@UnitedDepartment States AgricultiJre of Use of Sulfometuron in Hybrid

Forest Service _ Poplar Energy Plantations

North Central

Forest Experiment

Station Daniel A. Netzer

Research Note RN-NC-366

.

1995

ABSTRACT.---Reports that low rates of to methods that might be used in commercial

sulfometuron, 70 grams per hectare (1 ounce tending operations. Sulfometuron was applied

product or 0.75 ounces active ingredient per in the fall to a planting near Howard _e, MN,

acre), applied when hybrid poplars are com- and in the spring to plantings at Milaca, MN,

pletely dormant, can provide season-long weed and Mondovi and Harshaw, WI. At each of the

control and increase hybrid poplar growth. If four sites, height growth measurements were

plantation access is not possible before growth made in the growing season after herbicide

activity begins in the spring, late fall applica- application along with weed control and tree

tion of this herbicide may be best. damage observations. Herbicide rates and

clones were replicated in some, but not all

KEY WORDS: Intensive culture, weed control, trials. Spray date was confounded by location.

herbicide, short rotation, biomass, dormant All plantations were established using

season, unrooted hardwood cuttings.

Howard Lake: I-Year-Old Plantation,

Short-rotation intensive culture (SRIC) of Sulfometuron Applied in Fall

hybrid poplar uses an agronomic system of

plantation establishment similar to row crops A 12.3-meter-wide strip was sprayed with

such as corn and soybeans (Hansen et al. sulfometuron across a 48.5-hectare 1-year-old

1983). Control of competing weeds is critical hybrid poplar plantation near Howard Lake,

in establishing successful plantations. One MN, on October 23, 1987. Each of three

way of controlling weeds is by applying herbi- herbicide rates---70, 140, and 210 grams per

cldes, but few, ff any, herbicides are known to hectare (1, 2, and 3 ounces product or 0.75,

provide season-long weed control without 1.50, 2.25 ounces active ingredients per

damaginghybrid poplars (Netzer and Noste acre)--was applied to a 4-meter-wide section of

1978). Sulfometuron (Oust l) is a promising spray strip. A sprayer with an adjustable

candidate to fill this gap (Netzer 1986). I boom set 1.2 meters above the ground was

conductedstudies to determine if low rates of used to apply the chemical. The plantation

sulfometuron applied at the proper time of the consisted of clonal blocks of 11 hybrid poplar

year can Control competition without damag- clones (table 1), all of which appeared to be

ing hybrid poplars, completely dormant at the time of spraying.

Weeds were controlled before herbicide appliMETHODS AND RESULTS cation by discing, allowing the chemical to be

applied directly to bare ground.

Spring and fall applications of sulfometuron

were Compared in four trials in existing hybrid During 1987 and 1988 a record drought

poplar plantations in Wisconsin and Minne- occurred throughout the region (National

sota. A single application was made to each Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

plantation without shielding the trees, similar 1987, 1988). Control plots adjacent to the test

strips were disced once during the 1988

growing season and mowed once because the

Daniel A. Netzer is a Forester with the North

' Central Forest Experiment Station, _ Mention of trade names does not constitute

Rhinelander, Wisconsin. endorsement of products by the USDA Forest Service.
. Table 1.---Hybrid poplar clones tested for tolerance ofsulfometuron in Minnesota

and WLsconsln

Clone Parentage ' Site* i i

DN1 P. deltoidesx euramericana HowardLake,Harshaw

DN34 P. deltoides x euramericana(Carolina) HowardLake,Harshaw

DN164 P. deltoidesx euramericana Harshaw

DN182 P. deltoidesx euramericana HowardLake

NC5260 P. tristis x P. balsamifera HowardLake

NE41 P. maximowiczii x P. trichocarpa HowardLake

NE47 P. maximowiczii x P. berolinensis HowardLake

NE54 P. candicansx P. berolinensis HowardLake, Milaca

NE299 P. betulifolia x P. trichocarpa HowardLake

NE308 P. charkowiensis x P. incrassata HowardLake

NE387 P. candicans x P. berolinensis HowardLake

*Only I of the 45 hybrid poplar clones in the Mondovi, Wisconsin, plantation was exposed to more than two herbicide treatments, so all clones were combined for analysis.

parched soil could not be effectively disced. At _

180

theend of the year, weeds covered 90 percent 170 l-average growth - _

_160

of the area in the control plots, 41 percent in f1150_ =fastgrowers

the 70 gram per hectare plot, and 27 percent _40_30_=_lowg_ow_

inp both the 140 and 225 grams per hectare _i_- lots. The major components of the weed b

cover consisted of yellow foxtafl (Setar/a _

/utescens (Weigel)) and thistle (Cirsitun spp.). _ _

50

Height growth for the 1988 season, the year _ 403o

after herbicide application, was significantly 20

greater for all 11 hybrid poplar clones at all 100

0 52.5 (0.75) 105 (1.5) 157(2.25)

suffometuron rates compared to the control Rateof sulfometuroningramsactiveingredientperhectare(ouncesa/iperacre)

(fig. 1). Growth was greatest at the 70 gram Bars withthe same letter arenotsignificantlydifferent.

per hectare (1 ounce per acre) rate and decreased as the herbicide rate increased. The Figure l.--Average height growth of 11 hybrid

increase in growth rate was greater for four poplar clones after fall application of

faster growing clones than for six slower sulfometuron compared to that of slower and

growing clones (fig. I). faster growing clones of the group.

Milaca: 3-Year-Old Plantation, (7 gallons water per acre). No effort was made

Sulfometuron Applied in Spring to shield the trees from herbicide spray. Tree

growth in rows where herbicide was applied

A 3-year-old plantation near Milaca, MN, of a was compared with that in two rows that were

single hybrid poplar clone, NE54, was sprayed kept weed free by periodic discing. Buffer rows

April 24, 1992. Two single rows of trees were were left between each treatment. Although it

sprayed On both sides with sulfometuron at was late April, we could see no growth activity

140 grams per hectare (2 ounces per acre) on the hybrid poplars.

applied with a sprayer pulled by an all-terrain

vehicle (ATV) at a boom height of 0.5 meters There was no significant difference between the

above the ground. The chemical was applied sulfometuron rows and the disced rows in

with fiat fan nozzles in 65.5 liters per hectare height growth or diameter breast height (d.b.h.)

2
duringthe 1992 growing season (fig. 2). The because the original design of the plantation

height growth was 81 centimeters in the allowed for only one clone to receive more than

sprayed plots and 73 centimeters in the disced two treatments.

plots. However, the tree diameters in the disc

rows averaged 13.2 centimeters compared to In late June light to moderate damage to the

11.7 centimeters in the sprayed rows. Discing tree leaves was observed at both rates of

was needed twice during the 1992 growing sulfometuron. Weed control was nearly 100

•season. Rainfall was normal for the year. percent for the entire growing season in all

Observations of weed control in October 1992 herbicide-treated plots. Weeds completely

showed excellent season-long control in both covered the control plot, growing to heights of

the sulfometuron treated areas and the disced I to 1.2 meters and overtopping many of the

areas. Less than 5 percent of the ground was smaller trees. Deer seemed attracted to the

covered with weeds in both.treatments after open areas created by the herbicide applicaonecomplete growing season, tions; subsequent browsing ranged from 50

percent of the trees in the 140 grams per

hectare plots to less than 10 percent in the

9o [ Heightg_h control plots (fig. 3). Bud damage and result80 ant multi-branching occurred from the deer

70 browsing as expected, but additional bud

damage and multi-branching appeared to be _-60

_ the result of herbicide damage

50

*" 60

._ 3o DBH

. 20

10 ,_ 50

._ 40-

0 ¢_ b

sulfometuron discing sulfometuron discing 105 (1_,5) " 105 (1,_)

Rate of sulfometuron in grams active ingredient per hectare(ounces a/i per acre) "6 30 -

Figure 2.--One-year height growth and diam- _ 2o

eter breast height (DBH) of 3-year-old hybrid _,

poplar clone NE54 after spring application of _osulfometuron or dtsciru3.

o

0 52.5(0.75) 105 (1__)

_Rateof suifometuron in grams active !ngredient per hectare(ounces a/i per acre)

Mondovi: 1-Year-Old Planting, _ars with the same letter are not signiticantly different.

Sulfometuron Applied in Spring

Figure 3.--Percentage of 1-year-old hybrid

A l-year_old hybrid poplar clonal trial near poplar browsed by deer ajar application of

Mondovi, WI, containing 16-tree unreplicated three rates of sulfometuron.

plots of 45 clones, was treated with sulfometur0n at 70 and 140 grams per hectare (1, 2 Single-stemmed trees showed a slight increase

ouhces per acre) April 24, 199 I. "IXvorows in growth at the 70 gram rate and a significant

each were treated with 70 and 140 grams per decrease in growth at the 140 gram rate (fig. 4).

hectare and two rows were unsprayed con- Only one clone, NE 154, was located in both

trols. This six-row test was replicated three herbicide treatments and the control. This

times across the planting. Herbicide was clone showed a decrease in growth at both

applied directly over the tree rows with a boom sulfometuron rates compared to the unsprayed

sprayer pulled by an ATV with the spray boom control. In late October 100 percent of the

set at a constant height of 0.9 meter. The ground was weed covered in the controls, 51.6

trees showed some signs of growth initiation at percent was weed covered in the 70 gram per

the time of treatment; buds were swollen, but hectare areas, and only 5 percent of the ground

leaf tips had not yet extended from the buds. was weed covered in the 140 gram per hectare

All clones were clumped togethfr for analysis rate plots. Normal to above normal rainfall
" --a

. ..... [ a 160 -

180 a -] 150

170 I

160 _ _ 140

150 b _ 130 b

140 _ 120 b

130 _ II0

120 O 100

10090 _ 80

.,_ 80 _7o60

•_ 70 _ 50 6o

40 50

41) 30

"30 20

2{) 10

10 0

0 Disc Control suifometuron sulfometuron

0 52.5(0.75) 105 (1.5) 52.5 (0.75) 105 (1.5)

Rate of sulfometuron in grams active ingredient per hectare(ounces a/i per acre) Ra_ of sulf9meturonin grams active ingredient

Bars with the same letter are not significantly different per hectare(ounces an per acre)

J

Figure 4.--Height growth of 1-year-old hybrid Figure 5.--Average height growth of 1-year-old

poplar after late spring broo_cast appl_at_n hybrid poplar dories DN1, DN34, DN164,

of sulfometuroru after spring overspray with sulfometuroru

patterns occurred at Mondovi In 1991, provld- sulfometuron treatment, 2 percent for the.140

ing adequate moisture for trees in the weedy gram sulfometuron treatment, and 2 percent

control plots, for the disced area.

Harshaw: l-Year-Old Planting, DISCUSSION

•$_omet_on Applied in Spring

Height growth of I I hybrid poplar clones at

A l,year-old hybrid poplar plantation near Howard Lake Increased significantly during

Harshaw, WI, consisting ofthree hybrid poplar the second growing season (fig. 11. But appliclones, DN 1, DN34, DN 164, In pure clonal cation rates of more than 70 grams per hectblocks; was oversprayed on April 23, 199 I. are reduced tree height growth hn three of the

Sulfometuron was applied directly over the trials (figs. 1, 4, 5). It appears that damage

trees at rates of 70 and 140 grams per hectare occurs to trees that have begun any growth

(1, 2 ounces per acre) with a handheld boom activity even ff buds have not flushed, as seen

sprayer containing fiat fan nozzles. The tree at Harshaw. When treated in late fall, the

buds were more active than at Mondovi with same aged trees showed only a slight decrease

some green leaf tips extending from the buds. in growth as herbicide rate Increased at

Ineach of the 3 clones, I0 randomly located Howard Lake. However, tree growth increased

single-tree plots were treated per the 2 herbi- significantly in all sulfometuron-treated plots

cide rates and 10 plots were left as untreated when compared to control plots at Howard

controls. An area adjacent to the sprayed Lake. This may reflect the extreme effect of

piots was regularly dlsced throughout the the 1987-1988 drought on young hybrid

growlngseas0n and was compared to the other poplars. Mechanical weed control was ineffectest plots'even though it was not randomized tive because cultivators could not penetrate

within the rest of the test plots. In 1991 trees the dry soft. An herbicide would, in this case,

in the disced area grew significantly more in be the most effective way to control weeds.

height.than the .sulfometuron-treated plots The Howard Lake study was the only one of

and the controls (fig. 51. Height growth at the the four where sulfometuron was applied in

grams per hectare rate was signiflcanflv_-- the fall. It is possible that fall application after 140

iess than at the control and the 70 grams per complete tree dormancy has set in, but before

hectare rate. Weed control was significantly ground freeze up, may reduce, ff not comgreater in both sulfometuron treatments and pletely eliminate, tree growth damage the

the disc area compared to the control. The following year while still controlling weeds

control had weed cover averaging 86 percent throughout that growing season. Field condlcompared to 5 percent for the 70 gram tions are often drier in the fall than in the
early spring, making application of stflfo- CONCLUSIONS

meturon easier over dormant trees. In addition, fall application allows a longer time for the Low rates of sulfometuron, 70 grams per

herbicide to degrade and become less toxic to hectare (1 ounce product or 0.75 ounces active

the poplars, ingredient per acre), applied when hybrid

poplars are completely dormant, can provide

The hybrid poplar clones that have proven to be season-long control of weeds and increase

the best growers over a number of years hybrid poplar growth. Growth increases in

showed the greatest increase in growth with fall drought years or dry areas may be greater

herbicide application at Howard Ixtke (fig. 1). when weeds are controlled by herbicides

Tree size may have been important in that the rather than by mechanical cultivation. Trees 1

faster growing clones were larger than the year old and younger or smaller trees may be

slower growers at the time of herbicide applica- damaged during broadcast applications ff even

tion, thus exposing the smaller slower growers slight growth activity is just beginning for the

to more herbicide. Further evidence that tree season. A few weeds may escape sulfosize may be a factor in preventing herbicide meturon at low rates. Thistles seem most

damage was found at Mflaca where 3-year-old resistant to this herbicide and present the

trees treated in spring showed no growth greatest challenge to its use. Patches of thistle

reduction when compared to trees in plots may be controlled with directed sprays of

where standard discing was done to control contact herbicides like glyphosate. Late fall

weeds (fig. 2). The thicker bark and taller trees application of sulfometuron may be better

likely limited exposure to sulfometuron even than spring application if field access before

though the trees were not shielded from the early growth activity is a problem.

herbicide spray and it was near the time when

growth activlty is expected. Smaller trees LITERATURE CITED

exposed to complete coverage by the herbicide

spray are damaged if they are not completely Hansen, Edward; Moore, Lincoln; Netzer,

dormant, even at low sulfometuron rates. Daniel; et oL 1983. Establishing intenGreater than normal branchiness was noted in sively cultured hybrid poplar plantaa l-year-old hybrid poplar treated with tions for fuel and fiber. Gen. Tech. Rep.

sulfometuron at Mondovi, indicating possible NC-78. St. Paul, MN: U.S. Department of

herbicide damage. This type of damage has Agriculture, Forest Service, North Central

been noted in other plantings in Wisconsin by Forest Experiment Station. 24 p.

Michler (personal communication). Heavy deer

browsing of the Mondovi trees masked any National Oceanic and Atmospheric Adminisherbicide damage. Deer browse was heaviest tration. 1987, 1988. Minnesota annual

in the treated areas (fig. 3) possibly due to the summaries 1987, 1988. Ashevflle, NC:

easy access of these plots compared to the National Climatic Data Center. Vols. 93,94,

weedy controls. In commercial plantations Numbers 13,13.

larger acreages of hybrid poplar plantations

treated uniformly would likely eliminate this National Oceanic and Atmospheric Adminisdeer problem (Netzer 1984). tration. 1987, 1988. Wisconsin annual

summaries 1987, 1988. AsheviUe, NC"

Most weeds are controlled for the entire growing National Climatic Data Center. Vols. 92,93,

season by sulfometuron applied at the rates Numbers 13,13.

tested, even at the lowest rate of 70 grams per

hectare (1 ounce per acre) in these trials. A few Netzer, Daniel. 1984. Hybrid poplar plantagrasses can occasionally escape but are easily tions outgrow deer browsing effects. Res.

controlled by herbicides llke sethoxydim (Poast) Note NC-325. St. Paul, MN: U.S. Departduring the growing season. Thistle seems to ment of Agriculture, Forest Service, North

regularly escape control with sulfometuron and Central Forest Experiment Station. 3 p.

can cause severe problems when competing

with hybrid poplars. It can, however, be controlled by directed spray application of

glyphosate.

,

5
Netzer, Daniel. 1986. Effect of spring-applied sulfometuron and imazapyr on

newly planted tree seedlings in northern

Wisconsin. In: Proceed/ngs, North Central

weed control conference; 1986 December 2-

4; Milwaukee, WI. Champaign, IL:North

Central Weed Science Society, Inc: 115-117.

Netzer, Dan/el; Noste, Nonan. 1978. Herbicide

trials in intensively cultured Populus in

northern Wisconsin. Res. Note NC-235. St.

Paul, MN: U.S, Department of Agriculture,

Forest Service, North Central Forest Experiment Station. 4 p.

Pesticide PrecautionaryStatement

Thispublicationreportsresearchinvolvingpesticides.Itdoesnotcontainrecommendationsfortheiruse,nordoesitimplythatthe usesdiscussedhere have been

registered.Allusesof pesticidesmustbe registeredbyappropriateStateand/or

Federalagenciesbeforetheycanbe recommended.

CAUTION: Pesticidescan be injuriousto humans,domesticanimals,desirable

plants,andfishorotherwildlife--iftheyare nothandledorappliedproperly.Useall

pesticidesselectivelyandcarefully. Followrecommendedpracticesforthedisposal

of surpluspesticidesandpesticidecontainers.

O on recycled,recyclablepaper.

Printed

6