UNITED STATESDISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRIW OFFLORIDA

CASENO>20-21859-CIV-ALTONAGA/Goodman

FILED BY =ko D.C.

SEF 2i2222

cm ttllt%%wb

S..D.OFFLA.-MIAM.

Inthe M atteroftheCom plaintforExonerationfrom orLimitationofLiabilitybyJoseGarcia, asow nerof

the201940''BeneteauM otorYachtbearingHulIdentificationNo. BENER159L819

/

THIRD PARTY DEFENDANTAllisonDilonTorresAnswersaIIThird PartyCom plaintsasfollows:

1)ThisDefendantdeniesallallegationsintheComplaintsexceptthefolowing:

a)lwasontheboatatthetimeoftheaccident;and

b)Theboathadanaccident.

2)ThisDefendantaffirmativelystatesthefollowingasadefenseorAffirmativeDefensetothese

Com plaints:Iwasgiven permissiontobeontheboatbytheowner, JoseGarciabothoriginalyand after

dinner.Idid notturnontheboatanddid notattem ptto operate it. Ididtouchthesteeringwheelbut

did notintentionallyengage anym otorortrytosteertheboat.The motorwasalreadyonwhenIgot

backontheboat.

W HEREFORE,IrespectfulyrequestthattheCourtdism issaIlThirdPartyCom plaintsagainstmewith

prejudice.

1HEREBYCERTIFYthatacopyofthisAnswerisbeingsim ultaneouslymailedtoaIIattorneysofrecordas

setforthbelow .

M ustafaHasanDandashly

1SE3rd Avenue,Suite3020

M iam i,FL33131

SidneyArthurGoldberg

Goldbergand RosenP.A.

1111BrickellAve

Suite2180

M iam i,FL33131

Case 1:20-cv-21859-CMA Document 131 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/24/2020 Page 1 of 4
JohnW .Keler,lIl

121MajorcaAvenue

M iam i,FL33134

JonathanW illiam SkippandCraigPatrickLiszt

Horr,NovakandSkipp,P.A.

Two DatranCenter,Suite1700

9130SouthDadeland Blvd.

M iam i,FL33156

SheylaM esa

Keller& Bolz,LLP

121MajorcaAvenue

Suite200

CoralGables,FL33134

RobertD.Peltz

ThePeltzLaw Firm

10220SW 141Street

M iami,FL33176

AllisonDilonTorres Date

G R Y

Case 1:20-cv-21859-CMA Document 131 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/24/2020 Page 2 of 4
A'.l1g'l1sf-27.n()-'O

Tt7$V1t7.1111'5Ia)-C't.'lcenl.'

C)1slt-l'cl8.2020.1.StepllanyZapaîa-u-asinviîedt/'ali'iendonthebtnaîof511..JoseGarcia.Lrpon

arrivalt7tleboat-1qpasiltrodlcedtoN.Ir.JoseCiarciaandhistu-t7glests.Als.AlisonDillonaldN'Ir.

ClristiallEstrnda.

Afterafen'iloursoutatseau-itll.:11'.Garcia.hisglests.and113'friends.B'eB'elt1'oC'asablatca

Restalraltfordiller.Aftertlledilulel'.Xls.DilollalldlB'el'eils'ited(()gouvaitt'llAh'.Garcia*sbtval

svhileîlleluendiscussedandtookcareofthecllet-kpaylent.

Nvlileontleboat.IcolN'ersedu.'ill51s.Dilontogettolulou'eachotler.abitB'dsllvtirsttinlenleeting

ller..A4onepoitltshebegantotelllneastoryabollobtaililïgherdriq-erslicenseil.1el'lariA'ecolltry and

accidentall-blillpedtlebtnattl'tntle.

(--lïcethetlrotleAvasaccideluallyblllped.theboatbegantoltAN'e.Icanl000ocoltirnltlusactu'asal1

accident.asN'Is.Dillonneverilïtendedtonlovetheboal.s'Ioreover.atloptliltdid.NIs.Dillonturlany

key.Avhiclleadst'uletocolclldel'leboaf-slororsu-ereonnrllel)q'eboalqdedtheN-essel.

HadIseell-NIs.DilonattellpttopllrposelyturnontlleigltitiolortelllesheplatuledolloN'ilgthe

boat-lu't-luldhas'estoppedherbecallseitu'otldlaN'eptltbothofotlrliN'esil1danger..A.stlïeollyother

persononboardtheboatn-hentheaccideltoccurred.Icanguaranteetlat5ls.Dilloltlleqvel'ladtleintelt

todriveorlnoq'etleboatand thattheelltil'eactu'asantlnfortulïateaccidetlt.

Respectt-uly'hrours.

StephanyZapata

Case 1:20-cv-21859-CMA Document 131 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/24/2020 Page 3 of 4
t

D

C

'

.y

Bm

*

œ

@)

D

@

'o

=$

4-

t

O 5

*

# %

C à

,

7m .k'J'G

k m

>E Jr'

4î

=

œ

= c

m œ

o E

- œ

m

c

- ï

W

m

D

m

<

m

c

rn

= x

I . -A

:I.',..- -.-x rw)

-;:. .: 1 24; ; .'''' I ''o # *2 :' Na u txz! $ I c) .' 62 . . W j(a .

. y(ao , x uw=.o

X%.. ...'r

&

N'

jAzTq>h'

L- e$

&s CN

IN <..7

C)

m

N

T

Q

X.*8

>

Z

h8

71 *;

Z T20 çp

t:

r o

ç.''

? .r-*

Z R

N.

M7

*

g

eA

, (E,l-E-' # v

tlz F MQ

k? o o

i'>o -èk'h

*> +

xX #D

<

+ + + 8. + +

C

>

+

M

O

m

<

m

= +

+ + + +

$.-. .

Case 1:20-cv-21859-CMA Document 131 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/24/2020 Page 4 of 4