Appendix A-1: Unit-Level Incremental Emission Reductions and Costs for the Beyond-the-Floor Option

FacilityID UnitID NAICS Unit Count

Major 

Source?

Classificati

on

Size 

Category

Design 

Capacity 

(mmBtu/h

r)

Op Hours 

Per Year

Exhaust 

Flowrate 

(ACFM)

ARAnthonyForestProducts SN-12 321 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 29.56 8592 13186.19

ARAnthonyForestProducts SN-13 321 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 29.56 8592 13186.19

ARAnthonyForestProducts SN-16 321 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 29.75 8592 13270.94

FLOsceolaFarms Boiler No. 4311 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 280 3809 124903

FLOsceolaFarms Boiler No. 5311 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 330 3772 147207.1

GAADMLocation551 630- Wellons311 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 95 6391 42377.8

IDPotlatch PB-1 CE 321 1 Major SourceBoiler >=10 27.6 8544 12311.87

MNWeyerhaeuserIronton EU 001 - 4 Cell Furnace 321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 225 8114 100368.5

MSNorbordMS Wellons No. 1321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 100 8400 44608.21

MSNorbordMS Wellons No. 2321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 100 8400 44608.21

MSNorbordMS Wellons No. 3321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 100 8400 44608.21

MTPlumCreekWellons Plywood 321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 30 8500 13382.46

NCWeyerhaeuserGrifton ES-SHE-1901321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 57.16 8400 25498.05

TXNorbordTexasNacogdoches Konus No. 1321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 16 8000 7137.314

TXNorbordTexasNacogdoches Konus No. 2321 1 Major SourceProcess Heater >=10 16 8000 7137.314
Exhaust 

Flowrate 

(DSCFM) O2%

Combustor 

Design

Low NOx 

Burners?

Fuel 

Category 

for Unit

MACT Fuel 

Category

Solid Fuel 

Category

Total 

Control H

Cl Control Group

Hg Control GroupPM

Control Group

Metals Control Group

7414.352 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Cyclone or Multiclone 5 6 5 5

7414.352 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Cyclone or Multiclone 5 6 5 5

7462.009 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Cyclone or Multiclone 5 6 5 5

70230.67 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Bagasse Biomass Solid Wet Scrubber 1 4 4 4

82771.86 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Bagasse Biomass Solid Wet Scrubber 1 4 4 4

23828.26 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Fabric Filter 5 3 1 1

6755.83 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

55074.7 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

25082.38 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

25082.38 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

25082.38 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

7524.715 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

13991.42 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrostatic Precipitator 5 6 2 2

4013.181 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrified Filter Bed (EFB) 5 6 2 2

4013.181 6.46427 Fuel Cell False Wet BiomassBiomass Solid Electrified Filter Bed (EFB) 5 6 2 2
Percent 

Moisture

Temperatu

re

Small/Limi

ted Use?

Filterable PM 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Filterable PM 

Source

Filterable PM 

FLOOR 

(lb/MMBtu)

Filterable PM 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

Filterable PM 

MACT Floor 

(tpy)

8.416233 400 No 0.129252229 ET 0.033 16.41370949 4.19066208

8.416233 400 No 0.129252229 Facility Emission Average0.033 16.41370949 4.19066208

8.416233 400 No 0.129252229 Facility Emission Average0.033 16.51921033 4.217598

8.416233 400 No 0.190138889 ET 0.033 101.3934639 17.59758

8.416233 400 No 0.163055556 ET 0.033 101.4825167 20.53854

8.416233 400 No 0.00524345 Baseline Average LOOKUP0.033 1.591767174 10.0178925

8.481977 400 No 0.004133333 ET 0.033 0.48734976 3.8909376

8.481977 400 No 0.028662301 ET 0.033 26.16366503 30.123225

8.416233 400 No 0.008943542 ET 0.033 3.756287528 13.86

8.416233 400 No 0.008943542 ET 0.033 3.756287528 13.86

8.416233 400 No 0.008943542 ET 0.033 3.756287528 13.86

8.416233 400 No 0.061687034 Baseline Average LOOKUP0.033 7.865096784 4.2075

8.481977 400 No 0.061687034 Baseline Average LOOKUP0.033 14.80932953 7.922376

8.416233 400 No 0.037333333 ET 0.033 2.389333333 2.112

8.416233 400 No 0.037333333 ET 0.033 2.389333333 2.112
TSM8 Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

TSM8 Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

TSM8 FLOOR 

(lb/MMBtu)

TSM8 MACT 

Floor (tpy)

Meets 

Filterable PM 

MACT Floor?

Meets TSM8 

MACT Floor?

Filterable PM 

Reduction 

Efficiency (%)

0.002947784 0.37433844 0.19 24.1280544 No Yes 74.46852534

0.002947784 0.37433844 0.19 24.1280544 No Yes 74.46852534

0.002947784 0.376744539 0.19 24.28314 No Yes 74.46852534

0.000273307 0.145743691 0.19 101.3194 No Yes 82.64426589

0.000273307 0.170100811 0.19 118.2522 No Yes 79.76149915

4.15589E-05 0.012616146 0.19 57.678775 Yes Yes 0

1.62583E-05 0.00191697 0.19 22.402368 Yes Yes 0

0.000200681 0.18318625 0.19 173.43675 Yes Yes 0

0.000200681 0.084285844 0.19 79.8 Yes Yes 0

0.000200681 0.084285844 0.19 79.8 Yes Yes 0

0.000200681 0.084285844 0.19 79.8 Yes Yes 0

0.000200681 0.025586774 0.19 24.225 No Yes 46.50415481

0.000200681 0.048177788 0.19 45.61368 No Yes 46.50415481

0.000200681 0.012843557 0.19 12.16 No Yes 11.60714286

0.000200681 0.012843557 0.19 12.16 No Yes 11.60714286
TSM8 

Reduction 

Efficiency (%)

Minimum 

Reduction 

Efficiency (%)

Filterable PM 

Emission 

Reductions, 

0.19 TSM8 

Limit (tpy)

TSM8 

Emission 

Reductions, 

0.19 TSM8 

Limit (tpy)

As Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Be Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Cd Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

0 0 0 0 1.23965E-06 1.26259E-07 7.53622E-06

0 0 0 0 1.23965E-06 1.26259E-07 7.53622E-06

0 0 0 0 1.23965E-06 1.26259E-07 7.53622E-06

0 0 0 0 5.05667E-06 0.000000447 1.91667E-06

0 0 0 0 5.05667E-06 0.000000447 1.91667E-06

0 0 0 0 6.19348E-06 1.06259E-07 8.14564E-07

0 0 0 0 6.98506E-07 3.01277E-08 1.39464E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07

0 0 0 0 2.07712E-06 1.33105E-07 6.97649E-07
Co Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Cr Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Ni Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Mn Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Pb Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Sb Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

Se Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

2.21126E-06 4.75937E-06 7.13095E-06 0.002570691 8.88144E-06 3.64057E-06 1.3956E-06

2.21126E-06 4.75937E-06 7.13095E-06 0.002168667 8.88144E-06 3.64057E-06 1.3956E-06

2.21126E-06 4.75937E-06 7.13095E-06 0.001809667 8.88144E-06 3.64057E-06 1.3956E-06

8.06332E-07 7.25333E-05 0.0001187 0.0000618 2.13567E-05 2.06426E-06 0.00000453

8.06332E-07 7.25333E-05 0.0001187 0.0000618 2.13567E-05 2.06426E-06 0.00000453

8.53E-08 4.51993E-06 4.77155E-06 1.69071E-05 1.38063E-05 7.94333E-08 2.57387E-07

5.24712E-08 1.2698E-06 6.54851E-07 7.95268E-06 1.05429E-06 8.63854E-08 4.45857E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 1.38047E-05 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06

1.1803E-06 4.41653E-06 4.62475E-06 0.00036247 7.60405E-06 9.43646E-07 2.71056E-06
TSM10 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(lb/MMBtu)

TSM10 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

TSM10 

Emission 

Reductions, 

0.19 TSM8 

Limit (tpy)

Beyond-theFloor TSM8 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

Beyond-theFloor TSM8 

Emission Limit 

(lb/MMBtu)

Beyond-theFloor TSM8 

Emission Limit 

(tpy)

Meets TSM8 

Beyond-theFloor Limit?

0.002607612 0.33114004 0 0.37433844 0.000049 0.006222498 No

0.002205588 0.28008709 0 0.37433844 0.000049 0.006222498 No

0.001846588 0.236005025 0 0.376744539 0.000049 0.006262494 No

0.000289211 0.154224615 0 0.145743691 0.000049 0.02612974 No

0.000289211 0.179999093 0 0.170100811 0.000049 0.03049662 No

4.75412E-05 0.014432211 0 0.012616146 0.000049 0.014875053 Yes

1.63972E-05 0.001933342 0 0.00191697 0.000049 0.005777453 Yes

3.81924E-05 0.034862998 0 0.18318625 0.000049 0.044728425 No

0.000386857 0.162480049 0 0.084285844 0.000049 0.02058 No

0.000386857 0.162480049 0 0.084285844 0.000049 0.02058 No

0.000386857 0.162480049 0 0.084285844 0.000049 0.02058 No

0.000386857 0.049324301 0 0.025586774 0.000049 0.0062475 No

0.000386857 0.092873596 0 0.048177788 0.000049 0.011763528 No

0.000386857 0.024758865 0 0.012843557 0.000049 0.003136 No

0.000386857 0.024758865 0 0.012843557 0.000049 0.003136 No
Beyond-theFloor TSM8 

Reduction 

Efficiency (%)

Minimum 

Beyond-theFloor 

Reduction 

Efficiency (%)

Beyond-theFloor TSM8 

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy)

Beyond-theFloor 

Filterable PM 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

Beyond-theFloor 

Filterable PM 

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy)

Beyond-theFloor TSM10 

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

Beyond-theFloor TSM10 

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy)

98.33773463 74.46852534 0.278764316 16.41370949 12.22304741 0.33114004 0.246595105

98.33773463 74.46852534 0.278764316 16.41370949 12.22304741 0.28008709 0.208576726

98.33773463 74.46852534 0.280556103 16.51921033 12.30161233 0.236005025 0.175749462

82.07144347 82.07144347 0.119613951 101.3934639 83.2150794 0.154224615 0.126574368

82.07144347 79.76149915 0 101.4825167 0 0.179999093 0

0 0 0 1.591767174 0 0.014432211 0

0 0 0 0.48734976 0 0.001933342 0

75.58308831 0 0 26.16366503 0 0.034862998 0

75.58308831 0 0 3.756287528 0 0.162480049 0

75.58308831 0 0 3.756287528 0 0.162480049 0

75.58308831 0 0 3.756287528 0 0.162480049 0

75.58308831 46.50415481 0.011898913 7.865096784 3.657596784 0.049324301 0.022937849

75.58308831 46.50415481 0.022404673 14.80932953 6.88695353 0.092873596 0.043190081

75.58308831 11.60714286 0 2.389333333 0 0.024758865 0

75.58308831 11.60714286 0 2.389333333 0 0.024758865 0
Is ESP 

Currently 

Installed on 

Unit?

Is Fabric Filter 

Currently 

Installed on 

Unit?

Is Unit 

Expected to 

Install Fabric 

Filter for 

Compliance 

with Hg 

Emission 

Limit?

Is Unit 

Expected to 

DIFF for 

Compliance 

with HCl 

Emission 

Limit?

Control 

Installed for 

Compliance 

with Beyondthe-Floor Limit

Incremental 

Total Capital 

Investment for 

Beyond-theFloor Option 

($)

Incremental 

Total Annual 

Cost for 

Beyond-theFloor Option 

($)

No No no no ESP $448,260 $75,061

No No no no ESP $448,260 $75,061

No No no no ESP $450,052 $75,339

No No no no ESP $4,427,501 $806,458

No No yes no N/A $0 $0

No Yes N/A N/A N/A $0 $0

Yes No N/A N/A N/A $0 $0

Yes No N/A N/A N/A $0 $0

Yes No N/A N/A N/A $0 $0

Yes No N/A N/A N/A $0 $0

Yes No N/A N/A N/A $0 $0

Yes No no no Wet Scrubber $294,066 $52,577

Yes No no no Wet Scrubber $444,920 $76,571

No No no no N/A $0 $0

No No no no N/A $0 $0
Appendix A-2: Summary of Beyond-the-Floor Cost Effectiveness

Incremental Unit-Level Annual Costs ($/yr) $1,161,066

Incremental Emissions of TSM10 Reduced (tons/yr) 0.82

Cost Effectiveness for TSM10 ($/ton) $1,409,705

Incremental Unit-Level Annual Costs ($/yr) $1,161,066

Incremental Emissions of TSM10 Reduced (tons/yr) 130.51

Cost Effectiveness for PM ($/ton) $8,897

Metallic HAP (TSM10)

Filterable Particulate Matter (PM)