11/30/201 1 14:0 3 FA X 2024935U 2 FA A DM S 0001/00 4

V S . DEFARTMFN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA LAVIATIO NADMINISTRATIO N FNTHEMArrHROF : N U FASHIO NBEAUT Y SUPPL Y

DIS'IKIRTJTORS FA A Cas e No. ; 2011CF70002 3

N U FASHIO NBEAUT Y SUPPL Y DISTIBUTORS ' ANSWE R Come s no w N u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributors , b y counse l W . Bevi s Schock , an d state s for it s Answer 1 . \ .

J . 4 .

1 . Admitted . Admitted . Admitted . Admitted .

b . c . d . c . 

## t Admitted . Admitted . Admiued . Admiued . Admitted . Admitted .

a . Admitted . I

T l ---,•••'. 5



## " D FiQL^ C 3

11 1 

# RECEIVE D HEARIN G DOCKE T11/30/201 1 140 3 FA X 202493514 2 FA A- DM S 0002/00 4

Admitted . c . i - Admitted . ii . AdmiUiid . iii - Admitted . iv . Admitted . V . (Omitte db y Complainant ) vi . Admiued . vii . Admitted , d . Admiued . c . Admitted . f Admiuocl . g . Admitted . 2 . Admitted . 3 . Denied . iSr U FASHIO NBEAUT Y SUPPL Y DISTRIBUTOR S .ADDITIONA LFACT S 1 . I'h e entir e situatio nwa- s aresul t o f aninnocen t

mistake . N u Fashio nBeaui y Suppl y Distributo r

di^tribute. s beaut y product s i nth e St . Louis , Missour i area . N u Fashio n BeauT> ' Suppl y Distributo r receive ddefectiv e hairspra y fromaCanadia nmanufacture r an dcalle dth e manufacture r t o complain . Th e manufacture r aske dN u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributo r

t o retur non e bo x o f

produc t s o th e manufacture r

coul dinvestigat e th e problem . K u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributo r boxe du p th e produc t

for shipmen t

bac k t o Canad ab y air . N u Fashio nBeaui y Suppl y Distributor' s worke r ha dt o as k

th e UP S11/30/201 1 1 4 0 3 FAX 202493514 2 FA A- DMS @]003/00 4

drive r ho w t o fil l ou t

th e form s for

aCanadia nair

shipment . A t

th e airpor t

aUP S worke r hear dth e can s rattlin g togethe r an dstoppe dth e shipment . 2 . Nu Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributor s ha s neve r shippe daeroso l can s before , becaus e N u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributor s almos t alway s receive s shipment s o f beaut y supplies , an donl y i nthi s cas e ha dt o shi p defectiv e produc t bac k t o adistributor . 3 . N u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributo r i s unlikel y eve r

agai nt o shi p aeroso l can s b y an y mean. s bu t

truc k t o it s customers . 4 . N u Fashio nBeaui y Suppl y Distributo r i s a'^niall business . 5 . Th e aeroso l can s neve r mad e i t o nanairplane , (du e t o goo dwor k b y aUP S worker) . 6 . Th e entir e shipmen t wa s abo x o f

hairspra y - - aproduc t

designe dt o b e spraye da t th e user' s head . 7 . N u Fashio nBeaui y Suppl y Distributo r ha s take nthi s situatio nvco ' seriously , an d managemen t

i s ^.villin g t o underg o reasonabl e trainin g t o ensur e n o future violation . 8 . I f 5100,00 0 i s anappropriat e fin e for asituatio nresultinf

i i ndeath , seriou s illnes s o r sever e injury- t o aperson , thi s situatio ni s abou t 1 % a s seriou s a s that , an ds o a.^1,000.0 0 tm e woul db e appropriate . 9 . $15,000.00 , th e amoun t requeste db y th e Agenc y i s anamoun t o f penalt y ou t

o f proportio nt o th e facts. 10 . N u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributo r value s safct} ' o naiiplane. s a. s muc ha s an y san e American , an dha dn o inten t t o endange r

th e publi c o r

anyon e else . 11 . N u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributo r recognize s no w that

aeroso l product s ar e dangerou s an dshoul dno t b e o nairplanes . 12 . $1000.0 0 i s areasonabl e penall y unde r th e circumstances .11/30/201 1 14:0 3 FAX 202493514 2 FA A- QM S g]004/00 4

WHHKt-FORE , N u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributor s pray s tha t th e Administrativ e La w Judg e orde r

asses s acivi l penalt y o f $1,000 . Respeetfull y Submitted .



# - f\ ! m\v ^---x ^ Wr^Bevi.' = ScWock ! MBE' #3255 1 ^ Attorne y forN u Fashio nBeaut y Suppl y Distributor s 777 7 Bonhomm e Ave. , Stc . 130 0 St . Louis , M O 6310 5 wb:;chock@.schocklaw.co m Fa.\ : 314-72l-l69 » Voice : 314-726-232 2 CmTlFICAT EO FSERVIC L Th e undersigne dcertifie s tha t o nW.JZ ^ /^ /

, 201 1 (s)h e .serve dthi s documen t on : A . Leste r Haizli p Gayl e E . To"wnsen d Offic e o f Regiona l Counse l 90 1 Locust . Roo m50 6 Kansa s City , M O 6410 6 Federa l Aviatio nAdministratio n 80 0 Independenc e Ave. , S W Washington , D.C . 2059 1 Attn : Hearin g Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t BpiMing , Ste . 2W100 0 Th e metho do f

servic e was : han dde l ivory/regula r maUirouricr/l'edLx/e-mail/fax . I f fax , th e tim e wa s a.m./p.m. , an dth e nunibcffaxe dwa s