APPENDIX 10B. DETAILED NET PRESENT VALUE RESULTS
 

TABLE OF CONTENTS
 

10B.1 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 1
 

10B.2 DETAILED NET PRESENT VALUE RESULTS............................................................. 1
 

LIST OF TABLES 

Table 10B.2.1 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex 

System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ......................2
 

Table 10B.2.2 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ......................3
 

Table 10B.2.3 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...................4
 

Table 10B.2.4 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...................5
 

Table 10B.2.5 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large 

Multiplex System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount 

Rate .......................................................................................................................6
 

Table 10B.2.6 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...................7
 

Table 10B.2.7 Net Present Value for Small Display Cooler with Large Dedicated, 

Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ................................8
 

Table 10B.2.8 Net Present Value for Large Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...................9
 

Table 10B.2.9 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...............................10
 

Table 10B.2.10 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large 

Multiplex System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ..............11
 

Table 10B.2.11 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...............................12
 

Table 10B.2.12 Net Present Value for Medium Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...............................13
 

Table 10B.2.13 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ....................14
 

Table 10B.2.14 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large 

Multiplex System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount 

Rate .....................................................................................................................15
 

Table 10B.2.15 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate .................16
 

Table 10B.2.16 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large 

Multiplex System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount 

Rate .....................................................................................................................17
 

Table 10B.2.17 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate .................18
 

10B-i 
Table 10B.2.18 Net Present Value for Small Display Freezer with Large Multiplex 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate .................19
 

Table 10B.2.19 Net Present Value for Large Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate .................20
 

Table 10B.2.20 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...............................21
 

Table 10B.2.21 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large 

Multiplex System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ..............22
 

Table 10B.2.22 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...............................23
 

Table 10B.2.23 Net Present Value for Medium Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate ...............................24
 

Table 10B.2.24 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ....................25
 

Table 10B.2.25 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large 

Multiplex System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount 

Rate .....................................................................................................................26
 

Table 10B.2.26 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................27
 

Table 10B.2.27 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................28
 

Table 10B.2.28 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large 

Multiplex System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount 

Rate .....................................................................................................................29
 

Table 10B.2.29 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................30
 

Table 10B.2.30 Net Present Value for Large Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................31
 

Table 10B.2.31 Net Present Value for Large Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................32
 

Table 10B.2.32 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ...............................33
 

Table 10B.2.33 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large 

Multiplex System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ..............34
 

Table 10B.2.34 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ...............................35
 

Table 10B.2.35 Net Present Value for Medium Display Cooler with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ...............................36
 

Table 10B.2.36 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ....................37
 

Table 10B.2.37 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large 

Multiplex System Indoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount 

Rate .....................................................................................................................38
 

Table 10B.2.38 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................39
 

10B-ii 
Table 10B.2.39 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large 

Multiplex System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount 

Rate .....................................................................................................................40
 

Table 10B.2.40 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................41
 

Table 10B.2.41 Net Present Value for Small Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................42
 

Table 10B.2.42 Net Present Value for Large Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Outdoor Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate .................43
 

Table 10B.2.43 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ...............................44
 

Table 10B.2.44 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large 

Multiplex System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ..............45
 

Table 10B.2.45 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ...............................46
 

Table 10B.2.46 Net Present Value for Medium Display Freezer with Large Multiplex
 

System Refrigeration System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate ...............................47
 

10B-iii 
APPENDIX 10B. DETAILED NET PRESENT VALUE RESULTS 

10B.1 INTRODUCTION 

This appendix provides a more detailed version of the summary NPV results 

presented in the NIA analysis (preliminary TSD chapter 10). 

10B.2 DETAILED NET PRESENT VALUE RESULTS 

This section presents NPV results for each combination of envelope and 

refrigeration system product classes that DOE analyzed, arranged by envelope and 

refrigeration system CSL combination. Note that in this context, CSL refers to a standard 

that DOE could set, rather than the efficiency of the equipment. So, for example, a cell 

representing envelope CSL 5 and refrigeration system CSL 6 presents the NPV results 

that DOE expects to see from setting the WICF envelope standard at CSL 5 and the 

WICF refrigeration system standard at CSL 6. 

As noted in the NIA analysis (preliminary TSD chapter 10), NPV represents the 

total (discounted) reduction in consumer costs for WICF that DOE forecasts would result 

from energy conservation standards for WICF equipment. Note that this is not the same 

as the sum of all costs and benefits from such standards, e.g. environment benefits or 

costs of this rule are not included in the NPV calculation. 

All results are presented in 2009 dollars. NPV results are not provided for the 

combination of CSL 0 envelope and a CSL 0 refrigeration system, because this represents 

the baseline. Results are presented at both 7 percent and 3 percent discount rates. The 

greater the discount rate, the less weight is placed on events that occur in the future. This 

tends to place greater emphasis on the increased first cost of more efficient units and less 

emphasis on the decreased operating cost of more efficient units. 

10B-1 
Table 10B.2.1 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Indoor Refr

a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 1

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(0.06) 

0.07 

0.12 

(0.06) 

0.07 

0.12 

(0.07) 

0.09 

0.16 

(0.07) 

0.10 

0.16 

(0.07) 

0.10 

0.16 

(0.07) 

0.10 

0.17 

(0.07)

0.10 

0.17 

 (0.06) 

0.110.17

(0.06)

 0.11 0.17 

 (0.03) 

0.12 0.14 

0.04 0.12 0.08 

0.0.0.

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.06

0.09

 (0.08) 

0.11 

0.19 

(0.08)

0.11

0.19

 (0.09) 

0.13 

0.21 

(0.08) 

0.13 

0.22 

(0.08) 

0.13 

0.22 

(0.08) 

0.13 

0.22 

(0.08)

0.140.22

 (0.08) 

0.14 0.22 

(0.07)

0.140.21

 (0.04) 

0.15 0.19 

0.03 

0.15 0.13 

0.

0.0.

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.07

0.10

 (0.08) 

0.12 

0.20 

(0.08)

0.12

0.20

 (0.09) 

0.13 

0.22 

(0.09) 

0.14 

0.22 

(0.09) 

0.14 

0.22 

(0.08) 

0.14 

0.23 

(0.08)

0.140.23

 (0.08) 

0.14 0.22 

(0.07)

0.150.22

 (0.04) 

0.15 0.19 

0.02 

0.16 0.13 

0.

0.0.

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.08

0.11

 (0.08) 

0.13 

0.20 

(0.08)

0.13

0.20

 (0.08) 

0.15 

0.23 

(0.08) 

0.15 

0.23 

(0.08) 

0.15 

0.23 

(0.08) 

0.15 

0.23 

(0.08)

0.150.23

 (0.08) 

0.15 0.23 

(0.07)

0.160.23

 (0.04) 

0.16 0.20 

0.03 

0.17 0.14 

0.

0.0.

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.12

0.12

 (0.06) 

0.15 

0.21 

(0.06)

0.15

0.21

 (0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07)

0.170.24

 (0.07) 

0.17 0.24 

(0.06)

0.180.24

 (0.03) 

0.18 0.21 

0.04 

0.18 0.15 

0.

0.0.

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.12

0.12

 (0.06) 

0.16 

0.21 

(0.06)

0.15

0.21

 (0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07)

0.170.24

 (0.06) 

0.18 0.24 

(0.06)

0.180.24

 (0.03) 

0.18 0.21 

0.04 

0.18 0.15 

0.

0.0.

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.00 

0.12

0.12

(0.06) 

0.16 

0.21 

(0.06) 

0.16

0.21

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07) 

0.17 

0.24 

(0.07)

0.18 

0.24 

 (0.07) 

0.180.24

(0.06)

 0.18 0.24 

 (0.06) 

0.180.24

(0.03) 

0.18 0.21 

0.04 

0.19 0.15 

0.

0.0.

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.04 

0.13

0.09

(0.03) 

0.16 

0.19 

(0.03) 

0.16

0.19

(0.05) 

0.18 

0.22 

(0.05) 

0.18 

0.23 

(0.05) 

0.18 

0.23 

(0.05)

0.18 

0.23 

 (0.05) 

0.180.23

(0.04)

 0.18 0.23 

 (0.04) 

0.180.22

(0.01) 

0.19 0.20 

0.05 

0.19 0.14 

0.

0.0.

10B-2 
Table 10B.2.2 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Indoor R

at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.16)

0.28

0.44

 (0.16)

 0.28

 0.44

 (0.16)

 0.28

 0.44

 (0.16)

 0.36

 0.51

 (0.15)

 0.37

 0.52

 (0.14)

 0.38

 0.53

 (0.14)

 0.39 

0.53

 (0.12)

0.41

 0.53

 (0.09) 

0.42 0.52

0.02 

0.45 

0.44 

0.29 

0.47 

0.19 

0.45 

0.49 

0.04 

0

0

(0

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.04

0.05

 (0.17)

 0.31

 0.48

 (0.17)

 0.31

 0.48

 (0.17)

 0.31

 0.48

 (0.16)

 0.38

 0.55

 (0.16)

 0.39

 0.55

 (0.15)

 0.41

 0.56

 (0.14)

 0.41 0.56

 (0.12)

 0.43

 0.56

 (0.10) 

0.44 0.55

0.01 

0.47 

0.46 

0.28 

0.50 

0.21 

0.44 

0.51 

0.06 

0

0

(0

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08)

0.24

0.32

 (0.21)

 0.45

 0.66

 (0.21)

 0.45

 0.66

 (0.21)

 0.45

 0.66

 (0.20)

 0.51

 0.71

 (0.19)

 0.52

 0.71

 (0.18)

 0.53

 0.71

 (0.18)

 0.53 0.71

 (0.16)

 0.54 0.70

 (0.13)

 0.55 0.69

 (0.02) 

0.58 0.60 

0.26 

0.60 0.34 

0.42 

0.60 0.19 

000

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.06)

0.31

0.37

 (0.20)

 0.50

 0.70

 (0.20)

 0.50

 0.70

 (0.20)

 0.50

 0.70

 (0.19)

 0.55

 0.74

 (0.18)

 0.56

 0.74

 (0.17)

 0.57

 0.74

 (0.17)

 0.57 0.74

 (0.15)

 0.59 0.73

 (0.12)

 0.60 0.72

 (0.01) 

0.62 0.62 

0.26 

0.63 0.37 

0.43 

0.64 0.21 

000

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.44

0.45

 (0.17)

 0.59

 0.76

 (0.17)

 0.59

 0.76

 (0.17)

 0.59

 0.76

 (0.16)

 0.63

 0.79

 (0.16)

 0.64

 0.79

 (0.15)

 0.64

 0.79

 (0.14)

 0.65 0.79

 (0.12)

 0.66 0.78

 (0.10) 

0.66 0.76

0.01 

0.68 0.67 

0.28 

0.69 0.41 

0.44 

0.70 0.26 

0

00

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.44

0.45

 (0.17)

 0.59

 0.76

 (0.17)

 0.59

 0.76

 (0.17)

 0.59

 0.76

 (0.16)

 0.63

 0.79

 (0.15)

 0.64

 0.80

 (0.15)

 0.65

 0.80

 (0.14)

 0.65 0.79

 (0.12)

 0.66 0.78

 (0.10) 

0.67 0.77

0.01 

0.69 0.67 

0.28 

0.70 0.41 

0.45 

0.70 0.26 

0

00

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.46

0.45

(0.15)

 0.61

 0.76

 (0.15)

 0.61

 0.76

 (0.15)

 0.61

 0.76

 (0.15)

 0.65

 0.79

 (0.14)

 0.65

 0.80

 (0.14)

 0.66

 0.80

 (0.13)

 0.66 0.79

 (0.11)

 0.67 0.78

 (0.09) 

0.68 0.77

0.02 

0.70 0.67 

0.29 

0.71 0.42 

0.45 

0.71 0.26 

0

00

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.13 

0.48

0.35

(0.08)

 0.62

 0.70

 (0.08)

 0.62

 0.70

 (0.08)

 0.62

 0.70

 (0.09)

 0.66

 0.74

 (0.09)

 0.66

 0.75

 (0.08)

 0.67

 0.75

 (0.07)

 0.67 0.75

 (0.06)

 0.68 0.74

 (0.04) 

0.69 0.72

0.07 

0.70 0.63 

0.34 

0.71 0.38 

0.50 

0.72 0.23 

0

00

10B-3 
Table 10B.2.3 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Outdoor Re

at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.00) 

0.01 

0.01 

(0.00)

0.01

0.01

 (0.01)

 0.02

 0.02

 (0.01) 

0.03 

0.04 

(0.01)

0.03

0.05

 (0.01)

 0.03

 0.05

 (0.01) 

0.03 

0.05 

(0.01)

0.030.05

 (0.01)

 0.03 0.05

 (0.01) 

0.03 0.04 

(0.01)

0.030.04

 (0.01)

 0.03 0.04

 (

0.03 0.04 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.00

0.00

 (0.00) 

0.01 

0.01 

(0.00)

0.01

0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 0.03

 (0.01) 

0.03 

0.04 

(0.01)

0.04

0.05

 (0.02)

 0.03

 0.05

 (0.01) 

0.03 0.05 

(0.01) 

0.030.05

(0.01) 

0.03 0.05

(0.01) 

0.03 0.04 

(0.01) 

0.030.04

(0.01) 

0.03 0.04

(

0.03 0.04 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.01

0.02

 (0.01) 

0.02 

0.03 

(0.01)

0.02

0.03

 (0.01)

 0.03

 0.04

 (0.01) 

0.04 

0.05 

(0.02)

0.04

0.06

 (0.02)

 0.04

 0.05

 (0.02) 

0.04 0.06 

(0.02) 

0.040.06

(0.02) 

0.04 0.06

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05 

(0.01) 

0.040.05

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05

(

0.04 0.05 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.02

0.02

 (0.01) 

0.02 

0.03 

(0.01)

0.03

0.03

 (0.01)

 0.03

 0.04

 (0.01) 

0.04 

0.05 

(0.02)

0.04

0.06

 (0.02)

 0.04

 0.06

 (0.02) 

0.04 0.06 

(0.02) 

0.040.06

(0.02) 

0.04 0.06

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05 

(0.01) 

0.040.05

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05

(

0.04 0.05 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.03

0.03

 (0.00) 

0.03 

0.03 

(0.00)

0.03

0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.05

 (0.01) 

0.04 

0.06 

(0.01)

0.05

0.06

 (0.02)

 0.04

 0.06

 (0.01) 

0.04 0.06 

(0.01) 

0.040.06

(0.01) 

0.04 0.06

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05 

(0.01) 

0.040.05

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05

(

0.04 0.05 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.03

0.03

 (0.00) 

0.03 

0.03 

(0.00)

0.04

0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.05

 (0.01) 

0.05 

0.06 

(0.01)

0.05

0.06

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.06

 (0.01) 

0.04 0.06 

(0.01) 

0.040.06

(0.01) 

0.04 0.06

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05 

(0.01) 

0.040.05

(0.01) 

0.04 0.05

(

0.04 0.05 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.00 

0.03

0.03

(0.00) 

0.03 

0.03 

(0.00)

0.04

0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.05

 (0.01) 

0.05 

0.06 

(0.01)

0.05

0.06

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.06

 (0.01) 

0.05 0.06 

(0.01)

0.050.06

 (0.01)

 0.05 0.06

 (0.01) 

0.04 0.05 

(0.01)

0.040.05

 (0.01)

 0.04 0.05

 (

0.04 0.05 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.03

0.02

0.01 

0.03 

0.03 

0.01 

0.04

0.03

(0.00)

 0.04

 0.04

 (0.01) 

0.05 

0.05 

(0.01)

0.05

0.06

 (0.01)

 0.05

 0.06

 (0.01) 

0.05 0.06 

(0.01)

0.050.06

 (0.01)

 0.05 0.06

 (0.01) 

0.04 0.05 

(0.01)

0.040.05

 (0.01)

 0.04 0.05

 (

0.04 0.05 

10B-4 
Table 10B.2.4 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Outdoor Re

at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(0.24) 

0.25 0.49 

(0.24) 

0.25 0.49 

(0.29) 

0.34 0.63 

(0.29) 

0.35 0.64 

(0.29) 

0.35 0.65 

(0.28) 

0.37 0.65 

(0.28) 

0.37 0.65 

(0.26) 

0.39 0.65 

(0.24) 

0.400.64

(0.10) 

0.43 0.53 

0.20 

0.45 0.25 

0.38 

0.46 0.08 

0.46 

0.46 0.00 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.04) 

0.04 

0.08 

(0.27) 

0.28 0.55 

(0.27) 

0.28 0.55 

(0.31) 

0.37 0.68 

(0.31) 

0.38 0.69 

(0.31) 

0.38 0.69 

(0.30) 

0.39 0.70 

(0.30) 

0.40 0.70 

(0.28) 

0.42 0.69 

(0.26) 

0.430.68

(0.11) 

0.45 0.57 

0.19 

0.47 0.29 

0.36 

0.48 0.12 

0.45 

0.49 0.04 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.08) 

0.20 

0.29 

(0.30) 

0.40 0.70 

(0.30) 

0.40 0.70 

(0.34) 

0.47 0.81 

(0.34) 

0.48 0.82 

(0.34) 

0.48 0.82 

(0.33) 

0.49 0.82 

(0.32) 

0.50 0.82 

(0.30) 

0.51 0.81 

(0.28) 

0.520.80

(0.14) 

0.54 0.67 

0.17 

0.56 0.39 

0.35 

0.56 0.22 

0.43 

0.57 0.14 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.02) 

0.43 

0.45 

(0.26) 

0.57 0.83 

(0.26) 

0.56 0.82 

(0.31) 

0.62 0.92 

(0.30) 

0.62 0.93 

(0.30) 

0.62 0.93 

(0.30) 

0.63 0.93 

(0.29) 

0.63 0.93 

(0.27) 

0.64 0.92 

(0.25) 

0.650.90

(0.11) 

0.66 0.77 

0.19 

0.67 0.48 

0.37 

0.68 0.31 

0.45 

0.68 0.23 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.00) 

0.47 

0.47 

(0.24) 

0.60 0.84 

(0.24) 

0.59 0.84 

(0.29) 

0.64 0.94 

(0.29) 

0.65 0.94 

(0.29) 

0.65 0.94 

(0.29) 

0.65 0.94 

(0.28) 

0.66 0.94 

(0.26) 

0.67 0.93 

(0.24) 

0.670.91

(0.10) 

0.68 0.78 

0.20 

0.70 0.50 

0.38 

0.70 0.32 

0.46 

0.70 0.24 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.02 

0.52 

0.50 

(0.23) 

0.63 0.86 

(0.23) 

0.63 0.86 

(0.28) 

0.67 0.95 

(0.28) 

0.68 0.96 

(0.28) 

0.68 0.96 

(0.27) 

0.68 0.96 

(0.27) 

0.69 0.96 

(0.25) 

0.69 0.95 

(0.23) 

0.700.93

(0.09) 

0.71 0.80 

0.21 

0.72 0.51 

0.39 

0.73 0.34 

0.47 

0.73 0.26 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.04 

0.55 

0.51 

(0.22) 

0.66 0.87 

(0.22) 

0.65 0.87 

(0.27) 

0.69 0.96 

(0.27) 

0.70 0.97 

(0.27) 

0.70 0.97 

(0.26) 

0.70 0.97 

(0.26) 

0.71 0.97 

(0.24) 

0.71 0.96 

(0.22) 

0.720.94

(0.08) 

0.73 0.81 

0.22 

0.74 0.52 

0.39 

0.74 0.35 

0.48 

0.74 0.27 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.12 

0.66 

0.53 

(0.16) 

0.73 0.89 

(0.16) 

0.73 0.89 

(0.23) 

0.76 0.98 

(0.23) 

0.76 0.99 

(0.23) 

0.76 0.99 

(0.22) 

0.77 0.99 

(0.22) 

0.77 0.99 

(0.20) 

0.77 0.98 

(0.18) 

0.780.96

(0.04) 

0.79 0.83 

0.25 

0.79 0.54 

0.43 

0.80 0.37 

0.51 

0.80 0.29 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.13 

0.66 

0.53 

(0.15) 

0.74 0.89 

(0.16) 

0.73 0.89 

(0.22) 

0.76 0.98 

(0.22) 

0.76 0.99 

(0.22) 

0.76 0.99 

(0.22) 

0.77 0.99 

(0.22) 

0.77 0.99 

(0.20) 

0.78 0.98 

(0.18) 

0.780.96

(0.04) 

0.79 0.83 

0.25 

0.79 0.54 

0.43 

0.80 0.37 

0.51 

0.80 0.29 

10B-5 
Table 10B.2.5 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoor 

System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.76)

1.15

1.92

 (0.76) 

1.15 

1.91 

(0.76)

1.16

1.92

 (0.74)

 1.47

 2.21

 (0.72)

 1.52

 2.25

 (0.69)

 1.59

 2.27

 (0.66) 

1.61 

2.27 

(0.57)

1.69

2.26

 (0.47) 

1.74 

2.21 

0.03 

1.87 

1.83 

1.26 

1.96 

0.70 

2.00 

2.01 

0.01 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08) 

0.17 

0.25 

(0.82)

1.27

2.09

 (0.81) 

1.27 

2.09 

(0.81)

1.28

2.09

 (0.78)

 1.58

 2.36

 (0.77)

 1.63

 2.39

 (0.73)

 1.69

 2.42

 (0.70)

 1.71 2.41 

 (0.61) 

1.78 2.40

(0.51)

1.84

 2.34 

 (0.00) 

1.96 1.96 

1.23 

2.05 

0.82 

1.97 

2.10 

0.13 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.21) 

0.57 

0.78 

(0.90)

1.56

2.46

 (0.90) 

1.55 

2.45 

(0.90)

1.56

2.46

 (0.86)

 1.83

 2.69

 (0.84)

 1.87

 2.71

 (0.80)

 1.93

 2.72

 (0.77)

 1.95 2.72

 (0.67) 

2.01 2.69 

(0.57)

2.062.63

 (0.06) 

2.17 2.22 

1.18 

2.25 1.07 

1.92 

2.29 0.37 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.29) 

1.13 

1.41 

(0.95)

1.95

2.90

 (0.95) 

1.95 

2.89 

(0.95)

1.95

2.90

 (0.90)

 2.18

 3.08

 (0.87)

 2.22

 3.09

 (0.83)

 2.26

 3.09

 (0.80)

 2.28 3.08

 (0.71) 

2.33 3.04 

(0.60)

2.372.97

 (0.09) 

2.46 2.55 

1.15 

2.53 1.38 

1.89 

2.57 0.67 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.15) 

1.91 

2.06 

(0.86)

2.51

3.37

 (0.86) 

2.50 

3.36 

(0.86)

2.50

3.36

 (0.82)

 2.67

 3.49

 (0.80)

 2.69

 3.50

 (0.76)

 2.73

 3.49

 (0.74)

 2.74 3.48

 (0.64) 

2.78 3.42 

(0.54)

2.813.34

 (0.03) 

2.87 2.90 

1.21 

2.92 1.72 

1.94 

2.95 1.01 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.05 

2.47 

2.41 

(0.73)

2.90

3.63

 (0.73) 

2.90 

3.62 

(0.73)

2.90

3.63

 (0.71)

 3.02

 3.73

 (0.69)

 3.04

 3.73

 (0.66)

 3.06

 3.72

 (0.63) 

3.07 3.70

(0.55)

 3.10 3.65 

 (0.44) 

3.123.56

0.06 

3.17 3.11 

1.29 

3.20 1.92 

2.02 

3.22 1.20 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.15 

2.67 

2.52 

(0.66)

3.05

3.71

 (0.66) 

3.04 

3.70 

(0.66)

3.04

3.70

 (0.66)

 3.14

 3.80

 (0.64)

 3.16

 3.80

 (0.61)

 3.18

 3.79

 (0.58) 

3.19 3.77

(0.50)

 3.21 3.71 

 (0.40) 

3.233.63

0.10 

3.27 3.18 

1.32 

3.30 1.98 

2.06 

3.32 1.26 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.18 

2.69 

2.52 

(0.65)

3.06

3.71

 (0.65) 

3.05 

3.70 

(0.65)

3.06

3.70

 (0.64)

 3.16

 3.80

 (0.63)

 3.17

 3.80

 (0.60)

 3.19

 3.79

 (0.57) 

3.20 3.77

(0.49)

 3.23 3.72 

 (0.39) 

3.243.63

0.11 

3.29 3.18 

1.33 

3.32 1.98 

2.07 

3.33 1.27 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.25 

2.75 

2.50 

(0.60)

3.11

3.70

 (0.60) 

3.10 

3.69 

(0.60)

3.10

3.70

 (0.60)

 3.20

 3.80

 (0.59)

 3.21

 3.80

 (0.56)

 3.23

 3.79

 (0.53) 

3.24 3.77

(0.45)

 3.26 3.71 

 (0.35) 

3.283.63

0.14 

3.32 3.18 

1.36 

3.35 1.98 

2.09 

3.36 1.27 

10B-6 
Table 10B.2.6 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoor R

at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.89)

1.45

2.34

 (0.88)

 1.45

 2.33

 (0.89)

 1.46

 2.35

 (0.85)

 1.55

 2.40

 (0.77)

 1.66

 2.43

 (0.42)

 2.03

 2.45

 (0.35)

 2.09 

2.45

 (0.31)

2.11

 2.42

 (0.13) 

2.24 2.38

0.07 

2.34 2.27

0.11 

2.35 

2.25 

0.66 

2.50 

1.84 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.14)

0.31

0.44

 (0.99)

 1.69

 2.69

 (0.99)

 1.69

 2.68

 (0.99)

 1.70

 2.69

 (0.95)

 1.79

 2.74

 (0.87)

 1.89

 2.76

 (0.51)

 2.25

 2.76

 (0.44)

 2.31 2.75 

 (0.39)

 2.32

2.72

 (0.22)

 2.45

 2.67

 (0.01) 

2.54 2.56

0.02 

2.56 

2.53 

0.58 

2.70 

2.12 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.35)

1.02

1.37

 (1.16)

 2.26

 3.42

 (1.15)

 2.26

 3.41

 (1.15)

 2.27

 3.42

 (1.11)

 2.34

 3.45

 (1.02)

 2.44

 3.46

 (0.65)

 2.76

 3.41

 (0.58)

 2.81 3.39 

 (0.53)

 2.82

3.36

 (0.35)

 2.94

 3.29

 (0.14)

 3.02

 3.17

 (0.11) 

3.03 

3.14 

0.45 3.16 

2.70 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.48)

2.02

2.50

 (1.25)

 3.06

 4.31

 (1.24)

 3.05

 4.29

 (1.24)

 3.06

 4.30

 (1.20)

 3.12

 4.32

 (1.11)

 3.20

 4.31

 (0.73)

 3.47

 4.20

 (0.66)

 3.51 4.17 

 (0.61)

 3.53

4.14

 (0.43)

 3.62 4.05

 (0.22)

 3.69 3.91

 (0.18) 

3.70 3.88 

0.38 3.81 

3.42 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.25)

3.42

3.67

 (1.08)

 4.18

 5.25

 (1.07)

 4.16

 5.23

 (1.07)

 4.17

 5.24

 (1.03)

 4.21

 5.24

 (0.95)

 4.27

 5.22

 (0.58)

 4.46

 5.05

 (0.51)

 4.50 5.01 

 (0.47)

 4.51

4.98

 (0.29)

 4.58 4.86

 (0.08)

 4.63 4.71

 (0.04) 

4.63 4.68 

0.51 4.71 

4.20 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.09 

4.42

4.33

(0.82)

 4.97

 5.79

 (0.82)

 4.95

 5.77

 (0.82)

 4.96

 5.78

 (0.78)

 4.99

 5.77

 (0.70)

 5.03

 5.74

 (0.36)

 5.18

 5.54

 (0.30)

 5.20 5.50

 (0.25)

 5.21 5.46

 (0.08) 

5.26 5.34

0.12 

5.30 5.17

0.16 

5.30 5.14 

0.71 

5.36 4.65 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.25 

4.78

4.53

(0.70)

 5.26

 5.96

 (0.69)

 5.24

 5.93

 (0.70)

 5.24

 5.94

 (0.66)

 5.27

 5.94

 (0.59)

 5.31

 5.90

 (0.25)

 5.43

 5.69

 (0.19)

 5.45 5.64

 (0.15) 

5.46 5.61

0.02 

5.51 5.48

0.22 

5.54 5.32

0.26 

5.54 5.29 

0.80 

5.59 4.79 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.29 

4.83

4.53

(0.67)

 5.29

 5.96

 (0.66)

 5.27

 5.94

 (0.67)

 5.28

 5.95

 (0.63)

 5.31

 5.94

 (0.56)

 5.34

 5.90

 (0.23)

 5.46

 5.69

 (0.17)

 5.48 5.65

 (0.12) 

5.49 5.61

0.05 

5.54 5.49

0.25 

5.57 5.32

0.28 

5.57 5.29 

0.82 

5.62 4.79 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.42 

4.93

4.51

(0.57)

 5.38

 5.95

 (0.57)

 5.36

 5.92

 (0.57)

 5.36

 5.93

 (0.54)

 5.39

 5.93

 (0.47)

 5.42

 5.89

 (0.14)

 5.54

 5.68

 (0.08)

 5.56 5.64

 (0.04) 

5.57 5.60

0.13 

5.61 5.48

0.32 

5.64 5.31

0.36 

5.64 5.28 

0.90 

5.69 4.79 

10B-7 
Table 10B.2.7 Net Present Value for Small Display Cooler with Large Dedicated, Outdoor Refrigeration 

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.01)

0.03

0.03

 (0.01)

 0.05

 0.06

 (0.03) 

0.08 

0.11 

(0.05)

0.12

0.17

 (0.07) 

0.14 

0.21 

(0.07)

0.13

0.20

 (0.07) 

0.13 

0.20 

(0.07)

0.130.20

 (0.07)

 0.14 0.20

 (0.06) 

0.12 0.18 

(0.06)

0.120.18

 (0.06) 

0.12 0.18 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01) 

0.01 

0.02 

(0.01)

0.04

0.05

 (0.02)

 0.06

 0.07

 (0.04) 

0.09 

0.12 

(0.05)

0.12

0.18

 (0.07) 

0.15 

0.22 

(0.07)

0.14

0.21

 (0.07) 

0.14 0.21 

(0.07)

0.140.21

 (0.07)

 0.14 0.21

 (0.06) 

0.13 0.19 

(0.06)

0.130.19

 (0.06) 

0.13 0.19 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01) 

0.03 

0.05 

(0.02)

0.06

0.08

 (0.02)

 0.08

 0.10

 (0.04) 

0.10 

0.15 

(0.06)

0.14

0.20

 (0.07) 

0.16 

0.23 

(0.07)

0.15

0.22

 (0.07) 

0.15 0.22 

(0.07)

0.150.22

 (0.07)

 0.15 0.22

 (0.06) 

0.14 0.20 

(0.06)

0.140.20

 (0.06) 

0.14 0.20 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02) 

0.07 

0.09 

(0.03)

0.09

0.12

 (0.03)

 0.11

 0.14

 (0.05) 

0.13 

0.18 

(0.06)

0.16

0.22

 (0.07) 

0.17 

0.25 

(0.08)

0.16

0.24

 (0.07) 

0.17 0.24 

(0.07)

0.170.24

 (0.07)

 0.17 0.24

 (0.06) 

0.15 0.22 

(0.06)

0.150.22

 (0.06) 

0.15 0.22 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01) 

0.12 

0.13 

(0.02)

0.14

0.15

 (0.02)

 0.15

 0.17

 (0.04) 

0.17 

0.21 

(0.05)

0.19

0.25

 (0.07) 

0.20 

0.27 

(0.07)

0.18

0.26

 (0.07) 

0.19 0.26 

(0.07)

0.190.26

 (0.07)

 0.19 0.26

 (0.06) 

0.17 0.23 

(0.06)

0.170.23

 (0.06) 

0.17 0.23 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.00 

0.15 

0.15 

(0.00)

0.17

0.17

 (0.01)

 0.18

 0.19

 (0.03) 

0.20 

0.23 

(0.05)

0.21

0.26

 (0.07) 

0.21 

0.28 

(0.07)

0.20

0.27

 (0.07) 

0.20 0.27 

(0.07)

0.200.27

 (0.07)

 0.20 0.27

 (0.06) 

0.18 0.24 

(0.06)

0.180.24

 (0.06) 

0.18 0.24 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.16 

0.15 

0.00 

0.18

0.18

(0.00)

 0.20

 0.20

 (0.02) 

0.21 

0.23 

(0.04)

0.22

0.26

 (0.06) 

0.22 

0.28 

(0.07)

0.21

0.27

 (0.07) 

0.21 0.27 

(0.07)

0.210.27

 (0.06)

 0.21 0.27

 (0.06) 

0.19 0.25 

(0.06)

0.190.25

 (0.06) 

0.19 0.25 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.17 

0.15 

0.00 

0.18

0.18

0.00 

0.20 0.20

(0.02)

 0.21 

0.23 

 (0.04) 

0.22

0.26

(0.06)

 0.22 

0.28 

 (0.07) 

0.21

0.27

(0.06)

 0.21 0.27 

 (0.06)

0.210.27

 (0.06)

 0.21 0.27

 (0.06) 

0.19 0.25 

(0.06)

0.190.25

 (0.06) 

0.19 0.25 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

0.17 

0.15 

0.01 

0.19

0.18

0.00 

0.20 0.20

(0.02)

 0.21 

0.23 

 (0.04) 

0.23

0.26

(0.06)

 0.22 

0.28 

 (0.06) 

0.21

0.27

(0.06)

 0.21 0.27 

 (0.06)

0.210.27

 (0.06)

 0.21 0.27

 (0.06) 

0.19 0.25 

(0.06)

0.190.25

 (0.06) 

0.19 0.25 

10B-8 
Table 10B.2.8 Net Present Value for Large Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refrig

7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.09) 

0.33 

0.42 

(0.38)

0.81

1.19

 (0.36) 

1.05 1.41

(0.81)

 2.31 

3.12 

 (1.33)

3.54

4.88

 (1.33) 

3.54 

4.88 

(1.33)

3.55 

4.88 

 (1.27)

3.614.88

 (0.99)

 4.02 5.01

 (0.98) 

4.03 5.01 

(0.97)

4.045.01

 (0.95)

 4.05 5.00

 

  

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.12)

0.26

0.39

 (0.21) 

0.59 

0.80 

(0.49)

1.05

1.54

 (0.46) 

1.28 1.74

(0.88)

 2.49 

3.38 

 (1.38)

3.67

5.05

 (1.38) 

3.68 

5.05 

(1.38)

3.685.06

 (1.32)

 3.74 5.06

 (1.02)

 4.13 5.15

 (1.01) 

4.14 5.15 

(1.00)

4.155.15

 (0.98)

 4.16 5.14

 

  

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.32)

0.88

1.20

 (0.40) 

1.19 

1.60 

(0.66)

1.60

2.27

 (0.63) 

1.83 2.46

(1.00)

 2.92 

3.93 

 (1.45)

3.98

5.43

 (1.45) 

3.98 

5.44 

(1.45)

3.995.44

 (1.39)

 4.04 5.43

 (1.07)

 4.39 5.46

 (1.06) 

4.40 5.46 

(1.05)

4.415.46

 (1.03)

 4.42 5.45

 

  

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.43)

1.75

2.18

 (0.51) 

2.04 

2.55 

(0.76)

2.38

3.14

 (0.73) 

2.59 3.31

(1.07)

 3.53 

4.60 

 (1.49)

4.41

5.91

 (1.49) 

4.42 

5.91 

(1.49)

4.425.91

 (1.42)

 4.46 5.89

 (1.10)

 4.76 5.86

 (1.09) 

4.76 5.86 

(1.08)

4.775.85

 (1.06)

 4.78 5.84

 

  

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.23)

2.96

3.18

 (0.31) 

3.22 

3.53 

(0.58)

3.47

4.05

 (0.55) 

3.65 4.20

(0.94)

 4.37 

5.31 

 (1.42)

5.02

6.44

 (1.42) 

5.02 

6.44 

(1.41)

5.026.44

 (1.35)

 5.05 6.41

 (1.05)

 5.27 6.31

 (1.04) 

5.27 6.31 

(1.03)

5.286.30

 (1.01)

 5.28 6.29

 

  

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.08 

3.82

3.74

(0.01) 

4.06 

4.07 

(0.31)

4.24

4.55

 (0.29) 

4.41 4.70

(0.75)

 4.97 

5.72 

 (1.30)

5.45

6.76

 (1.30) 

5.45 

6.76 

(1.30) 

5.456.75

(1.24)

 5.48 6.72

 (0.97)

 5.63 6.60

 (0.96) 

5.64 6.59 

(0.95)

5.646.59

 (0.93)

 5.64 6.57

 

  

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.23 

4.13

3.90

0.13 

4.37 

4.23 

(0.18)

4.52

4.71

 (0.16) 

4.69 4.85

(0.66)

 5.18 

5.85 

 (1.25)

5.61

6.86

 (1.25) 

5.61 

6.86 

(1.25) 

5.616.86

(1.19)

 5.63 6.82

 (0.93)

 5.76 6.69

 (0.92) 

5.77 6.69 

(0.91)

5.776.68

 (0.89)

 5.77 6.66

 

  

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.27 

4.17

3.90

0.17 

4.40 

4.23 

(0.15)

4.56

4.71

 (0.13) 

4.72 4.85

(0.64)

 5.21 

5.85 

 (1.24)

5.62

6.86

 (1.24) 

5.63 

6.86 

(1.23) 

5.636.86

(1.18)

 5.65 6.83

 (0.92)

 5.78 6.70

 (0.91) 

5.78 6.69 

(0.90)

5.796.68

 (0.88)

 5.79 6.67

 

  

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.38 

4.26

3.88

0.28 

4.49 

4.21 

(0.05)

4.64

4.69

 (0.03) 

4.80 4.83

(0.57)

 5.27 

5.84 

 (1.20)

5.67

6.86

 (1.20) 

5.67 

6.87 

(1.19) 

5.676.86

(1.14)

 5.69 6.83

 (0.89)

 5.82 6.70

 (0.88) 

5.82 6.70 

(0.87)

5.826.69

 (0.85)

 5.83 6.68

 

  

10B-9 
Table 10B.2.9 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Refrigeratio

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.01) (0.00) 0.01 0.04 0.06 

OCS - 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 

NPV - 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.01 (0.02) (0.04) 

1 ICS 

OCS 

0.00 

0.00

(0.01)

 0.01

 (0.01)

 0.01

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.01) 

0.02 

(0.01)

0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.00) 

0.02 

0.01 

0.02 

0.04 

0.02

0.06 

0.02 

NPV 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.01 (0.02) (0.04) 

2 ICS 

OCS 

0.00 

0.00

(0.01)

 0.01

 (0.01)

 0.01

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.01) 

0.02 

(0.01)

0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.01)

 0.02

 (0.00) 

0.02 

0.01 

0.02 

0.04 

0.02

0.06 

0.02 

NPV 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.01 (0.02) (0.04) 

3 ICS 

OCS 

0.02

0.01

 0.00

 0.02

 0.00 

0.02

(0.00) 

0.02

(0.00) 

0.02

(0.00) 

0.02 

0.00

0.02

 0.00

 0.02

 0.00

 0.02

 0.01 

0.02 

0.02 

0.03 

0.05

0.03

 0.06 

0.03 

NPV (0.00) 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.01 (0.02) (0.04) 

10B-10 
Table 10B.2.10 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Refrige

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 

0 ICS - (0.56) (0.55) (0.55) (0.19) (0.11) 0.03 0.11 0.37 0.65 1.84 4.58 6.21 7.05 

OCS - 1.06 1.05 1.05 1.34 1.39 1.44 1.47 1.54 1.59 1.70 1.79 1.83 1.8

NPV - 1.62 1.60 1.60 1.54 1.50 1.42 1.36 1.17 0.94 (0.14) (2.79) (4.38) (5.1

1 ICS 

OCS 

0.02 

0.25 

(0.55)

1.24

 (0.54)

 1.23

 (0.53)

 1.23

 (0.18)

 1.50

 (0.10) 

1.54 

0.04 

1.60 

0.12

1.62 0.38 1.68 

0.66 

1.73 

1.85 

1.84

4.59

 1.92

 6.22

 1.96

 7.0

 1.9

NPV 0.23 1.78 1.76 1.76 1.68 1.64 1.56 1.50 1.30 1.07 (0.02) (2.68) (4.26) (5.0

2 ICS 

OCS 

0.06 

0.34 

(0.52)

1.29

 (0.51)

 1.28

 (0.50)

 1.29

 (0.16)

 1.55

 (0.08) 

1.59 

0.06 

1.65 

0.14

1.67 0.40 1.73 

0.68 

1.77 

1.87 

1.88

4.61

 1.96

 6.23

 2.00

 7.07

 2.02

NPV 0.27 1.82 1.79 1.79 1.71 1.67 1.59 1.53 1.33 1.10 0.01 (2.65) (4.23) (5.0

3 ICS 

OCS 

0.48 

1.05 

(0.25)

1.80

 (0.24)

 1.79

 (0.24) 

1.79

0.07 

2.00

0.14 

2.03 

0.27 

2.07 

0.35 

2.09 

0.60 

2.14 

0.87 

2.17 

2.05

2.25

 4.77

 2.32

 6.39

 2.35

 7.22

 2.3

NPV 0.57 2.05 2.03 2.03 1.93 1.88 1.80 1.74 1.53 1.30 0.21 (2.46) (4.04) (4.8

10B-11 
Table 10B.2.11 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Refrigerat

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.30) (0.28) (0.28) (0.21) (0.09) 0.39 0.48 0.52 0.75 0.98 1.02 1.60 

OCS - 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.63 0.67 0.82 0.85 0.86 0.91 0.95 0.96 1.02 

NPV - 0.89 0.87 0.87 0.84 0.76 0.43 0.37 0.33 0.17 (0.03) (0.06) (0.59) (

1 ICS 

OCS 

0.02 

0.20 

(0.28)

0.76

 (0.27)

 0.75

 (0.27)

 0.75

 (0.20) 

0.79 

(0.08) 

0.83 

0.40 

0.97 

0.49

0.99 0.541.00 0.76 1.05 

0.99 

1.09

1.03

 1.09

 1.61

 1.15

 

 

NPV 0.19 1.04 1.02 1.02 0.98 0.91 0.57 0.51 0.47 0.30 0.10 0.07 (0.46) (

2 ICS 

OCS 

0.05 

0.27 

(0.26)

0.81

 (0.25)

 0.80

 (0.25)

 0.80

 (0.17) 

0.84 

(0.06) 

0.88 

0.42 

1.02 

0.51

1.04 0.561.05 0.78 1.10 

1.01 

1.13

1.05

 1.14

 1.63

 1.19

 

 

NPV 0.22 1.07 1.05 1.05 1.01 0.94 0.60 0.53 0.49 0.32 0.13 0.09 (0.44) (

3 ICS 

OCS 

0.36 

0.84 

(0.03)

1.26

 (0.02)

 1.25

 (0.01) 

1.25

0.05 

1.28 

0.16 

1.31 

0.62 

1.42 

0.71 

1.44 

0.75 

1.45 

0.97 

1.49 

1.19

1.51

 1.23

 1.52

 1.81

 1.56

 

 

NPV 0.48 1.29 1.27 1.27 1.23 1.15 0.80 0.73 0.69 0.52 0.32 0.29 (0.25) (

10B-12 
Table 10B.2.12 Net Present Value for Medium Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Refrigeration 

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 

0 ICS - (0.14) (0.16) (0.34) (0.18) (0.05) (0.03) (0.01) 0.00 0.00 0.02 0.80 0.81 0.83 

OCS - 1.27 1.90 2.64 3.10 4.70 5.18 4.38 4.39 4.39 4.39 3.41 3.41 3.42 

NPV - 1.42 2.06 2.97 3.29 4.75 5.21 4.39 4.38 4.38 4.38 2.61 2.61 2.59 

1 ICS 0.03 (0.12) (0.13) (0.31) (0.16) (0.03) (0.02) 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.03 0.81 0.81 0.84 

OCS 0.56 1.80 2.41 3.10 3.56 5.06 5.43 4.63 4.63 4.63 4.64 3.62 3.62 3.63 

NPV 0.53 1.92 2.55 3.41 3.72 5.09 5.45 4.62 4.62 4.62 4.61 2.82 2.81 2.79 

2 ICS 0.08 (0.07) (0.09) (0.27) (0.12) (0.00) (0.00) 0.02 0.03 0.03 0.04 0.82 0.83 0.85 

OCS 0.74 1.97 2.58 3.25 3.70 5.17 5.52 4.71 4.71 4.71 4.72 3.69 3.69 3.70 

NPV 0.65 2.04 2.66 3.52 3.82 5.17 5.52 4.69 4.68 4.68 4.68 2.87 2.87 2.85 

3 ICS 0.63 0.44 0.40 0.16 0.30 0.31 0.18 0.20 0.20 0.21 0.22 0.95 0.96 0.98 

OCS 2.29 3.44 4.00 4.53 4.95 6.16 6.22 5.40 5.40 5.40 5.41 4.28 4.28 4.29 

NPV 1.66 3.00 3.60 4.37 4.65 5.86 6.04 5.20 5.20 5.20 5.19 3.33 3.33 3.31 

10B-13 
Table 10B.2.13 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Indoor R

at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.15)

0.26

0.40

 (0.15) 

0.26 

0.41 

(0.15)

0.27

0.42

 (0.15)

 0.28

 0.43

 (0.15) 

0.28 

0.43 

(0.15)

0.28

0.43

 (0.15)

 0.29 

0.45 

 (0.15) 

0.29 0.45 

(0.15)

0.300.45

 (0.16)

 0.32 0.48

 (0.13) 

0.33 0.46 

(0.11)

0.340.45

 (

  

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02)

0.04

0.06

 (0.15)

 0.28

 0.43

 (0.15) 

0.28 

0.44 

(0.16)

0.29

0.45

 (0.16)

 0.30

 0.46

 (0.16) 

0.30 

0.46 

(0.16)

0.30

0.46

 (0.16)

 0.31 0.47

 (0.16) 

0.31 0.47 

(0.16)

0.320.48

 (0.16)

 0.34 0.50

 (0.14) 

0.35 0.49 

(0.12)

0.360.47

 (

  

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

0.10

0.15

 (0.16)

 0.31

 0.48

 (0.16) 

0.32 

0.48 

(0.17)

0.33

0.49

 (0.17)

 0.33

 0.50

 (0.17) 

0.33 

0.50 

(0.17)

0.34

0.50

 (0.17)

 0.34 0.51

 (0.17) 

0.34 0.51 

(0.17)

0.350.52

 (0.17)

 0.37 0.54

 (0.14) 

0.38 0.52 

(0.13)

0.380.51

 (

  

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.05)

0.17

0.22

 (0.17)

 0.35

 0.52

 (0.17) 

0.35 

0.52 

(0.17)

0.36 

0.53

 (0.17)

0.37 

0.54

 (0.17) 

0.37 

0.54 

(0.17)

0.37 

0.54

 (0.17)

0.38 

0.55

 (0.17) 

0.38 

0.55 

(0.17)

0.38

0.55

 (0.17)

 0.40 

0.57

 (0.14) 

0.40 

0.55 

(0.13)

0.41 

0.54

 (

0.53

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

0.21

0.25

 (0.16)

 0.37

 0.53

 (0.16) 

0.37 

0.54 

(0.17)

0.38

0.55

 (0.17)

 0.39

 0.55

 (0.17) 

0.39 

0.55 

(0.17)

0.39

0.56

 (0.17)

 0.39 0.56

 (0.17) 

0.39 0.56 

(0.17)

0.400.57

 (0.17)

 0.41 0.58

 (0.14) 

0.42 0.56 

(0.13)

0.420.55

 (

  

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

0.22

0.26

 (0.16)

 0.38

 0.54

 (0.16) 

0.38 

0.54 

(0.17)

0.39

0.55

 (0.17)

 0.39

 0.56

 (0.17) 

0.39 

0.56 

(0.17)

0.39

0.56

 (0.17)

 0.40 0.57

 (0.17) 

0.40 0.57 

(0.17)

0.400.57

 (0.17)

 0.42 0.59

 (0.14) 

0.42 0.57 

(0.12)

0.430.55

 (

  

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

0.22

0.26

 (0.16)

 0.38

 0.54

 (0.16) 

0.38 

0.54 

(0.16)

0.39

0.55

 (0.17)

 0.39

 0.56

 (0.17) 

0.39 

0.56 

(0.17)

0.40

0.56

 (0.17)

 0.40 0.57

 (0.17) 

0.40 0.57 

(0.17)

0.410.57

 (0.17)

 0.42 0.59

 (0.14) 

0.43 0.57 

(0.12)

0.430.55

 (

  

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02)

0.24

0.26

 (0.15)

 0.39

 0.54

 (0.16) 

0.39 

0.54 

(0.16)

0.40

0.56

 (0.16)

 0.40

 0.56

 (0.16) 

0.40 

0.56 

(0.16)

0.40

0.56

 (0.16)

 0.41 0.57

 (0.16) 

0.41 0.57 

(0.16)

0.410.58

 (0.16)

 0.43 0.59

 (0.14) 

0.43 0.57 

(0.12)

0.440.56

 (

  

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.26

0.25

(0.14)

 0.40

 0.54

 (0.14) 

0.40 

0.54 

(0.15)

0.41

0.55

 (0.15)

 0.41

 0.56

 (0.15) 

0.41 

0.56 

(0.15)

0.41

0.56

 (0.15) 

0.42 0.57

(0.15) 

0.42 0.57 

(0.15)

0.420.58

 (0.16)

 0.43 0.59

 (0.13) 

0.44 0.57 

(0.11)

0.440.56

 (

  

10B-14 
Table 10B.2.14 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Indoor 

System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.31) 

0.88 

1.19 

(0.31)

0.88

1.19

 (0.31)

 0.89 

1.20 

 (0.32) 

0.93

1.25

(0.32) 

0.96 

1.28 

(0.32)

0.97

1.29

 (0.32) 

1.01 

1.33 

(0.32) 

1.02 1.33 

(0.31) 

1.09 1.40 

(0.31)

1.121.43

 (0.19)

 1.16 1.35

 (0.12) 

1.19 1.30 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.10

0.14

 (0.33) 

0.93 

1.26 

(0.33)

0.94

1.26

 (0.33)

 0.94 

1.27 

 (0.33) 

0.98

1.31

(0.33) 

1.01 

1.34 

(0.33)

1.02

1.35

 (0.33) 

1.06 1.39 

(0.33) 

1.06 1.39 

(0.32) 

1.13 1.46 

(0.32) 

1.161.48

(0.20) 

1.20 1.40

(0.13) 

1.22 1.35 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08)

0.38

0.45

 (0.34) 

1.08 

1.42 

(0.34)

1.08

1.42

 (0.34)

 1.08 

1.43 

 (0.35) 

1.12

1.47

(0.35) 

1.15 

1.49 

(0.35)

1.16

1.50

 (0.34) 

1.18 1.53 

(0.34) 

1.19 1.53 

(0.34) 

1.25 1.59 

(0.33) 

1.271.60

(0.21) 

1.31 1.51

(0.13) 

1.32 1.46 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.06)

0.57

0.62

 (0.34) 

1.17 

1.51 

(0.34)

1.18

1.52

 (0.34)

 1.18 

1.52 

 (0.34) 

1.22

1.56

(0.34) 

1.24 

1.58 

(0.34)

1.25

1.59

 (0.34) 

1.27 1.61 

(0.34) 

1.28 1.61 

(0.33) 

1.33 1.66 

(0.33) 

1.351.67

(0.20) 

1.38 1.58

(0.13) 

1.39 1.52 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.72

0.75

 (0.33) 

1.25 

1.58 

(0.33)

1.26

1.58

 (0.33)

 1.26 

1.59 

 (0.33) 

1.30

1.63

(0.33) 

1.31 

1.64 

(0.33)

1.32

1.65

 (0.33) 

1.34 1.67 

(0.33) 

1.35 1.68 

(0.32) 

1.39 1.72 

(0.32) 

1.411.73

(0.20) 

1.44 1.63

(0.12) 

1.45 1.57 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02)

0.75

0.77

 (0.32) 

1.27 

1.59 

(0.32)

1.28

1.60

 (0.32)

 1.28 

1.60 

 (0.32) 

1.31

1.64

(0.33) 

1.33 

1.66 

(0.33)

1.34

1.66

 (0.33) 

1.36 1.68 

(0.32) 

1.36 1.69 

(0.32) 

1.41 1.73 

(0.32) 

1.421.74

(0.20) 

1.45 1.64

(0.12) 

1.46 1.59 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02)

0.77

0.79

 (0.32) 

1.28 

1.60 

(0.32)

1.29

1.60

 (0.32)

 1.29 

1.61 

 (0.32) 

1.32

1.64

(0.32) 

1.34 

1.66 

(0.32)

1.35

1.67

 (0.32) 

1.37 1.69 

(0.32) 

1.37 1.69 

(0.32) 

1.41 1.73 

(0.31) 

1.431.74

(0.19) 

1.46 1.65

(0.12) 

1.47 1.59 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

0.82

0.80

(0.31) 

1.31 

1.61 

(0.31)

1.31

1.62

 (0.31)

 1.31 

1.62 

 (0.31) 

1.35

1.66

(0.31) 

1.36 

1.68 

(0.31)

1.37

1.68

 (0.31) 

1.39 1.70 

(0.31) 

1.40 1.71 

(0.31) 

1.43 1.74 

(0.31)

1.451.75

 (0.19)

 1.47 1.66

 (0.11) 

1.49 1.60 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.07 

0.88

0.81

(0.28) 

1.34 

1.62 

(0.28)

1.34

1.63

 (0.28)

 1.34 

1.63 

 (0.29) 

1.38

1.67

(0.29) 

1.39 

1.68 

(0.29)

1.40

1.69

 (0.29) 

1.42 1.71 

(0.29) 

1.42 1.72 

(0.29) 

1.46 1.75 

(0.29) 

1.471.76

(0.17) 

1.50 1.67

(0.10) 

1.51 1.61 

10B-15 
Table 10B.2.15 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor 

System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(0.68) 

1.03 1.72 

(0.69) 

1.05 1.73 

(0.70) 

1.10 1.79 

(0.71) 

1.13 1.84 

(0.71) 

1.13 1.84 

(0.71) 

1.14 1.85 

(0.72) 

1.18 1.90 

(0.72) 

1.18 1.91 

(0.73) 

1.211.93

(0.74) 

1.29 2.04 

(0.62) 

1.34 1.96 

(0.55) 

1.37 1.91 

(0

11

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.09) 

0.160.26

(0.73) 

1.12 1.85

(0.73) 

1.13 1.86 

(0.74) 

1.18 1.92 

(0.75) 

1.21 1.96 

(0.75) 

1.21 1.96 

(0.75) 

1.22 1.97 

(0.76) 

1.26 2.01 

(0.76) 

1.26 2.02 

(0.76) 

1.292.04

(0.77) 

1.37 2.13 

(0.65) 

1.41 2.06 

(0.57) 

1.43 2.00 

(0

11

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.21) 

0.440.65

(0.78) 

1.27 2.05

(0.78) 

1.28 2.06 

(0.78) 

1.33 2.11 

(0.79) 

1.35 2.14 

(0.79) 

1.35 2.15 

(0.80) 

1.36 2.16 

(0.80) 

1.39 2.19 

(0.80) 

1.40 2.20 

(0.80) 

1.422.22

(0.80) 

1.49 2.29 

(0.68) 

1.52 2.20 

(0.60) 

1.54 2.14 

(0

12

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.22) 

0.650.86

(0.78) 

1.38 2.16

(0.78) 

1.39 2.17 

(0.79) 

1.43 2.22 

(0.80) 

1.46 2.25 

(0.80) 

1.46 2.25 

(0.80) 

1.47 2.26 

(0.80) 

1.49 2.29 

(0.80) 

1.50 2.30 

(0.80) 

1.512.32

(0.80) 

1.57 2.38 

(0.68) 

1.61 2.29 

(0.60) 

1.62 2.23 

(0

12

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.19) 

0.790.98

(0.77) 

1.46 2.22

(0.77) 

1.47 2.24 

(0.77) 

1.51 2.29 

(0.78) 

1.53 2.31 

(0.78) 

1.53 2.32 

(0.79) 

1.54 2.33 

(0.79) 

1.56 2.35 

(0.79) 

1.57 2.36 

(0.79) 

1.582.37

(0.80) 

1.64 2.43 

(0.67) 

1.67 2.34 

(0.60) 

1.68 2.28 

(0

12

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.10) 

1.131.23

(0.73) 

1.64 2.37

(0.73) 

1.65 2.38 

(0.74) 

1.69 2.43 

(0.75) 

1.70 2.45 

(0.75) 

1.70 2.45 

(0.75) 

1.71 2.46 

(0.76) 

1.73 2.49 

(0.76) 

1.73 2.49 

(0.76) 

1.742.50

(0.77) 

1.78 2.55 

(0.65) 

1.80 2.45 

(0.57) 

1.82 2.39 

(0

12

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.09) 

1.171.26

(0.72) 

1.66 2.39

(0.72) 

1.67 2.40 

(0.73) 

1.71 2.44 

(0.74) 

1.73 2.47 

(0.74) 

1.73 2.47 

(0.75) 

1.73 2.48 

(0.75) 

1.75 2.50 

(0.76) 

1.75 2.51 

(0.76) 

1.762.52

(0.77) 

1.80 2.57 

(0.64) 

1.82 2.47 

(0.57) 

1.84 2.41 

(0

12

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08) 

1.191.27

(0.72) 

1.67 2.39

(0.72) 

1.68 2.40 

(0.73) 

1.72 2.45 

(0.74) 

1.73 2.47 

(0.74) 

1.73 2.48 

(0.74) 

1.74 2.48 

(0.75) 

1.76 2.51 

(0.75) 

1.76 2.51 

(0.75) 

1.772.52

(0.76) 

1.81 2.57 

(0.64) 

1.83 2.47 

(0.57) 

1.84 2.41 

(0

12

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.05 

1.301.25

(0.66) 

1.73 2.39

(0.67) 

1.74 2.41 

(0.68) 

1.78 2.45 

(0.69) 

1.79 2.48 

(0.69) 

1.79 2.48 

(0.69) 

1.79 2.49 

(0.70) 

1.81 2.51 

(0.71) 

1.81 2.52 

(0.71) 

1.822.53

(0.73) 

1.86 2.58 

(0.61) 

1.88 2.48 

(0.54) 

1.89 2.42 

(0

12

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.13 

1.361.23

(0.63) 

1.77 2.39

(0.63) 

1.77 2.41 

(0.64) 

1.81 2.45 

(0.66) 

1.82 2.48 

(0.66) 

1.82 2.48 

(0.66) 

1.83 2.49 

(0.67) 

1.84 2.52 

(0.68) 

1.84 2.52 

(0.68) 

1.852.53

(0.70) 

1.88 2.59 

(0.59) 

1.90 2.49 

(0.52) 

1.91 2.43 

(0

12

10B-16 
Table 10B.2.16 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoo

System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(1.49) 

3.48 4.97 

(1.49) 

3.50 4.99 

(1.49) 

3.52 5.00 

(1.51) 

3.71 5.21 

(1.52) 

3.82 5.34 

(1.52) 

3.87 5.39 

(1.52) 

4.01 5.53 

(1.51) 

4.055.56

(1.51) 

4.34 5.85 

(1.49) 

4.44 5.93 

(0.95) 

4.62 5.57 

(0.62) 

4.72 5.34 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.17) 

0.42 

0.60 

(1.56) 

3.71 5.26 

(1.56) 

3.73 5.28 

(1.56) 

3.74 5.30 

(1.57) 

3.92 5.50 

(1.58) 

4.03 5.62 

(1.58) 

4.08 5.66 

(1.58) 

4.21 5.79 

(1.57) 

4.245.81

(1.56) 

4.51 6.07 

(1.54) 

4.61 6.15 

(0.99) 

4.78 5.77 

(0.66) 

4.87 5.53 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.26) 

1.43 

1.69 

(1.59) 

4.23 5.83 

(1.59) 

4.25 5.84 

(1.60) 

4.26 5.86 

(1.61) 

4.43 6.04 

(1.62) 

4.53 6.14 

(1.62) 

4.57 6.18 

(1.61) 

4.68 6.29 

(1.60) 

4.716.31

(1.58) 

4.94 6.52 

(1.56) 

5.02 6.58 

(1.01) 

5.17 6.18 

(0.68) 

5.24 5.92 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.22) 

2.09 

2.30 

(1.58) 

4.58 6.15 

(1.58) 

4.59 6.17 

(1.58) 

4.60 6.18 

(1.59) 

4.77 6.36 

(1.60) 

4.85 6.45 

(1.60) 

4.88 6.49 

(1.59) 

4.99 6.58 

(1.59) 

5.016.60

(1.57) 

5.21 6.78 

(1.55) 

5.29 6.83 

(1.00) 

5.42 6.41 

(0.67) 

5.48 6.15 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.05) 

3.33 

3.38 

(1.51) 

5.23 6.74 

(1.51) 

5.25 6.75 

(1.51) 

5.25 6.76 

(1.53) 

5.40 6.93 

(1.54) 

5.46 7.00 

(1.54) 

5.49 7.03 

(1.53) 

5.57 7.10 

(1.53) 

5.597.12

(1.52) 

5.73 7.26 

(1.50) 

5.79 7.30 

(0.96) 

5.89 6.85 

(0.63) 

5.94 6.57 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.07 

3.84 

3.77 

(1.46) 

5.50 6.95 

(1.46) 

5.51 6.97 

(1.46) 

5.52 6.98 

(1.48) 

5.66 7.14 

(1.49) 

5.71 7.21 

(1.50) 

5.74 7.23 

(1.49) 

5.80 7.30 

(1.49) 

5.827.31

(1.49) 

5.95 7.44 

(1.47) 

6.00 7.47 

(0.93) 

6.08 7.02 

(0.61) 

6.13 6.73 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.11 

3.98 

3.86 

(1.44) 

5.57 7.01 

(1.44) 

5.58 7.02 

(1.44) 

5.59 7.03 

(1.46) 

5.73 7.19 

(1.47) 

5.78 7.26 

(1.48) 

5.80 7.28 

(1.48) 

5.87 7.35 

(1.47) 

5.887.36

(1.48) 

6.01 7.48 

(1.46) 

6.05 7.51 

(0.92) 

6.14 7.06 

(0.60) 

6.18 6.77 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.14 

4.04 

3.89 

(1.43) 

5.60 7.03 

(1.43) 

5.61 7.04 

(1.43) 

5.62 7.05 

(1.45) 

5.76 7.21 

(1.46) 

5.81 7.27 

(1.47) 

5.83 7.30 

(1.47) 

5.90 7.36 

(1.46) 

5.917.37

(1.47) 

6.03 7.50 

(1.45) 

6.08 7.53 

(0.92) 

6.16 7.07 

(0.59) 

6.20 6.79 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.30 

4.24 

3.95 

(1.36) 

5.71 7.07 

(1.36) 

5.72 7.08 

(1.37) 

5.73 7.09 

(1.39) 

5.86 7.25 

(1.41) 

5.91 7.32 

(1.41) 

5.93 7.34 

(1.41) 

5.99 7.41 

(1.41) 

6.017.42

(1.43) 

6.12 7.54 

(1.41) 

6.16 7.57 

(0.88) 

6.24 7.12 

(0.56) 

6.28 6.83 

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

0.54 

4.58 

4.03 

(1.26) 

5.88 7.14 

(1.26) 

5.90 7.15 

(1.26) 

5.90 7.16 

(1.29) 

6.03 7.32 

(1.31) 

6.08 7.39 

(1.32) 

6.09 7.41 

(1.33) 

6.15 7.48 

(1.33) 

6.167.49

(1.36) 

6.26 7.61 

(1.35) 

6.29 7.64 

(0.82) 

6.36 7.19 

(0.50) 

6.40 6.90 

10B-17 
Table 10B.2.17 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor 

System at a 7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV 

-

--

(1.60) 

3.885.48

(1.61) 

3.89 5.50

(1.61) 

4.26 5.86 

(1.63) 

4.39 6.02 

(1.64) 

4.55 6.19 

(1.64) 

4.64 6.28 

(1.63) 

4.84 6.46 

(1.63) 

5.16 6.79 

(1.62) 

5.226.84

(1.58) 

5.36 6.94 

(1.55) 

5.38 6.93 

(1.32) 

5.47 6.79 

(

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.20) 

0.52 0.73 

(1.70) 

4.185.88

(1.71) 

4.19 5.90

(1.70) 

4.55 6.26 

(1.72) 

4.68 6.40 

(1.73) 

4.83 6.56 

(1.73) 

4.91 6.64 

(1.71) 

5.10 6.81 

(1.70) 

5.40 7.10 

(1.68) 

5.467.14

(1.64) 

5.59 7.24 

(1.62) 

5.61 7.22 

(1.38) 

5.70 7.08 

(

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.30) 

1.76 2.07 

(1.75) 

4.886.63

(1.75) 

4.90 6.65

(1.75) 

5.26 7.01 

(1.77) 

5.36 7.13 

(1.77) 

5.49 7.27 

(1.77) 

5.56 7.33 

(1.75) 

5.72 7.47 

(1.73) 

5.98 7.71 

(1.72) 

6.037.74

(1.67) 

6.14 7.81 

(1.65) 

6.15 7.80 

(1.41) 

6.23 7.64 

(

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.25) 

2.57 2.83 

(1.73) 

5.357.07

(1.73) 

5.36 7.09

(1.73) 

5.71 7.44 

(1.74) 

5.81 7.55 

(1.75) 

5.92 7.68 

(1.75) 

5.99 7.74 

(1.73) 

6.13 7.86 

(1.71) 

6.36 8.07 

(1.70) 

6.408.10

(1.66) 

6.50 8.16 

(1.63) 

6.51 8.14 

(1.39) 

6.58 7.97 

(

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.06) 

4.11 4.17 

(1.63) 

6.227.86

(1.64) 

6.23 7.87

(1.64) 

6.59 8.22 

(1.66) 

6.66 8.31 

(1.67) 

6.75 8.41 

(1.67) 

6.79 8.46 

(1.65) 

6.90 8.55 

(1.65) 

7.07 8.72 

(1.64) 

7.108.74

(1.60) 

7.18 8.78 

(1.57) 

7.19 8.76 

(1.33) 

7.24 8.58 

(

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.08 

4.73 4.65 

(1.57) 

6.588.14

(1.57) 

6.59 8.16

(1.57) 

6.94 8.51 

(1.59) 

7.00 8.59 

(1.61) 

7.08 8.69 

(1.61) 

7.12 8.73 

(1.60) 

7.21 8.81 

(1.60) 

7.36 8.96 

(1.59) 

7.398.98

(1.55) 

7.45 9.01 

(1.53) 

7.46 8.99 

(1.29) 

7.51 8.80 

(

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.13 

4.91 4.77 

(1.54) 

6.688.22

(1.54) 

6.69 8.23

(1.54) 

7.04 8.58 

(1.57) 

7.10 8.66 

(1.58) 

7.17 8.75 

(1.59) 

7.21 8.80 

(1.58) 

7.30 8.88 

(1.58) 

7.44 9.02 

(1.57) 

7.479.04

(1.54) 

7.53 9.07 

(1.51) 

7.54 9.05 

(1.28) 

7.58 8.86 

(

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.17 

4.98 4.81 

(1.52) 

6.728.24

(1.53) 

6.73 8.25

(1.53) 

7.08 8.60 

(1.55) 

7.14 8.69 

(1.57) 

7.21 8.78 

(1.57) 

7.25 8.82 

(1.56) 

7.34 8.90 

(1.57) 

7.47 9.04 

(1.56) 

7.509.06

(1.52) 

7.56 9.09 

(1.50) 

7.57 9.07 

(1.27) 

7.61 8.88 

(

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.35 

5.23 4.89 

(1.44) 

6.878.30

(1.44) 

6.87 8.32

(1.44) 

7.22 8.66 

(1.47) 

7.28 8.75 

(1.49) 

7.35 8.84 

(1.50) 

7.38 8.88 

(1.49) 

7.47 8.96 

(1.51) 

7.59 9.10 

(1.50) 

7.629.12

(1.47) 

7.68 9.14 

(1.45) 

7.68 9.13 

(1.21) 

7.72 8.94 

(

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.64 

5.64 5.01 

(1.30) 

7.108.40

(1.30) 

7.11 8.41

(1.31) 

7.45 8.76 

(1.34) 

7.50 8.84 

(1.37) 

7.56 8.93 

(1.38) 

7.60 8.97 

(1.38) 

7.67 9.05 

(1.41) 

7.78 9.19 

(1.40) 

7.809.21

(1.38) 

7.86 9.23 

(1.36) 

7.86 9.22 

(1.13) 

7.90 9.03 

(

10B-18 
Table 10B.2.18 Net Present Value for Small Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refri

7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(0.03) 

-

0.03

(0.23) 

-

0

.23 

(0.24) 

0.00 

0.24 

(0.24) (0.03) 

0.20 

(0.24) (0.03) 

0.21 

(0.28) (0.10) 

0.18 

(0.28) (0.10) 

0.18 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.18

(0.27) (0.10) 

0

.18 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.18 

(0.27) (0.15) 

0.12 

(0.27) (0.15) 

0.12 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.04) 

-

0

.04

(0.07) 

-

0

.07

(0.25) 

-

0

.25 

(0.26) 

0.00 

0.26 

(0.26) (0.03) 

0.23 

(0.26) (0.03) 

0.23 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19

(0.29) (0.10) 

0

.19 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19 

(0.29) (0.15) 

0.13 

(0.28) (0.15) 

0.13 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.06) 

-

0

.06

(0.09) 

-

0

.09

(0.26) 

-

0

.26 

(0.27) 

0.00 

0.27 

(0.27) (0.03) 

0.24 

(0.27) (0.03) 

0.24 

(0.30) (0.10) 

0.20 

(0.30) (0.10) 

0.20 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19

(0.29) (0.10) 

0

.19 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19 

(0.29) (0.15) 

0.14 

(0.28) (0.15) 

0.13 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.05) 

-

0

.05

(0.08) 

-

0

.08

(0.26) 

-

0

.26 

(0.26) 

0.00 

0.27 

(0.26) (0.03) 

0.23 

(0.26) (0.03) 

0.23 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.20 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.20 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19

(0.29) (0.10) 

0

.19 

(0.29) (0.10) 

0.19 

(0.29) (0.15) 

0.14 

(0.28) (0.15) 

0.13 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.01) 

-

0

.01

(0.04) 

-

0

.04

(0.23) 

-

0

.23 

(0.24) 

0.00 

0.25 

(0.24) (0.03) 

0.21 

(0.25) (0.03) 

0.21 

(0.28) (0.10) 

0.18 

(0.28) (0.10) 

0.18 

(0.28) (0.10) 

0.18

(0.28) (0.10) 

0

.18 

(0.28) (0.10) 

0.18 

(0.28) (0.15) 

0.13 

(0.27) (0.15) 

0.12 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

-

(0.02)

(0.02) 

-

0

.02

(0.22) 

-

0

.22 

(0.23) 

0.00 

0.23 

(0.23) (0.03) 

0.20 

(0.23) (0.03) 

0.20 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17

(0.27) (0.10) 

0

.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.15) 

0.12 

(0.26) (0.15) 

0.11 

6 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.03 

-

(0.03)

(0.01) 

-

0

.01

(0.21) 

-

0

.21 

(0.22) 

0.00 

0.23 

(0.22) (0.03) 

0.19 

(0.23) (0.03) 

0.20 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17

(0.27) (0.10) 

0

.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.15) 

0.11 

(0.26) (0.15) 

0.11 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.03 

-

(0.03)

(0.00) 

-

0

.00

(0.21) 

-

0

.21 

(0.22) 

0.00 

0.22 

(0.22) (0.03) 

0.19 

(0.22) (0.03) 

0.19 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.27) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.26) (0.10) 

0.17

(0.26) (0.10) 

0

.17 

(0.26) (0.10) 

0.17 

(0.26) (0.15) 

0.11 

(0.26) (0.15) 

0.11 

8 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.07

-

(0.07) 0

.03 

-

(0.03)

(0.19) 

-

0

.19 

(0.20) 

0.00 

0.20 

(0.20) (0.03) 

0.17 

(0.21) (0.03) 

0.18 

(0.25) (0.10) 

0.16 

(0.26) (0.10) 

0.16 

(0.25) (0.10) 

0.15

(0.25) (0.10) 

0

.15 

(0.25) (0.10) 

0.15 

(0.25) (0.15) 

0.10 

(0.25) (0.15) 

0.10 

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.12 

-

(0.12) 

0.08 

-

(0.08)

(0.15) 

-

0

.15 

(0.17) 

0.00 

0.17 

(0.17) (0.03) 

0.14 

(0.18) (0.03) 

0.15 

(0.24) (0.10) 

0.14 

(0.24) (0.10) 

0.14 

(0.23) (0.10) 

0.14

(0.23) (0.10) 

0

.14 

(0.23) (0.10) 

0.14 

(0.23) (0.15) 

0.08 

(0.24) (0.15) 

0.09 

10B-19 
Table 10B.2.19 Net Present Value for Large Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refri

7 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(0.07) 

-

0.07 

(0.80) 

-

0.80 

(0.80) 

-

0.80 

(0.79) 

0.03 

0.82 

(0.80) (0.27) 

0.53 

(1.04) (0.82) 

0.21 

(1.04) (0.82) 

0.21 

(1.04) (0.82) 

0.21

(1.04) (0.82) 

0.21 

(1.03) (0.82) 

0.21 

(0.94) (1.27) (0.33) 

(0.93) (1.27) (0.34) 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.20) 

-

0.20

(0.26) 

-

0.26

(0.94) 

-

0.94 

(0.94) 

-

0.94 

(0.92) 

0.03 

0.95 

(0.92) (0.27) 

0.65 

(1.11) (0.82) 

0.28 

(1.11) (0.82) 

0.29 

(1.11) (0.82) 

0.29

(1.11) (0.82) 

0.28 

(1.10) (0.82) 

0.28 

(0.99) (1.27) (0.28) 

(0.99) (1.27) (0.28) 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.29) 

-

0.29

(0.35) 

-

0.35

(1.01) 

-

1.01 

(1.01) 

-

1.01 

(0.99) 

0.03 

1.02 

(0.98) (0.27) 

0.71 

(1.14) (0.82) 

0.32 

(1.14) (0.82) 

0.32 

(1.14) (0.82) 

0.32

(1.14) (0.82) 

0.32 

(1.14) (0.82) 

0.31 

(1.02) (1.27) (0.25) 

(1.01) (1.27) (0.26) 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.25) 

-

0.25

(0.31) 

-

0.31

(0.98) 

-

0.98 

(0.98) 

-

0.98 

(0.96) 

0.03 

0.99 

(0.95) (0.27) 

0.68 

(1.13) (0.82) 

0.30 

(1.13) (0.82) 

0.30 

(1.13) (0.82) 

0.30

(1.13) (0.82) 

0.30 

(1.12) (0.82) 

0.30 

(1.00) (1.27) (0.26) 

(1.00) (1.27) (0.27) 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.06) 

-

0.06

(0.12) 

-

0.12

(0.84) 

-

0.84 

(0.84) 

-

0.84 

(0.83) 

0.03 

0.86 

(0.84) (0.27) 

0.57 

(1.06) (0.82) 

0.23 

(1.06) (0.82) 

0.24 

(1.06) (0.82) 

0.24

(1.06) (0.82) 

0.23 

(1.05) (0.82) 

0.23 

(0.95) (1.27) (0.32) 

(0.95) (1.27) (0.32) 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.08 

-

(0.08) 

0.01 

-

(0.01)

(0.74) 

-

0.74 

(0.75) 

-

0.75 

(0.73) 

0.03 

0.76 

(0.76) (0.27) 

0.49 

(1.01) (0.82) 

0.18 

(1.01) (0.82) 

0.19 

(1.01) (0.82) 

0.19

(1.01) (0.82) 

0.19 

(1.00) (0.82) 

0.18 

(0.92) (1.27) (0.35) 

(0.91) (1.27) (0.36) 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.13 

-

(0.13) 

0.06 

-

(0.06)

(0.71) 

-

0.71 

(0.71) 

-

0.71 

(0.70) 

0.03 

0.73 

(0.73) (0.27) 

0.45 

(0.99) (0.82) 

0.16 

(0.99) (0.82) 

0.17 

(0.99) (0.82) 

0.17

(0.99) (0.82) 

0.17 

(0.99) (0.82) 

0.16 

(0.90) (1.27) (0.37) 

(0.90) (1.27) (0.37) 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.17 

-

(0.17) 

0.09 

-

(0.09)

(0.68) 

-

0.68 

(0.68) 

-

0.68 

(0.67) 

0.03 

0.70 

(0.70) (0.27) 

0.43 

(0.98) (0.82) 

0.15 

(0.98) (0.82) 

0.15 

(0.98) (0.82) 

0.16

(0.98) (0.82) 

0.16 

(0.97) (0.82) 

0.15 

(0.89) (1.27) (0.38) 

(0.89) (1.27) (0.38) 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.34 

-

(0.34) 

0.26 

-

(0.26)

(0.56) 

-

0.56 

(0.56) 

-

0.56 

(0.55) 

0.03 

0.58 

(0.60) (0.27) 

0.33 

(0.91) (0.82) 

0.09 

(0.91) (0.82) 

0.09 

(0.92) (0.82) 

0.09

(0.92) (0.82) 

0.09 

(0.91) (0.82) 

0.09 

(0.85) (1.27) (0.42) 

(0.84) (1.27) (0.43) 

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.62 

-

(0.62) 

0.54 

-

(0.54)

(0.36) 

-

0.36 

(0.36) 

-

0.36 

(0.36) 

0.03 

0.39 

(0.43) (0.27) 

0.16 

(0.81) (0.82) (0.02) 

(0.81) (0.82) (0.01) 

(0.81) (0.82) (0.01) 

(0.82) (0.82) (0.01) 

(0.81) (0.82) (0.01) 

(0.77) (1.27) (0.50) 

(0.76) (1.27) (0.50) 

10B-20 
Table 10B.2.20 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrigera

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. System CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - 0.01 

 OCS - 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 

 NPV - 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.05 

1 ICS 0.00 0.01 

 OCS 0.00 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 

 NPV 0.00 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.05 

2 ICS 0.00 0.01 

 OCS 0.01 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 

 NPV 0.00 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.07 0.07 0.07 0.07 0.05 0.05 

3 ICS 0.01 0.00 0.01 

 OCS 0.01 0.04 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.06 

 NPV 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.07 0.05 0.05 

4 ICS 0.03 0.00 0.01 

 OCS 0.02 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.06 

 NPV 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.05 

10B-21 
Table 10B.2.21 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrige

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.72) (0.71) (0.71) (0.68) (0.62) (0.59) (0.48) (0.45) (0.21) (0.09) 1.20 1.97 

OCS - 2.94 2.96 2.97 3.19 3.29 3.33 3.45 3.48 3.71 3.80 3.95 4.03 

NPV - 3.66 3.67 3.68 3.87 3.91 3.93 3.93 3.93 3.92 3.89 2.75 2.06 

1 ICS 0.02 (0.71) (0.70) (0.70) (0.67) (0.61) (0.58) (0.47) (0.44) (0.20) (0.08) 1.21 1.98 

OCS 0.43 3.16 3.18 3.19 3.41 3.50 3.54 3.65 3.68 3.89 3.97 4.12 4.19 

NPV 0.41 3.88 3.89 3.90 4.08 4.12 4.13 4.13 4.12 4.09 4.06 2.91 2.21 

2 ICS 0.19 (0.64) (0.64) (0.63) (0.60) (0.55) (0.52) (0.42) (0.38) (0.16) (0.04) 1.25 2.01 

OCS 0.77 3.34 3.36 3.37 3.58 3.67 3.71 3.81 3.83 4.03 4.11 4.24 4.31 

NPV 0.58 3.98 4.00 4.00 4.19 4.22 4.23 4.23 4.22 4.19 4.15 3.00 2.30 

3 ICS 0.45 (0.53) (0.52) (0.52) (0.50) (0.45) (0.42) (0.32) (0.29) (0.08) 0.03 1.31 2.07 

OCS 0.91 3.41 3.43 3.44 3.66 3.74 3.77 3.88 3.90 4.09 4.17 4.30 4.37 

NPV 0.45 3.95 3.96 3.97 4.15 4.19 4.20 4.20 4.19 4.17 4.14 2.99 2.30 

4 ICS 0.59 (0.48) (0.47) (0.47) (0.45) (0.40) (0.38) (0.28) (0.25) (0.04) 0.07 1.34 2.10 

OCS 1.03 3.48 3.50 3.51 3.72 3.80 3.83 3.93 3.96 4.14 4.22 4.34 4.41 

NPV 0.44 3.95 3.97 3.97 4.16 4.20 4.21 4.21 4.20 4.19 4.15 3.01 2.31 

10B-22 
Table 10B.2.22 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrigera

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. System CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.35) (0.35) (0.34) (0.31) (0.28) (0.25) (0.18) (0.07) (0.04) 0.04 0.07 0.32 

OCS - 1.46 1.47 1.70 1.75 1.81 1.85 1.92 2.04 2.06 2.12 2.12 2.16 

NPV - 1.81 1.81 2.04 2.07 2.09 2.10 2.10 2.11 2.10 2.07 2.06 1.84 

1 ICS 0.01 (0.34) (0.34) (0.33) (0.31) (0.27) (0.25) (0.17) (0.07) (0.04) 0.04 0.07 0.33 

OCS 0.24 1.60 1.60 1.84 1.88 1.94 1.97 2.04 2.15 2.17 2.22 2.23 2.26 

NPV 0.22 1.94 1.94 2.17 2.19 2.21 2.22 2.21 2.21 2.21 2.18 2.16 1.93 

2 ICS 0.10 (0.30) (0.30) (0.29) (0.27) (0.23) (0.21) (0.14) (0.04) (0.01) 0.07 0.10 0.35 

OCS 0.42 1.70 1.71 1.94 1.99 2.04 2.07 2.13 2.24 2.25 2.30 2.31 2.34 

NPV 0.32 2.00 2.01 2.23 2.26 2.27 2.28 2.27 2.27 2.26 2.23 2.21 1.99 

3 ICS 0.24 (0.23) (0.23) (0.22) (0.21) (0.17) (0.15) (0.08) 0.01 0.04 0.12 0.14 0.39 

OCS 0.50 1.75 1.75 1.99 2.03 2.08 2.11 2.17 2.27 2.29 2.34 2.34 2.37 

NPV 0.26 1.98 1.99 2.21 2.24 2.26 2.26 2.26 2.26 2.25 2.22 2.20 1.98 

4 ICS 0.31 (0.20) (0.20) (0.19) (0.17) (0.14) (0.12) (0.06) 0.04 0.06 0.14 0.16 0.41 

OCS 0.57 1.79 1.79 2.03 2.07 2.12 2.14 2.21 2.30 2.32 2.37 2.37 2.40 

NPV 0.26 1.98 1.99 2.22 2.24 2.26 2.27 2.26 2.27 2.26 2.23 2.21 1.99 

10B-23 
Table 10B.2.23 Net Present Value for Medium Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrigeratio

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.11) (0.47) (0.45) (0.34) (0.03) (0.02) 0.48 0.48 0.49 0.49 0.51 0.97 

OCS - - - - 0.07 (0.55) (1.68) (1.68) (1.68) (1.68) (1.68) (1.68) (2.58) 

NPV - 0.11 0.47 0.45 0.41 (0.52) (1.66) (2.15) (2.15) (2.16) (2.17) (2.19) (3.55) 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.03 

-

(0.03) 

(0.09) 

-

0.09 

(0.45)

-

0.45

 (0.44)

-

0.44

 (0.32) 

0.07 

0.39 

(0.01)

(0.55)

(0.53) 

 (0.01) 

 (1.68)

(1.67) 

0.49 

 (1.68) 

(2.16) 

0.49

(1.68)

(2.16)

 0.50

 (1.68)

 (2.17)

 0.50 

 (1.68)  (2.18) 

0.52

(1.68)(2.20)

 0.98

 (2.58) (3.56)

 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.22

-

(0.22)

 0.09 

-

 (0.09) 

(0.32) 

-

0.32 

(0.32) 

-

0.32 

(0.21) 

0.07 

0.27 

0.09

(0.55)

(0.64)

 0.10

 (1.68) (1.77)

 0.55 

 (1.68) 

 (2.23) 

0.55

(1.68)

(2.23)

 0.56

 (1.68)

 (2.24)

 0.57 

 (1.68) 

 (2.24) 

0.58

(1.68)

(2.26)

 1.03

 (2.58)

 (3.61)

 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.53

-

(0.53)

 0.38 

-

 (0.38) 

(0.12) 

-

0.12 

(0.12) 

-

0.12 

(0.02) 

0.07 

0.08 

0.26

(0.55)

(0.80)

 0.26

 (1.68) (1.94)

 0.66 

 (1.68) 

 (2.33) 

0.66

(1.68)

(2.33)

 0.66

 (1.68)

 (2.34)

 0.67 

 (1.68) 

 (2.35) 

0.69

(1.68)

(2.36)

 1.11

 (2.58)

 (3.69)

 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.68

-

(0.68)

 0.52 

-

 (0.52) 

(0.02) 

-

0.02 

(0.03) 

-

0.03 

0.08 

0.07 

(0.01) 

0.34

(0.55)

(0.89)

 0.34

 (1.68)

 (2.02)

 0.71 

 (1.68) 

 (2.38) 

0.71

(1.68)

(2.38)

 0.72

 (1.68)

 (2.39)

 0.72 

 (1.68) 

 (2.40) 

0.74

(1.68)

(2.41)

 1.15

 (2.58)

 (3.73)

 

10B-24 
Table 10B.2.24 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Indoor Ref

a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.11)

0.15

0.25

 (0.11)

 0.15

 0.25

 (0.13) 

0.20 

0.33 

(0.13)

0.21

0.34

 (0.13)

 0.21

 0.34

 (0.13)

 0.22

 0.34

 (0.13) 

0.22 

0.34 

(0.12)

0.230.35

 (0.11)

 0.24 0.34

 (0.05) 

0.25 0.30 

0.07 

0.26 0.19 

0.15 

0.27 0.12 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.05) 

0.12 

0.17 

(0.14)

0.23

0.37

 (0.14)

 0.23

 0.37

 (0.16) 

0.27 

0.43 

(0.16)

0.28

0.44

 (0.16)

 0.28

 0.44

 (0.16) 

0.28 0.44

(0.15) 

0.29 0.44 

(0.15)

0.290.44

 (0.13)

 0.30 0.43

 (0.08) 

0.31 0.39 

0.05 

0.32 0.27 

0.12 

0.33 0.20 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.06) 

0.13 

0.20 

(0.15)

0.24

0.39

 (0.15)

 0.24

 0.39

 (0.16) 

0.28 

0.45 

(0.16)

0.29

0.45

 (0.16)

 0.29

 0.45

 (0.16) 

0.29 0.45

(0.16) 

0.30 0.45 

(0.15)

0.300.45

 (0.14)

 0.31 0.45

 (0.08) 

0.32 0.40 

0.05 

0.33 0.28 

0.12 

0.33 0.21 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.05) 

0.17 

0.22 

(0.14)

0.27

0.41

 (0.14)

 0.27

 0.41

 (0.16) 

0.30 

0.46 

(0.16)

0.31

0.47

 (0.16)

 0.31

 0.47

 (0.15) 

0.31 0.47

(0.15) 

0.32 0.47 

(0.14)

0.320.47

 (0.13)

 0.33 0.46

 (0.07) 

0.34 0.41 

0.05 

0.35 0.30 

0.12 

0.35 0.23 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01) 

0.24 

0.25 

(0.11)

0.32

0.43

 (0.11)

 0.31

 0.43

 (0.14) 

0.35 

0.48 

(0.13)

0.35

0.48

 (0.13)

 0.35

 0.48

 (0.13) 

0.35 0.49

(0.13) 

0.36 0.49 

(0.12)

0.360.48

 (0.11)

 0.36 0.48

 (0.06) 

0.37 0.43 

0.07 

0.38 0.31 

0.14 

0.38 0.24 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01) 

0.24 

0.25 

(0.11)

0.32

0.43

 (0.11)

 0.32

 0.43

 (0.13) 

0.35 

0.48 

(0.13)

0.35

0.48

 (0.13)

 0.35

 0.48

 (0.13) 

0.36 0.49

(0.13) 

0.36 0.49 

(0.12)

0.360.48

 (0.11)

 0.37 0.48

 (0.05) 

0.37 0.43 

0.07 

0.38 0.31 

0.14 

0.38 0.24 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.00 0.25 

0.25 

(0.10)

0.33

0.43

 (0.11)

 0.32

 0.43

 (0.13) 

0.35 

0.48 

(0.13)

0.36

0.49

 (0.13)

 0.36

 0.49

 (0.13)

 0.36

 0.49

 (0.12) 

0.36 0.49 

(0.12)

0.370.49

 (0.11)

 0.37 0.48

 (0.05) 

0.38 0.43 

0.07 

0.39 0.31 

0.15 

0.39 0.24 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.07 0.26 

0.19 

(0.06)

0.33

0.39

 (0.06)

 0.33

 0.39

 (0.09) 

0.36 

0.45 

(0.09)

0.36

0.46

 (0.09)

 0.36

 0.46

 (0.09)

 0.37

 0.46

 (0.09) 

0.37 0.46 

(0.08)

0.370.46

 (0.08)

 0.38 0.45

 (0.02) 

0.39 0.41 

0.10 

0.39 0.29 

0.17 

0.40 0.22 

10B-25 
Table 10B.2.25 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Indoor 

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. System CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.31)

0.60

0.91

 (0.30) 

0.60 

0.91 

(0.30)

0.61

0.91

 (0.29) 

0.77 

1.06 

(0.29)

0.80

1.08

 (0.27)

 0.83

 1.10

 (0.26) 

0.84 

1.10 

(0.22)

0.88 1.10 

 (0.18) 

0.91 1.09 

0.03 

0.980.95

0.54 

1.03 0.49 

0.84 

1.050.21

1.06 0.07 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.08

0.11

 (0.32)

 0.66

 0.98

 (0.32) 

0.66 

0.98 

(0.32)

0.66

0.98

 (0.31) 

0.82 

1.13 

(0.30)

0.85

1.14

 (0.28)

 0.88

 1.16

 (0.27) 

0.89 1.16

(0.23)

 0.93 1.16 

 (0.19) 

0.951.14

0.02 

1.02 1.00 

0.53 

1.07 0.54 

0.83 

1.09 0.26 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.15)

0.48

0.64

 (0.40)

 0.94

 1.34

 (0.40) 

0.93 

1.34 

(0.40)

0.94

1.34

 (0.38) 

1.06 

1.44 

(0.37)

1.08

1.45

 (0.35)

 1.10

 1.45

 (0.34)

 1.12 1.45

 (0.29) 

1.14 1.44 

(0.25)

1.171.41

 (0.03) 

1.22 1.25 

0.48 

1.25 0.77 

0.79 

1.27 0.49 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.11)

0.63

0.74

 (0.38)

 1.04

 1.41

 (0.38) 

1.04 

1.41 

(0.38)

1.04

1.41

 (0.35) 

1.15 

1.50 

(0.34)

1.17

1.51

 (0.33)

 1.19

 1.51

 (0.31)

 1.20 1.51

 (0.27) 

1.22 1.50 

(0.23)

1.241.47

 (0.02) 

1.29 1.30 

0.50 

1.32 0.83 

0.80 

1.34 0.54 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02)

0.88

0.90

 (0.32)

 1.21

 1.53

 (0.32) 

1.21 

1.53 

(0.32)

1.21

1.53

 (0.30) 

1.30 

1.60 

(0.30)

1.31

1.61

 (0.28)

 1.33

 1.61

 (0.27) 

1.34 1.61

(0.23)

 1.36 1.59 

 (0.19) 

1.381.56

0.02 

1.41 1.39 

0.53 

1.44 0.91 

0.84 

1.45 0.62 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.90

0.91

 (0.31)

 1.22

 1.53

 (0.31) 

1.22 

1.53 

(0.31)

1.22

1.53

 (0.30) 

1.31 

1.61 

(0.29)

1.32

1.61

 (0.27)

 1.34

 1.62

 (0.26) 

1.35 1.61

(0.23)

 1.37 1.60 

 (0.18) 

1.381.57

0.03 

1.42 1.39 

0.54 

1.45 0.91 

0.84 

1.46 0.62 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

0.93

0.91

(0.29)

 1.25

 1.54

 (0.29) 

1.24 

1.53 

(0.29)

1.25

1.53

 (0.28) 

1.33 

1.61 

(0.27)

1.35

1.62

 (0.26)

 1.36

 1.62

 (0.25) 

1.37 1.62

(0.21)

 1.39 1.60 

 (0.17) 

1.401.57

0.04 

1.44 1.40 

0.55 

1.46 0.92 

0.85 

1.48 0.63 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.24 

0.96

0.73

(0.15)

 1.27

 1.42

 (0.15) 

1.26 

1.42 

(0.15)

1.27

1.42

 (0.16) 

1.35 

1.51 

(0.16)

1.36

1.52

 (0.15)

 1.38

 1.53

 (0.14) 

1.39 1.53

(0.11)

 1.41 1.51 

 (0.07) 

1.421.49

0.13 

1.45 1.32 

0.63 

1.48 0.85 

0.93 

1.49 0.56 

10B-26 
Table 10B.2.26 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Outdoor R

at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.00)

0.01

0.02

 (0.00)

 0.02

 0.03

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.05

 (0.02) 

0.06 

0.08 

(0.03)

0.07

0.10

 (0.03)

 0.07

 0.10

 (0.03)

 0.07 

0.10 

 (0.03)

0.070.10

 (0.03)

 0.07 0.10

 (0.02) 

0.07 0.09 

(0.02) 

0.07 0.09 

(0.02) 

0.07 0.09 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.01

0.01

 (0.00)

 0.02

 0.02

 (0.01)

 0.03

 0.03

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.06

 (0.02) 

0.06 

0.08 

(0.03)

0.08

0.10

 (0.03)

 0.07

 0.10

 (0.03) 

0.07 0.10

(0.03) 

0.07 0.10

(0.03) 

0.07 0.10

(0.02) 

0.07 0.09 

(0.02) 

0.07 0.09 

(0.02) 

0.07 0.09 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.03

0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 0.05

 (0.01)

 0.05

 0.06

 (0.02)

 0.06

 0.08

 (0.02) 

0.08 

0.10 

(0.03)

0.09

0.12

 (0.03)

 0.08

 0.11

 (0.03) 

0.08 0.11

(0.03) 

0.08 0.11

(0.03) 

0.08 0.11

(0.03) 

0.08 0.10 

(0.03) 

0.08 0.10 

(0.03) 

0.08 0.10 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.04

0.05

 (0.01)

 0.05

 0.06

 (0.01)

 0.06

 0.07

 (0.02)

 0.07

 0.09

 (0.02) 

0.08 

0.11 

(0.03)

0.09

0.12

 (0.03)

 0.08

 0.11

 (0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.08 0.10 

(0.03) 

0.08 0.10 

(0.03) 

0.08 0.10 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.05

0.06

 (0.00)

 0.06

 0.07

 (0.01)

 0.07

 0.08

 (0.01)

 0.08

 0.09

 (0.02) 

0.09 

0.11 

(0.03)

0.10

0.12

 (0.03)

 0.09

 0.12

 (0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.02) 

0.08 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.08 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.08 0.11 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.06

0.06

 (0.00)

 0.07

 0.07

 (0.00)

 0.07

 0.08

 (0.01)

 0.08

 0.09

 (0.02) 

0.09 

0.11 

(0.03)

0.10

0.12

 (0.03)

 0.09

 0.12

 (0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.00 

0.06

0.06

(0.00)

 0.07

 0.07

 (0.00)

 0.07

 0.08

 (0.01)

 0.08

 0.09

 (0.02) 

0.10 

0.11 

(0.03)

0.10

0.12

 (0.03)

 0.09

 0.12

 (0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.03) 

0.09 0.12

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

0.06

0.04

0.01 

0.07 0.06

0.01 

0.08 0.07

(0.00)

 0.08

 0.09

 (0.01) 

0.10 

0.11 

(0.02)

0.10

0.12

 (0.02)

 0.09

 0.12

 (0.02)

 0.09 0.12

 (0.02)

 0.09 0.12

 (0.02)

 0.09 0.12

 (0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

(0.02) 

0.09 0.11 

10B-27 
Table 10B.2.27 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Outdoor R

at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.45)

0.54

0.99

 (0.46) 

0.53 

0.99 

(0.55)

0.74

1.29

 (0.55)

 0.76

 1.31

 (0.55) 

0.77 

1.31 

(0.54)

0.79

1.33

 (0.53)

 0.81 

1.33 

 (0.49) 

0.841.33

(0.45)

 0.87 1.32 

 (0.18) 

0.93 1.11 

0.38 

0.97 0.59 

0.71 0.99 0.28 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.07)

0.09

0.16

 (0.50)

 0.60

 1.10

 (0.50) 

0.60 

1.10 

(0.59)

0.79

1.38

 (0.58)

 0.82

 1.40

 (0.58) 

0.82 

1.40 

(0.57)

0.85

1.42

 (0.56)

 0.86 1.42

 (0.53) 

0.89 1.42 

(0.48)

0.921.40

 (0.21) 

0.97 1.19 

0.35 

1.02 0.67 

0.69 

1.04 0.35 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.16)

0.41

0.57

 (0.56)

 0.84

 1.40

 (0.56) 

0.83 

1.39 

(0.64)

0.99

1.63

 (0.63)

 1.01

 1.64

 (0.63) 

1.01 

1.64 

(0.62)

1.04

1.65

 (0.61)

 1.04 1.65

 (0.57) 

1.07 1.64 

(0.52)

1.091.62

 (0.25) 

1.14 1.39 

0.31 

1.17 0.86 

0.65 

1.19 0.54 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

0.87

0.91

 (0.49)

 1.17

 1.65

 (0.49) 

1.16 

1.64 

(0.58)

1.27

1.85

 (0.57)

 1.28

 1.85

 (0.57) 

1.28 

1.86 

(0.56)

1.30

1.86

 (0.55)

 1.31 1.86

 (0.52) 

1.33 1.84 

(0.47)

1.341.81

 (0.20) 

1.37 1.58 

0.36 

1.40 1.04 

0.69 

1.41 0.72 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.00)

0.95

0.96

 (0.46)

 1.23

 1.68

 (0.46) 

1.22 

1.67 

(0.55)

1.32

1.87

 (0.55)

 1.33

 1.88

 (0.55) 

1.33 

1.88 

(0.54)

1.35

1.89

 (0.53)

 1.35 1.88

 (0.50) 

1.37 1.87 

(0.45)

1.381.84

 (0.19) 

1.41 1.60 

0.37 

1.44 1.06 

0.71 

1.45 0.74 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.04 

1.05

1.01

(0.43)

 1.30

 1.72

 (0.43) 

1.29 

1.71 

(0.53)

1.38

1.91

 (0.53)

 1.39

 1.92

 (0.53) 

1.39 

1.92 

(0.51)

1.40

1.92

 (0.51)

 1.41 1.92

 (0.47) 

1.43 1.90 

(0.43)

1.441.87

 (0.17) 

1.46 1.63 

0.39 

1.49 1.09 

0.73 

1.50 0.77 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.07 

1.11

1.04

(0.40)

 1.34

 1.75

 (0.41) 

1.33 

1.74 

(0.51)

1.42

1.93

 (0.51)

 1.43

 1.94

 (0.51) 

1.43 

1.94 

(0.50)

1.44

1.94

 (0.49)

 1.45 1.94

 (0.46) 

1.46 1.92 

(0.41)

1.471.89

 (0.15) 

1.50 1.65 

0.41 

1.52 1.11 

0.74 

1.53 0.79 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.23 

1.33

1.10

(0.30)

 1.49

 1.79

 (0.30) 

1.48 

1.78 

(0.42)

1.55

1.97

 (0.42)

 1.55

 1.98

 (0.42) 

1.56 

1.98 

(0.42)

1.56

1.98

 (0.41)

 1.57 1.98

 (0.38) 

1.58 1.96 

(0.34)

1.591.93

 (0.08) 

1.61 1.69 

0.47 

1.62 1.15 

0.80 

1.63 0.82 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.24 

1.33

1.10

(0.29)

 1.50

 1.79

 (0.29) 

1.49 

1.78 

(0.42)

1.55

1.97

 (0.42)

 1.56

 1.98

 (0.42) 

1.56 

1.98 

(0.41)

1.57

1.98

 (0.41)

 1.57 1.98

 (0.38) 

1.58 1.96 

(0.34)

1.591.93

 (0.08) 

1.61 1.69 

0.48 

1.62 1.15 

0.81 

1.63 0.82 

10B-28 
Table 10B.2.28 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoo

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(1.43)

2.49

3.93

 (1.43) 

2.49 

3.92 

(1.43)

2.50

3.94

 (1.39) 

3.19 

4.58 

(1.36)

3.30

4.66

 (1.29)

 3.43

 4.72

 (1.24) 

3.49 

4.73 

(1.08)

3.65 

4.73

 (0.88) 

3.77 

4.65 

0.06 

4.04

3.98 

2.38 

4.24 1.87 

3.76 

4.35

0.59 

4.40 (

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.15)

0.34

0.50

 (1.53)

 2.73

 4.27

 (1.53) 

2.73 

4.26 

(1.53)

2.74

4.27

 (1.48) 

3.39 

4.87 

(1.44)

3.50

4.94

 (1.37)

 3.62

 4.99

 (1.32)

 3.68 5.00

 (1.15) 

3.83 4.99 

(0.95)

3.954.90

 (0.00) 

4.21 4.21 

2.32 

4.41 2.09 

3.70 

4.51 0.81 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.40)

1.15

1.55

 (1.70)

 3.29

 4.98

 (1.69) 

3.28 

4.97 

(1.69)

3.29

4.98

 (1.61) 

3.88 

5.49 

(1.57)

3.97

5.54

 (1.50)

 4.08

 5.58

 (1.44)

 4.13 5.58

 (1.27) 

4.27 5.54 

(1.07)

4.375.44

 (0.11) 

4.60 4.71 

2.22 

4.78 2.56 

3.61 

4.87 1.27 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.54)

2.28

2.82

 (1.78)

 4.07

 5.85

 (1.78) 

4.05 

5.83 

(1.78)

4.07

5.85

 (1.68) 

4.55 

6.24 

(1.65)

4.63

6.28

 (1.57)

 4.73

 6.29

 (1.51)

 4.77 6.28

 (1.33) 

4.88 6.22 

(1.13)

4.976.10

 (0.17) 

5.16 5.33 

2.17 

5.31 3.15 

3.56 

5.39 1.83 

4

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.28)

3.86

4.14

 (1.62)

 5.15

 6.77

 (1.61) 

5.14 

6.75 

(1.61)

5.15

6.76

 (1.55) 

5.50 

7.05 

(1.51)

5.56

7.07

 (1.44)

 5.63

 7.06

 (1.38)

 5.66 7.04

 (1.21) 

5.74 6.95 

(1.01)

5.806.81

 (0.06) 

5.94 6.00 

2.27 

6.05 3.78 

3.65 

6.11 2.45 

4

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.10 

4.99

4.88

(1.37)

 5.93

 7.30

 (1.37) 

5.91 

7.28 

(1.37)

5.92

7.29

 (1.34) 

6.18 

7.51 

(1.31)

6.22

7.53

 (1.24)

 6.27

 7.51

 (1.19) 

6.29 7.48

(1.03)

 6.35 7.38 

 (0.83) 

6.407.23

0.10 

6.50 6.40 

2.42 

6.58 4.16 

3.80 

6.62 2.82 

4

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.28 

5.39

5.11

(1.25)

 6.21

 7.46

 (1.25) 

6.19 

7.44 

(1.25)

6.20

7.45

 (1.24) 

6.42 

7.66 

(1.21)

6.46

7.67

 (1.15)

 6.50

 7.65

 (1.10) 

6.52 7.62

(0.94)

 6.57 7.51 

 (0.75) 

6.617.36

0.18 

6.70 6.52 

2.49 

6.77 4.28 

3.87 

6.80 2.94 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.33 

5.44

5.11

(1.22)

 6.25

 7.46

 (1.22) 

6.23 

7.44 

(1.22)

6.23

7.45

 (1.21) 

6.45 

7.66 

(1.18)

6.49

7.67

 (1.12)

 6.53

 7.65

 (1.08) 

6.55 7.62

(0.92)

 6.60 7.52 

 (0.73) 

6.647.37

0.20 

6.73 6.52 

2.51 

6.79 4.29 

3.88 

6.83 2.94 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.47 

5.56

5.08

(1.13)

 6.33

 7.45

 (1.12) 

6.31 

7.43 

(1.13)

6.31

7.44

 (1.13) 

6.52 

7.65 

(1.11)

6.56

7.66

 (1.05)

 6.60

 7.64

 (1.00) 

6.61 7.62

(0.85)

 6.66 7.51 

 (0.66) 

6.707.36

0.26 

6.78 6.52 

2.56 

6.85 4.28 

3.94 

6.88 2.94 

10B-29 
Table 10B.2.29 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoor R

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(1.67)

3.14

4.81

 (1.66)

 3.13

 4.79

 (1.67)

 3.16

 4.83

 (1.59)

 3.35

 4.95

 (1.45)

 3.59

 5.03

 (0.79)

 4.39

 5.18

 (0.67)

 4.52 

5.19

 (0.58)

4.56

 5.14

 (0.25) 

4.85 5.10

0.13 

5.06 4.93

0.20 

5.09 

4.89 

1.23 

5.40 

4.17 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.26)

0.62

0.87

 (1.86)

 3.62

 5.49

 (1.86)

 3.61

 5.47

 (1.86)

 3.64

 5.50

 (1.78)

 3.82

 5.61

 (1.63)

 4.05

 5.68

 (0.96)

 4.82

 5.77

 (0.83)

 4.94 5.78 

 (0.74)

 4.98

5.73

 (0.41)

 5.26

 5.67

 (0.02) 

5.46 5.48

0.04 

5.48 

5.44 

1.09 

5.79 

4.70 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.67)

2.06

2.73

 (2.18)

 4.75

 6.93

 (2.16)

 4.74

 6.90

 (2.17)

 4.76

 6.93

 (2.08)

 4.93

 7.01

 (1.93)

 5.13

 7.05

 (1.22)

 5.82

 7.04

 (1.10)

 5.93 7.03 

 (1.01)

 5.96

6.97

 (0.66)

 6.21 6.87

 (0.27)

 6.39 6.66

 (0.20) 

6.41 6.62 

0.85 6.68 

5.83 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.89)

4.09

4.98

 (2.35)

 6.34

 8.68

 (2.34)

 6.31

 8.65

 (2.34)

 6.33

 8.67

 (2.25)

 6.47

 8.72

 (2.09)

 6.64

 8.73

 (1.37)

 7.22

 8.59

 (1.24)

 7.31 8.55 

 (1.15)

 7.34

8.49

 (0.80)

 7.55 8.35

 (0.41)

 7.70 8.11

 (0.34) 

7.72 8.06 

0.72 7.94 

7.22 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.47)

6.92

7.38 

 (2.03)

 8.55

10.57

 (2.02)

 8.51

 10.53

 (2.02)

 8.53

 10.55

 (1.94)

 8.63

 10.57

 (1.78)

 8.75

 10.53

 (1.09)

 9.17

 10.27

 (0.97)

 9.24

 10.21 

 (0.88)

 9.27

10.15 

 (0.54)

 9.42

9.95

 (0.15)

 9.52

 9.68

 (0.08) 

9.54 

9.62 

0.96 9.70 

8.74 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.17 8.94 

8.77 

(1.54)

10.13

11.67

 (1.53)

 10.09

 11.62

 (1.54)

 10.10

 11.64

 (1.47)

 10.17 11.64

 (1.33)

 10.26

 11.59

 (0.68)

 10.57

 11.25

 (0.56)

 10.62

 11.18

 (0.47)

 10.64

 11.11

 (0.14) 

10.75 10.90

0.23 

10.83 10.60

0.30 

10.84 

10.54 

1.33 

10.96 

9.63 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.47 

9.67 

9.20 

(1.31)

10.70

12.01

 (1.31)

 10.66

 11.96

 (1.31)

 10.67

 11.98

 (1.25)

 10.73 11.98

 (1.11)

 10.81

 11.91

 (0.48)

 11.07

 11.55

 (0.36)

 11.12

 11.48

 (0.27) 

11.14 1.41

0.04 

11.23 11.19

0.42 

11.30 1.89

0.48 

11.31 

10.83 

1.51 

11.41 

9.91 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.55 

9.76 

9.20 

(1.25)

10.77

12.02

 (1.25)

 10.72

 11.97

 (1.25)

 10.73

 11.99

 (1.19)

 10.80 11.98

 (1.05)

 10.87

 11.92

 (0.43)

 11.13

 11.56

 (0.31)

 11.17

 11.49

 (0.22) 

11.20 11.42

0.09 

11.29 11.20

0.46 

11.36 10.89

0.53 

11.37 

10.84 

1.55 

11.47 

9.92 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.79 

9.97 

9.18 

(1.07)

10.93

12.01

 (1.07)

 10.89

 11.96

 (1.07)

 10.90

 11.97

 (1.01)

 10.96 11.97

 (0.88)

 11.03

 11.91

 (0.27)

 11.28

 11.55

 (0.16)

 11.32

 11.48

 (0.07) 

11.34 11.41

0.24 

11.43 11.19

0.61 

11.49 10.89

0.67 

11.50 

10.83 

1.69 

11.60 

9.91 

10B-30 
Table 10B.2.30 Net Present Value for Large Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refri

3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.01)

0.06

0.07

 (0.02) 

0.10 

0.12 

(0.06)

0.17

0.23

 (0.09) 

0.26 

0.35 

(0.13)

0.31

0.43

 (0.13)

 0.28

 0.42

 (0.13) 

0.29 

0.42 

(0.13)

0.290.42

 (0.13) 

0.29 0.42 

(0.11)

0.270.38

 (0.11) 

0.27 0.38 

(0.11)

0.270.38

 

  

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.01)

0.02

0.03

 (0.02)

 0.08

 0.10

 (0.03) 

0.12 

0.15 

(0.07)

0.18

0.25

 (0.10) 

0.27 

0.36 

(0.13)

0.32

0.45

 (0.14)

 0.29

 0.43

 (0.13) 

0.30 0.43 

(0.13)

0.300.43

 (0.13) 

0.30 0.43 

(0.12)

0.270.39

 (0.12) 

0.27 0.39 

(0.12)

0.280.39

 

  

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

0.07

0.10

 (0.04)

 0.12

 0.16

 (0.04) 

0.16 

0.21 

(0.08)

0.22

0.30

 (0.10) 

0.30 

0.40 

(0.14)

0.34

0.47

 (0.14)

 0.31

 0.45

 (0.14) 

0.32 0.46 

(0.14)

0.320.46

 (0.14) 

0.32 0.46 

(0.12)

0.290.41

 (0.12) 

0.29 0.41 

(0.12)

0.290.41

 

  

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

0.14

0.18

 (0.05)

 0.19

 0.24

 (0.05) 

0.23 

0.28 

(0.09)

0.27

0.36

 (0.11) 

0.34 

0.45 

(0.14)

0.37

0.51

 (0.14)

 0.34

 0.49

 (0.14) 

0.35 0.49 

(0.14)

0.350.49

 (0.14) 

0.35 0.49 

(0.12)

0.320.44

 (0.12) 

0.32 0.44 

(0.12)

0.320.44

 

  

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.02)

0.24

0.26

 (0.03)

 0.28

 0.31

 (0.04) 

0.31 

0.35 

(0.07)

0.35

0.42

 (0.10) 

0.40 

0.50 

(0.13)

0.41

0.54

 (0.14)

 0.38

 0.52

 (0.14) 

0.39 0.52 

(0.14)

0.390.52

 (0.13) 

0.39 0.52 

(0.12)

0.350.47

 (0.12) 

0.35 0.47 

(0.12)

0.350.47

 

  

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.31

0.30

(0.01)

 0.35

 0.36

 (0.01) 

0.38 

0.39 

(0.05)

0.40

0.46

 (0.09) 

0.44 

0.53 

(0.13)

0.44

0.57

 (0.13)

 0.41

 0.54

 (0.13) 

0.42 0.54 

(0.13)

0.420.54

 (0.13) 

0.42 0.54 

(0.11)

0.370.49

 (0.11) 

0.37 0.49 

(0.11)

0.370.49

 

  

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

0.33

0.31

0.00 

0.37 0.37

(0.00) 

0.40 

0.40 

(0.05)

0.42

0.47

 (0.08) 

0.46 

0.54 

(0.12)

0.45

0.57

 (0.13)

 0.42

 0.55

 (0.12) 

0.43 0.55 

(0.12)

0.430.55

 (0.12) 

0.43 0.55 

(0.11)

0.380.49

 (0.11) 

0.38 0.49 

(0.11)

0.380.49

 

  

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.02 

0.33

0.31

0.01 

0.37 0.37

0.00 

0.40 

0.40 

(0.04)

0.42

0.47

 (0.08) 

0.46 

0.54 

(0.12)

0.45

0.57

 (0.13)

 0.42

 0.55

 (0.12) 

0.43 0.55 

(0.12)

0.430.55

 (0.12) 

0.43 0.55 

(0.11)

0.380.49

 (0.11) 

0.38 0.49 

(0.11)

0.380.49

 

  

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.03 

0.34

0.31

0.01 

0.38 0.37

0.01 

0.41 

0.40 

(0.04)

0.43

0.47

 (0.07) 

0.46 

0.54 

(0.12)

0.46

0.57

 (0.12)

 0.43

 0.55

 (0.12) 

0.43 0.55 

(0.12)

0.430.55

 (0.12) 

0.43 0.55 

(0.11)

0.390.49

 (0.11) 

0.39 0.49 

(0.11)

0.390.49

 

  

10B-31 
Table 10B.2.31 Net Present Value for Large Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refri

3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.17)

0.72

0.89

 (0.72)

 1.75

 2.47

 (0.67)

 2.27

 2.94

 (1.52)

 5.00

 6.51 

 (2.51) 

7.65 10.17 

(2.51)

7.66

10.17 

 (2.51) 

7.67 10.18 

(2.40)

7.81

10.20

 (1.86)

 8.69

 10.55

 (1.84)

 8.71

 10.55

 (1.82) 

8.73 

10.55 

(1.79)

8.75

10.54

 

 

 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.23)

0.53

0.77

 (0.40)

 1.24

 1.64

 (0.92)

 2.23

 3.15

 (0.87)

 2.73

 3.61

 (1.66)

 5.36

 7.02 

 (2.60) 

7.90 10.50 

(2.60)

7.91

10.51 

 (2.59)

 7.92

10.51

 (2.48)

 8.05

 10.53

 (1.92)

 8.89

 10.81

 (1.91)

 8.91

 10.82

 (1.88) 

8.93 

10.81 

(1.85)

8.95

10.80

 

 

 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.61)

1.78

2.39

 (0.76)

 2.46

 3.22

 (1.25)

 3.34

 4.59

 (1.19)

 3.82

 5.02

 (1.89)

 6.20

 8.09 

 (2.73) 

8.49 11.22 

(2.74)

8.49

11.22 

 (2.73)

 8.50

11.23

 (2.61)

 8.61

 11.23

 (2.02)

 9.37

 11.39

 (2.00)

 9.39

 11.39

 (1.98) 

9.40 

11.39 

(1.94)

9.43

11.37

 

 

 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.82)

3.54

4.35

 (0.96)

 4.17

 5.13

 (1.43)

 4.91

 6.34

 (1.37)

 5.35

 6.72

 (2.02)

 7.38

 9.40 

 (2.81) 

9.30 12.11 

(2.81)

9.30

12.11 

 (2.80)

 9.32 

12.12

 (2.68)

9.41 

12.09

 (2.08)

10.04

 12.12

 (2.06)

 10.06

 12.11

 (2.04) 

10.07 

12.11 

(2.00)

10.09

12.09

 

 

 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.43)

5.98

6.41

 (0.58)

 6.55

 7.13

 (1.09)

 7.09

 8.18

 (1.04)

 7.49 8.53 

 (1.78)

 9.03 

10.81 

 (2.67) 

10.44 

13.11 

(2.67)

10.44

13.11 

 (2.66)

 10.45

13.11

 (2.55)

 10.52

 13.07

 (1.97)

 10.98

 12.95

 (1.96)

 10.99

 12.94

 (1.93) 

11.00 

12.93 

(1.90)

11.01

12.91

 

 

 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.16 

7.74

7.58

(0.02)

 8.26

 8.28

 (0.59)

 8.65

 9.23

 (0.54)

 9.02 9.56 

 (1.42)

10.21 

11.63 

 (2.46) 

11.26 

13.71 

(2.46)

11.26

13.72 

 (2.45)

 11.26

13.71

 (2.34)

 11.31

 13.66

 (1.82)

 11.65

 13.47

 (1.80)

 11.66

 13.46

 (1.78) 

11.66 

13.45 

(1.75)

11.67

13.42

 

 

 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.43 

8.37

7.93

0.25 

8.87 8.62

(0.34)

 9.21

 9.55

 (0.31)

 9.57 9.88 

 (1.25)

10.64 

11.89 

 (2.36) 

11.55 

13.91 

(2.36)

11.55

13.91 

 (2.35) 

11.5613.91

(2.25)

 11.60

 13.85

 (1.75)

 11.89

 13.64

 (1.73)

 11.90

 13.63

 (1.71) 

11.90 

13.61 

(1.68)

11.91

13.59

 

 

 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.50 

8.44

7.94

0.32 

8.94 8.62

(0.28)

 9.28

 9.56

 (0.25)

 9.63 9.88 

 (1.21)

10.69 

11.90 

 (2.33) 

11.58 

13.92 

(2.33)

11.59

13.92 

 (2.32) 

11.5913.92

(2.22)

 11.63

 13.86

 (1.73)

 11.92

 13.64

 (1.71)

 11.92

 13.64

 (1.69) 

11.93 

13.62 

(1.66)

11.94

13.60

 

 

 

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.72 

8.62

7.90

0.53 

9.12 8.59

(0.09)

 9.44

 9.53

 (0.06)

 9.79 9.85 

 (1.08)

10.81 

11.89 

 (2.25) 

11.67 

13.92 

(2.25)

11.67

13.92 

 (2.25) 

11.6813.92

(2.15)

 11.72

 13.86

 (1.67)

 11.99

 13.66

 (1.65)

 11.99

 13.65

 (1.64) 

12.00 

13.64 

(1.60)

12.01

13.61

 

 

 

10B-32 
Table 10B.2.32 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Cooler with Small Multiplex System Refrigerat

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) (0.02) (0.01) (0.01) 0.02 0.08 0.11 

OCS - 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 

NPV - 0.04 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.04 0.02 (0.03) (0.06) 

1 ICS 

OCS 

0.00 

0.01

(0.02)

 0.03

 (0.02)

 0.03

 (0.02)

 0.04 

 (0.02) 

0.04

(0.02)

 0.04

 (0.02)

 0.04

 (0.02)

 0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 (0.01) 

0.04 

0.02 

0.04 

0.08 

0.05

0.11 

0.05

0.0

NPV 0.01 0.05 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.02 (0.03) (0.06) 

2 ICS 

OCS 

0.00 

0.01

(0.02)

 0.03

 (0.02)

 0.03

 (0.02)

 0.04 

 (0.02) 

0.04

(0.02)

 0.04

 (0.02)

 0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 (0.01)

 0.04

 (0.00) 

0.04 

0.02 

0.04 

0.08 

0.05

0.11 

0.05

0.0

NPV 0.01 0.05 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.02 (0.03) (0.06) 

3 ICS 

OCS 

0.03

0.03

 0.00

 0.04

 0.00 

0.04

(0.00) 

0.05 

(0.00) 

0.05

(0.00) 

0.05

0.00

 0.05

 0.00

 0.05

 0.01

 0.05

 0.01 

0.05 

0.04 

0.05 

0.09

0.05

 0.12

 0.06

 

 

NPV (0.01) 0.04 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.04 0.02 (0.03) (0.06) 

10B-33 
Table 10B.2.33 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Refrige

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 

0 ICS - (1.06) (1.04) (1.03) (0.37) (0.21) 0.05 0.20 0.70 1.22 3.47 8.62 11.68 13.2

OCS - 2.28 2.26 2.28 2.90 3.00 3.12 3.17 3.32 3.43 3.68 3.87 3.97 4.0

NPV - 3.34 3.30 3.30 3.27 3.21 3.07 2.97 2.63 2.21 0.21 (4.75) (7.71) (9.24

1 ICS 

OCS 

0.04 

0.51 

(1.03)

2.64

 (1.01) 

2.62 

(1.00)

2.63

 (0.34) 

3.21 

(0.18) 

3.30 

0.07 

3.41 

0.23

3.46 0.72 3.60 

1.24 

3.70 

3.49 

3.93 

8.64 

4.11

11.70 

4.20 

13.2

4.24

NPV 0.47 3.67 3.62 3.63 3.55 3.49 3.34 3.24 2.88 2.46 0.44 (4.53) (7.50) (9.03

2 ICS 

OCS 

0.12 

0.68 

(0.98)

2.75

 (0.96) 

2.73 

(0.95)

2.74

 (0.30) 

3.31 

(0.14) 

3.40 

0.11 

3.51 

0.27

3.56 0.75 3.69 

1.27 

3.79 

3.52 

4.02 

8.67 

4.19

11.73 

4.28 

13.3

4.32

NPV 0.56 3.73 3.69 3.69 3.61 3.54 3.40 3.29 2.94 2.52 0.49 (4.48) (7.45) (8.98

3 ICS 

OCS 

0.90 

2.11 

(0.47) 

3.74

(0.45) 

3.71 

(0.44) 

3.72

0.13 

4.17 

0.27 

4.24 

0.51 

4.33 

0.66 

4.36 

1.13 

4.47 

1.63 4.55 

3.85 4.72 

8.97 4.86

12.02 

4.93 

13.5

4.96

NPV 1.21 4.22 4.17 4.17 4.04 3.97 3.81 3.71 3.34 2.91 0.87 (4.11) (7.09) (8.62

10B-34 
Table 10B.2.34 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Refrigerat

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 

0 ICS - (0.56) (0.53) (0.53) (0.39) (0.17) 0.73 0.89 0.99 1.40 1.84 1.91 3.02 4.3

OCS - 1.29 1.27 1.28 1.36 1.45 1.78 1.84 1.86 1.97 2.06 2.07 2.20 2.2

NPV - 1.85 1.80 1.81 1.75 1.63 1.05 0.94 0.87 0.57 0.22 0.16 (0.82) (2.0

1 ICS 

OCS 

0.03 

0.41 

(0.54)

1.61

 (0.51)

 1.59

 (0.51)

 1.60

 (0.37)

 1.67

 (0.15) 

1.76 

0.75 

2.07 

0.92

2.12 1.012.14 1.42 2.25 

1.86 

2.33

1.93

 2.34

 3.04

 2.46

 4.3

 2.5

NPV 0.38 2.14 2.10 2.10 2.04 1.91 1.31 1.20 1.13 0.82 0.47 0.40 (0.58) (1.8

2 ICS 

OCS 

0.09 

0.55 

(0.49)

1.71

 (0.47)

 1.69

 (0.46)

 1.70

 (0.33)

 1.77

 (0.11) 

1.86 

0.79 

2.16 

0.95

2.21 1.052.23 1.46 2.34 

1.89 

2.41

1.97

 2.42

 3.07

 2.54

 4.3

 2.6

NPV 0.46 2.21 2.16 2.17 2.10 1.97 1.37 1.26 1.18 0.88 0.52 0.46 (0.53) (1.7

3 ICS 

OCS 

0.67 

1.70 

(0.05)

2.61

 (0.03)

 2.59

 (0.03) 

2.59

0.10 

2.65

0.31 

2.72 

1.17 

2.95 

1.33 

2.99 

1.42 

3.01 

1.82 

3.09 

2.24

3.15

 2.31

 3.16

 3.40

 3.25

 4.7

 3.3

NPV 1.02 2.66 2.61 2.62 2.55 2.41 1.78 1.67 1.59 1.28 0.91 0.85 (0.15) (1.4

10B-35 
Table 10B.2.35 Net Present Value for Medium Display Cooler with Large Multiplex System Refrigeration 

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.27) (0.31) (0.63) (0.35) (0.09) (0.06) (0.01) 0.00 0.01 0.03 1.50 1.52 

OCS - 2.75 4.10 5.70 6.71 10.17 11.20 9.46 9.48 9.48 9.50 7.37 7.38 

NPV - 3.02 4.41 6.33 7.06 10.26 11.25 9.48 9.48 9.48 9.47 5.87 5.86 

1 ICS 0.06 (0.22) (0.25) (0.58) (0.30) (0.06) (0.04) 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.05 1.52 1.53 

OCS 1.13 3.82 5.13 6.62 7.61 10.86 11.67 9.92 9.94 9.94 9.95 7.75 7.76 

NPV 1.07 4.03 5.39 7.20 7.91 10.92 11.70 9.92 9.91 9.91 9.90 6.23 6.22 

2 ICS 0.16 (0.12) (0.16) (0.50) (0.22) (0.00) (0.00) 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.08 1.54 1.56 

OCS 1.49 4.16 5.47 6.92 7.90 11.08 11.82 10.07 10.08 10.09 10.10 7.87 7.88 

NPV 1.33 4.29 5.63 7.42 8.12 11.08 11.82 10.03 10.03 10.03 10.02 6.33 6.32 

3 ICS 1.18 0.83 0.76 0.31 0.56 0.58 0.34 0.37 0.38 0.39 0.41 1.79 1.80 

OCS 4.63 7.12 8.34 9.48 10.39 13.00 13.14 11.35 11.36 11.36 11.37 8.94 8.94 

NPV 3.46 6.29 7.58 9.17 9.83 12.43 12.79 10.98 10.98 10.97 10.96 7.15 7.14 

10B-36 
Table 10B.2.36 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Indoor R

at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.27)

0.56

0.83

 (0.27) 

0.56 0.84

(0.28) 

0.59 

0.87 

(0.28)

0.61

0.89

 (0.28) 

0.61 0.89

(0.29) 

0.61 

0.90 

(0.29) 

0.63 

0.92 

(0.29)

0.640.93

 (0.29) 

0.65 0.94 

(0.30)

0.700.99

 (0.25) 

0.72 0.97

(0.21) 

0.74 0.95 

(

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03) 

0.08 

0.11 

(0.29)

0.60

0.89

 (0.29) 

0.60 0.89

(0.29) 

0.63 

0.92 

(0.30)

0.64

0.94

 (0.30) 

0.65 0.94

(0.30) 

0.65 

0.95 

(0.30)

0.670.97

 (0.30)

 0.67 0.97

 (0.30) 

0.68 0.99 

(0.31)

0.731.03

 (0.25) 

0.75 1.01

(0.22) 

0.76 0.99 

(

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08) 

0.21 

0.29 

(0.31)

0.66

0.97

 (0.31) 

0.67 0.98

(0.31) 

0.69 

1.01 

(0.32)

0.71

1.02

 (0.32) 

0.71 1.02

(0.32) 

0.71 

1.03 

(0.32)

0.731.05

 (0.32)

 0.73 1.05

 (0.32) 

0.74 1.06 

(0.32)

0.781.10

 (0.27) 

0.80 1.07

(0.24) 

0.81 1.05 

(

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.09) 

0.35 

0.44 

(0.31)

0.73

1.05

 (0.32) 

0.74 1.05

(0.32) 

0.76 

1.08 

(0.32)

0.77

1.09

 (0.32) 

0.77 1.09

(0.32) 

0.78 

1.10 

(0.32)

0.791.11

 (0.32)

 0.79 1.11

 (0.32) 

0.80 1.12 

(0.32)

0.831.16

 (0.27) 

0.85 1.12

(0.24) 

0.86 1.10 

(

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08) 

0.42 

0.50 

(0.31)

0.77

1.08

 (0.31) 

0.78 1.09

(0.31) 

0.80 

1.11 

(0.32)

0.81

1.12

 (0.32) 

0.81 1.12

(0.32) 

0.81 

1.13 

(0.32)

0.821.14

 (0.32)

 0.83 1.14

 (0.32) 

0.83 1.15 

(0.32)

0.861.18

 (0.27) 

0.88 1.15

(0.24) 

0.89 1.12 

(

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.08) 

0.44 

0.52 

(0.31)

0.78

1.09

 (0.31) 

0.79 1.09

(0.31) 

0.81 

1.12 

(0.31)

0.82

1.13

 (0.31) 

0.82 1.13

(0.31) 

0.82 

1.14 

(0.32)

0.831.15

 (0.32)

 0.84 1.15

 (0.32) 

0.84 1.16 

(0.32)

0.871.19

 (0.27) 

0.89 1.15

(0.23) 

0.89 1.13 

(

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.07) 

0.45 

0.53 

(0.31)

0.79

1.09

 (0.31) 

0.79 1.10

(0.31) 

0.81 

1.12 

(0.31)

0.82

1.13

 (0.31) 

0.82 1.14

(0.31) 

0.83 

1.14 

(0.32)

0.841.15

 (0.32)

 0.84 1.16

 (0.32) 

0.85 1.16 

(0.32)

0.871.19

 (0.26) 

0.89 1.15

(0.23) 

0.90 1.13 

(

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04) 

0.48 

0.52 

(0.29)

0.80

1.09

 (0.29) 

0.81 1.10

(0.30) 

0.83 

1.12 

(0.30)

0.84

1.14

 (0.30) 

0.84 1.14

(0.30) 

0.84 

1.14 

(0.30)

0.851.15

 (0.30)

 0.85 1.16

 (0.30) 

0.86 1.17 

(0.31)

0.891.19

 (0.26) 

0.90 1.16

(0.23) 

0.91 1.13 

(

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.01 

0.52 

0.51 

(0.27)

0.82

1.09

 (0.27) 

0.83 1.10

(0.27) 

0.85 

1.12 

(0.28)

0.86

1.13

 (0.28) 

0.86 1.14

(0.28) 

0.86 

1.14 

(0.28)

0.871.15

 (0.28)

 0.87 1.16

 (0.29) 

0.88 1.16 

(0.29)

0.901.19

 (0.24) 

0.92 1.16

(0.21) 

0.92 1.14 

(

10B-37 
Table 10B.2.37 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Indoor 

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.59)

1.90

2.49

 (0.59) 

1.91 

2.50 

(0.59)

1.92

2.50

 (0.59)

 2.01

 2.61

 (0.60) 

2.08 

2.68 

(0.60)

2.10

2.70

 (0.60) 

2.18 

2.78 

(0.59) 

2.20 2.79 

(0.59) 

2.36 2.95 

(0.58)

2.423.00

 (0.36) 

2.51 2.87 

(0.22)

2.572.79

  

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.07)

0.21

0.27

 (0.61)

 2.00

 2.62

 (0.61) 

2.01 

2.63 

(0.61)

2.02

2.63

 (0.62)

 2.11

 2.73

 (0.62) 

2.17 

2.80 

(0.62)

2.20

2.82

 (0.62) 

2.27 2.89 

(0.62) 

2.29 2.90 

(0.61) 

2.44 3.05 

(0.60) 

2.493.09

(0.37) 

2.58 2.96 

(0.24) 

2.632.87

2 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.15)

0.76

0.91

 (0.65)

 2.27

 2.92

 (0.65) 

2.28 

2.93 

(0.65)

2.29

2.94

 (0.65)

 2.38

 3.03

 (0.65) 

2.43 

3.08 

(0.65)

2.45

3.10

 (0.65) 

2.51 3.16 

(0.64) 

2.52 3.17 

(0.63) 

2.65 3.28 

(0.62) 

2.693.31

(0.39) 

2.77 3.16 

(0.25) 

2.813.07

2 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.11)

1.14

1.25

 (0.63)

 2.46

 3.09

 (0.63) 

2.47 

3.10 

(0.63)

2.47

3.11

 (0.64)

 2.56

 3.19

 (0.64) 

2.60 

3.24 

(0.64)

2.62

3.26

 (0.63) 

2.67 3.31 

(0.63) 

2.68 3.32 

(0.62) 

2.79 3.42 

(0.61) 

2.833.44

(0.38) 

2.90 3.28 

(0.25) 

2.943.18

2 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.06)

1.45

1.51

 (0.61)

 2.61

 3.23

 (0.61) 

2.62 

3.23 

(0.61)

2.62

3.24

 (0.62)

 2.70

 3.32

 (0.62) 

2.74 

3.36 

(0.62)

2.76

3.38

 (0.62) 

2.80 3.42 

(0.62) 

2.82 3.43 

(0.61) 

2.91 3.52 

(0.60) 

2.943.54

(0.37) 

3.00 3.38 

(0.23) 

3.043.27

3 

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.04)

1.52

1.56

 (0.60)

 2.65

 3.25

 (0.60) 

2.65 

3.26 

(0.61)

2.66

3.26

 (0.61)

 2.73

 3.35

 (0.61) 

2.77 

3.39 

(0.61)

2.79

3.40

 (0.61) 

2.83 3.45 

(0.61) 

2.84 3.45 

(0.60) 

2.93 3.54 

(0.59) 

2.973.56

(0.37) 

3.03 3.39 

(0.23) 

3.063.29

3 

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.03)

1.56

1.59

 (0.60)

 2.66

 3.26

 (0.60) 

2.67 

3.27 

(0.60)

2.68

3.28

 (0.61)

 2.75

 3.36

 (0.61) 

2.79 

3.40 

(0.61)

2.80

3.41

 (0.61) 

2.85 3.46 

(0.60) 

2.86 3.46 

(0.60) 

2.95 3.55 

(0.59) 

2.983.57

(0.36) 

3.04 3.40 

(0.23) 

3.073.30

3 

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.03 

1.66

1.63

(0.57)

 2.71

 3.29

 (0.57) 

2.72 

3.29 

(0.57)

2.72

3.30

 (0.58)

 2.80

 3.38

 (0.59) 

2.83 

3.42 

(0.59)

2.85

3.44

 (0.59) 

2.89 3.48 

(0.58) 

2.90 3.49 

(0.58) 

2.99 3.57 

(0.57)

3.023.59

 (0.35) 

3.07 3.42 

(0.21)

3.103.32

  

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.13 

1.78

1.65

(0.53)

 2.77

 3.30

 (0.53) 

2.78 

3.31 

(0.53)

2.78

3.32

 (0.54)

 2.86

 3.40

 (0.55) 

2.89 

3.44 

(0.55)

2.90

3.45

 (0.55) 

2.94 3.50 

(0.55) 

2.95 3.50 

(0.55) 

3.03 3.59 

(0.55) 

3.063.61

(0.33) 

3.11 3.44 

(0.19) 

3.143.33

3 

10B-38 
Table 10B.2.38 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor 

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV

 -

-

-

(1.29) 

2.23 3.52 

(1.29) 

2.27 3.56 

(1.31) 

2.37 3.69 

(1.33) 

2.44 3.77 

(1.34) 

2.44 3.78 

(1.34) 

2.47 3.81 

(1.36) 

2.55 3.90 

(1.36) 

2.56 3.92 

(1.36) 

2.623.98

(1.39) 

2.80 4.19 

(1.17) 

2.90 4.07 

(1.03) 

2.96 3.99 

(0

23

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.18) 

0.330.51

(1.36) 

2.40 3.76

(1.37) 

2.43 3.80 

(1.38) 

2.54 3.92 

(1.40) 

2.60 4.00 

(1.41) 

2.60 4.01 

(1.41) 

2.62 4.03 

(1.42) 

2.69 4.12 

(1.43) 

2.71 4.13 

(1.43) 

2.764.19

(1.44) 

2.93 4.38 

(1.22) 

3.03 4.24 

(1.08) 

3.07 4.15 

(1

34

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.39) 

0.891.29

(1.46) 

2.69 4.14

(1.46) 

2.71 4.17 

(1.48) 

2.81 4.29 

(1.49) 

2.86 4.35 

(1.49) 

2.87 4.36 

(1.50) 

2.88 4.38 

(1.50) 

2.95 4.45 

(1.51) 

2.96 4.46 

(1.50) 

3.014.51

(1.51) 

3.15 4.66 

(1.27) 

3.23 4.51 

(1.13) 

3.28 4.41 

(1

34

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.41) 

1.311.71

(1.46) 

2.90 4.36

(1.47) 

2.92 4.39 

(1.48) 

3.01 4.49 

(1.50) 

3.06 4.55 

(1.50) 

3.06 4.56 

(1.50) 

3.08 4.58 

(1.51) 

3.14 4.64 

(1.51) 

3.15 4.65 

(1.51) 

3.194.69

(1.51) 

3.31 4.83 

(1.28) 

3.39 4.66 

(1.13) 

3.42 4.56 

(1

34

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.35) 

1.601.95

(1.44) 

3.05 4.48

(1.44) 

3.07 4.51 

(1.46) 

3.16 4.62 

(1.47) 

3.20 4.67 

(1.47) 

3.20 4.68 

(1.48) 

3.22 4.70 

(1.49) 

3.27 4.76 

(1.49) 

3.28 4.77 

(1.49) 

3.324.80

(1.50) 

3.43 4.93 

(1.26) 

3.50 4.76 

(1.12) 

3.53 4.65 

(1

34

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.19) 

2.282.46

(1.37) 

3.39 4.75

(1.37) 

3.41 4.78 

(1.39) 

3.49 4.88 

(1.41) 

3.52 4.93 

(1.41) 

3.52 4.93 

(1.41) 

3.53 4.95 

(1.43) 

3.57 5.00 

(1.43) 

3.58 5.01 

(1.43) 

3.615.04

(1.45) 

3.69 5.14 

(1.22) 

3.75 4.96 

(1.08) 

3.77 4.85 

(1

34

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.16) 

2.372.54

(1.36) 

3.44 4.79

(1.36) 

3.46 4.82 

(1.38) 

3.54 4.92 

(1.40) 

3.57 4.96 

(1.40) 

3.57 4.97 

(1.41) 

3.58 4.98 

(1.42) 

3.62 5.04 

(1.42) 

3.62 5.04 

(1.42) 

3.655.07

(1.44) 

3.73 5.17 

(1.21) 

3.78 4.99 

(1.07) 

3.81 4.88 

(1

34

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.15) 

2.402.55

(1.35) 

3.45 4.80

(1.35) 

3.47 4.82 

(1.37) 

3.55 4.92 

(1.39) 

3.58 4.97 

(1.39) 

3.58 4.98 

(1.40) 

3.59 4.99 

(1.41) 

3.63 5.04 

(1.41) 

3.64 5.05 

(1.42) 

3.665.08

(1.44) 

3.74 5.18 

(1.21) 

3.79 5.00 

(1.07) 

3.82 4.88 

(1

34

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.09 

2.632.53

(1.25) 

3.56 4.81

(1.25) 

3.58 4.83 

(1.27) 

3.66 4.93 

(1.30) 

3.69 4.98 

(1.30) 

3.69 4.99 

(1.30) 

3.70 5.00 

(1.32) 

3.73 5.06 

(1.33) 

3.74 5.06 

(1.33) 

3.765.09

(1.36) 

3.83 5.19 

(1.14) 

3.87 5.02 

(1.01) 

3.90 4.90 

(0

34

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.24 

2.762.51

(1.18) 

3.63 4.81

(1.19) 

3.65 4.83 

(1.21) 

3.72 4.93 

(1.24) 

3.75 4.98 

(1.24) 

3.75 4.99 

(1.25) 

3.76 5.01 

(1.27) 

3.79 5.06 

(1.27) 

3.80 5.07 

(1.28) 

3.825.10

(1.32) 

3.88 5.20 

(1.10) 

3.92 5.02 

(0.97) 

3.94 4.91 

(0

34

10B-39 
Table 10B.2.39 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoo

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS

NPV

 -

-

-

(2.79) 

7.54 

10.33

(2.79) 

7.58 

10

.37 

(2.80) 

7.61 

10.41 

(2.83) 

8.02 

10.85 

(2.85) 

8.27 

11.13 

(2.86) 

8.38 

11.24 

(2.85) 

8.69 

11.54 

(2.84) 

8.76 

11.60 

(2.84) 

9.38 

12.22 

(2.80) 

9.61 

12.41 

(1.78) 

10.00 

11.78 

(1.17) 

10.20 

11.37 

(0

11

1 ICS 

OCS

NPV

(0.33) 

0

.86 

1

.18

(2.93) 

7.96 

10

.89

(2.93) 

8.00

 10.93 

(2.93) 

8

.03 

10.96 

(2.96) 

8.43 

11.39 

(2.98) 

8.66 

11.64 

(2.98) 

8.76 

11.74 

(2.96) 

9.05 

12.02 

(2.95) 

9.12 

12.07 

(2.93) 

9.71 

12.64 

(2.89) 

9.92 

12.81 

(1.86) 

10.29 

12.15 

(1.24) 

10.48 

11.72 

(0

1

1

2 ICS 

OCS

NPV

(0.49) 

2

.89 

3

.38

(3.00) 

8.96 

11

.95 

(3.00) 

9.00 

11.99 

(3.00) 

9.02 

12.02 

(3.02) 

9.39 

12.42 

(3.04) 

9.59 

12.63 

(3.04) 

9.68 

12.72 

(3.02) 

9.93 

12.95 

(3.01) 

9.98 

12.99 

(2.98) 

10.48 13.46 

(2.93) 

10.66 

13.59 

(1.90) 

10.98 12.87 

(1.27) 

11.14 

12.41 

(0

11

3 ICS 

OCS

NPV

(0.41) 

4

.22 

4

.62

(2.96) 

9.61 

12

.57

(2.96) 

9.64 

12

.61 

(2.97) 

9.66 

12.63 

(2.99) 

10.02 

13.01 

(3.01) 

10.20 

13.21 

(3.01) 

10.27 13.28 

(2.99) 

10.49 

13.49 

(2.98) 

10.54 

13.53 

(2.96) 

10.98 

13.94 

(2.91) 

11.14 

14.05 

(1.88) 

11.42 

13.30 

(1.25) 

11.57 12.82 

(0

1

1

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.10) 

6.74 

6

.83

(2.83) 

10.85

 13.68

(2.83) 

1

0.88 

13

.71 

(2.84) 

10.89 

13.73 

(2.87) 

11.21 

14.08 

(2.89) 

11.35 14.24 

(2.89) 

11.41 

14.30 

(2.88) 

11.58 14.46 

(2.88) 

11.61 

14.49 

(2.87) 

11.94 

14.80 

(2.83) 

12.06 

14.89 

(1.81) 

12.27 14.08 

(1.19) 

12.38 

13.57 

(0

11

5 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.13 

7.76 7.63

(2.74) 

11.35

 14.09

(2.74) 

11

.38 

14

.12 

(2.75) 

11.39 14.14 

(2.78) 

11.70 

14.48 

(2.81) 

11.82 

14.62 

(2.81) 

11.87 14.68 

(2.81) 

12.01 

14.82 

(2.80) 

12.05 

14.85 

(2.80) 

12.32 

15.13 

(2.77) 

12.43 

15.20 

(1.75) 

12.62 

14.37 

(1.14) 

12.71 

13.85 

(0

1

1

6 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.22 

8.04 7.83

(2.70) 

11.49

 14.19

(2.70) 

11

.52 

14

.22 

(2.71) 

11.53 

14.24 

(2.74) 

11.83 

14.58 

(2.77) 

11.95 

14.72 

(2.78) 

11.99 

14.77 

(2.78) 

12.13 14.91 

(2.77) 

12.17 

14.94 

(2.78) 

12.43 

15.21 

(2.75) 

12.53 

15.28 

(1.73) 

12.71 

14.45 

(1.12) 

12.80 

13.93 

(0

1

1

7 ICS

OCS

NPV 0

.27 

8

.16

7.89

(2.68) 

11

.54

 14.22

(2.68) 

11

.57 

14

.25 

(2.69) 

11.59 

14.27 

(2.72) 

11.89 14.61 

(2.75) 

12.00 

14.75 

(2.76) 

12.05 

14.80 

(2.76) 

12.19 14.94 

(2.75) 

12.22 

14.97 

(2.76) 

12.48 

15.24 

(2.73) 

12.57 15.31 

(1.72) 

12.75 

14.47 

(1.11) 

12.84 

13.95 

(0

1

1

8 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.56 

8.58

 8

.02

(2.56) 

11

.75

 14.31

(2.56) 

11

.78 

14

.34 

(2.57) 

11.79 

14.36 

(2.61) 

12.09 

14.69 

(2.64) 

12.19 14.83 

(2.65) 

12.24 

14.89 

(2.66) 

12.37 

15.03 

(2.66) 

12.39 

15.05 

(2.68) 

12.63 

15.32 

(2.66) 

12.73 

15.38 

(1.66) 

12.89 

14.55 

(1.05) 

12.98 

14.03 

(0

1

1

9 ICS

OCS 

NPV 1

.02 

9.25

 8

.23

(2.36) 

12

.08

 14.45

(2.37) 

12

.11 

14

.47 

(2.37) 

12.12 

14.49 

(2.42) 

12.40 

14.83 

(2.47) 

12.50 

14.97 

(2.48) 

12.54 

15.02 

(2.50) 

12.65 

15.15 

(2.50) 

12.68 

15.18 

(2.55) 

12.89 15.44 

(2.53) 

12.97 

15.50 

(1.55) 

13.12 

14.67 

(0.95) 

13.20 

14.14 

(0

1

1

10B-40 
Table 10B.2.40 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor 

System at a 3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS

NPV

 -

-

-

(3.01) 

8.39

11.40

(3.02) 

8

.43 

11

.45 

(3.02) 

9.21 

12.23 

(3.06) 

9.50 

12.56 

(3.09) 

9.85 

12.93 

(3.09) 

10.03 

13.13 

(3.06) 

10.46 

13.53 

(3.06) 

11.1714.23

(3.04) 

11

.29 

14

.33 

(2.97) 

11.60 

14.57 

(2.92) 

11.63 

14.55 

(2.47) 

11.84 

14.32 

1 ICS 

OCS

NPV

(0.38) 

1

.06 

1

.44

(3.20) 

8.96 

12

.16

(3.21) 

9.00 

12

.20 

(3.20) 

9.78 

12.98 

(3.24) 

10.05 

13.28 

(3.25) 

10.38 

13.63 

(3.25) 

10.55 

13.81 

(3.21) 

10.96 

14.17 

(3.19) 

11.62 

14.81

(3.17) 

11.74 

14

.90 

(3.09) 

12.03 15.11 

(3.04) 

12.06 

15.10 

(2.59) 

12.26 

14.85 

2 ICS 

OCS

NPV

(0.57) 

3

.57

 4

.13

(3.29) 

10

.32

 13.60

(3.30) 

10

.35 

13

.64 

(3.29) 

11.12 

14.41 

(3.32) 

11.35 

14.67 

(3.33) 

11.63 

14.97 

(3.33) 

11.79 

15.12 

(3.28) 

12.13 

15.42 

(3.26) 

12.6915.94 

(3.23) 

12

.79 

16.02 

(3.14) 

13.04 

16.18 

(3.10) 

13.06 

16.16 

(2.64) 

13.24 

15.88 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV

(0.48) 

5.20

 5

.68

(3.24) 

11

.20

 14.44

(3.25) 

11

.23 

14

.48 

(3.25) 

12.00 

15.25 

(3.28) 

12.20 

15.48 

(3.29) 

12.45 

15.75 

(3.29) 

12.59 

15.88 

(3.25) 

12.89 

16.14 

(3.22) 

13.39

16.61

(3.20) 

1

3.48 

16

.68 

(3.12) 

13.70 

16.81 

(3.07) 

13.72 

16.79 

(2.62) 

13.87 

16.49 

4 ICS 

OCS

NPV

(0.11) 

8

.31

 8

.42

(3.07) 

12

.88

 15.95 

(3.08) 

12

.90 

15.98 

(3.08) 

13.67 16.74 

(3.11) 

13.82 

16.94 

(3.14) 

14.01 

17.15 

(3.14) 

14.11 

17.25 

(3.11) 

14.35 

17.45 

(3.10) 

14.71 

17.81

(3.08) 

14.78 

1

7.86 

(3.00) 

14.95 

17.95 

(2.96) 

14.97 17.93 

(2.51) 

15.09 

17.59 

5 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.15 

9.579.42

(2.94) 

1

3.57

 16.51

(2.95) 

1

3.58 

16

.54 

(2.95) 

14.34 

17.29 

(2.99) 

14.48 

17.47 

(3.02) 

14.64 

17.67 

(3.03) 

14.73 

17.76 

(3.00) 

14.94 

17.94 

(3.01) 

15.2518.26

(2.99) 

1

5.31 

18

.30 

(2.92) 

15.46 

18.38 

(2.88) 

15.48 

18.35 

(2.43) 

15.58 

18.01 

6 ICS

OCS 

NPV 0

.25 

9.92 9.67

(2.89) 

13.75 

16

.65

(2.90) 

13.77 

16

.67 

(2.90) 

14.53 

17.43 

(2.95) 

14.66 

17.61 

(2.98) 

14.82 

17.80 

(2.99) 

14.90 

17.89 

(2.96) 

15.10 

18.06 

(2.97) 

15.40

18.37

(2.96) 

15

.46 

18

.41 

(2.89) 

15.60 

18.49 

(2.84) 

15.62 

18.46 

(2.40) 

15.71 

18.11 

7 ICS

OCS

NPV 0

.32 

1

0.07

9.75 

(2.86) 

1

3.83

16.69

(2.87) 

1

3.85 

16

.72 

(2.87) 

14.61 

17.48 

(2.92) 

14.74 

17.65 

(2.95) 

14.89 

17.84 

(2.96) 

14.98 

17.93 

(2.94) 

15.17 

18.11 

(2.95) 

15.46

18.41

(2.93) 

1

5.52 

18

.45 

(2.87) 

15.66 

18.52 

(2.82) 

15.68 

18.50 

(2.38) 

15.77 

18.15 

8 ICS

OCS

NPV 0

.65 

10

.58

9.93 

(2.70) 

14

.11

16.81

(2.71) 

14

.13 

16

.84 

(2.71) 

14.88 

17.60 

(2.76) 

15.00 

17.77 

(2.80) 

15.15 

17.96 

(2.82) 

15.23 

18.05 

(2.81) 

15.41 

18.22 

(2.84) 

15.68

18.52

(2.82) 

15

.74 

18

.56 

(2.76) 

15.87 

18.63 

(2.72) 

15.88 

18.60 

(2.28) 

15.97 18.25 

9 ICS

OCS

NPV 1

.20 

11

.41

 10.21

(2.44) 

14

.56

 17.00

(2.45) 

14

.57 

1

7.03 

(2.45) 

15.33 

17.78 

(2.52) 

15.44 

17.95 

(2.57) 

15.57 

18.14 

(2.59) 

15.64 

18.22 

(2.59) 

15.80 

18.39 

(2.65) 

16.04 

18.69

(2.64) 

16.08 

18

.72 

(2.59) 

16.20 

18.79 

(2.55) 

16.22 

18.76 

(2.12) 

16.30 

18.41 

10B-41 
Table 10B.2.41 Net Present Value for Small Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refri

3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS

NPV

 -

-

-

(0.06) 

-

0.06 

(0.43) 

-

0.43 

(0.44) 

0.01 

0.45 

(0.45) (0.07) 

0.38 

(0.45) (0.07) 

0.39 

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31 

(0.53) (0.21) 

0.31 

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31 

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31 

(0.52) (0.33) 

0.19 

(0.51) (0.33) 

0.18 

((

1 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

(0.07) 

-

0.07

(0.13) 

-

0.13 

(0.47) 

-

0.47

(0.49) 

0.01 

0.50 

(0.49) (0.07) 

0.42 

(0.49) (0.07) 

0.42 

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.54) (0.21) 

0.33 

(0.54) (0.21) 

0.33

(0.54) (0.21) 

0.33 

(0.54) (0.33) 

0.21 

(0.53) (0.33) 

0.20 

((

2 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

(0.11) 

-

0.11

(0.17) 

-

0.17 

(0.49) 

-

0.49

(0.51) 

0.01 

0.52 

(0.51) (0.07) 

0.44 

(0.51) (0.07) 

0.44 

(0.56) (0.21) 

0.35 

(0.56) (0.21) 

0.35 

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.55) (0.33) 

0.23 

(0.54) (0.33) 

0.21 

((

3 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

(0.09) 

-

0.09

(0.15) 

-

0.15 

(0.48) 

-

0.48

(0.50) 

0.01 

0.51 

(0.50) (0.07) 

0.43 

(0.50) (0.07) 

0.43 

(0.56) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.56) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34

(0.55) (0.21) 

0.34 

(0.55) (0.33) 

0.22 

(0.53) (0.33) 

0.21 

((

4 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

(0.02) 

-

0.02

(0.08) 

-

0.08 

(0.44) 

-

0.44

(0.46) 

0.01 

0.47 

(0.46) (0.07) 

0.39 

(0.46) (0.07) 

0.40 

(0.53) (0.21) 

0.32 

(0.53) (0.21) 

0.32 

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31 

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.31 

(0.52) (0.33) 

0.20 

(0.51) (0.33) 

0.19 

((

5 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

0.03 

-

(0.03)

(0.04) 

-

0.04 

(0.41) 

-

0.41 

(0.43) 

0.01 0.44 

(0.43) (0.07) 

0.36 

(0.44) (0.07) 

0.37 

(0.51) (0.21) 

0.30 

(0.52) (0.21) 

0.30 

(0.51) (0.21) 

0.30 

(0.51) (0.21) 

0.30

(0.51) (0.21) 

0.30 

(0.51) (0.33) 

0.18 

(0.50) (0.33) 

0.17 

((

6 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

0.05 

-

(0.05)

(0.02) 

-

0.02 

(0.40) 

-

0.40 

(0.42) 

0.01 0.43 

(0.42) (0.07) 

0.35 

(0.43) (0.07) 

0.36 

(0.51) (0.21) 

0.30 

(0.51) (0.21) 

0.30 

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29 

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29 

(0.50) (0.33) 

0.18 

(0.50) (0.33) 

0.17 

((

7 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

0.06 

-

(0.06)

(0.01) 

-

0.01 

(0.39) 

-

0.39 

(0.41) 

0.01 0.42 

(0.41) (0.07) 

0.34 

(0.42) (0.07) 

0.36 

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29 

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29 

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29 

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29

(0.50) (0.21) 

0.29 

(0.50) (0.33) 

0.17 

(0.49) (0.33) 

0.17 

((

8 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

0.13 

-

(0.13) 

0.05 

-

(0.05)

(0.35) 

-

0.35 

(0.37) 

0.01 

0.38 

(0.38) (0.07) 

0.31 

(0.39) (0.07) 

0.32 

(0.48) (0.21) 

0.27 

(0.48) (0.21) 

0.27 

(0.48) (0.21) 

0.26 

(0.48) (0.21) 

0.27

(0.48) (0.21) 

0.27 

(0.48) (0.33) 

0.15 

(0.47) (0.33) 

0.15 

((

9 ICS 

OCS

NPV 

0.23 

-

(0.23) 

0.15 

-

(0.15)

(0.29) 

-

0.29 

(0.32) 

0.01 

0.33 

(0.32) (0.07) 

0.25 

(0.34) (0.07) 

0.27 

(0.45) (0.21) 

0.24 

(0.45) (0.21) 

0.24 

(0.44) (0.21) 

0.23 

(0.44) (0.21) 

0.23

(0.44) (0.21) 

0.23 

(0.44) (0.33) 

0.12 

(0.45) (0.33) 

0.12 

((

10B-42 
Table 10B.2.42 Net Present Value for Large Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Outdoor Refri

3 Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS

OCS 

NPV 

-

-

-

(0.13) 

-

0.13

(1.51) 

-

1.51

(1.51) 

-

1.51 

(1.49) 

0.07 

1.55 

(1.52) (0.58) 

0.94 

(1.96) (1.78) 

0.18 

(1.96) (1.78) 

0.18 

(1.96) (1.78) 

0.18 

(1.96) (1.78) 

0.18

(1.95) (1.78) 

0.17 

(1.77) (2.74) (0.96) 

(1.76) (2.74) (0.97) 

(((

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.37) 

-

0.37 

(0.49) 

-

0.49

(1.78) 

-

1.78

(1.78) 

-

1.78 

(1.74) 

0.07 

1.81 

(1.74) (0.58) 

1.16 

(2.09) (1.78) 

0.32 

(2.10) (1.78) 

0.32 

(2.10) (1.78) 

0.32 

(2.09) (1.78) 

0.32

(2.08) (1.78) 

0.30 

(1.87) (2.74) (0.86) 

(1.86) (2.74) (0.87) 

(((

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.56) 

-

0.56 

(0.67) 

-

0.67

(1.90) 

-

1.90

(1.91) 

-

1.91 

(1.87) 

0.07 

1.93 

(1.85) (0.58) 

1.27 

(2.16) (1.78) 

0.38 

(2.16) (1.78) 

0.39 

(2.16) (1.78) 

0.38 

(2.16) (1.78) 

0.38

(2.15) (1.78) 

0.37 

(1.92) (2.74) (0.81) 

(1.91) (2.74) (0.82) 

(((

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.47) 

-

0.47 

(0.58) 

-

0.58

(1.84) 

-

1.84

(1.84) 

-

1.84 

(1.81) 

0.07 

1.87 

(1.80) (0.58) 

1.22 

(2.13) (1.78) 

0.35 

(2.13) (1.78) 

0.35 

(2.13) (1.78) 

0.35 

(2.13) (1.78) 

0.35

(2.12) (1.78) 

0.34 

(1.90) (2.74) (0.84) 

(1.89) (2.74) (0.85) 

(((

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

(0.11) 

-

0.11 

(0.23) 

-

0.23

(1.59) 

-

1.59

(1.59) 

-

1.59 

(1.56) 

0.07 

1.63 

(1.58) (0.58) 

1.00 

(2.00) (1.78) 

0.22 

(2.00) (1.78) 

0.22 

(2.00) (1.78) 

0.22 

(2.00) (1.78) 

0.22

(1.99) (1.78) 

0.21 

(1.80) (2.74) (0.94) 

(1.79) (2.74) (0.95) 

(((

5 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.15 

-

(0.15) 

0.02 

-

(0.02)

(1.41) 

-

1.41 

(1.41) 

-

1.41 

(1.38) 

0.07 

1.45 

(1.43) (0.58) 

0.85 

(1.90) (1.78) 

0.13 

(1.91) (1.78) 

0.13 

(1.91) (1.78) 

0.13 

(1.91) (1.78) 

0.13

(1.90) (1.78) 

0.12 

(1.73) (2.74) (1.00) 

(1.72) (2.74) (1.01) 

(((

6 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.25 

-

(0.25) 

0.11 

-

(0.11)

(1.34) 

-

1.34 

(1.34) 

-

1.34 

(1.32) 

0.07 

1.38 

(1.37) (0.58) 

0.79 

(1.87) (1.78) 

0.09 

(1.87) (1.78) 

0.09 

(1.87) (1.78) 

0.10 

(1.87) (1.78) 

0.10

(1.86) (1.78) 

0.09 

(1.71) (2.74) (1.03) 

(1.70) (2.74) (1.04) 

(((

7 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.31 

-

(0.31) 

0.18 

-

(0.18)

(1.29) 

-

1.29 

(1.29) 

-

1.29 

(1.27) 

0.07 

1.34 

(1.33) (0.58) 

0.75 

(1.84) (1.78) 

0.07 

(1.85) (1.78) 

0.07 

(1.85) (1.78) 

0.07 

(1.85) (1.78) 

0.07

(1.84) (1.78) 

0.06 

(1.69) (2.74) (1.05) 

(1.68) (2.74) (1.06) 

(((

8 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.64 

-

(0.64) 

0.50 

-

(0.50)

(1.06) 

-

1.06 

(1.06) 

-

1.06 

(1.04) 

0.07 

1.11 

(1.13) (0.58) 

0.55 

(1.72) (1.78) (0.05) 

(1.73) (1.78) (0.05) 

(1.73) (1.78) (0.05) 

(1.73) (1.78) (0.04) 

(1.73) (1.78) (0.05) 

(1.60) (2.74) (1.14) 

(1.59) (2.74) (1.15) 

(((

9 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

1.18 

-

(1.18) 

1.02 

-

(1.02)

(0.68) 

-

0.68 

(0.68) 

-

0.68 

(0.68) 

0.07 

0.74 

(0.81) (0.58) 

0.23 

(1.53) (1.78) (0.25) 

(1.54) (1.78) (0.24) 

(1.54) (1.78) (0.24) 

(1.54) (1.78) (0.23) 

(1.54) (1.78) (0.24) 

(1.45) (2.74) (1.28) 

(1.45) (2.74) (1.29) 

(((

10B-43 
Table 10B.2.43 Net Present Value for Small Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrigera

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.03) (0.03) (0.01) 0.01 

OCS - 0.08 0.08 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.11 0.11 0.11 

NPV - 0.12 0.12 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.11 0.10 

1 ICS 0.00 (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.03) (0.03) (0.00) 0.01 

OCS 0.00 0.08 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.11 0.11 0.11 

NPV 0.00 0.12 0.12 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.14 0.11 0.10 

2 ICS 0.01 (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.04) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.00) 0.01 

OCS 0.01 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.11 0.11 0.11 

NPV 0.01 0.12 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.14 0.14 0.14 0.14 0.12 0.10 

3 ICS 0.02 (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.03) (0.02) 0.00 0.02 

OCS 0.02 0.09 0.09 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.12 0.12 

NPV (0.00) 0.12 0.12 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.14 0.12 0.10 

4 ICS 

OCS 

0.05 

0.03 

(0.02)

0.10

 (0.02)

 0.10

 (0.02) 

0.11 

(0.02)

0.11

 (0.02)

 0.11

 (0.02)

 0.11

 (0.02) 

0.11 

(0.02)

0.11

 (0.02)

 0.11

 (0.01) 

0.12

0.01 

0.12 

0.02 

0.12 

NPV (0.02) 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.13 0.11 0.10 

10B-44 
Table 10B.2.44 Net Present Value for Medium Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrige

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (1.36) (1.34) (1.34) (1.28) (1.17) (1.11) (0.90) (0.84) (0.39) (0.17) 2.26 3.71 

OCS - 6.36 6.41 6.43 6.91 7.12 7.21 7.47 7.53 8.03 8.22 8.55 8.72 

NPV - 7.72 7.75 7.77 8.19 8.29 8.33 8.38 8.37 8.43 8.39 6.29 5.01 

1 ICS 0.04 (1.34) (1.32) (1.32) (1.26) (1.15) (1.10) (0.89) (0.83) (0.38) (0.16) 2.27 3.72 

OCS 0.87 6.78 6.83 6.85 7.32 7.52 7.60 7.84 7.90 8.36 8.53 8.84 9.00 

NPV 0.82 8.12 8.15 8.17 8.58 8.67 8.70 8.73 8.73 8.74 8.69 6.57 5.29 

2 ICS 0.35 (1.21) (1.20) (1.19) (1.14) (1.04) (0.98) (0.78) (0.72) (0.29) (0.08) 2.34 3.78 

OCS 1.55 7.12 7.16 7.18 7.65 7.83 7.91 8.14 8.19 8.62 8.78 9.08 9.22 

NPV 1.20 8.33 8.36 8.37 8.78 8.87 8.89 8.92 8.91 8.91 8.86 6.73 5.44 

3 ICS 0.85 (1.00) (0.99) (0.98) (0.94) (0.85) (0.80) (0.61) (0.55) (0.15) 0.06 2.46 3.89 

OCS 1.84 7.26 7.30 7.32 7.78 7.96 8.04 8.26 8.31 8.73 8.89 9.17 9.32 

NPV 0.98 8.26 8.29 8.31 8.72 8.81 8.84 8.87 8.86 8.88 8.83 6.71 5.43 

4 ICS 1.10 (0.90) (0.88) (0.88) (0.84) (0.75) (0.71) (0.52) (0.47) (0.08) 0.12 2.52 3.95 

OCS 2.08 7.38 7.42 7.44 7.90 8.07 8.15 8.36 8.41 8.82 8.98 9.25 9.40 

NPV 0.98 8.27 8.30 8.32 8.73 8.83 8.85 8.89 8.88 8.90 8.85 6.74 5.45 

10B-45 
Table 10B.2.45 Net Present Value for Large Non-Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrigera

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.65) (0.65) (0.63) (0.59) (0.52) (0.47) (0.33) (0.13) (0.08) 0.08 0.12 0.61 

OCS - 3.16 3.18 3.69 3.80 3.93 4.00 4.16 4.41 4.46 4.58 4.59 4.67 

NPV - 3.81 3.83 4.32 4.39 4.45 4.47 4.49 4.54 4.54 4.50 4.47 4.06 

1 ICS 0.02 (0.64) (0.64) (0.62) (0.58) (0.51) (0.46) (0.32) (0.12) (0.07) 0.08 0.13 0.61 

OCS 0.48 3.42 3.44 3.94 4.04 4.17 4.23 4.38 4.62 4.66 4.77 4.78 4.86 

NPV 0.46 4.06 4.07 4.57 4.62 4.68 4.70 4.70 4.74 4.73 4.69 4.65 4.24 

2 ICS 0.18 (0.56) (0.56) (0.55) (0.51) (0.44) (0.40) (0.26) (0.07) (0.02) 0.13 0.18 0.66 

OCS 0.85 3.63 3.64 4.14 4.24 4.36 4.42 4.56 4.78 4.82 4.92 4.93 5.00 

NPV 0.67 4.19 4.20 4.69 4.75 4.80 4.81 4.82 4.84 4.83 4.79 4.75 4.34 

3 ICS 0.45 (0.44) (0.44) (0.42) (0.39) (0.33) (0.28) (0.15) 0.02 0.07 0.22 0.26 0.74 

OCS 1.01 3.71 3.72 4.23 4.32 4.43 4.49 4.63 4.85 4.89 4.99 5.00 5.07 

NPV 0.57 4.15 4.16 4.65 4.71 4.76 4.78 4.79 4.82 4.81 4.77 4.73 4.33 

4 ICS 0.58 (0.37) (0.37) (0.36) (0.33) (0.27) (0.23) (0.10) 0.07 0.12 0.26 0.30 0.78 

OCS 1.15 3.78 3.80 4.30 4.39 4.50 4.56 4.70 4.90 4.94 5.04 5.05 5.12 

NPV 0.57 4.16 4.17 4.66 4.72 4.77 4.79 4.80 4.83 4.83 4.78 4.75 4.34 

10B-46 
Table 10B.2.46 Net Present Value for Medium Display Freezer with Large Multiplex System Refrigeratio

Percent Discount Rate 

Envelope CSL 

Ref. 

System 

CSL 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 

0 ICS - (0.21) (0.88) (0.86) (0.64) (0.05) (0.04) 0.90 0.90 0.92 0.93 0.97 1.83 

OCS - - - - 0.15 (1.18) (3.62) (3.62) (3.62) (3.62) (3.62) (3.62) (5.58) 

NPV - 0.21 0.88 0.86 0.79 (1.13) (3.58) (4.52) (4.52) (4.54) (4.55) (4.58) (7.41) 

1 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.05 

-

(0.05) 

(0.17)

-

0.17

 (0.85) 

-

0.85 

(0.83)

-

0.83

 (0.61) 

0.15 

0.76 

(0.02) 

(1.18) 

(1.16) 

(0.01) (3.62) 

(3.61) 

0.92

(3.62) 

(4.53) 

0.92 (3.62) 

(4.54) 

0.94

(3.62)

(4.55)

 0.95

 (3.62) 

 (4.57) 

0.98 (3.62) 

(4.60) 

1.84

(5.58)

(7.42)

 

2 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

0.41

-

(0.41)

 0.17 

-

 (0.17) 

(0.61) 

-

0.61 

(0.60) 

-

0.60 

(0.39) 

0.15 

0.54 

0.17 

(1.18) 

(1.35) 

0.18

(3.62) (3.80)

 1.04

(3.62) 

 (4.66) 

1.04 (3.62) 

(4.66) 

1.06

(3.62)

(4.67)

 1.07

 (3.62) 

 (4.69) 

1.10 (3.62) 

(4.72) 

1.94

(5.58)

(7.51)

 

3 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

1.00

-

(1.00)

 0.71 

-

 (0.71) 

(0.23) 

-

0.23 

(0.23) 

-

0.23 

(0.03) 

0.15 

0.18 

0.49 

(1.18) 

(1.67) 

0.50

(3.62) (4.11)

 1.24

(3.62) 

 (4.85) 

1.24 (3.62) 

(4.86) 

1.25

(3.62)

(4.87)

 1.26

 (3.62) 

 (4.88) 

1.30 (3.62) 

(4.91) 

2.09

(5.58)

(7.66)

 

4 ICS 

OCS 

NPV 

1.29

-

(1.29)

 0.98 

-

 (0.98) 

(0.04) 

-

0.04 

(0.05) 

-

0.05 

0.14

0.15 

0.00 

0.64 (1.18) 

(1.82) 

0.65

(3.62) (4.27)

 1.33

(3.62) 

 (4.95) 

1.34 (3.62) 

(4.95) 

1.35

(3.62)

(4.97)

 1.36

 (3.62) 

 (4.98) 

1.39 (3.62) 

(5.01) 

2.16

(5.58)

(7.74)

 

10B-47