05/19/2010 13:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA + DMS glOOI/00 7 

DENNIS R. HABER, P.A, 

Providing independent General Counsel services to the Business & Aviation Community 

Of Counsel: 

Jill Sharon White, Esq. i 

Jillrtiilawyermismi, CjMii 

Michael BemKtdn. Est). 2 

Mic.l'aelff/iluwvci-iiiiiin-)i.c.oiil 

F.nrique J. Fcriiaiidc/, ESQ. i 

P.'iri<]»c(^/'K)KrA.c(rni 

nciuiis R. Habcr, fl-sq, i 

l)c/iilix,vv)la>fv-orrtiijmi com 

Dmiiii.'i-'a'Hvyiawver.corrt 

I Admilla! to riorida. Wajhinjiiin I) C., nnd Neur Vorl 

2 Admitted ni Unridii, Nc v Jerftiy, siid New York 

^ AtfniiiKU ill l-'lui idti 

Member: 

I ',l«'^'l•^-|^Jol HHI ' 

AOI M I'I.I'I 

NUAA 

Services: 

tioiicrtil ( iiiiii'iii 

MTSH. IXM. iniJ 

("A A iiiiiMas iiilJ 

Ailiniiiiilralivc 

1 IcUTin.!."! 

AilLTllll 

('.'ip c I'l'VLn 

AiiajllftinO 

.S;I1L:I; A T'lircliibv 

('nriv.rriir <fc I jiriiv 

K.)rniLiiuin 

i.iimincri~i;il &. 

1 luhinr/t'rcdilfir 

r.ni|ili.ivini.'iil l.>i\t' 

l.i-'aKi'. tt riii:m<\-

Mk;ili-dlm:i iV 

Arbitrniliui 

I ()} l-.M-'hongL-.s 

May 5, 2010 

Hearing Docket Clerk 

FAA, AGC^30 

Suite 2W10.00 . .. 

Wilbur Wright Building 

800 Independence Ave., SW 

Washington, DC 20591 (lploSdobo\ /CPOIO'6I9;L. 

I ..J 

— -i 

c:3 

Rc: FAA V. Qoud Dancer Aviation 

Case No: Not Assigned Yet 

Dear Sir or Madam; 

With respect to the above referenced matter, enclosed please find my original and one 

copy of Respondent's Response to Complainant's Admission.?, Interrogatories, and 

Production. 

Thank you for your assistance and should you have any questions, please feel free to 

contaa my office. 

Sincerely, / 

Dennis R. Haber, Esq. 

V 

DRH:ad ' 

Cc: Michelle Harper, E.sq. 

Main Office 8925 SW 14« Slrco , Suite 200 • Miumi, FL 33176 • Fhoiw. 305-256..1()O2 • Fax: 305-256-."i0O4 

130 Main Sircet • Nyack, New York 1()%0 • Plioiie: 845-34S-4747 
•> m' i 11002/007 

05/19/2010 13:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA ^"^ 

.VIC, 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OK TRANSPORI ATAlON 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

IN THE MATTER OF: 

CI.OUD DANCER AVIATION AND H.YING CLUB, INC. 

FAA CASE NO; 2009SOl5()233 

FAA DOCKET NO: 

CIVIL PENALTY ACTION 

RESPONDENl'S RESPONSHTO COMPLAINANT'S ADMISSIONS. 

INTERROGATORIES. AND PRODUCTION 

Respondent, Cloud Dancer Aviation and Flying Club Inc., through counsel, files this their 

Response served April 5*, 2010, and states as follows; 

ADMISSIONS 

1. Admitted 

2. Admitted 

3. Admitted 

4. Admitted 

5. Admitted 

6. Without knowledge 

7. Denied 

8. Without knowledge 

INTERROGATORIES 

1. Identify each person you may call as a witness in thi.<: proceeding. 

Answer: See attached List. 

2. For each person identified above, state the subject matter to which each person is expected 

to testily and include a summary of the expected testimony of each witness. 

Answer: 'l"hc wimesses will contend that the frequent visits from Mr. Webner, and the 

jokes about the reason for his frequent visits, were my wife. 

3. Identify each person, other than any person already indentificd in response to Interrogatory 

No. 1, whom you believe to have knowledge of the facts of this matter. 

An.swer: FAA FSDO Inspector Larry Enlowe, FAA FSDO 15 Manager Diane Fraum, 

Supervisor Roberto Echevarria, and Inspector Frank Webner. 

Law Olticc of Dciml? R. Habcr, PA 

8925 SW 14B Street, Suite- 200, Miami, FI 33176 • Phone: 305-2'>6'3002 • Fax: 30.5.:?.56'3004 
* DMS @l003/007 

05/19/2010 13:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

4. Identify each expert witness you may call to testily at a hearing on this matter. For each 

expert wimess identified, state the subject matter upon which each is expected to testify, 

summarize the substance of such expected testimony (including, without limitation, the 

substance of expected opinion testimony) and state the grounds for each such opinion 

(including, without limitation, identification of all facts, treatises, reports, records, 

documents or tangible evidence that form the basis for such opinion). 

Answer: Not detemiined at this time. 

5. Please explain the factual basis for your denial of paragraph 11.3 of the Complaint, 

and identify witnesses and exhibits you anticipate offering as evidence for such tiactual 

basis. 

An.swer; It is believed that Frank Webner was not wholly acting within his scope of 

professional duties at the time of the visit. See attached Witness f .1st. 

6. Please explain the factual basis for your denial of paragraph 11,4 of the Complaint, 

and identify wimesses and exhibits you anticipate ottering as evidence for such factual 

baiis. 

An.swer: The representative was not denied access. 

7. Please explain the factual basis for your answer to paragraph 11.5 of the Complaint in which 

you assert you are without knowledge, and identify witnesses and exhibits you anticipate 

oHering as evidence for such factual basis. 

Answer: 1 personally did not receive a letter8. Please explain the factual basis for your denial of paragraph 11.6 of the Complaint, 

and identify witnesses and exhibits you anticipate offering as evidence for such tactual 

basis. 

Answer: Cannot respond to a letter 1 do not have. 

9. Please explain the factual basis for your denial of paragraph 1U. 1 of the Complaint, 

and identify wimesses and exhibits you anticipate offering as evidence tor such factual 

ba,«!rs. 

Answer; I do not believe there was any violation. 

10. Please explain the factual basis for your denial of paragraph 111.3 of the Complaint, 

and identify witnesses and exhibits you anticipate offering as evidence for such factual basis 

Answer: I am not in a position to determine what penalty is appropriate, if any. 

Uw Office of Dcniiis R. Habcr, PA 

892.5 SW 148 Sirctr, Suite 200, Miami, Fi 31176 • Phone: 305-256-3002 • Fax: 305-256-3004 
05/19/201 0 13:3 5 FAX 202493514 2 FAA + DMS gl004/00 7 

17. Please explain the Actual basis for your seventh affirmative defense to Ifae Complaint, 

and identify witnesses and exhibits you anticipate ofiTering as evidence for such factual 

basis. 

Answer: At all times relevant. Respondent was ready, willing, and able and av:ulable to 

have said aircraft inspected wi^u t delay. Any delay which may have 

occurred was the result of FSDO not sending out a duly authorized and 

qualified representative in a timely £ishion. 

18. For each request for admission not admitted or denied, please state in detail the factual basis 

for the denial or no-admission, aad identify witnesses and exhibits you anticipate ofiering as 

evidence for such factual basis. 

Aitswer: Answered in paragraph 4. 

PRODUCTION 

Questions 1-16. 

Answer Documents have not been hilly obtained, subject to further discovery and/or 

acquired during deposition, including but not limited to, documents provided 

to the Respondent's counsel's office by Complainant's counsel. 

Under penalties of perjuiy, I declare that { have read the foregoing, and the facts alleged are tme, to die 

best of my knowledge and belief 

Signed on ^AA ^ 3 ^ ^2010 

^ ^ 

David Alber, President 

Cloud Dancer Aviation and Flying Club Lie. 

STATE OF 

COUNTY OF V)<^ Vo ^ V Cy 

sSOday of ¥\ 

2010, 

Thejforegoing instnunent was acknowledged before me on thi&^VJdsy of H -' 

by VyCA.Ot(A L.l\ \ V •< ^ as representative of Cloud Dancer Aviation and F l ^ g Club 

Inc., -amT" V>;o who personally appeared before me and acknowledged diat they 

signed the instnunent voluntarily for the purposes ei^ress^ in it 

Public, State of yDEBORAH E. MCK6CHN(E 

\ Noiary PuMc - State of Florida 

•|My Coitimissiofl Enpires Aug 30,2010 

'S^ ^ Comniission # DO 530945 

r..W-' Bonded By National Notary Assn 

• W W IP— • •• * ^ y 

Print, Type, or Stamp Name 

[ ] Personally Known 

[4JV6ducedIdentification v .--'T^ x 

Type of Identification V 1 \y\-~\ 0 )^ \ C. 

LAW OCBCC of Denute R, Habcr, PA 

8925 SW 148 Street, Suite 200, Miami, Fl 33176' Phone 305-256-3002 • Fax; 305-256-3004 
05/19/2010 13:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA * DMS 0005/007 

Certificate of Service 

1 HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing was .submitted via mail on this _P_ _ day of May 

2010 to Andrea Michelle Harper, Esq., Office of Regional Counsel, ASO-7, Southern Region, P.O. Box 

20636, Atlanta, GA 30320. 

Respectfully submitted. 

Dennis R. Haber, PA 

8925 SW 148 Street, Suite 200 

Miami, Fl 33176 

Phone: 305-256-3002 

Fax; 305-256-3004 

Dennis R. Habi 

FBN: 660817 

Law Office of Dcrnis R. Habcr, PA 

8925 SW 148 Street. Suite 200, Miami, Fl 33176 • Phone; 305-256-?002 • Fax: 305-2'56-3004 
^ DMS glOOG/007 

05/19/2010 13:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPOR I ATAlON 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

IN THE MATTER OF: 

CLOUD DANCER AVIATION AND FLYING CLUB, INC. 

FAA CASE NO: 2009SO150233 

FAA DOCKET NO: 

CIVIL PENALTY ACTION 

LIST OF PROPOSED WITNESSES 

1. Andrea Timko 

701 S- Atlantic Avenue 

Daytona Beach, FL 32118 

2. Bob McK.ee 

624 Cumberlen Road 

Flagler Hcach, FL32164 

3. Candace Hart 

3324 Cimarron Dr. 

Orlando, FL 32829 

4. Cory Srrousc 

725 Katherine Street 

South Daytona, Fl 32119 

5. Nick Ma7.arcigos 

520 Vermont Avenue 

Daytona Beach, FL 32114 

6. Rcnato Quitao 

105 Manctte, Apt. 106 

Daytona Beach, FL 32119 

7. Matthew Nimmo 

935 N. Halifax Avenue, Apt. 910 

Daytona Beach, FL 32118 

8. Naaman Beck 

115 Powell Drive, Apt. 14208 

Daytona Beach, FL 32114 

Law Office of Dennis R. Habcr, PA 

8925 SW 148 Street, Suite 200, Miami. Fl 33176 • Phone: 30.5-256-3002 - Fax: 305-256-3004 
05/19/2010 13:35 FAX 2024935142 FAA * DMS @]007/007 

9. Jackie Burant 

725 Katherine Street 

South Daytona, Fl 32119 

10. Jamie Beckett 

1931 Orange Tree Drive 

Edgewater, FL 32141 

11. Jonathan Alber 

3156 Tunisia Drive 

Dcltona, FL 32738 

12. VinceDaSilva 

24 Blare Drive 

Palm Coast, FL 32137 

13. David Alber Jr. 

3156 Tunisia Drive 

Deltona, FL 32724 

14. .Fonathan Leach 

1630 Lemon Street 

Deland, FL 32720 

15. Eugene Heath 

1811 Golf view Blvd. 

South Daytona, F132J19 

Ldw Office of Dennis R. Haber, PA 

8925 SW 148 Street, Suite 200, Miami, tl 33176 • Phone: 305-256-3002 - Fax: 30.'>-2.'56-30O4