UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA 

Civil Case Number: /.,•zo-c11·-2.3 q3 8-J.3/3 

ll;vpv [<. Fof'/r//INE 

(Write the full name of the plaintiff) 

JAN 15 2021 

ANGELA E. NOBLE 

CLERK U.S. DIST. CT, 

S. D. OF FLA. • MIAMI 

(Write te full name of the defendant/sin this case) 

5 £Co #Q ,4 /111 1;11/ P el.7 

COMPLAINT UNDER 11lE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT, 42 U.S.C. § 1983 

I. Party Information 

A. Plaintiff: II NJ) y /? Fl}fV1ll::r:;v C: 

vs. 

Address: :?. /6 i.' ff c 0/?/?. ec-/2/?n.J' tt/¥· iJ!ke c.,~ !=t. )l.Jlj"" 

Inmate/Prison No.:._Jl~'fJ.,....:;.8_....1.-tl..::O_~L-y ______ _ 

Year of Birth: / 7 7'8 (Do .IlQ1 include day or month, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P 5.2) 

(Write your name, address and prison/inmate number, if applicable) 

1 L , 1 , oJ.l).IL,!./c,, .. • , , t] e,- , • ~~el ,1{ BJ Defendant: Mr1al{ JV c:..,z ()(+.c,'l,l --2.neMndant: C ,.11tv fLf 11 n a r' 1 lea, /41 '-t. c :c;./i.1I kf 

Official Position: fee~ .,/i Fae. Official Position: A {le& If/, c~ .t.e Cf;'illJ:?hf μ,t!/"t 

Place of Employment: ft.oid/4. Pep'fq__/lt"tiPJ.P_la~e of Emplo~me!1t: -La-:7-, ',Jd.- O<';-. rf: C o,;J,11, 

,J,:J I s. c';,d hov 11 . ~r, ";J.//4.IM- sS eq n ;>l) ' f I z. ().'', (1.:,., ,~11- NIH?. 5 5 q I 

(Write the full_ name of each ~~fendant, 6fficial p~~ition and plac of empl~,Yment. ~ttach a 

separate page 1f you need add1t1onal space for add1t10nal defen . ) 5,., i'fe_ 6 0 C· -:o l '>t'.'.7 I 3⁄4t / ,-h .,;; .f .5 (C' <-•:, (-l .J . 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 1 of 14
C(!tJTIIR.T'ON ~-1- FLO/<I'/)~t.l e.1/J )Ju/fl-. C&.n.e-- CoJ?'/J",'~'f'J<IJ-NCK f'tJPJ't.l0/1(,: 

001</J G'~r.ToL/1,/ 0£/l//J T/ir~• 0..51: COI.O/V) J'otlN PPl!z IT1 ~ ·-· 

JOI/ N,0O/3 '2 FL.OJ<f J)/1 Oe,plf o/1 CoT1P2ed-l~5 tJM'c<t!A-~· 

I f',μz.ry J: r,/b,n,-,,,#-hbn C!.;,nh"ni,11:!'~,,( 

8 -Oe/-e,nd~"'-1:, 

3,F-Rll/VC If P,l?fft.LOl't, /1,0,,✓ Ce.rr/2.,A,ary ::Cn,1,,,r , 1/4~1 e¥~'o/ 

/'f(JCJO 5, W °3777 " st ,r-l(),;l_lp/~ C/ty.; /Z, 330:3~ 

'I) OOR/-1 G'/9XI OL /t l"l 0~ Cen-fv,-,.,'qn./ :Zn~1'p,~~/ ~e1p~1'1J,-

/'}OOO 5W 377-t-Jt5/ FLor2,d,1:- C,~ FL 33O3q_; 

;)Df'N/1 r/17' E #.f/4 eE/Zlrt/~llfV ,::rn,:/lv-,~LP.et.l ci~~;Yy 

/'lCJr;Jt:il !('Id/ 37?,.,,,gf- fla,12.,;,/.L C-,J1 FL 330341 

6) .J(}.f'/,: C. _(}La~ l.l'dLfl,t/tl-✓ F,£¥;, :CnA1v,vP~/ IIU-id l}./¥1,'c,,,~( c:y.,,ee,,ly 

1,o~(i sw .:J??-1-i ,r F~,YL-~~ Ft.. sJo::J£/ 

7) '10h11 Doe JP~ _/J FPC C~<NZe?--h c~I 11/JP,'c.€~ (c.~J JC,,,e,l1~,W11.trl et.n~I (J#,~~l e"r~;, 

/90'70 5.w, ..3?7--r'15r, ELr;,~'e,/4- e..,_ry, FL 33r,;-:,4~' •;. 

'The FOC /.s Rdv::>1'::J-hlpn.-0,-,;{/e ,i1v~~e£-HV'e ~~<?nn-//4f,/II o/,'scr;;,1/e~ 

tJi.--+- vv/2 ,}:;/2 _?o,,'/1-1- +he. /V.i.J'ne c,:1,n ,be ~vd/·e/, /4- #,e Co lone I~ -1-

.0~ C.?7" .R~~e/-ro ~Vt~ /JA..MTG'~ arz cJ.-lloi.v .,eett-,.,,~~s- p,;, J) e/Pf-c;, -/-he /nve.$'%d~l0fl-1-he JZ.€-/J'--".n..1-., _ 

'8) J(:11//1 Pr-?e #~ ,4 rPC e,o. :r;,c,11v,/veL-I' {7~~,fy <,t.,,J(JP/!;'ct,#,/. 1 

~9dt:Jt:J S w. 3??-1--" ef. F°Lod?/L~ e, 'ly1FL 3303 Cf 

5JU11t1 &1.6 w1Ht Jqhn /;J,-;e ~ I i/r7f. 'H t/,,<:¥1/1~ f:J~,l,1~ r F..PC ;Y C.Lrflfnpi-

.ge-1---fhe p.Ltne9 ~~ -/he co/o>,1e/ ~--/- P~ -tvat,le/ n.:7-1-~>"'11⁄4 t-he 

f'e,lrne s t?s:12- _12~ 

/-ltl P ~. 'e.7 / n +>, e ,k o #,'cePI c dlc:Pdl-,C /~ w.e/2-e u n d,e.,z 'f-h e 

co/01z <71 Lt:4¥' 1',, +he.,/2. /2~.tpeefe'.e. j'oh.~, 

1r. e~~,'.:J +O,n. Jt,1J?I$ tl,cf,CJr/ 

1t1h1s Cr7v1z;l-htP~Jvrz.lst/.,'c-f-,'on v17/e,,z., -z.g 1,1:,c/,9/J)~l33?tkn-/l3C/3,. 

.e,)?1,e Fe/-e,z,p,,/ Clet.1'r11s t11-a€. ~ yaed,'c·J-+e/ ~r;n q.2_ vs-c. lft983~ IC/88' 

ro.n_ 1,A/:,/t(.,/.-,bn.5 ~1 +he gHt ~npl /~/Jmendtn-e-r,r tl...f:- cons:I. ',vl,'on · 

J) C. lt1-lt115" ~e. CJV~ed e,pan /Jrn~,'c~vts w, '-1-'1 /?•~~.,t..b,'/,1,/.,,'e.5 /kf-. ~).}//) 

'IZ.ll~C # /l..1'5~ /Z/3L..1 IZ/33 μ1d f5'c7'1 o-fl.+ne. ,eehd-h, 11,~f-,'47>1 ,11-Cf-U..?~} 

'l)'Per1/~.4q~ :Tva,'s e,/, ~~ ~n l~iJ??kn el'I fetl J,J~1$dlci/c} h _, 

Z.'l //Sc /:Jc? ~j ,•1:5 ,cz,,_, 5N.~ §'I/I"', I/II C,i.,, 'I ;lch'nr1.$ ht:9-sed il,/',v1 c/1~~ g/ ef-~er 

5 e e :P tL.f/.e l.l, 

2... 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 2 of 14
.IJC Statement of Claim / 

Briefly describe the facts of your case. Describe how each defendant is involved, names of other 

persons involved, and dates and pl aces. Each claim should be stated in a separately numbered 

paragraph. Please use short and plain staterrents, with separately numbered paragraphs indicating 

why the relief requested should be granted. Do not idude legal arguments or cite cases or statutes. 

Attach additional pageJ, if necessary. , / 

I) TA~ Pl~,'t,l,-,'+11- pn., 't:eLrLi D4414 cca; an o-r/z.11/L'l, 

s) l/2e ;.?/4!-,nf# 15 dls~bvt#-fl~ 'V5e.:,- d-:·. w~~elchee,/l{"4-/c) 

1-e Jmv'4! of1/2-0i/rl-d.Loe ../z;, r,/L -fft21a.&/ 1:, I ~.rl- V t1-:t7/ /VM-v~ v7 

e~meoi/4&zve /4me;te: /o +h~ m,Y ~ lbwc;a 

hoi't Ju,,,tf mu5ek --fl?~/inf ,~ +he ;v/2ak bc:flc. Ii 

°7/2,$ ~dl-:{(.$<?2 ~ev~ P4'.-,h ,;, fhe b~ p/m,'vn J 

)?e / v, !&;__yw, h pen 14, -fez:/, 'c /:,:;; /11), £ dU-1 /ley:c. conl-.',,,d 

~ Relief Requested C. I J-t',,, I 

Briefly state what you are requesting from the Court (what do you want the Court to do). Do not 

include legal arguments or cite cases or statutes. Attach additional pages, if necessary. 

:?tl !kc/4&!j 1<,I,_· e./1 ,d,.t,-1-, y the FZ>c Uak ?,11e ~ ~Jtwi,( 

C~e r11YA,bt?,; +b&ovo/z -lhe,a. me/21,:,;,a (paav«~? /2,,1v1t, C, 

be~a Gavelk,d 2/o«5ch.e(-t-b4UZ&/2 +/Je1/a. de@r-n,e,,ri:, 

. 1'c,L l¥n.-&:zce +e --!he p&1h+/M 2erz.1~p tttehc41 

f)e edr: fu<a< nt2Ll ,.. mec/2c£ ( J<--:ed.£t:P2 s; /7n/-lhJ.-~ 

Ft:1#2r1/! 1bnJ [L42zrrbidy t:Anefo/:i...fe -~ tbC:. on~$~ 

'>3 :f ',//nf.',/-1 ve 8 e hli(l tjdr'n d'-:7'-n cA d/.tJ ti C -M4.,ion 

C()n nl/ed On 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 3 of 14
ll c/ v ll- /7 .rz ,:,,Lr:- cl· 'v e .s e,,z_ v, 'c e 7 !61CfF /Jecl~l@J J2.elle-f11J tJ-vfh41.nt'z.ec;r/ ~ Z."R vse./ Z.2()/-- 2202. ~eJI Fed 12. 

Ct' V _r 5"i dl,hpl /I?.) und-l,1e J2e/r·1e/1 1'.s tJL.vfi,(P~ ,~d ~ rea',1? c.rt/ f~ ~&~ 

6. llenve ts ~,e;,z /n H1,,~ CQl./;z:/-pc,,fl_$V,,,l2-nT-fo 2.8 i/5Cef' /.391 

7 #// Cond,1⁄2bn.,· vnd~-z.+he /~R/9-A.,ILll"e be.e'-$ s..e.:l-,~,~~la,zw~; ept; 

ffe ff/IT£ /VI£ /VT CJ F Cf /1:T Pl CQni-,'r1v-evl huirl\ 

I/- o/17 e /?Ip!...,1⁄2 --f /.f_f /, .I'~ D•e:~ n of, ~._91?:JIP.5 ✓ ,,,Pq2.., d,n._ l-o dl.#2, v-4 dL "I- .,0 L~ C~ • 

,.;t-J-i Pa!_y - /J/ewzor;P/J~, .f MA:f /)d!,e/1 sch,dv/d ~ see -f-/,?.t!!' '1/~v,n.e,~/JJ-/' 

l'tll,h - /YI JLr1t!:7 rne;r!;; t9-l'td w d7.S be '!!;j _JJaZO P .Ve u t,,V 1#-h TeJA.R.--/-o I t-o 

-f'fl-te",:c/- -f-he /1/eav~ ,_}.Jc;(l ,'r-, " 

§) ?be :P~1⁄2 /Mdl-1',~,ne/lr .5~J..-~ ~ ~ ~ :$"tR(!f ~_y fl;) ~CJvt,~e- dl-

..5JJ10/2.I c-a/u:;/ 9'hmvl&~ /lbn..(/7£-/n ~e~-eP1-r.... 

d)t0..,0 P7£n~,,ne/i/--,<'~μf-h~ J#-~~d -fo _.P"'2£7Y1~ ~ tE/11..S vn1 1-I-

, ~- /-he b"'ck ~?A·n-:1".,. 

1) /'JIA-1::,/,:£.t'nfl/+1 ~ P·R. P'!''n<o an /01~~/111, cLf- .fh ls "-t?pa,'r,f-n,1e;,+./~ 

I-he R~11t, l-l# JI.. .sk e~ ~llf" &-v Con::rvf P' /J4 ,;1z._. f'//evai:Jl'~y 1-h ~-f- h~ tbe--ten 

o~cleaec/ tt-f- /7,~ ,P.:/l.im ,',,,,~,f./,,/,'-r'Qn, p,,~ .AhC' /'uf lr1 -&.n. d.- 11-et,V' 

/, z 

oon::;-v '.f- be.c&Lv::Je --fhr!:!. p,n.lc»2. t;Jne l,v~ 111'/~zn..d,~e r,.R-e~,m~,tr J?/.Rn1 ' 

(}n"' p) ~ Cerr/udz,flln, Pi11...1_1h. /J/fe~l;L l?,/J;R-/{JA-J:1/.L,ln~ ~~/ ~ Cr:J.r~l,ve, 

fr) JJ,,e -to Certfv.n-,~n ~ vs·e a .,a 1/l/f/,'z.#,'o 1 /11e{,.r1°'& rnr?1·tr U1Tl7.J f-1-1e-

?I.A..,,,,.,-/-.,'#! IJ ~G /1~ ~ee,1 HJe II«euA-4 5 /::,?'; JV'q.12 ~~ r/7ht:?/2 j?. rP~e~wr e,1-f--

1) II~ 1- ,.Oew ;r1t:14H1.> ,1--nd p7 ,,/hl)'-7/e. ~e !9 "t_k (:",d I& ~#./;j.£, 1.n ; 

°lk f 1~,'n-1-~ (j::' f,, led m ~1/ ,._J1ale,.-1Z11c-~ ,s, /9.ba vi-/JO_ f-tf?. e.,ll~a, e,; A_ 

JqJ Pvt?Zt:J -fh G.- +t'fl'J e ~+-'P&-de +he Plett,'n~ -&~t-.?/ w#5 sT~a,/ 

-3 f-,1⁄2,-,, ~$, "l/1<!!' /H"/ -/-/me /7/?. .P~///t?/1 J?e1Jv.$e:/ 1'Q fl<t:/1t!?e,V I'-/--~"1~ 

~eul.$~1'.becl /('~<Ab,,, ~ ,c/2 c/,~ r7c,7 W,.pc12#+iudz f-lie l?ev.12.17~1&,( 

,P~1'r1 .H,e ry,2J!l.--1-c,/ w-~ pJU7v,b/,~ 6'~/ne ..;.2elvef ~2, 

;t) ~e 7iY~,A.:/v/ w~ s~~c/ b~ct:Lr~e o-P secv£1~ na-1- W,,;L,n/-/_"!;j 

pe~e -k:::> 1-~ke rt.r;- /f/rz/--c/ve -/i7 ,ne~cdll /<-t?£.7liP/t51 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 4 of 14
P1e.d,•~e1 I -f'<~~ e-,,-f-el$e .v/,-erze wy o/t'd .Y(;I v cu1YY1e h~,. 

Bal-A ~ 1/bJ'e cf.. 'v,,e_ knQWlet,e, "'~ he!- h.£,I ,pe4scyz./b~ pdLm m.d/le-A../nn, 

eJ.r,d. <2Ju~cft.,..Ve de //J;,~ 1~ ol~e,,,ee when l,e. -2.e#v..se/ /'-o 

p;u:Jr,~ ~ r;f-h-e,,,z. mevr<c~~n ,'»k/4 ·Hl.,,e;-, H'"!P'2"- <?R p,n.ov,~e 

f-h~ CQn:;-~/1- w,Y-h -fhe f?ec1!ee~'f~.,. '7; me~~e ~~1~.J,~ 

J?J.,'n. Wh-en hid f-/re /{-qJpn.fr J tc:/ n#w~, 

13'ParzJL.. 

p~c4Z..lhe/ 

1J,11.JC1bk,. 

=Y 

,,_~,z 

,,., /.,~ m-vlf.iPk ~ l, 

~~11Nhfme411-/s 

w ;/2..:6 ~ 6 

/.e~,~ 

n1~nH,,~ et1-

C!!4Z/.Z-e 

~ -h,z.#~Ji-

~ 

~ w-,1/-J, J 7t~f=- le ~J' effedu:-r/;7tY f1/ .f/9Tl?5 -1-hP- ~o ~), ,~ ~ rhePl-<-1~1 f "¥(} ?.P-i ~1. 

/If) 7he- :P/et., 1nl-rl'ft'-. Ce'-'1n~f#re.. ~111hed-/.t.-c/1,te ro __se;-v_,bv$ r&chohg,"al 

5r1⁄4 ef??ec~/ ~ ,,,¥-dc;es 11~-bz_~i-7,μ'n -1~...-z h/nr cl~ b6- ~ctl?/1 

/-/- /lc,,.z. JL-..zed?/Z p;z_~",o,n. -fo _p,;z.,.f.p/7. /lru,I -1{~.n -, Je,/2.,Z$ ,be.e,1... fez_y~ 

~ Jer lf- 7,'J~ e:Ps" dl-11, tJ .. flea..3,Jn .ye-I' FJ?C /C&1IJ,i '~ fle:f.1v;,e~ 

1,J,11~ /,~,~ lo _y2e/1,;_se -I-he 9;' ,nhd!/,L~,-H,d p/~lnf.l-{?/Lw,,~· /2,·'n,,1/_y 

el-0 le h, .f6!~ 6"~ b/ .-4 tf:jc:L1',1 . ./lf--1-1, & ~/n-/,,,,-e.,;.T6'~,,"7/.L __ye I& 

eJ.;-1--H,e .P/£111-f.,,L/:I) Sntl~ ,.Yt:?v eUZe ~~~/C -h:> ev~ f-h, ~· 

'r;.(_Ae.$ ,-Pl'- hea- II/ 9S-/11 ~~h ,_..fp/•h <Jh f-h~ 4J-/oa,z /,'he ,,L_..;JYr.,:Y 

pvH;''::7 ~ Cl,/dlfe,_ on +he. y/.,{l,,f.#, "7J,-e/l ~~~ 9he w~l/1 '11'1!,y 

.1 /U}y,,'c/4 IV.>/1:t:JY} ~,I r/1~ Pc?e.-LV~e ~he lll/af- he,;,z. lb~ t£.¥i-/ 

/t- /JCJ Ir; i:; lf!?-,e /2 v a-15 -f-11-en f-h.e.. Pl~, nt-/# '5 ~' 'n e. ·Th , · e:? i.l u,: evl 

+J:,e- j/l<J-ln-f..v,,,e-!- C!'47,~ '1-n~. he ),,p~ 110/A/ /;, e.lrl p/,e,~vl"¢ ~,,,,,,; ,'::!:7 

no.,PdJ./n j2e..llt!I'- fia:o IJ·ev~l'fj"b,,/ p~/rt a_a -~!}' ..P~'';,-,.1 1/nf, '// 

J/Jl4l /:J-)211//7 h!-v--zn~-e,.,/:?t:?Z.cJt,,1l1/~ 30 ,L~ t;1f/-~t,1/.,n/4c~~·,/ISR"O. 

I I) 71-,-e f)r/2.fJY/p'e,z.. Ce fJ+vA- /'Q;n Q f- FL.Qn. 1 ;/.r;... h cfl~ ,Puf- 1 h j~/ek-e ,IL ,pa Irey 

-t,, onj .P1U1"''~e "41 30f/ll.s _,- t?-,41.. ero ~ ~r z.p,~ ,;z... /ey . -fh,e.;ze.. ~y oa_!y /JZ<?rl t/1~ ltr o/5-'f :'fPl,e,, ()n.. ,,, +h't! Ce,;te,- 9-/1 

fJ, t! S v I,;:, he- 1 ,s_o y, If& tt,.~ t:/d ~-5," OA ~ 30 dttfo/ $'Cfj?.17j,-_-l,pn.. '1t7 

~:$', -G'v-e,,n , 'f-L fl...hr;-:1-he,2. p-ea$°c/Z'r)?/.,1n, , .s J/V~~ H'o/ J#~.:,-r-~nuNLe 

/I- w //-11 , h ~h-e f/ ~ ky~ _ 

,., om erz..e ly I e~vt,'':j I-he ._P/-i..1',,-fv'#- ,v-,'/-11 /JO ~edb/Ml!I'/ r&a c4Y:t5 l1,,"e~'k';;· 

,Q ,-~ n1.?/Jf-hs. ,,.·v1;;./1 110 rJr1e-t1i cd!I .,/v ,-/ ,' ~. ·e~-1-,· or,, . 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 5 of 14
ii) ~ tler:,y,':J ,μ:Le.~!$ h f'A-Dpe,z ,r-,dr~~h·'a ~ IL l,t ,ne/;~f ~e,zw·e,e-~ 

if- h~5' C.ee(l(~e d ~he ;--:>/4tl/,,l-/f~+11 ~ lte~,',, pMn >~ ~u~~ 

/~,,u1~.-f.e ,.j? h,..-~ lt?w~ ,Ii~& ~1nee rhe n~v& P'-,mv~.l'l. 

~op// ~l/ovv rhe f'l~1hf~--h;, w-~l/4 J,ri,/ b/,ck :I-he /J~ :,., S'&~/4. 

/'I) 'Tn£ r£t1f.j' vn,1/- 'v'o,,I/ he{p f-h-e ~,IU!A :f~~/J,r,~, '71,e. P/,ill!-/?-1-f.,z..?+levevt 

o~~~ 1-;Q p;zov,~ h,} PI/Vf/1 /ev.-be, /lf-(Jne p:7/~+<1-- C'e11~..11,?.-,, 

£Jach:?n Og2.cfeA ep,£ fr tl.¥1# c~11fv.a.,?.?n n~e,z., ,)q/2.0Y'Ud',. ¥,, 

20) 012 /':)tl-Pi'/IPn μi,{ L/4.0~bl...t.. ll-+--.P-ll-t'/n,e_s /le1.//<!:~ 1-o -t2K&.;n,'n f-t, ~ 

rl tJ1..1'r!fvl1!Z, b~/.{ .oe4ell-V:1e-rh7 ..-'n~11f,'pn.Jty- ce/lvse/-n:.o ~~,~~ 

~e /~_,ve. 

"1../}l?eny,~ A'1~dr~I e4L,tz.~T" -m~~"7':Y o,~,'///--,fey ,~ e/e-,-y,9y ,-,,,~ 

+lie! ,erU11w~- c,/1 J;,IU?Pe'4,- r>t~t:/,1::<i/ C',1/2-e, "The.,,e.e o/ .£)/~cp,hfJ~~~ 

~ ~ ~ e /1f.7 /7 - d/~.ll.b k~/ -e..dt-'/rl:,, ~ e J~"7.0 v ,~/ ~~ <:fP~ ,,,,, e ~ {-:,/l / 

-,In e, .IZ,,-+-n,,e /1-,'--, 

t.'Z) '-!,y S1otPp 1 ~ m ~/,1~-l1"~n .1-J,.,_+- w,'~ fizedr±!:, ,'--/?le~ r'cJI ~41.17~~ 'Q,:, 

+htl!:rC'!dlo,e~ 11!.Y ol,'s"1h//,:/y '7he: fYμ~/2,.l~ c!.rR11n<lf-.s,,¥-~:5 lp'!7 

.Lr1 ti h Jt:-s Th I~ t/o M-7 r11 veh 1r7~le p/e,ti ~ p.1L1h, "l/2 e,2, by 

-l'u,n.:fhoz p//5Jl,€} //~ /1'1e, /3ectfl.V-'e- 5e:~V~ ,~ p/qt!!, rJ(??' w~r 

-r~/ J:::J~v,J/ed, {£;,,-en-H,,;,!::J/, I-he 1-=>/t:Jl.1 'n-1-,!.f/? onjJ,, ~t;,:/-t?n-te 

t:1t-r a!- h 'me ."->1d heLel 6/ap,::/ h,~r----h:;, c:J1~ck -Htc:- /ev-e6 l"o 

/n~t/~c::. h.c IV~ ..J-.,..,4,0 1 !1-

2,3) :C-r- IS cemv.n,hn s Pol,'c_y +t11 a'~/~ 4-vur' c/-e:;y ,,,., ec/1 r,;«,/ Qc4ne ~1~ '-'~e~ 

r/n/~J:JcJ?.-,1::/ ~1" o,/e.,,z -u/q,PH~~ oloc~Pf -/-Q 1,~(Plemedr /-l7-e~,e_ 

~ I ,'r: e ? -1-he.,z ~ iJ _y _p,,zo ,, W, ":!J $ (.J,b5 -h n~ c. ;,.e,;:z e. ,. rr:;,.,;112. h n c:, w rt 

~ .5e~/o.,., med1'cflll-/ ne~- %.9 +l,-en 12~..,dvd,e h ~ 

&>i,'.fc,'pl, 1r1e me,l,cttJI ..#'~-flq,n f-,e,..k,,~ wee/<9 -/7:J p,,e~r;Vwr. A~•f\f.,pG, 

"-,p/Jt?i'Y,l--rn ~n-1-s, 0.12 u!J'e vn~c,pn/ me,l,'e.-.t/ /te~;-2,n,h~h/;;,;,-1$ -i-t:? 

✓,,,~,.,,,,,,,,_ +Lnt.ae ~ 114e/,rr.,fl,.r ~,,;z,e:, 

'l-.'I) ~~ ::Cnch Ji-:$ .sec/2,efo/ ,rfl rt.an,~eL P¢1--teP c~ 1-fnCJIA/ s of Ce,/111,,zhn; 

,::t?l/ce~, Lr,,./,.!f- ,~ un;;/~h,'s- w~lt ,'s whe,,, C.enit,,a/9n 1-:Jcrl-,h 

plue. f-h" J'J<J/,'c_y "fl-/,',,,,,'-/-.~ IV.S/lf'O.$.- /1,-J/ I,~~ k,'/d -1-(;7 caA,2edt-he /,,R.C/4 a-11- e~, '1e.-uz.- ~ /enl':!;j r.1ee.t/e,/ _?e.,z1,Nb.~ ./-a, J?/:,d7/~I 

,~me;llk::>, /}$ .. ~,, ~~y,,wl- a/Lt-he ~+e. 

6 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 6 of 14
z~l IJ~clfltn.4' 1:!J tz, mv/f-,d'/e mt!";/,"4Lf pr.zav,1/4F-z s'° "64:,~· /9,J~/11'.Pi e14,,./ 

?,/1,~) Cenn,,p/qn l'1Q IQ'(j,e~z.._ ~ov,Ves ~,:;, f-e;, tf'dl/;1 /1?.P14::,PP1$7/'-

tla~z:?, 'rh/~ h~.s b~ ~ HJe ;:'/.-L1~I/# J-r-s ,.1⁄2~n,-ta77~" 

t211e he,.~ L.L/ce .iu#ka. ~/1'1~ ~ C1cec~f,t""'" llnp( /l'le#,,c,.,1./ e,en/-,;,e.)~ 

?1,e f"l.d- J.J<?Pr q_,/1 Caa.a hq~,~I, /ls -fhe i~/~ ,~rfl# h~? Peen ,~d<PFt!III' 

w/fh .c,1,s~/J~ ne.ave! ?~;, W Altc.4 ;r,~;, --1-n I'$ ,,~ i~~~,~ .,, 

j'j,Ra f/ ,~re._ 7f-n..,~-fm e-,r w,'fh ..i:J~/27 ~ /r,d ~~--e"> ~e , /l k r11:11vn 

/~~ve μ1J( e,h~$"1t::, ri(Jd' -fzp J::);A;Jv11⁄4 I-R-1.,,.:15nel'lj.rh.no~ A com -7d?."!,j' 

,F<?I l'c e 5',, 

'2.fJ) % ~- LJ..ef tll-;1°/"tPJh-/me,,ff--1P,¥/1 _JOeA./r, m.#?~m'f1'4/-#e:P~· /n Z.Cl I~ ,-.:/-

tvl, lc./11 _po,1⁄2/-+},e Po1,1n m~~,n~,r ~a q~/ ~ /11~ o/'he.. 

mehce€( ,Z)~fme-,,-ra",s;,/'•-e/-l-he lljflr /YJ J?-:J: ~~~ ~ --I-he h'~~e 

ln yr?i'/l :![prhe.. e..~,n,,1-<.fc? ,1⁄2 -I-lie ;rf~, 

t.)) /?fl~ l??turtfh!!S ofJ-~;z/er,d!,J/lcre~_ ~u:I ..5,~A- adl//:,:- f-he J.:,/d',1n~# 

,ve,,,r ~ ~ /411c ~.-,z, ~-e. Mi"<.£,, -:'' l ·. 

ti) j/rie4/Z...J-hc /11J2:C" P11Jlll,};/l. ~·~~,l:P~ ~~-dl-r~/ C~,.z,~., i-h:nt?~ 

/-1-s .,,P'Ol,ty h~ -I{,,£, 'led 7'z:> C'o/Jhnvt:! w/rh ..s~eC'/d-1,~ C!d,Z~,. /J/2 

.f'A'n m.,_,,,.,{:yl?'}t!?,r-, .IA-~ h~lr'L ,e.c/v4'i_7 .f~ed n?e~:C.tJL.~r'Qn 

-f-(ul. n~/> -m ~elleJ ( )? edl 5,:1u1,F,. 

-a.q) t'{.vetf j:J11"2.t:Jkrf-;~7 n .R~(tV,1⁄2,~ JLII /r1rneL-l-e~ be _p.n.Ql','p''#!',/ ,v,#-h ~ 

ef,vdf m (? /,·e-~ f ,/-,n ~,,e,Lp-r-e,1T. W/2-e //I -rhe p,-1ed/'c,I'/ j//47 P", ve.,.,-z_ 

/~ fl lfvse -A=, Tn--e~.f- t£_ &//..}p!b/ 1⁄4 7 , Y- /:; ,', s-c,7, :,,,_,, 4,,L-/; b h -ll.n.Q/J't 

·rh e _5~y/c e:, a -,4- -I-he A?(?/, 'c~ / d~..-"'2 ~n e,f·~. 

101 G~.,'.;;,lee_; ciYJ.-111 p,s,.._p//1,:,_n /2~Ve eJ.&'t? ,fle~~e/ ~ ./::,,.,zoy,We 

-1-.n ,~~rn-en~ ~)Q?.1t1J t/r'scv~e. +he lv'v,, ,'E,5 s u~-6t,1r1e///1 c-u.,lrn 

i.. +h~ H/~e. ~P~r-t,'nl:!',I ~r- >-- mt!!l/,-40-~/ <i!_,.,,1-e.vre~~ cy -1v/2en .6~t-

-1r, μ-, Q~/:/e hc?;f;1J11⁄2:el 141~1- /Jc.1r12--fl1-r!";Z ~..,~~-k,/ -1-JJe /J-e/Z-Ve ~/l~e 

tl!nA e tP--c/:!)evl /~/ t,ta _y -r-o -J-he P/4:t., 'n -h t../.1} 7&Y~"" 'l/1, /~ Hle 

,'fl-- /-J-,:s .(j n<;P~ ,'+-ol,:::,I n~ hd7,Ppe:-n ~,,n (I+ ,ne.e,l;,dl'-1, 

'30 ~ °i""'h~~e /i-~ve ~cLtBe¢'1-he Plct,'nf,'# 5~p~z-e_pot.,'1.31pftyc1 ;,e I 

~z ,~~n~ me,rl-.t.i tl.JJ!,J v 1'5 ;,/ lu5.,1 c,f1 tinJ10y m €11f-t:2"4 f,'-f1.s , r',,c,12.4Z4'~e~ 

c/,~,.,t_J.;u1⁄4,j,. r./"'J..Otn n.e:/!v.$~ -/?;J fin.e~ a','f.yn41~6f:/ ,ne/r'e::~f a~n~M~n~ 

Ja!. Jl./uX ~ov,Ve ~efffe ~en, ~ec,1~/ fr~ fi!#-eJJJ ,rz~vr,b/e 

ra..~tt£--fM -erlf:-

j? ";_;le a jf-d,l,f--S 1<.-e-l~'e 1-.fl-(J)~ c-1 eJl./M I. 

7 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 7 of 14
i\lr-n cl di-~ a..P CeV/-1-u~lbn.} ..Pu-iv11-e ptftOv,'/~5' +IPl~OvrW~ t;?-Me-fNe 

p..-ll/n ~~/1'1 +>l'i-!;- .:?~11f-+h~ ~h:e /,11-,/# /J,1Lck fr? ~e£-fn ,n.,,1242...yrnenrJ-Md 1-c> ;anov,~ f-hr:: 1-G1V5 μ,,/ 5/''h.P a~f'U( ;?/,,1,n//-/4£t1Pa -16JA. 

):JpLCk pcLl'r1 ~hd) ,5'~~/,n$'. /1,1pl~r1~ Ma~l,'cee,.f-1tcrn I/on -f-he 

pd. t1 a /4 II b .J1..<k ~~~ r,;,,, ?r 

?Jl)l::)1'-12,/1/Qa -10172.. JJ.-e_ ,~ e:/',/,~~j, ,:.,~,~e,r1-I--+, +he P/,1t.-/nf1/lf!cf 

.5~--z.,~v5 ol14:111a7?~/ ne@~5 C'.oe;~ ,b vnBct?~7 d,3/ /4/~ /g'"OCl. ooCJ.~ 

ComJ~Yl,?,:~---ho~ tfLrr~ .,f 4 F<Je O(j}t8 ./Jvn/rr/,,-e ,/?bY(,Ye3⁄4/10m/~/ tllMle,-R~ 

3 S-/6',g¥t_9/4= -l't?a .be,'~ /el,~~ i'nc/4 -.fk,,,,,f-f-o ,rJJe .?/4e/17fl .,L~ 

5 e.,,z /ov.JJ, ,,he1~ed' /1?~//cd /'?&e/4 ~ ~1 1:5 Jl,-;/ c:/4,,,,, '-:1_7 ~/42e 

/.-l'~(/1~ ./-)1eylt:1!.,',, /, ',¥!-w 5ttf¥1~ i1~te6"~7, h .:f'~'e.,zet' ~,.;,,., 

,~-~) {?(~0 cornpr2,Jp,L~.Y dA-YU,( /fo f'CJtf/ I/a? /7Plll1⁄21v€ c/μn'19-e~,,,. 

~~ r10,1-1 /~eR,/ deL,,rt~f:?y,. 

~2:1:&sb::. ..Pt:1n- enAo(f'l-Cr'y tLw/ ~ea#. e, -dn~ ~'tr~ fo C47,:l?,R e~+-~~:; 

·eJ,.nt/ ¢?,71!£,,// ,;,,i c-d!./2~ 1,-:5 f--lte ?-/e.1.-/;l-lt 5~,/',~e, /7.a'ml'r1 t'~dl-1--

,0~ c,:r: .5/Je ;v~~ w,1/1⁄2 :P¥/llon 1v/Jen /;,e rP- e.fl.5.:.e/ /---d ~e1,,,,/;t'e 

J2& ~a-f-'h e,~ -hz-e~ne//J-1;-#/1 ✓ -I'~ 11/e/ f/D _pv 71 ~/2 CJt:/2 cp~ ec-7'-fk e 

/n 5v#t;/c1'cL.uT tned.'ccRI _$,e:.,,z.v-1cf!!'§. -l-h£r- #'~ ~JJ- .S)'~m ,l-;.. IS-f'Ve t.L-f-//~ 

,/zfe {?CJ(i} ~ Cc.?/7~N/?~ ~,f75"""~t:}Q;?ji17/f/l/e a!'d-rn~5' JJ.,u;/ 

/1an, ,h,;€,,,r w/J~e eoflfl7-t!!/1~y IS~ ~/(o;,i,~~

'37) ~,I~ ~ , YeC,/2.,e~ plpd, W£_ .o~r (?~ C'~ e~ A::, 71..7' ~ 4,11, ~ 

1-o /r1.5V.Rt::!- ol,~42-J,levl' el2d'v'lfs μze y?~;,r,{,/,e/ ~(/d/ .ft$r2//, tq.y (? ~ 

ol-dett,vt#-k rneP,'i!.'c:R( .$te,{2.t/1 cl?'9, 'Th&-1-+h~ p/4,1n+, '42 ,:i c;/eM, f.e~ 

~e ,1-o ~ /~ ol, ':f P, 1⁄4!Y bi.d' -fr-~men-I-49 t:Ps 7'o cfJ-C.con? /'J'7c?/4~ 

h,s d /.:,J!!f11/JJ;y whe~ -/-he 7£"11/.5 t<!./J-.rl ~,j:'l'~(C!~ m'mvld-hz 

C!'o 1,1 I el LI Ip vV,? /dt-1 'r, WfP hv IA/ e12/,4r !f'~o/ tff /4nce«F, / SY2CZ, 000 

~?iStl, ~-.~ eQm~erJ ~.,,,t..k;":}1 tL-rz_ Pf .rt foo./ ot?0 /'u r, I 1⁄4I've 

c/~/n-1_5~ /?Om,b~/ w4'Je.,-zep a<Pm~1~76;vz:7 hoi'J--1/r;we-d ~o/4£,L,y 

-fhe ,/lpfi, r4d2. n;;,/ _,EY20v•"'bi,y ..Se,u/,c<e_p ~ d,'5 c-A,/~, 'n~./ on, 

-rr- 57/1-TI: 111 EIVT t?I ct// Z:/YI z. 

3)1) Ctn "olo?/z..q,, rh~ PIJL,'nh# ~ .7el/e,ze-ch~·r,,pe:(lr1n..7 JI-~ h~,~ 

-fnem +'@dZ- 4--i,veek w,!.fli /Jo J<es,pance -1-P ~ s,~,4- c,.t.//, .% t:i.fblfec/ 

.t>a12. e1-- md, ep' -e,11~io/ z.. t-t'm es, . 

-.,9J ;9-f-/.e,z. ,J,-n (;" #6 +-he ,ned,eJl~ c/'lfP~-eRtf- c/u:ltPSc ~ ,-en4 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 8 of 14
17,e P / ell1"1 -JI# ,f-e, Hle El<, a/-

~) 't}fe ~p-.?deR.-+r'on o-{1/ll'cce.rzC-;· •~hr:?H,,-ed t,t? , ;, f-he me/,~.,e,(, 'Jo ✓ 

'b:7.wd°rnen-f- --w /d-f' ./<-e'~r , b <1t'.47dc~ /3~ 8'7o 1/ ;{//~~lu,~ 

cfl..n,r/ sh~ff"IJ!!'s;) on I-he .J -e/2Yv<)ne/2r 

'fl) #-1-h ,<:J f·lme f-h~ P/~1h-h 1/#2- h~t/ rhe ~1~1/./l/!/c~ ~It ,s 

~~bOo/4 ,~ I-he F%1,11Jl~.-wh1e-e/aA~k ('1,v/4..J 

1/.iJ ~ /l/J4. rn ed,~ d Ip erz~.n Hu: n J:JI "1--cec/ ;1-hg _?L.e. r'r17'/ 4· ~..} 1 ;,1 

h-e.,z o/lAbe ,/k,az. ~& h~, 1⁄2, . <l3) n~ P/.#,~lv·# W',:,P~ 1,eAc~ tb The hr?5/7, !/-d'/!7y ~p/4ince4VALJ, 

JJ:-· rPC of/(},~f!"rl. If/Ir"~ ct-- w/Jee/4/4.:R,~ UJ!-'1./lolfow,e5 ~ / H,e,-

e O /-h ./4-+ ,?l.:/ZCec/ ~-he p~...e.-~ /f, fohe th/c:.J . l.f.tiJ /-1+ fhe h 1/11e fo /.e.:12-ve fh,e l~tfO,,fr.~I ~foe- .P/&..,/1:h/~ S'eR.t1~ ~d'1. 

her 17.;;,~ d.-- Wf<::., 7!9 FJ?C ~/le/ 7'.'P &21[;9 r;;,ne, 

1.fJi,,a;J;e -~f1.fp-.;¥z/- a/l{T,ce,A--3 h~J-1-he P/~,~-f;./1/2 f-.rUl~ -4,-:;-Hte 

h'7:y-;r~ ~ _, ~. 'Tli-e/1 IA/f~~ ?4tlly Re~~~1h-Bol" ~;;L,-',1.,, 

bdZo~hr ,f-Q f-tle- w/4 //e:12--n ~The e,al;vse:-/ a2- /2 ,~ 7l:?>"5 

1ndln I,/ vea. -Av 7<e4c-~ ·f,}-i.e JJlell,J,rfv!{l(] 1'(12.0rn f-h e wk. /Cl /-be. 

,11'~'1 Se.a-,/-, M 1en d...-n.;711-o//s../l-bkt/ ~v/r/;t,'tlvld /117-rb-e 7"Q~fe4' 

~ti lleef clue -h::, fJoe..ll"'tfl.e,/:o efl.Ce.01nm~-fe tJUid t17,zav,Vl!!!!--

ett,vd-/ ....9~",1',e.e~, JJ-vt-d ect,,tr~l~<F~hnen'J', 

1/1) *a,n .,,2..e-fv;:;z.r7 ~+-- t-he- 1 'n;;, h!/2,,,1,1⁄2YI Ct:J .1. IA/en/- ~&I Re/fl,"veq 

~.bl7'2.o.4 t211 iv/Je-ef eli,e..,1⁄2.. rJ, ~ f-he &e:1nr..ft'n..e. ~~em~ ./lei/ Qi/r 

at; OJ""'he PI.L.11⁄2fl# S.12-,'~ H1e Jv,/i, 1.!, f/h.9"~e iv v.se, 

'I?) C,0,1. Jo+ t:a z_ {Joi-,,-, Pae I Juul~ Jcetp~"iJ,J- -fh=Y ,bof-h cJ,n ~ 

on +-he V,Ln d.rJd' i17ldtred vtp fik: P/,,,ir'n..f.,;'(.?/!. JJ_y-1-he §lkll ,e,,,,,e.,;, 

/r1./4e. ~ .Soll.$ r;.P ~:f-L~?) "Y4,1/e ft~'h -11v(!j, /<.~~~/,7ec/ pf.1;i ✓ 

dA..~yed h ,,,,,., tP-cC/20$"' -Hie= I/ ~/1 ~ pl ~nl-n I'm I II --1-11 e. b~-e,i-/ 

i,,VQtet?I C!-h,t1w../ "J/2 ,;5 Wr,vlc:I' F1<i1TA~#·e,1 re:1 d..- nat,-- :rcR_h/~£( 

/nn,£,,+e - ,Al1~~ev.-ell-,n_,ed-~~~;I-, 

t18) I~ Jieloct:Jt-/t ~ f-'}, t:,,. .JJ/eL l,, f..1# f-t,C1ZC?!/IJ'h i4o~ce H,,,,e,r- w/~ 

unnec.,-&;~ Jt.-nd e~~ ~~/~e.J u,'o/,111!,,~/ eet,V~f m~e:a-4e,,,-+;-

"'"-d<b2- +;.,, ~-«/ /qfii /9,rn e,1d 1 /.?no/ w~ pe/4bea.,,e-:Ae ;t,L,ru/,f1t:/~Cft'J'1f.-

-f-c;, fhc- /:Jlet,t,,tf-/.,t/l~ ,nee/re& t:LIU/ /1?.P/r &J-~.carnm~#r·'an 11e.e'1!..7·,. 

/ 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 9 of 14
1/'I) ?ney +-Aen /e#-f-h-e ;P/.t/??~ ,n ~- b?zohen w,6 ~~ 

bel'::J f'lk~ ,.~ ~ l'Jc,n .. ~.DP. ~1s4'/~~bn e.e///JdJdL.tJ('lva. .. w~ 

'71,e p/dl-1'nf/'l!C 411 vtAJ-e/1 +he wJe..-el --4// q,¥!-pf21J,e whe'-bl~,h. 

wh //e he IV~ ~pl,~ ~ n?~e -H,e bu, ~ 13.n.c:n,,,y,J~ r1'e 

.hno.ke,,11 ~ 11.v'/,e,-, rh e, J>l~,,,,N#- /-r,1/d -,'-he $ec:v,z ~ wh-e.,z.,.e Ji,E~ 

¢ v(/.,46 ~--.Od?-:J)/UJ ;,,-, ble dLno-J-J, ~ IA/on.4, ~ $ ~ dev rCi!'. , i 

~/,:tJ~ rP-,1-i-n rh~~e-,~ ~ foe .1,1⁄4"h-h~ ft!,2.1~v~ m~-:ctli/' 

4~ qt,i/ /5 d/:,c~,'m/,,~'t:;,;, o/ f2-"'-t:'.!;f R:,..tJ<cc;nm~4~ 

Jh4. wh~{d,,£,1~ ~ ~~e/o~/.,z et?a-., 

;a) -'?y H-t ~ MlliW'a Co3-"-'~ co 2 m.Lnh.Lr1/rY '-3 +he pl""- -1⁄2-AI# i-' o/ 

lv1,,uz~d +he JJl~,1;,1', t/.:ts f/,t;/d,e.,,u.;,Jrl/~/Zdl2_~ f-h-e e;c,~i,,_~ 

bt!IZ-<'-4'-_ ~e9.,s-,lr,,::;J /'e,p.ve .?~'h.1 /-e5fi~J2./ ,?ell,.h, F)ne ,P&,.-,1,,~s 

-11.tJz/-JJe,,i_ 1'Q_/u,rze/ when 1]19 /lel/t:!Jt..rz//2d!/-rQ C!~ l,,~5 ~/47 

11.7 ~"The. m.e/~~e,1,l/'fP~/11 enf- pn Pl~ PJi,P/lh'!.,, <::r,M;,10/1- ,:,(Ji,~ 

'9~k ,12.~~~~to ~,,,,~ ~ 772.~1-~,,_r-gn. eve,z. ~rt 

€Ke:R..t41.t 

;iJ Jo5e ea/on +I,€. 1/Jv~en h~#ndlW~e tJ-fJ "2--,qf)~~d~v~e ef~e 

tJn dl~/~/ l~(Yl~kJ ,,/h~//1~/~✓ ~t.???/~ -/1-t,»'U,e" Andi 

tl'e4:/-?~-r--e 1h~c,6f1,ze;,1ce /?:,-/-he n~~c/~ ~ t:/,~C/2,.'m,;,~-I; ton 

tl,'R.ed-/y ~11 d/fell.?/ec/ lnm~ 5Pdt ol-5 m~/::7 p1..- b/4/Jd 

/1'1~ ~ o/~ vbwr1 ~fhno-wd-!J r/t's~k/,,,m~*" ~ 

w~J ch~,~., -~ w///p;/1!,y fTIV~ cl&./,»~ ,~ol,~-e 

V5<7:f vhnee/'lt!d 1't,/lce ~n d,~lred' ""'/?m~~_,4,,,/ 4',1e« 

to -Q:;);J¥l ec.,L, J.J-- -

6~.J rrl~e/l- P,~d2.b/1⁄2'j, JYll~ d /Zt2a,,b/~ h .Pg ),ee;-, ,1⁄2 fu 111-

~d .5e-#ld ~P-/ld.t'IPae ~ ~nVe ftedfl~rn aL-b/e. ~~mJ7'.1"~/4,,!J 

tVh~e -t-he (/.7· £)~ oAJv:;-7'-v'ce. J.:;f+e,11 p/..ed fi;1 .,_p'e/-mqn~:/2ir/. 

/(/l,,rnf::7ce~ a'tJe ~ rPC -1'2~11/1~ -k, ~~H»noc/~-h:2 . It- 5,ill-h11e~fw~ J'<eJJ.-clt e-', 

;-1 r P_C u n ~~:::(ncit +lvzhtea. n e ~~;ie,?-h Cc;;"?}) 3 lv,trh -fhe.. 

-5 e-"Hte ,n e,;7':- ,e ~A e't W"'heel (!li.,,e,1k r1,:;;,n -,11-Qce $~.r~~ C!e-~ t' ~ 

/71~~, h ,,,.,ulelt~ p/,'.t;£.J,/e/ 1nrn..£.k; whlk Re~l,i~dr 

1'f' /1/ow £?,5e£1,;p, 1/,3/ n_,:_;ft-1:s 1 $'" be/4tk ,',, -#,e .Se-con« J,d/ic~/ c!I~ 

-4> o,:, m~d!HI v~ ~ en-,4;;,.n. c,e_ +-h e ~ ~11-1 en"' 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 10 of 14
•iJH..1 r-»c w-;,, ~ p-2-0v#,::/e.. --fn..~,1r1/,1.:5 +- pA.c1r,-W'e J7t112-qpe.a- -

L ccomm'1d'J.-./rqn ~- 111t,r ti~ I~ lbzt<!.e whea...e, /nJ~., tfl,FZ~ d'U--.:#il. 1'h.:t-,/ 

...,_ nvf- /Jei~ di';, t!YZ,1mJLn/~ ~~ rDC ~,a,v~ 7D he', 

p~,1 ,~ ,.:;.Bta..//1~~ h J,,'::ull~t:/ l9me/2.1bcL-r, ~ -r}un.p~ ~~:JI,~ · 

/nJ'wz -7.J 1r1,R.-h 1 ~ ",,., -tu::te~, ~le- £,I ,,u/ ~ dl.- I μ,v l11_e_.--/-h P~ p_e.,,e,i, 

,'n pl~-ce. 00~ 30 Yedla.~, /l,,JJ/9 ~~ 67:J-r YetJ2,z~ ~ -1-h e /~ 

'f1J ?1, ~ie lt:v#l.£ rz'Y\IZ-/4 I,~~ 12L ,1/ed 7l7 I IYlr:J)l-e,/11-1td-c;i_cct:1rnm a ,I ~/t?) n ~ 

;-,u.,,h,'~Jt-j4nd f--,p /,.,~llt,IU? me/,'asL I ~-G,2,t,,1d::-~ ~ ~1,1~au; f()t=n~ 

ivl?<?e/ohJL,h.$ ~e-- n-,~1⁄2h,i,,,e~ dl-~/ A, s- ~do m7'-/'v'v.ae 

p ,hP7.eL~~ +h,1'241~1, n.:?Ae.dfZ~,:;,,n bur4'1f2-·H1e,k pi,,~, 'l'/~ 

#.# hi?n- d,~~/t-4 /lae w1'- /l?,t,r/ IJ~/kd due -h,, ff~,,.z~:;;_!y 

,lb tf!-CCc:unrn@/~, · 

"ZIJ<e /t'e ..f- CI dL-/"1 2- c. 1 1~ 

n .Jahn /.?,.;,ea..~ J""ahn DCJ.e z.. /1 IOC?;o~P jf,%1/JJ{Jt;;t:~ 

~~ /'.300 OOtD if'1m,1⁄2-~ tJJ2. J:)(P111/n~ wlJeae ~~1:;-.,J,.~ 1 17 

.. no/-tt.,llotv-ed 37,,y,~ tfa1e/ 5~62dll/ ~ P3/ct'JI./ /Vl4-zr~5 

5v~A~~d m~ IJf-r~,;t/~h.77,e,'n tVJd ~~~/ 1"$.5 o/1 ed':)'/'lf' lr­

~ /;!-/le 1'-nd ,h ~~~er;/ /'Y-1Qb//, ~ /tVf?..R /.nme~f- -rPs I-he .9/2@//~ 

~IIJl,(/l.y /2;5 m~e- ,-'t- p~,~#vl-m flf?I/ ~vnd '!_y t;P-J,2..(!?/d;11,W,//1;-

mfi:Jfe- C'olori A~ ~lowd-fhe cc;,nfi,1,l;l,ep/ pAe,t,/2b:e t:2'1 .tlhv.,;e /JI? 

o/,~/Lbl~ ,~mL-hetfl w-h-eae he- ,5 p.ee,vtr~~ by /4'-&V -tr.;, /n:,f,l/2,e,_ 

- .:1-I/ 1~~ &Ln~ Jzv/4,G tUZe #o//ow~"- li!,y~;1.:,-//1y -'lb OOJY2ec.,1f-t,/2 

~.,,t_-/1-../1 --I-he P/,,L1~,i-.lf4 StA.~-ed .?1Yc,!R,f fi!Jf,(,21~.,JJ~,'/1 dn, .9~~; 

mer~ ~ « ,~ 11; /11..:,.5 12 /J +h~ C!P,P,ilCi ~ fbn. Q ,~ t?,Y rY2-~,f o-12 I, 'fl,e, 

/lc:1~ t:?70~ c1qp-er1~/ ,ILrut'/so~ 000 pv,111/-l ..... t!-./ 

norn /n~l wh-en,e,<P/An/ht;-e.. , s 11(1-r- tfl--v~I /,,,e,h/e , 

60J ::Crtc h /L-5 .seea~y -~ '7 /~ ,_ ~~~/.7'-he iP~~e ,7j1'1:J-j- (!!_ Odl.62... -e cfr":;5 --rf)e_ k I, ~ce-?..e:Ae I 'n ~r~~;z.,eH Ce 't,l..,u/ p;l.<?J,lrltfe 

ez_vell--( Je/Z-r"tb?!;, ~~A ~co,rnrr?.?,p(~?'Yon~ -HJ~e m~,'lrl.1./4d 

heP-:5 /qJua~/ w,'rl, .JJl1..._ye,~/ )/ijlva.1~~✓ m~u,kl ~vl~~i1 hs.s o.../2-

C~c, ~ -12oa.--/h<: .e1:v'cym er1t-# lh~, 7cLt1/I tU-J/ ~ ~ ~ ou-w:P-k.JVL 

t?-/1 "-<c~~~ ,2€/h,,~ (;?rn~-"%_ med~~/bey.,/J,f{/ t/,~~1m/n~D;1Jt 

tOOt:3l)CJ~JIIC<:Jmpen~~ ~I?:)~ 0~ ~n/--hve. /_,e,,,,,1:f~/~ 

pom, hu t,vt/J~- ~)~ ,;- /,'r,, ,'fdl b7 /4(,,1,r, 1//()l#r'!:!) +he f 4fh/?nt!4::I 

II 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 11 of 14
Are you demanding a jury trial? ves No 

/ /J--1-h J-. I Signed this_-:.__,~..__ __ day of t:flr11/d{o/, 20~ 

~/;;.~- Signature of Plaintiff 

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is truce and correct. 

Executed on: / 0 ~h 4 oil: J IMV~ 2 n I 

#~ Signature of Plaintiff 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 12 of 14
---'-~-----'--------

_____ , 

----·-··--- ' --------------

- /J,vl, FanlYJ.lne- 148</CIC.i 

eotvm /J,1£._. C:.on~ed-t~I ;:t:;71#...d-xoYJ #n,,, 0 /C M

_f..tb E. C..0,12Jzech 'on 5 hr tfl-_;J: 

lJ--he wfy,Fl- 3z92s-

__ ,. ., 

-"'-,_ 

t_ .., ,/ ;, . ~-~'·:~ 

"It "" -' c:, . ~,, ~---7 4' '~ ,.:;; "- ' .... 

''"~l~lt,i ", , 

~---,,; 

<fo-

.,.---____ ..._ 

;_.

.,.------.__ 

-

...---...

-

JA~lfU£

TUE 11 J.M

--~

-~-

~

Vn lf-e) jf-J:fet1 J}/~d-U/v,1

Jt;;11/l,e;zll 7Jl5T Flo12,'/a-I !J,~

lf Oo ,V, fYI, ',J.m i' fl ve-

/11 ,°J.-111 /-l 3 JI z_ -g - 7c /a 

' 

f 

.~L 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 13 
., . 

' . l, 

.. 

Case 1:20-cv-23438-BB Document 17 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/15/2021 Page 14 of 14