APPENDIX S 

Responses to Comments 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-1 

Constitution Pipeline and Wright Interconnect Projects 

Comments on the Draft EIS and Responses 

INDEX

Document 

Number Commentor 

FEDERAL AGENCIES 

FA1 U.S. House of Representatives – Tom Reed 

FA2 U.S. Department of the Interior 

FA3 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 

FA4 U.S. Department of the Interior 

FA5 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers 

FA6 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 

FA7 Congress of the United States House of Representatives – Chris Gibson 

FA8 Congress of the United States House of Representatives – Chris Gibson 

FA9 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 

FA10 Congress of the United States House of Representatives – Chris Gibson 

FA11 United States Senate – Kirsten Gillibrand 

STATE AGENCIES 

SA1 NYS Department of Environmental Conservation 

SA2 NY Department of Public Service 

SA3 NYS Department of Agriculture 

SA4 NYS Department of Environmental Conservation 

SA5 Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources – 

Office of Policy and Planning 

SA6 State of New York Office of the Attorney General 

SA7 NYS Department of Environmental Conservation 

SA8 NYS Department of Environmental Conservation 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-2 

LOCAL AGENCIES 

LA1 Town of Meredith 

LA2 Town of Roseboom 

LA3 Schoharie County Soil and Water Conservation 

LA4 Town of Schoharie 

LA5 Town of Davenport 

LA6 Town of Maryland 

LA7 Town of Meredith NY Planning Board 

LA8 Village of Schoharie 

LA9 Rosenthal for Otsego County 

LA10 Delaware County Board of Supervisors 

LA11 Town of Meredith 

NATIVE AMERICAN TRIBES 

NAT1 Seneca Nation of Indians 

NAT2 Stockbridge-Munsee Tribal Historic Preservation Office 

NAT3 Mashantucket Pequot Tribal Nation 

NAT4 Oneida Indian Nation 

COMPANIES AND ORGANIZATIONS 

CO1 Stop The Pipeline 

CO2 Stop The Pipeline 

CO3 Stop The Pipeline 

CO4 Elefant for Kernan Land Trust 

CO5 Kernan Land Trust 

CO6 State University of New York 

CO7 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO8 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO9 Kernan Land Trust 

CO10 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO11 Earthjustice 

CO12 Hudson Highlands for Kernan Land Trust 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-3 

CO13 Delaware-Otsego Audubon Society 

CO14 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO15 Stop The Pipeline 

CO16 Otsego County Conservation Association 

CO17 Lilac Hill Farm 

CO18 Leatherstocking Gas Company LLC 

CO19 National Grid Gas Delivery Companies 

CO20 Independent Power Producers 

CO21 Board of Cooperative Educational Services 

CO22 Trout Unlimited 

CO23 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO24 Cornell for Kernan Land Trust 

CO25 Advocates for Springfield 

CO26 Otsego 2000 

CO27 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO28 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO29 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO30 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO31 Allegheny Defense Project 

CO32 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO33 Business Council of NY State 

CO34 The Christensen Family Trust 

CO35 Chesapeake Bay Foundation 

CO36 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO37 Kernan Land Trust 

CO38 Skyhill Farm LLC 

CO39 Allegheny Defense Project 

CO40 Damascus Citizens for Sustainability 

CO41 Earthjustice 

CO42 Stop The Pipeline 

CO43 Hudson Highlands for Kernan Land Trust 

CO44 NYS Council of Trout Unlimited 

CO45 Bluestone Pipeline Company 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-4 

CO46 Schenevus Central School 

CO47 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO48 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO49 Unatego Area Landowners Association 

CO50 Kernan Land Trust 

CO51 Pennsylvania Sierra Club 

CO52 Concerned Citizens of Trout Creek 

CO53 James Bacon for CWCWC 

CO54 Bruce S. Kernan for Kernan Land Trust 

CO55 Stanton Family Farms, LLC. 

CO56 Laborers International Union of North America (Local 785) 

CO57 Breathe Easy Susquehanna County 

CO58 Joint Landowners Coalition of New York Inc. 

CO59 Flying Changes B&B LLC. 

CO60 Laborers International Union of North America (Local 785) 

CO61 Upstate Landowners Group LLC 

CO62 Laborers International Union of North America (Local 785) 

CO63 Unatego Area Landowners Association 

CO64 Leatherstocking Gas Company LLC 

CO65 Center for Sustainable Rural Communities 

CO66 Binghamton-Oneonta Building and Construction Trades Council 

CO67 NYS Economic Development Council 

CO68 Delaware-Otsego Audubon Society 

CO69 Earthjustice 

CO70 Hudson Highlands Environmental 

CO71 Earthjustice 

CO72 Pace Environmental 

CO73 Earthjustice 

CO74 Earthjustice 

CO75 HydroQuest 

CO76 Nolan and Heller, LLP 

 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-5 

INDIVIDUALS 

IND1 Michele Barnes 

IND2 John H. Hill 

IND3 Irwin Waldman 

IND4 Kerry Lynch 

IND5 John Hotaling 

IND6 John Hotaling 

IND7 Robert Decker 

IND8 Judith Salzmann 

IND9 Bert W. Finch 

IND10 Edward Rubio, Jr. 

IND11 Marc Wishengrad 

IND12 Lisa J. Barr 

IND13 Karen O’Neill 

IND14 Rachel Polens 

IND15 Kim Rasmussen 

IND16 Janet Terchek 

IND17 John Miglietta 

IND18 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND19 Janet Terchek 

IND20 Mark Pezzati 

IND21 Stuart Anderson 

IND22 Joy Barteski 

IND23 Carole Marner 

IND24 Janet Marsh 

IND25 Tammy Reiss 

IND26 Daniel J. Brignoli 

IDN27 Lisa Zaccaglini 

IND28 Carolyn F. Melszer 

IND29 Lennard Davis 

IND30 Bob Rosen 

IND31 Murray Bell 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-6 

IND32 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND33 Robert Lidsky 

IND34 Chris Rosenthal 

IND35 Howard L. Hannum 

IND36 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND37 Leona Briggs 

IND38 Barbara Loeffler 

IND39 James F. Lange 

IND40 Leanne Harrison 

IND41 Eleanor M. Moriarty 

IND42 Wes Ernsberger 

IND43 Laura Jean Oliva-Brignoli 

IND44 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND45 Philip James and Rachel Diana Hulbert 

IND46 Deborah Krol 

IND47 Rachel Diana Hulbert 

IND48 Mark E. Archambault 

IND49 Rebecca S. Casstevens 

IND50 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND51 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND52 Richard Levine 

IND53 Ed Wagner 

IND54 Bob Rosen 

IND55 Christine Lange 

IND56 Florence Carnahan 

IND57 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND58 Michele Lechanteur 

IND59 Jean Hricik 

IND60 Robert Lidsky 

IND61 Matt Malina 

IND62 John L. Keiser 

IND63 Asher Pacht 

IND64 Peter B. Sweeny 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-7 

IND65 Amy Irene Anderson 

IND66 Julie Hagan Bloch 

IND67 Patricia Goldsmith 

IND68 Danielle Simon 

IND69 Daniel J. Brignoli 

IND70 Mary Donch 

IND71 Kenneth Klein 

IND72 Artineh Havan 

IND73 Joseph Lawson 

IND74 Mary Tuthill 

IND75 Robert Minotti 

IND76 Alaina Johnson 

IND77 Mary L. Tuthill 

IND78 Steven Kostis 

IND79 Anna Berg 

IND80 Gerald W. Shaftan, M.D. 

IND81 Fern Stearney 

IND82 Brian Fink 

IND83 Christopher H. Hachmann 

IND84 Amy Bernhardt-Moore 

IND85 Alex Stavis 

IND86 Stirling Davenport 

IND87 Christine R. Eckerson 

IND88 Mark Pezzati 

IND89 Ruth Carr 

IND90 Henrietta Statham 

IND91 Michael Meadows 

IND92 Brian Kelly 

IND93 Kathi Chipman 

IND94 Eugene Marner 

IND95 Eugene Marner 

IND96 Don Statham 

IND97 William Sharfman 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-8 

IND98 Paul Hetzler 

IND99 Cindy and Henry Greenblatt 

IND100 Christine M. Lange 

IND101 Jeff and Maggie Pangman 

IND102 Edward Butler 

IND103 Eleanor Moriarty 

IND104 Julie Wawrzynek 

IND105 Mark and Carmen D’Amico 

IND106 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND107 Bill Livingston 

IND108 Patricia Wheelhouse 

IND109 John Miglietta 

IND110 Susan Jacques 

IND111 Robert Lidsky 

IND112 Robert Lidsky 

IND113 Daniel J. Brignoli 

IND114 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND115 Anthony Macaluso 

IND116 Victoria Furio 

IND117 Walter and Judith Denton 

IND118 Jason Siemion 

IND119 Suzanne Winkler 

IND120 Dianne Sefcik 

IND121 James Bixby Sr. 

IND122 Margaret G. Bixby 

IND123 Kurt Seitz 

IND124 Ann S. Horan 

IND125 Robert Lidsky 

IND126 Sharon Goldstein 

IND127 Richard L. Walworth 

IND128 Eugene Marner 

IND129 John Miglietta 

IND130 Robert Lidsky 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-9 

IND131 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND132 Suzanne Winkler 

IND133 Allegra Schecter 

IND134 Bob Rosen 

IND135 Kate Ryan 

IND136 Patricia Wheelhouse 

IND137 Shyama Orum 

IND138 Cathy McNulty 

IND139 Thomas Gorman 

IND140 Bobbie Dee Flowers 

IND141 Thomas Gorman 

IND142 John 

IND143 Liz Wassell 

IND144 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND145 Steven Kostis 

IND146 Jared Cornelia 

IND147 Jack DiGirolamo 

IND148 Thomas M. Alba 

IND149 Mary Rojeski 

IND150 Eugene Marner 

IND151 Irwin Waldman 

IND152 Francois Lagasse 

IND153 Lisa Lerner 

IND154 Gina Dahlstron-Osburn 

IND155 Charlotte Jones 

IND156 Amy Irene Anderson 

IND157 Janice Cragnolin 

IND158 Mav Moorhead 

IND159 John Hill 

IND160 Bill Bianchetto 

IND161 Barry Harris 

IND162 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND163 May Colleen McKinney 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-10 

IND164 David Wright 

IND165 Dr. Nancy Rourke 

IND166 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND167 Donald Sykes 

IND168 Caroline Martin 

IND169 Caroline Martin 

IND170 Ann Roberti 

IND171 Sue Bailey 

IND172 Ronald Bailey 

IND173 Pamela Bohsung 

IND174 David and Rebecca Colby 

IND175 Nick Nazzaro 

IND176 Mary Pellegrino 

IND177 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND178 William H. Owen 

IND179 Carmela Marner 

IND180 Cristina Toro 

IND181 Sharon Meyer 

IND182 Patricia Bower 

IND183 Neil Bleifeld 

IND184 Thomas Buford 

IND185 Gretchen Herrmann 

IND186 Alanna Rose 

IND187 Mark Davies 

IND188 Charles Filipski 

IND189 Kathryn Davino 

IND190 Maria Kaltenbach 

IND191 Eugene Marner 

IND192 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND193 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND194 Michael Gogins 

IND195 J.L. Marsh 

IND196 Sara Zimmerman 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-11 

IND197 Dianne Srfcik 

IND198 Janet Terchek 

IND199 Dianne Sefcik 

IND200 Anthony Yacopino 

IND201 Steve Whitesell 

IND202 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND203 Jessica Galasso 

IND204 Marone S. Acee 

IND205 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND206 Richard D. Hill 

IND207 Florence Carnahan 

IND208 Robert Cusick 

IND209 Florence Carnahan 

IND210 Lisa Hoffman 

IND211 Florence Carnahan 

IND212 Zoya Kocur 

IND213 Linda Bevilacqua 

IND214 Wayne Hoffman 

IND215 Bruce E. Blanchard 

IND216 Epifanio Bevilacqua 

IND217 Anne Hemenway 

IND218 Tim Taggart 

IND219 Richard Cooper 

IND220 John Dennis McGreen 

IND221 Keith Hoffman 

IND222 Patti Packer 

IND223 David LaVerne 

IND224 Irwin Waldman 

IND225 John Dunham 

IND226 Constance Brace 

IND227 Suzanne Geoghegan 

IND228 Richard and Sudjai Bentley 

IND229 Kim N. Felter-Canarelli 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-12 

IND230 Suzanne Winkler 

IND231 Esther Lerman 

IND232 Joseph Maloney 

IND233 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND234 Geoffrey Schaffner 

IND235 Kaima Nelson-Bowne 

IND236 E. Driesen 

IND237 Bob Moss 

IND238 Joyce Moss 

IND239 Pat Roberts 

IND240 Gaetano Catapano 

IND241 Dianne Sefcik 

IND242 Lynn Hartz 

IND243 Deliss Reynolds-Lyssy 

IND244 Suzanne Winkler 

IND245 Kerry Hanley 

IND246 Christine Alexander 

IND247 Aaron Fumarola 

IND248 Douglas Vitarius 

IND249 Catherine M. Holleran 

IND250 Dee Singer and Len Terper 

IND251 Kenneth G. Stanton III 

IND252 Jean Manley 

IND253 T. Gorman 

IND254 Claudia H. Gorman 

IND255 Anne Lazarus 

IND256 Jeffrey Ellenberger 

IND257 Jonathan Chasan 

IND258 Werner and Doris M. Moennich 

IND259 Murray Bell 

IND260 Leona Briggs 

IND261 Allegra Schecter 

IND262 Kerry A. Lynch 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-13 

IND263 Bruce S. Kernan 

IND264 Barbara A. Loeffler 

IND265 Skyla Graig-Murray 

IND266 Jayne 

IND267 Ellen Sokolow 

IND268 Bob Rosen 

IND269 Allegra Schecter 

IND270 Mark Pezzati 

IND271 Eugene Marner 

IND272 Hazen B. Reed 

IND273 Megan Holleran 

IND274 Chancey B. Beneski 

IND275 E. S. S. Activity 

IND276 Summer Oxazanna Steenolsen 

IND277 Kiana Lum 

IND278 Leihau Deante Kaipolani Lauronal 

IND279 Cassie Acoba-Lee 

IND280 Chloe Smith 

IND281 Warren 

IND282 Valerie Dudley 

IND283 Kathleen Acoba 

IND284 Keahi-Malia Banagan-Cecchetto 

IND285 Kandice Grow 

IND286 Christine R. Eckerson 

IND287 Naia 

IND288 Douglas Kerr 

IND289 Ally Nisenoff 

IND290 Elizabeth Poreba 

IND291 Shary Skoloff 

IND292 William and Nancy Turick 

IND293 Patrice K. VanSlyke 

IND294 Devin Kerr 

IND295 Maureen Mackie Dill 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-14 

IND296 Lois L. Williams 

IND297 Bruce A. Baxter Jr. 

IND298 Michael Huarachi 

IND299 Patricia Koenig 

IND300 Jay Blotcher 

IND301 Amy Harlib 

IND302 Sandra Rourke 

IND303 Stuart Anderson 

IND304 Robert Lidsky 

IND305 Annjeanette Wright 

IND306 Jeanne Simonelli 

IND307 Marvin F. Jester 

IND308 David J. Chiusano 

IND309 Jacqueline F. Oliva 

IND310 Richard Friedberg 

IND311 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND312 Laurel A. Santomassino 

IND313 Gary D. Peake 

IND314 Gabriella Leach 

IND315 Gabriella Leach 

IND316 Gaetano Catapano 

IND317 Gaetano Catapano 

IND318 Anne Marie Garti 

IND319 Loretta N. Shaw 

IND320 Deanna Urrey 

IND321 May Miller 

IND322 May Miller 

IND323 Patty Woodbury 

IND324 Steve Hopkins 

IND325 Joshua C. Sparkes 

IND326 Wyldon King Fishman 

IND327 Linda Buman 

IND328 Tom Donohue 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-15 

IND329 Susan Spieler 

IND330 Gary Donelian 

IND331 Allegra Schecter 

IND332 Troy Hill 

IND333 Susan Pixley 

IND334 Anne Kiley-Pellechia 

IND335 Jason Starr 

IND336 George Meszaros 

IND337 Fred Breglia 

IND338 Rochelle Thomas 

IND339 Sharon Harvey 

IND340 Apollo 

IND341 Diane MacInnes 

IND342 Julie Edgar 

IND343 Janet and Jennifer Windus 

IND344 Stacie Edick 

IDN345 Jeffery Pendorf 

IND346 L.E. Mills 

IND347 Jessica Farrell 

IND348 Gene Pigford 

IND349 John Alfano 

IND350 Michael Suchorsky 

IND351 Linda Bryant 

IND352 Caroline Martin 

IND353 Judith Salzman 

IND354 Rachel Polens 

IND355 Darlene Bordwell 

IND356 Susan Dey 

IND357 Walter Ditman 

IND358 Sondra Wolferman 

IND359 Heidi Rogers 

IND360 Natalie Cronin 

IND361 Marta Szwedek 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-16 

IND362 John Miglietta 

IND363 Allegra Schecter 

IND364 Brad Ross 

IND365 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND366 Jo Ann C. Hurley 

IND367 Jo Ann C. Hurley 

IND368 Jo Ann C. Hurley 

IND369 Lucy J. Richards 

IND370 Joan Roche 

IND371 Chris H. Burgher 

IND372 Patricia Whelan 

IND373 Sandra K. Shaver 

IND374 Margaret M. Feinberg 

IND375 Christopher Dapkins 

IND376 Stuart Anderson 

IND377 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND378 Michael Stolzer 

IND379 Patty Woodbury 

IND380 Michael Stolzer 

IND381 Kathy Shimberg 

IND382 Thomas C. Earle 

IND383 Claudia H. Gorman 

IND384 Claudia H. Gorman 

IND385 Bridget 

IND386 Patrick Conway 

IND387 Stacia Norman 

IND388 Michael Gorr 

IND389 Albert Crudo 

IND390 Evan Ramos 

IND391 Jeannette F. Westcott 

IND392 Jeannette F. Westcott 

IND393 Alan Gaydorus 

IND394 Jeannette F. Westcott 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-17 

IND395 Gladys Paulsen 

IND396 Helen Ehman 

IND397 Ling Tsou 

IND398 Joseph Falis 

IND399 Joel and Julie Wexler 

IND400 Vera Scroggins 

IND401 Allegra Schecter 

IND402 Dennis Gonseth 

IND403 Artineh Havan 

IND404 Miriam Solloway 

IND405 Julie Solloway 

IND406 Cathy McNulty 

IND407 Michael Barnes 

IND408 Kristina Fedorov 

IND409 Cathy McNulty 

IND410 Cathy McNulty 

IND411 Michael Fedorov 

IND412 Cathy McNulty 

IND413 Katherine O’Donnell 

IND414 Harold D. Wright 

IND415 Michael Bosetti 

IND416 Dorothy Mackie 

IND417 N 

IND418 Paul A. Thayer 

IND419 Ann Moschovakis 

IND420 Margery Schab 

IND421 Dennis Tomkins 

IND422 Jennifer Mosher 

IND423 Barbara Kerr 

IND424 Marilyn Sango-Jordan 

IND425 Jessica Farrell 

IND426 Lynn Fischer 

IND427 L. Reik 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-18 

IND428 Kenneth Jaffe 

IND429 Suzanne Winkler 

IND430 Eugene Marner 

IND431 Kenneth Jaffe 

IND432 Linda A. Jaffe 

IND433 William and Christine Roche 

IND434 Chelsea Laible 

IND435 Janet L. Marsh 

IND436 Dianne Sefcik 

IND437 Thomas M. Gorman 

IND438 Daniel J. Brignoli 

IND439 Robert Lidsky 

IND440 Barbara Pete 

IND441 Garrett Brignoli 

IND442 Michael Stolzer 

IND443 I. Funk 

IND444 Robert Stack 

IND445 Mark Pezzati 

IND446 Wayne Stinson 

IND447 Allegra Schecter 

IND448 Allegra Schecter 

IND449 Thomas Gorman 

IND450 Mary Colleen McKinney 

IND451 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND452 Reanne Stack 

IND453 Robert Stack 

IND454 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND455 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND456 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND457 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND458 George Meszaros Jr. 

IND459 George Meszaros Jr. 

IND460 George Meszaros Jr. 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-19 

IND461 Raymond Lewis 

IND462 Joyce Bitran 

IND463 Raymond Lewis 

IND464 Philip Hulbert 

IND465 Raymond Lewis 

IND466 Jennifer Stinson 

IND467 Janet Marsh 

IND468 Karen Detert 

IND469 Raymond Lewis 

IND470 Glen and Laura Bertrand 

IND471 Michael Stolzer 

IND472 Wayne A. Stinson 

IND473 Raymond Lewis 

IND474 Raymond Lewis 

IND475 Joan Tubridy 

IND476 Patricia Desnoyers 

IND477 Raymond Lewis 

IND478 Raymond Lewis 

IND479 Raymond Lewis 

IND480 Raymond Lewis 

IND481 Raymond Lewis 

IND482 Brian Crabtree 

IND483 James A. Sikora 

IND484 Maria Luisa Tasayco 

IND485 Kelli Cain 

IND486 Dianne Sefcik 

IND487 Mark VanLaeys 

IND488 Dru Dempsey 

IND489 Dianne Sefcik 

IND490 Timothy Camann 

IND491 Epifanio Bevilacqua 

IND492 Renee Nied 

IND493 Edith Kantrowitz 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-20 

IND494 Valerie Dudley 

IND495 Marie Reinertsen 

IND496 Kathleen Brown 

IND497 Peter Hudiburg 

IND498 Clark J. Rhoades 

IND499 Kerry A. Lynch 

IND500 John Hviid 

IND501 Patrick Rider 

IND502 William Huston 

IND503 Dianne Sefcik 

IND504 Anne Marie Garti 

IND505 Heidi Nakashima 

IND506 Robert Strother 

IND507 Clark J. Rhoades 

IND508 Robert Strother 

IND509 William Huston 

IND510 Jill A. Wiener 

IND511 Robert Strother 

IND512 Laura Pierson 

IND513 Teresa Winchester 

IND514 Allegra Schecter 

IND515 Dianne Sefcik 

IND516 Linda Bevilacqua 

IND517 Bob Rosen 

IND518 Anthony Baroni 

IND519 Dave Elder 

IND520 Thomas Gorman 

IND521 Andra Leimanis 

IND522 Florence Carnahan 

IND523 Epifanio Bevilacqua 

IND524 Dave Parker 

IND525 Eric V. Haight 

IND526 Linda Bevilacqua 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-21 

IND527 Meredith Dillon 

IND528 Pamela Bohsung 

IND529 Maryann E. Zeffer 

IND530 Bridget Spann 

IND531 Bruce H. Madden 

IND532 Dianne Sefcik 

IND533 Victoria Quesada 

IND534 Kim Michels 

IND535 Margery Schab 

IND536 Delores Bennett 

IND537 Joyce Bitran 

IND538 Jerry Pellegrino 

IND539 Rachel Polens 

IND540 Jack T. Tessier 

IND541 Jennifer Miller-Heath and Lois G. Miller 

IND542 Glenn and Laura Bertrand 

IND543 Rebekah Schecter 

IND544 Lisa Barr 

IND545 Kim Rasmussen 

IND546 William B. Morton 

IND547 Ruby Mitchell 

IND548 Florence Carnahan 

IND549 Catherine M. Holleran 

IND550 Tom Driscoll 

IND551 Robert Minotti 

IND552 Sara Zimmerman 

IND553 Ruth Carr 

IND554 Sue Bailey 

IND555 Vera Scroggins 

IND556 Annemarie Hosenedl 

IND557 Karen Ellis 

IND558 Wanda Crain 

IND559 Joanne Cipolla-Dennis 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-22 

IND560 Anna Janiszewski 

IND561 Timothy Englert 

IND562 Karen Butler 

IND563 Lynn Ellen Marsh and Douglas Delong 

IND564 Randall Leavitt 

IND565 Lennard J. Davis 

IND566 Mick Bello 

IND567 Lisa Lombardi-Bello 

IND568 Roger and Ellen Jones 

IND569 Kristina Fedorov 

IDN570 Adrian Kuzminski 

IND571 Murray W. Bell 

IND572 Patricia Coyle 

IND573 Ellen Cantarow 

IND574 Martha Bremer 

IND575 Peter Clark 

IND576 Richard H. Kathmann 

IND577 Leona Briggs 

IND578 Gale E. Reardon 

IND579 Shirley C. Rice 

IND580 Rebecca Roter 

IND581 Kate Sikelianos 

IND582 Maria Kaltenbach 

IND583 Mary McDowell 

IND584 Allegra Schecter 

IND585 Shirley P. Uhle 

IND586 Allison Jones 

IND587 Richard Friedberg 

IND588 Justin Texeira 

IND589 Mary Boyle 

IND590 Stuart Anderson 

IND591 Gregory Cempa 

IND592 Jessica Roff 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-23 

IND593 Bruce Rosen 

IND594 Kenneth G. Stanton III 

IND595 Michael Stolzer 

IND596 Allegra Schecter 

IND597 Joel Murray 

IND598 Alice Zinnes 

IND599 Keith W. Schue 

IND600 Rebecca Roter 

IND601 Mark Pezzati 

IND602 Peter T. Fauth 

IND603 Steven Connors 

IND604 Marilyn Sango-Jordan 

IND605 Bret A. Jennings 

IND606 Kathy Shimberg 

IND607 George Meszaros Jr. 

IND608 Mark Pezzati 

IND609 Clark J. Rhoades 

IND610 Diana Modica 

IND611 William Huston 

IND612 Joan Tubridy 

IND613 Suzanne Winkler 

IND614 Rachel Soper 

IND615 George Cempa 

IND616 Marc Wishengrad 

IND617 Rachel Polens 

IND618 Ronald Bailey 

IND619 Thomas Foster 

IND620 Thomas M. Keane 

IND621 Trevor Wilson 

IND622 Mary T. Finneran 

IND623 Lee Ziesche 

IND624 Debra A. Cubbedge 

IND625 Brian Dobbs 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-24 

IND626 Charles Nunzio 

IND627 Karl Zarling 

IND628 Melanie A. Katz 

IND629 Chris Casper 

IND630 Sarah Proechel 

IND631 Michele Abbott 

IND632 Alicia M. Pettys 

IND633 Steven Sachs 

IND634 James Moore 

IND635 Greta Schiller 

IND636 Rita Casasse 

IND637 Adam Eilenberg 

IND638 David O. Brown 

IND639 Jeanie Piecara 

IND640 Teresa Iovino 

IND641 Michael Frys 

IND642 Moira Mosley-Duffy 

IND643 Eileen McInerney 

IND644 Lisa Zaccaglini 

IND645 Maria Moscatelli 

IND646 Holly Anne McKinney 

IND647 Penelope R. King 

IND648 Edward Michael Barnes 

IND649 Alexandra Hart 

IND650 Lena Rerazzo 

IND651 Dorothy Patashnick 

IND652 Jeffrey S. Arey 

IND653 Robert Chapman 

IND654 Jennifer Classon 

IND655 Andrea Simitch 

IND656 Mercedes Verdejo 

IND657 Nancy Pfau 

IND658 Elizabeth Nields 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-25 

IND659 Kari Buchanan 

IND660 Amy Curry 

IND661 Mitro Hood 

IND662 June Edelstein 

IND663 Phil Konigsberg 

IND664 Deborah M. Wetlsch 

IND665 Melody Safken 

IND666 Colleen M. Clarke Rizzo 

IND667 H. Claire 

IND668 Allison Gentile 

IND669 Catherine Shrady 

IND670 Lawrence J. Mazza 

IND671 Robin D. Wright 

IND672 Timothy Beach 

IND673 Philip S. Gloviak 

IND674 David Luxem 

IND675 Karl Guse 

IND676 Sarah K. Meredith 

IND677 Leona I. Briggs 

IND678 Robert Bruckman 

IND679 Patricia Hughes 

IND680 C. Roth 

IND681 Barbara O’Neil 

IND682 Caroline Wilson 

IND683 Murray W. Bell 

IND684 Carol Gundlach 

IND685 Katherine C. Hawkins 

IND686 Joan McCarthy 

IND687 David Green 

IND688 Walter Wouk 

IND689 Dennis Patterson 

IND690 Sandra Haigh 

IND691 Karen Jarobe 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-26 

IND692 Angelina Martinez 

IND693 Michele Fox 

IND694 Ethel Little 

IND695 Mark J. Major 

IND696 Michael K. Carter 

IND697 Ann B. Rennacker 

IND698 Mark M. Geise 

IND699 Bruce L. MacDuffie 

IND700 David J. Davis 

IND701 Rosemary D. McCarthy 

IND702 Janet M. Windus 

IND703 Roger Gural 

IND704 Rodney Gould 

IND705 Elizabeth Van DeValk 

IND706 Christopher Eastman 

IND707 Robert Rutkowski 

IND708 Brendan Guastella 

IND709 Charlie Silberman 

IND710 Gloria Foster 

IND711 John Lawrence 

IND712 Edward A. Bordinger 

IND713 Angelo Santoro 

IND714 Robert T. Ashley 

IND715 Jean D. Bizot 

IND716 Sean Glennon 

IND717 Michelle Fiore 

IND718 Nick Albaugh 

IND719 Mary T. Townsend 

IND720 Matthew Stetter 

IND721 Luis Calleja 

IND722 Claude Holbrook 

IND723 Margaret D. Davis 

IND724 Christine Amos 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-27 

IND725 Hilda Holbrook 

IND726 Howard L. Hannum 

IND727 Glen Sanders 

IND728 Individual (No name) 

IND729 Marcus Villagran 

IND730 Mary Finneran 

IND731 Dianne Sefcik 

IND732 Devon Smida 

IND733 Don Airey 

IND734 Jennifer Colon 

IND735 Earl W. Collay 

IND736 Steven Connors 

IND737 Claude Crispell 

IND738 Bruce and Michele Stacey 

IND739 Michael Dundon 

IND740 J. Alghauskas 

IND741 Tony Baroni 

IND742 Ronald Bailey 

IND743 Lisa Barr 

IND744 Stephen E. Barton 

IND745 Walter H. Bray 

IND746 Lois Chernin 

IND747 Francis J. Coney 

IND748 Rhonda Coullet 

IND749 Matt Walker 

IND750 Blane Pixley 

IND751 Keith Schue 

IND752 Kris Stafford 

IND753 Glen Sanders 

IND754 Sharon Corey 

IND755 Chris Lange 

IND756 Christina Frye 

IND757 Hoyt Emmons 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-28 

IND758 Mike Grossman 

IND759 Kevin Heatley 

IND760 Justin Hughes 

IND761 Julie Huntsman 

IND762 Susan Jacques 

IND763 Marion J. Karl 

IND764 Jennie Kerwood 

IND765 Gabriella Leach 

IND766 Robert Grajewski 

IND767 Philip Hulbert 

IND768 Kenneth Stanton III 

IND769 Anne Marie Garti 

IND770 Richard Friedberg 

IND771 Kenneth Stanton III 

IND772 Tracy L. Briggs 

IND773 Vincent Montone 

PUBLIC MEETINGS

PM1 March 31, 2014 – Richmondville, NY 

PM2 April 1, 2014 – Oneonta, NY 

PM3 April 2, 2014 – Afton, NY 

PM4 April 3, 2014 – New Milford, PA 

APPLICANTS 

A1 Constitution Pipeline Company LLC 

 
APPENDIX S – RESPONSES TO COMMENTS

S-29 

We note that the clarity of some letter images is low due to the necessity of reducing the files 

for our responses in this appendix. Appendix Q and each of the individual comment letters 

are available for viewing in their native formats on the FERC eLibrary website 

(www.ferc.gov) to resolve any issues with the images1

. 

The draft EIS for the proposed Constitution Pipeline and Wright Interconnect Projects was 

issued in February 12, 2014. The formal public comment period extended from the date of 

issuance to April 7, 2014. We received written comments on the draft EIS from issuance 

through preparation of the final EIS. All of the written comments received between February 

12, 2014 and September 19, 2014 were included in this appendix. We received numerous 

written comments over the 5 months following the close of the official comment period. All 

written comments received on the draft EIS are part of the public record for the projects and 

are available on the project docket (CP13-499 and CP13-502). 

                                                            

1

 Individual comment letters are available for viewing on the FERC Internet website (http://www.ferc.gov). 

Using the “eLibrary” link, select “General Search” from the ELibrary menu, enter an appropriate date range and 

“Docket No.” excluding the last three digits (i.e., CP13-499 or CP13-502), and follow the instructions. For 

assistance call 1-866-208-3676, or email FERCOnlineSupport@ferc.gov.