Author: Abt Associates Inc.

Date Created: 11/30/2009

Date Modified: 4/1/2011

Purpose:

Calculates the economic impact (income, jobs, earnings) of 316(b) regulatory options on a total economy basis, accounting for activity

effect of compliance outlays and loss in ouput from increased electricity rates

File Contents:

Worksheet Contents

Impact Analysis Summary Inputs Impact analysis information -- electricity rate impact and loss in manufacturer's net income -- that is assumed not to vary year-to-year over

relevant analysis periods.

Tables 3, 4, 5, 8, 11 Summary results tables for reporting in the EA chapter

Tables 9, 10 Summary results tables for reporting in the EA chapter

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es Analysis of electricity rate effects in electricity customer business sectors, based on sector-level demand and supply elasticities

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-n Es Analysis of electricity rate effects in electricity customer business sectors, based on sector-level demand elasticities only

Elasticity Vls by Sector Complilation of demand and supply elasticity values for impact analyses

Demand Elasticity Values Estimated demand elasticity in electricity customer business sectors

Supply Elasticity Values Estimated supply elasticity in electricity customer business sectors

Electricity Intensity by Sector Electricity consumption in relation to value added, for use in allocating total electricity rate impact across business sectors

RIMS 2006 Multx Total matrix of RIMS multipliers, extracted for use in this analysis

RIMS Mult Matrix Specific RIMS multipliers assigned to sectors for this analysis

2007 GDP by Sector GDP/value added by sector. Used in assessing change in output from increased electricity costs

GDP Deflator GDP deflator series, used for adjusting certain dollar values to a common dollar year

RIMS to NAICS3 Map Mapping of RIMS multiplier sectors to 3-digit NAICS sectors for use in impact analysis

SEDS Elec. Consumption, 2006 Gross sector electricity consumption from DOE State Energy Data System. Used in calculating electricity consumption intensity for

commercial and transportation sectors

NAICS_Commercial GDP by commercial sectors. Used in calculating electricity intensity for commercial sectors

NAICS_Industrial GDP by aggregate industrial sectors. Used in calculating aggregate electricity intensity for industrial sectors

Econ Census Data Value of shipments data, by sector, for use in impact analysis

EC Elec. Consumption, 2002 Electricity consumption data from Economic Census, for use in calculating electricity intensity values for certain aggregate sectors

BEA_GDP_US_2002_$2000 Sector level GDP/value added data, by sector, for use in calculating electricity intensity values

Variables Certain constants, used in various calculations

Input Files:

External data used in calculations/analysis:

Option 1 Cost Values Year-by-year compilation of compliance costs and electricity rate impacts in affected sectors and calculation of year-by-year impact of these

effects on income and employment using RIMS multipliers, for regulatory option 1

Option 2 Cost Values Year-by-year compilation of compliance costs and electricity rate impacts in affected sectors and calculation of year-by-year impact of these

effects on income and employment using RIMS multipliers, for regulatory option 2

Option 3 Cost Values Year-by-year compilation of compliance costs and electricity rate impacts in affected sectors and calculation of year-by-year impact of these

effects on income and employment using RIMS multipliers, for regulatory option 3

File_Info 1 of 60
Cost Inputs to the Economy-Wide Output and Employment Impact Analysis

millions of 2009 dollars

Cost Element Option 1 Option 2 Option 3 Notes

Analysis of Effects Due to Compliance Cost Outlays

Analysis of Effects Due to Increased Electricity Rates

Electricity Rate Effect Period 2013-2056 2013-2056 2018-2056 Period over which electricity rate impacts are analyzed

First Year of Impact Effects 2013 2013 2013 Inputs for rate impact analysis

Last Year of Impact Effects 2056 2056 2056 Inputs for rate impact analysis

Residential $178.6 $2,170.8 $2,235.1

Commercial $188.9 $2,297.0 $2,365.0

Industrial $128.6 $1,563.6 $1,609.9

Transportation $1.0 $12.0 $12.4

Business Elec Rate Impact, no ES - output -$599.7 -$7,290.6 -$5,424.8

Business Elec Rate Impact, no ES - jobs -3,982.6 -48,418.6 -49,851.8

Business Elec Rate Impact, w ES - output -$433.4 -$5,268.9 -$1,930.6

Business Elec Rate Impact, w ES - jobs -2,843.8 -34,573.9 -35,597.3

Manufacturers annualized compliance cost, after-tax $41.9 $110.2 $149.9 Yearly loss in net income, assuming no cost pass-through, in

manufacturers sectors from compliance outlays.

Annualized Rate Effect by Rule Option and customer sector,

from Electric Generators impact analysis

Summary annual results from electricity rate impact analysis

that are carried forward to analysis of total multiplier effects

on a year-by-year basis, including the effect of compliance

outlays

Impact Analysis Summary Inputs 2 of 60
Table 3: Average Annual Initial Compliance Costs ($millions, $2009)

Annual Direct Effect Value

Direct Effect

Applicable

Time Period Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

Generators

Technology installation 2012 – 2017 $308.2 $774.2 $783.2

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $8,443.1 $8,649.0

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $2,775.5 $2,775.5

Initial permitting costs 2012 – 2017 $3.3 $1.5 $1.1

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $1.9 $2.4

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $0.2 $0.2

Cost of downtime 2012 – 2017 $24.0 $43.6 $45.5

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $1,063.3 $1,192.7

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $358.6 $377.7

Manufacturers

Technology installation 2012 – 2017 $54.4 $29.8 $2.7

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $25.3 $48.8

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $240.8 $457.0

Initial permitting costs 2012 – 2017 $3.4 $3.0 $0.6

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $0.1 $0.7

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $0.3 $2.7

Cost of downtime 2012 – 2017 $3.4 $3.3 $0.2

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $0.1 $3.9

Source: U.S. EPA Analysis, 2010

Table 4: Average Annual Recurring Compliance Costs ($millions, $2009)

Annual Direct Effect Value Annual Direct Effect Value Annual Direct Effect Value

Direct Effect

Applicable

Time Period Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

Generators

O&M 2013 – 2017 $68.8 $4.0 $1.9

2018 – 2022 $115.0 $248.1 $250.1

2023 – 2027 $115.0 $490.0 $495.8

2028 – 2056 $107.1 $506.5 $511.9

Permit Renewal 2013 – 2017 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0

2018 – 2022 $1.8 $0.6 $0.3

2023 – 2027 $1.8 $1.6 $1.6

2028 – 2056 $1.5 $1.5 $1.5

Monitoring 2013 – 2017 $18.2 $5.2 $2.7

2018 – 2022 $30.4 $20.3 $18.6

2023 – 2027 $30.4 $29.5 $29.5

2028 – 2056 $28.3 $28.3 $28.3

Energy Penalty 2013 – 2017 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $1,165.0 $1,246.8

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $2,607.4 $2,743.7

2028 – 2056 $0.0 $2,840.7 $2,967.7

Manufacturers

O&M 2013 – 2017 $13.2 $6.9 $0.7

2018 – 2022 $22.1 $11.6 $1.2

2023 – 2027 $22.1 $20.5 $16.4

2028 – 2056 $20.5 $24.7 $24.7

Permit Renewal 2013 – 2017 $0.4 $0.3 $0.1

2018 – 2022 $1.8 $1.6 $0.3

2023 – 2027 $1.8 $1.7 $0.6

2028 – 2056 $1.5 $1.5 $1.5

Monitoring 2013 – 2017 $16.7 $14.7 $2.2

2018 – 2022 $27.9 $24.6 $3.6

2023 – 2027 $27.9 $25.9 $9.3

2028 – 2056 $26.0 $24.9 $12.1

Energy Penalty 2013 – 2017 $4.1 $3.9 $0.2

2018 – 2022 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0

2023 – 2027 $0.0 $0.1 $3.9

2028 – 2056 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0

Source: U.S. EPA Analysis, 2010

Tables 3, 4, 5, 8, 11 3 of 60
Table 5: Average Annual Electricity Rate Recovery for Generators ($millions, $2009)

Applicable

Time Period

Annual Direct

Effect Value

Applicable

Time Period

Annual Direct

Effect Value

Applicable

Time Period

Annual Direct

Effect Value

Residential Customers 2013 – 2056 $179 2013 – 2056 $2,171 2018 – 2056 $2,235

Non-Residential Customers

Commercial 2013 – 2056 $189 2013 – 2056 $2,297 2018 – 2056 $2,365

Industrial 2013 – 2056 $129 2013 – 2056 $1,564 2018 – 2056 $1,610

Transportation 2013 – 2056 $42 2013 – 2056 $110 2018 – 2056 $150

Source: U.S. EPA Analysis, 2010

Table 8: Manufacturer’s Average Annual Compliance Cost ($millions, $2009)

Applicable

Time Period

Annual Direct

Effect Value

Applicable

Time Period

Annual Direct

Effect Value

Applicable

Time Period

Annual Direct

Effect Value

Total annualized, after-tax cost 2013 – 2056 $42 2013 – 2056 $110 2018 – 2056 $150

Source: U.S. EPA Analysis, 2010

Table 11: Total Present Value and Annualized Values of Output and Employment Effects

Present Value

Annualized

Value Present Value

Annualized

Value Present Value

Annualized

Value

Total Output Effect ($millions, $2009)

without accounting for elasticity of supply response in industrial sectors affected by electricity price increase

7 percent discount rate ($1,900) ($140) $12,339 $907 $39,466 $2,901

3 percent discount rate ($6,354) ($259) $821 $33 $51,017 $2,081

with accounting for elasticity of supply response in industrial sectors affected by electricity price increase

7 percent discount rate $207 $15 $37,955 $2,790 $83,742 $6,155

3 percent discount rate ($2,438) ($99) $48,427 $1,975 $133,300 $5,437

Total Employment Effect (full-time-equivalent jobs)

without accounting for elasticity of supply response in industrial sectors affected by electricity price increase

7 percent discount rate -25,361 -1,864 -42,037 -3,090 -43,169 -3,173

3 percent discount rate -69,464 -2,833 -336,916 -13,741 -343,494 -14,009

with accounting for elasticity of supply response in industrial sectors affected by electricity price increase

7 percent discount rate -10,931 -803 133,389 9,804 137,449 10,102

3 percent discount rate -42,648 -1,739 -10,903 -445 -7,830 -319

Source: U.S. EPA Analysis, 2010

Direct Effect

Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

Direct Effect

Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

Direct Effect

Option 1 Option 2 Option 3

Tables 3, 4, 5, 8, 11 4 of 60
Output Effect, Reported as Average Annual Values by Effect Category for Indicated Time Periods

(millions, $2009) x x x x x

x x x x x Total Output Effect

x Compliance Outlay Effects Household Demand with x Demand with

Year Interval

Initial/

One-Time Recurring

Sector

Effects

Elasticity

only

Supply

Elasticity x

Elasticity

only

Supply

Elasticity

Option 1: IM Everywhere

2012 - 2017 $1,253 $245 -$426 -$500 -$361 x $572 $711

2018 - 2022 $0 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 x -$633 -$467

2023 - 2027 $0 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 x -$633 -$467

2028 - 2031 $0 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 xx -$633 -$467

2032 - 2036 $815 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 x $181 $348

2037 - 2041 $373 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 x -$261 -$95

2042 - 2046 $55 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 x -$579 -$413

2047 - 2051 $3 $478 -$512 -$600 -$433 x -$630 -$464

2052 - 2056 $0 $282 -$512 -$600 -$433 x -$829 -$663

2012 - 2056 $305 $425 -$500 -$586 -$424 x -$356 -$194

Option 2: Cooling Towers for Facilities with DIF > 125 MGD, Else IM

2012 - 2017 $2,719 $81 -$4,279 -$6,075 -$4,391 x -$7,554 -$5,869

2018 - 2022 $29,742 $3,287 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x $20,605 $22,626

2023 - 2027 $10,550 $7,070 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x $5,195 $7,216

2028 - 2031 $0 $8,194 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 xx -$4,230 -$2,209

2032 - 2036 $96 $8,194 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x -$4,134 -$2,112

2037 - 2041 $58 $8,194 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x -$4,173 -$2,151

2042 - 2046 $40 $8,194 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x -$4,190 -$2,169

2047 - 2051 $9 $8,194 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x -$4,222 -$2,200

2052 - 2056 $0 $4,912 -$5,134 -$7,291 -$5,269 x -$7,513 -$5,491

2012 - 2056 $4,862 $6,078 -$5,020 -$7,129 -$5,152 x -$1,209 $768

Option 3: Cooling Towers Everywhere

2012 - 2017 $2,647 $16 -$4,403 -$4,521 -$1,609 x -$6,261 -$3,349

2018 - 2022 $30,773 $3,371 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x $23,436 $26,931

2023 - 2027 $11,310 $7,331 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x $7,932 $11,426

2028 - 2031 $0 $8,468 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 xx -$2,240 $1,254

2032 - 2036 $24 $8,468 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x -$2,216 $1,278

2037 - 2041 $23 $8,468 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x -$2,217 $1,277

2042 - 2046 $41 $8,468 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x -$2,199 $1,295

2047 - 2051 $10 $8,468 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x -$2,230 $1,264

2052 - 2056 $0 $5,076 -$5,283 -$5,425 -$1,931 x -$5,632 -$2,137

2012 - 2056 $5,040 $6,272 -$5,166 -$5,304 -$1,888 x $841 $4,258

Employment Effect, Reported as Average Annual Values by Effect Category for Indicated Time Periods

(full-time-equivalent jobs) x x x x x

x x x x x Total Output Effect

x Compliance Outlay Effects Household Demand with x Demand with

Year Interval

Initial/

One-Time Recurring

Sector

Effects

Elasticity

only

Supply

Elasticity x

Elasticity

only

Supply

Elasticity

Option 1: IM Everywhere

2012 - 2017 9,421 1,029 -3,229 -3,319 -2,370 x 3,902 4,851

2018 - 2022 0 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x -5,873 -4,734

2023 - 2027 0 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x -5,873 -4,734

2028 - 2031 0 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 xx -5,873 -4,734

2032 - 2036 6,313 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x 440 1,579

2037 - 2041 2,887 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x -2,986 -1,847

2042 - 2046 423 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x -5,450 -4,311

2047 - 2051 24 1,985 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x -5,849 -4,710

2052 - 2056 0 1,170 -3,875 -3,983 -2,844 x -6,688 -5,550

2012 - 2056 2,328 1,767 -3,789 -3,894 -2,781 x -3,588 -2,475

Option 2: Cooling Towers for Facilities with DIF > 125 MGD, Else IM

2012 - 2017 20,625 385 -32,411 -40,349 -28,812 x -51,751 -40,214

2018 - 2022 221,193 12,672 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x 146,553 160,397

2023 - 2027 78,619 27,143 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x 18,449 32,294

2028 - 2031 0 31,456 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 xx -55,856 -42,012

2032 - 2036 748 31,456 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x -55,109 -41,264

2037 - 2041 449 31,456 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x -55,408 -41,563

2042 - 2046 312 31,456 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x -55,544 -41,700

2047 - 2051 69 31,456 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x -55,788 -41,943

2052 - 2056 2 18,852 -38,894 -48,419 -34,574 x -68,459 -54,614

2012 - 2056 36,238 23,346 -38,029 -47,343 -33,806 x -25,788 -12,251

Electricity Price Effects

in Dependent Product

Electricity Price Effects

in Dependent Product

Tables 9, 10 5 of 60
Option 3: Cooling Towers Everywhere

2012 - 2017 20,096 66 -33,353 -41,543 -29,664 x -54,734 -42,855

2018 - 2022 228,047 12,879 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x 151,051 165,306

2023 - 2027 84,294 28,081 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x 22,499 36,754

2028 - 2031 0 32,454 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 xx -57,421 -43,167

2032 - 2036 187 32,454 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x -57,235 -42,980

2037 - 2041 179 32,454 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x -57,242 -42,987

2042 - 2046 318 32,454 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x -57,103 -42,848

2047 - 2051 79 32,454 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x -57,343 -43,088

2052 - 2056 2 19,451 -40,023 -49,852 -35,597 x -70,422 -56,168

2012 - 2056 37,469 24,030 -39,134 -48,744 -34,806 x -26,379 -12,441

Tables 9, 10 6 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Supply and Demand Elasticity

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors

RIMS # RIMS Sector

Estimated Electricity

Consumption Intensity

(kWh/$mm, $2009)

2007 ValueAdded, National

($mm, $2009)

Estimated Electricity

Consumption (mm

kWh)

Rate Effect

Allocation

Factors

3 Industrial Oil and gas extraction 498,865 170,214 84,914 7.7%

4 Industrial Mining, except oil and gas 498,865 46,817 23,355 2.1%

5 Industrial Support activities for mining 498,865 67,176 33,512 3.0%

7 Industrial Construction 101,298 631,249 63,944 5.8%

8 Industrial Wood product manufacturing 561,952 32,451 18,236 1.7%

9 Industrial Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing 732,935 56,221 41,207 3.7%

10 Industrial Primary metal manufacturing 2,644,450 64,489 170,538 15.5%

11 Industrial Fabricated metal product manufacturing 365,051 145,101 52,969 4.8%

12 Industrial Machinery manufacturing 213,070 129,908 27,680 2.5%

13 Industrial Computer and electronic product manufacturing 166,909 151,198 25,236 2.3%

14 Industrial Electrical equipment and appliance manufacturing 227,764 60,355 13,747 1.2%

15 Industrial Motor vehicle, body, trailer, and parts manufacturing 319,250 101,798 32,499 2.9%

16 Industrial Other transportation equipment manufacturing 319,250 99,317 31,707 2.9%

17 Industrial Furniture and related product manufacturing 194,575 36,585 7,119 0.6%

18 Industrial Miscellaneous manufacturing 146,917 75,444 11,084 1.0%

19 Industrial Food, beverage, and tobacco product manufacturing 394,244 180,549 71,180 6.5%

20 Industrial Textile and textile product mills 1,140,472 20,463 23,337 2.1%

21 Industrial Apparel, leather, and allied product manufacturing 156,887 16,639 2,610 0.2%

22 Industrial Paper manufacturing 1,038,235 52,397 54,401 4.9%

23 Industrial Printing and related support activities 271,903 49,504 13,460 1.2%

24 Industrial Petroleum and coal products manufacturing 925,026 72,757 67,302 6.1%

25 Industrial Chemical manufacturing 724,670 257,543 186,634 16.9%

26 Industrial Plastics and rubber products manufacturing 681,336 68,416 46,614 4.2%

27 Commercial Wholesale trade 122,563 832,261 102,005 9.3%

28 Commercial Retail trade 122,563 922,381 113,050 10.3%

29 Transportation Air transportation 17,972 57,048 1,025 13.6%

30 Transportation Rail transportation 17,972 41,856 752 9.9%

31 Transportation Water transportation 17,972 11,058 199 2.6%

32 Transportation Truck transportation 17,972 131,872 2,370 31.3%

33 Transportation Transit and ground passenger transportation 17,972 19,946 358 4.7%

34 Transportation Pipeline transportation 17,972 12,402 223 2.9%

35 Transportation Other transportation and support activities 17,972 104,898 1,885 24.9%

36 Transportation Warehousing and storage 17,972 41,649 749 9.9%

37 Commercial Publishing including software 122,563 143,447 17,581 1.6%

38 Commercial Motion picture and sound recording industries 122,563 44,853 5,497 0.5%

39 Commercial Broadcasting and telecommunications 122,563 353,863 43,371 3.9%

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 7 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Supply and Demand Elasticity

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors

RIMS #

3

4

5

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

Industrial Commercial Transportation =Ed*Rate_Effect/(1-Ed/Es)

Option 1 ($mm, $2009)

Price

Elasticity,

Demand

Price

Elasticity,

Supply

Baseline

value of

shipments

$mm, $2009

Output

Multiplier

Earnings

Multiplier

Employment

Multiplier Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

-0.50 2.15 238,828 2.3938 0.6109 10.4152 $9.90 -$4.02 -$9.61 -$2.45

-0.50 2.15 83,837 2.4986 0.6588 12.8966 $2.72 -$1.10 -$2.76 -$0.73

-0.50 2.15 58,886 2.58 0.6103 12.7149 $3.91 -$1.59 -$4.09 -$0.97

-0.45 2.15 725,212 3.2336 1.0036 25.0564 $7.45 -$2.77 -$8.97 -$2.78

-0.78 2.15 105,290 3.2404 0.8273 23.0824 $2.13 -$1.22 -$3.94 -$1.01

-0.50 2.15 132,187 2.9695 0.7656 17.1388 $4.80 -$1.95 -$5.79 -$1.49

-1.00 1.44 268,561 2.6691 0.5847 12.4519 $19.88 -$11.73 -$31.31 -$6.86

-1.52 2.15 355,713 2.969 0.769 17.6386 $6.17 -$5.50 -$16.33 -$4.23

-1.08 2.15 358,864 2.9793 0.7707 16.5915 $3.23 -$2.32 -$6.91 -$1.79

-1.43 2.15 426,815 3.1256 0.906 17.8745 $2.94 -$2.53 -$7.90 -$2.29

-0.64 2.15 133,611 2.9564 0.7482 16.2123 $1.60 -$0.79 -$2.34 -$0.59

-1.17 2.15 751,465 3.301 0.7614 16.4103 $3.79 -$2.87 -$9.48 -$2.19

-1.17 2.15 9,963 2.8854 0.823 16.1784 $3.70 -$2.80 -$8.08 -$2.31

-1.26 6.77 87,816 3.1713 0.8371 21.6889 $0.83 -$0.88 -$2.80 -$0.74

-0.85 2.15 152,689 3.0937 0.9009 18.8377 $1.29 -$0.79 -$2.44 -$0.71

-0.30 2.15 609,319 3.4481 0.7671 19.9725 $8.30 -$2.18 -$7.53 -$1.68

-0.40 2.15 37,222 3.343 0.8107 20.1015 $2.72 -$0.92 -$3.07 -$0.74

-0.70 2.15 25,327 3.1 0.9217 25.11 $0.30 -$0.16 -$0.50 -$0.15

-0.63 0.80 181,692 3.0814 0.7211 16.4012 $6.34 -$2.23 -$6.88 -$1.61

-0.76 2.15 106,824 3.1434 0.9034 21.2284 $1.57 -$0.88 -$2.77 -$0.80

-0.60 1.30 626,558 2.286 0.4541 7.9432 $7.85 -$3.22 -$7.37 -$1.46

-0.89 4.01 763,021 2.9782 0.6642 13.2655 $21.76 -$15.85 -$47.20 -$10.53

-1.05 2.15 218,114 3.0766 0.7114 16.2544 $5.43 -$3.83 -$11.80 -$2.73

-0.50 2.15 2,800,194 2.6574 0.8007 17.6403 $17.48 -$7.09 -$18.85 -$5.68

-0.50 2.15 922,588 2.756 0.8222 26.528 $19.37 -$7.86 -$21.66 -$6.46

-1.03 2.15 151,474 2.8732 0.7431 16.7626 $0.13 -$0.09 -$0.27 -$0.07

-1.03 2.15 #N/A 2.5722 0.662 13.8662 $0.10 -$0.10 -$0.26 -$0.07

-1.03 2.15 37,264 3.0436 0.7356 16.6074 $0.03 -$0.02 -$0.06 -$0.01

-1.03 2.15 229,161 3.1126 0.9011 22.6462 $0.31 -$0.22 -$0.67 -$0.19

-1.03 2.15 27,870 3.1739 0.9888 36.7137 $0.05 -$0.03 -$0.10 -$0.03

-1.03 2.15 25,491 2.7536 0.5933 11.9286 $0.03 -$0.02 -$0.06 -$0.01

-1.03 2.15 2,750 2.7563 0.9986 23.201 $0.25 -$0.17 -$0.47 -$0.17

-1.03 2.15 25,485 2.7267 0.9646 26.442 $0.10 -$0.07 -$0.19 -$0.07

-0.18 2.15 282,570 2.8614 0.7811 17.225 $3.01 -$0.50 -$1.43 -$0.39

-0.18 2.15 98,350 3.0828 0.8091 19.6059 $0.94 -$0.16 -$0.48 -$0.13

-0.18 2.15 101,966 2.8208 0.627 13.6246 $7.43 -$1.23 -$3.48 -$0.77

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 8 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Supply and Demand Elasticity

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors

RIMS #

3

4

5

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

Option 2 ($mm, $2009) Option 3 ($mm, $2009)

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

-41.83 $120.34 -$48.83 -$116.89 -$29.83 -508.56 $123.90 -$50.27 -$120.35 -$30.71

-14.25 $33.10 -$13.43 -$33.56 -$8.85 -173.20 $34.08 -$13.83 -$34.55 -$9.11

-20.15 $47.49 -$19.27 -$49.72 -$11.76 -245.02 $48.90 -$19.84 -$51.19 -$12.11

-69.52 $90.62 -$33.73 -$109.07 -$33.85 -845.13 $93.30 -$34.73 -$112.29 -$34.85

-28.09 $25.84 -$14.80 -$47.95 -$12.24 -341.55 $26.61 -$15.23 -$49.37 -$12.60

-33.40 $58.40 -$23.70 -$70.36 -$18.14 -406.11 $60.13 -$24.40 -$72.45 -$18.68

-146.05 $241.69 -$142.60 -$380.60 -$83.38 -1,775.59 $248.84 -$146.82 -$391.87 -$85.84

-97.03 $75.07 -$66.88 -$198.56 -$51.43 -1,179.66 $77.29 -$68.86 -$204.44 -$52.95

-38.50 $39.23 -$28.21 -$84.05 -$21.74 -468.08 $40.39 -$29.05 -$86.54 -$22.39

-45.18 $35.77 -$30.73 -$96.05 -$27.84 -549.28 $36.82 -$31.64 -$98.89 -$28.67

-12.82 $19.48 -$9.61 -$28.41 -$7.19 -155.82 $20.06 -$9.90 -$29.26 -$7.40

-47.12 $46.06 -$34.91 -$115.24 -$26.58 -572.92 $47.42 -$35.95 -$118.66 -$27.37

-45.33 $44.94 -$34.06 -$98.28 -$28.03 -551.06 $46.27 -$35.07 -$101.19 -$28.86

-19.12 $10.09 -$10.72 -$33.99 -$8.97 -232.43 $10.39 -$11.03 -$34.99 -$9.24

-14.83 $15.71 -$9.57 -$29.61 -$8.62 -180.32 $16.17 -$9.86 -$30.49 -$8.88

-43.64 $100.88 -$26.56 -$91.59 -$20.38 -530.50 $103.86 -$27.35 -$94.30 -$20.98

-18.45 $33.07 -$11.16 -$37.30 -$9.04 -224.26 $34.05 -$11.49 -$38.40 -$9.31

-4.04 $3.70 -$1.95 -$6.06 -$1.80 -49.07 $3.81 -$2.01 -$6.24 -$1.85

-36.61 $77.10 -$27.14 -$83.62 -$19.57 -445.10 $79.38 -$27.94 -$86.10 -$20.15

-18.71 $19.08 -$10.71 -$33.68 -$9.68 -227.46 $19.64 -$11.03 -$34.68 -$9.97

-25.60 $95.38 -$39.19 -$89.58 -$17.80 -311.28 $98.20 -$40.35 -$92.24 -$18.32

-210.23 $264.50 -$192.67 -$573.81 -$127.97 -2,555.86 $272.33 -$198.37 -$590.79 -$131.76

-62.34 $66.06 -$46.62 -$143.44 -$33.17 -757.84 $68.02 -$48.00 -$147.69 -$34.15

-125.10 $212.48 -$86.22 -$229.11 -$69.03 -1,520.88 $218.77 -$88.77 -$235.89 -$71.08

-208.50 $235.49 -$95.55 -$263.34 -$78.56 -2,534.80 $242.46 -$98.38 -$271.14 -$80.89

-1.57 $1.63 -$1.14 -$3.27 -$0.84 -19.05 $1.68 -$1.17 -$3.36 -$0.87

-1.41 $1.20 -$1.23 -$3.17 -$0.82 -17.09 $1.23 -$1.27 -$3.27 -$0.84

-0.30 $0.32 -$0.22 -$0.67 -$0.16 -3.66 $0.33 -$0.23 -$0.69 -$0.17

-4.89 $3.77 -$2.63 -$8.18 -$2.37 -59.50 $3.88 -$2.70 -$8.42 -$2.44

-1.20 $0.57 -$0.40 -$1.26 -$0.39 -14.59 $0.59 -$0.41 -$1.30 -$0.40

-0.24 $0.35 -$0.25 -$0.68 -$0.15 -2.95 $0.37 -$0.25 -$0.70 -$0.15

-3.99 $3.00 -$2.09 -$5.76 -$2.09 -48.49 $3.09 -$2.15 -$5.93 -$2.15

-1.80 $1.19 -$0.83 -$2.26 -$0.80 -21.94 $1.23 -$0.85 -$2.33 -$0.82

-8.62 $36.62 -$6.08 -$17.41 -$4.75 -104.79 $37.71 -$6.26 -$17.92 -$4.89

-3.07 $11.45 -$1.90 -$5.86 -$1.54 -37.29 $11.79 -$1.96 -$6.04 -$1.58

-16.82 $90.35 -$15.01 -$42.33 -$9.41 -204.47 $93.02 -$15.45 -$43.59 -$9.69

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 9 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Supply and Demand Elasticity

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors

RIMS #

3

4

5

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

Total Employment

Effect

-523.61

-178.33

-252.28

-870.14

-351.66

-418.13

-1,828.14

-1,214.57

-481.93

-565.54

-160.43

-589.88

-567.37

-239.31

-185.66

-546.20

-230.90

-50.52

-458.27

-234.19

-320.49

-2,631.51

-780.27

-1,565.90

-2,609.83

-19.61

-17.60

-3.77

-61.26

-15.02

-3.03

-49.92

-22.59

-107.89

-38.40

-210.52

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 10 of 60
RIMS # RIMS Sector

Estimated Electricity

Consumption Intensity

(kWh/$mm, $2009)

2007 ValueAdded, National

($mm, $2009)

Estimated Electricity

Consumption (mm

kWh)

Rate Effect

Allocation

Factors

40 Commercial Information and data processing services 122,563 63,766 7,815 0.7%

41 Commercial Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation and related services 122,563 521,287 63,891 5.8%

42 Commercial Securities, commodity contracts, investments 122,563 245,451 30,083 2.7%

43 Commercial Insurance carriers and related activities 122,563 343,632 42,117 3.8%

44 Commercial Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles 122,563 17,569 2,153 0.2%

45 Commercial Real estate 122,563 1,639,615 200,956 18.2%

46 Commercial Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets 122,563 137,763 16,885 1.5%

47 Commercial Professional, scientific, and technical services 122,563 1,041,541 127,655 11.6%

48 Commercial Management of companies and enterprises 122,563 280,383 34,365 3.1%

49 Commercial Administrative and support services 122,563 393,962 48,285 4.4%

50 Commercial Waste management and remediation services 122,563 35,035 4,294 0.4%

51 Commercial Educational services 122,563 133,836 16,403 1.5%

52 Commercial Ambulatory health care services 122,563 514,776 63,093 5.7%

53 Commercial Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities 122,563 386,211 47,335 4.3%

54 Commercial Social assistance 122,563 88,569 10,855 1.0%

55 Commercial Performing arts, museums, and related activities 122,563 63,869 7,828 0.7%

56 Commercial Amusements, gambling, and recreation 122,563 74,411 9,120 0.8%

57 Commercial Accommodation 122,563 124,948 15,314 1.4%

58 Commercial Food services and drinking places 122,563 267,258 32,756 3.0%

59 Commercial Other services 122,563 326,166 39,976 3.6%

Total

Total Electricity Consumption

Commercial 1,102,683

Industrial 1,103,286

Transportation 7,562

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 11 of 60
RIMS #

403

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

59

Price

Elasticity,

Demand

Price

Elasticity,

Supply

Baseline

value of

shipments

$mm, $2009

Output

Multiplier

Earnings

Multiplier

Employment

Multiplier Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

-0.18 2.15 73,696 2.9251 0.7605 17.5864 $1.34 -$0.22 -$0.65 -$0.17

-0.56 2.15 46,472 2.2379 0.618 13.2187 $10.95 -$4.86 -$10.89 -$3.01

-0.56 2.15 653,177 3.3335 1.1312 21.8999 $5.15 -$2.29 -$7.64 -$2.59

-0.56 2.15 1,692,222 3.1602 0.88 18.8003 $7.22 -$3.21 -$10.13 -$2.82

-0.56 2.15 #N/A 3.9023 1.1441 22.047 $0.37 -$0.21 -$0.81 -$0.24

-0.55 2.15 356,083 1.9456 0.3263 9.7465 $34.43 -$15.08 -$29.35 -$4.92

-0.55 2.15 130,810 2.946 0.7159 17.9841 $2.89 -$1.27 -$3.73 -$0.91

-0.37 2.15 1,389,783 3.044 1.027 22.5074 $21.87 -$6.91 -$21.02 -$7.09

-0.50 2.15 #N/A 3.0088 0.9572 18.5948 $5.89 -$2.94 -$8.86 -$2.82

-1.00 2.15 582,116 2.9508 0.9508 30.7248 $8.27 -$5.65 -$16.67 -$5.37

-1.00 2.15 75,856 2.9095 0.7806 18.367 $0.74 -$0.50 -$1.46 -$0.39

-1.10 2.15 48,823 3.1209 1.0328 32.7968 $2.81 -$2.05 -$6.39 -$2.11

-0.36 2.15 715,309 2.9776 1.0231 23.7098 $10.81 -$3.33 -$9.93 -$3.41

-0.36 2.15 737,156 3.2177 1.0531 27.2508 $8.11 -$2.50 -$8.05 -$2.63

-0.36 2.15 127,992 3.0776 1.0114 41.7311 $1.86 -$0.57 -$1.77 -$0.58

-0.69 2.15 78,979 2.9641 1.0295 35.6989 $1.34 -$0.70 -$2.08 -$0.72

-0.69 2.15 102,639 2.7181 0.7919 29.2845 $1.56 -$0.82 -$2.22 -$0.65

-2.27 2.15 186,072 2.7267 0.7758 23.3633 $2.62 -$2.90 -$7.91 -$2.25

-2.27 2.15 447,399 3.0521 0.8195 33.8903 $5.61 -$6.20 -$18.93 -$5.08

-0.40 2.15 147,967 3.0651 0.8881 27.0131 $6.85 -$2.31 -$7.08 -$2.05

$318.54 -$154.23 -$433.39 -$114.70

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 12 of 60
RIMS #

403

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

59

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

-3.91 $16.28 -$2.70 -$7.91 -$2.06 -47.56 $16.76 -$2.78 -$8.14 -$2.12

-64.31 $133.09 -$59.14 -$132.36 -$36.55 -781.81 $137.03 -$60.89 -$136.28 -$37.63

-50.16 $62.67 -$27.85 -$92.83 -$31.50 -609.88 $64.52 -$28.67 -$95.58 -$32.43

-60.29 $87.73 -$38.99 -$123.21 -$34.31 -732.98 $90.33 -$40.14 -$126.86 -$35.32

-4.56 $4.49 -$2.51 -$9.80 -$2.87 -55.38 $4.62 -$2.59 -$10.09 -$2.96

-147.02 $418.61 -$183.38 -$356.79 -$59.84 -1,787.32 $431.00 -$188.81 -$367.35 -$61.61

-22.79 $35.17 -$15.41 -$45.39 -$11.03 -277.10 $36.21 -$15.86 -$46.74 -$11.36

-155.43 $265.92 -$83.96 -$255.57 -$86.22 -1,889.67 $273.79 -$86.44 -$263.13 -$88.78

-54.74 $71.58 -$35.79 -$107.69 -$34.26 -665.55 $73.70 -$36.85 -$110.88 -$35.27

-173.57 $100.58 -$68.68 -$202.65 -$65.30 -2,110.12 $103.56 -$70.71 -$208.65 -$67.23

-9.23 $8.94 -$6.11 -$17.77 -$4.77 -112.18 $9.21 -$6.29 -$18.30 -$4.91

-67.11 $34.17 -$24.88 -$77.63 -$25.69 -815.82 $35.18 -$25.61 -$79.93 -$26.45

-79.05 $131.43 -$40.53 -$120.70 -$41.47 -961.07 $135.32 -$41.73 -$124.27 -$42.70

-68.17 $98.60 -$30.41 -$97.85 -$32.03 -828.73 $101.52 -$31.31 -$100.75 -$32.97

-23.94 $22.61 -$6.97 -$21.46 -$7.05 -291.04 $23.28 -$7.18 -$22.10 -$7.26

-25.02 $16.31 -$8.52 -$25.26 -$8.77 -304.17 $16.79 -$8.77 -$26.00 -$9.03

-23.91 $19.00 -$9.93 -$26.98 -$7.86 -290.69 $19.56 -$10.22 -$27.78 -$8.09

-67.73 $31.90 -$35.25 -$96.10 -$27.34 -823.46 $32.84 -$36.29 -$98.95 -$28.15

-210.16 $68.23 -$75.39 -$230.10 -$61.78 -2,554.97 $70.25 -$77.62 -$236.91 -$63.61

-62.41 $83.27 -$28.09 -$86.10 -$24.95 -758.79 $85.74 -$28.92 -$88.65 -$25.68

-2,843.85 $3,872.61 -$1,875.08 -$5,268.89 -$1,394.44 -34,573.88 $3,987.24 -$1,930.58 -$5,424.85 -$1,435.71

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 13 of 60
RIMS #

403

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

59

Total Employment

Effect

-48.97

-804.95

-627.93

-754.68

-57.02

-1,840.23

-285.30

-1,945.61

-685.25

-2,172.58

-115.50

-839.97

-989.52

-853.26

-299.66

-313.17

-299.30

-847.83

-2,630.59

-781.25

-35,597.25

Rate Impact on Bsns Sctrs-w Es 14 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Demand Elasticity only

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors Industrial Commercial

RIMS # RIMS Sector

Estimated Electricity

Consumption Intensity

(kWh/$mm, $2009)

2007 ValueAdded, National

($mm, $2009)

Estimated Electricity

Consumption (mm

kWh)

Rate Effect

Allocation

Factors

Price

Elasticity,

Demand

3 Industrial Oil and gas extraction 498,865 170,214 84,914 7.7% -0.50

4 Industrial Mining, except oil and gas 498,865 46,817 23,355 2.1% -0.50

5 Industrial Support activities for mining 498,865 67,176 33,512 3.0% -0.50

7 Industrial Construction 101,298 631,249 63,944 5.8% -0.45

8 Industrial Wood product manufacturing 561,952 32,451 18,236 1.7% -0.78

9 Industrial Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing 732,935 56,221 41,207 3.7% -0.50

10 Industrial Primary metal manufacturing 2,644,450 64,489 170,538 15.5% -1.00

11 Industrial Fabricated metal product manufacturing 365,051 145,101 52,969 4.8% -1.52

12 Industrial Machinery manufacturing 213,070 129,908 27,680 2.5% -1.08

13 Industrial Computer and electronic product manufacturing 166,909 151,198 25,236 2.3% -1.43

14 Industrial Electrical equipment and appliance manufacturing 227,764 60,355 13,747 1.2% -0.64

15 Industrial Motor vehicle, body, trailer, and parts manufacturing 319,250 101,798 32,499 2.9% -1.17

16 Industrial Other transportation equipment manufacturing 319,250 99,317 31,707 2.9% -1.17

17 Industrial Furniture and related product manufacturing 194,575 36,585 7,119 0.6% -1.26

18 Industrial Miscellaneous manufacturing 146,917 75,444 11,084 1.0% -0.85

19 Industrial Food, beverage, and tobacco product manufacturing 394,244 180,549 71,180 6.5% -0.30

20 Industrial Textile and textile product mills 1,140,472 20,463 23,337 2.1% -0.40

21 Industrial Apparel, leather, and allied product manufacturing 156,887 16,639 2,610 0.2% -0.70

22 Industrial Paper manufacturing 1,038,235 52,397 54,401 4.9% -0.63

23 Industrial Printing and related support activities 271,903 49,504 13,460 1.2% -0.76

24 Industrial Petroleum and coal products manufacturing 925,026 72,757 67,302 6.1% -0.60

25 Industrial Chemical manufacturing 724,670 257,543 186,634 16.9% -0.89

26 Industrial Plastics and rubber products manufacturing 681,336 68,416 46,614 4.2% -1.05

27 Commercial Wholesale trade 122,563 832,261 102,005 9.3% -0.50

28 Commercial Retail trade 122,563 922,381 113,050 10.3% -0.50

29 Transportation Air transportation 17,972 57,048 1,025 13.6% -1.03

30 Transportation Rail transportation 17,972 41,856 752 9.9% -1.03

31 Transportation Water transportation 17,972 11,058 199 2.6% -1.03

32 Transportation Truck transportation 17,972 131,872 2,370 31.3% -1.03

33 Transportation Transit and ground passenger transportation 17,972 19,946 358 4.7% -1.03

34 Transportation Pipeline transportation 17,972 12,402 223 2.9% -1.03

35 Transportation Other transportation and support activities 17,972 104,898 1,885 24.9% -1.03

36 Transportation Warehousing and storage 17,972 41,649 749 9.9% -1.03

37 Commercial Publishing including software 122,563 143,447 17,581 1.6% -0.18

38 Commercial Motion picture and sound recording industries 122,563 44,853 5,497 0.5% -0.18

39 Commercial Broadcasting and telecommunications 122,563 353,863 43,371 3.9% -0.18

Rate Impact, Bsns Sctrs-No Es 15 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Demand Elasticity only

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors

RIMS #

3

4

5

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

Transportation

Option 1 ($mm, $2009) Option 2 ($mm, $2009)

Output

Multiplier

Earnings

Multiplier

Employment

Multiplier Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

2.3938 0.6109 10.4152 $9.90 -$4.95 -$11.85 -$3.02 -51.55 $120.34 -$60.17 -$144.04

2.4986 0.6588 12.8966 $2.72 -$1.36 -$3.40 -$0.90 -17.56 $33.10 -$16.55 -$41.35

2.58 0.6103 12.7149 $3.91 -$1.95 -$5.04 -$1.19 -24.84 $47.49 -$23.75 -$61.27

3.2336 1.0036 25.0564 $7.45 -$3.35 -$10.85 -$3.37 -84.05 $90.62 -$40.78 -$131.87

3.2404 0.8273 23.0824 $2.13 -$1.66 -$5.37 -$1.37 -38.27 $25.84 -$20.16 -$65.32

2.9695 0.7656 17.1388 $4.80 -$2.40 -$7.13 -$1.84 -41.16 $58.40 -$29.20 -$86.71

2.6691 0.5847 12.4519 $19.88 -$19.88 -$53.06 -$11.62 -247.54 $241.69 -$241.69 -$645.09

2.969 0.769 17.6386 $6.17 -$9.39 -$27.87 -$7.22 -165.55 $75.07 -$114.10 -$338.78

2.9793 0.7707 16.5915 $3.23 -$3.48 -$10.38 -$2.69 -57.82 $39.23 -$42.37 -$126.22

3.1256 0.906 17.8745 $2.94 -$4.21 -$13.15 -$3.81 -75.20 $35.77 -$51.14 -$159.86

2.9564 0.7482 16.2123 $1.60 -$1.03 -$3.03 -$0.77 -16.63 $19.48 -$12.47 -$36.86

3.301 0.7614 16.4103 $3.79 -$4.43 -$14.63 -$3.37 -72.74 $46.06 -$53.89 -$177.88

2.8854 0.823 16.1784 $3.70 -$4.32 -$12.48 -$3.56 -69.96 $44.94 -$52.57 -$151.70

3.1713 0.8371 21.6889 $0.83 -$1.05 -$3.32 -$0.88 -22.68 $10.09 -$12.71 -$40.31

3.0937 0.9009 18.8377 $1.29 -$1.10 -$3.40 -$0.99 -20.69 $15.71 -$13.35 -$41.31

3.4481 0.7671 19.9725 $8.30 -$2.49 -$8.58 -$1.91 -49.72 $100.88 -$30.26 -$104.35

3.343 0.8107 20.1015 $2.72 -$1.09 -$3.64 -$0.88 -21.87 $33.07 -$13.23 -$44.23

3.1 0.9217 25.11 $0.30 -$0.21 -$0.66 -$0.20 -5.35 $3.70 -$2.59 -$8.03

3.0814 0.7211 16.4012 $6.34 -$4.00 -$12.31 -$2.88 -65.53 $77.10 -$48.57 -$149.67

3.1434 0.9034 21.2284 $1.57 -$1.19 -$3.75 -$1.08 -25.31 $19.08 -$14.50 -$45.57

2.286 0.4541 7.9432 $7.85 -$4.71 -$10.76 -$2.14 -37.39 $95.38 -$57.23 -$130.83

2.9782 0.6642 13.2655 $21.76 -$19.36 -$57.67 -$12.86 -256.86 $264.50 -$235.41 -$701.08

3.0766 0.7114 16.2544 $5.43 -$5.71 -$17.55 -$4.06 -92.74 $66.06 -$69.37 -$213.41

2.6574 0.8007 17.6403 $17.48 -$8.74 -$23.22 -$7.00 -154.16 $212.48 -$106.24 -$282.33

2.756 0.8222 26.528 $19.37 -$9.69 -$26.69 -$7.96 -256.93 $235.49 -$117.75 -$324.51

2.8732 0.7431 16.7626 $0.13 -$0.14 -$0.40 -$0.10 -2.32 $1.63 -$1.68 -$4.83

2.5722 0.662 13.8662 $0.10 -$0.10 -$0.26 -$0.07 -1.41 $1.20 -$1.23 -$3.17

3.0436 0.7356 16.6074 $0.03 -$0.03 -$0.08 -$0.02 -0.44 $0.32 -$0.33 -$0.99

3.1126 0.9011 22.6462 $0.31 -$0.32 -$0.99 -$0.29 -7.24 $3.77 -$3.88 -$12.09

3.1739 0.9888 36.7137 $0.05 -$0.05 -$0.15 -$0.05 -1.77 $0.57 -$0.59 -$1.86

2.7536 0.5933 11.9286 $0.03 -$0.03 -$0.08 -$0.02 -0.36 $0.35 -$0.37 -$1.01

2.7563 0.9986 23.201 $0.25 -$0.25 -$0.70 -$0.25 -5.90 $3.00 -$3.09 -$8.52

2.7267 0.9646 26.442 $0.10 -$0.10 -$0.28 -$0.10 -2.67 $1.19 -$1.23 -$3.35

2.8614 0.7811 17.225 $3.01 -$0.54 -$1.55 -$0.42 -9.34 $36.62 -$6.59 -$18.86

3.0828 0.8091 19.6059 $0.94 -$0.17 -$0.52 -$0.14 -3.32 $11.45 -$2.06 -$6.35

2.8208 0.627 13.6246 $7.43 -$1.34 -$3.77 -$0.84 -18.22 $90.35 -$16.26 -$45.87

Rate Impact, Bsns Sctrs-No Es 16 of 60
Electricity Consumption and Multiplier Analysis, by Business Sector, using Demand Elasticity only

used to develop allocation factors for distributing business sector rate effect across economic sectors

RIMS #

3

4

5

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

Option 2 ($mm, $2009) Option 3 ($mm, $2009)

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect

-$36.76 -626.69 $123.90 -$61.95 -$148.30 -$37.85 -645.24

-$10.90 -213.43 $34.08 -$17.04 -$42.57 -$11.23 -219.75

-$14.49 -301.94 $48.90 -$24.45 -$63.08 -$14.92 -310.87

-$40.93 -1,021.80 $93.30 -$41.99 -$135.77 -$42.14 -1,052.05

-$16.68 -465.31 $26.61 -$20.76 -$67.26 -$17.17 -479.08

-$22.35 -500.44 $60.13 -$30.06 -$89.27 -$23.02 -515.25

-$141.32 -3,009.49 $248.84 -$248.84 -$664.19 -$145.50 -3,098.57

-$87.75 -2,012.64 $77.29 -$117.48 -$348.80 -$90.34 -2,072.21

-$32.65 -702.92 $40.39 -$43.62 -$129.96 -$33.62 -723.72

-$46.34 -914.18 $36.82 -$52.66 -$164.59 -$47.71 -941.24

-$9.33 -202.14 $20.06 -$12.84 -$37.95 -$9.61 -208.13

-$41.03 -884.31 $47.42 -$55.48 -$183.15 -$42.24 -910.49

-$43.27 -850.58 $46.27 -$54.13 -$156.19 -$44.55 -875.75

-$10.64 -275.70 $10.39 -$13.09 -$41.51 -$10.96 -283.86

-$12.03 -251.52 $16.17 -$13.75 -$42.53 -$12.39 -258.97

-$23.21 -604.43 $103.86 -$31.16 -$107.44 -$23.90 -622.32

-$10.73 -265.94 $34.05 -$13.62 -$45.54 -$11.04 -273.81

-$2.39 -65.03 $3.81 -$2.67 -$8.27 -$2.46 -66.95

-$35.02 -796.63 $79.38 -$50.01 -$154.10 -$36.06 -820.21

-$13.10 -307.76 $19.64 -$14.93 -$46.92 -$13.48 -316.87

-$25.99 -454.58 $98.20 -$58.92 -$134.70 -$26.76 -468.04

-$156.36 -3,122.77 $272.33 -$242.37 -$721.84 -$160.98 -3,215.20

-$49.35 -1,127.50 $68.02 -$71.42 -$219.73 -$50.81 -1,160.87

-$85.07 -1,874.15 $218.77 -$109.39 -$290.69 -$87.59 -1,929.62

-$96.81 -3,123.58 $242.46 -$121.23 -$334.12 -$99.68 -3,216.04

-$1.25 -28.17 $1.68 -$1.73 -$4.97 -$1.29 -29.00

-$0.82 -17.09 $1.23 -$1.27 -$3.27 -$0.84 -17.60

-$0.24 -5.41 $0.33 -$0.34 -$1.02 -$0.25 -5.57

-$3.50 -87.96 $3.88 -$4.00 -$12.45 -$3.60 -90.57

-$0.58 -21.57 $0.59 -$0.60 -$1.92 -$0.60 -22.21

-$0.22 -4.36 $0.37 -$0.38 -$1.04 -$0.22 -4.49

-$3.09 -71.68 $3.09 -$3.18 -$8.77 -$3.18 -73.81

-$1.18 -32.44 $1.23 -$1.26 -$3.44 -$1.22 -33.40

-$5.15 -113.55 $37.71 -$6.79 -$19.42 -$5.30 -116.91

-$1.67 -40.41 $11.79 -$2.12 -$6.54 -$1.72 -41.61

-$10.20 -221.56 $93.02 -$16.74 -$47.23 -$10.50 -228.12

Rate Impact, Bsns Sctrs-No Es 17 of 60
RIMS # RIMS Sector

Estimated Electricity

Consumption Intensity

(kWh/$mm, $2009)

2007 ValueAdded, National

($mm, $2009)

Estimated Electricity

Consumption (mm

kWh)

Rate Effect

Allocation

Factors

Price

Elasticity,

Demand

40 Commercial Information and data processing services 122,563 63,766 7,815 0.7% -0.18

41 Commercial Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation and related services 122,563 521,287 63,891 5.8% -0.56

42 Commercial Securities, commodity contracts, investments 122,563 245,451 30,083 2.7% -0.56

43 Commercial Insurance carriers and related activities 122,563 343,632 42,117 3.8% -0.56

44 Commercial Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles 122,563 17,569 2,153 0.2% -0.56

45 Commercial Real estate 122,563 1,639,615 200,956 18.2% -0.55

46 Commercial Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets 122,563 137,763 16,885 1.5% -0.55

47 Commercial Professional, scientific, and technical services 122,563 1,041,541 127,655 11.6% -0.37

48 Commercial Management of companies and enterprises 122,563 280,383 34,365 3.1% -0.50

49 Commercial Administrative and support services 122,563 393,962 48,285 4.4% -1.00

50 Commercial Waste management and remediation services 122,563 35,035 4,294 0.4% -1.00

51 Commercial Educational services 122,563 133,836 16,403 1.5% -1.10

52 Commercial Ambulatory health care services 122,563 514,776 63,093 5.7% -0.36

53 Commercial Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities 122,563 386,211 47,335 4.3% -0.36

54 Commercial Social assistance 122,563 88,569 10,855 1.0% -0.36

55 Commercial Performing arts, museums, and related activities 122,563 63,869 7,828 0.7% -0.69

56 Commercial Amusements, gambling, and recreation 122,563 74,411 9,120 0.8% -0.69

57 Commercial Accommodation 122,563 124,948 15,314 1.4% -2.27

58 Commercial Food services and drinking places 122,563 267,258 32,756 3.0% -2.27

59 Commercial Other services 122,563 326,166 39,976 3.6% -0.40

Total

Total Electricity Consumption

Commercial 1,102,683

Industrial 1,103,286

Transportation 7,562

Rate Impact, Bsns Sctrs-No Es 18 of 60
RIMS #

403

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

59

Output

Multiplier

Earnings

Multiplier

Employment

Multiplier Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

2.9251 0.7605 17.5864 $1.34 -$0.24 -$0.71 -$0.18 -4.24 $16.28 -$2.93 -$8.57

2.2379 0.618 13.2187 $10.95 -$6.13 -$13.72 -$3.79 -81.04 $133.09 -$74.53 -$166.79

3.3335 1.1312 21.8999 $5.15 -$2.89 -$9.62 -$3.27 -63.22 $62.67 -$35.09 -$116.98

3.1602 0.88 18.8003 $7.22 -$4.04 -$12.77 -$3.56 -75.98 $87.73 -$49.13 -$155.26

3.9023 1.1441 22.047 $0.37 -$0.21 -$0.81 -$0.24 -4.56 $4.49 -$2.51 -$9.80

1.9456 0.3263 9.7465 $34.43 -$18.94 -$36.85 -$6.18 -184.58 $418.61 -$230.24 -$447.95

2.946 0.7159 17.9841 $2.89 -$1.59 -$4.69 -$1.14 -28.62 $35.17 -$19.34 -$56.99

3.044 1.027 22.5074 $21.87 -$8.09 -$24.63 -$8.31 -182.15 $265.92 -$98.39 -$299.50

3.0088 0.9572 18.5948 $5.89 -$2.94 -$8.86 -$2.82 -54.74 $71.58 -$35.79 -$107.69

2.9508 0.9508 30.7248 $8.27 -$8.27 -$24.41 -$7.87 -254.20 $100.58 -$100.58 -$296.80

2.9095 0.7806 18.367 $0.74 -$0.74 -$2.14 -$0.57 -13.51 $8.94 -$8.94 -$26.02

3.1209 1.0328 32.7968 $2.81 -$3.09 -$9.65 -$3.19 -101.40 $34.17 -$37.59 -$117.30

2.9776 1.0231 23.7098 $10.81 -$3.89 -$11.59 -$3.98 -92.27 $131.43 -$47.31 -$140.88

3.2177 1.0531 27.2508 $8.11 -$2.92 -$9.40 -$3.07 -79.57 $98.60 -$35.50 -$114.22

3.0776 1.0114 41.7311 $1.86 -$0.67 -$2.06 -$0.68 -27.94 $22.61 -$8.14 -$25.05

2.9641 1.0295 35.6989 $1.34 -$0.93 -$2.74 -$0.95 -33.04 $16.31 -$11.25 -$33.35

2.7181 0.7919 29.2845 $1.56 -$1.08 -$2.93 -$0.85 -31.58 $19.00 -$13.11 -$35.63

2.7267 0.7758 23.3633 $2.62 -$5.96 -$16.24 -$4.62 -139.16 $31.90 -$72.41 -$197.45

3.0521 0.8195 33.8903 $5.61 -$12.74 -$38.88 -$10.44 -431.78 $68.23 -$154.89 -$472.74

3.0651 0.8881 27.0131 $6.85 -$2.74 -$8.40 -$2.43 -74.01 $83.27 -$33.31 -$102.10

$318.54 -$212.90 -$599.68 -$158.00 -3,982.64 $3,872.61 -$2,588.35 -$7,290.55

Rate Impact, Bsns Sctrs-No Es 19 of 60
RIMS #

403

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

59

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect Rate Increase

Decrease in

Demand

Total Output

Effect

Total Earnings

Effect

Total Employment

Effect

-$2.23 -51.54 $16.76 -$3.02 -$8.83 -$2.29 -53.06

-$46.06 -985.20 $137.03 -$76.74 -$171.73 -$47.42 -1,014.36

-$39.70 -768.54 $64.52 -$36.13 -$120.45 -$40.87 -791.28

-$43.23 -923.67 $90.33 -$50.58 -$159.86 -$44.51 -951.01

-$2.87 -55.38 $4.62 -$2.59 -$10.09 -$2.96 -57.02

-$75.13 -2,243.99 $431.00 -$237.05 -$461.21 -$77.35 -2,310.42

-$13.85 -347.90 $36.21 -$19.92 -$58.68 -$14.26 -358.20

-$101.05 -2,214.48 $273.79 -$101.30 -$308.36 -$104.04 -2,280.03

-$34.26 -665.55 $73.70 -$36.85 -$110.88 -$35.27 -685.25

-$95.63 -3,090.38 $103.56 -$103.56 -$305.58 -$98.46 -3,181.86

-$6.98 -164.29 $9.21 -$9.21 -$26.80 -$7.19 -169.15

-$38.82 -1,232.72 $35.18 -$38.70 -$120.78 -$39.97 -1,269.21

-$48.41 -1,121.80 $135.32 -$48.71 -$145.05 -$49.84 -1,155.01

-$37.38 -967.33 $101.52 -$36.55 -$117.60 -$38.49 -995.96

-$8.23 -339.71 $23.28 -$8.38 -$25.79 -$8.48 -349.77

-$11.58 -401.66 $16.79 -$11.58 -$34.34 -$11.93 -413.55

-$10.38 -383.87 $19.56 -$13.50 -$36.68 -$10.69 -395.24

-$56.18 -1,691.83 $32.84 -$74.56 -$203.30 -$57.84 -1,741.91

-$126.93 -5,249.29 $70.25 -$159.48 -$486.73 -$130.69 -5,404.66

-$29.58 -899.79 $85.74 -$34.30 -$105.12 -$30.46 -926.42

-$1,920.86 -48,418.60 $3,987.24 -$2,664.96 -$7,506.35 -$1,977.71 -49,851.77

Rate Impact, Bsns Sctrs-No Es 20 of 60
Price Elasticity of Demand, By Rate Impact Sector

Demand

Elasticity

Supply

Elasticity

RIMS

Sector RIMS Sector

Elasticity of

Demand

Elasticity of

Supply

Commercial Sectors 3 Oil and gas extraction -0.50 2.15

Wholesale trade -0.50 2.15 4 Mining, except oil and gas -0.50 2.15

Retail trade -0.50 2.15 5 Support activities for mining -0.50 2.15

Information -0.18 2.15 7 Construction -0.45 2.15

Finance and insurance -0.56 2.15 8 Wood product manufacturing -0.78 2.15

Real estate and rental and leasing -0.55 2.15 9 Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing -0.50 2.15

Professional and technical services -0.37 2.15 10 Primary metal manufacturing -1.00 1.44

Management of companies and enterprises -0.50 2.15 11 Fabricated metal product manufacturing -1.52 2.15

Administrative and waste services -1.00 2.15 12 Machinery manufacturing -1.08 2.15

Educational services -1.10 2.15 13 Computer and electronic product manufacturing -1.43 2.15

Health care and social assistance -0.36 2.15 14 Electrical equipment and appliance manufacturing -0.64 2.15

Arts, entertainment, and recreation -0.69 2.15 15 Motor vehicle, body, trailer, and parts manufacturing -1.17 2.15

Accommodation and food services -2.27 2.15 16 Other transportation equipment manufacturing -1.17 2.15

Other services, except government -0.40 2.15 17 Furniture and related product manufacturing -1.26 6.77

Government -0.10 2.15 18 Miscellaneous manufacturing -0.85 2.15

Total Commercial 19 Food, beverage, and tobacco product manufacturing -0.30 2.15

20 Textile and textile product mills -0.40 2.15

Manufacturing Sectors 21 Apparel, leather, and allied product manufacturing -0.70 2.15

Food & Beverage and Tobacco Products -0.30 2.15 22 Paper manufacturing -0.63 0.80

Textile Mills & Textile Product Mills -0.40 2.15 23 Printing and related support activities -0.76 2.15

Apparel & Leather and Allied Products -0.70 2.15 24 Petroleum and coal products manufacturing -0.60 1.30

Wood Products -0.78 6.77 25 Chemical manufacturing -0.89 4.01

Paper -0.63 0.80 26 Plastics and rubber products manufacturing -1.05 2.15

Printing and Related Support -0.76 2.15 27 Wholesale trade -0.50 2.15

Petroleum and Coal Products -0.60 1.30 28 Retail trade -0.50 2.15

Chemicals -0.89 4.01 29 Air transportation -1.03 2.15

Plastics and Rubber Products -1.05 4.01 30 Rail transportation -1.03 2.15

Nonmetallic Mineral Products -0.50 2.15 31 Water transportation -1.03 2.15

Primary Metals -1.00 1.44 32 Truck transportation -1.03 2.15

Fabricated Metal Products -1.52 2.15 33 Transit and ground passenger transportation -1.03 2.15

Machinery -1.08 2.15 34 Pipeline transportation -1.03 2.15

Computer and Electronic Products -1.43 2.15 35 Other transportation and support activities -1.03 2.15

Electrical Equip., Appliances, and Components -0.64 2.15 36 Warehousing and storage -1.03 2.15

Transportation Equipment -1.17 2.15 37 Publishing including software -0.18 2.15

Furniture and Related Products -1.26 2.15 38 Motion picture and sound recording industries -0.18 2.15

Miscellaneous -0.85 2.15 39 Broadcasting and telecommunications -0.18 2.15

Total Manufacturing 40 Information and data processing services -0.18 2.15

41 Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation and related services -0.56 2.15

Construction -0.45 2.15 42 Securities, commodity contracts, investments -0.56 2.15

43 Insurance carriers and related activities -0.56 2.15

Elasticity Vls by Sector 21 of 60
Demand

Elasticity

Supply

Elasticity

RIMS

Sector RIMS Sector

Elasticity of

Demand

Elasticity of

Supply

Mining -0.50 2.15 44 Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles -0.56 2.15

45 Real estate -0.55 2.15

Transportation -1.03 2.15 46 Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets -0.55 2.15

47 Professional, scientific, and technical services -0.37 2.15

48 Management of companies and enterprises -0.50 2.15

49 Administrative and support services -1.00 2.15

50 Waste management and remediation services -1.00 2.15

51 Educational services -1.10 2.15

52 Ambulatory health care services -0.36 2.15

53 Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities -0.36 2.15

54 Social assistance -0.36 2.15

55 Performing arts, museums, and related activities -0.69 2.15

56 Amusements, gambling, and recreation -0.69 2.15

57 Accommodation -2.27 2.15

58 Food services and drinking places -2.27 2.15

59 Other services -0.40 2.15

Elasticity Vls by Sector 22 of 60
Business Sector

Demand

Elasticity

Notes

Sources

Commercial

Wholesale trade -0.50 Professional Judgment

Retail trade -0.50 Professional Judgment

Information -0.18

Simple average of reported values for

telephone services and newspapers

Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Finance and insurance -0.56 Parker's Economics

Real estate and rental and leasing -0.55 Parker's Economics

Professional and technical services -0.37 Reported value for legal services Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Management of companies and enterprises -0.50 Professional Judgment

Administrative and waste services -1.00

Simple average of two reported values in

range

Economic Analysis of Effluent Limitation Guidelines and Standards for the

Centralized Waste Treatment Industry

Educational services -1.10 Mackinac Center for Public Policy (ref to other sources)

Health care and social assistance -0.36

Simple average of three reported values RAND Health; National Defense Research Institute. The Elasticity of Demand for

Health Care: A review of Literature and Its Application to the Military Health

System (ref to other studies); Mackinac Center for Public Policy (ref to other

sources); Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Arts, entertainment, and recreation -0.69

Simple average of two reported values The Economics of Art and Culture. James Heilbrun, Charles M. Gray. 2001. (p.99)

Accommodation and food services -2.27 Value reported for restaurant meals Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Other services, except government -0.40 Value reported for automobile repair Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Government -0.10 Professional Judgment

Manufacturing Sectors

Food & Beverage and Tobacco Products -0.30

Simple average of selected values Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004; The University of Georgia,

The Georgia Agricultral Experiment Stations; Consumer Demand for Fresh Fruits

and Vegetables in the United States; The World Bank; Welfare Costs of U.S.

Quotas on Textiles, Steel, and Autos (ref to other studies)

Textile Mills & Textile Product Mills -0.40

The World Bank; Welfare Costs of U.S. Quotas on Textiles, Steel, and Autos (ref to

other studies)

Apparel & Leather and Allied Products -0.70

Simple average of values for clothing and

shoes

Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Wood Products -0.78

Simple average of paper, furniture, and

construction.

Professional judgment

Paper -0.63

Simple average of three reported values Economic Analysis for the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air

Pollutants for Source Category: Pulp and Paper Production; Effluent Limitations

Guidelines, Pretreatment Standards, and New Source Performance Standards: Pulp,

Paper, and Paperboard Category - Phase 1; Federation of American Scientists,

Wood Use: U.S. Competitiveness and Technology - Vol II November 1984 (a

footnote on p 71 refering to claculations performed by the Kidder, Peaboody

Economics Group)

Printing and Related Support -0.76

Simple average of paper and chemicals Professional judgment

Petroleum and Coal Products -0.60 Value reported for gasoline Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004

Chemicals -0.89

Same value reported by both sources -

one for chemicals and one for

pharmaceutical products

Parker's Economics; AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies, A costBenefit Analysis of Drug Price Controls in the U.S.

Plastics and Rubber Products -1.05

Simple average of short-run and long-run

demand elasticity for tires

Mackinac Center for Public Policy (ref to other sources)

Nonmetallic Mineral Products -0.50 Professional judgment

Primary Metals -1.00

The World Bank; Welfare Costs of U.S. Quotas on Textiles, Steel, and Autos (ref to

other studies)

Fabricated Metal Products -1.52

Value for metals reported in Parker's

economics

Parker's Economics

Machinery -1.08

Simple average of fabricated metal

products and electrical equipment,

appliances category

Professional judgment

Computer and Electronic Products -1.43

Simple average of two sources Mackinac Center for Public Policy (ref to other sources); Criterion Economics,

L.L.C.; The $500 Billion Opportunity: The Potential Economic Benefit of

Widespread Diffusion of Broadband Internet Access (the estimate is from another

study)

Electrical Equip., Appliances, and Components -0.64 Simple average of all five sources

Transportation Equipment -1.17

Simple average of two sources Principles of Economics, McConnell-Brue, 16e, 2004; The World Bank; Welfare

Costs of U.S. Quotas on Textiles, Steel, and Autos (ref to other studies)

Furniture and Related Products -1.26 Parker's Economics

Miscellaneous -0.85 Simple average of all manufacturing Professional judgment

Construction -0.45

Simple average of residential demand

elasticity (0.7) and non-res demand

elasiticity (0.2)

Non-Residential Construction: A Simultaneous Model and Empirical Test of the

Demand and Supply of Retail Space (Benjamin, Jud, and Winkler), Journal of Real

Estate Research, 1998, vol. 16(1); Residential Construction: HUD, 2006

Mining -0.50

The World Bank; Welfare Costs of U.S. Quotas on Textiles, Steel, and Autos (ref to

other studies)

Transportation -1.03 Parker's Economics

Demand Elasticity Values 23 of 60
ElasticityID ProductName NAICSCode 3d NAICS code SICCode ElasticityEstimateElasticityType ElasticityCategory

150 Polymers / Resins 325 325 325 282 4.77 Own-Price Supply

164 Secondary Aluminum 331314 331 331 3341 2.33 Own-Price Supply

165 Secondary Lead Smelters 331492 331 331 3341 0.548 Own-Price Supply

175 Petroleum 324110 324 324 2911 0.58 Own-Price Supply

201 Petroleum refining 324110 324 324 2911 1.24 Own-Price Supply

561 Furnace Coke 324199 324 324 0.77 Own-Price Supply

562 Foundry Coke 324199 324 324 2.03 Own-Price Supply

563 Furnace Coke 324199 324 324 2.1 Own-Price Supply

564 Foundry Coke 324199 324 324 1.1 Own-Price Supply

565 Wood furniture -- Household 337 337 337 251 8.825 Own-Price Supply

566 Wood furniture -- Commercial 337 337 337 25 5.878 Own-Price Supply

567 Wood furniture -- Wood Cabinets 337110 337 337 243 5.604 Own-Price Supply

574

Market Pulp -- Special Alpha and dissolving

woodpulp 322110 322 322 261 0.2009 Own-Price Supply

575 Market Pulp -- Sulfate-bleached 322110 322 322 261 0.1856 Own-Price Supply

576 Market Pulp -- Sulfate-unbleached 322110 322 322 261 0.2674 Own-Price Supply

577 Market Pulp -- Sulfite-bleached 322110 322 322 261 0.232 Own-Price Supply

578 Market Pulp -- Secondary-bleached 322110 322 322 261 0.7641 Own-Price Supply

579 Market Pulp -- Secondary-unbleached 322110 322 322 261 0.8211 Own-Price Supply

580 Paper -- Newsprint 322122 322 322 2621 0.2939 Own-Price Supply

581 Paper -- Uncoated groundwood paper 322122 322 322 2621 0.3304 Own-Price Supply

588 Paper -- Tissue 322121 322 322 2621 0.8156 Own-Price Supply

589 Paper -- Wrapping 322 322 322 2621 1.6309 Own-Price Supply

590 Paper -- Shipping sack 322 322 322 2621 1.2618 Own-Price Supply

591 Paper -- Other bag and sack 322 322 322 2621 1.6309 Own-Price Supply

592

Paper -- Other bag and sack paper for

conversion 322 322 322 2621 2.2533 Own-Price Supply

593 Paper -- Waxing stock 322 322 322 2621 1.6309 Own-Price Supply

594 Paper -- Other 322 322 322 2621 1.2049 Own-Price Supply

595 Paper -- Specialty packaging 322 322 322 2621 1.6586 Own-Price Supply

596

Paper -- Glassine, greaseproof, and vegetable

parchment 322 322 322 2621 1.6309 Own-Price Supply

597 Paperboard -- Unbleached kraft 322130 322 322 2631 0.3158 Own-Price Supply

598 Paperboard -- Semichemical paperboard 322130 322 322 2631 0.2757 Own-Price Supply

599 Paperboard -- Recycled paperboard 322130 322 322 2631 0.4928 Own-Price Supply

600 Paperboard -- Wet Machine Board 322130 322 322 2631 0.3545 Own-Price Supply

601 Paperboard -- Construction paper 322130 322 322 2631 0.882 Own-Price Supply

602 Paperboard -- Insulating Board 322130 322 322 2631 0.7406 Own-Price Supply

603 Paperboard -- Linerboard 322130 322 322 2631 1.0139 Own-Price Supply

604 Paperboard -- Folding carton type board 322130 322 322 2631 0.7481 Own-Price Supply

605 Paperboard -- Milk carton board 322130 322 322 2631 0.443 Own-Price Supply

606 Paperboard -- Plate,dish, and tray stock 322130 322 322 2631 0.6807 Own-Price Supply

607

Paperboard -- Bleached paperboard for

miscellaneous packaging 322130 322 322 2631 0.6807 Own-Price Supply

608 Paperboard -- Other solid bleached board 322130 322 322 2631 0.6807 Own-Price Supply

Supply Elasticity Values 24 of 60
ElasticityID

150

164

165

175

201

561

562

563

564

565

566

567

574

575

576

577

578

579

580

581

588

589

590

591

592

593

594

595

596

597

598

599

600

601

602

603

604

605

606

607

608

ElasticityCountry CommodityMarket ForeignCountry TradeOrigin TradeDestination InputSub1 InputSub2 IncomeType IncomeSpecify

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

Supply Elasticity Values 25 of 60
ElasticityID

150

164

165

175

201

561

562

563

564

565

566

567

574

575

576

577

578

579

580

581

588

589

590

591

592

593

594

595

596

597

598

599

600

601

602

603

604

605

606

607

608

OtherSpecify FunctionalForm LagStructure QuantityMeasure FrequencyofObs DataYear Geography

Log-linear millions of kilograms Yearly 1970-1991 United States

Log-linear millions of dollars Yearly 1958-1994 National

Log-log tons Yearly 1970-1991 National

Log-linear short tons Annual 1993 United States

Log-linear short tons Annual 1993 United States

2000 United States

2000 United States

Value of Shipments (million$)Annual 1958-1989 United States

Value of Shipments (million$)Annual 1958-1989 United States

Value of Shipments (million$)Annual 1958-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

Supply Elasticity Values 26 of 60
ElasticityID

150

164

165

175

201

561

562

563

564

565

566

567

574

575

576

577

578

579

580

581

588

589

590

591

592

593

594

595

596

597

598

599

600

601

602

603

604

605

606

607

608

TimeSeries CrossSection PanelData MethodDescription ConstantorPointPointMedian PointMean PointXthPercentile

TRUE FALSE FALSE OLS (Restricted coefficients of inputs for the production function sum to one.

TRUE FALSE FALSE Used a production function approach; Assumed constant returns to scale; Adjusted for first-order serial correlation using Yule-Walker procedure. Constant

TRUE FALSE FALSE OLS Constant

FALSE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE meta analysis

FALSE TRUE FALSE Constant

FALSE TRUE FALSE Constant

FALSE TRUE FALSE

FALSE TRUE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

Supply Elasticity Values 27 of 60
ElasticityID

150

164

165

175

201

561

562

563

564

565

566

567

574

575

576

577

578

579

580

581

588

589

590

591

592

593

594

595

596

597

598

599

600

601

602

603

604

605

606

607

608

PointEquation TypeofTest TestStatValue TestStatp_value ConfidenceLevel UpperBound LowerBound

t-test 2.941

6-34 and 6-35

6-34 and 6-35

c-4 to c-8

c-4 to c-8

c-4 to c-8

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.236 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.663 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.303

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.865 0.9

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.029 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.029 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -2.292 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.214

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -4.461 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 0.28

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 2.475 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.428

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.87 0.9

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 0.516

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -2.363 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.135 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 0.541

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -7.535 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -4.19 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -7.471 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 1.097

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.66 0.9

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -0.436

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -0.853

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.407 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -2.527 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -0.008

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 2.302 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 0.67

Supply Elasticity Values 28 of 60
ElasticityID

150

164

165

175

201

561

562

563

564

565

566

567

574

575

576

577

578

579

580

581

588

589

590

591

592

593

594

595

596

597

598

599

600

601

602

603

604

605

606

607

608

Title DocumentType AuthorEditor

Economic Impact Analysis for the Polymers and Resins IV NESHAP - DRAFT EPA Document U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Economic Impact Analysis for the Final Secondary Aluminum Production National Emission Standard for Hazardous Air Pollutants EPA Document

Economic Impact Analysis of the Secondary Lead Smelters NESHAP -- Final EPA Document

World Oil Price Projections: A Sensativity Analysis Report William Hogman

Regulatory Impact Analysis for the Petroleum Refineries NESHAP EPA Document

Regulatory Impact Analysis of National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants for By Product Coke Oven Charging, Door Leaks, and Topside Leaks EPA Document

Regulatory Impact Analysis of National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants for By Product Coke Oven Charging, Door Leaks, and Topside Leaks EPA Document

Economic Impact Analysis of Final Integrated Iron and Steel NESHAP EPA Document

Economic Impact Analysis of Final Integrated Iron and Steel NESHAP EPA Document

Economic Impacts of the NESHAP for the Wood Furniture Industry EPA Document MathTech and E.H. Pechan

Economic Impacts of the NESHAP for the Wood Furniture Industry EPA Document MathTech and E.H. Pechan

Economic Impacts of the NESHAP for the Wood Furniture Industry EPA Document MathTech and E.H. Pechan

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Supply Elasticity Values 29 of 60
ElasticityID

150

164

165

175

201

561

562

563

564

565

566

567

574

575

576

577

578

579

580

581

588

589

590

591

592

593

594

595

596

597

598

599

600

601

602

603

604

605

606

607

608

DocYear DocURL

1995

1999

1994

1989

1995

1992

1992

2002

2002

1994

1994

1994

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

Supply Elasticity Values 30 of 60
ElasticityID ProductName NAICSCode 3d NAICS code SICCode ElasticityEstimateElasticityType ElasticityCategory

609 Paperboard -- Molded pulp products 322130 322 322 2631 0.2382 Own-Price Supply

610

Paper -- Clay coated printing and converted

paper 322 322 322 2621 1.653 Own-Price Supply

611 Paper -- Uncoated free sheet 322 322 322 2621 0.3087 Own-Price Supply

612 Paper -- Bleached Bristols 322 322 322 2621 1.2102 Own-Price Supply

613 Paper -- Cotton fiber writing paper 322 322 322 2621 0.1192 Own-Price Supply

615

Paper -- Unbleached kraft packaging and

industrial converting 322 322 322 2621 0.1858 Own-Price Supply

616

Paper -- Special industrial paper, except

specialty packaging 322 322 322 2621 0.9965 Own-Price Supply

617

Paperboard -- Heavyweight cup and round

nested food container 322130 322 322 2631 0.6807 Own-Price Supply

654 DGEBPA (in sealants and adhesives) 325211 325 325 2821 3.76 Own-Price Supply

655 DGEBPA (in coatings and paints) 325211 325 325 2821 3.76 Own-Price Supply

656 Wet strength resin 325211 325 325 2821 3.76 Own-Price Supply

657 Crops 111 111 111 1 0.305 Own-Price Supply

658 Meat Animals 112 112 112 2 0.187 Own-Price Supply

659 Milk-Poultry 112 112 112 2 0.172 Own-Price Supply

660 Other Livestock 112 112 112 2 0.966 Own-Price Supply

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

3d NAICS code RIMS Code El Value

325 25 4.01

331 10 1.44

324 24 1.30

337 17 6.77

322 22 0.80

111 1 0.31

112 1 0.44

2.15

Default Value 2.15

0.79

Supply Elasticity Values 31 of 60
ElasticityID

609

610

611

612

613

615

616

617

654

655

656

657

658

659

660

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

ElasticityCountry CommodityMarket ForeignCountry TradeOrigin TradeDestination InputSub1 InputSub2 IncomeType IncomeSpecify

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

US

cross a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, income elasticities, and trade elasticities) and economic sectors/product markets. A submittal form allows you to provide elasticity estimates for consideration as pa

Supply Elasticity Values 32 of 60
ElasticityID

609

610

611

612

613

615

616

617

654

655

656

657

658

659

660

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

OtherSpecify FunctionalForm LagStructure QuantityMeasure FrequencyofObs DataYear Geography

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

generalized leontief off-machine tons Annual 1985;1988-1989 United States

Log-linear millions of kilograms Annual 1958-1989 United States

Log-linear millions of kilograms Annual 1958-1989 United States

Log-linear millions of kilograms Annual 1958-1989 United States

1950-1986 Illinois

1950-1986 Illinois

1950-1986 Illinois

1950-1986 Illinois

A submittal form allows you to provide elasticity estimates for consideration as part of this databank

Supply Elasticity Values 33 of 60
ElasticityID

609

610

611

612

613

615

616

617

654

655

656

657

658

659

660

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

TimeSeries CrossSection PanelData MethodDescription ConstantorPointPointMedian PointMean PointXthPercentile

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

FALSE FALSE TRUE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

TRUE FALSE FALSE

Supply Elasticity Values 34 of 60
ElasticityID

609

610

611

612

613

615

616

617

654

655

656

657

658

659

660

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

PointEquation TypeofTest TestStatValue TestStatp_value ConfidenceLevel UpperBound LowerBound

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -1.132

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -4.832 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -4.539 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.518 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -0.472

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -2.124 0.95

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio -3.143 0.99

Discussion can be found on pages A:56-A:69 t-test of price ratio 0.506

9-87 and 9-88

9-87 and 9-88

9-87 and 9-88

234-236

234-236

234-236

234-236

Supply Elasticity Values 35 of 60
ElasticityID

609

610

611

612

613

615

616

617

654

655

656

657

658

659

660

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

Title DocumentType AuthorEditor

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact and Regulatory Flexibility Analysis of Proposed Effluent Guidelines and NESHAP for the Pulp,Paper, and Paperboard Industry EPA Document

Economic Impact Analysis for the Polymers and Resins II NESHAP EPA Document

Economic Impact Analysis for the Polymers and Resins II NESHAP EPA Document

Economic Impact Analysis for the Polymers and Resins II NESHAP EPA Document

Disaggregated Output Supply and Pesticide Policy Journal Article Lim, H, R. Shumway, and T. Honeycutt

Disaggregated Output Supply and Pesticide Policy Journal Article Lim, H, R. Shumway, and T. Honeycutt

Disaggregated Output Supply and Pesticide Policy Journal Article Lim, H, R. Shumway, and T. Honeycutt

Disaggregated Output Supply and Pesticide Policy Journal Article Lim, H, R. Shumway, and T. Honeycutt

Supply Elasticity Values 36 of 60
ElasticityID

609

610

611

612

613

615

616

617

654

655

656

657

658

659

660

Source: http://www.epa.gov/ttnecas1/Elasticity.htm

Elasticity Databank

In the absence of an encyclopedic ‘Book of Elasticities’ the Elasticity Databank serves as a searchable database of elasticity parameters across a variety of types (i.e., demand and supply elasticities, substitution elasticities, 

DocYear DocURL

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1993

1994

1994

1994

1993

1993

1993

1993

Supply Elasticity Values 37 of 60
Electricity Consumption Intensity by Business Sectors

Electricity Consumption divided by Value Added

Electricity Electricity Value Added Value Added

Electricity

Consumption

Using 2006 data Consumption Consumption 2006 2006 Intensity

National-Level Analysis, Based on SEDS Data (tBtu, 2006) (mmkWh, 2006) ($mm, $2000) ($mm, $2009) (kWh/$mm) Source, Comment

Commercial 4,435 1,299,744 8,564,029$ 10,604,684$ 122,563 Electricity consumption from SEDS, 2006

Industrial Sectors, Aggregate ($mm, $2000)

Industrial 3,451 1,011,298 2,171,403$ 2,688,810$ 376,114 Electricity consumption from SEDS, 2006

($mm, $2006)

Transportation 25 7,401 387,381$ 411,815$ 17,972 Electricity consumption from SEDS, 2006

($mm, $2000)

Industry and Transportation 3,476 1,018,699 2,558,784$ 3,168,497$ 321,509 Electricity consumption from SEDS, 2006

3 digit Electricity Electricity Value Added Value Added

Electricity

Consumption

Using 2002 data NAICS Consumption Consumption 2002 2002 Intensity

National-Level Analysis, Based on Economic Census Code (tBtu, 2002) (mmkWh, 2002) ($mm, $2000) ($mm, $2009) (kWh/$mm) Source, Comment

Construction 183 53,695 428,070$ 530,071$ 101,298

Mining 227 66,497 107,646$ 133,296$ 498,865

Manufacturing 2,781 814,888 1,384,377$ 1,714,249$ 475,361

3 digit Electricity Electricity Value Added Value Added

Electricity

Consumption

Using 2002 data NAICS Consumption Consumption 2002 2002 Intensity

National Level Analysis, Based on MECS Data Code (tBtu, 2002) (mmkWh, 2002) ($mm, $2000) ($mm, $2009) (kWh/$mm) Source, Comment

Manufacturing Sectors (3 digit NAICS), National

Food & Beverage and Tobacco Products 311, 312 256 75,026 153,684$ 190,304$ 394,244 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Textile Mills & Textile Product Mills 313, 314 103 30,186 21,375$ 26,468$ 1,140,472 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Apparel & Leather and Allied Products 315, 316 14 4,103 21,120$ 26,153$ 156,887 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Wood Products 321 72 21,101 30,324$ 37,550$ 561,952 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Paper 322 223 65,355 50,835$ 62,948$ 1,038,235 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Printing and Related Support 323 50 14,654 43,522$ 53,893$ 271,903 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Petroleum and Coal Products 324 127 37,220 32,494$ 40,237$ 925,026 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Chemicals 325 522 152,983 170,484$ 211,107$ 724,670 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Plastics and Rubber Products 326 181 53,046 62,874$ 77,856$ 681,336 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Nonmetallic Mineral Products 327 141 41,323 45,531$ 56,380$ 732,935 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Primary Metals 331 493 144,484 44,123$ 54,637$ 2,644,450 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Fabricated Metal Products 332 161 47,184 104,382$ 129,254$ 365,051 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Machinery 333 84 24,618 93,306$ 115,539$ 213,070 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Computer and Electronic Products 334 131 38,392 185,757$ 230,020$ 166,909 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Electrical Equip., Appliances, and Components 335 47 13,774 48,839$ 60,476$ 227,764 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Transportation Equipment 336 172 50,408 127,512$ 157,896$ 319,250 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Furniture and Related Products 337 24 7,034 29,193$ 36,149$ 194,575 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Miscellaneous 339 35 10,257 56,383$ 69,818$ 146,917 Electricity consumption from MECS, 2002

Total Manufacturing 2,836 831,150 1,321,738$ 1,636,685$ 507,825

Total Business Sector Consumption

Electricity Intensity by Sector 38 of 60
ST State RIMS Sector Final-demand Output /1/ (dollars) Final-demand Earnings /2/ (dollars) Final-demand Employment /3/ (number of jobs)

52 United States Crop and animal production 3.0058 0.6403 24.2396

52 United States Forestry, fishing, and related activities 3.2748 0.9435 33.028

52 United States Oil and gas extraction 2.3938 0.6109 10.4152

52 United States Mining, except oil and gas 2.4986 0.6588 12.8966

52 United States Support activities for mining 2.58 0.6103 12.7149

52 United States Utilities 2.2143 0.4635 8.4533

52 United States Construction 3.2336 1.0036 25.0564

52 United States Wood product manufacturing 3.2404 0.8273 23.0824

52 United States manufacturing 2.9695 0.7656 17.1388

52 United States Primary metal manufacturing 2.6691 0.5847 12.4519

52 United States Fabricated metal product manufacturing 2.969 0.769 17.6386

52 United States Machinery manufacturing 2.9793 0.7707 16.5915

52 United States manufacturing 3.1256 0.906 17.8745

52 United States manufacturing 2.9564 0.7482 16.2123

52 United States manufacturing 3.301 0.7614 16.4103

52 United States manufacturing 2.8854 0.823 16.1784

52 United States manufacturing 3.1713 0.8371 21.6889

52 United States Miscellaneous manufacturing 3.0937 0.9009 18.8377

52 United States manufacturing 3.4481 0.7671 19.9725

52 United States Textile and textile product mills 3.343 0.8107 20.1015

52 United States manufacturing 3.1 0.9217 25.11

52 United States Paper manufacturing 3.0814 0.7211 16.4012

52 United States Printing and related support activities 3.1434 0.9034 21.2284

52 United States manufacturing 2.286 0.4541 7.9432

52 United States Chemical manufacturing 2.9782 0.6642 13.2655

52 United States manufacturing 3.0766 0.7114 16.2544

52 United States Wholesale trade 2.6574 0.8007 17.6403

52 United States Retail trade 2.756 0.8222 26.528

52 United States Air transportation 2.8732 0.7431 16.7626

52 United States Rail transportation 2.5722 0.662 13.8662

52 United States Water transportation 3.0436 0.7356 16.6074

52 United States Truck transportation 3.1126 0.9011 22.6462

52 United States transportation 3.1739 0.9888 36.7137

52 United States Pipeline transportation 2.7536 0.5933 11.9286

52 United States activities 2.7563 0.9986 23.201

52 United States Warehousing and storage 2.7267 0.9646 26.442

52 United States Publishing including software 2.8614 0.7811 17.225

52 United States industries 3.0828 0.8091 19.6059

52 United States Broadcasting and telecommunications 2.8208 0.627 13.6246

52 United States services 2.9251 0.7605 17.5864

52 United States intermediation and related services 2.2379 0.618 13.2187

52 United States investments 3.3335 1.1312 21.8999

52 United States Insurance carriers and related activities 3.1602 0.88 18.8003

52 United States vehicles 3.9023 1.1441 22.047

RIMS 2006 Multx 39 of 60
ST State RIMS Sector Final-demand Output /1/ (dollars) Final-demand Earnings /2/ (dollars) Final-demand Employment /3/ (number of jobs)

52 United States Real estate 1.9456 0.3263 9.7465

52 United States of intangible assets 2.946 0.7159 17.9841

52 United States services 3.044 1.027 22.5074

52 United States enterprises 3.0088 0.9572 18.5948

52 United States Administrative and support services 2.9508 0.9508 30.7248

52 United States services 2.9095 0.7806 18.367

52 United States Educational services 3.1209 1.0328 32.7968

52 United States Ambulatory health care services 2.9776 1.0231 23.7098

52 United States care facilities 3.2177 1.0531 27.2508

52 United States Social assistance 3.0776 1.0114 41.7311

52 United States activities 2.9641 1.0295 35.6989

52 United States Amusements, gambling, and recreation 2.7181 0.7919 29.2845

52 United States Accommodation 2.7267 0.7758 23.3633

52 United States Food services and drinking places 3.0521 0.8195 33.8903

52 United States Other services 3.0651 0.8881 27.0131

52 United States Households 2.3203 0.6423 17.577

1. Each entry in column 1 represents the total dollar change in output that occurs in all industries within the state for each additional dollar of output delivered to final demand by the selected industry.

4. Each entry in column 4 represents the total dollar change in value added that occurs in all industries within the state for each additional dollar of output delivered to final demand by the selected industry.

6. Each entry in column 6 represents the total change in number of jobs in all industries within the state for each additional job in the selected industry.

2. Each entry in column 2 represents the total dollar change in earnings of households employed by all industries within the state for each additional dollar of output delivered to final demand by the selected

industry.

3. Each entry in column 3 represents the total change in number of jobs that occurs in all industries within the state for each additional 1 million dollars of output delivered to final demand by the selected

industry. Because the employment multipliers are based on regional data, the output delivered to final demand should be in regional year dollars.

5. Each entry in column 5 represents the total dollar change in earnings of households employed by all industries within the state for each additional dollar of earnings paid directly to households employed by

the selected industry.

RIMS 2006 Multx 40 of 60
RIMS Sector Name Short Name Output Earnings Employment

Construction Construction 3.2336 1.0036 25.0564

Utilities Utilities 2.2143 0.4635 8.4533

Households Household 2.3203 0.6423 17.577

Paper manufacturing Paper 3.0814 0.7211 16.4012

Chemical manufacturing Chemicals 2.9782 0.6642 13.2655

Petroleum and coal products manufacturing Petroleum 2.286 0.4541 7.9432

Primary metal manufacturing Primary metals 2.6691 0.5847 12.4519

Food, beverage, and tobacco product manufacturing Food, beverage 3.4481 0.7671 19.9725

RIMS Mult Matrix 41 of 60
Gross-Domestic-Product-by-Industry Accounts

Value Added by Industry

[Billions of dollars]

Release date: April 28, 2009

2007

1 Gross domestic product 13807.5

2 Private industries 12064.6

3 Agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting 167.9

4 Farms 137.3

5 Forestry, fishing, and related activities 30.7

6 Mining 275

7 Oil and gas extraction 164.7

8 Mining, except oil and gas 45.3

9 Support activities for mining 65

10 Utilities 281.4

11 Construction 610.8

12 Manufacturing 1616.8

13 Durable goods 922

14 Wood products 31.4

15 Nonmetallic mineral products 54.4

16 Primary metals 62.4

17 Fabricated metal products 140.4

18 Machinery 125.7

19 Computer and electronic products 146.3

20 Electrical equipment, appliances, and components 58.4

21 Motor vehicles, bodies and trailers, and parts 98.5

22 Other transportation equipment 96.1

23 Furniture and related products 35.4

24 Miscellaneous manufacturing 73

25 Nondurable goods 694.9

26 Food and beverage and tobacco products 174.7

27 Textile mills and textile product mills 19.8

28 Apparel and leather and allied products 16.1

29 Paper products 50.7

30 Printing and related support activities 47.9

31 Petroleum and coal products 70.4

32 Chemical products 249.2

33 Plastics and rubber products 66.2

34 Wholesale trade 805.3

35 Retail trade 892.5

36 Transportation and warehousing 407.2

37 Air transportation 55.2

38 Rail transportation 40.5

39 Water transportation 10.7

40 Truck transportation 127.6

41 Transit and ground passenger transportation 19.3

42 Pipeline transportation 12

2007 GDP by Sector 42 of 60
43 Other transportation and support activities 101.5

44 Warehousing and storage 40.3

45 Information 586.3

46 Publishing industries (includes software) 138.8

47 Motion picture and sound recording industries 43.4

48 Broadcasting and telecommunications 342.4

49 Information and data processing services 61.7

50 Finance, insurance, real estate, rental, and leasing 2811.2

51 Finance and insurance 1091.4

52 Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation, and related activities 504.4

53 Securities, commodity contracts, and investments 237.5

54 Insurance carriers and related activities 332.5

55 Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles 17

56 Real estate and rental and leasing 1719.8

57 Real estate 1586.5

58 Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets 133.3

59 Professional and business services 1694.1

60 Professional, scientific, and technical services 1007.8

61 Legal services 198.4

62 Computer systems design and related services 169.3

63 Miscellaneous professional, scientific, and technical services 640.2

64 Management of companies and enterprises 271.3

65 Administrative and waste management services 415.1

66 Administrative and support services 381.2

67 Waste management and remediation services 33.9

68 Educational services, health care, and social assistance 1087

69 Educational services 129.5

70 Health care and social assistance 957.4

71 Ambulatory health care services 498.1

72 Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities 373.7

73 Social assistance 85.7

74 Arts, entertainment, recreation, accommodation, and food services 513.3

75 Arts, entertainment, and recreation 133.8

76 Performing arts, spectator sports, museums, and related activities 61.8

77 Amusements, gambling, and recreation industries 72

78 Accommodation and food services 379.5

79 Accommodation 120.9

80 Food services and drinking places 258.6

81 Other services, except government 315.6

82 Government 1742.9

83 Federal 554

84 General government 484.2

85 Government enterprises 69.8

86 State and local 1188.9

87 General government 1099

88 Government enterprises 89.9

89 NIPA reconciliation item/1/ ...

2007 GDP by Sector 43 of 60
90 Addenda:

91 Gross domestic product, NIPAs ...

92 Less: Value added, all industries ...

93 NIPA reconciliation item/1/ ...

94 Private goods-producing industries/2/ 2670.6

95 Private services-producing industries/3/ 9394

96 Information-communications-technology-producing industries/4/ 516

1. The NIPA reconciliation item shows the differences between the Annual Industry Accounts (AIAs) and the National Income and Product Accounts (NIPAs) that result from the incorporation of source data in the AIAs that were not available to be

incorporated in the NIPAs. These differences do not indicate future revisions to the NIPAs, which will reflect the incorporation of additional key source data.

2. Consists of agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting; mining; construction; and manufacturing.

3. Consists of utilities; wholesale trade; retail trade; transportation and warehousing; information; finance, insurance, real estate, rental, and leasing; professional and business services; educational services, health care, and social assistance;

arts, entertainment, recreation, accommodation, and food services; and other services, except government.

4. Consists of computer and electronic products; publishing industries (includes software); information and data processing services; and computer systems design and related services.

2007 GDP by Sector 44 of 60
Year GDP Deflator Indexed to 100 at 2005

1990 72.201

1991 74.760

1992 76.533

1993 78.224

1994 79.872

1995 81.536

1996 83.088

1997 84.555

1998 85.511

1999 86.768

2000 88.647

2001 90.650

2002 92.118

2003 94.100

2004 96.770

2005 100.000

2006 103.257

2007 106.214

2008 108.483

2009 109.770

Convert 2000 to 2008: 122.38%

Convert 2000 to 2009: 123.83%

Convert 2007 to 2008: 102.14%

Convert 2007 to 2009: 103.35%

Convert 2006 to 2008: 105.06%

Convert 2006 to 2009: 106.31%

GDP Deflator 45 of 60
RIMS# RIMS II Sector NAICS 3 NAICS Sector Name RIMS#

Agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting

1 Crop and animal production 111 Crop production 1

1 Crop and animal production 112 Animal production 1

2 Forestry, fishing, and related activities 113 Forestry and logging 2

2 Forestry, fishing, and related activities 114 Fishing, hunting and trapping 2

2 Forestry, fishing, and related activities 115 Support activities for agriculture and forestry 2

Mining

3 Oil and gas extraction 211 Oil and gas extraction 3

4 Mining, except oil and gas 212 Mining (except oil and gas) 4

5 Support activities for mining 213 Support activities for mining 5

General Sector Utilities

6 Utilities 221 Utilities 6

General Sector Construction

7 Construction 236 Construction of buildings 7

7 Construction 237 Heavy and civil engineering construction 7

7 Construction 238 Specialty trade contractors 7

General Sector Manufacturing

8 Wood product manufacturing 321 Wood product manufacturing 8

9 Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing 327 Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing 9

10 Primary metal manufacturing 331 Primary metal manufacturing 10

11 Fabricated metal product manufacturing 332 Fabricated metal product manufacturing 11

12 Machinery manufacturing 333 Machinery manufacturing 12

13 Computer and electronic product manufacturing 334 Computer and electronic product manufacturing 13

14 Electrical equipment and appliance manufacturing 335 Electrical equipment, appliance, and component manufacturing 14

15 Motor vehicle, body, trailer, and parts manufacturing 336 Transportation equipment manufacturing 15

16 Other transportation equipment manufacturing 336 Transportation equipment manufacturing 16

17 Furniture and related product manufacturing 337 Furniture and related product manufacturing 17

18 Miscellaneous manufacturing 339 Miscellaneous manufacturing 18

19 Food, beverage, and tobacco product manufacturing 311 Food manufacturing 19

19 Food, beverage, and tobacco product manufacturing 312 Beverage and tobacco product manufacturing 19

20 Textile and textile product mills 313 Textile mills 20

20 Textile and textile product mills 314 Textile product mills 20

21 Apparel, leather, and allied product manufacturing 315 Apparel manufacturing 21

21 Apparel, leather, and allied product manufacturing 316 Leather and allied product manufacturing 21

22 Paper manufacturing 322 Paper manufacturing 22

23 Printing and related support activities 323 Printing and related support activities 23

24 Petroleum and coal products manufacturing 324 Petroleum and coal products manufacturing 24

25 Chemical manufacturing 325 Chemical manufacturing 25

26 Plastics and rubber products manufacturing 326 Plastics and rubber products manufacturing 26

General Sector Wholesale trade

27 Wholesale trade 423 Durable goods merchant wholesalers 27

RIMS to NAICS3 Map 46 of 60
RIMS# RIMS II Sector NAICS 3 NAICS Sector Name RIMS#

27 Wholesale trade 424 Nondurable goods merchant wholesalers 27

27 Wholesale trade 425 Wholesale electronic markets and agents and brokers 27

General Sector Retail trade

28 Retail trade 441 Motor vehicle and parts dealers 28

28 Retail trade 442 Furniture and home furnishings stores 28

28 Retail trade 443 Electronics and appliance stores 28

28 Retail trade 444 Building material and garden equipment and supplies dealers 28

28 Retail trade 445 Food and beverage stores 28

28 Retail trade 446 Health and personal care stores 28

28 Retail trade 447 Gasoline stations 28

28 Retail trade 448 Clothing and clothing accessories stores 28

28 Retail trade 451 Sporting goods, hobby, book, and music stores 28

28 Retail trade 452 General merchandise stores 28

28 Retail trade 453 Miscellaneous store retailers 28

28 Retail trade 454 Nonstore retailers 28

Transportation and warehousing*

29 Air transportation 481 Air transportation 29

30 Rail transportation 482 Rail transportation 30

31 Water transportation 483 Water transportation 31

32 Truck transportation 484 Truck transportation 32

33 Transit and ground passenger transportation* 485 Transit and ground passenger transportation 33

34 Pipeline transportation 486 Pipeline transportation 34

35 Other transportation and support activities 487 Scenic and sightseeing transportation 35

35 Other transportation and support activities 488 Support activities for transportation 35

35 Other transportation and support activities 492 Couriers and messengers 35

36 Warehousing and storage 493 Warehousing and storage 36

Information

37 Publishing including software 511 Publishing industries (except Internet) 37

37 Publishing including software 516 Internet publishing and broadcasting 37

38 Motion picture and sound recording industries 512 Motion picture and sound recording industries 38

39 Broadcasting and telecommunications 515 Broadcasting (except Internet) 39

39 Broadcasting and telecommunications 517 Telecommunications 39

40 Information and data processing services 518 Internet service providers, web search portals, and data processing services 40

40 Information and data processing services 519 Other information services 40

Finance and insurance

41 Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation and related services 521 Monetary authorities - central bank 41

41 Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation and related services 522 Credit intermediation and related activities 41

42 Securities, commodity contracts, investments 523 Securities, commodity contracts, other financial investments, and related activities 42

43 Insurance carriers and related activities 524 Insurance carriers and related activities 43

44 Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles 525 Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles (part) 44

Real estate and rental and leasing

RIMS to NAICS3 Map 47 of 60
RIMS# RIMS II Sector NAICS 3 NAICS Sector Name RIMS#

45 Real estate 531 Real estate 45

46 Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets 532 Rental and leasing services 46

46 Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets 533 Lessors of nonfinancial intangible assets (except copyrighted works) 46

General Sector Professional, scientific, and technical services

47 Professional, scientific, and technical services 541 Professional, scientific, and technical services 47

General Sector Management of companies and enterprises

48 Management of companies and enterprises 551 Management of companies and enterprises 48

Administrative and waste management services 0

49 Administrative and support services 561 Administrative and support services 49

50 Waste management and remediation services 562 Waste management and remediation services 50

General Sector Educational services 0

51 Educational services 611 Educational services 51

General Sector Health care and social assistance

52 Ambulatory health care services 621 Ambulatory health care services 52

53 Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities 622 Hospitals 53

53 Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities 623 Nursing and residential care facilities 53

54 Social assistance 624 Social assistance 54

Arts, entertainment, and recreation

55 Performing arts, museums, and related activities 711 Performing arts, spectator sports, and related industries 55

55 Performing arts, museums, and related activities 712 Museums, historical sites, and similar institutions 55

56 Amusements, gambling, and recreation 713 Amusement, gambling, and recreation industries 56

Accommodation and food services

57 Accommodation 721 Accommodation 57

58 Food services and drinking places 722 Food services and drinking places 58

General Sector Other services*

59 Other services 811 Repair and maintenance 59

59 Other services 812 Personal and laundry services 59

59 Other services 813 Religious, grantmaking, civic, professional, and similar organizations 59

General Sector Households

60 Households 814 Private households 60

RIMS to NAICS3 Map 48 of 60
National Electricity Consumption, 2006

Sector mm kWh

Residential 1,351,520

Transportation 7,401

Commercial 1,299,744

Industrial 1,011,298

Total 3,669,963

2006 SEDS

SEDS Elec. Consumption, 2006 49 of 60
Real GDP by state (millions of chained 2000 dollars)

National Total

FIPS State Industry Code Industry 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 SEDS Sector

0 United States 34 Wholesale trade 506767 564655 594132 591687 633123 639370 653105 666322 678293 689872 Commercial

0 United States 35 Retail trade 569950 598829 633853 662430 708602 723996 752246 771948 819153 859967 Commercial

0 United States 45 Information 341706 376962 437528 458304 476793 487009 501522 560146 624377 669147 Commercial

0 United States 50 Finance and insurance 593437 634611 678143 740488 772833 789961 817876 826490 877598 963705 Commercial

0 United States 55 Real estate and rental and leasing1085381 1108621 1156980 1190464 1232575 1233884 1254307 1305946 1358213 1403724 Commercial

0 United States 58 Professional and technical services542520 585863 623894 675122 679057 668771 695309 749984 782720 829836 Commercial

0 United States 62 Management of companies and enterprises 188959 184040 185587 183354 179923 185334 190528 181333 181963 177505 Commercial

0 United States 63 Administrative and waste services270029 281005 296887 282373 274423 277739 295512 298762 315488 323849 Commercial

0 United States 66 Educational services 73107 75627 77139 79239 79108 81171 84038 85719 85486 86432 Commercial

0 United States 67 Health care and social assistance570023 572975 583006 599197 620972 648411 677678 701136 715850 743538 Commercial

0 United States 71 Arts, entertainment, and recreation84201 84691 87884 88676 91464 94691 96501 99411 99364 103185 Commercial

0 United States 74 Accommodation and food services232117 242495 251175 261443 256161 258982 268093 279119 284160 292173 Commercial

0 United States 77 Other services, except government 227487 233400 229656 229109 225302 226057 230521 230875 229537 228829 Commercial

0 United States 78 Government 1085200 1100168 1113472 1134817 1146456 1166232 1177394 1179710 1184398 1192267 Commercial

Commercial 6,370,884$ 6,643,942$ 6,949,336$ 7,176,703$ 7,376,792$ 7,481,608$ 7,694,630$ 7,936,901$ 8,236,600$ 8,564,029$

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

NAICS_Commercial 50 of 60
Real GDP by state (millions of chained 2000 dollars)

National Total

FIPS State Industry Code Industry 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006

0 United States 3 Agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting 86,566$ 84,578$ 87,396$ 98,020$ 91,806$ 96,811$ 104,070$ 111,043$ 116,508$ 117,565$

0 United States 6 Mining 124,322$ 123,375$ 126,552$ 121,334$ 114,922$ 107,646$ 106,680$ 107,708$ 105,123$ 111,558$

0 United States 11 Construction 406,564$ 423,216$ 433,346$ 435,914$ 436,624$ 428,070$ 419,300$ 420,351$ 431,679$ 405,707$

0 United States 12 Manufacturing 1,205,414$ 1,286,185$ 1,342,121$ 1,426,218$ 1,346,866$ 1,384,377$ 1,400,092$ 420,351$ 1,492,984$ 1,536,573$

Industrial, Total 1,822,866$ 1,917,354$ 1,989,415$ 2,081,486$ 1,990,218$ 2,016,904$ 2,030,142$ 420,351$ 2,146,294$ 2,171,403$

Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis

NAICS_Industrial 51 of 60
SEDS Sector

Industrial

Industrial

Industrial

Industrial

NAICS_Industrial 52 of 60
2007 Economic Census

Release Date: 3/17/2009

Sector 00: EC0700CADV1: All sectors: Core Business Statistics Series: Advance Summary Statistics for the United States (2007 NAICS Basis): 2007

2007

NAICS

code

RIMS

Code Meaning of 2007 NAICS code

Footnote

identifier

Number of

establishments

Sales, shipments,

receipts, revenue, or

business done

($1,000)

Annual payroll

($1,000)

21 #N/A Mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction 21,169 369,191,012 37,308,193

211 3 Oil and gas extraction 6,293 231,091,506 9,549,901

212 4 Mining (except oil and gas) 6,465 81,120,949 11,493,778

213 5 Support activities for mining 8,411 56,978,557 16,264,514

22 #N/A Utilities 16,879 581,553,952 50,893,874

221 6 Utilities 16,879 581,553,952 50,893,874

23 #N/A Construction 725,101 1,781,778,684 348,138,262

236 7 Construction of buildings 209,203 701,719,130 74,031,139

237 7 Heavy and civil engineering construction 39,608 287,793,774 54,623,897

238 7 Specialty trade contractors 476,290 792,265,781 219,483,226

31-33 #N/A Manufacturing 293,919 5,339,345,058 612,474,100

311 19 Food manufacturing 22,058 589,580,258 50,469,329

312 19 Beverage and tobacco product manufacturing 3,233 127,889,507 7,328,727

313 20 Textile mills 2,601 36,016,075 5,254,584

314 20 Textile product mills 5,381 27,952,430 4,242,137

315 21 Apparel manufacturing 6,849 24,506,280 4,200,897

316 21 Leather and allied product manufacturing 1,061 5,800,278 1,069,691

321 8 Wood product manufacturing 14,862 101,879,082 17,438,662

322 22 Paper manufacturing 4,803 175,805,696 20,804,354

323 23 Printing and related support activities 28,754 103,363,897 25,760,212

324 24 Petroleum and coal products manufacturing 2,284 606,260,178 8,482,826

325 25 Chemical manufacturing 12,937 738,302,988 49,648,378

326 26 Plastics and rubber products manufacturing 13,615 211,048,378 33,117,587

327 9 Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing 16,114 127,905,191 20,170,420

331 10 Primary metal manufacturing 5,076 259,860,618 22,971,340

332 11 Fabricated metal product manufacturing 54,354 344,189,503 67,416,850

333 12 Machinery manufacturing 24,358 347,238,729 55,836,558

334 13 Computer and electronic product manufacturing 13,352 412,988,505 67,531,130

335 14 Electrical equipment, appliance, and component manufacturing 5,741 129,282,653 18,800,195

336 15 Transportation equipment manufacturing 11,767 727,121,247 85,145,182

336 16 Other transportation equipment manufacturing 9,640,000

337 17 Furniture and related product manufacturing 18,247 84,971,247 17,661,126

339 18 Miscellaneous manufacturing 26,472 147,742,318 29,123,915

42 #N/A Wholesale trade 432,094 6,039,227,184 336,128,248

423 27 Merchant wholesalers, durable goods 253,023 2,709,482,155 205,809,529

424 27 Merchant wholesalers, nondurable goods 133,153 2,753,808,263 116,749,252

425 27 Wholesale electronic markets and agents and brokers 45,918 575,936,766 13,569,467

44-45 #N/A Retail trade 1,122,703 3,932,027,444 364,991,713

441 28 Motor vehicle and parts dealers 125,895 892,701,075 72,834,983

442 28 Furniture and home furnishings stores 65,319 110,266,384 15,192,134

443 28 Electronics and appliance stores 50,041 111,313,877 11,121,198

444 28 Building material and garden equipment and supplies dealers 90,443 323,227,611 38,195,925

445 28 Food and beverage stores 146,951 541,202,096 55,676,935

446 28 Health and personal care stores 87,311 238,818,411 28,516,160

447 28 Gasoline stations 117,014 446,650,792 14,714,638

448 28 Clothing and clothing accessories stores 154,935 212,957,971 26,870,497

451 28 Sporting goods, hobby, book, and music stores 57,197 81,745,134 9,631,780

452 28 General merchandise stores 46,065 578,062,213 54,533,062

453 28 Miscellaneous store retailers 120,260 103,293,425 14,391,829

454 28 Nonstore retailers 61,272 291,788,455 23,312,572

48-49 #N/A Transportation and warehousing 102 217,926 655,857,245 172,166,275

481 29 Air transportation 101 5,763 146,566,633 25,639,464

483 31 Water transportation 1,814 36,056,934 4,048,233

484 32 Truck transportation 119,694 221,737,480 59,146,456

485 33 Transit and ground passenger transportation 17,769 26,967,135 10,011,617

486 34 Pipeline transportation 2,644 24,665,517 3,273,203

487 35 Scenic and sightseeing transportation 2,440 2,661,369 661,195

488 35 Support activities for transportation 41,189 96,256,063 25,129,206

492 35 Couriers and messengers 12,788 76,286,421 19,971,545

493 36 Warehousing and storage 13,825 24,659,693 24,285,356

51 #N/A Information 141,034 1,075,153,974 223,376,793

511 37 Publishing industries (except Internet) 30,016 273,416,279 75,847,046

512 38 Motion picture and sound recording industries 23,542 95,163,829 17,229,669

515 39 Broadcasting (except Internet) 10,030 98,662,919 17,646,785

517 39 Telecommunications 52,614 498,256,359 75,227,740

These data are preliminary and are subject to change; they will be superseded by data released in later data files. Includes only establishments of firms with payroll. Definition

of paid employees varies among NAICS sectors. Data based on the 2007 Economic Census. For information on confidentiality protection, sampling error, nonsampling error,

and definitions, see Survey Methodology.

Econ Census Data 53 of 60
2007 Economic Census

Release Date: 3/17/2009

Sector 00: EC0700CADV1: All sectors: Core Business Statistics Series: Advance Summary Statistics for the United States (2007 NAICS Basis): 2007

2007

NAICS

code

21

211

212

213

22

221

23

236

237

238

31-33

311

312

313

314

315

316

321

322

323

324

325

326

327

331

332

333

334

335

336

336

337

339

42

423

424

425

44-45

441

442

443

444

445

446

447

448

451

452

453

454

48-49

481

483

484

485

486

487

488

492

493

51

511

512

515

517

These data are preliminary and are subject to change; they will be superseded by data released in later data files. Includes only establishments of firms with payroll. Definition

of paid employees varies among NAICS sectors. Data based on the 2007 Economic Census. For information on confidentiality protection, sampling error, nonsampling error,

and definitions, see Survey Methodology.

ICS Basis): 2007

Number of paid

employees for pay

period including

March 12 Comment

703,129

161,625

219,608

321,896

632,432

632,432

7,399,047

1,408,457

1,013,620

4,976,970

13,333,390

1,466,719

151,864

156,433

142,764

169,131

36,338

519,651

416,886

636,754

105,296

814,024

853,960

475,160

444,204

1,594,425

1,143,322

1,070,420

423,861

1,548,327 value of shipments adjusted for BEA value in RIMS 16

from BEA value of shipments by sector tables

509,112

654,739

6,295,109

3,636,572

2,366,811

291,726

15,610,710

1,916,088

588,879

484,030

1,340,052

2,879,231

1,012,278

887,341

1,688,576

625,854

2,769,973

790,856

627,552

4,435,760

477,402

70,043

1,520,584

453,392

38,171

24,124

615,449

550,384

686,211

3,428,262

1,028,308

326,486

291,025

1,249,755

lishments of firms with payroll. Definition

tion, sampling error, nonsampling error,

Econ Census Data 54 of 60
2007

NAICS

code

RIMS

Code Meaning of 2007 NAICS code

Footnote

identifier

Number of

establishments

Sales, shipments,

receipts, revenue, or

business done

($1,000)

Annual payroll

($1,000)

518 40 Data processing, hosting and related services 16,911 71,308,452 26,841,390

519 40 Other information services 7,921 38,346,136 10,584,163

52 #N/A Finance and insurance 503,156 3,641,082,600 494,484,693

521 41 Monetary authorities- central bank 47 44,967,000 1,338,898

522 41 Credit intermediation and related activities 235,440 1,326,696,033 178,078,578

523 42 Securities, commodity contracts, investments 84,829 632,017,180 161,083,711

524 43 Insurance carriers and related activities 182,840 1,637,402,387 153,983,506

53 #N/A Real estate and rental and leasing 382,725 493,911,736 88,880,642

531 45 Real estate 313,930 344,548,019 64,393,306

532 46 Rental and leasing services 66,067 126,572,853 22,050,988

533 46 Lessors of nonfinancial intangible assets 2,728 22,790,864 2,436,348

54 #N/A Professional, scientific, and technical services 844,552 1,344,760,849 511,818,276

541 47 Professional, scientific, and technical services 844,552 1,344,760,849 511,818,276

56 #N/A Administrative and Support and Waste Mang and Remediation Srvs 389,073 636,657,422 293,802,755

561 49 Administrative and support services 367,819 563,258,810 277,915,718

562 50 Waste management and remediation services 21,254 73,398,612 15,887,037

61 #N/A Educational services 60,689 47,241,063 14,584,076

611 51 Educational services 60,689 47,241,063 14,584,076

62 #N/A Health care and social assistance 779,074 1,697,230,614 665,831,857

621 52 Ambulatory health care services 544,735 692,136,504 280,139,881

622 53 Hospitals 6,713 713,275,541 263,295,798

623 53 Nursing and residential care facilities 75,617 167,973,206 74,024,029

624 54 Social assistance 152,009 123,845,363 48,372,149

71 #N/A Arts, entertainment, and recreation 123,965 188,975,642 57,545,590

711 55 Performing arts, spectator sports, and related industries 43,771 76,420,290 27,255,351

712 55 Museums, historical sites, and similar institutions 7,133 13,241,667 3,631,032

713 56 Amusement, gambling, and recreation industries 73,061 99,313,685 26,659,207

72 #N/A Accommodation and food services 626,558 612,949,468 169,845,677

721 57 Accommodation 62,774 180,044,424 45,871,708

722 58 Food services and drinking places 563,784 432,905,044 123,973,969

81 #N/A Other services (except public administration) 537,820 417,512,388 99,809,780

811 59 Repair and maintenance 222,673 143,173,490 41,740,774

812 59 Personal and laundry services 208,403 84,244,614 26,849,320

813 59 Religious, Grantmaking, Civic, Professional, and Similar Orgs 106,744 190,094,284 31,219,686

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2007 Economic Census.

55 #N/A Management of companies and enterprises S S S

551 48 Management of companies and enterprises S S S

Econ Census Data 55 of 60
2007

NAICS

code

21518

519

52

521

522

523

524

53

531

532

533

54

541

56

561

562

61

611

62

621

622

623

624

71

711

712

713

72

721

722

81

811

812

813

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2007 Economic Census.

55

551

Number of paid

employees for pay

period including

March 12 Comment

399,581

133,107

6,562,546

19,063

3,203,232

930,838

2,409,413

2,309,725

1,611,159

666,317

32,249

8,079,319

8,079,319

10,195,685

9,828,905

366,780

562,210

562,210

16,859,513

5,791,128

5,535,620

3,055,542

2,477,223

2,070,524

441,224

128,834

1,500,466

11,587,814

1,979,836

9,607,978

3,515,796

1,304,601

1,340,717

870,478

S

S

Econ Census Data 56 of 60
Electricity Consumption for Selected Aggregate Sectors, National, 2002

Sector Code

Cost Purch

Electricity

($1,000)

Quan Purch

Electricity

(1,000 kWh)

Implied Price

per kWh

($/kWh) Source, Comment

Construction 23 2,574,813$ 53,694,980 from Economic Census, 2002

Mining 21 3,354,633$ 66,496,777 0.050$ from Economic Census, 2002

Manufacturing 31-33 38,910,038$ 814,887,870 0.048$ from Economic Census, 2002

Mining, Manufacturing 42,264,671$ 881,384,647 0.048$ use calculated price to estimate quantity for construction sector

EC Elec. Consumption, 2002 57 of 60
Real GDP (millions of chained 2000 dollars)

State

BEA

Code

NAICS

Code(s) Industry 2002

Requested

Industry?

United States 1 All industry total $9,981,850

United States 2 Private industries $8,817,039

United States 3 Agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting $96,811

United States 4 Crop and animal production (Farms) $70,096

United States 5 Forestry, fishing, and related activities $26,700

United States 6 Mining $107,646

United States 7 Oil and gas extraction $81,961

United States 8 Mining, except oil and gas $24,164

United States 9 Support activities for mining $6,943

United States 10 Utilities $187,670

United States 11 Construction $428,070

United States 12 Manufacturing $1,384,377

United States 13 Durable goods $827,746

United States 14 321 Wood product manufacturing $30,324 yes

United States 15 327 Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing $45,531 yes

United States 16 331 Primary metal manufacturing $44,123 yes

United States 17 332 Fabricated metal product manufacturing $104,382 yes

United States 18 333 Machinery manufacturing $93,306 yes

United States 19 334 Computer and electronic product manufacturing $185,757 yes

United States 20 335 Electrical equipment and appliance manufacturing $48,839 yes

United States 21 336 Motor vehicle, body, trailer, and parts manufacturing $127,512 yes

United States 22 336 Other transportation equipment manufacturing $64,228 yes

United States 23 337 Furniture and related product manufacturing $29,193 yes

United States 24 339 Miscellaneous manufacturing $56,383 yes

United States 25 Nondurable goods $555,657

United States 26 311, 312 Food product manufacturing $153,684 yes

United States 27 313, 314 Textile and textile product mills $21,375 yes

United States 28 315, 316 Apparel manufacturing $21,120 yes

United States 29 322 Paper manufacturing $50,835 yes

United States 30 323 Printing and related support activities $43,522 yes

United States 31 324 Petroleum and coal products manufacturing $32,494 yes

United States 32 325 Chemical manufacturing $170,484 yes

United States 33 326 Plastics and rubber products manufacturing $62,874 yes

United States 34 Wholesale trade $639,370

United States 35 Retail trade $723,996

United States 36 Transportation and warehousing, excluding Postal Service $300,207

United States 37 Air transportation $62,766

United States 38 Rail transportation $24,448

United States 39 Water transportation $5,624

United States 40 Truck transportation $87,510

United States 41 Transit and ground passenger transportation $14,620

United States 42 Pipeline transportation $9,612

United States 43 Other transportation and support activities $70,587

United States 44 Warehousing and storage $25,631

United States 45 Information $487,009

United States 46 Publishing including software $115,418

United States 47 Motion picture and sound recording industries $35,793

United States 48 Broadcasting and telecommunications $291,824

United States 49 Information and data processing services $43,691

United States 50 Finance and insurance $789,961

United States 51 Federal Reserve banks, credit intermediation and related services $381,172

United States 52 Securities, commodity contracts, investments $169,752

United States 53 Insurance carriers and related activities $224,737

United States 54 Funds, trusts, and other financial vehicles $11,975

United States 55 Real estate and rental and leasing $1,233,884

United States 56 Real estate $1,129,335

United States 57 Rental and leasing services and lessors of intangible assets $104,328

United States 58 Professional and technical services $668,771

United States 59 Legal services $132,564

BEA_GDP_US_2002_$2000 58 of 60
State

BEA

Code

NAICS

Code(s) Industry 2002

Requested

Industry?

United States 60 Computer systems design and related services $127,597

United States 61 Other professional, scientific and technical services $408,827

United States 62 Management of companies and enterprises $185,334

United States 63 Administrative and waste services $277,739

United States 64 Administrative and support services $253,233

United States 65 Waste management and remediation services $24,506

United States 66 Educational services $81,171

United States 67 Health care and social assistance $648,411

United States 68 Ambulatory health care services $343,133

United States 69 Hospitals and nursing and residential care facilities $245,615

United States 70 Social assistance $60,074

United States 71 Arts, entertainment, and recreation $94,691

United States 72 Performing arts, museums, and related activities $42,951

United States 73 Amusement, gambling, and recreation $51,734

United States 74 Accommodation and food services $258,982

United States 75 Accommodation $86,683

United States 76 Food services and drinking places $172,285

United States 77 Other services, except government $226,057

United States 78 Government $1,166,232

United States 79 Federal civilian $215,736

United States 80 Federal military $98,030

United States 81 State and local $852,365

Source: BEA

Available online at http://www.bea.gov/regional/gsp/

Accessed on November 26, 2008

BEA_GDP_US_2002_$2000 59 of 60
Variables

Variable Concept Excel Name Value Units Source, comment

thousands multiplier tm 1,000

millions multiplier mm 1,000,000

kWh Btu conversion btukwh 3,412 Btu per kWh

Vars 60 of 60