APPENDIX A

Air Quality System (AQS) and Indiana

Department of Environmental Management

(IDEM) Monitor Data Values for Southwestern

Indiana Area (2004-2006)
This page left intentionally blank.
Monitoring Data for the Southwestern Indiana Area

Annual 2004-2006

Average Average

SITE ID COUNTY SITE NAME YEAR J1gfmJ J1gfmJ

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper 2004 14.42

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper 2005 16.92

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper 2006 13.54 15.0

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2004 13.23

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2005 16.49

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2006 13.72 14.5

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2004 13.46

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2005 16.29

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2006 14.05 14.6

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2004 13.68

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2005 16.67

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2006 14.15 14.8

Year1v Annual Means

City Site Name 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

Jasper 200 W 6th St 17.16 16.54 16.34 15.72 14.42 16.92 13.54

Evansville Civic Center 16.17 15.45 15.36 14.93 13.23 16.49 13.72

Evansville WMiIlRd 16.17 15.15 15.27 15.27 13.46 16.29 14.05

Evansville Univ ofEvansville 15.70 16.16 15.24 15.09 13.68 16.67 14.15

value above the standard

Three Year Desill:n Values

Site # City Site Name 00-02 01-03 02-04 03-05 04-06

18-037-2001 Jasper 200W 6th St 16.7 16.2 15.5 15.7 15.0

18-163-0006 Evansville Civic Center 15.7 15.2 14.5 14.9 14.5

18-163-0012 Evansville WMiIIRd 15.5 15.2 14.7 15.0 14.6

18-163-0016 Evansville Univ of Evansville 15.7 15.5 14.7 15.1 14.8

value above the

standard

incomplete data

A-I
PM 2.5 Annual Mean Trends

Southwestern Indiana Area

18.00

17.00

16.00 CO)

15.00

14.00

13.00

12.00

..... - - ./ "

"

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

...-Southwest Indiana Monitors -Standard I

Three-Year Design Values For Fine Particles

17.0 ..,...------------------------,

16.5

16.0

cg 15.5

0, 15.0 .......... ::J 14.5

14.0

13.5

13.0 -l--I---'--...L--

200 W 6th St Civic Center

Jasper Evansville

WMillRd

Evansville

Univof

Evansville

Evansville

c=J 2000-2002" c=J 2001-2003 c:::::J 2002-2004

A-2

2003-2005 _ 2004-2006 -Standard
200 W 6th St

Jasper

Ci~c Center

Evans~lIe

WMillRd

Evans~lIe

Univ of Evans~lIe

Evans~lIe

2004-2006 -Standard I

A-3
This page left intentionally blank..

A-4
APPENDIXB

Air Quality System (AQS) and Indiana

Department of Environmental Management

(IDEM) Monitor Data Values for Southwestern

Indiana Area (2005-2007)
This page left intentionally blank.
Monitoring Data for the Southwestern Indiana Area

Annual 2005-2007

Average Average

SITE ID COUNTY SITE NAME YEAR III¥mJ III¥mJ

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper 2005 16.92

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper 2006 13.54

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper 2007 14.39 14.9

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2005 16.49

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2006 13.72

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2007 13.91 14.7

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2005 16.29

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2006 14.05

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2007 14.23 14.9

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2005 16.67

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2006 14.15

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2007 14.21 15.0

Yearlv Annual Means

City Site Name 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Jasoer 200 W6th St 17.16 16.54 16.34 15.72 14.42 16.92 13.54 14.39

Evansville Civic Center 16.17 15.45 15.36 14.93 13.23 16.49 13.72 13.91

Evansville WMiII Rd 16.17 15.15 15.27 15.27 13.46 16.29 14.05 14.23

Evansville Univ ofEvansville 15.70 16.16 15.24 15.09 13.68 16.67 14.15 14.21

value above the standard

Three Year Desie:n Values

Site # City Site Name 00-02 01-03 02-04 03-05 04-06 05-07

18-037-2001 Jasper 200 W 6th St 16.7 16.2 15.5 15.7 15.0 14.9

18-163-0006 Evansville Civic Center 15.7 15.2 14.5 14.9 14.5 14.7

18-163-0012 Evansville WMiIIRd 15.5 15.2 14.7 15.0 14.6 14.9

18-163-0016 Evansville Univ ofEvansville 15.7 15.5 14.7 15.1 14.8 15.0

value above the

standard

incomplete data

B-1
PM 2.5 Annual Mean Trends

Southwestern Indiana Area

18.00 .......----------------------------,

17.00 +---"--=::----------------_-'-----------(

16.00 +----------~__=,.._,_-----_#_-~,.__--------(

CO)

15.00 +------o ....__f'-----.;....--------/

= 14.00 +---------------~------:k~~~~_l

13.00 +------------------------------(

12.00 -I------r----,------,r-----,----,.------,----,....------l

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

-&-Southwest Indiana Monitors -Standard

Three-Year Design Values For Fine Particles

17.0 .......----------------------------,

16.5

16.0

C") 15.5

.E 15.0

::s 14.5

14.0

13.5

13.0 +-'-----'---"-.....

200 W 6th St Civic Center WMillRd Univof Evansville

Jasper Evansville Evansville Evansville

c:::::J 2000-2002 c:::=J 2001-2003 c:::=J 2002-2004

_ 2004-2006 _ 2005-2007 -Standard

2003-2005

B-2
200 W 6th St

Jasper

Ci'v1C Center

Evansville

WMillRd

Evansville

Univof Evans\lIIe

Evans'v1l1e

2005-2007 -Standard

B-3
This page left intentionally blank.

B-4
APPENDIXC

University ofEvansville Incomplete PM2•5

Monitoring Data Analysis
This page left intentionally blank.
Data Analysis for Missing PM2.5 Data at the University of

Evansville Monitor in Vanderburgh County, Indiana

Introduction

During the second quarter of2005 the University ofEvansville (UE) monitor located in

Vanderburgh County, Indiana, Site ID 18-163-0016, recorded an overall Valid Data

Return (VDR) for PM2.5 of68%. According to U.S. EPA guidance, the monitoring data

for the University ofEvansville monitor located in Vanderburgh County, Indiana is

incomplete. The U.S. EPA required VDR is 75%. Therefore, an analysis ofmissing data

during the second quarter of2005 was conducted and this section details the scenarios for

filling in the missing data.

Monitoring Network

There are three PM2.5 monitors in Vanderburgh County Indiana. These sites are: Civic

Center (18-163-0006), W Mill Road (18-163-0012) and University ofEvansville (18-

163-0016), all located in Evansville. Indiana operates an extensive network ofPM2.5

monitors stretching throughout the state, including a monitor in nearby Dubois County in

southwestern Indiana. A map showing the locations ofthe monitors in Southwest Indiana

is below in Figure 1.

Figure 1

PM 2.5 Monitors in Southwestem Indiana

Gib.on

C - 1

Davl••• Martin

A Jasper
Calculation ofthe PM~ Annual Standard

The U.S. EPA developed a "Guideline for Data Handling Conventions for the PM

NAAQS", released in April 1999, to assess compliance with the standard. The annual

PM2.5 standard is set at 15.0 micrograms per cubic meter (llg!m3). The annual standard is

met when the 3-year average ofthe annual mean concentrations across a designated area

is less than or equal to 15.0 llg!m3 (micrograms per cubic meter). Any design value

above this is a violation ofthe standard.

Missing Data Review

Examining the second quarter of 2005 for the UE monitor, the missing data was a result

of a variety of problems including power failure, machine malfunction, collection errors,

and the sample time out oflimits. For the remaining quarters of2005 the UE monitor had

an overall valid VDR over 75% and specifically was 100% for the first quarter; 100% for

the third quarter; and 97% for the fourth quarter. The dates in the second quarter of 2005

that data was missing at the monitor are April 22, May 25,28 and 31st and June 3, 6, 9,

12, 15 and 27th•

According to U.S. EPA guidance, the 2004-2006 design value for the UE monitor site is

incomplete. Table 1 below lists the annual means and three-year design value for the

monitors in southwestern Indiana. All ofthe monitors in southwestern Indiana are below

the PM2.5 standard.

Table 1

County Monitor Location Annual Annual Annual Design Value

Mean Mean Mean 2004-2006

2004 2005 2006

Dubois Jasper-Post Office 14.42 16.92 13.54 15.0

Vanderburgh Evansville-Civic 13.23 16.49 13.72 14.5

Center

Vanderburgh Evansville-W Mill 13.46 16.29 14.05 14.6

Rd

Vanderburgh Evansville-Univof 13.68 16.67 14.15 14.8*

Evansville

*The University ofEvansville monitor data is incomplete; it is missing the required

amount of data in the second quarter of 2005.

IDEM conducted an analysis ofthe missing data during the second quarter of2005 and

Table 2 below provides a summary ofthe captured data for 2005 along with alternate

methods for evaluating and substituting for the missing data.

C-2
Table 2

UNIVERSITY OF EVANSVILLE MONITOR (181630016)

% VALID Average A Average B Average C Average D

1Q 2004 90% 13.2321429

2Q 2004 100% 12.7

3Q 2004 97% 16.4133333

4Q 2004 100% 12.38

Year 2004

Average 13.6813691 13.6813691 13.6813691 13.6813691

1Q 2005 100% 15.1833333 15.1833333 15.1833333 15.1833333

2Q 2005 68% 17.0571429 24.2645161 21.7483871 16.17419

3Q 2005 100% 20.6233333 20.6233333 20.6233333 20.6233333

4Q 2005 97% 13.8266667 13.8266667 13.8266667 13.8266667

Year 2005

Average 16.6726191 18.4744624 17.8454301 16.4518808

1Q 2006 97% 11.9448276

2Q 2006 100% 14.5533333

3Q 2006 94% 18.7551724

4Q 2006 100% 11.3516129

Year 2006

Average 14.1512366 14.1512366 14.1512366 14.1512366

3 Year

Average

(2004-2006) 14.8350749 15.4356893 15.2260119 14.7614955

Average A: Average based on no substitution. Using this average makes the data

incomplete since the required VDR is 75% and the 2nd Quarter 2005 VDR is only

68%.

Average B: Average based on substituting historic high value for any day that had

missing data in the 2nd Quarter of 2005. The historic high value of 39.4 is the

hiQhest value that occurred in the 2nd Quarter on June 12, 2001.

Average C: Average based on substituting highest value that occurred in the 2nd

Quarter of the years 2004-2006 for any day that had missing data in the 2nd

Quarter of 2005. The highest value in the 2nd Quarter for the years 2004-2006 of

31.6 occurred in the 2nd Quarter of the year 2005 on June 30.

Average D: Average based on substituting fine particulate matter values from

nearby monitors. The higher of the two numbers at the Evansville Civic Center or

Evansville Mill Road monitor were substituted for each day that had missing data in

the 2nd Quarter of 2005.

C - 3
Substituting for Missing Data (Averages B and C)

The substitution procedure for data below the required 75% VDR is a conservative

mechanism to ascertain the likelihood that a site would meet or not meet the standards if

the site had collected the 75% criteria. The incomplete design value identified as

Average A (14.8 Ilglm3

) is more indicative ofthe monitor's air shed than the artificial

recalculated design values explained below.

Average A: Three-year average based on no substitution, calculated according to U.S.

EPA guidance. Using this average makes the data incomplete since the required VDR is

75% and the 2nd Quarter VDR for the rear 2005 is only 68%. U.S. EPA states that the

incomplete design value of 14.8 Ilglm , is still identified as the monitors true design

value.

Average B: Three-year average based on substitution, calculated according to U.S. EPA

guidance. The historic high value was substituted for any day that had missing data in

the 2nd Quarter of2005. The historic high value of 39.4 Ilglm3 is the highest value that

occurred in the 2nd Quarter on June 12, 2001. Using this average provides a conservative

number by using the highest value ever recorded in that quarter; however it makes the

three-year average over the standard.

Average C: Three-year average based on substitution. The highest value that occurred in

the 2nd Quarter ofthe years 2004-2006 was substituted for any day that had missing data

in the 2nd Quarter of2005. The highest value in the 2nd Quarter for the years 2004-2006

of31.6 Ilglm3 occurred on June 30, 2005. Using this average provides more current data

than Average B by using the 2nd Quarter high from the 3-year design period. It is

IDEM's understanding that U.S. EPA is starting to use this calculation rather than

Average B above. In this case, however it is not as conservative as Average B, although

the three-year average remains over the standard.

Averages B and C are overly conservative values that do not realistically represent the air

quality measured at the University ofEvansville. By substituting high values that reflect

rare or unusual air quality, such as the ones used in Averages B and C, for the days where

the monitor has missing data higher than normal averaged values were the result. Taking

a look at the historical monitoring data and evaluating the high values at the University of

Evansville monitor there are very few days where the high value was above the value

used for the substitution in Averages B and C. Table 3 below list the number of days for

each year that the monitored value was above the value used for substitution in Averages

B and C. The table is also broken down by how many days in the 2nd Quarter (the same

quarter that had missing data for 2005) and how many days in the entire year that were

above the substituted values. The University ofEvansville monitor had 10 days with

missing data in the 2nd Quarter of2005. As can be seen from Table 3 there are very few

days where the high value was above the value used for the substitution in Averages B

andC.

C-4
Table 3

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Number of Days in the 2 0 I 0 I 0 I 0 0

2nd Quarter that the

Value was> 31.6

Number of Days in the I 0 I 0 0 0 0 0 0

2nd Quarter that the

Value was> 39.4

Number ofDays in the 6 3 5 5 6 0 7 2 I

Year that the Value

was >31.6

Number of Days in the 2 0 I 4 I 0 2 2 0

Year that the Value

was >39.4

Time Series

PM2.5 values for the years 2004-2006 at all three Evansville monitors were plotted to

show comparison over time and to see how closely the monitors tracked together. The

Civic Center monitor is only 1.92 miles from the University ofEvansville monitor and

the Mill Road monitor is only 3.84 miles away. Given the fact that the monitors are in

close proximity to each other, the data from the three Evansville monitors track together

very well.

As illustrated in Graph 1 below, the PM2.5values from monitor to monitor do not show

much variation in trend or magnitude. . Graphs 2-4 show the years 2004, 2005 and 2006

individually and Graph 5 shows the second quarter of 2005 only.

Graph 1

eo ,-- Evansville =~~..;;.:,;,;,;;;.;..;..::.:..::..:...:::..:c'_'___ Monitors 2004-2006 ___,

501-----------------------t---__\

401--------------f---+--------t-I1---__\

301-......-----=-.------4t_~- .....~__fI_---_..____It_-......r_-__\

20

10

0

~ ~ ~ § 8 8 § § § § § § ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

;; iii i': a; ;; iii i': a; ;; ;; iii i': a; ;;

........Unlv of Evansville ~CMcCenter __Mill Road

C - 5
Evansville Monitors 2004

~I ,

IlII ~~ • r~ J IJ

rt4li

I'

...

E

!

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

--Univ of Evansville

Graph 2

---Ci~iC Center

Graph 3

__Mill Road

50

45

40

35

30

20

15

10

5

Evansville Monitors 2005

.. l •

iJ • r\ ~~~ II 1 f • W

Mr " ~~ I

--Univ of Evansville ---Civic Center -A-Mill Road

C-6
0

'"

0 (ugl)h3) g: '" ... ...

00 '" (u~3) ..

8 '" 0

'"

0

0

4/1120051

1"'OJIII1 I I I1

11212006

1/1612006

41812005

1 I I I .JJfI I I I I I 1/3012006

2/1312006

4/1512005 212712006

+ 311312006

c:

~, 412212005 312712006 am f 411012006

.." 412912005

c 4/2412006

iii

":c' a 5/812006 m<

51612005 .. CD :::J 512212006

+

..

m :l• < < iii CD

0 61512006 :l

~: i' C':) III

5/1312005 C':)

(j 10 !l: .,

+

611912006 i'

0

., :l !l:

-..,J I~

g "C

0 71312006

0 "C

=- s: :l

=- 512012005 g U'I 0 711712006 N0

iil

! 512712005

... 7/3112006 ... C>

C>

C>

C>

.!! ... 5:

8/1412006

il

+ 812812006 Q.

61312005 9/1112006 2

Q. 912512006

611012005

I

, I I I I I

1 I I 101912006

6117120051 I 1 I I I

II I I I I 1012312006

111612006

612412005

I I I I I .L-II I I 1112012006

12/4/2006

1211612006
Correlation

Correlation is a measure ofthe statistical relationship between two comparable time

series. In this case, the University ofEvansville monitor was compared to the Civic

Center monitor and to the Mill Road monitor. The relationship stated as the correlation

coefficient reflects the simultaneous change in value ofthe pairs of numerical values over

time. The correlation coefficient, which lies between the range of-1.00 to +1.00, as a

positive or negative probability that the members of a pair relate to each other. A

negative reading suggests that one member ofthe pair consistently moves up while the

other moves down. Conversely a positive reading suggests there is a tendency for the pair

to move together in the same direction.

The correlation coefficient was calculated between the three Evansville monitors for the

years 2004-2006. The correlation coefficient between the University ofEvansville

monitor and the Civic Center monitor is 0.987469. The correlation coefficient between

the University ofEvansville monitor and the Mill Road monitor is 0.976652. Both ofthe

correlation coefficients are positive numbers very close to 1.00 showing that the

Evansville monitors track very closely, and that data substitution from these sites results

in a realistic record. .

Additionally, the average for each ofthe sites for the 21 days in which all monitors

operated during the second quarter of 2005 were calculated. These averages came to 17.1

Ilg/m3 at UE, 16.6 Ilg/m3 at Civic Center, and 17.1 Ilg/m3 at Mill Road. This further

illustrates the correlation between the sites.

Day-Specific Substitution (Average D)

Average D: Three-year average based on substitution. Fine particulate matter values

from the nearby Evansville Civic Center and Evansville Mill Road monitors were

substituted for the missing days at the University ofEvansville monitor. The higher of

the two values at the Civic Center or Mill Road monitor was substituted for each day that

had missing data in the 2nd Quarter of2005. Using this average provides an average very

close to the true design value identified in Average A.

Table 4 below lists the daily values for each ofthe three Evansville monitors for the 2nd

Quarter of 2005. The highlighted values for the Civic Center and Mill Road monitors

show which value for that day was used for substitution for the missing data at the

University ofEvansville monitor.

C - 8
Table 4

Second Quarter 2005 Values

Univ of Evansville Civic center Mill Road

4/1/2005 7.2 7.3 6.4

4/4/2005 12.6 13.0 13.4

41712005 19.3 20.2 18.9

4/10/2005 18.8 18.6 17.9

4/13/2005 14.7 14.7 14.4

4/16/2005 18.3 19.5 17.1

4/19/2005 23.2 13.3 22.6

4/2212005 7.6 7.6

4/25/2005 6.1 5.7 4.9

4/28/2005 10.7 10.7 10.7

5/112005 7.0 6.7 6.4

5/4/2005 11.8 13.6 12.6

5n/2005 20.7 19.4 20.9

5/10/2005 11.2 11.4 13.4

5/13/2005 24.1 24.0 23.8

5/16/2005 9.6 9.3 10.4

5/19/2005 20.6 20.8 21.7

5/2212005 22.5 22.3 25.0

5/2512005 6.7 6.5

5/2812005 7.7 9.0

5/31/2005 16.6 14.7

6/312005 17.6 16.4

6/6/2005 15.0 14.7

6/9/2005 10.7 11.6

6/1212005 8.0 7.0

6/15/2005 7.5 7.6

6/18/2005 7.4 7.5 8.0

6/21/2005 30.8 30.3 28.4

6/24/2005 30.0 29.1 31.1

6/27/2005 43.2 43.4

6/30/2005 31.6 31.4 31.8

Conclusions

Using available data, the 2004-2006 PM2.

5 three-year average of 14.8 Ilg/m3 for the

University ofEvansville monitor is incomplete; it is missing the required amount of data

in the second quarter of2005. Through missing data review and data substitution

performed, according to the Guideline on Data Handling Conventionsfor the PM

NAAQS, issued April 1999, the incomplete design value of 14.8 Ilg/m3, is still identified

as the monitor's true design value.

U.S. EPA guidance recommends substituting the quarterly maximum value (Average B

which is the most conservative scenario) which results in the value being above the

C-9
standard. However, IDEM has shown that the substitution scenarios B or C are not

realistic representations ofthe PM2.5 concentrations registered at the University of

Evansville monitor. The Evansville monitors are highly correlated. Therefore, design

value Average D (14.8 J..lg/m3

), using the day-specific substitution, best represents the

true value for the University ofEvansville monitor had it collected the required 75 %

VDR.

C -10
APPENDIXD

2005 - 2007 Indiana Monitoring Data Summary

Supplement
This page left intentionally blank.
2005-2007 Indiana Monitoring Data Summary Supplement

Annual PM 2.5 NAAQS Value = 15 ug/m3

Site Design

Annual Means Value

County Site # City Site Name 2005 2006 2007 05-07

ALLEN 180030004 Fort Wayne Beacon St 15.64 11.92 13.23 13.6

ALLEN 180030014 Fort Wayne Tavlor Univ 15.69 11.80 12.90 13.5

CLARK 180190006 Jeffersonville Pfau 18.53 15.00 16.49 16.7

Muncie Central

DELAWARE 180350006 Muncie HS 16.36 11.93 13.30 13.9

DUBOIS 180372001 Jasper 2ooW6th St 16.92 13.54 14.39 14.9

Pierre Moran

ELKHART 180390003 Elkhart School 15.62 12.55 13.83 14

Green Valley

FLOYD 180431004 New Albany School 16.84 13.34 14.66 14.9

215 W Superior

HOWARD 180670003 Kokomo St 15.93 12.25 13.51 13.9

LAKE 180890006 East Chicago Franklin School 15.76 13.18 14.44 14.5

Eldon Ready

LAKE 180890027 Highland School 15.46 12.29 13.17 13.6

Water Plant, 650

LAKE 180890031 Madison St. 16.98 13.30 14.55 14.8

LAKE 180891003 Gary Ivanhoe School 15.71 12.57 14.01 14.1

LAKE 180892004 Hammond Purdue 15.40 12.67 13.80 14

LAKE 180892010 Hammond Robertsdale 15.59 14.79 13.68 14

Marsh

LA PORTE 180910011 Michigan City Elementary Sch 13.64 11.12 12.37 12.4

LA PORTE 180910012 LaPorte 1119 Lake St 14.10 11.39 12.09 12.5

MADISON 180950009 Anderson 44 W 5th St 16.06 12.06 13.70 13.9

MARION 180970042 Indianapolis Mann Road 16.10 12.49 14.57 14.4

Washington

MARION 180970078 Indianaoolis Park 16.39 14.14 15.78 15.4

MARION 180970079 Indianaoolis 7250 E. 75th St 16.88 12.75 14.76 14.8

MARION 180970081 Indianaoolis W 18th St 18.06 14.12 16.07 16.1

MARION 180970083 Indianapolis E. Michigan St. 17.54 14.15 15.93 15.9

Dunes Natl

PORTER 181270020 Lakeshore 14.00 11.02 13.04 12.7

Water Treatment

PORTER 181270024 Ogden Dunes Plant 14.59 11.81 13.79 13.4

Nuner

STJOSEPH 181410014 South Bend Elementary Sch 14.83 11.90 12.94 13.4

Site began

12.91 STJOSEPH 181410015 South Bend Shields Dr 06/06/06 12.84 12.93

STJOSEPH 181411008 South Bend Angela &Eddy 14.81 11.82 12.93 13.2

STJOSEPH 181412004 South Bend LaSalle HS 14.49 11.34 12.45 12.8

D-l
Site Design

Annual Means Value

County Site # City Site Name 2005 2006 2007 05-07

3401 Greenbush

TIPPECANOE 181570008 Lafayette St 15.85 11.83 13.47 13.7

VANDERBURGH 181630006 Evansville Civic Center 16.49 13.72 13.91 14.7

VANDERBURGH 181630012 Evansville WMillRd 16.29 14.05 14.23 14.9

Univof

VANDERBURGH 181630016 Evansville Evansville 16.67 14.15 14.21 15.01

VIGO 181670018 Terre Haute Lafayette St 15.44 12.97 14.11 14.2

VIGO 181670023 Terre Haute Devaney School 15.12 12.20 13.75 13.7

Nonattainment Incomplete Data

1 One Year of data

2 Two Years of data

BackQround, Transport and Source Oriented Monitors Not Used For Attainment Purposes

Site Design

Annual Means Value

County Site # City Site Name 2005 2006 2007 05-07

Site

began

14.1 1 DUBOIS 180370004 Jasper Sports Complex 02101/06 13.64 14.61

Site

began

14.41 DUBOIS 180370005 Jasper Golf Course 02101/06 13.78 14.92

HENRY 180650003 nla Shenandoah HS 15.69 11.14 13.13 13.3

SW PurdueAg

KNOX 180830004 nla Cntr 15.66 13.20 13.79 14.2

LAKE 180890022 Gary IITRI 18.25 13.57 15.06 15.6

LAKE 180890026 Gary Burr St 18.72 14.71 16.07 16.5

MARION 180970043 Indianapolis S. WestSt 19.10 15.50 17.29 17.3

MARION 180970066 Indianapolis English Ave 19.35 15.22 17.29 17.3

David Turnham

SPENCER 181470009 Dale Sch 16.76 12.78 14.13 14.6

Nonattainment

D-2

Incomplete Data

1 Two Years of data
2005-2007 Monitoring Data for the Southwestern Indiana Area

(Annual Average and Design Values)

Annual 2005-2007

Avera§e Design Value

Site ID County Site Name Year Jl,g/m Jl,g/m3

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper Post Office 2005 16.92

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper Post Office 2006 13.54 14.9

18-037-2001 Dubois Jasper Post Office 2007 14.39

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2005 16.49

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2006 13.72 14.7

18-163-0006 Vanderburgh Civic Center 2007 13.91

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2005 16.29

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2006 14.05 14.9

18-163-0012 Vanderburgh Mill Road 2007 14.23

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2005 16.67

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2006 14.15 15.01*

18-163-0016 Vanderburgh Univ ofEvansville 2007 14.21

*incomplete data, see Appendix C

Design Values for the Southwestern Indiana Nonattainment Area for Fine Particles, 2000-2007

Three-Year Design Values for Fine Particles

17~--------------------------------.,

16.5

16

15.5

C')

15 -+-t--t--t-Iii!i!ii ::s

14.5

14

13.5

200 W 6th SI Jasper Civic Center Evansville W Mill Rd Evansville Univ of Evansville Evansville

CJ2000-2002 c::::J 2001-2003 c::::J 2002-2004 2003-2005 _2004-2006 _2005-2007 -Standard

D-3
Southwestern Indiana Annual Fine Particle Trends, 2000-2007

Annual Fine Particle Trends

18.00,.-------------------------------------------,

17.00 +----.3II"""""---------------------- --------------l

16.00 +----"""-=--=-ooe:::-~:__----~......:__--------_#_H

:::I

15.00 L-----:L:=::~~~=~Si::;~~~~-~~&~--j~~-------j

14.00 t--------------------~-~-#_.J'----------__.tI

13.00 +-----------------------------------------1

12.00 ~----.,__----.,__----.,__----...._----.____----.____----.____-----1

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

~Jasper -Civic Center W Mill Rd

D-4

~Univ of Evansville -Standard
APPENDIXE

Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Sulfur Dioxides (S02) and

Direct Fine Particulate Matter (PM2.s) Point

Source Emissions (2002-2005) for Southwestern

Indiana Area
This page left intentionally blank.
2002

2005

127,628.35 2,359.71 349,633.78

86,585.69 3,234.67 366,527.03

Dubois 902.05 112.11 809.10

Gibson 45,316.49 218.95 127,503.29

Pike 24,023.24 235.61 65,235.73

Spencer 34,155.16 80.37 51,551.40

Vanderburgh 285.46 143.90 19.85

Warrick 22,945.95 1,568.77 104,514.41

Total 127,628.35 2,359.71 349,~33.78

2005-Point (Tons per Year

33.16 304.04 239.14 88.24 12.71

Gibson 30,310.01 132.01 154,234.50 57.13 2.49 0.45

Pike 18,227.01 232.03 52,810.03 72.67 1.06 4.89

Spencer 21,659.16 40.94 68,363.87 122.02 44.82 1.02

Vanderburgh 35.59 0.46 0.60 88.47 64.67 6.60

Warrick 15,472.96 1,524.15 87,112.35 216.09 1,070.64 3,675.97

Sub-Total 85,790.18 1,962.75 362,825.39 795.50 ,1,271.92 3,701.64

Point NOx Direct S02 PM2.5

Total 86,585.69 3,234.67 366,527.03

E-l
. . 6i'(:11~ "~y • NPJ;. . e 2 .~

ANR PIPELINE CELESTINE STATION 579.250 5.071 0.080

DMI FURNITURE 0.208 1.952 0.060

DMI FURNITURE 0.000 0.597 0.000

DUBOIS WOOD PRODUCTS, INC 1.770 1.147 0.091

F-JASPER 11TH AVE 1.625 1.517 3.619

INDIANA DESK-DUBOIS 0.600 0.046 0.004

INDIANA FURNITURE INDUSTIRES * 0.550 0.039 0.003

INWOOD OFFICE FURNITURE 0.000 0.220 0.000

JASPER CHAIR CO 0.997 3.810 5.570

JASPER CORPORATION 0.000 0.001 0.000

JASPER DESK COMPANY, INC. 0.725 1.886 0.016

JASPER ENGINE EXCHANGE, INC. 6.644 0.809 0.447

JASPER MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC UTILITY 234.273 40.793 773.242

JASPER SEATING CO 0.702 4.808 0.109

JOFCO PLT 1 & 2 COMBO (037-9 & 24)* 3.421 0.529 19.419

KIMBALL INTERNATIONAL COMBO 37- 0.000 2.091 0.00 30.50,53*

KIMBALL INTERNATIONAL COMBO 37- 13.627 2.618 0.644 30,50,53*

MASTERBRAND CABINETS PLANT #2 & #3A 0.042 5.803 0.000

MASTERBRAND CABINETS PLANT #2 & #3A 0.354 22.343 0.002

MOBEL, INC 0.315 0.024 0.002

Styline Industries 8.100 2.415 5.789

WOODMASTER. INC. 0.446 0.038 0.003

Total 853.649 98.557 809.100

Gibson 2002

MID-STATES RUBBER PRODUCTS, INC. 2.586 0.548 0.011

TEPPCO PRINCETON TERMINAL 0.296 0.071 0.004

127503.073

TOYOTA MOTOR MANUFACTURING OF

INDIANA 30.943 15.313

Total 33.825 15.932

E-2

0.201

0.216

'.ao2,
· ' I

BLACKFOOT LANDFILL

HOOSIER ENERGY - RATIS STATION

MIDWESTERN GAS TRANSMISSION

TEXAS GAS TRANSMISSION - PETERSBURG

Total

5.900

3988.976

0.588

76.223

4071.687

2.500

18054.251

0.000

0.007

18056.758

0.0900

0.000

0.090

~L

130.080

34013.580

34143.660

2

35.080

26.728

61.808

J)'

0.880

51550.428

51551.308

Vanderburgh 2002 ·~~;t,~~~,· . 8. I~ i,j.:.. ~.~;,,:~, -'~~~"'; 1i~1 ,0 ' ,. - "t~~L,~~7:, ': //;'.,NiJ~~··~M2t~~ '~]S0j~;~

A ASPHALT CO. INC. 0.262 0.174 1.195

AMERIQUAL FOODS, INC. 3.500 0.266 0.021

AZTECA MILLING, L.P. 20.150 39.374 0.121

BFI 38.712 7.858 6.868

BOOTZMFGCO 4.765 2.992 0.029

BRAKE SUPPLY 0.102 0.064 0.001

COLLIS INC. 6.822 45.632 0.041

DEACONESS HOSPITAL 1.440 0.098 1.285

DECORING SUPPLIES & EQUIPMENT, INC. 0.020 0.195 0.000

EVANSVILLE METAL PROD 0.050 0.004 0.000

EVANSVILLE STATE HOSPITAL 2.446 0.308 0.024

FAULTLESS CASTER CORP 2.080 0.067 0.012

FEHRENBACHER CABINETS 0.000 0.011 0.000

FERRO CORP. FILLED AND REINFORCED 0.000 10.359 0.000 PLAST.

FLANDERS ELECTRIC MOTOR SERVICE 0.900 0.690 0.005

FLANDERS ELECTRIC MOTOR SERVICE 0.037 0.003 0.000

GENERAL ELECTRIC I&RS 0.079 0.007 0.000

E-3
GEO KOCH SONS INC 0.163 0.098 0.001

GUARDIAN AUTOMOTIVE TRIM, INC. 7.050 0.864 0.042

HARTFORD BAKERY INC. 2.670 0.179 0.016

HOOSIER STAMPING & MFG. CORP 0.432 0.040 0.003

INDIAN INDUSTRIES - DBA ESCALADE SPORTS 0.000 5.999 0.00

INDIANA TUBE CORP. 2.165 0.128 0.010

INDUSTRIAL CONTRACTORS, INC. METAL FAB 0.074 0.006 0.000

INLAND PAPERBOARD - EVANSVILLE 4.300 0.018 0.026

INTRAMETCO PROCESSING INC. 10.411 0.083 17.156

J.H.RUDOLPH & CO 4.845 4.174 0.027

JERRY DAVID ASPHALT 3.551 0.098 5.234

KARGES FURNITURE CO., INC. 0.382 0.033 0.002

KERRY INGREDIENTS 4.359 8.001 0.026

KOCH ORIGINALS 0.799 0.060 0.005

KRIEGER & RAGSDALE CO., INC. 0.095 0.007 0.001

MASTER MANUFACTURING CO., INC. 0.375 0.029 0.002

MEAD JOHNSON AND COMPANY 13.308 2.190 0.313

OBRYAN BARREL CO., INC. 0.694 0.052 1.023

PPG INDUSTRIES, INC. WKS #28 4.107 0.382 0.026

RED SPOT PAINT & VARNISH CO., INC. 0.777 2.115 0.005

ROBUR CORPORATION 0.360 0.033 0.002

SIGECO - BERGDOLT ROAD - NEGT 0.784 0.047 0.040

SIGECO - OHIO RIVER 116.390 2.256 1.160

SILGAN CLOSURES, LLC 8.653 6.354 0.052

SKY CYLINDER TESTING, INC. 0.030 1.864 0.000

ST. MARY'S MEDICAL CENTER 1.012 0.077 0.077

ST. MARY'S MEDICAL CENTER - WELBORN 0.600 0.046 0.004

STERLING BOILER AND MECHANICAL, INC. 0.000 0.001 0.000

STRUCTURAL FABRICATORS, INC. 0.000 0.006 0.000

UNISEAL, INC.; PLANT #2 0.802 3.087 0.005

UNIV OF EVANSVILLE 4.823 0.335 0.027

UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN INDIANA 4.451 0.338 0.027

WHIRLPOOL CORP 13.943 1.059 0.159

Total 293.770 148.161 35.073

_RacJ ... - MULZER CRUSHED STONE

PC INDIANA SYNTHETIC FUEL #2 LLC

Total

E-4
22945.946 1566.205 104514.410

16456.995

250.795

6238.156

3191.717

7118.960

Dubois 2005

I:'~<"~;L ..'" 0

. ltaeilltV,Name :/orr '" 0 NG»)F;~ :~.pM2D5\f,j . , SG)2~o.~:'

ANR PIPELINE CELESTINE STATION 175.100 3.420 0.040

DMI FURNITURE 0.000 0.160 0.000

DMI FURNITURE 0.000 0.000 0.000

DUBOIS WOOD PRODUCTS, INC 1.310 0.630 0.140

FLEXCEL - JASPER 11TH AVE 1.380 1.050 3.970

INDIANA DESK-DUBOIS 0.650 0.050 0.000

INDIANA FURNITURE INDUSTIRES * 0.600 0.040 0.000

INWOOD OFFICE FURNITURE 0.000 0.220 0.000

JASPER DESK COMPANY, INC. 0.170 2.410 0.030

JASPER ENGINE EXCHANGE, INC. 47.370 0.730 0.420

JASPER MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC UTILITY 85.450 33.160 304.040

JASPER SEATING CO., INC., PLT #1 0.780 5.540 0.130

JASPER SEATING CO., INC., PLT #3 0.000 0.000 0.000

JOFCO PLT 1 & 2 COMBO (037-9 & 24)* 1.320 0.030 7.360

KIMBALL INTERNATIONAL COMBO 37-30,50,53* 0.000 0.440 0.000

KIMBALL INTERNATIONAL* 15TH. ST. COMPLEX 6.300 1.850 0.600

MASTERBRAND CABINETS PLANT #2 & #3A 0.720 5.200 0.000

MASTERBRAND CABINETS, INC. PLANT 4/22 2.280 45.060 0.010

MASTERBRAND PLANT #3 0.710 20.640 0.000

MOBEL,INC 0.120 0.010 0.000

STYLINE INDUSTRIES PLANT 1 0.000 0.730 0.000

WOODMASTER, INC. 0.340 0.030 0.000

Total 324.600 121.400 316.740

Gipson 2005

:c- ~,; ';:~~"" "), .NGJ.<tJ;ii .2~:$ o ;,

" "~>l18ciIIivtName ~li!£' ~~. s:ea,' - MID-STATES RUBBER PRODUCTS, INC. 2.590 0.590 0.010

TEPPCO PRINCETON TERMINAL 0.010 0.000 0.000

TOYOTA MOTOR MANUFACTURING OF INDIANA 54.530 1.910 0.440

Total 57.130 2.500 0.450

E-5
PSI ENERGY - GIBSON

Total

Pike 2005

'.:'''~~;;''':..;{':~'' '. ·.~)aciritVtl'ilalJi~,'·~;,lL'~ ~,'f'H ·~:t~~ n) I~ .~ 'NCDX~ l'lZlt912~5;!jI;~r.~)soi! "'" ",.•'.. .~fi~~

BLACKFOOT LANDFILL 8.200 0.660 3.500

HOOSIER ENERGY - RATTS GENERATING 2705.580 52.830 15124.020 STATIO

MIDWESTERN GAS TRANSMISSION 22.010 0.260 1.380

TEXAS GAS TRANSMISSION - PETERSBURG 42.460 0.140 0.010

Total 2778.250 53.890 15128.910

Pike EGU 2005

I~~;'~"~' ,-~~'. ';~<{,' FaciittiMim:e];> il;{ " '.' ';,~: ,.;, N@)<" .~. (. ~PM.2<l! 5~;.' . 'J,:s~"i' 1 •..• p

IPL PETERSBURG GENERATING STATION 15521.430 179.200 37686.010

Total 15521.430 179.200 37686.010

Spencer 2005

II! .....,:.";. ..:,,:' ·ffi '<v3:, . ....:~tY=iaGI'1IitSJiNo1~\~~r;j .'>.: am 1;. ~f!;~'<'~~}'fl . • l~(~m·;! ~2':5:J ):SJD2 c"

AMERICAN IRON OXIDE COMPANY 11.500 1.270 0.090

FLEXCEL - SANTA CLAUS 0.000 0.450 0.000

Total 11.500 1.720 0.090

Spencer EGU 2005

ICt'~~l~:~;i~'~! ~#"clif~15I~~l'~1·:f.~'¥:~... '''''''./: _:'·:;Nti'-f"·.~ ..PM2-c5~ y .. " .;. '- '. " .sante :-;"-'~". -,:.... ;::

AK STEEL ROCKPORT WORKS 110.520 43.090 0.930

INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER-ROCKPORT 21659.160 40.940 68363.870

Total 21769.680 84.030 68364.800

Vanderburah 2005

1k'A! .ql~1:~~"'<;:-" . ...... ;;~;'".:~~" ••i>"••.;.!lIiS(i!1I ,••. 1ilf'M_l:i:~,~" '. '. :~Y~:'--"""'~)'" .''''' ".;!':.' ','\i'- ;'...

NQj'g-/, " .l~eM.2~ [~Si2r~

AZTECA MILLING, L.P. 20.150 39.370 0.120

BFI WASTE SYSTEMS OF NORTH AMERICA, INC. 19.970 6.510 5.690

BOOTZ MFG CO 4.330 3.070 0.030

GUARDIAN AUTOMOTIVE TRIM, INC. 6.650 1.350 0.040

HARTFORD BAKERY INC. 2.680 0.180 0.020

INDIAN INDUSTRIES - DBA ESCALADE SPORTS 0.000 4.300 0.000

INDIANA TUBE CORP. 1.520 0.120 0.010

MEAD JOHNSON AND COMPANY 11.190 2.080 0.320

RED SPOT PAINT & VARNISH CO., INC. 0.200 0.340 0.010

£-6
SIGECO - BERGDOLT ROAD - NEGT 0.690 0.040 0.040

SIGECO - OHIO RIVER 34.900 0.420 0.560

SILGAN CLOSURES, LLC (868) 8.650 6.350 0.050

WHIRLPOOL CORP 13.140 1.000 0.320

Total 124.070 65.130 7.210

Warrick 2005

'::;~-2' '~~~>"::<..:Flciiftv'f..lame'~; _ :~~7f~~>, ..; .~ ;NQX? mii er _:~ 502 CO<

CYPRESS CREEK MINE 0.000 20.110 0.000

Total 0.000 20.110 0.000

Warrick EGU 2005

I~' ., ~;'. \~;" ,,:"',:. ;"Name -~l-' '>~ "

.~~;J~?': 1"'~"N:6x,,;. PM~'~1;; r~r~sC5Z'"

ALCOA APGI - WARRICK POWER PLANT 10718.380 1119.420 82029.280

ALCOA INC. - WARRICK OPERATIONS 216.090 1050.530 3675.970

SIGECO - F.B.CULLEY GENERATING 4754.590 404.720 5083.070 STATION

Total 15689.060 2574.670 90788.320

E-7
This page left intentionally blank.
APPENDIXF

Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Sulfur Dioxides (S02) and

Direct Fine Particulate Matter (PM2.s) (2002-2005)

Emission Trends, All Sources, Southwestern

Indiana Area
This page left intentionally blank.
I. ,:,i~ " ::~. ..,. . ~.,... 'ailo:2; .....,_.:c'c "5,'~''':' ..':\ .., ''-; ;' .. "", .... , ',.. ,';'c'" .

'. .-;~' '.\. "</". '>t. :,...-) .~. ;,:: ',:~f":',~~.. ',"

~.0U ' '; s.tof':~~ NbXt.- 9(j .~, '02

::) -... .'~i:..,·~.::",: ;~ .. ''';'.~'.'''' ·..:Ii' '. r"~

DUBOIS AREA 422.16 446.63 1,220.41

DUBOIS NONROAD 870.98 52.50 66.10

DUBOIS POINT 902.05 112.11 809.10

DUBOIS ONROAD 1,514.30 26.30 69.64

GIBSON AREA 179.10 160.62 433.37

GIBSON NONROAD 1,192.81 84.73 108.95

GIBSON POINT 45,316.49 218.95 127,503.29

GIBSON ONROAD 1,743.22 31.01 69.29

PIKE AREA 31.10 49.74 31.34

PIKE NONROAD 296.11 23.68 26.99

PIKE POINT 24,023.24 235.61 65,235.73

PIKE ONROAD 713.51 11.08 26.97

SPENCER AREA 93.66 136.46 188.50

SPENCER NONROAD .1,224.97 78.57 129.15

SPENCER POINT 34,155.16 80.37 51,551.40

SPENCER ONROAD 1,538.39 23.41 51.90

VANDERBURGH AREA 869.58 530.81 1,596.00

VANDERBURGH NONROAD 2,415.19 137.14 210.71

VANDERBURGH POINT 285.46 143.90 19.85

VANDERBURGH ONROAD 3,850.88 69.19 141.53

WARRICK AREA 157.20 135.74 269.58

WARRICK NONROAD 494.18 42.43 46.65

WARRICK POINT 22,945.95 1,568.77 104,514.41

WARRICK ONROAD 2,076.22 37.47 61.69

F-l
I~.;~t; ,"''''':. ~':l~~:"R.

[1!' . ,,,,. (;)'U. .' .;,,< '~..•>..~,., -~ "i:' , ;~ , .¢.'NFR!' "', ,·~.~;I·· '.'

",'1lJ,.';'9; ..,y~·"*~~ '>,.•".;,.!*l,~. C ,,}'l

DUBOIS AREA 382.98 174.57 197.98

DUBOIS NONROAD 628.78 43.00 56.45

DUBOIS POINT 324.59 121.40 316.75

DUBOIS ONROAD 1,194.73 21.84 28.07

GIBSON AREA 232.56 130.38 122.74

GIBSON NONROAD 553.22 53.89 59.08

GIBSON POINT 30,367.14 134.51 154,234.95

GIBSON ONROAD 1,511.79 23.89 35.23

PIKE AREA 40.66 161.76 21.86

PIKE NONROAD 150.71 16.49 17.38

PIKE POINT 18,299.68 233.09 52,814.92

PIKE ONROAD 520.31 7.96 12.28

SPENCER AREA 93.43 155.50 40.81

SPENCER NONROAD 303.02 29.35 33.43

SPENCER POINT 21,781.17 85.76 68,364.89

SPENCER ONROAD 1,148.66 17.59 25.83

VANDERBURGH AREA 794.16 113.50 307.28

VANDERBURGH NONROAD 1,163.24 87.86 114.61

VANDERBURGH POINT 124.06 65.13 7.20

VANDERBURGH ONROAD 3,151.87 57.31 94.31

WARRICK AREA 178.53 170.32 79.19

WARRICK NONROAD 418.97 36.46 46.92

WARRICK POINT 15,689.05 2,594.79 90,788.32

WARRICK ONROAD 1,684.75 30.53 41.04

F-2
419.04

588.55

198.46 2,359.71

421.02 349,633.78

236.76 366,527.03

906.03

769.86

267.05

327.86

159.12 3,234.68

F-3
This page left intentionally blank.
APPENDIXG

Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) and Sulfur Dioxides (S02)

Emissions from Electric Generating Units,

Southwestern Indiana Area
This page left intentionally blank.
STATEWIDE EGU NOx TRENDS

Year NOx Emissions, tons / year

1999 347,217

2000 334,522

2001 315,420

2002 281,146

2003 260,980

2004 224,311

2005 207,982

2006 202,728

Budget 2009-2014 108,935

Budget 2015 and later 90,779

Statewide EGU Trends NOx Emissions

400,000 -,----------------------,

350,000

300,000

250,000

200,000

150,000 -

100,000

50,000

o

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

j~~

G-l
Southwest Indiana NOx Trends from EGUs

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

1999 145,539

2000 144,670

2001 137,431

2002 128,011

2003 122,979

2004 94,380

2005 88,986

2006 95,647

Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 1999

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 8,216

Alcoa 18,391

Cinergy Gibson 49,451

F.B. Culley 7,670

Frank E. Ratts 3,669

IPl- Petersburg 20,197

AEP- Rockport 37,946

Total 145,539

Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2000

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 6,864

Alcoa 18,151

Cinergy Gibson 47,818

F.B. Culley 7,827

Frank E. Ratts 4,522

IPl- Petersburg 22,493

AEP- Rockport 36,994

Total 144,670

0-2
Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2001

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 7,252

Alcoa 17,228

Cinergy Gibson 44,060

F.B. Culley 6,542

Frank E. Ratts 4,631

IPL- Petersburg 22,722

AEP- Rockport 34,997

Total 137,431

Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2002

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 7,400

Alcoa 17,550

Cinergy Gibson 38,241

F.B. Culley 6,318

Frank E. Ratts 4,012

IPL- Petersburg 20,247

AEP- Rockport 34,243

Total 128,011

Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2003

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 6,773

Alcoa 15,721

Cinergy Gibson 38,416

F.B. Culley 4,704

Frank E. Ratts 3,723

IPL- Petersburg 18,268

AEP- Rockport 35,374

Total 122,979

G-3
Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2004

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 5,319

Alcoa 11,873

Cinergy Gibson 36,850

F.B. Culley 3,337

Frank E. Ratts 3,801

IPL- Petersburg 14,858

AEP- Rockport 18,341

Total 94,380

Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2005

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 5,103

Alcoa 10,879

Cinergy Gibson 30,284

F.B. Culley 3,371

Frank E. Ratts 2,706

IPL- Petersburg 15,521

AEP- Rockport 21,122

Total 88,986

Southwest Indiana EGU NOx Trends 2006

Facility NOx Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 4,883

Alcoa 10,364

Cinergy Gibson 28,533

F.B. Culley 3,212

Frank E. Ratts 4,119

IPL- Petersburg 16,413

AEP- Rockport 28,124

Total 95,647

0-4
,------------------------------- ---

Southwest IN NOx Emissions from EGUs

160,000 -,----------------------,

140,000

120,000

100,000

80,000

60,000

40,000

20,000

o

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

:~NOxl

G-5
This page left intentionally blank.

0-6
STATEWIDE EGU S02 TRENDS

Year S02 Emissions, tons I year

1999 941,852.4

2000 874,617.2

2001 795,505.6

2002 778,868.0

2003 804,828.6

2004 862,876.4

2005 870,811.8

2006 820,993.4

Budget 2010-2014 254,599

Budget 2015 and later 178,219

Statewide IN S02 Emissions from EGUs

1,000,000 -r--------------------,

900,000

800,000

700,000

600,000

500,000

400,000

300,000

200,000

100,000

o

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

G-7
Southwest Indiana S02 Trends from EGUs

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

1999 435,359

2000 409,986

2001 374,391

2002 360,294

2003 372,978

2004 385,682

2005 371,728

2006 377,036

Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 1999

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 11,253

Alcoa 119,655

Cinergy Gibson 158,901

F.B. Culley 11,329

Frank E. Ratts 17,180

IPL- Petersburg 50,196

AEP- Rockport 66,845

Total 435,359

Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2000

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 6,863

Alcoa 91,387

Cinergy Gibson 171,505

F.B. Culley 11,737

Frank E. Ratts 23,050

IPL- Petersburg 42,056

AEP- Rockport 63,389

Total 409,986

0-8
Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2001

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 7,593

Alcoa 87,885

Cinergy Gibson 148,331

F.B. Culley 9,795

Frank E. Ratts 21,423

IPL- Petersburg 42,000

AEP- Rockport 57,365

Total 374,391

Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2002

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 8,639

Alcoa 98,777

Cinergy Gibson 127,357

F.B. Culley 7,119

Frank E. Ratts 18,055

IPL- Petersburg 47,152

AEP- Rockport 53,196

Total 360,294

Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2003

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 8,219

Alcoa 108,677

Cinergy Gibson 136,536

F.B. Culley 5,847

Frank E. Ratts 17,603

IPL- Petersburg 42,536

AEP- Rockport 53,561

Total 372,978

G-9
Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2004

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 8,235

Alcoa 106,124

Cinergy Gibson 164,121

F.B. Culley 5,586

Frank E. Ratts 18,251

IPL- Petersburo 38,738

AEP- Rockport 44,626

Total 385,682

Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2005

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 9,039

Alcoa 82,962

Cineroy Gibson 154,235

F.B. Culley 5,511

Frank E. Ratts 15,124

IPL- Petersburg 37,653

AEP- Rockport 67,205

Total 371,728

Southwest Indiana EGU S02 Trends 2006

Facility 502 Emissions, tons I year

A.B. Brown 8,956

Alcoa 72,859

Cinergy Gibson 155,057

F.B. Culley 5,998

Frank E. Ratts 21,638

IPL- Petersburg 28,985

AEP- Rockport 83,543

Total 377,036

0-10
Southwest IN S02 Emissions from EGUs

500,000 ,-.-----------------------,

450,000 -t-----------------------l

400,000

350,000

300,000

250,000

200,000

150,000

100,000

50,000

o

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

G-ll
This page left intentionally blank.

0-12
APPENDIXH

Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) and Sulfur Dioxides (S02)

Emissions from Electric Generating Units, Six

State Region
This page left intentionally blank.
(6

357

87.341

45.935

357.035

37.539

241.079

51.097

212.366

55.455

69.481

279.909

93.23

KGen Hot Spring LLC 45.168

Union Power Station

AR

AR

AR

,- ,fiii1 _':I.;' ':;~::V'i.o~·,;;/, -"'::'.

A~~ .. ~I LYnch-- .!l'lg ,~-" " , "tQ9;J:' ',1;:' :,:.. '1:9.99",' ~7.516 ;~.~31 ·~.15 . . 1.645 ' 0.;;~~;6 . "·'13

AR Hamilton Moses 399.741 150.986 77.641 52.341 0.726 0.118 52

AR HarveyCouch 329 406.842 623.267 342.677 299.131 161.099 75.254 13.37 22.213 112.481 27.062 48

AR Lake Catherine 1724 959.339 1710.251 2666.246 2451.584 2060.917 1570.033 547.766 140.483 204.357 25.58 (1,544

AR Robert E Ritchie 1536 1328.81 2258.241 1814.74 2731.185 234.329 394.04 29.937 0.386 (394

AR Thomas Fitzhugh 260 350.24 435.189 432.003 279.404 218.152 74.218 38.538 7.126 76.271 56.221 (18

AR Carl Bailey 400 185.92 417.436 443.711 456.088 343.662 147.79 92.563 264.028 138.203 36.815 (111

AR McClellan 132 220.334 520.858 559.179 668.243 545.167 278.436 312.515 444.042 205.248 159.97 (118

AR Pine Bluff Energy center 48.544 227.881 792.504 267.021 208.157 190.162 (38

Wrightsville Generating

Station

AR

AR

AR

Hot Spring Power Co., LLC

White Bluff

Rint Creek Power Plant

22643 20093.059 20826.629

5052 6406.228 6399.141

20540.407

6096.715

22515.306 19159.856

6017.559 5940.657

17704.706

5095.808

19016.176

4755.575

18206.888

4944.856

41.388

16262.701

4627.796

102.932

14155.37

5460.765

103

(3,549

365

AR

AR

Independence

Fulton

20512 14440.054 14181.018 17546.506 15657.667 18559.994

17.028

16314.772

3.166

15743.107

1.749

15520.502

0.483

13171.061

5.751

14662.846

4.701

(1,652

2

IL Joliet 29 12827 11313.649 11674.723 12977.054 8377.874 4057.932 3809.772 4401.23 4010.94 3639.807 3485.558 -324.214

IL

IL

Rocky Road Power, LLC

Kendall Energy Facility

66.61 34.935 26.162 28.77

104.263

9.193

47.346

10.84

98.612

6.971

120.301

19.116

105.876

-9.654

1.613

IL Geneva Energy, LLC 7.111 72.635 63.026 51.606 0.247 1.31 42.856 -20.17

IL

IL

IL

IL

Cordova Energy Company

Elwood Energy Facility

Gibson City Power Plant

Pinckneyville Power Plant

61.381 107.437

6.511

4.299

20.669

72.796

43.873

47.292

45.501

104.839

12.657

61.451

23.358

44.659

7.142

29.052

23.54

42.024

1.485

23.584

47.944

105.455

20.789

60.565

24.288

38.899

4.308

51.947

-21.213

-65.94

-8.349

-9.504

IL Kinmundy Power Plant 21.468 14.54 10.618 1.881 16.761 4.346 -10.194

IL

IL

Lincoln Generating Facility

Lee Energy Facility

6.222 20.391

17.656

14.791

11.495

5.024

0.928

1.337

2.091

9.258

17.773

2.86

3.034

-11.931

-8.461

IL

Reliant Energy Shelby

County 55.033 27.74 52.343 2.841 3.824 40.225 14.771 -37.572

IL

NRG Rockford Energy

Center 4.349 18.482 28.315 5.239 5.819 6.731 7.643 -20.672

IL

IL

IL

University Park Energy

Crete Energy Park

Reliant Energy - Aurora

18.23

35.74

32.4

4.283

65.361

10.667

1.316

18.423

49.686

0.263

12.9

117.81

2.365

76.019

78.984

2.514

24.69

46.584

-1.769

-40.671

IL

IL

IL

IL

Southeast Chicago Energy

Project

Calumet Energy Team

Holland Energy Facility

Zion Energy center

8.205

1.963

17.847

23.419

13.101

3.977

13.956

43.045

25.626

3.721

13.367

6.382

9.19

8.218

71.915

8.334

16.298

7.809

53.672

10.677

8.093

5.846

35.825

-12.742

IL Raccoon Creek Power Plan 0.256 0.385 13.043 2.212 1.956

IL Elgin Energy center 0.068 10.796 6.193 11.089 11.529 11.461

H-1
IL Goose Creek Power Plant 0.687 0.187 9.867 6.914 6.914

PPL University Park Power

IL Project 10.412 11.41 78.918 94.934 147.855 137.443

NRG Rockford II Energy

IL Center 6.96 0.512 2.61 12.652 7.104 0.144

IL Duck Creek 7748 7062.134 7155.746 6454.7 6372.87 6615.817 5327.635 3578.193 3413.054 2079.724 3383.042 -1944.593

IL Newton 9361 10982.618 8778.134 7619.587 6840.927 5019.395 5251.658 5049.268 4822.221 5049.707 4747.54 -504.118

IL Collins Station 2447 3494.738 4020.441 2424.754 2153.371 2926.978 1893.047 1822.755 860.444 -1893.047

IL Interstate 0.754 131.182 111.999 16.103 53.656 13.488 15.267 5.773 16.543 6.694 -6.794

IL Tilton Power Station 15.147 41.622 62.279 73.921 55.217 34.932 60.71 36.122 -37.799

IL Alsey Station 1.91 6.377 6.377

IL Freedom Power Project 2.467 0.003 0.042 2.748 1.196 -1.271

IL MEPI Gt Facility 12.439 63.59 23.482 12.906 5.736 19.007 11.294 (12

IL Factory Gas Turbine 0.075 0.366 0.518 0.518

IL ED Edwards 12657 13482.702 10031.249 10193.487 10521.135 9612.466 8845.816 8123.546 7490.7 6537.134 6695.651 -2150.165

IL Coffeen 31337 29205.218 24812.78 27828.649 25806.572 15274.54 14339.282 11223.812 11452.796 9282.813 11680.276 -2659.006

IL Grand Tower 2733 3356.631 2079.753 2175.263 2502.152 121.022 342.379 53.633 76.605 108.796 95.696 (247

IL Hutsonville 2443 2415.459 1282.51 1444.39 1704.533 1802.663 1798.691 1804.331 1695.061 1602.066 1253.369 -545.322

IL Meredosia 4605 4867.93 3387.389 3746.309 3976.561 3481.844 3816.01 2511.859 2859.682 2449.49 2282.983 -1533.027

IL Crawford 4686 3027.469 4778.028 3138.098 5516.702 2449.6 2849.782 2294.416 2259.431 2248.857 2494.695 -355.087

IL Joliet 9 3480 10115.021 6890.794 9195.685 4982.669 2865.15 2561.897 4167.478 4553.145 5418.558 3366.761 804.864

IL Kincaid Station 26094 25996.677 32533.526 27113.727 23795.854 22644.417 20905.106 20317.221 19387.329 14304.494 11811.553 -9093.553

IL Powerton 24938 44316.977 33633.414 39561.284 33774.212 35618.922 27219.42 23630.706 25251.534 30099.703 25539.786 -1679.634

IL WaUkegan 7267 11627.478 9626.895 7650.555 6566.754 6313.701 4945.106 4613.327 5153.243 4639.788 4940.185 -4.921

IL Will County 13882 16540.949 12658.019 10984.14 11316.453 10806.134 10618.977 2837.598 4162.734 7773.817 6323.501 -4295.476

IL Fisk 1945 3173.06 3094.834 2344.036 3207.832 2440.431 2462.517 1206.1 1238.826 1138.281 1298.832 -1163.685

IL Joppa Steam 11487 11937.108 9509.504 8446.814 8768.414 6897.938 5796.474 5771.068 5860.46 5524.015 5705.479 (91

IL Baldwin Energy Complex 65140 65328.815 62710.975 55026.62 26336.452 28388.925 22374.604 19061.223 15566.352 4873.88 4746.772 -17627.832

IL Havana 3925 5497.147 4315.207 5352.308 5750.23 3724.648 3970.774 3407.288 2210.131 756.626 725.973 -3244.801

IL Hennepin Power Station 5105 5396.194 5111.992 1139.038 3330.728 3089.883 3621.36 1972.553 1463.115 1327.05 1256.819 -2364.541

IL Vermilion Power Station 155 865.771 1979.262 1962.227 2094.229 1935.12 2217.034 2257.802 2119.79 1504.435 1076.276 -1140.758

IL Wood River Power Station 7158.9 1911.559 6583.264 6676.568 5964.064 6072.552 2426.112 2129.177 1931.804 2372.048 2528.628 102.516

IL Venice 92 148.693 190.693 181.847 99.064 77.994 79.549 2.745 2.658 48.023 33.047 -46.502

IL Dallman 8525 8301.855 8013.365 8073.798 8270.802 7655.708 8029.837 5239.971 6006.914 6613.895 5804.421 -2225.416

Il Lakeside 965 1572.075 1288.611 981.045 1075.34 1626.061 1214.759 1309.652 913.044 1196.361 1402.445 187.686

IL Marion 5212 8741.62 11731.451 9073.212 7884.878 7718.437 6702.744 6557.043 6102.328 4480.101 5304.037 (1,399

IN cayuga 9929 11713.61 9944.74 10142.572 10315.221 10262.632 7772.098 9641.099 12038.081 11562.295 9161.495 1389.397

Connersville Peaking

IN Station 3.119 0 2.637 3.383 3.383

IN Edwardsport 1671 2517.31 2182.889 2890.361 2857.205 2600.37 1924.487 1839.468 2590.185 1556.612 589.789 -1334.698

IN Noblesville 1162 1604.674 2244.312 2157.104 2145.116 1578.376 1152.657 842.597 22.215 28.098 10.002 -1142.655

IN R Gallagher 7056 5782.633 7286.04 6923.291 7514.644 6663.221 6133.137 6393.713 6299.317 5305.916 4238.782 -1894.355

IN Wabash River 9548 7548.032 8351.934 9877.297 11413.783 10927.276 11057.924 10423.53 9860.411 9001.501 8454.093 -2603.831

Broadway Avenue

IN Generating Station 14.615 17.003 34.403 37.529 38

F B Culley Generating

IN Station 6711 6646.278 8224.351 7670.028 7826.647 6542.04 6318.379 4703.753 3337.351 3371.308 3212.462 (3,106

H-2
IN Whitewater Valley 2366 1243.12 1638.105 1724.745 1449.593 1587.469 1580.955 1542.641 1137.528 1117.884 856.495 -724.46

IN Frank E Ratts 2799 3418.431 4235.02 3668.456 4522.401 4631.027 4012.308 3723.23 3801.134 2705.509 4118.994 106.686

IN Vermillion Energy Facility 16.052 33.831 23.786 15.955 1.027 23.499 34.468 10.682

IN Worthington Generation 23.937 37.917 22.572 41.256 33.342 6.92 -30.997

Wheatland Generating

IN Facility LLC 70.808 70.246 2.083 1.899 9.412 16.856 -53.39

Montpelier Electric Gen

IN Station 29.537 46.336 14.347 8.942 29.017 24.054 -22.282

IN Whiting Clean Energy, Inc. 74.334 24.302 41.006 51.009 46.807 -27.527

Sugar Creek Power

IN Company, LLC 9.281 289.593 28.933 58.268 21.638 12.357

Lawrenceburg Energy

IN Facility 4.155 28.085 31.468 31.468

R M Schahfer Generating

IN Station 22922 26367.311 27701.81 29288.794 21074.519 19460.865 17370.887 18258.79 13585.603 16852.542 14752.406 -2618.481

IN Gibson 44901 50927.28 52752.415 49450.452 47817.942 44059.822 38240.999 38416.439 36850.199 30283.761 28532.846 -9708.153

A B Brown Generating

IN Station 6352 7272.066 6774.732 8215.769 6864.382 7251.616 7399.654 6772.653 5318.755 5102.997 4882.712 (2,517\

IN Rockport 33613 37417.014 39146.648 37946.072 36994.414 34996.919 34242.691 35411.11 18341.678 21125.294 28124.042 (6,119

IN Merom 18957 16596.577 16173.367 16109.712 16191.906 16049.44 14332.72 12980.779 9780.301 10043.101 7807.976 -6524.744

Alcoa Allowance

IN Management Inc 18959 24133.025 22409.209 18391.374 18150.905 17227.721 17550.143 15721.045 11872.88 10879.288 10363.734 (7,186

IN Richmond (IN) 7.905 4.071 5.876 4.473 2.388 1.707 1.992 -3.884

IN Anderson 9.274 5.389 5.234 3.485 1.89 1.903 2.722 -2.512

IN Georgetown Substation 3.023 8.518 9.564 1.022 2.564 16.504 7.465 -2.099

Henry County Generating - IN Station 161.696 31.395 10.442 23.013 48.79 31.186 -0.209

Hoosier Energy Lawrence

IN Co Station 52.081 15.669 15.669

State Line Generating

IN Station (IN) 5722 7430.91 1557.88 8115.059 9586.142 7866.358 7140.734 8369.704 8347.933 6847.924 7288.088 147.354

IN Clifty Creek 63454 59799.677 54458.957 33118.952 31881.976 31232.756 29230.952 21888.92 22678.391 22620.944 21661.695 -7569.257

IN Tanners Creek 37963 40234.258 29140.284 33807.091 32657.122 25774.694 17533.765 13416.706 12552.796 7961.347 8041.612 -9492.153

Harding Street Station (EW

IN Stout) 6188 5725.185 6654.924 7899.749 6434.27 6723.712 6633.669 6352.326 6238.023 4557.949 4336.372 -2297.297

IPL Eagle Valley Generating

IN Station 1752 3062.523 3541.052 3785.088 4444.501 4480.324 4494.458 4427.6 3756.858 3536.066 2897.774 -1596.684

IN Petersburg 22218 19929.08 23163.399 20196.69 22493.174 22721.837 20246.528 18267.951 14858.251 15520.931 16412.724 -3833.804

IN Bailly Generating Station 23242 22900.403 23484.799 25168.2 20824.408 18611.494 16380.035 13333.836 13900.763 12330.958 10355.172 -6024.863

Dean H Mitchell Generating

IN Station 3715 3249.733 3782.538 3397.081 3144.358 2966.945 50.379 -50.379

Michigan City Generating

IN Station 18656 15874.549 11553.019 7272.531 7838.132 10686.738 9897.115 7800.085 6992.437 5068.962 6231.873 -3665.242

KY Big Sandy 20589 22180.282 21976.678 20707.167 18615.642 19900.82 15153.766 12403.516 10856.164 12490.931 13850.983 -1302.783

KY EWBrown 8866 7927.751 8706.135 8556.06 9850.771 7800.113 7924.734 8351.031 6901.092 5960.497 6682.986 -1241.748

KY Ghent 37641 31238.048 32283.42 29933.884 23869.81 22429.685 19233.877 19071.26 13931.339 13909.156 14318.156 -4915.721

KY Green River 2589 2169.682 3784.753 3654.35 3996.891 3257.025 2197.557 1834.71 1676.741 1554.67 1482.256 (715

KY Pineville 340 247.552 533.232 643.824 718.123 576.224 0

H-3
KY Tyrone 655 593.359 1051.444 1110.831 1363.738 1181.904 672.242 638.558 580.239 954.617 648.657 -23.585

KY cane Run 9592 7756.206 8113.292 8174.719 7713.528 7188.311 6271.818 6664.733 5585.286 7040.542 6791.453 519.635

KY Mill Creek 22631 19389.214 20918.493 20865.473 20455.666 17576.283 14606.96 14395.663 11897.465 13068.451 12594.279 -2012.681

KY Paddy's Run 26.143 41.236 12.362 13.118 53.6 34.001 -7.235

KY Henderson I 270 163.778 168.567 110.494 112.914 84.393 39.811 18.824 424.14 29.525 (10

KY Elmer Smith 10264 14419.634 12361.516 12639.834 12678.747 14200.798 9559.302 10745.3 7893.466 7707.415 7044.592 (2,515

KY Paradise 148946 152517.54 113756.11 104356.646 61701.799 54548.905 47027.117 39802.856 37424.277 35878.856 43022.352 -4004.765

KY Shawnee 37277 34770.118 27761.923 23955.841 19674.324 18708.26 20061.123 19922.612 18598.772 19378.63 18216.354 (1,845

KY Coleman 12563 8049.925 6939.284 7156.843 7749.024 7410.79 6848.408 6199.203 5386.763 5133.421 5320.169 -1528.239

KY HMP&L Station 2 9565 5739.061 5954.542 6074.481 6058.206 5592.452 5684.995 4922.224 4147.661 3707.426 4061.843 (1,623

KY Robert Reid 569 1275.733 1024.1 1507.36 1425.558 1119.094 1295.672 1176.01 608.78 1119.668 453.659 (842

KY John S. Cooper 3699 3593.435 4036.357 4355.197 3908.859 4589.788 4771.187 4229.231 5184.257 4614.684 4570.287 -200.9

KY William C. Dale 2119 1946.546 2150.05 2119.913 1811.94 1909.597 1977.176 2199.224 2233.78 2320.084 3162.126 1184.95

KY Smith Generating Facility 66.526 79.149 261.948 99.428 409.08 735.098 68.088 -193.86

Bluegrass Generation

KY Company, LLC 28.262 1.085 0.085 15.633 4.221 -24.041

Riverside Generating

KY Company 14.38 80.822 6.253 1.003 21.868 7.177 -73.645

KY Marshall 40.689 (41)

KY East Bend 7415 10406.684 7733.31 10113.826 8670.966 8161.488 5454.935 7056.003 6187.165 3952.203 5399.748 -55.187

KY H LSpurlock 13820 13997.403 15528.015 15898.402 12961.511 11728.783 8234.106 6918.243 7641.177 10088.874 8124.52 -109.586

KY Trimble County 6761 8004.212 7391.329 7987.342 7187.353 6894.762 5214.071 3963.258 4429.516 3434.159 3981.08 -1232.991

KY RDGreen 7347 7154.551 7685.653 7257.571 7322.474 7736.881 7400.614 6839.052 6338.331 5691.52 6160.742 (1,240

KY DBWilson 8672 7318.152 9553.018 9876.013 8717.227 9556.388 8516.2 7653.898 6816.366 6330.159 5772.617 (2,744

MO Asbury 5870 7197.51 6396.548 6097.883 5876.884 4768.68 6169.076 5278.962 5611.444 5532.284 5693.852 (475

MO Hawthorn 5312 4867.299 4104.013 566.784 145.971 1003.999 2398.542 2459.933 1929.914 1548.736 1548.748 -849.794

MO Montrose 5870 6370.209 6210.704 6513.818 6132.464 5872.817 5586.542 5232.287 6216.942 6535.929 6040.625 454.083

MO Sibley 19580 19152.213 22627.672 18862.711 13139.035 11756.174 11491.436 12251.306 10233.618 9100.316 9134.683 -2356.753

MO Lake Road 1832 3542.164 3500.243 3098.768 2730.87 3241.367 3369.461 2628.949 2576.653 2439.028 2034.454 -1335.007

MO Labadie 14349 15865.153 15092.444 10426.597 9178.679 8615.621 7819.441 8313.971 9579.135 9528.397 9308.529 1489.088

MO Meramec 6409 6240.892 7019.661 7812.142 7764.882 9587.301 9419.184 10803.008 8007.818 7746.671 6824.305 -2594.879

MO Sioux 26379 27274.092 23552.85 24170.389 25265.2 15403.237 14090.118 12062.239 10144.497 8476.565 7339.518 -6750.6

MO Columbia 306 278.426 252.549 264.37 260.376 209.489 278.46 270.48 264.661 277.546 315.171 36.711

MO Blue Valley 120 322.42 594.496 328.798 289.397 305.416 96.147 343.064 403.74 326.936 391.993 295.846

MO James River 4114 3928.015 4336.563 4562.866 4960.423 4160.054 4584.306 4055.427 3215.586 3199.377 3021.279 (1,563)

MO New Madrid Power Plant 48632 54246.274 55610.078 52221.513 35860.836 37781.545 37464.764 39030.946 28662.798 32239.911 28757.109 (8,708)

MO Thomas Hill Energy Center 24823 26093.015 28375.801 31290.161 26774.931 22496.934 18275.784 20868.079 16878.612 16471.375 16302.011 -1973.773

MO Chamois Power Plant 2193 1962.236 1578.298 1582.164 1945.364 1836.759 1956.402 1647.058 1612.504 1282.749 1564.105 -392.297

MO Dogwood Energy Facility 58.32 66.586 52.618 56.508 19.365 9.704 -56.882

MO Audrain Power Plant 1.752 4.838 5.292 5.64 0.802

Columbia Energy Center

MO (MO) 1.386 1.851 1.727 0.859 1.856 4.686 2.835

South Harper Peaking

MO Facility 9.411 36.293 36.293

MO latan 7734 7040.894 7718.426 6429.794 6055.783 6896.77 7596.426 9965.35 9882.579 8347.964 7651.979 55.553

MO Rush Island 7999 6858.307 7105.547 5692.032 5390.645 4118.157 3991.808 3783.6 3266.125 4069.38 3967.101 -24.707

MO SouthweSt 2016 2319.519 2921.097 2546.864 2362.372 2931.298 2671.483 3348.559 2785.636 2685.278 2471.465 (200)

H-4
Empire District Elec Co

MO Energy Ctr 15.498 17.682 35.755 37.618 38

MO Sikeston 4823 4398.372 13758.188 2295.74 2362.114 2366.59 2204.988 2284.65 2346.262 2687.144 2272.439 67

MO State Line (MO) 1697.341 1195 145.483 66.63 71.673 102.617 77.097 (68)

MO St. Francis Power Plant 6.847 28.166 52.43 37.413 27.27 33.447 54.429 56.503 19

MO Essex Power Plant 12.078 37.984 26.497 15.854 2.236 1.483 1.79 8.951 (7)

MO Nodaway Power Plant 16.541 57.054 28.193 12.491 3.121 1.295 1.067 11.026 -1.465

MO Holden Power Plant 13.152 6.334 0.945 6.033 11.278 -1.874

McCartney Generating

MO Station 13.262 11.561 6.151 30.051 34.693 21

MO Peno Creek Energy Center 23.448 20.837 16.493 73.604 45.99 22.542

TN Allen 28967 29192.938 26389.223 16215.273 18707.78 18560.367 14470.535 11524.486 11304.85 12493.329 13287.657 (1,183

TN Bull Run 13109 17836.451 16588.061 13527.791 15596.024 18721.752 19363.902 17385.965 7994.341 11487.599 8351.999 -11011.903

TN Cumberland 140381 161522.19 119059.9 82671.367 52098.238 51179.775 49943.269 33609.443 34958.724 27185.993 34359.768 (15,584

TN Gallatin 12689 12314.337 11289.01 12982.526 10624.176 11036.1 11812.229 11909.352 9825.214 8504.873 6990.668 -4821.561

TN John sevier 12119 11196.849 10360.292 11777.171 10761.355 10183.982 10210.792 10621.133 10717.196 9621.096 9690.011 -520.781

TN Johnsonville 20376 18700.859 18003.154 20369.075 22650.222 20394.436 23913.561 22890.018 20057.381 17813.329 18201.568 (5,712

TN Kingston 30183 27426.469 27476.287 26055.442 25493.351 26165.526 26084.753 26544.358 14906.243 14318.402 13953.162 -12131.591

TN Watts Bar 0

TN Brownsville Power I, LLC 0 75.121 25.354 39.976 8.268 6.088 5.482 15.464 (25

TN Gleason Generating Facility 3.711 66.374 73.208 2.675 2.181 (71\

TN Lagoon Creek 31.06 84.126 93.619 37.642 93.341 67.203 (17

TotaJs 1517034 1573470.8 1461110.5 1345532.301 1174498.763 1095931.3 991782.23 913024.85 804119.35 759111.52 748463.55 -243318.677

H-5
H-6
. ; - . - .~..... " .' ~~iJi;'JiJil_d~_":'<; -,::,,,,,c:;"~:'~I\~ -. .'1 , ., .. .. '" '- ~Gt.1: ;~998t"';l f,I::::r;:tIi99:~ 1::\41;",2 '.. - .:1 ~lZ.,;~, k 2tJ. ~. ,:a0.Qi4::--" 1./ 72005::!.. ~'" :. .'. -

AR Cecil Lynch 0.55 0.284 0.134 0.004 0.001 0.043 -0.091

AR Hamilton Moses 0.425 0.366 0.225 0.182 0.003 0 -0.182

AR Harvey Couch 1.2 1.158 1.446 0.739 0.866 0.504 0.339 0.061 0.119 0.302 0.138 -0.201

AR Lake catherine 4 2.121 3.894 6.068 5.358 5.032 4.067 1.754 0.572 0.736 0.088 -3.979

AR Robert E Ritchie 4.5 3.558 5.393 4.141 7.038 0.551 0.888 0.102 0.004 -0.888

AR Thomas Fitzhugh 53.2 5.057 3.373 4.072 145.17 529.418 171.348 8.682 0.447 13.699 0.367 -170.981

AR carl Bailey 277.8 58.962 9.452 65.479 262.956 1560.006 380.279 434.511 1193.956 220.403 149.074 -231.205

AR McClellan 191.1 86.982 492.294 583.164 1640.601 2369.913 440.674 1668.734 2089.962 461.214 441.11 0.436

AR Pine Bluff Energy center 0.891 11.105 9.866 6.086 3.712 3.416 -7.689

Wrightsville Generating

AR Station 0.799 0.471 0.709 -0.09

AR Union Power Station 7.498 5.709 6.741 10.495 10.495

AR KGen Hot Spring LLC 2.021 2.403 1.347 1.39 2.16 0.139

AR Hot Spring Power Co., LLC 1.089 3.283 3.283

AR White Bluff 55442.3 46717.162 36861.405 38205.65 38270.989 36715.823 34151.42 39303.695 44497.997 34889.863 38122.068 3970.648

AR Aint Creek Power Plant 11083.3 14798.804 15047.198 11853.735 12862.888 14531.152 10961.213 9429.045 10098.571 8227.253 8526.449 -2434.764

AR Independence 28369.9 23120.513 ~3853.312 26674.296 21860.675 23015.138 24613.833 22140.18 23588.239 22363.256 26172.297 1558.464

AR Fulton 0.225 0.032 0.024 0.006 0.055 0.051 0.019

IL Joliet 29 18832.6 19895.243 20290.63 21101.48 19185.238 16130.821 20664.003 23293.596 16244.832 15286.851 14359.838 -6304.165

IL Rocky Road Power, LLC 0.297 0.275 0.212 0.228 0.075 0.092 0.048 0.15 -0.078

IL Kendall Energy Facility 2.374 1.005 1.309 2.991 2.762 0.388

IL Geneva Energy, LLC 2.171 170.949 57.353 63.473 0.24 3.08 34.383 -22.97

IL Cordova Energy Company 0.897 1.916 0.865 0.917 1.99 0.97 -0.946

IL Elwood Energy Facility 0.335 0.774 1.154 1.727 0.419 0.471 1.177 0.591 -1.136

IL Gibson City Power Plant 0.595 3.892 0.144 0.059 0.012 0.293 0.042 -0.102

IL Pinckneyville Power Plant 0.027 0.318 0.458 0.224 0.174 0.434 0.374 -0.084

IL Kinmundy Power Plant 0.807 0.127 0.091 0.014 0.16 0.034 -0.093

IL Lincoln Generating Facility 0.131 0.499 0.359 0.085 0.026 0.219 0.071 -0.288

IL Lee Energy Facility 0.252 0.208 0.017 0.038 0.351 0.057 -0.151

Reliant Energy Shelby

IL County 0.304 0.205 0.386 0.02 0.029 0.255 0.088 -0.298

NRG Rockford Energy

IL center 0.019 0.158 0.218 0.057 0.066 0.09 0.1 -0.118

IL University Park Energy 0.078 0.139 0.044 0.2 0.464 0.617 0.478

IL Crete Energy Park 0.093 0.02/ 0.005 0.052 0.053 -0.04

IL Reliant Energy - Aurora 0.483 0.676 0.26 0.169 0.977 0.28 -0.396

Southeast Chicago Energy

IL Project 0 0.035 0.071 0.022 0.039 0.039

IL Calumet Energy Team 0.023 0.039 0.037 0.079 0.077 0.054

IL Holland Energy Facility 0.434 0.309 0.317 1.965 1.516 1.082

IL . Zion Energy center 0.482 0.34 0.109 0.133 0.175 -0.307

IL Raccoon Creek Power Plan 0.004 0.005 0.238 0.05 0.046

IL Elgin Energy center 0.001 0.112 0.068 0.121 0.111 0.11

H-7
Il Goose Creek Power Plant 0.006 0.003 0.222 0.161 0.161

PPl University Park Power

Il Project 0.069 0.179 0.379 0.758 0.834 0.765

NRG Rockford II Energy

Il center 0.132 0.009 0.019 0.13 0.088 -0.044

Il Duck Creek 13668.6 16322.431 12648.709 11878.033 11114.943 11088.708 11025.623 10410.549 9998.952 5133.653 3848.534 -7177.089

Il Newton 26552.5 30317.13 21805.539 18811.797 15958.025 15457.788 17869.537 16870.072 17726.815 21049.62 20921.552 3052.015

Il Collins Station 2941.2 1236.821 1111.744 168.62 1273.08 5549.11 470.685 4059.596 2024.833 -470.685

Il Interstate 0.77 5.873 5.272 0.927 1.053 0.035 1.238 0.509 0.897 0.133 0.098

Il Tilton Power Station 0.09 0.279 0.39 0.499 0.365 0.223 0.383 0.199 -0.3

Il Alsey Station 0

Il Freedom Power Project 0.057 0.1 0.058 0 0.001 0.061 0.008 -0.05

Il MEPI Gt Facility 0.056 0.298 0.114 0.062 0.028 0.096 0.058 -0.056

Il Factory Gas Turbine 0 0 0 0

Il ED Edwards 67792.9 76405.827 70864.805 71994.728 56809.55 50125.589 35748.355 55035.352 42059.042 34864.82 33943.948 -1804.407

Il Coffeen 43754.6 47756.055 49412.611 47611.147 39089.071 37686.773 42331.064 44322.963 46364.551 40949.348 22006.748 -20324.316

Il Grand Tower 19552.5 25924.566 15022.842 12395.633 13774.121 0.764 2.698 0.396 0.626 0.791 0.816 -1.882

Il Hutsonville 19300.6 19621.897 10903.969 10651.892 13827.546 15102.127 14954.625 17295.22 14140.687 9928.32 5779.053 -9175.572

Il Meredosia 22726.8 28130.095 23580.948 18097.06 22512.401 22421.246 25148.415 11632.74 12300.312 11977.877 7732.362 -17416.053

Il Crawford 7974.4 4600.325 7878.831 6706.652 9331.539 5667.614 7595.558 7906.48 9137.467 9223.655 9045.893 1450.335

Il Joliet 9 1967.3 7963.481 5522.791 7324.367 4309.172 4063.125 4559.483 6084.961 4852.509 4854.258 4075.392 -484.091

Il Kincaid Station 20050.7 41095.796 46416.391 19866.933 18449.013 17805.171 17665.086 19143.531 21967.971 17446.447 13692.252 -3972.834

Il Powerton 23803.1 28111.005 19577.071 36068.946 22772.028 20522.345 16814.009 18532.25 23449.237 23793.774 19860.254 3046.245

Il WaUkegan 11533. 22717.47 23011.108 18102.62:.: 17650.736 11025.761 10781.94 .10425.13 14544.928 12174.364 11815.447 1033.507

Il Will County 1374 15318.903 16887.174 15402.257 16228.663 10933.029 13683.786 9129.85 14715.95 16189.272 17306.355 3622.569

Il FISk 3142. 5259.708 5350.308 4305.737 4848.132 3535.248 3842.633 4317.614 5136.794 4616.411 5640.693 1798.06

Il Joppa Steam 25286. 24200.47 23852.295 23744.24 23437.885 22179.662 23128.668 24025.955 28047.838 25963.058 26408.12 3279.452

Il Baldwin Energy Complex 273636 276034.5 284616.16 245243.209 36598.852 23130.1~ 26267.337 26311.253 27020.773 24008.718 24976.508 -1290.829

Il Havana 7655.9 11592.492 9476.485 9816.189 10976.536 8126.559 12881.817 9851.896 8568.746 7456.043 5810.124 -7071.693

Il Hennepin Power Station 46256.6 48134.388 48372.113 27717.095 5732.177 4173.188 4792.11 4213.225 4531.833 4603.89 4734.229 -57.881

Il Vermilion Power Station 578.9 6208.225 12220.267 10832.998 13000.693 15113.809 16517 17371.433 15046.011 11392.328 2222.475 -14294.525

Il Wood River Power Station 13834.8 3778.136 15264.277 14311.408 13569.402 17783.179 7262.011 6198.91 5652.844 7236.949 7628.395 366.384

Il Venice 33.9 50.926 17.385 24.532 6.829 1.808 0.5 0.083 0.158 0.523 0.373 -0.127

Il Dallman 35478.7 37445.338 36353.402 33808.746 22427.398 12132.044 3418.73 3143.594 3865.748 3634.956 3125.016 -293.714

Il lakeside 6044.1 10451.593 8293.618 6911.237 3328.807 2906.391 7210.512 8271.482 6042.365 7617.138 8984.871 1774.359

Il Marion 6738.9 14829.846 18879.013 17450.847 13632.516 15375.962 8994.578 7415.624 9452.215 7211.294 6376.801 -2617.777

IN cayuga 70847.8 108789.4 88938.564 83462.561 65733.704 58826.619 55616.693 66962.53 70796.059 77641.552 83173.546 27556.853

Connersville Peaking

IN Station 0

IN Edwardsport 8281.4 10469.154 9234.001 11308.055 10792.683 9124.968 8177.595 8020.997 10708.804 7141.44 3325.41 -4852.185

IN Noblesville 5806.1 7176.74 9279.44 9613.3 6874.101 4688.063 3611.213 1224.564 0.749 1.14 0.395 -3610.818

IN RGallagher 50435.4 46844.967 50578.935 49876.538 59008.192 47511.223 47767.202 53340.84 62653.584 56666.684 50819.116 3051.914

IN Wabash River 51109.2 46445.377 59405.059 60567.194 58471.231 52776.664 61899.363 64606.456 64429.615 66774.172 58793.292 -3106.071

Broadway Avenue

IN Generating Station 0

F B Culley Generating

IN Station 7097.6 6953.191 9590.01 11329.301 11737.3 9795.111 7118.784 5846.45 5586.106 5511.413 5997.784 -1121

H-8
IN Whitewater Valley 13862 12506.822 16997.166 18943.585 12073.159 13432.158 12872.552 12881.797 13321.028 11832.775 8330.74 -4541.812

IN Frank E Ratts 13349 16554.616 18627.399 17180.243 23050.188 21423.216 18055.039 17602.947 18251.175 15123.752 21638.294 3583.255

IN Vermillion Energy Facility 0.289 0.682 0.457 0.064 0.018 0.336 0.185 -0.272

IN Worthington Generation 0.156 0.246 0.148 0.279 0.237 0.056 -0.19

Wheatland Generating

IN Facility LLC 0.503 0.472 0.013 0.012 0.057 0.11 -0.362

Montpelier Electric Gen

IN Station 0.209 0.326 0.093 0.051 0.183 0.147 -0.179

IN Whiting Clean Energy, Inc. 1.668 1.156 2.049 2.823 2.898 1.23

Sugar Creek Power

IN Company, LLC 0.182 0.707 0.518 1.114 0.55 0.368

Lawrenceburg Energy

IN Facility 0.091 0.654 1.118 1.118

R M Schahfer Generating

IN Station 30989.7 34978.998 36583.426 41669.524 34934.727 34057.386 27494.36 35301.488 32224.236 40334.721 35907.718 8413.358

IN Gibson 155728.1 152512.98 169188.19 158900.899 171504.745 148330.72 127356.45 136536.35 164121.21 154234.59 155056.84 27700.385

A B Brown Generating

IN Station 8243.6 12453.271 11732.514 11253.049 6863.146 7592.535 8638.494 8218.871 8234.489 9038.907 8956.18 317.686

IN Rockport 66623.2 65643.269 67445.946 66844.521 63388.832 57365.214 53195.834 53561.112 44626.036 67205.171 83543.429 30347.595

IN Merom 37452.1 36141.801 37125.873 37355.657 16819.434 15490.92 12845.806 14689.379 15655.524 20818.81 14846.758 2000.952

Alcoa Allowance

IN Management Inc 92918.7 118901.09 113117.41 119655.391 91386.491 87885.157 98777.416 108676.85 106124.32 82961.638 72858.611 -25918.805

IN Richmond (IN) 4.381 0.503 0.234 1.42 0.436 0.3 0.024 -0.21

IN Anderson 3.283 0.699 0.38 1.406 0.062 0.37 0.132 -0.248

IN Georgetown Substation 0.089 0.222 0.241 0.023 0.052 0.341 0.157 -0.084

Henry County Generating

IN Station 0.071 0.237 0.075 0.151 0.345 0.218 -0.019

Hoosier Energy Lawrence

IN Co Station 0.387 0.12 0.12

State Line Generating

IN Station (IN) 5251.4 7234.745 1084.383 7084.955 8993.959 7860.054 8442.947 8010.985 9701.472 7949.356 7348.026 -1094.921

IN Clifty Creek 104328.8 93455.323 89192.398 52675.493 42678.202 39163.798 38197.48 32753.63 53136.037 74658.728 65371.759 27174.279

IN Tanners Creek 71046.9 76450.468 46672.163 50715.728 67446.142 55430.604 62531.681 53175.046 64387.33 46533.715 35494.163 -27037.518

Harding Street Station (EW

IN Stout) 38277.4 36726.653 39963.857 44589.642 40309.816 43052.698 47267.885 51016.887 44782.93 49350.714 46346.21 -921.675

IPL Eagle Valley Generating

IN Station 8913 13052.694 12879.771 15475.749 17662.581 16431.53 17216.274 16935.544 16759.716 17811.321 14829.317 -2386.957

IN Petersburg 67109.9 46369.725 50307.774 50195.787 42055.672 41999.451 47152.084 42535.643 38738.395 37652.899 28984.736 -18167.348

IN Bailly Generating Station 3835.1 3795.206 4205.199 3813.345 5144.825 6076.155 5217.628 4544.019 3608.682 4720.213 3308.728 -1908.9

Dean H Mitchell Generating

IN Station 7277.4 7684.183 9366.297 8829.995 6364.013 6797.175 127.332 -127.332

Michigan City Generating

IN Station 14841.1 15261.662 16668.356 10511.876 11297.882 10279.432 9178.011 8221.366 14876.859 16745.081 15992.795 6814.784

KY Big Sandy 56764.1 75254.507 71979.098 67367.641 51810.402 55845.863 41899.029 46959.659 48009.985 50098.358 46475.757 4576.728-

KY EW Brown 38573 36419.957 42244.031 45566.68 50379.346 49106.403 46605.438 56450.619 52121.816 42870.571 45191.437 -1414.001

KY Ghent 56114.5 54880.56~ 59221.257 61505.695 59186.628 52234.491 46571.248 46642.574 51497.726 50185.674 49912.686 3341.438

KY Green River 18419.4 17659.142 24727.785 20975.691 23360.441 19353.469 12980.311 15767.294 17928.802 15918.355 14176.622 1196.311

KY Pineville 666.1 556.966 1065.542 1334.442 1449.474 1144.064 0

H-9
KY Tyrone 1079.7 1083.026 1859.045 2087.517 2606.752 2341.627 2563.572 2552.874 2370.327 3191.654 2190.914 -372.658

KY cane Run 13097 16159.751 17634.215 17877.42 17438.701 16120.485 14984.594 16294.001 15769.971 18861.662 17122.084 2137.49

KY Mill Creek 51580.3 48620.679 48638.585 45051.265 34502.303 22514.718 22568.705 25079.917 25692.832 24032.243 25464.431 2895.726

KY Paddy's Run 0.602 1.277 0.085 0.091 0.394 0.274 -1.003

KY Henderson I 2443 1236.658 1580.281 996.286 698.409 517.747 382.438 185.616 2260.999 280.264 -102.174

KY Elmer Smith 6279.6 7688.039 7010.738 8402.48 6855.68 6369.78 7112.707 5015.789 6767.491 5824.134 2524.958 -4587.749

KY Paradise 190293 212376.8 158871.83 181064.952 145040.034 111231.96 84071.952 108463.17 90570.429 84401.215 83926.166 -145.786

KY Shawnee 45886.1 38297.02 34056.721 35874.065 34086.406 31428.302 35577.304 35513.212 33884.212 36231.217 35815.442 238.138

KY Coleman 57156.9 50620.363 38153.767 37437.194 45196.674 49119.961 49028.244 55449.803 59149.075 56813.014 10898.684 -38129.56

KY HMP&L Station 2 5893.1 4623.253 4526.741 5805.418 5901.596 6404.07 3484.405 4297.808 4563.71 4740.4 4573.738 1089.333

KY Robert Reid 2597.6 6235.24 5962.657 7913.005 7438.507 9896.544 10581.732 9590.269 5648.117 9279.932 3690.093 -6891.639

KY John S. Cooper 16652.4 15818.392 17612.942 19881.663 18101.644 23388.49 22713.134 20595.584 30529.165 23422.429 21182.235 -1530.899

KY William C. Dale 5080.6 6206.854 6977.886 6835.605 6286.362 6845.963 7403.871 7759.35 7758.339 8209.54 8624.431 1220.56

KY Smith Generating Facility 1.158 0.995 1.776 11.161 2.489 3.333 1.01 -0.766

Bluegrass Generation

KY Company, LLC 0.368 0.013 0 0.171 0.049 -0.319

Riverside Generating

KY Company 0.13 0.877 0.066 0.006 0.22 0.085 -0.792

KY Marshall 3.248 -3.248

KY East Bend 11022.7 13082.515 13064.084 18095.815 14850.423 13106.455 12918.1 14959.755 11545.53 3666.679 3946.544 -8971.556

KY H L Spurlock 37919.4 38274.552 42648.267 44985.785 38651.181 37382.573 40510.324 40362.354 31921.751 41686.87 38876.754 -1633.57

KY Trimble County 11841.2 13716.321 12633.988 14663.996 7583.19 7722.78 8371.752 5945.564 4725.572 5236.618 829.747 -7542.005

KY R D Green 3398.7 2326.189 3964.293 4843.797 3382.645 2755.033 3423.808 3134.598 2887.774 2280.189 2565.434 -858.374

KY DBWilson 9520.4 7964.024 10602.329 10416.064 10108.639 10612.971 8893.132 8527.971 9799.534 11007.761 9306.498 413.366

MO Asbury 6338.5 9236.182 8212.184 8045.6 3735.024 2216.355 4349.278 4165.111 7598.696 11964.932 14516.802 10167.524

MO Hawthorn 8352.2 9298.019 7107.956 821.945 1.56 3043.631 3752.43 2643.2 2181.529 2141.965 1896.618 -1855.812

MO Montrose 8308.1 9388.654 12947.466 9669.035 9516.743 15174.049 15826.364 15722.275 16847.265 15703.527 11561.135 -4265.229

MO Sibley 17893.5 19838.627 27055.681 26182.841 ·15878.791 10530.38 11804.088 12511.536 12858.749 13794.955 11967.053 162.965

MO Lake Road 8794.4 13339.944 7369.297 2088.359 1759.738 2243.237 2838.231 2483.167 2389.959 2613.17 2287.039 -551.192

MO Labadie 106905.3 53926.021 57595.911 38780.754 39293.288 44228.431 47610.005 56632.431 60711.588 55502.387 51444.635 3834.63

MO Meramec 17225 16938.988 14501.068 14699.762 17929.694 22635.384 16446.538 15450.887 29685.594 18013.447 20661.548 4215.01

MO Sioux 56395.9 55107.949 41947.359 43772.431 36538.053 39741.282 45957.325 49382.642 40115.062 51261.456 44148.04 -1809.285

MO Columbia 762 677.859 633.155 722.469 643.129 520.39 884.639 806.911 842.709 993.357 1204.332 319.693

MO Blue Valley 1129.5 1994.504 4857.67 5300.69 3903.237 4676.464 1359.791 5154.58 6977.864 5318.784 5996.869 4637.078

MO James River 15744.2 6576.695 5926.539 5027.386 6511.824 5262.321 4713.524 3790.657 4210.944 4157.43 4039.824 -673.7

MO New Madrid Power Plant 16862.3 19398.31 17753.46 16433.221 16450.755 14509.083 15797.742 14879.721 15105.466 13700.156 14677.609 -1120.133

MO Thomas Hill Energy Center 17416.9 19563.424 17716.743 21126.3 18313.743 18923.632 15220.638 18896.203 16985.402 17247.262 18495.117 3274.479

MO Chamois Power Plant 10272.2 9912.074 8196.394 8167.368 2653.729 1266.491 1225.538 1023.562 982.194 883.822 1112.187 -113.351

MO Dogwood Energy Facility 0.583 2.206 1.737 1.938 0.661 0.337 -1.869

MO Audrain Power Plant 0.033 0.091 0.123 0.139 0.048

Columbia Energy Center

MO (MO) 0.007 0.03 0.027 0.012 0.028 0.074 0.044

South Harper Peaking

MO Facility 0.111 0.452 0.452

MO latan 18712.9 17926.72 19296.113 17396.935 13430.025 16283.381 14856.258 18399.953 19219.079 19217.219 17517.851 2661.593

MO Rush Island 27269.2 25143.296 27408.865 27195.545 26899.32 19874.561 23255.498 24993.178 22917.815 28385.147 28674.461 5418.963

MO Southwest 3066.1 3784.749 6837.259 3537.868 2737.145 3631.654 3389.584 3855.902 3412.201 3208.007 4165.906 776.322

H-10
Empire District Elec Co

MO Energy Ctr 0.263 0.2 2.232 0.276 0.276

MO Sikeston 9947.6 10570.175 6580.253 7304.945 6523.288 6795.82 6236.152 6232.519 6251.031 7564.874 6351.207 115.055

MO State Line (MO) 3.145 2.941 3.038 2.245 2.722 4.264 3.564 0.526

MO Sl Francis Power Plant 0.326 1.455 1.757 1.24 0.873 1.024 1.638 1.801 0.561

MO Essex Power Plant 0.056 0.189 0.1 0.037 0.011 0.007 0.015 0.068 0.031

MO Nodaway Power Plant 0.11 0.347 0.205 0.131 0.028 0.013 0.013 0.105 -0.026

MO Holden Power Plant 1.664 1.08 0.077 0.381 0.25 -1.414

McCartney Generating

MO Station 0.053 0.063 0.034 0.162 0.205 0.152

MO Peno Creek Energy Center 0.307 0.48 1.49 1.099 0.331 0.024

TN Allen 20331.5 21323.002 20211.091 13680.792 18862.247 15454.411 18710.852 18784.668 23495.008 23882.405 17413.37 -1297.482

TN Bull Run 45415.1 66747.441 55309.298 38178.655 36669.12 46536.531 45605.928 44448.606 28606.11 37533.714 27986.584 -17619.344

TN Cumberland 22775.2 20967.82 20500.933 15920.839 19855.527 15550.24 16661.13 14791.004 18526.319 17473.366 18351.838 1690.708

TN Gallatin 116665.7 117103.06 86214.917 84841.209 78308.892 56182.389 34159.004 30634.489 26798.98 25900.318 23458.921 -10700.083

TN John Sevier 75022.3 68826.29 58189.252 61884.637 55899.176 41881.36 35487.385 38843.175 35145.901 30468.829 30125.585 -5361.8

TN Johnsonville 126366.5 115937.74 114588.36 119777.916 118425.947 94198.249 108792.93 100028.46 95676.869 74603.353 86792.722 -22000.21

TN Kingston 105188.2 106106.54 117184.97 109193.836 96951.453 90290.988 77570.969 91984.897 75060.818 56207.757 55472.542 -22098.427

TN Watts Bar 0

TN Brownsville Power I, LLC 0.029 0.683 0.253 0.397 0.084 0.04 0.051 0.157 -0.24

TN Gleason Generating Facility 0.027 0.459 0.485 0.017 0.013 -0.472

TN Lagoon Creek 0.895 5.478 16.729 3.926 11.084 4.717 -0.761

Totals 3267579 3373335 3241276.5 3088338.891 2612120.381 2369446.2 2258380.2 2369131.5 2392870 2301524.8 2122610 -135770.25

H-11

APPENDIX I

2005 Base Year Emissions Inventory and 2010 and

2020 Projected Emissions Inventory Nitrogen

Oxides (NOx), Sulfur Dioxides (S02) and Direct

Fine Particulate Matter (PM2.s) in Southwestern

Indiana Area
This page left intentionally blank.
2005 (Tons per Year)

I Area I Category NOx Direct PM25 I S02

Southwestern Indiana

Area Area 1,722.33 906.03 769.86

Southwestern Indiana

Area Nonroad 3,219.92 267.05 327.86

Southwestern Indiana

Area Onroad 9,212.11 159.12 236.76

Southwestern Indiana

Area Point 86,585.69 3,234.67 366,527.03

Total 100,738.05 4,566.88 367,861.51

2010 (Tons per Year)

I Area I Category NOx Direct PM25 I S0 2

Southwestern Indiana

Area Area 1,743.04 749.00 762.77

Southwestern Indiana

Area Nonroad 4,915.38 266.77 175.86

Southwestern Indiana

Area Onroad 6,144.94 108.21 84.24

Southwestern Indiana

Area Point 52,999.59 3,466.64 145,268.70

Total 65,802.94 4,590.62 146,291.56

2020 (Tons per Year)

I Area I Category NOx Direct PM25 I S02

Southwestern Indiana

Area Area 1,788.64 776.74 771.64

Southwestern Indiana

Area Nonroad 3,103.83 142.84 111.27

Southwestern Indiana

Area Onroad 2,914.05 72.16 45.75

Southwestern Indiana

Area Point 26,114.03 3,696.79 132,989.86

Total 33,920.55 4,688.54 133,918.53

2005 2020 Change % Change

NOx 100,738.05 33,920.55 -66,817.5 66.33%

decrease

502 367,861.51 133,918.53 -233,942.98 63.60%

decrease

Direct PM2.6 4,566.88 4,688.54 121.66 2.66%

increase

1-1
120,000

100,000

=0 80,000

Eo--I

- 60,000 =

=

=

= 40,000 -<

20,000

0

NOx Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

2005 2010

I~NOxl

2020

S02 Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

400,000 ,-------------------------,

350,000 +---

300,000 +---

=250,000 +--- I

-; 200,000 +---

== 150,000 +---

100,000 +---

50,000 +---

O+---

2005

1-2

2010

I~S021

2020
Direct PM2•5 Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

6,000

5,000

Q=4,000

I

- 3,000 =

=

=

=2,000 -<

1,000

0

2005 2010

ImDirect PM2.51

2020

400,000

Trends- All Anthropogenic Sources

Southwestern Indiana Area

350,000

300,000

250,000

-; 200,000 ::l

I:

I:

< 150,000

100,000

50,000

o

2005 2010

S02 • NOx 0 Direct PM2.51

1-3

2020
This page left intentionally blank.

1-4