# OAR Box 1781 Prepped by Ollie Stewart



# Document

Number: 

# 129 ) IV-C-4

3

Docket Number: 

# A-90-3 7 p. i 

## 1

Printed 10/29/2008 10:46:24

AM Sheet 129 of 142

### P. 2



# >* 08 

# X i UNITE D STATE S ENVIRONMENTA L PROTECTIO N AGENC Y RESEARC H TRIANGL E PARK , N C 2771 1



# Dea r Participants : JA N I 5 I99 9

EP AAI R DOCKE T OFFIC E O F AI R QUALITY PLANNIN G AN D STANDARD S



# Thi s i s t o announc e ameetin g o f stakeholder s wh o ar

e intereste di n me applicabilit y provision s o f

Ne w Sourc e Review (NSR) Reform , apreconstructio n review permittin g progra m unde r the Clea n Air Act

. The meetin g wil l b e hel do n Februar y 2-3,199 9 a

t th e J.W

. Marriot

t Hotel (133 1 Pennsylvani aAvenue , Northwest) i n Washington , D.C , beginnin g a t 10:00 a.m. , on Tuesday , Februar

y 2 , an da t 9:00 a.m. , Wednesday , Februar y 3 , an dending n o later

ma n 12:0 0 noon on Wednesday , Februar y 3

. The purpos e of

thi s meetin g wil l b e to discus s ane w approachto NS Rapplicability

. Attachedi s a1-pag

e outlin e o f

conceptua l requirement s an

dassociatedissue s tha

t hav e been suggestedto dat

e (Attachmen

t 1)

. Intereste dstakeholder s ar e invite dt o present , a

t tiiis meeting , a n approachfo

r implementing th e concept

. W e woul dals o encourag e presenter s to include consideration of

th e question s (Attachmen

t 2 ) tha t hav e been identifiedi n interna l Environmenta

l Protectio n Agency (EPA ) discussions

. The EP A i s willin g t

o pursu e sucha

n approachi f

it ha s promise

. W

e wil l evaluat

e th e approache s discusse db y early Marchanddecide whether w e wil l sustai n th e effor

t on me new approac hor resum e wor k on th e current

fina l NS RRefor

mrulemaking package

. In concer t wit h thi s decision , w e wil l als o evaluat e option s fo

r obtainin g furthe

r stakeholde

r input

. Plan s fo r ho w th e meeting will b e run ar e stil l unde

r discussio n withi n EPA

. Ther e i s uncertaint y a s to how man

y attendee s wil l b e present , an dther e ar e constraint s a s t o th e siz e o f th e meeting room . Initial thought s ar e tha t a t th e table , whic hwil l sea

t about 40-4 5 people , a

n equa l numbe r o f seat s wil l b e made availabl e t o representative s from: (1 ) th e industria l sector , (2 ) th e publi c interes t

groups , (3 ) Stat

e andloca l governments , an

d(4 ) th e Federa

l government

. W

e d o no t anticipat e tha t w e wil l b e abl e t o provide more tha n one sea t a t th e tabl e fo

r eachindustria

l sector

. Ther

e wil l b e additiona

l seating , theate

r style , in th e meeting room , availabl e on afirst com e first serve dbasis , fo

r abou t 5 0 people

. T o the exten

t possible , everyone who wishe s to spea k will hav e a

n opportunity

. A n addres s lis t

o f person s who ar

e bein g sen

t thi s lette r i s als o attache d(Attachmen t 3 ) an da n annoucemen

t wil l b e publishe di n th e Federa l Register

. It

i s als o bein g place don th e Offic e o f Air andRadiation' s Internet

website : (http://www.epa.gov/oar/oarnew.html ) an dm e NS Rwebsit

e (http://www.epa.gov/ttn/nsr/rule_dev.html)

. I f yo u know o f someone who ma

y not hav e receive dthi s lette

r bu t i s intereste di n participatin g i n suc ha n effort, fee

l free t o contac t them

. 

# I

Recycled/Recyclabl e (Printe d wit h Vegetabl e Oi l Base d Ink s o n 100 % Recycle d Pape r (40 % Postconsumer )

### P. 3



# Du e to th e unavailabilit

y o f sleeping room s a

t th e J.W

. Marriott , abloc k

o f room s ha s been reserveda

t th e Hotel Washingto n (51 5 15t hStreet , Northwest) , whic hi s ashor t distanc e awa y fromth e J.W

. Marriot

t Hotel

. The telephon e numbe r a t th e Hotel Washingto n i s (202 ) 638-590 0 an

dmentio n shoul db e made o f th e EP A Clea n Air Act meetin g when reservin g aroom . If yo u wis hto attendth e meeting , pleas e E-mail or call Pa mSmith , a

t E-mai l addres s "smith.pam@epa.gov " or

telephon e numbe

r (919 ) 541-0641 , b y Januar y 28

. It woul dals o b e helpfu l if yo u indicate whethe

r you pla n to giv e apresentation

. I f you hav e furthe

r question s regarding th e stakeholde

r meetin g on Februar

y 2-3 , yo

u ma y cal l Denni s Crumple

r a t (919 ) 541-087 1 or

Karen Blanchar

da t (919 ) 541-5503

.

Director Office o f Air Qualit y Plannin g andStandard s Attachment s (3 ) 1

. 1-Pag e Outline 2

. Question s 3

. Addresse e Lis t

### P. 4



# Attachmen

t 1



# A Ne w Approac

h to NS RApplicabilit

y
Th e basi c goa

l i s to reduc e emission s t

o acertain level , e.g. , BAC T o r LAER , fo r existin g source s tha

t currently hav e n o or

littl e emission contro l a

t som e fixeddate i n time , i n th e future

. Thi s wouldb e done either

throughadd-on technology or pollutio n prevention

. Majo r greenfield source s wouldstil l b e subject to curren t Ne w Sourc e Review (NSR) requirements

. Nettin g a s i t i s conductedtoda

y woul db e eliminated

. Criteri aan dissue s base don preliminar y discussion s include :

• The tes t

fo r applicabilit

y shouldb e asingl e se

t o f criteri atha

t i s eas y t o implemen t an denforce ;

• Provide a

n exemption fromman

y NS Rmodification s fo

r afixedperio dof

time (e.g. , 1 0 year s from1999)

. A t th e endo f tha t perio dNSR , meanin g th e applicatio n o f

BACT or LAER , woul dapply t o al l majo r unit s a t th e source . Som e lea dtime wouldb e provide dfo r source s t o instal l control s or retir e th e facility

.

• NS Rapplicabilit

y a s i s currently conductedwoul db e suspende dwit hth e following exceptions : Fo r modification s t o existin g units , EP A woul da t leas t continu e to review reconstructio n andmajo

r capacit y expansion s but

examin e th e possibilit

y o f temporarily exempting lesse r modification s fromNSR ; BACT/LAE

Ron al l ne

w emission s unit s and/or

reconstructio n an

dmajo r capacit y expansion s wouldstil l b e required

.

• Al l non-NS Rrequirement s o f th e Clea n Air Act andimplementatio n schedule s fo r attainin g heaUh-basedstandard s wouldremain unaffectedb y thi s new approach (e.g

. SIP requirements , Titl e IV , MACT etc.)

.

• Othe

r desirabl e outcome s ar

e to : Reduc e the incidenc e o f

case-by-cas e BAC T determinations—fo r example , establis hpresumptiv e BACT fo r specifi c industr

y sectors ; Factor improvement s in efficiency improvement s andpollutio n preventio n into BACT/LAE

Rdecisions—fo

r example , i f

larg e improvement s ar

e derive dbut

th e highes t

contro l level s ar

e no t achieved , shoul d BACT/LAE

Rb e afunction o f

air quality ?

### P. 5



# Relate dIssues : Wha t happen s fo

r source s i n sector s tha

t do no t hav e apresumptiv e BAC T established ? Ho w d o w e stimulat

e th e developmen

t or evolutio n o f

more effective contro l technologie s andP2 ? Ho w woul dEP

A an dpermittin g authorit

y dea l wit hth e possibilit

y o f hundred s o f

application s coming in on one date ? Ho w shouldreconstructio n b e definedfo r th e purpose s o f

NSR ?

### P. 6



# Attachmen

t 2
Question s Question s fo

r consideratio n in developing idea s fo r ane w applicabilit

y approachar

e liste d below : 1

. Wouldgrandfathering en don afixedcalenda

r date ? Ho w wouldEP

A andth e State s verif y evidenc e (vi aapermit) o f complianc e by th e severa

l thousan dsource s subject

t o th e requirement s a s o f

aparticula

r point i n time ? Wouldsom

e other triggerin g mechanis mb e employedsuc ha s the expectedlif

e o f th e facilit y or oldes t emission s units , or th e firs t modificatio n afte

r afixeddate , o r

som e combinatio n o f

these ? 2

. I f grandfathering wer

e t o en don afixeddat

e wha t woul dtha t dat e be ? 3

. What , exactly , trigger s NS Ra t th e en ddate ? The mer

e reachin g o f

tha t date , or som e even t a t th e sourc e afte

r th e enddat

e sucha s aphysica

l modification ? 4

. What , exactly , i s th e obligatio n whe n NS Ri s eventually triggered ? BAC T or LAE R depending on are aattainmen t status ? Coul dthe fac

t tha t aunit installe dBACT/LAE

Ri n th e pas t influenc e th e technology requirement , an di f so , b y how much ? 5

. I s apresumptiv e BACT / LAE Rrequiremen

t feasible ? Wha

t mechanism s ca

n EP A us e t o ensur e tha t contro l technologie s an

dpollutio n preventio n evolve ? For exampl e ar

e ther e way s to ge t more submittal s t o th e RACT/BACT/LAE RClearinghouse ? 6

. I s ther

e astatutor

y basi s fo r sucha n approach ? Ar

e there relate dissue s tha

t in orde r t o resolv e wil l lea

dto ates t tha t i s a s complex a s th e existin g one ? 7

. Wha

t other alternative s t o thi s approachshoul db e considered ? Thes e might include declining emissio n cap s or

othe r market-base dapproache s whic hset a n area-wide , statewide , or

regiona l emission s ca

p a t acertain level a

t acertain point

i n time , whil e still guarding agains t

loca l advers e impacts

. 8

. How doe s th e new approachfo r NS Rfit wit hefforts t o encourag e utilitie s t o voluntarily increas e efficiencie s o f

generatin g electri c powe

r andengag e in other

carbon emissio n reductio n efforts ? 9

. Ca n suc ha n approachb e supportedb y asufficientl y wid e numbe

r o f stakeholde

r group s to conclude tha

t i t ha s asignifican

t chanc e fo r bein g promulgate di n areasonabl e time frame?

### P. 7



# 10

. I f ther e i s widesprea

dsuppor t fo r ane w applicabilit

y tes t an dEP A decide s to mov e forward , ho w shouldth e EP A handl e som

e o f th e non-applicabilit

y issue s addresse di n th e current

NS RRefor

mrulemaking ? 11

. Shouldthi s approachb e mandatory ? Shouldi t completely replac e th e current systemor b e adiscretionar

y option ?
12

. Wha

t ar e th e consequences , eithe

r positiv e or

negativ e o f

ending netting ?

# NS R REFOR M i i STAKEHOLDE R MEMBER S Attachmen t 3

Updated ; 2/1/9 9 

# ("Thi s listin g i s stil l bein g updated.** )



# V NAM E 1 Alexius, Bruc

e 2 Amar , Pravee n 3 Anderson , Danie l P

.

' * Atay , Icla l

' * Ayres , Richard , Esq

. 4 Babos , Michae l 5 Bankoff , Barbar a 6 Barr , Michae l 7 Bates , Christin e 8 Becker , Juli e 9 Becker , Willia m 1 0 Bekfen , Ro y

* Berwick , An n 1 1 Bessette , Rober

t 1 2 Bobal , Rene e 1 3 Borrasca , Adeli a 1 4 Bowers , Terr

y 1 5 Brantley

. W

. Phi l 1 6 Broome , Shanno n 1 7 Browned , Willia m

* * Brubacker , Robert

* * Brunton , Jac k 1 8 Bumpers , Willia m

* * Burke , Jol e 1 9 Burkhart , Willia m 2 0 Burred , Laur a 2 1 Burtschi , Mar k 2 2 Carhart , Bruc e 2 3 Carney

. Mar k

* * Carter , To m

* * Cordes , Richar d 2 4 Cox

. Bett y 2 5 Cromwell , Te d 2 6 Dege , Joh n

* • Dewbury , Maxin e 2 7 Dionne

. Eda n

• * Dobriansky , Laris a 2 8 Dunn , Alexandr a 

### AFFILIATIO N bo w< :hemica l NESCAU M Chemica l Firs t NJDfc P Howre y& Simo n Merc k & Compan y Siemen s Corporatio n Plllsbury , Madiso n & Sutr o Genera l Motor s Argonau t (A-205-H ) formerl yAAM A STAPPA/ALAPC O Chadboum e & Park e M

. J

. Bradle yAssoc

. Counci l o f Industria l Boile rOwner s

Helle rEhrma n Whit e & McAuliff e Dept

. o f Defens e SESAR M & METRO ; Attn : Burea u o f Ai rQualit y Genera l Electri cCompan y Hunto n & William s Porter , Wright , Morri s & Autho r Sempr e Energ y Bake r& Bott s

Procto r& Gambl e Chemica l Manufacture s Asso c Nationa l Assoc , o f Manufacturer s Ozon e Transport Commissio n U S Generatin g CoVEG A America n Portlan d Cemen t Affianc e Minnesot a Pollutio n Contro l Agenc y America n Petroleu m Institut e Chemica l Manufacturer s Asso c Dupon t Procto r& Gambl e IB M Acki n Gum p Straus s Haure rFiel d La wFir m CM A 

### APJJRES S P S Box150 , Bldg

. 3502E , Plaquemine , L A 70765-015 0 12 9 Portlan d Street , Boston , M A0217 3 P O Bo x7005 , Pascagoula , M S 3956 8 40 1 Eas t Stat e Street , Trenton

. N J 0862 5 129 9 Pennsylvani a Ave. , NW , Washington , D C 2000 2 Centra l Env

. Resources , P O Box100 , Whit e Hous e Station , N Y 0888 9 70 1 Pennsylvani a Ave. , Suit e 720 , Washington , D C 2000 4 Naf I Assoc , o f Manufacturers , 22 5 Bus h Street , Sa n Francisco , C A 9410 4 48 5 W

. Milwaukee

. Detroit , M l 4820 2

44 4 N

. Capito l Street , NW , Suit e 307 , Washington , D C 2000 1 120 0 Ne wHampshir e Ave.

. NW

. Washington , D C 20036-680 2 4 7 Junctio n Squar e Drive , Concord , M A07014 2 603 5 Burk e Centr e Parkway , Suit e 360 , Burke

. V A22015-375 7

81 5 Connecticu t Avenue

. NW , Suit e 200 , Washington

. D C 2000 6

260 0 Bul l Street

. Columbia , S C 2920 1 313 5 Easto n Turnpike , Fairfield , C T 0643 1 190 0 KStreet , NW , Suit e 1200 , Washington , D C 2000 6 4 1 Sout h Hig h Street

. Columbus

. O H 4321 5 10 1 As h Street

. Sa n Diego

. C A9210 1 129 9 Pennsylvani a Ave. , Washington , D C 2000 4 (x351 ) Wlnto n Hi d Technica l Center , 611 0 Cente rHi d Ave. , Cincinnati , O H 4522 4 130 0 Wilso n Blvd.

. Arlington , V A2220 9 133 1 Pennsylvani a Ave.

. NW , Suit e 600 , Washington , D C 2000 4 44 4 N

. Capito l SL

. NW , Suit e 604 , Washington , D C 2000 1 750 0 Ol d Georgetow n Rd. , Bethesda

. M D 2071 4 122 5 Ey e Stree t NW

. Suit e 300 , Washington , D C 2000 5 52 0 Lafayett e Road , S L Paul , M N 5515 5 122 0 L Stree t NW , Washington

. D C 2000 5 130 0 Wilso n Blvd.

. Arlington , V A2220 9 100 7 Marke t Stree t N2S18-1 , Wilmington , D E 1989 8 Winto n H8 1 Technica l Center

. 611 0 Cente rHi D Ave.

. Cincinnati

. O H 4522 4 Bldg

. 1

. M/ D 2393

. Rout e 100 , P O Bo x100 , Somers

. N Y 1058 9 133 3 Ne wHampshir e Ave.

. NW

. Washington

. D C 2003 6 130 0 Wilso n Blvd.

. Arflngton

. V A 2220 9 

### 202-624-7864 202-624-786 3 202-974-572 6 202-974-560 2 978-369-553 3 976-369-771 2 703-250-904 2 703-239-904 2 PHONE
. EA X E-mai l 225-353-884 4 225-353-800 1 balexius@dow.co m 617-367-854 0 617-742-916 2 pmar@nescaum.or g 228-938-222 7 228-938-273 4 danderson@chemfirst.co m 609-984-051 5 609-984-636 9 latay@dep.state.nj.u s 202-383-677 8 ayresR@howrey.co m 908-423-781 2 908-735-110 9 michael_babos@merck.co m 202-434-481 0 202-347-136 1 babankof@erols.co m 415-983-115 1 415-983-120 0 ban-_mr@pillsburylaw.co m 313-556-788 5 313-556-762 9 Inusgmb.nzr1vr@gmeds.co m beckerj@ix.netcome.co m b4clnalr@sso.or g roy.belden@chadbourne.co m aberwick@mjbradly.co m bessette@cibo.or g renee.bobal@roche.co m 202-785-626 7 202-785-887 7 aborrasca@hewm.co m 703-602-476 9 703-602-554 7 bowers.terry@hq.navy.mi l 803-898-411 6 803-898-402 2 brantlwp@columb31.dhecstate.sc.u s 202-373-357 5 202-373-338 9 shannon.broome@corporate.ge.co m 202-955-155 5 202-778-220 1 bbrownell@hunton.com 614-227-203 3 614-227-210 0 rbnjbacker@porterwright.co m 619-696-250 9 Jbrunton@sempra.co m 202-639-771 8 202-639-789 0 william_bumpers@bakerbotts.co m 202-775-025 2 513-634-636 6 513-634-548 1 burkhartwt@pg.eo m 703-741-524 7 703-741-524 7 laura_burrell@cmahq.eo m 202-637-317 6 202-637-318 2 mburtschl@nam.or g 202-508-384 0 202-508-384 1 ozone@sso.or g 301-718-689 9 301-718-690 1 mcamey@usgen.co m 202-408-949 4 202-408-67 7 tcarter@apca.or g 651-296-815 7 richard.cordes@pca.state.mn.u s 202-682-825 0 202-682-825 0 cox@api.or g 703-741-524 6 703-741-624 6 ted_cfomwell@crnariq.co m 302-773-90 0 302-774-136 1 Jchn.a.dege@usa.dupontco m

914-766-272 9 914-766-282 4 dionne@vnetibm.co m 202-887-436 3 202-887-428 8 tdobriansky@ackin.co m 703-741-515 6 703-741-609 2 alexandra_dunn@cmahq.co m

0 0

# of c * * Dykes , Teres a

* * Edgemon , Kath y

* * Egan , Joh n 2 9 Emery , Davi d 3 0 Faulstich , Ji m 3 1 Feldcamp , Larr

y

* * Fontaine , Jo e

* * Fotis
. Steve 3 2 Frye , Russel l 3 3 Fulmer , Jerr

y

* * Ganguli , Anupo m

* * Gleason , Jef

f

* * Golson , Glen n 3 4 Grice , Michae l 3 5 Grumet , Jaso n

" Hansel , Mik

e 3 6 Harper , Stev e 3 7 Harris , Joh n 3 8 Hatcher , Juli a 3 9 Hawkins , Davi d

* * Hedman , Susa n

* * Helme , Ne d 4 0 Hmiel , To m 4 1 Hodanbosi , Rober

t

" Hoffman , Patrici a

' * Hofmann , Ja y 4 2 Holmes , Joh n G
. 4 3 Holt , Alexandra

' * Huff , Bernard 4 4 Hughes , Le e 4 5 Hyde , Rober

t 4 6 Isaacs , Davi d 4 7 Jaeger , Lisa

* Jacobsohn , Alic e 4 8 Jakubowics , Crai g

* Jezouit , Debr a 4 9 Jones , Gar

y

* Kanupke , Davi d

* Kaarsberg , Tin a 5 0 Kaufmann , Rober

t

* King , Debbi e

* Kinsman , Johr i 5 1 Knauss , Chuc k 5 2 Kochenderfer , Kari l Howre y & Simo n Cargil l Fertilizer , Inc
. Earthre s Group , Inc
. Phillips Petroleu m Hercule s Inc
. Bake r i Bori s N H Dept
. of Environmenta l Services SanNes s Fieldma n Chadboum e & Park

e fo r Alco a SCQMD , Senio r Mgr
. Souther n Environementa l La wCente r A L Dep t of Environmenta l Managmen t DaimlerChrysle r A G NESCAU M Koc h INTE L AMOC O Latha m & Watkln s Nat' l Resource s Defens e Counci l Environmenta l La

w& Polic

y Cente r Cente r fo r Clea n Ah

- Polic y BAS F Ohi o EP A DO E - Cogeneratio n Progra m Manage r Trinit y Consultants AEM S (fo r DaimlerChrysler ) Chicag o Dept
. Environmen t AEM S (fo r DaimlerChrysler ) Baye r Corporatio n Merc k & Compan y Electoni c Industrie s Alliance Bracewel l & Patterson , L.L.P
. Nationa l Soli d Waste s Mgm t Asso c Ediso n Electri c Institute Baker * Boris , LLP
. Graphi c Arts Technica l Foundatio n Beveridg e & Diamon d (LawFirm ) Northeast-Midwest Institut e America n Fores

t & Pape r Kin g & Spaldin g Ediso n Electri c Institute Swidle r Berli n Sheref

f Friedma n America n Textil e Manufacturer s Inst
. 129 9 Pennsylvani a Ave. , NW , Washington , D C 2000 2

881 3 Hwy
. 4 1 South , Riverview , F L 3356 9 713 7 Ol d Easto n Rd , Pipperfield , PA 1894 7 1 2 A 2 Phillips Bldg. , Bartlesville , O K7400 4 Hercules Plaza , Wilmington , D E 1989 4 On e Shel l Plaza , 91 0 Louisiana , Houston , T X 7700 2 6 4 Nort h Mai n Street , P O Bo x 2033 , Concord , N H 03302-203 3 105 0 Thomas Jefferso n Street , Suit e 700 , Washington , D C 2000 7 120 0 Chadborn e & Parke , LLP , Washington , D C 20036-680 2 266 9 Cedarvu e Drive , Pittsburgh , PA 1524 1 - fa x sam e a s phon e tt VO C Rules & NSR
. 2186 5 E
. Cople y Dr. , Diamon d Bar
. CA 91765-418 2 20 1 Wes t Mai n Street , Suit e 14 , Charlottesville , V A 2290 2 P O Bo x 301463 , Montgomery , A L 3613 0 100 0 Chrysle r Driv

e [CIM S 485-14-18] , Aubur n Hills
. M l 48326-276 6 12 9 Portlan d Street , Boston , M A 0211 4 P O Bo x 64596 , S t Paul
. M N 55164-059 6

100 1 Pennsylvani a Avenue , NW , Suite 1300 , Washington , D C 20004-250 5 135 0 NewYor k

Ave. , NW , Suit

e 300 , Washington , D C 2000 5 3 5 East Wacke r Drive , Chicago , I L 6060 2 75 0 1s t Stree t NE , Suit

e 1140 , Washington , D C 2000 2

P O Bo x 1049 , Columbus
. O H 43216-014 9 100 0 Independence Ave. , SW , Washington
. D C 20585-012 1 1280 1 N
. Centra l Expressway , Suit e 1200 , Dallas , TX 7524 3 435 0 N
. Fairfa

x Dr. , Suite 300 , Arlington , V A 2220 3

P O Bo x 960 , M D 552-A , Cincinnati , O H 4520 1 10 0 Baye r Road , Pittsburgh
. P A 1520 5 On e Merc k

Dr. , P O Bo

x 10 0 (Code : W53B05) , WhH e House Station
. N Y 0888 9 250 0 Wilso n Boulevard
. Arlington , V A 22201-383 4 200 0 KStreet , NW
. Suit e 500 , Washington , D C 2000 6 430 1 Connecticu t Ave. , NW , Suit e 300 , Washington , D C 2000 8

129 9 Pennsylvani a Ave. , Washington , D C 2000 4 20 0 Dee r Ru n Road
. Sewickley , P A 15143-260 0 1350 1 Stree t NW
. Suit

e 700 , Washington
. D C 2000 5 21 8 D Street , SE , Washington , D C 2000 3 (ext
. 3028 ) 111 1 19t h Street , NW , Suite 800
. Washington , D C 2003 6 173 0 Pennsylvani a Ave. , NW , Washington , D C 2000 6 70 1 Pennsylvani a Ave. , NW , .Washington , D C 2000 4 300 0 K Stree t NW , Suit

e 300 , Washington , D C 2000 7 202-383^691 9 813-671-636 9 215-766-121 1 918-661-304 1 302-594-762 6 713-229-157 3 603-271-679 4 202-298-190 8 202-974-563 6 412-851-077 7 909-396-318 5 804-977-409 0 334-271-786 1 248-512-412 4 617-367-854 0 651-437-62 7 202-628-383 8

202-637-223 8 202-289-686 8 312-759-340 0 202-408-926 0 973-426-262 4 614-614-227 0 202-586-607 4 972-661-810 0 703-516-244 4 312-744-314 2 513-287-388 4 412-777-222 1 908-423-399 4 703-907-757 6 202-828-584 7 202-364-372 4 202-508-562 0 202-639-772 8 412-741-686 0 202-789-611 5 202-544-520 0 202-463-258 8 202-626-373 7 202-508-571 1 202-424-764 4 202-862-065 6 813-671-614 9

215-766-124 5 918-661-614 6 302-594-599 6 713-229-152 2

202-298-190 8 202-974-560 2 412-851-077 7 909-396-332 4 804-977-148 3 334-279-304 4 248-512-92 6 617-742-916 2 651-437-86 8 202-628-252 5

202-637-220 1 202-783-591 7 312-332-158 0 202-408-889 6 973-426-262 2 614-644-368 1 202-586-165 8 972-385-920 3 703-524-485 4 312-744-645 1

412-777-306 3 908-423-132 2 703-907-750 1 202-223-122 5 202-364-379 2 202-508-567 3 202-639-789 0 412-741-231 1 202-789-619 0 202-544-004 3 220-463-242 3 202-626-544 9 202-508-515 0 202-424-764 3 202-862-064 6 dykes@howrey.co m

Kathy_Edgermon@cargill.co m Jeagan@earthris.co m dtemery@bvemx.ppco.co m Jfaulstich@herc.co m Iarry_feldcamp@bakertx3tts.co m l_fontaine@des.state.nh.u s njssell.frye@chadboume.co m JBfulmer@aol.co m aganguli@aqmd.gov jgteason@selcva.or g ggg@adem.state.al.u s mwgrice@chrysler.geis.co m Jgrumet@nescaum.org hanselM@kochin d .co m Stephen , harper@intel.co m John_d_harris@amoco.co m Julla.hatcher@LW.co m dhawkins@nrdc.or g shedman@elpc.or g nhelme@ccap.or g hmieH@basf.co m bob_hodanbosl@central.epa.ohio.gov Patricia.Hoffman@ee.doe.go v Jay_hofmann@trinityconsultants.co m holmesaems@aol.co m bhuff@Cinergy.co m lee.hughes.b@bayer.co m robert_hyde@merck.co m dlsaacs@eia.or g IJaeger@bracepatt.co m AliceJ@envasns.or g craigjgc@eei.or g debra_fezouit@bakerbotts.co m dkanupke@bdlaw.co m tina@nemw.or g nobert_kaufmann@afandpa.org deklng@kslaw.co m Jkinsman@eel.org chknauss@swidlaw.co m

T l ( O* •Krogh , Brando n

5 3 Laber , Michae l 5 4 Lamb , Donn a

* * Lane , Debr a 5 5 Langford , Richar

d D
. 5 6 Levine , Mik

e 5 7 Lewis , Willia m 5 8 Lilly
. Am y 5 9 Lopez , Sandra

* * Loredo , Thoma s A
. 6 0 Lucas , Am y 6 1 Mannato , A l 6 2 Manning , Mik

e

* * McAngus , Jes s 6 3 McCarroll , Patric k

" McCarthy
. Collee n

* * McCarthy , Dave 6 4 McCture , Jac k 6 5 McCord , Michae l

* * McCultough , Mary

* * McGee
. Patrici a 6 6 Medley , Joh n ft * * Miaktsz , Josep h

" Mohnlng , Donal d

* * Morrow , Norma n 6 8 Moye , Grac e 6 9 Nickel , Henr y 7 0 Odoulamy , Judy

- O'Sudlvan , Bid 7 1 Patton , Vicki e 7 2 Paul , Bernard 7 3 Paul , Joh n 7 4 Pedersen , Willia m

* * Phibbs , Pa t 7 5 Praschan , Eugen e

* * Quimby , Janic e 7 6 Rarer , Patric k

* •Rainey , Rober

t

* •Rakiewicz
. Ro

y

~ Rao
. Ra j 7 7 Reamy
. Jef

f 7 6 Reese
. Joh n 7 9 Ritts
. Lesli e 8 0 Rosenberg , Errt e Minnesota Powe r For d Moto r Compan y USD A Fores

t Service (cc : Ric h Fisher ) Westvac o Corporatio n Celanes e Portlan d Cemen t Industr y Morrjan , Lewis , & Bockiu s AIA M WESTA R Reynold s Metal s Compan y Waterma n & Asso c (No n Ferrow s Meta l Ind. ) America n Petroleu m Institut e BAS F Pilk o & Asso c In c Genera l Motor

s Corporatio n N Y Stat e DE C Indian a Powe r & Ligh t Co
. Shel l Chemical s Morga n Lewi s @ Bockiu s McKenn a & Cuneo , L.L.P
. Dupon t Corp
. Mobi l Corporatio n Niagara Mohaw k

Powe r Corp
. MidAmerica n Energ y Compan y Exxo n Chemica l America s Exxo n Chemica l America s Hunto n & William s Dept
. o f Energ y - GC- 1 N J Dept
. o f Environmenta l Protectio n ED F El i Lid y an d Compan y RAPCA Shaw , Pittman , Potts & Trowbridg e Air/Wate r Pollutio n Repor t formerl y AAM A Schneder , Harrison , Sega l & Lewi s Hoga n & Hartso n T N Valle y Authorit

y UA ! Grou p N Y Stat e DE C Phfflip s Petroleu m America n Petroleu m Institut e Hoga n & Hartso n LLP.
. NEDA/CAR P Occidenta l Petroleu m On e Parklan e Blvd , SuH e 728 , Parklan e Towe r East , Dearborn , M l 4812 6 Rock y Mtn
. Station , 24 0 W
. Prospec t Rd. , For

t Collins , C O 8052 6 Corp
. Env.
. Safet

y & Health i 110 1 John s Hopki n Road , Laurel , M b 20723-600 6 P O Bo x 1000 , Narrows , V

A 2412 4

180 0 M Street
. NW
. 8t h Floo r Washington
. D C 2003 6 100 1 19t h Street , North , SuHe 1200 , Arlington , V A 2220 9 100 1 S.W
. 5t h Ave.
. SuHe 1100
. Portland , O R 97204 210 2 Reyme

t Road , Richmond , V

A 23237 ; aR
. fa

x - 804-285-533 5 90 0 2n d Street , NNE , Suite 109 , Washington , D C 2000 2 122 0 L Stree t NW , Nint h Floor
. Washington
. D C 2000 5

304 4 West Gran d Blvd.
. Cos e 482112-149 , Detroit , M l 4820 2

P O Bo x 4320 , Houston , TX 7721 0 180 0 M Street , N W Eight h Floor , Washington
. D C 2003 6 190 0 KStree t NW
. Washington , D C 2000 6 100 7 Marke

t Stree t Roo m D7086 , Wilmington , D E 1989 8 322 5 Gallow

s Road
. Fairfax , V A 2203 7 Director , Env
. Regulator y Affairs , 30 0 Eri e Blvd
. W. , Syracuse , N Y 1320 2 40 1 Douglas
. Sioux , I A 5110 1 P O Bo x 3272 , Houston , TX 7725 3 1350 1 Kat

y Freeway , Houston , TX 7709 1 20 0 Pennsylvani a Ave. , NW , SuH e 9000 , Washington , D.C
. 2000 6 100 0 Independence Ave. , SW , Washington , D C 2058 5 40 1 E
. Stat e Stree t P O Bo x 2027 , Trenton , N J 0862 5

Lilly Corp
. Center , DC-1013 , Indianapolis , I N 4628 5 45 1 W
. Thir

d Stree t Dayton
. O H 4542 2 230 0 N
. Stree t NW , Washington
. D C 20037-112 8 873 7 Cotesvill e Road
. 11t h Floor
. Silve r Spring , M D 2091 0

160 0 Market Stree t SuH e 3600
. Philadelphia
. P A 1910 3 55 5 13t h Stree t NW , Washington , D C 2000 4 110 1 Marke

t Stree t Chattanooga
. T N 3740 5 6 Commerce Drive
. Redding , P A 1960 8 Divisio n of Air , 50 Wolfe Road , Albany , N Y 1223 3 177 6 Eye Stree t NW
. Washington
. D C 2000 6 122 0 L Stree t NW
. Suite 900 , Washington
. D C 2000 5 55513t h Stree t NW
. Washington , D C 2000 4 174 7 Pennsylvani a Ave.
. NW , Washington , D C 2000 6 218-723-395 4 218-723-391 6 bkrogh@exchange1.mnpower.com
. 313-248-234 7 313-594-292 1 mlaber@ford.co m 970-498-123 2 303-498-101 0 rfisher@lamar.colostate.edu 301-497-128 4 301-497-128 9 ddlane@westvaco.eo m 540-921-637 4 540-230-66 9 rianfor@wpo.hcc.eom

202-467-714 5 703-525-778 8 503-220-166 0 804-743-663 6 202-898-144 4 202-682-832 5

281-875-370 0 313-556-214 2 518-457-669 6

713-241-399 9 202-467-743 1 202-496-752 5 302-773-017 6 703-849-619 3 315-428-661 4 712-277-746 1 281-870-612 2 281-870-688 1 202-955-156 1 202-586-639 9 609-984-148 4 303-440-490 1 317-276-033 1 937-225-443 5 202-663-885 2 301-587-630 0

215-751-234 0 202-637-566 2 423-751-442 5 610-777-534 6 518-457-768 8 202-833-92 2 202-682-827 3 202-637-657 3 202-857-305 1 202-467-717 6 Iewl17145@mlb.co m

703-525-881 7 alllly@alam.or g 503-220-165 1 slopez@westar.or g 804-743-664 4 TALoredo@rmcco m 202-898-026 4 alucas@dcstrategies.eo m 202-682-803 1 mannatoa@api.or g

manninj@basf.co m Jess@pflko.co m Inusgmb.wz8kck@gmeds.co m canccart@gw.dec.state.ny.u s dmccarthy@ipalco.co m Jtmcclure@shedus.co m moc0743 1 @mlb.co m mary_mccullough@mckennacuneo.co m John_h_medley@email.mobil.co m mlakiszJ@nimo.co m demonhning@midamerican.co m norman.l.morrow@exxon.co m grace.n.moye@exxon.co m hnickel@hunton.co m Judy.odoulamy@hq.doe.go v wosufliv@dep.state.nJ.u s Vickie_Patton@edf.or g bpaul@imy.co m pauQa@rapca.org Blfl_Pederson@shawpHtman.co m Pphlbbs@bpinews.co m praschea+adet01%7332724@mdmall.co m JarUce_quimby@shsl.co m pmr@dc2.hhlaw.co m bobralney@tva.gov rrakiewicz@uaigroup.co m rnrao@gw.state.ny.u s Jmreamy@bvemx.ppco.co m reesej@apl.or g Isr@dc2.hhlaw.co m ernie_rDsenberg@oxy.co m 313-974-546 7

713-241-249 4 202-467-717 6 202-496-775 6 302-774-118 9 703-849-629 5 315-428-354 9 712-277-736 6 281-588-252 2 281-568-252 2 202-778-220 1 202-586-739 6 609-984-636 9

317-276-180 0 937-225-348 6 202-663-800 7 301-587-108 1

215-751-220 5 202-637-591 0 423-751-473 8 610-777-413 6 518-485-642 7 202-785-071 5 202-682-803 3 202-637-591 0 202-657-304 08 1 Russell , Chery l

8 2 Savage , Jacki e

* * Schanbacker , Davi d

" Schneider , Conra d 8 3 Shaver , Chri s 8 4 Shaw , Ton y 8 5 Shea , Quinla n

" Shearer , Russel l

" Shinn , Bo b

" Sicuranza , Le o 8 6 Siegler , Elle n

* * Slade , Joh n

" Slater , Davi d

* * Sliwinski , Rober

t

* * Snyder , Jennife r

* * Stanfietd , Rebecc a

* * Stoner , Ji m

* * Stolpe , Elizabet h

* * Stroman , Cynthi a

* * Taylor , Baro n

* * Teetz , Bo b

* * Thompson , Chet 8 7 Toensrng , Do n Q 8 8 Tosi , Loui s

" Trisko , Eugen e

* * Tulou , Christoph e 8 9 Tyndall , Willia m

* * Vemet , Jea n

* * Wade , Sara h 90 Wakelyn
. Phi l

* * Wallach
. Pau l 9 1 Wallenberg , Davi d 9 2 Waskiewtcz , Kath y

* * Walther , Margret

* * Weeks , An n B
. 9 3 Wierman , Susa n

• •Wolfe , Samue l A
.
* * Wolfe
. Thomas

" Wolman , Mar c 9 4 Woolbert , Jo e 9 5 Wyckoff , Pete r 9 6 Wygonik , Mar k 9 7 Wyles , Tamm y 9 8 Wyman , Rober

t Boein g

Daim'erchrysle r A g TX Natura l Resource Boar d Clear , Ai r Tas k

Force Nationa l Par k

Service , Ai r Qualit

y Divisio n F& TNetwor k Nationa l Minin g Associatio n Squire , Sanders , & Dempse y N J Dept
. of th e Env
. U.S
. Generatin g Compan y Hoga n & Hartso n P A Dept
. of Environmenta l Protectio n Thompso n Publishin g Grou p N Y Stat e DE P Co m Refiners Assoc , In c U S PIR G
Champio n Internationa l Corp
. Kin g & Spaldin g Stdle y S Austo n (LawFirm ) KeySta n Energ y So c o f Independan t Gasolin e Marketers U S EPA , Regio n VI I Shumake r Loo p & Kendric k Attorne y fo r Unite d Min e Workers o f America Christoph e Tulo u Assoc
. VP/Environmenta l Services , Cinerg y Corp
. Dep t o f Energ y ED F Nationa l Cotto n Counci l of Americ a Hel@Dorrlo p STAPPA/ALAPC O For d Moto r Compan y Coer r Environmenta l Corp
. Clea n Ai r Tas k

Force Mid-Atlanti c Regiona l Ai r Managemen t Asso c Publi c Service Electri c & Ga s Compan y Capita l Environmenta l Parson s Engineerin g Scienc e Eastma n Chemica l Compan y Gardner , Carto n & Douglas Flexibl e Packagin g Associatio n Georgi a Pacifi c (Amer
. Forest & Pape r Assoc. ) Latha m & Watkln s 80 0 Chrysle r Drive
. East [CIM S 482-00-61] , Aubur n Hill
. M l 48326-275 7

16 5 Par k Row , Brunswick

, M E 0401 1 P O Bo x 25287
. Denver , C O 8022 5 1536 3 Wort h Court , Centreville , V A 20120-393 9

120 1 Pennsylvani a Ave. , NW , P O Bo x 407 , Washington , D C 2004 4

On e Bowdoi n Square , Suit e 600 , Boston , M A 02114-291 0 55513t h Street , Washington , D C 2000 4 40 0 Marke

t St , Rache l Carso n State Office Bldg. , Harrisburg , P A 17105-846 8 172 5 KStreet , NW
. Suit e 700 , Washington
. D C 2000 6 5 0 Wol f Road , Albany , N Y 12233-325 1

21 8 D Street , SE
. Washington , D C 2000 3

1S75 1 Street , Ste
. 540 , Washington , D C 2000 6 17 0 Pennsylvani a Ave.
. NW , Washington , D C 2000 6

44 5 Broadholto

wRoad , Melville
. N Y 1174 7 (Collier , Shannon , Rill
. & Scott) 72 6 Minnesota Ave.
. Kansas City , KS 6610 1

P O Bo x 596 , Berkele

y Springs , W

V 2541 1 212 2 Californi a Street
. NW , SuHe 655 , Washington , D C 2000 8 13 9 East Fourt h Stree t Roo m 500-M , Cincinnati , O H 4520 1

152 1 NewHampshir

e Ave. , NE , Washington , D C 2000 2 1 4 Pennsylvani a Ave , NW , Washington , D C 2000 4 44 4 N
. Capito l Street , NW , SuHe 307 , Washington , D C 2000 1 SuHe 140 0 Parklan e Tower s East , On e Parklan e Blvd. , Dearborn , M l 48126-247 7

23 0 Congress Street , Boston , V A 0211 0 71 1 West 40t h Street , Suit e 318 , Baltimore , M D 2121 1 80 Par k Plaza , 17G
. Newark , M Y 07102-419 4 129 9 Pennsylvani a AVE , NW , Washington , D C 2000 2 Ai r Sciences Group , 30 Da n Road , Canton , M A 02021-280 9 P O Bo x 7444
. Longview , TX 75607-744 4 130 1 KStree t NW
. Washington , D C 2000 5 109 0 Vermon t Ave. , N.W. , SuHe 500 , Washington , D C 20005-496 0 13 3 Peachtree

t Stree t NE , Atlanta , G A 3030 3 63 3 West Fift h Stree t Lo s Angeles , C A 9007 1 703-465-361 3 248-576-805 4 512-239-122 8 201-721-867 6 303-969-207 4 703-815-0102 7 202-463-979 3 202-626-661 2

617-788-368 6 202-637-572 8 717-787-432 5 202-739-955 1 518-457-282 3 202-331-163 4 202-546-970 7 703-465-303 4 cheryt.a.russell@boeing.co m

248-576-792 8 Jas28@chrysler.co m

207-721-869 6 303-969-282 2 703-815-0104 3 202-463-325 7 202-626-678 0

617-788-315 0 202-637-591 0

202-739-957 8 518-457-79 4

202-546-246 1

202-785-988 8 202-785-328 6

312-853-471 7 516-391-613 3 202-342-881 5 913-551-744 6 313-594-775 2 304-258-197 7 913-387-944 0 513-287-352 2

202-387-350 0 202-745-780 5 202-942-842 9 202-624-786 4 313-594-775 2 919-932-384 0 617-292-028 8 410-467-024 6 973-430-370 9 202-383-691 9 781-401-211 2 903-237-547 5 202-408-714 9 202-842-388 0 404-652-728 1 213-891-833 4 516-591-607 9

313-248-503 0 304-258-392 7 202-387-944 5 513-287-349 9

202-483-404 0 202-942-848 4

313-248-50* 3

617-292-493 3 410-467-173 7 973-565-52 5

781-401-204 3 903-237-631 8 202-289-150 4 202-8420384 1 404-654-469 5 213-891-876 3 cshneider@ime.net

chris_shaver@nps.gov tshaw37@aol.co m qshea@nma.or g cshearer@ssd.co m rshlnn@dep.state.nj.u s LSicuran@BOSTON.USGEN.co m eslegler@hhlaw.co m slade.John@a 1 dep.state.pa.u s david_slater@thompson.co m rgsliwin@gw.decstate.ny.u s Jsrryder@com.or

g beckystan@pirg.or g stolpe@champint.co m cstroman@kslaw.co m bftaylor@sidtey.co m teetzrd@keystanenergy.co m cthompson@colshan.co m toenslng.don@epa.gov ltosi@slk-law.co m emtrisko@intreprid.net ctulou@erols.co m Jean.vemet@hq.doe.gov pwakelyn@cotton.or g paul.wallach@heloorr.co m
ktvaskiew@ford.co m mbw@coerr.co m aweeks@clnatf.or g swlerman@marama.or g samuel.wolfe@pseg.co m wotfet@howrey.co m marc_wolman@parsons.co m woolbert@eastman.co m pwyckoff@gcd.co m fpa@flexpack.or g trwyles@gapac.co m robert.wyman@lw.co m