 327.98 membrane bags 325 1,838 1,746

9.86 6.51 570.83 None 0 506 480

9.86 0.34 29.55 None 0 506 480

9.86 0.34 29.55 None 0 506 480

9.86 0.34 29.55 None 0 515 490

0.00 0.12 59.79 None 0 2,746 0

26.43 0.02 5.36 membrane bags 3 1,381 1,312

36.47 0.05 15.07 None 0 1,906 1,81018.49 0.69 113.65 membrane bags 112 1,483 1,409

38.52 0.42 142.94 membrane bags 140 3,090 2,935

15.57 0.75 104.06 membrane bags 103 321 305

15.57 0.69 95.19 membrane bags 94 321 30517.00 0.75 113.29 membrane bags 112 351 33324.32 0.12 26.68 None 0 270 25719.11 0.30 50.10 None 0 212 20287.28 0.19 151.18 None 0 147 140

9.55 0.33 28.28 membrane bags 27 636 604

9.55 0.33 27.82 membrane bags 27 636 604

0.00 0.34 386.83 None 0 3,612 0

31.76 0.28 79.35 None 0 2,063 1,960

0.00 0.34 120.23 None 0 107 0

76.55 0.19 128.75 None 0 3,557 3,379

25.99 0.15 34.84 membrane bags 33 4,157 3,949

25.50 0.34 76.37 membrane bags 74 4,077 3,874

52.87 0.33 60.58 None 0 977 92952.87 0.21 38.49 None 0 977 92953.19 0.14 25.39 None 0 983 93492.12 0.07 23.86 None 0 1,703 1,61894.50 0.06 20.89 None 0 1,747 1,66037.72 0.91 304.28 None 0 506 481

37.72 0.34 112.98 None 0 506 481

59.43 0.34 178.02 None 0 1,151 1,094

57.32 0.01 6.66 None 0 1,110 1,05523.89 0.00 6.66 None 0 4,796 3,35756.27 0.01 6.66 None 0 1,090 1,036

0.00 0.84 137.69 membrane bags 136 115 0

0.00 0.40 61.80 membrane bags 60 108 0

40.52 0 3.4 59.28 membrane bags 58 1,034 98269.99 0.34 102.39 membrane bags 99 380 361

0.00 0.08 9.56 None 0 8 0

0.00 0.12 14.83 None 0 8 00.00 0.34 42.00 None 0 188 0
14.70 0.13 16.91 None 0 1,179 1,120

108 15 None 0 435 413

0.00 0.34 42.00 None 0 6 0

28.14 0.34 84.29 None 0 123 116

0.00 0.28 91.56 None 0 97 0

114.25 0.75 350.20 membrane bags 346 5,593 5,313

52.48 0.03 13.36 membrane bags 9 5,586 5,307

0.00 0.48 150.23 None 0 3,777 0

41.00 0.48 176.64 None 0 1,836 1,744

16.64 0.18 18.57 membrane bags 18 2,602 2,472

16.64 0.15 16.15 membrane bags 15 2,602 2,472

21.70 0.10 15.09 membrane bags 14 3,835 3,643

1.38 0.01 1.78 membrane bags 0 1,196 837

1.44 0.01 1.75 membrane bags 0 1,243 870

19.17 0.35 60.39 None 0 4,232 4,02117.99 0.38 60.82 None 0 3,972 3,773

5.00 0.06 30.58 None 0 64 61

8.19 0.03 2.17 None 0 569 540

8.19 0.22 16.14 None 0 569 540

14.76 0.79 103.11 None 0 305 289

32.69 0.25 72.32 None 0 334 31715.45 0.12 16.91 None 0 1,239 1,177

14.70 0.13 16.91 None 0 1,179 1,12014.89 0.12 15.29 None 0 1,194 1,13414.70 0.98 127.96 membrane bags 127 1,021 970

22.83 0.45 91.39 membrane bags 89 1,585 1,506

79.40 0.18 126.20 membrane bags 119 1,639 1,557

25.99 0.01 1.73 None 0 536 51017.55 0.01 0.98 None 0 362 34433.06 0.21 62.47 None 0 682 64833.06 0.21 62.71 None 0 682 648

6.95 0.10 5.88 None 0 482 458

36.72 0.02 5.88 None 0 7 6

54.59 0.01 5.88 None 0 218 20771.92 0.18 98.00 None 0 512 486

0.00 0.63 48.97 None 0 327 0

0.00 1.91 147.24 None 0 327 0

0.00 0.01 3.68 None 0 106 00.00 0.02 10.15 None 0 427 0

42.55 1.73 654.03 None 0 359 341

48.38 0.18 76.33 membrane bags 72 494 470

1.58 0.09 43.36 None 0 562 394

71.15 0.17 108.15 None 0 727 691

6 2.7 1 9.4 108.15 None 0 435 413

18.05 0.68 108.95 membrane bags 107 1,253 1,191

18.05 0.67 108.11 membrane bags 107 1,253 1,191

18.05 0.67 106.79 membrane bags 105 1,253 1,191

8.99 0.25 19.59 None 0 186 176
24.87 0.34 74.51 None 0 254 241

8.99 0.23 18.44 None 0 186 176

10.17 0.22 20.09 None 0 210 199

0.00 0.02 6.85 None 0 350 0

60.48 0.22 116.79 None 0 618 587

69.66 0.19 116.79 None 0 712 676

0.00 0.34 40.69 None 0 1,090 0

0.00 0.34 45.90 None 0 316 0

61.23 0.22 122.29 membrane bags 117 626 594

232.61 0.15 83.64 membrane bags 78 652 619121.83 0.08 91.65 None 0 1,245 1,183

0.00 0.34 154.79 None 0 60 0

18.86 0.04 15.51 membrane bags 12 51 48

70.22 0.29 179.26 None 0 593 563

0.00 0.08 31.14 None 0 197 00.00 0.07 14.96 membrane bags 13 798 0

12.90 0.05 5.82 membrane bags 5 859 816

12.90 1.11 127.82 membrane bags 127 859 81619.48 0.02 4.25 membrane bags 3 1,296 1,231

39.39 0.01 4.25 None 0 1,099 1,04410.67 0.34 31.96 None 0 101 96

24.87 0.34 74.51 None 0 254 24173.16 0.34 219.15 None 0 59 5637.14 0.34 111.26 None 0 429 408

106.92 0.34 320.29 None 0 1,235 1,173

61.90 0.34 185.43 None 0 715 679

50.65 0.34 151.72 None 0 1,229 1,167

102.76 0.34 307.82 None 0 5,368 5,100

68.88 0.34 206.33 None 0 1,422 1,351

129.43 0.34 387.72 None 0 805 765

21.33 0.34 63.8893916 None 0 1,481 1,407

5,858 12,945 2,957 151,916 124,012 14,019

94.41% 23% 82%
) ($

Unit NEI ID (t/yr) Kiln Type clinker) SO2 (ton) clinker (%) TCI ($) TCI ($) TAC ($) TAC ($

New kilns subject to NSPS

AZNEW3 Cal Portland Rillito, AZ Posponed

AZNEW2 Cemex Seligman, AZ 2012 CEMS Cost Capital ($) Annual ($)

GANEW1 Houston AmerPerry, GA 2012 SO2 143,135 42,3

INNEW1 Lehigh Mitchell, IN 2012 NOx 140,951 41,8

NCNEW1 Titan America Castle Hayne, NC 2012 Flow meter 35,780 13,8

ILNEW1 Lafarge Gain Chain, IL 2013

ALNEW1 National CemeRagland, AL 2013

Cost to meet 1.33 lb SO2/ton clinker*

Unit NEI ID

Clinke

Produc

n 200

( /tyr)

r 

tio

8 

) Kiln Type

Baseline

SO2 

(lb/ton

clinker)

 Base

SO2 (

line 

ton)

r

m

lb

( ) c

Remova

efficienc

equired

eet 1.3

 SO2/t

linker (% )

l 

y 

 to 

3 

on 

)

L

Inje

TC

ime 

ction 

I ($)

Wet 

Scrubb

TCI ($)

er 

)

L

Inje

TA

ime 

ction 

C ($)

Wet 

Scrubbe

TAC ($

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner 0.09 58.50 -1378 0 0 0 

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner 1.30 1,235.00 -2 0 0 0 AZNEW3 1,100,000 Precalciner 1.30 715.00 -2 0 0 0 

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner 0.95 427.50 -40 0 0 0 

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner 5.58 5,094.54 76 0 0 0 

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner 1.15 703.80 -16 0 0 0 

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner 1.15 1,322.50 -16 0 0 0 

Cost to meet 0.4 lb SO2/ton clinker*

Unit NEI ID

Clinke

Produc

n 200

(t/yr)

r 

tio

8 

Kiln Type

Baseline

SO2 

(lb/ton

clinker)

Base

SO2 (ton)

line 

r

m

clinker (%)

Remova

efficienc

equired

eet 0.4

SO2/to

l 

y 

 to 

 lb 

n 

L

Inje

TCI ($)

ime 

ction 

Wet 

Scrubb

TCI ($)

er 

L

Inje

TAC ($)

ime 

ction 

Wet 

Scrubbe

TAC ($

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner 0.09 58.50 -344 0 0 0 

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner 1.30 1,235.00 69 0 0 0 AZNEW3 1,100,000 Precalciner 1.30 715.00 69 0 0 0 
AZNEW3 1. 715 00 85 0 0 0 

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner 0.95 427.50 58 0 0 0 

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner 5.58 5,094.54 93 0 0 0 

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner 1.15 703.80 65 0 0 0 

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner 1.15 1,322.50 65 0 0 0 

Cost to meet 0.2 lb SO2/ton clinker*

Unit NEI ID

Clinke

Produc

n 200

(t/yr)

r 

tio

8 

Kiln Type

Baseline

SO2 

(lb/ton

clinker)

 Base

SO2 (

line 

ton)

r

m

c

Remova

efficienc

equired

eet 0.2

SO2/to

linker (%

l 

y 

 to 

 lb 

n 

)

L

Inje

TC

ime 

ction 

I ($)

Wet 

Scrubb

TCI ($

er 

)

L

Inje

TA

ime 

ction 

C ($)

Wet 

Scrubbe

TAC ($

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner 0.09 58.50 -122 0 0 0 

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner 1.30 1,235.00 85 0 0 0 AZNEW3 1,100,000 1,100,000 Precalciner 1.30 715.00 85 0 0 0 

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner 0.95 427.50 79 0 0 0 

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner 5.58 5,094.54 96 0 0 0 

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner 1.15 703.80 83 0 0 0 

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner 1.15 1,322.50 83 0 0 0 

*Wet scrubbers are required for HCl control under the NESHAP; there are no additional control costs under the NSPS.
) ($) ($) 

Unit NEI ID (t/yr) Kiln Type clinker) NOX (ton) clinker (%) ($) ($) ($) ($) 

New kilns subject to NSPS

AZNEW3 Cal Portland Rillito, AZ Posponed

AZNEW2 Cemex Seligman, AZ 2012 CEMS Cost Capital ($) Annual ($)

GANEW1 Houston AmerPerry, GA 2012 SO2 143,135 42,3

INNEW1 Lehigh Mitchell, IN 2012 NOx 140,951 41,8

NCNEW1 Titan America Castle Hayne, NC 2012 Flow meter 35,780 13,8

ILNEW1 Lafarge Gain Chain, IL 2013

ALNEW1 National CemeRagland, AL 2013

Cost to meet 1.95 lb NOX/ton clinker

Unit NEI ID

Clink

Produ

n 20

( /ty

er 

ctio

08 

yr) Kiln Type

Base

NO

(lb/

clink

line 

X 

ton 

er)

B

N

aseline

OX (ton )

Rem

effi

requ

mee

lb NO

clink

oval 

ciency 

ired to 

t 1.95 

X/ton

er (%) 

 SNCR

($)

 TCI SCR TCI

($)

 SNCR

($)

 TAC 

)

SCR TA

($)

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,625.00 22 2,288,000 0 663,000 

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,375.00 22 3,344,000 0 969,000 AZNEW3 1,100,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,375.00 22 1,936,000 0 561,000 

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,125.00 22 1,584,000 0 459,000 

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,282.50 22 3,213,760 0 931,260 

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,530.00 22 2,154,240 0 624,240 

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,875.00 22 4,048,000 0 1,173,000 

13,187.50 18,568,000 0 5,380,500 

Cost to meet 1.5 lb NOX/ton clinker

Unit NEI ID

Clink

Produ

n 20

(t/yr)

er 

ctio

08 

Kiln Type

Base

NO

(lb/

clinker)

line 

X 

ton B

NOX (ton)

aseline

Rem

effi

requ

mee

NO

clinker (%)

oval 

ciency 

ired to 

t 1.5 lb

X/ton SNCR

($)

 TCI SCR TCI

($)

 SNCR

($)

 TAC SCR TA

($)

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,625.00 40 2,288,000 0 1,313,000 

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,375.00 40 3,344,000 0 1,919,000 AZNEW3 1,100,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,375.00 40 1,936,000 0 1,111,000 
AZNEW3 r 50 1, . 80 0 5,027, 0 2,750,0

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,125.00 40 1,584,000 0 909,000 

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,282.50 40 3,213,760 0 1,844,260 

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,530.00 40 2,154,240 0 1,236,240 

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,875.00 40 4,048,000 0 2,323,000 

13,187.50 18,568,000 0 10,655,500 

Cost to meet 0.5 lb NOX/ton clinker

Unit NEI ID

Clink

Produ

n 20

(t/y

er 

ctio

08 

r) Kiln Type

Base

NO

(lb/

clink

line 

X 

ton 

er)

B

N

aseline

OX (ton)

Rem

effi

requ

mee

NO

clink

oval 

ciency 

ired to 

t 0.5 lb

X/ton 

er (%)

SNCR

($)

 TCI SCR TCI

($)

 SNCR

($

 TAC 

)

SCR TA

($)

ALNEW1 1,300,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,625.00 80 0 5,941,000 0 3,250,0

AZNEW2 1,900,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,375.00 80 0 8,683,000 0 4,750,0AZNEW3 1,100,000 1,100,000 Precalciner ecalcine 2.50 1,375.00 80 0 5,027,000 0 2,750,0

GANEW1 900,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,125.00 80 0 4,113,000 0 2,250,0

ILNEW1 1,826,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,282.50 80 0 8,344,820 0 4,565,0

INNEW1 1,224,000 Precalciner 2.50 1,530.00 80 0 5,593,680 0 3,060,0

NCNEW1 2,300,000 Precalciner 2.50 2,875.00 80 0 10,511,000 0 5,750,0

13,187.50 48,213,500 0 26,375,0