|

Detainees

Positive

Responses 1. .

W
SUMMARY OF JUSTIFICATION CATEGORIES

CODED CATEGO ares INFORMATIONWITHHELI! S f I

Category

' l

INFORlV_1ATION_ ig

Category. b!! " AGENCY PERSONNEL RULES AND PRACTICES

 b!!-1 Internal FBITelephoneNumbers. '

Category h!!

. b!!-1.

CLEARLY UNWARRANTED INVASION OF

PERSONAL PRIVACY ' '

Names of FBI SpecialAgentsandSupportPersonnel. --

tb3>1»

. b!!-2

-3

PersonalInfolmation of FBI SpecialAgentsandSupport

Personnel,IncludingDates of EntranceonDutywiththeFBI

and Other Work-Related Personal Information.

Names of Employees of OtherGovernment Agencies, Including

Contract Employees. '

1

l

 b|!-4 NamesandIdentifyingInformation of ForeignDetainees,_

IncludingDOD DetaineeIdenticationNumbers.

tb!I|-5

Investigative Interest totheFBI.- . _ ' '

NamesandIdentifyingInfonnation of Individualswhoare of

iIb!I>-6 ~ Names of IndividualswhoareMerelyMentionedinFBI

InvestigativeRecords.

C*".°g°I'.Y b!! C! UNVVARRANTEDINVASION OF PERSONAL PRIVACY

1 l1!_! C!-1 Names of FBISpecialAgentsandSupportPersoimel. 

 l1!! C!-2 I

PersonalInformation of FBI SpecialAgentsandSupport

Personnel,IncludingDates of EntranceonDutywiththeFBI

and Other Work-Related Personal Information.

. |1!!lIC!-3 Names of Employees of OtherGovernmentAgencies,Including

ContractEmployees. _ '

 b!IIlIC!-4 NamesandIdentifyingInformation of ForeignDetainees,

IncludingDODDetaineeIdenticationNumbers. l _

 b!lHfC!-5 NamesandIdentifyingInformation of Individualswho are of

Investigative Interest tothe'FBI. - .

 b! IHIC!-6

tI11Ys§tigs1i:¢l%@s<>rd§- _ - " I

Namesoflndividuals whoareMalayMentioned in FBI
. T

CDDED CATEGORIES ATION VVITHI-IE -' -

"7 T71

r11wi1fgRM _ LD __ _

coNFl1JENT1AL soURci: MHAFTERIAL

 b!! D!-1

Tateeolw with! t __

Category b!! F! . i

Names and Identifying Information of Foreign Detainees who _

were Interviewed and Provided Infomiation to the FBI under

Implied Assurances of Condentiality.

ENDANGER LIFE UR PHYSICAL SAFETY OF ANY

.-INDIVIDUAL - -

i anmw!-1

Names and Identifying Information of ForeignDetainees who

were Interviewed and Provided Information to the FBI, the

Disclosure of Which Could Reasonably be Expected to

Endanger the Lives or Physical Safety of These Detainees of

Their Family Members. i i ' W '

I
. ' 1' '

& General

Information

' :
w-._ -n F J .

I

|-' - J I I memtnewn_ :D. . Z! ' _

- FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: Peionrrr - . Date: 09/02/2004

. To: Director's Office Attn: DD Bruce J} Gebhardt

From: ~Inspection _ -

- Office of Inspections _ _

Approved By:Gebhardt Bruce J.?Qr

- ' Qaproni_Valerie E. '

Drafted By: . . - b6 1

_ _ _ - _ ,4-I _ b?C-1 Case ID #:2.97.HQ-A132'?6.669-A Pending!; ~ ' _

Title: GTMQ ' _ _ -

' ' COUNTERTERRORI SM DIVI SION CTD] _

INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY I

Synopsis: Request_approval to designate captioned matter as an

- Inspection Division INSD! Special Inquiry. __ - A

-_ Details: Based upon a request from 0GC,_1NSD conducted a survey i

of all Bureau personnel who had served in any capacity at GTMO

since 09/11/2001. This surveys which was disseminated via email,

" requested personnel to advise INSD if they observed any _'

aggressive mistreatment, interrogations or interview techniques

of GTMOdetainees by representatives of any law enforcement,

military or_Bureau personnel which were not consistent with -. or

"Bureau guidelines. Records obtained by CTD determined there were

S32 Bureau employees or contractors who served at GTMOduring '

this time frame._ The survey resulted in identifying nine 

employees who observed such-treatment and they provided short t

"summaries of what they observed; There_were no documented ,

incidents involving any Bureaq personnel. These summaries were

provided to General Counsel Valerie Caproni, who requested these

nine employees be interviewed. ' . ' .

I In order to commencewith the interviews, it is

requested that the Deputy Director designate and approve this

matter as an INSD Special Inquiry. .

1

4

I

|

>-.

RESPONSES1 .
J w 92. . _ .

_ To: Director's Oégace From: Inspection :!

Re; 297-HQ~A13276669-A, 09/02/2004 _

LEADIB!:

Set Lead 1: Action!

DIRECIOR'S OFFIQE

- A'I_DDFO, DC - -

That the request for designation be brought to the

' attention of the Deputy Director.

¢+

Z

% ~ RESPONSES2 .

_
_______-------n-InnunIuIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

1- i F:-',-. - . .

* . ej 7 , I _.

 u" i o - mwnbmem; :> ' gt - 

. 1 ' ,

FEDERAL BUREAU DF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: ROUTINE  _ Date: 09/23/2004

To: Counterterrorism Attn- DAD T. Jw Harrington

General Counsel Attn= Valerie E. Caproni '

' From: 'Inspeetion_ " '*" "'" ~ -  --

- _ Office of ions_ __  i_ '

92 , k Contact: I _ jif b2 ei

Approved By: Thompson, Donald W1 J¥&@ 92 §jfc"f1 GI-5.1111 Robert 137:! - -

Case ID '#: -.'g9_§77'-é.'l:IQ§:j;l_3_-?"!£aé-7ii {Pending}*3_é,

Title: on-10 _ _

' - .- comrrsnrsnnonrsm DIVISION cam!.

INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY . _

' Sknopsis: -Provide results of captioned special inquiry to the

Office of the General Counsel EOGC! for review. - _

_ Enelosure s!: .Enclosed_£or OGC and CTD are the following:

_ Copies of FD~302s reflecting-interview results of the

. below listed FBI personnel. 

, e I _* I I  .

1!

2]

3!

.4! b61

5! , b?C 1

6}

7! --

B! 7 7 7 .77 Q

' 9 .

Details: In July, 2004, OGC requested INSD to conduct an inquiry

into whether FBI personnel had observed any mistreatment or

aggressive behavior of detainees at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba GTMO!.

Based upon this request, on 7X09/2004, INSD sent an email.message

to all FBI personnel who had served in any capacity at GTMO since

U9/ll/2001. The email was detailed as follows:  _ - '

|

¢

' RESPONSES-3

g -

I _ ~= .
1"! - .

To:Counterterroiggm From:'_lnspection :>'

Re: 2'97-HQ-l32'?5669A, 09/2322004

' "You have been identified as having conducted an

assignment at GTMO, Cuba since 09/ll/2001. The Inspection -

Division has been tasked with contacting those employees who have

served in any capacity at GTMOand obtain information regarding

the treatment of detainees. Employees should immediately respond

to the following: " -. -

_ 1! Employees who observed aggressive treatment,

interrogations or interview techniques on GTMOdetainees which

was not consistent with Bureau interview policy/guidelines,

should respond via email for the purpose of a followup interview.

- - 2} Employees who served at GTMD and observed no-'_

aggressive treatment of detainees, should respond via an-EC

documenting a negative response. The'ECshould include the -

employees official Bureau name, title, and tenure of assignment

at err-10; _ .  _ .

I . ' Q

The EC should be titled "GTMO, Counterterrorism ¬ '

Division, Inspection Special Inquiry", file number 297iHQ~

1327669-A. The EC should not be uploaded, but only serialized,

with a hard copy. _ ' ' ' _ _

CTD provided a list containing the identity of all

Bureau personnel and it was determined-493 had served in some

capacity. This list was utilized for the forwarding of the above

described email. _ -

INSD'received 434 responses from Bureau personnel.

Some non-responders included contractors no longer employed by

the FBI and employees who had since retired.y INSD received 26

positive responses from Bureau personnel. The majority of these

employees did not have knowledge of what the "approved" - -

interview/interrogation guidelines were, but wanted to ensure

INSD was aware of a possible incident of mistreatment. .It should

be noted that the 26 employees who responded did not observe any

mistreatment of detainees by FBI personnel._ Any mistreatment

observed or rumored to have occurred, was allegedly conducted by

employees of outside organizations. These 26 employees were

requested to provide a brief synopsis of what they observed in

order that OGC could make a determination of whether a follow-up

interview would.be required. The synopsis provided by each

personnel is attached to their enclosed FD302 in thiscommunication. ' ' -

_ ' The synopsis of each of-the 26 incidents was provided

to GGC for review. Subsequent to the review, OGC determined that

nine of the employees would be required to.be interviewed. The

personnel are identified as follows: - - I

' 2

RESPONSES4

§ _ ' .
' an

L I1 ' .

 To: Counterterroglgm From; Inspection C:>

Re: 297-Ho-132?6es9-A, 09/23/2004

1! Boston Division

.2} - crnc '

be _l 3! CIRG

_ bn;_1 4! Cleveland Division '

_ . - Los Angelee Division

- Houston Division

- Anchorage Division

9! - CIRG _ _

The interviews of the above personnel were conducted

durinqfthe first two weehs-of_September, 2004 with the exception of| _'_ _ _, "L*Ii W [is currently on extended sick '

b6 '1 leave due to a medical 1 ness and was not available. It should- b7°'1 be noted thatq;:;;;::]had previously documented his concerns of

interrogation ec 1 es at GTMO and provided this documentation to OGC. h copy ofEf?i::::]s communication is attached to this

report. ' _ _

The interviews resulted in a determination that no FBI -

'personnel were involved in any mistreatment or aggressive

behavior of detainees at GTMO. All incidents observed by these

employees involved outside entities, the majority of whom could

not be identified.; None of the incidents were similar in nature

to those reported at the Abu Ghurayb Prison. Specifics.regarding_.

~each reported incident are detailed in each of the enclosed FD~ '

. 3025; - ' - ' ' -

' 4

1

3

RESPONSES5

S!

6! - TD - - .' - 9

7!

8!
92.n - _ I

TO! CO92lD.t8ItE.11'_IC}r;m_>Bm 'FI'O'[fl.; I1'1:9

Re: 297-1-IQ13276669A, 09,-'23/2004

LE392.D s} =' - .

. J 

Set Lead 1: Info!

GENERAL COUNSEL

AT WASHINGTON , DC '

92 For informat ion and review . _

' e

92 Set Lead Z: {Info}

COU'NTERf§EEB,OgI §M I

 A'If_l-L11; wAs_11;Nc;ro1~1, DC -.

V For information.

0'

n

F

92

I

-_4.

 RESPONSES-6

'
__ _ __ 1- -|

if _ o __ _ __ H _ _ ' __ "  Z_'___7 _:-- -- --

¢

* _

[Rcv.0I-31-2003} . _ ' . - _ ' *

1 -FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 09/23/200*!

To = Inspection

From: Inspection

Office of Insgections _ ' l' Contact: Y _ I I -- b2 -1

b6 ~1 Approved By: - .| :--- lI

C 1 

I I

BY i

Case IIJ #= 29'?-'nQ~A132';ss9-A [Pending!-$56 

Title: G'I'MO -

- - COUNTERTERRORISM DIVISION [CTD}

INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY ' 

Synopsis: Forward-original FD-302s and investigative notes to

the INSD rotor. ' . -

Enc1osure s!: Enclosecifor the INSD rotor are the following:

Original FD-302s and investigative notes reflecting

interview results of the below listed FBI personnel. '

1! i it =_=.92:-rim-.92i";5[

2} - M5 Stet3}

41 _-r'|a92.'l J

wi--92 b6 -1

5} 5.=.A-J 31¢-} b7c ~1

5! __,,| soil7!

81i _i it J 1&5

'5?-»c'-o~92 5=L

Detai1s:_ Captioned special inquiry is concluded and the original

FD-3025 and investigative notes should be placed in file.

RESPONSES-7
I 17 i - l 5 l _: t 7? i _ i i

1

. _ I

T6: Inapectipn Igalm: Inspection _

, . Re: 297-HQ-13276669-A, 09/23/2004

E LEADIB!:

Set Lead 1: Info!

INSPECTION

AT WASHINGTON[ DC '

.- F

92 File the encloséd documentation.

0+ l .1

92-

2

- RESPONSES-8

_ .
FD-340:1{Rem11-12-89]

, _ -

QL »r92

[Title] __ ___. _

? * afI'F~yM»1ma@@{

-r7' "

Y1: N

-T'v.'

lr 311» +

?+- F ukil 92 t I

*/L5»-ls=, H

i  =" P 1~ i ,

*1l%

*"f* ~ { " =

* *  { 1 1 := 1 " * * + 1 1~   ~ 1

i "lg-¢92":"" - l _ _§_l i WWW

fl 11 7 U g ;* * _ I :

, _ _ _ T; _ _

4 ._ ' _ - 77

I 1:6..l '

__. _ we -1

. __ _ '7 ii i _

{ _

92

1/111%._

gs-*

92L!

r

¥

M5 1'

;;* *f; _ : in-I

Ff _F  L

W

92

 .

"7 _ T? _ _ _

Q, ,

,7? if

92 .

I

r»" _ <~__  ___;____ 7

1

92

H

j -+ 92

[ . .

T "1 1 i _ __ _ _

P_

*1'

L_ _p,

K

L _ .~

1 ___
-1-

Positive

Response

Number 1
i U <t.*1»t.¢.:¢S=&Lg=I-<-' n I . -2 _ l ':Page

116 "1 - From: F _ | BS_! FBl}- .._ L -_ -- -_ we ~1 "=~ - F . " -. - - Sent: __ I _Monclay, August U2. 200410:46 AM 12 X . _ I it |_§-lb_$,_.,,..__ é

._I

' H i a/if ---Subjieot: RE_:GT_M0-" -H M .- _ , I

mc-1=Mr' ~- - -. ._

_ Q ' As requested; hereis a brief summary of_"what I observed atG_TM.Q:- _ ._ . I _ I

J o*-e'¢'ou'piE 5r océissiorié, ".¬nte're?.fi'inte'iieWro6ms-to nes detainee 'cihai|*iec|*|ji'arit_'l al1d'foot'3i'n1af

. -_to.lhe-oor,with no -chair, too'd, orw_a_ter.' Most'time5-ihlr had. urihated or defacated on themselves, and-had ' - -.

-' been left there'for_.1B,.24 h_ourso'r' more. On one-_occas_sion, the air conditioning-had been turned down so far at"-5

theteifhperatufewas so cold in theioom, that-the barefpoted detainee was-shaking with cold. ' When I asked-the

- MF"s what was going on, [was told that interrogators from the-day prior had ordered this treatment, -and the - .-

- detainee was otlto he moved. On ariother ocoassion. the NC had-beentunied off, making the temperature in '

the_unventi|a_ted room pro_bab|y'we|i over 1'00 degrees. "The detainee-was-almost ohconbjous on -the oor, with a

'-pile-'of hair next,to'lI1irr_|. Hehad apparently been literallyrpulling his -own hair olgtth roughoutthe night. On another

. occassioo, not only was the temp'er_ature'unbearablY_hot, _butextre_r_r1e|y_io_ud tap 'rr_iusic was being played in the ;

' Ttoom, and had _ been since-.th,e_ day hefore,'with'the detainee ohaii-'iedI_hand and footin the-feta|.position on the tiie

._ _Ar_|1r-duestions,',feeifree'tocaiI_orask iria emai|_':r In l I-£3

~ -- -' * .'b7c-1~'

b6 J1 -'Fm'm: IN5D!- F31! In . .. " ' ' l -~ . .

-- we _1_; 5_EllttThl.l - Ju -29 2004-1o_:sam¢ ~ -_ - ._ _ -

- 1 . To es! FBI! .1 . -

" .5 :e=t_=' = .- __ " -;:-. -settles-tr-E111;=3?-:.6§te2ee.!'@2t1?se

" ' ' ' ' "' 'nsts:i*;*§*f*§:ii%;'" "ti  

. :' .11 '-".zgg§-.

-9;. -. . - _ '-

. Could you'piease.provide a.sh'_ortst|n1_maity ofiwhatyouqbserved? Thanksl. ' . _ V

1 - - ' . ,-.. Iii.-Si L :7? if i _ii "ii .

' - . .é-4>en*i}ia1Iiéiessa'e-.- . ' - " .' ' _ _

» . is i_i__'| has!-than eel-es w¢<te§titzi@;w&

"  wmr sHt1..<rtt%i§l1.:r1Ir:1;tt1*;;:s.t'- -

Frorh { - I '

ggc fl Sen't: Manda -Jul 12 20114 10:10 AM - _ -1 e" T===|_iltI~ w=Bn i i » l e

SI-1l2Jest= RE5§TI"lQ,___ _ _ M__ h_ H, _ _ _ M _ _

-  .. ._.5°. -"

r. ..t1-t=s.- ; i t;- ; » r r RESPONSES.-10-i

_I . . '_ i aihrespohding 'tt>.j~,;i;Jii.1i-_f-_EEil1.tES-iufttf aogressive-treatment and'inwpro_per - -

interviewtechniques used on detainees at GTMO. ldid observe treatment that wasnot only . - -

IDS -1 -

 b7C -1 -

adgressive; but personally very upsettir':g,' although l cant_say that this treatment-tiras_ perpetrated by --

'Bureau'en1ployees; I_t seemed thatthese techniques were beufig employed by.the_n'i|l|ta|'y. '. 

. _ - E , . _
_ ___ _ _ i'_ * 7-  i_ _ _ i _ __ 7 _ _ _

. II 1 llviessa- ={'é; 1_ _ . h--"-h-15":-.1

. . . V , __ L *_ _; _b1_ _ .

.| _ gwemméntcontigctempfcyeest _ J _ .

bsl - _. - ' ' '

' _ _ My name IS SA Boston-_D1ws|on,EOD _currenlIyas5|gnedt0Squa_1d1 ._

x

'_ _ " _ b2 -1- » '. b62

_,b'?C2_

2 . ;'' _-_

 .-fs.--------_ '--I-7 in :*><| I--1--» Iii. -L-92_..i.-,- I-_-5'-1 : .. .. _ _ _ _ _ __ .. -.-. ..._

Y J. T *7 *.--

n '- - .

. - _ J

I

F

92 |

4

' - +-

' '-

" '.  ? _. RESPONSES"-11= ' ~
_

1 .

I -0.

b6 -1

he ~1

b7C 1

- b6 -1

b7C *1

J4

K."

I. .-:

'b6

b7C

» Jytessag " in Hl fl ' Page 1tof2 r e

Caproni Valerie E. OGC! FBI! . " -

- o<~~s@»~=B~> i - ' e r :-

ttéglrleo t? s§fe?'atmzt3'm£§' iwiteiigis to 1 r_i t

- ....e1=;._@t'$.;ir?tFs.@.ti§T;£1faatiz-ea-

Caproni Valerie E OGC! FBI!

-Subject: FWI GTMO _

b7C 1' - . .- i -

Sent. Monday,AugustU2,_20D41D.5BAM . J T01" _ " '. -' . ~ .5 <

E. F»-

" _ TU

N - I . , V5 i

Here is the second summery./One'rY1*ore to go. /d ----Ori inal Messa e------/" - ' '  F~+~=iiBs>@<FB1> r

Sent: Manda Au ust 02, .QD41O:45AM ' .

r==i_"ti<1~sD> ran e r . -

.Subject::_RE: GFMO _ ' ' _ W -  i " '- - -

5 - y 1 __.__'.,1~3_iii?-l'I " t

' - _.;,:L.,L=1;,_-_- e+-.~:__ _ - @;¥.E'~.E§;§_1.!:@.1.EZ1_1lfL1:1i3;¥3:§L¬. -

. _ LI, J I

As requested, here isa brief summarpof whatlobserved at GTMO: _ - - ;

_ J:/1 . ._ r _ I

On a ggup'ie'E:f oooessions, I entered interview rooms toind adetaine_e chained hand and toot in a fetal position to the floor, with no phair, food, or W8iB@ll,_,OSfllf1'lB5,t92'TBy had urinateid or defaoated on themselves, and had , _

'been left there-for 18, 24' hours or more. n one oowssion, the air conditioning had beenturfned down so far and

the temperature was sooold inthe room, thatjhe baretooted detainee was shaking with cold. When l asked the

Ml?s what was going on ,'I w s gin that interrogators from the day prior had ordered this treatment. and the detainee was not to be m92:%On another oocassion, the"NC had been turned off, making the l;empera

-

the unventilated roor1].p"iot:|a well over 100 degrees._. The detainee was almost unconcious on the ith a -

.pile of hairnext to _hii_n. He had apparently been literally pulling his own hair out throughout the nigh nether.

odcassion, not only was the temperature unbearably hot, but extremely loud rap rnusio was being played in the - "

' room. and h_ad'beer| since the day before, with the detainee chained hand and foot in the feta! position on-the tile

oor; -' ' , , _ . _ " - .

V. I. _ I. _ _ . . . . _ _

Any questions, feel tree to call or ask via email. I L 7_" T -- b2 "1

' . it -----Original Message--» '_ l I ~I92_ ' ,

 Fmm= IN$Di FBI! be "1 "-

_l 1 u da ul 2 D041D:58AM C '1 Sen '

To: {E-S! FBI!

Subject: RE:.GTMO _ _ .

§@-lJ§Qg he re ~ _f_ -

Co uld you piease'pro~_vide a short summary of what you observed? Thanks. _ '

' ---on inal Mesa e'---- ' i

be _1 ,F~m=ih<Bs><»=B1> s r

 *1 §? °M1°1°AM iRE5P°5ES'12 It

ISD! FBI!
, , ,_ _

M835-E135 ' ' _ Page of 2

C ~ .

r U92--t_;-_;---

- b6 -1 ' " '

b7C~1 WI] L L L

I am responding to your equest for feedback on aggressive treatment andimproper . ' -

- intetviewtechniques usedpn detainees at GTMO. I did ob,se_rv,e treatment that was not only .

aggressive, 'but"personally very upsetting, although I cant say that this treatment was perpetrated by -

' bl ___ Bureau employees. It seemed that these techniques were bein employed by the-military, gcwernnient centred employeeei - _ - _

:33"; -- nameisSA Boston Division, EODmt:un'enl1y aeaig- ' - _C-9, telephone _ _ _.  . '_ : 92 _ -

' "  -b6 -2 .

- " - bi T1 ' _ etc -2

.tnnniégliawggaeanrnaf '*"

"sen _,t _ glee?! _

'1aawsHava4a;nueu;aummfna"t- *

_ - B!@!::t' 1 I -

RESPONSES13
b7C

Q  . bgiossagel _ ' ' , Papelof-1 

=2 _ i

|_ I

-1 ' -1'-.10; I _ | BS! FBI! ._ » - _ .

 ruse! FBI! -- " - e »,

Subject: RE: GTMO _ . h. _ _ I. , '

' Thank you. t witt pnnt outyour response and once thresponses are oompteted, adetermination wilt" be made

reference the intewiews. . - .. _ ' _ _. '

b6 -1

b7C l

b6 -1 -

b7C -1

bl ___

b6 1__

b7C -1

- Orl Inal Messa e' _ __

Sent: Mondaf ME 125 2 04 10:10 AM . '7 ._ . I

To: mso! FBI!

5ub'ject:RE:GTMO "' ' - - - . "

sWsn - Ami-°'F7_1= | .

I arn responding to your request for feedback on aggressive treatment and improper . _

interview. techniques used on detainees at GTMO. I did observe treatment that was not only aggressitfe,

but personally very upsetting, although -I can't say that this treatment was perpetrated byBureau -

.en1p|oy'ees ' ' ' es wene being employed by the military, government contract r"*P'=rrr*ir t "'15! t s t .

_My nameis SA - H Boston Division, EOD]::-{currently assioned to Squad C-19; -tetephonel | I _ _ - , . 92 _ * _ ' _

h 92_.  73- .' l ' b6 ~2 '

.' ' t b2 -1 - " b7C -2

'se|~r'srr| ' sslgreo _ - '

' <

- _....

IdHERE'*°5HUI¬11'=§IE£ER'ItI-

-r. .... ..-_M..o..,..Ji..|.-._.............?¬E'_M. _..~.-.-..-._..w-Q... .

RESPONSES14'
_ ___ ,

Q-I.-.'-...'>'.92l mm in _ , ' . I FD-3i
 Rw,10-6-Q5! i O

n.r"n- _ _

Li:

'FEDERA1=BUREALIOFINVESTFGATHHV

i _ Date oftuusnriptiun UQ/U9/2004

was t-elephonically contactedzconcerning her knowledge o any

£§?C'i1 aggressive treatment, interrogations, or interview techniques at

' Guantanamo Bay, Cuba {GTMOJ . After being advised as to the

identity of the_inte:rviewing Agent and the purpose of the I interview,|'::_| provided the following.information_to th

specific special inquiry questions: '

V [:|described her two month.TDY assignment at GTMO 

as an interrogatorof detainees. During February and March 2003, [;|wae. teamed withtwo different Naval Criminal '_'

 Investiga" we Service NCIS] Agents and severaltontract

translators for detainee interviews. 92:]initially worked

with one NCIS Agent for roughly the first three weeks of her

s ent, then a second Agent the last five weeks of the TDY. _

noted a slight work overlap between the two NCIS Agents

during their training -transition. The "primary questioning -

responsibility for the interro ations was alternated each ' interview between the Agents. .also. noted the interview -

_. assignment for the translators varie daily based on the spoken' language of thedetainee. ". ' ' ' -

' Shaver witnessed or was _aware of any aggressive

treatment, interrogations, or interview techniques employed on

detainees at GTMO in on istent with FBI or DOJ _ _

policy/guidelinesr had no knowledge or understanding ofDepartment of Defense 0 authorization for the permitted. use

h h/aggressive interrogation techniques. Furthermore, _. was- unaware of DOD authorized interview techniques.

' _ Shad no substantive contact with Military Police

or other-U.S. government personnel at GTMO regarding detaineeconditions or treatment and was unaware of any specific

allegations of misconduct or mistreatment by U.S. personnel -

alleged -by interviewees or others. |::| stated she had n_o

pictures, video, audio, notes, or other docu.mentation_whic1'1

depicted or described aggressive treatment, interrogations or '

interview techniques employed at GTMO or knowledge ofanycne

else who was in possession of such items. ._

* . .

Invcstignljonou 09/09f2004 at Washington, D. Cf. _. Ltelephonically}

Filed? 29?-HQ-nl32'?.669_-A  naemmea N/A - .- 1,, SSAL: *7 * _ JMW 35-E1 l RESPONSES

-This dcwnmcnt ountains uciihur recommendations not conclusions oftile FBI. ll is the properly of the FBI and is loaned to your agcnny;

b6 -2

.b7C' -2

b6 -1

b7C -1

I

b6 -1.

b'TC -1 .

b6 -1

b7C -1
,o_ _ i

q_.. - _V 1|.

w I - rs _ ,

FD-302a{Rev. 10-6-95! : '

4a'l'b - _

297HQA1327669A

. . b6 ~1

- i mo -_1 _

Continua1:ionofFD-3020f ' V 7 - _; J|-1. ,Paga - 2

I -I : W-itnessedtheaaaesuenlces at;'='erriap""7"'

questions e treatment of detainees on twodifferent occasions.

The two separate incidents occurred at the interrogation '

trailers namedDelta Camp. However,[:|was unable to

recall the specific dates or provide any knowledge of the two

detainees identities. In both incidents,. the detainees were .

c1'1'ained'hand"ad foot in the fetal position and laying on the b6 _1 I

floor of the interview r-ooms-. The "rooms were without 137:;-1

" furni_shings, to include any chairs.- also recalled the

rooms were without evidence of any food or water. Furthermore,

thetemperature control of the rooms was regulated to be either extremely coldorhot.Iilnoted oneoccasion where. -

excess ' loudrap mu-sic p ayed in the detainee"s interview ~' room. I believedthedetainees werekeptinsuch '

conditions for periods of time more than 18-24 hours, and

longer.- The detainees had llrinated and/for defecated on __

themselves. - ' ' _

J

- ' Shortlyafter theTDYassignment ended,'l:I senta b6-3.-

personal letter to the Director explaining her desire to return 1170 -1 toGTMO. |;:|informed theDirectorshewasinapositionto

- generate s gnificant intelligence collection regarding an -

investigative matter, and :'_=1,ddLes5Zthe_issue relating to thetreatment of detainees. .

- ~ 'b6~

" b1'c-

' RESPONSES-16
i

A. L. |_

..

92 ' ¢

|_______ ___ _ _ __7___ 1 _ W __--l-A-# _ __ ____ M

92

J ms-mu Raw. s-Mfr!

_ i

.. ..,_ ._,... ..,.. . ._._ _.. ... .. _ .

"s92 !: Universal Case.File Number J! - if?.

-Fie|dO[fice Aeqgltlng Evidence ,

iL.=- Seria1,# =1 o:igigi=.%zi' ':"i'?qg_V~ -2 I

.= 92 ;.92._f.= _.-'*"=.'- _' -'__'

_

b6 -2 Y

we -2 _§-

' 92

4:;-|_____-_ ____- :.92zr'r.. . = I _

;~f---!; .,.=@**-mqn. -' 7 ' 7

*7 = '-_. f_-;l-.-:,_,-_,- .,.;-,'. _

4 Fri 1

~ -Hétumel U Nlo_ 5

P: - . .- I. ._.. . .. 

;1@F**"¢.*1+'"'YIMe=@**@!i£11i§é¢i'%¢Pufmf ,

" 3,-.1ao,Ru|e-,5-' 9.!. .-l=i9d_éig§1l::FIl|?léé1fo'f_}Cfiif1i'riiiI"?E5

92=- _- 1 .»

. ' -- u - d ._ 92___.__;l__.'_f_._-.1_ _| I. - . _

 '

I

Ii

..':IFl§f9f'e|aoe:__ f - ~ .

. * <<=+?=>I--L-~T=.>=@rI1e'§!=:-=#<%i='r~s"1

_ Qg§r§|_'I_ptlon. Original nr>tef5"'reilj|tér_92rie92'ra -r3_:1

Q A 1

1 92 »- 

§-Fi_ec'aipt___i.ven. -1:1, . .' .

. -

||

b6 -

b?C

b6 -1

I

b7C -1

-n.-

>P

._92

Q

L

I

";
Egcmi A , 

' ' _ - L b6 -2b7C *2 LLLLLL@=1@>~/L»>,v{§@~L Z¢Z> N I

b21--L

1; 2% mu ms f P>»1H*¥.& N127 ml

L LLL.:%J.;L7;§_1_o II-I L Lemwf /wwW> L

LL

1»£r¬¬LWLLLLL§é1>L l

, ' L LL W5 Q4 >9P¢+1L§/ _LLL_L___L;L~L_1¢ 

Mg,Lr" 4waruzz

3 ii; AL *1 Tj - N % 1'5

,i;iiL_iLL f

; ;ij;;L;1Li;;;:;L;%;QZ@LL;;L L L L

 PI Ilillli-Q

ma! -M;

iL%i;1

"L A»»1~:6f%~=@

? L » _' msspowses-18 L

_ L
_i:

1 - @%

-I fi- 45+/1'? L L

g» ? é

LLLL1L1>LLLLLL'mg,,L L1:>|JP1a.»921LL 92 . L L q-q92_92u| 7

L LL L L L I I - L F@92:~:-

LL ~LLLw+//1f>TLfIw L 7JmAA~*r4-l> I

LL Q1. 1- n '

.r ' ' ' -. .

I

|

92

92

M

9292  92AP - - ,

Hu. L

V ' 3 L L_L~ RESPONSESQQ
Positive

Response

Number 2

¢
. 92

Message .. . ' ' Page 1 of 1 _

. - I d ll|.N$D! FB1! - .__._U_5____;:... -, - .

nu-11¢_.. . ._ - . . .. ._. . . .. .,;:,-.21.-3--.' _._.. _ _q»,,,.,..,-,,,,

- - ' -

Sent Friday, JulyO9,ZUU43:42PM _ . .{-' - " - .

To: [NSD!{FBI! V ' . ' " .

Cc:' Fedaircyk, Janice_K. |R! FB;;; |R! FBi! |R! FBI! ' . I

Sub]ec1:GTMOE-Ma~ ' ' ' __ - _- -  . '

iLO_bl=BLEQQEJl L »/

' b6 -1 /'

Perthérecent F BIHQe-mailrequest, be advised fhccfiduringmy GTMOTenure, I didwitness, aggressive

_Tr"ecmnanr, inferviiawinterrogafinn Tac_hniqua s],e.1'c. of'|Jafuinee.s bynon-Bureauperéonnel. -CIR6's ,

11122/2002Elecfopit Communicrion TOFBIHQ65A-MMC991C|2, serial724!dafoilssomeofPhase.

bbsanrutiuns. - _- ' . ' ' ' ' ' ' __- __ . -

i aZ S

. r l

, , "-3 ' ._ 'HapeaIl'_s weII,_- .

_.r .// . l , " i .b6 -1

» I * / _ = CIR6/'NCA'VC/BAU " .

1 ~ , I: L b2 _1

' 1 .4 .

_c Ssrso /' _ '

_. /-

f ' k';¢< i -

._ I

~_

5

RESPONSES-20 "

_ 92 . '
*5

;,

:1

3'.

__.

.. _ . - ,. "_ *"' "r"-'-' r

orca-20112-3-96!" - ! . _. I _

XXXXXX .

h i " FEDERAL BUREAU OF ]NVESTIGA.'IION

- . DELETED PAGE INFORMATION

. ' Page}- withheld entirely at location in the le. One or more of the _fol1owiing stateurents, where iridicat

- explain this deletion; - _

FOIPA

E-I Deletions were made pursuant to the exenzlptiom in cl ted below with no segregeble material available for ica

release toyou. _. -

' . 1

§

* - o M11 -

U 1!

U b!!

' .0

T3 b!! ' ~

U 'b!!' .

s ocbm. . I

' request is Listed inthe title -only- _ - _'

' |:1

' for reiriew and direct response to you.

U b!!{A!

E! b! T! B!

El b!J C!

U b!l D!

U ' ' b!J E!

U fb!! F!

U. fb! B!

El !9! -

Section 552a - .

U ¢1!!

U i!!'

U-¥I!!

- U 00! .

'ou=>e>. ~

h U 03!

 k!! - a

o-lam!

'.D

 km. _

- 1:1

_- _ 'Pages contain information l_:!{.another_ Governrnent agency ies}. Yon will be vise y e

' .. ' -' - to the releasahility of this information fllowing our consultation with theother ageneyes!. _-

' ' _ Pagelfs! witl1held'iJ1as'n1uch as a nal release _deterr1'Jination has not been made. Youdwillbe advised as tohe -

"_ ' " uispositionatalatet _ ' '

I {El Irifornnation plertainetl only tea party with no reference to the subject of or the subject of your

Documents originated with Government agennyes!. Ilreseuoelnnents were referred that agencyesl!

l  ' ad'db-rh'FBla

' 'Page s!withl1e1d for the following 1-easou s!; __- 1 - i __ ' _ _ _ _ _ _

' bl: Pages were not co11side're:i _ for release as they are._i_:Il1pl_ioative of joke _2'q"° '.&an

' E The following number is to be used for reference regarding -these pages:

l ' Posrrwe _-!'C¬-S,'_#g,1-§$Q.__'1VU ' £3-ea; '2__ _ _r f s :_

l t if Caeimses maes 2.1- 2.11-J Km; m,;.,;X,s mmm

-X for this page '

X Deleted Page s!

X No Duplication Fee
h in - '

i o 0

- U2 Rev, ID-5-95!

. _1_ __ _

FEDERAL BUREAU OF H'WESTIGATION-

-_ _ - . Darnoftrnnscription Qgrfl/2-094

_ _ , __ . __r., - _ _ Supervisory Sp_eg,.1.al Agent SSA! __ _;__~_ _ I ' EEC 32- E.0D:| I National Cen'ter'for the Analysis--of the Violent " _

Cri es CA C , BI Acad my, Q , m N V F e uantico Vir inia was interviewed g , b6 1_

regarding his knowledge of any aggressive treatment,. ' byc -1

interrogations, or interview techniques at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba -

 GTMO! ._ After being advised of the identit of the interviewing Agent and the purpose ofthe interview, ssab provided the |

following information in response to thirteen special inquiry

questions: I _ . _ ' .

s TDY ass-i nment to GTMO'began on 09/12/2002 and ne n 1 O2. |;q]was partnered with SSE: -

, also -from NCAVC, both whom providedbehavioral - __

assistance to the intelli enoe gathering mission involving "the b6 -1 - GTI-IO. detainees. While |:__E-:never participated in detainee bvc -1

interrogations, he 'so1Tletimes observed -them. Also, when '

requested, he reviewed background files of the detainees -to

- assist in the formation of interview st-rategiesf -

' primary point of contact was | a civilian w o a overall responsibility for the in errogation of 1,5 _

the detainees.'. He-directed the"military reservists who mc - conducted the in r ations of the- detainees. ' advised _ he "did not,'like , because of his attitu ean is I '

interrogation met o s. ' I , - . _

' Qdid witness aggressive treatment, interrogations

or interview eo niques employed on detainees at GTMO I _ be -1;

inconsistent with FBI or DOJ olicy/guidelines. Th-e incident , mt -1,4 involved detainee num}:-erC:F - - -

_ When arrived in GTMO, .numberg|was incarcerat

in'a dar ened ce J.l1 the Naval .Bri . The lea interrogator for nurnbei-[was staff Sergeant a reservist from. 

California. About two weeks after arr've in GTMO, _ V b6 413:4 |:] requested he and; observe numberjjand provide an" - b7C -113

assessment of his behav or. ' During the following week, ' _

- discussions concerning_integ_'oggtion options for number occurred betweenLd 7 _ _ __ ~ |.and The 

_ objective was to evelbp an interrogation stra egy w ich would

enable the, interrogators to elicit information from_r1uml_:>erU

Iavestigationoo:  -09/14/2004 at Quantico, VA -

Fa.» 297A-HQ-A1327665i-A 300 . _ - - Datedictated N./A

b6 -1 '

This document c0t|ta.|'11s neither recommendations nor conclusions of Lb: FBI. It is the pmparly of 111: FBI and is loanodin your agency; -
+

so-302 {Rev.11}-6-95! _ O h

e"n

29'?A-HQA132?669-A ' _ _

 'b61- '

 b7c- ' '

T On 4 Page 2

1

Brig to Camp Delta, at which point he was fed, and interrogated

by an interrogation team, however he failed to provide an

substantive information Later that same evening, number was

transported to Camp XRay where he was placed in a plywood ut

and interrogated by another military interrogation team until

the early morning hours of 10/04/2002 | and

observed both interrogatio adviseotthe interrogators

screamed and yelled at number during both interrogations At

some nd point during the scond :|.nterrogatJ.on,:t;__|a |E_::|

re t rned to u q their uarters During the late a ernoon ours o

10/04,/2004l:|and returned to- observe the

interrogation. of number advised the Koran had been .

placed in front of number ' aptain _ United- -P '.

States Marine Corp, began to -interrogate the detainee. At some

point_ during the interrogation Captain|:_|squatt_ed over the

. Koran, which incensed nuJnber|i___|and caused him toreach for the -Koran. Whi1e did not observe the incident, he was nearby

when it occurre , eard theyelling, -"and wentto -the hut to ---V 1 learn --what -ha 'ened. |:;|was then told what'occurred_. ., ' -and then re urned to_ their-quarters. On

10 05 2002, a German Shepherd was placed in front of n1:|_rnber,E

while h' dler commanded the dog to growl, bark, and show his teeth. - andt;lwere displeased with the interrogation techniques u l ize on number |:|and decided to depart Camp XRa . They were never again in the presence o number|:

. :|believed the interrogation of number |concluded on

10/OB/2002. - _ _

Can1:nationofF_D-3020 _l Z I 1' ' , Qggjgzzgg _ _

l ._ " ""6nt'1n'!0a?2'uo.2, t&"rzam"-if:-hej-w

 L: L -mg _,_| ,|c_1

Q1"!

'¥

- ' Approximately two weeks after the aforementioned .

1no1dent,| |and were at Camp Delta in an observation

room which was located Between two interro ation rooms. G was observing one "interrogation while was observing.

another interrogation--when entere t e observation room.

was laughing and he told and Ihe wanted to

. em somehthingh | |accoman1edh . Iwhil

remained in the observation room. later told that - had taken him to an interrogation room where-o served'

a. etainee with a full beard -whose.hea .had.been_'wrapped in duct tape. . -Shortly thereafter,|:land't| departed GTMO.

advised he andl:| corresponded 

-. telephonic nd via email with EBIHQ representatives, be

_ including and | and others  Q at FBIH _ b7C

RESPONSES-26 ' _

-» .

b6

92

b5

b?

1

-1

l,3

C l,3

1, 3, 4

b7C 1,3,
FD-3l]2a Rcv.lB-6-95! 1 ' Q I

0 '1'. tl

. 29'?Al-IQ-A1321-'569A _

1:6 -1 '

_ '_ 'b7C 11 _  Cnnnuaunufm-3020f I . ,Qn ,Page 3

regarding £Be££é5Emé5t""fthe'aéiaiees etmGTMO. £:::;:;1a1so" b6 -1 '

ensured UC was apprized of the even s a M0. bT<I -1

b5 *1 |:__|had=no knowledge or understanding of Department

11711'1 of Defense DoD! authorization for the permitted use of 1 _

harsh/aggressive interrogation techniques. He was. not sure if

' any of the interrogation techniques he observed were actually

authorized. j -'

_ _ |: had no contact with interviewees during his j I

tenure at GTMD. He also advised he -had. no pictures, audio, -

notes or other documentation which depicted or described. _ 116 -1

aggressivetreatment, interrogations or -interview techniques 1°76 '1

employed on detainees at GTMO.and_ had no knowled e "of anyone . else whoas in possession of such items. :1 had no

additional information related to _the_tr.eatmen of detainees at} _

' GTMO. _ . '

. , '

- _ Upon his return-from cmo, |:| along with':|

related the aforementioned incidents to SAC Stephen R. Wiley. b5 '1

Also, :| drafted an ac dated ll/22/20D2,_which_ outlined the _' C *1

aforementioned events, was approved by SAC Wiley, and

subsequently forwarded to CTD Executive Management. -

I

I

- RESPONSES-27
-z  "

2- @_'Fiel.Cl'Oil::e Acquiring-Evidence .

:1. _$gr_la_l #pfOrlglgatlng Document. . - ' H.

' .mmon;n=-.-.s-1,93! _.

. 31Djtgiieuelvaki"

. ,2:

_.._ 92.

 :. -~--~--~ -~-

' :'~-:~:*;':,::-92_r1_~_~" --L =14-Q r;'_>:-y-5:-<."' "

M 5*

¢

*1_Uniyppssjl Case FileNummr A -

. _|_-_' . .

- -{;";¥'i

'5

-_.é

..1' 92 -|92_| 9292

W ¢='!1,H."_=*?"'!'P"!°;!? » - .-

_ ,. -92.

_ H,1:

. 1;: - - - ' .'1 .; .

._! 1'

. .. ;

. ...4' .

1,a 1

- ';_'.+.

-q.--_

_1.;.

='<-'>.b6 -1 a Q-4__=. -

-_ '- .. Hameof'Spac1'E|1ge* _- " " F _

ToBeRelumedElYes;E11J.o '

F|B0ei'pf+Given -nYes i 0._

Grland.-JlJ_l'Y iuiéiei-131'{:bis§§hiii5§i;$_;Qh§

Mule

I_.;;__ jlh -_ .

l."92.'T|.I|B: h

.|,-

.92 '

;._.1.F_

N K w

A

1

' b

;_-.'5"1.-

.. -.r.."-. v-'1'-J. =5

_Reference: 7 :':i 

' ..4; 1.92 ..w"

.'_'.'-92. -

' 1'

I

1

1

- - . . .

.-.,.:__

$-" '1*3i°v'T1iT"4"iF&a1iq[1jl5¢1.9=iFi55!=!=¬ii=J,

92 i

Descpticn: 
6;§i}ia| _

If

92;..92

. £1.

92

T .

L

-_;*FaE§Po192|sEs-

. .'_._ l_ I 1_ s |

- :.¢.. - ¢ -'. _ .

- J ' _.. nod -.

. __,'_ . _

b6 -1

137:: -1

..

ea _ I *_ i__:- 7 __7_'|,,_j,'_k______ _ - _ -. ..-.

. u

1""?b7C 1 X

0

.%"'

:.--;92»§,-1

I

a

..:411..

..

-'-. '. .2 ....92

'92 _

1

92
/"'"k" * * "'1 ' " " W

_' } - __..__ - -.l._

9292

- W *  b6 .1 I - lid 5L7ln-H-*~iI-.b7c -1 _=1 ~ 1 ~ U»m~ L V

2 41% if *Q _ ' j i

j i Y*- -5*L-h_1:_/'££n_L; M133-C j

_ 1 7 L __-__. f 2-;Z_ Ii 1i,=__-_h

j- ~ 5343 56-2 f ~ j ~ »» @:~

b7C -2

.@ 7 , ,7 _ ' . _ _

V _ I; 5 QZ,;=._?'{{:Q;W Q:1 i

 H  L pggtgj £2-L92Q92-92f ééginm2 Q ;;_u§¢,;%, ' r J 1 __,

92__-___ P . CL!JfP92!"r-Ax _f_|Q§>L;t! "ub92-;;|'1|-q1____ _ __ 

A  _Q- r*1~hi-l31:»¥y-m@-if ;o *i ?92l:¢4<&-1»-»J<,

f ,_ _ -_ Lu?/W! B <L W ; j 7' 92

L ___ Z 1L92"£? <-Ln}-fxigmnl LL;-,_/'* r#"'-#*-4';_,7 J

 1

Q - 511.2,]

92 .

92 _ _ ; __1 ______._ '_ ____,_, T:

92é__ _,_~_,_ ___, 1 , ,_ W 1, Q ______1 _7"' __1 _ J_ ,

;_.:2c-:_5!_L|:|#_'_'-_1'592 M NM./. @7.|%L M,Q,mm_K

|____ _ _ -M14115; ;~/r--r»¢I. j j j '_' j j 7*

{ {_-{{-¢m@;».{,-92.a{ an ~92:m~_,?:924R'Q9" 92; .___; , ___ q_;1_'_0{1~_;§"¢

.___ _____ ' -____#2

% B-95-i*@-;~11

3,4* ff»W2 i'1'|f92§.D"#1~'?"£n-L1h'r£'h.{r.1:*_*=-JWJQ iib§.'C3,4 - FK $ - - _ K - 2 W 1, i -f W u~_-n r="@§-~1w' Wm; ff A] { _*% I {]@<.w~

»-_4_; __" _ { -_<_Qm I.gLt_.-;c--»~? ¥

{ { -[:]2*-Mg; >v _

 RESPONSES29 ?
/-~.

J

A77-n.-.-u7-7 --..¢.1~_- 7 77-_+ 7 77;__ 74+7- A 77- H ' ::~7i7 +777***_: 7; ___ 7_:~:77

92.

;l

I

'

92 1 " =55 77$

b'?C -4

7u 7i 7 

,5 7 -W

17 777v7u7 77777177773 £7>777~7

H779 7

 11»-Ff 5-W-1-*1 7 777-7? Q:92J_1'1-=7 2L+77r?»1.

125 92

-A 7 - _77n.n 74Laa;L77710~¬u.1ufJ1'-7,.77-'I1l*77"!¬:J7¬

7. 777 -- A92 7 ,77J¢""717'J7-i'§_777'

"~gz~*J3~rn7'*~1l7774l~Ln5-2.7 7

T1 777' -777 7 c§1_1_1f|_1~"3'_1"w'~"1"1=r77 79'7>"771Q17: 77?<7¢

F

r 7

'. b6 -1

{__.__b?c -1 -44

7ii"'_'i""-"

7~'7 Q1 L P~>U'7

_ _ P71 _ _ 7

77 7 77777 7»? 7l:::17@ 

l

[ 77777_ 7 : ~ b6 -1 Lmjziz ALP -

 77@i»~~7-» -JI1lJ7_|Z_|77~77~~

5+7= ~ ?% ~'4*5§ !?"@ 7L*"?}1 71< 77 7>~? L-_§

s7"@% _ _ mg»;-1n&r M%rn& Mbg

77 7 juflcgajl VIM/~£!n=/2. 4@ m7-72E|:l_

-77 Q7!» 77,17 7-77 -7

~.A -~7»?' _.. 7...]

3

77 7""7 '- 7J *5 7§92l""92-2&7-i!' _--J77 0- ~: 7 77

B5 73,4 if , 1 _~ - _.__- l

rm: 3,4 j *   7 ' * * 92

792 *  *7 '  1 7 * * 1 __ i 1 77 . ' 7 7 7 =1 --  "

4f?7_7 7  7 77 1 7 .1 7 ~ w

MJ

92 -'

b7F  92

7% 77 <=r=;77b;711{ 77777-T77»;

1 77 -7777 7-7 92-7r5¢"~*W!: 5711177 Li; 7;7~7-3=~7-7-11

gqg-| 7 7 71717 I-*1=-*~ 1>'*4

T7

9277 7 7t77 57711:»-1.77-7 ."$-r9-h'§}l;z7-'

H777 7777

Y

=**-~D

7 ¢L1§»~»7»~u--=-=7 1arn3'~Q7̇"-*"'~:792r7r92-7>I~!.7

7 777 : 1&1?-/=7*'~IL Q7»

7_ L A 7 7 ii? _§lrZ9

77 777 7i7¢[_J¥ L 7 77 771% 7 7 Fli b6 -4 .7-/. E-LHL chi H n{map .

_ we -4 _ - _

RESPONSES3O 7 -
I _ ___,__ .._,.,_.,..,_......_.,,,.,_...,...___.__.____.,....,_;,.,_.._,.,.. ,___..._.. .-_............,-a-.-.-..-'--__,---¢_._-_, ____--.._.-.._._,._,__..-92...--..-.-__..-.--I

. . q l.___..-____....-- I - JW

4 - . {Y

b6 

i

l,3,¢1 5,?hif/Q3,» _"1=r§i»~>r' _ ' ' 

| ,~¢,,,m}~.» ?

_ ?_ 92

9| . .

i___4, 7 7 jf 

I if __ [ Hi H-_=mJ.._.

 I w_/__¬

 I V TML1-/'___

Y % _ ~  ML? ?_i>J!<?1-

J-l1@

F gin 1 WM ML591:*v~QI/ Lad,L /n Er455-=1Y1='~1:>¬

-  j j ?_, :

. _ T> W ,_ m£dimg}!;_ _17 i

92 P. _ __. j___;Lgg__.,-_; I/:m-rim bi;-Fur¢jl;. _,-'. W _._*V

' 92 ' _v-I/'r'w».'_92792: _ _ _h_ _'_ _____ _ J_

w~ . J11;-1;Y1" ;@_==¢§ 40'" ml U-.1 =5»;- 1

w Nl34__ _,iIM"cl. °l13L;¢r? =L'?F;,_E 92

IT , ' ___ ' ______ _m~92gJ@ q-35; if-'31! _  cf-_£-Ln

_;__ _____' _ __ ».__, ____ W _.

Lb6-1,2,»-4'~5-I-"5~i ""/*?*3?"'l'3"l Q-"_L"* 

gb?°;§' _ " ;@ l:l; ¢Q,@M__~-&W@;»1m ;=»:w~=-~

1

L~f g Q %¢j_»~ 2_;-§_3[f;__§»'/ |"J@»»/*?_*1

L __:H__WW  -_;__, _  ___ _

F _ _' I _ _____/*?__l_ ' _:' _.f!_- *1":f"":92_,__!'~w1::-}l£P % "

1;? T 77 _ 92Z** _if - _?_wl2v:.__ ,_ Jf=_~"-"Li ¢S?-9:: 5_'°,,A*1§-__ _ - _J

' ._'__ M__7 j _j'_, __'_ 7.___,_ 111- 11 h

1F -|MI'f§1.r'~ J'H.|=~_¢L_L* r £5131?-'L J~9&IFE5! ;? 3

I 5 W W *7 1  1 _ _Z_ _ ,énrv92~';s- 4-1;-/Lf_ ff {4¢"'*/ 3/"--J-i. _, 1

| 92 . 4

I

kw ~ W92~~ ~ j f *7 if * ~ ~

I1

1

. . RESPONSES-31 -
 M

3i

|

_ 7 {_L!_i}___','____,_6l_J:__L_J- WE!M-ff1-vi" 7 f , *_

1

s

1

-k , i _* 113' _-1 !9*J1~»_"f7' ZC*'!¬r¢;L 7-"E/sLbi; £59 1  1'21-M - ?_ _~ 

Y

1

1

- pM¢..4-~. 01,4-@D1§=92_ __ 1

1 _ . . 1

IL - , - I _*~92,1:Q--1'11"-*-l~?t1.:1;1_ _Q::sr"~"',|_ £11 if

, f c;.1,;-- J§¢1--9>;._ - H WW j i 1 1

17 TM 11>1-- i X-.@§L-_ LLH.11:£g*u_L§_F"'

m9~1~»;:~i

1

7 1

1

: _ J_>_::s&_rl92?~a1;1=§m,_, 1::1l

'________Tb c -1_ _ -92_L_LL 1 _ __- Z _, Z_

,_W_WH  , '" ' - WW; ,- ,,,,,,,,,,,,,

_ . . _

lag1 l

I 1 H rm

i ' l Q,L}§ Lin/I1_i- W W i .__ '

~::+-{~'-==:~- W E]L1:1¢m~

b6 -3

b7C -3

1

1 1 l 92 j

U~Q19

_ Q-__1l,,,_é.~.|;-1-M. §>*i},r92-1 7 C-I-==~@l_,_1 ____Z?,'_ J c-

__92r-1:@92_rrI/rnr'1-. 54-5C__ ____

3

1

1

11..

_ - in-J" :"}.,~ r-?"_92r:ཇ°4&?L

| j r'QQ~1'1rm1L, W}:-;--1 1/I-~;v~92 *_c,1ul1¢n~J- 5%->;_&#V

-la .

1 ?_j _JIl.a--r*92'92>_Qt 2:1/1:1*1%_1 j 1

_ __ - _L é=1=|:]r Juu-§92~b~..»}-rw}-5;? 1

71

f Q§;_ *1;1-_  1f'f'_;__ 7 9,1-~s_.;~2/-w}%w ._<1:1,.,p1 LQL-__I:CJ"'921" -Q -, »,=-_____§__.1f_'

1

_.__..b6 -1,3,

b_7C -1, 3

41

,,,,,_ ~ 1W _i 1'/-1~=L~2P»»=

_W jr:?§;-g:~:4f==»~;I*=-- _ 1 Z

1

l

M

4: - W1 W1W-=1»@m,_?1°~<%>:£""b_# "~rr*<<>1"+

H11

i

I

7 W *_W+-»i""92_1EL1,_,; j _ "

L

1
I

1

l '1 -1l 1___,f'§",;"**1 1J11 'jL*_'Q,,_

- W_ L L@?__J=1; lr-Ls-92 --/g-Pr~'92. 77" 7 b5 4 _ _  77 7 H 7W7

_I! §L~£54mNgf%; ___Z_b7c '4 _ ____

92

Ia*1

Q . _ ML W k'!£lv-H v-$_r~.»92Q~,q;r,n~j-- ' I

If _ - __ - ' 4- 1.19 A j ?,c_1.<.=::>:,'>$.»1-?Jr*13<-'» - _T'ir:*"¢:".T @I?=,*-7" .

,_- ,7 _ H Mali»Q-Fr%j;F"~ i7_E1? i

, J _ _ H-J;;__,_ _ ,__, _ _ ___ ,___ ,

92 _ ~_ W _,, _

92 _ : , ,§"_9%,,.lLll_,¥-VLCQ; £L92r~q'1§- _

__ __?_W i _ b6_4 ix

W i _,?,Qm*=P' 'E"i§-:1-'I'92i_l-"" £2]:  bY°:L L<,{m/»¢:~.=4~_._ ¢~~.¢+Lag. U - _ '.1

1 IE! LJ;,.@,m».n;~¢:=:

I "i " - 77!W" " 7 ' ' "' ' "W"" _3 92

b -3

Y1

1

92 V IIIM-M

_ MD _ ,92J>s-4 . ' - -

. -" _ _ b7c -4 W" * T

H r H Wr I - Jjri __ if i 7_ ' _ -_ 7% _ _

 _ ~=>l¢1=>- _ H __

7

N. _ _ _ __ .__ __ __ ,

f

L 1:»! NJ. Y {_ {

I

92

W

z

Nj,

192

Y

ii

l

Wk

I1
~

Positive

Response

Number 3

n

t
1. -. '5 ' ,

k Mesoage * "_ . _ ' . -Page 1 of5

I ¥ u'$92 Owe» I I - ,I_ I____i<1'~1'==

mmmmm __I__I92»  we #° F

_ . . . bi-C 1 .. _:Ih_,;,_ C _1 $3-o-Ht: Thursday,Ju f5,2U04-10:03AM I I V __

I To: _ {|NSD!I{FBl! " t aw-"-""" - --F"It;e.*?_?-:¢§§3;"" .

I Subject: R_E:GTMO __ .- "

I SENSlTI92_!§_[3UI_l_.lb|CLASSlFlED - - _

. NON-RECORD I , ' " I -"I

b6 ~1 CIRG drafted a letter to OGC at their reciueet to send to the Depamneghefléetense iregerds to the ._

WC -1 o served treatment of GITMO prisoners while the Behavioral Ana sisIUnjt/members were dployed to GITMO. I

' have enciosed the eeeons that apply to my ob's'er'vati0r|s." =- " ' '_ _ ' 

' M. -

---Ori inat Messa e-- ~ _ ' b6 *1 F==m=i<:~sD><Fs1> at -I b7 ; -1' Sent: Wednesdaff Jlllf 14, ZUU4 12313 PM ' I'"_-.I

. To IIR! FBI! -

 Subject: RE: GTMO

_ se L! _CL I-IED j

, nor;-aecono " _ ' I" II --

- OK,' butI haveno knowiedgeof whet they ere, and we areaoting independently as of now. Could you . I

please, in bullet format, email me someof your obsenrations. _ . _ I _ _ - '

_ ' -3-_0rIlnaiMessae 3- '- " I 1. Fmm= m! Fs13 -

b6'_1 . Sent: We r1 a u 14,2004 11:52 AM

_ ' To: INSD! FBI!

_ - Subject:_RE:GTMO 1. j

S_ENS[TlVE BUT UlJ_QLA$SlF|_El1' _ I

' __, I ~_ - '_

. be 1 . ' . [:11 witness o.eve_ra_|"inoidents which have al-r_ady_been documented Witt: OGC.

1:.~?<:_-1 . -. _- . I _ . I I .

----Oi'igln§_.92li'92:l8S5aQE.-I---' _ . " _ ' _' _ " - ' '

 - From:-MCCRAW, STEVEN c. mso! FBI! ' I - -

- - Sent: Frida Jul D9 2004 2:42 PM ' '

' . '_ "rd: MM! FBI!; MM FBI!

- FBI!; 010 com; MM! FBI!;-

 rm FBI; NY! FB - MM! FBI!'

" LA! FBI!; H0.FBI!' cJ1s! §FBI!' BATTLE_ *-

- Hw-IK1E rrm! [FBI - M F - LA! <PBI!- F

I inc -1 * |=e1!_; HO! FB - 51! FBI!;

. LD! FBI!; on FBI!; NY FB

_ DL FBUEAN FBI!: . - {N0

~ - 1' _ F ;

. I!: ' ;

' FBI!; ! F5I!; |lu|£AQ! rm! us! FBI!;

R! FBI! NY] FBI I. . ITD

FBI , HO! OGA! CO! {FBI} ' CG

B

F MM FBI HO LL N FBI!;

 CTDHFBI!; '

_ _ I I - . 'RESPONSES-34 F '

"I11 Cll
 .

u

A

In late./Qetober 2002, FBI Special .Agmt was observing the interrogation of a_. .

detainee when cjnfilian army contraetor,'who was in 'cha.rgeofthe- ;An'11y's &#-

interrogators, came into the obse1'yation- room _and_-esked SA: to some see something. - be -1, 3

SA :1 then saw an unknown bearded, 1ong:hairet1 detainee 5.11 another inteno ation room. .b7 F3 - 1 e 3 The detainee had ben gagged with duet tape that covered much of his'head.. S ked &#

Mr.|:|w1.1ether the detainee nee spit at the inteI_rogatoI8- IvIe._E|-leweed that

the detainee hat-1 been emmmg the_Kora.1'1 end£¢eu'1d not stop. Mr. did not asiivér when '

SA|:j asked howthe duct tape would befernoved -from the detainee. P -- e

__ . _ 92.

In September or October of 2002 FBI agents :|an observed that a ' go I _ __, _ _ _ . d . 4 canine was u_sed_i'n_::m aggre_ssive

to intimidate detainee _' _ ' .

* _ . - I . _

_ .

RESPONSES-35
.  "F? - Ev

. - . ~ <13 0 o s

FD-302 R1:-v. 18-6-95! _ _

. _l_ -_

_ - s

FEDERAL BUREAU OFINVESTIGATION ' .

" Dale arm.-awe. 0'!-M15/2004

b6-1,2 .m _ .1 ' i Superuisory.Special AQent_{§§A!,,_H"j_

b7C-¥h2 EOD:| |National Center for the Analysis of Violent

Crimes NCAVC!, FBI Academy,-Quantico, Virginia, was interviewed

regarding his knowledge of any aggressive treatment,

interrogations, or interview techniques at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba

[GTMD}. After being advised of the identit of the interviewing Agent and thepurpose of th_e__interview, $SA:provided the

following information in response to thirteen special inquiry bjcfi questions:f ' 

b6 ].

 .1. [;;;;::]s TDY assignmentto GTMO began in the middle of September - and ended in late October 2002. [:;:;;:|was _

teamed with SSA|@UUUUUUUUUUUUUalso-from NCAVC,o of whom '

' were responsible for providing behavioral analysis assistance to b6-4

law enforcement and military personnel conducting interrogations b31

of detainees. While[::::::] never participated in detainee , '

interrogations, he sometimes observed them.' Also, when .'

requested, he reviewed background files of the detainees to

assist in the formation of interview strategies. - __ . - . _ - O

- primary point of contact was | 'a civilian.contrac or employed by the military,-who was ' ' _

responsible for the interrogations at GTMO. [::::::]directed. b5 *1.

military reservists who conducted the'interrogations of the ' b7c '1

detainees. '_ SSA |:] advised |:1 exhibited "bizarre 

 behavior", meaning he displayed a range of emotions and often -

"lost it" or.became very angry when something insigniicant -

- occurred. . _  _ " .

b6 -1

b7c--1

~

or interview tec nigues employed on detainees at GTMO P 7 ' f E::::::ldid-witness aggressive.treatment, interrog

inconsistent with FBI or DOJ policy/guidelines'on two occasions. b5 '4

The first incident occurred with detainee number'E:]and the b7C'4

second incident occurred with an unknown detainee. '

When[:;;::] arrived at GTMO, number was incarcerated

in a darkened ct 1 n the Naval Bri to _ g. - b_{ 34 d he

planned to have military personnel interrogate number for 24 b7c _L§,4

hours in an attempt to get him to cooperate. when -

objected to this technique, said the technique a_ been

approed by "the Secretary" who understood to be ' '

Iuwsgam on .' 0 9/'1 4 /2004 ,; Quantico, VA I RESPONSES_36'

. F=#29'?AHQ_A1327669A gm be _1 ' D,,,,_,m,,,, N/A

This donumt coma.-i.ns neither reconimondations :10! conclusions of the FBI. It is the ]J1'Opéi1}' of the FBI and is loaned no your agency",

' i i____
°¢:- wt , ' ' .

- . I

. , ._ -

~ ' Q y

FD-3028 Rev. I0-6-95] ___

K " l_

297AHQA132T669-A 

'- - _ b6 -1

b ,-vc 1 ~" ContimmtionufFD-3020f | _ _ W ,On_O9/IJIZQQQ ,Pagc' ,2 H

 " ' Seoretar "Rums'fe1'd."A'ft"eI: '-inpi-1 -frem - ~

- a the decision was made to provide number1t:]wit oo

since e_ ad been on a--self induced fast for a few days. Number

|:]'did eat the food, but still refused to provide any

information during his interrogation. I-le was subsequently moved -

to a plywood interrogation hut in Camp XRay. . While in Camp 

XRay, numbe-r|:| was aggre-ssivel interrogated by military . b6 -1,3,4 reservists at the direction of: During the b7C -1.3.4

interrogation, the reservists yelled and screamedat number C]

Additionally, a German Shepard was positioned at the door of the

interrogation hut and made to growl and bark at the detainee.

At one po'nt one of the- interrogators "placed a Koran in front _

of numberJ[:[while num.ber|:|was seated in a chair. "The '

- interrogator then straddled the Koran, at which 'point1_'.'he

detainee became very angry, but still refused to- provide any

information. _. . - '

- Late one evening, :witnessed a -second incident which involveda detainee who had been duct taped; |;| and " - Q-were in -an observation room, located between wo '

in errogation rooms, watching militar personnel conduct an . -

interrogation. At some pointyjentelted the roomand told Ito come with 'him as he wanted tosh'ow him something. ' ' - accompanied |:|'to another observation room, located "

down the hall, where several Military Police were observin an interrogation. when he enteredhe_-observation room, -

observed an unknown detainee with a full head_of hair an _a be, _

beard whose head was wrapped in duct tape in the adjacent b7C -

- interrogation room. There were two interrogators in the room with the detainee. :asked if the detaineehad been _

spitting at the interrogators ore:-: J. iting belli ere_nt=- behavior toward them. |:| replied no, and then told|t:|the

detainees head had been duct taped because he would not stop

quoting the Koran. did not approve of the treatment of

the detainee and asked how he planned to remove the duct tape, but[:| never answered him. |:'then exited the

observation room and_ returned to his quar ers.

Department of Defense authorization for Based.--on conversations with? believed e permi e use of 1 -

I -

harsh/aggressive interrogation techniques may have come from

 Secretary Rumsfeld. On several occasions when'|:] questioned b6 -

|:| about the techniques utilized said it had been - me - . approved by "the Secretary",_ who un' erstoodt

be ' I

Secretary Rumsfeld. With the excep ion of|:s comments

RESPONSES-37
Q ad, 5- H

FD-3Q2a Rev. I0-$95! ' o o -

n " Q

29?A-HQ-.A1327669A .. '

 " ' b6 -1 

_ -~ 1 b'?C -1 . Cvrr1i11=lH@n@fFl?-3l_>9-of _| .0u_Q2LL4/2904 .Pas=__,,_

'regard'in;g the Secre't'ary,':b-he-d~ no knowledge -or--~ -- - -V

understanding of Departmento efense {DOD} authorization for _ '

the permitted use of harsh/aggressive interrogation, techniques. b6 "

Furthermore, SSA|:believed|:| had the authority to WC  

approve interrogation techniques, including the use of t'he'cluc:t '

tape on the unknown detainee. . _ . ' '

|:| had no contact with interviewees during his

tenure at GTMO. He also stated he had no pictures, audio, notes '

or other documentation which depicted or described aggressive b6 -1

treatment, interrogations or interview techniques employed on_. 1976 "1 _

_ detainees at GTMO and had no knowledge of anyone else who was in

possession of such items. |:had no additional information

related to the treatment of detainees at GTMO.  _ -_ -

' Upon his return from G'IMO,I:| along with ' 

related the aforementioned incidents t'o SAC Stephen R 1. ey.. be" _1

_ 311%,: drafted an EC dated 11'/22/2002, which outlined the -We _1

aforementioned events, was approved by SAC Wiley, and

subsequently forwarded to _CTD Executive Management. - '

I

n

RESPONSES-38
92.-

"T ' -F **"';4".i!*.i' I" ** .. "'" "I " ~=.

92 * L V 1%?* ' >_;:,

1=n-a4oa g¢v'.s-1-9_ i ' _

__} ....--_._____#._7.._:,.;T_-.. . I U

=s92 ' ' < _.

. ?_ '-'"°'.?*' @$5'?%5'!P'""m°°F A

Field'O[pe_-Acquifing_-Euigl1§:nce;f Z ' -'»_;"1

_ y 92Seria;j;_i§§i'_Qriginatli1giloémant -' -' _ _§

, __,_, . |. . . ._

_.Date;_;!=ie¢:eivec_l _ , _- _ :__'__ .5:

ij_,;Fl'DlTl'_ -_ 7_ '. ' _ - ' '_ r~_j;. _ . _ .... F|_ame=Fcmmbu1un _ _

 -

, .- " [Address-oi_Oont|1butor] - Z ' 1-

_- -. - _ l:.:_92,f92_:.__ , . ' -

_ __ .- .r.92 -'- - - - J

. -.. ~92.-H- J _ . '

'_ ~ Byi _ .F: "Y: -1'u"E' ;' Q" ' - 

;- b6_1_1

§§§""To Be_Het1m'-Jed U YeB_,| -- -

Q46 - - -7'.1. r%,.Heceip:Given%.i;% !1;¥~*@=:» 1 L.

I -f§jéter1_'a_['.5;-liis§é&#.

- ~ Til-"T" -:0Rules ejs,Fedér&|1?g1-¢;_:'¢jj¥=f6n_mma] Flincadute? - '

1' -. - -92 .@j§111e: . - »

a3 ' . .

- .

.:: I9292 92 P

¢-.-

.-'.

_ 4. _ 

teferendezn.- ' -

' , ' - _{_C__Ol1'l-If|'1llF§l§§|i§EI|=!:|>_Mab/aJ]_., ,

' _ _Dasctioh:/l26§ginail_lmiegige iferxiiqw

=7 M » - 1 L_ a

.- =1

n": l -. r ' _. .

":41 - " :

:

J 1

I

l

. - ' E

M s

. i,

- -. ¢. ;

?_. _ w___3@!,1: j 7 * RESPONSES-39' _ -

.4 . -"- . '
92 0

_1l;gJ

.. -- - .. .-- _...___.-_..._._.....__-_.__.....--i......._._-_._._-_..._.-_...._.........- -..-_--I-_.-_-_--......_--..... ._ _.__ .. . ....___,,.._

, 92b61i H -- Tc -1"" *" * 

I

=1 _ I / V 1 i 7T ft 7i ii *74 it W:7? i 7 7 ' i 77 if ii ii 1

.. _ _i _ J

-1-"" 7_ i

*b1'c -2. 7* 1 1* * * 7 =

I ' 92 . ,92 J __? ,$24éis. -'1». _ '

_4i

" ~ 1 .

I '{2,mJ .%,1 0;. D513;! __[;_LQjk'7' i

fgm~rulLl-¢:*~?L=..u1u:¢..l

i .J_l:m:h_V,_b_f_r i__._?G;!vu:__|_£EA/J Wl m:: ll ff 4*V}_i 

/,__.

1 L

. . r- .

771 j j 7 ___ __Q ,__{92lr-92,, %_ _*__?__:_Q_____ __;___l________

i 7 j _g

92. ,1; F r"u,1»§s1L-L 9135

I5! _' jg? :,r.g;Lg*_J'i___ _ __ _ ___ _' 1; ____1 ____

J

b6

~-b7c

H

_¬4 '-  I ' J'*'}3 _F?!"1'.A;-- __._ --Jim§-5_

,_ Wjwimi-9¢Q~??*@+~sl,<***li?;L¢g@k_Qir7w=»s ~ i j -4

_ _._;. ,:.~r1., ?'=1|.--L3: 7j§Q_L[p_V_ 4 - ~_ J1

-lit" 1L92'-"'h'L@'z.ATig|f I

rQ,__ fit &:!:'b.L§ *a>_L~:'J-i~-*1 I21-_jQ':!? i i

i i b6-4 7-! l w_1~ K 

h l ""l31$a;'__,,  w4_p.1L=uc 11> j, 1 1

, _b?_c__4 ____ E -~r-I-.{;____jr1__ B7/l

92

3°|4-' @}1-*"" JILJJLQ--@~¢@-}*_'92~5~|-=-~<. I j W si -7 l5i2:%i ,

&_§;2~g:}'9l";L~'"92 f--'1 f _1:u'_LlL=""}r qI1___' ~

~ +01%__ ,_ ,_ if ____ __ ?_,__ __

._ -_,@,;:,p;,'5q é_b:}§_h§'L&#ml}: 9», i

b6 -3

b'i'C -

_  r i ii H Cir r 7 i fr ' f i iW 92 1...,

j W .UT%Jwtn ff ~ f i_;=lé$'-ak-F jjllw~» *1if

3 H}_W_il I i i Hi R c.i-n'_b_h¢;L jj"92r ::L_,

*i&i}::'*-_*4l92'92'::-£'_ _-__JLx ¢*- C92_92f'*&#

1 _ RESPONSES-40
/J' ___1-» L?"Ci,--'

' W

4L ' ____

--..... .....-.---.. .. .- -...- .-.... ...- - -».- ' *# __7'--..-_ ~f 1-4'_-..--H.-..-......-.....--.......-.._ .

| -

92 92. x I | /Q-__ I . ' ' 92

W 1 ~~ _ ~ . ~ 5;,-pjii 1 W

' g "" i r if? 1c'?Fi=1f3'q"f__ u.-.:nf925*""~ 1]'92A92A.dW  {4Magi;-m¢,W~A u:3~*=92=r%~r

11¢." {

&.-.¢+g-h.Pw' j z:;§_g9i%:=L""n_J': P~<g'92r~:==.7 f=c~

1~»:{§I: T7 { mm Wm~Pw1J:= i _? a

j _ _V,_--_ Z pl; hi:-if92__hr:-»e- ,,F'?1»'T-2:? §_|§&-92J,Bbgj l

,7 j f , f 9.»;,L1,,-m;,gW?§"2-><¢.i,5_L>-f*,H ,_W , ,_

l ,_§___ff ? ¢i'7?, #1-42.v~Q *~92_qLhn I

-i-i__,1=s -3_-"__,__, G !=*l1»'lI2; __ ,1.-1-@»-.»?

 l3n_f__f*:1"*-92_'/K mi £.;J:4. A

j j { ii _ " 4-,~@=~ Q ,

92

i 7-j--, j ol~ii?="'=~?1-}'Qggsvjg.

lg, 1. |,__ _Z1_, ',_¢Q15:-r*%p;-;9 _,,

L % _ _ j -__,_p~@?Ltv*92? % _

L iiah-;.t1§§~2r-i M5

7,-WQ'_@i-,*~~cn~$§_s-"_@~?=-+1~@?iv- 

,_____________b6 -4 jaw} 5, I l - W W  __

A 92"f""jfL.,?,~_,,_»<,,,L».-.b.;=»"-»,{-{{§%@,¢v-»1LJ {

I 1:;92_.-+- 92_~:1»>_1&# aha/1.* "

- il _,*'L_i5Jf92r~'*-1'1 °-W91:

f, W__Low»-". " j __ - l I

'1

I

1

H j if __ i 7

 RESPONSES-41
1

92

_-. .. - - .......-.-.--._._._..__-1.-...._..

92 x

, . "ii JJ?-'r'H..1df Z K Z K 711*i z

 _ _ _l_,_: iii:§3 '" _____ _

_ _ b6_,;_Wff I; M 1??, j f __,f , j -1___, Z " Z ' ' F

__*+¢1c|-1 4&Pk*¢} waif

i __ ,___,_I__fJ_gJ./'92" I I 92__n_§_. j _ __,__,,, ___ ' , _ ,_ ' _ id

:77-__ 1£n.§_]_1Llr~!_~f____ <:*_1"v~~Q'*/L5, 5_»¬92J'*F Y _111 |

11Lji. 7 7% _iW-1|::_l~-s:v:Q-'1~sP ,__'5:E§>7'

 j

L

¢_W  i~,

92 ' a

V,__,,J_,{L_w,.,? _ i T? *l§5§¢"§

- M-.M, 3/

if 'E_ @~:M9:1~~+/*~ ' Emm j ~ V { 9-M1 [llM2,;1%;-1'-"

L;L1-i"-<-FF -" Whfk M im,e:.,_ "l>£~¢=:~

 ' 7 -

.1;

, ?""Q

?,, j ha_'-~g$I_'w~"~»§£v; , k~'~#*-~'=- _ _*

yin}-Hf*;~>.%L-3 ?L1~" *?kl.1/!'_-_

92

If j ,7 - NE IL 1::::n'>'_

i .;_L__,

92

- 175., L1/§t~§{%A¢y@» ,;,,;¢s<>LT

,__z 7 ___ 4-_;,L->~Ji.r~+¢"~'§,r>w»~»;£,_ 7 _ 7 *1

92 292 |

~ _ b6 -3

i _  Wib-|"C-3 ___ __:

, 9292 L115_, '5 **'92*-rm _,__ ==J_s..n¢1$-*7:-1

1:

'1

rix , Q {1'!sH?592M-chm"? F ju ff jj iw;f A

1

1:5 4 H ' - . b"1c~4_D i __ff

_ 92ij_q192-J;-h;~,392-_ Z_, » $c_E3

-I

ll

'.

.|

1
it _ r i j

i_l. I

. r i

' I ' 1

- 1 _ ¬  1 . ,-

fj __:;;:.FY19t?}J"}92*"f*11fl»T'Qf"**l:!~-r1-__

fj. 1 W§::-ULl-*~~1'92h1'qy~~,=~-::*-V =1!

T I ,5NM [q " £1 -fA"#;ZZ§

:,L:_1;5jC}3 j 5:5-=~'hL }<1=§~_¢< j

 j _J:~l_!l{@~r~-w"z%-- ¢__,l¢ ; K k ,5»;i%..@41£ mtlmr hi;m,~1,,. | |

92

92

, ,, , ,,,_y 1 92 -J 4¢u~»@Pi_

-. _ *1,jif Q4927$* E§¢_f4?+.|

I Zsj 92;>~;_!_r*~q=2v-"'19--1[.Q-.>-'+11<

_,_, . __ W

92

_ H _ ____ _ _______ ___ 7 _______ 7_ _ ___ _ 7 __ _ __ _

é "  * b6 -=1 L H! -f¢4*-»c'Gi:_r¢~4n§ %,4=1»|:|_ Q b1c~1.__

= - j 7f--,7/??'7-'~3:->'???-"*§  ">*I""F 1Pilib*j_;?*<.9-;1E

i_:__;__] _. i_ Ikfl/9292_jll _ -___ __b6 _3 __ 

**_ - b7C -3

A j fU19*1/"Liz; n j @r~f~<=---=1-'~;c.rl-¢.i-WW, -

92

Jux

Z? H /-LLL -""'*'92J"*""¢ __PrQ5-5+

4 .

' ' ? -  RESPONSES-43 -

- f

H I I

92
4

I .

Positive %

1 Response s

. s Number 4

1
: Message ' _ ' _ -Page 1 of 1

1. - _H ,

L

" _'I[|i§|so! Fe|! ; __.I_ it g_ - I

-F."m=.I:Il°920:iFB'i- I 106 ~1 t ' t -

-sent: Wednesda .1s'142os4~2;1rPM- bic -1 ' ' 

.- Subject: GTMO ' _ - - - ' - I

' SENSITIVE BUTUNCLASSIFIED

. NON-RECORD ' . I

Iwas TDY to GTMO from the dates of dune 2, 2003 to-Juli} 17, 2004. During that time I did not observe ' 1*

. 39QfBSSiV.&..I;[§tlJJBIl_i..IHEHOJJEIQDQQEilTl1!%.i'ViEA92i-IlE3§?hl1l§|L1Q$.OD .2-IMO! detainees 92.-ir.t1.i.r;.i.1.-wa§.!21el Is9.n§i5.isr!i.Wit. . - Bureau interview polioyfguidellnes by'any FBI personnel or the interrogators from FT. Belvoir consisting of Air . sh ip .

Force OSI, Naval Investigative Service and possibly e few other services although I can't recall which ' -

_ . ones.__However. I do recall seeingome t_eoh_niq_ues utilized by other interrogators not associated with the FBI or

the»Ft. Belvoir interogators. ;I-occasionally sawsleep 'depravat-ion.interviews with strobe lights, and twodifferent P

' _ kinds of loud music. I asked the one of the interrogators what they were doing they said that i_t would take _

approximately four days to break semeene doing_an'interrogatlon 1-Ei hours on with the lights and music and tour -

hours oil. l'he sleeprdepravation and the lights and £1ItBl'I'l3lIr-tg beats of the music would wear the detainee down.. -

There was a-time period where the interrogations were obtmsive enough that the interview roomsfor an entire . treilerwere not available if one of these techniques were being utilized. - . - 5-: I I 9

' I heard many rumors about thlngelthat I did not observe. 1 spoke with one intenogator not sure if military or -gf, -

contractor or other! that bragged about doing a lap dance on-one Detainee ossibly 1tt:lAnother.inteb 6 -_ 4 {notsure if military or contractor or other! bragged .about making Detainee biisten- o sa anic blackrnetal we _4

music for hour and-hours. Then the intenogator dressed as _a Catholic "Priest and baptized the detainee inorder to

save him. - .- - . " _ _ - _ - ' . _ ' _

QEHSITNE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

.| s |

F

RESPONSES-44
' n - .

FD-3H2 aw. 1O~6'-95! -

» _ - . - -. .. - . . ¥rsns':1e=1"s.i-%':?#Tc7E

CI--Keir:an.2Wis§..!¢:rrEs_=»11~=r111-a-h; - . -1- .r5m_;;;§1§4'--.35,-;_ . - V +.a.r¢E.a§,xI1r;!.§.1_1

FEDERAL}BUREAUor INVESTIGATION -_ -

' -_ DaI=oftransc:ipl1'm'| 05-mggggggug '

. - Federal. Bur.eau_...of...lmrs;i1;.i.q§_92;ion FBI S__e'c_i_al__A_gent SA! 1:5-1 | ClevelandDivision, EOD wasadvisedor h-2

MC -1 ' the identit of the interviewing Agent and the nature of t-he ""' MC 2

- . interview. provided thefollowinginfor_mation.in regard to

his temporary duty- TDYJ assignment; to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba GTMO!:

. was assigned toGTMOint-hepositionof _ 115 -1 interviewer in errogator for 4'5 daysfroin 06/D2/2003 to 07/17,/2003 We "1. as art of a "SpecialProjects"team which consistedof FBI SA[:| - [C1'1ElJI_lOttB Division!andataskforceofficerwhosenamehe .

could not recall, -

b6 -1 , , . , .

b-,6 _1 d1.d'I1OlI. witnessor observeaggressivetreatment,

interrogations or interview techniques utilized on GTMO detainees

Conducted by FBI or other law enforcement personnel which were not

consistent with FBI or DOJ policy/guidelines, but did observe such__ _

behavior by nonlaw enforcement Department of Defense DOD!-

personnel on at least two occasions; On these occasions the DOD

personnel utilizedsleep depravation by playing load music for 16

hours at a time with four hours between sessions. and _ b6 _1

others brought these instances to attention of SSA who we _3_

was his Acting Supervisor, " Atlanta Division}. at GT _ -

' was notfamiliarwithDODpolicy/guidance - regarding w a ' in _erview/interrogation techniques were authorized. -

During conversations with unidentified DOD employees regarding

- interview techniques, |:::|recalled bein asked if he used "fear b6 -1 up"or-"familycompassion" techniques. It] didnotknowthe WC "1

"identities of the DOD interviewers or detainees involved in the .

activity. The aggressive interviews |:]witnessed occurred at

Camp Delta in either the Yellow, Brown or Gold areas. Most _ _ _

interviews conducted by law. enforcement and DODpersonnel occurred

in interview rooms located in trailers in these areas; Often DOD

personnel would reserve an ent're ' ' ' _ssive

interview-1' techniques; 1.5] bl. f f l i , _ , l

l O O . as . E5! _ ,

:| hadnosubstantivecontactwith DODpersonnel

regarding the condition or treatment or detai-ne.e'sother than . b6 *1

regularly held briefings by the DODCommandwhich provided eneral b7?'1 updatesofactivityandthenumber ofdetainees atGTMO. t] _

Investigation on Q9/15./2§_Q4'___=: 7Washington,_lD_. W i ._W_ t*elephon:i._call_yl

:=i|=#_282_-__NEW . 5m7.kp.gy 6- . . _1 -i gammavr"0%/1?/2O§1_4 * K . _ _or

by bjc_1_ - _

Thisdocumentcontainsneitherrecommendations norconclusionsof theFBI. It is thepropcrtyof the FBI andis loancdto youragcncgr,

id ' ' itandiscontents arenotInbedistributed outsyouragency. 1
I b7c_-1 _ _

Conn'm1ationofFD-3020f _ i___ ___' ___ ,-on 0_9JL15lf20[}4 _,Psgs_ :2_._

b6 -1

b7C ~l

FD-3'|J2a{Rev. mess! _ 0 O

g 1 .

_ "7 1 i

2B2.- NEW .

 b6 -1

and others were provided a tour of the cei'l area at GTHO' a'nd"he"'

characterized the cells as small but acceptable,- -He recalled that

the detainees were switched from Meals Ready to Eat ~MREs! to

regular food because the detainees were becoming overweight due to

the calories contained in the MREs._- ' 1

- c_ould not recall any allegation of mistreatment _ brought to 1S a ention by-detainees, other than the detainees

referring to techniques employed by DOD personnel as-"games."

|:|ind.ieate<i most of the interviews conducted by the his

Special Projects team were negative. Special Projects was tasked

with interviewing the most.hardened detainees. g

_ - . -F . '. ' . '. Ego E1 ' was not in possession cf: pictures, VlCleO, audio,

_ notes or other documentation which depicted or described aggressive

b6 -1

b7C -1

treatment. He indicated. the in_terv_iewers were '-searched for

contraband each time they entered or exited the compound. _'

 ' |:|heard'|many rumors -about aggressive -or

inappropriate interrogation techniques by DOD which were = "

-unsubstantiated. '-Among the rumors he heard were that a female DOD

interrogator did a lap dance on a detainee, that a DOD interrogator.

forced a detainee to listen to satanic black metal music for. hours,

and that a DOD interrogate: dressed as a Catholic Priest and '_ I

baptized a detainee in order to save him. I: had no first b6 _l

hand knowledge" of these events and was unsure as to if.th-ey MC _1

actually occurred. - ' .

¢

II

' RESPONSES-46 _
I h I

-1' I r

92 ~;'- "1bateFleceiiieuj _if .

_ __ -

92

 . * ' . Q fzr? ." V .*E'I.'513"- - ¥- _ Ll _.__ 2-._;.__ft. ,92, _»:',_¢_.-__*_!_':.'*'_:.__. ..._|_|;.=;_I

~. -».-."||- ; .-' 11 L ~-=;m~: 4 .

Q '-1=1>s§iub{nw.s:7-97:!"-_-_ _ - _ _ .711-

i .. . . gj ..--r'~

- ' " l;Jnivei'saI Caséd-Filg Nimbgr - {f-gl

' ' - -I 1 - '

3-.$erial#ofOQinatinQ-Iacument l _- ,-=_=,

Field omen Awqulnsiiaaenw farwg  %

hi "Ff

.- , . '

-- - . - t_.;,a<¥ -

';Fr9m"Q_ _ ,_H _ , ___ A

-.'_

92 %f 

__-

I5;

1--

. " " .* * {Add_ras§bfC-omributorj 7 

.

*

*~-1~@W=--

__.1.._..__..,......___.________, ____,_;______________

L

*7 *

_I_ _.___.;;_-gt...-

?.=;;_;? 1%

ii-By fJ» V _ , ___ :5;W1" -1..'

; '_.'rl'-'.;}- ' _ -- -*1A: __

Rewéd":'LY<=>}'-*.'-@"i"° '92

V. V

92??§%i¢'m"d-JHW-'@§°'"*v§Pvrwa"1 ? l

92.r!§_*' ' _j.;'_ .55.-Q" .-E1"-"?_-QM . _._. ' ._ H _

Rule6 -e§, Fedbzzil-HdlB1§:of §{3ri1_'|'iint~i1 Procedure '

_ Ly, .. ;1'»q;_;.':" = EIYBS-El N_Q_'. .. r ' ' - u - -" ' _.==2-..=;~ ' E3?-;Tie: ' ' _ -

' ' . ' :1_.r¥§§

92 val. - H .. .r -

in .

__ ya? :5.

92 . »=_ ,

Fleferer'1qe:_ .' __ '_*_; ' L;, .L .31 r

- -. ;. ;. _| {Gumgn_urioannEnclos]ng lqlatedalj -1.- .

. -Descpon? E1 n::!1§s|e'i Z ' Z iii

. b 6 -1 ' , ' P - ' "§

92> -- - 92_--.' _ -92. 92"i.

V

I.

r

-P 92 '1"

':

J _-_.<

92 " '5

- ' 4=am:o.r '

L ,

,_Il RESPONSES-47 ? V

-
I/*""~.

i 9// A? L L ,;§CL¬2L 9

b5 -1 I l Z .. L. L L. . b?C -1- | 3.929 ' | :57/,~¢3

- r/ ' '1-I" 7 "7/95 - ' d¢hw2>-.a.¢.'5 ' ' , ' ' L 5 A I A

A 1 5-51-'f&<3¢ L.-A _ m, L.,.~~.-#4 Mm ' ~

! Md A b'v,:§-'-"G /1/'554/-=

P-/J éi Hz-W -0" : mm  F-KI / _ /= L g7=u_4w 

// L V56

3! V 5/»v»fv:»'>-~..¢-.-»~ -Q1-0 m. 3&

L3,! ,L,,,z,,,L;,,,,;L,L VLL,/JiL;at

A; Q. I 7 -:1 0/ L 92 . I

i; b6 1 4!;, -

-we -1 14/  ' E

- I §=§e?**4i;L?§L.LLLLLi1*-11§§§I

- - i1*Ea=5:3'92Hf§1@."§. 1% L

_A 7/ /I/0 %a:L1=.L.,LL.L@-'==sL

1 _

 , -

¥ - L .

-  L

RESPONSES-48 L
. ___ i-

$1! /firQ

I iii I 1 i

A _,,,,%,-.,

é#,w=f-;@ la/9% 4»

~/ M ¢*""""""* f**

. W , ,,,,,,,. %

V L

"°"/ ~r£b<./A_%

I RESPQNSES 49
Positive

Response

Number 5

4i ii ii

-x
i _ _ i l

r' - ' '

 Rev DI 3] 2003]

i ' c i |=e_|:|s|=m_L suneiu OF luvssfrnsnrlou

,- _ . . _ ,

_ ' - - . K

_.r "- , .. - '

Precedenesi Imnsbists -. _ -Date: 01/09/2oo4_ '

.. Io: Cotmterterrorism Attn: : . '2? E

.- - I 7 -- "1 Inspection Division . _ C 1

' " ' ' Officeof Inspections -

Room 7531 ~ 

Frsm: Los Angeles _ ' --- .

. 'Squad I-2 1 ' e_ e_ 1+   "

' Contact} .' ],.L . I 1- ti *1

b6 >1 ~  . . ' i ", $%j§

b Q C __ 1 I QVB 6- B Y3 _ '  - -- '

_ jg7~- ,ssisa -

. . , _ X . _ rm ,

_ -Case ID #1 297HQA1327669A - {Pendingft-Eihy - 

1-

'Tit1e: Counterterrorism Division, §§§%§§%§q§.+-' __ srmo, ' i t i - ~ 1zL2._'-i

Inspection Special Inquiry, §§§§§%%%§ "'~ .' 2 9 '7 HQ -'-1'11 3 2 7 6 69 A' ' - i§".§§*3iiJ°*,l-5.,.5.Z;§»<§%§ B33 =§1E3,:;¥1:'3Z'

-

Synopsis: Response to inquiry, concerning potential knowledge '

of_mistreatment of-detainees at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. ' __-~ -

Details: 5 Writer .coi'np1eted a 45' day Ttemporary duty assignment

 TDYJ at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba GTMO!, for the tenure o May

13, 2003 through June 26, 2003.'.writer was'ta§ked as an

analyst providing'inyestigative assistance to the Military"

Liaison Unit MLUI and the Joint Terrorism Task Force JTTF!,

in support of Operation Enduring Freedom. Writer did not .

observe at any time during said TDY, aggressive treatment of _

' detainees and/er, witness interr0_gatioI1{s! or interview - "

techniques employed upon_GTMO detainees, which .wo.u_ld be '

considered inconsistent with existing Bnreau interview

policy/guidelines.'_ . I- - -

. ' .

1

However, although Writer did not observe any -

maltreatment of detainees, Writer does recall hearing about a

rumor, wherein a male_unsub detainee was purportedly dressed

in female clothing, make-up applied, and involuntarily given a .

.. lap dance by a female prison-guard, either at the direction or - ersonal pe_rfcirmancei_of_MiJ;i'tary Interrogators Si B1 music an t A 1~ er Writer ur J - . i,-TTTET rsessvemetst. as conveyedas a '

- u Fisgéiiiiési

n _ i

i RESPONSES-50 
JIM"? Q-nmpsnu

r

Ii 1|-|-||iI11|II|'7 '__ _ '__ 7 T7

' re i o

To: Couhterterrorism From: Los'Angeles .

tactic which would result in.the breakdown ad eventual

cooperation of the detainee.-- _ 1 U

It should be noted, Writer does not recall the

specific date, time; place? andor the idetity-of the

personls! stating the-aforementioned rumor.

. Writer's identifying information fO1lOWS:.

ofgicié-.1 Bureeueme __ _ <

Joh_Title ' _ 'Ihvestigative Analyst

Tenureoof Assignment 05/13/03 - 06/26/0§_.

#0

' f

!.

-vi-:1.

2 ~

RESPONSES,51_

fee; 297__-HQ-Ai32?es9_A, 0?/09,1200:-1 _ H _

J .

b6 -1

b'TC -1
1. t . . _ ,

To: Countérterrorisml From: ,LQB Angeleé - h

Re: 297HQAl327669-A,i§jjQ§j§£Q§m -

. - _ . .. . _ 1

_hm
=,' "

; .

Set Léad 15 Info!

= -.COUNT§ETERBORISM _ = , ~

AI I§SPECTIO11 531315 IQN

 ' _Read and clear.

§Q

-I"

I

92

F

3 _ -

~ RESPONSES-52.
1|

I _; J __*___

Q2 ' --- -2 I I ' I P ' _;. . E5 _ ', ¢h 3 Lo- -,.__-;_..._L.-..-;..-_-a D _¢ __ ' 0

6

FD-3U2 Rev.we-95; _ . .

5:1.-ITJET-1:;s.19.;:,;i~.1§¢=.§~;*~;%"F1??2*E'$ . ' _ - '

§+'.§E5551EIi?%I3¥$6.5_¥J;9i1iIW.£i;1i5i§E* = _ 1 _-

:1 a ,.-_i_:-__.'*£§-.=_;-4,_»;,=_-;;;;?_..5i;.._i=_ _,,,,- _ _

:?,;1~e=.+ l a

- FEDERALBUREAU011' INVESTIGATION

. Drtsoft|'u.nscr1pti0n' []Q{0',?£'2 ]O4

' -" - --_0n--B-9f0?~f2Q-¢_1--I-NVESTLGAT-IVE ANALYST q1A![:| . .

' dateof bJ.rth SocialSecurityAccountNumber b6_ _ I .,I .. . , N

hm " ] wasadvised astotheidentity oftheinterviewing-

 - ' - '_ ' .» IA -

as 1,2 _ _ 1 . _ J_ - , -

I , i

Agentandas to the purpose of the interview then

provided the following I!.I'LfOI'Il'I.&tJ.O

_ IA|4_ __ |entered_ondut with the Federal Bureauof we-1'2 Investigation FBI! on| I andiscurrently employed as

an Investigative Analys in e os ngeles Field Office

During the approximate time period of May 13 2003

throu h June 26 .2003 IA was on a tem orar dut . 9 I ! I P Y be_l assignment atGuantanamo ay,u_a GTMO! insupportfOgeration

bqc -1 Enduring Freedom. His primary duty during this.assignment was as a

liaison between the FBI and the U.S. Military,_primarily with the '

United States Army. Other than.routine administrative support, IA i presidedthemilitarywithinformationregarding FBI

in erviewsand other FBI investigative information as r_equ_ested.

I .. _ ' IA[:';_'|.:.as notamember ofanyinterviewor ' _

b6 -1 interrogation team, id not witness any-aggressive interrogation

b?C-1 techniques used on detainees, and has no first hand knowlede of _

- 

advised

anyimproper

he was

techniques not aware being of Departmentusedonetainees.

of Defense

IA

 DOD po_1cy

regarding interrogation techniques, is not aware of any violation

of" DODpolicy, and cannot identify anyone who might be aware of any

violation of DODor FBI/DOJ interview/interrogation policy.

b61 AI is not.inpossession ofanypicture-s, "video,

we '1 notes or other ooumentation which depicts or describesaggressive

treatment-, interrogations or interview techniques employed on .

detainees at'GTMO, and.is not aware of anyone else who might be in

possession of such items. . _ - - ~ -

$30-31-" 131:! didnothaveanysubstantivecontactwith

Military Police or other U.S. government personnel at GTMO

regarding detainees condition or treatment, and no allegations of

misconduct or mistreatment._by U.S. personnel was formally brought

to his attentionby interviewees. L _

o 7 ' . RESPONSES-53 '

'Irw=stisn!i=m an 7 O9/Q7/@004 J1!__ _____7_ _7__ _____ itelgephqnioallyl ' '

FM29?HQAl327669_~A hefzlpf 6 . Dmdiomm 09/Q?/2004' _  W 7. 7 - -7' ' ' 1 7 '77 ' '' b _1 -i * ' '77 :77 Wn7

- _ * I b-Io ~1 _ _ . s_ss§j j W

__ _ ,_

Thisdocument containsneitherrecommendations norconclusions ofLhc:FBI. It isthepropertyof theI-Blandisloa.ncd'1ao_yo|._|r agency;

it anditscontentsan:nottohadiptribmcdoutsideyourmommy. _
;__ _

i b 6

*92 .

.,.-..- _

O

FD 302a. R.ew. l0'6-95! I i 0 0

297HQ-A1327669A '

- b61 . .

- ' b7C ~1 _ Conrinuarimrm-Bvzor i he i _ ;,Dn Q2L'Q1L2_QD_4_ _.P=

b6 -1 -._.-

b7C -1.

IA

about a male

applied, who

risen quaxd

|:Idio' atluiisemhewe-ve"r, -that. he heaid 5 mmi¢£" H

detainee being dressed in female clothing with makeup

was given an involuntary lap dance from a at the direction 0f.militar92L interrogato1_:s ....

is:-F K - ' is_

-1 I

b7C l""'-

was a tactic

cooperation.

Z * i]The rumor lioa e

u s on *Eh**dEt fEee6own and ain his ed't0 reek e _ a g _

AI d not xemember where or from whom he

heard the rumor. AI could provide no further information

concerning this rumor. .

I

1

RESPONSES-54
.. '1' é

jw - - in nu-I ,*_

L ' - _ 1 -.

_ E

1 .

u

I-

|

I

J

92

0

92

.1

Jr1

 q

H-4-_

.__.

F?

,..

.,._;

92

L.

_.1;

E2:-'

fiff

;_"Ev,

r92'

E.

_,92

~..

!..

'1'.

'3".

1- .

-.<Y'-

.l%§.i

..':»"~

r..

§}'»FIeld 'O1f_[c'eAcjqulrlnEvidence V

"'1-J >-git.

=Fleceipt=_Given[3Ye§QNo ' ._,J.;;|_;,-¢;_'~;;j§l__:.

92§iFf:_h_ fl ' I _' - i -' ._ J

l?_.-;;- =.- W -

921.r:.¬:__ I . _l "

31; . '~" '

5 fl '" - -

5* = W °

:4.

1,

%;' "- T "7 . 1..;u.1 ,_

. _..,_:!.-_ ._I

L

. -;r" - . - ---=92=' :-='.-:<;.*-.~"--:?~>-f~¢=@¢§:?F. ' - ,- ' -. ".'-3.1 '-'. "_"-_--J11-..-_"-L '.-I . e . e L e .-_---1-¢_r'-_ ._ .-1-_-._-;-92_. | _..| ' .' '-I-' I_ ' -_;-'," ' ;-.'.-..';5»._'-..'.§-_

' ' _ 3, -- '- "4 ,'_4-91¢,-.31. "_§%} ""~""- " " - ~- -- -"-~ ~ ~- ~-.-P" *-= --92;¢;¢I,,-.:=~--;_;.w

.

.

.

r .'- . '--1-1--.1 ..,»__

- . _ '4 -?.1q.'_">

 - . 9;- ;_f_'{r_,

_ =-':;;=<'-5";-*;;1¢:-,=IA

.' ' . . - ' ">'T' '-'-»%1i.1:=F?.I-.'1.< - ' - - , _ ,r-/,.3»g;,' Universal-O;ise'File.Number 2?1zn@->-,;3;§2¢1jtI§e

senal # 9f"_'Orlginatinq_ _Dec|.|_ment. -$3.-. 2:

'Date'Reeeqve:_I"-5 9?-j7- qy W

.-' . --':=IQ3;§'3'$ _--:5-1;-»

 __k_ i .._§:s_ ' e -qnkmmaimugmq e 7

._. - _ 1-3;; _ .; I

- -- . _

;,;:" {AdcIress'ef0o111I1b:.;tnr! _ _. -"_.";'>'-'. 114?]

.. - - . __ - _-,-.»er;';5.?=>@*=E»I

* ' " " ' " 7* .

ByJig F 1 _ 1=~*;<'*

- - . INEIIIWI Sndalnentl -

. '2 _';"f_;;-1*r".~'§F_~§ -5? ." _ I . -j'?i3. #5:

'1Tn.Be Reiumed"ClYesNo <-Ff?

l.' 2- --'.

randJuryMatenhl - Dzsseminete

toFluie 6 !,Federal Hules of'Cfiininal Prmedig

DYesNNO - .-H

-_;i'1;_*;|':%;;_?_._=.s§;_ Ti e.

'5. .. '.'-'.3'-;~'¢'92

. ,. W

.-,»:..=:;-ii-5=,'r-%;~

...._la.-4%,-,-;, i

__

Fleferenee: _ '" - _ _.,_

 - -' 1cbmmuhim»n"E1iéiés1néM-=wnéu *-'=-=-;§¢;Ir:;@r;;;i%;.,

.' - 5 -

_ _ .. i . 1.

Descrlpglon. Or:gir_|al notes re intennew of_

~' e - - W -.1-+.-»-

. , __!-;.'<|-,,§,c.i"t.:f ' ._ :J'.,--.w.~;q_:.92

I? . .1?- '

Q;-"f'<>=.:'§:';"".."'

_ _ I_'._:-":-;:.|92-.1

1 '1.- -F!"';.eZ{?f..

._:T=:%§.?;"_s,;?;~

- ' 5*", 5._j "if-_-_'"'..'*

. F.. _._'_,._r.

. - ' .-J-59-=:"§-i

 - RESPONSES-55 " I4 - .}L3.--if-.1§*_5;':-='

- rs-.;92..1. -

- .. ' r =':'_'.i~.'-- 1'.

92, ¢.'<;:j11

-1 0 ""'.-

; .

- ., f

.. 92"4 .

-a viz.

-1 I

.-

b6 -1 1

b'?C -1

b6 -1

b'?CI .1

-I

;l'-.&#

.{-._'

,.

92

1

92
~ F --------.__ ._l__.,.,_,...,,.__.?=.T__..,.._.._._ ..._........-. . . , _ . I -

U

fins5':-1-"man §B1f§=§=s1§- -g_:.__E :_>__§_1%I;£r1;-1;__?j_g1IE,_- _ . '

Ig.-35""! l

. _ 1 E1_:=I; -3,, -»;-..-I-.__._.: :1,

Ii .

.... .5.5.'-r

*F'5

.-..- _~--w»- 7

i.

$1iiaarfamia 92

' 7i1%f§7®§I;§#§§IF§l¥7!@

- C '1 7;...T;5r§;§.§.H7.s1.§::¥:;;§;:Y::2@:#§.171@.

_7____ 7. 7L _Q..£..__ ._._... .... L

7 77 777 7 _/ I .

7 777777_7_:_'___7.777_.7 7777i. ?7r=-".77"777

-2 .-______.77 7777._77 7717-7-1-1- F: 77 : 7 71 7,__..7

.£§..*..C._7_77 _Z7

i i *7 ' * "1.---' b'1'C2 _

~

1@

- 7 7 _ . 7..7..._7_.__.__b__2

r " - _ 92 7 7 6 ' 5*v7-77; ..7;_¢.1.=...=¢7 <77J72¢--¢i4Za77:u§77.-L b7C 27.

75 " '- ' - - '"" " '.-' -'~"'"-:-~'-- ---~ --'---.-;- ----'-17..., 7...

 i77.7. 7»7*'k4:_¢7-r7 , _7_7771;

 

- - 77,5777 .

-;71-" . 77- _"77177.-T 7 ,7 #77-7-7c7-792,_71~77fr1<!-,L77a.1_ .' "' -_-:-~-=7_;¢je;*";92;~=gr.;_".§'-"1 i-*7<%T'=~

,'.*.-2~=_'-,~

i __ upL»7~:-*"+7~.77-»~7=; 7-:*-f 794 ~7§7:e--77% 771¬L:*-

L1

T1!"'=7¥7""__E$-Q7:--¢--..7 -95.77,-§ .77 ' 7-. 777-ii; 77.7-717 7 '7 1777-'-"7f

77/"'7"!'f77'7"""-'9'-57'!-é *"§7"7 7::"*"l"1'5E77- 77ll'7l:92-1.: 777 77 77_7 _' 7777 .__7_- _-71"_:;

"£1797-Q7-7.-7" H ' 177-5-""=77W 2-:r7&.7f**=-I=I7-3*~P777'I? 7rT57'3&# Q->11-&#

-

92

<-'4? -"1"-"" [777 77 " 77777 7 7 77 7777 7777777777777777 77777 77 7 777

____._ _7.7-__,7.__7_ 1»/=:$777e=2777§' E 77!7.:..§,_.§ -7'" LE17_'-*7! 7.?¢'=-'51

*i_-777-_.-

':_" ""117 ' ' @.r 7 &7777<7~7,~;<'77'7-77 77-L7=7:7»7-774.774-71-:-:1 5:-7-=71.-¢.7¢,.@r7_.r-@1474 77775?_~_~7-7§7¢77..3:-4

'-=;;57;<17s7Ij1-e777~7'1z »<»..=»>r7.7777*r3_7,.11¢~.T;7r»-97i77 7 77 77 75 _7' 77777 7

F

I

'1i

'_7 7 RESPONSES-55.-~ I 4"-"'_ d :7L7':f'_:-4-'92 E :1-57' -f_'92- _ 77, 7 7 _ 7 _ _ 7 +7777:7-77777777771

. . ' ' _ . L

- . ' . . -' _:__. __'__7;_"_'7 _. _737__-77'-7-7777 ' .7-.777 - "'7-1

"-4--';~'-=¢_- " '1»-"I-'Z'1 _7 7_7_7_ -Z!-7'-T"i"" 7;_.___7E'~$7 7 __7=I:=={77;¢:~:7~'7;;-;5..77;--*¢ _777_ _7 7 77 77

%747.¢77-"ml- Q;~r2==7'7'»~;---7~:r .77777 7777-777777777 77 7 777 77

92

H-.92

¢_L:f______J-Q-I177-7¢l-£77 ¢L'"7779 7 777777777;7__7_.77777:7

77 :7-*<'7¢£.4"777-!»492.7sti777¢-~;7_7f1@177-¢--2 -1-7"r2==~77 '?7~:1

|..¢...,=.._..._§

;77@£:r.777:7=7~77,e7- @7773.-.77>-.7777-7» £777-2;~+77;7,77@.....u1 7774877! 77~7<» 177777777

}7l-l<7¢».77§77777=E: 7!?-'2" -' * 757i:-* -77"i' 5- 592'-¢-7777 -7i¢'F=_>T -9eQ77755*:~_J77_*.l_¬1=r!l7*77777

1' 2"}. 7 7-=~=-=& 7 _?ii-77r_ r ~ ~ f fi; :i;_:i:f_____PfH___r 7_7

-_..__ _-._.7._....._T+92

,,,,, 7__77___.._77__l77+ "~7._.:l_§7-=7-777{777 7<-7*Tl!§7:;7.,777Q'Pi77l?:7:1170777 *7-:77=l7 7711:7773 £7F72:-7T7!=-'-Z77'

_r'*4417 77

"92| L ' <'l1'==-..e<£.___§:£.__1=7-_.J:£.1=,7-7_Q..7,

77-131-71:I I -
%.

1

92

J u

5'1 "H; JKK" WK ; ' K -F t"S 5- & "'3 »_ it _£{_ i _

 .__.-._~._._,...____.._____ "" K __,,_.,____;, "1/J,, ""V , ___,, J-2.!-_'__,Q _..___ _

_ " -=:"==-3'92i,,°-L'

92=_-._ ____________:__:-:1iJ§;""""_1 a,[!¢_;_=-.-"T 77¢-%»'92-u_|,2'._'J9g,._/W

, ?,,*____ __ 7

92_*........_._- .&¢a3,;-:~=-1,!Qt,=ZL=-7-'§,,,j_ f , _,?,?_ f W_

"" s =-~v-P J"?-&_,.<...._-L-buf-FL? W-vie-¬-I;;;:g' _

.._.-_..-.w___ _ ,___..:1!_J:3_;_@H

____._, _ _, ;,¢92,g:'r :"f92-1;!" __ J .

___ - ~15*7-_~5:_' f?J" ,l'"92-I £7 l in

X ;c- r--.9;--=92 ..»_--3-JQ-_._..j'92'_ c,__l'92'926-'1:-7 .7I§"F=-c 8. - 7;;$4.7_a,___ 92. ' 'i_r'e

r E H. 1? !.:_777_!' 9292'92--if

92

_ _lY'92_,__-ff e__»~,-¢-_1g ___5- |a'T"92-I _-;{_F_:g~_Q~ _g,,--.-.p__T_i _7___ _, :__ __ __

I - . " 7 =' *-'7"__@!-72-.¢§.1=Z_*'

| ..,_.....,...,____....,._._...--........ ,_____l'____cl&,g_..,L__5'l _ !1f=~__,-£"=91..n,.__Q___f1_.¢__1;;,¢_,L_,,_

,_,______

-bl ' "' " " 1 W TF5? *4,k§*-'-§L.'Z7-ll H-:23 ,::_1 1

"":I

_ __.._. :|____£' I1

Yy : j . h

*r-a 13»-=3,A.-1" /¢.._..,_,;,_,. 4,,

__1__~-1-_1_".|1-.1 r/q;:L _ g

=r'»?"~i1-L '+-=*="1'@-=-"T:@=_<1*s_,_'~*i4@=-zc *1», ,,;_¢1=_-T'Z**-92~'-=- =1»--.,-¢ 3?"

§_°-g-irg-_--_1 *-Hz. _ _ __,,________ _ _'T'=1_r_

Q

_ 'L'*"-s_;;?!"_'--'9l_92"1'_*3:-_'§ *5 _@*','5!_-r!- 1-9-Xv 5:5» 1

_n.it_<."._i :'4'L- a 5 ;;_-L-5l3'e?_

hiLi! i #1 .

9;-__ 27¢-31»g.L;F-Tl-é- L1147'-_ Q-a.¢~_-4 144:-2 77§._=!192_:" M;

1 - .

-----.._.._._.__-;:......_lLi:.Z.. .__ ' *iii _ _.. , _ ..__ .______ _ ,_

...._._.-.._.._..,...-._.._-.-92..-....

-..h___..--.__-.._-¢,-_..-......_,..._.__...  ,,,, .._. ?_*,__********___ ___

.-

JI';£' . ':_

_ " .0-i

. '=:'.1'r

EQWH;."|»-__

n__ ,_ _,,_,__

= 2:

.2» ~11" _

RESPONSES-57

92 . _
M i*__r""' ulwu - luwléfr .

*5-"Tr-as-~p -

Questions Conggrning ActivitiesatGuantanamo Bag,CubsQTMO} -

DescribeyourroleatGTMOandtheapproximatetimeframe. 1-==~'s ---. §<~'""'1 5*F

' = s;=.:r=..n-if no -ae-~-I .

If a memberofaninterviewteam,pleasexplaintherolesofthememberswhich

comprisedyourinterviefs-_' teamrM.-r"c _.-i.-s--.- _ '

Describeanyaggressivetreatment, interrogations orinterviewtechniquesemployedon

detaineesatGTMQ,whichyouwitnessedorareawareowhichwas-not consistent with

B131Tm; Dos-poneyi.g92iiceii;;efsf!a~3e1='~esarf*'e*"?1~e3r ;a';s_-',§_; - f-§_§.;---z;-L

What,ifany,wasyourunderstanding ofDepartment ofDefenseanthonzation forthe '

permitteduseof_11ars_i11faggressi!*e_inte1rogation tech11iques_2.»v.-pi *1-'-=__-----v-3* '6 10 r-W"rDescribe howyoubecameawareof DOD authorized techniques. .-'1/I A ;

Inyouropinion,wastheaggressivetreanneiit,-interrogations orinterviewtechniques

employedon_de_ta.inees at'G'Ii921iQ,"§_iifliich i§vi_i1_1esse_d orareawareof,consistent or _

inconsistent Withyournderstanding of DOD authorized activity?Lfinconsistent, '-

how?Identifyanyotherindiiliduals whosviniessed thisactivity. 3/; A '5 _  -

Do youknoyrtheidentityofeitherthedetaineeorthe DOD employeer/contractor, andthe

approximatedatetheincidentoccurred?A--_ o - ' ' '

If youwereawareofanyireatrnent, interrogationorinterviewteclniiques. employedat

GTMOwhichwasinconsistent withFBUDOIpolicy_a_1;i DOD authorized

techniques, did-youdocument-or report-it~to-.ar-1yone?' if so,howandtowhomdidyou

reportyourconcerns? /I/B ' _ - - ' '

PleaseidentifywheretheinterviewsoccurredatGTMO whichyoubelievemayhave

beenicontrarytopolicyorauthorizedtechniques. ,1./.-..-s-e - _ -

Didyouhaveanysubstantive contact with Policeorother government

personnel atGTTMOregardingdetaineesconditionortreatment?-Describe.~'92=>

Describeanyallegationsofmisconductormistreatmentby.U.S.personnelbroughto

yourattention by intervieweesorothers?-1-'<-M ¢~5-"Jain./'1'» -I-T1;asrs-Ti.».. Q--

Areyouinpossession ofanypictures, video, aiidio,notesorotherdocumentation which

depictsordescribesaggressivetreatment,interrogationsorinterviewtechniques

played ondetaineesatGTMO?Areyouawareofanyonelsewhois inpossessionof

suohiterns?/vs, .»vo"~_¢----<-»'~:.. e--I~:92.-..-,_ . -

. I I

_ RESPONSES-58 '

.-at an--mi.

r-.92.a. _.

. '_.-. - _-i.-' ..~ .*|_-_J_.L

92

l

b7C -1

if

it

l

r

l

l

I

ii

L

l

la

.

i

-it
7 __ 7 I

, r

13! - Do you have any additional information _re1ating' to the treatrnent of detainees at GTMO I.

which should bebrought to our attention? ;.BZ..'*'¢ 1 1%---~-9 , cu. 1* rum f 4*"-""  '*

 yvl-.1.-Ll of """~5"~. '

S

92

u

92

1 RESPONSES-'39

Q5
 j 3'

Positive

Response

Number 6

n

4

1
N MaSS&g¬ . ° Page 1 0f2

. - _ _;' s9292P§ ;92 d;}~5*"- s

7%; it 1i»s_r33___rFl-;»,5m,,6 " " r r - 1; 1 - - - . Wis? Eh

Te . l%_i_li¢TD>_<@Il s g i L - U/92 . ,5,» _;t 5...>. Subject: RE: GTMO ' ' ' *" " I -C .5, -

OK, I will oonsideryou a positive response _and oneed for you to do the EC. .Qnoe we-get all the responses, a

detemaination will be madeas-19-wl=|o gets interviewed. -Thanks-again. _ . - I

- . . ---_-0rlginaIMessa_ e-I-' . - ' _

be -1 re--»i::::|rm>><~=s> -

bjrr; -1 __5BI'lt: WEGFIESUBE: Jill? 14, ZUU4 2258-PM 5 ,, I __.¢

To: INSD! FBI!

- - Subject: -RE; GTMO

seusmve BUT UN_CLASSIi'-ED " '

_'NN-R on ., . ,

- Yes. There was-an incident of observation of a detaineein a stress position". ljhis was within the regs of

' military techniques buigoutside MIOG No Bureau personnel involved]. That was the lirnit of direct

obsenratioris. In témts of knowledge of mistreatment i can speak to that in great-detaii from formal

meetings which I attended and informal discussions with DoD personnel. BC _ .- ' _

,_ r - -eh - - -- . . .

" -~OriinalMessae--- _ ' _ - ' _b6 _1 -' rm-1~ialrI~$r>><rB1>i 2

hm _l Sen_i::Wednesda _July14,20i]4_2:54_PM .. . . To=l'__i___t'Ll _ . C-TB! an

' __ Subject: RE: GTMO J1", I _ '-

_. sertsnrgiaaur-i1uci.Ases1.ee '

Non-Recon-Q .. . - - - _'

- OK, l will print this out and retain for when the interviews start. iwiil take this'as' a negative - -

 response for Buau employees. -Any observations of other agencies mistreatment of detainees?

__ --Ori lnal Message-m ' - - be -1 s Fmm=E::iUD! FBI! ' A

b'rC -1 ' Sent: Wednesday, July 14, 2004 2:38PM

 I_NSD!. FBI! .

' T: s é= F5Ii is

- -Subject:RE:GTMO - - _ _

sausmve am" uucLAs_stEiEo ' RESPONSES-60

__|~| -RCO _ . _ -- _

~ bi -1 i - s ~ ~ - »

 WC "1 ' ._ ;_i ' "

~ .. At Or "1 t tit o i.ti-"711 l~ l,92,*;-;.3~¬_Qj t_=].>¢qa!,_o _, ,it~1.sria. w s H r s IF

- that time. it seemed the Bureau's focus was identiiying any iiabiiity in the form of direct

involvement. I would be happy to sit down with -you and walltyou through what! saw as the

_ predictable onset of aggressive treatment, interrogations or interview techniques. In short,

the-Bureau personnel there had no direct particiaiionl But I think I may be able to assist in.

describing the landscape for you and giving you the details about where some things went oft

the tracks. ljust-moved to ITIC [Tyson's Corner! and am phone-less, but l_ have this e-mait

--savanna
.1 _ . .| _.

Message '  ' 6 ' . Page 2 of 2'

Q - .

- up and running.-~ -- - »

- : 92

l b6 -4 k

W "1 CTD!Fly Team -- "

' SENSJTIVE BUT _UNBLASSIFlED- _

You have been identied as having conducted an assignment at GTMO, Cuba since

- 9111101.. The inspection Division has beentasked with contacting those employees _

who have served in any oapaoltv at GTMO and obtain information regarding the -

treatment of detainees. Employees should immediately respond to the following 1

- 1! Employees who observed aggressive treatment, interrogations or interview _ '

- _ teohniques on G-{MO detainees which was not oonsistentwlth Bureau interview

policviguidelines, should respond via email for thepurpose of a foliow-up i|_'|oervie'w.

Positive email responses should be directed to: " ' - -' , .

'  - b6 -1 "

I -._ _ _ - - _lnspeot1onDivision_-_ . ' - .

- . . 1, - - I

2! Employees who served at GTMO and observed no aggressive treatnirrt.-of"

' detainees, should respond via an EC documenting a negative response. The EC -

should include the employee's ofoial Bureauname, title. and tenure of assignment at GTMO. ' ' ' -, _ ' "

The EC shouldbetied Counterterrorism Division, GTIvlO,_inspectior1 Special _,

. lnquiryt, . 1 __ .- ' s

le # 297-HQA13276S9-A. The EC should not-be uploaded; but only-serialized, with _e- ' hard copy forwarded to: . - ' ' ' ' - ' - I _ _

Inspection Division ._

Ofoe oflns estions ' iii be '1

. -Room rear t ' T P7? '1 

' 1

_'§ENSlT]UE _B_l..[[ _U_|iCL_AS_S[F|ED

' SENSITIVE BUT l._lNCLA§§lFliED .

. J

SEQJSITIVE-BUTUNCLASSIFIED - -

5ENS_lTNE B'UT_L!NCLASS1EiED

RESPONSES61 .

. t . .
-=. A,_-;_<._

FD-30.2 Rev. 10-5-95!

I G

. _l_ _

" FEDERAL BUREAU or iNVESTIGA'lION

I .

. ' _ Dalefl-r41$¢IiPii°11 0311552004

136 l _ - I _

Division, ea quar ers,.EOD: was contacted - b6 -2

- regarding his knowledge of any aggres.siv_e'treatment, ' bf!-C _2

interrogations, or interview techni

{GTMOJ After being advised as to the identit of the interviewing

ques at Guantanamo Bay, Cu-be

.Agent and the purpose of the interview, |:_-LI provided the b6 ._l

following information to thirteen specific special. inquiry """ questions: . - - . ' ' _b7c '1

. Zdescribed his 15

135 "'1 a Case Agent tasked to participate

b? j .-]_his tenure,Z| was part of-an

- of FBI investigatoris!, Department

' investigator[s}, and a translator.

month TDY assignmentat GTMO as

in detainee interviews. During

interview team which consisted

of Defense DoD! '

' Investigator {s} representing

DoD, were -from Army Criminallnvestigative Division CID!, Air

Force Office of Special Investigations IOSI! and Naval Criminal Investigative Service NCISJ According to [:l -the'EB'I S

-

. usually took the lead role during detainee interviews. I-iowever, I

DoD Investigators also participated in detainee -interviews and onoccasion took the lead. -.

I '' h. I never - participated in any -aggressi_ve"treatment,

interrogations, or interview techni ques employed on detaineesat '

GTMO-inconsistent with FBI or DOJ olicy/guidelines. -- However, "

during the summer of 2002, walked into a Camp Delta i

observation room and noticed a detainee in an interview room

rubbing his leg due to possibly being placed in~a stress position.

Q56 -1

b7c ~1 bu, -

The detainee was wearin le irons andwas handonffed with cnffs b6 _'13 chained to his waist advised the chains were adjusted-to b7 _1 3 I

force the detainee to stand in a baseball catcher position. The C detainee was being questioned by two military officers. | .

- was unable to proved the names of the military officers or e name

. -to| or number _§j__the -detainee. * I - _ | JAG, usnc Reserve]. [:|did|not have |:| verbally reportedthis in

92

. any substantive oonfact with|::|regarding this matter -

advised that during the fall of 2002, detainee # was being held in the Navy Brig at Camp Delta. According to b6 -1 the FBI questioned detainee #|:| for approximately two x; _ - months with negative results. The military then moved detainee

to Camp XRay. General Geoff Miller requested permission to

Investigation on 09;/_3;O/209{1fiia":Vienna, Virginia i W _ Z _ -

. Filc29,1-no-.A13'27659-A 7 '_ y o1__" ii to no be 

'1? 935-A _, __ b7C

 This dooummr contains-neither ecommendations nor oonolusioos of the FBI.

it and its contents are not to be distributed outsid: your igoncy. ' '

'_ Date dictated _N/A. WH _ 11 - RESPONSES-62

11 is the pi-upeny of tho FBI and is loaned 1o_your agency;
l

. _. 3_ . I _ is i ,_

-.,, t® O,

FD-302a um. 1n-6-as!

' :-

23": -so-A13216'69-'A

' l b6 -1 '

' b7 -1 Gonnhu.-m'o11ofFP-3020? __|:| g ,_ ___ ,0, _Q_Q/1D/_2[!H !L_,Pag

utilige iésééiéi iheéiregative techniques on detainee~#E:]i.....,, b6 Q4

Corbett stated the FBI and DoD investigators had no further contact mo -4

with detainee E. once he was transferred to Camp X-_-ray. . V

Durin December 2002, Lieutenant[:::::::l Nurse, U;S. ' '- "Navy, i-nformed[:| that detainee #E|had been admitted to the

base hospital for hypothermia. During a'daily staff meeting, ' b6 L3,4 |;_] inquired about detainee #l:_|bein admitted to the hos ital b7C l,3

for ypothermia. Lieutenant Colonell ' -[advised] ithat <

detainee #[:]was not die nosed_with hypothermia.| Ito d I , |::|that detainee bod core tem erature. #|lg'| had Accordin- to[::i¬::] no add 'onal low blood res.-sure along with low

Y P G

information was provided to him regarding detainee ii ,

-|:| described his understanding of _DoD'authorization .

b51 for the permitted use of harsh/aggressive interrogation techniques b7: '1 --as very'unE:lea'r"'.' [:1 advised he became aware of DoD ' '

. authorized techniques'v1a meetings with General Miller.

I '. .-[:::::::]had no substantive contact with Military Police. d

or other U.S. government personnel at GTMO regarding detainee _

conditions or_treatment and was unaware oi any specific allegations

of misconduct or mistreatment by U.S. personnel alleged by - '_-

interviewees or others. [::::::] stated he had no pictures, video,-  ' audio, notes, or other documentation which depicted or described 

aggressive treatment, interrogations'or interview techniques" _

employed at GTMO orknowledge of anyone else who has in possession

of such items. " . - -

b6 ~l

b7C -1

1'

92

-'

_ _ , RESPONSES-63

iii in-is i*_ __

Ii-nn-3-i1$_*|i
.'i'

I

.|.'

92.'

>..

M

M .

.- 1. r. _

L.

. 92.'

.3.'92'

P q-'

.1"? * qa Q

gm le-':

;:;;T;;,i=le_iarenc:_e. i ~ ' . -.i92?°'1""P$=~?*F9Pj5¢=!P§l"q.*!#'9"J.¢.". .

-13ate_Hace'ived =- i_ ~ 1;_V_

=10Flulel e!,_'.I=.:e:riEi_-r'.2"a.'!-.lEi1.ii:r;:"-C_r_imhi'r|al Pkoieééire

-. .- 92_"r. . 1» . K 1-_, I .,--,.-__ ; __|-_.=-- .__... ,

I

92

. _ .

-_,__..__.___..__. . -._..r__,,J, _ _..=..

- . ... - . ___

Uhlversal Casa§F|Ie Number2i7-#0-Axazmr.

FieldOfceAcquiring.E_92fide-_.nce_ _ .

Serialif-ofOriginatingDqcument " :~1.

. . 92-

. _ .:

FromI.r,54":I ' _..

r ' I A -

r r r .<.'¥=!sr.2@=.;=r¢-1»;==;=w=»r~@J'" L

i%_ ._'- L -:">:r»:~F:-'- -?»1-W: W7

J iarwlsnllaeml * - 1

To BeHeiurned Eljigs.

Fiec:aipt'Gi92qen' Fl,_Yes_ _'

_ . 1 - . ._ . . .. ._ _.., .

C-i:'~an'd.Juiqf.Méiiqri§j_'¢i§§51 T

V » T u,§'é?%2:*1i1LNo,...' . r .

l"|t1e: = . -.:

1.

' r "I

. _»_. :=

an .- - ~ 1-.:- .. I. I I

92- - . . . . ....  .-. . . I-=._ __ ._. ._ . ., _ _

 - - -.. -1. . - . _- __ 7_______92,,_,|_- __; ____

' ;3.92;-7| ' = .».'.- -

. . /,'< , Pes'c'ripti0n.' .m'¬-1§r.§ir.§§i§¢r.¢'' - -.1; - . , a,_' r

>,.':-_-iv. '. ' _ .- -ii»:-Y, - '. - .

L-c'."-;. ' _ '_.' _ .- .

r 1'... ' ._.-; - .. _-r :

1'1 92 J L-'. ~

L":I ' H»-5,

:.:_;;.

i...=

:.-e:

.__ .___:. _ _ v @ . -. -

, . 5 , .

__ .

b6 l

b'?C 

J-J

-,.-__<,- _ -

"1-_:.. ..!"T.."]_

:-

1:

1

92'1

.."'

..921'1..-

.

. I».": '.

b6 l '

b7C *1--'

- 4

b6 -1*

b'FC-1
_-'.| _______

:1 ' . .

JLL; w K ,

_ _ Cm v<r,,-.,1....=., 11"»- ¢»_Z:>72{@/mg»? @

..-....1.-,3.._,92_»_.. 1...»-

. .,__, - 92 92 - 9292- K b6~1 /9gm; , N me-1 _

- b7C -2

__ Q1ACw4,;-/»¥ ; { K w { '7 y-J

f W _,£]~4-§=_?-- ;0Z§2v_9;'l~ j j _*_ ' f ,. . _.92

' @ Y»-5i 7 In 3 7 77+-.:.

_7 ___

92

W ___

,-., K Tr»;-.11-T! .3/I; K _ K: V - ' "_

. H3 j?-=3 .01.W. vi, W_ - ?__ j __#

" r f". ' i "1 ~ <.;

L '"1,'2£@#Eh i 7 "5. ' 

A 11 - fr; ? - - ? . I

. _u¬I¢r|j7Q/r-:!'%1/afvrrw __

_.-;w>._.:.."_.._  ._"

*2!' . ":."".:":1@"'_»...*.=+1=

- -' /QT - -'4" a/:0 ._ .r1;;;'-*&r

I '  _" ~  ~

{ t» g!_T,T_

I

 ' H. V 4 4; ,_ 4*}!/;'J

- .__ _ n I _ , - _ __ _._f_,__,,1 I;;.._. __ I W I v I 1 , £1522? dd 625&

l___h

I

A W H .;?¢im-iv ml-:4 " _ ___T 7 .¢;-.5,J-H5&25; _J1L-jwws/E; Jkf//1' 1-;;_,'Z9»'|:

 /ff?lf92;14~§-.-_i9 ¬

hair

we -4: _

Tm-F -1 | | ¢=12=¢¢- mlmiéj» =-Mwa

pv{7;3¢//j/_ 1; ll!»-v5_*. g-jY!"$"_-" ..@#"f~~.I .- 1..r.*.*=..1*_.._

_Em_{ , »lR';fg; LR_.7%m.Q@_;{,m; anwlhlbé 5;m 4;-/»5;

_;. { _$sE@2. '7 V;

b6 -4 *

92 ms -4

1 -441:

L r . _ r 7 7I" *7 MW. .. i " _

92 ' 

ml?iflfI'¬_%l1&#n5W£; if|§m 

.-In _r-"~

/{__:@

i i 7 7 _* _I'ifJ_"r if r if W

7 :

L2

E ow; 4>_;>;4»zW- 41 AF/3/L 5 Wm14¢, V

T92M~r$<Q a-¢{f"'S<"l 53] _-lo IA-M7"§¬~¬Iii¢rJM=&#_

L

t

YmJ1'I>-:»<' /1,65? §+w WM<_1;@i mg 7

' - RESPO NSES-65 ' 

4
, .

-'-'- 1-10"-"" -- __. _ _ '-,,--,-_.._--.- ._.._. . - ' _,¢--"-'-u-"*»---------.-1.----..-.-.-_,_-.. ..._.....-..----1-rwu-----an--v

Wm »~" W M@»~l.4

3 _ _{zL;cQ_] 1W1 A |M»»/»=»»<+¢ e

K.ELF 5I_If ii.TMY%",1,4'. A1hut,I014; §;1f¬_']['t'L" if;/man/if/-,-_9¢.77 JWJ* %fm/113/p4»W~/- ' _1_

ii i-'927____92 ' ,7 - __7 . M WW - i _éw

f 1' 7 »/4: i % ' 1 ":LM"~*l£1'~" F j j j

Z ' _W _SJ5'e:-5,;-1=_f_|7!_/Z ha!£}§@q~F¢F _ vlvSH155-,» ii

; - H-;s»1.¢ /La.»//Ja/W/I _ ' 

i H wag §J4.2I'fL -pt-r:A:I»7;;r;&I J

_2"/*'§§92 8/ @254 _ _ 92

s1 cm M M ~H» ~@¢>~r'*/;»»»*&

V7 1gliifytsj ¢¢5,fé;a;',é i .

1 j 7,;/ '2/in» ~;?»f'~_-s:g/"- , _ j __,. j

@* $5. 3 4 /,

 Z " *::"' " * 7

J.

 -____ ___V._-____ 7_ __ _ __ _ ___I7 __ ____ _ 7: 7

92

- . _ - , _, , __ , __L

, Q M, , ,

X

*"E$@  @6191l"»""'? @@%*@W#% %

3 92 ' *7 7*' jWW - 7 7 ' - -jm *1 " I

92 ' I

_ _ _ 92

,_._. @ Jj, GgD*H*/__;§1;[erf!'¢" JfgoM- _ - I __ ___ ___

J5 @Lm¢-.3! NJ92'I$ !%' ¥_ {hf 355-/IrI J

T - . . - .

Y W .. , 5 _ W £116 ' >::'__ 4; " -'~»~&; _ |

I  . L ___E$¢_§4 1!£19a";~j11_ -'/ ,1%"1'1'

-7 j 1 j i

L @~¢M 1 1

L _ { __

RESPONSES-66 -

Q

QaMme 1 ;
.*

92

92

J

_

1

-in

- ~- -..

I .._.<._,-.. .1_-.¢-..'-up-

J]@~~1§>~$*+*@@1<*ir<¢{~31 5% K Q,

" _1 _ _ ' **i ,fL:::;:;T'_ I ______,__ _ __ H

< T i 7 j

i

7 92 - _ J7 7 ""'777 i "

 92

w

_ ____r _ _ _

92 _

 I

F

E % 1 RESP6wsEs-57

"* .
c

PositiveResponse

Number 7
x I 

929292 -

2

V Messzigc

r ' ' 

Q -- - Pagelof

_ i I .

 |~so! |=an _- b6_1 it L  -.1. "

.. " bi-' - - ' - - i¢~@»s< -=51» - ° 1 I i - 92

Subject: RE: GTMO "  ' _

Yes. I will put you oown asapositivé response. Thank ydé. -- -

... :' . "' . '_l

. ___.;:,'_'.';.:_4-_.;;-=-'. ..;:|.92' ""-

- . '--Ori inalMessa e-- . " - From: H0! PB?! .- '

b6 "1 Sent Fri a Ju 09 2004 5-so PM  -"9 '1 'ru= . "1uéo! FBI! l H '

- - ¬_||.l_l:||'-.f _: : - . in

_ E" _ u UNCLASSIFIED

non-gecogg - - " _ 1

' _- l observed wl-lat msy have beén aggressivéiechniques used byjg-FBI interrogators, Does this still fall

- into what yougrg looking into? ," . .1 / . _. -

b6 -1 ' '  ' /' " " '

. s .

.- » - .

. __ . Houston Dwlsnon-1-"Corpus Christi -RA - RE5|J_Q|92|$E_5-68 - Jr" r - _ r

. I .

~

b6 -1

b7C -1

i .

FlF1F92lI92f92f'92J

,_.--:3-':~.'- Ir -I *:- _ / - --"f>-;f{- I- -"----Or|g1nalNle,ssage=~-__ | - - I X -' .-P! - _ - '

_. . ». - . _ .. _,- _v_._. _-

Frmp: Mqki,-STl'E92fEN'C. INSD! FBI! ' -' .  _ '- - _ I .

seht:.5nuay,_Ju:yo9,"2o041=42PM__ ~ - _ - _ _ ' .

.r===|_"i|W cMM_i,~ EB1!:|:r|<MM> -FBI H0> FBI!; »L {10! com ,_ MM FBI N BI

 mQ_ s=s: MM! FBI! LA! FBI

HO} FBI! * an FE! ATTLE FRANI-CI FBI 1

Ml_l!£FBI]. L LA! PB 1 9-"! FBI!.

HOUFBI J! Fl3I! _ LD FBI UN!

_

---92 FB1>;* 7 ' 7 NY! FBI!:. ' BLFBI!; V AN!

 FBI!; NO! 'FBI!; IR!' FB{. NY! "

 FBIi:~i.!FB-! FBI HUHU l - mi

.FB1- CGHFB1!: Ml&l!, FBI! MM FBI!;

l H0! FBI!: Il?~! FB1- NY!

 FBI!; AQ!GA!;. LSl_ FBI; - j .

 <rH:>1 FB1>; Am- FBI!; i N0 FBI!; l

T CID FBI!, _ MM FBI! o ITD! F51!

 * _ c'm! FBIi - ~ ASD! FBI - MM'! FB1'

I WP! FBI!: NY! cm!; |<><ran; V

Z PH! {FBI};-CUMMINGS, ARTHUR M. cm! FBI!; - MM FBI!;

 om! FBI!; - mo! FBI! - MM!

MM FBI!; MM! FBI!; MM! "

 FBI! MM! FBI!; | s1=!- |=a1 ; _ NY!. FBI!; co FBI!; * [ s1=!= - i r

 SE!- FBI' IR FBI __]=x! FBI _ i~1o!_ !; ! ! ii FBI nv 1 "PX con. ;- - H0.! or

 FBI!; IR! FBI! -CTD FBI!

 rs! FBI!; :-E! FBI! Px! BI

 WP! FBI {NY} FBI} w|=! FBI!; DE

 FBI! NF!_ I_=BI CTDUFBI _ . rw

 FBI'!; ' ALHF51; ' ' CUHFBI!; KKXHFBI!;

 FBI!;

' ~
¥ -

. e-.' . . .. _. - ' _ .

Message -" , ' , Q I Page 1 of

. | . V | ir~1so;| FBI! .. __ - - . """"' """' "77"" ' 'J'_'77"'""*" "W "*''"'"'""'" "'*."""  "W ""-""""*"""'E' "'

' ' "

- Sent: Wednesday, August .1Et,i'gil 12:33 PM ' 

|i:il~SD»<FB~»l i

-Subjec:t:__RE:- GT-M0 - . ' _

§EN§lI!.J.E E-_UJ_U.N¢J..A§SJFl.E_l.1 .

NON-RECORD . , ~ 

A military iriterrogator arid I were interviewing a new arrival at GITMO during the__e_venintj'hours when we heard

what sounded like thunder. 'After hearing-several "thundero|aps" we steppedoutside the interview room to take a

' break and see -if the-weather had made a drastic change tromJh'e clear_si<'ies we had witnessed prior to the start

of our interview. -As we walked down the hallway of the temporary building where the interview rooms were

' located, l glanced in_an*_open- doorway/iilrher_e new at least two individuals dressed in _BDU's standing and an .

.----inmate kneeling on"the»floo'r-with_- lgiaforehead on the ground, The-inmate was holding" his nose -and -crying. There

_ was a smell amount--of blood on the floor near the _inrnate's faoeggiiigslted the Bl;J.U-c_lad- personnel what had-

-1_ happened. They/explained that the,in'mate_ had become-_ups*¬t-w.i'th_them a'ri__d-threw himselfto the,-ooi,=_.' I-had //'

. I heard previouslyrdhat one of th_efféFna|e rnilit_a__ry=_persorrhel would wet her hands _alT|li.touol1'_the inmates as parfof

their psych-opsto make_the-ima'tes ie?e'l3"unclean" and upsetthemfi The inmate's nose appeared 'to__,be -

.bleedhig.' One of themilitary personnel:_left=the room to retrieve e medical kit for the inmate. I saw ngthingr-else to " con'tradict'the_miIitary personnel's'__exptanation-ofevents; -j - _ -.- - - - _._- ' _ i

1 eel I . _ " ' ' H Chr'stiRA MC 1' J M . " - ouston :v|s1on- orpus _l _ _ - ~ '

*2-1|: * i

_ ' 2.;--Ori inal Message_-'-- - . ' " ,-.' _. Fmm= rmso! FBI! - - ,

156 -1 Sent:T1'|ursda,-;i'u '29 2004 9:59 AM ~ *

trio -1To: H0! FBI! -

sub e- : . -: . _ ~ - r

-

~ i

3 - . 7

'- t ' sensitive B_U_T ur~|c:_1_Ass,||=|eo -

> . I _

"Could Krou please provide a short summary of what you obsen.-ed. Thanks. =

. ---Uri inal Nessa 'e---- ' ' be ~1 i i F~m=iiH@> en

b7C -1 I Sent: Frid, Jul U9, 2004 5:50 PM

' To:| |  INSD! FBI! '

SulJject:RE:G'l'MO' _- -

SENSiIlVE_B_lJT_UNQLASSlFlED _ _

_ I observed whet ma!: have beengg ressivetechniques used by 111:;-FBlinten'ogators. Do

b6 _1 still fall into what you are looking into? .' _ ,-

Houston |v|s|on- orpus Ct-1ristiRA

b2 -1 ..._I: _. _ - '

' ' RESPONSES-59

. - _ _ . 92-
b2 

b6 

b7C 

51' '2' © . Op

rs-suz {Rsv.lU-6-95! _

b6 -1

b']"C "1.

b6 ~1

b'r'C 1'

' -1- .

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

- Hmfmum O9/O7/2OU4

" '"'"" "5PE@ii1~Ag@Ht-ili _W_ A FedernlrBQ£§eU ' 'of Investi ation FBI!, who entered on dty'wit the FBI on [:::::::::: and arrived at the Houston Division of the FBI,

Corpus Christi Resident'Agency CCRA _ on or about 01/22/1998, and whose telephone number is [i::::ff::::] was advised of the

identity of the interviewing Assistant Inspector AI! and the

purpose of the interview. SA,[:::::]then provided the following

information telephonically: . , - _ '

' SA.[:::::]was assigned to an interviewing team at the

detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba {GITMO!, from about

S "t ep e mb t'l 1 t er un l a e ove N -mb e n rvi g r 2002. The i te 'ewin team _ .

consisted of three people, including S_A Besides

himself, SA s interviewing team inc u e a contract

linguist, whom_ A believes was contracted through the .

military and whose 1 en ity SA could not recall, and an .

Army representative whose name SA could not recall, -"-

either. The Army representative was rom an organization .

similar to'the'Air Force's Office of Special Investi ations' 1

 AFOSI!;?an'investigative entity; however, $A[::::::fcould-not recall the.name of the organization. He was certain it was not

a'Inilitary' intelligence entity since the acti'v_itie's of his -

interviewing team, deemed by officials at GITMO.to be law»

enforcement activities, were separated from intelligence _ '

gathering"interviews that military intelligence personnel and "

representatives from other government agencies performed. For

most o._f-his stay at GITMO, sA|:] and his team performed

interviews in the morning. .The afternoons and evenings were "4

, reserved.for-interviews conducted by those who were gathering _

in't.e.ll.-i.g'ence. ,-._$A|:921_}-aid not knowf the specific activities

that occurred during t e afternoon and evening interviews, 4- - .

' ' N-ea-r the end of SA gs tour of dut at GITMO, about two to three weks.before T anksgiving, SA£f:::;j was

partnered with a female military intelligence en iste person whose identity SA[::::::]could not recall, but who ma have been a military-reservist since she indicated to 5A[::::::Tthat she

was_a probation officer in-Los Angeles, Californ1a.J SA.[:::::]

and the military intelligence soldier were detailed to an -

interviewing effort that focused on a recent group of detainee

arrivals at-GITMO,.These interviews, unlike those he had '

. »

hWMnm- 09/0?/2004 u Washington, DC _ {telephonicallyj

Fuse 297-HQP=132'7669-A ., 395' - "- Datedicmcd N/A ' .,, Se/n| . ifia/3:,-11 RESPONSES

p

This document contains neither recommendations nor aunclusions of the FBI. It is the pmpcrty of the 1-Bl and is loaned to your agency;
q_-.II-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII____I_I!I__HIII_IIIII_-__________________-

L v.

-: '0; ' .

_ Q i.@ -

to-am aw.-. 10-e-95! '

-1- 1

29_'?-HQAl327669-A_

b6 '1 - -

'b7C-1 ' '

OmmmmFD§Qof -| |_______=on_Q2L01.Lz9_0_4.__

performed with

evenings. The

information as

exposed to the

the other interviewing team, occurred in the

purpose of the interviews was to-gain as much

possible from the detainees before they were

general detainee population. 

' . _ S_A|:heard through theperson placedincharge of

F 9 . The person n 'harge,-whose

b6 -1

b7C -1

agency personnel emphasized

law enforcemen _agency personnel at GITMO that other government

agencies were using female military intelligence personnel in

psychological operations-type activities a ainst the detainees. identity SA[::::;:]could notrecall, ' toldSA[:::i::Tthat in.anefforttodisrupetainees whowere

praying.during interrogations, female military intelligence. '

personnel would wet their-hands then touch the_detainee'sface,

causing the detainee to stop praying because he considered

himselfunclean. The person resp s'b e for law enforcement;

to SA that law enforcement; -

agency personnel werenotallows? pgpeethistypeofpractice when interviewing detainees. SA did not witness this _

technique,or.anything-similar to it, performed on a detainee.

1 SA|I|did_not haveknowledgeof-interviewing'- -

tactics or techniques addressed in any type of Department of

b6 -1

WC *1 _ materials describing such"a

- the technique of wetting of

the person placed in charge

. = Sometime near the

. ' partnered with the military

b6 -1

b?C ~1

the soldier were conductingdetaineewho had been appreh_ended.in Afghanistan. During the

Defense policy since he never received a briefing or written policy.SA[:::;;:]was onlyawareof _

the hands from s conversation with

of law enforcement agency personnel.

end of his tour at GITMO- when he was intelligence soldier, SA? and

an evening interview of_an, raqi _

' interview, SA[::::;:Land thesoldierheardbangingsounds

- similar to claps o hunder, but were perplexed by the sounds

- since there had not been any indication of rain when they '

entered the interviewing facility. They_decided to exit the"

facility to investigate the

. AssA|:_|andthesoldier wereexitingthe

' - interviewing faci 1 y, they noticed a detainee on the floor in

b6 -1 another interviewing room, crumpled over, and crying.. SA

sounds. ' --

b7C -1 :| askedthe personnelin the interviewing room, all of whom

appeared to be militar 'ersonnelbased on their uniforms, what hadhappene'd.- ' snIrecalled thatthemilitarypersonnel

may have res onded that the detainee had thrown himself-to the floor.SA bserved thathedetainee*'s noseappeared to

l

Responses-71

K
it

1.. 11 °

FD-302a Rev,10-6-95! - _ .

Con1inuatiunofFD-302a! _| . |_____,___ __,Q.,_ng[o7j§z00_4 ,Pag:___

b6 1

b7C -1

b6 -1

b7C -1

b6 -1

b7C -1

b6 -1

b7C 

2 9?.I-IQ-Al32'7669fA

_111, b7C -1

- - b6 -1 ;

bebliegdng. 1' lsiEsta notf§as"sir"hs.g¢' alnyehn1§* "sis;

the incident that ispu ed the account offered by the mil

personnel present in the room. SA[:::::]+did note that w

"asset

itary

hen he

exited the facility, there was no indication of thunder outside.

The lack -of thunder caused him to wonder about the noises

heard. However, since he did not observe the events that

transpired in the other interviewing room, and he did not

receive other information contradicting the account of ev

provided by those in the room where he found .the detainee

bleeding, apparently from the nose, SP.I:|-could not s

what transpired in that interview room fell outside U.S.

he had

ents

ay that

'Department of Justice DOJ! policy. However, SA[:::::]stated

that there was potential for the events'occurringin that

interview room to not fall in line with either FBI or DOJ

policy. "SA: emphasized that he did notobserve any FBI or

DOJ personnel-presentjin_the interviewing room where he observed

the bleeding detainee.

1_;- -Sh[:_|-did notknowtheidentify of thepersonnel.

present ~in"the_ intervi-ewingroom where he observed the bleeding

detaihee,_or the identity of the detainee; however,SA.[:::::j

felt that determining their identities would be possible by -

quer in logs maintained by the military at GITMO. According to Slki the date, interviewing room, andtheidentities of

-theinterviewers and detainees for each interview were

maintai-nedby the mili.'t_ary at GITMO. SA|:|produced

302 of;his_interview of the Iraqi detainee that evening;

however, he did not maintain a copy. =

an FD

-In addition to-the military intelligence soldier on SA

:]s interviewing-teamonthe eveninghe observedthe

bleedingdetainee,SA[i::::]receivéd interviewingassistance

from an Army psychologist or psychiatrist who was an officer.

SA-|:|stated that this ind'vidual was a major, but that he couldnot-recall his.name.SA: made a comment about what

he had observedto this person; '

-k i - SA[::::::]describedthe_interviewingfacilities

GITMO as temporary structures. The interviewing facility

used consisted of about 12 interviewing rooms on either s

at

he

ide of

a hallway. _There were six rooms in a row on one side of the.

hallway and six rooms on the other side. Adjacent to each room

were surveillance rooms that allowed other persons to obs GIVE '

interviews without entering an interviewing room. ?Durin the' evening when SA|:| sawthebleeding detainee, SA|t|was

RESPONSES-72 -
L 5 . I 92L '-

I O

FID-302a Rev. us-5-95! O

Cmmm@oJMof it '| ,.QggQ1¢2ggg my

b6.l

b7C 1

b6 l' '

b7C -1

b6 -1

b7C 1

29'?-I-IQA1327669-A u .

  b6 -1 - -

' _ ' _ 'b7C -1 '

occupying an interviewing room at one end of the faciIit§§ and"

he observed to detainee in an interviewing room two to three

rooms from his, and on the same side of the hallway. 

SA.[::::::Lreoeived a tour of the detention facilities

at GIIMO; however, e did not talk about what went on at the .

facility with the military personnel he encountered during the tour-. -Sasdid not consider any of these contacts

substantive in nature. - " _

_ .SA[::::::]noted that during the course of at least one

detainee interview, but possibly another as well, he documented

information he received from the detainee about abuses that may have occurred in Afghanistan. SA|UUUgUUstated that the Iraqi

he-interviewed the evening he observe t e bleeding detainee was

one of the detainees whose information about possible abusés_in'

Af hanistan was_specific enough to document in an FD 302. SA [:fE::]documented the information relating to possible detainee

abuse in a-separate case file; one that was being set up to

address possible war crimes. SA[:::::] did not know the case~

file number and he did not maintain a copy of the FD 302. SA _

E:::::]believed that representatives from other law enforcement

agencies at GITMO documented information regarding~possibledetainee abuse." " . _ ' -

,- ' Based on the condition of the facilities, and having .

had t e oppor uni h t t t lk th. o wa roug . - h the cells where detainees were held, SA[:::f%Ef%%Eff indication of systemic detainee

abuse at GITMO.- SA believed the detainees werewwell fed

and-provided with essential needs, such as medical treatment.

He was made aware of one detainee who received medical treatment

costing around $100,000.00 for an eye injury he sustained while

building an explosive device in Afghanistan intended for use

against U.S. soldiers._ , _

. RESPONSES-73
* * ' ~ ~ +

g |

v

_._r*'

I

~ .

I

-.

R "-t_.

s"

1;

LY.-

_§:.

*5."

Z. 92-Y.-K --f-1.

.

. .

- _"Z:' ,.

A-

| F

I .

s

- :-

.-

_*_1-_~ W T7 ~ _:_I-'._L'_ __.-__._- '

. ._.,_-.,_.___;_,__,1..._ .......n.. .-r... .,. _.,__., Fl3_¥34U HB92r.'7-29-_9; ' '- ' _

J

'-4'°=.""" ***'"_,.1-w.>.- |

I

. ... - .._' - '-1;. -. - -'_,. .: ' 1&1 - . _ .-. ' in-.>-.'r.Q' ' -.1.-->,@;'> .'.,-,|I

|

-_~ .92._ . -P:

92 ._- _-,

.

. -., ..,;_._._,_..._....~ '*: ; . -. 

. '.:>._. '6 --t-.;_;.L"'-; ;T'3 I-'-..92;it'-1. f

.- ' ~ -- ."f!"i~".-5 - . T- 1

7;..r. '.'__-.,"';_ _ .--... .-2' _ .___._ ,.~,_';i3l?-' ..-_' .=

- -.92~"";- -1-. 9292.,-43;:

. . ' .-_-=-.-_ . .=:£*-r_.._;;;-_?f-= -.,:;,-'-_t. '4'.

- -_|92l__*_': - j:..'>:..- -:' --»'- [

- . . - ' ' 5.1--~.'.:;-;-i:*:>.1;--W-"- ' 1'-'" 92;' '-I" f:- _.__-:'_'..*.,'j- -.1?_-E ' r

:- .=<,¥$';=:'-; ~

9292 U}1|versql.Casa FllaNumber El;-74"'<§Z*Z'

Fig.-Id Office Acqu_ _%lrmgEvIq!.eng_a[_ 	_-a;,%¢.»n,E5.-;=i_

Serial_-#_dj'0rlginaIlng_DocuméL _ __: __:-" ii

DataReceived 5;-1""':" ' 70215?":/>-w

c :- _

. 1. --:.--v1;";

. .1".._:92- 1 I

_ 1  j . _ 7» ..92| ..92.__,.. ll.

" ii ,__ ~ . . , ' "fr . ' - ~-be 1 Fmm.' = - " 92 . 13'-TC

" -% _ V *

% N % " _7 _- ':':: 1:-'-'21-.-";

- _ ,".:i.P_;{92j'--I-71__ as6iE°nmum! 7 H "xi" ' ..  - 

"-= ' .|ff--__1:;§-;

? _.. ~ -- -- "Y-="=*-5**'J'?-- <b6 -1 B5! .' _ 1 ' - , - _ -. _ {'k-.£'11~¥_

 ' ' I _ " I 5, ' °?§

ToBaRetumedElYes' E'§,_|o

Receipt Given ElYésQfllo_ - G;a_nd-Jplyflgteal -Dlssamiqqte OnlyPursuant-to Hujé6_ e!. ' '

Fédaral RuIéS;gI" O!'lmir]_at= P tlura

.3 1 _ L»r;|92<M1%'; , - -__ '_ _..1_L'

"I-':tle:'r_.__:-_,;-<-~,:§-' T -- "

. ___.:k__

." ¢ 1

Fleference..-- , ' '

r I -.| |-I-I -Q ' ,.,_. - - |_._'__

.}_.:92I92

. 5-Fifi 92 | L - ti: 92 "

.'<- . 92

. ' - - zs»"*5'.." " . _ . -,3, .

- 0

~J---T-'-3+. -r"-, , - _ - __~-. ,1-.1. . ~ - - -' '..:1-=-v-q¬.:-

ai

1|

. .-LIL. -

. ...-- __-_ .1-<4 . _ J I ' '-"2 .?"'-H!

>

- ' -1="'~;@?',"=$&

- -G"I'.1.'92-'»

' ,,'.'._.r=._1<[1.:92

_|-' .§;..__.-I

.-. - "5?-=F*7"~:&¥~p

. .

_ .vl

H " . .. J! . d -27 . - : . _.;~.-_ ..'_v. __- -

:_--f .' _--1

.;'>_§_a,. 1

. ....-:

 ' -;7:1.-i

 1.9. _.

_ . ' '~ i=1-51,-;~;;=;';&# 1

, ' I-:.%;"';-§¥1?

1..-:-.

. ..'¢T<;:§-<1; "Q;

1--_|.-".3".'f$_:-"I-:7? __ _., .'_ .._-... |_;._..-.=_..H

_-_1";~;_.;.|1§§1-7'¢&#

_- I:-' J,-_-_1 §j';7_,"92 J92 7. ,_ -fl, :_ = * i;>orr¢11urlicatiti|iEn:l:5§h'|g.|hTgter_ia}_}." __j3:.

J -_ I - _ _ -_._;_.

__ i __,_* --_' 11-"_ti~' ' "M1,

_L _,- I_.92|-j. 11

*_~'~f'

- _--.~.-.f_-,.-.-; , -"I:-1:_..w---_¬+.

' .' '1-':=.-,l£,'. '. L'.'.*";¥..-'-",5"

-- ¢v-"-rs_=_. ..',' ;.{-._-.- ' _, :;-;'_>" |Ja$c'|"lpti_p|_1:-_ J2-Clriginail"I'1§',iié§rein§é§&

c_:f__l in-- _ 1 ' ..

. ._1.-4:-_3n .,. ..-,. -

_ _:.| K

., , --. _;'-s -,1 ,. . '-1=;..;:.E.'.-11* a,-u-7,1_.-'1 ;-_.__,_"?:j,-.;-;_-if. b

- O: : . .12-W'r?i~;f~g;r_=§ b

' " -,-;-;.._ ,5-4'-

I

.

. I .

923|

¢~~-.--.-..

_.-:_.-_r=_ :_, .

' I '1-#*5':"'5 '1 92 - ..l';|92-H, -1

. __ IQ}--.,'>e:1._---3 - ... F7__|.._|.f._..

5 1

» ~ =.-'-;=.w=:-2*;¢

. . - -. ,-1:4:-0'» .§-_i.F-'-=~- __.'2;;~-.,a-__.1 " V. . '1 5.1,::~92

__ ' -; '*..:..3-'-_

. . 1 '. -_ an-'.

- - I _. >l.r?'92_.9292

_ _ ,. _ 1;

.-'-;:.u:t.' :*=: :

;; _ _ Q3. ._ ¢ .:92-3"I. 1- - I I-|---.-*4! -1

.. _._ W. _ -- -if.-;.=..

REEPONSES.-?.l.

.1 ._.-.... - .

92 -I _.

. ;r.

_ . -'-92- :_;.H'-::92 92

_ 1" . . - - _-.-_~;;.,:-;.*-.=;'.~

,_ -.5 .92 -. 92._-.-.---.1I._

- .- _,'= __-31.. :. .3, ..",-_~92.-f.- _.,.¢~.-_-1 ,,. '.'_1 ' .. -.' =."J_-. :.j-.'-.1-1

*'1fr '"+92 

' w

.92' H

p

_1

»-..- - =_~

.9Ii,

92

I

6 l

TC -.1
I

l,

i

b6 -1

b'Jc -1 H

b6 -"2

b7C -2 w

92

@-

F

.92

*4

@@

. 924

l

1

-2

1

r%

.61

/

// 6/ -' I 1-W r

rv {

0

J1? 6 T

ii"

a:zr¢¢¢_.,.¢l¢-w 0F

dcnm mi W--=-*-= Em cf OP/11/if

5'/¢5P§»_ c,..,,..§,r AIL

@r..;p1»|?!-is-¢4:.?'~./6 =F -£4-7 _

.r9~?.-.r'..d?-- ..

.¢_.__.. -__.__..92.. _7__~ _'-~;~ _ __ _ __ 7 ___ _ ______ __ _ _ _ __ ____ _ -.._--_------------.,.._----~ I

~11;

Y" . L y

I 92

b2 l

PET g /y§mL"E.77 -ll -Z-A.-ti} E até

%.=,¢.,," J» W» LW H-»-E"! M;

__/M ./=i.~.-. -

A, _;»_',»¢@,.-.,,,@,1,. _¢3--¢»~1'".%/.W-w"

. we-~L,=¥~»-J--T

' -- " I zzmwn www-

.. .. . .. . ..

92

-...._.-_.... . ...-£.<¬.-'.'...5..'. ._..¢.@..-ran .13.... . -

_.. _- ... £.*=.':_*-Q

-- i

J-/. . .- /1+ ;.'7

gyu @<"*-'

_0iZ- If .£4!'.{., ,. /Pm. /.r'.f' /H. L-5'15"/F

-..¢/=.. /ram

/A-M.¢:¢1'-I1 .7" 6-'-W I-w-_>e..-:1-r~I!1.'=¢M'_.&#

92

RESPONSES-75

2

4

5

3

1

92

6

P

1 i

.

I

92.

i
|un"'*ri_,*,,,;' ' 1 _ ii, ' ,

------~._--- .- 1-.._,_,Z,---- -- - »--_ -- -.. .1.-- ---- ___W_7' 77 W7" _W__:;7______:_____-;__-- 92 h 

92

' n

. 92

W _

®,

@

<9

J

92

1

.

I

|

|

l

I

I

1

I

 1

4

92

92

>1 % .

0* r rr/57 /:0

/2/¢-APQ?-* /' -w-¢:»'-v /rxgrn7"?/;=.-._, .l»T" ai¢»=*-W-. ' F

/-' r???$77?/' 7"?/QM. /'?Z?-J-try 1:/5"-i§.*¢/v ,F5'C-&

_ @»r7»'-'zn-¢- - //1//1» /$=---~ Mia 4"¢='-F?-f-/B

'/mww K»-1" r» 2;?/r'*£:.-"_7?-qosv.

-. fmm @999-.»-; Jar Z./41-./.eE=:-m .4/I--.

% ,- _.£;isr=-=-r2?:»..A-W! 7'" 1." /1"

 - KI , ., . I

% 1?/;»"»=4L+»L»<.»:@<L W/51/=/~'-¢-

- H ' ,. ' /-" . '

.... . .

..,.. . ..

___ZI¢11/¢,.;_>J...,__,¢¢e£@;-3.-_._...z?__._£-:.:.,¢|;=.:r._..W.-. _,__ ..

-Gs ' A'i5'v*/f21?M= tf ;";91-F

"414-_;

E

if

 92

L

F

92

:
W

_ ..M..__. -

I Q;

%

@

ia

1 j " 7 1 _ I

. _. _ _.. - .-...J-._-___.92__.__..._..-._.-....4._-..-.-~_..-.__p»....-. -. .- -...-_....J-92__ 4::-_i-_..._-...-1% .-_-92._-7~_.__<_..-1. ¢;- *____

52¢. of n/H» ./75514?I-V.-'1-I.

-=2 <'3°*'-P -F?mn-¬=-=-*92"- /n 7" ,P-F»-1-"*""- _

/I//////' fl . "

J-r/5%»,-pa /M.-:w.=»4-'1 /5,»--,;~_,==..-6-.,,':H"'

I __/z_M~am? 6/J*"_/!1'2E""_";$5av-L7.

//7.4,//./7'1l P1/1?-.=r_ M-»/awnmnt-fr -0'9 M7 0:? .

~ /.=v,%zw*'J--1-» ~

i

I -",.< m/..,./#1-+ /r;'1-mmf.

_ .. m <-/I.¢w-».'F- .7/1??/:*=-~¢-?¥"E""'

.//1!/?r. .. <.-Fer-ea.-_ /4'1? .. .. I

 . /I-' .62,

" I ..-.t.c.m'f,..

-_ .. .In

_"..___,@'¢1,za_-.,2~1:u-¢_;:*'_-'a=.."3:-1":¢"¢~l?.¢':@ 7?7@*%_ i}-;,*,,,¢-%_, ;-.}Zi,<¢<?§..f'I1-.L&

 %

__ .<?f'!<'/.-of

1/4*L".j,,,,. .. L4?./¥¬'#1

§},,¢=.=rm~ A;-.npm ,w- -I mr" OrwMm .,6.¢¢.¢-¢.-5-4'?" I?!z_E»=1-/I -W5 "17/F"~

.-,.6'f /m- II Y V I

.r;,

1-P1 '

. RESPONSES-?7

a

92

?%

L

r

I

F

E

E

I

i

92

I

92

z

1F
8 .

_! /gw__P¢-/ti/FRI, I .

I

-92

%7?" l92N ' -J.  -/ ' ' z ' Y //*f>77.%%3"-~.. %519*?»/J//if .//~~f L-7» -

,| i L i iii ____ , ,_ ig; ~!_ ___ _ _

.:. . .

5

I

. .§.. . -... _ -- -_ ._.--.-......

1.

AMi -

W

i

*1-_

_ L

RES PONSES-78 ' j 

@ /fiiv/r-Lomw Mk ea:/--i fnmr 7%?-,r - ¢-"=~"

1 /Z6/-=' ¢'%i'¢»-e-1*-=*?>' ¢-@~@.6?$'>-f- /4 V//-=i~=-»-»*---

A?-fm /rfrfw-=rr/c. @ 6=7?=4r'- /5?1%-='=

Auwf m- /#4 /4'5-#1-~ I

I45?-

I

92 92s

|

E

:
i i Ti l i 1 'g*q 7 T _

.-/1!

/2!

As

/3%

t/Ho

,/f o

-/7!

./8!

0/

to!

11!

12!

QuestionsConcerningActigitiesat_G_uantanamo Bay,Quba,_LGTMO1

DescribeyourroleatGTMO andtheapproximatetimeframe.

If amemberof aninterviewteam,pleaseexplaintherolesofthemembers which

comprisedyourinterviewteam.

Describeanyaggressivetreatment,interrogatiorisorinterviewtechniquesemployedon

detaineesatGTMO, whichyouwitnessedorareawareof,whichwasnotconsistentwith

FBI or DOJpolicy,/guidelines?

What, if any,wasyourunderstanding ofDepartmentofDefenseauthorigation"forthe

permitted use ofharshfaggressive interrogationtechniques?

DescribehowyoubecameawareofDODauthorizedtechniques. _ ,

In youropinion,wastheaggressivetreatment,interrogationsorinterviewtechniques

employedondetaineesatGTMO,whichyouwitnessedorareawareof,consistent or ~

inconsistent withyourunderstanding ofDODauthorizedactivity?If inconsistent,

how?Identifyanyotherindividualswhowitnessedthisactivity.

Doyouknowtheidentityof eitherthedetaineeortheDOD einployeefcontractor, andthe

approximatedatetheincidentoccurred?

It youwereawareofanytreatment, interrogatioii orinterviewtechniques employedat

GTMO which wasinconsistent withFBUDOIpolicyandDOD authorized

techniques, didyoudocument orreportittoanyone?If so,howandto whom didyour

reportyourconcerns? -

Pleaseidentifywheretheinterviewsoccurredat GTMO which youbelievemayhave

beencontrarytopolicyorauthorizedtechniques.

DidyouhaveanysubstantivecontactwithMilitaryPoliceorother U.S. government

personnelatGTMO regardingdetaj1iee's conditionortreatment?Describe.

Describeanyallegationsofmisconductormistreatment byUS. personnelbroughto

yourattentionbyintervieweesorothers? '-

Areyouinpossessionofanypictures, video,audio,notesorotherdocumentation which

depictsordescribesaggressivetreatment, interrogations orinterviewtechniques

employedondetaineesat GTMO? Areyouawareof anyoneelsewhoisinpossessionof

such items? -

RESPONSES-79
_

13! D0y0u have any additional infdrmation relating to the treatment of detainees at GTMO

_ whi eh should be brought fo our attention?

P

RESPONSES-80

_ _ _ ___ ll I
L

Positive

Response

Number 8

_ .0

 -c

, .

~

l . ' v
Q .

1 Wee/g1§???i7'

_{Rev.01-31 2003} .- _ I ~

f . ~|=eoe|=uu_ B_'UFlE.AUOF wives-rncgifneou '

. a 1 ' . - '-. - -~<92£¢¬* §_92F~}6-. Precedence: IMMEDIATE" ' ;//agkQDate:/09/2004 J - U0 ta ' ." -~ To;'Counterterrorism _ a Jy¥¢a CK - b6_1 Inspection' /EP " ¢" Att >

I ' l " _ .. ' '1;-><_ C; Roomeat: '_ _b?c __1i&

From:Anchorage  _ _ I Eryn" -é? - 

.4,,» . I squad 3 _ _ __, -3 ', ..-»" - Contact:-B14 ' , .

.. | -§~*f§ be *1 Approved By- - - -

h?C~1 _ ' ' _ * =b2-1 _ _fN

' ' -or--awe-

., .T-M

CaseID' # :u297HQrAl327669-A"'i iPending] _ - I

. 1- . _

- .1 . ' .

'Ii_tle: -COUNTERTERROR-ISMDIVISION, _

came, _ . -- _

. . INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY .- ._ .

. _ . . . - .

./' ,. Synopsis: Toprovideresponseto eemailfromstevenC._

MeGraw. Inspection.Division on 0?/09/2004. . ' _

Details:_ The purpose of this electronic communicationis to

provide a response to an e-mail from Steven C. McGraw. _

Inspection Division on 07/D9/2004. - J5 . I -. . i

. " Writer,Anchorage Fild--Ofite Special Agent|:] be,-1

f |:] briefly visi-ted etmoin o2,-'2-»oo2- to. debrief a detainee bee -1

' as FISA case_agegt on the "Portland-7" counterterrorism- _ '-

ihqestigationg While at GIMO,1writer-observed no apparently ,

improper aggressive'treatmentof detaineesme writer visited _

GTMOor a period-of approximately 3e4 days and returned_to

Portland Division, his office of assignment at the time.

Writer would add that when the detainee was brought

into the interview shack,at CampXray, the detainee appeared

to suffer from physical injuries to include possible brokenfingers and injuries to his face. Whenwriter inquired as to '

the cause of the detainee'sinjuries, writer learned that the '

detainee had recently exhibited noneompliance with a prison

guard,.and that the rapid reaction team was brought_in to -

bring the detainee into compliance. Writer learned.that no

Bureau employees were involved-in above incident.

ff -

I RESPONSES-81

. I I

i . - ' _" - - _
_ _ _ _ Ii

ii-i i QT  '

' -n, . . ' , ll I

or or

92 FD-302 [Rem 10-E-95} '

I l

. _1_ -

¢ FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

 ' - Dnteofwnnscripiiun 0950952004

' a- I - - | g l -See-C-i-11. »5sen.1:.. ..£nter_ed .99". D1~.1'.t.y... .E.<2P...

- . cu-rrentl assi ned to the Anchorage Division, office

b2 _ #9 e ep one h we |i'-_"i1 adv'sed n er was i of tn Off-iCiEll e ' 92 b6 _ identity of the interviewing SLIPEIVLSOIY-SPEClal

Agent{SSA%and MC _that the interview concerned" ascertaining any information

- possessedpertaining to the treatment and conditions of '

d"eta-inees at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba GTMO!. |:| thereafter provided the following information: . ' '

traveled to ,GTMO_in FebruarY_2002, to debrief a

b6 detainee identified as] W _ J regarding

b?C - case specific information on the*"Portland 7" Counterterrorism mo matter. Qwas not a member of any interview team. As a

HF " Co-case gen of the Portland 7 case, |::|went to GTMO for

the sole purpose of conducting one interview relating to that

- case. . -' - "

. The interview was conducted in _a makeshift plywood

shack used for conducting -interviews, located adjacent to the '

"Dog Cages" in Cam X-Ray. When the detainee was brought in -for | - - the interview, Ijobservect the detainee had- a' black eye,

-- facial cuts- around the nose area, and his fingers on both hands

b6 -1 were taped. up. The -detainee, who spoke English, said" words-to

1°70 "1 the effect "they", motioning to the Military Police MP! guards, .

_ had done this to him. A Colonel in charge of the MPs,~whose

| name: could not recall, advised that the detainee's

injuries were sustained in a scuffle due to the detainee.

. becoming K1011".-CiOIClplia1'1t and had to be bought into compliance by a .,

Rapid Response Team. The. detainee also had a cast on one of his

ankles which was for -an injury sustained priorto the detain_ees

arrival at GTMO. - ' '

I ' did not have any substantial dealing with any

- MP5, other military personnel, Department of Defense DOD!

civilians, or any other contr ctors at GMTO regarding detainees- b5 '1 condition and treatment. did not observe any aggressive 4

WC -1 or improper handling, treatment or techniques used by. anyone on -

any of "the detainees inconsistent with FBI or Department of

Justice" DOJ! policy gL1ideline3.- L: had no understanding of

what type of harsh or a ressive interrogation techniques were authorized by DOD. C did not ask anyone what the DOD

- lrrvcstigationon DBLQB/200_ __ Q-,____ tele:phoni,cal],y_} _ _ ___ _ _ __

no 297;H,O;l&_1_' 32 was-A' __{ieli_b g g i -6 -_ . *1 Dat:d1 09 09 2 04

w 5s,_92|i-ii i ;-mg i W,-1 _ -7 RESPO-*N_$ES82%

This document contains neither recommendations nocr conclusions of theFBI. It is the prpulfy of the FBI and is loaned to your agency;

- 77 7 7 ' 77 1 I .
_ __

. J

92|

~

FbémabulCi! _ :! _ 

=' -. 

~ '29":-so-A1321ss9-A . .

I ' ' - - - - - b7C--1 _ - '

ewes»-are-sozortt _,_,, _ ;§0n'_Q&LQ&L2_0,02 __

policies wara§éiE51n1a§ to the treatnenr"of detainees as he- ~  - " thought it was beyond the scope of his duty. Since[:::::]was I

unaware of what-DOD policies were_pertaining to the treatment of.

detainees, he was unable to state whether any aggressive

treatment, interrogations or interview techniques employed, in _ b6_1 his opinion, were inc0nsistenE:fEE&:iny DOD policy. Other than bW;_1 "the overall conditions, which described as being harsh, -

and without air conditioning, but which everyone there,

including U.S. military_personnel were subjected to, he did not _witness, or become aware of, any unduly" harsh treatment. ;| ._ attributed the overall conditions at GTMO in February.2UO , as

being-due to the operation being in its relatively early - .

stages, ' - _"' ', . ; '

 . ' _   1

. |:|w'as not aware of any allegations of mistreatment of detainees ma_e against any U.S. personnel; [:::::]did not. _ .

' haveny pictures, video, notes or any other type of ' ' '

b6-1 documentation which depicted or described any aggressive ~ u

- WC 1 treatment, interrogations or interview techniques employed on detainees at GTM0.Y[::::::]was not aware of_anyone else in I

. ossession of, or the existence of", any such items. ' ' - ' [E:::::]did not have any additional information relating_to the .

treatment or detainees at GTMO. .

92

o.

- RESPONSES-83
_ ----IIIIIIIIIIIIiIIIIIIIIIIIIII-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

-.

92

__ 77 W__*,.__' _ ;_ _1______ _ _____7'_~ J __ 92 ' .

.. ., .. ..*-':"'_"'-;.""*?"' - -

. - " ;'-":".@,r

92Universal CaseFlléNum5§r_. -5/9-'-Y .

L FmOfficeAcquIrhi'g_.E_Vi!i'iB;T1§e7 W "M

V.{Mseriéiiii-drIgiq_atl'§'E!§Eu;§;if""  L'%

VADaien=¢eiv@¢1§,+_.gz2go+i2f:2;@»~54ff V

92

-1 _'.;.;»_-.-'- _,'.--.'- - _ - ~<

92 - - . _{T92§dr'aE;spf mgwmn- 7*"* - -

.¢ , _ *___

J by { 'E';i*?i"f*" H

W. '-1?--.'"*{Name=1£;nwiala="1lJ" R ' .

92 -., . -'

L i'*@'%§é?¢v4'r~§¢* 5 u

-- - "ally?-:__=-___ -""f'§3_ '  " H. . .- .

" Héceipf-"Given: '* ~"____ -

.';=:--. _~1=_" F1; .-,' :_->j;."§_,,'?-5-.'§1?.:::'?;;:-'.'§,;:;i:L?;:i;;_> :2 - :'_ _'.. . '3_'- T _= ;.__ .5tan.é§4umhAa!*;5=i¬®i.5=§minateflily~BI1

-" ,. »" "L1; - -' -

10' 3e%6' eJ-- 'iE§B§%é1@BI§§i5£¥6*ih?Lé¥Er6cadur@@.-

 -. ' . I.Liii-@F=?Yi;a}d§Y~*§?1=??I:-F;-fffgr-'-;'@"3¥.=T

~ ==

.' '-5; ' .Z'E.=I:l'_'*:' . -'P,7§T;.'=:'1.'i:="':'7 "73-"<'1."_~ l - j- I

v

.;_

l¢*~ Fvp - '@ '-" , .

h_ w- _ , .

4.

_ . Y ;_ aw

1 ~= ;:;:. - .-- " - 5

.. - - . ;>- =¢Y92;~ . K1-._' __-.'.+. __H . 11"} _ - HeIarenoe:'i£1"'11;§3-F¢£?$:@;'=;% - 7.

- ,|-.- .=e _r.- ..--= _--p. -'"7

- ~.u%1=1 Y F ~

. 1- -; - -- - ..-2,,-._-.;_ -_--_-.-_,~---. - _{.-X-'-_ _;_I-_ --,- .

g, _-,_. _.:__i-3:? _.

. -,.,D_-;e':s_§:'r1j5t_J_o|'ii§ of'_=- l l

g'_' *;"- I i ' . ' .

: _' _ . . ' - '92."

4 ' .

92 IJ

l

1. n

I92

92l.

__ ' .:

92. -

92- J . w _._ __->... ;92H " I Vi

, _ _; l  ____7 ______--:14..--,.-

-m-a-som.=v.s;:-ay! _ '- __ 92 .

- - ..-:-j-Jidlaiiicbnfbuaugi---»T1¥

.3

92

1

M

J

Ir

92

92

-w.

*92

b6 -1

b7C -1

b6 -1

b':'C -1

n

? 1 » ,. -. ' . RESPONSE584

I

H

.-.1

..-~'.-,_

92

A-'

Ii..

.,___.
@~/F/:>~ Wm§@$92r**9l "T

if _ E1-ca.»,4,- P5 ___?,__; __W_,_ _

L1 ' _;

92.p-

___;~N W §Q¢£-1~$r<-_ j %@<:---<-- 1+ *_ _

A H #5; W2? ~ 

2%-f; we 

; ; 1; 92 Q52-~~¢<r/&~=;>w=W~w~~_ 1

_ Q

b 4

b7C

1:>7D *>¬ §,7Q=/ 5%'-¬4"§ § §i:l Q{ b7E +§%whM

12%-J] * /_? ;¢ ;-é». '7? j §* * L_ ~<;*~If~+

{mé- .- ?{WYK /W" C-at {=~K? 'I»?'-:;z/-»--~>-;»=1~ 1-_K?? »» ~+

__ ____77__'__/U56 ____ _-__,__, _TW,Q,__7*?!

ll 9 ¬?i~7F§..¥@ 52-JAc¢,%I Q@;~..~>v

___3f=~<f Q; :,____ i - ___ ,_ .

%>w@~% ?

;@.!/d?W "jj"_f"" ; _ ";=

_ ,7, _ , ;;_,~ H __ _ I:-A , f -_

' 1

. ,_....-._....,,.__.-__.,,._,___,,_,__.......__ ,____..,, ____,__,_,,,__ _ __;_ __ __ -___~ _- _ _' _ _ __
Positive

Response

Number9

i
1 .L;».? Q ,L L n ',  -

>6 f - SS u not interviewéd. He is out on extended 

bi-C 1 , _ _

. s1ck leave due to medlcal 11111655.. - "

- - _Atta_c11_edi_s his e_-mail angidocumentation.

I

_ 1

L -, . if __._! 

r, _. .

/ '

4-

/

.5

4' ,1. _. /

, ,.'_.

,' - .1

_/ __.-'

.»'

1

RESPONSES*86

. - ' @-

./ ' '

.. _ _ . ._
' w

. C t I ' Message 92_-7!  - n Q Page I of I 

| i '_? | |nso!FBI! ha _1 t -

"W" W '* .""'*" ';""'' *b7C 1""""* ~ " * f"'"" l " To: lR! FBl! " -- - .1 ' ' * ' lri._,;?_Yf!.=_I5"-_i.".¥'. Subject: RE: GTMO ' - -  .;_:_- 1

OK, thats positilie response. I leftyou a voicemail. Can you emaillme the EC you did? Thanks. '

----Ori lnal Messa e---- - F-'~=m=lil<1Rn0=B11 e 3,6 _1 '

Sent: Frida Jul 09 2004 3:10 PM ' bqc _1 10:: ms» t at ! er -

Subject: GTMO - _ _

m

As you may be -aware, lwasjn GTMO andl did observe aggressive interrogation practices and as a "

Behavioral Analysis Advisor on interrogation techniques was aware of extreme interrogation techniques -

.-:=. that were planned end implemented against certain detainees. ' ' ' - - _

. These events were summarized in_ memos and anEC written by myself and my colleagues between Oct. .

- and May of-2002. ' _ . _--

I have been discussing these events with GC Valerie Caproni. f

a 2&1 " r - , _ s  r - ll s .0,» i

B%.r~_I.cLa§§_lEl.ED_ - _   ¢;Ko, 47' of .

. _ - _ _ Y/FM

40 J -<"N ' /J o-J"

. _ - e i"CI*P>9

Lie

92

I
b 6

~ '3» 7*.

.-

~ - u n -.

.

. ' - t""92:- -.- ' {Remus-2-Zing! K0 "'H l '§"92: HJT'r'1':I-'#5:""r>-1a!n*~ Hrrb ¢ ...»..;~'}-*'-=-= =.~;-:.e- .. E':+ "-"I'92.|l+.4,_f,$ r_;;,.1¢_,~ 3;..-.-;;3;,-5" T51,- _

"§=-haa;J,~:'f1~£'l'*+'-:f"".,92I92 __,£92_f - 1 _r-=2.» -1. -3¬¥l!3»:.'r:;,,;,, v a _ ....1; ,_ _ . L,¢_r=:a*;_- H.3:L .._, _ an¢:"_Ji}£J;;;:_:fL:,¥;J%~'~EéEH_1g5

-.I-..>-.f.~_: ,4 *~*§*e~e we» "WI-=+»;.E§:= M 1 ~ ~-*~ '_ »~we

_ F _;;§=-1!»;-FJFf;?2- .:;' ._'**¢x.r 4-r;-if» .q-re, P35, ' .1.-.-.-0» :==~'--£1-~,;.~.r_j P --r. "*1 *=r?§L§=%1e:*:"

_ ... fr, -m;fn92.;! ,__,__j£-:;~~1-|_1 '3" 1 Q", APrecedence . ROU_.r:-=_ms 2*-.,1;,1§;;:;1;*_-;_»§.,,~;g§:§ji%,§%,,,

em" »-=r;., -

To . Counterterr * J: "W%§%§%%1§*?§¬§'&#H P 1?-_~. -F?§¬.e'!§¥".'%'£;i92=*

Raymond 5 MEY"

'»*' '3-EE§:~9 *1-9292 ;:=;""l"qJ.1q;.n' ow:>'-¢__-__ "'l1;Hz ~5r;,|_,;-,. _,

- ~ -34*.51: is 1*Z-1"1*.'§§¢.u=?1? 5='.1*aj,P=,»..f*s-:2*'r,<v=  "'1,-J: -.rr~5~ET- . }=r- _ - ' * *+=-9we11-* **"~5"i»'= ¢']"{:-¢"92";£.!'92- '=-L; n="=:"r"L§Z3§3 -.31;1*'§3.~.,:,;_;-11%; . - we-1 r*"§;~ -.,

2***"%-=* "r59*;"t*"3=*" '=?:3""i*$"*~*"?"* r Counselfor NEHZZLDHBI GeneralCou 5; ,;.§_~,il-..g;_;E;;-¢=§¢,,,,~r--~32<;¢%,;F;~§.u

 E Bowman,

'"?~=-1*5-_"~¬l1?» ":~a'»¢:~ - - .+_- F" '1.-~:.-=¢:,. .- I-r»§_.E.¬" '1»?!-¢1 ,5.Q,._¢u¢t1.~=-..*=¥Jg»:92 "" .. -P1-:1:-31:? gig "' **at'.=$;Z1§§ r-- 1.1; ' _"' f_ fa M1a.m:|. _»'§E*Z"~5~-*5 -b-_ 1 =,,;,+,~3I;,§=,~§'#$';§-,_{9

g*5"§**~*§?.**:-I*19**-i¬l=*3"* umG;ihgbpa-rh$§ ector Esq-ua , '1 my Mis ra

FI.'Oi'|12 . CIRG

* %*;;"*"-'1:1-Tum. »=¢T.._~.- 1'-- ..,_ ¢=;o,§i§$ ii~§:i~¥;E*1~W¥*"-.1;<",~

e-. C Frank F191l11ZZ11 __rgv__=¬;'*»92- 92;-1-rz4-< - 3 _l ff" """E ~13-1=+ 

M b -1

ll;J$. '1 ..:'f 1! n at 1nlu_..» *1 ' , ""

-w.L_

I ' _ Beh-avloral Analysls Unlt BAU} _ l

' . Contact SSA

_f*1 ApprovedBy: wlley Stephen R b C *1- _ . - Battle Frankie

Case.ID#1:{U}26-SA-MM 99102,}Pend:.ng! 19¢

. Title: {U} GTMOINIEL

- GUANTANAMO BAY CUBA

~ ' ' _oo MIAMI

. MAJOR CASE 188

 51'{'11Opsis_:I U! To document BAU El.SSJ_5tElI1C.'E and challenges encountered

. -during TDY assignment 1n Guantanamo Bay G'IMO}

-..ia.r_é¢.1:~;; .%VHu%$92E%%E -,1, -"~'.".-r,-~;~"-:-w- Q .-

Enoloeure s! : ' U! Enclosed documents provide adds.

_ regarding issues encountered by SSAs| |and

1 _ _

:|_n GTMO

Referral/Dlrect [DOD]

,~ ~n*"~

[U] 2.

P-§Zf§.=i§'i.§';%3;i3@liE

t-_§;_g,_§§ ;1_::;1a;a&j;j§;§;1»?a¥ 1: mo 2- 11- B:,:y";g§:f

w@=H=%¥li¥i+z5 '5 1*»...q,,..M,,_,,,.,. .. .

E|RI'[D.TIO

IS_§fUlI¬EI;AE

EX

jP§%'§Ii11117§A5IPm $51
l l FEDERAL B_T_tREAU OF 11~WE_sT1GnT10r~r

" FOIPA .

- . - DELETED PAGEJNFORMATION SEEET

. H in h _._..__._.:._..._. ....__._._..._......s.._.;_-

OPCA-10 R-3-95] ' ' - 92 51

' XXXXXX .

- ' Pagelfs! withheld Intirely at this_ location in the le. One or more of the following statements, where indicated, &#

. explain this deletion. '_ ' ' _

El. Deletions were made pursuant to the exemptions

release to you. _. __ . " '

' ' ' Section S52 . _

cl om!  -  E1 o>o'>oo

' ' C1 o-1! - 1:1 b!! B! .

I ' MEI moi E El cbmtca

_;_ t_§_-_r III wow!

 bi'J E!

U bl!EF!

00! '

' ' .

E1 0:->'<4> 1:.

U 01!!'  _ U 0JJ 9!

U b![_6!__ 1 .- . _

I indicated helow with no segregable material availahlelfor '

' Section 5522 I _

 E1!! .

U i!!

00!

' E!

El

" U 00! '

 K! !

06!

U.

El

' U K1015! -

U 053!

E E -cl new

' |:| _ l - th b'ect of 0111' request orthe gubjeet of your ,

' requestislistediinthe titleonly. _ _ ._

El Documents originated with another Government agenoy ies!._ These tlocum

' for review and direct response to you. ' . -

Information pertained only to 11 thirdparty with no reference to e J y _F _

ents were referred to that agencyes!

.. _ _ . .

- ' '.Pages infonnnon fnmished another Governnlent a.gency i-es!. willhe advised by the"F'-

" to the releasability of this infonnation following on: consultation with the other agency ies!. _ I

" ' _ Page 's! withhe1d'ines1nu[:h as - eternsination has not been made. -You nnal release _d will be advised as to the

' ' - dispositi'on_ats1aterdate.. - _ __ _ , _

_ - Pages were not considered for relesse as they duplicatiwe Of M-£5 h|o.e2-1&

' . ' - Page s! withheld for the following reason s!: _

"' Thefollowing number t5's="u.§@a forreference regarcling these-pages: I I I

- ' - __ _Ro1szTrv¬ tlQo'f>_q;.45e zyumzé-e l_-sh3,;: t>o,Qu,M9,;lT Qt; .

I I. " ;[£'¬$|i0v92/595 P§G¬5.?Q_'_t"q4'I

JDDLXXX

XXXXXX

_ X Deleted Page s_! X

X" No Duplication Fee _ X _

X forthis page 'X _

FBUDOI
DPCA-ll! -2-3-915! - ' - -._ _

P - - l -' JQQGDCX -

l _ - FEDERAL ntnznao OF INVESTIGATION

. " '- Form '

- - . . DELETED PAGE INFORMATION sneer

' Page s! withheld entirely at this Io - cation in the le. One or"more of the following statements, where indicated,

. explain this deletion. ._ ' _

' El Deletions were roade pursuant to the exemp

release toyou. _ _ ' _ ' "

' t' _'S_ection 552 . _

*_--5011! ~ _so b!! A!

i o c1»>r2!e - ci taxman ,

i o @165 - "11 o1t?! c>

o fb!!' D!

91;,- b!! E!

me; ' 1:1

El b!! U. b!!

III outt » " El -oats!

-E{b! '!'-_ . 4|

' El Information pertained onlytoathird withno r erence

' teqnest'i_slistedinthetitleonly.' _ ' _ ' ~_ _

V92 U

-  for review and direct response to you. _ ' - .

I - _ I. ' P s contain -information Gmtenziment agency

- - to the releasability of this _ _

I tions indicated below with no segregable" material available for - l

 Section 552a - _

U d!!

E 01!

00!

l 1:1 t1=!c2>:'j

. El

El k!!

U £!!

nee!

cl note!

"ff o

 U- KJU! .

_.

i ef I to the subject of yourjequest or'tl_1subject of your

Documents with another Govemment agencies!. 'Il1ese'doc|Jmen ts were referred tothat sigencyfies! _ .

Fig? . _ _

information following our consultation with the other agency ies!_ __

T  ies!. rm; willbe advised by no FBI as.

' ' _ Page s! wit]:|h_eIdinasniuch as alnal release'_deter1nin_ati on has not heen _made. L-You be advised m tothe

' . disposition at a later date. ' _ i . . V it u i L  _be7j4mee§§PAr;és-|1

_Pages.were" not considered for release -as they areduplicatisfe of _ 7 ___ _i

J Pagefs} withheld for the following :reason s!:' ' mi _ ____

'- H. The followingnumher is tobe-used for reference regaiding these pages? .

VV" _ s mmve ssesuvaoem E1 ra bqnv-'¢e-or 1> i act!/Lespa/users PIf66$i.5-;|lI!'J

iotxéoot

.;=ooot'§ot

'_De1eted Page s! -

X- No Duplication Fee '

for this page _

- Fennel
E-.-T. .

OPCA-20 -2-3-sis! - - _ __}

e .

l ' - FEDERAL, BUREAUon INVESTIGATION

' FOIPA '

- . . DELETEDPAGEINFORMATION_SHEE'_I-

ICXXICXX

' Page s!withheld h entirelyatthislocation inthefile.Oneorrnoreofthefoliowilig statements, otrhere indicated

- explainthisdeletion. _ ' ' _

VDDeletionswereroadspursuant to.Lheex p emtionsindicated he1ow' . withnosegregable materialvailablefor

releaseto you. '_ . _

I Siection552 

' ti coo! ~ ti

l CI bio! H b!f7! B!

D

 b!! A!

Q-

 b!!{C! i orMai i *

U o>c?>~<D>

t tr b! ?!EEJ

 b! _7J F!

 b!!

' __ _ El

E1 60! El.

El b!! ' El 010 9!

1:1{b! _6!. .. - .' . _ _

' El Inforniation pertained y _a p

" request isIistedin1_:]1etitleon1y.j _ _ . _ 92-_

E1

'- forreview_anddirectresponseto-you- -

" ' Pagescontain information filmished another Government agency

' ' tothereleasabilityof this"information fllowingourconsultation with the

onlto artywithnoreference tothesubject ofyo1.u'_request oriiie

Section 552a

U 03!

U i!!' -

El oo!

00! .h

moo!

<1<>t4i

clots:

1: _ k!!

-1:|

1:1

-1:1

"El

1 El-£!£7!_. .-

F

subjectofyour .

Documents originated with another Govemmen-t agem:':y ies}. These docunien tswerereferredtothatagencyes!

otheragencyes!. _

l : ies!:Youwillheadvisedby ti1e'Fasa _

' %_ Pag'e s! wifoheldinasmucll asanalre1ease'_detertoinati lon.hasnotheenmade. You beadvisedasto't1

dispositionat a laterdate i if if L i A be'f,m~ees-ime

_5....Pageswere notconsidered forelease astheyaredupiicative of__ _=_

' Pages! ntithheld forthefollowing 1'BH30I1]I' _____ _______-_:_ I __ - _

" H-_'1;]2e following number tobeitsedforeference regarding these pages:_ I _

s -Po-£LTn/E R-e.$_EU_tJ~§Q aivmatei"V1>*>$v/*92'1wE s

V Cztesan/ses Pass: H1-:16]

1- .

X '.Deleted P_age s} X

X No Duplication Fee _ X

X for this page '_X
 1:|

- FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

' FOIPA '-'

. J DELETED PAGEINFORMATIONs1=1EE_T

_% Pagefs! veithheld entirely atthislocation inthele.Oneormo

. I ' expam this deletion. _ ' " '_

E] Deletionswe1e_'nia:1e pursuant tohee_x_etnptions'indi

_releasetoyou

" U b!!

El '{b!!

er use! E

,,,._._.7 . _ _.'."_ ..._..... .-3. ... ._..._.,.-.. _ ._...._...:;.......;:..._e.........-__e ...__.....;. ._.._................_...-..._ _,_ '_ 92

" QPCA-20112-3-95! " 7 ' I ' ' It ' - _ XFOOQXX

XXXJDLX

I eated' belowwithnosegregable material available for

1seem552 _ " » _

 b!! A!

-.. - U

1' III b![7! B! -

' E3 fbJ! C!

__ _ ?_[J _ b><'o@>_

t ina»1o>'c;E!-

. _ I -

E3 b!J

13 W5!

El 013!

_1:1 b! ?! F!-

1 moss: -

- .11 mtg! E

Section 552a -

E1 011!

III 09! -E

1: 00!

l E El 00! n

1:1vets! _

U !! !

 k!!

In _ k!!

1, t1.<kJé1>

| . D

- reofthefollowingstatements, whereiridieated,

u .EI Information pertainedonlytoa -' partywithno_reference _ _ tothesubj-eet ofyourrequest or subject ofyour

' Ieqne-stis]istedin1etit1eon1y.' - -_ _ _

Documents originated. withanotlje - 1:Gevemment agency ies!. These tloenments werereferred tothatageneye

'- forreviewanddirectresponse toyou. _ _ _

n ' _Page s!'withh

_l..

I _Page s] withheld forthefollowing reason s}': %__:i _ _.__'-__ -

as ationfurnished by another Governnaent sgsneynes!. Yousinbeadvised by t11e'Fas.

Pageswere'_not__ considered orre _

elcl'inasmuch asanalreleasedetemiination hasnotbeenma

disposition atalaterdate_' ~ ' ' .. __ 2 -_ _

Pageseontajn-orm _I I _I _ _ _

- tothereleasahility ofthisinformationfollowingourconsultation withtheotheragencyes}. _ .

de--You beadvisedastothe

f lease as-they areduplicalive of IA-'19 "H I

E. uefollowingnnmb er ' 15tobeusedfor _ reference regarding these pages - - _F

EE _Poscr.-veeiectnsenmvmne-i3 -rbssnvmenr__E

JGDOCXX

XX}JC{X

92r'T.'_92f'§¢"'§:""'i'

messesmesu1+usJtL_

Deleted P2-1ge s!

No Duplication Fee

for thispage

FBIUDO]
DPCA-2{J'{12-3-96! ' H u - ' j u _

I

"' ~or1=>'> r @121,

cl too! ' 1:1 o>o><B> l

-1:1

' - FEDERAL J?-T.1_IR_EAU OF: nwnsrioarlon

- -FOIPA .

s . . DELEIEDPAGE INFORMATION sonar

X13{!DiX

' Page s! wiihheld entirely at this location in the fle. l0ne or more of the following statements, where indicated,

. explain this deletion. _ _ - _

D Deletions were inside pursnani 10 the exemptions indicated beloiv with no segregablc material available for

elcase to you. - _. ' 92

' _ I éection 552 I. .

 b!J A!

 bJ! C!

 b![7} D!

oiei ~ 'o

. E].

 in l bJ! -E!

U 'DJE7! FJ' '

El

-no

010!

 b!! '

' U. 010! '

El b! 9!

E]

' 1:|

ct-ago d i I , L r .. F

. _>

Section 552a a _

5 010! '_

 i! -'3! '

00!

I1 00! I

_.El

-1::

- U 013!

e 1:1 00!

= E1 rots!

U <!!

- i U- l'i!J_.

l

I h Wil no reference to the subject of yonrjequest or the subject of your Information pertained only toa party _

 ' requestislistedin'1et'rtIeon1y.' __ _ .

El I _dtI'1er= G-overnment age1:|::y{ies!_ 'I'hese' documents were referred Ito thatagency ie Documents originated with an

 - for reiriew anddirect response to you;

'____i'Pagesc_o1J1aJ11 orma r' inf. tion furnished _ another GOVCIIJJJIEEII: agency ies!- __ _ _ -You _willhe advised by the FBI

' ' ' ' ' ' ' " ' nsultation with the other agency ies!. _

- L

92

to the releasablhty ofthis inforrnation fU1lUW1Il.g our eo _

35'.

' '  Page s!.withheld'inasn1ueh asla nal re1ease'_d_ete1111ina1io11 has not Been made. -You will be advised as tothe

dispositi'on.at a later date. - _ ._ .

' esjweren not considered for release as -they are duplieative of _b Q-E-4llJ'_e_E d :5 PAG'es- i2

ls?-I

Pag

Page s! withheld-for ihe following reasons}: _ - _ " -

" - H» followiiag number is tohe used for reference regarding these pages? _ - . C 2 |°,0-LII!!/9. J1-E$_£cJ=J~£? --doom i -1 >¢¢v_e@~=Tr§-

}Of_X}D{X

' vv-vvvv

i I 2 [_e&Paal-£2! Pké-0-5'*Hq" l2q':|_

X Deleted Page! X"

X No Dupi_ioation- Fee _ X

X for this page ; ' X

'

FBIIDOI --
 ,4,-;'~WW_ _L .1 ;;

.~__. i._.WI_ OPCA-1:-ll .-- " ' * - - - 1 I _

Page s! withheldentirelyatthisIoca

- FEDERALBUREAU or INVESHGAIION

FOIPA '

- . . . DELETEDPAGEINFORMATION or

. explainthisdeletioli. _ - _ ' ' _ . I _

n ElDeletions wereniadepursuant tothexemptions indicated belowwith1:10segregahle material available for '

releaseto you. _. _

El

El

l i section 552i _ ;

our-11_ ' e ~ ' E1<b'J 'r! A!

 W2! - i U b!! B! _- --

oaola - 92 a B fb3J C! '

- to o>oJ<D> '

l tlmoatei

7_ *_ _+ ;: .

~ 1:1aam<1=1 -

El

C-

U

l U

om! V_ o.

om" I s E-' ave!

010! -

onset. - L .. . _

"Section S523 - _

Elitoo!

1:: em;'

U 00!

e E! Inca:.

13 {1§!}_

- ' El -1![4'!

06!

c 1:oats!

J E

- 1::._<1'<!o> _.

Infonieationpertained i onlyi ton _ ' I _partywithnoreference toths_ubject ofyourrequest or"_ 3

-' requestis1istedin1et:'n:leon1y.' _ _ - ,_

' El Doeurnaen-ts originated tauith aiother Govemment 'age1icy ies!. These-documents werereferred tothatagencyes

-. forreiriewanddirect response toyon. , .

. ' _ ' Pages eontziiu iofonztaon another Goverrlirtenr -agenCy ies!,' Yotrwillbeadvised bytheFBIas - .

' tolereleasability ofhis"infonnation followingDotconsultation withthe other agencyes!. .

lion in thele.Oneour moreofthefollowing .s1;aterne_nts, whereindicated

the s1.1h'ect ofyour

' l" Page{sJ withheldialasrmlch asa 1;*e1eas_¢'.determJ.u' ' ationhasnotbeen made_ "YouWillbe-advised ast:o

' ' cliwositionatalaterdate. _ _ __ _

dL

V it it i i V_ea- whee:»Pacest;t&

Pages.we1e:1ot_conSidered_ forelease they-areduplicative of ____ _ In

_ __P_age s! withheld forthefollowing reason{s!:__ ' 7' - __ '___ _ _ I __

. 92._ .

I I i b d forreference regarding thesepages:

=g__T11e followiognumher5a0t£t;_t-rssef q izjboguiueljr H

' }iX}£XJG{

' . XXXJGZK

' vvvvvv

K UK e tfwpaaweraws I15-I2-1 1'1 l

'_De1eted Page[5! X

X No Dup]i::ation- Fee _ X

' for thispage ' X

FBIIDOI
_

4-11-7 ._.-......__._. . .;......Z .1-s-If. .1. .l;_'.: ;. -.....'.'.._.__ ; W";._ .Y.i;.I....... *_{se..:'.i_._;Z1_¥*>37£.-e..- :_777 -W-orcs.-20 .- I12-3-say -_ " . " _ H jm ' " I ;gQ.5;;g;

- 1- - ' 1! XJGUDCX

- ' ' . Pagelfs! withheld entirely at

' FEDERAL BUREAU OF DQVESIIGATION

F011»;

. _ l nntertsn PAGE mnonnumon snnnr

XTDCXQ

I u m location in the le. C-me or more of the following stateroents, where indicated,

. explainthis deletion. _

 " U fb!!

o bx-21

- In cool

I - El Deletions were rdade pursuant -to the exemptions indicated below with no segregable material available for

release to you. _ . _

_' Section 552

-¢

I1 chm!

' III 610!

:1 one

' El

.1

. I G

1:1

In

CI

U

E]

 b!! A!

 b!! B!' -

tome!

 "D!JfD!

B b! ?!fE! .

 b!!fFJ

E1 b!!

unis! -

_ Section 552.21 - _

13 £1!-!

UX2!

U <!! . '

.j:|.

-_c| l<!!_ .

U <!! -

U k!!

 Ii! !

oats!

4. -=1

El

-Erri-:>cn_. t

Information pertained - only to_a _ party -wilno reference to 1e subject of your_request or."tI_1e subjec

of your

' requestislistedinletieonly; _

E1

' for reew and direct response to you.

' disposition at a later dste. -

Docunaents originated wia another Govemment agencjnfiesj. These" document s"were referred to that ageneyes!

' ' ' P es contain information BE . furnished anofner agency ies!.- will . be advised by FBI as - _

' to the releasahility -of this information following our consllltation wlth the otheragencjufiesj. ,_

' _'Page s! withhe1d'1nas' _n1uch as a nal1release_d_ete1Io1'nation has not heedmade. -You advisedns to the

i Q7;-imee:iPsseslc3oI-lacs 5 - Pageswere: not considered for release as they are dupiicative 'of__b _ 

. I -Pagr-: s! withheld for the following reasonfsjz _ ' ___ '- _ __ V _ _.-

 E. -The following number is to be used for refermce regarding these pages:

e __ Po.s J'r92/9 :~L<e_1dva:1§£/Q? - §2.e¢w'92wT I . __

!QD§l'XZ}Q§

'xx;x'Jo<J={

V fruspauses P/I6-85 I?-¬i"l3:7-:|

Deleted Page-.[s!

X No Duplication Fee _

for this page '

FBIID DI
 once.-in 2-3-96! ' L - -- _

i ' J XJ{XX_XX

&

L - FEDERAL BUREA.U_0F INVESTIGATION

FOII-_A _ -' . -

- . 1 r DELETED PAGE,1192*F0R1vnrnoN steneti"

Pa_ge s! withheld entirely at t: 1 _.

92 . explain this deletion. _2 , _ _ _

L El Deletions were niade pursuant to the exemptions ntdicatedhelow with no sep-cg

release to you. __ _

" _- Section 552 L _ .. _

in mum L ~ . E1 mats! .

Er 011! ' I: a>1m<B> L

El b!!L - _- '- f11L! 'f'} C!

___ t __ o , "E1@>mm> t

" t e i:I rn>:1><¢s>__ -

-~ - IIfbJ! FJ -

- El

-92

in

._ E1:1<w _6>.-_._ _ . _ _.

El em! | - Cl. MB!

I3 b!<5>= L - -1:1 coats!

lnfonnation pertained only to_ a Lpa.rt3= with no r erence U

' request is listed inle ttle Only. __ - ,' I _

Documents originated with Government agennyes!. __ I

' fur reiwiew and direct response to you. - - .

XXXJCXX

L L this lo at'oLn in the le One or more of the following statements, where indicated,

able em.-m1 available £01-

Section 552a - _

cans! E!

 i!!L

13 00! -

l 13 90! .

00!

 '1<!LJ

 KX5!

I11 secs!

El

CI

El .

is 11 mm _._

., .

ef to the subject of jlonrreqiiest ortiie subject of your

These documents were 1-Lefenred to that agency ies!

Pages contain L L  r ies!: LY@n win tie advised by h~L;'

. fnlnished another Govers.men_ agency

to the releasnbility of this information following onr eomnitatron wil t11eLLother agency ies!. _

Page s! witbJ1eld'.inasmnchL as a nal 1-_¢1 ease determination hes not been made. -You will be advised as 1Z0Lthe __ _

disposition at a later date L ' ' . I __ - L L L L L L L Lr 1>e1emee<sLePA¢

Pages wereL-not cons_idered' for release they ore dopiicative ta __

Pagefs! withheld for the following reaso-n _s!: ' _ - _ - ____

The following number tobe used for reference regarding these pages: t - I - beau/*92¬:O'T' I r _ eeqrrtve J?-¬5_QoA<¬ Nmaart L LL L .Le.:p¢.q.re.< Maia; 133 4:25

XXXXXX

.mmmm

X '_De1eted -P3,ge g! X

X No D_np1joation' Fee . X

X for this page L X
_ _ __ ', - _________ii _ _ _ _;__: -_ _ _ _;:ii _ _ __1 

UPC.A1l] 112-3-95! '

.__IU _ 'D! 1!

. E-L too!

o hm

El Deletions were roade pursuant to the exemptions in

release to you. __ .. __ _

' ' FEDERAL BUREAU OF ]NVEST_[IGATION_

 - - Form

" . . DELETED PAGE INFORMA'.I'ION SHEET

' Page s! withheld entirely at location in the file. One or more of the followingzstatenlents, wherindicated,

- explain this deletion. . _ _

! ..

_ _ _.

X?DD{_X.X

' 

h riicated below with no segregable matrial. available for

' E3 b!! A!

Er cb><1>@>_ -

 bJC"! C}

 M7393!

. ' [II

.7i IE

 _' .

o matinee: i

' oamrlee l

_ El

. T3 b!!

El 1311!

o one

V El

El

E1. W3!.

El EH9!

. . _ F I _ 

-Section 5529, - _

rots! D

U i! Z!_'

00!

00! . -

-D

-1:1

_E|06!

. El ~1!!

=I!!

63!

coco t

1

.5.

-- Ci.

92

l

- '92 -with no reference to foe nlbject of youijrequest or the subject of yur Information pertained only to a - V

' Iequestis1is"tedinfoetit1eonIy.' _ _ ' - _ '-

Docunlents oliginated  - with anotlier G emment enc es!; ov _ These ooooments were refettred to t.ha1;'- ag y

' for eview and direct response toyon- .

Pages eontam ' infonnation _ , 

fumished . .another "Govemnient . agencyfies!. You . . will be advised by tl1elFB1 as

' ' to the releasabity of this information following onr consultation with the other age11oy ies!._ _ _

' ' I Page s! WiTl1.held'n1as:nu'- l J oh as a nal relea_=;e_c_1eterro.1n.>1' tion l l ' 11' r as nobeen made. -You _wi11 be advieed as tothe

disposition at elater :iate__' _  ' _ _ - '

4' Pages.were'_11ot|'considered mimesr :31e- ms for releases they one dupiieative of _l_N _____

' Fagee! witbheltl for the "following reason s]: - ' _T,_

'" The following no-mber is to be used for reference regarding tl1ese'pages: - _

L l r ~ en. Q - .1>!>¢uM¬yJT Kl ~

' XXXJDCX -

' virvvvv

P2? B-_1¬_$_E0»1-£Q_zdm8e or _ __

L [' L'_e$P0nl$eS- Mae: I31 - If-I-0:] S

'.De1eted Page s! X -

X No Duplication Fee _ X

for this page ' X

FBUD OJ
* - IU b!J

U b! Z!

. U b}!

'. FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

- FOIPA _|

. DELETED PAGE INFORl92£[A'I'ION

'92' ' XDGQUDK orcn-20-2-3-96! - " ' _ "} _

- - 100055:

XXXXXX

' Page s! withheld entilelyat this -location in file. One or inore of following statements, where indicated

' - explain this deletion. . _ _

, i El Deletions were made pursuant to ex nip ons l e ti ' mdicated below with _ no segregable material available for

92 release to you. _ _ _ . _ _'

Section 552

 b!! -1*-J -

-U b!! B! -

 ~ [:1

-' I1 -oxmc! a

 b!! D!

U b! '7! E! -

l i -El b!! F! .

U b!!

U b!!

o mo

I El

I ' '3

_ I

J .. 'lage s! withheld for we fa11@wngr=mis>= ' -' e . - i U U i - do ptsnmpir 1+-r m>e?:=._ wees F23

U. BN3!

U b! 9!

Section 552:1 - .

 d!} -

U i! ?-!

- U 00!

' U <!!! .

U 'I!!' .

U E!!

 k!!

00! _

U

::|'_

|l -E coo! _ -

I with no referenoe to the snhject of yonrrequest or the stfbject of your Information pertained-only to_a party _ _

' reqnm is].iste£liJ11etltle0I11jI.' _ __ '_ ' _' _

Docurnents originated with another 1 d ents were referred to that age:icy ies Government agencyfies}. Il1ese'__ ocum

' for review and direct response to yon. . _ ' ' _ -

"  Pages information funiished another-_GovernmenI ag'ency ies!. Yon _wi]l be advised by the FBI as -

L " to the releasabiljty of this information following onr consnltation with the other agencyes!. -

' l ' - -_ Page s! withheldinasmnch as a nal release Iation has_not_been _ niade. -You ivi.l.l'be advised to'the

- - ' .dispositi'on at a later dat'e.' ' : _ ~

In U t 1* of DETHIMQQS PAR I3!-F

fbaeumor was newts

Pages were not considered for release as they i-uedupcative _ . . . _

  - ' - ~ ab 1'0

u  EH _ The following nnmlaer is to be used for reference regarding these pages: - _

Posrrave :Z¢.>5_E¢N$¬ gevmoeé if-1 t>ncgm_eHT L '

;~.JoQQ<;X-

.-x1_XXXX

XXXXXX

l f[ L _'.$£_>oM3_6'-H] I . .:>;:x!§:>k U ;e¢XX;QeQ

X Deleted Page s!

X No Duplication Fee . X

X for this page I X

FBIFDOJ
|-ix

:.T.:E'_:i.'.;:lT:.: .7.'_'.'._i';j'_*.*_.__*'__i__.__._._..._.._ __,,_;_ ______,___ __ ___ -.'I.I.._T-iI;'

UPCA-20112-3-96! - 3 J _

X!§:X.§fXX -

92-

XXXXXX

 - FEDER:-ll. BUREAUon INVESTIGATION . _

" ' FOIPA

. . DELETEDPAGE]NFORI92¬[A'IION -  .

~ Page s! witliheldentirely31thislocation in meme.Oneormore [J , f thefollowingstatements whereindicated

. explainthisdeletion. _ ' _ - ' - ' ' .

[II Deletions wereniadepursuant totheexemptions indicaled blelowW1'tl1 _nosegregablernaterial available for -

releaseto you. _. _

.-[1

Cl

El

om!

only

 b!l ; r

Section 552

' ~ I1 o><m>

 b!! Bl

 b! '?l C!

-:1

U

' - El lJ!J D!

1:1aware!

-

i ' 1:1 n=>o>cF>

El

CI

El

l U

 b!J

53! '

one .t . i

' El. b!!

I Ei chats!

Section 552a - 1

El

i:|

 d!!

 i! -'3! '

 k!! ' El

' ' U klll .

00!

u<1 _4'>

'l:l

.3

Ei 00! i

mo

D .

El- EX-7! .-

lnfonnationpertainedonlyto_a -' party I wiza-no reference tothesubject ofyonrjeqnest orthesubject ofyour

'reque'stis]istedin1etitleon1y.' _ _

- El

' forreviewanddirectresponsetoyon. . _

.i___ ' P1568 .

inf lI3J1ati0i1 furnshed . _another Governrneni agency ies!_. ifonwillbeadvisedbymeFBIas

" tothereleasability ofthisinformationfollowingonrconsultation wrththeotheragencyes!. _

Documents originated niith andt1i|erGovemn1ent agency ies!.- '_I'hcse§1ocnmen1sreferred tothatagencye

' Page s! wiT.b.he1d"inasmuch -asanal1;'e1ease'_d_.eter1:oinatio1i hasnotbeenmade. ' You. willbeadvisedasto the

disposition atalaterdate.'' ' - _ ' ' ' 

l 3 liege}: werenotconsideretl forrelease -they duplicative ail} g

.'l , 'Page s} withlielclfor thellowing-reason s!: - __ __.____ .__ _;:___

" B_'IlIe.-following mnnher tobeusedforreference regarding theseages: t_ P0-SCEIVE @;e.s£oM_e_Mvnf4m =2- >¢5¢_=-mwrjm _o__

XXXXXX

- I.L1~S|9.6'l'~_35¢-5Po¬S- [41 ' 

_ .X DeletedPage s} X 

' _ XNo DuplicationFee _ X _

X for thispage ' X

!D{XJCXX

DODCXXX FBUD03
OPCA1lU'2396! ' H ' W! ' ' ! ' _ XFDKXXX I

| FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION ' ,

- ' FOIPA _ _- , 

'. DELETED PAGE INFORMXIIDN SHEET " ' _ .

' Page s] withheld entirely at itislecationn tllefile- One or more of thefollowing statements; where indicated

explain this deletion. _ _ ' _ i ' _ '

III ' Deletions were madpursnant to the exemptions. indicated below. with no segregable material available for '

release to you. ' _. I _ _

 _ section 552 c _ Section sszai 1

" e a=!! ~ _ E1 c@!o!rA! _. 1:1 cd!<5!

[:1 cw! . E1 rb!r1!<e! - ! El ma!

i El n=!<3!'; - ' !n!rh!<?!<c! s 1:! mu!

1:1 <h!c1!rD! - 1:! 00!

' i:I"a=!<?!rE! 1:1 00! _

'- - U " b!E7J F! . _ El 00!

in e!<4!- ' 1:1. tb! 8! !_ 1:1 lets!: t

:1-o=!<5!" _ 1: w! 9! ~ ' m_a<!c6!

r:iw!c6!. V V _ - 1:r~ck!t"r!,

' El pertained -only a with no reference 'to the subject of yourreqoest ' subject of your

i ' request iS].i5'iBI1iJ11BI_iTl6OIJlj'.' _ l _ . ' _- ' - _ _-

D Docllmentsuoriginated with another Govemment a_gency ies!. '_I11ese' documents were refelzred to that agency iec

' tc'!r"reiriew and direct response to you. _' _- ' j _ . ' _ _ ' .

_ - I Pages co1_1ta.in- information fttrltished by another'Gove1:cenent agencye-s!. You will be advised I:1jrthe_PB1.a- _

_ - to the releasability of this information foowing on: consultation with the c|1er agency ies!_ . _

" ' _ Page s!_ withhe.1d'i.uas!:!uei1 1; a nal-release a¢¢¢niiiiia1i@n.1i=is not been made- -You be edvised asto the.

 ' disposition at a later date ' ' - -  ' . - _  _

6 . ftages were not considered. for release -they -dtrplieativel of l DQIAIMQES

Page s]withhe1dforthe f011uwingreason s!: - -i_ 7 -. ?_ f if T l

_ ' _ I _

' - 'D:|e foowingnumber to"be used for reference re_1jarding'these pages: - . ___ " s L "P-o.$rZ'rve i/teis!@a¢!ss¢_s!~;.@eerL ft; ft>act;Mjé3;U ¢;N

_

1 V i L 5t<:wi0se$~ mm :45 e-15¢] e

- ' "  - ' X Deleted Pages!

' - ' ._ X N'o'Duplieation Fee . _

_ ' X for this page

' §<"&"Y"i?"S?'Y F3]'_;"|_!Q] _
!-.;.*.:¬:::a.f.*

1

__ . .

El blfl!

 bl[2!

Er oioi.

l.el

~ El

' ' FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

FOIPA '

' _ DELETED PAGE nwsonmimow 5.1;-mar

' Page s! withheld entirely at this location in the le. One or more of the following statements; where indicated,

explain this deletion. _ _

I El Deletions were made pursuant to the exemptions indicated below with no segregahle 'm3:g1-i;-11 fg;-_ - 

1'el$e to you.__ _ ,

' _'Section 552 - _ ' -_

. _s>1o> A1 _ . ' 13

13 b!! BJ -

oioicca

 b!f7!' -U}

. . U

-c__ _ _ *_:_._ -1:1

-U" b!!_ E!

El b!! F!

I3 fB!{4J'

U b!!'

o om.

~ '3

L E Pages were not o_ons' ere .

V" I11. one

U b! 9J  ~

. J, '

ores-20-2-3-so " l - _ I 1 I l . 3753955

FDDDCXLX .

Section 552a - _ l

13 d!!

U iJ!'

. U EH1!

00! .

'- -U 66! '

U 613!

E1 coo!

- 1:|

- 13 *1!! -

l - III Goo! ;

u- El. Information pertained only to-_a with no referen6e"t0 the subject of-yourrequest or 'tl1e.suoyour.

' _ request is listed in thetie only." _ - _' __ .

' 0 _ .

Docuroents originated I u ' with another Govemment agencyes!. These" documents were referred to thatgertcy ie

' for review and direct response toyou. l - .

Pages oontain -o inf rmation fiirnislled _ by another _ _Governrneiit agenc:y ie.s!. ton vll be advised _ by the F_

- to the releasahility of this information -following ourconsultation with the other agency ies!.- I _ _ _.

B1215-.|

  _ Page s! virithlieldinasroueli as a i1a1'1_'elease_ determination has not been in ado. be advised as to the

' ' disposition at alatér date.' ' ' _ _ ' - ' _ _ . _-

' id clfor release as thy are duplioative of be-TAIQJQES " f 3 25513;!.

'  u .

. ' -Page s! withheld for the following reason s!: . __ i _- - i

' - 13- The following number is to he used for reference regarding these pages: . __

" ; ;P05;7'rvE_ /L6s'P0nJS¬r;Nv/.88|7- L - Mcvmen r. It 7

}IX.X'J92§CX

h Cr_1¬$P0'H5¢S.Pm;.c_$m |5|-% I53]

Deleted Page s!. X

X No 'DL1p1iCation- Fee _ X _

for this page ' X

'
I

E 0PC.A2-2-1+ - - i . _

e ' V FOIPA

' ' Pagelfsj withileld entirely at _

explain this deletion. I , ' _

1 El Deletions were made pursuant to e exemp

' release to you. __ _ ' . _

' _I ' _ _ Fiection 551

- "' E 11 rm! ~ :1 clonal

1:1 tomten

E El moi V "I11-cw-!»:c>

El ll?! ' -

' - El fb!!fD!

E3 fb}!{EJ

E! b!!_ F!

o'e>t4> L '- E El. one!

U - lJ!!' El i."b! 9!

Eloato. .

92 ' request isI.istcd_in the title only. _ '- - _' _ _ -

' for reiliew and direct response to you.

1 . I

disposition at a later date _

_l_.

l ' El originated with anoier Govemnneni a,gency{ies!. '_1]1ese'__docnJn _

" _ _l ' Pages contain infonnation fpmished anothet Government agency

to the releasability of this infortnation following our consultation with the other agencyeg!. _ _ -

' Page s! withheldinasmuch as a nal telease detennjnation

i _f.'..'_%_;iI' T '_i7:.'; :i..::Ti-.:£-.'.:il;_'k.7Q?7':.:{iilifI._.ii....i:i;_..:;.;.':1£.;;;:-._f"_ _' _ '.:_". ;.. ;..".._.i:;.. i...__T.f.E.i-;..._ ._1.. .. .. _ - .._:_ _____ ____ _ ___

ms} " X ' -. -:-~ ' XX'XX.!D{

l

i '- '-"FEDERAL BURon nwnsrrtoarxon

- . u DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET - __ - -

I location in the le. One or more of the following Statements; where indicated, _

' I. ! I i tJ:| ' tions indicated below with no segregable mate

available - &

Section 5523' - _

92-

5 f1!J

- 13 J'!!'

-U '1!!

' U FIX-'1! .

' 13 06!-

U k!!

92

' U k!! .

' U l~:!!

t - E1 coo! E

' El Infonnation pertained only to: a third wiano reference to the subject of youzjrequcsi o1-'t]_1of your

ents were Iefemred to -that ageneies!

 es!. ion @111 lrie advised by the P121 as ._ _

he not been made. -You will be advised as to the

Pages were not considered for release as they are dupljcative of DQ.'TPuAJQQ§- l| .

' Page s! withheld for the following reason s!: '

--E!-'lhfIl'-'b"'b arr d'1. : .

E B 9qimgmi ii_i?5i=§F'io3IéB6§3§3§i%5§eisi»51~.~,acur4<?P_

wwwesenkaci-lt54]sl E Xme<m- 7{1$i1QQ{" xx E

- ' ' -- 'X Deleted Page s}

'.

- ' ._X No'Dup1jcatii;m-Fee

- X for this page

FEIIPDEJI
_

orcn-20-2-a-95; - - . _

i - -- ! XXX.XX.Xu " ' - FEDERAL BUREAUOF11WEsT1o.4.1'1o1~q

norm " .

V . _ DELETED PAGEmsonm.-ufionsnEE:_r

FDOUOCK .

' Pagefs! withheld I H entirelyatthisulo ' ' diele Oneormoreofthefollowingstatements; whereindicated, cation lI1 . I

explainthisdeletion._ _ '_ _' ' _ I _ ' _

'E! Deletionsweremadepursuant i to p theexemtionsindicated blow. with no segregable material i available for -

I.1CIiSE to you. __ ' __

' ' . Section552 _

|- _ -

oM1! ~ E1mare-so_

0° .

incw! El b! ?! B! E

 1:1oars!E E "E1smote!

_ v . ' 1:1ant?!- D!

_ _ U b!! E} -

' F3 b!! F! '

E- W4! - - E-_. 011! '

El b!!' -III b! 9] -'

n<m<_o,.. I .-- l

Section 552:1 - _

U ' !!

_ El i! Z!'

- E1 00!

¢!C3! .

1-'3-00! --

13 »1!}

'i!J

1:1Mo

'¢!¬?3_.

- E3

I

.__-51 '

' nmomimmpe1'tein_ed onlyto a mesparty with no reference 't O JThe sub'ect of y0I1I,_11=qt1es't orTI_1e.su'bject ofyour

' request islistediutileiitleonly. _ -- _ _ '. - I '

El i i Docllruents I I I Thesedocuments werereferredto that a_ge.ucy ieoriginated withmane;Governnaent agcyes!. __ '

" forreviewanddirectresjionseto you. _ ' _ ' _

. ' "Pages eontziin informaon by another Goveuunent ageneies!.

_Page s! viithheldinasmuch asan:-11 release

' ' dispositionatalaterdatef ' _ - _ - _ i i L L l E ' it i it bernwees-P/teesstsz

-You willbeadvisedby-t11e'FBas - '

tothereleasability ofthisiJJ.fo1matio11 foliowing ourconstlltation wththeotheragencyes!.__

determination hesnot been made- .-You willbeadvisedastotheS Pages werenotrconsidered forrelease estheyai-e_duplieative of ' _ _ _ _ i W__

'Page[s! withheld forth;following reasonli _ - ' i __ _ __



' - Thefollowing number is to heusedforreference regarding these pages: . . _ ___ l _' E E 'f?o:;T_r;{e __.@f¢es£a@.:seHt~umserL Q¢_t1>o¢q;v|e.u 1 fl-% A crtesp¢~sesPs@esrss-M]_

|- 7 - - - I I II .

- XXXFULX

' '

X _De1eted'P'age s! X _

X No'Duplicatio11 Fee_ X __

X for this page ' X

I IFBUDOJ
b6 1,3,4 interviewed at Guantanamo Bay Naval Station, Guantanamo Ba ~-uh . '

b7c -1,3,4 '

b7D -1

b7F -1

FD-302 R:v.920-6-95! . 1 - '

.. , V-' .F1'*$5iFm;31§55A?§.3>kIIi-1%?-1-1§;ZJ§?;?; - ' " - 

P¥1$@H'=-"£1-?& Iii? -- __--_ I I '. . _ .

ht.§a&.$...._.. n:.;.:§.;_z_l:~L§..-;f;1..@§.J~@ . - - . < - 1 . "

. BTJREAU o11*1:1~§=w'rEsfz:l_cI'A:§&

' - 1I;I1¢1==_:»s:iof1"i- -. ...-. 1-§-.---;--.--#1------2 - -mm; lJ'EJ1: - -_~.:t -1...-: V s L n. Bea-§.¥1!a.§.a1?¢sI-1~n§$_Ir;1a;.;;;

§1'iE2.Ei5H@..I~_'1lEmsn-

-"varé@r.u-=im1pun~ 'o?g19g2oo:-1

. L Also" resent .E1i.1ring the'_'in_t'erv

was.-192TC'IS_Speoial 'Agent . 

o on T - f;[an<;'L----eont-r-a asawho*pr5§Iaed5tEe Pashtu.-aguage-translation.-- { t

- 'p:oVide t e following iniormation: t:f-,h1 j-H o _ ::_ -

- b6 -4 pointed-E '

I T _eTom1'pl_a_:;1f;g<i' _o_f_-'be_inq _.mi_stre'a:.te<:'{_b§{_ _'§1'§____'§ -  E-

,. q1_eten_t:|..on- in"Baqram and "di.1r'in'g;i1i§ 3C.rai1s3':.f:.- ft.-o_C'amp' '-i:Jel.ta. "

arks on his wrists that he d;§i@ed;¢e; ;':a.1.'1'se_d the I

bWI4; haekIes' AdditionaIlg;1 Iol '

@L ' ,3 <'V

ed that he was '1ipse't-13? ha92":i.'n.q_'-

d . bTD l_ to"

. b?F -1"

5 _ _ 7 . i 7 _ ._ I  jrialm ._. _; _ |_ _ 7 .

to"_wea§:t.a hood.wgile- i1'_:. transzi;-t'a.m5." -,1=1=.at _qIl§l_r§1§__¢j_i§l not -respon

a pain in his ear. ,Fu:ther}|4J Ialleged that the quardsbeat him,"

smile in tran_si1:.',_]i|_i:i;L1rrii92_ad_-_tl1e _f;ra1;.sJ._a.to_:_ tq£,1~.='.= _:i".l1_s_a:n._d_wa.s -- .

' told theta doo't:or'wo.u1d-seei himlatzer

; _came to f2i_is_-house w _1;_e=1i1=-P." was'_11aving'_ a' meal with guests.-.__US and

t * -Afghan military 'ersonnel entered his-home and staxted-searching.

USAforces showed. a-pi-oturefof hi-s brother that--they had found -

. i.<A¢i:-ording-to he -isinhooent' of.ahy-"offsns_e..-__ _£'oroi-_

b6~431' . inhis houseandaskedaQr~it1was.' |:::|adri1i92=ted"t-hatit washis -

b7C -4 -

b7D l '

b 7F -1 n

brother,andfurther_stated_that hisbjother_wasout]offton. E::::]

wasto1d_that weaponshadbeen'found in his house{'but[:::]iI :__ Ix 3

countered that they-were actually found'aG.hisbrother'shouse. _-'- _ 0

'1 '-[;:::1was_e3tremely upset_that-He_was detained idfront_of the; I '

7 - ema e members of his family and stated that he wasihnocent of any;

crime-I-~ 5

' -I later zod-ified. hisstoryregaidingtheweapons-Iannd . .

' admitted that only -two weapons" were. found at this house." one -of _

' ~' 'these'weapons was a Kalashnikov and the other was a British weapon f

b6 4

b7C -4 _ _

h7D -1

b7F l

that!did1_1ot"_.work.-" Duringthislater ;-scant qst'ated thatthe'- two-weapons were.used-£or_bitd hunting. [:::;]furterstatedthat"'

any additional '{-aezaponswnayi be the property o ' his brother"; and that -'

if there were any,yeapons@ithey had been_aoquired from a Mujahideen.

. eight-"to-'t_eri-years-ago that 'L¢as"ac-quainted'wi'th his brother. -' ' ._ .

I _Ahother theorysuggested by[%;:lwas thatheweapons maybelonga __

_ _-___._fy*i_§|l1:__ag'e'__;Le1dea§'-, a-nd"re'ite1f.f7ate t at his birqther Wou1d'k'now

proirenance of ET_1e-.weéIp6s. 7*"T'*f_f'f'f7_-*_'_7"7"'ffT

luvcsfigaticn1_o:1 _- '7-L1Q/ Q3 r

the f-

___RE_sP0_NsE$-1'62 _

='.' Guesténsms-Ban-s¢u_b§ ' " ; Iii- Q -

-_byui "' -17 _

s  _ " . _. 

' fuer: §_55_;';_*1y11§___'§;7-:9f5g_;Q;27 .1;-_$36'_ 1' ' _- _- ' '_D:iie dictatcd 17'[_]_9Z'' . I. ' ____: ___|_ ;| .

_Thisdocument containsneitherrecommendations norconclusionsfthoFQI.1: is bu:propurtyoftheFBIand is loanedto'3-our ngmcy; I

 ii andits::iJmen_ts- arenot.tobe d_i:n_rib1.:ted outsideyouragmcyf-- _. .
pM___,. Z __L Z ._W* _ 7 _Vi

'f}:=n-3o2=+fR'w.1o-5-9;; . ' __

- - ' "I _ ". _b7C -4-

.2-SSA-MM-9.99102 ." b"'D""1 -.

- - . - we -1 _ _

__ Con92iny_ationot':F1§-3l12of3 W ,cn_i1§/.o3_ p f Fag, 1, pi G;

b6 

b7C 

b7D 

b7F 

b6 "

b7C 

b7D 

h7F 

b6 4,5,6

b7C 4,5,6

b7D -1

-b7F -1

_.b6 -4 _m

_b7C 4_

b7D ~1-

' bTF 1

_ Gm multiple occasions, asked" that his acouser be '- u 1. _

resented to him According to an enem  of his family hac1 " . "promulgated" an'un.sub'stant-iated rumor thalinad weapons. '=

the basis for this alle ation was an ar ument that "I-Iowever ' .. _ - " " - "V ' g _' ' ' . ' " ' l __ _ _l "5 brother phonetic!. "had with phoneti'C

' _

f::|ar1d had =a"--l.ong_-standing isagreement ower money. ," -

_-Further}. was in the Afghan Ann pend used his relationship - with US '".s; to_':c_onvinCe _the- US" thatl had weapons at -his-_; _

house. insisted that he had-beenwrongly acoilsed and f

';i.mp].ic:ated- with"-the we-_apons'.._' :.' " ' _' . .  _ "'_

- ,. '|:|;descr-ibed an-added 'dime_ns'-ion to the conflict "between his

brother and-"enemies.'of'_his -f_a_mily."_ 'A=_:c;ordi_ng to I: a member _

of "onetribe 1. was killed, so someone--from the offending -tribe kil-led

'a member of"; the. o'p'pos'ing__-group. - This ociourred app:-oicimatel eight . years ago and was a fadlfoif intt-he animosit held against. e": family". ;_:]_sta"t_ec_1_,-. "_'Ihis1-"man' is the pause...

- _ on mul't.:i.'p_-le 'oooasioris asked. "for:p_roof'Ithat he had '-

committed "some ~-of n . opined _that if -hewere -a "fighter,_."he ' . w 'uld hav'e"ki"lled a: a 1;-1-ien himself |:f;|ins1sued that- -. 

he.-was a si_ le farmer and that '.i.t_ was-only the a se "alle ' one _

of. _t-hat had'draw1f1 the "attention oi 'the'US _ont'o '- _ _

su ested that his. hrother would. straighten out __the"__ situation, -' 

99

"hut that -US iorces would. not let hJ._m_c_ommun1c:ate w1th- hisbrother.

"As "an 'additio'nal" mark_ of, his inn'ocezf1ce, |:|opined that '_1.'.2hE

no ireason to arrest him and asks-d,. ".W-hyme" and not" my ;brothers?"' -' - who--were also present at the me__al". '|:%explai'ne

that his-brother "

had traveled to speak with a_ istriot offioial named _

-about a road that'was_-_t.o built -near :|S-'§am|i1Y ¢¢>1PF>und."_ .-

an t at this .was-w-hy..his brot_her._.was unavailable to corroborate. .

_ ' 1:] insisted that he kne,i-fnothing" of the 92i!eapons- -Eound-by Us ~

forces in" his family-s "tompoi.1nd._ Fur_the direoted -US_ forces 

"to inter92ri'ew- the people ofhis village. _ insistedl thatthé '

people of the village would support. hi"s'eto'1y- and corroborate that 1iE1¬.H¬£;f"HEEE3;a'ar*E1i"e""wea-§@*am*§a~s~4j'.m§c~a

- - stated that only "commanders have weapons, li eople don't, " _

and that he was a simple; unedu'<:ated__1'-I:armer.._ -claimed to b",

unable to read-or write .Pashtu. The only ormal education he had _

was through re.l'igi.ous- _t1:_ainirig did admit-to knowi-ng a. few '

 words-of Dari, but no other" languages; 5 _ . - - I - _

|:| stated"-" that his- family farmed a'--"plot" together and grew

_ ___"RES_PONSES-_163-- i _".
92 .b7C 

1b7F 

' I i -J W__ _ __ _

§ .

-~ .FD-302a[R|:v.10-6-95! . . s - - - --?"_ - _ '

F .

. -"C:r;1tin1iaEi.nnsfFl§-Il' J2uf l I ,' ,, i,_..0lI:l '¬l9/"-LP?-SL5 &

b6 -4

b7C 

 1->10 

_ bu" -

4

1

1.

b6 

mo -

b6 "

b7C 

b?D P

_ b7F 

be ~

_b7C -

b7D -

b7F 

b6 -4

b7C -4

'b7D -1

b7F -1

5

- ' _. 094_'n'-  F

~ . - b64 _

_ - _b7C -4i

- ""- _ _- : _ _b7D -1

- . -r _' . '_b7F ~1-

265A-M-c99102 _ ;~ ~- -

ve§;'e.tables, specifically onions _an_d:pomé<j_ranat'.'Q'sta

his hands=_were smooth and-_ did not reE1_ec't.hard manna labor beoause

the "doctors gave him something to"soften' them._"'_' To e lain how  -"his hands ,'.c'ould heal-from the rigors of farm work,_|stat.ec1 _

tha't,f"My-.hands_-_ju'st, got better" and""If you out me it will heal-in

four months. - ' - '_ ' ;. _

' .' ' _ |:-I s family-'"_had' maintained the-.-farm since 'mo'vi'ng to-

q'ill'age from Jalalabad approximate-ljr four ears -ago. Only s"- brother |:|remained- in- Jalalabad. des.c_:ribed- that -- '

pomegranates were pla1fited"in"the _fall., _but aterr chan ed this to planting inthe spring and-. harvest in t__he_ fa-ll._' 1'1a dea

'.of &1ow_lar.g"e this -year-"s crop of -pomegranates wou e. _ ' 

,<':l.a.imed that 1- 'ar,, his family hartvested 50.man,_ phC=net'J.c I of-< -pdmegranates.- s family also has -goats and cows. ' Q53 "

family-also grows "oriions -in one section "and grain in ano er

seonion of l-and. ' Th'e_-ent_i1_:e- family works-1:he' land and a1l- of the .

family members live wi-thina' compound -together, bt in -separate -

houses; The individual families ' '3 Y t;'her:'1se1ves-,.--but.-~share.fa -" geesthouse for'gues_ts_. Further,.|§L¬_r-ystatied that two-of hisf

brothers -do not get along, --but ithat '-the _o_t_hei_:s__ are_ close. '

" * - returned tohe theme that certain elements _in_ the. I -

village werehappy tojsee him arrested, by U5 foroes"and said," ."My

enemies are ve ha py I was captured. They stab people in the back. " . Again, amended- -_1:hi-s statement =1-ater by saying _t~ha-t:&

didnit persona y ave enemies ,_ but that his brothe-r' diddue to. the a1.terca1-;ion'_.bet_w'een his brother md |:|ea¢plaj.ned-that

his brother had a fight approximate y ten" ays prior to h:i.s._<;a'pture

-by .US -forces and imjplied -that this was somehow'1inked- to the. bad _'

blood betweennhis brother .a'f1d I" ._ -1 ' - _ .1

" r ' Fi1:i:the:t',_.it was possible thate weapons belonged -to Q]

 phonetic! a well"-known comrnande-1'. _|::|admitted that". i'f_ t; e- '

weapons found 'int21'e compound hadbee-n new, '-he would-b'e ' ilty. However, the weapons really belonged to 'h-is-brother." 

1lQ1;__,_11§;§{E,__1iE_2_!§LI;;_I}§_Q]._lZ1j.§___E§.6.EQ11.5- to anyone- because "once - ey- were ~ '

given a weapon, they were restorl§iEIe'_¬5Elf*¬'EETrrTnE?IdeT-*w1T

in. ' "--.. - -". 1 ." .- - -. ' ' ' ..

' |:I denied being a lmemberiof the T_alibanor Al Qaeda. j ' ' Addit-ionally, Q had" heard of the I-IIG, but heard it for the first

time aplpro-Jtimate y four months"-a o and did not know anything-about the organizatic-n._ Eurther,|js:-gatzsd that the Taliban did not -

bring peaoef Only since-the USarrival has Afghanistan been ' -

V ' ' ll esp@~sES154

3 ' 9
 J'.._.h. _. _.;§E§¥EjT. :!. .' V l H: .C:D.L _ L§ .

92 fa

. ¢92 I I. - 1' '-'-b6 -F4 --

- '-_ - _ -e _b7C -4 _

_ _ b7D -1j"

-1 2s5A<mM~e991di g T//? LT[.-

F11!-3i}2a{Re92{..lO-93] _. _ - i _ '. I . -_ - _ V _. _

aneeaofaw ,1_@9,.@;a_-;_.{ -i 4

o.'peacefol; e7-'ea1o@ &._-.a_ _f~e=;et- I|=,_ 1:_»j '.

b-6 " ' L e '

|:lre:.terated that the weapons haclbeen provided eightto-" ten years ago Further,[::::]cla1med that he cold-Us forces where '

to find fJ.VE boa-tee of al'ILI'E11.1f|.J.tl0I'l |:] s famlly brought the " _-

_ ammunltlon from Jalalaloacl when. they moved to -the farm four yeare -

mc »-1 ago._ Oboe _agai_rI,j|:|insieted that "the ax-nmu'r_1it'ion_ 92§&#not "hie, _

p70 *I- =but~belonged.to his-bfother} 

. . ' , E;:::]stated.that there - 1 . h' L " were_no

b?Ff1" _ro¢ket-propelled grenades.foun on the pIEm15ES. _Furt er, the__

' recoil1es$_ri£le found-by Us forces did not work and was rueted..

-_ -' opined that-_-' it:..ie'- probably _"over' a hundred years old, " but , '

later" modi-fie'd'; this byjeaying that it was"frorn._his- !'grandfathers a time;w'- lgmaintained that-he knew. nothing of any éddiI:_ionaI -

,="_weapons_t at may have been_found on his oompoundf 1' ;- 1_'~

,_ ,_'|i

Z

T ' ' ' ';RESPON5E5d65 "
_-- j.-;_ _ .. _'z W, T Z 1*  *

_'."'FD3U2[Rev.15Hi-;
! - " '~_;5' -92 E

. . " i%5$T"'TL7;Té?%t 1 - - -""'!""~ .- ---r.-a.---:urn1m- -nm1rr1:~m_. ' -

FLs-¥F;£§2;;.¬;£§Eil-?§i=m¬39-gm-'5 " .. I g". , If<':E1i§"'I&

P+'i3=¬5E!!'.i,§31f?31f¥.=§iZf?.?"_.__,_...._.~_5" '-V ' i * . .' t . 2 - " b1-ii:-;=Q;E*ri.1:-u-:§xza1.§§;.*2.§;;' - " ' ' '- ' ' -"'""""""""""*i""* -

--~ . ~--==- - - FEDERAL BUREAU.01?mvmsnemnon. _ _ . .

- -- "'De==~'=f'm.-_"o'e.,g"gv.

bqc_ was'.'interviewéa at 'Ca.1'l'lEDE1t3.. Eff-Isentto-r-~-theinterview were SA . _.'

b?D' FBI,' sAL,_* N " . |_l_92Tav'a1 Cri'1fni'nal- -7 -. 2

ms - __»lfnVestA.§I_592-t_§|.92{e Ser:v:.ce"{1jICIS!_,. AljiblcLlnqugstl - _N " Ci;|.._ .

 " I _ ' I ' ' "' ' Iprovfde. .

I V*=t*+@11¢>r1g~11##~=>@"?i°11»t*=m¥1~?¥@Fi7°YV111.-:1 c I

_' ' _ - -' I W [.s'1t,§t§;d -h§.~_'l1.-a_d. been/be;éLte1;i ,1.;iC_O_I'1S'Ci,C& _1. ' ' .' ~'

156-4 gL_gptQxi,mé.1i_E!l§! 1Z_Q1',' i'._i@'1jI>_Jf-"i-f'<Z!I.11'.'weeks;'_é.g'o f_w_1_i_gn -g-;Zwas__ .si':_i_Z|.l, at-Q;;a1_:'_g_11§

__b?c-4 "'-Ray-.7 .Ac-;:érdigg_,__1:gI___ Y I an,{1mJt:;pwn n:ir|beL:;__o_§';_gua;_c'|.-- -,

1:111-1 _ 1-=i;;j@@.=_¢:I.1-, unpr@v,6lce;£_;ja.;_=1_s1=,a:tg,;1j'sigiuuinq 'aln'd_-cursing -at. _1'1,ga,.'_ Thg -'

- F '1-gggzgscalled--';him_ iI__50nQf a bsttch,"-anda.-"_ba;tta'.j:_c1',j_..thengold

- -h'e"=wa's crazy. '- _' j -

. J _|? ' ' ulIQilE_§1:'O;Ii¬O:. 1;,J';._S:-_S_CC?lJ@i,C1l-;jC_.tot-ad: hiréiself.' _

- ' i .1:;§~.c'ausé' 'he'-_.had receptlI£641, st " Z _-_ '

__ __ gg'ld:_'_eI 11'a.1_m='.d'.-|__ omac]; _s_urqe:1ri stated a"

-b6L _ _ _on_h_i_§_B,a__qk_-;é|=nd'_e;-t'§r.t~3d .b_eat'i:1"1' it; _ MC _ t-}:1e_fa'&:e.. I |1':hé_', .1¢hQ}C-Eg'§'!:1i:i7m 1.u1_1;J;l -hejpéssed .ou.t'§_| n

' b-ID_ §tat.ed_t;na_ waibeatxn hm becgguse ' . __ig;'__a"92}§;ug;_:i;_;_;;-,-j_-

b7F - HI!-<;n_|_|_is_;C11::i.5;i.a.n. |_-indigaiéd.t3¢_1_e::;e--gays; a. fem?-'1e,_ . -.

" ~ 'gu'a.rd.-n.amed'._L |whQ ;9292:as_ also bj§a.t;_i.';_;cLhi:11"an<f1 qralgbgd--h-isThe__a-CI '_ '

' ani:1'b E;éggt :|.'n-tg ;Ke-c.g.l__-£100 -' '.- - _' _ U .

t i ~ 7 r. 7 _ . . . I .. _, .

-  -_ 5iét§d';hat'_;1l. 't13g__ié,Qldi_ers_wa_11;i. - '

I l.'9t_::_|Ia_'Cih P-I,D__E",-¥'T|,--'-_Q,_Elél-'~ldt 11.§__92§[aS ZQOt1;1_¢"_1;1_<'::'sB;i.§T§l.§t'§ifQ ..

béat:'.:1 -' where he 'r._ecei3§d__an §r_e'-ajznliént'_fq_J;T§i§,,lfag-:'L_;.1 . i

b5 -4 6 '- 1w¬cn;n_<15__._-_ c-laimgé.thg w-ard.ei1,. 'f.¢hq'.'5.,s a_'.'c.a.li' ll.-£7::.i5;{-.1 " ' 

137$ 1-92i;iérji_cajL1:;.___m_é.J;e_, vi-§;it'ed_l;3.';;q' 'at_ 1:hé-hé$s- ic'.a.1_%pd hold -the giodtors to ' '

MD* inrgediately :';etu:_r;; he 12 . ca:n3'J-L=- . 1reDort'ed ._the ' -» '- .

-I???._ I §£oreme_I;!:_i_D11§§, _J'.r1ci__ide_§1t__'tTg Ltwc-RadCross re réjsentétives-at C l .

. _ _ I_J_@._'1_ta,._w1io he-'_identi;f_i_e.-'d -a.g;_| 7 | 5l:;a.ted____-ha? - '

_did gzpgc._dda-i13k!l:hinci_ to_.cau'.se ._1:_h'e-' ggarais -to entie -.h"i.sdell. -and did - '

__-' e3rje'r§-'t.§;i_-i1g- 1:'_1;.e5:; i'_nsJ:=ruc1:ed."hi_'m jgdo. _ ' - Ihadwhat.!__ajgp_e'

" . _to_bé,a. rec_e11t__wQi1m_;1:on._t_1ze=1;92;-idqe;7_of%_¬;§5nogeZ.- _ Z.~_ ' f ' _- _ .

Egctlq '- -' _ ___ I s_tal:,ed't];':,at'_'-L-lye _wl.'=1s- pJ.1t_'i_;1; _a11_.-is_'c:la"c.:Lg::1 dell ' . _ -MD_1 '-After. he?wk-:.s_ i;;vclved_.i:g_a--diapute _é>vé:|.;__£l:>q_g1,__gj..92!en_.tr:___

 E '. ' - '

_b7F *17"I - _§tEd;e';1%th&t+h§;i>suaa-aJ;&,e_-51;p;~eaJ.:_ica;:l:aj.g,;§c=_1;1da.,,___§_

-pl_=1§;e.Q, in __:i-sgilation_a.jt.'er.argtui;1é;_ wifghj uaiilifl; _ " ' . ' .

___ 3* *'** :__ _ _ __1' _ I; " t __ i T __;_;*_'* tt _  ; _

. inveénsnonbn _"_5]L2 2' _. a1'_G;uag=;ta'r';ar-rno Hal, Cuba__ J .- __ ': I '

Fae» 2'65A--Mmlcé-9102" ' - _" ' 4,6-;_1',3" - ' D====rr=:===éi"s 23 6-2-. . .-

- 7 ~| [-Nels '_ - ' ~
L ' 7

_, . .-

'Fb-soza- R=v.1o-6-951 '- ' I - 2

., .,_ 115-4--

. _ '_ __ - ' a - ._b7C -4"-'

_..gss_A-om-cs"9102 

_con&5p=;_n;n=ufFD-iozér - ' -,"0n 's,¬12g'___ . ;p..;;. I

"b5 _;; , _. 'j . ' ' -stated -he was an -imam-at .the 

' _b7¢ -4_" 'Mosq'u_e in -" audi Arabia..'_ -This mosque was" frequented. - ' - '

'_ b?D.~1 f foreigners -lI1' Saudi Arabia for ewployment.- was qualified

. b7F -1 ' to be an imam, because he -'h_ad'-memorized "two sections of'the- Koran. - '

' :-hashad no jorrnal -religi-ous_tra.i_ni1ig-. " H ' -

_- " ' ' " 5 -|____Z |mE_'.a Jordanian male Ila-med '_whi'l

b6 -4,5,6 working at bakery ._in| | - _ |t_o1d he was -,

b?C 4,5,6 intere-sized -in traveling -to t- e- : an "meeting-a woman to' e't_.UlS. ;

'b7D -1 c:i'tizer-1'ship.": :| told -his'.brother had 

b7F -1 , moved -tofthe U.S., and i::pta'ine - U.S'. citizenshi ,. so - _ -; " ' 1' . ' 'arrar;g'ed .a meeting betweei-1| and'| . II __ - - _- .j

" ' ' ' ' ' as working iii-'5a11d1_ Arabia -'wI.i_en| .i"r1et- him.

__ av the telephone n1imber'_of ..-.e . _'_ '  '-_ -. . . his friend in ' '

 ___ rlndia-na 11atned'.[ _ _ _ '  I - ' ' 'mam"- -_

b7C _ name [,__.who worked at" 1'1'e'Is1am-ic- Center -in~ -. ' -

MD '_Indi_ana_,__ . thou ht -that rieeded an -ima1'n- an may 3

mi ' ave w l1ing_ to elp wit ' is trip- _

called and'.arrange -to travel to the U..S. an_d__teach at the,

Islarnic Center. '. " ' " ' . 

. ' _- -_ stated that-.'11,e' was arrested and .in'carcerated' -

I _ i? %a%di Arabia after b_ein'g;'ass'ociatewith an armed robbery. |:| '

_- _ was f.ri_end_s- with aman n d T -who -on-ned - '

' - a.__per:Eume' st ' - where was. -a re en cus_tomer_.' ' - -

 ' In addition, went. out-to" dinner with on a, regular 1'

_ -basi-s_. an . __wo of his _£.ri'ends-"named- ABE -

_b7c _ .were involved in"-an armed ro_ ery' an arrested by

. 1371:» e au i_ - ian -police. was also -arrestedbecause he '- -. "mp _ was an associate of'|_¬ T | stated he 'h_ad_r'

todo-

- '- with the robbery, bu _was coerced by torture to admit he was - -- ' '.i_nvolved"'by the Saudi Arabian .po1ice.- spent two years ' ' -

- " . " in'carcerat'ed'in a pr:'!.son' in] 1 one year a c-er; he.._was In 1E=leased.,-"he. s¢t~"92er1"i@='i--' . I - -" 1' - -  " I-

-56 -4 . an 1-;=>'24~Q .. lworkea for mel I we __4 | I - f <fo1v1P Y j92_1sti'T::uts-ie -a:.| k1{-e-~de-a1c~we'aah---¢

hm _1 passport issues for foreign workers and _repres"ented- the-company in - __j '

_ bjlf _1 _ -1-_ra£fic_vic_:1a-tions invoivi-ng_ foreign drivers. '- ' _  '

I - h-' ' -' advi_sed- that he_ took _a'tri1ito- 3ii3har1is't-

_ 1989, when e was sixteen years old. _ At t_h_e__ time, the Saudi , . '

. _ - Arabian gove"-r_nment was offering-a .759; ;idis<:ou.nt on iairplarie t:i,c_kets'

' -RESPONSES167 - .

_ u _ .92 ' . ', .. -
-_,i ||_|_ if .

' '-- -1| - -- ' . . . '

-"'Fcp3u1a n@v.1u4t9sj . . '1 = .' . ..

I a

* b5 [:::::::::]-rebeived training on.the KALASHNIKOV ahd-physical _" '_ '

' , -be-4'1. '

- =1 - - . -b7C -4-.

-_ _ mo -11 ._265;?1.M1924-CS{9_l_O2- Q "92b"»'F_ -1» 

- Con!-tIinualinn.ofFD-302 of I _ I I I ,O11 '5/LZZLQQ I ' :.P!I$= _ - ;3_ Q

, -to Paki-stan-, or the g$urp'os.e of traveling .'1;o'-AfghanistanH -Flights I

' le_ft_ tlxrice a wee1jc,__ and were--a1ways'boo}<:ed. _ ' . __

'. |_ . trave1ed frOm"Is'1ama.bad to.--PeshaPakistan .

b6 _4 5 and stayed in an Arab guest house called, .B'eit;A1-Ansar. . _The__ L  .b7C J1 5.]_eader of this -house was ar1_ex-Mujahid from S_a_r._1di_Ara

_ b7D.,f While he was at.the house. e was 1nfQrmed'there were two military .-

b7F._1 camps for training-in~Afghanistan; The A1-Siddeék camp was for - 7

' 3 xshoirt term trai-ning_,_ usually limited to ab ut two? weeks. - The All -. - ' " "_ "' -_' ' _.- was' ona br ak,.'from

_ Farowk camp was for longer training _ e

school-,' so: he ..decid_ed_' to. attend the sho_rt'ei'_ -A._lSiddee_}c' camp- 1' _. '

l  '* ' -' - The'AL4Siddeek camp has iocated near Khowst, Kfohanistan.

big _ exercise.  He claimed 11:. -1~§as.very' colfii land the camp's wellas - .-

mu ~ frozen- etat_ed he waeobese. at'_the- time "and was. unable. =b7F'~ to complete t e raining. ,He attended three days'oi

" F ;"g_ -.- ' - _be£.ore".rsquesting to-be sent-ho_m'e_. _H:|.s_;trainer was

' ' from-Mecta;'Saudi ArabiaL_ ".-~ - - -' J- wd '.'-_w _'-_¢

__ . - '- " . I:I trave'l'ecI to Bo'sn_ia -in 1.995. 3 At. the time. the '

 . ' _wsss;.:rent_ing an a artmelgtwith his wife-land-_strugg1i-ng ti-hanci-ally. _ ' ' - 'He=*.1as.tated S_heikI'P K Ifr'om[ _ I"Saudi_Arabia'o

1

_§.?C'_ to payhis" rent and proed Him'_with I?-[006 to l0,__0O0 __Saudi'_-Ri_

hm _ if-:he_.would agree .to journey to Bosnia to fight. He 1e£t_.Saudi..'- _-

1315 _ Ara'b;i_a withenother :_'Lan-_na_r§1ed __ W. ___ I I -- _-

' - -' c-laimed -his motivation for traveling to. Bosnia was money iand t_he._ - .

" _ pos-sibility _0f meeting a-.'woma:.'1.- Li was married at -the 1;_ime,

. . "lo but. indicated the marriage wasnot working. . _.

. - ' .- tra§e1eH £romI:ISaudi "to 'Zagrebr _

' -. _. . __.'Croatia by. p ane ona Croa " V . Fronizagreb the two traveled

' address by/bus to-Split. ,Croatia.. had an -_ ' 1:1 i S lit from' p - _

I. I his cousin who'wor_ked forAL HAI.'A'AL OLYAA L=._'EJAMI' AL 'TABAROA'I'~-

 - - LIMOBADAI MUSLIM1 AL BOSNIA AL_RIYADH}'"The_translation for this -»

106 - name means.-The'High. Committee" to -Collect Donations for the_Mus1ims_- .

...b7C ' ___92__'in__Bo'snia'_,.H-_ Rigadh, Saudi. Arabia. ,~Th-is organization was chaired by --

23? I - -Saudi Prince B7iI1f1EHDEL_'3£ZIZ.._"Th"e-"two-'s'

the beach in'..Spli_t for two_' orthree da -s. - They visited the off-ices .- ' b V-.of the_High Committee in SpIitJ[:;;::fi::¥mentioned the_Haramay

' _or-gani-zation was also iI1VDlVEd'J.IIl osnia w ile he was there. ' The '

- Haramayn organization supp-lied food, medica1- supp-l_i'e's, -and money to 

the Arab houses in Bosnia; :He had no_knowledge-of any military-= -

sugport provided by Haramayn, _' Haramayn was chaired by Sheik. - " .' ' I 7 _ W Iand Shei1cI:I'orI:| -Haramayzfwas -

'  Responses 1/as

. . - r _ -

_ - _. _ _ _ . ' _ . I.
_. .I1'_;'. _ - .-

r - - ' ' - .

nmmnauvmssnE7 -f* ;

 - ., ._ l_

I 265A-MM-cssioz

J b6 Q4

F" b7C -4_ '

- . b?D L

= b?F L___

' CunnuaunofFI¥3DiufJ _;_J W o,.oi1_51_2;1L02, 1""_.»_==;= ' '4&#

b7C 

_headciuartered in R'ivadli§-'Sa'uMabia'.' sta-tedlithis was

all-common knowledge in-Saudi Arabia _. .r _ ___ _ - o._~ '

They'boarded-a-bus in Split_andtraveledto Zenica,'Bo

me; with1a'grqupef-Ara b s fighting_wi":1-1- e an B ' osnian Ar" Th -1 "e

f_ Contactinformationfor this group.was_rovideoibI HYW |. Ihe

group of Arabs were called AL~KATEEBA. statedtE3s group 1' ' I t'M "' B t th_ B ' 

. - -_wa5_j_11vc	V_Ed."iI1_military opera ions in osnia_w1 _ ' e OE-_I'J.J."-9.1'l.-

.92__. . ; . A1-my'-_Th-ey_ traveledto -- E _'s' headquarters" in Zenioaand 92

b6 staY ed for a few--_da' Ys_.', _c1id.not__li'1-:'e the AL-KATEIEBA "group

- because of the. strict 'dlSC1P1E and-harsh schedule -' b7D statedhewasforcedto-get upeverymorning before tgeSl.lI1IlS6&#

b7F

H -J- _ to go to Q __ P Q __P' |_ _'_. I -- : l-

_ - }Zubair was also involved 1n_mil1tary operations w1th_the.Bosnia =e

' Army,'.but=-was _not__'as s_tri'ctwit:h :ii,scip_le.'_' Al-Zubair had A-rah

'" -housesin-Trzavnil-:1," _'Iu1s__a-, 'and.ano1iherqL;ni:1enti.£_ied city_.-|

" otated the Arabs_at.the houses would gen picked up by'the.BosnianArmy,-. issued weapons," and taken to fi ht. -There were no weapons :_

..present at any of the

_ - Zubair 92l~.'ere'rec'eiving'

. -I::|w¢@ "ts the

remainder of-his time

_hquses._ heard AL.KA'IEEBA_ andl ._

..weapons through the Croa.tianmafi_a from.'_Ii"an.

Travnik Arab house where he spent the I

in Bosnia; - . '. '-'- -*1 '-

was at the Travnik house he served as the I'b6 '4 ' cQdk' [::;%:iff%%;g%g;;g:Looking andafter theArabs at_the.ho

'b7c -4 'discoverej. is .ta1e_nt,_ they" a"l1owed-.him'to [stay '_at_.the.t1'ouse and. _

bin-1 " 'pe-rform Ehe.'coo"king duties.. |:| den-iedinvc>l_ve1'"ne'nt with<_any

1 b7F -1'=

Saudi Arabia was pregnant, BO Ego_ _o ' ' withtheleaderof thehousein Travnikname_ l '

bqn_ ' and wes_given pe ' " :return to Saudi. .- _

15 _ trave ed to Saudi with a-Sau¢i' , ' ' ' ' b

military-operations in Bosnia. fQ , @*. ' ' ,»_ Q '..

in Boenia, he learned-' his wife 15 -

he was forced to retur

from Jeddah who had "

_ " spent * thought was fou,r'months"' fighting in Bosnia. _i | __ I

-ii_nm_in,ma_g@Qd*;;§g§l;Qg;E§rtner;beoause he was not a devout Muslim and.

b6 -4

b7C 4

b7D -1

b7F -1

_ - ' ra erandAvesnotallowedto retiirnto Sleep.-IHe_.ple'atie.d. wi&11|:| 5'

 ' differentrou in" Bosniacalled'Al*Zu.bair -_A1-

' - ~ ' _enjoyedhavingagood"E'irr1ié-§1_'Ti1[-=1 ti?-*véli.n*';;.'T"':* ***** -" _*.-"-~------------_-~-»"-~ ---~--- -

' '_ h |J5eturned toSautli Arabiaandworked a-tag]

55 k W77 Contractorsas a liaisonbetweenthe Sau 1 ;

b7c _-governmen- an oreign workers in.Saudi. He worked for the coman

bTD b7F_ =_' fora roximately eihtmonths tooneyear; While working atEj%:jY . - _ Contract:ors;, | idecided- totakegatriptoMeceaand

".- -'visited in Je a_ on is Way homeifrom Mecca. I "1 _I

RESPONSES-"169. -

----------'i'------IIIIIII1IIInnn--------------
- e -17IIIIIIIIIIIIIIQIIII-IiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

1

. ,1 . __ - __ I.-._i. ,._ ' .;- __ __ - .

I - '-f _. _V x ; ::! o

* ?"@-3D1= r@=%:1v-bi§si~ f - . . - '- _n. ~-.

I 255A-MM-C99102 '

:b6 -4 .: '

' b?C -4

- ':b?D -1-,

-'. . b7? -1 i

cnnnnunnn nr_F0-302 or .. ' n i L-<>=1§>/2;/91 Y fan e §_;i_

i Al I <1 "g the -iiime was-int-roduoed to two 'indi§ridoa:ls&I

. ' ' - ' s this owI'1er'of_a_'pe-rfume shop in .He introduced 

to.

_ so_92ir:._ _l_-_ , -__ ,9; _. ~ 'fr%%,E]fe United Arab Emirates by his, frien?! . _ _

if_ _'a dire_'ct.descendan

né L nine: nnh'ammna' and an unidenfifie man oi Indian descent

b7C 

b7D 

b7F "

-.took s bhone|'1"1'u11ibe'r arid' qozitacted hirn":i.n 1§96 - ja trip to the Uni.te'd_-Arab Emirates-. __ jlhernhe _ar_r-ived at_E'"

5 hgmé in AbuHDhabi in the Emirates,.he.learned the-two'wereo »

.1 I, j ' 'p1.anni__ng -a -trip. iio Chechnya;--"_They. i;1vii:e<i'| W [to go"t:_o_' ' 3

. Chechn a no _ Y g fi ht with them. - jtoldl Ihe had no l i l .

mone for the tri ' I Itold him not toworry'and provided =f

expenses; f ' _Q_[ . fh

'b7C 

-b7D 

.b7F 

.'-|:]were -bored and returned. home,-_ 92 - . ' _ ' - . _.;

_ ' -' " unidentified 'amount_ of time 'in_..Saudi '-Arabia~ ' %dec1de:1=tc> in-51: we parents -of i

" - ' 6. friend-who " '1led -in Bosni-a.. They traveled a " b6 _4 5 6 _1:o 'Bahra_j_;1.a'nd balked to 's_'bro_t ' The three I

b-;c _4l5,5- decided -to-tra've_1 co Ta, ' ' '1 is an to _ _fi ht wo unteered 'to'-._ g _ . * - . _' . mg _1 _f_inan§:e the trip  and;gave'-him .a'n._&

amop.n_t_ of

b7F *1 mone§{'p1L15 -traveling e1-@ense_s.. ' The-Igroup traveled by vehicle back :

,- 3 . 1 ._ The -g1joup'_-'f1ew_ to Baku Azerbai an and-"e'Eayedlat'_ar1_-'. , _ 5 1_1-r|1i<':§enti£i'ed.hot.el_ in .1_:he city-_ | called a 'coi1tac&

ah ___ - _ _ -- safe" house in arr-uni-denti'f_ie oca_tJ._o11-_'._and they-were-fdriven to - l arrived at_.the' house he jU.I1E cte 1 me; b6 - _ __ ' . ,_ _ 'and'_a.z1ot"ber Sauc1i_named -

spent the-next '{:wo'monT_:hs at "the safe -house» During. I:bis=_time,. _- ..

" 1-'1'-ir'n.with 3,00-U-'to'4¢,-000 ,S.aucj._':i. Riyals -in addition to trave1__ _

they _'went. on. wa"_l1{S, .r-ode the 'm"erry¢gorr_ou.nd," and=_went sightseeing. "I .

._ I _.The_<-.'s_afe house was 'a eta in _a,rea=for' Arabs. tr.ave_lirig_-tq.=Che-chi1ya_. _

-' . , - .t"¢-if-ight, but when -was. t:,here_'the_ rote was'_cand no 3

one was "able" t:o- get -Into ech-nya. -. After ntwo mo_11"r;'_hs.,~ a1-1d ,-

, '._. to_Saudi Arabia end evehtually be Kuwait - They '_de,airlipe '[

. . ' re-gervatiions to'f1y..to' Pakistan. Sa;id a the ; .

- - ----__...._92__._...__.________-_________ '_i .-_- . .

. - connecbions necessary to get; them to Ta3.:Lkistan_. . - I -_

. - - -W_hile~t.he'_-group-_was

incident'at'the'Khobar,Towers

b6 -

b?C -

b7D -

" b7F -

the..;in erro ations. the group

up. returned to Bahra

group" was -detained"-by Kuwaiti,

was re ea e " W]... ou' 1c ar e 21 p -

_ _ jin and|_ !went to-".

. .Qa1_:ar for two gla s until things'_re{turned to normaf. Wh e- inr ' '- Qatag, {and 7 a_|had a disagreement overmone "anal '

Wei'f1gT1hKt1wai.§t""for'*a-fiiirghtq---&#

in Saudi Arabia -occurred and-'_the- "

Intelligence for teh days- . Following

1 'd."t;hth' atlslit

l ' * i |[Hepartec1' or an 1-lni_ent'i§iec1 ~location._ , decided'-"to 

' RESPONSES-1'70 '
_ n . -_ . - . .

. .- - .- . _ , . ; . ' -~ -

" FD~302a{R:vI.lU~é-953 _ '_ * _. . '

'1 . '- , ' ' 1 .

' ' _ "be -4 1

. 3'  _ _, ._ b7C -4 1

 ' -' ' - r b7D -1 ' ' 265A-Mlfi-92C99lD-2 - ' _ ms -1_

..C='"?1'""F*""°1'PD-361 OF. 9r|'92_'. " P=§:=1_Y_j

_ retdrnto-Saudi.Arabiai so he flew to Bahrain-andleaile his ' e 7- h

' parehts tQ piCk him up.f. . ;'.» - _' K _-.5 - -,-- ~b6 4"

-' H. _On his way.£rom Bahrain.to Saudi ArabiaI [::::::::]ums -b7D'

' arrested-by' Saudi.'1-ntelligence undersuspioions1:emming from the 579 '1 _

. Khobar_Towersbombing and his foreign travel. -Be was sent to -- =' "

' prison in Dammam where he -was beaten for .two_we_eJ1:'s .pri'0r to his

'_ ' interrbgatiohb He was detained by the Saudi government-f0r_;, j_,._

b5 _4 _ aapproximatel-y three months and _re'lea-segi. fl sis passport wa's.r'e_Vok_ec

b?C -4 forfone and-_-a, half:-_year's._.-_-He retizrnedhome and mfas-1_1J.red_ as an_ ' -.

b"-D -1 ' Imam ina- local mosque. Durin this time he; -was 1'13-5° f=FflPlE?yed by . -

- h ' "n H - ' --Two"weeks ater his passport 'was,-_returne_c1,'__ he _wa-is again ,-_

. ' - '" detained by the Sadi government." He"was taken to prison iJeddah

-b5 "4 "and interrogated'four times-over_the-next month-and a half.* He was'.:

b7C -? "¥ELeaSed and returned to| _ I but his passport was revoked for '

_b7D L- ,fi?e years. I ii Iblaimed to be unaware of the reasons behihd,

b7F -1 ' his apprehension and.passport revocation; _-' 19- "V| - jt;

. " '- ' ' ' . ' In- i998 the Bfahr_ain'.gove'rnment anno92.u1cec_1- it was reissuing _

, -- _ Bahraini ass ort-s to members of the - tribe -in, Saudi _ . -

55 _ Arabia-.'§.. s father was originally from Bahrain and as a '

b7C - ' result ' was able to receive a.Bahraini'__pas'spor't.. [:1 ' '-

b7D . ec~:Ee'c!1:e ooul-d no'lo_hgerflive -in: Saudiiarabia because of_

b7F * _ e" pars cot-ion -_ -_g I 1. e of the overnment He lanned oh oin to live in-j ' _ p= ' _ _ _

. _ - ."-_Kuwa-it or"-the United-Arab Emirat-e_s,~ but--met ,and- ' ' . '

. ..'. decided.to.itravel to the--U.S._ . '  ' ¢ ' _' _ _ '1

. ' 'trave1ed to'Bahrjain-and visited the-U.S. -.

__ embassy "an received a' five"year tourism visa. s ather

. - gave him 19,000 Saudi Riyals for h-is trip to the u.s_. jse flew Erorri- -

-- 1 7 and was icked u at '

. Bahrairto ISt&I1]QJ.1 to] ,,|to| I _. - Ip _ - p __

be - the airport.b _ " took_him.to the.Islamic -

1:=?c - center in 'IN.. was moved to the Islam-io _ ' ' ., b?D  ' ' en a _. , W __ if _ |.'IN'. -_ 'He_w

" '

C, .. .

.- . c ter t _

b"-F '_________h____j_o1q;_ap_pro§imat-e_J.§-;t§{o months_ before returning to 'saud:|..__.Arabia- to I ' ' visit his siok fathefT*Z§It¬Teightrmonths*inSaedi+Arab¥

_

 _ returned_tO the U.S. hHe'speht aboht'ten jays in_Wes ' 3

- -before he was transferred tg theIflamio center oh the _

___ _ _Z IN.' He spent - -_j .

approxfnatelyf -s-ix and. aha months W | .but,also- made . '.

side trips to Michigan and Buffalo, NY- _He returned to Saudi .-.' '

' Arabia:for two or three months, then retarded to_Buffa1o, NY until .

threeweel-cs after the Trade Center.di'saster. 'I-Ie--£1.-ew to _Bahra:i.n

_ . .. ._ RESPONSES-17i___ _ _ 
_ .1

- 1 i _ '

=~ .'T-~- -' - - . '-.

"- .ED=3Uia{R:v.1Qw5-95} ' .- P ~i§¬.- '- 92. __ _ _

. I . - _ , __fb6 *4 al

~ - -- " bvc -4

. . _ __b.?D __1.

- 2-55A-MM-c9s1o.2 .. - - ;_-'b'»'F 1'- 92.

__CunLinua..t-ion-nfFD-E-02 of._ -. | I_-' ,OrI__5 '22£9g_,&#H_.Pl§= _.- - 7 iii

-£01:-two c'1ays,th_er;- to-'Ir'an_w1ie_1;e he,met his'con'_-

' '_for themosqué_tour.0f Afghanistan. I 1 »~ '  ' _ _ '

- I ' - " " ,;~; -- b7C -5

-'_U-  J

1

I

e

It

_ I _ I 1 -_........,-.-.-............--....-__._, _-..__________....,._,.,_,___,_.__._.-.__- _.,..._-__.._,.. .. . ._..-,_._ ._._-

 - . 6 g - .

L

F

l

1» _ .

_'.; '- RESPQNSES-"-1Y2 _ ._
J I -

}  I

Positive

Response

Number 10

, I

:-

i"

I
ii------- - .

. . _-1 __ - I 92

_Capi'oni Valerie,-E. OGC}'[F-BI! I '  - -' 

ia 1 _ -I-NSD!tFBl!; . . V. ~

we -1 '_ Sent:' Munday,AuQust02.20042:45 PM .. - -. .- ' - J --l-1°-ii 'f'R>' F7e|!'__ l I

' -" _ - 'c==j _C_§e|'prcni,Valeriei'_ _" ,

_ ._$uPjec!;;i8E;__GTMQ"_ H .. ,_ I

' -" ' _ - 92_   L . " _ . I

.- .- '" '_: 0*"; 05*!

I OK, thanl-ca foriiie e|_uick.respie|'i_se.._' ' l '

F " "-jiiiiriginal - H - _

From: IR!- FBI!, _

_ #16 1 JSent:M0nda Au estC|2, 2001i2:40"PM -

_ *°f1 '- _'--Te:- zuse! :=e1!-- .

__ ' _5|gb]e :_' - - -- . "

._ I-.was-situated. in'thé"observatioi1._bcib1;h-in befWéer'1._.tWo i_ntew_iew roems, -qbservihg an intefview whibh '_ -I. '

ir.1c|uded-ai.-Ieasi-'dne_FB-i'SA,?and'-pdseibly a.col|eague.of'his-_fri:r!1&bf ti_1e.oth_er agencies with -. _ .. _'

inivesitgatiye. pers'onnel_ agsigneil tl'.ie_r_e'a_t-the_ time. The bdoth 92.-.ias_quile créwded because. thre were

" Iseuerel individ-uais. present who were obsenging-an "ihter92iiew" _in''1e.r0orrg bn thenther side _of'the_ booth. ' .

. in th a1'rbom',_tl'ie detainee wae seated in-'a ch_ai_r and was seciired-in the game method asI'd -seen for all _of. ' '

_ '_:the ether; detainees, shackled at his fee! so -that he cquld not Ieaxve t_h'e r_-orn_. Hoyveiverk there _wasnt n1u;:_h' _ _'

.  ";ta|_k'ing geing on,-be'ca'i.:se thei-|ights'had be_en'tumed~off and _a St|'0§:ie7|igiJiwas=ickeririg on ar.1d=0ff.3.d-" i =

- _ 1m:i.ud-rock mus_ic.wa§.being played. '.l estimate. that this went in fo'r.30 to 60 minutes. I was told by quite a. -

' '__-Jew FBI-pei'sc1>nr!e_'| that iaétics such-as this-were quite-'comrnpn.there_attheiime. This_.vi_ras-the'Qnly'-

.ever_itthatl.ob$eirveddirei:t|y. '- _' _I - r - -_ _- . ' _' . '_" _ _ 1 - 1

< _. H "_il.'».-;»4:;é1:}ei.i¢i;=.~=$'=_1a;-_;' T'i

 . . LPram-=ik1~s:~»>'<+=B1>-V.-V~V be -1 ' ' Sent and Au ust02,2Cr0411U3AM

1" .. - 5u_bect:'_ :_ .. "- '_

, ;_ q.L'Ji;,____._ " - 1 _

_' b?c ~1. |:|-could yc_.=u.piease_prcividi=.=:"ad,ditio|::alinforrnation,-rn'o:e spet_:i<': short si,|rg_|rji1ary!__,- -.

' .- - '" '"' _d1§'I§eie'd*oT1"tha'i"d"rie*i1'rcidenL"-+~f-.--r----~ -*-.----*-~------'~ -- ~->4 -- - - -

I ._ _ _ _ . _ ._ . _ H-I1 _. 1. I ll;

.. . ' ' ' - '. f_'--3-#O'ri i'naiMesea' - ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' L~ Fmm= IR! -FBI! i

' be '1 Sent: Fricla J 1 0.9 20044:10 PM . b'iC _-.1. l ' 'Te: ;Nm!' Fe1j'

- , - --._5lIbJ==t= . - - j

.II'i'lp_0I'E3._I'lFe: High _

. L V i » .. RE_SPONSES._:173_ -

l -Gm-'5I.r'92A - '. '_ __ .. . _ u ._ - . '_'
., . -I I - ._ I I -

- _Ret cm» e'_'-.ma-itmessage from-Steven C;-Mci3rew:rece.ived mime oh_Friday, Joly Def

 2oo4..,¢_ _ ~" - :-. h

I - As a membefof the Nationatcerper for the 'A_naiysie'cf Violen_t_Cme NCAVC! in-the. _ 3

Criticzii _lncidentResponse Group _ CIRG!,,i was assigned to a.tour_at GTMQ from Juiy--2 - 24,'

2003.1-.Whi|ethe|_-e, l provided inten.§iewlinten'ogation_ advice to F Bi. SAs who were tinvolvegi in -

ongoing interactions with detainees. _|'dire_ct|y observed [4 intewiews with 12detaineee. - _ ' '

.DUring one of these interviews I am notlsure which one at this time!, I-observed treatmeiit of _

another detainee by at diereht'interview'team,which included teptics tha__t, while not.ove'rIy _

' I 2iggres$ive,' were clearly not oonsistentwith Buieau-interview-poIicy!guide|i|j1es. To my _' .

-i ' knowledge, there were no FBI personnel invclyed in-thatinterview. I do not recall at this time - I

t I the identities oragency afiiations of those who were irwolxfed in thatinterview. " . ' ' "

- .5!-arting,~ne"_!ct i92_'ion"dey,-ItiuIyl_'1-2,-fDD4',will be ih ttevet statue in Sanblielgo Ceiifotnia, arid .' &

- . .~. - J,-J.1.§':19L89§i Al.¬§!<.El- .. |..i:'i|| P¢..?E92?! 5°! M0 fl1|l'WBB|<5- F9.tL1'Ti.i"9 to. mitt ?T°9.'°" M°daY1 J-"3'? _'.__'26'."My.direct'té1ephohe'n

g ' .-_ '

'---SA

- . . - . _ . J .b?C -1' - 1-

..=tat-_1|n-._._, . ,

- -   --- ---_,-------- ¢-.- -.... - - - ;. =.._._..._._._.92.._.;.__4.__ _-_ ._- _._;__...........-.. -.-..'_............:|.-_........-.,......-...-....._. .._.__ ....._ ._. .-. __ ______,_

. ' ' I ' ' <

92 _

_ "__RES'P_ONSES-1:74 '

-' '.ti.n:-anri.4-'7 . , " _ ' ' _ '. '. .-
i

. 1

Positive

Response

Number 11
o ' ** ______

t ,-L > 1'-Meé's_a'ge3 __ _ . _ 'Pagé

W ms.o_ FB|! ' b6 1 H W 7. .7: I _ _ -- P __ Y-__ ___1_j_ I if --;__ Vi-_-__ -_ .-. - -

b-TC--5'1 |: LD!tFB1! ' ? - .lL<?"'v- -t .

" = - Su'5joot:RE;'.";TMO _. __ '"_v?".%.

t t V ¢- o o t J

_ 'O|'<_..for now__W.é-v!riI|_oo_u_r!l you.! as a_."P0§iti92f§"' Fponjse. 'P}oa§o d_o_'the. EC anti fob.-f|ard. Jj92___ '_ U-_J{-i._

V~ T - +~@ H-'!a=M@1=sa 8--'-t » ' L. ~ I = V %1,+

b6 -1 .¢F~-i|<w> FBI! - H -bqq; -1 Sent: Monday, Jul? 12, 2004- -1:31 PM -_ -- ti!-1*-_. _ SH .' _&- ,,92

 -_ - -To: IN5D! FBQ ~' -  . "- L- ,3-e.

W - .- -Sl.Ib.iect_:RE:_GlM0 Q I  - _ - ' " _.-,-.@::<'.§iZ3'j?".t;"ieir1

.

. - - .- r .. - -. ' ~ . .' . .,.-1».-.' .-=.wa;_-l=-='-'- . "

_-; - §E_N$I"r'1yE am UNCLASSIFIED .. -  -- -' 1' 1 - ' -' - '

;--¢_~¥':j---~¥~NN-»RE§E-B%_:1"_: _- ¢jj _ _:~>+-j . .¥<".' ' -_ '--~"»-_--w---&

b7C -1, H-' %

~- . any agjressivé treah'nent-of'det;Toes.'- one déinee "_ --

' n ' u n blodshot d hat b'bI ' 1 "' I " . 1/__o agpgare J age _ 0 __eyes an w jagpears to e _ 0051 tha congea ed to'h|s_e1glashe§4 7 -

I ' _ am following thise-mail upwith an EC and enclosure that will contain a CD _wjth the original Raw ies and _ .

t -  - irnagos cotwerted to the TIFF format - l'a_n1 aIso'ir|c|udiF.I9' prints ranging-from fulléce to close ups:'of-the.

_ -- _ . '_ dotaineo;s'eyeo! _. r ._l I__ -.1 '" ' TI V - -.

bis .'1' ' ' pecra Hotographic Unitflr

.- _ ' .- .' ' ' .Lab_orator!¥ Div'i5iOH'- '- '

, .

92

f_;h6 -1 - .

"b7C -1 .~ .

1. ' -?:12k:é004--

1 Sent:

 T0:

- 15H. "FBI ;_ CUMMINGS ARTHUR M; CTD FBI]

---Ooiaim-$89?-" ' I . - - .

M_cc_RAw-, STEVEN C.. INSD_!. FBI!. -1 - . -_ 3 1 -- ,

u|" 12 20041213? = .- - " '  '

MM!. FBI.' MM! FBI!

_0I co - _ M_M FBI

- Fnom:

HO! FBI!. _

 NY -FBI

to - NYUFBI 7 MMHFB1!: o .umFBI L

_ Ho!.=BI!; @115! FBI ; aAT'n_E,"FR-ANIQE Cm! FBI -

oMM!<PB1!!<w~>ctFe1 cw:.c==BI- ' ,

_ Ho!_ FB1'; , _ sJL FB1~-- - . . I.-D!» F.BI]';' _ J ow! -_

 FBI!; NY! FBI!; DL! FBI!; AN! .

 FBI!; NO! FBI! IR!.{FBI -- NY! -

._ FBI!; -__'Tl'D} FBI HO! _OGA- G0!

FBI cG! FsI i_ MM! Fat!! --MM Est!; w

Hom=BI!; -<IB~1<EB-I!- MY!» ~

A"-0; _, "L5-!__s1-  , -- _ _

A o' FB_I!; 1 no FBI!; - 

ll'" FBI!, V - F-B »*'-L-"-

l CF13.-HFBI A50 -. _.l*.1I*'l3' FBI - -

Kt !' FBI~!; t~Y	c@GA!: I<>< FBI!; '

MM Fat!;

ow!

MM!. .Y_ -

 FBI!;

cm! FBI!:

-ll! m = !;

M!" FB1! mo _- '='

 FBI!; MM! =B'I!_; - - MM! {FBI};

 FBI!; MM! FBI!; _ SF. FBI!;

 Far!, co FBI sF!__ Fa1

 SE! IR FBI -~

' . - J: ' _

- FBI - ' FBQIL ITPX! Fer-!:|++|£N+<! c%I!Q PX! oak!; Mo!-, * t

 Ho!

_- V ~ " RESPONSES-175!." 3

. - . _ _ _ "  . 2-, - 1
----------------IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

_I|I|I|u_ _ 7 _+ f _ 7

a ' 'Q Y £Révjo1J$1-zone! 3 ' ::::j ' _ ' j ; aq _ -"---- - .J _ " :::! * -' 1 ' '

.. ii=£p|:aAL?

"- Pi'ec:édence': " ROUTINE-' . ' - - ;Da.'t.e: 0:!/12 2oo4_

___7 492

To*'-Counterterrorism - ' . Attn: ' b5*1

. _'- " . .- . . bjrc _l_

F#$§;a §abdiab0ty Qiviéianffi" I Ia: - a'? :._ '_ " ~[ a - j' __.SpeCial Photo ra.hic Unit /[:::].__ b2i. '

= .b?C -1

b6 -1 a#PPrPvéd'aBY=aaE::l#w " L %

Drafted By:f: jtb~ a '1

" _ ciasa-In-#=-.29.1--HQ-Ai32?6.-69-A-a¢7{Pending! ' .,_ __

. - :. , :' ' - _ .

' -;~'Ti£ia}:aCbah£ara:;O:ia@_D1§isioh;'§TMb,;fn$@a¢ti0hép

I ~;Inqui;y@__-'f <_q* j= ;,".:H I "_a;._. '92§, , U.

_5 synop§is{- No bbservafian bf aggreasive treatment of detainéés

__Qbut ph@tQg;aphed-one-dapa;nee who had_blood shot eyes and what

H appears to be bIoOd_tat_congeaLed to Qia eye¥ashes.1-" ~ ,Q'

 La " irt~;ae$d'f _:'hr : '~F§.Enclosure{s}: One CD containig a}l§ g ' , _; 4; 5" [35

,,"éé;5 '>a.FBj,numbBr[::::::::]';SNnumbe;[__ i _ é_ pbtographedfgn 1b?C _ fMa ch_I2 2004 at_4;36 PM by {$&T} Phot0§raphEr]_ _ |=af?

Z " a '}a#ailable from tha Special Pha£dgraphicfUnit,. uanticq{| -

Virginia;___.. ";_*.j - _»,-_-_ _» »'_-_._ " '. "a u

. be _hl E$eta;i_ls:: _.'Ph6tb§fapha'r.' Séi_anT;i'fiC'ah C1 _'" __

i-' bn;_1 J Téchnicall of the Special Photographic Unit,.Laboratory -.

¢§[' 1. '--a.Division,_was assigned to tephbtograph the detainee's far-eQ' ;5'.. - 'ug_sh6t$_o=severaL_days'and twO_travel'assignment5 f;¢m¢ ~_

_ March.11}to_March 16; during-ZOQ4 ;nd_JunejIQ ta I1; 2UO4._'H 1' _ '-

§- T _ if _i - Durin thé.firat~aasigment,.dn Mar¢h'lQ]'2004|_- _§ * - detainae ~ FBI nmmer IS-N .nur]zber ; - _

;'.':$C*f4-_:1 j I was photo§ra bed and Maan Case printéd at 4:36

H. . _ PM, .It was bbserved that had lcod s pt eye | I I ' b h' s

. ' ~- with Slight.Syel1ing-arqund-his_le£t eye. _After reviewing the

_ _' _  ;photoq:aphs what appears to be blood tha;-qongéaled to his 7

P" * . eyelasnes_was found. -No.observation qas"madeTa$ ta hw this

a; -_ .conditiop'came_about,_agd no qomment$'whare heard rom'aQy

**~**~T~+rmgpe:s0nai"regardingwaqgréssive<treatment+%@wara&%ha+¢ ' detainee.P .. . '-= '- i - ' ' -_- '

|.

.-

92

1.

_ ' REsPoNsEs-1_?e._ . i

r

;; , [:::§]' Fifteen 8.5 by 11 color print5*of the detaanee age also I " ' lHC uded in this enclosure..1Photographsfbf[:;§::]are . . '_

I
*-..-_ . ' .._,-..|_..._,1:_T"':¬': 11;;-ii-i" "'-';j-if E-":1;.;=;;.-._;=i§;;-;-1-.-.':5-.--;::::?i.'fj;>-;:":=-=_;_ .._-.3"-1-:_.1_" ;-""-'_"-_7'- - _'._.='7 .11-.,. -=_-..._-.=- ;..,=»....--;_;._.,-3-.¢._,.__- 1--= - ______'; _ } .. |.: -. - .. . ... - . ..  .|_ -.- _ ._. - ._,-_-I..._...-<- ;w:_-L..92_.1_-__ - -.-,_,_..._h.,_--.; __._.,.1 _i.A_..,l-;'- :_|-'.'_-_~_.;--

,|-.-E: *_. '-E.'*"'*'.i=_|,i -§:r:£'¥-'-=|'-'.-,;-'é,g§_'4-'1-P.-;_ ' J--"?i|';'-'-'1'»-E.-=-:=m'.'-;.-.;1-.; -:-;-_-:=I--;<-.r..'-.1 .!:.',.'F==.I-'.-'.'.-; =.--1._.-._ :-¢1él-"';:'.- -I.-9-;.~;--- . -._-, - , - .. -'.-.--...--: '- r - .--=1. '=-===1*=-:;-=-:.*.-¢'+»- -_-. .-_~' -at -H-.l:|;j_-LE:-524: -M--~ -- -' .-.-.-=1 - ._-.1- , ;.

.._01¢-1 .,-,1-. ., .- T. ...,,,_- -_ _.=§¬=':yEt=_Y_;=-...I::;'T'92i_;-:11,£1.--1._-5-,3-,;_92|a_-_;_"_;~,--__--;_1-92=.- q_».-1.,-__;_>=:92';>g"_,;;,92,:n__-=u?g._g;;g*'~ "?~ " . . _ p ~

_P~@= .?9Y-HQ=1HI3'27-E'5§=?WU?/12'!20;04'f"""' _  .

. .f -', 7N0 other detaineeé were observed to have sim;lar

'conditiQns, nor did I personally hear bf any commentsfrom

j Army pepsonnelponcérning their treatmentof the detainees,

t;T ".? f hgtéfpénsonaliy révigwed my wdrkfrqbQth-_-

_ assignmehtgtqpdnot Seen_any other questipnable imagé5.?

.*_

» a

' ~ - . r

: I¥Dr. Adams _ .

- - < -1--Mr-. 5 , *

_-"-1"'M'1'.' i_-.hire._1'. ' I

1Mr.. . .

Y

- _ I

_' -'RESPONSI_ES-'17_7

fihe

92-

92

>.
F__

.r , ¢

Positive

Response

ANumber 12s

' *92
__

'?i_ |_"' I 7 4'-_7 _ 7

F-.

nu

l. _ -

[Rev.0F§|-2on31'-- I ' .. " .. - l - _ _'.' _:-|:|194j=bo1.5c§_&

V _% .BU:RE.Ii1.I__§!_l5' l§iYE§fI-GATIOV -_ -_ 

_P'i-écea.eeee.=- RC:-UT11§1E_V __ Date: _;-07x12/20-01

T03; Inspeceion"¢.7'__ @6 ;i'j -Attnél O¬f%de'0f Infeectio

- - - _ _ b7C -1 .

- '- ' Rc0m7B37- _ sw _

.___ _ .. _ rm ,_H ___ __ __ _ Ji 4 ail; .

From:e Denver._,._z =. .-.-. . - .- - ._-- - e ;-

_ " ' Squad 14{JTTF - '=' '' " ' -¬$fw;$7_ f -_. 

- - - - Contact: _ _ _ j Lg

1:61? ""

b'?C -1 -

I ,_ I

;1bs -1

- _b7c ~1

=56 -1 '-

.'Ii.cle I .-ceUNT'ea:Emon1sM 'mv:s:0m;'_ Gfmd , 5

P~P1=='="=~-BY" l e V -

__- _,_ _ _I r, _ m2 _:- ,T'_i ._f~ihF__ii_;_92_fT_

7- u . h . -- .. .- . . - PP-'_1f1~?.=_.§ .?;:- Drain,-=<1 BY-i" - . §1~§§§IHE=i=*e?t .é§;;-22;_1;1

. " " * : . e . ? -. V e 2 .§F-3*-=*-.*{§'.§_F_.§-E-i'=Q_.';.. -

Case 'I:>_'#="_ 29?-HQ-A1321-s;_s9'~A-;.' / Pending-}." _. .-I2§§§Je»;I;1s¢.@H;§iii2§.;_@1

"|EEi1i".92>.:*"1-:EV ~

I I.N"SPE'CTION- SPECIAL.-INQUl'R1¬_ -" _ ;_ HERFIP!a;£§,1LTY2I*?I-§§,aIE.I1EI?

' ' 1 -" - - - 5#1¥EB-E.-.§.PlPeh11¢§!2ir;e.&1§.1--

:0: in£6r.ma'c_i<;m. iri_ _e'-_'ma'i1e de't|ec1_ -' ' . _éynopsis{ Reeponse e requeet_ _ I

-07/O912004=regardingpreeement of detainee5.gt'GTMQ_ -1; fT'] w " ¢"=

W

Details-. From ma --12, _ 2962- to June-Z-6-,_'_ @003, S-peciel Agent . .

-ISA} | EEIDen-ve_r, 1 served a.__TDY a_t: GTMO.- ' On c-nel occasion during the final two weeks ' unknown'bt-er- oi this TDY, SA[:::::1--~ Y

ebeerved=two other unknewe individuals.from an

government agency.t0nducting an interview with a detainee. 1'

' "th'FB' utilizing-techniques that were get consistent-wl V i,1_' i_nt e'1'92ri'e_w p¢>1_i_ cy/guidelines- -1 le, ' ' l - resent and wmhédhi. bi éht=;'""fT _ was a 5°. P . . . _ . _ _

Y '._Ihe'inte;viewin§ techniques that yere qbsered b§ BA.

@3'1_-otgex geve£nment'ageney-eitting involved the two unkngwn-interviewers from an unknown j, a detainee down on the floor _

-in the Cenen of an inperview'reom, while rap'type muslc waej

being played at.a very.high volume using-e portable Radiofcn _

player, and while the interviewers smdked cigers and blew the '

soke'from these cigare_towards'the-face of the detainee,-and_', . _

continueusly laughed at the deeeinee._ ' <.terview ~ ' - .

geec-hn=_a__q.u;es-ewereee-en;by e

' -" I -"-- ' * ' '" "d" " - b?C -1-__.._

glass ln an.adjacent room ea e Lneerv e om an were o'::>ser_<re@.fer' a .ew m:-7.nu'ce..s-.P'ri|e:: i_:o S2-L .51-nd'~_SA '_ _. '

--. . e RESPONSES-1?-'8."

' '92 '. . -. - " -
i| --q  1-___ _f- j W? 7

F _ I ":E§¥§E:EQ T$j_1t

15; Ineoection eFromE§'Denvet _ H Re:.'297-HQAl32756$-A} 0?/12/;0u4_, ~ -

Q n

b6 -l ~

b7C -1

I, . .

-a_-.._..1 "'1 L77

vacating

detainee

physiqal

detainee

-incident

male, eproximate

he other

unknown other gov

approximately~5'l

hair.{_T

hair{eg1

the ape

jbeing c

tdontact

in-this

.One o_

-from en

a8Ses.e

aFdue_to

ompleted.

jbetween

inCidet

their intervie eeesion.with enothei

I 1i:¢:>-t I

_ SA|:]d_:'.g1 -i'1ot.'obserire.any giirect .

the interviewers and the _ .~-__

. V __

the unknown.individuels-involved in this=|

unknown other government agency was a white '

ly 5'8"_to-5'10 inheight medium_build;.red 92

indiyidual involved'in~thi5,incident.from aq- .

efnment agency was a white-male,* _ "1 o ;_

1 to.6fl"'in height, large build. brown f_'

' 92

_b7C -I

- 92-.

.;b1 I?-

 b6 "1 .r

b7C -1

interviewe it GTMO during-this time.£zame} it_is believed with <

-reasonable certeint'-tnet the'two'indi¢iduals invoin this' ¬S!__

;*" Baeed on 3A1 Fs_acquéiht3jces' "<1 familia-;;y ~15? "  ._t;'_ , ;i f. .i] if i an __jf, _

'- with;cheL_ Z ®Névy ;_. -bl» Criminal'1n¬eL;1genceeAgehcy.TNET3]j1ntervLewe:s; and-. _ ' .. _' T

ind iélent _ we 1-e -notlfE:l---N¬;I~Si-;-----~~or-------

beiieved that_these wo in:e:viewe:é_mayYheye been from either -~

the Defense:Humint*Se;vioes, the Defense IntelligencéTAgency,."

Br contraoted in'so@E fashion through-the US Army.1Q= ;,H L~f

.j.___ =--'§A ;- I ' -"*1[::;;]did not 're¢iously:feport _ *. - I. .7: inci&ent'e_ _ .

it in not known y SA[:::;:Twhat interqiewing I = -_ . - _ guidelineefpolity_£hat ot er goyefpmept agencies may or may'_-

not be_requ;red to adhere to. '

92

_ L 
' T61; IhsectionFrom: 'Denver' _I _ 'f.'£'

=88: 291-HQ-A1327a59A; 0712/2004 ~: '

_ LEAD sI: " _ ,_

'.-se£'Lead,1} ,;£¢!'_. ,

- ..:Né?sc;;oN}' ;; _

' _AT w3§g;N@Tbni.nc* ._§ .;._" . j 3 ;=.

"_ '. QFor'info$méti¢ td Cquncértefrorism Di§isio,jGTM0J_f

Inspection Special Inquiry. _ --¢. _-_-_ "'_' -

.- - -i-7 _-' ='_ _l»_ -- '_~ - _._1' 77 7 _ -1 L QWM _. __...__"'_.-_'__._

. - w ++ -._ -- V . _ .. _ . V-_ -, ,

4

'_" 7 '* "* ' ** '7*" ~ ' ' '74 _ -- ;____.  -..._ W __ W ___ __|.._.__ 7 ';_____-..._

1 ' ' -92 '

_ _ -. 92 .

""'"""'r"" - - - _REsP0NsEs-1801.

' . - _ .

_ r~ _ 77 _ if
1 i é

-

Positive 1

Response »s

Number 13%
I

 _ - ' 7 _~1- --7 7- T .._.e We --'- -e '  . 7-7 ~-~ e» e. . . e~ "_'__ ii; 7 r an C. _

W '1 Te e {1PJ itsii" I I i 5:31 J *5

If rjf __ ___ - e 7

.-,. l . ~ .. h :1 .: ll. ll of-2. 1

E I .

1 I . - ..1'~?<=>>1Fe'>.r.. ;., _ i eel

Subject:_FtE:GTMO Detaineefreatment .' . -q __ 

' I will putyou down as a 'positive resp'onse.and OGC will make a deterrnination reference thetreatment and f

.whether_an in_terview._is required. _Tl1anl< you _for the re'sporise._- - 3 Ii -_ - - _ -_ __. ;_'___-t_.. '-

' I. _ .' - ' ' '. ' . - -F I ._ ' - . ' n ' .' .

.106 -1 ..

_ etc -1- f

Fwmeiili <1P1v<rB1>== . . I I

-Sent: Frida Ju U9 2004 5:19 PM '

Tc: NED! FBI!  ¢.=== l<IPl tFBI! P! FBIl; iP! ire: .

Subject: Detaineefreatrnent ._ _ _- ' , _ - _ in _ ._ .

sE_1"us|Tn!E"auT or FP r 1 .-

BECQBl;L29l;HQ-m_§2?6B9-A .- ' ' "' " - ' -

b7C -1 _

' This is"written_ in response to,yo{rr- inquiry'cor'1cerning' interview tech'niques used on'Guantanamo

detai_r_|ees_which.were not consistent with-Bureau interview policylguidelines. -. . '_ ' _ . _.

I - 1 was TD-Yin Guantanait1oiro'rh'Februar§r to to Marcher,-'2'oq3. While there, I heard th-roilgh the-_usual

rumor mill-{other agents; jrnilitary counterpartsiabout la technique useclb'y military iriiterrogators which was

notallowed to he Used by Agents. The technique was to leave a detainee shacttledliri an interrogation

1

-  a~-__.__ __-___'_..__-___._1__._,.

- z

roorn for an extended period oftime, twelve hoursi or more, and either turn the "air conditioner to its lowest '

possible temperature or off. Supposedly, the detainees were. not removed from the roorns even to relieve

themselves.- This was only used for the "ditfcult detainees who would not cooperate. _ _ - ' ' : . _

_'~;One day, whiiejn one ofthe interrogation buildings. I was in one of the observa_ti_o_n cooms which looked

intotwo-interrogation rooms. I was in this room because the-detainee I was Interyi éwing was inone of 1'

the interrogation-roorn obsewed from -this room. Laying on the oor of -the other intenogation room was a

detainee. I believe_thi_s detainee was subiect tothe above-mentionedextended stayin the terrogation _

ru0m_ ' -_ '. .' . "_ . _

' Thedetainee did not appear 'distresse'd. The detainee may possibly -have been asleep- t_-le was"

dressed in the normat detainee jum_psuit.-His leg hackles were attached to the I-bolt lh the center of the.

interrogation roomflodr as per SOP. I do not recall if the detainee was or __was not wearing handcuffs. I do

not recall observing any furniture in the roorn on whiclfthe detainee couldsit. The detainee did Qappear

tohave soiled himself and i did not"0bserve any uid onthe floor around-the detainee. = -I

.__-_~_._i._._ ._..._,__.;,__,.-

. _ : I J - - _ I . .

-I do not [chow how long the detairieewas in theroorrl prior to rny viewing him or howlong he remained

there after I sawhirn. Ido not know what the tmperature of the in'terroga_tlon room was or if the air _

eenditiening»was4;m-or-oil.-I-doindtJ<now+vmo.was.|:espoosibleioethis.detaineelsjniarmgatioo._.Ldo_no1 _

knowwho the detainee was nor would I rebognize'him-as ldonot recall seeing his face. ' " J -

I do nohremerrlber if anyone was wlthme-when I observed this or fthere was someone. who that '

iridividl.la_l_ was. _l' do not remember who lwas iriterviewing the day this occurred. I do not remember at -

what point during rny TDY this occurred or what day it was. This likely occurred in the morning as this was

vifhen most ermy interrogations tbok place. " ' _. f , . I - .

. . . I

. - - _ " b6 -1 " e

Iltny full hureau name I -bqc _l '

- Position: Special Agent '. 2 I - I -- ._

- ~ .. r ' ; f___RESP,Ol~.|SES1_81 _

, .- 1:12./zoom " _- -' -- '_

- at

.-
1' ' :Message' _ -- -' '_ '3 . I 2 ' . I Pa'gé20f2 1&

'. * _' -' _0'fc.#: I - b2 1 -5.. n I - I ' I

I Will be O_r1 AL fr0[I1 July 1310 13.'2004.'

'. 'SEN5ITlV_,E_-BUT L.lNCLAS_5_lF]ED

r

'.

_ I _____ __..__ _ T_._._ 92 _._ ______ ____- ___ _____ __7 ._.______ -.._7 .__.._...._?._-.,..__

1

>

...;

.- -----.___ 1  _ 777..-.92.+.-._____-_.*_____ _ _-_._» ____.._ __...._ 7 _ _ _ _._... __ ._ 7 -7 71_7;...-;_._++ __ 7 77_.-_--- --__ 7 _._! '7 .'._

- -- V ; ? RESPONSES-182 -

_'z_/12z2o041_- . ..
Positive

Response

Number 14
--.1, ,._,,.

. -Meséagn.

.  1 ___ 7 0 ?|; i:~i$0! Fa1!;-.

be -1 _ 0- 0 .. 0 0 ee e _

?7° 7 0 l°WFB'1i

' " 'Subj_eci: R-E: GTMO '_ _. _ '

' OK, I wiil eonsider that en posiihie respqnse; Once the fesponées ere re0eived.'delerminati0'ns willbe made as to .

" "-whuwillbe-irite_n:iewed. Thanks. - - _: _ "

. 1 - _ 92 . a

. . --~Ori inEii'Messa e---- .- .' . - 410 0 c':==-><0=> 0 _. We _1.. -_Sent:Frida -Jul 00 2004 +020 PM .-

. _' " " To-: ~50_!' F0r!_ 1 ,-

-- " ' _--'Sub_jer;t:RE:GTl"l0 _ jI_- _j.

' ' .' " " Page-1'b

.' _ , _

;-_-%5a';.Ir- '.

/1

_ _ . _  . - _I ' . '__ - ' ~ - '

. ,. =--.;|f~-':-' ' . . ' _ ' 1 _ . _ ._ . . A --92.::_-,.  _. < I _ I

M séN§i*E1i. ej§.u'r mic ___-__ _ _ _ _  -..____ _-.-_..--..__,_._ _SSlFIED_ '* -'1 .-

.0 '".,___._e__Q"-REWRTD ~ = 0. ,

_ b6 -1

b":C 1

-- . Whileat GTMO, "I 005%.-~L=.=0-.é¢m@ non-FBI po'lig:'y t'reetmeE|t'vJhi0wa ; conducted By nbri-Burreéuxand I .

; ' .. ,. _

_ ' 1 _nun-CITF per_'s0nne'|_ being dsedon one detainee; did-nut obsenje any'ph';"sit:a1 mistreatment of any -,

_ ~_b6 ~l . - detainee. ._ - _ _ -r ' " ' ' '  

-"W --|:l -- - 1' .

. -:50-I-0. 0 5-. 1 "' " -- 0 0 01.; 0 RESPONSES-1830

b2 -1"---

-- ._b6 -1 . -

L C -10 _. 00-00:!;

_ __ __;__I-;:-i.?._..___.-_-¢ ! l_ ; _ i

WP! FBI!: {ENYJ E- YEA!;

01!; cummm S,-ART1-llJRM@ FBI!;

 OM! FBI!? IR

J

'Ser|t: 'Fn'day,.July 09', Z004 1:42 PM

---_~'E'JriginaI Message---'-' . _ _.

From: MCCRAW,'S_TEVEI92l_C. IN$DJ_lfEBI'! -' _ _. - I _ . ~ __- A

-- MM§_ FB1-' i~1M!' z=0L}; HO} -FBI!;_' .

* ' Ta.

' _ - o1_0;_.. c0r-1* M|"_!"F8I; rw |=0r- 0 0 _0_ [NY' |=01- _ j -MM}_ FElI}'j _ 0__ LA! FBI!_;LL&

T . - I-lO!' I_=.BI]; ans; -FBI -'-'BA|'TLE . FRANKIE cm! {FBI - n

[[MM.! FB.I!;- .0! 01 -C_V!_ -F_Bf -_ . .

- - -HO!. FBI!; .sg_ F01-. _ .0 'FBI' 0 om! _

 FBI! J .NY!_ FBI!;

' _1=01! r~10! _E0n'. 0! F01!; _ " rm

 ITD! FBI ¬-HC'!<3P~ CO! . .

 FE-'51!;

FBI - - FBI

 HQ! F51!;

D_L!. FBI!;- Amy - _

-MM->001}; in FBI!;'_ -

001081»; » ~00 _

A' "000 ' 1.sJ_ F01- W - 0 .

cr01 FB1>;_

_ CID FBI!; -ASDRFBIJ; 1 F01!; " 1 -

MM FBI!; -rr0!- =01

PHF

' FBI MM FBI!;

0' 0 0 0 M-f"r!%FB = 0--

1o<- F01!; . "

-MM-EBI];3 - -.

.E".".'l- i

MM?- FBI!: MM! 

__ F01! MM! F01!; " FBI!;

 FBI!: co - - =01!,

{SE} FBI - __e _ IR

1?! FBI

F-_ __ Px! FBI" MO!  '-

"0=0I:= 0 T000; 0 0 ><10A:; _ HO -- 0

{FBI}; IR'!. FEiI!; Ill FBI!; T0! 00:11:]; I090! F011; 0=><,><F0n
-' .1-'_.;-',-.,j._ -¢;-.._. _ -. . .._._<;--_'.-. .1.

" ' " '_'.92_:.=.¢'-._.'r-:§';',._'-T -' -r'.:.:._ ='.I: - "

: =.--. :,=.-;:_'=".-':- ---_- .

.. g'."_~v.-m--_5.. ...- -

-- ,.; _.:-.- -,-

. .',..92- 75..

....L r _.

"b6 -1

- ma: -1_

be-1,-1

- ' b7C -1

"'b2~1'

-'b6-1 -

b7C 1 " .

7/U117 nnn

 w.

§gENS11I_iB_UI__'UhlCLA$1E§Q_."_- - . _. - ..

'- .5 _ _ -- _ _

- Whiie atG'|'M0- 'f'._obsenEei:'| game510" -F5|IJGHCY léatmént 92-vhicuzhh v-Bus condubfed by'r1.on'1 "

énc!nun-CITFpas-rsonnelbg.-ing-useqi ononedetainee. -Ididnotdbseweanyphysicalrr1istri'eati"ne_nt .

fan dtinee ' '- " '-'- - ' 0" fea .-I -_| . I _ .- _-

FBlOmaha . -- __ -

DesMoinesF1.A..I __ _RESPClNSE_5-18*-1_': '_:

_-¢---<_:>n'_ 51Mess'agg~'-i-L  1- _ ' I - I

Fran-um" W.5T_._9vEN-C. -Ir450; FBI!@ -- -

- Se:-it:Frid, Iv.09 2004_-: 1 42 PM_ ,- -. -'- '

~_""T0: MM! |=sI!,- MM FBI!{ H_lg:-1'0' _'

FBI!, N 010" cow!; '_[MM_! |_=B1	 .-

~ FBI MM _sI NYHFBI!; N¥'1{. !£F !

_ . 'lIL2]"[FBI!, -HO" Fan? 015! FBI!,same -_ -

NK1E CTD!{FBI-_ MM! F-BI!, cu-!u=s1, . -

.CV_[FBII; H<:-!¢1=s.~.:'-FBI!:-1 . ,-

_ KLEPHFBIL N FBI! BI - - if _92 -DLFBI!;_ i Am._¢EaI!; _ =- ' = -'

~ - - IR: Fem- NY!"<FBI}'FD}-G

-.- FBI! onoaa 92 cc-	n- it-_.,_-. .

-92. FBI! MM[_§F_I - MM!-{Faff

HO :=_s1!-- IRT[|=B " -92' "=" _-

.- _|[Ac;>_}-_gocA! _ j LS!_{£§I %3-FBI§_-_

- - 11:10: 11WLASQUF L MMUFBI1 mo!%I} 1sF><FBn- h

- I: FEDH i I-[SD n FBImV- _1'- .MM : .

" ' J'i_LwF§ FB1}' - ' [!NY}' 'OGA!--{KX}' "

___-[FBIH___"F 'PHL{FBIkLQLgMMINGS;.ART . ,

_- _[ - ; |_@q1~@_;FB1I |_ OM FBIIIRIJJ

- " FE-11*1 N MM!<FE-I! .- _wM><FBI1 7 - ~.

_ mM"!_qFs1!,-J. j _-MM - j Mr~T!=aI]; -" -- _

_ - E-SFLIFBI-"_ . |I@mFB1~- 0!: -

|=a1L|_ _ . FBI] _ {SE}" FE!-I!;

" IP~!EFBI!' '  PX!-[FBI M0 FBI!

NKMFB1! !' HQ --FBI, kR1_£FBI>:l- F " VH1 i . __ -"A-I-tr? - " ' |<bs! |=si * - .. - _ -_ _FBI]-"  

. - -

V ,1 ~_Y	 :=Bi-' "

_. ' aiF 1 --,

- .. l3E!_'_[FBI NF}_ F=BI -,- [x:1"m- Fan] _ [NY-saqg AL!_{EB1, go!wn$_-,-

_.-

--I

:=aI!-1* I ' : _lgggiglg-l! LA FBI!; f 55:4FBI, ITD FBI};T -

_ in 1!; _ :2 -1- .MM -F "--

- <'*1W1<FBYlz @E1- F511; ~

.-LFBS-'

- ' 

uI UK?iF£3mE.

H .

.* ' m1|f§§!{

FBI]- ;- 1§1§"

F1

WisFBI}! j ._Ps!- os¬g§g- .. NYB1- DL cow» -- . " I CON, _ 1. _ - FBI?" '

- 7 ' _ H;cs!§Fs1J|; L -! 1 !; - J59 '
' -in Message '- ' I

{CD-}fFBI!, _ rm *»=s:!"|', |'|1'J':J5' '

' ' L[ 'CIDQ|'F|'

' '- -- -7'Pa§&3o'f6

U. W f __  _

J11;

P:-TDI HOWE

!

DN FBI

- - EYE - "==-0&1?! I??? PB _--_ - &#

_ j . FBI wo! r=s1;¢ {o1! Fs1!.?_- '

- . _. sa _ _ _ {MM}. FE!I]§f'HA_RP.INGTON,TJ. CTDJ EBI!';?'

' -I B; SLHFBI! ME - ' -

E'_»I!;"N FBIJ_;MM! FBI!. ' _ rq - ' M FBI!, HN! FBI-1 WFJEFBIL  ;92 - - rm 1'-FBI; - . . _ 11"}; _* _EF!L[FBI-_ .-

'- AN![FBI; .110- FBI!; may , '

- oea IR FBI! m- N _ _ 1- _

92 - - |=B1- grim-Fsnj _92.{cro!n=m!,j - -FBI! Q50 Fs_I!L_ .,

-. . Q_,_1- 2

K-><![FBI! Mr~1;_gFq: _{~|-1 Fg_I3_!j___.. ,4,- CJIS J co!n=s1;1 

" - -*". ' '_ HA, -Fshj _ Crm_;Fs1 W; "

- AL" FBI; HO! FBI; 061 F_BI!f 92 _ _

. .s l_D!{'BI! AL'jFB1&f 92{1'rn[{7 - -. -_ - 51 FBI, 7 K! . Iz~1sDJ.{?BI;-, ._ ._ NE F51!? -V - -. . _ . I Iliif -- j mM;_q:.=s: _u-10! _.

E611" -FBI" -m i  W~11JFI- ?c T; in I _ _ R! cm BI SecD 7 ll. I ' I!? rm" . __ _

-_ _ .. - *~92_- I. Nlqggar -1 L 455:1! SE , X-

- - h ~- 3 FBI!, .- ~ -s1!;=_W? .M__ I . " -. _' 92-92 L FBI!; MM} r=5IFBI!?| 

H! I

2 ,- ' _.

 FBI! |£CG!_4fBI!f

._ -_ u W_ - l.D!_ FBI eager!! - <rRw=B1!:, - ____ - ?= H . L¢s~==cm§?I>;[ - . M;

cmgrar!, ca! = B PH}[E§§]*,. . '92.

:11}! , 92 1 " ' f L@ML FBI __ _ 1 '-

- _ L-1}- FBI c1n'!u=s1== _ Ml-?}[C!GA}; - 9

' ' LVHFBI E!_§FBI- [ FBI!,

. . LA B'I§BI . NY n.4|h..= '

B9? 92 _- 

. NY -FBI] '

B 7 " ' ' 0 ax 1 MM FBI

:~w»=a1 wr 06:»!

FBIJI | rm Fszfl 

cm! FBI! _ § rm om!, c J. . - . _' ?JMP§QGA>,Pa1» ,7 ' - _. - . l"l' *5 . _.92 F!_ FBr}}? ' ~ . _ _ _|_rI!_;Fs1 ' -_ |_ CTD_1_[FBI FE

 - _ .]B|jTfsI_Z[___ _ . _!gFa_I!_:[ . - BI, -

.- - ,__. 3 7* - . L910; FBI!; {_NY!_ FBf!, - r=. -»~ .

92 X :~>;HFBr;;" ' rrrzawar" . . .. 2 ;

- ;_ _ "- .|=s1-*1 i j _[@4M. FBI' . - wJ r=sr!*:| Q j j "- _ ' "" T '1 .....;. Lli-FBI-Ti E-39- -E51- f -MM PEIE;-_

' - - " N5!{FBI' - MM , ,- MM! .

"war, {PX! '3GP<" llM!' =. i _

{say FBI}- mu FBI Li cm! wsn? "92 - j _? +511 {FE-I!_[lE'1~. .-% %-1"

_ i i ' M ' ' L.1 1- an " - _ 9

GA! ' i LLIWYOGA n=5!_ r=BI _~.

5y_GA!'| |_,M|g92 FBI!? I ' . ' '- r MM Psi!, '[§BA'1_ |~BI " 7 7* 'sF' ;-_ _ _ FB1!f PX! ;_ " _ ,1; .

 .- .REsPbN'-1a5-".'f1 92"" 

7nnd ' " [0 " ' l 92''9
'

{ .

b6 -1 __ :_- -

b7C -1 . '-

. " 71:3 0:20:34-

" Y92@zEs1<»1s@>-<»~ ? .

M %; j j  . L % j j * FB1>'&&#

{FBI}?

.:_,-__MeSSage__ _. _ __ ., Page4¢

l {==B:§; I I '1v~r>rq.c'>sA; l u Isis.! ='sn,&#

NK F51! |~1M!':FE>1_!, {Oat} ; . -

CG! FBI -SU] FBI] oey ' -

FBI = w_v!{Fs1a. MP -'51!, LR FBI 2; - _ ' ___ - j sgtf FBI! ___ ;!|r cTD FBI ; U E bx

. r -- {asmsrj | rw! r=s1!; {NY . I;-

I |_ EP} 92-iggj M BI _

_ rr0!<F5r!*| _ i _ ESL om! NRFBI; " -" W u* B §t! OGF92. M| MM§' FBI' , '7 C<'3! F

§ '92

_ _ - - FBI i scycorq; __ _

 EH FBI!: - ! = -, * - ' .

_. 92g~¢YeA;fL_ _ , - 1=- 1 , j #50! :1; , j _~ M , ms "FBI' H0 1- rm FBI; . akCELLFBY " W9 FEW

 HO! FB1! cm! {FBI}, Ysugaz

] n.= my FslLgmwy FBI! m}' _

r  c» FD FBI FBI >< F!; " war ! _' SL

:- !_ FBI!_; _ - . - LAHFBI _ NY In. "' . - - : ' E. sew Fan cm! F511? W - '- H0-!__gPsI* LD!__ FBI* - _ 5MM FBI _'-' _ - . ~ c.'r_ FBI -- FBI - - - 92'92 |§'A&#

_t'_[ NY! . j l I ' _: - ____ cT~ay_Fa1 1 I , M M FBI? ~. " 1 r _

, _92 SD!- FBI! _ - {LD - FBI ; wF.;_ cow!-;~ -

h - if - I ~11 7 *7 |_iBs~;'gFE1' _ -

" _= wE!;.:=ax}; ___ =,_r-1!u=s1!j rw!_¢0s.=. __ I; .

- 

. ._[Fsn_;T - j MM}_[fBI1] _ ;l.s!_ FB1= W |_ H01_ Fag;]:| W qwqggsnj ._~92 _ 7 cm! :_

.. |_g:<;g1=B1- W _ IR}_@=aI *' * -. _

,92_&{-{{5}}; . . _ c>E}§|.=sI~ w1=!. FB_I-yf _ _' -

" - oar . - 'FBI! . ' =

-" ? EP!1*"!£FB1!i _ 'u:@L£FB1, 7 . 3 Ase! 1%: BBHFBI! c1.A>@ :1 I -. - -

- ._; f1_3y_ --§|="sI!,=i,~ FBI; _ "~ FBI 

_ - HOMFBI W smssr. mam ' ' FBI I W NO![FBI	 1- 1 - " "

. J? _ L - L i - ll "--.

. ' h ' - CE!'FBI"' . CTD! FBI! ?* EP  *'  ~

W -1=-s}n=s1!; . QTD!{FBI' -_

I " _ o1~'Q_{1=B1', _[s1:!JFB1!';T _ * . _ ~

HO! FBI	 [ ccg_[Fs1 =* _

_ 1 NY! __ | w! z=s1j:'E W" |_fMEJ_ FBI_.*~

_ s0;_gr=a1 "-i ._ W___ P<5Fsr.§|_LL _* as! - ,

._ _u_=sn-.|% j V |__T§W.PBI] j j %mE>~%<Fa:rl _ _ ~

' aw - FBI - Fs1!,'| if [[MO!JFBI " .. 1 . -

 _ _92 ll kl[HO--FBI], ' 'PX" FBI!;| 7* "lu_H0!__ L "<FBI1 u|L"HMfBi1

 I W- :1w!u=s: W |-m1 r=s1; W f HRTUFB , -- "

' F513? !f:-1&1";  HRn FB¥1i '- MHEQIF - Fa ,; , H'R'

W '

V ..  _ V _ _L A j _ . RESPONS'ES'186_. ' 92>92

- - . .,-9_ -x VL %

H __ _ BFMFE-I Di U. -J} _. ' <3 ~. c<¬;:G! _ ! ' kg-mi* ' '

 _. Far" - _n ._ ?;*FB1 _ M.! FBI _ - glisna j | +<c1 oeA!;  1%!! FBI!; _ ._ MM . "

----'----~_¢-F-><l!'-;£FBI g LEW-J;tI§BIJ5|* i j .0.CJLEBI!.l1,;?_.
_ b6 -1 .

b7C -1.

' .' . _ ' - ' - I " Inspection Diirision l '_ I 3' "

- -r,=s0r:004- '

. ="'-*--"Ness' -. ' I r ' ' - ' "_ ' . -' .11} _¢=_' ,- .. .t.,,=¥g6 H .

__ 'cre "Fe-I! nij_:.=sr'j l . s l - .

s, LA Ear ~ CTD Fer; . Cro ilk L i 1. F~'BI"" s 'CiDL FBI-' FL F=BI' i -

- BI l92_'

lTD' - __ Q7 I} BI _1 iD EF j T I . BI}

{LR} FBI! - FBI] - FBI ;_

|92rY!'_ -FBI 7 l _ _ .7 DIN]: 5 ' ' . .

!. FBI' _ L Jim FE!

mm! [FSI!' P FBI! _ cro FBI

"rFer'!'- to!_{FeI -AN} FBI!; L.» 1- .. V

s Lien-i __ |£CI'E>}£FB-I!: _ ..__ intre-

- s omen Y i TP FBI _

 Iii 7 -11 Li ALI _7Ei"*Bi1-BT"' _ _ I_ CTD 1=er!;," M Pi-i " Fen " MM [FBI!" . 3 ~__

 FBI]' _ NY!i'FBIl;, _ s 'IR]_[FBI- is - MML{FBI1rj_ ~ __ I Tilggon ' s ENYUOGA!; - .

{HO}{FBI * iJI;! FBI! _

c! r=eI! '1-iii - Pet!»

I LI s_ W9

t.BA.!tEBI!;| is _ t'_""*Ti~lf5I- Sut1jecI::GTt"1O'_z _ Impo_rj_ta'nc_e: High ' . ' -I _. '

§_EHSiTi.VE BUT UN'CIJ92S$lElEQ_; _. - _ " :-

 '- .- ..

You have beenidentied as ha92iing- oond|.icted_a_n assignment at GTMO, Cuba sin_ee'9!11t01.

The inspection Division has been tasked with contacting those employees-who ave sewed

in 'an'y.cap'acity at GTMO end'_obtaih information regarding the treatment of detainees. - ';

Emntvveeé Shwid .r@sPwd 10-the fviiowing. 1- - -1- ' ._  _ -- " . - . .

1! En-ieioyiees mind oiziseweud-¬=iQgressive -treatn'ieni,'_-interrogations or initer92riew'technic.;u-.

GTMO detainees which was not_c1onsistent_with Bureauintenriew_poiioyifgtiitteiines. shouid _

respond via email f.o_r thepurposeofa foiiow-up interview; Positive email responses should.

t:"edirectedtq:__ _' ~ - ." . -. _ _ , ~

_ ' '- ' _- Inspection i92»'|5t92'Jli' . _. _ _ _

2} Employees who served 'at GTMO and observed no aggressive treatment-ofdetaineest '

should respond via en EC documenting a negative response. The EC should include the

employee's official Bureao.nam_e._ titie, and tenure of assignment at GTMO. - i -. -;

The Ecsheuie-'eé nits: "El0untt-Efierrorietfn Division; G-i'ME_§,_in_spectioSoeciai"Inqui_r¢y"i . '

file # 29?-HQ-A132?6j69-A1 THE EC_should not be-uptoeded, but only. serialized. with a herd

COQYJQPQVBTQQG to: _, . ._ _ ' ' _- I -  _ _J '

.' Ofceof-Ins actions bk; _l

, ' -'.Roon1 B3? ' ' - -we '1

sensirive §UTUJ§iC_LA5Sl_E!_§I_2- . - _ _ .

' ' V i ' RESPONSES18?

| __ s i W i __ _ __ _ _
A 1 -

b6 -1

b7C ~1

.

b6J'.

.b?C 

l __ L V l t .9:f5

'ic§"§roni,vaiékiei§.ieecj'iFsn!' f ' ' j

" sefltii Friday, July-30, ZQQ4 2143 PM

, -Te; '_ Caprdni, Vlalerie E_. [OGC} FB|!" " __ _. _

h-Subject: l=_W: GTMO _" ,. .2. '_ .~ ' 1 5 -. 5

'sEnsi'r|vee._uj unct.Ass1|=u5e_.- . -

NO[§'-B§CQBD- -. . - 1 __

Here is one of the updated nsurnrnaries I reduested three ernp_l'oyees.~_ You can include. thiswith the package i

¢ii@Pi5eFi0ff."Two_m'oret0Qo. '- -' - ' -'  - ' -- - .- --

.0_riin H - "ii". " 5. "T .'. ' u

From OMi FBI_!_». I ' ' i

5.'¬ni:':iFi'ii:l¬E'?Jt'i¥ &-_1';se"Ps_~a __ To: msol FBI!

Svubject: _ V _'

.~ .

Now-gecogg - _ '- -

mt: -1- - _ " * - .- :" ' ;_-.-:. -" " .-

~ . - " ' "' ' " '_ - ' " '_intenr'_' _ _'_icii'n ._at_Carh D.eita]a_|t""' - r _ oi owing a detainee |nterv|_ew_exet_:t date_unkn0wn, while leaving the iew bun g p

approximately 6-:_3'O p.m'. or later-,-l tieard-and" obsenged in the hallway loud rh_usic_apd flashes otjight. '-i.-walked '

from the haiiliuay. into he-open d_oo_r of-ai_..mi_:initorin'g_.rc|or'n tdsee what 'wa's'gtJii1'g on-._l From the rnoi1it0ring.r0t!|'r_1, l'

looked inside the adjacent interview rdcn-i,_. .1tt.th'attirnei'saw another detainee sitting. on the fioor.of.the interview

room-with an I5;-_aeii ag draped-around him, idud_.mu'sic_ being played end a s_trot:|e- iighttiashing. "i left the . __

monitonng room imediateiyafter seeing this-activity. 'i did notlseeany other persons-in'si_de th_e_inter92iiew-room

withthe Israeli ag draped etainee, but suspect that this was a practice used by the DOD DHS since the o_n_iy' -

other persons inside the hallway near this particular intehiiew room were.dressed_in green military .'Fatigues,_. '. 

similar to thecnes worn by DOD_Di'-15-_and the__DC_1'!IJ___ltr1_i=. -Urtifo_rr'r_ie_d Reservists. At notime-did'i."dbsen'e any

physical assaults take placelef this d_e_tai|nee"ndr any;otners=wh,iie assigned to GTMCJ. I _ '_ I - ' . _ _. . :_ '

' I 'un_derst'ood prior to d.epio3m1ent to GTMO,-. that such techniques wei_'e_hot_aiiowed. norapprdved b_1-="FBi- '_

polic3;{._ .lNfhiieat'GTi92Ji£li nusuch techniques were nev_er_cpnducted»to_ my knowledge byany of the CITF personnel assigned at'GTMO. ~ _ _. ' . - '3 , J. 3 1. , ' _' , "' ' _ ~'

Approxii1'iatei§i'-one- or two-days later, DHS,tactics were discussed at a weeiyheid CITF staff meeting." Many of

the-C2-ifiF'Trivestigators discussed how~sorr|_e of_ the DHS-tactics,-had ibeen counte roduc1ive'ih building rapport with detainees who were being intery-ie'w_ed by §|.T Frn'em_bers." Acting FB'l'S

'a'no" 

C_ITF person_nei.ihciuding_- FBI agents were totake artin an such intewiews dr_'interrog_a ions which fell outside ' the FBi's policy of-inteririewing detainees. msA eo" advised us tha_tif.we bei_::-ame aw

oi any

similar'instances.-where agressive,DHS tactics ha ee_n 0 served to'r|o.tily_hirn, provide detaiisiland-"he would make sf instances-knot-;n_ to. aopropnate GTMO DOD and_D_OJ| officials. it shouid.t'

that while at

at GTMO

GTMO, ASS ' acted in an--e:-gemplaryniannerand-.represented.-the Flas,-a consumate . _ _ __

profes-sienal. T is summary detaiisthe only incident I_'i'tave'to report regarding observing arnpn-FBI approved" '_ . tactic being used on-a detainee I ._ -- _ " i = - _- - - .- _ -

13.6. _.1._ -. _ - ||-' .t:..i-. .. . .. ...-.-. I- _ _- _ _

ma a ' . -

Des Moines ELA1 ' - . - ' » t

- I J 5

_. _--*»Ori inaimessa ' - _ " heel _~ -|=r-<>m=_E:jj ] IN-$D}' FBI_!_.

"" we _1 . 5ent::Thursda July 29,-.200"4_ 9:59 AM - .- .. T=~=i:Q:_i<<>~>.<rBI>~. i . i .

' 7 .- . -I ' -RESP'ONSES188_.. '

" '2m¢>.nn'4'. . ' '  . F '
92../-" '1 .

'- ._SuE|jéct:RE:'GTMO U _

E smveaur ms _ . t t

0.0010 >100 ieese provide e-_sh0_rt surqmalyidf yvet yoq 0ba_e-wed. fhanke. - -

I '--_-on iha|Messa e----. I - - ' - 06 -1 0E~w=i<==~1.cFB1>e 0

. W; -1 5erit:.l=.rida -Jul 00 2004 4:20 PM - 0 " -0 we INF-11> FBI! ! _' " 7-5L|bjecl::'RE: G'iT~1C_J|

SENSITIV iJj' UNCLAGSIELEQ -' _-I..i.~ou-R-E0950 L  ' 1 

1:»-5 -1 - ' - - 92

. " -. -- Iwnile"at_GTMO I"00sehred some n0n¢FB|'p0|icy treatnenal-_|ich'wes.cdridnqnLBure'a_.

l - ' . and_-noh-QITF-pefsonnel'beipg used on.or_1e detainee. 1didnotopeerve-anjrphysicelmistreatm-

' U ofari detainee " - - - . - _ __ _ .. . - -ens 1 ._ _; __ - -

_.92 ibjc ___ - 5

-- ' -~ . "FBI-Omaha

. "11. _

Des Moinese.-AI P' q _-RESPONSES-189

.  '- ' _ '----'-0:figina'l_r-1'essage¢j-4-4' " ' "|='mm=.Mcc0.:92w,-sTE§.rE;~:»c. IN50!" FBI!"

 ':Fd .1: 00 ZOG41.42PM r|a"u' _ _ - - -:_' H

' TO FBI] MM FBI! VIIHQ

 FBI!; ON!;-_ MFWHFBIJ; {NY'! FBI_! gw!. ;|= - 1'_~1M!. -FBI"!; -- U m! F01!; HO FBI!; :_=B_1;!;0A . _ FRANKIE-[FBI ;' MM . B_; U92.!.¬FBI

0 FBI!: <H0!_0¥B11: 0sn'0=a0'=

- _-I-Dlt B : D WI-FBIJ} N  E511 .

- ~ 1:!; A0 FBI!?" N0 .FBI!:"; -

. _- 'TD!

b6 +1 0 0 , FBI! EWFBIJ 0 0 0MI~0e_:EBIe' W

7c - J " 0+0: = ; !<EB0;B .0 ~10 ~ 0 e - '- " '

i I IR! FBI!; .".NY!- F01!;

L HO] om!; co! FBI!

_b ll .. " ._

0 As0!_gFB1___ ~0!_ F01!_| -

01!] _ - ; _ _ Lt1T0 - FBI!

c:r0 FBI ASD! "F01-!; -

W 1- ' NY! Q55!

El:l!; EBI;fJ.J.BIMlNGS;,ABTI1UR M; cm ~-FBI -__ _

0 Lm011;rFBI - RD! ]?.r~10.FB»I>; M -FBIH | MM!-' FBI »

, [ s1.=F01 0 0 RNY.]_ FBI.'

cIR-1:cFBI>- 0 :P><-3+ <FB'r>- '

nmrnha '

; -E551-El e I --lr

r FBI. " - 92 . _!lL Mi'W!_-{FBQ1 MM}_ FB1- ' MM-F ~'- - ~' -

_ ' . 'c0!.

. . FBI! __F .FBI; SE FBI! 

 l F 3 A1 M0 HCj_{FBI1, .-" NK!_{.BI; _ -

0. 0 1 92 LQRMFBIMI 0 0 0 0|.

. _ TP.!_§_F_BI __ _? |_[DE1_ §BI-- 501!]? 0 0| ; i WF! .FBI!; U"lY!{I_=BI_!, WF! F-B
NF! FBI!

 CTD! FBI N FBI AL![F_BI!'

92 FBI! KX FBI] LA FBI!

. FBI!, MM " ~s. FBI!;

- "WF FBI!; PGUOGA]; INY FBI!;_

92 in L -s1 co N * CI!FB;.- ;.

j i _ ;_ FBI!; NY ocm!; as

 DLEFBI. ' ._ -FBI1;| I !' M i§M.O]_ FBI!['- _ I FB%!1:> FBI! F2112: FIB

u~ |{1W!_ FBI" t 7 f>EL Fr's1; H '

. _ -. FBI!; ' DLLEFBIJ; _. . 1TD FBi' ;"

_ - - - 'CID]_ FBI - CTD!

L % F511; % <H0><.w~:;| cm FBI -% r

, ' PH - FBI!, N03 FBI!; I! FBI!; . .

__ : SE!_i§BI!; MM 7 Vi _ _._. _ - __ FBI!; HARRe __. TJ.

=_;1i_"_ ' __ -." '. ' "7 _ If . .l' -~_ _ 92_ I 1" U - _ W. I .E

- ' V ' < ; _ - H0!.

 <. a; = L - I , 1T;D!:

- 6 "  - .. l ' '  " _

 " * ' " : ~ ' ' "Y

on {FBI}, SL! FBI!,

 FBI NY! FBI!, MM FBI

 MM! ¢LFBI! __ HNJ FBI! w1=! FBI!,

b -1 H0 FBI Aq!_gfB1j;| __ |[CTD!_g|=B1| D - 1%, w:.>,§;=:;@, <H@,§§

BI ,

CJIS]_ FBI! cu! FBI!

AL!_ FBI 1TD!_ FBI i;s1u_|=|ia!| INSD! FBI!, NE FBI

CGUFBIEDLEFBI MM FBI MM FBI HQ.

cm FBI!, SecD FBI! mm $51,»;-~. -

m<!_ §a1 MM 1!; ss -.

_ FB1W FBIH f [_ MM FBI!; _

..._'. E:|_! |=a1!;_| ' 2?-][MM].' FBI!;[ _ [;§0GC].§.FBI;},_- {*|;su1_- Fi!i - NH!_ FBI - _ CGUFBI!; - _

. 1 , -w!;@B;!t W _ j RB-FRFBLEI _|

. ~- , ,_[IRL F5I _ Z mLSI$I!; F} _

_ _ Im =. I _ CG!_ FBI' j -|=|-q_n=a11; : 0 =_ ; EP FBI};

- - LV! FBI ' CID!_ F-BI MF'!_ _C_J §A'!;

- - MP FBI _ _ _ LvUFBI' _ rDE!_ FBI!, f _ _ ___ - . !';__~ _

92 -" {CTl3!!" FBI ' Z |_{l"1M} FBI  ._F!{FBI!;

' . *7c.11s!_c_r=a11| [~:.~r!_@gg.' _ |<c_ . _'

-- "MP}_[OGA' 1'-113;: F,

_ HQRFBI h {NY}{FBI!,

N -131* rm. BI _ _ _. Y} _F_!,___ _£_! F_!, _

? _ k_ _RESPONSES;iE;{J" l h%

- ' cu-n-1nn..4.. _. .. .- - . V , _ . _ .. .

J_ n'n!_ |=a1 ;| NY!_ FBI _[EP!_ FBI AN! FBI! rm! g|=a1!j I

OGA [IR FBI! LA}_ CON _

FBI om! FBI Rcm FBI -

[[m< FBI!, 1-rt: FBI!

.A _;_ FBI .

" LA. _FBI!;|'u NY! FBI!; SU!_ FBI}_; - " .

- _ _ i.n~i~r! FBI; ____ NYHEBI ;-I __ h_ _ __|

_ |:>r»1- FBI; -- FBT-' V _ ;.M_..|=B ; _ _

T7 .r.~1Y FBI!;.N1 QGA-J; U"-- 'u=B1>:I j LL11?!<FB_11:<m> *1 ;

. '_ ~ ' IR! FBI}; _ ?_ m*!_@+__'-19%!,-J_*CTD ' U ;; s1;;< FBI" ; % 9

' .~<aH><FBn; . <rrouF.B1- y ;.

92 = j .  -SA FBI

 ___ ___ 7
. -. . _ r _ '.  . ' . - .

. ' '_ Messé-gé Pagé4of 6 l

I ' VI . - ':_' Mr~;J_ FB1 V .l f¬MLé§iJ;' .

" - F >_< 1:, H Lc1 FBI"| _ .___.-IR FBI;- _![_ L. .[  MM FBI!; 

- - NE! FBI!; . L MM! FBI? - L

. FBI PX! {OHM MM! FBI!

 SA! FBI! rm! FBI - IR! |=s1!;_ - "L

BI!; FD FBI!; i _ WFL[F,BI -L .

, . _ M FB' |' MLLi|}BI.!' _ 7' Lu92L 1!; _ L 92 1 ' L<~Y;"<@@A!:[_ ???? W " ~m0@A- " <L1R!cFBn; L

92 _, L.. Lm FBI! 5:. OGA! *' [mm = F!;

MM FBI!; y BA =13 j - W = _

 FBI; _ Z L PXEBI; ' . _ Z CLTD FBI!; .. . .

 FBI!; NYIHFJKFA!; w - - FBI!; -L

92 L ? MK FBI!: MM! FBI; ;w<sc!cFBn;

L " C61. ;U! _ ; DE.! - . _

- FBI N1_!' FBI! MP FBl; _= .

 ' * - - £56 FBI!; ICTD ' FBI= " '

L" "- . "IMM -1=.BIL- B'5iLEEI! ._ L. _r_»1_92;!_{_|=,B1.¢-' Lrw '.FBI';_

' ' L1 EP 551- a . MM FBI pl ? L <1"w:L-cFBn;923 -U- 1 1-- l" ;L " LL~ -_|§5E cnrsal] L MM! FBI __ L :c@>cFBI_!

i IR! 'FBI!'; L _ __ IR.!'_[FBI .L _ .SC .:CON]_; L .- L_

L .. * - Bi-I - FBI!; . . ITD! FBIJ; 7 L " .- if|~m_{osA!";| I[Px!_s1_ W , A§g!_ |=:ar- .

"_ L- b6 -1 .' ' LR FBI" RHOEEBI! iL I b7C -1' L .' ' - _ ._ ,, ' 1[lTD! FBI!|

j L 1 L1Tr=L<FBI!|L j _ o=sm<F,B11; wmsn %

|§ %|[HG}{FBI! |?|§muEI 1s!_ |=a 1; _' L- cm FBI! j - MW!. FBI!;' . L '1=z!L F_,B_I!;

 '1T1>! F,B1!; MM!.- FBI -- SI-! FBn_:L".. '

'; ' '  -SE! FBI'!; I.-AHFBI! . _'_-_,_ Lmr ~FBI!_;_ .'-_' _

L ' -- - ' Sei:Dj_ FBI!; -cm!; FB1!-EJ L" ' L - * '.n! r=s_1!_;j - . -L MM PsL="":_ I

L . [WW J1 M E L _' -L _ 'Aso!_[|=B1 NYLQG5; - ._ -

L FBI -; . j .. [gigs MM Lr=ar!;[ij "

-SD!-_' FBI W * .LD_EFB_I  -w_ -cow L " _j  _' _ Z _ BFE_FBIm_k _ W L ' .- Lk1~!_ r=BIL:;lk J L2w!sm; L L L 1c1=B:_.

L

CG _ CON; ' HO-FBI!; _ -- an I

, Fa1~!; ' % PG! FB1!:| , kmM>- .:L -_ .

- ' | .| KC]§0GA!; AN FBI!; MML

,L . * "FBIJ ""1L FBI' B5-H551!; : ' "

' WE!. FBI!;] _?__ Est!-;l ,_ _i ' |_ NY}_f0GA if _ - "_

mar L<wE;_ FBIL1,-1? |.sL' FBI ' +10% ~1=B11j_| _ _ ILQTD-! LL 1_~

' I' I=n :R!_ §g_i!,;| _ _ L m'.L __ VF 2 Jr _ I. T B_ J .. x A;-EBU1 LT _

L . sw>;<@@51-| MMHFBI!_ FBI; L { FZl smuF; I ' _ ASDn.FBITI; $s!é :=jj_j U_E.A!.L cow

_ . &#

L ? ? ? Em; = ; * " L L- -. *-" L ? <:E ¢Tv FBI , av FBI -" '

- j L , L 1-L1 er H rrw==uEaLLf- 2 - _:@M><FBI!:| ? L |-csc!:FBI!: ? NY:- FBI!;

? ' -- ' L L L Responses-'191-1 w L" " L" ?

 .-cu-92!"n':92'n.q,, I .' I _L n '- I

I - '1-_ W __ 7 "ii r r if

1m=»uFBI~ _ M >1 BI Lr l'

HO FBI SI FBI -

F 1*-1 UK ! c0¢Tn=Bn.| II
at r ~ 7

V ! Fs1!;! J '[;co!_-{|=s1- V l -- -

. PX!__ FBI _ rw!_ |= __ ; . _ , - " NY!_i F:?j |_ |._v!_ _§B1[-_l_ _ f ME FBI ___.

' so!"_§|.=sI- W F PGL FBIl

1 d __ Wiw/nirszgl , ; -L

_ ., /j |_ J|92|!_ Ee1 ,1 an [gsu Fag FBI M0-. 51- Ho] V_

" _' FBI!; u Mb]_EBI!; _ NHI!_f-FBI'iw" ' . F . -'r~1Y}-_gFaI!j 1-lug-FBI. . " -. 1 " '

1-um"! FBI!_| ji HR FBI!; " I-lR~"l'.

FBI -. - _ HRT!_gl=sI!,-j TLA!_ -F8111 " ~ .

 cT01_ FBI!i, , : _

_ , -I-=~-cosrxl V |§cr0z:|=Bn F CF01 or "

_ . K. ,- -FBI =TFD!_g1=e1 f W WF 1. f .

' F 18* we i

cro BI

-. b6 _1 L . -_ _ .

.__ b"ic -1_ ' _ !_,_ F ! gm! ,_g _ C113 _:

, .. ~ i - "F-.51-!i.U.i..FBI!; GIID-; EQI-!; " H11 FBI! i - B.5>tFBI!;|i|*&

i §MM!U 

-NY!_[FBI , . ' ! = - NH]_ FBI];-_ "

- - . _ _ '-Tl-R3§l.BI!_ ..

.- , Ml921!" FBI}; IP FBI! C1D!. 'FBI!; ~- F l.iIRL FBIl:| LLl w! PBI- A~!<F_B1

.jF-

_ R1,-i!;|  _ _ [_[§i'D!_ FBI' W ,__, MM!_[FBI'~

- d |_ FDL[FB-I |- TF.*!" i=e1~!;| d .

 c."ro!_. l=sI1j W ' ATHFBQ; cro FBI!

l .~ PH FBI!,

.- Fa:-!_ 1RL[fBI

_ MM FBI-}; ' TP!_ CONE| - jmmoony p

'_ HO-J FBI ' LA!- FBI ' . . l .

' KC! { FBI!; __ __ HR FBI!; _____

. _- an.» -FB[]_;_L___,, . Ho!=s1!

, I as-> FBI! V cr~1M1 FB_I! . F F

Sl.Ib]BCtI._ -_ _ _-

1|-qpiir-t§ance:_lfiigh ' _' __ _' ' 92 . .__ ' ' .

* 1 '§5|gs_|];_ we su"ru_n'c:::Ass|F1eo "_ '

'_.'.BON-B'EC'OBi2I j " 2 -_ . .- . __ _ 1 2 2

' You have been identied-as ha'vihg' oondubied ahassignment a GTMO, Cuba isinoe 9i:1!U1.. -

- The Inspection Division ha§ been tasked with oontaotirlg those employees-who 'havese_rved . '-

inany capacity at GTMO and obtain formation regarding the treatment of detainees; I -'

- ' Embioyees-should"imrnediatelg respond to the following: _'. ' - . -_ _

. 1} Employees who obseved aggressive treatment, interrogations or interviewjeohniques on

G.i'MO.detainees yv_hio'h was not consistent with Bureau interview polioyiguidelines, should ' -

respod via-email for. _the purpose of 'a'fol|_o'w-up interview._Positive email responses should -

F u '5?-ii?T?"!5fF¢i't'5T"-_*"'"'.'*'T__'.TY" ""'."i' '-""."'"'.-1". * " " _ ""..'". 

' ' ,- _ _ _ _ _ - '" -mo -1

-. ., . I - lnspect1onD|92{1s|on I _ _. . .

2} Employees who sewed g't'GT:MCl and obeer_ved- no -aggressive-lirestmenof detainees' 

,_ ._ should respond via an EC ocumenting a" negative response. The'EC should inoiuoe the "

- ernployeefs ofoial Elureau name. 1itle._Bd'tehure- of assignment atrGTMO. '. _ ' ' '

s .

_ The EIC: should titled "Coun0el'_terrorism Division, GTMO-, irispepiien Special inquiry", .'

_ . "RESPONSES*192_ x ~ F - V

- ".0Mhnn,-I. I . . _ - - .' ' 1. _' ._ =_ _ . _ _
- - " le#' 2-9.7-HQ.-_A 1 32?-S69-A.. The ECshpuidnot be |Jpi:';1_aded_,_bu-t onlyserialized, with a .I'Iarn&

 "

-wpvfvmardedw. e - -e A ~ 1 ~ . J

' g ' ' -- InspectionDivisIdn_-

_ - Ofce.ofl'ns eccins I _' ' -

 er L b6-1 -

-R0c_:m7837 ' .'- b7c -1 ' -

f seusmve BIUTUNCLASSIFIED_'

_ ISENSITIIVE eujrm_1Q|¢.ss:FIEn '

.. , ._ : . .  Q . _ "- - .'.' _ || -

.I -._ ...?_ I __ _ _ _

5,EJ~|s|f|'|-- ve BUTUN 9.5 SS_1I_-=l;IE];' _' _

_Tj§é1~is1-TNE e'Bl;_1T"Ul§l.CL._'-k'.£"»_§_IFLEIJh u

-- ; !.5ENs|T|vE|3gJurqq_Ag§s|F|E_g~ - " .

-1 -

r

x

_|-

_._... ........._,._-._'._ .. .. - _ _ - .. .._ __ _ .__----1....--.-;....__...-¢-.-.--92-_-r--...-.-..I......-..-....-._... _ I- _ _.__ ,_ _.,___ __ __,_,____;_,

~

3 .

_ ? , 'RE$PO_NSES'j& j

-.er"-1r':r'.1m|..-". ; - _ - . _f' _' .- . - -'

| _
___"_ _ W_ _ W A-

,.. _. __

- »' . .

z . I I I I I 7 _ 1 ' ' I ' - V. - -1 .

§$c}1 | msD!i¢ti=Br!" _ .- .

':__,,i_::_ _ v ' '___ '< - __ ___.. ,_ W _...:-1 c ____ ____._~r~~ _ W _ _ Ii P

I ' . -Fron;1:'._ Caprcni;Ve1!e'rie'E..- Oi;3§I} FB_l!"'.:-i _ _I -._»_' -I

f _"Sent:"--_M0}1day',Au'gu5t_16, 2004-1-o1'PM '

b6i-i1itTh-i=>i|:|i*'1I@P1ifFBi*?tii i '

$ensIII£§;BlQ: u.m;_t,A8$IE§2;' 1

-ON-_RECO . . . - -_ - .

Nofurth'er.ihterview necessary. Loud mtlsicaridstrobelight would hewithin'the ncticn'0f"_e'nvii'cdown"__

thatisana'p'prcved technique forDbD.'.'|The Israeli-ag;.though ocgncxious, doesn't seemto change the basic _:|

techniqueintocriethat_uii0'u1d beunlawfuiiyabpsi~.=e.P V. '_ '- ___ _. ._~_. " ' _ : _' I

'*_?1""" :".:"i' r ii'1E|.:MEhS5' ¬".""1":~"; - -

- '_ .t197$ -1 _1 , -5ent:'Mon tFr=.=mi¢1~sD>rF@1> BY,1"-92.Ug':LlSf_1§, ZQQ4 2:49 PM _ - t

_ ' __.lTb_: Caproni, 92»'alerie'E.. §JGC! FBI!_92- .- j t ~ ___'sahje_ct:"F*N;GTM1.> _ A

~.._'_'gEM'sr"rNE..BLITiJw.¢|.A§_gi|?|eQ.- *

5 This"-éiiBu{d.lbe £r__1é_.|§st one..':Let-me_kh'ct§:'fciIcv.+'f ' --".1-_i -

9- _ ' ,_ 5.-H--'O'ri ihal'MeSsé e--.--5.- u ' ' ' _ .

be_1< .tFwmi:lM>-<w1>t .

-_WC *1 . ' $e_n1::_F|ida ,July30,20041:_-$5_FfM'_': 1

. - - L 'Sul;ect:"RE:GTMO, 

r@=t;__t"1<1~sv><FBnw . _

_ ' --sgi@|s[['1vé-1é:ur'1,@' c;_i-g§5;1E]'5|; '. '. _

.- _, . IHQb;_RE_f;gBQ..__;'____ ;:_t_- 2 _I :

--?°° 1 __ Fuliowin'g.a'detaineeinterview'exact'date&_ac.Carnp Deltaat

- t .- - 'ab[:rr0xirate!y 8230-,'p._r'n. prlétei, I hz_~2et'r_d1and observers! inthehallwayioudr|_ju§ic'_andashes qfiight.i'" _ "

-waikedfrom'the-hallway intOthe'ope1j_d,o1:!r.qfa i'r|onitoring_ roamtoeeewhét'was goingon.--Fromthe -' _ '

.monitdringroom,--I icokedinside theadjacent intengiewroom."Attl-iattimel savg.-an;>the_t_det:§inee;sitting ' _

_' op _ti_'1e ccr pftheinterviey-;' rpcmvv_riti1 an is_raeii¢a_g' qlfapedaroundhir_n', ioudim.|5ic'_ being"p_l_éy'ed anda _'

etrobe_iightf{aéhir'1_g; I leitther'nc'nibcri'r_-iglrobm'irhmedi?ate|y'iaer&ecuity: __'.I djd_n_ot_"s'e"e-ényi .

other bersonsihsitietheintewiewjregmwithth_e@_iS_r_aeli_'ag d_repe_:_i,detqinee; ];92.pt_§u5pe'ct't§t:thwas a ~_ " _

' practiceuS'ed-icy -theDODDHSéince-the" un_iy='otif|er perso_r:s'ir_15id_e'tI'ié haili_vya!P-|jiear,this_parti¢ular:,.- _

- iritérviewroom-weredressedingreenn_'1ii_i_t_ari.1"fatigues,sifniigrtctthe-cajesrwqrn by'E_DO_D-OHS 'and theDOD

_ --M P4Jnifé1i'med#Ré5eqvisb5=:..At;hoTtinie-tiid»i-Qtieeir-tie;nyupIf:Qisical-H$53 _

'-eqyf6tHéisvi?Hilé'-ééé-igrieb]tci " _ . ' _.- '

. . ..|.understi:1c'>c'i; p_rip_r'.-to deployrn_er|_t_t_o GT_MO92.-_.' thatetichjtechniqties vqre"n0t'e1II_o92qq|,=§_d,_riqrexbyFBI_

-pc_|icy;. _W}:|i|e 'at GTMOno_suc'h techniqueswere;-never co'r_|_ducted-to my.kncwi_etigé.by anyiofthe,-GITF'. 92

personnel assigneda_tGTMO.:.' '- j - 1- -' - .___ Y ._- I"? _1;- -." -.

" Abprsximételyfche or twodays-later, ._Di_'jiS tacticswerediecu5s'ed1at.a w'ee|-y} heldICITFBtaffmeeting. --

';ru_'iariy oftheCITFi'r192_»e§tigatdrs"discuasedlhpw-s_omé.of theDHStectics'_ha'gi_ beeh-cbunterprqdctive in-'.

- _ ; b_ui|din ra crtwith-detainees whowere_be'iiI_§1-i['1_t_er92|i'_j92§_~weciby.-CITEmerriberé» "Acting-FBI.. - -

_.b6Q1_"'$S advisec_i_tha_t noCiTF_Qérscn13_e| incI_l.|tf.iirig-EB-1_éige|:|ts=wpfart'ih such. ~

b-JG_]_. - interviewsorinterrogations.-.-which.fellputs|tietj:1e'EB|s-'po|i_cy qf'int_e|'ir1ia92iiin_g"§iet.ainees; -P_tSSA_  - 1--

. ' aiso apI_vised,us thatifwebecame au_iajre5of"any _s|miIar instances where:-ag ressiveDHS

. 1 -

' snaxz-004 -. -- 5 '-

92
-'* Mesesagén :13" _' " ' I - I.  3 I .

- - V 0

' "técc$ nz;d:%§een'c->bs§éw'ed'ta nb7}".him- IPhF0v'id'er1.etaiIs,'an»§ h~§rnakelihene instances méwiwm" '--Q "

77 I

" Pa e2o'f.?

_ . appropriate GTMQDOD ._-1m1.o'oJ 0fciaIs'."It should be noted that while _at'GTMO-, ASS/ *5 1

actec_1__in_an exemplary manner and represented thé"FBJ as a consunn'ate'profes$iona|. _Thsummary MC -1

 I -det_aiis' the only incidentl haveto repert regarding nbserving a non-FBI -'approvec,i tactic beingiused on a' _

-det_ain_eeatG'TMO._-"- - -" .' - - __ I _' _' .1 - __ ' -

_. _ I136 1 _

.- I - -ma _' I - ' -¢--'

- 3'-Des Moinés-R.A.-. - 1 " -

V J - - -"l_-¢C_!|'"i' inal Nessa E:-'-'-" " . . _

~ b5 r F'°m= IN.5°>. @I>ln

b7C -1 _ .- -Se ntThursaJu 9 : . . 2. 2[II_04l-9:59-AM _

_ V >T|-if _ c:; OM! FBI!

..-92 "--Subjeqct:_RE:G_IT92*[O_"_ '"

" * ~ §ENSlT'|§!E92l§lr; '- l-'_= |,: 55 315' |g1;;_ -

"N95-ggcg_3m» ;  "- - _,

|- 1

' - *'-C" uidl 1 I ané n§v'iné..3.5brt|sufnn1aIYofwhatYbu czibsi-:'|'_h;=1nk$. I ~

F.Y°-Fe -P. -. .. . .. .

. '-Ori inaiMeSsa e -. . _ '- n . Fr@m=i:@~><FB1>.n b6 -1 - u us 2o0+4.2u PM-'._ -- _ _;-Sent. Fri a ,.J 92{- ,: ~ n-C -1 tin L <

- H - " -

1-b?c_¢1 -_-be -1 V I '

b6 -1 -1 -- .mistre'atmentofany detainee.-""'.

' rna.a~ ;

. -" - -- D'e5'.MoiheSR.Ai' - ' '

- _- I---'-Ojiginal Mes§age'7--- 1 -

_ '- .16.: mso! FBI} ..

- IFrum:--MccP.Aw;s*|"EvEu:c.{1Nso! F51!. ."  .-

Ser|t'Fnda Ju 09 2004 1:42.PM J . ' - _ -

MM '{|=BI!;| . I MM!-.{FBI!,=| |-

92

~ 1 'jS.E.I-:lSl_l']92.{.E GUI. gggg? 5§|E|gD_3 9

White at GTMO |,obsewedlson1e-nnn-FBI pbligy téafnneniiwhich '.-"asco.n'dnon- f

' B.U.reau_ and r'1on-'ClTF. personnel being used on|q~n|;.detainee- I did-_not gbslerve any physicat '

it - .Hoi!"_@a1;!;] . 'OID!'. C0N|_ MM"L FEiI;-

- _ _[ EN¬..¥FBi!; wr-F51; '

4 ~ - _£EBIJ.: -f-JJ.!~!_ E5I.!" H0!" ":_ . -

- be 1 " - - - 51* BATH. ----1.1. an --{Fan MM" FBI 3 L: 1+0! wan

N 1 FBI - -

Y %L _ CJIS F 11, .._h _ ; . -

; W1 -.1 LA Fan . ;.- - wu=.aI.>; .. . V <- . -_ ' h. . SJ FBIH l_'D"FBI; 0

- I - . - .1:=1.- -. .

_ "". . 1] J92f"."'L FB H . AN! -FBI; f NO. FBI; c:,";. IR FBI .- R TL __ - Q % ml 

-H'QL§O'GA 

- n - kNYm=BI-n 

W i i COM-F_BIj 

- <mn>cwI> n

J _ .- - . CG!_ FBI " n : T |:i<£*'M5TFBlFL I WMEMMMPBIM 

TKH0! - ...____ |=B1}, _ _ _ _; _ mYY{EBI_;_ -

92 . "

SE16./200'4§ ' -

REsPqmsES4195 .

92

9

92

9

- .92

I

¢
MaS'sage ' r

[ -

b6 -1

-mc ~1

 8/"1 6¢2O¬l4' I

J . -

I %_. -" -, * . j.l.-f~P».g=s.<>r1 O» % W

" I 'C'l'D! ;FBI! AI V ~ _ ; ' B - N BI; _.

._ I . . . j +{M|f4}__{FBI&#

IIDJJFBI __ |_ cTm_p=a1lL .[FBI!;| - _ MM!_ FBIF;{ w§!_¢[_|=B1g;|_ - ff

- N!!_GAJi| W _ _|<x EBI!_;_|' _ *__W __. a_|-1! FBI!;

 M mes, ARTHURM.- C170 FBI!;  - MM Fan 'qu%x_om.rFBIf; _ IL F % MM!

_{FBI!;_| MIMFBI!,-j t M!]FBI!;_| - ...|j MM!_;EB_I j_.[MM!_ |=s1 V_ s:_=_! . FBI {NY} Fan} C?_!_ FBI _ '

3 H5 ' . B .

 FBI; m!_ |=s-'- l -I ' 11 I 17 . "- . _ ' 0 F -

 ____ .PXL FB ' 7 W1_:!; EBI' NYFB - '

. i . =_ _ ._EmB _ _M___"

 9<PBn;. j war!: ' NO FBI]; '¢1:>uFB1>

MP FBI-; - 

:o<>;FBr|

' L U WF FBILIEMM |

l'_ F92L!_ FBI ' 7_

l.'|:' FBIEi|_ PGL OG#!_;_"'N_Y!_=B1UU. I. [[DL!_&#

' con " j i s1! ccm; -£1 FBI Iv *1 __ ' - MD FBI ' -- -'[[IIH . lL|_{CG}_[FBI,k[R&

. L L92lYDGAE r ssi_{. -

 j j uni, . t.FL!_'EFB_I};-|§_

I [Mm-_g|=B1y|_'L'=  CWHFBIMW |' M92ijj1UCEUFBLEG

' '.'D' FBI UUDMFBI LIA!,_- |I=;I I .'DtuFBni.1:51;

_ _ CTD}jF'=-BI; _ -|-|0!-_{00w-

_ cro>_ FB1; _ W_ P:-+gFB1-; ' WLmo!-- I

 FBI! %_~c0n. FBI!;-I i<SEa F5131 |

1-mm ' FBI-'HARRINGTON_,TJ. c'r|:>1_L=a1- _ _ . =

 ]'§sL.|=a'I!j -. . |_{ME*!]jFBI!_;|Z W

Fe: _lIil!i=I9H A I @;_¢sa;1,'J ?__ W

 AN FaI! rm!- -|=.B;!;- - r-ro!. _or5A!;

_ IR!'_ FBI _.u!_- cow; ma! y - -FBI '[DN!{FB1' '] cr0 |_=a1- "

i DLHFBI!

~ V - =RESPONSES-196 " -

_ IRL FBI- _ _ - _ 'Px!_._ FB1- i j 1 MojjFEQ;j - __

- 92. - =>.- -- H0 -- -

 N?1'_!.' -E51!" MP¥i!. .EBI-fl |J=_MM=!I qI -FBI U1 . - |£WFl- FBI

"W LE

|q_p=a'n;LLi ' |_TlI1]__ I-=EI' _ ' 1

HO!_' F_B -. _ l_ AQ_!_ .FaI!;_| ?,*__ *_ -

FBI-__ j -Ag1F*Bijj _ |_q[-no Pam-
 "

cc [1=BI§;| - [T+0q_@r-=B1;| jMM FBI!;-_ -.

- -HO-!- -FBI! - _ Q21-1s= EBI~ _

cn!_;.|=a1; - _ 1.'t>q-_QF'gt= _ _ AL}; .

FBI,1-;| 7 - " .1112. FBI *- * . -SI*,-Z-FBI - |'L_ _ INSD!_{FBI.* E |' -__MER1fs1

1'] | c

- FBI MM! FI H _HU.L§FBI&.| 

. , . MM F I.-' -- _, CTDHFBI} . __=._I ;_ 7 U B -IRD--~_

FBI'_ - NK}__{"FBIh-I _ _ .MM}_ r=BI' __

I I ]_ sg!_; Fs1] ;__ W _rro FBI-' H _.M . ;_ .

Q
156 -1

bjc -1 -

*- 8116f20U4. -

.. _. . . .- . _Pé,c4[.!f.7

 _-_,, _ _ . .1 __ _ . .

occ 'FBI' WW _ 5U]_[FBI' NH-!_{FBI1; 1 __ ce};;1=s11,-_| - W  _LDL FBI; ;

-:3 i§' " : - - - LTD FBI;

V _ _ -CTD!; FBI V 1

- CG]_[FBI' WW PH!__[FBI!j_FW W -OMFBI!;7' 1

W .EP!_§EBI _ _LV 1.=ar!;" . :

c10! |=a1! MP .0GA'!" = -

DE}_{FBI MP FBI!

_[DN!_.[FBI LA}_ FBI]_,_| ... !_§4,_|

W _ krw]_- FBI I;_ NY}_[OGA , §LA1~§FBI1;| _ _ 1R!_ |=a1E|_|__ W |.Ajj?EI1,-W . _;

cg;s!_ |=s1 NY! oszx! 

|<c;_ |=Es1!_,-_|__ W = Mlmgsn-;  MM FBI!;

- .'CE F ~ |'!92LQ,-§0GaW

HF-BI

Es: - W _, np}_.;FB- . - :w FBI =

. [ MML{FBI1{ _. -!.,;__ FBI"' W WWW um A _sA * _ W .~92q_{-cam] - N . -1 Rm, I- ' :=a1!,'_| WJ - L'L'| Jn|-!_ Fe-1!;] W - IISLEQGA. W "MM!__ 

FBI _td;MM_!_ Fa1.;,-L __W ' BHQFBI "- ~- -_W 5§!_ FB1 _ mjpx!-_=.5I!;_ _. ' -

_gc1-011551 _ -TPE=B1 - _ -- - m'1 o@A!;

. SL]_-_ FBI!_J|_'{m<'. "

= _g.M*réi!;{FB1. LGc]_-gal-I . I_ rm-1l|a:1j;- ~

% su1tFBI!i L i DE-HFB1-J; %<~Y>W<FB%1n:

= :$m=B1T1 ._. W -' 11= 11:21:11 7* rm FBI!; W_ W NYFBI _ W . : L

_ EP EBI": f|a_s-!n=aI!
 * l MM!| I FBI - . . '

H

érm -:=an;% LL? se OGA! MMRFBI . sn esp.! N} FBI!,

- FBI! 1 W IR IR!_[FBI

BH FBI rm FBI

--  -1 j CG!;

'---CON J1 ' ' -LP !:

NY!_ Q§A' W V _ .- __ "_

~-- -A-s|aq- =|_=a1-!- - 7 WW . El"=Ri{E5I____]_: +|e-@552!; - ' <;m FBI - - Ice. -FBI W _, ;

-rm. FBI. -1'ro1 |=a1!;| - ' .

 ASD! FBI!; HQ  FBI!: ..

-cm 'FBI'.CJI5"'FBI'- CTD -FBI-* '

W . . 'MW]_ FBI; _ IR 'r=a1 	» W II

rm ; ;_ r=sr-' WW W W .

Ili=! L_ s|.- - . 1!; ' . 1 -

! FBI-J; _|_A!_g55n;| .W - _ _N *_|=s1~

_ W  Se¢D!-{FBI} % V ?

 HO! F31! 1-D! F5111 MM! .

' ._ W,-_  RESPONSES,-_197 -- _' ' _

Y CTb!' FBI- i -II*i!'11 FB1|__11i.| §F!- FBIJE j .- I

_ LAL{f_BI W "~~rLg5s1.- W W su_g=s1» - ._; . NY! FBI!; . . 92"_ NY}_ §BI . j | ._

' - - - - . .- -MM FBI"

. 3 j Rf FBI_ .9!,.

FBI B-- ' ' --I£_- -

___ I M 1! {H6!_ FBI,

NY FBI} SA]_[FBl _

1'l'DJ_ FBI [ MM! FBI!  W. - - .W . ' 1 ; ' EMM!, ' FBI!; l IR FBI!| ' ENXUFBIEMM 'FBI] I CIUFBI '1!|9

I 1

92 ; '  - - . .4 .

1_ l ]:L|_' .MM!_{FBI'_ ._ LL|_ MM]_' FBI-{

.OGA' ' MM!W@{!j ' .. AiI FBI!: .- .1 _ rm FBI! _ - W -R .F W LLB! .&#

" = |_qMP;_ -F511] ' LR"- FBI- I
.. - .Més~§;g¢ .V i _ -. _.

 '»7?L" §% HI!;{M5-i!.=a:Al

. i _ Asn, FBI _ - '- ff |' r<:xf FBI

-MM~!_ FB{; ._ .;~1=s1y| *i w5_ c0N,

1W _ 'BF!_[FBI' _q2vvLq.0c-1A!:1 ' LM

rm osa

]_ FBI],| 1

Br=!_g|=a1

cs!_ ::or~n,

__ I : __

.JN}_g=a1 _ I

!_ FBI' j -j - .-

 NY! FBI '

_ - ?_ " >1-I 1 » '1 F'G' FBI-' kH0}_' FBnI-'

_ j FB V A!;|i_-&#

-- [Ll |gAr~1 .1?-BI 15

- ~ __ FBI __ BMM!_'_ FB"- _ l[MM!_[FBI - D 'NY!_GA}

Hi NL? as!{|=a' . _i we!

"DE FBI

L | |_s F511 I ' H _ FBI h __ l __ '

__." -CTD FBI ' ;MM] FBI ' WE!~ FB1_ '  .

-T CG FBI"IR FBI :

_ '.WF.FB!! j M ' |i~»;>§A* A LES Fan] 1

[MM . I I =

~cm!_ F.s1!,-J o!cFBI->; H .

= - II u~1M;>= Fsn" - L ' C0!" FBIJ;? ».

[-Li __ ; 'B5.}.' FB_I!; - .' __: I[_LA!_{CO'A - _ 1TD'L FB1 _' - - = 1 " - MW '-FBI- f | m0-- F211;" " 

- * - L % %LL|'@' FB L:@¢1_!FBI' _ ccE>rFBIg|.

b6 -1 -- _- " P. CTD}- FBI1;]- - l-mFBI'

I b7c -1. - .- _ "" |'?G!- FBI!. i . [f-tjTD1_§FBI- " gar»-n FBr!;

"' , 3 _- Cj{FBI!;|,___ _ lllfllliillil _ __

5 r1m=aI1,

HG FBI [{c0!_@l!_J PX}_[f,B£L k M NYMFBI I30: FE!

_. ow FBI} :.vFs1, . i M§Lg|=a1

- - | SD!__ FBI' - W_ _ PG}_ FBI.- . _

- | r~.|Y}_ |=Bj_ . ~: . -f

HN -FBI

_~. ' W 'Jr=1gFs1 j |_ su FBI!;

- __ MO '-FBI - iHOuFBI_L|_E 11>; ' __ _? _ _; -. -->- " _ Mo.Es;£| -

U I. - 'I I! 'HRI'-!_§F-BI ; : FB

UFBI

._ _"|_lIFFRT	EBr1" 7 . HRMFBIJ ~ , 7 _[1_-AEFB1--

NYUFBIJ, * _ kNYL |'-BL W 7

0 FBI F CTD!_ FBI

F-TD! F5113 CF-D! FBI!

_  |_w{!EFB1!; - "1'|'D.!_ FBI -

-- -_@cm1_{r=a1 i _ =.:92|r§!;gFs1-' j '-rr|::!i<?i=a" _. " ,__ :sA!. FBI! ? I-? rrrr>1 FE-I! * ~ V

I;'

- Lf Fs1 as FBI * MM EBI; L F U" NY!;_ fBI!_;] _u {as}-g0G_A,

ifiiFlHFBI IRE

#519CH1!FBIJ

l
"I . 2' V_-_ .1 1- *'-"_&

_;

. @@A>';<a¢><FaI> ; L toi "

. - - - ._ . KC'E]=BI _ - |-11:1!.

I1!!

b6 1 = ' -. ~ 1 - ~- --=b'7C1_' H _ _ '! H -'

" _ MM! ?iaI!_ - - ., -  - 7 _ _;

Subj_.ect:_'_. .- ~ ' - ' - - '__1 _92

1mp_c_vrtH"11ne:_ High : - ._-' _ ' ' ' ' '

.-

sensrrrve _gJTUNC_2L.Sf..i_[Fl_lE_l,1_-_-

-"NON-RECORQ" _' Q . _ _,- .

.- ' 1 - "- hou.i"|e|'ve'be'e1r| identiiiuqsidnes aoing odri-duotied ejssignnientliét GTMO_,'Ci& ' '

' ' s ' 9111101.The Inspection Divisionhasbeen-tasked with contacilng-tiwose employees  .

- _ who havesewedinanyoapaciiyat_GTMO-and obtaininformation regardingthe -- "

. - _tre'atrr|'er|t_ of d'e_tainees. Employees should immedigtgigresp'ond to the following :

. aQ§re§é.i*el-Ireeirnent. inierr.qe.?a1:I§3nsor.inten _ -

'- ' i'¬ChT]iqU92=§S¬5I1 GTMU U"éia'iiTe'i-ES Wiiii:!'fW§5 n0i't§O'n5iStéi'Wiih-Eliiféi-

. policyfguidelines, should respond v'ia-email forthepu_r_p'ose of a follow-upintervieyv, ' _ .

'_ Fosit_ive'e|_naiiresponsesshould be_dire'.c:ed-to; _ -_ -- -

r. _ _- .' . - - _ b6 ~1 - 

. __ . _. _  ~_ _nspeotion,_ lVI$||DT_92 _. - _ . .

2!-'_Er_1f|plo3?ees whosenieoatGTMOendobserveqnoaggressivelratrrienl of. '- _ _-__

-- .. 'detair1ees,'shouId respondviaéln'ECdo_cumenting-a.negative response, Tr|_e'E_c. - ' ' '

-. T shoijldinolude'|e'emplojreeTs oc_ial'Bureau nameitlel and£_en'ure.'_ofa$sigi1 ' _.-

' -TheECshoilrldbetitled"'C'ounterterrorism Divi5io_n;'GFN|Q_-, rnspe¢:ran;spe¢ia;_.._ _ ,

" -file#!'29_7'-HQ-A13276_69-A- The EC should notbe _up|5ade_d.'butonly-s&#

hardcopyfonvvarded'1o:_._. ' -_ _ _ .. - _i ' ' '. 4 _ 92 '. .r. _- - . _  , I-

' ' - - '1n's_p1ection'Di92iisiqn ' -' T

L '."0i<:eoilr92 econs _b6'_1 i

I _b7c: -1 

r

SENSiTNE_BUTU_NEI:ASSIE1EB ~

.--'_.' -Rm ';-'

__-'  -.s,g1:is'|T'1y:iz_13yi UN ,i7.b;S5l_E|Eg.'h .

_'. ' .~'- . -

"'_""__ P ' - T '" ."'j;'"'f'f-_" 1 if".""T"7":':f'j"- " * * ' "  " ".'_"j*"§','" ' " 1-7_&#

- §_ENSITl}1EBUT_!JNCL_ASSlF - D - IE

_:_gsns1'hyé B_L_i'-j|'L_LJl:l_!.f.?LA$SJ,i=iEl':p' -

.'V ' i .RE5|5cjNsEs-199.-'

_ . _-8/15.12004.-_ ;, ; _

i
.. ___ ___

.__|._r§§_s_s§.ge.' _' ' '_ T - P5gé._&#

 4-

' -§_l§5I;SlTNE_BUTiUCLA§SlFl_ED -

" -SEus|T1vEBu1'uNc1'.Ass||'=|, I ¢

I

1

.1

J

r

92

J

. in1

-92. .

92 , .

" .- ' - L %% RESPONSES-200.. >

sx16x2oo4~- - . --
Positive

Response

Number 15

¢ a
» '~. %'4" 7 - - .. _n|cLIN$B> FBI!n1 P' %

B¢ 4  i:;*|~~ss>w=B»> L? n

W1 _-1 Se-r_1t:' Wednesda ,July14,2D04.3:5QPM .

. - _ - . " - ' - -.:..,

5ubj¢¢+;R1;;eTMc_;y-' " _- - ,

UNCLASSIEIED " . , . -

"°"-RCRD 1 *

' '- '. OK-, Until we decidelwlhalwas i:c$rr_1;':iif=1nt,'li:=::i|jisidert1"|'isn nno n_ee;_! to do an

92 _ _ . -InaiMes;5'a e--n V I h; I in J - .

A In x L- ~-.-===r-=iF "11? ~ - I {me -1-: . ="-S'¢I__1i::>TueSda'-"3'u| -1-3:2 04-*9=s2-AM; " ' * ' ' ' * j~--. - - i ~ _ L _ Ns|3! 1 V Fm ~

be -1 '- -- -. -- - - - . . . 'b7c -1. M"'l;|' ' -' - - _' 92. _. --'

- . |have_ een assigneo-.to G_TMQ-slnca-Oct0t1er20lJ3 on a0nayear.TDY.-_ I -- " -. r -

' _ -. I hzlave ubéewéd interview iechniques not consistent with Bureau intervievi poiicy, but incompliance with

. I Department qf-Qéfense. "DODpolicy. Ih;'ve-npt_taken_ partjn any interyiew uyhere theseenhniques wegrg

allqwed.bL;thaye or'1lyo_bserveq|.._ . -;_ _ '. - ~ '. _ __'

7 _Thé Eletaiiéuof tnéss; i-r'1tér~:ie_92}v§'coi1:*;ist-c:_f, -njcu-rt'sha§c_|'<|in§ td-the ner, Edld tenn§er;h4ré5,'I§uB mln-' '

-st1fqbe_|igl1t§|énd.féf92- in interr0gau_m_-o'dm for Igngpefiods or tinge, __p|92ga_ir_1, this ~_¢_vas=conststé|'nt with U00. , 92

- pq|ic_yn0t_F-Blpoiicy - -" _ -' __- v -_ 1-_ _ _'.- f-

_ _ '._Fo'r infnrmatidn 5% |h§pe<=mm 0j_visicn,": .-.-mi be_of['GTMO rrém Ifxsimn sno*"._ bmtq cén Contact me if ' .. I ,- . .- necessarqyi - " -_¥ - - '- _ -  _ "_ . " , -_.- _

-i bvc -1? - . _ . .= ',

|§n:L.g§s|F1g'Q" _. , '-

[ . I . - . _ 1

-92.-_ -... __. _ _....._.:._..---_ __A 7:_..._ _' ..'...:;_. ...__ _..____,_ ,.._._._'__._'._,___4_,._,_._....._.' __._._-_,__- .__'______,___,-__ L1,___,.........~_ ________,_.,___.__.,' _..__ __ ____';_ _ ____ ,,..

' 1

-. - = _-*RiESPQN§ES-.2.01".: __

" -71412004. -- _. __ _

| _ . - .
92.

n

Positive

»- '

Response

Number 16

_, .

* ' *7 mi _
' - -'__ Moslsgel _ ' 1 _ I -H _- Pagelof2

hi6 -1 iI ;_____ __,._, _e ,__, i _msD! Q ____ _____j__,,__, _ ,

 - '.Subject:l§EiGTMO. :- .. . - l -

'_ l-.ivill.olassify thie as _a oosive fesponae; No needito do an EC.-T Thanks." _ i '

- - - -J-¢"'a<;i¥* .

i _ --'--on lnal'Messa e---- -_ . " ' " '

. - - " Fron'92: | i0<!- FBI! ._ - 5 .. §§c"11 'Sent: uesd zoo»; 4:25 PM» ~ __ -- . '

- - _ T° _ INso! Fa1! _ _'

 -s ct:RE: MO. ;." .____uJ"_1._ _

. "h 's_E.L4S|Tjve'_e1'L1j,1_|gQAssiF1EQ '~ __ - i

'b7C _' , -'

i "i ' ' ' just atom-ed fmm ;in|1i_1a|.lea§ie and read_the_be|ow reouested repiy_e-ntail.

. '-1wasioyioomormmsizsioa-1ir11rn3j ; ' .

-. - -"I-he only-rhatterwhioh may berelevantthatlol1seriied.t1vas':':__- -_ _- -- . -

-. 115 "1 l. {Date L'ln'known,_possilqi3i' -3-ctl'No~ttimeiamejat'Campi_l2elta,: -

-' MC 71 ' Gold'Trai1er,'"l_ believe! lnlewiewllntenogation treiler.-We heard loud musiocoming from, the right fa'r_near '.

- - _. ' of one ofthe"interikiewiinterrogatlon roomsfand proceeded to enter the observation hoothin bet_wee_n-- .

'- I - - -_rooms,' The 1ig'l_-its werje_off'in the-lnteniiewllnterrogation room butthere was a strobe light on with loud .

_ . e -_ music inside and a clothed detainee sitting on the oor, no one else was in the roorn. An unknown white ' =

_ be _1 " -- 'm'ale civilian clothing ente:edthe'obaeniation room we werein. and toldus we should notoe there._ SA'f .. .

an-fc _1 -_|':_lE]andn1yselte:dted1eroonj.' 

, . - . -i - . _ . _. ' _ ~ 1 -~_ "_

I _- 

. 5

.' : ._I Does this constitutelaggneesiyejeatment and wafranta follow-up-linteriview-by you ? ' if not, should I " .

_ .' - c'_.ornp_letea'negat_ive reply ECstating I did- not observe anji other uhusuoliaggressive treatment? _. '_ _ ' -1 - _- _.. -_ . ___ ' .- . .'- -_- . .. -~ ' .. .

b7C 1 --'3A' FB|- 1 - . "'3 '

= _ ' . K ' "on, Johnson-city RA

"_o2 -"1__ _' .1-

. .-~.--OI'ig_ina_ll'/le'.;5agt=;---' _. - - - .-

_ Fi'om:' MCCRAW, SFEVEN c. NSD! FBI! l

_  sent: Friday,July 09, 2004 2:42 PM . = _.

" supject:errM0_ - -- " - " -'

- - - -. ..1mpor.ta_r|ce:..t-li'gh_. ...-. _ _ - . . _ _ _ A _

' SENS]J'iVEEiIi'UNCL555SlFlEQ

". t" -

You have been identied as'hav'jr|g conducted an assignment at GTMO. Cuba since 9!11l01; The _

inspection Division has beer|.iaslced_ with contacting those employeesguho havesewed in any '

' capacity at GTMO and obtaininformation r_eg'arding the treatment of detainees. Employees should

1 immegiatelg respond to the following : l M l. I ' - _" T .. .. I '' -

i l i ' . REsP0r~|'sEsé2o'2'.
|__ 92' ___ ;: ___ _

t

_ I |<Ii~ev_>t¢FB!> -t:§¬~55i,&#

Sent: Tuesday, Ju|y2?', 2004 1:25 PM-H '_b7° _1 __ " _ _ _ -

. , Subject:"GTMO-- ' ' T .. ' . .. .

. SEN-SlIlVE-__B._UJ' u1§ICLAs§:F|E0_1&#_ ' - -' . -

. - IQON-RECORD .- - " . ', ' ' '

b6l _

'b?C -1 | j _|_5tte|k' dtq sA|:|regeming_mi's matter. He advised he'_v92fas not"wi_t_h_ r_rie oh the d;1y'i_n,quesdn"

5- _ --At the-time, ith:5ught'it Wes SA|;_|uitr1_me_fdr_we ii-re paired tbgether mest_cf1e_tjme_L .|'can n0t.recalt- .'

-'uwhoitwasthatwaswithmel;. -" i - -_ _ ;-;. 1 -"

- 1 Knoxville Division, -.}ohnson.City'RA -b6 _1

b -1

B .. r: 1- -_ hewiidremembem1e-ter|ing'-hi

:~~--- -~:;-:-- - - '- <- r-:.= -2- -"--=1 j

--_-e--O_ri Ina!-Messa e'---"- _ . '

= . ~ r.r==m=ei<i<><>-<FB1> e -V V .

b5 '1 Sent'Tuesda Ju 13 2004425 PM lb7c_ -1_-___j-q= NSD5__ EBI'! '_ -

'  Sub' : :G-TMO.-'~ .

_ - NONiR5QQ_ 31:1," -_. _ Q__; . J §-" '

- ' = ' b6 -1 w

Iljust_rét11'i'|1ed.frorn'anr:1_u'alIeéive-add _read'-the h_eiew? 'féc|_ue5ted-reply éfmgilf - _ _i

|__weeTDY tb'emo :mm"'sr251ds-11:11x0a... ~ - - 3__ ._ _

The o_nty_-mafteriavhieh m§y?ui=; reieirant-that! dbsewe_~i:I west_ '. I _ :._ = _:- ' '_ _l; I _ " ' ' " ' .

- {Date U_ni<no~.-in, -poslsibty Oct!Nov timefragnej SA ar|d n-zyseif were at Camb Betta; in the Goid EEC E1

' Treiier, I believe] interview-lnterrtugaticn trailer. heard-ie_ud_. music comiftg fr0r1|1the right fat rear of one-of the -. -_. '

 intewjewlinten'ugatio_n rooms and proceeded tq enter the oI:iser92__r§ti_on_bodth in -betweeri roqms. The lights were -

' -. ' C|ff_in the Intewiewflterregation room but'there'wes a strobe light-on with laud rijusic_inSi_dé-and_ eéibthadf _ " ' j ' _

' _' _ detainee sit_ting'c:n the oor, no cine else was in the teem. A_LlkD92'f~WhitB male in ciyilian dlothingi entered'_the- 3,5 -1 '  _;_--#e|::serVBtienreerr|?we>we_n=$'iq% "and:tatd'~E|s-»ye1shQu|d

C_ 1

" Dge_e.this deqstitdte-ag_gree$i1;e~treatn'rentand-warrants Retina»;-up inzémew by you-?" '|rnfd:,.sn@uiacm-npreée-a -_ ' "

' _negative reply EC stating! did not observe anyether unusuavaggressive treatment? _ I - Q _ _

_ . I . . . . _1 92 _ -_ I _ .- . ' :_ ,, i-..$A|:]FBi- ' -- ma -1 . ' - -'  ' ' KD§ Vl||B D'iviiIo|*-1. Johnson-City'_RA .' - - ' - . ' I -

;"- '- b2 -1 . __ _ _

I - - _92RESPONS_ES2Q3 -'

. _?/2?x200¢_ __ _- _ ._ t -&_ w __ ,-

* 7 _ 117 i 4| I I_ i
Positive

Response

Number 17

. 92 »

-
i ' I§f1'3s§a.Ee I :.'Pa.ge1

1°" ".1! sear;-.' -'1Nednesqa7y,July14:-2004-7:59AM _ - _ H -

. - 1 ___7._f_?f'- .2 -

éubge-;i:.ee;sj~_1o-. -7 V, '- ' . it/ ,»~'.

_SEt~1S1|_iv-E BUT u_Mci..==.s§IE1§_I;_r . , . ._ "Q1 - . -_ . .

__ M017:-gggggn 3- _ - _ _ _. '- _ " - -_ _ - ~I -. -

OK, I-'wi_|I COi1SideE__thi5 a pbsitixie 'resp|_:|r'1se._No req1_.1irementfory0ute d_o-an EC.. Thank; fer the respgnse.

_ , inal l?*ie§Sa _. 5. _- " : ' ' ' I I -' -:' - "I ' '- ~ FP9m= 5E-ll-@I!--- i " WH t t t

. b6 *1 " sent: Tuesday,"-Juiy 13, 21304 2-1;-4' PM_ _ _-

it i b?° 61 'T0i §5D1 F5I!, I

' . . Subje¢t:G-l'M_0.. .. _- r

.SEN_SlTIU'E Bl[l'.UNC_LASS_IE1§Q _-

-[gem-Rscogn 5 .. - _ ,_ .- -. ._

9292- ' -u _|i-1.-:respe_;1sé' _tc:_'t_h-e'recjuest-for ¥nf_0.rrT_1_atidn'g"egt-_reet1T92_er|t_efd_eta_i1I'|et GTMQ: I._ __ -

_' "|"s_é5F@u_;LT;iY"51_I_errMoTfrqm ear1y:.I1.]|'*ie id 'rr;|idLJu|y.-20$-. O_ri one .-ncaassipn | witiiessed ziitemiéw. 9

.techniqué.s thetibetieve wrenot cons,ist_e'nt with F;Bl_'iF1lENiB_W_pQ|ipy or gpidelinee. Sometime in mid tqi 1 . ..

-_ léte June I viewed an |'hter_rogatio_n'th'rough one way'glass_beh'|g conducted in an actiaeent interview room. _ '1

- -I witnessed "a cteta,ir1iae=seetect-in the middle of the ¢_er'while lqudlrap crheaw metal music was eeir;g_ ' , -- _.

...-pfgye from a porteble CD_ player. Two intértogatbrs were standikig above__tha detairiee end continuously; -

' laughing and blowing ciar 5II_1O|<8 in the detéir;ee_'s'fai;e;' Wlilethe identies ofthe interrogators is _92 __ _

- unknqwn, I believe that they were_assnqiatetI.wit|¢i'Defense Hu_n_1int _S'ewices'0r cpntragted by the US-Army. _

 __ l. 1 "_ .' -'_,:¢1ir1|ore -detailed éC'v92_aitl:_be se:jt'reg'ari:ijhgtj'1is.5 :' . _:' '_ l 7' lj 

.b61- i -_ A b?C _1i-2 slii V " i '

~ ' "-FBiS.eattle ' ' .

 '. ._ .'-_b2 -1 .- _.

1 - gezisiriveeu1iuuc§L2§§iFiEn_~ _. ' "

_-i_L-.emeeere-s1nite_e.u1u.ttc1.»issIEIEL._. ittt;.?.t,i,_..__.._;._,.;;._-_.--t+;._.-=..__i-;___.__i, i.: _i. _-.;.;_ _-_

' -RESPONSES204

. -- 71-'14."z004 . -' " .:

-be-'1' lN5D.!{F5t!~ H if u '_ "_ ' T

I i ~ T==e= |:irsE>»<EB*>f P " ~L  - 
r

Positive

Response

Number 18

. i, .

ilé
92 ' _' - -92 - _ .

Message." W - . " . Pagelofl

 ;F_ at r ,' T{e1N$v! FBI!J = ~ ea dd

b7C -1 _Sent: Monday, July 26,'-200-42:52 PM _ ' [_ 7 1%-=r |j|<%'~$.D>r<FBeI1e _ Suh§ect:GTMOlnquiry ._ _.  " . _-

§ENSIT1VE_BUT_lJ N-Q1-&§$lFLE._E_J_' ' . ,

be -'1 Fnr.liet-reeoneilieon purposes. 8A Albuquerque wision, did not inerscrnélly obleerve abusive

b?c -1 -behavior towards detainees while at GTMO. As indicated in my ._5C,,instar1ces of reprted abuse bydetainees

- were reported via interview FD-3025; _ _ ' _. _- ' ' ' 

_ d emsJ1, ILE Bur UNCLASSIFIED ' _ .

I

¢

 F

*1

-2

92-

:-

J

-' RESPONSESQO5 -

1126:2004 ~ - _ -_ - * .

rp
F J77 77 *7 * 7 W '7 7   7 7 _ 7 77 ___ j

e ' 'FEDEFlAL_BUREA_U OF lNvE$T|aATioN- H, i

l _. I I. I v_ _5 H. _. hl

'Precede::ice.:' -RQUTI1-12.} __ -. _'Da._3c'.e:-' 0'7./231- -' 

_ .Io_: __ Ii1spec921:io'n' l ' Attn':i92__T;_Tnit :Chief.s 

' -- -= - . - Room ?837'. - - b7C L.

Iii Fru5- Rlbuquerqéi '"Ti.; 1"-@ , .' _j_u' J ""l f ' .'

, . .' Squad.6XLCRA ' "' - ' " ' ' I -- _ ._Cr:»n_tact:: -132 -1.

' b6 1 - '-- "!1,._ - ___ -,_ -mc: ~1 APPIQVE5 31" llh 5-"§/ -3 ' -' ' I '_ __I - -_ .- - - _ I

' _ -=_'_ i ._ ' ' .-§g ,_ e _:-¢§§y§1 = _ "- ;

+ e P M 11 »

i Case -:1: #= '23"?-H'Q-A1jgvss;9iA _-ipem-ring!". ' '1~it1é=-..- ',cou:41T

" . <

_'"'i.c;'rr~1o;~ _ . - .;_ - ~- 3-_ .

- - INSPECTION-SPECIAL INQUIRY i . -- , _ _-

.' ifcfl. . _'sy£=@psi-'5; --Res-iaonse of '.;L¢1;ing',ssRA|:|: f'eeG"l"1'*10- y

_ I |_ -;-_in|t;eI1;Qgat|iC_JI'1s _'_ .-_ l I I : _ 1-. ll -__ _

.?C-1 --~ _:bé-ta:i.-ié=" sA was 'r1:iY-ro_ jermei bégi';1ningl - Tl " '28. Z0133 for 45_ daY$'&i1'i Pa-rti-=:'iPat'eQ. in_ interrb at'i0ne'-3 

. -- _.-b6 4 .

_ - . "_ 1 almds e';<'¢1.us_i_»-eg with U-1'8-. Army CID--of-ficer - NC _3. ' bl - i Z 5 7 At the outset, 2.. '- _

"Ig5; Véi [and*6féf'E?EEpETe6e1 ETTIV1 natJGIMQ we;e_' __ e

.. . -instructed;in=e clbsed-door orientation to abide by Bureau ;.-  -// policy and guidelines b6 -1 .-. - .= _ - _ .- 

in conducting inte:r0gaLionsr'with the 

. . - ... -,.. .< _

~ ~H _

b7c _1' Bxcepeion that detainees were net to be giveqsiranaa . -_ l_ - ' warnings. QBureeu.personne1 yere;¢1ear1y{told-that theaFBI¥did'.i "

'~' - -notcondqe-dz participate in, sbme mili¬ary_interrogatiqn , 

I techniques j This referenpe was made_specifically td. - _ -_;

I - iI1'ter1C:gatiOn -te_C_h:1iq1.1'ésI of military ilfite-1],-igerice officers, _

.| not to other milita membere of the_CriminaL"Investigetive . ,

11$ '1_ '_ Ta_._ak Force ,_ -Slx dic1'rIbt 'witn'e'any,ab'1.1sive-1;r&#_.

11¢ -L detainees during interrqgations or othepwise. ' -_§'_- _'-' 

i e§' "_ Qdeasiqhaiif, during interviewseesiqne}-Qeteiheee _-

complained 0f_ineppropriete behaior by military;pereDnneL.= .

Such Qpmplaints were'inc¢rporaced intd interYiew.FD-3Q2s~per ~ ,

_ins¬ructions of Bureau management _'An example-of sueh.e.__ - _ _

"" ""-'" repéfrt -déin -'}':>'ef_ft:1Td"ifi3'l"51iI'?F[MIC9'9T0F2TA1?1£4"--.-.--~;------1--_ " zwhich e detainee allged.a female.guard_removed.her_b

*, /h?¢¥,

.and. while pressing her'body against a shackled and restrained ,.~+-__

detainee from behind, ' handled. his genitalia a.nd_' wiped _ - _

menetrual blood on his head and face as a ford of punishment '1 ' _

5 .for lack of_Cooperation, .TheHdetaihee.stated ;his'persen '

"P¥T5;=%1?..¬E¥33.2WB6_ ':_  1  T f. ' J i

 5':'i1w.$IFInéiiféBii.?.2E9.m*-z{'2.L§.i=.~;!.a§' RESPONSES-Z06. ' . - . __... , c... ....$... .;_.._e .,_... ,_. ., -~-r . -- _

tEmwm§@§@H_n . _'~ _ _ . _=_ ' _-F- ,eei,,»%mi;T- M PELCZIAS$lFY;i£!i§§.1Z;l?§l5§?_D_3.l? . - -»-1.-- E15???"-=_?§?T¥--5--Zl":i;-I-"-==»

F?-E155--$9-

. ----- . * - - . , _ _ §I3LEi§3'§§!§§!111i°¬U'm-E_.§- -
;.

.

Re:.

% G *1

Ir1spectionH'P1OT=' 'A1buquer_§nie '

291-HQ"*A13'2?"a59-A, 01/23/2_oo4 "

_ . '_ - . 92 .. : .

. re§urgd'fr0m ché interrogation'with bldod 9i$iblE@H-his92f@¢E

.- "andhead; = - " ' . .'.-"--3*- . 1 -- "' '@ - .Q5=

I

. n n '- ,- "7 - . ' ' .. - 7 _ 6

I.

I _

92

. , . -,: -' .

J .

.- '- . "

. . - RESPONSES+207-

. ': _.
, .

92

a

0 .

- To: ' 'insp__eC_tiTon _From ' Albuquefque. - " '

.q?{g3/2004 *

. . 1 . _ - . I

Rei- 2; 297fHQzA1327669< _ I

. L33D sJ: .- "QY' .

SgtLe_.a'd .l:'. - _{II1fO!-.Z_:

INSPECTION _ _ _ _

' =:hAT'WASH;NGTON' Dc;"

_ Q-;For_inorma;iQn onlyl I

J

I

1 9

' - an .

. ' _ ; . - - ' : - -_ ' ' J 1 

_ _-_I _ I 1 . - ----I--__._._-.-.~.._ -I-.----.--3-_-1-L-----_---71-----i_...-___.T_..._..-._-_-.-._..L-_.__.T_._._.._._._|___,___,___,,,. ._,_.,._...

-

r

. - ' - r

:- _ _ - I _

1 1

....__.,_

; - F ?RESPONSE_S20fi
a_'- "'.

. FDM2mwJW&%! ' _ 5 - ; - .

b6 r

b7C 

b TD _

DTF "'

_b6 ~4

1::-TC-11

1:3-TD -1 -

..b'?E -1 -

-b6 -4

b?C -4

_b7D -1

b7F -1;

I .

"ts -4 "

b?C -4'

b?D -1,

'b?F -1

1." FZEIiERAL'BU1¬1§AU or INVESTIGATION""_

__- - = -internment Serial-Numberi .

 ISN} an Egyptian male, was interviewed-at CampDelta, United States Nayal Base GuantanamoBay, Cuba, by Special

Agents| [of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and l,__ e , _l-eflthénité 9% d ates A ._ -i ' Criminal 7 - ' 

Investigations Division Contract linguist :

interpreted between-Arabic and-English. The iollowing ocburred -

during the'oonrseof the_teo¢hour;interviey;i_: -_._., __ ,

. _ I}~] The'firstfifteen minhtés'of the interview occurred in

English, [:::::::] said'he learnedwhatEnglishhe knowsat the '

University of Cairo, Egypt. ;He appeared to heYé.appr0ximately a

level commandof.English on.a 5 scale - He'smiled frequently and. madesome-attemptsat humor-E:::::::]eaid hehadbeeninterview

1by_a man this mqrning._ The interviewer would not say what agency

--he-repreeented.. - garuer-small,-t'a_lk, |:| requested"the"-intervi

'oontinue'dn Arabic.- 1 qq-_l"-= _;'e*_]'-' Q}? ,_ - 

i .' ' [:1-beoane""se_rio'ns='and saidhe -learnedafter coniin

2

ed

EW

gt

to CampDelta that the-Egyptian government has accused him of being

part of'ai1955 plot to assassinate President Mubarak _Theyalso

say he is part'ofan.organization called Al Wa!ad;- He then said he

wanted~to describe_what the Egyptian government-is like._ He said

in'i9E1, a law was passed-in Egypt_which'says he can be tried in

.Egypt without anyxrights:andfwithont a lawyer, and that the death

penalty_oan_be imposed on.him.';T%is lamplaoes'oi%i1iansuneer-~

military law,.THe.believes'peopleshould be tried'bycivilian ,

-courts, not military courts. He also said the Egyptian'government

conducts operations such as bombings-and blames'themon Islamic

groups to justify their actions against snch groups,-This happens

-under past,administrations,in Egypt also- _ Q ;~l '- *

d

_ t» lE::::::::]said the accusationsof the Egyptiangoeernmen

against him, such as his.alleged part in the assassination-plot,

are.not true '-He reasoned that,if these things were true, he';

would have been arrested by Egyptian authorities while he was inEgypt. After all, he said, it was_not as if the allegation were

1in_-iQ_@haEnhelhadiQbbed_a;QaQg,;it;yas a_plot to kill the-President of

Egyptl Yet -he weeable to -f'ly'~out' e-F"E"aff6"T1§iEf1TfvafLjir1-p~a*e'ep~ 

.in his true name. It was only after he traveled to Afghanistan and

t

*,,5Ee,' e ,9 ~

"-""5§=*°"'" 104.42112093.!-El§i1enteIsme;_Eie>s,,,,¢,ube , h - J "

- _; .Fi||:# ;g55__5_h1g;]g1_~[399j'j;g2. $l;_3L_,r§A_§=1_0_.-_ - *' -I>*1== di'=I51==d D'4J1.'/_20___.__

b6-1 "b ' ' _ _ . .' __' 'f . T_ ," .

b7C 1 _?_ 'ii,,,_;, oi _"1 1 i_: ' -__ii~_,ii,

_ Thisdocnjsnt contains nsilther recs-rninundauns not§:'on_::|usinns of -u:- FB].;" it isthepmpea1'y of '-ih: andisieaned'_tn !r:mir agency;

-1tandits cuntzntiarenot tn be distributedoutsideyouragency. ' ' ' - ' . ._, . . . 1 ,
 b6

All

_ -4

-=b7C -4_-_

-b?D -1"

-b7F -1-

'-b6 -4 "

b7C 4;

.'b7D -1

' b7F -1

b6'4'.'

b7C -4 - '

.b7D *1

'b7F -1 ";

:@mMwc@JMOf';;i ";'__ ,@1Q§Zg;K2DU3 oh; -1?

I -. ED-3n2aG%¢v.I04a5j '-' - "_ GZ:?-*'___ --; _ :;:1 _*

J _ _ . ' 92

"b6 -4

265A=MM_C'99lO2. SUB.AA 40 . -_ _ me -4" _ ,

- ' .= '- _t _ _;;' I -b7D -1 =- _. I

was arrested that the allegations were made; -He believes he.is one

of many who were arrested ae a IE.S_p0I1SE to the Septefnber 11, "2'_0Ol'

attacks.in order to show that.the United States was doing something

about the-attacksL._ .. . --. "- --7 -- "__3r 1 -_

. J 't-" [;;::::::]said'he has found all the interrogators to_be'

liars. _He. oes not trust any of them;1-Heigeve an example o£_the

behavior of Americans. A detainee returned£rom.anfinterrogation' ;

-with blood on his-face and head. ,He said a female_interrogator,jj

after'not getting'cooperation fromYhimq1called.f0dr guards into the

room.,.While the guards held_him,-she removed her blouse, embraced

the detainee_froo.behindand put her hand on his genitaIs. The _

interrogate: es on her_menstrual period and she wiped_blood £rom'-

her body on his face and head? He said he asked one guard, "Why_do

you hate me?"_The guard reeponded;fPI£-I:oould¢ I would kill you."'

T -:' _. cop1ained'-.o_.one-"i1as'-I-t'o1d him what he is. _-

accueed_o doing. He is_ready to he tried-if there is evidence qi

against him. He offered that there are three poseib1e_outcom

him:-i.'I..Y*'~' _' 1.; -,. _ ..-1.. q '-".

He wi1iface_a military'tribuhal '- _a -"_ "'_ -= '

He will be-returned'to'Egypt, where he will face life

_ "imprisonment and torture _. ;-_ 1" ' i  e '

Iv 3: _He will-be released to.a contry where he can claim-

" '  political asylum-i _. ":__ _" -H. - ;'; i "

1.

2A."

-i ¢ "¥'i he said he nnderstands the'imoact'of'the*Seoill

-attaokspn But he complained about the treatment_he has received '_

during_his arrest, traneport,'and detention. _He said the prisons"

in Egypt are better-than here. But he declined to say'how he knewthe difference. He denied ever telling previous interrogators thathe had-been-tortred before by_Egyptien authorities; J ' »

-. ;_ -92 According t before; he wa's'arrested,' he -

believed in the humane treatment of prisoners in the United States,

Fof'EH1ewreaeoT*when"hewae%irse~in£

ihterrogators. Bet he found his assumptions-about~treatmein the

U.S. system to;be-incorrect Helbelieves the United.States extendsno-rights to Arabs. He doubts anyone who interviews him will be

honest with him. .He-believes the.D,S.-inte11igence'agencies 1- '

override decisions of the U SJ military and that Jewish people

control _-the American media. " .  - ' j _ -

-- ~RESPONSES<21'U " -

n-:1: q--
b6 -1

brc -1

- 5-50mi-.10-s-95; _ -_.. '_ " 1. _- .

. ._ -_ -_ __ _I I- _ 106-4

1 '2.ssA~M_M-cs91o2-'suB_AA 40 l " ' Egg ii

. ' '5 .- ~'b7E1"

'-'r::@"ri:s:1u=u192an¢'.r'1=:»ani=5r- - N L '_',;.0h§iéC2i/,P_=:=h_._ - . . . ~ .- . - . -

' - h The ihteitjriewers e;@Ilained'-to that"'he was" i '

_detained during a time of war 'and- that he falls under a military"

' "System of justice; '- 'IIIhis is why he is-not _bein afforded the -same 1 rights as people-who face civil tribunalsl |-asked what_ &#

'- would be done with him. "He was told he wi].-_ -either be tried or

_"released-'- -He""s,aid-he. believes he will he returnedto Egypt. He

- .- '_wa's t_:o_ld'i;he 'U_i'iite'd."Stai:es is -not following the 'dictates"o-f the W

Egyptian]-government, "that the. possibility of political asyliim was.

. ment_ion_ed in his fi-1'e.. and -that _his'- fate was not certain. .The-_

I interviewers are-_t-rying to determine who is linked to the Tal_iban'

--' ancllto Al'*Q_ae|_:1a. _ '_ . '-._. ~ . "_ _-- . .

b6 '4 -' _ ' H. - | said-"he__know's how both" the Cilia and the FEI'- -'

MD _1. . _Ioperate. He o_ '37: '4." " ' w how e "do 't1'1i s' a'nd'how the tr to obtain sI t_Ih y ._ _'ng , __ yI I y I bu. _1 ' :LnforImatioh.___._He would not s_ay-,how 'he'.knows these things". =

= . . I-Ie then. asked", 'ii'.the' int-enticn--is .1:_c. -turn.-hin1_back't'cI

I Egypt, why-' not just. turn h-irrr ove:r:I'n'o'w?. .'IHe -was told t_.here-- are it-cc

_- many unanswe-iced 'questions{ tc}' let-- him go. immed-i-ately. _.I'-Le said. he

I belie'ves- from the intervi-"ewer_s_' ,.po'int ,-of view,-.he is .eithe'r ' _ -

asscciatfed with the Taliban and-Al-Qaeda, or he was just -caught in

the 'net,- so why not get as rriuch "ir1Itell'igence"_'from him as possiblel

: I As-vsoon "as the interrogators get all they can from him, ..t.hey= will:

I I __',. _. _- I _ I - _ .. II -_ _ .

E1 =3 - - ' offer was made to'hc1d'moie f"req1.1eIit'inI:Er92.'iews. ~-In this way, ' ggcfq

- perhaps some tr.ust_ could-be_ c1e've1oped and-[:| wou1d- feel- =" _b7D _1

comfortable opening-_up and -providing his complete histo ', which ' 1375- _1 a cculdhelp h-i'm1con;_p'1ete the process at Guantanamo Bay. - - seemed willing to address this piopcsal ' He then asked w at-time  -92

it"was _ar1d asked if he." could sayhis prayers. The interviewwas

two weeks, at which time -this pioposal could be'Id:i._sc1is-sed again. .I

. hand him over to. Egypt "cr-1' a pl-ate .- -. -I I. I I II

- - '_'Ihie conversation was--' followed by -a '_dis_cussion of. how '

- trust could -be. developed betwe'e'n" SA -Jw  e" at Camp -

De1.ta'lon --enou h to; have repeated-meetings, and ' -'

b6 -4

b7C -4

b7D -1

b7F -1

.  ended with the understanding. that another iritervi-ew' would occur irI1_; -

I I-I .-_-._..-_._.-____._..._.._._..-__._._i.-_.__;___,..__._92 __ _______ _' _ __ . _ I .

j- " RESPONSES-.211
-

Positive

Response

Number 19

O
- 7 7

_ Message l_ _ _ __ '- I '  1=-_" ofl 

ha T<1~S@HF§n11,_" -» -1 L

_ -3u'bject:FlE:GTMQ... ._ ._ - _ 1. __ I -I

OKf0rnow'weWi|| éountthisasja positive response.-No need-todo an EC.-j[nanks.'-- ,,w,_. = .

. ' --Ori'ina|-Messa e-=-- -_: ;- -- .- _ " - e .- _-I -

 ~ _ Fr=mj=|gIil.tI<><>- FBI: 2L - -L -

-b6 -1  - _Sent:Tu$da' Jul 1.3-2004912B"AM-_ _- . _ -- . - A 1~s:=-ml» - »

-I 1- ' , ,S_u_bject':G'1-M0 ' ' - - '

_ -1sg;gs[1j|i{Eeu-T"u'Mg_1,.A§'s1E|Eo

-"b6l . - ' .- - 2. ._ "' .: mb":c1'-'--.MF-|:[ ' _' " -_ -- '_

_ - '_--_-I wofked.-at~GTMO from June-through Augustof2U02.'-Durin_g that time penodl_ob§eweo one incidenf -

' ' '- 1 in an interrogation roornwhich waacontraryto Bureau interview p'ol'icy!guide|ines. |Ob5e|.'Ued3d_et_3ir1e.

. in aderkened interrogation roofn shackieto the bolt on the oor in _a kneeiingposiiiori. The room was - ,

~ COIT1ple_t&ly92dark and there;-eas a_as|-ring Frtdbe .|igh_t plecedin front ofthe detainee and a Stereo was ' -_

' playing loudfnusic in-Vthe foom. looeewed a male intefrogator outsiqe theroom during the time.'3met|'.

' -loheerved tl-iis activity; _ The interrogate? vJas'wea_rin_g_ a BDU unifo_rm_w|'th no-unft_patc11es._or-heme page on"

. the uniform am haveno idea-'wf1a_t agency he worked for; "howeyrerfl never obsemed any FEE! pen-sone! -I.involyedinrthisjnterrogatiori._l11atIcieecribeo. ' -" r  T ' _ -- '_ _

-- -"sensrrIvE;eu1f,o§|ii,LAss|FJEn '- - ~

',s-"

1

- :'RESP.ONSES-212'_

. -I __ ?3;2004 _ .. 92 _ _ _
Positive

Response

Number 20
"- Wlssaaé - " l 1 l l Pae¢_&

l

ll all i e t liitwrii

bi? _-1 .Sent: _Mon;day,Juty12,20El4B;46__AM - - 1 Li |:lf5E>IFB*i .,

' - SlJb]6C! RE GTMO b

92'_ "'..'5EN~,LlT1V_E-_E'JTuwCLA§§lE.Q -- » _

. l T'h'ank_ you forthe responae.»_l will'print.your response outaridttadetenninationisrnade whether this'prao_. '

.; . __ wasnotappropn'ate,_youwillbejntervieweej _ __ 1 _l _ _ ._ __ _' .

._ .-,.:or.i nairmessa e.~4:-... - . . . _ "U, e. o ,-Fwm=' §Ei-_ FBIi-:' r -

b6 -1 .- sent: Sunda Jul 11 2oo4'3:_z9 PM _ _ _ ._ -5 ~; _ 3!; bt -1 ._ '__To= IN5DJ FBI! I ' -Cc: {_SE!_{FBI!" . gt __ -" '

= _-§ubje'<_it:__RE:Gl'MO' _ F - ._ t .-

, .. §§ns|31|ve1eU*r,un§LA§§J§l2..- .

 - - -NON-R§CORQ' _ g ,

-1564 ._ - .

' . -I'm responding '_uiale4l11ail because I wasaware of apractice of irxterrogating';letainee_s_ which l did-not feel? _

was appropriate. During myshort TOY at GTMO in July 2002,! took part in _some|discussioJ-|s'abouta . _

- -practice-whjich hadbeen utilized in whichthe detainee would be placed in the interview room approximately -

. .6-By _ -'or=to the schedglgd.inte{92iiew'. The 'air"conditionir|g_in_ the room would beturijied down to as - -

' 55 de§'rees_- ltwas comm0n.practice_to -have-thedetatnees restricted frommovementwith ' '

hand lego _ff5, end a_ chair-1-bolted to the tloor,- which would prei/er.it'tl_1em fromoving around the _ '

room, whit: tt-his case would-prevent them from adjusting theair cohditioning temperature.  "

' . Myinteriiiewteam did not parttc-ipate in his practice; but l vaguely recall seeing detainees in rooms by -

themselves in conditiolns which! believed included un_comfortabl5r cold environmen_ts.. There '_ _ I -

_ were octzasionsfwhen our interview team" would show up l°or'an interview and the temperature in the room '.

' was uncomfortabtycotd. However. the'd.etainee'was rarely in the-roomior any length of-time before the __

Y interview aridwe would immediately torn The air conditioning temperature to a.com_fortab|e-level. t brought ' -

_ the topicup to the Marine Corps JAG assigned to us-and they actually-lziegari to discourage this practice,  92

- -not neceesarity because of myefforts, but_othe_r_s that agreed with my vyeiwsas well. . ' ' ;' - -

._ .__t>2 -1 If fee heed to ecintaot me a_beut thie mate}, he i-eeizhed at t-.-5m.a'i[_:[ tat mycell hpmné,|:| H

h-__b?<_= -1 , _ -_ _REsP0r»i$|_5s-,213~ '

" .----0riginalt4essage-- I . _ _ ,

" From:MCCRAW,.STEVEN-C.'[INSD![FBI! _ -_ l_ _ -_ ." - '  Sent: Frida' Jul oe, 2004 1.1-:42AM_' . . _ .- _ . -- _V . b61- l To: tM tMM>cFa1 Ho>u=s1

t

_ .b7c -1 1 _ [O10] cowl [MM eat" j hm F81; _ _. _i i _ Nt'.UFBI- . i MM!ti=a1>;l |<i.¢i; i=a1

- -

. -. HO! i=_eI!;92_____| cJIs_!_t1=en,- BA " FBI!;

"_1w12r2004 I - ' .-
Pesitive

Response

Number 21
. _M-essage _ "' ~ . " _' - _. - . ,. -.- ' l."3.gBl.0ID

I I - Wll'"f*°ll_E."l>.;~ ~~ ~l

be -1" ie==fm=.l:li<*~s5>iiFB*>ii e »

MC -1. Sent:_'- Monday,-July1'2,2Oi_B:31AM ' ' I. _ _ __ .sl:|<@e1¢PB':es- . 

- - 

is i r?&;~* . .'~@%mW;@H;a  ~. rm

Subject: RE: GTMO ', . _ ' -I . __=-,_='E¢*,'<etc --i

UNCI:A§§lFlED _ _ '_ - _" vN

_. NON-BE-COBQ - .. _ " 92

._ '_| will put izou down as _a positive response, so no need todo an-EC. !'wil|'p:rintoutt|1ele' Q

. -ascertain ifihe treatment is beyond the scope. ,'Thank_-"you-for y.oi|r response. - _- - - _ _ _ 

_'b6 -1 '

_ b?C -1:

W .92_-

3 b6 -4

' 1170 -4' '

I b6 ~4

- bTC -4

----0ri?ma1Messa?e----- .- .- "- -

'F|*n_m. cs! FE1I].- ..

Sent: _F|'.iday, July U9, 2004 5:32 PM 3 I

To: mso! FBI! _.

5ubje_ct:F'-E: _ . . _ - ' ' _---. _-

I"an:_i i¢i;ig'.ie e1r_.oi1'the:sid_e of c_auti0i1_her_e,:so'tl_1ese inmy or may 111;-i fen

. .wit.hii:i the parameters you-are using. I have been repeatedly assured tl1at,'a1tlio_ugh some of the . _

techiiiqties titilized;-by some of the non-FBI interrogators here awe]l'outsid_.e what would _ " -

generallybe .coi/isidered-standard proeediire for-a CONUS'__FBI interview, _al1 of the techniques. t ---

iised have beeo'_ap'proved by the Se'eDe_f. _H-owei-Yer I personally feel about these techniques; Lhave

been-.assured' that DOD had permission. I further do iiot'h'eli_e_ve- anything al<in",to the aetivities at .;

Plbu Ghareb in Iraq have talteii place here. -~ _ _ " . . ~ '- I ' _

Eitiiationz Ifwas told on or about_Th11i'sday,' 22 April ZQQ4 by a member of DOD's_North A'I

Eiirspe NA'E!' team sia:|:| whom he d,ebriefs,_ had provided the 'foi1oWi11g: _S_oi'netime.iJ1 ' -1

'secon_d_or 'l1l'l.l.1'Cl week of Fehniary of 20U_4,|:was _tak_eri to reservation i:}was on both FBI '

and NAB hold_!- He did not recognize the'-interviewers. anew-hen he told he__didnt want to -, -_

speéik to an one unless they were ii_1t_-roduoed by ]ii.is=ri=.-_g1;i1a'r interrogators; he wasyelledj at for 25 ' e

inintL'1es.|iLlwa.'s short.-shackled, the rooni.'_tempe_ratore was sigiiicantly.-lowered"stro'b&

were used, and possibly oud niusio._ There were two male interrogators; one stood behind '

alnd.t];ie- other in :ont. The yelled athim and 'to.ld_ him he was never leaviiig_l1ere.. The ' _' iiiterrogator ti-led to gr-=i|jis identify photos. After me iiiitia1'25 iniiiiites or yeHing,|:|was, left

alone in the 1'OOIIl in this condition for eppfoxiniately 1'-2 hotilrs. 1 At onepoint,-the'interr'ogato'-

ceme.haok in-theefternoon to rnsl-re _sure'he was 's_til1' there. Diiring the 12 how.-1rs,|jwas not ' . _

permitted to 'ea.t,'j:ii<ay, or use the bathroom. ' One of the inteiro gators was desc:_ribed_as olclflate ;

50's, grey and black hair, -mustache with no he;1rd,_short,' slciiiriy, arid wore a Blue sh_irt._.- -_ ' - '

My actions: I verbally iliforrned my GTMO SSA_wl:ien I received the information ,._1later' _ _- i

- "-ii1fonn'edtlierG1°MO~{9nScerie-¬~on;im-ander~viae-maileiH95il95?'20EI4s--§--------=--&#»- -

Note: It isirny nnderstanding all of these techniques were, at thatttime, _permitte_d per DOD. We

believe the interviewers may have been with CTC based iipon the physical despription and"tlie fact

mats was taken to an interview room without -appearing on the -schedule. .. I believe-they are the

only entityherethatcandothat. '_ »" - -1 . 92. '. '- . . - _ '

ell! » r Situation: I observed the following

in earlyApril of 2004: Ijwas being debriefeclfor severa
t-_ . .

v1 .

b6 -4

b7C -4.

b6 3,4

b7C 3,4

I - .

b6 #4

b7c ~-1

- be-

- i

92

92

.92 ..[RL FB cmlgrs ?_ |_[qpB- ;| fl - ' . F P FBI! ~ _{a=*-

_ -

I S ;

 hm app¢,@at.;1y 15 hsmgby NAB. Ttbughout st s¢s5;¢n;|:|pe55¢@11y trew-ujs in a? - ' 

_= trash can; At the time; Ifvyaé told he-had anulcer -and that the stress was-irritating it. I was later. ._

' . advised he had a stcmachvirus. Iwas told héhad been.gi92'ren' a shbt of Motrin or soriiething like

-.that!b3rthe.medica1staff. ' -" - _'.

' My actigns: Dile in part to the fact that LTC |:wa_-s_pres¢'nt anH.did not-object ti! the -'

I - situation,"and that I nav_e1' hbard|:|ask t6 bG'1'BU.Il¢d to his cell 0r'_requ¢S1'n1cdica1 aI Y

. ' tbcpk ho arztion- I stzbsequently reported this td-the GT-MO O11:-Sceni:Co;nm:1_nd~';i"via_e-ion _j_

-05/osrzood. - -_ .1 . -- t -. , ..  _- I

Situat1on:._I b_ri;-observed the fOll0jari11g'i1-1_-{early Aptil_0f20 _: 'A'n¢m;_1rs-were beininade by NAE'tb. debrief |i_|[::|refu.sed to -spaakor i.t'1teract'w1't

itlterrogatqrs-it; anywaIbelieve _&.

|:]was kaptin an i11tc1r0g;_ti0n ro'0m.for-aj:proxi1natc1y_1_5 hours, :sho;'t-sha¢_k1ed;_vrith ___

.' -lights andpossibly niusic. .. _ l_ ' _- ' - _--. '- ' ._ . -_ '_

" Mylacticms: Because it was my nndergtmding that,"-athat"ti1:[1é, all of _thesetech1:|iques I ,

- ?pernj:itt§:dpe:rDC:}D-,1did-.notrcpoi<t'this.: _' 1» ..' ' . _ ~_ ' :_-'- ~"

-' Fi-nm.:MC§CRAW,STEVENC={1'NSD! FBI} ~ - _ .h . - - _ -- ._ _

. . Sent:Fri?:'9i'20042-:42PM"" - -" - - " w

_ - Tu: cwncmn; MM! FB11; - _  ' FBI!; - I 01~I!; MM!u=1a '; 1

~ t<N*nrEB11- ._ aw! FB1- MM!-z-1=B11; t

'_ '. I.-.A!{FBI!; O!_ FBI! _ CHS! FB1!;.BATI'LE, '- .~

-.~ cm F.B1- :1~m>_<FB -< §w '1:-.

_ I BI; 0 ml . S B];- Z_ LD!- FBI!; 1

. ~ -D -.fFBI!_ t FBI-1;. BL 10;. 1

. A'N! FB1!f - 0!~ FBI!;1>.;=1a1!; 

-rNY!t<EB11; -. - mo: 1_ <Ho><@GA>; 

" <c0>r1=P»1>- <c@>u=Bn= t 0; _

. " ?_ - !_ FB ;' 0 ;

 Era!-1; FBI!; A 1 OGA]-' '~

. B1!:-,! FB _ CTg]JD=_BI!%:!_ ASD! ._ _FBU

~ ' ' rm BI!; _ - t -c-rivv]- PR1!; . . ".DJ:1=tBn; 9 _ 1 V ><Fn;[ MM B WP PB J NY! OGA} 1 urr - ; WC ~1- 5 - |@H! FBI!;ctn~/11~'.-nlqqes ARTHURM. - -"  01"-13!_g1=Bn;l _ W win an * " 0 .mn _ t FBI] i -1 - ~; . 1!: FBI!

'! FBI!. FBI! I HFBI!;

FBI] FBI! C0 FBI!;

_ _ . . 'F1" FBIJ; SEHFBI! '

" IRJCFBI PX!- PB 0 FED

- FBI! P 0;-.1; HQ	FB1-1 -

[ Ink. '

IJI . us FBI!; j

BI cm FBI N}f;____ .

1'5 Ili '

I-A FBI!; MPH = . I" __ i

- _" s1_=!Q='B1 PG! . ._

' YOGA!; FBI!; D1-] C'9N]i

_ . $D. C0N] CI! F13 CG! FBI!; . _ -

 N"1.! OGA} P-$}' .F13l!; MO [FBI]; -

I

_ I _

" _. 1 : - T. " _ _ .]_ -PB _ __ -

' rm 1311;" - om _1! ' 1!;. -

t MJJJFB - __ _ . MW]_[FE5_- . _~ - .<F_Br>;] _1 t i. <c"rm'a=BI>;l - _ |u:>L! FBIn; _ I.L - " t ' ' " 2 I '---RESPONSES-'215 . I -'

?/f1'2/2004- Q: In ' l -. ' .
__

Positive

Response

N umbers22

I_ -pg _
_,v .

-I

b6 -1'

b7C -1

l

. _< . ._

nF°m=.-i|::<d1"$°><FB>dn '_ - .' V. V ;

. Sent: '-Monday, July_12, 2004 9:09 AM .

.T='= |:|I°TD>FB>d¢in '

_'SnIhject: G'|'M_O_- u- . -1 _" .. d II V nr. "

ssjgsrnvs au1uJ~n':Lgs§|F1En_ - ' . - hi5!-_ ; i . _ - '

"b6 1 +

b7C -1

b6 1

b7C -1

b6 "1

b7C -1

Nb Eflhnaquihred, I will handIé.. Th'anks.' - - _ - J, __,_ ..¢:-:~ .

- _i. . I _ I I. ~ . . V

E >_,92l '92 .~_ _ .

u '- :-- . ~.

. .51 - I - -' -4-§'1§JrIginai'i'_P'_1essage--_e-'-" - - .

. - F@m Cm! F5I! ' h ' '- '

56 ti M Cl -]U| '1.-2 2004' 9:93-AM I l

-__._l1_ona _ l

"- T1== I ! |l*i|1~===» FBI |. _

__ g-5i.|bjeCt:'RE':GTMO ~. _

- - ' |:|Iha'vej11§:ver beérj to GTMO-, do ymifstill nédd an EC?_|:lI .

' -. . - -~'--'-Ori ' Messa e---- ' ' - '  '_ -- ' '

_ Fffom: {I192lSD} FB"I!' '- -

b6 -1 ' -Sént:Mbn-7:12z'2004 8:21 ' .1

we ~1 1 r@=|::|1¢w>@Bn L

. -' .- -Sub]ei:t:RE:GTMEO_-_ _- L1 '-

1 -uucLA§'§|E|g-0 _ _

- ngn-gscggn . - _ - ._ _ . '

Piease respdnd via EC'thét you did n<§t'.d|:>serIve agg_'__re:»-sixie treatment zit GTMO. I willput your

.- - _name'd.own_§_f'a subsequent Afghanistan rgeuirgw is. required._ '" ' _ I ' -' ;' . -' '

' __ "-'---0rfina|iMes5a '- ~- i - -I ' .' -- _  be -1 " _ FT9m= U-:BI!' '" IRESPUNSESQ216: . ;

byc _1' _5ent:M0nd'a'.JuI 12 2UU4'_3:1'6AM_ - - - _- ,- L. - .1~==|i|<:e=.s@><FB1> » ¢

_ Sub3ect:-Fg1l:GTrg1GJ _' -.

I '-.Importance:g-Ugh 1 _, '_ .. _-

. 5 |:]_I did nOt'obs'crve tréatlncnt -at GTIN-EEU, however, I did obsérveteafrnent dud _

- _sDm¢ procedures in Af anistan. _I will rsspljgid if required .I am cilrrqntly '[_DY to

- '- _ ,.I_,egat'Riya_dh._Thanl<s§, _ _ - ._'_ 1 ~_ _ -

..__. .1.-..-._ .... ......__...:_..-.:_.....-.i..--3 --v--.-.__.. ... .....'- n ._ I .-  .. _

' _ From:-MCCRAW,STEV'EI~T_.C. D92ISD! FBI'. -I _' . - _ . .

I. _ _. -.Sent:'Fri H9!-ZIJIIJ4 2:42 PM ' __ ' - ' - , . _ ' ' - -' .

' .' Togli ,, 7__' |_1M1.92rI__ _![F_-Bf ' . ' '_ _

I I 195 1 

 - ~ - I |_ H0}_ FBl1;_|_ | I!,

-' - we

~ ¢ d d B11;-I , l¢1WuPB1_I____ ism}-cPBd~ 6

-1 _ - M1vILEBI!_;_| | LAJ.£FBI]i| _ TI V . l _ - mum |_ CHS1jFBl2.;J:3A;'gII_!.¥

BB. " _

I=.1 I1 52210! F211 El <s1"_>u,~', -

- m2z2o0¢ ' ' " -- '
92

Positive

Response

Number 23
_,i, i||L*-I __ . -_-I

ilvfessagen . -i '1 _l ' pi _| I. _ F'alznfi 1

@ I 'II1@> V

117° "1 sass; . Monday, July12,20D4 12;5s PM _§ _ .- - - ' ' 53>; :;;:;1:»'--'' - . - -

s'uEjss:-he-GTMQ "' -' ' -

' §§!j'§5lTlVE_BUTUN§LASS- pg _, _ ~92 -f'é*'

'|s Ywco - -_-Count . vé: ' D~ n/J Fz'i&

. '- W ' ' -; Y

l;£C'E13 _ as eenwn¢ep_ is in dje_pr_ca::'e§s of-péing approved. _' _: " '

- ' _ - _-'7.-O{igi'na| Message---» _' ; ' .- -

"'_Frdfn': MCCRQW, STE92!_EN'C. [N5Q}. FBI}

-Sent: |YIo_r1_d3y, July .12_-QZQU4 12:13 PM .

-"'Tfo:. I ;_ .-

_S!-'b.ie_¢_t:.G,I'P-1'E>'_ s

"Impd__r-tance:'High _ . V

_ s.|sz~:"s'17r|i/15 BUT U_NCLé;§§lPlEQ 3- "- "

_ _.NDN-REORD i ; _ -. _-_

. -.56 -_1 - "_ Rafgrence pr;eviouss_"e-mail re captiongd maér. T¥10's'92=_;_i'r.it1i92hégve rapliess and svhlo - 3- ' -'

_b7C _ 1 sgswere previou_sl1,r~ instructsfd tosubrfi_ft an to the{fnsp_ECti0n Divi§i_qn,_Attentj'on:' Unit Chief .

V _ _- 3s.-s_:,1ss|s i senq a snort. neqauvs e-mall-to Un|t Chj1f3f|:|t_o assist in redunoilialiqh ef'thé <51.-Mo -'

- _C2i:Jl'as3cicinsLfegardingthis'r1?|si11e1f&#bé_dire'cted_t§"lEinitCHief|:]at| _ b2 -1]

" - ' - 1 ' b6 -1 .'

_ §ENS|TlVE_ BUTUNCL!k§SlFl§;Q _;_ _ _ we _1_

' 5 sE;us1Tjv1i Bu'r"_;JfgE:-L,-=92's:s'|g=lE1:>' -

:

. .

1'

' RESPONSES-21'? '_
.'FD-302{Rev.1-6-95}-- - _ - -_ .

. -Ll-:1-. .

3 -FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

92

_ _ _ _ '_ _ _. Dareefuanscz-i1m'cn' OjL[29"g2!1§

be - ,' l ' -' l lSN:' was'iiite_rviewed-at De1ta,'GuantaY

bio~ _ . Ba " Cubay Special Agent ederal Bureau oflnvestigation FBI! maj b-7D _ N'av_a] C_I'iII1iI1a'1 Inves

er:/ice _ CIS!-_' The illterviiew was conduoted English 

b7E

__ _. . was advised of the reason forthe 1I1_lZ81'V'l.BW-. __ i _ __ ___ _. __. _ __

ea" -4 _ . ' .' _qttesti.o11-ed speciogjjgi about his Icaphire byithe l92lortIjlern_llliance 

.215 '4 'Kondoz, Afghanistan and his subsequent transfer toMazar-'e-Sharif. ' . _ ' _ - -

. b7F -1 ,. - j___ ' ' " . -' Aroilnd Neeemear 205% Noveniberl; 2.001 d his tweets were mg to

-L - . get out of Kozidoz. |::|and'others jitmped in the beds oftmc s. ' etrucks .drove- for awhile, then _'

 - - " - came to a river, _where' they were forcedto get out of the trucks- Their plan was to s1-11-render to United

_ b5 ' I~Iations- forces. At a_ opt 0190 toZ_020Q,_mgre.t1-ucks appeared. mg to get into one of these _. 33°  trucks"-buthis friend - _. _ I £5151-:[ _ .. had failedto pu his shoes -

Mg : ori. . He WE-1.i'I'3d_fU1f and _while_wait_ii1g, tlte-tifucigsthey _wcre_go1__ng'to get in-to, drofve _oi_f. -Some

-~ -- planes flew overhea . ' _mce it was dark he coiild notfsee the tnatlciiztgs on the planes; .'I'1:te p1e;nest1sed' &

;- _ _ _ . _some type of ho or ' cendiary device and proceeded to blew 1_1pl1lZ[6_E[1lClC$ thatg was initially -. 7- goingtoetmt 'saw'm@y peopledic orgetsevercly--1_11Jured. i _- . _

L r is Js id] and sweet s-1e1e, s1i= I:l.

 ._ - started wallciiig. They could hear gunfire i11t]1c distance. . '_ey ' so ear elicopters. Themed walked-

" b6 - bat-'k"towards'-the river and observed women crying. The women werelocals whose homes-hadbeen .

1°79 - destroyed by-the. pl_anes.|:| estimated that eight to ninetruclts were d_estroyed.. They were full of

hm _ pegplg to surrender. He bclieifesathat between 390 a_t_1d 4-DO eo le were-killed wl1en.tl:le trucks t We-e e blew -up; Had his fr_iend,|:|been_ready;with_hi_s shoes on |:|wouldhave':-

.-; - ___dicdoI1'one-ofthe'tr'ucks;i .'- -. - _ - I -

' - -- ' H ' " ' 'l:_l'saw"TaI'i'bby indifferent yelaioi-es. He-

 - Pakistani truck inan attempt t'o|gc ot-I1 thearea. The trLLckd1'ove away and ws event_

- b6 _4 stopped bytlie__l92_ljortheri1 Allialice. -and t1'1e' others in the truck were forced to get out_.-The

157:; -4 -i Nor1en1'A1liance soldiers took their jackets ,1 money, and shoes. The-Northern Alliance soldiei-s were

mo 1 _- toot in any type-O=f uniform. -They did not have glms at this time. Theyloolced like civilians. _ _ .

_ NF _ . . . .

-' , . _ ' -- |:|and'his group wereforced to wthroiigh avalicy, between two high hills. He .

. I '_  c se people on the hills-with guns and camcorders. They--were videotaping the group of walkers.

= _ __ was Searched a-gainnd l1l5_l1il1.Il.Cl5 were tied behind his back. _ _ .. __ '_ "  - _ -_

b6 "Q " '- -- ' - - On the second dayafterhis-capu1reil::|i-aas put into a_ ditch by the Northern Alliigmc

b-,92C -' _ so'1'diers.l;:|desoribed the Northern Alliance as_"'Ch.1Iiese'people. I-lo spent all night in the ditch. 1579 - ' On the thir day trucks showed up andthe prisonerawere allowed tojutrtp into ll'_lB_ti'

1:>?a- ' ".

|' lpmrisntin on 01-Z'L'9f2i303___Z ' allQC-ua1f1tane:mo_Ba-92LL__Cuba_ ' . _ _:' '

I-"i|=# 255;a_;MM;"¢99_102w-i . J I ' -_ Dela dictated Q1-.-L29
_gg37

3,, i QAE _ Wb7C :1 i._/p - "_ W

'!'92~'lmM» 'n nu'U|I¢Inl|rr92I92nv92|92lI92!lOIiI92'I1E nnr l92I'Ir|i"] i'nr|:~ nfeke FD! fl it' HiI nlAnarm af Iha ED! and Cr |l92I92nnI'|In um» <um»
' b7C -4

- ' -"F15-snzatasvr to-5-95! e - . .

> . . . _ ;

_ . ' - - b6 -4

zs=5n-1viM-c991__o2-- bl? "4 _

- _ _ _- _. . . __ b?D -1 _' _ , _ __

 -_ _ " - we -1 _ . _' V _ _ 1

.. Culitirlhntion q1'm-3q25r1' . _ . . ._ --0; 0.1/:9/200,3 _;Psu '

' - . ' ' .1 - - .. .,, '

116- __| . . _ _ _ ,_ b7C I i land Jgotmto onetrnck,'and[:|got1_nto=anoth

fuJ1ofA.fghan1

me - ' * ' " ' ' = '

b7F 

' -_ " _I'he'tr|.ieks drovelfor awhile -andstopped at ari'tir1,k;nov_m.-loc_ation.

'ta1-1, caueasian, Anieriizan loolci.ng:nan who was .w  0 - __ej_ea_11_s_. The rnan_was.talc.u1g pictures cfthe trucks and the occupants; -The man-then left an did notisee him agai1i.' Thetrucks started

. - hp agai11_.a,r_1d drove off. At night they arrived at Mazar-e-Sharif. ;;]saw -lines of people h0ld

guns, The truck m % in hacked up t_o'a large container an I te oocupantspf the bed'Qf&#

truck-were-forced.-i_nto'1the container-.; -_ -- Q _.; . -;- 1 , - '_ _, :' . -__ . I - ._ 

;'_ .; 92_ _'- descnb.ed the container as being rd in color, looking like-a shipping containe

-It was about'_ e size o 6 detain_ee_ cells-at Camp Delta, but -wider. . | windows and only smal

holes near the top"for ventilation. The container was made of inotal. estimated that atleast 100

rnen were forced into"-the container. The container-was -then closed. P_eop1e.inside_b.egan to screarn" and

hang-on the outside-of the .contain_er; -but noone opened it.-|_:[blaoked; out ¬1l1_e .to1ack_ of air while

'itv_v.-asstill dark outside. He-carneto_Whenit'-=qas.1ightand-noticed that it appeared there wre new holes

in the outside -wall of the container. .-He-notied that the 1':neta]' was pushed inward, .t_owards thepeople

inside" the _conta"i1_1er-,.as if sonlethirig had pugnctured the container 'orn the outside. -He said.he had a

g:razi.ug' type we un¬l- on his right elbow wliieh _he'.thou_g_ht mayhave been .from.a-bullet. thou

the _.punctL1res- in the metal container rnay hat-'e'o'ome'from. gunre". I-I_[e' tfloesnot be1i'e92_ze_ t. e p'unetu_re_

'-he-sawere present pnorto his blanking ont.'_j ._ .| "E-' -- - - . .. ,_ -'j .2,-i ; = .

a

b6 -4

_b7D -1 p.

are -1 '

' .- . _ --|:noticed-the-tn-an 'next.tc'_hi1n was dead. - lie saw-green;-fo.ac_on:u'theInan.?s'n1otith'. had not eaten or El.t'3I1l -3J1},f1.l1.i.t1_g fortwo days..= He was still not given anything

to eater; The men-~i.n'-the container toolesloths and-rnhbed-them against the ceiling of~the'container

to get the condensation that had _ac_cun1ulated_:_there. 'The3--rung the cloths" out so they could drink the

water. 1- _: -" ' " . ' -- ' .

. _ !_ - l:helieves he eontainerlforiapproitirnately -I-Iezeshtirnatedlthat

_ only about 20 people survivedthe ordeal. _ ' ' ' .  -- . _ . -

' - '_ When the contained ws nally opene'd;I:|noced the peopl'e wopened th

b -4 - container wore the same type of civilian clothes he hadseen ear ier on the Northern Alliance soldiers. 14:70  4 . put min the container at Mazar-e-Sharif and when it was opened they were at Sabergaan j ail. iii? :i ' ' e COIHEIIIISI " hdbeenmoved92whilehewasinit.~ a ' _ ' " ' _ -

A.-.d0<=tnr;1T=atsdhiS.attI1W1;th.i9§§ins-aftst.ttis.rslsss== . _ _.. .. .. _.; -. a

= - .:j:ould not say why -he was putinto the container. H thought it might. have been- bee ause -he looked.more like an Afghani than a Pakistani. Lgdid not see what happened to the

_. deceased, but "later heard that the captures had gone through; _ err poo ets and taken money and_perso_nal

items. The dead were put into Ia big hole and buried. He also heard that some of the men who were too

weak to-get out of the container on their own were put into the hole also. . . - _ -.

i U The U.S. soldiers a1TiV¢d_ 31 StlbergaanF111?-bt1ut:onehahe w& released front the

container|:|s initial_capture and placement into he container-weret e t 'ee worst days of his life.

  . -- as-spouses-219' _ =_ -- ;'-

-1 .
' L

Positive

s Response

Number 24

.-

i iii
1

b6 -1

b7C -1

-Megsage - '- - _ -_".'_P§"1 ofl

I _|<i$F1TF"3'T | -' I § t £1 {{{{ it t ~|_i|:¢T@={FB->it Q-. ~, - 1

-'s@m&'_ 'Mo_r|day,_Ju|y12,2C|D4 3:22_PMh -. _ '  Q =1 -'

fsubjecu GTMO, :.~ ' ~_I ' ' _' '' Q; - - -

_SENSlT1VE agr UNQLASSIFIED Y '

you-ggconn-: - .. 4 --

Fositivefesponse perourcohyersatioh c:n'O7I12I2_0t'J4!I_ . - -_ . .

rwas"TDY at GH11/10 from 0TI1i3»2l!-0;!--'09_f1J'2!2iIfi03arid a:.<_:;&1'0i2a12ob3'-11n_aI2thé pigodlof

[W16 - 093032003, on one occasion I witnessed a detainee in an interview rdorn who was, sub]et:t_ed' to loud '- V '

.mu$5;;.a§1;|,-gtrgiqe lights-. _-I-witnessed .tt;is_.whi_le:wa_[kin'g1_paSt the r2DOIT!.0__r1=£T1!'? way t'0= another interview. I do'not_ ' -'__ 

.racal| the exact date or the ti_m'e -this oqcurred-.-The_re wéré _no,FB| pEl'50|'ll1é|_in th_e room thé io'ud.i_'riusic a

étrobelights. '-|' "" '_.:;¢ - _; -. '-_- _- _..

- -- -' b5 -1

i._ i J . ' bYC_1

.-TFOS/RFFIUYI/Roam 1.5223 .. T

.-  b.2.'1"

SEBlSLi1;N&B:_lJT'UNCLA$..iSlI$lE_I5 "

J

r

92

I

r

I

_ . l

t RESPO'N'SES=220 - *

m2:2oo4 " V _.
Positive

Response

Number25

. i - _.

J

' 1.-

_i "' Ji i i

-

i
fl 7 _ _; Y7 _ _ _7_:_ _ ___;___ _ __ ._Me'ssaLgc"" 2' 1- '. ' ' ll ' ' H Y: -. '_ . " _Pa5e1_

0 ,,

- L _, __,__rI~§v> <=?B{11 i ~ ,7; ; _ _

 92:i1<@r@>"<rB'> - L i * - 6*-1 V i

- , Subject: RE: RE: GTMO mreavusws 1" _ _

OK thanks. vvill keep this as a_poeitive_resporise,' gthlerihave statechue same. Nd neeci fur y0u'to_dc- aEC, " -

.h'_'-h£3'I-ih_inaii'ies'sa e-L--I -. -' I - " ,' ' I-._ * - r==r=m=F_;Q|<<:w><rB1> ~ 4 _ ,

r -1:6 -1 _' _ Sent: Tuesda Ju 13 2004 11:06 AM. -' _ _ WC ~1. Tm <1~$@1<FB11 ". e 1 ' ' ~ -I Suhjec1:_:RE:G1'i"1E!I|{1'ER92flE92-'ifS_:_ .. ._ - "i . _ '

_ .1 . ' - . ' _ _ _-

bvc1 . - ' = _'

- - ' was deployed rc->"c;n}10" $11 thefoiinwingviaie-as listen}; o2;_1s:ea_1D"o3:1ar63; crumbs 10' 09102103, 1 " -

' -, USIS1 I04 tg GU02/04'-;.in_crde_r't0 ponduci interviews of nancial operatives of Al-Qaeda and _U1e Taliban. I

" did not witness any aggresaive bhavior or interview techniques being_used on GTMD detainees that isnot

' ./consistent with Bureau poiicy. However, during the éecnnd depinyment; 01117303 10 09.92'0?J03_, i ubsehred v '

 -- a detainee beingvexposaci to loud n1usic~,and a;$i.rqbe. iight=during_ an interrogailon. I do no; rec_aiI thedate--,

1 that this took place, the_Idetain'ee-s nam_e,.or who" was interrqgating the_det_ainee. I"-saw wh; was going on ' .

' _.a1 approximateiy 10:00am and I believ_a'tne-qetainee was refened in as.-the poisifan m'dL1e tcvhis _ 1 _

_ knowledge-_o_fchan'1ical &'b_io|ogiq.a|_weépo'né._" - - -_ T .. ,3 . - _-

'b7C -1' _ _-

' 5Eli1$lT192,f__E_-_l3I._I|"LiN.CLASSiFIEQ- _

92

2

1

- - - ---- --"v--- ----- ---;--+--- --_'-- --_-._ _----- --_--_--'..--i_',-.__--_--_-- _-.._-92---_ ----.- --._.._..__ ---_... __ ___.. . ..____ __ _.. ___ --_. _.. ..

.¢

x "- _ " RESPON-SE5-221"

2r;3xzo04 - '_ .. .- _
Positive es

Response

Number 

, . 26

.
92

F

I

i

b6

1:7

. _' __

Ballla "- Frankie '

'Las92_'IN -arno

»--1

'. RESPONSE-S-222

1 .

F92l's92_Na'ma 1|

92 92

Gander - Tm='a1'qr

me. . cum '

Ms; -_ Cuba

Mr._ Cub

Mr.-_I. Cuba'_

0 _Cui_1a' ~

Ms.- --Cuban -" CubaMr, .- _.- Cuba

ML." - Cuba--

Mr. ~ I uba

Mr. -Cuba .- .

Mr.-_¥ Cuba .

Mr. " Cuba."

Mr. CubaMr_ - . Cuba " '

Mr. "Cuba .-

Mr, . ._Quba -

Mr..' .' Quna.

Mr. - CubaML -- _.Cuba -

Mr-. '_ . ". I Cuba _'

Mr; V_ Cuba:-

Mr. . .Cuha

Mr. ._t_';uba'

M5; . 'r'3ul:ra'_

Mr.'_ r _Cuba

Mr. ' '- Cuba"

Mr, Cuba

Mr, ' Cuba

Mr. Cuba . -

"Mr. cuna

My -- Cuba"_"

_Mr. ' _Cuba'

Mr.-" cups. Mr. -' Cuba '

Opaall92'M92' 1- 1 ' '

OperalibnEnduringFreedom

OperationEn_d|_1ring F:e_ad_<_:-m

OperationEnduring'Fre;-:dpn1'

péralinnErtdunngF_ree4on92-

0P'QI'a1i0n _EfldurinQ Fr_eac|o_m

OperationEnduringFreedom

Dperalinn:EnduringFrB_Bd0m

' _-DrieratiunEnduringFraiaclorri

opeisriun §ndLi_ng- Frcdum

,0pqra|iunEnduring'Fregdu'm

DpéraliunEnquringFreedgm

l_II{1eraliun'E1;lLrrirl1g Fraadpnn

Operauon EnduringFre|_§dorn__'

OpagatfunEr1durin'g.FrB_ed0rn

Operatidn-EnduringFraedorn

Oeathn_Erldurirng Fraadorn

Qlperalidn EnduringFréeriur-n

UprlidnEnduringFreedom

Operéllun-Ellduring Fr'eadom_

OperationEndunngFraédom

Dperaliun_Em:luring FreedomDperaliunEnduringFreéciom

DpérallbnEnduringr=|-ee_d_6_m

0para1iE|n.Endur'ir1gFrGedum

-- - -Ciper}|tionEndunng Freedom

OpararicmEridilrlngFreedom

OperalionEnduring-Frnaplom

operation Freedom

OperationEnduring I-fniedom

OparaliqnEnduringFraédom

qpmauén'EI'|c'Iuring_ freedom

.Qnafél92ar_§ Endu;ing'-F.réadom

_C|peri-Minn EnduringFreédom

Dperaiiqri EnduringFreedbm

OperationEdujng Fréédom

City . '

Guantanamoay

Guanranamnay-_

GuantanamoBa?-

'Guar921§marr_92_r:_ Bay

'Gu_antanan_m:92 HayGuanlahamnBay

GuanlanamnBay

.G|_ranlanar1iu _Bay

GU§|nta'namd'Bay

Gut-.inl_anamn Bay

Guah'tarqan'1n Bay

GuanlénarnuBay

GuantanamuBay

Guarilanamu'Bay

Gu_antanarrn: Bag?

Guantanarncr Ba;

GuanlanmnBay

car.1rar'1'am@' Bay

GuantanamoBay

GuanlaharnpBai

G'u an_lunam0_ Bay

GuanlahuniuBuy

Guanianarnoay

Guanlanamulay

_'Gua|_1lanamo Bay

GuantanamoBay

GuanlanamoBay

Guantanamo Bay

GuantanamoBay

GuantanamoEl-ay.

.Guanlanarm' Hay

GuanlanampBayi

GuanianamnBay

GuantanamoBay

~ - . I? "- r W

"A .;'H0_-

A ss

L +'w

Jab-Tm: ' lrmudfrléé 5__ , . .

_'@M~»

3 _- IMM 1

gno-

- 5B3.

If §nM_-

";.H@ - -"

-- {Mm

-' I Vj'_NY -.' '

_ _ {NY

' . MM

'LA " V195 ._

1

1 4*!" ' '

1 E110_

.'_, -FIR

A Qua '

R-1.-.-_E'<1~'

A _ .

_A, -. ;NY"

A in .ir::>1__.

L r4r=;-Ir-M.

"---.1e'a"m . -

J

92

r
no -1

b7C -1

1

m. r

-L

0 i

Pi--t -ii

L5»: Namé First Hams '-

_ _____ _ _ ,7 g

oar.

"- Mi.

.- Mr.

. Mr.

- Mr.

' MI.

'. Mra"I'

Mr.

Mr.

- Ms.

Mr.

_ -Mr;

MI.

. Mr.

Mr.

Mr.

. Ml.

"_ rm.

Ms.

. Mr.

' Ms.

M5,,

-Mr.

_ Ml. ' Ms.

- Ma.

.Mr.

' ' Mr.

'- IMF;

.4-

-"! 2;

.Mr._

' Mr.

Mr.

' - Mr.

MS.

. Mr.

|::5§-**%"

der' _.Thoat

Cuba"

Cuba

Cuba Cuba

Cuba

OI

Cuba

Cuba .

coup

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba C.ub-a -

Cuba.

' Cuba

Cuba

Euba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba '

Cuba

Cuba

Cfuba

Cuba

Cubs

Cuba

' Operation l_Enduring'F_reo_d|:ifn'-'

Citpaalion-;_ _' -II _

operation Erfdunng Ereadom

Opa-ra1ioh'End_urin§; I-readom_

Qperation Enduring Fraaolum."

Dpargtion Enduring Freedom

Operation Enduring Ereadorrg

.Upofation _Eiiu_a-ring Eréédoni

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation Endur_in_g_Freadom

Operation Enduring Fréadom

Operation Enduring" Freedom

Dporationnduring-Froédom

0peration.Enduring Freédorn

Unara92ion_Endusi.r92g Froaoam

0pe_ration_Enduring Freedom

0pa_rat_ion- End_uri_n'g Freedom

Qperatipn Enouring Feedom

4Z1oeration_End92nin923 ftéaidorn

Dperat1'on:EndurIng'Freedom

Operation Endunng-Freedom

Oparation Enduririg Fréadom

'-Dparation _Enduring Freedom

Ut>B'Iation.Enourihg Froedom

-_Ope_ration Enduririg_Froedo'|"n

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation-Enduring Freedom

0oerat_ton Erhduring. Fe_edorn

Oparation Enf Freedom

CubaCuba

Cu_.|i:|EI

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

--D|:eratiE?7'1T!'3.I:|;iu'rin'g" Eiaedom

01ior_a'tion'h Enduring Freedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

_Oporat_ion Endttng Freedom Dparation Endurtng figgtiiorn '

.. ._Op}iration Enduring Etlaadom

Operation Enduring Frééiziom

... 2_of'1

1 1

City _ ' -

Guantanamo Bay

Quantanamo Bay

Guaotanaino any

Guantanamo Eiay

Guantanamo Bay ' Guantanamo-aay_

-_Gu anianan1o_ Bay

<$uantana_mo'Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Gunntanarno Bay

- Guantanamoay

Guantananio Ba»;

Guantanamo Bay

Gujanta'narnoBay

Guantanamo Bay '

Guantanamo Bay

Guatariamo Bay

Guantanamo Boy:

Guantanamo Bay Guantanamo Bay. ' '

Guantanamo Bay

ouauaaam Bay

Guantanamo Bay ' Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guani-anam_o.Bay

Guan|anarr1o_Bay.

Guantanamo Bay

GU_3I'i928I"i6_i'i"lO B81 _ =

Guantanamo Bay

G118-.11'i===!11Bi"11.=' Bar

Guantanamo Bay

Gutin92anat11O B181

Jab Title

6

A.

F .

A.-

§rrq|dorr1_c_e- '

inn "- -

i"°»

NY .

.=r_P "

[H0

co

{MM -

Erw-. °

4

iHO

=01

iQT.-

EHCI

}CG

§LS '

= on

I

I

tin.

i-NO

HQ

MM

an '

-|R- '

ERF '

LAB -

HE].

HQ T

=_
hi5 1

b'i|'C - 1

O

. Last Name ' First Name

turn;-:-izi.=@=

_U|Tll'I'92'I'lQ3 -

"r -cuts:

~Mr.

Gémtor. '- TheaterMr. ' _ Cuba 

Mr. Cuba

Mr. _ _Cuba - Ms!-.~:Cuba_' ' l "

Mr. . qutia _.

Mr. Cuba -

Mrj. - . -Cuba-_

Mr: - I.- Cuba

Mr. -

Mr. Cuba

Cuba]

Cuba

Cuba '

M9, ' _Cuba Mrs 1 ' ' '1

Mr. "_'Cuba '

Ms. . _. Cuba

lti'ir.__

Mr.

Cuba _

Mr. - ' -Cuba

Mr.__ -Cuba. Mr." Cuba '

Ms. Cuba '

Mi. . -El.lb3'

Cuba

Cuba I

Mr... __ '

Mr. -.

Ms. - _ Cuba

Ms. j ' gonaMr.. = Cuba

cube Mr. Cuba '

Mr, Cuba.

Ms. Cuba .-

Ms. "Cuba'-

Mr._- , _Cuba-

"opq'aiibn_.- . - _ -- ..

Operation

" '.Ur1r.ali_on Opqration

D|}eratio_n

Operation

Operation

t;uba:'-{I255,t?.z*m%;3Ei%ii%

Operation

Operation

Enduring Freédom

Enduring Freedom"

Enoiii1{1g_Fiééimm'

'End'urir1g Fraedom

"Enduring Freedom

Eriduring 'Free'dorn

City '

Guantanamo BayGuantanamo-Bay

Guantqnamci-Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guanlonarno Bay

iiiiatiirt§?RrééiiBiiiT§§t;oan|eiijar§io,B;ir

.Endi._iring Freedom

Endu ring Ereédom

.CLIDG.

Opératioh Enduring Freedom

Ope|"atio'|_1-Enduring__Froedom

Qparrition Enduring lfraadoin

Of>eration.'_£ndurtng Freedom

Opia'ration'-Enduring Fréedom

Operation Enduring Fré_odon"i

Opt-:'ra1io|i_ Enduring Freedom

.. .0peralton_Enduring Freedom

Operation Endurlg Fraadorr!

Oiaerétlon _Eno'1_.iring Fregd'orri_

Operation Enduring _Fre'a;li:m

OperalicinEnd_uril1g .Fr_oedom

Cip_aral1on_Endurii1g Freédom

Operation Enduring Freédon-i

Operation Endurin Freedom

oiiartition Enduring Fraadbt

Opéralion Enduring Freociom_

Oporation Enduring Feedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

Opération Enduring Freedom

Dperatiorl Enduring Froedom

Opgratlnn Enduring Fégdori-i

tjooraiion _Ei'1uiiiriii;i Ff§§a_iiom

Opétraliunl Edung F:rée:_i'or1"i

Guantanamo Hair

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanarno Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bajr

Guantanamo Bay

.t_'3uanlanamo Bay

D|I|'eFatioEi]§?idiig. i_=.'r'_'oa1i:iii._=-}

'Guar1tan_amo'Bay

§_=_uantana'mojElay='..-gr

Gua_nt*anamo~Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

G'u3nlanaI'I10 Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay"-h

Guantanamo H_ay. - _

Guantanamo Boy

G'u_antan'amo Bay

Buantanamo'Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantrganuo Bay

-Guantanamo Bay

't?iuantanarno_Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Job Tllto O

A

A

A

O

S

S

S.

A.

-'3of1Ei ' - RESPONSES-224

| . >

|

Fioid Oléo

PH"_

MM. .

no -

HoAl'- '

MM

sr= '

-NY

CD '

HQ
iT

arc -1 i

,_.j_.-i-i-an---_

F"

"T

i

b6 -1

.

6

=,:.=:-as-r_:

L-ii

2

.MS. .

' I

f' Last Name First Name . - Gander1_-

'<*_~~:--

 i

Lrr]

P

Theatei . 1

"Cuba

Cuba =

*,5I:'|ii1r"§;?.g!Y>I-5;3"E='.§="fCi.t1i'."

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba '

CUIJG

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba_ Cuba

Ct.Iba=

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cut:a£.., 1 ' - Cuba"

onun

Cuba:

CubaCuba

Cuba

Ctpeélliio"

Operation Eriquilng Freedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

§Jij'i:r'atia'n Enduring Freedom

- - .'0perat'|on Enduringfrefadm

City - - -

'GUS[liB[l3F_i1D B87

_. ~canrraropnrniian"=En_aisn@T¢?ae=inm:-> auamananinraay.

Guantanamo Ba"?

-Guantanamo B?!

I .

I N

Jdp Title A .

A ._. _' .-

bi92
hm Gander." .Th-aalir -- -'

Mr. ._ Cuba -

Mr._'- Cuba

tt.rtr1- - ICuba

Ms.'_ . - "Cuba".-

- 3; M r.- 2» ours ;"=92iifwi?_'L'-':'I*i1i=i-3??

Mr.1 ' Cuba

Mr. 1 .Cuba

Mr. " ' Cuba

Mr. _ Quh

Ms. Cuba"

Mr; - ._ .Cuba

Mr. V__ Cuba

Mr. - '-Cuba '

Mr. ' -_ _Cuba"

Mr.. ".-" t:uoa__

Mr. Cuba -

It-tr. ._ . -Cuba

ti-Ir. ._ '_ 'Cub'a Mr. - -Cuba.

Mn Cuba t

Mr. _Cuba -' '

Mr. Cuba-'

Ms.- -' Cuba

Mr."" .' Cuba --

M5.92. "_ Cuba

Mr. _-Cuba

Mr-. - Cuba .

Mr. = .Cuba 1 -1Oparatton_Endu'rir_1g Freedom

MI.-_ _f _ Cuba

ML '. Cuba'-

Ms.- l_ Cuba '

Mr. '_ Vuba-_ _

ML. - .'C|.rtJ'a'

Mr. g ' Cuba

Mr. ;__-_ ' ' Cuba _'

1'31 ~ gm-16.-. gt , '_RESPOl92iSE_Erf

D_lJBB"_" " 1 1- "V '. .

Dpara_tion Enduring Fréadom

1

=;Il.'v"- ..

Guonlanarno Bay

Operation Endurlng_Fraettom I _Guantana'ma Ba?

Ogeratloijl Er_idurIrig'Froadom._ Guantanamo Bay

0|;-aratton Endurlng Fre_edom ._ Guantanamoayi

iieiiaitorr l_§iiout_tt1§?I§_ri§Elnji§?;'Gtianta_naijng;.§ay=;

Opa'rotio_n Enduring Freédom

Opatoon Endunq Freéaom

Operation Endur1'r'|g Freedom

Operation. Enduring Fraedom

Oporati-on Enduring Freedom

Operation Endur|'in'g Eréiedom

' ' Operation Enduring Fraeoom

Operation Enduring Fraedom

Operation Enduring Frao'd:in'I

Operation Enduring-!fra'ga'do1'1i

Operation Enduring Free_dorn

- ' .Oporation_.Endurlr_'ig Freedom

Operation,-Entiuring Frae,d_om

' 0pora1ion_.Enclurtr|g Eraaoom

Operation Endurtng Feedom

Oporation EndL|n'r|g' Fréedom

Opgration Enduring Freedom

Operation Enduring Frozydqm

Operation Enduring Fraadom

Dporalion~Endur|ng Freaoon'|

OparatioI1'_E|iour§ngFréedom

Opérat_|o'I1 Enduring Freedom

D|Ji:|'El_t%1Jl1'En_:1uFing Freudorrfi

Operation Enduring Freactorn

_ O|J'era1i_ori'Er1duiing Frieaqoi-ri -

'- I" '.Dpéra1ion E_nd1i_ring Fraaoom '

°P°.m"='i92 Ewg Fi§§s1°i".'

Operation-Enduring Frpadom

Operation [Enduring Frébdom

1

4

Guantanamo Bay

Guanlananio B;92,r_

Guantanamo_Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guan1ariarrio_Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

wnwhamo Bay

Guantanamo-Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Gu_antar1amo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

ooinrgnamd Bag}

Guantanamo Hay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

'Guanta'r1amo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

-Guantanamo Bay

Guantdnarno Bay

Gi.la_ntanamo Bay Guantanamo Bay " '

Quantafnarno Bay

Guan lé1ri£l_m'D Bay

Guantanamo Bay

5 . I

92. f-

.

"CG

Field Clftrca

AL 

no 

K§tt:-

MP"

MM

SF

WF

NY

St

cur -_

'BS.'

MM

MM

DL.

i-A.

ERF

o92__

ERF

LA"

i
C5

1:5 -1

]:>'?C -1.

Laet___1'~|ama F|rst_Nar|1e_ _-

' Mr. Cuba

i _' '2 Mr.-' l :;Cub:a':.

__ _ ,'Mr.' . __Cui::a . '

' ' _ .- Ms. ": Cuba

- ._ ._ Ms. ' Cuba

M " -_Mr.-' '_ -Cuba

". _. ' -" _Mr.- . '_Du_ba _ y- S

 - 1 i-'-*<:r.=a=:;:.~",f=*-Y~i:uriaa:t*~.'C'¢'aiifua-aaaivriénliiEmaiiira-iFi§aani.T

- I -Ms, _'Cuba " __O|:ierat|onE_r1dur|i1g'Freédorn G|.ian_lanamoBa§r ' --[MM

Harrington Thurjnas Mr

A

Gender Theater

. - Cuba

Mr. -Cuba '

'uu._ ..cuu.='

Ms. ' __.CuI:ia

Mr, = - Cuba -

Ms.-_ --Cuba

Mr. ' Cuba

Mr. 1' -Cuba .

Mr.'. _ . .: Cuba

Mr. - Cuba --

Mr. _' -' CU'ba' '

Mr.'. |- . outta

Mr.'_' .' Cuba_

Mr.__ CubaMr.» - Cuba

Mr; -_. _..Cubti.

Ms. _Cuba"

Mr. . _.Cuba '

Mr." - Cuba

Mr. ' Cuba

|'irir.- _. -Cuba

Mr, ' CubaMs.. "- Cuba

Mr, ' ' Cuba

Mr. Cuba "

Mr. h. Cuba

[Mi

' 92

Op-aationli. _ ' ii

OparatlonEnduringFreedom

0p_era_iiunEduringFraecium

'_Oparaiion'E|1during Freedom

QgieraiionEnduringlfreadoin

_OperationEnduringFreadpm

OoeraiionEnduringFreedom

City" .

GuantanamoBay

'"_'Guanta'nan'92o aay

GuantanamoBay

GuantanamoBay

GuatariarripBay

GuantanamoBay

Uoerati_on'Eridu1'irig FraadorrrGuantanamoBa

QparalionEduringFr;-{edom

OperationEnduringFre_ei:|orr_|

OperationEnduringFreedom

OparalionEniiringF_reeclon'i_

QparaiionEnduringFreedom

OperatihnEnduring_F=readam._

0peratio|1.|_Endur|ng Fréadmn

OperationEnduringFreedbrn

CiparaiionEnduringFréedom

OperationEduringFreedorn

OpgratlonEnduringFraedfzrn

CiIpe'ra1ion'Enouririg_ Fratj.-oorn

OfaaralionEr'icIu'ririg_ Freedpm_

Op;-:ratio_n -,Endurin_g "Freedom

Opérailon"Endtiring Feadorn

OperationEncluring-Freadorn

OperationEnduringl_?reed0rr1

Opératio'n'Endu_r|ng Freedom

OperatingEn|:iu_rinj;| Freedom

Operation. Enduring_Fre'e'dciri'1

OperationEndy'rin_g Freedom

OparalionEnduringFraegiorri

_Oparati_onYEnduring'Freeci0rn

opayaisan Erlouring} Fl:-igaclom

operation" Enuu_rmii'Fj§§aum

OparaiionE_r|ou'r|ng'Freedum

- '-"ti oi'1B_ j

c

Guaritanarnq Bay

Guanlainarno Bay

GuanlanainoBay

GuantanamoBay

Gualnlalnamo Bay

Guanta'narn0 Bay:"

GuantanamoBay

Guanianqrio B31;

Goant_ana|'rio_ BayGunianamoBay

GuantanamoBay

-iii-Iuantanamo Bay

GuantanamoBay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantar1arno_Bajl-' '

Guanlana'r92"|i':|'_Ba5t

GuantanamoBay

GulanianambBay

_BuantanamoBay

GuantanamoBay

Guantanamo Bay

Guanianamoay

Guantanamo Bay

G_ua'n92a_r_1arno Bay

GuantanamoBay

GuantanamoBay

' JobTmii -

A.

_-

Ag -.1 -

.s- .-

5'; ..A __

_ RESPONSES-222 _'

_.i.N9

EFieldDifica iH=e- '

.iHCl "

tho _,PH -

EH0-.

inc:

f~oi~t- _

ME.

-'_EFtF ' -

:.u~r 

'=' EP.

- ERF --

§|R '

§'CG'.

:I-[Q - '-
i

K3

bTC -1

r 1

st__Na1'no

 r

' :-r:2?;".:;i.irr"r1;;;:_;:--_;.

1 - i

r t -

b6 -1. i

r i r

t . {$1

t , .

in """-T-

_f=:T'/"9"":; l-_- .

..Firbtl92-lama I _ I

. Gander",T_l1B'nl|t-r - -

ML:

--_Mr. .

Mr. -. '

- Ms. '. .

' - Mr.I .- --

- -Mr. '-

. Mr'..=f

__' ME. II.

-' Mr. -

Mr.

I Ml'.'_ __

.-Mutt

Mr. -I __

M5_ ' '

-' ,Mfs.-.-'.

.- Ms. _-

Mr. 1_

. Mr. '

. Ms:

ltrtr

" - Mr...._f

: _' Mr.

. Mr. ..

Mr.

Mr. .

Mr. - - '

_l -1r_.»-"

. I Mr" I .

jtm!

/-.rJa..-'92.-

ca.-ha Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cub8:: Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cbé
7 I

Q 92

. J

Last Narne Elrat Namb

b  1 .

$1 Ir;-§

Mr. - "Cuba "

Mr. .' Cuba-

-.-.---a

a----_ --

I

w

.P_ candor ..ThdateI" "O|?iaa_{i0n_- _ ' _- . '

Mr. ,. '-Cubaf Mo. ' ' -I Cuba

Mr. -' Cuba ' ' '

Mr. . 'Guba'

Ms. Cuba .-

X " _' Cut-B

X_ - , Cuba-'

Mr. -_ ' Cuba "

Ms- - "-Cuba" '

Mr. Cuba "

Mr. "_ - Cuba

nn.- '_j3uba'

Mr. - - CopaMr. __ f.C!.tbEl_ . Mr. '- -Cuba __

Mr. ' - Cuba;

Mr. _ _' __Cul:ial

Ms.- - Cuba '

Mr. Cu_ba' '

nu. pupa '

Mr. ' Cuba

Ma.- ..Cuba I

ML. _ " 'Ci..|bB'

Mr. . CubaMr. _ Cuba".

Ms._ Cu_ba'

Mr. ' . Cuba .-.

Ms. -=: E:-Cuba

Mr. - Cuba

Mr. Cuba '~

Mr. . C|.fha' '

=- '-' l::'ra}- .-

Oporation Enduring Freadbm

Operation Enduring Fraédol

Oporation_Endtirinb FreedomGparalion_ Enduring _Fraedo'm

Operation Enduring Fr'ead1:im

Operation Enduringi Fraadom ' "0p_araU6n ¬r_|duiingTFrendom

Oparaiion_En_du||ng Freedom

Operation Enduring Fratadbrn

Operatiori'Enduring_F_maddm

Operation _Enduring Fraedofn

O'p'Br_a1i'on Endung Freaqun

Operation Enduring Fréadntn

Oparaiiulfl Enduring Fri-iadom

Oi:n;raLion'Enduring Freadorn

Opératton Enduring Freedom.

'Oparation_Endu|1ng Fraed-om

Mr. - j Quba . .Op'eraE|on Enduring Freedom Guan|anan1oBay_'

. ==35"g?+:g;;;q;g;;jggooo.w;§;-gag;§3paraijon:_E_niti|"§$%i*i§?{"niif;3ii'ant'i|i5'é

Operation Er1_du_r'ing Freedom

Opqrdllgbn Enduring Freedom

Operation Endurlrig 'Fre_¢dorr|

tjperallun Enduring Frdtaljiiirn

Qperalinn Enduring Freedom

-Operation Enduring Freedom

Qpération Enduring Faadonji

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation En_durIn'g Fmadom

Operation Enduring §=roadon1

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation Endunrig Eraeiiorn

_OporBliI:Jr92 EI_1dI.Ir_1g Freedom

svwrartwi Endurlné F.r=?;==9'=m

Operation Enduring Fédorn

Operation gndurmg Frébuum

= -an tsj - ' _ RESPO'iiSE5¢229-.'

"'_Guantana|'nq-Ba

. -Gua'rita_namo"_é!ay

Cll§| :_.

guantanamu B_ay_ : '

_ Guantanamo Bay

Guen'ta'narno Bay

'- G'uanlar3_alno_B

£3-u anlaftamo Hay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo _Bay

Guantanamoay

Guantanamo ay

Guantanamo

Guantanamo Bay

_._Guantaharuo Bay

-Guantanamp'_B_ay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Etay

Guantanamo Bay

GiIantanamp_Bay

Guantanamo Spy

_Guar1tanamo-Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Gt.ian!an_arnp Bay

GU'&nl£_m'at't&

Guantanamo Bay

G'uantanamo' Bay

Guantanamo Bay-'

Gu'ant.a_na:_-no Bay

Guaritanaipu Bay-

-Guanlanamolbay

Guantanamo Bait.

Guantanamo Bay

..=ERFHQ '

. g H0

r.is';:s"-:t*.i¥=.I3¥-'- 

' - PI-I

i=_|;i=i' ulna;

oi; -_. -

W-

WED _

LAB .

BF '

IF! - .

.H° 1 -

w.

no --

L92it- -_

DE -.

EMF "

Ho"-.
b'?C  Be -1- 92 i

1 1

O

i .

._ Last Name ' First Name

_

'92.

Gnradar Thealfar Mr. ' 3 "Cuba

Mr." _- Cuber -

Mr. - -Cuba

Mr. Cube. -

Mn .. Cuba?

Cuba

MT:

Mr. ' Cuba '

Mr. 0 Cuba

Mr. Cuba

Mr.- .' Cuba

Md. __ G_uha",'_- Mr. -'_ C_ulJj:a"'

Mr. Cuba

Ms." '.-Cuber

Mr.'_ "t>£|ua'_

Mr. '-lCuba'-

Mr. Cuha_ -_

Mr. " Cuba .

Mr. . Cuba

HT; . Cuba

Mr; __ urinaMr..'_ I Cui:|e_ 

MS. -  DUDE!

Mr_- _ -_ Cuba

Mr." '. Cuba

Mr._- . : _Cuha'- _

Mr. -Cuba '

Mr. '. 1; Cuba

Ms. .- Cuba '

Mr. ,- Cuba

Ms. __ Cuba-.

Mr, Cuba'

1

1

Me. I .- Cuba T

. 92

1:°r?.1Jii?E.i¬l~.{'#-.i=»f§rT:ri?§i1i§i§r*i§,a-r3§;i_i_§;;:_"_Q;iér;iis¢ihEuuii I-?ll;'iacl|

- - __Guarilan'emn Bay

-1 Opeetion 1 '_

Oparailpn Endilrlng Freedom

Uperajiun Er-|duri'rig' Freedhm

OpEri;l|dr_r_E|'|_du'rin'g Freédrairl

U1!_£+I8_llr_§i'| Endur|ng_Fre_ed0lr1

Operation Enduring F_rea'do'n'_|

O'parat||:_ii'| Enduring Frqeddm

Operation Edduring Feelduin

,Opera_llor_1 Enduring .Fr_eadom'

Ojie_ralidn:'Endurihg'-Freedom

Dpqralion Endurinig Freedom

Upqrdriqn Enduring Freédom

Upere.lun_Endi.|ring Freedom

Operalldn Enduring Fre|:_d_orri

Oparariqn Enduring Freedom

- _ Operation Enduring] Freedom

O'|:|eratirfm Enduring Freedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

0pBr§I1iojEnduri'r1_§Fr§gédqm

_0pera_lion Endung Freedom

Opereiibn_'Endufin5'; Freedom

Dperajiuri Enduring Fréedom

. -Operation _Eni1urlng_F.teedr_5'rn

Operatidn Enduring Freedcrm

Opératibn Enduring Féedbm

Ode.-ration _Endurin'g Freedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

_DpEIdi}dn Enduring .F_r'e'edom

Operetlon Enduring Fraedarh

Ugerdiien Enduring Freedom

Operalinii Enduring Freedom

Dileraiion Er'1_during'Fréedcri'| __

Ouéqiim EF?*='*!'F!-E! Fréédm

Opérellbn Ehduring'Fré_§dum'

[Jpqratian Enduring Freedom

any - .

G'1.i$ntanamq Bay

C-§uantanamu_Bay

l§uan92ai1amu_Bay

Guentanemo Bay"

G_Lfe|f|tan_amo Bay

Guentanamu Bay

G_uantanamo._Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Eiuénianéme Bey

Giranienaib Say

' .Gu;1n1ar'rerm Bay

Guantanmp Bdy

Gui-1'ntanar'ru:r Bay

Gualjlarreme Bey

Gdarnlenemp Bay

Guantanamo Bay

_GLlanlanaTno Bey

Guantanamo Béiy

Guantanamo Bay

Guanlenamn Bey

Guenianamd Bay

i§ueirrtaii_smn' Bay

Guégnianarnd _Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Gueinianarm Bay

Guanfanamo Bay

Gua_nt_a'n 8"}? Bay

Gueniariamu Bay

Gua_n_l'anarnq Hay

-GLi-3-l1|Bi'lBT|'1O'BB!

'_Guankan:irr_1d Bay

1 'fa'=>r1e I "RESPONSES-230 " 1

FA

Guanlanamo Bay;

Guénlenamo Bay;

I i

-_.J;.r§b'TilIe

'3 '2

_-A

._A- ..;

'%i'=.1?."E:-'-.'i*»_r

K

_i._A_"'

0". . ' i

-1 .

9'-*

5

-A . "

.Sj_'- '-

.-A_ _.

Fluid 0fcb- -

'su _ 1 ..

bu

-

mu: ..

Ho -.lr

NY ' _;

SA '

NY, .

ERF .

 I'l'l'l_ I

i

, - i
Z _

1':TC -1

r

_l..'aat_Narne -'-First Name _

. I

i i

..-_qr_,.,_..

'  ' '1q-Eil - 

1115' -1 - - u

F-:---:--i-=:

-Mr. - .-

5

I . .

Gander.  Theater '

Ms; ' -Cuba -

Ms..' _'CUba' -

.i'ul.r'.- =-'[1uba -

Ms. ._ -._ Cuba

MS. .- CL|l:|i!_

MF:___ ,- cUb_a' -

Dpeatiun - ' _ l '-

0p_era92§qn gqdumgfregoom

Oparaiion Enduring; Freédoni

Oparaiion Enduring F_lje'ad0i'11'

Operation Enduring Freedorn

' - Qperaiion Enduring-.Fraadorn'

Operation Enduring Freedorn

3"!" . .

Guantanamo Bay

-Gu_a_nt_anamo Bay

_G_[_1a'ntanamc| Bay

.GuanIanamo_

Guan_iar_92arr_1o Ba?

G_uanlanamo Bay

M3-H5-;¥3.;@'=:,¬ can-=; : '1 oi: M11611" ari1ji1rrn'§iFra'ao6iri<r=-ti u am air:-airia"|§5§

Mn - cuoa .

Mr. -. Cuba .

Mr_._ . Cuba '-

Cuizra _'

Mr. "- - Cuba I

Mr.

Ms. Cuba "

mi.-' '. .'.cuoa-.._

~1r_.=, - _Cuba '

Map -. Cuba'-

Ms-.. - Cuba

.Mr. " ,Guba-.

m;.'._. Cuba.--

Ms.__ .'Cuha ,-

Ml'_ . CIUD3 "

Mn 'coha ,-

Mr. £IL!B'.'-

Mr. - Cuba

.IMs.' --Gubja

Cuba _

-Cuba.

CLiba_

Mr._ -E-_' Cuba -

Ms. .- Cuba

M5. - Cuba'-

Mr.

' M r.

.i92iis.

"Mr. _' I Cuba Mrl.-' H Cuba *'

Mr. ,. Cuba

i i ' _ hii

i . . _ . . i

i

.-

a ¢

4

Cuba-_ '

Operation Enduring Feedom.

Operalion Enduring Freedoln

' .'_Dparali0n Enduring .Freadqm

Operation Enduring Freedom

- ' '._Operaiion-Enduriruj Freedom

Qperaiion Enduring Freedom

Uperaiion Enduring Freedom

Ops:-aiicn E'ndu'ring'Fr.aeEi'cm

Oparaiion 'Enduring Fr'E:edori1

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation Enduring Eeadorn

Oparaiibi] _Enduring' Freedom

Opemrion Enduring F-e_edorn'

0para_l|o'n Enduring Freedom

Oped-aIIon'En'durh92g Freedom

Dparaon En'dl'.Irin_g Freedom

Operation Qnduifing Freadurn

Oparaiion Enduring. Freedom

-Uperaiion Enduring Freedom

Oper'a_i_ic_:r_1 Enduring Freedpil

Opaijaiion Enduring Freedom

Operaiion Encluiing Eraadom

Clpération lgnduring Fraadorn

Operation Enduring Freedom

. Operation Enduring Fraadom

°Pa.H"Pn Endurrig Ffaaibm

-'O|:fér_atIuii Enduring F[_e'étlcirn

Opai'_atic':n Enduring Fr.a'edori1'

.'Gua'nlE'|namo Ba§*'.

-_ouah£ananio.aay"

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guariianamo Bay

Guantanamo Barf

=Guaritan_an"|o'Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guanlanarno Ba?

Gua'nlanarnb_Bajr

Guanianamo Bay

'_Guia'nta_nar_nd Bay."

-Guanianamo Bay

Guan|anamo- Bay

Guanlanamo Bay

.Guan'ianamo Bay

Quanianamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo Bay

_Guantanamc_| Bay

Guantanamo Bay

'Guan|animo Bay

Guanianamo_Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guantanamo -Bay

.Guantanam'o Bay

Guantanamo Bay

=1".-I D, ,6R'EsPons'E.S-231_

r

-15?

Job

S .

A

We5.-_-;92g'.;:_~ an 1

r

O

S

A.

s

.°

3

A.

IA

Tllla

1

1

1

i

i

I

Flelclfflioia

MM _-

SA .

ERF '

IF! -

"WP .

MM '. --

'PH --

NY -

HQ

IR.
Flrsl Hams

,

.0-M 0-Iv

-92 <

Gender [heal'a_r_

"Cuba Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba" '

CulJa_;

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

Cuba

W ?nh§=a¢?;;m Ollba

l';1.|1-.ia

Cuba

Cuba

Cub?

Cuba

Guba

Cuba

Cuba Cuba.D|;:e-allon -. -' " - T" _'

City  __
1

-1

h'.|'C -1 -

' Last Nama-

._ .

-.Firsl-.Name -- '

Mr. .

iiiriti '

v

'__Mr. . Cuba

.-Ms. 1 ' Cuba

I _, Cuba

Mr.-' /Cuiia

- .Mr.

Gender - ' -Theater_. 3

- . Mr. - Cuba"

' Mr. Cube

_ ' Mr.'_"r.Cuba

1

E.in=.=Iii=ii" .- . '

DrieraiionEnduringHeédoni

Operaiion-Enduring Freedorrl

DperaiiunEduringFreedom

OperationEnduringF92'oai1oi"ri'

Ci'p_i_3raiion EnduringFreedorn

OperationEnduringFroedom

Ciperaiiori _Endur|ngFreedom

r

City -_

GuanlanarlioBay

_Guanlar-amoBay

E.U3l,Bl5iEIl;lU-EB?

Guantanamo-Bay

GuantanamoBey

Guia_ntsnp|;i1o _Bay

GuarjianarrioBay

_ _M1'_.'- -Cuba"'- ' OperaiinnE|'li3Ll'l'|ng'Fl8B¬|D|'1;l GuanlanarrioBay

-_.-..C_uba

.=r Mr. _-.__Cuba

Mr. ' Cuba

Mr_"' _ cub;

i _Mr'.' ' cube

_ 'Mr.. '-Cuba

-"C_uba_

._ "Cuba

My. - ;

Mr

' Mr. I Cuba

_ _ I Cuba

- ' -Cuba

. ' Mr.. r --

-- . -. I/Cuba Mr

Mr.»__fCuba

' Mr -" "aim;

_- Cube

 Mr..'_-_.' h-Qulia

'Mr;» ._ Cuba

Mr. Cuba

1- Ms. " _Cuba

Mr.J _' Cuba

_. Ml. _Cuba

. -Mr; -Cube

-Mr.  Cuba

" -. Mr.' - >.Cuha

_ Mr.. *Cu'ha'

-_ ':.rzrr.! _ i 1

i _ ', ""'_:2"5""°: " 1:|i|;.:"§PouSEs-2.3a-' E. ; 6~?'*"m j ' .- =

'_4'*i-'L;i*;';-l§'1E§:!'-:'§!E'

OperationEnduring-Freedonii

OperationE_ndurir_rg Freedom

QperaiionEnduringFreedom

DpofraiiunEnduringFreedom

Operolion-EnduringFreedom

OperationEnduringFreedom

EJpe|'a'un EnduringFraédom

D'perallon"EnduringFraedom

OperationEndur_ing_Freedom_"

GuantanamoBay

GuantanamoBay

GuantanamoBay

GuanléamoCay

Gugnianerrlo Bey

_Guarii_ar|'arno,Bay

Guarilanarno Bay

GuantanamoBay

GuantanamoBay

GllientanernoBey

Oiioroiioii Enduring FreedomGuantanainopay

OperaiionEduringFreodorn

QperallonEndurhg'Fr_eedo1_'_h

OperaiionEnduringFraadom'

Oparalion_l-Qnduring Freadom

OperaiionEnduringFreedom

OperationEnduringFreedom

Operation"EnduringFroedom

D|:|ei'atI'c_in- Enduring-Freedom:

Operation.E_nduringFreedom

C'para'iion EriduririgFreedom

OpéralionEnduringFreedom '

Operleion EnduringFreedom

0i>or§1lkin_Endurinu FIFQQQW

Operation. E_nduring_ Freedom

Gua_nl'anarno.Bay

Guantanamo Bay

Guan_ianar|'[o_B

Guanianerrioqgy

Guanianamo Bay

GuanianamoBay

GuanianajmoBay

GuanlanamoBay

GuanlanamoBay.

Guan_iar|anioBay

G'ua_ni_an:irno Bay

GuarilanamhBay"

'§.-3_u'a;nlanamo Bay

GuantanamoBay

-Jo!!Tilla l

TA

i=.- I R i ' C 1 ' ' Mr ' -" ._Op_eraiion.Enduring Frogqdoi ' ' ' S "

._.A

_.S

:Z£i§'i?%*33|5§'5Ui§ii=-'§!iE'HFF19FE9955Ri1'V

_'A

r

Pxu

ll-{Q

FRF -

ii»

ERF- - '

1

ERR.

inn

PL

H0'

ho.

in. _,

ERF

MM. '

EL: .

be.

i_A-.

iii -

r~irr--

HQ..

I

I

."° ~

HO

l

|

l

d Office"

k i
C

b -1

25,1Y *

. O

92

LastNew '

i

V

First Narnia! .'.Garider "_THg'al'ér: -- 7

- ' Mr Cum;

. Cuba '

Cuba

- 1-X -I----.._cu|=a'

Cuha

. - Ms. .-Cuba

Ms

Ms.._

1 -.|'u'|s."

. rm.- M13-

Mé; Cuba

Mr.-" --Guba-

/.Mr-. _.<,3uha-.

B.-_'Mr. . '.'_Cu_l§a .'

- __ Mr. - Cuba

'_Mr.' Cuba-:

' Mr, Cuba

Mrf " Cuba

_Cuba

_'Mr.- ' ' _Cub_B'

" Mr.,__ ._Cuba_

.' Mr.---.'@*1l=é.-_

a 92 ~'_Mr. ; " Cuba -

_- Ms. . Cuba '

_ ME. _ Gubti

 - "Ms.'- Cuba I

Mr." Cuba

-~Mr'_"Cuba -

Mr. t _Cuba

Mr. - Cuba.-

 _'-_ MI._ '-_C|'.|ba

_- . .. Cuba

' .. Cu§'=l_

Mr. -" "Cuba .

. ~_Mr. "_Cuh_1a.'

- Mr. ' - Cuba

K

{-4.

1

- ."{""}-'.

term 1

'Mr.', "Cuba.

O|aeatlgS}92-

0p'e|jalinn EnduringFpaédqm

O'peraliun"_E_ndurir|g Freedom

QparuinnEnduringFnaeddr

-Operation.EndurIngFréedom

Qper6rg_Endui'_ing Freadb

Operation'Endu:-trig Frqédom

OaerétidnEmurmg'FmBd§;T|

OpemdnEnduringFrea'dbr_n

Ope1é|t§on'Er'1dur'|ng Fljbedm

O'p_ai'$l§on EriduringFre'eU0m'

Dparalior|'E'nduring 'Frae|:lDm

OperationEnduring Freedi

l .0péra'1it>n EnungFrpedun

_Opqrali_o:_: _En|:lui'ir1-3 Fraqdnm

DperalipnEnduring.Fl'¬IBl2iDlT!

DpérationEhdurjngEreeqarn

Dpé_raI,ia_r92 Endu{L_ng Fyéednm

O'para'liuf> EijdurigFreadpm

_Opera1ic|n Enduring;Fl'QBd_l3!'I_l

_0Qeralin;1Endurmg Fiiaedorn

0pef3lIr.ih;EndlH'i'92g'FrBed

Operann Eiidurig Feedom

ogerarianEdugFréadnm

Operaiiup -E_riquri_1g Fre'édo1j|1

Op-iafatlbnEnduringFraud-um

Ope'ralinri' Enduring Eraadnaa

OperationEnglurlng'FrB¬I:Idn]

OperafionEndungEreedom

OperationEhdui]Ffeadom

Mr____ __ _. 0piaral1onEndunjngFreedom _ , y = ]_ -_

92.P ="::$?-.??;¢;L*_1;.~*@%~'ai92_4f<i;-;j=g1@_=;~;_.!;uban?92z§§¥§%jDn§rlI§,'Eng. ~

Mr ' lperaliunudurlrjg Fraaqparn_ GuantanamoBayCity .. - "

Guz_a_n_lanai1'|o Bay

GuanlaambBay

GuanlériéinoBay

GuanianamoBay

GuzinlanarnuBay

Guanlanarnu _E!ay'_

GuantanamdBay

'_C-iuaplanarnc: Gay

GuarqmcBaj;

Guénljanamo Bay

G|.ia_f|I_anarm_:| Baj

GuantanamoBay

Gua1921_ana'1'rlo Bay

'3ua'r|{1anamo_Ba§

Guanianamo Bay

GuanlanafnbBay

GuantanampBay

GuanlanamoBay.

Guanlanamujay

Guantanamo Bag

Guanlanamo-Bay

Guan1ar|an'|o Bay

GuantanamoBay

Guaniailafno Billy

GuahfanarnoBayGuanianamo"Bay

GuaniaamoBay

G_ua_nIai'!amo Bay

GuanianaméBay

Guarlfanamo. ea

QpgrgiitmEnglung GuE|I'lTa'!'laITllO Bay

Dparqn-_Endu|'ir_1g FmacfomGuanlzanamcr-Ba

1 "

|.

-1

.r

-s ' jznr .-

_'_f~A_: - lJiM_' _ -

--5 Ha".

-. '-1.

TRu1'='|fRT_éb|= _' ' .

s '1 .EBF..

. Q.

_.Ii Q Egg1,._

_; g=s__--

.___.; _ PF

. 3-

. -1M. -

.5 -,wE-"

-A ;-_im|u_ j .' 0pe}a1kgn.E5un§_E§aéi{6m Guania_r1é1'noBay ' ' ' E

y A LS

;~ -_1;;;DH5._-- 5ReSPQu_sEs=z33__-

 NJ: '- ' r_.;¢+i.-,1._ " '  '

E

1

JobTitle"i=1¢|'a 0{II|:a'
b5 -1

b7C -1

92__. __Mr.. . __'§3uba ' Ci .Ms-- |

"Mr; Cuba "

I  Mr.

92 . 92 - :Mr.. . ' I

Mr'

92 Mr '

3!

92 f

 Ms

' Mr. -

-' Ma

. Mr.. ..

- ~ "Ms

. K_

 Mr..

Mr. -

 _ Mr. .

-. Mr, .

' Mr.

Mr. -

- Mr.

' Mr

Mr.

Mr

Mr.

r  Mr.

I.

~' Last_l92_lama r FirstNarria - .Ga'nda'r" __'Th_aater- '

.- Mr.

 - ' Mr.- .. .

'E;uba - ' T

Cuba

Cuba - '

Cuba -' ' '_

puba'

Cuba .

Cuba

Cuba'_ -

Cuban;.,'

Cuba I -

Cuba -

Cuba_j.

Dpm_llior|' _ .' -' _ '-

OparatlonEnd_u'rin'g Freédorn

.Operation ._EndurinoFtbedorn , .

_§lparati'oI'i EnduringFréeom

OpBr892io_'Ehduring Pqaéunm

Qpe'n_atior_| EndurinhFreedom

OparaiionEnduringFraédom

OperationEnduringFraadorn;

OperationEnduringFraaoom

OperallonErich.i|'ing FroeQ'omOparallon. EnduringFrae_ddr_n_

O1iaration'|E_hc|uring Fteodom

Dilatation-':Ei_92du'ring Fréadonl

Operation E|'1du|'i:_1g'lf-'r£:E¢.d0_n_'1

Upe}ation' Er||:lu_ring Freadom

ciw - . -

'Guanlom_:|mo Bay:

-.Bu==92§*9»m<> Bar

"GuantanamoBay-

"Guantanamo §a3r

_G_uanlanamo-Bay

',.G§1a'f1§anamo&#

I;-lqiantanarno Ba?

GuantanamoBay

I _Guar1l_an_ama'Bay

Guar|@'an_amr5"Bay

Guanianamo Bay

Gqaniooamo'Bay

Gu5I3'|I§;I1amo' Bay.

Guantanai-noBay

Cuba" " Opr3}ratioriE|1d|,rrinQ'92-=r=1_e'odom' Guaniar1eimo.|§_&1r

Cuba -

...Cuba - -. '

Cuba _-_

cum:

Cuba Y

Cuba '

Cuba "

Cuba '1

Cuba -' . '

opuamn E-ndunngFrgedom

OparalronEnduringFr9§domDpBf3UlI_lll.El'_'lUrig freedom

Oparallon-Endurlhg_FrBe,dom

OparatiorjEnduringFraador-n_'

OperationEnduringFréadorn

OperaonEntfUrIng'Ereadom

OperationEnduringFreedom

,Opara_Iion E_i1o_urir'1g'FlfBédom'

CubaJAIg'hani_s0pé_ration EnduringFreedom

Cuba -'

Cuba

Guba_'_ - .

-Cuba1- .

Cuba

Cuba -'"' i_'

'AIghanisIa_n

Afghapislan

_Afgl1_arif5lan

Operaiion" Enr!_u1-ing'?robdom_

U|:|'ara'1ror_92 Enduring" Freedom

Clperalion EnourigFf?Bdon1-

0per'_a1Ion EhguringFraadriwm

Opararion Enouring'Free_domOperationEnduring_F_n;§:dr>m

oneran..En<1urin9'Fr¢i=dvm

-'G_|5aralIo_n_ EnduringFréedom

OpiaralionEduringfréedom

.- 1_dof16. ' '

_Gi:ar11.ana'nu:| Bay

GuaniarramoBay

Guanranomo Bay

Goanianarnnfajr

Guantanamo Bay

_GuanIarjamo.Ba3i

Guantanamo Bay

GuantanamoBay

Guan_lanarn'o Bay

.Gu'an92anamn Bay

Gu_a_I'nl_ariamo_ Ba} '

Guantanarno Bay

GuantanamoBay

Guanlanam-oBay

GuantanamoBay

- REs'P0'|~rsEs-2'35

.1ohTié .

A

*9-

s

S

A

A

A

A

-0

 sr:--3 '=ramr:;;aE;2%§5.b§ra=:@r"rr4»:z§;iiE?n§3?§Mr " " ' ' ' -Guanifanarruoay A1

A.

A

E1 . _

Inurrnr.

. 92 .

'iF§é#<'%,|?!¬Ji--- .- - '

[E|a|u Dillte

-an 1 .

:"° .. r*""=n

-wi: _

co '- -

4 _ .

w|=0

anna. -' 1_..

MM

ino -

.._.iHQ . _

his-' -

-g-,1.

$;.ERF-

imam.

QC. 5'

"1

IPGJ_l-IQ in»-. r

-PB" 92

HR" 92
i

i

b6

pm:

1

-1

Q .

92

Last Name _-First Name

<3 i .

iMrL' i i

Ger|itlor '|_"i-'|_'a'aI|'rr --

Mr. . - '. -Afghanistan

Mr. ;-. ' Afghélniétan

' Iixfgénistan

Vifghaniqlan

Mr. - _Afghan_is'ian

'N'ir. -'

Mr. -,.'

Mr. -- Afghanistan

Mrj ' _*_Aighar|i5ian

Mr. - _ A_fghanistan'

Mr; - - . Nghalntstan

--Mr. A. - IAfghanista_n

.M_r. ' :'- iafghonisiah

Mr. ' - - Afghdnisién

Mr. Afghanistan

Mrfl "J5.fgha_r|is|an

Mr. _ .. Afghanttan

Mr. ' _"Afgi'i£ir|islsI1

Mr.. " _Afghlar'|islan

Mr.' Afghanisién

Mr.Ngpnisian

Mr. j_"'Aighanistan

ii-1r. __Argha_n|_sr_an

Mr. ' -QAhghanislan

Arghaniatén Mr. - 7" Aighairiislan

-Mr. I

Mr. . _'Afghanislan

. ' ,Aigha|1iston- - Mr

Mr. I -Afganlsin

.Mr. " ' _'Afgl-_|ani5i8n

_Mr. -_ ' -_Afgi92anfs_Ia_n'

_  '=Aighq;92'r'5i1an

_Mr.' '_ JPifghanldlpn

.Mr; Afghanistan , Mr..'_ ' ' "

oiohanisi

_ _ Afghaniélan

Mr.- -. Afghanistan

1

Or_!nat|on__' _ _ 1:" '

OperationEnduringFregadom

operationEnduring_F|e'edci_m

Oporation'EnduriI'IQ' Freedom

OperationEduring 'Frea-dom

" DoormanEnduringFre_e_d'orr1

OperationEnduringFreedom

OperationEduringF|'BBdOi'[|

Oporr-rtii;vr3 Enduring Freedorn

OparationEnduringFreedom

OperationEduringF_r_e9_ciom

Operation; IjEn|':_iui1ng FraBd§:||*|1

OperationEnduringj Ffeodom

OperpilonEndurlnq.Fread_orn

OpariipnEnduringFreedom

OperationEn'dL1i1'|_1g Freedom

_Opé ation'Enduring F_-reédorn

Opéra_tion_'E|_1dui1ng Frgédorri

OperationEnduringFreedom

OperétionEndu_r_ing_Freecidm

OperationEnduringFreedom

OperationEnduringFreédom

OperationEnduringFreedom"

OperationEnduringFreedom

DparaqnEnduringFreedom

OperationE_riduring' Fro:-1_dorri"

DperbiiqnEnduringFr'eBd :r|'i

OperationEnduringFreedcirn

Operatipij EnduringFreddorn "

OppraiiogEnduring"Freedom

OperationEnduringFrgedom

OperationEnduring'Froadom

OperationEndurirrgFreB_d0m_ .-

"-Qii.@rii.tii>n §i'"3iiT!!Q'FT-°9d°{"

_Clperation EnduringFraa-dm-ri

_O|J§2IE[itIlI'i EnduringFraodpm

.- _'; _1'sqr_1a_'

.'Cit5r -_ '

5

r :

_<' .,

RESPONSES-236

A--

'-Pi

.1-§i3114_1%|$"'

A .

92

'|iN_Y

1 r

i _

4. -- .

f_,EieldOftl=é '

1cG.'HQ.' -

_iQM '

is ..

P.

i1'i°.

I-i. .

ii» O

OCINY _. '

LV '

"line

13!? _.'-.&#

riB3. '

Y-1 '

.ME .- .-

:JN :l

'SU [_o~|_.' .

11=

iuo=

no'- IPX'- iro F

IMO.

ifNH_"

NY. _-

rm

lunr .-

urn

lint I .

'HRT liu=.1" '

mar

92.. -- r
Last Name FIrst_N ama

to

Gander Theater .

Afghanistan

Afghanistan

Afghanistan

Afghanistan" '

Afghanistan _.

Afghanistan

Afghanistan

Afghanistan

Afghgrnisian

Afghélhisttl

Afghapislon -.

Afghanistan

AfganIs_tar|

nrgnqntslun

- jperation Endunhg Freedom

Opeiliinn - Lt? .

Operalion Enduring Freedom

Operelion Endurirgg Free_dom

Operation Enduring Freedom"

'D|5e'rot[on Enduring" Fifaedoln

Operation EhdLl_l'|l'1Q'FfEéd0l'r1

' _ _Opara1to_n Enduring _Freed|om

Operation -Enduring Freedom

Operation Ehdut-Ind Freedom

Operation Enduring Freedom

Operation Elidurifig Freedom

Operéliunnduring .f-Ieedom

QpBrE|liun'ErIi1u1|g Freedom

<n.ngnan|st;tn,;;'£3r;ittr1Jtt13ti;¬rij!l§ itt9..Fre§dnmt§é:¢§§.'

Afghanlsiarw .0pe_ration Enduring F_r,aedom.- . - _ _

Afghanistan . O_parattn'n_l§.n'durIng Freedom

Aigheinlgdafl 'o;;.=;rattut1_'t5'i|u92'1_r1ngFieit<1r>m-__ '_ _  '_ "

.-

1

'- 1'anr1e

 .

. 0

.. .. Y

_ 1 -_ - fur

Operation Endgflng Freedom" l ' l

.- 1 '

_92 - ..

' RE5PONSES237'

i.'

I

|l5l_oIdiQfll|::a

|l;A >

""-1H0 ' ' ;

-Ew.-' .

f".@- {HO '

QHQ .-. "" lwm ' ' :"r'r1.1 ' -pr.

;Hm=Iy réarn

iHD-Fly Téam

, i-_lO¢F|y Téam

ICRU. .-

!LR_ -' 1 .-

1

; -.

1 1
Response

Which Are

Not Purely

Negative

I
Resp0nse'A

1 . '
o o

 Rev. 01-31-200:1 - -

i FEDERAL eunenu or INVESTIGATION

?

:==-maenw PRIORITY Date 0 7 / 12 / 2 0 04

'92 ,_ . Inspec ion Special Inquiry

From: Boston_ ' Hudson RA ' ~ * 1 '

Contact: SA I _ I N ext: , E

Approved By: I Z _ I ' 92 /

b2 -1 ma-ta By} jat _

o a a =/W

Case ID #: 297-HQ-B13276-69-A Pending] '

b6 -1

b7C l

- Title: GTMO SPECIAL INQUIRY ' _

Synop si s : To report negative response from captioned writer.

Details: 0 -lC'iEl Bureau name: 1;?

' Title: Special Agent -' ' - -.

Tenure of Assignment at GTMD: 45 days _[July'Auguet

' 2002}

_ ; With t1-1e exceptionf fluctuations in room temperature

controls by military personnel, captioned writer did not observe

any aggressive treatment towards detainees during his tour of -

duty. -' -

.¢'§

Ir

&

RESPONSES238

. b6 ff 1 l:l C

To :»-"'Countedr;t'errorism> tn: Z *1

Inspec ion Division

.- _ - _ _ _ .. . _ ..___._.._... _____._i.6g._. .._bé_ _

 ~ 1'-c -

1

-1
Response B
Ihglessagq ;' '_' - :P_ag61

l______J 9~8=>>»<PB=> a

a'°'f - . H 1! , - MC -l . i- . -51%-TE:,;12l¢3f12U sent; Monday. August 02,2094 5:22 PM - - . a ---

5 I5 . . - '

_ ;,.__ g _£§___,.. , 1ii;l*i§'§ifIr:*'15%Bi?'é&#.. _ M..- _

| a a aE;~§a@aa@§a>aa§~ a a -

- " '§.._¢I-ms H1; r1~'r"=§L-.a.=" 1_-3; ?1?.?.éi .

S_u_bject: RE: GTMO - _ I - . _ -I _ _ - _-

__i§£~NC-N-R RD ' ' - . . " -. i;1I?%I1&-FmP.m:aiI0§??EdTTi.iE1iiEE -

_ ' _ . _ ' ___-._a:.......;__,..._........,_.,1.:192..:..§.:.;.- ,-_:,--~ _.., , _ ...._ ,5,,_,,_-_,,__ _

-- ' - ' b6 -1 ' -§ERE_II1I:'§§I;§§%I.TlJIlI1-.L15$iJIA

I-was MaatETml!12!tI2I2lilIM1f1Iil2BIIii and aaa not aI:rsnnally'ullsar1e anu_mislram|.1=_m nl J~

Hi-aiainaas. I wan!!! aa um sllmiaad _ii.aI1!nl1i||9;sir':1_iIar in -311111 iifiil uccanad at Sauna _;l!ei!a' arinr in

or lliW I'M at '"iTg_i_EI.. I mm: annat haaue that an absiws astiuinl wauiui mam auauma in the -- _

iIrBsaan'a-aihureaunlsaanaa. - -J ._ -- i. ' _ =" I I _ "11 .' ~ _.

<~ .

3liil!flIliI3'92lil$_II_!;9Ei!§i:_lI saaa;laai_11un.aauaalaa , - - .'

mv aiiagaligns-_ragarainn _ _ :2 r__:au|nagu1a:.§:u _ all imas_aaia!!aua;n.1iaa1m uarspnnal were-Y - harsh lraammnt are inalunaliin ma !a'aarauraun me $-

302. -allaaiaa iinllllslll is aaraaanv as aggressive as ma mannlnues ailsaaa-as have Man - =

usau at lm Bilraib.-.a!J: ai!_aaatiaasara_;;ma can allegalimlsat u_n§'|si_cai"§st|*_a_ -.

I-aeaame am o'i';~.rai!a.'at6TM1i. mialnianal Iniaamatianmaj: ha. amalnea item mamas Saaaiaiis!

inlanI1an'af2!3II3.- = , ~ .; a a- a V ? .k

Tim 1!i1g¥nursIa§'¢f"|aae'!'aaa1nI&#uwnn-aaznauian East Ta__rkasma,w!_1in:n mfafs taaa avlizr-'lIma-alllnesa

and ranamama1tiniianu'|Imvinna-ui.-unlna. I'l1e_iIi!B.l!rs 'wara-uljnrau !a:1_||1inl_1imanistananler In _

amt imrsanel auiiasinu iihinaaa uII|1ression._- Tim were amen Inspired-by-Ba;_iu,frea ma. man £8 _

b  _ 1 gwasjairmerill a l:rua|1aa5£erinr.Tns lliqhu_rs.éahsiaretnalnsaluas to ha glmng tar ; 1. _  .

aamncranv; and may iuulizell-ihr: llnimn Stains. llliluugn me lliululrs ara_-Muslim their agaua -|Ii:inutauaaar ill anciuna lSi3Illi_!} raniualism; may ciimesl in am an anlitiaal -t:ung|e|:1iuu"ia Islamic - - ;

zarrariats ur me Taiiiuan. Huweuemlair camu in iuhanistan-was l1umne:_|,_a_riuI may an! in .Pai{ist_an. ' _

'mc'lIiu8iars weracaumraaj Imus PiIIii$liilll5,WiHl haltilein iramerfatl In-I15 l:il$lmi!l.iIi1Ii l1ali_IIn":iI!. "

ramapmeal airaav-ta__ninasa .ui::iais._ Il_I._-.pa_s aiiauell that ma liiulmrs who alara.-lraiusiena-aireivlixltn

ma ilinasa Han: immaaiatalu axaaulaa. M ma iimaoi my 1'M,.lIS' tlicials ware aaa_si_:3arinu wllallier _

Ia Mara m-1igimrs'ta aim &:l|inasa;aussilm1 to gain salunura-far ancinatan I15. actian in Ilia mmaaa

iasi. ma iiiglwr aalainaast ama were-cumzinaan mat may waula he immamamly axa|:utaa.it_meu_

wereramma}|ml:nilia._ ..' ' _ ';. . '_ 3 -j 1- - - " - 1 ' '

92

bi

b7C

b7D

b7F

b 1 

- if _ AI/|

b6

11

[1$i|:[lhaaaiuiilunumansiatar-listingmqTBY.. aamamu Iii ar1raas:anar,1§|:_|naa._ as ~1 regular aamact Wl_EiI 'a!_l_uI_il:a_a:_1n_ra1&

mm jgaur aaiainaas." -lS92ai_1ama in . fl

4
~' - , ._ . ll I . , . _ . 1,

_§.§C*}1l $n|:|Ba:zgsiBmB:np.mBwBm 1::-:!nln::e:B:imes§B1z_;u;:_u ~

_ _  r ' ' _ _ F  _ L I|||L_ h MeBB2=;ge_- ~-. - __ - I l Palgc-:2o

&#

cs: F I B F B F F - F " ~

bl _ _ _ F B %iE¬'H$1§, -I"|17_Ii!2ElIl2.!%J_§a

j linclnnen that ~

! n r|:1at;B_mn.ii:e	a_raBraBi11ali§nema1uaa!|B2.Iiuiavaiiaisqiasnatlling-1owing-a5!ysiBa!a1i_usaB

- i E'i'_l'_lI;lllliit-$16585§ll!lI!Il!~!§l§IIl!i'5'SiI1li1;ilIIIill£11373_ = . , '_ -- hm -1

_ ..-BTBB Uighur steal!:-is_:;sa:3n_at!I_l.a§!||1is1l:B uniulinglwas awBreur.u|a:-mm dowin:harsh {mammal =

- ' awatalnees;--Hal auantlu a-"smukina {%l!n'.' reggnliug allusaui min-uamiuaas. Hawauggji-.!I1e.lilgl1urs&#-"

an aratrua

1 .- .mBrBwBsaaamu.atGIr,::i_tw_as ismzpmlazi-uriarm|||uIIIY.an|l,1l1|lilnmllriuriu [lIB.!}|lS1I&

~ . ._s_ii=am1|'_eI1B. I-1:|:IiBvBit'Baa:sBalI_Bli am-Bay. iHfii'i!lli_l$B nncurresl iiIi]Ti'I1]I.1l92J!lli]lI'l

. -_ - have nsnuryemargasm asliiaiy miniiIiillU0iilBlIl!?illl_I1l}l'SlllI!jl!i, . "_ _. _ .. ~_

FF 'Ih':_1;t-B-a1?li_i'i:aia'|_n,:_'F

' 'nhse|'£'am'Bssiuetaanantlelaineé ' ' arei-3l!25':ayai'I!il|i 33;?

ulienriaws inma llmhursl Ii: Ii b7D -

b?F 

. - - _ -' _ ¢ _' ' _ _ -'

_ i.-.-'-Crr1gina| Ma-ssag'e-I--I? _' - - - __ . _ ' I  .- ..  - , _

1 - Fwm.=Mc<:RAw,FFEvE~ <3- INSDHFBII ~ "F F 9 J F '-: I , B

-  Sent Frida Jul" 09 2004 1-42 PM '. ' ' .- " - - .- ' ' . "' I - '1-B: ' l ' r~1§~4!. F_B_t! ' gMM! FB1 Ho! FBi!&#

.

-._, [o1o!, c,0~- Ml¢Jl_!_]FBI' t ~:&_gFB1!; , H0 FBILE - NY!_' FBI' = MM! FBI] g mu? L|]iu92!_-{5B1- Hr! | . " ~_ FRAN ,B1; @@F  -. 1U-A! F 1-.10 FBI!; _ -.

 am! FBI!_ . j - '

- WF! FBI!;| _ | |w! QOGAJL! B |I|9_9_{FBl!; _

[PH} EBI!; cummwss ART!-I.UR"M. cm FBI MM! FBI!;

~ _ T _ °MFB1 IRD! FBI' MM FBI!; l MP-1>£FBI- MM FBI ~ 92 MM!{EBI!{U . i

-. '_ | MM! F511;! lJ sF! FB1- NY! FB[!; - _

CO!- FBI-!_; B B B sF! FB1! _ ss! FBI-! i . j

IR!_ FBI' Fm-FB1!;[ mo FBI NK! FBI};

- - * .£PXOG§~;_ J Q FBI] _! H IR! FB1!;- -

 BF"= $éE?? am?! F 1 i l*§%cFE11n F wE><FB1>- Jj~FuFBn,- '1 

i

 CII{J F_BI! _ J<><! FBI! LAWBI!; j F MP! FBI!; 

B . NY " F - FALUFBI W

 "_

_' ' " " l  V V ' V BESF0N'sEs'-24' "

-_ ' Q B_ ___! LsFB;!,LBATrLE,'

~ FBI _ . _ FBI! _ ,|cu

, . 7 B ; " wm=B1!,] NY! |

F15! i <n1.!.FH1~ B A.NlFB1' !<FB1!;-

._ " - - H0H%g FBr- ; FBI' K j ]Fr[|:=!_gFBI!_~ _ - _ - . CO--FBI cs!_-_[gB1- -b6 -1 ' MM"!' FBI F ~ M!cFB1!- U <Ho!<FE11;J B I ~

'-bin: ~1 n1B>FBI- NYHEBI!; FQ!<o<:-M Ls! . A

! -F . Fen Fm! FBI! <As1:>!<FBI- mo! F

92 9 1 FBI!; {CID! F MM! FBI- ITD] '

92 FBI - FBI ASD!_[FBI MM! FBI!;
Response C
aemnunlnni u £2; - <:>

Fensnnn. Bunenu or INVESTIGATIONA

Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 07114/2004

To: Counterterrorism .Attn: 'MDLU _

Inspection 1=*== UC |:| £?<: 31

-From: Counterterrorism Divsion ' FA/RDTU [ <~ Contact: SA W

Approved By: Bald Gary M 9292

Harrington T J b2 _1

- Battle Frankie 1' |

. - I - ' - | b6 -1 I _ ,,_ b7C ~1

Drafted By: I iald I

- Case ID #: 297-HQ-l327569A _ Pending!

Title: COUNTERTERRORISM DIVISION

GTMO, INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY

Synopsis: To advise of observations of treatment during

tenure at GTMO. -  "

Details:' Special Agent| ' Iwas assigned TD!

to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba [GTMO from 1 March 2004 through 27 b6_1 April 2004. While there SA witnessed interviews MC _l

which could be characterized as adversarial in nature. However, SA did not observe any aggressive treatment

or the use o in erview/interrogation techniques that were

inconsistent with Bureau interview policy/guidelines.

O0

' b6 -1 S:92CTD92Ely Team92 Gtmo.ee.wpd 137;: -1

RESPONSES-241
_ 92-

Resp0nseD

i
__ ___  I:  

Message l _ ' Page 1 of 4

' If _ lilwsgurslw _ I

_ 7 77 7 77 7T2:qV:;7j;V 77

_ Cc: IR! FBI!

| ' ' Subject: RE-'_:GTrv1O - - .

Since you did not personally observe any mistreatment, we will classify this asa negative response. Thanks.

r----Ori " --- ' ' - ~ - I

, From: IR! FBI!

b6 -1 Sent Tuesda Jul 13 = - ' 1 2004 9 20 AM

. Cc {IR]{FBI! -

| Subject; RE: GTMO '

1 ssns|1ivs_s_u;r uncr_Ass||=:so _

NON-RECORD -

- I was assigned-to GTMO from July 1?, 2003 - August ?, 2003. l'm a member of CIFEC-is Behavioral _

' Analysis Unit and our function was to observe interviews of detainees and provide interview strategies as .

heeded. During mytenure there, I never personally witnessed agressive treatment, interrogations or

interview techniques on GTMO detainees. I did hear loud music being played and people yelling loudly

from behind closed doors of interview rooms but Icouldnot say they were yelling at detainees. Ialso

observed strobe lights in interview rooms on a number of oooasions but never observed those being used

on detainees. _.  ' -' i - - - ' _ '

There weremany comments made by investigators during my tenure at GTMO that every time the FBI

' established a rapport witha detainee, the military wouldstep in and the detainee wouldstop being _

cooperative. There were also accusations that the Military would present themselves as FBI Agents to

detaineesand harrass thern but that was never personally observed by me.

_ I lfyou have any questions, please contest me a - __' b2 _1

~ agile or I

etc -1 ' 1 - ' ' " " CR6! CA C . - .

. - _ FBI Academy ' ' _ -_ Quantiedvirginia 22135 ' - RESPONSE; 242 '

--_-Original Message--. ,

. " From: MCCRAW STEVEN C. INSD! FBI! - . '

_ Sent: Monday; July 12, -2004 12:13 P '

.- ' Te=EP'11|J FBI!; MM! FBIl' HO!- FBI!;

" o1o! c'on- - MM FBI' _ NY FBI-

 N_Y!_ FBI!; - _ t MM! tn:-11!; um 1. Q

- no!=s1!; ' CllI5! FBI - earns F_RANl IE CTD! FBI - ' 136 _1 . MM! FBI!; B m! Fs1 cu! FBI __ we *1 _ HO! FBI!; s1!_gFs1!;_ to FBI; en;

 FBI!; NY! FBI : I31-HFB1!; I * *

- - FBI!; 0! FBI; IR! FBI- NY!

 FBI!; no! FBI i-lO! OGA' co!

FBI - __ cs! FBI MM! FBI!; - FBI!;

no! FBI!; us! _ FBI!' NY!

 FBI!; HQ! OGAJ; _1-5!'iFBI!;'

- 7/1312004 '
I interviews while they were in progress but routinely took contro

 Rev. or-31-zoos! ' -

" FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION .

1 , -

Precedence: ROUTINE __ Date: 0'? 3/2004

- - b6 -1

-To: Inspection _' " Attn: . b?C -1 

' .FI.OIl1i. CIRG. . -

_ p NCAVC, BAU 3 . _WWWW .. - - - . ctintact: ssA| |_' b2 -1

.b6l Approved By: Tidwell J Stephen id?/W __ '

b7C -1' _ _ Fedarc k Janice. '

 Drafted By: _

Case ID #: 29?HQA132'?669-A Pending!i',?5"2-*

- Title: COUNTERTERRORISM DIVISION, -

en-10, ' ' . _

- INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY - ' . _ __

Synopsis: SSA did not personally witness any 1;$C_El

aggressive treatment, interrogations or interview techniques on

GTMO detainees. _ - '

Administrative:, Reference electronic mailings of AD'Steven C. _

McCraw, Inspection_Division; July 9 and 12, 2004. - _

Details: SSA Critical Incident Response Group b6 '1

- CIRGJ , Behavioral Analysis Unit 3 saw-3} wasdeployed to stmo we '1

from July 17, 2003 - August 7, 2003. Members of the BAU Unite

were regularly deployed to GTMO to observe interviews of --

detainees and provide interview strategies and other behavioral "

assistance as needed. During my tenure at GTMO, I never _ '

personally witnessed any aggressive treatment, interrogations or interview techniques on GTMO detainees. '

"I On several occasions, I did hear loud music being

played and people yelling loudly from behind closed doors of

interview rooms but I could not say that detainees were present

in those rooms. I also observed strobe lights in interview rooms

on several occasions but never observed those being used on

detainees. - . .   _

' There were many comments made by investigators during

my tenure at GTMO that every time the FBI established a rapport

with a detainee, the military would step in and the detainee '

would stbp being cooperative. The military did not stop the '

V . . .

RESPONSES-243 

92 . -

- |
To: Inspection From: CIRG ' _ 0 Q

Re: 297-HQ-P11327669-A, 01/13/2004

of the detainee when the interview was completed. The next time '

that detainee was interviewed, his level of cooperation was J

diminished. .There were also accusations made by different- '

investigators that Military interrogators would present .. -.

themselves as FBI Agents to detainees and harass them but that be _i was never personally observed by SSA[::::::] _ ' ' b7C_q

r1

4

1

1'

.2 - RESPONSES-244 '
* 0 ? 91'

Toi IDS-Pectipn ?i5om-. CIRG -

Q Re: "297-HQ-A1327669-A, 0?/13/2004

_ .

LEADKB!:

Bet Lead 1: Info!

' INSPECTQQQ .

AT WQSHINGTON, DC

Read and cléar.

+6 I

3

RESPONSES-245
Response E
 Rev. OI-31-2003!

Q!

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence : _ ROQTINE

To: Inspection Division Attn:

- sate: /2004

".'£Q§-ffi¢_é:§?'F&#

??}§:5F3.<'?5.§,.@-.111.  o t-'i;;ofnS-1; it e 

, ' r " "3

From: New York I CD~30 Contact: SS I _ _If _]_.

b6 -1 _

if/TC "1 Approved By:

-1

Case ID #: -;t29¬HQ§Ai32§6¬§e§71; Pending1"fqB1*E7 .-.._'_' _;_. .- _ _92-',-.||,-__..',, ..' .1 .. 92 1-..-q 1..-.sf.=-..- ._-------

'1:i. tle: COUNTERTERRORI SH DIVISION

§?3T;_-..§.E-..12i.1f~=;:zq@_

. -L395_§j¥E,{l3{ff_:i.§','

PE-AS 011- Q;-* 4 == 4% F 92D B : |-'.---_-_--2-»=-g _=m-:-.- ,.'._' r ed Y I ng ~

b6 -1

b'?C -l

Sfz

§i;E:nF0sHATIOHscnwrrrurs w GTMD ~~*'~~=@r.rar.M tn-

- - seesiisiuti=1ef'EIE1;.s;.><&#

. INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY @§E%gmmmmE$ e__-

Synopsis: - To report writers two ! tours of assignment

at the Us Military Base i_n_ Guantanamo Bay Cuba G'I'1'-10} . _

Details: - Ti! I Writer conducted two '{2! assignments at G'IfMO,

Cuba in a FBI/Interrogator capacity. The first tour commenced on

O4[3'0/2002 and ended 05/30/2002. The second tour r:ommeric_ed on

07/17/2002" and ended oa-/1'?/2002.

I .

IHQ At the time, writer was a New York City Police

Department INYCPD} Detective assigned to-the Joint Terrorism Task Force {JTTF! within-theFBI/%fy Kg;g_Qffice, Squar-I-as. _ ' A555 ipsorscra i;* -

 U1 During the periods noted above, writer interrogated a

great many of the detainees at GTMO. These interrogations were

conducted jointly with US military intelligence officers. At no

time did writer observe

aggressive treatment of

was noted. A few of the

the interrogators, i.e.

some wanted to be moved

proper officials.

or was persona 11 ldith y invo ve w any

the detainees and in fact the opposite

detainees directed certain concerns to

minor medical issues, food complaints and

closer to others.that spoke the same

language. All these issues however minor were forwarded to _the

RESPONSES-246.

7 . e - e _----cc:

OO -

|..

am-H@~"Prl3;17éb?-/

1_,!@5»;..'.1§.-'1. 1.? . _BEAR§HEn_" **ma:1> _

sanmzs: r| _

I | , -' cxf p'_.-m92a_,,._ MT:-hT_. 1.___. . _e§ =_|-92;,|'.'i;"r_:;=-=_":' . . ._. _ U Q

V aha!, I b6 1 _ - - niiv mm: I

; T TC ' '* 

LED
v.

Response F
' ' ?§ y - Q2; Qg;

 Rev. Ol-I1-2003! _ _ J

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

92 .

Precedence: ROUTINE Date: U7/l /2004

To:- Inspection I Attna V Steven C. raw

' . Unit Chief

Room 783 _

Erm: Memphis - _

| Squad 7/Nashville RA Con : SA I ' I _ bg -1 b6 1 ~e, -5 " I e*

'?C 1 App aved, ' I

1:36 -1

h7C -1

b _ I

====-We Br l:l

I Case ID #= '29?-no-A132?6s9-A {Pen

-Title: CONTERTERRORISM DIVISION;

~ GTMO; -

INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY

Synopsis: Response to request from FBIHQ regarding treatment.

of detainees at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba GTMO!. _

- Administrative: This EC is in response to email from.AD I

Steven C. McCraw, Inspection Division, dated July 9, 2004, .

requesting responses from employees who served assignments at

GTMO. The email requested that employees who observed _ I

a -ressive treatment -immediately email Unit Chief[:| -

and that those who did not observe such treatment b6 -1

' s ou submit an EC stating such. The email further requested. b?C-1

that the EC should not be uploaded, but should be serialized, with ahard copy directed to unit Chief I

' Details: -Respondent's official Bureau name and title is S.

" S ecial A ent endin transfer to Le at Rabat b6 1 - '- E -I? g P Q 9. as ALAT, e ective August 15, 2004}._ Tenure of assignment at GTMO was March 3, 2003 through April 15, 2003?,

I observed no aggressive treatment or interrogations

of GTMO detainees. "I did not use nor did I observe the use of

interview techniques which were not consistent with Bureau

interview'policyfguidelines. ' -

'0n two or three occasions,_during regularly

. scheduled interviews, detainees advised me that they had been

subjected to loud music to keep them awake and had been shown

pornographic photos in an effort to upset them. I have no

_ RESPONSES-247
' u

Q Q

To: Inspection From: Memphis~ _

RE: 297HQA1327669-A, O7/12/2004:

knowledge that these activities were done by FBI employees and

was under the impression that these were techniques used by

Department of Defense DOD! contract interviewers. This was

common knowledge among FBI employees and it was a topic as I

reoall that was_disoussed at staff meetings because it was

sometimes detrimental to our efforts of attempting to

establishrapportwithdetainees:""i"aisoreCall"thatm""""m

translators who worked with both FBI and DOD_interviewers}

also confirmed the allegations of the detainees regarding

sleep deprivation. , '

No detainees or translators advised me of any '

physical mistreatment of detainees by any interrogators,

guards, or any other employees, civilian or military, at_GTMO.

M

I

r

z_ z

RESPONSES-248 "

u

r

-..
. I .61? 92-..|- .

, To: Inspection From: Memph_1s - _

Re: 297-HQ-Al327669-A, U?/12/2004

I-EAD s!:

Set Lead 1: [Info].

INSPECTION '

AT EQSHINQIQN, DQ

For information.

§§_

1

¥

-3

<

'7 41* W" '7:__ _ _ ___

Q1

RESPQNSES-249

7" lI_ _7
i

Response G
_ k ___ _ __ .4__.. __jT _____.. __; 1

-. - - - - El,--|,} - - . _ .

If it _**'_I_?_|r~rso! Fs|!. W-- __ ' _ -

rs»-=si:irs~>»<rr»i r '1

}Q§,C_§1 Sent: M@ncia',.1uiy.1s,2uo45;2r PM.

Tu: l lNSD! FBl! '

" Subject: GTMO 92 " l l " '

. . 

§§_hlSlTI1E s'uT uM<;1_As_stFIEni '

_ N'N-.RECORD_ -- ~ _ . _ - -

b6 -1 lnspect0rQ- l just returned to the ofce toda' after being gone for two weeks, so that is why this response is 1217C -1 _a week Ia e. y-official Bu name is Special Agent, and tenure of assignment at.GTMQ of

 3i4I03 to#18203. I observed no aggressive traatrnen , interrogations, or interview techniques on GTMO . '

detainees which was not cor|_sjstent with Bureau interview policy or guidelines. lft had; I wouid have reported

' such abuse immediately. If anything,-the detainees were treated with professionalism. as well as extreme '

' restraint, considering some of their aotions against the guards. Most detaineesi interviewed were asked by - __

myself, or the other CITF interrogat_or,.how?tl1ey were being treated. The onlycomplaints I recall dealtwith rriail .

not being rreceived, dental issues not being g|92_ren- immediate attention, andother non-abusive ISSUES. The senior ._

CITF ofcial Iwas teamed with wouldfoliow u on these complaints as soon as the interviewiinterrogation was completed. An'EC,will follow. Thani_< gou_ '_SLC, Boise Rf-92, _ - _ _

sbsnsijws BL1T_UNCl._i}92$§IFlED ' _155 _1 _' _.~ _

 - - . me -1 '1->2 -1_

1

_ RESPONSES-250 '

. "In omnna - _ _ - _ -
1-: 1--_77_ _ -L r _ _

_ -1

G! . r. Q

' rev. 0113?-zoos!

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: ROUTINE Date: - 0%9/2004 be 1

To: Inspection ittml p_ __. C '1 . Room 7&7 92_. , 

- -- --From: Sal-1: -La-I;-e~-C-it-y!" b2 -1

 - Q3. E - B '8 RA 2 _ / ' ' I _ ' Contact: SA f i I

b6 ~1 ' . ' E 7 9 l The Boise HA ls a W? -1 APP°"°d BYDEUJ _ e  ' r J um: Hmadmtlmlm: mall once

I=raf=e=1BY= l:|='dek an  92 Case ID #= 29'7HQ-Al32'?669.-A &#

. "

Title: Counterterrorism Division,

". GTMO, '

' . - Inspection Specia-1 Inquiry .

Synopsis: Provide negative response to abuse inquiry. -

Details: Special Agent! _, I Salt Lake City, 92 '

-Boise RA, served a 45-day TDY as an interrogator/interviewer '

during the period March 3, 2003, to April 17, 2003. Actual days at GTMO, were March 4  April 16, 2-003. March 3 and April 17 were }k:§;C:l

travel days between Boise, Idaho and Ft. Lauderdale, Florida. During this TDY period, SA_ did not observe any .

aggressive. treatment, interroga ions or interview techniques on

GTMO detainees which was ot c nsistent with Bureau interview 92 policy/guidelinesf SA would have reported such -

treatment immediately had _she observed it. - __ _

' The detainees interviewed by SA and her be -1

various _CI'IF Criminal Investigation Task: Force partners were -1:11: -1

asked if they had any complaints about their treatment. The

complaints that were made concerned lack of mail/delay in mail,

dental appointments not being made, not being allowed to grow

their hair/beards to desired length, etc. The complaints

concerning mail and dental appointments were followed up on by

the investigators. ' '

I

a

n!
 C { " _ - _ _

. &0: Inspection ggig: Salt Lake City Z!

Re: 297-I-IQAl327659A, 0'?/19/2004

LEAD B!:

Set Lead 1: Action!

' IN§PECTIQN

AT WASHINGIQE, QC

Read and Clear.

n 

2

RESPONSES-252
_ -

Response H

1|

r

1
it ____ 7 7_ _ _ . _

be -1 [see _ ;| lHsDHFB.I! 'i _ Z. '  ' "

iii _ -7*» '* 7"" irgiiw-q n whrq 7" '_iW'_""-_ 7* 7 i " 7 in Viivi 7". Fri 7' W7*' " " ' T "' 'i7*7"**:' fa '1' .

 _5ubject: RE: GT_MOlnspection Special inquiry . - I __ _ I _ _

_ QK thanl<sL i~iad'a couple ofthe same 'resporisesi,ob_servationst i do not beieive it ts the criteria of the inquiry, so

- we will consider it anegative response. Thanksagain. "__  .

_ - _ ---'-ifJri'?'inalMessa?e-:-- _- " " '

, _From. [CG![FBI! - gcfl Ser|t:Tuesi:la Jul 13 2ou4'2;17 PM ' 1

. . To: zi~iso! FB1!

'- ., Cc: . -BI! , .- ~_

Subject: GT M0 nspection Special -Inquiry

' I S NSITN UT 

_RECQ_BQ.29I-HQ-A13ZT_669 . - i ;_ 1 I _

__| did HQIIOUSEFVB any physically aggressive treatment of GTMO detainees but, as the email-was '-

92 ' written requestingiomnation regarding the observation oi "aggressive'treatment, interrogations or"

_ interview techniques dn GTMO detainees which was not consistent with Bureau interview -_ .- - -

' - policy-iguideiines" . I willinclude the following obsewations andiallow the inspeotion Division to dete_rrnine_if

it falls under the desired criteria: ' __ ._ -_ - ' - " .- .5 _

- A detaineelwas led into an iterview roorn by hooded MPs. The dtainee was also hooded and the hood -'

was _|'B'i11OVEi.T by the MP5 for theinterview. This procedure-was not under ourtdireotion. This happened on

two occasions. ' ' '» ; ' ' I 1'-" _ -_ , "

__ In an interview trailer, i observed an interviewroorn with ashing lights and loud rock music coming through

'onlyon§:e._; I - ' _" "' " ' ' . . -. _. -,

' 7 An EC wiii. follow reporting the above. - ,

_ - -- -_ - - ' _- D6 -1

~ i $Al:| --»w<: -1

' __cT-1- _- _ _ . . - "

I _ ' T ' - __sEi~is|TivE _BU;-U_N§_LASSIEi§Q - _

_ ' h '.RESPONSES253

-. . w14:2o04 __ ; _

' and under a door. I didnot observe anyindividuals inside as the solid oor was closed. I observed this - '
J

Response I
, i it F |i*~*"@F>>rFBi> K t __ K i 156 1 ll Front LA! FB|!.l ' . '" "

C 1 . Sent: Wednesday, .Ju|§1-1', 2'00-41:2? r5M- -

_

i I::i~~e>e-> f Si._|b_iect:GTl'MO' _ -. .

~ _SEIilSITE*BUT_LJ|'iiCLASSlFiED '

-- QQN-B§CORD . ~ . - .

b61 - ';

- = I eawj one inter.view_where the detainee was interviewed while sitting on the oor. The foiiowing _mqming ' » -

during theail handsbrieng there was direction given on the proper treatment of detainees during an interview. '| - '

. qnly assume this dieeussion was e_ result of the detainee beirig interyiew white sitting on the oor.- ' _ - . _.

' ': Any further qniestion orcornmente please coritact the @ direot line. L bi -1 ' - - 

.- SENSIIIYEBUT UNCLAS§lF|ElQ;

"92-

.. - - _ t _ _ RESPONSES254 .,

' 1r14i2oo4'- - " - - - r -_ ; -

*7 ' ' "i'ii*
Response J

i'
Message - " '. _ " _ " ' I ' _ Page l|_of"3

p

° e ll:I<P><=<FlB'I>l I ~

Subject: RE: GTMO. _- ' ' _ _

I wl classify that as a negative. Thanks fer_ the rsponse.

_ Sent: Wednesda%' Jul? 14, ZUO4 1Z:23'AM" _.

--¥0rl' inai Mes e-'--- _- _ _

==~=~=h<P><»<e:> L

b _1 To: INSD!- FBI!_

Subject: RE: GTMO - '

. ._ _ ._'_ I ,. ' 92 _  -_ ._ . -

O11 one morning my parmer em OSI went hio the ohsetfvatibn roem_ accross the hallfrom our -'

interogation roomto get a chaii. While in the'r'e he called me in. In-_ one of the ether mte1-og_ati'on .

.,_ I

reotns was detainee sittirig in e chair alone in the 1_'o_0n:|. -The g1 assI2.way mirror wasvery waim '

to the touch, as -if the room teII;p.__wa.s92 theinterfiogatibn room-._ The-detainee appeered to -be

s1eepingit1thechai1'.' i ' _  -1 - __ ' I .

The next day vathilen getting achair irt the bserttatieij teem I ebserved'wha't appeared to be the

same detainee the san1e'i'oom-.. The window felt very cool that-moming, as if the room temp.

was low. Again the detainee was aloneattd appearedtc be sleeping in the ro'om.- ' _ ' '- _

I do not kpe-w _wl{at'lSN number the detainee I.1OI"'_92_PV-hi! hadthe detainee in-the roont. I_clid_not

go -into he interogaen roan; and do_n_'t1c;1~;>w how the ream felt._' ' 3' . _' - -. - - ' _

Aer making tl1ese'ohserva0ns we left ithe 0bsem1ttion_re0m and subseqtiently conducted bur _'

inter~rie}r_facross-.thehall._- '_ ' ' '  -' . '

I wouldeppreeiate any-input you.'.l:'1ave _regardiiig_ these obse1_vat1'0ns." .

_ = -_---O'ina.1'Messa -=--" _ " . t, _

b _ eFroa?ht<n<sD> re-1: L

Sent: Tue'Hl3l2D04-7:41 AM . -_ "

' T°=I::|lPX1rFBI> . .-

7 Cc: ' - : , "

Subject: RE: _GTMO _ -

' -UNCLASSIEJED . F

_ u;uaec;uu- f'-- .- _ -l; _ . _-. l _ . -

b __ - - If youlceuld just provide-rhelan emailtwith a short syhopsis of what you observed and we will- . mhe a'determina1:'on of whether it should he classted as rrhstreatnwent Thanks. -

b _1' - ' -'-----Ori ina|Messa l-1-'" - -. - ' _ ' b -t LF1-»=h<1=><><FB1> 1 .

' .  ' '. '= . ' -RESPONSESZ55

m4r2004 '" ' . " -' " _:'

W _ __ _ _ . +~.
Message

sol V

b6 -1 '

b7C -1 '

s h  h l .:.~Pae='~*-<=.w

Sent:92'lu_esda jut 13 2Dt'J412:48 AM u - To: INSD! FBI! Sub : . '_ _ - .

Import:ance:High-_ - . - .

' While at GTMO I observed something that may or 'may_:'not be -consistent with our

policy because my infcnnation is very l.i1iu'ted_-'-I would like to discuss this to - 

- determine how I-should r'espon'd. I-_am c11rrej;itly'I-DY in Isianiabad, Pakistan until

V2.1 end-.wi1l return to the office in Phoenix Division, Tucson RA on W26. . _

- .- , " 'YOILIliIl3YC011I$.Ci8_ii.lIiilB.ISi.8J1121iJ3.Ci Le attbv e-mail or wheuifetum to Tucson ,_ - ' b2 __1-. ~Maynun1ber,inTucson_is '" 3 - .. g __ __

._b6 -1

b?c ~1

_ m4g2@04 ,

- Thanks, ' i 1' -

' . ---Olig;inalI92fIessage---- _' _ -' " ,, . - _ . - -- . _ .

_ From: MCCRAW, STEVEN C. LINED! FBIJL ' __ _- "- ' . '_ . ' -

Sen:F?i'i ' -- - 7 " ' ' " estiiiiieeieta i a

' Subject:GWU_'.-' _' ' i ' .

SENSITIVE BUl_UNClugSS'IFiE_E.g_ -

_ . -- _, 1 _. , _. _

i You have been identied as having conducted an essignrn_er'it at C-§|'IvlO,' Cuba since '

-. _ 9t1i,1U1. The inspection Division has been tasked with co_r_"|t_acting thoseernployees ' _

. who have served in any capacity at GTMO and'o_btaininforn1ation regarding the

treatment of detainees.gmploveesshould immediately; respond to the toilmving : -

'1! Employees _who observed aggressive treatment, interrogations or interview '

- teehniques on GTMO detainees which was not consistent with Bureau intervi_ew_ -

~. polieyiguidelinesi, hould respond viaernaitfor the purpose ofatoilow-up 'iriter_view_:_

- _ Positive ernail responses should be directed to:-' - . - -~ 5 L

' . ' ' . _ . . - ~ - b6 -J. -'

_ _ _ _ inspection Division . ' .1 I - .

; .

t -2! Employees whoserved at GTMO-and observed no aggressive treatment of '

' detainees. should-respond via an'EC documenting a negative response. The EC - -

. shuld ineiude the employee's oiciai Bureau name. title. andtenure of assignment at '

'G.TMO._ , __ _ . -_ _ -

- - The EC should betitled "Quuntenerronsni Divlision} GTMO. Inspection Soecial _" I

'" |nqui|'y",- - . '- - - H-I ' - . _ -1 . . ..

I -il|B # 29?-HQ-A312-17559-A. The EC Shlitlid FIOI b¬'UD|OEdEd. iJl.li only §EliE|iZBd, -|'ii'E. '

. hard copy idniizarded to: '  .. ' ' t - - ' - _

' ' ' inspection Division ' _ _,

. _ - - Ofce of Ins ectionls ' " ';

Rizsponsas-25's. t ] _-P -1

_ 14!
Messagej. '- '. - " Pa_gc.3o

' ' Room 7'83?" '.

SENS-ITE!E.BUl 1.1§i=A§SlFlED_ . ' - - , . H

I

'_ - ' RESPONSES-2_57_.

m4r2004'.- '- _ _ _

_ in
[ 

l .

Response K
b6 ~1

b7C -1

bl -.

151 .-

.MBSS&ge.__*_* % 7.  ? Page _1C;f1"f l . __ Ml..Eh;e:.E;.|._ilE...._!.__.-.} _ _ -I .

Prl5_'_,=_~3=¢11>><FB'>e 1 , Y I-|1

Sent: '|=neey;'Ju|yo_e,20043159-PM - . ' ' _' - -

Te |:|<1~S@> FEW eeef . l -

Subject: GTMO aeeignment -- . '- I - u _' ' - . ' " . PEA'$°.lT;57§1'-§4'?§l-l§- - -

" r -- l " * . = likeii2i.iiIefi.:t*§-§éE=f%'f§eie.I. - -

-QNGLASSIF-IED _- - - _ : ~ . . ~- " . _ _

Non-gggoen - - ~ . - " ' . l5? L

1 was assigned to GTM p _?!2_3 - 8122102. While 1 einer observe eny elielreetmen-

detainees and did not pa c|pa e Inany If} ewiews, I did become aware that the interview rooms were kept pretty '

coldand that interviewees were kept in'those rcerns for extended perlods oftime. _ ' ' 

, if . 7 _i - N _ __ I

Additienallyl 7 __ _ ne detainee wast-cept

in the cell in |so|'¬on for an extended per1od3f'Tin'|e, 1-ilnli up to Slays. -' . -' ' -

Are these considered violationsff'Bureau interview,poiicylguidelines? ' - _ I,

e - ' r ;- .-

' .

" . - -"

?§iiIm§unIE:RIii;I 512? ' '

_ _

:

" L  l i t V l L . Jaeseonses-zse l

_m_2/2004'. - - - "- - . - . _.
Response L
b6 ~i

b7C -1

b6 1

b7C -1

' ' - ' > , .

Message; _- I l __-V}-I-agg

_ 92- - - _

' From;-L V 1 _ *[s|::-! r=e|! '- -- _- -

Sent: TuesdaJul 13 2004 :24PM ' _- _ _ -

" 5ubje¢t m'garding GTMO treatment ofDetainees Forthcoming fromLJC ' -'

.LLlilQ.LA§5.l.E|§Q. -

NON-RECORD

-'Hei'IoMrl:|" '_ '.' " _ H" - f

Per email instructionsfromStevenC.McCraw,-Iarnsendingthisemailtoyoptoadvise-Iwibesubmittingan _

email-anddid_n0t'personaily obsenreaggressive treatment ofdeiainees. ' - - '" _

I--arln ewarehowever, thatcletalinees couldbeidentied tobeniacedon a Iiet-for a speriicinterrbgaticrt '

techn-iqué-involving interruptionofsleeppattern,-callledfrequent yerprograrri. I was,TOYto QTMO 91.1103.

1rough11-!11J03._ " ._ . _ -' __ I '_ _ _, _ ' ' -- 1_

- " ' _-b6 1

" nitC |e - - -' _ -

SAAPU ' ' I I-' '

iggat t

. _ '1_ 1

_.,,

| L

I-.

~

" _RE$PONSES-259'

?ri4r2n04 ' . - -
i - I

.  e - ."r Rev. 01-3l-1003! ® . =

1.

I

b6 -1

me -

92|

FEDERAL BUREQU OF INVESTIGATION

Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 7*./15/2004 _

To! Inspection Division Attn: . b6 -1

" _ Office pections blc-J

' ' ; Room 37 _

From: Administrative Services

' SAAPU, Room 10130 ' "

Contac:t.| ii '_ I Z--' J.  I Ll: _

Approved By:l f ' kid}? _ '

E JM51 t

Case ID #=_ 297-HQ-A132'7669A

Drafted. By: | p _

Tit1e:' COUNTERTERRORISM DIVISION, GTMO,

INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY

FOR SPECIAL AGENT SA! APPLIC}NTS' ' .

Synopsis: Report of negative observation of aggressive treatment,

interrogations or interview techniques on GTMO detainees. _

Details: This EC is in response to email of July 9, 2004 from

Steven C. McCraw to all individuals identified as having

conducted an assignment at GTMO, Cuba since 09/11/2001. _

I was on TDY assignment to GTMO, Cuba for the.Military

Detainee-Liaison Unit IMDLU! from September 1, 2U03.through .

November ll, 2003. During this time frame I was assigned to

participate in interviews-of the detainees being held at GTMO.

During my assignment I did not observe any aggressive treatment

or aggressive interrogation or interview techniques of detainees

at GTMO.

During my assignment at GTMO.I received a briefing from

the military personnel aseigned_to operations at GTMO, that noncooperative detainees could be placed on a list for a specific

interrogation.technique involving interruption of sleep pattern,

called the "frequent flyer program." With this particular- ' , .

technique, identified detainees were moved frequently from cell

block to cell block at intervals that appeared to be every hour

or every two hours depending on the_shifts and availability-of _

military pereonnel to move the detainee. Detainees were moved

along with all of their personal belongings. Due to the movement

RES PONSES-260

"""""' 7* $?
I ~ To:fnspection DivieionFrom:Administrativg;Services

Re: 297-HQA1327669-A, 07/15/2004 - '

-

_ to different cells the detainees had their sleep interrupted

throughout a 24 hour period. "The duration of the program for

particular detainees seemed to depend on the,cooperativeness of

the detainee. I did not participate in this program and do not _

know of any participation of FBI personnel in recommending

detainees to this program. I did observe on the detaineemovement-databaee,-some-detainees were on the movement-records,

moving approximately every hour or every two hours.'I do not

recall the names of these detainees. ' '

1

9

2 . _

RESPONSES-261
. : _ _ _ ""92

- . J , _ To: Inspection Didieion From: Administrativgggervicee  Re: 297HQ~Al327669<A, O7/15/2004 _

LEAD{s!: 

Set Lead 1: Info!

£1!-?1"1I1ET,I5Te13£¥T1,*92"E ,§ERi

AT AGENT PRQCES5ING, no

- For information only.

Set Lead 2: Action!

INSPECTION DIVISION -

' Bring the information in this communication to the

attention of appropriate personnel. _ '_

Q9

. 3

' ' RESPONSES-262