UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA 

Objection Codes (SDFL Local Rule 16.1) 

A – Authenticity H – Hearsay

I – Contains inadmissible matter UP – Unduly prejudicial 

R – Relevancy P – Privileged

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 1 of 19

Erik Chavez, et al., 

vs.

Grill Enterprises, LLC, et al. 

PRESIDING JUDGE PLAINTIFF’S ATTORNEY(S) DEFENDANT’S ATTORNEY(S) 

Hon. Jonathan Goodman Anthony F. Sanchez Brian H. Pollock 

Todd W. Shulby

TRIAL DATE(S) COURT REPORTER COURTROOM DEPUTY 

May 8, 2023 

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

 – EXHIBITS – 

 

 ERIK CHAVEZ RECORDS (PHASE I) 

P-1a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/21/17 

P-1b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/21/17 

P-2a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/2/17 

P-2b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/2/17 

P-3a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/19/17 

P-3b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/19/17 

P-4a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/2/17 

P-4b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/2/17 

P-5a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/16/17 

PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST 

Case No.: 20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN [CONSENT] 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 1 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 2 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-5b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/16/17 

P-6a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/30/17 

P-6b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/30/17 

P-7a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/13/17 

P-7b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/13/17 

P-8a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/27/17 

P-8b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/27/17 

P-9a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/11/17 

P-9b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/11/17 

P-10a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/25/17 

P-10b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/25/17 

P-11a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/8/17 

P-11b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/8/17 

P-12a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/22/17 

P-12b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/22/17 

P-13a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/6/17 

P-13b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/6/17 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 2 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 3 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-14a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/20/17 

P-14b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/20/17 

P-15a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/3/18 

P-15b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/3/18 

P-16a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/17/18 

P-16b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/17/18 

P-17a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/31/18 

P-17b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/31/18 

P-18a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/14/18 

P-18b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/14/18 

P-19a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/28/18 

P-19b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/28/18 

P-20a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/14/18 

P-20b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/14/18 

P-21a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/28/18 

P-21b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/28/18 

P-22a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

4/11/18 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 3 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 4 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-22b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

4/11/18 

P-23a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

4/25/18 

P-23b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

4/25/18 

P-24a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/9/18 

P-24b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/9/18 

P-25a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/23/18 

P-25b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/23/18 

P-26a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/6/18 

P-26b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/6/18 

P-27a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/20/18 

P-27b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/20/18 

P-28a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/4/18 

P-28b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/4/18 

P-29a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/18/18 

P-29b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/18/18 

P-30a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/1/18 

P-30b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/1/18 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 4 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 5 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-31a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/15/18 

P-31b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/15/18 

P-32a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/29/18 

P-32b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/29/18 

P-33a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/12/18 

P-33b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/12/18 

P-34a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/26/18 

P-34b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/26/18 

P-35a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/10/18 

P-35b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/10/18 

P-36a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/24/18 

P-36b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/24/18 

P-37a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/7/18 

P-37b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/7/18 

P-38a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/21/18 

P-38b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/21/18 

P-39a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/5/18 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 5 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 6 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-39b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/5/18 

P-40a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/19/18 

P-40b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/19/18 

P-41a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/2/19 

P-41b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/2/19 

 A, I, H ERIK CHAVEZ (PHASE II) 

P-42a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/16/19 

P-42b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/16/19 

P-43a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/30/19 

P-43b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/30/19 

P-44a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/13/19 

P-44b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/13/19 

P-45a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/27/19 

P-45b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/27/19 

P-46a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/13/19 

P-46b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/13/19 

P-47a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/27/19 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 6 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 7 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-47b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/27/19 

P-48a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

4/10/19 

P-48b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

4/10/19 

P-49a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

4/24/19 

P-49b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

4/24/19 

P-50a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/8/19 

P-50b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/8/19 

P-51a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/22/19 

P-51b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/22/19 

P-52a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/5/19 

P-52b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/5/19 

P-53a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/19/19 

P-53b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/19/19 

P-54a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/3/19 

P-54b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/3/19 

P-55a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/17/19 

P-55b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/17/19 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 7 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 8 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-56a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/31/19 

P-56b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/31/19 

P-57a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/14/19 

P-57b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/14/19 

P-58a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/28/19 

P-58b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/28/19 

P-59a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/11/19 

P-59b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/11/19 

P-60a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/25/19 

P-60b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/25/19 

P-61a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/9/19 

P-61b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/9/19 

P-62a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/23/19 

P-62b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/23/19 

P-63a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/6/19 

P-63b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/6/19 

P-64a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/20/19 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 8 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 9 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-64b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/20/19 

P-65a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/4/19 

P-65b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/4/19 

P-66a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/18/19 

P-66b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/18/19 

P-67a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/1/2020 

P-67b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/1/2020 

P-68a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/15/2020 

P-68b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/15/2020 

P-69a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/29/2020 

P-69b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/29/2020 

P-70a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/12/2020 

P-70b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/12/2020 

P-71a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/26/2020 

P-71b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/26/2020 

P-72a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/11/2020 

P-72b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/11/2020 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 9 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 10 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-73a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/25/2020 

P-73b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/25/2020 

P-74a A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/28/2020 

P-74b A, I, H Plaintiff Erik Chavez’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/28/2020 

 LEO DIAZ RECORDS (PHASE I)

P-75a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/9/2018 

P-75b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/9/2018 

P-76a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/23/2018 

P-76b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/23/2018 

P-77a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/6/2018 

P-77b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/6/2018 

P-78a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/20/2018 

P-78b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/20/2018 

P-79a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/4/2018 

P-79b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/4/2018 

P-80a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/18/2018 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 10 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 11 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-80b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/18/2018 

P-81a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/1/2018 

P-81b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/1/2018 

P-82a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/15/2018 

P-82b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/15/2018 

P-83a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/29/2018 

P-83b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/29/2018 

P-84a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/12/2018 

P-84b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/12/2018 

P-85a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/26/2018 

P-85b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/26/2018 

P-86a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/10/2018 

P-86b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/10/2018 

P-87a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/24/2018 

P-87b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/24/2018 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 11 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 12 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-88a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/07/2018 

P-88b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/07/2018 

P-89a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/21/2018 

P-89b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/21/2018 

P-90a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/05/2018 

P-90b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/05/2018 

P-91a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

12/19/2018 

P-91b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

12/19/2018 

P-92a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/2/2019 

P-92b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/2/2019 

 LEO DIAZ RECORDS (PHASE II)

P-93a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/16/2019 

P-93a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/16/2019 

P-93b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

1/30/2019 

P-94a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

1/30/2019 

P-94b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/13/2019 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 12 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 13 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-95a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/13/2019 

P-95b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

2/27/2019 

P-96a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

2/27/2019 

P-96b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/13/2019 

P-97a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/13/2019 

P-97b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

3/27/2019 

P-98a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

3/27/2019 

P-98b A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

4/10/2019 

P-99a A, R, I, H, 

UP

 Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

4/10/2019 

P-99b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

4/24/2019 

P-100a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

4/24/2019 

P-100b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/8/2019 

P-101a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/8/2019 

P-101b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

5/22/2019 

P-102a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

5/22/2019 

P-102b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/5/2019 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 13 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 14 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-103a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/5/2019 

P-103b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

6/19/2019 

P-104a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

6/19/2019 

P-104b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/3/2019 

P-105a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/3/2019 

P-105b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/17/2019 

P-106a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/17/2019 

P-106b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

7/31/2019 

P-107a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

7/31/2019 

P-107b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/14/2019 

P-108a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/14/2019 

P-108b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

8/28/2019 

P-109a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

8/28/2019 

P-109b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/11/2019 

P-110a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/11/2019 

P-110b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

9/25/2019 

P-111a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

9/25/2019 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 14 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 15 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-112b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/9/2019 

P-112a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/9/2019 

P-113b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

10/23/2019 

P-113a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

10/23/2019 

P-114a A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Paystub / Payroll Details for period ending 

11/6/2019 

P-114b A, I, H Plaintiff Leonel Diaz’s Time and Shift Details for period ending 

11/6/2019 

 

P-115 R, I, UP, H, 

A 

 “Paycheck Protection Program” loan application completed by 

Defendant Ruben Sierra for Defendant Grill Enterprises, LLC. 

(Filed as DE 65-3) 

P-116 R, I, UP, H, 

A 

 Composite of first page of Form 1120S corporate tax returns of 

Defendant Grill Enterprises, LLC for the tax years 2015 – 2020. 

(Filed as DE 65-1) 

P-117 R, I, UP, H, 

A 

 Composite of Schedule K-1 (“Shareholder’s Share of Income, 

Deductions, Credits, etc.”) excerpts of Defendant Grill Enterprises, 

LLC’s corporate tax returns for the tax years 2015 through 2020. 

(Filed as DE 65-2) 

P-118 R, I, UP, H, 

A 

 Form 1120S corporate tax returns of Defendant Grill Enterprises, 

LLC for the tax years 2015 – 2020. 

P-119 R, I, UP, H, 

A, P 

 Form 1040 tax returns of Defendant Ruben Sierra for the tax years 

2015 – 2019. 

 

P-120 H, C Affidavits and unsworn statements/declarations of Ruben Sierra 

(Filed as DEs 67-3, 73-1, 96-3, 103-1) 

P-121 H, C Affidavits and unsworn statements/declarations of Yeison Gonzalez 

(Filed as DEs 67-4, 73-3, 96-4, and 103-3) 

P-122 H, C Affidavits and unsworn statements/declarations of Vanessa Carrillo 

(Filed as DEs 67-5, 73-2, 96-5, and 103-2) 

 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 15 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 16 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-123 R, I, UP, A, 

H 

 Composite of “Florida Department of Revenue Employer’s 

Quarterly Report[s]” (a/k/a “RT-6” forms) for the quarter ending 

6/30/15 through quarter ending 6/30/20. 

(Filed as DE 65-8) 

P-124 R, I, UP, A, 

H 

 Composite of “Sunbiz” entity details for the following entities: 

Alejandro C. Chef, LLC; At Your Fingertips 81, LLC; Consultaora 

Latinoamericana T I, Inc.; Global Castle LLC; Jacob Supply LLC; 

Lux-Pro Detail, LLC; T&S Supplies, Inc.; Troxx LLC; VIP Crew 

Inc. 

 

P-125a R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Grill Enterprises, LLCs answers (served by Defendants 

on 2/2/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Set of Interrogatories. 

P-125b R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Ruben Sierra’s answers (served by Defendants on 2/2/21) 

to Plaintiffs’ First Set of Interrogatories. 

P-126a R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Grill Enterprises, LLC’s supplemental answers (served 

by Defendants on 6/18/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Set of Interrogatories. 

P-126b R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Ruben Sierra’s supplemental answers (served by 

Defendants on 6/18/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Set of Interrogatories. 

P-127 R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendants’ joint answers (served by Defendants on 8/9/21) to 

Plaintiffs’ Second Set of Interrogatories. 

P-128a R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Grill Enterprises, LLC responses (served by Defendants 

on 2/2/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Request for Production of Documents. 

P-128b R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Ruben Sierra’s responses (served by Defendants on 

2/2/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Request for Production of Documents. 

P-129a R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Grill Enterprises, LLC’s supplemental responses (served 

by Defendants on 3/12/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Request for 

Production of Documents. 

P-129b R, I, UP, H, 

C 

 Defendant Ruben Sierra’s supplemental responses (served by 

Defendants on 3/12/21) to Plaintiffs’ First Request for Production of 

Documents. 

P-130 R, I, UP H, 

C 

 Defendants’ joint responses (served by Defendants on 3/15/21) to 

Plaintiffs’ Second Request for Production of Documents. 

P-131 R, I, UP H, 

C 

 Defendants’ joint supplemental responses (served by Defendants on 

6/18/21) to Plaintiffs’ Second Request for Production of Documents. 

P-132 R, I, UP H, 

C 

 Defendants’ joint responses (served by Defendants on 8/9/21) to 

Plaintiffs’ Third Request for Production of Documents. 

 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 16 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 17 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

P-133 R, A, H, UP 2017 - Florida Minimum Wage Publication

P-134 R, A, H, UP 2018 - Florida Minimum Wage Publication

P-135 R, A, H, UP 2019 - Florida Minimum Wage Publication

P-136 R, A, H, UP 2020 - Florida Minimum Wage Publication

 

P-137 R, I, UP, H, 

A, C July 1, 2020 Demand for unpaid wage and statutory damages 

 

P-138 R, I, UP, H, 

A, C 

 All documents produced by Defendants during the course of 

discovery in this case. 

P-139 R, I, UP All documents referenced by Defendants in their responses to 

Plaintiffs’ discovery requests in this case. 

P-140 All exhibits listed by Defendants. 

P-141 U, R, I, UP Any exhibits necessary for rebuttal or impeachment. 

P-142 R, I, UP, H, 

A 

 Any summaries of evidence under Rule 1006 and other 

demonstrative exhibits 

 

 – WITNESSES –

 Erik Chavez 

 Leonel Diaz 

 Ruben Sierra 

 Vanessa Carrillo 

 Yeison (a/k/a Nelson) Gonzalez 

 Mariana Pinto 

 Denysse Carrillo 

 “Alejandro C Chef” 

address unknown 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 17 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 18 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

 Cesar LNUK 

address unknown 

 “Consultora Latinoamericana/Consultora Latinoamericana TI” 

address unknown 

 Farid Abouchedid 

address unknown 

 Gallego LNUK 

address unknown 

 Gerardo Fernandez 

address unknown 

 “Global Castle”/”Global Castel” 

address unknown 

 Gustavo Diaz 

address unknown 

 Hedixon Bueno 

address unknown 

 Idelfonso Moreno 

c/o Todd W. Shulby, PA 

 Iris Pedrosa 

address unknown 

 Ivan LNUK 

address unknown 

 “Jacob Supply” 

address unknown 

 Jaime Diaz 

address unknown 

 Jose Hernandez 

address unknown 

 Jose Romero 

address unknown 

 Josefina Ramirez 

address unknown 

 “Lux Pro Detail” 

address unknown 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 18 of 19
PLAINTIFFS’ WITNESS & EXHIBIT LIST – CONTINUATION 

Chavez vs. Grill Enterprises, LLC CASE NO. 

20-22603-CIV-GOODMAN 

*Include a notation as to the location of any exhibit not held with the case file or not available because of size. Page 19 of 19

PLF. 

NO.

DATE 

OFFERED MARKED OBJECTION ADMITTED DESCRIPTION OF EXHIBITS* AND WITNESSES

 Manuel Bravo 

address unknown 

 Manuel M (LNUK) 

address unknown 

 Miguel Nava 

address unknown 

 Roger Lahoud 

address unknown 

 “Troxx” 

address unknown 

 Vanesa Bohorquez 

address unknown 

 “VIP Crew” 

address unknown 

 Wilmer Castro 

address unknown 

 Yonathan del Valle 

address unknown 

 Any witness listed by Defendants. 

 Any rebuttal or impeachment witness. 

 Any witness identified in Defendants’ responses to Plaintiffs’ 

discovery requests. 

 Any witness identified in Plaintiffs’ responses to Defendants’ 

discovery requests. 

 Any employee or non-employee “contractor” of the Defendants who 

participated in the “tip pool”. 

 Any witness identified during depositions taken in this case. 

Plaintiffs reserve the right to amend or supplement this list. 

Case 1:20-cv-22603-JG Document 144-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 04/24/2023 Page 19 of 19