OAR Box 1781 

Prepped by Ollie Stewart 

Document Number: 

129) IV-C-43 

Docket Number: 

A-90-37 

p.i 

1 

Printed 10/29/2008 10:46:24 AM Sheet 129 of 142 
P.2 

>*08X 

i UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

RESEARCH TRIANGLE PARK, NC 27711 

Dear Participants: 

JAN I 5 I999 

EPA AIR DOCKET 

OFFICE OF 

AIR QUALITY PLANNING 

AND STANDARDS 

This is to announce a meeting of stakeholders who are interested in me applicability 

provisions of New Source Review (NSR) Reform, a preconstruction review permitting program 

under the Clean Air Act. The meeting will be held on February 2-3,1999 at the J.W. Marriott 

Hotel (1331 Pennsylvania Avenue, Northwest) in Washington, D.C, beginning at 10:00 a.m., on 

Tuesday, February 2, and at 9:00 a.m., Wednesday, February 3, and ending no later man 

12:00 noon on Wednesday, February 3. 

The purpose of this meeting will be to discuss a new approach to NSR applicability. 

Attached is a 1-page outline of conceptual requirements and associated issues that have been 

suggested to date (Attachment 1). Interested stakeholders are invited to present, at tiiis meeting, 

an approach for implementing the concept. We would also encourage presenters to include 

consideration of the questions (Attachment 2) that have been identified in internal Environmental 

Protection Agency (EPA) discussions. 

The EPA is willing to pursue such an approach if it has promise. We will evaluate the 

approaches discussed by early March and decide whether we will sustain the effort on me new 

approach or resume work on the current final NSR Reform rulemaking package. In concert with 

this decision, we will also evaluate options for obtaining further stakeholder input. 

Plans for how the meeting will be run are still under discussion within EPA. There is 

uncertainty as to how many attendees will be present, and there are constraints as to the size of 

the meeting room. Initial thoughts are that at the table, which will seat about 40-45 people, an 

equal number of seats will be made available to representatives from: (1) the industrial sector, (2) 

the public interest groups, (3) State and local governments, and (4) the Federal government. We 

do not anticipate that we will be able to provide more than one seat at the table for each industrial 

sector. There will be additional seating, theater style, in the meeting room, available on a first 

come first served basis, for about 50 people. To the extent possible, everyone who wishes to 

speak will have an opportunity. 

An address list of persons who are being sent this letter is also attached (Attachment 3) 

and an annoucement will be published in the Federal Register. It is also being placed on the 

Office of Air and Radiation's Internet website: (http://www.epa.gov/oar/oarnew.html) and me 

NSR website (http://www.epa.gov/ttn/nsr/rule_dev.html). If you know of someone who may not 

have received this letter but is interested in participating in such an effort, feel free to contact 

them. 

I 

Recycled/Recyclable (Printed with Vegetable Oil Based Inks on 100% Recycled Paper (40% Postconsumer) 
P.3 

Due to the unavailability of sleeping rooms at the J.W. Marriott, a block of rooms has 

been reserved at the Hotel Washington (515 15th Street, Northwest), which is a short distance 

away from the J.W. Marriott Hotel. The telephone number at the Hotel Washington is 

(202) 638-5900 and mention should be made of the EPA Clean Air Act meeting when reserving 

a room. 

If you wish to attend the meeting, please E-mail or call Pam Smith, at E-mail address 

"smith.pam@epa.gov" or telephone number (919) 541-0641, by January 28. It would also be 

helpful if you indicate whether you plan to give a presentation. If you have further questions 

regarding the stakeholder meeting on February 2-3 , you may call Dennis Crumpler at 

(919) 541-0871 or Karen Blanchard at (919) 541-5503. 

Director 

Office of Air Quality Planning 

and Standards 

Attachments (3) 

1. 1-Page Outline 

2. Questions 

3. Addressee List 
P.4 

Attachment 1 

A New Approach to NSR Applicability 

The basic goal is to reduce emissions to a certain level, e.g., BACT or LAER, for existing 

sources that currently have no or little emission control at some fixed date in time, in the future. 

This would be done either through add-on technology or pollution prevention. Major greenfield 

sources would still be subject to current New Source Review (NSR) requirements. Netting as it 

is conducted today would be eliminated. 

Criteria and issues based on preliminary discussions include: 

• The test for applicability should be a single set of criteria that is easy to 

implement and enforce; 

• Provide an exemption from many NSR modifications for a fixed period of time 

(e.g., 10 years from 1999). At the end of that period NSR, meaning the 

application of BACT or LAER, would apply to all major units at the source. 

Some lead time would be provided for sources to install controls or retire 

the facility. 

• NSR applicability as is currently conducted would be suspended with the 

following exceptions: 

For modifications to existing units, EPA would at least continue to review 

reconstruction and major capacity expansions but examine the possibility 

of temporarily exempting lesser modifications from NSR; 

BACT/LAER on all new emissions units and/or reconstruction and major 

capacity expansions would still be required. 

• All non-NSR requirements of the Clean Air Act and implementation schedules for 

attaining heaUh-based standards would remain unaffected by this new approach 

(e.g. SIP requirements, Title IV, MACT etc.). 

• Other desirable outcomes are to: 

Reduce the incidence of case-by-case BACT determinations—for example, 

establish presumptive BACT for specific industry sectors; 

Factor improvements in efficiency improvements and pollution prevention 

into BACT/LAER decisions—for example, if large improvements are 

derived but the highest control levels are not achieved, should 

BACT/LAER be a function of air quality? 
P.5 

Related Issues: 

What happens for sources in sectors that do not have a presumptive BACT 

established? 

How do we stimulate the development or evolution of more effective 

control technologies and P2? 

How would EPA and permitting authority deal with the possibility of 

hundreds of applications coming in on one date? 

How should reconstruction be defined for the purposes of NSR? 
P.6 

Attachment 2 

Questions 

Questions for consideration in developing ideas for a new applicability approach are listed 

below: 

1. Would grandfathering end on a fixed calendar date? How would EPA and the States 

verify evidence (via a permit) of compliance by the several thousand sources subject to 

the requirements as of a particular point in time? Would some other triggering 

mechanism be employed such as the expected life of the facility or oldest emissions units, 

or the first modification after a fixed date, or some combination of these? 

2. If grandfathering were to end on a fixed date what would that date be? 

3. What, exactly, triggers NSR at the end date? The mere reaching of that date, or some 

event at the source after the end date such as a physical modification? 

4. What, exactly, is the obligation when NSR is eventually triggered? BACT or LAER 

depending on area attainment status? Could the fact that a unit installed BACT/LAER in 

the past influence the technology requirement, and if so, by how much? 

5. Is a presumptive BACT/ LAER requirement feasible? What mechanisms can EPA use to 

ensure that control technologies and pollution prevention evolve? For example are there 

ways to get more submittals to the RACT/BACT/LAER Clearinghouse? 

6. Is there a statutory basis for such an approach? Are there related issues that in order to 

resolve will lead to a test that is as complex as the existing one? 

7. What other alternatives to this approach should be considered? These might include 

declining emission caps or other market-based approaches which set an area-wide, 

statewide, or regional emissions cap at a certain level at a certain point in time, while still 

guarding against local adverse impacts. 

8. How does the new approach for NSR fit with efforts to encourage utilities to voluntarily 

increase efficiencies of generating electric power and engage in other carbon emission 

reduction efforts? 

9. Can such an approach be supported by a sufficiently wide number of stakeholder groups 

to conclude that it has a significant chance for being promulgated in a reasonable time 

frame? 
P.7 

10. If there is widespread support for a new applicability test and EPA decides to move 

forward, how should the EPA handle some of the non-applicability issues addressed in 

the current NSR Reform rulemaking? 

11. Should this approach be mandatory? Should it completely replace the current system or 

be a discretionary option? 

12. What are the consequences, either positive or negative of ending netting? 
NSR REFORM ii STAKEHOLDER MEMBERS Attachment 3 

Updated; 2/1/99 ("This listing is still being updated.**) 

V 

NAME 

1 Alexius, Bruce 

2 Amar, Praveen 

3 Anderson, Daniel P. 

'* Atay, Iclal 

'* Ayres, Richard, Esq. 

4 Babos, Michael 

5 Bankoff, Barbara 

6 Barr, Michael 

7 Bates, Christine 

8 Becker, Julie 

9 Becker, William 

10 Bekfen, Roy 

* Berwick, Ann 

11 Bessette, Robert 

12 Bobal, Renee 

13 Borrasca, Adelia 

14 Bowers, Terry 

15 Brantley. W. Phil 

16 Broome, Shannon 

17 Browned, William 

** Brubacker, Robert 

** Brunton, Jack 

18 Bumpers, William 

** Burke, Jole 

19 Burkhart, William 

20 Burred, Laura 

21 Burtschi, Mark 

22 Carhart, Bruce 

23 Carney. Mark 

** Carter, Tom 

** Cordes, Richard 

24 Cox. Betty 

25 Cromwell, Ted 

26 Dege, John 

*• Dewbury, Maxine 

27 Dionne. Edan 

•* Dobriansky, Larisa 

28 Dunn, Alexandra 

AFFILIATION 

bow < :hemical 

NESCAUM 

Chemical First 

NJDfcP 

Howrey & Simon 

Merck & Company 

Siemens Corporation 

Plllsbury, Madison & Sutro 

General Motors Argonaut (A-205-H) 

formerly AAMA 

STAPPA/ALAPCO 

Chadboume & Parke 

M. J. Bradley Assoc. 

Council of Industrial Boiler Owners 

Heller Ehrman White & McAuliffe 

Dept. of Defense 

SESARM & METRO; Attn: Bureau of Air Quality 

General Electric Company 

Hunton & Williams 

Porter, Wright, Morris & Author 

Sempre Energy 

Baker & Botts 

Proctor & Gamble 

Chemical Manufactures Assoc 

National Assoc, of Manufacturers 

Ozone Transport Commission 

US Generating CoVEGA 

American Portland Cement Affiance 

Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 

American Petroleum Institute 

Chemical Manufacturers Assoc 

Dupont 

Proctor & Gamble 

IBM 

Ackin Gump Strauss Haurer Field Law Firm 

CMA 

APJJRESS 

PS Box 150, Bldg. 3502E, Plaquemine, LA 70765-0150 

129 Portland Street, Boston, MA 02173 

PO Box 7005, Pascagoula, MS 39568 

401 East State Street, Trenton. NJ 08625 

1299 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20002 

Central Env. Resources, PO Box 100, White House Station, NY 08889 

701 Pennsylvania Ave., Suite 720, Washington, DC 20004 

NafI Assoc, of Manufacturers, 225 Bush Street, San Francisco, CA 94104 

485 W. Milwaukee. Detroit, Ml 48202 

444 N. Capitol Street, NW, Suite 307, Washington, DC 20001 

1200 New Hampshire Ave.. NW. Washington, DC 20036-6802 

47 Junction Square Drive, Concord, MA 070142 

6035 Burke Centre Parkway, Suite 360, Burke. VA 22015-3757 

815 Connecticut Avenue. NW, Suite 200, Washington. DC 20006 

2600 Bull Street. Columbia, SC 29201 

3135 Easton Turnpike, Fairfield, CT 06431 

1900 K Street, NW, Suite 1200, Washington, DC 20006 

41 South High Street. Columbus. OH 43215 

101 Ash Street. San Diego. CA 92101 

1299 Pennsylvania Ave., Washington, DC 20004 

(x351) 

Wlnton Hid Technical Center, 6110 Center Hid Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45224 

1300 Wilson Blvd.. Arlington, VA 22209 

1331 Pennsylvania Ave.. NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20004 

444 N. Capitol SL. NW, Suite 604, Washington, DC 20001 

7500 Old Georgetown Rd., Bethesda. MD 20714 

1225 Eye Street NW. Suite 300, Washington, DC 20005 

520 Lafayette Road, SL Paul, MN 55155 

1220 L Street NW, Washington. DC 20005 

1300 Wilson Blvd.. Arlington, VA 22209 

1007 Market Street N2S18-1, Wilmington, DE 19898 

Winton H81 Technical Center. 6110 Center HiD Ave.. Cincinnati. OH 45224 

Bldg. 1. M/D 2393. Route 100, PO Box 100, Somers. NY 10589 

1333 New Hampshire Ave.. NW. Washington. DC 20036 

1300 Wilson Blvd.. Arflngton. VA 22209 

202-624-7864 202-624-7863 

202-974-5726 202-974-5602 

978-369-5533 976-369-7712 

703-250-9042 703-239-9042 

PHONE. EAX E-mail 

225-353-8844 225-353-8001 balexius@dow.com 

617-367-8540 617-742-9162 pmar@nescaum.org 

228-938-2227 228-938-2734 danderson@chemfirst.com 

609-984-0515 609-984-6369 latay@dep.state.nj.us 

202-383-6778 ayresR@howrey.com 

908-423-7812 908-735-1109 michael_babos@merck.com 

202-434-4810 202-347-1361 babankof@erols.com 

415-983-1151 415-983-1200 ban-_mr@pillsburylaw.com 

313-556-7885 313-556-7629 Inusgmb.nzr1vr@gmeds.com 

beckerj@ix.netcome.com 

b4clnalr@sso.org 

roy.belden@chadbourne.com 

aberwick@mjbradly.com 

bessette@cibo.org 

renee.bobal@roche.com 

202-785-6267 202-785-8877 aborrasca@hewm.com 

703-602-4769 703-602-5547 bowers.terry@hq.navy.mil 

803-898-4116 803-898-4022 brantlwp@columb31.dhecstate.sc.us 

202-373-3575 202-373-3389 shannon.broome@corporate.ge.com 

202-955-1555 202-778-2201 bbrownell@hunton.com 

614-227-2033 614-227-2100 rbnjbacker@porterwright.com 

619-696-2509 Jbrunton@sempra.com 

202-639-7718 202-639-7890 william_bumpers@bakerbotts.com 

202-775-0252 

513-634-6366 513-634-5481 burkhartwt@pg.eom 

703-741-5247 703-741-5247 laura_burrell@cmahq.eom 

202-637-3176 202-637-3182 mburtschl@nam.org 

202-508-3840 202-508-3841 ozone@sso.org 

301-718-6899 301-718-6901 mcamey@usgen.com 

202-408-9494 202-408-677 tcarter@apca.org 

651-296-8157 richard.cordes@pca.state.mn.us 

202-682-8250 202-682-8250 cox@api.org 

703-741-5246 703-741-6246 ted_cfomwell@crnariq.com 

302-773-900 302-774-1361 Jchn.a.dege@usa.dupontcom 

914-766-2729 914-766-2824 dionne@vnetibm.com 

202-887-4363 202-887-4288 tdobriansky@ackin.com 

703-741-5156 703-741-6092 alexandra_dunn@cmahq.com 

00 
ofc 

** Dykes, Teresa 

** Edgemon, Kathy 

** Egan, John 

29 Emery, David 

30 Faulstich, Jim 

31 Feldcamp, Larry 

** Fontaine, Joe 

** Fotis. Steve 

32 Frye, Russell 

33 Fulmer, Jerry 

** Ganguli, Anupom 

** Gleason, Jeff 

** Golson, Glenn 

34 Grice, Michael 

35 Grumet, Jason 

" Hansel, Mike 

36 Harper, Steve 

37 Harris, John 

38 Hatcher, Julia 

39 Hawkins, David 

** Hedman, Susan 

** Helme, Ned 

40 Hmiel, Tom 

41 Hodanbosi, Robert 

" Hoffman, Patricia 

'* Hofmann, Jay 

42 Holmes, John G. 

43 Holt, Alexandra 

'* Huff, Bernard 

44 Hughes, Lee 

45 Hyde, Robert 

46 Isaacs, David 

47 Jaeger, Lisa 

* Jacobsohn, Alice 

48 Jakubowics, Craig 

* Jezouit, Debra 

49 Jones, Gary 

* Kanupke, David 

* Kaarsberg, Tina 

50 Kaufmann, Robert 

* King, Debbie 

* Kinsman, Johri 

51 Knauss, Chuck 

52 Kochenderfer, Karil 

Howrey & Simon 

Cargill Fertilizer, Inc. 

Earthres Group, Inc. 

Phillips Petroleum 

Hercules Inc. 

Baker i Boris 

NH Dept. of Environmental Services 

SanNess Fieldman 

Chadboume & Parke 

for Alcoa 

SCQMD, Senior Mgr. 

Southern Environemental Law Center 

AL Dept of Environmental Managment 

DaimlerChrysler AG 

NESCAUM 

Koch 

INTEL 

AMOCO 

Latham & Watklns 

Nat'l Resources Defense Council 

Environmental Law & Policy Center 

Center for Clean Ah- Policy 

BASF 

Ohio EPA 

DOE - Cogeneration Program Manager 

Trinity Consultants 

AEMS (for DaimlerChrysler) 

Chicago Dept. Environment 

AEMS (for DaimlerChrysler) 

Bayer Corporation 

Merck & Company 

Electonic Industries Alliance 

Bracewell & Patterson, L.L.P. 

National Solid Wastes Mgmt Assoc 

Edison Electric Institute 

Baker* Boris, LLP. 

Graphic Arts Technical Foundation 

Beveridge & Diamond (Law Firm) 

Northeast-Midwest Institute 

American Forest & Paper 

King & Spalding 

Edison Electric Institute 

Swidler Berlin Shereff Friedman 

American Textile Manufacturers Inst. 

1299 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20002 

8813 Hwy. 41 South, Riverview, FL 33569 

7137 Old Easton Rd, Pipperfield, PA 18947 

12 A2 Phillips Bldg., Bartlesville, OK 74004 

Hercules Plaza, Wilmington, DE 19894 

One Shell Plaza, 910 Louisiana, Houston, TX 77002 

64 North Main Street, PO Box 2033, Concord, NH 03302-2033 

1050 Thomas Jefferson Street, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20007 

1200 Chadborne & Parke, LLP, Washington, DC 20036-6802 

2669 Cedarvue Drive, Pittsburgh, PA 15241 - fax same as phone tt 

VOC Rules & NSR. 21865 E. Copley Dr., Diamond Bar. CA 91765-4182 

201 West Main Street, Suite 14, Charlottesville, VA 22902 

PO Box 301463, Montgomery, AL 36130 

1000 Chrysler Drive [CIMS 485-14-18], Auburn Hills. Ml 48326-2766 

129 Portland Street, Boston, MA 02114 

PO Box 64596, St Paul. MN 55164-0596 

1001 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Suite 1300, Washington, DC 20004-2505 

1350 New York Ave., NW, Suite 300, Washington, DC 20005 

35 East Wacker Drive, Chicago, IL 60602 

750 1st Street NE, Suite 1140, Washington, DC 20002 

PO Box 1049, Columbus. OH 43216-0149 

1000 Independence Ave., SW, Washington. DC 20585-0121 

12801 N. Central Expressway, Suite 1200, Dallas, TX 75243 

4350 N. Fairfax Dr., Suite 300, Arlington, VA 22203 

PO Box 960, MD 552-A, Cincinnati, OH 45201 

100 Bayer Road, Pittsburgh. PA 15205 

One Merck Dr., PO Box 100 (Code: W53B05), WhHe House Station. NY 08889 

2500 Wilson Boulevard. Arlington, VA 22201-3834 

2000 K Street, NW. Suite 500, Washington, DC 20006 

4301 Connecticut Ave., NW, Suite 300, Washington, DC 20008 

1299 Pennsylvania Ave., Washington, DC 20004 

200 Deer Run Road. Sewickley, PA 15143-2600 

13501 Street NW. Suite 700, Washington. DC 20005 

218 D Street, SE, Washington, DC 20003 (ext. 3028) 

1111 19th Street, NW, Suite 800. Washington, DC 20036 

1730 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20006 

701 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, .Washington, DC 20004 

3000 K Street NW, Suite 300, Washington, DC 20007 

202-383^6919 

813-671-6369 

215-766-1211 

918-661-3041 

302-594-7626 

713-229-1573 

603-271-6794 

202-298-1908 

202-974-5636 

412-851-0777 

909-396-3185 

804-977-4090 

334-271-7861 

248-512-4124 

617-367-8540 

651-437-627 

202-628-3838 

202-637-2238 

202-289-6868 

312-759-3400 

202-408-9260 

973-426-2624 

614-614-2270 

202-586-6074 

972-661-8100 

703-516-2444 

312-744-3142 

513-287-3884 

412-777-2221 

908-423-3994 

703-907-7576 

202-828-5847 

202-364-3724 

202-508-5620 

202-639-7728 

412-741-6860 

202-789-6115 

202-544-5200 

202-463-2588 

202-626-3737 

202-508-5711 

202-424-7644 

202-862-0656 

813-671-6149 

215-766-1245 

918-661-6146 

302-594-5996 

713-229-1522 

202-298-1908 

202-974-5602 

412-851-0777 

909-396-3324 

804-977-1483 

334-279-3044 

248-512-926 

617-742-9162 

651-437-868 

202-628-2525 

202-637-2201 

202-783-5917 

312-332-1580 

202-408-8896 

973-426-2622 

614-644-3681 

202-586-1658 

972-385-9203 

703-524-4854 

312-744-6451 

412-777-3063 

908-423-1322 

703-907-7501 

202-223-1225 

202-364-3792 

202-508-5673 

202-639-7890 

412-741-2311 

202-789-6190 

202-544-0043 

220-463-2423 

202-626-5449 

202-508-5150 

202-424-7643 

202-862-0646 

dykes@howrey.com 

Kathy_Edgermon@cargill.com 

Jeagan@earthris.com 

dtemery@bvemx.ppco.com 

Jfaulstich@herc.com 

Iarry_feldcamp@bakertx3tts.com 

l_fontaine@des.state.nh.us 

njssell.frye@chadboume.com 

JBfulmer@aol.com 

aganguli@aqmd.gov 

jgteason@selcva.org 

ggg@adem.state.al.us 

mwgrice@chrysler.geis.com 

Jgrumet@nescaum.org 

hanselM@kochind .com 

Stephen, harper@intel.com 

John_d_harris@amoco.com 

Julla.hatcher@LW.com 

dhawkins@nrdc.org 

shedman@elpc.org 

nhelme@ccap.org 

hmieH@basf.com 

bob_hodanbosl@central.epa.ohio.gov 

Patricia.Hoffman@ee.doe.gov 

Jay_hofmann@trinityconsultants.com 

holmesaems@aol.com 

bhuff@Cinergy.com 

lee.hughes.b@bayer.com 

robert_hyde@merck.com 

dlsaacs@eia.org 

IJaeger@bracepatt.com 

AliceJ@envasns.org 

craigjgc@eei.org 

debra_fezouit@bakerbotts.com 

dkanupke@bdlaw.com 

tina@nemw.org 

nobert_kaufmann@afandpa.org 

deklng@kslaw.com 

Jkinsman@eel.org 

chknauss@swidlaw.com 

Tl 

(O 
*• Krogh, Brandon 

53 Laber, Michael 

54 Lamb, Donna 

** Lane, Debra 

55 Langford, Richard D. 

56 Levine, Mike 

57 Lewis, William 

58 Lilly. Amy 

59 Lopez, Sandra 

** Loredo, Thomas A. 

60 Lucas, Amy 

61 Mannato, Al 

62 Manning, Mike 

** McAngus, Jess 

63 McCarroll, Patrick 

" McCarthy. Colleen 

** McCarthy, Dave 

64 McCture, Jack 

65 McCord, Michael 

** McCultough, Mary 

** McGee. Patricia 

66 Medley, John 

ft ** Miaktsz, Joseph 

" Mohnlng, Donald 

** Morrow, Norman 

68 Moye, Grace 

69 Nickel, Henry 

70 Odoulamy, Judy 

- O'Sudlvan, Bid 

71 Patton, Vickie 

72 Paul, Bernard 

73 Paul, John 

74 Pedersen, William 

** Phibbs, Pat 

75 Praschan, Eugene 

** Quimby, Janice 

76 Rarer, Patrick 

*• Rainey, Robert 

*• Rakiewicz. Roy 

~ Rao. Raj 

77 Reamy. Jeff 

76 Reese. John 

79 Ritts. Leslie 

80 Rosenberg, Errte 

Minnesota Power 

Ford Motor Company 

USDA Forest Service (cc: Rich Fisher) 

Westvaco Corporation 

Celanese 

Portland Cement Industry 

Morrjan, Lewis, & Bockius 

AIAM 

WESTAR 

Reynolds Metals Company 

Waterman & Assoc (Non Ferrows Metal Ind.) 

American Petroleum Institute 

BASF 

Pilko & Assoc Inc 

General Motors Corporation 

NY State DEC 

Indiana Power & Light Co. 

Shell Chemicals 

Morgan Lewis @ Bockius 

McKenna & Cuneo, L.L.P. 

Dupont Corp. 

Mobil Corporation 

Niagara Mohawk Power Corp. 

MidAmerican Energy Company 

Exxon Chemical Americas 

Exxon Chemical Americas 

Hunton & Williams 

Dept. of Energy - GC-1 

N J Dept. of Environmental Protection 

EDF 

Eli Lidy and Company 

RAPCA 

Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 

Air/Water Pollution Report 

formerly AAMA 

Schneder, Harrison, Segal & Lewis 

Hogan & Hartson 

TN Valley Authority 

UA! Group 

NY State DEC 

Phfflips Petroleum 

American Petroleum Institute 

Hogan & Hartson LLP.. NEDA/CARP 

Occidental Petroleum 

One Parklane Blvd, SuHe 728, Parklane Tower East, Dearborn, Ml 48126 

Rocky Mtn. Station, 240 W. Prospect Rd., Fort Collins, CO 80526 

Corp. Env.. Safety & Healthi 1101 Johns Hopkin Road, Laurel, Mb 20723-6006 

PO Box 1000, Narrows, VA 24124 

1800 M Street. NW. 8th Floor Washington. DC 20036 

1001 19th Street, North, SuHe 1200, Arlington, VA 22209 

1001 S.W. 5th Ave.. SuHe 1100. Portland, OR 97204 

2102 Reymet Road, Richmond, VA 23237; aR. fax - 804-285-5335 

900 2nd Street, NNE, Suite 109, Washington, DC 20002 

1220 L Street NW, Ninth Floor. Washington. DC 20005 

3044 West Grand Blvd.. Cose 482112-149, Detroit, Ml 48202 

PO Box 4320, Houston, TX 77210 

1800 M Street, NW Eighth Floor, Washington. DC 20036 

1900 K Street NW. Washington, DC 20006 

1007 Market Street Room D7086, Wilmington, DE 19898 

3225 Gallows Road. Fairfax, VA 22037 

Director, Env. Regulatory Affairs, 300 Erie Blvd. W., Syracuse, NY 13202 

401 Douglas. Sioux, IA 51101 

PO Box 3272, Houston, TX 77253 

13501 Katy Freeway, Houston, TX 77091 

200 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, SuHe 9000, Washington, D.C. 20006 

1000 Independence Ave., SW, Washington, DC 20585 

401 E. State Street PO Box 2027, Trenton, NJ 08625 

Lilly Corp. Center, DC-1013, Indianapolis, IN 46285 

451 W. Third Street Dayton. OH 45422 

2300 N. Street NW, Washington. DC 20037-1128 

8737 Cotesville Road. 11th Floor. Silver Spring, MD 20910 

1600 Market Street SuHe 3600. Philadelphia. PA 19103 

555 13th Street NW, Washington, DC 20004 

1101 Market Street Chattanooga. TN 37405 

6 Commerce Drive. Redding, PA 19608 

Division of Air, 50 Wolfe Road, Albany, NY 12233 

1776 Eye Street NW. Washington. DC 20006 

1220 L Street NW. Suite 900, Washington. DC 20005 

55513th Street NW. Washington, DC 20004 

1747 Pennsylvania Ave.. NW, Washington, DC 20006 

218-723-3954 218-723-3916 bkrogh@exchange1.mnpower.com. 

313-248-2347 313-594-2921 mlaber@ford.com 

970-498-1232 303-498-1010 rfisher@lamar.colostate.edu 

301-497-1284 301-497-1289 ddlane@westvaco.eom 

540-921-6374 540-230-669 rianfor@wpo.hcc.eom 

202-467-7145 

703-525-7788 

503-220-1660 

804-743-6636 

202-898-1444 

202-682-8325 

281-875-3700 

313-556-2142 

518-457-6696 

713-241-3999 

202-467-7431 

202-496-7525 

302-773-0176 

703-849-6193 

315-428-6614 

712-277-7461 

281-870-6122 

281-870-6881 

202-955-1561 

202-586-6399 

609-984-1484 

303-440-4901 

317-276-0331 

937-225-4435 

202-663-8852 

301-587-6300 

215-751-2340 

202-637-5662 

423-751-4425 

610-777-5346 

518-457-7688 

202-833-922 

202-682-8273 

202-637-6573 

202-857-3051 

202-467-7176 Iewl17145@mlb.com 

703-525-8817 alllly@alam.org 

503-220-1651 slopez@westar.org 

804-743-6644 TALoredo@rmccom 

202-898-0264 alucas@dcstrategies.eom 

202-682-8031 mannatoa@api.org 

manninj@basf.com 

Jess@pflko.com 

Inusgmb.wz8kck@gmeds.com 

canccart@gw.dec.state.ny.us 

dmccarthy@ipalco.com 

Jtmcclure@shedus.com 

moc07431 @mlb.com 

mary_mccullough@mckennacuneo.com 

John_h_medley@email.mobil.com 

mlakiszJ@nimo.com 

demonhning@midamerican.com 

norman.l.morrow@exxon.com 

grace.n.moye@exxon.com 

hnickel@hunton.com 

Judy.odoulamy@hq.doe.gov 

wosufliv@dep.state.nJ.us 

Vickie_Patton@edf.org 

bpaul@imy.com 

pauQa@rapca.org 

Blfl_Pederson@shawpHtman.com 

Pphlbbs@bpinews.com 

praschea+adet01%7332724@mdmall.com 

JarUce_quimby@shsl.com 

pmr@dc2.hhlaw.com 

bobralney@tva.gov 

rrakiewicz@uaigroup.com 

rnrao@gw.state.ny.us 

Jmreamy@bvemx.ppco.com 

reesej@apl.org 

Isr@dc2.hhlaw.com 

ernie_rDsenberg@oxy.com 

313-974-5467 

713-241-2494 

202-467-7176 

202-496-7756 

302-774-1189 

703-849-6295 

315-428-3549 

712-277-7366 

281-588-2522 

281-568-2522 

202-778-2201 

202-586-7396 

609-984-6369 

317-276-1800 

937-225-3486 

202-663-8007 

301-587-1081 

215-751-2205 

202-637-5910 

423-751-4738 

610-777-4136 

518-485-6427 

202-785-0715 

202-682-8033 

202-637-5910 

202-657-3040 
81 Russell, Cheryl 

82 Savage, Jackie 

** Schanbacker, David 

" Schneider, Conrad 

83 Shaver, Chris 

84 Shaw, Tony 

85 Shea, Quinlan 

" Shearer, Russell 

" Shinn, Bob 

" Sicuranza, Leo 

86 Siegler, Ellen 

** Slade, John 

" Slater, David 

** Sliwinski, Robert 

** Snyder, Jennifer 

** Stanfietd, Rebecca 

** Stoner, Jim 

** Stolpe, Elizabeth 

** Stroman, Cynthia 

** Taylor, Baron 

** Teetz, Bob 

** Thompson, Chet 

87 Toensrng, Don 

Q 88 Tosi, Louis 

" Trisko, Eugene 

** Tulou, Christophe 

89 Tyndall, William 

** Vemet, Jean 

** Wade, Sarah 

90 Wakelyn. Phil 

** Wallach. Paul 

91 Wallenberg, David 

92 Waskiewtcz, Kathy 

** Walther, Margret 

** Weeks, Ann B. 

93 Wierman, Susan 

•• Wolfe, Samuel A. 

** Wolfe. Thomas 

" Wolman, Marc 

94 Woolbert, Joe 

95 Wyckoff, Peter 

96 Wygonik, Mark 

97 Wyles, Tammy 

98 Wyman, Robert 

Boeing 

Daim'erchrysler Ag 

TX Natural Resource Board 

Clear, Air Task Force 

National Park Service, Air Quality Division 

F&T Network 

National Mining Association 

Squire, Sanders, & Dempsey 

NJ Dept. of the Env. 

U.S. Generating Company 

Hogan & Hartson 

PA Dept. of Environmental Protection 

Thompson Publishing Group 

NY State DEP 

Com Refiners Assoc, Inc 

US PIRG 

Champion International Corp. 

King & Spalding 

Stdley S Auston (Law Firm) 

KeyStan Energy 

Soc of Independant Gasoline Marketers 

US EPA, Region VII 

Shumaker Loop & Kendrick 

Attorney for United Mine Workers of America 

Christophe Tulou Assoc. 

VP/Environmental Services, Cinergy Corp. 

Dept of Energy 

EDF 

National Cotton Council of America 

Hel@Dorrlop 

STAPPA/ALAPCO 

Ford Motor Company 

Coerr Environmental Corp. 

Clean Air Task Force 

Mid-Atlantic Regional Air Management Assoc 

Public Service Electric & Gas Company 

Capital Environmental 

Parsons Engineering Science 

Eastman Chemical Company 

Gardner, Carton & Douglas 

Flexible Packaging Association 

Georgia Pacific (Amer. Forest & Paper Assoc.) 

Latham & Watklns 

800 Chrysler Drive. East [CIMS 482-00-61], Auburn Hill. Ml 48326-2757 

165 Park Row, Brunswick, ME 04011 

PO Box 25287. Denver, CO 80225 

15363 Worth Court, Centreville, VA 20120-3939 

1201 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, PO Box 407, Washington, DC 20044 

One Bowdoin Square, Suite 600, Boston, MA 02114-2910 

55513th Street, Washington, DC 20004 

400 Market St, Rachel Carson State Office Bldg., Harrisburg, PA 17105-8468 

1725 K Street, NW. Suite 700, Washington. DC 20006 

50 Wolf Road, Albany, NY 12233-3251 

218 D Street, SE. Washington, DC 20003 

1S751 Street, Ste. 540, Washington, DC 20006 

170 Pennsylvania Ave.. NW, Washington, DC 20006 

445 Broadholtow Road, Melville. NY 11747 

(Collier, Shannon, Rill. & Scott) 

726 Minnesota Ave.. Kansas City, KS 66101 

PO Box 596, Berkeley Springs, WV 25411 

2122 California Street. NW, SuHe 655, Washington, DC 20008 

139 East Fourth Street Room 500-M, Cincinnati, OH 45201 

1521 New Hampshire Ave., NE, Washington, DC 20002 

14 Pennsylvania Ave, NW, Washington, DC 20004 

444 N. Capitol Street, NW, SuHe 307, Washington, DC 20001 

SuHe 1400 Parklane Towers East, One Parklane Blvd., Dearborn, Ml 48126-2477 

230 Congress Street, Boston, VA 02110 

711 West 40th Street, Suite 318, Baltimore, MD 21211 

80 Park Plaza, 17G. Newark, MY 07102-4194 

1299 Pennsylvania AVE, NW, Washington, DC 20002 

Air Sciences Group, 30 Dan Road, Canton, MA 02021-2809 

PO Box 7444. Longview, TX 75607-7444 

1301 K Street NW. Washington, DC 20005 

1090 Vermont Ave., N.W., SuHe 500, Washington, DC 20005-4960 

133 Peachtreet Street NE, Atlanta, GA 30303 

633 West Fifth Street Los Angeles, CA 90071 

703-465-3613 

248-576-8054 

512-239-1228 

201-721-8676 

303-969-2074 

703-815-01027 

202-463-9793 

202-626-6612 

617-788-3686 

202-637-5728 

717-787-4325 

202-739-9551 

518-457-2823 

202-331-1634 

202-546-9707 

703-465-3034 cheryt.a.russell@boeing.com 

248-576-7928 Jas28@chrysler.com 

207-721-8696 

303-969-2822 

703-815-01043 

202-463-3257 

202-626-6780 

617-788-3150 

202-637-5910 

202-739-9578 

518-457-794 

202-546-2461 

202-785-9888 202-785-3286 

312-853-4717 

516-391-6133 

202-342-8815 

913-551-7446 

313-594-7752 

304-258-1977 

913-387-9440 

513-287-3522 

202-387-3500 

202-745-7805 

202-942-8429 

202-624-7864 

313-594-7752 

919-932-3840 

617-292-0288 

410-467-0246 

973-430-3709 

202-383-6919 

781-401-2112 

903-237-5475 

202-408-7149 

202-842-3880 

404-652-7281 

213-891-8334 

516-591-6079 

313-248-5030 

304-258-3927 

202-387-9445 

513-287-3499 

202-483-4040 

202-942-8484 

313-248-50*3 

617-292-4933 

410-467-1737 

973-565-525 

781-401-2043 

903-237-6318 

202-289-1504 

202-84203841 

404-654-4695 

213-891-8763 

cshneider@ime.net 

chris_shaver@nps.gov 

tshaw37@aol.com 

qshea@nma.org 

cshearer@ssd.com 

rshlnn@dep.state.nj.us 

LSicuran@BOSTON.USGEN.com 

eslegler@hhlaw.com 

slade.John@a1 dep.state.pa.us 

david_slater@thompson.com 

rgsliwin@gw.decstate.ny.us 

Jsrryder@com.org 

beckystan@pirg.org 

stolpe@champint.com 

cstroman@kslaw.com 

bftaylor@sidtey.com 

teetzrd@keystanenergy.com 

cthompson@colshan.com 

toenslng.don@epa.gov 

ltosi@slk-law.com 

emtrisko@intreprid.net 

ctulou@erols.com 

Jean.vemet@hq.doe.gov 

pwakelyn@cotton.org 

paul.wallach@heloorr.com 

ktvaskiew@ford.com 

mbw@coerr.com 

aweeks@clnatf.org 

swlerman@marama.org 

samuel.wolfe@pseg.com 

wotfet@howrey.com 

marc_wolman@parsons.com 

woolbert@eastman.com 

pwyckoff@gcd.com 

fpa@flexpack.org 

trwyles@gapac.com 

robert.wyman@lw.com