UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

Miami Division

DECURTIS LLC,

Plaintiff,

v.

CARNIVAL CORPORATION,

Defendant.

 

Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA/Torres

CARNIVAL CORPORATION,

Plaintiff,

v.

DECURTIS CORPORATION and

DECURTIS LLC,

Defendants.

DEFENDANTS’ TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1 of 220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1 ACC_DCC00001 ACC_DCC00096 Trident Studio Audit2 Adams_CC_0021 Adams_CC_0026 Adam Leonards Portfolio3 ASSAABLOY0000001 ASSAABLOY0000012 Allure brochure4 ASSAABLOY0000013 ASSAABLOY0000031 Allure by Vingcard5 ASSAABLOY0000032 ASSAABLOY0000041 Allure: the Next Generation of Security and Sophistication6 ASSAABLOY0000042 ASSAABLOY0000089 Workforce Security and Access Solutions7 ASSAABLOY0000100 ASSAABLOY0000100 Allure Main Control Unit

1

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

8 ASSAABLOY0000101 ASSAABLOY0000102 Door Lock Communication Module9 ASSAABLOY0000103 ASSAABLOY0000103 Links related to Allure

10 ASSAABLOY0000104 ASSAABLOY0000106

Assa Abloy Press Release - VingCard Elsafe Introduces "Allure by VingCard" a Revolutionary "No-lock-on-thedoor" REID Hotel Locking Solution

11 ASSAABLOY0000107 ASSAABLOY0000126 Installation Instruction - Mobile Access Option12 ASSAABLOY0000131 ASSAABLOY0000159 SEOS Lock Bluetooth Profile13 ASSAABLOY0000288 ASSAABLOY0000418 Visionline User Manual14 ASSAABLOY0000419 ASSAABLOY0000426 Visionline by VingCard - Stay Connected, Go Online

2

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

15 ASSAABLOY0000427 ASSAABLOY0000431 HITEC show photos16 ASSAABLOY0000428 ASSAABLOY0000428 Image of booth17 ASSAABLOY0000429 ASSAABLOY0000429 Image of booth18 ASSAABLOY0000433 ASSAABLOY0000443 Salt Channel19 ASSAABLOY0000454 ASSAABLOY0000459 Project Trident - Project description20 ASSAABLOY0000460 ASSAABLOY0000476 Email from Gerald McMillan to Douglas Steele21 ASSAABLOY0000477 ASSAABLOY0000478 Email from from Jan Elfstrom to Robert Lawrence; Patrick Mendiuk; Peter Nilsson et al.

3

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

22 ASSAABLOY0000479 ASSAABLOY0000490 ASSA ABOLY - AAH Carnival Protocol Description23 ASSAABLOY0000505 ASSAABLOY0000506 Door Comm Unit Eng. Drawing24 ASSAABLOY0000507 ASSAABLOY0000508 Main Control Unit Eng. Drawing25 ASSAABLOY0000511 ASSAABLOY0000562 VingCard Allure User Manual26 ASSAABLOY0000579 ASSAABLOY0000603 R&D Software Confidential27 ASSAABLOY0000604 ASSAABLOY0000604 Door Lock Communication Module28 ASSAABLOY0000615 ASSAABLOY0000623 The ClientChannel Implementation

4

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

29 ASSAABLOY0000626 ASSAABLOY0000645 First Source Code Commit, Implemented Encrypted Channel (Symmetric Encryption)30 ASSAABLOY0000646 ASSAABLOY0000646 License impact31 ASSAABLOY0000658 ASSAABLOY0000663 ServerChannel, First Version32 ASSAABLOY0000665 ASSAABLOY0000665 Salt Channel Intro33 ASSAABLOY0000666 ASSAABLOY0000682 Seos Core - Technical White Paper34 ASSAABLOY0000696 ASSAABLOY0000793 Photos of the Alion Beach Hotel in Cyprus35 ASSAABLOY0000756 ASSAABLOY0000756 Image

5

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

36 ASSAABLOY0000783 ASSAABLOY0000783 Image37 ASSAABLOY0000784 ASSAABLOY0000784 Image38 ASSAABLOY0000811 ASSAABLOY0000814 Vingcard Elsafe's New Allure RFID Locking System Makes Global Debut at Luxury Alion Beach Hotel in Cyprus39 ASSAABLOY0000817 ASSAABLOY0000848 Assa Abloy Beyond In Room Security40 ASSAABLOY0000849 ASSAABLOY0000849 Allure orders41 ASSAABLOY0000851 ASSAABLOY0000854 VingCard Keycards42 ASSAABLOY0000855 ASSAABLOY0000859 Assa Abloy Hospitality Partners With Hotel News ME for Key Card Initiative At the Hotel Show 2016

6

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

43 ASSAABLOY0000954 ASSAABLOY0000955 Email from Robert Lawrence to Vince Ball; Patrick Mendiuk; Gerald McMillan et al.44 ASSAABLOY0000956 ASSAABLOY0000958 Email from Robert Lawrence to Vince Ball; Patrick Mendiuk; Gerald McMillan et al.45 ASSAABLOY0000959 ASSAABLOY0000961 Email from Robert Lawrence to Vince Ball; Patrick Mendiuk; Gerald McMillan et al.46 ASSAABLOY0000962 ASSAABLOY0000963 Email from Robert Lawrence to Vince Ball; Patrick Mendiuk; Gerald McMillan et al.47 ASSAABLOY0000964 ASSAABLOY0000965 Email from R. Lawrence to G. McMillan48 ASSAABLOY0000966 ASSAABLOY0000972 Email from Peter Nilsson to Robert Lawrence; Deven Bryant; Jeff Johnson et al.49 ASSAABLOY0000973 ASSAABLOY0000988 Email from Gerald McMillan to Robert Lawrence; Thomas Dahl; Douglas Steele et al.

7

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

50 ASSAABLOY0000989 ASSAABLOY0000993 Email from Robert Lawrence to Douglas Steele; Gerald McMillian; Joe Bezzina et al.51 ASSAABLOY0000994 ASSAABLOY0000995 Email from Robert Lawrence to Vince Ball; Patrick Mendiuk; Gerald McMillan et al.52 ASSAABLOY0001075 ASSAABLOY0001083 AAH Carnival Protocol Description53 ASSAABLOY0001088 ASSAABLOY0001089 Email from Cici Hu to Jan Elfstrom54 ASSAABLOY0001092 ASSAABLOY0001092 Email from Jon Padgett to Johan Warnstrom; Douglas Steele; Mark Lewis et al.55 ASSAABLOY0001093 ASSAABLOY0001094 Email from Johan Warnstrom to John Padgett; Gerald McMillan56 ASSAABLOY0001095 ASSAABLOY0001101 Email from Gerald McMillan to Vanessa Otero; John Padgett; Douglas Steele et al.

8

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9 
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

57 ASSAABLOY0001102 ASSAABLOY0001111 Agreement between Carnival Corporation and ASSA ABLOY Hospitality Inc.58 ASSAABLOY0001112 ASSAABLOY0001112 Letter from Johan Warnstrom to John Padgett59 ASSAABLOY0001113 ASSAABLOY0001124 Statement of Work No. 160 ASSAABLOY0001125 ASSAABLOY0001125 Email from Gerald McMillan to Jon Padgett; Vanessa Otero; Catharina Tunberg61 ASSAABLOY0001126 ASSAABLOY0001126 Email from Gerald McMillan to Vanessa Otero; John Padgett; Douglas Steele et al.62 ASSAABLOY0001127 ASSAABLOY0001128 Letter from G. McMillan to J. Padgett63 ASSAABLOY0001129 ASSAABLOY0001129 Email from Jon Padgett to Gerald McMillan; Vanessa Otero

9

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

64 CARNIVAL00000054 CARNIVAL00000055 Assembly Drawing for Medallion 2.065 CARNIVAL00000265 CARNIVAL00000268

Statement of Work No. 1 for Master Services Agreement between Carnival Corporation and EDS/ DeCurtis Corporation

66 CARNIVAL00000270 CARNIVAL00000284 Master Services Agreement between Carnival Corporation and DeCurtis Corporation67 CARNIVAL00000285 CARNIVAL00000287 Statement of Work No. 2, Attachment to Email (DeCurtis_00157388)68 CARNIVAL00000298 CARNIVAL00000307

Statement of Work No. 10 for Master Services Agreement Between Carnival Corporation andDeCurtis Corporation

69 CARNIVAL00000308 CARNIVAL00000312 Statement of Work No. 12 - (May EIC Show, Support and Execution70 CARNIVAL00000313 CARNIVAL00000321

Statement of Work No. 13 for Master Services Agreement Between Carnival Corporation andDeCurtis Corporation

10

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

71 CARNIVAL00000313 CARNIVAL00000321 Statement of Work No. 13 for MSA Between Carnival and DeCurtis72 CARNIVAL00000322 CARNIVAL00000331 Statement of Work No. 14 for MSA Between Carnival and DeCurtis73 CARNIVAL00000332 CARNIVAL00000336 Statement of Work 9 between Carnival and DeCurtis74 CARNIVAL00000337 CARNIVAL00000339

Statement of Work No. 2 for Master Services Agreement Between Carnival Corporation andEDS / DeCurtis Corporation

75 CARNIVAL00000340 CARNIVAL00000356 Carnival Global Experience Innovation76 CARNIVAL00000357 CARNIVAL00000375 Carnival Corporation, Experience Innovation77 CARNIVAL00000384 CARNIVAL00000423 Carnival Corporation, Global Experience Innovation

11

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

78 CARNIVAL00000424 CARNIVAL00000439 Ocean Innovations, Project Ocean - Capital Authorization Request - Phase I: FY15-FY1679 CARNIVAL00000449 CARNIVAL00000488 Carnival Corporation, Global Experience Innovation80 CARNIVAL00000489 CARNIVAL00000518 Project Trident, DeCurtis Corporation81 CARNIVAL00000669 CARNIVAL00000670 Notes from DeCurtis Meeting82 CARNIVAL00000671 CARNIVAL00000672 Notes - DeCurtis1 2015 Aug 6.pdf83 CARNIVAL00000675 CARNIVAL00000681 Carnival -ASSA_Door Lock Review_25 August 201684 CARNIVAL00000685 CARNIVAL00000690 Door Lock Overview

12

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

85 CARNIVAL00000730 CARNIVAL00000741 Project Trident Door Lock Project Overview86 CARNIVAL00000742 CARNIVAL00000763 Nytec Door Lock - Product Requirements Document87 CARNIVAL00000902 CARNIVAL00000919 Trident - Level 11 Tri-Project Kickoff88 CARNIVAL00000946 CARNIVAL00000959 SOW No. 5 between Carnival and Level 1189 CARNIVAL00001115 CARNIVAL00001141 Nytec Passenger Medallion - Firmware Requirements Document90 CARNIVAL00001142 CARNIVAL00001150 Medallion Life Mode Changing-Verifying91 CARNIVAL00001154 CARNIVAL00001154 BLE Antenna, LDS, 42-10069, N 20160826

13

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

92 CARNIVAL00001613 CARNIVAL00001718 Notes for Project Trident Meetings - Miami July 7-9, 201593 CARNIVAL00003364 CARNIVAL00003376 Project Trident - Request for Comment #294 CARNIVAL00003394 CARNIVAL00003394 Image95 CARNIVAL00003397 CARNIVAL00003397 Image96 CARNIVAL00003400 CARNIVAL00003400 Image97 CARNIVAL00003418 CARNIVAL00003418 Image98 CARNIVAL00003419 CARNIVAL00003419 Image

14

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

99 CARNIVAL00003425 CARNIVAL00003425 Image

100 CARNIVAL00003433 CARNIVAL00003433 Image101 CARNIVAL00003436 CARNIVAL00003436 Image102 CARNIVAL00003439 CARNIVAL00003439 Image103 CARNIVAL00003444 CARNIVAL00003444 Image104 CARNIVAL00003464 CARNIVAL00003571 Draft - Nytec xiReader - 11-10160 - Interface Control Document (ICD)

105 CARNIVAL00007239 CARNIVAL00007260 Trident PRD DoorLock

15

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

106 CARNIVAL00007423 CARNIVAL00007440 Project kickoff v1.4.pptx107 CARNIVAL00010961 CARNIVAL00010979 Amendment in Response to Non-Final Office Action Under 37 C.F.R. §1.111108 CARNIVAL00010983 CARNIVAL00010996

Prosecution History of U.S. Patent 10,045,184 - Examiner’s May 25, 2017 Non-Final Rejectionof claims.

109 CARNIVAL00011090 CARNIVAL00011097 First Preliminary Amendment Under 37 C.F.R. §1.115110 CARNIVAL00011307 CARNIVAL00011316 Notice of Allowance and Fees Due re Application No. 15/460,997111 CARNIVAL00011362 CARNIVAL00011374 April 23, 2018 Remarks in response to Final Rejection of then-pending claims112 CARNIVAL00011427 CARNIVAL00011442 Final Rejection of then-pending claims

16

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

113 CARNIVAL00014539 CARNIVAL00014539 Carnival introduces new high-tech concierge Ocean Medallion - Orlando Rising114 CARNIVAL00014898 CARNIVAL00014900

Press Release - Carnival Corporation's CEO Arnold Donald Unveils Game-Changing Guest Experience Platform in Historic Keynote Address at CES 2017

115 CARNIVAL00015237 CARNIVAL00015237 Letter to V. Pearce from J. Stearns116 CARNIVAL00015242 CARNIVAL00015244 Letter to M. Holleman from V. Pearce117 CARNIVAL00017467 CARNIVAL00017533 Carnival Employee Handbook118 CARNIVAL00017597 CARNIVAL00017611 Master Services Agreement between Carnival Corporation and Level 11119 CARNIVAL00017622 CARNIVAL00017636 Carnival-Nytec MSA

17

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

120 CARNIVAL00017637 CARNIVAL00017651 Master Services Agreement between Carnival Corporation and Nytec121 CARNIVAL00017665 CARNIVAL00017667 Offer Letter from Carnival Corporation to Douglas Steele122 CARNIVAL00019197 CARNIVAL00019200 Email fromBethany Diloreto re Support Documents123 CARNIVAL00037288 CARNIVAL00037289 RFC Arch 108 - Stateroom Door Lock Ecosystem124 CARNIVAL00037686 CARNIVAL00037686 Patent Ideas125 CARNIVAL00037687 CARNIVAL00037699 Patent Ideas and Concepts by EIC Project126 CARNIVAL00037999 CARNIVAL00038014 Carnival Corporation - EIC Team

18

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 1
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

127 CARNIVAL00038324 CARNIVAL00038324 Image128 CARNIVAL00038325 CARNIVAL00038325 Image129 CARNIVAL00052210 CARNIVAL00052227 Master Services Agreement between Carnival Corporation and and ASSA ABLOY Hospitality Inc.130 CARNIVAL00052228 CARN IVAL00052232 Mutal Non-Disclosure Agreement between ASSA ABLOY Hospitality and Carnival Corporation131 CARNIVAL00052273 CARNIVAL00052284 Master Services Agreement Between Carnival Corporation and Assa Abloy Hospitality132 CARNIVAL00053206 CARNIVAL00053218 Statement of Work No. 30 For Master Services Agreement between Carnival Corporation and Nytec - Project Trident133 CARNIVAL00054255 CARNIVAL00054269 Carnival-Ophir Manufacturing Solutions MSA

19

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

134 CARNIVAL00055225 CARNIVAL00055239 Carnival-Digital Kitchen MSA135 CARNIVAL00056535 CARNIVAL00056549 Carnival-WOW!Works International MSA136 CARNIVAL00063868 CARNIVAL00063871 Statement of Work (Architecture Analysis and Documentation)137 CARNIVAL00063872 CARNIVAL00063874 Statement of Work (Architecture Analysis and Documentation)138 CARNIVAL00063877 CARNIVAL00063890 SOW 6 – DeCurtis and Carnival139 CARNIVAL00063891 CARNIVAL00063893 Statement of Work No. 7 for Master Services Agreement Between Carnival Corporation EDS / DeCurtis Corporation140 CARNIVAL00063894 CARNIVAL00063897 Statement of Work No. 8 - (Architecture Analysis and Documentation)

20

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

141 CARNIVAL00064390 CARNIVAL00064446

Experience Operating System Component Purchase and License Agreement between Carnival Corporation and Level 11

142 CARNIVAL00066606 CARNIVAL00066620 Carnival-Matter MSA143 CARNIVAL00069815 CARNIVAL00069838 Carnival-UIEvolution MSA144 CARNIVAL00070525 CARNIVAL00070539 Carnival-XPO Logistics MSA145 CARNIVAL00070602 CARNIVAL00070603 Letter from Gerald McMillian to John Padgett re 516 Patent146 CARNIVAL00070609 CARNIVAL00070619 Letter from Johan Warnstrom to John Padgett re Project Trident147 CARNIVAL00070817 CARNIVAL00070818

Meeting invite from Vanessa Otero to John Padgett; Kyle Prestenback; Douglas Steele et al. re Carnival Corp and ASSA ABLOY Meeting

21

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

148 CARNIVAL00070934 CARNIVAL00070946 Ideas and concepts developed by EiC project149 CARNIVAL00070947 CARNIVAL00070959 Ideas and concepts developed by EIC project150 CARNIVAL00070960 CARNIVAL00070965 Ideas and concepts developed by EIC project151 CARNIVAL00120635 CARNIVAL00120642 Patent Assignment152 CARNIVAL00121143 CARNIVAL00121149 Patent Assignment153 CARNIVAL00121150 CARNIVAL00121817 Certified Patent File History for US Patent 10,045,184154 CARNIVAL00121872 CARNIVAL00122401 Certified Patent File History for US Patent 10,049,516

22

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

155 CARNIVAL00122456 CARNIVAL00123079 Certified Patent File History for US Patent 10,157,514156 CARNIVAL00124784 CARNIVAL00124784 PCL Caribbean Tracking-Balcony157 CARNIVAL00124806 CARNIVAL00124806 ms Excel 2007 Spreadsheet158 CARNIVAL00124827 CARNIVAL00124834

Agreement to Avoid Intellectual Property and Related Disputes between Carnival Corporation and Virgin Cruises Intermediate Limited, Inc.

159 CARNIVAL00124884_001 CARNIVAL00124884_002

Letter from T. Vann Pearce to Jorge Martinez re Carnival Corporation's patent rights relating to wireless guest engagement systems

160 CARNIVAL00124886_001 CARNIVAL00124886_002

Letter from T. Vann Pearce to Daniel S. Farkas re Carnival Corporation's patent rights relating to wireless guest engagement systems

161 CARNIVAL00125422_001 CARNIVAL00125422_002 Draft Agreement

23

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

162 CARNIVAL00125646 CARNIVAL00125646 Email from Chris Congdon to Miles Clark re Scarlet Lady Doors163 CARNIVAL00126750 CARNIVAL00126784 Project Ocean - Goldman Sachs164 CARNIVAL00127336 CARNIVAL00127537 Email from Mr. Sestak to Arnold Donald re 2018165 CARNIVAL00128020 CARNIVAL00128050 Email from Maria Leon to Micky Arison; Arnold Donald; Iris Vega re April 8, 2020 Meeting of the Board of Directors166 CARNIVAL00129563 CARNIVAL00129563 Email from Mark Friedman to John Padgett; Jan Swartz; Jason Cahilly et al. re Project Ocean Presentation Materials167 CARNIVAL00129564 CARNIVAL00129630 Project Ocean Discussion Materials - June 29, 2020168 CARNIVAL00131193 CARNIVAL00131193 Backgrounder

24

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

169 CARNIVAL00131513 CARNIVAL00131524 The Band Preliminary Investigation and Findings170 CARNIVAL00131834 CARNIVAL00131834 CARNIVAL00131834 xlsx171 CARNIVAL00343753 CARNIVAL00343790 Email from Douglas Steele to Sean Alm re Your thoughts on this172 CARNIVAL00344633 CARNIVAL00344668 Princess Cruises O.C.E.A.N - Global Marketing Summit - 2017 the next wave in vacation173 CARNIVAL00345048 CARNIVAL00345063 Trident Marketing Strategy Brainstorm174 CARNIVAL00374690 CARNIVAL00374721 Carnival Corporation, Global Experience & Innovation, Ocean Experience Platform, October 7, 2020175 CARNIVAL00375145 CARNIVAL00375164 Email from RohanBatra to Vanessa Otero; Yohan Minaya; Annabeth Gellman re January 2020 Deck – Ocean Meeting

25

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

176 CARNIVAL00375147 CARNIVAL00375164 Princess Cruises Presentation, "PCL Strategic Update MedallionClass / OCEAN"177 CARNIVAL00375784 CARNIVAL00375850 Evercore Presentation, "Project Ocean Discussion Materials"178 CARNIVAL00382998 CARNIVAL00383004 Carnival Corporation and Carnival Cruise Lines ("Carnival") Records Management Program Policy179 CARNIVAL00383039 CARNIVAL00383043 The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language 108 (5th ed. 2016)180 CARNIVAL00383193 CARNIVAL00383195

Email from Keegan Hartman to Deanna Austin; Jan Swartz; Gordon Ho et al. re Caribbean (OCEAN) Curves - 5/9/17 Update

181 CARNIVAL00383195 CARNIVAL00383195 Ocean Medallion Weekly Summaries, Fall 2017/Spring 2018182 CARNIVAL00383228 CARNIVAL00383233 Email from Neil Rippon to Kirk Bardin re Ocean Executive Summary for June (Pass 1)

26

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

183 CARNIVAL00383233 CARNIVAL00383233 OCEAN Impact 2019184 CARNIVAL00383510 CARNIVAL00383511

Email from Kathryn Mulqueen to Neil Rippon; Robert Morgenstern; Jen Wright, et al. re Ocean Executive Summary - June 2019

185 CARNIVAL00383512 CARNIVAL00383536 Attachment to Email186 CARNIVAL00383611 CARNIVAL00383662

Email from Kirk Bardin to Jan Swartz,; Mario Siebaldi; Lorna Warren et al. re Ocean Executive Summary - November & December 2019

187 CARNIVAL00383612 CARNIVAL00383637 Carnival Presentation, "OCEAN KPI's November Executive Pack," November 2019188 CARNIVAL00383638 CARNIVAL00383662 Princess MedallionClas Presentation, "OCEAN KPI's December Executive Pack"189 CARNIVAL00383694 CARNIVAL00383718 Carnival Presentation, "OCEAN KPI's June Executive Pack," June 2019

27

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

190 CARNIVAL00383736 CARNIVAL00383758 Princess MedallionClass Presentation, "OCEAN KPI's April Princess Pack"191 CARNIVAL00384544 CARNIVAL00384571 Email from Diana Martin to Neil Rippon re OCL Pricing Data Extract - Caribbean + North America - 2020-02-25192 CARNIVAL00384561 CARNIVAL00384561 North America Balcony 2/25/20193 CARNIVAL00384562 CARNIVAL00384562 North America Balcony 2/25/20194 CARNIVAL00385816 CARNIVAL00385822 Email from Diana Martin to Neil Rippon; Marsha Patrick; Heidi Rutter et al. re Travelzoo Offer 5.20195 CARNIVAL00385822 CARNIVAL00385822 TravelZoo Caribbean Offer_5.20196 CARNIVAL00388927 CARNIVAL00389013 Email from Fina Lam to Kimberly Henigman; Deanna Austin; Neil Rippon et al. re YODA 101

28

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 2
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

197 CARNIVAL00388928 CARNIVAL00389013 Carnival Presentation, "YODA: Yield Optimizer & Demand Analytics"198 CARNIVAL00397764 CARNIVAL00397773

Meeting Invite from Mitchell Peacock to Neil Rippon; Anthony Gaviola; Charles Clark et al. re Competitors NonPublic/Discounted Fares

199 CARNIVAL00406033 CARNIVAL00406410 Email from Jordan Avery to Diedra Ward; Brian McDowell; Fredrick Gardner et al. re UAT Training Deck200 CARNIVAL00407550 CARNIVAL00407658 Email from Neil Rippon to Erica Netzley re AD Presentation Update 8/13 @ 11:38 AM201 CARNIVAL00407773 CARNIVAL00408006 Email from Neil Rippon to Michelle Leslie re Printouts for 8:30 Meeting202 CARNIVAL00413460 CARNIVAL00413482 Email from Deanna Austin to Jan Swartz; Gordon Ho; Lisa Syme et al. re Brand Reviews203 CARNIVAL00413596 CARNIVAL00413650

Email from Lisa Syme to Mark Barnes; Neil Rippon; Deanna Austin re Neil and LisaConsolidated Slide Draft

29

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

204 CARNIVAL00414506 CARNIVAL00414512 Email from William Meyenberg to Neil Rippon re Competitor Price Tracking Refresh205 CARNIVAL00414510 CARNIVAL00414510 PCL British Isles 12 day Tracking - Inside - 2019-08-27206 CARNIVAL00421482 CARNIVAL00421534

Carnival Corporation and Carnival Cruise Lines - Records Management Program Company Records Retention Schedule Version 2.4

207 CARNIVAL00422122 CARNIVAL00422174

Carnival Corporation and Carnival Cruise Lines - Records Management Program Company Records Retention Schedule Version 2.4

208 CARNIVAL00422177 CARNIVAL00422179 Carnival Corporation and Carnival Cruise Lines Records Management Program Procedure209 CARNIVAL00422180 CARNIVAL00422181

Carnival Corporation and Carnival Cruise Lines Records Management Program Policy -Destruction of Records

210 CARNIVAL00422185 CARNIVAL00422191 Carnival's Records Management Program Procedure - Legal Hold Orders

30

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

211 CARNIVAL00448109 CARNIVAL00448116

Email from Simeon Waldron to Mark Francone; John Abdullah re Ocean Presentation for theBOD

212 CARNIVAL00448420 CARNIVAL00448431 Evercore Presentation, "Project Ocean"213 CARNIVAL00448421 CARNIVAL00448430 Evercore Presentation, "Project Ocean Financial Overview February 2021"214 CARNIVAL00448437 CARNIVAL00448487 PCL Strategic Update Medallion Class/OCEAN215 CARNIVAL00448628 CARNIVAL00448629 Email from Simeon Waldron to Jan Swartz re Project Ocean File216 CARNIVAL00448629 CARNIVAL00448629 PCL GXI Ocean Pricing Workings217 CARNIVAL00449104 CARNIVAL00449119 Email from Mark Barnes to Simeon Waldron; Deanna Austin; Anna Maria Munoz et al. re ABG Commentary

31

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

218 CARNIVAL00457186 CARNIVAL00457187 Email from Rai Calouri to Mario Siebaldi re RCL219 CARNIVAL00457658 CARNIVAL00457659 Email from Denise Guerra to Mario Siebaldi; Barry White; Davis Mudakara et al. re Concession Response220 CARNIVAL00478655 CARNIVAL00478656 Email from Mark Francone to Simeon Waldron re Ocean Financial Analysis Board Presentation Support221 CARNIVAL00478656 CARNIVAL00478656 Ocean Financial Analysis-Board Presentation Support222 CARNIVAL00491643 CARNIVAL00491643 Email from Simeon Waldron to Deanna Austin; Mark Barnes; Neil Rippon re Arnold Question223 CARNIVAL00505802 CARNIVAL00505802 “Project Ocean,” CARNIVAL00505802.xlsb224 CARNIVAL00509477 CARNIVAL00509477 GXI Service Options and Pricing Document

32

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

225 CARNIVAL00509743 CARNIVAL00509743 Email from John Padgett to Gianabel Fernandez re Investor Briefing Document226 CARNIVAL00509744 CARNIVAL00509749 Ocean Platform/XperienceVerse - Investor Briefing Content - Executive Summary

227 CARNIVAL00511411 CARNIVAL00511432

Email from Mathieu Balicco to Kyle Weiss; Kristina Kaylen; Laura Whittaker- Rawlinson et al. Knowledge Transfer Files

228 CARNIVAL00511412 CARNIVAL00511412 Glossary OCL Database229 CARNIVAL00512910 CARNIVAL00512910 Email from Aashih to Kristina re PC COMP Data updates and validation with attachments230 CARNIVAL00512911 CARNIVAL00512911 Email from G. Curtis to J. Padgett re Nytec meeting update231 CARNIVAL00512912 CARNIVAL00512912 Email from G. Curtis to S. Nair re EIC Studio

33

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

232 CARNIVAL00525876 CARNIVAL00525888_0 03 Email from Gianabel Fernandez to John Padgett re With my comments...

233 CARNIVAL005609475 CARNIVAL00509478 Email and attachment from Emily Martinez-Lanza to John Padgett re GXI Service Options and Pricing234 CARNIVAL00565051 CARNIVAL00565052 Agreement235 CARNIVAL00565242 CARNIVAL00565409 Email from Giana Fernandez to John Padgett re Final Deliverables236 CARNIVAL00565245 CARNIVAL00565409 Evercore/Accenture Presentation, "Project Ocean Due Diligence Deliverable"237 CARNIVAL00569040 CARNIVAL00569043 Email from Joh Weinstein Re Tracing System238 CARNIVAL00624978 CARNIVAL00624982 58 Email from Gordon Ho to Jan Swartz; Deanna Austin; Neil Rippon et al. re Update & Action - ICON Media Barter

34

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

239 CARNIVAL00631091 CARNIVAL00631092

Email from Susan Hamilton to Shiky Chen; Neil Rippon; Ashley Schweizer et al. re Shanghai 7/8 day - Cruise Tour Options

240 CARNIVAL00700754 CARNIVAL00700768 Email from Neil Rippon to Deanna Austin re Updated slides241 CARNIVAL00701775 CARNIVAL00701801 Email from Deanna Austin to Mark Barnes; Lisa Syme re Detailed ocean pack242 CARNIVAL00705186 CARNIVAL00705189 Email from Mark Barnes to Deanna Austin; Neil Rippon; Lisa Syme re Capacity Growth Pax and %243 CARNIVAL00706289 CARNIVAL00706290 Email from Mark Barnes to Sanna Maria Re 2020 Walk with attachment244 CARNIVAL00706290 CARNIVAL00706290 2020 Plan NTR walk by Quarter RM-Final245 CARNIVAL00706794 CARNIVAL00706800 Email from Neil Rippon to Mark Barnes; Deanna Austin re Slides for AD Presentation

35

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

246 CARNIVAL00730697 CARNIVAL00730698

Email from Wise to Charrow re FW: MSC for Me Experience Assessment with attacdhed MSC for Me_Experience_Assessment

247 CARNIVAL00753743 CARNIVAL00753809 Project Ocean Discussion Materials - June 29, 2020248 CARNIVAL00756271 CARNIVAL00756320 Email from Jan Swartz to David Bernstein; Stein Kruse; Arnold Donald et al. re Ocean BOD Presentation249 CARNIVAL00756272 CARNIVAL00756320 Carnival Presentation, "PCL Strategic Update MedallionClass/OCEAN"250 CARNIVAL00761811 CARNIVAL00762318 Carnival Corporation Form 10-Q for period ended 8/31/2020251 CARNIVAL00765736 CARNIVAL00765744 Purchase and License Agreement between Carnival Corporation and O8 LLC252 DeCurtis_00000018 DeCurtis_00000018 Receipt

36

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

253 DeCurtis_00000042 DeCurtis_00000042 Receipt254 DeCurtis_00000046 DeCurtis_00000046 Receipt255 DeCurtis_00000104 DeCurtis_00000106 Receipt256 DeCurtis_00000143 DeCurtis_00000146 Statement of Work No. 1257 DeCurtis_00000221 DeCurtis_00000222 Receipt258 DeCurtis_00000249 DeCurtis_00000251 Receipt259 DeCurtis_00000429 DeCurtis_00000429 Receipt

37

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

260 Decurtis_00000439 Decurtis_00000440 Receipt261 DeCurtis_00000535 DeCurtis_00000536 Receipt262 DeCurtis_00000603 DeCurtis_00000603 Receipt263 DeCurtis_00000697 DeCurtis_00000697 Receipt264 DeCurtis_00000962 DeCurtis_00000965 Statement of Work No. 5265 DeCurtis_00001513 DeCurtis_00001515 Statement of Work (Architecture Analysis and Documentation)266 DeCurtis_00002177 DeCurtis_00002228 Master Project, Software License, Hardware and Support Agreement

38

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 3
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

267 DeCurtis_00002229 DeCurtis_00002236 Services Agreement268 DeCurtis_00002237 DeCurtis_00002240 Amendment (No. 1) to Services Agreement269 DeCurtis_00002241 DeCurtis_00002245 Amendment (No. 2) to Services Agreement270 DeCurtis_00002246 DeCurtis_00002253 Amendment (No. 3) to Services Agreement271 DeCurtis_00002250 DeCurtis_00002253 Amendment (No. 4) to Services Agreement272 DeCurtis_00002254 DeCurtis_00002273 Amendment (No. 5) to Services Agreement273 DeCurtis_00002274 DeCurtis_00002281 Services Agreement

39

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

274 DeCurtis_00002282 DeCurtis_00002287 Amendment No. 6 to Service Agreement275 DeCurtis_00002288 DeCurtis_00002289 First Amendment to Software Development Services Agreement276 DeCurtis_00002290 DeCurtis_00002291 Change Request #1 Owners Supply277 DeCurtis_00002292 DeCurtis_00002293 Change Request #1 Owners Supply278 DeCurtis_00002294 DeCurtis_00002301 Services Agreement279 DeCurtis_00002302 DeCurtis_00002311 Software Development Services Agreement280 DeCurtis_00002312 DeCurtis_00002320 Services Agreement

40

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

281 DeCurtis_00002321 DeCurtis_00002322

First Amendment to Software License, “First Amendment to Software License and SupportServices Agreement”

282 DeCurtis_00002323 DeCurtis_00002326 Second Amendment to Software License and Support Agreement283 DeCurtis_00002327 DeCurtis_00002327 Second Amendment to Software Development Services Agreement284 DeCurtis_00002328 DeCurtis_00002345 Services Agreement285 DeCurtis_00002346 DeCurtis_00002353 Services Agreement286 DeCurtis_00002354 DeCurtis_00002361 Services Agreement287 DeCurtis_00002362 DeCurtis_00002367 Second Amendment to Software Development Services Agreement

41

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

288 DeCurtis_00002368 DeCurtis_00002375 Services Agreement289 DeCurtis_00002378 DeCurtis_00002402 Software Development Services Agreement290 DeCurtis_00002403 DeCurtis_00002406 Third Amendment to Software Development Services Agreement291 DeCurtis_00002407 DeCurtis_00002415 Software License and Support Services Agreement292 DeCurtis_00002416 DeCurtis_00002437 Software Development Services Agreement293 DeCurtis_00002438 DeCurtis_00002439 First Amendment to the Software Development Agreement294 DeCurtis_00002440 DeCurtis_00002451 Services Agreement

42

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

295 DeCurtis_00002452 DeCurtis_00002457 Exhibit B - Software, Hardware and Support Order Form296 DeCurtis_00006669 DeCurtis_00006696 Mobile Assembly - Application Functions297 DeCurtis_00157216 DeCurtis_00157227 Ideas and concepts298 DeCurtis_00157254 DeCurtis_00157256 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis; Michael Jungen299 DeCurtis_00157327 DeCurtis_00157328 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis300 DeCurtis_00157329 DeCurtis_00157331 Email from David DeCurtis to Jim Learish and Derek Fournier301 DeCurtis_00157332 DeCurtis_00157426 Email from Padgett to Leonards

43

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

302 DeCurtis_00157333 DeCurtis_00157338 Global Brand Portfolio303 DeCurtis_00157339 DeCurtis_00157339 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis304 DeCurtis_00157340 DeCurtis_00157341 Email from Adam Leonards to JP305 DeCurtis_00157342 DeCurtis_00157342 2014-07-21 Fw: Scenarios306 DeCurtis_00157343 DeCurtis_00157349 2014-07-21 Fw: Scenarios Attachment: Scenarios v.1.pdf307 DeCurtis_00157351 DeCurtis_00157351 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis308 DeCurtis_00157352 DeCurtis_00157352 Eamil from Padgett to DeCurtis

44

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

309 DeCurtis_00157366 DeCurtis_00157367 Email from John Padgett to Mark Hadland; Paul Matthaeus; Bill Fritsch et al.310 DeCurtis_00157370 DeCurtis_00157371 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis et al.311 DeCurtis_00157372 DeCurtis_00157373 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis et312 DeCurtis_00157385 DeCurtis_00157387 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis313 DeCurtis_00157388 DeCurtis_00157388 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis314 DeCurtis_00157395 DeCurtis_00157399 Email from JP Personal to David DeCurtis315 DeCurtis_00157400 DeCurtis_00157400 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis

45

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

316 DeCurtis_00157404 DeCurtis_00157404 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis317 DeCurtis_00157405 DeCurtis_00157405 Email from Glenn Curtis to David DeCurtis; Mark Hadland; Manny Vellon; John Padgett318 DeCurtis_00157407 DeCurtis_00157408 Email from John Padgett to Manny Vellon; David DeCurtis; Glenn Curtis; Adam Leonards319 DeCurtis_00157409 DeCurtis_00157409 Email from John Padgett to David Decurtis320 DeCurtis_00157416 DeCurtis_00157416 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis321 DeCurtis_00157418 DeCurtis_00157418 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis322 DeCurtis_00157426 DeCurtis_00157426 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis

46

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

323 DeCurtis_00157427 DeCurtis_00157427 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis324 DeCurtis_00157428 DeCurtis_00157429 Email from John Padgett to Glenn Curtis; Manny Vellon; David Decurtis; Mark Hadland325 DeCurtis_00157430 DeCurtis_00157430 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis326 DeCurtis_00157431 DeCurtis_00157431 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis327 DeCurtis_00157432 DeCurtis_00157432 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis328 DeCurtis_00157433 DeCurtis_00157435 Email from Jim Learish to John Padgett et al.329 DeCurtis_00157436 DeCurtis_00157439 Email from John Padgett to Mike Collier

47

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

330 DeCurtis_00157440 DeCurtis_00157440 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis331 DeCurtis_00157441 DeCurlis_00157442 Email from Glenn Curtis to David Decurtis; John Padgett332 DeCurtis_00157443 DeCurtis_00157443 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis333 DeCurtis_00157444 DeCurtis_00157444 Email from John Padgett to Adams Leonards334 DeCurtis_00157445 DeCurtis_00157445 Email from John Padgett to Mark Dundore335 DeCurtis_00157446 DeCurtis_00157448 2015-01-09 Re: meeting update336 DeCurtis_00157449 DeCurtis_00157449 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis

48

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 4
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

337 DeCurtis_00157450 DeCurtis_00157456 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis; Mark Hadland; Glenn Curtis et al.338 DeCurtis_00157458 DeCurtis_00157459 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis339 DeCurtis_00157460 DeCurtis_00157460 Email from Jorge Herrera to John Padgett et al.340 DeCurtis_00157461 DeCurtis_00157461 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis341 DeCurtis_00157462 DeCurtis_00157462 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis342 DeCurtis_00157463 DeCurtis_00157464 Email from G. Curtis to J. Padgett343 DeCurtis_00157471 DeCurtis_00157471 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis

49

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

344 DeCurtis_00157472 DeCurtis_00157473 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis345 DeCurtis_00157474 DeCurtis_00157474 Email from Janet DeDonato to David DeCurtis346 DeCurtis_00157475 DeCurtis_00157477 Email from Glenn Curtis to David DeCurtis; Mark D. Hadland; Manny Vellon347 DeCurtis_00157478 DeCurtis_00157478 Email from John Padgett to Michael Jungen348 DeCurtis_00157489 DeCurtis_00157490 Email from Jorge Herrera to Jim Learish et al.349 DeCurtis_00157491 DeCurtis_00157491 Email from Jorge Herrera to David DeCurtis et al.350 DeCurtis_00157492 DeCurtis_00157497 Strategic Services Timeline Powerpoint, Attachment

50

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

351 DeCurtis_00157498 DeCurtis_00157499 Email from Jorge Herrera to David DeCurtis352 DeCurtis_00157500 DeCurtis_00157500 Email from Jenn Revilla to David DeCurtis et al.353 DeCurtis_00157501 DeCurtis_00157502 Email from Jenn Revilla to Jim Learish354 DeCurtis_00157503 DeCurtis_00157503 Excel, Attachment355 DeCurtis_00157504 DeCurtis_00157505 Program StatusReport 5 29 15 PowerPoint, Attachment356 DeCurtis_00157513 DeCurtis_00157515 Email from David DeCurtis to Derek Fournier357 DeCurtis_00157516 DeCurtis_00157516 Email from David DeCurtis to Michael Jungen et al.

51

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

358 DeCurtis_00157517 DeCurtis_00157519 Email from Lewis Branda to David DeCurtis359 DeCurtis_00157520 DeCurtis_00157522 Email from Lewis Branda to David DeCurtis360 DeCurtis_00157523 DeCurtis_00157525 Email from David DeCurtis to M Jungen and John Padgett361 DeCurtis_00157526 DeCurtis_00157532 Email from David DeCurtis to David Herrera362 DeCurtis_00157533 DeCurtis_00157533 Email from David DeCurtis to David Herrera363 DeCurtis_00157534 DeCurtis_00157535 Letter from David DeCurtis to David Herrera364 DeCurtis_00157536 DeCurtis_00157536 Email from David Herrera to David DeCurtis

52

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

365 DeCurtis_00157543 DeCurtis_00157547 Notes about John Padgett366 DeCurtis_00157548 DeCurtis_00157548 Carnival EIC Tracker367 DeCurtis_00157570 DeCurtis_00157582 BOG Technology Architecture368 DeCurtis_00157596 DeCurtis_00157597 Email from Michael Jungen to David DeCurtis369 DeCurtis_00157601 DeCurtis_00157604 Email from John Padgett to Adam Leonards370 DeCurtis_00157605 DeCurtis_00157606 Email from Michael Jungen to Valli Aluri et al.371 DeCurtis_00157607 DeCurtis_00157608 Email from Craig Feldman to John Padgett et al.

53

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

372 DeCurtis_00157609 DeCurtis_00157609 Email from Craig Feldman to Adam et al.373 DeCurtis_00157613 DeCurtis_00157614 Email from Jorge Herrera to Michael Jungen et al.374 DeCurtis_00157641 DeCurtis_00157642 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis375 DeCurtis_00157643 DeCurtis_00157644 Email from Lewis Branda to Megha Agrawal376 DeCurtis_00157645 DeCurtis_00157651 Email from David DeCurtis to Jim Learish et al.377 DeCurtis_00157652 DeCurtis_00157660 Email from David DeCurtis to Jim Learish et al.378 DeCurtis_00157676 DeCurtis_00157679 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis et al.

54

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

379 DeCurtis_00157680 DeCurtis_00157681 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis et al.380 DeCurtis_00157682 DeCurtis_00157690 Email from Andy Howard to Derek Fournier381 DeCurtis_00157820 DeCurtis_00157835 Mobile Assembly Suite (MAS)382 DeCurtis_00160689 DeCurtis_00160690 Email from Douglas Steele to Derek Fournier; David DeCurtis; Jim Learish; Michael Jungen383 DeCurtis_00161273 DeCurtis_00161273 Email from Laura Hall to David DeCurtis384 DeCurtis_00162350 DeCurtis_00162351 Email from David DeCurtis to Michael Jungen385 DeCurtis_00166857 DeCurtis_00166873 Mobile Assembly Suite (MAS)

55

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

386 DeCurtis_00168906 DeCurtis_00168911 Email from Frank Cardell to Jim Learish387 DeCurtis_00168946 DeCurtis_00168951 Email from Frank Cardell to Jim Learish; Dwayne Warner; David Decurtis; Derek Fournier388 DeCurtis_00172207 DeCurtis_00172262 Master License and Services Agreement389 DeCurtis_00172440 DeCurtis_00172460 DeCurtis - E-Muster Software License Agreement390 DeCurtis_00172740 DeCurtis_00172741 Email from D. DeCurtis to L.Hall391 DeCurtis_00173061 DeCurtis_00173062 Email from David DeCurtis to Michael Jungen392 DeCurtis_00173252 DeCurtis_00173275 SOW 16 – DeCurtis and Carnival

56

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

393 DeCurtis_00228306 DeCurtis_00228306 Email from Laura Hall to David DeCurtis394 DeCurtis_00233505 DeCurtis_00233519 Email from Michael Jungen to David DeCurtis cc'ing John Padgett395 DeCurtis_00233920 DeCurtis_00233928 Email from M. Jungen to D. DeCurtis396 DeCurtis_00236222 DeCurtis_00236277 Master License and Services Agreement397 DeCurtis_00241755 DeCurtis_00241755 Email from John Padgett to David Decurtis398 DeCurtis_00241867 DeCurtis_00241874 Email from Glenn Curtis to John Padgett; Adam Leonards; Manny Vellon et al.399 DeCurtis_00242071 DeCurtis_00242072 Email from John Padgett to Glenn Curtis; David DeCurtis; Adam Leonards et al.

57

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

400 DeCurtis_00242613 DeCurtis_00242617 Email from John Padgett to David Decurtis401 DeCurtis_00242707 DeCurtis_00242714 Email from mannyvellon to Adam Leonards402 DeCurtis_00242858 DeCurtis_00242861 Email from Glenn Curtis to John Padgett; David DeCurtis; Manuel Vellon et al.403 DeCurtis_00243066 DeCurtis_00243067 Email from Glenn Curtis to John Padgett; David DeCurtis; Manuel Vellon et al.404 DeCurtis_00243084 DeCurtis_00243084 Email from Glenn Curtis to David DeCurtis405 DeCurtis_00244708 DeCurtis_00244708 Email from Glenn Curtis to John Padgett; Manny Vellon; Jim Brennan; David Decurtis406 DeCurtis_00244710 DeCurtis_00244712 Email from Glenn Curtis to David DeCurtis and others

58

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 5
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

407 DeCurtis_00245021 DeCurtis_00245022 Email from J. DeDonato to D. DeCurtis408 DeCurtis_00245151 DeCurtis_00245151 Email from Manny Vellon to Glenn Curtis; John Padgett; Paul Matthaeus409 DeCurtis_00245492 DeCurtis_00245492 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis410 DeCurtis_00245611 DeCurtis_00245613 Email from Mark Hadland to David DeCurtis; John Padgett411 DeCurtis_00245638 DeCurtis_00245638 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis412 DeCurtis_00245690 DeCurtis_00245690 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis413 DeCurtis_00245691 DeCurtis_00245696 Attachment 1 to Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis

59

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

414 DeCurtis_00245697 DeCurtis_00245700 Attachment 2 to Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis415 DeCurtis_00245701 DeCurtis_00245704 Attachment 3 to Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis416 DeCurtis_00321913 DeCurtis_00321917 Main Components417 DeCurtis_00362269 DeCurtis_00362274 Assa Abloy (VingCard Allure) Capabilities and Questionnaires418 Decurtis_00364029 Decurtis_00364030 Email from Glenn Curtis to Seema Nair419 Decurtis_00364531 Decurtis_00364531 Email from David DeCurtis to Seema Nair420 DeCurtis_00367132 DeCurtis_00367133 Email from Derek Fournier to DeCurtis Team

60

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

421 DeCurtis_00383098 DeCurtis_00383107 Technical Support Document422 DeCurtis_00469096 DeCurtis_00469123 DeCurtis Disney Portfolio423 DeCurtis_00503223 DeCurtis_00503225 Email from Seema Nair to David DeCurtis424 DeCurtis_00526304 DeCurtis_00526305 Email from A. Schwalb to A. Breitenstein425 DeCurtis_00557370 DeCurtis_00557370 Email from P. Sharma to M. Agrawal426 DeCurtis_00678469 DeCurtis_00678469 Email from David DeCurtis to Jitendra Kumar, Pardasani427 DeCurtis_00725731 DeCurtis_00725737 DXP Location Solution

61

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

428 DeCurtis_00727448 DeCurtis_00727449 Email chain429 DeCurtis_00730954 DeCurtis_00730955 Email from R. Hartmann to B. Garr430 DeCurtis_00751732 DeCurtis_00751734 Email from I. Sayegh to K. Mongwa431 DeCurtis_00767636 DeCurtis_00767637 Wearable Process Flow432 DeCurtis_00771499 DeCurtis_00771500 Email from Jan Elfstrom to Blaine Schmidt et al.433 DeCurtis_00776776 DeCurtis_00776795 Cabin Control434 DeCurtis_00777274 DeCurtis_00777284 Door Lock Requirements Document

62

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

435 DeCurtis_00777427 DeCurtis_00777435 Technical Specification436 DeCurtis_00807560 DeCurtis_00807585 Current Request Response Protocol, Attachment to Email437 DeCurtis_00808687 DeCurtis_00808697 Door Lock Requirements Document438 DeCurtis_00813375 DeCurtis_00813375 Email from E. Murroni to David DeCurtis et al.439 DeCurtis_00813376 DeCurtis_00813376 Integrations Excel Spreadsheet, Attachment to Email440 DeCurtis_00821963 DeCurtis_00821965 Email from Babak Aghevli to Kan Mongwa et al.,441 DeCurtis_00852681 DeCurtis_00852683 Email from Babak Aghevli to Tyler Myers

63

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

442 DeCurtis_00856804 DeCurtis_00856805 Email from M. Arya to D. Choudhury443 DeCurtis_00880165 DeCurtis_00880166 Email from Babak Aghevli to David DeCurtis444 DeCurtis_00885178 DeCurtis_00885187 Email from Babak Aghevli to Akash Uday445 DeCurtis_00891919 DeCurtis_00891922 Email from Babak Aghevli to Kan Mongwa et al.446 DeCurtis_00907158 DeCurtis_00907158 Email from Babak Aghevli to Milay Ruiz et al.447 DeCurtis_00966139 DeCurtis_00966141 Email from Apurva Saxena to Glenn Curtis; David DeCurtis; Manny Vellons et al.448 DeCurtis_01076369 DeCurtis_01076383 Email from Babak Aghevli to Akash Uday

64

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

449 DeCurtis_01237326 DeCurtis_01237327 Email from A. Leonards to D. DeCurtis450 DeCurtis_01248833 DeCurtis_01248890 DeCurtis Portfolio451 DeCurtis_01249561 DeCurtis_01249561 Email from Megha Agrawal to Derek Fournier452 DeCurtis_01256609 DeCurtis_01256609 Excel Spreadsheet453 DeCurtis_01258249 DeCurtis_01258265 DXP Presentation454 DeCurtis_01265502 DeCurtis_01265503 Email from Babak Aghevli to Kan Mongwa et al.455 DeCurtis_01274677 DeCurtis_01274678 Email from Babak Aghevli to Ricardo Ceballos et al.

65

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

456 DeCurtis_01274846 DeCurtis_01274846 Email from Babak Aghevli to Kevin Moore457 DeCurtis_01284641 DeCurtis_01284642 Email from Babak Aghevli to Lauri Bayless458 DeCurtis_01298359 DeCurtis_01298359 Email from Babak Aghevli to Roberta Greene and Issam Sayegh459 DeCurtis_01298559 DeCurtis_01298559 Email from Babak Aghevli to Brad Shank460 DeCurtis_01326525 DeCurtis_01326527 Email from Borja Sagarduy to Joe Bezzina et al.461 DeCurtis_01340504 DeCurtis_01340504 Email from Babak Aghevli to Megha Agrawal462 DeCurtis_01340791 DeCurtis_01340792 Email from Babak Aghevli to Kan Mongwa et al.

66

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

463 DeCurtis_01341065 DeCurtis_01341065 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Lehman et al.464 DeCurtis_01341346 DeCurtis_01341346 Email from Babak Aghevli to Brian Barreto et al.465 DeCurtis_01343448 DeCurtis_01343448 Email from Babak Aghevli to Arnold Bramnick et al.466 DeCurtis_01343449 DeCurtis_01343449 Meeting Minutes and Action Items467 DeCurtis_01419356 DeCurtis_01419358 Email from Joe Carino to Jim Learish et al.468 DeCurtis_01459249 DeCurtis_01459249 Email from D. Bhatia to M. Vellon469 DeCurtis_01459569 DeCurtis_01459569 Email from Adam Leonards to John Padgett and David DeCurtis

67

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

470 DeCurtis_01459616 DeCurtis_01459617 Email from John Padgett to Mark Dundore; Greg Sieg; David Decurtis471 DeCurtis_01459694 DeCurtis_01459696 Email from John Padgett to John Zajac; Derek Fournier; Michael Jungen et al.472 DeCurtis_01459777 DeCurtis_01459780 Door lock pdf473 DeCurtis_01461494 DeCurtis_01461499 DeCurtis Cruise Experience474 DeCurtis_01463914 DeCurtis_01463954 Presentation475 DeCurtis_01464407 DeCurtis_01464686 Presentation476 DeCurtis_01465358 DeCurtis_01465359 Invoice

68

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 6
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

477 DeCurtis_01465360 DeCurtis_01465361 Invoice478 DeCurtis_01465362 DeCurtis_01465363 Invoice479 DeCurtis_01465884 DeCurtis_01465889 Ideas and concepts480 DeCurtis_01465996 DeCurtis_01466008 Ideas and concepts481 DeCurtis_01473563 DeCurtis_014735649 Presentation482 DeCurtis_01474502 DeCurtis_01474544 Presentation483 DeCurtis_01486040 DeCurtis_01486041 Email from David DeCurtis to Jim Learish

69

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

484 DeCurtis_01489106 DeCurtis_01489125 Presentation485 DeCurtis_01491115 DeCurtis_01491116 Email from Shawn Nock to David Decurtis; Casey Collins; Jiten Chandiramani; Jim Learish486 DeCurtis_01494562 DeCurtis_01494562 Email from Derek Fournier to Jim Learish487 DeCurtis_01496218 DeCurtis_01496218 Email from Joe Bezzina to David DeCurtis488 DeCurtis_01496668 DeCurtis_01496668 Email from Mitch Learish to David DeCurtis et al.489 DeCurtis_01496669 DeCurtis_01496677 Attachment to Email490 DeCurtis_01496994 DeCurtis_01496999 Email from Helena Sandberg to Jan Elfstrom et al.

70

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

491 DeCurtis_01497000 DeCurtis_01497004 Attachment to Email492 DeCurtis_01497112 DeCurtis_01497114 Email from Jan Elfstrom to David Decurtis; Shawn Nock; Saeed Ghasemi et al.493 DeCurtis_01497767 DeCurtis_01497775 Decurtis Corporation - Wearable494 DeCurtis_01498261 DeCurtis_01498263 Email from Saeed Ghasemi to Shawn Nock; Helena Sandberg; Jan Elfstrom495 DeCurtis_01509331 DeCurtis_01509335 Email between Derek Fournier and Alexander Tavernini496 DeCurtis_01509731 DeCurtis_01509731 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis; Jim Learish497 DeCurtis_01509732 DeCurtis_01509732 Planning document

71

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

498 DeCurtis_01530060 DeCurtis_01530067 Project Proposal499 DeCurtis_01597389 DeCurtis_01597393 ASSA ABLOY Document500 DeCurtis_01607137 DeCurtis_01607137 Email from Joe Carino to David DeCurtis; Derek Fournier; Jim Learish501 DeCurtis_01607138 DeCurtis_01607138 Invoice502 DeCurtis_01612633 DeCurtis_01612633 Invoice503 DeCurtis_01615132 DeCurtis_01615133 Email from Sommer to Aghevi504 DeCurtis_01615903 DeCurtis_01615903 Ship-level Input and Calculations

72

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

505 DeCurtis_01620132 DeCurtis_01620144 ASSA ABLOY Document506 DeCurtis_01620722 DeCurtis_01620729 Email from Jim Learish to Joe Carino et al.507 DeCurtis_01633169 DeCurtis_01633169 Email from Fournier to DeCurtis508 DeCurtis_01638993 DeCurtis_01638995 Email from Derek Fournier to Alexander Tavernini509 DeCurtis_01638996 DeCurtis_01639028 Proposal510 DeCurtis_01639370 DeCurtis_01639372 Email between Derek Fournier and David DeCurtis511 DeCurtis_01641452 DeCurtis_01641453 Email from Glenn Curtis to David DeCurtis; Derek Fournier

73

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

512 DeCurtis_01642458 DeCurtis_01642467 Statement of Work No. 15513 DeCurtis_01643055 DeCurtis_01643070 Email from D. Fournier to D. DeCurtis514 DeCurtis_01643376 DeCurtis_01643385 Email from D. Fournier to D. DeCurtis & J. Learish515 DeCurtis_01654320 DeCurtis_01654324 Email from D. DeCurtis to J. Learish516 DeCurtis_01670280 DeCurtis_01670280 Email from D. DeCurtis to D. Fournier517 DeCurtis_01674015 DeCurtis_01674016 Email from Derek Fournier to Joe Carino; Jim Learish; David DeCurtis518 DeCurtis_01674193 DeCurtis_01674223 Email from Fournier to Wismar

74

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

519 DeCurtis_01674528 DeCurtis_01674530 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis et al.520 DeCurtis_01674622 DeCurtis_01674623 Email from Derek Fournier to Andy Howard521 DeCurtis_01675219 DeCurtis_01675219 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis522 DeCurtis_01694207 DeCurtis_01694209 Email from Derek Fournier to David DeCurtis523 DeCurtis_01696049 DeCurtis_01696050 Email from Richard Criado to Jonathan Kling; Mark Hadland; Chris Massot et al.524 DeCurtis_01699999 DeCurtis_01700000 Email from Joe Carino to David DeCurtis525 DeCurtis_01701454 DeCurtis_01701460 Email from David Herrera to David DeCurtis

75

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

526 DeCurtis_017023932 DeCurtis_01702929 Master Services and Software Maintenance Agreement527 DeCurtis_01703003 DeCurtis_01703010 Email from Herrera to DeCurtis528 DeCurtis_01703008 DeCurtis_01703010 Letter from T. Vann Pearce to Daniel Farkas529 DeCurtis_01703370 DeCurtis_01703372 Email Between David DeCurtis, Harry Sommers, and David Herrera530 DeCurtis_01703955 DeCurtis_01703957 Email from Herrera to DeCurtis531 DeCurtis_01704322 DeCurtis_01704323 Email from Harry Sommer to David DeCurtis532 DeCurtis_01704823 DeCurtis_01704827 Email from David DeCurtis to David Herrera

76

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

533 DeCurtis_01704891 DeCurtis_01704898 Email from David DeCurtis to David Herrera; Harry Sommer534 DeCurtis_01705403 DeCurtis_01705406 Email from Harry Sommer to David DeCurtis535 DeCurtis_01712896 DeCurtis_01712899 Statement of Work No. 9536 DeCurtis_01713929 DeCurtis_01713933 Statement of Work No. 5537 DeCurtis_01714290 DeCurtis_01714295 Email from David DeCurtis to Joe Carino et al.538 DeCurtis_01717845 DeCurtis_01717847 Email from David DeCurtis to Glenn Curtis539 DeCurtis_01729308 DeCurtis_01729309 Email from David Herrera to David DeCurtis; Harry Sommer; Joe Carino

77

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

540 DeCurtis_01732782 DeCurtis_01732782 Email from David Herrera to Joe Carino541 DeCurtis_01733565 DeCurtis_01733659 DeCurtis Q3 Board Meeting542 DeCurtis_01734012 DeCurtis_01734013 Email from Joe Carino to Derek Fournier543 DeCurtis_01734016 DeCurtis_01734019 Email from Joe Carino to Derek Fournier; David DeCurtis; Jim Learish544 DeCurtis_01734043 DeCurtis_01734044 Email from Joe Carino to David DeCurtis545 DeCurtis_01734474 DeCurtis_01734477 Email from Joe Carino546 DeCurtis_01734485 DeCurtis_01734485 Email from Joe Carino to Derek Fournier et al.

78

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 7
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

547 DeCurtis_01736494 DeCurtis_01736495 Email from David DeCurtis to David Herrera; Joe Carino; Dan Farkas; Lincoln Vidal et al.548 DeCurtis_01745597 DeCurtis_01745598 Email from John Padgett to David DeCurtis549 Decurtis_01747379 Decurtis_01747380 Email from Mark Clennon to David DeCurtis550 DeCurtis_01753131 DeCurtis_01753131 Email from A. Leonards to J. Padgett551 DeCurtis_01753132 DeCurtis_01753134 Carnival Vision Project Plan, Attachment to Email552 DeCurtis_01755582 DeCurtis_01755582 Email from A. Leonards to J. Padgett553 DeCurtis_01755640 DeCurtis_01755641 Email from JP to David DeCurtis

79

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

554 DeCurtis_01755712 DeCurtis_01755712 Email from John Padgett to D. DeCurtis555 DeCurtis_01755713 DeCurtis_01755713 Experience Innovation Architecture556 DeCurtis_01759239 DeCurtis_01759249 Door Lock Requirements Document557 DeCurtis_01759296 DeCurtis_01759296 Email from Blaine Schmidt to David DeCurtis et al.558 DeCurtis_01759297 DeCurtis_01759307 Door Lock Requirements Document, Attachment to Email559 DeCurtis_01773072 DeCurtis_01773080 Email from Mark Hughes to Joe Bezzina560 DeCurtis_01786979 DeCurtis_01786980 Location Services Joint Development Agreement <draft>

80

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

561 DeCurtis_01789075 DeCurtis_01789078 Email from David DeCurtis to Blaine Schmidt562 DeCurtis_01793978 DeCurtis_01793978 Gangway High Level Architecture563 DeCurtis_01793979 DeCurtis_01793979 Restaurant Service564 DeCurtis_01793980 DeCurtis_01793980 GFF Diagram565 DeCurtis_01793981 DeCurtis_01793981 GFF Architecture566 DeCurtis_01793982 DeCurtis_01793982 CDA - Resort Mode567 DeCurtis_01793983 DeCurtis_01793985 Quick Architecture Logical View

81

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

568 DeCurtis_01879174 DeCurtis_01879177 Email from David Herrera to David DeCurtis; Joe Carino569 DeCurtis_01879179 DeCurtis_01879179 Transaction Information570 DeCurtis_01880736 DeCurtis_01880741 Order Location Service571 DeCurtis_01882317 DeCurtis_01882317 Be Our Guest Restaurant Technology of the Year Award572 DeCurtis_01882318 DeCurtis_01882318 Be Our Guest Restaurant Technology of the Year Award573 DeCurtis_01945577 DeCurtis_01945795 DeCurtis Strategy Session Offsite Agenda574 DeCurtis_01945580 DeCurtis_01945622 Presentation

82

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

575 DeCurtis_01946098 DeCurtis_01946151 Presentation576 DeCurtis_01961733 DeCurtis_01961733 Model - Excel577 DeCurtis_01962520 DeCurtis_01962541 Email from David Decurtis to Jim Learish578 DeCurtis_01962521 DeCurtis_01962524 SOW579 DeCurtis_01962525 DeCurtis_01962527 Master Services Agreement to DeCurtis Corporation580 DeCurtis_01976165 DeCurtis_01976166 Email from Derek Fournier to Alexander Tavernini581 DeCurtis_01977228 DeCurtis_01977229 From B. Rankin to M. Jungen

83

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

582 DeCurtis_01982513 DeCurtis_01982521 Technical Specification583 DeCurtis_01983568 DeCurtis_01983592 Applied Cryptography - Protocols, Algorithms, and Source Code in C (Foundations)584 DeCurtis_01984201 DeCurtis_01984268 CC1310585 DeCurtis_01984269 DeCurtis_01984274 Secure Channel586 DeCurtis_01984275 DeCurtis_01985088 The Handbook of Applied Cryptography587 DeCurtis_01985089 DeCurtis_01985089

Encyclopedia Britannica - Electromagnetic Spectrum (July 21, 2015 Wayback MachineCache).pdf

588 DeCurtis_01985138 DeCurtis_01985316 Introduction to Microstrip Antennas

84

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

589 DeCurtis_01985436 DeCurtis_01985469

Kahn, J. M., & Barry, J. R. (1997). Wireless infrared communications. Proceedings of the IEEE,85(2), 265-298 at 265

590 DeCurtis_01985473 DeCurtis_01985494 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_battery_sizes591 DeCurtis_01985495 DeCurtis_01985505

Marsh, G. W., & Kahn, J. M. (1997). Channel reuse strategies for indoor infrared wirelesscommunications. IEEE Transactions on Communications, 45(10), 1280-1290

592 DeCurtis_01985512 DeCurtis_01985515 Microsoft Computer Dictionary, Fifth Edition593 DeCurtis_01985517 DeCurtis_01985519 New Oxford American Dictionary, First Edition594 DeCurtis_01985520 DeCurtis_01985522

Newton, H. (2013). Newton’s Telecommunication Dictionary. United Book Press, TwentySeventh Edition at 977

595 DeCurtis_01985523 DeCurtis_01985565 BLE Antenna Design Guide Rev. 2.0

85

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

596 DeCurtis_01985566 DeCurtis_01985571

Globe News Wire article "Nytec Designed and Engineered Technology that Brings CarnivalCorporation Ocean Medallion (TM ) Wearable and Network of Intelligent Sensors to Life"

597 DeCurtis_01985572 DeCurtis_01985574

Oxford University Press. (2005). Oxford Dictionary of Electronics and Electrical Engineering,Fourth Edition at 506

598 DeCurtis_01985575 DeCurtis_01985582 Radio Systems Engineering (Steven W. Ellingson)599 DeCurtis_01985583 DeCurtis_01985585 Random House Webster's Computer and Internet Dictionary600 DeCurtis_01985589 DeCurtis_01985591

Petersen, J. K. (2002). The telecommunications illustrated dictionary. CRC press, SecondEdition at 776

601 DeCurtis_01985592 DeCurtis_01985604 Texas Instruments Application Report - Antenna Design Guide for the TRF79xxA

602 DeCurtis_01985605 DeCurtis_01985622 US Patent 8,730,004 ("Elfstrom")

86

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

603 DeCurtis_01985623 DeCurtis_01985633 US Patent 10,091,633 ("Ghabra")604 DeCurtis_01985802 DeCurtis_01985804 Wiley Electrical and Electronics Engineering Dictionary by Steven M. Kaplan605 DeCurtis_01985805 DeCurtis_01985815

Carruthers, J. B. (2002). Wireless infrared communications. Wiley Encyclopedia ofTelecommunications, 5, 2925-2931 at 2930

606 DeCurtis_01985816 DeCurtis_01985823

Val, T., Peyrard, F., & Misson, M. (2003). Study and simulation of the infrared WLAN IrDA: analternative to the radio. Computer Communications, 26(11), 1210-1218 at Abstract

607 DeCurtis_01985824 DeCurtis_01986009

Yepes, D., at al., Practical Hardware and Software Add-Ons to Enhance the Security of MobileDevice Operations

608 DeCurtis_01986014 DeCurtis_01986015 Glossary - Secure Channel609 DeCurtis_01986016 DeCurtis_01986017 Infrared Products Home Page

87

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

610 DeCurtis_01986023 DeCurtis_01986028 Kirkland Reporter article "Nytec unveils new technology for Carnival cruises"611 DeCurtis_01986096 DeCurtis_01986100 Wikipedia - Secure Channel612 DeCurtis_01986097 DeCurtis_01986097 TIR2000 4-MBPS IrDA EVM613 DeCurtis_01986986 DeCurtis_01986986 Email from Aghevli to Fournier614 DeCurtis_01987714 DeCurtis_01987724 Email from David DeCurtis to John Padgett615 DeCurtis_01987715 DeCurtis_01987724 DeCurtis Cruise Development Experience Doc616 DeCurtis_01987725 DeCurtis_01987728 Email from D. DeCurtis to J. Padgett

88

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 8
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

617 DeCurtis_01987729 DeCurtis_01987734 Email from D. DeCurtis to J. Pagett and attachment618 DeCurtis_01987959 DeCurtis_01987976 Services Agreement619 DeCurtis_01988391 DeCurtis_01988394 Letter from Daniel S. Farkas to Derek Fournier620 DeCurtis_01990422 DeCurtis_01990424 Email chain from David Fournier to David Herrera621 DeCurtis_01990501 DeCurtis_01990501 Email from Derek Fournier to Frank Del Rio622 DeCurtis_01990966 DeCurtis_01990967 Email from Babak Aghevli to Harry Sommer et al.623 DeCurtis_01991244 DeCurtis_01991244 Invoice

89

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

624 DeCurtis_01991245 DeCurtis_01991245 Invoice625 DeCurtis_01991561 DeCurtis_001991583 Second Amendment to Software Development Agreement626 DeCurtis_01991566 DeCurtis_01991569 Second Amendment to Software Development Agreement627 DeCurtis_01993131 DeCurtis_01993131 Email from Paul Schottland to Derek Fourier628 DeCurtis_01994948 DeCurtis_01995003 Updates629 DeCurtis_01999953 DeCurtis_01999955 Agreement630 DeCurtis_01999956 DeCurtis_02000007 Agreement

90

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

631 DeCurtis_02000008 DeCurtis_02000013 Agreement632 DeCurtis_02000014 DeCurtis_02000035 Agreement633 DeCurtis_02000032 DeCurtis_02000035 Agreement634 DeCurtis_02000036 DeCurtis_02000044 Agreement635 DeCurtis_02000045 DeCurtis_02000053 Agreement636 DeCurtis_02001890 DeCurtis_02001897 Email from D. DeCurtis to D. Fournier637 DeCurtis_02002250 DeCurtis_02002255 Email from David DeCurtis to Michael Jungen; Jonathan Zegers; Douglas Steele et al.

91

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

638 DeCurtis_02003705 DeCurtis_02003707 National Restaurant Association Finalists639 DeCurtis_02003745 DeCurtis_02003745 Adam's MagicBand depiction640 DeCurtis_02003752 DeCurtis_02003752 Email from Adam Leonards to Kristin Ong; Mark Lewis; Richard Criado; et al. Jungen641 DeCurtis_02003964 DeCurtis_02003969 Email from David Herrera to David DeCurtis642 DeCurtis_02005673 DeCurtis_02005673 Email from David DeCurtis to John Padgett643 DeCurtis_02006495 DeCurtis_02006496 Email from David Herrera to Joe Carino; David DeCurtis; Harry Sommer644 DeCurtis_02006659 DeCurtis_02006664 2013-10-27 Re: DCL

92

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

645 DeCurtis_02006968 DeCurtis_02006968 Email from D. DeCurtis to M. Jungen646 DeCurtis_02007761 DeCurtis_02007762 Email from Derek Fournier to Camille Olivere; Joe Carino647 DeCurtis_02007826 DeCurtis_02007835 Email from Joe Carino to David Herrera648 DeCurtis_02008382 DeCurtis_02008382 Email from JP to Adam Leonards et al.649 DeCurtis_02008383 DeCurtis_02008383 Attachment to Email650 DECURTIS_2-00002069 DECURTIS_2- 00002085 US Patent Application 2017/0116561 ("Saddler")651 DECURTIS-SC-000001 DECURTIS-SC-000097 DeCurtis Source Code

93

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

652 DECURTIS-SC-000098 DECURTIS-SC-000241 DeCurtis Source Code653 DECURTIS-SC-000242 DECURTIS-SC-000293 DeCurtis Source Code654 DECURTIS-SC-000294 DECURTIS-SC-000502 DeCurtis Source Code655 DECURTIS-SC-000503 DECURTIS-SC-000511 DeCurtis Source Code656 DPEP 00001 DPEP 00189 Guest Detected At Table657 DPEP-00001 DPEP-00002 Flowcharts658 DPEP-00007 DPEP-00017 Order Location Service

94

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

659 DPEP-00027 DPEP-00027 Inside Architecture Diagram660 DPEP-00071 DPEP-00073 xConnect System661 DPEP-00074 DPEP-00110 Master Services and Software Maintenance Agreement662 DPEP-00117 DPEP-00189 Application documentation from 2012663 DPEP-00269 DPEP-00273 SOW No. 10664 DPEP-00277 DPEP-00280 SOW No. 39665 DPEP-00281 DPEP-00284 SOW No. 29

95

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

666 DPEP-00285 DPEP-00289 SOW No. 34667 DPEP-00290 DPEP-00293 SOW No. 35668 DPEP-00294 DPEP-00298 SOW No. 36669 DPEP-00299 DPEP-00304 SOW No. 37670 DPEP-20001 DPEP-20062 Detailed Database Design671 DPEP-20026 DPEP-20026 Disney Cruise Line Data672 DPEP-20063 DPEP-20079 Database Design

96

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

673 DPEP-20083 DPEP-20196 Database Design674 DPEP-20204 DPEP-21638 Scope Document675 DPEP-20243 DPEP-20290 Architecture Document676 DPEP-20332 DPEP-20362 Log Document677 DPEP-20363 DPEP-20435 Technical Support Document678 DPEP-20436 DPEP-20503 Technical Support Document679 DPEP-20504 DPEP-20550 Troubleshooting Guide

97

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

680 DPEP-20594 DPEP-20603 Technical Support Document681 DPEP-21612 DPEP-21638 MyMagic+ Products and Services July Town Hall682 DPEP-21792 DPEP-21805 xConnect Product Suite683 DPEP-24692 DPEP-24702 Investigation Report684 DPEP-24993 DPEP-25011 Door Lock Prototype Development Overview685 EVR0000032 EVR0000033 Litigation Summary686 GlennCurtis-0001 GlennCurtis-0044 EIC Vision

98

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 9
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

687 GlennCurtis-0045 GlennCurtis-0057 Ideas and concepts688 JAYCON_0003467 JAYCON_0003468 Email from David DeCurtis to AJ Gutierrez689 JP_CC_00000127 JP_CC_00000143 100_Day Plan 5690 JP_CC_00000175 JP_CC_00000234 Email from Juan-David Quinones to John Padgett691 JP_CC_00000330 JP_CC_00000330 Email from JP to David DeCurtis692 JP_CC_00000333 JP_CC_00000333 Email from JP to David DeCurtis693 JP_CC_00000454 JP_CC_00000454 Email from JP to David DeCurtis

99

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

694 JP_CC_00000565 JP_CC_00000565 Email from JP to David DeCurtis695 JP_CC_00000634 JP_CC_00000634 Email from JP to David DeCurtis696 Launch Consulting_0015707 Launch Consulting_0015736 Product Requirements Document IO Node

697 MJ_CC_00000058 MJ_CC_00000064 Email from Michael Jungen to Adam Leonards; Glenn Curtis; Craig Feldman698 MJ_CC_00000068 MJ_CC_00000071 Email from Karl Sestak to Michael Jungen699 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Amended Notice of Videotaped Remote Deposition of Vincent Ball700 N/A N/A Interview

100

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

701 N/A N/A Patent File History for US Patent 10,045,184702 N/A N/A US Patent 10,045,184703 N/A N/A US Patent 10,157,514704 N/A N/A Patent File History for US Patent 10,157,514705 N/A N/A US Patent 10,049,516706 N/A N/A Patent File History for US Patent 10,049,516707 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Stephen Becker

101

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

708 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Deposition of Stephen Becker709 N/A N/A Stephen Becker LinkedIn Profile710 N/A N/A Combined Declaration and Assignment for Patent Application711 N/A N/A Combined Declaration and Assignment for Patent Application for US Patent 10,049,516712 N/A N/A Combined Declaration and Assignment for Patent Application for US Patent 10,157,514713 N/A N/A Patent Applications Handbook § 5:17 Introduction—Determining inventorship714 N/A N/A Patent Applications Handbook § 6:81. Avoiding inequitable conduct

102

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

715 N/A N/A Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary - 11th Edition716 N/A N/A

Investor Relations, News Release: Fast Company Ranks Carnival Corporation as a MostInnovative Company for 2017

717 N/A N/A Carnival Corporation Recognized as CES 2019 Innovation Awards Honoree for OceanMedallion718 N/A N/A Plaintiff Carnival Corporation's First Set of Interrogatories Pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.Pro 33719 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation's First Set of Requests for Production of Documents Pursuant toFed.R.Civ.Pro 34

720 N/A N/A

Answers of DeCurtis LLC and DeCurtis Corp. to Carnival Corporation's First Set ofInterrogatories

721 N/A N/A

Responses of DeCurtis LLC and DeCurtis Corp. to Carnival's First Set of Requests for Production of Documents

103

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

722 N/A N/A First Amended Answers of DeCurtis LLC and DeCurtis Corp. to Carnival Corporation's First Set of Interrogatories723 N/A N/A Email from Pearce to Schmidt724 N/A N/A Carnival Corporation's First Notice of 30(B)(6) Deposition to Defendant DeCurtis LLC725 N/A N/A Email from Najemy726 N/A N/A First Preliminary Amendment Under 37 C.F.R. §1.115 (Application NO: 15/459,906)727 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Richard Criado728 N/A N/A Richard Criado LinkedIn Profile

104

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

729 N/A N/A Email from Scott Henderson to John Stiehl; David Gross; Michell Cooper730 N/A N/A Thumbs Up Photo731 N/A N/A Email from Manny Vellon to Disney_XBand_Synapsters; David Gross; David DeCurtis et al.732 N/A N/A Email from Rich Criado to Randy Chancey; David DeCurtis; Kristin Ong et al.733 N/A N/A Pucks and the Puck Keys Photo734 N/A N/A Email from Jungen to Douglas Steele; Richard Criado; Mark Lewis et al.735 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Glenn Curtis

105

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

736 N/A N/A

Combined Declaration and Assignment for Patent Application for Wireless Guest EngagementSystem

737 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Glenn Curtis738 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2017/0048495 ("Scalisi")739 N/A N/A Application No. 15/460,997 - Reply to Office Action of January 22, 2018 - Remarks740 N/A N/A Application/Control Number: 15/460,997 - Claim Rejection741 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Deposition of Arnold Donald742 N/A N/A

Declaration of Dr. William R. Eisenstadt in Support of Carnival's Opposition to DeCurtis' Motionfor Summary Judgment

106

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

743 N/A N/A Curriculum Vitae of William Richard Eisenstadt744 N/A N/A Design of Compact Adaptive RF Matching Circuits using Square Split Ring Resonators745 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoenas to Third-Party Assa Abloy Global Solutions, Inc.746 N/A N/A Assa Abloy Marine Product Catalogue 2016747 N/A N/A Estimote, http://estimote.com748 N/A N/A

Giorgio Corbellini, Stefan Schmid, and Stefan Mangold all at Disney Research in Zurich Switzerland, “Two-Way Communication Protocol using Bluetooth Low Energy Advertisement Frames”http://disneyresearch.s3.amazonaws.com/wpcontent/uploads/20160314235049/Two-WayCommunication-Protocol-using-Bluetooth-Low-EnergyAdvertisement-Frames-Paper.pdf

107

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

749 N/A N/A Declaration of Francis Farro750 N/A N/A Supplemental Declaration of Francis Farro751 N/A N/A

Tim Andersson, “Bluetooth Low Energy and Smartphones for Proximity-Based Automatic Door Locks,” Final Thesis presented to the Department of Computer and Information Science at theInstitutionen for Datavetenskap (June 8, 2014)

752 N/A N/A Advanced Encryption Standard en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Encryption_Standard753 N/A N/A

Apple Watch Edition - Technical Specifications https://web.archive.org/web/201604262041 19mp_/https://support.apple.com/kb/SP737?viewlocale=en_US&locale=en_US

754 N/A N/A Bernstein, et al., TweetNaCl: "A crypto library in 100 tweets", LatinCrypt 2014755 N/A N/A

BLE Link Layer Security Featureshttps://microchipdeveloper.com/wireless:ble-link-layersecurity

108

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

756 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation’s Objections and Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s Second Set of Requests forProduction of Documents (Nos. 88-90)

757 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation's Answer and Affirmative Defenses to Decurtis LLC's First AmendedComplaint

758 N/A N/A Carnival’s Objections and Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s First Set of Requests for Admission759 N/A N/A Carnival’s Objections and Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s Sixth Set of Interrogatories (No. 22)760 N/A N/A Carnival’s Opening Claim Construction Brief761 N/A N/A Carnival’s Response to DeCurtis LLC’s Fourth Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 19-20)762 N/A N/A Carnival’s Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s Fifth Set of Interrogatories (No. 21)

109

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

763 N/A N/A Carnival’s Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s Third Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 16-18)764 N/A N/A

Christian Alexander Goosen, Design and Implementation of a Bluetooth 4.2 LE Infrastructure for Mobile Devices, Ulm University, Faculty of Engineering and Informatics (December 2, 2014)

765 N/A N/A

Daniel J. Bernstein, The Poly1305-AES MessageAuthentication Codehttps://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/11502760_3#:~:text=Poly1305%2DAES%20is%20a% 20state,and%20a%2016%2Dbyte%20nonce

766 N/A N/A Disney's $1B Bet on a Magical Wristband https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9177375767 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 1768 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 2769 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 3

110

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

770 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 4771 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 5772 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 6773 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 7774 N/A N/A Invalidity Contentions Rider 8775 N/A N/A

Kalamandeen, A., Scannell, A., de Lara, E., Sheth, A., & LaMarca, A. (2010, June 15-18). "Ensemble: Cooperative Proximity-based Authentication", In MobiSys ‘10 (pp. 331-343).

776 N/A N/A

M. Jakobsson and S. Wetzel. “Security Weaknesses in Bluetooth”, In CT– RSA ’01. LNCS 2020. Springer-Verlag, 2001. pp. 176–191.

111

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

777 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Amended Objections and Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s First Setof Requests for Production of Documents (Nos. 1-87)

778 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Objections and Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s First Set ofInterrogatories

779 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Objections and Responses to DeCurtis LLC’s Third/Fourth Setof Requests for Production of Documents (Nos. 91-114)

780 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Objections and Responses to Defendant DeCurtis LLC’s ThirdSet of Requests for Production of Documents (Nos. 91-95)

781 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Objections and Supplemental Responses to DeCurtis’ First Set oInterrogatories

782 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Second Supplemental Response to Defendant DeCurtis LLC’sFirst Set of Interrogatories (No. 1)

783 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Second Supplemental Response to Defendant DeCurtis LLC’sSecond Set of Interrogatories (No. 6)

112

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

784 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Supplemental Response to DeCurtis LLC’s Second Set ofInterrogatories (No. 13)

785 N/A N/A US Patent 8,994,827786 N/A N/A US Patent 9,832,020787 N/A N/A US Patent 9,955,289788 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2010/0052916789 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0180327790 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2018/0005469

113

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

791 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2019/0108699792 N/A N/A US Provisional Application No. 15/459,906793 N/A N/A US Provisional Application No. 15/460,983794 N/A N/A US Provisional Application No. 61/948,470795 N/A N/A US Provisional Application No. 62/420,998796 N/A N/A WIPO 2006/098690797 N/A N/A WIPO 2016/185013

114

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

798 N/A N/A

Christian Alexander Goosen, "Design and Implementation of a Bluetooth 4.0 LE Infrastructurefor Mobile Devices", Ulm University, Faculty of Engineering and Informatics (May 16, 2014)

799 N/A N/A Carnival’s Responsive Claim Construction Brief

800 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0198287

801 N/A N/A Joint Claim Construction and Prehearing Statement and all relevant briefing802 N/A N/A

Michael Jungen “From MagicBand to Ocean Medallion: Using Interactive Devices to Unlock Next-Generation Guest Experiences”https://members nfcw.com/3193/from-magicband-to-oceanmedallion/

803 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation’s Third Supplemental Response to Defendant DeCurtis LLC’s Second Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 4, 7-12 & 15)

804 N/A N/A

Ultra-low Power Wireless System On-Chip Solution - Product Specification v.1.6https://infocenter nordicsemi.com/pdf/nRF24LE1_PS_v1.6.pdf

115

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

805 N/A N/A US Patent 10,431,026806 N/A N/A US Patent 9,589,402807 N/A N/A Specification of the Bluetooth System, Covered Core Package version: 4.0808 N/A N/A US Patent 9,483,887809 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0308859 ("Barry")810 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0284147811 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2015/0178532

116

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

812 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0366858 ("Seltzer")813 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Michael Jungen814 N/A N/A Separation Agreement between Michael Jungen and Carnival Corporation815 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Sander Lam816 N/A N/A Article titled "Nytec Unveils New Technology for Carnival Cruises"817 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Adam Leonards818 N/A N/A Adam Leonards LinkedIn Profile

117

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

819 N/A N/A

“No Sail Order and Suspension of Further Embarkation; Third Modification and Extension of No Sail Order and Other Measures Related to Operations,” Federal Register, 85(193), available at https://www federalregister.gov/documents/2020/10/05/2020-

22030/no-sail-order-and suspension-of-further-embarkationthird-modification-and-extension-of-no-sail, accessed onFebruary 10, 2022

820 N/A N/A

Adam Coulter, “What Cruise COVID-19 Changes Are Likely Here to Stay–And What’s Not,” Cruise Critic, available at https://www.cruisecritic.com/articles.cfm?ID=5731, accessed on February 8, 2022

821 N/A N/A

Aswath Damodaran, “Discount Rates, The D in the DCF,” pp. 21–112, available at https://people.stern.nyu.edu/adamodar/pdfiles/eqnotes/dcfrates.pdf, accessed on February 22,2022

822 N/A N/A

Aswath Damodaran, “Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds, and Bills - United States,” available a https://pages.stern nyu.edu/~adamodar/pc/datasets/histretSP.xls, accessed on January 25, 2022

823 N/A N/A

Aswath Damodaran, “Levered and Unlevered Betas by Industry: U.S.,” available athttps://pages.stern nyu.edu/~adamodar/pc/datasets/betas xls, accessed on January 25, 2022

824 N/A N/A

Aswath Damodaran, “Margins by Sector (US),” available at https://pages.stern nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/margin html, accessed onFebruary 20, 2022

118

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

825 N/A N/A

Callum Cyrus, “Royal Caribbean Cruises Creatively with Intelligent IoT Bracelet,” IOT World Today, available at https://www.iotworldtoday.com/2021/10/07/royal-caribbeancruisescreatively-with-intelligent-iot-bracelet/, accessed on February 3, 2022

826 N/A N/A Carnival Corporation and PLC, SEC Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended November 30, 2019827 N/A N/A

CDC, “Cruise ship No Sail Order extended through September 2020,” available at https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2020/s0716-cruise-shipno-sail-order.html, accessed onFebruary 10, 2022

828 N/A N/A

Christopher C. Klein, “The Economics of Sham Litigation: Theory, Cases, and Policy,” Bureau o Economics Staff Report to the Federal Trade Commission, available at https://www ftc.gov/reports/economics-sham-litigationtheory-cases-policy, accessed on February28, 2022

829 N/A N/A

Cruise Critic, “What to Expect on a Cruise: Getting Off the Ship,” available athttps://www.cruisecritic.com/articles.cfm?ID=63 , accessed on February 19, 2022

830 N/A N/A

Cruise Critic, “What to Expect on a Cruise: Visiting Cruise Ports,” available athttps://www.cruisecritic.com/articles.cfm?ID=1161, accessed on February 1, 2022

119

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

831 N/A N/A Cruise Industry News, “Cruise Industry News 2021 Annual Report”

832 N/A N/A

Cruise Industry News, “The Evolution of the Cruise Ship Safety Drill,” available athttps://www.cruiseindustrynews.com/cruise-news/25377-the-evolution-of-the-cruise-ship-safety drill html, accessed on February 8, 2022

833 N/A N/A

Cruise Line International Association, “State of the Cruise Industry Outlook 2022 available at https://cruising.org/-/media/clia-media/research/2022/clia-state-of the-cruiseindustry2022_updated.ashx, accessed on February 8, 2022

834 N/A N/A

Cruise Line International Association, “State of the Cruise Industry Outlook 2022,” available at https://cruising.org/-/media/clia-media/research/2022/clia-state-of-the-cruiseindustry2022_updated.ashx, accessed on February 8, 2022

835 N/A N/A

Cruise Lines International Association, “Cruise Travel Report,” available at https://cruising.org/-/media/research-updates/research/consumer-research/2018-

clia-travel-report.pdf

836 N/A N/A

Cruise Market Watch, “Cruise Pulse,” available at https://cruisemarketwatch.com/cruise-pulse/, accessed on February 1, 2022

837 N/A N/A

Cruise Market Watch, “Current COVID-19 Cruise Line and Cruise Ship Sailing Cancellations,”available at https://cruisemarketwatch.com/current-covid-19-cruise-line-and-cruise-ship-sailing- cancellations/, accessed on February 3, 2022

120

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

838 N/A N/A

Dean Takahashi, “Princess retrofits more ships with Medallion wearables for the day when we ca cruise again,” VentureBeat, available at https://venturebeat.com/2020/12/21/carnival-retrofits- moreships-with-medallion-wearables-for-the-day-when-we-cancruise-again/, accessed onJanuary 21, 2022

839 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Activity Reservations Suite, “Eases Reservation Management,” available https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/ActivityReservation_ProductSheet.pdf accessed on February 17, 2022

840 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Activity Reservations Suite,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/activity-reservations-suite/, accessed on January 21, 2022

841 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “DeCurtis ShieldTM for Cruise,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/sea/decurtis-shield/, accessed on February 8, 2022

842 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Embarkation Suite,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/embarkation-suite/, accessed on January 21, 2022

843 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Food & Beverage Suite,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/food-beverage-suite/, accessed on January 21, 2022

844 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Food & Beverage,” available at https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2020/05/DeCurtis_FoodBeverageModuleSheet.pdf, accessed on February 17, 2022

121

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

845 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Hardware, Wearables & Fulfillment,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/hardware-wearablesfulfillment/, accessed on January 21, 2022

846 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Housekeeping Suite,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/housekeeping-suite/, accessed on January 21, 2022

847 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Location and Proximity,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/sea/location-proximity/, accessed on January 21, 2022

848 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Media Suite,” available at https://www.decurtis.com/suites/media-suite/,accessed on January 21, 2022

849 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Mobile Assembly Suite,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/mobile-assembly-suite/, accessed on February 15, 2022

850 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Table Management Suite,” available athttps://www.decurtis.com/suites/table-management-suite/, 

accessed on January 21, 2022

851 N/A N/A

DeCurtis Corporation, “Transformational Experience Technology,” available at,https://www.decurtis.com/decurtis-experienceplatform/transformationalexperiencetech/, accesse on January 21, 2022

122

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

852 N/A N/A

Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission, “Horizontal Merger Guidelines,” available at https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/atr/legacy/2010/08/19/hmg-2010.pdf, accessed onMarch 1, 2022

853 N/A N/A

Dori Saltzman, “What Lines Are Doing With Next-Gen Cruise Technology,” CruiseCritic.com,available at https://www.cruisecritic.com/articles.cfm?ID=3885, accessed on February 4, 2022

854 N/A N/A

Erica Silverstein, “Top 10 Reasons to Take a Cruise,” available at https://abcnews.go.com/Travel/top-reasonscruise-family-friendly-affordable-vacationdeals/story?id=11796434 accessed on February 19, 2022

855 N/A N/A

Greg Dorai, “DeCurtis and Cisco: Cruising Right Along with ADP,” Cisco, available at https://blogs.cisco.com/networking/decurtis-and-ciscocruising-right-along-with-adp, accessed onFebruary 15, 2022

856 N/A N/A

Heidi Sarna, “Cruise Ship Safety: What to Expect in a Muster Drill,” Frommers, available athttps://www frommers.com/tips/cruise/cruise-ship-safetywhat-to-expect-in-a-muster-drill, accessed on January 21, 2022

857 N/A N/A

Jason Cochran, “Carnival's New ‘Ocean Medallions’ Track Every Move—And Make Spending Thoughtless,” Frommers, available at https://www frommers.com/tips/cruise/carnivals-new-ocean medallions-track-every-moveand-make-spendingthoughtless, accessed on January 21, 2022

123

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

858 N/A N/A

Johanna Jainchill, “Cruise line contactless technology: Once a novelty, now a Covid-era necessity,” Travel Weekly, available at https://www.travelweekly.com/CruiseTravel/Cruise-lines contactless-technology-Once-noveltynow-Covid-era-necessity, accessed on January 21, 2022

859 N/A N/A

Johanna Jainchill, “NCL's second Prima-class ship to be named Norwegian Viva,” Travel Weekly available at https://www.travelweekly.com/Cruise-Travel/NCL-secondPrima-ship-NorwegianViva, accessed on February 12, 2022

860 N/A N/A

Julie Weed, “Cruise Lines Use Technology to Add the Personal Touch,” The New York Times, available at https://www nytimes.com/2019/02/01/travel/cruise-lines-usetechnology-to-add-thepersonal-touch.html, accessed on January 21, 2022

861 N/A N/A

Julie Weed, “Cruise Lines Use Technology to Add the Personal Touch,” The New York Times, available at https://www nytimes.com/2019/02/01/travel/cruise-lines-usetechnology-to-add-the- personal-touch html, accessed on January 21, 2022

862 N/A N/A

Matt Hochberg, “Royal Caribbean patents new way to alert cruise ship passengers in their cabin,” Royal Caribbean Blog, available at https://www royalcaribbeanblog.com/2021/07/06/royalcaribbean-patents-new-way-alert-cruise-ship-passengerstheir-cabin, accessed on February 8,2022

863 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “Annual Report 2020,” available at https://www msccruises.com/en-gl/Assets/A-R2020.pdf, accessed on February 12, 2022

124

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

864 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Armonia,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/mscarmonia, accessed on February 20, 2022

865 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Bellissima,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/mscbellissima, accessed on February 20, 2022

866 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Divina,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/mscdivinia, accessed on February 20, 2022

867 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Fantasia,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc- fantasia, accessed on February 20, 2022

868 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Grandiosa,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/mscgrandiosa, accessed on February 20, 2022

869 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Lirica,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-lirica,accessed on February 20, 2022

870 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Magnifica,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/mscmagnifica, accessed on February 20, 2022

125

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

871 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Meraviglia,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/mscmeraviglia, accessed on February 20, 2022

872 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Musica,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-musica, accessed on February 20, 2022

873 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Opera,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-opera, accessed on February 20, 2022

874 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Orchestra,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-orchestra, accessed on February 20, 2022

875 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Poesia,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-poesia, accessed on February 20, 2022

876 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Preziosa,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-preziosa, accessed on February 20, 2022

877 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Seashore,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-seashore, accessed on February 20, 2022

126

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

878 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Seaside,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-seaside, accessed on February 20, 2022

879 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Seaview,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-seaview, accessed on February 20, 2022

880 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Sinfonia,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-D889 sinfonia, accessed on February 20, 2022

881 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Splendida,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-splendida, accessed on February 20, 2022

882 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC Virtuosa,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-virtuosa, accessed on February 20, 2022

883 N/A N/A

MSC Cruises, “MSC World Europa,” available at https://www msccruisesusa.com/cruise/ships/msc-worldeuropa, accessed on February 20, 2022

884 N/A N/A

Nick Huntington-Klein, “The Effect: An Introduction to Research Design and Causality,” (London: Chapman and Hall, 2022), available at https://theeffectbook net/chFixedEffects html#how-does-it-work, accessed on February 28, 2022

127

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

885 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Bliss,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/bliss, accessed on February 19, 2022

886 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Breakaway,” available at https://www.ncl.com/cruiseship/breakaway, accessed on February 19, 2022

887 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Dawn,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/dawn,accessed on February 19, 2022

888 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Encore,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruiseship/encore, accessed on February 19, 2022

889 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Epic,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/epic, accessed on February 19, 2022

890 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Escape,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruiseship/escape, accessed on February 19, 2022

891 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Gem,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/gem,accessed on February 19, 2022

128

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

892 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Getaway,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruiseship/getaway, accessed on February 19, 2022

893 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Jade,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/jade,accessed on February 19, 2022

894 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Jewel,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/jewel,accessed on February 19, 2022

895 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Joy,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/joy,accessed on February 19, 2022

896 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Pearl,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/pearl,accessed on February 19, 2022

897 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Prima,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise/prima,accessed on February 21, 2022

898 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Sky,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/sky, accessed on February 19, 2022

129

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

899 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Spirit,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/spirit,accessed on February 19, 2022

900 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Star,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/star,accessed on February 19, 2022

901 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Sun,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/sun,accessed on February 19, 2022

902 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Viva,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise/viva,accessed on February 21, 2022

903 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Norwegian Viva,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise/viva,accessed on February 21, 2022

904 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Line, “Pride of America,” available at https://www ncl.com/cruise-ship/pride-oamerica, accessed on February 19, 2022

130

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

905 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Lines, “Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Announces Order for Next Generation of Ships for Norwegian Cruise Line ,” available at https://www ncl.com/press- releases/norwegian-cruise-lineholdings-announces order-next-generation-ships-norwegiancruise,accessed on February 23, 2022

906 N/A N/A

Norwegian Cruise Lines, “Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Confirms Orders for Fifth and Sixth Ships in Next Generation of Newbuilds for Norwegian Cruise Line,” available at https://www.ncl.com/press-releases/norwegiancruise-line-holdings-confirms-orders-fifth-andsixth-ships-next-generation-, accessed on February 12, 2022

907 N/A N/A

PhocusWire, “Headed for A Comeback–A Promising Outlook for the Cruise Industry,” availableat https://www.phocuswire.com/headed-for-comebackpromising-outlook-for-cruise-industry, accessed February 8, 2022

908 N/A N/A

Princess Cruises, “It's Time for a REAL Vacation (and One of the Safest!),” available athttps://www.princess.com/plan/cruise-withconfidence/cruise-health/, accessed on January 21, 2022

909 N/A N/A

Princess Cruises, “Princess MedallionClass®,” available at https://www.princess.com/ships-andexperience/ocean-medallion/, accessed on January 21, 2022

131

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

910 N/A N/A

RateGain, “Navigate with AI Powered Revenue Management,” available athttps://rategain.com/cruises-ferries/, accessed on February 11, 2022

911 N/A N/A Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd., SEC Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2020912 N/A N/A

Royal Caribbean International Press Center, “Odyssey of the Seas Fast Facts,” available at https://www royalcaribbeanpresscenter.com/factsheet/33/odyssey-of-the-seas/, accessed on February 21, 2022

913 N/A N/A

Royal Caribbean International Press Center, “Wonder of the Seas Fast Facts,” available athttps://www royalcaribbeanpresscenter.com/factsheet/34/wonder-of-the-seas/, accessed on February 21, 2022

914 N/A N/A

Royal Caribbean International, “How big are Royal Caribbean cruise ships?” available at https://www royalcaribbean.com/faq/questions/how-big-areroyal-caribbean-cruise-ships,accessed on February 20, 2022

915 N/A N/A

Royal Caribbean International, “What is a muster drill (safety briefing) on a Royal Caribbean cruise ship?” available at https://www royalcaribbean.com/faq/questions/muster-drillonboard- safety, accessed on January 21, 2022

132

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

916 N/A N/A

Tanner Callaise, “Explained: Why Are Cruise Ships So Big,” Cruzely.com, available at https://www.cruzely.com/explained-why-are-cruise-ships-sobig/, accessed on February 28, 2022

917 N/A N/A

Tracesafe, “What You Need To Know About The Internet Of Things And Cruise Ships,” available at https://www.tracesafe.io/newsroom/what-you-need-to-knowabout-the-internet-ofthings-and-cruise-ships, accessed on February 4, 2022

918 N/A N/A

U.S. Department of Justice, “Monopoly Power,” Competition and Monopoly: Single-Firm Conduct Under Section 2 of the Sherman Act, available at https://www.justice.gov/atr/competition-and-monopolysingle-firm-conduct-under-section-2-sherman-act-chapter-2

919 N/A N/A

Commission of the European Communities, Case No COMP/M.2706, Carnival Corporation/P&O Princess, Regulation No 4064/89 Merger Procedure, available at https://ec.europa.eu/competition/mergers/cases/decisions/m2706_en.pdf, accessed on March 1, 2022

920 N/A N/A

Federal Trade Commission, “Statement of the Federal Trade Commission Concerning Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd./P&O Princess Cruises plc and Carnival Corporation/P&O Princess Cruises plc, FTC File No. 021 0041,” available at https://www ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cases/2002/10/cruisestatement htm, accessed on March 25, 2022

133

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

921 N/A N/A

Investor Relations, News Release: Carnival Corporation's OceanMedallion Named IoT Wearable Innovation of the Year

922 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Blazer and Flip Flops Inc.923 N/A N/A Decurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Patrick Mendiuk924 N/A N/A Patrick Mendiuk LinkedIn Profile925 N/A N/A Email from Pearce to Schmidt926 N/A N/A Carnival Letter to DeCurtis Corporation927 N/A N/A Letter from Gustman to Pearce

134

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

928 N/A N/A Email from Gustman to Pearce929 N/A N/A Oxford Dictionary of Electronics and Electrical Engineering930 N/A N/A The Telecommunications Illustrated Dictionary, 2nd Edition, Updated and Expanded931 N/A N/A Newton's Telecom Dictionary, 27th Expanded and Updated Edition932 N/A N/A Radio Systems Engineering (Steven W. Ellingson)933 N/A N/A Declaration934 N/A N/A US Patent 10,037,642

135

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

935 N/A N/A US Patent 10,304,271936 N/A N/A Responses of DeCurtis LLC and DeCurtis Corp. to Carnival's Second Set of Interrogatories [Nos. 13-19]937 N/A N/A Subpoena to Produce Document, Information, or Objects or to Permit Inspection of Premises in a Civil Action938 N/A N/A Topics for Examination939 N/A N/A Simon Murray LinkedIn Profile940 N/A N/A Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Ltd., SEC Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2020941 N/A N/A Presentation

136

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

942 N/A N/A Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition of Carnival Corporation943 N/A N/A Email from Laura Najemy to Richard Self; Diana Fassbender; Steven Routh et al.944 N/A N/A Carnival Corporation Second Amended Complaint945 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to John Padgett946 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Notice of Subpoena to Kyle Prestenback947 N/A N/A Kyle Prestenback LinkedIn Profile948 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00383193-195

137

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

949 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00383510-536950 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARRNIVAL00385816-822951 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00383228-233952 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00511411-432953 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00384554-571954 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00448628-629955 N/A N/A Metadata Report of CARNIVAL00478655-656

138

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

956 N/A N/A PCL Caribbean Tracking-Balcony Screenshot957 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00414506-512958 N/A N/A PCL British Isles 12 day Tracking - Inside - 2019-08-27-- SCREENSHOT959 N/A N/A Metadata for CARNIVAL00124806960 N/A N/A CARNIVAL00124806_PCL Mexico Traking insides-- Screenshot961 N/A N/A Metadata Report for CARNIVAL00512910-912962 N/A N/A 977 Spreadsheets Produced by Carnival on November 15, 2021

139

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

963 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's First Requests for Production of Documents to Defendant Carnival Corporation964 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Second Set of Requests for Production of Documents to Carnival Corporation965 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Third Set of Requests for Production of Documents to Carnival Corporation966 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC's Third Set of Requests for Production of Documents to Carnival Corporation967 N/A N/A DeCurtis's Rule 26 Disclosures968 N/A N/A Supplemental Initial Disclosures of Carnival Corporation969 N/A N/A Plaintiff Carnival Corporation's First Amended Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions

140

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

970 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation's Objections and Responses to Defendant DeCurtis LLC's First Set of Request for Production of Documents (Nos. 1-87)

971 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation's Objections and Responses to Defendant DeCurtis LLC's Second Set of Interrogatories (Nos. 4-15)

972 N/A N/A Carnivals Production Volume 1 Meta Data973 N/A N/A Carnivals Production Volume 4 Meta Data974 N/A N/A

Plaintiff Carnival Corporation's Objections and Supplemental Responses to Defendant DeCurtis LLC's First Set of Interrogatories

975 N/A N/A

Bluetooth Low Energyhttps://www nordicsemi.com/Products/Bluetooth-LowEnergy

141

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

976 N/A N/A

Cyr, Britt, Webb Horn, Daniela Miao, and Michael Specter, "Security analysis of wearable fitness devices (fitbit)." Massachusetts Institute of Technology 1 (2014) at 3 https://media kasperskycontenthub.com/wpcontent/uploads/sites/43/2015/03/20082016/17-cyrbrittwebbhorn-specter-dmiao-hacking-fitbit.pdf

977 N/A N/A

Genie Smart Lock Aims for Year-Long Battery Life, TechCrunch, Jul. 22, 2014http://techcrunch.com/2014/07/22/genie-smart-lock/

978 N/A N/A Hotel LED Display Mifare 1 Card Lock (http://www.ecvv.com/product/2490752 html

979 N/A N/A

How NFC Works https://web.archive.org/web/20120128093512/http://nearfieldcommunication.org/how-itworks html

980 N/A N/A

Near Field Communication Technology Standards https://web.archive.org/web/20120128093517/http://nearfieldcommunication.org/technology html

981 N/A N/A

Nokia's low-power Wibree to become Bluetooth standard https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/nokias-low-power-wibreeto-become-bluetooth-standard/

142

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

982 N/A N/A

Nordic Semiconductor is key player in Wibree https://www.edn.com/nordic-semiconductor-is-key-player-inwibree/

983 N/A N/A nRF24LE1 - Ultra-low Power Wireless System On-Chip Solution - Product Specification v1.6984 N/A N/A

Turning an iOS Device into an iBeacon Device https://developer.apple.com/documentation/corelocation/turning_an_ios_device_into_an_ibeacon_device

985 N/A N/A US Patent 9,383,730986 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2004/0199454987 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2010/0308964988 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2012/0154125

143

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

989 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2013/0018661990 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2013/0018684991 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2013/0331027992 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2014/0122148993 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2014/0122170994 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2014/0122263995 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2014/0310651

144

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

996 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0066123997 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0117458998 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2016/0371910999 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2017/0127222

1000 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2020/00597741001 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2021/00295241002 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2021/0092580

145

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1003 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2021/02978361004 N/A N/A Order Regarding Magistrate Judge’s Reports and Recommendations as to Motions to Dismiss1005 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2012/02180761006 N/A N/A WO Patent Application 2016/1776681007 N/A N/A US Patent 10,171,9781008 N/A N/A US Patent 10,499,2281009 N/A N/A DeCurtis LLC’s Notice of Subpoena to Douglas Steele

146

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1010 N/A N/A Complaint against DeCurtis Corporation, DeCurtis LLC1011 N/A N/A Decurtis' Motion for Summary Judgment Regarding Invalidity Under 35 U.S.C. §1121012 N/A N/A Subpoena to Testify at a Deposition in Civil Action to Disney Parks, Experiences and Products, Inc.1013 N/A N/A Article titled "Disney Get Into Wearable Tech With The MagicBand"1014 N/A N/A Article titled "Disney's $1 Billion Bet on a Magical Wristband"1015 N/A N/A xConnect System Interactions1016 N/A N/A Door Lock Prototype Development Overview

147

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1017 N/A N/A State of Door Locks1018 N/A N/A US Patent 8,205,3701019 N/A N/A US Patent 8,479,4261020 N/A N/A US Patent 8,601,7311021 N/A N/A US Patent 8,250,7971022 N/A N/A US Patent 8,250,7961023 N/A N/A US Patent 8,276,298

148

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1024 N/A N/A US Patent 8,590,1921025 N/A N/A US Patent 8,296,9831026 N/A N/A Curriculum Vitae of Nicholas P. Godici1027 N/A N/A U.S. Patent Application No. 16/663,9421028 N/A N/A U.S. Patent Application No. 17/067,4681029 N/A N/A U.S. Patent Application No. 17/221,1901030 N/A N/A U.S. Patent Application No. 17/111,313

149

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1031 N/A N/A Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Markus Jakobsson1032 N/A N/A

Cruise Market Watch, “Cruise Pulse,” available at https://cruisemarketwatch.com/cruise-pulse/, accessed on February 1, 2022 (“Cruise Market Watch Data”)

1033 N/A N/A

American Bar Association, “Applying Econometrics to Assess Market Definition and Market Power,” in Econometrics: Legal Practical and Technical Issues, Second Edition, (Chicago, IL: ABA Publishing, 2010)

1034 N/A N/A

Alyssa A. Lutz and Luaren J. Stiroh, “The Relevant Market in IP and Antitrust Litigation,” IP Litigator, 9(4), May/June 2003

1035 N/A N/A

Dennis W. Carlton and Jeffrey M. Perloff, Modern Industrial Organization, Fourth Edition (Boston, MA: Pearson/Addison Wesley, 2005)

1036 N/A N/A

Gregory J. Werden, “The 1982 Merger Guidelines and the Ascent of the Hypothetical Monopolis Paradigm,” Antitrust Law Journal, 71(1), 2003

1037 N/A N/A

Malcom B. Coate and Jeffrey H. Fischer, “A Practical Guide to the Hypothetical Monopolist Test for Market Definition,” Federal Trade Commission, October 2007

150

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1038 N/A N/A The Guidelines §§ 2.1.3, 4, 4.1.11039 N/A N/A

Andreas Papatheodorou, “The Cruise Industry: An Industrial Organization Perspective,” in Cruis Ship Tourism, ed. Ross K. Dowling (Oxfordshire, UK: CAB International, 2006)

1040 N/A N/A

Michael Clancy, “Power and Profits in the Global Cruise Industry,” in Cruise Ship Tourism, eds. Ross K. Dowling and Clare Weeden (Oxfordshire, UK: CAB International, 2017)

1041 N/A N/A

Morten Hviid and Matthew Olczak, “Raising Rivals’ Fixed Costs,” International Journal of the Economics of Business, 23(1)

1042 N/A N/A

Fiona Scott Morton and Carl Shapiro, “Patent Assertions: Are We Any Closer to Aligning Reward to Contribution?” Innovation Policy and the Economy, 16, National Bureau of Economic Research, 2016

1043 N/A N/A

Mark A. Allen, et al., “Reference Guide on Estimation of Economic Damages,” in Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence, 3rd Edition, (Washington DC: The National Academies Press, 2011)

1044 N/A N/A

American Bar Association, “Quantifying Damages,” in Proving Antitrust Damages: Legal and Economic Issues, 2nd Edition, (Chicago, IL: ABA Publishing, 2010)

151

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1045 N/A N/A

Tim Koller et al., “Chapter 5: Frameworks for Valuation,” in Valuation, Fourth Edition,(Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2005)

1046 N/A N/A

Tim Koller et al., “Using Multiples for Valuation,” in Valuation, Fourth Edition, (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2005)

1047 N/A N/A Angelo Corelli, Analytical Corporate Finance, Second Edition, (Switzerland: Springer, 2018)1048 N/A N/A https://docs microsoft.com/enus/dotnet/core/introduction

1049 N/A N/A https://www mongodb.com/mean-stack1050 N/A N/A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MEAN_(solution_stack)1051 N/A N/A https://blogs.oracle.com/oracleuniversity/post/why-doesjava- remain-so-popular

152

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1052 N/A N/A https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/

1053 N/A N/A https://www faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/atc_html /chap5_section_2.html1054 N/A N/A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_traffic_control_radar_beac

on_system

1055 N/A N/A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_Dependent_Surveil lance%E2%80%93Broadcast

1056 N/A N/A https://www.onlinemathlearning.com/triangle-centroid.html1057 N/A N/A https://handwiki.org/wiki/Trilateration1058 N/A N/A https://www merriam-webster.com/dictionary/trilateration

153

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1059 N/A N/A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truerange_multilateration1060 N/A N/A http://wiki.gis.com/wiki/index.php/Trilateration1061 N/A N/A https://www.gps.gov/multimedia/tutorials/trilateration1062 N/A N/A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalman_filter1063 N/A N/A https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1312/1312.6829.pdf (first published in 2012)1064 N/A N/A https://www.level11.com/location-services-lok81065 N/A N/A https://www.eng.ufl.edu/newengineer/in- memoriam/remembering-rudolf-e-kalman-1930-2016

154

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1066 N/A N/A https://www.cs.unc.edu/~welch/kalman/1067 N/A N/A US 5,890,068

1068 N/A N/A US 9,459,339

1069 N/A N/A https://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs4758/2012sp/materials /MI63slides.pdf1070 N/A N/A https://www.eng.ufl.edu/newengineer/in- memoriam/remembering-rudolf-e-kalman-1930-2016/1071 N/A N/A https://www.virginvoyages.com/press/latest-releases/smart- cruise-wearable.1072 N/A N/A https://www.cruiseandferry net/articles/cruising-to-success- with-new-ships-and-more

155

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1073 N/A N/A

https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/norwegiancruise-line-recognizes-everyday-heroes-with-celebrationaboard-norwegian-bliss-in-new-york-1028763426

1074 N/A N/A https://www.travelagentcentral.com/cruises/norwegian- teams-decurtis-corporation-to-implement-new-tech1075 N/A N/A

https://hotelierinternational.com/norwegian-cruise-linepartners-with-decurtis-corporation-to-develop-cruisefreedom/

1076 N/A N/A https://cruise.blog/2019/02/norwegian-cruise-line-will-debut- new-cruise-freedom-norwegian-encore1077 N/A N/A

https://www.travelpulse.com/news/cruise/norwegian-cruiseline-teams-with-decurtiscorporation html

1078 N/A N/A https://www royalcaribbean.com/blog/5-ways-royal- caribbeans-app-changes-cruising/1079 N/A N/A https://www msccruises.com/en-gl/Discover-MSC/MSC-for- Me.aspx

156

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1080 N/A N/A https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/disneys-1-billion- investment-internet-things-brent-lorenz/

1081 N/A N/A https://www madhattertech.ca/chatter/disneys-imagineering- mobile-and-geo-location-technology-their-magic-band1082 N/A N/A

https://www.technologyreview.com/2013/05/31/178246/disneys-electronic-wristband-illustrates-why-big-companiespush-contactless-wallets/

1083 N/A N/A https://futurelab.assaabloy.com/en/developing-mobile-access- for-hotels/

1084 N/A N/A

https://www.securityinfowatch.com/access-identity/accesscontrol/access-control-mobileapps/news/12050418/assa-abloy-to-license-seos

1085 N/A N/A https://www.asmag.com/showpost/19819.aspx1086 N/A N/A

https://www.intelligentopenings.com/Other/Intelligent_Openings/Solutions/Mobile%20Access/Mobile%20Access%20Solutions%20Documents/Bluetooth-Mobile-Access-FAQFinal.pdf

157

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1087 N/A N/A

https://www nfcw.com/2014/11/03/332389/starwood-hotelspicks-bluetooth-mobile-room-keys-work-smartphones-applewatch-devices/

1088 N/A N/A

https://www.anixter.com/content/dam/Suppliers/Honeywell/hid-global-mobile-access-ebookenterprise-part-2.pdf

1089 N/A N/A https://www hospitalityandcateringnews.com/2015/04/starw ood-launches-keyless-check-spg-app-apple-watch/1090 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/1091 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/our-journal/1092 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2022/09/14/award-winning-virginvoyages-deploys-the-decurtisexperience-platform-to-drive-enhanced-guest-experiences/

1093 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2022/08/12/virgin-voyagesstandardizes-on-aruba-esp-to-deliverexceptional-sailor-experiences/

158

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1094 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2022/09/07/babak-aghevlipromoted-to-chief-technology-officer-at- decurtiscorporation/

1095 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2022/03/31/decurtis-championsspecial-olympics-florida-and-themission-of-inclusion/

1096 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2021/07/15/decurtis-corporationreceives-patent-on-a-method-toimprove-fidelity-and-reduce-traffic-incurred-for-locationservices/

1097 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/07/08/how-aware-care-can- ensure-suicide-watch-is-effective/1098 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/06/25/a-note-from-derek- fournier/1099 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/06/18/how-mas-improves- emergency-drills-at-chemical-plants/1100 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2021/06/04/why-wearables-arebetter-for-location-tracking-inemergencies-than-phones/

159

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1101 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/06/04/cruise-lines-may- resume-operations-this-summer/1102 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/05/25/when-every-second- counts-decurtis-delivers/1103 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2021/05/13/innovations-thatimprove-the-emergency-evacuationprocess/

1104 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/05/07/how-to-protect-your- employees-without-infringing-on-their privacy/1105 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2021/05/04/decurtis-corporationreceives-a-new-us-patent-focused-on-contact-tracing-vialocation-service/

1106 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/04/30/how-decurtis-shield- can-help-during-an-active-shooter-situation/1107 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/04/23/how-wearable- technology-can-help-your-business-in-an-emergency/

160

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1108 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2021/04/16/how-businesses-canmeet-new-health-and-safetyexpectations/

1109 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/03/22/keeping-your- employees-healthy-during-and-after-covid- 19/1110 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/03/17/safety-measures-to- put-in-place-before-returning-to-the-office/

1111 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/03/12/cdc-says-reopen- schools-safely/1112 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/03/09/new-faces-on-board-at- decurtis-corporation/

1113 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/03/05/the-latest-on-the- cruise-industry-and-covid-19/1114 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/02/25/the-dangers-of- depending-on-pooled-covid-testing/

161

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1115 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/02/19/the-importance-of- contact-tracing-now-and-in-the-future/1116 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/02/15/technology-safer- health-protocols/1117 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/02/12/possible-problems- with-pre-cruise-covid-testing/1118 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/02/03/why-businesses- should-consider-covid-smart-training-certification/1119 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/02/03/key-west-cruise- referendums-face-challenge-in-court/1120 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/01/28/viruses-not-curable- just-preventable/1121 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2021/01/22/businesses-need- protective-measures-post-vaccine/

162

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1122 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/12/17/the-city-of-houstonselects-decurtis-shield-to-enhance-the-health-and-safety-oftheir-facilities/

1123 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/12/11/how-to-make-holiday- travel-safer-for-your-customers/1124 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/12/04/how-to-make-in-storeholiday-shopping-safer-forcustomers/

1125 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/11/30/the-rise-of-contactless- biometric-solutions-in-a-post-covid-world/

1126 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/11/19/why-choose-decurtis- safety-and-security-technology/1127 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/11/10/three-health-and- safety-requirements-all-businesses-should adopt/1128 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/11/04/health-and-safety- technology-are-here-to-stay/

163

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1129 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/28/virgin-voyages-selectsdecurtis-shield-as-a-core-part-of-their-voyage-well-programand-broader-health-and-safety-approach/

1130 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/26/sales-empowermentgroup-installs-decurtis-shield-as-part-of-its-new-health-andsafety-initiative/

1131 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/26/story-highlight-safer- environments-for-restaurants/1132 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/23/how-assisted-check-in- can-protect-your-medical-facility/1133 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/22/highlight-story-city- leaders-can-keep-infrastructure-open/1134 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/21/highlight-story-peace- of-mind-at-school/1135 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/20/decurtis-corporationenters-the-education-sector-with-decurtis-shield-at-capehenry-collegiate/

164

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1136 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/13/how-to-ensure-safe- visitation-for-care-facility-residents/1137 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/09/safety-measures-tokeep-manufacturing-facilitiesoperating/

1138 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/10/06/invest-in-future-proof- security-solutions/1139 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2020/09/22/decurtis-corporationpartners-with-sms-international-shore-operations-to-improvethe-health-in-ports-worldwide/

1140 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/09/18/the-dangers-of-using- banned-surveillance-cameras/1141 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/09/15/use-thermal-imaging- systems-as-a-first-line-of-defense/1142 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/07/31/decurtis-corporation- announces-the-launch-of-decurtis-capital/

165

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1143 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/07/24/digital-health- passports-are-vital-to-future-travel/1144 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/06/23/decurtis-corporation- appoints-derek-fournier-as-ceo/1145 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2020/06/16/health-and-safety- maturity-model-the-how/1146 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2019/10/03/decurtis-corporation- wins-supplier-of-the-year-at-annual-seatrade-awards-dinner/1147 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2019/08/29/the-guest-experience- on-a-cruise-is-improving/1148 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2019/08/29/decurtis-corporation- selected-as-a-finalist-for-supplier-of-the-year/1149 N/A N/A decurtis.com/2019/08/27/decurtis-corporation-hires-joe- carino-as-chief-financial-officer/

166

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1150 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2019/05/22/decurtis-receives- growth-investment-from-shamrock- capital/1151 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2018/10/10/using-beacons-at-anevent-to-enhance-customerexperience/

1152 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/2018/10/21/introducing-our- bluetooth-low-energy-module/1153 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/mobile-assembly-suite/1154 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2020/03/MAS_ModuleSheet.pdf1155 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/journey/muster-drill/1156 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/decurtis-experience-platform/

167

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1157 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/mobile-assembly-suite- land/1158 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/suspicious-activity-search/1159 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/dynamic-delivery-suite/1160 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/food-beverage-suite/1161 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/location-solution/1162 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/hardware-wearables- fulfillment/1163 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/activity-reservations-suite/

168

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1164 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/housekeeping-suite/1165 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/voyage-reservations-suite/1166 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/aware-care/1167 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/embarkation-suite/1168 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/wayfinding/1169 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/table-management-suite/1170 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/suites/media-suite/

169

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1171 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/journey/food-beverage/1172 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/decurtis-experience-platform/1173 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/decurtis-experience- platform/safety-and-security-technology/1174 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/sea/1175 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/sea/location-proximity/1176 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/sea/transformational-experience- technology/1177 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/sea/health-safety-maturity-model/

170

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1178 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/sea/journeys/1179 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/about/1180 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/land/1181 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/land/location-proximity/1182 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/land/health-safety-maturity- model/1183 N/A N/A https://cruiseindustrynews.com/cruise- news/2022/10/decurtis-driving-technical-innovation-at-sea/1184 N/A N/A https://www.virginvoyages.com/

171

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1185 N/A N/A https://www.virginvoyages.com/ship1186 N/A N/A https://www.virginvoyages.com/press/latest-releases/smart- cruise-wearable

1187 N/A N/A https://www.virgin.com/about-virgin/latest/virgin-voyages- reveals-wearable-technology-sailors1188 N/A N/A https://www royalcaribbeanblog.com/2014/11/19/royal- caribbean-wowbands-what-you-need-know1189 N/A N/A

https://www royalcaribbeanblog.com/2016/05/30/spotlightroyal-caribbean-wowbands-harmonyof-the-seas

1190 N/A N/A

https://www.travelagentcentral.com/cruises/excalibur-royalcaribbean-s-top-to-bottom-techrevamp

1191 N/A N/A US 20140122148

172

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1192 N/A N/A US 109118931193 N/A N/A US 109157331194 N/A N/A US 109320891195 N/A N/A US 110620461196 N/A N/A US 111661421197 N/A N/A US 114421291198 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation's Objections and Responses to DeCurtis's First Set of Requests forProduction of Documents (Nos. 1-87)

173

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1199 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation's Objections and Responses to DeCurtis's Second Set of Requests forProduction of Documents (Nos. 88-90)

1200 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation's Amended Objections and Responses to DeCurtis's First Set of Requestsfor Production of Documents (Nos. 1-87)

1201 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation's Objections and Responses to DeCurtis's Third Set of Requests forProduction of Documents (Nos. 91-95)

1202 N/A N/A

Carnival Corporation's Objections and Responses to DeCurtis's Third [Fourth] Set of Requestsfor Production of Documents (Nos. 91-114)

1203 N/A N/A Carnival's Second Set of Requests for Production1204 N/A N/A DeCurtis's Reponse to Carnival's Second Set of Requests for Production1205 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2020/03/MAS_ModuleSheet.pdf

174

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1206 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2021/04/MAS_LAND_Product-Sheet.pdf1207 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2021/04/SAS_Product-Sheet.pdf1208 N/A N/A

decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/DynamicDelivery_ProductSheet.pdf

1209 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2020/05/DeCurtis_FoodBeverageModuleSheet.pdf

1210 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/Location-Solution_-ModuleSheet.pdf

1211 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/ActivityReservation_ProductSheet.pdf

1212 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2021/07/Housekeeping_Product-Sheet.pdf

175

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1213 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/Voyage-Reservation_ProductSheet.pdf

1214 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2021/04/Aware-Care_Product-Sheet.pdf1215 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2020/03/Embarkation_ModuleSheet.pdf1216 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/wpcontent/uploads/2021/07/Table-Management_ProductSheet.pdf

1217 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/wp- content/uploads/2021/07/Media-Suite_Product-Sheet.pdf1218 N/A N/A Assa Abloy Hotel Security and Access Solutions1219 N/A N/A Specification of the Bluetooth System, Covered Core Package version: 4.2

176

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1220 N/A N/A Metadata Report of CARNIVAL00509475-4781221 N/A N/A Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition of Carnival Corporation1222 N/A N/A International Standards ISO/IEC 14443-2 (Radio Frequency Power and Signal Inference)1223 N/A N/A International Standards ISO/IEC 14443-3 (Initialization and Anticollision)1224 N/A N/A International Standards ISO/IEC 14443-4 (Transmission Protocol).1225 N/A N/A Notice of Deposition of Carnival Corporation1226 N/A N/A Response and Objections to Notice of Deposition of Carnival Coporation

177

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1227 N/A N/A Mike Lingwiler Linkedin Page1228 N/A N/A Global Infrastructure Services Standard Operation Procedures Carnival Cruise Lines Backup Strategy1229 N/A N/A Document Retention1230 N/A N/A Computer Hardware Procurement Policy1231 N/A N/A Email from Diana Szego Faasbender to Judha James etc al1232 N/A N/A Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Shoemake1233 N/A N/A Intentionally Ommitted

178

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1234 N/A N/A

Electronic Hotel Card Lock (E4031)(http://orbitalock.en.made-inchina.com/product/gMVEFhColDkc/China-Hotel-RF-CardLock- E3031- html)

1235 N/A N/A Intentionally Ommitted1236 N/A N/A Intentionally Ommitted1237 N/A N/A Intentionally Ommitted1238 N/A N/A

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blacklist_(computing)#:~:text=In%20computing%2C%20a%20blacklist%2C%20disallowlist,)%2C%20except%20those%20explicitly%20mentioned.

1239 N/A N/A European Patent Application EP 2 514 888 A1

1240 N/A N/A US Patent 9,582,034

179

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1241 N/A N/A US Patent Application 2015/00380801242 N/A N/A Resume of Manos (Emmanouil) M. Tentzeris1243 N/A N/A EIC Studio Layout - Final1244 N/A N/A https://www.youtube.com/@princesscruises/videos1245 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1246 N/A N/A US Patent 8,935,1191247 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/about/meet-the-team/

180

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1248 N/A N/A Workpaper 11249 N/A N/A Workpaper 21250 N/A N/A Workpaper 31251 N/A N/A Workpaper 41252 N/A N/A Workpaper 51253 N/A N/A Workpaper 61254 N/A N/A Workpaper 7

181

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1255 N/A N/A Workpaper 81256 N/A N/A Workpaper 91257 N/A N/A Workpaper 111258 N/A N/A

https://www.carnivalcorp.com/news-releases/newsreleasedetails/carnival-corporationsoceanmedalliontm-named-iot-wearables

1259 N/A N/A

Computer Security Resource Center (an official website of the United States government) defining “secure channel” as a path that ensures confidentiality, integrity, as well as mutual authentication

1260 N/A N/A Workpaper 11261 N/A N/A Workpaper 2

182

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1262 N/A N/A Workpaper 31263 N/A N/A Workpaper 61264 N/A N/A https://web.archive.or g/web/201604262041 19mp_/https://support .apple.com/kb/SP7371265 N/A N/A Physical Exhibits: Disney MagicBands1266 N/A N/A Advanced Encryption Standard 128 Specification, United States National Institute of Standards of Technology, 20011267 N/A N/A Image on Page 95 of Jakobsson Opening Report1268 N/A N/A Images on Page 96 of Jakobsson Opening Report

183

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1269 N/A N/A Images on Page 99 of Jakobsson Opening Report1270 N/A N/A https://www.decurtis.com/contact/1271 N/A N/A Workpaper 71272 N/A N/A Lynde Rebuttal Expert Report, Ex. 41273 N/A N/A Lynde Rebuttal Expert Report, Ex. 51274 N/A N/A Lynde Rebuttal Expert Report, Ex. 61275 N/A N/A

https://www.decurtis.com/2022/03/08/decurtis-corporationannounces-strategic-investment-from-invictus-globalmanagement/

184

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1276 N/A N/A https://www.travelweekly.com/In-the-Hot-Seat/Carnival- Corp-John-Padgett

1277 N/A N/A

Horizontal Merger Guidelines, available at https://www.justice.gov/atr/horizontal-mergerguidelines-08192010

1278 N/A N/A Declaration of Joe Carinio1279 N/A N/A Second Supplemental Declaration of Francis Farro1280 N/A N/A U.S. Published Application 2016/0275735A11281 N/A N/A U.S. Patent No. 10,156,8671282 N/A N/A U.S. Patent No. 10,223,521

185

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1283 N/A N/A U.S. Patent No. 8,690,2051284 N/A N/A Assa Abloy Product Brochure (2014)1285 N/A N/A

“Practical Hardware and Software Add-Ons to Enhance the Security of Mobile DeviceOperations,” Thesis Presented to Radboud University, Nijmegen, April 11, 2016

1286 N/A N/A Ho, G., et al., Smart locks: Lessons for Securing Commodity Internet of Things Devices1287 N/A N/A Disney MyMagic+ and MagicBand Systems1288 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1289 N/A N/A Royal Caribbean WOWBand Systems

186

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1290 N/A N/A DE197389381291 N/A N/A DE102007024705A11292 N/A N/A

Evangelatos, O., et al., A Framework for Creating Personalized Smart Environments using Wireless Sensor Networks

1293 N/A N/A Peusaari, J., et al., An Access Control and Time Management Software Solution Using RFID1294 N/A N/A WO2016134022A11295 N/A N/A WO2016007877A11296 N/A N/A US20150348049

187

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1297 N/A N/A US53173091298 N/A N/A US201501786981299 N/A N/A US201700178151300 N/A N/A US201602694031301 N/A N/A US98010591302 N/A N/A

Eddystone Protocol Specification, April 2016 (Michael Ashbridge et al.), available athttps://github.com/google/eddystone

1303 N/A N/A

Kalamandeen, A., et al., Ensemble: Cooperative Proximitybased Authentication, 2010 International Conference on Mobile Systems and Applications and Sevices, pp. 331-343, June 18 2010

188

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1304 N/A N/A US8947239

1305 N/A N/A US20180005469

1306 N/A N/A https://disneyparks.disney.go.com/blog/2013/01/taking-the- disneyguest-experience-to-the-next-level/1307 N/A N/A https://thenextweb.com/insider/2013/05/29/disney-goes-into- wearable-tech-with-the-magic-band/1308 N/A N/A https://www.wired.com/2015/03/disney-magicband/1309 N/A N/A

https://apps fcc.gov/oetcf/eas/reports/ViewExhibitReport.cfm?mode=Exhibits&RequestTimeout=500&calledFromFrame=N&application_id=u4xHZuYLEdVwL%2BZS3FOcyg%3D%3D&fcc_i d=Q3E-XBR-R1G1

1310 N/A N/A https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/faq/my-disney- experience/my-magic-plus-privacy/

189

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1311 N/A N/A

https://attractionsmagazine.com/hands-on-with-disneysfastpass-and-magicbands-your-mymagic-questionsanswered/

1312 N/A N/A https://www magicbandcollectors.com/be-our-guest- restaurant-testmagicband-discovered/1313 N/A N/A http://www hitools-access.com/upload/MIFARE-DESFire- EV2-Leaflet.pdf1314 N/A N/A

https://www.ti.com/lit/an/sloa213/sloa213.pdf?ts=1603406707813&ref_url=https%253A%252F%252Fwww.google.com%252F

1315 N/A N/A https://futurelab.assaabloy.com/en/shift-on-the-wearable- horizon/1316 N/A N/A

https://www.packthepjs.com/geeky-bitz-wowband-rfidtechnology-on-board-new-royal-caribbeansmart-ships/

1317 N/A N/A https://www hospitalitynet.org/news/4070670.html

190

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1318 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted

1319 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1320 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1321 N/A N/A https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9177375

1322 N/A N/A https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/faq/bands- cards/understanding-magic-band/1323 N/A N/A https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/faq/my- disneyexperience/frequency-technology/1324 N/A N/A https://www rtinsights.com/whats-behind-disneys-real-time- magicmagicbands8918

191

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1325 N/A N/A https://gizmodo.com/how-i-let-disney-track-my-every-move- 17928753861326 N/A N/A Assa Abloy RFID Keycards & Carriers1327 N/A N/A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnfcY7nUhOI1328 N/A N/A

https://attractionsmagazine.com/hands-on-with-disneysfastpass-and-magicbands-yourmymagicquestions-answered/

1329 N/A N/A US 9,801,0591330 N/A N/A US 8,947,2391331 N/A N/A US2003/0090386

192

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1332 N/A N/A US2010/01489181333 N/A N/A US2019/00586011334 N/A N/A US2016/03071891335 N/A N/A US 9,430,8881336 N/A N/A DE10350081A11337 N/A N/A US2016/01428681338 N/A N/A US 9,743,254

193

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1339 N/A N/A US2015/02352021340 N/A N/A US 10,270,5871341 N/A N/A US 2016/01714801342 N/A N/A US 9,332,3221343 N/A N/A US 9,832,7071344 N/A N/A US 9,171,3211345 N/A N/A US 8,600,443

194

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1346 N/A N/A WO2015/142813A11347 N/A N/A JP2010109722A1348 N/A N/A US 8,253,5331349 N/A N/A DE102005034035A11350 N/A N/A DE10253503A11351 N/A N/A WO2011/1410581352 N/A N/A US2007/0200666

195

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1353 N/A N/A US2006/02502151354 N/A N/A US2010/03213251355 N/A N/A US 8,610,6291356 N/A N/A US 8,922,4431357 N/A N/A US 6,957,0851358 N/A N/A US 9,723,5051359 N/A N/A US 9,693,369

196

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1360 N/A N/A US 9,191,8331361 N/A N/A US 9,130,6561362 N/A N/A DE1020070064731363 N/A N/A

Libelium, Bluetooth Low Energy to Connect Sensors with Smartphones and Tablets, available athttps://www.libelium.com/libeliumworld/bluetooth-lowenergy-ble-4-0-smart-connect-sensors- smartphone/ (April 

21, 2014)

1364 N/A N/A ISO 18092, 2013, ISO/IEC Joint Technical Committee1365 N/A N/A Yong Tae Park, et al., Smart Digitial Door Lock for the Home Automation, Tencon, 20091366 N/A N/A https://web.archive.org/web/20151015183005/https://quuppa .com/technology

197

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1367 N/A N/A Kevo Reference Guide 20141368 N/A N/A

Twice VIP Awards 2014: Second Annual Awards Honor the Best, TWICE: This Week inConsumer Electronics, August 18, 2014

1369 N/A N/A Mifare Desfire EV2 Data Sheet (February 24, 2016)1370 N/A N/A Mifare Desfire EV1 Data Sheet (December 9, 2015)

1371 N/A N/A Mifare Classic EV1 Data Sheet (March 3, 2014)

1372 N/A N/A Be Our Guest Restaurant Experience1373 N/A N/A https://www royalcaribbeanblog.com/category/category/wo wband

198

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1374 N/A N/A

https://www.packthepjs.com/geeky-bitz-wowband-rfidtechnology-on-board-new-royal-caribbeansmart-ships/

1375 N/A N/A

https://www.cntraveler.com/stories/2014-11-21/royalcaribbean-quantum-of-the-seas-smart-shiptechnology

1376 N/A N/A https://nfctagfactorycom.wordpress.com/2015/07/20/royal- caribbean-cruises-uses-assa-abloy-rfid wristband/1377 N/A N/A

https://www royalcaribbeanpresscenter.com/video/481/quantum-of-the-seas-rfid-wowbandwristbands-b-roll/

1378 N/A N/A Fung Business Intelligence Center (FBIC) Publication: Disney MagicBand1379 N/A N/A https://www nova-labs.org/blog/2014/02/16/dissecting-walt- disney-worlds-rfid-bracelet/1380 N/A N/A https://www rtinsights.com/whats-behind-disneys-real-time- magicmagicbands8918/

199

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1381 N/A N/A

https://apps fcc.gov/oetcf/eas/reports/ViewExhibitReport.cfm?mode=Exhibits&RequestTimeout= 500&calledFromFrame=N&application_id=2tq8ssg3a61ikYM7Ocow8w%3D%3D&fcc_id=Q3EXPD-R1G1

1382 N/A N/A https://www magicbandcollectors.com/be-our-guest- restaurant-test-magicband-discovered/1383 N/A N/A

https://www royalcaribbeanblog.com/boards/index.php?/profile/16507-rtripp/content/&type=forums_topic_post

1384 N/A N/A

Sawti Sehgal, “BLEPProxiMesh: A Bluetooth Smart Mesh Network for Sensing IndoorLocation,” Dissertation Presented to the University of Dublin, Trinity College, August 2015

1385 N/A N/A Apple iWatch1386 N/A N/A

Park, Yong Tae; Pranesh Sthapit; and Jae-Young Pyun, “Smart Digital Door Lock for the Home Automation,” In TENCON 2009-2009 IEEE Region 10 Conference, pp. 1-6. IEEE, 2009

1387 N/A N/A DE10144702A1

200

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1388 N/A N/A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnfcY7nUhOI1389 N/A N/A https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/plan/my-disney- experience/bands-cards/1390 N/A N/A

https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360004716091-Wayback-MachineGeneral-Information

1391 N/A N/A

https://help.archive.org/help/wayback-machine-generalinformation/#:~:text=What%20is%20the%20Wayback%20Machine,archived%20version%20of%20the%20Web.

1392 N/A N/A https://help.archive.org/hc/en-us/articles/360004651732- Using-The- Wayback-Machine1393 N/A N/A https://help.archive.org/help/using-the-wayback-machine/1394 N/A N/A http://dbis.eprints.uni-ulm.de/

201

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1395 N/A N/A www.bluetooth.com

1396 N/A N/A https://www.bluetooth.com/specifications/specs/core- specification-4-2/1397 N/A N/A

https://web.archive.org/web/20160917215647/https://www.bluetooth.com/specifications/adopted-specifications

1398 N/A N/A https://repository.ubn ru.nl/handle/2066/1575891399 N/A N/A http://urn kb.se/resolve?urn=urn nbn:se:liu:diva-107332.1400 N/A N/A https://www.iso.org/standard/28729.html.1401 N/A N/A https://www.iso.org/about-us html.

202

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1402 N/A N/A http://www.iso.org

1403 N/A N/A https://www.iso.org/standards html

1404 N/A N/A

NXP Semiconductors BLE Antenna Design Guide ApplicationNote Revision 2.0

1405 N/A N/A

https://web.archive.org/web/20190821094950/https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/userguide/UM10992.pdf

1406 N/A N/A

https://web.archive.org/web/20181222145005/http://www.ti.com/lit/an/sloa241b/sloa241b.pdf

1407 N/A N/A https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/2797044.27970491408 N/A N/A

https://www researchgate.net/publication/299905831_TwoWay_Communication_Protocol_using_Bluetooth_Low_Energy_Advertisement_Fr ames

203

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1409 N/A N/A https://www royalcaribbeanblog.com/2016/06/11/top-4- places-use-wowbands

1410 N/A N/A https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/dining/magic-kingdom/be- our-guest-restaurant/

1411 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1412 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1413 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1414 N/A N/A 47 U.S.C. §18.301 Operating Frequencies1415 N/A N/A

Handbook of Applied Cryptography by Alfred J. Menezes, Paul C. Van Oorschot and Scott A.Vanstone

204

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1416 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: DeCurtis Wearables1417 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: Assa Abloy Door Locks and Access Panels1418 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: DeCurtis Keycards1419 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: DeCurtis Wearables Prototypes1420 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: Assa Abloy Door Locks and Access Panels Prototypes1421 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: DeCurtis Keycards for Prototypes1422 N/A N/A Physical Exhibit: BLE Readers

205

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1423 N/A N/A Intentionally Omitted1424 NCL-000032 NCL-000084 Mobile Assembly Suite (MAS) - BRD 1.51425 NCL-004571 NCL-004577 Email from Babak Aghevli to Alexander Tavernini1426 NCL-005049 NCL-005051 Notes1427 NCL-007241 NCL-007247 Email from David Herrera to Harry Sommer; Lincoln Vidal; Babak Aghevli et al.1428 NCL-007253 NCL-007255 Email from Lincoln Vidal to Babak Aghevli; Simon Murray; Dan Farkas1429 NCL-007256 NCL-007256 Email from David Herrera to Harry Sommer; Simon Murray; Russell Jones et al.

206

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1430 NCL-007258 NCL-007260 Email from David Herrera to Gabriel Herrera; Harry Sommer; Russell Jones et al.1431 NCL-007261 NCL-007264 Email from Russell Jones to Harry Sommer; David Herrera; Simon Murray et al.1432 NCL-007265 NCL-007267 Email from Harry Sommer to Russell Jones; David Herrera; Simon Murray1433 NCL-007268 NCL-007268 Email from Alexander Tavernini to Babak Aghevli; Simon Murray1434 NCL-007914 NCL-007915 Email from Simon Murray to Harry Sommer; Babak Aghevli; Dimple Jethani et al.1435 NCL-008160 NCL-008211 Master Project, Software License1436 NCL-008225 NCL-008233 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani

207

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1437 NCL-008244 NCL-008244 Email from Babak Aghevli to Dimple Jethani; Scott Piccolo; Timothy Scharf1438 NCL-008245 NCL-008246 Email from Babak Aghevli to Gregory Picozzi; Dimple Jethani; Georgios Mortakis et al.1439 NCL-008354 NCL-008356 Meeting Minutes 5-13-191440 NCL-008582 NCL-008582 Email from Babak Aghevli to Dimple Jethani1441 NCL-008740 NCL-008742 Email from Babak Aghevli to Alexander Tavernini1442 NCL-009000 NCL-009005 Email from B. Aghevli to A. Tavernini1443 NCL-009057 NCL-009057 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani; Alexander Tavernini

208

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1444 NCL-009098 NCL-009098 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Lincoln Vidal; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani1445 NCL-009100 NCL-009101 Email from Babak Aghevli to Timothy Scharf; Dimple Jethani1446 NCL-009232 NCL-009237 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani; Lincoln Vidal1447 NCL-009284 NCL-009284 Email from Babak Aghevli to Simon Murray1448 NCL-009773 NCL-009775 Email from Babak Aghevli to Christine Wagner1449 NCL-009790 NCL-009791

Email from Babak Aghevli to Simon Murray; David Herrera; Dimple Jethani; AlexanderTavernini

1450 NCL-009798 NCL-009799 Email from Babak Aghevli to Dimple Jethani; Scott Piccolo; Timothy Scharf

209

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1451 NCL-009817 NCL-009818 Email from Babak Aghevli to Lincoln Vidal1452 NCL-010015 NCL-010017 Email from Babak Aghevli to Dimple Jethani; David Herrera; Simon Murray1453 NCL-010018 NCL-010022 Email from Babak Aghevli to Dimple Jethani1454 NCL-010023 NCL-010024 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani1455 NCL-010025 NCL-010027 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray1456 NCL-010240 NCL-010241 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani1457 NCL-010826 NCL-010831 Email from Babak Aghevli to David Herrera; Simon Murray; Dimple Jethani

210

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1458 NCL-010911 NCL-010911 Email from Babak Aghevli to Dimple Jethani1459 NCL-019628 NCL-019643 Digital Experience Platform1460 SHAMROCK_00000001 SHAMROCK_00000329 Agreement1461 SHAMROCK_00005229 SHAMROCK_00005339 Presentation1462 TE2-000013 TE2-000013 Email from Bob Walters to Ben Mathews1463 TE2-000365 TE2-000383 TE2 – Transforming Hospitality Experiences1464 TE2-000384 TE2-000400 Master Services Agreement

211

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1465 TE2-000401 TE2-000435 Experience Operating System Component Purchase and License Agreement1466 TE2-000460 TE2-000466 Statement of Work No. 11467 TE2-000467 TE2-000473 Statement of Work No. 21468 TE2-000474 TE2-000479 Statement of Work No. 31469 TE2-000484 TE2-000494 Statement of Work No. 41470 TE2-000508 TE2-000519 Statement of Work No. 61471 TE2-000629 TE2-000641 Statement of Work No. 14

212

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1472 TE2-000644 TE2-000655 Statement of Work No. 151473 TE2-000738 TE2-000749 Statement of Work No. 211474 TE2-000762 TE2-000778 Agreement1475 TE2-001319 TE2-001319 Email from Bob Walters to Ben Mathews1476 TE2-001330 TE2-001332 Email from Ben Matthews to Bob Walters1477 TE2-001383 TE2-001383 Email from Bob Walters to Ben Mathews1478 TE2-001390 TE2-001390 Email from Bob Walters to Joshua Bass; Ben Mathews

213

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1479 TE2-001407 TE2-001408 Email from Ousama Charouf1480 TE2-001422 TE2-001422 Email from Scott Sahadi to Bill Kunneke1481 TE2-001432 TE2-001434 Email from Jason Sohn to Bob Walters; Ben Mathews; Albert Na et al.1482 TE2-001441 TE2-001442 Email from Manny Vellon to Ian Ursino; Bob Walters; Leszek Mazur1483 TE2-001654 TE2-001655 Email from Ray Atkin to Michael Jungen; Craig Feldman; Ben Mathews; Joshua Bass1484 TE2-001763 TE2-001763 Email from Bob Walters to Ben Mathews1485 TE2-001837 TE2-001837 Email from Bob Walters to Ben Mathews; Diana Caale

214

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1486 TE2-001841 TE2-001842 Email from Craig Feldman to Adam Leonards; Ashfague Chowdhury; avitagIiano@thisisdk.com et al.1487 TE2-002026 TE2-002026 Email from Sunil Gupta to ray@theexperienceengine.com; Deepak Bhatia: David DeCurtis et al1488 TE2-002165 TE2-002172 Email from Craig Feldman to Ben Mathews; Michae Jungen1489 TE2-002275 TE2-002285 Email from Ben Matthews to Bob Walters1490 TE2-002378 TE2-002378 Email from Michael Jungen to Ben Mathews1491 TE2-002389 TE2-002390 Email from Ben Matthews to Jose Carranza; Brian Freid1492 TE2-002489 TE2-002490 Email from Ben Matthews to Scott Sahadi

215

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1493 TE2-002536 TE2-002536 Email from Adam Swiatek to John Padgett; Michael Jungen; Craig Feldman et al.1494 TE2-002622 TE2-002622 Email from Craig Feldman to Adam Leonards; Ben Mathews; Bhu Bains1495 TE2-002683 TE2-002698 from Craig Feldman to adam@mattergIobaI.com; Ashfague Chowdhury; avitagIiano@thisisdk.com; Ben Mathews et al.1496 TE2-003083 TE2-003087 Email from Ousama Charouf to Den Mathews; Doug Steele1497 TE2-005917 TE2-005920 The Experience Engine (TE2)1498 VIRGIN0000001 VIRGIN0000003 VingCard Allure website1499 VIRGIN0000004 VIRGIN0000005 NFC reader

216

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1500 VIRGIN0000026 VIRGIN0000026 nRF528321501 ASSAABLOY0001056 ASSAABLOY0001083 Email from from Jan Elfstrom to Patrick Meridiuk; Douglas Steele; Stig Lagerstedt et al.1502

CARNIVAL00003401, -419, -

426, -434, -437, -438, -440, -447, -38320, -322

Photo

1503 CARNIVAL00015245 CARNIVAL00015247 Email from Vann Pearce Jr. to Jason Stearns re Carnival / DeCurtis: Request for Audit1504 CARNIVAL00038172 CARNIVAL00038172 EIC Studio Layout - Final--Native color version1505 CARNIVAL00014795 CARNIVAL00014798 How a Quarter-Sized Disc Could Change the Way You Vacation1506 DeCurtis_00169464 DeCurtis_00169467 Email from Laura Hall to David DeCurtis re Mustering Guest Notes

217

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1507 DeCurtis_00169483 DeCurtis_00169484 Email from Laura Hall to David DeCurtis re Meetings This Week1508 DeCurtis_00245211 DeCurtis_00245211 Email from Phyllis Fleischer to David DeCurtis re NDA1509 DeCurtis_00368485 DeCurtis_00368487 Email from David DeCurtis to Seema Nair re xCMNS1510 DeCurtis_00397829 DeCurtis_00397834

Email from Bob Freebeck to David DeCurtis re MAS Breeze_CCL Enhancements - Add Station Section - Estimates

1511 DeCurtis_00501954 DeCurtis_00501955 Email from Seema Nair to Jitendra Pardasani re Backlog1512 DeCurtis_01986943 DeCurtis_01986944 Email from Lalit Bhatia to Megha Agrawal re Carnival Corp Application List1513 DeCurtis_02002200 DeCurtis_02002200 Email from Jim Learish to David DeCurtis re Revised MSA

218

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220
Defendants' Trial Exhibit List

Carnival Corp. v. DeCurtis Corp. and DeCurtis LLC , Case No. 20-22945-CIV-SCOLA

DTX 

No. Beg Bates End Bates Description Witness 

1514 N/A N/A

From MagicBand to Ocean Medallian: Using interactive devices to unlock next-generation guest experiences (downloaded from link at DTX-802)

1515 N/A N/A https://www.phocuswire.com/carnival-to-bring-magicband- like-wearable-medallions-to-cruise-passengers1516 N/A N/A Linkedln Profile of Mr. John Padgett, https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnpadgett/ 1517 CARNIVAL00561119 CARNIVAL00561126 Evercore -- Project Ocean -- Overview Materials1518 DeCurtis_01506978 DeCurtis_01506981

Norwegian Cruise Line Partners with DeCurtis Corporation to Develop - Cruise Freedom - A State-of-the-Art Technology Platform

1519 N/A N/A CES 2017 Keynote https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U47_KktBnCk1520 DeCurtis_01803069 DeCurtis_01803071 Email from Rakesh Joshi re Silvia APK for NCL

219

Case 1:20-cv-22945-RNS Document 540 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/27/2023 Page 

220