Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

Bark Coal

avg ppm avg ppm

avg 

ppm

% Difference 

from Bark

% Difference 

from Coal

avg 

ppm

% Difference 

from Bark

% Difference 

from Coal

avg 

ppm

% Difference 

from Bark

% Difference 

from Coal

avg 

ppm

% Difference 

from Bark

% Difference 

from Coal

avg 

ppm

% Difference 

from Bark

% 

Chlorine 59.48 465.73 360.6 506.2% -22.6% 236.4 297.5% -49.2% 607.2 920.9% 30.4% 758.8 1175.7% 62.9% 528 787.7% 

Nitrogen 0.35 1.25 0.6 77.1%Formaldehyde 4 359 8875.0%Arsenic 0.78 19.73 1.15 46.7% -94.2% 2.97 279.9% -84.9% 0.46 -41.2% -97.7% -- -- -- 4.75 507.6% 

Beryllium 0.02 1.55 0.21 1102.2% -86.7% 0.13 641.6% -91.8% 0.05 201.0% -96.7% -- -- --

Cadmium 0.14 0.07 0.38 164.4% 458.1% 0.92 546.1% 1263.9% 0.39 175.0% 480.4% 0.05 -63.1% -22.1% 0.90 532.5% Chromium 4.54 9.24 11.35 150.2% 22.8% 27.85 513.6% 201.2% 3.23 -28.9% -65.1% 0.31 -93.2% -96.7% 15.40 239.3% Lead 1.96 7.10 4.94 151.5% -30.4% 63.53 3134.7% 795.3% 8.34 324.8% 17.6% 0.22 -89.0% -96.9% 50.30 2461.2% 

Manganese 229.86 25.62 380.75 65.6% 1386.0% 430.36 87.2% 1579.5% 37.12 -83.9% 44.9% 67.43 -70.7% 163.1%

Nickel 3.85 13.45 23.08 499.7% 71.7% 17.82 363.0% 32.5% 1.52 -60.5% -88.7% 0.50 -87.0% -96.3% 4.20 9.1% 

Selenium 0.07 2.28 0.18 169.6% -92.3% 1.52 2218.1% -33.4% 0.44 572.6% -80.7% -- -- --

Mercury 0.01 0.09 0.040 407.0% -54.7% 0.008 -5.5% -91.6% 0.022 180.3% -75.0% 0.004 -53.4% -95.8% 0.073 816.2% 

WWT Residuals Dataset A TDF Dataset A Sander Dust w/Resin Dataset B OCC Rejects Dataset A Urban Wood (NYS
Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

Bark Coal

avg ppm avg ppm avg ppm

%

Difference 

from Bark

%

Difference 

from Coal avg ppm

%

Difference 

from Bark

%

Difference 

from Coal avg ppm

%

Difference 

from Bark

%

Difference 

from Coal avg ppm

%

Difference 

from Bark

%

Difference 

from Coal avg ppm

%

Difference 

from Bark

%

Difference 

from Coal avg ppm

Dif

fro

Chlorine 59.48 465.73 520.4 775.0% 11.7% 604.2 915.9% 29.7% 329.1 453.4% -29.3% 223.4 275.6% -52.0% -- -- -- 758.8 1

Formaldehyde 4 359 8

Arsenic 0.78 19.73 14.06 1697.8% -28.7% 0.63 -19.1% -96.8% 1.61 105.3% -91.9% 0.97 23.5% -95.1% <1.1 40.7% -94.4% -- Beryllium 0.02 1.55 0.15 744.9% -90.6% 0.22 1195.2% -85.6% 0.02 22.6% -98.6% 0.04 146.4% -97.3% <0.01 -41.7% -99.4% -- Cadmium 0.14 0.07 2.13 1395.4% 3056.6% 0.64 350.6% 851.3% 0.67 370.3% 892.8% 0.07 -49.2% 7.1% 0.10 -29.7% 48.4% 0.05 -Chromium 4.54 9.24 21.41 371.8% 131.6% 11.39 151.1% 23.3% 5.52 21.6% -40.3% 3.98 -12.2% -56.9% 0.09 -98.0% -99.0% 0.31 -

Lead 1.96 7.10 64.14 3166.2% 804.0% 9.10 363.3% 28.2% 38.44 1857.6% 441.8% 3.98 102.9% -43.8% <0.2 -89.8% -97.2% 0.22 -

Manganese 229.86 25.62 318.89 38.7% 1144.5% 218.71 -4.9% 753.6% 67.00 -70.9% 161.5% 39.54 -82.8% 54.3% 113.00 -50.8% 341.0% 67.43 -

Nickel 3.85 13.45 12.98 237.2% -3.5% 7.57 96.6% -43.7% 4.14 7.6% -69.2% 4.68 21.7% -65.2% 0.09 -97.7% -99.3% 0.50 -

Selenium 0.07 2.28 -- -- -- 0.61 829.6% -73.3% 4.14 6217.3% 81.4% 0.65 891.7% -71.5% <1.1 1578.2% -51.8% -- 

Mercury 0.01 0.09 0.316 3859.9% 253.7% 0.081 914.7% -9.4% 0.013 68.6% -84.9% 0.039 389.5% -56.3% 0.002 -78.7% -98.1% 0.004 -

Mixed Sludge Dataset B Primary Sludge Dataset B TDF Dataset B OCC Rejects Dataset B Panel Trim Dataset B Sander Dust 
11/22/2011 Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

No. of 

Samples 

No. of 

Samples 

Dates

No. of 

Samples 

Dates

HHV Btu/lb 94 9,010 2,270 5,800 -- -- -- Chlorine ppm 93 4,800 24.0 360.6 7 705 316.7 520.4 26 Arsenic ppm 77 6.00 0.00 1.15 7 38.23 1.63 14.06 28 Beryllium ppm 53 0.59 0.00 0.21 7 0.20 0.09 0.15 28 Cadmium ppm 82 1.60 0.00 0.38 7 4.73 0.35 2.13 28 Chromium ppm 84 44.0 2.00 11.35 7 35.47 7.44 21.41 28 Lead ppm 77 10.6 0.29 4.94 7 169.47 1.30 64.14 28 Manganese ppm 84 1,600 0.10 380.75 7 429.67 137.00 318.89 28 Nickel ppm 84 159 1.60 23.08 6 20.00 4.64 12.98 28 Selenium ppm 55 0.66 0.00 0.18 7 <1.1 <0.49 -- 28 8-Metals TotalMercury ppm 82 0.47 0.00 0.040 4 0.50 0.13 0.32 25 

Dataset A - IP fuel analysisDataset B - NCASI statistical analysis of boiler MACT Fuel data

TABLE A

Max Min Mean Max Min Mean 

NON-HAZARDOUS SECONDARY MATERIAL ANALYSIS

SLUDGE

WWT Residuals Dataset A Mixed Sludge Dataset B Pri

FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY

Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx
11/22/2011 Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

No. of 

Samples 

No. of 

Samples 

Dates

HHV Btu/lb 46 16,800 10,200 14,928 -- Chlorine ppm 46 630 40.0 236.4 30 434 Arsenic ppm 46 18.00 0.23 2.97 30 4.07 Beryllium ppm 11 0.39 0.00 0.13 20 0.05 Cadmium ppm 46 2.20 0.15 0.92 30 0.93 Chromium ppm 46 210 1.90 27.85 30 13.20 Lead ppm 46 250 2.40 63.53 30 57.46 Manganese ppm 45 1,800 11.00 430.4 30 220.00 Nickel ppm 46 120 1.80 17.82 30 8.97 Selenium ppm 19 6.30 0.00 1.52 30 8.97 Mercury ppm 32 0.026 0.0011 0.008 30 0.025 

Dataset A - IP fuel analysisDataset B - NCASI statistical analysis of boiler MACT Fuel data

TABLE B

Max Min Mean Max 

NON-HAZARDOUS SECONDARY MATERIAL ANALYSIS

TIRE DERIVED FUEL

FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY

TDF Dataset A TDF Datas

Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx
11/22/2011 Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

No. of 

Samples 

No. of 

Samples 

Dates

HHV Btu/lb 9 11,860 7,430 9,399 -- -- Chlorine ppm 9 2,073 45.0 607.2 14 393 Arsenic ppm 9 1.50 0.00 0.46 17 3.50 Beryllium ppm 6 0.06 0.05 0.05 12 0.06 Cadmium ppm 8 0.50 0.05 0.39 6 0.14 Chromium ppm 9 7 0.86 3.23 17 9.70 Lead ppm 9 20 0.66 8.34 17 12.17 Manganese ppm 9 56 23.00 37.1 17 59.13 Nickel ppm 9 4 0.36 1.52 17 13.77 Selenium ppm 7 0.50 0.09 0.44 17 2.20 Mercury ppm 9 0.046 0.0025 0.022 14 0.057 

Dataset A - IP fuel analysisDataset B - NCASI statistical analysis of boiler MACT Fuel data

TABLE C

NON-HAZARDOUS SECONDARY MATERIAL ANALYSIS

OCC REJECTS

FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY

OCC Rejects Dataset A OCC Rejects D

Max Min Mean Max 

Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx
11/22/2011 Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

No. of 

Samples 

No. of 

Samples 

Dates

HHV Btu/lb -- -- -- -- -- -- Chlorine ppm -- -- -- -- 10 2,600 Arsenic ppm 1 -- -- <1.1 10 <1.3 Beryllium ppm 1 -- -- <0.01 9 <0.50 Cadmium ppm 1 -- -- 0.10 5 0.09 Chromium ppm 1 -- -- 0.09 6 0.40 Lead ppm 1 -- -- <0.2 9 0.50 Manganese ppm 1 -- -- 113.0 10 160.00 Nickel ppm 1 -- -- 0.09 10 0.50 Selenium ppm 1 -- -- <1.1 10 <1.3 Mercury ppm 1 -- -- 0.002 9 0.004 

Dataset B - NCASI statistical analysis of boiler MACT Fuel data

TABLE D

NON-HAZARDOUS SECONDARY MATERIAL ANALYSIS

RESINATED WOOD

FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY

Panel Trim Dataset B Sander Dust w/Res

Max Min Mean Max 

Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx
11/22/2011 

No. of 

Samples 

HHV Btu/lb 4 8,244 7,620 7,984Nitrogen % 4 0.68 0.59 0.62Chlorine ppm 4 528Arsenic ppm 8 6 1 4.75Beryllium ppmCadmium ppm 8 1.6 0.38 0.90Chromium ppm 8 21.8 11.5 15.40Lead ppm 8 67.5 22.9 50.30Manganese ppmNickel ppm 8 5.12 3.2 4.20Selenium ppmMercury ppm 8 0.1 0.04 0.073

Dataset From NYSERDA study, as listed in NCASITechnical Bulletin 906

Max Min Mean

TABLE E

NON-HAZARDOUS SECONDARY MATERIAL ANALYSIS

URBAN (C&D) WOOD

FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY

Urban Wood (NYSERDA)

Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx
Forest Products NHSM data 6‐9‐11.xlsx 

Fuel BTU (BTU/lb) Hg (ppm) Cl (ppm) As (ppm) Be (ppm) Cd (ppm) Cr (ppm) Pb (ppm) Mn (ppm) Ni (ppm) 

Coal 12,371 0.089 466 19.73 1.55 0.07 9.24 7.10 26 13.45 Bark 7,756 0.008 59 0.78 0.02 0.14 4.54 1.96 230 3.85